Appendix — Johnson v. Transit Transit Mix Concrete Concrete Concrete & Materials Co. (No. 08-404)
Supreme Court brief2008
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
TABLE OF CONTENTS
APPENDIX A: Opinion of the Texas Court of
Appeals for the 11th District
i ss dcnsinnendseonesncsess la
APPENDIX B: Judgment of the 58th District Court,
Jefferson County, Texas (June 25, 2003)............... 7a
APPENDIX C: Order of the Texas Supreme Court,
Denying Review (February 22, 2008)................... 19a
APPENDIX D: Order of the Texas Supreme Court,
Denying Re-hearing of Petition
a cenecensanessees 20a
APPENDIX E: U.S. Const. art V1 .............00000..0.2.. 21a
APPENDIX F: 29 U.S.C. 654(a)(1)........................ 22a
Pe ree G: BO UB.C. GOL ...........cccscercccerssccceees 23a
Meares Be: BO U.B.C. GOB.............0.0.00.0cccccccees: 25a
So 5 29a
APPENDIX J: 30 U.S.C. 814(a)...............0cccccceee. ...40a
Perens Me: BO U.S.C. BIG..........cccccccccssccccscocess 4la
APPENDIX L: 30 U.S.C. 820(a) ......................0000.. 49a
APPENDIX M: 30 U.S.C. 955............ ce ceeeeseeeeees 5la
APPENDIX N: 30 C.F.R. 46.12 20.0.0... eeeee. 53a
Py yy 8 ee Fok os 5 ncaa nnane 55a
APPENDIX P: 30 C.F.R. 48.25..................:csccceesees 60a
APPENDIX Q: U.S. Department of Labor, Mine
Safety and Health Administration,
Metal / Nonmetal Mine Fatality Fatalgram
I i a ss cctsemucwonsepenss 65a
APPENDIX R: U.S. Department of Labor, Mine
Safety and Health Administration,
Accident Investigation Report
I Es i is cniaemnenoouiinadel 67a
la
APPENDIX A
OPINION OF THE TEXAS COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE 11TH DISTRICT
(OCTOBER 12, 2006)
Court of Appeals of Texas, Eastland.
TRANSIT MIX CONCRETE & MATERIALS
COMPANY and Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit
Mix and Materials Company, Appellants
v.
Darletta Rochelle JOHNSON, individually and as
Representative of the Estate of Brad F. Johnson, Sr.,
Deceased, and as next friend of Brad Johnson, Jr.,
Jerelle Johnson, and Amethyst Johnson, Minors,
Appellee.
No. 11-03-00300-CV.
Oct. 12, 2006.
Rehearing Overruled Dec. 6, 2006.
Background: Wife of deceased worker,
individually and as representative of worker's estate,
and as next friend of worker's three minor children,
brought wrongful death action against sand and
gravel mine company at whose site worker was
injured. The 58th District Court, Jefferson County,
James William Mehaffy, J., entered jury verdict in
favor of worker's estate and survivors. Mine company
appealed.
2a
Holding: The Court of Appeals, Jim R. Wright,
C.J., held that the mine company did not exercise
contro! of worker so as to create a duty to worker.
Reversed and rendered.
OPINION
JIM R. WRIGHT, Chief Justice.
In 1999, Brad Johnson Sr. was killed while
working at a sand and gravel mine owned and
operated by Trinity Materials, Inc. and Transit Mix
Concrete & Materials Company.! Darletta Rochelle
Johnson, individually and as representative of the
estate of her husband Brad F. Johnson Sr. and as
next friend of the three minor children, Brad
Johnson Jr., Jerelle Johnson, and Amethyst Johnson,
filed suit against Trinity under the Wrongful Death
Act, TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM.CODE ANN. §§
71.001-.012 (Vernon 1997 & Supp.2006), and the
Texas Survival Statute, TEX. CIV. PRAC. &
REM.CODE ANN. § 71.021 (Vernon 1997). The jury
found Trinity negligent and awarded Johnson's
estate and survivors $164 million in damages. In its
final judgment, the trial court remitted the award to
$27,357,090.83. We reverse and render.
Johnson was employed as a mechanic by RDO
Equipment Company, a heavy equipment dealer.
RDO performed repair work on heavy pieces of
equipment for various companies. As part of the
contract price, RDO provided an_ experienced
' The parties stipulated that Trinity Materials, Inc. and
Transit Mix Concrete & Materials Company were the same
entity for the purposes of this case. We will collectively refer to
the appellants as “Trinity” as did each of the parties.
3a
mechanic and equipped the mechanic with a field
truck and necessary tools. RDO provided field
services to numerous sand and gravel mines, and
Johnson worked at several of those mines.
Trinity contracted with RDO to _ provide
mechanical services, and RDO sent Johnson to
perform the work. On the day of the accident, a
Trinity employee assigned Johnson to repair the
brakes on a Euclid B-30 dirt hauler. The B-30 had
mud and sand around the tire and wheel assembly,
and Johnson had difficulty removing it. Johnson
consulted with Trinity employees on how to remove
the tire, and the employees offered their suggestions.
A Trinity employee tried to assist Johnson in
removing the tire but returned to his assigned job
when unable to remove the tire. Johnson said that. he
was going to use heat to break up the debris around
the tire. Johnson used an acetylene torch with a
rosebud attachment to apply heat to the debris. The
tire exploded from the heat, and Johnson suffered
multiple injuries resulting in his death.
[1] Trinity first argues that it owed no duty to
Johnson, an independent contractor's employee.
Negligence consists of three essential elements: (1) a
legal duty owed by one person to another; (2) a
breach of that duty; and (3) damages proximately
resulting from the breach. Duty is the threshold
inquiry. E] Chico Corp. v. Poole, 732 S.W.2d 306, 311
(Tex. 1987); Howarton v. Minn. Mining and Mfg.,
Inc., 133 S.W.3d 820, 824 (Tex. App.-Eastland 2004,
no pet.).
4a
*95 [2][3][4] Ordinarily, a general contractor does
not owe a duty to ensure that an independent
contractor performs its work in a safe manner. Lee
Lewis Const., Inc. v. Harrison, 70 S.W.3d 778, 783
(Tex.2001); Elliott-Williams Co. v. Diaz, 9 S.W.3d
801, 803 (Tex. 1999); Hoechst-Celanese Corp. v.
Mendez, 967 S.W.2d 354, 356 (Tex. 1998). A duty
does arise, however, if the general contractor retains
some control over the manner in which the
independent contractor performs its work. Lee Lewis,
70 S.W.3d at 783; Elliott-Williams, 9 S.W.3d at 803.
A general contractor can retain the right to control
an aspect of an independent contractor's work or
project so as to give rise to a duty of care to that
independent contractor's employees in two ways: by
contract or by actual exercise of control. Lee Lewis,
70 S.W.3d at 783; Coastal Marine Serv. of Tex., Inc.
v. Lawrence, 988 S.W.2d 223, 226 (Tex. 1999). The
general contractor's duty of care is commensurate
with the control it retains over the independent
contractor's work. Lee Lewis 70 S.W.3d at 783;
Hoechst-Celanese, 967 S.W.2d at 355.
[5] The parties do not contend that Trinity
contracted the right to control Johnson's work.
Therefore, the question betore us is whether Trinity
exercised actual control over Johnson's work. For a
general contractor to be liable for its independent
contractor's acts, it must have the right to control the
means, methods, or details of the independent
contractor's work. Elliott-Williams, 9 S.W.3d at 804;
Coastal Marine, 988 S.W.2d at 226. The
Restatement (Second) of Torts specifically outlines
the degree of control necessary to create a duty:
{[T}he employer must have retained at least some
degree of contro! over the manner in which the work
5a
is done. It is not enough that he has merely a general
right to order the work stopped or resumed, to
inspect its progress or to receive reports, to make
suggestions or recommendations which need not
necessarily be followed, or to prescribe alterations
and deviations. Such a general right is usually
reserved to employers, but it does not mean that the
contractor is controlled as to his methods of work, or
as to operative detail. There must be such a
retention of a right of supervision that the contractor
is not entirely free to do the work in his own way.
See RESTATEMENT (SECOND) OF TORTS § 414
cmt. c (1965); Elliott-Williams, 9 S.W.3d at 804.
{6] Trinity assigned Johnson to repair the brakes
on the B-30, but Trinity did not provide detailed
instruction on the method or means of how to
perform the job. See Hoechst-Celanese, 967 S.W.2d
at 357. When Johnson had difficulty completing the
assigned task, Trinity employees made suggestions
and recommendations on how to perform the task.
The Trinity employees whom Johnson consulted
were not in a supervisory role over Johnson. Johnson
alone made the decision to use the heat torch in
effort to remove the tire.
[7][8] There was evidence presented that Trinity
had the right to stop unsafe acts by independent
contractors. Having the right to stop unsafe work is
not enough to create a duty of care. Dow Chem. Co.
v. Bright, 89 S.W.3d 602, 608 (Tex. 2002). A general
contractor or an employer is not required to stand
idly by while another is injured or killed in order to
avoid liability. Id. However, if a general contractor
6a
exercises control by requiring an independent
contractor to comply with its safety regulations, the
general contractor owes the independent contractor's
employees a narrow duty of care that its safety
requirements and procedures do not unreasonably
increase the probability and severity of injury. Id. at
607. Trinity's*96 safety regulations did not increase
the probat ility and severity of injury. Moreover, the
jury charge did not include an issue on Trinity's
safety regulations and there was no objection to the
omission of that issue. See TEX. R. CIV. P. 274; see
also State Dept. of Highways & Pub. Transp. v.
Payne, 838 S.W.2d 235 (Tex. 1992).
There is no evidence that Johnson was not free to
perform “the work in his own way.” See Section 414
cmt. c; Elliott-Williams, 9 S.W.3d at 804. There is
no evidence that Trinity approved of Johnson's use of
heat to remove the tire. Trinity assigned the task;
Johnson ultimately made the decision to perform the
task using heat to remove the tire. By assigning the
task, offering suggestions on completing the task,
and reserving the right to stop unsafe work practices,
Trinity did not exercise control over Johnson's work
so as to create a duty. Trinity's first issue on appeal
is sustained. Because of our disposition of Trinity's
first issue on appeal, we need not address Trinity's
remaining issues. TEX. R. APP. P. 47.1.
