Joint Appendix Vol II — SEC v. Edwards
Supreme Court brief2004
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
=
778 b ae
sone oo Ont
f /S | JUN 2 6 2003
Bud.
No. 02-1196
In the Supreme Court of the United States
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, PETITIONER
U.
CHARLES E. EDWARDS
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
JOINT APPENDIX
(VOLUME II)
THEODORE B. OLSON* MICHAEL K. WOLENSKY*
Solicitor General ETHAN H. COHEN
Department of Justice LAURA J. SAURIOL
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001 | KUTAK Rock LLP
(202) 514-2217 225 Peachtree Street, N.E.
Suite 2100
Atlanta, GA 30303-1731
(404) 222-4600
*Counsel of Record *Counsel of Record
for Petitioner for Respondents
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED: Feb. 13, 2003
CERTIORARI GRANTED: Apr. 21, 2003
‘> (
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Docket Entries:
United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh
Circuit
United States District Court for the Northern
District of Georgia
Complaint
Transcript of Preliminary Injunction Proceedings ...
Exhibits in support of SEC’s motion for pre-
limary relief:
Exhibit 1
Exhibit 6
Exhibit 7
Exhibit 15
Exhibit 16
Exhibit 17
Exhibit 18
Exhibit 20
Exhibit 21
Exhibit 22
Exhibit 23
Exhibit 24
Exhibit 2 to Edwards’ declaration
Declaration of Sheldon E. Friedman
Letter to Beverly Slater
149
[PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 20]
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND
EXCHANGE COMMISSION
File No. A-02502
IN THE MATTER OF ETS PAYPHONES, INC.
HEARING
TRANSCRIPT
APPEARANCES:
5 g
On behalf of the Securities and Exchange Com- g
BARRY LAKAS, Accountant
ROBET Loud, Attorney
JAMES LONG, Attorney
Enforcement Division
Securities and Exchange Commission
Suite 1006, 3475 Lenox Road
Atlanta, Georgia 30326
On behalf of the Witness
W. Scott SORRELS, Attorney
WILLIAM B. SHEARER, JR., Attorney
POWELL, GOLDSTEIN, FRAZER & MURPHY
191 Peachtree Street, N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30303
150
[3]
Whereupon,
CHARLES E. EDWARDS
appeared as a witness herein, and having been duly
sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
EXAMINATION
BY MR. LAKAS:
(7]
Q. Have you ever testified in an investigation by the
Commission or its staff or any other federal agency, any
state agency, any stock exchange or the NASD?
A. Only an informal investigation here at this office.
Q. When was that?
A. 1995.
Q. Was it an investigation at the time?
MR. SORRELS: I don't think that was testimony.
I think it was an interview that Larry Grant was
involved in.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Did he call you in or did you contact him for
information?
A. No, he called us in.
Q. What became of that?
A. There was no action per se. He did make two
recommendations to us which we fully complied with.
One was to get out—at that time, I was in both mar-
151
keting and leasing and he told me to either get out of
leasing or marketing and to give more control to our
phone owner, which we in fact did, where they can take
it back at any time.
Was there a court reporter at this?
A. No, sir, just my attorney and Mr. Grant.
And it was related to ETS Payphones?
A. Yes, sir.
[13] :
Q. Okay. So you started ETS in what year?
A. Six years ago this month. So that would be 1994.
Q. 1994?
A. Right.
Q. Now you said something about Inter-Met?
A. Inter-Net was a company I had—that I started
when I left Global. It sold—we were a switchless
reseller of long distance and prepaid calling cards.
That’s how ETS started. We were selling payphones
through that company also. When Mr. Grant investi-
gated us, Inter-Net was selling the payphones and ETS
was the payphone company side.
Q. I’m sorry, Inter-Net was marketing—selling the
payphones?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was ETS doing?
A. They were the payphone company.
152
-
Q. Oh, okay. They were actually supplying the pay-
phones?
A. Yes, and managing the payphones.
116]
Q. Okay. What's your financial—do you have more
than five percent stock ownership in any company right
now?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What would that be?
A. ETS. Twin Leaf, Inc.
MR. SORRELS: Just any company, Barry, or
public companies?
MR. LAKAS: Any company. Well this asks for
five percent stock ownership, but any financial par-
ticipation. I guess he means a private company. If it's
a corporation, he probably owned the stock anyway.
THE WITNESS: Right.
BY MR. LAKAS:
.So that's it, ETS and Twin Leaf, Inc.?
A. That I’m directly ownership in, yes. I now have an
LLC that I have ownership in called Pleasant Hills.
Anything else?
No, sir.
What does Twin Leaf, Inc. do?
It’s a holding company for a number of businesses.
And what type of businesses are they in?
S O Y
—
153
A. Mainly telecommunications and interior duet work
cleaning.
Q. Where is it located?
A. Twin Leaf?
1171
Q. Yeah.
A. At my address.
Home or business?
A. Business address.
Q. How many employees does it have?
A. I think we have about eight or nine.
Q. It’s a holding company in telecommunications and
does duct cleaning?
A. Yeah, one of the subsidiaries does, yes, sir.
Q. Now what type of telecommunications does it do?
A. It has a company called Legends Communications,
which is a full IXC carrier such as AT&T, MCI or
Sprint. It’s certified in 49 states for long distance and
prepaid calling cards, and is certified as a CLEC in
three states, also.
Q. Is it affiliated with ETS in any way?
A. Yes. It carries ETS’ zero plus—I mean one plus
traffic and prepaid calling card traffic.
Q. What about Pleasant Hills, where is that located?
A. In Duluth.
Q. The same address?
A. No, sir, it’s—lI don’t know the exact—well, I’ll
back up on that. It would be—the official address
: 154
would be the same as Twin Leaf. We have a building,
that’s what that is.
118]
Q. It’s in the same building as the Oakbrook
Parkway?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you have a separate
A. It's a separate building.
Q. A separate building, okay. Oh, I’m sorry, Twin
Leaf and Pleasant Hill are in the same building?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And what’s their address?
A. The one I looked in my pocket and gave you.
Q. I guess I’m a little lost. I thought you said ETS.
was at Oakbrook Parkway.
A. No, sir, no, sir. ETS is at 1490 West Fork Drive.
I’m not an ETS employee per se.
Q. Okay. So when I asked for your business
address—what’s Oakbrook Parkway?
A. That’s where Twin Leaf—and that’s the company
I work for, and that’s where my office is at.
Q. Okay. So what’s your position with ETS?
A. I am the CEO.
Q. Okay. But where is most of your time spent?
A. It's about 50/50 in ETS’ address, which is in Lithia
Springs, Georgia and the Oakbrook office.
Q. Okay. Now I've got you. What does Pleasant Hills
do?
155
A. It only owns the building.
[19]
Okay. But that’s the LLC?
Yes, sir.
Are you doing that for tax purposes?
For an investment.
PoP, Y
130]
Q. While I’m on that train of thought, why don't we
go into—I still want to know how you got into this. But
while we’re on this subject, ETS of today, how many
employees do you have?
A. ETS today, we have a little over 400 employees.
We operate out of 28 offices in the United States. We
have phones in 38 states. We have one in Canada and
we’re in the Virgin Islands.
(31)
Q. Can you describe the corporate structure now?
You say you have a department that locates phones?
A. We are the—either the second or third largest
payphone company in the United States today. We're
the largest independently owned. The other two in
there some place—the largest one is a public company
and there’s one pretty close to our size that’s a public
company. We have a—I’m the president and CEO of
the company. I have a chief operating officer, a—
Q. Whois the chief operating officer?
156
A. My son Jason Edwards. I have a CFO, Walter
Kadalka. I have legal counsel, John Wagner.
Q. He's in-house legal counsel?
A. Yes, sir. And they work mainly on location dis-
putes and acquisition contracts and all. I’m trying to
remember what else that reports direct to me. I have
the Leasing Department, which is Mary Spencer. That
would be the four departments that report direct to me.
Q. The Leasing Department?
A. They work direct with the phone owners and the
leasing and all. We've got, I think, 12 or 13 people that
work in that department.
32
Q. The locator group, how many people do you have
in there?
A. The locator is the marketing group, which would
be under operations. We have—I would say nationwide
probably 25-30.
Q. So their business is just—their role is to just go
out and find payphone locations?
A. Right. Well, I’ve got one portion of them that do
nothing but work with convenience store chains. I have
two gentlemen that do that that are employees, and one
subcontractor, because we have focused on convenience
stores because of all the changes that’s happened in our
industry. Then the other sales people, out of all the
different operations, their job is to find new locations
for our phones that are not profitable so we can put
them in a new location, hopefully to make them more
profitable. And we try to roll 10 percent of our phones
each year, the bottom 10 percent.
157
Q. Do these locator people report to your son who is
the chief operating officer?
A. Right.
Q. Okay, let’s go back. You say in 1994 and 1995 you
basically were just purchasing payphones. You say you
started going into I guess this—what do you call it, the
leasing program in 1996? ,
A. 1996. .
133
Q. How did all of that start?
A. Well, I had looked at ways to get into market
payphones. Back then, you could not go and knock on
the bank and borrow money to start a payphone
company because they wouldn’t loan any money on an
outside piece of equipment that’s hung outside. And so
we looked at this as a method where we could have
equipment that we could lease and build a payphone
company with the ultimate goal of owning all the
equipment ourselves.
Q. Whocame up with this concept?
A. I did.
Q. Did you hear about it from any other company
doing it?
A. I had an acquaintance in Tennessee that told me
about a company that had done it.
Q. A payphone company?
A. Idon’t know—they were a marketing company. I
don’t know whether they were a payphone company or
not. They were marketing payphones, but I don’t know
whether they were a payphone company themselves.
158
Q. They were marketing payphones. When you say
marketing, does that mean selling there?
A. Yes, sir, selling payphones.
Q. What was the name of that company?
A. I believe it was Amtel. I’m not for sure on that.
[34]
Q. Sogo into your concept. What was your concept?
You say you couldn’t get loans from the bank—in other
words, you wanted financing to purchase a lot of
payphones, is that correct?
A. I guess you could say it that way. I wanted pay-
phones is the ultimate goal I wanted because it was a
very profitable business at that time. Your coins was
very good, your long distance was extremely good.
This was before the days of the 1-800 dial-around and
all the other changes that’s happened. We looked at a
method to do that equipment and be able to sell the
equipment to individuals and then lease the equipment
from them on a lease payment.
Q. Did you try—did you approach any banks before
you—
A. I talked to a couple of banks, yes, sir.
Q. And they said no financing?
A. On the payphones, none. Now since that time
there has been a couple of banks that have loaned
money on payphones.
So what was your initial idea, just sell these pay-
phones to individuals?
159
A. Inter-Net sales people sold the
A. | payphones t
individuals, and ETS, if they chose to, 2 them from
them or they serviced them for them.
Q. So you came up with this conce
pt of leasing even
[35] before you sold the first payphone to any indivi.
duals or corporations or investors?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. In 1996, approximately how
‘ ma -
phones did—you say it was Inter-N et? *
A. Inter-
at that — had sold approximately 220 payphones
Q. That was in 94 and ‘95?
A. Correct.
8 g How about when you came up with this concept in
A. No, the concept, I came up with in 94.
Q. Oh, the leasing of the payphones?
A. Yes, but I didn’t reall ith i
. y take off with it—well
actually, we did our first lease in 1995, because —
six years—in 94, because we di i
— id our first lease in
136
Q. And then in 1995 when I had the i igati
investigation
with Mr. Grant, that’s when he said for me—you —
suggested we either get out of marketing or get out of
leasing. So we chose to get totally out of marketing.
That’s when we went to inde
pendent marketin
away from Inter-Net or ETS or anybody. *
160
Q. Okay. So ETS was actually selling payphones,
though?
A. No,sir.
Q. Well, I mean in ‘94 and ‘95 before you spoke with
Mr. Grant.
A. No, ETS has never sold a payphone. Inter-Net
sold [37] the payphones.
Q. Okay. Inter-Net sold the payphones.
A. And ETS leased the payphones.
Q. Okay. Well, let's go into—did you come up with
the concept of a person who purchases a payphone can
either manage the payphone itself, have limited
management or do the lease program? Did you come up
with that concept?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Okay. Inter-Net sells the payphones. Did they
basically just say that ETS was the sole entity that
would lease the payphones?
A. At that time we were the sole entity that would
lease the payphone. Now they could choose to put it up
themselves and manage it themselves if they wanted to.
Q. Of this initial 220 people, did they all go for this
leasing program? Did they all subscribe to the leasing
program?
A. I’m trying to remember when my first option—at
that time we only had two options, and that was the
option of buying a phone and putting it in yourself. I
think in the first two years we did have two people that
bought that way. But then—and the 220 would be the
ones that were leased phones.
161
Q. Okay. Now the marketing tools that you used,
what was told to the individuals or investors who
purchased a [38] payphone?
A. Now you're talking about which time frame?
Q. ‘94 and 95.
A. They were told about the industry. They were
given the option what to do with their payphone. If
they leased it, they got a $75 a month lease payment
that was for five years, and then at that time there was
an option to renew it for another five years.
Q. Were they told at that time that at the end of five
years they could get their money back for the purchase
of the payphone?
A. Yes, sir. They had the option to sell the payphone
back to us if they chose, or they could keep it them-
selves if they chose.
Q. At the end of five years?
A. Yeah—well they could get their phone any time
they wanted.
Q. They could also get their money back any time
they wanted?
A. Well when Mr.—after my interview with Mr.
Grant, that’s when we basically put in the fact that they
could request to sell us the phone at any time with no
penalty whatsoever. We had a 180-day window in
which to liquidate the payphone.
Q. And that would be for the full cost of what they
39] purchased the payphone for?
A. Correct.
Q. And what were they renting for in 1994 and ‘95?
162
A. They were at 4,500 and 5,000.
Q. And you said you were purchasing your pay-
phones through—where were you purchasing the
payphones from?
A. Well Johnny was actually purchasing the pay-
phones. They were either coming out of Becktel or—
Becktel or Atlantic Marketing?
Right—North Atlantic Marketing.
Oh, Atlanta Marketing?
No, North Atlantic Marketing.
North Atlantic Marketing?
Yes, sir.
. Okay. And how much were you paying for the
payphones themselves, $3,000 approximately?
A. Correct. I think we did our first acquisition of
payphones in—we bought a payphone company in Day-
tona Beach I believe in—it was either ‘95 or ‘96 we
bought 47 payphones there. It had to be in 95 because
Johnny was still servicing the payphones.
Q. I guess what I’m curious about is, it cost you
$3,000 approximately to put a payphone at a certain
site.
A. Correct.
Q. How could you promise the full amount back?
140]
A. Well the payphone and location backs up every
lease. The equipment with the income stream is the
value they’ve got there. That backs up every lease,
O O O Y
163
because some phones based on the income stream is
worth a lot more than what the people paid for them.
Q. Yeah, but some are probably worth less, aren't
they?
A. I would say yes.
Q. 1 would think of a phone as a depreciating—I
mean, the thing still needs—what is the life of a phone?
A. Fifteen years.
Q. Those things could last 15 years?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What about new technology? I thought things
come out, like smart phones?
A. We continually upgrade them. We started with
smart phones from the very first, but they are con-
tinuously upgraded.
Q. So phones at those locations are continually being
improved?
A. Oh, yes, sir, absolutely, because every time we
have—you see, when area code changes happen and all
of that, we have to change the chips. We have to
upgrade the boards and everything so they properly
work. We've put electronic coin mechanisms in our
phone since that time, [41] which is a $230 charge, but it
cuts our service down by about 80 percent on coin jams
and all. We've got everything you can put in a
payphone on our payphones.
Q. Well then what do you do if someone does sell the
payphone site site? Do you resell it?
MR. SORRELS: I'm sorry, will you
THE WITNESS: I don’t follow you.
164
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Will say someone—say I'm an investor and I have
my payphone and at the end of four years—or even at
the end of five years I want to sell it back to you, and
you pay me back. You give me my 4 or $5,000 back.
Okay, you give me the 4 or 5,000 back, what do you do
with that payphone site? Do you resell it?
A. We put it back in our inventory and the odds are it
would be resold, yes, sir, but it would be upgraded at
that time.
Q. It it was profitable, would your company keep it?
A. Yes, sir. Well, no, the phones we own—we own
phones naturally, but we own—so we wouldn’t be
pointed at and said you cherry picked and kept all the
best phones. We have a database, all of our phones,
where they be new install, an acquisition, replacement,
whatever goes into that database. We own everything
that’s not assigned to a lease and what we own this
month we won’t own next month. But [42] nobody can
ever say I’ve ever cherry picked the phones or gave
somebody a better choice because a computer totally
assigns the pay phones.
Q. Well getting back to one of my original question,
has everyone elected to use the lease option?
A. No, sir. We've got people that’s done all three
options. Now the majority of them do a lease option,
yes, sir
Q. Now what’s the—of the payphones sold between
1994 and 2,000, what is the percentage that used the
lease option?
A. Ninty-nine percent.
165
Q. Ninty-nine percent?
A. (Witness nods.)
Let's go into why you went to the marketing
companies.
A. Mr. Larry Grant suggested that, and so I—when I
sat down with Mr. Grant, I said if I’m doing anything
wrong, please tell me and I’ll change. And so the two
suggestions he suggested, we immediately went back
and did it. The first independent marketing group we
had was Bee Communiations out of Cartersville. And
from that point on, Inter-Net no longer sold pay
phones. Bee was originally the exclusive people that
we bought payphones—or leased payphones from, I
should say.
