Opposition Brief — Union de Transports Aeriens v. Beckman

Supreme Court brief1988

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. 87-873

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Gnited States

OCTOBER TERM, 1987

UNION DE TRANSPORTS AERIENS,

Petitioners,

-against-

ROBERT M. BECKMAN, ESQ.,

Respondent.

RESPONDENT'S OPPOSITION TO PETITION

FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

JACOB A. STEIN, Esq.*

PaTRiCK A. MALONE, Esq.

STEIN, MITCHELL, & MEZINES

1800 M Street, N.W.

Suite 1060-N

Washington, D. C. 20036

(202) 737-7777

Attorneys for Respondent

Robert M. Beckman, Esq.

* Counsel of Record

PRESS OF BYRON 8S. ADAMS, WASHINGTON, D.C. (202) 347-8203

COUNTER-STATEMENT OF QUESTIONS PRESENTED

I. Does Fed. R. Civ. P. 11 require sanctions for inad-

vertent errors in a pleading that do not affect the validity

of the pleading and which were timely corrected?

II. In reviewing a district court’s denial of a motion for

Rule 11 sanctions in a case where an attorney’s intent is

in dispute, is the court of appeals required to make a de

novo determination of the attorney’s state of mind?

TABLE OF CONTENTS

COUNTER-STATEMENT OF QUESTIONS PRESENTED ..

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ..........ccccccscccccceseceecceesseeeees

-COUNTER-STATEMENT OF THE CASE o..ececcesccessseseees

REASONS For DENYING THE WRIT ..............00ecceeeees

1.The Facts Are Not Undisputed As The

Petitioner ASSCrts ............ccccssssssseseeeeeeeeeees

2.There Is No Conflict Among The

CONS ks ccesaineeeintinn

3.The Record Is Not Developed For Ade-

quate Review By This Court ....................

COMCEAIIONE | cscs ccnciccincnncdnmudsbicnseamconiialmmskeiainaks

APPENDIX

Affidavit Of Robert M. Beckman In Opposition To

UTA’s Supplemental Memorandum .................

on me E:

10

la

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES: Page

Eastway Const. Corp. v. City of New York,

762 F.2d 243 (2d Cir. 1985) ...............eseeceeeeee 8

Golden Eagle Distributing Corp. v. Burroughs

Corp., 801 F.2d 1531 (9th Cir. 1986) ............. 8,10

Hudson v. Moore Business Forms, Inc.,

827 F.2d 450 (9th Cir. 1987) ....... eee 8

Westmoreland v. CBS, Inc., 770 F.2d 1168

i I socal cndesk cideseseininsnccenasepnenssececorees 7

RULES:

RN TF i icais ca haneencjaccsncvesdtatsesesecdsnese 2,4,6,9

i isc cicisnspnchavadevacnspetencncsentnas 4

PN IS Be BED adnicessidcaccinciccesensersccoquccsvoncanence 3

» , y

’

peek ; p

i -

" . P

; ’

wit

:

‘

; j

fr |

) é ¥

“ 7

;

. I

. J ‘

a

- t

»

;

r :

be ;

‘

P 9 A

wits os ri 1

wae my Se adie Uae,

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Gnited States

OCTOBER TERM, 1987

No. 87-873

UNION DE TRANSPORTS AERIENS,

Petitioners,

-against-

RoBERT M. BECKMAN, Esq.,

Respondent.

RESPONDENT’S OPPOSITION TO PETITION

FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

COUNTER-STATEMENT OF THE CASE

This case concerns an editing mistake made by

plaintiffs’ counsel in the drafting of a lengthy and

complex complaint in Adams v. Pan American World

Airways, Inc., et al., Civil No. 86- 0304. The com-

plaint contained 345 paragraphs and was 161 pages

long. As the court of appeals noted, the complaint

“was prepared under extreme time pressures.

Lee |

There were 11 defendants, nine of which were air-

lines. As a drafting device, the nine airline defendants

1 Adams v. Pan American World Airways, Inc., 828 F.2d 24,

32 (D.C. Cir. 1987).

———— -

2

were referred to by the defined term “airline

defendants.” In six places in the complaint, the use

of the generic term was incorrect because the alle-

gation, which did apply to eight of the nine airline

defendants, did not apply to Union de Transport

Aeriens (UTA). These allegations related to price fix-

ing by Laker’s existing competitors on the North At-

lantic. UTA did not operate on the North Atlantic.

