Amicus Curiae Brief — United States v. Mead Corp.
Supreme Court brief2001
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
LOC
~ Supreme Coor.uUSs.
6) F I L K bD
AUG 14 2099
No. 99-1434
IN THE CLERK
Supreme Court of the United States _
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Petitioner,
v.
THE MEAD CORPORATION,
Respondent.
On Wnt of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF THE JOINT INDUSTRY GROUP,
THE ALLIANCE OF AUTOMOBILE MANUFACTURERS
AND THE INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION
IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENT’S OPPOSITION TO THE
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES
Of Counsel: William D. Outman, II
Richard H. Abbey Counsel of Record
Sarah M. Nappi Joint Industry Group
Ablondi, Foster, Sobin & Alliance of Automobile
Davidow, P.C. Manufacturers
and International Mass Retail
Bruce N. Shulman Association
Stein, Shostak, Shostak & O'Hara Baker & McKenzie
and
Evelyn M. Suarez
Alexander H. Schaefer
Sonnenschein Nath & Rosenthal
815 Connecticut Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 452-7010
T AVAILABLE COPY
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES.................. iil
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE
,
: a ORS ee ee 13
" Tatiff classification ral
represent only one of the many
ways Customs issues
agency position ..............., 14
> . NF deb eek
in only a limited sense. .......... 15
; The j ;, id '
nature of Customs rulings
subject for Chevron deference. .... 17
4 Granting Chevron deference to
tanff classification rulings
would create uncertainty as to
the level of deference owed to
RR, ac’ 0 05:044 408 eee 19
B Giving Chevron Deference to Rulings
Would Discourage Commercial Parties
from Seeking a Ruling from the .
Customs Service, and Would Result in
2 21
CORICLAIUBIIN . occ ccc un uuu 24
P|) ) GM a
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
CASES
Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources
Defense Council Inc., 467 U.S. 837
se 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 17, 19, 20, 21, 23
Christensen v. Harris County, 120 S. Ct. 1655
aa 5, 7, 10, 13, 19, 20
Midwood Indus., Inc. v. United States, 313 F. Supp.
951 (Cust. Ct. 1970), appeal dismissed, 57 C.C PA.
TON iekeeess..s............ 20, 21
Sassy, Inc. v. United States, No. 00-93, Slip Op.
(Ct. Int’! Trade August 2,2000).....0000 21
IVA v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153 Ee 9
United States v. Haggar Apparel Co., 526 U.S. 380
i istives.o...,.........._ 5, 7, 10
STATUTES
8 11, 12,19
I9US.C.§ 150%)... 3, 5,8, 11, 12, 15
IV Vv
TRUDE. 6 AOI. oo onc ode bc nets vevecsevdees 4 John F. Manning, Constitutional Structure and
Judicial Deference to Agency Interpretations of
Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. § 5S5l et seg. ... 5 Agency Rules, 96 COLUM. L. REV. 612 (1996) _......_..
N.Y. Ruling 864206 (June 19, POE TTC Te Ree
OTHER AUTHORITIES
North American Free Trade Agreement
Application of Producers’ Good Versus Consumers’ Implementation Act, PUB. L. 103-182, § 637(a).......
Good Test in Determining Country of Origin
Marking; Final Interpretation, 65 FED. REG. 13,827 North American Free Trade Agreement
A SEE EEE FORRES SI NG 20 Implementation Act, PUB. L. 103-182,§640....____.
C.S.D. 97-1, Tariff Classification of Sewing Thread: T.D. 96-5, Tariff Classification of Sleepwear
General Notice, 31 CUST. BULL. & DEC. 18 at | Separates: Final Determination Regarding
(Apr. 30, 1997) ... 0... cece eee ee eect e ene 4 Inconsistent Tariff Classification Rulings of
Sleepwear Separates, 30 CUST. BULL. & DEC. 2 at 2
General Notice: Guidance Concerning the Tariff ETT PP nO a ane
Classification of Pharmaceutical Products Imported
for Clinical Research, 34 CUST. BULL. & DEC. 21 at T.D. 96-7, Tariff Classification of Imported
Te eeerrrerrrrrrrrrrrrrirre ere a Glassware: Change of Practice, 30 CUST. BULL. &
DEC. 3 at 3 (Jan. 17, 1996)
. “_* *
"Se eee eeeeeeeeees ees
. _* *
General Notice: Solicitation of Comments Regarding
the Classification of Pharmaceutical Products T.D. 96-24, Tariff Classification of Headbands and
Imported for Clinical Research, 33 CUST. BULL. & Similar Articles: Final Interpretive Ruling, 30 CUST.
DEC. 31 at 14 (Aug. 4, 1999)........... Shee sass 18 BULL. & DEC. 13 at 1 (Mar. 27,1996) ...........
General Notice: Tariff Classification of Hydraulic T.D. 96-80, Crystallinity of Ceramic Floor and Wall
Mine Roof Shield Supports, 30 CUST. BULL. & Tile: Final Notice on Testing of Floor and Wall Tile
DEC. 50/51 at 13 (December 18, 1996) .............. a for Percent of Crystallinity Necessary to Satisfy
Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States, 30
H.R. REP. NO. 361, 103d Cong., 1" Sess. 138 (1993) .. 12 CUST. BULL. & DEC. 50/51 at 1 (Dec. 18, a
Headquarters Ruling 953126 (Jan. 11, 1993) .......... 8
vi
U'S. Treasury Dep’t, Synopsis of Sundry Decisions
Rendered by the Treasury Department under the
Tariff and Other Acts, U.S. Gov't Printing Office
OEE ccc nstasdedecsTassdudedunnnesevetseses 2
REGULATIONS
I odes nawencawiedackes 14, 22
EPR. 6 WTRIMDED ...... ccc cccecsvereresen 15
PUR CUNNING ii 5 oc cvccccdiessoiessiiese: 3
CPR OUVIBRED «200.0 ccc cccccccocseeecee: 3
SOOM, OSTUGOD oo oo ciniis sn sss scdeecas: 15, 16
eer re 2, 8, 16
i NN: . gs vik enc env aeasn ues 8, 16
| Re er ner pee 15
19 CER §177.10(a) .......-.---005: ee eee: 16
14
POORER i. idivsiccise Nines
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE
Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.3(a) on written
consent of all parties, the Joint Industry Group, the Alliance of
Association respectfully submit this brief amicus curiae in
support of respondent The Mead Corporation’s (Mead)
opposition to the Government’s position in this case.'
INTERESTS OF AMICUS CURIAE
The Joint Industry Group is a coalition of over 160
in international trade, which represents the interests of its
members before the Customs Service, the Department of
Commerce, the United States Trade Representative, other
government agencies and the Congress. The members of the
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers (“Alliance”) include
thirteen global manufacturers of cars and light trucks. The
Alliance represents the interests of its members in public policy
matters, with particular emphasis on vehicle safety, the
The International Mass Retail Association is the world’s
leading alliance of retailers and their product and service
suppliers, representing over 200 retail companies and 550
supplier companies before both the Federal and State
governments.
. This brief was not authored in whole or in part by counsel for a
party to this case. No person or entity, other than the amicus curiae, its
members, or its counsel, made a monetary contribution to the preparation
or submission of the brief. The individual members of each association
included within the amicus curiae are listed in the Appendix.
