Reply Brief — Nat'l Ass'n of Mfrs. v. Dep't of Def., 137 S. Ct. 811 (2017) (No. 16-299)

Supreme Court brief2017

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court of the United ‘States

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF MANUFACTURERS,

Petitioner,

v.

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE,

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, AND

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, ET AL..,

Respondents.

——EEE —————————

On Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit

REPLY BRIEF OF RESPONDENTS WATERKEEPER

ALLIANCE, INC., CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY,

CENTER FOR FOOD SAFETY, HUMBOLDT BAYKEEPER,

RUSSIAN RIVERKEEPER, MONTEREY COASTKEEPER,

SNAKE RIVER WATERKEEPER, INC., UPPER MISSOURI

WATERKEEPER, INC., TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION

NETWORK, INC., SERRA CLUB, AND

PUGET SOUNDKEEPER ALLIANCE

IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER

JENNIFER C. CHAVEZ ALLISON M. LAPLANTE

EARTHJUSTICE Counsel of Record

1 assachusetts Av. NW § JAMES N. SAUL

pay — EARTHRISE LAW CENTER

Washi n, DC 20036 LEWIS & CLARK LAW SCHOOL

ashingta 10015 S.W. Terwilliger Blvd.

(202) 667-4500 Portland, OR 97219

jchavez@earthjustice.org (503) 768-6894 (LaPlante)

(503) 768-6929 (Saul)

