Joint Appendix — U.S. Army Corp of Eng'rs v. Hawkes Co., 136 S. Ct. 615 (2015) (No. 15-290)
Supreme Court brief2015
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
FILED
Court, U.S,
JAN 22 2016
No. 15-290 L_OFFICE OF THE CLERK
In the Supreme Court of the Anited States
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
PETITIONER
Vv.
HAWKES Co., INC., ET AL.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT
JOINT APPENDIX
DONALD B. VERRILLI, JR. M. REED HOPPER
Solicitor General Pacific Legal Foundation
Department of Justice 930 G Street
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001 Sacramento, CA 95814
SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov mrh@pacificlegal.org
(202) 514-2217 (916) 419-7111
Counsel of Record Counsel of Record
for Petitioner for Respondents
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED: SEPT. 18, 2015
CERTIORARI GRANTED: DEC. 11, 2015
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Court of appeals docket entries .................c..c.scecsseeereesereereeees 1
District court docket entries ...................c.cccsecseseseeceseeeeseneeeees 3
Amended complaint for declaratory and injunctive
ee 7
Amended complaint exhibits:
Exhibit A (Letter of Mar. 15, 2011) ........0.....cccccccccessesees 27
Exhibit B (Letter of Aug. 25, 2011) ...0.........cccccecceseseees 31
Exhibit C (Administrative appeal decision) ................. 37
Materials Previously Reproduced
The following documents have been omitted from the
Joint Appendix but may be found in the appendix to the
petition for a writ of certiorari in this case.
Court of appeals opinion (Apr. 10, 2015) ..................cece0000 la
District court memorandum opinion and order
Ee 22a
' 1 juriedictional determination
Eee 44a
Court of appeals order (July 7, 2015) ...............ccccccecesesees 103a
Statutory and regulatory provisions ..................c.s00s00 105a
(I)
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 13-3067
HAWKES Co., INC.; PIERCE INVESTMENT COMPANY;
LPF PROPERTIES, LLC, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS
v.
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
DEFENDANT-APPELLEE
DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE PROCEEDINGS
9/19/13 Civil case docketed. [4077221] (13-3067)(CYZ)
12/11/14 ARGUED & SUBMITTED in St. Paul to Judges
4/10/15
James B. Loken, Myron H. Bright, Jane Kelly on
12/11/2014 Mr. Reed Hopper for Appellants
Hawkes Co., Inc., Pierce Investment Company
and LPF Properties, LLC and Mr. Robert
Lundman for Appellee United States Army
Corps of Engineers. No Rebuttal RECORD-
ED [4224907] [13-3067] (CYZ)
OPINION FILED—THE COURT: James B.
Loken, Myron H. Bright and Jane Kelly AU-
THORING JUDGE: James B. Loken (PUB-
LISHED). CONCUR BY: Jane Kelly
[4264064] [13-3067] (CMD)
(1)
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
4/10/15
6/9/15
W/T/15
TAG/15
JUDGMENT FILED—The judgment of the orig-
inating court is REVERSED and REMANDED
in accordance with the opinion. JAMES B.
LOKEN, MYRON H. BRIGHT and JANE
KELLY Hrg Dec 2014 [4264084] [13-3067]
(CMD)
a a
PETITION for enbanc rehearing and also for re-
hearing by panel filed by Appellee United States
Army Corps of Engineers w/service 06/09/2015
[4283652] [13-3067] (RL)
JUDGE ORDER: Denying [4283652-2] peti-
tion for enbanc rehearing filed by Appellee
United States Army Corps of Engineers. The
petition for panel rehearing is also denied.
[4283652-3] PUBLISHED ORDER. Hrg Dec
2014 [4292636] [13-3067] (MER)
MANDATE ISSUED. [4295880] [13-3067]
(MER)
i a it fe
3
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA
Civil Docket No. 0:13-cv-00107-ADM-TNL
HAWKES Co., INC. ET AL, PLAINTIFFS
v.
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
DEFENDANT
DOCKET ENTRIES
DOCKET
DATE NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
V1V/13
3/13/13
l
IN
COMPLAINT for Declaratory and
Injunctive Relief against Us Army
Corps Of Eng. (Filing fee $ 350
receipt number 0864-3411674.)
Filed by Hawkes Co., Inc. LPF
Properties, LLC, Pierce Investment
Company. Filer requests summons
issued. (Attachments: # 1 Ex-
hibit(s) A-C, # 2 Civil Cover Sheet)
(Merz, Gregory) (Entered:
01/11/2013)
*_ *- *&* & *
AMENDED COMPLAINT for
Declaratory and Injunctive Relief
against United States Army Corps of
Engineers. Filed by Hawkes Co.,
Inc., LPF Properties, LLC, Pierce
Investment Company. No sum-
DOCKET
DATE NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
mons requested.
(Attachments:
# 1 Exhibits(s) A, B, C) (Merz,
Gregory) (Entered: 08/13/2013)
* + + *
4/19/13 ll MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of
Jurisdiction by United States Army
Corps of Engineers. (Dertke, Dan-
iel) (Entered: 04/19/2013)
4/19/13 12 MEMORANDUM in Support re 11
MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of
Jurisdiction filed by United States
Army Corps of Engineers. (Attach-
ment: Certificate of Service).
(Dertke, Daniel) Modified text on
4/19/2013 = (Imb).
04/19/2013)
*_ = *&* © *
(Entered:
5/29/13 25 MEMORANDUM by Pacific Legal
Foundation re 11 MOTION to Dis-
miss for Lack of Jurisdiction Amicus
Curiae Memorandum of Law in
Support of Plaintiffs’ Opposition to
US Army Corps Motion to Dismiss
filed by Pacific Legal Foundation.
(Attachments: # 1 LR7.1/LR722
Word Count Compliance Certificate)
(Kaardal, Erick)
05/29/2013)
(Entered:
DOCKET
DATE NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
5/31/13
6/21/13
8/1/13
8/1/13
26
IS
Is
MEMORANDUM in Opposition re
11 MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of
Jurisdiction filed by Hawkes Co.,
Inc., LPF Properties, LLC, Pierce
Investment Company. (Attach-
ments: # 1 LRT7.1/LR722 Word
Count Compliance Certificate)
(Merz, Gregory) (Entered:
05/31/2013)
*_ *+ *&* © *
Reply to Response to Motion re 11
MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of
Jurisdiction filed by United Staets
Army Corps of Engineers. (Attach-
ments: # 1 LR7.1/LR72.2 Word
Count Compliance Certificate) (Der-
tke, Daniel) (Entered: 06/21/2013)
* * * &© *
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND
ORDER granting 11 Defendant’s
Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Juris-
diction (Written Opinion). Signed
by Judge Ann D. Montgomery
on 08/01/2013. (TLU) (Entered:
08/01/2013)
JUDGMENT (Attachments: # 1
Civil Notice—appeal) (jz) (Entered:
08/01/2013)
DOCKET
DATE NUMBER PROCEEDINGS
IIT/13
32
NOTICE OF APPEAL TO 8TH
CIRCUIT by Hawkes Co., Inc., LPF
Properties, LLC, Pierce Investment
Company. Filing fee $ 455, receipt
number 0864-3699153. (Hopper, M)
(Entered: 09/17/2013)
7
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA
Court File No. 13-107 (ADM/THL)
HAWKES Co., INC., PIERCE INVESTMENT COMPANY, AND
LPF PROPERTIES, LLC, PLAINTIFFS
vz.
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
DEFENDANT
Filed: Mar. 13, 2013
AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY
AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
Plaintiffs Hawkes Co., Inc., Pierce Investment
Company, and LPF Properties, LLC, for their Amend-
ed Complaint seeking declaratory and injunctive relief
allege as follows:
INTRODUCTION
1. In this action, the Plaintiffs seek review pur-
suant to the Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”), 5
U.S.C. § 551, et seq., of a final agency action of the
United States Army Corps of Engineers (the “Corps”),
finding that certain property in which the Plaintiffs
have an ownership or other beneficial interest (the
“Property”) is a water of the United States under the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1251,
et seg., known as the Clean Water Act (“CWA”), and
therefore subject to the Corps’ jurisdiction.
8
2. As a result of the Corps’ unlawful assertion of
jurisdiction, Plaintiffs are unable to use the Property
without fear of a CWA enforcement action, fines, and
penalties. The Corps’ improper assertion of jurisdic-
tion also subjects Plaintiffs to an unlawful and burden-
some permitting requirement.
