Joint Appendix — Festo Corp. v. Shoketsu Kinzoku Kogyo Kabushiki Co.
Supreme Court brief2002
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
~ [es
‘1?)
L AUG 31 2001
No. 00-1543 OFFICE OF THE ULEKK
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
¢
FESTO CORPORATION,
Petitioner,
SHOKETSU KINZOKU KOGYO KABUSHIKI CO., LTD.,
a/k/a SMC CORPORATION and
SMC PNEUMATICS, INC.,
Respondents.
¢
On Writ Of Certiorari
To The United States Court Of Appeals
For The Federal Circuit
—_—_—__-— @
JOINT APPENDIX
VOLUME I, PAGES I-1 TO 1-153
+
Rosert H. Bork ARTHUR I. NeustTapt
Counsel of Record Counsel of Record
Suite 1000 Cuartes L. GHoLz
1150 17th Street, N.W. Rosert T. Pous
Washington, D.C. 20036 Oston, Sprvak, MCCLELLAND,
(202) 862-5851 Maier & Neustapt, P.C.
1755 Jefferson Davis Highway
Arlington, Virginia 22202
(703) 413-3000
Counsel for Respondents
[Additional Counsel Listed On Inside Cover]
——————$$&&|a=a=aBnap]a]=CIoICIU===l"™"L™h™——=_=_—™"=——s™()]—====—=—=———_—e—~Ii_ie—_aananaananana
Petition For Certiorari Filed: April 9, 2001
Certiorari Granted: June 18, 2001
—SSESEEEEEEEleE=eES=nDBQQnnnnnlQllQq@NlNOONQNQSQ=SSQQ“Q>YOOWmaSan@aa =
Counsel for Petitioner
CuHar.es R. HorFMANN
GERALD T. BODNER
GLENN T. HENNEBERGER
ANTHONY E. BENNETT
HorrMANN & Baron, LLP
6900 Jericho Turnpike
Syosset, New York 11791
(516) 822-3550
ANpDreEw L. Frey
Donato M. FALk
Rosert L. BRONSTON
Mayer, Brown & PL Latt
1909 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 263-3000
Counsel for Petitioner
James B. LAMPERT
HALE AND Dorr
60 State Street
Boston, Massachusetts
02109
(617) 526-6000
Counsel for Respondents
TABLE OF CONTENTS
VOLUME I
re ocbbccens I-1
Excerpt of Report of the Special Master Herbert F.
Schwartz, Esq. Pursuant to Rule 53(e)(1)
PE asidecdvetetessenscencecessccevcsceccees 1-40
Excerpt of Festo Corporation’s Objections to
Report of Special Master Herbert F. Schwartz,
Esq. Pursuant to Rule 53(e)(3) F.R.Civ.P........... I-53
Excerpt of Plaintiff Festo Corporation’s Pretrial
Memorandum Under L.R. 16.5.............00005. I-57
Excerpt of Defendant’s Exhibit 105, Plaintiff Festo
Corporation’s Trial Memorandum................ I-61
Excerpt of Plaintiff Festo Corporation's Trial Brief
PT thd eebeeeeneeececcessocssseccescoecees 1-64
Order of Hon. Judge Saris re: Pretrial Motions,
| EAPPPPTITITITTTITTT ELT TTT Te eee 1-66
Excerpt of Defendant SMC’s Exhibit 64, Festo
PS 6ececesovccccccesccccececccceccceceses 1-81
Defendant SMC’s Exhibit 66 Festo Document ...... 1-84
Transcripts of Jury Trial before Hon. Patti B. Saris:
Sy BS BP OD BD Die cccccccccccccccccccccccess 1-90
Day 3 pp. 67 to 74; 90 to 95; 110 to 111; 115 to
ERR EREEEEPOPTTTTTTETTTTTLT LETT TETE TTT 1-94
Day 4 pp. 20; 57 to 59; 61 to 62; 100 to 119..... 1-115
Day 6 pp. 52 to 54; 69 to 71.......... 6c cece eee 1-139
Day 7 pp. 76 to 77; and 87 to 88............... 1-145
Day 8 pp. 104; 119 to 120 .................20000- 1-150
NTS - Continued
TABLE OF CONTE —_
VOLUME II
U.S. Patent No. 4,354,125 to Stoll (Plif. Ex. 15)...... II-1
File history of U.S. Patent No. 4,354,125 to Stoll -
(Plf. Ex. 14), including cited references.......-.-. -
Translation of German Patent Publication DE-OS
SD TD GO , cc cccccccccccecescocecesosococesecse
US. Patent No. 3,779,401 to Carroll (Pif. Ex. 17).... 0-121
U.S. Reexamination Certificate for B1 3,779,401 to —
Carroll (Plf. Ex. 19).........eee cece cere ee eeeees -
File History of U.S. Reexam to Carroll Patent
“(Plt Ex. 18), including cited references and
Translation of German Petty Patent 1982379... . II-133
Date
Aug 4
Sep 26
Sep 30
Oct 19
Nov 8
1989
Oct 2
I-1
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
United States District Court
N.R.
1
10
39
PROCEEDINGS
Complaint, FILED, S/I CFI LR10
18A
D’s ANSWER and COUNTER-
CLAIMS, FILED. cs
D’s Amended ANSWER and coun-
ter claims, FILED. cs
P’s demand for trial by jury, FILED.
cs
P Festo Corporation’s Reply to D’s
Counterclaims, FILED. cs
MAZZONE, D.]J., Memorandum
and Order, entered. Since Festo KG
did not take any action itself to
establish minimum contacts in Mas-
sachusetts and none of Festo US's
activities can be deemed as per-
formed for Festo KG, I find that the
criteria of the Massachusetts long-
arm statute are not satisfied.
Accordingly, the motion of Festo
KG to dismiss is allowed. cc/cl
Amended Complaint, Filed.
Pitf Reply to Dfts Cntrol in Dft’s
Response to Pitf’s Amended Com-
plaint filed cs
Pitf Demand a Trial by Jury on all
issues, filed c/s.
1-2
U.S. District Court - Massachusetts (Boston)
1/31/92 95
2/21/92
2/26/92
2/28/92
2/28/92
3/20/92
99
104
138
117
Trial briefs by Festo Corp. (mcm)
[1:88cv1814]
Trial briefs by Smc Pneumatics, Inc.
filed cs. (dlw) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Shoketsu Kinzoku Kog, Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for summary judgment
mtn for stoll patent invalidity filed cs.
(mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Status conference held Re; schedule for
trial. D’s reply trial Doc. filed in court
under seal. Based on its review of the
[trial] documents, the court has con-
cluded that this case is inappropriate
for trial to jury. The parties have ruled
out settlement. Accordingly, the parties
may elect on[e] of two options: 1. agree
to a Special Master, or submit 3 names
each an the court will select; 2. Show
cause why a rule 706 expert should not
be appointed. The parties have 20 days
to report to the clerk their decision.
(sad) [Entry date 04/08/92]
[1:88cv 1814]
Judge A. D. Mazzone. Clerk’s Notes:,
Trial is hereby conce[aJled. Ruling on all
pending motions deferred pending
appointment of special Master or Rule
706 Expert. . . . terminated deadlines
(sad) [Entry date 04/08/92]
[1:88cv1814]
Motion by Shoketu Kinzoku Kog, Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for summary judgment
of non-infringement of the stoll patent
3/20/92
3/20/92
3/24/92
5/1/92
5/7/92
118
119
122
149
1-3
filed cs. (mcm) [Entry date 03/23/92]
[1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Shoketsu Kinzoku
Kog, Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in support of
[117-1] motion for summary judgment
of non-infringement of the stoll patent
(mem) [Entry date 03/23/92]
[1:88cv1814]
Statement of Facts by Shoketsu Kinzoku
Kog, Smc Pneumatics, Inc. Re: [117-1]
motion for summary judgment of non-
infringement of the stoll patent (mcm)
[Entry date 03/23/92] [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Shoketsu Kinzoku Kog, Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for summary judgment
of non-infring of the stoll and carroll
patents by the one seal SMC Rodless
Cylinder filed cs. (req for oral argu-
ment) (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
EMERGENCY/Motion by Festo Corp.
to strike [122-1] motion for summary
judgment of non-infring of the stoll and
carroll patents by the one seal SMC
Rodless Cylinder, [117-1] motion for
summary judgmnt of non-infringement
of the stoll patent, [104-1] motion for
summary judgment mtn for stoll patent
invalidity filed cs. REQ FOR ORAL
ARGUMENT (mcm) [Entry date
05/06/92] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. in opposition
to [117-1] motion for summary judg-
ment of non-infringement of the stoll
patent (mcm) [Entry date 05/14/92]
[1:88cv 1814]
5/21/92
5/21/92
7/8/92
8/13/92
4/27/93
5/11/93
166
170
172
176
178
1-4
Judge A. D. Mazzone. Order referring
case to Herbert F. Schwartz as special
master for the purpose of considering
all claims presented in this case by the
parties and for such other matter as
may be referred to the Master by the
Court such as discovery disputes.
(mem) [Entry date 06/02/92]
[1:88cv 1814]
Judge A. D. Mazzone. Order of refer-
ence entered for Alternative Dispute
Resolution. Referred to: Herbert Schwa-
rtz for: alternative dispute (mcm) [Entry
date 01/24/95] [1:88cv1814]
Ltr from Special Master H. Schwartz re:
confirming ctrm 1110 for hearings on
the following dates: September 14-18,
1992, September 21-15, 1992 and Octo-
ber 19-23, 1992. Arrangements for a
court reporter will be made by Mr.
Hoffman and Mr. Neustadt. (mcm)
[1:88cv1814]
Order of Special Master Herbert F.
Schwartz Entered (sad) [Entry date
08/24/92] [1:88cv1814]
Report of the Special Master Herbert F.
Schwartz, Esq., Pursuant To Rule
53(e)(1) F.R.Civ.P., filed. (see file dkt
#176 for further details) (mcm)
[1:88cv1814]
Motion by Shoketsu Kinzoku Kog, Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for entry of summary
judgment and direct verdict of Non-
Infringement of the stoll patent FILED
c.s. (jmr) [1:88cv1814]
5/18/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
6/9/93
184
185
186
187
191
194
198
202
1-5
Judge A. D. Mazzone. Order, Objections
or motions with supporting memoranda
for confirmation of Special Master's
Report shall be filed and served by
6/9/93. Entered cc/cl (sad) [Entry date
06/08/93] [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Festo Corp. to vacate or
modify those portions of the Report of
the SM in accord w/pltf objection filed
and to confirm the remaining portions
of the report filed cs. (mcm)
[1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. in opposition
to the Report of the Special Master, pur-
suant to Rule 53(e)(3), FR Civ P, filed cs.
(mem) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Festo Corp. for summary
judgment of validity and a directed ver-
dict of the reexamined Carroll Patent
filed cs. (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Festo Corp. for summary
judgment and or a directed verdict of
infringement of the reexamined Carroll
Patent filed cs. (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Festo Corp. for summary
judgment and a directed verdict of
VALIDITY OF THE STOLL PATENT
filed cs. (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Festo Corp. for summary
judgment and directed verdict of
INFRINGEMENT OF THE STOLL PAT-
ENT filed cs. (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to the May 18, 1993 ORDER
6/30/93
1/25/94
2/3/94
2/3/94
205
209
1-6
CONCERNING THE SPECIAL MAS-
TER’S REPORT, filed cs. (mcm)
[1:88cv1814]
Response by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in
opposition to [198-1] (4) motions for
summary judgment and directed ver-
dict of INFRINGEMENT OF THE
STOLL PATENT (mcm) [Entry date
07/07/93] [1:88cv1814]
Case reassigned from Judge Mazzone to
Judge Patti B. Saris upon appointment
to the bench. Notice (1/18/94) sent to
counsel. (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Clerk’s Notes: hear-
ing on pending motions for SJ. Parties
to consider trial by jury on liability, and
to court on damages. Special Masters
report will be redacted and submitted
to the jury. Pltfs physics expert will be
allowed; dft can depose physics expert.
NOTED that Miamoto patent was not
addressed in SM trial, but is the sub-
stance of SMC’s counterclaim. Trial will
be limited to one week per side. FPTC
set for 5/6/94. Jury trial set for
5/16/94, 10-15 days. Settlement cnf
held off the record. Parties to report to
cleck by 2/11/94 re: status of settlement
and if they want settlement cnf w/prin-
cipals scheduled w/Sr. Judge Mazzone.
Further briefing order to issue. (mcm)
[Entry date 02/25/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
denying [178-1] motion for entry of
summary judgment and direct verdict
of Non-Infringement of the stoll patent
CRS ee ame -
net cr A a eee
2/3/94 -
2/3/94 -
2/18/94 208
1-7
(mem) [Entry date 02/25/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
denying [194-1] motion for summary
judgment and a directed verdict of
VALIDITY OF THE STOLL PATENT
(mem) [Entry date 02/25/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
denying [198-1] motion for summary
judgment and directed verdict of
INFRINGEMENT OF THE STOLL PAT-
ENT (mcm) [Entry date 02/25/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Procedural Order,
set settlement conference before Judge
A. D. Mazzone for 10:00 3/16/94, set
pretrial conference for 2:00 5/6/94
before Judge Patti B. Saris. For the rea-
sons stated in court on 2/3/94, the par-
ties mtns for s.j dkt
#104,117,122,178,194 and 198 are
DENIED. The parties mtns for s/j dkt #
122 and 187 are DENIED. Ruling is
DEFERRED on the pltfs mtn for mtn for
s/j and directed verdict of infringement
on the reexamined Carroll patent dkt
#191 pending receipt of supp briefing.
by 2/25/94, the parties shall file supp
memo on the following issues: new case
on doctrine of equivalents (Carroll pat-
ent); literal infringement (Carroll pat-
ent); any other issues raised. Any
responses to the above submissions
shall be filed no later than March 4,
1994. (see file dkt #208 for further
2/25/94
2/25/94
2/25/94
3/4/94
3/4/94
3/4/94
3/14/94
210
211
212
213
214
216
215
1-8
details) (mcm) [Entry date 02/25/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Pitf Festo Corp., Supplemental Mem-
orandum Re: New case law on the Doc-
trine of Equivalents with respect to the
Carroll Patent, filed cs. (mcm) [Entry
date 02/28/94] [1:88cv1814]
SMC’S Memo concerning the absence of
literal infringement of the Carroll Pat-
ent, filed. (mcm) [Entry date 02/28/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for
consideration of Special Master’s rec-
ommendation filed cs. (mcm) [Entry
date 02/28/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. to [212-1]
motion for consideration of Special
Master’s recommendation, FILED. (c/s)
(cmg) [Entry date 03/14/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. to SMC’s
Memorandum Concerning the Absence
of Literal Infringement of the Carroll
Patent, FILED. (c/s) (cmg) [Entry date
03/14/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response of SMC’s to Festo’s supple-
mental memo regarding new case law
on the doctrine of equivalents, filed cs.
(mem) [Entry date 03/16/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for motion
hearing held on 2/4/94 before Judge:
Saris (mcm) [1:88cv1814]
3/30/94 -
5/3/94 220
5/10/94 222
1-9
DFTS SUPPLEMENTAL Memorandum
by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in support of
[178-1] motion for entry of summary
judgment and direct verdict of Non-
Infringement of the stoil patent (mcm)
[Entry date 04/04/94] [1:88cv1814]
Fretrial memorandum by Festo Corp.,
filed. (mcm) [Entry date 05/04/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Clerk’s Notes: re:
FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
HELD, Trial date continued . . . set Jury
trial for 5/31/94 Plaintiff h/f/updated
trial document; dft will stand on previ-
ously-filed trial document. No motions
in limine f. Trial to proceed w/o bifur-
cation. Counsel anticipate 10-15 trial
days, incl. damages and break for lia-
bility deliberations (plaintiff‘s case
infringement; dft’s case invalaidity)
Order of presentation: plaintiff’s case
first, dft’s second. Counterclaim on
Miamoto patent is waived except for
attys. fees issue. Jury to decide willful-
ness; Court to decide attys fees. Submis-
sion of MASTER’S REPORT (issue
briefed earlier by pltf): Counsel w/h/
t/stip to fact findings in SM’s report:
redact rest. SM REPORT t/b/given to
jury to read, but not keep. Witnesses
w/n/b permitted to comment on SM
REPORT. TEN JURORS t/b/empaneled;
all will deliberate. FIVE PEREMPTORY
CHALLENGES PER SIDE. Local coun-
sel need not always be present. Motions
6/22/94
6/22/94
6/24/94
6/24/94
6/27/94
6/28/94
6/29/94
261
262
224
I-10
in limine, propsed jury interrogs., pro-
posed voir dire, jury instructions t/b/
f/by 5/23/94 . . . Both sides to supp.
experts by 5/31/94. Parties anticipate
10-15 days of trial (1 for opening/clos-
ing statements, 4 for pltf’s liability case,
4 for dft’s, 2 days per side for dmgs,
plus break for deliberations on liability
phase). (Court will hold parties to this
schedule. (tmc) [Entry date 05/18/94]
[Edit date 06/22/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. in opposition
to Special Master Report of May 21,
1993, (DOCUMENT FILED UNDER
SEAL) filed. (scj) [Entry date 09/14/94]
[Edit date 09/14/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Festo Corp. to response to the
May 18, 1993 Order concerning the Spe-
cial Master’s Report (DOCUMENT
FILED UNDER SEAL), filed. (scj) [Entry
date 09/14/94] [1:88cv1814]
Trial brief by Smc Pneumatics, Inc.,
filed. (scj) [Entry date 06/27/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Jury instructions filed. (scj) [Entry date
06/27/94] [1:88cv1814]
Trial brief by Festo Corp., filed. (scj)
[Entry date 06/28/94] [1:88cv1814]
SMC’s further comment and objection
concerning the Special Master’s Report
(scj) [Entry date 06/29/94] [1:88cv1814]
Pre-trial conference held. (scj) [Entry
date 07/01/94] [1:88cv1814]
6/29/94 236
7/5/94 -
7/6/94 =
7/7/94 =
7/8/94 -
I-11
Judge Patti B. Saris. Clerk’s Notes: re:
Final Pretrial Conference [229-1] motion
in limine to exclude testimony and evi-
dence of Defendants SMC Corporation
and SMC Pneumatics, Inc. taken
under advisement Court Reporter:
Cloonan . . . Issues for trial... 1)
Carroll patent (validity) 2) Stoll patent
(validity) 3) Infringemenet on Carroll
patent granted to P by way of ST, opin-
ion to issue, SJ opinion to issue. SJ to
dfts on Bolt issued. For purposes of
trial, both dfts. w/b/ collectively
referred as SMC. Proposed voir dire
verdict form covered. Jury empanei-
ment: 10 jurors, 5 peremtories per side.
to dft on Bolt Issue. SJ (scj) [Entry date
07/01/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day One (Empanelment)
opening statements given; adjourned at
1:15pm until 7/6/94; 9:00AM . . . (sad)
[Entry date 08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day Two: hearing held
RE:submission of Special Master’s
report to jury. adjourned until 7/7/94;
9:00AM. . . . (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Jury trial heid. Day Three; lobby confer-
ence. adjourned until 7/8/94; at
9:00Am. (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day Four . . . cross exam
continued redirect, no re cross.
adjourned to 7/11/94 9:00Am. . . . (sad)
[Entry date 08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
7/11/94 242
7/11/94
7/12/94
7/13/94
7/13/94
243
244
I-12
Judge Patti B. Saris. Order entered
granting in part, denying in part [122-1]
motion for summary judgment of non-
infring of the stoll and carroll patents
by the one seal SMC Rodless Cylinder
granting as to the Carroll patent and
denying as to the Stoll patent, granting
[187-1] motion for summary judgment
of validity and a directed verdict of the
reexamined Carroll Patent, granting
[191-1] motion for summary judgment
and or a directed verdict of infringe-
ment of the reexamined Carroll Patent,
denying [104-1] motion for summary
judgment mtn for stoll patent invalidity,
denying [117-1] motion for summary
judgment of non-infringement of the
stoll patent. cc/cl (scj) [Entry date
07/13/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day Five; adjourned to
7/12/94 at 9:00AM. . . . (sad) [Entry
date 08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day Six; defendants
move for directed verdict; arguments on
defendant’s motion for directed ver-
dict/judgment as a matter of law.
