Appendix — Washington State Dept. of Social and Health Servs. v. Guardianship Estate of Keffeler

Supreme Court brief2003

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Qe

™~.

(2 Pri + Y

Mi 14 20 war | 4 2002

Noy QIRICE OF THE GLB

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF

SOCIAL AND HEALTH SERVICES, ET AL.,

PETITIONERS,

Vv.

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF DANNY KEFFELER,

By WANDA PIERCE, GUARDIAN,

AND OTHER PERSONS SIMILARLY SITUATED,

RESPONDENTS.

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

To THE SUPREME COURT OF WASHINGTON

APPENDIX TO THE PETITION FORA

WRIT OF CERTIORARI

CHRISTINE O. GREGOIRE

Attorney General

William Berggren Collins

Sr. Assistant Attorney General

Counsel of Record

1125 Washington Street SE

Olympia, WA 98504-0100

360-753-6245

Counsel for Petitioners

APPENDIX TABLE OF CONTENTS

Guardianship Estate of Keffeler ............cccccsccecseeseeseeseeeserees |

145 Wash. 2d 1, 32 P.3d 267 (2001)

Order Denying Motion For Reconsideration....................- 40

SII sulietinsdetadedepalancineddscndtdcdninbadescanansidbisamicnnmememmeensitl 42

Ee a 43

Court’s Findings Of Fact On Order Of

Remand From Supreme Coutt ...............:ccccccssesseeeseeeeeeees 46

Plaintiff's Order Granting Plaintiffs Motion

iB EE 112

BN II cnctencnnncsitivenibasicensensmsnnesaneenneneccoreess 122

Order Allowing Amendment Of Complaint.................... 131

Order Granting Amendment Of Order

SE 133

Order Certifying Case To Proceed As A Class

Action, Defining The Class And Denying

Defendants’ Motion To Dismiss..................s:ssseseesseeee 136

| ES a a 141

ET a 142

Letter From Ronald Carpenter to Counsel................:0:+++: 143

(stay motion denied)

A eR OC a A oe ae 145

| A Ta aa a a 205

a I iicstaitilieaisdisindiiadlibichntithinndibdeseedicadaeorestcesnete 245

we

A-!l

Supreme Court of Washington,

En Banc.

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF Danny KEFFELER, by

Wanda Pierce, Guardian, and

other persons similarly situated, Respondents,

Vv.

STATE of Washington DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL

AND HEALTH SERVICES;

Lyle Quasim, Director of the Department of Social and

Health Services; and

Michael R. Hobbs, Program Manager for the Department of

Social and Health Services,

Appellants.

No. 67680-1.

Argued Nov. 8, 2000.

Decided Oct. 11, 2001.

SANDERS, J. The plaintiff class asks us to hold

the Washington State Department of Social and Health

Services (DSHS) violated that provision of the Social

Security Act (the Act), 42 U.S.C. § 407(a) which forbids

creditor access to Social Security benefits. Here DSHS acts

as a representative payee under 42 U.S.C. § 405(j) for

foster children and then applies the Social Security benefits

to reimburse the state budget for payments made to foster

parents for the basic needs of those children. We are also

asked if DSHS’s actions deprived the foster children of

their property absent due process and abridged their right to

equal protection of the laws. Lastly the plaintiff class

asserts entitlement to an award of reasonable attorney fees.

We hold DSHS as a representative payee violates §

407(a) of the Act when it applies Social Security benefits to

the current maintenance needs of foster children for whom

it acts as representative payee. Given this disposition we

find it unnecessary to consider the due process and equal

protection claims. We remand for further proceedings,

including further consideration of the reasonable attorney

fee award.

ISSUES

1. Does DSHS violate § 407(a) of the Social

Security Act when, as a representative payee under § 405(j)

of the Act, it uses Social Security benefits to pay current

maintenance costs of children in foster care?

2. Is the class entitled to an award of reasonable

attorney fees?

FACTS

Foster care in Washington is provided by an

amalgam of federal, state, and private funds, although the

program is largely state-funded. In fiscal year 2000, for

example, the total foster care budget was $37.4 million in

state funds, plus approximately $12.9 million in federal

funds. To be eligible for federal funding under the Social

Security Act, a state must provide foster care services under

a plan approved by the Secretary of Health and Human

Services. 42 U.S.C. § 670.' RCW 74.13.0317 authorizes

' The Act authorizes federal assistance for state foster care

services:

For the purpose of enabling each State to provide, in

appropriate cases, foster care and transitional independent

A-3

DSHS to provide foster care services to children in

Washington.

Foster care is generally provided in Washington to

children who have been abused or neglected or have

become the responsibility of the state through our juvenile

living programs for children who otherwise would be eligible

for assistance under the State’s plan approved under part A of

this subchapter [as such plan was in effect on June 1, 1995)

and adoption assistance for children with special needs, there

are authorized to be appropriated for each fiscal year

(commencing with the fiscal year which begins October |,

1980) such sums as may be necessary to carry out the

provisions of this part. The sums made available under this

section shall be used for making payments to States which

have submitted, and had approved by the Secretary, State

plans under this part.

42 U.S.C. § 670.

? RCW 74.13.031 provides, in pertinent part:

The department shall have the duty to provide child welfare

services and shall:

(1) Develop, administer, supervise, and monitor a

strengthens services for the protection and care of runaway,

dependent, or neglected children.

(2) Within available resources, recruit an adequate

number of prospective adoptive and foster homes, both regular

and specialized, i.e. homes for children of ethnic minority,

including Indian homes for Indian children, sibling groups,

handicapped and emotionally disturbed, teens, pregnant and

parenting teens, and annually report to the governor and the

legislature concerning the department’s success im: (a)

Meeting the need for adoptive and foster home placements;

(b) reducing the foster parent turnover rate; (c) completing

home studies for legally free children; and (d) implementing

and operating the passport program required by RCW

74.13.285.

A-4

justice laws, Title 13 RCW.’ On behalf of these children,

the state pays a schedule of monthly allotments to foster

parents who in turn pay for the basic necessities such as

food, shelter, and clothing for the children in their charge.

As of September 1999, there were 10,578 foster children

under DSHS’s supervision. An additional 2,352 children

were in the custody of tribal authorities or child care

agencies for whom DSHS paid support. Five hundred

sixty-seven additional children received support through

DSHS’s Division of Developmental Disabilities (DDD).

Although DSHS provides foster care for children

who need it, it is Washington public policy to attempt to

recover the costs of foster care from the parents of children

in foster care who are primarily liable for the costs of that

care:

It is declared to be the public policy of this state that

this chapter be construed and administered to the

end that children shall be maintained from the

resources of responsible parents, thereby relieving,

at least in part, the burden presently borne by the

general citizenry through welfare programs.

RCW 74.20A.010 (support of dependent children act). See

also In re Welfare of Feldman, 94 Wash.2d 244, 250, 615

P.2d 1290 (1980) (“It is true that parents bear the primary

responsibility for the support of their children.”).

In the context of foster care, DSHS implemented

the Legislature’s cost recovery policy by regulation:

> See, e.g, RCW 13.34.210 (if a child has no parent with

parental rights, court may commit child to DSHS’s custody; DSHS in

turn may seek adoption for child or place the child in foster care or

other suitable placement).

Parents of children in foster care paid by the

department satisfy their legal obligation to support

their children when there is a superior court order

for support by paying the amounts specified in the

order or in the absence of a superior court order, by

paying the amount determined under RCW

74.20A.055 and regulations promulgated in chapter

388-11 WAC.

Former WAC 388-70-075(1) (1976), repealed by St. Reg.

01-08-047 (Apr. 30, 2001).

If parents of a foster child are unavailable or

unwilling to reimburse DSHS for the costs of foster care,

DSHS may reimburse itself using “moneys and other

funds” that come into its possession while the child is in its

custody. RCW 74.13.060 provides, in pertinent part:

The secretary [of the Department] or his

designees or delegatees shall be the custodian

without compensation of such moneys and other

funds of any person which may come into the

possession of the secretary during the period such

person is placed with the department of social and

health services pursuant to chapter 74.13 RCW. As

such custodian, the secretary shall have authority to

disburse moneys from the person’s funds for the

following purposes only and subject to the

following limitations:

(1) The secretary may disburse any of the

funds belonging to such person for such personal

needs of such person as the secretary may deem

proper and necessary.

A-6

(2) The secretary may apply such funds

against the amount of public assistance otherwise

payable to such person. This includes applying, as

reimbursement, any benefits, payments, funds, or

accrual paid to or on behalf of said person from any

source against the amount of public assistance

expended on behalf of said person during the period

for which the benefits, payments, funds or accruals

were paid.

DSHS implemented RCW 74.13.060 with the following

regulation:

(1) If a child in foster care is entitled to

financial benefits the income received shall be used

on behalf of the child to help pay for the cost of the

foster care received, except for resources held in

trust for an American Indian child according to

provisions in WAC 388-28-650.

(a) Income includes SSI [Supplemental

Security Income], RSDI [retirement survivors

disability insurance], veteran’s benefits, railroad

retirement benefits, inheritances, or any other

payments for which the child is eligible, unless

specifically exempted by the terms and

conditions of the receipt of the income.

____(b) Receipt of other income as described

above shall not relieve the child’s responsible

parent(s) of the liability for payment of child

support in accordance with WAC 388-70-075

through 388-70-084.

(2) Any person, agency, or court which

receives any payments on behalf of a child in foster

A-7

care shall remit such payments to the office of

support enforcement, in accordance with WAC 388-

70-082.

(3) Resources in the control of a child in

foster care shall be treated in accordance with WAC

388-28-400 through 388-28-455.

Former WAC 388-70-069 (1983), repealed by St. Reg. 01-

08-047 (Apr. 30, 2001).

Where a child is eligible for Social Security

benefits,’ federal law provides a process by which a

“representative payee” may be appointed to administer the

funds on behalf of the child. Section 405(j)° of the Act

authorizes the Social Security Administration

(Administration or SSA) to appoint such a “representative

payee” for the child beneficiary:

If the [Administration] determines that the

interest of any individual under this subchapter

would be served thereby, certification of payment of

such individual’s benefit under this subchapter may

be made, regardless of the legal competency or

incompetency of the individual, either for direct

payment to the individual, or for his or her use and

benefit, to another individual, or an organization,

* Children are eligible to receive either Title II Social Security

Administration (SSA) benefits (based on the death or disability of a

parent), or Title XVI Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits

(based on the child’s own disability), or both.

* Section 405(j) authorizes the appoinument of a representative

payee to receive SSA benefits under Title I]. The appointment of a

representative payee to receive SSI benefits under Title XVI is also

authorized. 42 U.S.C. § 1383(aX2\AYii).

A-8

with respect to whom [certain] requirements ... have

been met (hereinafter in this subsection referred to

as the individual’s “representative payee”).

42 U.S.C. § 405G)(1)(A); see also 20 C.F.R. § §

404.2001(b), 416.601(b). Generally, a representative

payee is appointed whenever a beneficiary is under 18

years of age. The Administration has an order of

preference for representative payees for such children,

generally favoring the appointment of parents or relatives

of the child; it will appoint an authorized agency only if no

parent or guardian is available. The appointment of a state

agency like DSHS is the last on that priority list.° 42

U.S.C. § § 405(j(3)(B), 405G)(2C\iii)MID; 42 U.S.C. §

1383(aX(2)(B); 20 C.F.R. § § 404.2021, 416.621.

The Code of Federal Regulations explains the

function of representative payees:

A representative payee may be either a person or an

organization selected by us [the Social Security

Administration] to receive benefits on behalf of a

beneficiary. A representative payee will be selected

if we believe that the interest of a beneficiary will

be served by representative payment rather than

direct payment of benefits. Generally, we appoint a

representative payee if we have determined that the

beneficiary is not able to manage or direct the

management of benefit payments in his or her

interest.

® The Act prohibits the appointment of a creditor as

representative payee except, inter alia, where the creditor is a relative or

legal guardian of the beneficiary, or the creditor is a licensed state

facility. 42 USC. § 405G\2KCKIXID; 42 USC. §

1383(a)(2)(B\iii).

20 C.F.R. § 404.2001 (a).

The appointment of a representative payee such as

DSHS may be challenged. The Administration must notify

the beneficiary or legal guardian of the appointment of a

representative payee and must advise that the beneficiary

has the right to a hearing before the Commissioner and

judicial review to challenge any appointment. 42 U.S.C. §

405(j(2)E)(i), (ii); 42 U.S.C. § 1383(a)(2)(B)(xi), (xii).

_ Representative payees, including state agencies,

must use Social Security benefits for the beneficiary, and in

the beneficiary’s best interest, under guidelines set forth in

the Administration’s regulations. 20 C.F.R. § §

404.2035(a), 416.635(a). The regulations specifically

authorize representative payees to use benefits to defray the

cost of the beneficiary’s “current maintenance,” including

food, shelter, clothing, medical care, and personal items.

The regulations state, in relevant part:

We will consider that payments we certify to a

representative payee have been used for the use and

benefit of the beneficiary if they are used for the

beneficiary's current maintenance. Current

maintenance includes cost incurred in obtaining

food, shelter, clothing, medical care, and personal

comfort items.

20 C.F.R. § § 404.2040(a)(1), 416.640(a). The regulations

also specify that the cost of institutionalized care is an

authorized expense. 20 C.F.R. § § 404.2040(b), 416.640(b).

When monthly SSA and/or SSI benefits exceed the

amount needed for current maintenance, the representative

payee is required to conserve and invest the remaining

A-10

benefits in trust for the benefit of the benefici

ciary. 20

C.F.R. § § 404.2045(a), (c), 416.645(a), (c). Large

amounts of retroactive benefits must be placed in a

separate, dedicated account and may be used only for

certain, enumerated expenditures. 20 C.F.R. § 416.640(e).

If 2 representative payee misuses benefits, the

representative payee may be removed by the

Admini tration. 42 U.S.C. § 405(j)(1(A); 42 U.S.C. §

1383(a)(2)(A)(iii). Moreover, a representative payee’s

misuse of the beneficiary’s funds is a felony. 42 U.S.C. §

408(a)(S). Given the criminal penalty for misuse of funds

some courts have inferred a fiduciary relationship between

beneficiary and representative payee, although the statute

and implementing regulations do not say as much. See,

e.g., Garvey v. Worcester Housing Auth., 629 F.2d 691 (Ist

Cir.1980), cert. denied, 450 U.S. 925, 101 S.Ct. 1379. 67

L.Ed.2d 356 (1981); Bradley v. Austin, 841 F.2d 1288 (6th

Cir.1988); C.G.A. v. State, 824 P.2d 1364 (Alaska 1992):

In re Estate of Merritt, 272 Ul.App.3d 1017, 209 Ill.Dec.

502, 651 N.E.2d 680 (1995); Rice v. Perales, 156 Misc.2d

631, 594 N.Y.S.2d 962 (Sup.Ct.), afd 193 A.D2

599 N.Y.S.2d 211 (1993). - aie

In September 1999, of the thousands of foster

children in the custody of DSHS pursuant to Title 13 and

chapter 74.13 RCW, 1,480 foster care children were

receiving Social Security benefits. Nine hundred twenty-

three children were receiving SSI benefits, 469 were

receiving SSA benefits, and 88 children were receiving

both. DSHS acted as a representative

children in foster care and in DDD. 2 Na aa

Two units within DSHS perform the actual function

of representative payee for the Social Security benefits of

class members. The Children’s Administration

A-ll

(Children’s) provides services to all foster children

regardless of whether the children also receive Social

Security benefits. These services include monitoring the

child’s needs, determining special needs, and developing an

individual service plan for each child. The Trust Fund Unit

accounts for Social Security benefits received by DSHS as

representative payee.

When a child is placed in foster care, Children’s

identifies those children who may be eligible for Social

Security benefits and makes an application on their behalf.

If Children’s believes a denial of benefits is erroneous,

Children’s will appeal for the child. In each case, DSHS

also applies to the Administration to become the

representative payee for the child (except for

developmentally disabled children).

When DSHS receives Social Security benefits as

representative payee for a foster child the funds are

deposited in a Foster Care Trust Fund Account at the Office

of the State Treasurer. Although the funds are in a single

account, the Trust Fund Unit maintains an individual

“subsidiary account” for each child for whom benefits are

received.’

Children’s is responsible for providing the current

maintenance needed by a child in foster care. However,

”? The only exception to this practice occurs when DSHS

receives a lump sum payment of SSI benefits of over six times the

monthly benefit amount. Since October 1996, these lump sum

payments have been deposited by the Administration directly into a

dedicated account at a local bank. These funds cannot be used for basic

foster care expenses, and can be expended only for special needs,

primarily related to a child's impairment. Prior to October 1996, these

funds were used to reimburse Children’s for past foster care expenses.

A-12

Children’s does not normally purchase a child’s food,

shelter, clothing, and other items directly. Rather, such

items are purchased and provided by the child’s foster

parent. Children’s pays the foster parent a fixed amount

based on a schedule. Where a special item or expenditure

is needed, the Trust Fund Unit will issue a check to either

the foster parent or directly to a store or service provider.

Such expenditures are authorized by DSHS in its discretion

as the representative payee.

The Trust Fund Unit typically uses a child’s Social

Security benefits to pay for a child’s basic foster care

expenses. Every month, Children’s generates a report

showing the amount of money paid by Children’s to a care

provider for each child in foster care. The Trust Fund Unit

uses this report to determine how much of a child’s SSI and

SSA funds it will direct the state treasurer to pay to

Children’s. In general, if the amount in the trust fund

account is adequate to reimburse the entire cost of foster

care, as claimed by Children’s, the entire claimed amount is

paid. If the funds in the trust fund account are not adequate

to reimburse the entire cost of foster care, the Trust Fund

Unit uses up to the amount available in the trust fund

account. The amount to be paid for foster care is

transferred from the Foster Care Trust Fund Account to

Children’s.

