Joint Appendix — Osborn v. Haley

Supreme Court brief2007

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Jn the Supreme Court of the United States ss

PAT OSBORN

Petitioner

v.

BARRY HALEY; GAYE LUBER; AND

LAND BETWEEN THE LAKES ASSOCIATION, INC.

Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

JOINT APPENDIX

ERIC GRANT C. THOMAS MILLER

ATTORNEY AT LAW WHITLOW, ROBERTS, HOUSTON

8001 Folsom Blvd., Ste. 100 & STRAUB, PLLC

Sacramento, California 95826 Post Office Box 995

(916) 388-0833 300 Broadway

(916) 691-3261 fax Paducah, Kentucky 42002

Counsel of Record for Petitioner (270) 443-4516

(270) 443-4571 fax

PAUL D. CLEMENT Counsel of Record for

Solicitor General Respondents Gaye Luber

Department of Justice and Land Between the

Washington, D.C. 20530 Lakes Association, Inc.

(202) 514-2217

(202) 514-8844 fax

Counsel of Record for

Respondent Barry Haley

AE SS

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED: NOVEMBER 7, 2005

CERTIORARI GRANTED: MAY 15, 2006

i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Docket Entries in the Court of Appeals

ee Pe ey err ey eer re Srey ee 1

PP 26/060 6omibhéccnbueteneeeetauccaveeens 6

Docket Entries in the District Court ................. 10

Complaint (June 23, 2003) ................ Luber App. 1°

Certification of the Acting United

States Attorney (Aug. 20, 2003)......... Luber App. 23

Answer of the United States

ke er ere Luber App. 16

United States’ Motion to Dismiss

EE 5.44 hdd Beebe v eked séeee Luber App. 24

Plaintiffs Response to United States’

Motion to Dismiss (Jan. 27, 2004) ...............4.. 17

Exhibit A—Memorandum of Under-

standing Between the U.S. Forest

Service and LBLA (Sept. 22, 2000) .............. 21

Exhibit B—Affidavit of Petitioner

Pree Goes Ge, Se ccc ccc en evecessess 34

Exhibit C—Letter from Robert A.

Kuenzli to William J. Bolls, Jr.

an ED nc ec Ped asedessucses Luber App. 30

United States’ Reply to Plaintiff's

Response to United States’ Motion

I a es ug eee eeeee 35

District Court Opinion (Mar. 12, 2004) ...... Pet. App. 19a

District Court Order (Mar. 12, 2004) ........ Pet. App. 17a

*“Luber App.” is short for the Appendix to the Brief in Opposition

for Respondents, Gaye Verdi f/k/a Gaye Luber and Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc., filed on March 31, 2006.

li

TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued

Page

United States’ Motion to Reconsider

Order Denying Motion to Dismiss

and Substitution of United States

for Federal Defendant Barry Haley

A EE ce bek duane Gbeeoseetiseeceoeduene 40

Exhibit 1—Declaration of Respondent

Barry Haley (Mar. 22, 2004) ................... 51

Exhibit 2—Declaration of Respondent

Gaye Luber (Mar. 22, 2004) ................... 53

District Court Opinion on Reconsideration

OEE SCRIP Pet. App. 12a

Court of Appeals Opinion (Sept. 8, 2005)...... Pet. App. la

1

General Docket

US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit

Court of Appeals Docket #: 04-5716 Filed: 6/18/04

Nsuit: 2360 P.I.: Other

Osborn v. Haley, et al

Appeal from: Western District of Kentucky at Paducah

* * * * *

Docket as of May 18, 2006 9:25 pm

* * * * *

04-5716 Osborn v. Haley, et al

6/18/04 Civil Case Docketed Notice filed by Appellant

Barry Haley. Transcript needed: n (ac)

[04-5716]

6/18/04 BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting briefing

schedule: appellant brief due 7/28/04;

appellee brief due 8/30/04; reply brief due

9/16/04; appendix due 9/23/04; fimal briefs

due 10/14/04. [04-5716] (ac) [04-5716]

6/18/04 _— Electronic case filing. District court record

can downloaded electronically. [04-5716] (ac)

[04-5716]

6/28/04 APPEARANCE filed by Attorney Barbara L.

Herwig for Appellant Barry Haley [04-5716]

(ac) [04-5716]

6/28/04 APPEARANCE filed by Attorney Peter R.

Maier for Appellant Barry Haley [04-5716})

(ac) [(04-5716)

6/28/04 PRE-ARGUMENT STATEMENT filed by

Peter R. Maier for Appellant Barry Haley

[04-5716] (ac) [04-5716]

2

04-5716 Osborn v. Haley, et al

6/28/04

7/15/04

7/15/04

7/19/04

7/19/04

8/11/04

TRANSCRIPT ORDER FORM filed by

Peter R. Maier for Appellant Barry Haley:

No hearings held in District Court. [04-5716]

[2983693-1] (blh) [04-5716]

ORDER filed to consolidate for briefing and

submission cases 04-5716/5820 (04-5716,

04-5820] (ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting pro se

briefing schedule: appellant brief due 8/24/04;

appellee brief due 9/27/04; reply brief due

10/14/04; appendix due 10/21/04. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

Appellant MOTION filed to extend time to

8/27 to file brief. Motion filed by Barbara L.

Herwig and Peter R. Maier for Appellant

Barry Haley. Certificate of service 7/16/04

[04-5716] (ac) [04-5716]

RULING declaring as moot the motion to

extend briefing |2991939-1] filed by Barbara

L. Herwig, Peter R. Maier. Briefing was

reset when the related appeal (04-5820)

was docketed [04-5716] (ac) [04-5716]

Appellant MOTION filed to extend time to 9/7

to file brief. Motion filed by Barbara L. Herwig

and Peter R. Maier for Appellant Barry Haley.

Certificate of service date 8/10/04 [04-5716]

(ac) [04-5716]

3

04-5716 Osborn v. Haley, et al

8/18/04

9/3/04

9/3/04

9/8/04

9/22/04

10/7/04

LETTER SENT by ac granting motion to

extend briefing [3005539-1] filed by Barbara

L. Herwig, Peter R. Maier, Thomas Miller,

[3007396-1] resetting briefing schedule:

(04-5716, 04-5820] appellant brief due now

9/7/04; appellee brief now due 10/7/04; reply

brief now due 10/21/04; appendix now due

10/28/04; final briefs now due 11/18/04. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

PROOF BRIEF filed by Peter R. Maier and

Barbara L. Herwig for Appellant Barry Haley.

Certificate of service date 9/2/04. Number of

Pages: 40. [04-5716] (Imn) |04-5716]

Request to require oral argument filed by

Peter R. Maier and Barbara L. Herwig for

Appellant Barry Haley. [04-5716] (Imn)

(04-5716)

BRIEFING LETTER SENT requesting

proof brief corrections from Peter R. Maier

because corporate disclosure statement is

missing; Page #1 should be the jurisdictional

statement; more information needed for

references. Corrections due: 9/22/04. (Imn)

(04-5716)

Corrected Appellant's proof brief filed by Peter

R. Maier and Barbara L. Herwig. Copies: 1.

Certificate of Service date 9/21/04 [04-5716]

(Imn) [04-5716]

BRIEF filed by Pat Osborn for Appellee Pat

Osborn. Copies: 7. Certificate of service date

10/4/04. Number of Pages: 2. |04-5716,

04-5820] (Imn) [04-5716 04-5820]

4

04-5716 Osborn v. Haley, et al

10/29/04

10/29/04

10/29/04

11/18/04

4/8/05

6/1/05

APPENDIX filed by Peter R. Maier and

Barbara L. Herwig for Appellant Barry

Haley. Copies: 5 (One volume). Certificate

of service date 10/27/04. (04-5716, 04-5820)

(Imn) [04-5716 04-5820]

FINAL BRIEF filed by Peter R. Maier and

Barbara L. Herwig for Appellant Barry

Haley. Copies: 7. Certificate of service date

10/27/04. Number of Pages: 41. [04-5716]

(Imn) {04-5716}

Request to require oral argument filed by

Peter R. Maier and Barbara L. Herwig for

Appellant Barry Haley. [04-5716] (Imn)

[04-5716]

APPEARANCE filed by Attorney J. Duncan

Pitchford for Appellant Land Between the

Lak, Appellant Gaye Luber in 04-5820

[04-5820] (yh) [04-5820]

Submission on briefs date set for June 1,

2005, Notice sent to counsel. (pjm) [04-5716

04-5820)

CAUSE SUBMITTED on briefs to panel

consisting of Judges Moore, Cook, Gwin

sitting on 06.01.05. |04-5716, 04-5820] (kal)

{04-5716 04-5820]

5

04-5716 Osborn v. Haley, et al

9/8/05

9/8/05

11/2/05

11/29/05

5/18/06

OPINION filed: The district court’s denial

of substitution and remand orders are

VACATED and the case is REMANDED for

further proceedings, decision for publication

pursuant to local rule 206. [04-5716, 04-5820)

Karen N. Moore, Circuit Judge, Deborah L.

Cook, Authoring Judge, James Gwin, U.S.

District Judge for the N.D. of OH. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

JUDGMENT: VACATED and remanded.

(ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

MANDATE ISSUED with no cost taxed

(04-5716, 04-5820] (ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

U.S. Supreme Court notice filed regarding

petition for writ of certiorari filed by Appellee

Pat Osborn in 04-5716, Appellee Pat Osborn

in 04-5820. Filed in the Supreme Court on

11-07-05, Supreme Ct. case number: 05-593.

