Opposition Brief — Airwork Service Division v. Director, Division of Taxation of New Jersey

Supreme Court brief1985

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Office-Supreme Court, US.

FILED

* 3

\v MAY 8 1985

Wo. 84-1506

L. STEVAS,

on Fh CLERK

€

Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1984

fa’

Vv

AIRWORK SERVICE DIVISION,

Petitioner,

v.

DIRECTOR, DIVISION OF TAXATION,

Respondent.

a’

Vv

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the

Supreme Court of New Jersey

ra

Vv

BRIEF AND APPENDIX IN OPPOSITION TO

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO

THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY

fy.

Irwin I. KIMMELMAN

Attorney General of New Jersey

Attorney for Respondent,

Director, Division of Taxation

Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex

CN 112

Trenton, New Jersey 08625

(609) 292-1527

JAMES J. CIANCIA

Assistant Attorney General

Of Counsel

Harry HavsHALTER

Deputy Attorney General

On the Brief

COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CoO., (800) 835-7427 Ext. 333

COUNTERSTATEMENT OF THE CASE

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

ARGUMENT:

\

The Supreme Court Of New Jersey Correctly De-

clined To Consider The Due Process Claim As A

Matter Of State Law Since That Issue Was Never

Raised Below By Airwork And Was Alleged For

The First Time On Appeal By An Amicus Curiae

Before The Supreme Court Of New Jersey... 6

oF RSet Bares SURI MERSIN POO a TR wel a SN 14

APPENDIX la

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES:

Atirwork Service Dwision v. Director, Division

of Taxation, 2 N.J. Tax 329 (Tax Ct. 1981); 4

N.J. Tax 532 (App. Div. 1982) ; 97 N.J. 290, 478

A.2d 729 (1984) 2

Automobile Club of Michigan v. Commission of

Internal Revenue, 353 U.S. 180 (1957) 12

Bethlehem Bd. of Education v. Bethlehem Edu-

cation Association, 177 N.J. Super. 479, 427 A.2d

80 (App. Div. 1981) 7

Bruschaber v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 240 U.S.

1 (1916) 12

Cardinale v. Louisiana, 394 U.S. 487 (1969) 8

Central Illines Public Service Co. v. United States,

435 U.S. 21 (1978) 11,12

Cooper v. United States, 280 U.S. 409 (1930) 0. ~=—«12

ii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued

Page

Dixon v. United States, 381 U.S. 68 (1965) 12

Endress v. Brookdale Community College, 144

N.J. Super. 109, 364 A.2d 1080 (App. Div. 1976). 7

\ Engle v. Isaac, 457 U.S. 1141 (1982) .... ’

Fisher-Stevens v. Director, Div. of Tax., Division

of Tax Appeals, August 12, 1977 (Docket No.

S.T. 109), aff’d 121 N.J. Super. 513, 298 A.2d

77 (App. Div. 1972), certif. den. 62 N.J. 575,

303 A.2d 328 (1973) 10, 11, 13

Hill v. California, 401 U.S. 797 (1971) -... 8

Inre Byram Tp. Bd. of Education, 152 N.J. Super.

12, 377 A.2d 745 (App. Div. 1977) 7

Kolender v. Lawson, 461 U.S. 352 (1983) ececeecceeconnnnnnne «7

Moore v. Illinois, 408 U.S. 776 (1972) ea

Registrar and Transfer Company v. Director,

Div. of Taz., 166 N.J. Super. 75, 398 A.2d 1335,

(App. Div. 1979), certif. den. 81 N.J. 63, 404 A.

2d 1162 (1979) 10

Watmwright v. Goode, — U.S. —, 78 L.Ed.2d 187

(1983) 7

Welch v. Henry, 305 U.S. 134 (1938) 12

Williams v. Eggleston, 170 U.S. 304 (1897) 8

STATUTES:

28 U.S.C. § 1257 (3)

N.J.S.A. 52:14B-1 et seq. 2

N.JS.A. 52:14B-8 10

N.J.S.A. 54:32B-1 et seq. 1, 6, 10

ili

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued

\ Page

N.J.S.A. 54:32B-3 6

N.J.S.A. 54:32B-3(b) (2) 6

N.J.S.A. 54:32B-14 9

TExtTs :

New Jersey Public Law 1966, chapter 30, enacted

April 27, 1966 9

New Jersey Public Law 196°, chapter 51 9

COUNTERSTATEMENT OF THE CASE

Petitioner, Airwork Service Division (“Airwork’’), is

seeking, by writ of certiorari, to have this Court review

a decision by the Supreme Court of New Jersey sustain-

ing an assessment imposed under the New Jersey Sales

and Use Tax, N.J.S.A. 54:32B-1 et seq., by the respondent,

New Jersey Director of the Division of Taxation (“Diree-

tor’’). Airwork maintains that the decision sustained an

unpublished change in the Director’s policy which was

retroactively applied against Airwork in violation of the

Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. This

issue was not addressed by the Supreme Court of New

Jersey because it was never raised below by Airwork and

was raised for the first time before the Supreme Court of

New Jersey by an amicus curiae, the American Civil Lib-

erties Union.

Airwork is in the business of repairing plane engines

for customers. Airwork conducted its repairing services

solely in New Jersey for customers located throughout

the country. At issue is the taxability of those receipts

derived from repairing services performed on plane en-

gines destined for delivery to out-of-state customers fol-

lowing the performance in New Jersey of the taxable

services for the period August 12, 1971 to June 30, 1973.

Airwork challenged the assessment before the Tax Court

of New Jersey maintaining that the repairing services,

performed on goods destined for out-of-state delivery,

were not taxable under the literal language of the Sales

Tax, that the assessment violated the Commerce Clause

of the United States Constitution by burdening inter-

state commerce, that the assessment violated the Ecual

Protection Clause on the basis that the performance of

1

2

services in this state on goods destined for out-of-state

delivery should be treated similarly to the sale of goods

across state lines, that the assessment violated the Due

Process Clause because New Jersey had insufficient nexus

with the transaction to warrant the assessment and that

the policy underlying the assessment should have been

reflected in a regulation adopted pursuant to the New

Jersey Administrative Procedure Act, N./J.S.A. 52:14B-1

et seq., as a condition for imposing the assessment.