UTA operated in Europe and the Far East. Plaintiffs’

counsel knew this fact. The complaint should have

been worded in those six places: “airline defendants

except UTA.” It was so corrected in a timely manner

by an amended complaint before UTA moved for

sanctions in the District Court under Fed. R. Civ. P.

11.

The error had no substantive impact on the claims

against UTA in the complaint. While UTA did not

directly compete with Laker, Laker had proposed to

expand its operations into markets UTA was serving,

and Laker thus posed a competitive threat to UTA.

UTA was deeply involved in the conspiracy to put

Laker out of business.

In the prior case, Laker Airways, Ltd. v. Pan

American World Airways, Civil Nos. 82-3362, 83-416

and 83-2791, discovery had revealed that UTA’s chair-

man had sent telexes to the top executives of eight

other airlines suggesting they jointly pressure certain

lenders to breach their agreement to provide Laker

with necessary financing. UTA’s efforts were suc-

cessful. UTA’s actions directly led to the destruction

of Laker Airways.’?

? This evidence is described in an affidavit by plaintiff's counsel

Robert M. Beckman, Esquire, the respondent here. The affidavit

Plaintiffs’ opposition to UTA’s supplemental mem-

orandum was filed on April 11, 1986, four days after

plaintiffs responded to the main motion to dismiss by

all defendants. The supplemental opposition focused

on showing the factual basis for alleging that UTA

had conspired with the other defendants to destroy

the plaintiffs’ workplace. This opposition included an

affidavit by respondent Beckman reciting in detail the

evidence showing that UTA had in fact participated

in crucial aspects of the conspiracy to destroy Laker

and that Laker was in the process of expanding into

UTA’s markets in Europe and the Far East. The

affidavit further stated, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.

56(f), that discovery was needed to demonstrate that

there was a genuine issue of material fact as to

whether UTA’s participation in the conspiracy was

motivated by its fear of Laker’s proposed expansion

‘into UTA’s markets before the trial court could prop-

erly rule on UTA’s motion for summary judgment

based on UTA’s status as a non-competitor of Laker.

The error of including UTA by implication in the

price-fixing allegations relating to Laker’s existing

was filed in the District Court and is included here as an ap-

pendix.

4

competitors did not affect the issue of whether the

plaintiffs stated a claim against UTA. Accordingly,

the plaintiffs’ supplemental opposition did not address

the error resulting from failing to exclude UTA from

the generic term “airline defendants” in six places in

the complaint, which counsel regarded as a non-sub-

stantive housekeeping matter.

On April 14, 1986, UTA’s counsel sent respondent

Beckman a demand that he dismiss the lawsuit against

UTA, contending again that there was no basis for

including UTA as a defendant. UTA’s demand did

not address the facts shown in plaintiffs’ April 11,

1986 opposition concerning UTA’s participation in the

conspiracy.

On April 28, 1986, plaintiffs filed a motion under

Fed. R. Civ. P. 15 to amend the complaint to correct

the six places where the complaint erroneously in-

cluded UTA by implication. The amended complaint

also added factual allegations that spelled out UTA’s

leading role in the conspiracy to destroy Laker’s fi-

nancing.

UTA then filed its motion for Rule 11 sanctions on

May 7, 1986. On June 30, 1986, the district court

granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss but denied

UTA’s motion for sanctions in a footnote. Adams v.

Pan American World Airways, Inc., 640 F. Supp.

683, 686 n.11 (D.D.C. 1986). The court of appeals

affirmed the district court on both issues.’

* Plaintiffs have petitioned for a writ of certiorari on the is-

sue of their standing to sue. See Adams v. Pan American World

Airways, Inc., No. 87-1218.

5

REASONS FOR DENYING THE WRIT

1. THE FACTS ARE NOT UNDISPUTED AS THE

PETITIONER ERTS.

- As respondent's Counter-Statement of the Case

makes clear, UEA's slow of whet begpened in the

District Court is far from undisputed. This is not a

case of bald and deliberate misrepresentation. It was

an editing error made under time pressure that was

not caught before the complaint was filed because the

error was one’ of implication, not of express misstate-

ment.

