Joint Appendix Vol III — Kelo v. New London

Supreme Court brief2005

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

C3- 2004

CATICL Ob The cade

Supreme Court of the United States

SUSETTE KELO, THELMA BRELESKY, PASQUALE

CRISTOFARO, WILHELMINA AND CHARLES DERY, JAMES

AND LAURA GURETSKY, PATAYA CONSTRUCTION

LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, and WILLIAM VON WINKLE,

Vv

Petitioners,

CITY OF NEW LONDON, and NEW

LONDON DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION,

@

Respondents.

On Writ Of Certiorari To The

Supreme Court Of Connecticut

eo

JOINT APPENDIX

Volume III, Pages 488 to 735

A

Horton, SHIELDS & Knox, P-C.

WESLEY W. HortTon*

DANIEL J. KRISCH

90 Gillett Street

Hartford, CT 06105

(860) 522-8338

(860) 728-0401 (fax)

WALLER, SMITH & PALMER, PC.

EDWARD B. O’CONNELL

52 Eugene O’Neill Drive

New London, CT 06320

(860) 442-0367

(860) 447-9915 (fax)

Conway & LONDREGAN

THOMAS J. LONDREGAN

JEFFREY T. LONDREGAN

38 Huntington Street

New London, CT 06320

(860) 447-3171

(860) 444-6103 (fax)

Counsel for Respondents

*Counsel of Record

INSTITUTE FOR JUSTICE

WILLIAM H. MELLOR

Scott G. BULLOCK*

DANA BERLINER

1717 Pennsylvania Ave., NW

Suite 200

Washington, DC 20006

(202) 955-1300

(202) 955-1329 (fax)

SAWYER Law Firm, LLC

Scott W. SAWYER

The Jili S. Sawyer Building

251 Williams Street

New London, CT 06320

(860) 442-8131

(860) 442-4131 (fax)

Counsel for Petitioners

OOOO

Petition For Certiorari Filed July 19, 2004

Certiorari Granted September 28, 2004

OOOO S OO

COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO (800) 225-6964

OR CALL COLLECT (402) $42 2831 /

| Supreme Cour! US

JOINT APPENDIX TABLE OF CONTENTS

Volume I

Relevant Docket Entries from the Courts below................ 1

EXHIBITS FROM TRIAL HELD IN THE

SUPERIOR COURT, JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF

NEW LONDON IN JULY AND AUGUST, 2001

MAPS

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit TT — Fort Trumbull MDP Area —

New London, Conmecticut ................::ccccccccseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees 3

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit VV — Fort Trumbull MDP Com-

posite Land Use Plan Map 3..............::cccssscsseeeseseeeeseenees 4

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit YY — Fort Trumbull Develop-

ment Site Plan dated October 10, 2000 .....................0000 5

OTHER EXHIBITS

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit B - Representative Statement of

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit I - New London Development

Corporation (NLDC) Board’s Record of Vote and

Resolution dated October 16, 2000 ...................ccccceeeeeeees 9

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit II —- Letter to George Milne from

Claire Gaudiani dated December 15, 1997................... 18

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit PP1 — Email to George Milne

from James Serbia dated October 21, 1998................... 21

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit PP2 - Letter to Dr. Claire

Gaudiani from George Milne, Jr. dated March 8,

ii

JOINT APPENDIX

TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued

Defendant NLDC’s Exhibit 12 - New London City

Counsel Resolution of January 18, 2000, author-

izing the use of eminent domain.................c0000eees 26

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit HHH - Memorandum from

Developer Marty Jones of Corcoran Jennison to

Joseph E. Corcoran, Gary Jennison, Scott

Dumont, Harry Nash and Eliza Edelsberg dated

GRRTIRGED TR, TRO cccnsscccesnsscsesccssvesncecscsocsccecssccccccummmmnanaes 30

Excerpts from Defendant NLDC’s Exhibit 38 — Fort

Trumbull Municipal Development Plan (MDP) Revised

Administrative Draft, August 1999

* Section 1: Introduction (pgs. 1-1 through 1-11

CIID scncnannncnnscsessnsnntocenntncnnasesensccenesscencesessesssccinammanane 83

* Section 3: Existing Site Conditions (pgs. 3-19

Oe ctenecsesersccnsscassnnmeetesesmenemmmmens 96

¢ Section 5: Proposed Improvements..................00+ 108

¢ Section 9: Administrative Plan Summary ............. 188

¢ Appendix A: Selection of and Rationale for the

Preferred Alternative — Fort Trumbull MDP

¢ Proposed Land Uses Map 5.1...........::::ccceeceeeeseeeees 212

Volumes II and III

Defendant NLDC’s Exhibit 34 - Lraft Environ-

mental Impact Evaluation — dated November 10,

JOINT APPENDIX

TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued

Page

The following documents have been omitted in the

printing of this Joint Appendix. They may be found in the

Appendix to the Petition for Writ of Certiorari at the

following pages:

Opinion of the Superior Court of Connecticut,

Judicial District of New London, At New London,

Decided March 13, 2002 ................ccccccccceeseeeeeeeees App. 191

Opinion of the Connecticut Supreme Court, De-

SS een App. 1

Order of Connecticut Supreme Court Granting

Motion for Stay of Execution Pending Decision by

the United States Supreme Court, Decided April

Order of the Connecticut Supreme Court Denying

Motion for Reconsideration, Decided April 20,

488

4.0 IMPACT EVALUATION

4.1 Overview of Impacts

source are evaluated for the six land use concept alter-

natives presented in Section 3.0 of this document. This

impact evaluation has been organizationally struc-

tured to be compatible with the existing conditions

inventory presented in Section 2.0 of this document.

Major issues evaluated include (1) consistency with

state and local land use policies for the Fort Trumbull

area; (2) consistency with the Connecticut Coastal

Management Act with respect to water dependency of

waterfront uses; (3) consistency with the project goals

of world class development, economic stimulation, wa-

terfront public access, and the revitalization of down-

town New London; (4) consistency with flood manage-

ment policies; (5) neighborhood relocation impacts; (6)

traffic and parking impacts; and (7) other identified

issues particular to each alternative.

A brief summary of significant positive and negative

impacts of each alternative is presented in Tables 4.1-

1 through 4.1-6. These are described in greater detail

in Sections 4.2 through 4.18 of this document.

A summary that rates the alternatives’ consistency

with project goals and objectives and related impacts is

presented in Table 4.1-7. Designations have been as-

signed for general consistency and impact, without re-

gard to the weight of each area or the degree to which

lective opinion of the project consultant team based on

available data and information, as well as input from

NLDC, state agencies, and various other reviewers. To

assign numerical values to these attributes would be

overly subjective and was therefore not done.

489

The following project goals merit further description:

Complement Pfizer — Consistency of alternatives

with the planned Pfizer facility to the south (and out-

side) of the MDP area is based on whether or not the

land uses would complement the planned develop-

ment. The only alternative which was considered to

be inconsistent was the no action alternative, since it

would result in segmented and disconnected projects,

with no improvements proposed between the two. The

recreation/tourism and residential/commercial alter-

natives were considered neutral in that they would

not be anticipated to detract from the Pfizer facility,

but would not necessarily complement it either. The

business campus and mixed use alternatives were de-

termined to be compatible with and complement the

planned Pfizer facility.

Economic and Financial Considerations — Con-

sistency of alternatives with economic stimulation, job

creation, generation of tax revenues, and creation of

spin-off activity was based on the socioeconomic

analysis presented in Section 4.3 of this document.

Downtown Revitalization - New London is cur-

rently undergoing analysis and evaluation of its

downtown community. Most of these planning pro-

jects are underway and finalized details are not yet

available. The determination of consistency (or lack

thereof) of the alternatives for the Fort Trumbull area

with downtown revitalization is based upon whether

proposed uses would complement or detract from

downtown uses. For instance, a large retail compo-

nent or ferry services would likely duplicate services

which are currently or will soon be provided in the

downtown area, whereas uses in the Fort Trumbull

area that would draw upon or rely on downtown

amenities were considered to be consistent. Residen-

tial uses would be considered neutral or marginally

490

consistent with downtown revitalization in that they

would not likely detract or complement the revitaliza-

tion efforts in downtown New London.

The Fort Trumbull area benefits from its proximity to

downtown New London, which is a major transporta-

tion hub. It is situated near Interstates 95 and 395,

with numerous multi-modal transportation amenities

in the immediate vicinity. Amtrak and Shoreline East

provide daily train service to downtown New London.

Amtrak expects its electrified track to be operational

by the year 2000. Cross Sound Ferry Services, Inc.

provides water transportation to Long Island, Block

Island, and Fisher’s Island. The city has recently in-

vested in a large parking facility located in central

ditionally the Groton/New London Airport is located

across the Thames River in Groton, providing service

to Philadelphia and New York City. South East Area

Transit (SEAT) provides bus service to the southeast

region. Other land uses in downtown New London in-

clude municipal offices, places of worship, business of-

fices, industrial operations, retail, and residential

uses.

Common to Alternatives 2 through 6 is a physical

linkage to downtown New London through the pro-

posed waterfront riverwalk which will ideally make

use of the Amtrak bridge at the entrance to Shaw’s

Cove. Alternately, this linear walkway could take an

inland route, connecting the Fort Trumbull area with

downtown New London.

Resource Impacts - Impacts on resources, regula-

area are also summarized in Table 4.1-7. These are

based upon the analysis presented in Sections 4.2

through 4.16 of this document.

on 491

TABLE 4.1-1

Advantages and Disadvantages of Alternative

No. 1 - No Action

Advantages Disadvantages

¢ Proposed uses at the|* The land uses off NUWC

NUWC site are consistent} would continue to be in dis-

with state and local land) parity with local zoning

use policies for the area. state planning

° Proposed waterfront uses|* Would not meet the project

are water dependent and| goals, objectives, or vision

are consistent with the| for the Fort Trumbull area

CCMA. in total.

* Implementation § would/* Would not complement

result in economic gains,) Pfizer due to the disconti-

and no cost would be in-| nuity of sites.

curred the cit

NLDC. by , Would not have a strong

' itive impact on down-

* No neighborhood reloca- a ‘talizati

tion would be involved. —_

© Public access to the water-

front would not be maximized.

© Would not receive the benefit

of positive roadway and util-

ity improvements proposed]

in the MDP process.

¢ Would not provide aes-

thetic improvements to the!

Fort and Gateway Areas

¢ Flood hazards would not be}

reduced.

* Traffic and parking impacts}

would not be mitigated.

¢ The existing building

492

TABLE 4.1-2

Advantages and Disadvantages of

Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Advantages

© Proposed waterfront uses| ¢

are water dependent and

are consistent with the

¢ Would be compatible with

flood management poli-|*

cies.

¢ Aesthetic and visual im-

provements would result. | ¢

493

TABLE 4.1-3

Advantages and Disadvantages of

Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

Advantages

Disadvantages

494

TABLE 4.1-4

Advantages and Disadvantages of

Alternative No. 4 -

Business Campus

Proposed waterfront uses

are water dependent and

are consistent with the

CCMA.

Waterfront access would

be provided by the pro-

posed riverwalk.

Will encourage private

investment.

Minimal neighborhood

relocat vn would be nec-

essary.

Aesthetic and visual im-

provements would result.

* Proposed uses are not

onsistent with state and

local land use policies for

the area.

© Would create fewer

number of jobs and tax

revenues as compared

with other alternatives.

¢ Would result in less spin-

off economic activity as

compared to other alter-

natives.

¢ May not have a strong

public funding source.

¢ Would not have a strong

positive impact on down-

town revitalization.

* Would locate residential

uses in a flood hazard

zone (but could be miti-

gated).

¢ Traffic and parking im-

pacts would result (but

could be mitigated).

Advantages

Disadvantages

¢ Proposed uses are consis-

tent with state and local

land use policies for the

area.

¢ Proposed waterfront uses

are water dependent and

are consistent with the

CCMA.

e Waterfront access would

be provided by the pro-

posed riverwalk.

e Would maximize number

of jobs in close proximity

to Pfizer.

¢ Would create highest

number of jobs and tax

revenues as compared to

other alternatives.

* Would result in greatest

spin-off economic activity

as compared to other ai-

ternatives.

¢ Aesthetic and visual im-

provements would result.

e Would be consistent with

and complement down-

town revitalization.

¢ Would locate residential

uses in a flood hazard

zone (but could be miti-| ©

gated).

* Traffic and parking im-

pacts would result (but

could be mitigated).

* 100% neighborhood relo-

cation would result from

implementation of this

alternative (but could be

mitigated).

495

TABLE 4.1-5

Advantages and Disadvantages of

Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

Advantages

Disadvantages

496

TABLE 4.1-6

Advantages and Disadvantages of

Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

¢ Proposed uses are consis-

tent with state and local

land use policies for the

area.

e Proposed waterfront uses

are water dependent and

are consistent with the

CCMA.

e Waterfront access would

be provided by the pro-

posed riverwalk.

e Would provide a balanced

mix of land uses.

e Will encourage private

investment.

e Would create jobs and tax

revenues consistent with

project goals.

¢ Would result in spin-off

economic activity consis-

tent with project goals.

e Aesthetic and visual im-

provements would result.

e Would be consistent with

and complement down-

town revitalization.

e Would locate residential

uses in a flood hazard

zone (but could be miti-

gated).

* Traffic and parking im-

pacts would result (but

could be mitigated).

¢ Neighborhood relocation

would result (but could be

mitigated).

Advantages

Disadvantages

¢ Proposed uses are consis-

tent with state and local

land use policies for the

area.

e Would provide a balanced

mix of land uses.

¢ Proposed waterfront uses

~ are water dependent and

are consistent with the

CCMA.

e Waterfront access would

be provided by the pro-

posed riverwalk.

¢ Would create jobs and tax

revenues consistent with

project goals.

¢ Would result in spin-off

economic activity consis-

tent with project goals.

e Will encourage private

investment.

e Would be comparible with

e Aesthetic and visual im-

provements would result.

e Would be consistent with

and complement downtown

¢ 100% neighborhood relo-

cation would result from

implementation of this

alternative (but could be

mitigated).

¢ Traffic and parking im-

pacts would result (but

could be mitigated).

497

TABLE 4.1-7

Fort Trumbull MDP Area Alternatives Impact Summary

IMPACTS

STVIMaLYW snoauvzvul

sion)

o;0

ALITVND uv}

oO

0

9o;oO;0

o;}OoO;0

o};oO;,0

LN@WNOUIANS 1VDISAHd|

o

o

o

LINIWNOUWANS av19071016)

o;o;o0;0;0

TVILNTLOd CUVZVH

+

SADANOSTA VALVM

ONDNVd GNV Dl4sVUL

SIDUNOSIY TVANLIND

SADIAUNTS GNV SELLIMLN DIT

o;o;@;o;o;o

o;o;e@;0o0

SIDUNOSIY IWASIA/DILAALSIV

+

+

SADIANIS/STILITIOVA ALINAWWO

91oO;or1To;}@;oao;e;a;oa

NOILVIO134 aoorsoaHoran)

+

S)IWONOII01909

+

DNINOZ GNV ASN anvil

+

GOALS & OBJECTIVES

NOILVZIMULIATY NMOLNMOG|

Oo

Sasn LNIGNId3aG waived

SSZDOV LNOUTMILVM

ALIAILDV 440-NIdS ALVIN}

GANGAT XVL a1vuana9l

NOtLVIe) aOr

NOLLV'TNWILS DLINONOD A]

uaZldd LNaWa1aWwoo}

LAND USE CONCEPT ALTERNATIVE

Alternative | - No Action

Alternative 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Alternative 3 - Residential/Commercial

Alternative 4 - Business Campes

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2

O Marginelty Consictent/Minimnal impact (Positive or Negative) © inconsistent/Negstive lepect

lanpect

+

498

4.2 Land Use and Zoning Impacts

4.2.1 Consistency With Relevant Policies and

Programs

Detailed discussions of statewide land use policies,

municipal zoning regulations, and coastal manage-

ment policies are presented in Section 2.1 of this

document. Brief summaries are presented below.

Statewide Land Use Policies

The majority of the Fort Trumbull MDP area has

been designated in the Conservation and Development

Policies Plan for Connecticut as an Urban Area Re-

gional Center. Regional Centers encompass land

areas containing traditional core commercial, indus-

trial, transportation, specialized institutional ser-

vices, and facilities of intertown significance.

State policy seeks to concentrate economic develop-

ment to the extent possible in major urban centers,

promoting infill development and intensification

where appropriate. It is also intended to promote sta-

bility of urban communities and to support staged,

orderly growth of urban development. The goals and

objectives of the statewide plan are used to assess the

consistency of proposed actions with state policy.

State actions (including projects which are funded in

whole or in part with state money) that influence the

form and location of development or conservation be-

cause of investments in infrastructure, real property,

physical facilities, and human services should con-

form to this strategy.

Pertinent goals of regional centers include revitaliza-

tion of the economic base, revitalization of the quality

of life for urban area residents, and economic devel-

opment assistance emphasizing site cleanup, land

499

assembly, structural rehabilitation, and the location

of labor-intensive businesses to revitalize the eco-

nomic base. Priority should be given to. infrastructure

proposals, new product development and facilities for

start-up firms, location of appropriate state facilities

within urban areas, promotion of recreational uses of

urban rivers, and development of heritage parks.

Regional Land Use Goals and Objectives

In 1997, the Southeastern Connecticut Council of

Governments (COG) published their Regional Conser-

vation and Development Policy Guide for Southeast-

ern Connecticut. The following major land use goals

and objectives have been identified for the region.

Minimizing the risks of high unemployment and over-

dependence on a single industry has been identified

by the COG as a major issue of concern. Their goal is

a restructuring the regional economy in order to pro-

vide a balanced and diversified economic base

through the creation of development opportunities.

Improved coordination between the various entities

having primary responsibilities with respect to eco-

nomic development has been cited as the major objec-

tive in achieving this goal.

