Opposition Brief — O'Leary v. Mack
Supreme Court brief1997
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No,
t
IN THE
SUPRE MI COURT Of THe UNITED STATE
OcTOBER TERM, 199/
JOHN MACK,
RESPONDENT,
Vv.
MICHEAL O’LEARY, €T AL.,
é PETITIONERS.
JOHN LIPSCOMB-BELY, REPONDENT
V.
HOWARD A. PETERS, fit, 1 AL.,
PETITIONERS.
ON BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO WRIT OF CERTIORARI
'O THE UNITED STATES LOURT OF A PPEALS For THe
_ SEVENTH CIRCUTLT
& BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO WRIT OF CERTIORARI FOR
PLAINTIFF / RESPONDENT JOHN MACK
MR. JOHN MACK
REGISTER No. a-73457
). C.C, P.O. Box 4002
DANVILLE, IL, 618434
Dif
ST ST RL EA TE I I LE A
ANSWERS "TO QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW"
Section: 200Cbb-1 of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (42 U.S.C.
' " :
§ 2000bb-1) provides, rrectiy in part, that “government shali not subdstant
] , ms ‘eT , 1 4 ‘
-laily Durden a er n's exercise r reiigion... ine seventh Circult round
igitimate pressing security reason t verride (im this case) with a pc-
“to force adherents of a religion to refrain from religiously motivated
conduct, inhibits or constrains conduct or expression that manifests a cen-
tral tenet of a person's religious beliefs, or compels conduct or expression
that is contrary to those beliefs."
Answers to the questions presented is:
nr i? fAaet ied ‘ sneer ‘ 1 bees in _
ie ile eve Url LT a | sC Laila L10n 3Uu stantiai surden, which ac
} e
rately interprets the irameters of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act,
nh 7 ‘ re ; * oY ‘ > th er > > 4 « — 44 : r '
whic! y it yery reation, ensures tnat if tnere exist any disturdance, 2
y ‘ 9 } ,?¢ ‘ ~ . . t moavuely inm*f ing _ rr "ow ry . 4 ’
eru id I e parts I tne tates ) uncqcueiy iniringe ipon expressions
tnat manitrtest 3 entrai tenet I 2 persons reiigious oeilers, Ir compeis n
; r , - . . ] ’ "
4 res nat [ | L L e eile 3
, ‘ e e + ‘ ‘
j gO¢ ght tne eart tne ice ti 3 ne J jing ia
. ¢ j
r er tne nst itior;r ,», the quest r 3 t yroperiy re ted
‘ ¥ ? ; ; r + + tf rogt nH ’ m+ © "
e event Jit 2€1L init 1 Oo syuostant ai juTGcel! whi Niiicts
a > aa | rr ?
wit le I uiated y ther irts ippeais
; © t ¥ _
t whetne the event t 1as r eri icerprete: aS a jud
' ‘ ‘ . ‘
; tit cneé iw and iit the t Ls jraited D the eg iative ay
‘4 r ¥ t , _
k ‘ , 4 G JNa i Lari 1s e limp sea Witnin pris , wne
tner r erriding iegit ate securit ncern
ii
PARTIES TO PREOCEEDING
Petitioners:
MICHAEL O'LEARY, Deputy Director, Department of Corrections
Salvador A. Godinez, former Warden of Stateville C. C.
Jerome Springborn, Assistant Warden of Programs
James Schomig, Assistant Warden of Operations
Howard A. Peters, lll, former Director, Department of Corrections
George C. Welborn, former Warden of Menard Correctional Center
Alan L. Frentzel, former Assistant Warden of Menard Correctional
Leo Hayes, Chaplin
Respondents:
John Mack
John Lee Lipscomb Bey
Center
iii
TABLE O F CONTENTS
Page
QUESTIONS PRES ENT BD cocccccccscoscccsscsvessceseccess i
PARTIES TO PROCEEDING S$ asecccccccccecsccccescessses ii
TABLE OF AUTHOR ITLE S evcvescsccccecccesessssesceses iv
OPINIONS BBL OW cecaccccvcccccscccscvcceveseseesosessssses l
JUR LCSD I CTT ON cevcccccccccccccccccccccccscesesccsesesesesesse l
STATUE LBVOL VV ED ccceccccccessccccesocscsossesecesesessecs l
STATEMENT OF THE CASE cosecccveccescccscscccescces 2
Proceedings Relating to Johm Mack ..sceesescecceecesenseesseees 2
Proceedings relating to John Lee Lipscomb Bey —s ..sseeeeseeeccucs 3
Decisions of the Court of AppealS = ..csscccescceeseeeeseeeseeees 4 :
REASONS POR GRANTING THE WRIT cocccccesces 5
i.
THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT'S DEFINITION OF “SUBSTANTIAL BURDEN"
AS A TERM CORRECTLY INTERPRETS THE APPLICATION OF THE TERM
AS IT RELATEs TO THE STATES IMPOSING UNDUE RESTRICTIONS ON
BELIEFS THAT MANIFEST CENTRAL TENET OF A PERSON RELIGIOUS
a BELIEFS, OR COMPELS CONDUCT OR EXPRESSIONS THAT IS CONTRA- q
RY TO THOSE OULINUS. cc ccccccceccovescccccesécoscesocosoves 6
Ll.
THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT WAS CORRECT OF IT'S DEFINITION OF SUB-
STANTIAL BURDEN BEING IMPOSED LNA PRISON SETTING, WITHOUT
THE STATE FIRST PRESENTS NO OVERRIDING LEGITIMATE SECURITY
CONCERN. ccc cccccccccccccccccsccecccccceseseeeeeeseseeeeses 7
CON CL U SL ON cececcccccccccccccccccccccesccesessesessesesseeses 10
AP PE NDI X_ ceeccccccccccccccccccccccccrescesessssssesssssssssssss infra
ee
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Case Page
Allah v. Mene1, 844 F. Supp. 1056 ( E.P.D.A. 1994)..... 8
Benjamin v. Coughlin, 905 F. 2d 571, 575, (2nd Cir. 1990). 8
City Of Boerne, Texas in City Of Boerne v. Flores, No. 95-
2ZOTG c cee cree ces COOH OO TOOS SES OOSS EOE S ES ESESECESESEEOE SELENE 6, 10
Employment Division v. Smith, 494 U.S. 872 (1990)....... 4
Everson v. Board Of Education, 330 U.S. 1,15, 67 S. Ct. 504,-
SIL, DL Le Bd. TIL CIDGT ) cccccccccccccccccccccccceseccccecese 9
Hicks v. Garner, 69 F. 3d. 22, 26, (Sth Cir. 1995).-.....-. 7
Mack v. O'Leary, 80 F. 3d. 1175, (7th Cir. 1996).........-. l
Small v. Lehman, 98 F. 3d. 762, 767 (3rd Cir. 1996)....... ]
Sullivan v. Sasmett, NO. 96-710, -cccccccccccccescesseceses 6
Wallace v. Jaffree, 472 U.S. 38, 53, 105 S. Ct. 2479, ---
2488, 86 L. Ed. 2d (1985)... cc cccccccesccccvesescesesescesess 9
Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205, 218 €1972)..-ccccccccces
Statutes
42 U.S.C. 2000bb-1
28 U.S.C. 1254(1)
1983
§
§
42 U.S.C. § § 2000bb-2000bb-4
42 U.S.C. §
§
42 U.S.C.
2000bb.
whan
OPINIONS BELOW
The judgement and opinion of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit of which petitioners seek review is reported
at 80 F. 3d 1175 (7th Cir. 1996) and is not in reprint (respondent is
a pauper). The order of the Court of Appeals upon the petitioners’ Pe-
tition for Rehearing, With Suggestions for Rehearing En Banc was de-
nied, and is not reprinted for the abcve stated reason.
The opinion of the District Court for the Northern District of
Illinois in Mack v. O'Leary is unreported and is in reprint in the ap-
pendix at 2-13. The opinion of the District court for the Southern -
District of Illinois in Lipscomb Bey v Peters is unreported and in not
in reprint (this case was consolidated with respondent Mack and issues
are fundamentally different).
