Respondents Brief — Alaska v. Southeast Alaska Alaska Conservation Council (No. 07-990)

Supreme Court brief2009

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

)

: .

Nos. 07-984, 07-990

aed

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

COEUR ALASKA, INC.,

Petitioner,

we

SOUTHEAST ALASKA CONSERVATION COUNCIL, ET AL.,

Respondents.

STATE OF ALASKA,

Petitioner,

Vv.

SOUTHEAST ALASKA CONSERVATION COUNCIL, ET AL.,

Respondents.

On Petitions For A Writ Of Certiorari

To The United States Court Of Appeals

For The Ninth Circuit

BRIEF FOR RESPONDENT GOLDBELT, INC.

IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS

DAVID C. CROSBY

Counsel of Record

5280 Thane Road

Juneau, AK 99801-7717

(907) 586-6262

Counsel for Respondent Goldbelt, Inc.

QUESTION PRESENTED

Respondent Goldbelt, Inc. supports and incorpo-

rates the questions presented in the petitions for a

writ of certiorari filed by Coeur Alaska, Inc. and the

State of Alaska.

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING

Respondent Goldbelt, Inc. adopts the statement

of the parties to the proceedings in the petitions filed

by Coeur Alaska, Inc. and the State of Alaska.

Pursuant to this Court’s Rule 29.6, undersigned

counsel state that Goldbelt, Inc., intervenor-

defendant-appellee below, is an Alaska Native urban

corporation created pursuant to Section 14(h)\(8) of

the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, 48 U.S.C.

§ 1613(h\(8). It is wholly owned by its Tlingit Indian

shareholders. It has no parent corporation, and no

publicly held corporation owns any of its shares.

ill

TABLE OF CONTENTS

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE

Seen seins Dyciactapeseiadanceiiiesl eaaeiieincinetsb iusmeshicasiisosaia 2

iv

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Page

Cases

City of Angoon v. Marsh,

448 F.2d 2415 (Gbia Cir. 19B4)........cccccerccsccssccccccecs 2

Koniag, Inc. v. Koncor Forest Res.,

39 F.3d 991 (Sth Cir. LOBA4)..............cccccsccscscscceees an

Statutes

a iniancdsmebnadastanenn |

RNIN rT I cn case aeitariinphilaninmiiameniletil 2

BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITIONS

Respondent Goldbelt, Inc. respectfully submits

this brief in support of the petitions for a writ of cer-

tiorari to review the judgment of the United States

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Goldbelt

adopts the Opinion Below, Jurisdiction, Statutory

Provisions Involved, and Statement of the Case sec-

tions of the petitions filed by Coeur Alaska, Inc. and

the State of Alaska.

Goldbelt is the permittee under United States

Army Corps of Engineers Permit POA-1997-245-N,

issued pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water

Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1344, to construct a marine terminal

for the single purpose of providing mine worker shut-

tle services to Coeur’s Kensington Gold Mine. Re-

spondents Southeast Alaska Conservation Council,

Sierra Club and Lynn Canal Conservation chal-

lenged Goldbelt’s permit in the same proceeding that

is the subject of the Petitions filed by Coeur and the

State of Alaska. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

vacated Goldbelt’s permit for the sole reason that its

stated purpose supposedly failed as a result of the

Court’s ruling vacating Coeur’s Section 404 permit

for disposal of tailings from the Kensington Mine.!

Alaska Pet. App. 3la—32a.

if this Court grants the Petitions and subse-

quently grants the relief requested by either Coeur

1 Goldbelt’s dock permit was not tied to any method of tail-

ings disposal. The Ninth Circuit arbitrarily assumed that

Coeur will abandon the project if it cannot use the challenged

method of tailings disposal.

2

or the State of Alaska on the merits, it should also

reverse the Ninth Circuit’s decision vacating Gold-

belt’s Section 404 permit.