Developing a transportation system that provides ac-

cess to regional resources for both residents, region-

ally employed, and visitors is also a key issue to the

Southeastern Connecticut COG’s planning efforts.

The intent is to balance needs via several objectives

outlined in the regional! plan, including:

* coordination of policies among key transportation

stakeholders;

* protection of natural and cultural resources during

new system development;

500

* recognition of fiscal constraint;

* expansion of intermodal links; and,

¢ development of alternative modes of transporta-

destrian paths, and light trails.

Additionally, provision of a public utility infrastruc-

ture system that balances the needs and protection of

the region’s population and resources is also a high

priority. It is intended that development and expan-

sion be focused within the region’s core. Objectives

identified for meeting this goal include the following:

* maintenance and improvement of public facilities

such as water, sewer, and solid waste facilities;

* improved coordination between various utilities

and authorities; and,

* encouragement of high density development in ar-

eas suitable to service.

Municipal Zoning Regulations

There is currently a disparity between land use and

zoning in the Fort Trumbull MDP area. Three mu-

nicipal zones occur within the project area. These are

Waterfront Commercial/Industrial (WC-I), Waterfront

Development District (WD), and General Commercial

District (C-I). As would be expected, the majority of

waterfront property is zoned WC-I and WD, with the

interior parcels zoned C-l. There are no residential

zones within the MDP boundary.

Municipal zoning can be modified as part of the MDP

process. However, the Fort Trumbull area has been

targeted for renewal and revitalization for many

501

years and the current zoning reflects the historic

planning philosophy of the city.

Consistency of Program Elements with the

Connecticut Coastal Management Act Policies

Coastal management policies, statutes, and regula-

tions give highest priority and preference to uses and

facilities which are dependent upon proximity to the

water or the shorelands immediately adjacent to ma-

rine and tidal waters. Water-dependent uses are de-

fined by the CCMA to be those uses which:

require direct access to, or location in, marine or

tidal waters and which therefore, cannot be lo-

cated inland, including but not limited to: mari-

nas, recreational and commercial fishing and

boating facilities, finfish and shellfish processing

plants, waterfront dock and port facilities, ship-

— yards and boat building facilities, water-based

recreational uses, navigation aides, basins and

channels, industrial uses dependent upon water-

borne transportation or requiring large volumes

of cooling or process water which cannot rea-

sonably be located or operated at an inland site

and uses which provide general public access to

marine or tidal waters [C.G.S. Section 22a-

93(16)).

Numerous proposed waterfront uses have been re-

viewed for consistency with the CCMA with respect to

water dependency, since these uses are common to

numerous alternatives. Other aspects of CCMA con-

sistency are addressed under their individual topics

in this section of the document (i.e., flood control. bio-

logical resources, etc.). Moving from south to north

along the perimeter of the peninsula, the following

waterfront uses are proposed:

502

Riverwalk - A proposed riverwalk would follow the

perimeter of the peninsula. This feature is intended to

encourage public access to a water resource that has

been unavailable to the general public for many dec-

ades. The riverwalk is proposed to be located primar-

ily in state designated preservation areas, consistent

with policies which are intended to discourage inten-

sive development in these areas. Other uses, such as

the proposed hotel site, residential, and office uses

that are proposed in the various alternatives would

occur landward of the riverwalk, thus providing pub-

lic access directly adjacent to the waterfront. This

philosophy is consistent with the CCMA and with re-

cent Department of Environmental Protection ap-

provals.

Regional Water Pollution Control Facility - Sew-

age treatment disposal is water dependent because of

the need for a receiving waterbody for the large vol-

ume of treated wastewater effluent. The regional

WPCF has been located along the Thames River in

New London since 1929. The only anticipated modifi-

cations are related to improvements to odor control

and aesthetics. No land use or zoning changes are

proposed.

State Park - The CCMA encourages public access to

the waters of Long Island Sound by expansion, devel-

opment, and effective utilization of state-owned rec-

reational facilities within the coastal area that are

consistent with sound resource conservation proce-

dures and constitutionally protected rights of private

property owners. The development of the proposed

Fort Trumbull State Park is therefore consistent with

CCMA policy.

Navy/Coast Guard Facilities - These are existing

operations which are located on the NUWC property

waterfront. These would remain unchanged in their

503

nature. Water dependency is integral to these two or-

ganizations.

Waterfront Related Commercial/Columbia Cove

Area - Two areas along the peninsula perimeter have

been designated as water related or waterfront com-

mercial. These are currently occupied in part by the

Fort Trumbull Marina and the New London Seafood

Distributors. Ongoing water-dependent uses are pro-

posed under all alternatives, either as rehabilit .ed

existing facilities or new water-dependent facilities.

4.2.2 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Alternative 1 assumes change only to the NUWC

property. This area is currently zoned as a Waterfront

Commercial/Industrial District. Current land use is a

vacant naval base facility, with limited activities.

Land uses and zoning off the NUWC property would

reflect current conditions.

The majority of the NUWC property is designated as

a regional center in the Conservation and Develop-

ment Policies Plan for Connecticut. The fringes of this

land mass are classified as either Conservation or

Preservation areas, presumably due to their flood

prone nature immediately adjacent to the Thames

River.

The proposed land uses at the NUWC site under this

alternative include a 16-acre state park, an area iden-

tified as municipal maritime conveyance, and public

sale for business office uses. These are consistent with

local zoning classifications as well as regional and

statewide planning documents.

‘he coastal management regulations and guidelines

give high priority and preference to uses and facilities

which are dependent upon proximity to the water or

504

the shorelands immediately adjacent to marine and

tidal waters. A state park and ferry terminal would

likely be viewed by the Department of Environmental

Protection as water-dependent land uses. The pro-

posed business/office use is located inland from the

waterfront.

4.2.3 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

The Recreation/tourism alternative includes an ex-

panded state park and other recreational amenities in

the Fort and NUWC portions of the MDP area, along

with several water-related and waterfront commercial

uses. Office and retail uses are concentrated in the

Gateway Area, west of the Amtrak rail line and away

from the Thames River waterfront.

Although recreational facilities offer positive benefits

with respect to public use and public access to the wa-

terfront, they do not promote the overall goals and ob-

jectives of local, regional, or statewide planning

policies and philosophies. This issue alone may not

preclude development as proposed under this alterna-

tive. However, it is a significant factor in evaluating

its consistency with pertinent land use planning poli-

cies. Office and retail uses, proposed in the interior

Gateway Area, are consistent with local, regional, and

statewide policies.

4.2.4 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

The proposed uses under this alternative, particularly

those east of the Amtrak railroad, are less intensive

than existing land uses or that which is allowed un-

der current zoning regulations. yo ee

dential use does not promote local, regional, or

statewide planning policies and philosophies and does

not meet the identified objectives and goals which are

505

used to assess consistency of a proposed action in ur-

ban regional centers. Likewise, zoning in the project

area has not been specifically designated for residen-

tial uses. However, similar to Alternative 2, this issue

alone may not preclude development as proposed un-

der this alternative.

The proposed marina/waterfront commercial and wa-

ter-related commercial uses east of the railroad line

are in keeping with state land use planning policies

and local zoning regulations. Similarly, commercial

and retail uses in the Gateway Area are consistent

with the same.

4.2.5 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

The majority of land uses associated with the busi-

ness campus scenario are consistent with statewide

planning policies and with local zoning regulations.

The Gateway Area provides a mix of office and retail

uses, with a small amount of residential uses on the

west side of Howard Street.

4.2.6 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

This alternative provides a more balanced mix of uses

in the MDP area. Although residential uses are not

explicitly encouraged in regional centers, the area of

residential use in the Fort and NUWC areas is offset

by the concentrated office/incubator uses in the

Gateway Area. The business office. retail, and ho-

tel/conference center uses are consistent with state-

wide policies and local zoning regulations.

506

4.2.7 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

This alternative is similar to Alternative 5 in that it

provides a balanced mix of uses without a dispropor-

tionate amount of residential land uses. The Gateway

Area supports a strong office/incubator use to offset

the residential use in the Fort Area. The expanded

Hotel/Conference Center is better suited to meet eco-

nomic goals. These latter uses are consistent with

statewide policies and local zoning regulations.

Socioeconomic Impacts

Key socioeconomic impacts have been estimated for

each of the six alternatives. Included in the impact

analysis is a review of the potential for job creation,

including direct jobs, indirect jobs, and construction

employment. An estimate of the net property tax gain

is also presented for each alternative, which includes

the projected decline in valuation associated with

demolition of existing structures, as well as the pro-

jected increase in valuation associated with the con-

struction of new facilities. A discussion of the

economic costs and benefits is also presented for each

alternative.

4.3.1 Methodology

In order to estimate the tax impacts associated with

each of the alternative land use plans, several sources

of information were utilized. The estimated current

value of facilities in the study area is based on indi-

vidual building assessments, as provided by the New

London assessor’s office. The level of new construction

activity for each alternative is as presented in Section

3.0 of this document. Construction costs for each type

of facility were developed based on construction cost

data provided by the Marshall & Swift Valuation

507

Service, a well known construction cost estimating

guide. These construction cost estimates serve as the

basis for estimating property tax revenues for the de-

velopment alternatives.

The baseline estimates for jobs within the MDP area

(as well as housing units and occupancy) are based on

windshield surveys of the area and on information

gathered through a review of property tax cards pro-

vided by the New London assessor’s office. The study

area was toured on several occasions to determine oc-

cupancy and to compare field observations with in-

formation provided by the assessor’s office.

Estimates of potential direct employment are based

on multipliers provided by the Urban Land Institute

(ULI. ULI tracks development trends throughout the

United States and has estimated ranges of the square

footage required for each employee by industry. Some

of the key components of this information are in-

cluded in Table 4.3-1.

TABLE 4.3-1

Square Footage Per Employee by Industry

650

108,900 174,240

500 2,000

=.

250

2.9 rooms per

employee

2.0 rooms per

employee

Source: Urban Land Institute

‘Although ULI does not track hotels as a separate cate-

gory, information for New London has been developed

based on data obtained from the U.S. Bureau of the

Census.

508

These figures have been used to create a range of di-

rect employment for each alternative, based on the

build-out estimates presented in Section 3.0. In order

to estimate the indirect or induced employment for

each industry, the findings of the U.S. Department of

Commerce’s Regional Input-Outp it Modeling System,

known as RIMS II, were utilized. The RIMS II model

calculates induced employment by industry for each

state. Indirect or induced employment is created as

workers (direct jobs) spend their earnings in the re-

gional economy for food, clothing, housing, automo-

biles, etc. As these earnings are “recycled” through

the economy, additional jobs are created at food

stores, clothing stores, and the like. The key Con-

necticut multipliers used in this analysis are summa-

rized in Table 4.3-2.

TABLE 4.3-2

RIMS II Multipliers by Land Use Category

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce

509

As illustrated in Table 4.3-2, every direct job created

in the retail sector creates an additional 0.4992 jobs

elsewhere in the economy. The higher multipliers as-

sociated with new office development are related to

the nature of the development associated wit> Pfizer

and the generally higher multiples of R&D ane »«nu-

facturing operations.

Estimates of construction jobs associated with new

development in the study area are based on the pro-

jected construction costs for each facility, as deter-

mined through the Marshall & Swift Valuation

Service. Based on the total construction cost for each

land use alternative, total construction wages have

been estimated at 45% of construction costs. Using

the average construction wages for southeastern

Connecticut of $38,388, as provided by the Connecti-

cut Department of Labor, the number of person-years

of construction employment associated with each land

use alternative can be estimated. For example, if con-

struction wages are estimated to be $5,000,000, a to-

tal of 130.25 person-years of construction employment

would be created at an average wage of $38,388.

It is important to note that all financial information

contained in this document is stated in 1998 dollars.

No allowance has been made for inflation or the tim-

ing of revenues and/or expenses.

4.3.2 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Alternative 1 is referred to as the No Action alterna-

tive. However, this name is somewhat misleading,

since the implementation of this alternative includes

creation of a state park on a portion of the former

U.S. Navy Undersea Warfare Center (NUWC) site as

well as private development of approximately 380,000

square feet of non-residential facilities at NUWC.

510

Job Creation

The implementation of this alternative is anticipated

to create between 1,080 and 1,779 direct jobs. The

majority of these jobs (950 to 1,520) are related to the

reuse of the former NUWC facilities by private sector

entities. The occupancy of an existing under-utilized

office building accounts for an additional 126 to 253

jobs. The remaining jobs are associated with the crea-

tion of the state park. No existing jobs are expected to

be lost under this alternative, with the exception of

the NUWC caretaker staff, estimated to be between

10 and 15. Additional indirect jobs are estimated to be

between 802 and 1,321. This brings the total number

of net new direct and indirect jobs associated with

this alternative to between 1,872 and 3,085.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative will add new

property to the city’s tax base in the form of the for-

mer NUWC property, which was tax-exempt due to

federal government ownership. Based on an analysis

of properties within the study area, the average prop-

erty assessment is estimated to be $26.00 per square

foot of building area. Using the estimated 380,000

square feet of facilities at NUWC which would be de-

veloped, the city’s tax base would increase by $9.88

million. Using the tax rate of $27.30 per $1,900 of

valuation, property tax revenue for the City of New

London would increase by approximately $270,000.

4.3.3 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

The development program of Alternative 2 is summa-

rized in the Table 4.3-3.

511

TABLE 4.3-3

Development Program - Alternative 2 -

Recreation/Tourism

Land Use Programmed Development

State Park 30 Acres

Columbia Cove Area 80 — 100 Slips

Water-Related Commercial 25,000 — 30,000 SF

otel 80 Rooms

ation Center 25,000 SF

useum(s) 55,000 — 70,000 SF

ce (Existing) 50,500 SF

ce/Incubator 80,000 SF

tail 20,000 SF

D/Office 5,000 SF

aterfront Commercial 25,000 SF

Based on the identified development program, the

projected job creation associated with this alternative

has been estimated. Direct job creation is projected to

be between 506 and 1,019. Due to the density of em-

ployment, office uses contribute the largest number of

jobs, accounting for 339 jobs under the low estimate

and 598 under the high estimate. Table 4.3-4 provides

the estimated job creation by land use category.

512

TABLE 4.3-4

Estimated Range of Direct Employment -

Alternative 2 - Recreation/Tourism

— Low Estimate High Estimate

ployment Employees | Employees

tate Park 8 12

lumbia Cove Area 1 5

ater-Related Commercial 46 120

27 40

tion Center 13 50

useum(s) 4 14

ce (Existing) 126 253

ce/Incubator 200 320

31 80

D Office 13 25

aterfront Commercial 38 180

506 1,019 a

Source: Urban Land Institute and RKG Associates, Inc.

As an offset to the jobs created under this alternative,

it is necessary to subtract the existing jobs in the

study area. It is estimated that 148 to 222 people cur-

rently work within the MDP area. Eliminating these

jobs brings the net gain from this alternative to be-

tween 358 and 797 jobs.

Additional indirect jobs will also be created in the re-

gional economy, based on the recirculation of wages

and purchases through the economy. It is estimated

that between 337 and 659 indirect jobs will be cre-

ated, as detailed in Table 4.3-5.

513

TABLE 4.3-5

Estimated Range of Indirect Employment -

Alternative 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Land Use Category

tate Park 4 6

umbia Cove Area 1 3

ater-Related Commercial 23 60

otel 15 22

tion Center 7 27

useum(s) 2 8

(Existing) 94 188

ce/Incubator 149 238

15 40

D Office 9 19

aterfront Commercial 19 50

337 659

The construction of new facilities in the study area

will also generate additional employment in the form

of short-term construction jobs. Implementation of

this alternative is expected to result. in between $28.2

and $58.1 million in new construction within the

area. Assuming that 45% of this cost is for wages, be-

tween $12.7 million and $26.1 million in construction

wages will be paid out. Using the average construc-

tion wage of $38,388 for the region, 331 to 681 person-

years of construction employment will be created.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative is expected to

generate between $28.2 and $58.1 million in new con-

struction activity. The projected construction costs are

detailed in the Table 4.3-6. -

mr eee

Source: Marshall & Swift Valuation Service and RKG

Associates, Inc.

Assuming that these facilities are assessed at an av-

erage of 70% of their construction cost, the New Lon-

don tax base would expand by between $19.8 million

and $40.7 million. However, the demolition of existing

structures in this area must also be accounted for.

Approximately $6 million in existing tax base will be

eliminated to implement this plan, making the net in-

crease in the tax base between $13.8 million and

$34.7 million. This translates into a net increase in

property tax revenues of between $375,000 and

$950,000.

515

43.4 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

The development program of Alternative 3 is summa-

rized in the Table 4.3-7.

Based on the identified development program, the

projected job creation associated with this alternative

has been estimated. Direct job creation is projected to

be between 335 and 710. Office uses contribute the

largest number of jobs. accounting for 376 jobs under

the low estimate and 398 under the high estimate.

Table 4.3-8 provides the estimated job creation by

land use category.

Source: Urban Land Institute and RKG Associates, Inc.

As an offset to the jobs created under this alternative,

it is necessary to subtract the existing jobs in the

study area. It is estimated that 148 to 222 people cur-

rently work within the study area. Eliminating these

jobs brings the net gain from this alternative to be-

tween 187 and 488 jobs.

Additional indirect jobs will also be created in the re-

gional economy, based on the recirculation of wages

and purchases through the economy. It is estimated

that between 220 and 452 indirect jobs will be cre-

ated, as detailed in Table 4.3-9.

517

TABLE 4.3-9

Estimated Range of Indirect Employment -

Alternative 3 - Residential/Commercial

= Indirect Employment

d Use Category Low Estimate

tate Park 2 3

olumbia Cove Area 1 3

ater-Related Commercial 23 60

tdoor Recreation Area 0 1

ce (Existing) 94 188

ce/Incubator 56 89

tail 15 40

D Office 9 19

aterfront Commercial 19 50

220 452

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and RKG Associ-

ates, Inc.