2
The members of these associations either are importers or assist
importers. They request thousands of rulings from the Customs
Service annually and, when necessary, litigate adverse rulings
in the Court of International Trade and the Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit. The decision of the Court in this case will
directly affect their decisions on whether to seek pre-
importation guidance from the Customs Service on the
classification of imported merchandise and other laws enforced
by Customs through the administrative rulings process or,
alternatively, to by-pass the rulings process entirely and rely
ultimately on the courts for guidance on the construction of the
tariff laws.
STATEMENT
For more than a century,’ importers have sought
guidance from the United States Customs Service on how
imported products should be classified and appraised under the
various tariff laws that have been enacted by Congress. The
Customs Service has provided that guidance through ruling
letters. These are almost always issued in response to an
importer’s written request’ and, according to the procedural
regulations issued by Customs, are limited to the facts
presented in the request and binding only on Customs with
respect to the importer who requested the ruling. * The importer
: The Customs Service has been issuing such decisions at least
since 1868. U.S. Treasury Dep't, Synopsis of Sundry Decisions
Rendered by the Treasury Department under the Tariff and Other Acts, -
U.S. Gov't Printing Office (1869).
. On occasion Customs issues rulings in response to internal
inquiries from its field personne! without any notice to parties in the
importing community that may be affected by the decisions therein.
. 19 C.F.R. § 177.9%a).
3
is also bound to follow the ruling,’ unless and until
is overturned by the courts, or revoked or modified by Customs
in accordance with the procedures set forth in 19 US.C. §
1625(c). Rulings are issued by customs Officials at ports of
entry (principally, New York) and the Office of Regulations
and Rulings at Customs headquarters in Washington, D.C.°
At present, importers make extensive use of the ruling
letter procedure for obtaining Customs’ current position on
various issues, including the classification and appraisement of
the millions of different products that enter the country.
Customs also issues ruling letters on, among other things,
country of origin and country of origin marking; drawback;
trademarks and copyrights; the entry of merchandise; foreign
trade zones, the entry and clearance of vessels, vehicles and
aircraft entering and leaving the United States; customs bonds;
customs brokers, vessel repairs; overtime charges; and the
merchandise processing and harbor maintenance fees. Rulings
on these topics vary little from rulings on classification and
appraisement, except for the subject matter. While
classification rulings tend to be very brief.' simply stating the
$ 19 CFR. § 177.8(a)(2).
: 19 C.F.R. § 177.2(a).
19 U.S.C. § 1502(a), the legislative authority relied on by the
legis! by
_o “wes Classification, appraisement, and the
. In 1999, Customs’ field officers at the ports issued
approximately 10,000 brief classification rulings, and the Office of
4
facts and Customs’ opinion as to the correct classification,
some rulings from Customs headquarters do provide a fuller
analysis of the facts and applicable law.”
The substance of a ruling letter involving classification,
whether it be brief or expansive in explaining how the
conclusion was reached, can, with one exception,’® only be
challenged by the importer through filing an administrative
protest contesting the liquidation of an entry covering an actual
importation of the product. Such a protest may be filed,
however, even though the importer did not obtain a ruling. If
the protest is denied by Customs, the importer may obtain
judicial review of Customs’ classification decision by filing a
summons in the Court of International Trade.
This case presents the narrow question of whether the
courts must defer under Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural
. Nearly all rulings result from an importer-initiated request and
are made available electronically throv gh the Internet on Customs’
website, or through private publishers to whom Customs provides the
rulings electronically. Other than revocations or modifications of
existing rulings that must by law be published in the Customs Bulletin
and Decisions (the Customs Service’s “official” publication), these
rulings are not required to be published. In fact, only seven rulings or
other documents announcing Customs’ position on a classification matter
have appeared in that publication since 1996. Of these seven, five were
published in 1996 (T.D. 96-5, T.D. 96-7, T.D. 96-24, T.D. 96-80, and
General Notice: Tariff Classification of Hydraulic Mine Roof Shield
Supports). Only two have been published since 1997 (C.S.D. 97-1 and
General Notice: Guidance Concerning the Tariff Classification of
Pharmaceutical Products Imported for Clinical Research).
= Rulings can be challenged directly in the Court of International
Trade without filing a protest upon a showing of irreparable harm. See
28 U.S.C. § 1581(h).
5
Resources Defense Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984), to the
tariff classification rulings issued by the Customs Service. The
decision of this Court is likely to have broad ramifications for
importers. Unless this Court continues to adhere to the “bright
line” rule announced in Chevron and reaffirmed in United
States v. Haggar Apparel Co., 526 U.S. 380 (1999), and most
recently in Christensen v. Harris County, 120 S. Ct. 1655
(2000), which limited deference to interpretive regulations
promulgated under the Administrative Procedure Act,'' the
decision will inject greater uncertainty and less uniformity into
the law than exist today, contrary to the Government’s
assertion, and will result in increased litigation and, thus,
increased costs to business.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
Extending Chevron deference to tariff classification
rulings is both legally and commercially inappropriate.
Applicable judicial precedent draws a clear, workable
distinction between regulations, which have the force of law,
and rulings, which do not. This Court’s decisions emphasize
that Chevron deference is warranted only when agencies act
pursuant to a Congressional delegation of authority. In the
most recent decision of this Court discussing Chevron
deference, Christensen v. Harris County, this Court refused to
extend Chevron to an agency’s ruling letter. Here, where again
the Government argues that this Court should give controlling
weight to an agency’s ruling letter, it cites 19 U.S.C. § 1502(a)
as a specific Congressional delegation of authority. We submit,
however, that a plain reading of the statute and its legislative
history establishes that such rulings are simply another form of
. 5 U.S.C. § 551 et seq.
6
general information on classification and appraisement that
Congress has long directed should be disseminated to Customs
officials at ports of entry to ensure that imported merchandise
arriving at any port in the country is treated fairly and
uniformly. The Government’s attempt to dignify customs
“binding rulings” as a form of delegated lawmaking therefore
fails.
Practical and commercial considerations also militate
against extending Chevron deference to classification rulings.
First, there is no simple way to distinguish classification rulings
from Customs’ interpretive pronouncements in other contexts.
There are many types of rulings and interpretive statements, of
varying degrees of applicability and persuasiveness. Customs
ruling letters themselves are “binding” in only a limited sense,
as they bind only the requesting party and the Customs Service
and are limited to the facts presented in the request, be it from
an importer or a customs officer. Other types of rulings and
agency pronouncements may be of broader applicability and
carry more precedential weight. Tariff classification rulings are
frequently revoked or modified, and therefore, at the time a
ruling is issued Customs explicitly warns third parties not to
rely upon them. Given the wide variety of agency interpretive
statements (rulings and otherwise), granting Chevron deference
to this category of rulings would create great uncertainty as to
the level of deference due to Customs’ numerous other kinds of
pronouncements.
The commercial considerations weighing against the
Government’s position in this case also include the likely effect
on the behavior of private parties. Granting Chevron deference
to classification rulings would undermine the current legal
framework that seeks to promote uniformity and predictability
7
in commercial transactions by encouraging importers to seek
guidance from Customs. If courts were to give classification
rulings Chevron deference, importers would be discouraged
from seeking such advance guidance because of the risk of
having to bear a higher burden in a subsequent judicial
challenge. Importers would instead have the incentive to
litigate classification disputes directly in court, without having
obtained an advance ruling. Thus, it is highly likely that
granting Chevron deference to such rulings would result in
greater uncertainty and more litigation for the trade community.
ARGUMENT
q a
arn tnetanite indiciel Ermentent Risky shes Rernlati
The decision of the United States Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit in this case correctly followed this Court’s
decision in United States v. Haggar Apparel Co., 526 U.S. 380
(1999), in determining the type of agency action that warrants
controlling-weight deference under Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v.
Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984).
The Federal Circuit concluded that Chevron deference should
not be extended to ordinary classification rulings. Mead Corp.
v. United States, 185 F.3d. 1304, 1307 (Fed. Cir. 1999). This
Court in Christensen v. Harris County, 120 S. Ct. 1655 (2000),
reaffirmed this principle and clarified that Chevron deference
is warranted only where agency action has the force of law, as
when it promulgates regulations under the Administrative
Procedure Act. Informal administrative ruling letters of the
type at issue in this case do not have the force of law, and
therefore are not entitled to Chevron deference. Such rulings
have a limited purpose to provide only the importer who asked
for the ruling with certainty as to the rate of duty on goods it
8
intends to import and to ensure that the same classification and
rate of duty will be applied by customs officers “at the various
ports of entry.” 19 U.S.C. § 1502(a).
A. Rulings, Unlike Regulations, Do Not Have
the Force of Law.
In the initial classification ruling in this case, Customs
informed Mead that, for tariff classification purposes, its
product is an “other (nonenumerated) article{ ] similar to
registers, account books, notebooks, receipt books and
diaries.”'? Customs subsequently reversed the initial ruling and
classified the product as a bound diary.’ This ruling did not
contain general guidelines, and it was not subject to notice-and-
comment or any other form of reasoned or deliberative
rulemaking. In fact, the customs regulations caution importers
about the limited application of such interpretive rulings,
stating that “[n]o other person should rely on the ruling letter or
assume that the principles of that ruling will be applied in
connection with any transaction other than the one described in
the letter.” 19 C.F.R. § 177.9(c). Thus, the customs regulations
provide that the classification ruling here can only be applied
to Mead and cannot be relied upon by other parties. '*
= N.Y. Ruling 864206 (June 19, 1991).
. Headquarters Ruling 953126 (Jan. 11, 1993).
- The government cites to the provision of the regulations that
makes such rulings binding on all Customs officials (19 C.F.R. §
177.9(a)) to somehow suggest that the rulings have greater force. This
argument is misplaced. The binding nature of such rulings is intended to
promote the goal of uniformity among the ports. This is not the same,
however, as adopting a rule of general applicability that has the force of
ies other than Customs and the applicant
a. J al |
When Agencies Act Pursuant to a
C ional Delegati
The object of deference to agency action under Chevron
is to give effect to the intent of Congress where it has delegated
its lawmaking authority. See John F. Manning, Constitutional
Structure and Judicial Deference to Agency Interpretations of
Agency Rules, 96 Colum. L. Rev. 612 (1996). In this way, the
courts do not usurp power granted to the executive branch. As
this Court noted in Chevron, the courts should not engage in
policy determinations that are vested in other branches. 467
U.S. at 866, citing TVA v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153, 195 (1978).
The decisions of this Court have established an
effective and comprehensive framework for the courts to use in
determining when to accord Chevron-style deference to a given
agency action. This framework rests on the separation of
powers and the very limited role of the judiciary. This Court
has drawn a clear path for agencies and the courts: where
deference is sought or to be given, the agency must be engaged
in a deliberative process of lawmaking. If not, as here, the
policy concerns raised by this Court in Chevron are absent and
deference of that type is unwarranted.’
” As indicated in Respondent’s Supplemental Brief, the
government has failed to raise the question of whether a lesser deference
standard is available; the consideration of such a standard has therefore
been waived.
10
Chevron Deference.
This Court properly accorded Chevron deference to
duly promulgated regulations in United States v. Haggar
Apparel Co. However, in Haggar, a primary consideration was
that the agency engaged in notice and comment rulemaking in
promulgating the regulation at issue. 526 U.S. at 390. To deny
deference to an agency action of this nature “implies a
significant departure from conventional contemporary
administrative practice.” Jd. In Christensen, by contrast, this
Court confronted “an interpretation contained in an opinion
letter, not one arrived at after, for example, a formal
adjudication or notice-and-comment rulemaking.” 120 S. Ct.
at 1662. In holding that the opinion letter was not entitled to
Chevron deference, the Court stated:
Interpretations such as those in opinion letters —
like interpretations contained in _ policy
statements, agency manuals, and enforcement
guidelines, all of which lack the force of law —
do not warrant Chevron-style deference.
Id. Thus, the Court underscored the clear distinction between
the promulgation of a regulation which is subject to a
deliberative process, as was at issue in Haggar, and the
issuance of an informal ruling letter which involves only a
limited review.
. The Government cites 19 U.S.C. § 1502 throughout its
brief, but in disregard for how the Congress actually worded the
statute. The Government states in its brief, beginning on page
5:
That statute authorizes the Secretary of the
Treasury to adopt “rules and regulations”
providing for the issuance of such “binding
rulings prior to the entry of the merchandise” as
may “be necessary to secure a just, impartial,
and uniform appraisement of imported
merchandise and the classification and
assessment of duties thereon * * * .”
The law itself, however, reads differently:
(a) Powers of Secretary of the Treasury
The Secretary of the Treasury shall
establish and promulgate such rules and
regulations not inconsistent with the law
(including regulations establishing procedures
for the issuance of binding rulings prior to the
entry of the merchandise concerned), and may
disseminate such information as may be
necessary to secure a just, impartial, and
uniform appraisement of imported merchandise
and the classification and assessment of duties
thereon at the various ports of entry.
12
19 U.S.C. § 1502 (emphasis added).
‘ Congress authorized the Customs Service to
“promulgate such rules and regulations” .. . “(including
regulations establishing procedures for the issuance of binding
rulings prior to the entry of merchandise.)” The parenthetical
language in 19 U.S.C. § 1502(a) was added in 1993 by Section
640 of the North American Free Trade Agreement
Implementation Act, Public Law 103-182 (1993). The House
of Representatives Report explains that the amendments to 19
U.S.C. § 1502, among other things, “authorize the Secretary to
prescribe regulations for the issuance of binding rulings prior
to the entry of merchandise.” H.R. Rep. No. 361, 103d Cong.,
1" Sess. 138 (1993). This amendment simply ratified what the
Secretary had been doing for decades — promulgating
procedural regulations for the issuance of rulings and issuing
rulings on not only classification and appraisement, but also on
every other aspect of the law the Customs Service administers.
The legislative history establishes that the purpose for
adding the parenthetical language was to provide importers
with a procedure by which they could obtain guidance from the
Customs Service prior to entry in exercising their new
responsibilities to classify and appraise merchandise imposed
by Section 637(a) of the North American Free Trade
Agreement Implementation Act. Long before 1993, Congress
had directed that the Secretary of the Treasury provide rules
and regulations and disseminate classification and appraisement
information. The statute was and still is directed to Customs
officials themselves, not the public and not the courts, and was
intended to ensure that Customs officials throughout the
and uniformly. The Government’s expansive reading of 19
U.S.C. § 1502(a) is dictated by its need, after this Court’s
13
decision in Christensen, to find a specific Congressi
. . . . onal
delegation to issue rulings. However, a plain reading of the
statute and its legislative ‘history establishes that Congress’
intent was much more limited.
. The standard established by Chevron is clear that only
interpretive regulations, which are promulgated through the
formal notice and comment procedures, are entitled to judicial
deference. Extending this deference to classification and
appraisement rulings would require the courts to draw
distinctions between various forms of such rulings, between
classification and appraisement letter rulings and letter rulings
on other laws administered by Customs, and between letter
= and other types of Customs policy pronouncements
€ is no simple way to distinguish, for ses ,
determining an eggliedtie tov of detummen, beeen mart
classification rulings and Customs’ pronouncements of policy
and interpretation in other contexts. Should the Court depart
from its current “bright-line” position, it would create great
uncertainty as to the deference to be accorded to these other
agency statements.