JURISDICTION OF THIS COURT
The judgement of the United States Court of Appeals for the Se-
venth Circuit of which petitioners seek review was entered on April 3,
1996. Petitioners filed a timely petition for rehearing, with suggest-
ions for rehearing en bamc was filed with that court on May 8, 1996, u
-pon an extension of time granted by the court. The court denied the
petition for rehearing on January 8, 1997. The jurisdiction of this
Court is invoked by petitioners pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1254(1). Note:
All of the judges on the original panel voted to deny the petition and
none of the active judges has requested a vote on the suggestion for
& rehearing en banc.
2. aw ee ie eek Oe ee oe fe
The text of the RELIGIOUS FREEDOM RESTORATION ACT (42 U.S.C. §§
2000bb-2000bb-4) is reprinted in the appendix at 19-21.
PROCEEDINGS RELATING TO JOHN MACK
Your Respondend John Mack, a citizen of the United States of America
and, the State of Illinois, is a practitioner of the Islamic Faith (a de-
vout muslim), an inmate within the [Illinois Department of Corrections; and,
resident of the Danville Correction Center. Appearing pro se filed a pro se
complaint against various officials within the IDOC February of 1994, pur-
suant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for alleged deprivations of basic rights guran——
teed and afforded respondent under the lst and 14th amends. to the United
States of America's Constitution; as well as being subjected to Cruel and
ee Unusual Punishment as a result thereof. As well in violation of the Reli-
gious Freedom Restoration Act ("RFRA"), RELATING TO THE Ramadan services -
held at the Stateville Correctional Center in 1992 and 1993. Respondent in
addition claimed that particularly muslim above and beyond other faiths at
Stateville were discriminated against; and forced to gather in a clearly un
-santized and filthy environment (dinning hall) directly after the general
population finshed eating. Respondent further alleged that muslims were pre
-vented from engaging in the obligatory form of wudu, which is a prerequi—
site before believers offer their prayers and declare their intention to -
fast for the next hourly period to fast. Also the obligatory manner of con-
“ gregational prayer amongs the believers were prohihibited due to the tables
and garbage cans scattered over the recently departed feeding hall.
mproperly entered judgement
i
On january 10, 1995, the district court
for the defendants and dismissed respondent's claim with prejudice. The de-
termination of the court was based off of it’s finding that respondent had
railed to state a claim upon relief could be granted, even assuming the ——
truth of respondent's allegations. The court erred in it's conclusion that
the claims against defendants in their individual capacities did not vio-
late respondent's federal rights. The court also rule that respondent's al-
leged claims against defendants in their official capacities were outside -
the scope of § 1983 and barred by the Eleventh Amentment. Additional, the
court concluded that the RFRA was not implicated because respondent fai
to establish that the defendants substantially burdened the exercise of his
beliefs.
=o
The district court erroneously concluded that defendants made a
reasonable effort to provide respondent with the opportunity to prac
tice his faith during the months of Ramadan in 1992 and 1993. The mis-
understood the essential element and order for which respondent or mus
-~lim in general must purify themselves after eating and before the of-
fering of prayer. The court determine that respondent had an opportuni
“ty to pray in the cafeteria, notwithstandind the unsanitaze condition
and the unability tu congregate in accordence with tenets to the re-
spondent's faith due to the physical impediments of the cafeteria it-
self.
Mack filed a timely notice of Appeal.
PROCEEDING RELATING TO JOHN LEE LIPSCOMB BEY
Respondent John Lee Lipscomb Bey, a member of the Moorish -——
Science Temple of America ("MSTA") and an inmate of the IDOC, appear—
ing pro se, filed a complaint against various officials of the IDOC in
January 1992, pursuant to 42 § 1983 for deprivations of his right gu-
ranteed by the Ist and i4th amends. relating to the refusal to permit
a MSTA religious banquet on prison grounds with outside guests in at-
tendance.
A magistrate judge presided over a bench trial on July 22, 1993.
Lipscomb Bey represented himself. On July 27, 1993, the ma .strate ——
judge recommended that judgement be entered in favor of the defendants,
concluding that the failure of the prison officials to allow the ban-
quet did not rise to the level of a constitutional violation. On March
ll, 1994 the district court adopted the magistrate findings and conclu-
sions and entered judgement in favor of the defendants.
John Lee Lipscomb Bey filed a timely notice of appeal.
DECISION OF THE COURT 0 F APPEALS
: ns ps . : '
,
The Seventh Circuit upon it’s own druthers discharged an order which
Ww
consolidated the pro se appellate cases of John Mack and John Lee Lipscomb-
Bey on or about December 3, 1996. The court determined that both cases in-
volved "for the first time the meaning of the term ‘substantially burden
a person's exercise of religion,’ which is the key term in the Religious
Freedom Restoration Act of 1993, 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb."
The crux of the court's ruling was that the RFRA corrected and/or re
-stored limitations imposed on the free exercise of religion; via such case
as Employment Division v. Smith, 494 U.S. 872 (1990). Although the court -
beyond” (did the RFRA extend beyond -
went on to ask the question “how far
ra the Smith Supra) noting that the question was posed and answered different-
ly by the different circuits
The Fourth, Ninth, and Eleventh Circuits define "substantial burden"
is that which either compels the religious adherent to engage in conduct -
that his religion forbids or forbids him to engage in conduct that his re-
ligion requires. While the Eighth and Tenth Circuits aggreed, but went far-
ther by defining to be action that forces religious adherents to refrain
from religious] iotivated iduct or that significant] inhibit r n-
sCrain conduct r expression that manifest me entrali tenet [ i er-
son’ s individual beliefs imposes a substantial burden on the exercise of ,
B -~ligion. While the Sixt rcuit alternative in njunct yetween bot -
similar view; once it determines that the burdened practice is “essential”
fr LA
Tr indamental
The irt iW | eee. C Lt i I ae c € A it irt 1e-
termining that Che Ling were 4 @ i that an est ctl indue
mposed upon adherents, r é inism whi indus pe in adnerent c
InNWwiilsing vage in icts I Ssion whnicn > in it @e wit! ianere C
~' > pe ilietl t e i sUD fantali juracen
Ait » tne irt te iat lé Ct Cre ear ta tor inguag |
»' * nal a . ’ ’ ; > , _ . rou ' ¥
L ice, 1é IT t lete Lhned t at le Lrcu Tt ea Ore t u
effect of the definition of “substantial burden”
The court ultimately determined that Respondent had made actiona-
ble claim, based on the “sustantial burden" term and remanded said cause
for further proceedings. In the same decision the court dismissed the re
~spondent claim for damages against defendants in their official capaci-
ty (which respondent is not challenging), while infering that respondent
may have an actionable claim against defendants in their individual ca-
pacitiy; if ic is determined that said restrictions imposed on plaintiff
as an Islamic adherent, were central to the tenets of respondent's faith
and obligatory to respondent's fundamental belief.
However, the court reached a different determination on the merit
of Respondent John Lee Lipscomp Bey's claim of “substantial burden". Re-
spondent John Lee Lipscomb Bey sougnt to be allowed to have banquets in-
conjunction with certain legitimate Moorish Holy Days. This included the
attempt Co have outside guest appear for said desinated Holy Day events.
[he court affirmed the dismissal of John Lee Lipscomb Bey's case.
It determined that the restrictions imposed were of a term to be defined
as a "modest burden", because the defendants were able to establish both
'
‘a compelling governmental interest in imposing the 'modest burden' and
the absence of any less restrictive alternative.
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
The petitioners plea is constructed in their stance that the RFRA
is interpreted definition of RFRA is so divergent amongs the various -
Vircults, in re .uw«dsS to the correct application of the Statutory lan-
guage of Che statue. Including a proportionate number of prison cases in
-“vOlved in the application of the statue.
Thus, petitioners “definition” of the Circuits court unmonolithic
divergent views of the statue; and, the fact that many prisons admini-——
Strators must daily promulgate rules inconjunction with the law, the set
y | 8 }
~tling of the issue is of parawount of importance
The petitioners main concern addressed as the total underlying
thought is due to the cases of City of Boerne, Texas in City of Boerne
v. Flores, No. 95-2074 and Sullivan v. Sasmett, No. 96-710, now pend
ing before this court. These cases seek to challenge the constitution-
ality of the RFRA. Without directly asking to have this cause stayed
until the complete adjudication on the constitutionality of RFRA, pe
titioners request to have this writ of certiorari be considered in
light of any decision of this court affecting/effecting aforesaid.