The Tax Court heard this matter on crossmotions for

summary judgment and upheld the assessment in a writ-

ten decision dated March 27, 1981. Airwork Service Divi-

sion v. Director, Division of Taxation, 2 N.J. Tax 329

(Tax Ct. 1981) (Supp. App. 3a). Airwork appealed the

judgment to the New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate

Division, which affirmed the trial court’s holding. 4 N.J.

Taz 532 (App. Div. 1982) (Supp. App. 21a). The Supreme

Court of New Jersey granted Airwork’s petition for cer-

tification and, in a decision dated July 23, 1984 (97 NJ.

290, 478 A.2d 729 (1984)) (App. la), held as follows:

1. As a matter of state law, the repairing services

performed on plane engines in New Jersey are tax-

able services under the Sales Tax, notwithstanding

that the engines were delivered to out-of-state custo-

mers following the performance of the services.

2. As a matter of state law, the Director was not

equitably estopped from imposing the assessment

merely because the taxes on such transactions were

not imposed for earlier tax years.

3. As a matter of state law, the Director was not

required to publish a regulation in accordance with

the New Jersey Administrative Procedure Act, N.J.

S.A. 52:14B-1 et seg. as a prerequisite to imposing

3

the assessment since the statutory standard clearly

reflected the taxability of the repairing services.

4. As a matter of state law, the constitutional issue

alleging a retroactive application of the sales tax in

violation of the Due Process Clause was not prop-

erly before the Court since it was never raised by

Airwork but rather was briefed for the first time

by an amicus before the New Jersey Supreme Court.

Although Airwork contends that the assessment im-

posed against it was contrary to the official policy of the

Division of Taxation as reflected in the Commerce Clear-

ing House New Jersey State Tax publication (“CCH’’)

and was thus retroactively imposed, there is no basis for

that factual finding in the record. The affidavit of Vin-

cent A. Carretta, who was the superintendent of audit

and was responsible for coordinating the audit activities

of the Division of Taxation, states that the Airwork as-

sessment,

.. Was imposed in accordance with the policy of the

Division of Taxation of subjecting to the tax all tax-

able services performed within this State notwith-

standing that the items serviced were delivered out of

the State after the rendition of the taxable service.

[Resp. App. *2a].

In addition, the affidavit of John Baldwin, the present

Director of the Division of Taxation, similarly states that,

. the policy of the Division of Taxation since the

inception of the Sales and Use Tax Act in July of

1966 has been to tax all services subject to the sales

tax performed within the State regardless of whether

the products upon which such services are performed

* The designation “Resp. .” refers to the appendix at-

tached to this brief submitted on behalf of the respondent,

Director, Division of Taxation.

are shipped out of the State subsequent to the per-

formance of the taxable service. [Resp. App. 6a par.

9}.

Mr. Baldwin consistently reiterated that position in his

deposition, noting taat the Division’s policy was to tax

the receipts from ali taxable services performed in New

Jersey notwithstanding the ultimate destination of the

goods serviced. Mr. Baldwin noted that the instructions

accompanying the sales tax returns issued in 1966 and

thereafter stated that only taxable services performed

outside of New Jersey were an exempt category, thus in-

ferring that all taxable services performed in New Jersey

were taxable (Resp. App. 24a). This instruetion form

was filed with the Secretary of State and, therefore, had

the force and effect of a regulation (Resp. App. 25a).

There is no evidence in the record to contradict the acser

tion that since 1966 the Division of Taxation has con-

sistenily taxed all taxable services performed in New

Jersey regardless of the destination of the serviced goods.

Mr. Baldwin’s affidavit further notes that the Sales

Tax Act became effective April 27, 1966 but applied to

transactions occurring after July 1, 1966 (Resp. App. 5a).

Immediately following the effective date of the act but

prior to the first date of its application, the Division o

Taxation drafted a proposed oificial news release con-

taining questions and answers about the act. One pro-

posed question and answer contained in said draft was

the following:

Q. Is the labor charge for repair work done to a boat

subject to tax where: (a) The boat docks in a

port outside New Jersey for repairs; (b) In con-

nection with such repairs, parts are transferred

from the boat to a repair shop located in New

Jersey; (c) Pursuant to a contract, upon com-

pletion of the repair work the parts are delivered

back to the boat outside New Jersey?

A. No. Charges fer repairs where the articles upon

which the work is performed are delivere’, upon

completion, pursuant to contract, to a urchaser

outside the State for use outside the tate are

exempt from the sales tax. Under the facts set

forth above, the labor charge would uot be sub-

ject to the sales tax.

The draft of the proposed official news release was modi-

fied and the quoted question and answer deleted. The

official news release that was published in June 1966,

therefore, did not contain the question and answer involv-

ing repair services performed on a boat (Resp. App. 5a

to Resp. App. 6a). Although the draft of the prc posed

news release was published by Commerce Clearing House

in its New Jersey State Tax Reporter, this draft of the

proposed news release containing the noted question and

answer was neither officially published by the Division of

Taxation nor filed with the New Jersey Secretary of State

(Resp. App. 6a).

ARGUMENT

The Supreme Court Of New Jersey Correctly De-

clined To Consider The Due Process Claim As A

Matter Of State Law Since That Issue Was Never

Raised Below By Airwork And Was Alleged For

The First Time On Appeal By An Ainicus Curiae

Before The Supreme Court Of New Jersey.

The New Jersey Sales and Use Tax, N.J.S.A. 54:32B-1

et seq., imposed a 5% levy for the assessment period in

question on the receipts derived from the sale of tangible

personal property and the performance of designated

services. N.J.S.A. 54:32B-3. The Legislature enumerated

as taxable services the “... maintaining, servicing, repair-

ing tangible personal property not held for sale in the

regular course of business. ...’’? N.J.S.A. 54:32B-3(b) (2).

The applicable statute for the period in question made no

distinction between taxable services performed on goods

destined for out-of-state delivery or goods remaining in

New Jersey and clearly taxed the servicing and repairing

functiors performed by Airwork in this state regardless

of the eventual destination of the repaired aircraft en-

gines.