As representative payee, DSHS has the discretion to

expend a child’s SSA or SSI funds on items other than

current basic foster care expenses. Children’s staff may

request that a child’s benefits be used for extra items or

special needs, such as computers, educational expenses,

summer camps, counseling, toys, clothing, athletic

equipment and orthodontics. When in doubt, the Trust

Fund Unit consults with the Administration to determine

whether a particular expenditure is authorized.

Children in foster care for whom a person or entity

other than DSHS serves as representative payee still receive

state-supported foster care. Foster children who do not

receive any Social Security benefits are eligible for state

funding for extra items and special needs if funds are

available in the state foster care budget.

DSHS is also authorized to conserve and invest

Social Security benefits for foster children. Funds not used

for basic foster care or special needs are deposited into a

single interest-bearing account. The interest earned on this

account is credited to the child’s individual subsidiary

account. These funds are ultimately forwarded to a

successor representative payee or paid directly to the child

upon emancipation.

There is a $2,000 resource limit on any child

receiving SSI benefits (although funds deposited to the

dedicated account are not subject to this limit). DSHS

monitors each child’s subsidiary account to ensure the

balance remains below the limit. When a balance is

ing the resource limit, the Trust Fund Unit notifies

Children’s of the need to spend down the account balance.

Children’s determines what special needs might be met

using the excess funds and requests disbursements from the

Trust Fund Unit. DSHS uses reimbursements to Children’s

for current expenses as a means of not exceeding the

$2,000 limit.*

* Prior to October 1996, some dedicated accounts as well as

subsidiary accounts were spent down by reimbursing Children’s for

previous basic care expenditures. In addition, the practice of “account

sweeping” sometimes results in DSHS’s taking all of a child’s Social

Security funds and applying those funds ‘o accumulated (past)

reimbursable foster care expenses.

Federal law forbids creditor access to Social

Security benefits. 42 U.S.C. § 407(a) provides:

The right of any person to any future payment under

this subchapter shall not be transferable or

assignable, at law or in equity, and none of the

moneys paid or payable or rights existing under this

subchapter shall be subject to execution, levy,

attachment, garnishment, or other legal process, or

to the operation of any bankruptcy or insolvency

law.

Commonly referred to as an antialienation provision, this

statute evinces Congress’s intent to remove Social Security

benefits from the reach of creditors employing legal

process. Dionne v. Bouley, 757 F.2d 1344, 1355 (ist

Cir.1985). The statute also prohibits the voluntary transfer

or assignment of Social Security benefits by the

beneficiary. Gardner v. Ewing, 88 F.Supp. 315 (S.D.Ohio),

aff'd, 185 F.2d 781 (6th Cir.1950), rev'd on other grounds,

341 U.S. 321, 71 S.Ct. 684, 95 L.Ed. 968 (1951); accord

Hurd v. Ill. Bell Tel. Co., 136 F.Supp. 125 (N.D.II11.1955),

aff'd, 234 F.2d 942 (7th Cir.), cert. denied, 352 U.S. 918,

77 S.Ct. 216, 1 L.Ed.2d 124 (1956). As the United States

Supreme Court noted in Bennett v. Arkansas, 485 U.S. 395,

397, 108 S.Ct. 1204, 99 L.Ed.2d 455 (1988), any state law

contrary to § 407(a) runs afoul of the Supremacy Clause.

Accord Crawford v. Gould, 56 F.3d 1162, 1165 (9th

Cir.1995).

The present case arose from DSHS’s treatment of

class representative Danny Keffeler. Apparently, an

overzealous Department employee sought to have Danny's

grandmother and guardian removed as representative

payee. DSHS now asserts this was the only time it has ever

A-15

tried to remove a private representative payee. After four

years of , tigation involving just Danny, his guardian filed a

class action lawsuit in the Okanogan County Superior

Court on Danny’s behalf and on behalf of others “similarly

situated.” Clerk’s Papers (CP) at 1-15. According to the

amended complaint, DSHS has now abandoned its efforts

to become the representative payee for Danny.

The trial court certified the class, and later amended

the certification to include children receiving both SSA and

SSI benefits. The class now consists of “All foster children

within the State of Washington, past, present, and future in

foster care that receive [either SSA or SSI benefits) for

whom the State of Washington acts or has sought to act as

‘representative payee.” “ CP at 574.”

The gravamen of the class action is that DSHS’s

actions violate the antialienation provision of 42 U.S.C. §

407(a) where DSHS, as representative payee, uses a foster

child’s Social Security benefits to reimburse the state for

the costs of foster care. The class also presents several

constitutional causes of action. First, the class alleges

DSHS has acted irrationally, invidiously, and arbitrarily

and capriciously in violation of 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Second,

the class alleges DSHS’s actions violate the due process

clauses of the Washington Constitution and the Fourteenth

Amendment. Third, the class alleges the state discriminates

against the class members “by subjecting them to a lower

* The actual number of class members cannot be determined

from records available to DSHS. Based on available records there are

7,798 class members dating back to July of 1991. According to the

trial court, “the claims of the class extend back 18 years plus one year

for a total of 19 years back from the filing of the plaintiffs’ action, i.e.

to 1979.” Court’s Findings of © +t on Order of Remand from Supreme

Court at 18.

A- 16

standard of living than children who are not so situated.”

Finally, the class alleges the state “maliciously, recklessly

and wantonly is invading federally protected funds for its

own improper advantage, to the detriment of Plaintiff and

all other foster children’s financial and emotional well-

being.” CP at 13-14.

In its prayer for relief, the class seeks (i) a

permanent injunction enjoining DSHS from using Social

Security payments to offset the cost of foster care; (ii)

reimbursement to class members of all Social Security

payments used by DSHS for reimbursement; and (iii) an

award of attorney’s fees.

DSHS moved to dismiss the action, i

. . 7 . . arguing the

Administration was an indispensable party that cannot be

sued in state court. In response, the class argued it was not

claiming the Administration has done anything wrongful,

only that DSHS is unlawfully taking Social Security

pert pen pry eee ~eeahcereor hegre

certifying the class. sorties

On cross motions for summary judgment, the trial

court filed a memorandum opinion and entered judgment in

favor of the class. The trial court held DSHS’s use of

Social Security benefits to reimburse the cost of foster care

violates 42 U.S.C. § 407(a), and DSHS violates procedural

due process by failing to provide notice, beyond that

required by federal law and regulation, of the “intended

result” of the appointment of DSHS as representative

payee. The trial court did not address the class’ remaining

constitutional arguments, nor did it specifically conclude

— rights violations under 42 U.S.C.

A-17

The trial court’s judgment provided the following

relief:

1. An injunction preventing DSHS from

ing action to replace any private representative

payee.

2. An injunction preventing DSHS from

requiring any private representative payee to repay

DSHS for the cost of maintaining a child in foster

care from Social Security benefit payments.

3. An injunction requiring DSHS to provide

written notice containing certain information to a

child’s parent(s) or legal guardian whenever DSHS

applies to become a representative payee for the

child.

4. An injunction preventing DSHS from

using Social Security payments to reimburse the

costs of foster care.

5. An order requiring DSHS to produce an

accounting of Social Security fund disbursements

for all children that had been in the custody of

DSHS for the purpose of receiving foster care.

6. An order of restitution of Social Security

funds used to reimburse DSHS for foster care

expenses.

7. An award of attorney's fees, with the

amount to be determined in the future.

DSHS appealed the trial court’s judgment to

Division Three of the Court of Appeals, although no error

A-18

was assigned to items | or 2 referenced above. Because of

the importance of the issues in this case, the Court of

Appeals certified the case to us and we granted the

certification. After the first oral argument of the case, we

remanded the matter to the trial court pursuant to RAP

9.11. The parties have supplemented the record and the

trial court has made findings of fact.

ANALYSIS

A. DSHS’s actions as representative payee violated

42 U.S.C. § 407(a).

Simply put, if DSHS is appointed representative

payee for a foster child it will confiscate the child’s SSI

money to benefit the state. However, if anyone else is

appointed, the state will bear the cost of foster care, and the

child’s SSI will be available to benefit the child in addition

to the state- funded foster care program. The issue is

whether this confiscation violates federal law. For the

reasons which follow we believe it does.

DSHS admits it would probably not even apply to

be a representative payee if it could not rely on the child’s

SSI benefits to reimburse the cost of care. By the same

token, DSHS admittedly cannot actively seek

reimbursement from benefits paid to private representative

payees because Congress specifically protects Social

Security benefits from transfer, assignment, execution,

levy, attachment, garnishment, or other legal process under

42 U.S.C. § 407(a).'° [FN10] Thus, DSHS receives

'° The federal code provides, in pertinent part,

The right of any person to any future payment under this

subchapter shall not be transferable or assignable, at law or in

equity, and none of the moneys paid or payable or rights

A-19

reimbursement for foster care only if it serves as a

representative payee, and it only serves as representative

payee so it can confiscate the child’s money. ''

This schemé stands in stark contrast to 20 C.F.R. §

404.2021 which expressly provides, “Our primary concern

is to select the payee who will best serve the beneficiary's

interest.” (Emphasis added.) Obviously the child is better

off with any payee other than the state because DSHS must

provide foster care under state law regardless of whether it

receives a reimbursement.’ DSHS’s self-prioritization is

extremely disquieting in the face of a regulatory mandate

that we consider these disenfranchised children before

enriching government coffers.

1. DSHS as a creditor

Whether DSHS acts as a creditor when it

reimburses itself for foster care costs out of the foster

children’s Social Security Administration (SSA)

existing under this subchapter shall be subject to execution,

levy, attachment, garnishment, or other legal process, or to the

operation of any bankruptcy or insolvency law.

42 U.S.C. § 407(a). This section was made applicable to Title

XVI benefits by 42 U.S.C. § 1383(d\(1).

'! The trial court found “/fJor the sole purpose of obtaining

reimbursement for foster care costs, DSHS applies to the Social

Security Administration to be appointed representative payee for all

children in foster care who are eligible for social security benefits.”

Clerk’s Papers (CP) at 623 (Trial Court’s Mem. Op. (Sept. 29, 1998) at

3) (emphasis added).

'2 DSHS forecasted it would receive $6.733 million from such

reimbursement, or fully 18 percent of the state’s contribution to the

foster care budget of $37 million, for fiscal year 2000. CP at 1899,

1911 (Trial Court’s Findings of Fact on Order of Remand, Exs. B, F).

A-20

entitlements is the crucial question. If DSHS’s

reimbursement scheme is that of a creditor, the

antiattachment provisions of § 407(a) apply and DSHS’s

cost recovery policy runs afoul of a federal statute which

preempts state law under the Supremacy Clause of the

United States Constitution. U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 2.

The facial logic of DSHS’s reimbursement scheme

demonstrates a creditor relationship, a_ relationship

involving creditor-type acts, vis-a-vis foster children and

their SSA benefits. Further, while no federal case

addresses the peculiar set of facts involved here, the course

of federal precedent in similar situations arising under §

407(a) undercuts the claim that DSHS complies with

federal law.

In Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Bd., 409 U.S.

413, 93 S.Ct. 590, 34 L.Ed.2d 608 (1973), the United States

Supreme Court described the broad protection § 407

affords Social Security benefits. Philpott declared that §

407 barred New Jersey’s attempt to reach federal Social

Security disability benefits in order to reimburse the state

for public assistance expenditures made on behalf of the

petitioners. State welfare recipients were made to execute

an agreement, as a condition precedent to receiving welfare

benefits, to reimburse the county welfare board with any

funds that came into their possession. When Philpott

refused to turn his SSA disability benefits over to the

welfare board the latter sued to enforce the agreement. The

Supreme Court held § 407 on its face prohibited New

Jersey from reaching the petitioner’s federal disability

payments, explaining, “We see no reason why a State,

performing its statutory duty to take care of the needy,

should be in a preferred position as compared with any

other creditor.” Philpott, 409 U.S. at 416, 93 S.Ct. 590.

A-2l

Responding to the argument New Jersey may not be

a creditor with respect to the SSA benefits, the Court

continued: “§ 407 does not refer to any ‘claim of

creditors’; it imposes a broad bar against the use of any

legal process to reach all social security benefits. That is

broad enough to include all claimants, including a State.”

409 U.S. at 417, 93 S.Ct. 590. This language evinces a

federal policy with respect to SSA benefits--the “broad

bar”--which controls this case.

The Supreme Court again took up § 407(a) in

Bennett v. Arkansas, 485 U.S. 395, 108 S.Ct. 1204, 99

L.Ed.2d 455 (1988), where Arkansas attempted to attach

certain federal benefits paid to individuals incarcerated in

Arkansas prisons to reimburse the state for maintaining a

prison system. Arkansas argued an “implied exception” to

the broad bar of § 407(a) (as here) where the state is

providing public money for the care and maintenance of the

SSA beneficiary. The Court found no such “care and

maintenance” exception for states “given the express

language of § 407(a) and the clear intent of Congress that

Social Security benefits not be attachable.” Bennett, 485

U.S. at 397-98, 108 S.Ct. 1204. DSHS in the instant case

attempts to evade § 407(a) by arguing that it simply

provides the “care and maintenance” intended by the SSA.

We find that argument as unavailing, notwithstanding some

factual dissimilarities, as did the Supreme Court.

Closer to home, the Ninth Circuit ruled in Brinkman

v. Rahm, 878 F.2d 263 (9th Cir.1989) DSHS may not

deduct SSA benefits as reimbursement for the costs of care

and maintenance, paid out of public funds, for involuntarily

committed mental health patients in state hospitals. The

court noted, “The state collects this debt from the appellees

by withdrawing [Old Age Survivor’s and Disability

Insurance] funds from appellees’ accounts at the state

A-22

hospital accounting offices,” finding § 407 i

preempts this

procedure. Brinkman, 878 F.2d at 264. There Sie a

significant enough difference between DSHS’s methods in

Brinkman and its methods of reaching the foster children’s

SSA benefits in this case’ to justify a different result.

The Ninth Circuit again addressed the issue in

Crawford v. Gould, 56 F.3d 1162 (9th Cir.1995) where,

under California law, patients committed to state

psychiatric hospitals were held responsible for the costs of

their own incarceration. California accordingly required all

funds and income, including SSA benefits, to which the

patient was entitled to be placed in a hospital trust account

from which the state could deduct as reimbursement the

costs of care and maintenance expended on the patient.

porter er dimer: Am: carp Spent dn pre

authorized deduction. Holding § 407 preem this

procedure, the Ninth Circuit held: ae

'? DSHS’s actual practice, as described by its Office Chief for

the Office of Federal Funding in the Division of Program and Policy

for the Children’s Administration, is:

to apply to the Social Security Administration (SSA) to be the

Representative Payee for social security monies whenever a

child is placed in foster care. If SSA chooses to make DCFS

[Division of Children and Family Services] the Representative

Payee, the actual checks are sent to the Department's Office of

Financial Recovery and the money is then transferred to a

suspense account in the Department’s Office of Accounting

Services. This money is used to reimburse the Department for

monthly foster care expenses, including food, clothing, shelter

and other personal or medical expenses as governed by the

Code of Federal Regulations. Excess money is placed in trust

ane SSD NaS SPN SS Se SUNN SIRENS,

CP at 120 (Aff. of Richard Anderson) (emphasis added).

A-23

Our conclusion, that “other legal process” includes

the procedure that California uses to deduct Social

Security benefits, is consistent with the purpose of §

407. The nonassignment provision was not

designed to preclude use of only the judicial process

to obtain Social Security benefits. Rather, § 407(a)

is designed “to protect social security beneficiaries

and their dependents from the claims of creditors.”

The cramped reading of § 407 California urges

would enable the state to obtain Social Security

benefits through procedures that afford less

protection than judicial process affords.

Crawford, 56 F.3d at 1166 (citations omitted).

These cases evince an expansive interpretation of

the protections of § 407. The thrust of the case law is that

Social Security benefits are, for all intents and purposes,

beyond the reach of the state, however clever or subtle its

attempt to seize them. Philpott and the cases in its line,

including Crawford, are on point and persuasive.

The state claims King v. Schafer, 940 F.2d 1182

(8th Cir.1991) justifies DSHS’s position, particularly

because DSHS acts as a representative payee under 42

U.S.C. § 405(j) for the foster children in this case. In King

the State of Missouri, as representative payee, received

SSA benefits due involuntarily committed mental patients

and reimbursed itself for the care and maintenance costs

expended out of public funds for the patients. The patients

argued the state’s application to become the patient's

representative payee to accept the patients’ SSA benefits

violated the “other legal process” provision of § 407(a).

However the King court disagreed, noting the illogic of

presuming § 407(a) would outlaw a procedure (applying to

become representative payee) expressly authorized by §

A-24

405(j). “We cannot agree with the plaintiffs,” wrote the

King court, “that the Department’s participation in the

administrative proceeding to become a representative payee

is the kind of coercive legal process envisioned by §

407(a).” King, 940 F.2d at 1185.

In light of King, and the fact that DSHS enjoys the

status of representative payee (for most) of the foster

children under § 405(j) and 20 C.F.R. § 404.2001(a), the

significance of the state’s representative payee status

requires further discussion. '

The King plaintiffs challenged the state’s procedure —

for applying to become representative payee, arguing that

procedure (incident to which the state seized the mental

health patient’s SSA benefits) violated § 407(a) as “other

legal process.” However here it is not DSHS’s procedure

to apply to become the foster children’s representative

payée that is under attack; rather it is DSHS’s practice of

reimbursing itself from the foster children’s SSA benefits

once it becomes representative payee.

'* Apparently DSHS is not the representative payee for Danny

Keffeler, the class representative. Keffeler’s grandmother apparently

remained his representative payee, despite DSHS’s zealous efforts to

remove her. Br. of Appellants at 1-4. This fact is of some interest in

light of King, because the King court found that with respect to those

mental health patients for whom the state was not the representative

payee, the state’s attempts to reach the SSA benefits did constitute

“other legal process” and was preempted by § 407(a). King v. Schafer,

940 F.2d 1182, 1185 (8th Cir.1991). We doubt the King court’s

distinction is internally consistent but refrain from entertaining those

doubts, as it does not further the analysis on this point.

