Appendix — Kirk v. Louisiana
Supreme Court brief2002
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
KENNEDY KIRK, PETITIONER
VERSUS
STATE OF LOUISIANA, RESPONDENT
APPENDIX TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
SUPREME COURT FOR THE STATE OF LOUISIANA
Sherry Watters
Attorney for Petitioner, Kennedy Kirk
Louisiana Appellate Project
P.O. Box 58769
New Orleans, Louisiana 70158-8769
504-723-0284
4D et’
KENNEDY KIRK, PETITIONER
VERSUS
STATE OF LOUISIANA, RESPONDENT
INDEX TO APPENDIX
1.Louisiana Supreme Court denial of writ with three dissents .......................... Al
2.Louisiana 4th Circuit Court of Appeal opinion ......... 0.6... 6.6 cece ee A2
3.Transcript of the Hearing on the Motion to Suppress the Evidence.................... A3
4. Application for Search Warrant with Affidavit and Retum............ 2. .....0..... A4
5. Diagram of 2300 block of Washington Avenue ...............06662. 600 c eee eee AS
State of Louisiana
VERSUS
Kennedy D. Kirk
CALOGERO, Chief Justice, dissents and assigns reasons.
~k
(>
Ne
I dissent from the majority's denial of this writ because I believe the lower
courts erroneously denied the defendant's motion to suppress. The Fourth
Amendment to the United States constitution has drawn a firm line at the entrance to
the home, and thus, the police need both probable cause to either arrest or search and
exigent Circumstances to justify a nonconsensual warrantless intrusion into private
premises. State v. Welch, 449 So.2d 468, 470 (La. 1984). Pursuant to La. Code
Crim. Proc. art. 703, the state has the burden of proof on the admissibility of evidence
seized without a warrant. Here, the defendant was arrested inside an apartment,
without a warrant, and the state has not demonstrated that exigent circumstances were
present. Consequently, defendant's arrest was unconstitutional, and his motion to
suppress should have been granted.
Ret 0.2
31
32
PARISH OF ORLEANS
STATE OF LOUISIANA
STATE OF LOUISIANA
VERSUS # 398-116
KIRK, KENNEDY SECTION G
Motion hearing taken in the
above-captioned matter before the HONORABLE
JULIAN A. PARKER, Judge presiding Section G
taken on the lst of June, 1998.
APPEARANCES :
ADA JOHN JERRY GLAS
Representing the State of Louisiana
JACK DOLAN, 0O.I.D.P.
Representing the defendant
REPORTED BY:
BRIAN P. SALZER
CERTIFIED COURT REPORTER
, i Bae os
et
oa ae
” a
4
|
NR
uw
i Was working
~
5 a ] . te .@e2 l QO h V
Q 0}
K ws And OY ha da da d
| , y u ‘ a fe
4 we 1e Occas ] }
\ e y
S A Yes, we did
Q. Was this arrest:
Search Warrant the e
, I xecut i
=
Lon of a
Ss
& Warrant? Bes
“ A T!
; sNat’s Correct.
~ O “~
e Could
~ as
*OCation that
+
from
the apartment. We cou]
+
~ a | 7 - Cur n
p ~
, e r
nol ing a —s ve a . m we
,
Called n
in a Cakedown unit
,
Subjecr down cis
co
nfirmed that Crack Cocai
in
from that location
-
© secured the Premise
MM BEST AVAILABL!
search warrant for the target location.
Q. And did you personally prepare that
search warrant?
A. Yes, I did.
MR. GLAS:
May I approach, Your Honor?
THE COURT:
Yes.
EXAMINATION BY MR. GLAS:
Q. I’m going to show you what I’m marking
as S-1 for the purposes of the motion hearing
only. Can you identify S-1 for the Court?
A. (Witness reviewing exhibit.) Yes,
this is the search warrant I prepared for the
target location which is 2316 Washington
Avenue, Apartment Number 15.
Q. And is that apartment on the first
floor, or is it, in fact, on the second floor?