3. Plaintiffs seek by this action a declaration that
the Property is not a water of the United States under
the CWA. Plaintiffs also seek an injunction enjoining
the Corps from exercising jurisdiction over Plaintiffs’
Property.
4. The Court’s review of the agency action that is
the subject of this proceeding is based upon the ad-
ministrative record before the Corps at the time the
Corps made its decision.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
5. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject
matter of this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (fed-
eral question jurisdiction); 28 U.S.C. § 2201 (author-
izing declaratory relief); 28 U.S.C. § 2202 (authorizing
further “necessary or proper relief”); and 5 U.S.C.
§ 702 (providing for judicial review of agency action
under the APA).
6. The Property consists of approximately 530
acres of real estate located in New Maine Township,
Marshall County, Minnesota. Venue in this judicial
district is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1931(e)(2) because
the Property that is the subject of the action is located
within this district.
9
PARTIES
7. Plaintiffs Pierce Investment Company (“Pierce
Investment”), a Minnesota corporation with its princi-
pal place of business in Minnesota, and LPF Proper-
ties, LLC (“LPF Properties”), a North Dakota limited
liability company with its principal place of business in
North Dakota, each own portions of the Property.
8. Plaintiff Hawkes Co., Inc, (“Hawkes”) is a
North Dakota corporation with its principal place of
business in North Dakota. Hawkes will pay royalties
to the owners of the Property in consideration of its
use of the Property to expand Hawkes’ existing nearby
peat mining operations to the Property.
9. All three plaintiffs are owned by the same four
or five members of the Pierce family, and Kevin Pierce
is an officer of all three plaintiffs and has been acting
on their behalf in these proceedings.
10. Defendant United States Army Corps of En-
gineers is a branch of the Department of the Army and
an agency of the United States.
LEGAL BACKGROUND
11. In 1972, Congress enacted the CWA to regu-
late “navigable waters.”
12. Section 301(a) of the CWA, 33 U.S.C. § 1311(a),
prohibits the unpermitted discharge of dredged and fill
material into “navigable waters.”
13. Section 502(7) of the CWA, id. § 1362(7), de-
fines “navigable waters” to mean the “waters of the
United States, including the territorial seas.”
10
14. Section 404 of the CWA, 33 U.S.C. § 1344,
authorizes the Secretary of the Army, through the
Corps, to issue permits for the discharge of dredged
and fill material into “navigable waters.”
15. By regulation, the Corps may determine
whether a particular parcel of property contains “wa-
ters of the United States” by issuing an Approved
Jurisdictional Determination (“JD”). 33 C.F.R.
§§ 320.1(a)(6), 331.2.
16. The Corps has promulgated regulations defin-
ing “waters of the United States.” Jd. § 328.
17. Under those regulations, navigable waters, in-
terstate waters, intrastate waters with uses that could
affect interstate or foreign commerce, impoundments
of waters, tributaries of waters, territorial seas, and
wetlands adjacent to other waters that are not them-
selves wetlands, are considered “waters of the United
States.” See id. § 328.3.
18. In 2001, the United States Supreme Court, in
Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v.
United States Army Corps of Engineers (“SWANCC”),
531 U.S. 159 (2001), held that isolated, intrastate,
non-navigable bodies of water are not “waters of the
United States.”
19. In response to the SWANCC opinion, the
Corps, along with the United States Environmental
Protection Agency (“EPA”), issued an Advance Notice
of Proposed Rulemaking on the Clean Water Act Reg-
ulatory Definition of “Waters of the United States,”
seeking comment on whether and how the agencies
should amend the definition of the term in order to
11
account for the Supreme Court’s decision. 68 Fed.
Reg. 1991 (Jan. 15, 2003).
20. The Corps did not follow through with the rule-
making.
21. Notwithstanding SWANCC, the Corps and
EPA continued to interpret their authority under the
CWA to extend to waterbodies and wetlands so long as
these features had at least a “hydrological connection”
to navigable-in-fact waterbodies. See, e.g. United
States v. Rapanos, 376 F.3d 629, 638 (6th Cir. 2004),
vacated, remanded by Rapanos v. United States, 547
U.S. 715 (2006).
22. In Rapanos v. United States, the Supreme
Court rejected the agencies’ hydrological connection
theory of CWA jurisdiction. See 547 U.S. at 739
(piurality opinion); id. at 780-82 (Kennedy, J., concur-
ring in the judgment).
23. In that decision, Justice Scalia authored a
plurality opinion, joined by three other Justices, which
concluded that the Corps’ jurisdiction over
non-navigable waters only extends to “relatively per-
manent, standing or continuously flowing bodies of
water” that are “connected to traditional interstate
navigable waters.” Jd. at 739, 742 (plurality opinion).
In addition, wetlands adjacent to such jurisdictional
waters will qualify as jurisdictional when “the wetland
has a continuous surface connection with that water,
making it difficult to determine where the ‘water’ ends
and the ‘wetland’ begins.” Jd. at 742.
24. Justice Kennedy concurred in the judgment
but adopted a broader interpretation of the Corps’ jur-
isdiction over non-navigable waters, finding them
12
jurisdictional if they “possess a ‘significant nexus’ to
waters that are or were navigable in fact or that could
reasonably be so made.” Rapanos, 547 U.S. at 759
(Kennedy, J., concurring in the judgment). Accord-
ing to Justice Kennedy, a significant nexus exists
where non-navigable waters, either alone or in combi-
nation with similarly situated waterbodies, “signifi-
cantly affect the chemical, physical, and biological in-
tegrity” of navigable-in-fact waters (also known as
“traditional navigable waters”). Jd. at 780. The
Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals recognizes both the
plurality opinion and Justice Kennedy’s significant
nexus test as supporting CWA jurisdiction over wet-
lands. United States v. Bailey, 571 F.3d 791 (8th Cir.
2009).
25. After Rapanos, the Corps, in conjunction with
EPA, issued a non-binding guidance document opining
on the scope of the agencies’ CWA jurisdiction. See
Clean Water Act Jurisdiction Following the U.S. Su-
preme Court’s Decision in Rapanos v. United States &
Carabell v. United States (Dec. 2, 2008). In that
guidance document, the Corps and EPA assert their
intention to exercise jurisdiction over “waters of the
United States” that satisfy either the Scalia “relatively
permanent” test or the Kennedy “significant nexus”
test.
26. In April, 2011, the Corps and EPA issued a new
draft guidance document, but it has not yet been final-
ized. See Draft Guidance on Identifying Waters Pro-
tected by the Clean Water Act (2011). In that guid-
ance document, the Corps and EPA state their inten-
tion to continue to assert jurisdiction over “waters of
the United States” that satisfy either the Scalia or the
13
Kennedy test. The document also notes the agencies’
intention to engage in APA rulemaking after finalizing
the new guidance.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
The Property
27. The Property contains peat and, as such, is
necessarily wetland. All peat mining occurs in wet-
lands because peat is only found in wetland environ-
ments. Thus peat mining is known as a “wetland de-
pendent” activity and, in Minnesota, peat mining and
wetland replacement and restoration associated with
peat mining are regulated under permits issued by the
Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.
28. The Plaintiffs’ Property is located over 120
river miles from the nearest traditional navigable
water (“TNW”), the Red River of the North.
29. There is no significant connection between
Plaintiffs’ Property and the Red River of the North
located 120 river miles away. There is no significant
e .emical, physical or biological impact on, or connec-
tion between, the wetlands on Plaintiffs’ Property and
the Red River of the North.
30. There is no continuous surface connection be-
tween wetlands on Plaintiffs’ Property and a water of
the United States, such that it is difficult to determine
whe~e the water ends and the wetland begins. A
farm, a separate, shallow ditch dug for farming pur-
poses in an area the Corps concedes is upland at the
border of the farm most distant from Plaintiffs’ Prop-
erty, and a sizable upland area are all located between
Plaintiffs’ Property and the area that the Corps claims
14
is a “relatively permanent water.” In other words,
the wetlands on Plaintiffs’ Property are easily distin-
guishable from any jurisdictional water.
31. The wetlands on Plaintiffs’ Property are not
“waters of the United States” and in the two years that
the Corps has had to establish that there is a signifi-
cant nexus between the Red River of the North and
Plaintiffs’ Property, there is no information in the
administrative record to support any such significant
nexus.
