Joint Appendix — Shell Oil Products Products Co., LLC v. Mac's Shell Service Service, Inc. (Nos. 08-372, 08-240)
Supreme Court brief2009
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
UD [|
OOS ~ 4 “ Fx 08-230, 08- Me? Bye
-
Qar'o: ymig |
- a "
i. ee.) ee
IN THE
Supreme Court of the Anited States
MAC’s SHELL SERVICE, INC., ET AL.,
Petitioners,
Vv
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY LLC, ET AL.,
Respondents.
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY LLC, ET AL.,
Petitioners,
V.
MAc’s SHELL SERVICE, INC., ET AL.,
Respondents.
On Writ of Ceriiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the First Circuit
JOINT APPENDIX
JEFFREY A. LAMKEN GARY R. GREENBERG
Counsel of Record JOHN F. FARRAHER, JR.
ROBERT K. KRY Counsel of Record
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P. GREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP
1299 Pennsylvania Ave., NW One Internationa! Pl., 20th F'.
Washington, D.C. 20004-2400 Boston, MA 02110
(202) 639-7700 (617) 310-6000
jeffrey.lamken@bakerbotts.com farraherj@gtlaw.com
Counsel for Shell Oil Products Counsel for Mac’s Shell
Company LLC, et al. Service, Inc., et al.
[List of Counsel Continued on Inside Cover]
A I a SE ILI
WILSON-EPES PRINTINGCO..INC — (202) 789-0096 - WASHINGTON, D.C. 20002
Petitions for a Wnt of Certioran Filed — August 21 and September 19, 2008
Certioran Granted - June 15, 2009
Oo
ry ut
MACEY REASONER STOKES
DAVID M. RODI
BAKER BOTTs L.L.P.
One Shell Plaza
910 Louisiana
Houston, TX 77002-4995
(713) 229-1234
PAUL D. SANSON
VAUGHAN FINN
KAREN T. STAIB
SHIPMAN & GOODWIN LLP
One Constitution Plaza
Hartford, CT 06103
(860) 251-5000
JAMES COWAN
SENIOR COUNSEL
SHELL OIL COMPANY
P.O. Box 2463
Houston, TX 77252-2463
(713) 241-4089
Counsel for Shel Oil Products
Company LLC, et al.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Relevant Docket Entries from the United
States District Court for the District of
Massachusetts in 7'’saniklides v. Shell Oil
Products Co., No. 1:00-ev-11295-RW2Z............... l
Relevant Docket Entries from the United
States District Court for the District of
Massachusetts in Marcousx v. Shell Oil
Products Co., No. 1:01-cv-11300-RW2Z ............... 7
Relevant Docket Entries from the United
States Court of Appeals for the First
Circuit in Marcouz v. Shell Oil Products
5 a SERIES ESRI SE nr O 44
Relevant Docket Entrics from the United
States Court of Appeals for the First
Circuit in Marcoux v. Shell Oil Products
iin ST TIT litctiitduncsenathetcnsinsiinnimdiadendennéloneneseeion 46
Complaint, Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 1
Ne uasneieins 55
Memorandum of Decision on Motion to
Dismiss, Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 95
SSE TREE ea ch ORR LN 88
Second Amended Complaint, Dist. Ct. Dkt.
eB SG __. e 92
Order Selecting Dealers for Trial, Dist. Ct.
i I FI BID aieiccterciinenccsionncecedinessineees 122
Memorandum of Decision on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction, Dist. Ct. Dkt.
S&C enna 123
' All references to “Dist. Ct. Dkt.” are to the docket in No. 1:01-ev-
11300-RWZ.
(1)
ii
Affidavit of Robert Weiner, Dist. Ct. Dkt.
8 REE Ror oes ee 127
Memorandum of Decision on Motions for
Summary Judgment, Dist. Ct. Dkt. No.
I a cicerhcetiiiairlbiiceahnmndenidiindisanendececisiie 132
Testimony of Cynthia Karol (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 316 (Nov. 16, 2004)..........00..... 136
Testimony of John Sullivan (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 316 (Nov. 16, 2004)................. 145
Testimony of John Sullivan, continued
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 307
FAERIE ME US a a oo ee 146
Testimony of Akmal Moawed (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 307 (Nov. 17, 2004)... 154
Testimony of Akmal Moawed, continued
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 308
Fs ee i casincascaailiaieitecntnncdasensssbteieaninisesendasintin 156
Testimony of Francis Marcoux (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 309 (Nov. 19, 2004)... 161
Testimony of Francis Marcoux, continued
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 321
RS RES ERSTE ES Oa oo 166
Deposition of Eugene Goll (excerpts),
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 811 (C.A. App. 3582)
(taken Jan. 7, 2004; played at trial
RRS er ene ev 174
Testimony of Richard Melanson (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 321 (Nov. 22, 2004)... 178
Testimony of Richard Melanson, continued
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 310
ON aisle siainlainianlidie 181
Testimony of Sid Prashad (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 310 (Nov. 23, 2004)... 185
Testimony of Jordan Avramidis (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 310 (Nov. 23, 2004).........::0+ 189
Testimony of Jeffrey Bernard (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 311 (Nov. 24, 2004)................. 194
Testimony of Stephen Pisarezyk (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 317 (Nov. 29, 2004)............000+ 201
Memorandum of Law in Support of
Defendants’ Motion for Judgment as a
Matter of Law (excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt.
No. 323 (dated Nov. 29, 2004; docketed
EE RRS er ere nena kr 208
Testimony of Robert Morris (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 337 (Dec. 1, 2004)................... 214
Testimony of Michael F. Hanley (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 337 (Dee. 1, 2004) ........000.0..... 216
Testimony of Michael F. Hanley, continued
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 324
a ccsmuatunasen 220
Testimony of Michael Joseph Roman
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 324
BN i TED ialisscasibiniisiigeteiincaiemnanitinisianinseestennmeereonss 223
Testimony of Timothy Brooks (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 324 (Dec. 2, 2004) ................... 227
Testimony of Dennis Nielsen (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 324 (Dec. 2, 2004)... 229
Testimony of John Umbeck (excerpts), Dist.
Ct. Dit. No. 324 (Dec. 2, 20064)............:..c.c0cese000. 232
TRIAL EXHIBITS:
Shell Motor Fuel Station Lease —
Sid Prashad, dated July 10, 1994,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1246
NT III rsiceresichcre ities ntenonnenscenstiicbenseiiin 239
iv
Motiva Retail Facility Lease —
Sid Prashad, dated July 13, 2000,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1249
a, I Bee ecteeremsainneninissiiiiaiaanneniindatiies 268
Motiva Retail Facility Lease —
Akmal, Inc., dated Dec. 18, 2003
(excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit 1166
ii, SE. Ser iaecvthersincsntiiesisiantaiinsincabiaiiniate 310
Motiva Retail Facility Lease -
3 & M Avramidis, dated Jan. 7, 2002
(excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit 1175
sali: TEI. TP UIND wscssnsescsinscinnsiaisceciisiiemenseniniiainiins 312
Motiva Retail Facility Lease -
Cynthia Karol, dated Dec. 21, 2000
(excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit 1188
Cee FI TED sesciccniensistinttininininiiiinvenataniasioniinnt 314
Motiva Retail Facility Lease —-
Mac’s Shell Service Inc. (South-
bridge), dated Oct. 238, 2001 (excerpt),
Defendants’ Exhibit 1218
eh, GG Se enticnninniatminnee 316
Motiva Retail Facility Lease —
Mze’s Shell Service Inc. (Webster),
dated Oct. 23, 2001 (excerpt),
Defendants’ Exhibit 1220
FS TT
Motiva Retail Facility Lease —
RAM Corporation Inc., dated May 10,
2001 (excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit
I A. i, Ba erivieccvcesscivsscenembeniamaian 322
Motiva Retail Facility Lease -
John A. Sullivan, dated May 3, 2000
(excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit 1293
CCD, BI TEI GG ccersessarssnnbcinticssnataeiia ae
v
Motiva Extension Letter - Stephen J.
Pisarezyk, dated June 1, 1999,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1232
Ee 326
Motiva Extension Letter - Stephen J.
Pisarezyk, dated Feb. 29, 2000,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1235
is ccnsnenesrnes 328
Motiva Extension Letter — Stephen J.
Pisarezyk I], dated June 22, 2000,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1236
EE 330
Shell Offer of Variable Rent Program -
John A. Sullivan, dated Nov. 30, 1995,
Defendants’ Exhibit 1055
I iciiestssintncsisascserssnaccoscssocesccvcce | OE
Cindy Karol — Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’
Exhibit 800 (C.A. App. 2825).......0..0....0.. 336
John Sullivan — Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’
Exhibit 802 (C.A. App. 2827)... 337
Akmal Ine. — Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’
Exhibit 803 (C.A. App. 2828).............:.:ceceee 338
Mac’s Shell Service Inc. (Southbridge) -
Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 804
ES
Mac’s Shell Service Inc. (Webster) -
Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 805
ESE 340
Fran Marcoux (Webster) — Transitional
Rebates, Defendants’ Exhibit 1510
EEE 341
RAM Corp., Inc. — Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’
Exhibit 812 (C.A. App. 2836)..........cccccceceeeees 343
vi
Sid Prashad — Rents Paid, Plaintiffs’
Exhibit 815 (C.A. App. 2809).........cccccsseeseeees 344
J&M Avramidis, Inc. — Rents Paid, Plain-
tiffs’ Exhibit 817 (C.A. App. 2841)................. 345
Stephen Pisarezyk — Rents Paid, Plain-
tiffs’ Exhibit 823 (C.A. App. 2866)................. 346
Akmal, Inc. - Summary Financial Infor-
mation, Defendants’ Exhibit 1508
Fase A SIE ccacsicnsciiniendssabeshieniasecdnsensininni 347
Mac’s Shell Service, Inc. - Summary
Financia] Information, Defendants’
Exhibit 1516 (C.A. App. 3556)..........0...... 348
R.A.M. Corporation —- Summary
Financial Information, Defendants’
Exhibit 1518 (C.A. App. 3557)..........0..0........ 349
Mac’s Shell Service, Inc. (Marcoux) —
Analysis of Profitability (excerpt),
Defendants’ Exhibit 1537
Ble ee I aiircicniaiinasiientaiapdinicinniinncnnonies 350
Akmal, Inc. - Analysis of Profitability
(excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit 1540
oe ccisadenid 351
Pleasant St. Shell (Karol) — Analysis of
Profitability (excerpt), Defendants’
Exhibit 1543 (C.A. App. 3572)................ 352
J&M Avramidis Inc. - Analysis of Profit-
ability (excerpt), Defendants’ Exhibit
1546 (C.A. App. 3574) ....cccecccsccscceseseeesnneene 353
Harborside Shell (Sullivan) - Analysis of
Profitability (excerpt), Defendants’
Exhibit 1555 (C.A. App. 3576)..cccsceeccccnee 354
R.A.M. Corporation (Melanson) - Analy-
sis of Profitability (excerpt), Defend-
ants’ Exhibit 1558 (C.A. App. 3578) .............. 355
Vii
Defendants’ Motion for Jury Instructions
(excerpts), Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 351
I
Defendants’ Proposed Supplemental and
Amended Jury Instructions (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 332 (filed Dec. 6, 2004)
Transcript of Charge Conference (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 384 (Dec. 6, 2004).........
Transcript of Jury Instructions (excerpts),
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 339 (Dec. 7, 2004).........
Special Verdict, Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 335
SEERA eet ne Pe eaee Sree EOD
Memorandum in Support of Defendants’
Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law
or, in the Alternative, for a New Trial
(excerpts), see Dist. Ct. Dkt. Nos. 353,
367 (Pitfs. C.A. Supp. App. 139)
I a cinniis
Order on Trial and Post-Trial Motions,
Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 367 (Sept. 19, 2005)......
Judgment, Dist. Ct. Dkt. No. 399
Ss Ps MT stiveouseensenneiesiisedenseaenebiinadbinennivins
Memorandum of Decision and Order on
Fees and Costs (excerpts), Dist. Ct.
Dkt. No. 406 (Dec. 26, 2006) .00.00..0000 ccc.
Opinion of the Court of Appeals in
No. 05-2771 (Apr. 18, 2008) .............:ccceeeees
Order of the Court of Appeals Denying
Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc
in No. 05-2771 (May 23, 2008) .......:.c.sces000e-
seis 356
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS (BOSTON)
Case No. 1:00-ev-11295-RWZ
DEMETRIOS TSANIKLIDES, JR., LARRY RUBENSTEIN,
ALI JABER, LASCO ENTERPRISES, PAUL SROCZYNSKI,
J ENTERPRISES, INC., CHARLES LAGASSE, KACH
CORPORATION, NIKOLAS MANOUSARIDIS,
THE SHELL DEALERS DEFENSE GROUP,
Plaintiffs,
V.
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY
AND MOTIVA ENTERPRISES,
Defendants.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE No. PROCEEDINGS
06/03/2000 1 Complaint filed. Case assigned to Judge:
Zobel. Receipt#: 23486 Amount:
$150.00. Fee Status: pd (dj) (Entered:
07/05/2000)
* * * * *
09/01/2000 5 Answer by Shell Oil Products, Motiva
Enterprises to complaint; jury demand,
filed. (jdj) (Entered: 09/06/2000)
*~* * * *
DATE
No. PROCEEDINGS
10/05/2000
10/05/2000
11/01/2000
11/07/2000
11/14/2000
03/07/2001
7
8
14
15
16
18
Motion by Shell Oil Products, Motiva
Enterprises to dismiss, filed es. (jdj)
(Entered: 10/05/2000)
Memorandum by Shell Oil Products,
Motiva Enterprises in support of [7-1]
motion to dismiss, filed. (jdj) (Entered:
10/05/2000)
x * KK *
Memorandum by Demetrios Tsaniklides
Jr., Larry Rubenstein, Ali Jaber, Lasco
Enterprises, Paul Sroczynski, J Enter-
prises, Inc., Charles Lagasse, Kach Cor-
poration, Nikolas Manousaridis, The
Shell Dealers in opposition to [7-1] mo-
tion to dismiss, filed. (jdj) (Entered:
11/02/2000)
Reply by Shell Oil Products, Motiva En-
terprises to response to [7-1] motion to
dismiss, filed. (jdj) (Entered: 11/07/2000)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Clerk’s Notes: re:
motion hearing held [7-1] motion to dis-
miss taken under advisement Court Re-
porter: McLaughlin (jdj) (Entered:
11/17/2000)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Clerk’s Notes: re:
scheduling conference held: Judge de-
cides a part of motion to dismiss and has
DATE
3
No. PROCEEDINGS
03/15/2001
05/01/2001
05/01/2001
05/01/2001
05/02/2001
05/09/2001
20
21
22
23
another part to decide and will do that in
a memorandum and order. (jdj) (En-
tered: 03/07/2001)
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Endorsed Order
entered granting in part, denying in part
[7-1] motion to dismiss. [EOD Date
3/16/01] ce/cl (jdj) (Entered: 03/16/2001)
* * * Ke *
Motion by Demetrios Tsaniklides Jr. for
preliminary injunction, filed. (jdj) (En-
tered: 05/01/2001)
Memorandum by Demetrios Tsaniklides
Jr. in support of [20-1] motion for pre-
liminary injunction, filed. (jdj) (Entered:
05/01/2001)
Affidavit of Demetrios Tsaniklides Jr.,
re: [20-1] motion for preliminary injunc-
tion, filed. (jdj) (Entered: 05/01/2001)
Motion by Demetrios Tsaniklides Jr.,
Larry Rubenstein, Ali Jaber, Lasco En-
terprises, Paul Sroczynski, J Enter-
prises, Inc., Charles Lagasse, Kach Cor-
poration, Nikolas Manousaridis, The
Shell Dealers to amend [1-1] complaint,
filed. (jdj) (Entered: 05/02/2001)
Judge Rya W. Zebel. Endorsed Order
entered granting [19-1] motion to amend
[5-1] answer. ece/el [EOD Date 5/9/01)
(jdj) (Entered: 05/09/2001 )
DATE
No. PROCEEDINGS
05/09/2001 24 STIPULATION by Demetrios Tsanik-
05/14/2001
05/14/2001
05/16/2001
05/17/2001
05/29/2001
26
29
lides Jr., Larry Rubenstein, Ali Jaber,
Laseco Enterprises, Paul Sroczynski, J
Enterprises, Inc. Charles Lagasse,
Kach Corporation, Nikolas Manousari-
dis, The Shell Dealers, Shell Oil Prod-
ucts, Motiva Enterprises, Response to
motion reset to 5/29/01 for [23-1] motion
to amend [1-1] complaint, filed es. (jdj)
(Entered: 05/09/2001)
Withdrawal of [20-1] motion for pre-
liminary injunction. (lau) (Entered:
05/14/2001)
Plaintiff Demetrios Tsanikilides, Jr.’s
withdrawal of motion for Preliminary
Injunction, filed. (lau) (Entered:
05/14/2001)
Motion by Shell Oil Products to trans-
fer venue, filed cs. (jdj) (Entered:
05/16/2001)
* * * * *
Amended Answer to Complaint by Shell
Oil Products, Motiva Enterprises, filed
es. Answer amends [5-1] answer; jury
demand (jdj) (Entered: 05/17/2001)
Response by Demetrios Tsaniklides Jr.,
Larry Rubenstein, Ali Jaber, Laseo Fin-
terprises, Paul Sroczynski, J Enter-
prises, Inc., Charles Lagasse, Kach Cor-
poration, Nikolas Manousaridis, The
Shell Dealers in opposition to [26-1] mo-
DATE
No. PROCEEDINGS
05/29/2001
05/29/2901
06/12/2001
06/12/2001
08/10/2001
30
31
tion to transfer venue, filed cs. (jdj) (En-
tered: 05/30/2001)
Memorandum by Demetrios Tsaniklides
Jr., Larry Rubenstein, Ali Jaber, Lasco
Enterprises, Paul Sroczynski, J Enter-
prises, Inc., Charles Lagasse, Kach Cor-
poration, Nikolas Manousaridis, The
Shell Dealers in opposition to [26-1] mo-
tion to transfer venue, filed es. (jdj) (En-
tered: 05/30/2001)
Response by Shell Oil Products, Motiva
Enterprises in opposition to [23-1] mo-
tion to amend [1-1] complaint, filed es.
(jdj) (Entered: 05/30/2001)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Endorsed Order
entered granting [26-1] motion to trans-
fer venue. The cases shall be trans-
ferred to New Hampshire and Rhode Is-
land [EOD Date 6/12/01) (jdj) (Entered:
06/12/2001)
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Endorsed Order
entered denying [23-1] motion to amend
[1-1] complaint. Plaintiffs may file a new
case which may be deemed related
[EOD Date 6/12/01) ee/cl (jdj) (Entered:
06/12/2001)
2. & 2 F
Stipulation of dismissal by Demetrios
Tsaniklides Jr. in 1:00-ev-11295, Larry
6
DATE No. PROCEEDINGS
08/10/2001
09/07/2001 39
Rubenstein in 1:00-ev-11295, Ali Jaber in
1:00-ev-11295, Laseo Enterprises in
1:00-ev-11295, Paul Sroczynski in 1:00-
ev-11295, J Enterprises, Inc. in 1:00-ev
11295, Charles Lagasse in 1:00-ev-11295,
Kach Corporation in 1:00-ev-11295, Ni-
KOlas Manousaridis in 1:00-ev-11295, The
Shell Dealers in 1:00-cv-11295, Shell Oil
Products in 1:00-cv-11295, Motiva En-
terprises in 1:00-ev-11295 w/out preju-
dice, filed es. (jdj) (Entered: 08/13/2001)
Case closed. (jdj) (Entered: 08/13/2001)
TRANSCRIPT of Motion to Dismiss
Hearing held on November 14, 2000 be-
fore Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Jim
McLaughlin. The original transcripts
are maintained by the Clerk’s Office.