Motion Denied for reasons stated in
court. adjourned until 9:00AM on
7/13/94. . . . (sad) [Entry date
08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
SMC’s objections to propsed special
verdict form (scj) [Entry date 07/14/94]
[1:88cv1814]
SMC’s objections to proposed jury
instructions (scj) [Entry date 07/14/94]
[1:88cv1814]
7/13/94
7/14/94
7/14/94
7/14/94
7/15/94
7/18/94
7/18/94
245
246
1-13
Jury trial held. Day Seven. . . . plaintiff's
rebuttal case..adjourned to 7/14/94 at
9:00Am . . . (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv1814]
SMC’s Objections to Revised Jury
Instruction (scj) [Entry date 07/18/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Special Verdict Form as answered by
the Jury (scj) [Entry date 07/18/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Jury trial held. Day Eight . . . Evidence
closed . . . closing arguments; jury
charge. . . . 4:00PM verdict returned;
motions for directed verdict; both
motions Denied. . . . (sad) [Entry date
08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day nine. . . . Conference
with counsel re-damages, no chance of
settlement. defendant will move for
mistrial based on brief delibera-
tions . . . (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day 10... re; dam-
ages. . . . (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Status conference held. plaintiff advises
it will not pursue willful infringement
issue. defendant moves for mistrial
based on evidence and short delibera-
tions on liability phase. DENIED .. .
Juror injured in slip and fall on [stairs].
recessed until 10:20am . . . opening
statements on damages phase.
adjourned until 7/19/94. . . . (sad)
[Entry date 08/25/94] [1:88cv1814]
7/18/94
7/19/94
7/20/94
7/20/94
7/21/94
7/26/94
9/8/94
252
248
247
253
I-14
Judge Patti B. Saris. Clerk’s Notes: re:
status conference Court Reporter:
Cloonan (sad) [Entry date 08/25/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Jury trial held. Day 11. . . . defendant
opening statement. . . . court adjourned
at 1:00PM jury excused. . . . (sad) [Entry
date 08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
SMC objections to proposed Speecial
verdict form and damage jury instruc-
tions filed (sad) [Entry date 08/02/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Jury trial held. Day 11.. . jury excused;
charge conference. . . . (sad) [Entry date
08/11/94] [1:88cv1814]
Jury trial held. Day twelve; defendants’
closing arguments . . . plaintiffs’ closing
argument..charged. . . . delebration
resume . . . questions to be filed... .
2:40pm verdict reached and returned
... jury dismissed. . . . plaintiff's to file
motion for permant injunction.
proposed judgment due by
8/19/94... (sad) [Entry date 08/11/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Post-Trial Mem-
orandum, ENTERED, cc/cl. (ktb) [Entry
date 07/27/94) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Non-Infrigement
(“sleeve made of a magnetizable mate-
rial”), filed. (scj) [Entry date 09/09/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
9/8/94
9/8/94
9/8/94
9/8/94
9/8/94
9/8/94
9/16/94
9/30/94
254
255
256
257
258
259
263
1-15
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Non-Infringement
(“Two seal-one seal”), filed. (scj) [Entry
date 09/09/94] [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Invalidity (“Best
mode and obviousness”) and Carroll
Patent Invalidity (Obviousness), filed.
(scj) [Entry date 09/09/94] [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to alter
judgment on th{e] grounds that there
was no substantial evidence to support
the jury’s 100% lost profit damages of
$4,739,183.00, filed. (scj) [Entry date
09/09/94] [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for new
trial under the Alternative Rule 59,
filed. (scj) [Entry date 09/09/94]
[1:88cv1814]
SMC’s Brief concerning a stay pending
appeal of any injunction. filed (scj)
[Entry date 09/09/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in
opposition to prejudgement interest in
the amount of $416,727.00, filed. (scj)
[Entry date 09/09/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Notice of Hearing/
conference: set for October 24, 1994 at
~ 3:00. (scj) [1:88cv1814]
Terminated document mooting [113-1]
motion in limine to exclude testimony
and evidence of dfts SMC Copr & SMC
10/13/94 266
10/14/94 272
1-16
Pneumatice & cntrclm pitf SMC Corpo
mooting [115-1] motion to ORDER
admitted pltfs admission request no
1-17 denying [144-1] motion to strike
[122-1] motion for summery judgment
of non-infring of the stoll and carroll
patents by the one seal SMC Rodless
Cylinder, [117-1] motion for summary
judgment of non-infringement of the
stoll patent, [104-1] motion for sum-
mary judgment mtn for stoll patent
invalidity mooting [148-1] motion to
stay all mtns and rsps pending denying
[185-1] motion to vacate or modify
those portions of the Report of the SM
in accord w/pltf objection filed and to
confirm the remaining portions of the
report mooting [212-1] motion for con-
sideration of Special Master’s recom-
mendation mooting [229-1] motion in
limine to exclude testimony and evi-
dence of Defendants SMC Corporation
and SMC Pneumatics, Inc. These
motions are moot; see trial transcript
and opinion dated 07/26/94. Requested
by dw. (dlw) [Entry date 10/17/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [255-1] motion for judgment on
the pleadings with respect to the Stoll
Patent Invalidity (“Best mode and obvi-
ousness”) and Carroll Patent Invalidity
(Obviousness), filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/14/94) [1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [253-1] motion for judgment on
10/14/94
10/14/94
10/14/94
10/14/94
10/14/94
10/20/94
273
274
275
276
277
267
1-17
the pleadings with respect to the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringement (“sleeve made
of a magnetizable material”), filed. (scj)
[Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [257-1] motion for new trial
under the Alternative Rule 59, filed.
(scj) [Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to SMC’s Brief in Support of its
objection to prejudgmenet interest,
filed. (scj) [Entry date 10/31/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [257-1] motion for new trial
under the Alternative Rule 59, filed.
(scj) [Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [258-1] remark, SMC’s Brief con-
cerning a stay pending appeal of any
injunction filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [254-1] motion for judgment on
the pleadings with respect to the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringement (“Two seal-
one seal”), filed. (scj) [Entry date
19/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to [253-1] motion for judgment
on the pleadings with respect to the
Stoll Patent Non-Infringement (“sleeve
made of a magnetizable material”),
filed. (scj) [Entry date 10/24/94]
[1:88cv 1814)
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
268
269
270
271
280
281
1-18
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to [257-1] motion for new trial
under the Alternative Rule 59, filed.
(scj) [Entry date 10/24/94] [1:18cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to [255-1] motion for judgment
on the pleadings with respect to the
Stoll Patent Invalidity (“Best mode and
obviousness”) and Carroll Patent
Invalidity (Obviousness), filed. (scj)
[Entry date 10/24/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
Festo’s response to SMC’s Brief in sup-
port of its Objection to prejudgement
interest, filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/24/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
Festo’s response to SMC’s Brief con-
cerning a stay pending appeal of any
injunction, filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/24/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to [254-1] motion for judgment
on the pleadings with respect to the
Stoll Patent Non-Infringement (“Two
seal-one seal”), filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
- response to [253-1] motion for judgment
on the pleadings with respect to the
Stoll Patent Non-Infrigement (“sleeve
made of a magnetizable material”),
filed. (scj) [Entry date 10/31/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/21/94
10/24/94
10/24/94
282
283
284
285
286
302
I-19
Memorandum by Smc Pneumatics, Inc.
in opposition to Festo’s Opposition to
SMC’s Brief in Support of it’s Mo|[tiJon
to Prejudgement Interest, filed. (scj)
[Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
response to [255-1] motion for judgment
on the pleadings with respect to the
Stoll Patent Invalidity (“Best mode and
obviousness”) and Carroll Patent
Invalidity (Obviousness), filed. (scj)
[Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in
opposition to [274-1] opposition mem-
orandum, filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in
opposition to [273-1] opposition mem-
orandum, filed. (scj) [Entry date
10/31/94] [1:88c1814]
Reply by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
Festo’s response to SMC’s Rule 50 and
Rule 59 Motions concerning Festo’s
Asserted Lost Profits Damages, filed.
(scj) [Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Motion hearing held-#296, #297-300,
#301 and #257 (scj) [Entry date
11/13/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Clerk’s Notes: re:
Post Trial Motions granting [296-1]
motion for leave to file response to
opposition, denying [297-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings on the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringement (Sleeve made
of a magnetizable material, denying
10/26/94 -
10/26/94 -
10/26/94 -
I-20
[298-1] motion for judgment on the
pleadings on the Stoll Patent Non-
Infringement (Two Seal-One Seal),
denying [299-1] motion for judgment on
the pleadings on the Stoll Patent
Invalidity (Best Mode and Obviousness
and Carroll Patent Invalidity (Obvious-
ness), denying [300-1] motion for judg-
ment on the pleadings concerning
Festo’s asserted lost profit’ damages,
denying [301-1] motion for new trial,
denying [257-1] motion for new trial
under the Alternative Rule 59-Fees date
to stop as of last day of trial (7/21/94)
stay pending appeal w/b denied once
injunction enters. Order of injunctions
w/b stayed for 45 days. Any supple-
mental filings due 10/26/94 Court
Reporter: Marie Cloonan (scj) [Entry
date 11/13/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [255-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Invalidity (“Best
mode and obviousness”) and Carroll
Patent Invalidity (Obviousness). (scj)
[Entry date 10/27/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [254-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Non-Infringement
(“Two seal-one seal”). (scj) [Entry date
10/27/94] [1:88cv1814]
judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [253-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
10/26/94 -
10/26/94 -
10/27/94 -
10/27/94 290
I-21
to the Stoll Patent Non-Infri[n]gement
(“sleeve made of a magnetizable mate-
rial”). (scj) [Entry date 10/27/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [256-1] motion to alter
judgment on th grounds that there was
no substantial evidence to support the
jury’s 100% lost profit damages of
$4,739,183.00. (scj) [Entry date
10/27/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [255-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings with respect
to the Stoll Patent Invalidity (“Best
mode and obviousness”) and Carroll
Patent Invalidity (Obviousness). (scj)
[Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris, by the Court, by
Deputy clerk Whitney. Endorsed Order
entered granting [249-1] motion for
entry of judgment. (SEE SEPARATE
JUDGEMENT ENTERED) (scj) [Entry
date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Judgment entered
for Smc Pneumatics, Inc. against Festo
Corp. Principal: $4,322,456.00 , and Pre-
judgment interest in the amount of
$416,727.00. Each party is to bear its
own costs and attorneys’ fees. Judgme-
ment is hereby entered in favor of Plat-
iff Festo Corporation against
Defendants SMC Corporation and SMC
Pneumatics, Inc. and each of them on
the issues of liability and damages. (scj)
[Entry date 10/31/94] [1:88cv1814]
10/28/94 291
10/28/94 292
10/31/94 278
10/31/94 288
10/31/94 294
11/3/94 295
11/3/94 304
1-22
SMC’s Objections to Proposed Judge-
ment (scj) [Entry date 11/01/94}
[1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. in opposition
to proposed judgement. (attachment-
Irrevocable Standby Letter of Credit
Account Form of the Agahi Bank, Lim-
ited), filed. (scj) [Entry date 11/01/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Memorandum by Festo Corp. in opposi-
tion to [256-1] motion to alter judgment
on th grounds that there was no sub-
stantial evidence to support the jury’s
100% lost profit damages of
$4,739,183.00, filed. (scj) [1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
amend the judgement enterd by the
Court on October 28, 1994, filed. (scj)
[1:88cv1814]
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. to
amend [290-1] judgment order entered
on October 28, 1994, filed. (scj) [Entry
date 11/03/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Festo Corp. in opposition
to [288-1] motion to amend the judge-
ment enterd by the Court on October
28, 1994, filed. (scj) [Entry date
11/04/94] [1:88cv1814]
Response by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. in
opposition to [275-1] opposition mem-
orandum filed by Festo concerning
SMC’s Motion for Relief under Rule
59%e), filed. (scj) [Entry date 11/21/94]
[1:88cv1814]
11/9/94
11/9/94
11/9/94
11/9/94
11/9/94
297
298
299
300
301
11/10/94 -
I-23
Refiling (as suggested by the Court at
the October 24, 1994 hearing) of the
Motion by Smc Pneumatics, Inc. for
judgment on the pleadings on the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringment (Sleeve made
of a magnetizable material, filed. (scj)
[Entry date 11/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Refiling (as suggested by the Court at
the October 24, 1994 hearing) of the
Rule 50 (b) Motion by Smc Pneumatics,
Inc. for judgment on the pleadings on
the Stoll Patent Non-Infringement (Two
Seal-One Seal), filed. (scj) [Entry date
11/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Refiling (at the suggestion of the Court
at the October 24, 1994 hearing) of the
Rule 50(b) Motion by Smc Pneumatics,
Inc. for judgment on the pleadings on
the Stoll Patent Invalidity (Best Mode
and Obviousness and Carroll Patent
Invalidity (Obviousness), filed. (scj)
[Entry date =11/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Refiling of the Rule 50 and Rule 59
Motion (at the suggestion of the Court
at the October 24, 1994 hearing) by Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for judgment on the
pleadings concerning Festo’s asserted
lost profits damages, filed. (scj) [Entry
date 11/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Refiling of Rule 59 Motion by Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. for new trial, filed.
(scj) [Entry date 11/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered denying [294-1] motion to
amend [290-1] judgment order entered
11/10/94 - 303
11/14/94 -
11/18/94 305
1-24
on October 28, 1994. SMC’s motion for a
stay of the execution upon the judgment
and for the substitution of a letter of
credit and agreement (exhibit A)
instead of a supercedeas bond is
allowed (scj) [Entry date 11/14/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Notice of appeal to Federal Circuit by
Smc Pneumatics, Inc. filed. Fee Status:
pd Fee Amount: $105.00 Receipt #:
264844 Appeal re: Appeal record due on
12/12/94 (mmh) [Entry date 11/16/94]
[1:88cv 1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris, by the Court, by
Deputy Clerk Whitney. Endorsed Order
entered denying [301-1] motion for new
trial, denying [300-1] motion for judg-
ment on the pleadings concerning
Festo’s asserted lost profits damages,
denying [299-1] motion for judgment on
the pleadings on the Stoll Patent
Invalidity (Best Mode and Obviousness
and Carroll Patent Invalidity (Obvious-
ness), denying [298-1] motion for judg-
ment on the pleadings on the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringement (Two Seal-
One Seal), denying [297-1] motion for
judgment on the pleadings on the Stoll
Patent Non-Infringment (Sleeve made
of a magnetizable material. (scj) [Entry
date 11/16/94] [1:88cv1814]
Amended Notice of appeal by Smc
Pneumatics, Inc. filed. Fee Status:
waived Fee Amount: $105.00: Appeal
record due on 12/19/94 (scj) [Entry
date 11/23/94] [1:88cv1814]
11/28/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
12/6/94
321
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
1-25
Notice of Docketing Appeal in the Fed-
eral Circuit Appeal No. 95-1079 (scj)
[Entry date 12/10/94] [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 6/29/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/5/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/6/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/7/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/8/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/11/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/12/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/13/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/14/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/18/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/19/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/20/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 7/21/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814]
Transcript of proceedings for 10/24/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmbh) [1:88cv1814]
12/6/94 320
12/6/94
12/8/94 322
1/5/95
12/14/95 -
12/14/95 324
4/2/96
326
1-26
Transcript of proceedings for 11/10/94,
before Judge: Saris. (mmh) [1:88cv1814}
Order (1) SMC’s motion for a stay,
pending appeal, is denied. (2) SMC’s
motion to file a reply is granted. 95-1066
(mmh) [Entry date 12/12/94]
[1:88cv1814]
Mandate of US Court of Appeals re:
[303-1] appeal dismissing [303-1]
appeal. Appeal Number 95-1079 (mmh)
[Entry date 12/12/94] [1:88cv1814]
Case closed. (dlw) [1:88cv1814]
Notice of Docketing Record on Appeal
from USCA re: received. USCA
NUMBER: 95-1066 Case from Federal
Circuit (mmh) [Entry date 12/18/95}
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Judgment entered
in the United States Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit affirming the
judgment entered by United States Dis-
trict Judge Patti B. Saris on October 31,
1994. (scj) [Entry date 01/17/96]
[1:88cv1814]
Judgment entered in the United States
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
affirming the decision of the United
States District Court for the Diestrict of
Massachusetts entered on October 31,
1995 from Judge Patti B. Saris. Pre-Judg-
ment interest % (scj) [Entry date
04/16/96] [1:88cv1814]
8/1/96 340
8/12/96 -
12/22/00 347
DATE
1-27
Judge Patti B. Saris . Order entered . . .
Accordingly, the total damages due
Festo, including post-judgment interest
is $7,120,758 in accordance with the
Judgment of October 27, 1994, FILED.