Airwork maintains .aat it was a mere collector of the

tax, that it properly relied on the information published

in CCH in not collecting the tax and that the state is there-

by prohibited trom assessing an allegedly “retroactive”

tax under the Due Process Clause. This issue of “un-

constitutional unfairness” was never previously raised by

Airwork and was raised for the first time before the Su-

preme Court of New Jersey by the American Civil Lib-

erties Union, participating as an amicus curtae.

ee ce

ore eT

ae mee

The New Jersey Supreme Court declined to address

this issue, noting that this issue was raised by the Ameri-

ean Civil Liberties Union, was not previously considered

by the lower courts and was thus not being presented with

a sound and complete record to demonstrate the viability

of this allegation (Supp. App. 13a). It is well established

as a matter of state law that an amicus is not a party to

an action but merely seeks to advise and assist the court

on an issue already part of the litigation. An amicus must

thus accept the issues previously raised by the parties and

is precluded from injecting new issues not already con-

sidered. Bethlehem Bd. of Education v. Bethlehem Edu-

cation Association, 177 N.J. Super. 479, 490, 427 A.2d 80

(App. Div. 1981); In re Byram Tp. Bd. of Education, 152

N.J. Super. 12, 18, 377 A.2d 745 (App. Div. 1977) ; Endress

v. Brookdale Community College, 144 N.J. Super. 109, 123,

364 A.2d 1080 (App. Div. 1976). Therefore, since Airwork

never raised this constitutional issue before any level of

the New Jersey courts, the Supreme Court of New Jersey

properly declined to address that issue as a matter of

state law.

This Court has consistently recognized that federal

courts should intervene in the state judicial process only

to correct wrongs of a federal constitutional dimension.

Engle v. Isaac, 457 U.S. 1141 (1982). In evaluating issues

concerning state law, a federal court must defer to the

determinations by the state courts. Kolender v. Lawson,

461 U.S. 352, 356 (1983). Particularly with regard to the

views of the state’s highest court concerning issues of

state law, such views are binding on the federal courts.

Wainwright v. Goode, — U.S. —, 78 L.Ed.2d 187, 192

(1983). The fact that there was a division of opinon

among the members of a state’s highest court does not

prevent the opinion of the majority from becoming the

decision of the court and as such binding and conclusive

on the federal courts. Walliams v. Eggleston, 170 U.S.

304, 309 (1897). The decision by the Supreme Court of

New Jersey declining to consider the issue of substantive

due process in this matter on the basis that said issue

was not properly before the Court was a decision of state

law which should not now be subject to further review.

This Court’s jurisdiction to review this case arises

under 28 U.S.C. § 1257(3), which concerns federal rights

and privileges that have becn “specially set up or

ciaimed’’ and upon which there has been a final decision

of the state’s highest court. As noted, the claim by Air-

work of a substantive due process violation was never

raised by it in the state courts and is thus not a proper

issue before this Court. As noted in Cardinale v. Louist-

ana, 394 U.S. 437, 439 (1969),

Questions not raised below are those on which the

record is very likely to be inadequate, since it cer-

tainly was not compiled with those questions in mind.

And in a federal system it is important that state

courts be given the first opportunity to consider the

applicability of state statutes in light of constitu-

tional challenge, since the statutes may be construed

in a way which saves their constitutionality. Or the

issue may be blocked by an adequate state ground.

Even though States are not free to avoid constitu-

tional issues on inadequate state grounds, O'Connor

v. Ohio, 385 U.S. 92, 17 L.Ed.2d 189, 87 S.Ct. 252

(1966), they should be given the first opportunity to

consider them.

See also Moore v. Illinois, 408 U.S. 776, 799 (1972); Hill

v. California, 401 U.S. 797, 805 (1971). Therefore, the

Ee

oe

9

federal constitutional issue raised in the petition should

not be considered and the petition should be dismissed.

However, should this Court deem the challenge to the

sales tax assessment on substantive due process grounds

to be properly raised, Airwork’s assertion is, nevertheless,

without merit. Airwork, as the vendor of the taxable re-

pairing service, had the statutory obligation to charge the

sales tax to its customers or otherwise be directly liable

therefor as a ‘‘taxpayer’’ to the State. N.J.S.A. 54:32B-14.

The statute clearly provides that a vendor is to presume

that “all receipts for property or services of any type

mentioned in subsection (a), (b) and (c) of section 3...

are subject to tax until the contrary is established. . . .”

Airwork, under the alleged reliance upon the question and

answer concerning boat repairs appearing in CCH, ig-

nored this standard and failed to collect the sales tax on

the repair services. It is clear, however, that the CCH

material contained unofficial, outdated and erroneous in-

formation. For example, the same CCH publication that

contained the question and answer on the boat repairs

also contained the following question and answer regard-

ing the taxability of clothing:

Q. Is clothing taxable?

A. The sale of an item of clothing or footwear is

taxable only if the price of the item exceeds

$50. ... [Resp. App. 7a, par. 3].

The original sales tax act, New Jersey Public Law 1966,

chapter 30, was enacted on April 27, 1966 and exempted

only the first $50 of clothing and footwear purchases.

Prior to the July 1, 1966 effective date of the sales tax,

the law was amended by New Jersey Public Law 1966,

10

chapter 51 to totally exempt from the tax the sale of

clothing and footwcar. CCH continued to publish the

news release notwithstanding that it contained clearly

outdated and erroneous information. Airwork, therefore,

had no basis for reliance upon such suspect and dated

information in failing to collect the sales tax relating to

its repairing services.

Airwork, as the vendor of taxable repairing services

generating substantial receipts, should not have relied on

the CCH information and instead should have either col-

lected the sales tax from its customers or requested spe-

cific advice from the Division of Taxation as to the tax-

ability of these services. The Division of Taxation, in

accordance with N.J.S.A. 52:14B-8 of the Administrative

Procedure Act, N.J.S.A. 52:14B-1 et seg., would have is-

sued an advisory or declaratory ruling as to the taxability

of Airwork’s services had it been requested to do so.* In

addition, the assessment in question did not predate the

decision in Fisher-Stevens v. Director, Div. of Tazx., de-

cided by the Division of Tax Appeals on August 12, 1977

(Docket No. S.T. 109), aff’d 121 N.J. Super. 513, 298

A.2d 77 (App. Div. 1972), certif. den. 62 N.J. 575, 303 A.

2d 328 (1973). Fisher-Stevens, involving the taxability

of certain advertising services, unequivocally established

* In addition, Airwork could have initiated a declaratory judg-

ment action seeking clarification of the taxability of its repair-

ing services. For example, in Registrar and Transfer Company

v. Director, Div. of Tax., 166 N.J. Super. 75, 398 A.2d 1335,

(App. Div. 1979), certif. den. 81 N.J. 63, 404 A.2d 1162 (1979), a

vendor of storage services filed a declaratory judgment action

seeking a court determination as to whether the storage serv-

ices were properly taxable under the Sales Tax. The purpose

of the suit was to seek certainty as to the taxability of the

storage services.