Copies may be obtained by contacting
the court reporter at 617/320-1173 or the
Clerk’s Office. (Sealfani, Deborah)
7
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS (BOSTON )
— y
Case No. 1:01-ev-11300-RWZ
FRANCIS MARCOUX, RONNIE ABOUD, ABRAHAM ABRA-
HAM, MAHENDRS AMIN, MASSOUD ATALISH, MIKE ATAL-
ISH, JORDAN AVRAMIDIS, CHRISS AZAZIAN, RICHARD
BAIMA, ED BAKER, STEVE BLACK, DOUGLASS CHAPMAN,
JAMES COGGESHALL, MICHAEL CORBETT, PATRICIA
DASILVA, ALEX DASILVA, STEVE FALCONE, GEORGE
FONTAINE, BILL FONTAINE, CAMILLE FRANCIS, STEVE
FRANGIAS, MATTY GAETA, DONALD GAGNON, JOHN GEN-
EROSO, JOHN GOLDEN, KAL HAMZF, ARRAHAM HAMZBE,
TIBOR HANGYAL, PATRICK HINES, ADAM HIPP, MUHAM-
MAD IMATIAZ, JAY JON, KAY JON, ABDUL KAFAL, JAQUE
KANAAN, GEORGE KANTARGES, JIM KANTAROWSKI, CYN-
THIA KAROL, WILLIAM KAUFMAN, JOE KELLEHER, HUS-
SEIN KOBESSI, MIKE LAMARCHE, RICHARD MELANSON,
AKMA[L] MOAWED, JAMES MORAIDIS, SUNNY PATEL,
CONSTANTIN PEIDES, RUSSELL PICARD, STEPH[E]N PIS-
ARC[Z]YK, SID PRASH[A]D, PAUL RICHARDS, HARVY RUD-
NICK, FRED SAAD, AZIZ SABA, WALID SAMROUT, EARL
STICKNEY, THOMAS SULLIVAN, ROGER THIBAULT,
DIMITRIOUS TSANIKILIDES, TOUFIC ATALLAH, DROR
DUSDUSHMAN, EARL MCLAUGHLIN, STEPHEN SHEA,
JOHN SULLIVAN, WILSON TIBURTINO, J. ENTERPRISE,
INC., LASCO ENTERPRISE, INC., NIKOLAS MANOUSARI-
DIS, LARRY RUBENSEIN, PAUL SROCZYNSKI, JES
SERVICE, INC., MAC’S SHELL SERVICE, INC.,
Plaintiffs,
8
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY, MOTIVA
ENTERPRISE[S], AND SHELL OIL COMPANY,
Defendants.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE
No. PROCEEDINGS
07/27/2001
08/06/2001
08/10/2001
09/04/2001
1
10
Complaint filed. Case assigned to Judge:
Zobel. Receipt#: 32756 Amount:
$150.00. Fee Status: pd (jdj) (Entered:
07/30/2001)
* * * * *
Amended complaint by Francis Marcoux
in 1:01-ev-11300 filed. (Answer due
8/16/01 for Motiva Enterprisefs], for
Shell Oil Products). Amended complaint
amends [1-1] complaint; (jdj) (Entered:
08/07/2001)
* * * * *
Amended complaint by Francis Marcoux
in 1:01-cv-11300 filed. (Answer due
8/20/01 for Motiva Enterprise[s], for
Shell Oil Products). Amended complaint
amends [4-1] amended complaint. filed
es (jdj) (Entered: 08/13/2001)
* * * * *
Answer by Shell Oil Products in 1:01-ev-
11300, Motiva Enterprise[s] in 1:01-cv-
11300 to complaint; jury demand, filed.
(lau) (Entered: 09/04/2001)
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
01/10/2002 30
01/31/2002 71
02/20/2002
03/01/2002 72
ees
Motion by Francis Marcoux et al. in
1:01-ev-11300 to amend [4-1] amended
complaint, filed cs. (jdj) (Entered:
01/14/2002)
fe Se 2
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Clerk’s Notes: re:
motion hearing held granting (25-1) mo-
tion for Robert E. Weiner to withdraw
as attorney. A letter from Mr. Weiner
to all parties not represented by Green-
berg Trau[rjig, indicating that he has
filed a motion to w/draw, and that any-
one who wishes to proceed w/the case
needs to contact new counsel (or Green-
berg Trau[rjig) and have new counsel
enter appearance by 2/28/02. case will
proceed w/new counsel in the interim.
Parties will collaborate on the letter
from Mr. Weiner to unrepresented
Plaintiffs. Court Reporter: McLaughlin
(jdj) (Entered: 02/05/2002)
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Endorsed Order
entered granting [30-1] motion to amend
[4-1] amended complaint. ce/el [EOD
Date 2/20/02] Gdj) (Entered: 02/20/2002)
Motion by Francis Marcoux [et al.] to
transfer and coordination, filed. (jdj)
(Entered: 03/01/2002)
a a
10
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
03/15/2002
03/15/2002
04/30/2002
05/01/2002
05/01/2002
05/10/2002
78
79
82
83
87
Motion by Shell Oil Products in 1:01-ev-
11300 to dismiss, and for judgment on
the pleadings, filed es. (jdj) (Entered:
03/19/2002)
Memorandum by Shell Oil Products in
1:01-ev-11300 in support of [78-1] motion
to dismiss, [78-2] [] and for judgment on
the pleadings, filed cs. (jdj) (Entered:
03/19/2002)
*x* kK Kk * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Order of Dismissal
entered. [EOD Date 4/30/02} ce/el (dj)
(Entered: 04/30/2002)
Response by Francis Marcoux et al. in
1:01-ev-11300 in opposition to [78-1] mo-
tion to dismiss, [78-2] [|] and for judg-
ment on the pleadings, filed es. (jdj) (En-
tered: 05/02/2002)
Memorandum by Francis Marcoux et al.
in 1:01-ev-11300 in support of [83-1] op-
position response, filed cs. (jdj) (En-
tered: 05/02/2002)
* *x* * * *
Reply by Shell Oil Products in 1:01-ev-
11300, Motiva Enterprise[s] in 1:01-ev-
11300 [in] response to [78-1] motion to
dismiss, [78-2] [] and for judgment on
the pleadings, filed es. Gdj) (Entered:
05/10/2002)
11
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
05/14/2002
05/17/2002
07/03/2002
07/12/2002
08/16/2002
08/26/2002
89
90
93
94
* * * * *
Response by Francis Marcoux in 1:01-
ev-11300 in opposition to [78-1] motion to
dismiss, [78-2] [] and for judgment on
the pleadings, filed es. (jdj) (Entered:
05/16/2002)
Transcript of proceedings [ } held on pro-
ceeding date: 5/9/02 before Judge: Zobel.
Court Reporter: James McLaughlin
(jdj) (Entered: 05/17/2002)
MDL 1:01-430 transferred to this Dis-
trict for pretrial proceedings. Master
Docket assigned as 01-cv-11300 (dj)
(Entered: 07/16/2002)
** * & *
MDL 1:01-514 transferred to this Dis-
trict for pretrial proceedings. Master
Docket assigned as 01-11300 (dj) (En-
tered: 07/16/2002)
* * * * *
Supplemental Memorandum by Shell Oil
Products in 1:01-ev-11300, Motiva En-
terprise[s] in 1:01-cv-11300 re: defen-
dants[’] motions to dismiss and for judg-
ment on the pleadings. filed es. (jdj) (En-
tered: 08/20/2002)
Supplemental Memorandum by Francis
Marcoux in 1:01-cv-11300 re: plaintiffs["]
opposition to defendants[’] motion to
12
DATE No.
PROCEEWVINGS
10/07/2002 95
10/29/2002 97
12/03/2002 107
dismiss and motion for judgment on
the pleadings filed. (dj) (Entered:
08/26/2002)
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Memorandum and
Order entered granting in part, denying
in part [78-1] motion to dismiss, granting
in part, denying in part [78- 2] motion []
for judgment on the pleadings. Accord-
ingly, the defendants’ motion to dismiss
and motion for judgment on the piead-
ings as to the plaintiffs[’) fraud and mis-
representation claim is [a]llowed. As to
all other claims, the motions are denied.
Entered ec/el [EOD Date 10/7/02] (lau)
(Entered: 10/07/2002)
** * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Clerk’s Notes: re:
scheduling conference held, Ten cases to
go forward first, automatic discovery
[by] plaintiffs to be complete by the end
of November; fact discovery to be com-
plete by mid-(F Jebruary|;] set pretrial
conference for 2:00 3/13/03 Court Re-
porter: (jdj) (Entered: 10/30/2002)
* * * * *
Motion by (Shell Dealers) Francis Mar-
coux et al. in 1:01-ev-11300 to amend
[1-1] complaint, filed es. (jdj) (Entered:
12/04/2002)
* * * K *
13
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
12/12/2002 111
01/10/2003
01/13/2003 119
01/13/2003 120
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Clerk’s Notes: re:
status conference held, Court is to pick
10 plaintiffs; decide motion to amend
complaint[s]; complete discovery re: 10
plaintiffs by 4/30/03; experts by 2/14/08
set pretrial conference for 2:00 5/28/03,
set expert discovery due for 5/23/03 (jdj)
(Entered: 12/16/2002)
* * * kK *
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Endorsed Order
entered granting [107-1] motion to
amend [1-1] complaint. ec/e] [EOD Date
1/13/03] Gdj) Modified on 01/13/2008
(Entered: 91/13/2003)
Judge Rya W. Zobel. Order: The court
selects the following plaintiffs for the
first trial: J&M Avramidis[] (dba Wal-
pole Shell)[;} Three Ks, Inc.; Cynthia
Karol (dba Pleasant St Shell)[;] Mac’s
Shell Service, Inc.; RAM Corp; Akmaf]],
Inc.; Stephen Pisa[{rJezyk; Sid Prashad
(dba Madison Shell)[;] Reading Shell &
Tire Center; John A. Sullivan. entered.
ec/el [EOD Date 1/13/03] (jdj) (Entered:
01/13/2003)
Second Amended complaint by Francis
Marcoux et al. in 1:01-ev-11300 filed.
(Answer due 1/23/03 for Motiva Enter-
prise[s], for Shell Oil Products). Amend-
ed complaint amends [4-1] amended
complaint. (jdj) Modified on 01/13/2003
14
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
04/16/2003 124
04/16/2003 125
04/16/2003 126
07/30/2003 149
07/30/2003 153
(Entered: 01/13/2003)
* * * * *
Answer by Motiva Enterprise[s] (as to
Mace’s Shell Service, Inc.) in 1:01-ev-
11300 to complaint; jury demand, filed
es. (jdj) Modified on 04/17/2003 (En-
tered: 04/16/2003)
Answer by Shell Oil Products (as to
Mac’s Shell Service, Inc.) in 1:01-ev-
11300 to complaint; jury demand, filed
cs. (jdj) Modified on 04/17/2003 (En-
tered: 04/16/2003)
Answer by Shell Oil Company (as to
Mac’s Shell Service, Inc.) in 1:01-ev-
11300 to complaint; jury demand, filed
es. (jdj) Modified on 04/17/2003 (En-
tered: 04/16/2003)
* * * * *
MOTION for Preliminary Injunction by
Abraham Abraham [et al.]. (Document
filed under Seal) (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 07/31/2003)
** * * *
SEALED DOCUMENT (Affidavit of
counsel in support of plaintiffs[{’] request
for injunctive relief) placed in secure
file room. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
08/01/2003)
~
15
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
07/30/2003
10/22/2003
154
AFFIDAVIT of Joseph Kelleher. (Jonn-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of Donald Gagnon. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of Jose Bento. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of John Generoso. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of Richard Baima. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of James Kantarowski.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of Cynthia Karol. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
AFFIDAVIT of George Fontaine.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/01/2003)
x* kK * Kk *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: Endorsed ORDER
entered denying 149 Motion for Prelimi-
nary Injunction, granting 152 (Sealed
Motion) plaintiff’s motion to compel to
the extent defendants have not already
responded to plaintiffs{’] interrogatories
and motion for sanctions is allowed in
the amount of plaintiffs’ attorneys’ fees
and costs for preparing the 2 discovery
motions; counsel shall file the requisite
affidavits, denying 166 Motion for De-
fault Judgment without prej[ud]ice. De-
fendant’s motion for sanctions is denied.
16
DATE No.
03/16/2004
03/16/2004
04/08/2004 209
05/03/2004
PROCEEDINGS
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 10/23/2003)
* * Ke K *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: Endorsed ORDER
entered denying 186 Motion for TRO.
Provided that defendant shall, at the
time of delivery of gasoline notify any
plaintiff whose inventory is increased by
more than 10% over the former cap as a
result of the use of the AIM program.
Defendant shall also, upon request of
any plaintiff, afford the plaintiff a period
of 30 days to pay for any such increase.
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 03/16/2004)
Judge Rya W. Zobel: Endorsed ORDER
entered denying 187 Motion to Amend
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 03/16/2004)
* * K *K *
MOTION for Relief From or Clarifica-
tion re Order on Motion for TRO, by
Motiva Enterprise, Shell Oil Company,
Shell Oil Products Company. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 04/09/2004)
* + & KH
Judge Rya W. Zobel: endorsed ORDER
entered granting 209 Motion for Clarifi-
cation. Defendant's request to eliminate
the notice and 30 day billing procedure
is allowed on defendant’s representation
that it will reinstate the delivery caps.
17
DATE No.
05/04/2004 216
05/04/2004 218
05/04/2004 219
06/14/2004 224
PROCEEDINGS
Defendant(s] agreed to lift them only for
limited periods during the winter and
emergencies and on prior notice to
the dealers. (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
05/05/2004)
MOTION for Summary Judgment as to
plaintiffs Three K’s, John A. Sullivan,
Reading Shell & Tire Center, Ram
Corp. and Stephen Pisarezyk based on
their release of claims by Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil
Products Company. (Urso, Lisa) (En-
tered: 05/07/2004)
* * * * *
MEMORANDUM in Support re 216
MOTION for Summary Judgment filed
by Motiva Enterprise|s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 05/07/2004)
* * * * *
AFFIDAVIT of Peter W. Benner re 216
MOTION for Summary Judgment by
Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 05/07/2004)
+ * * * *
Opposition re 216 MOTION for Sum-
mary Judgment filed by Abraham Abra-
ham [et al.]. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
18
06/15/2004
06/15/2004
06/15/2004
06/22/2004
07/09/2004
07/09/2004
225
226
227
229
241
242
06/15/2004)
MOTION for Summary Judgment by
Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 06/15/2004)
MEMORANDUM in Support re 225
MOTION for Summary Judgment filed
by Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 06/15/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Peter W. Benner re 225
MOTION for Summary Judgment.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 06/15/2004)
*** * *
REPLY to Response to Motion re 216
MOTION for Summary Judgment filed
by Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil Prod-
ucts Company. (Spaulding, Cathryn)
(Entered: 06/22/2004)
* * * Kk *
Response to defendants|[’] statement of
facts pursuant to LR 56.1 by Abraham
Abraham [et al.]. (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 07/13/2004)
Plaintiffs[’] Opposition re 225 SECOND
MOTION for Summary Judgment filed
by Abraham Abraham [et a!.]. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 07/13/2004)
* * * kK *
19
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
07/09/2004
07/09/2004
07/09/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
244
245
246
251
252
253
254
255
256
PLAINTIFFS|’] MEMORANDUM in
Opposition re 225 MOTION for Sum-
mary Judgment filed by Abraham Abra-
ham et al. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
07/13/2004)
AFFIDAVIT? of Allison K. Jones in Sup-
port re 242 Opposition to Defendants|’]
Motion for summary judgment. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 07/13/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Robert Weiner. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 07/13/2004)
* * * *€ *
Response to defendants[’] statement of
facts pursuant to local rule 56.1 by Fran-
cis Marcoux et al. (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Counsel in Support of
Plaintiffs[’] Opposition to Defendants[’]
Motion for Summary Judgment w/at-
tachments. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by StephfeJn Pisare[z]yk.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Stephen Shea. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by John Sullivan. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Richard Melanson.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
20)
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/10/2004
08/11/2004
08/12/2004
08/12/2004
08/12/2004
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
AFFIDAVIT by Abdul Kafa!. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Brian Gorin. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Fred Bucklin. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Jeffrey Bernard. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 08/10/2004)
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER on Appli-
cation for Sanctions entered. Fees in the
amount of $7,300 and costs in the
amount of $306.58. (Urso, Lisa) (En-
tered: 08/11/2004)
MOTION for Summary Judgment on all
claims by Motiva Enterprise|s], Shell Oil
Company, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/12/2004)
MEMORANDUM in Support re 262
MOTION for Summary Judgment filed
by Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 08/12/2004)
NOTICE of ADDENDA by Motiva En
terprise|s], Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil
Products Company re 262 MOTION for
Summary Judgment (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 08/12/2004)
= oe
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
09/14/2004 :
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
09/14/2004
267
269
270
271
272
275
276
Opposition re 262 THIRD MOTION for
Summary Judgment filed by Francis
Marcoux. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
09/14/2004)
* * * * *
Response to Defendants[’] Statement of
Facts Pursuant to LR 56.1 by Francis
Marcoux et al. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of John F. Farraher Jr. re
267 Opposition to Motion for summary
judgment. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT of Robert Weiner re 267
Opposition to Motion for summary
judgment. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT re 267 Opposition to Mo-
tion for summary judgment by Jordan
Avramidis. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
09/14/2004)
SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT by
Jordan Avramidis. (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Abdul Kafal. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Cynthia Karol. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Richard Melanson.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
22
DATE No.
09/14/2004 277
09/14/2004 278
09/14/2004 279
09/14/2004 280
09/14/2004 281
09/14/2004 282
09/14/2004 283
10/25/2004 293
10/28/2004 296
PROCEEDINGS
AFFIDAVIT by Francis Marcoux.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Akmal{l] Moawed.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Stephlejn Pisare[z]yk.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Sid Prashf{a]d. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by Stephen Shea. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
AFFIDAVIT by John Sullivan. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
MEMORANDUM in Opposition re 262
THIRD MOTION for Summary Judg-
ment filed by Francis Marcoux. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 09/14/2004)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: Memorandum of
Decision entered denying 216 Motion for
Summary Judgment, denying 225 Mo-
tion for Summary Judgment, granting
262 Motion for Summary Judgment as
to Three K’s and Stephen Pisarezyk.
Entered (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
10/26/2004)
* *+ KK *
EMERGENCY MOTION for Limited
Reconsideration of the entry of sum-
mary judgment against Plaintiff Ste-
23
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
10/28/2004 297
11/02/2004 3038
11/03/2004
11/12/2004
phen Pisarezyk by Francis Marcoux.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 10/29/2004)
EMERGENCY MOTION for Reconsid-
eration of Court{’)]s 10/25/04 Memoran-
dum and Decision w/respect to defen-
dants|’] Motions for Summary Judgment
by Motiva Enterprise|s], Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 10/29/2004)
** * * *
Opposition re 297 MOTION for Recon-
sideration filed by Shell Oil Company.