+618

TABLE 4.3-10

Estimated Construction Costs -

Alternative 3 - Residential/Commercial

= a

d Use Category Low Estimate

tate Park $3,200,000 | $12,000,000

olumbia Cove Area $450,000 $750,000

ater-Related Commercial $1,855,500 $2,941,800

utdoor Recreation Area $105,000 $393,750

idential Mid-Range $8,049,780 | $13,130,100

idential High-End $21,463,200 | $25,872,000

ce/Incubator $1,907,100 $4,070,700

$1,237,000 | $1,961,200

D/Office $317,850 $678,450

aterfront Commercial $1,546,250 $2,451,500

$40,131,680 | $64,249,500

The construction of new facilities in the MDP area

will also generate additional employment in the form

of short-term construction jobs. Implementation of

this alternative is expected to result in between $40.1

and $64.2 million in new construction within the

study area. Assuming that 45% of this cost is for

wages. between $18.1 million and $28.9 million in

construction wages will be paid out. Using the aver-

age construction wage of $38,388 for the region, 470

to 753. person-years of construction employment will

be created.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative is expected to

generate between $40.1 and $64.2 million in new con-

struction activity. The projected construction costs are

detailed in the Table 4.3-10.

Source: Marshall Valuation Service and RKG Associates,

Inc.

Assuming that these facilities are assessed at an av-

erage of 70% of their construction cost, the New Lon-

don tax base would expand by between $28.1 million

and $45.0 million. However, the demolition of existing

structures in this area must also be accounted for.

Approximately $6 million in existing tax base will be

eliminated to implement this plan, making the net in-

‘crease in the tax base between $22.1 million and

$39.0 million. This translates into a net increase in

property tax revenues of between $600,000 and $1.1

million.

4.3.5 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

Alternative 4 focuses on development of the study

area as a business campus. The development program

for this alternative is summarized in the Table 4.3-11.

519 520

TABLE 4.3-11 Development Program -

As an offset to the jobs created under this alternative,

Alternative 4 - Business Campus

it is necessary to subtract the existing jobs in the

Land Use Proposed Development study area. It is estimated that 148 to 222 people cur-

tate Park 16 Acres rently work within the study area. Eliminating these

olumbia Cove Area 80-100 Slips jobs brings the net gain from this alternative to be-

ater-Related Commercial 25,000-30,000 SF tween 1,184 and 2,067 jobs. Additional indirect jobs

otel/Conference Center 200 Rooms will also be created in the regional economy, based on

-- sidential Mid-Range 30 Units the recirculation of wages and purchases through the

ce (Existing) 50,500 SF economy. It is estimated that between 949 and 1,610

ce/Incubator 380,000-405,000 SF indirect jobs will be created, as detailed in Table 4.3-

tail 15,000 SF | 13.

D/Office 5,000 SF

aterfront Commercial 20,000-25,000 SF a pages «nh ts sicidtiaiialinn,

Job Creation Alternative 4 - Business Campus

Based on the identified development program, the job Indirect Employment

creation associated with this alternative has been esti- | = Use Category Low Estimate! High Estimate

mated. Direct job creation is projected to be between 1,332 tate Park 2

and 2,289. Office positions account for a large percentage

of total job creation, with 1,150 to 1,700 jobs. Table 4.3-12

provides the estimated job creation by land use category.

TABLE 4.3-12

Estimated Range of Direct Employment -

Alternative 4 - Business Campus

= Direct Employment

d Use Category Low Estimate Estimate

tate Park 4 6

olumbia Cove Area 1 5

ater-Related Commercial 46 120

otel/Conference Center 68 100

ce (Existing) 126 253

ce/Incubator 1,013 1,620

tail 23 60

D/Office 13 25

aterfront Commercial 38 100

1,332 2,289

Source: Urban Land Institute and RKG Associates, Inc.

3

olumbia Cove Area 1 3

ater-Related Commercial 23 60

otel/Conference Center 37 54

ce (Existing) 94 188

ce/Iucubator 753 1,204

i 12 30

D/Office 9 19

aterfront Commercial 19 50

tal 949 1,610

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and RKG Associ-

ates, Inc.

The construction of new facilities in the study area will

also generate additional employment, in the form of -

short-term construction jobs. Implementation of this

alternative is expected to result in between $56.8 and

$104.2 million in new construction within the MDP

area. Assuming that 45% of this cost is for wages, be-

tween $25.5 million and $46.9 million in construction

wages will be paid out. Using the average construction

521

wage of $38,388 for the region, 665 to 1,222 person-

years of construction employment will be created.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative is expected to

generate between $60.9 and $104.2-million in new

construction activity. The projected construction costs

are detailed in the Table 4.3-14.

TABLE 4.3-14

Estimated Construction Costs -

Alternative 4 - Business Campus

Land Use Category _ Low Estimate! High Estimate

Construction Costs

522

in property tax revenues of between $930,000 and

$1.8 million at full build-out.

4.3.6 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

Alternative 5 focuses on mixed use development of

the study area. The development program is summa-

rized in the Table 4.3-15.

tate Park $3,200,000 $12,000,000

olumbia Cove Area $450,000 $750,000

ater-Related Commercial! $1,855,500 $2,941,800

otel/Conference Center | $20,920,000 $26,038,000

idential Mid-Range $1,788,840 $2,917,800

ce/Incubator $25,745,850 $54,954,450

tail $927,750 $1,470,900

D/Office $317,850 $678,450

aterfront Commercial $1,546,250 $2,451,500

tal $56,752,040 | $104,202,900

TABLE 4.3-15

Development Program -

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

Proposed Development

16 Acres

olumbia Cove Area 80-100 Slips

ater-Related Commercial 25,000-30,000 SF

otel/Conference Center 200 Rooms

idential Mid-Range 115 Units

25,000 SF

ce (Existing) 50,500 SF

ce/Incubator 100,000 SF

10,000 SF

5,000 SF

aterfront Commercial 20,000-25,000 SF

Source: Marshall Valuation Service and RKG Associates,

Inc.

Assuming that these facilities are assessed at an

avenge of 70% of their construction cost, the New

London tax base would expand by between $39.7 mil-

lion and $72.9 million. However, the demolition of ex-

isting structures in this area must also be accounted

for. Approximately $5.6 million in existing tax base

will be eliminated to implement this plan, making the

net increase in the tax base between $34.10 million

and $67.3 million. This translates into a net increase

Job Creation

Based on the identified development program, the job

creation associated with this alternative has been es-

timated. Direct job creation is projected to be between

574 and 1,099. Due to the density of employment, of-

fice uses contribute the largest number of jobs, ac-

counting for 389 jobs under the low estimate and 678

under the high estimate. Table 4.3-16 provides the es-

timated job creation by land use category.

523

TABLE 4.3-16

Estimated Range of Direct Employment -

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

524

TABLE 4.3-17

Estimated Range of Indirect Employment -

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

= Direct Employment

: d Use Category Low Estimate High

tate Park 4 6

olumbia Cove Area 1 5

ater-Related Commercial 46 120

otel/Conference Center 68 100

thletic Club 13 50

ce (Existing) 126 253

ce/Incubator 250 400

tail 15 40

D/Office 13 25

aterfront Commercial 38 100

tal 574 1,099

Source: Urban Land Institute and RKG Associates, Inc.

hie Indirect Employment

d Use Category Low Estimate Estimate}

tate Park 2 3

olumbia Cove Area 1 3

ater-Related Commercial 23 60

otel/Conference Center 37 54

thletic Club 7 27

ce (Existing) 94 188

ce/Incubator 186 297

tail 8 20

D/Office 9 19

aterfront Commercial 19 50

tal 385 720

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and RKG Associ-

ates, Inc.

As an offset to the jobs created under this alternative,

it is necessary to subtract the existing jobs in the

study area. It is estimated that 148 to 222 people cur-

rently work within the study area. Eliminating these

jobs brings the net gain from this alternative to be-

tween 426 and 877 jobs.

Additional indirect jobs will also be created in the re-

gional economy, based on the recirculation of wages

and purchases through the economy. It is estimated

that between 385 and 720 indirect jobs will be cre-

ated, as detailed in Table 4.3-17.

The construction of new facilities in the study area

will also generate additional employment in the form

of short-term construction jobs. Implementation of

this alternative is expected to result in between $43.7

and $72.9 million in new cc.struction within the

study area. Assuming that 45% of this cost is for

wages, between $19.7 million and $32.8 million in

construction wages will be paid out. Using the aver-

age construction wage of $38,388 for the region, 512

to 854 person-years of construction employment will

be created.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative is expected to

generate between $47.8 and $72.9 million in new con-

struction activity. The projected construction costs are

detailed in Table 4.3-18.

525

TABLE 4.3-18

Estimated Construction Costs -

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

Construction Costs

Low Estimate High

$3,200,000 ($12,000,000

$450,000 $750,000

$1,855,500 $2,941,800

$20,920,000 26,038,000

$6,857,220 ($11,184,900

$1,591,000 $2,299,000

$6,357,000 13,569,000

$618,500 $980,600

$317,850 $678,450

$1,546,250 $2,451,500

$43,713,320 72,893,250

Source: Marshall Valuation Service and RKG Associates,

Inc.

Assuming that these facilities are assessed at an av-

erage of 70% of their construction cost, the New Lon-

don tax base would expand by between $30.6 million

and $51.0 million. However, the demolition of existing

structures in this area must also be accounted for.

Approximately $6 million in existing tax base will be

demolished to implement this plan, making the net

increase in the tax base between $24.6 million and

$45.0 million. This translates into a net increase in

property tax revenues of between $670,000 and $1.2

million.

4.3.7 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

Alternative 6 focuses on mixed use development of

the study area. The development program is summa-

rized in the Table 4.3-19.

526

TABLE 4.3-19

Development Program -

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2

Proposed Development

16 Acres

olumbia Cove Area 80-100 Slips

ater-Related Commercial 25,000-30,000 SF

otel/Conference Center 250 Rooms

idential Mid-Range 115 Units

25,000 SF

ce (Existing) 50,500 SF

ce/Incubator 100,000 SF

i 10,000 SF

5,000 SF

aterfront Commercial 20,000-25,000 SF

Job Creation

Based on the identified development program, the job

creation associated with this alternative has been

estimated. Direct job creation is projected to be be-

tween 591 and 1,124. Due to the density of employ-

ment, office uses contribute the largest number of

jobs, accounting for 389 jobs under the low estimate

and 678 under the high estimate. Table 4.3-20 pro-

vides the estimated job creation by land use category.

527

TABLE 4.3-20

Estimated Range of Direct Employment -

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2

|

tate Park

umbia Cove Area

Water Related Commercial

Hotel/Conference Center

Athletic Club

~—

Ses88e88..

Direct

Land Use Category Low Estimate

4

1

46

85

13

126

250

15

13

38

construction wages will be paid out. Using the aver-

age construction wage of $38,388 for the region, 574

to 931 person-years of construction employment will

be created.

Total 591 1,124

Source: Urban Land Institute and RKG Associates, Inc.

As an offset to the jobs created under this alternative.

it is necessary to subtract the existing jobs in the

study area. It is estimated that 148 to 222 people cur-

rently work within the study area. Eliminating these

jobs brings the net gain from this alternative to be-

tween 443 and 902 jobs.

Additional] indirect jobs will also be created in the re-

gional economy, based on the recirculation of wages

and purchases through the economy. It is estimated

that between 394 and 734 indirect jobs will be cre-

ated, as detailed in Table 4.3-21.

TABLE 4.3-21

Estimated Range of Indirect -

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2

| Indirect :

Low Estimate Estimate

2 3

1 3

23 60

46 67

7 27

94 188

186 297

8 20

9 19

19 50

394 734

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and RKG Associ-

ates, Inc.

Tax Revenue Created/Lost

The implementation of this alternative is expected to

generate between $48.9 and $79.4 million in new con-

detailed in Table 4.3-22.

529

TABLE 4.3-22

Estimated Construction Costs -

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2

Construction Costs

Land Use Category Low Estimate

tate Park $3,200,000 | $12,000,000

umbia Cove Area $450,000 $750,000

ater-Related Commercial | $1,855,500 $2,941,800

otel/Conference Center | $26,150,000 | $32,547,500

idential Mid-Range $6,857,220 | $11,184,900

thletic Club $1,591,000 $2,299,000

Office/Incubator $6,357,000 | $13,569,000

$618,500 $980,600

D/Office $317,850 $678,450

aterfront Commercial $1,546,250 $2,451,500

Total $48,943,320 | $79,402,750

Source: Marshall Valuation Service and RKG Associates,

Inc.

Assuming that these facilities are assessed at an av-

erage of 70% of their construction cost, the New Lon-

don tax base would expand by between $34.2 million

and $55.6 million. However, the demolition of existing

structures in this area must also be accounted for.

Approximately $6 million in existing tax base will be

demolished to implement this plan, making the net

increase in the tax base between $28.2 million and

$49.6 million. This translates into a net increase in

property tax revenues of between $770,000 and $1.4

million.

4.3.8 Summary

The six land use alternatives for the study area have

impacts that are widely varied. Table 4.3-23 provides

an indication of the range of direct employment asso-

ciated with each of the six land use alternatives

530

proposed for the study area. Implementation of any of

the six alternatives (including the no action alterna-

tive) would result in a net increase in jobs and prop-

erty tax revenues.

Alternative 4 (Business Campus) is the highest gen-

erator of jobs, followed by Alternatives 1, 6, 5, 2, and

3. It is interesting to note that Alternative 1 (No Ac-

tion) generates the second highest number of jobs

(1,779), behind only the Business Campus Alternative

(#4). This is because the No Action Alternative antici-

pates the reuse of approximately 380,000 square feet

of existing facilities at the Naval Undersea Warfare

Center (NUWC). The reuse of this space accounts for

more than 1,500 of the 1,779 jobs to be created under

this alternative.

In addition to these direct jobs, the six alternatives

are also expected to result in the creation of addi-

are expected to be created as direct employees on the

site spend their wages in the regional economy for

food, clothing, etc. Table 4.3-24 provides an estimate

of the projected number of indirect jobs expected to be

created in the study area for each of the six land use

alternatives.

The land use alternatives for the study area also have

varied projected construction impacts. Total construc-

tion costs range from as low as $3.2 million to as high

as $113.0 million. Estimates of construction wages

range from as low as $1.4 million to as high as $51

million. Between 37 and 1,304 person-years of con-

struction are expected to be created through these

projects, as shown in Table 4.3-25.

New tax revenues are projected to range from a mod-

est $57,000 to as much as $2.0 million as presented in

Table 4.3-26.

TABLE 4.3-23

Range of Employment Estimates by Land Use Alternative

(Direct Employment - Low Estimate)

Land Alt. 1 Alt. 2 Alt. 3 Alt. 4 Alt. 5 Alt 6

Use No Recreation/ | Residential/| Business | Mixed | Mixed

Category Action Tourism |Commercial| Campus Use 1 Use 2

State Park 4 8 4 4 4 4

Columbia Cove Area - 1 1 1 1 1

Water-Related Commercial 46 46 46 46 46

Hotel - 27 - - 0 -

Recreation Center - 13 - - 0 -

Outdoor Recreation Area - - 1 - 0 -

Museum(s) - 4 - - 0 -

Hotel/Conference Center - - - 68 68 85

Residential High-End - - - - - -

Athletic Club - - - - 13 13

Office (Existing) 126 126 126 126 126 126

Office/Incubator 950 200 75 1,013 250 250

Retail - 31 31 23 15 15

R&D/Office - 13 13 13 13 13

Waterfront Commercial - 38 38 38 38 38

Total 1,080 506 335 1,332 574 591

(Direct Employment - High Estimate)

Land Alt. 1 Alt. 2 Alt. 3 Alt. 4 Alt. 5 Alt 6

Use No Recreation/ | Residential/| Business | Mixed | Mixed

Category Action Tourism |Commercial| Campus Use 1 Use 2

State Park 6 12 6 6 6 6

Columbia Cove Area - 5 5 5 5 5

Water-Related Commercial - 120 120 120 120 120

Hotel : | : ; . ;

Recreation Center - 50 - - - -

Outdoor Recreation Area - - 1 - - -

Museum(s) - 14 - - - -

Hotel/Conference Center - - - 100 100 125

Residential Mid-Range - - - - - -

Residential High-End - - - - - -

Athletic Club - - - - 50 50

Office (Existing) 253 253 .. 253 253 253 253

Office/Incubator 1,520 320 120 1,620 400 400

Retail - 80 80 60 40 40

R&D/Office - 25 25 25 25 25

Waterfront Commercial - 100 100 100 100 100

Total 1,779 1,019 710 2,289 1,099 1,124

Tes

TABLE 4.3-24

Range of Indirect Job Creation by Land Use Alternative

Alternative 1} Alternative | Alternative 3 | Alternative 4 | Alternative 5 | Alternative 6

No Action | Recreation/ | Residential/ Business Mixed Mixed

Tourism 2 Commercial Campus Use 1 Use 2

Low Estimate 802 337 220 949 385 394

High Estimate 1,321 659 452 1,610 720 734

Source: U.S. Department of Commerce and RKG Associates, Inc.

TABLE 4.3-25

Summary of Construction Impacts by Land Use Alternative

Alt. 1 Alt. 2 Alt. 3 Alt. 4 Alt. 5 Alt. 6

No Recreation/ | Residential | Business Mixed Mixed

Action Tourism 2 |Commercial| Campus—} Usel Use 2

Construction Costs — Low $3,200,000} 28,321,500) 40,131,680! 56,752,040 | 43,713,320) 48,943,320

Construction Costs — High $12,000,000} 58,098,330! 64,249,500} 104,202,900 | 72,893,250; 79,402,750

Construction Wages — Low $1,440,000} 12,704,175! 18,059,256! 25,538,428 | 19,670,994| 22,024,494

Construction Wages — High $5,400,000} 26,144,249) 28,912,275| 46,891,305 | 32,801,963} 35,731,238

Construction

Employment — Low 38 331 470 665 512 574

Construction

Employment — High 141 681 753 1,222 854 931

Source: Marshal! Valuation Service and RKG Associates, Inc.