A. It’s on the second floor.
Q. And when you saw these transactions
taking place, how far away were these
transactions taking place from this apartment?
What was the relationship?
A. Right in front of the door.
Q. Right in front of the door?
A. Right, they were walking to the door.
Q. Did you have the occasion to execute
this search warrant?
A. Yes, we did.
Q. Okay. And what happened when you
executed the search warrant?
Reg?" ‘a
to
~
>
?
a
©
to
>
N
uw
th
o
Le
tw
Oo
Ww
tO
based on the exigent circumstances. And at
that time, we frisk-searched the subjects for
weapons upon entering the apartment. The
subject, Kennedy Kirk, was in possession of a
plastic -- it looked more like a medicine
bottle. I think he had like 53, 58 pieces,
something like that of crack cocaine on his
person.
Q. Okay. And when you say on his
person -- and you may go ahead and refer to the
incident report to refresh your memory. Do you
have it?
A. It was located in his front
underpants, I believe.
Q. Okay. And was that crack cocaine
alone, or was it inside a plastic bottle, or
anything like that?
A. I think it was inside a plastic
bottle.
Q. Okay. Was Mr. Kennedy alone in the
apartment, or was there someone else there by
the name of Paul Cook?
A. Yes, there was also aMr. Paul Cook.
And if I’m rot mistaken, at the time we
entered, when we entered the apartment, he ran
over to -- there was a chair located between
the bed and I think there was another dresser
Or something over there. And he sat on top of
a weapon. I’m not sure what it was. I think
it might have been a nine millimeter or
pe é
something.
~
—
~
>
?
ui
16
31
32
a search of Mr. Paul Cook as well? by
A. Yes. Mr. Cook was also in possessio)
of I think like 19 rocks that he had in one of
his front pants pockets. 4
Td
Q. Okay. And do you see Mr. Kirk Kennedy
present here in the courtroom here today? i
A. Yes, he’s seated next to the defense
attorney in the orange OPP uniform.
Q. And do you see Mr. Paul Cook present
in the courtroom today?
A. No.
MR. GLAS:
Okay. At this time, Your Honor,
the State tenders the witness.
THE COURT:
Cross-examination?
EXAMINATION BY MR. DOLAN:
Q. All right, Officer, let me ask you
this: You stated on March Sth, 1998
approximately 7:15 p.m.?
A. On what?
Q. On March 18th?
A. Okay.
Q. Have you got that?
A. No.
Q. You were there. All right, you
received information of some activity in the
2300 block of Washington Avenue?
A. The task force received information.
Q. The task force?
A. It went to Sergeant --
we #
31
32
out of that apartment complex. Was there any
foot traffic directly going to one specific
apartment at that point in time?
A. I didn’t say in and out of the
apartment complex. I said to that apartment.
Q. Okay. Now you stated some information
came through an informant. Did that informant
marrate to your sergeant and he in turn narrate
to you the possible number that was handling
this traffic, the possibility of that narcotic
activity?
A. I was already in possession of
the apartment number when I originally set up
the surveillance.
Q. Okay. You set up that surveillance.
Then you saw activity. Then you saw some of
what you believe somebody made a purchase,
correct? Did you, yourself, after that
purchase was made by that individual, did you,
yourself, or your partner stop that individual
and check him out to see if he had any
contraband on him?
A. No, but we directed a takedown on that
individual.
Q. A takedown. That means a stop,
correct?
A. Correct.
Q. How far was that arrest made from that
particular complex?
A. Like I stated earlier, it was within a
hundred yards of tiat apartment.
ree yf &
31
32
A. It was near the intersection of
LaSalle and Washington.
Q. All right. When this takedown as
stated was made on that subject, whoever he
be, did you have an idea of where that
individual came out of or what apartment he
came out of at that time?
A. We saw him purchase the contraband.
That’s why I directed the takedown on that
individual.
Q. I’m saying Apartment A, B, 1, 2, 3.
Anything designated?
