Opposition Brief — National Gypsum Co. v. United States Environmental Protection Agency
Supreme Court brief1988
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ai tas Wiaiamer Cat of te Cinaee Blas
OcToBER TERM, 1988
NATIONAL GYPSUM COMPANY, PETITIONER
v.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT IN OPPOSITION
CHARLES FRIED
Solicitor General
ROGER J. MARZULLA
Assistant Attorney General
i _ MARY ELIZABETH WARD
> Attorney
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 633-2217
QUESTION PRESENTED
Whether the court of appeals erred in concluding that
the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s
school-asbestos rules were lawful under the Asbestos
Hazard Emergency Response Act of 1986, 15 U.S.C.
(Supp. IV) 2641-2654.
(I)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SIE ng ou cccccnecscavecvettscedeseseccceteces l
as ce dena sé sachisnsésnesdarsb sdnascae l
ns es cis pg e 64b0 60600006 dhe esde se vbadas l
I db ckban oven ccbededesecdesncsdedectecssscess 9
GD i ina a uis'g eek vend ehh ebed ce Saes obeeas 13
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Case:
Industrial Union Dep’t v. American Petroleum Institute,
i CTD ¢.0« co.she hewn tnd eae Cade de se soe 11
Statutes:
Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act of 1986, Pub.
L. No. 99-519, § 2, 100 Stat. 2970-2988 .............. |
Toxic Substances Control Act, Tit. II, 15 U.S.C. (Supp.
Ts casas asascshes
fF ol Sl ll.) ee
BD Gee I, OD MIE onc cs cccccccscss
iS U.S. Goaee. TV) SECTS) ........-.22055.
Be i, IS I once ccc cccccaccces
BD Gres MG WU IED oc ccc ccc ccc ccccces
15 U.S.C. (Supp. IV) 2643(b)-(e) ...............
RRR Re SS! Ene
bRIR Ree RE yy. 4,1
15 U.S.C. (Supp. IV) 2643(d)(1)-(5) .............
oe eR Se eee 3,
15 U.S.C. (Supp. IV) 2643(i1M(A)-(D) ........-.
eek ee Sl ee
ee eae > | eee
Ek fate Se
Be ps I OD MID np cc cscs cccccseces
ER Fok SE Le ee
15 U.S.C. (Supp. IV) 2646(a)(1)-(3) .............
PO SED can cb kpacasecsedeevenvcbwaceases 10
UAUbhb hh aL Sh aK WwW Ww Ww WY Ww Ww
IV
Statutes and regulations — Continued:
I ons oc nbicsceccdectescnctdsasse
ec ioechcbadsecaddcddotsseceasda
PTS CAS dubbedesccuescbecss cddisaxta
40 C.F.R. Pt. 763, Subpt. E, App. C ..... 2... cece neces
52 Fed. Reg. (1987):
p. 41846 (to be codified at 40 C.F.R. 763.80(A)) ....
pp. 41846-41848 (to be codified at
ee io coc ctcceddvcceaces
pp. 41848-41849 (to be codified at
MP rc etiaccecccsccscsacecees
p. 41849 (to be codified at
ED eo cancdeccccnccccancess
p. 41850 (to be codified at
SE oo bdkoe's ee cdcsccccsevecs
pp. 41850-41851 (to be codified at
ee an nnekeseenes
pp. 41853-41854 (to be codified at
cer cccccccccnsceocnoses
p. 41853 (to be codified at
Ee eens abanchucseueceeacs
p. 41854 (to be codified at
GCF te PIO oc ccceseccsecdccesces
Miscellaneous:
132 Cong. Rec. H8823 (daily ed. Oct. 1, 1986) ..........
i. wong. Rec. (daily ed. Oct. 3, 1986):
I, oc cnc dah dh bdaehe ened asecanes
ST CCS Uae cee daccdtthaseddnnsescasas
I os ics cave sec dakeneddoes
Es oon oo bn becbces cusudbebcens
52 Fed. Reg. (1987):
PAT TS bbs dwaedee s068'od Cane eed beeedeees
i a e)
Miscellaneous — Continued: Page
p.
p.
p. 41830
p.
p.
p.
sheseesnees Paces CC aOosnaceseneneqeseeen”
In the Supreme Court of the Gnited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1988
No. 88-241
NATIONAL GYPSUM COMPANY, PETITIONER
Vv.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT IN OPPOSITION
OPINION BELOW
The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. Al-A13)
is reported at 846 F.2d 79.