TABLE 4.3-26

Summary of Tax Revenues Generated by Land Use Alternative

Alt. 1 Alt. 2 Alt. 3 Alt. 4 Alt. 5 Alt. 6

No Recreation/ Residential | Business Mixed Mixed

Action Tourism 2 |Commercial| Campus Use 1 Use 2

Tax Revenues — Low $61,152 375,704 603,116 931,651 671,562 771,507

Tax Revenues — High $229,320 946,459 1,064,008 1,838,437 | 1,229,190 | 1,353,587

Source: Marshall Valuation Service and RKG Associates, Inc.

ZES

533

4.4 Neighborhood/Housing Impacts

The overall character of the Fort Trumbull area will

be enhanced by the disposition of a portion of the

NUWC property (+16 acres) to the Department of En-

vironmental Protection for the creation of a state-

owned and operated park. This park will have a posi-

tive impact on the neighborhood, both physically and

economically. An aesthetically pleasing park would

beautify the area, significantly increase useable open

space, provide public access to the waterfront, and, as

a consequence of this $20 million public investment,

increase surrounding land values to the benefit of the

residents. These benefits will accrue to each of the al-

ternatives to be discussed herein.

4.4.1 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

The development of the NUWC property alone would

not directly impact the area’s housing stock since the

No Action plan calls for only the creation of areas for

open space, maritime conveyance, and public sale.

There would be no project generated changes in the

residential or commercial properties in the Fort

Trumbull MDP area. However, private investment in

the existing building stock would likely be stimulated

by development of the State Park and, depending on

the future use of the NUWC area to be sold, further

investment in residential and commercial properties

is possible.

4.4.2 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Both the Fort and Gateway Areas would be signifi-

cantly impacted by a reuse option geared toward rec-

reation and tourism. The state park at Fort Trumbull

will serve to improve the appearance and waterfront

accessibility of the area. The NUWC site has served

534

various military purposes since the American Revolu-

tion and has not been generally open to the public.

Amenities such as a recreation center, museum, and

the riverwalk would provide activities for New Lon-

don residents to enjoy as well as tourist coming to this

new destination. New opportunities for employment

would be created through neighborhood and water-

related retail activities, development of a hotel, and

R&D, incubator, and office spaces. Neighborhood re-

tail is proposed to service employees and visitors to

the area, as well as adjoining residential areas.

In this alternative, the Gateway Area would become

an extension of the adjoining Shaw’s Cove Redevel-

opment Area that was redeveloped during the 1980's.

The addition of office, incubator, and retail uses along

Howard Street would complete a transition in use and

function of this corridor, which began approximately

20 years ago. All alternatives that propose redevel-

opment of the Howard Streét corridor would serve to

implement City policy to renew this area.

The current neighborhood and its housing stock

would cease to exist in its present configuration under

this scenario. All of the 115 dwelling units in the area

would be removed, of which 92 are currently occupied.

(Fort Area: 81 dwelling units, 69 households. Gateway

Area: 34 dwelling units, 23 households.) This would

require the relocation of all the families in the area.

In addition, 28 businesses may be displaced. All

households and businesses displaced would receive

assistance under the Connecticut Uniform Relocation

Assistance Act and the Relocation Plan adopted as

part of the MDP. Table 4.4-1 presents an estimate of

displacement under this scenario.

535

4.4.3 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

This alternative proposal seeks to create a balance

between the current character of the neighborhood

with new opportunities for the future. The area would

maintain a significant amount of land in residential

uses (+25.8 acres) while adding the state park (+16

acres) along with new retail and commercial uses.

The retail uses would be geared toward employees,

the tourist coming to the area, as well as the

neighborhood residents. The office component along

Howard Street would serve to link the area with the

existing commercial and industrial uses found in the

Gateway Area. In addition to the public amenities

such as the state park and riverwalk, an area of open

space (+3.5 acres) would be preserved in the center of

the Fort Area.

The housing stock would be beneficially changed by

this land use alternative. Forty-five dwelling units in

the Fort Trumbull area would be removed, of which

40 are occupied. The plan does allow 36 existing

dwelling units, of which 29 are currently occupied, to

remain. Also, 29 households in 34 dwelling units

would be displaced from the Gateway Area.

In total, 79 of the 115 dwelling units would be dis-

placed under this scenario. This would result in the

relocation of 63 households. In addition, 28 business

may be displaced. All households and businesses dis-

would receive assistance under the Connecti-

cut Uniform Relocation Assistance Act and the

Relocation Plan adopted as part of this MDP. Table

4.4-2 presents an estimate of displacement under this

scenario.

# of

— Total#of | Dwelling Households | Businesses

Land Area | Dwelling | Units to be Total # of to be

Land Use Type Property Use Uni Demolished | Households | Displaced Displaced

State Park, Navy & -

Coast Guard Facilities Fort Trumbull 36 36 29 29 1

Columbia Cove Marina Fishing Docks 0 0 0 0 0

Hotel 0 0 0 0 0

Recreation Center 0 0 0 c 1

Museum Res/Comm 39 39 35 35 8

Office (Existing) 0 0 0 0 3

Office/Incubator Res/Comm 17 17 8 8 7

R&D/Office Vacant/Industrial 1 1 0 0 3

Retail Res/Comm 17 17 15 15 2

Water Related Commercial | Res/Comm 5 5 5 5 2

Waterfront Commercial RR/Comm 0 0 0 0 1

WWTP 0 0 0 0 0

115 115 92 92 28

537

TABLE 4.4-2

Estimate of Displacement -

Alternative 3 - Residential/Commercial

# of

Total#of | Dwelling

Land Area | Dwelling | Units to be

(Ac.) Units Demolished

16.0 0 0

0.0 0 0

3.5 12 12

16.5 63 27

6.4 0 0

2.2 4 4

2.1 0 0

1.3 1 1

3.0 17 17

2.5 5 5

4.3 0 0

10.5 0 0

2.9 13 13

71.2 115 79

Total # of

|

BacoaRowoofgco

(

a

5

fs

Bwckwnwawoukro

538

With this alternative, there would be new residential

uses created in the Gateway Area. Twenty dwelling

units would be built, resulting in a net loss of 14

dwelling units. Furthermore, there would be 115 mid-

density dwelling units in the area (36 preserved plus

79 newly constructed) and 160 high-density dwelling

units at the completion of the project. This would re-

sult in 275 units in the area compared to the 81 that

currently exist.

4.4.4 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

This alternative commits most of the developable area

to office, incubator, and campus use. A hotel/

conference center on 7.5 acres supports the office

function. The Gateway Area along Howard Street

would accommodate office/incubator use on the east-

ern side, much of which is an existing building, and

residential and neighborhood retail use on the west-

ern side. This alternative brings residential use to

Howard Street, which currently is predominately non-

The current neighborhood and all of its housing stock

except eight dwelling units would cease to exist in its

current configuration under this scenario. Of the 115

dwelling units in the area, 107 would be removed, of

which 86 are currer.tly occupied. (Fort Area: 81 dwell-

ing units removed, 69 households. Gateway Area: 26

dwelling units removed, 16 households.) This would

require the relocation of 85 households from the area.

There would be 22 new dwelling units created under

this alternative for a net loss of 85 dwelling units. In

539

part of this MDP. Table 4.4-3 presents an estimate of

displacement under this scenario.

4.4.5 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

The addition of a hotel/conference center, an athletic

club/field, the Fort Trumbull State Park, and water-

related commercial activities in this alternative seeks

to expand and improve the current residential/

commercial character of the neighborhood, creating a

truly mixed land use environment. This is accom-

plished by expanding the office/incubator uses in the

Gateway Area, changing the location of some of the

residential uses, while keeping their number con-

stant, and providing residents with opportunities for

recreation. As with the other alternatives, the crea-

tion of the state park and riverwalk would serve to

balance the built environment with open space and

natural settings.

540

Land Use Type

State Park, Navy &

Coast Guard Facilities

Columbia Cove Marina

Hotel/Conference Center

Residential

Office (Existing)

Office/Incubator

R&D/Office

Retail

Water Related Commercial

Waterfront Commercial

WWTP

Residential (Existing)

Current

Property Use

Fort Trumbull

Fishing Docks

Fort Trumbull//RR

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

Vacant/Industrial

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

RR/Comm

WWTP

Residential

TABLE 4.4-3

Estimate of Displacement -

Alternative 4 - Business Campus

# of

Total # of Dwelling

Land Area | Dwelling | Units to be

(Ac.) Units Demolished

16.0 0 0

0.0 0 0

7.5 0 0

3.1 14 14

2.2 0 0

22.1 79 79

1.3 1 1

1.8 8 8

2.5 5 5

2.1 0 0

10.5 0 0

0.8 8 0

69.9 115 107

Total # of

Households

SaraccanwncoBohtococne

# of

Households

to be

Displaced

RocoounoBortoco

# of

Businesses

to be

Displaced

BrornrwRwworo

541

The housing stock in the area would undergo no net

change in number of dwelling units in this reuse op-

tion. The plan calls for 115 dwelling units, which is

the same as the current number. Of these 115 dwell-

ing units, 36 would be in existing structures, while

the remaining 79 would be from new construction.

This would mean the relocation of 63 households.

(Fort Area: 45 dwelling units removed, 40 households.

Gateway Area: 34 dwelling units removed, 23 house-

holds.) Additionally, there are 28 businesses in the

area that may require relocation. All households and

businesses displaced would receive assistance under

the Connecticut Uniform Relocation Assistance Act

and the Relocation Plan adopted as part of this MDP.

Table 4.4-4 presents an estimate of displacement un-

der this scenario.

4.4.6 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

The current neighborhood and its housing stock

would cease to exist in its present configuration under

this scenario. All of the 115 dwelling units in the area

would be removed, of which 92 are currently occupied.

(Fort Area: 81 dwelling units, 69 households. Gateway

Area: 34 dwelling units, 23 households.) This would

require the relocation of all the families in the area.

In addition, 28 businesses may be displaced. All

households and businesses displaced would receive

assistance under the Connecticut Uniform Relocation

Assistance Act and the Relocation Plan adopted as

part of this MDP. The level of displacement under this

alternative would the same as Alternative 2 as pre-

sented in Table 4.4-1.

542

TABLE 4.4-4

Estimate of Displacement -

Alternative 5 - Mixed Use 1

Land Use Type

State Park, Navy &

Coast Guard Facilities

Columbia Cove Marina

Hotel/Conference Center

Athletic Club/Field

Residential Mid-Range

Office (Existing)

Office/Incubator

R&D/Office

Water Related Commercial

Waterfront Commercial

WWTP

Current

Property Use

Fort Trumbull

Fishing Dock

Fort Trumbull/RR

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

Res/Comm

Vacant/Industrial

RR/Comm

WWTP

Residential

Land Area

(Ac.)

16.0

0.0

7.5

3.5

16.5

2.2

8.0

1.3

2.5

2.1

10.5

70.1

# of

Total # of Dwelling

Dwelling Units to be

Units Demolished

0 0

0 0

0 0

12 12

63 27

0 0

34 34

1 1

5 5

0 0

0 0

115 79

# of # of

Households to Businesses to

Total # of be be

Households Displaced Displaced

SooncokoSpoce

to oe

BooncohoBpoco

BornwowaerH oo

543

4.5 Community Facilities and Services Impacts

4.5.1 Common Elements

Fire Protection — Al) of the land use alternatives are

expected to have similar positive impacts on local fire

and police services. The demolition of old, fire prone

buildings is expected to reduce the potential for oc-

currence of an uncontrolled fire and enhance fire pro-

tection capabilities in the area. Construction of new

buildings would be completed in accordance with cur-

rent fire code and would employ sprinkler systems to

provide additional fire protection capabilities. The

improvement of public water service in the area will

also allow for the installation of additional fire hy-

drants. Additionally, redevelopment activities can be

designed to provide emergency vehicle access to the

buildings, thus improving accessibility over existing

conditions. Proposed roadway improvements would

provide better emergency access to the area in the

event of a fire. (Personal communication, 10/6/98,

Chief Samuels). As part of the NUWC closure, the

City of New London acquired a Navy fire truck, thus

increasing its equipment inventory.

Police Protection — Current land uses in the MDP

area limits the volume of people, minimizing the need

for police patrol. This is particularly evident at the

NUWC property which is currently secured by Navy

staff. All of the alternatives would result in increased

use of the Fort Trumbull area, including NUWC, thus

requiring more frequent police patrol of the area.

Proposed alternatives which minimize open public ac-

cess are viewed as most favorable for police protec-

tion. (Personal communication, 10/6/98, Deputy Chief

Gavitt).

Health Care — Health care facilities are not antici-

pated to be measurably affected by the implementa-

tion of any of the alternatives.

544

Recreation — The disposition of a portion of the

NUWC property (+16 acres) to the Department of En-

vironmental Protection would result in a positive im-

pact to parks and recreation. The state-owned and

operated park would complement the local park net-

work and provide additional] waterfront access to the

New London residents and to visitors from outside

the New London area This new amenity would be af-

forded without any additional maintenance or staffing

burden on the city, as these responsibilities would rest

on the Department of Environmental! Protection.

4.5.2 Alternative No. 1 —- No Action

Since development at the NUWC property associated

with this alternative does not include a residential

component, no impact on education or the need for

additional educational facilities is anticipated. A posi-

tive impact on education is anticipated as a result of

the Fort Trumbull State Park due to the educational

aspect of the historic fort and associated park.

Emergency services (i.e., police, fire, ambulance, etc.)

are not expected to be negatively impacted by this al-

ternative. A far less intense land use would result in

comparison to the fully operational NUWC facility at

this site.

As indicated, the positive impacts of locating a state

park in this area would be experienced under this al-

ternative.

4.5.3 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

A component of the Recreation/Tourism alternative

includes cultural and museum recreation, with the

potential for a 50,000 to 70,000 square foot museum

facility. This. in binati th tl aeaattunall

545

aspect of the proposed Fort Trumbull State Park,

would have a positive impact on education in the

community. No need for additional educational facili-

ties or impact on New London's school system is an-

ticipated in association with this alternative.

A positive benefit from the proposed Fort Trumbull

State Park would be similar to that described in Al-

ternative 1, except that the park would be expanded

from 16 acres to approximately 30 acres. The con-

additional number of dwelling units under this alter-

native would be on the order of 169.

Table 4.5-1 illustrates the demographics of New Lon-

don’s school aged population under exsting and pro-

from

Existing to

Proposed

Conditions

+450

umber of 10,712 126 295 +169

~~"

—s 2.66 2.66 2.66 0

ity?

tion 6.5% 22 51 +29

% or number)

5 through

0 Years’

tion 2.9% 10 23 +13

% or number)

ll

3 Years’

tion 3.5% 12 27 +15

% or number)

14

7 Years

yy) eee

sumed to be age 10 and one-half assumed to be age 11.

Note: Information current as of August 1998

It is assumed that elementary school aged children

are ages five through 10 years; middle school aged

547

children are ages 11 through 13; and high school aged

students are ages 14 through 17. As a result of the

proposed conditions, there is the potential for an addi-

tional 57 children in the New London public school

system (29 in elementary school, 13 in middle school,

and 15 in high school). These estimates are somewhat

conservative in that a fraction of school aged students

attend non-public schools or require additional assis-

tance through a special education program offered at

the Little Red Schoolhouse. Additionally, it is possible

that some of the residential population would be relo-

cating from within the city and would, therefore, sim-

ply be a redistribution of school aged children.

At the present time, most of the New London schools

operate at enrollment levels below the rated capacity

of the buildings. The majority of the MDP area lies

within the Harbor School elementary education dis-

trict. This facility currently (1998/99 school year) has

an excess capacity of about 100 students. The Bennie

Dover Jackson middle school has additional capacity

for approximately 50 students, and New London High

School has capacity for an additional 75 students.

Based on the current enrollment and maximum ca-

548

4.5.5 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

This alternative allocates approximately 4.1 acres of

residential use west of the railroad in the Gateway

Area. This would result in approximate!y 30 dwelling

units in the area. Existing residential use in the proj-

ect area occupies approximately 45.2 acres, with a

resultant 126 dwelling units (as of August 1998).

Therefore, there would be an overall decrease in resi-

dential use, with an associated decrease in school

aged children in the MDP area. Therefore, no nega-

tive impacts are anticipated with respect to educa-

tional facility needs under this alternative.

The positive benefits from the proposed Fort Trum-

bull State Park and riverwalk would be the same as

described in previous alternatives. Additional recrea-

tional amenities are also offered in this alternative,

including a possible marina use and a 200-room hotel/

conference center with views of the waterfront. These

features are expected to result in a positive impact to

parks and recreation since they would replace non-

recreational land uses.

4.5.6 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

This alternative allocates approximately 16.5 acres of

residential use east of the railroad in the Fort Area

and NUWC property with a resultant 115 dwelling

units. Existing residential use in the project area oc-

cupies approximately 45.2 acres, with a resultant 126

dwelling units (August 1998). Therefore, there would

be an overall decrease in residential use, with an as-

sociated decrease in school aged children in the MDP

area. Therefore, no negative impacts are anticipated

with respect to educational facility needs under this

alternative.

at

549

The positive benefits from the proposed Fort Trum-

bull State Park and riverwalk would be the same as

described in previous alternatives. Additional recrea-

tional amenities are also offered in this alternative,

including a 25,000 athletic club/field, possible marina

use, and a 200-room hotel/conference center with

views of the waterfront. These features are expected

to result in a positive impact to parks and recreation

since they would replace non-recreational land uses.

4.5.7 Alternative No. & - Mixed Use 2

The impacts of Alternative 6 are identical to that of

Alternative 5, except that additional open/recreational

space and opportunities are provided in Alternative 6.

