Opposition Brief — SD Warren Co. v. Maine Bd. of Environmental Protection
Supreme Court brief2006
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
@
No. 04-1527
Supreme Cour tS
JUN 15 2095"
| OFMICE OF” 2E tii
~
In The
Supreme Court of the Anited States
¢
S.D. WARREN COMPANY,
Petitioner,
v.
MAINE DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION,
Respondent.
sf
On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari
To The Maine Supreme Judicial Court
SJ
BRIEF FOR THE INTERVENORS IN OPPOSITION
¢
SEAN MAHONEY
(Counsel of Record)
VERRILL DANA, LLP
One Portland Square
Portland, ME 04112
(207) 774-4000
RONALD A. KREISMAN
25 Page Street
Hallowell, ME 04347-1418
(207) 626-0248
Attorneys for Intervenors
American Rivers and Friends
of the Presumpscot River
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
QUESTIONS PRESENTED BY PETITIONER
Does the mere flow of water through an existing dam
constitute a “discharge” under Section 401, 33 U.S.C.
§ 1341, of the Clean Water Act, despite this Court’s
holding last year in Miccosukee that a discharge re-
quires the addition of water from a distinct body of
water?
Does the State of Maine’s expansive application of
Section 401 conflict with the Federal Energy Regula-
tory Commission’s comprehensive licensing authority
over hydroelectric generating projects under the Fed-
eral Power Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 791a et seq.?
ii
- PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS
The parties to the proceedings are Petitioner S.D.
Warren Company, the owner and operator of five hydroe-
lectric projects on the Presumpscot River (the “Projects”),
Respondent Maine Department of Environmental Protec-
tion (“DEP”), the state agency that issued the Section 401
water quality certification at issue, and Intervenors
American Rivers and Friends of the Presumpscot River,
who have been parties in this action at all stages of admin-
istrative and judicial review. Pet. App. 18, 21, and 37.
RULE 29.6 STATEMENT
American Rivers is a not-for-profit corporation organ-
ized in Washington, D.C. Friends of the Presumpscot River
is a non-profit entity organized pursuant to the Maine
Nonprofit Corporations Act, 13 M.R.S.A. §§ 101-1406.
Neither entity has a parent company nor has either issued
stock. Each is recognized as tax exempt under Section
501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Questions Presented by Petitioner ........................:000008 i
Parties to the Proceedings ................c.cccsceceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees ii
EE eT ii
eT v
a ee 1
EE ee 1
Ee 1
STIs edecrebrmecinticeedneseousssssesenegecccosescsccccococes 3
EE 3
1. Petitioner’s First Question Presented for Review
Fails, Procedurally and Substantively, to Meet
the Standards for Granting Certiorari ................ 4
A. Petitioner’s Failure to Raise or Address
the First Question Presented Before the
SJC Requires Denial of Certiorari ............. 4
B. The SJC’s Decision That Petitioner’s Pro-
jects Result in a Discharge Under Section
401 Is Consistent With Prior Decisions of
This Court and Courts of Appeals .............. 5
i. The SJC’s Decision Does Not Conflict
oe 6
ii. The Maine SJC’s Decision Does Not
Conflict With Other Decisions of This
Court or Courts of Appeals................... 7
iii. The Application of Section 401 Re-
quires No Clarification From This
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS -— Continued
Page
2. The Second Question Presented By Peti-
tioner Does Not Present A Conflict Or
Controversy That Merits This Court’s Re-
WE ccncccisnsiesicdnneiicitniiibantshtniethieanisatitiiiiaimbinniaiitinn 13
I SADT T ET ne 15
Vv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
FEDERAL CASES
Alabama Rivers Alliance v. FERC, 325 F.3d 290
ets MEE SUT scncenicisiticncinneidnliiiienianidnsisinibiiniamsmieaianes 9, 11,12
California v. FERC, 495 U.S. 490 (1990)..................0000000s 13
Catskill Mountains Chapter of Trout Unlimited,
Inc. v. City of New York, 273 F.3d 481 (2nd Cir.
See ccrsctinnteenriesininsstiaittaiteaantituhiaiiedeiagasdeideasiitecabdiiiaaintlaadiaa tid 8, 12
Dubois v. Department of Agriculture, 102 F.3d 1273
eS TEI: TUITE insecieicicehsesnbiiavandieninpuaibinnaebeapscticiupiaietaendibiitile 7,12
Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (1982)............ cece ceeeeeeeeeeeeees 4
Nat'l Wildlife Fed’n v. Consumers Power Co., 862
ee EET TIEED: TUTTI sicitsicniceiciasniiinisieitainareniapasiuminintidataish 7,12
North Carolina v. FERC, 112 F.3d 1175 (D.C. Cir.
IITUT icsicisienisiniunecienitaiiienainalitinihiaiindiguieiinsitaaceamaiiil 9, 10, 11, 12
Oregon Natural Desert Ass’n v. Dombeck, 172 F.3d
IE Be cinncccninsnisieticetiinichietsctiitennpatasiiniiuipaiuiaiinatiia 12
PUD No. 1 v. Washington Dep't of Ecology, 511 U.S.
Fe IE ccrsccesnnstnrreniiesinnnnnnennennenintaniniineaened passim
South Florida Water Mgmt. Dist. v. Miccosukee
een 3, 4, 6, 7, 8
Yee v. City of Escondido, 503 U.S. 519 (1992).................004. 5
STATE CASES
Power Authority of New York v. Williams, 101
el icisiiscinsnsciinerciiiiiteaiensiinmintaieatenansiinaiinial .12
S.D. Warren Co. v. Board of Environmental Protec-
ae, See ee Oe Ge cannsenctcescsderseteemniasenensscsenienenean 1
vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES — Continued
Page
STATUTES AND REGULATIONS
ee OE 3
STE, UN TITTITTT coininerninitnnniiccdinenpaieniibatipuesesinmmedioaeis 14
SPE ETEts Ut TIE nscsenisstanteituncecuaiipansitiiennisundnandmintdamenesetiinattil 14
its Ue aT atecccisccnciinniceieninietantsedsidienajapiiendinsbeemamainedetes 1
ee sO SII sccvecsiesiissipcianeiiinisicingsiiainicleitataalaianiniaiboaiiibid 2,7
8 RRR NRO NU Den mE E TEN 3, 14
as iii eisa iinet ciihininintetciaeeneeaa cla ial neate 7
te Hi TTTIET sciinicieccieni hicesieniamnnenciteiniiinicipniiibnisbeabigsidiiieiinibidin 7
SC Ue TIITII ssiccstncssinsinnniniicniesiibciiileaniapiniiibiiiat ial alia leaden 7
I i I a iiciaicciciiaiaiaciiaasiiaiisiieaiialealiniiaioniaeliabiaiiais 6
AGENCY DECISIONS
City of Augusta, Georgia, 109 F.E.R.C. { 62,210
SITs aaah inna 12
City of Fort Smith, 42 F.E.R.C. J 61,362 (1988)............... 13
In re Central Vermont Pub. Serv. Corp., 85 F.E.R.C.
ans OUIIITIIIE cbcisihtchnnnsinniedchigheindimenddeiniiiiadiinialibsinimaiibais 13
S.D. Warren Co., 105 F.E.R.C. J 61,013 (2003)................... 3
Virginia Electric and Power Co., 77 F.E.R.C.
| TE A ean ence nS ae a ERA NN TP TEN een 11
Vii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES -— Continued
Page
OTHER
Brief for Petitioner, PUD No. 1 v. Washir~ton Dep't
of Ecology, 511 U.S. 700 (1994), 1993 W. 632338. .......... 9
Brief of the United States as Amicus Curiae, PUD
No. 1 v. Washington Dep't of Ecology, 511 US.
700 (1994) (1992 Lexis U.S. Briefs 1911).................e0ee 9
1
OPINIONS BELOW
The decision of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court
(“SJC”) is reported at S.D. Warren Co. v. Board of Envi-
ronmental Protection, 2005 ME 27 (2005). Pet. App. 1-18.
The decision of the Maine Superior Court (Pet. App. 19-34)
is unreported.
¢
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the SJC was entered on February 15,
2005. Pet. App. 1. The petition for a writ of certiorari was
filed on May 12, 2005. This Court’s jurisdiction is invoked
under 28 U.S.C. § 1257(a).
4
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Petitioner owns seven dams on the Presumpscot
River, which stretches just 27 miles from Maine’s Sebago
Lake to the Atlantic Ocean. Six of Petitioner’s dams
generate electricity by removing water from the Presump-
scot, running that water through turbines, and then
discharging that water back into the Presumpscot. In
2001, five of those dams (the “Projects”) required new
licenses from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
(“FERC”) in order to continue operating. Current opera-
tions of the Projects prevent the Presumpscot River from
meeting its water quality standards.’
* The DEP made this finding, see Pet. App. 88-89, 106-107, 111-112,
116, and it was affirmed by three reviewing tribunals. Pet. App. 12, 25-
33, and 49. Specifically, Petitioner’s Projects significantly alter the
(Continued on following page)
2
Petitioner’s Projects are licensed by FERC. Section
401 of the Clean Water Act (“CWA”) requires that any
applicant for a federal license whose operations “may
result in any discharge into the navigable waters” obtain a
certification from the affected state that such discharge
will comply with state water quality standards. 33 U.S.C.
