Petitioners Reply Brief — Go Air, Inc. v. Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration
Supreme Court brief1988
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No.
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1987
GO AIR, INC. Petitioner,
¥;
ADMINISTRATOR, FEDERAL AVIATION
ADMINISTRATION, and NATIONAL TRANS-
PORTATION SAFETY BOARD, Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Lawrence B. Smith
3938 E. Grant Rd., #191
Tucson, Arizona 85712
(602) 326-0283
Counsel for Petitioner
July, 1988
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Is it a violation of the Fifth
Amendment right to due process for Congress
to authorize the Administrator of the
Federal Aviation Administration to issue
emergency orders that are the equivalent of
a judicial temporary restraining order, and
which instantly shut down businesses, put
pilots out of their jobs, yet fail to
provide any hearing whatsoever where the
use of that power may be challenged?
2. Is the failure of the Federal
Aviation Administration to either publish
its emergency policies in the Federal
Register or promulgate them as rules
through public notice and comment procedur-
es a violation of the Administrative
Procedure Act which requires dismissal?
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
QUESTIONS PRESENTED @eeeoeeesee3#s+#e342se+#oee#ee#e#es#e## es @ i
OPINIONS BELOW Pe es a rE ee ee
JURISDICTION err ee ee er ee Te ee re
STATUTES INVOLVED eeeeceee#3#eoees#se#e#ee#e#tfeeeeeee##e# @ 2
STATEMENT OF THE CASE Se @€@ 08 @ 2A Ce eee 26 Oo 8 2 2 2 a 3
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT .......-2--18
I. The FAA emergency power constitutes
an executive branch TRO; failure to
provide any hearing to challenge its
use violates due proceSS ....e.eee022-18
II. FAA failure to either publish or
promulgate its emergency policies
violates the APA and requires
dismissal Pe ere re ee eee ee re ee ee
A. Failure to publi@h <.ccccustscoeceeseau
B. Failure to promulgate ..cccccccsccseeedd
CONCLUSION one ee de kinee ene eee
APPENDIX (Judgment of Court of Appeals;
Opinion and Order of the National
Transp. Safety Bd., etc.) .«...-.-a-1 tO a-/5
Certificate, Rule 28.1 Go Air, Inc., no
subsidiaries, is owned by The Go Group Un-
limited, in turn owned by Ronald J. Clark,
and affiliated with Go Group's Go Leasing,
Inc. and Royal American Airways, Inc. None
is currently operating.
ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases: Page
Aiken v. Obledo, 442 F.Supp. 628
ieGe es PRES 1977) errr rer re yy er Treree Ty
Air East, Inc. v. NTSB, 512 F.2d
1227 (3rd Cir.), cert. denied
- * Se | 5) > yb . ) Er 22
Am. Standard, Inc.. v. U.S., 602 F.2d
Zee GUemeGes CE CAMS 1979) ccccccses 34
Appalachian Power Co. v. Train, 566
Pau Wee CSG GEFs AFT) ceccccccoccce 32
Armstrong v. Manzo, 380 U.S. 545
(1965) e*eeteeeeneeneeteseetseese#ser#er#e#keeenreee#e#eeeeeee 25
Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v.
Gorsuch, 713 F.2d 802 (D.C. Cir
1983) eenrtreenrexsee#*e#s#se#e#eee#ee#eee#ee#eere#ee#e#eee#eee#ee#e#ee#e#ee#e#ee#*#ee#e« 35
Fuentes v. Shevin, 407 U.S. 67 (1971) ...23
Go Leasing, Inc. v. National Transp.
Safety Bd., 800 F.2d 1514 (9th
DER e ES Bos éeessceccoeess eccccece 58,29
Komjathy v. National Transp. Safety
Bad., 832 F.2d 1294 (D.C. Cir.
1987), cert. denied U.S.
faeee, teams CE. BO. G7°1808) wccccces 29
Matthews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319
(1976) e*eneteeseges e# ¢ @« eoeeeeenteesreensee#eeee#e#se#e 23
Morton v. Ruiz, 415 U.S. 199 (1974) .....32
Nevada Airlines v. Bond, 622 F.2d 1017
irs BOBO) geceéoees -20,21,24,26,29
iii
Northern California Power Agency v.
Morton, 396 F.Supp. 1187 (D.D.C.
1575), affirmed 539 F.2d 243 (D.C.
ge So 1976) e*eeeeeneieeecse#ee7#ee#eseesee#s25fee#e#eeee#e## eer
Pastrana v. United States, 746 F.2d
1447 (11th Cir. 1984) .....eeee eee eee 34
Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Ass'n v.
Finch, 307 F.Supp. 858 (D.C. Del.
1970) weececcccereseeseccesssessesss 35
Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Department of
Energy, 449 F.Supp. 760 (D.Del.),
affirmed 596 F.2d 1029 (Emer.Ct.App.
LD7S) cccccccccccccccccccccesescseseee3s®
South Pacific Island Airways, NTSB Order
EA-2526, May 26, 1987, SE-8089 .......20
United States v. Harper, 335 F. Supp.
504 (De. BASS. 1972) cocccscsccsces Tree?
Constitution and Statutes:
U.S. Const. Amend V (Due Process
opt a rrrrrrrTrrrrrrerrs --18,23,29
Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C.
§§ 551-559, 702-706 (1982):
§ 551(4) wccccccvees Pererrrre rs Seer 33
§ 552(a) (1) coccccccccccsccess ee e31,33,35
§ S53 cccccccccccces coccccccccce 3 5954,35
§ 706 coccccccccccccssceces cocccccccce 35
Federal Aviation Act of 1958, as amended,
49 U.S.C. app. §§ 1301-1552 (1982):
§ 1429(a) (§ 609) ccc e eee eel, 2,19,30
iv
G 1488 cccccccccccscccccccsccssccesesceds
G 1486 wccccccccccccccsccccsescseesessyar
G 1487 cccccvcccccccccccccccccsccesslgae
Regulations:
Civil Aeronautics Regulations:
14 C.F.R. § 408.25 (1952) ..-.222.229,36
Federal Aviation Regulations, 14
C.F.R. Parts 1-199 (1988):
G 13.19 ccccccccccsesecccccscssseesesessu
G 13.25 acccccccccccveccccesesssceseseal
Miscellaneous:
Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(b) wccceeceeeeee 22,27
Compliance and Enforcement Program,
FAA Order 2150.3 (1980) wccccccccccsee3dl
No.
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1987
GO AIR, INC., Petitioner,
Ve
ADMINISTRATOR, FEDERAL AVIATION
ADMINISTRATION, and NATIONAL TRANS-
PORTATION SAFETY BOARD, Respondents.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Petitioner Go Air, Inc. respectfully
prays that a writ of certiorari issue to
review the judgment (without opinion) of
the United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit, entered in
this proceedings March 7, 1988; Order
Extending Time to File Petition For Writ of
Certiorari to and including July 5, 1988,
entered by this Court on May 6, 1988.
OPINIONS BELOW
The judgment of the Court of Appeals for
the District of Columbia Circuit is not
reported, and is reprinted in the appendix.
(a-41). The opinion and order of the
National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB)
has not yet been reported. It is reprinted
in the appendix. (a-29)
JURISDICTION
The Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA), on May ?, 1985, initiated an
enforcement action against petitioner,
under 49 U.S.C. app. § 1429(a), by ordering
1
on an emergency basis the revocation of its
FAA Repair Station operating certificate.
The company appealed to the NTSB, under §
1429(a), hearing was held by an administra-
tive law judge on May 5, 1986 at which
petitioner was unable to contest the
charges, and his initial decision upholding
the revocation was affirmed by NTSB Order
No. EA-2431, Nov. 7, 1986, SE-6767. Go Air,
Inc. then petitioned the Court of Appeals
for the Dastrict of Columbia Circuit for
review, uider 49 U.S.C. § 1486. That court
entered jwdgment affirming the NTSB order
on March 7, 1988.
The jurisdiction of this Court to review
the judgment of the District of Columbia
Circuit is invoked under 28 U.S.C. §
1254(1) and 49 U.S.C. § 1486(f).
STATUTES INVOLVED
The statutes and regulations directly
relevant to the issues are here listed,
with their text set forth in the appendix:
2
EEO EOE OO Eee |
Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C.
§§ 551-559, 702-706 (1982): §§ 551(4),
552(a) (1), 553, 558, 706;
Federal Aviation Act of 1958, as
amended, 49 U.S.C. app. §§ 1301-1552
(1982): §§ 1429(a), 1485, 1486, 1487.
Federal Aviation Regulations (FARs), 14
C.F.R. Parts 1-199 (1988): §§ 13.19, 13.25.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On May 3, 1985 FAA officials served an
emergency order which combined the cases
and revoked the operating certificates of
three affiliated Tucson companies: petitio-
ner Go Air, Inc., holder of an FAA Part 145
Repair Station Certificate, Go Leasing,
Inc., holder of a Part 125 private, large-
aircraft charter certi- ficate, and Royal
American Airways, Inc., holder of a Part
121 air carrier certificate. All were owned
or controlled by The Go Group Unlimited, a
holding company, owned by Ronald J. Clark.
Revocation was ordered on grounds that
3
the companies, because of the multiplicity
of maintenance and bookkeeping violations
charged, failed to "exercise the degree of
care, judgment and responsibility required
of the holder" of their respective certifi-
cates, which demonstrated a lack of quali-
fications. (a-25)
Clark, mainly because its charges were
less extensive and it was then providing
the only cash flow ($750k/mo.), elected to:
take just Go Leasing to the accelerated
hearing afforded emergency cases. Royal
American had been temporarily shut down
three weeks earlier. Although Go Air did
the others' maintenance, there was no
requirement they use a licensed repair
station: its mechanics could have gone on
Go Leasing's payroll, or worked indepen-
dently. The urgency was to save Go Leasing
with its contracts it could still perform.
At the June 1985 Tucson hearing the
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) found its
4
revocation to be unjustified and reduced it
to a ten-month suspension.1! Royal American
and Go Air came to trial December 9, 1985
in Los Angeles, but when the ALJ saw Royal
American could not be finished that week,
he put it over to February 1986 in Denver--
where he lived. With cashflow gone, Clark
couldn't afford the enormous cost of
transportation and lodging for lawyers and
witnesses a thousand miles from Tucson.2 So
a certificate conservatively worth $500,000
was lost. Despite strong objection, the ALJ
later set Go Air for May 1986 in Phoenix,3
but lodging made that prohibitive too, so
no defense was presented.
It is critical to note that at none of
1 see, Go Leasing, Inc. v. NTSB, 800
F.2d 1514 (9th Cir. 1986).
Los Angeles was arranged because
Clark's lawyer and by this time certain key
witnesses lived there; Clark had a home
there in which witnesses could be lodged.
And it was fair to expect the cases would
be tried to their conclusion there.
At 120 miles, too long a commute.
these hearings could the government's use
of the emergency power, which overrides an
otherwise automatic statutory stay of any
suspension or revocation, be challenged.
The NTSB will not entertain the issue, and
the FA Act provides no other recourse.
As a result of the emergency revoca-
tions, 143 persons (about 70 of them at Go
Air) lost their jobs, all but twenty immed-
iately, those a few months later. When
Clark shut down the next morning, three
Rock bands and hundreds of Club Med members
were left stranded.4 Go Leasing had $3
million of in-house contracts, not includ-
ing Club Med, and could expect another $2
million to pop up later in the year.>°
The Go Group operated from its $4 mil-
4 May 3 was a Friday. Many lawyers
believe FAA officials serve emergency
orders late on Fridays to make it difficult
to get a TRO from a federal judge.