14
interpretive statements of agency position.
A review of the various forms of Customs’ written
pronouncements may demonstrate to the Court the
inappropriateness of extending any form of deference to
classification rulings. Such rulings may take the form of a brief
letter describing the merchandise and providing a reference to
the applicable tariff provisions, or they may contain a detailed
description of the merchandise and a fuller analysis of the
relevant tariff provisions, the history of those provisions, and
pertinent court decisions. In addition to rulings, other forms of
agency written decisions include: internal advice memoranda
issued by Customs’ headquarters in response to requests from
officials at local ports of entry (issued after goods have entered
the country);'* protest review decisions, which are issued by
headquarters in response to a request from an importer who
seeks independent review of a port official’s decision (issued
after goods have entered the country);’’ Treasury Decisions,
generally published in the Customs Bulletin and on occasion in
the Federal Register, which are issued by headquarters to
address particular policy issues, including its interpretation of
tariff terms; General Notices, yet another form of policy
statement issued by headquarters, generally published in the
Federal Register; “Informed Compliance” publications on the
classification of many products, which are made available to
the public on Customs’ website;"* and Directives and other
- 19C. FR § 177.11.
wd 19 C.F.R. § 174.23 et seq.
= According to a statement contained at the beginning of every
Customs Service’s position on or interpretation of the applicable laws or
15
documents published on Customs’ website and electroni
nic
bulletin board, which contain official statements of agency
position.
2. Customs rulings are “binding” in only a
limited
As the Government asserts, the law authorizes Customs
to promulgate “regulations establishing procedures for the
issuance of binding rulings.” The term “binding rulings,”
though much relied upon by the Government, is not defined
either in the statute or in Customs’ regulations. While the
regulations address the “binding” nature of ruling letters, they
also indicate a distinction between “rulings” and “ruling
letters.” Customs defines the term “ruling” as “a written
statement issued by the Headquarters Office or the appropriate
office of Customs ... that interprets and applies the provisions
of the Customs and related laws to a specific set of facts.”?°
Rulings may be set forth in “ruling letters” issued in response
to written requests,” or they may be “other rulings,” which are
“statements of the official position of the Customs Service
which are likely to be of widespread interest and application”
and “are published in the Customs Bulletin, as described in §
177.10.”" Section 177.10, in turn, refers to the publication of
= 19 C.F.R. § 177.1(d)(1).
ws Id.
- 19 CFR. § 177.80).
16
“any precedential decision,” which term includes, for purposes
of ‘tn paragraph, “any ruling letter, internal advice
memorandum, or protest review decision. % However,
whereas § 177.8(b) rulings are to be published in the Customs
Bulletin, “precedential decisions” need not be as long as they
are made available for public inspection.
While the regulations do not discuss binding rulings,
Customs makes very clear in its regulations that a ruling letter
(as opposed to a ruling) is “binding” only on the Customs
Service and on the party who requested it,” and that other
parties are not to rely on it:
A ruling letter is subject to modification or
revocation without notice to any person, except
the person to whom the letter was addressed.
Accordingly, no other person should rely on the
ruling letter or assume that the principles of that
ruling will be applied in connection with any
transaction other than the one described in the
letter.
19 CFR § 177.9%).
Thus, under its authority to promulgate regulations for
the issuance of “binding rulings,” Customs has created a
confusing array of agency pronouncements. Ruling letters are
” 19 C-F.R. § 177.10(a).
- 19 C.F.R. § 177.9(a). “A ruling letter issued by the Customs
Service under the provisions of this part represents the official position
of the Customs Service with respect to the particular transaction or issue
described therein and is binding on all Customs Service personnel in
accordance with the provisions of this section until modified or
revoked.”
17
binding only on the requesting party and on Customs; some
ruling letters (as well as “other rulings”) may be “precedential”
and “of widespread interest and application” and are to be
published in the Customs Bulletin or otherwise made available
to the public; but under no circumstances should third Parties
rely upon them or assume that the rulings’ principles will be
applied to any other transaction. Nonetheless, the
Government asks the Court in this context to extend Chevron
deference to tariff classification rulings, when Customs will not
permit any third party to rely on those rulings.
As acknowledged in Chevron, “[t]he power of an
administrative agency to administer a congressionally created
.. . program necessarily requires the formulation of policy and
the making of rules to fill any gap left, implicitly or explicitly,
by Congress.” Chevron, 467 U.S. at 843. Where the Customs
Service counsels in its regulations against relying on any ruling
or the principles contained in those rulings, even in so-called
“precedential decisions,” it can not be said to be “making . . .
rules to fill any gap left, implicitly or explicitly, by Congress.”
Customs rulings makes them an
iate subject for Ch
deference.
As noted above, customs rulings may be issued either
by attorneys at Customs headquarters or by import specialists
at individual ports of entry. As the Federal Circuit noted in
Mead, these rulings are “an even less formalized body of
interpretation than IRS revenue rulings.” 185 F.3d at 1308.
Unlike IRS revenue rulings, they do not issue from a single
entity within the agency, and few of them are actually
published. See id Customs rulings suffer from a lack of
18
consistency in terms of both the nature and degree of legal
analysis. For example, one importer may obtain a one-
paragraph ruling from an import specialist stating how a
particular product should be classified but giving no
explanation for the conclusion, whereas another importer may
obtain a lengthy, well-reasoned ruling from Customs
headquarters which supports its conclusion with a clear
exposition of the facts and controlling legal authority. A
decision that all tariff classification rulings deserve deference
would also encompass the former type.
Furthermore, Customs appears not even to have a full
appreciation of rulings it has issued in the past. This results in,
among other problems,” the issuance of rulings that reach
different conclusions on the correct classification of what
appear to be identical products.** Customs appears not always
to research its own position on a particular product Sefore
issuing another ruling pertaining to that product. If deference
is to be given to all classification rulings, courts will have
difficulty reconciling such conflicting rulings. It is conceivable
that a court could be asked to review a ruling -- and give
as Even where Customs revokes or modifies a ruling, it does not
attempt to identify existing rulings which may be affected. Instead, it
inserts the following standard language into all notices of revocation or
modification: “This [revocation or modification] will cover any rulings
on this issue which may exist but have not been specifically identified.”
= For example, in an August 4, 1999, “General Notice,” the
Customs Service admitted that it “has issued inconsisient rulings
regarding chemical compounds imported in bulk . . .” and requested
comments from the public as to how to reconcile these rulings. General
Notice: Solicitation of Comments Regarding the Classification of
Pharmaceutical Products Imported for Clinical Research, 33 Cust.
BULL. & Dec. 31 at 14 (Aug. 4, 1999).
19
judicial deference to that ruling -- when another ruling exists in
which the agency reached a contradictory conclusion.
This inconsistency is underscored by the frequency with
which such rulings are modified or revoked. Since January
1994, there have been 459 rulings either modified or revoked
by Customs, and of these, 135 were rulings prepared by
attorneys in the Office of Regulations and Rulings in Customs’
headquarters.”’ These numbers suggest the rather perfunctory
process by which the rulings are often issued and the frequency
with which the agency acknowledges that they are incorrect or
inconsistent.
4. Granting Chevron deference to tariff
uncertainty as to the level of deference
owed to other forms of agency statements.