(04-5716, 04-5820] (swh) [04-5716 04-5820]

U.S. Supreme Court letter filed granting

petition for writ of certiorari [3277314-1)

filed by Pat Osborn, Pat Osborn. In addition

to the Questions presented by the petition,

the parties are directed to brief and argue

the following Question: Whether the court of

appeals had jurisdiction to review the district

court's remand order, notwithstanding 28

U.S.C. Sec. 1447(d) |04-5716, 04-5820)

Supreme Court No. 05-593 in 04-5716,

granting petition for writ of certiorari

[3277314-1] filed by Pat Osborn, Pat Osborn

[04-5716, 04-5820] in 04-5820. Filed in the

Supreme Court on 05-15-06. (swh) [04-5716

04-5820)

6

General Docket

US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit

Court of Appeals Docket #: 04-5820 Filed: 7/15/04

Nsuit: 4360 P.I.: Other

Osborn v. Haley, et al

Appeal from: Western District of Kentucky at Paducah

* * * * *

Docket as of May 18, 2006 9:25 pm

* * * * *

04-5820 Osborn v. Haley, et al

7/15/04 _. Civil Case Docketed. Notice filed by

Appellants Gaye Luber, Land Between the

Lak. Transcript needed: n (ac) [04-5820]

7/15/04 Electronic case filing. District court record -

can be downloaded electronically. [04-5820]

(ac) (04-5820)

7/15/04 ORDER filed to consolidate for briefing and

submission cases 04-5716/5820 (04-5716,

04-5820] (ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

7/15/04 ##BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting pro se

briefing schedule: appellant brief due 8/24/04;

appellee brief due 9/27/04; reply brief due

10/14/04; appendix due 10/21/04. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

7/15/04 APPEARANCE filed by Attorney C. Thomas

Miller for Appellants and Between the Lak,

Gaye Luber. [04-5820] (ac) [04-5820]

7/15/04 $PRE-ARGUMENT STATEMENT filed by C.

Thomas Miller for Appellants Land Between

the Lak, Gaye Luber. 04-5820 [04-5820] (ac)

[04-5820]

7

04-5820 Osborn v. Haley, et al

7/20/04

8/16/04

8/18/04

9/7/04

9/7/04

10/7/04

TRANSCRIPT ORDER FORM filed by C.

Thomas Miller for Appellant Land Between

the Lak, Appellant Gaye Luber: No hearings

held in District Court. [04-5820] [2994328-1]

(blh) [04-5820]

Appellant MOTION filed to extend time to

8/27 to file brief. Motion filed by C. Thomas

Miller for Appellant Land Between the Lak,

Appellant Gaye Luber. Certificate of service

date 8/13/04 |04-5820] (ac) [04-5820]

en

LETTER SENT by ac granting motion to

extend briefing [3005539-1] filed by Barbara

L. Herwig, Peter R. Maier, Thomas Miller,

[3007396-1] resetting briefing schedule:

[04-5716, 04-5820] appellant brief due now

9/7/04; appellee brief now due 10/7/04; reply

brief now due 10/21/04; appendix now due

10/28/04; final briefs now due 11/18/04. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

PROOF BRIEF filed by C. Thomas Miller

for Appellants Land Between the Lakes and

Gaye Luber. Certificate of service date 9/3/04.

Number of Pages: 16. [04-5820] (Imn)

[04-5820]

Request to require oral argument filed by C.

Thomas Miller for Appellants Land Between

the Lakes and Gaye Luber. [04-5820] (lmn)

[04-5820] ,

BRIEF filed by Pat Osborn for Appellee

Pat Osborn. Copies: 7. Certificate of service

date 10/4/04. Number of Pages: 2. |04-5716,

04-5820] (Imn) [04-5716 04-5820]

8

04-5820 Osborn v. Haley, et al

10/29/04

11/8/04

11/8/04

11/8/04

11/18/04

4/8/05

6/1/05

APPENDIX filed by Peter R. Maier and

Barbara L. Herwig for Appellant Barry

Haley. Copies: 5 (One volume). Certificate

of service date 10/27/04. [04-5716, 04-5820]

(Imn) [04-5716 04-5820]

TENDERED : Appellant’s Final Brief from

J. Duncan Pitchford for Appellant Land

Between t*e Lakes and Gaye Luber. Waiting

for Notice of appearance from Mr. Pitchford.

[04-5820] (Imn) [04-5820]

FINAL BRIEF filed by J. Duncan Pitchford

and C. Thomas Miller for Appellants Land

Between the Lakes and Gaye Luber. Copies:

7. Certificate of service date 11/5/04. Number

of Pages: 16. [04-5820] (Imn) [04-5820]

Request to require oral argument filed by

J. Duncan Pitchford and C. Thomas Miller

for Appellants Land Between the Lakes

and Gaye Luber. [04-5820] (Imn) [04-5820]

APPEARANCE filed by Attorney J. Duncan

Pitchford for Appellant Land Between the

Lak, Appellant Gaye Luber in 04-5820

[04-5820] (yh) [04-5820]

Submission on briefs date set for June 1,

2005, Notice sent to counsel. (pjm) [04-5716

04-5820]

CAUSE SUBMITTED on briefs to panel

consisting of Judges Moore, Cook, Gwin

sitting on 06.01.05. [04-5716, 04-5820] (kal)

(04-5716 04-5820]

9

04-5820 Osborn v. Haley, et al

9/8/05

9/8/05

11/2/05

11/29/05

5/18/06

OPINION filed: The district court’s denial

of substitution and remand orders are

VACATED and the case is REMANDED for

further proceedings, decision for publication

pursuant to local rule 206. |04-5716, 04-5820]

Karen N. Moore, Circuit Judge, Deborah L.

Cook, Authoring Judge, James Gwin, U.S.

District Judge for the N.D. of OH. (ac)

[04-5716 04-5820]

JUDGMENT: VACATED and remanded.

(ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

MANDATE ISSUED with no cost taxed

(04-5716, 04-5820] (ac) [04-5716 04-5820]

U.S. Supreme Court notice filed regarding

petition for writ of certiorari filed by Appellee

Pat Osborn in 04-5716, Appellee Pat Osborn

in 04-5820. Filed in the Supreme Court on

11-07-05, Supreme Ct. case number: 05-593.

(04-5716, 04-5820] (swh) [04-5716 04-5820)

U.S. Supreme Court letter filed granting

petition for writ of certiorari [3277314-1)

filed by Pat Osborn, Pat Osborn. In addition

to the Questions presented by the petition,

the parties are directed to brief and argue

the following Question: Whether the court of

appeals had jurisdiction to review the district

court’s remand order, notwithstanding 28

U.S.C. Sec. 1447(d) (04-5716, 04-5820]

Supreme Court No. 05-593 in 04-5716,

granting petition for writ of certiorari

{3277314-1] filed by Pat Osborn, Pat Osborn

(04-5716, 04-5820} in 04-5820. Filed in the

Supreme Court on 05-15-06. (swh) [04-5716

04-5829]

10

U.S. District Court

Western District of Kentucky (Paducah)

CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 5:03-cv-00192-TBR

Osborn v. Haley et al

Assigned to: Judge Thomas B. Russell

Cause: 28:1446 Petition for Removal- Personal Injury

Date Filed: 08/20/2003

Jury Demand: None

Nature of Suit: 360 P.I.: Other

Jurisdiction: U.S. Government Defendant

* * * * *

{Docket as of June 12, 2006]

Date

Filed

08/20/2003. 1 NOTICE OF REMOVAL from Trigg

County Circuit Court, case number

03-CI-00119, filed by Barry Haley,

Land Between the Lakes Association,

Inc., and Gaye Luber. (Attachments:

# 1 Exhibit 1 (2) Exhibit 2 (3) Cover

Sheet) (SGH) (Entered: 08/25/2003)

08/20/2003 2 Case Assignment (Random Selection):

Case Assigned to Judge Thomas B.

Russell. (SGH) (Entered: 08/25/2003)

08/20/2003 3 MOTION for Extension of Time to

File Answer by Barry Haley, Land

Between the Lakes Association, Inc.,

and Gaye Luber. Responses due by

8/28/2003 (Attachments: # 1 Proposed

Order) (SGH) (Entered: 08/25/2003)

# Docket Text

Date

Filed

09/05/2003 4

10/16/2003 5

10/24/2003 6

11/19/2003 7

11/25/2003 8

12/03/2003 9

12/18/2003 10

11

Docket Text

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell on

8/31/03; granting 3 Motion for Extension

of Time to Answer up to & including

10/20/03 to file its initial pleading (cc:

all counsel) (KJI) (Entered: 09/05/2003)

MOTION for Extension of Time to File

Answer an additional 30 days by Barry

Haley. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed

Order) (KJI) (Entered: 10/20/2003)

ORDER by Thomas B. Russell on

10/22/03: granting 5 Motion for

- Extension of Time to Answer an

additional 30 days. (cc: all counsel)

(KJI) (Entered: 10/24/2003)

ANSWER to Complaint by Barry Haley,

Land Between the Lakes Association,

Inc., Gaye Luber.(KJI) (Entered:

11/20/2003)

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell

on 11/25/03: Scheduling Conference set

for 1/12/2004 at 2:45 PM before Judge

Thomas B. Russell. (cc: all counsel)

(KJ1) (Entered: 11/25/2003)

NOTICE FOR CORRECTED SERVICE

by Land Between the Lakes Association,

Inc., Gaye Luber. (KJI) (Entered:

12/03/2003)

AMENDMENT TO PROPOSED

DISCOVERY PLAN by Pat Osborn.

(KJI) (Entered: 12/18/2003)

Date

Filed

01/09/2004

01/09/2004

01/09/2004

f

01/16/2004

01/27/2004

01/29/2004

11

12

13

14

15

16

12

Docket Text

MOTION to Substitute Party United

States for Barry Haley by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc. Responses

due by 1/27/2004 (Attachments:

# 1 Certification # 2 Proposed Order)

(KJI) (Entered: 01/12/2004)

MOTION to Stay Discovery by Land

Between the Lakes Association, Inc.