I.
THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT'S DEFINITION OF “SUBSTANTIAL BURDEN“ ‘AS A TERM COR
-~RECTLY INTERPRETS THE APPLICATION OF THE TERM AS IT RELATES TO THE
STATES IMPOSING UNDUE RESTRICTIONS ON BELIEFS THAT MANIFEST A’ CENTRAL
TENET OF A PERSON RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, OR COMPELS CONDUCT OR EXPRESSIONS
THAT IS CONTRARY TO THOSE BELIEFS TEEUTUTEETLEPT ELECT
[The Religious Freedom Restoration Act ("RFRA") was created to
ensure that the powers of government shall not substantially burden a
person's free exercise of religion; unless the government can reasona-
blly demonstrate that the application of the burden is for the furth-
erance of the compelling governmental interest and in the least re-
strictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.
[The Seventh Circuit in essence and substance iggreed with the
decisions of other Circuits courts ruling appropos RFRA. While the Se-
venth Circuit voiced it's dec ision and interpretation to entail that:
" . ; } “A \ + 14 hy
i SuDSCanCial urden on Che [ree exercise Of reiigion, within the
meaning of the Act, is one that forces adherents of a religion cto re
[rain from rellgilousiy motivated conduct, inhibits or constrains con-
4 : ‘ '
auct ir expression that manifests a central tenet I i person s reli
gious beliefs, or compels conduct or expression that 18 contrary Ci
Hicks v. Garner, 69 F.3d 22, 26 (Sth Cir. 19
55) and mmaaii yv Lehman » 96 F.3d 7/6; /6/ (3rd Cir. i996)
. { , . -
‘
é é
‘ ‘ ,
ss . - aa . : st : .
jae ; , ft c i : ial € irt ' re ¢ Che Smith :
€ AUS¢ is : : | aia | 2a¢ ; > at ci s 5
‘ , —T . , . ¢ . Se
i : il ; é aa 5Sé LCiadi ie é ‘ 3 es ai . >
e* t ‘ rR
a : a4 . ‘ 5 ‘ ; Ni i. ‘ ‘ : ic ~
| 2 . 3 . a4 cacwu i 4¢ >¢ is + > 4 ; 4
i irt iia ractice ~ 4as C essentia Che scone ent i
'
" j t «2 [ > i e ianer;re Lait . ie juest €
. : ,
i = : ~~ Ga : sc c cs [
1oOweVve I j review the iower irt il leCer ine tnat tne
; ezed esi ed ‘ e 1 tne for ins i tne adnerenct If T 4
. ‘ . Jas . ; ; .
ing i ; a1 and ec Llgactor act, tne ircgen is tne n le
4% . . 4 ‘ " } + ae | 7 ; . nt rq Wy
aanerent s4€Cetmine the imposition is Lt a 3uU anciai JurTden ry
‘ : at s eli : bh Hie uC ‘ ta ‘ it
é n tc ft ece < [rT the 1 ea . i i irden” I i
i Zz int - ind tfhie east cI t é eans eing emp j
Che ‘ enc; iste I é i na rtunity che pectiti el
ij ivé é é tea t é j [ . pel tne est ndent ind Chie
e eve Were I ed t ‘pa iké j imadan” absent € » ii wed c
perform Ligatory acts of Wudu and Salat i i splritual prescribed
THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT'S DEFINITION OF “SUBSTANTIAL BURDEN" AS A TERM COR
RECTLY INTERPRETS THE APPLICATION OF THE TERM AS IT RELATES TO THE
STATES IMPOSING UNDUE RESTRICTIONS ON BELIEFS THAT MANIFEST A CENTRAL
& TENET OF A PERSON'S RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, OR COMPELS CONDUCT OR EXPRESSION
(S) THAT IS CONTKARY TO THOSE BELIEFS ....... eee
eeeeeeeceeee eeeeceesees
ce eve 1 W I Ane et ined tnat [ ers
ea é é é é le i le iDiii€ es lé
ra x i e ¢ ‘ t et en i an adherenc;
ne irt seCermined afte jue l feviewing Che available re rd, that
ried y ee 4 ‘ ¥ iA4 e} ; ie ‘. ,
POL Ata Metis aSSCi Li ii ‘ ws VY ANULIILE ~ ic tL cCayv ndent wWitil cast 2Vicl |
; sd ‘ ‘ ; idir¢ ;
j », whe La e [ ] t ta t I j ndent
Was 5§ ected wa if east c eo oer t iitel it ve i Ladle
ine Kes ident eciared that e sit i iaced ‘ re 3]
@ lent ing si aT 1anerencts [i the i ra lj; Were a t ind é ]
r r r > ; " ; he >]
Che reasonadie accomadations afforded the il is Cner Celigzgious faith
$s). Ben jamin v. Coughlin, 77> we a
a
-
~™
J
w
~
Ww
2nd Cir. 1990); Allah v.
Menei, 844 F. Supp. 1056 (E.P.D.A. 1994).
ihis unequal protection under the law is the primary reason that
eated the "substantial rde r ior have the eticione isserted an
mpeiiing interest ¢t 1OC afford Kespondent the POSSi1D1iiCy ¢t pract
ice the essentiai elements of the Respondent's faltn; certified as in
maitenable right and mandated by the Cenets i the Respondent's raitn.
The month of Ramadan Deing Che sacred month for all Muslims over
the worid, clearly the prescribed methods of Worship, were piaced to -
Drin. all the adherents together as one Umma (Islamic Body) in accord—
ance with the overall command and decree of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
LE aE TNL TE TT EE TE TT Te
and the obligatory submission on the part of the adherants to the commands
and decrees fostered by the sacred tenets of Islam. Wallace v. jaffree,
472 U.S. 38, 53, 105 S. Ct. 2479, 2488, 86 L. Ed. 2d (1985)(citing Ever-
son v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1,15,67 S.Ct. 504, 511, 91 L. Ed. 711
(1947).
Subsequently the RFRA was created and enacted by Congress to ensure
that any restrictions imposed by the government on adherents to reconize
religious faiths, a compelling interest of the States had to be demonstrat
-ed and for an alternative a less restrictive means had to be substituted.
The manner that muslims pray together, are in ranks of rows, consol
~idating the believers together as one, their prayer offering to their One
& God-ALLAH. But prior to said prayer be performed. all believers are compel
-~led to porform the act of wudu, a form of purification means, right be-
fore the prayer offering. To force adherents to do differently, when less
restrictive means were available (different facilities which were afforded
other adherents of ther faiths) is incompatible and at odds with the fund-
amental tenets of Muslims’ beliefs. Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205, 218
(1972). Creating an unneccessary burden on religion; unfairly characteriz-
ed by petitioners (non-muslims) as a "mere inconvenience".
This attitude buttressed by petitioners deliberate inertia, is the
very thing Congress had in mind when RFRA was enacted and the very idea of
excluding the prison setting from the applicability of RFRA was rejected -
resoundly by the Congress in the first place.
In essence the petitioners are requesting of the court, to hence-
forth disallow the prisoners from engaging in legitimate forms of worship,
when clearly there is no compelling governmental interest to impose re-
strictions. By glossing over the illussions of the opening of “pandora's -
door" and all forms for superflous inartful forms of demands of worship u-
pon the State by prisoners bent on folly; clearly devalues the intent of
the law and undermines the ligitimate role religion plays in the rehabila-
tative process amongs serious minded adherents to legitimate “reconized" -
religious Orders.
Religion is Law, and Law is Government. Without the one the others
cannot exist. And it was never questioned in this instance was Respondent-
a member of a ligitimate religious order. So why the limitations?
WHEREFORE, yout espondent respectfully urge the Honorabie istice
to isider careful! the respondents reply argument, and determine tnat
tn } iuseé mst é etu eda ¢t et € l ; é cé t
to war it the “substantial burden posed t es ent a
-nherenct ¢ the 11th ie . é t . i f t
~it I a writ I ‘ t rari; i . { ta tn iu b
Boerne v. Flores, No. 95-2074, the answer ¢t ‘
come I City of
in this matter i fundamentally setforth different
Respect J | acm t ted,
he Jk
Life f EE
ade
COUNS EL
OF
RECORD
oh
Se Reg.