(cc/cl) (emg) [Entry date 08/05/96]
[1:88cv1814]
Judge Patti B. Saris. Endorsed Order
entered granting [355-1] motion to stay
pending disposition by the Supreme
Court. Allowed on the condition that
the letter of credit is increased in value
to cover th amount FESTO seeks by
9/12/96; issued cc/cl. (sat) [Entry date
08/13/96] [1:88cv1814]
Mandate of US Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit re: reversing appeal
95-1066. (jr) [Edit date 01/03/01]
[1:88cv 1814]
FEDERAL CIRCUIT
PROCEEDINGS AND ORDERS
December 12, 1994 8 Received an amended notice of
Feb 2, 1995
appeal (filed on 11/18/94) and
certified list from the district
court. (bah)
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLANT,
filed. (MS-2/2/95)
Mar 14, 1995
Mar 31, 1995
Apr 7, 1995
April 14, 1995
December 14, 1995
March 6, 1996
I-28
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLEE,
filed. (MS-3/14/95) (cr)
REPLY BRIEF FOR THE
APPELLANT, filed.
(MS-3/31/95) (cr)
JOINT APPENDIX, Vols-I-II-III
12 copies each filed, Vol-III
(Confidential Nonconfidential
Vol-III 5 copies filed.
(MS-4/7/95) (cr)
SUPPLEMENTAL JOINT
APPENDIX, Vols-II-&-III 12
copies each field. (MS-4/14/95)
(cr) (Per fxg) 6/20/96.
AFFIRMED. “JUDGMENT
ENTERED” (P). (av) 72 F3d 857
APPELLANT - COMBINED
PETITION FOR REHEARING
AND SUGGESTION FOR
REHEARING IN BANC
(MS-01/03/96) FILED 01/03/96
PETITION CIRCULATED:
01/18/96 SUGGESTION CIR-
CULATED: 02/07/98
RESPONSE REQUESTED
FROM: APPELLEE (FESTO
CORP.) RESPONSE DUE:
02/23/96 RESPONSE FILED:
02/23/96 RESPONSE CIRCU-
LATED: 02/23/96 PETITION /
SUGGESTION: DENIED/
DECLINED ON 03/06/96.
(EOD 03/06/96 BY SCH)
95-1065
April 17, 1997
June 9, 1997
June 2, 1997
June 9, 1997
July 25, 1997
29.
30.
31
1-29
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CER-
TIORARI FILED 03/26/96,,
SUPREME COURT : 95-1546,
CERT. GN ON 03/17/97. 30.
JUDGMENT: VAC.RMD ON
03/17/97. U.S.L.W.: 64-3669
(EOD 04/17/97 BY CS) 95-1066
APPELLANT - SUGGESTION
FOR HEARING IN BANC
(MS-04/04/97) FILED:
05/28/97 SUGGESTION CIR-
CULATED: 05/28/97 SUGGES-
TION: DECLINED ON
06/09/97. (EOD 06/09/97 BY
AV) 95-1066
[a] CERTIFIED COPY OF THE
U.S. SUPREME CT. JUDG-
MENT RECEIVED: 06/02/97
(EOD 06/02/97) (AV) 95-1066
ORDERED: APPELLANTS’
SUGGESTION FOR REHEAR-
ING IN BANC HAVING BEEN
DECLINED, THE CASE IS
RETURNED TO THE PANEL.
THE MANDATE IS VACATED.
SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEFING
SCHEDULE SET OUT IN THIS
ORDER. BY: CLERK.
(CS-06/09/97) FILED:
06/09/97 (EOD 06/09/97) (AV)
95-1066
SMC CORP. ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - UPON REMAND
FROM THE SUPREME COURT.
OPENING BRIEF OF DEFEN-
DANTS-APPELLANTS SMC
August 12, 1997
August 22, 1997
April 19, 1999
1-30
CORP., ET AL. (MS-07/07/97),
FILED: 07/07/97. [974282]
(EOD 07/25/97 BY SPP)
95-1066
FESTO CORPORATION
[APPELLEE] - ON REMAND
FROM THE UNITED STATES
SUPREME COURT, SUPPLE-
MENTAL BRIEF OF PLAIN-
TIFF-APPELLEE FESTO
CORPORATION
(MS-08/11/97). FILED:
08/11/97. Reete—33—Netice—of
Settiement-tssted. (sp) [974398]
(EOD 08/12/97 BY SPP)
95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - UPON REMAND
FROM THE SUPREME COURT
REPLY OF DEFENDANTS-
APPELLANTS SMC CORP., ET
AL. (MS-08/21/97). FILED:
08/21/97. [974488] (EOD
08/22/97 BY SPP) 95-1066
AFFIRMED IN PART,
VACATED IN PART, AND
REMANDED. PRECEDENTIAL
OPINION BY: J. NEWMAN.
JUDGMENT ENTERED:
04/19/99. COSTS AGAINST
EACH SIDE. (EOD 04/19/99
BY KSH) 95-1066 JUDGMENT
VACATED & OPINION OF CT.
WITHDRAWN BY CT. ORDER
ON 8/20/99.
August 20, 1999
August 20, 1999
October 20, 1999
November 30, 1999 44.
I-31
APPELLANT - COMBINED
PETITION FOR REHEARING
AND SUGGESTION FOR
REHEARING IN BANC
(MS-05/03/99) FILED:
05/03/99 PETITION CIRCU-
LATED: 05/03/99 SUGGES-
TION CIRCULATED: 05/13/99
RESPONSE REQUESTED
FROM: APPELLEE (FESTO
CORP.) RESPONSE DUE:
05/28/99 RESPONSE FILED:
05/28/99 RESPONSE CIRCU-
LATED: 05/28/99 PETITION /
SUGGESTION: DENIED/
GRANTED ON 08/20/99. (EOD
08/20/99 BY AV) 95-1066
APPELLEE - PETITION FOR
REHEARING (MS-05/03/99)
FILED: 05/03/99 PETITION
CIRCULATED: 05/03/99 PETI-
TION: DENIED ON 08/20/99.
(EOD 08/20/99 BY AV) 95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - IN BANC OPENING
BRIEF OF DEFENDANTS-
APPELLANTS SMC CORP., ET
AL. (MS-10/19/99), FILED:
10/19/99. [001115] (EOD
10/20/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
PROCTER & GAMBLE -
MOTION OF THE PROCTER &
GAMBLE COMPANY FOR AN
EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE
AN AMICUS BRIEF.
(FS-11/17/99) FILED;
November 19, 1999 45.
December 1, 1999
December 2, 1999
December 2, 1999
48.
I-32
11/17/99. REPLY 1 (46) FILED:
11/22/99. ACTION ON
MOTION 47): MOTION
GRANTED THE BRIEF IS DUE
12/15/99. BY CT- EN BANC.
FILED: 11/30/99, (EOD
11/30/99 BY AV) 95-1066
PROCTER & GAMBLE CO
(AMICUS) - NOTICE THAT
APPELLANT’S WILL NOT BE
FILING A RESPONSE IN
OPPOSITION TO THE
MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF
TIME TO FILE BRIEF.
(FS-11/18/99) RECEIVED:
11/18/99 (EOD 11/19/99)
(AMT) 95-1066
A.LP.L.A. [AMICUS] - BRIEF
FOR AMICUS CURIAE AMERI-
CAN INTELLECTUAL PROP-
ERTY LAW ASSOCIATION
(MS-11/29/99). FILED:
11/29/99. [001162] (EOD
12/01/99 BY AVV) 95-1066
FESTO CORPORATION
[APPELLEE] - EN BANC
RESPONSIVE BRIEF OF
PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE FESTO
CORPORATION
(MS-12/01/99). FILED
12/01/99. ENTRY OF APPEAR-
ANCE NOTICE ISSUED.
[001163] (EOD 12/02/99 BY
SPP) 95-1066
CERTIFICATE OF INTEREST
FOR THE AMICUS CURIAE,
December 2, 1999
December 2, 1999
December 2, 1999
December 2, 1999
49.
50.
51.
1-33
LITTON SYSTEMS INC.
(MS-12/01/99) FILED:
12/01/99. (EOD 12/02/99 BY
AMT) 95-1066
HEWLET PACKARD -
MOTION OF HEWLETT PACK-
ARD CO FOR LEAVE TO FILE
BRIEF AS AMICUS CURIAE IN
SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS-
APPELLANTS. (FS-12/01/99)
FILED: 12/02/99. ACTION ON
MOTION (49); MOOT. LEAVE
OF COURT TO FILE AS
AMICUS IS NOT REQUIRED
IN THIS CASE. BY CLERK.
FILED: 12/02/99. (EOD
12/02/99 BY AMT) 95-1066
CERTIFICATE OF INTEREST
FOR THE AMICUS CURIAE,
HEWLETT-PACKARD CO.
(F-12/01/99) FILED: 12/02/99.
(EOD 12/02/99 BY AMT)
95-1066
CERTIFICATE OF INTEREST
FOR THE AMICUS CURIAE,
Procter & Gamble Co.
(MS-11/30/99) FILED:
12/01/99. (EOD 12/02/99 BY
AMT) 95-1066
LITTON SYSTEMS, INC.
[AMICUS] - EN BANC BRIEF
OF AMICUS CURIAE LITTON
SYSTEMS, INC. IN SUPPORT
OF AFFIRMANCE
(MS-12/01/99), filed: 12/01/99,
=—
December 2, 1999
December 2, 1999
December 3, 1999
December 3, 1999
1-34
[001163] (EOD 12/02/99 BY
SPP) 95-1066
THE BAR ASSOCIATION OF
THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
[AMICUS] - AMICUS CURIAE
BRIEF OF THE PATENT.
TRADEMARK & COPYRIGHT
SECTION OF THE BAR ASSO-
CIATION OF THE DISTRICT
OF COLUMBIA IN SUPPORT
OF NEITHER PARTY
(MS$-12/01/99), FILED;
12/01/99. [001164] (EOD
12/02/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
THE PROCTER & GAMBLE
COMPANY [AMICUS] - BRIEF
FOR AMICUS CURIAE THE
PROCTOR & GAMBLE COM-
PANY SUPPORTING DEFEN-
DANTS-APPELLANTS'’
POSITION FOR REVERSAL
(MS-11/30/99). FILED:
11/30/99, [001165] (EOD
12/02/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
HEWLETT-PACKARD COM-
PANY [AMICUS] - BRIEF OF
HEWLETT-PACKARD COM-
PANY AS AMICUS CURIAE IN
SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS-
APPELLANTS (MS-12/01/99).
FILED: 12/01/99, [001166]
(EOD 12/03/99 BY SPP)
95-1066
IBM, EATMAN KODAK COM-
PANY AND FORD MOTOR
COMPANY [AMICUS] - BRIEF
December 6, 1999
December 9, 1999
I-35
FOR AMICI CURIAE INTER-
NATIONAL BUSINESS
MACHINES CORPORATION,
EASTMAN KODAK COM-
PANY AND FORD MOTOR
COMPANY (MS-12/01/99).
FILED: 12/01/99. [001166]
(EOD 12/03/99 BY SPP)
95-1066
THE HOUSTON INTELLEC-
TUAL PROPERTY LAW ASSO-
CIATION [AMICUS] - BRIEF
FOR AMICUS CURIAE OF THE
HOUSTON INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY LAW ASSOCIA-
TION REQUESTING AFFIR-
MANCE IN SUPPORT OF
APPELLEE FESTO CORPORA-
TION (MS-12/01/99).
RECEIVED: 12/02/99,
REJECTED: 12/06/99, COR-
RECTED BRIEF DUE:
12/20/99, [001166] (EOD
12/06/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
THE HOUSTON INTELLEC-
TUAL PROPERTY LAW ASSO-
CIATION [AMICUS] -
CORRECTED BRIEF FOR
AMICUS CURIAE OF THE
HOUSTON INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY LAW ASSOCIA-
TION REQUESTING AFFIR-
MANCE IN SUPPORT OF
APPELLEE FESTO CORPORA-
TION (MS-12/01/99), COR-
RECTED BRIEF RECEIVED:
December 28, 1999
December 28, 1999
December 28, 1999
January 6, 2000
1-36
12/08/99, FILED: 12/01/99.
[001166] (EOD 12/09/99 BY
SPP) 95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - IN BANC REPLY
BRIEF OF DEFENDANTS-
APPELLANTS SMC CORP., ET
AL. (MS-12/20/99). FILED:
12/20/99. [001186] (EOD
12/28/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - PURSUANT TO
LEAVE OF COURT, RESPONSE
OF DEFENDANTS-APPEL-
LANTS SMC CORP., ET AL. TO
BRIEFS SUBMITTED BY
AMICUS CURIAE
(MS-12/20/99). FILED:
12/20/99. [001186] (EOD
12/28/99 BY SPP) 95-1066
FESTO CORPORATION
[APPELLEE] - COMBINED
REPLY OF PLAINTIFF-APPEL-
LEE FESTO CORPORATION
TO THE BRIEFS OF AMICUS
CURIAE (MS-12/20/99).
FILED: 12/20/99. [001186]
(EOD 12/28/99 BY SPP)
95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - UPON REMAND
FROM THE SUPREME COURT,
JOINT SUPPLEMENTAL
APPENDIX (MS-08/27/97).
FILED: 12/30/99. [001193]
January 6, 2000
November 29, 2000
1-37
(EOD 01/06/00 BY SPP)
95-1066
SMC CORP., ET AL. [APPEL-
LANTS] - JOINT APPENDIX (3
VOLUME) (Volume III has con-
fidential and nonconfidential
versions) (MS-12/30/99).
FILED: 12/30 (sp) 29/99.
[001193] (EOD 01/06/00 BY
SPP) 95-1066
Reversed. Precedential Opinion
by J. Schall. in which Mayer,
Chief Judge, and Plager, Lourie,
Clevenger, Bryson, Gajarsa, and
Dyk, Circuit Judges, join; in
which Michel, Rader and Linn,
Circuit Judges, join with respect
TO Parts III-A, III-B, and III-D;
and in which Michel, Circuit
Judge joins with respect to Part
III-E. Concurring opinion by
Plager, Circuit Judge; concur-
ring opinion by Lourie, Circuit
Judge; Opinion concurring-part
and dissenting-in-part with
respect to Part III-C by Michel,
Circuit Judge, in which Rader,
Circuit Judge joins; Opinion
concurring-in-part and dissent-
ing-in-part with respect TO Part
IlI-C by Rader, Circuit Judge, in
which Michel and Linn, Circuit
Judges join; opinion concur-
ring-in-part and dissenting-in-
part with respect to Part III-C
by Linn, Circuit Judge, in which
February 23, 2001
March 22, 2001
May 8, 2001
June 19, 2001
65.
66.
1-38
Rader, Circuit Judge joins; opin-
ion concurring-in-part and dis-
senting-in-part with respect to
Parts III-A, III-B, IlI-C, and IV
by Newman, Circuit Judge. —
Judgment entered: 11/29/00.
Costs against each side. (eod by
ksh on 11/29/00) 95-1066
THE APPLICATION FOR EXT.
OF TIME TO FILE A WRIT OF
CERT HAS BEEN PRESENTED
TO THE CHIEF JUSTICE, WHO
ON 2/13/01, EXTENDED THE
TIME TO AND INCLUDING
MARCH 29, 2001. (cs-02/13/01)
RECEIVED: 02/23/01 (EOD
02/23/01) (BG) 95-1065
THE APPLICATION FOR AN
EXTENSION OF TIME WITHIN
WHICH TO FILE A CERT PETI-
TION HAS BEEN PRESENTED
TO THE CHIEF JUSTICE, WHO
ON 3/20/01, EXTENDED THE
TIME TO AND INCLUDING
4/9/01. (CS-03/20/01)
RECEIVED; 03/20/81 (EOD
03/22/01) (BG) 95-1066
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CER-
TIORARI FILED 04/09/01,
SUPREME COURT #: 00-1543.
(EOD 05/08/01 BY BG) 95-1066
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CER-
TIORARI FILED 04/09/01,
SUPREME COURT #: 00-1543,
CERT. GRANTED ON
1-39
06/18/01. (EOD 06/19/01 BY
BG) 95-1066
1-40
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Defendant,
V.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI CO
LTD., a/k/a SMC ;
CORPORATION and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.
Defendants and
Counterclaim Plaintiffs.
Civil Action No.
88-1814-MA
ee ee ee Nee? ee ee ee ee See See See ee Ce
REPORT OF SPECIAL MASTER
HERBERT F. SCHWARTZ, ESQ.
PURSUANT TO RULE 53(e)(1), F.R.Civ.P.
b. The Magnetizable Sleeve
Festo asserts that the SMC driven member’s non-
magnetizable sleeve is an equivalent of the magnetizable
sleeve in claim 1 of the Stoll patent. (Festo’s Post Trial
Brief, pp. 3-7.) In support of this contention Festo urges
that (1) the magnetizable sleeve limitation did not appear
in the German Stoll patent and should not have been
added to the U.S. patent (Festo’s Post Trial Brief, p. 5; Tr.
457); and (2) the sleeve material does not affect the
operation of the invention. (Festo’s Post Trial Brief, Ppp.
I-41
5-6; Tr. 642-645.) Neither of these arguments is
convincing.
First, the specification and prosecution history do not
support Festo’s assertion that the magnetizable limitation
should not have been in claim 1. In the specification the
sleeve is described as “made of a magnetizable material
to reduce magnetic leakage fields.” Col. 3, lines 61-62.
The prosecution history shows that the patent was filed
with a claim 1 that did not have the magnetizable
limitation; claim 8, which was dependent from claim 1,
had the limitation. In response to a rejection based on
Section 112 ¥ 1, claim 1 was rewritten as claim 13 and
claim 8 was canceled. (Px 14.) Since consideration was
given to whether or not the term should appear in the
claim after the first Office Action, Festo’s assertion that it
was not meant to be there is not persuasive.
Second, the specification contradicts Festo’s
argument that the sleeve material does not affect the
operation of the invention. Festo has tried to characterize
the invention as dealing only with sealing, wiping and
guiding. (Festo’s Post Trial Brief p. 3-4; Tr. 412-413.)
Nevertheless, the specification not only describes the
sleeve as being made from a magnetizable material but
also explains the reason for choosing that material:
If the driven assembly is provided with a sleeve
made of a magnetizable material, which
encircles the hollow cylindrical assembly of the
magnet arrangement, magnetic leakage fields in
the vicinity of the driven assembly can be kept
to a minimum. In this way, undesirable braking
forces, which would otherwise be generated
while piston and driven assembly pass
I-42
magnetizable machine components, are avoided.
(Px 15 col. 2, lines 23-30.)
Festo performed an experiment which was supposed
to demonstrate that regardless, of whether the sleeve was
made of a magnetizable or a non-magnetizable material,
the operation of the rodless cylinder was the same (Tr.
697-700; Festo’s Post-Trial Brief, p. 6.) SMC criticized the
test because it was not performed under load. (Tr.
806-808; SMC’s Post-Trial Brief, p. 15.) More importantly,
the test shed no light on whether or not both sleeves
achieved the advantages that Stoll attributed to having a
sleeve made of a magnetizable material: i.e. that both
magnetizable and non-magnetizable sleeves served to
minimize magnetic leakage fields in substantially the
same way.