In addition, contrary to UTA, plaintiffs’ counsel

never “continued to rely on the false assertions in

resisting a motion to dismiss the complaint.’ Rather,

plaintiffs’ counsel focused on refuting UTA’s mis-

leading contention that correction of the error would

eliminate it from the case. Plaintiffs’ counsel thus set

out evidence showing the District Court how UTA

had participated in the anti-competitive conspiracy and

that UTA was a potential competitor of Laker, and

then within a short time made the housekeeping cor-

rections to eliminate UTA from the allegations of

price-fixing by the eight other airline defendants.' Con-

trary to UTA’s representations here, UTA never made

‘UTA Petition for Writ of Certiorari at 3.

5 UTA thus seriously misleads this court when it asserts that

Beckman knowingly used false allegations to defend against the

motion to dismiss. Petition for Writ at 11. The errors in the

complaint were corrected long before the district court ruled on

the motion to dismiss. It was UTA, not Beckman, that tried to

capitalize unfairly on the errors in the complaint by using them

to argue misleadingly that UTA had no role in the conspiracy

against Laker.

a formal demand simply that the errors be corrected

but demanded instead that the entire complaint

against it be dismissed. Indeed, UTA’s position as to

the alleged intent of the respondent is nonsensical:

There is no motive that would explain why counsel

would deliberately make an allegation that his adver-

sary can easily and conclusively disprove. The only

possible explanation is simple error.

It was this sharp factual dispute as to the

respondent’s alleged state of mind that the District

Court implicitly resolved against UTA by its terse

denial of the motion for sanctions. The’District Court

Judge, Harold Greene, is well known as a careful and

thoughtful judge. In this case, he was familiar with

counsel on all sides, having presided over the original

Laker suit. His decision showed that he viewed UTA’s

sanctions effort as a meritless tempest in a teapot in

which UTA was trying to convert an innocent mistake

into something sinister. UTA is still rearguing the

same facts that failed to persuade both courts below.

2. THERE IS NO CONFLICT AMONG THE CIRCUITS.

There is no conflict among the circuits as petitioner

UTA suggests in the law concerning the scrutiny with

which appellate courts review Rule 11 decisions by

district courts. UTA misreads the decision of the ap-

pellate court below in trying to manufacture a con-

flict.

The court below, citing the lead case in its circuit,

held that it could reverse the district court “‘only if

it abused its ‘wide discretion’ to determine whether

grounds exist to support Rule 11 sanctions.” Adams

v. Pan Amerwan World Airways, Inc., supra, 828

F.2d at 32, citing Westmoreland v. CBS, Inc., 770

F.2d 1168, 1174 (D.C. Cir. 1985). This is a reference

to the district court’s fact-finding role, not to its con-

clusions of law. The full quotation from the cited pas-

sage of Westmoreland makes this clear:

In determining whether factual (1) or dilatory

or bad faith (3) reasons exist which may give

rise to invocation of Rule 11 sanctions, the

district court is accorded wide discretion. For

the district court has tasted the flavor of the

litigation and is in the best position to make

these kinds of determinations. However, once

the court finds that these factors exist, Rule

11 requires that sanctions of some sort be

imposed.

Westmoreland v. CBS, Inc., supra, 770 F.2d at 1174-

75 (emphasis in original).®

We read the D.C. Circuit’s opinions in Adams and

Westmoreland simply to hold that the fact-finding in-

quiry is subject to review for abuse of discretion,

whereas the legal issue of whether specific conduct

violates the rule is subject to de novo review—once

it has been determined what the conduct is.

The circuits that UTA cites as being in conflict with

the D.C. Circuit are in fact in accord with this view.

The Ninth Circuit, for example, has made an obser-

vation about the advantage of the district court very

similar to the D.C. Circuit’s statement quoted above

in Westmoreland.

® The court also said that de novo review, rather than review

for abuse of discretion, would be appropriate where the issue

involved the legal sufficiency of the pleading. Jd., 770 F.2d at

1175. That is not an issue here.

[AJjlthough this court reviews de novo whether

particular conduct is sanctionable, it is nec-

essarily handicapped in its review because it

is more distant from the parties and events

than the district court.

Hudson v. Moore Business Forms, Inc., 827 F.2d 450,

453-54 (9th Cir. 1987). The court went on to say that

the district court’s personal contact with the attorneys

was a factor to weigh in the appellate review process.’

