Joint Appendix — Arizona Free Enterprise Club's Freedom Club PAC v. Bennett
Supreme Court brief2010
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
7 oe
+ JAN 13 2011
an The OPNICE OF THE CLERA
Supreme Court of the United Sates
VRIZONA FREE ENTEREPRISE CLUBS
PRER DOM CLUB PAC. et al
Nos. 10-238, 10-239
\
AN ‘
TORN MCCOMISHE et al
\
KEN BENNERPT. et al
Nespondenis
°
On Writs Of Certiorart bo The United States
Court Of Appeals For The Ninth Cireuit
°
JOINT APPENDIA, VOLUME 1, PAGES 1-460
®
Nik WOiAS C DRANTAS* Mass ROO apy
Gaohoware Rr INsrire be Soliitor General
SCHARP NORTON CENTER bs IOS West Washington
COONSTETU TIONAL Lirica rion Phoenm, AZ Sia?
SOO Fast Coronade Road bel GOOUrSde S888
Phoem, AZ S504 Fan GOS) S42 4085
Pel (O02) Fer SOOO Solmator Generabtacar von
Fax (602) 256. 7045 Counsel for Respondent ts
ndraniaseyotdw aterinstitutle ony Aer Berne 7
Counsel for Petitioners Reamey S Par + LO
Folin MoComush. ef a Munces. Torres & Orson LLP ed Be)
Wrotrase Ro Maunes M95 South Grand Avenus my > m
INSTITUTES PON FOSTIC! Phrarty. Batthy Blower RO z= |
LOL Yesler Way, Suite 008 Los Angeles, CA S007] oO, — mn
Seattle, WAYS TO4 Pel (21S ess 81loo Oz; @ |
Pel (Os) BVT sok ban (Tab One afar 5 ~ <=
Fan (208) G41-9311 Brad Pitbipsetrata: conn VO = mM
Wraurerelil ory ( sisel for Resp rer cm ©
( s 7%, if ‘ ( , \ ' Jo2
\ » J uw Forte Te | . } —E
Bre Cub PAC. « ' .
i} Additional Counsel lasted ln loside Front Cover
Petitions For Writ Of Certiorar: Filed Auggust 17, 2010
Certiorart Granted November 29, 2010
CUINT Bolick
GOLDWATER INSTITUTE
SCHARE NOR DON CENTER BOR
CONSTEDU TIONAL LE biGALION
SOO Fast Coronade Roaud
Phoeniww, AZ SS004
Tel (oor) fer S000
Fan cOOD) 256 7045
Additional Cou MINe i fire Presilianrte rs
John MeComiush, et al
WibtiaM Et MerLtOR
STEVEN M- SIMPSON
INSTITUTE POR TUSTICE
901 North Glebe Road Suite 800
Arlington, VA 22203
Pel (703) BS2-a870
Fan 1 7TOR) OSY URI
wmellorey org
. > . aw. . >
, > , . . . . e
Nddivonai Counsel for Petitioners
Anzona Free Enterprise Clubs Freedom Clab PAC,
PiMorny DO WELLER
Paci VOAVELAK
INSTIPU TE POR PUSTICr
G98 South Mall Avenue, Suite 30)
Tempe, AZ SoS 1
Tel (480) 557-8300
Fan (480) SAT-SROS
thellere?y org
pavelarey org
Additional Counsel for Petitioners
Anizona Free Enterprise Clubs Freedom Club PAC,
’
ee
’
ali
hMiMoTHY A NELSON
Cinet Deputy Attorney General
James EF Bannon I
Assistant Attorneys General
27S West Washinton
Phoenta, AZ S500;
Tel (QOD) O49-833838
Fan (602) S42-4085
Additional Courses for Respondent
Aen Ben mete. ef al
GRANT A] DDAVIS-DENNY
Fiisanrrnd NPunatverk
Muncer, Tottrs & OLSON LIP
355 South Grand Avenue
Tharty-Fitth Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071)
Te! (21S) 683-8 100
Fax. (213) OST-8702
Additional Counsel for Hespomdent
ia) Pe > lect: . B os ete” i
Cican MOOCTIONNS TST, Ine
Monica YOUN
Misty MAgOIANI
Tht BRENNAN CENTER
POR JUSTICE AP NYU
SCHOOT OF LAW
161 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 100138
Tel. (212) 992-8158
Fan (212) 998s 4550
monica vounenvu_ edu
Additional Counsel for Responder:
-_" es
( CAN Rlections Institute. [ry
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
VOLUME 1
Relevant docket entmes United States District
Court, District of Arizona | cade
Relevant docket entries: United States Court of
Appeals tor the Ninth Cireunt 73
“25 factors guiding state polev” Undated....0.0........84
“Clean Money = Clean Elections.” Undated ........ sy
“Clean Money, Clean Elections.” Undated....0000.......98
“Yeah, But...” Undated : M5
“Diticult Questions About Clean Elections,”
Undated . iscatadiah eee ’ 104
“Justification for Clean Elections Matching
Funds.” Undated ................... A
Election Reform Study Committee Final Report,
+L) bt) na Vis vendamamaaibenaads | 111
“Videotapes Show Pavotts.” O2 0S L991 122
“Indictment of Lawmakers Another Blow to
Arizona Etinics.” O02 O98 199) oo ... connpewnacen hae
“Excerpts from indictment tell tale of political
ag ER Rape eee eapeMon, paresis. Se mip AaMs 136
“Civics 101 on Tape in Arizona, Or, ‘We All
Have Our Prices,” 02/11/1991..............................144
“New Tarnish on Arizonas Image Bribe Case
Has State ‘In Shock’ Lawmakers on Video-
tape,” 02/13/1991........... gern sibs paeebnabentaekanee
ll
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
“For Arizona, The Scandals Just Keep on
Coming,” 02 25 1991
“Trying to Repair a Damaged State” 05 TO 1991
“AvScam fallout is far from over, politicians
say, 06-24 1991.
“Survey savs opimons vary on. state ethics.”
I BID denncsvessenseves ictaeiaeaeenareumaneaae |
“Hull rehes on lobbvists she regulates for
funding.” 12 22 1996... |
“Lobbyists bearing gitts solidity gmp on Cap,
tol,” 12/22/1996
“Special interests funnel funas to Key law
es ha oy > 18 | re
“Arivona Ponders Hs High-Otfice Headaches,”
OS 121997
SSCS EES EERE EEE HEE EOE EOE EERE REE!
“Arizona Governor Guilty of Fraud, Forced to
Resign,” Q9 04 1997. Eerie MEASSS AR ee
“Holiday premium on fund-raising.” 12 14 199)
Josh Silver Confidential Memo (Excerpts),
0-406 1998
“GOP drafts lobbyists for help in crucial races.”
OS 20/1998
Arguments For Prop. 200, 11/03 1998 2.
Memorandum of the Citizens Clean Elections
Commission re: doan — Fitz-Randolph,
TRAE i A OMA AN Al ts rae a
Tere eee eee ee eee eee ee ee ee ee ee
CHS SEES HEHEHE EEO HEHEHE HEHEHE E HEH SOS SSH HS HEHEHE TOS ES
in
TABLE OF CONTENTS —- Continued
Page
Recommended Decision of ALJ re: Joan Fite-
Randolph, 10 31 2000... (ease ndedauecerbaguiendcummoscageec: 238
“Bush to Stump for Fellow Republicans in
Arizona,” 09/26/2002 o..........ccccccccccccosecececes. ineonencaiiel
Executive Summary Report by CEL, 12.01 2002... 246
Declaration of Dean Martin, 02 162004... 987
Declaration of Chris Bowen (Excerpts),
02/18/2004 ..... ian hdinn bmnnk taaihileedetipiponiadmintbincakanuncaken sack 2S4
Declaration of Matt Salmon, 02:18 2004... 286
“More Dirt on Clean Elections,” 07 29 2004.00. 293
“Clean up the Act,” 08/22/2004... 24
“Losing Candidate Probed Over Signatures to
Qualify for Public Funding,” 09/10 2004.00.00. 298
“Clean Elections Panel Backs Extra Funds for
Close Races,” 09/15/2004 .............cccc0000000-0.. clic 300
Reforming a reform,” 12/02/2004... 302
“Clean Elections Commission not so clean?”.
I eee oe vo Te Pe ie 0S
Advertisement by Citizens Clean Elections
Commission (text only), 09/25/2005 000 308
Awareness and Attitude Study (Jan. 2006)
eran, GEO ono cscs 309
Citizens Clean Elections Commission Op-Ed,
ch i eR ese et MRI Rh bl, SPST TLE, OAS 319
“Catalog in Clean Election sights,” 07/11/2006... 322
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS -—- Continued
Page
“What happens when you run afoul of the
gg ide ae es Pe 8 eee 325
“The problem with ‘Clean Elections’ commis-
ge. EIS ERERR RR ss Alf Poel PRD Rh Se 330
Declaration of Chad “arkpatrick in Support of
Amended Complaint, 11/20/2007... 332
Declaration of Dean Martin in Support of
Amended Complaint, 11’26/2007.........0....0........... 336
“Money and Politics: The Good, The Bad, And
re I ae casiivnenahians wrnespreasiavaatevecnecens 341
Michael Miller, Gaming Arizona: Public Money
and Shifting Candidate Strategies, 41 PS:
Political Science & Politics 527 (Jul. 2008),
III Gita achiphasuicosintiaadusscutistheideenadbenesaimiddakelieenante 357
Press Release: Equality Arizona, 08/07/2008 ..........382
2008 Pre-Primary Election Report (Excerpts),
TIEN Lincs ctsetexkadeas ccgudsersuusdvcinshemlemimcmncunaensunths 354
Declaration of David Schapira, 08/28/2008 0.0.00... 386
Declaration of Rick Murphy in Support of
Motion to Intervene, 08'29/2008 . 00000... 389
Plaintiff-Intervenor Murphy's Response to De-
fendants’ and Defendant-Intervenors’ Inter-
rogatories and Document Requests, 09/09/2008 ....393
Excerpts from the Deposition of John MceComish,
PEIN i conedcsseraisiesicuniedceimcasnicienbeludieamndnnetonncaeona 403
Excerpts from the Deposition of Richard A.
I SI Ics a coc souipnavs sacewiganieoenteakoruaboin 406
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
Excerpts from the Deposition of Nancy McLain,
SPIED sccucsnsncotecsuseeeionesnseunmmeencebinddamebsesrensicn
Excerpts from the Deposition of Shane Wikfors,
SIE iorencnnsiansthecsinenniordsncistepeadusieianpetiniacariinicienace:
Declaration of Ed Ableser in Support of De-
fendants’ Response in Opposition to Plain-
tiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Motions for
Preliminary Injunction, 09/17/2008 ..................
Excerpts from the Deposition of Robert Burns,
Io aivcalcaicubatedias tudes diduasaienbbdaddndaedntedcniioinadeds
Declaration of Tammie Pursley in Support of
Defendants’ Response in Opposition to Plain-
tiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Motions for
Preliminary Injunction, 09/17/2008 ..................
Excerpts from the Deposition of Todd Lang,
EEF eR retre ONE A Re NO AEA a a mee
Plaintiff-Intervenor Burns’ Responses to Defen-
dants’ and Defendant-Intervenors’ Interroga-
tories and Document Requests (Excerpts),
TEE oisinithdsvsicadsdwusias dertnsaniaiaviatiidmeubeiamidions
VOLUME 2
Excerpts from the Deposition of Marcus B.
Osborn, Ph.D., 09/19/2008 .................ccccccccsceceess
Declaration of Pamela Durbin in Support of
Defendants’ Response in Opposition to Plain-
tiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Motions for
Preliminary Injunction, 09/19/2008 ..................
...426
vil
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
CCEC Disbursement Summary, 09/22/2008 ........
Exhibit 2 to the Declaration of Dr. Kenneth R.
I acl enlnines
Declaration of Meg Burton Cahill in Support
of Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elections
Institute, Inc.’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ and
Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Motions for a _ Pre-
liminary Injunction, 09/23/2008 ........................
2008 Post-Primary Election Report (Excerpts),
II sisdcnsssiidcinnniddeniencninaisnesssstniisamiamnmeesinnes
Picture: “Help Them to Support Illegals,”
SEITE csicosiccsascisiehosatidensesspsaieniniiaaeiiaonsminbeniees
Declaration of Maria Weeg, 10/24/2008................
Victory 2008 Memorandum of Law (Excerpts),
IIE 34 suchtissabineuicbitccsanliunidininieindeinaneneimnianhioniies
Victory 2008 Verified Complaint (Excerpts),
10/24/2008 .................... ee ee
Declaration of William G. Whitaker, 10/24/2008 ....
Victory 2008 Oral Argument Transcript (Ex-
i IIIT side shihictictasanicidesinuniictinunciniatuncioiiness
Picture: “Supports Giving Illegal Aliens In-
State Tuition,” UL/OB/BOOG .........cccresseccsesesscovcosees
Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Responses to Defendants’
and Defendant-Intervenor’s First Set of In-
terrogatories and Requests for Production,
IE kadicseviserscesssissisdnarininescienseniiommeinen
... 040
045
047
048
TABLE OF CONTENTS | Continued
Excerpts from the Deposition of Dean Martin,
IT 5200p. conus paimencinthogudeinien:
Excerpts from the Deposition of Chad WKirkpat-
“i NER ee ae eee eee
Excerpts from the Deposition of J. Fite Svwm-
ineton, HL, 02°04 2009 .............
Excerpts from the Deposition of Constantin
Querard, 02 12 2009 |
Excerpts from the Deposition of Russell
Smolden, 02 17 2009...
Excerpts from the Fed. R. Civ. Po 30.66) Depo-
sition of Designee Damiel Ruiz, I], 02 19 2009
Exeerpts trom the Depostiion of David Lujan,
0219/2009 ..........
Excerpts trom the Deposition of Basilio Aja,
02/20/2008 .....
Excerpts from the Fed. R. Civ. P. ep bio) Depo-
jos
sition of Designee Colleen MeGee, 02 235 2009
Excerpts from the Deposition of Lom Damiets,
EEE IE Pa ea en me a :
Cruvens Clean Elections Commission, ZOOS An-
nual Report (Excerpts), 02 26 2009 ....0......... |
Excerpts from the Deposition of Stephen dames
Gy MN PIPE vices skies ccaccesccctsccdeiessussses
663
Vill
TABLE OF CONTENTS Continued
PlaintiY-Intervenors’ Responses and Objections
to Defendants’ First Request tor Admissions
and Second Request tor Production (Ex-
cerpts), 0227 20089 ..
~~ =~ ¢
NCCLS Overview: State Limits on Contributions
to Candidates, 03 02 2009
Participating Primary Winner Candidates for
the 2008S General Election, 03 05 2009
Excerpts trom the Deposition of Louis J. Hoffman,
03 06 Zoos
Piaintft-Intervenor Dean Martin's Supplementa:
Response to Defendants’ Request tor Clarthi
cation, O38 12 2009
“The Dirty Truth About Arvona Campaign
Finance Reform’ «Excerpt), 03 31 2009
VOLUME 8
Expert Report of Donald Po Green (Excerpts),
0413 2009 |
List of All Candidate Committees fer the 2006
General Election Cvele, 04 14 2009.
Excerpts trom the Deposition of Dr. Donald P.
Green, 0S OS 2OdY9
Declaration of Dennis Shane Wiktors on Behall
oft PlainutY-Intervenor Arizona Tanxpavers
Action Committee in Support of Motion tor
Summary dudgment, 05/07 2009 ooo.
Page
ak
TABLE OF CONTENTS | Continued
Declaration et Steven Voeller en Behalt of
Plainatt-Intervenor Arizona Free Enterprise
Club's Freedom PAC In Support of Motion tor
Summary dudgment, 05 09 2009 .
Excerpts from the Deposition of Kenneth R
Maver, Ph D., 05 12 2009.
Declaration of Plaintitt-Intervenor Robert Burns
in Suppert of Motion for Summarv Judg.
ment, OS 19 VOOsS.
Declaration of David M. Prime, Ph.D in Sup-
port of Plainaff-Intervenors’ Motion tor Sum-
marv dudgment, 05 26 2009
Plaintut-Intervenors’ Chart of “Level the Play
ing Field” andor “Limit Spending” Reter-
ences, OG 12 2009 ....
Detendants and Detendant-Intervener’s dont
Statement of Undisputed Facts. O68 12 2009
Declaration of Donald Green in) Suppert of
Detendant-Intervenor Clean Elections Insti-
tute, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgment
LExcerpts), O68 12 2009
Plauntu® Intervenors’ Statement of Material
Facts in Support of Motion for Summary
Judgment, OG 12 2009...
Plaintitts’ Summarv Table ot Documents (Ex-
cerpts), 0G 18 2009
Page
is
Say
Sob
e.g
4@
TABLE OF CONTENTS | Continued
Page
VOLUME 4
Exhibit 10 te the Declaration of JetYrey Ober,
OF 14 2009 | | oer SYD
Exhibit C to the Declaration of Todd Lang: Pri.
marv Funding Overview Report, 07 1a 2009 Y138
Declaration of Joshua Lo Heath in Support of
Plantiut-Intervenors Response to Motion ter
Summary dudgment by Clean Elections, Ine..
07/16/2008 ............ | iaeila 914
Declaration of David M. Primo, PhD). in Sup
port of the Plantuff-Intervenors’ Response to
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Fleectrons Inst:
tute. Inc’s Motion tor Summary Judgment.
OF Le 2009 | , 919
Defendants’ and Detendant-Intervenor’s Jot
Response to Plaintifts’ Separate Statement ot
Facts (Excerpts), O7 17 2009 824
Declaration of Donald Green im Support of
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elections In
stitute, Inc's Opposition to Plaintitts ana
Plaintitintervenors’ Motion for Summary
Judgment (Excerpts), O7 17 2009 000 0. Y39
Plaintitt-Intervenors’ Response to Detendants’
and Detendant-Intervenor’s Joint Statement
of Undisputed Facts (Excerpts), 07 17 2009 980
Nl
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
Pare
Plaintitls’ Response to Detendants Defendant
Intervenor’s doint Statement of Facts and
Statement of Facts in Opposition to Defendants
Detendant-Intervenor’s Motions tor Sum.
marv dudgment (excerpts! Q7 17 2009 YOS
Declaration of Todd FO Lang in) Support of
Defendants’ Response to PlarntitYs’ and
Piaintltt-Intervenors’ Motions for Summary
Judgment, OF 17 2009 wee
The following ttems were filed in the US Court of
Appeals tor the Ninth Cireurt
Declaration of State Senator Jack Harper in
Support of Motion to Vacate Stav and in
Opposition to Entry of Appellate Stay,
OL 26 2010 | ) ass
‘
Declaration ot dohn Munger im Suppert ot
Motion to Vacate Stay and in Opposition to
Entry of Appellate Stay, OL 26 2010 Vs
The following items were tiled in the US) Supreme
Court
Declaration of Herbert Coleman in Support of
Plarnttts’ Emergency Appheation to Vacate
Stay Before the Hon. Justice Anthony M
Kennedy, 02 082010... ........ QOS
Declaration of Tom Horne in Support of Plain
tiffs’ Renewed Emergency Appheation to Va
eate Stay Before the Hon) Justice Anthony
M. Kennedy, 05 21 2070 a | LOS
Nil
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
Page
Declaration of Dusti Leeann Morris in Support
of Plainutts Appellees’ Motion tor Stay ot
Mandate Pending Petition tor Certierar,
OH US LOTO | Loads
Declaration of Erie Ulis in Support of Plain
uffs Appellees’ Motion for Stav ot Mandate
Pending Petitien for Certrorar:, 06 03 2010 1O13
Declaration ot John Munger in Support of
Plaintiffs Appelees’ Motion tor Stay of
Mandate Pending Petition for Certiorari,
OG OS ZOLO | LOLS
Declaration of Michael Blarre in Support ef
Plaintitts Appellees’ Motion) tor Stay of
Mandate Pending Petiuion ter Certiorari,
OG OS LOLO | 1022
The tollowine tlems were reproduced in the Appen-
} Yt
dices to the Petiovens tor Writ of Certiorar and are
net reproduced herein
Deciaration of Chad Kirkpatrick,
11 20 2007... 10 Las Cert App. Los
US. Dhastrict Court tor the Distriet of Arizona
Order, OS 20 2008 |. 10-238 Cert. App. 119
10-239 Cert. App. 120
Declaration of Robert Burns,
OS LO 2008 LO-23S8S Cert. App. td4
Selections from Sept. 156, 2008S Deposition of
Plaintit? Nanev MeLain 10-2389 Cert. App. 190
Nah
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Pare
Selections trom Sept. 18, 2008 Deposition of Corpo
ration Commission Candidate Paul Bo Newman
vomaitting exhibits | and 2). 10-239 Cert. App. 19s
US.) Distret Court for the District of Arvona
Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law,
LQ 17 2008 : 10-238 Cert. App. 90
LO-239 Cert. App. 92
Excerpts trom the Deposition Transcript of
Stephen James Voeller Gaken on February
26, 2009) | e rede. 10-238 Cert. App. 162
Declaration of Plaintitt-Intervenor Dean Mar-
tin aim Support of Motion tor Summary
Judgment, 0S 06 2OO9 LO VSs Cert. App. 150
Declaration of Plaintitt intervenor Rick Mur
phy ino Support of Motion tor Summary
Judgment, 0S 19 2009 10-238 Cert. App. 165
Declaration of Phauntu? Tony Bowie in Support of
Plantitts’ Motien for Summary Judgment (omit
ting exhibits), OG OD 2009 10-289 Cert. App. 304
Declaration of Plaintut?® John MeComish in
Support of Vlaintitts’ Motion for Summary
Judgment (omitting exhibits 1 and 4),
06/09/2008 2.0... cccceessssesesssseseens AO COORG, A, ee
Declaration of Plaintits’ Expert Dr Marcus
Osborn (omitting Exhibits | through 14),
OG/ 11/2008... cee ceseceeseseenese MOM OD RACER, ORRIN Geman
NIN
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
Page
Declaration of Law Intern detfrey Ober in Oppost
tion to Defendants Defendant-Intervenor’s Mo-
tions for Summary — (omitting exhibits
1 through 10), O7 1420092000000. 10-289 Cert. App. 277
Rebuttal Declaration of Tony Bowe in Support
of PlanntitffYs’ Motion for Summary Judgment,
07/24/2009 ..............0000 Scceeeeeee 10-239 Cert. App. 298
U.S. District Court tor the Distmet of Arizona
Order, O1/20/2010...................... 10-238 Cert. App. 45
10-2389 Cert. App. 47
Rebuttal Declaration of Plaintit? Tony Bowie in
Support ot Second Motion tor Preliminary
Injunction, OL 20 2010... . LO-239 Cert. App. 295
Judgment Entered by the U.S. District Court
for the District of Anvona in Favor of Plain-
tiffs, entered Jan. 21, 2010.......10-239 Cert. App.
