Motion — U.S. Army Corp of Eng'rs v. Hawkes Co., 136 S. Ct. 615 (2015) (No. 15-290)
Supreme Court brief2015
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 15-290
LT ET TE
In The
Supreme Court of the Anited States
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
Petitioner,
v.
HAWKES Co., INC. ET AL.
Respondents.
On Petition For A Writ of Certiorari To
The United States Court Of Appeals
For the Eighth Circuit
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE
AND BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HOME
BUILDERS IN SUPPORT OF
PETITIONER
THOMAS J. WARD*
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
OF HOME BUILDERS
1201 15th Street, N.W
Washington, D.C. 20005
(202) 266-8200
tward@nahb.org
* Counsel of Record
‘SA ech ine cali aie ridecinlelmttis
October 6, 2015
NORMAN D. JAMES
FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C.
2394 E. Camelback Rd,
Suite 600
Phoenix, AZ 85016
(602) 916-5346
1
MOTION OF AMICUS CURIAE
FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF IN SUPPORT
OF PETITIONER, UNITED STATES ARMY
CORPS OF ENGINEERS
Amicus curiae National Association of Home
Builders (“NAHB”) respectfully moves for leave of
the Court to file the accompanying brief under
Supreme Court Rules 21, 33.1, 37.2. Counsel for
both parties received timely notice of amicus curiae’s
intent to file the brief. The Solicitor General has
consented to the filing of this brief and written
consent has been filed with the Clerk of the Court;
counsel for Hawkes Co. takes no position.
NAHB has been involved with litigation concerning
whether Clean Water Act jurisdictional
determinations are reviewable under’ the
Administrative Procedures Act. In addition, as a
representative of land developers, NAHB brings
considerate expertise to the issue before the Court.
A large part of building homes consists of obtaining
and preparing the land for construction.' That land
often contains “waters of the United States,” as the
federal government has defined and interpreted that
term. See 33 C.F.R. § 328.3(a); 40 C.F.R. § 122.2.
Often land developers must alter those “waters” to
ensure that their community makes the best use of
1 NAHB estimates that the cost of the “finished” lot
averages 19 percent of the sales price of a home. Heather
Taylor, Cost of Constructing A Homes, Special Studies (Jan. 2,
2014), http://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?section] D=734
&genericContent] D=221388&channelID=311 (last visited
Sept. 30, 2015)
ll
the land in accordance with local and state zoning
and land use requirements.
Unfortunately, property owners cannot simply look
at their property to determine where “waters of the
United States” are present. They must hire
consultants — engineers, scientists, and regulatory
and compliance specialists, who assist the
developers with the permitting process. Those
specialists will often develop a “jurisdictional
determination” and submit it to the Corps of
Engineers for approval. It is common for the
developer's consultants and the Corps to disagree on
the Corps’ jurisdiction. The amount of jurisdiction
the Corps asserts over a project will affect whether
and how the development proceeds, and sometimes
results in a community not being built.
In its Petition for Review, the government cited an
Endangered Species Act case, National Ass'n of
Home Builders v. Norton, 415 F.3d 8 (D.C. Cir.
2005), to support its belief that approved
jurisdictional determinations are not reviewable
under the Administrative Procedure Act. In the
attached brief, amicus curiae provides the Court
with an analysis of a different NAHB case that is
more analogous to this matter: National Ass’n of
Home Builders v. United States Army Corps of
Engineers, 417 F.3d 1272 (D.C. Cir. 2005).
In addition, NAHB provides an example of situation
where the government conducted a jurisdictional
determination on its own accord for the purpose of
later asserting jurisdiction over thousands of square
miles of land. Incredibly, even in that situation, the
il
go ernment argued that the determination was not
a “final agency action” under the APA.
Given the nationwide importance of the issue
presented to our members, NAHB agrees with the
government that the issue presented in this case is
worthy of this Court’s review. However, NAHB
believes that approved jurisdictional determinations
should be subject to judicial review. Therefore,
amicus curie respectfully requests that the Court
grant leave to file this brief.
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page(s)
ee I onciniconpctcniesnententindenenianwcnhiuniie i
TARE OF AUT ERIE BEBO cvccccccccccccccccccescscesesees ii-il
TABLE OF APPENDICES .................ccccccccseessseeeeees iV
STATEMENT OF INTEREST OF
EE iiepisietteinncedinceseinnnenesctinninisnitnns l
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT.........0.0... eee 2
IEEE Srentsttniatintnsinpsediemnncianiiiiuntedennitisietandiels 3
1. JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATIONS
IMPACT LAND DEVELOPERS’ DAY-TO-
ee Se icititcniiiinanigutansnansnsicaingiiineinntin 3
Il. JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATIONS
CAN PROVIDES THE GOVERNMENT WITH
AUTHORITY TO CONTROL THOUSANDS
OF ACRES OF PRIVATE PROPERTY ........... 6
ee Pccrecciccnsensnacennnnsnsentgansisenteivagenitieniinsnis 12
7]
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page(s)
CASES
Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154 (1997)........0....00...... 6
National Ass’n of Home Builders v. U.S. E.P.A.,
731 F.Supp.2d 50 (D.D.C. 2010), aff'd on other
grounds, sub nom. National Ass’n of Home
Builders v. E.P.A., 667 F.3d 6
a Ey GNI Giichidhecsinatiianithapliseninnbimininbeccanninianenine 1]
National Ass'n of Home Builders v. Norton,
GUE FBG B D.C. Caer. BGBD ..cccccccccccecccccceccccecssee 2,3
National Ass’n of Home Builders v. United States
Army Corps of Engineers, 417 F.3d 1272
I A a ne 2, 4, 5, 6, 12
National Ass’n of Home Builders v. United States
Army Corps of Engineers, 297 F.Supp.2d 74
ERR APT Se aE La eee 4
Rapanos v. United States, 547 U.S. 715 (2006) .. 3, 8
Sackett v. United States Envtl. Prot. Agency,
566 US. ---, 132 S.Ct. 13867 (2012) .....00.0 0. 7,11
STATUTORY AND REGULATORY
PROVISIONS
I. ctssichiotnnnciaemssincemnssinnteensiocial 11
ill
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES (cont.)