A-25

The difference is subtle, but the distinction is

crucial. There is nothing ipso facto wrong with DSHS

applying to become the representative payee for certain

foster children, as § 405(j) and the SSA’s accompanying

regulations explicitly contemplate. We may even agree the

representative payee application is not “other legal

process.” But it is equally clear the reimbursement process

is “other legal process,” given the definition of that phrase

furnished by Philpott, Brinkman, Bennett, and Crawford.

Accordingly, King must be distinguished, as Judge

Burchard below correctly concluded, “[T]here is no legal

basis for giving foster children less protection for their

social security benefits than adult welfare recipients, state

prisoners or involuntarily committed mental patients

receive.” CP at 627 (Trial Court’s Mem. Op. (Sept. 29,

1998) at 7).

The state also claims C.G.A., 824 P.2d 1364

supports its position. But C.G.A. only said the state may

apply to become a representative payee. C.G.A., 824 P.2d

at 1366. The court did not hold the state could reimburse

itself but deferred that determination to the Social Security

agency under the doctrine of primary jurisdiction. /d at

1370. Like King, C.G.A. stands for no more than the

uncontested proposition DSHS may apply to become a

representative payee.

DSHS reimbursement is barred by § 407(a) because

despite DSHS’s status as representative payee it performs

the role of creditor when it takes the foster child’s SSA

entitlement to reimburse itself for moneys spent on the

child. A representative payee may not be a “creditor of

such individual who provides such individual with goods

and services for consideration.” 42 USC. §

405(j(2(C)G)CID.

A -26

However to claim DSHS does not provide goods

and services for consideration is only to say that DSHS is

not the kind of creditor which § 405(j) excludes from

representative payee status. It is not to say the definition of

a creditor “who provides such individual with goods and

services for consideration,” id, is an exhaustive definition

of other creditors who do not, nor is it to say DSHS cannot

become a creditor or act like a creditor despite the fact it is

a representative payee. If DSHS is allowed under § 405(j)

to become a representative payee for the foster children,

that fact does not establish the legality of taking the child's

money.

Furthermore, the bare logic of reimbursement also

implies a creditor-debtor relationship. Common sense and

dictionary definition of “reimburse” is “[t]o pay back, to

make restoration, to repay that expended; to indemnify, or

make whole.” Black's Law Dictionary 1287 (6th ed.1990).

In common parlance one need not make a payback unless

something “loaned” was “owed” by the recipient back to

the payee. In fact the public policy of our state to recover

the costs expended from public funds on foster children

implies exactly this sort of debtor-creditor relationship. '*

'* That policy finds its statutory expression in RCW

74.13.060:

The secretary [of DSHS] or his designees or

delegatees shall be the custodian without compensation of

such moneys and other funds of any person which may come

into the possession of the secretary during the period such

person is placed with the department of social and health

services pursuant to chapter 74.13 RCW. As such custodian,

the secretary shall have authority to disburse moneys from the

person's funds for the following purposes only and subject to

the following limitations:

(1) The secretary may disburse any of the funds

belonging to such person for such personal needs of such

A-27

As DSHS presently conceptualizes the matter, RCW

74.13.060 (and its implementing regulation, former WAC

388-70-069)'° requires it to reimburse itself for the public

assistance it has meted out to foster children from money,

including SSA entitlements, that come into the children’s

possession. If the Legislature and DSHS did not hold the

costs of foster care were somehow “owed” back to the

taxpayers, it would not claim the right of DSHS to

“reimburse” itself on the taxpayer’s behalf.

person as the secretary may deem proper and necessary.

(2) The secretary may apply such funds against the

amount of public assistance otherwise payable to such person.

This includes applying, as reimbursement, any benefits,

payments, funds, or accrual paid to or on behalf of said person

from any source against the amount of public assistance

expended on behalf of said person during the period for which

the benefits, payments, funds or accruals were paid.

'® The code states, in pertinent part, that:

(1) If a child in foster care is entitled to financial

benefits the income received shall be used on behalf of the

child to help pay for the cost of the foster care received...

(a) Income includes SSI, RSDI, veteran's

benefits, railroad retirement benefits, inheritances, or

any other payments for which the child is eligible,

unless specifically exempted by the terms and

conditions of the receipt of the income....

(2) Any person, agency, or court which receives any

payments on behalf of a child in foster care shall remit such

payments to the office of support enforcement, in accordance

with WAC 388-70-082.

Former WAC 388-70-069( 1 (a), (2).

A-28

DSHS’s_ representative payee status further

undercuts the legality of its reimbursement process because

a representative payee is charged under SSA regulation, 20

C.F.R. § 404.2035, with the responsibility to “[u]se the

payments he or she receives only for the use and benefit of

the beneficiary in a manner and for the purposes he or she

determines, under the guidelines in this subpart, to be in the

best interests of the beneficiary.” Id § 404.2035(a)

(emphasis added). We seriously doubt using the SSA

benefits to reimburse the state for its public assistance

expenditure is in all cases, or even some, “in the best

interests of the beneficiary.”

Using this money for the care and maintenance of

the beneficiary, as required under 20 C.F.R. § 404.2035(a),

would indeed be in the best interest of the beneficiary, but

that is significantly different from using the money to

reimburse the state for payments it made for the care and

maintenance of the foster child--especially when that

payment to the state cannot be legally compelled and,

moreover, could be used or conserved for other special

needs of the child.

As the state concedes, DSHS takes on a fiduciary or

quasi-fiduciary role when it acts as representative payee.

Br. of Appellants at 3. DSHS’s reimbursement procedure

hence constitutes a conflict of interest precisely because

DSHS uses the SSA benefits it receives as representative

payee in a manner inconsistent with the best interests of the

foster children entitled to the money. However worthy cost

recovery might be, DSHS cannot violate federal law at the

expense of foster children to accomplish it.

Accordingly we hold each instance of

reimbursement makes DSHS a creditor, or, if not a creditor,

then at least committed to a creditor-type action that is

A-29

preempted by the “broad bar” of § 407(a). DSHS’s

application under § 405(j) to become a foster child’s

representative payee is at best immaterial to the analysis

pertaining to its use of SSA benefits as reimbursement, or

is at worst incompatible with that use of the benefits, as

discussed above. Given our view that the state’s actions

violate the Supremacy Clause we find it unnecessary to

consider other alleged constitutional infirmities such as

deprivation of property without due process or denial of the

equal protection of the law. See U.S. Const. amend. XIV.

B. The trial court award of attorney fees is not

sufficiently specific.

The summary judgment which we review provided:

It is hereby ordered that plaintiff should be

awarded attorney fees, the amount of which, and the

theory under which awarded, shall abide future

ruling of this court.

Pl.’s Order Granting Pl.’s Mot. for Summ. J., CP at

666. The quoted language does not clarify the scope or

basis of the attorney fee award and therefore must be

revisited on remand.

Under the American Rule for attorney fees,

compensation may be awarded only if authorized by

contract, statute, or a recognized ground in equity. Bowles

v. Dep't of Ret. Sys., 121 Wash.2d 52, 70, 847 P.2d 440

(1993) (citing Painting & Decorating Contractors of Am.

Inc. v. Ellensburg Sch. Dist., 96 Wash.2d 806, 815, 638

P.2d 1220 (1982); Seattle Sch. Dist. 1 v. State, 90 Wash.2d

476, 540, 585 P.2d 71 (1978)). A_ well-established

A-30

equitable ground for awarding attorney fees is the common

fund doctrine. See Covell v. City of Seattle, 127 Wash.2d

874, 891, 905 P.2d 324 (1995); Bowles, 121 Wash.2d at 70,

847 P.2d 440; Seattle Sch. Dist. 1, 90 Wash.2d at 542-45,

585 P.2d 71. It applies when a litigant preserves or creates

a common fund for the benefit of an ascertainable category

of persons. Miotke v. City of Spokane, 101 Wash.2d 307,

339, 678 P.2d 803 (1984) (quoting Pub. Util. Dist. No. 1 of

Snohomish County v. Kottsick, 86 Wash.2d 388, 390-91,

545 P.2d 1 (1976)). The doctrine serves important public

functions, and, in light of the purpose of the American Rule

for attorney fees, should be applied only when such

functions are met. Accord Covell, 127 Wash.2d at 892, 905

P.2d 324 (awarding attorney fees based on the common

fund doctrine because the policy reasons “clearly are

supported”). If properly applied, it provides greater access

to those who otherwise may be unable to afford the services

of an attorney. Bowles, 121 Wash.2d at 71, 847 P.2d 440.

Although the common fund doctrine provides an

avenue whereby attorneys may be reimbursed from the

fund created, other equitable and/or statutory grounds may

allow an affirmative recovery against the nonprevailing

party. 42 U.S.C. § 1988, for example, may provide an

arguable basis for such an award; however, neither the trial

court nor the parties have adequately articulated the

equitable or statutory basis to impose liability against the

state for reasonable attorney fees and expenses of litigation

in the context of this case. This issue therefore must be

considered further on remand.

CONCLUSION

We therefore hold DSHS violated § 407(a) of the

Act when acting as the representative payee under § 405(j)

of the Act by reimbursing itself for foster care payments,

A-3l

contrary to the Supremacy Clause of the United States

Constitution. We therefore affirm the trial court’s result,

with this opinion. The class shall recover its statutory costs

on appeal without prejudice to a further award of

reasonable attorney fees to be determined on remand.

ALEXANDER, C.J., and SMITH, JOHNSON and

MADSEN, JJ., concur.

BRIDGE, J. (concurring in part/dissenting in part). |

agree with the majority that the Washington State

Department of Social and Health Services (DSHS)

impermissibly used social security funds to reimburse itself

for past due foster care payments. However, the majority

goes too far in concluding that any use of social security

funds by DSHS violates the antiattachment rule. Under a fair

reading of the controlling federal statute and regulatory

authority, DSHS is entitled to use the funds to pay for current

maintenance costs, provided that special

children are satisfied first. = eo

The federal law governing the appointment of

representative payees and the use to which funds received on

behalf of beneficiaries can be put is 42 U.S.C. § 405(j).

RCW 74.13.060 allows DSHS to become the custodian (i.e.

representative payee) “without compensation” of social

security funds’ payable to foster children:

The secretary or his designees or delegatees shall be

the custodian without compensation of such moneys

and other funds of any person which may come into

the possession of the secretary during the period such

person is placed with the department of social and

health services pursuant to chapter 74.13 RCW.

Tracking federal law, state law provides that once DSHS

becomes the custodian (“representative payee”) of the funds,

DSHS is permitted to spend these funds only for the child’s

“personal needs” or to reimburse the state for “the amount of

public assistance otherwise payable to” the child during the

period for which the benefits were paid. RCW 74.13.060(1),

Social Security (SSA) and Supplemental Security Income

(SSI) benefits.

A-33

(2). Former WAC 388-70-069 (1983), repealed by 01-08-

047 (Apr. 30, 2001), specifically allowed the social security

funds to be used on behalf of the child to help defray the

state’s cost for foster care:

(1) If a child in foster care is entitled to

financial benefits the income received shall be used

on behalf of the child to help pay for the cost of the

foster care received, except for resources held in trust

for an American Indian child according to provisions

in WAC 388-28-650.

(a) Income includes SSI, RSDI [retirement

survivors disability insurance], veteran’s benefits,

railroad retirement benefits, inheritances, or any

other payments for which the child is eligible,

unless specifically exempted by the terms and

conditions of the receipt of the income.

The majority concludes that “If DSHS’s

reimbursement scheme is that of a creditor, the

antiattachment provisions of § 407(a) [of the Social Security

Act] apply and DSHS’s cost recovery policy runs afoul of a

federal statute which preempts state law.” Majority at 275.

This statement is misleading in its scope. The Social

Security Act, chapter 7, 42 U.S.C., does not rule out

appointment of a creditor as representative payee in all

situations. One of the exceptions to the antiattachment

provisions of the act allows the appointment of “an

individual who is determined by the Commissioner ... to be

acceptable to serve.” 42 U.S.C. § 405(j)(2)(C)ili)(V). Thus,

even if DSHS is characterized as a creditor, the

commissioner of social security may find, and here has

found, DSHS acceptable to serve as a representative payee

A-34

for these children in foster care.” The determination of the

Social Security Act should control. The real issue, in my

view, is the conflict of interest that arises when DSHS serves

both as a representative payee and as a creditor for the same

funds (which funds belong to the eligible child, the

beneficiary) and the permissible uses of such funds.

Federal regulations not only govern the selection of a

representative payee, but also define the lawful uses to which

a representative payee may put the social security funds

entrusted to its care. Specifically, a representative payee has

a responsibility to “[uJse the payments he or she receives

only for the use and benefit of the beneficiary in a manner

and for the purposes he or she determines, under the

guidelines in this subpart, to be in the best interests of the

beneficiary.” 20 C.F.R. § 416.635(a). Current maintenance,

including the cost of food, shelter, clothing, medical care,

and personal-comfort items is deemed to be for the use and

benefit of the beneficiary. 20 C.F.R. § 416.640(a).

An example in the regulations clarifies the definition

of “use and benefit” inthe context of payments to an

institution for current maintenance of the beneficiary and

indicates a clear intent that special needs of the beneficiary

should take precedence over general maintenance or

reimbursement for care.’ The example states that the

? If the commissioner may find an individual acceptable to serve,

he may presumably find an entity acceptable to serve. This interpretation

is reinforced by the fact that the commissioner routinely appoints entities

such as DSHS to serve as representative payees.

> Example: An institutionalized beneficiary is entitled to a

monthly Social Security benefit of $320. The institution charges

$700 a month for room and board. The beneficiary's brother,

who is the payee, learns the beneficiary needs new shoes and

does not have any funds to purchase miscellaneous items at the

institution's canteen.

A-35

representative payee should deduct the cost of special needs

items from the amount paid to the institution, and also makes

clear that any remaining money may be used for current

maintenance

The majority relies on four federal cases to assert that

DSHS may not use social security funds for current

maintenance: Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Bd., 409 U.S.

413, 93 S.Ct. 590, 34 L.Ed.2d 608 (1973) (holding that New

Jersey may not attach social security benefits to reimburse

itself for welfare benefits); Bennett v. Arkansas, 485 U.S.

395, 108 S.Ct. 1204, 99 L.Ed'2d 455 (1988) (holding that

Arkansas may not attach federal benefits for care and

maintenance of prisoners); Brinkman v. Rahm, 878 F.2d 263

(9th Cir.1989) (forbidding Washington State from attaching

federal benefits for the care of involuntarily comumitted

mental health patients); and Crawford v. Gould, 56 F.3d

1162 (9th Cir.1995) (holding that California may not deduct

the costs of caring for psychiatric inpatiemts from # trust

account to which social security payments were deposited).

These cases are readily distinguished from the DSHS

practice at issue here. Critically, none of the cited federal

The payee takes his brother to town and buys him a pair

of shoes for $29. He also takes the beneficiary to see @ movie

which costs $3. When they return to the institution, the payee

gives his brother $3 to be used at the canteen.

Although the payee normally withholds only $25 a

month from Social Security benefit for the beneficiary's

personal needs, this month the payee deducted the above

expenditures and paid the institution $10 less than he usually

pays.

The above expenditures represent what we would

consider to be proper expenditures for current maintenance.

20 C.F.R. § 404,2040(2\(b).

A-36

cases involve the expendiwre of social security benefits by a

state that was designated as a representative payee. In fact,

the class certified in Brinkman specifically excluded patients

for whom the state served as representative payee.

Brinkman, 878 F.2d at 264. As explained above, under

federal regulations a representative payee has considerable

authority to spend the funds entrusted to its control, provided

the expenditures are for the best interests of the beneficiary.

20 C.F.R. § 416.635(a).

Thus, the issue as I see it is not whether DSHS may

spend the funds for current maintenance, provided it gives

priority to special needs of the foster children, but whether it

may use those funds to reimburse itself for past maintenance

or for its own administrative services, such as mileage

reimbursements for social workers. The fact that DSHS in

the context of reimbursing itself for past care of the

beneficiary puts its need for reimbursement ahead of the

needs of the foster children further demonstrates the

fundamental conflict between its roles as representative

payee and creditor.

The federal mandate to give priority to the special

needs of the beneficiary directly conflicts with the express

policy of DSHS to conserve the expenditure of public

assistance funds on foster care and thereby lighten the burden

on the taxpayer. See chapter 74.20 RCW (Support of

Dependent Children):

It is the responsibility of the state of Washington

through the state department of social and health

services to conserve the expenditure of public

assistance funds, whenever possible, in order that

such funds shall not be expended if there are private

funds available or which can be made available by

judicial process or otherwise to partially or

A-37

completely meet the financial needs of the children of

this state.

RCW 74.20.010. The state aggressively pursues this

‘ recovery policy, not only seeking money for current

maintenance but also sweeping lump sum payments into the

treasury to prevent a child’s account from exceeding the

$2,000 resource limit imposed by the SSA.

In order to provide states with an incentive to provide

financial assistance to needy individuals awaiting disposition

of their SSI applications, Congress provided that back

payments made at the time the secretary makes the first

payment would be exempt from the general antiattachment

rule. 42 U.S.C. § 1383(g)(2). However, a recent case held

that a retroactive payment after a period of denial is not the

same as an initial payment and therefore does not fall under

the exemption to the antiattachment rule that is found in 42

U.S.C. § 1383(g)(2). Catarine v. Wing, 710 N.Y.S.2d 569,

274 A.D.2d 310 (2000). Accord Conaway v. Soc. Servs.

Admin., 298 Md. 639, 471 A.2d 1058 (1984) (holding that

the use of conserved social security benefits to reimburse the

cost of past foster care is prohibited). Thus, the lump sums

that DSHS “sweeps” into the treasury to reimburse the state

for past foster care expenses cannot fall under the initial

payment exception. There is no other exception which would

validate DSHS’s action.