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITIONS

In addition to the reasons given by Coeur and the

State of Alaska, this Court should grant the petitions

because the decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of

Appeals will deprive Goldbelt and its Tlingit Indian

shareholders of the economic benefits intended by

Congress when it enacted the Alaska Native Claims

Settlement Act (““ANCSA”), 43 U.S.C. § 1601 ef seg.,

and thus will deal a devastating blow to economically

disadvantaged Tlingit Indians throughout northern

southeast Alaska.

The Tlingit have lived in southeast Alaska from

time immemorial. Their aboriginal territory in-

cluded lands in and around Berners Bay, where the

Kensington Mine is located. C.A. J.S.E.R. 1084.2

When Congress enacted the landmark ANCSA in

1971, it granted Goldbelt, on behalf of its more than

3,000 Tlingit shareholders, the right to select 23,040

acres Of land in partial compensation for the lands

illegally taken from them by non-Native interlopers

and the United States Government. Jd. 1086. Con-

gress intended that these lands would be used for

economic development and betterment of Goldbclt’s

shareholders. Koniag, Inc. v. Koncor Forest Res., 39

F.3d 991, 996-97 (9th Cir. 1984) (Congress expected

and intended that Alaska Native Corporations woui!d

select their Settlement Act lands for economic devel-

opment purposes); City of Angoon v. Marsh, 749 F.2d

2 “CA. J.S.E.R.” refers to the Joint Supplemental Excerpts of

Record filed in the court of appeals.

3

1413, 1488 (9th Cir. 1984) (permitting Native Corpo-

ration to log ANCSA lands within Admiralty Island

National Monument) (“it is inconceivable that Con-

gress would have extinguished their aboriginal

claims and insured their economic well being by for-

bidding the only real economic use of the lands con-

veyed”).

But when the Secretary of the Interior withdrew

lands on Admiralty Island, the Sierra Club and oth-

ers sued to block Goldbelt’s selections. Unlike other

Native Corporations, which successfully asserted

their right to develop their lands within the National

Monument, Goldbelt attempted to accommodate the

environmental community by agreeing in 1979 to ex-

change its Admiralty Island selection rights for other

lands thought to be less environmentally sensitive,

including lands at Cascade Point on the southern

shore of Berners Bay. C.A. J.S.E.R. 1086. These

lands are on the Juneau road system and potentially

very valuable. The City and Borough of Juneau has

designated the lands around Cascade Point as a “new

growth area,” and Goldbelt has expended consider-

able time and effort in responsible land use planning

for the area. 7d. 1087. Unfortunately for Goldbelt,

however, every single attempt to put these lands to

productive use has been challenged and frustrated by

the same groups that forced Goldbelt to abandon its

selection rights on Admiralty Island. /d. As a result

of the inequitable actions of the Sierra Club, SEACC,

and Lynn Canal Conservation, the intent of Congress

has been frustrated, and Goldbelt’s lands on Berners

Bay have lain unproductive for the past quarter cen-

tury.

When Coeur announced its intent to reopen the

historic Kensington Mine on the north shore of Bern-

4

ers Bay — which is accessible only by air or water —

Goldbelt saw a perfect opportunity to develop its

lands at Cascade Point on the south shore of the Bay

as a marine terminal to provide mine worker shuttle

services to the Mine. Goldbelt’s proposal was treated

as a component of the overall Kensington Plan of

Operations, and was subjected to exhaustive envi-

ronmental studies — none of which has been chal-

lenged by the Sierra Club, SEACC, or Lynn Canal

Conservation.

The Army Corps of Engineers concluded that

Goldbelt’s dock proposal was the least environmen-

tally damaging, practicable alternative for transport-

ing workers to the mine site. C.A. J.S.E.R. 868.

When the Corps issued its Section 404 permit for a

marine terminal hmited to mine shuttle operations,

however, the Sierra Club, SEACC, and Lynn Canal

Conservation filed suit alleging that Goldbelt’s per-

mit was inextricably linked by purpose to Coeur’s

Section 404 permit for tailings disposal and could not

survive a successful companion challenge to Coeur’s

permit.