Too often lost sight of in these
cases is the impact on banks, creditors,
leasing companies, stockholders...
lion dollar base at Tucson International
Airport with a Fort Lauderdale, Fla.,
satellite. It owned twenty Vickers Viscount
four-engine turbo-prop aircraft of which
ten were being operated®. Go Leasing
chartered seven of these, which were in
executive (arm-chair) configuration, to
Rock bands and other entertainers such as
Lawrence Welk, who would use them on
concert tours, often six months or more.
Royal American had flown some scheduled
routes for Air-Florida, but mostly charte-
red to Caribbean casinos and resort hotels.
Mr. Clark and Go Air were both in Chapter
11 in 1985 due to a failed attempt to start
a L.A.-Las Vegas discount airline. But with
Go Leasing's growing cash flow he was well
on his way towards reorganization.
How was it that FAA officials took such
6 The Viscount was a popular British
‘50s and ‘60s airliner. The executive ver-
sions came from major corporations.
a drastic step they well knew would destroy
Clark's operations? It got started when Go
Leasing's principal operating inspector
(POI) objected to a contract to fly Club
Med members from Miami to its Dominican
Republic resort at Punta Cana. / Shortly
thereafter, FAA lawyers--one of whom admit-
ted at the hearing that reasonable men
could disagree about whether the contract
did violate the rules--invited the company
to seek an exemption--which, if granted,
would have made it all legal. Clark prompt-
ly applied to these same officials, who
then ignored it, nor did they ever tell him
they would bring an action if he didn't
7 The claim was that Go Leasing was
indirectly "holding out" through Club Med,
so big, membership fee so low ($30), that
it was in effect selling air transporta-
tion. See Go Leasing, 800 F.2d at 1524-26.
This is hard to accept since the airstrip
at Punta Cana was Club Med's own, nothing
else was there, the nearest airport was
four hours away over bad roads, and it cost
a $700+ vacation package to go there, of
which air travel was but a minor part.
cease and desist;8 two weeks later they
dispatched a special inspection team to
audit the entire Go Group operation.
For five full weeks, February 20 to
March 27, eight inspectors were on the
premises going through files and records on
personnel and airplanes, much of it years
old. They drew up a list of claimed
discrepancies. Five weeks after March 27th,
when they finished, using that list for his
claimed safety violations, FAA regional
counsel DeWitte Lawson, on May 2nd, issued
the "emergency" order on grounds the
companies were "immediate" threats to air
safety. (a-26)
Salient facts In the 15 years Mr. Clark
had been carrying dozens of entertainment
groups and thousands of passengers in his
8 Although there were minor problems
which could have been solved, or likely
given exemptions, Clark, were he warned,
could have switched the service to Royal
American's air carrier certificate, which
was Clearly lawful.
Ee ee
Viscounts he had never had an accident, not
even an incident like an engine fire; his
multitudinous aviation operations, which at
one time included a world-wide DC-7 freight
operation, and an executive jet service,
had never even had a violation of record.
No complaint about any operation had come
from the public before the emergency order.
Club Med was most happy with the service.
None of the charges involved false
entries, or pilots flying when they had not
had their required six-month check ride,
the sort that usually underpin immediate
safety concerns. The worst sounding were
those that claimed Royal American had oper-
ated two aircraft with several appliances
(e.g., a flap motor) that had not been
overhauled within the time required, alled-
gedly making them unairworthy for a thous-
and hours of previous flight. This was a
phony issue. All these appliances had been
bought from United Air Lines' surplus stock
10
of spares from its retired Viscount fleet.
The real claim was that the UAL tags on
these parts which certified overhaul were
not sufficient evidence of that, although
the exact same tags were accepted by UAL'sS
FAA inspectors. United destroys overhaul
paper-work after two years, but the tag
continues to serve as proof.
The principal maintenance inspectors for
Royal American? had been accepting these
tags as lawful evidence of overhaul for at
least four years. Moreover, by the time of
the emergency order, Royal American was
shut down and the very two aircraft to
which these charges applied had, with the
approval of the principal inspectors in
Phoenix, been transferred to Go Leasing's
certificate where these same overhaul rules
did not apply so that the aircraft were
9 All operating certificates have
named inspectors--operations, maintenance,
etc.--assigned to them. The Go Group's
operated out of Phoenix.
11
Ee
perfectly legal. Vague claims about lack of
management ignored the fact that the Go
Group's had been specifically approved by
its principal inspectors; at the time of
the special inspection, Clark had already
added a top manager to the repair station
to help with the physical reorganization of
it shop and huge parts supply; that Clark
had shut down Royal American, when two key
personnel left in order to concentrate
management on Go Leasing. In other words,
the criticism, even if valid, at the time
of the emergency was weeks out of date.
Anyone reading the emergency order would
agree that the operations sounded so bad
they should have been shut down. They would
also agree that the principal maintenance
and operations inspectors obviously were
incompetent and should have been fired,
deruted or transferred. In fact, the prin-
cipai maintenance inspector and assistant
were promoted, operations untouched.
12
aii Le
The Go Group was probably one of the
most surveilled operations in the country,
with inspectors in and out almost weekly.
During the pendency of a short-lived suit
in federal district court (dismissed for
lack of jurisdiction), discovery produced
hundreds of documents, especially surveil-
lance reports for the preceding year, 1984.
Of these, 97.6% were “satisfactory.” Those
unsatisfactory (there are only the two
ratings), were usually for a minor main-
tenance problem, always corrected by the
next report.
Three retired FAA regional counsel
agreed with this attorney that a team of
inspectors can go into any operation, the
bigger, the easier, and find a multitude of
seeming technical violations. The 76,000 of
Eastern in recent times is an example. (FAA
doesn't shut down large carriers, but lets
them pay civil money fines.)
During any special inspection the team
13
is directed to tell the operator and its
principal inspectors!9° if it finds any
problem that reflects on air safety, so, if
necessary, it can be immediately remedied.
During the five-week inspection, when the
team inspectors were of course aware Go
Leasing was carrying hundreds of Club Med
members every week, they did this just
twice:11 (1) they found that a single
generator (of four) on one Viscount had
been calibrated by bench-test equipment
itself several months overdue on its own
calibration. At a cost near $10,000, Mr.
Clark immediately grounded the aircraft in
Freeport, Bahamas, chartered another
airplane to return the passengers the fifty
miles or so to Florida, flew another
generator out, then brought the plane back.
10 who do not participate, since one
purpose is to show them where they may have
been lax.
11 and in neither instance did they
insist it be done right away.
14
ta
(2) The team discovered that two
recently hired flight attendants, during
their emergency training in the Viscount,
due to a regulatory misunderstanding by the
chief flight attendant, and because the two
women had done so with their previous
carrier, did not actually activate the
emergency evacuation chute as required. The
next morning at Ft. Lauderdale they did so.
Problem remedied.
That these were the only two discrepan-
cies so treated by the team during the five
weeks undercuts any claim of an immediate
threat to air safety as, of course, does
the five-week delay after the inspection.
Also relevant is the fact that the FAA
officials who initiated the special
inspection and this case deliberately
violated their own formal requirement that
at the end of such the operator be allowed
to rebut, mitigate or correct any deficien-
cies found. Although specifically promised,
15
Clark was never allowed to see it.
There is strong reason to believe that
the motive behind the use of the emergency
power was retribution. In 1978 these same
FAA officials had conducted a three-month
investigation into Clark's Viscount
operations. Even with an FAA lawyer from
another region as a kind of agreed-upon
referee on claimed civil penalties, out of
more than a hundred charges involving
operations, maintenance and claimed
subterfuge in violation of Civil Aeronaut-
ics Board (CAB) air charter regulations,
not a single one was proved convincing. Two
months later regional counsel] Lawson, after
seeking more than $100,000, the same who
signed the emergency order here, suggested
a compromise civil penalty of $2,000.
Clark, who'd spent $85,000 in legal fees
defending, declined. Lawson, who could have
pursued the matter through a United States
Attorney in district court, took no further
16
EEO
action. In the Go Leasing hearing, Clark
testified under oath that when he called
Lawson the evening of the day the emergency
order was served, among other things,
Lawson said, “I've got you this time."
It is this writer's opinion that at
least 80% of the long list of charges were
invalid or utterly deminimus. Mr. Lawson,
himself, at the start of the Royal American
hearing voluntarily dropped a substantial
number. It is fact that the Go Group's
principal inspectors did not know that top
region officials were going to revoke the
three companies, nor were they consulted.
The inspection team leader was heard by
this writer to say that he'd had no idea
revocation was going to be used. In other
words, this drastic action was conceived
only by top officials unsupported by those
who conducted the special inspection or the
inspectors responsible for and familiar
with the certificate holders.
17
ee es
None of the charges constituted any real
threat to air safety. In the two instances
noted, where the team felt management
should be alerted, remedial action was
instantaneous. Of those that may have been
valid, any and all could have been cor-
rected overnight, or the aircraft volun-
tarily grounded, had management been told
what the discrepancies were. It is obvious
this was not done because it would have
left no basis for the claim five weeks
later that there was an “immediate” threat
to air safety.
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
I. The FAA emergency power constitutes an
executive branch TRO; failure to provide
any hearing to challenge its use violates
the Fifth Amendment right to due process.
Petitioner's statement of the case shows
clearly that in any emergency, where safety
violations form the basis for revoking an
18
operating certificatel2 (rather than a dis-
abling failure to meet some specific regu-
latory requirement laid down for holding
it) the issue of whether the operator is a
threat to air safety is distinctly separate
from the issue of guilt. Holding a hearing
on the air-safety impact issue, necessary
because the emergency power is draconian in
the extreme and open to abuse, is entirely
feasible. Yet Congress failed to provide
any. That failure, on its face, violates
rudimentary concepts of due process.
FAA suspension and revocation of certif-
icates is ordered pursuant to the FA Act, §
609, 49 U.S.C. app. § 1429(a).13 That order
may be appealed to the NTSB (for a hearing
12 These cases are rarely brought for
any other reason.
FAA also relies on section 1005,
49 U.S.C. § 1485, which deals with emergen-
cy orders. It is not clear this is needed:
the act makes no cross-reference, and
certificate action is authorized only by
section 609, but the question is of no
moment since it doesn't change the issue.
19
de novo). Id. The appeal carries an auto-
matic stay of the order
unless the [Administrator] advises the
National Transportation Safety Board
that an emergency exists and safety in
air commerce or air transportation
requires the immediate effectiveness of
his order, in which event the order
shall remain effective and the National
Transportation Safety Board shall
finally dispose of the appeal within
sixty days after being so advised by the
[Administrator].
Id. But here is the problem:
SPIA also argues that the evidence
did not justify the grounding of its
aircraft, and the Board should therefore
terminate the emergency suspension. As
the Administrator points out, the Board
has held repeatedly that the Administra-
tor's determination that an emergency
exists is not subject to Board review.
South Pacific Island Airways, NTSB Order
EA-2526 at 3, n. 4, May 26, 1987, SE-8089
[emphasis added]; see also, Nevada Air-
lines, Inc. v. Bond, 622 F. 2d 1017, 1020
n. 4 (9th Cir. 1980). Obviously, this
leaves the FA Act with a serious void.