This sweeping of lump sums not only is unauthorized

under any exception to § 407(a), but also often constitutes

double reimbursement. The sums “swept” to the treasury

frequently reimburse the state for amounts already paid by

the federal government under Temporary Assistance for

Needy Families or paid by parental support. DSHS

apparently keeps no accurate record to allow tracing of the

“swept” sums.

Under § 407(a), rights to future payments are not

transferable or assignable.

The right of any person to any future payment

under this subchapter shall not be transferable or

assignable, at law or in equity, and none of the

moneys paid or payable or rights existing under this

subchapter shall be subject to execution, levy,

attachment, garnishment, or other legal process, or to

the operation of any bankruptcy or insolvency law.

42 U.S.C. § 407(a). DSHS receives the payments not on its

own behalf, but on behalf of the beneficiaries, and is not

permitted to assign pending (i.e., future) payments to the

reimbursement of its expenditures on behalf of the foster

children. Where an agency puts reimbursement to itself

ahead of the best interests of the child, ignoring the policy

expressed in the federal regulations to prioritize the child’s

special needs, it effectively transfers the payments to its own

use. This transfer from the state in its role as representative

payee to the state in its role as guardian of the public purse is

contrary to § 407(a). Where the agency pursues that policy

to the extent of double reimbursement, the conflict of interest

is egregious.

To the extent that RCW 74.20A.010 encourages the

State to “sweep” a child’s benefits into the treasury to repay

past-due foster care, | agree with the majority that the statute

is incompatible with § 405(j), which forbids any “substantial

conflict of interest” between the payee. U.S.C. §

405G2KCiv\MIl). See also 42 U.S.C. § 405(j)(1A)

(mandating removal of a representative payee if the

commissioner or a court of competent jurisdiction later

determines that it has misused any individual’s benefit.) It is

also incompatible with § 407(a), which prevents transfer of

A-39

the benefits. Under the Supremacy Clause of the United

States Constitution, federal law takes precedence. Thus, any

use of social security funds for purposes other than current

care and maintenance is unlawful, as is giving priority to

maintenance over the children’s special needs.

Remedies

I agree with the majority that in relying on RCW

74.20A.010, DSHS has given preference to the interests of

the taxpayer over the special needs of foster children and has

acted as creditor by reimbursing itself for past payment of

foster care, directly contrary to § § 405(j) and 407(a) of the

Social Security Act. But for reasons already set forth in this

opinion, I would remand this matter to the trial court with

directions to modify the injunction to prevent DSHS from

using social security payments to reimburse the costs of past

due foster care or other expenses not directly related to

current maintenance, and to require DSHS give special

needs a higher priority than current maintenance. On

remand, the trial court should order DSHS to produce an

accounting of social security fund disbursements for all

children that had been in the custody of DSHS for the

purpose of receiving foster care, establish restitution of social

security funds used to reimburse DSHS for past due foster

care expenses, other expenses not directly related to current

maintenance, and unmet special needs, and determine

appropriate attorney fees.

I thus respectfully concur in part and dissent in part

from the majority opinion.

IRELAND, J., and GUY, J.P.T., concur.

A-40

THE SUPREME COURT OF WASHINGTON

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF

DANNY KEFFELER, BY WANDA

PIERCE, Guardian, and other No. 67680-1

persons similarly situated,

ORDER DENYING

Respondents, MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION

Vv.

STATE OF WASHINGTON

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND

HEALTH SERVICES, LYLE

QUASIM, Director of the

Department of Social and Health

Services, et al.,

Appellants.

The Court having considered the Appellants’ Motion

for Reconsideration;

Now, therefore, it is hereby

ORDERED:

That the Appellants’ Motion for Reconsideration is

denied.

DATED at Olympia, Washington this 14th day of

December 2001.

//s/I

Chief Justice Gerry L. Alexander

cc:

A-4l

I have affixed the seal of the Supreme

Court of the State of Washington and

filed this Mandate this 14th day of

December 2001

//s//

C.J. MERRITT

Clerk of the Supreme Court, State of

Washington |

Debra Casparian

Lawrence Lockwood

Rodney Reinbold

Deborah Kant

Colette Matzzie

William Collins

Richard Price

Eugene Studer

William Kanter

Reporter of Decisions

A-42

THE SUPREME COURT OF WASHINGTON

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF

DANNY KEFFELER, BY WANDA

PIERCE, Guardian, and other MANDATE

persons similarly situated,

Respondents,

V. Okanogan County No.

STATE OF WASHINGTON —

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND

HEALTH SERVICES, LYLE

QUASIM, Director of the

Department of Social and Health

Services, et al.,

NO. 67680-1

Appellants.

THE STATE OF WASHINGTON TO: The Superior Court

of the State of Washington in and for Okanogan County.

This is to certify that the opinion of the Supreme

Court of the State of Washington filed on October 11, 2001,

became the decision terminating review of this Court in the

above entitled cause on December 14, 2001. This cause is

mandated to the superior court from which the appeal was

taken for further proceedings in accordance with the attached

true copy of the opinion.

Pursuant to Rule of Appellate Procedure 14.3, costs

are taxed as follows: No cost bills having been timely filed

costs are deemed waived. Order Denying Motion for

Reconsideration was entered here in [sic] on December 14,

2001. Copy attached.

A-43

THE SUPREME COURT OF WASHINGTON

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF

DANNY KEFFELER,

No. 67680-1

Respondent,

by WANDA PIERCE, Guardian, and

other persons similarly situated,

ORDER ON REMAND

Vv.

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND

HEALTH SERVICES, et al.,

Appellants.

Oral argument was heard in the above reference case on

June 24, 1999. The Court having considered the above case:

Now, therefore, it is

ORDERED:

The case is remanded pursuant to RAP 9.11 to the trial

court for the record to be supplemented as follows:

1. The State should submit the August 1998 audit by the

Social Security Administration of the Department of Social

and Health Services referred to at page seven of the amicus

curiae brief of the Commissioner of the United States Social

Security Administration.

2. The parties should submit the following information

and the trial court make findings of fact on the following:

The current number of foster care children in the

State’s custody pursuant to chapter 74.13 RCW.

. The number of such children who are also

beneficiaries of any Social Security payments,

identifying the specific program under which the

payments are made.

. The number of children identified in paragraph b for

whom the State is the representative payee pursuant

to the provisions of 42 U.S.C.A. § 405(j) (1998).

. A detailed explanation of how the State processes and

uses Social Security payments it receives as the

representative payee of foster care children, to include

the following information:

for foster care children;

ii. How the State administers those accounts with

respect to the $2,000 limit on accumulation of

Title XVI Social Security payments;

iii. Whether and how Social Security payments to the

State receives as representative payee are “passed

through” to the foster parents of the beneficiary

children.

. A detailed explanation of the services the State

performs on behalf of foster care children in its

capacity as representative payee.

. The number of class members and how far back in

time their claims extend.

A-45

submit additional evidence to assist the trial court in its

, See

; The trial court is directed to expedite the hearing of

this matter and return its findings of fact to this Court as soon

as practical.

DATED at Olympia, Washington this 2nd day of

December, 1999.

//s// [Richard P. Guy]

CHIEF JUSTICE

A-46

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE

STATE OF WASHINGTON

IN AND FOR THE

COUNTY OF OKANOGAN

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF

DANNY KEFFELER, by WANDA | No. 96-2-00157-2

PIERCE, Guardian, and other

persons similarly situated, SUPREME COURT

NO. 67680-1

Plaintiffs,

COURT’S FINDINGS

v. OF FACT ON

ORDER OF

STATE OF WASHINGTON REMAND FROM

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND | SUPREME COURT

HEALTH SERVICES,

Defendant,

And

LYLE QUASIM, DIRECTOR OF

THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL

AND HEALTH SERVICES; AND

MICHAEL R. HOBBS,

PROGRAM MANAGER FOR

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND

HEALTH SERVICE,

THIS matter came before this court pursuant to the Order

on Remand issued by the Supreme Court pursuant to RAP

9.11 on December 2, 1999. The order on Remand directs this

court to make findings of fact on the following:

a. The current number of foster care children in

the State's custody pursuant to chapter 74.13.

RCW.

b. The number of such children who are also

beneficiaries of any Social Security Payments,

Identifying the specific program under which the

payments are made.

c. The number of children identified in paragraph

b for whom the State is the representative payee

pursuant to provisions of 42 USCA § 405(j)

(1998).

d. A detailed explanation of how the State

processes and uses social security payments it

receives as the representative payee of foster

children, to include the following information

i. Whether the State maintains individual

accounts for foster care _ children;

ii. How the State administers those accounts

with respect to the $2,000 limit on

accumulation of title XVI Social Security

Payments;

iii. Whether and how Social Security

Payments the State receives as representative

payee are “passed through” to the foster

parents of the beneficiary children.

(e) A detailed explanation of the services the State

performs on behalf of foster care children in its

capacity as representative payee.

(f) The number of class members and how far

back in time their claims extend.

After reviewing the affidavits, depositions, and the

exhibits filed herein and having considered counsel’s

arguments, the court makes the following findings of fact in

response to the questions posed in the Order on Remand.

Paragraph 1 «* the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

1. The 1998 audit conducted by the Social Security

Administration of the Department of Social and Health

Services referred to at p. 7 of the Amicus Curiae Brief of the

Commissioner of the United States Social Security

Administration is attached hereto as Exhibit A and herein

incorporated as if fully set forth.

Paragraph 2(a) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

2. The Department has historically observed a time lag

when extracting this type of data from the Children’s

Administration’s automated information system (Case

Management Information System or CAMIS). The

Department believes monthly data more accurately reflects

the number of children in the custody of DSHS in out-of-

home placement than either a specific date or a yearly

average. Thus, the Department reported the number of foster

children in the state’s custody in September 1999 as the most

recent reliable data available as of January 15", when the

information was provided to the trial court. Affidavit of

Tamara Erickson, p. 3, para. 5.

A-49

3. In September 1999, there were 10,578 foster children

in the state’s custody pursuant to RCW 74.13. Affidavit of

Tamara Erickson, p. 3, para. 4.

4. In September 1999, there were an additional 2,352

foster children for whom the Children’s Administration may

be responsible for providing the funding for maintenance and

care but who were in the custody of a private child-placing

agency, tribe or tribal child-placing agency, or other

organization. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 3, para. 4.

5. Additionally, another 567 individuals under the age of

21 receive services from the Department of Social and Health

Services (DSHS), Division of Developmental Disabilities,

under RCW 74.13.350. Of these individuals, 303 of them

receive either SSA or SSI. These individuals are in the legal

custody of their birth/adoptive parents, have a guardian, or

may be emancipated. Affidavit of Linda Gil, p. 2, para. 3;

Linda Gil Deposition, p. 50, Il. 5-7.

Paragraph 2(b) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

6. In September 1999, there were approximately 1,480

children in foster care who were receiving social security

benefits. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 4, para. 6.

7. Approximately 923 of the 1,480 children in foster care

in September 1999 received SSI benefits under Title XVI of

the Social Security Act. Approximately 469 received SSA

benefits under Title I] of the Social Security Act, and

approximately 88 received both SSA and SSI benefits

concurrently. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 4, para. 6.

A - 50

Paragraph 2(c) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

8. In September 1999, the number of children in the

State’s custody pursuant to chapter 74.13 RCW, and for

whom the Secretary of DSHS is the representative payee

pursuant to provisions of 42 USCA § 405(j) (1998) was

1,411. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 2, para. 3.

9. Of these 1,411 children for whom DSHS serves as

representative payee, approximately 1,325 of them are in

foster care with the Children’s Administration. The

remaining 86 children are placed by the Division of

Developmental Disabilities (DDD). Affidavit of Karen

Kegley Justinen, p. 2, para. 3.

10. At the present time, the Cash Accounting Unit

receives $700,000 to $800,000 a month in SSI and SSA

funds. Approximately $505 per child and $520 per child is

received for two different SSI payments and approximately

$250 per child, on the average, is received in SSA payments.

Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 70, ll. 13-25; p. 71, Il.

1-8.

11. DSHS has forecasted receipt of $6,733,000 in

SSI/SSA revenue for the year 2000 for children in foster

care. See the Budget Forecasting Document from the

Tamara Erickson Deposition, attached hereto as Exhibit B.

Paragraph 2(d) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

12. Whenever a child in State foster care is entitled to

receive SSI or SSA benefit payments, the State applies to the

Social Security Administration to become the representative

A-51

payee except for developmentally disabled children since

July 1988. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, pp. 4-5, para. 8.

13. Title XVI (SSI) benefits are based on a child’s

disability. Title II (SSA) benefits are based on a death or

disability of a parent who contributed to the Social Security

program. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 2, para. 4.

14. The accounting for the way in which the state

processes and uses social security payments received by the

Secretary of DSHS on behalf of foster children in the custody

of DSHS, when the Secretary is their representative payee, is

done by the DSHS, Office of Accounting Services, Trust

Fund Unit. The Trust Fund Unit is also responsible for the

accounting of other monies received on behalf of children in

the care of DSHS, including Veterans Administration and

Railroad Retirement benefits, and Excess Child Support

Payments. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 2, para. 2.

15. The Trust Fund Unit is not part of the DSHS

Children’s Administration, which is responsible for child

protective, child welfare, family reconciliation and licensing

services in Washington State. Karen Kegley Justinen

Deposition, p. 8. The Children’s Administration is

responsible for foster care services for those children who

cannot remain in their own home as a result of abuse or

neglect. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 2, para. 1.

16. Karen Kegley Justinen oversees the Trust Fund Unit,

which records Title II (SSA) and Title XVI (SSI) benefit

payments received by the Cash Accounting Unit, on behalf of

the foster children, and maintains an individual “subsidiary

account” for each child receiving these benefits. Affidavit of

Karen Kegley Justinen, pp. 2-3, paras. 4-5.

A- 52

17. Every month, the Department receives SSI and SSA

payments on behalf of foster children in the custody of

DSHS, and for whom the Secretary is their representative

payee, and except for “retroactive SSI payments,” deposits

these funds in a Foster Care Trust Fund Account at the State

Treasurer’s Office. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 3,

para. 4. Karen Justinen Deposition, p. 9, ll. 6-15.

18. Retroactive SSI payments are lump sum payments of

over six times the monthly benefit amount. Since October of

1996, these lump sum retroactive SSI payments have been

subject to different rules and are accounted for differently.

They are deposited by the Social Security Administration

directly to a dedicated interest-bearing account at a local

bank. Payments deposited to this dedicated account, and the

interest earned, are credited to the individual child’s indi-

vidual subsidiary account maintained by the Trust Fund Unit.

Since October of 1996, regulations prohibit use of funds from

the dedicated accounts to provide for basic foster care

services. The funds can only be used for permitted expen-

ditures of special needs, primarily related to the child’s im-

pairment. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 3, para. 6.

18.1 The Department has not established how many

children have dedicated accounts. It is possible this

information was not requested or ordered produced by the

court. The record does not show how many dedicated

accounts there are, however, the Department has produced

samples of two such dedicated accounts. None of the 50

random accountings include dedicated accounts. This

information is not included in the accounting provided.

18.2 Prior to October of 1996, a different procedure

regarding SSI lump sum payments appears to have been

followed. An example of this is provided in the accounting

for Jasmine Cotton, where it appears that a lump sum

A-53

payment of the amount of $11,676 was received on May 8,

1996 and on June 2, 1996 the Children’s Administration was

reimbursed a total amount of $11,696.00 for past foster care

expenses from April of 1994 through April of 1996. There

is no evidence to contradict the finding that this was the

ordinary procedure followed prior to October of 1996.

19. The Trust Fund Unit has provided a summary page

for each of the 50 children’s accounts provided comine to

court order. The summary page lists six separate categories

as follows:

“Payments Received” Amount of SSI/SSA or both received.

“Interest Earned” Interest earned from money held in

trust.

“Payments Returned” Amount of Money Returned to the

Social Security Administration

“Account

Disbursements” SSA and or SSI Monies Spent Directly

for the Benefit of the Child for Items

Other Than Basic Foster Maintenance

Such as Clothing, Toys, Computers,

Summer Camps, Medical/Dental

Expenses, Educational Expenses, etc.

(See Summary Social Security

Accounting Cover Pages for Thomas

Bakkon and Danetta Hutchinson,

copies of which are attached hereto

and herein incorporated as if fully set

forth as Appendix “7”)

“Foster Care

Reimbursements” § Amount authorized by Trust Fund Unit

to be paid from the Children’s

Administration Trust Fund Account.

“Balance” Balance in the child’s trust fund

account.

(See Summary Social Security Accounting Cover Pages for

Thomas Bakkon and Danetta Hutchinson, copies of which

are attached hereto and herein incorporated as if fully set

forth in Exhibit “G”.)

Paragraph 2(d)(i) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand. (Individual Accounts)

20. The DSHS Office of Accounting Services, Trust

Fund Unit, maintains an individual “subsidiary” account for

each of the 1,411 children in the State’s custody pursuant to

chapter 74.13 RCW, and for whom the Secretary of DSHS is

the representative payee pursuant to provisions of 42 USCA

§ 405(j) (1998). Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 3,

paras. 4-5.

Paragraph 2(d)(iii) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand. (Pass Through)

(Note, paragraph 2d(iii) of the Order on Remand is

addressed prior to paragraph 2d(ii) for better continuity.)

21 The source of the funds available to the Children’s

Administration for foster care includes Federal and State

match Title IV-E funds, TANF, SSI, SSA monies, and

parental child support.

A-55

22. In developing the amount of the State’s funds needed

to make up the balance of the total foster care budget the

State includes as part of its revenue resources, SSA and SSI

payments anticipated to be received by DSHS as

representative payee. Tamara Erickson Deposition, p. 41, Il.

14-25, p. 42, p. 43, 1. 4. See the Budget Forecasting

Document from the Tamara Erickson Deposition, attached

hereto as Exhibit B.