MR. GLAS:
Objection, argumentative. He’s
answered it.
THE COURT:
Overruled.
THE WITNESS:
Like t stated earlier, Apartment
Number 15. That was the location.
EXAMINATION BY MR. DOLAN:
Q. Fifteen, okay, all right. Based on
that information, what did you do? Is that
when you went out to secure the search warrant
or one of the officers secured the search
warrant based on some activity coming out of
Apartment 15?
A. Once the subject was taken down, he
was transported to the Sixth District Police
Station. He was interrogated by Sergeant
Gaudet, Sergeant Poole. At that time, we were
p.*°
a
31
32
the target location. And upon doing so, based
on the exigent circumstances, the apartment was
secured and then we obtained the search
warrant.
Q. The information was coming from an
individual who had been placed under arrest for
possession of cocaine, right? It wasn’t from
any informant? It was from an individual
subject who you interrogated at the district
station?
A. That particular takedown was.
Q. Right, the takedown person?
A. Correct.
Q. Your information was based primarily
for you to secure that search warrant, right?
A. If the sergeant obtained information
from that individual, we didn’t need his
information. We already had our own
information. We were already working that
information. I called in the takedown on that
individual after I observed him purchasing
illegal contraband from Apartment Number 15.
He just confirmed everything that we already
knew.
Q. All right. That arrested subject from
what I gather from the application was a fellow
by the name of Leslie Butler?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And based on that, you say the
stoppage and the arrest of that subject, you
went and secured a search warrant from the
pps?
correct?
A. That’s correct.
Q@. All right. Now, to your knowledge,
during the time that that search warrant was
secured, was any activity going on at that
apartment by any members of the New Orleans
Police Department knocking on doors, pushing
doors in, anything like that?
A. Ask the question again.
Q. I’m saying who -- put it this way.
Let’s start with this premise: Who went to get
that warrant, you?
A. Yeah, I wrote the warrant, correct.
Q You wrote the warrant?
A. After we had secured the residence.
Q To your knowledge, was any activity
going on by NOPD at that particular apartment,
Number 15, during the absence of you going to
secure that warrant? y
A. We left officers in the apartment,
that’s correct.
Q. You had officers in the apartment?
A. That’s correct. Like I stated
earlier, we secured the apartment. We entered
the apartment and secured it. Then we obtained
the search warrant. Once we entered the
apartment to secure it,'all the subjects in the
apartment were searched. |
Q. How did you secure the apartment?
That’s what I can’t figure out. How did you
secure the apartment? What right gave you to
pst
C*\
®
The exigent circumstances believing
illegal contraband would be
MR. GLAS:
I object.
THE COURT:
Go ahead and finish.
we had
Once information that
detained someone that left the
to them and they would destroy the
contraband.
EXAM
~
a
apartment
going to
guestioni
This Court is
the right
him, "What
EXAMIN
la
\
apartment
INATION BY MR. DOLAN:
You had somebody who left the
? Who was that?
MR. GLAS:
Now I’d like to object. I’m
object to the whole line of
ng. It conclusion.
here to decide whether they had
to enter the apartment. He’s asking
right did you have?"
THE COURT:
Objection overruled. Proceed.
ATION BY MP. DOLAN:
What right did you have to enter that
?
MR. GLAS:
Asked and answered.
THE COURT:
He's already answered that.
13
Ao. 8 “Be
destroyed.
eee
ORDER __OF____ SEARCH
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF THE NEW ORLEANS DEPARTMENT OF POLICE”
and/or HIS DESIGNATED REPRESENTATIVES.
AFFIDAVIT(S) HAVING BEEN MADE BEFORE ME BY:
THAT he has good reason to believe that on or in the
(premises) (persen): (vehicle) located at ~
within the Parish of Orleans, State of Louisiana, as more fu
in the application for this warrant, there is now being conc
property, namely, A ontraband contre d dangero’ . '
physical evic
et ¢ f . r
© t w t : onc Om. t
either substantive or trace, assc 3 with it's use, possess:
and distribution.