§ 1341(a)(1).
In 1999, Petitioner filed applications to renew the
FERC licenses for its Projects that were to expire in 2001.
As required by Section 401, Petitioner also filed applica-
tions with the Maine Department of Environmental
Protection (“DEP”) for water quality certification. As is
routine with virtually all states in FERC relicensing
procedures, Maine reviewed the impacts of Petitioner’s
Projects on the Presumpscot’s ability to meet its water
quality standards. The Maine DEP then issued its Section
401 certification in April 2003, with conditions that DEP
determined were necessary to ensure that operation of the
Projects will not continue to violate those water quality
standards. Pet. App. 121-139. As required by the CWA and
its own regulations, FERC incorporated Maine’s Section
chemical, physical and biological nature of the Presumpscot River by
impounding the water above each of its dams, then removing the water
from the river and running it through its turbines to generate electric-
ity, and then discharging that water back into the Presumpscot River,
often times leaving that portion of the riverbed just below the dam
(known as bypass reaches) devoid of any water. The Maine Board of
Environmental Protection found, and Petitioner did not contest, that
Petitioner’s Projects have caused long stretches of the natural river bed
to be essentially dry and thus unavailable as habitat for indigenous
populations of fish and other aquatic organisms; that the Projects have
blocked passage of eels and sea-run fish to their natural spawning and
nursery waters; that the Projects have eliminated the opportunity for
fishing in long stretches of the river; and that the dams have prevented
recreational access to and use of the river. Pet. App. 49.
3
401 certification and its conditions into the renewed
licenses for the Projects ultimately issued to Petitioner. 33
U.S.C. § 1341(d); 18 C.F.R. § 4.34(b).
Petitioner unsuccessfully challenged the Maine DEP’s
Section 401 certification before the Board of Environ-
mental Protection, Pet. App. 35-73, the Superior Court,
Pet. App. 19-34, and the SJC, Pet. App. 1-18. Petitioner
also unsuccessfully challenged the FERC licenses them-
selves which, based on the recommendation of FERC and
other federal agency staff and independent of the Section
401 certification, incorporated into the licenses almost the
same conditions as contained in the Section 401 certifica-
tion. S.D. Warren Co., Project Nos. 2897-003, 2932-003,
2941-002, 2931-002 and 2942-005. 105 FE.R.C. § 61,013
(2003) (“FERC’s Multi-Project Order”).
In its petition for writ of certiorari, Petitioner argues
for the first time that this Court’s decision in South
Florida Water Mgmt. Dist. v. Miccosukee Tribe, 541 U.S. 95
(2004), supports its assertion that its Projects should be
exempt from Section 401 because they do not result in any
discharge into the Presumpscot River. Petitioner also
asserts that Maine’s Section 401 certification represents a
“power grab” by Maine usurping FERC’s broad authority
under the Federal Power Act.
¢
ARGUMENT
Summary
This Court should deny this petition for certiorari for
three basic reasons. First, Petitioner’s first question
presented does not warrant this Court’s review because
4
Petitioner failed to raise it below and it was not addressed
by the SJC and the lower tribunals. Second, the SJC’s
decision is consistent with the decisions of this Court and
other Courts of Appeals on Section 401’s applicability to
hydroelectric projects and the authority of states to condi-
tion Section 401 certifications. This Court’s decision in
Miccosukee is not applicable to Section 401 and thus the
SJC’s decision does not conflict with it. And third, the
SJC’s decision is consistent with the practice of state and
federal regulatory agencies applying Section 401 to hy-
droelectric projects; that practice requires no clarification
by this Court. Certiorari should therefore be denied.
1. Petitioner’s First Question Presented for Review
Fails, Procedurally and Substantively, to Meet
the Standards for Granting Certiorari.
A. Petitioner’s Failure to Raise or Address the
First Question Presented Before the SJC Re-
quires Denial of Certiorari.
Petitioner contends that the SJC’s decision directly
conflicts with this Court’s decision in Miccosukee. Pet. 7-
17. Although Miccosukee was decided on March 23, 2004,
well before briefing (September 2, 2004) and oral argu-
ment (November 16, 2004) was complete in the SJC,
Petitioner failed to even cite Miccosukee, never mind to
argue its merits. As such, the application of Miccosukee to
a Section 401 certification was not addressed by the SJC.
It is well established that this Court does not consider
issues that were not raised or considered in the lower
courts. See Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 218 n.1 (1982)
(“the Court developed the rule that a claim would not be
considered here unless it had been either raised or
5
squarely considered and resolved in state court”). Only in
“very rare exceptions” will the Court examine claims not
addressed below when reviewing state court judgments.
Yee v. City of Escondido, 503 U.S. 519, 533 (1992).
There are no such exceptional circumstances to merit
review of Petitioner’s first question presented here. On
this basis alone, certiorari should be denied.’
B. The SJC’s Decision That Petitioner’s Projects
Result in a Discharge Under Section 401 Is
Consistent With Prior Decisions of This
Court and Courts of Appeals.
Just as Petitioner now attempts to manufacture an
issue that merits this Court’s review, it attempts to manu-
facture a conflict between the SJC’s decision and prior
decisions of this Court and courts of appeals. No such
conflict exists. Rather, courts have consistently found that
the operation of hydroelectric projects such as Petitioner’s
involve at least one discharge when the project returns
water back into the river after using it to generate electric-
ity; therefore the licensing of such projects triggers Section
401, just as the SJC found in this case.
? As noted above, Petitioner’s appeal of the FERC licenses them-
selves was recently and summarily rejected. Intervenor’s Appendix
(“Inter. App.”) 1. As such, even if this Court were to grant this petition
for certiorari and ultimately to agree with Petitioner’s argument, in
whole or in part, Petitioner would still have to operate its Projects
under its FERC licenses, which incorporate almost all of the conditions
contained in the Section 401 certification. See FERC’s Multi-Project
Order, { 61,013; Inter. App. 2-7.
6
i. The SJC’s Decision Does Not Conflict
with Miccosukee.
Petitioner claims that the SJC’s decision is “directly
contrary to this Court’s decision in Miccosukee” and that
the SJC “erroneously ignored Miccosukee.” Pet. 9, 13. Even
if the Court were willing to overlook Petitioner’s failure to
even raise Miccosukee below, Petitioner’s argument fails
because it ignores the clear limits of Miccosukee and the
fundamental difference between Section 401 and Section
402 of the CWA.
The issue addressed by the Court in Miccosukee was
what constituted a “discharge of a pollutant” under Sec-
tion 402 of the CWA. Miccosukee, 541 U.S. at 102-103. The
Court’s opinion did not address in any manner what
constituted the more broadly and separately defined scope
of “any discharge” under Section 401. 33 U.S.C. § 1362(16).
As such, this Court did not address the distinction be-
tween Section 402’s “discharge of pollutant” and Section
401’s “any discharge.” Moreover, because neither the legal
nor factual issues in Miccosukee were suitably raised or
developed below, the Court remanded without reaching
any final decision on either issue. Jd. at 112. In light of
Miccosukee’s substantive limitation to Section 402 and its
procedural limitation of an undeveloped record, Peti-
tioner’s attempt to stretch the Miccosukee decision as one
relevant to the SJC’s decision of what constitutes “any
discharge” under Section 401 should be rejected.
Moreover, Section 402 is fundamentally different
than Section 401. The former’s purpose is to regulate the
discharge of pollutants to navigable waters by requiring
a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System
(“NPDES”) permit issued under Section 402 before “the
—
discharge of any pollutant by any person” to navigable
waters is allowed. 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311(a), 1342. Section 401’s.
purpose is quite different — to give states the ability to
ensure that federally licensed projects (i.e., licensing that
is not controlled by the state in which a project is situated)
including hydroelectric projects will comply with the
state’s water quality standards. See PUD No. 1 v. Wash-
ington Dep't of Ecology, 511 U.S. 700, 707-08 (1994).
Section 401’s cooperative federalism approach to protect-
ing and improving water quality is clearly broader than
Section 402. That difference is reflected in how Congress
limited Section 402’s application to the “discharge of any
pollutant” as opposed to Section 401’s application to any
federally licensed activity that “may result in any dis-
charge.” 33 U.S.C. §§ 1341(a)(1), 1342(a).
Miccosukee addresses only what constitutes a “dis-
charge of a pollutant” under Section 402 and is therefore
limited to the question of whether an NPDES permit is
required for the activity in question. The SJC’s decision
addresses what constitutes “any discharge” under Section
401. As such, the conflict that Petitioner claims to exist
between the SJC’s decision and this Court’s decision in
Miccosukee is illusory.
ii. The Maine SJC’s Decision Does Not Con-
flict With Other Decisions of This Court
or Courts of A»peals.
The same illusory tension exists between the SJC’s
decision and the decisions cited by Petitioner. Specifically,
each of the pre-Miccosukee cases that Petitioner claims the
SJC decision conflicts with - Nat? Wildlife Fed’n v. Con-
sumers Power Co., 862 F.2d 580 (6th Cir. 1988), Dubois v.