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the court of appeals was entered on
May 10, 1988. The petition for a writ of certiorari was
filed on August 8, 1988. The jurisdiction of this Court is
invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254(1).
STATEMENT
On October 17, 1987, the United States Environ-
mental Protection Agency (EPA) issued rules pursuant
to the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act of 1986
(1)
2
(AHERA)' requiring schools—described as local educa-
tion agencies (LEAs) under AHERA —to establish and to
execute plans to manage asbestos-containing materials
found in school buildings. 52 Fed. Reg. 41826 (1987) T
(AHERA rules).2 Several former manufacturers of |
asbestos-containing products, including petitioner, chal-
lenged the rules as failing to fulfill AHERA’s mandate.
The court of appeals upheld the AHERA rules (Pet. App.
Al-Al3).
1. Since 1979, the EPA has operated a technical
assistance program to assist LEAs and other building
owners to identify and to control asbestos in their
buildings. In connection with that program, the EPA
issued several documents designed to provide guidance for
managing asbestos in buildings. The last of such guides, |
issued in 1985, was entitled “Guidance for Controlling |
Asbestos-Containing Materials in Buildings” and is known |
as the “Purple Book.” The book provides a brief intro-
' Pub. L. No. 99-519, 100 Stat. 2970. Section 2 of AHERA, 100
Stat. 2970-2988, added Title II to the Toxic Substances Control Act
(TSCA), 15 U.S.C. (Supp. IV) 2641-2654, which is reproduced in the
appendix to the petition for a writ of certiorari (at A1l4-A51).
Hereafter, we cite AHERA to the United States Code section but omit
express reference to “Supp. IV.”
2 Exposure to asbestos presents well-documented and potentially
serious risks to public health, including asbestosis, pleural and
peritoneal mesothelioma, and cancers of the lung and other organs.
The asbestos in place in school buildings could release dangerous
fibers if not dealt with properly, and even ordinary maintenance and
cleaning can cause dangerous concentrations of fiber. See 47 Fed. )
Reg. 23363 (1982); see also 45 Fed. Reg. 61969 (1980). Although the
EPA banned use of asbestos in 1973 (40 C.F.R. 61.148; 38 Fed. Reg.
8826 (1973)), a large amount of asbestos used before 1973 remains in
buildings, including schools, throughout the country.
Citations to the AHERA rules are hereafter to the provisions of 40
C.F.R. at which they are to be codified. See Pet. App. A53-Ai03.
catia iittala inate
3
duction to the problem of asbestos but is merely advisory
and contains only general guidance.
In response to a number of concerns about the EPA’s
asbestos program, Congress enacted AHERA in 1986. It
expressly found that the EPA’s then-current rules for deal-
ing with asbestos in schools did not contain “standards for
* * * appropriate response actions” or a “requirement that
response actions * * * be carried out in a safe and com-
plete manner.” 15 U.S.C. 2641(a)(1). Congress also found
that there was neither a uniform program for accrediting
persons who identify or remove asbestos nor a regulatory
requirement that only accredited persons perform those
tasks. 15 U.S.C. 2641(a)(2). In addition, Congress deter-
mined that the EPA’s Purple Book was insufficient to en-
sure adequate responses. 15 U.S.C. 2641(a)(3).
Accordingly, Congress in AHERA directed the EPA to
promulgate comprehensive rules within 360 days of the
statute’s enactment. 15 U.S.C. 2643(a). The rules must (1)
require schools to inspect for asbestos; (2) describe
response actions for at least four circumstances — when
there is actual or reasonably likely damage or significant
damage to friable asbestos’; (3) require schools to imple-
ment those response actions; and (4) require schools to
develop management plans detailing the inspection of, and
actions to be taken with respect to, asbestos. 15 U.S.C.