Responses due by 1/27/2004

(Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)

(KJI) (Entered: 01/12/2004)

MOTION to Dismiss by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc. [N.B.: should

be: “by United States”] Responses due

by 1/27/2004 (Attachments: # 1 Proposed

Order) (KJI) (Entered: 01/13/2004)

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell

on 1/12/04: Telephone Conference set

for 3/10/2004 at 8:45 AM before Judge

Thomas B. Russell. (ce: all counsel, pla)

(KJI) (Entered: 01/16/2004)

RESPONSE to Motion re 13 MOTION

to Dismiss by Pat Osborn. (Attachments:

# 1 Exhibit A # 2 Exhibit B # 3 Exhibit C

# 4 Proposed Order) (KJI) (Entered:

01/27/2004)

MOTION to Dismiss by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc.; Gaye

Luber. Responses due by 2/17/2004

(Attachments: # 1 Memorandum in

Support # 2 Proposed Order) (KJTI)

(Entered: 01/29/2004)

Date

Filed

02/09/2004

02/25/2004

03/12/2004

03/12/2004

03/24/2004

03/24/2004

17

18

19

20

21

22

13

Docket Text

REPLY to Response to Motion re 13

MOTION to Dismiss by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc. [N.B.: should

be: “by United States”] (KJI) (Entered:

02/10/2004)

REPLY to Response to Motion re 16 .

MOTION to Dismiss by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc., Gaye Luber.

(KJI) (Entered: 02/25/2004)

MEMORANDUM AND OPINION by

Judge Thomas B. Russell on 3/10/04:

separate order entered this date

consistent w/ memo opinion (cc: all

counsel) (KJT) (Entered: 03/12/2004)

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell on

3/10/04: Remanding case to Trigg Circuit

Court (cc: all counsel, Trigg Circuit

Court) (KJI) (Entered: 03/12/2004)

MOTION to Stay Remand Order by

Barry Haley; Land Between the Lakes

Association, Inc. Responses due by

4/12/2004 (Attachments: # 1 Proposed

Order) (KJI) (Entered: 03/25/2004)

MOTION for Reconsideration re 19

Memorandum & Opinion, 20 Order

Dismissing Case by Barry Haley.

Responses due by 4/12/2004

(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1

# 2 Exhibit 2 # 3 Proposed Order

# 4 Proposed Order) (KJI) Modified

on 4/27/2004 (deleted incorrect filer)

(KJI). (Entered: 03/26/2004)

Date

Filed

04/06/2004

04/19/2004

04/26/2004

04/29/2004

05/13/2004

06/14/2004

23

24

25

26

27

28

14

Docket Text

RESPONSE to Motion re 22 MOTION

for Reconsideration re 19 Memorandum

& Opinion, 20 Order Dismissing Case by

Pat Osborn. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed

Order) (KJI) (Entered: 04/06/2004)

MOTION for Extension of Time to

File Reply to Response to Motion to

Reconsider by Barry Haley. Responses

due by 4/27/2004 (Attachments:

# 1 Proposed Order) (KJI) (Entered:

04/20/2004)

REPLY to Response to Motion re 22

MOTION for Reconsideration re 19

Memorandum & Opinion, 20 Order

Dismissing Case by Barry Haley.

(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit) (KJ1)

(Entered: 04/27/2004)

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell

on 4/24/04; granting 24 Motion for

Extension of Time to File Reply up to

4/26/04 (ce: all counsel) (KJI) (Entered:

04/29/2004)

ORDER by Judge Thomas B. Russell

on 5/13/04; denying 21 Motion to Stay,

denying 22 Motion for Reconsideration

(cc: all counsel) (KJI) (Entered:

05/13/2004)

NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 27 Order

on Motion to Stay, Order on Motion for

Reconsideration by Barry Haley. (KJI)

(Entered: 06/15/2004)

Date

Filed

06/18/2004

06/18/2004

06/22/2004

06/25/2004

06/28/2004

06/29/2004

07/02/2004

29

30

31

32

33

34

15

Docket Text

Transmission of Notice of Appeal and

Docket Sheet to US Court of Appeals

re 28 Notice of Appeal (KJI) (Entered:

06/18/2004)

USCA Case Number 04-5716 for 28

Notice of Appeal filed by Barry Haley.

(KJI) (Entered: 06/18/2004)

NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 19

Memorandum & Opinion, 20 Order

Dismissing Case, 27 Order on

Motion to Stay, Order on Motion for

Reconsideration, by Land Between

the Lakes Association, Inc., Gaye

Luber. Filing fee $ 255, receipt number

13696. (Attachments: # 1 Receipt)

(KJI) (Entered: 06/23/2004)

DESIGNATION of Record on Appeal

by Barry Haley re 28 Notice of Appeal

(KJI) (Entered: 06/25/2004)

TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Barry

Haley No Hearings re 28 Notice of

Appeal (KJI) (Entered: 06/29/2004)

Transmission of Notice of Appeal and

Docket Sheet to US Court of Appeals

re 30 Notice of Appeal (K.JI) (Entered:

06/29/2004)

TRANSCRIPT REQUEST by Land

Between the Lakes Association, Inc.,

Gaye Luber re 30 Notice of Appeal, no

hearings (KJI) (Entered: 07/02/2004)

Date

Filed

07/02/2004

10/07/2004

11/07/2005

12/06/2005

05/22/2006

#

35

36

37

38

16

Docket Text

DESIGNATION of Record on Appeal

by Lar.d Between the Lakes Association,

Inc., Gaye Luber re 30 Notice of Appeal

(KJI) (Entered: 07/02/2004)

NOTICE of Appearance by Michael D.

Ekman on behalf of on behalf of Barry

Haley Substitution for: Brady Miller

(Ekman, Michael) (Entered: 10/07/2004)

MANDATE of USCA as to 30 Notice

of Appeal, filed by Gaye Luber,, Land

Between the Lakes Association, Inc., 28

Notice of Appeal filed by Barry Haley;

remanding case for further proceedings

(KJS) (Entered: 11/09/2005)

Remark : Received letter from Supreme

Court of the United States addressed

to US Court of Appeals advising that a

petition for writ of certiorari was filed

on 11/7/05 and placed on the docket

11/10/05 as 05-593. (KJS) (Entered:

12/06/2005)

Letter from Office of the Clerk, Supreme

Court of the United States that petition

for writ of certiorari granted. (CSD)

(Entered: 05/22/2006)

17

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY

PADUCAH DIVISION

Case No. 5:03CV-192-R

[Filed Jan. 27, 2004]

PAT OSBORN PLAINTIFF

vs. PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO UNITED

STATES’ MOTION TO DISMISS

BARRY HALEY,

ET AL DEFENDANTS

Plaintiff Pat Osborn requests the court to deny the

United States’ motion to dismiss plaintiffs complaint, and

in support thereof, submits the following memorandum of

law.

MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF

PLAINTIFF'S REQUEST TO DENY

UNITED STATE’S MOTION TO DISMISS

Summary of Argument

A. Plaintiffs complaint alleges facts that show defendant

Barry Haley acted outside the scope of his employment

when performing the acts which form the basis of plaintiffs

complaint.

B. Plaintiff has information that leads her to believe that

a written “Memorandum of Understanding” executed by

USDA Forest Service and LBLA, in effect at the time of her

discharge, specifically prohibited Forest Service employees

from participating in any LBLA decision regarding the

hiring or firing of LBLA employees.

C. Defendant Barry Haley’s conduct in causing plaintiff to

be fired for filing a veterans preference inquiry fails the

scope of employment test under Kentucky Law as set out in

Coleman v. United States.

18

Argument

I. Factual Background.

Defendant was employed by USDA Forest Service, a

United States government agency. Plaintiff was employed

by LBLA, a private association. Plaintiff ap" lied for a job

with USDA Forest Service. When plaintiff did not get the

job with USDA Forest Service, she exercised her right to file

a veterans’ preference inquiry with the U.S. Department of

Labor. Defendant Barry Haley became aware of the fact

that plaintiff had filed a veterans’ preference inquiry. De-

fendant Barry Haley acted to cause plaintiffs employer,

LBLA, to fire plaintiff. Complaint pages 1-5, 7, 8, 10.

Il. Defendant Barry Haley acted outside the scope of his

employment.

A. Plaintiffs complaint alleges that defendant Barry

Haley was“. . . acting outside the scope of his employment.”

Complaint page 7. After finding out from a Department of

Labor investigator that plaintiff had filed a veterans’ pref-

erence inquiry (Complaint page 4), defendant Barry Haley

“... induced, persuaded, or coerced defendant Gaye Luber

to discharge plaintiff from her job with defendant LBLA

in retaliation for plaintiff filing a veterans’ preference in-

quiry|.”] (Complaint page 7).

B. Attached to this response as “Exhibit A” is a copy of

a draft of a Memorandum of Understanding between U.S.

Forest Service and LBLA. It states in item 3 at the bottom

of page 4 “A Forest Service employee shall not partici-

pate in any LBLA decision concerning the relation-

ship of the LBLA to the Forest Service, including,

but not limited to executing or negotiating contracts,

signing checks, OR HIRING OR FIRING LBLA EM-

PLOYEES. (Emphasis added). Filed with this response as

“Exhibit B” is plaintiffs affidavit stating that she has infor-

mation credible information that a similar Memorandum of

Understanding was executed and in effect for the period in

which she was fired from her job.