No.
A-734 si
or. Ff: 2 Bete
App. Il
IN THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
NO. 95 - 1331
John Mack,
Plaintiff-—-Appellant,
-Vs-
Micheal O'Leary, et al.,
Defendaats-—Appellees
APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT
COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT
OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION
Honorable Charles R. Norgle Senior Presiding
BRIEF AND REQUIRED SHORT APPENDIX OF PLAINTIFF
APPELLANT JOHN MACK
Mr. John Mack
Register No. A-73457
€.€.€. P.O. BOE V7a3
Centralia, Il. 62801
EDITOR'S NOTE
THE FOLLOWING PAGES WERE POOR HARD COPY
i
AT THE TIME OF FILMING. IF AND WHEN A
BETTER COPY CAN BE OBTALNED, A NEW FICHE
WILL BE ISSUED.
App.
‘Ty
a)
ha
b+ iu mw U
App. 4
Minute Order Form (rev. 12/90)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
Name of Assigned Judge Sitting Judge if Otner |
CHARLES R. NORGLE Sulla Acekanad aide
r Magistrate Judge
~
Case Number 94 C 621 Date
January 9, 1995
Case JOHN MACK v. MICHAEL O’LEARY, Deputy Director, SALVADOR
Title GODINEZ, Warden, J. SPRINGBORN, J. SCHOMIG, Asst. Wardens
[in the following Box (a) indicate the party filing the motion. eg plaintiff, defendant, Ird-party plaintlf
MOTION: and (b) state briefly the nature of the motion being sresenied |
DOCKET ENTRY:
ed motion of [use listing in “MOTION” bon above}
i
Orner docket ent
0) |* |
are dismissed as moot (specifically doc. #36).
5) | Brief in support of motion due
<) | -
=
| } -
. j | Answer Drief to Motion due Repiy {0 answer Drief Gue
ai i
|
r ic 1
| i | ia na
(4) | ee ° on et to a Sree A j
i | | Hear ng — |
“a ~——- -_— -_-—-. i
|
| - P :
S} | Status Nearing | | heid | Nued to | | set for | fa-set for 3
‘al
’ a ee |
} ' i '
(6) | Pretrial cont neid | continued to | lsert | « set at
\~/ |
| f f
| . j Set tor | e-se at
>) P a
/) | s 2 iniceia |
|
eras oT : : ‘See
(8) | Bench al y a | |ea | nheid and nued a
| } i sags, Zz
- ! i i
(9) | his case is dismissed | Lwithout | lwith prejudice and without costs | | Dy agreement | oursuan
/ '
|
wa f j | |
—_— FACP 4(;) (fariure to serve | Seneral 2ule 2' (want of oresecution 1FACP atiaiit | | FACP sta
a
Defendants’ motion to dismiss (doc. #22) is granted. The complaint
is dismissed with prejudice and the case is closed. ll pending motions
h; /,
/
f ] —
(11) [For further deiail see | i e nA ire traverse of Pal Jer attacned to tne original minute order form
i
No notices required advised in open court | | number ot
>—-—_-----= '
| notices
NS notices required |
} ‘
Notices marlied by judge's staff jate Document #
ldocketed
counsel Sy telepnone |
Cocketing to mail sotices Gocketing
i doty imitiais
- | Mari AO 450 form —
date majled
lc Dy [0 judge/magistrate Judge
notice
courtroom
testime & in
deputy's Oatert: rd eceived mailing
Initials central Clerk's Office doty initrals
App. 5
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILL
EASTERN DIVISION
JOHN MACK, )
Plaintiff,
No. 94 C 621
Vv.
HONORABLE CHARLES R. NORGLE
MICHAEL O’LEARY, Deputy Director,
SALVADOR GODINEZ, Warden,
J. SPRINGBORN, Assistant Warden,
and J. SCHOMIG, Assistant Warden,
Defendants.
eee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee
OPINION AND ORDER
CHARLES R. NORGLE, SR., District Judge:
Before the court is the motion of defendants Michael O’Leary,
Salvador Godinez, James M. Schomig, and Jerome Springborn
("defendants") to dismiss the complaint pursuant to Federal Rule of
Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) for failing to state a cause of action.
For the following reasons, the motion is granted and the complaint
is dismissed with prejudice.
FACTS'
Plaintiff John Mack ("Mack") is a convicted felon currently
serving his sentence at Centralia Correctional Center in Centralia,
Illinois. During the period relevant to this litigation, Mack was
, The following facts are drawn from the complaint filed on
January 31, 1994, and a pleading filed in response to defendants’
motion to dismiss.
incarcerated at Stateville Correctional enter ("Stateville”™)
According to Mack’s allegations defendants deprived him of his
right to freely exercise the Isla faith The complaint alleges
that in 1992 and 1993, defendants refused to allow Mack to worship
and pray in the manner prescribed by the Muslim Communit standard
during the Fast of Pamadan.
More specifically, Mack complains that during the relevant
periods, he was forced to pray to Allah ina cafeteria where there
was no facility or running water to purify his body, a cafeteria
that was unclean and unsuitable for a religious observance, 4a
cafeteria that was equipped with bolted tables which hindered Macx
from taking the se body formation required to pray to Allan, and
was forced to pray facing the guard tower. The prison officiais at
Stateville allowed Mack to purify himself only with the water
available in his cell before being taken to the cafeteria. Mack
was then allowed to consume his meal and to hold his prayer meeting
at the conclusion of the meal.
DISCUSSION
On a motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 12(b) (6), all well-pleaded factual allegations are
presumed to be true. Land v. Chicago Truck Drivers, 25 F.jd 509%
Sik {7a Cae. 1994) rhe ourt must view those allegations in the
light most favorable to the plaintiff, Gould v. Artisoft, Inc., 1
App. 7
F.3d 544, 546 (7th Cir. 1993), and accept all reasonable inferences
to be drawn from those allegations as true. Meriwether v.
Faulkner, 821 F.2d 408, 410 (7th Cir.), cert. denied, 484 U.S. 935
(1987). Furthermore, pro se complaints are to be liberally
construed, and pro se civil rights complaints may be dismissed only
"if it is beyond doubt that there is no set of facts under which
~*
the plaintiff could obtain relief." Wilson v. Civil Town of
Clayton, Ind., 839 F.2d 375, 378 (7th Cir. 1988). The complaint
must, however, state allegations, either directly or inferentially,
to establish the necessary elements for recovery under the chosen
legal theory. Glatt v. Chicago Park Dist., 847 F. Supp. 101, 103
(N.D. Ill. 1994).
In the instant action, Mack seeks to recover monetary damages
from defendants in their individual capacities as well as in their
official capacities as officials with the Illinois Department of
Corrections ("“IDOC"). Mack claims he is entitled to monetary
damages because defendants violated his right to freely exercise
his religion as guaranteed by the First.and Fourteenth Amendmert.
In contrast, defendants contend that even if all of Mack’s
allegations are true, they fail to state a § 1983 cause of action.
The court agrees.
The claim of constitutional violation against defendants in
their official capacities is insufficient as a matter of law and
must be dismissed pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure
App. 8
12(b) (6) with prejudice. A suit against a state official in his or
her official capacities is treated as a suit against the State.
Hafer v. Melo, 502 U.S. 21, 112 S. Ct. 358, 361 (1991); Frances J.
vw. Meiah®, 19 F.36 337, 342 {7th €Cir.}; cere. dented, 118 8. Ce.
204 (1994). While a local governmental entity may be subject to
biability under § 1983 because it is considered a "person" within
the meaning of that provision, Baxter by Baxter v. Vigo County
Schoo] Corp., 26 F.3d 728, 734 (7th Cir. 1994), a State is not a
"person" subject to § 1983. Will v. Michigan Dept. of State
Police, 491 U.S. S58, 109 S. Ct. 2304, 2312 (1989). In this case,
defendants are Illinois officials; thus, Mack’s claim against them
in their official capacities as IDOC officials, are outside the
scope of § 1983.
Furthermore, Mack’s claim against defendants in their official
capacities is barred under the Eleventh Amendment. Garcia v. City
of Chicago, Ill., 24 F.3d 966, 969 (7th Cir. 1994). "The Eleventh
;
Amendment prohibits federal courts from deciding suits brought by
private litigants against states or their agencies, and that
prohibition extends to state officials acting in their official
capacities." Id. This general rule is not without an exception.