According to the specification of the Stoll patent, a
sleeve made of a magnetizable material achieves the
benefit of minimizing magnetic leakage fields. Stoll
claims a device with a sleeve made of a magnetizable
material. The specification is silent concerning the use of
a sleeve made of a non-magnetizable material. Moreover,
at the time the application was filed, Stoll thought there
was an advantage to using a sieeve made of a
magnetizable material. (Tr. 461.)
Although Stoll initially filed a claim broad enough to
cover the use of a sleeve made of a magnetizable
material, he opted not to pursue such a claim after the
first Office Action. As the Federal Circuit said in Unique
Concepts, Inc. v. Brown, 939 F.2d 1558, 1562, 19 USPQ2d
1500, 1504 (Fed.Cir. 1991):
1-43
The statute requires that an inventor
particularly point out and distinctly claim the
subject matter of his invention. 35 U.S.C. § 112
(1988). It would run counter’ to this statutory
provision for an applicant for patent to
expressly state throughout his specification and
in his claims [a claim limitation] and then be
allowed to avoid that claim limitation in a later
infringement suit by pointing to one paragraph
in his specification stating an alternative that
lacks the limitation, and thus interpret the claim
contrary to its plain meaning. Such a result
would encourage an applicant to escape
examination of a more broadly-claimed
invention by filing narrow claims and then, after
grant, asserting a broader scope of the claims
based on a statement in the specification of an
alternative never presented in the claims for
examination.?2
The subject matter disclosed but not claimed in a
patent application is dedicated to the public. Miller v.
Brass Co., 104 U.S. 350 (1881). As the Federal Circuit
pointed out in Unique Concepts, if the applicant intended
to claim an alternative embodiment, he had to persuade
the examiner to issue the claim. As is apparent from the
Stoll patent prosecution history, Stoll submitted one claim
without the magnetizable material limitation and another
with the limitation. Both claims were rejected and Stoll
decided to only pursue a claim directed to a sleeve made
of a magnetizable material. (Px 14.)
22 See also International Visual Corporation v. Crown Metal
Manufacturing Co, Inc., No. 92-1262 (Fed.Cir. 1993) (Lourie, J.,
concurring at p. 5).
1-44
The doctrine of equivalents is the exce; tion and not
the rule. In this case, the meaning and scope of claim 1 of
the Stoll patent was clear. Stoll consciously chose to not
claim an embodiment of his invention that used a
magnetizable sleeve. Festo cannot now try to use the
doctrine of equivalents to recapture a claim that Stoll
abandoned during prosecution “because other players in
the marketplace are entitled to rely on the record made in
the Patent Office in determining the meaning and scope
of the patent.” Lemelson v. General Mills, Inc., 968 F.2d
1202, 1208, 23 USPQ2d 1284, 1289 (Fed.Cir. 1992).
Festo’s commercial embodiment, like SMC’s, uses a
non-magnetizable sleeve. (Px 118, 210.) However, the
patent claim, and not any commercial embodiment,
serves as notice to others of the patentees rights. SMC
had a right to rely on the claim language, in light of the
specification and the prosecution history, and to design
around it. London v. Carson Piri Scott & Co., 946 F.2d 1534,
20 USPQ2d 1456 (Fed.Cir. 1991), supra, accord, State
Industries v. A.O. Smith Corp., 751 F.2d 1226, 224 USPQ 418
(Fed.Cir. 1985). Therefore, claims 1-3 and 5-7 of the Stoll
patent are not infringed by the SMC rodless cylinders.
IV. DAMAGES
A. FESTO’S MOTION TO INCLUDE DAMAGES
PR
The majority of SMC’s sales were made in the years
1989-1991. (Tr. 1388; Dx 494.) This information was
produced on August 31, 1992 pursuant to an Order of the
Special Master. (Dkt. 172.) To protect the confidentiality
1-45
of SMC’s sales data, Festo used an independent
accountant to testify about damages at the hearing on
damage.
There was a dispute between the parties as to
whether Festo should be permitted to introduce into
evidence the testimony by its accountant, Steven Skalak,
and related exhibits taken de bene at the hearing on
damages because basis for the new evidence was not
included in the pretrial order.
* * om
sales denied to him is the measure of his loss,
and the Infringer is liable for that. Lam, Inc. v.
Johns-Manville Corp., 718 F.2d 1056, 1065, 219
USPQ 670, 675 (Fed.Cir. 1983) quoting Livesay
Window Company v. Livesay Industries, 251 F.2d
469, 471-72, 116 USPQ 167, 169 (5 Cir. 1958).
Festo and SMC were the only suppliers of sealed
magnetically coupled rodless cylinders during the period
of infringement. (Tr. 32.) There was a demand for the
magnetically coupled rodless cylinder because of their
unique characteristics. (Tr. 28-30.)
Mechanical rodless cylinders, like the band and cable
cylinders, did not offer the advantages of the
magnetically coupled rodless cylinder. (Tr. 1415-1425,
1844-1860.) Among these advantages are the ability to be
leak proof and the ability to work without special
lubricated operating fluid. Moreover, Festo could have
met the demand for increased rodless cylinders. (Tr. 1427,
1431.)
Festo failed to prove, however, that it lost any profits.
For seven out of ten years reported Festo had operating
1-46
losses. (Tr. 1643, 1755-1756.) For every dollar of Festo
sales, forty to fifty cents represents the cost of the product
and fifty to sixty cents represents the selling expenses.
(Tr. 1916-1918; Dx 102.) Festo did not show that the DGOs
were any more profitable than Festo’s other products. (Tr.
1638-1639.) Thus Festo did not demonstrate that, on a
straight dollar average, any increase in sales would have
led to an increase in profits. (Tr. 1640, 1691-1692.) Festo
did not offer proof to support the argument that on an
incremental basis additional sales would have created
profits.
Festo asserted that a company does not have to be
profitable to recover lost profits. Festo relied on Saf-Gard
Products, Inc. v. Service Parts, Inc., 491 F.Supp. 996, 206
USPQ 976 (D.Ariz. 1980) for this proposition. This
reliance is misplaced. In Saf-Gard, the plaintiff was
awarded lost profits based on a price erosion theory. The
infringing defendant’s presence and actions in the
marketplace drove down the price of the product, making
the plaintiff less profitable and, ultimately, bankrupt. The
court awarded damages based on the uneroded price. 491
F.Supp. at 1009, 206 USPQ at 986-987. Festo did not claim
price erosion. In fact, Festo’s rodless cylinders remained
more expensive than SMC’s throughout the infringement
period. (Tr. 1437, 1524.)
Festo has simply failed to show that it would have
netted anything had it made SMC’s sales. There is no
basis for awarding damages under a lost profits theory.
1-47
2. Reasonable Royalty
When a patent owner cannot establish lost profits or
an established royalty, it is entitled to a reasonable
royalty. This is characterized as the amount that would
have been set at the time the infringement began between
a hypothetical willing patent owner and a willing
potential
* * *
Lantech, Inc., 807 F.2d 970, 1 USPQ2d 1202 (Fed.Cir. 1986).
When the patentee makes substantive changes, the
reexamined claims are treated like reissue claims under
35 U.S.C. § 252. “Thus a person practicing a patented
invention would not be considered an infringer for the
period between issuance of an invalid patent and the
conversion through reexamination to a valid patent.”
Fortel Corp. v. Phone-Mate, Inc., 825 F.2d 1577, 1579, 3
USPQ2d 1771, 1773 (Fed.Cir. 1987), quoting H.R. Rep. No.
1307, 96th Cong., 2d Sess. 8 (1980).
During reexamination of the Carroll patent, Festo
canceled the only independent claim and added a new
independent claim. See supra. pp. 15-17. This was a
substantial change. As a result, the damages are based on
SMC sales made from the time the reexamination
certificate issued (October 25, 1988) to the expiration of
the reexamined Carroll patent (December 18, 1990). The
total infringing SMC sales was $1,470,127. A fifteen
percent royalty equals $220,519.
1-48
1. Prejudgment Interest
35 U.S.C. § 284 authorizes the award of
“interest . . . as fixed by the court.” In General Motors
Corp. v. Devex Corp., 461 U.S. 648, 657, 217 USPQ 1185,
1189 (1983), the Supreme Court found that awarding
prejudgment interest was within the discretion of the trial
court, but that prejudgment interest should ordinarily be
awarded
* * *
Thus, Festo’s contention is unfounded. SMC sought
the advice of outside counsel. SMC’s counsel reviewed
the patents and their prosecution histories and formed a
competen: legal opinion regarding infringement of the
Stoll pater.. and validity of the Carroll patent. Festo has
not proved willful infringement by clear and convincing
evidence by SMC.
A. ATTORNEY’S FEES
35 U.S.C. § 285 states. “The court in exceptional cases
may award reasonable attorney’s fees to the prevailing
party.” Festo has asked for an award of attorney’s fees
based on its contention that SMC’s infringement was
willful. (Fest Post Trial Brief, p. 48.) SMC has also
requested an award of attorney’s fees based on its
contention that several of Festo’s arguments were
frivolous and that Festo did not disclose the best mode of
making the Stoll patent. (SMC’s Post Trial Brief, pp.
47-48.)
This lawsuit was hotly contested. However, this is
not an exceptional case meriting the award of attorney’s
I-49
fees. I recommend that each side bear its own costs and
attorney’s fees.
VI. SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND DIRECTED
VERDICT MOTIONS
SMC moved for summary judgment of invalidity of
the Stoll patent based on failure to disclose the best
mode. (Dkt. 104.) SMC moved for summary judgment of
noninfringement of the Stoll patent based on its use of a
non-magnetizable sleeve. (Dkt. 117.) SMC also moved for
summary judgment of noninfringement of the
reexamined Carroll patent and the Stoll patent based on
its use of one seal, instead of two. (Dkt. 122.) At the
conclusion of plaintiff's evidence, SMC moved for a
directed verdict. (Tr. 866.) SMC renewed this motion at
the conclusion of the hearing on liability (Tr. 1302.)
It is proper to grant summary judgment under Rule
56(c), F.R.Civ.P. if “ the pleadings, depositions, answers to
interrogatories, and admissions on file, together with the
affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to
any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to
a judgment as a matter of law.” The Supreme Court has
said that under this standard, “the mere existence of some
alleged factual dispute between the parties will not defeat
an otherwise properly supported motion for summary
judgment; the requirement is that there be no genuine
issue of material fact. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477
U.S. 242, 247-48 (1986) (emphasis in original).
The Federal Circuit has found that “[s]ummary
judgment is as available in patent cases as in other areas
1-50
of litigation.” Continental Can Co. USA, Inc. v. Monsanto
Co., 948 F.2d 1264, 1265, 20 USPQ2d 1746, 1747 (Fed.Cir.
1991). Of course, the court must “view the evidence
presented in a light most favorable to the nonmoving
party” and “draw all reasonable inferences in favor of the
nonmoving party.” C.R. Bard, Inc. v. Advanced
Cardiovascular Systems, 911 F.2d 670, 672, 15 USPQ2d 1540,
1542 (Fed.Cir. 1990). “The burden of establishing
summary judgment is with the movant, with due
consideration to the burdens and presumptions at trial.”
Laitram Corp. v. NEC Corp., 952 F.2d 1357, 1363, 21
USPQ2d 1276, 1280-1281 (Fed.Cir. 1991).
The Supreme Court has adopted the view that the
standard for summary judgment mirrors the standard for
a directed verdict. Anderson at 250. Thus “the trial judge
must direct a verdict if, under the governing law, there
can be but one reasonable conclusion as to the verdict.”
Id. Directed verdicts are now called judgments as a
matter of law under Rule 50, F.R.Civ.P., but this standard
has not changed. 1991 Advisory Committee Notes.
Because the motion for a directed verdict was made to a
Special Master, and not a trial judge, I have also
considered this motion under Rule 52(c)?* as a motion for
judgment on partial findings. Rule 52(c) parallels Rule
50(a), allowing the court to enter judgment when it can
appropriately make a disposition on the evidence.
In light of the findings of fact and recommendations
made in this report after the hearings herein, |
24 Before December 1, 1991 such a motion was available
under Rule 41(b), F.R.Civ.P. See, e.g., Pitts v. United States 599
F.2d 1103 (1 Cir. 1979).
I-51
recommend that the motion concerning invalidity on best
mode of the Stoll patent be denied. I also recommend that
the notion concerning the noninfringement of both
patents based on SMC’s use of one seal be denied.
Based on the analysis contained in this report
concerning the magnetizable sleeve limitation in the Stoll
patent claims, summary judgment and a directed verdict
or judgment on partial findings in favor of SMC is
appropriate with respect to SMC’s noninfringement of
claims 1-3 and 5-7 of Stoll.25 Festo and SMC agree that the
SMC driven member has a non-magnetizable sleeve.
Therefore there is no dispute as to any material fact. The
dispute centers on the meaning of the limitation in the
claim.
Claim construction is a question of law for the court.
Loctite Corp. v. Ultraseal, Ltd., 781 F.2d 861, 228 USPQ 90
(Fed.Cir. 1985). To properly construe the claims, the court
should look to the specification, file history, other claims
and expert testimony. Whittaker Corp. v. UNR Industries,
Inc., 911 F.2d 709, 15 USPQ2d 1742 (Fed.Cir. 1990);
Lemelson v. General Mills, Inc., 968 F.2d 1202, 1208, 23
USPQ2d 1284, 1289 (Fed.Cir. 1992). As demonstrated
supra. pp. 47-51, when properly construed the Stoll claims
cannot be read to cover the non-magnetizable sleeves
used in the SMC rodless cylinders. Therefore I
recommend that SMC’s motion for summary judgment
25 The discussion in this report makes plain that there is no
basis for granting Festo’s motion for a directed verdict. (Tr.
1302.) And, in any event, Festo never briefed such a motion as it
said it would. (Tr. 1308.)
1-52
and its motion for directed verdict of non-infringement of
claims 1-3 and 5-7 of Stoll be granted.
Vil. CONCLUSION
SMC’s rodless cylinders do not infringe any of claims
1-3 or 5-7 of the Stoll patent. The SMC cylinders with
cushions, in both the basic and the slider lines, and two
seals literally infringe claims 5, 6 and 9 of the reexamined
Carroll patent. The SMC cylinders with cushions, in both
the basic and the slider lines, and one seal infringe claims
5,6 and 9 under the doctrine of equivalents. Based on this
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent, I
recommend that damages and prejudgment interest in the
amount of $251,850 be awarded.
/s/ Herbert F. Schwartz
Herbert F. Schwartz, Esq.
Special Master
April 27, 1993
I-53
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
x
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Defendant, Civil Action
7 No. 88-1814-MA
SHOKETSU KINZOKU KoGYo : 5BO #549137
KABUSHIKI CO., LTD., a/k/a
SMC CORPORATION, and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.,
Defendants and
Counterclaim Plaintiffs.
X
FESTO CORPORATION’S OBJECTIONS TO REPORT
OF SPECIAL MASTER HERBERT F. SCHWARTZ, ESQ.
PURSUANT TO RULE 53(e)(3), E.R. CIV. P.
* * =
invention includes a number of functionally and struc-
turally cooperatively assembled components of which the
sleeve is merely one of many. This is readily apparent
from reading clair’ 1 of the patent. The solution of the
wiping, guiding and sealing problems as defined in
Claim 1 of the Stoll patent involved the use of separate
guide and seal rings, as acknowledged by the Special
Master on pages 27 and 38-39 of his Report. The separate
rings act in cooperation with the remaining elements of
the claim to carry out the functions of the invention in
1-54
wiping, guiding and sealing in order to operate in keep-
ing dirt and impurities from interfering with the func-
tioning of the rodless cylinder.
The sleeve on the outer or driven member serves to
encircle and assist in holding the rings and magnets in
position. Whether it is made of steel (magnetizable) or
aluminum (non-magnetizable) does not matter for the
recited functions of the claimed invention including
wiping, guiding and sealing. (TR 411-413; 642-645).
The gratuitous inclusion of the words relating to the
sleeve as being formed “of a magnetizable material” was
not necessary and not intended by the inventor to have
been included and should not be considered as material
to the interpretation of the claim for purposes of infringe-
ment. (TR 412). Dr. Stoll should not be held to uninten-
tional limitations added incorrectly by an attorney of
which he was not aware and of which he certainly did not
intend. In the remainder of the world, Stoll’s correspond-
ing patents do not have a sleeve material restriction in
their main claim. (TR 412). The claim should clearly be
interpreted to hypothetically omit the language “of a
magnetizable material”. The law clearly permits such an
interpretation as discussed below.
Minimizing braking forces due to magnetic field
leakage is incidental to the invention and not included in
the claim. Dr. Wolf pointed this out in his testimony (TR
820-821). Dr. Stoll also clearly explained that for purposes
of the invention, the sleeves are the same. (TR 411-413;
535-539). In fact, the difference in minimizing magnetic
field leakage braking forces is insubstantial as pointed
out by the uncontroverted testimony of Dr. Wolf. The
1-55
video film presented as evidence by Festo through Dr.
Wolf displaying two cylinders operating in synchroniza-
tion for a period of time shows no difference in braking
force between the steel and aluminum sleeves in opera-
tion. (Px P-22).
It must be emphasized that claim 1 does not require
and does not even mention a function of minimizing
magnetic field leakage to carry out the invention.
There is no prior art basis for limiting the interpreta-
tion of the claim in this manner. There was no file wrap-
per estoppel. The Examiner presented no prior art to limit
this interpretation
* * *.
carrying out the invention and then attempted to invali-
date the patent on that basis. (TR 971, 988). Accordingly,
no prior art was presented and none is known which
would require the Stoll invention to include a recitation
of the magnetizable material for the purpose of minimiz-
ing magnetic leakage fields or any other purpose. A
hypothetical Claim 1 eliminating the words “of a magne-
tizable material” is clearly patentable over the prior art.
In rejecting SMC’s failed attempt to invalidate Claim 1 of
the Stoll patent independent of whether the sleeve is
magnetizable or not, the Master clearly pointed out the
numerous ways in which the patent claims in issue were
valid independent of the sleeve material. (Master's
Report pgs. 31-42).
Accordingly, there was no reason for Dr. Stoll to
include a gratuitous recitation such as magnetizable
sleeve material in his broadest claim, Claim 1. He has
1-56
clearly testified that this was not the case. He never
intended to do so and it should not have been done. (TR
457). The prior art does not require it and Dr. Stoll did not
choose to include it. It was mistakenly included by the
attorney prosecuting the application before the United
States Patent and Trademark Office without consultation
with the inventor. (TR 455). It certainly does not represent
the inventor’s wishes and he should not be bound by it.