Administrative Proceedings Before the Corps and
Plaintiffs’ Exhaustion of their Administrative Remedies
32. Hawkes is in the business of mining and pro-
cessing peat. A portion of Hawkes’ business involves
the sale of peat meeting certain specifications to the
golf course industry for use in construction of greens.
In order to be suitable for the standards imposed by
the industry the peat must meet certain quality stand-
ards.
33. The Property has substantial amounts of high
quality peat that able to meet Hawkes’s requirements
for the next ten to fifteen years.
34. In October 2006, Pierce Investment obtained
an option to purchase the Property, subject to receiv-
ing approval to conduct peat mining operations on the
Property.
35. On March 20, 2007, Kevin Pierce, with Hawkes,
met initially with representatives of the Corps and
the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources
(“MDNR”). The discussion at this meeting focused
on potential roadblocks to the plan to mine peat on the
15
Property, including discussion of the Property's status
as a rich fen and a wetland.
36. On January 15, 2008, Mr. Pierce again met with
representatives of the Corps and the MDNR to review
plans to conduct peat mining on the Property.
37. At this meeting, Mr. Pierce, on behalf of
Hawkes, discussed with the Corps and MDNR repre-
sentatives the high quality of the peut available at the
Property and the importance to Hawkes’ business of
being able to mine peat on the Property. As Mr.
Pierce explained, the peat then available to Hawkes
provided approximately seven to ten years (as of Jan-
uury 2008) of future operations. Mr. Pierce also ex-
plained that, by expanding peat mining to the Proper-
ty, Hawkes would extend the lifespan of its peat min-
ing operation by ten to fifteen years.
38. On or about December 13, 2010, Huwkes ap-
plied for a permit from the Corps under Section 404 of
the CWA two expand its existing peat mining operations
to a portion of the Property.
39. As part of its permit application, Hawkes iden-
tified fifteen sites that it had evaluated as potential
alternatives to the Property. None of those sites pro-
vided a viable alternative to peat mining on the Prop-
erty.
40. In January 2011, Mr. Pierce again met with the
Corps and MDNR representatives. At that meeting,
Corps representatives spent the majority of time at-
tempting to persuade Mr. Pierce to abandon his plans
to mine peat on the Property. To that end, Corps
representatives emphasized the cost assuciated with
the permitting process, that there was no guurantee
16
that a permit would ever be granted, and that, even if a
permit were to be granted, the process would take
many years before it would be completed. Mr. Pierce
advised that he had an option to purchase the Property
and that he intended to proceed.
41. On or about March 15, 2011, the Corps issued a
letter to Hawkes indicating the Corps had made a
“preliminary determination that this wetland is a wa-
ter of the United States and is regulated by the Corps
under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act.” See Ex-
hibit A. The Corps’ letter went on to assert that “at a
minimum” an environmental assessment will be re-
quired.
42. Mr. Pierce again met with representatives of
the Corps and the MDNR on April 23, 2011. At that
meeting, one of the Corps representatives, Tamara
Cameron, expressed the opinion that the Property
would be completely and permanently destroyed if
peat were to be mined on the Property. Ms. Cameron
also stated that it could take years before a permit
would be granted and that the process would be very
costly.
43. On May 31 through June 3, 2011, representa-
tives of the Corps conducted a site visit of the Proper-
ty. At that time, a Hawkes employee told Steve Eg-
gers, from the Corps, how important expanding opera-
tions to the Property was to Hawkes’ ability to contin-
ue its business and how much he hoped that Hawkes
would be able to begin mining on the Property soon.
In response to these comments, Mr. Eggers suggested
to the employee that he should start looking for an-
other job, or words to that effect. Mr. Eggers has
previously been the subject of complaints on one or
17
more occasions regarding his over-zealous actions on
behalf of the Corps.
44. On or about August 25, 2011, the Corps sent
another letter to Hawkes with a list of nine additional
information items that would be needed in connection
with the permit application. These included hydro-
logical assessments of the wetland and of groundwater
flow spatially and vertically, functional resource as-
sessments including vegetation surveys, inventorying
and analyzing the quality of wetlands in the entire
watershed, evaluation of upstream potential impacts,
and more. See Exhibit B. The cost of performing all
of these requirements is anticipated to exceed One
Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000.00).
45. Faced with these overly burdensome demands
by the Corps and disagreeing with the Corps’ prelimi-
nary determination of jurisdiction, Plaintiffs requested
information on the basis for this determination.
46. On November 1, 2011, representatives of the
Corps met with the then owner of the Property. Al-
though Mr. Pierce had asked to be present in any
meeting between the Corps and the landowner, the
Corps chose to exclude him from this meeting. At the
meeting, the Corps representatives emphasized to the
landowner the harm that would result if peat mining
were to be permitted on the Property and insisted that
the landowner try to sell the Property to a wetlands
bank or to another party. The Corps made these
statements even though the Corps representatives
were aware that Mr. Pierce had obtained an option to
purchase the Property. The Corps also indicated that
there is a very good possibility that an Environmental
Impact Statement (“EIS”) will be required by the
18
Corps for the permit application. An EIS will delay
issuance of the permit for several years.
47. On November 8, 2011, the Corps provided
Plaintiffs with a copy of a “draft” Jurisdictional De-
termination (the “draft JD”) for the Property. The
draft JD reflected a conclusion that the Property was
connected by a Relatively Permanent Water (“RPW”)
—a series of culverts and unnamed streams which
flowed into the Middle River—to a TNW (the Red
River) and the Property was, therefore, subject to the
Corps’ jurisdiction under the CWA. The draft JD did
not determine that there was a significant nexus be-
tween the Property and any navigable waters.
48. On December 1, 2011, Corps representatives
conducted a site visit of the Property for the purpose
of making a jurisdictional determination.
49. By correspondence dated December 19, 2011,
Plaintiffs, through their wetland consultant, identified
numerous errors in the draft JD and provided the
Corps with additional information to be considered in
connection with its jurisdictional determination. This
information showed that there was, in fact, no RPW
that connected the Property to a TNW
50. On or about February 7, 2012, Defendant is-
sued an Approved Jurisdictional Determination (the
“Initial JD”), concluding that there was a significant
nexus between the Property and the Red River and
accordingly, the Property was a “water of the United
States” subject to the Corps’ jurisdiction under the
CWA.
51. On or about April 4, 2012, Plaintiffs filed a
timely appeal of the JD under 33 C.F.R. § 331.6 setting
19
forth the reasons why the Property is not a water of
the United States.
52. On or about April 23, 2012, the Regulatory
Appeals Review Officer sent Plaintiffs’ consultant a
letter indicating that the appeal was appropriate for
consideration by the administrative appeals program
and the Corps then provided the administrative record
to the Review Officer.
53. The parties presented their oral arguments
before the Review Officer on July 24, 2012, and an
Administrative Appeal Decision was issued on October
24, 2012, finding that the appeal had merit and that
the administrative record “[did] not contain sufficient
documentation/analysis to support a finding of Clean
Water Act jurisdiction.” See Exhibit C. In support
of that conclusion, the Administrative Appeal Decision
noted, among other things:
e “The [Administrative Record] does not con-
tain data supporting flow regime, volume,
duration, or frequency from the wetlands to
the river. Additionally, the District states
that indicators of the transport of energy,
materials, and nutrients were observed dur-
ing a site visit, but there is no quantitative
date [sic] given to support the finding.”
(footnote omitted)
e “While the [Administrative Record] provides
information indicating an OHW [i.e., “ordi-
nary high water”) mark for the unnamed
tributary exists, it does not provide suffi-
cient evidence to establish a significant nex-
us that the number of flow events, volume,
20
duration, and frequency of water flowing
through the tributary are such that it has an
appreciable effect on the TNW” (footnote
omitted)
e “The [Administrative Record] included a de-
scription of the stream channel riparian cor-
ridor from the unnamed tributary to the
TNW. However, the water flow regime in-
formation was not sufficient to indicate that
a significant nexus exists.” (footnote omit-
ted)
54. Following remand, on or about December 31,
2012, the Corps issued a revised JD (the “Revised JD”)
and advised that the Revised JD is a “final Corps per-
mit decision in accordance with 33 C.F.R. § 331.10.”
According to 33 C.F.R. § 331.21, Plaintiffs are consid-
ered to have exhausted their administrative remedies
when a final decision is made pursuant to 33 C.F.R.
§ 331.10.