Us. Court of Appeals tor the Ninth Cireuit
Order, 01/29/2010................... 10-238 Cert. App. 87
Lats insadshinseess seessssesersssesecessssss Ae Cert. App. 90
US. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cireun
Order, O20) 2010..000000.00.......... 10-288 Cert App. 80
aatieke SM RaIMINaCadesvesensssensesvsess BOP Oe Cette. App. 84
Order of the U.S. Supreme Court denving
Emergency Appheation to Vacate Stay,
a) |) | on 10-239 Cert. App. 83
Judgment Entered by the US. Court) of
Appeals tor the Ninth Circuit, entered May
| ee Ut NRE p a ea 10-259 Cert. App. 1
\V
TABLE OF CONTENTS — Continued
Page
Order of the US. Supreme Court denying
Renewed Emergeney Application to Vacate
Stay, filed June 1, 2010.00.00... 10-239 Cert. App. 82
US. Supreme Court Order Granting Joint
Second Renewed Emergency Application to
Vacate Stay, OG 08 BOLO... 10-238 Cert. App. 79
Sounehiemsaiaidsaspatubaasti@ins Lecassseresecessses AOSaR Cert. App. 81
Excerpts trom Transcript of Proceedings betore
Arizona Citizens Clean Elections Commis
sion on June 9, 2010 200... 10-239 Cert. App. 182
Us. Court of Appeals tor the Ninth Cir-
eu Order and Amended Opinion,
06/23/2010............ ascinounddabhishneiaas 10-238 Cert. App. 1
Satu Sear dale shi Tey
U.S. Const. Amend. I.................. 10-238 Cert. App. 132
shel ecnaiialals 10-239 Cert. App. 134
US. Const. Amend. XIV. 10-238 Cert. App. 132
ia eal a i a aaa ae 10-239 Cert. App. 134
42 U.S.C. §$ 1988 ........... NO eae 10-238 Cert. App. 153
iecaetekiea deducted inielieiintsnmbinkentidenat 10-239 Cert. App. 137
Arivona Citizens Clean Elections Act, Anz. Rev.
Stat. § 16-940 et seq... 10-2388 Cert. App. 1
elabededsaindiiehnrisiaenteaameceia 10-239 Cert. App. 138
U.S. District Court
DISTRICT OF ARIZONA (Phoenix Division)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 2:08-cv-01550-ROS
MecComish et al v. Brewer et al
Date Filed # Docket Text
OS'2L2008 1 COMPLAINT. Filing fee received:
$ 350.00, receipt number PHX074822,
filed by Doug’ Sposito, John
McComish, Naney MeLain, Kevin
Gibbons, Frank Antenori, Tony
Bouie..MHA) (Entered: 08/22/2008)
08212008 This case has been assigned to the
Honorable Roslyn O. Silver. All
future pleadings or documents
should bear the correct case number:
CV-08-1550-PHX-ROS. This is a
TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no
PDF document associated with this
entry. (MHA) (Entered: 08/22/2008)
OS’262008 10 ORDER —- IT IS ORDERED Plain-
tiffs’ Motion for a Temporary Re-
straining Order shall be filed with
the Court and Defendants notified
by 5:00 p.m., August 26, 2008. IT IS
FURTHER ORDERED Defendants
shall file a response by 8:00 a.m.,
August 28, 2008. IT IS FURTHER
ORDERED a hearing on Plaintiffs
Temporary Restraining Ordershall
be held at 3:00pm, August 28, 2008
before Judge Roslyn QO. Silver.
»
Signed by Judge Roslyn O Silver on
8/26/08. (CLB) (Entered: 08/26/2008)
08262008 13 First MOTION for Temporary Re-
straining Order by Doug Sposito,
John McComish, Nancy McLain,
Kevin Gibbons, Frank Antenori,
Tony Bouie. (Attachments: # 1 Ap-
pendix Table of Contents to Exhibits,
# 2 Affidavit Declaration of Gibbons,
# 3 Exhibit Gibbons Ex. A.l, # 4
Affidavit Boure, # 5 Exhibit Bouie
Ex. B.1, # 6 Exhibit Boule Ex.B.2, #
7 Affidavit Sposito, # 8 Errata
Sposito Ex. C.1, # 9 Exhibit Sposito
Exhibit C.2, # 10 Exhibit Sposito Ex.
C.3, # 11 Text of Proposed Or-
der\ Bolick, Clint) (Entered:
08/26/2008)
08262008 14 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 13 First MOTION for
Temporary Restraining Order
Spostto Aff., Ex.C.l by Plaintiffs
Doug Sposito, John McComish,
Nancy McLain, Kevin’ Gibbons,
Frank Antenori, Tony Bouie. (Bolick,
Clint) (Entered: 08/26/2008)
O8’26/2008 15 NOTICE of Hearing on Motion 13
First MOTION for Temporary Re-
straining Order :Motion Hearing set
for 8/28/2008 at 03:00PM _ before
Judge Roslyn O Silver filed by John
McComish, Nancy MeLain, Kevin
Gibbons, Frank Antenori, Tony
Bouie, and Doug Sposito. (Bolick,
08/26/2008
DRA
0 OOS
ios)
by
oP)
ty
08/27/2008
16
17
19
3
Clint) Modified on 8/27/2008 (TLJ).
DOCKET TEXT MODIFIED TO
IDENTIFY FILERS. (Entered:
08/26/2008)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 13 First MOTION for
Temporary Restraining Order Dec-
laration of Andrea Woodmansee
by Plaintiffs Doug Sposito, John
McComish, Naney McLain, Kevin
Gibbons, Frank Antenori, Tony
Bouie. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit
Woodmansee Ex. D.1, # 2 Exhibit
Woodmansee Ex. D.2)(Bolick, Clint)
(Entered: 08/26/2008)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 13 First MOTION for
Temporary Restraining Order Dranias
Declaration by Plaintiffs Doug
Sposito, John McComish, Nancy
McLain, Kevin Gibbons, Frank
Antenori, Tony Bouie. (Attachments:
# 1 Exhibit Dramias Aff., Ex. E.1, # 2
Exhibit Dranias Aff., Ex. E.2, # 3
Exhibit Dranias Ex. E.3\Bolick,
Clint) (Entered: 08/26/2008)
Notice re of Filing Motion to Trans-
fer and Consolidate by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit A)\O’Grady, Mary) (Entered:
08/27/2008)
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
ty
i)
24
Si
1
26
+
Notice re Notice of Filing of Objec-
tion and Alternative Response to
Motion to Transfer and Consolidate
in Martin v. Brewer, 04-cv-0200
by Doug Sposito, John McComish,
Nancy McLain, Kevin Gibbons,
Frank Antenori, Tony Bouie (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 08/28/2008)
RESPONSE to Motion re 13 First
MOTION for Temporary Restraining
Order filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (O’Grady, Mary)
(Entered: 08/28/2008)
DECLARATION of Declaration of
Tanja Shipman re 23 Response to
Motion for Temporary Restraining
Order by Defendants Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit)(O’Grady, Mary) (Entered:
08/28/2008)
DECLARATION of Jackie Thrasher
re 23 Response to Motion for Tempo-
rary Restraining Order by Defen-
dants Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels.
(O’Grady, Mary) (Entered: 08/28/2008)
DECLARATION of Kara Kelty re 23
Response to Motion for Temporary
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
08/28/2008
08/29/2008
27
29
30
)
Restraining Order by Defendants
Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels.
(O’Grady, Mary) (Entered: 08/28/2008)
DECLARATION of John Valdez re
23 Response to Motion for Tempo-
rary Restraining Order by Defend-
ants Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels.
(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)(O’Grady,
Mary) (Entered: 08/28/2008)
DECLARATION of Todd Lang re 23
Response to Motion for Temporary
Restraining Order by Defendants
Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels.
(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)O’Grady,
Mary) (Entered: 08/28/2008)
Minute Entry. Proceedings held
before Judge Roslyn O Silver: Tem-
porary Restraining Hearing held on
8/28/2008. Matter is taken under
advisement. Order to issue. (Court
Reporter Liz Lemke.(CLB) (En-
tered: 08/28/2008)
ORDER denying 13 Motion for a
Temporary Restraining Order. IT IS
FURTHER ORDERED a hearing
will be held on September 3, 2008,
1:30 p.m. to determine whether a
O98 OL PODS
OY OLDS
OY OL VOUS
Sl
On
dO
.
wo
preliminary injunction should = be
granted or, should the parties decide
that discovery is necessary, the
preliminary injunction hearing will
be continued and a status hearing
will be held in its place. Signed
by Judge Roslyn © Silver) on
S29 08.CLB) (Entered: 08 29 2008)
First MOTION to Irtervene as
Plaintiis by Dean Martin, Robert
Burns. Rick Murphy. Arizona Free
Enterprise Club's Freedom Club
PAC, Arizona Taxpayers Action
Committee. (Attachments: # 1 Text
of Proposed Order granting motion
to intervene as plaintiffs, # 2 Exhibit
Exhibits <A-D\Keller. Nimothyv)
(Entered: OY O1 2008)
LODGED Proposed Proposed Com-
plaint In Intervention re: 31 First
MOTION to Imervene as Plarntrfs.
Document to be filed by Clerk if
Motion to Leave to File er Amend ts
granted. Filed by Dean Martin.
Robert Burns. Rick Murphy. Arizona
Free Enterprise Clubs Freedom
Club PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Committee. (Attachments: # 1 Ex-
hibit Exhilits A-C\Keller. Timothy)
(Entered: 09 01 2008)
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction
by Robert Burns. Rick Murphy.
Arizona Free Enterprse Ciub’s
Freedom Club PAC. (Attachments:
O89 22008
09 U2 2008
OY 02 VOOsS
O98 02 Vods
09 022008
o4
36
o7
ou
# 1 Text of Proposed Order granting
preliminary injunction, #2 Exhibit
Exhibits A-E\ Keller, Thmothy) (En-
tered: 09 01 2008)
ORDER denving 33 Motion for Pre-
liminary Injunction. Signed — by
Judge Roslyn O Silver on 9208.
DMT.) (Entered: 09 02 2008)
RESPONSF to Motion re 31 First
MOTION to Intervene as Plaintifts
fled by dan Brewer. Garv
Scaramazzo, Rovann J Parker, Jet-
frey L. Fairman, Donald Lindholm.
Lon S) Daniels. (O'Grady. Marv)
(Entered: 09 02 2008)
MOTION tor Preliminary Injunction
by Robert Burns. Rick Murphy. Arizo-
a= 6 Taxpavers) Action Committee
(\Atachments: # 1 Text of Proposed
Order granting preliminary injune-
tion, # 2 Exhitit Exhibits A-E\ Keller,
Timothy) (Entered: 09 02 2008)
REPLY in Support re 31 First MO-
TION to fears ene as Plaintiffs tiled
by Dean Martin, Robert Burns, Rick
Murphy, Arvona Free Enterprise
Club’s Freedom Club PAC. Arizona
Taxpayers Action Committee. (At-
tachments: # 1 Exhibit Attchment
Declarations \ Keller. Thmothy) (En-
tered: O9 02 2008)
First MOTION for Preliminary In-
yanction filed dv Original Plainirt}s
U8 2200S
O98 V2 2008
O9 OL VOUS
s
by Doug Sposite, dohn MeComush,
Nancy MeLain, Kevin Gibbons,
Frank Antenonm, Tony Bome. (At-
tachments: # 1 Appendix Index to
Exhibits, # 2 Atidavit Dramas Supp.
Declaration, * 3 Affidavit MeComuish
Declaration, # 4 Affidavit McLain
Declaration, # 5 AMdavit Gibbons
Supplemental Declaration, # 6
Affidavit Bowie Supplemental Decla-
ration, # 7 Affidavit Sposito Supple-
mental Declaration, #8 Text of
Proposed Order Proposed Order for
Preliminary Injunction \ Drantias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 09 02 2008)
NOTICE of Hearing on Motion 43
First MOTION tor rapeye-” arv In-
junetion filed bv Original Plaintz¥s
“Motion Hearing set ter 93 2O00S at
01:30 PM in Courtroom 604, 401
West Washington Street. Phoenix,
AZ Sd003 before Judge Rosivn O
Silver. (Dranias. Nicholas) (Entered:
09 02 ZOOS)
MOTION to Intervene by Clean Elee-
tions Institute. Inc.. (Attachments
# 1 (Proposed) Order\ Neubauer,
Elisabeth) (Entered: 09 02 2008)
REQUEST re: Request for Judicial
Notice i7 Supt port of Motion to Inter
vene by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Flections Institute, Inc. (Neubauer.
Elisabeth) (Entered: 09 02 2008)
a
OPUS 2S 4S) Notice re of Detendants’ Proposed
Preliminary Injunction Brneting and
Lhiscovery Schedule by dan Brewer,
Clean Elections Institute. Inc. Gary
Scaramaz7o, Rovann J Parker,
Jettrey L. Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Lori S Damiels (Grady,
Mary) (Entered: 09 03 2008)
OPUS DAS AY DECLARATION of Declaration re 37
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction
Declaration of Dennis Shane Wikfors
by Intervenor Parties Dean Martin,
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy, Anvona
Free Enterprise Club's Freedom
Club PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Actien
Committee. (Reller. Timothy) (En
tered: 09 03 2008) .
OMUSVAIS 52 Minute Entry. Proceedings held
before Judge Roslvn O Silver: This ts
the time set for a Preliminary In
jyunction Hearing. Hearing is vacated
and Status Hearing is held. IT IS
ORDERED granting the Motion to
Intervene bw Clean Elections Insti-
tute, Inc. {doc. 45). Order to issue. IT
IS FURTHER ORDERED taking
under advisement the Motion to
Intervene by Dean Martin. Robert
Burns, Rick Murphy. Arizona Free
Enterprse Clabs Freedom Club
PAC, Arivona’ Taxpavers Action
Committee (doc. 31). (Court Reporter
Elaine Cropper \CLB) (Entered
U9 OS ZOOS)
OY AR VOUS
09 U3 2OOS
09-03 Loads
08 O38 VOUS
OS OL LOdS
mr
~)
= .
or
ay
ob
10
ORDER granting 45 Motion to
Intervene CEI shall bepermitted to
intervene as ai defendant in this
action... Signed by Judge Rosivn O
Silver on 9S 08. DMT, ) (Entered:
OM OS ZOOS)
ORDER granting 31° Motion to
Intervene. All intervenors shal! be
allowed to intervene as PlaintitYs.
Parties shall submit a case man
agement plan and, aif necessary,
request a status hearing by 9:00
am. Friday, Sep. 5, 2008.) Signed
by dudge Rosivn O | Silver on
8 SO0S.DMTP) Entered: 09 08 2008)
COMPLAINT IN| INTERVENTION
filed by Dean Martin, Robert Burns,
Rick Murphy, Anzona Free Enter-
prise Club’s Freedom Club PAC,
Anvzona Taxpavers Action Commit-
tee against defendants, DMT, )
\Fntered: 0905 2008)
Additonal Attachments to Main
Document ore 58 Complaint by
Intervenor Plaintiffs being exhibits
(DMT, ) (Entered: 09 08 2008)
AMENDED COMPLAINT dy Orcgr-
nai Plaing: Ps against dan Brewer,
Clean Elections Institute, Inc.. Gary
Searamazzo, Rovann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fauwman, Donald Lindholm,
Lom S Damets, filed by Kirk Adams,
Doug Spostte. John MeComiush,
11
Nancy MeLain, Kevin Gibbons.
Frank Antenon, Tony Bowe Dramias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 09 04 2008)
QVusVOdS Sl ORDER Preliminary | Injunction
Hearing set as to 37 MOTION tor
Preliminary Injunction, 43° First
MOTION tor Preliminary Injunction:
Motion Hearing set for 109 2008 at
OS00AM before Judge Roslvn O
Silver. The deadline for depositions
shall be Friday, September 26, 2008.
See PDF document for preliminary
imunction brefing schedule. The
parties shall submit) a proposed
hearing schedule by Monday, Octo-
ber 5, 2008. Signed by Judge Roslyn
OM Silver on 99YOS (LSP) (Entered
U9 OY ZOOS)
OF Og LVONS SS ORDER that a Preliminary Injunce-
tion Hearing is set for 109 2008 at
O9:00 AM before Judge Rosivn O
Silver. See attached pdf for full
details and deadhnes. Signed by
Judge Rosivn O Silver on 09 09 0S
(ESL, ) (Entered: 08 09 2008)
OP 102008) SY TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings — re
Temporary Restraining Order Hear
ing held on S2SOS before Judge
Roslyn © | Silver. Court) Reporter
Elizabeth A Lemke Transcript may
be viewed at the court pubhe term:
nailer purchased through the Court
Reporter Transcriber before the dead-
line for Release of Transcript
O9 LA VOUS
OILS ZOOS
~ ~~
0923 2S
115
120
21
12
Restriction. After that date it may be
obtained through PACER. Redaction
Request due 1012008. Redacted
Transcript Deadline set tor
10142008) Release of Transeript
Restriction set for 12.9 2008. (BAS, }
(Entered: 09.10 2008)
TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings — re:
Preliminary Injunction and Status
Hearing held on 93.08 betore Judge
Rosivn © Silver. Court Reporter:
Elaine Cropper. Transcript may be
viewed at tie court public terminal
or purchased through the Court
Reporter Transcriber before the
deadline for Release of Transcript
Restriction. After that date it may be
obtained through PACER. Redaction
Request due 10/14 2008. Redacted
Transcript Deadline set for
10-24 2008) Release of Transcript
Restriction set for 12 22/2008. (BAS.)
(Entered: 09 23 2008)
,”
RESPONSE in Opposition re 37
MOTION tor Preliminary Injunction,
43° First MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Original Plain.
tiffs tiled by Clean Elections Insti
tute, Inc. (Davis Denny. Grant)
(Entered: 09°23 2008)
DECLARATION of Declaration of
Meg Burton Cahill in) Support. of
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elee-
tions Institute, Ine.’s Opposition te
13
Plaintiffs’ and Plaintif!-Intervenors’
Motions for Preliminary Injuction re
120 Response in Opposition to Motion
by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Inc. filed by Clean
Elections Institute, Ine. (Davis-
Denny, Grant) (Entered: 09 23 2008)
OYL3SVOOS 122 DECLARATION of Grant A. Davis-
Denny in Support of Detendant-
Intervenor Clean Elections Institute,
Inc’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ and
Plaintift-Intervenors’ Motions for a
Preliminary Injunction re 120 Re-
sponse in Opposition to Motion by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Eiec-
tions Institute, Inc. filed by Clean
Elections Institute, Inc... (Attach-
ments: # 1 Exhibit A. # 2 Exhibit B,
# 3 Exhibit C. # 4 Exhibit D, # 5
Exhibit BE. #6 Exhibit FL # 7 Exhobit
G, # S&S Exhibit H. # 9 Extubit 1,
# 10 Exhiint J\Davis-Denny. Grant!
(Entered: 09 23 2008)
OOVSVOOS 123 Additional Attachments to Main
Document — re 22 Declaration,,
Exhibit A to Declaration of Grant A
Daris-Dennyv in Support of Defendant
Intervenor Clean Elections Institute,
Inc.’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ and
Plaintiff Intervenors’ Motions for Pre-
liminary Injunction by Intervenor
Defendant Clean Elections Institute,
Inc... (Davis-Denny, Grant) (Entered:
09 23 2008)
0923 2008
09 23 2008
O93 2008
124
126
144
RESPONSE to Motion re 837 MOTION
for Preliminary Injunction filed by
Jan Brewer, Garv Scaramazzo,
Rovann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels.