Leal
See Ex parte Young, 209 U.S. 123, 28 S. Ct. 441 (1908). The
doctrine of Ex parte Young, however, is a narrow exception which
the United States Supreme Court has declined to provide expansive
effect. See Puerto Rico Aqueduct & Sewer Auth. v. Metcalf & Eddy,
App. 9
—
Inc., 113 S. Ct. 684, 688 (1993); Pennhurst State Sch. & Hosp. v.
Halderman, 465 U.S. 89, 104 S. Ct. 900, 909 (1984); Edelman v.
Jordan, 415 U.S. 651, 94 S. Ct. 1347, 1357-58 (1974). The
exception only applies to “prospective relief, does not permit
judgments against state officers declaring that they violated
federal law in the past and has no application in suits against the
States and their agencies, which are barred regardless of the
relief sought." Puerto Rico Aqueduct, 113 S. Ct. at 688 (citation
omitted). In the instant matter, Mack complains of defendants’
conduct in 1992 and 1993 and requests monetary relief.
Accordingly, the general rule bars the claim against defendants in
their official capacities.
State officials sued in their individual capacities are,
however, “persons™ for purposes of § 1983 and may be subject to
liability. Hafer, 112 S. Ct. at 360. Nonetheless, Mack’s claim
against defendants in their individual capacities does not fare any
better. To state a cause of action under § 1983 against defendants
in their individual capacities, Mack must establish two elements:
(1) that defendants were acting under color of state law; and (2)
that their conduct deprived plaintiff of his federal rights.
Parratt v. Taylor, 451 U.S. 527, 101 S. Ct. 1908, 1912-13 (1981);
Procopio v. Johnson, 994 F.2d 325, 328 (7th Cir. 1993); Letisha A.
by Murphy v. Morgan, 855 F. Supp. 943, 947 (N.D. Ill. 1994).
Defendants do not challenge the sufficiency of the complaint as it
App. 10
relates to the first element. They do, however, contend that Mack
fails to establish the second element in his complaint.
It is well established that prison inmates retain the right to
freely exercise their religious beliefs under the Free Exercise
Clause of the First Amendment. Alston v. DeBruyn, 13 F.3d 1036,
1039 (7th Cir. 1994). The right of a lawfully incarcerated
individual under the Free Exercise Clause, however, is not as
expansive as the right of a non-incarcerated individual. O’Lone v.
Estate of Shabazz, 107 S. Ct. 2400, 2404 (1987); Richards v. White,
957 F.2d 471, 474 (7th Cir. 1992). With lawful incarceration, many
privileges and rights, including the right to exercise religion,
are restricted and limited. Id. (citing Price v. Johnston, 334
U.S. 266, 68 S. Ct. 1049, 1060 (1948)). Prison officials are
required to make only a reasonable effort to provide the inmates an
opportunity to practice their religion. Alston, 13 F.3d at 1039.
"The limitations on the exercise of constitutional rights arise
both from the fact of incarceration and from valid penological
objectives--including deterrence of crime, rehabilitation of
prisoners, and institutional security." O’Lone, 107 S. Ct. at
2404.
The court recognizes that Congress enacted the Religious
Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 ("Act"), 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb, et
seg., “to restore the compelling interest test as set forth in
(Sherbert v. Verner,] 374 U.S. 398 (1963) and (Wisconsin v. Yoder, ]
App. ll
406 U.S. 205 (1972) and to guarantee its application in all cases
where free exercise of religion is substantially burdened... ."™
42 U.S.C. § 2000bb(b). The Act provides a statutory claim or
defense to those individuals whose religious freedom is
"substantially burdened" by a governmental entity. Means _v.
Wortham, 115 S. Ct. 460, 460 n.1 (1994) (mem.). The Act, however,
has no application in this case because the complaint fails to
establish that defendants “substantially burdened" Mack’s exercise
of his belief. See Brown-El v. Harris, 26 F.3d 68, 69 (8th Cir.
1994).
The allegations in this case demonstrate that, while Mack was
incarcerated in Stateville, defendants made a reasonable effort to
provide him an opportunity to practice his faith during the month
of Ramadan in 1992 and 1993. Defendants gave Mack the opportunity
to purify his body before being escorted to the cafeteria and
permitted to worship and pray with other followers in the
cafeteria. While the allegations establish that worshipers were
unable to do certain things during prayer, the allegations do iot
rise to the level of "substantial burden." The alleged
restrictions imposed by the physical limitations of the facility
may interfere with the desired method of prayer, but the
restrictions do not trespass upon Mack’s ability to retain and
worship the principle that is central to Islam. See Vernon v. City
of Los Angeles, 27 F.3d 1385, 1393 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 115 S.
App. 12
Ct. 510 (1994). Thus, Mack fails to satisfy the second element
necessary to state a § 1983 claim against defendants in their
individual capacities.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the motion of defendants to dismiss
the complaint is granted and the complaint dismissed with
prejudice.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
/ / CHARLES RONALD NORGLE, SRY, Judge
—_— United States Dist
DATED: Bs
XXDecision by Court. This action came to trial or hearing before the Court
ot
AO 450 (Rev. 5/85) Judgment in a Civil Case ©
United States District Court
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
Eastern Division
JOHN MACK
JUDGMENT IN A CIVIL CASE
CASE NUMBER: 94 C 621
© Jury Verdict. This action came before the Court fora trial by jury. The issues have been tried anc the jury
has rendered its verdict.
The issues Nave been tried or
heard and a decision has been rendered
IT 1S QROERED AND ADJUDGED that the motion of defendants to dismiss the
complaint is granted and the complaint is dismissed with prejucice.
January 9, 1995 , vinnonis
: H. STUART CUNNINGHAM
Date Clerk
«
(8y) Deputy Clerk us sovennaient PRINTING OFFICE |985—806~007
14
App.
Gnited States Court of Appeals
For the Seventh Circuit
Chicago, Illinois 60604
JUDGMENT- WITHOUT ORAL ARGUMENT
Date: April 3, 1996
BEFORE: Honorable RICHARD A. POSNER, Chief Judge
Honorable DANIEL A. MANIO
o
Honorable MICHAEL S. KANNE,
No. 94-1849
JOHN L. LIPSCOMB-BEY,
é Plaintiff - Appellant,
v.
HOWARD A. PETERS, III, GEORGE C. WELBORN, Warden Menard
Correctional Center, ALAN L. FRENTZEL, Assistant Warden of
Menard Correctional Center, et al.,
Defendants - Appellees
No. 95-1331
{HN acx,
Plaintiff - Appellant,
y.
MICHAEL O’ LEARY, et al.,
Defendants - Appellees.
Appeals from the United States District Court for the
Southern District of Illinois, East St. Louis Division
No. 92 C 55, William D. Stiehl, Judge (94-1849)
No. 94 C 621, Charles R. Norgle, Sr. Judge (95-1331)
The judgment of the district court in appeal No. 95-1331 is AFFIRMED
in part (the part based on the Eleventh Amendment), but is otherwise
REVERSED and REMANDED for further proceedings. Appeal No. 94-1849 is
AFFIRMED. The above is in accordance with the decision of this court
entered on this date.
1060-110393)
Gnited States
ror
By the Court:
JO L. LIPSCOMB-BEY,
Plaintiff-Appellant,
-18419
HOWARD A. PETERS, III, GEORGE C.
WELBORN, Warden Menard Correctional
Center, ALAN L. FRENTZEL, Assistant
Warden of Menard Correctional
Center, et al.,
Defendants-Appellees.
JOHN MACK,
Plaintiff-Appellant,
nm
MICHAEL F. O'LEARY,
SALVADOR A. GODINEZ, Warden,
ne
L. SPRINGBORN, Assistant Warden,
3 oe
Defendants-Appellees.
Deputy Director,
t of Appeals
a ee |
Comnd tut &
Appeal from the United
States District Court for
the Southern District of
tiiinocis, Sast St. Louis
Division.
DO. Fa Ge wo
William D. Stiehl,
Judge
No. 92 C 55
William D. Stiehl,
Judge.
Appeal from the United
States District Court for
the Northern District of
Illinois, Eastern
Division.