19

C. In Coleman v. United States, 91 F.3d 820 (6th Cir.

1996), the court states four factors to consider under Ken-

tucky law to determine if an employee is acting in the scope

of his employment. 1) Whether the conduct was similar to

that which the employee was hired to perform; (2) whether

the action occurred substantially within the authorized spa-

cial and temporal limits of the employment; (3) whether the

action was in furtherance of the employer’s business; and

(4) whether the conduct, though unauthorized, was expec-

table in view of the employee’s duties. Citing Flechsig v.

United States, 991 F.2d 300, 303 (6th Cir. 1992); Frederick

v. Collins, 378 S.W.2d 617, 619 (Ky. Ct. App. 1964); Wood v.

Southeastern Greyhound Lines, 194 S.W.2d 81, 83 (Ky. Ct.

App. 1946).

Defendant Barry Haley’s conduct fails test 1 because

he was not hired by U.S. Forest Service to interfere in the

employment relationship of a private individual employed

by a private association. This was prohibited conduct.

Defendant Barry Haley’s conduct may or may not have

occurred at his employer’s place of business as discussed in

test 2, but this is irrelevant if the conduct itself was prohi-

bited.

Defendant Barry Haley’s conduct was not in further-

ance of the U.S. Forest Service business as required in test

3, and in fact acted to taint the image of his employer by

having a veteran fired from her job for exercising a legal

right.

Finally, defendant Barry Haley’s conduct was not auth-

orized by his employer as required in test 3. In fact, in the

draft Memorandum of Understanding discussed above, de-

fendant’s conduct was SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITED

by defendant’s employer (emphasis added).

Finally, plaintiff has attached as “Exhibit C” a letter

from Mr. Robert Kuenzli, the Department of Labor inves-

tigator who spoke with defendant Barry Haley concerning

20

plaintiff's veterans preference inquiry. The letter is to Mr.

Kuenzli’s supervisor and states that plaintiff was fired

because of the inquiry. While the letter may not be admis-

sible at trial, Mr. Kuenzli is expected to testify on plaintiffs

behalf.

Conclusion

The United States’ motion to dismiss should be denied

for the reasons outlined. In addition, the Attorney General’s

certification that defendant Barry Haley was acting in the

scope of his employment should be reversed. Barry Haley

should be resubstituted as defendant in this action ifhe has

been removed. In addition, any stay that has entered re-

lating to discovery should be lifted. A proposed order is at-

tached.

It is plaintiff's position that her complaint alleges facts

that, when viewed in the manner most favorable to plain-

tiff, show that defendant Barry Haley’s conduct was outside

the scope of his employment and should survive the United

States’ motion to dismiss. If the court were to view the com-

plaint as fatally defective, plaintiff will file a motion pursu-

ant to Rule 15(a), FRCP to amend her complaint to include

the additional facts alleged in this response. In this case,

plaintiff would ask the court to postpone ruling on the mo-

tion to dismiss until she can prepare a motion to amend her

complaint. Again, it is plaintiffs position that this is not

necessary and the motion to dismiss should be dismissed.

DATED: _1-26-04 BY: _/s/ Pat Osborn

Pat Osborn

[address and telephone number]

PLAINTIFF PRO SE

{Certificate of service omitted in printing]

21

[Exhibit A]

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING

BETWEEN THE

USDA FOREST SERVICE & LBLA

Federal Fiscal Year 2001

[The remainder of the text on this page is handwritten.]

9/22/00 FYO1

Final Version

Expired—> 9/30/01 /s/ William P. Lisowsky

William P. Lisowsky

Area Supervisor

Please

See P’s 4&5

herein

22

Fs agreement No. 11086001-020

Cooperator Tax # [blacked out]

9/22/00

Page 1 of 6

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING

BETWEEN THE

USDA FOREST SERVICES, LBL NRA

AND THE

LAND BETWEEN THE LAKES ASSOCIATION

The USDA Forest Service, LBL NRA (Forest Service),

and the Land Between The Lakes Association (LBLA), here-

by enter into the following Memorandum of Understanding

(MOU).

WITNESSETH:

Whereas, the Forest Service is responsible for developing

the National Forest resources for sustained yields of prod-

ucts and services in the best combination for the use, enjoy-

ment, and education of the American people, as provided in

the Organic Administration Act of 1897, the Multiple-Use

Sustained-Yield Act of 1960, and other laws. It is the policy

of Congress that the National Forests are established and

shall be administered for outdoor recreation, range, timber,

watershed, and wildlife and fish purposes.

Whereas, the Forest Service is conducting a program to pro-

vide facilities within the National Forest for outdoor recre-

ational and educational activities for the public; and

Whereas, the Forest Service deems it desirable to provide

educational and interpretive information about the forest

resources, natural phenomena, local history, and similar

matters; and

Whereas, the LBLA has as a purpose the promotion of the

educational, historical, scientific, and other values of LBL

and of assisting educational and interpretive activities of

the Forest Service;

23

Now therefore, in consideration of the above premises, the

parties agree as follows:

A.

Ff

P

LAND BETWEEN THE LAKES ASSOCIATION

SHALL:

Administer and staff each of LBL’s three visitor recep-

tionist facilities—the North and South Welcome Sta-

tions and the Golden Pond Visitor Center.

Greet and orient visitors.

Provide LBL and regional information.

Check game harvested at LBL.

Sell LBL user permits and maps.

Keep all appropriate daily records as requested by the

Forest Service.

Deposit in Forest Service designated night depositories

daily fee collections.

Arrange for basic cleaning services for the North and

South Welcome Stations.

Provide visitor receptionists for LBL’s Nature Station

and The Homeplace 1850.

Greet and orient visitors.

Collect fees for the respective facilities.

Keep all appropriate daily records as requested by the

Forest Service.

Deposit in Forest Service designated night depositories

daily fee collections.

Cooperatively provide major gift funds development

services for LBL.

Prepare an annual Funds Development Plan for LBL.

Identify major philanthropic markets.

24

Research potential funding opportunities and partner-

ship opportunities for LBL.

Prepare grant requests and other solicitation mater-

ials.

Maintain ongoing funds development records.

Provide direct delivery interpretive staff for LBL’s

Golden Pond Planetarium, Nature Station, The Home-

place 1850, Elk & Bison Prairie, and other sites within

LBL to meet Forest Service needs.

Hire, pay, and supervise direct delivery interpretive

staff.

Provide interpretive programs and events with direc-

tion from, and under the guidelines of, the US Forest

Service.

Assist in maintenance and care of artifacts and inter-

pretive materials.

Provide for maintenance and care of livestock and

wildlife under the US Forest Service and US Fish and

Wildlife guidelines and direction.

Participate in planning and development of physical

site, program, and exhibit improvements.

Provide the operational needs for LBL’s Elk & Bison

Prairie.

Collect monies from the machine on an as necessary

basis.

Deliver monies collected to the Forest Service deposi-

tory.

Replace token supply.

Replenish brochures in rack as necessary.

Clean dollar bill validating equipment weekly.

25

Keep financial and visitation records as required by

the Forest Service.

Keep the Elk & Bison Prairie free of litter.

Maintain the cleanliness of displays.

Distribute tokens to LBL staff and facilities as neces-

sary.

Administer the operations of the Golden Pond Plane-

tarium and Observatory.

Purchase and develop shows for the planetarium.

Arrange for the annual maintenance for the Spitz pla-

netarium equipment from Spitz, Inc.

Properly maintain al] current planetarium and observ-

atory equipment.

Promote visitation to the planetarium. «

Cooperatively provide administration for the LBL Vol-

unteer Program.

Identify and develop volunteer opportunities.

Recruit volunteers.

Train volunteers to the extent LBLA is qualified to do

so.

Acknowledge volunteer efforts.

Maintain volunteer records.

Provide administration of funds restricted for specific

uses at LBL.

Except as otherwise set forth by granting guidelines,

the LBLA will retain interest earned on restricted

funds for operational needs.

Administer an annual membership program.

26

10. Administer and staff retail operations at the Golden

11.

12.

Pond Visitor Center, the Nature Station, The Home-

place 1850, and North and South Welcome Stations for

the sale of educational and interpretive items for the

benefit of the visiting public.

Sell interpretive and educational items, such as pub-

lications, maps, visual aids, handicrafts, and other

objects directly related to the interpre sive and educa-

tional themes of the facilities at LBL.

Sell visitor convenience items as relate to the enjoy-

ment of LBL, such as tick spray, sunscreen, etc.

Not sell artifacts protected by the Antiquities Act of

1906 (P.L. 59-209), the Archeological Resources Protec-

tion Act of 1979 (P.L. 96-95), and the Alaska Historic

Preservation Act of 1971, as amended.

By this agreement, not be granted the right to sell

items that would infringe upon applicable contract

rights of concessionaires.

Maintain professional standards and quality in all

items produced or sold.

Sell items at fair market value.

Display the items in good taste and in keeping with the

general design and decor of the Forest Service facilities

at that location.

Provide soft drink and snack machines throughout

LBL for the convenience of LBL visitors.

Accounting Records

Be solely responsible for the financial arrangements

for the work under this agreement, including costs of

obtaining stocks of LBLA materials and for the receipt

and disposition of monies from sales, and hold harm-

less the Forest Service or its officers responsible for

loss of LBLA materials or money from sales, or for any

13.

27

other financial loss incurred as the result of this agree-

ment.

Keep appropriate financial books, records, and ac-

counts pertaining to this Agreement to standards ac-

ceptable to the Forest Service or generally acceptable

accounting practices.

Unless otherwise protected by law, allow authorized

officials or Agents of the Forest Service, or any other

Federal agency authorized to do so, to examine such

financial books, records, and accounts of the LBLA,

as deemed necessary by the Forest Service, or other

authorized Federal agency, and that these records and

accounts will be retained by the LBLA and kept avail-

able for at least 3 years, unless disposition is other-

wise authorized in writing by the Forest Service. Such

books, records, and accounts may be examined at any

reasonable and convenient time during such periods.