23. The State’s inclusion of anticipated SSA and SSI

children benefit payments in the State budget reduces the

amount of money that the legislature is required to

appropriate to meet the State’s foster care expenditure

responsibilities. Tamara Erickson Deposition, p. 42, ll. 18-

25, p. 43, ll. 1-4.

24. The term “pass through” in the context of SSI and

SSA benefits is not one that is used by the DSHS Trust Fund

Unit. Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p 17, 1. 25; p. 18,

ll. 1-8. :

25. The Children’s Administration does not normally

directly purchase the food, clothing and shelter that a child in

foster care needs. Rather, such items are generally purchased

and provided to a foster child by a foster parent. The

Children’s Administration pays foster parents a base amount

from a pre-existing schedule. See the Family Foster Care

Rates schedule, attached as Exhibit C and by this reference is

incorporated herein. The special needs and exceptional costs

may be provided if funds are available.

26. Where a special need or extra item is authorized, the

Trust Fund Unit will issue a check drawn from a child’s

subsidiary account where SSI and SSA benefits were

deposited to issue a payment directly to a foster parent, store,

or other service provider. Such expenditures are authorized

A -56

under the discretion of the representative payee who

considers the extent that it benefits the client among other

considerations.

27. The Trust Fund Unit typically uses a child’s social

security payments to. pay for a child’s basic foster care

expenses. Every month the Children’s Administration

generates a report that shows for each child in foster care the

amount of money paid by the Children’s Administration to

the care provider for the cost of that care. The Trust Fund

Unit reviews the report and compares it to the child’s trust

fund account to determine the amount to be reimbursed for

the child’s foster care. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen,

p. 4, para. 8.

28. Each month the Trust Fund Unit accesses Children’s

Administration’s computer generated list of “reimbursable

foster care expenses” in order to determine how much of the

children’s SSI and SSA funds it will direct the State

Treasurer to pay to Children’s Administration.

29. In general, if the amount in the trust fund account is

adequate to reimburse the entire cost of the foster care, as

claimed by Children’s Administration, the entire claimed

amount is paid. If the funds in the trust fund account are not

adequate to reimburse the entire cost of the foster care, the

Trust Fund Unit uses up to the amount available in the trust

fund account. The amount to be paid for foster care is

transferred from the Trust Fund Unit’s Foster Care Trust

Fund Account to the Children’s Administration. Affidavit of

Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 4, para. 8.

30. The representative payee has the option to authorize

expenditure ci all of the SSA and or SSI benefit payments it

receives on items other than current foster care maintenance.

A-57

Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 76, ll. 14-25, p. 77,

ll. 1-4.

31. The Trust Fund Unit has the authority to disburse

from a child’s trust fund account monies for “extra items and

special needs” for the “direct benefit” of the child. Affidavit

of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 4, para. 9; Trust Fund

Handbook Section 3, Account Disbursements.

32. This discretion goes so far as to allow all of the

child’s trust funds to be expended for extra items and special

needs with nothing to be paid to Children’s Administration

for “reimbursement.” Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p.

18, ll. 9-25, p. 26, Il. 3-25, p. 27, ll. 1-2, p. 39, Il. 11-17, p.

76, ll. 14-25, p. 77, ll. 1-4.

33. “Direct benefit” is the standard by which the

representative payee is to judge approval of any disbursement

requests. Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p.. 76, ll. 14-15.

34. Children’s Administration staff can request that a

child’s Social Security payment(s) be used for the child’s

extra items or special needs instead of for basic foster care

costs. Children’s Administration staff can also request that a

child’s Social Security payments be conserved. Conservation

can be employed for a time period prior to their emancipation

to allow a child to have funds available when they transition

to living independently, or for further education or other

approved purposes for the direct benefit of the child.

Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, pp. 4- 5, paras. 9-10.

35. Upon request from the Children’s Administration

worker, funds may be disbursed from a child’s trust fund

account for both extra items and special needs of the child,

subject to Trust Fund Unit approval. Examples of the most

common disbursements are for computers, educational

A-58

expenses, summer camp, counseling, toys, clothing, athletic

equipment, orthodontics, etc. Affidavit of Karen Kegley

Justinen, pp. 4-5, paras. 9-10.

36. Examples of extra items or special needs which the

Trust Fund Unit recognized as appropriate expenditure of SSI

and SSA funds are computers, educational expenses, summer

camp, counseling, toys, clothing, athletic equipment,

orthodontics, etc. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 4,

para. 9.

37. The Department of Social and Health Services,

Office of Accounting Services, Trust Fund Handbook,

Section 3 provides, in part, as follows:

USE OF FUNDS: Funds can be used for any goods or

E ion hnatindin

clothing, toys, computer, summer camp, medical/dental

expenses (not covered by medical coupons), educational

expenses, etc. (our emphasis) (Trust Fund Handbook

Section 3.) (Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, Exhibit 5,

Section 3.)

38. The Secretary of DSHS is the representative payee.

The record does not establish that the Secretary or anyone

else has issued separate written instructions or guidelines

establishing when and if special needs, extra items and

savings should be requested or approved. Affidavit of Karen

Kegley Justinen, p. 2, paras. 1-2; Karen Kegley Justinen

Deposition, p. 48, ll. 12-25; p. 49, ll. 1-11.

39. The head of the Trust Fund Unit is unaware of what

the caseworkers in the field are told or what information they

are provided regarding when to request special items. Karen

Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 80, ll. 9-25, p. 81, ll. 1-4.

A-59

40. There is no evidence that the child or the foster care

provider are provided information about the availability of

the SSI and SSA payments to be expended, in their entirety if

deemed in the best interest of the child, for extra items and

special needs directly benefiting the child. As a result, some

eligible children probably fail to request extra items for

special needs.

41. There is no evidence that the representative payee

makes any regular, systematic or uniform attempt, on a

monthly basis or otherwise, to determine what “extra items”

and/or “special needs” would directly benefit the children in

State foster care before applying the SSA and SSI funds, in

his control, to reimburse Children’s Administration. Karen

Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 75, li. 24-25, p. 76, ll. 1-11.

42. Of the 48 randomly selected individual trust fund

accounts reviewed by plaintiffs counsel, 35 (or 73%)

received SSI benefit payments, 11 (or 23%) received SSA

benefit payments and 2 or 4% received both SSA and SSI.

43. Of the 35 children entitled to SSI benefits, the total

amount cf money received by the State was $596,378. The

total amount used by the Trust Fund Unit to fund the State’s

foster care budget was $501,556 (or 84%). The total amount

spent to directly benefit the child for extra items and special

needs “account disbursements”, was $19,534 (or 3%). See

Plaintiff's Summary of Payments for 48 Random Cases,

attached as Exhibit D.

44. Of the 11 children entitled to SSA benefits, the total

amount of money received by the State was $98.152. The

total amount used by the Trust Fund Unit to fund the State’s

foster care budget was $73,755 (or 75%). The total amount

spent to directly benefit the child for extra items and special

needs, “account disbursements,” was $4,180 (or 5%).

45. Of the two children entitled to combined SSA and

SSI benefits, the total amount of money received by the State

was $91,422. The total amount used by the Trust Fund Unit

to fund the State’s foster care budget was $87,586 (or 95%).

The total amount spent to directly benefit the child for extra

items and special needs, “account disbursements,” was $0

(0%).

46. Of all 48 accounts combined, the State received

$785,952 in SSA and or SSI benefit funds on behalf of the

children. To fund the State’s foster care budget, the State

reimbursed itself $662,897 (or 84%) from these same funds.

47. Of the 48 children for whom accounts were

randomly selected, ten received “extra items and or special

need” expenditures. This amounted to $23,714 (or 3%) of

the total $785,952 in benefit payments received by the State.

48. The 48 random accounts show 3 of the 30 males

received “account disbursements.” Eleven of 18 females

received $35,659 in “account disbursements.”

49. The record does not fully explain why special

benefits by way of “account disbursements” are not sought

for some children.

50. Children in state foster care whose SSA and SSI

benefits are paid to a representative payee other than the

Secretary of DSHS can still receive state supported foster

care maintenance. Tamara Erickson Deposition, p. 36, p. 37,

ll. 1-8.

51. Foster children who do not receive any SSI or SSA

benefits may qualify for extra items and special needs from

A-61

the total Foster Care Budget if funds are available. Tamara

Erickson Deposition, p. 51, ll. 3-19.

52. The record does not establish the extent to which

foster children who were not on SSI or SSA receive special

need payments or extra item payments.

53. The Department’s process for making a disbursement

from SSI or SSA benefits for extra items or special needs

starts when a Foster Parent and/or Children’s Administration

staff determine a child needs extra items or has any special

needs. If so, Children’s Administration staff submit a request

for disbursement of funds to the Trust Fund Unit. Trust Fund

staff review the request and if approved and the child has

available funds, the Trust Fund Unit disburses the funds.

Usually, a warrant is sent to the foster care provider made

payable to a store or other service provider. However,

occasionally warrants for extra items or special services are

sent directly to the store or other service provider. If the staff

is uncertain whether the request is an appropriate use of

social security funds, the staff will consult with the Social

Security Administration for approval. Affidavit of Karen

Kegley Justinen, pp. 4-5, paras. 9-10. The record does not

establish the existence of specific standards which direct

foster parents or caseworkers when to apply for special needs

or extra items.

54. Reimbursement is used by the Department to mean

that it must expend the money up-front. The Department

cannot claim federal funds back until the expenditure has

already been made. In that sense, it is a reimbursement

process, but only in the accounting sense.

55. Social Security Funds that are accounted for by the

Trust Fund Unit and are not used for basic foster care costs,

extra items, or special needs, are deposited into a collective

A - 62

interest bearing savings account at a local bank. It is the

policy of the Trust Fund Unit that the interest earned from

this collective account is to be credited to each child's

individual trust fund account on a monthly basis. These

funds are ultimately forwarded to the child’s successor

payee, or paid directly to the child if emancipated. Affidavit

of Karen Kegley Justinen, pp. 6-7, paras. 13-17.

Paragraph 2(d)(ii) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand. ($2000. Limit)

56. A child receiving SSI benefits cannot have available

resources over $2,000 and remain eligible for the monthly

SSI benefit. (Funds deposited to the Dedicated Account are

exempt from the $2,000 resource limit. The Children’s

Administration maintains that it is its policy to ensure a

child’s trust fund account balance remains below the resource

limit by reviewing every SSI account each month by Trust

Fund staff to determine if the balance is approaching the

resource limit. If the balance is nearing the resource limit,

the Trust Fund Unit contacts Children’s Administration staff

notifying them of the need to spend down the child’s account

balance. The Children’s Administration staff assess what

special needs of the child could be met using the excess

funds and request disbursement of funds from the Trust Fund

Unit. If the request is an appropriate use of the child’s Social

Security benefits, the Trust Fund Unit disburses the funds.

Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 5, para. 12; Affidavit

of Tamara Erickson, p. 5, para. 10. Prior to October 1996,

some accounts were spent down by reimbursing Children’s

Administration for previous basic care expenditures. None

of the 48 randomly selected accounts demonstrated the

spending down procedure after October 1996.

57. The State pays SSI payments to reimburse the

Children’s Administration as reimbursement for

A - 63

reimbursable foster care expenses as a means of not

exceeding the $2000 accumulation ceiling. Karen Kegley

Justinen Deposition, p. 41, ll. 20-25; p. 42, ll. 1-18.

58. “Account sweeping” sometimes results in taking all

the Social Security funds, which have accumulated to that

date, and applying them to all of the State's accumulated

reimbursable foster care expenses. For examples of “account

sweeping” see accoun's of Nacole Blimka, Case No. 4; Clark

Casey, Case No. 9; Jasmine Cotton, Case No. 11; Jennifer

Filbeck, Case No. 15; Clayton Gemoyla, Case No. 17;

Rachel Hernandez, Case No. 21; Christopher Mulkins, Case

No. 34; and others discussed in Plaintiffs’ Narrative

Summary of 48 Random Accounts. See Plaintiff's Narrative

Summary of 48 Random Cases, attached as Exhibit E.

Paragraph 2(e) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

59. Prior to applying to the Social Security

Administration to serve as representative payee, the

Children’s Administration identifies all children in the foster

care system who may have a significant mental or physical

impairment that would make them eligible for SSI benefits.

The Children’s Administration also must apply on behalf of

any child who is eligible for SSA benefits as required by 20

CFR 416.210. If Children’s Administration staff believe the

child may be eligible for SSI, the staff submits an application

to the Social Security Administration. If Children’s

Administration staff believe a denial of eligibility is

erroneous, they will appeal on behalf of the child. Affidavit

of Tamara Erickson, pp. 4 and 5, para. 8.

60. The Children’s Administration provides a number of

services to all foster children regardless of whether they

receive Social Security. Children’s Administration staff are

A - 64

responsible for monitoring a child’s service needs, including

food, clothing, shelter, therapy, child care (specialized or

regular), special dietary needs, any special equipment the

foster parent may need to care for the child, or any other

special needs the child has through the child’s case plan.

Children’s Administration is required to do an Individual

Service and Safety plan for each child in foster care. This

plan addresses the child’s needs and where the child shoul’

live. This plan also addresses the child’s permanent

placement (either returning home to their parents

(reunification) or another plan such as adoption or

guardianship if reunification is not possible) and what the

parents must do in order to achieve reunification. Affidavit

of Tamara Erickson, p. 5, para. 9.

61. Children’s Administration staff, along with Trust

Fund Unit staff, are also responsible for maintaining the

child’s eligibility for SSI benefits by monitoring the amount

of benefits available on a child’s behalf. If resources are

available beyond the monthly cost of foster care, staff may

identify additional service needs and will purchase those

services for the child. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 5,

para. 10; Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 5, para. 12.

62. If the child’s social worker identifies additional

services or needs beyond basic food, clothing, and shelter,

the social worker may recommend that the child’s monthly

social security benefits be used to pay for those needs or

services in addition to, or instead of, basic foster care

mainteaance. The DSHS will give priority to the special

needs when it is consistent with the social security

regulations and when it is in the child’s best interest.

Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 5, para. 11.

63. SSI financial redeterminations are completed by

Children’s Administration staff who interview the social

A-65

worker, child, foster parent, and/or guardian. Financial

redeterminations are required by the Social Security

Administration to determine continued income eligibility.

There are several different types of redetermination forms

used by the Social Security Administration depending on

whether or not the child is flagged by the Social Security

Administration as likely to have changes to their record, such

as frequent moves and wages or other sources of income.

Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, pp. 5 and 6, para. 12.

64. Children who receive SSI benefits are required by

the Social Security Administration to have completed

Continuing Disability Reviews (CDR). Children’s

Administration staff complete CDRs approximately every

three years and then again just before the child turns 18. Ifa

CDR is not completed, the child’s SSI benefits are terminated

by the Social Security Administration. Affidavit of Tamara

Erickson, p. 6, para. 13.

65. Children’s Administration staff report to the Social

Security Administration any changes to the child’s income

that will affect the SSI payment amount or continuing SSI

eligibility (i.e., wages, child support payments, etc.). For

example, Children’s Administration receives a list from the

DSHS, Division of Child Support, which match children

receiving an SSI benefit with those for whom the Division of

Child Support received a child support payment. The

Children’s Administration has the obligation to report these

child support collections to the Social Security

Administration as income, which could lower the child’s SSI

benefits (not dollar for dollar). In the past, Children’s

Administration has not filed such reports. Staff also notify

the Social Security Administration regarding changes in the

circumstances of the child (change of address, change in

custody, on the run, etc.).

A - 66

66. Children’s Administration staff complete the reports

and forms required by the Social Security Administration for

SSA benefits. For example, staff prepare Beneficiary

Recontact Reports which track beneficiaries’ marital status,

and student statement forms which track school attendance

for continued eligibility. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 6,

para. 15.

67. Children’s Administration staff also complete

Disabled Adult Child (DAC) claims for those children

receiving both SSA and SSI benefits or children receiving

SSA who may be eligible for SSI. The Disabled Adult Child

program allows a child, under certain circumstances, to

receive benefits under SSA beyond their 18” birthday.

Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 6, para. 16.

68. Children’s Administration staff assist 18-year-olds,

parents, adoptive parents, foster parents, and/or guardians in

accessing dedicated account funds. Affidavit of Tamara

Erickson, p. 7, para. 17.

69. Children’s Administration staff make necessary

arrangements with the new custodian or the 18-year-old to”

facilitate reunification or emancipation. Some children

would be unable to return home or live independently

without a source of income. With proper planning between

staff and the child or custodian, SSI eligibility may be

preserved with benefits available after the child leaves foster

care. If the child is eligible for SSA, staff advises the new

custodian or the 18-year-old on how to apply to the Social

Security Administration to become the new representative

payee. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p. 7, para. 18.

70. Children’s Administration staff also complete

adoption support screenings for SSI eligible children.

Children who are eligible for SSI are also eligible for medical

A -67

benefits under COBRA (Consolidated Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act). This service is provided because

families outside of Washington State adopt some children, or

the adoptive family may move to another state. COBRA

allows reciprocal medical coverage in other states that may

not be available otherwise. Affidavit of Tamara Erickson, p.

7, para. 19.

71. The Trust Fund Unit also monitors the amount of

monthly payment received for the child to ensure the correct

benefit amount is received from the Social Security

Administration, and monitors the amount of dedicated

installment payments deposited by the Social Security

Administration directly into the child’s dedicated account, to

ensure the correct retroactive benefit amount is received.

Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 6, para. 13.

72. Trust Fund Unit staff also communicate with the

Social Security Administration to resolve any discrepancies

regarding benefits due, overpayment amounts, etc. The Trust

Fund Unit will refund, to the Social Security Administration,

benefits for which the child is not entitled to. Affidavit of

Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 6, para. 14.

73. The Trust Fund Unit staff also comply with strict

reporting and accounting requirements. The Trust Fund Unit

reports to the Social Security Administration if balances

exceed the SSI resource limit of $2000; submits annual

accountings for each child to the Social Security

Administration (reporting on benefits received, used, and

conserved); and submits additional account information to

the Social Security Administration (interest earned, account

balances, etc.) as requested. The Trust Fund Unit maintains

complete and individual records of each child’s account for

auditing purposes. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Jusiinen, p. 6,

para. 15.