Page(s)
I ios aes ccinictsnicetsnihiseeneaimaaapiainetigl 3,11
re a iccccrtesicninoseieeninennscrstienaitesibeatinemn 3
I siecccsernserssneiciniisisaienenancnssinuisiauanbicss 3
er is ccinriccirneistcessesesientirionnncensisnsinetoninnen 8
8 EERE anes nen eNe ECT aT 11
Ts staceraemnansdiateeitanenteiinninenianbiaines 3
ITE incaisitsiscnciencepttebenbnaheiditenstuninaiinnies 11
OTHER
U S EPA, Memorandum of Agreement Between
the Department of the Army and the
Environmental Protection Agency Concerning
the Determination of the Section 404 Program
and the Application of the Exemptions Under
Section 404(F) of the Clean Water Act,
http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/wetlands/
AERP a ER ER AED Beal Pete OS SAARC EUS ee 9-10
IV
TABLE OF APPENDICES
Page(s)
APPENDIX A -— Letter from Benjamin H.
Grumbles, Assistant Administrator to The
Honorable John Paul Woodley, Jr., Assistant
Secretary of the Army, Civil Works (Dec.
APPENDIX B — Memorandum from John Paul
Woodley, Jr., Assistant Secretary of the Army,
Civil Works for Director of Civil Works (Sept.
ESE ERE eee EE ARS IN 4a
APPENDIX C — E-mail from Colonel Thomas
H Magness, SPL, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
to Steven L Stockton, HQ02, U.S. Army Corps
of Engineers (June 30, 2008 4:53 PM) ............... 6a
APPENDIX D ~ E-mail from Chip R Smith, ASA,
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Civil Works to
Mark D Cohen, SPL, U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers (June 13, 2008 8:30:01) ..................... 8a
APPENDIX E — Memorandum from Colonel
Thomas H. Magness, U.S. Army Commander for
the Record (May 23, 2008) .....................ccceeeeeees 10a
1
STATEMENT OF INTEREST OF
AMICUS CURIAE!
The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)
is a Washington, D.C.-based trade association whose
mission is to enhance the climate for housing and
the building industry. Chief among NAHB’s goals is
providing and expanding opportunities for all people
to have safe, decent, and affordable housing.
Founded in 1942, NAHB is a federation of more than
800 state and local associations. About one-third of
NAHB’s approximately 140,000 members are home
builders or remodelers, and they constitute 80% of
all homes constructed in the United States.
As presented in the attached motion, the cost of land
development can affect whether a homebuilder can
develop a viable community. Furthermore, the
presence of “waters of the United States” on a
homebuilders’ property affect the cost preparing the
land. Thus, NAHB’s members believe it is vital for
them to be able to challenge the government's
jurisdiction over their private property in a court of
law without first incurring tens (or hundreds) of
thousands of dollars in costs and experiencing
substantial project delay in order to contest
jurisdiction.
l Counsel of record for all parties received notice at least
10 days prior to the due date of the amicus curiae's intention
to file this brief. No counsel for a party authored this brief in
whole or in part, and no counsel or party made a monetary
contribution intended to fund the preparation or submission of
this brief. No person other than NAHB, its members, or its
counsel made a monetary contribution to its preparation or
submission.
2
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
In its Petition for Review, the government cites an
Endangered Species Act case, National Ass'n of
Home Builders v. Norton, 415 F.3d 8 (D.C. Cir.
2005), to support its argument that approved
jurisdictional determinations are not reviewable
under the Administrative Procedure Act. Amicus
curiae summarizes a different NAHB case that is
analogous to the matter before the Court and
supports the argument that jurisdictional
determinations are judicially reviewable. National
Ass'n of Home Builders v. United States Army Corps
of Engineers, 417 F.3d 1272 (D.C. Cir. 2005).
Additionally, NAHB provides an example of
situation where the government conducted a
jurisdictional determination on its own accord for
the purpose of later asserting jurisdiction over
thousands of square miles of land. Incredibly, even
in that situation, the government argued that the
determination was not a “final agency action” under
the APA.
3
ARGUMENT
I. JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATIONS
IMPACT LAND DEVELOPERS’ DAY-TO-
DAY BUSINESS.
When the government provides a landowner with an
“approved jurisdictional determination,” it informs
the landowner where “waters of the United States”
are present and where they are not. See 33 C.F.R.
§§ 328.3(a), 331.2 (defining “waters of the United
States and “approved jurisdictional determination”).
With respect to Clean Water Act (“CWA”) section
404, 33 U.S.C. § 1344(a), that landowner may place
dredged or fill material on those portions of her
property that do not contain “waters of the United
States” free from federal governmental interference.
Often, land developers will avoid the “waters of the
United States” completely and only work in the
“upland” areas. They do so because the time and
expense of obtaining a section 404 permit can
drastically alter the expenses of a project.?
The government cites National Ass’n of Home
Builders v. Norton, 415 F.3d 8 (D.C. Cir. 2005) to
support its contention that approved jurisdictional
determinations are not “final agency action” under
the judicial review section of the Administrative
Procedure Act (“APA”), 5 U.S.C. § 704. Pet. for Writ
2 “The average applicant for an individual permit spends
788 days and $271,596 in completing the process, and the
average applicant for a nationwide permit spends 313 days and
$28,915—not counting costs of mitigation or design changes.”
Rapanos v. United States, 547 U.S. 715, 721 (2006) (plurality
opinion).
4
of Cert. at 16. That case involved a challenge to a
survey protocol — a guidance document intended to
assist landowners in avoiding “take” of a rare
butterfly. A more analogous case to the case before
the court, however, is National Ass'n of Home
Builders v. United States Army Corps of Engineers,
417 F.3d 1272 (D.C. Cir. 2005) (hereinafter NAHB v.
Corps). In that case, the D.C. Circuit held that the
APA allows judicial review of a Corps’ CWA program
that affects the manner in which private landowners
may use their property.
In NAHB v. Corps, NAHB challenged a suite of
Corps’ issued general permits known as nationwide
permits (“NWPs’). NWPs “authorize certain
discharges of dredged and fill material into [waters
of the United States] without any detailed, project-
specific review by the Corps’ engineers.” NAHB uv.
