Amicus Curiae Brief — Borden Ranch Partnership v. United States Army Corps of Engineers
Supreme Court brief2002
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 01-1243
In the =
Supreme Court of the United States
>
BORDEN RANCH PARTNERSHIP;
ANGELO K. TSAKOPOULOS,
Petitioners,
Vv.
UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS;
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY,
Respondents.
—@——
On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
+
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF CALIFORNIA FARM
BUREAU FEDERATION, CALIFORNIA
CATTLEMEN’S ASSOCIATION, AND PACIFIC
LEGAL FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT OF
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
—>
ROBIN L. RIVETT
ee of Record
HOPPER
ieee Foundation
yet lacerville nt
5827
Telephone’ (9 73) stom tte
St a ( 16) 362-2932
Counsel for, Amici Curiae
California Farm Bureau
Zlee
i
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
Does deep plowing of normally dry, seasonally wet ranch
land, which involves turning over dirt in place, constitute
the addition of a pollutant under Section 404 of the Clean
Water Act?
Does Section 404 require a permit for deep plowing of
normally dry, seasonally wet ranch land, to plant deep-
rooted crops, when the Clean Water Act expressly
exempts normal farming and ranching activities, such as
plowing, from such permit requirements?
ll
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
QUESTIONS PRESENTED .............0ccceeeeees eee i
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES .............000cceceeeeee: «iii
INTEREST OF AMICICURIAE ............:00eeeeeeee. l
STATEMENT OF FACTS ......cccsccccccccscccccces 7
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ..........05.000ceeeeees 8
PPPPTTTTITT LITTLE LC LETT eee 10
I. THIS COURT SHOULD GRANT THE WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO RESOLVE CONFLICT AND
CONFUSION AMONG THE CIRCUITS........... . 10
Il. THIS COURT SHOULD GRANT THE WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO ADDRESS THE IMPORTANT
QUESTION OF WHETHER PLOWING RANCH
LAND IS EXPRESSLY EXEMP7T FROM SECTION
CUE ce scccesescccossrcccccceces . 1S
CEE S6NSb0ccrecdoscecovcscocccceccoscees . 19
=
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
Cases
Avoyelles Sportsmen's League, Inc. v. Marsh,
715 F.2d 897 (Sth Cir. 1983) ........ 0. cece ees 11-12
Borden Ranch Partnership v. Army Corps of
Engineers, 261 F.3d 810
SPEED oceccccecceescccessces 4, 12-14, 17-18
National Mining Association v. United States
Army Corps of Engineers, 145 F.3d 1399
i «eect ennaceeneeeeceeceess 9, 13-14
Rice v. Harken Exploration Co.,
250 F.3d 264 (Sth Cir. 2001)... 0. ccc ecccecccees 17
Rybachek v. United States Environmental
Protection Agency, 904 F.2d 1276
co ctdadedectvestesectecceseeces 13
Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County
v. United States Army Corps of Engineers,
PP ED cdccascicccedcecccess 11, 17-19
United States v. Akers,
785 F.2d 814 (Sth Cir. 1986)... 0... cece ee eee 18
United States v. Deaton,
EL EE « cc ccccccceceseceeces 14
United States v. Larkins,
Se EES EEE OS Vo scccccoccecccecece 9
United States v. Newdunn Associates,
Civ. No. 2:01cv508 (E.D. Va. Opinion
Sy FUE ER NEED ccccccccccccccccccccces 17
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
Page
United States v. Rapanos,
2002 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3957
(E.D. Mich. S.D. February 21, 2002) .............. 18
United States v. Riverside Bayview Homes,
ee cesvees 1
United States v. Wilson, 133 F.3d 251
°C" eR ee een re Rion 1
Statutes
SURG OUI icckks Shicdeeedeid ictar ede 1
REE. cndcsidebnckibdeetnilichduncOkseaces 8
OE eR rrr: end ete 1
OL REST RR a ARN ates SEP Ae 8
FR ne he ere ee 8-9
a RE Satna ry OL v Yet 16
alla APC RSE Me eae tie 17-18
TRAGER ete Ti ae TREE R 1.