The only other circuit cited by UTA as being in

alleged conflict with the D.C. Circuit is the Second

Circuit. That court, in the case cited by UTA, simply

observed: ‘‘Where the only question on appeal be-

comes whether, in fact, a pleading was groundless,

we are in as good a position to determine the answer

and, thus, we need not defer to the lower court’s

opinion.” Eastway Const. Corp. v. City of New York,

762 F.2d 243, 254 n.7 (2d Cir. 1985).

The issue here is very different. UTA’s petition for

writ of certiorari, as well as all of its arguments in

the court below, make plain that its motion for sanc-

tions hinges on the respondent’s alleged state of

mind.* That is an issue of fact, not of law, and no

7 The other Ninth Circuit case cited by UTA is in accord with

respondent’s view of the law. In Golden Eagle Distributing Corp.

v. Burroughs Corp., 801 F.2d 1531, 1538 (9th Cir. 1986), the

court stated: “{W]hether specific conduct violated the Rule is a

legal question which must be reviewed de novo. [citation omitted]

If there is any dispute as to factual determinations concerning

the conduct, the determinations would be reviewed under a

clearly erroneous standard.”

®* For example, the petition for writ of certiorari argues that

Beckman’s conduct “‘can hardly be deemed inadvertent.” Petition

at 4.

ee eee Tee

9

court to our knowledge has held that an appellate

court that has never seen the respondent lawyer face-

to-face can judge de novo his state of mind.

3. THE RECORD IS NOT DEVELOPED FOR ADE-

QUATE REVIEW BY THIS COURT.

The District Court made no express findings on

UTA’s motion for sanctions. Impliedly, the court sim-

ply found the motion for sanctions wholly meritless

and gave it appropriately short shrift. As noted above,

the facts as to respondent’s state of mind and his

motive are in sharp dispute. At most, the only relief

UTA could request would be an order of remand for

the district court to enter findings of fact and explain

its reasons for denying sanctions. That would be a

useless exercise here. There were multiple appropriate

reasons for denying sanctions which were fully briefed

in both courts below. Besides the reasons discussed

above—that respondent Beckman simply lacked the

sinister intent alleged by UTA—another reason is that

the errors did not affect the validity of the complaint

against UTA.

Rule 11 is directed by its plain language to the

overall factual and legal basis for the pleading. It is

not aimed at rooting out and sanctioning every error

in an otherwise meritorious pleading. As one court

held:

Nothing in the language of the Rule or the

Advisory Committee Notes supports the view

that the Rule empowers the district court to

impose sanctions on lawyers simply because

a particular argument or ground for relief

contained in a non-frivolous motion is found

by the district court to be unjustified.

10

Golden Eagle Distributing Corp. v. Burroughs wesiegs Ss

supra, 801 F.2d at 1540-41.

Because UTA participated in the conspiracy against

Laker, the error in the complaint gave UTA no

grounds to urge dismissal apart from those raised by

its fellow conspirators. Therefore UTA was put to no

extra work because of plaintiffs’ counsel’s mistake. A

simple denial of the inaccurate allegations in an an-

swer to the complaint would have protected UTA’s

position.? Instead, UTA multiplied the proceedings

needlessly by a series of petulant pleadings in the

district court, by a meritless appeal, and by this now

meritless petition for certiorari.

CONCLUSION

This is not a case where undisputed facts present

a clean legal issue to this court for resolution. Rather,

the record reflects sharp factual dispute about a law-

yer’s motive and intent. There is no conflict among

the circuits as to the deference by appellate courts

to a district court’s fact-findings in this peculiarly

fact-intensive issue of state of mind. In any case, UTA

is the perpetrator, not the victim, of abusive litigation

tactics by its continued pursuit of sanctions for an

inadvertent error in an otherwise valid complaint that

caused UTA no injury.

® In addition, as we noted in both courts below, UTA not once

tried to resolve the problem informally. A five-minute telephone

call would have straightened out the misunderstanding. That

UTA so plainly was pouncing on its adversary’s mistakes to

seize advantage no doubt affected the district court’s decision

to deny sanctions.