laplante@|clark.edu

saul@lclark.edu

Counsel for Respondents Library of Comepes.se

Law Litwury

i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

SARE CF BAF CEE ED ove cesesccosnssnsonesesesensecesasese i

BITTE tv ciincicissnnnccndtuiiviisetnnnennnanaiininteiemmandnaaals 1

A. The Clean Water Rule Is Not An “Other

Limitation” Within The Meaning Of Section

Re icatiitnssevcccupsecieinchebeainiaaeaheaatadn: 1

B. The Agencies Did Not Promulgate The Clean

Water Rule Pursuant To Section 1311 Or Any

Of The Other Sections Listed In Section

asics cecdsnstcctcccessenimatc neste: 10

| I esi a aerENS, 13

rm

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases Page

Am. Petroleum Inst. v. EPA,

Se EN GI BIE Decccccccccccccccecccccccccccccosess 4

E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train,

RE ER AE TR 3, 4

In re United States Dept. of Defense and United

States Environmental Protection Agency Final

Rule: Clean Water Rule: Definition of “Waters of

the United States”,

817 F.3d 261 (6th Cir. 2016) ...............0.-.-00000--- 8,13

Texas Oil & Gas Ass’n v. EPA,

161 F.3d 923 (Gth Cir. 1906).............ccc0.-.ssceessereeeees 4

Virginia Elec. & Power Co. v. Costle,

666 F.2d 446 (4th Cir. 1977)..............c0ccccecscevecsseeses 5

Yates v. United States,

Ee 2

Federal Statutes Page

Ee passim

na senccamnnnsscnnsnconss 7, 8, 9, 13

I seseisislibannci 9

a as cemeccancednecnnbuanent Bowers 3

EE 3, 13

Sd sesseeee, 18

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

33 U.S.C.

SI ic tinigthimaegtnapeesantecnnstnamemapeietantnii 3, 13

TELE ayaa ea manerter ene ser 3

SII ise ctiiteaidietsdiniediinatnainingennbennicialakaan 3

EPI TREE Sees ewan we 3

IIIT os iccacinctighamsiandiansiineniemanmncindeapsdénibinnaaiia 3

iia leentniciaeendhioatainaie 3

SUT iicinsictpicicnlncdedasasindnscibiantentiasininimmmall 3

SEES EER Rina tees ae 1, 3, 4, 10

I icant sinetnatcipinsinnnpiitiieininisiasnisaniaiaaiedal 3

ESS eee ren earecnr nn 12

Stites nenrepeninsemmninnnamiennsinaiel passim

Dn ccscnenenencinndensesenabmnssannneaniiiins 3

a eiiaeiiiibasadiiadl 4

I siatpremnneusniibiinsabansemmnannniannts 11

EEE TESTS aera PAREN Tone Smee Pes 4

SERRE S RO Rese aren ee os 7 4

aie metieslanlpounseananiiindl 4

SP Ra DERE a Se oenebe 12

IT i. ccstcteacctsnemnennasinimindiniibneniainnit 11

ERE ERPEREE ART aneenssewe sveme news seer ans 5

SEITE cots ecnnsiunnepessianncsoesimccibenmmesiiainainaiie 5

SI iitcinteiaciumestinentnenegeiuntmidnisdegienbiianaint 10, 12

eons 8, 10, 12

IE i ose sitenariatnentanliapsetunitenapnennainelll 7

SII inicttsicsneiannnsiatniusenennmnicmmimnionsiiial 4

STIs snduinssindngisandienidecsiimninienipnbiiiiatea 4

RI iss cicsceeisasuinatietigninmadniiionabenaiaiala 4

SIT iisshiensiseasdtnatnsnittnciiaunbteaesenibial 10, 12

I sii sins actntnteacenbetieteagnenatciaieddiiinlil passim

Si ois suncidueniniatetininiinseendebenigeniaaniniial 3

Sst scntcenninsietiinsemninaaiinansnmsinatamnmntiin 5, 6

ES panto namner nrcen rene 6

eee 10

SUIT ic. disnctiedsintiesenstenpinitsiesineaninineaads 11, 12, 13

a ee 8, 11, 13

EE ae ee eee 11, 12

I ceaderinel 3, 5, 7

i ei eesinenatilsdeiaael 4

seein 4

RC passim

Federal Regulations Page

I ceeueerseaanteieeelll 6

a ienietiiiadiniaiaiiaedlll 6

I eel cecetialell 6

Other Authorities Page

Clean Water Rule: Definition of “Waters of the

United States”, 80 Fed. Reg. 37,054

ECE ERE 8, 10, 12

EPA, A Plain English Guide to the EPA Part 503

Biosolids Rule (September 1994), available at

https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/ files/2015-

05/documents/ a_plain_english_ guide to_

the epa_part_503_biosolids_rule.pdf..................... 6

Standards for the Use or Disposal of Sewage

Sludge, 58 Fed. Reg. 9248 (Feb. 19, 1993) ............ 6

1

ARGUMENT

Section 1369(b)(1)(E) of the Clean Water Act

(“CWA” or the “Act”) applies to actions taken by the

Administrator of the U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency (“EPA”) in “approving or

promulgating any effluent limitation or other

limitation under section 1311, 1312, 1316, or 1345

of this title.” 33 U.S.C. § 1369(b)(1)(E). In this case,

EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

(collectively, the “Agencies”) argue that the Clean

Water Rule qualifies as an “other limitation” under

Section 1311 of the Clean Water Act. This

argument fails for two reasons. First, the Clean

Water Rule does not properly qualify as an “other

limitation” within the meaning of Section

1369(b)(1)(E) because it merely interprets the

Congressional! definition of those waters to which

existing limits apply; it does not create a new one.

And second, the Agencies did not promulgate the

Clean Water Rule pursuant to Section 1311 or any

of the other sections listed in Section 1369(b)(1)(E).

A. The Clean Water Rule Is Not An

“Other Limitation” Within The

Meaning Of Section 1369(b)(1)(E)

On its face, Section 1369(b)(1)(E) applies only to

“effluent limitation|[s}” and “other limitation[s}”

approved or promulgated pursuant to the four

specified statutory sections, 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311,

1312, 1316, and 1345. The Agencies urge this Court

to deem the Clean Water Rule an “other limitation”

2

promulgated pursuant to Section 1311. The Court

should reject this invitation.

While Congress did not define the term “other

limitation” as used in Section 1369(b)(1)(), it is

best understood by virtue of its relationship to both

the immediately preceding phrase, “effluent

limitation,” and the four specified statutory

sections listed in Section 1369(b)(1)(E).