Provide two copies of form FS 2300-5, Annual Report

Interpretive Associations by April 15 each year to the

Regional Forester with a copy to the Forest Supervisor.

Other

Designate a LBLA member or employee who is auth-

orized to act as liaison with the Forest Service.

Maintain a distinct separation, evident to the public,

between the activities and management of the LBLA

and those of the Forest Service.

Reimburse the Forest Service for member benefit cou-

pons on discounted LBL fees.

Purchase at a minimum the Forest Service mandated

level of liability insurance for all LBLA activities.

FOREST SERVICE SHALL:

Technical Assistance

28

Provide broad program direction and guidance for

LBL’s Nature Station, The Homeplace 1850, and Elk

& Bison Prairie.

Provide technical assistance as required, i.e. provide

prompt updates to facility staff regarding operational

changes, interpretive planning, etc.

Include the Golden Pond Planetarium in promotional

materials produced for LBL.

Sale Items

Cooperate with the LBLA in the planning and design

of merchandise appropriate for sale by the LBLA at

the Forest Service facilities.

Maintain the right to request the discontinuance of

any sale item deemed inappropriate.

Facilities and Equipment

Provide the LBLA with such space and other facilities

as may hereafter be deemed necessary or desirable by

the Forest Service, provided that the Forest Service

reserves the right to relocate or withdraw any such

facilities, subsequent to reasonable notice, in order to

meet the needs of the Forest Service.

Provide the LBLA with appropriate storage space for

surplus sales inventory.

Provide the LBLA with a staging area for unpacking

and labeling sale items.

Provide the LBLA with adequate administrative office

space and interpreter office space.

Allow the LBLA to utilize Forest Service meeting

rooms as needed for regular business meetings and

meetings of the Board of Trustees.

Allow the LBLA free use of Forest Service copying and

facsimile machines.

29

Provide the LBLA an office/workroom in the Golden

Pond Visitor Center for planetarium staff.

Allow the LBLA to utilize Forest Service depositories

for temporary secure storage of daily sales receipts.

Make such surveys and inspections, as the Forest Ser-

vice deems necessary.

Reserve the right to design and construct any new fa-

cilities, and shall allow the LBLA review and comment

on any plans thereof.

Provide the LBLA with incidental utility services at

each assigned facility, including water, electricity,

heat, air conditioning, telephone, to the extent these

utilities are required for the operation of the building

for Governmental purposes.

Provide all general maintenance and repair services

for the Government-owned buildings. With the excep-

tion of basic cleaning of the North and South Welcome

Stations, which will be provided by the LBLA.

Provide computers, computer software, and computer

support services for LBLA interpretive staff.

Provide non-specialty computer software, and all com-

puter support services for all LBLA functions.

Personnel

Designate an employee as Interpretive Association Co-

ordinator who will serve as a liaison to the LBLA. The

role of the Interpretive Association Coordinator (liai-

son) is to represent the interests of the Forest Service

and to provide assistance to the LBLA; hence, he or

she shall not be a board member of the LBLA. His or

her scope of LBLA responsibility shall be limited to

ensuring that the spirit and intent of this Agreement

are fulfilled and to provide expertise to LBLA.

or

C.

30

Provide all employees who will establish program di-

rection and guidelines for LBL’s Nature Station, The

Homeplace 1850 and coordinate daily operations.

Other

Shall old harmless the LBLA for loss of materials or

money from sales, or for any other financial loss in-

curred as the result of this agreement.

Provide tokens to LBL’s Elk & Bison Prairie for LBLA

membership benefits.

IT IS MUTUALLY AGREED AND UNDERSTOOD BY

AND BETWEEN THE PARTIES THAT:

The LBLA’s Articles of Incorporation and the LBLA’s

By-Laws shall comply with requirements of the State

in which the LBLA is incorporated. Non-profit status

501(c)(3) must be maintained in accordance with Fed-

eral and state laws, and the LBLA will make available

for inspection, at the request of the Forest Service, doc-

uments demonstrating non-profit status. This Agree-

ment will automatically terminate if non-profit status

is lost.

Forest Service employees may be members of the

LBLA, but shall not be officers, LBLA employees, or

members of the Board of Trustees.

Forest Service employees shall not represent the LBLA

in any matter between the LBLA and the Forest Ser-

vice. A Forest Service employee shall not participate

in any LBLA decision concerning the relationship of

the LBLA to the Forest Service, including, but not lim-

ited to, executing or negotiating contracts, signing

checks, or hiring or firing LBLA employees.

Association personnel are not Government employees

and are not authorized to undertake any Government-

al function or activity on behalf of the Forest Service

beyond routine visitor information services and parti-

31

cipation in museums, living history, or like programs.

Association employees shall not engage in activities

that would reasonably lead the visiting public to con-

clude that they are Government employees. No LBLA

employee shall wear a Forest Service or other Govern-

ment employee uniform unless they are under a vol-

unteer agreement. All LBLA employees shall wear

some easily observable and readily identifiable indica-

tion of LBLA affiliation while working with the public

on LBLA business.

The Forest Service wil] authorize the LBLA’s entry,

occupancy and use of LBL land under the applicable

statutory authority when needed.

Any activities considered to be accomplished by the

parties directly benefiting the Forest Service and re-

quiring a payment by the Forest Service to the LBLA,

shall be accomplished using procurement procedures.

This agreement by itself, does not limit competition.

The rights and benefits conferred by this agreement

shall be subject to the laws of the United States gov-

erning the Forest Service and to the rules and regula-

tions promulgated hereunder, whether now in force or

hereafter enacted or provided; and the mention of spe-

cific restrictions, conditions, and stipulations herein

shall not be construed as in any way impairing the

general powers of supervision, regulation, and control

by the Forest Service.

Pursuant to Section 22, Title 41, United States Code,

no member of, or delegate to, Congress or Resident

Commissioner shall be admitted to any share or part

of this Agreement or to any benefit that may arise

there from, but this restriction shall not be construed

to extend to this Agreement if made with a corporation

or company for its general benefit.

10.

11.

12.

32

The LBLA agrees that all of its activities shal] be con-

ducted in accordance with all applicable laws and regu-

lations, both State and Federal. Specifically the LBLA

shall comply with the requirements of (a) Executive

Order No. 11246 of September 24, 1967; (b) Title V,

Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act of September 26,

1973 (P.L. 93-112), which requires contractors and co-

operators to take affirmative action to employ and to

advance in employment qualified handicapped individ-

uals; (c) Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and all

requirements imposed by or pursuant to the Regula-

tions of the U.S. Department of Agriculture (7 CFR,

Part 15) issued pursuant to that Act.

In all cases where rights or privileges are granted

herein in general or definite terms, the extent of the

use of such rights or privileges by the LBLA shall be

determined by further written agreement.

This agreement is neither a fiscal nor a funds obliga-

tion document. Any endeavor involving reimburse-

ment or contribution of funds between the parties to

this agreement will be handled in accordance with ap-

plicable laws, regulations, and procedures including

those for Government procurement and printing. Such

endeavors will be outlined in separate agreements that

shall be made in writing by representatives of the par-

ties and shall be independently authorized by appro-

priate statutory authority. This agreement does not

provide such authority. Specifically, this agreement

does not establish authority for noncompetitive award

to the cooperator of any contract or other agreement.

Any contract or other agreement for training or other

services must fully comply with all applicable require-

ments for competition

Either party, in writing, may terminate the agreement

in whole, or in part, at any time before the date of ex-

piration.

33

13. Modifications within the scope of this agreement shall

be made by the issuance of a bilaterally executed mod-

ification prior to any changes being performed.

14. This agreement in no way restricts the Forest Service

or the LBLA from participating in similar activities

with other public or private agencies, organizations,

and individuals.

15. This agreement is executed as of the last date shown

below and expires on September 30, 2001, at which

time it will be subject to review, renewal, or expiration.

16. The principal contacts for this agreement are:

William Lisowsky Gaye Luber

USDA Forest Service Executive Director

Land Between The Lakes Land Between The

NRA Area Supervisor Lakes Association

100 Van Morgan Drive 100 Van Morgan Drive

Golden Pond, Kentucky 42211 Golden Pond, Kentucky 42211

(270) 924-2000 (270) 924-2088

IN WITNESS WHEREOF the parties hereto have executed

this agreement as of the last date of signature:

USDA Forest Service, LBL NRA

By:

William Lisowsky, Area Supervisor

Date

Land Between The Lakes Association

By:

Gaye Luber, Executive Director

Date

34 |

[Exhibit B]

AFFIDAVIT

THE AFFIANT, after first being duly sworn, states as

follows:

1. My name is Pat Osborn and I reside at [address].

2. I am the plaintiff in the case Osborn v. Haley et al,

Civil Action No. 5:03-CV-00192-R, United States District

Court, Western District of Kentucky at Paducah.

3. It is my belief, based upon information from more

than one credible source, that at the time I was fired by my

employer LBLA, there was a “Memorandum of Understand-

ing” in effect between LBLA and the U.S. Forest Service,

Land Between the Lakes National Recreation Area. The

memorandum was similar to the one attached as “Exhibit

A” to plaintiff's Response to United States’ Motion to Dis-

miss. It also contained a similar provision specifically pro-

hibiting U.S. Forest Service employees from participating in

any LBLA decision regarding the hiring or firing of LBLA

employees.