55. The Revised JD does not contain any new in-
formation to support a significant nexus between the
Property and the Red River of the North. However,
the Revised JD still purportedly relies on Justice
Kennedy’s “significant nexus” test to assert jurisdic-
tion over the Property, which is described by the Re-
vised JD as a “Non-Relatively Permanent [Water] that
flow[s] directly or indirectly into [a] Traditional Navi-
gable [Water].”
56. The Revised JD does not add any new infor-
mation that would demonstrate how Plaintiffs’ land, ei-
ther quantitatively or qualitatively, significantly af-
fects the physical, biological, and chemical integrity of
21
the Red River of the North located 120 river miles
from the property. Even though the Corps has had
two years to establish jurisdiction, its Revised JD, like
the Initial JD, speaks only to the overall functions
provided by wetlands in general and stream headwa-
ters in general and, as the Review Officer found, it
does “not speak to how the specific onsite wetland and
tributaries have a significant nexus that is more than
speculative or insubstantial on the chemical, physical
or biological integrity of the downstream TNW ”
57. Any further efforts to obtain a permit to con-
duct peat mining on the Property would be futile, ei-
ther because the Corps has already decided that it will
not issue a permit or because the delay and expense of
finally obtaining a permit would substantially impede,
if not prevent, Hawkes from proceeding with its plans
to mine peat on the Property.
Applicable Tests for Exercise of
Jurisdiction Under the CWA
58. The controlling tests for defining “waters of
the United States” are Justice Scalia’s plurality opin-
ion in Rapanos v. United States and Justice Kennedy’s
significant nexus test.
59. The Revised JD does not meet either applica-
ble test for assertion of jurisdiction under the CWA.
60. First, the Revised JD does not meet Justice
Sealia’s “relatively permanent” test because there is
no substantial evidence that Property contains any
“relatively permanent, standing or continuously flow-
ing bod[y] of water” that is connected to a jurisdic-
tional water such that one cannot distinguish tell
where the wetlands on Plaintiffs’ Property end and the
22
alleged jurisdictional water begins. Rapanos, 547
U.S. at 739 (plurality opinion). Upland area clearly
separates the two locations.
61. Second, the Revised JD does not meet Justice
Kennedy’s “significant nexus” test. No substantial
evidence supports the Revised JD’s conclusion that a
significant nexus exists between the Property and the
Red River of the North. The Revised JD does not es-
tablish a significant nexus because there is no new
evidence in the Revised JD to determine the qualita-
tive or quantitative effect on the Red River of the
North. Such evidence is necessary to distinguish
between a jurisdictional significant nexus and a non-
jurisdictional insignificant nexus as indicated by the
Corps’ own Review Officer.
62. Since no substantial evidence exists to support
the Revised JD’s conclusion that a significant nexus
exists between the Property and the Red River of the
North, the JD impermissibly assumes, contrary to
Justice Kennedy’s concurring opinion in Rapanos, that
a non-speculative effect is necessarily a significant
effect.
Plaintiffs’ Property is not subject to the CWA be-
cause it does not contain any “waters of the United
States.” Therefore, the Revised JD is arbitrary and
capricious, contrary to law, and unsupported by sub-
stantial evidence. See 5 U.S.C.§ 706(2).
23
FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF—
INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
63. Plaintiffs hereby reallege and incorporate by
reference the allegations contained in all preceding
paragraphs as though fully set forth herein.
64. Plaintiffs wish to conduct their business activi-
ties on the Property that the Corps wrongfully claims
to be subject to its CWA permitting authority.
65. Plaintiffs are and will continue to be directly
affected and injured by the Corps’ expansive and un-
lawful assertion of CWA jurisdiction over their Prop-
erty.
66. The Corps’ Revised JD imposes significant in-
jury on Plaintiffs by preventing them from using their
Property as they wish without risking an enforcement
proceeding, fines, and penalties. The Corps’ Revised
JD also imposes on Plaintiffs the illegal, burdensome,
and expensive requirement that they obtain a Section
404 CWA permit in order to conduct their peat mining
activities. As aresult, Plaintiffs’ use of their property
has been, is being—and unless the Court grants relief
—will continue to be adversely affected. Hence, the
Corps’ unlawful exercise of jurisdiction causes Plaintiff
irreparable injury.
67. Setting aside the Corps’ Revised JD will re-
dress Plaintiffs’ injuries by allowing Plaintiffs to use
their property.
68. Plaintiffs have no plain, speedy, and adequate
remedy at law. Absent judicial intervention, Plaintiff
will continue to suffer irreparable injury.
24
69. The Corps’ Revised JD is a final agency action
subject to judicial review under the APA. See 5
U.S.C. § 702; 33 C.F.R. § 320.1(a)(6).
70. Accordingly, injunctive relief enjoining the
Corps from exercising jurisdiction under the CWA is
appropriate.
SECOND CLAIM FOR RELIEF—DECLARATORY
JUDGMENT
71. Plaintiffs hereby reallege and incorporate by
reference the allegations contained in all preceding
paragraphs as though fully set forth herein.
72. An actual and substantial controversy exists
between Plaintiffs and the Corps over the Corps’ fail-
ure to comply with the CWA in determining that
Plaintiffs’ Property contains a jurisdictional water-
body.
73. Plaintiffs contend that their Property contains
no jurisdictional waterbodies, whereas the Corps,
through its Revised JD, contends that it does. The
Corps has had two years to develop information sup-
porting its allegations of jurisdiction, there is a com-
plete administrative record on which the Revised JD
was made, and any further administrative proceedings
before the Corps would be futile. Therefore, no fur-
ther factual development is necessary to resolve the
legal issues raised by this action.
74. The Corps’ Revised JD is a final agency action
subject to judicial review under the APA. See 5
U.S.C. § 702; 33 C.F.R. §§ 320.1(a)(6) & 331.21.
25
75. The case -is currently justiciable because the
Corps has unlawfully asserted jurisdiction over Plain-
tiffs’ Property.
76. Plaintiffs are currently and continuously in-
jured by the Corps’ unlawful exercise of jurisdiction
because the existence of the Revised JD decreases the
value of their Property and prevents them from exer-
cising their livelihood on their Property.
77. Plaintiffs are currently and continuously in-
jured by the Corps’ unlawful exercise of jurisdiction
because they cannot conduct peat mining on their
property without fear of an enforcement action being
brought against them. The Revised JD increases the
likelihood that Plaintiffs will be subject to an enforce-
ment action should they initiate these activities. Fur-
ther, the Revised JD increases Plaintiffs’ potential
civil and criminal liability should they initiate these
activities.
78. Plaintiffs are currently and continuously in-
jured by the Revised JD because it obligates them to
go through the time consuming and expensive process
of obtaining a Section 404 permit from the Corps be-
fore conducting their proposed activities, and the
Corps has informed Plaintiffs in its correspondence of
the substantial and expensive area wide research pro-
jects that it would require of Plaintiffs’ in an effort to
obtain a Section 404 permit from the Corps.
79. Plaintiffs are, therefore, entitled to a declara-
tory judgment declaring that the Revised JD is invalid
and that the Corps does not have jurisdiction over the
Property pursuant to the CWA.
26
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
Wherefore, Plaintiffs pray for judgment as follows:
1. A declaration that Plaintiffs’ Property is not
subject to the CWA;
2. A declaration that Defendant’s Revised Ap-
proved Jurisdictional Determination is invalid;
3. An injunction enjoining Defendant from exer-
cising jurisdiction over Plaintiffs’ Property;
4. An award of attorney’s fees, to the extent al-
lowed by law pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2412(d)(1)(A),
together with expenses, and costs; and,
5. For any such other and further relief that the
Court deems proper under the circumstances of this
case.
DATED: Mar. 13, 2013.
Respectfully submitted,
GRAY, PLANT, MOOTY,
MOOTY & BENNETT, PA.
By /s/ GREGORY R. MERZ
GREGORY R. MERZ (185942)
Nancy Quattlebaum Burke (161044)
500 IDS Center
80 South Eighth Street
Minneapolis, MN 55402
(612) 632-3257 / 3029
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
27
[SEAL OMITTED]
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
ST. PAUL DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
180 FIFTH STREET EAST, SUITE 700
ST. PAUL MINNESOTA 55101-1678
Mar. 15, 2011
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF
Operations
Regulatory (2007-01914-LSP)
Kevin Pierce, Vice President
Hawkes Peat Company, Inc.
P.O. Box 14111
Grand Forks, North Dakota 58208
Dear Mr. Pierce;
The St. Paul District, Corps of Engineers (Corps) is
in receipt of a permit application from Hawkes Peat
Company regarding a proposal to expand a peat min-
ing operation at the company’s Mercil Site. The pro-
ject is located in the SW \%, and S %, and the NW %,
Sec. 13, T. 157N., R.44W Marshall County, Minnesota.