SIE suc cesdeiusaendandielacaaiale 1
EPI E SL LL BBE Lat 12
ONE Re ee er OR Re dere eit 12
Regulations
33 C.F.R. § 323.2(a)(S) (1978)... 2... ccceceeeeeeees il
SIIGND ocnccccccdewethseebticiceeioedl 16
TS PE AOR om cnr erctenie meen stl 16
v
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
Page
BG Fe GR Fee cc ccccccccvcstccccccccosscecvcses 8
BREED cones coveseseeceececsecececéoos 16
DEED Sdcecdsacubacesecedsocsecosoese 13, 16
Rules |
Supreme Court Rule 37.3 ....... cece cescccccccceces l
8 PEPE TTTITTIT ITT TTI TTT TT TTI Tee l
Miscellaneous
A Legislative History of the Clean Water Act
of 1977, Vol. 3, (1978); House debate,
December 17, 1977, Report on Resolution
Providing For Consideration of Conference
Report on HR 3199, Clean Water Act of 1977 .... 15-16
Bianucci & Goodenow, The Impact of Section 404
of the Clean Water Act on Agricultural Land Use,
10 UCLA J. Envtl. L. & Pol’y 41 (1991) ........... 10
California Department of Food and Agriculture,
Agricultural Resource Directory 2001 (2001) .... 2-3,5
California Farm Bureau Federation, Facts & Stats
About California Agriculture (2002) ..........0004 6
Department of Water Resources, California
Water Plan Update Bulletin
We asebadeseessdeadeococccoescceceess 2
Goode, Bernard, & Albrecht, Virginia,
Wetland Regulation in the Real World,
ALI-ABA Course of Study Materials,
Vol. 1 (February, 1994)... 2... 2... c cece eee eee ee 6
vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
Interview with Hal Collin, President of
Agri-Struction (March 15, 2002) ............006. 2-3
Interview of Kevin Kester (March 12, 2002)............ 5
Kumiroff, Nikolai V., Sumner, Daniel A..,
& Goldman, George, The Measure of California
Agriculture 2000, University of California
Agricultural Issues Center, November, 2000. ......... 5
National Mining Association v. Army Corps
of Engineers, 27 Ecology Law Quarterly
CPU cadena dddecddendedocvocedicovcovvces 10
Regulatory Guidance Letter No. 96-02,
Applicability of Exemptions Under Section
404(4) to “Deep Ripping” Activities in Wetlands
ST CEE Ect ccccaseseeusesescoossess 7-8
United States Department of Agriculture, National
Agricultural Service, 1997 Census of Agriculture,
AC 97-S-2, Ranking of States and Counties,
Fa Sp PUNE Scbccadescccccuccccese 2
University of California Cooperative Extension,
California Cotton Review (Sept. 1977) .............. 2
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Managing and Modifying Problem Soils (1974) ....... 2
University of California Cooperative Extension, Production
Practices and Sample Costs to
Produce Loose Leaf Lettuce (1996) .............4.. 3
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
Page
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish an Almond Orchard
and Produce Almonds (2001) ..........0cceeeececece 2
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish an Apple Orchard
and Produce Apples (1994) ......... ccc cece ceeeees 3
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish a Fig Orchard
GER PCIGIEEED Cocco ceeds veccccececcess 3
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish a Manzanillo Olive
Orchard and Produce Olives (1997) ...........6.445: 3
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish an Orange Orchard
and Produce Oranges (1999) ........00.0ceeeeeeee 3
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish a Pecan Orchard
and Produce Pecans (1998) ..........000seeeeeues 3
University of California Cooperative Extension,
Sample Costs to Establish a Prune Orchard
and Produce Prunes (1997) .........00ccceccceees 3
University of California, Division of
Agricultural Sciences, Leaflet No. 2946,
How to Appraise Soil Physical Factors for
PE CE EEUED 0 clSbcecccveccccccccess 2
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE
Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.3, the California Farm
Bureau Federation, California Cattlemen’s Association, and
Pacific Legal Foundation respectfully submit this brief amicus
curiae in support of the Petition for a Writ of Certiorari.'
Written consent for amici curiae participation in this case was
granted by counsel of record for all parties.
The California Farm Bureau Federation (CFBF) is a
nonprofit, tax-exempt California corporation. Its members are
53 county farm bureaus located throughout California through
which it represents owners and operators of farms and ranches,
as well as other residents of the state who are interested in the
welfare of agriculture. CFBF represents approximately 43,000
California farm families who grow over 250 kinds of crops.
Many of these families farm on lands that contain the types of
seasonally wet ranch lands at issue in this case. If the Ninth
Circuit’s decision in this case is not overturned, these families
will no longer be allowed to choose what crop they wish to
grow if (ae crop requires deep plowing.’ Instead they will have
to seek approval from the federal government. Not only was
this requirement never intended by Congress, but having to seek
time delaying approvals is devastatingly incompatible with the
day to day needs of normal farming operations.
' Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.6, Amici Curiae California Farm
Bureau Federation, California Cattlemen's Association, and Pacific Legal
Foundation affirm that no counsel for any party in this case authored this
brief in whole or in part; and furthermore, that no person or entity has made
a monetary contribution specifically for the preparation or submission of this
brief.
? Deep plowing occurs where a crop needs irrigation water to penetrate
through the soil, but the soil is too highly compacted without the plowing.
Deep plowing is often needed to convert land from less-intensive agriculture,
such as grazing, to more intensive agriculture, such as orchards, vineyards,
alfalfa, and certain vegetable crops. This kind of plowing is done at depths
greater than 16 inches and can exceed 4 feet. See n.23 infra.
2
California agriculture has a tremendous impact on the
lives of individuals throughout the world. If California were a
country, it would be the sixth leading agricultural exporter in
the world.’ California is home to eight of the top ten United
States farm counties‘ and in every single one of them deep
plowing is a long practiced, normal farming activity.’
California’s top four farm exports—almonds, wine, cotton, and
table grapes°—all require deep plowing prior to planting.’
Besides producing all of the nation’s almonds, California is the
nation’s sole producer (99% or more) of figs, kiwi fruit, olives,
> Department of Water Resources, California Water Plan Update Bulletin
160-98, Vol. 1, 1-4 (1998).
* United States Department of Agriculture, National Agricultural Service,
1997 Census of Agriculture, AC 97-S-2, Ranking of States and Counties, 27,
Vol. 2, Subject Series Part 2.