74. The Trust Fund Unit forwards a child’s remaining

balance or unused benefits to either the Social Security

Administration or the new payee when the Social Security

Administration appoints a new representative payee.

Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p. 6, para. 16.

Paragraph 2(f) of the Supreme Court’s Order on

Remand.

75. The actual number of class members is not

determinable from records available to DSHS. Based on

records available, there are up to 7,798 class members dating

back to July of 1991. Affidavit of Karen Kegley Justinen, p.

7, para. 19.

76. According to the Trust Fund Handbook, there are

approximately 2,000 children in State care with a trust fund

account. The State claims its records are available back to

1991. Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, Exhibit “5” Trust

Fund Handbook, Sec. 1.

The claims of the class extend back 18 years plus one

year for a total of 19 years back from the date of the filing of

plaintiffs’ action, i.e., to 1979.

Additional Findings of Fact to Assist the Court

77. The Department of Social and Health Services

admits that its divisions fail to communicate adequately with

regard to the accounting for and crediting of child support

payments made on behalf of foster children who are also

receiving SSA/SSI benefits. Karen Kegley Justinen

Deposition, Su, ll. 23-25; p. 51, Il. 1-4; p. 54, Il. 20-25,

Exhibit 3; p. 55, ll. 1-9.

A -69

78. When child support is collected, the portion

denominated as “current support” is used to offset “current

reimbursable foster care expenses.” Child support identified

as “Back Support” is used to repay accumulated reimbursable

foster care expenses. The excess of current support over

reimbursable foster care expenses is sent to the Trust Fund

Unit as excess child support. Affidavit of Alan Rhoten, p. 3,

para. 5.

79. The State’s system does not report to the Foster Care

Trust Fund Unit that it has used parental support to pay for

all or a part of “current reimbursable foster care expenses.”

Alan Rhoten Deposition, p. 38, Il. 5-21.

80. In those months when child support is received from

a parent of a child in state foster care who is also receiving

SSA and or SSI benefit payments, the child’s’ trust account

is not credited to the child’s subsidiary” trust accounting

record. Karen Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 55, Il. 9-25; p.

57; p. 58, Il. 1-19.

81. The head of the Trust Fund Unit has known, since at

least 1994, because of the failure of the Trust Fund Unit to

communicate with the Division of Children’s Services, that it

potentially reimburses itself twice for the same months foster

care expenses, once through use of the foster child’s SSA and

SSI money and once from parental support payments. Karen

Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 16; p. 17, ll. 1-19, Exhibit 3.

82. The State may experience a double payment when it

“sweeps” the children’s trust fund account to repay

reimbursable foster care expenses which have accumulated

from prior months where child support has already been paid.

For examples of such sweeping, see accounts of Nacole

Blimka, Case No. 4; Clark Casey, Case No. 9; Jasmine

Cotton, Case No. 11; Jennifer Filbeck, Case No. 15; Clayton

A-70

Gemoyla, Case No. 17; Rachel Hernandez, Case No. 21;

Christopher Mulkins, Case No. 34; and others discussed in -

Plaintiffs’ Narrative Summary of 48 Random Accounts.

83. To date, the State’s system has not been corrected to

eliminate this potential problem for double payment.. Karen

Kegley Justinen Deposition, p. 17, ll. 20-24, Exhibit 3.

84. The potential significance of this problem is

highlighted by the fact that the State forecasts collecting

approximately $3.25 million for FY2000 in child support for

children in foster care. See the Budget Forecasting

Document from the Tamara Erickson Deposition, attached

hereto as Exhibit B.

85. The source of funds for the Children’s

Administration’s total foster care budget for FY2000 is

$37,407,045 State Only, $9,317,124 Title IV-E, $3,579,000

TANF, and $3,579 Title XIX. See Source of Funds for

Foster Care Budget, attached as Exhibit F.

86. Most children in foster care qualify for Title IV-E

and/or TANF funding while awaiting a determination of

SSI/SSA benefits.

87. Following a determination of Social Security

eligibility, the State representative payee will receive a lump

sum payment for prior months’ eligibility.

88. Under the TANF Program, federal funding is

provided directly to the State to reimburse 100% of its

reimbursable foster care costs. Affidavit of Tamara

Erickson, pp. 31-33. Federal funding is also provided under

Title IV-E to reimburse a percentage of foster care costs.

Applications were made in some of the 48 random cases

under both programs for children in foster care receiving SSI

’ A-7i

and SSA. Eligibility requirements and funding availability

are such that the state does not apply for federal funding for

all children, neither does the state apply for federal funding

for all of a child’s costs. The State argues that its accounting

system is such that overpayments do not occur since the

federal share of foster care costs, collected from the foster

child’s trust fund account are passed through to the federal

government. The record does not establish this point or rule

it out.

89. Currently there are 567 Developmentally Disabled

children or qualifying young adults in Foster Care. Three

hundred three of them are entitled to receive Social Security

benefits. Linda Gil Deposition, p. 13, ll. 7-12.

90. The children with developmental disabilities were

transferred from the regular Foster Care Program,

administered by Children’s Services, into the Developmental

Disabilities Foster Care Program, administered by the

Department of Developmental Disabilities in July of 1998.

Affidavit of Linda Gil, p. 2, para. 5.

91. The transfer involved an Interagency Agreement,

which agreement contains a provision of unresolved issues

by a committee, identified in the agreement. Among the

unresolved issues were the responsibilities of the DSHS Trust

Fund Unit.

92. _ DSHS served as renresentative payee for the

Developmentally Disabled cuildren until July 1999.

Affidavit of Linda Gil, p. 2, para. 4. The Developmentally

Disabled Foster Care children were thus a part of the plaintiff

class when the Court entered its Order on January 5, 1996.

93. The Secretary of Washington State DSHS no longer

serves as representative payee for foster children with

A-72

Developmental Disabilities. Instead, various private agencies

such as the ARC of King County and the ARC of Spokane

now serve as representative payee. Linda Gil Deposition, p.

30, ll. 11-13.

94. The aforesaid institutional Private Representative

payees administer the Social Security benefits of the

developmentally disabled foster care children by re7rng the

benefits directly to the foster home. The State then p ys any

difference between the cost of foster care and the Social

Security benefit. Affidavit of Linda Gil, p. 4, paras. 9-10.

95. In this way, the State’s foster care payment for

Developmentally Disabled Foster Children is reduced by the

amount of their Social Security Benefit.

96. The State relies on the representative payee to pay all

SSI payments directly to the foster home. The record does

not establish that the State controls the decisions made by

representative payees in disposition of SSI/SSA funds. Linda

Gil Deposition, p. 32, ll. 16-20.

97. The Parents of the Developmentally Disabled Foster

Children are Required to Sign a Voluntary Placement

Agreement (VPA) which Provides in Part:

Parent/Guardian Agrees:

I voluntarily agree that the above named child be placed

in the care and under the supervision of DSHS. I!

authorize DSHS to carry out the duties and

responsibilities as described later in this agreement.

DSHS is further authorized to apply as a Representative

Payee for any benefits the child is eligible to receive, and

to use the fund to cover the cost of care and services

provided to the child. (Our emphasis)

L.SCOTT LOCKWOOD

98. It appears that developmentally disabled children do

not have SSI or SSA funds available for “special needs”,

“extra items” or savings.

DATED this 30th day of May, 2000.

: //s//

JUDGE JACK BURCHARD

Approved as to form only:

CHIRISTINE O. GREGOIRE

Attorney General

//s//

WSBA No. 19248

RODNEY M. REINBOLD

WSBA No. 4656

Co-Counsel for Plaintiffs

RICHARD B. PRICE

WSBA No. 3203

Co-Counsel for Plaintiffs

A-74

Exhibit A

[ATTORNEY GENERAL LETTERHEAD]

December 29, 1900

The Honorable Jack Burchard

Okanogan County Superior Court

149 Third N.

P.O. Box 112

Okanogan, WA 98840-0112

RE: i

Superior Court Cause No. 92-2-00157-2

Supreme Court Cause No. 67680-1

Dear Judge Burchard:

I represent the Department of Social and Health

Services in the above matter. As the court ordered in its

Scheduling Order on Proceedings on Remand from Supreme

Court, enclosed please find a copy of the August 1998 audit

by the Social Security Administration of the Department of

Social and Health Services referred to at page 7 of the amicus

curiae brief of the Commissioner of the United States Social

will be submitting a declaration in support of this audit report

by January 15, 2000.

Should you have any questions, please feel free to

contact me at (360) 459-6949.

Sincerely,

//s//

Debra E. Casparian

A-75

Exhibit A

Social & Health Services Division

(360) 459-6949

DEC:lan

Enc.

cc: Deborah Kant, Appellate Staff, Department of Justice

Victoria Blais, General Counsel, Social Security

Rodney Reinbold, Attorney at Law

Richard Price, Attorney at Law

A-76

Exhibit A

DECLARATION OF KEVIN MCCAHILL

1, Kevin McCahill, declare as follows:

1. I am an employee of the Social Security Administration,

Office of Program Benefits, Division of Representative

Payment and Evaluation (DRPE).

2. I traveled with Ed Fotheringill and other DRPE central

office staff members to Seattle the week of August 24,

1998 to August 28, 1998 to conduct onsite reviews of the

Washington State Department of Social and Health

Services (DSHS) and other organizational payees.

3. Mr. Fotheringill prepared the attached trip report on

September 28, 1998.

4. Mr. Fotheringill is no longer employed at the Social

Security Administration.

5. I have read Mr. Fotheringill’s trip report and believe that

it accurately depicts DRPE’s onsite review of DSHS and

the opinions DRPE formed about DSHS during the onsite

review.

Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746, I declare under penalty of

perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

//s//

Kevin McCahill

Senior Policy Analyst

Office Program Benefits

Division of Representative

Payment and Evaluation

A-77

Exhibit A

DRPE TRIP REPORT — SEATTLE 1998

DRPE Central Office Staff traveled to Seattle the week of

8/24-8/28/98 to conduct onsite reviews of three different

types of organizational payees: (1) a State mental facility

(Western State Hospital); (2) the Department of Social and

Health Services (DSHS); and (3) a _ fee-for-service

organization (Safety Net Services).

The fundamental purpose of the onsite reviews was three-

fold: (1) to gain a better understanding of how different

kinds of organizational payees operate; (2) to determine the

organizations’ strengths and weaknesses in the context of

payee performance; and (3) to encourage an open, responsive

line of communication between the organizations and the

parallel field offices.

DRPE staff was represented by Kevin McCahill, Pat Gregus,

Ray Hairston, and Ed Fotheringill. Seattle RO staff was

represented by Ila Andrews.

It is not the intention of this report to document, in detail, all

that transpired during the field reviews. Rather, the intention

is to give an over-view of some of the more noteworthy

insights gained from our discussions. Detailed information

will be made available upon any verbal de-briefing deemed

necessary.

Wednesday 8/26

Onsite Review of The Department of Social and Health

Services (DSHS), Olympia, WA:

The review methodology was four-fold:

A-78

Exhibit A

1. A discussion with DSHS administrators and staff on rep

payee duties and responsibilities;

2. A review of a sample of accounting records;

3. A discussion with case workers and SS] facilitaters;

4. A close-out session to discuss findings and make

recommendations for corrective action. r

The DSHS for the State of Washington is a model agency

that could stand as a prototype for effective organizational

payeeship. There is excellent communication both within

and between each DSHS component, as well as between the

DSHS and the parallel FO.

The foster care section provides a broad range of care and

maintenance, including emergency placements, family

conflict issues, child welfare services, psychological services

for both children and their parents, alcohol and drug

rehabilitation, etc. The key to the practical functioning of the

foster care section lies in the in-tandem work process

involving SSI facilitators (social workers who take the SSI

applications and handle all paperwork, money transactions,

and interaction with the FO) and case workers (social

workers who do all of the hands-on management of foster

care situations in the field). The SSI facilitators and case

workers are in constant communication and actually provide

a kind of check-and-balance function that is extremely

effective.

The accounting system is two dimensional: (1) there is an

automated record reflecting monies coming in and going out,

A-79

Exhibit A

and (2) a paper file, held by the case worker, showing the

entire paper tail for the case, including documentation of

expenditures. The separation of automated and paper records

makes an audit quite cumbersome, but when the files are

brought together with the automated records, the system

reflects accurate and responsible accounting. The only

recommendation for corrective action involved the posting of

interest to a few cases that had gone unrecognized.

The DSHS brought to our attention one issue that they

believe impedes inter-agency work effectiveness: FO

management is constantly rotating staff assignments and

responsibilities, making it difficult for DSHS and SSA to

have 4 liaison that can gain any momentum. As soon as the

the [sic] interagency relationship becomes comfortable and

effective, the FO manager rotates a new (and inexperienced)

person into the job. The current SSA Claims Rep wants to

Stay in the liaison position, but is scheduled to rotate out

shortly. We basically left this in Ila’s hands.

Brief meeting with Colleen St. Louis at the RO at Columbia

Tower:

Ed briefed Colleen on all that transpired at DSHS. Colleen

---unreadable--- (and relieved) that the inter-agency work . . .

A-80

Exhibit B

Forecast 11/98 for 99-01 budget [handwritten]

Recoveries Model Values

—— Recoveries Expenditures Actual

———— Recoveries Expenditures Forecast

Date Recoveries Date Recoveries

Jul-97 ~$742,357 Jul-99 -$755,835

Aug-97 -$734,409 Aug-99 -$755,164

Sep-97 -$724,047 Sep-99 -$754,493

Oct-97 -$728,563 Oct-99 -$753,822

Nov-97 -$740,867 Nov-99 -$753,152

Dec-97 -$738,170 - Dec-99 -$752,481

Jan-98 -$749,654 Jan-00 -$751,810

Feb-98 -$752,263 Feb-00 -$751,140

Mar-98 -$758,971 Mar-00 -$750,469

Apr-98 -$760,149 Apr-00 -$749,798

May-98 -$765,224 May-00 -$749,128

Jun-98 -$764,554 Jun-00 -$748,457

Jul-98 -$763,883 Jul-00 -$747,786

Aug-98 -$763,212 Aug-00 -$747,116

Sep-98 -$762,542 Sep-00 -$746,445

Oct-98 -$761,871 Oct-00 -$745,774

Nov-98 -$761,200 Nov-00 -$745,103

Dec-98 -$760,529 Dec-00 -$744,433

Exhibit B

Jan-99 -$759,859 Jan-01 -$743,762

Feb-99 -$759,188 Feb-01 -$743,091

Mar-99 -$758,517 Mar-01 -$742,421

Apr-99 -$757,847 — Apr-01 -$741,750

May-99 -$757,176 May-01 -$741,079

Jun-99 -$756,505 Jun-01 -$740,409

FY 98 ~ $8,959,208 FY 00 -$9,025,749 |

+t 99 -$9,122,329 FY Ol -$8,929,169

[97-99 Bi. -18,081,557 99-01 Bi. -17,954.918

RM 1000.xis

A -82

Exhibit B

This shows how foster care is spread to programs by the forecast.

The allotment distribution of foster care by month is shown on pages 15 and 16.

"Regions Allotment Region! Region 2

Allotment

FY00

Family Foster | A1910 $1,614,991 | 51,614,991 | 6,593,302 5,728,994

Care

Personal Care | A1920 1,302,292 1,302,292 174,096 151,274

Group Care Al193x, | 42,777,015 | 42,777,015 | 5,718,610 4,968,964

4x, 9x

Staff Secure A1996 1,050,600 1,050,600 140,449 122,037

GH

Receiving A1950 4,331,660 | 4,331,660 579,075 503,164

Homes

Mie PC afc. ARTS BRIS

Employ. FPCC | A1964 8,606,758 | 8,606,758 | 1,150,587 999,768

FH Recruit. A1965 447 000 447,000 26,068 22,651

FC Liaisons A1966 252,000 252,000 0 0

Passport Prog. | A1967 2,052,240 | 2,052,240 268,005 234,327

Intensive FC A1968 1,604,000 | 1,604,000 |

Assess

Adopt Home A1969 0 0

Study

FP Suprv.Visit | A1971 1,145,154 1,145,154 150,588 131,006

FP Training A1972 1,190,690 1,190,690

Reimburs. A1973 467,392 467,392

FP Supp.-DLR | A1976 100,000 | . 100,000

Other Services | A!961-78 | 14,112,257 | 14,112,257 | 1,864,486 1,618,461

Total Misc. A1960-70 | 29,977,491 | 29,977,491 | 3,459,734 3,006,203

FC Recoveries

Support Enfor. | A’98!-2 | (3,250,890) | (3,250,890) 0 0

SSI/SSA A1983 (6,733,676) | (6,733,676) | (900,185) (782,182)

Total Recov. A1980 | (9,984,566) | (9,984,566) | (900,185) (782,182)

A - 83

Exhibit B

“Region3 Region4 Region5 Region6 HQ

7,228,942 13,788,037 7,445,418 8,535,298 2,295,000-

190,880 364,072 196,598 225,374 0

6,269,923 11,958,864 6,457,681 7,402,973 0

153,989 293,709 158,600 181,816 0

634,901 1,210,971 653,914 749,635 0

1,261,512 2,406,130 1,299,289 1,489,482 0

28,582 54,515 29,437 33,747 252,000

0 0 0 0 252,000

308,739 500,920 340,601 363,994 35,654

1,604,000

176,697 301,290 185,057 200,518 0

1,190,690

467,392

100,000

2,017,747 3,972,208 2,052,486 2,391,029 195,840

3,793,277 7,235,063 3,906,870 4,478,788 4,097,576

0 0 0 0 (3,250,890)

(986,970) (1,882,486) (1,016,526) (1,165,327) 0

(986,970) (1,882,486) (1,016,526) (1,165,327) (3,250,890)

1,190,690

467,392

A - 84 A - 85

Exhibit B Exhibit B

Region 3 Region 4” Region 5 Region6 HQ

Regions Allotment egion! Region 2

Allotment

FY00

TITAS. 35968290 17,802,583 20,408,537 —

"Total Foster | Al900 | 121,609,483 731,069,483 | 15,765,081 13,698,454 802, 408. 3,141,686

a

orecast Months December January February

March

Total July August September October | November 0.08226 0.08227 0.08293 0.08563 oaesen aaaie ain

1.00000 0.07994 0.08194 0.08211 0.08217 0.08180

RM 1000.xls

A - 86

This shows how foster care is spread to programs by the forecast.