It was two decades before an appeals
court noted it, and recognized that viola-
20
tion guilt is distinctly separate from the
issue of threat to air safety:
Our initial concern is with the review-
ability of the emergency revocation
order. We distinguish here the Adminis-
trator's determination that an emergency
warranted immediate effectiveness of the
order from his underlying substantive
determination that revocation was war-
ranted. Under section 609(a) of the
Federal Aviation Act .. ., the latter
determination may be reviewed by peti-
tion to this court after resolution of
the administrative appeal pending before
the NTSB. Whether the former determina-
tion is reviewable now is an issue of
first impression.
We are persuaded .. . that Nevada
Airline's claim for relief is cognizable
at this time,14 even though administra-
tive remedies remain available to chal-
lenge the underlying revocation order.
Nevada Airlines, supra, 622 F.2d at 1019.
To this point, challenges always arose as
part of the review of the NTSB decision.
The due process violation urged was usually
lack of notice, during some extended period
14 the airline immediately sought an
injunction against the emergency order in
district court; the judge dismissed for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction, thus
the appeal. 622 F.2d at 1018.
21
of time after an inspection, that FAA
planned to use the emergency power.15 See
Air East, tInc. ¥. Wes, $12 F.28@ i227? tare.
Cir.), cert. denied, 423 U.S. 863 (1975).
The lack of notice issue is off the
mark. The real issue is right to an immed-
iate hearing in which to challenge the
emergency order, just as one would have
with a temporary restraining order (TRO).
See Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(b). It is the ess-
ence of a TRO that it can be granted, if
necessary, without notice to the other par-
ty. But that is ameliorated by a prompt
hearing, usually within ten days. 1d.16
15 petitioner has noted the delay in
its own case, but only to show there was a
legitimate question whether its operation
was truly a threat to air safety, and it
should have been afforded an immediate
satin: to challenge the emergency.
16 Nor does any FAA official have to
state under oath the compelling reasons for
such drastic action--as is required by Rule
65(b)--which would give the operator or
pilot something to challenge. All that is
provided is the unsworn and bare statement:
"Based upon the foregoing circumstances,
the Administrator .. . has determined that
22
Wyzanski, J., the eminent jurist, was
quick to see this and said that a section
609 emergency order "might be regarded as
analogous to a judicial temporary restrain-
ing order issued ex parte in an emergency."
United States v. Harper, 335 F.Supp. 904,
906 (D. Mass. 1972). He explained:
"The right of a person to be heard
before he is deprived of his property by
governmental action is the most elemen-
tary, fundamental, and comprehensive of
the rights guaranteed by the due process
clause of the Fifth Amendment. [Citing
cases] .. . Such a guarantee may be
validly limited only under the most com-
pelling circumstances and then generally
only for the briefest of periods... .
Id. at 906-07. See also Fuentes v. Shevin,
407 U.S. 67, 80 (1971) (parties whose
rights are to be affected are entitled to
be heard); Matthews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S.
319 (1976).
The Ninth Circuit in Nevada Airlines
safety in air commerce and the public
interest require the immediate revocation,
on an emergency basis, of .. . Repair
Station Certificate No. 434-1." (a-26)
23
failed to recognize the order as an
executive-branch TRO, but did note its
unfairness. It explained that
[a] lthough the administrative appeal is
expedited in these emergency situations,
the net effect is suspension without
prior notice and hearing for a period of
up to 60 days. .. . The emergency
determination would deprive the certifi-
cate holder of a significant property
interest and affects substantial rights
that might be lost if review is denied
or delayed.
This determination could not be
insulated from prompt judicial review
without raising serious due process
concerns.
622 F.2d at 1019-20 (footnote omitted). The
clear holding here is that 60 days violates
due process, it is far too long, and vir-
tually assures that any aviation business
will be destroyed.
The problem with Nevada Airlines,
however, is that instead of simply declar-
ing section 609 unconstitutional, the Ninth
Court tried to patch together a solution
out of the FA Act. It determined that
Congress had solved it when it gave the
24
courts of appeals exclusive jurisdiction
over FAA orders in section 1006, 49 U.S.C.
app. 1486(a). In our view, this is without
merit. There is no evidence Congress had in
mind the emergency hearing problem when it
drafted section 1006. In fact, any reading
of that section indicates that the orders
it contemplates result from evidentiary and
adjudicated proceedings. This is precisely
what an emergency order is not. It is an
arbitrary ex parte order signed by a single
FAA functionary.
The Nevada court's confused approach may
be shown by the comment: “We recognize the
difficulty facing a petitioner in marshall-
ing evidence at this stage, but we find no
showing that the Administrator's finding of
an emergency was unreasonable.” 622 F.2d at
1021. An appeals court is an eminently ill-
equipped place to do that. The opportunity
to be heard must be granted "in a meaning-
ful manner." Armstrong v. Manzo, 380 U.S.
25
)
545, 552 (1965). The only way that that can
be done is with the full assortment of
federal discovery procedures, along with a
hearing in which FAA officials can be sub-
poenaed and cross-examined. Which means
district court. "Where we are given no
concrete information casting doubt on the
authenticity or gravity of any of the
Administrator's charges, we shall not
interfere with his determination that
summary action was required.” 622 F.2d at
1021. Absent a explicit statutory provis-
ion, where would the practitioner learn how
to advance his client's rights, other than
by reading Nevada Airlines?
What the Ninth Court was doing here, in
our view, was legislating a solution for
the sloppy job Congress did.1’ How would
17 No legislative history indicates
the FA Act was considered by either judi-
ciary committee. It is common knowledge
its passage was hurried because of the 1956
Grand Canyon UAL-TWA collision, followed by
three military jet fighters ramming into
26
its determination be binding in the Fourth
Circuit, Eighth? Moreover, if its solution
is so obvious, why had no one else seen it
in the preceding twenty-two years?
Interestingly--and overlooked--was the
fact that Congress provided an additional
path to follow in an emergency which, when
contrasted with sections 609 and 1005,
highlights their unconstitutionality. It
has given the FAA abundant authority to
seek remedies, specifically including
injunctions, for any enforcement problem,
through United States Attorneys and
District Court. FA Act § 1007, 49 U.S.C.
app. 1487;18 see 14 C.F.R. § 13.25. Using
this procedure would of course bring into
play the protections afforded by Rule
65(b). But given the choice between
airliners, one on the very eve of hearings.
Given the express authority here
for FAA to go to district court, one would
think Congress made it plain that that
court has subject matter jurisdiction over
protective orders against FAA overreaching.
27
,
Gictating a form letter to his secretary
which only needs his signature and cannot
be contested, and selling the need for an
emergency order which will destroy a busi-
ness, first to a United States Attorney,
then to a federal judge, with detailed
affidavits supporting the matter, which can
be challenged in a prompt hearing, it is
not difficult to see which route FAA
regional counsel will take.
Almost all these cases involve weeks of
preparation. It would be rare indeed when
the agency would have to get a district
judge out of bed. And it should be noted,
were the section 609 emergency power
declared unconstitutional, FAA's power to
seek a remedy is in no way crippled until
Congress should act: it would simply be
forced to use the section 1007 district
court procedure, where the right of a
prompt hearing would be assured.
The District of Columbia Circuit in the
28
a
instant case, without elaboration, chose to
follow Go Leasing, Inc. v. NTSB, 800 F.2d
1514 (9th Cir. 1986).19 (a-42). Since that
relies on Nevada Airlines, id. at 1523-24,
we ask, in effect, review of the latter.
The Ninth Court properly recognized the
dichotomy in issues--guilt vs. threat--and
lack of a prompt hearing, but its solution
was constitutionally inappropriate.
The failure to provide a prompt and
meaningful hearing in which to challenge
FAA use of its emergency power denied
petitioner Go Air, Inc. its Fifth Amendment
right to due process. 20
19 It also cited Komjathy v. NTSB,
832 F.2d 1294 (D.C. Cir.), cert. denied,
U.S. (1988) (Sup. Ct. No. 87-
1805), but it is not relevant, as no
emergency was involved.
Compare the Civil Aeronautics Ad-
ministration (CAA) emergency rule which
provided it “shall enter upon a hearing
which shall be disposed of as speedily as
possible . . ." 14 C.F.R. § 408.25 (1952)
(a-66). Since the “immediate” threat
criteria is contained in this rule, it is
fair to assume that that could be made an
issue in such a hearing.
29
———————————
II. FAA failure to either publish or pro-
mulgate its emergency policies violates the
Administrative Procedure Act and requires
dismissal.
A. Failure to publish In its rules, see
FAR § 13.19(d), 14 C.F.R. § 13.19(d), FAA
merely adverts to the emergency power by
reciting the language of section 609, 49
U.S.C. § 1429(a). The policy which imple-
ments it is found only in an agency manual:
Gg. Emergency orders of suspension or
revocation.
(1) Basis for issuance.
(a) Emergency suspension or revo-
cation of a certificate should be used
only as an emergency safety measure and,
thus, to provide immediate protection to
the public. Generally, the longer the
interval between the date of the incid-
ent and the date of the action, the more
difficult it will be for the FAA to
Claim that an emergency exists. There-
fore, emergency actions should be taken
as soon aS posSible after the date of
the incident.
(b) An emergency suspension or rev-
ocation should never be used for puni-
tive reasons. When receiving a recom-
mendation for emergency action, counsel
should ensure that there is sufficient
evidence of an emergency requiring imm-
ediate effectiveness of an order of sus-
pension or revocation. ...
30
Compliance & Enforcement Program, FAA Order
2150.3, 4 1203.9. at p. 173 [emphasis
added) [1980 Handbook].
The APA provides that each agency shall
"publish in the Federal Register for the
guidance of the public-- .. . [inter alia]
[1] rules of procedure .. . [2] statements
of general policy or [3) interpretations of
general applicability formulated and
adopted by the agency .. .” 5 U.S.C. §
552(a) (1). Unless the person has actuéi and
timely notice, "a person may not in any
manner be required to resort to, or be
adversely affected by, a matter required to
be published in the Federal Register and
not so published. .. ." Id. This is a
legislative exclusionary rule, the only
remecy should an agency fail to publish.
Careful inspection of the Federal
Register reveals the emergency policy has
never been published since FAA's creation
in 1958. Thus the only issue is whether it
31
a
eee
meets one or more of the categories noted.
It arguably meets all three, but certainly
is both a [2] and a [3]. Publication in an
agency manual is not sufficient to meet APA
requirements. Morton v. Ruiz, 415 U.S. 199
(1974). "The statute [5 U.S.C. § 552(a) (1)]
clearly provides that no administrative
action taken pursuant to unpublished
procedures can be allowed to stand against
a person adversely affected thereby."
Northern California Power Agency v. Morton,
396 F.Supp. 1187, 1191 (D.D.C. 1975),
attivues 539 F.2G 243 (D.C. Cir. 1976).
"Any agency regulation that so directly
affects preexisting legal rights or oblig-
gations .. . indeed, that is ‘of such a
nature that knowledge of it is needed to
keep the outside interests informed of the
agency's requirements in respect of any
subject within its competence,’ is within
the publication requirement." Appalachian
Power Co. v. Train, 566 F.2d 451, 455 (4th
32
Cir. 1977). Unless determined that the
emergency policy is not a [1], [2] or [3]
category, FAA's failure to publish requires
dismissal. 5 U.S.C. § 552(a) (1).
B. Failure to promulgate. The emergency
policy constitutes a "rule" as defined by
the APA: "rule" means the whole or a part
of an agency statement of general or parti-
cular applicability and future effect des-
igned to implement, interpret, or prescribe
law or policy or describing the organiza-
tion, procedu 2, or practice requirements
of an agency .. ." 5 U.S.C. § 551(4). The
basic question, however, is whether or not
a "rule" is "substantive" within the
meaning of id. § 553(d) ("The required
publication of a substantive rule shall be
made ..."). If so, it must be adopted
pursuant to formal procedures which
require, inter alia, notice of proposed
rulemaking published in the Federal
Register, with a statement of basis and
33
purpose (NPRM), opportunity for public
comment, and publication of the rule as
finally adopted. Id. § 553(b).