No 94 C 621
oe ee = -_ a - 7
VNari®S R. NOKQLIS,
Judge.
(OVER )
IT IS ORDERED that ¢t
App- 17
United States Court of Appeals
For the Seventh Circuit
Chicago, Illinois 60604
January 8, 1997
Before
Hon. Richard A. Posner, Chief Judge
Hon. Daniei A. Manion, Circuit Judge
Hon. Michael S. Kanne, Circuit Judge
JOHN MACK, } Appeal from the United States
Plaintiff-Appellant, } District Court for the
} Northern District of Illinois,
No. 95-1331 v. } Eastern Division.
} No. 94C 621
MICHAEL O’LEARY, et al., } Charles R. Norgle, Sr., Judge.
}
Defendants-Appellees.
JOHN LEE LIPSCOMB-BEY, Appeal from the United States
Plaintiff-Appellant, District Court for the
Southern District of Illinois.
No. 94-1849 v. Nos. 92 C 31, 92 C 55
William D. Stiehl, Judge.
HOWARD A. PETERS III, et ai.,
Defendants-Appeilees.
Net et et et et ee te
ORDER
Defendants-appellees filed a petition for rehearing, and a supplement thereto, with
suggestion for rehearing en banc. All the judges on the original panel have voted to
deny the petition, and none of the active judges has requested a vote on the suggestion
for rehearing en banc. The petition is therefore DENIED.
App. 18
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
WASHINGTON, DC 20543-0001
WILLIAM K. SUTER AREA CODE 202
CLERK OF THE COURT 479-3011
June 3, 1997
John Mack, #A-73457
Danville Correctional Center
RR. #5; Rt. 136
P.O. Box 4001
Danville, IL 61834
Re: 96-1598 — O’Leary, Michael, et al.
v. John Mack, et al.
Dear Mr. Mack:
On April 9, 1997, a petition for a writ of certioran in the above case was
filed in this Court to review an order of the United States Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit (No. 95-133 1/9), dated Apni 3, 1996. Our records indicate that you were
served with a copy of the petition.
The Court has directed this office to request that a response be filed in this
case: Forty printed copies of your response, together with proof of service thereof,
should be filed on or before July 3, 1997.
Your attention is directed to the provisions of Rule 33 of the rules of this
Court. Please note that the color of the cover of your brief should be orange.
Sincerely,
Wk. hott
William K. Suter
Clerk
Cc: John Lipscomb-Bey
Rita M. Novak, Esquire
App. 19
CHAPTER 21B.
RELIGIOUS FREEDOM RESTORATION
§ 2000bb. Congressional findings and
declaration of purposes
(a) Findings. The Congress finds that—
(b)
(1) the framers of the Constitution, recognizing free
exercise of religion as an unalienable right, secured
its protection in the First Amendment to the Consti-
tution;
(2) laws “neutral” toward religion may burden reli-
gious exercise as surely as laws intended to interfere
with religious exercise;
(3) governments should not substantially burden re-
ligious exercise without compelling justification;
(4) in ang bmg Division v. Smith, 494 U.S. 872
(1990) the Supreme Court virtually eliminated the re-
quirement that the government justify burdens on
religious exercise imposed by laws neutral toward
religion; and
(5) the compelling interest test as set forth in prior
Federal court rulings is a workable test for striking
sensible balances between religious liberty and com-
peting prior governmental interests.
Purposes. The purposes of this Act are—
(1) to restore the co ing interest test as set
forth in Sherbert v. Verner, 374 U.S. 398 (1963) and
Wisconsin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) and to guar-
antee its application in all cases where free exercise
of religion is substantially burdened; and
(2) to provide a claim or defense to persons whose
religious exercise is substantially burdened by govern-
ment.
App. 20
§ 2000bb-1. Free exercise of religion protected
(a) In general. Government shall not substantially bur-
den a person’s exercise of religion even if the burden
results from a rule of general applicability, except as pro-
vided in subsection (b).
Meise (b) Exception. Government may substantially burden a
oro te person’s exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that
application of the burden to the person—
(1) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental
interest; and
End (2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that
compelling governmental interest.
(c) Judicial relief. A person whose religious exercise
has been burdened in violation of this section may assert
that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial
and obtain appropriate relief against a government. Stan
ing to assert a claim or defense under this section shall
be governed by the general rules of standing under arti-
cle III of the Constitution.
§ 2000bb-2. Definitions
As used in this Act—
[ 2 (1) the term “government” includes a branch, de-
) partment, agency, instrumentality, and official (or
other person acting under color of law) of the United
States, a State, or a subdivision of a State;
(2) the term “State” includes the District of Colum-
bia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, and each ter-
ritory and possession of the United States;
(3) the term “demonstrates” means meets the bur-
dens of going forward with the evidence and of per-
suasion; and
(4) the term “exercise of religion” means the exer-
cise of religion under the First Amendment to the
Constitution.
App- 21
§ 2000bb-3. Applicability
(a) Im general. This Act applies to all Federal and State
law, and the implementation of that law, whether stat-
utory or otherwise, and whether adopted before or after
the enactment of this Act [enacted Nov. 16, 1993].
ee ee (b) Rule of construction. Federal statutory law adopted
| | after the date of the enactment of this Act [enacted Nov.
16, 1993] is subject to this Act unless such law explicitly
excludes such application by reference to this Act.
(c) Religious belief unaffected. Nothing in this Act
shall be construed to authorize any government to burden
) any religious belief.
§ 2000bb-4. Establishment Clause unaffected
Nothing in this Act shall be construed to affect, inter-
pret, or in any way address that portion of the First
Amendment prohibiting laws respecting the establishment
of religion (referred to in this section as the “Establish-
ment ”). Granting government funding, benefits, or
exemptions, to the extent permissible under the Establish-
ment Clause, shall not constitute a violation of this Act.
As used in this section, the term “granting”, used with
respect to government funding, benefits, or exemptions,
F* does not include the denial of government funding benefits
be or exemptions. ;
App- 22
pores: ¢ rr he . ' " MUSLIM JOURNAL SEPTEMBER i8. 1
ee bade oe ie 4 “¢
: nae eS Gz edued rai | as . * eh PH a! *. re
SS dtd * wee ye >" tw
53 sedeeows ai cae o "Tin Aa ahAcove. Te ConPARONATE
| AL. ISLAM: literally .
means submission to osu will ,
bs of Allah (Creator).’* 2
~ MUSLIM ‘means one +
who is submitting to the will
of Allah (Creator):
- Articles of F aith
“Muslims accept. the. following ‘s six items ' :
as our articles of faith:
‘1 There is no: » deity except Allah. :
. (Creator). ” :
2. Muslims believe in all of the:
scriptures (books) of Allah
.: (Creator); and ‘they believe the.
-: Holy Qur’ an is the Last Revela-#
~ tion...
23, beating ‘believe, ‘or: accept, all”
oe ‘from. Allah (Creator).°'
“Some ‘of these Prophets are Abra-:- he
“PRINCIPLES: OF
~. AL-ISLAM
a The réligion i“ Al- hia has principles of
“practice that are sical on all adult
_ Muslims
+ To testify that Allah (Creator) is
the only deity and Prophet
_ Muhammad is His Messenger.
(Shahadah)
2. °2.Prayer at five prescribed times
each day. (Salat)
3. Charity. (Zakat) -
4. Fasting during the ninth month of
a the lunar calendar... (Ramadan. )
un ed Eo. Pilgrimageto ‘Mecca. at least once
;, during a lifetime if it is affordable.
wap
« >ham,: Pee, Jesus, and Muham- «. dpe eA
-mad.;
ae Bt ‘Muslims’ Gates in 1“ Angels that:
perform. specific. functions in.
+ ---Cieation: under. the - guthority. of:
"Allah | (Creator). “=
ae 5 ‘Muslims’ believe. in 1 ‘the Day of.”
resurrection; "a aneaicciiy and life:
after death." oe ee
1
weetee
i. ‘Muslims: believe. in’ the divine.
ordinance: : Sito
Muslims do not worship Prophet
. Muhammad. The only object of worship
for Muslims is Allah (Creator). Muslims
do not believe that Allah (Creator) is like
anythingin creation (universe).