Section 1369(b)(1)(E) clearly juxtaposes the

terms “effluent limitation[s]” and “other

limitation[s]” approved or promulgated under the

relevant provisions. As Justice Ginsburg recently

noted in Yates v. United States, “we rely on the

principle of noscitur a sociis—a word is known by

the company it keeps—to avoid ascribing to one

word a meaning so broad that it is inconsistent

with its accompanying words, thus. giving

unintended breadth to the Acts of Congress.” __

U.S. __, 135 S.Ct. 1074, 1085 (2015) (plurality

opinion) (internal quote and citation omitted). In

the present context, this Court should look to the

characteristics of “effluent limitation{s]” under the

Statute, and how they are implemented, to

understand what Congress must have meant by the

counterpart phrase, “other limitation.”

Congress defined the phrase “effluent

limitation” in the following terms:

The term “effluent limitation” means

any restriction established by a State

or the Administrator on quantities,

3

rates, and concentrations of chemical,

physical, biological, and _ other

constituents which are discharged

from point sources into navigable

waters, the waters of the contiguous

zone, or the ocean, including schedules

of compliance.

33 U.S.C. § 1362(11). In practice, EPA typically sets

these limitations, often pursuant to an express

grant of statutory power. Indeed, the statutory

sections referenced in Section 1369(b)(1)(E)—

Sections 1311, 1312, 1316 and 1345—speak

frequently and explicitly about the approval or

promulgation of standards meeting the above

definition. !

| See, e.g., 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311(c), (d), (g), (hb), @, (&),

(m), (mn), and (p) (allowing EPA, with the

concurrence of the states in some instances, to

update or approve modifications—in specified

contexts—to either the substance or the timing of

the relevant requirements), 1312(a) (authorizing

EPA to establish water-quality-related permit

conditions), 1316(b)(1)(B) (authorizing EPA to

promulgate new source performance standards),

and 1345(b) (authorizing EPA to promulgate

sewage sludge regulations where the handling of

such sludge by a treatment plant may impact the

navigable waters). The sole exception to this

dynamic is in Section 1311(b), which, as this Court

noted in E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, is

oddly silent about “who sets the § [1311] effluent

limitations.” 430 U.S. 112, 121 (1977) (EL. du

More significantly, and as the Agencies

acknowledge, effluent limitations generally take

effect for individual dischargers only when they are

incorporated intu permits issued under the national

pollutant discharge elimination system (“NPDES”);

in this context, the permit issuer—which may be

either EPA or a state, see 33 U7 S.C. § 1342(a)(1)

and (b)(1)—in effect “translates” the national

standards into facility-specific requirements.

Federal Respondents’ Brief at 23 (citing Texas Oil

& Gas Ass'n v. EPA, 161 F.3d 923, 928 (5th Cir.

1998) and Am. Petroleum Inst. v. EPA, 661 F.2d

340, 344 (5th Cir. 1981)). Once the effluent

limitations are incorporated into the relevant

permits, the esulting permit conditions become

enforceable under the Act. See, eg., 33 U.S.C. §§

1319(a), (b), and (d) (EPA enforcement) and

1365(a)(1) and (f) (citizen suits).?

Turning to the realm of “other limitation|s],”

three of the statutory sections referenced in Section

1369(b)(1)(E)—Sections 1311, 1316, and 1345—

authorize EPA to establish substantive

Pont’). Nonetheless, the E.J. du Pont Court found

that EPA had correctly interpreted Section 1311(b)

as giving it the power to set those standards

through rulemaking. /d. at 135-136.

2 Although these provisions also reference other

statutory sections, including Sections 1311, 1312,

1316, and 1346, for permitted entities in most cases

it is the permit condition that must be enforced, not

5

requirements, some of which cannot constitute

“effluent limitation[s]” because they do not address

“discharge[s] from point sources into navigable

waters,” as required under Section 1362(11). In the

first two of these contexts, this power emerges from

the interplay between these sections and Section

1326 of the Act. In that section—dealing with

thermal discharges—Congress gave EPA the power

to establish what are colloquially referred to as

“intake structure” regulations, governing water

withdrawals by power plants. 33 U.S.C. § 1326(b).