11

the taxability of such services notwithstanding that they

were performed on goods destined for out-of-state de-

livery.

The label of ‘‘unfairness’’ placed by Airwork on this

assessment is grounded in the contention that the assess-

ment reflected a change in policy which was retroactively

applied to transactions occurring prior to the change.

Airwork cites Central Illinois Public Service Co. v. United

States, 435 U 8. 21 (1978), as purportedly supporting the

constitutional impropriety of the assessment. That case

concerned whether an employer was liable to the Internal

Revenue Service for failing to withhold federal income

taxes in 1963 on lunch expense reimbursements made to

its empleyees. The Supreme Court held that the lunch

expense reimbursements did not constitute wages for with-

holding purposes in 1963, the employer was not respon-

sible for withholding any taxes on such reimbursements

in 1963 and the employer could ivi be held responsible

in 1971 for such taxes. In reaching its decision, this Court

stressed that in 1963 the existing judicial decisions opined

that lunch expense reimbursements did not constitute

taxable wages.

Further, in 1963 and for some time thereafter all

judicial decisions were the other way, even on the

deductibility issue. Only with Correll, decided by

this Court in 1967, was there a ruling of nondeducti-

bility. And until the Court of Appeals’ decision in

the present case, no court had ever held lunch reim-

bursements to be wages for withholding purposes.

[435 U.S. at 32].

Bas<d on the judicial climate in 1963, this Court quite

properly found that the employer had no basis for with-

12

holding taxes on the employees’ reimbursed lunch ex-

penses.

The holding in Central Illinois does not support the

claim that Airwork was being retroactively subjected to

the sales tax. In August of 1971, Fisher-Stevens left no

doubt as to the taxability of Airwork’s services. The }

record in this case does not reflect any retroactive ap-

plication of the sales tax upon services. The Director of

Taxation has consistently imposed the sales tax upon all

taxable services performed in this State, regardless of

the destination of the serviced goods. Since no contrary

evidence appears in the record, Airwork has no basis for

asserting that the tax in question was retroactively im-

posed. The Supreme Court of New Jersey made such a

finding without implicating any federal constitutional

principle. This issue is, therefore, bereft of any appropri-

ate federal constitutional question reviewable by this

Court.

However, even if there is a perceived federal con-

stitutional issue involved in this case, this Court has

steadfastly sustained the imposition of tax levies clearly

warranted under the applicable tax law even in circum-

stances of retroactive application where the taxpayer

may have relied to his detriment on previous administra-

tive policy. Dixon v. United States, 381 U.S. 68, 73

(1965); Automobile Club of Michigan v. Commission of

Internal Revenue, 353 U.S. 180, 183 (1957). See also

Welch v. Henry, 305 U.S. 134 (1938); Cooper v. United

States, 280 U.S. 409 (1930); Bruschaber v. Union Pacific

R.R. Co., 240 U.S. 1 (1916). It is clear that the legal

contention proposed by Airwork is without merit and cer-

tainly does not warrant further review by this Court.

a

13

The Sales Tax statute on its face provided no exemption

for taxable repairing services performed completely in

New Jersey merely because the goods serviced were ulti-

mately destined for out-of-state delivery. The assessment

imposed was unequivocally consistent with the statutory

standard and thereby, under the clear precedents articu-

lated by this Court, could not be construed to deprive

Airwork of due process of law.

In summary, Airwork had no basis to rely on the

CCH information in failing to collect the tax, Airwork

ignored the clear holding in Fisher-Stevens regarding the

taxability of services performed in New Jersey, Airwork

failed to seek clarification from the Division of Taxation

as to the taxability of its repairing services in accordance

with the procedures outlined in the Administrative Pro-

cedure Act, Airwork ignored the clear language of the

Sales Tax that repairing services, without exception, are

subject to the tax and Airwork failed to adhere to the

presumption of taxability explicitly articulated in the

Sales Tax. In addition, there was no regulation or of-

ficial instruction issued by the Director to Airwork which

established the nontaxability of the repairing services,

there was no judicial opinion which reflected an incon-

sistent policy and there was no ambiguity in the statute.

As a matter of state law, the Supreme Court of New

Jersey sustained the assessment and properly declined to

consider the substantive due process issue which was

never raised by Airwork in the state courts.

The petition for writ of certiorari plainly does not

raise a question of constitutional dimension which would

warrant the granting of such extraordinary relief. There-

fore, the petition should be denied.

14

CONCLUSION

For the above-stated reasons, it is respectfully sub-

mitted that the petition for writ of certiorari should be

denied.

Respectfully submitted,

Irwin I. KrmMELMAN

Attorney General of New Jersey

Attorney for Respondent,

Director, Division of Taxation

By: Harry HavusHarer

Deputy Attorney General

Member of the Bar of the

United States Supreme Court

DATED:

James J. CIANcIA

Assistant Attorn: , General a’)

Of Counsel i

Harry HAvuSHALTER

Deputy Attorney General

On The Brief

la

APPENDIX

AFFIDAVIT OF VINCENT A. CARRETTA

DOCKET NO. 8.T. 279-7"

TAX COURT OF NEW JERSEY

JOHN J. DEGNAN

Attorney General of New Jersey

Attorney for Defendant,

Director, Division of Taxation

107 West State Street

Trenton, New Jersey 08625

By: Harry Haushalter

Deputy Attorney General

609/292-1527

ATRWORK SERVICE DIVISION, a division of Pacific

Airmotive Corporation, and a subsidiary of Purex Cor-

poration Ltd., a California corporation,

Plaintiff,

vs.

DIRECTOR, DIVISION OF TAXATION,

Defendant

STATE OF NEW JERSEY )

COUNTY OF MERCER ) SS.

Civil Action

AFFIDAVIT OF VINCENT A. CARRETTA

IN SUPPORT OF CROSS-MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT

VINCENT A. CARRETTA, of full age, being duly

sworn according to law, upon his oath deposes and says:

1. I am employed by the New Jersey Division of

Taxation as Superintendent of Audit and am responsible

-

2a

for supervising audit activity conducted by the Division

of Taxation.

2. I am familiar with the assessment imposed upon

the plaintiff for repair services under the New Jersey

Sales and Use Tax Act, N.J.S.A. 54:32B-1 et seq.