The proposed project will involve the expansion of
the current peat mining operation near Newfolden,
Minnesota by approximately 150 acres. The project
will involve the construction of drainage ditches, re-
moval and stockpiling of topsoil overburden, mining of
peat over an approximately 20 year time frame and
restoration of the site at the cessation of the mining
operation.
28
The Corps has made a preliminary determination
that this wetland is a water of the United States and is
regulated by the Corps under Section 404 of the Clean
Water Act. The activity as proposed would require
Department of the Army authorization under Section
404.
The Corps’ evaluation of a Section 404 permit
application involves multiple analyses, including
(1) evaluating the proposal’s impacts in accordance
with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
(33 CFR part 325), (2) determining whether the pro-
posal is contrary to the public interest (33 CFR
§ 320.4), (3) determining whether the proposal com-
plies with the Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines (Guidelines)
(40 CFR part 230). Information about the Corps
permitting process can be obtained online at
The processing of a standard individual permit for
the proposed peat mine will, at a minimum, require an
environmental assessment (EA) to satisfy the re-
quirements of NEPA. An EA is used to determine
whether an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)
must be prepared to disclose and evaluate the impacts
of your proposal. There are two possible outcomes
from an EA: a finding of no significant impact
(FONSI) or a determination that an EIS will be re-
quired. Due to the nature of the proposed site (rich
fen), the Corps would like to meet with you to discuss
the federal requirements for preparation of environ-
mental documents.
It is our understanding that this project exceeds the
state threshold for a mandatory Environmental As-
29
sessment Worksheet (EAW) and may require the prep-
aration of a state EIS. Therefore, to allow for timely
joint review by both state and federal agencies, we
recommend that your environmental document ad-
dress the requirements of both state and federal pro-
grams.
We would like to meet with you at your earliest con-
venience, so that we may discuss with you the infor-
mation we will need to review your proposal and reach
a permit decision. We would also like to coordinate
with the State of Minnesota so that both agencies
could be represented at the meeting.
Because the proposal involves several state and
federal agencies located in St. Paul, this may be the
most efficient location for a meeting. If you need ad-
ditional information or would like to discuss this pro-
ject further, please contact Larry Puchalski at 218-
444-6381, the Corps’ project manager for the County in
which this proposal is located.
30
Sincerely,
/s/ [ILLEGIBLE]
for Tamara E. Cameron
Chief, Regulatory Branch
Cf:
Kurt Johnson, NRRI
Steve Hofstad, BWSR
Danny Thorstad, Marshall County SWCD
Garry Bennett, MnDNR Waters, Thief River Falls
Julie Jordan, MnDNR Lands and Minerals, Hibbing
Nathan Kestner, MnDNR Region 1 Environmental
Review, Bemidji
Steve Colvin, Unit Director, MnDNR Environmental
Review
Randall Doneen, MnDNR Environmental Review Op-
erations Lead, St. Paul
Jennifer Engstrom, MnDNR Mineland Reclamation
Manager, St. Paul
Jill Clancy, Corps of Engineers, St. Paul
Steve Eggers, Corps of Engineers, St. Paul
31
[SEAL OMITTED]
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
ST. PAUL DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
180 FIFTH STREET EAST, SUITE 700
ST. PAUL MINNESOTA 55101-1678
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF
Operations
Regulatory (2007-01914-DJS)
Aug. 25, 2011
Mr. Kevin Pierce
Hawkes Peat Company Inc.
P.O. Box 14111
Grand Forks, North Dakota
Dear Mr. Pierce:
This letter is in regard to the permit application you
submitted on behalf of Hawkes Peat Company Inc., for
your proposed peat mining expansion proposal at the
Mercil Property Site. The project location is in Sec-
tion 13, T. 157N., R. 44W., Marshall County, Minnesota.
In order for the Corps to issue a Public Notice (PN)
for your proposed project, our regulations require that
specific information be submitted for it to be a com-
plete application. Items generally necessary for a
complete application are listed in 33CFR 325.1. A
public notice is the primary method by which the
Corps advises interested parties and commenting
agencies of the proposed activity. The notice must
include information sufficient to explain the nature of
the activity and the probable impact on the public
32
interest. Depending on the scale and magnitude of
the proposed project, information sufficient to gener-
ate meaningful comment may vary with each proposal.
Based on the proposal and comments received, addi-
tional resources assessments/studies or analyses eval-
uating the site or nature of the activity and magnitude
of the impacts/effects, individually and cumulatively,
may be required during the permit review process.
One specific area of information that is required in-
cludes the amount of wetland/waters of the U.S. im-
pacted by filling or dredging and the proposed com-
pensatory mitigation for those impacts. Based on the
results of our site visit on June 1, 2011, the wetland
determination and general wetland impact assessment
you submitted in your application is not sufficient to
depict the actual extent, location and type of wetlands
at the site and thus, determine the impacts that may
result from your proposed project.
During our site visit, we observed additional wet-
land areas on the parcel that were not included in your
wetland determination. The determination submitted
in your application utilized the National Wetland In-
ventory (NWI). The NWI has limited accuracy in
several parts of northern Minnesota. Therefore, a
wetland delineation completed in accordance with the
1987 Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual
and appropriate Regional Supplement (Great Plains
Region) is required.
An understanding of the amount, type and location
of wetlands on the project site and an accurate impact
assessment is fundamental to our review. Based on
the results of the delineation, the overall impacts to
33
aquatic resources may be greater than the 150 acres
identified in your application. The areas of proposed
roads, sedimentation basins, drainage ditches and
stock piles must also be evaluated for the presence of
wetlands. The impact assessment should include the
amount of types of wetland impacts of the project
including all direct impacts, temporary and permanent
(e.g., direct fill and excavation); and all indirect tem-
porary and permanent impacts (e.g., lateral effect as a
result of ditching and wetland conversion). Upon re-
ceipt of this information, we should be able to issue a
public notice of your permit application, in accordance
with our regulations, inviting public and resource
agency comment on your proposal, which would in-
clude the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and
the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
The following additional information is needed to
facilitate our analysis of the potential effects of your
proposed project:
1. The depth of peat across the site; the proposed
depth of mining and the peat reserves proposed
to be left in place at the end of the operation;
2. A hydrogeologic assessment of the rich fen sys-
tem including the mineral/nutrient composition
and pH of the groundwater; groundwater flow
spatially and vertically; discharge and recharg-
es areas;
3. A functional/resource assessment of the site in-
cluding a vegetation survey and identification of
native fen plant communities across the site;
and
34
4. An inventory of similar wetlands in the general
area(watershed), including some analysis of
their quality—to provide some assessment of
the extent of the loss of the specified amount
and quality of rich fen community relative to the
overall amount and quality of that resource in
the area (watershed).
5. An inventory of rich fen plant communities that
are within sites of High and Outstanding Biodi-
versity Significance in the area (watershed).
6. Information on potential impacts to unmined
upstream portions of this rich fen (i.e. state land
to the west) through disruption of groundwater
flow, lowering of the water tables, and changes
in surface runoff.
7. Details of the proposed road construction and
removal and/or mitigation upon closure of the
operation.
8. Information on the planned site reclamation as
described in your application related to the
amount of peat that will be removed from the
site due to mining and the anticipated wetland
community that will result. Please discuss how
this wetland community would replace the func-
tions lost from the existing fen ecosystem.
9. To facilitate our review of your mitigation pro-
posal, please provide us with any examples of
successful restorations to a fen community with
a similar level of quality.
As discussed with you in March 2011, in order for
the Corps to reach a permit decision, the Corps must
complete multiple analyses which includes evaluating
35
the probable impacts of the project in accordance with
the National Environmental Policy Act; demonstrating
compliance with the Section 404(b)(1) guidelines (al-
ternatives, avoidance and minimization, compensatory
mitigation); evaluating the impacts of the activity on
the public interest; and demonstrating compliance with
other applicable laws, such as the National Historic
Preservation Act and the Endangered Species Act.
The Corps would like to meet with you and your
agent or consultant to further discuss your alterna-
tives analysis, proposed mitigation and the level of
analysis required to comply with the National Envi-
ronmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Section 404 of the
Clean Water Act (CWA). We also recommend coordi-
nating this meeting with the State of Minnesota, so
that both federal and state agencies can be represent-
ed at the meeting. Please contact Mr. Dan Seemon in
our St. Paul office at (651) 290-5380. In any corre-
spondence or inquiries, please refer to the Regulatory
number shown above.
