Amicus Curiae Brief — Alaska Dept. of Environmental Conservation v. EPA

Supreme Court brief2004

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. 02-658

LSERICE OF THE CLERK

— Sul tS 3004

Supreme Court of the United States

—

STATE OF ALASKA,

DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION,

Petitioner,

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, et al.,

Respondents.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

| BRIEF FOR THE NATIVE VILLAGE OF KIVALINA

AS AMICUS CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS

Michael J. Frank

Counsel of Record

Peter Van Tuyn

Trustees for Alaska

1026 West Fourth Avenue, Suite 201

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 276-4244

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PAGE

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES. .............---++++++: il

STATEMENT OF INTEREST...........-.----+++ 1

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ..........-.--+++++- 2

ARGUMENT. ............ccccccccccccccscecsccsceees 2

CONCLUSION ...........ccceceeeeceeeeeeeeeeceeees 8

il

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases:

United States v. Kagama, 118 U.S. 375, 384-85

(EGBG) «0 cncccccccsessdecseannnenneee

Statutes:

23 U.3.C. §§ 479-479 G1 2... ccccvccccsvccescsssnes

42 U.S.C. FOOL ...cccoscssesdessscansaunnaneee

Administrative Materials:

U.S. Department of the Interior, National

Park Service, Heavy Metals in Mosses

and Soils on Six Transects Along the

Red Dog Mine Haul Road (May 2001),

_ available at http://www.nps.gov/akso/

reddog/RedDogrpt.pdf (last visited

re

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Enforcement & Compliance History

Online (ECHO), at http://www.epa.gov/

echo/search_by_permit.htm] (permit

number AK0038652) (last visited

FURS DE, DOGG) ooccesscscesssonseeee

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

and Department of the Interior, Final

Environmental Impact Statement,

Red Dog Mine Project Northwest

Alaska, EPA-10-AK-Wulik-NPDES-884

(September, 1984)............. ccc cece cece eee

4,5

ili

Federal Register:

45 Fed. Reg. 46581, 46582 (July 10, 1980)......

47 Fed. R. 53130, 53131, and 53134

(Bev. B46, 19BZ).....cccccccccccccccccccccccccces

65 Fed. Reg. 12976 (Mar. 10, 2000)..............

67 Fed. R. 46328, 46332 (July 12, 2002).........

Other:

Alaska Dept. Environmental Conservation

Public Notice at http://www.state.ak.us/

dec/dawq/aqm/calendar.htm (last visited

nnn oc cnicccceoncooccosooesccees

AIDEA Project Fact Sheet: DeLong Mountain

Regional Transportation System (DMTS)

Road and Port serving mining district

that includes the Red Dog Mine (May 20,

2003) (“AIDEA Project Fact Sheet”),

at http://www.aidea.org/PDF%20files/

DMT°SFactSheet. pdf (last visited

a

Maniilag Association, Kivalina, at http://

www.maniilag.org/kivalina.html.

(last visited June 24, 2003)...................

State of Alaska Department of Community

and Economic Development, Alaska

Community Database, at http://www.

dced.state.ak.us/cbd/commdb/CF_

BLOCK.cfm (last visited June 24, 2003)....

PAGE

5,7

2,3

1,4

iv

PAGE

Teck Cominco, Inc., 1999 Annual Report, at

p. 2, available at http://www.teckcominco.

com/investors/ren~*ts/clt/clt-99-ar. pdf

(last visited June 2", ee 6

http://www.teckcominco.com/investors/

reports/ar2002/tc-2002-highlights. pdf

(last visited June 24, Es 7

STATEMENT OF INTEREST

The Native Village of Kivalina is a federally recog-

nized Alaska Native Tribe, providing services to, and

protecting the interests of, the Inupiat Eskimo peoples of

Kivalina.' The Native Village of Kivalina is one of the

“Indian tribal entities. . . recognized as having a spe-

cial relationship with the United States” and thereby is

eligible for Bureau of Indian Affairs Services. Indian

Tribal Entities Recognized and Eligible To Receive Ser-

vices From the United States Bureau of Indian Affairs,

47 Fed. Reg. 53,130-31, 53,134 (1982); see also 25

U.S.C. §§ 479-479a-1; Indian Entities Recognized and

Eligible To Receive Services From the United States

Bureau of Indian Affairs, 67 Fed. Reg. 46,328, 46,332

(2002). It also has been recognized as an “aboriginal

group” for the purposes of eligibility for grants from the

U.S. Department of Justice’s Law Enforcement Assis-

tance Administration. Determination of Eligible Alaska

Native Villages, 45 Fed. Reg. 46,581, 46,582 (1980).