(Attachments: #1 Affidavit) (Spaulding,
Cathryn) (Entered: 11/02/2004)
[E]lectronie Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Initial Pretrial Conference held on
11/3/2004. Jury Trial reset for 11/15/2004
09:00 AM in Courtroom 12 before Judge
Rya W. Zobel. Pretrial Conference set
for 11/12/2004 09:00 AM before Judge
Rya W. Zobel. Parties are engaging in
mediation; (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
11/03/2004)
* * * ek
[kt Jlectronie Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel :
Final Pretrial Conference held on
11/12/2004. 9 jurors; (Court Reporter
Romanow.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
24
DATE No. PROCEEDINGS
11/15/2004)
x eK K
11/15/2004 Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Selection held on 11/15/2004. Jury
of nine selected and sworn. Plaintiff’s
opening, defendant’s opening. (Court
Reporter Romanow.) (Hurley, Virginia)
(Entered: 11/29/2004)
11/16/2004 Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial day two held on 11/16/2004;
plaintiff witness #1 Cindy Karol, cross,
redirect, recross; witness #2 John Sulli-
van (Court Reporter Romanow.) (Hur-
ley, Virginia) (Entered: 12/01/2004)
* * * KX *
11/17/2004 Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial day 3 held on 11/17/2004; con-
tinued of John Sullivan; witness #3 Ak-
mal Moawed; d[irJect; (Court Reporter
Shelley.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
12/01/2004)
11/18/2004 Flectronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Four held on 11/18/2004;
continued [c]ross of Akmal Moawed; re-
direct; re-cros[s]; video deposition of Mi-
chael Hanllely; video deposition of
25
DATE
No. PROCEEDINGS
Laura Styslinger; (Court Reporter Shel-
ley.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 12/01/2004)
11/19/2004 307 TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Three
held on November 17, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 11/19/2004)
11/19/2004 308 TRANSCRIPT of Jury Tria] Day Four
11/19/2004
held on November 18, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 11/19/2004)
Electronie Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day 5 held on 11/19/2004;
plaintiff witness #6 Greg McCombs; di-
rect; cross; re-direct; plaintiff witness
#7 Frances Marcoux; direct; cross;
(Court Reporter Shelley.) (Urso, Lisa)
(Entered: 12/01/2004)
11/22/2004 309 TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Five
11/22/2004
held on November 19, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 11/22/2004)
* * * K *
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Six held on 11/22/2004;
continued cross of Frances Marcoux
(#7); video deposition of Eugen[ Je John
Goll; witness #9 Richard Melanson; di-
rect; cross; (Court Reporter Shelley.)
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 12/01/2004)
26
DATE No.
11/23/2004
11/24/2004
PROCEEDINGS
*x* * * * *
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Seven held on
11/23/2004; continued cross of Melanson;
re-direct; re-cross; plaintiff’s witness
#10 Sid Prash[a]ld; direct; cross; re-
direct; witness #11 Jordanis Avramidis;
direct; cross; re-direct; re-cross; (Court
Reporter Shelley.) (Urso, Lisa) (En-
tered: 12/01/2004)
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Eight held on 11/24/2004;
plaintiff's expert Frank R. Zito; direct;
cross; expert Fred W. Bucklin; direct;
cross; expert witness Jeffrey Bernard;
direct; cross; (Court Reporter Shelley.)
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 12/01 /2004)
11/29/2004 310 TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Seven
11/29/2004 311
11/29/2004 314
held on November 23, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Debra M. Joyce.
*** (Entered: 11/29/2004)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Eight
held on November 24, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Debra M. Joyce.
* * * (Entered: 11/29/2004)
MOTION for special verdict by Plaintiff
Lessee-Dealers Francis Marcoux et al.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 11/30/2004)
DATE No.
27
PROCEEDINGS
11/29/2004 Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
11/30/2004 315
11/30/2004 316
11/30/2004 317
11/30/2004
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Nine held on 11/29/2004;
e[x]pert witness Bernard continued
cross; plaintiff witness #15 Stephen Pis-
arczyk; direct; cross; redirect; recross;
video deposition of Hanson; witness #17
direct; cross; (Court Reporter [ ]Shel-
ley.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 12/01/2004)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day One
held on November 15, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Richard H. Ro-
manow. * * * (Entered: 11/30/2004)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Two
held on November 16, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Richard H. Ro-
manow. * * * (Entered: 11/30/2004)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Nine
held on November 29, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M. Killi-
an. * * * (Entered: 11/30/2004)
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Ten held on 11/30/2004;
continued cross of Brian Gorin; re-
direct; re-cross; defendant witness #1
Professor Joseph P. Kalt; direct; cross;
(Court Reporter Shelley.) (Urso, Lisa)
(Entered: 12/01/2004)
*** * *
28
DATE No.
12/01/2004
12/02/2004 322
12/02/2004 323
12/02/2004
PROCEEDINGS
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day Eleven held on 12/1/2004;
con{tlinued cross of Prof. Kalt; re-direct;
re-cross; defendant witness #2 []Alyn
Hanson; direct; cross; witness #3
Robert Morris; direct; cross; re-direct;
re-cross; witness #4 Michael T. Hanley;
direct; (Court Reporter Shelley.) (Urso,
Lisa) (FE. ntered: 12/01/2004)
* * kK Kk *
MOTION for Judgment as a Matter of
Law by Motiva Enterprise{s], Shell Oil
Company, Shell Oil Products Company.
(Johnson, Jay) (Entered: 12/03/2004)
MEMORANDUM in Support re 322
MOTION for Judgment as a Matter
of Law filed by Motiva Enterprise[s],
Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil Products
Company. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
12/03/2004)
[E}lectronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial day 12 held on 12/2/2004. De-
fendant witness #4 Michael Hanley; di-
rect contin[{uled; cross; redirect; recross;
witness #5 direct; cross; redirect; re-
cross; witness #6 Lee Fry; direct; cross;
redirect; recross; witness #7 Timothy
Brooks; direct; cross; redirect; recross;
witness #8 Dennis Nielsen; direct;
29
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
12/03/2004 321
12/03/2004
12/03/2004 325
12/03/2004 326
12/03/2004 350
cross; witness #7 (expert) John Um-
beck; direct; (Court Reporter Shelley.)
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 12/06/2004)
* * * * *
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Six
held on November 22, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Valerie A.
O’Hara. * * * (Entered: 12/03/2004)
[E}lectronie Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Jury Trial Day 13 held on 12/3/2004.
[Djefendant witness #9 Umbeck; con-
tinued; cross; redirect; recross; witness
#10 Webster Collins; direct; cross; redi-
rect; re[ |jeross; witness #11 Howard
Gordon; direct; cross; redirect; recross;
witness #12 Steve Bradley; direct;
cross; redirect; recross; (Court Reporter
Shelley.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
12/06/2004)
Plaintiff Lessee-Dealers Proposed Jury
Instructions by Francis Marcoux et al.
(Johnson, Jay) Modified on 12/8/2004
(Johnson, Jay). (Entered: 12/07/2004)
AMENDED DOCUMENT by Francis
Marcoux et al. (Special Verdict). (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 12/07/2004)
MOTION for special verdict by Shell
Oil Products Company, Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company. (filed in
open court 12/3/04) (Johnson, Jay) (En-
30
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
12/03/2004
12/06/2004
12/06/2004
12/06/2004
12/07/2004
12/08/2004
351
324
329
332
333
335
tered: 02/16/2005)
MOTION for jury instructions by Shell
Oil Products Company, Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 02/16/2005)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day
Twelve held on December 2, 2004 before
Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Lee A.
Marzilli. * * * (Entered: 12/06/2004)
SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION for Spe-
cial Verdict by Motiva Enterprise[s],
Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil Products
Company. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
12/07/2004)
* * * * *
Proposed Supplemental and Amended
Jury instructions by Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company, Shell Oil
Products Company. (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 12/07/2004)
Trial Exhibit List by Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company, ‘shell Oil
Products Company. (Johnson, Jay) (En-
tered: 12/08/2004)
* * * * *
SPECIAL JURY VERDICT in favor of
plaintiffs against defendant. (Urso, Lisa)
Modified on 12/13/2004 (Johnson, Jay).
(Entered: 12/10/2004)
31
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
12/14/2004
01/07/2005
01/07/2005
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
336
341
343
337
338
339
340
342
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Fif-
teen held on December 8, 2004 before
Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 12/14/2004)
MOTION for Permanent Injunction by
Francis Marcoux et al. (Johnson, Jay)
(Entered: 01/11/2005)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Rulings
of Law on Count 3 by Francis Marcoux
et al. (Attachments: #1 part 2) (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 01/11/2005)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Elev-
en held on December 1, 2004 before
Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 01/10/2005)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Thir-
teen held on December 3, 2004 before
Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 01/10/2005)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Four-
teen held on December 7, 2004 before
Judge Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 01/10/2005)
EXCERPT TRANSCRIPT of Jury
Trial Day Fourteen (Jury Instructions)
held on December 7, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M.
Killian. * * * (Entered: 01/10/2005)
MOTION for an award of punitive dam-
ages arising from defendants[’) willful
disregard of the PMPA by Francis Mar-
32
No.
PROCEEDINGS
01/28/2005
02/07/2005
02/07/2005
02/07/2005
02/07/2005
345
346
347
349
coux et al. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
01/11/2005)
* + * * *
STIPULATION of Dismissal by
Stephen Shea and Reading Shell. (John-
son, Jay) (Entered: 02/01/2005)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Rulings
of Law by Shell Oil Products Company,
Motiva Enterprisels], Shell Oil Com-
pany. (Attachments: #1) (Johnson, Jay)
Additional attachment(s) added on
2/9/2005 (Johnson, Jay). Additional at-
tachment(s) added on 2/9/2005 (Johnson,
Jay). (Entered: 02/08/2005)
MEMORANDUM in Opposition re 341
MOTION for Permanent Injunction
filed by Shell Oil Products Company,
Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil Com-
pany. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
02/08/2005)
MEMORANDUM in Opposition re 342
MOTION [for] an award of punitive
damages arising from defendants[’] will-
ful disregard of the PMPA filed by Shell
Oil Products Company, Motiva Enter-
prise[s], Shell Oil Company. (Johnson,
Jay) (Entered: 02/08/2005)
Response by Shel! Oil Products Com-
pany, Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil
Company to 343 Proposed Findings of
Fact. (Attachments: #1) (Johnson, Jay)
33
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
02/28/2005 352
02/28/2005 353
03/04/2005 355
04/05/2005 361
(Entered: 02/08/2005)
* * * Ke *
MOTION for Judgment as a Matter of
Law, or in the alternative MOTION for
New Trial by Shell Oil Products Com-
pany, Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell Oil
Company. (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
03/02/2005)
MOTION for Leave to File Memoran-
dum in Excess of 20 pages by Shell Oil
Products Company, Motiva Enterpris-
e([s], Shell Oil Company. (Johnson, Jay)
(Entered: 03/02/2005)
* * * * *
REPLY to Response to Motion re 341
MOTION for Permanent Injunction
filed by Jordan Avramidis. (Urso, Lisa)
(Entered: 03/04/2005)
2 2 = =
(Assented to) MOTION for Leave to
File Brief in Excess of 20 Pages by Jor-
dan Avramidis | et al.]. (Attachments: #1
Memorandum in Opposition to Defen-
dants|’] Motion for Judgment as a Mat-
ter of Law or [iJn the Alternative for a
New Trial) (Johnson, Jay) (Entered:
04/06/2005)
2 =e Ss
34
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
04/28/2005 364
04/28/2005 365
09/19/2005 367
REPLY to Response to Motion re 352
MOTION for Judgment as a Matter of
Law MOTION for New Trial filed by
Shell Oil Products Company, Motiva En-
terprise[s], Shell Oil Company. (Attach-
ments: #1 Exhibit 1) (Sanson, Paul)
(Entered: 04/28/2005)
Assented to MOTION for Leave to File
Reply to Plaintiffs’ Opposition to De-
fendants’ Motion for Judgment as a
Matter of Law or, in the Alternative,
For a New Trial by Shell Oil Products
Company, Motiva Enterprise[s], Shell
Oil Company. (Sanson, Paul) (Entered:
04/28/2005)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered
denying 296 Motion for Reconsideration,
denving 297 Motion for Reconsideration,
denying 298 Motion in Limine, denying
299 Motion in Limine, denying 302 Mo-
tion in Limine, granting 314 Motion, de-
nying 322 Motion for Judgment as a
Matter of Law, granting 329 Motion, de-
nying 341 Motion for Permanent Injunc-
tion, denying 342 Motion, granting 350
Motion, granting in part and denying in
part 351 Motion, denying 352 Motion for
Judgment as a Matter of Law, denying
352 Motion for New Trial, granting 353
Motion for Leave to File, granting 361
Motion for Leave to File, granting 365
35
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
10/17/2005 369
10/18/2005 371
12/05/2005 377
Motion for Leave to File (Urso, Lisa)
(Entered: 09/19/2005)
* * * * *
NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 367 Order
on Motion for Reconsideration, Order on
Motion in Limine, Order on Motion for
Miscellaneous Relief, Order on Motion
for Judgment as a Matter of Law, Order
on Motion for Permanent Injunction,
Order on Motion for New Trial, Order
on Motion for Leave to File, by Shell Oil
Products Company, Motiva Enterpris-
e[s], Shell Oil Company. $255 * * * (En-
tered: 10/19/2005)
* * * kK *
NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 367 Order
on Motion for Reconsideration, Order on
Motion in Limine, Order on Motion for
Miscellaneous Relief, Order on Motion
for Judgment as a Matter of Law, Order
on Motion for Permanent Injunction,
Order on Motion for New Trial, Order
on Motion for Leave to File, by Mac’s
Shell Service, Inc., Jordan Avramidis,
Cynthia Karol, Steph[e]n Pisare[z}yk.
$255 * * * (Entered: 10/21/2005)
x* * * kK *
USCA Case Number 05-2770 for 371
Notice of Appeal, filed by Jordan Avra-
midis, Cynthia Karol, Steph[e]n Pis-
36
DATE
No.
PROCEEDINGS
12/07/2005
01/25/2006
02/07/2006
02/07/2006
02/07/2006
02/16/2006
378
383
384
385
387
are[zjyk, Mac’s Shell Service, Inc.,
(Ramos, Jeanette) (Entered: 12/05/2005)
USCA Case Number 05-2771 for 369
Notice of Appeal, filed by Shell Oil Com-
pany, Shell Oil Products Company, Mo-
tiva Enterprise{s]. (Ramos, Jeanette)
(Entered: 12/07/2005)
* * * * *
Joint MOTION for Entry of separate
Judgment under Rule 54(b). (Urso, Lisa)
(Entered: 01/25/2006)
TRANSCRIPT of Jury Trial Day Ten
held on November 30, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Shelly M. Killi-
an. * * * (Entered: 02/07/2006)
TRANSCRIPT of Charge Conference
held on December 6, 2004 before Judge
Zobel. Court Reporter: Sheliy M. Killi-
an. * * * (Entered: 02/07/2006)
TRANSCRIPT of Motion Hearing held
on May 5, 2005 before Judge Zobel.
Court Reporter: Shelly M. Killian. * * *
(Entered: 02/07/2006)
* * * * *
MOTION for Attorney Fees, /Haxpert
Witness Fees, And Costs Pursuant to 15
USC 2805(d)(1)(C) and Fed. R. Civ. P.
54(d) by Jordan Avramidis, Mac’s Shell
Service, Inc., Cynthia Karol, Richard
37
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
08/31/2006 397
10/26/2006 398
10/27/2006 399
Melanson, Akmaj(l}] Moawed, Stephl[eJ}n
Pisare|z]yk, Sid Prash{a]d, John Sulli-
van. (Attachments: ***) (Farraher,
John) (Entered: 02/16/2006)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered
granting 382 Motion for Entry of Judg-
ment under Rule 54(b). The parties shall
submit a joint proposed judgment that
incorporate[s] the court’s rulings. (Urso,
Lisa) (Entered: 09/01/2006)
NOTICE by Jordan Avramidis, Shell Oil
Products Company, Mac’s Shell Service,
Inc., Abdul Kafal, Motiva Enterprise[s],
Cynthia Karol, Richard Melanson, Ak-
ma(l] Moawed, Steph[eJn Pisare[z]yk,
Sid Prash[a]d, John Sullivan, Shell Oil
Company re 397 Order on Motion for
Entry of Judgment under Rule 54(b) re:
Filing of Revised Proposed Final Judg-
ment (Attachments: #1 Revised Pro-
posed Judgment and related Exhibit A)
(Sanson, Paul) (Entered: 10/26/2006)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered.
JUDGMENT entered. (Urso, Lisa)
Additional attachment(s) added = on
10/30/2006 (Urso, Lisa). Additional at-
tachment(s) added on 10/31/2006 (Urso,
Lisa). (Entered: 10/27/2006)
38
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
11/02/2006 401
11/10/2006 402
12/26/2006 406
01/09/2007 407
AMENDED DOCUMENT by Jordan
Avramidis, Mac’s Shell Service, Inc.,
Abdul Kafal, Cynthia Karol, Richard
Melanson, Akmal[l} Moawed, Steph[e]n
P.sare|zlyk, Sid Prash[aJd, John Sulli-
van. Amended Notice of Appeal. (F arra-
her, John) (Entered: 11/02/2006)
Subsequent NOTICE OF APPEAL by
Shell Oil Products Company, Motiva En-
terprise{s], Shell Oil Company: DE-
FENDANTS’ AMENDED NOTICE
OF APPEAL. Filing fee $455. Appeal
Record due by 11/30/2006. (Sanson,
Paul) (Entered: 11/10/2006)
* * kK * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered
allowing in part {87 Motion for Attorney
Fees. Status conference set for January
18, 2007, at 3:00 p.m. (Diblasi, Lily)
Modified on 12/27/2006 (Johnson, Jay).
(Entered: 12/26/2006)
* * * * *
SECOND AMENDED NOTICE OF
APPEAL by Jordan Avramidis, Mac’s
Shell Service, Inc., Abdul Kafal, Cynthia
Karol, Richard Melanson, Akma[]] Moa-
wed, Steph[e]n Pisare{z]yk, John Sulli-
van. (Farraher, John) Modified on
1/10/2007 (Johnson, Jay). (Entered:
01/09/2007)
39
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
01/16/2007 408
06/21/2007 411
04/21/2008 413
AMENDED NOTICE OF APPEAL by
Shell Oil Products Company, Motiva En-
terprise[s], Shell Oil Company. Amend-
ment to 369 Notice of Appeal, 402 Sub-
sequent Notice of Appeal: Defendants’
Second Amended Notice of Appeal.
(Sanson, Paul) Modified on 1/18/2007
(Johnson, Jay). (Entered: 01/16/2007)
* * * * *
MANDATE of USCA as to 371 Notice of
Appeal, filed by Mac’s Shell Service,
Inc., Cynthia Karol, Jordan Avramidis,
Steph[e]n Pisare[z]yk. Upon considera-
tion of the parties’ stipulation of dis-
missal, it is hereby ordered that this ap-
peal be voluntarily dismissed pursuant
to Fed. R. App. P. 42(b) with each party
to bear its own costs. This dismissal does
not affect No. 05-2771, which remains
open. Mandate issued in the USCA
6/21/2007 (Rame., Jeanette) (Entered:
06/21/2007)
* * * * *
USCA Judgment as to 402 Subsequent
Notice of Appeal filed by Shell Oil Prod-
ucts Company, Shell Oil Company, Mo-
tiva Enterprise(s], 369 Notice of Appeal,
filed by Shell Oil Products Company,
Shell Oil Company, Motiva Enterpris-
e{[s]. Upon considerati{o]n whereof, it is
now here ordered, adjudged and decreed
40
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
04/21/2008 414
06/09/2008 415
as follows: The judgment of the district
court on the state contract claims, the
unreasonable gasoline pricing claims,
and the constructive termination claims
is affirmed. The judgment on the con-
structive nonrenewal claims is reversed.