Q. Did you—well who went to that meeting with Mr.
Grant?
[43]
A. Myself and Shelly Friedman, an attorney.
Q. And what firm is he with?
A. Freidman and
MR. SoRRELS: Associates, I think.
THE WITNESS: Friedman & Associates?
MR. SoRRELS: I think that's right.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Okay, now you say Bee Communications was your
first distributor?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you instrumental in helping form Bee Com-
munications?
166
A. No, sir. Instrumental—I offered her—I told her if
she would set it up, I would lease phones from her. In
that instance, I was. But she said—it was a lady,
Beverly Slater, that set it up.
Q. Did you know Beverly Slater?
A. Yes. She had been a marketer for ETS. I don’t
mean ETS, I'm sorry, for Inter-Net.
Q. What about—
A. Asa matter of fact, her sale is what generated the
investigation by you guys, the SEC.
Q. Whois Jim Jordan?
[44]
A. Jim now owns Bee Communications. BCI, he calls
it. He bought Ms. Slater out.
Q. Did you know Mr. Jordan before he bought
Beverly Slater out?
A. Yes, sir. ;
Q. And where did you know him before that?
A. I met him initially through Inter-Net. He was the
sales manager for a long distance marketing company
out of Vancouver, Canada and we had talked at one
time about merging with that company. That’s where I
met Mr. Jordan, and then we became friends.
Q. So did you approach Beverly about purchasing
Bee, or did you—did you have anything to do with
Beverly and Jim Jordan meeting?
A. They met because of me, yes, but he had met her
prior to them talking about buying her marketing
group. ;
167
Q. What is Hayes Communication? I believe it’s
Hayes.
A. Yes. They are a marketing group out of St. Pete.
Q. Getting back to Bee. Does Bee sell—or does Bee
recommend ETS exclusively?
A. I don’t know that, no, sir. They—I—no, I don't
know. I know they sell other products.
Q. What is your affiliation or relationship with
Hayes?
45
A. They're an independent marketing group, also.
Q. And who owns Hayes?
A. Curtis Hayes.
Q. Did you have any prior relationship with Mr.
Hayes?
A. I met him—he was a marketer for Bee and that’s
where I met him.
Q. So Bee was formed in approximately 1996?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How about Hayes?
A. I think Hayes has been about—it’d be around ‘97.
I think it had been a little over three years.
How about National Communications?
Yes, they’re an independent marketing group.
Who owns that one?
Tom Murray out of Boca Raton.
They’re also in Florida?
Yes, sir.
5 O N Y
168
Q. Do you know—what’s his name, Tom Berry?
A. Murray, M-u-r-r-a-y. He came out of the Bee
organization. As a matter of fact, he came out of Bee
and Hayes came out of his group.
Q. So these entities sell payphones and then they
recommend that ETS lease—they recommend that the
individuals that purchase these payphones, that they
lease [46] them back to ETS, your company, is that
correct?
A. I don’t know whether they recommend them, I
know they give them the option and if they have an
interest, then those people contact us and we send them
the information, ecause none of the agents represent
ETS, period.
Q. Does ETS sell payphones also?
A. No, sir.
Q. Well, from what it's going to show later, it does
look like ETS has some payphones. I have seen a sales
brochure for ETS.
But that’s for getting locations.
Getting locations.
Correct.
In other words, that’s the convenience stores or
Right, the mom and pop. When the information is
requested from a prospective pay phone owner, they
fax us and ask for information on ETS, in that packet
we send out an ETS brochure and a sample copy of the
lease. But it’s a generic brochure.
—
> O O
Q. How many payphones does ETS have under man-
agement at the current time?
169
A. Approximate 47,000.
Q. And they're all under this lease program?
A. Oh, no, sir. We have a little over 200 we manage
for other people, we have I think 50 or so that we
picked up [47] from another company that was doing a
lease and these people took their phones back and we
leased them from them. There was no money ex-
changed, we just took over the lease for them.
Q. Does ETS own any?
A. The phones that are not assigned.
Q. \ Okay, now Hayes, National Communications and
Bee—am I missing any others?
A. No, that’s the only three we have.
Q. When they sell a payphone to an individual or a
customer, do they—where does the payphone come
from?
A. They get the payphones—the marketing groups
— 1 the payphones from PSA, which is a subsidiary of
Q. Where is PSA located?
A. In—the actual corporate office is listed where I’m
8 warehouse the equipment and everything at
Q. So approximately how many payphones are sitting
in the PSA warehouse right now?
A. In the PSA warehouse, there's probably 2000 or
80.
Q. Maybe 2000 in there, in inventory right now?
A. Yeah, ETS probably has got probably 5-6000
that’s in different phases of being installed.
170
Q. Okay, let’s go into I guess the sequence here. How
does Bee market these payphones, to the best of your
knowledge?
A. They have a marketing group of independent [48]
marketers and they contact individuais and sell pay-
phone equipment. If those people buy the equipment,
then they have a choice of either putting it up them-
selves and operating it or they can contact us and if
they contact us they have a couple more options, which
allows them to- we'll put up a payphone for them and
do everything and they take all the risk, they pay us a
flat fee and they get the profit or loss off that phone; or
they can do the lease, we take the risk and they get a
flat monthly lease payment.
Q. But the actual payphone itself, Bee sells the pay-
phone and, what do they do?
A. Bee sells the payphone and gives a bill of sale
direct to the individual with serial number of the pay-
phone equipment.
Q. And how do they get the serial number?
A. From PSA.
Q. They purchase exclusively from PSA—that was
Bee, National and Hayes—is that correct?
A. The phones that ETS leases, I would think so; yes,
sir.
Q. Going back to the original cost, is it still $3000 to
PSA for the purchase of these payphones?
A. Well, it depends. Last year, our cost of an acquisi-
tion was a little over $4200 per phone. A cost to put up
a new pay phone and get it profitable, because 30 to 40
[49] percent of the payphones that we do new installs
171
with never become profitable and we have to move
them to make them profitable, we have basically the
same cost per phone, by the time we new phone
profitable too.
Q. I'm just talking about the original cost I guess.
A. If I’m—just original cost on the payphone?
Q. The ones sitting in the PSA warehouse.
A. With all parts, about $1000 to $1100, depending
on—
Q. Oh, that’s right.
A. And that’s the phone housing itself with a board.
Q. Well, if someone from Bee purchases a payphone,
does PSA assign the location?
A. No, sir, ETS assigns the location.
Q. I guess PSA just sells the actual payphone itself?
A. They sell the actual equipment.
Q. Sell the actual equipment, and ETS finds the
location for the Bee investor.
A. Correct—well actually finds it for the phone
owner.
8 And then ETS has all these locations sitting out
there.
A. We've got approximately 13-14, 000 locations to-
day we don't have phones at that are paid for.
Q. You've already paid for the location?
150]
A. Les, sir, they re under contract.
172
MR. SORRELS: Can we take a break when you
get to a stopping point, Barry?
MR. LAKAS: Let's go off the record at 11:11 a.m.
(A short recess was taken.)
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Going back to that statement you made that
there’s, what was it, 3-4000 locations that haven’t
been—
MR. SORRELS: I think it was 13-14,000.
MR. LAKAS: Oh, yeah, you’re right.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Okay, 13,000-14,000 locations that have been
located that have not been sold yet?
A. That we have location contracts to put payphones
in.
Q. There are no payphones at these sites at the
present time?
A. Not as yet; no, sir.
Q. How much does Bee, Hayes, National Communi-
cations, how much do they get for a payphone location
when they sell it?
A. They're selling the equipment, the location, the
package. The suggested retail today is $7000.
Q. And who came up with that figure, was it Bee or
you helped?
(51)
A. I would say I did, we did.
Q. And what does—well PSA sells the payphone to
Bee.
173
A. Right.
Q. What does PSA get?
A. $5250.
Q. $5250. And what does ETS get, just the leasing
arrangement?
A. I need to change that $5250. $984 of that $5250
goes direct to ETS for the install from the distributor,
and the remainder comes to PSA. And that started the
first of last month.
MR. LOUGH: That was $900 and how much?
THE WITNESS: $984.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. That's usually the amount of the first year’s lease
payments?
A. Yes.
[53]
Q. Now the universe of payphone units, is this
universe unlimited? I mean, how can you keep selling
payphones? It seems like there’s got to be some type of
limit to the number of payphones that can be sold.
A. There's approximately 2.3 million payphones in
the United States. In the country of Mexico, they’re
wanting an additional two to three million new pay
phones installed over the next five years. That’s the
goal of the government. Internationally, it’s a wide
open market in South America and the different
islands; in Europe, it’s an already completed industry.
Was that what you were looking for?
174
[54]
Q. Well, it seems to me like different cities have dif-
ferent regulations, only so many it seems like you could
only put so many payphones up.
A. Oh, I'm sorry, I apologize
Q. You're kind of addressing it.
A. The way we get our phones is we either do an
acquisition where we purchase a payphone route which
is already existing sites or like we just got the Circle K
account, so we will go in and replace the independent
payphone provide that’s there with our equipment, or
we do new installs, which would be a new convenience
store opened or restaurant, whatever it may be. And
we do—last year, approximately 60 percent of our
phones were through acquisitions, 35 percent was
through replacement and about five percent was
through new installs.
No, buying existing payphone companies.
. Oh, I'm sorry, existing sites. Who do you usually
buy them from? i
A. Independent payphone owners.
Q. You mean just the individual person who bought
it [55] for whatever reason?
A. No, the last company we bought was Triangle,
2200 payphones. They had a very strong operating
Q. I’msorry, 60 percent was
A. Through acquisitions.
Q. Through acquisitions.
A. Buying other—
Q. Of old sites?
A.
Q
175
business and the gentleman was retiring, so we bought
his business. We bought all his technicians and trucks
and everything, took over his business.
Q. I guess that kind of addresses my question.
That’s kind of finite because there’s only so many out
there that are existing at the time.
A. Correct. The industry is really in a consolidatin
because of all the changes happening in it. We have
bought payphones from GTE, when they have chose to
move out of a state, we bought the payphones from
them. We have bought probably—and I don’t know the
exact number, but I’ll make a guess of probably 80
individual routes from different people over the period
of time.
Q. What about new payphone locations, what’s the
competition? Say someone opens a convenience store, I
mean, do you automatically send someone there to try
to get the location or does BellSouth send someone
there? How does this—
A. Yes, all the above. Most of the time when we
have a convenience store chain on contract, then any
time they build a new store, we automatically get that
account. We have all the Diamond Shamrocks nation-
wide, we have all the [56] Convenience Stores USA, the
Swifty Serve, Murphy Oil. We have the Phillips 66, we
manage their phones nationwide. We have the Texaco
Star Marts in Texas and in Florida we have the Golden
Pantries. We just got the Circle K, I said. We've got
the Daytona Speedway, Darlington, we've got basically
all of the NASCAR tracks under contract. We have
Tampa Stadium, which we've had some time. We've
got a ball park at Arlington, we’ve got airports at
Huntsville and at Montgomery. We’ve got a number of
176
counties, like in Pensacola, we have all the phones on
the beach that the county has there. We do in Atlantic
City. So it’s—
Q. Municipalities?
A. We do a lot in the municipality, but as far as a
complete municipality, no. The closest one would
probably be Brunswick, Georgia where we have all the
payphones in the courthouse and the lobby of the jail
and all their parks and everything. We have half of all
the phones in the roadside parks in Texas. Lots of
hotels—Cobb Galleria here. A number of large shop-
ping centers across country too.
Q. If I see one of your phones at a street corner, is
that usually through the municipality or is it usually
with the sidewalk rights with the business that happens
to be near?
A. See, here in Georgia, BellSouth has the sidewalk
rights. Any phone we have here is on private property.
It [57] could be sitting on a curb, but it’d be sitting on
like a convenience store’s private property. Now in
New York City where we have quite a few phones, now
we've got two franchises in New York City where we
have curbside phones that are licensed by the City.
Q. Because I’ve seen some of yours on looks like
street corners, but I guess you’re saying it’s on private
property.
A. Right.
Q. Associated with a convenience store or restaurant
or something.
A. If they were on the street corner, the City of
Atlanta would have already jerked them off because
they are tough about that.
177
Q. Now what’s your arrangement with the location
owner?
A. We have either five, seven or ten year contracts
where we have the exclusive rights to put payphones
up. And then they get a percentage of the net revenue
and sometimes it’s of the gross revenue.
Q. Do you have to send them some kind of account-
ing records?
A. They get an accounting each month with their
check on their phones. And the larger accounts, such as
Diamond Shamrock, you know, we've got 5000 phones
with them, so they [58] get a breakdown of every
phone.
Q. So you have what, a group of people that goes out
and checks these payphones every month?
A. I’ve got 300 people that do nothing but service
payphones full time.
Q. So they're collecting the coins out of them every
month?
A. Collect a minimum of once a month, they’re
normally at every phone twice a month. Some phones,
the really good phones, we'll be there every week.
Q. So 300 people doing 47,000 pay phones?
A. Right. Now I’ve got—as I say, I’ve got sub-
contractors that will take—probably about 1000 of
those are done by subcontractors. The rest are done by
our independents.
I'm sorry, how many offices do you have in other
states?
A. Twenty-eight offices. That includes this office
too, here in Atlanta.
178
Q. Are they mainly servicing people that run around
to these piiones?
A. Right. We have a regional office in Brooklyn,
New York and a regional office in Dallas; one up in
Minnesota and one in California. And then we have
what we call branch offices, rest of them.
159]
Q. So you've got 300 people doing approximately
47,000 payphones per month.
A. Correct.
Q. How about—well, actually how many—you might
have a good idea of this—how many of the payphones
are actually profitable, of the 47,000?
A. Forty-two. We've got somewhere around 6-8000
that are marginal phones. Advertising is one of the
new things that’s really starting to generate tremen-
dous revenue for us, and some of those phones will take
advertising booths, so we're not pulling in—but that’s
why we try to cull a minimum of 10 percent each year of
our payphones, because just the economic conditions
make good phones this year that will be bad phones
next year, or marginal. Or somebody will build a store
next door and put up phones.
Q. How have cell phones affected your business?
A. In the top 40 percent of the payphones, we've had
a decrease in revenue; the bottom 60 percent, we have
not. So it has affected and that’s part of the change
that’s happened in our industry.
Q. How does this work, say I have a calling card and
I go up to one of your payphones—calling cards, you
carr usually just walk up to a payphone and—you don't
179
even have to put 35 cents in. Does it deduct part of the
calling card?
A. No, because you'll dial a 1-800 number there to
60] get—that’s called dial-around, we get compensated,
as of today, at 24 cents per call on those. And that’s
been in turmoil with the regulators for the last three
years and hopefully, we’re going to get another—a
decision is coming down this next month that will clear
that up. But it’s eventually going to come back to the
pay phone, in my personal opinion.
E + + „*
BY MR. LOUGH:
Q. You indicated that you cull approximately 10
percent of the phones each year.
A. Right.
By that I guess you mean you take them out of
service and relocate them or something like that?
A. Correct.
(61)
Q. Approximately what percentage or what number
of the 47,000 phones that you have are subject to the
kind of contract that requires that you maintain the
phone, that you are not permitted to cull that phone?
A. I’ve got approximately 20,000 convenience stores,
so I would say—which is about what, 40 percent of
them, and those I would not want to cull, they’re our
best phones. That’s why we are concentrating on con-
venience stores because when all this change happened,
we chose to—how do you overcome the change, and we
180
vertically market into that store, we do their air and
vac machines, we do ATMs, we do their prepaid calling
cards and we do the long distance for that one location.
And now of course we’re doing advertising, which is—
I’d like to talk a lot about that, but you haven't asked
that question.
(Laughter.)
Q. You're talking about advertising on the phone?
A. We have the right to a patented payphone booth
and what started this, when we got our two franchises
in New York [62] City, at the same time they let five
contracts to advertising agencies to sell the advertising
on payphones. We are currently contracting with a
company called Outdoor Concepts. On our Manhattan
curbside phones, they’re paying us a $7000 signing
bonus and guaranteeing us a $450 per month minimum
net-net-net commission on our phones because the City
gets a commission since it’s curbside and I don’t have a
location.
My outer boroughs got a $4000 signing bonus and
a guarantee of $150 a month. Now I have a 15-year
contract with the City on those phones and I have a
five-year contract with the advertising company on the
guarantee.
When I saw that, I says if that’ll work like that,
I’ve got 20,000 convenience stores out here that tobacco
is screaming for some place to advertise and they can
advertise up to 13 square feet on private property
where cigarettes are sold over the counter—conven-
ience stores.
So we started looking, and we patented two
different types of phone booths in conjunction with the
manufacturer. We have an illuminated 12 x 18 over the
181
phone and we have a two foot by three foot on the back
and a two foot by three foot on each side that are
illuminated 24 hours a day. That booth will generate an
additional $725 per month gross revenue. Then we
developed one that’s on the wall and whether it be on
the wall of a convenience store or a wall of a sports bar,
that has an angled ad on it so it doesn’t take [63] out the
— room when you walk by it or so on, it has one over
i
So we’ve done two contracts with R.J. Reynolds on
advertising, one in the northeast where we’ve got our
first booths going up, and one in Phoenix, Arizona.
It is manna from heaven, for a choice of a better
word.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. How often do people want refunds? That is give
you the 180 days notice?