The Examiner at the Patent and Trademark Office
certainly did not require that the recitation be included in
the claim. He
1-57
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Defendant,
v.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI CO.
LTD., a/k/a SMC
CORPORATION and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.
Defendants and
Counterclaim Plaintiffs.
Civil Action No.
88-1814-PBS
tll i i i i
PLAINTIFF FESTO CORPORATION’S
PRETRIAL MEMORANDUM UNDER L.R. 16.5
100. Festo has its main headquarters on Long
Island, New York and has about 100,000 square feet in its
building.
101. Mr. Kurt Stoll is a graduate mechanical
engineer and received his diploma in 1960. He is one of
the owners of Festo KG, the parent of Plaintiff Festo. He
is also a Director of Festo KG. He and his brother,
Wilfried Stoll, are Managing Partners of Festo KG.
1-58
102. The products sold in the United States are
manufactured and sold by Festo Corporation, the U.S.
subsidiary of Festo KG.
FACTS WHICH FESTO INTENDS
TO PROVE AT TRIAL
IN SUPPORT OF EACH CLAIM
1. The Carroll and Stoll patents were duly and
legally issued and are valid.
2. The making, assembly and selling of magnetically
coupled rodless cylinders in this judicial district and
elsewhere in the United States by SMC Pneumatics
constitute direct and contributory infringement of, and
active inducement to infringe, the Carroll and Stoll
patents.
3. The shipping of parts of the magnetically coupled
rodless cylinder into the United States for assembly here,
and the selling of magnetically coupled rodless cylinders
in this judicial district and elsewhere in the United States
by SMC Corp.
* * *
and the magnets on the piston so that there would be
minimal resistance to movement of the piston within the
tube under pneumatic or hydraulic force. Additionally, it
was necessary to seal the tube and to wipe dirt particles
or contaminants within the tube away from the area
where the magnets are located. In this way, the possibility
of reducing the magnetic attraction force due to
contamination or dirt is minimized.
1-59
91. Prior art rodless cylinders incorporated a single
ring on the piston which was used to not only maintain
the separation between the piston and the inner wall
surface of the tube but also to create a seal with the inner
wall surface so that fluid pressure can build up within the
tube on one side of the piston to move the piston. A more
rigid or harder material used for the seal is desirable in
order to maintain the separation between the piston and
the inner wall surface of the tube. However, when a more
rigid or harder material is used for the seal, the sealing
and wiping functions are not effectively obtained. On the
other hand, if a soft resilient material is used for the seal,
it will conform well to the engaging surface of the inner
wall of the cylinder tube and seal and wipe effectively;
but, the magnetic force and free floating piston will
overcome the soft material and the magnets will engage
the tube wall and interfere with the reciprocal movement
of the piston in the tube.
92. Mr. Stoll conceived of a solution to the above
problems. Mr. Stoll divided the task of accomplishing
these separate functions into separate means positioned
on the piston.
93. Mr. Stoll conceived of the idea of using an inner
guide ring on the piston, which ring is made of a more
rigid but slidable material, to maintain the proper
spacing between the piston magnets and the wall of the
tube while the piston reciprocately moves in the tube. Mr.
Stoll further conceived of the idea of using a wiper ring
adjacent to the guide ring where the wiper ring is made
from a soft resilient material, which carries out the
primary wiping and sealing function.
1-60
94. There is some overlap in function between the
wiping and sealing ring and the guide ring and the
ultimate result is a very effective magnetically coupled
rodless cylinder which will have a long operational life.
95. The above problem-and solutions are fully
described in U.S. Patent No. 4,354,125, which issued on
October 12, 1982 to Kurt Stoll.
96. The claims of the Stoll patent specifically define
Mr. Stoll’s invention in regard to the guiding, wiping and
sealing functions.
I-61
DEFENDANT’S EXHIBIT 105
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
x
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Defendant, Civil Action
7 No. 88-1814-MA
SHOKETSU KINZOKU KOGY] : BBO #549137
KABUSHIKI CO., LTD., a/k/a
SMC CORPORATION, and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.,
Defendants and
Counterclaim Plaintiffs.
X
PLAINTIFF FESTO CORPORATION’S
TRIAL MEMORANDUM
* 7 +
B. SMC’s Infringement Of The Carroll Patent.
As will be established at trial, SMC has literally
infringed claims 9, 5 and 6 of the Carroll patent. In other
words, the accused SMC devices include each and every
element recited in the above claims.
C. SMC’s Infringement Of The Stoll Patent.
Most of the accused SMC devices include each and
every element recited in claims 1-3 and 5-7 of the Stoll
I-62
patent with the exception of the composition of the cylin-
drical sleeve which encircles the tube of the driving mem-
ber. Specifically, the sleeves of the accused devices are
made from a non-magnetizable material, such as an alu-
minum alloy, instead of a magnetizable material as
recited in the claims. In addition, some of the accused
devices apparently employ only one sealing ring instead
of “rings” as claimed.
1. The substitution of a non-magnetizable
sleeve for a magnetizable sleeve does not
substantially change the operation of the.
device -as claimed.
The courts have addressed situations on all fours
with the case at bar. In Graver Tank, supra, which is
considered the classical equivalents decision, the patentee
claimed a fusible composition containing “a major pro-
portion of one or more alkaline earth metal silicates.” The
* * *
thereby be well equipped to determine whether SMC has
made a change of such substance as to make the doctrine
of equivalents inapplicable, or whether they have simply
replaced a sleeve of one type of material with one of a
different material that does not cause the invention to
operate in a materially different manner.
1-63
2. The use of one sealing ring, as opposed to
more than one ring, for wiping the internal
wall of the tube containing the piston is not a
change of such substance as to make the
doctrine of equivalents inapplicable.
It is well settled that “infringement is not avoided by
making into one part that which has been shown as two.”
No-Joint Concrete Pipe Co. v. Hanson, 344 F.2d 13, 15 (9th
Cir. 1965). SMC has nevertheless attempted to avoid
infringement of the Stoll patent by using only one sealing
ring in some of its rodless cylinders rather than more
than one. It is clear that the unit will be sealed, thereby
allowing the piston to be moved by pneumatic pressure
regardless of the number of sealing rings used. It is also
clear that one sealing ring will provide wiping action as
described in the Stoll patent. It will accordingly be shown
at trial that SMC’s units are functionally equivalent to the
patented Festo construction.
The use of two seals may provide certain additional
advantages over one, such as more efficient wiping. The
court addressed the same situation in the No-
1-64
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Defendant,
Civil Action No.
88-1814-MA
BBO #549137
V.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI CO.
LTD., a/k/a SMC
CORPORATION and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.
Defendants and
Counterclaim Plaintiffs.
ee eee ee eee eee
PLAINTIFF FESTO CORPORATION'S
TRIAL BRIEF
= * *
alloy materials. Festo will also provide evidence that the
sleeve material of the SMC device performs substantially
the same function, in substantially the same way to
achieve substantially the same result as the claimed
invention. More specifically. the Stoll invention is
directed to wiping, guiding and sealing, i.e. wiping dirt
and impurities away from the magnets of the piston and
driven member, guiding the piston and driven member
inside and outside the cylinder tube, respectively, and
sealing the piston to prevent “blow-by”. Accordingly, the
material used for the sleeve which encircles the outer
1-65
magnet arrangement is inconsequential to the Stoll
invention of wiping, guiding and sealing. Festo will show
at trial that the specific arrangement of the guide rings
and seals are not affected by the driven member sleeve
material.
A function attributable to the sleeve material in the
specification of the Stoll patent will be shown by Festo to
not be part of the claimed invention; however, even if one
were to include the function of keeping magnetic leakage
fields in the vicinity of the driven member to a minimum,
Festo will prove at trial that the aluminum alloy sleeve
material will function in substantially the same way to
achieve substantially the same result as a magnetizable
sleeve material.
The jury will thereby be well equipped to determine
whether SMC has made a change of such substance as
1-66
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff,
Vv.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI CO.,
LTD., a/k/a SMC
CORPORATION and SMC
PNEUMATICS, INC.,
Defendants.
CIVIL ACTION NO.
88-1814-PBS
ee wee wee eee le el oe le we
ORDER RE: PRETRIAL MOTIONS
July 11, 1994
Saris, U.S.DJ.
On February 3, 1994, this Court heard oral argument
on the following motions: The motions by SMC Conpene-
tion and SMC Pneumatics, Inc. (collectively “SMC”) for
summary judgment on non-infringement of the Stoll Pat-
ent, non-infringement of the Carroll Patent, and
invalidity of the Stoll Patent’; and the motions by Festo
Corporation (“Festo”) for summary judgment and for a
1 Prior to the Master’s Hearing, SMC filed motions for
summary judgment on non-infringement of the Stoll —
non-infringement of the Stoll and Carroll Patents by the _~ ne
SMC rodless cylinder, and invalidity of the Stoll Pa y=
Following the Master's Hearing, SMC filed a motion ~
summary judgment and a directed verdict on non-infringemen
of the Stoll Patent.
I-67
directed verdict on infringement of the Carroll patent,
validity of the Carroll patent, infringement of the Stoll
patent, and validity of the Stoll patent. As discussed in
court that day, and as explained in a Procedural Order
issued on February 18, 1994, all motions for summary
judgment were denied, with the exception of the motions
concerning infringement of the Reexamined Carroll pat-
ent. After additional briefing on that issue, this Court
now orders that Festo’s and SMC’s motions are each
allowed and denied in part. This opinion also addresses
the use of the Master’s Report (“Report”) at trial, and
assumes familiarity with that report. The Court also
explains the reasons for denial of the motions concerning
infringement of the Stoll Patent under the doctrine of
equivalents, which SMC urged the court to reconsider.
1. Master’s Report
On May 21, 1992, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 53(e)(3),
Judge Mazzone referred this case to Special Master Her-
bert F. Schwartz, Esq. for the purpose of considering all
claims presented by the parties. In the Order of Refer-
ence, Judge Mazzone explained that the appointment of a
special master was warranted because “[nJot only are the
claims complex, but the history of this litigation, the
voluminous record, and the contentions of the parties
promise that this case will require an inordinate amount
of judicial time and resources at a time when this Court
has four pending vacancies and my own schedule is
severely taxed.”
SMC filed a limited objection to the reference, pri-
marily directed to the contention that the Master’s
1-68
authority be no broader than that provided under Fed. R.
Civ. P. 53(e). Hearings on the issues of infringement,
invalidity and enforceability of the reexamined Carroll
and Stoll patents were held before the special master on
September 14-21 and hearings on damages were held on
October 19-22 and on November 9, 1992. The Master
issued his report on April 27, 1993. Both sides filed objec-
tions in a timely fashion.
Fed. R. Civ. P. 53 (b) provides that a reference to a
master shall be “the exception and not the rule.” “In
actions to be tried by a jury, a reference shall be made
only when the issues are complicated. . . . ” Id. In an
action to be tried by a jury, the master’s “findings upon
the issues submitted to the master are admissible as evi-
dence of the matters found and may be read to the jury,
subject to the ruling of the court upon any objections in
point of law which may be made to the report.” Fed. R.
Civ. P. 53(e)(3).
“(T]he court has the power to appoint masters with-
out the consent of the parties.” Constant v. Advanced
Micro-Devices Inc., 848 F.2d 1560, 1566 (Fed. Cir.) (“Con-
stant”), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 892 (1988). “Reference of
issues to a master, even compulsory reference, does not
violate the 7th Amendment right to trial by a jury to
which a master’s findings may be read under Rule
53(e)(3).” Id. (citing Crateo, Inc. v. Intermark, Inc., 536 F.2d
862, 868 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 429 U.S. 896 (1976)). See
also Ex parte Peterson, 253 U.S, 300, 312 (1920).
“Where complicated issues of patent law are
involved, the appointment of an experienced patent attor-
ney is quite appropriate.” Constant, 848 F.2d at 1567.
1-69
“Masters can properly aid the court in evaluating issues
of patent validity and infringement in the context of
motions for summary judgment, and have often done so.”
Id. at 1566. Cf. International Nickel Co. v. Ford Motor Co.,
166 F. Supp. 551, 553 (S.D.N.Y. 1958) (reference to master
in highly technical patent case). “Masters have been
employed by courts (under Fed. R. Civ. P. 53 (e)(3)) to
explain technology to the jury or make findings on speci-
fic issues which are then read to the jury.” Structural
Rubber Products Co. v. Park Rubber Co., 749 F.2d 707, 720
(Fed. Cir. 1984).
| in jury cases, some courts have held that the master’s
findings constitute prima facie evidence to be submitted
to the jury for its consideration. Coyner v. United States,
103 F.2d 629, 634-35 (7th Cir. 1939). See generally Irving R.
Kaufman, Masters in the Federal Courts: Rule 53, 58 Colum-
bia L. Rev. 452, 460 (1958).
SMC has filed a motion in limine objecting to submis-
sion of the master’s fact findings to the jury. This court
has determined that the master’s report will be submitted
to the jury because of the complexity of the issues and
technology involving magnetically coupled rodless cylin-
ders and two dific cent patents. Due to the length of the
report, the number of issues, and the complexity of the
technology, the Court will allow the jury to read the
report by themselves rather than have the report read
orally to them. However, in order to ensure that the
master’s report not receive undue weight, it will not
remain with the jurors while deliberating. The attorneys
have conferred and agreed to sanitize the report to delete
contentions of the parties, and issues which the court has
ruled on as a matter of law.All disputes were resolved by
1-70
the court. Finally, the Court will not instruct the jury that
the master’s report is “prima facie” evidence, as that
language is missing from Rule 53. Rather, the Court will
instruct the jury that it may deterrine what weight, if
any, to give the master’s findings.
2. Infringement Under Doctrine of Equivalents of
Stoll Patent Concerning | Magnetizable Sleeve
Limitation
Based on the analysis contained in the report con-
cerning the magnetizable sleeve limitation in claim 1 of
the Stoll patent, the master recommended that SMC’s
motion for summary judgment should be granted with
respect to SMC’s infringement of claims 1-3 and 5-7 of
Stoll. SMC has moved that this Court adopt the master’s
recommendation with respect to non-infringement of the
Stoll patent. Festo has moved for summary judgment
and/or a directed verdict of infringement of the Stoll
patent.
“In order to determine a question of patent infringe-
ment, a district court must (1) determine as a matter of
law the scope and meaning of the claims at issue and (2)
determine as a factual matter whether the properly con-
strued claims encompass or ‘read on’ the accused
device.” Vaupel Textilmaschinen v. Meccanica Euro Italia,
944 F.2d 870, 879 (Fed. Cir. 1991) (“Vaupel”). See also ZMI
Corp. v. Cardiac Resuscitator Corp., 844 F.2d 1576, 1578
(Fed. Cir. 1988). “To ascertain the meaning of claims, [the
court considers] three sources: the claims, the specifica-
tion, and the prosecution history.” Unique Concepts, Inc. v.
Brown, 939 F.2d 1558, 1561 (Fed. Cir. 1991) (“Unique”). To
I-71
constitute an infringement, the accused device must con-
tain each and every limitation of the claim or its substan-
tial equivalent. Vaupel, 944 F.2d at 879. “An equivalent
must be found for every limitation of the claim some-
where in an accused device, but not necessarily in a
corresponding component, although that is generally the
case.” Corning Glass Works v. Sumitomo Elec. U.S.A., Inc.,
868 F.2d 1251, 1259 (Fed. Cir. 1989) (adding negative
dopant to the cladding is equivalent to adding positive
dopant to the core in the context of the claimed inven-
tion).
The court agrees with the conclusion of the Master
that “when properly construed the Stoll claims cannot be
read to cover the non-magnetizable sleeves used in the
saec rodless cylinders.” Report, pp. 47-50, 68. Thus, there
is no literal infringement as a matter of law. Festo does
not dispute this ruling.
However, the court disagrees that summary judg-
ment can be granted with respect to the claim of infringe-
ment by equivalents. A finding of infringement by
equivalents requires a determination whether the accused
device performs substantially the same function in sub-
stantially the same way to achieve substantially the same
result. Unique, 939 F.2d at 1564. See generally Graver Tank
& Mfg. Co.. Inc. v. Linde Air Prods. Co., 339 U.S. 605, 608
(1950). “This equitable doctrine evolved from a balancing
of competing policies, each of which supports the Consti-
tutional purpose of promoting the ‘useful arts.’ ” London
v. Carson Pirie Scott & Co., 946 F.2d 1534, 1538 (Fed. Cir.
1991) (“London”) (citing U.S. Const. art. |, § 8, cl. 8).
I-72
On the one hand claims must be ‘particular’ and
‘distinct,’ as required by 35 U.S.C. § 112, so that
the public has fair notice of what the patentee
and the Patent Trademark office have agreed
constitute the metes and bounds of the claimed
invention. . . . On the other hand, the patentee
should not be deprived of the benefits of his
patent by competitors who appropriate the
essence of an invention while barely avoiding
the literal language of the claims. . . . Thus,
where an infringer, instead of inventing around
a patent by making a substantial change, merely
makes an insubstantial change, essentially mis-
appropriating or even ‘stealing’ the patented
invention, infringement may lie under the doc-
trine of equivalents. Application of the doctrine
of equivalents is the exception, however, not the
rule. ...
Id. (citations omitted).
“The essence of prosecution history estoppel is that a
patentee should not be able to obtain, through the doc-
trine of equivalents, coverage of subject matter that was
relinquished during prosecution to procure issuance of the
patent.” Hoganas AB v. Dresser Indus., Inc., 9 F.3d 948,
951-52 (Fed. Cir. 1993) (“Hoganas”) (emphasis added).
“The legal standard for determining what subject matter
was relinquished is an objective one, measured from the
vantage point of what a competitor was reasonably enti-
tled to conclude, from the prosecution history, that the
applicant gave up to procure issuance of the patent.” Id.
at 952.
“The doctrine of prosecution history estoppel bars ‘a
patentee from enforcing its claims against otherwise
legally equivalent structures if those structures were
1-73
excluded by claim limitations added in order to avoid
prior art.’ ” Vaupel, 944 F.2d at 882 (quoting Mannesmann
Demag Corp. v. Engineered Metal Prods. Co., Inc., 793 F.2d
1279, 1284 (Fed. Cir. 1986)). “In determining whether
prosecution history estoppel applies because of a change
in claim language during prosecution, the court must
consider not only what was changed, but the reason for
such change.” Id. (emphasis in original) (because the
record does not indicate that the limitation was added to
avoid prior art, there was no estoppel to finding infringe-
ment by equivalents). “The scope of estoppel must be
determined in light of the prior art that occasioned the
change, as well as representations made to the patent
examiner as to the reason for change.” Sun Studs, Inc, v.
ATA Equipment Leasing, Inc., 872 F.2d 978, 987 (Fed. Cir.