WHICH said pecponty constitutes evidence of the commission of a
crime or offense against the laws of the State cf Louisiana set forth in the
Louisiana Revised Statutes, and as I am satisfied from the affidavit(s)
submitted in support of the application for this warrant chat there is
probable cause to believe that the aforesaid j;rounds for the issuance search
Warrant exist;
YOU ARE HEREBY ORDERED to search forthwith the aforesaid
(premises) (persen) (vehic.e) for the property specified, serving this
search warrant and making “he search, and if the property be found there, to
seize it, leaving a copy o* this warrant and a receipt for the property
seized, to make your written return on this warrant including a written
inventory of the property seized, and to bring the said seized property into
the court (before the judge, the clerk, the sheriff, or any court officer
who usually acts as the custcdian) within ten days of this date as required
by law.
YOU ARE (ARE-NOT) AUTHORIZED to execute this warrant and to make
this search during the daytime or the nighttime and if the property herein
described be found on the (premises) (persen) (vehicle)
herein described to seize said property in accordance with law.
YOU ARE (ARE-NOT) AUTHORIZED to execute this warrant and make
this search on a Sunday and if the property herein described be Aound on the
(premises) (persen) (vehicle) herein described to seize said pyoperty in
accordance with law.
THIS WARRANT MADE. IN DUPLICATE ORIGINAL, NEW ORLEANS, LOUISI
THIS O5th DAY OF March 1998.
COPIES:
Original: Unit File
lst Copy: Issuing Magistrate
2nd Copy: Person Being Served
3rd Copy: District Attorney
4th Copy: Issuing Magistrate
Upon making Return
NOPD Form 117-A (rev. 7/73)
JUDGE, SECTION
CRIMINAL DIS
S\ AA a
AND STATE OF LOUISIANA ee 7
On Thursday, March S, 1998, at approximately 7:15pm, Detective John
Brunet, assigned to,the Sixth District Task Force, was on surveillance in
the 2300 block of Washington Ave. The target location was and upstairs
apartment on the second floor, and was visible from Washington Avenue. The
detectives obtained this information from a Sixth District hot-line
complaint form, stating that narcotics were being sold from this location
day and night. The detectives then formulated a plan for the surveillance,
and a take down unit on the outer edge of the target location.
| At or about 8:15 pm, Detective Brunet had observed what appeared to be
several drug transactions as a short brown skin, b/m subject known to the
detectives as "Paul", and a taller b/m subject known as "Kennedy", served
several subjects from the door of the apartment. The subjects exchanged U.S.
currency for a small package of some sort, believed by the detective to be
rack cocaine.
Based on Detectives Brunet's eight years of undercover narcotics
experience, a take down was called after a subject attired in a brown
jacket, and gray sweet pants purchased contraband. He attempted to walk
from the area. The subj ct was taken down near the intersection of
Washington and Lasalle Street and found to be in possession of crack
cocaine. After he was advised of his Miranda rights, and the charges
ending he admitted to the detectives, Sat S. Gaudet and 4 S. Poole that
e purchased the contraband from a second floor apartment located at 2316
Washington Ave. apartment number #15. This conformed the facts and
circumstances listed in the hot-line complaint, and the surveillance
observation made by Detective Brunet from his surveillance vehicle, parked
across the street from the apartments.
The arrested subject was identified as Leslie Butler, b/m, D.O.B.
7-18-54, residing at 4600 Laurel st. apt #4. He was arrested and booked
accordingly.
The Detectives immediately secured the apartment do the exigent
circumstance, based on the amount of foot traffic in the area, and believing
that word of the arrest would get back to the occupants of the apartment,
and vital evidence would be destroyed.
Based on the above listed circumstances Detective John A. Brunet
respectfully request, that this warrant be signed ordering the search of
apartment #15, located at 2316 Washington Ave.
APP. , 9.