3. In a revised final determination letter dated De-

cember 17, 1974, the Division of Taxation assessed $628,-

255.31 in sales taxes plus accrued interest against the

plaintiff. Of that amount, $612,999.00 represents sales

taxes imposed by the Division of Taxation upon receipts

earned by the plaintiff for repair services performed in

this State upon plane engines and $15,256.31 represents

sales taxes imposed by the Division upon receipts earned

by plaintiff for the rental of plane engines to customers.

4. The sales taxes imposed upon the rendering of

the repair services were levied pursuant to N.J.S.A.

54 :32B-3(b) (2) and involve receipts earned by the plain-

tiff for a repairing service conducted solely within New

Jersey.

5. The assessment in question was imposed in ac-

cordance with the policy of the Division of Taxation of

subjecting to the tak all taxable services performed within

this State notwithstanding that the items serviced were

delivered out of state after the rendition of the taxable

service.

6. The assessment period in question includes Au-

gust 12, 1971 to June 30, 1973 and commenced on the cate

of the decision by the Division of Tax Appeals in Fisher-

3a

Stevens v. Director (S.T. 109), aff’d 121 N.J. Super. 51%

(App. Div. 1972, certif. den. 62 N.J. 575 (1973)

/s/ Vincent A. Carretta

Sworn to and subscribed

before me this 14th day

of January, 1980.

/s/ Harry Haushalter

Attorney at law of New Jersey

4a

AFFIDAVIT OF JOHN R. BALDWIN

SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY

CHANCERY DIVISION—MERCER COUNTY

DOCKET NO. C-1571-74

WILLIAM F. HYLAND

Attorney General of New Jersey

Attorney for Defendant

State House Annex

Trenton, New Jersey 08625

By: Harry Haushalter

Deputy Attorney General

609/292-1527

AIRWORK SERVICE DIVISION, a division of Pacific

Airmotive Corporation, a California corporation and a

subsidiary of Purex Corporation, Ltd., a California cor-

poration,

Plaintiff,

vs.

DIVISION OF TA*¥ ATION,

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY,

STATE OF NEW JERSEY,

Defendant.

STATE OF NEW JERSEY )

COUNTY OF MERCER ; i

Civil Action

AFFIDAVIT OF JOHN R. BALDWIN

JOHN R. BALDWIN, of full age, being duly sworn

according to law, upon his oath deposes and says:

5a

1. I am presently employed as Assistant Superin-

tendent of Collection and Enforcement in the Division of

Taxation, Department of the Treasury, State of New

Jersey.

2. I was formerly employed as Assistant State Su-

pervisor of the Sales Tax Bureau of the Division of Tax-

ation prior to the reorganization of the Division of Tax-

ation.

Subsequent to the effective date of the New Jersey

Sales and Use Tax Act, N.J.S.A. 54:32B-1 et seg. (April

27, 1966) and prior to the first date of applicability of the

taxes imposed thereunder (July 1, 1966), I was involved

in the promulgation and implementation of policy re-

garding the administration of said statute, and remained

so involved thereafter.

4. Immediately following the effective date of the

New Jersey Sales and Use Tax Act, but prior to the first

date of applicability of the taxes imposed thereunder, cer-

tain representatives of the Division of Taxation drafted

a proposed offivial news release containing questions and

answers about the Sales and Use Tax Act. One proposed

question and answer contained in said draft was the fol-

lowing:

Q. Is the labor charge for repair work done to

a boat subject to tax where: (a) The boat docks in

a port outside New Jersey for repairs; (b) In con-

nection with such repairs, parts are transferred from

the boat to a repair shop located in New Jersey; (c)

Pursuant to a contract, upon completion of the repair

work the parts are delivered back to the boat outside

New Jersey?

A. No. Charges for repairs where the articles

upon which the work is performed are delivered, upon

completion, pursuant to contract, to a purchaser out-

6a

side the State for use outside the State are exempt

from the sales tax. Under the facts set forth above,

the labor charge would not be subject to the sales tax.

5. The draft of the proposed official news release

was modified and the specific question and answer appear-

ing in paragraph 4 above was deleted. Attached to this

affidavit as Exhibit C is a copy of the official news re-

lease that was published in June of 1966.

6. The draft of the proposed news release was pub-

lished by Commerce Clearing House and presently ap-

pears in Volume 1 of the New Jersey State Tax Reporter

at pp. 6371-6383. The specific citation noted in paragraph

4 above is cited at p. 6380.

7. Since the proposed draft of the official news re-

lease containing the noted question and answer was never

officially published, said material was neither officially

released for publication to Commerce Clearing House nor

was it ever filed with the Office of the New Jersey Secre-

tary of State.

9. To the best of my knowledge, the policy of the

Division of Taxation since the inception of the Sales and

Use Tax Act in July of 1966 has been to tax all services

subject to the sales tax performed within the State re-

gardless of whether the products upon which such serv-

ices are performed are shipped out of the State subse-

quent to the performance of the taxable service.

/s/ John R. Baldwin

Sworn to and Subscribed

before me this 28th day

of January, 1975.

/s/

Notary Public of New Jersey

My Commission Expires Jan. 5, 1976

7a

(SEAL)

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

OFFICIAL NEWS RELEASE

Office of the State Treasurer

Statehouse, Trenton, N.J.

Phones: 292-5031, 292-5032 or 292-5119

For Release At Will

WHAT NEW JERSEY’S SALES AND USE TAX

‘. ©

MEANS TO YOU...THE CONSUMER

Must the sales tax be paid on ‘purchases complete-

ly delivered before July 1, 1966 but partially paid

for after July 1, 1966?

No. There is no tax where the goods were com-

pletely delivered before July 1, 1966.

Is there a tax on the sale of goods completely

paid for before July 1, 1966, but delivered after

July 1, 1966?

No. There is no tax where complete payment is

made before July 1, 1966.

Is clothing taxable?

The sale of an item of clothing or footwear is

taxable only if the price of the item exceeds $50.

Accessories such as jewelry, handbags, and um-

brellas, however, are taxable, regardless of price.

If a sport coat is purchased for $40 and a hat

for $15, is there a tax?

No, because the sale price of each item is under

$50.

If a suit is purchased for $55 and a hat for $15,

is there a tax?

The tax is payable on the $55 suit which is consid-

ered a single item of clothing. There is no tax

ag

> Ope

10.

11.

8a

on the sale of the hat because the sale price is

under $50. :

Is the fuel used in heating my residence taxable?

No. Purchase of all fuel is tax exempt.

I rent my living quarters. Will the rent I pay

to the landlord be taxable?