Corps, 417 F.3d 1279-80. When a landowner who
needs to discharge dredge or fill material cannot
utilize one of the Corps’ NWPs, she must obtain an
individual permit before discharging pollutants into
waters of the United States. Jd. at 1275.
The District Court held that the NWPs were not
final agency action. It reasoned that the NWP’s
were just “the first step of a larger permitting
process that enables the agency to streamline the
overall process ” National Ass'n of Home
Builders v. United States Army Corps of Engineers,
297 F.Supp.2d 74, 80 (D.D.C. 2003). The Court of
Appeals disagreed. It explained that the impact of
the NWPs on a builder’s’ “day-to-day business” was
not hard to understand.
5)
While some builders can discharge
immediately, others cannot. If fa
builder’s] planned activities do not
meet the applicable NWP’s conditions
and thresholds, they have two options.
They can either put their projects on
hold and run the Corps’ individual-
permit gauntlet or modify the projects
to meet the conditions. Either way,
through increased delay or project
modification, the NWPs directly affect
investment and project development
choices of those whose activities are
subject to the CWA.
NAHB v. Corps, 417 F.3d at 1280.
The impacts of jurisdictional determinations on
builders are very similar to the impacts of the
NWPs. A builder who has obtained an approved
jurisdictional determination providing that no
“waters of the United States” are present on her
property can place dredge or fill material on the
property free from federal governmental
interference.
In contrast, if a Corps’ jurisdictional determination
provides that “waters of the United States” are
present, and the landowner needs to place dredge or
fill material in those areas, she can “either put [her]
project on hold” and try to obtain a costly (and time
consuming) CWA permit, or modify her project to
3 There are, of course, other federal statutes that may
affect land use (i.e. the Endangered Species Act), but they are
not relevant to this example.
6
avoid the jurisdictional waters. Either way,
jurisdictional determinations, like NWPs, “affect
investment and project development choices” and
are therefore “final agency actions.” Jd.; See also
Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154, 169 (1997) (providing
that while a biological opinion in theory serves an
“advisory function,’ in reality it has a powerful
coercive effect gp
NAHB v. Corps illustrates how Corps’ decisions that
occur before issuance (or denial) of a permit impact
the manner in which landowners may use their
property Therefore, NAHB respectfully request the
Court grant certiorari and affirm the Eighth
Circuit’s holding that CWA jurisdictional
determinations are reviewable under the APA.
II. JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATIONS
CAN PROVIDE THE GOVERNMENT
WITH AUTHORITY TO CONTROL
THOUSANDS OF ACRES OF PRIVATE
PROPERTY.
In its Pet. for Writ of Cert., the government explains,
“because jurisdictional determinations (unlike EPA
compliance orders) are typically provided to persons
who request them, they are not easily used “to
enable the strong-arming of regulated parties.” Pet.
for Writ of Cert. at 19. While it is true that the
government’ generally conducts jurisdictional
determinations for those who request them, that is
not always the case. When the government conducts
a jurisdictional determination on its own, it is later
able to assert control over large areas of land, which
can affect thousands of private property owners.
Yet, even in such situations, the government will
7
argue that it has not altered any rights or
obligations, or that no legal consequences flow from
such a determination. When this occurs, without
any protections for the regulated public, the “strong
arming” the Court was concerned with in Sackett v.
United States Environmental Protection Agency, 566
U.S. ---, 132 S.Ct. 1367 (2012), is still in existence. The
government’s jurisdictional determination that two
reaches of the Santa Cruz River in Arizona ure
“traditionally navigable waters” provides a perfect
example of such a situation. 4
In May 2008, Colonel Magness, U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers, issued a determination that two reaches
of the Santa Cruz River are “traditionally navigable
waters” (hereinafter the “TNW Determination”).
App. 10a. The government characterized this as a
Clean Water Act jurisdictional determination.
The Santa Cruz River, from the 1800's to today is a
discontinuous stream, normally flowing only in
response to significant rainfall or discharges of
effluent from regional wastewater treatment plants
near Nogales and Tucson, in Southern Arizona. One
of the two TNW reaches is only 22 miles long and the
other is 32 miles long and begins at the discharge
outlet of Pima County’s Roger Road wastewater
treatment plant in Tuscon, AZ. App. 10a-16a.
4 The Corps TNW Determination became the subject of
a Congressional investigation by the Committees on
Oversight and Government Reform and on Transportation
and Infrastructure. The Committees subpoenaed
documents and, ultimately, issued a report on December
16, 2008. NAHB has provided some of the subpoenaed
documents in its Appendix.
8
However, the Santa Cruz River watershed covers
over 10% of Arizona, contains over 8,000 square
miles, and includes the Tucson Metropolitan area —
the second largest population center in Arizona.
The TNW _ Determination was “stand-alone,”
meaning it is not associated with a request from a
property owner or permit application. See App. 4a;
see also 33 C.F.R. §329.14. Instead, the Colonel made
this determination because, in his words, “[wl]e
cannot determine jurisdiction [in the Santa Cruz
River watershed] without first identifying the
nearest downstream TNW” App. 6a. Recognizing
the vital importance of TNWs to CWA jurisdiction
following this Court’s decision in Rapanos v. United
States, 547 U.S. 715 (2006), Colonel Magness issued
the stand-alone TNW Determination “to support
some of the pending JDs” within the watershed.
Id.
In June 2008, the Assistant Secretary of the Army
for Civil Works suspended the TNW Determination
pending a 60-day review by Corps’ Headquarters.
During the review period, Colonel Magness and his
staff emphasized the importance of the Corps’ TNW
Determination for obtaining jurisdiction to regulate
tributaries within the Santa Cruz River watershed.
According to the Colonel, “without this TNW, the
closest TNW may be the Colorado River, several
hundred miles away. Using the [Colorado River] as
a basis for JDs would likely mean that we would lose
most of our jurisdiction in the state.” App. 7a.