The judgment of the trial court is reversed, and
judgment is rendered that Darletta Rochelle
Johnson, individually, as representative of the
estate, and as next friend of the three minor
children, take nothing from Trinity.
Transit Mix Concrete & Materials Co. v. Johnson,
205 S.W.3d 92. (Tex. App.-Eastland 2006).
“
Ta
APPENDIX B
JUDGMENT OF THE 58TH DISTRICT COURT,
JEFFERSON COUNTY, TEXAS
(JUNE 25, 2003)
CAUSE NO. A-164,606
IN THE DISTRICT COURT
JEFFERSON COUNTY, TEXAS
58TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
DARLETA ROCHELLE JOHNSON, §
INDIVIDUALLY AND AS
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE
OF BRAD F. JOHNSON, SR, DECEASED,
AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF §
BRAD JOHNSON JR., JERELLE JOHNSON,
AND AMETHYST JOHNSON, MINORS
V.
TRINITY MATERIALS, INC., ET.AL.
FINAL JUDGMENT
On the 26th day of March, 2003, came on to be
heard the above-entitled and numbered cause, and
Plaintiff Darleta Johnson, appeared Individually and
by attorney of record, and as Next Friend of Brad
Johnson, Jr., Jerelle Johnson, and Amethyst
Johnson, Minor Children, and as Representative of
the Estate of Brad Johnson, Sr. Deceased, and as
Representative of the Lawful Heirs under the Texas
Wrongful Death Act and Texas Survival Statute, and
8a
announced ready for trial. Brian Sutton appointed by
the Court on behalf of the minor Plaintiffs, appeared
as Guardian Ad Litem, and Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and Transmit Mix and Materials
Company, appeared by attorney of record and
announced ready for trial; and a jury having been
previously demanded, consisting of twelve (12)
qualified jurors, was duly emplaned; and the case
proceeded to trial.
Before the court's Charge was submitted to the
jury, Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit
Mix and Materials Company, made a written election
to receive a dollar-for-dollar settlement credit,
pursuant to Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.014,
for the $400,500.00 settlement payment made by
Bridgestone/Firestone North American Tire, LLC, to
Plaintiffs in this lawsuit.
At the conclusion of the evidence, the court
submitted the questions of fact in the case to the
jury. After deliberation, the jury returned and
announced its verdict in open court, which verdict
was unanimous and was duly received and filed by
this court. As part of its verdict, the jury found that:
(1) Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and
Transit Mix and Materials Company,
exercised control of the work activity that
caused the death of Brad Johnson, Sr.
(2) The negligence of Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix and
Materials Company, proximately caused the
occurrence in question.
9a
(3) Responsibility for the harm for which
recovery was sought was attributed 100% to
the Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and
Transit Mix and Materials Company.
(4) The Plaintiff, Darleta Rochelle Johnson,
individually, sustained damages for
pecuniary loss, loss of companionship and
society, and mental anguish in the past in
the amount of $3,300,000.00; and she, in
reasonable probability, will sustain a loss in
the future of - $36,500,000.00.
(5) The minor Plaintiff, Brad Johnson, Jr.,
sustained damages for pecuniary loss, loss of
companionship and society, and mental
anguish in the past in the amount of
$3,300,000.00; and he, in_ reasonable
probability, will sustain a loss in the future
of $28,100,000.00.
(6) The minor Plaintiff, Jerelle Johnson,
sustained damages for pecuniary loss, loss of
companionship and society, and mental
anguish in the past in the amount of
$3,300,000.00; and he, in_ reasonable
probability, will sustain a loss in the future
of $56,200,000.00.
(7) The minor Plaintiff, Amethyst Johnson,
sustained damages for pecuniary loss, loss of
companionship and society, and mental
anguish in the past in the amount of
$3,300,000.00; and she, in_ reasonable
10a
probability, will sustain a loss in the future
of $28,100,000.00.
(8) The deceased Plaintiff, Brad Johnson, Sr.
sustained damages for:
(a) pain and mental anguish before his
death in the amount of $1,600,000.00;
(b) medical expenses for treatment of his
injuries in the amount of $112,685.83;
and
(c) funeral and _ burial expenses
reasonably suited to his station in life of
$10,000.00.
The court finds that the parties stipulated during
the trial of the case that the deceased Plaintiffs
medical, funeral and burial expenses amount to
$119,590.83. Accordingly, the Plaintiffs have agreed
to voluntarily remit the amount of $3,905.00 from
the award to Brad Johnson, Sr. The court finds that
prejudgment interest has accrued on Plaintiffs' claim
for actual damages. The prejudgment interest is
calculated as simple interest at the rate of ten (10%)
percent. Prejudgment interest as allowable by law
began on February 16, 2001 (the day suit was filed),
and ends on the day before the final judgment is
signed.
The court further finds that the deceased
Plaintiff, Brad Johnson, Sr., was injured on February
17, 1999, while in the course and scope of his
employment. The parties stipulated that his
employer's worker's compensation carrier, Sentry
Select Insurance Company, who is not a party to this
lawsuit, has expended $164,084.83 in medical and
indemnity benefits on his behalf to the date of the
judgment, and, thus, Sentry Select Insurance
ii
lla
Company is entitled, and will continue to be entitled
to subrogation of those amounts until paid in full, or
in an amount to the satisfaction of Sentry Select
Insurance Company and Plaintiffs as follows: a) all
medical and funeral benefits paid by Sentry Select
Insurance Company shall be satisfied out of the
award to Darleta Johnson, as representative of the
estate of Brad Johnson, Sr.; b) all indemnity benefits
paid by Sentry Select Insurance Company to Darleta
Johnson shall be satisfied out of the award to
Darleta Johnson; and c) all indemnity benefits paid
by Sentry Select Insurance Company to Brad
Johnson, Jr.; Jerelle Johnson; and Amethyst Johnson
shall be satisfied as having been received by each
child, out of the award to each said child.
The court finds that Brad Johnson, Jr., Jerelle
Johnson and Amethyst Johnson, the persons
designated in the trial pleadings as minor Plaintiffs,
are in truth and in fact minors under the age of
eighteen (18) years whose disabilities of minority
have never been removed, and there are no lawful
guardians of the persons and/or the estates of said
minor Plaintiffs, but further finding that a conflict
existed between the minors and the next friend
before the court appointed Bran Sutton as guardian
ad litem of the minor children in this lawsuit. Prior
to the entry of judgment, the court heard evidence on
the guardian ad litem fees for Brian Sutton.
Accordingly, the court finds that Brian Sutton,
Guardian Ad Litem appointed by the court for the
minor Plaintiffs, is a fit and proper person to serve in
the capacity of Guardian Ad Litem to represent the
interests of the minors. The court further finds that
no conflict of interest exists between the minor
12a
Plaintiffs and their Guardian Ad Litem, Brian
Sutton. Having heard the evidence, including the
extraordinary circumstances of the minor Plaintiff,
Jerelle Johnson, an autistic child, the court further
finds that Brian Sutton has acquainted himself with
the facts and the laws of the case, so that after the
time and labor involved, and the results obtained,
the nature and length of his professional relationship
with the minor Plaintiffs, the fee customarily
charged in this locality for similar legal services, the
time limitations imposed on him by _ the
circumstances, including much_ study’ and
deliberation, and his participation in the trial, as
well as at numerous mediations before trial, during
trial and post verdict, that $120,000,00 is a fair and
reasonable charge for the services rendered by him
as the Guardian Ad Litem for said minor Plaintiffs
under the appointment of this court
The court further finds that should a notice of
appeal be filed by any party then a further fair and
reasonable sum for the services rendered by Brian
Sutton as the Guardian Ad Litem for said minor
Plaintiifs under the appointment of this court during
the pendency of the appeal at the court of appeals is
$10,000.00.
The court further finds that should a petition for
review be filed by any party with the Supreme Court
of the State of Texas, then a further fair and
reasonable sum for the services rendered by Brian
Sutton as the Guardian Ad Litem for said minor
Plaintiffs under the appointment of this court during
the pendency of the appeal at the Supreme Court of
the State of Texas is $10,000.00.