(Shipman, Tanja) (Entered:
09 23/2008)
DECLARATION of ‘Tanja K. Ship-
man in Support of re 124 Response
(Opposition) to Motion for Prelimi-
nary Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royvann J Parker.
Jeffrey L. Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lorin S Damiels. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit Exhib-
it 2, #3 Exhibit Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhib-
it Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit Exhibit 5, #
6 Exhibit Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit
Exhibit 7. # S Exhibit” Exhibit
SkShipman, Tanja) Modified on
9242008 INCORRECT EVENT
SELECTED. THIS ENTRY IAS
BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Affidavit)
TO (Declaration) DOCKET TEXT
MODIFIED FOR DOCUMENT
LINKAGE (KMG). (Entered:
09/23/2008)
DELARATION of Todd FO Lang in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION. for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royvann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lom S Daniels. (Attachments: # 1
0923/2008
0923 2008
127
128
15
Exhibit Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit Exhib-
it 2\Shipman, Tanja) Modified on
9/24/2008 INCORRECT EVENT
SELECTE. THIS ENTRY HAS
BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Affidavit)
TO (Declaration). DOCKET TEXT
MODIFIED FOR CORRECT DOC-
UMENT LINKAGE (KMG). (En-
tered: 09/23/2008)
DECLARATION of Daniel Patterson
in Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Donald Lindholm.
(Shipman, Tanja) Modified = on
9242008 INCORRECT EVENT
SELECTED. THIS ENTRY HAS
BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Affidavit)
TO (Declaration). DOCKET TEXT
MODIFIED FOR CORRECT DOC
UMENT LINKAGE (KMG). (En-
tered: 09/23/2008)
DECLARATION of Paula Forster in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lon S Damels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24°2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (At-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEAT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
16
DOCUMENT LINKAGE (KMGQG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09232008 129 DECLARATION of Kathy Romano in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J _ Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
DOCUMENT LINKAGE (KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09'23/2008 130 DECLARATION OF MATT HEINZ
in Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Rovann J _ Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
DOCUMENT LINKAGE (KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09232008 1383 DECLARATION of Dr. Kenneth R.
Maver in Support of 124 Response
(Opposition) to MOTION for Prelim.-
nary Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
09/23/2008 134
09/23/2008 135
17
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit Ex-
hibit 2, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit 3\(Ship-
man, Tanja) Modified on 9/24/2008
INCORRECT EVENT SELECTED.
THIS ENTRY HAS BEEN MODI-
FIED FROM (Affidavit) TO (Decla-
ration). DOCKET TEXT MODIFIED
FOR CORRECT DOCUMENT LINK-
AGE (KMG, ). (Entered: 09/23/2008)
DECLARATION of Tammie Pursley
in Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J _ Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
DOCUMENT LINKAGE (KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
DECLARATION of David Schapira
in Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker, Jeffrey
L Fairman, Donald Lindholm, Lori S
Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja) Modified
09/23/2008 136
09/23/2008 137
18
on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT EVENT
SELECTED. THIS ENTRY HAS
BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Affidavit)
TO (Declaration). DOCKET TEXT
MODIFIED FOR CORRECT DOC-
UMENT LINKAGE (KMG). (En-
tered: 09/23/2008)
DECLARATION of Ed Ableser in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM
(Affidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCK-
ET TEXT MODIFIED FOR COR-
RECT DOCUMENT LINKAGE
(KMG). (Entered: 09/23/2008)
DECLATION of Pamela Durbin in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
19
DOCUMENT LINKAGE(KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09/23/2008 138 DECLARATION of Phil Lopes in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer, Gary
Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
DOCUMENT LINKAGE(KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09/23/2008 139 DECLARATION of Jorge Garcia in
Support of 124 Response (Opposi-
tion) to MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Jan Brewer,
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Daniels. (Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 9/24/2008 INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. THIS ENTRY
HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM (Af-
fidavit) TO (Declaration). DOCKET
TEXT MODIFIED FOR CORRECT
DOCUMENT LINKAGE _ (KMG).
(Entered: 09/23/2008)
09/25/2008 143 REPLY to Response to Motion re 43
First MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Original Plain-
tiffs filed by John McComish, Nancy
V9 LIS VOUS
09 2S 2008
144
145
20
McLain. Tony Bowe. (Attachments:
# 1] Affidavit Moll Dec.. # 2 Exhibit
Moll Dee.. Ex. Fl. # 3 Affidavit
Osborn oy = a Exhibit Osborn
. * S&S Exhibit Osborn
Dec.. Ex. ae 6 Exhibit Osborn
3 pl. # 7 Exhibit Osborn
Dee. Ex. GS p2. # 8 Exhilut Osborn
3 p3. # 9 Exhibit Osborn
Dec. Ex. G.3 p4\Dranias. Nicholas)
Entered: 09 25 2008)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 43 First MOTION tor
Preliminary penction filed dy
Original Plaintiffs Continuation
Osborn Dec.. Ex. G.3 by Plaintiffs
John MeComish, Nanev MeLain,
Tony Bouie. (Attachments: # 1 Ex.
hitut Osborn Dec. Ex. G.3 pe. #
Exhibit Osborn Dec. Ex. G.3 p7,. #
Exhibit Osborn Dee. Ex. G3 ps. #
Exhibit Osborn Dee. Ex. G.3 pg. #
Exhibit Osborn Dec. Ex. G. 8 plo, =
Exhibit Osborn Dee. Fx. G.3 pll. #
er Osborn Dec. Ex. G.
12\Dranias. Nicholas) (Entered:
09° 25 2008)
DECLARATION of Dramas Sec.
Supp. Dee. re 43 First MOTION for
Preliminary Injunction fled dy
Original Plainti?s by Plaintifts John
MecComish, Naney MeLain. Tony
Boune. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Ex.
H.1. Osborn Dep., # 2 Exhibit Ex.
* 63-1 3D) Gt he te !
O09 2a DOS
09 2a DOS
09 2G 2OUS
147
149
150
21
H.2, Newman Dep, # 3 Exhitit Ex
Hi.3. Kennedy Dep, # 4 Exhibit Ex
H.4. Lang Dep, # 5 Exhitit Ex. H.5.
MeComish Dep.. # 6 Exhibit Ex. H.8,
George Dep... # 7 Exhibit Ex. HLT.
Bowe Dep.. # S Exhibit Ex. HLS.
Becker Dep.. # 9 Exhibit Ex. H.9,
MeLain Dep., # 10 Exhibit Ex. H.10.
Det. Dise. Resp.\ Dramas, Nicholas
(Entered: 09 25 2008)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 143 Reply to Response
to Motion., Elec. Signed Osdorn Dec
by Plaintiffs John MeComish, Naney
MeLain, Tonv Boure. (Dramas.
Nicholas) Entered: 09 26 2008'
REPLY in Support re 37 MOTION
for Preliminary Injunction fo De-
fendants filed by Dean Martin.
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy. Arizona
Free Enterprise Club's) Freedom
Ciub PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Committee. (Keller. Timothy) (En-
tered: 09 26 2008)
DECLARATION of Timothy D
Keller in Support of Reply to De-
fendants in Support of Motion for
Preliminary Injunction re 149 Reply
in Support of Motion by Intervenor
Plaintiffs Dean Martin. Robert
Burns, Rick Murphy. Arizona Free
Enterprise Clut’s Freedom Club
PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Committee filed by Dean Martin,
U9 Da DOS
09 2a Das
1002 2008
lol
152
lS;
“ye
of
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy, Arizona
Free Enterprise Club’s) Freedom
Club PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Committee. (Attachments: # 1) Ex-
hituat) Exhibits A-H. # 2) Exhibit
Exhibits I-R\ Keller, Tiymethy) (En-
tered: 09 26 2008)
REPLY in Support re 37 MOTION
for Preliminary Injunction — fo
Defendant-Intervenor filed by Dean
Martin, Robert Burns. Rick Murphy,
Anzona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arizona Taxpay-
ers Action Committee. (Neller, Timo-
thy) «Entered: 09 26 2008)
DECLARATION of Timothy D
Keller in) Support of Piaintit?-
Intervenors) Reply to Defendant-
Intervenor in Support of Motion for
Preliminary Injunction re 151 Reply
in Support of Motion bv Intervenor
Piainaffs Dean Martin, Robert
Burns. Rick Murphy, Arizona Free
Enterprise Club's Freedom Club
PAC, Arizona Taxpayers Actior Com-
mittee filed by Dean Martin, Robert
Burns, Rick Murphy. Arizona Free
Enterprise Club’s) Freedom Club
PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Conunittee. (Attachments: # 1 Exhuib-
it Exhitits A-B\Keller. Timothy)
(Entered: 09 26 2008)
MOTION to Strike re Plaintiffs’
Reply to Brmets in Opposition to
1Q02 2008
1008 200s
10 06 Sods
10-08 2008
lds
161
Las
lot
|
~*
Motion tor Preliminary Injunction bv
Clean Elections Institute. — Inc.
(Attachments: # 1 Text of Proposed
Orderk Neubauer, Elisabeth) (En-
tered: 1002 2008)
AFFIDAVIT in Support re 157 MO-
TION to Strike re Plaintiffs’ Reply to
Briefs in Opposition to Motion for
Preliminary Injunction dv Elisadeth
J. Newdauer filed bw Clean Elections
Institute, Inc.. (Neubauer, Ehsabeth)
(Entered: 10 02 2008)
ORDER that Defendant-Intervenor’s
157 Motion to Strke is granted in
part and demed part. Defendant.
Intervenor shall have until 3:00pm
100608 to file a surreply to Plas’
Reply, Signed by Judge Roslyn O
Silver en TAOS 0S. ESL) (Entered:
10 03 2008"
RESPONSE in Opposition re 43
First MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed bv Original Plain
fis filed by Clean Elections Inst:
tute, Inc. (Neubauer, Elisabeth)
(Entered: 10 06 2008)
AFFIDAVIT in) Opposition re 438
First MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Original Plavy
tiffs In Support of Defendant
Intervenors Surrepiv filed bw Clean
Elections Institute, Ine. (Attach-
ments: # 1 Exhilut Exhibit Ato
1O O98 20S
L009 Vods
loo
lo,
)
~4
Declaration of Elisabeth J. Neubauer
In Support of Defendant-Intervenor
Clean Elections Institute, Inc's
Surreply In Opposition to Piarntitts
and PlainutY-Intervenors’ Motions tor
A Preliminary Injunction\ Neubauer,
Elisabeth) (entered: 10:06 2008)
First MOTION to Amend Correct re
Plaintiffs’ Motion tor Leave to File
Second Amended Complaint by John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Boure, (Attachments: # 1 Appendix
Exhibit List. # 2 Exhibit Redlined
Proposed Complaint, # 3° Exhibit
“Clean” Proposed Second Amended
Complaint, # 4 Text) of Proposed
Order Proposed 9 Order) Dranias.
Nicholas) Modified en 10 10 2008,
ORIGINAL AMENDED PLEADING
INCORRECTLY ATTACHED TO
THE MOTION. ATTORNEY NO-
TICED, (LSP). (entered: 10 09 2008)
LODGED Proposed Second Amended
Complaint re) 166 First MOTION to
Amend Correct re Plaintiffs’ Motion
for Leave to File Second Amended
Complaint. Document to be filed by
Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or
Amend is granted. Filed by John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowie. (Dramas, Nicholas) Modified
on lO 1d 2008, COVER SHEET
MISSING. ATRORNEY NOTICED,
(LSP). (Entered: 1009 2008)
L009 2O0S
10.09 200s
10 10-2008
10 10 2008
De
a?
16S ORDER — A Preliminary Permanent
170
Inmunction Hearing ois set for
LOY ZOOS at 9:00 AM. The new
hearing start time is 930 AM. in
Courtroom 604, 401 West Washing-
ton Street, Phoenix, AZ 85003 before
Judge Roslwn O Silver. THIS IS A
TIME CHANGE ONLY" Signed
by dudge Roslvn O | Silver on
10.09 2008. This is a TEXT ENTRY
ONLY. There is no PDE document
associated with this entry. (ROS, |
(Entered: 10 09 2008)
Minute Entry. Proceedings held
before Judge Roslyn O Silver: Pre-
liminary Injunction Hearing held on
1092008. The court takes under
advisement 37 Motion for Prelimi
nary Inunction and 43 Motion for
Prehminary Injunction. Order to
issue. (Court Reporter Elaine Crop-
per KOLB) (Entered 10.09 2008)
SUPPLEMENT of Supplement Re
garding Undisbursed = Matching
Funds, Related Declaration and
Exhibits re 159 Exhitit List, 48 First
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction
filed bv Original Plaintiffs by Plain-
ufts John MeComish, Nanev MeLain,
ony Bowe. (Dramas, Nicholas)
(Entered: 10 10 2008)
SUPPLEMENT of Parties Joint Sub-
mission of Supplemental Exhibit 149
re 154 Exhibit Last by Defendants
10 10-2008
10 14 2O0S
10:14 2008
10 17 VoOas
1S80
Isl
Sd
_
a
dan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Foirman,
Donald Lindholm, Lor S Damels.
(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit: Supple-
mental Exhit 149\Shipman, Tana)
(Entered: 10 10 2008)
AMENDED DOCUMENT by John
MeComish, Nanev Melain, Tony
Bowe. Amendment to 171 Supple
ment, regarding Ladtshursed Match.
ing Funds. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 10 10 2008)
ORDER Detendants and Defendant-
Intervenors may file a response to
Plaintit?’s MOTION for Leave to File
Second Amended Complaint within
10 davs of this order. Signed by
Judge Roslyn O Silver on 10 14.08
(LSP) (Entered: 10 14 2008)
ORDER denving 48 Plaintiff's Mo-
tion fer Prehminary Injunction
Findings ot Fact and Conclusions of
Law will follow this Order no later
than 101708. Signed by Judge
Roslyn O Silver on 1014084 LSP)
(Entered: 10 14 2008)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CON.
CLUSIONS OF LAW — Plaintiffs
have shown a very strong hkelhood
of success on the merits. However,
given the extraordinary balance of
the harms required in the context of
an ongoing election, Plaintiffs have
1028 2008
10 30 2008
ISS
190
not met their burden in showing that
they are entitled to a preliminary
injunction. For this reason, Plain-
utts’ Motion 43 was demed. Signed
by Judge Roslyn O | Silver on
10 17-08. (LSP) (Entered: 10 17 2008)
RESPONSE in Opposition re 166
First MOTION to Amend Correct re
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to File
Second Amended Complaint filed by
Clean Elections Institute. Inc.
(Neubauer, Elisabeth) (Entered:
10 28 2008)
ORDER pursuant to 189 Stipulation
For Extension of Time To Answer
Complaint: Dtts and Dft-Intervenor
shall not answer Pla’s First) or
Second Amended Complaints — or
Pla-Intervenors’ Proposed Complaint
In Intervention before this Court
enters its order on Plas’ Ex Parte
Motion for Leave to File Second
Amended Complaint. FURTHER
ORDERED the deadline for Dfts and
Dft-Intervenor to answer or other-
wise respond to Plas’ First or Second
Amended Complaint. and Pla-
Intervenors’ Proposed Complaint In
Intervention, shall be suspended
until ten (10) davs trom the date of
the entry of the Court's order on
Plas’ Ex Parte Motion for Leave to
File Second Amended Complaint
Signed by Judge Roslyn O Silver on
1L03 2008
11042008
05112009
191
192
2oy
28
10 30.08. (KMG, ) (Entered:
1030 2OOS)
REPLY in) Support re 166 First
MOTION to Amend Correct re Plain-
tiffs’ Motion for Leave to File Second
Amended Complaint filed by John
McComish, Naney MeLain, Tony
Bowe. (Dranias, Nicholas) (Entered:
11-03 2008)
TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings — re:
Preliminary Injunction Hearing held
on 10908 betore Judge Roslyn O
Silver. Court Reporter: Elaine
Cropper. Transcript may be viewed
at the court) public terminal or
purchased through the Court
Reporter Transcriber before — the
deadline for Release of ‘Transcript
Restriction. After that date it may be
obtained through PACER. Redaction
Request due 11252008. Redacted
Transcript Deadline set for
1252008. Release of Transcript
Restriction set for 22-2009. (BAS, )
(Entered: 11/04/2008)
ORDER granting in part and deny-
ing in part 166 Plaintiff's Motion to
Amend. Plaintiffs may not amend
their Complaint to include proposed
13-16. All other proposed amend-
ments are allowable. Signed = by
Judge Roslyn O - Silver — on
S109. LSP) (Entered: 05/11/2009)
0S LL 2009
05 192009
05262009
05262009
OQ
260 AMENDED COMPLAINT Second
269
ty
~]
ty
271
Amended Complaint against Jan
Brewer, Clean Elections Institute,
Inc., Gary Searamazzo, Rovann J
Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Lori S Daniels, filed by
John MecComish, Nancy MeLain,
Tony Bouie. Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 05/11/2009)
MOTION to File Amicus Curiae
Brief on Summary Judgment by
Center for Competitive Politics.
(Attachments: # 1 Memorandum
in Support, # 2 Text of Proposed
Order, # 3 Corporate Dsclosure
Statement Cox, Reid) (Entered:
05/19/2009)
DEFENDANTS ANSWER to.) 58
Complaint IN INTERVENTION by
Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Lori S Damiels,
Ken Bennett. Shipman, Tanja)
Modified on 5/27/2009 (DMT. ).
DOCKET TEXT MODIFIED TO
IDENTIFY CORRECT — FILER.
(Entered: 05/26/2009)
Defendants ANSWER to 260 Amend-
ed Complaint, (Second Amended
Complaint) by Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L. Fairman,
Lori S Daniels, Ken Bennett.Shipman,
Tanja) Modified on 5/27/2009 (DMT, ).
DOCKET TEXT MODIFIED TO
05/26/2009
05/26'2009
06/03/2009
06/08/2009
06/10/2009
30
IDENTIFY CORRECT FILER.
(Entered: 05/26/2009)
273 Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elections
274
Institute, Inc.'s ANSWER to Com-
plaint (Second Amended) by Clean
Elections Institute. Inc...Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 05/26/2009)
Defendant Intervenor’s ANSWER to
Complaint of Plaintiff Intervenors by
Clean Elections Institute, Inc.(Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 05/26/2009)
280 RESPONSE in Opposition re 269
281
MOTION to File Amicus Curiae
Brief on Summary Judgment filed by
Clean Elections’ Institute, Inc..
(Sandhu, Puneet) entered: 06/03/2009)
REPLY in Support re 269 MOTION
to File Amicus Curiae Brief on
Summary Judgment filed by Center
for Competitive Politics. (Attach-
ments: # 1 Exhibit)Cox, Reid) (En-
tered: 06/08/2009)
ORDER granting 269 Motion to File
Amicus Curiae Brief on Summary
Judgment, which shall be no longer
than seventeen (17) pages, con-
sistent with the page length for
motions specified in the Local Rules
of Civil Procedure for the District of
Arizona; and shall be served and
filed no later than seven (7) days
(excluding intermediate Saturdays,
Sundays, and legal holidays) after
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
to
6 2)
~]
31
the filing deadline for the parties’
and intervenors’ motions for sum-
mary judgment. Any party who
wishes to may file a Response to the
Center's brief, not to exceed seven-
teen (17) pages. Signed by Judge
Roslyn O Silver on 6/10/09..DMT, )
(Entered: 06/10/2009)
285 First MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment by Clean Elections Institute,
Inc.. (Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered:
06/12/2009)
286 MEMORANDUM re: iso Motion for
Summary Judgment re 285 First
MOTION for Summary Judgment by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elec-
tions Institute. Inc... (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06/12/2009)
First MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment by John McComish, Nancy
McLain, Tony Bouie. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 06/12/2009)
288 First MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment by Dean Martin, Robert Burns,
Rick Murphy, Arizona Free Enter-
prise Club’s Freedom Club PAC,
Arizona Taxpayers Action Commit-
tee. (Attachments: # 1 Memo in
support of Summary Judgment, # 2
Statement of Facts, # 3 Declaration
in support of Motion for Summary
Judgment, # 4 Exhibit Ex. 1-10, # 5
Exhibit Ex. 11-18, # 6 Exhibit Ex.
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
06/12/2009
32
19-24, # 7 Exhibit Ex. 46-59, # 8
Exhibit Ex. 60-79)(Maurer, William)
(Entered: 06/12/2009)
290 STATEMENT of Separate Statement
re 285 First MOTION for Summary
Judgment by Intervenor Defendant
Clean Elections Institute, Inc..
(Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered: 06/12/2009)
291 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment Proposed Order
by Plaintiffs John McComish, Nancy
McLain, Tony’ Bouie. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 06/12/2009)
292 DECLARATION of Puneet Sandhu
re 285 First MOTION for Summary
Judgment by Intervenor Defendant
Clean Elections’ Institute, Inc..
(Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered: 06/12/2009)
293 MOTION for Summary Judgment by
Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels,
Ken Bennett. (Shipman, Tanja)
(Entered: 06/12/2009)
294 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 288 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment Exhibits 80-184
by Intervenor Plaintiffs Dean Mar-
tin, Robert Burns, Rick Murphy,
Arizona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arizona Taxpay-
ers Action Committee. (Attachments:
33
# 1 Exhibit Ex. 91-130, # 2 Exhibit
Ex. 131-184)(Maurer, William) (En-
tered: 06/12/2009)
06/12/2009 295 DECLARATION re 293 MOTION for
Summary Judgment Declaration of
Tanja K. Shipman by Defendants Jan
Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo, Royann J
Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Lori S Daniels, Ken
Bennett. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit
Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit 2,
#3 Exhibit Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit
Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit Exhibit 5, # 6
Exhibit Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit Exhib-
it 7, # 8 Exhibit Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhib-
it Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit Exhibit
10Shipman, Tanja) (Entered:
06/12/2009)
06/12/2009 296 DECLARATION of Declaration of
Todd Lang re 293 MOTION for
Summary Judgment by Defendants
Jan Brewer, Gary Scaramazzo,
Royann J Parker, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Lori S Daniels,
Ken Bennett. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit Exhib-
it 2, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhib-
it Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit Exhibit
5)(Shipman, Tanja) (Entered:
06/12/2009)
06/12/2009 297 MEMORANDUM re: Memorandum
of Law Supporting Pla MSJ re 287
First MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment by Plaintiffs John McComish,
OG L2 2009
O08 12 2009
OG 12 2009
Oa
Vad
Oa 122009
as al
OW} 12 2009
Dag
300
S01
S03
2 Additional
od
Nanev MeLain, loay Bowe. (Drantas,
Nicholas) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Matin
Document re 28? Declaration Avrd.
wt A (part 1 oof 2) bv Intervenor De-
tendant Clean Elections Institute.
Inc. (Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered
OG 12 VOOR)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Fahich
if A (part 2 of 2) bv Intervenor De-
tendant Clean Elections Institute,
Inc. (Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered:
OG 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Ewiid-
i B bv Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Ine. (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration EwxArrd
oC by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute. Ine. (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Eyirb-
“vp bv Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Ime. (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 LD DOOY)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re VOY Declaration Faxed
if F by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Klections Institute. Ine (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 08 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Extra
fF bw Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute. Ine. (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Eaid
iG by Intervenor Detendant Clean
Klections Institute. Ine. Sandhu,
Puneet) (entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Matin
Document re 292 Declaration Byars
¢ Hf by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute. Ine (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: O68 12 2000)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Fyasd
ol oby Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute. Ine (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Declaration Exch
ied by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute. Inc (Sandhu,
Puneet) (Entered: 06 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Yocument re 292 Declaration by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elee-
lions Institute, Ine. (Attachments
* 1 Exhitit K. # 2 Exhibit L. # 3
Exhibit M, # 4 Exhibit No #5 Exhibit
OG 12 2009
Oo 12 2009
OG 12 2dd09
Oo T2009
310
8
312
*¥,°
to)
OO, # © Exhibit PO #® 7 Extubit Q. #8
Exhibit R, # 9 Exhibit S. # 10 Exhib
uot) #® 11 extobat UL # 12 Exhibit V,
#13 Exhibit W. # 14 Exhibit X. & 15
Exhibit YL # 16 Exhibit 2. # 17 Ex-
hitit AA, # 18) Exhibit BRB, #& 19
Extiubit CC\Sandhu, Paneet) (en
tered: OG 12 2009)
DECLARATION of Donald Green re
28h First MOTION. for Summary
Judgment by Intervenor Defendant
Clean Elections Institute, Ine
(Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered
OG 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re S10 Declaration by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elee-
tions Institute, Inc. (Attachments
# 1 Exhibit AX\Sandhu, Puneet!
(Entered: 068 12 2009)
DECLARATION of Angela Migally
re 285 First MOTION for Summary
Juegment by Intervenor Defendant
Clean Electrons Institute, — Ine
(Sandhu, Puneet) (Entered
OG L2LZOOY)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 312) Declaration by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elec:
tions Institute, Inc. (Attachments
# L Exhitit) lkSandhu, Puneet)
(Entered O68 12 2009)
OG 122009
OO
Oo
On
OG
On
L22009
22009
122009
22009
—_ &—
12 Vode
“<
S14 Additional Attachments to Manin
Document re 2ST First MOTION
for Summary Judgment Separate
Sfatement of Facts bv Plainttts John
MeConush, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowie (Dranias, Nicholas) (Entered
OG 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Manin
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment Evfsdie List bv
PlaintitYs John MeComish, Naney
MeLarn, Tony Bowe (Dramas,
Nicholas) (Entered O08 12 2009)
> Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 2S7 First MOTION
fer Summary Judgment Fave 7
MeCorush Dec bv Plaintit¥s John
MeConmush, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowe. (Dramas, Nicholas) (Entered
OG L2 2009)
+ Additional Attachments toe Main
Document re 287 First MOTION tor
Summary dudyment Aa? Melain
Dec bv Plainttts John MeComuish.
Naney MeLain, Tony Boure. (Dranias.
Nicholas) (Entered: 0&8 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document Pla Ex 8 (Bouse Deo! by
Planuftts John MeConush, Naney
McLain, Tony Bowe (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 0G 12 2009)
S19 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 2S7 First MOTION for
Oy LOO
Oe 122009
Oe 122009
OG
eae © Oe
BVO
>
ot
.
‘
‘
»
5
>»)
-
’
ve i
».
.
.
‘
Summarv Judgment Pao Fy 7
Dramas Dee bv Plainttts John
MeComish, Nanev MebLain, Tony
Bowe. (Dranias, Nacholas) (entered
OG 122009)
Additional Attachments te Main
Document re 287 First MOTION tor
Summary Judgement Plarmntif?s Ba
18 Sinema Dep) by Plaintilts John
MeConush, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowe. (Dranias, Nicholas) (Entered
O8 LL LOO)
~~“ &
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re ZS7 First MOTION tor
Summary dudgment fai ky 16
(Gven Dep) by Plains John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain Tony
Bowe. (Dramas. Nicholas) (entered
OW 12 LOY)
i~_- =~
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary dudgment Pa Fx 17
(Maver Dep) bv Plaintiffs John
MeConmush, Nanev MebLai, Tons
Bowe. (Dranias, Nicholas) (Entered
Oe 12 2OO9)
Additional Attachments to Manin
Document re 2S7 First MOTION tor
Summary Judgment Pa Bal 8 Lagan
Dep) by PlaintatYs John MeComuish,
Nancy MeLain (Attachments # 1
Exhibit Lagan Ex D\ Dramas, Nicho
las) Entered: 06 12 2009)
Oa L2odg
Oa L20009
Oy TADOOY
|
ae
B24 Additional Attachments to Main
»
Ja
ss
O68
a’
ST
-)
.
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment ?Va Fx 4 Osdhorn
Dec bv PlanntutYs John MeComush,
Nanev MeLain, Tony Bowe (Attach
ments: # Ll Exhitit Osborn Ex 1, # 2
Exhibit Osborn Ex 2. #8) Exhibit
Osborn Ex. 8 Dramas, Nicholas)
(Entered: 068 12 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re O24 Additional At-
tachments to Main Document. Os
born Exhilieg 4 bv Plaintiffs John
MeComish, Nanev Melaun, Tony
Bowie (Attachments: ® 1) Exhibit
Osborn Exhibit Oo, #2 Exhibit Osborn
Ex. 6, # 3 Exhitat Osborn Ex 7, # 4
Exhitaut Osborn Exhitut S. #5 Exhib
uw Osborn Exhibit 9. #& 6 Exhatat
Osborn Exhilit 10. # 7 Exhobit
Osborn Exbtibit ll. # SS) Exhibit
Osborn Exhibit 12.) # 9 Exhibut
Osborn Exhibit 18, #® 10) Exhibit
Osborn Exhitit: 14) Dramias, Nicho
las) (Entered: 0G 18 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document Subach CCEC Dec by
Plainutts John MeComish, Nanes
MeLain, Tonv Bowe. (Attachments
# 1 Exhibit Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit
Subach CCEC Exhibits 2-6, # 38
Exhilnt Subach CCEC Exhibits 7-
kDranias, Nicholas) (Entered
OG 18 VOO9)
AQ
OF LAVOOM SLT Additional Attachments to Manin
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment Sudback CE!
Dec ine FalY bw Plaintitts John
MeComush, Nanev MelLain, Tony
Bowe. (Dramas, Nicholas) (Entered
OG 13 LON)
OS TAO SVS Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary dudgment Plants MS
Ry 98 Fist Dep bw Plaintitfs John
MeComish, Nanev Melain, Tony
Bowie. (Attachments: # 1) Exhibit
Ehst Ex 1, #@ 2 Exhibit Ehst Ex 2. #3
Extutat Ehst Ex o, # 4 Exhibit Ehst
Exhitut G6 Dranias, Nicholas) (En.
tered: OG 13 2OQ09)
OG LAVA BLY Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 287 First MOTION tor
Summary Judgment /Vainstifts MS
BFwibie 10 bv Plaintif¥s John
MeComush, Nanev Melain, Tony
Bouse. (Attachments: # 1) Exhibit
Rue Dep Ex: 2. # 2 Exhibit Rui Ex
3. #3 Exhibit Ruas Ex 4, # 4 Exhubit
Ruiz Ex 5, #5 Extitit Rus Ex 6, #6
Exhibit Rune @ 7 Exhibit Ruiz Ex 9,
® S Eaxhitit Ruse Ex 10, # 9 Exhibit
Rua Ex ll, # 0 Exhibit Ruiz Ex
Lg) Dramas, Nicholas) (Entered
OW LE LOOM)
OW TS VodN 230 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re JS7 First MOTION tor
Summary Judgment /Va MS. Ex 11
Oo LALO
O88 LA VOY
Oo La lody
>»
oh)
“-.
ww“
-
‘
”
’
‘
’
w“e
-
’
‘*
ts
»
y
41
McGee Dep by Plaintiffs John
MeComush, Nanev MeLain, Tons
Bowe (Attachments # 1) Exhibit
CCEC MeGee Ex 17, # 2 Exhibu
CCEC MeGee Ex 22. #3) Exhibit
CCEC MeGee Ex 24. 8% 4 Exhibit
CCEC MeGee Ex 25, # 5 Exhibit
CCEC MeGee Ex 27\ Dramas, Nich
Olas) (Entered: 06 13 2009)
Additional Attachments to Manin
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment ?Va MS Fa 72
‘Lang Dep) bw PhunulfYs John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowe. (Attachments # 1) Exhibit
Lang Ex 30\Dramas. Nicholas
(Entered: 06 18 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 287 First MOTION for
Sumunary Judgment va MS./ Ex 24
Daniels Dep bv Plaintiffs John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain, Tony
Bowe (Attachments. # 1) Exhuibuat
Damels Fx 7. #@ 2 Exhibit Damels
#3 Exhibit Damels Ex 10, # 4 Exbob-
it Damels Ex 12, 4 5 Exhibit Daniels
Ex 18, #6 Exhibit Damels Ex 15, #1
Exhibit Damels Fx 16, 4 S Exhibit
Damels Ex 17) Dramas, Nicholas!
(Entered: 06 18 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 2JS7 First MOTION tor
Summary dudgment Pla Ms.) Fy 15
Hoffman Dep) bv Plaintit’s John
Og 1S Loads
OO LA DOOY
Oo 2a BOO
OF V2 2009
ae
-*
oy
a-
yy?
se
~
sis)
p-
MeComish, Nanevy MeLain, Tony
Bowe. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit
Hoffman Ex 5, # 2 Exhibit Hoffman
Ex 6, #3 Exhibit Hoffman Ex 9, # 4
Exhitnt Hloffman Ex 10 Dramas,
Nicholas) (Entered: 06 18 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 292 Deelaration by
Intervenor Detendant Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc. (Attachments
*# 1 Exhitit F\Sandhu. Puneet)
(Entered: 06 15 2009)
ERRATA re 285, First MOTION tor
Summary dudgment bv Intervenor
Detendant Clean Flections Institute,
Inc. (Sandhu, Puneet! (Entered:
O8 LS LOO)
> BRIEF re 28S First MOTION for
Summary Judgement, 287 First
MOTION for Summary Judgment,
285 First MOTION for Sammary
Judgment, 2988 MOTION for Sum-
mary Judgment by Amicus Center
tor Competitive Politics (Cox, Reid)
(Entered: 06 23 2009)
sAdditional Attachments to Matin
Document re 288 First MOTION tor
Summarv Judgement Rvhrhits 24 5
by Intervenor Piaintit!s Dean Martin,
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy, Arnzona
Free Enterprise Club's) Freedom
Club PAC, Amrona Taxpayers Action
43
Committee. (Keller, Timothy) (En-
tered: O7 U2 2009)
OT 022009 339 ERRATA regarding Ewhidits 25-4
by Intervenor Plaintiffs Dean Mar-
tin, Robert Burns, Rick Murphy,
Anzona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arizona Taxpay-
ers Actton Committee. LAttachments
# 1 Exhitut Exhibit 25-45) Keller,
Timothy) (Entered: 07 02 2009)
O7 172009 343 RESPONSE to Motion re 285 First
MOTION tor Summary Judgment
by Clean Elections Institute filed by
Dean Martin, Robert) Burns, Rick
Murphy, Arizona Free Enterprise
Club's Freedom Club PAC, Arizona
Taxpavers Action Committee. (Maurer,
Wilham) (Entered O7 17 2009
O7 172009 344 RESPONSE to Motion re 293 MO
TION for Summary Judgment §)
Ken Bennett. et al filed bv Dean
Martin, Robert Burns, Rick Murphy,
Anvona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arizona Paxpay-
ers Action Committee. (Keller, Timo-
thy) (Entered: OF 17 2009)
OT 179009 S45 RESPONSE =o re 290) Statement
Defendant &Defendant-Intervenors
Statement of Undisputed Facts by
Intervenor PlaintitYs Dean Martin,
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy, Arizona
Free Enterpmse Club's Freedom
Club PAC, Arizona Taxpayers Action
OT Ly BVOds
O7 17 Boos
OF 17 2009
_
O7 17 Boos
OF 1, 2009
G16
O47
S45
349
Bo
44
Committee (Attachments: # 1 Ex-
hibit Ex. A-C, # 2 Exhibit Ex D, #3
Extibit Ex E-l. # 4 Exhibit Ex. JM,
#5 Exhibit Ex. N Pt. 1, # 6 Exhibit
Ex. N Pt. 2. # 7 Exhibit Ex. N Pt. 3,
# 8S Exhiit Ex. O-U\Keller, [mo-
thy) (Entered: O7 17 2009)
RESPONSE to Motion re 285 First
MOTION tor Summary Judgment,
298 MOTION tor Summary Judg-
ment filed by John MeComish,
Nanev McLain, Tony Bowe. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
MEMORANDUM re: Placntat?s’ Com
bined Bret in Opposition to Dets
Det-Int MsSJs re 346 Response to
Motion by Plaintiffs John MeConush,
Nanev MeLain, Tony Bowe. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
STATEMENT of Response to Dets
Def-Int Joint Statement of Facts re
346 Response to Motion by Plaintitts
John MeComish, Nancy MeLain,
Tony Bowe (Dramas, Nicholas)
“> «>
(Entered: O7 17 ZOO)
Exhibit List for Pla. Response to
Defs Def-Int) Motions jor Summary
Judgment by dohn MeComuish, Nancy
MeLain, Tonv Bowe. (Dramas,
Nicholas) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
RESPONSE in Opposition re 28s
First MOTION tor Summary Judg-
ment, 287 First MOTION © tor
O7 17 2ooY
OF LF 2009
OF 17 2009
OF 17 BOs
OF LF 2009
O7 17 VoOOs
ead .
OOH
45
Summary Judgment filed by Gary
Scaramazzo, Rovann J Parker, Jet
trev Lo Farman, Donald Lindholm,
Lor S Damels, Ken Bennett. (Ship-
man, Tanja) (Entered: 07 17/2009)
DECLARATION of Ex. 18: Ober Dec
re 346 Response to Motion by Plain-
tiffs John MeComiush, Nancy MeLain,
Tony Bowe. (Dramas, Nicholas)
(Entered: 07 17 2009)
DECLARATION of Ex. 19: Tsontakis
Dec. re 346 Response to Motion by
Plaintitts John MeComish, Naney
McLain, Tony Bowe. (Dramias,
Nicholas) Entered: 07 17 2009)
DECLARATION of Ex. 20: Dranias
Dec re 346 Response to Motion by
Plaintitts dohn MeComish, Nancy
McLain, Tony Bowe. (Dramas,
Nicholas) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
RESPONSE in Opposition re 28s
First MOTION tor Summary Judg-
ment filed by Clean Elections Insti-
tute, Inc. (Neubauer, Elisabeth)
(Entered: 07 17 2009)
Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 346 Response to Mo-
tion Fx. 27: Boure Dep. SP by Plain-
titts John MeComish, Nanev McLain,
Tony Bowe. (Dramas, Nicholas)
(Entered: 07/17/2009)
Additional Attachments to Main Doc-
ument re 346 Response to Motion
46
Bx: 22> Daniels Dep. S2 by Plaintiffs
John MeComish, Nancy MeLain,
Tony Bowie. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 07 17/2009)
O7 17 2009) 357 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 346 Response to Mo-
tion kx. 23: Green Dep. S? by Plain-
titts John McComish, Nancy MeLain,
Tony Bouie. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 07 17/2009)
O07 17-2009 358 DECLARATION of Declaration of
Michael Valder in Support of
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc.'s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’
Motion for Summary Judgment re
354 Response in Opposition to Mo-
tion by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Inc.. (Neubauer,
Elisabeth) (Entered: 07/17/2009)
O7 17-2009 359 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 346 Response to Mo-
tion Ex. 24: Osborn Dep. (2009) S2
by Plaintiffs John MeComish, Nancy
McLain, Tony Bouie. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 07/17/2009)
07/17/2009 360 DECLARATION of Declaration of
Donald Green in Support of
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc.'s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’
Motion for Summary Judgment re
354 Response in Opposition to
47
Motion by Intervenor Defendant
Clean Elections Institute, Inc.. (At-
tachments: # 1 Exhibit 1-7 to Decla-
ration of Donald Green)Neubauer,
Elisabeth) (Entered: 07/17/2009)
0717/2009 +361 Additional Attachments to Main
Document re 346 Response to Mo-
tion Ex. 25. Mayer Dep. S2 by Plain-
tiffs John McComish, Nancy McLain,
Tony Bouie. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 07/17/2009) °
07/17/2009 362 DECLARATION of Declaration of
Elisabeth J. Neubauer in Support of
Defendant-Intervenor Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc.’s Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ and Plaintiff-Intervenors’
Motions for Summary Judgment re
354 Response in Opposition to Mo-
tion by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Inc.. (Attach-
ments: # 1 Exhibit A-J to Declara-
tion of Elisabeth J. Neubauer, # 2
Exhibit K-Y to Declaration of Elisa-
beth J. Neubauer)(Neubauer, Elisa-
beth) (Entered: 07/17/2009)
07/17/2009 363 STATEMENT of DEFENDANTS
AND DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS
JOINT RESPONSE TO PLAIN-
TIFFS SEPARATE STATEMENT re
314 Additional Attachments to Main
Document, 287 First MOTION for
Summary Judgment, 297 Memoran-
dum by Intervenor Defendant Clean
Elections Institute, Inc., Defendants
OF 17 2009
OF Ly 2009
oa
UP
™ A>
oo
OY
SO4
BOO
B66
4s
Gary Scaramarzo, Rovann d Parker,
Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald Lindholm,
Lori S Damels, Ken Bennett. (Ship-
man, Tanja) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
STATEMENT of Detendants and
Defendant-Intervenor’s dont Re
sponse to Plaintiff-Intervenors’ Sepa-
rate Statement re YZSS_ First
MOTION tor Summary dudgment by
Intervenor Detendant Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc. Defendants
Gary Scaramazzo, Rovann J Parker,
Jetfrey lL. Fainnan, Donald Lindholm,
Lort SS Damels. Ken Bennett
(Neubauer, Elisabeth) (Entered
O7 17 2009)
RESPONSE in Opposition re 2S?
First MOTION tor Summary dudg-
ment filed by Clean Elections Insti
tute. Ine. (Neubauer, Elisabeth)
(Entered: O7 17 2009)
DECLARATION of COLLEEN
MCGEE IN SUPPORT OF DEFEND.
ANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFES’
AND PLAINTIFFINTERVENORS'
MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDG:-
MENT re 363 Statement, 350 Re-
sponse in Opposition to Motion by
Defendants Garv Scaramazscso, Rovann
J Parker, detYrey L Fairman, Donald
Lindhelm, Lor S Damels. Ken
Bennett. (Shipman, Tania) (entered
O7 17 2009)
490
OF LF VOW B67 DECLARATION of OF DANIEL
RUIZ IL IN SUPPORT OF DEFEND.
ANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’
AND PLAINTIFFINTERVENORS’
MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDG
MENT re 3868 Statement, 350 Re-
sponse in Opposition to Motion by
J Parker, Jeffrey Lo Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Lom S Damels, Wen
Bennett. (Shipman, Tanja) (Entered
O7 17 2009)
OF TF 2009 SBS DECLARATION of DR. KENNETH
Ro MAYER IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO
PLAINTIFFS AND PLAINTIFF:
INTERVENORS MOTIONS FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT re S638
Statement, 3850 Response in Opposi
ion to Motion by Defendants Gary
Scaramaczo, Revann do Parker,
Jeffrev L Farman, Donald Lindholm,
Lon S Damels, Ken Bennett. (At-
tachments: # 1 Exhibit A\Shipman,
Tanja) (Entered: 07 17 2009)
OF TF 2008 B69 DECLARATION of TODD FO LANG
IN SUPPORT OF DEFEDANTS’
RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ AND
PLAINTIFF-INTERVENORS) MO
TIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDG.
MENT re 363 Statement. 350
Response in Opposition to Motion by
Defendants Garv Scaramazzo, Rovann
J Parker, defYrev Lo Fairman, Donald
OF Le 2009
OF 24 2009
OF Va Dodd
S70
onl
‘
~
‘
a)
~
ov
Lindholm, Lom S Damels, Ken
Bennett. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit
A-F # 2 Extitit G Annual Reports
2000-2004 (part Lot 2), #3 Exhibit G
Annual Reports 2005-2008 (part 2
of 2kShipman, Tana’ (Entered
O7 17 209)
DECLARATION of | TANIA OW
SHIPMAN IN SUPPORT OF DE
FENDANTS' RESPONSE TO
PLAINTIFFS) AND PLAINTIFF
INTERVENORS MOTIONS FOR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT re 3638
Statement, 300 Response in Oppost-
tion to Motion bw Defendants Gary
Scaramazzo, Rovann 4 Parker,
Jeffrev lL. Faarman, Donald Landhelm,
Lorn S) Damiels, Ken Bennett (At-
tachments: # L Exhibit 11-26. 4 2
Exhibit 27-41, # 3 Exhaitit 42
90°’. Shipman, Tanga) iEntered
OF LF 2009)
MOTION to File Amicus Curie bv
Campaiutn Legal Center. (Attach
ments: # 1 Annecus Memorandum, # 2
Amicus Corporate Disclosure State
ment, # & Amicus Proposed Or-
der Rvan, Paul) (entered: 07 24 2009)
RESPONSE in Opposition re 37
MOTION to File Amicus Curae fled
by John MeComish, Nanev Mebaan,
Tony Bowe. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: O7 24 2O09)
ol
O77 VSVOOE BTS First MOTION tor Leave to File
Motion for Leave to File Separate
Response to Defendants Joint State
ment of Additional Facts by John
MeComush, Nanev MebLain, Tony
Bome (Attachments # 1 Text. of
Proposed Order\ Dramas, Nicholas)
(Entered O7 2S ZOD)
OF SLLOO9 ST7 MEMORANDUM re) Memorandum
of Law in Support of Motion tor
Leave to File re S73 First MOTION
tor Leave to File Motion tor Leave to
bile Separate Response to Detend
ants dont Statement of Additional
Facts bv Plaintitts John MeComush,
Nanev MeLain, Tony Bome (Dranias,
Nicholas! (Entered: O7 SL 2009)
“-
OT BLL STS REPLY to Response to Motion re 28s
First MOTION tor Summary duds
ment Renliv to Defendants’ Response
to Planta? i ntervenors’ Motion for
Suman dudgment filed by Dean
Martin, Robert Burns, Rick Murphy,
Arizona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Clab PAC, Arivona Taxpay
ers Action Committee (Maurer,
William) (Entered) 07 31 2009)
OT BLVOO9 BTA REPLY to Response to Motion re 2SS
birst MOTION tor Summary duds-
ment Maintiffintercenors’ Repiv to
Defendant-Intervenor's Memo tn
Opposition to Motions for Sumenan
Judgment filed bv Dean Martin,
Robert Burns, Rick Murphy, Arizona
Free Enterprise Club's | Freedom
Club PAC, Arizona Taxpavers Action
Committee (Attachments: @ 1) At.
tachment A, # 2 Attachment B, # 3
Attachment C. # 4 Exhibit Ex) 185
Iso, #5 Exhibit Ex. 190-197) Keller.
Timothy) (Entered O07 31 20090)
-
we
OF SL2009 SSO REPLY an) Support) re SS First
MOTION for Summary Judgment
fled by Clean Elections Institute,
Inc. (Neubauer, Elisabeth) (Entered
OF 31 2009)
OF SLL SST DECLARATION. of Declaration of
Bart Turner in Support of Defendant.
Intervenor Clean Elections Institute,
Inc’s Reply in Support of Motion tor
Summary Judgment re 380 Reply in
Support of Motion by Intervenor
Defendant Clean Elections Institute,
Inc filed by Clean Elections Instr
tute, Ime. (Neubauer, Elisabeth)
(Entered. OT SE 2OQO9)
OF ST 2009 S82 REPLY in Support re 288 MOTION
for Summary Judgment filed by dan
Brewer, Gary Scaramaccso, Rovann J
Parker, JefYrey Lo Fairman, Donald
landholm, Lorn S Damels, Ken
Bennett. (Shipman, Tana?! (Entered
OF 31 YOO)
OF SL 2009 S83 LODGED Proposed Separate Reply
to Det Additional Facts re 373 First
MOTION tor Leave to File Motion
tor Leave to File Separate Response
OF B19
OF SL 2009
OS O38 YOY
OS LL 2009
384
.
as
.s =
OS i
‘
*“we*e*
oss
ow’
“ae
to Defendants Joint Statement of
Additional Facts. Document to be
filed by Clerk af Motion to Leave to
File or Amend as granted Filed by
John MeComish, Nancy Melain,
Tony Bowme (Dramas, Nicholas
(Entered OF SL 2009)
REPLY wo Support re wee First
MOTION for Summary Judgment
to CEI Response filed bv John
MeCormush, Nanev Mebain, Tons
Bowe Attachments #1) Aida
vith Dramas, Nicholas! (Entered
O77 SL Poo
REPLY ino Suppert re 2ST First
MOTION tor Summary Judgment
Reply to CCEC. Response filed by
John MeComish, Nancy Melanin,
Tony Bowe (Dramas. Nichelas
(Entered O7 381 2o09)
AMENDED DOCUMENT by Arico
na Free Enterprise Clubs Freedom
Club PAC, Anzona Taxpavers Action
Committee, Robert) Burns, Dean
Martin, Rick Murphy Praeceipe fo
, , . , .
; - os ‘ '
Darra } Pers Declaration ier Sup
port of Motion for Summary Judy
meng (Attachments: # L Corrected
Page\ Maurer, William Entered
OS AI LOY)
ORDER the Campaign Legal Cen
ter’s Motion 371 is GRANTED and
the Campaiyrn Legal Center Amicus
OS TL 2009
OS 142009
OS 14 2009
OS ZS LOO9
389
39]
"» .’
ay
393
od
Cunae Memorandum in Opposition
to Plaunttts’ and Plant Intervenors’
Motions for Summary Judgment
shall be tiled in this case Surned by
Judge Roslyn © Silver on S 1109
KMG) (Entered OS 11 2009)
RESPONSE (Memorandum) in
Opposition to Plas re USS) First
MOTION tor Summary Judgment
and PlaintitY Intervenors’ 287 First
MOTION for Sammary Judgment
fled by Campaign Legal Center
AMG) Entered OS LL VOOYD)
RESPONSE to Motion re S73 First
MOTION tor Leave to File Motion
for Leave to File Separate Response
to Detendants Jomt Statement of
Additional Facts tiled by Ken Bennett,
dan Brewer, Clean Elections Institute,
Inc, bem SS Damels, Jeffrey L
Fiaorman, Donald Lindholm, Rovann J
Parker, Garv Scaramazzo. (Shipman,
Tanja) (Entered OS La 2009
REPLAY to Response to Motion re O73
First MOTION tor Leave to File
Motion tor Leave to File Separate
Response to Detendants Jornt
Statement ot Additional Facts tiled
by Tonv Bowe, John MeCormuish,
Nancy MeLain (Dramas, Nicholas)
Entered OS 14 2000)
First MOTION to Supplement f/re
Record with New Persuasive Preevdent
OS VA LOO
ON VS VLOOY
OS VS VOY
OE DOdY
” -
BY
by Tonv Bowe, John MeComush,
Nanev MeLain (Dramas. Nicholas!
(Entered OS 28 2009)
LODGED Proposed Decision in
Green Party of Connecticut vo Gar.
field ev 3 0Gev L080 re S98) First
MOTION to Supplement fie Record
with New Persuasive Precedent
Document to be filed by Clerk if
Motion to Leave to File or Amend ts
granted Filed by Tony Bowe, John
MeComish, Nancy MeLain. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: OS 28 2009)
MEMORANDUM re) Memorandum
In support of motion to supplement
re 393 First MOTION to Supplement
the Record with New Persuasive
Precedent’ by Plaintiffs Tony Boute.
John MeComish, Nanev Melain
(Attachments # 1 Text of Proposed
Order? Dramas. Nicholas! (Entered
OS VS LOY
Notice re Notice of Supplemental
Authority bv Arizona Free Enter
prise Club’s) Freedom Clab) PAC,
Anvona Taxpavers Action Commit
tee, Robert Burns, Dean Martin,
Rick Murphy (Attachments #& |
Attachment AbkMaurer, William
(Entered OS 2S LOO9)
38s RESPONSE to Motion re G93 First
MOTION to Supplement ie Aecord
woth Neu Persuasive Precect rf
OS IS 2009
OS TN 2odY9
OS TN odY
OY VN VOY
ay
400
WwW
403
ow
Defendants and Defendant-Intervenor’s
Joint Response to Phav niitis’ Motion
fo Supple? meni the Record filed bry
Ken Bennett, Clean Elections Instr.
tute, Inc. Lor S Damels, Jeffrey 1.
Farman, Rovann J Parker. Gary
Searamayco. (Davis-Denny, Grant)
iP ntered: 09 04 2009)
Second MOTION tor Leave to File
Supplemental Authority by Tony
Bome, John MeComish, Naney
MeLain. (Attachments # 1 Text of
Proposed Order) Drantas, Noreholas)
(Entered 09 18 2009)
LODGED Proposed us Court) of
Appeals Washington, 1) Co Cireurt re
399 Second OTION tor Leave to
bile Supplemental Authority. Doeu-
ment to be filed by Clerk ait Motion
to Leave to File or Amend ts srant-
ed. Filed bw Tony Bowe. John
MeComnsh, Nancy Melain (Dranias.
Nicholas) (Entered. 09 1S 2oOg)
MEMORANDUM © re 399 Second
eee for Leave to File Supple
rental Authority by PlaintitYs Tom
“ne John MeComish, Nanev
MeLain) (Dramas. Nicholas) (En
tered: O98 TS 200d)
RESPONSE to Motion re 399 Second
MOTION for Leave to File Supple
mental Authority. Defendants and
Defendant-Intervenor’s Joint Response
TORY RAY
11 122009
1!
409
to Plaintiffs’ Second Motion to Sup
plement the Record tiled try Ken
Bennett, Clean Elections Institute,
Inc. Lom S Damels, Jeffrey 1
Fairman, Rovann J) Parker, Gary
Scaramazzo. (Davis-Denny, Grant)
(Entered: 09 2S POO)
ORDER. Dit Secretary of State shall
submit a brmef addressing the issues
outhned above. That brief shall be
filed no later than 1112.09 and must
not erceed ten pages in length Df
Clean Elections Institute, Ine) may
submit a brief under the same re-
quirements Pla John MeComush
shall tile a responsive bref That
response shall be filed no later than
LL i908 and shall not exceed ten
pages in length Phas represented by
separate counsel may also submit
responses under the same require.
ments No rephes shall be filed
Signed by Judge Roslvn O Silver on
1OLZMOAM (NOTE: See attached pdf
for complete detarls) (ESL) (Entered
LO 29 2009)
SUPPLEMENT of DEFENDANTS
SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF AD.
DRESSING ISSUES RAISFI) IN
OCTOBER ve, 2009 COURT OR
DER re 406 Order. by Defendants
Ken Bennett, Jan Brewer, Lor: S
Damiels, deYrev Lo Fairman, Donald
Landhelm, Rovann J Parker,
LL 122009
LL IS 2009
11 18 2009
LL Ga2009
410
411
412
413
os
Gary Scaramazzo. (Shipman, Tanja)
(Entered: 11 12 2009)
SUPPLEMENT of | Supplemental
Brief in Support of Motion for Sum-
marv dudgment re 406 Order,, by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Ine. (Neubauer,
Elisabeth) Moditied on IL 13 2009
(SAT). DOCUMENT NOT IN COM-
PLIANCKE WITH LRCiv 7 1e).
ATTORNEY NOTICED. (Entered:
11 12 2009)
RESPONSE re 406 Order,, Supp/le-
mental Brief in| Support of Cross-
Motion for Summary Judgment bv
Plaintiffs ‘Pony Bowe, John McComush,
Nancy MeLain. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 11 18 2009)
SUPPLEMENT of Response — to
Detendant and Detendant-Intervenor’s
Supplemental Briefs re 406 Order,,
410 Supplement, 409 Supplement,
by Intervenor Plaintiffs Arizona Free
Enterprise Club’s Freedom Club PAC,
Anzona ‘Taxpayers Action Committee,
Robert Burns, Dean Martin, Rick
Murphy. (Keller, mothy) (Entered:
11 19 2009)
Notice re Notice of Supplemental
Authority by Ken Bennett, Lor S
Damiels, Jeffrey Lo Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Royvann J Parker, Gary
Scaramazzo (Attachments: # 1
12022009
1209 2009
OLOS 2010
OLS 2010
OLO0G 2010
414
415
416
417
419
5a
Exhibit Attachment AShipman,
Tanja) (Entered: 11/30 2009)
OBJECTION re 413 Other Notice
filed by Tony Bouie, John MeComish,
Nancy McLain. (Dranias, Nicholas)
(Entered: 12/02/2009)
Joinder re 413 Other Notice of Sup-
plemental Authority and Response to
Plaintiffs’ Objection by Intervenor
Detendant Clean Elections Institute,
Inc. filed by Clean Elections Insti-
tute, Inc.. (Neubauer, Elisabeth)
(Entered: 12/09/2009)
Second MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction by Tony Bouie, John
McComish, Nancy MeLain. (Attach-
ments: # 1 Text of Proposed Or-
der) Dranias, Nicholas) (Entered:
01/05/2010)
MEMORANDUM re: Supporting
Plaintiffs’ Second Motion for Prelim-
inary Injunction re 416 Second
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction
by Plaintiffs Tony Bowe, John
McComish, Nancy MeLain. (Dranias,
Nicholas) (Entered: 01/05/2010)
ORDER re Hearing set as to 288
First MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment, 287 First MOTION for Sum-
mary Judgment, 285 First MOTION
for Summary Judgment, 293 MO-
TION for Summary Judgment:
Motion Hearing set for 1/15/2010 at
60
01:30PM before Judge Roslyn O
Silver. FURTHER ORDERED dfts
shall respond to the 2nd motion for
preliminary injunction 416 no later
than 1/11/10. Plas shall file a reply
no later than 1/13/10. Signed by
Judge Roslyn O Silver on 1/6/2010.
(LAD) (Entered: 01/06/2010)
01062010 420 Second MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction by Rick Murphy. (At-
tachments: # 1 Memorandum in
Support of 2nd Motion for Prelimi-
nary Injunction, #2 Affidavit Decl.
Murphy in Support of 2nd Motion for
Preliminary Injunction, # 3 Text of
Proposed Order)Keller, Timothy)
(Entered: 01/06/2010)
OV112010 421 RESPONSE to Motion re 420 Second
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction,
416 Second MOTION for Prelimi-
nary Injunction filed by Ken Ben-
nett, Lori S Daniels, Jeffrey L
Fairman, Donald Lindholm, Royann
J Parker, Gary Scaramazzo. (Ship-
man, Tanja) (Entered: 01/11/2010)
01/11/2010 422 RESPONSE in Opposition re 416
Second MOTION for Preliminary
Injunction and 420 Second Motion
for Prelimary Injuction filed by Clean
Elections Institute, Inc.. (Davis-
Denny, Grant) Modified on 1/15/2010
(DMT, ). DOCKET TEXT MODIFIED
61
TO CORRECT DOCUMENT LINK-
AGE. (Entered: 01/11/2010)
01/11/2010 423 DECLARATION of OF TODD F.
LANG IN SUPPORT OF DEFEND-
ANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS
AND PLAINTIFF-INTERVENOR
RICK MURPHYS SECOND MO-
TIONS FOR PRELIMINARY _IN-
JUNCTION re 421 Response to
Motion by Defendants Ken Bennett,
Lori S Daniels, Jeffrey L Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Royann J Parker,
Gary Scaramazzo. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit 1Shipman, Tanja) (En-
tered: 01/11/2010)
01/11/2010 424 DECLARATION of OF TANJA K.
SHIPMAN IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO
PLAINTIFFS AND PLAINTIFF-
INTERVENOR RICK MURPHYS
SECOND MOTIONS FOR PRELIM-
INARY INJUNCTION re 421 Re-
sponse to Motion by Defendants Ken
Bennett, Lori S Daniels, Jeffrey L
Fairman, Donald Lindholm, Royann
J Parker, Gary Scaramazzo. (Attach-
ments: #1 Exhibit i-15\Shipman,
Tanja) (Entered: 01/11/2010)
01/11/2010 425 DECLARATION of GOVERNOR
JAN BREWER 2010 COMMITTEE
re 421 Response to Motion by De-
fendants Ken Bennett, Lori S Dan-
iels, Jeffrey L Fairman, Donald
Lindholm, Royann J Parker, Gary
OL 122010
OL 1A 2010
OL 132010
OL LS 2010
496
429
430
A
,
y
l
oO.
Searamazzo. Shipman, Tana)
(Entered: O01 11 2010)
ORDER, the parties shall) submit
simultaneous bmeting addressing
the issues ntiioned in this order no
later than 5 p.m. on Januarv 13,
2010; the parties hall submit. re-
sponses no later than 4 p.m. on
January 14, 2010; no rephes shall be
filed. Signed by Judge Roslyn O
Silver on 11210. (REW, ) (Entered:
OL 12 2010)
Notice re Supplemental Authority by
Ken Bennett, Jan Brewer, Lori S
Daniels, Jeffrey LL. Fairman, Donald
Lindholm. Rovann J Parker, Gary
Searamazzo (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit Attachment A\Shipman,
Tanja) (Entered: 01.18 2010)
REPLY in Support re 420 Second
MOTION tor Preliminary Injunction
filed by Tony Boute, John MeComish,
Nancy MeLain. (Attachments: # 1
Affidavit Margaret Dugan, # 2 Afnh-
davit Tony Bowe, # 3 Affidavit
Marcus Osborn, # 4 Affidavit John
Munger, # 3 Affidavit Buz
Mills\Dramas, Nicholas) (Entered:
OL 13 2O1L0)
BRIEF ore: Supplemental Brief
Addressing Court Order re 426
Order, by Plaintiffs Tony Boute, John
MeComish, Nanev MeLain. (Dramas,
OL TARO 10
OL VO1L0
OL 1A 2010
432
433
ASA
o3
Nicholas) Modified on 1 14 2010
(The). INCORRET EVENT SE-
LECTED. ENTRY MODIFIED
FROM MEMORANDUM TO BRIEF
(Entered: OL 18 2010)
MEMORANDUM re Plaintt?
Intervenors’ supplemental bmefing
on scope of rehei and repiv ino sup
port of 2nd motion fer summary
judgment. re 420 Second MOTION
for Preliminary Injunction, 426
Order, bv Intervenor Plaintiffs
Arizona Free Enterprise Club’s
Freedom Club PAC, Arizona Taxpay-
ers Action Committee, Robert Burns,
Dean Marturn, Rick Murphy. (At
tachments: # 1 Affidavit Declaraton
of Dean Martin) Maurer, William)
(Entered: OL 18 2OLO)
SUPPLEMENT of Detendant-
Intervenor’s Supplemental Breting
Regarding Possible Rehet re 426
Order, bv Intervenor Detendant
Clean Elections Institute. — Ine
(Neubauer, Elisabeth) (Entered:
OL 13 2OLO)
BRIEF re DEFENDANTS BRIEF
ADDRESSING ISSUES RAISED IN
THE COURTS 11210 ORDER: re
426 Order, by Detendants Ken Ben
nett, dan Brewer, Lor: S Damels,
Jeffrey L Farman, Donald Landholn,
Rovann Jd Parker. Gary Scaramazzo
(Shipman, Tanja) Medified — on
O4
1 14 2OLO (TLD) INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED. ENTRY MOD.