36
Sincerely,
/s/ LLLLEGIBLE]
for Tamara E. Cameron
Chief, Regulatory Branch
Copy furnished:
Kurt Johnson, NRRI
Danny Thorstad, Marshall County SWCD
Garry Bennett, MnDNR Waters, Thief River Falls
Julie Jordan, MnDNR Lands and Minerals, Hibbing
Nathan Kestner, MnDNR Region 1 Environmental
Review, Bemidji
Steve Colvin, Unit Director, MnDNR Environmental
Review
Randall Doneen, MnDNR Environmental 1 Review
Operations Lead, St. Paul
Jennifer Engstrom, MnDNR Mineland Reclamation
Manager, St. Paul
Steve Eggers, Corps of Engineers, St. Paul
37
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL DECISION
HAWKES PEAT COMPANY, INC.
JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION
FILE NO. MVP 2007-01914-DJS,
ST. PAUL DISTRICT
Oct. 24, 2012
Review Officer(s): Mr. Mike Vissichelli, U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers, North Atlantic Division (Lead)
Ms. Tonya Acuff. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers,
Mississippi Valley Division
Appellant/Applicant: Mr. Kevin Pierce, Marshall
County, Minnesota
Authority: Section 404 of the Clean Water Act
Receipt of Request for Appeal: 6 April 2012
Date of Acceptance of Request for Appeal: 23 April
2012
Approved JD Appeal Conference Call: 24 July 2012
Summary of Appeal Decision: I find that one of Mr.
Pierce’s reasons for appeal have merit. There is in-
sufficient documentation in the record to support the
finding that the wetland on Mr. Pierce’s property,
along with other similarly situated wetlands adjacent
to the tributary, has a significant (more than insub-
stantial or speculative) effect on the chemical, physical,
and biological integrity of the Red River of the North.
The administrative record does not support the Dis-
trict’s determination that a significant nexus exists
between the subject property wetlands and the tradi-
tional navigable water, Red River of the North. The
38
remaining reasons for appeal have been determined
not to have merit.
Background Information:
Mr. Pierce (appellant) is challenging the assertion by
St. Paul District, MVP (the “District”), that the U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers has jurisdiction over his
property. In particular, he alleges that a significant
nexus does not exist between the 155 acres of wetlands
on his property and the Red River of the North, a
navigable water of the United States. The property
(known as the Mercil Site) is located in Section 13,
Township 157 North, Range 44 West, near Newfolden,
Marshall County, Minnesota.
The District contends that the onsite wetlands are
adjacent to a non-Relatively Permanent Water (RPW)
that flows directly or indirectly into a traditional nav-
igable waterway (TNW) which is the Red River of the
North.
The District claims jurisdiction over the wetlands via
significant nexus to the downstream TNW.
Mr. Pierce’s consultant, Mr. Brian Ross with Widseth,
Smith, Nolting & Associates (WSN), provided infor-
mation in December 2010 to the St. Paul District to
establish the lack of Corps jurisdiction of the site’s
wetlands based on the no hydrologic connectivity to a
navigable water of the U.S. There is no question that
the site contains wetlands: the appellant is arguing
that the wetlands are isolated and therefore, not regu-
lated. The approved jurisdictional determination
(AJD) sent to the appellant on 7 February 2012, did
not identify the limits of Corps jurisdiction on the site.
39
The consultant stated that if the site is determined to
be jurisdictional, they would furnish a wetland deline-
ation for Corps review at a later date.
Information Received During the Appeal and its Dispo-
sition:
1. The District provided a copy of the administrative
record (AR), which was reviewed and considered in
this request for appeal. The AR was provided on 3
May 2012.
2. The appellant’s agent provided clarifying infor-
mation at the time of the submittal of the RFA.
3. The District provided additional clarifying infor-
mation via email dated 17 September 2012, regarding
procedures used to calculate the drainage basin size at
the request of the RO.
Evaluation of the Reason for Appeal/Appeal Decision
Findings:
APPEAL REASON #1: There is no basis for jurisdic-
tion because the expansion area wetland’ is not adja-
cent to the ditch or the non-Relatively Permanent
Water. ‘
FINDING: This reason for appeal does not have mer-
it.
ACTION: No action required.
DISCUSSION: The appellant states in the RFA that
“The Corps must show a substantial nexus to the Red
River of the North. In order to do so, the Corps must
' This refers to the project area which is a 155-acre expansion of
the ongoing peat mining operation.
40
first connect the river to the expansion area wetland
by showing that the expansion area wetland is ‘adja-
cent’ to a jurisdictional water” It further states that
“there is no wetland adjacent to a ‘tributary’ or other
jurisdictional water here that would allow for the as-
sertion of jurisdiction.” Additionally, if the expansion
area wetland is to be jurisdictional, it must mean that a
jurisdictional water is ‘neighboring’ the expansion
”
area
The District staff (William Baer and Craig Jarnot)
made a site visit on 1 December, 2011* to the property
of Mr. Jon Hirst who owns the property southeast of
the expansion area. The District observed a non-
jurisdictional, man-made ditch located along the north-
ern border of the property (and adjacent to the larger
wetland complex). Water flow is described as travel-
ing through the excavated ditch and through the
pasture/hayfield. The water then flows into a natural,
meandering channel to the Middle River. The Dis-
trict notes that there were ordinary high water (OHW)
indicators within the natural channel reach. The indi-
cators were natural lines impressed upon the bank,
shelving, changes in the character of the soil, sediment
sorting, leaf litter disturbed or washed away, scour,
deposition, bed and banks, and changes in the plant
community. The rationale for the District’s findings
that the natural channel contained a definable OHW
indicator in accordance with Regulatory Guidance
letter (RGL) 05-05* is supported in the AR. Accord-
® AR page COE000068
* Regulatory Guidance Letter No. 05-05, Subject: Ordinary
High Water Mark (OHWM), 7 December 2005
41
ing to the AR, OHW indicators were found in the man-
made ditch (matted down, bent, or absent vegetation
within the majority of the ditch). However, the AR
also noted that it was difficult to tell if this was due to
water movement, or wildlife grazing/travel activity.
The expansion area wetland is part of a contiguous, ap-
proximately 591l-acre complex of wetlands within the
Snake River drainage area, HUC 0902309, as demar-
cated by the United States Geological Service (USGS).
The District is asserting jurisdiction over the expan-
sion area via adjacency to non-RPW located along the
southern border of the wetland complex. In the Sec-
tion II.B.1.(a) of the JD form, the District identifies
the wetlands as being “adjacent to non-RPWs that flow
directly or indirectly into TNWs”
For CWA purposes, the term “adjacent” means bor-
dering, contiguous, or neighboring as stated in 33
C.F-R. 328.3(c). Revised Rapanos guidance, released
on December 2, 2008‘, further addresses the definition
of adjacency, stating that:
* On June 5, 2007, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Agencies) issued joint agency
guidance regarding Clean Water Act (CWA) jurisdiction following
the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in the consolidated cases Ra-
panos v. United States and Carabell v. United States (“Rapanos”).
In response to comments received, the agencies provided revised
guidance on December 2, 2008 (Revised Guidance), which remains
the most current and in effect. It ~~ d be eetvenses at: huinu
e pa.go lReatadl ures! CW AGuL A | CEA OF Following
_Rapanos120208. pdf.
42
[T)he agencies consider wetlands adjacent if one of
the following three criteria are satisfied. First,
there is unbroken surface or shallow sub-surface
connection to jurisdictional waters. Second, they
are physically separated from jurisdictional waters
by man-made barriers, natural rivers berms, beach
dunes and the like, Or third, their proximity to a ju-
risdictional water is reasonably close, supporting
the science-based inference that such wetlands have
an ecological interconnection with jurisdictional
waters.
The District determined that the project area is part of
a larger complex, of which, a portion is adjacent to a
drainage ditch and flows ultimately to the Red River of
the North. The District indicated current drainage
on the site flowed through the man-made ditch,
through the natural stream channel, to the Middle
River, and then to the Red River of the North, a
TNW’ While the man-made ditch along the southern
border of the wetland is not jurisdictional, it provides a
discrete hydrologic connection from the wetland to the
Red River. Using a non-jurisdictional ditch to estab-
lish adjacency to a TNW is supported by the Revised
2008 Guidance‘, which states:
“Ditches (including roadside ditches) excavated
wholly in and draining only upiands and that do not
carry a relatively permanent flow of water are gen-
erally not waters of the United States because they
are not tributaries or they do not have a significant
nexus to downstream traditional navigable waters.