5 Interview with Hal Collin, President of Agri-Struction (March 15, 2002),
a family-owned agricultural land improvement company in business since
1934. Deep plowing allows for better water penetration which in turn allows
the roots of the crop to grow deeper. This provides for more stability in tree
and vine crops. It also results in better yields, better quality, more efficient
use of the water applied to the crop, recharging the ground water, and more
efficient utilization of fertilizers and agricultural chemicals that are applied
to the crop. Jd. See also University of California Cooperative Extension,
Managing and Modifying Problem Soils 4-6 (1974).
° California Department of Food and Agriculture, Agricultural Resource
Directory 200] 34 (2001).
’ See University of California, Division of Agricultural Sciences, Leaflet
No. 2946, How to Appraise Soil Physical Factors for Irrigated Vineyards
(1977); University of California Cooperative Extension, Sample Costs to
Establish an Almond Orchard and Produce Almonds 3 (2001); University
of California Cooperative Extension, California Cotton Review 5-6 (Sept.
1977).
a Te ee TE
—— ———
3
persimmons, pistachios, prunes, raisins, and walnuts,’ each of
which also often requires deep plowing prior to planting
particularly in areas like California’s Central Valley that contain
clay soils.? Nectarines, peaches, plums, oranges, apples, pears,
gueros and jalapeno chili peppers, lettuce, all nut crops, loose
leaf lettuce, and alfalfa often require deep plowing too."°
The California Cattlemen’s Association (CCA) is a
nonprofit, tax-exempt California corporation. CCA represents
the majority of the California cattle industry and nearly 2000
ranching families statewide. California ranchers own over 20%
of the private land in this state, and cattle grazing in general
occurs on over 37% of the land mass in the state.'' CCA, like
CFBF, is deeply concerned that the Corps of Engineers’
exercise of Section 404 permitting jurisdiction over the deep
plowing of the usually dry, seasonally wet ranch land at issue in
this case, will have severe economic consequences on the
® California Department of Food and Agriculture, Agricultural Resource
Directory 200] 33.
Interview with Hal Collin, President of Agri-Struction (March 15, 2002).
See also University of California Cooperative Extension , Sample Costs to
Establish a Fig Orchard and Produce Figs 4 (1994); University of
California Cooperative Extension, Sample Costs to Establish a Manzanillo
Olive Orchard and Produce Olives 4 (1997); University of California
Cooperative Extension, Sample Costs to Establish a Prune Orchard and
Produce Prunes 4 (1997).
© See University of California Cooperative Extension, Sample Costs to
Establish an Orange Orchard and Produce Oranges 4 (1999); University
of California Cooperative Extension, Sample Costs to Establish an Apple
Orchard and Produce Apples 3 (1994); University of California Cooperative
Extension, Production Practices and Sample Costs to Produce Loose Leaf
Lettuce 3 (1996); University of California Cooperative Extension, Sample
Costs to Establish a Pecan Orchard and Produce Pecans 4 (1998).
'' http://www.calcattlemen.org/aboutcca.htm (last visited April 10, 2002).
4
state’s agricultural industry. Vernal pools’ and drainage
swales’® are pervasive throughout California’s ranch lands.
Many CCA members are terrified that their ability to continue
to graze and grow crops on their lands, indeed their very right
to maintain viable agricultural operations, will be seriously
undermined if the common activity of deep plowing in these
areas may not go forward without a permit from federal
bureaucrats.
Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) is the largest and most
experienced nonprofit public interest law foundation of its kind
in America. Litigating nationwide since 1973, PLF provides a
voice in the courts for thousands of Americans who believe in
limited government, private property rights, individual freedom,
and free enterprise. PLF is headquartered in Sacramento,
California, and has offices in Miami, Fiorida; Honolulu,
Hawaii; Bellevue, Washington; and a liaison office in
Anchorage, Alaska. PLF has participated in numerous cases
across the country concerning the interpretation of the Clean
Water Act and its restrictions on landowners’ rights to use their
private property in a reasonable, productive manner.
The ranchers and farmers amici represent are faced with
ever increasing demands to improve profitability or convert
their lands from agriculture to other uses. For instance,
between 1964 and 1997, the amount of land used for agriculture
in this country dropped about 16% to less than 932 million
'? Vernal pools are not at issue in this case. Borden Ranch Partnership v.
Army Corps of Engineers, 261 F.3d 810, 816 (9th Cir. 2001).
'> Drainage swales are “shallow linear features ranging from several inches
to several feet wide, and up to several hundred feet long—which exist and
carry stormwater runoff for brief periods only during and after seasonal
rains, and which ultimately drain to intermittent streams.” Pet. for a Writ of
Certiorari at 6.
5
acres.'* In California, the most productive agricultural state in
the country,’* agricultural land use dropped by well over 9
million acres during the same period—37 million to 27.7
million acres, a 25% reduction.'® Between 1988 and 1998 over
420,240 acres in agricultural production were converted to
urban and built up uses.’