1989) (no estoppel where the discussion of patentability
before the PTO was unrelated to the description of the
geometric shape) (“Sun Studs”), overruled on other grounds
by A.C. Aukerman Co., v. R.L. Chaides Const. Co., 960 Fd
1020, 1038-39 (Fed. Cir. 1992). “[E]stoppel is not auto-
matic whenever a claim is cancelled... . ” Id. at 987.
ee history estoppel is ordinarily a question of
aw.
SMC vigorously argues that this Court should adopt
the master’s recommendation that Festo is estopped
under the doctrine of prosecution history estoppel from
claiming that it is entitled to a range of equivalents which
would erase “meaningful structural and functional! lim-
itations of the claim on which the public is entitled to rely
in avoiding infringement.” Hoganas, 9 F.3d at 954 (quoting
Perkin-Elmer Corp. v. Westinghouse Elec. Corp., 822 F.2d
1528, 1532 (Fed. Cir. 1987)). In Hoganas, the court found
1-74
prosecution history estoppel where: the examiner during
prosecution issued an office action rejecting claims for
obviousness; the claimant distinguished the claims so as
to relinquish coverage of capillary-sized fibers; and the
examiner subsequently allowed the claims based on this
distinction. The court held: “In our view, a reasonable
competitor could have concluded, from a reading of the
prosecution history, that the examiner relied on this dis-
tinction in allowing the claims, and thus, that Hoganas
had given up coverage of the subject matter incorporat-
ing this distinction.” Hoganas, 9 F.3d at 953.
Here, in the First Office Action, the examiner rejected
all claims under 35 U.S.C. § 112 par. 1, which provides:
“The specification shall contain a written description of
the invention, and of the manner and process of making
and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms
as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it
pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to
make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode
contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his inven-
tion.” The examiner commented: “Exact method of opera-
tion unclear. Is device a true motor or magnetic clutch.”
Claims 4-12 were also rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112 for
being improperly multiply dependent. Report 37. They
were not rejected for obviousness under 35 U.S.C. § 103.
The initial claim 1 did not limit the sleeve of the
driven member to being constructed of a magnetizable
material. Claim 8, which was dependent from claim 1,
had such a limitation. Report 31. In response to this first
office action, Stoll cancelled independent claim 1 and
substituted a completely new independent claim which
I-75
required that the driven member have a sleeve con-
structed of a magnetizable material. Report 32.
Although the examiner identified certain “cited refer-
ences believed pertinent,” there is nothing in the record
or the report to indicate that the limitation of a magnetiz-
able sleeve was necessary to distinguish the claimed
invention over prior art. Further, there is nothing in the
record or the report to suggest that the limitation of a
sleeve of magnetizable material was necessary to meet
the requirements of specification under 35 U.S.C. § 112.
Indeed, the reason why the newly substituted indepen-
dent claim has the limitation that the sleeve be made of
magnetizable material is a mystery, as nothing seems to
turn on its composition for purpose of procuring the
patent. At the very least, it is a question of fact. Sun Stud,
872 F.2d at 987. This Court is not persuaded by SMC’s
reliance on Haynes Int’l., Inc. v. Jessop Steel Co., 8 F.3d
1573, 1577-78 (Fed. Cir. 1993) (“Haynes”), in which two
claims reciting a relatively broad range of chromium con-
tent were abandoned, and a third claim with a more
specific chromium content was retained. In Haynes,
unlike the present case, it was clear from the prosecution
history “that chromium content was the principal distinc-
tion between the claimed subject matter and the prior art,
and this was the primary area of dialogue between Cabot
and the PTO.” Id. at 1578. Accordingly, in light of the
circumstances of the present record, this court declines to
adopt the recommendation of the master that the claim of
infringement by equivalents is barred under the doctrine
of prosecution history estoppel.
In addition, with respect to equivalency Festo has
presented expert testimony of Dr. Robert Wolf and of Dr.
1-76
Stoll to support its claim of infringement under the doc-
trine of equivalents. Festo argues that SMC has produced
no evidence to dispute the testimony of Wolf and Stoll
that magnetizable and non-magnetizable sleeves operate
in substantially the same manner. However, the patent
itself states that if the driven assembly is provided with a
sleeve made of magnetizable material, “magnetic leakage
fields in the vicinity of the driven assembly can be kept to
a minimum. In this way, undesirable breaking forces,
which would otherwise be generated while piston and
driven assembly pass magnetizable machine components,
are avoided.” Record 48. This language in the specifica-
tion, together with the prosecution history, creates a dis-
puted issue of fact appropriate for resolution by a jury
under the function/way/result test. Unique, 939 F.2d at
1564 (even where there was no literal infringement as a
result of plain language of claim and prosecution history,
the court examined expert testimony in evaluating
whether there was infringement by equivalents). Accord-
ingly, both motions are denied. |
3. Literal Infringement of the Reexamined Carroll
Patent
Festo has moved for summary judgment on its claim
of infringement with respect to the reexamined Carroll
patent. Claim 9 of the reexamined Carroll patent requires
“a pair of cushion members formed of resilient material,
the cushion members being situated near opposite axial
ends of the central mounting member to help prevent
damage to the piston when the piston contacts an axial
end of the cylinder... . ”
I-77
A. 6, 10 and 15 mm slider pistons
The 6, 10 and 15 mm slider pistons have no cushions
and Festo does not contend that they infringe.
B. 25, 32, and 40 mm slider pistons
SMC contends that the cushions in the 25, 32 and 40
mm slider pistons cannot prevent damage by making
contact with the end plates, because a bolt protrudes from
the piston such that the end plate will make contact with
the bolt rather than the cushion. (Testimony of Dr. Blanco,
Tr. 1800). Festo has neither put forth any evidence to
dispute the contention nor pressed the issue in its briefs.
Accordingly, SMC’s motion for summary judgment on the
claim of literal infringement will be granted.
C. Basic Pistons
As to the basic pistons, SMC contends that “in nor-
mal operation,” their cushions do not “prevent damage to
the piston” since they do not make contact with the end
plate. This is because “in normal operation” the piston is
stopped by stopping the load rather than stopping the
load by stopping the piston. The court agrees with the
conclusion of the master that the language of claim 9 of
the reexamined Carroll patent does not distinguish
between situations where contact with the axial end of
the cylinder is the normal result of the completion of a
stroke and where it comes into play only in the case of
decoupling. Report 20-22. Accordingly, the court grant’s
Festo’s motion for summary judgment with respect to the
claim of literal infringement of claims 5, 6 and 9 of the
1-78
reexamined Carroll patent on the basic pistons with two
seals and cushions.
4. Infringement Under Doctrine of Equivalents of
Reexamined Carroll and Stoll Patents Concerning
Seals
SMC has moved for summary judgment on non-
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent and the
Stoll patent based on its use of one seal rodless cylinders,
instead of two. Festo has also moved for summary judg-
ment on their claim of infringement by equivalents. Since
the Carroll and Stoll patents specifically recite two seals,
there is no dispute that the one seal basic and the one seal
slider SMC rodless cylinders do not literally infringe.
Claim 1 of the Stoll patent states inter alia:
Said piston further including plural guide ring
means encircling said piston body and slidingly
engaging said internal wall and first sealing
rings located axially outside said guide rings for
wiping said internal wall as said piston moves
along said tube to thereby cause any impurities
that may be present in said tube to be pushed
along said tube so that said first annular mag-
nets will be free of interference from said impu-
rities.
Claim 9 of the reexamined Carroll patent specifically
defines “a pair of resilient sealing rings situated near
opposite axial ends of the central mounting member and
engaging the cylinder to provide a fluid-tight seal there-
with.”
1-79
SMC argues that use of only one seal allows dirt to
enter the piston chamber and is therefore not equivalent
to two seals. The master rejected the argument as
“flawed” as applied to the reexamined Carroll patent
because it is based on the meaning and function of the
sealing rings as described in the Stoll patent, not in the
Carroll patent. Report 24. Rather, the Master found that
under the Carroll patent: “The seals create a fluid-tight
seal against the pressure medium, enabling the piston to
be pushed by its force. This results in the piston being
efficiently moved by the pressure medium without
“blow-by” or air getting around the seals.” Report 24.
Festo has presented undisputed evidence that for this
purpose the one seal in the SMC device performs sub-
stantially the same function and achieves substantially
the same result in substantially the same way as two
seals.
The only evidence which SMC has produced to dis-
pute the claim of infringement by equivalents is state-
ments made by Festo in the context of prosecution of the
Stoll patent. In particular, there is a statement by Dr. Stoll
that two seals are necessary under the Stoll patent
because without two sealing rings, dirt attracted by the
magnet will enter the side without the sealing ring. This
evidence concerning dirt and impurities does not bear on
the meaning and function of the sealing rings as
described in the reexamined Carroll patent.
Accordingly, the Court allows Festo’s motion for
summary judgment that the one seal SMC basic cylinders
infringe claims 5, 6 and 9 of the reexamined Carroll
patent under the doctrine of equivalents. However, the
Court denies Festo’s motion for summary judgment that
the one seal SMC basic cylinders infringe claim 1 of the
1-80
Stoll patent under the doctrine of equivalents. Consider-
ing the above statement by Dr. Stoll on the importance of
two seals, as well as conflicting testimony from Dr. Wolf
and Dr. Stoll at the master’s hearing, there is a genuine
issue of material fact as to whether one seal functions
substantially the same way as two seals in eliminating
interference from impurities.
ORDER
For the foregoing reasons, the Court hereby
ORDERS as follows:
1. SMC is granted summary judgment on non-
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent by the 6,
10 and 15 mm cushionless pistons;
2. SMC is granted summary judgment on non-
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent by the 25,
32, and 40 mm slider pistons with bolts;
3. Festo is granted summary judgment on the
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent by the
SMC basic pistons with two seals and two cushions;
4. Festo is granted summary judgment on the
infringement of the reexamined Carroll patent by the
SMC one-seal rodless cylinders.
5. All other motions for summary judgment are
DENIED for the reasons stated above and in Court on
February 3, 1994.
/s/ Patti B. Saris
PATTI B. SARIS
United States District Judge
1-8]
TELEFAX
FAX: 6014
TO: Mr. Loesener
FROM: Ralf Haller
FESTO-USA
Fax # 516-435-8026
RE: INK AGITATOR
DATE: Nov. 29, 1988
Achim,
Enclosed is a sketch of ink agitator as discussed on the
telephone earlier. As you can see on the agitator sub-
assembly, the pinion is prevented from moving off the
rack by means of two counter rollers. Also, at the bottom
there are 4 rollers going along a guide rail virtually
preventing any misalignment of the sub-assembly.
The whole sub-assembly slots into a bracket mounted on
the mounting face of the DGO. In addition, the DGO has
got play at both ends (about 1 mm) both lateral as well as
axial.
The whole agitator is a device sold by our customer to be
used to agitate ink, i.e. to prevent skin forming on the
surface. Viscosity varies from ink to ink but never
approaches that of honey.
As you can see, the possible sideload from the lever on
the agitator is taken care of by the 4 rollers at the bottom.
Whatever loads are left are minimal and the DGO should
be able to cope easily.
1-82
The design here incorporates mechanical improvements
that I have suggested to the customer during a visit of
mine some 2-1/2 months ago. This visit became necessary
after a sudden series of breakdowns after very short cycle
life to which we could not give satisfactory explanations.
The customer accepted my suggestions and partly re-
designed his product. To our embarrassment the situation
is still as bad as ever, which we found out just now.
We have had alot of goodwill by the customer but obvi-
ously we are now under pressure with very little time
and the competition falling over each other on the cus-
tomer’s door step. The account is worth to us $100 K +
with a large part being DGO sales.
At this moment in time we have started to conduct tests
with the customers device which they have put at our
disposal.
Three sample cylinders that have failed in the field after
less than 50 miles exhibit very bad seal wear as follows:
1) 2 areas radially opposed by 180 degrees on both seals
2) 3 areas at angles of 120 degrees on the circumference
on both seals.
3) 3 areas at angles of 0, 120, and 180 degrees on the
circumference.
We also received back an old DGO which we were told by
the customer was typical for what they used to have and
which at that point in time had done well in excess of 2
million cycles. The seals almost looked new ('!!)
I appreciate that at the moment there is not a lot you can
do for us but I need to gather as much information as I
1-83
can get and there is obviously an outside chance that you
may be aware of similar problems elsewhere or you may
have access to statistical data that could point in the right
direction or that there may be minor but possibly impor-
tant changes in the specs. or supplier, etc.
I personally still favor looking at an application specific
problem, however, in that case we would stil] need to
explain why the cylinders started to fail { i
1. arte, din rom a certain
At this stage, if there is anything that you feel might be
important to help us solve this problem I would i
ate if you let us know. ——
Best regards,
Ralf Haller
1-84
DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT 66
MINUTES FROM ESS/FESTO MEETING
SEPTEMBER 13, 1988
PRESENT AT MEETING: Tim Epach, Purchasing/
Production Mgr/ESS
William Gardner,
Engineering Mgr/ESS
Bernd Ruckdaeschel,
Project Engr/ESS
Nancy Novak, Credit
Mgr/ESS
Jonn Geragosian, Midwest
Regional Mgr/FESTO
Mike Collins, Sales
Representative / FESTO
J. Geragosian noted that Ken Hughes has been calling
Festo in New York and Charlotte threatening lawsuits
and harassing Festo personnel.
T. Epach stated that K. Hughes should not be talking with
Festo at this point and should be getting all his informa-
tion from ESS. He instructed J. Geragosian to have Festo
personnel refer Hughes to ESS if he calls again.
J. Geragosian asked about the agitator patent situation; T.
Epach explained our license agreement currently in force
between ESS and Hughes.
T. Epach gave the background on the test cylinder which
failed over the weekend and during last night. He stated
that this is a major concern at this point, i.e. whether we
can get one to work. He also pointed out that even if we
have a cylinder which will work, Festo has so far not
provided any data on how long they will last. He stated
that we need this information in order to make warranty
1-85
decisions, as well as to advise our customers on the life
expectancy. He stated that other cylinder manufacturers
provide life expectancy ratings for their products.
J. Geragosian stated that Festo’s test data shows a cylin-
der with a 25mm bore will last approximately 1800 miles /
stroke, 1200 miles/stroke if run unlubricated. These tests
were run with a load of '/w linear force at 6 bars pressure.
He stated that cycle rates and speeds are major factors in
life expectancy, and that you will generally see a 15-25%
reduction in life when running on an unlubricated air
supply. He noted, however, that no life expectancy claims
can be made without extended testing in a particular
application.
T. Epach stated that K. Hughes has told ESS that Festo
claimed at one point that the cylinders will last indefi-
nitely, but we cannot substantiate who made the state-
ment, if it was made at all.
W. Gardner stated that the original cylinder received
from Festo was run 2 million cycles, then cut down to
check seals, which were found to be ok. But now, we are
having tremendous problems with the cylinders in the
field. The original spec called for “clean, dry air.” Later,
Festo stated that the cylinders were being overlubricated
when assembled.
). Geragosian stated there are two lubrication issues, one
concerning the air supply and one concerning the cylin-
der. On the pre-lube of the piston and the yoke, Festo
wants to monitor them carefully to prevent overlubing.
1-86
J. Geragosian requested data on which cylinders are fail-
ing. It was agreed this would be provided him in approxi-
mately two weeks, as it is being gathered now.
W. Gardner stated that one cylinder which was returned
was on the press a maximum of 3 months, which calcu-
lated out to 115 miles. This cylinder has been sent to the
New York office for evaluation.
B. Ruckdaeschel stated that the current speed for the
cylinders is approximately 3 inches/second.
W. Gardner stated that the competition is running at
approximately 22 seconds for a 40" cylinder, while our
speed equates to approximately 15 seconds, which is not
totally acceptable to customers.
T. Epach stated that the failures are running approxi-
mately 25%. As an example, he stated that a shipment of
six cylinders will yield two cylinders which will fail,
while the other four operate properly. It appears to be a
question of tolerances.
J. Geragosian stated that ESS has an unusual application
for the cylinder and that tolerances indeed may be affect-
ing the performance. He also acknowledged that ESS is
experiencing seal failures. He said he suspects the prob-
lem may be one of not getting a clean valve shift, that air
is bleeding out.
T. Epach/B. Ruckdaeschel agreed with this statement.
B. Ruckdaeschel noted problems ESS is having with the
flow control valve, and said it appears to be the check
valve not operating properly at low cycle speeds; may not
be seating correctly.
1-87
J. Geragosian will investigate the configuration of the
seal.
B. Ruckdaeschel stated Festo may also want to look at a
lower micron filter, as dirt appears to be building up
around the needle valve, which may be contributing to
the switch problems. ESS plans to test a filter of 5
microns.
J. Geragosian suggested taking apart one control valve.
T. Epach noted that we have not had a lot of switch and
valve returns of late, and that ESS has worked through
the component problems experienced early on. He stated
that now we can switch cylinders on a unit and have
them work.
J. Geragosian suggested building a fixture with different
components to test the new cylinder; suggested using a
different limit switch, because he thinks that the current
one may not be getting a clear enough signal at the slow
speed. He also stated that the new seal is actually a
harder seal. This fixture was set up and completed on °/1s.
T. Epach stressed that ESS needs someone of authority
from the Engineering Group, and perhaps a Production
Manager with Festo to address the problem. He stated
that ESS wants to know if we are trying to do the impos-
sible and if we will continue to experience these prob-
lems. He noted that we did not see these cylinder
problems during the first 6-8 months of production and
thus we wonder what has been changed in the cylinder
design.
1-88
). Geragosian agreed to investigate the possibility of
design changes and will look into getting Engineering
personnel in to assist in solving the problem.
A copy of an ESS nvemo dated September 8, 1988 regard-
ing recent jcsts run on cylinders was given to J. Gerago-
sian.
J. Geragosian stated that a program could be set up to
rebuild cylinders out of warranty, rather than forcing the
customer to buy new ones. He also stated that the cylin-
der is not field repairable.
T. Epach stated that the seals are showing failure prob-
lems.
J. Geragosian stated he would like the unit with the new
seals to be put on a new fixture with new switches. B.
Ruckdaeschel stated that this would be completed today.*
B. Ruckdaeschel stated that he feels that low speeds will
create problems, and that he was told by M. Collins that
ESS is running at speeds not in the cylinder’s design. He
asked if this is indeed true. J. Geragosian stated that he
could not definitively answer that question. B.
Ruckdaeschel stated that he feels we are at the limit of the
cylinder’s design.
J. Geragosian agreed to become more involved with the
situation to ensure it is resolved in a reasonable time. He
also stated that he has been talking with Festo/West
Germany about whether any changes were made to the
cylinder, but not regarding the application. He stated that
“NOTE: The test fixture was completed on 9/13/88; the unit
failed on 9/14/88.