® Support for flow rationale is found in AR Pgs COE000020-22
[Figs 2, 3, and 4}; AR pg COE000142 [site visit)
43
Even when not jurisdictional waters subject to
CWA § 404, these geographic features (e.g., swales,
ditches) may still contribute to a surface hydrologic
connection between an adjacent wetland and a tra-
ditional navigable water.”
This reason for appeal does not have merit because
the District supported in the AR the rationale, in
accordance with applicable law, regulation, and pol-
icy, for stating that the expansion area wetlands are
adjacent to the man-made ditch and non-RPW.
APPEAL REASON #2: The Corps mapped the incor-
rect drainage area for the expansion.
FINDING: This reason for appeal does not have mer-
it.
ACTION: No action required.
DISCUSSION: The appellant states in the RFA that
“The Corps has incorrectly mapped the drainage area
to overestimate the relevant reach and overstate its
claim of any nexus to the Red River of the North.
Figure 4 of the JD shows a much more inclusive drain-
age area for the ravine than actually exists.” The
appellant states that “furthermore, our analysis of the
light detection and ranging (LiDAR) data shows a
drainage divide at the north of the main expansion
area wetland basin. The LiDAR data shows a north-
west to southwest trending trough highlighted by the
1140 contours just north of the drainage divide.
North of the drainage divide, there are surface water
channels within the wetlands that carry the water to
the southeast.” The appellant states in the RFA that
the drainage area is 551 acres, which is less than the 1
44
square mile needed to meet the District’s definition of
tributary “seasonal flow”
In Section III.B.1.i of the JD Form’, the District iden-
tified the drainage area as 2.4 square miles (or 1536
acres) and located within Hydrologic Unit Code (HUC)
09020309, as noted on AR COE000005.
The Corps mapped the drainage area using various
hydrology database tools within ArcToolbox and also
LiDAR data available’
This reason does not have merit because the District
supported in the AR the rationale and methods used in
determining the drainage basin for the project area.
The District used best available information in the de-
termination of the project area’s drainage basin.
While the appellant stated the drainage area is incor-
rect, the District supported their methods of using
LiDAR and associated program tools to calculate the
drainage area.
APPEAL REASON #3: The “relevant reach” is not a
tributary or other jurisdictional water.
FINDING: This reason for appeal does not have mer-
it.
ACTION: No action required.
* AR page COE000006
’ Per a clarifying email to the Review Officer dated 17 September
2012, Tim Smith, Regulatory project manager, described the drain-
age basin mapping techniques used by the Corps in determining
the project drainage area.
45
DISCUSSION: The appellant states in the RFA that
“the Corps identifies a ‘tributary”’ of the Middle River
that is allegedly part of a relevant reach, but nothing
in that location meets the definition of a tributary.
Rather, a grassed swale leads to an erosional] ravine
that incises the upland plain area.”
According to the Guidebook’, “A tributary, as defined
here, is a natural, man-altered, or man-made water
body that carries flow directly or indirectly into a
TNW”
Both the Guidebook and the Revised 2008 Guidance
state that “A tributary is the entire reach of the stream
that is of the same order (ie, from the point of conflu-
ence, where two lower order streams meet to form the
tributary, downtream to the point such tributary en-
ters a higher order stream.)”
The AR identified the relevant reach on a map labeled
Figure 4° The map depicts jurisdiction being asser-
ted through the 1,518 linear-foot natural, unnamed
tributary which flows into the Middle River. The
Middle River ultimately flows into the Red River of
the North (TNW). The relevant reach is described in
* AR page COE000022
* The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Jurisdictional Determina-
tion Form Instructional Guidebook is used as the U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers Regulatory Program Standard Operating
Procedures for conducting an approved jurisdictional determina-
tion evaluation and the documenting practices to support an ap-
proved jurisdictional determination. 2007 version, Page 40.
° AR page COE000022
46
the AR" as the confluence of two first order streams
which enter the Middle River (a second order stream).
In Section III.B.1.(ii)(c) of the JD form, the District
documented the natural tributary used for establishing
relevant reach as having both a bed and bank, and
OHW indicators which included the features of clear,
natural impressed lines on the bank, changes in the
character of soil, shelving, leaf litter disturbed or
washed away, sediment sorting, and abrupt change in
plant community.
This reason for appeal does not have merit because the
District supported in the AR the rationale for the iden-
tification of the relevant reach used for jurisdiction in
accordance with the Regulations.
APPEAL REASON #4: In the RFA, the appellant
alleges that a significant nexus does not exist between
the expansion area wetland and the Red River of the
North. The following are several specific reasons for
appeal relating to the District’s determination:
APPEAL REASON 4a): There is no significant chem-
ical connection to support nexus to TNW.
FINDING: This reason for appeal has merit.
ACTION: Upon remand, the District shall reconsider
the JD and provide sufficient documentation of a sig-
nificant nexus on the wetlands, including an analysis of
whether the wetlands have more than a speculative or
insubstantial effect on the chemical integrity of the
nearest traditional navigable water (TNW), the Red
River of the North. In doing so, the District shall
" AR page COE000016
47
document the hydrologic, ecologic, and other functions
performed by the tributary and all of its adjacent
wetlands. Specifically, the District will document the
volume, duration, and frequency of water flow from the
wetlands to the TNW.
DISCUSSION: The appellant stated in the RFA that
“the District provides no measureable or quantitative
data on how the expansion area wetlands would affect
the Red River of the North. The Corps only talks in
generalities about the functions of headwater streams
and their importance for nutrient transformation”
In the AR”, the District described the stream chemical
properties as follows:
“(Sjurface flows were not observed in the tributary
by the Corps staff. The contributing area to the
tributary is predominantly comprised of open space
with limited agricultural usage (row crops and hay)
and residential dwellings. Water quality has not
been formally assessed by the MPCA but is ex-
pected to be good based on adjacent land uses,
amounts of wetlands in the area, and buffers from
the tributary.”
The District states in the additional significant nexus
information” that “there is no water quality data for
the unnamed tributary. However, general inferences
about potential pollutants can be made by evaluating
the land use within, and upstream of, the drainage area
of the relevant reach. The contributing area to the
tributary is predominantly comprised of open spaces
% AR page COE000008
* AR page COE000016
48
with limited agricultural usage (row crops and hay)
and residential dwellings. In general, areas with lim-
ited impervious and agricultural use have a better
water quality and are less likely to have water quality
impairment. As a result, the discharges from the
relevant reach would be viewed as having a beneficial
effect on the downstream TNW.”
The 2008 Guidance states “ agencies will con-
sider other relevant factors, including the functions
performed by the tributary together with the wet-
lands, and any adjacent wetlands, which affect down-
stream traditional navigable waters, such as the ca-
pacity to transfer nutrients and organic carbon vital to
support downstream food webs (e.g., macroinverte-
brates present in headwater streams convert carbon in
leaf litter making it available to species downstream)
”
The AR does not contain data supporting flow regime,
volume, duration, or frequency from the wetlands to
the river. Additionally, the District states that
indicators of the transport of energy, materials, and
nutrients were observed during a site visit, but there is
no quantitative date given to support the finding.
The District’s use of the word “suggest”, and “rea-
sonable to conclude” in their descriptions of ground
water influence on tributary flow implies speculation.
There were no specific facts documented that could
verify these assertions.
“ AR page COE000016
49
APPEAL REASON 4(b): There is no significant phys-
ical connection to support nexus to TNW.
FINDING: This reason for appeal has merit.
ACTION: Upon remand, the District shall reconsider
the JD and provide sufficient documentation of a sig-
nificant nexus on the wetlands, including an analysis of
whether the wetlands have more than a speculative or
insubstantial effect on the physical integrity of the
nearest traditional navigable water (TNW), the Red
River of the North. In doing so, the District shall
document the hydrologic functions performed by the
tributary and all of its adjacent wetlands. Specifical-
ly, the District will document the number of flow
events per year, volume, duration, and frequency of
flow events from the wetlands to the TNW.
DISCUSSION: The appellant stated in the RFA that
“the physical connection between the expansion area
wetland, and any wetlands in the relevant reach to the
Red River of the North, is insignificant because the
drainage area is small and outflow is limited by the
basin orientation.” The RFA further states that
there is little to no runoff of water from the wetlands
to the TNW, therefore there is no significant physical
connection of runoff reaching the river.