2643(b)-(e) and (i). The EPA’s regulations “must protect
human health and the environment” (15 U.S.C. 2643(a)),
3 The statute requires the EPA to define the appropriate response
action in at least four circumstances — when there is either (a) damage
or (b) significant damage to friable asbestos-containing material, and
when such asbestos is in areas regularly and normally used by building
occupants and either (c) damage or (d) significant damage is
reasonably likely. 15 U.S.C. 2643(c). Asbestos-containing material is
“friable” if, when dry, it may be “crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to
powder by hand pressure” (15 U.S.C. 2642(6)).
4
and they must offer such protection against both “actual |
[and] potential exposures to releases of asbestos that may y
cause adverse effects on human health or the en- .
vironment” (132 Cong. Rec. H8823 (daily ed. Oct. 1, 1986) ’
(remarks of Rep. Florio) (emphasis added); 132 Cong.
Rec. $15065 (daily ed. Oct. 3, 1986) (emphasis added)
(joint explanatory statement)).
More specifically, AHERA requires that the EPA, in
describing appropriate response actions, identify the least
burdensome methods that protect human health and the
environment, taking into account local circumstances, in-
cluding occupancy, building use, and costs. 15 U.S.C.
2643(d)(1)-(5). The statute also directs the EPA to con-
sider and assess various technologies in order to improve
LEAs’ response-action decisionmaking processes. 15
U.S.C. 2643(c)(2). And, to ensure that there is oversight
and participation by parents, teachers, and school
employees, the EPA’s regulations must require each LEA
to develop an asbestos management plan (15 U.S.C.
2643(i)) that includes, among other things, the results of
the inspection of the school buildings and a detailed
description of the measures to be taken in response. 15
U.S.C. 2643(i)(1)(A)-(J). That plan must be made
available for inspection by the public (15 U.S.C.
2643(i)(5)) and must be submitted to the Governor (15
U.S.C. 2643(i)(6)), who is empowered to disapprove it if,
among other things, it does not conform to the EPA’s
AHERA rules (15 U.S.C. 2645(a) and (c)).
2. The AHERA rules promulgated by the EPA
prescribe detailed procedures for the inspection of
schools. They require that inspectors be accredited (40
C.F.R. 763.85)* and that each inspector classify any
4 AHERA provides that no one may inspect a school, develop a
management plan, or design or conduct response actions without
5
damaged or potentially damaged asbestos according to
prescribed categories (40 C.F.R. 763.88(a)(1)) and provide
the LEA with a written assessment (40 C.F.R.763.88(b)).
Under the rules, an accredited management plan developer
must then recommend in writing appropriate response ac-
tions in accordance with the AHERA rules. That recom-
mendation must be placed in the LEA’s mandatory
management plan (40 C.F.R. 763.93) and submitted to the
Governor and made available to the public —in particular,
to parents, teachers, and other school employees (40
C.F.R. 763.93(a) and (g)(1)(4)).
In accord with prevailing scientific opinion, the EPA
decided not to prescribe air monitoring as the primary tool
for determining the appropriate response action for
asbestos. The agency explained that numerical values in
air tests would “provide a false sense of precision regard-
ing the presence and severity of asbestos hazards” —
specifically, the threat posed by episodic releases of
asbestos fiber. 52 Fed. Reg. 41838 (1987). It concluded, in-
stead, that visual inspection of the condition of asbestos-
containing materials in particular locations, when con-
ducted by a trained expert, would be a better method for
evaluating potential as well as actual fiber releases. Jd. at
15831, 41838.
In addition to rejecting air monitoring as the primary
assessment tool, the EPA refined the definitions of the
categories of asbestos problems identified by Congress
(actual or potential damage or significant damage). 40
C.F.R. 763.83; see 52 Fed. Reg. 15823 (1987). For example,
being properly accredited. 15 U.S.C. 2646(a)(1)-(3). Accreditation
must be accomplished either by the EPA or by a state that has a plan.
at least as stringent as the EPA Model Accreditation Plan (15 U.S.C.