The allotment distribution of foster care by month is shown on pages | 5 and 16.

A -87

"Regions “Allotment Region! Region2

Allotment

FYOl

Family Foster | A1910 54,998,907 | 54,998,907 | 7,039,542 6,116,737

Care

Personal Care | A1920 1,164,561 1,164,561 155,682 135,276

Group Care A193x, | 46,527,545 | 46,527,545 | 6,210,994 5,404,625

4x, 9x

Staff Secure A1996 1,071,612 1,071,612 143,257 124,478

GH

Receiving A1950 4,485,574 | 4,485,574 599,649 521,043

Homes

Employ. FPCC | A1l964 9,967,152 9,967,152 | 1,332,451 1,157,781

FH Recruit. A1965 447,000 447,000 26,088 22,651

FC Liaisons A1966 252,000 252,000 0 0

Passport Prog. | A1967 2,093,285 2,093,285 273,365 239,014

Intensive FC A1968 1,604,000 1,604,000

Assess '

Adopt Home A1969 0

Study

FP Suprv.Visit | A197] 1,168,057 1,168,057 153,599 133,626

FP Training A1972 1,215,344 1,215,344

Reimburs. A1973 468,392 468,392

FP Supp.-DLR | A1976 100,000 100,000

Other Services | A1961-78 | 17,032,449 | 17,032,449 | 2,254,428 1,957,252

Total Misc. A1960-70 | 34,347,679 | 34,347,679 | 4,039,911 3,510,324

FC Recoveries

Support Enfor. | A198!-2 | (3,284,372) | (3,284,372) 0 0

SSI/SSA A1983 (6,661,623) | (6,661,623) | (890,554) (773,812)

Total Recov. A1980 | (9,945,995) | (9,945,995) | (890,554) (773,812)

“Region 3 Region 4 ~ RegionS Region6 HQ

7,718,202 14,721,222 7,949,330 9,112,974 2,340,900

170,691 325,568 175,805 201,539 0

8,819,647 19,007,373 7,023,867 8,052,039 0

157,069 299,583 161,772 185,453 0

657,461 1,254,000 677,149 776,272 0

1,460,908 2,788,445 1,504,658 1.724.911

, , , , , > 0

er we 29,437 33,747 252,000

0 0 252,000

314,914 510,938 347,413 371,274 36,367

1,604,000

, 0

180,231 307,316 188,758 204,527 0

1,215,344

468,392

100,

2,444,752 4,789,125 2,491,764 —- 2.895.371 aa

4,429,387 8,448,339 4,582,028. 5,229,830 4.127.860

5 ,

0 0 0 0 (3,284

72

(976,409) (1,862,342) (1,005,648) (1,152,858) — ;

(976,409) (1,862,342) (1,005,648) (1,152,858) (3,284,372)

1,215,344

468,392

A - 88 A-89

Exhibit B Exhibit B

Regions ‘ Allotment ion] Region 2

Allotment

FY00

Total Foster A1900 1 132,049,885 | 132,049,883 | 17.307.481 15,038,671

Care

Forecast Months December January February March ;

April Ma J

Total july August = September © October November 0.08185 _ 0.08209 ~—_0.08279 e..

100000 0.07931 0.08166 0.08190 ~—_—0.08175__—0.08 137 0.08592 0.08598 0.08694 0.08844

Allotment Methodology FY00-01 14.6572% 27.9563% 15.0961% 17.3050%

Total 100.00% 13.3684% 11.6160%

A-91

Exhibit C

This page intentionally left blank.

——

$6660 $1060 ys 08b v0'89P vs'ssv aed m4 + doy

18°97 py'siy y7'0lP vl LOE ve'Sse aaa SHVAA $0

le 1SE Zp bye L9' LEE LI'Sze L9ZIE anon

0) dq —ereud

. : 191504

107s! £0'6v! IVI shed — wo ae

16s L6LS 8°95 £895 vn evs 11099

o —or'ss z0'vs 96°75 9677S ae ec LY $010

& E $9°0S $96 89'S 89°83 89 2ouRMO||Y S[EIUSPIOU] [BUOSIAd

< : s9p|0 ® ZI

— — wtp ey'Z tyr oe oalteaaia

EV'le ov'9€ 69'SE 69st os aouemoj}y BuIyvoid

: saplo ZI

39°96 16° 88£ 87 18t 8L'89t 87'9St poten ssvoA + 019

8S vee Z0'8ZE 6S 1ZE 60'60t tn vent sswak ¢ 010

e$'£97 LESSZ O€ €S7Z 08° 0v7Z 0 (q2py) pseog 7F WOOY

| 201AJ9§

- 4 pe iy yom iesy oma King = 9661 “1 AIP asec) 193804 Aj)we4

‘ Aing = 661 ‘1 AIDE = 8661 “1 AIME L :

-_ 6661 “€ 2unf

sayey aed Jajso.4 Ajwey

A-92

Exhibit D

Page | “Payments | Interest yments

Received | Earned | Returned

"Galee Anderson. | 5S! |$ 24,243 | $0 2,919

“Thomas Bakkon | SSI | $ 28,418 $0.61 S~=«1,50)

Angeline Behrent | SSA |$ 19,418 | $0 |$ 1,158

Nacole Blimka Ssi_ |$ 10,916 $0 $3,003

Alisha Breaux ssi |$ 9,531 a Hu 953

Johnathan Cathey yo 1,886 | So )

Miracle Combs A |S 6856 | $2 |S Oo

Jasmine Cotton SSI |$ 23,362 ae im 0

illiam II] Dipert : a ~ $0 a

Latasha Enochs Ssi_ | $ 20,550 $62 |S 1,388 |

Jennifer Filbeck SS) 1 $ 49,507 | $75 1S 3,241 |

SSA

Monique Frazier | SSI | $ 22,025 | $56 |$ 1,357

(IV-E =

of Care)

1001.10

Clayton Gemoyla | SSI |$ 25.778 | $0 |S 1,

"Wisbea Graves A |$ 3,535 $28

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

Exhibit D

Account (2) Extra items & ~ Foster Care

Disbursements special needs Reimbursements

; .

_ 7 26,917

$ 1.296 Transferred to 16,964

New Rep. Payee

ieee $ 7,912

$ 0 8,584

a t 11,545

| 2 $ 15,028

S$ 0 $ 1,691

"$1,189 Transferred to $ 5,691

New Rep. Payee

$ 0 23,362

FS —

0 > 874

$ 1,232 Breakdown: $ 17,990

74.78 camp

$50.00 computer

200.00 clothes*

208.00 skating party

200.00 clothes*

*double billing _

vv wa overpayment 46,308

"$ 3,768 Breakdown: 16,954

670.00 computer

400.00 bicycle, toys, clothing

jacket, shoes

960.00 Ankle/foot orthosis &

collapsable stroller

$00.00 resting splint

1200.00 Trip to Disneyland

5 24,736 |

1,040 Breakdown: $ 1,743

115.00 insur. premium

825.00 ?

20.00 Therapy 4/97

20.00 Therapy 4/97

20.00 Therapy 4/97

20.00 Therapy 4/97

20.00 Therapy 8/97

A-94

Exhibit D

Page 2 ‘Payments | Interest | Payments

Received | Earned | Returned

Anthony Hallet 517,737 | 30 2275

“Because of

help, he got

to pay cost

of his food,

clothing and

shelter”?

Rachel Hernandez S194 | $0 TS 3,009

“Because her

yle Hontz SSA TS 143 | $0

$3530. | S108 | $3547

Hutchinson

source limit)

lasJohns | SSI_|$ 114 | $0 =

Jones SST ie o re Oo , ane"

Dustin King SSA_[S_ 3.682 | 301 |

7 $s 4900 | 30 |S 3,

Scont Lemiere | SSI] $38,194] $0] $7281

Zachery Lucas A |S 1,665 so TS 0]

Kyra Mitchell SSA |$ 13% |

Malbpre .

Sarah Nelson ssl 7S 3,503 | $0

(1)

(1)

$750 balance to father for ume child with

him, but State continued to pay Foster Care

Support! (3)

Exhibit D

Account (2) Extra items & Foster Care

Disbursements _ special needs Relmbursoments

ee 15,483

; 0 8,904

— 7 143

F750 Breakdown > 23,258

1,604 development toys, riding

lessons, copier, clothing

1,500 computer

1,492 swingset

1,636 Big Toy*

250 Big Toy

1,122 Furnitue & computer

*Told care worker only 200 available

a :

S950 Erroneous acct. - child got 0

nothing

. ee 0 3,682

e— _ 1,350

§ 0 30,913

"S333 Transferred wo New Rep 1534

Payee |

+ " $10,930

es 7 1,508

S354 “For care™ 73,669

"5 3:732 Guardianship Fees mt

A-9%6

Exhibit D

Page 3 “Payments | Interest yments

Received | Earned | Returned

Marcel Paul SsI_|$ 27,031 | $0 384

“Samantha SSA ; $is2 |S 0

Maurath

Alyssa McLennan | SSI |$ 14,497 | $66 |S 527.

Ryan O'Connor S$ 28,266 | $0 |$ 2,589,

Brandon Phillips | SSI 14,92 pS TS 505 |

SSI took

“Justin Reynolds I 13,791 | $0 4

Joseph Rogers SSI 12,036 | $0 |$ 1474,

Jasmine SSI [S$ 4,397 $0 1,404

Justin Scherer Ssl_|$ 24,078 | $54 15S 1,206

Leah Shay is 0; 9 TS

Denita Smith A |$ 5,977 | $0 |$ 610

"Daniel Stephenson | SSI | $ 38,662 | $0 |S 1,001

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

Exhibit D

Account (2) Extra items & “Foster Care

Disbursements special needs Reimbursements

i= $ 26,647

'$ 5,515 Transferredto NewRep. |S 17,329

$ 4,584 Breakdown $ 9,453

2,000 Bedroom set

328 Preschool

400 Daycare

700 Rocking chair, computer,

clothing, educational toys

365 Daycare a

$ 500 $ 25,176

“I am requesting DCFS forego

reimbursement in final month to provide

child _with transitional expenses he is

i yy

(Why not all children?)

0 8,642

vo Ue hy,

$ 1,519 New Trustee 12,047

0 $ 10,562

$ ol : 2,980

“After reimbursing for all care thru 2/97

oy’ 7 a remaining account balance of

5 525 tena $ 20,700

913 part payment on piano for

brothers

1,312 for one-half of beds for

brothers

ia F 0

$ 1,838 Breakdown: 3,529

614 for transition rent &

damage deposit

1,224 for rent & utilities —_

$ 0 $ 37,621

(1992-1997)

(2) See TRUST FUND HANDBOOK Section 3 Account Disbursements

(Dep. Justinen, Ex. 5)

(3) Smoking Gun

(4) Includes only amounts actually paid for direct benefit to children (i.e.,

small print)

A-98

Exhibit D

Page 4 ’ Payments

Received

Jacob Taylor 41,825

/SSI

Amanda SSA 6

Tulowetzke

Jay Warden $ 44,186

Wiley Anitra SSI |$ 21,436

(1) over payment

Exhibit D

(2) Extra items & "Foster Care

Disbursements special needs Reimbursements

S547 New Trustee 41.278

1991-1997)

“$11,300 19.488

9,197 transferred to Amanda

following Court ordered

DSHS denied $127.50

dental care bill?

See letter of Sharon

377 School clothes/supplies

875 Alternative school

200 School clothes

200 School clothes

Clothing

$ 42,580

(1991-1999)

Breakdown. ;

clothing, learning aids &

Plaintiff s Narrative Summary of

48 Random Cases

Date: March 9, 2000

Case No. 1:

Case No. 2:

Case No. 4:

Calee Anderson

Comments: 15 year old girl, who was in

foster care from 1993 until 1997. No Special

needs account disbursement was ever made on

her behalf.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $21,323.82 of foster care

reimbursement

Thomas Bakkon

Comments: This 12 year old in [sic] was in

foster care for 5 years (recorded). No Special

needs account disbursement was ever made on

her [sic] behalf.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $26,917.31 of foster care

reimbursement

Nacole Blimka

Comments: Nacole also received no

disbursements. The account was swept on

8/5/97 when the State reimbursed itself

Case No. 9:

Case No. 11:

A-101

Exhibit E

$1,966.20 for foster care previously provided.

Account again swept on 10/15/97 for $983.00

of previously provided foster care expenses.

Nacole’s case demonstrates that the State does

not pass benefits through to children but,

instead, repays itself for services already

provided.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $7,912.70 of foster care

reimbursement

Clark Casey

Comments: This is another illustration of

account sweeping. On a single day in 1995,

the State reimbursed itself $2,233 for foster

care provided in the months of May, June,

July, August, September and October of 1994.

No Special needs account disbursement was

ever made on Casesy’s [sic] behalf.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $2,233.00

Jasime Cotton

Comments: This case illustrates that the

payment was not a pass-through payment but

a reimbursement. On 5/8/96, Cotton received

$11,676.29 of social security payments, likely

lump sum social security award. The account

was diminished on 12/2/96 from $12,171.00

to $495.42. The State thus repaid foster care

A- 102

Exhibit E

expenses of $11,696.00 dating back to 4/94.

She received no account disbursements in hers

[sic] 3 years of foster care.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $23,362.37

Case No. 12: Latasha Enochs

Case No. 15:

Comments: Enochs received $200 for

clothing with some regularity to keep her

account balance below $2,000. She was also

sent to camp, and received a computer and

had a savings account.

Account Disbursements: $1,232

State Received: $20,550

Jennifer Filbec!

Comments: Jennifer was in foster care for 9

years. Caseworker identified no special needs

until last day of care when Jennifer received

$123.20. The case also illustrates that the

State repays itself foster care rather than

passing the benefits through to the children.

In July, 1989, the State repaid the cost of

foster care for August, October, November

and December, 1988; and May, 1989. It also

illustrates the State’s savings policy. For

instance, the State on 8/30/89 transferred

$300.00 to savings but withdrew from savings

on 12/4/89 $115.40 to repay its cost of foster

care having previously diminished the account

Case No. 16:

Case No. 17:

A- 103

Exhibit E

balance by foster care reimbursements to

itself.

Account Disbursements: $123.20

State Received: $46,308.63 for foster care

reimbursement

Monique Frazi

Comments: Monique Frazier received

$3,768.73 of account disbursements. In

March of 1995, she went to Disneyland; in

April of 1995, she received an ankle splint; in

July of 1995, she received a stroller; and in

March of 1997, she received a computer, all in

the category of special needs.

Account Disbursements: $3,768.73

State Received: $16,954.99 for foster care

reimbursement

Clayton Gemovla

Comments: On 9/18/96, Clayton received

$14,485.19, likely the lump sum payment.

$13,989.77 was then paid to the State. The

State received $25,778.17 and the boy

received nothing in his 2 years in foster care.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $24,736.17 for foster care

reimbursement

A- 104

Exhibit E

Case No. 21: Rachel Hernandez

Case No. 23:

Case No. 32:

Comments: State reimbursed itself

$1,966.20 on 6/18/97 to repay for services

previously rendered. Another illustration of

account sweeping and illustrates that the

state’s reimbursement program is repayment

of past debt and not pass through.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $8,904.80 for foster care

reimbursement

Danetta Hutchinson

Comments: Danetta received $7,604.60 of

special disbursements including a $1,600 big

toy. The price of the big toy exceeded her

foster care balance and the foster care

program reimbursed the remainder. She also

received a computer, toys, riding lessons, a

copier, clothing, and a savings account. State

paid itself $23,258.40 compared to Danetta’s

$7,604.60. Danetta received 33% of her

social security check back in special benefits.

Account Disbursements: $7,604.60

State Received: $23,258.40 for foster care

reimbursement

Alyssa McLennan

Comments: Alyssa received a _ rocking

chair, a keyboard, a clothing allowance, and

Case No. 34:

Case No. 36:

A- 105

Exhibit E

education toys totaling $4,584.26. The State

repaid itself $9,453.46. Here the caseworker

managed to provide 50% of the benefit to

meet special needs.

Account Disbursements: $4,584.26

State Received: $9,453.46 for foster care

reimbursement

Christopher Mulki

Comments: The State reimbursed itself

$23,669.88. Chris received special

disbursements of only $324.00. The State

swept the account on 2/2/96 collecting a little

over $1,500 to repay itself foster care it had

provided on 8/95, 9/95 and 12/95. In this

young man’s case, the State chose the sweep

method to keep the account below $2,000.

Account Disbursements: $324.00

State Received: $23,669.88 for foster care

reimbursement

Ryan O’Connor

Comments; From 1993 to 1998 the State

reimbursed itself $25,176.95. On the last day

of his care, Ryan received $500.00. Ryan is

disabled and started his adult live [sic] with

only $500.

Case No. 37:

Case No. 38:

Case No. 41:

Case No. 45:

A- 106

Exhibit E

Account Disbursements: $500.55

State Received: $25,176.95 for foster care

reimbursement

Marcel Paul

Comments: Marcel was in foster care from

1992-1997. He received no special account

disbursements.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $26,647.33

Brandon Philli

Comments: Brandon Phillips received no

money during his 3 yrs. in foster care.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $8,642.51

Joseph Rogers

Comments: 12 yr. old Joseph Rogers also

received no money between 1995-1997.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $10,562.13

Daniel Stephenson

Comments: From 1992-1998, the State paid

itself $37,621.73. This young man, between

Case No. 46:

Case No. 47:

A- 107

Exhibit E

the age of 6-12 Received [sic] no special

account disbursements.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $37,621.73

Jacob Taylor

Comments: Jacob Taylor, a male, collected

$41,825.96 of SSA/SSI benefits. The State

collected $41,278.08 and $547.88 was

returned to the Social Security Administration.