x
+
13a
ACCORDINGLY, because it appears to the Court
that the verdict of the jury was for Plaintiffs and
against Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and
Transit Mix and Materials Company, judgment
should be rendered in favor of Plaintiffs and against
Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix
and Materials Company, and the court having
considered sua sponte the evidence and the
excessiveness of the jury verdict as to actual
damages, and hereby deciding to remit those actual
damages to those amounts as awarded below,
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND
DECREED, by the court that Plaintiffs, Darleta
Johnson, Individually, and as Next Friend of Brad
Johnson, Jr., Jerelle Johnson, and Amethyst
Johnson, Minor Children, and as Representative of
the Estate of Brad Johnson, Sr., Deceased, and as
Representative of the Lawful Heirs under the Texas
Wrongful Death Act and Texas Survival Statute,
shall recover from Defendants, Trinity Materials,
Inc., and Transmit Mix and Materials Company, as
follows:
(1) That Darleta Johnson, individually, shall
recover from the Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and Transmit Mix and
Materials Company, the sum of
$6,765,000.00, less a settlement credit of
$178,000.00, plus prejudgment interest in the
amount of $1 ,550,200.82, accrued and
calculated as simple interest at the rate of ten
(10%) percent beginning on February 16, 2001
(the day suit was filed), and ending on the day
before the final judgment is signed (June 24,
14a
2003); plus post judgment interest on the total
amount of the judgment at the rate of 10%
interest per year, compounded annually, from
the day the judgment is signed (June 25,
2003) until the day the judgment is satisfied;
(2) That Darleta Johnson, as representative of
the Estate of Brad Johnson, Sr., Deceased,
and as Representative of the Lawful Heirs
under the Texas Wrongful Death Act and
Texas Survival Statute, shall recover from the
Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc., and
Transit Mix and Materials Company the sum
of $294,590.83, plus prejudgment interest in
the amount $69,329.73, accrued’ and
calculated as simple interest at the rate of ten
(10%) percent beginning on February 16,2001
(the day suit was filed), and ending on the day
before the final judgment is signed (June 24,
2003); plus post judgment interest on the total
amount of the judgment at the rate of 10%
interest per year, compounded annually, from
the day the judgment is signed (June 25,
2003) until the day the judgment is satisfied;
(3) That Brad Johnson, Jr., minor plaintiff,
shall recover from the Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc, and Transit Mix and
Materials Company the sum $5,350,000.00,
less a settlement credit of $74,166.66, plus
prejudgment interest in the amount of
$1,241,627.63, accrued and calculated as
simple interest at the rate of ten (10%)
percent beginning on February 16, 200 I (the
day suit was filed), and ending on the day
before the final judgment is signed (June 24,
2003); plus post judgment interest on the total
15a
amount of the judgment at the rate of 10%
interest per year, compounded annually, from
the day the judgment is signed (June 285,
2003) until the day the judgment is satisfied;
(4) That Jerelle Johnson, minor plaintiff, shall
recover from the Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix and
Materials Company the sum $10,000,000.00,
less a settlement credit of $74,166.68, plus
prejudgment interest in the amount of
$2,335,970.09, accrued and calculated as
simple interest at the rate of ten (10%)
percent beginning on February 16, 2001 (the
day suit was filed), and ending on the day
before the final judgment is signed (June 24,
2003); plus post judgment interest on the total
amount of the judgment at the rate of 10%
interest per year, compounded annually, from
the day the judgment is signed (June 285,
2003) until the day the judgment is satisfied;
(5) That Amethyst Johnson, minor plaintiff,
shall recover from the Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix and
Materials Company the sum $5,350,000.00,
less a settlement credit of $74,166.66, plus
prejudgment interest in the amount of
$1,241,627.63, accrued and calculated as
simple interest at the rate of ten (10%)
percent beginning on February 16, 2001 (the
day suit was filed), and ending on the day
before the final judgment is signed (June 24,
2003); plus post judgment interest on the total
amount of the judgment at the rate of 10%
l6a
interest per year, compounded annually, from
the day the judgment is signed (June 25,
2003) until the day the judgment is satisfied;
and
(6) That Plaintiffs, collectively, recover of and
from the Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc.,
and Transit Mix and Materials Company as
actual damages as more specifically set out in
items (1) through (5) above, the total sum of
$27,357,090.83, together with prejudgment
interest in the total amount of $6,438,755.90,
accrued and calculated as simple interest at
the rate of ten (10%) percent beginning on
February 16, 2001 (the day suit was filed),
and ending on the day before the final
judgment is signed (June 24, 2003), for a total
judgment against Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc., and ‘Transit Mix and
Materials Company, in the sum _ 0of
$33,797,846.73; which sum shall bear interest
at the rate of 10% interest per year,
compounded annually, from the day the
judgment is signed (June 25, 2003) until the
day the judgment is satisfied.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED
AND DECREED by the court that Plaintiffs, Darleta
Johnson, Individually, and as Next Friend of Brad
Johnson, Jr., Jerelle Johnson, and Amethyst
Johnson, Minor Children, and as Representative of
the Estate of Brad Johnson, Sr., Deceased, and as
Representative of the Lawful Heirs under the Texas
Wrongful Death Act and Texas Survival Statute,
have and recover from Defendants, Trinity
Materials, Inc, and Transit Mix and Materials
17a
Company, all costs of court expended or incurred in
this cause by Plaintiffs, including all mediator fees.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND
DECREED that a reasonable fee in the amount of
$120,000.00 shall be paid to Brian Sutton, Guardian
Ad Litem, which fee is a fair and reasonabie charge
for his services rendered under the appointment of
this court and on behalf of the minor Plaintiffs, Brad
Johnson, Jr., Jerelle Johnson and Amethyst Johnson,
and said fee is hereby taxed against Defendants,
Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix and
Materials Company.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND
DECREED that a further reasonable fee in the
amount of $10,000.00 shall be paid to Brian Sutton,
Guardian Ad Litem, which further sum is a fair and
reasonable charge for his services rendered under
the appointment of this court and on behalf of the
minor Plaintiffs, Brad Johnson, Jr., Jerelle Johnson
and Amethyst Johnson, should a notice of appeal be
filed by any party, and said further fee is hereby
taxed against Defendants, Trinity Materials, Inc.,
and Transit Mix and Materials Company.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a further
reasonable fee in the amount of $10,000.00 shall be
paid to Brian Sutton, Guardian Ad Litem, which
further sum is a fair and reasonable charge for his
services rendered under the appointment of this
court and on behalf of the minor Plaintiffs, Brad
Johnson, Jr Jerelle Johnson and Amethyst Johnson,
should a petition for review be filed by any party
with the Supreme Court of the State of Texas, and
18a
said further fee is hereby taxed against Defendants,
Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit Mix and
Materials Company.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED by the court that
Plaintiffs are granted all writs, processes,
proceedings, actions and remedies necessary for the
enforcement and collection of this judgment or the
costs of court and same may issue as necessary for
the benefit of Plaintiffs, and against Defendants,
Trinity Materials, Inc, .and Transit Mix and
Materials Company,
The Charge of the court, including the jury
questions, definitions and instructions; the verdict of
the jury; the stipulations entered into by the parties;
and Defendants’, Trinity Materials, Inc., and Transit
Mix and Materials Company, settlement credit
election and the amounts allocated from that
settlement to the Plaintiffs in this lawsuit,. are
incorporated in this judgment for all purposes by
reference.
All other relief not expressly granted is denied,
SIGNED THIS 25th day of June, 2003.
JUDGE PRESIDING
19a
APPENDIX C
ORDER OF THE TEXAS SUPREME COURT,
DENYING REVIEW
(FEBRUARY 22, 2008)
THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS
Orders Pronounced February 22, 2008
ORDERS ON PETITIONS FOR REVIEW
THE FOLLOWING PETITIONS FOR REVIEW
ARE DENIED:
07-0063 DARLETA ROCHELLE JOHNSON,
INDIVIDUALLY AND AS REPRESENTATIVE OF
THE ESTATE OF BRAD F. JOHNSON, SR.,
DECEASED, AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF BRAD
JOHNSON, JR., JERELLE JOHNSON AND
AMETHYST JOHNSON, MINORS v. TRANSIT MIX
CONCRETE & MATERIALS COMPANY AND
TRINITY MATERIALS, INC.; from Jefferson
County; llth district (11-03-00300-CV, _.. SW3d
___,10-12-06).
20a
APPENDIX D
ORDER OF THE TEXAS SUPREME COURT,
DENYING RE-HEARING OF PETITION
(JUNE 27, 2008)
THE SUPREME COURT OF TEXAS
Orders Pronounced June 27, 2008
ORDERS ON CAUSES
ORDERS ON MOTIONS FOR REHEARING
THE MOTIONS FOR REHEARING OF THE
FOLLOWING PETITIONS FOR REVIEW ARE
DENIED:
07-0063 DARLETA ROCHELLE JOHNSON,
INDIVIDUALLY AND AS REPRESENTATIVE OF
THE ESTATE OF BRAD F. JOHNSON, SR.,
DECEASED, AND AS NEXT FRIEND OF BRAD
JOHNSON, JR., JERELLE JOHNSON AND
AMETHYST JOHNSON, MINORS v. TRANSIT MIX
CONCRETE & MATERIALS COMPANY AND
TRINITY MATERIALS, INC.; from Jefferson
County; llth district (11-03-00300-CV, _._ SW3d
___,10-12-06).
2la
APPENDIX E
U.S. CONST. ART VI
United States Code
Constitution of the United States
Article VI. Debts Validated--Supreme Law of Land--
Oath of Office
Clause 2. Supreme Law of Land
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States
which shall be made in Pursuance thereof: and all
Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the
Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme
Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall
be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or
Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.
22a
APPENDIX F
29 U.S.C. § 654(a)(1)
United States Code Annotated
Title 29. Labor
Chapter 15. Occupational Safety and Health
§ 654. Duties of employers and employees
(a) Each employer--
(1) shall furnish to each of his employees
employment and a place of employment which are
free from recognized hazards that are causing or are
likely to cause death or serious physical arm to his
employees;
(2) shall comply with occupational safety and
health standards promulgated under this chapter.
(b) Each employee shall comply with occupational
safety and health standards and all rules,
regulations, and orders issued pursuant to this
chapter which are applicable to his own actions and
conduct.
23a
APPENDIX G
30 U.S.C. § 801
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
§ 801. Congressional findings and declaration
of purpose
Congress declares that--
(a) the first priority and concern of all in the coal or
other mining industry must be the health and safety
of its most precious resource--the miner;
(b) deaths and serious injuries from unsafe and
unhealthful conditions and practices in the coal or
other mines cause grief and suffering to the miners
and to their families;
(c) there is an urgent need to provide more effective
means and measures for improving the working
conditions and practices in the Nation's coal or other
mines in order to prevent death and serious physical
harm, and in order to prevent occupational diseases
originating in such mines;
(d) the existence of unsafe and_ unhealthful
conditions and practices in the Nation's coal or other
mines is a serious impediment to the future growth
of the coal or other mining industry and cannot be
tolerated;
24a
(e) the operators of such mines with the assistance of
the miners have the primary responsibility to
prevent the existence of such conditions and
practices in such mines;
(f) the disruption of production and the loss of income
to operators and miners as a result of coal or other
mine accidents or occupationally caused diseases
unduly impedes and burdens commerce; and
(g) it is the purpose of this chapter (1) to establish
interim mandatory health and safety standards and
to direct the Secretary of Health and Human
Services and the Secretary of Labor to develop and
promulgate improved mandatory health or safety
standards to protect the health and safety of the
Nation's coal or other miners; (2) to require that each
operator of a coal or other mine and every miner in
such mine comply with such standards; (3) to
cooperate with, and provide assistance to, the States
in the development and enforcement of effective
State coal or other mine health and safety programs;
and (4) to improve and expand, in cooperation with
the States and the coal or other mining industry,
research and development and training programs
aimed at preventing coal or other mine accidents and
occupationally caused diseases in the industry.