Department of Agriculture, 102 F.3d 1273 (1st Cir. 1996)
8
and Catskill Mountains Chapter of Trout Unlimited, Inc. v.
City of New York, 273 F.3d 481 (2nd Cir. 2001) — addressed
whether an NPDES permit under Section 402 was neces-
sary. None of them addressed Section 401 in general nor
what constituted “any discharge” under Section 401 in
particular. Thus, the interpretations of what constitutes
an “addition” and thus a discharge of pollutants under
Section 402 by these three Courts of Appeals are, like this
Court’s decision in Miccosukee, not applicable to what
constitutes “any discharge” under Section 401.
Petitioner also tries to create tension between the
cases that have addressed what constitutes “any dis-
charge” under Section 401 and the SJC’s decision. But its
efforts to do so, which include aii but ignoring this Court’s
decision in PUD No. 1,’ are unavailing.
In PUD No. 1, the petitioner conceded that the hy-
droelectric project at issue would “at a minimum result in
two possible discharges — the release of dredged and fill
material during the construction of the project, and the
discharge of water at the end of the tailrace after the
water has been used to generate electricity.” PUD No. 1,
511 U.S. at 711. Although conceded, the issue was fully
briefed to this Court. In its brief, petitioner described the
operations of its run-of-river facility and concluded that “a
discharge from a hydroelectric facility occurs when water
is released or emitted that has been removed or blocked
* Petitioner’s only cite to PUD No. 1 is in a footnote and is to a
portion of the dissent. Pet. 20 n.6.
9
from the flow of the stream.” Brief for Petitioner, PUD No.
1, 1993 WL 632338 at *29.*
Similarly, the United States, having been invited by
the Court to file an amicus brief, observed that “Congress
employed the term ‘discharge’ when used without qualifi-
cation (as in Section 401(a;) more broadly than the term
‘discharge of any pollutant’ which is used in a number of
other provisions of the CWA,” and concluded that a dam’s
release of water is a “discharge” that triggers § 401. Brief
of the United States as Amicus Curiae Supporting Affir-
mance at 15 n.4. (1992 Lexis U.S. Briefs 1911.) Satisfied
that Clean Water Act jurisdiction had been triggered, the
PUD No. 1 Court then proceeded to the merits.
Having ignored the PUD No. 1 decision, Petitioner
attempts to distinguish the decisions by the D.C. Circuit
Court of Appeals since PUD No. 1 that address what
constitutes a discharge under Section 401, North Carolina
v. FERC, 112 F.3d 1175 (D.C. Cir. 1997) and Alabama
Rivers Alliance v. FERC, 325 F.3d 290 (D.C. Cir. 2003).
Those decisions, tuough, are consistent with the acknowl-
edgement in PUD No. 1 that the discharge of water back
* Petitioner in PUD No. 1 explained the basis for that conclusion in
its brief as follows: “The operation of a hydroelectric facility necessarily
results in the discharge of water... . In general, hydroelectric projects
use the gravitational force of water as it moves down a stream from an
upper to a lower elevation to drive a mechanical turbine that spins a
generator, and thus produces electricity. The force of the falling water is
exploited by a dam, or by a diversion structure like the Elkhorn
Project’s weir, that diverts water into a penstock, which then conveys
the water down and into the turbine. Water that has passed through the
turbine is then returned to the stream somewhere below the powerhouse,
through a conveyance known as a tailrace. Thus, hydroelectric facilities
typically involve at least one discharge. Brief for Petitioner, PUD No. i,
1993 WL 632338 at *27-*28 (emphasis added).
10
into a river after it has been used to generate electricity
triggers Section 401.
In North Carolina, the D.C. Circuit upheld FERC’s
ruling that an application to operate a pipeline that would
withdraw water from the impounded portion of a river
above a dam to use as drinking water would not result in
“any discharge” and Section 401 certification was not
required for the license amendment. North Carolina, 112
F.3d at 1187.° As support for its decision, FERC contrasted
the proposed pipeline withdrawal with the discharge that
is associated with the typical operations of a hydroelectric
project:
The ‘discharge’ from the operation of the [hydroe-
lectric] project is the water that leaves the project
as it flows through a dam, or through penstocks,
powerhouse turbines and tailraces, and reenters
the river or some other waterway.
In a proceeding for a new license (relicense) of
the project after the original license has expired,
if no new facilities are proposed to be con-
structed, then the activity requiring certification
is the continued operation of the project. The
place of discharge is the place at which project
waters leave the project impoundment or bypass
facilities and reenter the river or other waterway.
* Initially, FERC ruled that Section 401 did not apply because
FERC’s regulations governing license amendments did not require
Section 401 certification. North Carolina, 112 F.3d at 1172. The D.C.
Circuit expressed “serious reservations” about FERC’s attempt to
redefine the statutory term “any discharge,” but deferred addressing
the issue because on appeal, FERC discarded the regulation as a basis
for its decision. Jd. at 1186.
11
Virginia Electric and Power Co., 77 F.E.R.C. ¥ 61,519
(emphasis added).°
The D.C. Circuit’s subsequent decision in Alabama
Rivers squarely addressed whether the flow of water
through turbines constituted a discharge for purposes of
Section 401. Specifically, the D.C. Circuit held that “an
increase in the volume of water passing through the dam’s
replacement turbines may result in any discharge into the
navigable waters within the meaning of [Section 401).”
Alabama Rivers, 325 F.3d at 296-299.’
Collectively, the decisions in PUD No. 1, North Caro-
lina and Alabama Rivers stand for the proposition that
when a hydroelectric project removes water from a river,
uses it to generate electricity and then returns that water
to the river, there is a discharge for purposes of Section
401. In the case below, the Maine SJC concluded that
“water that leaves the river and runs through the dam
before returning to the river constitutes a discharge for
the purposes of [Section 401].” Pet. App. 10. That conclu-
sion is entirely consistent with the decisions in PUD No. 1,
* Underscoring this analysis by FERC is the fact that the very
same licensee who in North Carolina vigorously opposed the applicabil-
ity of Section 401 in the context of a license amendment to withdraw
water did not contest Section 401’s applicability a few years later when
it sought to renew its license from FERC. Like the petitioner before this
Court in PUD No. 1, the licensee, Dominion North Carolina Power, fully
acquiesced that water flowing through its turbines and discharged
downstream constituted a “discharge” triggering the Section 401
certification process. Int. App. 8-20.
" As did the court in North Carolina, the Alabama Rivers court
expressed serious reservations about FERC’s argument that “any
discharge” and “discharge of any pollutant” are one and the same but
did not address the issue because FERC failed to properly present it for
review. Alabama Rivers, 325 F.3d at 298 n.11.
12
North Carolina and Alabama Rivers. Moreover, nothing in
the SJC’s decision applying Section 401 conflicts with the
decisions applying Section 402 in Consumers Power,
Catskill Mountain or Dubois. Accordingly, there is no
conflict that merits granting certiorari.
iii. The Application of Section 401 Requires
No Clarification From This Court.
Petitioner’s claim that without this Court’s clarification
there will continue to be uncertainty as to what constitutes
“any discharge” under Section 401 is as manufactured as the
claim of conflict between the SJC’s decision and decisions of
this Court and other courts of appeals. Simply put, there is
no uncertainty among the courts or the regulatory agencies
as to the legal test to apply in determining whether a li-
censed activity “may result in any discharge.”
Courts and regulatory agencies have all recognized
that Section 401’s use of the phrase “any discharge” is
broader and more inclusive than Section 402’s use of the
phrase “discharge of any pollutant” such that “any dis-
charge” includes, but is not limited to, the discharge of a
pollutant. See, e.g., Power Authority of New York v. Wil-
liams, 101 A.D.2d 659, 660 (1989) (“This broad definition
of the word ‘discharge’ and its application to ‘any dis-
charge’ in [Section 401] requires that we reject petitioner’s
fundamental argument, i.e., that for section 401 to apply, a
discharge must contain a specific and identifiable pollut-
ant.”); Oregon Natural Desert Ass’n v. Dombeck, 172 F.3d
1092, 1098 (9th Cir. 1998) (“‘Discharge’ is the broader
term because it includes all releases from point sources,
whether polluting or nonpolluting.”); City of Augusta,
Georgia, 109 F.E.R.C. 9 62,210 ¥ 11 (2004) (“As defined in
13
the CWA, the term ‘discharge’ includes a ‘discharge of a
pollutant,’ and thus the former term comprises a broader
class of activities than the latter.”); and Pet. App. 35, 41
(finding by Maine Board of Environmental Protection that,
consistent with position of U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency, “any discharge” as used in Section 401l(a) is
broader than “discharge of pollutants.”)
Thus, in determining if an activity “may result in any
discharge,” courts and regulatory agencies uniformly agree
that there must be some release, addition or flow from the
licensed activity to the navigable water. See, e.g., PUD No.
1, 511 U.S. 700, 711 (no dispute among FERC, State of
Washington, EPA and owner of hydroelectric project that
release of water at end of tailrace constitutes discharge
under Section 401); In re Central Vermont Pub. Serv.