A. Right.
Q. Oris it 90 days? I’m sorry.
A. 180 days. We have, in the first five years had a
one percent per year average of liquidations. Last
year, because I had two rescissions, we had a four
percent liquidation.
165
Q. So in if 2002, 8000 phones 8000 purchasers
wanted or elected not to renew or lease, that would be
what, $6000 a phone or $7000 a phone?
2 2 say they were probably 86000 a phone at
182
Q. So you're talking about what?
A. 848 million.
Q. $48 million. Say that happened, what—how is
ETS going to pay that back?
A. Well, the payphone and location backs up every
piece of equipment. If I did not have the revenue from
my internal operations or from external resources, then
I could sell the payphone locations to other payphone
vendors. But our goal is certainly not to sell them, our
goal is to own [66] them all ourselves.
Q. At the end of five years, how much time do you
have to pay these people back?
A. Pay them—we notify them at 120 days prior and
then at 90 days, whether we choose to purchase or not.
And if they request us to purchase. Then we buy it
back at the anniversary date.
Q. You buy it back at the anniversary date.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So is there any pattern of these things going up,
these locations? Because you said you believe that
some—say only 1000 became due, you're saying that
some other marketer or some other payphone company
would buy all these locations.
A. Ves, sir. Let me explain why. Today, the value of
a payphone is based on total sources of revenue from
that payphone minus your line charge you pay the
phone company, minus the commission you pay for that
location, that’s called gross net and we say times 30,
that is the normal way payphones are sold. Now put
advertising on these payphones.
183
Let’s say that payphone booth that can generate $700
only generates $400 a month. The value of outdoor
advertising is you take that $400 times 12 is $4800 times
five to ten, so my payphone booth and phone now is
worth somewhere from $25,000 to $30,000 each in the
marketplace. That's current value [67] that everybody
is paying for outdoor advertising.
So I’m saying I think my locations are going to be
worth considerably more.
Q. You think.
A. Absolutely. I'll give you a personal opinion. I
think payphones in five years will be worth—loca-
tions—will be worth between $10,000 and $12,000 with
operating income on them. That’s my personal opinion.
R + „ „ &
Q. Okay, let's go over this scenario. All 8000 pay-
phones, the purchasers elect not to renew the leases, all
8000 are due. No company wants to purchase them.
What are you going to do to make these people whole?
A. Well, I don’t owe anybody anything. I don’t know
what it’ll be two years from now, but today I don’t owe
anybody anything. So I have outside resources I could
call on. All of my trucks, everything is paid for, my
other businesses are there generating income, so |
certainly can generate the revenue to buy them.
Q. If that happens though, you start selling your
trucks—
A. No, I could borrow all of it.
Q. I thought you said you couldn’t borrow from
banks.
- 184
68]
A. No, no, I said I couldn't borrow when I first
started. You know, I’m in a whole different situation
now. I was zero and we did $170 million last year, so
we’re a major payphone player. And then our other
businesses, we’ve got a very, very large business here.
Q. But you do say 42,000 of these payphones are
profitable, is that correct?
A. Ves, sir.
MR. LONG: Barry, could I ask some questions?
MR. LAKAS: Sure.
MR. LONG: There were a couple of points I'd like
to get some further information on.
BY MR. LONG:
Mr. Edwards, you said PSA was a subsidiary of
TS?
mo
Yes, sir.
Is that like a 100 percent owned subsidiary?
Correct.
And is that the name of the company, PSA?
I believe it’s PSA, Inc.
Do you know where it’s incorporated?
It's a—I don’t know for sure. I’ll have to check
and find out for you, sir.
Q. Are there other subsidiaries of ETS?
A. Yes, sir, there's ETS Vending, which does the air
and vac; there is POA, which is our limited partnership
that [69] does Mexico.
rope Pp &
185
Q. Are those wholly owned by ETS?
A. ETS owns 100 percent of Vending and it owns 60
percent of POA.
Q. Of course, I need to know who owns the other
part of POA.
A. I know the two principals, but I don’t know
whether the stock is direct in their name or in a
corporation they have—it’s name. I can certainly get
that information.
Q. Whoare the principals?
A. Jack Limke and—oh, geez, I’ll think of it in a
minute.
Q. So those are all of the subsidiaries. Well, let's put
it this way, those are all—this is all of the subsidiaries
of ETS?
A. Correct, sir.
. Are there other affiliated companies that might
not be considered subsidiary that are involved in these
operations?
A. There's other companies that Twin Leaf owns,
which I own both Twin Leaf and ETS.
Have you mentioned those on the record already?
Yes, sir.
You said last year there were two rescissions?
Yes, sir. ö
Would you elaborate on what those amounted to?
One was in Kansas, which we got a cease and
desist, and we had voluntarily stopped selling there.
Instead of fighting and paying large legal fees, we chose
* O O Y
186
to do a rescission. Eleven percent of the individuals
chose to take the rescission. And in Pennsylvania, we
voluntarily stopped selling. There was no C and D or
anything. And we did a rescission there, and 34 percent
of the people took it.
73
Q. Before we go on, let me just ask a couple of
things. You said that last year you had two rescissions,
one resulted in Kansas and the other was in Pennsylva-
nia?
A. Correct.
. And Kansas had followed as a result of a cease
and desist order. What agency issued or entered that C
and D, do you know?
A. I think the Department of Security in Kansas.
Q. And what is your understanding as to the basis
for that cease and desist order?
A. They thought we were selling a security.
Q. In Pennsylvania, was there an inquiry that came
from some regulatory body within the state?
A. The Department of Security.
Q. Okay. And it did not lead to a cease and desist
order, is that right?
A. No, sir.
Q. Were any proceedings initiated?
A. No, sir, none. There was no proceedings in either
one.
187
Q. Allright. Have you had regulatory inquiries from
any other state regulatory bodies?
A. Yes, sir. I’ve had them from Florida, from North
Carolina, from Iowa, Oregon, Kansas and Pennsylvania
—and Rhode Island.
77
THE WITNESS: If you're looking at the total
number of phones operating as we have now, you
probably have 34,000 that are totally profitable because
some of them are in the process new installs and so we
don't really know what the profitability of them are yet.
We know [78] approximately 34, 000 are profitable.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Going back to this Exhibit Number 7, do you
recognize this document?
A. Ves, sir.
Q. Would you describe it, please?
A. It is the brochure and disclosure that is sent out
to prospective lease holders when they request it from
ETS.
Q. When they request it. So not everyone gets this?
A. Only—they either fax or send us a letter with a
written request and it is sent out to them.
Q. How would they know it exists?
A. When the marketing people talk to them, if they
have an interest in the leasing of the program, then
they fill out a form and send it to ETS.
Q. Does that form identify this document?
- 188
A. lt requested information on ETS, is what it does.
It’s a fax form, just a single page.
Q. Oh, so if they send that in to you, then you
automatically mail them this?
A. Yes.
Q. Other times, they just take the person’s check—
they fill out an application, they take the person’s check
and they never see this? I guess I’m confused, why do
some get it and some don’t?
[79]
A. Well, everybody gets it that leases a phone.
Q. Oh, everyone does get this that leases a phone?
A. Everybody that has requested information on
leasing—no, not everybody that leases—every one we
don’t—send out does not end up in a lease.
Q. Right.
A. But everybody that does a lease has had one.
Q. Whosupplies it to the agents?
A. The agents do not handle it. It is sent out direct
by ETS to the individual payphone owners who request
it.
Q. Whorequest it.
180]
A. Correct.
A. My understanding is that the marketing agent or
salesman contacts a prospective phone owner, talks to
189
them about buying payphone equipment, they do not
represent ETS in any way, shape or fashion. If that
individual is interested in either leasing a payphone or
having service on a payphone, then the individuals
themselves request that we send them a package which
we do. And then if they choose to lease the phone or
take option 2, then we deal direct with the individual
once they own the equipment.
[89]
BY MR. LAKAS:
. That's why—going back to my statement about
how finite is the universe of selling payphones, because
this financial statement looks to me like you have to
keep selling payphones and payphones and more
payphones to be profitable and to pay your expenses.
Eventually this is going to have to dry up.
A. I would say yes to that.
* * „ „ „*
MR. SORRELS: This financial statement doesn’t
[90] reflect anything in the way of advertising revenue,
does it?
THE WITNESS: No, sir.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. Well, how much advertising revenue did you have
last year?
A. had zero last year.
Q. And what do you expect the advertising revenue
to be next year?
190
A. This year?
MR.SORRELS: 2000.
THE WITNESS: 2000?
Q. 2000. Okay, this year. We're already in it, but—
A. We should hit pretty close to $15 million to $20
million. ;
Q. How much have you had the first three months?
A. We got our first check in last month. $8300.
Q. $8300? Is this $15 million based on the $8300?
A. That was the first—that was 103 of the booths we
had up and of course that grows every month as we're
putting our enclosures up.
193
Q. So is there a time lag between when people
purchase a payphone and when they're assigned a
payphone?
A. Ves, sir, it can be as short as two weeks and go as
much as two to three months, depending on inventory
and where they’re going.
Q. Why would it go to two to three months? I
thought you said you had 11,000 to 13,000 locations.
A. We do. Well, for instance, like we got the Swifty
Serve account, which we took over January 1. These
are [94] convenience store phones. Well, the people
that are currently in there are just now taking their
phones out, so although we’ve had the contract this
long, it’ll be another 45 days before we get the phones
in those contracts and that happens occasionally, more
191
than we like, when we’re replacing another vendor’s
equipment.
Q. Are purchasers of these payphones bein
g told
that there might be a three month delay before they—
A. Yes, sir. And then they get an addendum to their
lease that states where their location is, so they can go
out and feel and touch and see their payphone.
Q. But they get assigned a serial number right
do they not? *
A. Ves, sir.
BY MR. LOUGH:
Q. At what point in time do they receive information
regarding the location of the payphone?
A. It will be anywhere from the time they receive
their lease up to two to three months later, depending
on the install. Then they get an addendum that gives
_the location of every one of their phones.
Do they receive that directly from ETS?
A. Correct.
Q. That doesn’t go back through Bee Communi-
cations or whoever sold them the phone?
195
A. No, actually Bee has sold them the phone and
location. We assign the location, their location, which is
part of the original purchase.
BY MR. LAK AS:
Q. But you said they are informed that they may not
have a payphone for a few months.
A. Well, they’ve got a payphone—
192
Q. They might not have a location for a few months.
A. Correct.
Q. Okay, go to Note C, commitments and contingen-
cies, which is on the next to last page. I’ll read the first
paragraph: “As discussed in Note A, the company
leases payphone units. Lease arrangements provide
that the company may purchase the payphone unit
upon 30 days notice and the lessor as a put option to sell
the payphone unit to the company upon 180 days
notice.”
The next line says, “If a significant number of
lessors were to exercise their put option, the company
does not have the available resources to satisfy its
obligations.”
Is that a true statement?
MR. SORRELS: As of December 31, ‘98?
A. Not in the bank. But we have other sources of
revenue.
BY MR. LAKAS:
Q. What might those be?
[95]
A. You know, lines of credit, external financing.
Q. That statement there, are purchasers of pay-
phones being informed the company does not have the
available resources to satisfy its obligations if everyone
were to exercise their options to sell the payphones
back? |
A. I'm sorry, I didn’t understand your question.
Q. Are purchasers of payphones being told this—
that the company does not have the available resources
193
to satisfy its obligations if a significant number of
lessors were to exercise their put options?
A. I would not think so, no.
199]
Q. They get them [the hone assi
— payp ignments] auto-
A. Tes.
Q. From that inventory of 11,000 to 13,000 locati
that you have. —
A. Right.
Q. If you go to the last page, there’s a lot of lease
numbers with serial numbers but with nothing on them.
A. That means there has been no locati i
these, as of this date. *
Q. So these people have purchased their pay-
phones—
A. Correct.
Q. —So they're part of the 3000 or so at the end of
the year that haven’t been assigned payphones—or at
any point in time.
A. Correct.
101]
BY MR. LOUGH:
>. Approximately how many phones per month are
sold?
A. Last year, we averaged about 1250 a month.
194
Q. About 1250 a month?
A. l believe that’s correct.
102
Q. But there is a lag time between the sale and the
placement of the phone.
103]
A. Correct.
And I think you previously testified that can be a
. weeks, it can be a few months. What's the longest
lag time?
A. I think the longest we’ve ever had would be
between three and four months.
Q. Okay. Do you know what the average would be?
A. I would say the average would be within six to
eight weeks.
Q. Have you done any kind of a study of that, to
actually determine what that is?
A. I did approximately six months ago.
Q. And that resulted in your determining that it was
six to eight weeks?
A. Correct.
Q. Is that of concern to the company, that there is
that period of time between the sale and the actual
placement of the phone?
A. From my viewpoint, no.
Q. Why is that not of concern?
195
-
A. Because we are—if the delay is there, it’s because
of a legitimate reason and we are constantly working
104] to pull it back. It’s just a matter of doing busi-
ness, because the sales will come in, maybe 1000 this
month and then 2000 next month. If I get 2000 sales a
month, now that’s going to put a pressure on us to get
things caught back up, which we do.
Q. And you've said that you essentially have a certain
number of locations that—I think you said between
12,000 and 14,000—
A. Correct.
E that are under contract. Now a number of those
are not available for installation, I take it, as present?
A. A few of them, yes. I would say probably 2000 are
in the process of removing—well, maybe closer to
3000—in the process of removing the phones from
existing vendors.
RE * * *& „
BY MR. LONG:
Q. I'd like to ask a couple of questions, Mr. Edwards.
Concerning your compensation in 1999, it’s not clear to
me exactly what that was that grew out of the ETS
operations either directly or indirectly. Would you
state for the record what that was?
A. Well, PSA pays to Twin Leaf a management fee, a
figure per phone.
Q. How much is that?
A. It's $250 per phone. And we cover all of our
105] my management team, covers all their expenses
and everything out of that.
196
Q. So what was your personal compensation in 1999
that came directly or indirectly from the ETS opera-
tions?
A. Okay, because PSA being ETS—$380,000.
Q. Was that your top year?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. With respect to the—if you view the ETS opera-
tions that have been described on the record as a
method of raising capital to acquire phones, can you
quantify the cost of that capital in a percentage basis?
A. It varies on each of the different leases because as
we started, it was a higher percentage, but I would say
on an average right now, it’s about 14 percent—overall
average about 16 percent.
Q. And that’s paid to whom?
A. Io the lease holders.
* * X * *
[107]
Q. If you had a source of capital say from a financial
institution, what would the rate have to be in order to
be a better rate than what you’re paying now?
A. Of course 15 percent would be better. But see,
that’s one of the situations in our business, because
after I talked to Mr. Grant and I gave the put to the
owner, that he can come back and get the phone any
time, he’s got absolute control of the phone. Well, he
sort of controls what I can and cannot do with the
phone. If he chooses for me to buy that phone, then I
can take those phones to Wall Street, if I chose, and
raise the money because I’ve got the equipment to sell.
Today, I don’t own any phones, the owners own the
197
phones. So the cost of my dollars—the equipment came
in, [108] I’m leasing that phone for the use of that
equipment. So I’ve really not borrowed his d
I’ve got his equipment. „„
198
[PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 21]
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND
EXCHANGE COMMISSION |
File No. A-02501
IN THE MATTER OF ETS PAYPHONES, INC.
INVESTIGATIVE INTERVIEW
TRANSCRIPT
APPEARANCES:
1 ;
On behalf of the Securities and Exchange Com-
BARRY LAKAS, Staff Accountant
Securities and Exchange Commission
Suite 1000, 3475 Lenox Road
Atlanta, Georgia 30326
(404) 842-7600
On behalf of the Witness
WILLIAM G. LEONARD, Attorney
2115 East Lake Road
Atlanta, Georgia 30307-1835
* * * * *
Whereupon,
MARIO ROBERT COMMITO
appeared as a witness herein, and having been first
duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
199
EXAMINATION
BY MR. LAKAS:
[14]
Q. Let's get to the questions now. Can you go over
again how you got hired by ETS?
A. ETS actually ran an ad in the newspaper looking
for a CFO. I was—I sent in a resume and they asked
me to come in.
(21)
Q. Who was out there selling these payphones, to
your knowledge?
A. There were independent sales groups.
Q. Okay, that’s the marketing groups?
A. Marketing groups.
Q. ETS didn’t sell any payphones themselves?
A. ETS sold no payphones.
Q. Now when you had your interview with Mr.
Edwards or maybe even Mr. Ginsburg, did they go over
the company structure?
A. Charles did go over the company structure.
Q. Do you remember what he said the company
structure was?
A. The company structure was that there were
actually two companies, one of which was ETS, which
was an operator of payphones.
Q. Okay.
A. The other company was PSA, which was a com-
pany that did the acquisition of the routes and sold
phones and Charles was very careful about this dis-
tinction—sold phones to the independent marketing
companies.
Q. Seller of payphones—and that was PSA subsidiary
of ETS?
A. Asister company I believe, not a subsidiary.
22]
.So then who owns stock of PSA?
A. I believe it was owned by Twin Leaf, to my
knowledge, which was Charles’ personal company.
Q. Twin Leaf owned PSA?
A. I believe. I’m not sure, I did not do anything on
Twin Leaf’s books.
Q. Were you hired them to be the CFO for ETS and
PSA?