However, the Ninth Circuit’s majority decision below
ignored the intent of Congress not to impede normal farming
activities with the Clean Water Act Section 404 program,”* but
has instead provided additional burdens that will force more
and more farm land into nonagricultural uses. For example, if
Parkfield, California, rancher and farmer Kevin Kester had been
unable to convert 51 acres of his grazing land in 1998 to
vineyards, he would have been forced to sell some of his land
for nonagricultural uses.'? The conversion from rangeland to
fully planted vineyards enabled Mr. Kester to obtain an
Nicolai V. Kumiroff, Daniel A. Sumner & George Goldman, The
Measure of California Agriculture 2000, University of California
Agricultural Issues Center, November, 2000, at 11.
'S California Department of Food and Agriculture, Agricultural Resource
Directory 200] 30.
‘© “Over a quarter of California’s landmass is used for agriculture
(down from over a third as recently as 1964). Just over half of the
27.7 million acres of agricultural land is pasture and range and about
39% is cropland. Most California farms are small in terms of cash
receipts and total sales, and are family or individually operated.
California has a greater share of female farm operators and farms
with Hispanic, Asian and Pacific Islander backgrounds than the
United States as a whole.”
Kumiroff, et al., at 7.
Kumiroff, et al., at 16.
'® See n.29, infra at 16.
'? Interview of Kevin Kester (March 12, 2002).
6
increased cash flow needed to pay estate taxes and avoid the
need to sell off part of his property. However, if Mr. Kester had
been subject to the Ninth Circuit’s Borden Ranch decision, he
would not have been able to take this action in a timely manner,
if at all. It could have taken well over a year just to get the
Section 404 permit needed to make the conversion.” However,
because the Borden Ranch decision did not apply to his
operation, he was able to act in a timely manner and keep all his
acres in agriculture.”'
This pressure to sell off land is a troubling scenario that is
repeating itself time and again. Farmers must retain flexibility
in their operations and an ability to make decisions quickly so
they can withstand the tremendous economic and societal
pressures arrayed against them. Estate taxes, property taxes,
market conditions, urban encroachment, changes in water
availability, environmental regulation, and a host of tensions
work against farming. The Ninth Circuit’s decision that the
federal government can regulate normal deep plowing under
Section 404 was never intended by Congress but is now one
more, possibly insurmountable, burden for a number of family
farmers in this country.
2° One study showed that the average amount of time necessary to obtain a
Section 404 permit was 373 days. Bernard Goode & Virginia Albrecht,
Wetland Regulation in the Real World, ALI-ABA Course of Study
Materials, Vol. 1 (February, 1994).
?! Farms provide significant open space and ecologically valuable habitat for
local flora and fauna. Indeed, 75% of the nation’s wildlife lives on farms
and ranches. California Farm Bureau Federation, Facts & Stats About
California Agriculture (2002).
ll
7
STATEMENT OF FACTS
In 1993, Borden Ranch Partnership acquired an
8,400-acre ranch in the Central Valley of California.” This
land had been used previously for cattle grazing, irrigated
pasture, and growing wheat, hay, alfalfa, and row crops.
Borden Ranch acquired the land to continue farming it and
introduce higher value vineyard and orchard crops. Pet. at 9.
Much of the soils on the ranch were heavily compacted
and if not subjected to the common soil preparation practice of
deep plowing, would not allow adequate penetration of
irrigation water needed for vineyard or orchard crops. Deep
plowing loosens and mixes—virtually in place—the compacted
soils to a depth of four to six feet. It breaks through the hard
soil to allow the percolation of irrigation water.”
2 The Central Valley has over one half of California’s agricultural land.
The Valley, with about 64% of California’s cropland, recorded 44% of
statewide cropland conversion out of agriculture between 1988 and 1998.
Valley grazing land, about 44% of state total, contributed 27% of total
grazing land conversions. Kumiroff, et al., at 19.
* The Corps describes deep plowing, which it calls deep-ripping, as
the mechanical manipulation of the soil to break up or pierce highly
compacted, impermeable or slowly permeable subsurface soil layers,
or other similar kinds of restrictive soil layers. These practices are
typically used to break up these subsoil layers (e.g., impermeable soil
layer, hardpan) as part of the initial preparation of the soil to
establish an agricultural or silvicultural operation. Deep-ripping and
related activities are also used in established farming operations to
break up highly compacted soil. Although deep-ripping and related
activities may be required more than once, the activity is typically not
an annual practice. Deep-ripping and related activities are
undertaken to improve site drainage and facilitate deep root growth,
and often occur to depths greater than 16 inches and, in some cases,
exceeding 4 feet below the surface .. ..
(continued...)
The Corps objected to Borden Ranch’s deep plowing in
areas the Corps contends contain waters of the United States
(seasonal drainages). The Corps charged that without a Permit,
the deep plowing in these areas constitutes a dischatge of
dredged or fill material prohibited by Section 404 of thé Clean
Water Act. The lower courts agreed with the Corps. (See Pet.
at 9-15, for a detailed explanation of the facts in this ca!S¢-)
Whether a Section 404 permit is required for the normal,
deep plowing that farmers must do for a variety of cropS !5 an
exceptionally important question of law. The Ninth Circuit's
answer that it does require a permit is contrary to thi¢ Plain
language and legislative history of the Clean Water Act. The
Corps has no jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act to regulate
Borden Ranch’s plowing, whether it be shallow or deep Pecause
Congress never sought to have the federal government Control
what crops a farmer may plant. However, if left int@ct, the
Ninth Circuit’s nonsensical decision will provide that authority
and, in the course, seriously hurt farming in California 44 this
nation.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
Section 404 of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1344,
authorizes the Corps” to require permits for those activities that
“discharge” or “add” a “pollutant” from a “point sour©e” into
waters of the United States. Section 404 express*Y exempts
from this permitting requirement “normal farmin 4nd ranching
activities, such as plowing,” which do not cvvert an area of
water “into a use to which it was not pre«“10usly subject.” 33
U.S.C. § 1344(f). This case involv~S ® question of great
2 (...continued) ew |
Regulatory Guidance Letter No. 96-2, Applicability of Exemptions Under
Section 404(4) to “Deep Rippiné Activities in Wetlands (December 12,
1996).