The jury award of attorney’s fees and
costs is vacated and remanded for re-
consideration in light of our mixed dis-
position of the claims under the Petro-
leum Marketing [Practices Act]. Costs
on appeal are awarded to the appellees.
Judgment issued in the USCA 4/18/2008
(Ramos, Jeanette) (Entered: 04/21/2008)
OPINION of USCA. Opinion issued in
the USCA 4/18/2008 (Attachments: #1
part 2) (Ramos, Jeanette) (Entered:
04/21/2008)
* * Ke K *
MANDATE of USCA as to 402 Subse-
quent Notice of Appeal filed by Shell Oil
Products Company, Shell Oil Company,
Motiva Enterprise{s], 369 Notice of Ap-
peal, filed by Shell Oil Products Com-
pany, Shell Oil Company, Motiva Enter-
prise. Mandate issued in the USCA
6/6/2008 (Ramos, Jeanette) (Entered:
06/09/2008)
* * * * *
41
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
06/20/2008 418
08/07/2008 425
10/27/2008
10/27/2008 468
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered.
(Jury Trial set for 11/17-11/21 @09:00
AM in Courtroom 12 before Judge Rya
W. Zobel; 12/8-12/12; 12/15-12/19; Pre-
trial Conference set for 11/5/2008 02:00
PM in Courtroom 12 before Judge Rya
W. Zobel.) (Urso, Lisa) (Entered:
06/20/2008)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered.
The discovery and trials will proceed on
the basis of the First Circuit ruling.
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 08/07/2008)
* * * * *
Electronic Clerk’s Notes for proceed-
ings held before Judge Rya W. Zobel:
Telephone Conference’ held on
10/27/2008. Case has settled; defendant
to file a proposed show cause hearing for
Abe Abrahams for 11/19/08 at 2:00 p.m.;
motion to be filed for Joe Kelleher to
dismiss; lst group not a party to the set-
tlement; sealed settlement; Court to get
back to counsel re: NH & RI cases; (At-
torneys present: Farraher & Sanson)
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 10/27/2008)
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered.
Accordingly, the court will notify the
Clerk of the Panel of the filing of the
parties[’] stipulation of dismissal and
42
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
11/13/2008 471
thereby resolve ‘the transfer | order.
(Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 10/27/2008)
* * * * *
STIPULATION of Dismissal (S77PU-
LATION OF PARTIAL DISMISSAL
IN C.A. No. 01-11300) by Chriss Azazi-
an, Richard Baima, Ed Baker, Steve
Black, Douglass Chapman, James Cog-
geshall, Michael Corbett, Patricia Da-
silva, Alex Dasilva, Francis Marcoux,
Steve Falcone, George Fontaine, Bill
Fontaine, Camille Francis, Steve Fran-
gias, Matty Gaeta, Donald Gagnon, John
Generoso, John Golden, Kal Hamze,
Shell Oil Product{ js Company, Abraham
Hamze, Tibor Hangyal, JES Service,
Inc., Patrick Hines, Adam Hipp, Mu-
hammad Imatiaz, Jay Jon, Kay Jon, Ab-
dul Kafal, Jaque Kanaan, George Kan-
targes, Motiva Enterprise[s], Jim Kan-
tarowski, William Kaufman, Hussein
Kobessi, Mike Lamarche, James Mo-
raidis, Sunny Patel, Ronnie Aboud, Con-
stantin Peides, Russell Picard, Paul
Richards, Harvy Rudnick, Fred Saad,
Aziz Saba, Walid Samrout, Earl Stick-
ney, Thomas Sullivan, Roger Thibault,
Dimitrious Tsanikilides, Toufiec Atallah,
Dror Dusdushman, Earl McLaughlin,
Stephen Shea, Wilson Tiburtino, J. En-
terprise, Inc., Mahendrs Amin, Lasco
Enterprise, Inc., Nikolas Manousaridis,
43
DATE No.
PROCEEDINGS
11/19/2008 476
Larry Rubensein, Paul Sroczynski, Shell
Oil Company, Massound Atalish, Mike
Atalish. (Sanson, Paul) (Entered:
11/13/2008)
* * * * *
Judge Rya W. Zobel: ORDER entered.
JUDGMENT entered dismissing Mr.
Abraham’s claims against Shell with
prejudice and without costs to either
party. (Urso, Lisa) (Entered: 11/19/2008)
* * * kK *
44
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT
Docket No. 05-2770
FRANCIS MARCOUX, ET AL.,
Plaintiffs,
MAC’S SHELL SERVICE, INC.; CYNTHIA KAROL; JOHN A.
SULLIVAN; AKMAL, INC.; SID PRASHAD; RAM
CORPORATION, INC.; J&M AVRAMIDIS, INC.;
THREE K’s, INC.; STEPHEN PISARCZYK,
Plaintiffs-Appellants,
V.
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY, LLC; MOTIVA
ENTERPRISES, LLC; SHELL OIL COMPANY,
Defendants-Appellees.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE PROCEEDINGS
11/30/2005 CIVIL CASE docketed. Opening forms sent.
Notice of Appeal filed by Appellants Cynthia
Karol, Sid Prash[a]d, John B. Sullivan, Mac’s
Shell, RAM Corp., J&M Avramidis, Inc.,
Akmal, Inec., Three K’s, Ine., Stephen Pis-
arc[zy|k. Appearance form due 12/14/05.
Docketing Statement due 12/14/05. Tran-
script Report/Order due 12/14/05. [05-2770]
(JC)
45
DATE PROCEEDINGS
* * * * *
06/21/2007 JUDGMENT entered: Upon consideration of
the parties’ stipulation of dismissal, it is
hereby ordered that this appeal be voluntar-
ily dismissed pursuant to Fed. R. App. P.
42(b) with each party to bear its own costs.
This dismissal does not affect Appeal No. 05-
2771, which remains open. Mandate to issue
forthwith. [1259530- 1) (05-2770) (JC)
06/21/2007 MANDATE ISSUED. [05-2770] (JC)
46
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT
Docket No. 05-2771
FRANCIS MARCOUX, ET AL.,
Plaintiffs,
CYNTHIA KAROL; SID P|RAJSHAD; JOHN A. SULLIVAN;
MAC’S SHELL SERVICE, INC.; RAM CORPORATION, INC.;
J&M AVRAMIDIS, INC.; AKMAL, INC.; THREE K’S, INC.;
STEPHEN PISARCZYK,
Pluintiffs-A ppellees,
V.
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY, LLC; MOTIVA
ENTERPRISES, LLC; SHELL OIL COMPANY,
Defendants-Appellants.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE PROCEEDINGS
12/02/2005 CIVIL CASE docketed. Opening forms sent.
Notice of Appeal filed by Appellants Shell Oil
Products, Motiva Enterprises and Shell Oil
Company. Appearance form due 12/16/05.
Docketing Statement due 12/16/05. Tran-
script Report/Order due 12/16/05. [05-2771]
(JC)
12/02/2005 RECORD filed: 1 volume consisting of docket
entries 369 and 371 (filed in 05-2770). No
transcripts filed. [1065048-1 ] [05-2771] (JC)
47
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
01/03/2006
02/09/2006
02/09/2006
12/01/2006
* * * * *
ORDER entered: The parties have filed
cross-appeals in Civil Action No. 01-11300 (D.
Mass). Pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 28.1, it is
hereby ordered that the above-named defen-
dants be deemed the appellants/cross-appel-
lees (?appellants?) and that the above-named
plaintiffs be deemed the appellees/cross-
appellants (Yappellees?). The parties are di-
rected to use the above caption on all future
filings related to these cases. A _ briefing
schedule will be set once the record on ap-
peal, including all necessary transcripts, 1s
complete and the stay is lifted. The attached
information sheet sets forth the filing re-
quirements for briefs filed pursuant to Fed.
R. App. P. 28.1. (05-2770, 05-2771] (JC)
ae ea ae
SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD consisting of
USDC transcript #’s: 383-385 filed. [1089331-
1] (05-2770, 05-2771] (MC)
Transcripts of #383: Jury Trial (day 190),
11/30/04; #384: Charge Conference, 12/6/04;
#385: Trial, 5/5/05 filed by court reporter
Shelly Killian in 05-2770 & 05-2771. (05-2770,
05-2771] (MC)
? =.= eS a
SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD consisting of
docket entries 399 and 402 filed. [1191380-1]
(05-2771, 05-2770] (JC)
48
DATE
12/06/2006
12/15/2006
12/15/2006
12/15/2006
12/15/2006
02/15/2007
Amended Notice of Appeal filed. Dist Ct #:
01-11300 Lead Dist Ct #: 01-11300 Entry
Date of Order/Judgment: 10/27/06 Date
Amended NOA Filed: 11/10/06 [05-2771] (JC)
SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD consisting of
docket entries 1, 4-10, 12-18, 20, 21, 23-27, 29,
30, 71-73, 76, 78-80, 82-89, 91-95, 97, 98, 106-
112, 114-199, 228, 251, 252-260, 315, 316, 317-
322, 329-335, 337-381, 387-392, 394-403
[1195816-1| Docket entries 152 and 164 filed
under seal. ***FILED WITH 05-2770***
{05-2770, 05-2771] (JC)
Transcript of November 22-24, 2004 jury trial
filed by court reporter Valerie O'Hara.
***F TILED IN 05-2770*** (05-2770, 05-2771]
(JC)
Transcript of May 5, 2005 motion hearing;
November 17, 18, 19, 29, 2004 December 1, 3,
7 and 8, 2004 jury trial filed by court reporter
Shelly Killian. ***FILED IN 05-2770*** [05-
2770, 05-2771] (JC)
Transcript of November 15, 16, 2004 trial
filed by court reporter Richard Romanow.
***FTLED IN 05-2770*** (05-2770, 05-2771]
(JC)
x* * * Kk *
SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD consisting of
docket entries 407 & 408 filed. [1215763-1]
[05-2770, 05-2771] (JC)
49
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
02/15/2007
02/15/2007
04/10/2007
04/10/2007
04/12/2007
06/01/2007
Amended Notice of Appeal filed. Dist Ct #:
01-11300 Lead Dist Ct #: 01-11300 Entry
Date of Order/Judgment: 12/8/04, 12/10/04,
9/19/05, 8/31/06, 10/27/06 and 12/26/06. Date
Amended NOA Filed: 1/16/07 [05-2771] (JC)
Amended Notice of Appeal filed. Dist Ct #:
01-11300 Lead Dist Ct #: 01-11300 Entry
Date of Order/Judgment: 12/8/04, 9/19/05,
8/31/06 and 10/27/06 Date Amended NOA
Filed: 11/10/06 [05-2771] (JC)
- a a ye
BRIEF filed by Appellants Shell Oil Prod-
ucts, Shell Oil Company and Motiva Enter-
prises. Length: 86 pages, 18,647 words, Cop-
ies: 9, delivered by hand. Certificate of ser-
vice date 4/9/07. [1235391-1] Appellee brief
due 5/9/07 [05-2770, 05-2771] (JC)
* * * * *
JOINT APPENDIX filed. Copies: 5. Vol-
umes: XI. Delivered by hand. Certificate of
service date 4/9/07 [1237526-1] [05-2770, 05-
2771) (JC)
SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD consisting of
trial exhibits filed. [1236595-1] [05-2770, 05-
2771] **Filed in the exhibit room** (JC)
* * * * *
PUBLIC NOTE: Motion for voluntary dis-
missal of cross-appeal filed in 05-2770. [05-
2771] (JC)
50
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
06/11/2007
06/21/2007
06/21/2007
07/06/2007
*+ * &* KK *
SUPPLEMENTAL APPENDIX filed by the
appellees. Copies: 5. Volumes: 1. Delivered by
mail. Certificate of service date 5/30/07
| 1255670-1 | [05- 2770, 05-2771] (JC)
* * kk *
BRIEF filed by Appellees Cynthia Karol,
Steph[e]n Pisare{[z]yk, Sid PrashlaJd, John
Sullivan, Mae’s Shell, RAM Corp., J&M
Avram Jidis, Inc., Akmal, Inc., Three K’s,
Ine. and Stephen Pisare|zy]k. Length: 18,972
words, 80 pages, Copies: 10, delivered by
mail. Certificate of service date 5/30/07.
(1259568-1] Reply brief due 7/9/07. Reply
brief deadline set from date appellees’ brief
was docketed. [05-2771] (JC)
* * * K* *
MOTION filed by Movant BP Products
North America Inc. for leave to file amicus
curiae brief and appendix in support of appel-
lants and to accept amicus curiae brief in-
stanter. Certificate of service dated 6/20/07,
by mail. [05-2771] (JC)
* * * * *
ORDER entered by Judge Kermit V. Lipez:
BP Products’ motion to file an amicus brief
and appendix is provisionally granted. Plain-
tiffs may respond to the amicus brief in a
supplemental appellee brief, not to exceed
51
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
07/06/2007
07/06/2007
07/10/2007
07/20/2007
5000 words, to be filed within two weeks of
the date of this order. In provisionally allow-
ing the amicus brief to be filed, we do not now
decide whether the amicus is impermissibly
presenting a new argument on appeal, but
rather leave that matter to the panel that will
eventually decide the appeal. [05-2771] (JC)
BRIEF filed by Amicus Curiae BP Products
in 05-2771 in support of Appellants. Length:
23 pages, 5,656 words, Copies: 10, delivered
by mail. Certificate of service date 6/20/07.
[1264315-1] [05-2771] (JC)
APPENDIX filed by Amicus Curiae BP
Products. Copies: 5. Volumes: 1. Delivered by
mail. Certificate of service date 6/20/07
[1264316-1] [05- 2771 ] IC)
REPLY BRIEF filed by Appellant(s} Shell
Oil Products in 05-2771, Motiva Enterprises
in 05-2771, Shell Oil Company in 05-2771.
Length: 40 pages (8,933 words), Copies: 10,
delivered by mail. Certificate of service date
7/9/07. [1265383-1] [05-2771] (RL)
i ae oe ee
OPPOSITION to BP Products North Amer-
ica, Ine’s Amicus brief filed by Appellees
Cynthia Karol, Steph{ejn Pisare{zlyk, Sid
Prash[a]Jd, John B. Sullivan, Mac’s Shell,
RAM Corp., J&M Avram Jidis, Ine., Akmal,
Inc., Three K’s, Inc. and Stephen Pisare|zy]k.
Certificate of service dated 7/20/07, by Fed-
eral Express. [1269388-1] [05-2771] (JC)
52
DATE
PROCEEDINGS
09/07/2007
09/07/2007
09/07/2007
09/07/2007
09/14/2007
* *&* & * *
SUPPLEMENTAL APPENDIX filed by
Appellants Shell Oil Products, Motiva Enter-
prises and Shell Oil Company. Copies: 5. Vol-
umes: 1. Delivered by mail. Certificate of ser-
vice date 7/9/07. Provisionally filed NOT un-
der seal per order of this date. [1285272-1]
[05-2771 j (JC)
REPLY BRIEF filed by Amicus Curiae BP
Products in 05-2771. Length: 6 pages, Copies:
10, Served by mail. Certificate of service date
§/9/07. [1285273-1} [05-2771] (JC)
MOTION filed by Appellees Cynthia Karol,
Steph[e]n Pisare[z]yk, Sid Prash[a]d, John B.
Sullivan, Mac’s Shell, RAM Corp., J&M Av-
ram| jidis, Inc., Akmal, Inc., Three K’s, Ine.
and Stephen Pisare[zy]k to file sur-reply
brief. Certificate of service dated 9/7/07, by
Federal Express. [05-2771] (JC)
PLEADING TENDERED: Sur-reply brief,
filed by John F.. Farraher for plaintiff-appel-
lees. [1285524-1] Certificate of service date
9/7/07 [05-2771] (JC)
CASE ARGUED 9/14/07. Torruella, How-
ard, Delgado-Colon, JJ. Paul D. Sanson for
Appellant Shell Oil Company, Appellant Mo-
tiva Enterprises, Appellant Shell Oil Prod-
ucts. John F. Farraher for Appellee Stephen
Pisare[zy]k, Appellee Three K’s, Inc., Appel-
lee Akmal, Inc., Appellee J&M Avram] Jidis,
Inc., Appellee RAM Corp., Appellee Mac’s
dd
DATE
04/18/2008
04/18/2008
04/25/2008
05/02/2008
Shell, Appellee John B. Sullivan, Appellee Sid
Prash{ajd, Appellee Stephfe]n Pisarc{z]yk,
Appellee Cynthia Karo] (KT)
2 ao oe
OPINION issued by Juan R. Torruella, Ap-
pellate Judge; Jeffrey R. Howard, Appellate
Judge and Aida M. Delgado-Colon, U.S. Dis-
trict Judge. Published. |05-2771] (MH)
JUDGMENT entered by Juan R. Torruella,
Appellate Judge; Jeffrey R. Howard, Appel-
late Judge and Aida M. Delgado-Colon, U.S.
District Judge. 05-2771 Affirmed/Reversed
[05-2771] (MH)
MOTION filed by Appellees Akmal, Inc.,
J&M Avran jidis, Inc., Cynthia Karol, Mac’s
Shell, Steph[eJn Pisare(z|yk, Stephen Pis-
are|zy]k, Sid Prash{aJd, RAM Corp., John B.
Sullivan and Three K’s, Inc. to clarify opinion
(published), [5240803-2]. Certificate of service
dated 04/25/2008. |05-2771} (AS)
“* * * *
PETITION filed by Appellants Motiva En-
terprises, Shell Oil Company and Shell Oil
Products Company for rehearing and rehear-
ing en bane. Certificate of service dated
05/02/2008 by FedEx. {05-2771} (AS)
* * * * *
54
PROCEEDINGS
05/23/2008
06/05/2008
06/06/2008
06/19/2008
ORDER entered by Michael Boudin, Chief
Appellate Judge; Juan R. Torruella, Appel-
late Judge; Sandra L. Lynch, Appellate
Judge; Kermit V. Lipez, Appellate Judge;
Jeffrey R. Howard, Appellate Judge and
Aida M. Delgado-Colon, U.S. District Judge
denying petition for rehearing and rehearing
en bance filed by Appellants Motiva Enter-
prises, Shell Oil Products Company and Shell
Oil Company. [05-2771] (AS)
ERRATA sheet to opinion (published) filed.
[05-2771] (SBT)
MANDATE Issued. [05-2771] (CP)
* * * * *
ORDER entered by Juan R. Torruella, Ap-
pellate Judge; Jeffrey KR. Howard, Appellate
Judge and Aida M. Delgado-Colon, U.S. Dis-
trict Judge of the District of Puerto Rico, sit-
ting by designation on motion to clarify order
filed by Appellees Stephfe]n Pisare[z|yk,
Akmal, Inc., Three K’s, Inc., Stephen Pis-
are|zy|k, Mac’s Shell, J&M Avram] lidis, Inc.,
Cynthia Karol, John B. Sullivan, Sid Pra-
shfald and RAM Corp. [05-2771] (AS)
a a
Haya)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FRANCIS MARCOUX, et al| |., )
) [FILED
Plaintiffs, ) JUL 27701]
VS. )
) C.A. No.:
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS 01-11300 RWZ
COMPANY, INC., and
)
)
MOTIVA ENTERPRISES, LLC, )
)
)
Defendants
COMPLAINT AND JURY DEMAND
INTRODUCTION
1. In response to the ruling in Civil Action number 00-
11295-RW2Z, the plaintiffs in the above-captioned matter
are the franchisees and members of the Shell Dealers
Legal Defense Group, which is the name of an unincorpo-
rated association of Shell gasoline station dealers that
was originally named as a plaintiff. The Court ruled that
the Shell Dealers Defense Group lacked standing. Thus,
this action is being filed in the name of the individual
franchisees, rather than that of the Shell Dealers De-
fense Group.