/s/ Pat Osborn 1-26-04

Pat Osborn Date

[Jurat omitted in printing]

35

[Filed Feb. 9, 2004]

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY

AT PADUCAH

PAT OSBORN PLAINTIFF

v. CIVIL ACTION NO. 5:03-CV-00192-R

BARRY HALEY, Individually

GAYE LUBER

LAND BETWEEN THE

LAKES ASSOCIATION, INC. DEFENDANTS

UNITED STATES’ REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S

RESPONSE TO UNITED STATES’

MOTION TO DISMISS

The United States moved the court to dismiss the

above-styled case as against the federal defendant, and

plaintiff filed a response. The United States submits as

follows in reply thereto.

MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF UNITED

STATES’ REPLY TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE

E A MOTION DISMIS

INTRODUCTION

While working at Land Between the Lakes Association

(“LBL”), plaintiff, a veteran, applied for a Forest Service job.

When she was not hired for that job, she filed an inquiry

with the Department of Labor to find out whether she was

accorded veteran status in the hiring process. She claims

that LBL supervisor Gaye Luber and Forest Service man-

ager Barry Haley, unhappy with her Department of Labor

inquiry, conspired to fire her from her job at LBL.

36

The United States filed a motion to substitute the

United States for individual federal defendant Barry Haley

because he was acting within the scope of employment at all

times relevant to the common law tort allegations in the

complaint. The United States also moved to dismiss the

complaint for lack of jurisdiction because plaintiff failed to

file an administrative claim with the Forest Service before

bringing suit, as required by the Federal Tort Claims Act.

Plaintiffs sole response is to contest scope of employ-

ment. She argues that Haley’s alleged act of causing her

firing violated an agreement between the Forest Service

and LBLA, thus exceeding the scope of his employment un-

der Kentucky law. Response at 2, 3. As explained below,

however, plaintiff fails utterly to meet her burden of coming

forward with specific facts to refute the scope certification.

Accordingly, the United States should be substituted for

Barry Haley in this action, which should be dismissed for

failure to exhaust administrative remedies under the Fed-

eral Tort Claims Act.

ARGUMENT

A certification by the Attorney General is conclusive

evidence that the employee was acting within the scope of

his employment. Once the certification is filed, and plain-

tiff seeks to challenge it, the burden of proof on the question

of scope shifts to the plaintiff. See, e.g., Borneman v. United

States, 213 F.3d 819, 827 (4th Cir. 2000); Day v. Massachu-

setts Air National Guard, 167 F.3d 678, 685 (1st Cir. 1999);

Taboas v. Mlynezak, 149 F.3d 576, 581 (7th Cir. 1998); Pal-

mer v. Newton, 93 F.3d 196, 198 (5th Cir. 1996); Flohr v.

Mackojak, 84 F.3d 386, 390 (11th Cir. 1996); Billings v.

United States, 57 F.3d 797, 800 (9th Cir. 1995); Richman v.

Straley, 48 F.3d 1139, 1145 (10th Cir. 1995); Kimbro v,

Velten, 30 F.3d 1501, 1505 (D.C. Cir. 1994); Melo v. Hafer,

13 F.3d 736, 747 (3d Cir. 1994).

Plaintiff fails to meet her burden. Plaintiff argues her

complaint “alleges facts that show defendant Barry Haley

37

acted outside the scope of his employment when perform-

ing the acts which form the basis of plaintiff's complaint.”

Response at 1. The complaint does nothing of the sort. Ra-

ther, it states that Haley was employed by the Forest Ser-

vice at all times relevant to complaint. Complaint at { 6.

The complaint further states:

15. OnJune 17, 2002, plaintiff was contacted by

telephone by Mr. Robert Kuenzli, an investigator

with the United States Department of Labor,

and interviewed regarding the written veterans’

preference inquiry filed by the plaintiff with the

United States Department of Labor.

16. During plaintiffs conversation with Mr.

Kuenzli on June 17, 2002, Mr. Kuenzli asked

plaintiff whom he could contact at the U.S. Forest

Service to determine if plaintiff had received her

veterans’ preference points when being considered

for the position. Plaintiff told Mr. Kuenzli that

defendant Barry Haley should be contacted, and

provided his phone number. Plaintiff also stated

to Mr. Kuenzli that if defendant Barry Haley

found out that plaintiff had filed a veterans’

preference inquiry with the U.S. Department of

Labor, there was a good chance defendant Barry

Haley would cause plaintiff to lose her job.

17. On June 17, 2002, after his conversation

with plaintiff, Mr. Kuenzli contacted defendant

Barry Haley by telephone. While investigating

the award of veterans’ preference points to ap-

plicants in the hiring process for the Contract

Specialist Trainee, at defendant Barry Haley's

insistence, Mr. Kuenzli acknowledged that plain-

tiff had filed a written veterans’ preference in-

quiry with the Department of Labor.

38

Complaint at {9 15-17. The complaint next states that,

after Kuenzli’s conversation with Haley, Gaye Luber sum-

moned plaintiff to her office and asked her to apologize to

Haley, that plaintiff refused, and that two days later plain-

tiff was fired. Complaint at 7§ 18-20.

The foregoing constitute all the “facts” in the complaint

concerning Barry Haley’s conduct. These factual assertions

are insufficient to rebut the Attorney General’s certification

that Haley acted within the scope of his employment. To

be sure, the complaint additionally contains conclusory al-

legations that Haley “wrongfully and maliciously induced,

persuaded, or coerced defendant Gaye Luber to discharge

plaintiff’ from LBL. Complaint at 7, 8,10. These allega-

tions, however, have no putative factual basis in plaintiff's

own complaint. Plaintiffs bare assumption of a nexus be-

tween her firing and her veterans’ preference inquiry is in-

adequate to provide a factual basis for challenging the scope

certification. Plaintiff presents no facts, either in her com-

plaint or in her response to the motion to substitute, that

would support her allegation that Haley acted outside the

scope of his employment. Accordingly, the Attorney Gen-

eral’s certification must stand. See, e.g., Rogers v. Manage-

ment Technology, Inc., 123 F.3d 34, 37 (1st Cir. 1997).

Plaintiff attached to her response two documents, nei-

ther of which provides support for her claims. The first is a

memorandum of understanding between LBL and the For-

est Service which states in pertinent part that the latter will

not interfere in LBL’s employment matters. As discussed

above, plaintiff alleged no facts to support an inference that

Haley even attempted to affect her employment.

Plaintiff also attached to her response a letter from

Department of Labor investigator Robert Kuenzli stating

that his phone call to Haley caused Osborn to “loose [sic] her

job.” However, the letter is of no probative value as it is

clearly based entirely on plaintiffs complaints to the inves-

tigator.

39

CONCLUSION

For the reasons stated above, in its motion to substi-

tute, and in its motion to dismiss, the United States should

be substituted as sole defendant herein in place of federal

defendant Barry Haley, and the action should be dismissed

for failure to exhaust administrative remedies under the

Federal Tort Claims Act.

Respectfully submitted,

DAVID L. HUBER

United States Attorney

/s/ W. Brady Miller

W. Brady Miller

Assistant U.S. Attorney

510 W. Broadway, 10th Floor

Louisville, KY 40202

(502) 582-5166

(Certificate of service omitted in printing]

40

[Filed Mar. 24, 2004]

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY

AT PADUCAH

PAT OSBORN PLAINTIFF

v. CIVIL ACTION NO. 5:03-CV-00192-R

BARRY HALEY, Individually

GAYE LUBER

LAND BETWEEN THE

LAKES ASSOCIATION, INC. DEFENDANTS

UNITED STATES’ MOTION TO RECONSIDER

ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS AND

SUBSTITUTION OF UNITED STATES FOR

FEDERAL DEFENDANT BARRY HALEY

The United States, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e),

moves the court to reconsider its Order entered March 12,

2004, denying the United States’ motion to dismiss and

overruling the United States’ substitution of itself as de-

fendant herein in place of federal defendant Barry Haley.

In support, the United States submits the following memo-

randum of law.

MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO

RECONSIDER ORDER DENYING MOTION

TO DISMISS AND SUBSTITUTION OF

UNITED STATES FOR FEDERAL

DEFENDANT BARRY HALEY

The United States, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e),

moves the court to reconsider its Order entered March 12,

2004, denying the United States’ motion to dismiss and

overruling the United States’ substitution of itself as de-

41

fendant herein in place of federal defendant Barry Haley.

In support, the United States submits as follows:

INTRODUCTION

By order entered March 12, 2004, this court denied the

United States’ substitution of itself as defendant in place

of Barry Haley, and overruled the United States’ motion to

dismiss for failure to file an administrative claim. The court

also remanded the action to the Trigg County Circuit Court.

(R. 20: Order). In its memorandum opinion accompanying

the order, the court found that plaintiff adequately alleged

conduct that, if proven, would fall outside the scope of Barry

Haley’s employment. Since the court believed the United

States did not contest the allegations, it accepted them as

conclusive on the issue of scope, and found that the United

States could not be substituted as defendant. (R. 19: Memo-

randum and Opinion at 4, 6). The court also found no need

for an evidentiary hearing on the issue of scope, again be-

cause it believed the United States did not deny plaintiffs

factual allegations. (Jd. at 4). Finally, the court decided

that since the United States was not a proper party defend-

ant, the matter must be remanded to the state court. (Ud.

at 6, 7).

The United States moves the court to reconsider its

rulings. First, the United States, as evidenced by the an-

swer it filed herein and by the attached Declarations, vigor-

ously contests plaintiff's allegations. At the least, the court

should hold a hearing or otherwise further consider the evi-

dence relating to scope, as Barry Haley has done nothing

which can be construed to fall outside the scope of his em-

ployment.

The United States also notes that, if court reconsiders

it rulings herein, allows the substitution, and grants the

motion to dismiss, plaintiff would yet have remedies within

the federal system. Although the dismissal would be with

prejudice as to this action, under the Federal Tort Claims

Act, plaintiff may file an administrative claim with the For-

42

est Service within two years of when her claim accrued. If

denied, the claim could then be pursued in federal court

under a separate action, provided the requirements of the

Act are met.