Corp., 85 F.E.R.C. 7 61,410, 62,557 (1998) (a “discharge”
from the operation of a hydroelectric project is the water
that leaves the project as it flows over or through a dam,
or through penstocks, powerhouse turbines and tailraces,
and reenters the river or enters some other waterway);
City of Fort Smith, 42 F-E.R.C. J 61,362 at 62,047 (1988)
(same). Accordingly, there is no legal issue this Court
needs to clarify that merits granting certiorari.
2. The Second Question Presented By Petitioner
Does Not Present A Conflict Or Controversy
That Merits This Court’s Review.
No dispute exists in this case or in the courts below
concerning either FERC’s exclusive licensing authority
over hydroelectric projects, California v. FERC, 495 U.S.
490 (1990) or states’ authority to certify with conditions
that such projects meet applicable water quality stan-
dards. See PUD No. 1, 511 U.S. at 707-08. That question
14
was explicitly addressed and resolved by this Court’s
decision in PUD No. 1. In addition, there is no dispute or
confusion as to the application of Section 401 to the
licensing of hydroelectric projects, as set forth above. As
such, there is no legal or factual dispute which merits
certiorari as to the second question presented.
Substantively, Petitioner's argument ignores the
system of cooperative federalism created by the CWA, and
specifically Section, 401, that gives states a clear and
defined role in enforcing water quality standards within
the state. 33 U.S.C. § 1341(d); 18 C.F.R. §§ 4.38(f)(7), 16.8.
As this Court held in PUD No. 1, a state may place condi-
tions on the activity as a whole that are necessary to meet
state water quality standards. 511 U.S. at 712-719. In
makirg this conclusion, this Court also ruled that Section
401 did not interfere with FERC’s exclusive licensing
authority. Jd. at 721-22.
Because the SJC’s decision is consistent with the
language of the CWA and FERC’s regulations and this
Court’s decision in PUD No. 1, it is difficult to discern
what Petitioner is asking this Court to review. At best,
Petitioner’s argument is a fact-bound issue that does not
warrant this Court’s review. Certiorari should be denied as
to Petitioner’s second question presented.
+
15
CONCLUSION
The petition for writ of certiorari should be denied.
Respectfully submitted,
SEAN MAHONEY
(Counsel of Record)
VERRILL DANA, LLP
One Portland Square
Portland, ME 04112
(207) 774-4000
RONALD A. KREISMAN
25 Page Street
Hallowell, ME
(207) 626-0248
Counsel for Intervenors
American Rivers and Friends
of the Presumpscot River
App. 1
United States Court of Appeals
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
No. 04-1105 September Term, 2004
S.D. Warren Co.,
Petitioner,
v.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,
Respondent.
On Petition for Review of Orders of the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Before: GINSBURG, SENTELLE and HENDERSON, Circuit
Judges.
JUDGMENT
(Filed May 6, 2005)
This cause was heard on the record from the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission and on the briefs and
arguments by counsel. For the reasons set out in the
accompanying memorandum, it is
ORDERED thai the petition for review is denied.
Pursuant to D.C. Circuit Rule 36, this disposition will
not be published. The Clerk is directed to withhold issuance
of the mandate herein until seven days after resolution of
App. 2
any timely petition for rehearing or rehearing en bane. See
Fed. R. App. P. 41(b); D.C. Cir. Rule 41.
Per Curiam
FOR THE COURT:
/s/_ Mark J. Langer
Mark J. Langer, Clerk
S.D. Warren Co. v. FERC, No. 04-1105
MEMORANDUM
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC or
Commission) issued a series of orders granting licenses to
S.D. Warren Company (Warren) to operate and maintain
five hydroelectric projects on the Presumpscot River in the
State of Maine. S.D. Warren Co., Project Nos. 2897-003,
2932-003, 2941-002, 2931-002 and 2942-005, 105 FERC
{ 61, 013 (2003) (Multi-Project Order); S.D. Warren Co.,
Project No. 2931-002, 105 FERC 461,010 (2003); S.D.
Warren Co., Project No. 2932-003, 105 FERC {761,011
(2003); S.D. Warren Co., Project No. 2941-002, 105 FERC
{ 61,012 (2003); and, S.D. Warren Co., Project No. 2942-
005, 105 FERC ¥ 61,009 (2003). Pursuant to the terms of
the Federal Power Act (FPA), 16 U.S.C. §§ 792 et seq., the
FERC attached conditions to the licenses to protect envi-
ronmental and recreational interests affected by Warren’s
hydroelectric projects. The conditions included fishway
prescriptions filed by the Department of Interior (Interior)
under § 18 of the FPA, id. at § 811, that required Warren
to install eel ladders at each project dam to facilitate
upstream migration by American eel and mandated an
eight-hour shutdown of the project turbines for an eight-
week period in the fall of each year to protect downstream
eel migration. Multi-Project Order, 105 FERC at 61,138,
App. 3
{i 42-43. Interior also placed conditional obligations on
Warren to provide upstream and downstream fish passage
facilities at each project dam as fish passage is achieved at
the next most downstream dam. /d. at 61,137-38, {{ 35-
41. Specifically, if fish passage is achieved at a down-
stream dam not controlled by Warren over which the
FERC lacks jurisdiction, within two years Warren is
required, inter alia, to construct denil fish ladders at its
most downstream dam. Jd. at 61,137, { 36. Construction of
fish passage facilities at each of Warren’s upstream dams
is conditioned on the attainment of specific fish population
triggers at the next downstream dam. Jd. The FERC also
attached conditions imposed by the State of Maine pursu-
ant to the state water quality certification (WQC) process
under § 401 of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1341(d).
Maine’s WQC conditions imposed, inter alia, dissolved
oxygen standards and minimum bypass flows (intended to
mitigate the dewatering of the Presumpscot River spill-
ways below each project) and required Warren to develop a
recreational facility enhancement plan for each project.
See Multi-Project Order, 105 FERC at 61,136, 7 25. In
addition, pursuant to §10(a) of the FPA, 16 U.S.C.
§ 803(a), the Commission imposed conditions designed to
ensure that the projects would “be best adapted to a
comprehensive plan for ... the adequate protection,
mitigation, and enhancement of fish and wildlife (includ-
ing related spawning grounds and habitat), and for other
beneficial public uses, including ... recreation[].” Jd. at
§ 803(a)(1). Based on the Final Environmental Impact
Statement (FEIS) issued by the Commission staff on June
26, 2002, the FERC required Warren, inter alia, to develop
a Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) for its two largest
projects with a shoreline buffer zone of 200 feet. Multi-
Project Order, 105 FERC at 61,141-42, {]{ 64-66. The
App. 4
FERC also required Warren to monitor and report on
recreational use near the project sites every 12 years. Id.
at 61,149-50, Article 409. The FERC issued the licenses for
a 40-year term. Jd. at 61,144, { 86.
Warren petitioned the Commission for rehearing: On
rehearing, the FERC upheld the orders with respect to the
license requirements which it had included and denied
rehearing as to the § 18 and § 401 conditions, concluding
that it had no authority to revise or remove those provi-
sions from the licenses. S.D. Warren Co., Project Nos.
2897-005, 2931-004, 2932-006, 2941-004, and 2942-007,
106 FERC { 61,087, 61,293-94, {7 3, 4, 7, 11-14, 16 & nn.
7-8, 13 (issued January 29, 2004) (Rehearing Order). See
Bangor Hydro-Elec. Co. v. FERC, 78 F.3d 659, 663 (D.C.
Cir. 1996) (“[I]t is not the Commission’s role to judge the
validity of Interior’s position — substantially or proce-
durally.”); 33 U.S.C. § 1341(d) (“Any certification provided
under [§ 401] ... shall become a condition on any Federal
license or permit subject to the provisions of this section.”).
See also Alabama Rivers Alliance v. FERC, 325 F.3d 290,
292-93 (D.C. Cir. 2003) (same).
Warren challenges the sufficiency of the evidence in
the record to support the Commission’s § 10 conditions and
Interior’s § 18 prescriptions. Warren also challenges the
40-year license term as arbitrary and capricious. We
uphold the Commission’s orders because they are sup-
ported by substantial evidence in the record, 16 U.S.C.
§ 8251(b), and because the Commission “examined the
relevant data and provided a reasoned explanation sup-
ported by a stated connection between the facts found and
the choice made.” North Carolina v. FERC, 112 F.3d 1175,
1189 (D.C. Cir. 1997) (internal quotation marks omitted).
The conditions imposed by the Commission under § 10 are
App. 5
supported by substantial evidence. The FEIS upon which
the Commission relied considered the comments of several
entities, including the FWS and National Park Service, as
well as the Maine Department of Marine Resources, the
Maine Atlantic Salmon Commission, the Maine Depart-
ment of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife and three individu-
als. See Multi-Project Order at 61,135, {18 & n.5. The
Commission altered the scope of the conditions recom-
mended by the FWS, reducing the 500-foot buffer zone for
the SMPs to 200 feet and decreasing the reporting re-
quirement for recreational use studies from every six
years to every 12 years, because the FWS had failed to
provide sufficient evidence to support its more stringent
recommendations. Jd. at 61,141-42, {{ 64-66.