It is clearly substantive: it affects a
property right. See Pastrana v. United
States, 746 F.2d 1447 (11th Cir. 1984).
Search of the Federal Register since 1958
reveals no such NPRM. "The reviewing court
shall--hold unlawful and set aside agency
action . .. found to be-- .. . not in
accordance with law." Aiken v. Obledo, 442
F.Supp. 628, 650 (D.C. Calif. 1977); see 5
U.S.C. § 706(2) (A). "The purpose of requi-
ring a statement of the basis and purpose
is to enable courts, which have the duty to
exercise review, to be aware of the legal
and factual framework underlying the agen-
cy's action." Am. Standard, Inc. v. U.S.,
602 F.2d 256, 269 (U.S.Ct. of Claims 1979).
Section 553(b), was meant to provide an
opportunity for public participation in the
rule making process when that process re-
34
sults in the promulgation of rules or regu-
lations of substantial impact. Pharmaceu-
tical Mfrs. Assoc. v. Finch, 307 F.Supp.
858 (D. Del. 1970); Phillips Petroleum Co.
v. Dep't of Energy, 449 F.Supp. 760 (D.
Del.), affirmed 596 F.2d 1029 (Emer.Ct.App.
1978). “Any claim of exemption from APA
rulemaking requirements ‘will be narrowly
construed and only reluctantly coun-
tenanced.' [Citing cases]" Environmental
Defense Fund, Inc. v. Gorsuch, 713 F.2d
802, 816 (D.C. Cir. 1983). Unless the
emergency policy is found not to be
substantive in nature, FAA failure to
promulgate it requires dismissal. 5 U.S.C.
§§ 552(a) (1), 553 and 706. It is difficult
to see how FAA could so claim, or that the
policy should at least be published, since
the CAA, from which it metamorphosed, as
noted above, had an emergency rule no doubt
the origin of FAA's handbook policy:
"Under section 609 of the act, in
35
cases of emergency .. . [the CAA
Administrator may suspend a certificate
if] the condition or conduct of a certi-
ficate holder is such as to indicate
immediate danger of injury to person or
damage to property, and the immediate
suspension of the certificate might
reasonably be expected to avert such
injury or damage...
14 C.F.R. § 408.25 (1952) (a-66). Even
assuming the worst case, that there might
have been a threat to air safety between
February 20 and March 27, 1985, what did
that have to do with May 2nd? Was not
petitioner entitled to a formal due process
hearing in which to determine that? And a
formal rule on which to base that chal-
lenge?
CONCLUSION
For these various reasons, this petition
for certiorari should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
LAWRENCE B. SMITH
3938 E. Grant Rd., #191
Tucson AZ 85712
602/326-0283
Counsel for Petitioner
July 1988
36
APPENDIX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FAA Order of SuSpensSion ....cceeceeves
NTSB Opinion and Order ....cccecccvcces
Dist. Of Col. Circuit Judgment ..ccces
Supreme Court Order extending time ...
U.S. Const. Amend V ....
5 Uebeote
49 U.S.C.
14 C.F.R.
14 C.F.R.
§ 551(4)
§ 552(a)(1) ...
§
§
553 eoeeees#sseen#e*enteenteeneeeeteeeee
706 eoeeeene7e*enee*eenee#eee#ee#ees#?#e##
app.
§
§
§
§
§
§
§
1429 (a) cece
1486
1487
408.25 (1952)
13.19
13.25
US Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
Western-Pacific Region
Los Angeles, California
Case No. 85WP070100
Royal American Airways, Inc.
Case No. 85WP070099
Go Leasing, Inc.
Case No. 85WP070098
Go Air, Ine.
Case No. 85WP070044
Go Leasing, Inc.
May 2, 1985
To: Mr. Ronald J. Clark, President
ROYAL AMERICAN AIRWAYS, INC.
GO LEASING, INC.
GO AIR, INC.
100 East Valencia
Tucson International Airport
Tucson, Arizona 85706
EMERGENCY ORDER OF REVOCATION
It has been determined by the Administrator
of the Federal Aviation Administration,
acting by and through his Regional Counsel,
that:
I.
1. Royal American Airways, Inc., (RAMA) is,
and at all times mentioned herein was, the
a-l
holder of Air Carrier Operating Certificate
No. ASW-61 and is thereby authorized to
engage in air transportation under the
supplemental rules of Part 121 of the
Federal Aviation Regulations (FAR's)
utilizing Viscount, model 700 aircraft.
2. Go Leasing, Inc. (Go Inc.) is, and at
all time mentioned herein was, the holder
of Operating Certificate No. WE-34-1 and is
thereby authorized to conduct commercial
operations under Part 125 of the FAR's
utilizing Viscount, model 700 aircraft.
3. Go Air, Inc. (Go Air) is, and at all
times mentioned herein was, the holder of
Repair Station Certificate No. 434-1 and is
thereby authorized to perform maintenance
on aircraft components in accordance with
Part 145 of the FAR's and the ratings of
its certificate.
p. 1
4. Commencing on or about February 20,
1985, and until on or about March 27, 1985,
a-2
the FAA conducted an Operational and
Airworthiness inspection of RAMA, Go Inc.
and Go Air. Said inspection disclosed facts
which include the following:
a. Ronald J. Clark is the president of
RAMA, Go Inc. and Go Air and the
Director of Operations for RAMA and Go
Inc.
b. The principal office for all three
organizations is the same address in
Tucson, Arizona.
c. The position of Director of Main-
tenance for all three organizations is
held by the same person.
d. The position of Chief Inspector for
all three organization is held by the
Same person.
e. The Chief Pilot for RAMA and Go Inc.
is the same person.
f. RAMA does not have a full time
General Manager as required by FAR
121.59.
a-3
g. RAMA does not have a full time
Director of Operations as required by
FAR 121.59.
h. RAMA does not have a full time
Director of Maintenance as required by
FAR 121.59.
i. RAMA does not have a full time Chief
Pilot as required by FAR 121.59.
j. RAMA does not have a full time Chief
Inspector as required by FAR 121.59
k. As a result, RAMA does not have
enough qualified management personnel to
provide the highest degree of safety in
its 121 operations as required by FAR
121.59.
1. Go Leasing does not have enough
management personnel, including the
Director of Operations as to assure that
its operations are conducted in accor-
dance with requirements of Part 125
operations as required by FAR 125.25.
a es
m. Pilot records, flight records,
training records, flight and dispatch
releases for RAMA and Go Inc. are
maintained in the same location (room).
mn. RAMA and Go Inc. conduct operations
using a total of sixteen pilots. Eight
pilots engage in flight for both RAMA
and Go Inc.
©. RAMA and Go Inc. conduct operations
using a total of nine flight attendants.
Seven flight attendants are used on both
RAMA and Go Inc. flights.
p. The functioning, activities, person-
nel, officers and management of RAMA and
Go Inc. are so joined, intermixed and
indistinguishable as to constitute a
single FAR Part 121 air carrier opera-
tion.
eet ®t
x*eetee
p. 3.
IV. GO AIR INC.
a-5
1. Go Air, Inc. maintained or altered the
following instruments and radios and
approved them for return to service.
a. VHF Transmitter, Part Number TA-20A-
1, Serial Number 61 on 10-29-84.
(Installed No. 2 position, N200RC).
b. VOR Receiver, Part Number 51R3,
Serial Number 5000 on 10-29-84. (In-
stalled No. 1 position, N200RC).
c. Marker Beacon Receiver, Part Number
MN61B, Serial Number 1-824 on 10-25-84.
(Installed N200RC).
d. Fuel Quantity Indication, Part Number
300-1N-135, Serial Number 31 on 10-25-
84. (Installed, unknown).
e. Marker Beacon Receiver, Part Number
MN-61B, Serial Number 1-544, 10-25-84.
(Installed, N24V, 10-31-84).
2. Go Air, Inc. was not rated under its
Part 145 certificate to maintain or alter
the instruments or radios listed in
paragraph 1 above.
3. The instruments or radios listed in
paragraph 1 a, b and c above were installed
and utilized on an aircraft operated by Go
Leasing, Inc. under its Part 125 operations
specifications. The instrument listed in
paragraph le above was installed and utili-
zed on an aircraft operated by RAMA under
its Part 121 operations specifications.
4. The maintenance or alteration performed
by Go Air, Inc. did not comply with RAMA's
Part 121 continuous airworthiness program
or Go Leasing, Inc.'s approved inspection
program.
5. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraph 1 thru 4 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Secticns 145.2(a) and (b) of the
Federal Aviation Regulations.
6. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 1 and 2 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 145.53 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
7. The airworthiness inspection conducted
by the FAA described in paragraph 1.4 above
revealed the following deficiencies in the
Go Air, Inc. facilities equipment and
materials:
a. Stock room-
(1) The stock room area was open to
dirt and dust;
(2) Numerous parts were not properly
protected;
(3) The parts were not segregated as to
serviceable versus unserviceable parts;
(4) Parts were not properly tagged; and
(5) Many parts exceeded shelf life.
b. Hanger area-
(1) Various parts and major components
were stored in the hanger area with no
means of determining their serviceabili-
ty. Included among these are nose and
main landing gear, wheels and tires,
flap sections, flight control as-
semblies, landing gears, propellers,
a-8
ee Se ee Se ed
aircraft batteries and ground equipment
batteries;
Accessory Shops-
(1) Parts were scattered throughout the
shop and bench stock parts were mixed
with no means of determining ser-
viceability of parts;
(2) The area was dirty with open cans of
grease scattered throughout the Diep
mixed with other parts; and
(3) The shop was not properly main-
tained.
Engine Shop-
(1) Some parts were not properly tagged
in that the tags on them were not
identifiable;
(2) Numerous parts with serviceable tags
had open ports and no protection to
elements the possibility of damage from
dirt and dust. Examples of this deficie-
ney are the following:
a. Propeller Control Unit CU/84 S/N
a-9
84/58/80 Off Engine SN/8261, W.O.
1216/Nov. 84 TSO 3628.2.
p. 38
b. Fuel Control United P/N CCU/39/30AM,
S/N 84353, Removed from Engine SN7353
TSO 1941.6.
c. Fuel Pump, P/N GB 222/3A0, SN4882,
Removed from Engine, S/N7353, TSO
1941.6.
d. Fuel Control United P/N 509100,
SN4903R, W.O. 1216 Removed from Engine
S/N8261.
e. Feather Pump, P/N REP/26, S/N
26/58/42, TSO 1941.6, Removed from
Engine, S/N 7353.
f. Low Torque Transmitter, S/N 10899,
Removed from Engine, S/N 8261.
(3) Numerous parts were scattered through-
out the shop and were intermixed with parts
that had serviceable tags and parts that
had no tags or means of identification.
(4) Certain parts were tagged with plain
a-10
Shee ack
Nie th airspeed Dace
green tags which were not listed in Go Air,
Inc.'S manual as follows:
a. Propeller Control Unit, 111522 Number
3 position 200RC, leaking oil from
flange.
b. Impeller, Go Air, Engine S/N 6394,
Modification 1732.
c. Two shafts, Numbers 99522 and 98155,
no information on tags.