* The Environments’ Protection Agency (EPA) oversees the Corps’
enforcement of Sect00 404. 33 U.S.C. § 1344(c); 40 C.F.R. pt 231.
9
importance to the farmers of this country: does the Corps have
jurisdiction under Section 404 to prohibit a farmer from the
normal farming activity of deep plowing his soil so he can grow
the crop of his choice? The Ninth Circuit ruled that the Corps
did have jurisdiction over deep plowing and in so doing created
not only a conflict among the circuits, but also established a
direct contradiction with the express language of the Clean
Water Act and Congressional intent.
The Ninth Circuit's finding that the Corps has section 404
jurisdiction over deep plowing is in conflict with National
Mining Association v. United States Army Corps of Engineers,
145 F.3d 1399, 1404 (D.C. Cir. 1998). There the District of
Columbia Circuit held that incidental fallback of dirt into
wetlands during dredging activities is not an addition of a
pollutant and therefore is not subject to the Corps’ section 404
regulation. Deep plowing, which does not even remove soil
from the ground, is at most a type of incidental fallback that
adds no more of a pollutant to waters of the United States than
the fallback in National Mining. Additionally, the Ninth
Circuit’s finding that the normal farming activity of deep
plowing is not exempt from Section 404 regulation contradicts
both the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1344(f), and the Corps’
own regulations, 33 C.F.R § 323.4(1)(iii)(D). It also conflicts
with Congressional history. Each of these sources establishes
that the normal activity of plowing was never intended to be
subject to section 404 regulation. Nevertheless, through an
expansive regulatory interpretation of its authority, the Corps
has taken the position that it can stop a farmer from turning
over even a shovel full of dirt on his usually dry ranch land.”
5 One scholarly article evaluated the continuing expansion of the Corps’
jurisdiction and described it as “broadened by liberal interpretation of
wetlands physiology.” It cited with approval Judge Merrit from the Sixth
Circuit who stated in United States v. Larkins, 852 F.2d 189, 193-94 (Sth
Cir. 1988) (Merrit, C.J. concurring) that “the Corps has now expanded the
(continued...)
10
This Court should grant the Petition for a Writ of
Certiorari to eliminate this conflict between circuits and to rein
in the Corps’ unauthorized exercise of section 404 jurisdiction.
Otherwise, the future of family farming in this country will be
bleak indeed.
ARGUMENT
I
THIS COURT SHOULD GRANT THE WRIT
OF CERTIORARI TO RESOLVE CONFLICT
AND CONFUSION AMONG THE CIRCUITS
A critical question in this case is whether deep plowing
normally dry, seasonally wet ranch land adds a pollutant to
waters of the United States. Without such a finding, the Corps
has no Section 404 permitting jurisdiction over Borden Ranch
and other similar farm operations. This Court has provided no
definitive answer to this question while the circuits show no
consistency in confronting the issue.** We are left only with a
circuit conflict which needs to be resolved.
For plowing to be controlled by Section 404, it must
involve the “discharge of dredged or fill material into the
* (...continued)
definition of ‘navigable waters’ to include any creek or stream or moist area
...» A farmer's low-lying farmland or a homeowner's low-lying
backyard—adjacent to a small stream or creek, but many miles from a
navigable waterway—has apparently been converted into government
property no longer subject to control or improvement by the owner without
government permission.” Bianucci & Goodenow, The Impact of Section 404
of the Clean Water Act on Agricultural Land Use, 10 UCLA J. Envtl. L. &
Pol'y, 41 (1991).
* “The effect of the National Mining decision [no Section 404 jurisdiction
over incidental fallback) on holdings in other courts has been ambiguous.”
Morrison, Administrative Law, Clean Water Act: National Mining
Association v. Army Corps of Engineers, 27 Ecology Law Quarterly 649,
663-4 (2000).
11
navigable waters”’ at specified disposal sites.” 33 U.S.C.
§ 1344(a). This is a specific requirement derived from Section
301(a) of the Act which prohibits the “discharge of any
pollutant” unless in compliance with the permit (e.g., Section
404) requirements of the Act. 33 U.S.C. § 1311(a). The term
“pollutant” includes “dredged spoil, . . . rock, sand, cellar dirt
. .. and agricultural waste discharged into water,” 33 U.S.C.
§ 1362(6), and has been interpreted by the courts to include
soil. United States v. Wilson, 133 F.3d 251, 259 (4th Cir.