With respect to Warren’s challenge to Interior’s
fishway prescriptions under § 18, we apply the same
arbitrary and capricious standard that governs the actions
of the Commission. Wisconsin Power & Light Co. v. FERC,
363 F.3d 453, 461 (D.C. Cir. 2004). Interior’s fishway
prescriptions must be “reasonably related” to its goal of
fish preservation. Bangor Hydro-Electric, 78 F.3d at 663.
The scientific evidence in the record demonstrates signifi-
cant populations of American eel and a 2000 study of the
Presumpscot projects commissioned by Warren documents
the extent to which the project dams impaired the ability
of the eels to migrate upstream due to difficulty ascending
dam faces. Studies of similar projects demonstrated the
hazards of downstream migration, specifically, high
mortality rates caused by project turbines. Interior’s
prescriptions are reasonably calculated to mitigate these
harms. The required eel passageways provide for efficient
upstream migration at a “relatively low cost,” according to
the FEIS. Interior’s requirement that Warren shut down
App. 6
turbine operation for a period of eight hours per day for
eight weeks during peak migration is likewise a reason-
able prescription. Interior reasonably concluded that
current scientific evidence does not permit a reliable
estimate of a shorter peak migratory period that would
ensure similar protection of the eel with a less stringent
shutdown requirement. Interior has directed Warren to
conduct a three year study of migratory patterns, the
results of which may enable Interior to reduce the 8/8
requirement without proportionally increasing the risk to
migrating eels. Likewise, Interior’s prescriptions with
respect to anadromous fish species are reasonable. The
fish passageway requirements are conditioned on restora-
tion of the relevant species to the areas below each project. .
In the absence of species restoration, Warren need not
undertake any construction based on the prescription. The
target levels for fish population that trigger action,
roughly 20 per cent of the maximum estimated population
size, are reasonably calculated to ensure that Warren need
not undertake construction at its upstream projects
unnecessarily.
The conditions imposed by the FERC require Warren
to undertake a “moderate amount of construction and
environmental mitigation and enhancement measures.”
See Multi-Project Order at 61,144, 4 86. The record evi-
dence supports the Commission’s assessment. More
extensive construction that might be required under
Interior’s conditional fishway prescriptions could, if
actually imposed, provide a basis for extending the license
term. Until that time, the 40-year license term, instead of
the 50-year license Warren had sought for “extensive”
construction, cannot be considered arbitrary or capricious.
App. 7
M.G. Deacon, Jr. [LOGO]
Vice President
[Illegible] & Hydro
Dominion Generation
Innsbrook Technical Center
5000 Dominion Boulevard, Glen Allen, VA 23060
August 26, 2003
Ms. Magalie R. Salas, Secretary
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
888 First Street, N.E.
Washington, DC 20426
(Filed Aug. 27, 2003)
Dear Ms. Salas:
Virginia Electric and Power Company, doing business as
Dominion Virginia Power (Dominion) is working with
FERC staff to complete the record for the license renewal
for Roanoke Rapids and Gaston, project no. 2009. Attached
you will find the State of North Carolina’s CWA Section
401 Certification for the project.
If you have any questions related to this submittal, please
call Jim Thornton (804) 273-3257.
Sincerely,
isi MGDJ
M. G. Deacon, Jr.
App. 8
Attachment
ec: Mr. Allan Creamer, FERC, Washington, DC
App. 9
[LOGO] [Names Omitted In Printing]
July 30, 2003
(Filed Aug. 27, 2003)
Mr. Malcolm G. Deacon, Jr. Vice President —
Fossil and Hydro
Dominion Energy and Dominion Generation
Innsbrook Technical Center
5000 Dominion Blvd.
Glen Allen, VA 23060
Dear Mr. Deacon:
Re: Certification Pursuant to Section 401 of the Federal
Clean Water Act for the Roanoke Rapids and Lake
Gaston FERC Relicensing Project
WQC Project #02-0919
FERC Number 2009
Halifax County and adjacent counties
Attached hereto is a copy of Certification No. 3208
Issued to Dominion North Carolina Power dated July 30,
2003. If we can be of further assistance, do not hesitate to
contact us.
Sincerely,
/s/
Alan W. Klimek, P.E. Director
Attachments
ce: Raleigh and Washington DWQ Regional Offices
Doug Huggett, Division of Coastal Management
File Copy
Central Files
Darlene Kucken; DWQ Basinwide Planning
Program Unit
Jim Mead, NC Division of Water Resources
App. 10
Marc Bernstein, NC Attorney General’s Office
Robin Smith, DENR
Thomas Leahy, Ill P-E., City of Virginia Beach, VA
Jean McCarter, Lake Gaston Association
Bob Lindsay, Roanoke River Basin Association
Garland Pardue, US Fish and Wildlife
Service — Raleigh
David Rackley, National Marine Fisheries Service,
Charleston, SC
Shannon Denton, NC Wildlife Resources Commission
Ron McKittrick, Federal Energy Regulator
Commission
Sara Winslow, NC Division of Marine Fisheries
Bud Laroche, Virginia Department of Game
and Inland Fisheries
Rheta Geddings, SC Department of Health and
Environmental Control
Ellen Gifinsky, VA Water Control Board,
Wetlands Program
Joseph Hassell, VA Department of
Environmental Quality
NORTH CAROLINA 401 WATER
QUALITY CERTIFICATION
THIS CERTIFICATION is issued in conformity with
the requirements of Section 401 Public Laws 92-500 and
95-217 of the United States and subject to the North
Carolina Division of Water Quality (DWQ’) Regulations in
15 NCAC 2H, Section .0500. It is issued to Dominion
North Carolina Power (“the applicant”) in Halifax County
and adjacent counties pursuant to a revised application
filed on the 20th day of November, 2002 to, among other
things, retain the Gaston and Roanoke Rapids dams
across the Reanoke River.
RPO
App. 11
The application provides adequate assurance that the
retention of fill material into the waters of the Roanoke
River in conjunction with retention and operation of these
dams and other project activities will not result in a
violation of applicable Water Quality Standards, discharge
guidelines and other applicable State laws. Therefore, the
State of North Carolina certifies that this activity will not
violate the applicable portions of Sections 301, 302, 303,
306, 307 of PL 92-500 and PL 95-217 if conducted in
accordance with the application and conditions hereinafter
set forth.
This approval is only valid for the purpose and design
that you submitted in your application, as described in the
revised application. If you change your project, you must
notify us and may be required to send us a new application
for a new Certification. If the property is sold, the new
owner must be given a copy of the Certification and
approval letter and is thereby responsible for complying
with all conditions. For this approval to be valid, you must
follow the conditions listed below. The issuance of this
Certification shall not exempt the applicant from comply-
ing with any and all statutes, rules, regulations, or ordi-
nances tuat may be imposed by other government agencies
(local, state and federal) which have jurisdiction, including
but not limited to applicable river buffer rules in 15A
NCAC 2B .0200, erosion and sedimentation control re-
quirements in 15A NCAC Chapter 4 and under the Divi-
sion’s General Permit NCG010000, and any requirements
pertaining to wetlands under 15A NCAC 2B .0200, 15A
NCAC 2H .0500 and 15A NCAC 2H .1300. This Certifica-
tion is issued on the express representation by the appli-
cant that the Settlement Agreement referenced herein has
been executed by all necessary signatories and therefore is
App. 12
in effect. If the Settlement Agreement is not in effect as of
July 30, 2003 then this Certification may be modified by
DWQ in order to coincide with the relevant provisions of
that Settlement Agreement.
Condition(s) of Certification:
1 Flow In the Bypass Reach -
1.1 Flow of water in the bypass reach shall not be
1.2
less than 325 cfs at any time except as modified
by future adaptive management studies as ap-
proved in writing by DWQ. The adaptive man-
agement studies shall focus on the spawning
window (at least March 15 through June 15).
However, slight reduction in flows in the winter
months may be approved, but shall not result in
minimum flows less than 300 cfs. The flow shall
be released from both the north and south ends
of the dam so that it is evenly distributed into
the reach. The precise schedule for release may
be developed in consultation with the Coopera-
tive Management Team (“CMT”) consisting of
representatives of the NC Department of Envi-
ronment and Natural Resources (“DENR”), NC
Wildlife Resources Commission (“WRC”), US
Fish and Wildlife Service (“USFWS”), National
Marine Fisheries Service (“NMFS”) and the ap-
plicant.
The applicant shall provide on a periodic basis
for the duration of 24 consecutive hours, flow to
the bypass reach of 500 cfs (“freshet flow”) on a
schedule provided by DWQ in consultation with
WRC. The scheduling of the 500-cfs flow may be
on weekends in order to minimize the cost of
hydropower losses.
— —
1.3
1.4
App. 13
The applicant shall follow an annual schedule
provided by DWQ upon consultation with WRC
to the applicant by November 30 for the follow-
ing year. The annual scheduling of the 500-cfs
may not exceed a total of 17 days of the freshet
flows. After the annual schedule has been pro-
vided to the applicant, DWQ may modify the
schedule in consultation with WRC but shall
give the applicant a minimum of 10 days notice
prior to modification of the 500-cfs schedling.