8. The conditions described in paragraph 7
above were such that Go Air, Inc.'s
facilities equipment and materials did not
meet the requirements set forth in Section
145.35 and 145.47 of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
9. By reason of paragraphs 7 and 8 above,
Go Air, Inc. violated Section 145.55 of the
Federal Aviation Regulations.
10. All of the test equipment utilized by
Go Air, Inc. in its accessory shop was not
properly tested for calibration. Specifi-
cally, the calibration for all of the test
a-1l
equipment in the accessory shop was due to
be accomplished no later than August 31,
1984. This calibration had not been
accomplished as of the date of the FAA
inspection.
Pp. 39
11. As a result of the condition described
in paragraph 10 above, Go Air, Inc. did not
meet the requirements set forth in 145.47-
(a) and (b) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
ie By reason of paragraph 10 and 11
above, Go Air, Inc. violated Section 145.55
of the Federal Aviation Regulations.
13. Go Air, Inc. performed maintenance on
accessories and returned them to service
utilizing test equipment that was not
properly tested for calibration as follows:
a. Voltage Regulator, Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number NGA 52809/105,
Overhaul December 6, 1984.
b. Voltage Regulator, Part Number
a-12
23/44018E, Serial Number [none given]
Overhaul December 6, 1984.
c. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number NBA 54533/123,
| Bench Check November 14, 1984.
d. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number [none given]
Bench Check November 14, 1984.
e. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/440i8E, Serial Number NBA 5433/179,
ee ae eS ee =a
Bench Check November 14, 1984.
f. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number NBA 56251/139,
Bench Check November 14, 1984.
g. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number [none given]
Bench Check November 14, 1984.
h. Voltage Regulator Part Number
23/44018E, Serial Number [none given]
Te lh Lat et hit Title
Bench Check November 14, 1984.
i. DC Generator, Part Number B2112,
Serial Number 3014, Overhaul December 3,
a mt lal tn ae had, Seite Dk
a-13
1984.
j}. DC Generator, Part Number B2112,
Serial Number 74-10478, Overhaul
November 11, 1984.
k. DC Generator, Part Number B2112,
Serial Number 2350, Repair and test
November 14, 1984.
1. DC Generator, Part Number B2112,
Serial Number 2741, Overhaul November
20, 1984.
p. 40
14. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraph 13 above, Go Air, Inc. violated
Section 43.13(a) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
15. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraph 13 above, Go Air, Inc. violated
Seccrion 43.13(b) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
16. The Pacitron Fuel Test Set used by Go
Air, Inc. for testing fuel quantity systems
calibration was due for calibration on or
a-14
about February 21, 1984. At the time of the
FAA airworthiness inspection, this calibra-
tion had not been accomplished.
17. Go Air, Inc. signed off on Work Form
MM-300 as having accomplished a fuel
quantity calibration test in the following
instances:
a. Civil Aircraft N24V on or about March
7, 1984 (Go Air Work Order T-1194); and
b. Civil Aircraft N24V on or about
February 6, 1985 (Go Air Work Order-
1234).
18. Go Air, Inc. performed said fuel
quantity calibration test either by using
the Pacitron Fuel Test Set referenced in
paragraph 16 above or by draining and
filling the tank and measuring the various
fuel tank indicators, The latter procedure
was not provided for in the RAMA continuous
airworthiness maintenance program.
19. The condition described in paragraph 16
above was such that Go Air, Inc. did not
a-15
meet the requirements set forth in Sections
145.47(a) and (b) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
20. The aircraft referenced in paragraph 17
above, were used by RAMA in its operations
conducted under Part 121 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
21. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 16 and 19 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 145.55 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
22. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 16 thru 18 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 43.13(a) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
23. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 16 thru 18 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 43.13(b) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
p. 41
24. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 17, 18 and 20 above, Go Air,
a-16
tee he
Inc. violated Section 145.2(a) of the
Federal Aviation Regulations.
25. The below listed test equipment was due
for calibration testing as follows:
a. Torque Wrench, Proto (800" lbs.)
{sic) S/N A93926P60 - Aug. 19, 1984.
b. Torque Wrench, Torque Controls (600
ft. lbs) S/N 8 — Nov. 12. 1984.
c. Megometer, Gen. Radio Go-Type 1862-C,
S/N 852 - Jan. 7, 1983.
d. Oscillator Test Set, Loran Electron-
ica P/N BC376K S/N2026 - Jan. 9. 1983.
e. Decade Resistance Box - March 10,
1984.
f. Turner Adapter Press. Gauge (0-600
PSI) (in Stores) - Aug. 9, 1984.
g. Turner Adapter Press. Gauge (00-4000
PSI) S/N T7068-Aug. 9, 1984.
h. Tire Press. Gauge P/N 8885 S/N 1868 -
Aug. 9, 1984.
i. Tire Press. Gauge P/N 8844 S/N 1546
(in Stores) - Aug. 9, 1984.
a-17
26. None of the items listed in paragraph
25 above had been tested for calibration at
the time of the FAA airworthiness inspec-
tion.
27. The conditions referenced in paragraphs
25 and 26 above were such that Go Air, Inc.
did not meet the requirements set forth in
Sections 145.47(a) and (b) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations
28. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 25 and 27 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 145.55 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
p. 42
29. Go Air, Inc. overhauled, repaired,
modified or tested the below listed
components and returned them to service:
Component Serial No. Date Work Order
a. Volt reg NBA52809/67 12/12/83 GO-T-1504
b. Gear Box 68679 1/7/85 Missing
c. DC Gen 2824 3/26/84 1504
d. DC Gen 2786 6/21/84 1504
ee |
e. Volt reg 46221/36 12/16/83 Go-T-1504
f. DC Gen 74-10478 11/14/84 1504
g. Volt Reg 56251/139 11/14/84 1504
h. Df Relay 1936 11/14/84 N/A
i. Df Relay 1499 11/14/84 N/A
j. Df Relay 1097 4/17/84 Missing
k. Df Relay 1366 11/14/84 N/A
30. Following said maintenance, Go Air,
Inc. attached improper tags to the above
items. Specifically, Go Air, Inc. attached
an “Approval F or Service Tag” which did
not contain a certification that the
article was airworthy with respect to the
work performed and did not contain the
record entries required by Section 43.9 of
the Federal Aviation Regulations. Go Air,
Inc. did not use the Form R-16 “Serviceable
Tag” which was authorized by the Ad-
ministrator.
31. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 29 and 30 above, Go Air, Inc.
a-19
violated Section 43.5(a) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
32. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 29 and 30 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 43.5(b) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
p. 43
33. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 29 and 30 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 145.59(a) of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
34. On or about February 6, 1985, Go Air,
signed an airworthiness release following a
"Cc" check for Civil Aircraft N24V, a
Viscount 745D aircraft being operated by
RAMA under its Operations Specifications
issued under Part 121 of the Federal
Aviation Regulations.
35. In completing said release, Go Air,
Inc. failed to complete the following sign
off blocks as required by RAMA's continuous
airworthiness program:
a-20
a. "C" Check Inspection Form MM-300
(1) Page 7, Items 48, 49, 50a, b, c thru
61 - no sign off in the mechanic block;
(2) Page 8, Items 62, 63, 64a, 64c, 65
66 and 67 - no sign off in the mechanic
block;
(3) Page 9, Items 68, 72a thru e and 76a
thru d - no sign off in the mechanic
block;
(4) Page 10, Items 77 thru 82 - no
signoff in the mechanic block; |
(5S) Page 11, Items 83 thru 93 - no
signoff in the mechanic block; and
(6) Page 12, Items 94 thru 99 - no
signoff in the mechanic block.
b. Avionics Ramp Inspection, Form MM-66 -
Item 1 thru 21 have no signoff in the
mechanic block.
36. During the period between January 4,
1982 thru March 13, 1984, Go Air performed
200/400/600 and 800 hour inspections on
Civil Aircraft N140RA, a Viscount 745D
a-21
aircraft operated by RAMA under its Part
121 operations specifications, and com-
pleted Work Forms 300 and M-66 for said
work. The following discrepancies were
noted in said forms as:
a. Work Form MM-300, Item 139 on Page 8
- the mechanic and inspection signoff
blocks are left blank; and
b. Form MM-66, Item 20 - there is a line
through the mechanic signoff block and
the due time and date were left blank on
the top of the form.
p. 44
37. Each of the items referenced in
paragraphs 35 and 36 above are required to
be completed in accordance with RAMA
continuous airworthiness program.
38. By reason of the matters alleged in
paragraphs 34 thru 37 above, Go Air, Inc.
violated Section 145.21(a) of the Federawl
Aviation Regulations.
39. Go Air, Inc. conducted inspections on
a-22
aircraft operated by Go Inc. under Part 125
PON rnd ts aa otc
of the Federal Aviation Regulations and
failed to sign for all items on the Go Inc.
Inspection Forms as follows:
a. Civil Aircraft N150RC, Work Order
1235 dated February 13, 1985 - the
model, registration number, serial
number, date and action taken are left
blank.
b. Civil Aircraft N150RC, Inspection
Form dated February 29, 1984:
(1) No identification on sheet for
accounting;
(2) Top of sheet not filled out.
(3) Inhibit Fuel System item - not
signed off.
c. Civil Aircraft N240RC, Work Order
1233 dated March 2, 1985:
(1) Item 12 on 75 hour check for No. 2
engine - no signoff.
(2) Item 26 on 75 hour check for No. 2
engine - no signoff.
a-23
(3) Item 8 on Propeller replacement card
- no signoff.
(4) Item 17 on Propeller replacement
card states N/A, but it is applicable.
(5) Last item on MM-25, Propeller
Installation Record, has no mechanic
signature.
(6) The final signoff on MM-25 for the
mechanic and inspector was not signed.
p. 45
(7) the maintenance release stamp is
missing and not affixed to completed
work order. The “mechanic” and "inspec-
tor" block is not filled out.
40. Completion of the items listed in
paragraph 39 above are part of the approved
inspection program for Go Inc.
41. By reason of the matter alleged in
paragraphs 39 and 40 above, Go Air violated
Section 43.11(a)(7) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
42. By reason of the matters alleged in
a-24
Atehvett _vevcoinabieidbliill
paragraphs 39 and 40 above, Go Air violated
Section 145.2(b) of the Federal Aviation
Regulations.
By reason of the circumstances hereinabove
described:
a. RAMA, Go Leasing, Inc. and Go Air, Inc.
have not been managed or operated as
separate entities with separate and
distinct FAR compliance responsibilities;
b. RAMA has failed to exercise the degree
of care, judgment and responsibility
required of the holder of a Part 121 air
carrier operating certificate;
c. Go Leasing, Inc. has failed to exercise
the degree of care, judgment and respon-
sibility required of the holder of a Part
125 operat+*ng certificate;
d. Go Air, Inc. has failed to exercise the
degree of care, judgment and responsibility
required of the holder of a repair station
certificate;
e. RAMA has demonstrated that it presently
lacks the qualifications required of a
holder of an air carrier operating certifi-
cate;
f. Go Leasing, Inc. has demonstrated that
it presently lacks the qualifications
required of a holder of a repair station
certificate.
Based upon the foregoing circumstances,
the Administrator has determined that an
emergency requiring immediate action exists
with respect to safety in air commerce, and
he has determined that safety
p. 46
in air commerce and the public interest
require the immediate revocation, on an
emergency basis, of Air Carrier Operating
Certificate No. ASW-61, Operating Certifi-
cate No. WE-34-1 and Repair Station
Certificate No. 434-1.