Extending Chevron deference to classification rulings
raises the question whether deference is due to the myriad other
types of non-regulation agency actions.“ Most of Customs’
pronouncements are in the nature of general policy statements
(as in the case of Treasury Decisions or “informed compliance”
publications), even though they may be issued through formal
notice-and-comment procedures (as in the case of some -- but
not all -- “General Notices”). This Court in Christensen
clearly stated that such interpretations “do not warrant
ad This information was obtained through a query of Fuglei’s
“Customs Info” CD-ROM database, which is commercially available and
widely used in the trade community. The query covered the period
January 1, 1994, through May 19, 2000.
= Many rulings are not issued under 19 U.S.C. § 1502, which only
applies to classification and appraisement rulings.
20
Chevron-style deference.” Christensen, 120 S. Ct. at 1662.
The courts’ current standard -- according deference only to
interpretive regulations -- is clear and workable.
Granting judicial deference to Customs’
pronouncements would also require courts to acquiesce in what
may be improper assumptions of authority by the agency. For
example, in a “final interpretation” published in the Federal
Register regarding criteria to be used in determining country of
origin marking, Customs announced that it was departing from
judicial precedent on the issue because it believed that
precedent was no longer valid. While the court had expressly
indicated that a shift from a producers’ good to a consumers
good is relevant in determining whether the good undergoes a
substantial transformation for marking purposes (Midwood
Indus., Inc. v. United States, 313 F. Supp. 951 (Cust. Ct. 1970),
appeal dismissed, 57 C.C.P.A 141 (1970)), Customs
announced its decision not to follow this case. “It is Customs’
opinion that based on subsequent court decisions applying
substantial transformation analysis, Midwood would be decided
differently today.” Application of Producers’ Good Versus
Consumers’ Good Test in Determining Country of Origin
Marking; Final Interpretation, 65 Fed. Reg. 13,827 (2000).
This statement of the agency’s position was, like a customs
regulation, promulgated through formal notice and comment
procedures and intended to be a rule of general application. If
deference were extended to customs rulings, which lack such
procedural safeguards, then a court would also seem to be
required to grant deference to agency pronouncements such as
these, giving Customs almost unfettered discretion to contradict
21
otherwise valid case law in establishing agency policy.”” There
is no possible reason for requiring the courts to defer to
Customs on the construction of a law when Customs feels free
to disregard court decisions it finds unpersuasive.
B. Giving Chevron Def 10 Ruli
The Government argues that there is "substantial
practical importance" attending the decision whether to defer
to rulings issued by the Customs Service. Government's Brief
at 37. According to the Government, the Customs Service
"routinely employs" what it calls "binding rulings" to “address
the proper application of the detailed customs provisions to the
‘limitless factual variations’ created by modern commerce." /d.
at 37-38 (citation omitted). The Government concludes that
without deference, both importers and the Customs Service
would be left "without effective guidance for a wide range of
transactions." /d. at 38.
The companies that make up this amicus curiae agree
that there is a "substantial practical importance" to the issue
before the Court today. If courts are required to give Chevron
deference -- "controlling weight"-- to Customs Service rulings,
29
Since the publication of this notice, at least one judge of the
Court of International Trade has indicated continuing approval of the
Midwood rationale by citing case law that follows Midwood: “See, e. g.,
S.D.I. Technologies, Inc. . . . (noting that a shift from producer goods to
consumer goods may have some evidentiary value).” Sassy, Inc. v.
United States, Slip Op. No. 00-93, at 9 (Ct. Int’l Trade August 2, 2000)
(internal citation omitted).
22
the effect would be to discourage commercial parties from
seeking a ruling in the first place. After all, if an importer
receives a ruling from the Customs Service with which it is
dissatisfied, that importer would be in the anomalous position
of having a more difficult burden in court than an importer who
did not receive a ruling from the Customs Service. That is, the
importer would be required to show that the statute at issue Is
unambiguous, or if ambiguous, that Customs’ interpretation ts
unreasonable.
Importers are not required to seek a ruling from the
Customs Service. If an importer is not satisfied with the
decision of the Customs Service reflected in the liquidation of
an entry of merchandise, the importer must file an
administrative protest contesting the decision as a prerequisite
to obtaining judicial review of the matter. If the importer files
a protest with the Customs Service, it will receive a decision on
the protest simply allowing, denying, or allowing in part the
protest. If, however, the importer also requests "further review"
of the protest” and Customs determines that further review is
warranted, then in addition to a decision on the protest, the
importer will also receive a ruling in the form of a "protest
review decision" from the Customs Service providing the
reasons for the Customs Service's decision.
If the courts are required to give deference to Customs
Service rulings, the effect would be to discourage importers
from requesting a protest review decision. Importers who
receive a simple decision on the protest without a ruling would
then be able to challenge the decision in court without having
the court give "controlling weight" to the position taken by the
Customs Service.
” 19 C.F.R. § 174.23.
|
:
|
;
-
|
*
|
t
$
*
23
Moreover, the Government has argued that the Federal
Circuit’s decision not to give deference to rulings will result in
"experisive customs litigation and unpredictable outcomes."
Government's Brief at 38. The member companies of this
amicus curiae believe that the opposite is true.
As noted above, giving deference to rulings would
discourage commercial parties from seeking rulings from the
Customs Service. Importers would refrain from seeking
rulings, and would use the protest procedures to obtain judicial
review of any adverse ruling without having to overcome the
high hurdle of proving its "unreasonableness." As is currently
the practice, the courts would consider the validity of Customs’
decisions based on the evidence presented at trial and the
persuasiveness of the legal reasoning.
The Government has indicated that Customs’
headquarters issues more than 1,000 “binding rulings" each
year “involving tariff classification, customs valuation and
country of origin determinations."*’ Government's Brief at 38,
note 26. We acknowledge that, as Congress intended, these
rulings are in many cases helpful and provide guidance to the
importing community as to the Customs Service's current
position on a given topic, and provide a measure of certainty to
those engaged in importing. The ruling process was not,
however, intended to give Customs unfettered power to limit
the rights of importers and other parties to obtain effective
judicial review. However, if importers are discouraged from
requesting rulings because the courts must give Chevron
deference to Customs’ pronouncements, they will have lost the
benefit of having this corpus of interpretation and guidance.
- The Government conveniently ignores the more than 10,000
ruling letters issued by other offices within Customs.
24
The result would be, using the Government's terms, "expensive
litigation and unpredictable outcomes."
CONCLUSION
The judgment of the court of appeals should be
affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
Of Counsel: William D. Outman, II
Richard H. Abbey Counsel of Record
Sarah M. Nappi Joint Industry Group
Abiondi, Foster, Sobin & Alliance of Automobile
Davidow, P.C. Manufacturers
and International Mass Retail
Bruce N. Shulman Association
Stein, Shostak, Shostak & Baker & McKenzie
O’Hara 815 Connecticut Ave., N.W.
and Washington, D.C. 20006
Evelyn M. Suarez (202) 452-7010
Alexander H. Schaefer
Sonnenschein Nath &
Rosenthal
DATED: August 14, 2000
APPENDIX
Pe
APPENDIX
JOINT INDUSTRY GROUP
3M
Ablondi, Foster, Sobin & Davidow, p.c.
Adduci, Mastriani & Schaumberg, LLP
Air Courier Conference of America
Airfreight Warehouse Corporation
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Haver & Feld, LLP
b
JOINT INDUSTRY GROUP, continued
Dorsey & Whitney
E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co.
Elle International
Emery Customs Brokers
Expeditors International of Washington, Inc.