A. And PSA.
Q. For some reason, I always thought PSA was a
Subsidiary, because the audit—not the audit, they don’t
have audited financial statements—but the consoli-
dated financial statements I’ve seen—
A. They combine the two.
Q. They do combine the two. It says ETS Pay-
phones, Inc, and this is Note A to the December 31,
1998 financial statements which I’m going to show you
later, it says “ETS Payphones, Inc. and subsidiaries are
engaged... .”
A. There's a bunch of other subsidiaries.
201
Q. But PSA was not a subsidiary.
A. I think it was a sister company, I'm not sure. 1
never saw the ‘98 financials, they didn’t finish them—
* X * „ „
23]
Q. But ETS—you’re not sure if PSA is included in
the—
A. No, I'm not.
. Ain the financial statements. So vou believe Twi
Leaf owned PSA. Now what’s Twin Leaf? :
A. It's a holding company or a com
Charles Edwards personally. W
3 holding company, and what do they hold, just
A. PSA. They may own ETS, they—I beli :
gends was under Twin Leaf rey elieve Le
Q. So Twin Leaf also owned— well when
. you say
Charles Edwards controlled ETS. it
— , It was actually Twin
A. Well, Charles was Twin Leaf.
Q. Well, give me all you know about Twin Leaf.
A. Very little. It was a company that was Charles
Edwai ds’ company, it wasn’t even domiciled with us.
Their whole function, I don’t know what it was, I never
did the books for them, they were done by Dan Weldon.
202
[25]
ding company and
So you have Twin Leaf as a ho
— that, you have ETS, PSA and Legends?
A. Uh-huh.
Q. Any others? |
A. There were some—there was an LLC but I’m —
sure what the ownership was there, that we pu
together with a company in Mexico to do oy eer —
Mexico City. And there are long acronyms —
there in Spanish. And there was a company set up here
in the states to be the LLC that would own the —
company. And I believe Twin Leaf was the partner o
that LLC. |
Q. How about a company called I believe it was MSC?
A. MSC was a subsidiary of ETS.
26
: | How about Pleasant Hill, have you ever heard of
that?
A. Pleasant Hill, vaguely remember it.
I believe it was just a company owned by Charles
Edwards that owned the building that—
A. That’s what it is, they were just breaking ground
on the building when I left.
Q. How much did you deal with Don or Dan Weldon?
i of we talked about setting up
. back and forth.
i i i loyee, he
We talked about—prior to him being an emp
— to me some of the struetures between PSA
203
and ETS because he was involved with Charles at that
level. And then information back and forth for cash
advances that when we transferred money out of
PSA, I would get notification that money had been
transferred and then I would confirm with him who
received it.
Q. Where was the money going?
A. Twin Leaf primarily, PSA would pay that over-
head fee. Occasionally we did—at the very beginning
we did some small advances to Legends.
Q. How much—well during the time you were con-
troller or CFO, do you know how much approximately
was transferred from PSA to Twin Leaf?
A. It was—I couldn’t give you an exact amount but
[27] it was probably in the range of $100,000 to $150,000
a month. g
Q. So you were there almost a year, is that correct?
A. Right, just short of a year.
Q. So maybe $1.2 million?
A. Yes.
Q. Any other type of advances to Twin Leaf from
PSA or ETS?
A. Not while I was there. There was a lot of things
done prior to my getting there and I don’t have access
to the records as to what the opening balances were.
Q. How about Legends?
A. Legends, I think the total we gave them was very
small, it was over about six months to cover payrolls
and things as they were rebuilding the switch and
204
setting it up. And it was probably a total of about
$200,000 to $300,000 over the entire year I was there.
[29]
Q. Did you have any disputes with Charles Edward
when you were working for ETS?
8 ot disputes. I mean we had discussions over a
— of things. I take the position as a CFO that I
have to look at things with a very clear, hard eye.
Charles once sat me down at night and said I sense a
certain amount of negativity. I said no, Charles, it’s not
negativity, when there are problems, you face them.
Q. What were some of the problems that you were
having?
A. Wewere losing money as an operating company.
[30]
Q. Okay, did you do the financial statements?
A. Yes.
Q. For the company?
A. Yes.
Q
This is kind of tricky. Did you consider the sale of
the payphones as revenue?
A. Yes, we treated them as revenue.
Q. Is that the way Charles Edwards wanted them
recorded—
A. Yes.
Q. —on internal financial statements?
A. Yes, it is.
205
Q. Did you see any problem with that?
A. When I joined the company, they had had a prior
accounting firm named Gross, Collins & Cress, it’s a
local firm and a good firm. And they had refused to
issue a statement recognizing the sale of the phones by
PSA as a revenue item. The audit for the prior year,
which was ‘97, had never been closed. And the—
Q. Was that Grant Thornton?
A. No, that was Gross, Collins.
Q. Oh, that’s right, they weren’t in yet.
A. And when I came in, what I wanted Charles to do
was to get an opinion, clean opinion, on the company
and he wanted the recognition of the revenue. I met
with Gross, and [31] of course 1 got the job of getting
them to cut the outstandi g fee, which had been run up
to like $140,000 for a small audit. We reached negotia-
tion and they were dismissed as auditors.
And he said who should we bring in and that’s
when I recommended Grant. When Andre came in, we
spent a considerable amount of time on the issue and
I’m not a GAAP expert, that’s why I bring in people
that area. I’m a business accountant.
Q. Right.
A. Andre spent untold hours both with his staff, with
me, also with the managing partner of the office here
and they even brought in their GAAP experts from I
believe it was D.C. And they could not come to a way—
now they could recognize pieces of it as prepaids or
fixed assets, they could do a number of things, but they
206
Q. Yeah, from a GAAP viewpoint, I just don’t see
how these things could be considered revenue. But for
internal purposes, I guess you could account for them
any way you want.
A. Sure.
Q. There's usually nothing wrong with that.
But do you know how Charles Edwards reacted
when the CPA firms told him that he couldn’t
recognize—
[32]
A. He tried to convince them that these were truly
sales.
Well, no audit report was ever issued, was it, be-
cause of the fact that these payphone sales could not be
recognized as revenue?
A. That’s correct. Gross, Collins got to the point in
the draft, but recognized debt rather than revenue and
they were let go because of that, it was not an
acceptable report. And Grant was still working on it
when I left, but they could not come up with a GAAP
presentation that they could make an opinion on.
_ So it looks like Charles Edwards had a dilemma.
Why did he want audited financial statements?
A. Well, Charles’ long-term thinking is to be a public
company and he recognized the fact that you'd have to
be GAAP, you'd have to be audited, you'd have to have
a reasonable firm give that attestation. That's why I
brought in Grant because I thought that they’re big
enough to do a public offering and yet they’re small
enough and boutique enough that they really do give
you a lot of good service.
Q. Right.
A. So that was his long-term plan, was public.
Q. Well, when you see the financial state
I'm going to show them to you later, — 7 GAAP
viewpoint, it's pretty obvious that this company existed
from the salel 33] of new payphones. I mean, you can
always argue that any company has to exist from the
sale of their products, but this company was making
their lease payments from the sale of new payphones
they—and actually the sale of these new payphones
were actually, to me, more capital lease obligations or
debt instruments. Technically the company, to me, had
like a $350 million liability because they had a promise
to buy these payphones back.
Was Mr. Edwards aware of that?
MR. LEONARD: When you say com are
talking about ETS or PSA or the combination?
MR. LAKAS: Well, the wh i N
ä e whole thing, I'd say the
BY MR. LAK AS:
Q. To your knowledge, was Mr. Edwards
fo yo . i aw
that — that this company was really — —
was dependent on making its lease
sale of new payphones? 1 r N
A. To my knowledge, Charles felt that thi
. is was
very good deal for the payphone lessor and owner. ;
Q. Oh, yeah, it was.
A. That he felt that he had done people a great favor
and he actually gave a number of speeches where he
felt that he had changed people’s lives for th
e better b
the stream of income that he had provided for them. .
[34]
He also recognized that at some point, you know, a
payphone is going to be tendered back. But I think that
was where he felt that the public company would be
important. That people would be willing to tender back
in exchange for stock in a public company.
Q. So his long-term plan was to convert that so-
called debt that he would owe these people for the
payphones in the future to some type of equity
instrument?
A. Well, either that or by raising funds in the public
arena, being able to actually buy the phones back,
because it was his statement on numerous occasions
that he wanted to own those phones and not be in a
position of leasing them, that it would be much more
effective to have a large company owning the phones.
Q. Right, because if these payphones were so pro-
fitable, why didn’t he just own them himself?
A. Because to build up quickly, you need some fund-
ing vehicle.
Q. Sothese were funding vehicles.
A. Not funding vehicles in that sense. The statement
I was about to make is, as a startup company, you can’t
fund out of a bank, nobody is going to give you a loan.
As a matter of fact, | approached a couple of bankers I
know and they said fine, put up a CD and we'll lend you
the amount of the CD. Well, terrific.
[35]
He felt that he was in the business of signing
leases just the way you would lease trucks or tractors
or construction equipment or anything else, on a
209
leaseback from an owner of a j
é payphone. That was his
contention throughout the entire time I was there.
* * * * *
Q. Right. Well, let me show you these financial
, 36
statements now. I’m handing the witness what’s —
previously marked as Exhibit Number 9. These are
compiled financial statements of ETS Payphones, Inc.
as of December 31, 1998. I'll let look
— you look at those for a
(The witness reviews the document.)
Q. Have you seen these financial statements before?
A. This look like—I’m not sure, but it looks lik
, ea
draft that was prepared by Grant Thornton.
Q. Did you participate in the pre
3 preparation of these
A. I believe I—I believe this is what I gave to Grant
as the way we were keeping the internal statements.
. If you goto the consolidated statement of opera-
tions, on the third page, it’s kind of blacked out, — do
you see operating revenue almost $100 million. I would
assume that the sale of payphones were included in that
operating revenue.
A. Yes.
Q. Well, if you go to the balance sheet though—an
this is what I’m really interested in here. Under —
rent assets, the fourth line, it says, aceounts receivable
affiliates. Close to 84.5 million was advanced to
affiliates. Do you know who those affiliates were?
210
iginal books and
uld have to go back to the origina
3 — see who they were. Most of that was on
the books [37] before I was there.
Q. It was?
A. Oh, yeah. When I got there—
i hart or workpaper
Did you ever do any type of chart |
— that account, or just determining, you know,
who owed that money?
A. I think there was a worksheet in the files there
that had been done by Kevin on a monthly basis.
I remember seeing one Grant Thornton work-
j C, but then it was—
heet. It said a lot of it was to MSC,
it looks like it was adjusted out back to Twin Leaf.
A. MSC was incurring loses and they were sending
ll and to cover—now that
money up there to cover payro
you — it, it was about 2 to 300,000 a month was
going up to MSC for loses.
Q. Well, to your knowledge, was Charles —
just taking money out of this company and sending it
his affiliates? *
i , it was go
I | think—I don’t remember that i
— the company very much. It may have —
prior to my getting there. But there was very u
cash flow within ETS. PSA had the cash flow. —
incurring loses on an operating basis every * as
was MSC, which was folded into ETS as part of their
overall loss.
And MSC was just doing the same thing that ETS
38] was, just managing payphones?
A. Just managing the 2,700 phones.
211
Q. Well MSC, though, was a subsidiary of ETS, is
that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. So any money that was advanced to them should
have been canceled out—wouldn’t show up as that—
A I would have to go back to the actual finan-
cials—you know, our general ledger.
Q. Okay. What I’m showing you has been previously
marked as Exhibit Number 15. These are the consoli-
dated financial statements and accountant’s compilation
report for ETS Payphones, Inc. as of March 31, 1999,
which is three months later. This was compiled by
Grant Thornton. These financial things have been
prepared on what I consider a modified GAAP basis.
The revenues from the sale of payphones are not
included as actual revenues. They do set up capital
lease obligations.
A. And record the equipment.
Q. Right. They have reported the equipment as
assets. But if you go to other assets under the balance
sheet, you’ll see the account, accounts receivable affili-
ates. It’s now up to over $8 million, and at December
Zist, 1998 it was only 4.5 million. So it's gone up
another $3.5 million in a period of three months.
139]
A. By this time there was also the Mexican operation,
which, I believe, was related to ETS because it was
payphones.
Q. What was the name of this Mexican operation
again?
212
A. I’ve really forgotten it. It was a—it was in
Spanish.
Q. So—
A. There was money flowing to the other operations,
but they were payphone operations.
Q. Who was responsible for writing checks?
A. Checks that were paid for bills and for telephone
bills and operating expenses were written in the
accounting department and they were done on a
signature slogan and it was Charles’ signature and mine
while I was there. Any movement of funds was done by
a wire transfer and it was done by his personal secre-
tary, who was also the corporate secretary. We would
get a slip of paper, a recap, at the end of the month that
would list all of the wire transfers that she had made,
both any wires that came into the company and wires
that went out from the company. There would be a
journal entry made to pick those up.
Q. Okay. Do you remember because you were ob-
viously controller or CFO at this time, do you remem-
ber where this money went to for it to increase that
much in a three-month period, to go from 4.5 million to
$8 million?
[40]
A. 1 would think that—since this includes PSA, I
would think—I’m not sure. It would have—I would
think this includes PSA in this statement-—
q. I think it does, yes.
A. —sol—
Q. It would have to because the payphone sales—
A. Right, are in here.
213
Q. Aare included.
A. Legends by that time would have go
significant dollars because they had to buy —
and that was a third of a million dollars to buy the
switch, and then they had to spend a lot of money for
equipment to bring it up to spec that they had to
purchase from the manufacturer of the switch. So there
were probably, during this period, half a million to
three-quarters of a million dollars that went into
Legends. The acquisition or the joint venture in
Mexico, there was about 3 or $400,000 worth of open
bills to a company called Elkotel that makes phones
that it shipped to the Mexican operation. They needed
them to put them up and they were stalled at the
border because the Mexican operation had never paid
for those phones. So that had to be cleaned up. 8
You would have had payments or loa
PSA to Twin Leaf. I think that the — *
Q. Do you mean $225 per payphone?
41
A. The 125 and any other additional fu i
nds Twin Leaf
needed. I know that they had put up by this —
shortly thereafter we were up to- Pleasant Hill had
used 6 or $700,000 worth of
— 4 of advances, which probably
Q. Do you know what they were for?
A. For the construction of the buildi
ing, and that cam
— of PSA also. So there's almost $2 million richt
there. So, you know, the funds that were being spent
were - they were going out of PSA, not out of ETS.
Q. But you still were the controller for PSA?
214
A. Yes.
Q. In your opinion, were these payments being made
for legitimate business purposes?
A. It would be strictly an opinion.
Q. That’s what I’m looking for. That's all you have.
A. Some—well some. Some of the things that that
Charles had done over the years—which I’m not sure
where the money came from, but ultimately, I assume it
came somewhere out of the companies. He made an
investment to remodel a home down in the islands,
which I didn’t think was—you know, at the stage of the
company 'm pretty much a conservative accountant
and at that stage of the company, I thought that wasnt
the brightest use of money. That was done before I was
there. So some of these
Q. Who told you that was done?
42
He did.
Was it done through Twin Leaf? Did he
I believe so, yes.
This was an investment in his—in a home where?
St. Simons.
Did he tell you how much he—
It was a lot. I mean, it was hundreds of thousands.
The building we were building was—I thought was a
decent investment in terms of a company headquarters.
Q. Where was this going to be?
A. It was at Pleasant Hill and Peachtree Industrial.
„ Or O pol
215
Q. That's why it's called Pleasant Hill. That makes
sense.
A. Peachtree Industrial and Pleasant Hill, which is a
good construction area for offices. I thought that was a
reasonable business use.
Q. What was he going to do, consolidate everything
there?
A. He was going to consolidate the Twin Leaf
operations there and the corporate operations there
and leave the—because the daily operations require a
lot of truck storage, materials storage. It requires a
loading dock that is secure so that you can bring a
Brinks truck in and load it up every day. They had to
have a secure safe area where they did the coin
counting. It doesn’t lend itself to high- [43] quality
office space.
Q. Where’s that now, in Lithia Springs?
A. That's in Lithia Springs.
Q. Is that where your offices were located?
A. That's correct.
Q. I’m trying to remember where Lithia Springs is.
Is it on the west side of town?
A. It’s on the west side. It’s the exit after Six Flags.
Q. Okay. Getting back to Twin Leaf again, what—
we've been over this before, but refresh my memory.
Does Twin Leaf have any legitimate business purpose?
A. Ihave no idea what Twin Leaf did. I do know that
we advanced money, as I say, as an override out of
PSA, 125 a phone.
Q. So you just followed the instructions—
216
i 1 tter of me
e didn’t even—it wasn t ama
33 — I would get a slip of paper 22
there were X hundreds or thousands of —
made this month, times 8125, and we wire tra
ey, please record it.
pron 1 had a separate bank account fro
and ETS?
A. Yes, each company had their own accounts.
Q. Well this $8 million to affiliates, do you know 44
how much was advanced to Twin Leaf?
m PSA
A. No, I don't.
Q. 1 thought the amount that you had advanced to
Twin Leaf was $250 a payphone?
A. It may have changed after I was there. ;
Q. It was just $125 the whole time you were there:
A. It was $125 all the time I was there. a
Did you ever question Charles Edwards abou
some of these payments to Twin Leaf?
’s a 100 percent owner.
re — — canna I realize that. I understand that.
* „ „ „ *
BY MR. LAKAS:
i ile I’ let's go over the
mmito, while I've got you,
—— of ETS and PSA. Who was the chief
operating officer of PSA?