IFIED FROM SUPPLEMENT PO
BRIEF. (Entered: O1 18 2010)
OL IS2010 485 DECLARATION of David Ligan re
1G4 Supplement by Detendants Ken
Bennett, dan Brewer, Lor S Damiels,
detfrev Lo Fairman, Donald Landholm,
Rovann d Parker, Gary Searamarco
(Shipman, Tanja) Modified | on
114 2010 (TLD) INCORRECT
EVENT SELECTED ENTRY MOD
IFIED FROM AFFIDAVIT PO DEC
LARATION (Entered O1 18 2010)
OLIE2010 486 RESPONSE re 4338 Supplement, (34
Supplement, 426 Order, by Plaintitts
Tony Bouie, dohn MeConush, Nanev
MeLain. (Dranias, Nicholas) (ken
tered: O1 14 2010)
OLIA20LO AST RESPONSE re 433 Supplement,
426 Order, Re Possrhle Relves by
Intervenor Detendant Clean Elec
tions Institute, Ine (Davis Denny,
Grant) (kentered: O1 14 2010)
OL 12010 A388 RESPONSE re 433 Supplement,
434 Supplement, fo Defendant and
Defendant-Intervenor’s dSriefing on
scope of relief bv Intervenor Plain
ufts Arivona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arnvona Taxpay-
ers Acuhion Committee, Robert Burns,
Dean Martin, Rick Murphy. (Maurer,
William) (entered: 01 14 2010)
OL 14 2oOld
OLLADOLO
OL 1492010
OL Le eolo
OLA DOL
OL Ta VOTO
y.)
QM RESPONSE re 486° Response 432
441
442
444
Memorandum, by Defendants Ken
Bennett, dan Brower, Lori S Dames,
Jeffrey L. Foirman, Donald Lindholm,
Rovann J Parker, Gary Scaramay so
(Shipman, Tanga) Entered
OL 14 LOTTO)
DECLARATION ot Declaration ot
Tania KO Shipman re 4389 Response
by Detendants Ken Bennett. Jan
Brewer, Lori S Damels, JetYrev 1.
Fairman, Donald Lindholm, Rovann
J Parker, Garv Scaramaszo (At
tachments: # 1 Exhibit) Exhibit
I\Shipman, Tanga’ Entered
OL Ta 2OLO
DECLARATION of Declaration ot
Carl Seel re 4389 Response by De-
tendants Ken Bennett. Jan Brewer,
Lorn S Damels, Jeffrey Lo Fairman,
Donald Lindholm, Rovann J Parker,
Gary Scaramazzo. (Shipman. Tanja)
(Entered: OL 14 2010)
PROPOSED ORDER trom — the
Chambers of dudge Roslyn O Silver
KREW, ) (Entered: OL 14 2010)
ORDER denving Plaintitts’ 420
Motion tor Prelhminaryv Injunction
Signed by Judge Roslyn O Silver on
L 1s 1LOGREW, ) kntered: 01 18 2010)
Minute Entry Proceedings held
before dudge Roslyn O Silver) Mo
tion Hearing held on 1 1d 200
OLINVOLO
OL INDOLO
OLINVOTO
AAD
440
447
its
regarding documents JSo, 2S), USS,
298, STS, BM38, S99, 404, 416. and
118. IT IS ORDERED all documents
are taken under advisement. Fur-
ther bmeting is ordered as set forth
on the reeord Order to issue. (Court
Reporter Elaine | Cropper }CLB)
(Entered: O1 15 2010)
SUPPLEMENT of DEFENDANTS
SUPPLEMENTAI BRIEF ND
GARDING IMPLEMENTING IN
JUNCTION LIMIPED TO PER
SONAL MONTES by Defendants
Ken Bennett, dan Brewer, Lor: S
Damels, deffrev Lo Fairman, Donald
Lundhelm, Rovann 4 Parker, Gary
Searamazzo. (Grady. Marv) (ken
tered OL TS LOO
DECLARATION of DECLARATION
OF TODD F LANG IN SUPPORT
OF DEFENDANTS SUPPLE
MENTAL BRIEF REGARDING
IMPLEMENTING INJUNCTION
LIMITED TO PERSONAL MONTES
re 445 Supplement by Detendants
Ken Bennett, dan Brewer, Lom S
Damels, Jeffrey Lo Parrman, Donald
landholm, Rovann J Parker, Gary
Scaramarzo. (Attachments: #8 1
Exhibit) Exhibit T\O°Grady, Mary
(Entered: OL 1S 2010
RESPONSE to Defendants’ Supple
mental Bret Regarding Scope of
OL INLOLO
OLINDOLO
tas
449
tv,
Proposed Injunction re 445 Supple
ment by Intervenor Plaintitls Arizo
na Free Enterprise Club's Freedom
Club PAC, Arnvona Taxpavers Action
Committee, Robert Burns, Dean
Martin, Rick Murphy (Maurer,
William) Modified on 1 19 2010
‘TL INCORRECT FVENT SE
LECTED ENTRY MODIFIED
FROM SUPPLEMENT TO. RE
SPONSE (Entered: OL 1S O10)
SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF re Re
sponding to Defendants’ Response to
dan lo Order re 444 Order on Mo
fon fer Leave to File, Order on
Motion to Supplement. Order on
Motion for Hearing or Conference.
Order on Motion tor) Preliminary
Imunection, Order on Motion for
Summary Judgment,...Motion Hear
INS $40 Supplement by Plain
afs Tony Bowe, John MeComush,
Nanev MeLain) (Dramas, Nicholas)
Modaitied on Lis 2ole (TL)
DOCKET TENT MODIFIED FROM
MEMORANDUM TO SUPPLE
MENTAL BRIEF (Entered
OLIN DOL)
SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION
of Marcus Osborn re 448 Memoran
dum, by Plaintiffs Tony Boure, Kevin
Gabbons, John MeConush (Dranias.
Nicholas) Modited on 1192010 (TL)
INCORRECT EVENT SELECTED
OLIN VOLO
OT OOVOLO
OL LaQLOL0
OL POU LOTO
400
45)
os
ENTRY MODILFIFI FROM AFFL.
DAVIT TO SUPPLEMENTAL DEC.
LARATION (Entered OL 1S POLO)
ORDER Defendants shall submit a
repliv addressing the issues outlined
in this order and other matters
raised by Plants no later than
lO ain on January 20, 20LQ Signed
by Judge Roslvn O Silver on 119 10
LSP) (Entered 01 19 2010)
RESPONSE re 450 Order Supple
rental Bricfinas Rewanding the
Courts January 19, 2010 Order by
Intervenor Defendant Clean Elee-
tions Institute, Ine) (Davis-Denny,
Grant) (Entered: O1 20 2010)
2 Reply re 450 Order, 445 Supplement
by Defendants Ken Bennett. dan
Brewer, Lor S Damels, Jeffrey Lb
Fairman, Donald Lindholm, Rovann
J Parker, Gary Scaramasso (Grady,
Marv) (Entered O1 20 2010
ORDER granting the Motions tor
Summary dudgment 2ST and VSs
Anivona Revised Statutes section 1.
M52 may not be apphed IT IS FUR-
THER ORDERED denving — the
Motions for Summary Judgment 285
and 29S TP is FURTHER OR
DERED denving the Motion for
Leave to Pile Separate Response
873 TT Is FURTHER ORDERED
OLLZOLVOTO
OLVOVOULO
OL L010
i » >
4
407
ah
granting the Motions to File Sup
plemental Authority 393° and Sey
IV IS FURTHER ORDERED deny
ing the Motion tor Status Hearnng
404. TP IS FURTHER ORDERED
denving the Motion for Preliminary
Imunction 416 and Motion tor Hear
ing 418 ITP IS FURTHER oR
DERED the Clerk shall enter
judgment in taver of Plaintitts (See
Order tor further details) Signed
by dudge Rosivn © | Silver on
120 1O.CLB) Entered: 01 20 2010)
SUPPLEMENT to the Record wath
New Persuasive Precedent by Plain
tifts Tony Bowe. John MeComish,
Nancy Mclain NOTE. Filed pursu
ant to 454 Order (LSP) (Entered
OLP2T 2010)
SUPPLEMENT to the record wath
US Court of Appeals Decision by
Phantitts Tony Bowe, John MeComuish,
Naneyv Melains NOTE: Filed pursu
ant to 454 Order (LSP) (Entered
OLLT 2010)
CLERK'S JUDGMENT at ts ordered
and adjudged that pursuant to the
Courts order tiled on January 20,
2010 and upon the Court's instruc:
thon therein, qudgment is entered for
the PlaintifYs and against Defend.
ants. (LSP) (Entered: 0121 2010)
OLV2V010
OL V7010
OLVEVola
OLVAVOLO
O17 VOLO
459
401
4o4
40
4G7
Pat
NOTICE OF APPEAL to Sth Cireunt
re 497 dudgment, bv Clean Elections
Institute, Inc. Filing fee received
$ 455.00, receipt number o970-
SS4TLMO. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit
A and B\Neubauer, Ehsabeth)
Modified on 122 2010 TO INCLUDE
DOCUMENT LINKAGE KMG )
(Entered: O1 22 2010)
NOTICE OF APPEAL to 9th Cireunt
re 457 Judgment, by Ken Bennett,
Jan Brewer, Lor: S Damels, Donald
Landholm, Rovann d Parker, Garv
Searamazzo. Filing tee received
S$ 455.00. receipt number O970-
3548008) (Grady, Marv) Modited
on P22 2010 TO INCLUDE DOCU.
MENT LINKAGE (KMG) (Entered
OL 22 2OLO)
Ninth Cireuit Case Number 10-
15165 tor 461 Notice of Appeal Caled
by Bennett! REW) (Entered:
OL 2oOLO1L0)
Ninth Cireuit Case Number 10-
Ls loo for 459 Notice oft Appeal filed
by Clean Elections) (REW) (En-
tered: OL 26 2O10)
TRANSCRIPT filed tor hearing on
Motion Hearing for dates of
OLIS 2010 before dudge Roslyn O
Silver Court Reporter) Elaine Crop-
per Re 461 Notice of Appeal, Tran
scmpt mav be viewed at the court
OL 29 2010
OLVERA VOLO
470
te
re
pubhe terminal oor purchased
through the Court Reporter
Transeriber before the deadline for
Release of Transcript Restriction
After that date i may be obtained
through PACER. Redaction Request
due 217 2010) Redacted Transerpt
Deadline set for GS 1LV010 Release
of Transernpt Restriction set tor
427 2010 (BAS) Entered: O12S 2010)
ORDER of 9th Cirreuit, this court sua
sponte consolidates 10 15165 and 10
15166; the briefing schedule remains
unchanged, re’ 10-15165 and 10
15166 461, 459 Notices of Appeal
(CREW) (Entered: 01 29 2010)
ORDER of 9th Cireunt, that the stay
issued by the district court on Janu-
ary 2O, VOLO is extended pending
further action by the panel assigned
to hear the merits of these appeals.
These consolidated) appeals are
expedited. The briefing schedule ts
reset as indicated in this order. This
cease shall be heard during the week
of Apml 12-16, 2010 in San Francis-
co, Cahforma; appeal case number
10. 15165; 10-15166, as to 461 Notice
of Appeal, filed by Rovann J Parker,
Garv Scaramazzo, Ken Bennett, dan
Brewer, Lor S Damels. Donald
Lindholm, 459 Notice of Appeal, filed
by Clean Elechons institute, Ine.
(DMT) (Entered: 02 08 2010)
OG OS LO LO
48S ORDER of Sth Cireuit as to 46]
Notice of Appeal filed by Royann J
Parker, Gary Scaramazzo, Ken
Bennett, Jan Brewer, Lori S Daniels,
Donald Lindholm, appeal case num-
ber 10-15165 re order from the
Supreme court that the application
to vacate the stay of the District
Court’s Injunction and to stay the
Mandate of the US Court of Appeal
is GRANTED pending the timely
filing and disposition of a petition for
writ of certiorari. (note: see attached
pdf tor complete details) ESL) (En-
tered: 06.08 2010)
73
:eneral Docket
United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit
JOHN MCCOMISH; NANCY MCLAIN;
TONY BOUIE,
Plaintiffs-Appellees,
RORERT BURNS,
Plaintiff-intervenor-Appellee,
Vv.
ARIZONA FREE ENTERPRISE CLUB'S
FREEDOM CLUB PAC; ARIZONA TAXPAYERS
ACTION COMMITEE, agent of Taxpayers Action
Committee; DEAN MARTIN; RICK MURPHY,
Plaintiff-intervenors-Appellees,
KEN BENNETT, in his official capacity as
Secretary of State of the State of Arizona;
GARY SCARAMAZZO; ROYANN J. PARKER:
JEFFREY L. FAIRMAN; LOUIS HOFFMAN:
LORI S. DANIELS, in their official capacities
as members of the Arizona Citizens Clean
Elections Commission,
Defendants-Appellants,
and
CLEAN ELECTIONS INSTITUTE, INC.,
Defendant-intervenor.
01222010 1 DOCKETED CAUSE AND ENTERED
APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL.
SEND MQ: Yes. The schedule is set
as follows: Mediation Questionnaire
01/29/2010
11
74
due by Attorney Mary O’Grady due
on 01/29/2010. Appellant Ken Ben-
nett, Appellant Lori S. Daniels,
Appellant Jeffrey L. Fairman,
Appellant Louis Hoffman, Appellant
Royann J. Parker and Appellant
Gary Scaramazzo opening brief due
05/10/2010. Appellee Arizona Free
Enterprise Club’s Freedom Club
PAC, Appellee Arizona Taxpayers
Action Commitee, Appellee Tony
Bouie, Appellee Robert Burns,
Appellee Dean Martin, Appellee
John McComish, Appellee Nancy
McLain and Appellee Rick Murphy
answering brief due 06/09/2010.
Appellant’s optional reply brief is
due 14 days after service of the
answering brief. [7205486] (GR)
Filed order (BARRY G. SILVER-
MAN, RICHARD A. PAEZ, and
CARLOS T. BEA) This court sua
sponte consolidates appeal Nos. 10-
15165 and 10-15166. All parties on a
side are encouraged to join in a
single brief to the greatest extent
practicable. See 9th Cir. R. 28-4.
The briefing schedule remains
unchanged. Appellees’ emergency
motion to vacate the temporary
appellate stay is denied. Appellants’
emergency motions for a stay pend-
ing appeal will be addressed by
separate order. BEA, dissenting, I
would grant appellees’ motion to
02/01/2010 16
02/16/2010 27
75
vacate the temporary appellate stay.
(7213601) [10-15165, 10-15166] (DAF)
Filed order (BARRY G. SILVER-
MAN, RICHARD A. PAEZ and
CARLOS T. BEA) The stay issued
by the district court on January 20,
2010 is extended pending further
action by the panei assigned to hear
the merits of these appeals. See
California Pharmacists Ass’n _v.
Maxwell-Jolly, 563 F.3d 847, 850
(9th Cir. 2009). These consolidated
appeals are expedited. The briefing
schedule is reset as follows. The
opening briefs and excerpts of
record are due February 9, 2010; the
answering brief is due February 16,
2010; and the optional reply briefs
are due within 3 days after service
of the last-served answering brief.
All parties on a side are encouraged
to join in a single brief to the great-
est extent practicable. This case
shall be heard during the week of
April 12-16, 2010 in San Francisco,
California. BEA, Circuit Judge,
dissenting. (See order for full text of
dissent) [7215926] [10-15165, 10-
15166) — {Edited 02/02/2010 by JI]
(DAF)
Submitted (ECF) Opening brief for
review. Submitted by — Clean Elec-
tions Institute, Inc. and Appellants
Ken Bennett, Lori S. Daniels, Jeffrey
— .
ra)
L. Fairman, Louis Hoffman, Rovann
J. Parker and Gary Secaramacszo in
10-15165, Appellant Clean Elections
Institute, Ince. in 10-15166. Date of
service: 02162010. [7232574] | 10-
15165, 10-15166] (EDN)
02162010 29 Received a copy of Supreme Court
order regarding the application to
vacate the stay presented to Justice
Kennedy and by him reterred to the
Court is demed. (FYI panel)
[7232842] | 10-15165, 10-15166) (RL)
O2172010 80) Filed Appellants’ excerpts of record
in 26 volumes. Served on 02162010.
(FedEx to Panel) (723423-4] [10-15165,
10-15166] CLA)
O2172O10 31) Notice of Oral Argument on APRIL
12, 2010 Calendar. Please return
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF HEAR-
ING NOTICE torm to: SAN FRAN-
CISCO Office. Attention: The Notice
of Docket Activity may not list vour
case number. Please open attached
documents to view details about
your case. [7234460] [10-15165, 10-
15166] (AM)
O22H2010 37 Received Supreme Court 9 order
dated 02:16 2010. The application to
vacate the stay presented to dusitce
Kennedy and by him referred to the
Court is denied. Denial is without
prejudice to a renewed application
on 61/2010, or when the Court of
O802 2010
O8 02 VOLO
QSAR VOTO
V804 L010
Ss
40
|
Appeals has issued its decision on
the merits of the case, whichever
date is earher. | 7246884) | 10-15165,
10-15166) (GV)
Submitted CECE) Answernng bnei
tor review. Subnutted by Appellees
Tony Bowe, dohn MeComish and
Nanev MeLain in i0-lolee. Date ot
service: OS OL LOLO. [T24ASS7T7T] [| 10-
15165, 10-15 166) (COURT UP-
DATE: Attached corrected version of
Answering Briet. O38 O02 2010 by RY!
NCD)
Submitted (CECE) Answering bret
tor review. Submitted by Appellees
Arnona Free Enterprise Club's
Freedom Club PAC, Arizena Tax-
pavers Action Commitee, Robert
Burns, Dean Martin and Rick Mur-
phy in 10-1565) Date of service
VS O2 LALO, [F2H04GO}] (10-15 165,
10-1L51l66 (WRM)
Piled Plaintifs-intervenors-Appelices
Dean Martin, et al’s supplemental
excerpts of record on appeal in. 1
volume. [725LV578) [| 10-15165, 10-
15166) (LA)
Filed Plaintitts-Appellees Tony Bowne,
John MeComish and Nanev Melain
supplemental excerpts of record on
appeal in 3 volumes. [72538752] [ 10-
15165, 10-15166) (LAS
OS 09 VOTO
O29 VOLO
OA TLVOLO
OS 17 VOL
46
4s
~j
Submitted (ECE) Amicus bret tor
review and filed Motion to become
amncus curtae. Submitted by Center
for Competitive Politics Date of
service: OS OMVOLA [FZHSO LL] 1 10-
15165, 10-15166) (SMH)
Submitted (ECE) Reply brief for
review Submitted by — Clean Elee-
tions Institute, Inc. and Appellants
Ken Bennett, Lom S. Damels, Jettrey
L. Farman, Louis Hoffman, Revann
J. Parker and Gary Scaramazco in
1O- 18165. Date of service: 03 09 LOO
TLAMNNS? | 1O-15165, 10-15166) (GD)
Kiled clerk order (Deputy Clerk SC)
The unopposed motion of the Center
for Competitive Politics for leave to
file brief of amicus curiae in support
of appellees urging affirmance 1s
granted, and the proposed amicus
bret. lodged with the motion, ts
ordered filed. (7262720) (10-15165,
10-1To166) (SC)
Filed (ECF) Clean Elections In-
stitute, Inc) and Appellants Ken
Bennett, Lori So Damels, Jetirey L
Fairman, Louts Hottman, Roevann J
Parker and Gary Searamayczo in 10
15165 Motion to file substitute or
corrected bret) Date of service
OB 17 ZOO, [F2EG9ISGS!) 1100-15165,
LO- 15166) (GD)
OS INVOLO
OS VaVvolo
OAVOVOLO
OS81 VO
O44 OLVOLO
ao!
.»)
e,.?