This young man received no money

whatsoever while he was in foster care.

Account Disbursements: $547.88

State Received: $41,278.08

Amanda Tulowetzke

Comments: This case, again, illustrates that

girls do a little better in foster are [sic] than do

boys. She received account disbursements of

$11,300.26. Caseworker requested money for

a dental crown. Trust fund unit refused

because dental crowns are not within medial

care authorized for federal reimbursement.

Amanda received regular disbursements from

her account for clothing, 3 months of

alternative school enrollment with supplies.

The lion’s share of her special reimbursement

occurred when she surprised DSHS with an

emancipation decree. She received $9,179.76

on the date of her emancipation.

Case No. 48:

A - 108

Exhibit E

Account Disbursements: $11,300.26

State Received: $19,488.93

Jay Warden

Comments: Jay Warden was in foster care

for 8 years, receiving no disbursements.

Account Disbursements: -0-

State Received: $43,580.92

A- 109

Exhibit F

Children’s Administration

Regional Allotments

10/29/99 12:34

C19

Source of Funds FY00

| 1910, 1920

State 37,407,045

Total State 37,407,045

IV-E (658) 9,317,124

_T19 (T & VU) 2,614,114

TANF 3,579,000

Total Federal 15,510,238

A-110

Exhibit G

SOCIAL SECURITY ACCOUNTING

Last Name HUTCHINSON

First Name DANETTA

MI

SSN 536-27-6761

DOB 4/5/93

Funding Source SSI

Payments Received $34,302.52

Interest Earned $108.08

Payments Returned $3,547.60

Account Disbursements $7,604.60

Foster Care Reimbursement $23,258.40

Balance $0.00

Wendesday, January 15, 2000

A-lll

Exhibit G

Social Security Accounting

Last Name BAKKON

First Name THOMAS

MI T

SSN 536-90-8793

DOB 7/22/81

Funding Source SSI

Payments Received $28,418.96

Interest Earned $0.00

Payments Returned $1,501.65

Account Disbursements $0.00

Foster Care Reimbursement $26,917.31

Balance $0.00

Thursday, December 23, 1999

A-112

SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON

COUNTY OF OKANOGAN

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF DANNY

KEFFELER, BY WANDA PIERCE,

GUARDIAN, AND OTHER PERSONS _| No, 96-2-00157-2

SIMILARLY SITUATED,

PLAINTIFF'S

Plaietitt, PROROSED

ORDER

v. GRANTING

PLAINTIFF'S

STATE OF WASHINGTON MOTION FOR

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND SUMMARY

HEALTH SERVICES, AND THE aincnanet

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING,

Defendants.

This matter came on for hearing upon Plaintiff's Motion

for Summary Judgment. The following documents were

considered.

I.

DOCUMENTS CONSIDERED

1. Complaint for Class Action, Cd 1;

2. Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment, Cd 35;

3. Declaration of Facts in Support of Plaintiff's Motion

for Summary Judgment, Cd 36, with attached Exhibit

Notebook;

A-113

4. The Exhibits contained in Plaintiff's Exhibit

Notebook referei sed in the aforesaid Declaration of

Facts, Cd 36;

5. Brief in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment

filed by Plaintiff, Cd 37;

6. Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment, filed by

the State of Washington, Department of Social and

Health Services, Cd 40;

7. Affidavit of Richard Anderson, dated July 24, 1997,

with attachments and exhibits, Cd 40;

8. Memorandum in Support of Defendant’s Motion for

Summary Judgment and in Opposition to Plaintiff's

Motion for Summary Judgment, filed by the State of

Washington, Cd 41;

9. Reply Brief filed by Plaintiffs, Cd 44A;

10. Affidavit of Richard J. Anderson, dated

September 17, 1997, Cd 51;

11. Department’s Response to Plaintiff's Reply Brief,

filed by the State of Washington, dated September 17,

1997, Cd 50;

12. Plaintiff's Motion to Amend Complaint to Clarify

Redress Sought by Plaintiffs, dated October 1, 1997,

Cd 46;

13. Plaintiffs Motion to Add Additional Named

Defendants as Parties in Interest, Cd 45;

14. Declaration of Richard Price, Cd 4

A-114

15. Plaintiff's Motion to Amend Complaint, Cd 55;

16. Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint, Cd 58;

“17. Defendant’s Motion to Strike Portions of Amended

Complaint, Cd 63;

18. Department’s Supplemental Memorandum in Support

of Motion for Summary Judgment, Cd 65;

19. Order Granting Amendment of Order Certifying

Class Action, Cd 66;

20. Order Allowing Amendment of Complaint, Cd 67;

21. Plaintiff's Reply brief re Motion to Strike, CD 68;

22. Department’s Supplemental Brief on Summary

Judgment, Cd 70;

23. Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss, Cd 71;

24. Defendant’s Memorandum in Support of Motion to

Dismiss, CD 73;

25. Plaintiff's Brief in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss,

Cd 74;

26. Plaintiff’ s Outline of Briefing Arguments (not filed);

27. Motion to Strike Outline of Briefing Arguments, Cd

75;

28. Outline of Defendants Briefing Arguments, Cd 77;

A-115

29. Memorandum Opinion, CD 78;

30. Arguments of Counsel, Rodney M. Reinbold for

Plaintiff and Debra Casparian for Defendants, heard

October 3, 1997;

31. Answer;

32. Motion for Class Action Certification;

33. Motion and Memorandum in Support of Motion to

Dismiss Office of Financial Recovery’s Failure to

Join a Necessary and Indispensable Party;

34. Amended Answer;

35. Reply Brief Re: Class Certification and Motion to

Join the Social Security Administration;

36. Order Certifying Case to Proceed as a Class Action,

Defining the Class and Denying the Defendant’s

otion [sic] to Dismiss; and

37. Motion to Amend Class.

NOW, THEREFORE,

Based upon the Court’s Memorandum Opinion dated

Po aay 29, 1998, the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary

udgment as amended, is granted, accordingly IT

ORDERED: nad -

A-116

Il.

INJUNCTIVE RELIEF

2.1 The State of Washington and its officers, agents or

representatives including the above named Defendants, Lyle

Quasim and Michael R. Hobbs, are enjoined from engaging

in any legal process to remove a private representative payee

designated by the Social Security Administration or to

institute or threaten to institute legal proceedings or

administrative proceedings to require a private ————

payee to repay the State of Washington for the cost 0

maintaining a child in foster care from Title Il Social

Security Benefits or Title XVI Social Security Benefits.

FURTHER ORDERED that the State of

a. H, : and its agents are mandatorily enjoined

beginning 120 days from entry of this Order, in those

situations where the State or its DSHS Trust Fund Unit,

apply to become a representative payee on behalf of minors

in its Foster Care Program, under Title II or Title XVI of the

Social Security Act, to, in advance of, or simultaneously with

such application, provided the minor child’s , [sic] parent or

legal guardian and court with notice including, but not .

limited to, at least, the following:

2.2.1 A written notice that any money received by the

representative payee is to be held in trust to be

paid for the benefit of the child beneficiary and

will not be paid to the state to offset the cost of

maintaining a child in foster, and

2.2.2 An lication form for representative payee

status is to be enclosed with a list of preferred

representative payees along with the necessary

mailing and filing deadline.

A-117

2.3 In those cases where the State of Washington, its

agents, or the Department of Social And Health Services

Trust Fund Unit, have been or will be serving as

Representative Payee under Title II or Title XVI of the Social

Security Act, for a child enrolled in the State’s foster care

program, the State of Washington, and its agents and

representative and the Washington State Department of

Social and Health Services Trust Fund Unit, are enjoined

from in any way administering the funds to offset the State’s

cost of maintaining a child in foster care but will administer

the program to maximize public assistance and social

security benefits.

III.

ACCOUNTING FOR DIVERTED BENEFITS

-3.1 The State of Washington, its agents, and its

Department of Social and Health Services Trust Fund Unit

are hereby ordered to provide to the Court and to Rodney

Reinbold and Richard Price within (120) days after this

Order is signed.

3.1.1 A list of all class members for whom it has acted

or is acting as representative payee under Title II

of the Social Security Act since April 18, 1975

and for whom the statute of limitations has not

expired; and

3.1.2 A list of all class members for whom it has acted

Or is acting as representative payee under Title

XVI of the Social Security Act since April 18,

1975 for whom the statute of limitation s [sic] has

not expired ; [sic] and

A-118

3.2 An accounting of all moneys received and spent for

each listed beneficiary since April 18, 1975, [sic]

3.3 Defendants will preserve all current records and will

not destroy, alter or purge any records now in existence.

3.4 The records produced shall be kept confidential by

the attorneys who receive them and they shall be filed with

the clerk of the court in a sealed envelope.

3.5 The Defendant, pursuant to RCW 40.14.060, has

destroyed records earlier than 1991.

IV.

RESTORATION OF DIVERTED FUNDS

4.1 Upon receipt of the aforesaid information, Richard

Price and Rodney Reinbold shall, within 45 days, file a claim

with the State of Washington Office of Risk Management

notifying the State of its obligation to restore benefits which

are revealed to have been wrongfully diverted from each

class member’s account. Such Claims shall include interest

at the rate of 12% per annum.

4.21IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the total dollar

amount determined in paragraph 4.1 shall be paid into a

single estate guardianship “common fund” to be administered

by an independent attorney/estate guardian approved by the

Court.

4.3 The guardian shall administer the common fund as

follows:

4.3.1 The Attorney/Guardian shall deposit and maintain

control of the monies funded by the state in a

4.3.2

4.3.3

4.3.4

4.3.5

4.3.6

A-119

single bank account entitled “Keffeler Class

Action Social Security Benefits Account”;

The Attorney/Guardian shall hire an accounting

firm, approved by the court, to establish an

accounting system in order to account to

individual class members in accordance with this

and subsequent orders. The Attorney/Guardian

shall invest the funds, pending distribution, in

accordance with RCW 11.92.040(5)(a);

The Attorney/Guardian shall pay the attorney fees

ordered by the Court;

The Attorney/Guardian shall apply for the set

aside of funds budgeted for administration of the

fund.

Following payment of attorney fees and set aside

for costs of administration, the Attorney/Guardian

shall disburse funds from the common account to

individual class members or their representative

payees on a pro-rata basis in accordance with the

accounting to be approved by this Court, and in

accordance with RCW Title 11 concerning the

disbursement of funds to minor guardianship

estate beneficiaries. Provided, however, in no

event shall the funds be disbursed to the State of

Washington to offset the cost of maintaining the

child in foster care.

The Attorney/Guardian shall file a quarterly

report with the Court as to all actions taken

including an accounting for all funds received and

disbursed.

A- 120

4.3.7 No administration fees or expenses shall be paid

unless approved by order of this Court.

V.

ATTORNEYS FEES

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Plaintiff should be

awarded attorney fees, the amount of which, and the theory

under which awarded, shall abide future ruling of this Court.

IV.

JUDGMENT IN FAVOR OF DANNY KEFFELER

6.1 The State of Washington violated 42 U.S.C. 408

when it and its agents diverted $4,998 (20 months payments

from July 1991 to March 1993) to itself to reimburse the

State’s cost of foster care for him. Accordingly, Danny

Keffeler is entitled to restoration of his Social Security

Benefits in the amount of $4,998 plus interest from May

1992, the midpoint between the months in which payments

were diverted (July 1991-March 1993), at the rate of 12% per

annum, which interest total $3, 872 to November 1, 1998.

6.2 Additionally, the State’s violation of 42 U.S.C. 408,

proximately caused Danny Keffeler to incur attorney’s fees

of $2,639, in appearances before the Social Security

Administration Board of Hearings and Appeals in defending

himself against the State of Washington’: effort to divert

$5,430 of his benefit.

6.3 Additionally, the State’s violation of 42 U.S.C. 408

proximately caused Danny Keffeler to incur attorneys fees in

appearances before the Superior Court of the State of

Washington to preserve Social Security moneys against

A-121

claims made by the State of Washington against his

Guardianship Estate for reimbursement of the a. of foster

care, which fees were in the amount of $2,791. This amount

should bear interest at 12% per annum as of February 2,

1995, approximately the last charge made, which will result

in interested charges of $1,256 to November 1998.

Dated: January 5, 1999.

/s//

Jack Burchard, Superior Court Judge

Presented by:

REINBOLD & GARDNER

//s//

Rodney Reinbold WSBA #4656

Attorney for Plaintiff

LAW OFFICES OF RICHARD B. PRICE, P.S.

//not s//

Richard B. Price, WSBA #3203

Attorney for Plaintiff

A- 123

A-122

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE children in foster care the state makes

STATE OF WASHINGTON of basic care and needs such as food, clothing oe nour

IN AND FOR THE medical care. ,

COUNTY OF OKANOGAN

q Danny Keffeler’s grandmother was appoi é‘

GUARDIANSHIP ESTATE OF DANNY his estate in state court and protective ey os

KEFFELER, BY WANDA PIERCE, social security payments by the Social Sect his

GUARDIAN, AND OTHER PERSONS | No, 96-2-00157-2 Administration. The State of Washingto cco

SIMILARLY SITUATED, Social and Health Servi stage aad

ces (DSHS) successfully applied to

MEMORANDUM | the Social Security Administration to be appoi ;

Plaintiff, ON payee (For th inted protective

OPINI or the purpose of this argument DSHS, DCFS and

v. ae ee eee omen Base, Se Oller

oe and Appeals eventually ruled that the

STATE OF WASHINGTON sandieneiios — so cums. §=Wille ik coved

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL AND pa ng) = ye Sry eng Se tapi pede

HEALTH SERVICES, QUASIM AND tp Snir 9-day

HOBBS, : payments and without his consent paid thet money to itself as

pensation for his foster care expenses.

Defendants.

When the grandmother instated

DSHS attempted collecti a a as protective payee

QUESTION PRESENTED: tion by filing a creditor’s claim and a

: motion to show cause in the state guardi .

DSHS also pursued administrati ty eg sea

Does 42 USC § 407 preempt the procedure whereby social securi d administrative appeals of the adverse

Washington DSHS, as protective payee, takes social urity administration action.

security benefits from children in compensation for ™ D iam

~ the cost of foster care? childrea j pe rol Keffeler’s claim is typical of all foster

benefits rn Washington who are entitled to social security

Danny Keffeler sues one behalf of himself and other apply a pea licy of the State of Washington DSHS to

foster children. Danny was placed in foster care in 1989. representativ ial Security Administration to become the

When his mother died in 1990, he was left with no surviving procedure i " + a é' for all children in foster care. That

parent and became eligible for social security survivor WAC 208-70.00n rized by state law. RCW 74.13.060.

benefits under Title Il. In the State of Washington cs gst rear + dings ped

dren in foster care receive survivor to itself < of foster children, it transfers the money

as reimbursement for foster care expenses it has paid.

approximately 370 chil

benefits under Title II of the Social Security Act and about

1261 receive benefits under Title XVI which provides

supplemental security income for the disabled. For all the

A-124

The Department of Social and Health Services is acting

under the authority of RCW 74.13.060 which provides in

relevant part:

The secretary or his designee or delegatee shall be the

custodian without compensation of such moneys and

other funds of any person which may come into the

possession of the secretary during the period such cone

is placed with the Department of Social and iH

Services pursuant to RCW 74.13. As such custodian, the

secretary shall have authority to disburse moneys from

the person’s funds for the following purposes only and

subject to the following limitations.

_. . (2) The secretary may apply such funds against the

Pa. of public assistance otherwise payable to such

person. This includes applying, as reimbursement, dl

benefits, payments, funds, or accrual paid to or on behal

of said person from any source against the amount of

public assistance expended on behalf of said person. .. .

The Department believes that a number of enernag tn

regulations also require it to use foster children’s ow

security benefits to repay the cost of foster care.

Department particularly relies upon WAC 388-70-069 whic

states:

ild i i i ial benefits

1) If a child in foster care is entitled to financial

~ income shall be used on behalf of the child to help

pay for the cost of the foster care received ....

(a) Income includes SSI, RSDI, veteran’s benefits,

railroad retirement benefits, inheritances, or any other

payment for which the child is eligible. . . .

A- 125

For the sole purpose of obtaining reimbursement for

foster care costs, DSHS applies to the Social Security

Administration to be appointed representative payee for all

children in foster care who are eligible for social security

benefits. Under federal regulation DSHS may be appointed

as representative payee. DSHS claims that when it

compensates itself for foster care services it is acting

properly because it is using the money toward the cost of

maintenance (including food, shelter, clothing, medical care

and personal comfort items) as required by federal law, 20

CFR § 404.

Similar state attempts to reach social security payments

have experienced a history of rejection. The issue arises

because federal law provides unique protections to social

security payments. 42 USC § 407 states:

(a) The right of any person to any future payment under

this subchapter shall not be transferable or assignable, at

law or in equity, and none of the moneys paid or payable

or rights existing under this subchapter shall be subject to

execution, levy, attachment, garnishment, or other legal

‘process, or to the operation of any bankruptcy or

insolvency law.

(b) No other provision of law, enacted, on or after April

20, 1983, may be construed to limit, supersede, or

otherwise modify the provisions of this section except to

the extent that it does so by express reference to this

section.

- The Supreme Court first addressed the issue in Philpott v.

Essex County Welfare Board, 409 U.S. 413, 93 S. Ct. 590, 34

L. Ed. 2d 608 (1973). New Jersey provided financial

assistance to the totally disabled. As a condition of receiving

assistance they were required to execute an agreement to

A- 126

reimburse the county welfare board. When one of the

beneficiaries collected social security disability, the welfare

board sued to enforce the agreement to reimburse. The

Supreme Court ruled that § 407 bars a state from attempting

to attach social security ben

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.