2. The filing of this action was necessitated by the ac-
tions of the defendants, including those of the Shell Oil
Company, and the entities formed as a result of its “Alli-
ance” with Texaco, Motiva Enterprises, LLC, Equiva
Services LLC, and Equiva Trading Co., LLC; which have
inflicted harm upon the Plaintiffs, including irreparable
harm such as harm to the dealer Plaintiff’s business
56
goodwill and reputations, and loss or threatened loss of
the businesses of the dealer Plaintiffs, the latter being
Shell branded franchised retailers throughout the Com-
monwealth. At a time when gasoline prices command na-
tional headlines, and Shell itself has stated that it is
“awash in a Niagara Falls of cash”; Shell retailers are
suffering from a decline in their business viability, as ap-
proved by management at the highest levels of the Defen-
dants. The Defendants had studies done known as the
“Mercer Studies”; which showed that no retailers in the
motor fuel industry were paying the rent levels that the
Defendants planned to implement, and that indeed, the
retailers would not survive such an implementation.
Nonetheless they have gone forward [] with the im-
plementation of what they call the “Strategic Marketing
Initiative”; which, among other things, is reported to con-
tain information on the displacement of iessee dealers by
commission operated and salary operated retail outlets
“CORO” and “SORO”).
On a more localized basis, the Defendants have created
entities; known as the Regional Planning Units, which in
turn developed key document packages known as the
“Regional Planning Strategies,” all of which were com-
bined into a national master plan known as the Strategic
Marketing Initiative. Shell has taken great pains to en-
sure that the “RPS” documents are not reviewed by any-
one, because of the damning content.
At its core, the goal of the Initiative is to seize the value
of the billions of dollars of investment, and the millions of
hours invested by the plaintiff independent dealers, by
raising the dealers|’} costs, primarily station rent, and
“wholesale” gasoline pricing, in order to insure the re-
placement of as many independent dealers as possible
with a network of stations directly operated and/or con
57
trolled by the Defendants, known as salary operated re-
tail outlets (SORO) or commission operated retail outlets
(CORO’s). Regrettably, the Defendants can engage in
this action, at very little cost to themselves, because the
Plaintiff Dealers are locked into the stations by reason of
their investment, and are contractually precluded from
obtaining the exact same gasoline from distributors, at
far lower prices. The Dealers must maintain their gaso-
line volumes by reason of minimum gallonage provisions
in their contracts, or face the risk of franchise termina-
tion. Moreover, the Dealers are obligated to pay the op-
pressive new rent, that Shell calls “Program Rent” until
such time that this Court declares this “DISENFRAN-
CHISEMENT PROGRAM RENT” illegal or unenforce-
able.
The only constraint upon the devious plot of the Defen-
dants is the legal and political opposition that can be
mounted by the independent dealers in defense of their
business; and the ability, or lack thereof, of the Defen-
dants to staff the newly taken over locations. Because
federal law, such as the Petroleum Marketing Practices
Act, 15 U.S.C. 2801 et seq., prohibits the Defendant fran-
chisors; Shell Oil Company and Motiva Enterprises,
LLC; (collectively referred to as “Shell” or “Defen-
dants”), as well as a number of state laws cited herein,
prohibits a direct takeover of the dealer locations, Shell
seeks to do indirectly, what it cannot do directly.
Shell’s wrongful conduct includes, but is not limited to
efforts to effectively evict the dealers from their fran-
chised locations, by forcing unreasonable and oppressive
franchise provisions upon the franchisees that would
make continued operation of the franchises uneconom-
ical, and would allow Shell, Motiva, and Equiva to take
over the locations for their own account.
58
In other cases, Shell has attempted to argue that because
they are offering renewal contracts to the dealers, they
are not seeking to disenfranchise them. This argument is
utterly meritless, and is truly disingenuous: Shell is of-
fering renewals only because the PMPA compels it to, 15
U.S.C. 2802(a); and its argument is analogous to an axe
murderer doing an autopsy on its victim, and proclaiming
natural causes as the cause of death.
As noted, the primary tool used by this unholy trinity
(Shell/Motiva/Equiva) is to increase the franchisees[’]
costs of doing business, while locking the franchisees into
non-negotiable minimum purchase arrangements, and
otherwise take unfair advantage of the fact that the deal-
ers are locked into these locations by reason of their in-
vestment of time and money into the stations.
There are 4 key pillars to the disenfranchisement
scheme: the Strategic Marketing Initiative; Regional
Planning Systems, the new wholesale pricing practices
reflected in the “MPSI Price Zones”; and application of
the “SPEARS” (street back pricing evaluation and re-
sponse system) in a manner to fix dealer margins at a
level where the rent and other Shell/Motiva/Equiva im-
posed costs cannot be recovered. The actions of the De-
fendants are even more indefensible in light of the fact
that the Shell Dealer Creed drafted by the defendants
specifically calls for fair treatment generally; and speci-
fically for a “fair allocation of profits between the retailer
and the companies.” The Defendants, through their new
policies, practices and procedures, have redefined the
term “fair” to mean, all for us, nothing for you. Indeed,
the new policies are designed to minimize or eliminate
dealer incomes.
Specifically, the Defendants{’] new policies include (but
are not limited to):
59
(a) using a contractor, MPSI of Tulsa, Oklahoma, to de-
velop new “price zones” or in “Shell speak” price PADS,
whereby the dealer locations targeted for conversion to
company or commission operation pay a higher price for
the same gasoline in the same purchase quantity than
other Shell branded locations;
(b) attempting to economically evict the dealers[ ] from
their franchised locations by terminating a rent program
that has been the cornerstone of Shell’s marketing pro-
gram in place in excess of 16 years, a program known as
the “Variable Rent Program”; which the dealers relied
upon, and reasonably relied upon at the urging of Shell
personnel extending to the highest level of the company.
In lieu of replacing the VRP with an equivalent or com-
parable program, something it pledged to do in the event
the VRP was ever terminated, Shell is in the process of
replacing the VRP or VRP substitute with a new oppres-
sive rent program, known as “Program Rent,” or charg-
ing full “Contract Rent” despite the fact that Shell openly
stated [and] knew the dealers could not survive at “Con-
tract Rent” levels.
Under this new rent structure, rents to the plaintiff deal-
ers are universally increasing and increasing drama-
tically, often in excess of two to four times the rent that
the dealers have been subject to since the establishment
of their franchises, and in many cases, in excess of the
annual profit of the business. It is this very rent program
that representatives of Shell have expressly and/or impli-
edly assured the dealers year after year would never
take affect, as Shell has been and remains aware that this
oppressive rent structure all but guarantees the failure of
all but a few select dealers.
Moreover in implementing the new rent plan, Shell wrote
to the dealers that it would base the rents upon indepen-
60
dent appraisals, performed by a Member of the Appraisal
Institute, using his or her best judgment. Instead of
honoring this commitment, Shell proceeded to issue limit-
ing instructions to the appraisers; and had them apply
upward adjustments to various elements of the appraisal,
resulting in a higher base value, which in turn was ad-
justed upward to ensure that the maximum rent could be
extracted from the dealers.
Next, Shell provided a challenge procedure, whereby the
dealer would pay for an appraisal under the limiting in-
structions, from a list of Shell approved appraisers, and
thus, purporting to deny the dealer access to appraisals
to be performed by other Members of the Appraisal In-
stitute; and again the appraiser would not be allowed to
simply apply the Uniform Standards of Professional Ap-
praisal Practice in accordance with his or her best profes-
sional judgment: instead Shell insisted that the rules be
slanted as it desired; also violating the law;
(c) imposing contract terms that shift costs of doing busi-
ness such as maintenance of Shell owned property to the
dealers; and that purport to illegally shift liability for ac-
tions such as increasing use of the controversial additive
MTBE in its gasoline to the dealers; in violation of clear
statutory prohibitions, or imposing minimum gallonage
provisions in spite of statutory prohibitions thereupon,
(d) forcing dealers to offer their franchises for sale or as-
signment at [| fire sale prices, and telling a prospective
franchisee that it can take only a worthless trial franchise
(15 U.S.C. 2803) which allows Shell to exercise a right of
first refusal clause in its contract. For example, plaintiff
Kauser paid $350,000 for the rights to his franchise in
1998; and was forced to sell out for $50,000, allowing
Shell to rid itself of the franchisee, and now company op-
erate the station.
61
(e) charging Dealers exorbitant fees for a worthless con-
venience store franchise known as “ETD” or Experience
the Difference; which is more aptly titled, “Emasculate
the Dealer”; despite being warned by its consultant, Ar-
thur Andersen, that the program would not produce
nearly the results being used to induce the dealers to in-
vest in the program, and actually pulling the core of the
program, a software program known as “FMS” out of its
company operated stations or the work as promised and
(f) other illegal actions as more fully set forth herein,
which include, but are not limited to, [] an undisclosed
rental charge in the gasoline price charged to the dealers
during the time the VRP program was in effect.
The federal franchise law, the Petroleum Marketing
Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. 2801, 2805, provides that the law
of each dealer[’Js home state governs the franchise
agreements, and there are a number of Massachusetts
state law claims in addition to the claims common to each
dealer (breach of contract; breach of covenant of good
faith and fair dealing, fraud, promissory and equitable
estoppel, Massachusetts General Laws 93A and 93E, and
U.C.C. provisions, including the 2-305 open price term
provision), that must be applied in this action.
In any event, the key operative fact[] is that this acticn
had to be brought because of Shell’s decision to canni-
balize the goodwill and business created by the Plaintiff
dealers, who prior to the creation of Motiva had made
Shell the #1 marketer of gasoline in the Country, and led
many of these dealers to listen to Shell and oppose fed-
eral and state legislation on the basis that “it would cause
Shell to cancel the VRP”; at the time that Shell was plot-
ting their demise.
4. Through oppressive new contract terms, and changes
to its marketing policies, practices and procedures, Shell
62
is inflicting ever higher costs of doing business, such as
increasing its wholesale price of gasoline, or dealer tank-
wagon price, both on an absolute scale and with respect
to its competitors, and otherwise seeking to collect addi-
tional rent and fees from the dealers, in an effort to im-
plement its dealer elimination scheme.
By virtue of this action, the Dealers seek relief from the
new rent scheme, or at a minimum, that Shell live up to
its promise to base the rent on the fair market value of
the station, used as a service station, and have the value
be arrived at by qualified Members of the Appraisal In-
stitute using their best independent judgment; as op-
posed to being hamstrung by limiting instructions from
Shell. In addition to relief from the oppressive franchise
terms and practices, Plaintiffs seek actual and punitive
damages. as well as statutory damages that may he al-
lowed under the law.
The Dealers also seek to stem other immediate and irrep-
arable harm in the form of a declaratory judgment ad-
judging the actions of Shell, and the offending provisions
of the new franchise agreements to violate [] state and
federal law.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
2. This complaint|] is filed, and proceedings instituted
pursuant to the following:
(a) The Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, 15
U.S.C. 2805, providing for jurisdiction in this
Court and venue in this court as well,
(b) The federal Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C.
1331,
(c) supplemental jurisdiction over the following Mas-
sachusetts law claims:
1. Fraud and Fraudulent Inducement
63
Promissory Estoppel
Equitable Estoppel
Breach of Contract
FP PP
Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith and
Fair Dealing
(B) Statutory Claims Applicable to All Plaintiffs
1. Breach of U.C.C. 2-103 (express covenant of good
faith and fair dealing)
Breach of U.C.C. 2-202 (Unconscionability)
3. Breach of U.C.C. 2-305 (breach of open price term
provision)
Massachusetts General Laws
Mass. Gen. Laws 93A: Unfair Trade Practices Act
93E: Gasoline Dealers Franchises
93: Massachusetts Antitrust Act
3. The Defendants are Delaware corporations, and the
amount in controversy exceeds jurisdictional thresh-
olds, therefore federal diversity jurisdiction is pre-
sent.
~~
4. The Plaintiffs are either Massachusetts corporations,
residents of the Commonwealth, or have their princi-
pal place of business in the Commonwealth, thus pro-
viding for jurisdiction and venue in this Court under
15 U.S.C. 2805, as weil as the general statutes.
PARTIE
5. The plaintiffs include the following Franchisees:
Plaintiff __|Station Address
Ronnie Aboud 384 Washington Street, Braintree, MA and
oo e heed | 1434 Washington Street, Hanover, MA
Abraham Abraham | 264 Timpeny Boulevard, Gardner, MA
Mahendrs Amin 181 Main Street, Hudson, MA
b4
Massoud Atalish
620 Belmont Street, Brockton, MA
Mike Atalish
1525 Smith Street, N. Providence, R.I.
Jordan Avramidis
920 Main Street, Walpole, MA
Chriss Azizian
10 HoJo Plaza, Dorchester, MA
Richard Baima
139 Medway Street, Milford, MA
Ed Baker 875 Highland Avenue, Needham, MA
Steve Black 372 Plymouth Avenue, Fall River, MA
Douglas Chapman | 1095 Massachusetts Avenue, Lexington, MA
James Coggeshall | 1612 Oak Street, Brockton, MA
Michael Corbett 1 Rutberford Avenue, Charlestown, MA
Patricia & Alex
Dasilva
129 Ashley Boulevard, New Bedford, MA
Steve Falcone
712 Southbridge Street, Auburn, MA
George Fontaine
890 S. Washington Street, N., Attleboro, MA
Bill Fontaine
461 E. Washington Street, N., Attleboro, MA
Camille Francis
138 Haverhill Street, Methuen, MA
Steve Frangias
249 Main Street, Stoneham, MA
Matty Gaeta 14 Newbury Street, Peabody, MA
Donald Gagnon 535 Lynnway, Lynn, MA
John Generoso 511 Totten Pond Road, Waltham, MA
Joe Golden 612 Oak Street, Brockton, MA
Ka] Hamze 111 North Street, Salem, MA and
987 Worchester Road, Wellesley, MA
Kal and Abraham
Hamze
1100 Lakeview, Dracut, MA
Tibor Hangyal 201 Magazine Street, Cambridge, MA |
Patrick Hines 1072 GAR Highway, Route 6, Somerset, MA
Adam Hipp 446 Station Avenue, S. Yarmouth, MA
Muhammad Imtiaz
189 Chelmsford Street, Chelmsford, MA and
431 Lincoln, MA
Jay & Kay Jon
520 Broadway, Revere, MA
Abdul Kafal
351 Bridge Street, Somerville, MA
Jacque Kanaan
George Kantaryes
27 Bridge St. Weymouth, MA
--- —_- 4
26 Ocean Street, Dedham, MA
Jim Kantarowski
2128 Ocean Street, Marshfield, MA
‘Cynthia Karol
182 Pleasant Street, Attleboro, MA
William Kaufman
65
281 Orchard Street, Watertown, MA
Joe Kelleher
—- +f
82 River Street, Dorchester, MA
Hussein Kobessi
280 Southbridge Street, Auburn, MA
Hussein Kobessi
747 Plantation Station, Worchester, MA
Mike Lamarche
436 Lancaster Street, Leominster, MA
Francis Marcoux
135 East Main Strect, Southbridge, MA
123 East Main Street, Webster, MA
Richard Melanson
904 Main Street, Southbridge, MA
Akmal Moawed 302 W. Broadway, South Boston, MA
James Moraidis 962 Main Street, Waltham, MA
Sunny Patel 155 Providence Boulevard, N..,
Chelmsford, MA
Constantin Peides
394 Providence Highway, Westborough, MA
Russell Picard 128 Turnpike Road, Westborough, MA
Stephan Pisareyk /|114 Boylston Street, W. Boylston, MA
Sid Prashed 45 Madison Street, Worcester, MA
Paul Richards 1420 Main Street, S. Weymouth, MA
Harvy Rudnick 491 Walpole Street, Norwood, MA “a
Fred Saad 127 Main Street, Milford, MA
Aziz Saba 54 S. Main, Bradford, MA
Walid Samrout 54 Chauncy St, Mansfield, MA
Ear! Stickney 26 Commercial Road, Leominster, MA |
Thomas Sullivan 211 East Boston Street, E. Boston, MA |
Roger Thibault 290 President Avenue, Fall River, MA {
Dimitrious 145 Spring Street, W. Roxbury, MA
Tsanikilides
Toufie Atallah 430 Taunton Avenue, Seekonk, MA
Dror Dusdushman
510 VF W Parkway, W. Roxbury, MA
Ear] McLaughlin
123-127 Union, Ashland, MA
Stephen Shea
122 Boston Street, Lynn, MA and 110 Main
Street, Reading, MA
John Sullivan
141 Front Street, Scituate, MA
Wilson Tiburtino
1363 S. Main & Broadway and 33 Mariano
Bishop, Fall River, MA
6. Defendant, Shell Oil Products Company, Inc., was
and is now, a corporation duly organized and existing
oJ
66
under the laws of the state of Delaware, with its prin-
cipal place of business at One Shell Plaza, Houston,
Texas 77067.
Defendant, Motiva Enterprises, LL, (“Motiva”) is a
Delaware Limited Liability Corporation with its prin-
cipal place of business at 12700 Northborough, Ste.
100, Houston, Texas 77067. It is a joint venture of
Shell Oil Products Company, Inc., Texaco, Inc., and
Saudi Aramco. These companies announced the for-
mation and operational start up of Motiva on August
1, 1998. It is a combining of major elements of these
companies, in Eastern and Gulf Coast United States
refining and marketing businesses.
ALLEGATIONS of FACT
For many years, Shell had the best relationship with
its dealers of any oil company, [and] was seen as [a]
‘dealer orientated company’. This situation changed
in the late 1990’s and Shell/Motiva’s conduct, such as
its insistence upon franchise terms that were out-
lawed over its opposition in 1994, has made Shell diffi-
cult, if not impossible to deal with.
Most prominently, since the announcement of a joint
venture with Texaco, resulting in the formation of the
defendant, Motiva and Equiva Enterprises, LLC, the
dealers| ] have become targeted for elimination, pur-
suant to a plan that, on information and belief is called
the “Strategic Marketing Initiative”.
The SMI is contained in a series of documents and
executive summaries that set{ |] forth the move to re-
place the dealers with company and commission op-
erated stations, constrained only by legal and political
opposition.
67
10. Indeed, the renewal contracts form a template for
dealer elimination by purporting to allow the follow-
ing:
(1) imposition of oppressive and unconscionable rent
increases on the dealers, that standing alone are
often enough to force the dealer to either leave the
location, allowing the company to change the loca-
tion to a “CORO” or contractor operated retail
outlet, or “SORO”, salary operated retail outlet.
The idea behind a “CORO” is to strip the retailers
of their protected status as franchisees under
state and federal law; while giving the company
control over the retail pricing at the station.