At 10:40 pm, on 04-05-98 _, I the undersigned of the
naw .0 lems Department Of Police?>~@xecuted the for SEE int
: ~~
5
ae
I searched the residence d : ee
left. 072 od, the, resic nce Segcribed in said search warrant, and oe
together with a receipt for the items—serrex— nize: agit
The following is an invent ee
the said foregoing search warrant; of the property Cee ee bi
}| BEASTES FEDS GANETER SQUAAINENG (5) FHESES QF 8 MITE RBH
LASIIC TOBE CONTAINING RESIDUE
ER
ITE CLO BAG
NTAINER W RESIDUE
G bney” RED HANDLE CONTAINING RESIDUE
-AUT
© HANDGUN .380 CAL. 4"IN BARREL, IM
CAL PO GAgINE CLIP —
REVOLVER, 2" BARREL R.G. W/BROWN GRIPS
SEr*UKE PREDERENRUBBLOUE EDERGD
BOX SSNTAINING 73) -45 CAL CARTRIDGES
- ene opt tewing is list of all persons arrested pursuant to service
PAUL COOK, N/M, D.O.B. 11-20-67, RESIDING AT 2316 WASHINGTON AVE.
KIRK KENNEDY, N/M, D.O.B. 2-2-64, RESIDING AT 2316 WASHINGTON AVE.
Ss
:
oul
ANE
HOt
* NOOWND
oO
HWOrZZ
NOwZCoWmMM
NCoOMG
RRR RHI
,2
1
—
MONMIHZOW
Ww
HOM MMMM MMMMmMm Mmmm
- we
MMM Rr rrr O@ IOUS WAP
“
SOUP WN O
8
i
6
1
1
1
e
The following is a list of all persons listed as wanted pursuant to
service of the se@arc’ warrant:
NONE
This return made in duplicate original, in the presence of Zeygeant
8, New Or
Steven Gaudet/S. Poole, on this 06th day of March, 199 eans,
Louisiana.
A
ET. JOHN BR
Badge No. 582
AP.¢, p>
ie.
2000 WL 1716507
(Cite as: 2000 WL 1716507 (La.App. 4 Cir.))
lesser intrusive investigatory stop is that in the
former, a reasonable person would not feel that he is
free to leave, while in the latter, a reasonable person
would feel free to leave after identifying himself and
accounting for his suspicious actions; it is the
circumstances indicating intent to effect an extended
restraint on the liberty of the accused that is
determinative of when an arrest occurs. U.S.C.A.
Const.Amend. 4.
(8) Arrest €—63.4(1)
35k63.4(1)
A warrantless arrest must be based on probable
cause. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 4
[9] Arrest @—63.4(2)
35k63.4(2)
Probable cause for a warrantless arrest exists when
the facts and circumstances, cither personally known
to the arresting officer or of which he has
reasonably trustworthy information, are sufficient to
justify a man of ordinary caution in believing that
the person to be arrested has committed a crime.
U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 4.
[10] Arrest ©—63.4(2)
35k63.4(2)
Probable cause for a warrantless arrest is assessed
by an objective standard that must withstand the
detached, neutral scrutiny of a judge. U.S.C.A.
Const. Amend. 4.
{11} Arrest = 63.4(2)
35k63.4(2)
In determining whether probable cause existed for a
warrantless arrest, the court should take imto account
the practical considerations of everyday life on
which average police officers can be expected to act.
U.S.C_A. Const.Amend. 4. *
[12] Arrest @—63.4(2)
35k63.4(2)
The determination of probable cause for a
warrantless arrest, although requiring something
more than bare suspicion, does not require evidence
sufficient to support a conviction; probable cause, as
the very name implies, deals with probabilities.
Page 2
U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 4.
[13] Arrest €—63.4(2)
35k63.4(2)
The determination of probable cause for a
warrantless arrest, unlike the determination of guilt
at trial, does not require the fine resolution of
conflicting evidence that a reasonable doubt or cven
a preponderance standard demands. U.5S.C.A.