2646(a)), which requires initial accreditation and annual refresher
courses. The Model Plan is codified at Appendix C to Subpart E of 40
C.F.R. Pt. 763.
6
the agency’s definitions for damaged asbestos focus on
physical characteristics such as loss of structural integrity,
sagging, water damage, gouges, and the like. The EPA
also defined the various response actions identified by
Congress in AHERA. The definitions require that
enclosure, encapsulation, and repair of asbestos, if under-
. taken by LEAs, must prevent the release of asbestos
fibers. 40 C.F.R. 763.83; see 52 Fed. Reg. 41830, 41832,
41836 (1987).
Recognizing that its descriptions of appropriate re-
sponse actions must be flexible enough to accommodate
the variations in the condition and location of asbestos in
schools across the nation, the EPA decided to allow LEAs
discretion to define their responses within a range of ap-
propriate alternatives. The appropriate response thus
would depend on such factors as the location and condi-
tion of the asbestos-containing material, the technological
feasibility of various response actions, and economic con-
siderations. See 52 Fed. Reg. 15829 (1987); id. at 41832.
The EPA also described an approach by which the LEA.
can select the least burdensome option from the range of
response actions that are sufficient to protect human
health and the environment. 40 C.F.R. 763.90; 52 Fed.
Reg. 15829, 41832 (1987). Under that approach, if
asbestos is in some degree damaged, some action is
generally required. The overriding concept, however, is to
return the damaged material to an undamaged state or to
prevent damage from occurring, so as to prevent fiber
release.
3. Various asbestos manufacturers challenged the
AHERA rules on several grounds. They argued, among
other things, (1) that the EPA had failed to identify ap-
propriate response actions that were sufficient to protect
health and the environment and were the least burdensome
and that the EPA had erred in leaving those determina-
7
tions to the LEAs with the help of accredited contractors;
(2) that the EPA had erred in failing to determine what
level of exposure to asbestos was “safe”; (3) that the EPA
had failed to provide an objective means for distinguishing
safe from unsafe schools and should have adopted air
monitoring as the objective means for doing so; and (4)
that the EPA had improperly permitted LEAs to remove
asbestos in schools even though removals increase rather
than decrease airborne asbestos levels. The court of ap-
peals rejected all of those arguments (Pet. App. Al-A13).
First, the court held (Pet. App. A7-A9) that the EPA
had acted properly under the statute in not specifying a
single least burdensome response action in the statutorily -
specified situations but instead “offer[ing] a list of specific
responses that it adjudged sufficient to protect human
health, along with a method by which school officials
should be able to determine the least burdensome
response” (id. at A8) (emphasis in original). The court
noted that Congress had imposed on the EPA the burden
of reconciling several competing demands — notably, that
the EPA generally describe response actions using the least
burdensome methods, and that, in doing so for the more
than 30,000 schools covered by the statute, it take account
of local conditions (id. at A7-A8). Because the EPA could
not visit every school, the EPA could reasonably settle on
a solution that worked a compromise — providing for in-
spections of local conditions by accredited inspectors,
preparation of detailed reports setting forth options and
recommendations, selection of a response action from
among those found sufficient by the EPA, and oversight
by state Governors. That compromise solution, the court
concluded (id. at A8), effected a “reasonable, faithful in-
8
terpretation of AHERA’s somewhat contradictory com-
mands.”
The court of appeals also found meritless the contention
that the EPA erred in acting before determining what
quantitative measure of asbestos exposure was safe and in
not mandating use of air monitoring to determine when
that level is exceeded (Pet. App. A9-A10). The court
observed (ibid.) that Congress had recognized that experts
currently disagree over what levels of exposure are safe,
that the EPA had not abandoned its duty but had con-
sidered evidence on the question, and that Congress had
“stated that EPA’s existing guidelines should serve as
minimum standards in devising appropriate response ac-
tions” (id. at A9). The legislative history, the court noted
(ibid. (citing 132 Cong. Rec. S15064-S15066 (daily ed.