No. The sales tax is not imposed on the rental

of any real property, except hotel or motel rooms

occupied for 90 days or less where the charge is

more than $2 a day.

Is the purchase of a home taxable?

No. The sales tax does not apply to the sale

either of new or old real property no matter

whether it is residential, business or industrial.

Would the purchase of furnishings for a home be

taxable?

Yes. Any purchase of tangible personal prop-

erty is subject to the sales tax, unless specifically

exempted.

Will the sales tax apply to the materials pur-

chased by contractors and repairmen for use in

building homes and other private structures?

Yes. Sales to contractors and repairmen for use

by them in erecting private structures for others

or improving, altering or repairing real prop-

erty of others are deemed to be retail sales and

therefore taxable.

Will groceries, meat, vegetables or dairy prod-

ucts be taxed?

No. Most food for human consumption at home

is not taxable. However, candy, confectionary,

soft drinks, certain fruit drinks and liquor and

wine for off-premises consumption are taxable.

Restaurant meals are also taxable.

nage a

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

©

9a

Are admissions to skating rinks, beaches and

swimming pools taxable?

No. Charges for admission to or the use of fa-

cilities for sporting activities where the patron

is a participant are not subject to the tax.

Would the rental of shoes at a bowling alley, or

beach umbrellas at a beach or pool be taxable?

Yes. These items are taxable as tangible per-

sonal property, notwithstanding their use for par-

ticipant sports.

Are automobile repairs taxable?

Yes. The tax is payable both on parts and labor.

Most other types of services to automobiles are

also subject to tax, such as lubrication, battery

charging, towing, washing and waxing.

What restaurant meals are taxable?

A tax is imposed on restaurant meals and drink,

except alcoholic beverages.

Are meals taxable to those attending functions

of non-profit organizations, such as religious or

educational conventions?

No. An exemption is provided for meals paid

for or sold directly by organizations when these

meals are furnished at organization affairs.

Are utility bills taxable?

No. Consumers; utility services, including tele-

phone and telegraph gas, water, electricity, steam,

refrigeration services and fuel are exempt.

Would the lease or rental of a car, truck, trailer,

boat, garden tools or building tools be taxable?

Yes. The rental or lease of any tangible personal

property is taxable, unless specifically exempted.

19.

21.

22.

23.

>

10a

Would the purchase of textbooks from a college

book store be taxable?

No. Textbooks for student use are exempt. How-

ever, sales of other items sold in shops or stores

operated by charitable, religious, or educational

non-profit organizations are subject to tax.

If a resident of New Jersey buys a movie camera

outside New Jersey and brings it into the State,

must he pay a tax?

Yes, if the out-of-state vendor does not collect

the New Jersey sales tax, the buyer must pay

the use tax directly to the New Jersey Sales Tax

Bureau.| (Where a sales tax has also been paid

to another state or locality in that state, inquiry

should be made as to whether credit can be

claimed for the tax paid the other state or local-

ity in that state.)

If a resident of another state bought an auto-

mobile in this State, is the sale taxable?

No. Sales of motor vehicles to a non-resident

who has no permanent place of abode in New

Jersey are not subject to the sales tax, even if

delivered in this State, provided the motor ve-

hicle will not be used in carrying on any business,

employment or profession in this State. Pur-

chases of all other tangible personal property by

non-residents are taxable if delivered here, but

exempt if delivered outside the State.

Will a tax be payable on the purchase of a news-

paper, magazine or periodical?

No. These purchases are specifically exempt.

If a person buys his own textile material and

accessories and has a tailor make them into a

suit, are the tailor’s services subject to tax?

Yes. The production of tangible personal prop-

erty such as a suit is taxable. However, tailoring

24.

26.

27.

28.

30.

4 >

> Ob ©

ope

lla

which .nvolves the repairing or mending of tangi-

ble property is exempt.

Is a charge for radio or television repairs sub-

ject to tax?

Yes. This constitutes a repair to tangible per-

sonal property and both the charges for the parts

and labor are subject to tax.

Are cosmetics and cosmetic supplies taxable?

Yes.

Is the purchase of medicine or drugs by prescrip-

tion taxable?

No. Prescription drugs and prescription medi-

cines for the cure, relief, treatment or prevention

oi illness or disease in humans are exempt from

the tax. Non-prescription drugs or medicines,

such as aspirin, are taxable. Drugs and medi-

eines with or without prescriptions for animals

are taxable.

Is a sales tax payable on the development of

home movies, photographic films and prints?

Yes. Services performed on tangible personal

property not held for resale are taxable.

Is there a tax on “room service” meals charged

by a hotel?

Yes. The additional charge is considered part

of the cost of the meal and, therefore, taxable.

Are dietary foods and health supplements sub-

ject to the sales tax?

No. These items are exempt.

Are such things as artificial limbs, dentures and

prescription glasses taxable?

No. These prosthetic aids are exempt from the

tax.

31.

32.

33.

39.

36.

37.

-

> ©

©

© p

> Ob

12a

Are auto parking lot charges subject to tax?

No.

What types of services to tangible personal prop-

erty are taxable?

In general, the sales tax applies to the cost of

installing tangible personal property when it is

not incorporated into real property so that it

represents a capital improvement. It also applies

to maintaining, servicing and repairing tangible

personal property not held for resale in the or-

dinary course of business.

If a repair is made to my home, on what must a

tax be paid?

The tax is on the total charge, including both

labor and materials.

Are charges for lawn-mowing and snow removal

services subject to the tax?

Services of this kind are not subject to tax unlcss

performed by someone who is in a regular trade

or business offering these services to the public.

Is a charge by a tree service company for pruning

trees subject to tax?

Yes. Servicing real property is taxable.

If a home owner has his house painted or his

lawn mowed by a person who does this kind of

work only occasionally, does he pay a tax on the

amount paid?

No. This is a service rendered by a person who

is not in a regular trade or business offering his

services to the public.

In the above illustration, is there a tax on the

paint purchased?

Yes. The purchase of the paint represents a re-

tail sale of tangible property.

38.

39.

40.

41.

42.

43.

> Ope

13a

If a home-owner has his grounds cared for by a

commercial gardener, are the services taxable?

Yes. Services rendered by an individual who is

in a regular trade or business offering his services

to the public are taxable.

Would the installation of a new heating system

in a private home be taxable?

No. There is no tax on the cost of installing

property which becomes a capital improvement

to real property. However, the tax does apply

to the materials used in the installation.

Is a charge for removing the stucco exterior of

an older house and installing aluminum siding in

its place subject to tax?