NOW. THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, pursuant
to the authority vested in the Administra-
a-26
4
tor by Section 609 and 1005 of the Federal
Aviation Act of 1958, as amended, that:
(1) Effective immediately, Air Carrier
Operating Certificate No. ASW-61 held by
Royal American Airways, Inc. is hereby
revoked on an emergency basis;
(2) Effective immediately, Operating
Certificate No. WE-34-1 held by Go
Leasing, Inc. is hereby revoked on an
emergency basis;
(3) Effective immediately, Repair
Station Certificate No. 434-1 held by Go
Air, Inc. is hereby revoked on an
emergency basis.
(4) Said certificates be surrendered
immediately by mail or delivery to the
Regional Counsel of the Federal Aviation
Administration, Post Office Box 92007,
Worldway Postal Center, Los Angeles,
California 90009 (envelope enclosed) or
at the Office of Regional Counsel, Room
6W14, 15000 Aviation Boulevard, Lawn-
a-27
dale, California 90260.
/s/ DeWitte T. Lawson, Jr.
Regional Counsel
APPEAL
This Order may be appealed by the filing
of an Appeal with the National Transporta-
tion Safety Board, Room 822, Docket
Section, Washington, D.C. 20594, within ten
(10) days of the date of service of this
Order. A copy of your Notice of Appeal
should be furnished this office. In view of
the fact that your certificates have been
revoked on an emergency basis, and the
Administrator has determined that safety in
air commerce and the. public interest
require the immediate effectiveness of this
Order, the revocation of said certificates
shall remain effective during the pendency
of any appeal proceedings before the
National Transportation Safety Board. In
the event of an appeal of this Order, Part
821 of the National Transporation Safety
a-28
Board's Rules of Practice will be ap-
plicable to and govern ti.e proceedings, and
a copy of this Order will be filed with the
Board and will constitute the Administra-
tor's Complaint.
p. 47
SERVED: Nov. 7, 1986
NTSB Order No. EA-2431
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Adopted by the
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD
at its office in Washington, D.C.
on the 24th day of October, 1986
DONALD D. ENGEN, Administrator,
Federal Aviation Administration,
Complainant,
Docket:
SE-6767
Ve
GO AIR, INC.,
Respondent.
mn mr ee ee ee ee ee
OPINION AND ORDER
The respondent, by counsel, has appealed
to the Board an order Administrative Law
Judge Patrick G. Geraghty issued on May 5,
1986 at the conclusion of the evidentiary
hearing that had been convened pursuant to
respondent's appeal from an emergency order
of the Administrator revoking its Part 145
repair station certificate. 1/ The law
judge's order granted a
1/ The Administrator's order, dated May 2,
1985, also revoked the Part 121 certificate
held by Royal American Airways, Inc. and
the Part 125 certificate held by Go
Leasing, Inc., two companies closely
affiliated with respondent. Royal American
(Docket SE-6765) and respondent waived the
expedited procedures applicable to emergen-
cy cases under the Board's Rules of Pract-
ice, 49 CFR Part 821, subpart I. Go Leasing
(Docket SE-6766) did not waive those proce-
dures. A hearing on the charges in the
revocation order against it was held in
a- 30
OO
June, 1985.
p. 1
motion filed by the Administrator for
summary judgment on the numerous regulatory
violations the revocation order--the com-
plaint herein--alleged respondent had com-
mitted in connection with its repair or
maintenance of aircraft operated commer-
cially by Go Leasing, Inc. and Royal Ameri-
can Airways, Inc. in their charter and
scheduled services. 2/ Respondent, who put
on no evidence at the hearing in defense of
the charges, does not on this appeal
challenge the sufficiency of the evidence
adduced by the Administrator in support of
his allegations. Rather, respondent
presents various procedural or jurisdic-
tional contentions which it maintains
warrants the dismissal or invalidation of
the revocation order. 3/ For the reasons
discussed below, we will deny the appeal.
2/ The portions of the complaint pertain-
ing to respondent (pp. 1-3 and 37-47) have
been attached to this opinion as an
Appendix. The law judge did not affirm the
allegations in paragraph 30 with respect to
the component listed at b. of paragraph 29.
See tr. at 121. As to the remaining
allegations, the law judge found that the
Administrator's evidence established at
least a prima facie case which, in the
absence of contrary evidence, was suffi-
cient to meet his burden of proof.
3/ Respondent's brief is styled a "Com-
bined Appeal Brief and Motion to Dismiss"
and on it first page paradoxically requests
that the Board "dismiss this action on
grounds the Board lacks jurisdiction to
hear it.” The basis for respondent's req-
uest appears to be its belief that the Adm-
inistrator does not have authority to re-
voke or suspend certificates for regulatory
violations. Respondent asserts “[i]f FAA
a- 32
OO
has no authority to impose the sanction of
revocation or suspension on account of off-
enses or violations, ergo, the Board has no
jurisdiction to hear such a case" (brief at
11). Respondent's motion is self-defeating.
If the Board could not hear this appeal, it
could not grant respondent the relief it in
effect seeks; namely the invalidation of
the Administrator's order. Since we assume
respondent does not want the Board to
dismiss the appeal it initiated, we will
deny the motion to dismiss.
p. 2
Respondent in its brief presents
numerous arguments to the effect that under
the Federal Aviation Act ("FA Act"), the
Administrative Procedure Act, and the U.S.
Constitution the Administrator cannot
lawfully revoke or suspend certificates for
violations of air safety regulations, but
must instead pursue civil penalty actions
that afford certificate holders the
a- 33
opportunity for jury trial on such offenses
ina federal district court. It further
argues that even if the necessary statutory
authority existed, the Administrator has
not adopted appropriate internal procedures
or regulations for the proper exercise of
such authority. These same arguments were
advanced by Go Leasing on appeal from the
Board's affirmation (with a reduction in
sanction) of the Administrator's emergency
revocation of its Part 125 certificate in
the order under consideration here. 4/ In a
thorough and well-reasoned opinion the
Court rejected Go Leasing's multi-faceted
challenge to the Administrator's certifi-
cate action against it. Go Leasing v. NTSB
and FAA, C.A. 9, No. 85-7401, decided
September 30, 1986. 5/ Specifically, the
Court held, among
4/ See NTSB Order EA-2190 (1985).
5/ Also of relevance in this proceeding
a- 34
are the Court's observations concerning
certain accusation by counsel for Go
Leasing, who also represents respondent, on
matters relating to the investigation that
led to the charges and their prosecution
(slip op. at 5): “Before we proceed with
our analysis of the legitimate issues
presented in this appeal, we reject Go
Leasing's numerous and repetitive asser-
tions of a continuing conspiracy by the FAA
to cover up its alleged lack of authority
for so-called punitive certificate actions.
Nor do we approve of Go Leasing's impugning
the ethics of FAA officials, its counsel,
and the NTSB. There is no evidence whatever
of any cover-up or of any unethical conduct
on the part of the FAA or NTSB."
p.3
other things, that the Administrator had
legal discretion to choose between civil
penalties and certificate action for
violations of safety regulations and "that
a- 35
[he] need not promulgate rules constraining
his discretion as to when to employ a
particular statutory enforcement action"
(Id. slip op. at 17), that the Administrat-
or's regulations relating to enforcement
actions (14 C.F.R. §13.19) had been validly
adopted, and, generally, that the Ad-
ministrator's standards aiid policies
concerning how various enforcement matters
will be prosecuted withstand due process
scrutiny. We find the Court's disposition
of these and other similar issues, many of
which involve questions beyond our cog-
nizance, to be controlling in this proceed-
ing to the extent it involves the same or
closely related contentions. 6/
In addition to the attack on the
Administrator's authority to revoke its
certificate, respondent objects to the law
judge's disposition of two procedural
matters. The first of these objections is
the claim that respondent was denied a
a- 36
"speedy trial" because the law judge, at
the time he scheduled the week of December
9, 1985 to hear the appeals of Royal
American
6/ One argument the court did not have to
consider was the claim that the revocation
order is invaled because it does not state,
as assertedly required by section 125.29-
(b), that the alleged violations would have
been grounds for denying an application for
a certificate. We find the point meritless.
The cited regulation does not impose a
notice requirement on the Administrator.
Rather it merely provides advice concerning
additional circumstances under which the
Administrator might exercise his authority
to suspend or revoke a certificate.
p. 4
in Docket SE-6765 and of respondent as
well, if time permitted, declined to
reschedule two unrelated cases that
a-37
previously had been set for the following
week so that more time would be available
to hear respondent's appeal. 7/ We find
respondent's objection to be without merit.
To begin with, it is somewhat anomalous for
respondent to raise any issue concerning
the pace of this proceeding, since it
waived expedited review of the emergency
order and subsequently requested several
continuances which effectively precluded a
prompt disposition of its appeal. In fact,
one of those requests, made on December,
1985, sought "at least" a 90-day con-
tinuance on the ground that it would be
impossible to prepare its case by December
9. 8/ In these circumstances, we do not
agree that the law judge's disinclination
to inconvenience the parties in cases whose
hearings were scheduled for the week of
December 16 can be deemed "arbitrary and
Capricious."
Respondent also challenges the law
a-38
judge's denial of its request for a change
of venue for the hearing from Phoenix to
Tucson, Arizona. 9/ We find no prejudicial
error in this ruling. Although the law
judge had advised the parties in February,
1986 that respondent's hearing would be
held either in
7/. As it turned out, the Royal American
hearing consumed the entire week and had to
be continued in February, 1986.
8/ The law judge denied that request as
premature on December 6.
9/ Respondent's reason for requesting the
change was its asserted inability "to pay
the cost of housing in Phoenix for wit-
nesses." The Administrator opposed the
motion for change in venue.
o>. 5
Phoenix, Arizona or in Los Angeles,
California, respondent raised no objection
to either location until April 17, follow-
a-39
ing a notification (issued on April 4) that
the hearing had been scheduled for May 5-9
in Phoenix. Given respondent's failure to
contest either of the hearing sites
proposed by the law judge until after one
had been selected, we do not believe his
denial of the request for a change of venue
as untimely was an abuse of discretion.
ACCORDINGLY, IT IS ORDERED THAT:
1. Respondent's appeal and its motion to
dismiss are denied, and
2. The order of the law judge granting
the Administrator's motion for summary
judgment is affirmed.
BURNETT, Chairman, GOLDMAN, Vice Chairman,
LAUBER and NALL, members of the Board,
concurred in the above opinion and order.
S. 6
a-40
Not to be published, see Local Rule 8(f)
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
For the District of Columbia Circuit
No. 87-1000 September Term, 1987
Go Air, Inc.,
Petitioner
¥, Filed Mar 7, 1988
National Transportation Safety
Board and Donald D. Engen, Admin-
istrator, Federal Aviation Admin-
istration,
Respondents
PETITION FOR REVIEW OF AN ORDER OF THE
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD
BEFORE: Ruth B. Ginsburg, Starr and
Buckley, Circuit Judges
JUDGMENT
This petition for review of a decision
of the National Transportation Safety Board
was considered on the administrative record
and on the briefs filed by counsel for the
parties. The court has determined that the
issues presented occasion no need for a
published opinion. See D.C. Cir. Rule
14(c).
a-41
The several arguments raised by petitio-
ner have been considered and decided ina
manner adverse to petitioner's contentions.
See Komjathy v. NTSB, 832 F.2d 1294 (D.C.
Cir. 1987); Go Leasing v. NTSB, 800 F.2d
1514 (9th Cir. 1986). The former decision
is law of this circuit, and we find the
latter decision entirely persuasive. For
the reasons stated in those opinions, it is
ORDERED and ADJUDGED by the court that
the petition for review be denied.