Oct. 3, 1986) (joint explanatory statement); id. at H8823
(daily ed. Oct. 1, 1986) (remarks of Rep. Florio)), “affirm-
atively suggests” that the EPA need not rely on air
monitoring or establish a quantitative measure of
minimum safety. Rather, Congress contemplated growing
precision in the EPA’s regulations as more information
becomes available (Pet. App. A9-A10). The court added
(id. at AlO (emphasis in original)): “Indeed, the peti-
tioners’ insistence that EPA construct a quantitative model
before it do anything else offends common sense as well as
congressional intent, for the potential hazards posed by
presently undamaged [asbestos-containing material] ob-
viously could not be quantified or measured by air
monitoring techniques.” Especially in light of the congres-
sional directive that the EPA err on the side of caution, the
5 The court also observed (Pet. App. A7): “it is highly ironic that in-
dustry representatives assail EPA for supplying inadequate guidance
to school officials when their counsel have assured us that those of-
ficials are now thoroughly satisfied with the regulatory guidance pro-
vided by EPA.”
WO ei as nm
9
court concluded (ibid.), the EPA’s decision not to require
air monitoring or to designate certain exposure levels as
safe was not arbitrary or capricious.
The court of appeals further ruled (Pet. App. A1l1-A13)
that the EPA reasonably rejected the manufacturers’ con-
tentions that removal of asbestos should be prohibited or
limited. The court observed (id. at All (emphasis in
original)) that the EPA reasonably rejected the manufac-
turer’s evidence that removal caused increased levels of
asbestos in the air, because that evidence was “based on a
small sample of cases, in at least some of which abatement
actions were not done properly,” and the “EPA’s regula-
tions covering removal were intended to prevent this oc-
currence in the future.” The court added (id. at Al1-A12)
that “Congress apparently assumed that removal would
always be an option.” Finally, the court rejected as
“patently mistaken” the argument that removal should be
prohibited simply because it is “merely innocuous rather
than beneficial” (id. at Ai2). The court noted that the
EPA’s regulations were entirely neutral with respect to
removal and were fully in accord with congressional in-
tent, because the legislative history made clear that the
EPA “ ‘should not discourage a school from going ahead
and eliminating [its] long-term asbestos problem if school
oli.cials should decide that is the best course of action.’ ”
Ibid. (quoting 132 Cong. Rec. $15067 (daily ed. Oct. 3,
1986) (remarks of Sen. Baucus) and citing id. at S15066
(remarks of Sen. Stafford)).
ARGUMENT
The decision below is correct. It does not conflict with
any decision of this Court or of any other court of ap-
peals. Accordingly, further review by this Court is not
warranted.
10
Petitioner’s primary contention (Pet. 17-21) is that the
court of appeals failed to hold the EPA to the mandate of
AHERA and instead permitted the agency to escape its
duty because it had made a “good faith” effort. That con-
tention is wholly without merit. Nowhere in the court of
appeals’ opinion do the words “good faith” appear, and
nowhere in the opinion is there any suggestion that a mere
good faith effort to comply with a statutory mandate can
validate a regulatory action that is in fact contrary to
statutory commands. What the court of appeals concluded
was that AHERA contains “somewhat contradictory com-
mands” and that the EPA’s AHERA rules are a “rea-
sonable, faithful interpretation” of those commands in
light of current scientific knowledge (Pet. App. A8). Ac-
cordingly, the court of appeals did not, as petitioner sug-
gests, depart from ordinary principles of judicial review of
agency rulemaking.
Petitioner is also incorrect in its more focused chal-
lenges (Pet. 17-18, 20-21, 24-28) to the court of appeals’
ruling. In fact, the court correctly found the EPA’s rules
valid.6 As the court of appeals explained (Pet. App.
A8-A9), Congress directed the EPA, within 360 days, to
describe appropriate response actions for various situa-
tions presenting actual or potential asbestos problems and
to do so in a way that ensures that account would be taken
of the local conditions at more than 30,000 schools
throughout the nation. The statute further recognizes that
it is the schools, not the EPA, that are to develop the
necessary asbestos management plans. In those cir-
cumstances, it was entirely appropriate, as the court of ap-
6 Petitioner does not dispute that the regulations must be upheld
unless they are “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion or other-
wise not in accordance with law” (5 U.S.C. 706(2)(A)). See 15 U.S.C.