™
os
oO
fh
Filed (ECE) Appellees Tony Bowe,
dohn MeComish and Nanev MelLain
In 1O-15166 ertation of supplemental
authornties. Date of service O38 TS VOLO
PT2T TY TOTS BS, L018 166) NCD)
Filed (ECF) Appellees Anzona Free
Enterprise Club's Freedom Club PAC,
Arnvona taxpavers Action Commntee,
Rebert Burns, Dean Martin and
Rick Murphy in 1015165 eutation of
supplemental authorities. Date of
service: O8 2E VOTO, [7280827] [10-
LS165, 10-15166) (TDK)
Filed (ECE) Appellees Arivona Free
Enterprise Club's Freedom Clab PAC,
Anvona Taxpayers Action Commitee,
Robert Burns, Dean Martin) and
Rick Murphy in 10-15165 citation of
supplemental authorities Date of
service: O38 VO VOLO. [TR2SOSS0) | 10-
LS165, 10-15 168) (TDK)
Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:SC
Appellants’ Motion to File Corrected
Opening and Reply Briets is granted
and the corrected briefs appended to
the motion are deemed filed The
Clerk shall inform appellants whether
the separate electronic and or paper
tilings of said brets will be required
Le 2S8H3846) [10-15 165, 10-15 1668) (SC
Submitted CECE) Opening bref for
review Submitted by — Clean Elec
tions Institute, Inc. and Appellants
OLOL VOTO
OF LZVOLO
OQAVTVYOLO
OO 2010
wl
ty)
OO
Se
O,
SU
Ken Bennett, Lorn S) Damels, Jeffrey
L. Fairman, Louis Hoffman, Rovann
J) Parker and Garv Scaramaceo in
LO-1L5165.) Date of service O4 02 2010
OPZSS1T35) (10-15 165, 10-15 1660 CRAIN
Submitted (ECE) Reply brief for re
view Submitted by Clear Elec
tions Institute, Inc. and Appellants
Ken Bennett, Lom So Damets, Jetfrev
lL. Fairman, Lous Hotfman, Rovann
J) Parker and Gary Secaramaszo in
LO-1TS165. Date of service: O4 02 2010
(TRSSIST) ELO-1LS 165, 10-15166) CRIN)
ARGUED AND SUBMIPTED TO
ANDREW KLEINEFELD, A
WALLACE TASHIMA and SIDNEY
R THOMAS [7287581) (10-15165,
10-15 166) RS)
FILED OPINION (ANDREW J
KLEINEFELD, A WALLACE
TASHIMA and SIDNEY R
THOMAS) REVERSED AND RE
MANDED Judge AJK Concurring,
Judge AWT Authoring, Judge
PILED AND ENTERED JUDG
MENT (7845699) [10-15165, 10
LS166) RE
Received letter trom the Supreme
Court dated OG OL LOLO re: The up
pheation to vacate stay is demed
without premadice (7354997) | 10-
Lo165, 10-15166) HED
OGL POLO
OG OE VOTO
OQaOy VOLO
OG OS VOLO
Gs
S1
Received letter dated OS 26 2010 re
requests that the Court de
publish current opinion and reissue
mo owathout the language discussing
Governor Symingten’s tarled crim
nal prosecution. | 7357386) | 1LO-1S165,
10 1Lh166) (GY)
Reeaved Supreme Court onder dated
OG OLLOLO The apphleation to vacate
the stay presented to Justice Kenne-
dv and by him referred to the Court is
demed without prerudice to a renewal
appucation af the parties represent
that thev intend to file a timely pe
tition for a owrit of certiorart betore
this Court. The motion of Buss Whills
for Governor Campaign for leave to
file a bmef as amicus cumae is granted
BOBS 7TS) [TO TS165, TO 1S 166) (GV)
Received letter dated O68 08 2OLO
from Attorney John Dowd reo con-
tinue to respecfully request that the
Court de-publish its Maw Zl. 2010
opinion. | FS3B4164) 1O-1S1T65,) 10
Ls1668) (GV)
Received letter from the Supreme
Court dated QGOS 2010 re The appl
cation to vacate the stay of the dis-
trict courts inpunetion and to stay
the mandate of the 9th Cireuit is
GRANTED pending the timely tilhns
and disposition of a petition for a writ
of certiorari [73864057) (10-15168,
1015166) (HH)
(My LOVOLO
Ws 1T VOLO
OW VAVOLO
ONVAVO 10
ON VA VOLO
|
—
su
Sl]
S2
Biled (ECE) Appellees Tony Bowie,
John MeComish and Nancy MeLain
in LO-15166 Motion to stay the man-
date) Date of service 06 10-2010
T3OS8477) | 10-15165, 10-15 166) NCD)
Filed order (ANDREW. J. KLEIN.
FELD, A WALLACE TASHIMA and
SIDNEY RO THOMAS) The motion
of plaintiffs-appellees to stay issu-
ance ot the mandate is demed as
moot, Inasmuch as our mandate has
already been staved by the order of
the Supreme Court, issued on dune
8S. VOLO, in No. OYATIOS. [7375354]
(10-15165, 10-15166) (SC)
biled order and amended opimon
ANDREW Jo KLEINFELD. A
WALLACE TASHIMA and SIDNEY
R THOMAS) Amending Disposition
Opimien REVERSED AND RE-
MANDED. [738 18S37) (10 14165, 10-
15166) (PED
Received notice from the Supreme
Court) petition for certioran: tiled on
OS 17 2OLO Supreme Court Number
LO-V398 [FT44S1T86) [10-15165, 10-
1S 166) (LC)
Received notice from the Supreme
Court: petition for certiorart filed on
OS 17 2010. Supreme Court Number
LO-VSS. [7448140] [10-15165, 10-
15166) (LOC)
S3
LPBQVOIO =ST Received notice from the Supreme
Court. Petition tor certioran
GRANTED on LL 29 2010) Supreme
Court Number 10-239. The petition
tor Cert in No 10-238 is granted
The cases are consohdated and a
total of 1 howr *s alloted tor oral
argument. [75622241 (10-15165, 10-
LS166) (GV)
S4
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed Jun. 18, 2009)
(Tithe Omitted In Printing!
25 factors guiding state policy
Who's got the ‘quice when it comes Capitol influence?
| \
2 \a
juice: Slang Pohtical power or influence; clout. The
Free Dictronary
When they overwhelmingly approved term limits in
1992, Arizona voters transferred a slice of intluence
on public pohey from the elected to the non-elected.
“Lobbyists have more influence. and dectsions are not
always based on a historical mindset.” Rep. Laura
Knaperek, R-17, said
In 1998, voters passed the Clean Elections Act, a
controversy-laden initiative providing candidates for
state office the option of puble funding for their
campaigns a change in election law that some
observers say has actually tilted the Legislature more
to the right.
And voters through other ballot measures, including
the Voter Protection Act and separate measures
requiring a two-thirds °
and that a funding source be designated for mew
‘supermajority” to raise taxes
spending, continue to have “juice” when it comes to
state law, pohey and direction under which elected
officials must govern.
SO
Voters
For its significant influence on state government
albeit many voters may consider themselves power-
less to change anything — the electorate is one of the
25 most influential factors guiding state policy, as
selected by Arizona Capitol Times, based on research
and a series of interviews with people im and close to
stale government.
Term limits
Many lawmakers who supported term limits at the
time now rue the day because, they say, the result
has been a diminution of institutional knowledge in
the halls of the Legislature and a transfer of a good
deal of influence to individual lobbyists, lobbying
organizations and legislative staff, notably those that
have been around tor decades.
In an October 2004 report, The Morrison Institute on
Public Pohey at Arizona State University concluded
the effects of term limits reform have been positive
and negative.
“When it comes to policy, observers saw term hmits
hindering legislative efforts to deal with long-range
problems ... and with complicated matters such as
the budget.” the Institute stated.
“(Tlerm limits have encouraged greater competition
for legislative and other seats and have given voters a
greater choice among candidates. At the same time,
they have generally reduced the power of legislative
Sb
leaders and generally increased the influence of
lobbyists, though not all lobbyists and staff have
gained equally”
The Institute concluded from a series of interviews
with legislators and lobbvists that new lawmakers
might rely too heavily on lobbyists tor information,
“and some, no doubt, have been misled as a result.”
Morrison added that lobbyist influence is less in the
Senate because many
A challenge by Rep. David Burnell Smith, R-7, to its
constitutionality is) the latest argument leveled
against the Clean Elections Act, which, according to
recent polling, is still supported by voters who ap-
proved the public financing of state campaigns seven
vears ago. Like term limits, the act had unintended
consequences, say its opponents.
“The primary effect of pubhe financing has been to
increase the influence of social conservatives by
enabling them to compete in Republican primaries
with business-backed candidates, who tend to be
more moderate, writes former legislator Greg Patter-
son on his Republican blog, “Espresso Pundit.”
“Despite the availability of puble funding, special
interests exerted considerable influence,” he wrote.
“First they served as bagmen for the $5 contributions
needed to quality for public funding. Labor unions
were the most conspicuous players this time around,
but in future elections we can expect environmentalist,
the Religious Right, or even political parties to act as
‘“_
di
power brokers by offering rosters of $5 donors to
would-be candidates.
“Clean Elections didn’t push the right wing to the
margin of Arizona politics. Instead it freed them from
having to go hat in hand to the more moderate cham-
ber of commerce types and their liberal trophy wives.”
For the same reasons, liberal candidates have bene-
fited from the Clean Elections Act, observers say.
In the House, 12 of 16 ultra-conservatives ran publicly
funded last year, and four of eight ultraconservatives
in the Senate were Clean Elections candidates.
What lawmakers said
Arizona Capitol Times in a separate e-mail survey of
legislators asked whom or what they would name as
the number-one influencer of public policy. Their
answers included:
Tim Hogan
The National Rifle Association
Clean Elections
Marty Shultz
“Business”
Kevin DeMenna
The Constitution
YO
oe
Top 25, influencers of state policy
(In alphabetical order)
Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry
Arizona Hospital and Healthcare Association
Arizona Medical Association
* + *
89
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
[Title Omitted In Printing]
(Filed Jun. 12, 2009)
CLEAN MONEY = CLEAN ELECTIONS
GIVE AVERAGE CITIZENS MORE
PRESENTATION!
REDUCE AND LIMIT CAMPAIGN SPENDING!
STOP THE ENDLESS MONEY CHASE!
STOP SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY!
LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD!
Recent polls found voters wanted the all of
the above. True, various legislation is in the works
that would address some of these issues. But, if we
are really serious about meaningful reform, all of
these problems can and must be included.
Currently, only wealthy or well-connected candi-
dates run for office because they can raise the $$$.
Abe and George wouldn’t have stood a chance in our
last election.
The cost of winning the average US House race
has more than doubled in the last 10 years. In the
1996 elections, nearly $800 million was spent on
congressional campaigns.
As soon as we elect our representatives, their
primary concern is how they will raise the money
necessary for their re-election. For some, they weigh
their guaranteed retirement benefits with their
alternative of grubbing for $$$ and choose the easier
alternative.
90)
And for those who choose to run tor re-election,
all the time they spend raising money is time
they are not spending tending to the business
they were hired to manage.
As it is now, the largest donors buy the ears of
our elected representatives. Special favors and tax
breaks are the pavbacks expected (and delivered in
far too many cases) for generous campaign contribu-
tions.
By limiting the candidates who are able to raise
$$$ required to run for publhe office, we now elim.-
nate people whose primary interests are those that
represent our values.
By reducing the ante to get into the game, we
open the process to a more diverse pool of can-
didates representing broader interest
The guy who coined the phrase “Build a better
mouse trap and vou get a smarter mouse” could never
had envisioned the ingenious loopholes our lobbyists
have created.
While some in the beltway don't think anything
is broken therefore nothing needs to be fixed. others
are concerned with what may have been illegal fund
raising in our last session.
Truth is, it is what is legal that makes voters
crazy. If private business attempted to operate in this
manner, they would immediately be visited by our
alphabet soup of federal agencies empowered to
“protect the citizens.”
|
So, what is the alternative”?
Our coahtion, Arizonans For Clean Elections,
has been working on a solution that would address
all the current corruptive practices on a state
level
We have concluded that the only plan that deals
with all the major problems of our current system 1s
the clean money solution using total public
financing. A 10% surtax on all eri and ermminal
fines currently provided under state law could finance
the clean elections fund
It would lower the cost and length of cam-
paign and block special interests from using their
campaign contributions to promote their special
interests that may not be in the interests of the man
on the street
Candidates who choose to use tetal public
financing will have to agree to the following
conditions
.
Gather a set number of $35) contributions
from voters in their district
Accept no private tinancing uncluding special
interests. mech relatives or their own piggy
bank)
Accept spending limits
Shorten campaign time
0)
This is not about giving money to politi-
cians, it's about the public taking power - tak-
ing control over our elections
Your choice Keep the existing system where
the rich and special interest have the control or join
us and make CLEAN MONEY = CLEAN ELEC-
TIONS a reality’
Marilou Stanley. State Director
United We Stand America-Arizona 6OD-972-2969
Member of Arizonans For Clean Elections Coalition
YS
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed dun. 1’. DOO)
(Tithe Omitted In Printing’
Clean Money, Clean Elections
Visit our website at: www.azclean.org
Limit campaign & Clean Elecuon candidates must
spending
Remove the
influence of big
money from
politics
Level the playing
field for voters
and candidates
agree to fined spending limuts
@ Clean Election candidates may
only raise a limuted amount of
private Mone
7?
. '
All Clean) Election candidates
who agree to spending kmuts and
demonstrate a broad base of
support) received a fixed and
equal amount of craven funds tor
the pmnmarv and general elec
ons
“Issues trom healthcare to the environment are not
being decided on merit, but by campaign contribution
This abuse must stop.”
Ida Schwartz, President
AZ League of Women Voters
Shes
“Senators and Representatives weigh
every decision against the question, ‘How wall
this affect my fundraising prospects” rather than
‘How will this affect the national interest?”
Former US senator Barry Goldwater (R-AZ)
w4
Td find out more. call
Arizonans for Clean Elections
(O02) 840-6633 or email into@azclean. org
Paid tor and authorized by
Arnizonans tor Clean Elections
Endorsed by: League of Women Voters
and The Sierra Club
U
Q
Oh
SS. District Court for the District of Arizona
Filed dun. 12. Bod)
Tithe Omitted In Printing!
“YEAH, BUT...”
For more information,
contact “Arivonans tor Clean Elections”
B336 No S2nd Street. Suite 106,
Phoenix, AZ SSOTS, (602) 840-6635
> «dee
E-mail info@azelean org Fax: 602-2236
The Most Asked Questions About Arizona's
Clean Money, Clean Elections Initiative
What does the Arizona Clean Monev. Cican
*, ,
. ‘, " see 7. ‘
Rlecthions Jrrtiative he
The Initiative addresses the most serious prob
lems that concern voters. It wall
~ hmit campaign spending
~ shorten the campaign period
prohitnt special-interest contributions to par
ticipating candidates
~ eliminate the need for candidates & lawmakers
to waste valuable Gime doing tund raising so
they can instead focus full time on doing: their
robs
~ provide a level plaving field. financially, so
good people without money or connections to
special interests have a fair chance to run for
office
Qe
How will the Initiative accomplish these goals
Candidates would receive a set amount of money
from the Anzona Clean Elections Fund if they
voluntanmly agree to reject all private special.
interest contmbutions, to limit campaign spend-
ing, and to shorten their campaign season
Before receiving money from the Fund, candi-
dates would first have to demonstrate that they
had public support by collecting a specific num-
ber of $5 “quahtving contributions” to be deposit-
ed into the Anzona Clean Elections Fund
Candidates who choose to raise money by contin
uing to use the old system ~ accepting contmbu-
tions from wealthy special interests ~ would be
faced with various disincentives to raise more
money than a Clean Elections opponent
It toughens up election laws by providing more
oversight of campaign finance reports and in-
creasing fines for those who break the laws that
govern our democratic elections
[sit constitutional:
Yes. According to the U.S. Supreme Court, publi
financing of election campaigns ts constitutional
as long as the system is voluntary. Candidates do
not have to choose it; they are free to reject publie
financing and continue raising and spending pri-
Vate money, just as betore
ls there realiv a need for Clean Monev Campaign
Reform ina state like Arizona:
Yes. Despite past reforms, special-interest money
still dominates AZ elections. The majority of the
Y7
money comes from a very few wealthy individu
als, corporations, and PACs. Only '. of 1% of the
American public gives more than $200 in cam-
paign donations to candidates. Most candidates
have to get money to run their campairns from
somewhere to compete; if not from us, then
where?
Here hes the problem. Who do you suppose has
the ready cash tor campaigns’ Those very
wealthy special interests who have an issue be-
tore the Legslature. The concentration of that
much political power ~ or the ability to dispropor-
tionately effect who gets elected ~ by a very smal!
number of Amzonans is inherently undemocratic
In short, money talks, especially in politics, and
campaign money is coming from the same inter-
ests who will be lobbving in Phoenix when Elec-
tion Day is over
, , ’
d . : bys? .¢ , ~. | .
Are Vou SQNVINA that Os contributors OWUV AU rr
ers voles:
No candidate would sav that a contribution trom
a special interest lobbyist would buy a specific
vote. But one does question whether special
interest groups would contribute as much as they
do today, sometimes millions of dollars, if they
didn't think they would benefit in some way
lf a baseball plaver were to give a thousand
dollars to an umpire before the umpire called him
“safe” or “out,” we'd call ita bribe. Pemod. Ifa de
fense lawver were to give a thousand dollars to
each member of a jury and the judge before they
reached a decision or ruled on a case, we'd want
that lawver disbarred and thrown in jail,
Q
Q
9S
Yet we allow big business, the wealthy, and
special-interest groups to make large contribu-
tions to the very people who will vote on legisla-
tion that effects their future business profits
concerns. We are not saying that these contribu-
tions are buying influence or votes. However, one
might question why corporate welfare blossoms
in AZ. During the last few years, our politicians
have doled out huge corporate welfare subsidies,
predominantly to the largest and most powerful
businesses. The Diamondbacks got $240 millon
for their stadium. Intel got about $180 millon for
their Chandler factory, and Sumitomo got about
$165 million for their north Phoemix factory.
Even Dial Corporation received $7 millon when
they downsized their workforce by 250 jobs and
moved to Scottsdale
What makes vou think candidates will choose to
finance their campaigns with Clean Money?
There wall be strong incentives for candidates. No
elected official hikes having to spend so much
time raising money, vear in and year out. No
challenger looks forward to the task of trying to
raise the huge sums of money being spent today
And what candidate or elected official enjovs the
public perception, if not the reality, that thev are
compromised by their acceptance of large contri-
butions from special interests”
Wont the publicly-funded candidates still get
buried by wealthy, self-financed candidates who
do not need to fund ratse and can spend as much
monev as thev want ~ such as Steve Forbes &
Ross Perot:
99
No. Under this Initiative, participating candi-
dates will get a dollar-for-dollar match, up to a
set limit. If a non-participating opponent spends
more than the public financing limit, the Clean
Money candidate is eligible for up to three times
the set amount. In addition, under a system that
offers public funding. candidates will have the
“free-of-special-interest” leverage that a Clean
Money campaign will provide. This benefits the
image of al] candidates that participate.
How much will Clean Money Campaign Reform
cost? How will tt be patd for?
Assuming near total participation by candidates,
we estimate this system would cost approximate-
lv $8 milhon a vear from a state budget of $6 bil-
hon, or about $5 per vear per tax paving family.
Revenue for the Clean Money Fund will come
from a combination of sources. Funding sources
include a $5 check off on state income tax forms
(a taxpaver that checks this box also receives a
$5 reduction in the amount of tax owed), a $100
annual fee for lobbvists representing commercial
or for-profit activities, a 10°% surcharge on civil
and criminal fines and penalties, plus taxpavers
may redirect tax owed to the state to the Clean
Elections Fund (up to 20% or $500 whichever is
greater). All the $5 “qualfving contributions”
candidates collect would also be put in the Fund.
To put the cost of Clean Elections in perspective,
if we simply repealed the 1997 legislature's tax
cut mveaway to the 1,300 people who already
make more than a million dollars a vear, we
would have enough money to pay for the whole
proposal.
Q
100
What is “Arizonans for Clean Elections?”
Arizonans for Clean Elections is a growing,
broad-based citizens’ organization that is bring-
ing energy, hope and concrete solutions to the
campaign finance reform movement. It is a non-
partisan organization that is working toward
putting a Clean Money, Clean Elections Initia-
tive on the Arizona ballot in 1998. Supporters
currently include the League of Women Voters of
Arizona, Common Cause of Arizona, Arizona Si-
erra Club, National Organization for Women,
National Association of Letter Carriers, United
We Stand-Arizona, Arizona Citizens Action, sev-
eral community leaders, and the list goes on.
Coalition members believe the way to end the
corrupting relationship between special interests
and politicians is to offer another way to finance
campaigns. They believe if candidates choose
Clean Money Campaign Reform, they can free
themselves of big-money special interest & the
conflict of interest that invariably follows. The
coalition is offering citizens, candidates, & politi-
clans a better way.
Citizens must get engaged, take responsibility for
the problem, and solve it. Please join the team
and help make democracy work in Arizona. Apa-
thy translates Into approval of the current sys-
tem.
Won't the public see this as just another govern
ment spending program, or worse, a welfare pro-
gram for politicians?
A
101
Clearly, the public distrusts politicians, and
taxpayers are wary of new public expenditures.
However, Clean Money Campaign Reform is very
likely to save taxpayers money. Studies show
that wealthy individuals and powerful corpora-
tions who supply most of the money for congres-
sional campaigns are the recipients of billions of
dollars of unnecessary tax breaks, subsidies, and
regulatory exemptions. By eliminating candi-
dates’ dependence on these big-money donors,
Clean Money reform will make it more likely that
lawmakers will be able to say ‘no’ to these kinds
of costly giveaways.
Won't Clean Money enable “fringe candidates” to
run for office with public money?
The public has a right to support whomever it
wants, but qualifying requirements will be stiff
enough to deter fringe candidates who lack public
support from getting public financing. Some form
of public financing already exists in 22 states and
a number of municipalities. Where these systems
are in place, the fears that opponents had raised
about public money going to fringe candidates
have not come to pass.
What about the person who says, “I can’t give time
to help a candidate. Why shouldn't I be allowed to
give money?”
People will still be able to give money after
Clean Money reform. During the primary period,
they can give a $5 “qualifying contribution” and
a small amount in “seed money” to help their fa-
vorite candidate qualify for public financing.