As the Fourth Circuit recognized in Virginia Elec.

& Power Co. v. Costle, 556 F.2d 446 (4th Cir. 1977),

however, Section 1326(b) itself makes clear that the

regulations were to be promulgated under Sections

1311 or Section 1316 (for existing or new sources,

respectively). Id. at 450, citing 33 U.S.C. § 1326(b)

(“any standard established pursuant to section

[1311] or [1316] ... shall require that the location,

design, construction, and capacity of cooling water

intake structures reflect the best technology

available for minimizing adverse environmental

impact’). Thus, the court correctly determined that

the standards constituted “other limitation[s]”

within the meaning of Section 1369(b)(1)(&). Jd.

In similar fashion, Section 1345(d) of the Act

charged EPA with establishing standards for the

disposal of sewage sludge generated by sewage

treatment plants. 33 U.S.C. § 1345(d). These

regulations cover, inter alia, the land application of

such sludge (e.g., as fertilizer), the disposal of

sludge at surface sites, and the incineration of

sludge in sewage sludge incinerators. 40 C.F.R.

6

Part 503 (subparts B, C, and E, respectively). Here

also, at least some of the regulations cannot

constitute “effluent limitation[s],” because they

address threats to soils and air, not the navigable

waters.® Thus, these regulations zre best viewed as

“other limitation[s]” within the meaning of Section

1369(b)(1)(E).

In both of the above contexts—dealing with

intake structures and sewage sludge—the

requirements are implemented through permit

conditions. See 40 C.F.R. § 125.90(a) (intake

structures) and 33 U.S.C. § 1345(f) (sewage

sludge).4

3 See, e.g., 40 C.F.R. § 503.43 (imposing limitations

and other requirements under authority of Section

1345 for the incineration of sewage sludge intended

to control air pollutant emissions); see also 58 Fed.

Reg. 9248, 9249 (Feb. 19, 1993) (Preamble to EPA’s

initial Part 503 regulations, promulgated under

authority of Section 1345, noting that “[c]oncern for

air quality necessitates proper controls over sludge

incineration’).

4 In the sewage sludge context, the permit does not

necessarily need to be an NPDES permit. See 33

U.S.C. § 1345(f). As EPA has noted, however, it

usually is. EPA, A Plain English Guide to the EPA

Part 503 Biosolids Rule (September 1994) at 11 (“In

most cases, Part 503 requirements will be

incorporated over time into [NPDES] permits

issued to [the relevant entities].”), available at

https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/ files/2015-

05/documents/a_plain_ english guide to_the_epa_p

In lne with the above, the phrase “other

limitation,” as used in Section 1369(b)(1)(E), is best

understood in context. In the four statutory

provisions referenced in that Section, Congress

charged EPA with establishing various

requirements, which were then to be made

applicable to individual dischargers through permit

conditions. As befits the NPDES program’s primary

focus on discharges of pollutants, see 33 U.S.C.

§1342(a), most of these requirements qualify as

“effluent limitation[s]” within the meaning of

Section 1362(11). The others—those not governing

discharges—constitute the relevant “other

limitation[s].”

The Agencies, by contrast, urge a practically

unlimited interpretation of the “other limitation”

phrase, at least insofar as it deals with a subject

relating to Section 1311 in any way. Federal

Respondents’ Brief, pp. 17—18. In particular, they

argue that “[a] rule that specifies which sites are

‘waters of the United States’ imposes on persons

who discharge pollutants to those waters the full

panoply of effluent and other limitations under

Section 1311.” Jd. This position is untenable. As

Judge Griffin noted below, it is the Act itself—not

the Clean Water Rule—that “restricts the

industry's untrammeled discretion.” In re United

States Dept. of Defense and United States

Environmental Protection Agency Final Rule: Clean

art_503_biosolids_rule.pdf (ast checked September

8, 2017).