No, since this constitutes a capital improvement

to real property rather than a repair. However,

the tax does apply to the aluminum siding.

If a home-owner has some broken windows re-

placed by a glazier or bathroom fixtures repaired

by a plumber, are these costs taxable?

Yes. The tax would apply to the total charge, in-

cluding both labor and materials.

Is the cost of a window-cleaning service taxable?

Yes.

Is a roofer’s charge for replacing shingles, blown

off during a windstorm, subject to tax?

Yes. This would be taxable as a repair to real

property, unless the work was extensive enough

to consider it a capital improvement.

If a home-owner has a porch added to his home,

is the total cost of this improvement taxable?

No. This represents a capital improvement and

as such only the cost of material is taxable.

47.

49.

ol.

52.

> ©

a. Pe ee ae

©

l4a

Is the service provided by a stock broker in the

purchase and sale of securities taxable?

No. Financial, management and consulting serv-

ices rendered to an individual are not taxable.

Are services rendered by the trust department

of a bank in the management of one’s estate tax-

able?

No. Personalized management and consultant

services are not taxable.

Are the charges for landscaping services taxable

for both labor and materials?

Yes—except where it becomes a capital improve-

ment. When a capital improvement is made, the

materials are taxable but no tax is due on the

service rendered.

Are services rendered by exterminators taxable?

Yes. This is one of the taxable services to tangi-

ble personal or real property.

Are alterations and repairs to wearing apparel

subject to tax?

Alterations and repairs are exempt, except alter-

ations to new clothing.

Are laundry and dry cleaning services subject to

tax?

No. Laundering and dry cleaning services are

exempt.

Are laundering and dry cleaning services per-

formed by coin-operated machines taxable?

No. Laundry and dry cleaning services are ex-

empt regardless of the method used.

Are charges for boarding dogs, cats, or other pets

subject to tax?

qv

qr

©

57.

Pp ©

Pr &

15a

Yes. In addition, other services to pets and ani-

mals, such as grooming and clipping, are taxable.

So are sales of pet foods, even though bought in

a grocery store.

Is the storage of personal and household effects

subject to tax?

Yes. The storage of all tangible personal prop-

erty not held for sale in the regular course of busi-

ness is taxable.

Are moving and storage charges subject to tax?

Storage of tangible personal property is taxable,

but moving (transporting) property is not tax-

able if the transportation cost is separately

charged.

Is the rental of a safe deposit box taxable?

Yes. The rental of a safe deposit box or similar

place is taxable.

Where the sale of food is not stated separately

but is included in a single charge which also covers

lodging—as in an American plan hotel—is the

total amount taxable?

Yes. However, if the purchaser is exempt from

the hotel room occupancy tax because he is a per-

manent resident, the portion of the charge al-

locable to lodging is not taxed.

Are loans received from a finance company tax-

able?

No. Financial services are not taxable.

Are premiums paid on insurance policies taxable?

No. Insurance premiums and annuity considera-

tions are not taxable.

Which organizations are exempt?

Exempt organizations include: (a) The United

States government and its agencies; (b) The

61.

62.

>

©

l6éa

United Nations or any international organization

of which the United States is a member; (c) The

State of New Jersey and its agencies and instru-

mentalities; and (d) Non-profit organizations op-

erated solely for religious, charitable, scientific,

literary, educational purposes, for the prevention

of cruelty to children or animals, or testing for

public safety.

However, if any of these organizations sells goods

or services in a shop or store and such goods or

services are normally sold commercially, except

for textbooks, then the exempt organization must

collect the sales tax from its customers.

When does the sales tax apply to hotel and motel

rooms?

The tax applies to transient occupancy if the

charge is more than $2 per night.

Is there a tax on hotel or motel rooms occupied

as a permanent residence?

No. If the hotel or motel rooms are occupied for

at least 90 consecutive days, there is no tax.

The YWCA rents rooms at rates of $3 per day

and up. Is the rental income from these rooms

taxable?

No. Any non-profit charitable, religious or educa-

tional organization that operates a hotel, or offers

rooms for rent, is not subject to the tax if it car-

ries on its other activities in that building.

If the hotel lists separately the charges for room

rental and the charges for certain services such

as the use of equipment, maid service, towel and

linen service, elevator service, ete., how much of

the total is subject to tax?

The total amount is taxable since charges for fur-

nishings and accommodations accompanying the

use of the room constitute rent.

67.

69.

71.

A.

A .

©

l7a

Are admissions to stock car races taxable?

Yes—if the charge is in excess of 75¢.

Are admissions to high school basketball games

taxable?

No. Admissions to elementary and high school

athletic games are exempt if the proceeds go to

the school.

Are admissions to or charges for use of skiing

facilities taxable?

No. Charges for admissions to sporting activities

in which the patron is a participant are exempt

from sales tax. This would include such sports

as bowling, swimming, roller skating and ice skat-

ing.

Are admissions to a dance sponsored by a church

taxable?!

No. Most admissions charged for non-athletic

events by non-profit groups are exempt from sales

tax.

Are admissions to college athletic events taxable?

Yes. No exemption is provided for athletic event

admissions of non-profit groups except those of

elementary and high school groups.

Are admissions paid for a ride on a ferris wheel

taxable?

Yes—if the charge exceeds 75¢

Are admission charges in excess of 75¢ to horse

races taxable?

Yes. Admissions to certain sporting events, such

as, horse racing, football and basketball are sub-

ject to the sales tax.

Are charges for delivery services taxable?

A.

72. Q.

A.

73. Q.

‘

18a

No. Charges for transportation of property from

the vendor to the consumer are not taxable where

the charge is separately stated in the written con-

tract, if any, and any bill rendered to the pur-

chaser.

Is there a tax on haircuts and beauty parlor

services?

No. All services upon the person of an individual

are not taxable. This includes, among other serv-

ices, massage, manicuring and reducing treat-

ments. Materials or supplies purchased in con-

nection with such services usually are taxable.

Are the fees charged by an employment agency

taxable?

No.

19a

(p. 1) DIVISION OF TAX APPEALS

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

DOCKET NO. S8.T. 279-75

AIRWORK SERVICE DIVISION, a Division of Pacific

Airmotive Corporation, a California corporation, and a

subsidiary of Purex Corporation, Ltd., a California Cor-

poration,

Petitioner,

Vs.

DIRECTOR, DIVISION OF TAXATION,

Respondent.