11

Respectfully submitted,

Jacob A. Stein*

Patrick A. Malone

STEIN, MITCHELL & MEZINES

1800 M Street, N.W.

Suite #1060N

Washington, D.C. 20036

(202) 737-7777

Attorneys for Responde:.t

Robert M. Beckman, Esquire

* Counsel of Record

APPENDIX

la

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

DAVID WEAVER ADAMS, et al.,

)

)

Plaintiffs, )

y, . Civil Action

) No.. 86-0304

PAN AMERICAN WORLD AIRWAYS, INC.,

)

et al., )

)

Defendants )

)

)

JOHN ERIC CLIFTON, et al., )

)

Plaintiffs, )

)

v. )

)

PAN AMERICAN WORLD AIRWays, INC.,

)

et al., )

oa ae

Defendants. Civil Action

= : No. 86-0629

AFFIDIVIT OF ROBERT M. BECKMAN

In OPPOSITION TO

UTA’S SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM

Robert M. Beckman, being duly sworn, states as follows

on information and belief based on personal knowledge:

1. I am familiar with the documents produced by UTA

and other defendants in response to discovery requests in

2a

Laker Airways Limited v. Pan American World Airways,

Civil Action Nos. 82-3362, 83-0416 and 83-2791. These doc-

uments were returned to the defendants pursuant to the

Settlement Agreement. Copies of certain documents are

in public records. In addition, I have notes and recollec-

tions of the information developed in discovery in that

case.

2. UTA has submitted a document in Adams v. Pan

American Worid Airways which it has styled ‘“Supple-

mental Memorandum of UTA in Support of Defendant’s

Motion to Dismiss the Complaint.”” UTA’s Supplemental

Memorandum asserts that facts alleged in plaintiffs’ Com-

plaint are “‘erroneous’’. In support of its assertions, UTA

submits an affidavit of its counsel, Sanford C. Miller, Esq.

8. On April 7 1986, the undersigned telephoned Mr.

Miller and asked for clarification of UTA’s intention in

submitting an affidavit in support of its Motion to Dismiss

under Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(bX6). The undersigned pointed out

to Mr. Miller that the presentation by UTA of matters

outside the pleading if not excluded by the court, could

lead to the motion being treated as one for summary judg-

ment and disposed of as provided in Rule 56. If UTA’s

Supplemental Memorandum were to be so treated by the

court, then Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b) provides that “all parties

shall be given reasonable opportunity to present all ma-

terial ade pertinent to such a motion by Rule 56.” The

undersigned pointed out to Mr. Miller that UTA and the

other defendants had moved for a stay of discovery (which

the court granted on April 7, 1986, subsequent to the

telephone conversation with Mr. Miller). The undersigned

explained to Mr. Miller that UTA had placed the plaintiffs

on the horns of dilemma. If UTA is seeking summary

judgment, the plaintiffs must submit specific facts as would

be admissible in evidence to show that there are genuine

issues for trial. Plaintiffs are unable to present fully the

facts essential to justify their position because discovery

is stayed, at the request of UTA and the other defendants.

3a

UTA’s intention or to take

iF

i

TRE, SF

+

iH

i

1

ct

H

i

H

Se

:

:

are unable to present fully

i

4!

i

af

i

genuine issues for trial as to UTA’s

5. UTA argues in its Supplemental Memorandum that

critical factual nexus between UTA and Laker Air-

:

‘ what this assertion has to

do with the issue of standing. It is also unclear what UTA

means by a “critical factual nexus.”

6. UTA argues that it was not a competitor of Laker

i state what conclusion it draws

as to whether UTA joined the conspiracy to destroy the

plaintiffs’ workplace, as alleged in the Complaint.

7. Exhibits C and D to Mr. Miller’s affidavit show that

UTA operated airline service between points in Europe.

Those exhibits also show that UTA operated airline service

to Australia. Sir Freddie Laker has testified that Laker

Airways was planning to provide air transportation within

Europe in competition with UTA and was planning to

provide air transportation to Australia that would compete

with UTA. UTA’s President, Mr. Rene Lapautre, has tes-

tified under oath in his deposition in the Laker Airways

case, that he knew that Laker Airways wanted to operate

4a

low fare scheduled service in Europe and that Laker Air-

ways had applied for rights to serve Australia.