8

Water Rule: Definition of “Waters of the United

States”, 817 F.3d 261, 279-280 (6th Cir. 2016) (in re

Dept. of Defense’) (Griffin, J., concurring in

judgment). Specifically, Section 1311(a), when

taken together with the definitions in Section 1362,

prohibits persons from discharging pollutants into

the “waters of the United States,” except to the

extent that they comply’ with specified

requirements, including—in appropriate cases—the

requirements of the NPUVES permit program. 33

U.S.C. 1311(a) (referencing 33 U.S.C. §1342). This

prohibition is in no way dependent upon the Clean

Water Rule, which does not “limit” anything. The

Agencies conceded as much in the preamble to the

Rule:

The action imposes no enforceable

duty on any state, local, or tribal

governments, or the private sector,

and does not contain regulatory

requirements that might significantly

or uniquely affect small governments.

Clean Water Rule: Definition of “Waters of the

United States,” 80 Fed. Reg. 37,054, 37,102 (June

29, 2015).

Instead of establishing limitations, the Clean

Water Rule merely clarifies the waters to which the

statutory prohibition in Section 1311(a) applies.

The Agencies’ comments in the preamble also

confirm this point:

9

This rule is not designed to “subject”

any entities of any size to any specific

regulatory burden. Rather, it is

designed to clarify the statutory scope

of “the waters of the United States ...”

consistent with Supreme Court

precedent.

Id. (citation omitted).

The conclusion that the Clean Water Rule does

not constitute an “other limitation” is further

underscored by the fact that nothing in the statute

even contemplates that the Agencies would write

rules further elaborating on the scope of the

statutory waters, or on any of the other

jurisdictional elements of Section 1311(a), let alone

requires them to do so. Nothing would have

constrained the Agencies from proceeding from the

outset without regulations defining the “waters of

the United States.” In following such a course, the

Agencies could have gradually established at least

some clarification through litigation. While

attempting to write clarifying regulations on an up-

front basis may be a salutary undertaking,

clarifying the scope of a limitation simply is not the

same thing as establishing a limitation. Congress,

not the Agencies, created the limitation in Section

1311(a)(1).

10

B. The Agencies Did Not Promulgate

The Clean Water Rule Pursuant To

Section 1311 Or Any Of The Other

Relevant Sections Listed In Section

1369(b)(1)(E)

Even if the Court determines that the Clean

Water Rule establishes limitations capable of

qualifying as “other limitation[s]” under Section

1369(b)(1)(E), it still would not trigger the

applicability of that Section. This is so because

Section 1369(b)(1)(E) also requires—as a

precondition to its applicability—that EPA approve

or promulgate the rule pursuant to one of four

statutory sections, 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311, 1312, 1316,

or 1345. In the preamble to the Clean Water Rule,

the Agencies cited five separate sections as

providing the legal basis for their authority,

including, most notably, Sections 1311 and 1361. Of

the five, Section 1311 is the only one that appears

on the list of qualifying authorities in Section

1369(b)(1)(E). 80 Fed. Reg. at 37,055.5 Perhaps for

this reason, the Agencies rely entirely on Section

1311 in their brief. Federal Respondents’ Brief, pp.

17—30.6 Section 1311 does not provide an adequate

statutory basis for the Clean Water Rule. EPA’s

5 The others were Sections 1341, 1342, and 1344. 80

Fed. Reg. at 37,056.

6 The Agencies reference Section 1361 once as

support for the Rule, in a footnote in the

introduction to their argument. Federal

Respondents’ Brief at 17, n.3. It never comes up

again.

11

proper basis for promulgating a rule further

defining the Act’s jurisdictional terms resides in

Section 1361(a), which is not within the scope of

Section 1369(b)(1)(E).