It would be difficult to overstate the importance

of the Kensington Gold Project to the Tlingit Indians

of the Juneau area. The Ninth Circuit’s decision to

vacate the Coeur and Goldbelt permits has done far

more than unfairly dash Goldbelt’s most recent at-

tempt to use its ANCSA lands. It has struck a crip-

pling blow to the economic aspirations of a genera-

tion of Tlingit Indians living in northern southeast

Alaska.

Southeast Alaska generally has been hard hit by

the decline of the timber and fishing industries. C.A.

J.S.E.R. 1081. In the Juneau area. the economic

downturn has been compounded by a contraction of

5

employment opportunities in the public sector. See

C.A. Br. of the City and Borough of Juneau, as

Amicus Curiae in Support of Defendants-Appellees

12. Economists estimate that the lack of decent pay-

ing jobs is resulting in a net out-migration of as

much as 4500 persons a year from Southeast Alaska,

especially in the 25- to 35-year-old range. See C.A.

Amicus Curiae Br. of Southeast Conf. in Support of

Defendants-Appellees 6 (the Southeast Conference

represents the interests of thirty Southeast Alaska

member communities, nine Alaska Native corpora-

tions, and numerous other private and public entities

in the region).

The economic nard times have crippled the rural,

largely Native, areas of Southeast Alaska where em-

ployment opportunities are virtually non-existent.

See C.A. Br. of Amicus Curiae Berners Bay Consor-

tium in Support of Appellees 4 (the Consortium is a

coalition of Native Corporations and Coeur Alaska.

Inc.). Although many of Goldbelt’s shareholders re-

side in the Juneau area, their unemployment rates

are two to three times higher than the rates for non-

Natives. Much of the employment that is available

to them is seasonal, low paying and without benefits.

C.A. J.S.E.R. 1078-79.

From the outset, Coeur has recognized that the

Kensington Mine lies at the heart of Tlingit tradi-

tional territory, and has taken truly extraordinary

efforts to insure that Native Alaskans are included

in the prosperity that the mine promises. These ef-

forts not only have been exemplary, they are un-

precedented. As one Tlingit leader put it:

No other company... has ever worked

so conscientiously as Coeur to involve

the Natives of Northern Southeast

6

Alaska in the planning of its activities,

or been so diligent in its efforts to en-

sure that Alaska Natives are included

in the economic benefits to be derived

from its operations.

C.A. J.S.E.R. 1080.

Before the Ninth Circuit effectively shut down

the Kensington Mine, Coeur had been training

Alaska Natives for high-paying, full-time jobs in the

mining industry. Roughly 25 percent of the con-

struction workforce at the Kensington Mine was

Alaska Native. Coeur had promised partnerships

with Native Corporations, including Goldbelt, to pro-

vide goods and services — such as the mine shuttle

service Goldbelt plans to operate from its Cascade

Point terminal. C.A. J.5.E.R. 1079-80.

The optimism generated by Coeur’s Native-

friendly operations has beem dashed by the Ninth

Circuit’s rulings. This Court should intervene — not

only to correct an erroneous reading of the Clean

Water Act — but to fulfill the quarter-century-old

promise of Congress that the lands it intended for

the economic benefit of the Tlingit Indians not be

locked up in perpetuity by endless litigation intended

to keep those lands in de facto wilderness status.

CONCLUSION

For these reasons and for the reasons set out in

the petitions of Cocur Alaska and State of Alaska,

the petitions for a writ of certiorari should be

granted.

7

Respectfully submitted.

DAVID C. CROSBY

Counsel of Record

5280 Thane Road

Juneau, AK 99801-7717

(907) 586-6262

Counsel for Respondent Goldbellt, Inc.

February 11, 2008

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.