25a
APPENDIX H
30 U.S.C. § 802
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
§ 802. Definitions
For the purpose of this chapter, the term--
(a) “Secretary” means the Secretary of Labor or his
delegate;
(b) “commerce” means trade, traffic, commerce,
transportation, or communication among the several
States, or between a place in a State and any place
outside thereof, or within the District of Columbia or
a possession of the United States, or between points
in the same State but through a point outside
thereof;
(c) “State” includes a State of the United States, the
District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto
Rico, the Virgin Islands, American Samoa, Guam,
and the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands;
(d) “operator” means any owner, lessee, or other
person who operates, controls, or supervises a coal or
other mine or any independent contractor performing
services or construction at such mine;
26a
(e) “agent” means any person charged with
responsibility for the operation of all or a part of a
coal or other mine or the supervision of the miners in
a coal or other mine;
(f) “person” means any individual, partnership,
association, corporation, firm, subsidiary of a
corporation, or other organization;
(g) “miner” means any individual working in a coal or
other mine;
(h)(1) “coal or other mine” means (A) an area of land
from which minerals are extracted in nonliquid form
or, if in liquid form, are extracted with workers
underground, (B) private ways and_ “*roads
appurtenant to such area, and (C) lands,
excavations, underground passageways, shafts,
slopes, tunnels and workings, structures, facilities,
equipment, machines, tools, or other property
including impoundments, retention dams, and
tailings ponds, on the surface or underground, used
in, or to be used in, or resulting from, the work of
extracting such minerals from their natural deposits
in nonliquid form, or if in liquid form, with workers
underground, or used in, or to be used in, the milling
of such minerals, or the work of preparing coal or
other minerals, and includes custom coal preparation
facilities. In making a determination of what
constitutes mineral mulling for purposes of this
chapter, the Secretary shall give due consideration to
the convenience of administration resulting from the
delegation to one Assistant Secretary of all authority
with respect to the health and safety of miners
employed at one physical establishment;
(2) For purposes of subchapters II, III, and IV of
this chapter, “coal mine” means an area of land and
27a
all structures, facilities, machinery, tools, equipment,
shafts, slopes, tunnels, excavations, and other
property, real or personal, placed upon, under, or
above the surface of such land by any person, used
in, or to be used in, or resulting from, the work of
extracting in such area bituminous coal, lignite, or
anthracite from its natural deposits in the earth by
any means or method, and the work of preparing the
coal so extracted, and includes custom coal
preparation facilities;
G) “work of preparing the coal” means the
breaking, crushing, sizing, cleaning, washing, drying,
mixing, storing, and loading of bituminous coal,
lignite, or anthracite, and such other work of
preparing such coal as is usually done by the
operator of the coal mine;
(j) “imminent danger” means the existence of any
condition or practice in a coal or other mine which
could reasonably be expected to cause death or
serious physical harm before such condition or
practice can be abated;
(k) “accident” includes a mine explosion, mine
ignition, mine fire, or mine inundation, or injury to,
or death of, any person;
(1) “mandatory health or safety standard” means
the interim mandatory health or safety standards
established by subchapters II and III of this chapter,
and the standards promulgated pursuant to
subchapter I of this chapter;
(m) “Panel” means the Interim Compliance Pane]
established by this chapter; and
28a
(n) “Administration” means the Mine Safety and
Health Administration in the Department of Labor.
(0) “Commission” means the Federal Mine Safety and
Health Review Commission.
29a
APPENDIX I
30 U.S.C. § 811
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
Subchapter I. General
§ 811. Mandatory safety and health standards
(a) Development, proinulgation, and revision
The Secretary shall by rule in accordance with
procedures set forth in this section and in accordance
with section 553 of Title 5 (without regard to any
reference in such section to sections 556 and 557 of
such title), develop, promulgate, and revise as may
be appropriate, improved mandatory health or safety
standards for the protection of life and prevention of
injuries in coal or other mines.
(1) Whenever the Secretary, upon the basis of
information submitted to him in writing by an
interested person, a_ representative of any
organization of employers or employees, a nationally
recognized standards-producing organization, the
Secretary of Health and Human Services, the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health, or a State or political subdivision, or on the
basis of information developed by the Secretary or
otherwise available to him, determines that a rule
should be promulgated in order to serve the
objectives of this chapter, the Secretary may request
30a
the recommendation of an advisory committee
appointed under section 812(c) of this title. The
Secretary shall provide such an advisory committee
with any proposals of his own or of the Secretary of
Health and Human Services, together with all
pertinent factual information developed by the
Secretary or the Secretary of Health and Human
Services, or otherwise available, including the
results of research, demonstrations, and
experiments. An advisory committee shall submit to
the Secretary its recommendations regarding the
rule to be promulgated within 60 days from the date
of its appointment or within such longer or shorter
period as may be prescribed by the Secretary, but in
no event for a period which is longer than 180 days.
When the Secretary receives a recommendation,
accompanied by appropriate criteria, from the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health that a rule be promulgated, modified, or
revoked, the Secretary must, within 60 days after
receipt thereof, refer such recommendation to an
advisory committee pursuant to this paragraph, or
publish such as a proposed rule pursuant to
paragraph (2), or publish in the Federal Register his
determination not to do so, and his reasons therefor.
The Secretary shall be required to request the
recommendations of an _ advisory committee
appointed under section 812(c) of this title if the rule
to be promulgated is, in the discretion of the
Secretary which shall be final, new in effect or
application and has significant economic impact.
(2) The Secretary shall publish a proposed rule
promulgating, modifying, or revoking a mandatory
health or safety standard in the Federal Register. If
the Secretary determines that a rule should be
proposed and in connection therewith has appointed
3la
an advisory committee as provided by paragraph (1),
the Secretary shall publish a proposed rule, or the
reasons for his determination not to publish such
rule, within 60 days following the submission of the
advisory committee's recommendation or the
expiration of the period of time prescribed by the
Secretary in such submission. In either event, the
Secretary shall afford interested persons a period of
30 days after any such publication to submit written
data or comments on the proposed rule. Such
comment period may be extended by the Secretary
upon a finding of good cause, which the Secretary
shall publish in the Federal Register. Publication
shall include the text of such rules proposed in their
entirety, a comparative text of the proposed changes
in existing rules, and shall include a comprehensive
index to the rules, cross-referenced by subject
matter.
(3) On or before the last day of the period
provided for the submission of written data or
comments under paragraph (2), any interested
person may file with the Secretary written objections
to the proposed mandatory health or safety standard,
stating the grounds therefor and requesting a public
hearing on such objections. Within 60 days after the
last day for filing such objections, the Secretary shall
publish in the Federal Register a notice specifying
the mandatory health or safety standard to which
objections have been filed and a hearing requested,
and specifying a time and place for such hearing.
Any hearing under this subsection for the purpose of
hearing relevant information shall commence within
60 days after the date of publication of the notice of
hearing. Hearings required by this subsection shall
32a
be conducted by the Secretary, who may prescribe
rules and make rulings concerning procedures in
such hearings to avoid unnecessary cost or delay.
Subject to the need to avoid undue delay, the
Secretary shall provide for procedures that will
afford interested parties the right to participate in
the hearing, including the right to present oral
statements and to offer written comments and data.
The Secretary may require by subpoena the
attendance of witnesses and the production of
evidence in connection with any proceeding initiated
under this section. If a person refuses to obey a
subpoena under this subsection, a United States
district court within the jurisdiction of which a
proceeding under this subsection is conducted may,
upon petition by the Secretary, issue an order
requiring compliance with such subpoena. A ~-
transcript shall be taken of any such hearing and
shall be available to the public.
(4) (A) Within 90 days after certification of the
record of the hearing held pursuant to paragraph (3),
the Secretary shall by rule promulgate, modify, or
revoke such mandatory health or safety standards,
and publish his reasons therefor.
(B) In the case of a proposed mandatory health
or safety standard to which objections requesting a
public hearing have not been filed, the Secretary,
within 90 days after the period for filing such
objections has expired, shall by rule promulgate,
modify, or revoke such mandatory standards, and
publish his reasons therefor.
(C) In the event the Secretary determines that
a proposed mandatory health or safety standard
should not be promulgated he shall, within the times
33a
specified in subparagraphs (A) aud (B) publish his
reasons for his determination.
(5) Any mandatory health or safety standard
promulgated as a final rule under this section shall
be effective upon publication in the Federal Register
unless the Secretary specifies a later date.
(6) (A) The Secretary, in promulgating mandatory
standards dealing with toxic materials or harmful
physical agents under this subsection, shall set
standards which most adequately assure on the basis
of the best available evidence that no miner will
suffer material impairment of health or functional
capacity even if such miner has regular exposure to
the hazards dealt with by such standard for the
period of his working life. Development of mandatory
standards under this subsection shall be based upon
research, demonstrations, experiments, and such
other information as may be appropriate. In addition
to the attainment of the highest degree of health and
safety protection for the miner, other considerations
shall be the latest available scientific data in the
field, the feasibility of the standards, and experience
gained under this and other health and safety laws.
Whenever practicable, the mandatory health or
safety standard promulgated shall be expressed in
terms of objective criteria and of the performance
desired.
(B) The Secretary of Health and Human
Services, as soon as possible after November 9, 1977,
but in no event later than 18 months after such date
and on a continuing basis thereafter, shall, for each
toxic material or harmful physical agent which is
34a
used or found in a mine, determine whether such
material or agent is potentially toxic at the
concentrations in which it is used or found in a mine.
The Secretary of Health and Human Services shall
submit such determinations with respect to such
toxic substances or harmful physical agents to the
Secretary. Thereafter, the Secretary of Health and
Human Services shall submit to the Secretary all
pertinent criteria regarding any such substances
determined to be toxic or any such harmful agents as
such criteria are developed. Within 60 days after
receiving any criteria in accordance with the
preceding sentence relating to a toxic material or
harmful physical agent which is not adequately
covered by a mandatory health or safety standard
promulgated under this section, the Secretary shall
either appoint an advisory committee to make
recommendations with respect to a mandatory
health or safety standard covering such material or
agent in accordance with paragraph (1), or publish a
proposed rule promulgating such a mandatory health
or safety standard in accordance with paragraph (2),
or shall publish his determination not to do so.