Section 1361(a) provides EPA with the general

authority to “prescribe such regulations as are

necessary to carry out [its] functions under [the

Act].” 33 U.S.C. § 1361(a). As alluded to above, see

footnote 1 and accompanying text, several sections

of the Clean Water Act provide EPA with the

authority to promulgate regulations that are

geared to specific programs. See also, e.g., 33 U.S.C.

§§ 1317(b) (requiring EPA to promulgate

“pretreatment standards” for those who discharge

effluent into publicly owned treatment works) and

1322(b) (requiring EPA to “promulgate Federal

standards of performance for marine sanitation

devices”).

Putting aside any issues regarding the merits of

the Rule, the proper legal authority for the Clean

Water Rule is found only in Section 1361(a). This is

so for at least two compelling reasons. First, no

other provision of the Act provides any explicit

basis for the promulgation of regulations

interpreting the definitional components of Section

1362 (including the definition of “navigable waters”

in Section 1362(7), which is where the “waters of he

United States” language appears). In other

situations, of course, a court might infer that an

agency has the implied authority to resolve any

definitional ambiguities. But here there is no need.

12

Section 1361(a) explicitly provides a breadth of

authority that readily encompasses such a rule.

Second, the terms that are being defined here—

“waters of the United States” and thus, in turn,

“navigable waters’—apply across the _ entire

statute. The Agencies themselves recognized this in

the preamble to the Clean Water Rule:

The jurisdictional scope of the [CWA]

is “navigable waters,” defined in

section [1362(7)] of the statute as

“waters of the United States, including

the territorial seas.” The term

“navigable waters” is used in a

number of provisions of the [CWA|,

including the section [1342] National

Pollutant Discharge Elimination

System (NPDES) permit program, the

section [1344] permit program, the

section [1321] oil spill prevention and

response program, the water quality

standards and total maximum daily

load programs (TMDL) under section

[1313], and the section [1341] state

water quality certification process.

80 Fed. Reg. at 37,055 (footnote omitted). It is self-

evident that a provision giving EPA statute-wide

rulemaking authority is the proper place to ground

the authority for the most over-arching regulation

promulgated under the statute.

13

Section 1311 simply will not bear the weight the

Agencies place upon it. While it contains several

provisions authorizing EPA to create, update, or

modify effluent limitations, see, e.g., Section

1311(c), (d), and (g), that section simply contains no

indication that it provides EPA with any authority

to interpret the Act’s jurisdictional definitions. The

Agencies point to the basic prohibition in Section

131l(a), but nothing in that provision is even

suggestive regarding the creation of any general

rulemaking authority. Moreover, as Judge Griffin

noted below, “the definitional section the Clean

Water Rule modifies—‘the term ‘navigable waters’

means the waters of the United States”—does not

emanate from Section 1311l(a). In re Dept. of

Defense, 817 F.3d at 277 (Griffin, J., concurring).

Instead, as Judge Griffin further acted. it finds its

origin in Section 1362, which is not mentioned in

Section 1369(b)(1)(E).

This Court should deem the Clean Water Rule

to have been promulgated under Section 1361(a) of

the Clean Water Act, thus making it ineligible for

expedited review under Section 1369(b)(1)(E).

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons and for the reasons

stated in Respondents’ opening brief, the judgment

of the court of appeals should be reversed.

14

Dated: September, 2017.

Respectfully submitted,

Allison M. LaPlante

Counsel of Record

James N. Saul

EARTHRISE LAW CENTER

Lewis & Clark Law School

10015 S.W. Terwilliger Blvd.

Portland, OR 97219

(503) 768-6894 (LaPlante)

(503) 768-6929 (Saul)

laplante@lclark.edu

saul@lclark.edu

Counsel for Respondents

Waterkeeper Alliance, et al.

Jennifer C. Chavez

EARTHJUSTICE

1625 Massachusetts Av. NW

Suite 702

Washington, DC 20036

(202) 667-4500

jchavez@earthjustice.org

Counsel for Respondents

Sierra Club and Puget

Soundkeeper Alliance

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.