Whenever flood flows require opening o. the
Roanoke Rapids darn floodgates for at ieast one
24-hour period and up to 21 days, this will
count as one of the 500-cfs flow days. (A 22 to
42-day flood release would vount as two freshet
flow days, etc.) If, during a study cycle, the flow
for a period of 21 days equals or exceeds 500 cfs,
the number of freshet flows requirec for that
year will be reduced by one. The applicant shall
provide to DENR and WRC by March 31 of the
following year, a report that lists the days that
the 500 cfs freshest flow was passed into the by-
pass reach. Consistent with article FL1, section 4
of the Settlement Agreement, during cycles two,
three and four of the bypass reach study, the an-
nual scheduling of the 500-cfs may not exceed a
total of 13 days of the freshet flows.
The applicant shall reduce flood flow releases at
the Roanoke Rapids dam from 35,000 cfs (or
any flow greater than 5,000 cfs through the
floodgates) to 25,000 cfs in consultation with
the US Army Corps of Enginvers (“USACE”).
Once the flood releases through the Roanoke
Rapids floodgates are reduced to 5,000 cfs, the
applicant shall reduce the flows in the bypass
reach per the rates in Table 1 below:
1.5
1.6
App. 14
Table 1
Hour Release (cfs)
0 5,000
4 4,000
8 3,000
12 2,000
16 1,500
20 1,000
24 700
28 500
32 325
If flood releases occur but do not reach 5,000 cfs
through the floodgates, the table above shall
still be used starting at the maximum flood re-
lease. The bypass reach flow may be temporarily
modified if required by unusual circumstances
upon written agreement between the DWQ and
the USACE and in consultation with the Licen-
see and the WRC. Temporary changes will be
coordinated with the other agendas of the CMT
in a timely manner.
If DWQ, in consultation with the CMT, delays
Implementation of this condition to allow for
the collection of baseline data, Implementation
shall begin as determined by DWQ. If the im-
plementation of this condition is not so delayed,
then the applicant shall begin releasing water
into the bypass reach within one week of accep-
tance of the new license for Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission Project No. 2009 (“new
FERC license”).
The applicant, in consultation with the CMT,
shall conduct the study described in article
FL1, section 4 of the Technical Settlement (Ap-
pendix B) of the Settlement Agreement. Consis-
tent with such article, the applicant shall not
App. 15
adopt a new flow regime for the bypass reach
without written approval from DWQ.
2 Minimum Releases from the Roanoke Rapids
dam - The following schedule shall be followed for
the minimum release of water from the dam. “Decla-
ration” refers to the daily mean of the USACE
weekly declaration. The applicant shall implement
this new flow regime within 30 days of acceptance of
the new FERC license.
2.1 - Minimum and Target Flow Releases
from Roanoke Rapids Dam
Timeframe Condition Minimum Flow
Jan. 1-15 Declaration < 6000 cfs} 2000 cfs
Declaration < 6000 cfs| 2500 cfs
Jan. 15-Feb. 28/29 |Declaration < 6000 cfs! 2500 cfs or
declaration,
whichever is less
Declaration > 6000 3000 cfs
March Declaration < 3500 cfs) minimum flow =
Declaration > 3500 minimum flow =
two of the weeks
Rampup _ [Ramp up from min.
by 5000 cfs hold for 1
pon Geneome
oad
App. 16
App. 17
flood control releases from the Roanoke Rapids
dam, the applicant shall work in conjunction
with the USACE to reduce flows in the main-
stream river gradually during the months of
May through September to minimize the effects
of inflow of water with low oxygen levels into
Roanoke River from downstream wetlands.
Upon agreement with the USACE and in con-
sultation with DWQ, the applicant shall im-
plement the following step-down schedule from
a 20,000-cfs flow:
Ramp down p down to min.
ow + 5000 cfs, hold
or one hour then go
minimum flow.
April 1-June 15 All conditions = mean of
eekly declaration,
peaking
Ramp from one to
weekly declara-
ion cannot exceed
cfs per hour
June 16-June 30 All conditions 2800 cfs or
declaration,
whichever is less
July 1-September All conditions 2000 cfs
15
Sept. 16-Nov. 15 All conditions 1500 cfs
Nov. 16-Nov. 30 All conditions 2000 cfs
Dec. 1-Dec.31 |Declaration < 6000 cfs|__ 2000 cfs
Declaration > 6000 cfs| 2500 cfs
2.2 When the USACE declares a drought, the ap-
Table 3
Hour Flow (cfs)
0 17,000
8 14,000
16 12,000
20 11,000
24 10,500
28 10,000
32 9,500
6 9,000
plicant shall maintain the following drought
minimum flows unless otherwise directed by
the USACE in consultation with DWQ and
WRC:
Table 2
January — August
2000 cfs
September — November /|1500 cfs
December
2000 cfs
2.3 Transition from Flood Control to Normal Hy-
dropower Operations —
The applicant shall work in conjunction with
the USACE to gradually reduce flows in the by-
pass reach per the schedule described in Condi-
tion 1 of this Certification. Following USACE
This schedule may be revised upon written re-
quest to DWQ if the ongoing USACE section
216 study indicates a different step-down
schedule should be followed.
Table 3, above, represents a maximum flow re-
duction schedule. A slower step-down schedule
(one that reaches the 9000 cfs flow over a longer
period of time) may be approved by the USACE
in consultation with DWQ and the applicant on
a case by case basis. During the time-frame
needed to execute the flow reduction schedule,
the applicant would not engage in _ load-
following operations. The applicant shall im-
plement the step-down flow schedule beginning
App. 18
when the applicant has accepted the new FERC
license.
3 Downstream Water Quality -
3.1 Minimum Flow — Minimum flows to address
3.2
downstream uses are discussed in Condition 2
of this Certification.
Erosion and Sedimentation — The applicant
shall develop a plan to monitor the effect of
within-day peaking on benthic macroinverte-
brates, fish communities and stream bank ero-
sion along the Roanoke River downstream of
the Roanoke Rapids dam. The development of
that plan shall be in cooperation with a CMT
consisting of WRC, DENR, USFWS, NMFS, the
Nature Conservancy (“TNC”), and the appli-
cant, with the Regional Partnership of Local
Governments (“RPLG”) as an ex officio member.
Monitoring cycles shall consist of five-year peri-
ods beginning when the applicant accepts a new
FERC license. The applicant shall be required
to fund the cost of Implementing the monitoring
plan up to the amount of $30,000 annually
(2002 dollars adjusted according to the Con-
sumer Price Index). Any portion of the $30,000
not utilized shall be carried forward to the Li-
censee’s future annual budget cycles and shall
be in addition to the $30,000 allocated for that
cycle. In the thirtieth year of the license, the Li-
censee shalt consult with the GMT to determine
if an increase in funding of the monitoring pro-
gram is appropriate. Within one year of the ac-
ceptance of the new FERC license, the applicant
shall transmit the plan to DWQ for written ap-
proval and subsequent implementation by the
applicant. If DWQ does not provide written
comments to the applicant within 60 days of
App. 19
receipt of this plan, then the plan may be Im-
plemented as submitted. During the first moni-
toring cycle, data collection shall not be
required to start until year two to allow for de-
velopment of the monitoring plan and protocols.
DWQ, in consultation with the CMT, will re-
view monitoring data at the end of each cycle to
determine if it establishes a link between the
applicant’s within-day peaking and (a) erosion
of the banks of the Roanoke River downstream
of the Roanoke Rapids dam and/or (b) negative
effects on downstream benthic macroinverte-
brate or fish species and communities. If such a
link is established, then DWQ - in consultation
with the CMT — will develop an approach that
requires the applicant to address those effects
by modifying one of the following: maximum
peaking flow; difference between base flow and
peak flow on peaking days; ramping rates; du-
ration of base flow (in hours) between peaking
releases; modification of the definition of a
peaking period in condition 8 of this Certifica-
tion; or some other modification that the CMT
suggests might reduce adverse impacts of
within-day peaking on aquatic biota and/or
stream bank stability. Seasonal variations may
also be incorporated in this approach. Upon
written notice of the development and written
approval from DWQ for this approach, the ap-
plicant shall Implement this approach.
If subsequent monitoring indicates a continuing
link between within-day peaking operations
and bank erosion and/or negative effects on
downstream aquatic species and immunities,
then DWG - in consultation with the CMT - will
develop an additional Incremental modification
from the [sic] those listed in the paragraph
3.3
App. 20
above that the applicant must implement to
further reduce those effects. Upon written noti-
fication of any additional incremental modifica-
tion, and so long as such modifications reduce
the latitude available to the applicant for
within-day peaking by a proportional amount
equivalent to 5 divided by the period of the new
FERC license in years, the applicant shall im-
plement such modification. The exact means for
calculating the proportionality of steps will be
determined by DWQ in consultation with the
CMT. If any operational changes subject to this
section (3.2) would conflict with release re-
quirements subject to sections 2, 3.4 or 3.5 of
this Certification, then the flow-related condi-
tions of these other sections shall take prece-
dence.