(7) Any mandatory health or safety standard
promulgated under this subsection shall prescribe
the use of labels or other appropriate forms of
warning as are necessary to insure that miners are
apprised of all hazards to which they are exposed,
relevant symptoms and appropriate emergency
treatment, and proper conditions and precautions of
safe use or exposure. Where appropriate, such
mandatory standard shall also prescribe suitable
protective equipment and control or technological
procedures to be used in connection with such
hazards and shall provide for monitoring or
measuring miner exposure at such locations and
35a
intervals, and in such manner so as to assure the
maximum protection of miners. In addition, where
appropriate, any such mandatory standard shall
prescribe the type and frequency of medical
examinations or other tests which shall be made
available, by the operator at his cost, to miners
exposed to such hazards in order to most effectively
determine whether the health of such miners is
adversely affected by such exposure. Where
appropriate, the mandatory standard shall provide
that where a determination is made that a miner
may suffer material impairment of health or
functional capacity by reason of exposure to the
hazard covered by such mandatory standard, that
miner shall be removed from such exposure and
reassigned. Any miner transferred as a result of such
exposure shall continue to receive compensation for
such work at no less than the regular rate of pay for
miners in the classification such miner held
immediately prior to his transfer. In the event of the
transfer of a miner pursuant to the preceding
sentence, increases in wages of the transferred miner
shall be based upon the new work classification. In
the event such medical examinations are in the
nature of research, as determined by the Secretary of
Health and Human Services, such examinations may
be furnished at the expense of the Secretary of
Health and Human Services. The results of
examinations or tests made pursuant to the
preceding sentence shall be furnished only to the
Secretary or the Secretary of Health and Human
Services, and, at the request of the miner, to his
designated physician.
36a
(8) The Secretary shall, to the extent practicable,
promulgate separate mandatory health or safety
standards applicable to mine construction activity on
the surface.
(9) No mandatory health or safety standard
promulgated under this subchapter shall reduce the
protection afforded miners by an existing mandatory
health or safety standard.
(b) Emergency temporary mandatory standards
(1) The Secretary shall provide, without regard to
the requirements of chapter 5 of Title 5 for an
emergency temporary mandatory health or safety
standard to take immediate effect upon publication
in the Federal Register if he determines (A) that
miners are exposed to grave danger from exposure to
substances or agents determined to be toxic or
physically harmful, or to other hazards, and (B) that
such emergency standard is necessary to protect
miners from such danger.
(2) A temporary mandatory health or safety
standard shall be effective until superseded by a
mandatory standard promulgated in accordance with
the procedures prescribed in paragraph (3) of this
subsection.
(3) Upon publication of such standard in the
Federal Register, the Secretary shall commence a
proceeding in accordance with subsection (a) of this
section, and the standards as published shall also
serve as a proposed rule for the proceeding. The
Secretary shall promulgate a mandatory health or
safety standard under this paragraph no later than
37a
nine months after publication of the emergency
temporary standard as provided in paragraph (2).
(c) Modification of standards
Upon petition by the operator or the representative
of miners, the Secretary may modify the application
of any mandatory safety standard to a coal or other
mine if the Secretary determines that an alternative
method of achieving the result of such standard
exists which will at all times guarantee no less than
the same measure of protection afforded the miners
of such mine by such standard, or that the
application of such standard to such mine will result
in a diminution of safety to the miners in such mine.
Upon receipt of such petition the Secretary shall
publish notice thereof and give notice to the operator
or the representative of miners in the affected mine,
as appropriate, and shall cause such investigation to
be made as he deems appropriate. Such investigation
shall provide an opportunity for a public hearing at
the request of such operator or representative or
other interested party, to enable the operator or the
representative of miners in such mine or other
interested party to present information relating to
the modification of such standard. Before granting
any exception to a mandatory safety standard, the
findings of the Secretary or his authorized
representative shall be made public and shall be
available to the representative of the miners at the
affected mine. The Secretary shall issue a decision
incorporating his findings of fact therein, and send a
copy thereof to the operator or the representative of
the miners, as appropriate. Any such hearing shall
38a
be of record and shall be subject to section 554 of
Title 5.
(d) Judicial review
Any person who may be adversely affected by a
mandatory health or safety standard promulgated
under this section may, at any time prior to the
sixtieth day after such standard is promulgated, file
a petition challenging the validity of such mandatory
standard with the United States Court of Appeals for
the District of Columbia Circuit or the circuit
wherein such person resides or has his principal
place of business, for a judicial review of such
standard. A copy of the petition shall be forthwith
transmitted by the clerk of the court to the
Secretary. The filing of such petition shall not, unless
otherwise ordered by the court, operate as a stay of
the standard. No objection that has not been urged
before the Secretary shall be considered by the court,
unless the failure or neglect to urge such objection
shall be excused for good cause shown. The validity
of any mandatory health or safety standard shall not
be subject to challenge on the grounds that any of the
time limitations in this section have been exceeded.
The procedures of this subsection shall be the
exclusive means of challenging the validity of a
mandatory health or safety standard.
(e) Distribution of copies of proposed standards or
regulations
The Secretary shall send a copy of every proposed
mandatory health or safety standard or regulation at
the time of publication in the Federal Register to the
operator of each coal or other mine and the
representative of the miners at such mine and such
39a
copy shall be immediately posted on the bulletin
board of the mine by the operator or his agent, but
failure to receive such notice shall not relieve anyone
of the obligation to comply with such standard or
regulation.
40a
APPENDIX J
30 U.S.C. § 814(a)
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
Subchapter I. General
§ 814. Citations and orders
(a) Issuance and form of citations; prompt issuance
If, upon inspection or investigation, the Secretary or
his authorized representative believes that an
operator of a coal or other mine subject to this
chapter has violated this chapter, or any mandatory
health or safety standard, rule, order, or regulation
promulgated pursuant to this chapter, he shall, with
reasonable promptness, issue a citation to the
operator. Each citation shall be in writing and shall
describe with particularity the nature of the
violation, including a reference to the provision of the
chapter, standard, rule, regulation, or order alleged
to have been violated. In addition, the citation shall
fix a reasonable time for the abatement of the
violation. The requirement for the issuance of a
citation with reasonable promptness shall not be a
jurisdictional prerequisite to the enforcement of any
provision of this chapter.
4la
APPENDIX K
30 U.S.C. § 815
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
Subchapter I. General
§ 815. Procedure for enforcement
(a) Notification of civil penalty; contest
If, after an inspection or investigation, the Secretary
issues a citation or order under section 814 of this
title, he shall, within a reasonable time after the
termination of such inspection or investigation,
notify the operator by certified mail of the civil
penalty proposed to be assessed under section 820(a)
of this title for the violation cited and that the
operator has 30 days within which to notify the
Secretary that he wishes to contest the citation or
proposed assessment of penalty. A copy of such
notification shall -be sent by mail to. the
representative of miners in such mine. If, within 30
days from the receipt of the notification issued by the
Secretary, the operator fails to notify the Secretary
that he intends to contest the citation or the
proposed assessment of penalty, and no notice is filed
by any miner or representative of miners under
subsection (d) of this section within such time, the
citation and the proposed assessment of penalty shal]
be deemed a final order of the Commission and not
subject to review by any court or age cy. Refusal by
42a
the operator or his agent to accept certified mail
containing a citation and proposed assessment of
penalty under this subsection shall constitute receipt
thereof within the meaning of this subsection.
(b) Failure of operator to correct violation;
notification; contest; temporary relief
(1)(A) If the Secretary has reason to believe that
an operator has failed to correct a violation for which
a citation has been issued within the period
permitted for its correction, the Secretary shall notify
the operator by certified mail of such failure and of
the penalty proposed to be assessed under section
820(b) of this title by reason of such failure and that
the operator has 30 days within which to notify the
Secretary that he wishes to contest the Secretary's
notification of the proposed assessment of penalty. A
copy of such notification of the proposed assessment
of penalty shall at the same time be sent by mail to
the representative of the mine employees. If, within
30 days from the receipt of notification of proposed
assessment of penalty issued by the Secretary, the
operator fails to notify the Secretary that he intends
to contest the notification of proposed assessment of
penalty, such notification shall be deemed a final
order of the Commission and not subject to review by
any court or agency. Refusal by the operator or his
agent to accept certified mail containing a
notification of proposed assessment of penalty issued
under this subsection shall constitute receipt thereof
within the meaning of this subsection.
(B) In determining whether to propose a
penalty to be assessed under section 820(b) of this
title, the Secretary shall consider the operator's
history of previous violations, the appropriateness of
43a
such penalty to the size of the business of the
operator charged, whether the operator was
negligent, the effect on the operator's ability to
continue in business, the gravity of the violation, and
the demonstrated good faith of the operator charged
in attempting to achieve rapid compliance after
notification of a violation.
(2) An applicant may file with the Commission a
written request that the Commission’ grant
temporary relief from any modification or
termination of any order or from any order issued
under section 814 of this title together with a
detailed statement giving the reasons for granting
such relief. The Commission may grant such relief
under such conditions as it may prescribe, if--
(A) a hearing has been held in which all
parties were given an opportunity to be heard;
(B) the applicant shows that there is
substantial likelihood that the findings of the
Commission will be favorable to the applicant; and
(C) such relief will not adversely affect the
health and safety of miners.
No temporary relief shall be granted in the case of a
citation issued under subsection (a) or (f) of section
814 of this title. The Commission shall provide a
procedure for expedited consideration of applications
for temporary relief under this paragraph.