Another Corps staff member explained that without
the Corps’ Stand Alone TNW Determination, the
Corps would lose CWA jurisdiction over much of the
Santa Cruz River watershed:
9
If these reaches are not TNWs, there
would be a profound effect on our
ability to regulate tributaries to the
Santa Cruz River. While the Santa
Cruz would still likely be an RPW, the
nearest TNW to the 8,600 square mile
Santa Cruz River Watershed Basin
would be 300 river miles away (the
Colorado River) from the Pima County
line. An inability to find a significant
nexus for these tributaries would lead
to a wide loss of jurisdiction and
ultimately pose serious water quality
concerns for the area.
App. 9a. Thus, the Corps made the TNW
Determination because without it, the Corps would
lose control over thousands of acres of private
property.
Corps Headquarters never completed its 60-day
internal review of the TNW _ Determination.
Instead, in August 2008, EPA Headquarters
declared the Santa Cruz River a “special case”
under the U.S EPA, Memorandum of Agreement
Between the Department of the Army and the
Environmental Protection Agency Concerning the
Determination of the Section 404 Program and the
Application of the Exemptions Under Section 404(F)
of the Clean Water Act [hereinafter the MOU],
available at http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/
wetlands/404f.cfm. A special case is “a circumstance
where EPA makes the final determination of the
geographic jurisdictional scope of waters of the
United States for purposes of section 404” of the
CWA. Id. According to the MOU, “[c]ase-specific
10
determinations made pursuant to” it are “binding
on the Government” — both EPA and the Corps —
“and represent the Government's position in any
subsequent Federal action or litigation regarding
the case.” Id.
The EPA concluded its review on December 3, 2008,
affirming the Corps TNW Determination. App. la.
In affirming the TNW Determination, the
EPA described the regulatory and practical
implications for landowners within the Santa Cruz
River watershed:
I have asked EPA Region 9 to begin
immediately to implement _ this
decision and request that you also
transmit this determination to the Los
Angeles District so it may be used by
the Corps to complete pending and
future jurisdictional determinations
for the Santa Cruz River watershed.
App. 2a (emphasis added).
Thus, the government made an immediately binding
determination that two reaches of the Santa Cruz
River were “traditionally navigable waters.” A
decision it made i) so it could assert control over desert
washes and other “tributaries” within 8,600 square-
miles and ii) that would impact the rights of thousands
of private land owners. Yet, neither those people who
own land that contains tributaries of the Santa Cruz
River, or those who own land bordering the Santa
Cruz itself were notified of the determination.5 In
5 Pursuant to the Corps regulations, landowners have a
right to an administrative appeal of approved jurisdictional
11
other words, all of this occurred “behind closed doors.”
NAHB and its affiliates in Arizona disagreed with the
analysis used to support the TNW Determination and
with the process the government used to finalize it.
With respect to the process, NAHB believed that a
binding determination that affects millions of acres
and thousands of private landowners must be
accomplished in accordance with the notice and
comment procedures set forth in the APA. 5 U.S.C. §
553. Therefore, NAHB filed its initial lawsuit
challenging the EPA’s and Corps’ Santa Cruz TNW
determination in 2009.
Without answering NAHB’s_ Complaint, the
government filed a motion to dismiss. Among its
arguments, the government asserted the TNW
Determination is not a “final agency action” under the
APA. 5 U.S.C. § 704. Specifically, the government
explained that the TNW Determination was not a
“final agency action” until used in an enforcement
action or incorporated into a permit decision.®
Therefore, according to the government when it makes
a “binding” decision asserting authority over millions
of acres of land, affecting thousands of private citizens
in a major metropolitan area, none of those citizens
determinations. 33 C.F.R. § 331.1(a). The regulations also
explain that the Corps will notify affected parties of their right
to appeal. 33 C.F.R.§ 331.4.
6 Under the line of cases overturned by Sackett, 566 U.S.
---, 132 S.Ct. 1367 (2012), the District Court ruled that the
Clean Water Act precluded review of the TNW Determination.
National Ass'n of Home Builders v. U.S. E.P.A., 731 F. Supp.
2d 50, 56 (D.D.C. 2010), aff'd on other grounds, sub nom.
National Ass'n of Home Builders v. E.P_A., 667 F.3d 6 (D.C. Cir.
2011).
12
can seek judicial review of that decision until one of
them applies for and completes the Corps’ costly and
time consuming permitting process. Furthermore,
depending on the type of permit sought, the landowner
may have to complete an administrative appeal before
obtaining judicial review See NAHB v. Corps, 417
F.3d at 1275.
Amicus provides this example of a stand-alone
jurisdiction determination to illustrate how the issue
in the case before the Court may affect thousands of
people without them evening knowing it. Amicus
requests that the Court grant certiorari in this matter
and explain to the government that when it asserts
jurisdiction over private property, those landowners
have a right to contest such assertion in court.
CONCLUSION
Whether a landowner may obtain judicial review of a
CWA approved jurisdictional! determination is of vital
importance to the home building industry. Therefore,
NAHB respectfully requests that the Court grant
certiorari in this matter and affirm the decision of the
Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.
13
DATED: October 6, 2015
Respectfully submitted,
NORMAN D. JAMES THOMAS J. WARD*
FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C. NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
2394 E. Camelback Rd, HOME BUILDERS
Suite 600 1201 15th Street, N.W
Phoenix, AZ 85016 Washington, D.C. 20005
(602) 916-5346 (202) 266-8200
tward@nahb.org
*Counsel of Record
APPENDIX
l
APPENDIX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page(s)
APPENDIX A — Letter from Benjamin H.
Grumbles, Assistant Administrator to The
Honorable John Paul Woodley, Jr., Assistant
Secretary of the Army, Civil Works (Dec.
RET TERR RC aat Steer eee Reamer la
APPENDIX B — Memorandum from John Paul
Woodley, Jr., Assistant Secretary of the Army.
Civil Works for Director of Civil Works (Sept.
RESET ea Ec neve vice nnn oR 4a
APPENDIX C — E-mail from Colonel Thomas
H Magness, SPL, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
to Steven L Stockton, HQ02, U.S. Army Corps
of Engineers (June 30, 2008 4:53 PM) ............... 6a
APPENDIX D — E-mail from Chip R Smith, ASA,
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Civil Works to
Mark D Cohen, SPL, U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers (June 13, 2008 8:30:01) ...........0......... 8a
APPENDIX E — Memorandum from Colonel
Thomas H. Magness, U.S. Army Commander for
the Record (May 23, 2008).....................:cccceeees 10a
APPENDIX A
la
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY
WASHINGTON DC 20460
OFFICE OF
DEC 3 2008 WATER
The Honorable John Paul Woodley, Jr.