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. A-853 *
GO AIR, INC.
Applicant,
Vv.
NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BD., ET AL.
ORDER EXTENDING TIME TO FILE PETITION
FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
UPON CONSIDERATION of the application of
counsel for the applicant,
a- 42
IT IS ORDERED that the time for filing a
petition for a writ of certiorari in the
above-entitled cause be, and the same is
hereby, extended to and including July 5,
1988.
/s/ William H. Rehnquist
Chief Justice of the United States
Dated this 6th day of May, 1988.
Amend. 5 CONSTITUTION
No person shall be held to answer for a
Capital, or otherwise infamous crime,
unless on a presentment or indictment of a
Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the
*land or naval forces, or in the Militia,
when in actual service in time of War or
public danger; nor shall any person be
subject for the same offense to be twice
put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall
be compelled in any criminal case to be a
witness against himself, nor be deprived of
life, liberty, or property, without due
process of law; nor shall private property
a-43
be taken for public use, without just
compensation.
aaa — ———————————_————_
5 0.S.C. § 551(4) (1982)
For the purpose of this subchapter --
(1) "agency" means each authority of the
Government of the United States, whether or
not it is within or subject to review by
another agency, but does not include --
x* *&* & ®
x* «& *& ®
(4) "rule" means the whole or a part of
an agency statement of general or parti-
cular applicability and future effect
designed to implement, interpret, or
prescribe law or policy or describing the
organization, procedure, or practice
requirements of an agency and includes the
approval or prescription for the future of
rates, wages, corporate or financial
structures or reorganizations thereof,
a- 44
prices, facilities, appliances, services or
allowances therefor or of valuations,
costs, Or accounting, or practices bearing
on any of the foregoing.
5 U.S.C. § 552(a) (1) (1982)
Public information; agency rules, opinions,
orders, records, and proceedings
(a) Each agency shall make available to
the public information as :ollows:
(1) Each agency shall separately
State and currently publish in the
Federal Register for the guidance of the
public --
(A) descriptions of its central
and field organization and the estab-
lished places at which, the employees
(and in the case of a uniformed
service, the members) from whom, and
the methods whereby, the public may
a- 45
obtain information, make submittals
or requests, or obtain decisions;
(B) statements of the general
course and method by which its
functions are channeled and deter-
mined, including the nature and
requirements of all formal and
informal procedures available;
(Cc) rules of procedure, descrip-
tions of forms available or the
places at which forms may be
obtained, and instructions as to the
scope and contents of all papers,
reports, or examinations;
(D) substantive rules of general
applicability adopted as authorized
by law. and statements of general
policy or interpretations of general
applicability formulated and adopted
by the agency; and
(E) each amendment, revision, or
repeal of the foregoing.
a- 46
Except to the extent that a person has
actual and timely notice of the terms
thereof, a person may not in any manner be
required to resort to, or be adversely
affected by, a matter required to be
published in the Federal Register and not
so published. For the purpose of this
paragraph, matter reasonably available to
the class of persons affected thereby is
deemed published in the Federal Register
when incorporated by reference therein with
the approval of the Director of the Federal
Register.
5 U.S.C. § 553 (1982)
Rule making
(a) This section applies, according to
the provisions thereof, except to the
extent that there is involved --
(1) a military or foreign affairs
function of the United States; or
a- 47
ma mae.
ii. cP ee Te a ee eee LL Oa a Se
33 ri ~ ‘ « ,. ae ¥
-— ———s - 4. Me le __ _ a _alree ot
(2) a matter relating to agency
management or personnel or to public
property, loans, grants, benefits, or
contracts.
(b) General notice of proposed rule
making shall be published in the Federal
Register, uniess persons subject thereto
are named and either personally served or
otherwise have actual notice thereof in
accordance with law. The notice shall
include --
(1) a statement of the time, place,
and nature of public rule making
proceedings;
(2) reference to the legal authority
under which the rule is proposed; and
(3) either the terms or substance of
the proposed rule or a description of
the subjects and issues involved.
Except when notice or hearing is
required by statute, this subsection
does not apply --
a- 48
(A) to interpretative rules,
general statements of policy, or
rules of agency organization,
procedure, or practice; or
(B) when the agency for good cause
finds (and incorporates the finding
and a brief statement of reasons
therefor in the rules issued) that
notice and public procedure thereon
are impracticable, unnecessary, or
contrary to the public interest.
(c) After notice required by this
section, the agency shall give interested
persons an opportunity to participate in
the rule making through submission of
written data, views, or arguments with or
without opportunity for oral presentation.
After consideration of the relevant matter
presented, the agency shall incorporate in
the rules adopted a concise general
Statement of their basis and purpose. When
rules are required by statute to be made on
a- 49
the record after opportunity for an agency
hearing, sections 556 and 557 of this title
apply instead of this subsection.
(ad) The required publication or service
of a substantive rule shall be made not
less than 30 days before its effective
date, except --
(1) a substantive rule which grants
or recognizes an exemption or relieves a
restriction;
(2) interpretative rules and state-
ments of policy; or
(3) as otherwise provided by the
agency for good cause found and
published with the rule.
(e) Each agency shall give an interested
person the right to petition for the
issuance, amendment, or repeal of a rule.
5 U.S.C. § 706 (1982)
Scope of review
a- 50
To the extent necessary to decision and
when presented, the reviewing court shall
decide all relevant questions of law,
interpret constitutional and statutory
provisions, and determine the meaning or
applicability of the terms of an agency
action. The reviewing court shall --
(1) compel agency action unlawfully
withheld or unreasonably delayed; and
(2) hold unlawful and set aside
agency action, findings, and conclusions
found to be --
(A) arbitrary, capricious, an
abuse of discretion, or otherwise not
in accordance with law;
(B) contrary to constitutional
right, power, privilege, or immunity;
(C) in excess of statutory
jurisdiction, authority, or limita-
tions, or short of statutory right;
(D) without observance of proce-
dure required by law;
a- 51
(E) unsupported by substantial
evidence in a case subject to
sections 556 and 557 of this title or
otherwise reviewed on the record of
an agency hearing provided by
statute; or
(F) unwarranted by the facts to
the extent that the facts are subject
to trial de novo by the reviewing
court.
In making the foregoing determinations, the
court shall review the whole record or
those parts of it cited by a party, and due
account shall be taken of the rule of
prejudicial error.
49 U.S.C. app. § 1429(a) (1982)
Reinspection or reexamination; amendment,
suspension, or revocation of certification
(a) Procedure; notification; hearing;
appeal to National Transportation
Safety Board; judicial review
The Secretary of Transportation
a- 52
[Administrator] may, from time to time,
reinspect any civil aircraft, aircraft
engine, propeller, appliance, air naviga-
tion facility, or air agency, or may
reexamine any Civil airman. If, as a
result of any such reinspection or reexami-
nation, or if, as a result of any other
investigation made by the Secretary of
Transportation [Administrator], he deter-
mines that safety in air commerce or air
transportation and the public interest
requires, the Secretary of Transportation
[Administrator] may issue an order amend-
ing, modifying, suspending, or revoking, in
whole or in part, any type certificate,
production certificate, airworthiness
certificate, airman certificate, air
Carrier operating certificate, air naviga-
tion facility certificate (including
airport operating certificate), or air
agency certificate. Prior to amending,
modifying, suspending, or revoking any of
a- 53
the foregoing certificates, the Secretary
of Transportation [Administrator] shall
advise the holder thereof as to any charges
or other reasons relied upon by the
Secretary of Transportation [Administrator]
for his proposed action and, except in
cases of emergency, shall provide the
holder of such a certificate an opportunity
to answer any charges and be heard as to
why such certificate should not be amended,
modified, suspended, or revoked. Any
person whose certificate is affected by
such an order of the Secretary of Transpor-
tation [Administrator] under this section
may appeal the Secretary of Transporta-
tion's [Administrator's] order to the
National Transportation Safety Board and
the National Transportation Safety Board
may, after notice and hearing, amend,
modify, or reverse the Secretary of
Transportation's [Administrator's] order if
it finds that safety in air commerce or air
a- 54
transportation and the public interest do
not require affirmation of the Secretary of
Transportation's [Administrator's] order.
In the conduct of its hearings the National
Transportation Safety Board shall not be
bound by findings of fact of the Secretary
of Transportation [Administrator]. The
filing of an appeal with the National
Transportation Safety Board shall stay the
effectiveness of the Secretary of Transpor-
tation's [Administrator's] order unless the
Secretary of Transportation [Administrator]
advises the National Transportation Safety
Board that an emergency exists and safety
in air commerce or air transportation
requires the immediate effectiveness of his
order, in which event the order shall
remain effective and the National Transpor-
tation Safety Board shall finally dispose
of the appeal within sixty days after being
so advised by the Secretary of Transporta-
tion [Administrator]. The person substan-
a- 55
tially affected by the National Transporta-
tion Safety Board's order may obtain
judicial review of said order under the
provisions of section 1486 of this
Appendix, and the Secretary of Transporta-
tion [Administrator] shall be made a party
to such proceedings.
49 U.S.C. § 1485 (1982)
Orders, notices, and service
(a) Effective date of orders; emergency
orders
Except as otherwise provided in this
chapter, all orders, rules, and regulations
of the Board! or the Secretary of Transp-
ortation [Administrator] shall take effect
within such reasonable time as the Board or
[Administrator] may prescribe, and shall
continue in force until their further
order, rule, or regulation, or for a
l Refers to the Civil Aeronautics
Board, which no longer exists.
a- 56
specified period of time, as shall be
prescribed in the order, rule, or regula-
tion: Provided, That whenever the [Ad-
ministrator] is of the opinion that an
emergency requiring immediate action exists
in respect of safety in air commerce, the
[Administrator] is authorized, either upon
complaint or his own initiative without
complaint, at once, if he so orders,
without answer or other form of pleading by
the interested person or persons, and with
or without notice, hearing, or the making
or filing of a report, to make such just
and reasonable orders, rules, or regula-
tions, as may be essential in the interest
of safety in air commerce to meet such
emergency; Provided further, That the
[Administrator] shall immediately initiate
proceedings relating to the matters
embraced in any such order, rule, or
regulation, and shall, insofar as prac-
ticable, give preference to such proceed-
a- 57
ings over all others under this chapter.
(b) Designation of agent for service
It shall be the duty of every air
carrier and foreign air carrier to desig-
nate in writing an agent upon whom service
of all notices and process and all orders,
decisions, and requirements of the Board
and the [Administrator] may be made for and
on behalf of said carrier, and to file such
designation with the [Administrator] and in
the office of the secretary of the Board,
which designation may from time to time be
changed by like writing similarly filed.
Service of all notices and process and
orders, decisions, and requirements of the
[Administrator] or the Board may be made
upon such carrier by service upon such
designated agent at his office or usual
place of residence with like effect as if
made personally upon such carrier, and in
default of such designation of such agent,
service or any notice or other process in
a- 58
any proceedings before said [Administrator]
or Board, may be made by posting such
notice, process, order, requirement, or
Gecision in the office of the [{Administrat-
or] or with the secretary of the Board.
(c) Manner of service
Service of notices, processes, orders,
rules, and regulations upon any person may
be made by personal service, or upon an
agent designated in writing for the pur-
pose, or by registered or certified mail
addressed to such person or agent. Whenever
service is made by registered or certified
mail, the date of mailing shall be con-
Sidered as the time when service is made.