Depcsitions Upon Oral Examination of:

JOHN R. BALDWIN

TRANSCRIPT of the deposition of JOHN R. BALD-

WIN, witness in the above-entitled matter, called for

Oral Examination pursuant to the Rules of Civil Practice

and Procedure, Notice to Take Depositions and Stipuia-

tion and Agreement entered into by and between counsel

for the respective parties, said deposition being taken by

and before PATRICIA J. KEARNS, a Notary Public

and Certified Shorthand Reporter of the State of New

Jersey, at the offices of WHARTON, STEWART &

DAVIS, ESQS., 50 West Main Street, Somerville, New

20a

Jersey, on Tuesday, November 1, 1977, commencing at

approximately ten o’clock in the forenoon.

(p. 1A)

APPEARANCES:

PITNEY, HARDIN & KIPP, ESQS.,

BY: JAMES F. KEEGAN, ESQ., and

GERALD G. NEARY, ESQ.,

Attorneys for the Petitioner.

HARRY HAUSHALTER, ESQ.,

DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL

Attorney for the Respondent.

(p. 2) INDEX

WITNESS:

JOHN R. BALDWIN,

By Mr. Keegan 3

EXHIBITS:

NO. DESCRIPTION

P-1, Id. Notice to Take Depositions

and produce documents

P-2, Id. Documents consisting of

three pages

P-3, Id. Documents consisting of

two pages

Pp-4, Id. Press Release

P-5, Id. Star Ledger Photostat

P-6, Id. Affidavit of John R. Baldwin

P-7, Id. Form

DIRECT

PAGE

46

47

48

62

66

71

101

cena a eine AC ETI eB A ELEN.

Ae

2la

(p. 3) JOHN R. BALDWIN, having been duly sworn

according to law by the officer, testified as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

BY MR. KEEGAN:

Q. State your home address for the record.

A. 72 Mountainview Road, West Trenton, New

Jersey.

Q. Mr. Baldwin, my name is James Keegan. I am

an attorney from Pitney, Hardin and Kipp. We repre-

sent Airwork in the pending proceeding before the Divi-

sion of Taxation Appeals, and we are here to take your

deposition today.

Have you ever been deposed?

A. Yes, I have.

Q. Are you familiar with the procedures and the

way the deposition is handled?

A. Well—

Q. I’m going to ask you a number of questions. If

you don’t understand a question, please say so. If you

would like me to rephrase it or try to approach it a differ-

ent way, tell me. Mr. Haushalter might want to inter-

ject an objection on the record, so please allow him an

opportunity to do that before you answer it.

What is your present position with the Division of

Taxation?

22a

(p.97) happened? A. I don’t recall any mention. Often

times in a conversation of that nature, somebody might

refer to some other matter, you know, that might have

been litigated or it might have been a full-blown hearing

on it; or there might have been an agent’s opinion on it

or any number of things. They might refer to another

matter. I don’t have any recollection of anybody raising

another specific case and, you know—

Q. Do you know if the Division has ever published

to the public a statement of the policy referred to in para-

graph nine of your affidavit?

A. Not in specific terms, no. At least I don’t know

of any, okay? I think, inferentialiy, that implies that

policy.

For example, we refer to services performed outside

of New Jersey as a category of exempt gross receipts.

We do this in our instructions for the preparation of the

return. Now, inferentially, I think, you could draw a con-

clusion that we are saying that services which the tax

is imposed upon—we begin with ‘‘When performed in

New Jersey,”—are subject to tax regardless of where the

property on which the services are performed or deliv-

ered. Now, granted, that every citizen might not be able

to draw that inference, but certainly it would be enough

to raise a question in the mind of somebody |p. 98) who

was preparing that return.

Q. Now, if I understand your testimony, you are

saying if someone reviewed the Division’s statements of

policy concerning the taxability, sales taxability of serv-

ices performed outside the State of New Jersey would

23a

draw the conclusion, inferentially, that service performed

in the State cf New Jersey were taxable is that correct?

A. I certainly read it that way or at least there

would be enough of a doubt raised to specifically pursue

the question.

Q. Where would they find those publications con-

cerning the services?

A. They get one in the mail every three months.

Q. Concerning the taxability of services performed

outside the State of New Jersey?

A. I think I testified this morning that that appears

in the instructions for the completion of the sales tax

return.

Q. Are there any—

A. It did then and does now.

Q. Are there any policies to that effect for services

performed outside the State of New J ersey which appear

in any of the news releases or in CCH or Prentice Hall?

(p. 99) <A. Well, I can’t speak to what appears in

CCH and Prentice Hall unless your question is specific.

Q. Would you take the Prentice Hall and if there

are any in there review them quickly and tell me if you

ean if there is a statement of policy concerning the tax-

ability of services performed outside the State of New

Jersey?

A. Let me see if I understand this. You want me

to review this whole section?

Q. No.

24a

MR. KEENAN: Excuse me for one second.

Off the record. \

(Discussion held off the record.)

A. What are you looking for?

Q. Directing your attention to CCH, Volume 1, page

6187-3, I believe in the bottom right-hand side of the page.

Are those the instructions you just referred to in your

testimony?

A. May I see those? Well, this is a later version

of the same thing. The one in CCH is a revision dated

6/70, and the one I have in my hand, the actual instruc-

tions are dated 5/67.

Q. And the instructions which you refer to in your

testimony—

A. Well, to the extent that that item is on the work-

sheet. Services performed out of New Jersey (p. 100) is

in the deductions’ worksheet in both instances.

Q. And what are the instructions you referred to

in which you said the taxpayer could draw the inference

that they were taxable?

A. Well, the simple statement that we have a de-

duction item for service performed out of New Jersey

raises a question in, you know, in my opinion, that any

prudent man would say, ‘‘Wait a minute, the inference of

that is that if I perform taxable services in New Jersey

that the tax applies.”

Q. That would put him on notice that he should check

further into that?

25a

A. In my mind—I am not addressing the question

whether the court will see it that way—what I am saying

is that in my mind someone responsible for a tax affair

of a major corporation would certainly be troubled by that.

@. This document which you produced, the instruc-

tions, the ST-50A form, 5-67 was the one in use in 1967?

A. The ST-50A, yes.

Q. Do you know if that version of the form was pub-

lished in CCH?

A. At that time?

Q. Yes.

A. I donot. I would assume that it was. That docu-

ment was filed in the Secretary of the State’s Office

which is significant in that it gives the force and effect

of a regulation.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.