ARGUMENT

I. THE UNITED STATES CONTESTED AND

CONTINUES TO CONTEST PLAINTIFF'S

ALLEGATIONS THAT BARRY HALEY ACTED

OUTSIDE THE SCOPE OF HIS EMPLOYMENT.

A. The Answer Specifically Refutes Plaintiff's

Allegations.

The United States filed its answer herein on May 19,

2003. (R. 7: Answer). In it, the United States denied each

and every factual allegation by plaintiff against Barry

Haley. Plaintiffs “First Cause of Action” is alleged against

Luber alone. Plaintiffs “Second Cause of Action, Inter-

ference with Employment Relationship” is alleged against

Haley alone. (R.1: Notice of Removal, Exhibit 1 (complaint)

at 7, ]§ 27-31). The United States specifically denied the

allegations contained therein. (R. 7: Answer at 3, JJ 12-14).

This includes a denial that Haley acted outside the scope of

his employment. (R. 1: Notice of Removal, Exhibit 1 at 7,

{ 29; R. 7: Answer at 3, 9 14).

Plaintiffs “Third Cause of Action, Conspiracy to

Wrongfully Discharge Plaintiff is alleged against both

Luber and Haley. (/d. at 8, |] 32-38). The United States

specifically denied the allegations contained therein. (R. 7:

Answer at 3, J] 15-17). Plaintiff's “Fourth Cause of Action,

Conspiracy to Interference with Plaintiff's Employment Re-

lationship” is alleged against both Luber and Haley. (/d. at

10, {4 39-45). The United States specifically denied the al-

legations contained therein. (R. 7: Answer at 3-4, JJ 18-20).

This includes a denial that Haley acted outside the scope of

his employment. (R. 1: Notice of Removal, Exhibit 1 at 10,

9 41; R. 7: Answer at 3, J 19).

43

Plaintiffs “Fifth Cause of Action, Outrageous Conduct”

is alleged against both Luber and Haley. (/d. at 11, JJ 46-

53). The United States specifically denied the allegations

contained therein. (R. 7: Answer at 4, JJ 21-23). Plaintiff's

“Sixth Cause of Action, Conspiracy-Outrageous Conduct” is

alleged against both Luber and Haley. (/d. at 13, J] 54-61).

The United States specifically denied the allegations con-

tained therein. (R. 7: Answer at 4, J 24-26).

“The theory of Rules 8(b) and (d) is that a defendant’s

pleading should apprise the opponent of the allegations in

the complaint that stand admitted and will not be in issue

at trial and those that are contested and will require proof

to established to enable plaintiff to prevail.” Wright & Mil-

ler, 5 Fed. Prac. & Proc. Civ. 2d § 1261 at 1 (2004) (citing

cases). The filing of a responsive pleading by the United

States squarely placed in controversy the matters asserted

in the complaint, and put all on notice that the United

States contested plaintiffs allegations against Mr. Haley.

B. Both Barry Haley and Gave Luber (now

Gieselman) Contest Plaintiffs Allegations.

“Plaintiff's action is based on the fact that she was dis-

charged from her employment at LBLA in retaliation for

exercising her legal right in requesting an [Department of

Labor] inquiry.” (R. 18: Plaintiffs Reply to Motion to Dis-

miss at 3). The foregoing statement by plaintiff forms the

gravamen of her entire complaint. (See R. 1: Notice of Re-

moval, Exhibit 1 (complaint)).

Attached are Declarations from Barry Haley and Gaye

Luber (now Gaye Gieselman) specifically contesting plain-

tiffs allegations that she was fired in retaliation for contact-

ing the Department of Labor regarding consideration of her

veteran’s preference in connection with her application for a

Forest Service position. In his Declaration, attached hereto

as Exhibit 1, Barry Haley asserts that he is employed by the

U.S. Department of Agriculture (“USDA”) Forest Service as

Business Manager at Land Between the Lakes National

44

Recreation Area. (Haley Declaration at J 1). Mr. Haley

further states that in Spring 2002, the USDA Forest Service

advertised the position of Contracting Officer Trainee to

work in the Business Department at Land Between The

Lakes National Recreation Area. (Jd. at J 2). Mr. Haley

states that applications for the position were received at the

USDA Forest Service Regional Personnel Office in Atlanta,

Georgia, for ranking and personnel certification. (Jd.) The

Personnel Office sent to Haley’s office a personnel certifi-

cate ranking the candidates for the position. (/d.). By reg-

ulation, Mr. Haley could only consider the top three candi-

dates, who were all highly qualified Veterans Preference

candidates. (/d.). Pat Osborn was not listed as one of the

top three candidates, Haley did not know she had applied

for the position. /d.). On May 20, 2002, Haley announced

the selection of the new Contracting Officer Trainee. (Jd. at

{ 3). On June 17, 2002, he received a telephone call from

Robert Kuenzli at the Department of Labor inquiring whe-

ther Pat Osborn’s status as a veteran was considered in con-

nection with the posting for the Contracting Officer Trainee

position. (Ud. at J 4). After Haley’s office faxed to him a

copy of the personnel certificate, Mr. Kuenzli confirmed

that the matter was handled correctly. (Ud.).

Mr. Haley further states that, before Gaye Luber ter-

minated Pat Osborn’s employment with the Land Between

the Lakes Association, he had no communication with Ms.

Luber about the Department of Labor inquiry, or whether

Osborn’s veteran status was considered in connection with

her application for Contract Officer Trainee. (Jd. at 7 5).

Mr. Haley states that he had no advance knowledge of the

termination of Osborn’s employment at LBLA, that he did

not advise Gaye Luber regarding the matter, and that he

did not attempt to influence her independent decision to fire

Ms. Osborn. (/d. at J 6).

Gaye Gieselman, formerly Gaye Luber, has also sub-

mitted a Declaration further controverting plaintiff's claims.

See Declaration, attached hereto as Exhibit 2. Ms. Gie-

45

selman states that, acting as Executive Director of Land

Between the Lakes Association, Inc., she terminated Pat

Osborn from her employment with LBLA on June 19, 2002.

(Gieselman Declaration at J 2). She states that at the time

she terminated Pat Osborn, she had no knowledge that

Osborn had raised any sort of issue or had complained to

anyone, either formally or informally, regarding whether

her veteran's status was considered in the course of her job

application with the Forest Service. (/d. at J 3). At the

time she terminated Pat Osborn, Gieselman had not dis-

cussed this issue with Barry Haley, Pat Osborn, or anyone

else, and did not know it existed. (/d.).

Ms. Gieselman further states that, prior to Osborn’s

termination, Gieselman met with her on June 17 to discuss

problems with her employment, and that her veteran’s pre-

ference status was not mentioned at all during this meeting.

(Id. at J 4). She also states that Osborn’s alleged complaint

about consideration of her veteran status in applying for a

Forest Service job was not, and could not have been, a factor

in the decision to terminate Ms. Osborne [sic], because she,

Ms. Gieselman, did not know about the complaint. (/d. at

q 5).

The foregoing Declarations by Barry Haley and Gaye

Gieselman (formerly Gaye Luber) provide ample evidence

that Barry Haley never acted outside the scope of his em-

ployment and directly and specifically controvert any alle-

gations to the contrary.

II. BECAUSE THERE IS AN ISSUE OF MATERIAL

FACT WITH REGARD TO WHETHER HALEY

ACTED WITHIN THE SCOPE, THE COURT

SHOULD FURTHER CONSIDER THE ISSUE,

INCLUDING, IF NECESSARY, FURTHER

DEVELOPMENT OF THE RECORD.

As shown above, the United States vigorously contests

plaintiffs allegations that Barry Haley acted outside the

scope of his employment. The United States respectfully

46

requests that the court revisit this issue and decide it in

favor of the United States, based on its answer filed herein

and on the additional evidence provided. Alternatively, the

United States asks that the court allow limited discovery

and/or hold an evidentiary hearing to resolve this issue.

As argued previously, plaintiff has not met her burden

in attempting to contest the certification of scope. (R. 17:

Reply at 2); see also Schrob v. Catterson, 967 F.2d 929, 935

(3d Cir. 1992) (if certification is challenged, plaintiff must

come forward with specific facts rebutting the certification);

Raisig v. United States, 34 F. Supp. 2d 1053, 1055 (W.D.

Mich. 1998) (“The plaintiff must come forward with specific

evidence or the forecast of specific evidence that contradicts

the Attorney General’s certification decision, not mere con-

clusory allegations and speculation.” (citations omitted)).

This burden must be met by a preponderance of the evi-

dence. Jd. at 1054. Here, the certification of the U.S. At-

torney that Haley acted within scope, together with the De-

clarations of Haley and Gieselman (Luber), are sufficient

to establish scope absent specific facts from plaintiff. If, as

Mr. Haley and Ms. Gieselman both have stated, they had no

communication regarding Osborn’s veterans preference in-

quiry or her firing, then Haley cannot possibly have acted

outside the scope of his employment. Plaintiff has put for-

ward no facts sufficient to contest the showing that Haley

acted within scope.

At the least, however, the court should find that the

evidence now in the record presents a legitimate issue of

material fact. If the court continues to believe that plaintiff

has met her burden of putting forward specific facts sup-

porting an argument that Haley acted outside the scope,

then limited discovery may be indicated regarding the issue.

See, e.g., Maron v. United States, 126 F.3d 317, 322 (4th Cir.