A. Charles—Charles Edwards.
Was anyone else involved in the 0
PSA?
perations of
217
[45]
A. There was a separate staff that did all of the
contact with the lessors. The placing of the specific
phone numbers and all of that was handled by a clerical
staff.
Q. Well that would have been in ETS though,
wouldn’t it?
A. No, they were in PSA. They were PSA em-
ployees.
Q. And they handled the lease—the lessors?
A. They handled the lessors, they handled the—
Q. Paying the lessors? That would come out of ETS,
wouldn't it?
A. Paying lessors came out of ETS, but all contact
with the lessors was done through a separate group of
people.
Q. Okay. And who was in charge of that department?
A. I forget the name. There was—there were about
three departments and they were basically under Joan
—I think her name was Wagoner, but I’m not—no, no,
Wagoner was the attorney. I don’t know Joan’s last
name. She was Charles’ secretary and the corporate
secretary, so it’ll be somewhere in the corporate min-
utes.
Q. Again, ETS, what was the structure of ETS? Who
was the—
A. When I joined ETS, Charles was the president and
CEO; Larry Ginsburg was the chief operating officer
and I was the CFO.
218
Q. And what other departments did they have in
ETS?
[46]
A. They were manager-level people in charge of the
actual field operations and when I joined the company,
Jason Edwards, who was Charles’ son, was in charge of
field operations. He was in charge of maintaining the
phones and collecting the money for the Atlanta area.
Q. Just for the Atlanta area?
A. Yes.
Q. Well they were in 38 states. Who collected. . .
A. Well they only recently were in 38 states. They
had a structure of regions. Florida being a region. The
Southeast, out of Atlanta, there were a few phones.
Most of the phones were in the Atlanta—the immediate
area, with a few phones in North and South Carolina,
probably 100 in Tennessee. They just had local offices.
In some cases they had independent contractors collect-
ing the money and maintaining the phones.
Q. Who would those independent contractors be,
individuals or corporations?
A. Individuals or companies that were in the business
of maintaining payphones.
Q. So they didn’t have offices in all of these states
that they were working in?
A. No. When I was involved there, we probably
branched into five or six states. We were probably up
to about 12 states at that point.
(47)
Q. That's all?
219
A. Yeah. The growth has been pheno
the last things I did in March and Aged of 2 — —
consummate the acquisition of a company in Texas
which got them into about seven or eight new states It
got them into Oklahoma; it got them into the Chica 0
area; it got them into the upper Midwest. .
(51)
Q. How did this company |
» nny wher pany look on a cash flow basis
A. ETS Payphone was not cash flowi iti
wing positive.
was a negative cash flow—significant dollars, — 74
was a very high positive cash flow.
1 always doing separate analysis for each
A. Yes.
Q. You never combined the two for—
A. We combined them on a statement basis, because
Charles, you know, wanted t i
— o present a picture of the
Q. Okay. Now the ETS Pa
| yphones, you say, fro
cash-flow viewpoint was not making — —
A. That's correct.
Q. What did—what were the cash-fl
flow sources fi
es eet When you say it was losing —
— © money coming from and where was it
A. The money came from three basi
ie sources. One i
the actual coins collected from the telephones —
selves. The second was what's called dial around, which
220
is when someone dials an 800 number to access a long
— carrier, the law was passed that the ev
is entitled to receive some compensation. —
individual long- distance carriers were supposed to *
money every month to the [52] payphone ——
operators. Then the third source of funds was advan
out of PSA.
Q. Advances from PSA?
A. From PSA.
Ives are a
So would you say payphones themse
328 business based on what you — at ETS?
Actually were ETS’ payphones profitable?
A. No.
Q. ETS’ payphones did not make money?
A. No, they did not. —
5 in
And by operations, we mean the money come
ke actual em and the maintenance of them and
paying employees for servicing and administration,
payphones at ETS were not profitable?
A. Correct.
Q. Do you know if they were losing money before you
got there?
A. Yes, they were.
Q. And when you left they were still losing money?
A. Yes.
Q. Was Charles Edwards aware of that?
A. Yes.
221
Q. Was there ever any meetings with him about this,
where this was discussed that we're losing money on
these payphone operations, what should we do?
153]
A. Numerous.
Q. Did he Say let’s just go out and sel] more pay-
phones to remedy this?
A. He would demand more efficiencies in the opera-
tions. He would look at is dial around being sent on
time, which, of course, it wasn’t because there were
continual lawsuits back and forth between the pay-
phone owners association and the long distance carriers
saying we don't agree with the court. Whatever the
courts came up with as a split, the other side would
counter sue that felt that they had lost. So we were
owed millions of dollars in dial around. But even then—
Q. But every payphone operator had that problem.
A. That's right. The expenses were too high, and
Charles’ attitude was, if we can get to a critical mass
with the number of phones, then the expenses would
even out.
Q. In your dealings with Charles Edwards and this
whole company ETS/PSA, were they more in the busi-
ness of operating payphones or just selling these pay-
phones?
lecting phones, cleaning phones. Charles had extremely
high standards, that he wanted the phones to be
222
maintained, those added to the cost inefficiencies. For
example, he [54] wanted every payphone actually
physically visited by a technician twice a month. Collec-
tions twice a month. There were phones that didn’t call
for collections twice a month. It’s a very difficult
business at best.
Q. Well did he ever stress selling more and more
payphones as opposed to operations?
A. The sale of payphones had nothing to do with
ETS. That was strictly a PSA function and the people
in ETS really weren’t involved in that at all.
Q. Well you were also the controller of PSA, though,
weren't you?
A. Right, but I had no contact with the sales side of
that business.
Q. Because that was done through these indepen-
dent marketers?
A. al through independent marketers.
* * * * *
225
224
}
10
Hi Sa
Hal
i
1
el op
s| 3
il
i
i
i
i}
}
fii
Ij i!
ck FE
4
1
10 i
08/23/2000
D. etspayphones.com/smart_phone hm
08/23/2000
http /www etspeyphones com/
226 227
— u——ů— —
ongoing revenue generation ts available in today's
telephone industry *
08/23/2000 http //www etspayphones.com/opportunities him 08/23/2000
228
http //werw etspayphones com/opportunibes hum!
09/88/2088 12:25 2
ETS
July 1, 2000
Dee | seeehoiier
Recently, | have received seversi questions from our Lessors. | would personally lice to take come time and
snewer many of those questions for you end to essure you thet ETS is as strong as ever and looking
forward to continued growth:
Q &s the payphone indvaty stowing down?
A No, | don’ think the industry is slowing down, sithough It is going trough @ number of changes - which
inctude « widespread use of wireless phones end 1-800 calls (dis! sround cals).
O Are payphones losing cals because of wireless phones?
—
i
|
|
"Yes, not because of less call stlempts, but because we are only collecting about SO% monthly of what is
ectusily owed us for these Gia! sround cals. .
WE rece(pt of dia/ around compensation improve for peyphone cornparuss 7
> ©
—
—
. nf. nr
rr
wwe — — Com
09/06/00 FRI 12:08 {[TI/RE MO 8734)
5
20
510 » FO
230
nal happens to my lease payments after | reques! οπ
They continue on up to fe day your equipment is liquidated You never lose income on your peypnone
equipment
What is ETS’ involvement with the Nebona/ Cente: for Missing and Exploited Chien and the Adem
Weish Chitdren’s fund?
ETS ts very committed to the National Center for Missing end Expiotied Chiidren and the Adan Weisn
Fund rr ee
Can | contribute to the National Cente for Missing and Exptoted Criidren?
Yes, we wil be sending out more details in the near faure.
Yes, we made a profi of nearly $6,700,000 last year and ow profi potential looks even better for Mu
year ETS has become the leader in the payphone Pidustry.
Hopefully, this wil answer some of your questions. You wil be receiving a number of news updates a
programs that ETS is invoived in. There nas never been 8 better time to be in the payphone industry.
OPPORTUNITY DOESN'T ALWAYS KNOCK, SOMETIMES IT RINGS!
08.05/00 FR) 12:08 (Ti/Rk MO 8734)
ETS Payphones
= doesn't always knock... sometimes it
Deregulation of the phone industry has made it
possible for aimost anyone to participate in the
lucrative, multi-billion dollar payphone industry. Now
ETS Payphones, Inc. makes it even easier for the
novice by making available their proven
management, maintenance and teasing programs.
We will manage your phones for you if you wish to
become less active in management and maintenance
Lease Program
Under certain conditions, we will lease your phone
from you and pay you # monthly rental fee. This will
allow you to become detached from the day-to-day
demands of the payphone business
Management Program Requirements
Your phones must be “smart” phones.
The software must be compatible with ETS software
management systems.
You furnish site and site contact with owner
Payphone must be located in states in which ETS is
operations! New territories are opening on a reguiar
http /www proinsuranceinc com/InvestOppE TSphone hun
Seving and making you money is our busine Ss.
|
08/23/2000
232
investment Uppvitulitics ~ t [ >
basis
ovesiment Upporiumtics . | a>
We provide limited maintenance services for $45.00
monthty, and full maintenance services for $75.00.
Lease Program Requirements
The phone end related equipment must be new and
meet ETS specifications.
Atianta, Georgia
770-819-1600 * FAX 770-891-1685
Lease term of 60 months.
Introduction rental fee of $82.00 per month, totaling
$984.00 per year.
Lessor is owner of equipment that may be
depreciated (See your tax advisor).
Lessor (owner) options at lease-end:
a. Lessor may renew the lease at their existing
lease rate.
2. Lessor may keep the phone and location and
operate it
3. “Option to Sell Agreement” to purchase the
payphone and location from owner at e
end.
Please contact ETS for complete information on any
of the above described programs.
Aap www promnsuranceinc com/In\estOppET Spo him
234
indenmem Oppum ucs ~ t |
"Service 1s Our commument
Sewing and making you money is our business *
The Most Often Asked
Questions & Answers
About the ETS Payphone
Equipment Lease Program:
i
|
i
Q. What is the cost of cach “Smart” Phone?
A. The cost of each “smert” payphone is $7000.
Q. What is the equiveient yieid of the lease payment that
the peyphone owner receives when the owner leases 2
payphone to ETS, and receives the $82 per month lease
payment per payphone’
A. The Payphone Owner's Lease Peyment is equivalent to «
14.1% return per year.
Q. Can I purchase « “Smart” Payphone directly from ETS?
A NO’ ETS §s 2 payphone operating company and does not set!
peypnones “Smart” payphones ere purchased onty from
Independent Marketing Groups setling these payphones
ut pr einc com/InvestOppET S fag ham 08/25 2000
hry www promsurancein com/lnvestOppé TS fag hun
235
co ee LApPpul tiem > ~ t 2 9
Q. What about liquidity ?After the payphone owner has
entered tos lease egreement with ETS, can the owner
get thelr money beck, and when?
A Yes! ETS will purchase the payphone from the owner/lessor at
anytime dunng the period of the lease, for the ongine!
purchase price of the phone, without any penalty
Q. What is the norma! term of the lease
agreement”
A. The normal term of the lease is 5 years.
Q. What are the owner's options at the end of the term of
the teese?
A. At the end of the term of the lease the owner has the
following opuions .
1. Renew the lease with ETS at the existing lease rete.
2. The owner may choose to keep the phone on location
and operete the phone.
3. ETS wil purchase the phone at the end of the term of
the ease from the owner for the full purchase price.
without any penalty
Q What is the # .>4rmum sumber of payphones necessary
to quality fer the ETS tease program?
A The minenum cumnber of payphones required for the ETS
Lease Program is just ome (1) payphone.
Q. Is the ETS Payphone Leasing Program suitabic for IRAs
and other penstor pians’
A Yes. The ETS peyphone leasing program is suitabie for IRAs
anc other pension plans
Q Ti 1 wast to wrvest sey IRA or Pension Fund Money into
the FETS peyphone teasing program what shouts | do”
A To wrest IRA or Pension Fund Money into the ETS Pryphone
teasing program. you shawtd Go the following
1. Gsteblish « “Sel-Directed IRA” eccournt with an ETS
approved sdrrwrstretive trust company
2. Transfer sufficient money from your existing IRA or
Pension Fund into your new “self-directed IRA” account
3. Instruct your new “self-directed IRA” account to
purchase the number of peyphones you desire and to
place therm into the ETS Payphone Lease Program.
* 237
INV coiMen UPpl usu 4 a a ee ‘ 8 .
Q. Is there 2 tax advantage to owning # Payphone (I-E-)? ane
a The owner of payphone equipment may be able to depreciate ayphones, Inc.
the cost of that equipment (individual owners should contact
their tax advisor since we do not give tax advice). 22 Sas. to teenies tm the 2
Q. Is It possible to see s sample of the lease agreement
with ETS?
A. Yes. ETS will be pleased to send # sample lease agreement to
that setts “smart” peyphone(s) and errange for the
phone(s) to be placed in the leasing program with ETS.
POPU
paperwork *
Leasing enen? :
‘ >
Contact Us
mie...
Seving and making you money is ovr business.”
Contact Us
my N promsuranceinc com/ContactUs hem
Page | of |
239
(PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 25
DECLARATION OF RANDALL WILLEY
I, Randall Willey, declare under penalty of perjury
that:
5
I have personal knowledge of all the facts stated
herein.
I am currently 75 years old. I live in St. Charles,
Missouri. I am also retired.
I became aware of ETS Payphones, Inc. (“ETS”)
approximately three years ago through Bob
Sewell, who worked through Communications
Marketing Association, located in Boca Raton,
Florida.
I purchased a total of 7 payphones from ETS. |
purchased three payphones for $6,000 apiece and
four payphones for $7,000 apiece. My total
investment in those payphones was $46,000.
According to information received from ETS, my
payphones are located in South Carolina, Geor-
gia and Texas. However, I have never actually
seen any of my payphones. None of my pay-
phones are located near my residence in
I invested my money in ETS because it appeared
to be a good investment and offered a good rate
of return. I did not enter into this investment
with the intention of actually operating any
payphones myself.
1
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
240
I leased all my payphones back to ETS. I
receive monthly lease payments from ETS of
approximately $82 per payphone.
I signed an agreement with ETS in which ETS
promised to buy back my payphones within 180
days at my request.
I have always received my monthly lease pay-
ments from ETS. I have not yet exercised any
buyback agreements.
I do not manage any of my payphones nor do I
intend to ever manage any of my payphones. In
fact, I do not possess the expertise to manage
payphones. All my payphones are managed by
ETS.
Neither ETS nor any of its representatives have
ever informed me, either before or after making
my investment, that the receipt of my monthly
lease payments is dependent on the sale of pay-
phones to new ETS investors.
Neither ETS nor any of its representatives have
ever informed me, either before or after making
my investment, that ETS payphone operations
are not profitable.
In January 2000, I attended a meeting in Boca
Raton, Florida at which Charles Edwards, the
Chief Executive Officer of ETS, spoke. At that
meeting, Mr. Edwards stated that ETS was
profitable. He specifically stated that the income
earned from payphone operations and advertis-
ing was sufficient to offset the cost of operations.
Neither ETS nor any of its representatives have
ever informed me, either before or after making
Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746,
of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this 22 day of September 2000.
241
my investment, that if a significant number of
investors decided to exercise their options to sell
their payphones back to ETS, that ETS did not
have the available financial res
he 2 ources t
its obligations. *
I declare under penalty
/s/
RANDALL WILLEY
242
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR
THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
ATLANTA DIVISION
No. 1:00-CV-2532
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, PLAINTIFF
V.
ETS PAYPHONES INC., AND CHARLES E. EDWARDS,
DEFENDANTS
DECLARATION OF CHARLES E. EDWARDS
1.
I, CHARLES E. EDWARDS, am over the age of
eighteen and am competent in all respects to make this
Declaration. This Declaration is made and presented in
support of the “Opposition of Defendant Charles E.
Edwards To Plaintiff’s Application for Preliminary In.
junction, Asset Freeze, and Other Equitable Relief,
submitted on my behalf in the above-referenced action.
PERSONAL BACKGROUND AND INFORMATION
2.
I am the controlling shareholder, the current Chair-
man of the Board, and, until early 2000, I was the Chief
Executive Officer, of ETS Payphones, Inc. (“ETS „ A
Georgia corporation. James Blyth is now the President
and Chief Executive Officer of ETS. ETS filed a volun-
tary petition under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code
on September 11, 2000, in Delaware. The lead debtor in
243
the bankruptcy proceeding is Payphone Systems
Acquisitions, Inc. (“PSA”), a Delaware corporation and
wholly owned subsidiary of ETS. ETS’ decision to
voluntarily file its bankruptcy petition, and its proposal
for settlement of the instant matter as preliminarily
agreed to by the Securities and Exchange Commission
(the “SEC”), is discussed in greater detail below.
3.
I am 62 years old. I have been married for 17 years,
and my wife and I have lived in the Atlanta area
continuously since 1989. After graduating from high
school, I served four years in the Air Force. Since that
time, I have been involved in a number of businesses,
including, since 1989, the telecommunications business.
4.