1997), Avoyelles Sportsmen's League, Inc. v. Marsh, 715 F.2d
897, 922 (Sth Cir. 1983). Thus, soil is a pollutant and can be
”” The Clean Water Act defines navigable waters only as “the waters of the
United States, including the territorial seas,” § 1362(7). This Court in Solid
Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v. United States Army Corps of
Engineers (SWANCC) 531 U.S. 159 (2001), addressed whether the Corps’
definition of “waters of the United States” in 33 C.F.R. § 323.2(a)(5) (1978),
term “navigable” out of the definition by expanding “waters of the United
States” to include “isolated wetlands” and later, “intermittent streams, prairie
potholes, and other waters that are not part of a tributary system to interstate
waters of the United States, the degradation of which could affect interstate
commerce.” 33 C.F.R. § 323.2(a)(5). This Court earlier found Section 404
jurisdiction over nonnavigable wetlands located directly adjacent to open
waters, United States v. Riverside Bayview Homes, 474 U.S. 121, 134
(1985), but in SWANCC the Court refused to expand jurisdiction per the
Corps’ regulation to “isolated wetlands” not adjacent to open water bodies.
To do so would make a nullity of the word “navigable” as used in the Clean
Water Act. SWANCC, 531 U.S. at 172.
While this Court did not address jurisdiction over the types of “wetlands”
now involved in this case, Amici strongly believe that this Court's reasoning
in SWANCC should also bring into question the Corps’ Section 404
jurisdiction over the “widely dispersed seasonal drainage swales and
intermittant drainages” on the “semi-arid Borden Ranch.” Pet. at 6. This
Court recognized that Congress may have intended Section 404 to cover
only “waters adjacent to ‘navigable waters,’ such as nonnavigable tributaries
and streams.” SWANCC, 531 U.S. at 171. Borden Ranch did not enter any
tributaries or streams but confined its plowing to less than a collective 2
acres of normally dry areas where rainwater collected or flowed downhill.
jurisdictional waters of the United States.
12
“dredged or fill material” subject to Section 404. However, for
“plowing” to be controlled by Section 404, it must also involve
the “discharge” of dredged or fill material.
The Act defines the “discharge of a pollutant” as “any
addition of any pollutant [or pollutants] to navigable waters
from any point source.” 33 U.S.C. § 1362(12) (emphasis
added). Accordingly, the terms “addition” and “point source”
also must be satisfied for plowing to come under Section 404
control. Unfortunately, the Act does not define the term
“addition,” although it does define “point source” as any
discernable, confined, and discrete conveyance, including but
not limited to any pipe, ditch, channel, tunnel, conduit, well,
discrete fissure, container, rolling stock, concentrated animal
feeding operation, or vessel or other floating craft, from which
pollutants are or may be discharged.” 33 U.S.C. § 1362(14).
The Corps concluded that Borden Ranch’s plowing is
subject to Section 404 control because it causes the addition of
a pollutant (dirt) from a point source (plow) into navigable
waters (normally dry, seasonally wet ranch land) at specified
disposal sites (the plowed ranch land). The Ninth Circuit
agreed, ruling that the plowing here constitutes an “addition” of
a pollutant. Borden Ranch, 261 F.3d at 814. But this finding
and the court’s reasoning conflict with the District of Columbia
** Amici agree with Petitioners that a plow has never been characterized
before as a “point source” (Pet. at 20) and by doing so the lower court has
put the nation’s farmers in a tenuous situation. When they plow a wet area,
must they first obtain permission from the Corps? Amici agree with
used by Borden Ranch to the bulldozers and backhoes previously found to
constitute point sources. In those latter instances, that machinery was used
for clearing the land by significant soil] movement, leveling, and filling
sloughs and cutting brush and vegetation at ground level. See Avoyelles, 715
F.2d at 923. However, that machinery was not used just to turn over and
break up soil as was the machinery in this case. Thus, the lower court's
likening of the machinery used to remove, redistribute, and pile dirt in
wetlands to machinery used only to mix and loosen the soil in place is faulty.
13
Circuit’s decision in National Mining Association, 145 F.3d
1399. In that case, the Corps sought to regulate under Section
404 the removal of soil from a wetland area where, during
removal, some of the dirt would fall back onto the wetland.
The court found that
the straightforward statutory term “additions” cannot
reasonably be said to encompass the situation in
which material is removed from the waters of the
United States and a small portion of it happens to fall
back. Because incidental fallback represents a net
withdrawal, not an addition, of material, it cannot be
a discharge.
Id. at 1404. Of course, plowing also is not an act of discharge
or adding pollutants to a wetland. It is an act of “breaking up,
cutting, turning over, or stirring of soil to prepare it for the
planting of crops.” 33 C.F.R. § 323.4(1)iiiX(D); 40 C.F.R.
§ 232.3(d)(4). All plowing involves nothing more than the
“incidental fall back” of soil that is being broken up and turned
over. It “adds” nothing to the land.
However, rather than recognize National Mining
Association as controlling, the court instead found Borden
Ranch was governed by two completely inapposite cases, one
in the Ninth and one in the Fourth Circuit. See Borden Ranch,
261 F.3d at 814. In those cases, soils had been removed by
buckets from waters and wetlands and then later redeposited
into those areas. In Rybachek v. United States Environmental
Protection Agency, 904 F.2d 1276 (9th Cir. 1990), a placer
miner excavated dirt and gravel from a stream bed to an out of
stream location, sifted out the gold, and later disposed of the
leftover waste material by redepositing it back into the stream.