The District identified a 155-acre forested wetland on
the appellant’s property, and determined that this
wetland area is part of a larger wetland complex that is
adjacent to an unnamed, non-RPW tributary. Per the
50
Rapanos guidance, a wetland adjacent to a non-RPW
requires a significant nexus evaluation”
The 155-acre wetland in question is located within
a larger 550-acre wetland complex. The complex
wetlands are adjacent to a 448 linear-foot, non-
jurisdictional drainage feature that flows approxi-
mately 512 feet into an unnamed tributary of the Mid-
dle River for 1518 linear feet, into the Middle River
which then flows into the Red River of the North.
Ultimately, the water flows through two tributaries,
and 30 or more miles, before entering the TNW.
The AR included documentation regarding precipita-
tion amounts, snowfall amounts, watershed size, drain-
age area, and estimated acre-feet of water storage
within the wetlands, but did not contain any esti-
mated flow events per year. The unnamed tributary
was determined by the District to have a bed and bank
and an OHW indicator in accordance with RGL 05-05°
In regards to the “physical” nexus with the down-
stream TNW, the District described stream surface
flow as follows:
‘© In his concurring opinion in Rapanos, Justice Kennedy con-
cluded that wetlands are waters of the United States “if the wet-
lands, either alone or in combination with similarly situated lands
in the region, significantly affect the chemical, physical and biolog-
ical integrity of other covered waters more readily understood as
‘navigable’” According to the Rapanos guidance, similarly situ-
ated wetlands include all wetlands adjacent to the same tributary,
thus in this case, all wetlands adjacent to the man-made ditch must
be included in the significant nexus evaluation.
© AR page COE000023
51
“The District was only able to observe the tributary
once on December 1, 2011. At that time, there was
no surface flow in the channel but pools were ob-
served sporadically throughout its length. These
observations were made at a severe drought in this
portion of Minnesota and suggest that there is a
groundwater component to the flow in the channel.
To further evaluate flow in the tributary the Dis-
trict utilized its seasonal stream evaluation proto-
col. In general, tributaries that have drainage ar-
eas in excess of one square mile typically meet the
agency’s definition of seasonal flow (continuous flow
for at least three months). The drainage area for
the unnamed tributary was determined to be 2.4
square miles or almost 2.5 times the threshold iden-
tified during the District’s assessment of flow dura-
tion on first and second order tributaries. Given
this information, it is reasonable to conclude that
the tributary has seasonal flow between ice out
and mid-June. Flow may persist longer in years
with normal precipitation of groundwater discharge
is supplying flow to the tributary. However, addi-
tional site investigations would be required to con-
firm this contribution”
Additional tributary flow information was provided in
the supplemental significant nexus attachment” pro-
vided inthe AJD. The District stated that:
“Flow in the unnamed tributary has not been qual-
itatively assessed and the only direct observations
of the channel were made in December of 2011 at
which time there was standing water in pools but no
7 AR page COE000016.
52
continuous flow. In northern Minnesota, it is ex-
pected that for this type of stream channel, velocity
would typically be highest in the spring (March and
April) in response to snowmelt and precipitation.
Stream flow would steadily decline through late
April and May and would be expected to completely
dissipate by sometime in June or July when evapo-
transpiration rates are highest. Flow may be ob-
served periodically outside of this time frame in
response to precipitation events.”
The 2008 Revised Guidance states that “Principle con-
siderations when evaluating significant nexus include
the volume, duration, and frequency of the flow of
water in the tributary and the proximity of the tribu-
tary to a traditional navigable water. In addition to
any available hydrologic information (e.g., gauge data,
flood predictions, historic records of water flow, statis-
tical data, personal observations/records, etc.), the
agencies may reasonably consider certain physical
characteristics of the tributary to characterize its flow,
and thus help inform the determination of whether or
not a significant nexus is present between the tribu-
tary and downstream traditional navigable waters.
Physical indicators of flow may include the presence
and characteristics of a reliable ordinary high water
mark (OHWM) with a channel defined by bed and
banks. Other physical indicators of flow may include
shelving, wracking, water staining, sediment sorting,
and scour.”
While the AR” provides information indicating an
OHW mark for the unnamed tributary exists, it does
'S AR page COE000068
53
not provide sufficient evidence to establish a signifi-
cant nexus that the number of flow events, volume,
duration, and frequency of water flowing through the
tributary are such that it has an appreciable effect on
the TNW. The District stated that flow was present
during the site visit; however, the District could not
definitively identify any type of flow present in the
channel by either precipitation runoff or by ground-
water flow. Additionally, the District stated that ad-
ditional site investigations would be needed to deter-
mine the site’s hydrologic connectivity.
APPEAL REASON 4(c): There is no significant bio-
logicai connection to support nexus to TNW.
FINDING: This reason for appeal has merit.
ACTION: Upon remand, the District shall reconsider
the JD and provide additional documentation of a sig-
nificant nexus on the wetlands, including an analysis of
whether the wetlands have more than a speculative or
insubstantial effect on the biological integrity of the
nearest traditional navigable water (TNW), the Red
River of the North. In doing so, the District shall
document the hydrologic, ecologic, and other functions
performed by the tributary and all of its adjacent
wetlands.
DISCUSSION: The appellant states in the RFA that
“the ravine and the expansion area wetland provide no
fish habitat to support a biological connection. The
ravine is without flowing water during a vast majority
of the year, and in some years there is no flow in the
ravine at all. Furthermore, the Middle River biome, a
bottomland forest, is different from the Mercile wet-
land (expansion area), a rich fen, and so they are not
54
connected biologically or ecologically, and they are
separated by a twenty-foot vertical gradient.”
The AR” included a description of the stream channel
riparian corridor from the wnnamed tributary to the
TNW. However, the water flow regime information
was not sufficient to indicate that a significant nexus
exists. As indicated in Reason 4(b), field assessments
did not provide evidence of water flow.
The 2008 Guidance states “ habitat services
such as providing spawning areas for recreationally or
commercially important species in downstream waters,
and the extent to which the tributary and adjacent
wetlands perform functions related to maintenance of
downstream water quality such as sediment trapping.”
The District also did not indicate if the expansion area
wetland supports any aquatic/wildlife diversity. The
AR” mentioned aquatic species that the Red River of
the North supports, but no mention of species being
located within the tributary or wetland. Additional
information is needed to indicate if the wetland pro-
vides any significant biological/ecological contribution
to the TNW.
CONCLUSION:
In discussing the significant nexus in the Rapanos
memo, Justice Kennedy stated: “The required nexus
must be assessed in terms of the status’s goals and
purposes. Congress enacted the Clean Water Act
(CWA) to ‘restore and maintain the chemical, physi-
® AR page COE000008
” AR page COE000018
55
cal, and/or biological integrity of the Nation’s waters
” Consistent with Justice Kennedy’s in-
struction, EPA and the Corps will apply the significant
nexus standard in a manner that restores and main-
tains any of these three attributes of traditional navi-
gable waters. While the District does not need to
clearly support all three attributes, they do need to
clearly support that the onsite wetlands and tributary
provide more than a speculative or insubstantial effect
on the physical, chemical, or biological integrity of the
Red River of the North. The decision is being re-
manded to document whether a significant nexus does
indeed exist between the onsite wetlands and tributary
and the Red River of the North for any of the attrib-
utes.
Based on the information contained in Reason #4 (a),
(b), and (c), the AR does not provide sufficient docu-
mentation to establish a significant nexus between the
expansion area wetlands and the Red River of the
North based on the information provided.
The District speaks to the overall functions provided
by stream headwaters, the similarly situated wetlands,
and wetlands in general, within the review area.
However, they do not speak to how the functions that
the specific onsite wetland and tributaries have a sig-
nificant nexus that is more than speculative or insub-
stantial on the chemical, physical, or biological integ-
rity of the downstream TNW
For the reasons stated above, I find that the appeal
has merit since the District’s AR does not support its
determination that the subject property contains ju-
risdictional wetlands and waters. I am remanding the
AJD back to the District for reconsideration in light of
56
this decision. The District shall complete these tasks
within 60 days from the date of this decision and upon
completion, provide the Division office and appellant
with its decision document and final AJD.
/s/ [ILLEGIBLE]
for John W. Peabody
Major General, U.S. Army
Commanding
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.