I began in the pay telephone business in about 1993
by serving as marketing director for Global Commu-
nications, a company that, among other things, sold pay
telephones to end users. In 1994 I formed ETS; it was
incorporated in Georgia. At its inception, ETS sold and
managed pay phones, engaging in 22 sales and lease
agreements in 1994. In September of 1995 a company
then related to ETS received a letter from the SEC, a
copy of which is attached as Exhibit 1. As described in
more detail below, in 1995, the SEC conducted an
informal inquiry of my pay telephone business. As a
result of the SEC’s investigation, I participated in
several meetings with the SEC during which ETS’
attorney and I were provided suggestions by the SEC
lawyer on how to conduct the business to avoid running
afoul of the SEC laws and rules. | made several
fundamental changes to the business in a good faith
effort to comply with the letter and spirit of the SEC’s
244
suggestions. One of the changes, was to set up a new
wholesale telephone company, and use the services of
independent distributors who would, separate from
ETS, market pay telephones.
5.
In addition to ETS and its wholly owned subsidiary,
Payphone Systems Acquisitions, Inc. (“PSA”), I am cur-
rently the controlling shareholder, directly or indi-
rectly, of a number of other business concerns which
support the business of ETS, including: (1) Twinleaf,
Inc., which provided management and consulting ser-
vices to ETS and PSA based upon a flat fee payment
per telephone sold; <2) Legends Communications, Inc.,
which provided switch-based long distance telephone
services to ETS managed payphones and ETS facilities;
(3) TPL, Inc., which manufactures prepaid calling cards
and printing for ETS; (4) Twinleaf Media, Inc., which
owns patent rights to and markets an advertising kiosk
for payphones; and (5) Axis, Inc., which holds patent
rights to and markets a three-dimensional advertising
concept for various locations, including payphones.
Twinleaf also owns IAQ Duct Doctor, Inc., which is in
the business of cleaning and servicing heating and air
conditioning ductwork.
6.
I have no intention of engaging in the pay telephone
business with any business other than ETS. I have no
intention of engaging in any business involving the sale
of securities unless and until questions regarding ETS
are resolved.
245
7.
I have an ongoing interest in and am dedicated to
various charitable community issues. Included among
my efforts in this regard is work and contributions
to the Atlanta Union Mission over the past three years
and a national program that I have spearheaded
through ETS. This is a program for lost or missing
children called “Star 1, 2, 3.“ This program, established
in conjunction with the American Public Communica-
tion Counsel and the National Center for Missing and
Exploited Children, will enable lost, missing or kid-
napped children anywhere in the nation to be able to
pick up a public payphone at any time and dial “Star 1,
2, 3” which will put them directly in contact with a
private counselor trained to deal with such situations. |
am a Board Member of the International Center for
Missing and Exploited Children.
ETS'S STRUCTURE AND OPERATIONS
8.
. ETS, during all times relevant herein, was engaged
in the business of operating coin operated pay phones
for a profit. The phones are primarily customer-owned,
coin/coinless-operated telephones (“COCOTs”), al-
though ETS also operates phones that are not owned
by third parties.
9.
ETS is the largest privately owned hone opera-
tor in the United States and one of the — —
payphone companies in the United States. ETS cur-
rently operates, maintains or services tens of thousands
of payphones in thirty-eight states throughout the
continental United States, Puerto Rico, Mexico and the
246
Virgin Islands. ETS has one phone in Canada. ETS
employees over 440 people, operating out of 32 offices
located throughout the United States and four offices in
Mexico.
10.
PSA, ETS’s wholly owned subsidiary, purchases tele-
phone equipment and locations for payphones and then
sells the equipment and location (the “COCOT Inter-
est”) to independent marketing organizations (the “Dis-
tributors”). These Distributors, in turn, sell COCOT
Interests, among other products, to individuals and
others who want to own a COCOT Interest (the
“COCOT Owners”). The primary Distributors include:
B. E. E. Communications (now known as BCI), located in
Cartersville, Georgia; Hayes Communications, located
in St. Petersburg, Florida; and National Communi-
cations, located in Boca Raton, Florida. I have no
ownership or control over any of these Distributors.
11.
ETS has no knowledge about the identity of persons
who may be offered purchase opportunities by the
Distributors for COC OT Interests or other products.
When the Distributors sell the COC Os, the Distribu-
tors provide their own information packages describing
the owner’s options for operating the COCOT. These
options might include, for instance, operating the phone
themselves; placing the phone with a management
company; or leasing the COCOT Interest to a payphone
operator, including, but not necessarily limited to, ETS.
There are numerous other companies that provide pay-
phone management services, including one larger than
ETS and several others that service more than 10,000
payphones.
247
12.
Before 2000, Distributors were not allowed to make
any representation on behalf of ETS or its programs
but instead directed the COCOT Owner as how to ob-
tain additional information from ETS. Once contacted
by a COCOT Owner, ETS would then handle all paper-
work and negotiations with any COCOT Owner inter-
ested in a relationship with ETS. Beginning in 2000, in
those states where the Distributors were registered
under Business Opportunity laws, the Distributor was
allowed to provide ETS materials t
— al als to an interested
13.
PSA uses three methods of acquirin hones f
sale to Distributors: (1) the —— — rd
operating locations from existing owners; (2) the pur-
chase of payphone components from equipment whole-
salers, which PSA then assembles into complete units;
and (3) the purchase of complete payphones from
manufacturers. The first method is the most common.
In substantially all cases, either the complete payphone
or at least the basic electronic components are products
of one of three manufacturers: El
. cotel, Protel or
14.
During 1999 and 1998, approximately 90% and 70%,
respectively, of the payphones acquired by PSA were
acquired in locations from existing owners, with the
: 248
remainder of 10% or 30%, respectively, being purchased
from either manufacturers or equipment wholesalers.
15.
Although each purchase of a payphone already
situated in a specific location is individually negotiated
with the seller, the following are general principals
used in valuation when PSA purchases payphones in
existing locations:
a. PSA determines all sources of revenue which
6.
includes coin, long distance, dial-a-round (800
numbers), intra-Lata (local areas prescribed
by the local phone company), credit card calls,
1-800 collect calls, advertising, etc.
PSA subtracts certain costs such as the
phone line plus the payments to the location
owner, taxes and any local license fees. PSA
considers the monthly revenue less such costs
to be the “gross net.”
PSA pays for the typical payphone already
“situated in a specific location approximately
30 times the monthly gross net, although
multiples have ranged generally from 24 to 36
times the gross net, based on terms of the
location lease, the number of units involved in
the purchase, the desirability to PSA of par-
ticular locations, the age and condition of the
equipment (which can vary the value by plus
or minus 5%), and other factors.
16.
PSA’s acquisition program depends on market condi-
tions and transactions available at the time, but the
249
following is a general description of the economics
based on recent conditions:
a. Before September 1999, the avera
, ge price
paid by PSA for a payphone in location was
approximately $3,787 and that cost has not
materially changed;
b. After a phone route is purchased, PSA either
upgrades or totally replaces the payphone
equipment for an additional average cost of
approximately $1,200 per phone, resulting in
an overall cost of approximately $4,987 per
phone in location purchased;
e. In addition, approximately 20% of the pay-
phones acquired existing locations will need
to be moved to a new location, resulting in a
further approximate $1,200 cost for the uni
that are moved. **
17.
When PSA installs a payphone at a new location. i
generally incurs the following costs: —
EQUIPMENT COST
Smart Phone-average (current range $1,000*
is approximately $930 to $1,100) ö
Enclosure and Pedestal 350
Mast Pole and Signs 75
Misc. (Bolts, Wires, etc.) 25
Signing Bonus paid to location 400
owner-average
(current range is approximately $50
to $1,500)
250
Payment to the locator-average 300**
(current range is approximately $150
to $400)
Concrete Pad —
Labor
TOTAL $2,750
from
* Assumes payphone is newly purchased
manufacturer or wholesaler; if purchased in loca.
tion, total eost approximates $5,000, as described
above, and some of the foregoing costs are
avoided.
** Most locators are independent contractors (not
affiliated with Distributors). Some are employees
of PSA.
18.
Approximately 30% of all new installations will not
develop sufficient revenue to meet expenses, requiring
a relocation of the phone to another new location, re-
sulting in an additional cost of approximately $1,200 per
phone.
19.
i ion for
PSA normally must support each new installation
approximately six months before it becomes profitable.
20.
! i he
As a result of the above-described factors, t
average total cost of a newly installed phone to reach
break-even is estimated at close to the same as the
overall amount which is expended when phones already
situated in a specific location are purchased.
251
21.
Initially, ETS sold payphones for $3,600 to the Dis-
tributor, with a suggested resale price of $4,500. Over
the years the price has increased. Most recently, PSA
typically sold payphones to Distributors for $5,250, with
a suggested resale price from the Distributor to the
Purchaser of $7,000, although PSA does not participate
in that transaction.
22.
Once a payphone is purchased by PSA from a
manufacturer or wholesaler, PSA must perform the
following to each payphone before it can be placed in
service, adding to the payphone’s value: (1) find a
location for the unit; (2) negotiate and document appro-
priate arrangements with the location owner; (3) pay
commissions to the locator; (4) order, purchase and
install the payphone and ancillary equipment; (5) if
necessary, make the front end payment to the location
owner; (6) program and set the internal parameters of
the payphone; (7) contract with the long distance
carrier; (8) order a payphone line from the local carrier;
(9) test the units; (10) obtain any necessary licenses
from regulatory bodies; and (11) create appropriate re-
cords and controls.
ETS MANAGEMENT OPTIONS
FOR PAY TELEPHONES SOLD BY DISTRIBUTORS
23.
When a Distributor attempts to sell payphones, the
Distributor, among other options, presents the avail-
ability of the ETS management options to the prospec-
tive COCOT Owner, and advises the prospective
COCOT Owner how to obtain additional information
252
from ETS. Where permitted by Business Opportunity
Law, the Distributor may present the ETS disclosure
document.
24.
If a COCOT Owner thereafter initiated contact with
ETS, ETS then provided the COCOT Owner with
information regarding the three options available for
management/lease of the payphone.
25.
The sale of the payphone by the Distributor to the
COCOT Owner did not employ high- pressure sales
tactics. The purchase agreements used by the Distribu-
tors generally provided for a fifteen (15) day can-
cellation period at the election of the COCOT Owner.
26.
Moreover, in a typical transaction, a period of time
(from several days to up to several weeks) passed be-
fore the COCOT Owner receives any written informa-
tion about the services offered by ETS, including the
Payphone Program involving the lease and option to
sell arrangements. Once the COCOT Owner received
the information from ETS, he or she was free to con-
sider it in consultation with any other person, including
attorneys, accountants, or other financial advisers. In
fact, the materials prepared by and delivered to
COCOT Owners by ETS specifically encouraged
COCOT Owners to “read all of the lease carefully, and
take time to decide if it is right for you. If possible,
show your lease to an advisor (i.e., a lawyer CPA, etc.).
253
27.
The materials provided by ETS to COCOT Owners
upon their request presented three options for pay-
phone management.
28.
Under Option I, the “Internal Maintenance Pro-
gram,” the COCOT Owner engages ETS to perform
certain installation, maintenance and management
services for the COCOT Owner’s phone. Under this
option, ETS does not find locations for operation of the
payphones, secure agreements with the locations’
owners, or collect the revenue generated therefrom.
The standard fixed fee for these ETS services is ap-
proximately $45 to $65 per month per COCOT, depend-
ing on the location.
29.
Under Option II, the “Turnkey Maintenance Pro
gram,” PSA obtains a site location for each of the
COCOT Owner’s payphones, and ETS performs a more
comprehensive range of services for the COCOT
Owner, including collection, counting, bagging and de-
positing all coins. ETS’s fixed fee for this service is
approximately $75 per month per payphone. Under this
option, the owner retains all revenues from the pay-
phone.
30.
Under Option III, the “Payphone Equipment Lease
Option” (the “Lease Program”), the COCOT Owner
leases the COCOT to ETS and ETS assumes full re-
sponsibility for all aspects of their placement, main-
_tenance, operation, etc. The location for each payphone
is selected by computer from a general database of
locations.
254
31.
Under the most recent Lease Program, ETS pays the
COCOT Owners a fixed rental rate of $82 per month
per payphone, and ETS retains all revenues generated
by the leased payphone. Certain other COCOT Owners
receive a fixed rental rate of either $75 or $80 per
month per payphone. The monthly rate varied depend-
ing on when the COCOT Owners entered into the ETS
Lease Program. The rental payments increased with
regard to the retail price of the phone (e.g., COCOT
Owners received either $75 or $82 per month per pay-
phone, respectively, compared to the then retail value
of the payphones of either $4,500 or $7,000). The
COCOT Owner has no benefit or risk relating to the
profitability or performance of the COCOTs, but re-
ceives only a fixed net monthly rental from ETS.
32.
The vast majority of COCOT Owners who do busi-
ness with ETS do so under the Lease Program, with
the option to sell the payphone to ETS (collectively, the
“Payphone Program”).
DETAILS OF THE PAYPHONE PROGRAM
33.
Under the Payphone Program, in effect for all leases
entered into prior to February, 2000, ETS gives the
COCOT Owner an option to sell the payphone to ETS
prior to or upon expiration of the lease term for a fixed
price equal to the original price per payphone, with no
penalties for early termination of the lease. A true and
correct copy of an ETS Equipment Lease Agreement
entered into prior to February, 2000, is attached hereto
as Exhibit 2.
255
34.
Specifically, under the Payphone Program, in effect
for all leases entered into subsequent to February,
2000, ETS gives the COCOT Owner an option to sell
the payphone to ETS prior to or upon expiration of the
lease term for a fixed price as follows:
a. At any time between the nineteenth month of
the lease term and prior to the completion of
the sixtieth month of the lease term, for the
purchase price (currently $7,000) less the
monthly rental times twelve;
b. Subsequent to the completion of the sixtieth
month of the lease term for the purchase price
(currently $7,000).
35.
A true and correct copy of an ETS Equipment Lease
Agreement entered into after February, 2000, is
attached hereto as Exhibit 3. This change was made
because we discovered that some of the Distributors’
agents were encouraging COCOT owners to sell their
phones and buy new ones merely to generate sales
commissions.
36.
Upon termination of the lease under Option III, the
COCOT Owner may renew its lease with ETS, cause
ETS to purchase the payphone, or take control of the
payphone with the possibility of selling the payphone,
leasing it to, or entering into a management agreement
with another operating company, or self-managing the
payphone.
256
37.
ETS has always attempted to provide potential
COCOT Owners with sufficient information about ETS
and its officers to ensure they make an informed
decision. For example, attached hereto as Exhibit 4 is a
true and correct copy of disclosure documents provided
by a registered Business Opportunity Distributor to
COCOT Owners, which contains the disclosure docu-
ments provided by and regarding ETS, compiled by
ETS in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission
disclosure regulation rules.
RELIANCE ON ADVICE OF PROFESSIONALS AND
SEC STAFF SUGGESTIONS
38.
ETS started the Lease Program in 1994. ETS ex-
pended considerable resources engaging various attor-
neys to provide not only guidance on the structuring of
the debt-financing of the Lease Program, but the con-
tinued operations of ETS. ETS began, and maintained,
its Lease Program with the understanding that it was
not involved in the sale of a “security.” Attached as
Exhibit 5 is a copy of a 1996 opinion of counsel.
Attached as Exhibit 6 is a 1998 opinion of counsel. Each
of these counsel advised ETS that the Payphone Pro-
gram sales do not constitute the offer or sale of securi-
ties. In 1997, I learned that the Sixth Circuit Court
decided a case that ruled that pay phones utilized in a
sale, lease-back, buy-back program did not involve the
sale of securities. I read the Court’s opinion and relied
on what it said as stating the law. I had no reason to
believe that these opinions of counsel and this Court
opinion were inaccurate in any way or a misstatement
of the law.
257
39.
I also relied, in part, on discussions with attorneys
and a draft opinion letter from, the law firm of Powell,
Goldstein, Frazer & Murphy LLP (“Powell Goldstein”).
A copy of the draft opinion letter dated July 30, 1999, is
attached as Exhibit 7. Powell Goldstein similarly ad-
vised ETS that the Payphone Program sales do not
constitute the offer or sale of securities.
40.
My understanding that the Payphone Program sales
do not constitute the offer or sale of securities was also
based, in part, on the recommendations regarding the
corporate structure of ETS’s operations received dur-
ing meetings with the SEC Staff in Atlanta in 1995. In
1995, the SEC Staff of the Atlanta office performed
what was explained to me as an “informal investiga-
tion” of ETS and its operations. As part of this inves-
tigation, I met, along with Sheldon Friedman, an attor-
ney engaged on behalf of ETS, with an SEC lawyer
Larry Grant. I explained to Mr. Grant, as I explained
to the SEC during my later testimony in March 2000
that I — been willing to undertake all actions
necessary to ensure that ETS was operating pr
and in accordance with all applicable — 9
41.
In addition, I showed to Mr. Grant the then-current
financial statements of ETS.
42.
At the time of my meetings with Mr. Grant in 1995,
ETS and the predecessor to PSA, Inter-Net, were
directly involved in both the marketing and leasing
258
aspects of the business. During the course of these
meetings with Mr. Grant, Mr. Grant recommended to
me that ETS divest itself from the direct marketing
and/or leasing aspects of the business and that ETS
give more control over the payphones to the COCOT
Owners.
43.
As a result of, and relying on, the recommendations
received from Mr. Grant, I initiated the restructuring of
the business operations of ETS and assisted in the start
up of certain Distributors to ensure that ETS was re-
moved from the direct marketing of the Lease Pro-
gram. In addition, in order to provide the COCOT
Owners with more control, I initiated the implementa-
tion of the liquidation option for owners to be enable
them to sell their payphone(s) to ETS during or at the
conclusion of their payphone lease terms.