(d) Suspension or modification of orders
Except as otherwise provided in this
chapter, the [Administrator] or the Board
is empowered to suspend or modify their
orders upon such notice and in such manner
as they shall deem proper.
(e) Compliance with orders
a- 59
It shall be the duty of every person
subject to this chapter, and its agents and
employees, to observe and comply with any
order, rule, regulation, or certificate
issued by the [Administrator] or the Board
under this chapter affecting such person so
long as the same shall remain in effect.
(f) Findings of fact; service of orders
Every order of the [Administrator] or
the Board spall set forth the findings of
fact upon wkich it is based, and shall be
served upon the parties to the proceeding
and the persons affected by such order.
Judicial review
(a) Orders subject to review; petition for
review
Any order, affirmative or negative,
issued by the Board or Secretary of Trans-
portation [Administrator] under this chap-
ter, except any order in respect of any
a- 60
foreign air carrier subject to the approval
of the President as provided in section
1461 of this Appendix, shall be subject to
review by the courts of appeals of the
United States or the United States Court of
Appeals for the District of Columbia upon
petition, filed within sixty days after the
entry of such order, by any person disclos-
ing a substantial interest in such order.
After the expiration of said sixty days a
petition may be filed only by leave of
court upon a showing of reasonable grounds
for failure to file the petition there-
tofore.
(b) Venue
A petition under this section shall be
filed in the court for the circuit wherein
the petitioner resides or has his principal
place of business or in the United States
Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia.
(c) Notice to Board or Secretary of
a- 61
Transportation; filing of record
A copy of the petition shall, upon
filing, be forthwith transmitted to the
Board or [Administrator] by the clerk of
the court, and the Board or [Administrator]
shall thereupon file in the court the
record, if any, upon which the order
coplained of was entered, as provided in
section 2112 of title 28.
(d) Power of court
Upon transmittal of the petition to the
Board or [Administrator], the court shall
have exclusive jurisdiction to affirm,
modify, or set aside the order complained
of, in whole or in part, and if need be, to
order further proceedings by the Board or
[Administrator]. Upon good cause shown and
after reasonble notice to the Board or
[Admininstrator] interlocutory relief may
be granted by stay of the order or by such
mandatory or other relief as may be
appropriate.
a- 62
(e) Conclusiveness of findings of fact;
objections
The findings of facts by the Board or
[Administrator], if supported by substan-
tial evidence, shall be conclusive. No
objection to an order of the Board or
[Administrator] shall be considered by the
court unless such objection shall have been
urged before the Board or [Administrator]
or, if it was not so urged, unless there
were reasonable grounds for failure to do
sO.
(£) Review by Supreme Court
The judgment and decree of the court
affirming, modifying, or setting aside any
such order of the Board or [Administrator]
shall be subject only to review by the
Supreme Court of the United States upon
certification or certiorari as provided in
section 1254 of title 28.
a- 63
49 U.S.C. app. § 1487 (1982)
Judicial enforcement; jurisdiction;
application; costs
(a) If any person violates any provision
of this chapter, or any rule, regulation,
requirement, or order thereunder, or any
term, condition, or limitation of any
certificate or permit issued under this
chapter, the Board or Secretary of Trans-
portation [Administrator], as the case may
be, their duly authorized agents, or, in
the case of a violation of section 1514 of
this Appendix, the Attorney General, or, in
the case of a violation of section 1371(a)
of this Appendix, any party in interest,
may apply to the district court of the
United States, for any district wherein
such person carries on his business or
wherein the violation occurred, for the
enforcement of such provision of this
chapter, or of such rule, regulation,
requirement, order, term, condition, or
a- 64
limitation; and such court shall have
jurisdiction to enforce obedience thereto
by a writ of injunction or other process,
mandatory or otherwise, restraining such
person, his officers, agents, employees,
and representatives from further violation
of such provision of this chapter or of
such rule, regulation, requirement, order,
term, condition or limitation, and requir-
ing their obedience thereto.
(b) Upon the request of the Board or
[Administrator], any district attorney of
the United States to whom the Board or
[Administrator] may apply is authorized to
institute in the proper court and to
prosecute under the direction of the
Attorney General all necessary proceedings
for the enforcement of the provisions of
this chapter or any rule, regulation,
requirement, or order thereunder, or any
term, condition, or limitation of any
certificate or permit, and for the punish-
a- 65
ment of all violations thereof, and the
costs and expenses of such prosecutions
shall be paid out of the appropriations for
the expenses of the courts of the United
States.
14 C.F.R. § 408.25 (1952)
Emergency suspensions. Under section 609 of
the act, in cases of emergency a type
certificate, production certificate,
airworthiness certificate, airman certifi-
cate, air carrier operating certificate,
air navigation facility certificate, or air
agency certificate may be suspended, in
whole or in part, for a period not in
excess of 30 days, without regard to any
requirement as to notice and hearing; the
[Civil Aeronautics] Administration shall
immediately give notice of such suspension
to the holder of such certificate, and
shall enter upon a hearing which shall be
a- 66
disposed of as speedily as possible; and
during the pendency of the proceeding the
Administration may further suspend such
certificate, in whole or in part, for an
additional period not in excess of 30 days.
In the event the condition or conduct of a
certificate holder is such as to indicate
immediate danger of injury to person or
damage to property, and the immediate
suspension of the certificate might
reasonably be expected to avert such injury
Or damage, an emergency will be deemed to
exist within the meaning of section 609.
Under such circumstances, any employee of
the Administration charged with the duty of
examining a certificate holder or enforcing
aeronautical statutes and regulations, may
suspend for a period not to exceed 30 days,
any of the foregoing certificates issued by
the Administration other than an air
Carrier operating certificate, which may be
Suspended in an emergency only by the
a- 67
Administrator. Any such employee of the
Administration making an emergency suspen-
sion will, if practicable, notify orally
the party or parties involved, that an
emergency suspension of the certificate has
been made pursuant to the authority of
section 609, and will, within a reasonable
time thereafter, confirm such notification
in writing. Formal proceedings will be
instituted immediately, during the pendency
of which the Administrator, a Deputy
Administrator, or the Regional Administra-
tor serving the region in which the
condition is likely to exist or conduct is
likely to occur, may further suspend such
certificate, in whole or in part, for an
additional period not in excess of 30 days.
oo
————
14 C.F.R. 13.19 (1987)
Certificate action.
(a) Under section 609 of the Federal
Aviation Act of 1958 (49 U.S.C. 1429), the
a-68
Administrator may reinspect any civil
aircraft, aircraft engine, propeller,
appliance, air navigation facility, or air
agency, and may re-examine any civil
airman. Under section 501(e) of the FA
Act, any Certificate of Aircraft Registra-
tion may be suspended or revoked by the
Administrator for any cause that renders
the aircraft ineligible for registration.
(b) If, as a result of such a reinspec-
tion, re-examination, or other investiga-
tion made by the Administrator under
section 609 of the FA Act, the Adminis-~-
trator determines that the public interest
and safety in air commerce requires it, the
Administrator may issue an order amending,
suspending, or revoking, all or part of any
type certificate, production certificate,
airworthiness certificate, airman certifi-
cate, air carrier operating certificate,
air navigation facility certificate, or air
agency certificate. This authority may be
a-69
exercised for remedial purposes in cases
involving the Hazardous Materials Transpor-
tation Act (49 U.S.C. 1801 et seq.) or
regulations issued under that Act. This
authority is also exercised by the Chief
Counsel, the Assistant Chief Counsel for
Regulations and Enforcement, and the
Regional Counsel concerned. If the
Administrator finds that any aircraft
registered under Part 47 of this chapter is
ineligible for registration or if the
holder of a Certificate of Aircraft
Registration has refused or failed to
submit AC Form 8050-73, as required by §
47.51 of this chapter, the Administrator
issues an order suspending or revoking that
certificate. This authority as to aircraft
found ineligible for registration is also
eaercised by the Aeronautical Center
Covnsel.
(c) Before issuing an order under
paragraph (b) of this section, the Chief
a-70
Counsel, the Assistant Chief Counsel for
Regulations and Enforcement, the Regional
Counsel concerned, or the Aeronautical
Center Counsel (as to matters under Title V
of the FA Act) advises the certificate hol-
der of the charges or other reasons upon
which the Administrator bases the proposed
action and, except in an emergency, allows
the holder to answer any charges and to be
heard as to why the certificate should not
be amended, suspended, or revoked. The hol-
der may, by checking the appropriate box on
the form that is sent to the holder with
the notice of proposed certificate action,
elect to --
(1) Admit the charges and surrender
his or her certificate;
(2) Answer the charges in writing;
(3) Request that an order be issued
in accordance with the notice of pro-
posed certificate action so that the
certificate holder may appeal to the
a-71
National Transportation Safety Board, if
the charges concerning a matter under
Title VI of the FA Act;
(4) Request an opportunity to be
heard in an informal conference with the
FAA counsel; or
(5) Request a hearing in accordance
with Subpart D of this part if the
charges concern a matter under Title V
of the FA Act.
Except as provided in 13.35(b), unless
the certificate holder returns the form
and, where required, an answer or motion,
with a postmark of not later than 15 days
after the date of receipt of the notice,
the order of the Administrator is issued as
proposed. If the certificate holder has
requested an informal conference with the
FAA counsel and the charges concern a mat-
ter under Title V of the FA Act, the holder
may after that conference also request a
formal hearing in writing with a postmark
a-72
of not later than 10 days after the close
of the conference. After considering any
information submitted by the certificate
holder, the Chief Counsel, the Assistant
Chief Counsel for Regulations and Enforce-
ment, the Regional Counsel concerned, or
the Aeronautical Center Counsel (as to mat-
ters under Title V of the FA Act) issues
the order of the Administrator, except that
if the holder has made a valid request for
a formal hearing on a matter under Title V
of the FA Act initially or after an infor-
mal conference, Subpart D of this part gov-
erns further proceedings.
(dq) Any person whose certificate is af-
fected by an order issued under this sec-
tion may appeal to the National Transporta-
tion Safety Board. If the certificate hol-
der files an appeal with the Board, the Ad-
ministrator's order is stayed unless the
Administrator advises the Board that an
emergency exists and safety in air commerce
a-73
requires that the order become effective
immediately. If the Board is so advised,
the order remains effective and the Board
shall finally dispose of the appeal within
60 days after the date of the advice. This
paragraph does not apply to any person
whose Certificate of Aircraft Registration
is affected by an order issued under this
section.
14 C.F.R. § 13.25 (1988)
Injunctions
(a) Whenever it is determined that a
person has engaged, or is about to engage,
in any act or practice constituting a
violation of the Federal Aviation Act of
1958, or any regulation or order issued
under it for which the FAA exercises
enforcement responsibility, or, with
respect to the transportation or shipment
by air of any hazardous materials, in any
act or practice constituting a violation of
a-74
the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act,
or any regulation or order issued under it
for which the FAA exercises enforcement
responsibility, the Chief Counsel, the
Assistant Chief Counsel for Regulations and
Enforcement, the Regional Counsel con-
cerned, or the Aeronautical Center Counsel
may request the United States Attorney
General, or the delegate of the Attorney
General, to bring an action in the ap-
propriate United States District Court for
such relief as is necessary or appropriate,
including mandatory or prohibitive injunc-
tive relief, and punitive damages, as
provided by section 1007 of the Federal
Aviation Act of 1958 (49 U.S.C. 1487) and
section llli(a) of the Hazardous Materials
Transportation Act (49 U.S.C. 1810).
x* & & ®
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.