Assistant Secretary of the Army (Civil Works)
Department of the Army
108 Army Pentagon
Washington DC 20310
Dear Secretary Woodley:
In August 2008, I designated the Santa Cruz and
Los Angeles Rivers as special case pursuant to the
1989 Army/EPA Memorandum of Agreement
Concerning the Determination of the Geographic
Jurisdiction of the Section 404 Program and the
Application of the Exemptions under Section 404(f)
of the CWA. EPA continues to evaluate relevant
information and to coordinate with the Los Angeles
District and others on this matter.
xk
EPA’s determination to affirm the District’s
designation of the two reaches as TNW’’s is based on
several key considerations, including:
e Evidence that the physical characteristics
with the Study Reaches indicate a
susceptibility for use in the future for
2a
commercial navigation, including
commercial water-borne reaction. For
example, river-width, when combined with
flow data from relevant flow gauges, shows
sufficient levels of flow in the Study
Reaches to support navigation.
e Evidence that the Study Reaches, or
portions thereof, have been navigated.
e Evidence of the likelihood of future
commercial navigation use, including two
ongoing Corps of Engineers river
restoration feasibility studies.
e Visual inspection by EPA during site visits
to Study Reaches.
*x***
I have asked EPA Region 9 to begin immediately
to implement this decision and request that you also
to transmit this determination to the Los Angeles
District so it may be used by the Corps to complete
pending and future jurisdictional determinations for
the Santa Cruz River watershed.
In consultation with the Los Angeles District, EPA
is proceeding with its geographic jurisdictional
analysis of the remainder of the Santa Cruz and the
Los Angeles River and will make decisions for both
when our review is complete. I appreciate the Corps
assistance in this important evaluation. Please feel
free to call me or have your staff contact my Chief of
Staff, Greg Peck, with any questions regarding this
matter.
3a
/s/ Grumbles
Benjamin H. Grumbles
Assistant Administrator
cc: Wayne Nastri, Regional Administrator, EPA
Region 9
Stephen A. Owens, Director, ADEQ
APPENDIX B
4a
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT SECRETARY
CIVIL WORKS
108 ARMY PENTAGON
WASHINGTON DC 20310-0108
SEP 24 2008
MEMORANDUM FOR DIRECTOR OF CIVIL
WORKS
SUBJECT: Traditional Navigable Water
Determinations Under the Clean Water Act
Effective immediately, the determination that a
specific water body is a “traditional navigable water”
(TNW) will be made by the Division Commander.
Such TNW determinations will be based on a formal
report of findings prepared by the District Engineer,
accompanied by a legal opinion of the District
counsel, and forwarded to the Division Commander
for final decision. Every formal report of findings
will be based substantially on applicable portions of
the format described in paragraph (c) of 33 C.F.R.
§329.14.
This directive applies to stand-alone TNW
determinations for watercourses where the District
Engineer proposes an upstream and downstream
limit of navigability. This directive does not apply to
TNW determinations associated with approved
jurisdictional determination(s) or authorizations for
the discharge of dredged or fill material into all
waters of the United States, including wetlands. The
purpose of this directive is to require additional
technical review and_ oversight of TNW
5a
determinations affecting watercourses and/or
significant aquatic resources. This review will
establish whether or not the TNW determination is
supported by the Clean Water Act, the agency’s
implementing regulations, relevant case law. and
existing guidance.
This directive shall remain in effect until
rescinded in writing.
/s/ John Paul Woodley, Jr.
John Paul Woodley, Jr.
Assistant Secretary of the Army
(Civil Works)
APPENDIX C
6a
From: Magness, Thomas H COL SPL
Sent: Monday, June 30, 2008 4:53 PM
To: Stockton, Steven L HQO2
Cc: McMahon, John R BG SPD; Lang, Lawrence
A HQ02; Benavides, Ada HQO2; Moyer, Jennifer A
HQO02; Hannon, James R MVD
Subject: Re: Santa_Cruz_River_TNW_
Determination (UNCLASSIFIED)
Sir
Here are a few points on this:
-- We have a backing of nearly 400 JDs in the LA
District. We are getting crushed under the weight of
these post-Rapanos decisions. We cannot determine
jurisdiction without first identifying the nearest
downstream TNW This decision in Arizona was to
determine the nearest TNW to support some of the
pending JDs. We made these TNW calls on the Gila
River and are now moving forward to look at
associated JDs while similarly moving out on
examinations of other rivers.
-- While Juridsiction [sic] is a complicated measure
of chemical, biological, and physical impacts, the
TNW determination is mostly a function of water
quantity. In other words, does the water body have
sufficient flow to support navigation? I am confident
that we had the evidence and data to support this
case.
Ta
-- On the Gila River, we identified two reaches with
sufficient flow to support navigation. We deployed
scientists to verify, looked at recent and historical
flow data, and collected photographic evidence to
verify these conditions.
-- In making this decision, we have stayed in contact
with HQ Regulatory folks and with other districts
making similar decisions, especially here in the
West. The flow in these reaches is sufficient year-
round to support our navigability decision. While it
is mostly, but not exclusively. effluent from a
wastewater treatment plant, we believe that case
law does allow for this source in decisions of
navigability
-- While not a factor in this decision, without this
TNW, the closest TNW may be the Colorado River,
several hundred miles away. Using the CR as a basis
for JDs would likely mean that we would lose most
of our jurisdiction in the state. I do not believe this
was the intent of the Rapanos decision, even under
the most conservative interpretations.
As you know sir, we are pinched on both ends on this.
In California, we are taking heat from
environmental groups who did not think we made
enough of the LA River as a TNW In Arizona, we
are hearing from developers who don’t agree with
what we have called TNWs.