44a
(c) Discrimination or interference prohibited;
complaint; investigation; determination; hearing
(1) No person shall discharge or in any manner
discriminate against or cause to be discharged or
cause discrimination against or otherwise interfere
with the exercise of the statutory rights of any
miner, representative of miners or applicant for
employment in any coal or other mine subject to this
chapter because such miner, representative of
miners or applicant for employment has filed or
made a complaint under or related to this chapter,
including a complaint notifying the operator or the
operator's agent, or the representative of the miners
at the coal or other mine of an alleged danger or
safety or health violation in a coal or other mine, or
because such miner, represemtative of miners or
applicant for employment is the subject of medical
evaluations and potential transfer under a standard
published pursuant to section 811 of this title or
because such mines fepresentative of miners or
applicant for empi@yment has instituted or caused to
be instituted amy proceeding under or related to this
chapter or has testified or is about to testify in any
such proceeding, or because of the exercise by such
miner, representative of miners or applicant for
employment on behalf of himself or others of any
statutory mght afforded by this chapter.
(2) Any miner or applicant for employment or
representative of miners who believes that he has
been discharged, interfered with, or otherwise
discriminated against by any person in violation of
this subsection may, within 60 days after such
violation occurs, file a complaint with the Secretary
alleging such discrimination. Upon receipt of such
complaint, the Secretary shall forward a copy of the
45a
complaint to the respondent and shall cause such
investigation to be made as he deems appropriate.
Such investigation shall commence within 15 days of
the Secretary's receipt of the complaint, and if the
Secretary finds that such complaint was not
frivolously brought, the Commission, on an expedited
basis upon application of the Secretary, shall order
the immediate reinstatement of the miner pending
final order on the complaint. If upon such
investigation, the Secretary determines that the
provisions of this subsection have been violated, he
shall immediately file a complaint with the
Commission, with service upon the alleged violator
and the miner, applicant for employment, or
representative of miners alleging such
discrimination or interference and propose an order
granting appropriate relief. The Commission shall
afford an opportunity for a hearing (in accordance
with section 554 of Title 5 but without regard to
subsection (a)(3) of such section) and thereafter shall
issue an order, based upon findings of fact, affirming,
modifying, or vacating the Secretary's proposed
order, or directing other appropriate relief. Such
order shall become final 30 days after its issuance.
The Commission shall have authority in such
proceedings to require a person committing a
violation of this subsection to take such affirmative
action to abate the violation as the Commission
deems appropriate, including, but not limited to, the
rehiring or reinstatement of the miner to his former
position with back pay and interest. The complaining
miner, applicant, or representative of miners may
present additional evidence on his own behalf during
any hearing held pursuant to his [FN1) paragraph.
46a
(3) Within 90 days of the receipt of a complaint
filed under paragraph (2), the Secretary shall notify,
in writing, the miner, applicant for employment, or
representative of miners of his determination
whether a violation has occurred. If the Secretary,
upon investigation, determines that the provisions of
this subsection have not been violated, the
complainant shall have the right, within 30 days of
notice of the Secretary's determination, to file an
action in his own behalf before the Commission,
charging discrimination or interference in violation
of paragraph (1). The Commission shall afford an
opportunity for a hearing (in accordance with section
554 of Title 5 but without regard to subsection (a)(3)
of such section), and thereafter shall issue an order,
based upon findings of fact, dismissing or sustaining
the complainant's charges and, if the charges arc
sustained, granting such relief as it deems
appropriate, including, but not limited to, an order
requiring the rehiring or reinstatement of the miner
to his former position with back pay and interest or
such remedy as may be appropriate. Such order shall
become final 30 days after its issuance. Whenever an
order is issued sustaining the complainant's charges
under this subsection, a sum equal to the aggregate
amount of all costs and expenses (including
attorney's fees) as determined by the Commission to
have been reasonably incurred by the miner,
applicant for employment or representative of miners
for, or in connection with, the institution and
prosecution of such proceedings shall be assessed
against the person committing such violation.
Proceedings under this section shall be expedited by
the Secretary and the Commission. Any order issued
by the Commission under this paragraph shall be
subject to judicial review in accordance with section
816 of this title. Violations by any person of
Ala
paragraph (1) shall be subject to the provisions of
sections 818 and 820(a) of this title.
(d) Contest proceedings; hearing; findings of fact;
affirmance, modification, or vacatur of citation,
order, or proposed penalty; procedure before
Commission
If, within 30 days of receipt thereof, an operator of a
coal or other mine notifies the Secretary that he
intends to contest the issuance or modification of an
order issued under section 814 of this title, or
citation or a notification of proposed assessment of a
penalty issued under subsection (a) or (b) of this
section, or the reasonableness of the length of
abatement time fixed in a citation or modification
thereof issued under section 814 of this title, or any
miner or representative of miners notifies the
Secretary of an intention to contest the issuance,
modification, or termination of any order issued
vader section 814 of this title, or the reasonableness
of the length of time set for abatement by a citation
or modification thereof issued under section 814 of
this title, the Secretary shall immediately advise the
Commission of such _ notification, and_ the
Commission shall afford an opportunity for a hearing
(in accordance with section 554 of Title 5, but
without regard to subsection (a)(3) of such section),
and thereafter shall issue an order, based on findings
of fact, affirming, modifying, or vacating the
Secretary's citation, order, or proposed penalty, or
directing other appropriate relief. Such order shall
become final 30 days after its issuance. The rules of
procedure prescribed by the Commission shall
provide affected miners or representatives of affected
48a
miners an opportunity to participate as parties to
hearings under this section. The Commission shall
take whatever action is necessary to expedite
proceedings for hearing appeals of orders issued
under section 814 of this title.
49a
APPENDIX L
30 U.S.C. § 820(a)
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
Subchapter I. General
§ 820. Penalties
(a) Civil penalty for violation of mandatory health or
safety standards
(1) The operator of a coal or other mine in which a
violation occurs of a mandatory health or safety
standard or who violates any other provision of this
chapter, shall be assessed a civil penalty by the
Secretary which penalty shall not be more than
$50,000 for each such violation. Each occurrence of a
violation of a mandatory health or safety standard
may constitute a separate offense.
(2) The operator of a coal or other mine who fails
to provide timely notification to the Secretary as
required under section 813() of this title (relating to
the 15 minute requirement) shall be assessed a civil
penalty by the Secretary of not less than $5,000 and
not more than $60,000.
(3) (A) The minimum penalty for any citation or
order issued under section 814 (d)(1) of this title
shall be $2,000.
50a
(B) The minimum penalty for any order issued
under section 814(d)(2) of this title shall be $4,000.
(4) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed
to prevent an operator from obtaining a review, in
accordance with section 816 of this title, of an order
imposing a penalty described in this subsection. If a
court, in making such review, sustains the order, the
court shall apply at least the minimum penalties
required under this subsection.
5la
APPENDIX M
30 U.S.C. § 955
United States Code Annotated
Title 30. Mineral Lands and Mining
Chapter 22. Mine Safety and Health
Subchapter V. Administrative Provisions
§ 955. State laws
(a) No State law in effect on December 30, 1969 or
which may become effective thereafter shall be
superseded by any provision of this chapter or order
issued or any mandatory health or safety standard,
except insofar as such State law is in conflict with
this chapter or with any order issued or any
mandatory health or safety standard.
(b) The provisions of any State law or regulation in
effect upon the operative date of this chapter, or
which may become effective thereafter, which
provide for more stringent health and _ safety
standards applicable to coal or other mines than do
the provisions of this chapter or any order issued or
any mandatory health or safety standard shall not
thereby be construed or held to be in conflict with
this chapter. The provisions of any State law or
regulation in effect on December 30, 1969, or which
may become effective thereafter, which provide for
health and safety standards applicable tc coal or
other mines for which no provision is contained in
this chapter or in any order issued or any mandatory
52a
4 health or safety standard, shall not be held to be in
4 conflict with this chapter.
53a
APPENDIX N
30 C.F.R. § 46.12
Code of Federal Regulations Currentness
Title 30. Mineral Resources
Chapter I. Mine Safety and Health Administration,
Department of Labor
Subchapter H. Education and Training
Part 46. Training and Retraining of Miners Engaged
in Shell Dredging or Employed at Sand, Gravel,
Surface Stone, Surface Clay, Colloidal Phosphate, or
Surface Limestone Mines
§ 46.12 Responsibility for independent
contractor training.
(a)(1) Each’ production-operator has_ primar
responsibility for ensuring that site-specific hazard
awareness training is given to employees of
independent contractors who are required to receive
such training under § 46.11 of this part.
(2) Each’ production-operator must _ provide
information to each independent contractor who
employs a person at the mine on site-specific mine
hazards and the obligation of the contractor to
comply with our regulations, including the
requirements of this part.
54a
(b) (1) Each independent contractor who employs a
miner, as defined in § 46.2, at the mine has primary
responsibility for complying with §§ 46.3 through
46.10 of this part, including providing new miner
training, newly hired experienced miner training,
new task training, and annual refresher training.
(2) The independent contractor must inform the
production-operator of any hazards of which the
contractor is aware that may be created by the
performance of the contractor's work at the mine.
55a
APPENDIX O
30 C.F.R. § 48.5
Code of Federal Regulations
Title 30. Mineral Resources
Chapter I. Mine Safety and Health Administration,
Department of Labor
Subchapter H. Education and Training
Part 48. Training and Retraining of Miners
Subpart A. Training and Retraining of Underground
Miners
§ 48.5 Training of new miners; minimum
courses of instruction; hours of instruction.
(a) Each new miner shall receive no less than 40
hours of training as prescribed in this section before
such miner is assigned to work duties. Such training
shall be conducted in conditions which a: closely as
practicable duplicate actual underground conditions,
and approximately 8 hours of training shall be given
at the minesite.
(b) The training program for new miners shall
include the following courses:
(1) Instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under the Act; authority
and responsibility of supervisors. The course shall
56a
include instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under the Act, including a
discussion of section 2 of the Act; a review and
description of the line of authority of supervisors and
miners' representatives and the responsibilities of
such supervisors and miners' representatives; and an
introduction to the operator's rules and _ the
procedures for reporting hazards.