This is not comparable to the instant situation. Borden Ranch
did not remove the soil, change its character, and redeposit the
spoils. To the contrary, Borden Ranch simply turned the dirt
over in place. Borden Ranch added no pollutant by its deep
14
plowing. As Judge Gould explained in his dissent in this case,
deep plowing “does not involve any significant removal or
‘addition’ of material to a site.” Borden Ranch, 261 F.3d at
820. Moreover, “[b]ecause deep [plowing] does not move any
material to a substantially different geographic location and
does not process such material for any period of time,
Rybacheck is not controlling.” Jd.
The second case relied on by the majority, United States
v. Deaton, 209 F.3d 331 (4th Cir. 2000), is no more persuasive.
In that case, a landowner excavated a drainage ditch in wetlands
and sidecast the dredged material onto the wetlands bank
alongside the ditch. The court adopted the position that once
material is removed from a wetland it becomes a pollutant, and
its redeposit becomes an addition of a pollutant subject to
Section 404. Jd. at 335-36. Under this creative reasoning, the
major *y in this case found deep plowing was analogous to
Deaton’s sidecasting although there was no removal and
redepositing of the dirt. Borden Ranch, 261 F.3d at 814. In
contrast, dissenting Judge Gould once again found National
Mining Association more persuasive stating, “[a] farmer who
plows deeply is not, in my view, redepositing dredged or
excavated materials.” /d. at 820.
Thus, the reasoning of the Ninth Circuit majority in this
case squarely conflicts with the reasoning of the D.C. Circuit in
National Mining Association. This underscores a clear conflict
as to which circuit’s decision controls “deep plowing.” This
Court should grant certiorari to clear up this conflict. Does
deep plowing on normally dry, seasonally wet ranch land add
a pollutant to the nation’s waters subjecting it to Section 404
regulation? Amici emphatically believe it does not, but without
Supreme Court intervention regulation of this common
agricultural practice will continue as a serious detriment to
15
THIS COURT SHOULD GRANT THE WRIT OF
CERTIORARI TO ADDRESS THE IMPORTANT
QUESTION OF WHETHER PLOWING RANCH
LAND IS EXPRESSLY EXEMPT FROM
SECTION 404 REGULATION
The Ninth Circuit’s determination that the Corps has
Section 404 permitting jurisdiction over Borden Ranch’s
seasonally wet ranch land raises another serious question that
needs to be resolved. Is plowing such land that has a history of
uninterrupted agricultural use exempt from Section 404
regulation where the purpose of the plowing is to plant a new
crop that needs better percolating soil? As shown earlier, supra
at 2-5, ranchers and farmers regularly convert from one crop to
another as part of normal farming operations. Economic
exigencies often call for it. Congress knew this and wanted to
make sure such management decisions were not encumbered by
Section 404. In fact, because Congress “emphatically did not
want the law to impede these bucolic pursuits,” National
Mining Association, 145 F.3d at 1405, Congress passed
amendments to the Clean Water Act in 1977 adding specific
exemptions for farming activities.”
> Congressman Roberts explained that due to the regulatory expansion of
the Section 404 program since its 1972 inception, the bill “excluded from
regulation normal ranching activities.” A Legislative History of the Clean
Water Act of 1977, Vol. 3 (1978); House debate, December 17, 1977,
Report on Resolution Providing For Consideration of Conference Report on
HR 3199, Clean Water Act of 1977 at 351 (hereinafter Clean Water Act
Legislative History). Congressman Hammerschmidt further clarified that
we will now have for the first time statutory recognition that normal
intended these activities to be considered discharges of dredged or
fill material. Jd. at 349.
Congressman Stump explained that “(t]he conferees have clarified that
plowing . . . [was] not intended to require Section 404 permits.” /d. at 420.
(continued...)
16
Section 404 was amended to allow, without a permit, any
discharge from normal farming, silviculture, and ranching
activities such as plowing, seeding, cultivating, minor drainage,
harvesting for the production of food, fiber, and forest products,
or upland soil and water conservation practices. 33 U.S.C.
§ 1344(f)(1)(A). This subsection does not limit itself to certain
types of plowing but the Corps unilaterally decided in 1996,
without formal rulemaking, that the deep plowing needed to
prepare compacted soil for vineyards or orchards does not
constitute a “normal farming” activity. (See Petitioner’s
Appendix 4, 199-207; RGL 96-02.) This new interpretation
conflicts with the government’s own regulations which
recognize that plowing is not a Section 404 regulated activity
and, hence, is a normal farming activity. See 33 C.F.R.
§ 323.2(f); 40 C.F.R. § 232.3(c)(1)(i). When defining what the
term “discharge of fill material” means, the Corps of Engineers
categorically states that “the term does not include plowing.”
33 C.F.R. § 323.2(e). EPA’s regulatory definition for plowing,
40 C.F.R. § 232.3(D)(4), expresses the same conclusion:
Plowing means all forms of primary tillage,
including moldboard, chisel, or wide-blade plowing,
discing, harrowing, and similar physical means used
on farm, forest or ranch land for the breaking up,
# (...continued)
Later in debate, conferee Senator Stafford further clarified the conference
report explaining that
the bill includes the clarification that permits are not required for
certain normal farming activities such as plowing and seeding which
are not discharges of dredged or fill material.