APPENDIX D
8a
Santa Cruz River TNW Data
From: Smith, Chip R Mr ASA (CW) <email
redacted>
To: Blaine, Marjorie E SPL
Ce: Troxel, Tiffany A SPL; Lester, Cynthia J SPL;
Castanon, David J SPL; Young, Anne M Ms OGC
<email redacted>; Moyer, Jennifer A HQO2;
McLaughlin, Kimberly S HQ02
Sent: Fri Jun 13 08:30:01 2008
Subject: Re: ASA Inquiry on the Santa Cruz River
TNW Determination
Good stuff. How long is the river and what is the
length of the two sections. If these reaches are NOT
TNWs what is the effect on the landscape in terms
of jurisdiction over tribs and wetlands?
Chip
xk
From: Cohen, Mark D SPL <email redacted>
Sent: Friday, June 13, 2008 5:55 PM
To: Smith, Chip R Mr ASA (CW)
Ce: Castanon, David J SPL; Blaine, Marjorie E
SPL; Lester, Cynthia J SPL
Subject: Re: ASA Inquiry on the Santa Cruz River
TNW Determination
Chip,
In response to your questions this morning:
The river is approximately 225 miles long. Reach A
is 22 miles and reach B is 32 miles in length.
9a
If these reaches are not TNWs, there would be a
profound effect on our ability to regulate tributaries
to the Santa Cruz River. While the Santa Cruz
would still likely be an RPW, the nearest TNW to the
8,600 square mile Santa Cruz River Watershed
Basin would be 300 river miles away (the Colorado
River) from the Pima County line. An inability to
find a significant nexus for these tributaries would
lead to a wide loss of jurisdiction and ultimately pose
serious water quality concerns for the area.
Tributaries to the Santa Cruz include many
perennial and intermittent streams, with wetlands
and other high value resources (including Sabino
Canyon, Davison Canyon, and Cienega Creek).
Let me know if you need anything else.
Thanks,
Mark
APPENDIX E
10a
CESPL-RG-A 23 May 2008
MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD
SUBJECT: Determination of Two Reaches of the
Santa Cruz River as Traditional Navigable Waters
(TNW)
umm
The Corps’ Los Angeles District has determined that
two reaches of the Santa Cruz River, Study Reach A
from Tubac gage station (USGS # 09481740) to the
Continental gage station (USGS #09482000) and
Study Reach B from Roger Road wastewater
treatment plant (WWTP) downstream to the
Pima/Pinal County line, Arizona, as shown in
Exhibit A, are TNWs (collectively, referred to as the
“Study Reaches”). This determination is consistent
with the Clean Water Act (CWA), the agencies’
regulations (including 33 C.F.R.§ 328.3), relevant
case law, and existing guidance, including the June
5, 2007 joint U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
and Department of the Army legal memorandum
entitled Clean Water Act Jurisdiction Following the
U.S. Supreme Court's Decision in Rapanos v. United
States & Carabell v. United States (Rapanos
Guidance) and Appendix D of the U.S. Army Corps
of Engineers Jurisdictional Determination Form
Instructional Guidebook issued June 5, 2007
(Appendix D).
lla
Background
The Santa Cruz River originates in Arizona, flows
south into Mexico, and then flows north again into
Arizona. It is the primary river which flows from
Nogales, Mexico through Tucson, Arizona, and a
number of Indian reservations, including Tohono
O’odham Nation (TON), to the Gila River near
Phoenix. The watershed of the Santa Cruz River is
approximately 8,600 square miles. Until the late
nineteenth century, the Santa Cruz River was
primarily a perennial watercourse that served the
region's agricultural needs until a quickly
developing industrial society began to tap the river's
subsurface flow (Exhibit B).
The Upper Santa Cruz River Valley, located between
Nogales, Arizona on the US-Mexico border, and
extending 65 miles north to the major urban area of
Tucson, has a long history of European settlement
spanning three centuries. Prior to the discovery of
the area by European explorers, the area was
inhabited for thousands of years by aboriginal native
peoples. The Santa Cruz River has long been an
important corridor for trade and exploration. The
river and its well established riparian habitat have
served as a vital commodity for people and wildlife
in the region.!
In addition to the use of the Study Reaches by
recreational watercraft described in case-specific
1 The Santa Cruz River: A Resource Shared by Two Cities by
Hugh Holub, paper presented to the Border XXI EPA Regional
Water Sub Work Group Meeting on March 6, 2001, Nogales,
Sonora.
12a
analysis below, in the mid 1850s, William Rowlett
and his brother, Alfred, constructed an earthen dam
on the Santa Cruz River south of the present-day
Silverlake Road. They also installed a water-
powered flour mill at this location in 1857/58. In
1860, William Grant purchased the flour mill and
the dam/lake and improved the dam and mill in
order to supply military posts in the southwestern
region. He built a second, larger mill on the river and
purchased the machinery in California. However,
the mill was burned in 1861 to keep it from falling
into Confederate hands. The mill was purchased by
James Lee and returned to operations in 1864. In
1884, the mill, dam, and lake were sold to Frederick
Maish and Thomas Driscoll who developed the
Silver Lake Resort. In 1883, Solomon Warner built
a second dam and mill on the river. The lake was
approximately 60 acres, 8 feet deep, and the Arizona
Citizen reported the use of a flat-bottom boat on the
lake. Waterfowl populated the lake and hunting
organizations claimed exclusive rights to shooting
the waterfowl. The dams at both Silver Lake and
Warner's Lake were breached by floods in 1886 and
1887; the Arizona Star reported on July 13, 1887
that the river was wide and deep enough to float a
“mammoth steamboat.” In 1888, Frank and Warren
Allison purchased Warner Lake, repaired the dam,
and stocked the lake with carp for commercial fish
production selling over 500 pounds of fish per day.
l3a
Both dams were washed out by 1890.2
Further, in the summer of 1951, Glenton G. Syke,
Tucson city engineer, navigated the Santa Cruz
River in a 14-foot-long boat from the San Xavier del
Bac Mission to Congress Street in Tucson.
The Study Reaches were selected based on personal
knowledge of the river by Regulatory staff, evidence
of perennial flows based on stream gage data, and
more readily available evidence of navigability.
Basis for TNW Determination
The Rapanos Guidance indicates that in its context,
the term TNW refers to those waters that are under
the jurisdiction of the Corps, pursuant to 33 C.F.R.