Federal Express
Ford Motor Company
General Electric
General Motors Corporation
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP
Global Customs Advisors
Gottlieb & Pearson
Hapag-Lloyd America Inc.
Hewlett-Packard
Hitachi America, Ltd.
Honeywell
Hoppel, Mayer & Coleman
Intel Corporation
International Business Machines
International Mass Retail Association
International Warehouse Logistics Association
Int'l Business-Government Counsellors
JBC International
Katten Muchin & Zavis
Ken Kumm
Kent & O'Connor
KPMG LLP
Law Offices of Stewart & Stewart
Levi Strauss & Co.
Lexmark International Inc.
Limited Distribution Services
Logicon/Northrup Grumman
Lucent Technologies, Inc.
c
JOINT INDUSTRY GROUP, continued
MAERSK Sealand
Matsushita Electric Corporation
Mattel
Microsoft Corporation
Miller & Company P.C.
Motorola, Inc.
National Association of Foreign Trade Zones
National Association of Manufacturers
National Retail Federation
NCBFAA
Neville, Peterson & Williams
NextLinx Corporation
Northern Telecom
P&O Nedlloyd Limited
Pacific Merchant Shipping Association
Parker & Company
Parker & Company
Patton Boggs
Powell, Goldstein, Frazer & Murphy, LLP
PricewaterhouseCooopers LLP
Roadway Express, Inc.
Rockwell Collins, Inc.
Rode & Qualey
Ross & Hardies
Samuel Shapiro & Co., Inc.
Sandler, Travis & Rosenberg, P.A.
Sara Lee Knit Products
Sea-Land Service, Inc.
Serko & Simon
Shea & Gardner
Sonnenschein, Nath & Rosenthal
Sony Electronics Inc.
Stein, Shostak, Shostak, & O'Hara
d
JOINT INDUSTRY GROUP, continued
Sun Microsystems, Inc.
Tech Data
Texas Instruments, Inc.
The Dow Chemical Company
The Procter & Gamble Distributing Co.
Tower Group International
Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.
Toyota Tsusho America, Inc.
Unz & Company
UPS Customhouse Brokerage
Vastera
Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease LLP
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
Warner-Lambert Company
Washington International Insurance Co.
West Gulf Maritime Association
Weyerhaeuser
Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering
ALLIANCE OF AUTOMOBILE MANUFACTURERS
BMW Group
Daimler Chrysler Corporation
Fiat Auto S.p.A.
Ford Motor Company
General Motors Corporation
Isuzu Motors America, Inc.
Mazda North American Operations
Mitsubishi Motor Sales of America, Inc.
Nissan North America, Inc.
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
Toyota Motor North America, Inc.
Volkswagen of America, Inc.
Volvo Cars of North America, Inc.
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION
The 1/2 Off Card Shop/Card and Party Giant
A.J. Wright
AAA National Headquarters
Academy Corp.
Ace Hardware
Active International
Advance Auto Parts, Inc.
Aerial Company, Inc.
Almacenes Exito S.A.
Ames Department Stores, Inc.
Ammar's, Inc.
Armature Inc.
Army & Air Force Exchange Service, HQ
AutoZone
B.J.'s Wholesale Club Inc.
Babbage's Etc.
The Bargain! Shop Holdings, Inc.
Bass Pro Shops
Bath & Body Works
The Behnke Nurseries Co.
Benny's Ins.
Best Buy Company, Inc
BesiBuy.Com
Bi-Way Stores Limited
Big W Limited
Bill's Dollar Stores Inc.
Blain Supply, Inc.
BOAT/U:S. (Boat America Corporation)
f
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Retail Member Companies
Bradlees, Inc.
Brand Names Sale
BrandsMart U.S.A.
Burlington Coat Factory
Canadian Tire Corporation Limited
CANEX
CarMax
Casa Video
Chase-Pitkin Home & Garden
Circuit City Stores, Inc.
Claire's Stores, Inc.
The Clicks Organisation (PTY) Ltd
COMPRAS COMODAS
Consolidated Stores Corporation
Copeland's Sports
CSK Auto, Inc.
Denning House - A Buck Or Two
DFS Group Ltd.
Dickies Outlet Stores
The Disney Store, Inc.
Dollar General Corporation
Dollar Tree Stores, Inc.
Drogueria Y Farmacia El Fenix, S.A. de C.V.
Drug Emponum
DSW Shoe Warehouse
Duckwall-Alco Stores, Inc.
Eastern Mountain Sports, Inc.
Exodus Genesis
Express
Factory 2-U Stores, Inc.
Family Dollar Stores, Inc.
Farm & Fleet of Dodgeville, Inc.
8
INT, ERNA TIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION. continued
Retail Member Companies
Farmacias Arrocha
Fleetwood Retail Corp.
Food Lion, Inc.
Frank's Nursery & Crafts, Inc.
Fred's, Inc.
G.I. Joe's Inc.
Garden Ridge Corporation
Giant Eagle, Inc.
Giant Tiger Stores Ltd.
Gibson's
The Glidden Company
Goodwill Industries International, Inc.
Goody's Family Clothing, Inc.
Gordman's, Inc.
Gordon Brothers Group, LLC
Grainger Industrial Supply
Great American Group
Gregg Appliances, Inc.
Grupo Triangulo
Healthy Fundraising, Inc.
Heilig-Meyers Co.
Hilco Trading Company, Inc.
The Home Depot, Canada
The Home Depot, U.S.A., Inc.
Home Hardware Stores Limited
Home Shopping Network
HomePlace of America, Inc.
Hub Distributing, Inc.
Hudson's Bay Company
IKEA U:S., Inc.
J. Baker, Inc.
Jerry's Home Improvement Center
h
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Retail Member Companies
Jo-Ann Stores, Inc.
Kay International
Kay-Bee Toy Stores, Inc.
Kinko's, Inc. World Headquarters
Kitchin's Stores
Kmart Canada Ltd.
Kmart Corporation
La Fragua S.A., C/o CARBEN, Inc.
Lari Group Co., Inc.
Lechters, Inc.
Levitz Furniture Corporation
Lian Hua Supermarket Co., Ltd. (Lian Mao Corp.)
Lima Bargain Center
The Limited, Inc.
Lowe's Companies, Inc.
Marburn Stores, Inc.
Marina Export, Inc. (Almacenes Vivero S.A.)
Marks & Spencer, PLC
Maurices Incorporated
McDonald's Corporation
Meijer, Inc.
Mervyn's California
Michaels Stores, Inc.
Midas International Corporation
Mills Supply, Inc.
Modell's Sporting Goods
Modern Woman
Navy Exchange Service Command
Northern Tool & Equipment Co.
Ocean State Jobbers, Inc.
Office Depot, Inc.
Ollie's Bargain Outlets, Inc.
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Retail Member Companies
One Price Clothing Stores, Inc.
Orscheln Farm and Home L.L.C.
Pamida, Inc.
Party City Corporation
Payless Cashways, Inc.
Payless ShoeSource, Inc.
Penske Auto Centers
PEP BOYS
Petco Animal Supplies, Inc.
PETsMART, Inc.
Price-Less Drug Stores, Inc.
Pricebusters Co., Ltd.
Purina Mills America's Country Store
Quality Stores, Inc.
Regis Corporation
Rooms To Go, Inc.
Royal Duty-Free Shops, Inc.
ru4.com
SAAN Stores Ltd.
SAM'S Club
Schottenstein Stores Corporation
Scotty's
Shaw's Supermarkets
Shonac Corporation
ShopKo Stores, Inc.