(2) attempting to illegally force assignees of dealer
franchise agreements to take nearly valueless “tri-
al franchises” as that term is defined in the Petro-
leum Marketing Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. 2801, as
opposed to the regular franchise mandated by 15
U.S.C. 2801(1)(B)(iii); and 15 U.S.C. 2806(a), ena-
bling Motiva to utilize its “first refusal right” to
match offers to dealers at depressed or fire sale
prices, or to remove anyone after one year if they
so desire.
(3) attempting to require, as a condition of renewal,
that the dealer release Shell from claims arising
out of prior franchise relationships; and
(4) attempting to define new reasons for franchise
termination in the franchise agreements, that are
contrary to the PMPA.
11. The company has become so brazen, that some re-
gional managers, including here in New England,
have openly told the dealers “that at least two-thirds
of them will be eliminated within two years.[”}
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
68
This institutional arrogance is also reflected in the of-
fending provisions of the contracts themselves, which
are contrary to 1994 Amendments to the PMPA,
Amendments that Shell and Texaco waged an unsuc-
cessful campaign of distortion against in the 103rd
Congress.
Under the 1994 Amendments, and 15 U.S.C. 2805, no
company, especially these the two major opponents of
the new provisions, may condition renewal of a fran-
chise relationship, upon the inclusion of franchise
provisions, that purport to waive any right the fran-
chisee may have.
The Shell contracts, which are attached hereto, and
incorporated herein by reference, contain provisions
which purport to release any claims the franchisee
may have under any previous agreement, See, Retail
Sales Agreement at paragraph 28, Retail Facility
Lease at paragraph 31.
The most effective of the dealer elimination tools is [ ]
to increase the costs of doing business to the dealer.
Shell has embark[ed] upon a new system of pricing at
SORO’s and CORO’s that [is] designed to facilitate
the dealer elimination and has engaged in other
wholesale pricing manipulation that violate[s] the pro-
visions of law, set forth, infra. The most obvious of
the deaier elimination tools is the rent, and the failure
to honor “The Pledge” that the Variable Rent pro-
gram or its equivalent would be in place.
The Variable Rent Program
Prior to the late 1990’s, Shell sold gasoline, gasoline
related products and other products and services such
as are commonly sold at retail gasoline stations (here-
after collectively, “gasoline products”) to the public
17.
18.
19.
20.
69
only through independent franchised retail dealers
such as the Plaintiffs. The principal product sold to
the public by such dealers was gasoline and diesel
fuel, but dealers also variously operated convenience
markets, car washes and repair services.
The dealers have conducted and still conduct their
retail operations under written franchise agreements
with Shell. Such agreements consist of multiple pre-
printed documents unilaterally prepared by Shell.
The agreements are contracts of adhesion whose es-
sential terms were not negotiable in any manner be-
fore execution. Pursuant to these contracts, Shell
provides the station premises, which the dealer leases
under a form ground lease entitled “Motor Fuel Sta-
tion Lease”, or in its most current version, a Retail
Motor Fuel facility lease.
Shell also provided a written form “Dealer Agree-
ment” as a part of the franchise package, which all
dealers are required to execute. The latest version of
the Document is called a Motor Fuel Supply Agree-
ment. Each dealer purchased and purchases “Shell”
branded petroleum products under this agreement
for resale to the public.
Before Shell permitted a prospective dealer to enter
into a franchise agreement, it required completion of
a pro forma profit and loss statement for the pro-
posed location. In New England, such prospective
dealer statements were prepared together by the
dealer and by Shell’s representatives. Shell reviewed
each such statement to satisfy itself as to the eco-
nomic viability of the franchise before entering into a
franchise agreement for that station. Such state-
ments always clearly showed that the dealer’s prem-
ises rent and cost of gasoline products, together, de-
21.
23.
24.
70
termined the profitability of the dealer’s business.
The dealers relied on these projections in under-
taking the franchise relationship; and Shell knew that
the dealers relied thereon.
As set forth, supra, Gasoline costs and station rents
are the largest components of the cost of doing busi-
ness for a retail gasoline dealer, including the co[s]ts
imposed upon the Plaintiff. Shell dealers buy gasoline
from their franchisor, Shell, which has always and by
contractual right unilaterally set the prices which the
dealers pay for gasoline products. The Shell dealers’
written motor fuel station leases include a stated rent
that is known as “Contract Rent”. That figure is and
was set pursuant to a secret formula that remains un-
known to the dealers to this day.
. The “Contract Rent” is a figure that through the
course of dealing has little meaning other than to
serve as the baseline for calculation of the actual rent
paid under the VRP. Dealers simply did not pay Con-
tract Rent, and Shell and its representatives encour-
aged the Dealers to ignore the Contract Rent figure.
The actual station rents would be charged under a
“variable rent program” by which Shell granted the
dealers a credit against each following month’s rent,
usually at the rate of 4.5 cents for each gallon of mo-
tor fuel which the dealer purchased from Shell over a
figure known as the “VRP Threshold”.
The VRP threshold was set by local Shell manage-
ment pursuant to a secret formula or guideline, which
was often zero. In this way, Shell tied the actual sta-
tion rents directly to the volume of gasoline being put
through the station. This variable rent program, or
VRP, resulted in dealers’ effective station rent being
far below the pre-printed “Contract Rent”; and in fact
25.
26.
27.
71
when reviewing contracts for renewal of the franchise
relationship, Shell personnel would go so far as to
chide the Dealers[] for even looking at the Contract
Rent figure.
The VRP was the foundation of the course of dealing
between Shell and the dealers[] for over 16 years.
Indeed, in a number of forums, such as other cases,
and legislative hearings, high level Shell personnel
with decision making authority have described the
“VRP” as the cornerstone of Shell’s marketing ef-
forts, the item that allowed Shell to rise to the top of
the U.S. gasoline volume charts and something that
its competitors did not have an answer for.
While Shell has recently attempted to characterize
the VRP as a voluntary program, every Shell dealer
participated in the program, it was memorialized in
various writings as well as through a 16 year course of
dealing from Portland, Maine to Portland, Oregon,
and in fact was not voluntary at all. Indeed, the VRP
was such a critical component of the Shell marketing
scheme, that Shell encouraged the dealers to oppose
federal and state legislative initiatives on the claim
that such legislation, if enacted, would require chang-
es to, or elimination of the VRP.
Shell’s written communications that contained the
“offers of variable rent program,” stated that Shell
could, at its option, discontinue or modify the pro-
gram on 30 days notice. Nevertheless, in addition to
the course of dealing between the parties, the dealers’
received numerous types of assurances that VRP or
its equivalent would be there for them, to ignore the
language of the VRP offer letters; and to ignore the
contract rent figure, as it was something that they
would not have to pay, as Shell knew that the Dealers
28.
29.
30.
72
could not survive, much less prosper, if the VRP was
terminated, and an equivalent substitute not put in its
place.
For over 16 years, the dealers received assurances
from the highest levels of the marketing department
on down to the field sales representatives, that the
VRP program would always be there for them, or that
in the alternative, [] a program that would be the
equivalent of VRP would be put in place as Shell was
very aware that dealers could not pay the “Contract
Rent” and survive.
These assurances were given to dealers through
Shell’s dealer panels, which were groups of dealers
that Shell had appointed both regionally and nation-
ally purportedly as representative of all dealers, as
well as through general meetings of dealers in the
geographic area and through individual communica-
tions by Shell representatives to current and prospec-
tive dealers. Shell kept the minutes of these meet-
ings, and provided written transcripts thereof to the
dealer representatives.
Other writings reinforce the point that the economic
and legal! reality was that the VRP was anything but a
voluntary, short-term program, and that Contract
Rent did not serve as anything other than a baseline
for VRP caleulation. For example, Shell also rou-
tinely provided to its dealers a document| | called the
“Delivery Platform Summary”, which indicated gaso-
line delivery volumes and changes in those delivery
volumes. These documents prominently featured | |
printed “variable rent calculations” which reflected
the VRP allowance and calculated the actual (as dis-
tinguished from the stated) rent.
dl.
32.
33.
73
Shell, through its duly authorized representatives,
encouraged and even demanded that the dealers take
actions based upon the “VRP Pledge”, and engaged in
a pattern of misrepresentation with respect to the
rent provision, and in reliance upon these represen-
tations, the Dealers made substantial investments in-
cluding, but not limited to:
(1) Purchasing the franchise rights at Shell branded
stations;
(2) purchasing the franchise rights of dealers that
Shell did not like, due to the active encouragement
of Shell management;
(3) investing in ancillary business located at the motor
fuel marketing premises such as convenience
stores, and car washes; and
(4) entering into renewals of the franchise relation-
ship with Shell based upon the misrepresentations
with respect to the contract rent, as opposed to
taking other action, such as selling the franchise.
In addition, the Dealers” generally adopted a market-
ing strategy based upon paying “VRP rent” as op-
posed to “Contract Rent”; that enabled them to sell
fuel to the public at prices lower than would be possi-
ble if “Contract Rent” was charged.
Again, all of these actions were taken in the context of
a lengthy course of dealing, and Shell representatives
telling the dealers to pay no attention to the Contract
Rent, or the “offers of variable rent program” to the
extent it stated that Shell could at its option discon-
tinue or modify the program on 30 days’ notice.
There were innumerable representations to the effect
that the “Contract Rent” was something the Dealers’
34,
35.
36.
37.
74
would never have to worry about, and never have to
pay.
By using the variable rent program to tie the station
rent directly to the volume of gasoline it delivered to
each station, Shell made the ground rent a part of the
price it charged the dealers for its gasoline products.
Since defendants obtain their revenues from the op-
eration of franchised independent retail Shell stations
primarily from a combination of station rents and
gasoline purchase prices, they have in practice and for
their own business purposes treated station rents and
gasoline sales revenues as interchangeable parts of
their revenue stream. The dealers’ profitability has in
turn been based on the interdependence of reasonable
rents and reasonable fuel prices. Among the claims of
the dealers herein is a claim that an undisclosed
rental charge was hidden in the price of gasoline.
At all times material hereto, defendants well knew
that if the VRP program terminated, the price for
gasoline products would become oppressively high
and unfair and that the dealers[’] profit would erode
to such a point so as to force the dealers out of busi-
ness.
By virtue of its status as a joint venture of Shell and
Texaco, Motiva and Equiva are charged with know-
ledge of all that Shell knew and of all commitments
Shell made to the dealers.
In entering into their franchise agreements and per-
forming there under, the plaintiffs and all Shell deal-
ers relied on the representations that the motor fuel
station rents stated in the station leases were pro
forma and would not be enforced, but that rents
would be calculated under the VRP program or its
equivalent. At no time until the events hereafter re-
38.
40.
75
lated did the dealers have any reason to suspect that
these representations about the manner in which
their actual rent was calculated were not truthful or
would not be kept, or that defendants had any inten-
tion not to perform those promises throughout the re-
lationship of the parties. The fact that defendants
had intimate knowledge of the dealers[’] financial
planning and of their actual financial results on a
monthly basis, which plans and results reflected the
critical role of the VRP rent program in maintaining
the dealers’ solvency, reinforced the dealers’ belief
that defendants would keep their promises about
maintaining viable station rents.
Equiva and Motiva assumed Shell’s responsibilities
for day-to-day operations with the dealers August 1,
1998.
. In and about July 1998, Equiva and Motiva informed
plaintiffs that it was terminating the Variable Rent
Program, effective shortly thereafter. Equiva and
Motiva then offered dealers in various regions dif-
fering “substitute” gasoline revate program which
varied from the VRP program in [J significant re-
spects.
Effective January 1, 2000, Motiva and Equiva aban-
doned the last of the substitute programs, and began
doing what it said it would never do, because it knew
the dealers[ ] could not survive: charge full “Contract
Rent” or the new “Program Rent” for those dealers
whose franchise relationships have come up for re-
newal. As set forth more fully, infra, these rents
were often several multiples of the rents which the
dealers had paid for many years under the prior VRP
program.
41.
42.
76
Defendants’ charging of the stated rents has made
the operations of the Plaintiffs’ locations, as well as
those of an overwhelming majority of franchised Shell
retail dealers’ businesses uneconomical. This pro-
gram has caused plaintiffs and other similarly situ-
ated dealers great losses, and some dealers are being
foreed into insolvency by it.
FAIR MARKET VALUE or PROGRAM RENT
In addition to charging the “Contract Rent” to those
dealers whol[se] franchises have not come up for re-
newal, the Defendants have moved ahead with Pro-
gram Rent, or what is more accurately termed “disen-
franchisement Program Rent”. While this rent is os-
tensibly based upon the fair market value of the loca-
tion, plus triple net expenses, the fact is that the re-
tailers are not given a disclosure of the evaluation,
and if challenged, the retailer is limited to choosing a
Shell designated appraiser, paying for an appraisal,
which the retailer is then not allowed to see! For ex-
ample, unless and until confronted with sanctions mo-
tions, one of which recently resulted in a default
judgment against an allied company, the Company
denies having access to basic records such as credit
card records and dealer files[ ]. The key point is that
Shell top level management implemented this pro-
gram fully knowing and intending that the dealers
would not survive it; as evidenced by the Mercer con-
sulting work, and consistent with the representations
made to the dealers that the VRP or a substitute
would always be in place, because Shell knew that the
dealers could not survive without it.
77
PRICING
I. Shell’s “Price Pads”
43. Shell sells its gasoline directly to its dealers, including
44.
the Plaintiffs, at “tank wagon” (“dealer tank wagon”
or “DTW”) prices established solely by Shell. Shell
manufactures the gasoline it sells to the Plaintiffs at
its refinery in various parts of the Country, and dis-
tributes its gasoline from facilities, known in the trade
as “the rack”, as delivery racks exist at this terminal
where Shell, its distributors, and unbranded market-
ers pick up gasoline refined by or otherwise obtained
by the defendants and certified by them to meet their
trademark specifications.
Shell delivers all Shell gasoline directly to each of the
Plaintiffs’ stations in delivery trucks, 7.e. tank wagons,
owned and operated by Shell, or in some cases, Shell
delivers gasoline to Plaintiffs via common carriers.
The Plaintiffs are charged Shell’s DTW price existing
at the time the fuel is loaded at the applicable rack.
Shell sells its gasoline to the Dealers, and the Dealers
purchase their Shell gasoline in the course of inter-
state commerce.
. The Plaintiffs do not, however, pay the same price for
the same gasoline. Shell, in conjunction with a con-
sulting firm known as MPSI, Inc., has recently
changed its pricing system, and has arbitrarily estab-
lished “price pads” or zones in the affected metropol-
itan areas. Contrary to economic reality, and course
of dealing in the industry, Shell places individual sta-
tions in their own price zone, thus station[s] could be
across the street from cach other, but have different
wholesale prices as Shell discriminates in its DTW
prices to the Dealers.
46.
47.
48.
78
Shell tank wagons are often “re-routed” when the
original dealer-purchaser is unable, for some reason,
to accept the fuel delivery. These “re-routed” tank
wagons then deliver the identical load of gasoline to
another dealer. Even though the gasoline is identical
and the sale occurs within hours of the aborted sale,
Shell often charges a different price for the gasoline
to the ultimate dealer-purchaser.
The enst of transportation incurred by Shell in de-
livering the Dealers’ gasoline does not justify these
price differences. For example, many plaintiffs pay a
DTW price for Shell gasoline delivered to their Sheil
stations than other Shell Dealers even though the
other Shell dealers may be located more than 30 miles
farther from Shell’s distribution facility or rack.
The Dealers are competitors with each other for the
retail sale of gasoline. Therefore, the differential in
DTW prices charged by Shell to these dealers creates
“favored” and “disfavored” classes of retail resellers
of gasoline. The favored sellers are able to, and have
in the past, dropped their retail (or “street’”) price of
gasoline to correspond with the tank wagon discount
afforded them by Shell. Such discounts in the street
price for Shell gasoline causes economic injury to
those competing with disfavored Shell Dealers, be-
cause the disfavored dealers must either reduce their
“margin” by also dropping their street price, or face
reduced sales of gasoline due to their higher street
price.
. On information and belief, Shell has designed the sys-
tem so as to eliminate key competitors that should by
any logic, be considered as competitors of the dealer
operated stations. In addition to manipulating the
MPSI system work in drawing the zones, Shell re-
50.
ol.
D3.
79
gional personne! have substantia! discretion in setting
a wholesale price pursuant to a program known as
SPEARS, or street back evaluation and response.
While the SPEARS program was ostensibly put in
place to help the dealers, the fact is that it is now used
as a method to limit dealer margins, and target the
locations most fervently desired for company opera-
tion.
In addition to discriminating between franchisees,
Shell also has a new program to benefit the CORO
and SORO locations, and to make the claim to share-
holders that these company operated locations are
more profitable to Shell. Specifically, the profitability
of these locations is judged by assuming no rent or
other real estate occupancy cost (despite the fact that
by operating the stations, Shell forgoes any rent); and
more importantly, it assumes that the lower wholesale
prices such as the jobber rack price, or the spot mar-
ket price is the price charged for accounting pur-
poses, not the much higher DTW or dealer tank-
wagon price.
. Finally, Shell also sells its gasoline to unbranded mar-
keters at prices 20 cents or more per gallon less than
the DTW its charges the dealers. Even given a 4 cent
per gallon brand value, and a maximum volume dis-
count, this evidence shows that Shell’s DTW is at
least 12-15 cents per gallon higher than can be justi-
fied.
Shell has recently offered temporary “discounts” to
[its] dealers of up to 2 cents per gallon, but is con-
ditioning receipt thereof upon the dealer lowering his
or her already squeezed margin even further; in a fu-
tile attempt to compete with the growing fleet of
80
CORO and SORO locations, which enjoy an artificial
and discriminatory price advantage.
OTHER ELEMENTS Of The PLAN
54. In addition to the cost-price squeeze outlined above,
Motiva and Equiva regional units were directed to set
aside funds in their capital improvement budgets to
“buy out” dealers, particular[ly] those who were likely
to be involved in Jeading “cells of dealer resistance” or
to otherwise survive the onslaught.
55. Two key provisions of the new contracts provide that
Shell has the right to match any offer the dealer has
for the business, and that any prospective assignee
will be given a worthless trial! franchise. These two
provisions, combined with the squeeze on the dealer’s
profitability[ ] (most offers are based upon 3 years
profits)[,] assure that Shell can reacquire the stations
at firesale prices, and move forward with the grand
plan to convert the network to company operation.
CAUSES OF ACTION
I; INJUNCTIVE RELIE ANT TO THE
PETROLEUM MARKETING TICES ACT
56. The plaintiff dealers repeat and incorporate by refer-
ence paragraphs 1-55 as if fully set forth herein.
57. The plaintiff dealers are franchised dealers of motor
fuel in a contractual relationship with Shell, a refiner
of motor fuel, as defined by the Petroleum Marketing
Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. § 2801, et seq.
58. By terminating the Variable Rent Program and
charging the plaintiff dealers the unconscionably high
rents of the Contract Rent and Program Rent struc-
tures, and by revising the pricing structure, and im-
posing a number of “offending” provisions in the new
59.
60.
61.
8]
contracts [s?c] terminated the plaintiff dealers’ fran-
chises.
Shell has made the changes to the franchise agree-
ments in bad faith, and for the purpose of converting
stations operated by the franchised dealers to CORO
and SORO operation, i.e. for Shell’s own account, in
violation of the PMPA. Pursuant to the standards set
forth by the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, 15
U.S.C. the individual dealers seek a preliminary and
permanent injunction preventing the imposition of ei-
ther full “Contract Rent” or the “Program Rent”.