§ 328.3(a)(1), (i.e., “[a]ll waters which are currently
used, or were used in the past, or may be susceptible
to use in interstate or foreign commerce, including
all waters which are subject to the ebb and flow of
the tide.”
As stated in Appendix D: “when determining
whether a water body qualifies as a “traditional
navigable water” (i.e., an (a)(1) water), relevant
considerations include whether a Corps District has
2 History of Navigation of the Santa Cruz River by Don Bufkin,
citation unknown.
3 Admiral of the Santa Cruz by Glenton G. Sykes, The Journal
of Arizona History, Vol. 20, Number 4, Winter, 1979.
14a
determined that the water body is a navigable water
of the United States pursuant to 33 C.F.R. § 320.14,
or the water body qualifies as a navigable water of
the United States under any of the tests set forth in
33 C.F.R. Part 329, or a federal court has determined
that the water body is navigable-in-fact under
federal law for any purpose, or the water body is
“navigable-in-fact” under the standards that have
been used by the federal courts.”
To determine whether the Study Reaches are a
TNW, in accordance to 33 C.F.R. § 328.3(a)(1), a
case-specific analysis to evaluate whether the Study
Reaches are navigable-in-fact, including
consideration of its potential susceptibility to
interstate and foreign commerce, was undertaken.
The Corps has determined that the Study Reaches
are a TNW based on the following factors:
1. The physical characteristics of the Santa Cruz
River within the Study Reaches indicate that they
have the capacity and susceptibility to be navigated
by recreational watercraft.
A. Study Reach A is approximately 22 miles
in length. The river near Tubac is typically more
confined in ordinary flows to a _ channel
approximately 15-20 feet wide with an approximate
1.5 mile wide, densely vegetated floodplain.
Downstream of Amado, the floodplain increases in
width to approximately 2.5 miles; the river channel
is less confined, less vegetated, and more braided.
Exhibit C shows monthly and daily flows for the
Tubac, Amado, and Continental gage stations, as
well as peak flows for the Amado and Continental
gage stations (Tubac information unavailable). The
l5a
monthly gage data indicate perennial flow at Tubac
since 1996, flow most months at the Amado gage
station since 2003 (prior years unavailable), and
intermittent flows at the Contintental gage station.‘
Average daily flows are typically lower in May and
June but increase during the summer monsoon
season which typically begins in July. Average daily
flow rates again typically increase during December
and January. The gage data indicate the highest
daily mean value at the Tubac gage station over the
last 11-12 years was 637 cubic feet per second (cfs)
during October and the lowest daily mean value at
the same station during the same period was 4.5 cfs
during June. The highest daily mean values
typically occur from July-October.5 The range of
mean monthly flows (6.9 to 78 cfs) and the average
daily flow in a representative year of 35 cfs indicate
perennial flow at the Tubac gage station. The mean
monthly discharge information at the Amado gage
station is only available since October, 2003; the
mean monthly discharge at this station in the last
four years varied from .97 cfs to 67 cfs while the daily
mean flow chart at the Amado gage station indicates
perennial flow. The mean monthly discharge at the
Continental gage station since 1940 varies from 43
cfs to 76 cfs while the mean daily values since 1939
4 http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/az/nwis/monthly
5 http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/az/nwis/dvstat
16a
shows flow daily with the exception of mid to late
May through mid-June. This is expected since the
river begins subsurface fiow at this point, which
defines the downstream end of this Study Reach.
B. Study Reach B is approximately 32 miles
in length. The width of the riverbed varies from
approximately 280 feet at the Roger Road WWTP to
approximately 670 feet at Cortaro§ and
approximately 575 feet at Trico Road while the
active (ordinary flow) river channel at all three
locations varies from 40-60 feet; at one location
within this Study Reach, the river diverges into two
similarly-sized channels. The river in Study Reach
B is often confined at its maximum width by steep
banks with soil cement or other bank stabilization in
several locations. In other locations, for example at
Ina Road, the river has lower, easily accessible,
vegetated banks. Some areas are more densely
vegetated than others. Exhibit C shows monthly,
daily, and peak flows for gage stations at Cortaro
and Trico Road (just upstream of the Pima/Pinal
County line). Average daily flows are typically lower
in May and June but increase during the summer
monsoon season which typically begins in July.
Average daily flows again typically increase during
December and January. The highest average daily
mean value at the Cortaro gage station over the last
57-60 years was 703 cfs, also in October, and the
lowest average daily mean value at the same station
over the same period was 22 cfs during June. The
average monthly discharge ranges from 23 to 124 cfs
and the average daily flow in a representative y_ar
of 75 cfs indicate perennial flow at the Cortaro gage
station. At the Trico Road gage station, since 1997,
17a
the average monthly discharge ranged from 3.5 cfs
to 710 cfs and daily mean values since 1989 ranged
from 11 cfs to 863 cfs. The gage data document
perennial flow at the Cortaro and Trico Road gages
every month since 1996 with the exception of
October, 1996.®
C. The peak flow charts demonstrate the
frequency of flows which exceed 1,000 cfs.7 Peak flow
data is unavailable at the Tubac gage station;
however, the maximum peak flow at the Amado gage
station since 2004 was approximately 7,800 cfs and
peak flow has approached or exceeded 2,000 cfs
annually. The maximum peak flow at _ the
Continental gage station was approximately 45,000
cfs in the early 1980s and the minimum peak flow
has exceeded 1,000 cfs 63 times since 1940. The
maximum peak flow at the Cortaro gage station
exceeded 60,000 cfs in the early 1980s and has
exceeded 1,000 cfs on an annual basis from 1940-
1988 with the exception of once in the 1940s and
once in the 1950s; the peak flow at the Cortaro gage
station has also exceeded 1,000 cfs on an annual
basis since approximately 1995. The maximum peak
flow at the Trico gage station exceeded 25,000 cfs in
2007 and the minimum peak flow has been at or
exceeded 1,000 cfs most years since 1989. The
figures at the end of Exhibit C indicate the “real
time” stages for late March-early April, 2008, at the
6 Ibid
7 http://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/az/nwis/peak
18a
Tubac, Cortaro, and Trico Road gage stations
indicating flows in the river on a daily basis.® All
three stations indicated flows with depths varying
from 1-2 feet and no precipitation had occurred for
approximately 6 weeks.9 Additional real-time stage
data obtained for late May is also provided for
Tubac, Green Valley (near Continental), Cortaro,
and Trico Road and indicates 1-2 feet of water
currently in the channel at all the above locations.