14.
Following the 1995 “investigation” of ETS, I did not
hear from the SEC again until 2000—some 5 years after
their initial investigation.
45.
My understanding that ETS was not involved in the
sale of “securities” was further reinforced from the re-
view of opinion letters received from Phoenix Telecom,
LLC (“Phoenix”), a corporation discussed further be-
low, regarding this exact issue. Attached as composite
Exhibit 8, are examples of opinion letters received by
Phoenix regarding the propriety of its operations.
259
46.
My understanding that the Payphone Program sales
did not constitute the offer or sale of securities was re-
inforced by the decision of the state securities regula-
tors in Massachusetts, which found that the ETS Pay-
phone Program sales were not securities. “Memoran-
dum of Decision and Order,” Securities Division of the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts, In the Matter of
Frances A. Rahaim Financial Services, No. E-2000-22,
Securities Division, Office of the Secretary of the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts (July 11, 2000). A
copy of this decision and order is attached as Exhibit 9.
GAAP VS. NON-GAAP FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING
CONVENTIONS
47.
ETS does not employ accounting conventions known
as “Generally Accepted Accounting Principals”
(“GAAP”) because it is not required to do so and
because ETS management believes that non-GAAP
financial statements more appropriately measure the
company’s financial performance.
48.
Accordingly, ETS prepared and maintained financial
information (including income Statements) in non-
GAAP format. As part of its normal accounting prac-
tices, ETS did finalize its year-end statements of
financial information, including income statements, in
that format. The ETS “Statement of Income for the
Twelve Months Ending December 31, 1999,” attached
as page 2 of Exhibit 3 to the Affidavit of Robert Lough
(filed by the SEC in support of its Application for Pre-
liminary Injunction, Asset Freeze, and Other Equitable
260
Relief) is a preliminary, draft Statement of Income.
Attached as Exhibit 10 to this Declaration is a true and
accurate copy of the final version of the ETS “State-
ment of Income for the Twelve Months Ending Decem-
ber 31, 1999.”
49.
There are significant differences between the finan-
cial statements conforming to GAAP and those which
are not prepared in accordance with GAAP, which are
discussed below.
50.
Under GAAP, the financial statements treat the
leased payphones as assets of the company, being
acquired by it under a financing arrangement, although
the COCOT Owners hold legal title to their payphones
and may never elect to sell them to the Company. The
payments made by the company under lease agree-
ments are treated as interest expenses and the underly-
ing leases are treated as capital leases.
51. :
In the GAAP financial statements, the company’s
liabilities include $164.4 million that would become due
to the COCOT Owners if all of them exercised their sale
options. If a COCOT Owner exercises the sale option,
the amount paid by the company is recorded as a
reduction in the liability.
52.
In addition, the GAAP financials value the company’s
payphones at their historic cost, less depreciation. The
company believes that the current fair market value,
for which many of the payphones could be liquidated
promptly, exceeds their carrying value on the GAAP
261
statements. Thus, this unrealized appreciation i
’ preciation is not
reflected in the GAAP financial statements.
53.
. In contrast, under non-GAAP accounting conven-
tions, the payphones leased by the company are treated
as assets of the COCOT Owners and not the company.
Therefore, the Company does not treat depreciation-of
the payphones as a company expense and does not
claim a tax deduction for such depreciation on its tax
return. The COCOT Owners get that tax benefit.
54.
Under non-GAAP accounting standards, the -
ments made by the company under the lease —ä——
ments are treated as rental expense in the financial
statements and the underlying leases are treated as
operating leases. If a COCOT Owner exercises the sale
option, the amount paid by the company is recorded as
an expense in the company’s results of operations when
paid and the payphone becomes a company asset.
55.
Importantly, under non-GAAP accounting methods
revenues from the sale of payphones are recognized in
the company’s results of operations when
have been received from the Distributor. ä
56.
The resulting differences in treatment in financial
statements prepared under GAAP versus non-GAAP
are that in 1999 (for example), under GAAP, the com-
pany incurred a $26.8 million loss whereas under non-
GAAP, the company showed net income of $8.7 million.
The principal reason for these differences is the treat-
262
ment of the revenue from Payphone Program sales
(decreasing revenue from that stated in non-GAAP
financial statements by $118.7 million) and the sale
option given to COCOT Owners (increasing liabilities
from that stated in non-GAAP financial statements by
$164.4 million).
57.
Accordingly, assuming that any statements were
made (and are properly attributed to ETS or to me
personally) that the financial condition of ETS was
positive, these statements were neither inaccurate nor
misleading given that ETS was an operating company
that did not Keep records in accordance with GAAP
accounting conventions, and paid taxes and monitored
performance on that basis.
58.
The SEC has pointed to an ETS brochure that ad-
dresses how payphones can be profitable. The descrip-
tion in the brochure is of a single payphone. It does not
address and was not intended to describe the profitabil-
ity of a payphone management such as ETS.
59.
The SEC has repeatedly used the term “Ponzi
scheme” to describe ETS’s business. As has been
explained to me, a Ponzi scheme is a scheme in which
there is no real business and newly invested money is
used merely to pay off old investors and convince them
that they are “earning profits rather than losing their
shirts.” The ETS payphone business is not a Ponzi
scheme. ETS and PSA used revenues raised by the
sale of payphones to purchase phones and locations and
ETS expected that its revenues from the operation of
263
the payphones would increase over time until ETS no
longer needed to utilize revenues from individual pay-
phone sales to support its other operations.
THE PHOENIX ACQUISITION
60.
On or about July 17, 2000, ETS Management Ser-
vices, LLC (“ETS Management”), a wholly owned sub-
sidiary of ETS, acquired the payphone business of
Phoenix Telecom, LLC (“Phoenix”) by entering into an
asset purchase agreement and a management services
agreement with Phoenix. Attached are true and
correct copies of the asset purchase and management
services agreements as Exhibits 11 and 12 respectively.
61.
The impetus for the ETS/Phoenix transaction was to
provide some protection for the Phoenix lessors con-
cerning their executory lease agreements with Phoenix
and which would in no way assure the Phoenix lessors’
ability to enter a new lease with ETS. ETS’s motiva-
tion for the transaction was also to avoid, or at least, to
minimize, any negative impact on the public communi-
cations industry which could have resulted in a cata-
clysmic failure of the independent payphone provider
network. In addition, ETS management, including me,
believed that an expanded network would enhance
ETS's possibilities for growth and prosperity pursuant
to its business model.
62.
Under the management agreement, Phoenix’s pay-
phones were to remain operational and in compliance
with state and federal utility regulatory requirements
264
during implementation of the ETS/Phoenix business
transactions. Pursuant to the terms of the management
agreement, ETS Management was to manage the day-
to-day operations of the Phoenix payphones until new
leases with ETS could be executed or alternative
instructions obtained from Phoenix lessors.
63.
Pursuant to the asset purchase agreement, ETS
Management acquired Phoenix’s assets, identified in
particular on the schedules attached thereto. In addi-
tion, ETS Management assumed certain liabilities of
Phoenix and agreed to assign payphones to all Phoenix
lessors who had yet to be assigned a payphone.
64.
Importantly, ETS agreed to offer Phoenix lessors the
opportunity to enter into the ETS Lease Program with
lease payments by ETS commencing July 1, 2000, the
date on which Phoenix began missing lease payments.
If all Phoenix lessors were to execute an ETS lease,
ETS would have paid $1,080,000 in July lease payments
as consideration for the assets acquired. ETS has paid
more than $2,800,000 in lease payments to former
Phoenix lessors.
65.
Prior to the acquisition of Phoenix by ETS, from
approximately 1997 to December 1999, I personally
acted as a consultant to Phoenix. As compensation for
my role as a consultant to Phoenix, Phoenix agreed to
pay me personally (and not ETS or any other corporate
entity) $100 for every payphone lease agreement
entered into by Phoenix. In fact, I received only about
265
one-half of the compensation promised by Phoenix for
my consultation services.
PAYMENTS AND LOANS MADE BY ETS
\ 66.
The SEC has alleged that I have personally taken “at
least $14 million out of ETS through loans and fees paid
to companies controlled by” me (Complaint, 1 49),
which figure allegedly includes transfers in the form of
loans of more than $11,600,000 to affiliates (SEC Brief,
p. 9) and management fees on Payphone Program sales
in excess of $3 million (SEC Brief, p. 9). In fact, there
were funds loaned to Twinleaf by PSA, which, as of
September 30, 2000, amounted to approximately $7.4
million.
67.
The SEC implies that these fees and loans were
illegal or for the purpose of funneling the COCOT
Owners’ funds to me personally. These contentions are
absolutely untrue. The loans made and management
fees paid by ETS and PSA to various companies affili-
ated with ETS and/or controlled by me were accounted
for in the records of the companies and were for
legitimate business reasons, in the most part to support
ETS’s operations.
68.
For example, PSA did not perform the administra-
tive function associated with payphone sales cash man-
agement. These functions were provided by Twinleaf.
Twinleaf maintains computers, office equipment, docu-
ment storage facilities and employs data entry per-
sonnel and accounting clerks, who perform the function
266
for PSA. Twinleaf also monitors lease payments to
COCOT Owners. In addition, Twin Leaf provided the
administrative, managerial, and consultation services of
myself, Joel Geer and Joan Shepler, among others, with
regard to PSA acquisitions, legal services, and other
issues involved in the Payphone Programs, which ser-
vices were rendered for the benefit of ETS and PSA.
69.
In return for performing these administrative and
consulting services, since January 1, 1999, ETS/PSA
has paid Twin Leaf a one-time management fee of $250
for each payphone sold by PSA (the fee was $125 per
phone prior to that time).
70.
This one-time management fee represented the only
managerial fee paid for the indefinite duration of the
ownership of the payphone by a COCOT Owner.
71.
Each of these loans is properly reflected on the books
and records of PSA and the companies receiving the
loan. Given PSA’s bankruptcy proceeding discussed in
more detail herein, the loans are now assets of PSA,
which are governed and protected by the bankruptcy
court.
72.
I have submitted a stipulation on behalf of myself and
Twinleaf to the Bankruptcy Court to liquidate the loans
to Twinleaf in that forum. A copy will be provided to
the Court.
267
THE BANKRUPTCY FILING OF ETS AND PSA
73.
The advent of and explosive growth in the use of both
cellular telephones and the “1-800-Dial-Around” market
has had a dramatic impact on ETS’s business over the
last two years. I estimate that the introduction of these
enterprises into the market has reduced the profitabil-
ity of individual payphones by as much as 25% or more.
The introduction of the various companies by Twinleaf
to support ETS was designed to offset these revenue
losses.
74.
Despite the best efforts of ETS and PSA, as a result
of these factors described above and other factors not
within the control of ETS and PSA management, in-
cluding independent market forces and the cost of
certain litigation in New York over a claim to an
ownership interest in ETS (not involving and unrelated
to COCOT Owners), the business of ETS and PSA has
experienced a significant downturn.
75.
On September 11, 2000, ETS and PSA filed for the
protection of the Federal Bankruptcy Court in Dela-
ware under Chapter 11 of Title 11 of the U.S. Code.
76.
I understand that a Creditors’ Committee has been
appointed by the Court and that ETS and PSA have
met with the Creditors’ Committee to discuss the
status of the case and the plan for emerging from bank-
ruptey. ETS and PSA are working with the Creditors’
Committee to develop a plan of reorganization.
268
THE PHOENIX ORDER
77.
On Monday, August 14, 2000, the Honorable Judge
Jack T. Camp, United States District Judge, entered an
Order in the case of SEC v. Phoenix Telecom, LLC,
Civil Action File No. 1:00-CV-1970-JTC (N.D. Georgia).
The Court found, among other things, that the
payphone program sales of Phoenix Telecom were
securities and entered a preliminary injunction and
other relief sought by the SEC.
78.
Because ETS is engaged in a similar business using a
similar business model (sale/lease/purchase options of
payphones) and the order had obvious impact on ETS's
opinions of counsel that its Payphone Program did not
involve the offer or sale of securities, ETS voluntarily
ceased all Payphone Program sales. This voluntary
cessation of sales remains in effect pending a decision in
the case filed by the SEC against ETS and me also in
the Northern District of Georgia.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing
is true and correct.
Executed this 1] day of October, 2000.
/s/ CHARLES E. EDWARDS
CHARLES E. EDWARDS
Payphones, Inc., a 1
— — LESSEE”) and THOMASINA MARSELLA
Exhibit A, attached hereto and by reference made 0
— — —.— rr
| terms and subject to the conditions hereinafter set forth.
parties hereto, intending to be legally bound, hereby agree as follows: oes
l.
269
Telephone Equipment Lease Agreement
Lease Number: 10423
*
1
HIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into this Sch day of December, 1999, by and between ETS
Witnesseth:
WHEREAS, LESSOR, as owner of three (3) unit(s) of the telephone EQUIPMENT described on
EQUIPMENT from LESSOR, all upon the
NOW, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the mutual promises and covenants herein contained
hereby acknowledged, the
LEASE OF EQUIPMENT. Subject to the conditions herein, LESSOR hereby QUIPMENT
to LESSEE and LESSEE hereby leases the BOUIPMENT (— ee
TERM. This
lease shall commence (the “Commencement Date”) as of the date provided above and shall
remain in full force and effect for an Initial Term of si
— —— et * sixty (60) months thereafter (the “Initial Term”).
Renewal Team of sixty (60) months (the —
RENT. LESSEE shall pay monthi :
y rental to LESSOR for the EQUIPMENT at the rate
month per unit. The first monthly rental payment shall be due on the —— ae
— monthly rental payments shall be due on the Ist or 15th day of each succeeding calendar
month accordance with the “Commencement Date” through the Term hereof.
Note: LESSOR Rental checks shall be sent out
U.S. Mail and shall be
— — by sent on the Ist or 1 Sth day of
— . N the Ist or 15th of the month fall on a Saturday or Sunday, the checks
denen nis Agreement creates a lease of the EQUIPMENT. Nothing contained herein shal] be
deemed or construed as enabling LESSEE to acquire the right, title or interest in the EQUIPMENT or
LOCATION, except as set forth in Sections 15 and 16 hereof. *
NET LEASE. Except as i i i
Ghat tha in a Na . . e herein, the parties hereto expressly agree to and
d
Ge a
270
LOCATION. LESSEE may, at LESSEE’s expense, contract with parties to provide such
service and maintenance.
LOCATION. The location of the EQUIPMENT shall be set forth on Exhibit A. LESSEE shall be
responsible for selecting the location for installation of the EQUIPMENT. Lessee has the right and
sole authority to move EQUIPMENT to a new location should the original location prove to be
unprofitable or prove to be in a high vandalism area LESSOR will be notified in the event of site
exchange and will receive notification of the address of the new location. LESSEE shall assign the
applicable location lease to the LESSOR by a written letter of assignment between the parties. In the
event that LESSOR terminates the lease prior to the expiration of the Term and elects to retain the
EQUIPMENT, LESSEE shall assign the applicable location Jease to the LESSOR by a written letter of
assignment between the parties; otherwise LESSEE shall retain the rights to the location.
INDEMNIFICATION AND INSURANCE.
a LESSEE shall indemnify and hold LESSOR harmiess from and against any and all loss, damage,
liability and expense (including, without limitation, reasonable attorney’s fees) which LESSOR
shall sustain as a result of (i) the loss of or damage to the EQUIPMENT because of fire, theft.
collision, lightning, flood, windstorm, or any other casualty at any time during the Term hereof, or ö
(ii) the death of or injury to any person or damage to any property as a result, in whole or in part, of
the use or maintenance of the EQUIPMENT at any time during the Term of this Lease.
d. LESSEE’s obligations pursuant to Section 7a above shall be deemed satisfied if LESSEE obtains
and maintains in full force and effect throughout the Term hereof, at the sole cost and expense of
- LESSEE, a policy or policies of insurance issued by an insurer reasonably satisfactory to LESSOR,
7a{i) hereof with minimum coverage of $100,000 for property damage (55 2,000 for the death of or
injury to any one person) end $2,000,000 for any one accident or occurrence.
c. LESSEE’s failure to obtain the insurance coverage specified in Section 7b hereof shall not affect
LESSEE’s obligations under this lease. The loss of, damage to or destruction of the EQUIPMENT
shall not terminate this Lease; nor to the extent that LESSOR is actually compensated by insurance
paid for by LESSEE, as herein provided, relieve LESSEE from LESSEE’: liability hereunder.
Should LESSEE fail to so procure or maintain the insurance required under this Section 7, then
LESSOR shall have the option, but not the obligation, to procure or maintain such insurance
coverage for the account of LESSEE, and in that event, LESSEE shal] reimburse LESSOR within
seven (7) days after receipt of any invoice for any payment made therefore by LESSOR. Failure to
so reimburse LESSOR shall be deemed a default under the terms of Section 10 hereof.
TAXES AND OTHER CHARGES. LESSEE shall pay, when due, any and all use taxes, personal
property taxes and any and all other taxes which may be imposed by the ownership, possession, use or
operation of the EQUIPMENT at any time during the Term hereof or which are levied against or
measured by the gross receipts delivered to LESSOR as a result of the payment of rent by LESSEE
hereunder.