1997); Melo v. Hafer, 13 F.3d 736, 747 (3d Cir. 1994). Such

discovery should be “circumscribed as narrowly as possible,”

and limited to scope of employment issues. Schrob, 967

F.2d at 936; see also Maron, 126 F.3d at 327; Gutierrez de

47

Martinez v. Drug Enforcement Administration, 111 F.3d

1148, 1154-55 (4th Cir. 1997).

Allowing limited discovery on the scope issue, includ-

ing exploration of Osborn’s employment record, could also

reveal evidence supporting an argument that, even if the

allegations are true, the alleged conduct falls within the rel-

evant Kentucky law on scope. For example, plaintiff alleges

that Haley influenced Luber to fire her because he was

upset plaintiff filed a Department of Labor complaint.

Assuming, for the sake of argument only, that Haley and

Luber interacted regarding plaintiffs employment, Haley

would conceivably know of any job-related problems that

could have contributed to Osborn’s firing, such as poor work

performance, bad attitude, being a trouble-maker, or the

like. In such a scenario, Haley’s alleged conduct of causing

Osborn’s firing could be construed as for the benefit of the

Forest Service, due to that entity’s interest in not having its

employees work closely with undesirable or poor-performing

“Forest Service partners.” Such conduct arguably would

have taken place within the spacial and temporal limits

of Haley’s work, would be similar to his work as Business

Manager, would further his employer's goals of partnering

with competent contract employees in a healthy and produc-

tive work environment, and would not be unexpectable by

the Forest Service. See Booker v. GTE.net LLC, 350 F.3d

515, 518-19 (6th Cir. 2003).

If, after discovery limited as described above, the court

determines that a genuine issue of material fact remains, a

pretrial hearing is indicated in order to resolve whether the

United States should be substituted as the proper party

defendant. Taboas v. Mlynczak, 149 F.3d 576, 580 (7th Cir.

1998). At such a hearing, the court would hear evidence

from each party on the scope of employment issue. Arthur

v. United States, 45 F.3d 292, 295 (9th Cir. 1995); Melo, 13

F.3d at 747; Kimbro v. Velten, 30 F.3d 1501, 1509 (D.C. Cir.

1994). As with discovery on the scope issue, any such hear-

ing should be “narrowly circumscribed” and limited to the

48

facts in material dispute which have a bearing on scope of

employment. Schrob, 967 F.2d at 936; Gutierrez, 111 F.3d

at 1154-55.

Here, the court decided the scope issue against the

United States without holding a hearing, stating the United

States had not presented evidence contesting plaintiff's al-

legations. As argued above, the answer filed by the United

States and the additional evidence submitted herewith de-

monstrate that the United States contests the allegations

and that an issue of fact exists. Moreover, the case cited by

this court in ruling that no evidentiary hearing was neces-

sary seems to support the right of the United States to a

hearing prior to any adverse ruling on scope. In the case of

Rutkofske v. Norman, 114 F.3d 1188, 1997 WL 299382 (6th

Cir. (Mich.) June 4, 1997), the court stated:

The government supported its motion to dismiss

with evidence—in the form of the certification—

that [federal employee’s] conduct was within the

scope of his employment. Our prior cases make

it clear that a plaintiff must submit relevant evi-

dence in response to such a motion or face dis-

missal. Because Rutkofske failed to present any

relevant evidence to oppose the motion, there was

no fact at issue and no need to hold an evidenti-

ary hearing.

Id. at **4. Respectfully, the above-cited section of the op-

inion appears to suggest that all the government need do

to sufficiently support a motion to dismiss, is to file a cer-

tification of scope. If plaintiff then submits sufficient evi-

dence in opposition, a hearing is warranted. As this court

observed, the Rutkofske court noted that other courts ad-

dressing the issue have held a hearing necessary “only if

there is conflicting evidence as to a material fact.” IZd., cit-

ing McAdams v. Reno, 64 F.3d 1137, 1145 (8th Cir. 1995);

Kimbro, 30 F.3d at 1509; Melo, 13 F.3d 747. However, the

courts in two of the cited cases——as well as the Rutkofske

49

court—applied thet test to plaintiffs failure to rebut the

Attorney General’s certification, not to the government.

McAdams, 64 F.3d at 1145 (McAdams “failed to come for-

ward with sufficient evidence to undermine’ certification);

Kimbro, 30 F.3d at 1509 (certification given prima facie ef-

fect “which obliges plaintiff to come forward after reason-

able discovery with evidence supporting his allegations both

as to scope and as to the merits”). The third case cited by

Rutkofske may prove particularly instructive in the instant

case. In Melo, 13 F.3d at 736, 747, plaintiff brought an ac-

tion against a United States Attorney and others claiming

that they conspired to interfere with her contractual rela-

tionships. Jd. at 739. The district court concluded that for

purposes of determining scope it must accept as true the

facts alleged in the complaint. Jd. at 740. Because the con-

duct alleged, if true, would have exceeded the scope of the

U.S. Atte ney’s employment, the district court denied, with-

out a hearing, the United States’ motion to substitute. Jd.

at 741. Concluding “that a district court need not accept the

allegations of the complaint as true when deciding a motion

for substitution,” the Third Circuit reversed and remanded

for a hearing on the issue of scope. Jd. at 739. This court

should follow the same path as the court in Melo. To let

stand its decision in this case would mean that all a plain-

tiff need do to defeat a substitution motion is to allege con-

duct on the part of a defendant which, if proven, would fall

outside the scope of employment. A federal employee who

legitimately contests said allegations, as here, is entitled to

have the scope issue determined in a federal forum. See,

e.g., Kimbro, 30 F.3d at 1505 (though scope question and

merits in case “often overlap, sometimes exactly,” Westfall

statute precludes remand to state court before scope issue

is resolved).

CONCLUSION

Based upon all of the foregoing, the United States re-

spectfully requests that the court grant its motion to re-

consider its Order entered March 12, 2004, overruling the

50

United States’ motion to substitute itself as defendant, and

denying its motion to dismiss. The United States respect-

fully requests that the court enter a finding that federal

employee Barry Haley acted within the scope of his employ-

ment, substitute the United States, and dismiss the case.

Alternatively, the United States asks the court to provide

both parties the opportunity for discovery specifically lim-

ited to the issue of scope, and/or conduct an evidentiary

hearing on that narrow issue.

Respectfully submitted,

DAVID L. HUBER

United States Attorney

/s/ W ill

W. Brady Miller

Assistant U.S. Attorney

510 W. Broadway, 10” Floor

Louisville, KY 40202

(502) 582-5166

[Certificate of service omitted in printing]

51

[Exhibit 1)

DECLARATION PURSUANT TO 28 U.S.C. § 1746

1. 1am Barry Haley, employed by the U.S. Depart-

ment of Agriculture Forest Service as Business Manager at

Land Between the Lakes National Recreation Area.

2. In Spring 2002, the USDA Forest Service adver-

tised the position of Contracting Officer Trainee to work in

my Business Department at Land Between The Lakes Na-

tional Recreation Area. Applications for the position were

received at the USDA Forest Service Regional Personnel

Office in Atlanta, Georgia, for ranking and personnel certi-

fication. The Personnel Office sent to my office a personnel

certificate ranking the candidates for the position. My con-

sideration was limited by regulation to the top three candi-

dates who were all highly qualified Veterans Preference

candidates. Pat Osborn was not listed as one of the top

three candidates, and I did not know she had applied for

the position.

3. On May 20, 2002, I announced the selection of the

new Contracting Officer Trainee.

4. OnJune 17, 2002, I received a telephone call from

Robert Kuenzli at the Department of Labor. Mr. Kuenzli

inquired whether Pat Osborn’s status as a veteran had been

considered in connection with the posting for the Contract-

ing Officer Trainee position. My office faxed to him a copy

of the personnel certificate on the position from the Forest

Service Personnel Office. Mr. Kuenzli confirmed that the

matter was handled correctly.

5. Before Gaye Luber terminated Pat Osborn’s em-

ployment with the Land Between the Lakes Association, I

had no communication with Ms. Luber regarding the De-

partment of Labor inquiry to my office, nor regarding whe-

ther Osborn’s veteran status was considered in connection

with her application for Contract Officer Trainee.

52

6. I had no advance knowledge of the termination

of Pat Osborn’s employment with Land Between the Lakes

Association. I did not advise Gaye Luber regarding the mat-

ter, nor did I attempt to influence her independent decision

to fire Ms. Osborn.

Certification

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of

the United States of America that the foregoing is true and

correct.

Executed this 22™ day of March, 2004.

/s/ Barry W. Haley

Barry Haley

53

[Exhibit 2]

DE TION PURS 28 U.S.C. § 17

I, Gaye Gieselman, do declare and state as follows:

1. I was known as Gaye Luber at the time of the

events in question in this litigation.

2. Acting as Executive Director of Land Between the

Lakes Association, Inc., I terminated Pat Osborn from her

employment with LBLA on June 19, 2002.

3. At the time I terminated Pat Osborn, I had no

knowledge that she had raised any sort of issue or regis-

tered any sort of complaint, formal or otherwise, to any per-

son or entity, regarding whether her veteran’s status was

considered in the course of her job application with the For-

est Service. At the time I terminated Pat Osborn, I had not

discussed this issue with Barry Haley, Pat Osborn, or any-

one else, and did not know it existed.

4. Prior to her termination, I met with Ms. Osborn

on June 17 to discuss problems with her employment. Her

veteran's preference status was not mentioned at all during

this meeting.

5. Pat Osborn’s alleged complaint about considera-

tion of her veteran status in applying for a Forest Service

job was not and could not have been a factor in my decision

to terminate Ms. Osborne [sic], because I did not know it

had occurred.

54

Certification

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of

the United States of America that the foregoing is true and

correct.

Executed this 22 day of March _ , 2004.

/s/ Gave Gieselman

Gaye Gieselman

{handwritten telephone number?]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.