Minimum Oxygen Releases from the Roanoke
Rapids Dam — Water flowing through the hy-
dropower turbines from the Roanoke Rapids
dam shall meet or exceed the Instantaneous
dissolved oxygen standard in effect as of the
date of the discharge. The Instantaneous dis-
solved oxygen standard as of the date of this
Certification is 4.0 mg/L (ppm) (15A NCAC 2B
.0211(3)(b)).
Water flowing through the hydropower turbines
from the Roanoke Rapids dam shal] meet or ex-
ceed the mean, daily dissolved oxygen standard
in effect as of the date of the discharge. The
mean, daily dissolved oxygen standard as of the
data of this Certification is 5.0 mg/L (ppm) (15A
NCAC 2B .0211(3)(b)). The daily mean oxygen
concentration shall be calculated as the mean of
all instantaneous analyses collected in a 24-
hour period to be no less than 24, hourly meas-
urements. If dissolved oxygen concentrations
App. 21
immediately upstream of the project do not
meet or exceed the instantaneous dissolved
oxygen standard and mean, daily dissolved
oxygen standards in effect as of the date of the
discharge, then the Raleigh Regional Office of
DW@Q shall be notified in writing and via tele-
phone. In any case, the dissolved oxygen in the
water flowing through the hydropower turbines
from the Roanoke Rapids dam shall equal or
exceed the upstream dissolved oxygen concen-
tration.
Oxygen concentrations shall. be measured in
the tailrace.
Within six months of the applicant’s acceptance
of a new FERC License, the applicant shall
submit a draft agreement to DWQ regarding
the location of the sampling point upstream of
the project if the dissolved oxygen water quality
standard is not met in the tailwaters below
Roanoke Rapids dam, then the applicant shall
begin sampling for dissolved oxygen levels
within two business days in Lake Gaston and in
the tailwaters below Lake Gaston.
Data from the Roanoke Rapids monitoring shall
be maintained on a real-time basis via Internet
and forwarded to the Wetland/401 Unit, the
Ecosystems Unit and the Raleigh and Washing-
ton Regional Offices of DWQ every other month
from November 1 through May 31 and monthly
from June 1 through October 31. Data must be
submitted electronically and DWQ shall be no-
tified in writing that the data have been sent.
Data must include Flow (cfs), Dissolved Oxygen
concentrations (mg/L) and Water Temperature
(°C).
3.4
App. 22
In the event of temporary emergency conditions
arising in the performance of the above condi-
tions, the applicant shall cooperate in good faith
with DWQ and WRC to take such reasonable
steps to protect the water quality of the Roa-
noke River below the Gaston and Roanoke Rap-
ids dams.
Flow Augmentation from Lake Gaston Storage
during Drought Conditions — Conditions requir-
ing flow augmentation from Gaston storage:
If all four of the following conditions are met,
the applicant shall begin augmenting down-
stream flows from the Lake Gaston storage in
consultation with DWQ and WRC.
a) USACE is operating Kerr reservoir under
its drought management strategy,
b) Roanoke Rapids dam is not in a hydro-
power peaking mode and is only releasing
drought minimum flows as directed by the
USACE drought management strategy or
when condition 2.2 is in effect,
c) A weekly declaration from USACE is is-
sued that is less than the total of drought
minimum flow required at the Roanoke
Rapids dam, and
d) Lake Gaston water level is above 197' msl.
Lake Gaston storage — Lake Gaston normal wa-
ter level shall be regulated by the applicant: in
order to maintain the existing uses of the lake
with the following provisions. if all of the
drought storage is used for downstream flow
augmentation, then the applicant shall regulate
Lake Gaston from 197.5’ msl to 196.5' msl, in
App. 23
order to meet system operational needs with
the following provisions:
a) For the purpose of flow augmentation
downstream under the conditions listed
above, Lake Gaston has 3 feet of drought
storage.
b) Lake Gaston has approximately 60,000
acre-feet of storage between 200' msl and
197' msl.
c) The applicant utilizes one foot of storage
for normal operation between 200' msl and
199’ msl.
Once above conditions are met, Lake Gaston
storage shall be used to augment the down-
stream flow to adhere to the FERC minimum
flow, per direction of DWQ.
Once Lake Gaston reaches 197' msl. flow aug-
mentation shall cease and flow entering the
project from Kerr Lake shall equal the flow
leaving the Roanoke Rapids dam, after account-
ing for consumptive withdrawals, evaporation
and inflows to Lake Gaston and Roanoke Rap-
ids Lake.
When the USACE weekly declaration begins to
exceed the Roanoke Rapids dam drought mini-
mum flows, the applicant shall allow Lake Gas-
ton to refill to 199.5' msl prior to:
a) exceeding drought minimum flow at the
Roanoke Rapids dam and,
b) starting to operate the Roanoke Rapids pro-
ject in a hydropower peaking mode.
3.5
App. 24
The applicant shall implement these conditions
only upon consultation with and direction from
the USACE and DWQ.
Downstream Water Quality Monitoring -
The applicant shalt fund three of the current
USGS continuous water quality monitoring sta-
tions for dissolved oxygen and temperature at
Halifax, Oak City and Jamesville. These sta-
tions shall be operated continuously throughout
the year.
The applicant shall provide funding annually
by March Ist of each year to DENR.
The stations shall be monitored to document
that dissolved oxygen levels in the Roanoke
River, as a result of the drainage of water from
the floodplain resulting from project operations,
equals or exceeds the instantaneous dissolved
oxygen standard and mean, daily dissolved oxy-
gen standards in effect as of the date of the dis-
charge in the mainstem river (15A NCAC 2B
-.0211(3)(b)). This concentration shall be calcu-
lated using all available daily data or as (at
least) the mean of 24, hourly instantaneous
analyses.
At such time DWQ establishes that the appli-
cant’s operations do not or no longer affect
downstream water quality, applicant funding
shall no longer be required.
If funding is discontinued in accordance with
this Condition and subsequent applicant opera-
tional changes enable DWQ to demonstrate
that water quality monitoring is again neces-
sary, the applicant’s funding requirement shall
App. 25
be reinstated. The study period shall be mutu-
ally agreed upon by the applicant, DWQ and
WRC.
Data shall be forwarded to the Wetland/401
Unit, the Ecosystems Unit and the Raleigh and
Washington Regional Offices of DWQ every
other month (bi-monthly) from November 1
through May 31 and monthly from June 1
through October 31. Data must be submitted
electronically. Data must include all available
parameters collected by the USGS (e.g. stage or
flow) in addition to: site, date, time, depth, dis-
solved oxygen concentrations (mg/L.), and wa-
ter temperature (oC). In the event of emergency
water quality conditions, the applicant shall co-
operate in good faith with DWQ and WRC to
take such reasonable steps to protect the water
quality of the Roanoke River below the Roanoke
Rapids dam.
The applicant, DWQ and WRC shall mutually
agree upon a method of evaluating data col-
lected within the first year of monitoring. Data
evaluation shal! occur on a five-year cycle.
If during water quality data evaluation, DWQ
(in consultation with WRC) finds that scientific
data establish a causal link between the appli-
cants rescheduling of the USACE’s weekly dec-
laration and the reduction of water quality in
the mainstem river below State standards, the
applicant with concurrence of DWQ and WRC
shall identify and implement operational
changes that will significantly reduce the appli-
cant’s water quality impacts.
Each operational change implemented accord-
ing to the preceding paragraph must reduce the
App. 26
applicant’s rescheduling of the USACE weekly
declaration by a proportional amount equiva-
lent to 5 divided by the period of the new FERC
license in years. Thus, if as the result of moni-
toring, the applicant implements a change to
reduce its rescheduling of the USACE weekly
declaration at the end of each monitoring cycle,
by the end of the last monitoring cycle, each day
the applicant shall release one seventh of the
USACE weekly declaration. The exact means
for calculating the proportionality of steps will
be determined by DWQ in consultation with
WRC and the applicant.
The applicant’s flexibility for scheduling re-
leases during a peaking day is not constrained
by this condition.
The applicant is not required by this Certifica-
tion to make modifications to the USACE
weekly declaration.
The maximum operational duty of the applicant
under this Condition is reached when the daily
water flow through the Roanoke Rapids dam
equals one-seventh of the USACE weekly decla-
ration as long as this flow does not conflict with
the requirements of condition 3.4 above.
App. 27
FERC license and shall report proposed new or
expanded consumptive uses to DWQ and DWR
within 30 days of receiving a request for the
proposed new or expanded withdrawal and be-
fore submitting any requests to FERC. Condi-
tions 4 through 7 of this Certification apply to
large consumptive uses, but not exclusively.