Kivalina is located in northwest Alaska on ihe coast of

the Chukchi Sea, roughly 20 miles northwest of the port

for Teck Cominco Alaska Incorporated’s (“Teck Com-

inco”) Red Dog mine. U.S. Environmental Protection

Agency and Department of the Interior, Final Environ-

mental Impact Statement, Red Dog Mine Project North-

west Alaska, EPA-10-AK-Wulik-NPDES-884 (1984)

(“FEIS”), at IV-51. Nearly all of Kivalina’s approxi-

mately 380 residents are Inupiat Eskimo. State of Alaska

Department of Community and Economic Development,

! No counsel for any party authored this brief in whole or in

part, and no person or entity, other than the amicus curiae and its

members, made a monetary contribution to the preparation of sub-

mission of the brief. S. Ct. Rule 37.6. This brief is filed with the con-

sent of the parties; copies of the consents have been filed with the

Clerk. S. Ct. Rule 37.3.

2

Alaska Community Database, at http://www.dced. state.

ak.us/cbd/commdb/CF_BLOCK.cfm (last visited June

24, 2003); Maniilaq Association, Kivalina, at http://www.

maniilaq.org/kivalina.html. (last visited June 24, 2003).

In proceedings before the Ninth Circuit Court of

Appeals, the Native Village of Kivalina filed an amicus

curiae letter supporting the position of the respondents

United States Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”)

et al. It continues to support EPA’s position, and urges

affirmance of the decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of

Appeals.

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

The Native Village of Kivalina supports the EPA’s exer-

cise of authority under the Clean Air Act to prevent the

State of Alaska’s Department of Environmental Conser-

vation (“ADEC”) from permitting Teck Cominco to install

a generator at the Red Dog mine that has inadequate pol-

lution control technology. The Native Village of Kivalina

supports the actions of the EPA because federal oversight

over Alaska’s permitting authority is essential to pre-

serving the clean environment upon which Kivalina’s vil-

lagers depend for their subsistence foods and culture.

ADEC’s determination that “low” nitrogen oxides (“NOx”)

is the “best available control technology” (“BACT”) for

the proposed new generator disregards its environmental

responsibilities under the Clean Air Act and will mean that

more pollution enters Kivalina’s environment.

ARGUMENT

ADEC’s approval of low NOx technology allows the

company to use a less effective pollution control. The

record shows that in reaching its permit determination,

ADEC based its decision on some unquantified calculus

3

of economic benefit to the region and to Teck Cominco

and disregarded environmental considerations that are

very important to the Native Village of Kivalina.

In northwest Alaska, subsistence hunting, fishing and

other food gathering activities comprise most of the

local non-cash economy. Kivalina is a traditional Inu-

piat Eskimo village where subsistence activities, includ-

ing whaling, provide most food sources. Jd. From time

immemorial, Inupiat Eskimo in the Kivalina area have

thrived by hunting caribou, moose, whale, walrus, and

seal, by harvesting fish from the Chukchi Sea and local

rivers, and by gathering other foodstuffs that grow on

the area’s tundra, such as the leafy plant sour dock and

different kinds of plentiful berries, and these activities

provide the source of most of the food in Kivalina. /d.;

FEIS, 1V-54-61. Degradation of the natural environment

upon which the villagers and their food resources depend

will spell the end of the villagers’ subsistence culture.

The people of Kivalina live with airborne pollution

from the mine. Two years ago the U.S. Department of

the Interior’s National Park Service announced the

results of a study of pollution along the 24-mile length

of the mine’s haul road located in Cape Krusenstern

National Monument. National Park Service, U.S. Depart-

ment of the Interior, Heavy Metals in Mosses and Soils

on Six Transects Along the Red Dog Mine Haul Road,

NPS/AR/NRTR-2001/38, (May 2001) available at

http://www.nps.gov/akso/reddog/RedDogrpt.pdf (last

visited June 24, 2003). The study found that levels of

lead, zinc, cadmium and other metals were well in

excess of regulatory standards, with some cadmium lev-

els exceeding “concentrations in samples from heavily

polluted regions in Eastern Europe.” Jd. at 21. EPA has

listed Red Dog mine for the last eight quarters (July

2001-June 2003) as a High Priority Violator, or HPV,

under the Clean Air Act because of violations of the

4

mine’s air quality control permit. U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency, Enforcement & Compliance History

Online (ECHO), at http://www.epa.gov/echo/search_by_

permit.html (permit number AK0038652) (last visited

June 24, 2003).