“Visit a ‘a Masjid or Muslim Coaimeniie Center’ in
“your area to. learn more about the Religion of. Al-Islam.
ct SE A
App. 23
——— << Ss <a Eeee as «
WUDU
(Adlution or Wash)
To prepare yourself for the wonderful experience known as prayer end
to bring yourself into the right spiritual mcod, it is required that
you perform WUDU before prayer. First you say your intentions; (I in-
tend to purify myself for the service of worship to Allah).
1. Washing the hands to the wrist (3) times doing the right hand first:
The hands symbolize actions, the hand does the Conscience act of the
body and mind, so we clean those actions first. The right hand is our
strength, the left hand follows.
2. Rinsing the mouth out (3) three times: The mouth symbolize expression.
Lies comes from the mouth, we want the mouth clean at all times. |
3+ Rinsing the nose (3) three times, each nostril: The nose symbclize
desires. We have people saying he's nosy or he's putting his nose in
somebody's business.
4. Washing the face (3) three times, using both hands: The face is the
symbol of character. You can watch some peoples face and tell whets
on their mind and the next move they are going to make.
5. Wash the arms, up to the elbows (3) three times: Arms are the symbol
of power. When we clean our power then that clean power can te used —
to check the other powers in us or in our society to clean them up. *
6. Wash the ears once (using both'hands at the same time): Ears are the
symbol of knowledze and understanding. Our ears should always be clear
and open to hear, to listen to what is good, — oe, '
7+ Wash the head once, using both hands: The head also is the symbol of
Anowhedas If mans knowledge is not clean we will have corruption fror
our own (self) knowledge, ; es
8. The feet are last, but not least; each is to be washed (3) three time:
each. Feet symbolize our habits. We must have clean habits. Seciety-....
has been walking and steping fe filth since the dawn of time. Mans
—_— (habits) in the society should be clean and in a righteous direc
tion, ee
!
App- 24
| LARA RI
ve 2, re : BILD 3 we ‘>
we OF Vege! 4% oe
. * ve ‘ ’ e
aes At ohh a (BY
mm
‘‘Ramadan Karim Mubarak’’ "SS
Ramadan Karim means “may you have a generous Ramadan.”
Karim as an Arabic term is rich in expression. [t also means the
gifts that enhance the worth of the human being in terms of moral
dignity and self-respect. Karim means noble, honorable, repectable
and generous.
Ramadan Mubarak means “Blessed Ramadan.” We do not just
want to corne out with the human dignity and be without the
blessings of increased faith and enlightenment. Allah blesses us
from directions we do not perceive.
The nights of Ramadan are for prayers and contemplation on the
Guidance of Allah and His blessings in our lives. The days of
Ramadan are for restraint of appetities and to teach discipline to
Stav away from forbiddemthinvs.
During Ramadan, the Muslim keeps his or her mind on things
that are valuable, important, good and clean. If you did not keep
your mind on Allah and on higher values of life, your fasting would
have been hard for you. For Ramadan is not just abstinence of food,
it is a fast of the total person - physically, spiritually, and mentally.
The greatest benefit of fasting is “self-mastery.” Fasting gives us
the strength to overcome the drive of physical needs.
In the Holy Qur’an Allah says that fasting is for Him.
During the Ramadan fast, the Muslim reflects on Allah and thanks
Allah. He reflects on the wonders and truth of creation that sup-
ports the heavens and design of creation.
And we leave with “Eid Karim Mubarak.”
Imam W. Deen Mohammed and the M_.A.C.A. Staff
oe i a er
°° Al 220° TOWN AL ee PETES ND MONIES (Vom 8 iy
Bellovers: On behalf of myself and my family. we wish
yo osT SMU thangs to you for “our many Eid Greetings. }
We aise sish you a blessed and happy Eid, . ‘tai re
% 4
3 9 "a WAS see Crd :
12D MEAS ws OCONEE we
i a ee “-. . a i —-
App. 25
Prepare for Ramadan!
Or. Muzammil Sidcigi
Saiman reported at the Prophet (peace
be upon him) gave us a sermon on the
last doy of Sha’ban. He said:
5 people. o great and blessed month
is approaching you. There is a night in
this month which is better than one
thousanag months. Aliach nas made
fasting in this month an obtigation and
night prayers an act of voluntary obe-
dience. Whoever will do a good deed
in this month will receive the reward as
great as the reward of obligatory ffard)
deeds in other days; and, wnosoever
will do a fard in this month will receive
the reward as great as of seventy fard
done at other times.
This is the montn of perseverance and
the reward of perseverance is
paradise. This is tne montn of kindness
ond compassion. in this month the
good fortune of believers is increased.
Whoever will invite a fasting person in
this month for Iftar with nim wil find
forgiveness for his sins and Celiverance
from punishment of hell and he will
receive the reward of one who Is fasting
without any reduction in the reward of
that person himself
The first part of this month is mercy, the
middie part of this month is forgiveness
Publication Committee
'$ publshed on tne first of every month.
The statt consists mostty of volunteers trom
ine community. Please send your comments
and contributions io the Chauman, Publica-
von Committee. /siamic Society of Orange
County, 9752 W. 13th St. Garden Grow
CA 92642
cna tne icst part of this month is
deliverance from the punishment of
neil.
Once again in Our life we nave the op-
portunity to witness the biessed month
of Ramacan and take benefit from the
experience Of fasting, additional
prayers and good deeds.
Ramadan is the spring season of
goodness and virtue. It is a time when
yOu Can strike G specici bargain on the
blessings of God.These biesssings are
availabie to cil Mankind in plenty and
ot a grect “discount.” Why is the
bargain so good and $0 plen-
tiful in this Month? What is the
significance of this month? And why do
we fast? Let me answer these questions
Criefly.
In many religions of the worid there is
something called “guspicious time” or
“sacred time.” That time is associated
either with harvest, spring season. or the
birth of a Nero, saint or holy person, or
some historical event important in that
particular religious traditon. The month
of Rerrmadan is. in a similar way, an
Quspicious time, and a sacred time. it
is Associated with the revelation of the
Holy Qur’an.
The Qur'an says:
Ramadan is the month in which wos
sent down the Qur'an gs a guide fo
mankind and clear signs of guidance
and judgment between fright and
wrong. (2:185)
The revelation of the Holy Qur'an began
in this month. Since the advent of the
Holy Qur'an Is the greatest manifesta-
tion of Divine guidance and love for
mankind. The month that is associated
with the Holy Qur'an is considered as
the biessed and great month.
Ramadan is, thus, the month of the
Qur'an.
Why co Musiims fast in this month? We
fast in this month because if Is the com-
mand of God to recognize this month
and to thank Him for giving the Qur'an
in this month. There is furthermore a
in Hira when he received the revelation
of Alich and he was granted the first
revelation of the Qur'an. Other Prophets
too received revelation while they were
fasting. Propnet Moses was in Sinai
fasting for forty days when he received
his first reveiation. Proohet Jesus too was
fasting for forty days wnen he receivec
nis first call to Prophethood.
Fasting Qwakens the heart, enlightens
the spirit ond prepares the mind to
receive the word of God. It is like shin-
ing the mirror to see the good reflection
and image in it. We have to cleanse our
neart and mind from gross materialism
to let the word of God snine in It. It is for
this reason that muslims are urged to in-
crease their reading of the Qur'an dur-
ing this month. They co their individuc:
reading of the Qur'an and they aisc
listen to it In their tarawih prayers.
We human beings cre a combinatior:
of body and soul. Our body puils us
towards its source and origin, that is
towards the earth, the materia things:
food, drink and sex; but our soul nas a
celestial source and origin. it calis us to
rise above the monotonous routines of
eating and drinking and appeasemen:
of other urges of flesh. There is ciwcys
G tussle and conflict between the urge:
of the body and urges of the spirit. isicr>
wants to create a harmoneous relator
and a balance between these two vx
tremes. Through fasting we learn hov
to control ourselves and how tc
‘ discipline our urges. isiamic fast is «
disciplinary fast. It changes the routin-
of eating and drinking and gives a nes
schedule for a month. This is good fr
our spiritual and moral well-being
weil as for our physical strengnth ar
stamina. ©
Essay Competitio;
Essay Competition offered by Wore
Committee, Open to ail youth of ¢
isiarnic Society of Orange County
Topic:
i Contempiction of our inevitot.’
questioning by Allah on the Day
Judgement write an essay ado
yourself and now you would answer tn -
questions regarding the use of yo.