Aesthetic/Visual Resource Impacts

The proposed municipal development of the Fort

Trumbull area will alter the appearance of the

neighborhood when viewed from both interior and ex-

terior locations. The primary viewsheds that look out

Shaw's Cove, observers viewing the site from or

across the Thames River (including small craft and

ferry boats), the view from Pequot Avenue and the ad-

jacent Pfizer site, and limited views from the Gate-

way Area. The railroad embankment limits external

views of the Fort Area from the west.

The aesthetic quality of a landscape is somewhat sub-

jective, depending upon the judgment and experiences

of the viewer. Typical elements include mass, texture,

color, height and width proportions, and the presence

of natural versus common or unusual cultural fea-

tures.

550

4.6.1 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

The visual appearance of the site would have moder-

ate change, even if no action were to be taken under

the MDP process. The private sale of NUWC build-

ings could lead to alteration of that site, and the state

park would still proceed to clear older wood frame

structures from the southern half of the NUWC prop-

erty. This would improve the view from the Fort Area.

There would be no significant changes anticipated in

the Gateway and Fort Areas.

4.6.2 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism —

The redevelopment of the Gateway and Lower Pequot

Avenue Area would noticeably alter the appearance of

these areas, with removal of existing buildings and

construction of new ones. The exact composition of

size, shape, and color has not been established at this

time.

The Fort Area west of Smith Street would have a to-

tally new look, intended to complement a new cul-

tural center/museum and recreational center theme.

This would likely involve new low-rise buildings with

pedestrian walks, terraces, and parking lots. Many

would consider this an improvement over existing

conditions.

The proposed Columbia Cove area and adjacent hotel

site would be designed to complement the waterfront

and be visible across the river and Shaw’s Cove. A

well balanced waterfront design with public access

would be attractive.

The focal point of Alternative 2 is an enlarged Fort

Trumbull State Park, including removal of additional

buildings in its northern area east of Smith Street.

This would open up views of this congested site from

551

the river, and introduce natural elements into the

viewshed.

4.6.3 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

New residential units would be constructed in the

underutilized area along Howard Street and would

need to complement the scale of the neighborhood.

They would serve as a transition to office uses east of

Howard Street. Generous front setbacks would be de-

sirable between these separate uses. Similar colors

and materials would also be desirable. However, it

would be difficult to blend such diverse uses into a

comfortable neighborhood. Medium and high density

residential units, raised on fill or piers in flood prone

areas, would be constructed in the Fort Area on both

sides of the present Smith Street. They are visible

from the river and Shaw’s Cove and would detract

from the waterfront vista. In contrast, the proposed

Columbia Cove area is more likely to be of visual in-

terest, as would be the state park.

The proposed open space between Goshen Street and

the railroad is of internal interest and could be land-

scaped to form an attractive gateway beyond the Wal-

bach Street bridge and buffer the residential area.

4.6.4 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

The proposed Gateway Area mix of residential retail!

and office would be similar to Alternative 3, with mi-

nor spatial orientation changes. The core of this al-

ternate is a large area of office and incubator business

space in a campus type of layout. This offers the op-

portunity for an integrated visual design that could

include courtyards, streetscape features, and mini

parks. While not a distant viewshed attraction, it

could complement the marina. Having a band of

552

green along the water and near the hotel would be a

plus.

4.6.5 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

The proposed office and office/incubator areas in the

Gateway Area has enough mass to create its own

neighborhood character and needs only a suitable

buffer or transition on the west side. The internal ap-

pearance and use would be self-defined.

The proposed hotel conference center and Columbia

Cove area, as per previous alternatives, can be attrac-

tive waterfront features. The large residential area on

both sides of Smith Street is a difficult backdrop to

the marina and state park, particularly since flood

management regulations would require higher eleva-

tions of these buildings. This could appear, from the

water, as a cluttered hillside of little boxes.

4.6.6 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

This alternate is similar to Alternative 5, but with a

reorientation of space in the Fort Area and in the

northern portion of the NUWC property. A 12-acre

passive recreation open space/athletic center would be

provided along the river and the floodplain, with the

Alternative 5 residential areas shifted west away

from the water. This helps to hide the residential area

into the hollow between Smith Street and the railroad

embankment, and opens up the greenway along the

river. It would complement the waterfront and hotel

sites.

4.7

553

Public Utilities and Services Impacts

4.7.1 Common Elements

Under the various land use alternatives, the MDP

area would be partitioned into several different reuse

parcels to be utilized by different tenants. There are

various infrastructure improvements that are com-

mon to all of the land use alternatives. The common

elements are summarized in the ensuing discussion.

Elements that are specific to each alternative are de-

scribed in subsequent sections.

Many of the utility systems that currently serve

NUWC base, including electric, water, steam and

sewage, are contiguous in nature. There will be a

need to ensure that all parcels/buildings have use of

all utilities during and following any site partitioning

and construction.

Water System

The existing water distribution system east of the

railroad right-of-way is currently in poor condition

and is inadequate to provide the necessary fire flows

for the proposed development uses. Fire flow tests

performed to date have verified this. Computer simu-

lations performed by the Navy have indicated that

the flow capacity in the water mains is well below the

normal capacity of the six-inch and eight-inch pipe

sizes indicated on the record plans. This condition is

probably due to advanced tuberculation of the pipe

walls and inoperable gate valves.

It is anticipated that under Alternatives 2 through 6

the layout of the water distribution system infrastruc-

ture will be modified to accommodate a new street

alignment and to meet needed fire flow demands for

the development.

554

It is anticipated that the state park will be on a sepa-

rate private water system which will be intercon-

nected with the City of New London water system at

several master meters at the perimeter of the park.

The U.S. Coast Guard and the Naval facilities will be

provided water from the New London system via

easements across the state park or in a relocated

street.

Water demands associated with all of the alternatives

are anticipated to be less than historic demands when

NUWC was fully operational. Water usage at the

NUWC facility was estimated in March of 1987 by the

Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Northern

Division in a study entitled “Utilities Systems As-

sessment.” At that time, all meters supplying water to

the NUWC facility were found to be inoperative, as

well as 23 of 26 individual building meters. Water

demand was estimated based on population of the

buildings multiplied by 30.75 gallons per capita per

day usage. The daily flow was estimated at 43,671

gallons.

Existing water demands off the NUWC site but

within the MDP area is estimated at 75,200 gpd. If

the estimated NUWC use of 43,671 gpd is added to

this, a rough estimate of the historic usage is 119,000.

Sanitary Sewer System

There is currently adequate capacity in the existing

sanitary sewer system to collect the existing and pro-

jected sewage flows (see specific program elements). It

is anticipated that all discharges to the sewers will be

domestic waste and that any industrial waste gener-

ated will be minimal in volume or be contained in a

closed loop system and treated internally. Depending

on the final configuration of the development, new

555

sanitary sewers may need to be constructed along any

relocated road or driveway alignments.

Storm Drainage System

Any significant introduction of constituents such as

nutrients, toxics, heavy metals or pathogens, or sig-

nificant alterations of the physical and chemical

characteristics thereby degrading water quality would

be considered an adverse impact to the estuarine wa-

ters of the Thames River. Hence, the use of advanced

stormwater management associated development in

the Fort Trumbull area will be necessary to protect

coastal water quality and marine life.

If sufficient controls are not utilized, development and

construction have the potential to alter stormwater

quantities and quality. These alterations can be due

to changes in vegetation, impervious cover (roads,

parking lots, buildings), reduced infiltration, diver-

sions, and modified channels or storm drains. Poten-

tial impacts include:

¢ higher peak flow rates;

¢ larger runoff volumes;

* inc: eased flow velocities;

¢ soil erosion;

¢ water quality degradation; and

¢ sediment deposition.

The three fundamental storm drainage needs for this

project are to (1) prevent nuisance flood problems in

developed areas; (2) minimize downstream impacts;

and (3) treat stormwater prior to discharge. Specific

concepts are to control pollutants at their sources,

plan for both frequent and rare storm events, avoid

unnecessary impervious cover, and use multiple

556

treatment practices to reduce pollution loadings and

concentrations.

It is anticipated that some existing storm drains may

be cleaned and reused, while new drainage facilities

will be required where new roads are constructed or

older roads are rebuilt. Of special interest is providing

adequate drainage of the low elevation points at rail-

road underpasses that tend to pond runoff during

storm events which are coincident with high tides. All

new storm drain discharge points will avoid existing

or potential wetlands and have appropriate water

quality controls.

Under all land use alternatives, the existing storm

drainage system will need to be modified to accom-

modate any new roadway alignments and to correct

deficiencies in the existing system. All of the storm

drainage systems will incorporate stormwater quality

renovation elements such as inlet chambers (Vortech-

nics, Stormsceptors, or similar equipment) and/or in-

filtration systems.

DEP general stormwater permits for construction ac-

tivities in tidal areas specify post construction man-

agement requirements, including retention (i.e.

infiltration) of the first inch of runoff from the site. If

retention not possible, detention may be required.

The general permit also requires 80% total suspended

solids removal and velocity dissipation. These ele-

ments will be factored into the Municipal Develop-

ment Planning process and project design.

Each of the alternatives will change the amount of

impervious coverage due to the changes in land use.

Table 4.7-1 presents the change in coverage for the six

alternatives. The estimates are given in ranges since

it is not possible to determine the exact amount until

a more detailed design is developed.

TABLE 4.7-

Estimated Changes in Impervious Coverage

Alternative Existing Proposed Change in

Impervious Impervious Impervious

Coverage Coverage _ :

1 — No Action 45% 40%-45% 0%-5% Reduction

2 — Recreation/

Tourism 45% 35%-40% 5%-10%

3 — Residential’

Commercial 45% 40%-45% 0%-5% Reduction

— Business

Campus 45% 50%-60% 5%-15% Increase

5 — Mixed Use 1 45% 45%-55% 0%-10% Increase

6 — Mixed Use 2 45% 45%-55% 0%-10% Increase

Note: Numbers are approximate.

The changes range from a reduction of 5 to 10% under

the Recreation/Tourism alternative to an increase of 5

to 15% under the Business Campus Alternative. The

changes in the alternatives are largely due to the

parking demand of each alternative. Conventional

engineering design will be utilized to design the pipes

for the storm sewer systems in each of the alterna-

tives. The pipe sizes will be proportionally larger un-

der the more intensive land uses.

Gas

Yankee Gas has adequate capacity to service the fu-

ture development. Gas mains currently exist on most

of the municipal streets in the vicinity of the project

area. Some upgrading of the mains in the roadway

may be required depending on the final configuration

of development. Additional distribution facilities will

need to be constructed on the land of the NUWC base,

since a central steam plant previously heated it.

Energy Use and Conservation

There is no known data readily available on historic

energy use in the MDP area and guidelines have not

been prepared for future energy use. In general, it is

anticipated that new buildings will be more energy ef-

ficient than the older existing buildings, and will need

to conform to or exceed current standards.

High electrical-demand uses are not proposed under

any of the identified land use alternatives. However,

it is anticipated that individual users will take advan-

nents, lighting, and HVAC.

Telephone and Cable

The loca] telephone and cable utilities are required to

extend capacity to serve developments if they are lo-

cated on a public street. If it is desired to have facili-

ties located underground in the roadway, the owner/

developer is required to contribute to the cost. Exten-

sion of telephone service to private property would

have to be completed by the owner/developer.

4.7.2 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Under the No Action alternative, there will be a net

reduction in utility demand from the historical usage

due to a reduction in the intensity of development.

Water Supply

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the

City of New London. Estimated water usage under

this alternative is 108,850 gallons per day (gpd). This is

less than the estimated historic usage in the Fort Trum-

bull area. Flow meters that are currently installed to

monitor water usage are inoperable and would have to be

repaired or replaced in order to monitor the amount of

water consumed by future tenants and uses. The State of

Connecticut and other future occupants will need to up-

grade the water distribution system to accommodate the

needed fire flows. Table 4.7-2 presents estimates of do-

mestic water demand for this alternative.

TABLE 4.7-2

Alternative 1 - No Action

Note: Number of residential units and square footage es

of August 1998.

Sanitary Sewage

Sewage discharge under this alternative would be be-

low the historical rates at the NUWC facility and sur-

rounding area. The existing sewer serving NUWC

and would continue to serve the site and domestic

sewage would continue to be treated at the regional

WPCF. Meters would have to be installed at different

discharge points of each parcel/building in order to

monitor usage for billing purposes.

4.7.3 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Water Supply

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the

City of New London. Per capita water usage is esti-

mated to be 20 gallons per day per employee and five

gallons per visitor. Estimated water usage is between

41,890 and 43,990 gallons per day. This is less than

installed to monitor water usage are inoperable and

would have to be repaired and/or replaced in order to

monitor the amount of water consumed by future ten-

ants and uses. Table 4.7-3 presents estimates of do-

mestic water demand for this alternative.

TABLE 4.7-3

Estimated Domestic Water Usage -

Alternative 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Estimated Estimated Estimated

Employees Domestic Domestic

Water Usage Water Usage

(gallons per (gallons per

day/per unit) day)

Park 100 20 (20 gpd*100

5 gpd/visitor ) +900

# visitors * 5 gpd)

= 6,500 gpd

Assume 2000 | 20 gpd/slip 1,600- 2,000

SF office 2000

SF + 250 SF/

ial | employee = 8

Hotel Assume 5,000 (20 gpd*20

SF office 5,000 | 75 gpd/room employee)

SF + 250 SF/ + 80 rooms *75

employee = 20 gpd) =

6,400 gpd

250 parking 15 gal/visit 7,500 gpd

spaces x 2

Museum =10 estimated 20 gpd/emrplcyes (20 gpd * 10

5 epd/visit

562

Retai 20,000 + 650 SF/ 0.10 gpd/sfof | 2,000 gpd

employee=30 _gross area

Waverfront | 250 20 gpd/employee| 3,200-4,000 gpd

250 SF/ gpd/employee 2,000-2,400 gpd

=160-200

20 estimated 20 400 gpd

TOTAL | 41,890-43,990

= | | gpd

Note: Number of residential units and square footage as

of August 1998.

Sanitary Sewage

Sewage flow from the existing NUWC complex is not

metered. Typically, sewage flow is equal to about 80%

of the potable water used at most facilities.

The existing sanitary sewer serving NUWC would

continue to serve the site and the sewage would con-

tinue to be treated at the regional WPCF. The daily

sewage flow is estimated between 33,500 and 35,200

gallons. Therefore, no upgrading or rerouting of cur-

rent sewer lines would be necessary. However, for fu-

which would be required. Additions and relocations to

the existing drainage system would be implemented

to accommodate any new drainage changes that may

result from the activity.

Stormwater associated with new development would

be subject to the DEP permitting programs. Stormwa-

ter pollution prevention plans would need to be pre-

pared prior to formal approval for permit coverage.

The permit would need to include applicable compo-

nents of the sediment and erosion and control site

plan standards, site permits, and stormwater man-

agement site plans.

Steam

High-pressure steam is currently generated in the

steam plant (Building 99) and distributed through-

out the site via a contiguous system. It is antici-

pated that Building 99 would no longer be used for

steam generation.

Electrical

Electrical service would continue to be provided by

Connecticut Light and Power (CL&P). The maximum

historical electrical demand at NUWC was 4243 kV or

4714 KVA. During this time period the incoming

feeder was loaded to 88% of its rated capacity. Addi-

tionally, there is only one electrical feed that is me-

tered for one owner. Assuming multiple users of

electricity under this alternative, sub-metering of the

current electrical system or the installation of addi-

tional electrical feeds would be required. Given the

potential for different and varied electrical needs of

future tenants, specific future amounts of electrical

consumption cannot be predicted at this time. How-

ever, given comparable levels of usage between the

564

alternative build-out and the historical demand at

NUWC, differences in electrical demand would not be

significant.

4.7.4 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

Water Supply

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the

City of New London. Per capita water usage is esti-

mated to be 75 gallons per day per resident. Esti-

mated water usage under this alternative is between

105,230 and 106,830 gpd. This is less than historic

usage in the Fort Trumbull area, and only slightly

greater than existing estimated demands. Flow me-

ters that are currently in place to monitor water us-

age are inoperable and would have to be repaired and

or replaced in order to monitor the amount of water

consumed by future tenants and uses. Table 4.7-4

presents estimates of domestic water demand for this

alternative.

565

TABLE 4.7-4

Estimated Domestic Water Usage -

Alternative 3 - Residential/Commercial

Estimated | Estimated

Domestic | Domestic

d Estimated Water Usage Water Usage

= Employees | (gpd/unit) (gpd)

State Park 50 20 gpd/ | (20 gpd * 100

employee employee) +

5 gpd/visitor | (900 visitors *

5 gpd) = 6,500

Columbia Asseme 2000SF| 20gpd | 1,600-2,000

Cove Area office 20,000 SF gpd

+ 250 SF/

employee = 8

Open Spare 0.09 employee/

acre x 3.5 ac =0

identi 135 SFA/SFD x 3.575 gpd/person| 35,440 gpd

identi 160 TH/APT x 3.5|75 gpd/person| 42,000 gpd

=

Office 50,500 + 250SF/| 20 gpd/ 4,040 gpd

(existing) __| employee=202 | employee

Office/Incubator 250 SF/ 20 gpd/ 2,400 gpd

employee = 120 | employee

250 SF/ 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

employee = 20 | employee

= 20,000 + 650 SFY | 0.10 gpd/sf of} 2,000 gpd

. employee = 31 area

fater-related | 250SF/employee| 20 gpd/ 2,000-2,400

ame = 100-120 employee | __gpd_

Waterfront 250 SF/employee| 20gpd/ | 3,200-4000

Commercial = 80-100 employee | __gpd

WWTP 20 estimated 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

employee

566

2.9 ac x 7 dwell- |75 gpd/person| 5,250 gpd

ings/ac x 3.5

persons/unit = 70

persons

TOTAL 105,230-

106,830 gpd_

Note: Number of residential units and square footage as

of August 1998.