8. Mr. Lapautre has testified that on January 28, 1982,

he sent a telex message to the Chief Executives of KLM,

SAS, Swissair, Lufthansa, Alitalia, British Caledonian, Sa-

bena and Iberia, stating as follows:

I would like to draw your personal attention on

the situation presently developing between Laker

and MDC/General Electric by which the two man-

ufacturers would invest 9.4 million USD and have

a 18 to 28 percent holding in this carrier. It is

totally inacceptable to see two of our main sup-

pliers utilizing funds generated by their main

clients to provide direct assistance to the one who

very openly and knowingly generated the disas-

trous crisis which we are in. I suggest we make

known to the presidents of McDonnell Douglas

and General Electric our opposition to such a

move. Could you advise your comments.

9. Sir Adam Thomson, the Chief Executive of British

Caledonian, replied to Mr. Lapautre’s telex of January 28,

1982 by a telex dated January 29, 1982, stating as follows:

BCAL has already taken the action you propose.

The financial support is much greater than the

9.4 million U.S.D. you méition.

Mr. Lapautre testified that he received this telex from

Sir Adam Thomson.

10. On February 2, 1982, Sir Adam Thomson, Chief

Executive of British Caledonian, sent copies by telex to

the Chief Executives of UTA, KLM, SAS, Swissair, Luf-

thansa, Alitalia and Sabena of a telex message he sent on

February 2, 1982, to Sanford N. McDonnell, Chairman of

the Board of McDonnell Douglas, and John Brizendine,

President of Douglas Aircraft Co., stating as follows:

ee ee eT

5a

Assuming information supplied by John Gentling

to Trevor Boud this morning re MDCs massive

support and investment for Laker Airways is cor-

rect BCAL has no further interest in McDonnell

Douglas aircraft.

Mr. Lapautre testified that he received this telex.

11. Mr. Lapautre testified that on February 2, 1982,

Mr. Lapautre sent copies by telex to the Chief Executives

of KLM, SAS, Swissair, Lufthansa, Alitalia, British Ca-

ledonian, Sabena and Iberia of a telex message he sent

on February 2, 1982, to Sanford McDonnell, Chairman of

MDC, and Brian Rowe, a Senior Executive of General

Electric, stating as follows:

I am addressing you as a longstanding client of

your company with which UTA has done business

valued millions of dollars. I am extremely upset

by the information about the intended commit-

ment of your company in Laker Airways.

This is a fundamental departing from the estab-

lished neutral position of every manufacturer

which cannot be accepted. Furthermore it is iron-

ical that you would provide direct support to the

one who openly and knowingly generated the dis-

astrous crisis which we are in. It would be out-

rageous to the whole air transport industry and

particularly to your clients who are providing

funds to your company.

Such a decision from your part would undoubt-

edly bear consequences on our future relationship

and I do hope you will avoid entering such un-

desirable situation.

Best regards

R. Lapautre/Chairman

6a

12. Mr. Lapautre testified that he received a telex mes-

sage on February 2, 1982, from the Chief Executive of

Swissair addressed to Mr. Lapautre and the Chief Exec-

utives of KLM, SAS, Lufthansa, Alitalia, Sabena, British

Caledonian and Iberia, stating as follows:

Following telex just sent to Sanford N. Mc-

Donnell Chairman of Board McDonnell Douglas

and J. Brizendine President Douglas aircraft:

“In view of negotiations between MDC and Laker

Swissair would like to express deep concern if

any debt portion should be converted into any

form of equity. Such a move would be detrimen-

tal to our current good business relations.”’

13. Mr. Lapautre testified that he received a telex mes-

sage on February 3, 1982, from the Chief Executive of

Lufthansa addressed to Mr. Lapautre and also to the Chief

Executives of KLM, Alitalia, British Caledonian, Sabena

and Iberia, stating as follows:

Subject MDC/GE Salvage Operation vs. Laker

Held telconf yesterday with Sandy McDonnell,

Ed Hood and Warren Kraemer. Had visit of

James McMillan, President, MDC Finance Corp.

today in Frankfurt.

Admittedly bank consortium in its Laker survival

plan requires MDC to transform 46 million USD

of outstanding debt into nonvoting preferred

stock. Further to inject 8 million USD cash into .

Laker in order to secure immediate liquidity de- ;

mands and bring him over March and April. }

Figures for GE are 10 and 2 million USD re-

spectively.