Shorr Electronic's Inc.
The Shui Hing Company, Ltd.
Simply Fashion Stores, Ltd
The Sports Authority, Inc.
Starbucks Coffee Co.
Strauss Discount Auto
Sunglass Hut International
j
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Retail Member Companies
Syms Corporation
Target Corporation
Target Stores, Inc.
Toy Biz, Inc.
Tractor Supply Company
Trend-Lines, Inc.
Truck Pro
TruServ Corporation
Urban Outfitters
Value City Department Stores, Inc.
Variety Wholesalers, Inc.
Wal-Mart Canada, Inc.
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
wal-mart.com
Warner Brothers Studio Stores
West Marine
WhatsHotNow.Com
Wilkinson Hardware Stores Ltd.
Woolworths Limited
Zale Corporation
Zellers Inc.
Supplier Member Companies
‘K' Line America, Inc.
3M Company
A & W Products Co., Inc.
A. T. Cross Company
A.J. Siris Products Corporation
AAi Foster Grant, Inc.
Accessory Network
Acclaim Entertainment
Accu Chek, Inc.
k
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member C .
Aero Plastics, Inc.
Air Plus Limited
Alliance Logistics Consulting Group, Inc.
Almar Sales Co.
Alpha Security Products
American Coin Merchandising
American Color Graphics
American Dream Team Network
American Express Company
American Greetings Corporation
Amerock Cabinet Hardware
Ames True Temper
Ampad
Anchor Hocking Glass Company
Anderson Merchandisers, Inc.
Andis Company
Anheuser-Busch Companies
Ann's House of Nuts, Inc.
Appliance Co. of America LLC
Applied Communications, Inc.
Applied Graphics Technologies
Applied Science Fiction
ARC International
Arch Chemicals, Inc.
Arthur Andersen LLP
Auburn Hosiery Mills, Inc.
Aurora Foods, Inc.
Avista Advantage
B & G Foods, Inc.
Baptista's Bakery
h
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Barth & Dreyfuss of California
Bax Global
Bayer Corporation, Consumer Care Division
Bemis Manufacturing Company
Benckiser Consumer Products
Benetton Sportsystem
Bestfoods
Bestform, Inc.
The Betesh Group
BIC Corporation
Biederlack of America
Binney & Smith Inc.
Bissell, Inc.
Black & Decker (U.S.), Inc.
Braun Inc.
Braun National Retail Services
Bretlin Inc.
Brian P. Hakan & Associates, Inc.
Briggs & Stratton Corporation
The Brinkmann Corporation
Buena Vista Home Entertainment
Bulldog Hardware
Burian & Assoc., Inc.
Burlington Industries
The Burlington Northern and Santa Fe Railway Company
The Buschman Company
Butler Home Products
C&S Products Co., Inc.
California Cartage Company, Inc.
The Campbell Group
Campbell Soup Company
CANDLE-LITE
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Checkagain
Checkered Flag Sports
Checkpoint Systems, Inc.
Chemence, Inc.
Chep USA
Cheyenne Industries
Child's Play
Chipman-Union, Inc.
Cleaning Solutions Group
Clear-Vu Products
The Clorox Company
Coats & Clark
The Coca-Cola Company - Licensing Division
Coca-Cola USA
COELIMA USA, Inc.
Coleman Consulting Group, Inc.
Colgate-Palmolive Co.
Command Security Corporation
Con-Tact Brand/Decora, Inc.
Conair Corporation
Commar Corporation
Conros Corporation
Consolidated Freightways Corp.
Corporate Security Management, Inc.
Cox Target Media
CPM Worldwide, LLC
Cranston Print Works, Co.
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Creative Solutions Group
Crimebite, LTD
Deloitte & Touche LLP
Deluxe Payment Protectron Systems, Inc.
Demand Management in:
Deni/Keystone Manufactumng Co , Inc.
Design Forum
Did You Sports
Discount Store News
Discover Business Services
Disney Consumer Products
Dr Pepper / Seven Up, inc
E3 Corporation
Eastern America Transport & Warehousing, Inc.
Oo
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
The Eureka Company
Ex-Cell Home Fashions
Exel Logistics Americas
EZ Paintr
Fairchild Publications
Fantasia Accessories, Ltd.
Fasteners For Retail
Fedders North America
The Federal Wholesale Group
FedEx Services
Feldstein & Associates, limc
Fiesta Gas Grills, LLC
Fifth Avenue Channe: Retail
Forrester & Vos Co.
Fort James Corporation
P
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Fox Consumer Products
Fragrance Solutions
Franco Manufacturing Co., Inc.
Franklin Sports, Inc.
Freeride.Com, LLC
French Toast
Frito-Lay, Inc.
Fruit of the Loom
Fuji Photo Film USA, Inc.
Garrity Industnes
GE Home Electric Products, Inc.
GEA Management & Consulting
Gemini Industnes, Inc.
GENCO Distribution System
General Mills, Inc.
Georgia-Pacific Corporation
Gerber Childrenswear, Inc.
The Gillette Company
Ginsey Industries
Glenoit Corporation
Goody Products
Goya Foods, Inc.
Grosfillex
H. J. Heinz Co.
The Haddad Apparel Group, Ltd.
Hallmark Cards, Inc.
Hallmark Jewelry
Hamilton Beach/Proctor-Silex, Inc.
Hanover Accessories
Happy Kids
Harbortown Industries, Inc.
Harper Leather Goods
q
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Harte - Hanks Direct Marketing
The Hartz Group
Hasbro, Inc.
Haywin Textile Products, Inc.
Hedstrom Corporation
Heinz Pet Products
Helen of Troy, L.P.
Helmac Products Corp.
Henry Doneger Associates, Inc.
HMG Worldwide
Holiday Housewares, Inc.
The Holmes Group
Home Products International
Honeywell Consumer Products
The Hoover Company
Hormel Foods Corporation
HotOffTheWire.Com
Howard Schultz & Associates International
Hub Group, Inc.
Hudd Distribution Services, Inc.
Huffy Corporation
Hypnotic Hats, Ltd.
IBM Corporation
ideavillage.com
Imperial Home Decor Group
Information Resources, Inc.
Innovative Global Consulting, Inc.
Integrated Business Consultancy
Intercraft/Holson Burnes
Interlake Material Handling, Inc.
Intermatic, Inc.
International Silver/Farberware Home Products
r
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Internet Cash.Com
Intertek Testing Services
Invacare Corporation
IRIS USA, Inc.
iSolve.com
J & H Marsh McLennan
J & M, Inc. - The Tattoo Source
J.E. Morgan Knitting Mills
Jack Link's Beef Jerky
Jelmar
Jerzees
Jevic Transportation Inc.
Jockey International, Inc.
Johnson & Johnson
Joseph Pedott Advertising/Joseph Enterprises Inc.
Just My Size Clothing Company
K & M Associates, L.P.
K' nex Industries
Kayser-Roth Corporation
Keebler Company
Kellwood Company
Kenzer Corporation
Keter North America
Kids International Corporation
Kikomo, Ltd.
KitchenAid
Konica Photo Imaging
KPMG
Kraco Enterprises, Inc.
Kurt Salmon Associates
L&N Sales and Marketing, Inc.
L'eggs Products
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
L.A. Darling Company
L.R. Nelson Corporation
Lamour Hosiery USA
Lancaster Colony Corporation
Lander Co., Inc.
Lasko Metal Products, Inc.
Learning Horizons
LeeRowan
Leggett & Platt
Levolor Home Fashions
Libbey Inc.