2618(c)(1)(B).
11
peals ruled (id. at A9), for the EPA to establish a range of
appropriate response actions together with a sound
method by which local officials, with oversight and ac-
credited expert guidance, would select the proper: actions
for particular problems.’
Similarly, given the persistent scientific disagreements
about what level of exposure to asbestos (if any) is safe
and the clear congressional directive to address potential
as well as actual exposure, the EPA acted reasonably, as
the court of appeals concluded (Pet. App. A8-A10), in
choosing to rely on expert visual inspection rather than air
monitoring and in declining to declare that certain levels
of exposure are safe. In particular, the EPA’s action fully
complied with the statutory mandate to “consider and
assess” (15 U.S.C. 2643(c)(2)) air monitoring; and the
EPA reasonably concluded, based on the risk of exposure
during peak episodes of fiber release, that visual inspec-
tion is preferable to air monitoring, which could give
school officials a false sense of security. Certainly, peti-
tioner’s suggestion that the EPA should have done nothing
until it could resolve the scientific uncertainty and con-
struct a quantitative model “offends common sense as well
as congressional intent” (Pet. App. A10).®
’ Contrary to petitioner’s suggestion (Pet. 18), the congressional
declaration that the Purple Book provided inadequate guidance is no
ground for finding the EPA rules invalid. The EPA rules furnish more
guidance than the Purple Book, including a step-by-step procedure for
LEAs to select the least burdensome response action. And the level of
detail in the guidance furnished by the EPA rules is, as noted,
reasonable in light of the commands of AHERA.
* Contrary to petitioner’s contention (Pet. 20), the court of appeals’
decision does not conflict with this Court’s decision in Jndustrial
Union Dep't v. American Petroleum Institute, 448 U.S. 607 (1980).
That case did not involve AHERA but 29 U.S.C. 652(8). The Court’s
construction in that case, without a majority opinion, of a different
12
Petitioner contends (Pet. 21-24) that this Court should
grant the petition because the ruling below is in an “area of
great national importance with far-reaching fiscal and en-
vironmental consequences” (id. at 21). But the alleged con-
sequences of petitioner’s challenge are not sufficient to
render further review of the court of appeals’ decision ap-
‘propriate, there being no intercircuit conflict and no sub-
stantial legal question presented. Moreover, aithough the
problem of asbestos in school buildings is important, peti-
tioner overstates the impact of its particular challenges.
Petitioner does not challenge the requirements that
schools conduct inspections and develop operations and
management plans for asbestos that they find. It is those
requirements that produce most of the costs associated
with the AHERA rules. Similarly, it is at best speculative
to suggest that petitioner’s challenge would have a signifi-
cant effect on the costs associated with the many lawsuits
that various building owners have brought against
asbestos manufacturers seeking reimbursement for abate-
ment. And, of course, the rules do not apply at all to non-
school buildings. Hence, even if petitioner were correct in
its challenges and the alleged deficiencies in the AHERA
rules were eliminated, allowing the court of appeals’ deci-
sion to stand would not have the far-reaching conse-
quences that petitioner states.
statute with different language and different legislative history is of
little relevance to the proper construction of AHERA in this case.
There is also no merit in petitioner’s suggestion (Pet. 20) that the
EPA’s authorization for schools to delegate their duties to expert con-
tractors (40 C.F.R. 763.80(a)) creates a constitutional delegation
problem. The regulation cited by petitioner itself makes clear that
schools retain ultimate responsibility for asbestos response actions. In
any event, insofar as delegation principles are relevant, AHERA itself
clearly provides sufficient standards to guide agency action.
13
CONCLUSION
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.
Respectfully submitted.
CHARLES FRIED
Solicitor General
ROGER J. MARZULLA
Assistant Attorney General
MARY ELIZABETH WARD
Altorney
OCTOBER 1988
w U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1988— 241-699/60713
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.