Sanitary Sewage

Sanitary sewage generation would be between 84,200

and 85,500 gallons per day. However, for future bill-

ing purposes, meters would have to be installed at dif-

ferent discharge points of each parcel/building in

order to monitor usage.

Stormwater Systems

The existing surface water drainage system at NUWC

is controlled by a series of catch basins and under-

ground piping. As over 20 buildings would be demol-

ished and new parking spaces would be provided,

additions and relocations to the existing drainage sys-

tem would be implemented to accommodate stormwa-

ter discharges. Any construction activities associated

with the development of this alternative would be

subject to DEP permitting programs.

Steam

It is anticipated that Building 99 would no longer be

utilized for steam generation.

567

Electricity

Specific electrical demand cannot be estimated at this

time. However, sub-metering of the current electrical

system, or the installation of additional electrical

feeds, would be required due to multiple users of elec-

tricity.

4.7.5 Alternative No. 4- Business Campus Water

Supply

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the

City of New London. Per capita water usage is esti-

mated to be 20 gallons per day per employee. Esti-

mated water usage is estimated between 67,565 and

71,665 gallons per day. This is less than histuric and

estimated current water usage in the Fort Trumbull

area. Additionally, flow meters that are currently in-

stalled to monitor water usage are inoperable and

would have to be repaired and/or replaced in order to

monitor the amount of water consumed by future ten-

ants and. uses. Table 4.7-5 presents estimates of do-

mestic water demand for this alternative.

Sanitary Sewage

Sanitary sewage generation is estimated to be be-

tween 54,100 and 57,300 gallons per day. However, for

future billing purposes, meters may have to be in-

stalled at different discharge points of each par-

cel/building in order to monitor usage.

568

TABLE 4.7-5

Estimated Domestic Water Usage -

Alternative 4 - Business Campus

| Estimated | Estimated

Domestic Domestic

Water Usage Water Usage

Land Estimated | (gallons per | (gallons per

Use/Type Employees _ day/per unit) day)

te Park 50 20 (20 gpd * 50

gpd/employee | employee) +

5 gpd/visitor | 450 visitors *

5 gpd) =

3,250 gpd

Columbia §Assume2,000SF 20gpdslip 1,600-2,000

CoveArea office 2,000 SF +

250 S/F

employee = 8

Hotel 200 rooms 50 gpd/unit 10,000 gpd

Residential 30 SFA/SFDx3.5 75 gpd/person | 7,875 gpd

persons/unit

Office 50,500 SF/250 | 20 gpd/unit 4,040 gpd

(existing) SF/ employee

= 202

Office 380,000- 20 gpd/ 30,400-32,400

405,000/250 employee gpd

SF/employee =

1,520-1,620

employee

D/Office | 5,000/250 = 20 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

| employee

Retail 250 SF/ 20 gpd/ 1,200 gpd

employee = 60 employee

Water-related| 25,000-30,000+| .10gpd/sfof |2,500-3,000

Commercial 650 SF/ gross area

Water front 20 gpd/ _—1,600-2,000

Commercial employee Bo

569

160 dwellings/ac| 20gpd/ _3,200-4,000 gpd.

employee

Residential | 0.8 acx7dwell-| 75 gpd/person | 1,500 gpd

(existing) ings/ac x

3.5 persons/unit

= 70 persons

TOTAL 67,565-71,665

gpd

Note: Number of residential units and square footage as

of August 1998.

Stormwater Systems

Additions and relocations to the existing drainage

system would be implemented to accommodate any

new drainage changes that may result from the activ-

ity. As is the case with the Residential/Commercial al-

ternative, any construction activities associated with

the development of the Business alternative would be

subject to the NPDES permit program.

Steam

Building 99 would be located within the Of-

fice/Incubator component of this reuse alternative. It

is anticipated that Building 99 could provide steam to

other non-military-retained buildings. However, sub-

metering at points of use would have to be imple-

mented in order to monitor usage.

Electricity

Specific electrical demand cannot be estimated at this

time. However, sub-metering of the current electrical

system, or the installation of additional electrical

feeds, would be required due to multiple users of elec-

tricity.

570

4.7.6 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

Water Supply

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the

City of New London. Estimated water usage under

this alternative would be between 70,660 and 71,860

gallons per day. This is less than historic usage in the

Fort Trumbull area and approximately equal to exist-

ing estimated usage in the area. Table 4.7-6 presents

estimates of domestic water demand for this alterna-

tive.

Sanitary Sewage

Sanitary sewage generation is estimated to be be-

tween 56,500 and 57,500 gallons per day. However, for

future billing purposes, meters would have to be in-

stalled at different discharge points of each par-

cel/building in order to monitor usage.

Steam

It is anticipated that Building 99 would no longer be

used for steam generation.

Electricity

As is the case with the other alternatives, specific

electrical demand cannot be estimated at this time.

However, sub-metering of the current system or the

installation of additional electrical feeds would be re-

quired because multiple users of electricity are also

anticipated.

Estimated [Estimated

Domestic Domestic

Estimated Water Usage Water Usage

Employees (gallons per (gallons

or Units day/per unit) per day)

State Park 50 20 gpd/ (20 gpd * 50

employee5 | employee) +

gpd/visitor 450 visitors * 5

\gpd = 3,250

Columbia Assume 2,000 20 gpd/slip 1,600-2,000

Cove office 2,000 SF +

Area 250 SF/

employee = 8

Assume 10,000 20 gpd/ (20) gpd * 40

SF office 10,000; employee employee) +

SF+250SF/ | 75gpd/room 200 rcoms * 75

GPD) =

15,800 gpd

2,250 gpd

30,320 gpd

4,040 gpd

400 gpd

1,000 gpd

400

v2 573

WWTP 40 estimated 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

Athletic 25,000SF x6 | 15gal/visitor | 2,250 gpd

employee Club/Field visits/day/

TOTAL ae a 1,000 SF

Note: Number of residential units and square footage as co ”

of August 1998. a

Office 50,500 + 250 20 gpd/ 4,040 gpd

4.7.7 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2 Water Supply (existing) SF/employee employee

Potable water would continue to be obtained from the aa 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

City of New London. Estimated water usage under employee = 20

this alternative would be between 74,410 and 75,610

gallons per day. This is less than historic usage in the

Fort Trumbull area and approximately equal to exist-

ing demands. Table 4.7-7 presents estimates of do- | .

mestic water demand for this alternative. Cnr — A A ee

emplovse

TABLE 4.7-7 = 100 120

Estimated Domestic Water Usage - 25u SF/ 20 gpd/ ——

Alternative 6 - Mixed Use 2 — employee

WWTP 40 estimated 20 gpd/ 400 gpd

employee

74,410-75,610

_gpd

Note: Number of residential units and square footage as

of August 1998.

Sanitary Sewage

Sanitary sewage generation is estimated to be be-

tween 59,500 and 60,500 gallons per day. However, for

future billing purposes, meters would have to be in-

stalled at different discharge points of each par-

cel/building in order to monitor usage.

48

574

Steam and Electricity

Impacts to steam generation and electricity for Alter-

native 6 are the same as those for Alternative 5.

Cultural Resources Impacts

Future development in the Fort Trumbull MDP area

will include ground disturbances from machine ac-

cess, demolition of some existing structures, construc-

tion of new buildings, utility installation, and land

plans

will have varying affects on different parts of the pro-

ject area, and possibly associated archaeological sites.

Archeological reconnaissance surveys (Phase lb) are

planned in all areas that have been identified in the

archaeological assessment surveys (Reeve, Keegan

and Keegan 1998; TAMS 1998) as moderately and

highly sensitive for prehistoric or historic period ar-

are anticipated.

Archeological investigations should not prevent fu-

ture deve'oupment of the project area. Representatives

of the Connecticut Historical Commission (CHC) have

indicated that Phase lb, and, if necessary, Phase 2

and Phase 3 level investigation, can proceed over the

long term as development plans and construction

schedules are adopted. CHC has further indicated a

willingness to work closely with all parties to assure

protection of significant historic resources and to as-

sure the success of New London revitalization.

In any of the alternatives, structures on the NWUC

demolition of currently registered

contemplated, it is likely that some or all of the other

575

structures on this property would be destroyed in the

implementation of various alternatives. Based on the

building ‘nventory presented in Section 2.3.3, reuse

and rehabilitation of most of these buildings would be

likely for Building 34 (Bowditch Hall) and Building 14

within the public sale portion of NUWC. These are

described in detail in Section 2.7.2 of this document.

Numerous mitigative measures have been proposed to

offset impacts to cultural resources. These are de-

scribed in Section 5.0 of this document.

4.8.1 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Hypothetically, any archeological resources off the

NUWC property would be preserved under this alter-

native. Due to the potentially sensitive contexts of

certain properties in this area, the City of New Lon-

ing land use on a parcel-by-parcel basis. However,

there is no mandatory or programmatic requirement

to do so. Therefore, with no firm commitment to con-

sources may be lost if the no action alternative were

pursued as compared with the other alternatives.

The LRA’s preferred reuse plan for NUWC contem-

plates the reuse of five buildings (Buildings 2, 80, 96,

99, and 101) in the public sale portion of the property,

as well as restoration and reuse of Buildings 13, 14,

27, 32, and 42 for office and as attractions. Buildings

41, 44, 34, 28, and 94 (which have been identified as

eligible structures) would be demolished.

576

4.8.2 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Moderately to highly sensitive archeological areas are

crossed by the state park expansion, the riverfront

walkway, and the Pequot Avenue R&D area. Specific

areas are likely to be affected by hotel construction,

cultural museum/active recreation, the recreation

center, and office/incubator construction. Archeologi-

cal investigations should provide substantial thematic

contexts for museum programs, exhibits, and tour-

ism in this alternative. Substantial areas contain-

ing archeological sites might be preserved in this

plan. Most, if not all of the identified eligible struc-

tures in the future development area at NUWC

would be demolished. This is also true for Alterna-

tives 3 through 6.

4.8.3 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

Residential development may be able to incorporate

preserved. Archeological sites identified in the R&D,

office/incubator, and retail] areas are expected to have

intensive ground modifications that may require data

recovery of significant archeological sites, if found.

4.8.4 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

As in other alternatives, the business campus devel-

opment is expected to affect moderately to highly sen-

sitive archeological areas, with few opportunities for

- 4 space preservation of identified archeological

4.9

577

4.8.5 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

Similar to Alternative 3, residential and recreational

development can be designed to incorporate archeo-

logical site preservation in the open space areas.

Office/incubator, R&D, and hotel/conference center

development are less adaptable for archeological

preservation.

4.8.6 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

Impacts associated with Alternative 6 would be simi-

lar to Alternative 5, except that the larger area of

open space designated in the eastern portion of the

MDP area would result in less ground disturbance

and, therefore, be more adaptable for archeological

preservation.

Traffic and Parking Impacts

4.9.1 Traffic Generation

Analyses required to assess existing (1998) and future

year (2010) anticipated traffic volumes (with and

without site traffic) for the weekday AM. and PM.

peak highway hours are based on manual turning

movement counts conducted on Thursday, August 13,

1998, and on Fridays, August 14 and 21, 1998. The

turning movement counts for the periods

7:00 A.M.-9:00 A.M. and 4:00 PM.-6:00 PM. deter-

mined that weekday peak commuter hours are from

8:00-9:00 AM. and 4:15-5:15 PM. Existing (1998)

weekday A.M. and P.M. traffic volumes are presented

in Appendix D (Figures 1 and 2, respectively). Based

on existing traffic patterns and proposed development

land uses, it is anticipated that the most intense traf-

fic impacts will occur during the weekday A.M. and

P.M. peak commuter hours.

578

Future year 2010 projected traffic volumes without

Fort Trumbull MDP development consists of expan-

sion of existing year 1998 traffic volumes by 1.0% per

year compounded annually plus the addition of peak

hour traffic generated by the Pfizer facility. Estimated

2010 traffic volumes for the A.M. and P.M. weekday

peak commuter hours, without the Fort Trumbull

MDP area development, are presented in Appendix D

(Figures 3 and 4, respectively).

Anticipated future year traffic generated by the pro-

posed Fort Trumbull MDP were developed for six de-

velopment alternatives including:

Alternative 1 — No Action Alternative;

Alternative 2 — Recreation/Tourism Alternative;

Alternative 3 — Residential/Commercial Alternative;

Alternative 4 — Business Park Alternative;

Alternative 5 — Mixed Ll se 1; and

Alternative 6 — Mixed Use 2.

Estimates of anticipated traffic generated by these al-

ternatives were developed for the various proposed

land uses in the MDP area using the Institute of

Transportation Engineers’, “Trip Generation” publica-

tion, 6th Edition. Trips generated by existing office

space (50,500 square feet) are based on General Office

Building trip generation rates (ITE Land Use 710),

whereas proposed office/incubator and Research &

Development office spaces are based on ITE Land Use

760 for Research and Development Center Uses.

Projected traffic generation is summarized in Table

4.9-1.

579

TABLE 4.9-1

Summary of Projected Traffic Counts

Condition | A.M. | P.M.

EnteringExitingEnteringExi

Alternative 1 - - 1,081 326 333 961

No Action

Alternative 2 - 690 402 280 565

Recreation/Tourism

Alternative 3 - 575 478 341 495

Residential/

Commercial

Alternative 4 - 973 466 337 812

Business Campus

Alternative 5 - 654 417 315 541

Mixed Use 1

Alternative 6 - 671 428 331 556

Mixed Use 2

Development Alternatives 1, 4, and 6 represent high

trip generations relative to the six development alter-

natives and are used for analysis in this report. Ta-

bles 4.9-2 and 4.9-3 present a breakdown of the

anticipated site trips generated during the weekday

A.M. and P.M. peak highway hours for Alternatives 4

and 6, respectively.

Site traffic is distributed over the study area roadway

system based on existing traffic patterns and distri-

bution patterns presented in previous traffic reports

for developments in the area, including the traffic

study for Pfizer’s adjacent facility. The distribution

pattern used for the MDP area is as follows:

77% of the site traffic is oriented to and from the

north and east, by way of Howard Street and

Bank Street through New London’s Central

Business District, to/from the I-95 interchange;

580

© 8% of the site traffic is oriented to and from the

north and west by way of Bank Street using

Howard Street and Shaw Street for access;

© 10% of the site traffic is oriented to and from the

west by way of Willetts Avenue; and

¢ 5% of the site traffic is oriented to and from the

south by way of Pequot Avenue.

Alternatives 4 and 6 include approximately 12 land

use areas within each alternate. For purposes of traf-

fic analyses, access to development area is grouped

within each alternate by a common access via Hamil-

ton Street via the intersection of Howard Street/

Walbach Street, via the intersection of Trumbull

Street/Pequot Avenue, via Trumbull Street and via

Walbach Street.

Site generated traffic in Alternatives 4 and 6 were

superimposed on the future year base traffic volumes

to create future year (2010) combined traffic volumes

for the weekday A.M. and P.M. peak highway hours.

Appended Figures 5, 6, 7 and 8 present the combined

traffic volumes for each scenario (Appendix D).

581

Anticipated Site Generated Traffic

Alternate 4 — Business Campus Alternate

Fort Trumbull MDP, New London, Connecticut

Land Use Size ITE Weekday Trip Generation Rate Weekday Generated Vehicle Trips

Code AM PM Daily AM PM Daily

Enter | Exit | Enter| Exit | Enter| Exit | Enter | Exit | Enter | Exit | Enter | Exit

PENINSULA AREA

State Park 16.0 Acres - - - - - 45 5 10 40 100 100

Columbia Cove Marina| 100 Slips 420 | 0.03 | 0.05 | 0.11 | 0.08 | 1.48 | 1.48 3 5 1l 8 148 148

Hotel/Conference 200 Rooms 310 | 0.34 | 0.22 | 0.32 | 0.29 | 4.12 | 4.12 68 44 64 58 824 824

Center

Office/Incubator 375,000 760 | 1.03 | 0.21 | 0.16 | 0.92 | 4.06 | 4.06 | 386 79 60 345 | 1,523 | 1,523

Water Related 30,000 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34| 93 100 34 45 610 610

Commercial

Waste Water 40 Employees - - - - - - - (30) (4) (6) (30) | (60) | (60)

Treatment Plant — (Assumes 3 shifts with 30 employees on first shift, 6

employees on second shift and 4 employees on third

shift)

Peninsula Area Sub Totals | 625 237 185 526

GATEWAY AREA

Residential 30 Single 270 | 0.11 | 0.40 | 0.40 | 0.22 | 3.75 | 3.75 4 12 12 7 113 113

Family

attached/

detached units =”

Office (Existing) 50,500 sq. ft. 710 | 1.37 | 0.19 | 0.25 | 1.24 | 5.51 | 5.51 69 10 13 63 278 278

Retail/ 3,750 sq. ft. 852 | 15.51 | 15.51 | 16.94 | 17.63 - - 58 58 64 66 - -

Specialty Retail 11,250 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34); 35 38 13 17 229 229

R & D Office 70,000 sq. ft. 760 | 1.03 | 0.21 | 0.16 | 6.92 | 4.06 | 4.06 72 15 12 65 305 305

Waterfront Commercial | 25,000 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34} 77 84 28 37 509 509

Residential (existing) |8dwellingunits; 210 | 0.19 | 0.56 | 0.65 | 0.36 | 4.79 | 4.79 2 5 5 3 38 38

(existing)

Office/Incubator 30,000 sq. ft. 760 1.03 | 0.21 | 0.16 .92 4.06 | 4.06 31 7 5 28 122 122

Gateway Area Sub Totals | 348 229 152 286

TOTALS 973 466 337 #812

(xx) Estimated

582

ANTICIPATED SITE GENERATED TRAFFIC

Alternate 6 — Mixed Use Alternate #2

Fort Trumbull MDP, New London, Connecticut

(xx) Estimated

Notes: 1.