(2) Self-rescue and respiratory devices. The course
shall be given before a new miner goes underground
and shall include--
(i) Instruction and demonstration in the use,
care, and maintenance of self-rescue and respiratory
devices used at the mine;
(i) Hands-on training in the complete donning
of all types of self-contained self-rescue devices used
at the mine, which includes assuming a donning
position, opening the device, activating the device,
inserting the mouthpiece, and putting on the nose
clip; and
(i) Hands-on training in transferring between
all applicable self-rescue devices.
(3) Entering and leaving the mine;
transportation; communications. The course shall
include instruction on the procedures in effect for
entering and leaving the mine; the check-in and
checkout system in effect at the mine; the procedures
for riding on and in mine conveyances; the controls
in effect for the transportation of miners and
materials; and the use of the mine communication
systems, warning signals, and directional signs.
57a
(4) Introduction to the work environment. The
course shall include a visit and tour of the mine, or
portions of the mine which are representative of the
entire mine. A method of mining utilized at the mine
shall be observed and explained.
(5) Mine map; escapeways; emergency evacuation;
barricading. The program of instruction for mine
emergency evacuation and firefighting approved by
the District Manager under 30 CFR 75.1502 or the
escape and evacuation plan under 30 CFR 57.11053,
as applicable, shall be used for this course. The
course shall include--
(i) A review of the mine map; the escapeway
system; the escape, firefighting, and emergency
evacuation plans in effect at the mine; and the
location of abandoned areas; and
(ii) An introduction to the methods of
barricading and the locations of the barricading
materials, where applicable.
(6) Roof or ground control and ventilation plans.
The course shall include an introduction to and
instruction on the roof or ground contro] plan in
effect at the mine and procedures for roof and rib or
ground control; and an introduction to and
instruction on the ventilation plan in effect at the
mine and the procedures for maintaining and
controlling ventilation.
(7) Health. The course shall include instruction on
the purpose of taking dust, noise, and other health
measurements, and any health control plan in effect
58a
at the mine shall be explained. The health provisions
of the act and warning labels shall also be explained.
(8) Cleanup; rock dusting. The course shal]
include instruction on the purpose of rock dusting
and the cleanup and rock dusting program in effeet
at the mine, where applicable.
(9) Hazard recognition. The course shal) include
the recognition and avoidance of hazards present in
the mine, particularly any hazards related to
explosives where explosives are used or stored at the
mine.
(10) Electrical hazards. The course shall include
recognition and avoidance of electrical hazards.
(11) First aid. The course shall include instruction
in first aid methods acceptable to MSHA.
(12) Mine gases. The course shall include
instruction in the detection and avoidance of hazards
associated with mine gases.
(13) Health amd safety aspects of the tasks to
which the new miner will be assigned. The course
shall include instruction im the health and safety
aspects of the tasks to be assigned, including the safe
work procedures of such tasks, the mandatory health
and safety standards pertinent to such tasks,
information about the physical and health hazards of
chemicals in the miner's work area, the protective
measures a miner can take against these hazards,
and the conter.’s of the mine's HazCom program.
59a
(14) Such other courses as may be required by the
District Manager based on circumstances and
conditions at the mine.
(c) Methods, including oral, written, or practical
demonstration, to determine successful completion of
the training shall be included in the training plan.
The methods for determining such completion shall -
be administered to the miner before he is assigned
work duties.
(d) A newly employed miner who has less than 12
months of mining experience and has received the
courses and hours of instruction in paragraphs (a)
and (b) of this section, within 36 months preceding
employment at a mine, does not have to repeat this
training. Before the miner starts work, the operator
must provide the miner with the experienced miner
training in § 48.6(b) of this part and, if applicable,
the new task training in § 48.7 of this part. The
operator must also provide the miner with annual
refresher training and additional new task training,
as applicable.
60a
APPENDIX P
30 CFR § 48.25
Code of Federal Regulations
Title 30. Mineral Resources
Chapter I. Mine Safety and Health Administration,
Department of Labor
Subchapter H. Education and Training
Part 48. Training and Retraining of Miners
Subpart B. Training and Retraining of Miners
Working at Surface Mines and Surface Areas of
Underground Mines
§ 48.25 Training of new miners; minimum
courses of instruction; hours of instruction.
(a) Each new miner shall receive no less than 24
hours of training as prescribed in this section. Except
as otherwise provided in this paragraph, new miners
shall receive this training before they are assigned to
work duties. At the discretion of the District
Manager, new miners may receive a portion of this
training after assignment to work duties: Provided,
That no less than 8 hours of training shall in all
cases be given to new miners before they are
assigned to work duties. The following courses shall
be included in the 8 hours of training: Introduction to
work environment, hazard recognition, and health
and safety aspects of the tasks to which the new
miners will be assigned. Following the completion of
this preassignment training, new miners shall then
6la
receive the remainder of the required 24 hours of
training, or up to 16 hours, within 60 days.
Operators shall indicate in the training plans
submitted for approval whether they want to train
new miners after assignment to duties and for how
many hours. In determining whether new miners
may be given this training after they are assigned
duties, the District Manager shall consider such
factors as the mine safety record, rate of employee
turnover and mine size. Miners who have not
received the full 24 hours of new miner training shall
be required to work under the close supervision of an
experienced miner.
(b) The training program for new miners shall
include the following courses:
(1) Instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under the Act; authority
and responsibility of supervisors. The course shall
include instruction in the statutory rights of miners
and their representatives under the Act, including a
discussion of section 2 of the Act; a review and
description of the line of authority of supervisors and
miners’ representatives and the responsibilities of
such supervisors and miners' representatives; and an
introduction to the operator's rules and _ the
procedures for reporting hazards.
(2) Self-rescue and respiratory devices. The course
shall include instruction and demonstration in the
use, care, and maintenance of self-rescue and
respiratory devices, where applicable.
62a
(3) Transportation controls and communication
systems. The course shall include instruction on the
procedures in effect for riding on and in mine
conveyances where applicable; the controls for the
transportation of miners and materials; and the use
of mine communication systems, warning signals,
and directional signs.
(4) Introduction to work environment. The course
shall include a visit and tour of the mine, or portions
of the mine which are representative of the entire
mine. The method of mining or operation utilized
shall be observed and explained.
(5) Escape and emergency evacuation plans;
firewarning and firefighting. The course shall
include a review of the mine escape system, and
escape and emergency evacuation plans in effect at
the mine; and instruction in the firewarning signals
and firefighting procedures.
(6) Ground control; working in areas of highwalls,
water hazards, pits and spoil banks; illumination
and night work. The course shall include, where
applicable, and introduction to and instruction on the
highwall and ground control plans in effect at the
mine; procedures for working safely in areas of
highwalls, water hazards, pits and spoil banks; the
illumination of work areas; and safe work procedures
during the hours of darkness.
(7) Health. The course shall include instruction on
the purpose of taking dust measurements, where
applicable, and noise and_ other health
measurements, and any health control plan in effect
at the mine shall be explained. The health provisions
of the Act and warning labels shall also be explained.
63a
(8) Hazard recognition. The course shall include
the recognition and avoidance of hazards present in
the mine.
(9) Electrical hazards. The course shall include
recognition and avoidance of electrical hazards.
(10) First aid. The course shall include instruction
in first aid methods acceptable to MSHA.
(11) Explosives. The course shall include a review
and instruction on the hazards related to explosives.
The only exception to this course component is when
no explosives are used or stored on mine property.
(12) Health and safety aspects of the tasks to
which the new miner will be assigned. The course
shall include instructions in the health and safety
aspects of the tasks to be assigned, including the safe
work procedures of such tasks, the mandatory health
and safety standards pertinent to such tasks,
information about the physical and health hazards of
chemicals in the miner's work area, the protective
measures a miner can take against these hazards,
and the contents of the mine's HazCom program.
(13) Such other courses as may be required by the
District Manager based on circumstances and
conditions at the mine. :
(c) Methods, including oral, written or practical
demonstration, to determine successful completion of
the training shall be included in the training plan.
Upon completion of training, the methods for
64a
determining successful completion’ shall be
administered to the miner. The method for
determining successful completion of pre-assignment
training under paragraph (a) of this section shall be
administered to the miner before he is assigned to
work duties.
(d) A newly employed miner who has less than 12
months of mining experience and has received the
courses and hours of instruction in paragraphs (a)
and (b) of this section, within 36 months preceding
employment at a mine, does not have to repeat this
training. Before the miner starts work, the operator
must provide the miner with the experienced miner
training in § 48.26(b) of this part and, if applicable,
the new task training in § 48.27 of this part. The
operator must also provide the miner with annual
refresher training and additional new task training,
as applicable.
65a
APPENDIX Q
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, MINE SAFETY
AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION, METAL /
NONMETAL FATALITY FATALGRAM
(FEBRUARY 17, 1999)
U.S. Department of Labor
Mine Safety and Health Administration
Protecting Miners' Safety and Health Since 1978
METAL/NONMETAL MINE FATALITY - On
February 17, 1999, a 35-year-old technician
(contractor operator) with 10 years experience was
fatally injured at a sand and gravel operation. The
victim used a fork lift attached to a chain while
attempting to remove a wheel assembly from a dump
trailer in preparation to repair the brakes. After
these attempts failed to free the wheel, he applied
heat to the back side of the wheel with an
oxygen/acetylene torch and the tire ruptured.
Best Practices
Never apply a heat source to a tire rim/hub
until the tire has been removed from the rim/hub
assembly.
The manufacturer's guidelines for wheel
removal should be consulted and followed.
Tire and rim safety training should be
provided to maintenance personnel who are
required to service tires and rims.
66a
MSHA Publication IG 60, "Tire and Rim
Safety Awareness Program" is available frow the
National Mine Health & Safety Academy or cn
the Internet at http:// www. msha. gov/sc:
hinfo/IG60.PDF. The tile is in PDF.