Const.Amend. 4.
APPEAL FROM CRIMINAL DISTRICT COURT
ORLEANS PARISH NO. 398-116, SECTION "G"
Honorable Julian A. Parker, Judge JUDGE
MICHAEL E. KIRBY
Harry F. Connick, Distvict Attorney, Juliet Clark,
Assistant District Attorney, New Orleans, LA,
Counsel for Plaintiff/Appellee.
Junki Kim, Student Attorney Tulane Law School
Community Services Program, Sherry Watters,
Louisiana Appellate Project, New Orleans, LA,
Counsel for Defendant/ Appellant.
(Court composed of Judge WILLIAM H.
BYRNES, Ill, Judge MICHAEL E. KIRBY, Judge
TERRI F. LOVE).
KIRBY.
*1 STATEMENT OF THE CASE:
The defendant and co-defendant, Paul Cook, were
charged by bill of information with possession of
cocaine with intent to distribute on May 18, 1998.
pled not guilty on May 21, 1998. He filed a motion
to suppress evidence which was denied June |,
1998. A twelve member jury found defendant
{1} La. R.S. 40;967(B\4)(b) provides that only the
first five years of the sentence be served without
benefit of parole, probation or suspension of
Copr. © West 2000 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works
Af?.2, 9.
2000 WL 1716507
(Cite as: 2000 WL 1716507, *1 (La.App. 4 Cir.))
sentence. Because the defendant was sentenced
without those benefits on the entire fifteen year
sentence, the denial of those benefits on the last ten
years of his sentence are deleted.
FACTS:
Detective John Burnett testified at trial that he and
his partner, Detective Derrick Brumfield, went to
the 2300 block of Washington Avenue on March 5,
1998, around 5:00 p.m. to observe the apartment in
question. At the motion to suppress hearing, the
officer testified that they went to the location in
response to a citizen complaint. Once there, they
saw a person approach the apartment and exchange
currency for a small object. They continucd
watching the apartment and saw a total of four
apparent narcotics transactions. Burnett saw the
defendant complete a transaction. After the fourth
transaction, Burnett ordered that the buyer be “taken
down.” Detective Steven Gaudet and his partner
stopped the man. Because the stop took place within
a block of the apartment, Burnett feared that
evidence would be destroyed and ordered that the
apartment be entered. Upon the officers’ entering,
the defendant sai on a gun. Another weapon was on
a table to the defendant's left. Both defendants were
“secured.” Officers obtained a search warrant. Afier
the warrant was obtained, a search of the defendant
revealed fifty-eight pieces of crack cocaine and
$283.00. The officers seized a cooking tube from
the apartment.
ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR:
[2] The defendant argues the trial court erred in
denying the motion to suppress evidence. He makes
a long atgument that there were not exigent
was not found in the apartment, but on his person.
The only items found in the apartment were a
cooking tube and guns, and the defendant was not
charged with a firearms offense.
(SU4USHOMTHSHIM OM LIIZ13) This court
recently reviewed the law on point in State v.
Dorsey, 99-1819, pp. 5- 6 (La.App. 4 Cir. 4/19/
00), --- So.2d ----:
*2 On trial of a motion to suppress, the State has
their testimony. State v. Mims, 98-2572, p. 3
(La.App. 4 Cir. 10/5/99), 752 So.2d 192, 1999
WL 1012959. “In reviewing a trial court's ruling
on a motion to suppress, an appellate court is not
limited to evidence adduced at the hearing on the
motion to suppress; it may also consider any
pertinent evidence given at trial of the case.” State
v. Nogess, 98-0670, p. 11 (La.App. 4 Cir. 3/3/
99), 729 So.2d 132, 137.
A search conducted without a warrant is per se
unreasonable, subject only to a few specifically
established and well-delineated ec .
Schneckloth v. Bustamonte, 412 U.S. 218, 93
S.Ct. 2041, 36 L.Ed.2d 854 (1973); State v.