Conservation and Drought Management -
In anticipation of low flow conditions, such as
occur during critical droughts, the applicant
shall take actions as described in this Certifica-
tion to ensure that sufficient water of adequate
quality is and will be available to assure com-
pliance with State water quality standards and
other appropriate requirements of State law. In
furtherance of the purposes of this condition,
article FL6, section 3 of the Technical Settle-
ment (Appendix B) of the Settlement Agree-
ment (“FL6 §3”), is made part of this
Certification as if set forth fully herein. Any
amendment to FL6 § 3 shall not become a part
of this Certification except through the proce-
dures set forth in condition 7. The applicant
shall take all actions specifically required of the
applicant by FL6 §3 and shall take all other
necessary actions within its authority to im-
4 Reporting of Consumptive Uses - plement FL6 § 3.
The applicant shall identify and report in writ- 6 No Rights Granted -
ing existing and proposed consumptive uses to
DW@Q and the NC Division of Water Resources
(“DWR”). The applicant shall report the existing
or projected (as appropriate) average consump-
tive withdrawal and maximum capacity for
each withdrawal. The applicant shall report ex-
isting consumptive uses to DWQ and DWR
within 60 days of the acceptance of the new
This Certification does not grant or affirm any
property right, license or privilege in any waters
or any right of use in any waters. This Certifica-
tion does not authorize any person to interfere
with the riparian rights, littoral rights or water
use rights of any other person, and this Certifi-
cation does not create any prescriptive right or
App. 28
any right of priority regarding any usage of wa-
ter. No person shalt interpose this Certification
as a defense in any action respecting the de-
termination of riparian or littoral rights or
other water use rights. No consumptive user is
deemed by virtue of this Certification to possess
any prescriptive or other right of priority with
respect to any other consumptive user regard-
less of the quantity of the withdrawal or the
date on which the withdrawal was initiated or
expanded. This Certification issues on the ex-
press understanding of DENR that, pursuant to
Federal Power Act section 27, 16 U.S.C. § 821,
the new FERC license does not establish or de-
termine a proprietary right to any use of water.
It establishes the nature of the use to which a
proprietary right may be put under the Federal
Power Act.
Continuing Compliance -
The applicant shall conduct its activities in a
manner consistent with State water quality
standards (including any requirements result-
ing from compliance with section 303(d) of the
Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1313(d)) and any
other appropriate requirements of State law
and federal law. If DWQ determines that such
standards or laws are not being met (including
the failure to sustain a designated or achieved
use or to comply with any new or amended wa-
ter quality standards or other appropriate re-
quirements of State or federal law) or that
State or federal law is being violated, or that ,
further conditions are necessary to assure com-
pliance, DWQ may reevaluate and modify this
Certification to include conditions appropriate
to assure compliance with such standards and
requirements in accordance with 154A NCAC
App. 29
2H.0507(d). Before modifying the Certification,
DWQ will notify the applicant and FERC, pro-
vide public notice in accordance with 15A
NCAC 2H.0503 and provide opportunity for
public hearing in accordance with 15A NCAC
2H.0504. Any new or revised conditions will be
provided to the applicant in writing, will be
provided to the USACE for reference in any
permit issued pursuant to Section 404 of the
Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1344, for the pro-
ject, and shall also become conditions of the
new FERC license for the project. This condi-
tion shall constitute “reserved authority” as
that term is used in Section 9.2 of the Settle-
ment Agreement. The conditions of this Certifi-
cation are not modified or superseded by any
condition or article of the new FERC license.
Definitions/Glossary of Terms -
The listed terms are definitions utilized
throughout this Certification unless otherwise
specified in specific conditions of the Certifica-
tion.
cfs — (Cubic feet per second) — Volume of one
cubic foot of water passing a given point in one
second.
Day — The 24 hour period from midnight to
midnight.
Diadromous Fish - Fish that live as adults in
a salt water system and spawn in a fresh water
system (anadromous) or fish that live as adults
in fresh water and spawn in salt water
(catadromous).
Drought Declaration — For the purpose of
this settlement agreement, a declared drought
App. 30
is whenever the USACE activates the Drought
Advisory Committee.
Electrical Demand Emergency - A condition
of the applicant’s power grid that potentially
would lead to reduction in voltage (brownouts)
or removing alternating customers from electri-
cal service (rolling black-outs) because demand
exceeds production within the applicants ser-
vice area.
Flood Control — The controlled release of wa-
ter from the USACE Kerr dam when the level
in Kerr Reservoir is in or above Zone E of the
' guide curve. 7
Instantaneous Flow — The flow in cfs passing
a point at a particular instant.
Kerr Dam (Buggs Island Dam) — The dam on
the Roanoke River immediately upstream of the
Gaston dam, forms Kerr Lake federally owned
and operated by the USACE.
mg/L (milligrams per liter) — An expression
of chemical concentration of matter (solid, liq-
uid or gas) dissolved in a liquid (usually water).
Minimum Flow and Target Flow — Unless
otherwise stated, minimum flow and target flow
shall refer to the sum of the instantaneous re-
leases made by the applicant from Roanoke
Rapids dam.
MWH (megawatt hour) — A unit of measure
for the production of electricity equal to 1 mil-
lion watts for one hour.
Peaking Day — Any day when the amount of
water released by the applicant from the Roa-
noke Rapids dam exceeds the daily mean of the
App. 31
USACE weekly declaration by 1000 cfs aver-
aged over the day.
Peaking Period — Any two-hour period when
the mean rate of release in cfs exceeds the
hourly mean of the daily release by 2500 cfs or
more, or as modified as per section 3.2.
ppm (parts per million) — An expression of
chemical concentration of matter (solid, liquid
or gas) dissolved in a liquid (usually water).
One ppm = one mg/L.
Settlement Agreement -— The “Comprehen-
sive Relicensing Settlement Agreement for the
Roanoke Rapids and Gaston Dam Project,
FERC Project No. P-2009,” effective July 2003.
USACE Weekly declaration - The total
amount of water the USACE allocates for release
in one week, plus additional water (energy) util-
ized by the applicant or Progress Energy from
their storage accounts, including adjustments the
USACE may make during the week. The declara-
tion may be referred to in either power (MWH) or
flow (cfs) units. When compared to or used to de-
fine minimum flow or target flow, the weekly dec-
laration shall be net of evaporation, consumptive
uses and local inflows into Lake Gaston and Roa-
noke Rapids Lake, except that water withdrawals
shall not be considered consumptive uses to the
extent they are supported by the release of water
from dedicated storage in Kerr Reservoir.
Week - The period of 7 days covered by the
weekly declaration of the Corps, currently, Sat-
urday 0000 hours through Friday 2400 hours.
Weekly Declaration Flood (WDFlood) — any
flood plain inundation that results (or would
App. 32
result) from a USACE weekly declaration of
flood control releases whether or not the appli-
cant releases peaking flows during the week.
Within-day Peaking - Any day with one or
more peaking periods.
Within-week Peaking — Any week with one or
more peaking days.
Violations of any condition herein set forth may result
in revocation of this Certification and may result in
criminal and/or civil penalties or other enforcement action.
This Certification shall become null and void unless the
above conditions are made conditions of the FERC Permit
This Certification shall expire upon expiration of the
FERC permit.
If this Certification is unacceptable to you, you have the
right to an adjudicatory hearing upon written request within
sixty (60) days following receipt of this Certification. This
request must be in the form of a written petition conforming to
Chapter 150B of the North Carolina General Statutes and filed
with the Office of Administrative Hearings, PO. Box 27447,
Raleigh, N.C. 27611-7447. If modifications are made to an
original Certification, you have the right to an adjudicatory
hearing on the modifications upon written request within sixty
(60) days following receipt of the Certification. Unless such
demands are made, this Certification shall be final and binding.
This the 30th day of July 2003
DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY
/s/ [illegible]
Alan Klimek, P.E., Director
Certification Number 3208
App. 33
Certificate of Completion
DWQ Project No.: 02-0919 County: Halifax and other
adjacent counties
Applicant: Dominion North Carolina Power
Project Name: Roanoke Rapids and Lake Gaston FERC
Project
Date of issuance of 401 Water Quality Certification:
July 30, 2003
Upon completion of all work approved within the 401
Water Quality Certification or applicable Buffer
Rules, and any subsequent modifications, the appli-
cant is required to return this certificate to the
401/Wetlands Unit, North Carolina Division of Water
Quality, 1621 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC,
27699-1621.This form may be returned to DWQ by the
applicant, the applicant’s authorized agent, or the pro-
ject engineer. It is not necessary to send certificates
from all of these.
Applicant’s Certification
I, , hereby state that, to the best of my
abilities, due care and diligence was used in the ob-
servation of the construction such that the construc-
tion was observed to be built within substantial
compliance and intent of the 401 Water Quality Certi-
fication and Buffer Rules, the approved plans and
specifications, and other supporting materials.
Signature: Date:
Agent’s Certification
I, , hereby state that, to the best of my abilities,
due care and diligence was used in the observation of
the construction such that the construction was ob-
served to be built within substantial compliance and
Intent of the 401 Water Quality Certification and
App. 34
Buffer Rules, the approved plans and epecifications,
and other supporting materials.
Signature: Date:
If this project was designed by a Certified Professional
I, , as a duly registered Professional
(i *., Engineer, Landscape Architect, Sur-
veyor, etc) in the State of North Carolina, having been
authorized to observe (periodically, weekly, full time)
the construction of the project, for the Permittee
hereby state that, to the best of my abilities, due care
and diligence was used in the observation of the con-
struction such that the construction was observed to
be built within substantial compliance and intent of
the 401 Water Quality Certification and Buffer Rules,
the approved plans and specifications, and other sup-
porting materials.
Signature: Registration No. Date
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.