LifeScan, Inc.
Lifetime Hoan Corporation
Lion Brand Yarn Company
Lipton
The Little Tikes Company
Lochridge & Company
Logistics Information Systems, Inc.
Loss Prevention Products, Inc.
Loss Prevention Systems
Lozier
Lumilite Products Co.
M&M / Mars
M-D Building Products, Inc.
M.R.S. Companies
M.S. Carriers
Madix Store Fixtures
Maersk Logistics
Magic Sliders L.P.
Magla Products
Magnivision
Main Street Products, LLC
t
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Major League Baseball Properties
Malt-O-Meal Company
Mancini Safe Company
MANCO, Inc. - A Henkel Group Company
MarketMAX, Inc.
MarketSource Corporation
Masonways Indestructible Plastics
Master Lock Company
Mattel, Inc.
Maurice Sporting Goods, Inc.
Maxell Corporation of America
MBR Industries
McCormick & Company, Inc.
Mead Consumer & Office Products
MEAG Power
The Media Group, Inc.
Media News Group
MEG
Meguiar's, Inc.
MELITTA USA, INC.
Meridian Advertising
The Metal Ware Corporation
METO USA
Meyer Corp.
Micro Software Services, Inc.
Milliken Rugs
Milnot/Beech-Nut Company
MinderSoft, Inc.
Mirro/‘WEAREVER
Mohawk Rug & Textiles
Motion Systems
Motorola
u
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Motorola TalkAbout
MTD Products, Inc.
Nabisco Food Company
National Manufacturing Company
National Picture & Frame Company
National Retail Systems
NationaLease
Native Tan
NCR Corporation
Nestle U.S.A.
The Network, Inc.
Neuville Industries, Inc.
New Creative Enterprises, Inc.
New Energy Ventures
New West Energy
Newell Industries Canada, Inc.
Newell Office Products
Newell Rubbermaid Inc.
Newell Window Furnishings Company
NFL Properties
Nickelodeon Consumer Products
Nomus Interiors, Inc.
Norelco Consumer Products Company
North American Plastics Corporation
Northland Cranberries, Inc.
NorthSound Music Group, Inc.
Nourison Rug Corp.
NOVA Home Appliances Mfg. Company, LLC
Novartis Consumer Health
Novus Services, Inc.
O'Sullivan Industries, Inc.
The Ocean Group
Vv
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
OG&E Electric Services
Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc.
Old Williamsburgh Candle Corporation
Omega Paw, Inc.
Opus Inc.
Orient Consolidation Services
Orion Systems
Osram Sylvania Products Inc.
OurPet's
Over and Back, Inc.
Pacer International
Pacific Alliance/Regatta
Packaging Concepts Ltd.
Pan-Oston Company
Panasonic Battery Sales Group
Paragon Trade Brands
Parker Metal Corporation
The Paul Schultz Companies
Pen-Tab Industries, Inc.
Pentech International
Pentel of America, Ltd.
Pepsi-Cola Company
The Perrier Group of America
Personal Optics
Pet Friendly, Inc.
The Pfaltzgraff Company
Philips Lighting Company
PICS Retail Networks
Pilot Pen Corporation of America
Pinkerton Services Group
Pinnacle Art & Frame
Pioneer Photo Albums, Inc.
Ww
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Plainwell Tissue, Inc.
Plano Molding Company
Plochman, Inc.
Plus Mark, Inc.
Polaroid Corporation
Premier Candle Corp.
Presto Products Company
Price Waterhouse Coopers
PriceWaterhouse Coopers
Procter & Gamble Company
Procter & Gamble Company
Professional Logistics Management Co.
The Profit Recovery Group International, Inc.
ProFoot Products
Progressive International Corp.
Projexx, LLC
Protex International Corporation
Pyramid Accessories, Inc.
The Quaker Oats Company
Quebecor World
R Brands
R. M. Palmer Company
R.R. Donnelley & Sons Company
Radio Systems
Ralston Purina Company
Rapistan Systems
The Raymond Corporation
Rayovac Corporation
Real Time Solutions
Rebound
Red Devil, Inc.
Red Oak Farms, Inc.
. y
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies Supplier Member Companies
Rehrig International, Inc. Salson Logistics Inc.
Reid Psychological Systems Salton/T oastmaster/F arberware
Reliant Energy Sanford
Rembrandt Corporation SAP American
Remington Products Company, L.L.C. Sara Lee Branded Apparel
Renfro Corporation Sara Lee Sock Company
Retail Distributors, Inc. SaraMax Apparel Group, Inc.
Retail Merchandiser Sarne’ Corporation
RetailExchange.Com SAS Group, Inc.
Revion Beauty Care Division SC Direct, Inc.
Revion Classic Cosmetics & Fragrance SC Johnson Wax
Revion Inc. Schreiber Foods, Inc.
Revlon Professional Products Group SDI Industries, Inc.
REW Marketing, Inc. SDI Technologies, Inc.
Reynolds Metals Company Se-Kure Controls, Inc.
RGIS Inventory Specialists Securitech Group, Inc.
Roadway Express, Inc. Security Source, Inc.
Robinson Knife Company Sedgwick Risk Management
Rollins Leasing Corp. Sedlak Management Consultants, Inc.
Romar Select-A-Vision
Ross Products Division Sensormatic Electronics Corporation
Royal Appliance Manufacturing Co. Sentry Group
Royal Floor Mats Sentry Technology Corporation
Royal Lace/Royal Brites. Serengeti Eyewear, Inc.
Rubbermaid Home Products Sergeant's Pet Products
S-B Power Tool Company Shalom International Corp.
SacSaver, Inc. ShopperTrak (A Division of Quadrix Corp. )
Safe Science ShopVac Corporation
Safe-Strap Company, Inc. Shortage Control, Inc.
Safety 1st Canada, Inc. Signature Apparel
Safety Ist, Inc. USA SII Marketing International, Inc.
Saft America Inc., Licensee of the Polaroid Corp. for C Silicon Energy
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Simple Green
Sisco, Inc.
SubmitOrder.Com
Sunbeam Health & Safety Company
Sunlite Casual Furniture
Super Glue Corporation
Symbol Technologies, Inc.
Syratech Corporation
Syroco, Inc.
Tahiti Apparel/Signal Apparel
Tamor Corporation
Tasco Worldwide, Inc.
TC Advertising
TDK Electronics Corporation
TeleBrands Corporation
Telxon Corporation
Temerlin McClain —
Teters Floral Products, Inc.
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Tetley U.S.A., Inc.
The Thermos Company
Thermwell Products Co., Inc.
Thomas Nelson Publishers, Inc.
Thorco Industries, Inc.
Tibbett & Britten Group
Tilia, Inc.
TimeCorp, A Division of Hewlett-Packard
Timex Corporation
Toastmaster, Inc.
Totes - Isotoner Corp.
Town & Country Linen Corp.
TradeOut.Com
Unarco Material Handling, Inc.
Unilever Home & Personal Care USA
UnionTools, Inc.
United States Mutual Association (USMA)
United Steel & Wire Company
USA Detergents, Inc.
USF Distribution
bb
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
USF Processors
Vandale Industries
Vantage Industries
Vassarette
cc
INTERNATIONAL MASS RETAIL ASSOCIATION, continued
Supplier Member Companies
Wilton Industries
World Kitchen, Inc.
Worldwide Dreams LLC
Wundies Enterprises, Inc.
Yuppie Puppy Pet Care, Inc.
ZELCO Industries, Inc.
Zeta Consumer Products Corporation
Zodiac
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.