January 23, 1998, prepared by TAMS, page 4.4-2 and Table 4.4-1.

Wilbur Smith Associates

DEIS — Disposal and Reuse of Naval Underwater Warfare Center, New London, Connecticut;

Land Use Size ITE Weekday Trip Generation Rate Weekday Generated Vehicle Trips

Code AM PM Daily AM PM Daily

Enter | Exit | Enter | Exit | Enter | Exit | Enter| Exit | Enter| Exit | Enter| Exit

PENINSULA AREA

State Park 16 Acres (Note 1)}_ - - - - - - 45 5 10 40 100 100

Columbia Cove Marina} 100 Slips 420 | 0.03 | 0.05 | 0.11 | 0.08 | 148 | 1.48 3 5 1l 8 148 148

Hotel/Conf Center 250 Rooms 310 | 0.34 | 0.22 | 0.32 | 0.29 | 4.12 | 4.12 85 55 80 73 1030 | 1030

Athletic 25,000 sq. ft. 492 | 0.73 | 0.73 | 0.92 | 0.92 | 8.57 | 8.57 19 19 23 23 215 215

Club/Field (Assumes 50% in, 50 percent out)

Residential Mid-Range|115 Units | 270 0.11 | 0.40 | 0.40 | 0.22 | 3.75 | 3.75 13 46 46 25 432 432

(Single family attached

and deatched units)

Water Related 30,000 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34)| 93 100 34 45 610 610

Commercial

Waste Water 40 Employ - - - a i - - (30) (4) (6) (30) | (60) | (60)

Treatment Plant Plant (Assumes 3 shifts with 30 employees on first shift, 6

employees on second shift and 4 employees on third

shift)

Peninsula Area Sub Totals| 288 234 210 # £244

GATEWAY AREA =

Office (Existing) 50,500 sq. ft. 710 | 1.37 | 0.19 | 0.25 | 1.24 | 5.51 | 5.51 69 10 13 63 278 278

Office/Incubator 100,000 sq. ft.| 760 | 1.03 | 0.21 | 0.16 .92 4.06 | 4.06 | 103 21 16 92 406 | 406

Retail/ 2,500 sq. ft. 852 | 15.51 | 15.51 | 16.94 | 17.63 - - 39 39 43 44 - -

Specialty 7,500 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34) 23 25 9 11 153 153

R & D Office 70,000 sq. ft. 760 | 1.03 | 0.21 | 0.16 | 0.92 | 4.06 | 4.06 72 15 12 65 305 305

Waterfront Commercial | 25,000 sq. ft. 814 | 3.08 | 3.33 | 1.11 | 1.48 | 20.34 | 20.34} 77 84 28 37 509 509

Gateway Area Sub Totals | 383 194 121 312

TOTALS 671 428 331 556

583

Anticipated future year 2010 combined traffic vol-

umes are sufficient to require roadway and intersec-

tion improvements within and external to the MDP

area. Vertical and horizontal clearances at existing

railroad underpasses on Pequot Avenue and on Wal-

bach Street were examined and three roadway im-

provement options (A, B, and C) were developed.

These improvement plans, described in Section 3.0 of

this document, were evaluated for the A.M. and P.M.

peak commuter hours in alternate development sce-

narios 4 and 6.

Future year 2010 combined traffic volumes, as pre-

sented in Appendix D (Figures 5, 6, 7 and 8), are con-

sistent with roadway improvement Options A and C.

Roadway Option B introduces three improvement

strategies concepts which alter existing traffic pat-

terns; namely, Shaw Street is proposed to be a cul-de-

sac south of Harris Street; Hamilton Street (east of

Howard Street) will cross the rail line and provide

new access to the site on the east side of the railroad;

and Walbach Street would cease to be a vehicular ac-

cess under the railroad. Accordingly, revised traffic

patterns are presented for the weekday A.M. and P.M.

peak highway hours for Alternatives 4 and 6 in Ap-

pendix D (Figures 9, 10, 11 and 12).

4.9.2 Intersection Capacity Analysis

Capacity analyses and levels of service determina-

tions were computed to determine the adequacy of

study area intersections in existing year 1998, future

year 2010 without site traffic, and future year 2010

with site traffic. Future year 2010 analyses with site

traffic were performed under roadway improvement

Options A, B, and C for Alternatives 4 and 6. Capacity

analyses were performed at the following intersec-

tions:

584

Bank Street at Shaw Street/Truman Street;

Bank Street at Howard Street/Reed Street;

Howard Street at Hamilton Street;

Hamilton Street at Shaw Street;

Howard Street at Walbach Street;

Howard Street at Shaw Street/Pequot Avenue/

Willetts Avenue;

* Pequot Avenue at Trumbull Street/Pfizer Drive;

and

¢ Howard Street at Relocated Hamilton Street

(Applicable to Roadway Option B only).

Intersection capacities were performed in accordance

with analyses techniques described in the 1994

Highway Capacity Manual, Special Report 209, pub-

lished by the Transportation Research Board, Na-

tional Research Council, Washington, D.C. Capacity

analysis software is Highway Capacity Software -—

1994 version 2.4g (signalized intersections) and ver-

sion 2.1g (unsignalized intersections).

4.9.3 Evaluation Methodology

The adequacy of the study area intersections were

analyzed to determine operating characteristics and

the need for proposed improvements. Level of Service

analyses were computed for existing and future year

operations using these analyses.

A study of capacity is important in determining the

ability of a specific roadway or intersection to accom-

modate traffic under various levels of service. Level of

service (LOS) is a qualitative measure describing

driver satisfaction with a number of factors that in-

fluence the degree of traffic congestion. These factors

include speed and travel time, traffic interruption,

freedom of maneuverability, safety, driving comfort

and convenience, and delay.

585

There are six levels of service describing flow condi-

tions. The highest, Level of Service A, describes a

condition of free flow, with low volumes and high

speeds. There is little or no restriction in maneuver-

ability due to the presence of other vehicles, and driv-

ers can maintain speeds with little or no delay. This

occurs when vehicle progression is extremely favor-

able, and most vehicles arrive during the green phase

of a traffic signal.

Level of Service B represents a stable traffic flow with

operating speeds beginning to be restricted somewhat

by traffic conditions. Drivers still have reasonable

freedom to select their speed and lane operations.

Level of Service C, which is normally utilized for de-

sign purposes, describes a stable condition of traffic

operation. It entails moderately restricted movements

due to higher traffic volumes, but traffic conditions

are not objectionable to motorists.

Level of Service D, acceptable for traffic operation in

urban environments and during peak hours of traffic

flow, reflects a condition of more restrictive movement

for motorists. Queues and delays may occur during

short peaks, but lower demands occur often enough to

permit clearance of developing queues, thus prevent-

ing excessive backup. At Level of Service D, the influ-

ence of congestion becomes more noticeable and

longer delays may result from unfavorable vehicle

progression.

Level of Service E is defined as the actual capacity of

the roadway or intersection, and involves delay to all

motorists due to congestion. This is considered to be

the limit of acceptable delay. These high delay values

generally indicate poor vehicle progression.

The lowest. Level of Service F, is described as forced

flow and is characterized by volumes greater than the

586

theoretical roadway capacity. Complete congestion oc-

curs and, in extreme cases, the volume passing a

given point drops to zero. This is generally considered

unacceptable traffic operations. _

Levels of service criteria for signalized intersections is

quantified in terms of delay, which may be used as a

measure of driver discomfort, excess fuel consump-

tion, and lost travel time. Specifically, level of service

criteria, stated in terms of the average “stopped” de-

lay per vehicle, are presented in Table 4.9-4.

TABLE 4.9-4

Levels of Service for Signalized Intersections

Level of Service|Stopped Delay per Vehicle (seconds)

—

5.0 or less

5.1 to 15.0

15.1 to 25.0

25.1 to 40.0

40.1 to 60

HS) OOo >

greater than 60

Level of service criteria for unsignalized intersections

is given in terms of reserve or unused capacity of the

approach lane in question under STOP control. These

are presented in Table 4.9-5.

TABLE 4.9-5

Levels of Service for Unsignalized Intersections

Level of Service|Reserve Capacity (vehicles per hour)|

400 or more

300 to 399

200 to 299

100 to 199

0 to 99

HS O|O|o | >

Demand exceeds lane capacity.

587

These levels of service are defined by the 1994 High-

way Capacity Manual, Special Report 209, published

by the Transportation Research Board, National -

Academy of Sciences.

Table 4.9-6 summarizes anticipated levels of service

for the study area intersections. Table 4.9-7 presents

critical volume/capacity ratios. The analyses assume

that future improvements would be made to mitigate

anticipated traffic flows including:

Int

Bank Street & Reed St./Howard Street

Bank Street & Truman St./Shaw Street

Hamilton Street/Shaw St. & Commercial Drive

10

Howard Street & Hamilton Street

Howard Street & Relocated Hamilton Street

Howard Street & New Bridge Road

Howard Street & Walbach Street

Howard St./Shaw St/Willetts Ave/Pequot Avenue

Pequot Ave. & Trumbull St/Pfizer Drive

n/a — not applicable, intersection does not exist.

588

ANTICIPATED LEVELS OF SERVICE

Fort Trumbull MDP Area

TABLE 4.9-6

New London, CT

1998 2010

Existing w/osite”

AM PM AM PM

B B C OD C

i i i a

| a oe ae ome

rH fF ££ 6

n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a

n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a

a an ae

rr Ee FF =

, i an oe

Notes: All intersections are signalized except as noted

(1) Includes Pfizer Global Development Facility

(2)

(3)

All Way Stop Sign Controlled

Two Way Stop Sign Controlled

D C

B B

A” A®

Wa A

B_ n/a

C n/a

wa B

B C

sia

B

A”

A

n/a

n/a

B

Cc

B

Year 2C10-

Development Alternative 6

Road AltA Road AltB Road Alt C

AM PM AM PM AM PM

Cc Cc C C €C C€

ze an a =

A” A” A” A® A® A®

A A nwa na A A

w/a n/a BB —0»r/a ni/a

Wa Wa BB »rn/a ni/a

B B n/a n/a B_ B

>» €&€ BB BSB €

B B B B B_B

589

TABLE 4.9-7

Anticipated Critical Volume/Capacity Ratios

For Trumbull MDP Area ~

Year 2010 - Year 2010 -

Development Alternative 4 Development Alternative 6

1998 2010 w/o

Existing site” | Road Alt A| Road Alt B | Road Alt C | Road Alt A | Road Alt B | Road Alt C

Intersection A.M.| P.M. A.M.|P.M.|A.M.|P.M.|A.M.|P.M.|A.M.|P.M.|A.M.|P.M.|A.M.| P.M.

Bank & Reed St./Howard. a 0.40 | 0.60 | 0.88 | 0.97 | 0.91 | 0.95 | 0.91 | 0.95 | 0.91 | 0.95 | 0.81 | 0.86 | 0.81 | 0.86 | 0.81 | 0.86

Bank & Truman/Shaw 0.61 | 0.83 | 0.71 | 0.87 | 0.61 | 0.78 | 0.61 | 0.78 | 0.61 | 0.78 | 0.61 | 0.78 | 0.61 | 0.78 | 0.61 | 0.78

Hamilton/Shaw & Commercial Dr.’ 0.08} 0.14*|0.09*| 0.26°| 0.12*| 0.27°| 0.14”|0.38"| 0.12”|0.27°| 0.117|0.267| 0.14”|0.437| 0.117] 0.26"

Howard & Hamilton 0.06°|0.15°|0.22°|0.47°| 0.63 | 0.70| n/a | n/a | 0.63/ 0.70 | 0.52] 0.66) n/a | n/a | 0.52 | 0.66

Howard & Relocated Hamilton St. n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | 0.63/ 0.61) n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | 0.61) 0.53} n/a | n/a

Howard & New Bridge Rd. n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | 0.89/ 0.87) n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | 0.73) 0.80} n/a | n/a

Howard & Walbach St. 0.07°|0.09*|0.18"| 0.27 | 0.80| 0.81} n/a | n/a | 0.80/ 0.81 | 0.56/0.73| n/a | n/a | 0.56/ 0.72

Howard/Shaw/Willetts/Pequot 0.36°|0.57°|0.99"| 1.74’| 0.83 | 0.95 | 0.73 | 0.80 | 0.83 | 0.95 | 0.80 | 0.89 | 0.68 | 0.75 | 0.80 0.89 |

Pequot & Trumbul/Pfizer Dr. 0.04°|0.03°|0.81°| 1.08°| 0.79 | 0.76 | 0.76 | 0.73 | 0.72 | 0.76 | 0.76 | 0.71 | 0.73 | 0.71 | 0.72 | 0.71

n/a — not applicable, intersection does not exist.

Please note all intersections are signalized except as noted.

(1) Includes Pfizer Global Development Facility

(2) All-way Stop Sign Controlled

(3) Two-way Stop Sign Controlled

590

¢ Implementation of Roadway Improvement Op-

tions A, B, or C as appropriate;

e Providing a westbound double left turn lane and

a northbound double right turn lane at the inter-

section of Bank Street/Howard Street/Reed

Street.

e An upgraded traffic signal installation with new

timing, phasing and sequencing at the Bank

Street/Howard Street/Reed Street intersection;

- © Revised timing of the existing traffic signal at

Bank Street/Shaw Street/Trumbull Street;

¢ Installation of new traffic signals (from STOP

sign control) at the following intersections:

- Howard Street at Hamilton Street;

- Howard Street at Relocated Hamilton Street

(Roadway Improvement Option B only);

- Howard Street at Walbach Street;

- Howard Street at Shaw Street/Willetts Ave-

nue/Pequot Avenue; and Pequot Avenue at

Trumbull Street/Pfizer Drive.

In addition, on-street parking on Howard Street be-

tween Shaw Street and Walbach Street is proposed to

be prohibited to maintain four lanes of traffic.

These analyses indicate that, in general, Level of Ser-

vice C or better can be achieved at most intersections

under Alternatives 4 and 6, with roadway Alterna-

tives A, B, and C. The exceptions are the intersection

of Howard Street at Hamilton Street and New Bridge

Road in Alternative 4 with Roadway Improvement

Option B, where LOS D is provided in the A.M. peak

591

highway hour; and the intersection of Bank Street at

Howard Street/Reed Street in Alternative 4 in the

P.M. peak highway hour.

4.10 Water Resources Impacts

The predominant water resource in the project area is

the Thames River. Various potential impacts have

been evaluated with respect to water quality and the

Thames River. Water quality issues associated with

stormwater runoff are presented in Section 4.7 of this

document. Flood related impacts are presented in

Section 4.11. Potential impacts to fisheries and living

marine resources in the Thames River are presented

in Section 4.12.

4.11 Flood Hazard Impacts

Each of the alternative development plans have been

reviewed with respect to conformance with state

floodplain policies and FEMA planning considerations

as defined in part 60.22 of the National Flood Insur-

ance Program regulations. A summary of flood hazard

impact potential for each alternative follows. Figure

110-1 (presented in Section 2.10 of this document)

graphically presents the FEMA Flood Zones in the

MDP area.

4.11.1 Common Elements

The proposed 2.l-acre waterfront commercial use

area next to Shaw’s Cove is a feature of Alternatives 2

through 6. While this is a flood prone area, the exist-

_ ing and proposed water-dependent activities must be

located adjacent to coastal waters and cannot avoid

being flood prone. New buildings would have to com-

ply with FEMA structural standards.

592

The office incubator and retail type uses planned in

Alternatives 2 through 6 would be located largely in

designated flood hazard areas. The first floor levels

would, therefore, need to either be elevated above the

base flood, floodproofed, or allowed to flood with dam-

ages. Any increase in the square footage could be in-

consistent with state floodplain policies (Section 25-

68h).

The southern part of the Fort Area is subject to

coastal flooding. The existing regional Water Pollu-

tion Control Facility which bisects Trumbull Street is

in an original flood prone area; however, buildings

and tanks have been elevated with fill material to re-

duce their risk. All new construction at this site must

also be elevated.

Alternatives 2 through 6 include 2.5 acres of water-

related uses at Trumbull Street and Smith Street in a

flood prone area. This area includes the existing Fort

Trumbull Marina and lobster packaging operations.

Any future buildings will need to be designed to mini-

mize flood hazards.

The proposed Columbia Cove area in Alternatives 2

through 6 is a water-dependent use in a flood prone

area. Its location is unavoidable. The proposed ho-

tel/conference center at the north end of the MDP

area is at the edge of the flood hazard area. This af-

fords the opportunity to avoid the flood prone area by

moving the core building west to high ground or to

elevate it above the base flood.

4.11.2 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Under the no action alternative, existing flood prone

areas would remain subject to flooding and new con-

struction would have to be in compliance with local

593

floodplain zoning and building standards. The flood-

plain has little impact on development of the state

park.

4.11.3 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

The portion of the Fort Area north of Hamilton Street

consists of dry upland between the railroad and ex-

tension of Smith Street, with flood prone areas near

the shoreline. The higher ground is suitable for the

recreation center proposed in Alternative 2.

The central part of the Fort Area has a high rocky hill

that extends above coastal flood levels. It is well

suited for cultural uses. However, the proposed open

space in Alternative 2 underutilizes this upland area.

The west side of Pequot Avenue south of Trumbull

Street is not in a designated flood hazard area and is,

therefore, suitable for the planned research and de-

velopment office space, as well as other activities

which are poorly suited for flood prone areas.

The north and south ends of the NUWC site, and its

eastern coastline, are in flood prone areas. The pro-

posed state park is consistent with open space flood-

plain usage. New buildings should be limited to

upland areas, or designed to be insensitive to flood

inundation.

4.11.4 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

The planned residential development on the west side

of Howard Street in the Gateway Area is in a flood

prone area and is inconsistent with state floodplain

management policy (Section 25-68h). State funds

cannot be used for residential uses in the floodplain.