The injunctive relief is requested on the grounds that:
the dealers’ franchises have been constructively ter-
minated by Shell’s termination of the Variable Rent
Program and failure to provide a similar alternative;
there exists sufficiently serious questions going to the
merits to make such questions a fair ground for litiga-
tion; and
the hardship suffered by Shell by reinstating a rent
program that it maintained for over 16 years would be
minimal compared to the egregious harm that will oc-
cur to the dealers, that being the end of their busi-
nesses and livelihood, if such preliminary injunction is
not granted.
: VIOLATION OF THE PETROLEUM MARKET-
ING PRACTICES ACT
The plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1-59 as if full{y] set forth herein.
The plaintiff dealers are franchised dealers of motor
fuel in a contractual relationship with Shell, a refiner
of motor fuel, as defined by the Petroleum Marketing
Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. § 2801, et seq.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
82
The Petroleum Marketing Practices Act strictly regu-
lates the requirements for a refiner of motor fuel,
such as Shell, to terminate the franchises of dealers of
motor fuel, such as the plaintiff dealers.
By terminating the Variable Rent Program and insti-
tuting the unconscionable rents under the Program
Rent structure, in the face of its express and implied
promises that it would not do so, Shell has and is ter-
minating the dealers’ franchises in violation of the Pe-
troleum Marketing Practices Act.
By terminating the Variable Rent Program and insti-
tuting the unconscionable rents under the Program
Rent structure, in the face of its express and implied
promises that it would not do so, Shell has and is at-
tempting to convert the dealers’ franchises into com-
mission operated retail outlets (“CORO”), or salary
operated locations (“SORO”), in violation of the
Petroleum Marketing Practices Act[,} 15 U.S.C.
§ 2802(b)(3)(A)(ii).
By including waiver and release clauses in its retail
lease and service agreements, Shell has and is violat-
ing the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, 15 U.S.C.
§ 2805.
In accordance with the provisions of the Federal De-
claratory Judgment Act, 28] U.S.C. § 1331, de-
claratory relief is requested that this Court enter a
judgment that the actions of the Defendants as above
described in this complaint have violated the provi-
sions of the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act.
In addition, Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, com-
pensatory and punitive, together with interest, costs,
and attorney’s fees, for all of the above violations and
83
the loss of value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer fran-
chises.
lil: VIOLATION OF THE MASSACHUSETTS
68.
69.
70.
71.
REGULATION OF BUSINESS PRACTICES
FOR CONSUMERS PROTECTION
The plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1-67 as if fully set forth herein.
The Defendants are in trade or commerce as defined
by Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 93A.
The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
would always be kept in place, in manipulating the
price zones, charging a transfer price to CORO and
SORO locations that is less than dealer tank wagon,
and failure to implement the “Fair Market Value
Rent” as promised constitute unfair and/or deceptive
acts, as prohibited by the terms of Chapter 93A.
Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, compensatory and
punitive, together with interest, costs, and attorney’s
fees, for all of the above violations and the loss of
value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer franchises.
VI: VIOLATION OF THE MASSACHUSETTS
72.
73.
74.
RE ATION OF DEALERS’ AGREEMENTS
FOR THE SALE OF GASOLINE
The Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference
paragraphs 1-71 as if full[y] set forth herein.
The Defendant, Shell/Motiva, is a supplier as defined
by Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 93E.
The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
75.
~
~)
84
would always be kept in place, constitute failures on
the part of Shell/Motiva to make requisite disclosures
pursuant to Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter
93E, Section 3, et seq.
The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
would always be kept in place, constitute failures on
the part of Shell/Motiva to make requisite disclosures __
pursuant to Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter
W3E, Section 3, et seq.
. The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
would always be kept in place, constitute unfair meth-
ods of competition and/or unfair and deceptive prac-
tices or acts as prohibited by Massachusetts General
Laws, Chapter 93E, Section 5, et seq.
. Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, compensatory and
punitive, together with interest, costs, and attorney’s
fees, for all of the above violations and the loss of
value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer franchises.
IX: BREACH OF CONTRACT
78.
79.
80.
The plaintiffl[s] repeat{ ] and incorporate[ | by refer-
ence paragraphs 1-77 as if full[y] set forth herein.
The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
would always be kept in place, constitute a breach of
contract, actual or implied, between Shell and the
dealers, that it would not do so.
Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, compensatory and
punitive, together with interest, costs, and attorney’s
85
fees, for all of the above violations and the loss of
value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer franchises.
X: FRA ISRE TATION
81. The plaintiffls] repeat|] and incorporate[ | by refer-
ence paragraphs 1-80 as if fullly] set forth herein.
82. The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly and intentionally misrepresenting to the
dealers that the Variable Rent Program or a similar
rent. program would always be kept in place, consti-
tute fraud, deceit and/or misrepresentation.
83. The dealers have relied on the misrepresentations of
Shell in being induced to enter into their franchise
agreements, to invest time and money into their fran-
chises and have been induced to enter into renewals
of their franchise agreements based on these misre-
presentations.
84. As a direct result of their reliance on Shell’s misre-
presentations, the dealers have and are suffering im-
mediate and irreparable harm, including, without lim-
itation, extreme pecuniary loss.
85. Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, compensatory and
punitive, together with interest, costs, and attorney’s
fees, for all of the above violations and the loss of
value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer franchises.
XI: PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL
86. The plaintiffls] repeat{ ] and incorporate[] by refer-
ence paragraphs 1-85 as if full[y] set forth herein.
87. In order to induce the plaintiff dealers to enter into or
renew their franchise agreements with Shell, the
company promised and agreed that the Variable Rent
Program or a similar alternative would always be
maintained by Shell.
88.
86
Pursuant to that promise, the plaintiff dealers made
substantial investment, pecuniary and otherwise, into
the establishment and growth of their respective
franchises. Wherefore equity requires that Shell be
stopped from now terminating the Variable Rent
Program or a similar alternative.
XII: BREACH OF IMPLIED COVENANT OF
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
GOOD FAITH AND DEALIN
The plaintifffs] repeat{] and incorporate| | by refer-
ence paragraphs 1-88 as if full[y] set forth herein.
At all times relevant, the franchise agreements be-
tween plaintiffs and defendants contained an implied
covenant of good faith and fair dealing that neither
party would do anything that would injure the right of
the other to receive the benefits of the franchise
agreements.
The acts of Shell/Motiva, including, without limitation,
expressly misrepresenting to the dealers that the
Variable Rent Program or a similar rent program
would always be kept in place, constitute a breach of
this implied covenant.
Plaintiffs seek monetary damages, compensatory and
punitive, together with interest, costs, and attorney’s
fees, for all of the above violations and the loss of
value with respect to Plaintiffs’ dealer franchises.
JURY DEMAND
Plaintiffs[ | claim trial by jury as to all causes of ac-
tion.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
Pursuant to the foregoing, the Plaintiffs pray that this
Honorable Court:
87
1. Issue an injunction requiring Shell to maintain the
Variable Rent Program, or an equivalent program,
and to enjoin the instituting of the Program Rent
structure, or charging the dealers “Contract Rent”.
2 Enter a declaratory judgment adjudging the Offend-
ing Provisions of the Shell contracts to be unlawful
under federal and state law.
3. Award damages, compensatory and punitive, includ-
ing costs, interest, and attorneys’ fees.
Award such other relief, as this Honorable Court deems
reasonable and appropriate.
Respectfully Submitted:
The Plaintiffs,
By their attorneys
Dated: /s/
ROBERT E. WEINER
[Service BBO#: 551980
Stamp: LAW OFFICES OF ROBERT E. WEINER
7/26/01) One Longfellow Place, Suite 3409
Boston, MA 02114
(617) 227-8383
&8
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
CIVIL ACTION NO. 01-11300-RWZ
FRANCIS MARCOUX, ET AL.,
Vv.
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS Co., INC.
AND MOTIVA ENTERPRISES, LLC
MEMORANDUM OF DECISION
October 7, 2002
ZOBEL, D.J.
On June 30, 2000, lessee-dealers of Shell brand auto-
mobile gasoline, acting through the Shell Dealers De-
fense Group (“Group”), and other individual franchisees,
filed an action against Shell Oi] Products Company and
Motiva Enterprises (“defendants”) for numerous causes
of action centered on the defendants’ termination of its
Variable Rent Program (“VRP”). See Demetrios Tsani-
klides, Jr., et al. v. Shell Oil Products Co., Inc. and Mo-
tiva Enterprises, LLC, Civil Action No. 00-11295. After
the Court determined that the Group did not have stand-
ing, the lessee-dealers sought to amend the complaint to
add themselves in their individual capacities. On June 12,
2001, the Court denied the motion, but stated that plain-
tiffs “may file a new case which may be deemed to be re-
lated.” On the same day, the Court ordered that the
cases involving the Rhode Island plaintiffs and New
89
Hampshire plaintiffs be transferred to their respective
states. The remaining parties subsequently stipulated to
a dismissal of the action without prejudice. The present
action seeking the same relief was then filed on July 27,
2001. Defendants have filed a Motion to Dismiss and a
Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings.
Defendants contend that Counts One and Two of
plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint concerning constructive
termination are barred by the one-year statute of limi-
tations under the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act, 15
U.S.C. § 2805 (“PMPA”). Defendants assert that the
statute of limitations began to run when Shell terminated
the VRP on August 1, 1998, while plaintiffs allege that it
began on January 1, 2000, when the VRP substitute was
eliminated. Count One of the Amended Complaint states
that plaintiffs seek injunctive relief on the grounds that
the “dealers’ franchises have been constructively termi-
nated by Shell’s termination of the Variable Rent Pro-
gram or a similar alternative....” (Paragraph 49, Sub-
paragraph 1.) Count Two incorporates the same state-
ment by reference. Paragraph 42 of the Amended Com-
plaint states that Shell/Motiva abandoned the last substi-
tution of the VRP on January 1, 2000 and began to
charge “Contract Rent” or the new “Program Rent.”
Viewing the facts as stated in the Amended Complaint
in a light most favorable to the plaintiffs, the statute of
limitations for the PMPA claims began to run on Janu-
ary 1, 2000. Plaintiffs then filed suit on June 30, 2000,
well within the one-year statute of limitations. Since the
present suit is deemed to relate back to the date of the
original complaint in accordance with the Court’s order
dated June 12, 2001, plaintiffs’ PMPA claims are not time
barred. In fact, none of plaintiffs’ claims, including the
state law claims, is barred by the PMPA’s statute of limi-
90)
tations. Similarly, plaintiffs’ claims under M.G.L. ch. 93E
are timely.
Defendants also contend that the Rhode Island plain-
tiffs (except for Paul Sroezynski and his corporation, J.
Enterprises) and the New Hampshire plaintiffs (except
for Charles Lagasse, Kach Corporation and Ali Jaber),
who did not file suit individually in the first action, are
time barred. However, both sets of plaintiffs were par-
ties to the first action as members of the Group. The
Court ordered that the cases involving those out-of-state
plaintiffs be transferred to their respective states pursu-
ant to 28 U.S.C. § 1406(a). Because those actions relate
back to the date of the first action, they, too, are timely.
Defendants’ motion to dismiss plaintiffs’ claim for
fraud and misrepresentation is allowed. “In the First
Circuit, Rule 9(b) requires a party pleading fraud to
specify the time, place, and content of the alleged false
representation.” Mead Corp. v. Stevens Cabinets, Inc.,
938 F. Supp. 87, 90 (D. Mass. 1996). Paragraph 31 of the
plaintiffs’ amended complaint states that “[flor over 18
years, the dealers received assurances from the highest
levels of the marketing department on down to the field
sales representatives, that the VRP would always be
there for them....” Plaintiffs have not specified either
the time or place of defendants’ misrepresentations re-
garding the VRP as required.
Finally, defendants’ assertion that allegations of con-
structive termination of the franchise are not covered by
the PMPA is simply wrong. See Riverdale Enterprises
Inc. v. Shell Oil Co., 41 F. Supp. 2d 56, 62 (D. Mass. 1999)
(stating that “[a]bsent a claim of per se unlawful termina-
tion, a PMPA franchisee must show that a constructive
termination has occurred.”).
91
Accordingly, the defendants’ Motion to Dismiss and
Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings as to the plain-
tiffs’ fraud and misrepresentation claim is allowed. As to
all other claims, the motions are denied.
[October 7, 2002 | /s/ Rya W. Zobel}
DATE RYA W. ZOBEL
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
92
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
MAC’S SHELL SERVICE, INC., ) [Filed 01/13/2003)
et al.,
Plaintiffs, C.A. No.
V 01-CV-11300-RWZ
SHELL OIL PRODUCTS
COMPANY, LLC (f/k/a SHELL
OIL PRODUCTS COMPANY),
SHELL OIL COMPANY, and
MOTIVA ENTERPRISES, LLC,
Defendants.
i i a a ee a a oe ae oe a
SECOND AMENDED PLAINT
AN RY DEMAND
I. INTRODUCTION
1. This civil action seeks to prevent irreparable and
irremediable harm to Plaintiffs, which includes, inter
alia, loss of Plaintiffs’ businesses and harm to Plaintiffs’
business goodwill and reputations. The Plaintiffs are
franchised dealers of Shell brand automobile gasoline.
The harm is occurring due to the wrongful conduct of the
Defendant franchisors, Shell Oil Products Company LLC
(f/k/a Shell Oil Products Company), Shell Oil Company
and Motiva Enterprises, LLC, whose wrongful conduct
includes such actions as forcing unreasonable and op-
pressive franchise provisions upon Plaintiffs that would
make continued operation of Plaintiffs’ franchises uneco-
93
nomical and would, in the regular course, allow Defen-
dants to take over Plaintiffs’ franchise locations for their
own account.
2. Defendants are attempting to economically evict
the dealers from their franchised locations by, among
other things, terminating their rent programs that have
been in piace for over 18 years (knows as the “Variable
Rent Program”) without replacing it as promised and
agreed to by Defendants with an equivalent or compara-
ble rent program. Defendants have replaced the Vari-
able Rent Program and a comparable Variable Rent Pro-
gram substitute with a new oppressive non-comparable
rent program, known as “Program Rent,” or are now
charging full rent described as “Contract Rent”, despite
an agreement between the parties that Contract Rent
would not be charged. That Defendants made this agree-
ment with Plaintiffs[] is not only evidenced by the oral
representations made by Defendants to Plaintiffs, but
also is established and evidenced by the long standing
course of dealing and course of conduct that has taken
place between Defendants and Plaintiffs[ ] since the Vari-
able Rent Program was instituted in 1982, over twenty
years ago.
3. Defendants fraudulently induced the Plaintiff fran-
chisees to sign the written franchise agreements by mis-
representing their intentions concerning the duration of
the Variable Rent Program. Defendants declared from
the outset of the partfies’] relationship that the Contract
Rent provisions were to be inoperative and represented
that it harbored no intention of invoking the Contract
Rent provision; thus, these oral representations then he-
came the basis of the binding agreement between the
parties.
94
4. The Contract Rent provision was not the result of
negotiations between the parties; rather, the provisions
were inserted unilaterally by Defendants. It was Plain-
tiffs’ acceptance of Defendants’ assurances on the issue of
the Variable Rent Program that constituted the parties’
agreement on this issue and not the contradictory written
provision in the franchise agreements which Plaintiffs
were induced to sign.
5. When the Plaintiffs signed the franchise docu-
ments, which included in [them] the Contract Rent provi-
sion, and at the same time Defendants repeatedly and ex-
pressly stated that the provision was a mere technicality
never to be effective, the parties did not adopt the fran-
chise agreement as their complete integrated agreement.
Rather, Plaintiffs only signed a document that contained
terms that were expressly limited by Defendants’ inde-
pendent oral agreement guaranteeing a Variable Rent
Program or its equivalent.
6. Where Defendants stood in a greatly disparate po-
sition with respect to Plaintiffs, Plaintiffs’ reliance upon
and acceptance of Defendants’ oral representations limit-
ing their written agreement were objectively reasonable,
and these oral agreements became integral parts of the
contracts between the parties.
7. Defendants have unilaterally changed the agreed
upon term despite the fact that Defendants openly stated
that they knew that the dealers could not survive eco-
nomically without the Variable Rent Program or a com-
parable rent program. Defendants’ actions in this regard
amount[ ] to an economic termination of the dealers’ fran-
chises in violation of the Petroleum Marketing Practices
Act, 15 U.S.C. § 2802 (““PMPA”).
8. Under the new rent structure imposed by the De-
fendants, rents to the Plaintiffs are increasing drama-
95
tically, three to four times more than the rent that Plain-
tiffs have been subject to since the establishment of their
franchises, in many cases, the new rent, be it Program
Rent or Contract Rent, is in excess of the annual profit of
Plaintiffs’ businesses. The Contract Rent provisions are
the very ones that Defendants’ representatives promised
and agreed would never take effect. Defendants remain
aware that Program Rent or charging full Contract Rent
all but guarantees the failure of all but a few of the Plain-
tiffs’ franchises and businesses and will significantly and
adversely reduce the value and profitability of those
franchises that are able to survive.
Il. PARTIES, JURISDICTION, AND VENUE
9. Plaintiff Abraham V. Abraham is a former Shell
franchisee with a former principal place of business at
264 Timpany Blvd., Gardner, Massachusetts.
10. Plaintiff J & M Avramidis, Inc. (d/b/a Walpole
Shell) is a Shell franchisee with a principal place of busi-
ness at 920 Main St., Walpole, Massachusetts.
11. Plaintiff Expressway Service Station, Inc. is a
Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 10
Hojo Plaza, Dorchester, Massachusetts.
12. Plaintiff Richard H. Baima (d/b/a Plaza Shell), is a
Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 139
Medway St., Milford, Massachusetts.
13. Plaintiff E.H. Baker, Inc., is a former Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 875 Highland
Ave., Needham, Massachusetts.
14. Plaintiff Olive Street Associates, Inc. (d/b/a Ply-
mouth Ave. Shell) is a Shell franchisee with a principal
place of business at 372 Plymouth Ave., Fall River, Mas-
sachusetts.
96
15. Plaintiff James Coggeshall (d/b/a Jim’s 139 Shell
and Jim’s Westgate) is a former Shell franchisee with
principal places of business at Mazzeo Drive (Rt. 139),
Randolph, Massachusetts and 612 Oak St., Brockton,
Massachusetts.
16. Plaintiff Michael Corbett (d/b/a City Square Shell)
is a Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 1
Rutherford Ave., Charlestown, Massachusetts.
17. Plaintiff Ashley Mini Mart, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chise with a principal place of business at 129 Ashley
Blvd., New Bedford, Massachusetts.
18. Plaintiff Auburn Plaza Shell, Inc. is a former Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 712
Southbridge St., Auburn, Massachusetts.
19. Plaintiff Tri-Fon Enterprises, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with principal places of business at 461 E. Wash-
ington St., N. Attleboro, Massachusetts and 890 S. Wash
ington St., N. Attleboro, Massachusetts.
20. Plaintiff Kamil & Son, Ine. is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 188 Haverhill St.,
Methuen, Massachusetts.
21. Plaintiff Gaeta Enterprises, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 14 Newbury
St., Peabody, Massachusetts.
22. Plaintiff Casey’s Lynnway Foodmart, Ine. is a
Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 535
Lynnway, Lynn, Massachusetts.
23. Plaintiff Totten Pond Shell, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 511 Totten
Pond Rd., Waltham, Massachusetts.
97
24. Plaintiff Hamze Lakeview Service, Inc. is a Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 1100
Lakeview, Dracut, Massachusetts.