Tomasetti, 381 So.2d 420, 423 (La.1980). One of
those exceptions is a search of a person and the
area within his immediate control incident to a
lawful arrest. Chimel v. California, 395 U.S. 752,
89 S.Ct. 2034, 23 L.Ed.2d 685 (1969); Tomasetti,
381 So.2d at 423. La.C.Cr.P. art. 201 defines
arrest as “the taking of one person into custody by
another [by] actual restraint of the person.” The
distinguishing factor between an arrest and the
lesser intrusive investigatory stop is that in the
former, a reasonable person would not feel that he
is free to leave, while in the latter, a reasonable
person would feel free to leave after identifying
himself and accounting for his suspicious actions-
“it is the circumstances indicating intent to effect
an extended restraint on the liberty of the accused”
that is determinative of when an arrest occurs.
State v. Allan, 95-1754, p. 6 (La.9/5/96), 682
So.2d 713, 719.
A warrantless arrest must be based on probable
cause. State v. Jackson, 450 So.2d 621, 627
(La.1984); State v. Creecy, 98-1472, p. 6
(La.App. 4 Cir. 7/14/99), 742 So.2d 615, 619.
Probable cause ecxisis when the facts and
circumstances, cither personally known to the
arresting officer or of which he has reasonably
trustworthy information, are sufficient to justify a
man of ordinary caution in believing that the
person to be arrested has committed a crime. State
Copr. © West 2000 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works
f°. p. 3
2000 WL 1716507
(Cite as: 2000 WL 1716507, *2 (La.App. 4 Cir.))
v. Johnson, 98-2544, p. 6 (La.App. 4 Cir. 11/17/
99), 748 So.2d 527, 1999 WL 1080209; State v.
Bryam, 98-1115, p. 5 (La.App. 4 Cir. 8/4/99),
744 So.2d 108, 111. Probable cause is assessed by
an objective standard that must withstand the
“detached, neutral scrutiny of a judge.“ State v.
Fisher, 97-1133, p. 8 (La.9/9/98), 720 So.2d
1179, 1184 (quoting State v. Flowers, 441 So.2d
707, 712 (La.1983), cert. denied, 466 U.S. 945,
104 S.Ct. 1931, 80 L.Ed.2d 476 (1984)). In
determining whether probable cause existed, the
court should take into account the “practical
considerations of everyday life on which ...
average police officers can be expected to act.” Id.
(quoting State v. Raheem, 464 So.2d 293, 296
(La.1985). The determination of probable cause,
although requiring something more than bare
suspicion, does not require evidence sufficiem to
support a conviction; probable cause, as the very
name implies, deals with probabilities. State v.
Green, 98-1021 (La.App. 4 Cir. 12/22/99), ---
So.2d ----, 1999 WL 1257281. The determination
of probable cause, unlike the determination of guilt
at trial, does not require the fine resolution of
conflicting evidence that a reasonable doubt or
Page 4
» even a preponderance standard demands. Id.
In this case, the officers received information from
a citizen that drugs were being sold from an
apartment. They observed the defendant come to the
door and complete drug transactions. They stopped a
buyer and found him in possession of cocaine. They
immediately knocked on the door of the apartment,
arrested the defendant, searched him thereto and
discovered the cocaine and the money. The officers
had probable cause to arrest and properly searched
the defendant incident thereto. The trial court
properly denied the motion to suppress. This
assignment is without merit.
CONCLUSION:
*3 Therefore, we affirm the conviction, delete the
denial of benefits on the last ten years of the
sentence, and affirm as amended.
AFFIRMED AND AS AFFIRMED AMENDED.
END OF DOCUMENT
Copr. © West 2000 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works
AAP 2 p-4
H+ Oust?
~
rt Ouse
——
rov se
Laeanenselfiasnenndl
——
House
—
ioe wale
Lidashingten Ave.
Locatien
5 be werk
hy 2a20
HOUSE
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.