Extremely light precipitation occurred one day
during this timeframe; however, the amount of
precipitation received would not have been sufficient
to cause surface flows!® A list of the large magnitude
peak flow events of the Santa Cruz River over the
last 100 years is provided at Exhibit D.!!
D. While there is a variation in minimum flow
required for canoeing, studies indicate the 95%
confidence interval on the predicted minimum
canoeing flow of 86 cfs for flatwater is 63 to 118 cfs.!2
Approximately two-three feet of water depth is
sufficient to float a canoe, kayak, or small boat.
8 National Weather Service Advanced Hydrologic Prediction
Service: http://www/nws.noaa.gov/oh/ahps/
9 Personal observation, Marjorie Blaine, Senior Project
Manager, Regulatory Division, Tucson Project Office
10 Ibid
11 http://www.wrh.noaa.gov/twc/hydro/floodhis.php
19a
Based on the above information, during most days
from July-October and again for approximately half
the months of December and January. there is
sufficient flow in the Santa Cruz River within the
Study Reaches to float a canoe (based on the average
daily mean value). Typically a kayak would be able
to navigate in lower flows and less water than
canoes.
E. Based on aerial photographs attached at
Exhibit E, the Santa Cruz River from Tubac gage
station to just upstream of Continental gage station
and Roger Road WWTP to the Pima/Pinal County
line has uninterrupted flow.
F The Arizona Department of Environmental
Quality has adopted water quality standards for the
Santa Cruz River for partial body contact.!3 Partial
body contact allows for use of the surface water
where the body comes into contact with the water
but does not become fully submerged. Allowable uses
under partial body contact would include but are not
limited to boating and wading.
2. The Study Reaches within the Santa Cruz
River have public accessibility.
A. The river has low banks in the vicinity of
Tubac which allows for easy public access; these
12 Riparian Areas of the Southwestern United States:
Hydrology, Ecology, and Management by Malchus B. Baker
and Peter F. Ffolliott, CRC Press, 2004
13 Personal communication with Steve Pawlowski, Arizona
Department of Environmental quality, Unit Manager, Water
Quality Standards and Assessments, April 24, 2008.
20a
areas are currently frequented by riders on
horseback. Resorts along the river provide access for
out-of-state visitors for birding and hiking along the
river.
B. Two Corps of Engineers feasibility studies
for river restoration, El] Rio Medio and Tres Rios del
Norte, are in process. El Rio Medio will begin at
Congress Street and progress downstream to Prince
Road; Tres Rios del Norte will begin at Prince Road
and progress downstream to Sanders Road in
Marana. These projects will provide public trails
along the river. Although the final design for these
two projects has not been completed, it is likely river
access will be provided. The two projects are shown
in Exhibit F
C. There is currently public access to the river
at several bridges, including but not limited to the
Ina Road bridge where there are pull-out areas, the
Cortaro Road bridge (including a parking lot), and at
the Sanders Road bridge in Marana. All of these
bridges have easy access to Interstate 10.
D. The historic 1200-mile Juan Bautista de
Anza National Historic Trail runs from Nogales,
Arizona to San Francisco, California. This trail
parallels and overlaps the Santa Cruz River in the
Study Reaches. The river can be accessed at several
points along this trail in the Study Reaches by auto
or also on foot (Exhibit F).
3. The Study Reaches of the Santa Cruz River
have been used for interstate commerce and have
the potential to be used for commercial activities
involving navigation and interstate commerce in the
future.
2la
A. Navigation has occurred historically and
recent times within the Study Reaches of the Santa
Cruz River.
(1) On August 23, 2005, as part of a
promotion, a local radio show host navigated the
Santa Cruz River in a raft for an unspecified
distance starting at El] Camino de! Cerro (within
Study Reach B) (Exhibit G).
(2) In October, 1994, two members of the
Friends of the Santa Cruz navigated a 17-foot-long
canoe from a point south of Tubac three miles to a
point north of Tubac (Exhibit G).
B. The Santa Cruz River is an international
and interstate water. Several areas along the river
provide access for birding by out-of-state visitors and
resorts bordering the river, such as the Tubac Golf
Resort, host out-of-state visitors who partake in local
recreation including hiking, horseback riding, and
birding along the river. The Tucson Audubon
Society's North Simpson Farm is an area where
prolific riparian habitat restoration projects have
been focused and it is well-known for its
opportunities for birding. This type of “ecotourism”
provides a_ significant water resource-oriented
opportunity in the desert. The Study Reaches and
other areas within the region receive many
interstate and foreign tourists seeking to expand
their “bird list”; the Sonoran Desert, particularly in
riparian areas such as the Santa Cruz River,
provides a significant opportunity to see species
endemic to this area.
22a
C. Use of the river within the Study Reaches
by recreational watercraft provides evidence of the
susceptibility for commercial use.
Determination
Public access points within of the Study Reaches
such as low river banks, bridges, and trail systems,
together with their physical characteristics, such as
frequency, duration, and permanency of flow,
indicate that the Study Reaches have the potential
to be used for commercial recreational navigation
activities, such as canoeing, kayaking, birding,
nature and wildlife viewing. Such attractions and
activities demonstrate that the Study Reaches may
be susceptible to use in interstate commerce.
Collectively, the above discussed factors
demonstrate that the Study Reaches are navigable-
in-fact, and thus a TNW, susceptible to use in
interstate commerce associated with recreational
navigation activities. Therefore, I hereby determine
that the Study Reaches are subject to the
jurisdiction of Section 404 of the CWA, pursuant to
33 C.F.R. § 328.3(a)(1).
This determination does not 1) consider any other
potentially applicable bases for determining CWA
jurisdiction within the Study Reaches or 2) foreclose
analysis of other areas of the Santa Cruz River
outside the Study Reaches for purposes of
determining CWA jurisdiction.
05/23/08
Date /s/ Thomas H. Magness
Thomas H. Magness
Colonel, US Army
District Commander
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.