Id. at 485. He also explained that other farming activity that would “connect
water to dry land including, for example, those occasional farm or forestry
activities that involve dikes, levees or other fills in wetland or other waters,”
activities unlike plowing, would still require a permit. Jd. And last, Senator
Baker made it quite clear in debate that “activities . . . such as plowing. . .
do not involve point source discharge of dredged or fill material.” Jd. at
524.
17
cutting, turning over, or stirring of soil to prepare it
for the planting of crops .... Plowing, as described
above, will never involve a discharge of dredged or
fill material.
Thus, all plowing, including deep plowing, must be a normal
farming activity within the meaning of Section 404(f)(1)(A), or
it would not be expressly excluded from the meaning of
“discharge of dredged or fill material” by the Corps’ and EPA’s
own regulations.
However, the court below found otherwise and also ruled
that even if the deep plowing were exempt, Subsection (f)(2)
provides an exception to the farming exemptions applied to
Borden Ranch. Borden Ranch, 261 F.3d at 815. Subsection
(f)(2) is known as the recapture provision. It states:
Any discharge of dredged or fill material into the
navigable waters incidents] to any activity having as
its purpose bringing an area of the navigable waters
into a use to which it was not previously subject,
where the flow or circulation of navigable waters
may be impaired or the reach of such waters be
reduced, shall be required to have a permit under this
section.”
© Once again, the application of Section 404 is limited by its express terms
to “navigable waters.” Under SWANCC, waters of the United States subject
to Section 404 jurisdiction include wetlands adjacent to traditional navigable
waters, possibly including adjacent nonnavigable tributaries and streams.
531 U.S. at 172. However, it is undisputed that Borden Ranch did not
conduct plowing activities in wetlands adjacent to either traditional
navigable waters or nonnavigable tributaries or streams. As expressed by the
Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in Rice v. Harken Exploration Co., 250 F.3d
264, 271 (Sth Cir. 2001), “it would be an unwarranted expansion of [the
Clean Water Act] to find that discharges onto land that only infrequently
carried running water were discharges into navigable waters.” See also
United States v. Newdunn Associates, Civ. No. 2:0lev508 (E.D. Va.
Opinion and Order, April 3, 2002) (no Section 40% jurisdiction over surface
(continued...)
alee cia
18
33 U.S.C. § 1344(f)(2) (footnote added).
The Ninth Circuit interpreted this subsection to negate the
subsection (f)(1) plowing exemption if a farmer is changing his
crop, for example, from seasonal hay or pasture grass to
orchards or vineyards and the plowing causes “substantial
hydrological alterations.” Borden Ranch, 261 F.3d at 815-16
(citing United States v. Akers, 785 F.2d 814, 819 (9th Cir.
1986)). But the Akers decision never held that plowing solely
done for the purpose of changing crops constituted “bringing an
area [of the farm] into a use to which it was not previously
subject.” On the contrary, Akers dealt with converting a
nonfarmable part of the farm known as the Big Swamp to
uplands by massive dyke building, grading, leveling, and water
diversion activities. Akers, 785 F.2d at 816. Borden Ranch’s
plowing activities were of a completely different nature, but
nevertheless were treated by the Ninth Circuit as identical to
Akers.
The court took the position, in essence, that under Section
404 it is not the farmer but the Corps that has the role of
determining what crops may or may not be produced by the
farmer. Under this interpretation, the government would
control through the Section 404 permitting process all plowing
on land with any type of seasonal, normally dry wetland area.
If this is so, the 1977 farming exemptions are virtually
meaningless. The Corps will have become the managing
general partner of vast acreages of private farmland across the
nation. But Congress never intended such agency authority. As
this Court recognized in SWANCC, in addressing the
jurisdictional scope of the Section 404 program, “[r]ather than
© (...continued)
water that drains into a series of ditches that drain into navigable water
body); United States v. Rapanos, 2002 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 3957 (E.D. Mich.
S.D. February 21, 2002) (no Section 404 jurisdiction over wetlands draining
into nonnavigable creeks that drain into navigable water body over 20 miles
away).
expressing a desire to readjust the federal-state balance in this
manner, Congress chose to ‘recognize, preserve and protect the
primary responsibilities and rights of states . . . to plan the
development and use . . . of land and water resources’... 33
U.S.C. § 1251(b).” SWANCC, 531 U.S. at 174. The Ninth
Circuit ignored this principle.
The Ninth Circuit’s interpretation of the Section 404(f)
exemption eliminates virtually any practical application of the
exemption for farmers. This interpretation that includes
plowing as a Section 404 regulated activity threatens the
viability and independence of this nation’s family farmers. This
is an issue of great importance the Court should review.
+>
CONCLUSION
Amici urge the Court to grant the Petition for a Writ of
Certiorari.
DATED: April, 2002.
Respectfully submitted,
ROBIN L. RIVETT
Counsel of Record
M. REED HOPPER
Pacific Legal Foundation
10360 Old Placerville Road,
Suite 100
Sacramento, California 95827
Telephone: (916) 362-2833
Facsimile: (916) 362-2932
Counsel for Amici Curiae
California Farm Bureau
Federation, California
Cattlemen's Association, and
Pacific Legal Foundation
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.