This is the tenth fatality reported in calendar
year 1999 in the metal and nonmetal mining
industries. As of this date in 1998, there were
eight fatalities reported in these industries. This
is the first fatality classified as Exploding Vessels
Under Pressure in 1999. There were no Exploding
Vessels Under Pressure fatalities in the same
period in 1998.
http://www.msha.gov/FATALS/1999/FAB99M 10. htm
67a
APPENDIX R
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR,
MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH
ADMINISTRATION,
ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT
(FEBRUARY 17, 1999)
U.S. Department of Labor
Mine Safety and Health Administration
Protecting Miners' Safety and Health Since 1978
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION
SOUTH CENTRAL DISTRICT
Metal and Nonmetal Mine Safety and Health
Accident Investigation Report
Surface Nonmetal Mine
(Sand & Gravel)
Fatal Exploding Vessel Under Pressure Accident
RDO Equipment Company
I.D. No. ZEL
at
Trinity Materials Incorporated
Waco Pit
Waco, McLennan County, Texas
I.D. No. 41-03492
February 17, 1999
68a
by
Michael C. Sanders
Mine Safety and Health Inspector
Donald Peiffer
Physical Scientist
Richard Dunst
Chemical Engineer
Originating Office
Mine Safety and Health Administration
South Central District
1100 Commerce Street, Room 4C50
Dallas Texas 75242-0119
Doyle D. Fink
District Manager
GENERAL INFORMATION
Brad Johnson, service technician, age 35, was
critically injured at about 1:30 p.m., on February 17,
1999, when a tire exploded after heat had been
applied to the rim. He died on March 1, 1999.
Johnson had 10 years experience as a_ service
technician, 5 years with this employer. He had not
received training in accordance with 30 CFR part 48.
MSHA was notified at 2:00 p.m. on the day of the
accident by a telephone call from the safety director
for the mining company. An investigation was
started the same day.
69a
The Waco Pit, a surface sand and gravel
operation, owned and operated by Trinity Industries,
Inc., was located near Waco, McLennan County,
Texas. The principal official was Walter Poston,
manager. The plant and pit were normally operated
one, 10%-hour and one, 12™%-hour shift a day, five
days a week. A total of 23 persons was employed.
Sand and gravel was extracted by dragline and
hauled to the plant where it was washed, sized and
stockpiled. The finished products were sold for use in
the construction industry.
The victim was employed by RDO Equipment
Company, an independent contractor in Hewitt,
McLennan County, Texas. The contractor was
enlisted by the mine operator to repair the brakes on
a haulage unit. The principal operating official was
Bradley Campbell, general manager.
The last regular inspection at this operation was
completed on September 9, 1998. Another inspection
was conducted at the conclusion of this investigation.
Physical Factors Involved
The accident occurred in the main shop building
at the plant. The equipment involved was a 1975
Euclid B-30 tractor and bottom dump trailer rated at
60,000 pounds capacity. The trailer had been
removed from service to repair the left rear brakes.
The tire was a Firestone tubeless type Super Rock
Grip WB size 29.5 X 25 with 28-ply rating. It
weighed approximately 1500 pounds. The diameter
was 67 inches and tread width was 26 inches. The
70a
tire was mounted on a 25-inch diameter rim secured
with a five-piece lock-ring assembly. The tire and rim
assembly was secured to the wheel with 20 wheel
clamps, tensioning washers and nuts. Normal cold
operating pressure was 60 PSI.
The oxygen/acetylene cutting torch used to heat
the rim was mounted on a two-wheel cart. The
compressed gas cylinders had been secured to the
cart with a chain and provided with protective valve
covers. The heating tip was a multiple flame heating
nozzle (rosebud).
Laboratory tests indicated that the application of
heat caused the tire material to produce combustible
gases inside the tire. The heated rim and tire
provided an ignition source for the combustible
gases, which resulted in the explosion.
The victim was using a fork lft truck to remove the
tire. The fork lift was a Hyster model H80C, rated at
8,000 pounds load capacity.
Description of the Accident
On the day of the accident, Brad Johnson (victim)
reported to the mine shop at 9:00 a.m. and received
his work assignment from Robert’ Farmer,
purchasing agent for Trinity Materials. Johnson was
assigned to repair the brakes on the Euclid B-30
trailer. Johnson and Terry Heard, mechanic for
Trinity Materials, backed the trailer into the
maintenance shop. Johnson then drove Heard to the
pit to pick up the fork lift. Heard drove the fork lft
back and parked it in the shop near the trailer.
7
' F
Tla
Heard went about other duties in the shop while
Johnson jacked up the trailer and supported the left
rear with a jack stand. He removed the wheel
clamps, tensioning washers and nuts then positioned
the fork lift with the forks under the tire. He
wrapped a chain around the back of the tire/rim
assembly and attached it to the load carrier guard on
the fork lift.
Johnson attempted several times to loosen the
tire/rim assembly from the wheel by hammering on
the back of the rim and tugging on it with the fork
lift. He also used compressed air to remove any sand
and gravel lodged between the rim and wheel that
might be binding the assembly.
At about 12:30 p.m. Johnson, Heard and Farmer
stopped for lunch. Johnson and Heard discussed the
problem of the rim being stuck to the wheel. After
lunch, Heard suggested that they let the air out of
the tire. Johnson removed the valve cap and
depressed the valve core for 10 to 15 munutes.
Johnson attempted several more times without
success to remove the tire and rim assembly by
tugging on it with the fork lift.
The jack stand had begun to slip out of place so
Johnson repositioned it and then asked Heard about
using heat. Heard replied that it was up to Johnson.
Johnson positioned the oxygen/acetylene cart behind
the left rear of the trailer and began to heat the rim.
After 45 minutes to an hour, Johnson called out for
Heard to come to the trailer. As Heard approached
the right side rear of the trailer the tire exploded
throwing him backward. Heard recovered
72a
momentarily and found Johnson lying unconscious
against the inside of the right side rear tire
Johnson's pants leg was on fire and while Heard
was extinguishing the flame, Robert Villa, plant
manager, arrived. They pulled Johnson from under
the trailer. He did not have a pulse and was not
breathing. Heard administered five or six chest
compressions and Johnson's pulse was restored and
he began breathing on his own. Villa administered
first aid to control bleeding and Farmer called the
local 911 emergency assistance number. The sheriff's
deputies and an ambulance arrived a short time
later. Johnson was transported to a local hospital,
_ where he died on March 1, 1999.
CONCLUSION
The accident was caused by the application of
heat to the tire rim, which caused a buildup and
subsequent ignition of combustible gases inside the
tire.
73a
VIOLATIONS
RDO Equipment Company
Citation No. 7874001 was issued on February 17,
1999, under the provisions of section 104(a) of the
Mine Act for violation of 30 CFR 56.4500:
A fatal accident occurred at this operation on
February 17, 1999, when a tire exploded while
a contractor employee was attempting to
remove the tire/rim assembly from the rear of
a Euclid B-30 trailer. After several attempts
to remove the assembly failed, heat was
applied to the rim with a torch. The heat
generated combustible gases inside the tire
which resulted in an explosion.
This citation was terminated on February 26,
1999 after the contractor issued a hazard alert to all
employees and provided training nationwide in safe
work practices for removing wheels from mobile
equipment and prohibited the use of heat from any
source.
Trinity Materials, Inc.
Citation No. 7874002 was issued on April 5, 1999,
under the provisions of section 104(a) of the Mine Act
for violation of 30 CFR 56.4500:
A fatal accident occurred at this operation on
February 17, 1999, when a tire exploded
while a contractor employee was attempting
to remove the tire/rim assembly from the
74a
rear of a Euclid B-30 trailer. After several
attempts to remove the assembly failed, heat
was applied to the rim with a torch. The heat
generated combustible gases inside the tire
which resulted in an explosion.
This citation was terminated on April 8, 1999,
after the mine operator provided training at all
company operations in safe work practices for
removing wheels from mobile equipment and
prohibited the use of heat from any source.
Related Fatal Alert Bulletin:
Appendix I
List of Participants in the Investigation
RDO Equipment Company
Timothy Lowe ... service manager, hewitt shop
William Cody Brown warranty/safety manager
Bradley Campbell ... general manager, product
support
Trinity Materials, Inc.
Steven Andrews ......................... safety director
dd ncudisinsenill safety manager
EE nn. ccncsssicguvbndpeuesall plant manager
Terry Heard ...... scindusiaiasiievetneniameiaa mechanic
Mine Safety and Health Administration
Michael C. Sanders ...... mine safety and health
inspector
IID cous sccocceccacusseuds physical scientist
IIIS»... cotemadaeliane chemical engineer
75a
Appendix II
Executive Summary of Laboratory Analysis
Trinity Materials, Inc. Mine ID #41-03492,
MSRS 049921
A laboratory investigation was conducted at the
Approval & Certification Center (A&CC) as part of
the accident investigation for MSHA, Metal and
Nonmetal Mine Safety & Health, South Central
District on the tire explosion accident that occurred
at Trinity Materials, a surface sand and gravel
aggregate facility. The laboratory investigation
included literature review, visual and microscopic
examination, and ignition and heating tests on the
damaged and undamaged liner materials.
After completion of the laboratory testing and
analysis, it was concluded that the most likely event
that caused the accident was the heating of the rim
and brake drum assemblies with an acetylene
cutting torch. The heat from the acetylene torch was
conducted through the rim and into the tire material.
The tire material decomposed and produced hot
embers and a combustible gas mixture within the
tire. The heated tire material provided an ignition
source for the combustible gases which subsequently
ignited, causing the tire to explode.
Given that the tire before the explosion was at
least at an initial pressure of about 36 psig, a
maximum explosion pressure of approximately 325
psig could have developed. This explosion pressure
would be over 3 times greater than would develop
from a combustion explosion at normal atmospheric
76a
pressure and over 3 times greater than the pressure
at which the tire would be expected to fail if
overpressurized with air. The rate of explosion
pressure rise could have been about 7500 psi/sec and
would be several times greater than would have
developed from a combustion explosion at normal
atmospheric pressure. This magnitude of maximum
pressure and rate of pressure rise from an explosion
in the tire is consistent with the degree of physical
damage observed at the accident site.
Comprehensive test results can be obtained from
the Chief of the A&CC, RR 1, Box 251, Industrial
Park Road, Triadelphia, West Virginia 26059.
http://www.msha.gov/FATALS/1999/FTL99M10.htm
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.