GE refused for principal reasons involvement of

this type with airline but seems prepared to con-

tribute indirectly via MDC. MDC itself feels com- |

Ta

pelled to protect somehow own risks in magnitude

of 50 million USD, dis::garding impact on other

airlines.

Expressed following position of Lufthansa in a

very clear language:

1. Understand financial pressures however are

extremely concerned about such business prac-

tices resulting in further damage to the in-

dustry.

2. Very obviously Laker was poor in private eq-

uity but aimed to jeopardize manufacturers

main clients with precarious fare policies in a

quite presumptuous manner.

3. Sellers credit protection has to be limited to

A/C mortgages or similar securities but noth-

ing more. Otherwise Lufthansa will require di-

rect business risk sharing provisions in any

future purchase contract with MDC/GE and

will cease MDF 100 evaluation with immediate

effect.

4. Major clients of MDC/GE directly or indirectly

lost much more through Lakers’ malpractices

than now at stake for the suppliers. Are not

prepared to suffer one year longer and con-

tinue normal business relations with manufac-

turers involved!

MDC/GE seemed quite alerted by our interfer-

ence and promised to review their position in

light of arguments presented. There were also a

lot of excuses all disregarding impact on airlines.

For reasons understandable GE at present seems

to react more responsive than MDC.

Will press Airbus Industrie to offer cancellation

rights A 300/A 310 without penalty if such right

is granted to Laker.

8a

14. Mr. Lapautre testified that he received a telex mes-

sage on February 3, 1982, from the Chief Executive of

Sabena which was also addressed to the Chief Executives

of Swissair, KLM, SAS, Lufthansa, Alitalia, British Ca-

ledonian and Iberia, stating as follows:

Please find hereafter copy my telex sent to MDC

and GE to the attention of Sanford N. Mc-

Donnell, J. Brizendine and Brian Rowe.

“In view of numerous press releases about ne-

gotiations between MDC and Laker I wish to

express deep concern over the reported attitude

you could be adopting which goes beyond a man-

ufacturer’s role. Such practices would adversely

affect our present good business relationship.

Best regards,

C. Van Rafelghem”

15. Mr. Lapautre testified that he received a telex mes-

sage on February 4, 1982, from the Chief Executive of

KLM which was also addressed to the Chief Executives

of Lufthansa, SAS, Swissair, Alitalia, British Caledonian,

Sabena and Iberia, stating as follows:

Sent following Telex to MDC and GE Attention

S. McDonnell, J. Brizendine, B. Rowe

“Please note KLM is deeply-eoncerned about re-

cent reports of planned financial assistance by

MDC and GE to Laker Airways. See for instance

Wall Street Journal of Jan. 21. According to ru-

mors actual investment will be much higher than

dirs 9.4 Mil as mentioned. Would appreciate

learning in how far above info is correct.”

16. Mr. Lapautre testified that he received a telex mes-

sage on February 4, 1982, from the Chief Executive of

Alitalia which was also addressed to the Chief Executives

of KLM, Lufthansa, Sabena, British Caledonian and Iberia,

stating as follows:

9a

I quote telex sent 2 Feb t Sanford McDonnell

and General Electric.

“Having received information on your intention

to invest a conspicuous amount of capital in Laker

Airways I would appreciate your confirming if

affirmative. If so I feel obliged to advise you that

this move by an aircraft engine manufacturer may

have severe consequences on our future decision

of choice of suppliers for new equipment. Ac-

cording to my view there is an incompatibility

that suppliers become shareholders of their own

clients for evident reasons.”

17. The foregoing demonstrates UTA’s participation in

the alleged conspiracy to destroy the plaintiffs’ workplace.

The undersigned avers that the documents and testimony

of the defendants and their alleged co-conspirators will

produce more evidence of the complicity of UTA in the

alleged conspiracy. The evidence will show that UTA was

a driving force in forming the group of MDC and GE

customers that made a significant contribution to the de-

struction of plaintiffs’ workplace. These additional facts

cannot be product by affidavit because the witnesses and

custodians of the documents are hostile parties. The stay

of discovery prevents plaintiffs from obtaining further

facts.

/s/Robert M. Beckman

Robert M. Beckman (638)

Sworn to and subscribed before me this llth day of

April 1986.

Notary Public

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Opposition Brief — Union de Transports Aeriens v. Beckman · 485 U.S. 934 | Frix