USE, OPERATION, ALTERATIONS AND ADDITIONS. The EQUIPMENT shail at all
tumes during the Term hereof be under the sole and absolute control of LESSEE, subject to the
271
TRE — , and shall
solely responsible for the payment of any and all fines or penalties resulting from its failure to comply
therewith. LESSEE shall maintain the EQUIPMENT in good working order at the location identified
on Exhibit A, attached hereto, at all times throughout the Term hereof or at any other location where
the EQUIPMENT may have been relocated. LESSEE may from time to time add further parts or
accessories to the EQUIPMENT, provided any such addition does not materially affect or materially
impair the value of the EQUIPMENT. Any such additions shall become the property of the LESSOR.
0. DEFAULT AND REMEDIES
a. DEFAULT. The occurrence of any one of the following events shall constitute an event of default
by LESSEE:
1. A default by LESSEE in the payment of any amount due hereunder as and when the same
shall become due and the continuance of such default for a period of more than twenty (20)
days following LESSEE’s receipt of written notice of such default requiring the same to be
cured; or °
2. A default by LESSEE in the performance of any of its material obligations under this Lease
and the continuance of such default for a period of more than thirty (30) days following
LESSEE’s receipt of written notice of such default requiring the same to be cured; provided,
however, that if more than thirty (30) days are reasonably required in order to cure any such
default, then no default shall be deemed to have occurred so long as the curing of such default
is commenced by LESSEE within such thirty (30) day period and LESSEE thereafter
diligently prosecutes the curing of such default to completion; or
3. Whenever an involuntary petition shall be filed against LESSEE under any bankruptty or
insolvency law or under the reorganization provisions of any law or like import, or a receiver
of LESSEE of or for the property of LESSEE shail be appointed without the acquiescence of
LESSEE and such situation under this section 10a-3 shall continue and remain undischarged
or unstayed for an aggregate period of thirty (30) days (whether or not consecutive) or shall
not be remedied by LESSEE within thirty (30) days; or
4. Whenever LESSEE shall make an assignment of the property of LESSEE for the benefit of
creditors, shall file a voluntary petition under any bankruptcy or insolvency law, or whenever
any court of competent jurisdiction shall approve a petition filed by LESSEE under the
reorganization provisions of the United States Bankruptcy Act or under the provisions of any
law or like import; or
3. The abandonment of the EQUIPMENT by LESSEE or the discontinuance of the operation of
such EQUIPMENT by LESSEE; or
6. The failure to notify LESSOR of any relocation within sixty (60) days; or
7. The failure of LESSEE to remove within thirty (30) days any mechanics liens on the
EQUIPMENT for additional work performed on such EQUIPMENT.
rights of LESSOR in the event of a default by LESSEE as provided herein. LESSEE shall comply .
eco rag ooo
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
272
—
. REMEDIES. Upon the occurrence of an event of default under )
° continuing and remains uncured, then LESSOR may, at its option, during the continuance of .
event of default:
1. Terminate this lease by written notice to LESSEE and recover ;
incurred by reason of such default, including the reasonable —
EQUIPMENT and reasonable attorney's fees relating thereto, in which event
immediately surrender the EQUIPMENT to LESSOR, and if LESSEE fails to do so, LESSOR
may take possession of the EQUIPMENT; and in that event, any rights to the EQUIPMENT
that LESSEE may possess pursuant to this lease shall automatically terminate, LESSEE
shall have no further right to use of the EQUIPMENT; LESSOR may, without demand or
legal process, retake and retain the EQUIPMENT; all rights of LESSEE in and to the
location of the installed EQUIPMENT shall be deemed automatically assigned to LESSOR:
and LESSEE shall have no further rights to such location whether such rights existed during
the Term hereof or arose or were to arise following termination or expiration hereof, or
N EQUIPMENT and thereupon ̃ EQUIPMENT, as LESSEE'sagentra the bes price
obtainable by reasonable efforts, and in such event, LESSEE shall be liable to LESSOR §
any deficiency between (i) the amount of rental due hereunder plus the reasonable *
LESSOR of recovering and reletting the BQUIPMENT, including reasonable attorney
, — . nation of this lease,
SURRENDER. Except as set forth herein, upon the expiration or earlier termination | le
LESSEE shall return the EQUIPMENT and LOCATION to LESSOR in good operating condiuon,
normal wear and tear excepted. :
RIGHT OF INSPECTION. LESSOR shall have the right at all times throughout the Term hereof to
inspect the EQUIPMENT whenever and wherever the same shall be located.
ARRANTIES AND CLAIMS THEREUNDER. LESSOR makes no warranty or representation,
cxpressed or implied, with respect tothe EQUIPMENT; provided, however, that the EQUIPMENT
shall be subject to any standard warranty of the manufacturers of such EQUIPMENT or componsats
thereof. LESSOR hereby appoints LESSEE as its agent and attomey-in-fact throughout —
hereof to assert and enforce, at LESSEE’s sole expense, any claims LESSOR may have as owner
EQUIPMENT against any vendor, manufacturer or supplier with respect thereto.
IGNMENT. LESSEE shall have the right to assign or sell any of its rights hereunder. LESSOR
shall have the right to sell or assign its rights hereunder, incoding any o all of LESSOR’s right, se
and interest in and to the EQUIPMENT and location and the rent reserved herein. In the event
assignment by LESSOR, the assignee thereof shall thereupon acquire all rights and remedies n
by or available to LESSOR. Upon receiving proper notice of any such assignment, LESSEE
‘thereafter make any and all rental payments as therein directed.
i from a third party for the
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL . In the event LESSOR obtains an offer
purchase of the EQUIPMENT, then LESSOR shall thereupon provide LESSEE with written notic: ©
its receipt of such notice in which to give written notice to LESSOR of its election to purchase & 7
EQUIPMENT upon the same terms and conditions as the third-party offer. If LESSOR . A
i=
—— — aa aa
8
5
273
— written netics — EO within — — period, then
LESSOR shall be free to sell the EQUIPMENT pursuant to such third-party offer. Should LESSEE
notify LESSOR of its election to purchase, then LESSEE shall have one hundred eighty (180)days to
close sale from the date of the original notice.
OPTION TO SELL AGREEMENT. Should LESSOR choose to sell the equipment to the
LESSEE prior to or upon the end of the Term of the Lease, then LESSOR shall execute the Option To
Sell Agreement attached hereto and by reference made a part hereof as Exhibit B. The terms and
conditions of the Option to Sell Agreement shall govern the purchase by the LESSEE of the
EQUIPMENT. LESSEE shal} have one hundred eighty (180) days from the date of receipt of the
Original written notice to purchase said EQUIPMENT. ,
17. PERSONAL PROPERTY: The EQUIPMENT is and at all times throughout the Term hereof
shall remain personal property, even if all or any portion of the EQUIPMENT becomes affixed or
attached in any matter whatsoever to any real property. A
18. ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF DISCRETION. LESSOR represents and warrants that (a) LESSOR is
free to enter into agreements with parties other than LESSEE for the economic exploitation of the
EQUIPMENT; (b) LESSOR was not required to enter into this lease as a condition to purchasing the
EQUIPMENT, and (c) LESSOR has freely and voluntarily entered into this lease and acknowledges
that LESSOR is not entering into or executing this lease in reliance upon any promise, representation or
warranty not contained herein.
19. NOTICES. Any and all notices required or permitted hereunder shall be notarized in writing and sent to
the intended recipient, addressed to its address set forth below, either by registered or certified mail,
return receipt requested, postage prepaid, overnite delivery service, or personal delivery. Each such
notarized notice shall be effective (a) if given by mail, as of three (3) business days after such notice or
communication is deposited in the United States Mail; (b); if sent for overnite delivery via Federal
Express or other reputable national overnite delivery service, one (1) business day after such notice or
delivery is entrusted to such service, with recipient signature required; or (c) if personally delivered,
when delivered at the address of the intended recipient. Any party may change the address to which
notices or other communications hereunder are to be delivered by giving the other party notice in the
manner set forth herein. Any notice required to be made within a stated period of time shall be
considered timely mailed if deposited before midnight of the last day of the stated period.
20. GOVERNING LAW. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the
laws of the State of Georgia.
21. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE. Each party acknowledges and agrees that the other party would be
damaged irreparably in the event any of the provisions of this Agreement are not performed in
accordance with their specific terms or otherwise are breached. Accordingly, each party agrees that the
other party shall be entitled to an mjunction or injunctions to prevent breaches of the provisions of this
Agreement and to specifically enforce this Agreement and the terms and provisions hereof in any action
instituted in any court of the United States or any state thereof having jurisdiction over the parties and
the matter, in addition to any other remedy to which it may be entitled, at law or in equity.
22. DISPUTE RESOLUTION CONTRACT PROVISION.
a DISPUTE. Any dispute, controversy, or claim of whatever nature (except an interlocutory
bearing for an action for a temporary restraining order, preliminary injunction, or similar
ETS9O1 70 (04.00)
274
-- or relating to, this
Agreement or the breach hereof, shall be settled by arbitration, if requested, by any party pursuant
to this Section 21. The arbitration shall be conducted by one (I) arbitrator, who shall be appointed
pursuant to the Commercial Arbitration Rules of the American Arbitration Association (“AAA”).
The arbitration shall be held in Atlanta, Georgia, and shall be conducted in accordance with the
Commercial Arbitration Rules of the AAA, except that the rules set forth in this Section 21 shall
govern such arbitration to the extent that they conflict with the rules of the AAA.
NOTICE. Upon written notice by a party to another party of a request for arbitration hereunder,
the parties shall use their best efforts to cause the arbitration to be conducted in an expeditious
manner, with such arbitration to be completed within sixty (60) days after selection of an arbitrator.
in the arbitration, Georgia law shall govern, except to the extent those laws conflict with the
Commercial Arbitration Rules of the AAA and the provisions of this Section 21. There shall be no
discovery except as the arbitrator shall permit following determination by the arbitrator that the
party seeking such discovery has a substantial demonstrable need All other procedural matters shall
be within the discretion of the arbitrator. In the event a party fails to comply with the procedures in
any arbitration in any manner determined by the arbitrator, the arbitrator shall fix a reasonable
period of time for compliance and, if the party fails to comply within such period, a remedy deemed:
just by the arbitrator, including, without limitation, an award of default, may be imposed.
23. MISCELLANEOUS. This Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto and their heirs,
executors, administrators, successors and assigns. Wherever possible each provision of this
Agreement shall be interpreted in such a manner as to be effective and valid under applicable law,
but if any provision hereof shall be prohibited or invalid under applicable iaw, such provision shall
be ineffective to the extent of such prohibition or invalidity without invalidating the remainder of such
provision or remaining provisions of this Agreement. No delay or failure on the part of either party in
the exercise of any right or remedy hereunder shall operate as a waiver thereof, nor as an acquiescence
in any default, nor shall any single or partial exercise by either party of any right or remedy preclude
any other right or remedy. This Agreement and the documents referred to herein constitutes the entire
agreement between the parties concerning the subject matter hereof, and any other agreements or
understandings of any nature with respect to such matters are hereby superseded and revoked. This
Agreement shall not be modified or amended except in writing signed by both parties. This Agreement
may be executed and delivered in any number of counterparts, including facsimile counterparts, all of
which when executed and delivered shall have the force and effect of an original. In construing this
Agreement, feminine or neuter pronouns shall be substituted for those masculine in form and vice vers
in any place where the context so requires, and plural terms shall be substituted for singular and
singular for plural in any place where the context so requires. The headings in this Agreement are
inserted for convenience only and are not a part of the Agreement.
275
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have hereunto set their hands and seals as of the date first above
Check one [x] Individual [I Parmership [C] Corporation UO Self-Directed IRA [] Trust
U Joint Tenancy with Rights of Survivorship Q Other:
8
ee. . ee,
Title: CEO
—
Wee Metall
Title: = Individual
Address: 561 Thornton Road, Suite K Address: 10 PAOLINO STREET
Lithia Springs, GA 30122
PROVIDENCE, RI 02909
Telephone Number:
(770) 819-1600 Telephone Number: (401) 421-6438
dae: 24 (2 on)
Date: December 15, 1999
276
Lease: 10423
Date:
The equipment described herein constitutes three (3) units
01/24/00
277
THE EQUIPMENT
(Exhibit *A*)
of operating payphone stations.
Unit 1:
Unit 2:
Unit 3:
Location: BATES MARKET & DELI
Phone #:
Location:
3145 HWY 61 EAST
LUTRELL, TN 37779
423-992-9753
FRIENDLY INN #2
700 OLD FEDERAL HWY
HALLANDALE, FL 33009
954-458-9044
LAKESIDE LAUNDRY
016 W HALLANDALE BEACH BLVD
HALLANDALE, FL 33009
954-455-8912
e —
(Exhibit B to Telephone Lease Agreement)
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into as of the | Sth day of December, 1999. by and
4 . , between
THOMASINA MARSELLA (Individual) (hereinafter referred to as -L ESSO R. —
2 Georgia Corporation (hereinafter referred to as L. ESS EE N) z
THE PARTIES HERETO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS AGREEMENT INURES
BENEFIT OF LESSOR, AND THAT LESSOR RETAINS SOLE AND COMPLETE DISCRETION
IN DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT TO EXERCISE THE REQUIREMENTS
HEREINAFTER SET FORTH.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS LESSOR is the owner of three (3) unit(s) of pay telephone Equipment (the “Equipment”)
pursuant to that certain PURCHASE A ’
= — W dated Octaber 26, 1999, es veflected on invoice Number
Option To Sell AGREEMANT “S
Ser al #: 32268
Serial : 37125
Serial . 3712)
WHEREAS, LESSOR and LESSEE have entered into that certain Lease Agreement (the “Lease
Agreement”) dated December 15, 1999 bearing Lease number | ;
* 8 — — 0423, pursuant to which LESSEE has
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Lease Agreement, LESSOR is entitled to require LESSEE to purchase
Equipment prior to or upon termination of the LEASE AGREEMENT; and * *
WHEREAS, the parties have therefore determined that it would be in thei
appropriate and m theu mutual best
interests to enter into this Option to Sell Agreement in order to evidence the rights of LESSOR and te
obligations of LESSEE for the sale and purchase of said Equipment, and
— ———— eap ae ee
Lease Agreement, all of which are incorporated herein and by reference made a part hereof.
LESSOR shall give written notice to LESSEE of such requirement. LESSEE
the date of receipt of 9 1
278
ermination. . ²˙ m
termination of the Lease Agreement; or (ii) the expiration of one hundred and twenty (120) months
execution hereof.
4. Notices. All notices required or permitted hereunder shall be notarized , in writing and may be delivered
by hand, by nationally recognized private courier, or by United States mail. Notices delivered by mail
shall be deemed given three (3) business days after being deposited in the United States mail, postage
prepaid, registered or certified mail, return recerpt requested. Notarized notices delivered by hand, or by
nationally recognized private courier shal] be deemed given on the day of receipt(if such day is a business
day or, if such day is not a business day, — All notices shall be
addressed as follows
If te LESSOR: THOMASINA MARSELLA (Individual)
10 PAOLINO STREET
PROVIDENCE, RI 02909
If to LESSEE: ETS Payphones, inc.
561 Thornton Road, Suite K
Lithia Springs, Georgia 30122
and/or to such other respective addresses as may be designated by notice given in accordance with the
provisions of this Section 4.
5. Governing Law. This Option to Sell Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with
the laws of the state of Georgia .
6. Construction. The parties have participated jointly in the negotiation of this Option to Sel] Agreement
In the event an ambiguity or question of intent or interpretation arises, this Option to Sell Agreement
shall be construed as if drafted jointly by the parties and no presumption or burden of proof shall arise
favoring or disfavoring any party by virtue of the authorship of any of the provisions of this Option to
Sell Agreement. Any reference to any federal, state, local or foreign stature or law shal] be deemed also
to refer to all rules and regulations promulgated thereunder, unless the context requires otherwise.
7. Dispute Resolution Contract Provision.
a Dispute. Any dispute, controversy, or claim of whatever nature (except an interlocutory hearing for
an action for a temporary restraining order prelmminary inyunchon, or similar equitable relief) asserted
by amy party against another party arising out of, or relating to, this Option to Sell Agreement or the
breach hereof, shall be settled by arbitration, if requested, by any party pursuant to this Section 7. The
arbitration shal] be conducted by one (I) arbitrator, who shall be appointed pursuant to the Commercial
Arbitration Rules of the American Arbitration Association (“AAA”). The arbitration shail be held in
Atianta, Georgia, and shall be conducted in accordance with the Commercial Arbitration Rules of the
AAA, except that the rules set forth in this Section 7 Shall govern such arbitration to the extent that they
conflict with the rules of the AAA.
d. Notice. Upon written notice by a party to another party of a request by arbitranon hereunder, the
parties Shall use their best efforts to cause the arbitration to be conducted in an expeditious manner, with
such arbitration to be completed within sixty (60) days after selecnon of an arbitrator. In the arbitration
ja law shall govern, except to the extent those laws conflict with the Commercial Arbitration
279
. — — — —
an, ut following determination by the arbitrator that the party seeking such discovery has a
substantial demonstrabie need. All other procedural matters shall be within the discretion of the
arbitrator. In the event a party fails to comply with the procedures in any arbitration in any manner
determined by the arbitrator, the arbitrator shal! fix a reasonable period of time for compliance and. if the
party fails to comply within such period, a remedy deemed just by the arbitrator, including, without
lumstanon, an award of default, may be umposed.
MISCELLANEOUS. This Option to Seil Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto and thew
heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns. Wherever possible each provision of this
Opuon to Sell Agreement shall be interpreted in such a manner as to be effective and valid under
applicable law, but if any provision hereof shall be p
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.