1-89
we need to concentrate on the design of the agitator as a
whole in order to resolve the problem.
The test cylinder was then reviewed in the Production
area.
9/13/88nrn
I-90
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Civil Action
Defendant No. 88-1814-PBS
V.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI
CO. LTD., a/k/a SMC
CORPORATION and
SMC PNEUMATICS,
INC.,
Defendants and
Counterclaim
Plaintiffs
Courtroom No. 6
Federal Building
Boston, MA 02109
9:00 a.m., Wednesday
July 6, 1994
Before: THE HONORABLE PATTI B. SARIS, District
Judge and a Jury
Second Day of Trial —
* * *
1-91
[2-19] THE COURT: Right, not for the truth of
it. It’s just for the marketing techniques that they use.
Go ahead.
(Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 109, Press Release: “New
DGO ... ,” received in evidence.)
A. Yes, Exhibition 109 is the typical press release
which we send to the magazines and to some of our
distributors and employers as introducing the product
into the market. Direct mail campaigns, et cetera.
Q. Now, upon introduction of this product, the
DGO line, how were your marketing plans directed with
regard to this product as opposed to other products of the
company?
A. Well, when you come into a market which is
completely established as a newcomer, initially we estab-
lished this Highlights catalog. And it is very difficult to
penetrate a new market if you haven’t got anything to
offer what is not already on the market.
DGO is an innovative product, was a pacesetter for
us and was a great door opener when we visited cus-
tomers. Engineers immediately looked at this. They never
saw anything like it, that magnets could be used in a such
a configuration, and the features offered great potential
and immediately it was a great conversation piece. And
we could not only with this product sell this product
itself -
[2-20] MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, your Honor.
We’re again deviating from the question-and-answer for-
mat.
I-92
THE COURT: Yes. What’s the next question?
Q. Mr. Saalbach, has the product sold successfully?
A. The product has been successfully sold until -
had continued growth of one hundred to a hundred fifty
to 200 percent growth every year until approximately
1988 when it flattened out, and the sales have stagnated
equal since then.
Q. And why have they flattened out?
A. Because of the unfair competitiveness in intro-
ducing a product by SMC in the market.
Q. Now, is the DGO protected by patents?
A. The DGO has two patents, one patent developed
by the principal owner of our company, Dr. Kurt Stoll,
and the second patent which was purchased by the par-
ent company from an inventor in order to eliminate any
confrontation in the market at that time.
MR. HOFFMANN: Your Honor, I would like to
offer into evidence a certified copy of the Stoll Patent,
which is U.S. Patent Number 4,354,125. I show it to the -
THE COURT: What number is that?
MR. HOFFMANN: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 15.
MR. NEUSTADT: No objection, your Honor.
THE COURT: All right, fine.
[2-90] THE WITNESS: Okay.
Q. Could you explain the application you're refer-
ring to down in Disney World?
1-93
A. Yeah. In Disney World we have several applica-
tions, but two distinctive ones which I think everyone
would identify.
This is Thunder Mountain where this train comes
down thrashing this mountain and it’s real frightening
and you see this waterfall all of a sudden appearing in
front of you, and then this big rock falling down. And the
rock is actually moving through the water because of the
feature of the cylinder. Because it’s completely leak proof,
it can be used within water. It guides this rock, invisible
to the spectator of course, by this device.
The same thing with Twenty Thousand Leagues
Under the Sea where you have different exhibits moving
as a submarine moves along. Here, again, the same
device, the Festo device underneath water, because there
is no leakage so you can use it exactly that way.
Q. Are there any other advantages of the magnet-
ically coupled rodless cylinder?
A. Another advantage is because the yoke is only
magnetically coupled and not mechanically coupled, it is
loose. Consequently, it rotates freely around the stainless
steel tube.
1-94
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and
Counterclaim Civil Action
Defendant No. 88-1814-PBS
V.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU
KOGYO KABUSHIKI
CO. LTD., a/k/a SMC
CORPORATION and
SMC PNEUMATICS,
INC.,
Defendants and
Counterclaim
Plaintiffs
Courtroom No. 6
Federal Building
Boston, MA 02109
9:06 a.m., Thursday
July 7, 1994
Before: THE HONORABLE PATTI B. SARIS, District
Judge and a Jury
Third Day of Trial
. * *
1-95
[3-67] development, was my main activities, production
and technical sales, and my brother heads the commercial
side.
Q. And have you personally made a number of
developments over the years on your own?
A. I made more than a hundred different patents in
Germany and worldwide Festo itself has about 600 pat-
ents.
Q. And you're talking about patents that cover your
inventions?
A. Partly my inventions and partly covering inven-
tions —- and partly inventions from other engineers.
Q. Have you been the author of any publications?
A. Yes. The pneumatic field at that time was rather
new, so it was very important to give know-how, to give
application details to our customers, and that’s why we
had to be very active in marketing, marketing not only by
catalog, price lists, but also by books and by illustrations
in trade magazines.
I was the co-author of five different books and about
120 different prints in trade magazines. The books are
called in the pneumatic field, first one, Introduction to
Pneumatics; second one, Application of Pneumatics; the
third one, Pneumatics in the Woodworking Industry;
number four, Pneumatics in the Packaging Industry; and
the fifth one, Cutting Cost With the Help of Pneumatics.
Besides these books, we have our own trade [3-68]
magazine which we send out to 40,000 different cus-
tomers in 50 countries, and this trade magazine comes
1-96
out every four months and I am the publisher of it. It’s
called Pneumatic Tips.
Q. Now, in regard to the books, what's the scope of
publication on the books, the distribution?
A. The first book, the oldest one, called Introduc-
tion to Pneumatics, passed the ninth edition just last
week, and it’s printed in 14 different languages so we can
utilize it as a sales help in our 40 different countries,
Festo countries.
Q. Have you had anything to do with developing
an understanding of terminology in the pneumatics
industry?
A. Yes, we found a need on the market that there is
no dictionary about special terms in the fluid power
industry, and I got a little bit angry about it and started
the first 50 pages myself and now today it’s on the open -
you know, the book shops or whatever, an English /Ger-
man, German/English dictionary about fluid power,
expressions for this industry, and also for schools and
universities.
MR. HOFFMANN: Your Honor, I'd like to mark
for identification Plaintiff’s Exhibit 610.
THE CLERK: Award marked as Plaintiff's
Exhibit 610 for identification.
THE COURT: Well, we don’t need it for [3-69]
identification. Let’s not do that. Any objection?
MR. NEUSTADT: Your Honor, I was not pro-
vided with the translation of this, so I’m hopeful that
someone will tell me what's said here. I have no idea, so
1-97
I'd like to wait until after the witness testifies before |
state an objection or not.
THE COURT: Well, I don’t want - all right, but
we're normally not going through the ID route, is that
true -
MR. HOFFMANN: Okay.
THE COURT: - because that takes too much
court time.
THE CLERK: So I can -
THE COURT: You will, because when it’s trans-
lated - although that looks like Latin, not German. Is it?
THE WITNESS: That’s German. But we can
leave it out if you want.
THE CLERK: 610 marked for ID.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 610, Diesel award, marked for
identification.)
BY MR. HOFFMANN:
Q. Dr. Stoll, I’m going to show you Exhibit 610 and
maybe you can explain what this is and what it says for
the Court.
A. I received a gold medal for making inventions.
It’s [3-70] called the Diesel. Diesel is the diesel engine.
And on account of Mr. Diesel a few hundred years ago,
the German patent office is handing out three to four
oo per year for extraordinary inventions in various
ields.
Q. And is this an award that you received?
1-98
A. Yes.
And when did you receive it?
0
A. It was last year.
THE COURT: Wait a minute. So it’s not in yet.
MR. HOFFMANN: Okay. I want to offer it in
evidence.
MR. NEUSTADT: No objection, your Honor.
THE COURT: Fine.
(Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 610 marked in evidence.)
MR. HOFFMANN: Your Honor, I have two
others, award-type documents.
THE COURT: Just show it to him, have him
identify it and we'll mark it as an exhibit. Why don’t you
show it first to Mr. Neustadt.
MR. HOFFMANN: Fine. He’s seen them
already. Exhibits 592 and 593 shown to the witness.
A. The first one is an honorary doctor’s degree from
the Technical University in Vienna, Austria, and the sec-
ond one is a medal received from the German govern-
ment.
[3-71] Q. And the award from the Technical Univer-
sity in Austria, what is that for?
A. For our - for my achievements in the technical
field of fluid power.
Q. And the other award relating to the German
government, what is that for?
1-99
A. That’s also for the same achievements.
MR. HOFFMANN: Your Honor, I'd like to
move Mr. Stoll’s awards into evidence.
MR. NEUSTADT: No objection.
THE CLERK: University award marked as
Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 592, and German Federal Ser-
vice Cross award marked as Plaintiff’s Exhibit Number
593.
(Plaintiff’s Exhibit Number 592 marked in evidence.)
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 593 marked in evidence.)
BY MR. HOFFMANN:
Q. Dr. Stoll, are you a member of any organiza-
tions?
A. Here in the U.S.A. you have a National Fluid
Power Association where most of the manufacturers are
combined. We have a similar association called VDMA
with the same function in Germany, and I was sitting on
the board of directors up to last year for the last 15 years.
Q. Are you a member of any other technical organi-
zations?
A. German Engineering Society, VDI, I’m also a
member and guest speaker.
[3-72] Q. Now, Dr. Stoll, in the years that you've
been with the company since 1957, have your respon-
sibilities grown?
A. At the very beginning where we were a rather
small group, I had many more fields of activities as today,
1-100
where today I’m concentrating more on technique and
organization only.
Q. Is there still a portion of your time involved in
the development of new products?
A. I would say at least half of the time is spent for
new inventions. Festo is known to bring on to the Hano-
ver exhibition each year at least 30 or 40 inventions.
Q. So since you’ve been with the company, you've
been heavily involved in the development of products, is
that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, Dr. Stoll, I’m going to show you a copy of
the patent in suit, Plaintiff's Exhibit 15. Do you recognize
this patent?
A. Yes.
Q. Is this a patent that covers an invention of yours?
A. Yes.
Q. Could you give us some idea as to how you first
became involved with the technology that resulted in this
patent invention?
A. Here we are speaking of a linear drive, linear
motor [3-73] driven with compressed air.
When we started in the pneumatic field and visiting
customers with our first products, we found differently -
a need on the market side not only for short-stroke,
medium-stroke, but also for long-stroke cylinders, long-
stroke in the sense of ten-foot and going even more up to
50-foot. This -
1-101
Q. What time period are we talking about?
A. Around in the sixties. There was nothing on the
market which could go to such long strokes and I was
really tempted to do something in that field. I was look-
ing around what kind of functions could be - could be
used for this - for this solution.
And you all know about the mail chute which is also
pneumatically driven. You have a tube and inside a cap-
sule which moves back and forward by air pressure, but
this kind of application has a lot of limitations, mainly
weight and also in volume.
So the basic idea was, why not take a load inside the
capsule where you want to transport something, mail or
whatever, why not take it outside the tube and take the
tube only as a driving means and the load outside of the
tube.
So there was your basic idea of the first linear cylin-
der. And the question came: How can we transform,
transmit the interior force, the interior driving energy, to
[3-74] the outside, to the load? And from physics we
know what we could use a magnetic coupling. If I put a
magnet inside and a magnet outside, have a carriage
inside, have a carriage outside mounted on rollers, then I
could prove that with this prototype that the idea was
correct, was working.
Q. Were you aware of anything like that at the time?
A. Pardon?
Q. Were you aware of anything like that at the time?
A. No.
1-102
Q. So did you go about trying out this idea?
A. Yes, I built a prototype with a long plastic tubing
and used a carriage inside and a carriage outside con-
nected or coupled with a permanent magnet.
Q. And did you actually build this in a room at
Festo or how did you go about it?
A. Yes, in our workshop we had made it up and it
worked.
Q. Now, are we still talking about 1960's, is that
correct?
A. Correct.
Q. Now, when you tried out your idea in this
nature, the magnetic coupling in a tube with the carrier
on the outside, what did you do when you built it and
observed it? Did you take any action?
A. The first action was to apply for a Petty patent in
Germany, which we received, to cover the basic idea.
* * *
[3-90] worked, what didn’t.
A. We tried on the outside, we tried various mate-
rial where it’s hardness, soft-hard, even up to metal and
we found that a semihard wiper action was giving us the
best solution for wiping as well as for guiding the outer
magnets.
On the inside, we first started to make a soft seal
only without the guide. But then the soft seal was bearing
down so fast on account of the eccentric action, on
account of friction, that I mentioned before, so that the
I-103
only solution was to split the two functions, which is
leakage and which is a way of - friction, to split the two
functions also in two different materials.
MR. HOFFMANN: Maybe it would be helpful
if you come over here if it’s all right, your Honor, because
he’s talking about a vacuum as to where he’s working in.
THE COURT: Yes.
Q. Now, you were just explaining that you're talk-
ing about on the inside. Do you mean the inner piston?
Why don’t you show us where that is.
A. The inner piston is here.
Q. You said you tried a soft ring first, a soft type of
seal ring, is that correct?
A. Right.
Q. What happened when you tried that?
[3-91] A. The soft ring was bearing down relatively
fast on account of the eccentric motion.
THE COURT: You know, this is a problem with
this huge room. If you’d just standing so that your back
isn’t totally to me. I just couldn’t hear at all what you had
to say.
THE WITNESS: Should I stand on this side?
THE COURT: No. That way the jurors don’t
hear. Just like were you are right now would be fine.
THE WITNESS: Okay. The Piston is here, the
soft seal is here, and when we took only a soft seal, then
the soft seal would wear down very fast because we have
too much friction for the two magnets.
1-104
Q. Does that relate to that radial force you were
talking about?
A. Off the radial force, correct.
And then we found that we have to split the two
functions of sealing against air and of guiding against
friction to split these two different functions into two
different material -
Q. First before you split it -
A. -a soft material for leakage and a hard material
for wear, because both together would be a compromise
and would not work.
Q. Okay. Now, before you tried to split them
between a [3-92] softer and a harder material, did you try
to just make the first ring harder?
A. Yes. We tried to make the first ring harder but
then the sealing effect was limited. Because in the tubing
we get unevenness, and the unevenness of the tubing of
the surface, of the inside surface of the tubing you can
seal only if you take a soft enough seal. With 7" hard seal
you won't get a leakage free surface. So that’s why we
had to go back to a soft seal and the hard seal did not
work for these two functions which are necessary to
make it movable.
Q. So you said then you tried two different rings.
A. Two different rings and two different materials, a
soft material for sealing and a hard material for guiding.
Q. And how did you take care of the dirt problem
you were talking about?
1-105
A. The dict problem we have inside and outside.
Inside for the dirt which comes with the compressed air
and also the dirt which could come from impurities from
the steel tubing itself or from the magnet.
On the outside, we have no compressed air, so out-
side we have to fight only against the dirt from the
outside. And that’s why we could go here to a harder seal
than on the inside because we don’t -
THE COURT: Now that you've confused me,
are we talking about a harder seal or a harder wiper? See
these [3-93] terms are being used -
THE WITNESS: I just wanted to say a harder
seal like inside we could not take. We could not take
because outside we don’t have any compressed air, so it
doesn’t have to be soft. We went right away to a harder
wiper. And the harder wiper has two functions: A wiping
function against the dirt and a guiding function against
the friction. So by combining these two functions against
dirt and friction, we are able to solve the outside portion,
because outside we don’t have the leakage problem.
Whereas, there are three problems inside. Leakage,
friction and dirt we were able to solve with the principle
which I mentioned, which is the soft seal and a separate
hard seal - guide for guiding. Excuse me.
Did I make it clear?
Q. Right. So I think that’s clear enough. And you’re
able to take care of the three internal problems, sealing,
wiping, and guiding -
A. And guiding.
1-106
Q. - by the two sets of rings, is that correct?
A. And outside the two solutions.
Q. Okay.
THE COURT: Excuse me. Now, when you say
“outside two solutions” -
THE WITNESS: Two functions.
(3-94] THE COURT: Two functions.
THE WITNESS: Two functions, solutions for the
two problems; for the problem of wear and the problem
of dirt. Outside we don’t have the problem of leakage.
THE COURT: That’s two wipers?
THE WITNESS: Pardon?
THE COURT: How many wipers?
THE WITNESS: One wiper for each side.
Q. Okay.
Did you eventually reach a satisfactory solution in
this matter?
A. Yes.
Q. How long a period of time are we talking about
that you tried these different things and materials and
rings and solutions to come up with the answer?
A. That’s a time consuming process because we
wouldn’t go to the market with any prototype which is
not tested at least for a few million cycles or 10,000
kilometers. That means we go into a torture test so that
1-107
we can prove the quality before it goes to the customer.
Otherwise, we could not be specified as the first Euro-
pean company by General Motors to become a supplier,
so quality is quite a big issue for us.
It’s not only a slogan or a nice pamphlet, but for this
quality test it took a long time not only for this [3-95]
product but for other products to come to the final solu-
tion.
Q. Why don’t you go back to the stand. I think that
will be adequate for that.
A. (Witness complied.)
Q. Did there come a point in time when you applied
for a patent when you felt you had a unique design and
applied for a patent?
A. After going through all of these details here and
getting the final results from the torture test chamber, I
found now we had made a big step, a big progress in the
right direction and that should be covered by a patent
because it’s a real step forward for making a lineal motor
with a magnetic coupling workable.
© And what was the essence of the invention that
you felt you had that was in that application?
A. The essence was to solve the three problems,
leakage, dirt and friction and the solution of it, the soft
seal, the hard guide and the wiping and guiding function.
Q. Okay.
Is that the patent that we’re involved with here the
Plaintiff's Exhibit?
1-108
A. Yes. Claim No. 1 is concentrating on these three
functions.
Q. Now, at the time, were you involved directly
a * *
[3-110] A. If I recollect it correctly, it was a little
later. .
Q. It was a little later?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know how much later?
A. Not exactly.
Q. Today, it is your belief that radial is better than
axial?
A. They both work. Technically they only have the
price difference on account of the different production
procedure.
Q. We're talking about your patent. Is there any
other aspect of your patent that you feel is not necessary
in the U. S. Patent?
A. I found a difference in Claim No. 1. I mean, in
the main claim, because it reads different in the American
Patent than in the seven other countries where we've also
got the patent, which does not contain the mentioning of
magnetizable sleeve. This wording is not mentioned in
claim No. 1 in all other countries that we applied for the
patent. Only in the American one this language came in.
Q. And what is your concern about that language?
1-109
A. Well, it’s not of importance, the magnetizable
sleeve, because it doesn’t have to do anything with the
function, what we mentioned before about friction, about
leakage, about dirt. This shielding effect of the magnetiz-
able sleeve is outside and is not even touching all the
three [3-111] elements, wiping, guiding and sealing, what
we mentioned before.