If it is not equipped Selective Catalytic Reduction

(“SCR”) technology, emissions of nitrogen oxides from

Teck Cominco’s new generator will be substantially

higher than if it is equipped with SCR. Theses nitrogen

oxide emissions could affect vegetation used by caribou

and moose in Cape Krusenstern National Monument and

Noatak National Preserve. Thousands of animals from

the Western Arctic Caribou Herd graze on the tundra in

the vicinity of the mine, and airborne toxins accumu-

lating in the lungs of these animals and coating the veg-

etation they graze are in turn ingested by the people of

Kivalina. Airborne toxins accumulating on berries and

other vegetation could be directly consumed by vil-

lagers. ADEC ignored these considerations when, as

described by the State in its briefing before the Ninth

Circuit Court of Appeals, it “gave particular weight to

the” fact of “the remote location of the mine and absence

of a population likely to be affected by NOx emissions[.]”

9th Cir. Petitioners’ Combined Opening Brief, at 10.

Operations of the Red Dog mine also have a very real

impact on the quality of Kivalina’s water. The Wulik

River flows by Kivalina and it is the source of the

village’s drinking water. State of Alaska Department of

Community and Economic Development, Alaska Com-

munity Database, at http://www.dced.state.ak.us/cbd/

commdb/CF_BLOCK.cfm (last visited June 24, 2003).

The Wulik River also is the village’s primary subsistence

fishery. FEIS, 1V-55-61. Kivalina is forced to live with

the Red Dog mine’s periodic illegal discharges of toxic

mining byproducts, including heavy metals and other

chemicals, into the upper tributaries of the Wulik River.

5

In 2001 and 2002 the mine had significant effluent vio-

lations of its National Pollution Discharge Elimination

System Permit under the Clean Water Act, and EPA lists

the Red Dog mine as in “significant non-compliance”

with the Act. U.S. EPA, Enforcement & Compliance His-

tory Online (ECHO), at http://www.epa.gov/echo/ search_

by_permit.htm] (permit number AK0038652) (last vis-

ited June 24, 2003).

Economic benefits from the mine have been overstated

by the NANA Regional Corporation, Inc. (“NANA”), but

especially in comparison to the northwest Alaska Natives’

reliance on a subsistence way of life. Brief of Amicus

Curiae NANA, at 5. According to information from the

Alaska Industrial Development and Export Authority

(“AIDEA”), an agency of the State of Alaska, of the 522

permanent, full-time jobs and 59 temporary jobs at the

mine in the summer of 2002, just 292 were staffed by

NANA shareholders. AIDEA, Project Fact Sheet: DeLong

Mountain Regional Transportation System (DMTS) Road

and Port serving mining district that includes the Red

Dog Mine (May 20, 2003), available at http://www.

aidea.org/PDF%20files/DMTSFactSheet.pdf (last visited —

June 24, 2003). NANA and Teck Cominco maintain a

“fly-in camp” at the mine, which enables non-share-

holders to work at the mine and port after commuting

from cities where they live and spend their paychecks.

Many paychecks from the mine’s operation never enter

that part of the local economy that is cash-based.

More importantly, the cash benefits from the mine must

always be weighed against its environmental costs. To the

extent pollution from the mine degrades the environment,

the mine depresses the local subsistence-based economy.

Use of the most effective pollution control at the mine

will help preserve the local environment and will enable

the Inupiat Eskimo of Kivalina to survive as subsistence

food gatherers long after the mine is played out.

6

Although NANA emphasizes the economic gap the

Red Dog mine would leave if it were forced to close,

there is nothing in the record indicating that the mine

cannot be operated profitably while using SCR tech-

nology on one of its generators. Brief of Amicus Curiae

NANA, at 5. In fact, ADEC recently issued a Public

Notice of a draft permit that would allow Teck Cominco

to install and use SCR on the new generator at the mine.

See Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation,

Public Notice (Expired), at http://www.state.ak.us/dec/

dawq/aqm/calendar.htm (last visited June 24, 2003).

Moreover, in light of the magnitude of the Red Dog

mine and the substantial size of Teck Cominco itself,

there was no need for ADEC to be concerned about

impacting Teck Cominco’s operations. Teck Cominco’s

annual report for 1999 lists the company’s revenues in

that year as $1.645 billion, and its operating profits from

zinc operations in that year as $234 million. Cominco,

1999 Annual Report, available at http://www.teckcom-

inco.com/investors/reports/clt/clt-99-ar.pdf (last visited

June 24, 2003). Although the report does not review how

much of Teck Cominco’s revenues and profits were

attributable to the Red Dog Mine, the report does state

that

[Teck] Cominco’s flagship operation, the Red Dog

Mine in Alaska, holds approximately 23% of the

world’s zinc mine reserves. These reserves are the

largest and richest ever discovered and play a key

role in our strategic efforts to become the world’s

lowest cost and most profitable zinc producer. More

than just a single deposit, Red Dog is proving to be

a zinc ‘district’ that is unrivaled in the world today.

Id. at 2. Teck-Cominco’s annual reports lists its revenues

as $2.187 billion in 2002 and $2.379 billion in 2001 and

the operating profits from its worldwide zinc mining

7

operations as $50 million in 2002, and $87 million in

2001. See Cominco, 2002 Annual Report, available at

http://www.teckcominco.com/investors/reports/ar2002/tc

-2002-highlights.pdf (last visited June 24, 2003).

The federal oversight provisions of the Clean Air Act,

meant to prevent the actions of state and local authorities

from weakening national goals for environmental pro-

tection, are particularly important to Native American

Tribes like the Native Village of Kivalina. This Court

recognized long ago that federal government must

undertake a trust duty to protect tribal interests because

states often do not keep the interest of the tribes at

the forefront. United States v. Kagama, 118 U.S. 375,

384-85 (1886).

Here the State of Alaska has interests that conflict

with an objective view of its responsibilities under the

Clean Air Act and with Kivalina’s interests. Through

AIDEA, Alaska has invested nearly $267 million dollars

in the construction of the mine’s haul road and port facil-

ity. AIDEA, Project Fact Sheet, available at http://www.

aidea.org/PDF%20files/DMTSFactSheet.pdf. As reim-

bursement, Teck Cominco pays Alaska a toll for the use

of these facilities. Jd. In January 2000, AIDEA under-

wrote part of a feasibility study by the U.S. Army Corps

of Engineers to develop a plan to greatly expand the

port, a project that AIDEA also would substantially

underwrite. See Notice of Intent to Prepare an Environ-

mental Impact Statement for the DeLong Mountain Ter-

minal Navigation Improvements, 65 Fed. Reg. 12976

(2000); AIDEA, Project Fact Sheet, available at http://

www.aidea.org/PDF%20files/DMTSFactSheet. pdf (indi-

cating AIDEA is the local sponsor for this expansion

proposal). These financial interests have led ADEC to

subjugate the environmental concerns of the Native Vil-

lage of Kivalina to the economic concerns of Alaska,

8

NANA, and Teck Cominco, and to shunt aside the BACT

requirement of the Clean Air Act.

NANA’s supervision of environmental concerns

around the mine also has not provided an adequate safe-

guard for Native Village of Kivalina. Because of NANA’s

for-profit mandate, it must be concerned foremost with

the success of its business partner, Teck Cominco. This

perspective has weakened NANA’s ability to act as a

vigilant watchdog for the environmental concerns of

Kivalina.

CONCLUSION

Because Kivalina villagers live in a subsistence-based

economy, they depend on the environmental vitality of

the land. ADEC’s refusal to require adequate pollution

controls at the Red Dog mine threatens that vitality. The

Native Village of Kivalina therefore supports EPA’s

exercise of authority under Sections 113(a)(5) and 167

of the Clean Air Act in overseeing Alaska’s implemen-

tation of the Act’s permitting requirements and urges

affirmance of the decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of

Appeals.

Respectfully submitted,

Michael J. Frank

Peter Van Tuyn

Trustees for Alaska

1026 W. Fourth Avenue, Suite 201

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 276-4244

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

Native Village of Kivalina

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.