YOUTH, your TIME, your LEISURE, you:
HEALTH, and your WEALTH.
include your past in general and your
future (Inshalian) with pians for ac-
compiisnment. Write your first draft with
ail the details that only you and Allan
would know. Keep this for yourseif.
Make a second dratt using generalities
to avoid those things that are too per-
sonal! to be shared and made public.
Essays shouid be 3-4 typewritten pages
and are due by May 16, 1987. (piease
, turn into the office to the attention of the
Women's Committee) a
App. 26
Some Rules About Fasting
Or. Muzarnmil Siddiqi
Fasting is mandatory on every Musiim who
i$, Ault, Not sick ANd Not on Gc journey. Ad-
ditional condition in the case of women is
freecom from menstruction and post cniid
birth confinement periods.
Exemptions trom Fasting
1. The insane.
2. Children who are not acolescent yet.
3. The eideriy and the chronically ill for
whorn fasting is unreasonably strenous. A
person, in this category, however, |s re-
quired to feed one poor person for every
dey of Ramacan in which he/she misses
fasting.
4. Pregnant women and nursing mothers
who fear that tasting may endanger their
lives of heaith or those of their fetuses or
infants.
5. Those who are i! or traveling provided
that they make up the missed Goys of
fasting when they are weil.
6. Women during the period of menstruc-
tion or of past-chiidbirth confinement
Fasting during these periods is not permit-
tec and if shoulG De made up icter. a day
for a day
Duration ct Fasting
Fasitng starts every Gay in Ramadan a few
minutes oefore Fajr time (Dawn) and ends
soon after sunset. if one Goubts whether it
is Fayr time yet, he May continue to eat and
Grink until ne is Cefain. |t is certainty that
counts, not Goud?. Alich says: “And eat
GNd Grink, until (Ne white threcd of dawn
Gppecr fo you Gistinct trom its block
thread; then compiete your fast till the
night appears. . .(2:187)
Requirements tor the Vatidity of Fasting
1. Adstaining from food, drink, smoking
anc sex Defween Gown and sunset for
ecch day in Ramadan.
2. The intention to fast betore dawn every
Gay. The intention need not be in words
and is valic at cnv time after sunset
(for the following day). According to
some jurists. ihe intention can be made
onty once for the whole month (L.g.. in
ine Night preceding the first doy of
Ramacan)
|
|
|
|
|
Desirabie Things in Fasting
1. To take @ pre dawn meai (called
shucor) as Close fo Fajr time as possibile.
Prophet Muhommad (S.A.W.) says: “Par-
take Sunoor for there is bdiessing in
Suncor.” (Bukhari, Musiim)
The blessings of Suhoor include
strenghtening the fasting person,
enaciing him/ner to continue to be ac-
ive Guring the Gay. Gnd making fasting
tolerabie.
2. To break the fast Gs soon as one is
sure that tne sun nos set
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon
hirn) saic: “if any of you was fasting, let
him break the fast with Gates. if he can’t
find dates 3 him oreak the fast with
water. for woter is wholesome
(At-Tirrnidhi)
3. When breaking the fast. it is recom-
mended to make Ou a (Prayer). Follow-
ING Ofe Two versions of the Prophet's
Ova.
“O Allah for you cid | fast and with your
bounties do | oreak the fast.’
(Abu-Dawoogd)}
“Gone is the thirst and moistured are
the veins and achieved is the reward
Dy fhe will of Aliah.” (Abu-Dawood)
Continued on page 12
Fastings Continued from page 4
4, To avoid any act which is contradic-
tory to fasting, the Prophet (peace be
UPON him) said: “Fasting is not (mere)
refraining from food and drink. Fasting
is refraining from vain talk and indecen-
cy. And if one sianders you or agresses
against you, say | am fasting, | am
fasting. (Al-Hokim)
5.To be more generous especicily to
the Poor aNd to spend more time stu-
dying the Qur'an. Also to hove more
voluntary iciah and taraweeh Prayer.
Things which do not invalidate
Fasting
During Fasting, the following things are
permissibie:
1. Bathing. The Prophet (S.A.W.) was
reported to have poured water over his
nead while he was fasting either
decause Of thirst or heat. (Ahmad, Matik
and Abu-Dawocod) If water is swallow-
ec invoiuntrily. it does not involidate
fasting.
2. The use of Kuhi (eye powder). Anas
reported that the Prophet (S.A.W.) used
to use Kuhl while fasting.
3. Kissing one’s husband or wife provid-
Gt might (anytime Sefore dawn). in ail of the
above cases, Sathing may be delayed
UNTI the following morning and the fast Is
valid.
ne/she ects of drinks, provided that one
SNOUIC STOP eating or Grinking as soon as
ne/sne remembers. The same rule applies
to those who are involuntarily forced to
break the fast.
ed that one is abie to control
himselt/nerseit from sexual excitement
4. Rinsing tne mouth or nostrils with
water provided that it is not overdone |
($0 Gs to Gvoid swallowing water).
'
5. Swaliowing things which are not |
possidbie to avoid such as one’s own
secretions (@.g. saliva) or street
dust. . . etc.
6. Tasting tne food being purchased or
COOKed) with the tip of the tongue. (This
was reporied by ibn Abbas.)
7, Taking injections (of any type).
8. Smelling flowers or wearing per-
furnes, etc.
|
9. One may continue his/her fast even
if Ne/she is Junub, (the state after inter-
course and before bathing). Likewise,
women at tha end of the periods of
menstruation post-cnild birth confinement
periods May start tasting if bleeding stops
10. if one forgets that ne/she is fasting and
14. In either case. the person must con-
tinue to fast for the rest of the day
3. The beginning of menstruation or post- |
childbirth bleeding even in the iast mo-
ment before sunset. |
4. Ejaculation for reasons other than sex-
UG! intercourse, (@.g. kissing or hugging
one's wife).
5. Eating, drinking, smoking or having sex-
ual intercourse cfier Fajr (dawn) on the
mistaken Assumption that it is not Fajr time
yet. Similarty, engaging in these acts
before Magnrid (sunset) on tne mistaken
GssumMption that it is ciready Maghrib time
if one breaks ones fast delibertely (by |
eating. Grinking, sexual act) then the |
penaity is fasting sixty days (after |
Ramadan
Things Which Invatidate the Fas!
Those which invatidate fasting and requre
@ada’ Only (making up the missed day or
Goys, G Gay for a day).
| 1. Eating and/or arinking deliberStety (in- |
| cluding partaking non-nourishing iterns by |
the mouth).
'
;
2. Deliberately causing oneseif to vomit. |
| without interrur -
STATE OF ILLINOIS )
) ss.
COUNTY OF VERMILION )
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
I, JOHN MACK, #A-73457,state that I served a copy of the document to
which this affidavit is attached upon each party, or, if represented by
counsel,upon the attorney of record for said party(ies) by enc losing
the same in a sealed envelope are (Forty Printed Copy Of My Brief) pla-
inly addressed as is discloosed by the pleading s of record herein and
by depositing each of envelopes in the box designated for United States
Mail at Danville Correctional Center, Danviile, Illinois, 61834-4001-2,
together with a Money Voucher for Amount Due attached, addressed to the
Clerk; William K. Sutter, Of The United States Supreme Court, Office Of
The Clerk Washington, DC 20543-0001. On this 30th, day of June, 1997.
| flack ALAS]
MACK, #A-73457
VERIFICATION OF CERTIF’ CATION
I, JOHN MACK, #A-73457, the undersigned, certify and state that:
1. I am the Respondent, in the above captioned legal matter;
2. I have read the Foregoing application and have knowledge of its contents;
and
3. Under penalties as provided by law pursuant to sec. 1-109 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, I certify that the statements set forth in the foregoing
motion and this affidavit are true and correct except as to matters therein
stated to be on information and belief, and as to such matters I certify -
that I believe the same to be true.
Phback HTKST
OHN MACK, #A-73457
SUBSCRIBED AND DECLARED TO ME
OFFICIAL SEAL
CAROL DEMOSS
NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF ILLINOIS
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES 5-6-09
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.