25. Plaintiff Hamze Brothers, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 987 Worcester
Road, Wellesley, Massachusetts.
26. Plaintiff Hamze Brothers Autocare, Ine. is a Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 111 North
Street, Salem, Massachusetts.
27. Plaintiff Magazine Beach Service, Inc. is a Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 207 Maga-
zine St., Cambridge, Massachusetts.
28. Plaintiff Hipp Enterprises, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 446 Station
Ave., S. Yarmouth, Massachusetts.
29. Plaintiff Three K’s, Inc. is a Shell franchisee with a
principal place of business at 1220 Main St., Tewksbury,
Massachusetts.
30. Plaintiff Ange’s Service, Inc. is a former Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 27 Bridge
St., Dedham, Massachusetts.
31. Plaintiff JJK Enterprises Inc. (f/kK/a Dedham
Shell, Inc.) is a Shell franchisee with principal places of
business at 2126 Ocean St., Marshfield, Massachusetts
and formerly in Pembroke, Massachusetts.
32. Plaintiff Cynthia Karol (d/b/a Pleasant St. Shell) is
a Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at
182 Pleasant St., Attleboro, Massachusetts.
33. Plaintiff William Kaufman is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 281 Orchard St., Wa-
tertown, Massachusetts.
98
34. Plaintiff Kelleher Petroleum, Ine. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 82 River St.,
Dorchester, Massachusetts.
35. Plaintiff Kanes Shell FM, Inc. is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 380 Southbridge St.,
Auburn, Massachusetts.
36. Plaintiff Plantation St. Shell, Ine. is a Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 747 Plantation
St., Worcester, Massachusetts.
37. Plaintiff Mina Enterprises, Inc. (d/b/a Mike’s Su-
per Shell Service) is a Shell franchisee with a principal
place of business at 436 Lancester St., Leominster, Mas-
sachusetts.
38. Plaintiff Mac’s Shell Service, Inc. is a Shell fran-
chisee with principal places of business at 135 East Main
St., Southbridge, Massachusetts and 123 East Main St.,
Webster, Massachusetts.
39. Plaintiff RAM Corporation, Inc. is a former Shell
franchisee with a former principal place of business at
904 Main St., Southbridge, Massachusetts.
40. Plaintiff Akmal, Ine. is a Shell franchisee with a
principal place of business at 302 West Broadway, S. Bos-
ton, Massachusetts.
41. Plaintiff Constantinos Peides is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 394 Providence
Highway, Westwood, Massachusetts.
42. Plaintiff Stephen Pisarczyk is a former Shell fran-
chisee with a former principal place of business at 257 W.
Boylston St., W. Boylston, Massachusetts.
43. Plaintiff Sid Prashad (d/b/a Madison Shell) is a
Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 48
Madison St., Worcester, Massachusetts.
99
44. Plaintiff Windsor Tire Co., Inc. is a former Shell
franchisee with a principal place of business at 491 Wal-
pole St., Norwood, Massachusetts.
45. Plaintiff JES Service, Inc. is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 460 King St., Little-
ton, Massachusetts.
46. Plaintiff Reading Shell & Tire Center, Ine. is a
former Shell franchisee with a principal place of business
at 110 Main St., Reading, Massachusetts.
47. Plaintiff Terjac, Ine. is a former Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 122 Boston St., Lynn,
Massachusetts.
48. Plaintiff J. Enterprises, Inc. is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 2345 Gar Hwy,
Swansea, Massachusetts.
49. Plaintiff John A. Sullivan is a former Shell fran-
chisee with a principal place of business at 141 Front St.,
Scituate, Massachusetts.
50. Plaintiff Takis Shell, Inc. is a Shell franchisee
with a principal place of business at 145 Spring St., W.
Roxbury, Massachusetts.
51. Plaintiff Dedham Square Auto Service, Ine. is a
Shell franchisee with a principal place of business at 525
Providence Pike, Dedham, Massachusetts.
52. Defendant Shell Oil Products Company LLC (f/k/a
Shell Oil Products Company) is, upon information and
belief, a limited liability company duly organized and ex-
isting under the laws of the state of Delaware, with its
principal place of business of One Shell Plaza, Houston,
Texas 77067.
53. Defendant Shell Oil Company is, upon information
and belief, a corporation duly organized and existing un-
100
der the laws of the state of Delaware, with its principal
place of business at One Shell Plaza, Houston, Texas
77067. Upon information and belief, at all times relevant,
Shell Oil Products Company LLC (f/k/a Shell Oil Prod-
ucts Company) was an authorized agent and/or subsi-
diary of Shell Oil Company. Hereinafter, Shell Oil Com-
pany and Shell Oil Products Company LLC (f/k/a Shell
Oil Products Company) may be referred to collectively as
“Shell”.
54. Defendant Motiva Enterprises, LLC (“Motiva”) is,
upon information and belief, a Delaware Limited Lia-
bility Corporation with its principal place of business at
12700 Northborough, Ste. 100, Houston, Texas 77067.
Upon information and belief, Motiva was originally a
joint venture of Shell Oil Company Texaco, Inc., Star En-
terprises and Saudi Refining, Inc. These four companies’
transferred their marketing and refining assets east of
the Appalachians to Motiva in August 1998. Upon infor-
mation and belief, Texaco, Inc., and Star Enterprises
subsequently divested themselves of any interest in Mo-
tiva.
55. This Court has jurisdiction and venue over this
matter, as follows:
(a). This matter arises under The Petroleum Market-
ing Practices Act, 15 U.S.C. § 2805, providing for
general federal question jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C.
§ 1331. Venue is proper in this Court, being a ju-
dicial district in which the franchisees conduct (or
have conducted) business.
(b). The federal Declaratory Judgment Act, 28 U.S.C.
§ 2201.
(c). Supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367
over the following pendent and/or ancillary state
101
law claims: (i) claims under Massachusetts Gen-
eral Laws chapters 98E and 938A; and (ii) claims
pursuant to the Massachusetts contract and com-
mon law; and
(d). This Court has jurisdiction over the above-
referenced state law claims and provisions, in the
alternative, pursuant to the federal diversity stat-
ute, 28 U.S.C. § 1332. There is complete diversity
between all of the Plaintiffs and al] of the Defen-
dants in this matter[;] each of the Defendants are
Delaware companies with principal places of busi-
ness in Texas and not in Massachusetts. Plaintiffs
are each citizens of the Commonwealth of Massa-
chusetts and the amount in controversy exceeds
$75,000.00.
II]. ALLEGATIONS OF FACT
56. Since the announcement of the formation of Mo-
tiva, the Shell franchisee dealers have become targeted
for elimination, pursuant to a plan that, on information
and belief, is called the “Strategic Marketing Initiative.”
57. The Strategic Marketing Initiative, upon infor-
mation and belief, is contained in a series of documents
and executive summaries that set| ] forth the move to re-
place the franchisee dealers with company and com-
mission operated stations.
58. The renewal of franchise contracts, as the prior
contract term ends, target dealer elimination by:
(a). imposition of oppressive and unconscionable rent
increases on the dealers, that standing alone are
often enough to force the dealer to either leave
the locations, and/or allow the franchisor to
change the location to a contractor operated retail
outlet (“CORO”) or a salary operated retail outlet
102
(“SORO”). The idea behind a “CORO” or “SORO”
is to strip the retailers of their protected status as
franchisees under federal and state law while giv-
ing the company control over the retail pricing at
the station;
(b). attempting to illegally force assignees of dealer
franchise agreements tu take nearly valueless
“trial franchises” as that term is defined in the Pe-
troleum Marketing Practices Act, 15 U.S.C.
§ 2803, as opposed to the regular treatment of un-
expired portions of franchise agreements as set
forth in 15 U.S.C. § 2801(1)(B)(iii) and enabling
~hell/Motiva to utilize its contractual “first refusal
right” to match offers to dealers at depressed or
fire sale prices, or to remove anyone after one
year if they so desire.
(c). attempting to require, as a condition of renewal,
that the dealer release Shell from claims arising
out of prior franchise relationships, contrary to
the Petroleum Marketing Practices Act; and
(d). attempting to define new reasons for franchise
termination in the franchise agreements, that are
contrary to the Petroleum Marketing Practices
Act.
59. The Defendants’ regional manager has openly
stated to the dealers that many of them would be elimi-
nated within two years.
60. This harsh attitude is also reflected in the provi-
sions of the new franchise contracts themselves, which
offend the 1994 Amendments to the Petroleum Market-
ing Practices Act. Under the Petroleum Marketing Prac-
tices Act 15 U.S.C. § 2802(a)(2), Shell is prohibited from
failing to renew Plaintiffs[’] franchise agreements and
103
under the 1994 Amendments specifically, 15 U.S.C.
§ 2805(f), no company, including Shell/Motiva, may con-
dition renewal of the franchise by inserting new franchise
provisions that cause Plaintiffs to waive any rights that
Plaintiffs have under the Petroleum Marketing Practices
Act and otherwise under both Federal and State Law.
61. The Shell franchise agreements contain provisions
that purport to release any claims the franchisee may
have under any previous agreement.
62. Shell has embarked upon a new system of pricing
at CORO’s and SORO’s that is designed to facilitate deal-
er elimination and has engaged in other wholesale pricing
and manipulation that violate the provisions of law. The
most obvious of the dealer elimination tools is the rent,
and the failure of Shell to honor its agreement and com-
mitment to plaintiffs that the Variable Rent Program or
its equivalent would always be in place. Moreover, De-
fendants have engaged in a practice of giving [their]
CORO’s and SORO’s as well as other intermediary
wholesalers known as “jobbers” a substantial and pref-
erential discount on the wholesale price of Shell gasoline.
Upon information and belief, CORO’s, SORO’s and job-
bers purchase Shell gasoline from terminals in Massa-
chusetts at a “rack price” established by Defendants.
The rack price paid by CORO’s, SORO’s and jobbers is
substantially lower than the dealer tank wagon (“DTW”)
price charged by Defendants to Plaintiffs for the same
fuel purchased from the same terminal. Because of these
higher prices, Plaintiffs are forced to sell their gasoline to
consumers at prices that are substantially higher than
the retail prices changed by CORO’s, SORO’s and job-
bers. This has caused Plaintiffs’ volume of gasoline sales
(as well as profits) to decrease.
104
The Variable Rent Program
63. Prior to the late 1990’s, Shell sold gasoline, gaso-
line related products and other products and services
that are commonly sold at retail gasoline stations (here-
inafter collectively, “gasoline products”) to the public in
New England almost exclusively through independent
franchised retail dealers such as the Plaintiffs. The prin-
cipal product sold to the public by such dealers was gaso-
line and diese] fuel, but some dealers also operated con-
venience markets, car washes and repair services.
64. The dealers have conducted and still conduct their
retail operations under written franchise agreements
with Shell/Motiva. Such agreements consist of multiple
pre-printed documents unilaterally prepared by Shell/
Motiva.
65. The franchise agreements are contracts of adhe-
sion whose essential terms were not negotiable in any
manner before execution by the dealer franchisees. Pur-
suant to these contracts, Shell provides the station prem-
ises, which the dealer leases under a lease entitled “Mo-
tor Fuel Station Lease”, or in its most current version, a
“Retail Motor Fuel Facility” lease.
66. Shell/Motiva also provided a written form “Dealer
Agreement” as a part of the franchise package, which all
dealers are required to execute. The latest version of the
document is called a Motor Fuel Supply Agreement, un-
der which Plaintiffs purchase Shell branded petroleum
products for resale to the public.
67. Before Shell approved Plaintiffs as franchisees, it
required many of the prospective franchisee to complete
a pro forma profit and loss of statement for the proposed
location. In New England, such prospective dealer state-
ments were prepared together by the dealer and by
Shell’s representatives. Shell reviewed each such state-
105
ment to satisfy itself as to the economic viability of the
franchise before entering into a franchise agreement for
that station. Such treatments always clearly showed that
the dealer’s premises rent was calculated according to
Sheil’s Variable Rent Program and this determined the
profitability of the dealer’s business. The dealers relied
on these projections, which were part of their business
plans. These business plans so calculated were submit-
ted to financial institutions from whom Plaintiffs ob-
tained loans, and in some instances included the Small
Business Administration in undertaking the franchise
relationship; Shell knew of the reliance thereon.
68. Gasoline costs and station rents are the largest
components of the cost of doing business for a retail gaso-
line dealer, including the costs imposed upon the Plain-
tiffs. Shell dealers buy gasoline from their franchisor,
Shell/Motiva, which has always by contractual right uni-
laterally set the prices which the dealers pay for gasoline
products. The Shell dealers’ written leases include a
stated rent that is known as “Contract Rent.” That fig-
ure is and was set pursuant to a seeret formula that re-
mains unknown to the dealers to this day. Shell repre-
sentatives have expressly agreed and promised that this
Contract Rent would not be charged and Plaintiffs{ | have
reasonably relied upon same to their detriment. That
this contract rent would not be charged was also estab-
lished by the course of dealing and course of conduct that
took place between the parties.
69. The “Contract Rent” is a figure that through the
course of dealing has little meaning other than to serve
as the baseline for calculation of the actual rent to be paid
under the Variable Rent Program. Dealers simply did
not pay the Contract Rent, and Shell and its represen-
106
tatives encouraged each of the Plaintiffs to ignore the
Contract Rent figure.
70. The actual station rents would be charged under
the Variable Rent Program by which Shell granted to
dealers a credit against the following month’s rent, usu-
ally at the rate of 4.5 cents for each gallon of motor fuel
which the dealer purchased from Shell over a figure
known as the “VRP Threshold”.
71. The VRP Threshold was set by local Shell man-
agement pursuant to a secret formula or guideline, which
was often zero. In this way, Shell tied the actual station
rents directly to the volume of gasoline being put through
the station. This Variable Rent Program resulted in rent
being far below the pre-printed “Contract Rent;” and, in
fact, when reviewing contracts for renewal of the fran-
chise relationship, Shell dealer representatives would go
so far as to chide the Plaintiffs for even looking at the
Contract Rent figure.
72. The Variable Rent Program was the foundation of
the course of dealing between Shell and the dealers for
over 18 years. While Shell has recently attempted to
characterize the VRP as a voluntary program, every
Shell dealer participated in the program. It was memori-
alized in various writings as well as through a 18-year
course of dealing and, in fact, was not voluntary at all.
Indeed, the VRP was such a critical component of the
Shell marketing scheme that Shell previously encouraged
the dealers to oppose federal and state legislative initia-
tives on the claim that such legislation, if enacted, would
require changes to, or elimination of the VRP.
73. For over 18 years, the dealers received assurances
from the highest levels of the marketing department on
down to the field sales representatives, that the VRP
would always be there for them, or that in the alterna-
107
tive, a program that would be the equivalent of VRP
would be put in place as Shell was very aware that deal-
ers could not pay the “Contract Rent” and survive.
74. These assurances were also given by Sheil repre-
sentatives to Shell’s dealer panels, which were groups of
dealers that Shell had appointed, regionally and na-
tionally, purportedly to represent all dealers, as well as
through general meetings of dealers in the geographic
area and through individual communications by Shell re-
presentatives to current and prospective dealers[.] Shell
kept the minutes of these meetings, and provided written
transcripts thereof to the dealer representatives.
75. Other writings reinforce the point that the econo-
mic and legal reality was that the VRP was anything but
a voluntary short-term program and that Contract Rent
did not serve as anything other than a baseline for VRP
calculation. For example, Shell also routinely provided to
its dealers documents called the “Delivery Platform Sum-
mary,” which indicated gasoline delivery volumes and
changes in those delivery volumes. These documents
prominently featured printed “variable rent calculations”
which reflected the VRP allowance and calculated the ac-
tual (as distinguished from the contract) rent.
76. Shell, through its duly authorized representatives,
encouraged and even demanded that the dealers take ac-
tions based upon the “VRP assurances and commit-
ments”, and engaged in a pattern of misrepresentation
with respect to the rent provision. In detrimental reli-
ance upon these representations, the Dealers made sub-
stantial investments, including but not limited to:
(a). purchasing the franchise rights at Shell branded
stations;
108
(b). purchasing the franchise rights of dealers that
Shell did not like, due to the active encouragement
of Shell management;
(c). investing in ancillary business located at the mo-
tor fuel marketing premises such as convenience
stores, and car washes; and
(d). entering into renewals of the franchise relation-
ship with Shell based upon the misrepresentations
with respect to the contract rent, as opposed to
taking other actions, such as selling the franchise.
77. In addition, the Dealers adopted a marketing stra-
tegy based upon paying “VRP rent” as opposed to “Con-
tract Rent;” it enabled them to sell fuel to the public at
prices lower than would be possible if “Contract Rent”
was charged.
78. All of these actions were taken in the context of a
lengthy course of dealing and course of conduct, with
Shell representatives telling the dealers to pay no atten-
tion to the Contract Rent, or the written “offers of vari-
able rent program” to the extent it stated that Shell
could, at its option, discontinue or modify the program on
30 days notice. There were numerous assurances and
commitments that the VRP or its equivalent would be
there for them and that the “Contract Rent” was some-
thing the Dealers would never have to worry about, and
never have to pay as Shell knew that the Dealers could
not survive, much less prosper, if the VRP was termi-
nated, and an equivalent program not put in its place.
The fact that Defendants had intimate knowledge of the
dealers’ financial planning and of their actual financial
results on a monthly basis, which plans and results re-
flected the critical role of the VRP rent program in main-
taining the dealers’ solvency, reinforced the dealers’ be-
109
lief that Defendants would keep their promises about
maintaining viable station rents.
79. By using the VRP to tie the station rent directly to
the volume of gasoline it delivered to each station, Shell
effectively made rent a part of the price it charged the
dealers for its gasoline products. The Defendants obtain
their revenues from the operation of franchised indepen-
dent retail Shell stations, primarily from a combination of
station .ents and gasoline purchase prices and Shell has
treated station rents and gasoline sales revenues as in-
terchangeable parts of their revenue stream. The deal-
ers’ profitability has in turn been based on the interde-
pendence of reasonable rents and reasonable fuel prices.
80. At all times material hereto, defendants well knew
that if the VRP program terminated, the price for gaso-
line products would become oppressively high and unfair
and that the dealers[’) profit would erode to such a point
so as to force the dealers out of business.
81. By virtue of ils status as a joint venture of Shell,
Texaco, Star Enterprises and Saudi Refining, Inc., Mo-
tiva Enterprises, LLC is charged with knowledge of all
that Shell knew and of all commitments Shell made to
Plaintiffs.
82. Upon information and belief, Motiva assumed re-
sponsibility from Shell for the day-to-day operation of the
dealer network on August 1, 1998. Moreover, and upon
information and belief, Shell assigned to (and Motiva ac-
cepted) all of Shell’s rights, obligations and liabilities
arising under the franchise agreements.
83. Thereafter, Shell/Motiva informed Plaintiffs and
all Shell dealers in Massachusetts, New Hampshire and
Rhode Island that it was terminating the Variable Rent
Program, effective August 1, 1998. Shell/Motiva then of-
110
fered dealers a “substitute” gasoline rebate program
which, although similar to the VRP, was less advanta-
geous to the Plaintiff dealers.
84. Effective January 1, 2000, Shell/Motiva abandoned
the substitute gasoline rebate program, and began doing
what it said it would never do and charged full “Contract
Rent” or the new “Program Rent” for those dealers
whose franchise relationships have come up for renewal.
Both of these rent programs were economically oppres-
sive and were not made in good faith and in the normal
course of its franchise relationship with the plaintiffs.
85. The ne
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.