And, of course, they can still make a financial
102
contribution to a political party. It’s important to
point out that contributing money to political
campaigns is not one of the principal ways most
people participate in the political process. Studies
show that 96% of the American people make no
political contributions at all, & that most of the
money in congressional races comes from less
than '/: of 1% of the population.
Why total public financing? Why not push for
partial public financing, or a matching system
like the one we have for presidential primaries.
This past round of presidential primaries, lke
the ones before it, made it abundantly clear that
providing matching money does not solve the
problems that the public is rightly concerned
about. If candidates must solicit or use any spe-
cial interest or private money, they have com-
promised their independent position.
Is the passage of a Clean Money, Clean Elections
Initiative a real possibility or Just wishful think-
ing?
Clean Money Campaign Reform is more than a
dream or wishful thinking. It’s already state law
in Maine, where it was approved by voters in
Nov. by a 56 to 44 percent victory. A grassroots
movement is gaining momentum across the U.S.,
and nearly two dozen other states are working on
similar items.
A system similar to this has worked successfully
in Tucson for years for their city elections. As a
result, candidates for mayor spend less now in
real dollars than they did ten years ago ~ a
>
103
statement that is not true of any other major city
in the country.
What's the long-term strategy/goal?
The national strategy is to focus on the state
level first. Maine’s passage of full public financ-
ing for candidates was the first step in the jour-
ney toward the end goal of passage of such
legislation on the federal level. It is hoped that 3
or 4 more states will pass similar legislation in
1998 ~ the leaders of this movement are looking
to Arizona to be one of those states. Once the
public has demonstrated broad support for this
idea across the nation, we will then demand that
Congress pass a similar system for all federal
elections, including Congress & the presidency.
Senators Paul Wellstone, John Kerry, and John
Glenn have introduced a Clean Money, Clean
Elections bill in the Senate. But they need the
grassroots support from across the country to
make our congressional representatives listen.
After all, the majority of the elected officials
aren't going to upset the system that got them
where they are. The system worked for them, so
obviously, in their eyes, the system isn’t broken,
so why fix it? We need to help enlighten them
and push for change ... change that makes
$ense!
LO4
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed Jun. 12, 2009)
{Title Omitted In Printing!
Difficult questions about Clean Elections:
We must be prepared to answer difficult questions on
our initiative. Imitiatives are susceptible to attack
because generally the public knows httle about their
details and is more apprehensive about “the devil
they don’t know” than “the devil they know.” Here are
some responses to the most difficult questions.
Will this increase my taxes?
No, it won't. Taxpavers may direct a portion of their
tax obligation to the Clean Elections Fund. but thev
do not have to pay more than before. In fact, it’s just
the opposite of a tax increase. Clean Elections will
result in savings. Under our current system, special
interests get tax breaks and subsidies as a result of
currving favor with elected officials. Clean Elections
severs the link between special interests and the
politicians we elect and will help eliminate the “pork”
projects that cost taxpavers millions every vear
How much will this cost?
Very little. To get big money out of state elections and
to reduce campaign spending. Clean Elections will
cost less than 2 percent of the current dudget surplus.
It amounts to approximately $5 for each Arizona
household. Compared to the special favers and tax
105
breaks that wealthy individuals and special interests
get in return tor their contributions, Clean Elections
should result in a savings of tax dollars. The annual
appropnation for the fund would be capped, and anv
extra funds allocated would roll back to the genera!
fund.
Where will the money come from?
We think the money should come from savings in tax
breaks and subsidies that corporate special interests
now get for their campaign contributions. If voters
pass Clean Elections. money will come trom an in-
creased fee on lobbyists. a $5 voluntary tax check-ot?
that features a $5 rebate, a 10% surcharge on civil
and criminal fees and fines. Taxpavers mav also
direct up to 20> or $500 of their tax obligation to the
Clean Elections Fund
Who would administer the Clean Elections
fund?
The Clean Elections Commission will administer and
oversee the system. The committee would be picked
from a pool of candidates nominated by the judiciary
nomination board. The highest ranking official from
each party would choose from the candidates sequen-
tially.
106
Will this create a new, larger bureaucracy?
No. Voters need an enforcement agenev that has the
power and the teeth to oversee elections, and to
identity and correct violations of the law when thev
happen - not after the election is won or lost. Today,
Arizona has some of the strictest election laws in the
country, but they are not enforced. Many legislators
do not file complete reports and they are not on time
We should be proud that here in Arizona we will have
an independent and effective agency set up to admin-
ister disclosure. We learned in 1994 that tinkering
with the current svstem — through lewer contmbution
limits alone — won't fix the problem. We need both
spending and contribution lumits. Providing free or
reduced media time to candidates who agree to
spending hmuits and to reject big money from special
interests should be an important piece of federal
reform. But free TV time alone won't eliminate the
influence of special interest money on candidates and
elected officials. Tnstead. uo simply subsidizes the
private financing of public officials. It’s throwing good
money — or resources - after bad. The airwaves do
belong to the public. but so dees our government.
Let's not have one without the other
I'm all for campaign finance reform, but not
this.
Let's go back to basics: reform must get rid of special
interest money: make elections more competitive;
level the playing field: return to the principle of one
1O7
person, one Vote, and give average people a fair shot
to run and win elective office. Clean Elections is the
only retorm proposed in this state that accomplishes
these goals. The “I’m for reform but not this” argu-
ment is a classic dodge that defenders of the status
quo on Beacon Hill and Capito! Hill use to eriticize
proposals that challenge their power It allows them
to say they support something while doing nothing.
Lets not fall into that trap. Clean Elections is the best
alternative to get the kinds of results voters are
looking for reducing the influence of big money in
poltuics, setting reasonable spending limits, lev eling
the playing field, ending the monev chase. and short-
ening campaigns for all candidates and voters alike
It is the only proposal endorsed by leading Republi
cans and Democrats in Arizona, major newspapers,
many citizen orgamivations, and leading publi fig-
ures. Citizens are working feverishly to collect the
signatures to get on the ballot. If vou want campaign
finance reform now, Clean Elections is the answer
The initiative is unnecessarily complicated.
It's actually quite straightforward. I've read it. Cam
paign finance reform is an inherently complicated
problem and no comprehensive reform is simple
Arizona voters are more than smart enough to read
and understand the importance of the Clean Flee
tions Law. They certainly understand the current
special interest-controlled svstem doesn't work for
them. Clean Elections sets spending limits, contmbu
tion limits, and provides a fixed amount of money for
LOS
qualified candidates. It ends the money chase and
shortens campaigns. It’s as simple as that
Isn't it ironic that you're going to raise large
contributions and spend lots of money to win
campaign finance reform?
It takes money to get big money out of politics. We're
talking about far-reaching, but common sense reform
We have our work cut out for us Do veu think
opponents of reform will think twice about doing
what they always do — spending lots of monev on
negative distorting TV ads to defeat this” We can't tie
our hands behind our back. Our democracy is too
MMportant
109
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed Jun. 13, 2009)
(Title Omitted In Printing}
Justification for Clean Elections Matching Funds
There are two main reasons for matching funds:
fairness and limiting overall campaign spending.
Fairness
Currently, legislative candidates receive $28.300 in
base funding ($11.3820 primary, $16,980 general) For
governor, $950,000 ($380,000 primary, $570,000
general)
Obviously, if an opponent raises two or three times
that amount, Clean Elections candidates will be
vastly outspent and will most likely defeated. Match.
ing funds promote tairness, and elections are decided
by who has the best ideas, not the most money.
Some have proposed eliminating matching tunds and
giving each Clean Elections candidate a higher base
amount. Again this leaves CE candidates at the
merey of a good traditional fundraiser, who knows up
front how much to raise in order to outspend the CE
candidate
A higher base amount ts wasteful in situations where
the CE candidate is running unopposed) And there
may come a day when a higher initial grant would
cause a shortfall in the Clean Elections Fund.
L110
Matching funds limit spending.
A traditional candidate may think twice about raising
additional funds in a race against a Clean Elections
candidate. For every dollar raised above the base
amount, the CE candidate is matched There is no
incentive for the traditional candidate to raise and
spend more, unless that candidate intends to out-
spend the CE candidate by going bevond three times
the initial grant.
The initial grant amount sets the tone for the race. In
a race with two or more CE candidates, all must
abide by the initial amount.
Without matching funds, many contests will simply
become bidding wars. [ts becoming more common-
place for nonparticipating state senate candidates to
exceed $100,000 in spending (Jim Weters and Barbara
Leff in 2002, Jake Flake, Bill Konopnicki and Slade
Mead in 2004).
With the Clean Elections matching funds system, it
can be argued that millions of dollars in spending
never takes place. That money should come back to
consumers in lower prices and fewer favors for the
special interests who otherwise would be donating.
Ll
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed Jul. 17, 2009)
[Title Omitted In Printing]
ELECTION REFORM STUDY COMMITTEE
Il.
VIL.
VILL.
FINAL REPORT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Subject Page
Introduction l
Recommendations for Lobbyist Registra-
tion and Disclosure Requirements 3
Recommendations for Election Laws,
Personal Disclosure Requirements and
Entorcement N)
Recommendations for Campaign Ethics Li
Recommendations tor Initrative and Ref
erendum LY
Recommendations for Campaign Fi-
nance 20
Minutes from meetings of Election Re-
form Study Committee Appendix A
July 11, 1991
July 18, 1991
August 1, 1991
September 5, 1991
September 12, 1991
Draft lemslation tor Lobbyist Remstration
and Disclosure Requirements Append:x B
IX.
112
Draft legislation for Elections Laws,
Personal Disclosure Requirements and
Enforcement Appendix C
Arizona Election Commission (with
amendment)
Election laws; penalties
State officers; terms
State officers; term limits
State officers; salary
Legislators; per diem; subsistence
Independent expenditure disclosure
Primary elections; date
Campaign contributions and expenses
Independent parties; signatures
Independent candidates
Elections; seventy-five foot limit notices
Elections; polling place disclosure
Elections; questioned ballots
Elections; absentee voting
Elections inspectors and judges
Voter qualifications; nominating proce-
dures
Draft legislation for Campaign Eth-
ics Appendix D
Campaign ethics; enforcement
Ethics, handbook
Legislators; conflict of interest (HB 2480)
Arizona Ethies Board
Draft legislation for Initiative and Ret-
erendum Appendix FE
Draft) legislation for Campaign Fi-
nance Appendix F
—
ELECTION REFORM STUDY COMMITTEE
113
—— - =
FINAL REPORT
INTRODUCTION
PURPOSE
The Election Reform Study Committee was estab-
lished by Laws 1991, Chapter 241. The purpose of the
study committee, as stated in the promulgating
legislation, is to develop specific recommendations for
both
statutory and constitutional changes needed to
enact positive ethics and election reforms including at
least the following areas:
a Whom
-
~
DL ~J
Campaign finance
Lobbyist registration and financial disclosure
Laws governing elected officials
Laws regarding the initiative and referendum
process
Voter remstration laws
Absentee voting process
Campaign ethics
Enforcement of election laws
MEMBERSHIP
The
nor:
—"
Y
t
f-
wy
U1 de
x
following members were appointed by the Gover-
Susan Bitter Smith
Mark Dioguardi
Eugene Hughes
Henry Kenski
Billy Shields
114
The following members were appointed by the Presi-
dent of the Senate:
1. Senator Alan Stephens, cochair
2. Senator Manuel “Lito” Pena
Senator Lester Pearce
4. Senator Ann Day
5. Bruce Burke
6. Tim Delaney
The following members were appointed by the Speak-
er of the House of Representatives:
1. Representative Patti Noland, cochair
2. Representative Bev Hermon
3. Representative Peter Goudinoff
1. Representative Benjamin Hanley
5. Steve Betts
6. Robert Matthews
™ » »
ELECTION REFORM STUDY COMMITTEE
RECOMMENDATIONS ON CAMPAIGN FINANCE
PURPOSE
The Election Reform Study Committee was directed
to develop specific recommendations for statutory and
constitutional changes regarding campaign finance
laws. To ensure that this area was thoroughly re-
viewed, the Study Committee created the Subcom-
mittee on Campaign Finance. The subcommittee was
requested to examine the following general subject
matters along with other issues the subcommittee
deemed appropriate:
115
1. Fund raising activities during the legislative
session
2. Disclosure of funding and reporting requirements
for independent campaign committees
3. Public financing of campaigns
4. Proposition 200 limits and technical corrections
MEMBERSHIP
The following persons were appointed as subcommit-
tee members at the first meeting of the Election
Reform Study Committee:
1. Representative Peter Goudinoff, chair
2. Representative Bev Hermon
3. Bruce Burke
4. Mark Dioguardi
5. Henry Kenski
6. Robert Matthews
7. Billy Shields
MEETINGS
The Subcommittee on Campaign Finance met on July
11 and August 1, 1991. A joint subcommittee meeting
of the Elections Laws, Personal Disclosure Require-
ments and Enforcement Subcommittee and_ the
Campaign Finance Subcommittee was held on Sep-
tember 5, 1991.
116
ISSUES AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Below are the recommendations relating to campaign
finance that were adopted by the Election Reform
Study Committee. A copy of the proposed legislation
is included in Appendix F-
I. Independent Campaign Committees
The Election Reform Study Committee recommends
that independent campaign committees be subject to
further disclosure and reporting. Specific language is
included in Appendix B of this report.
II. Proposition 200 Technical Corrections
The Election Reform Study Committee recommends
the technical corrections to the campaign finance
statutes contained in Appendix B of this report. The
draft contains the following provisions:
e Eliminates the confusion resulting from the
current use of the term “campaign committee” by
replacing it with the more descriptive term “polit-
ical committee” to cover all organizations who
must register and report. Candidate campaign
committees are under the umbrella of political
committees. The current use of the term “cam-
paign committee” has caused confusion among
noncandidate committees concerning their need
to comply because they believe the term applies
only to candidate committees.
117
Provides new definitions for the following terms:
Agent
Anonymous contribution
Candidate
Candidate’s campaign committee
Clearly identified candidate
Contribution
Earmarked
Election
Expenditure
Identification
Independent expenditure
In-kind contribution
Itemized
Personal funds
Political committee
Political party
Sponsoring organization
Statewide office
Surplus funds
Changes the name of the initial registration
statement for political committees to “Statement
of Organization” to conform to existing practice
and common understanding and usage.
Requires political committees to register within
10 days of their designation or organization. This
is more realistic than the current requirement
that committees register before having any fi-
nancial activity since there usually are some ex-
penditures that must be made in connection with
organizing a committee.
11s
Requires political committees to include in their
registration the name of any sponsoring organi-
zation.
Requires political committees to have at least one
bank account and to disclose where their ae-
counts are maintained.
Requires certain out-of-state or federal political
committees to file certain campaign finance re-
ports from other jurisdictions when registering in
Arizona.
Aliows a candidate to designate only one cam-
paign committee for each election. All filing of fi-
nance reports will be done by the candidate's
committee. The current system is confusing be-
cause reporting obligations enist for both the
candidate and the committee. There would no
longer be a question concerning whether the can-
didate is required to file a Contributions and Ex-
penditures Statement or simply a Statement of
Exemption.
Presembes that a candidate who receives contri-
butions and makes disbursements is an agent of
his campaign committee.
Provides that the mere designation of a cand-
date’s committee would not invoke Arizena’s re-
sign-to-run law.
Provides more detatled duties for the treasurer of
a political committee.
Proscribes giving false intormation to the cam-
paign treasurer regarding receipts and dis-
bursements.
119
Clarifies what occurs when a candidate contrib-
utes the threshold amount of personal funds.
Provides that a committee’s qualification and
certification to make contributions at the higher
committee limits is valid for two vears.
Clarifies that only unemancipated minors are not
entitled to have their own contribution limits.
Provides methods for designating how contr:bu-
tions are to be apphed to various elections.
Sets forth how an endorsement. guarantee or
repayment of a loan is treated.
Proseribes ceriain methods of making contribu-
tions, including earmarked contributions.
Provides that contributions from partnership
funds be made as individual contributions.
Provides tor regular reporting of independent
expenditures by political committees and for re-
porting of independent expenditures within 24
hours if the expenditure is made 20 davs before
the election.
Provides for more than the reporting of only
contributions and expenditures by requiring that
all receipts and disbursements be included. The
current statements of contributions and expendi-
tures are replaced with campaign finance state-
ments. which more accurately describe the
content.
Requires political committees to file periodic
campaign finance reports, regardless of whether
120
any receipts or disbursements occur, according to
a new schedule:
- Inan election vear, reports would be filed be-
fore each election, after anv noen-primary
election and quarterly.
- Ina non-election vear, a report for the period
ending dune 30 and a report for the period
ending December 31 would be filed.
Exempts judges who are candidates for retention
from filing a campaign finance report if the yudge
has no campaign committee and does not receive
contributions or make expenditures.
Provides for the formal ending of a political
committee by the filing of a termination state-
ment, and prescribes the conditions that must be
met for termination
Details more accurately the information to be
required on each campaign finance report. This
also reflects the intent to capture all receipts and
disbursements and not just traditional contribu-
tions and expenditures.
Amends the section pertaining to disposal of
surplus campaign funds by eliminating duplica-
tions and unnecessary distinctions that currently
exist while retaining the recently enacted prohi
bition against converting surplus funds to a can-
didate’s personal use.
Clarifies when a required report or statement is
deemed to be filed.
Requires that a political committee that makes
independent expenditures aggregating $500 made
~
l21
less than 20 days before an election must report
the expenditure within 2-4 hours
e Allows campaign committees to incorporate only
for hability purposes without prohibiting them
from influencing candidate elections
Additional Items Discussed by the Election Reform
,
Study Committee But Not Adopted
lL = Voluntary Expenditure Limitations
The Election Reform Study Committee considered the
issue of voluntary campaign expenditure limitations.
A motion to recommend the adoption of voluntary
campaign expenditure imits was withdrawn
Il. Public Financing
The Election Reform Study Committee discussed the
issue of public financing and recommended that it not
be pursued
122
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona
(Filed Jun. 12, 2009)
LTtle Omuitted In Printing)
Arizona Daily Star
February 8, 1991
Videotapes show payoffs
Ariz. legislators, lobbyists appea
at sting meetings
Mary K. Reinhart; The Arizona Daily Star
Anizona lemslators were immortalized on videotape
taking stacks of money from a man they knew as J
Anthony Vincent in exchange for their votes
Phoenix police released the tapes and transcripts
vesterday of meetings between the undercover police
agent and lawmakers and lobbyi ts as they mapped
out stratemes to legalize gambling and get mech from
the 500-room casinos that would result
The investigation by the department’s organized
crime bureau and the Maricopa County Attorney's
Office produced 22,000 pages of transcripts, 600 audio
cassettes and 300 videotapes.
Authorities used former FBI informant Joseph
Stedino to set up an elaborate sting operation im
which Stedino posed as Vincent, a fast-talking, free-
spending Reno, Nev. gaming consultant who wanted
to buy votes to set up gambling operations in Arizona.
123
Lawmakers and lobbyists were taped during meet
ings with Vincent at his plush Phoenix office and
apartment, the Ritz-Carlton Hotel, and in cars and
restaurants. Telephone conversations also were
taped
On Sept. LS. Sen. Carolyn Walker, D-Phoenix, met
Vincent at his office and accepted $15,000 in cash
1S $100 bills — telling Vincent: “We all have our
prices.”
She tells Vincent she will support casino-gambling
legislation, as well as bills to allow private firms to
construct prisons and the election of judges.
The color videotapes show a relaxed Walker wearing
a lime-green shirt and Indian-print skirt sitting in an
armchair across from Vincent, whois seated behind a
desk. She sips het Coke, laughs and talks about
using the money to finish paving her daughter's
college taition.
A month later, Walker met Vincent and asked tor a
loan of $500,000 to $750,000 to launch a recording
company. Vincent told Walker he would let his friends
in the recording industry know that Walker was “with
him.”
“Well, that’s one of the reasons why I came to vou
‘cause | figured that IT would have some of your pro
tection,” Walker said, according to court records. “I'm
on board with va, let me tell va”
Another video, made Sept. 18. shows Sen. Jesus
“Chuy” Higuera, D-Tucson, sitting across the desk
124
from Vincent in Vincent's office, eating sandwiches
and discussing Higuera’s running the shrimp conces-
sions at casinos that Vincent would open once casino
gambling was legalized.
“Vd ike to own a business that supphes vour shrimp
That's what Td lke to do.” Higwera said on the vide-
otape.
Higuera agreed to support casino gambling legisla.
tion. Vincent gave Higuera $1,540 in money orders
and $1,000 cash
A video made at Vincent's office April 30 shows Rep.
Don Kenney, R-Phoenix, lobbyist Ron Tapp and
Vincent discussing the lemslation. Kenney agreed to
“quarterback” the operation, and was handed a stack
of tills that an indictment alleges was $55,000. He
put the money into a gvm bag that he brought to the
meeting, according to court records
Other new developments in what could be the biggest
political scandal in Arizona history:
The indictment of Gary Bartlett, a Phoemx private
investigator hired by Vincent to drum up support
among legislators for the gambling legislation.
Bartlett was amo
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.