This alternate includes a large area of residential de-

velopment in the Fort Area and in the north end of

594

the NUWC property near Columbia Cove. About half

of the residential development is in the floodplain and

is inconsistent with state floodplain management

policies (Section 25-68h). While construction is al-

lowed in A-zones in accordance with specific building

criteria, it is not advisable to locate residential struc-

tures, especially high density residences, in a flood

hazard area when alternative locations exist.

The waterfront commercial area at South Cove is also

in the floodplain, as is some retail and office areas.

However, these latter uses are subject to less rigorous

standards.

4.11.5 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

The enlarged proposed residential area in the flood-

plain west of Howard Street in the Gateway Area is

inconsistent with state floodplain management policy

(Section 25-68h). State funds cannot be used for resi-

dential uses in the floodplain. The waterfront com-

mercial area at Shaw’s Cove and the limited retail

and office areas are also in the floodplain but may not

be considered intensive uses.

A significant portion of the proposed office incubator

campus space is located in the desigNated floodplain

area. State policy discourages any increase in the

square footage of such building space in flood prone

areas. However, in view of the large area of existing

office space at NUWC that is being replaced, it could

be proportioned to avoid a more intensive use. Build-

ing space should still be elevated and/or floodproofed.

The western and southern part of the proposed busi-

ness campus is not within the floodplain and is thus

The proposed hotel conference center area is partially

within the floodplain. It is anticipated that th » actual

595

building of moderate size could avoid the floodplain.

As in previous alternatives, the proposed Columbia

Cove area is in a floodplain and cannot avoid being in

an exposed area.

4.11.6 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

The proposed land use west of the railroad would be

office and office/incubator spaces in the floodplain.

Any increase in the square footage of this type of ac-

tivity could be considered an “intensive use” with re-

spect to state floodplain management policies. New

buildings would have to conform with floodplain zon-

ing and building standards. The waterfront commer-

cial area at Shaw’s Cove remains flood prone as per

previous alternatives.

The large flood prone area in the Fort Area on both

sides of Smith Street would be developed with resi-

dential uses. Similar to Alternative 3, this is in con-

flict with the state floodplain management policies

(Section 25-68h). Extensive fill would be necessary for

this alternative and said fill is not eligible for state

funding.

The proposed hotel/conference center is partially lo-

cated within a floodplain area. As in other alterna-

tives, it is anticipated that the actual building of

moderate size could avoid the floodplain. The pro-

posed Columbia Cove area is in the floodplain and

cannot avoid the flood prone area.

4.11.7 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

The proposed Alternative 6 land uses in the Gate-

way Area are similar to Alternative 5. Any increase

in square footage over existing conditions could be

considered “intensive” with respect to floodplain

596

management policies. Buildings would need to be ele-

vated and/or floodproofed.

The primary difference between Alternatives 5 and 6

is the location of residential uses away from the

floodplain. The area east of Smith Street would be

utilized for open space and athletic facilities, with

higher density uses located on the higher ground,

closer to the railroad. This also allows additional

space for a larger hotel/conference center. Open space

uses such as fields and recreational facilities are more

appropriate in coastal flood hazard areas.

The Columbia Cove area would remain in a flood

prone area as in other alternatives. This is an un-

avoidable location and the associated buildings must

be designed accordingly.

4.11.8 Summary

Alternatives 2 and 6 are most compatible with flood-

ing issues in the MDP area due to the larger areas of

park and open space, while Alternatives 3 and 5 are

least compatible with flood prone areas with respect

to their residential uses. Alternative 6 places open

space/recreational facilities in the river side flood-

plain areas, while increasing the building density in

upland areas. A summary of impacts is presented in

Table 4.11-1.

597

Table 4.11-1

Summary of Uses and Associated Flood Impacts

Area Location | Flood Risk | Wave Risk Alt. 1 Alt. 2 Alt. 3 Alt. 4 Alt. 5 Alt. 6

Gateway North High Low No proposed |Waterfront |Waterfront |Waterfront | Waterfront Jaterfront

change. Commercial |Commercial |Commercial |Commercial |Commercial

South High Low No proposed | Office/ Office/ Office/ Office/Retail | Office/

change. Commercial |Residential |Incubator Incubator

Fort North Moderate Low No proposed |Hotel/ Residential | Hotel/ Hotel/ Hotel/

change. Recreation Conference /|Residential {Conference

Central Low Low No proposed |Cultural/ Residential/ | Office/ Residential/ | Recreation

change. Museum Open Incubator Ath. Club

South Moderate Low No proposed | WPCF WPCF WPCF WPCF WPCF

change.

Southeast Moderate Moderate No proposed | Water-related | Water-related | Water-related | Water-related | Water-related

change. Use Use Use Use Use

NUWC South High Moderate State Park (State Park (State Park (State Park (State Park (State Park

Central High Moderate Office State Park /Residential /Office/ Residential | Athletic

Incubator Center

North High Low Water-related|State Park /|Residential | Hotel/ Hotel/ Hotel/

Use Conference |Conference /|Conference

Pequot All Low Low No proposed |R&D Office |R&D Office |R&D Office |R&D Office | R&D Office

change.

598

4.12 Biological Environment Impacts

4.12.1 Alternative No. 1 - No Action

Fisheries

The Thames River estuarine waters are of significant

value to many of Connecticut’s freshwater and marine

resources. The river provides productive feeding and

spawning habitat to fish species, many of which are of

commercial and recreational importance.

Under Alternative 1, water-related and waterfront

uses include the proposed Fort Truball State Park, a

high speed ferry terminal, and a biotech office park.

Waterfront uses would include the use of Piers 4 and

7 for recreation and fishing. Additionally, Pier 7 would

be used for boat mooring and R&D support. Building

45 would be retained by the Coast Guard along with

the adjacent land and Pier 2.

The use of existing piers for fishing, recreation, and

boat mooring would not significantly impact fisheries

resources in the Thames River. No activities have

been identified under this alternative that involve the

disturbance of riverbed substrate, such as dredging,

filling, or the construction of new piers or marinas.

Any future proposed in-water activities would require

a regulatory permit from either or both the Connecti-

cut Department of Environmental Protection and the

Army Corps of Engineers.

Living Marine Resources

The lower Thames River provides habitat for several

shellfish species. However, the reach of the Thames

River adjacent to the project area is classified as a

prohibited shellfish area by the Bureau of Aquacul-

ture.

599

The use of existing piers for fishing, recreation, and

boat mooring would not be expected to impact marine

resources.

Vegetation

The MDP area is currently developed to very near its

maximum density. The majority of the project area

consists of commercial and industrial buildings, resi-

dences, sidewalks, parking lots, and roads. For the

most part, vegetation is limited to small maintained

lawns, some with ornamental trees. The study area

contains several undeveloped parcels that are over-

grown by invasive plan species that tend to thrive in

areas that have been disturbed.

Under Alternative 1, the NUWC site would be rede-

veloped as mixed-use, including Fort Trumbull State

Park, as well as recreational, waterfront, Coast

Guard, and future development uses. This proposed

redevelopment would possibly result in the loss of

several lawns and a number of ornamental trees as-

sociated with the NUWC facility. However, the pro-

posed state park and recreational uses would likely

result in more, higher quality vegetation than that

which currently exists. Additionally, it is likely that

vegetated areas would be maintained so as to keep

invasive species under control.

Under Alternative 1, the remainder of the project

area would remain in the context of the existing land

use patterns, with possible redevelopment of the area

taking place on a parcel by parcel basis. The vacant

parcels, if developed, would most likely be cleared of

existing vegetation.

Inland Wetlands

The small ephemeral watercourse located on the va-

cant parcel between Howard Street and Shaw Street

is situated in a depressed channel with steep banks of

fill material. Minimal areas of regulated wetland soils

have been identified in this area. Under Alternative 1,

the parcel containing this wetland area would remain

in the context of the existing land use pattern.

Tidal Wetlands

Tidal wetlands occur at the western edge of Bentley

Creek between the regional Water Pollution Control

Facility and the future Pfizer facility. This area is the

focus of a restoration plan in conjunction with the

planned Pfizer development. Pfizer is currently work-

ing with the Department of Environmental Protec-

tion’s Office of Long Island Sound Programs to

develop an acceptable restoration plan for this tidal

wetland area.

Wildlife

The MDP project area is characterized by commercial

and industrial buildings, residences, sidewalks, park-

ing lots, and roads. Due to the intensive development

of these areas, there is insufficient natural habitat to

support most wildlife species. The project area con-

tains several undeveloped vegetated parcei.. Al-

though these areas do not offer significant natural

habitat, and are unlikely to support most wildlife spe-

cies, they probably support a limited number of wild-

life species that have adapted to life in an urban or

near urban environment. Several of these species

benefit due to their interaction with humans.

601

Under Alternative 1, proposed redevelopment in-

cludes the NUWC parcel only. This area contains in-

sufficient natural habitat to support most wildlife

species. The remainder of the project area would re-

main in the context of the existing land use patterns,

with possible redevelopment of the area taking place

on a parcel-by-parcel basis. The vacant parcels, if de-

veloped, would result in the displacement of several

ubiquitous wildlife species.

Species of Special Concern

The Thames River is the only resource listed in the

Department of Environmental Protection’s Natural

Diversity Data Base, due to the occurrence of Atlantic

sturgeon in the river. Potential fisheries impacts are

described above.

4.12.2 Alternative No. 2 - Recreation/Tourism

Fisheries

UnderAlternative 2, potential impacts to fisheries are

limited to those activities associated with the pro-

posed land uses in and around Columbia Cove and

the existing Fort Trumbull Marina.

The majority of land use concepts associated with the

Recreation/Tourism alternative do not infringe upon

the Thames River and would not result in in-water

activities. This area of the Thames River shoreline

has been heavily disturbed through the years, includ-

ing extensive dredging and construction of shoreline

structures. Shallow shoreline habitats which are con-

ducive to many fisheries species are essentially non-

existent in the project area.

Fishing piers, associated with a future state park, are

not likely to have an adverse affect on fisheries in the

602

Thames River nor would the reuse of existing mari-

nas. Specific proposals involving in-water activities

have not yet been developed. At such time as a spe-

cific activity is proposed, the proper controls to avoid

environmental impacts would be prescribed.

Activities that involve the disturbance of riverbed

substrate, such as dredging, filling, or the construc-

tion of new piers or marinas, could potentially have a

negative impact on fisheries habitat if proper con-

struction methods were not employed or if ongoing

operational practices were not in keeping with best

management practices and regulatory requirements.

Any future proposed in-water activity would require

regulatory permits from either or both the Connecti-

cut Department of Environmental Protection and the

Army Corps of Engineers, as well as local permits.

Living Marine Resources

Under Alternative 2, potential impacts to marine re-

sources pertain to in-water activities as well as those

which would occur along the Thames River shoreline.

The lower Thames River provides habitat for several

shellfish species. However, the reach of the Tharses

River adjacent to the project area is classified as a

prohibited shellfish area by the Bureau of Aquacul-

ture.

As with the No Action alternative, the use of existing

piers for fishing, recreation, and boat mooring would

not be expected to impact marine resources. Activities

that involve the disturbance of riverbed substrate,

such as dredging, filling, or the construction of new

piers or marinas, could potentially have a negative

impact on living marine resources if shellfish beds

were present in these areas. However, existing data

and information does not indicate the presence of

603

such resources in this area. Additional study associ-

ated with regulatory permitting would be necessary if

such activities were proposed.

Vegetation

The majority of proposed land use in Alternative 2 to

the east of the railroad is recreational or tourism re-

lated. The state park would be expanded from ap-

proximately 16 acres to 30 acres. A small amount of

lawn and other low-quality vegetation would likely be

cleared for the proposed park and other identified

uses. However, the park would likely result in more,

higher quality vegetation than that which currently

exists. Additionally, it is likely that vegetated areas

would be maintained so as to keep invasive species

under control.

Inland Wetlands

The small ephemeral watercourse located on the va-

cant parcel between Howard Street and Shaw Street

is situated in a depressed channel with steep banks of

fill material. Minimal areas of regulated wetland soils

have been identified in this area, with minimal func-

tional value other than to convey stormwater. Under

Alternative 2, the parcel containing this wetland area

would be developed as an office/incubator use. The

density of this development, as well as development

in the other alternatives, is such that direct impact

can be avoided. Given the low quality of this wetland,

the potential exists to partially restore it during fu-

ture development. Under this and all other alterna-

tives, additional wetland delineation and survey

would be necessary prior to conducting any construc-

tion activities.

- SS ee

Tidal Wetlands

The Thames River shoreline has been altered by

many decades of shoreline dredging, filling, and

placement of structural barriers, leaving the area de-

void of significant areas of tidal wetlands. Tidal wet-

lands do occur at the western edge of Bentley Creek

between the regional Water Pollution Control Facility

and the future Pfizer facility. This area is the focus of

a restoration plan in conjunction with the planned

Pfizer development. Pfizer is currently working with

the Department of Environmental Protection’s Office

of Long Island Sound Programs to develop an accept-

ablo restoration plan for this tidal wetland area.

Wildlife

The MDP project area is characterized by commercial

and industrial buildings, residences, sidewalks, park-

ing lots, and roads. Due to the intensive development

of these areas, there is insufficient natural habitat to

though these areas do not offer significant natural

habitat, and are unlikely to support most wildlife spe-

cies, they probably support a limited number of wild-

life species that have adapted to life in an urban or

near urban environment. Several of these species

benefit due to their interaction with humans.

Under Alternative 2, development of the vacant par-

cels would result in the displacemen op emgeainesd

uitous wildlife. The displacement species

would be more than offset by the development of a

natural area in Fort Trumbull State Park.

605

Species of Special Concern

The Thames River is the only resource listed in the

Department of Environmental Protection’s Natural

Diversity Data Base, due to the occurrence of Atlantic

sturgeon in the river. Potentiai fisheries impacts are

described above.

4.12.3 Alternative No. 3 - Residential/Commercial

Fisheries

Under Alternative 3, potential impacts to fisheries are

limited to those areas associated with the develop-

ment of Columbia Cove and the redevelopment of Fort

Trumbull Marina. Therefore, impacts would be the

same as those discussed under Alternative 2.

Living Marine Resources =

Potential impacts to living marine resources associ-

ated with Alternative 3 would be the same as those

discussed for Alternative 2.

Vegetation

Alternative 3 focuses on providing housing to meet

the needs of the existing community and future resi-

dents. Fort Trumbull State Park would occupy ap-

proximately 16 acres. A small amount of lawn and

other low-quality vegetation would likely be cleared

for the proposed development. The proposed sTate

park would likely result in more, higher quality vege-

tation than that which currently exists. It is likely

that vegetated areas would be managed so as to

maintain the health of the vegetation and to keep in-

vasive species under control.

Inland Wetlands

Potential impacts to inland wetlands associaved with

Alternative 3 would be the same as those discussed

for Alternative 2.

Tidal Wetlands

Potential impacts to tidal wetlands associated with

Alternative 3 would be the same as those discussed

for Alternative 2.

Wildlife

Under Alternative 3, development of the vacant par-

cels would result in the displacement of several wild-

life species that have adapted to life in an urban or

near-urban environment. The displacement of these

species would be more than offset by the development

of a natural area in the 16-acre Fort Trumbull State

Park.

Species of Special Concern

Potential impacts to species of special concern associ-

ated with Alternative 3 would be the same as those

discussed for Alternative 2.

—

4.12.4 Alternative No. 4 - Business Campus

Potential i bs to fisheri livi ;

lands, wildlife, and —— ‘al

ated with Alternative 4 would be the same as those

discussed for Alternative 2. ie

607

4.12.5 Alternative No. 5 - Mixed Use 1

Potential impacts to fisheries resources, living marine

resources, vegetation, inland wetlands, tidal wet-

lands, wildlife, and species of special concern associ-

ated with Alternative 5 would be the same as those

discussed for Alternative 2.

4.12.6 Alternative No. 6 - Mixed Use 2

Potential impacts to fisheries resources, living marine

resources, vegetation, inland wetlands, tidal wet-

lands, wildlife, and species of special concern associ-

ated with Alternative 6 would be the same as those

discussed for Alternative 2.

4.13 Physical Environment Impacts

The physical environment of the project area includes

topography, surficial geology, and bedrock geology. Po-

tential impacts to the physical environment are com-

mon to all alternatives and are, therefore, evaluated

together.

No dramatic changes are anticipated in topography in

any of the alternatives. Localized regrading is prob-

able on a site-by-site basis to accommodate future

land uses. Placement of fill in flood prone areas may

also be undertaken to raise base elevations or struc-

tures above the 100-year flood elevation. However, ex-

treme modifications to area topography are not

contemplated.

The general erodibility of soils which occur in the pro-

ject area is low. However, site specific sedimentation

and erosion controls will be required as part of any

parcel development or redevelopment.

4.14 Air Quality Impacts

4.14.1 Short-Term Air Quality Impacts

Potential short-term air quality related impacts in the

project area are common to all alternatives and are,

therefore, evaluated together in the ensuing discus-

sion. Historically, the area has been a core of industry,

manufacturing, and shipyard traffic. Thus, potential

short-term air quality degradation would be similar to

or less than that experienced during the peak of in-

dustry in the area.

The primary short-term air quality concerns relate to

construction and demolition activities and their po-

tential to generate fugitive dust and mobile source

emissions. Such sources of dust are attributed to con-

dumping, and bulldozing on any areas cleared for the

development. Meteorological conditions and

the intensity of the activities as well as soil moisture

content also govern the extent to which particles will

become airborne.

Al underlain by soils of a stony nature, much

of den an ban tome Oe Gab Gee over the

years. As a result, soils in the project area would tend

to be composed of smaller particles and since the area

is not well vegetated, wind erosion could become a

source of mobilization of dust. Standard controls can

be implemented to reduce the impact from such fugi-

tive dust emissions as well as the effects of wind ero-

sion. Proper phasing of c

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Joint Appendix Vol III — Kelo v. New London · 545 U.S. 469 | Frix