Q. So what you’re saying, in the essence of the
invention, you don’t believe that the sleeve has any
effect?
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, leading.
THE COURT: Sustained.
A. It has a shielding effect, and we did not specify
any material with our claim. We said only if you use.
Q. Okay. Let me go to that.
In the specification you suggest the use of a magne-
tizable sleeve as a possible portion of the structure, is that
correct?
A. Correct.
Q. And why did you put that in?
A. The only function of the magnetizable sleeve is
to keep the magnetic flux, the magnetic field inside the
lineal motor. That was the only reason for putting it in.
Q. Now, have you found anything out about that
feature over the years since you filed the application?
THE COURT: Can I back up for just one sec-
ond?
I-110
THE WITNESS: Yes.
THE COURT: What do you mean by magnetiz-
able sleeve?
THE WITNESS: Magnetizable sleeve, it can be
any material which is magnetizable. We did not state any
* * *
[3-115] car. In both functions you need an outer shell.
MR. HOFFMANN: Okay.
THE WITNESS: And it doesn’t matter whether
we take steel, aluminum or whatsoever.
Q. Now, during times you gave testimony in this
case. At one time we were talking about seal rings. How
many seal rings do you have on a Festo cylinder?
A. If you take a rodded cylinder, we can work with
one seal ring if it acts in both directions.
If you have more space, like here, on the DGO and
magnetic tie, we prefer a sealing on each side outside the
magnets. A soft seal on this side, a soft seal on this side.
Q. Could you come over again? Maybe it’s best to
work with your drawing.
A. (Witness complied.)
Q. When you're referring to the piston, you have a
seal ring shown. What seal rings are on the piston? I'm
talking about the magnetically coupled ones?
A. We have here the seal ring, and the seal rings
have to get the air tightness, leakage zero from the com-
pressed air here. So we can take two different kind of seal
I-111
rings. A, a seal ring which works from both directions,
like an O ring, for instance, or a double seal, or, what we
prefer is the single seal, which works only for this direc-
ner or the [3-116] second one, for this direction (Indicat-
ing.
So you can take either two seals or you can take one
single seal. They both work, but the double seal has more
life expectancy. Because a double seal has a self compen-
sating effect. Even if it wears down, it still is pressed out
by air pressure. Whereas, a single seal, either a round or
any kind of figure, configuration, if it wears down, it
does not have a self-compensate - a way of compensating
for that.
| So you either can take a single seal for the piston or -
which is working in both directions, or you can take two
seals which are working in one way and in one way.
THE COURT: And just to be clear, when you
are saying two seals, you mean one seal on each end?
THE WITNESS: Right.
THE COURT: Not two seals on each end?
THE WITNESS: No, one seal here and one seal
here, on each end.
Q. Now, if you use a two-way seal, which you can
use, you said -
A. Right.
Q. - you'd need one on each end?
A. No, only one, only one.
I-112
Q. So when you were -
A. A one-way seal here, a one-way seal here, or a
double [3-117] seal, two-way seal, whatever you call it, on
one side only is sufficient.
Q. Now, you could put two, or four, or six or eight?
A. Any kind, but minimum of one.
Q. Okay.
Now, when you were talking about the Festo struc-
ture and using always two, were you talking about the
two one-way seals?
A. Two one-way seals.
Q. Why does Festo prefer that in their commercial
form?
A. Because you get a higher life expectancy and
because you have a redundancy effect. If one breaks
down, you still have the other.
Q. Okay.
Now, during that period of questioning, you were
asked if there was only one sealing ring, you said dirt
could get in. What did you mean by that?
A. The sealing ring acts for leakage, as well as for
dirt. So if you would eliminate the sealing ring, you still
have the guiding ring which take away the dirt or impu-
rities.
Q. And that would keep it from the magnets?
A. Keep it from the magnets.
I-113
Q. Now, if you didn’t have a guide ring in there,
what would happen?
[3-118] A. Then you would get the dirt to the guide
rings, if you don’t have a seal ring. So the best mode is
from - the minimum mode is two guide rings, one sealing
ring and the best mode is two plus two.
Q. Okay.
| MR. HOFFMANN: I'm trying to think if there is
anything else we haven't covered. I don’t think so. I think
that’s all I have.
THE COURT: Thank you.
Let me just ask you this, Mr. Neustadt. Do you need
Dr. Stoll up here or would you rather have him back on
the stand?
MR. NEUSTADT: Back on the stand.
THE COURT: Back on the stand. That's great.
Why don’t you move the chart back.
MR. NEUSTADT: Over there?
THE COURT: Yes.
While we're doing this, why don’t you stand and stretch,
a final stretch.
CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR. NEUSTADT
Q. Dr. Stoll, can you see this all right?
A. (Nodes head.)
I-114 1-115
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS
Q. This is a model that we made. This is the inner
member or the piston, and this is the tube and this is
what
FESTO CORPORATION,
Plaintiff and Counterclaim _: Civil Action
Defendant No. 88-1814-PBS
V.
SHOKETSU KINZOKU KOGYO
KABUSHIKI CO. LTD., a/k/a
SCM CORPORATION and
SMC PNEUMATICS, INC.,
Defendants and Counterclaim
Plaintiffs
Courtroom No. 6
Federal Building
Boston, MA 02109
9:10 a.m., Friday
July 8, 1994
Before: THE HONORABLE PATTI B. SARIS, District
Judge and a Jury
Fourth Day of Trial
[4-20] refers back to that statement there that we read
before?
A. Right.
1-116
Q. So you do have responsibility for this, do you
not?
A. Yes, but I don’t have responsibility for claim
number 1, which was totally changed. That’s what I men-
tioned before. I don’t feel responsible for claim number 1,
which is completely different from claim number 1 in
German, British/English, seven other countries, and
claim number 1 in the American final, converted,
improved, changed claim number 1. That was what I was
referring to and not to the general description.
Q. Is there any way in which someone reading your
patent would know that you do not feel that you’re
responsible for the language in the patent?
A. I’m responsible for the language in the pateat if I
know of, but for the changed version, this was not my -
this I didn’t come across to me. This was signed here. It
says here: “Attorney signing the application letter.” Here
(indicating) are the page numbers, so and so, and what
we mentioned just now. On the back page states my
signature an don the front page it says: “Attorney signing
the application” of the changed version where the
number 1 claim, the important claim, was changed with-
out my knowledge, That’s what I meant. I cannot be held
responsible for a change which I didn’t know.
* * *
[4-57] you don’t have to differentiate, and at that time we
had only radial.
Q. Now, Dr. Stoll, we were discussing yesterday the
difference between one seal and two seals?
A. Correct.
1-117
Q. Okay. And I think you told me that on all Festo
rodless cylinders there are two seals.
A. Preferably.
Q. Pardon me?
Q. Preferably.
Q. Preferably. I’m not asking about preferably. I’m
asking about a fact.
A. That’s what I mentioned yesterday. You can do it
with two or with three.
Q. Yes, but my question is how has Festo done it in
the past with its commercial rodless cylinders.
A. We have done it with two single-acting, one-way
seals.
Q. Always two, correct?
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. Now, you remember | referred -
A. What I showed you yesterday on my sketch
where we were also doing it with one double-acting seal.
Q. Now, you remember the deposition testimony
that I referred to previously with Mr. Kelly. This was in
Mr. Hoffmann’s office?
[4-58] A. I wouldn’t recall the details.
Q. And do you remember he too asked you about
the use of two seals?
A. Two soft seals.
1-118
Q. Well, we'll see. Let me show you what his ques-
tion and your answer was. This is Mr. Kelly referring to
your patent.
“Continuing down column one, line 49, there’s refer-
ence to a piston which is slidable in the tubular part and
then the disclosure goes on to say and which has sealing
means at each end for wiping engagement with an inter-
nal surface of the tubular part. My question, Mr. Stu, is,
who suggested using two sealing means on the piston?”
And then your answer was: “You always need two
when there’s a double cylinder, so I proposed it.”
And then Mr. Kelly said: “When you say double
cylinder, you mean double-acting?”
A. Correct.
Q. And your answer was: “Yes. I suggested it
because you always need two when there’s double-acting
cylinder.”
And then Mr. Kelly said: “What will happen if I only
use one sealing means?”
And then your response was: “Then on the side
where there’s no seal, dirt could come in. Attracted by the
magnet.”
[4-59] And then Mr. Kelly finished up with: “To your
knowledge, has Festo ever made a rodless cylinder with
only one sealing means?”
And your answer at that time, at least, was: “Always
both sides. Always two. One on each side or one on each
end.”
I-119
A. That is correct, and that’s what I mentioned yes-
terday. There are two ways of doing it. There’s a double-
acting, two-way seal, and there are single-acting seals
where you need two, and the life expectancy is much
higher in a one-way seal where you need two pieces. I
made it quite clear yesterday. :
Q. And in this testimony here, didn’t you say that
you need two seals to keep the dirt out?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you remember in the patent office in the
prosecution of your patent telling the patent office the
same thing, namely that it was necessary to keep the dirt
out?
A. The dirt out? You can do it by the soft seal as
well as by the guiding ring.
Q. Well, I’m not asking you how you can do it. I’m
_ asking you if you recall what you told the patent office,
and maybe I can help you by showing you exactly what it
was that was said in your application.
[4-61] A. Uh-huh.
Q. And that’s what he’s talking about when he says:
“These references.”
He says: “These references,” which were the two
patents cited by Festo, “are obviously clearly distinguish-
able over the subject matter of the claims” - those are
your claims - “now present in this application.”
1-120
And then he says: “It is clear that neither of these two
references discloses the use of structure preventing the
interference by impurities located inside the tube and on
the outside of the tube while the arrangement is moved
along the tube.”
Is your understanding of this statement that the two
references did not disclose a mechanism for keeping the
dirt out? Is that your understanding of this statement?
A. Impurities? Yes, located inside and outside, cor-
rect.
Q. These are the impurities that you said before can
be attracted by the magnet.
A. In the sense of dirt. Impurities and dirt is the
same, right?
Q. Right.
A. Okay.
Q. So this was the statement, as you understand it,
by your attorney to the patent office in your patent appli-
cation that your invention distinguished over these [4-62]
references because you were able to keep the dirt out?
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. And do you recall that you said to Mr.
Kelly in that deposition we just read that if you have only
one seal, the dirt will come in on the side that doesn’t
have the seal?
A. Again, the same what I mentioned before, yes
and no.
I-121
Q. And so isn’t it true that if the cylinder that we
are examining has only one seal and let’s the dirt come in,
that it is not part of your invention as recited in this
exhibit?
A. Could you repeat that, please?
Q. Let me rephrase it.
In this statement to the patent office, you're saying
that your invention is important because it keeps the dirt
out.
A. Correct.
Q. And that the other references don’t keep the dirt
A. Correct.
Q. And in the deposition that we just read with you
and Mr. Kelly, you told Mr. Kelly that it you had only one
seal, dirt would come in where you did not have a seal,
attracted by the magnet?
A. In the one-way seal.
Q. So here you’re arguing that your invention dis-
tinguishes over the prior art because it keeps the dirt
* - »
[4-100] Incidentally, in this certified copy we have
established that it is totally out of order. Papers get mixed
up in a patent office and so I’m having difficult.
Q. Well, here is the board.
A. May I go over there?
I-122
The examiner issued his office action, which gives
the results of his examination. And, essentially, what he
said, this is a paper attached to it, it’s a summary form.
Essentially he allowed the claims, which would have
gone to patent, but he had some questions as to formal-
ities, which, again, is a very common thing. His questions
as to formalities under certain sections, they set these
sections. The sections they’re referring to here, 35 U.S.
Code 112 say you have to be clear. Remember | told you
in the application, you have to present it to the office, you
have to present a very clear specification as well as
clearly pointing out the claims.
The examiner had a question. “Exact method of oper-
ation unclear.” And he then specifically simply asked a
question. “Is device a true motor or magnetic clutch?” He
just said, what is it, one or the other?
Now, when they went in the application, which was
translated from the German, it called this whole deal here
that we’re talking about a linear motor. The examiner had
this question on that point. A question simply as to
[4-101] semantics.
He also said, “Improperly multiply dependent.” He
was talking about the claims. You have to specifically
number the claims in a certain way. Under a German
practice or foreign practice.
THE COURT: Hold on.
(Fire engine going by.)
THE COURT: It’s hard enough to hear in this
courtroom without outside interference.
(Pause.)
1-123
THE COURT: All right.
THE WITNESS: Thank you, your Honor.
A. Under German practice and other countries’
practice they can give certain numbers in the dependent
claims, referring back to more than one or two. It’s easily
straightened out - because remember I said it was a
translation of the German - by renumbering. So the
examiners found no art, no prior art, nothing in his
examination that said you can’t have a patent because
Jones shows this and Smith shows that. He said: I find it
allowable. Clear this up, tell me what it is.
Q. Okay.
Now, as a result of that action, was there a response
by the applicant’s attorney? ?
A. Yes.
[4-102] Incidentally, you have a three-month period
in which to respond back. You have the right to respond
back to the examiner with respect to this office action. It’s
called a response. And, again, all of this has to be in
writing.
Q. Now, what was contained in the - we have
another board here, maybe you can exp!ain what's on this
board for the Court and the jury.
A. Should I come there?
Q. Yes. Why don’t you move over there.
THE COURT: The one with file history on it is
exhibit?
1-124
MR. HOFFMANN: The one with the file history
the office action on it is P-68, I believe.
A. Correct, Plaintiff's Exhibit P-68.
THE COURT: Do the jurors have that in their
little book?
MR. HOFFMANN: Yes.
THE COURT: Okay. Now what are we going to
now?
MR. HOFFMANN: 31A which is not in the
book but it’s the Claim 1 of the issued patent.
THE COURT: Which is Exhibit 14.
MR. HOFFMANN: Right.
THE COURT: Don’t they have the issued patent
in [4-103] their book?
MR. HOFFMANN: The issued patent’s in the
book, yes. That’s the exhibit right in the beginning, the
first exhibit is the issued patent. Claim 1 of the issued
patent.
THE COURT: All right, you have all these three
documents in your book. You can go back and forth with
them when you hit the deliberation room.
Q. Now, why don’t you explain what happened or
how a response was filed by the applicant's attorney.
A. The exact is in the file history, but this is essen-
tially what hoppened here. the United States attorney for
Dr. Stoll in response to that office action came back and
he canceled Claim 1, which is that claim over there,
1-125
original Claim 1, he canceled it, which is permissible
under the practice; and he canceled some other claims of
those original 12, and he inserted a new claim, which was
13.
At the very end of examination as a patent issues
they renumber all the claims. It may be confusing when
we talk about original Claim 1 and now new Claim 1
which went in as 13. Claim 1 in the patent was this Claim
13 that went in at this point.
When the U. S. attorney for Dr. Stoll put in this Claim
13 that I'm pointing to here, he added additional lan-
guage to the claim. He also made a very brief statement
to the patent office saying: I’m resubmitting this and here
[4-104] it is.
He also, at that time canceled or amended the claim -
Strike that.
What he did in his claim that he resubmitted, he no
longer referred to either a linear motor or a clutch, but he
used entirely new words. He used “in an arrangement”
and so forth. So in his new claim he did not answer that
directly.
Q. In your opinion what did he do? What had he
done?
A. Well, he added a lot of unnecessary language.
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection.
THE COURT: Overruled.
Q. Can you point to any particular language tha? is
significant here to what we're talking about?
1-126
A. Well, right here the words we've been hearing -
THE COURT: Unless they've got the greatest
eyesight in the world...
Q. You will have to read it and they have copies of
the claim. Count down the lines of the claim perhaps and
they can follow -
A. Well, it’s not the same as in their book. I'll read
it. There is a statement in here. “Wherein said driven
member includes a cylindrrical sleeve made of a magne-
tizable material and encircles said tube,” he added this
language among a few other things in there which in my
opinion -
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, your Honor, move
to [4-105] strike. He’s giving testimony now -
THE COURT: Overruled. It’s his opinion it’s
unnecessary language. You can cross on it.
Now, what's the next question?
Q. I would like him to finish the answer.
What is your opinion on adding that language?
A. He added this terminology, he added that term
in there which in my opinion is unnecessary. The exam-
iner was willing to allow the claim, as I pointed out over
here, he just had a couple of questions here. In my
opinion, all that was necessary for the U. S. attorney to
say is it’s a linear motor, that’s. what | take it to be, the
testimony is it’s a linear motor.
As to the second, he simple had to say renumber it.
That's why I say this language was unnecessary.
1-127
. Q. : Would your opinion with the claim as originally
filed with an explanation as to linear motor would that
have been allowed?
A. Yes.
Q. And would that then have appeared in the
issued patent as originally filed?
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, leading.
THE COURT: Sustained.
Q. If that original Claim 1 had be allowed, what
would have been the result of that?
[4-106] A. It would have appeared in the issued
patent as Claim 1, the independent claim.
Q. Okay.
However, after he submitted the new claims, what
was the next step in prosecution?
A. The examiner in effect allowed it at that point
with the new claims, but there was in the specification,
the written portion that explains - there was still a refer-
ence to linear motor, so the U. S. attorney had not
changed that or addressed that, so he asked them to clear
that up. So the U. S. attorney simply entered what we call
amendments and asked the patent office on Line 6 to
change “linear motor” to “magnetically coupled arrange-
ment” or whatever term used, and then the patent issue.
Q. As a result of the prosecution history, have you
reached any conclusions regarding the scope of the
claims?
1-128
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, your Honor.
THE COURT: Sustained.
Q. Are you familiar with the Doctrine of Equiva-
lents?
MR. NEUSTADT: Objection, your Honor.
THE COURT: Let me see you at side bar as to
where this is going.
[4-197] (CONFERENCE AT THE BENCH AS FOLLOWS:
THE COURT: What’s your question going to
be?
MR. HOFFMANN: My question is going to be
what is the Doctrine of Equivalents. And follow up: In
your opinion, that would prevent the Doctrine of Equiva-
lents from being applied?
THE COURT: I will sustain that objection.
MR. NEUSTADT: A clearly legal conclusion.
THE COURT: What I will allow, however, and
we talked about this at length in conference beforehand,
because as you know, I should be issuing an opinion
soon. This is the only area I really disagreed with the
Master on. Mr. Neustadt said that one issue maybe
whether or not a reasonable competitor looking at the
prosecution history would believe that the inventor was
forced to relinquish or abandon a certain limitation in
order to procure the patent. I may not have the words
exactly right but that’s the gist of it from all the cases. I
think the Hoganas case is the one I’m thinking of, partic-
ularly, the one you cited to me.
1-129
MR. NEUSTADT: Yes.
THE COURT: So I
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.