Suggestion of Mootness — Friends of Earth v. Laidlaw Environmental Services

Supreme Court brief2000

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court, U.S,

F it. E D

JUN 9 1999

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, ef al.,

Petitioners,

Vv.

LAIDLAW ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES (TOC), INC.,

Respondent.

On Writ of Certiorari to the

United States Court of Appeals

for the Fourth Circuit

SUGGESTION OF MOOTNESS

DONALD A. COCKRILL *

Nancy W. MONTS

OGLETREE, DEAKINS, NASH,

SMOAK & STEWART, P.C.

The Ogletree Building

300 North Main Street

P.O. Box 2757

Greenville, SC 29602

(864) 271-1300

Counsel for Respondent

Dated: June 9, 1999 * Counsel of Record

a RT ETD

WILSON - Erpzs PRINTING Co., INC. - 789-0096 - WASHINGTON, D.C. 20001

pat

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

LF ii

EERE STN A oe 2

a A, ee 3

Permanent Closure of the Facility Has Mooted

REE as SSR GS A a ’ 3

ERT JE EE coe ee RR — 7

mar

ii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES Page

Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Environ-

mental Services (TOC), Inc., 956 F. Supp. 588

CD.B.C. BBDDD ....ccecccccsccrecsesescesusensssiuneneee 2

Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Seobaunne

tal Services (TOC), Inc., 149 F.3d 303 (4th Cir.

1998) .. vecceosueveesusessosvesecceasseanennnnnnn 3

Gwaltney ot ‘Smithfield, “Ltd. v Chesapeake Bay

Foundation, Inc., 484 U.S. 49 (1987)... 3

Los Angeles v. Lyons, 461 U.S. 95 (1983) ..... 4

Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555

REE s. PE 4

O'Shea v. — ton, 414 U.S _ 488 (1974) . A

Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better Environment,

523 U.S “'s ) Fe 2,3

U.S. Vancorp. v. Bonner Mall Partnership, 573

UB. 2B CIGDED onccccciccccocccecccncesessncnsnunenneaeeeean 7

United States v. W. T. Grant Co., 345 U.S. 629

| | setacoessesenslniaanl 3

STATUTES

33 U.S.C. § 1865 (a) ; usc oes 2

33 U.S.C. § 1865 (b) ...... ssdgaiaauiinia ae 2

UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION

Article III of the United States Constitution ___... 3

RULES AND REGULATIONS

oy 5 ae asia ioc 1

OTHER AUTHORITY

Affidavit of Roebuck Environmental Manager

Chariese G. BECE BOG ....0<ccnss<2s0sssececsseneeeee 8, 4, 5

January 28, 1997 Spartanburg Herald Journal:

“Laidlaw Mulling Options” 2... ed 6

In THE

Supreme Cant of the Wuited States

No. 98-822

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, ef ai.,

. Petitioners,

LAIDLAW ENVIRONMENTAL Services (TOC), INC..,

Respondent.

On Writ of Certiorari to the

United States Court of Appeals

for the Fourth Circuit

SUGGESTION OF MOOTNESS

Pursuant to Rule 21 of the Rules of this Court, Re-

spondent Laidlaw Environmental Services (TOC), Inc.

(“Laidlaw”) respectfully suggests that this case has be-

come moot and that the Writ of Certiorari should be

dismissed. This issue of mootness is in addition to the

substantive issues of standing and mootness already be-

fore the Court. Petitioners raised the specific issue in

their brief of whether closure of Respondent's facility

moots the case. The Petitioners did so, however, with-

out support in the record, thereby precipitating this sub-

mission in order to provide the Court with additional

facts necessary for an evaluation of this issue. Respond-

ent further respectfully requests that the Court suspend

the remainder of the briefing schedule pending the Court's

disposition of this Suggestion.

2

BACKGROUND

The questions presented in this case pertain to the issue

of whether a citizens group has standing to bring a citi-

zens suit under Section 505 of the Clean Water Act, 33

U.S.C. 1365(a), and whether that suit becomes moot

because the remedy sought—civil penalties—will not re-

dress the alleged injury pursuant to this Court's decision

in Steel Company vy. Citizens for a Better Environment,

523 U.S. 83 (1998). The question of a citizen plaintiff's

entitlement to attorneys’ fees or litigation costs in a moot

case is also before this Court.

These questions arise out of a citizens suit filed by

Petitioner’ Friends of the Earth (“FOE”) on June 12,

1992 against Respondent Laidlaw claiming injury caused

by Laidlaw’s alleged ongoing violations of a National

Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (“NPDES”) per-

mit that regulated wastewaster discharges from an in-

cinerator at Laidlaw’s Roebuck, South Carolina facility.

The district court found that, although Laidlaw had made

good faith efforts to achieve compliance prior to the filing

of the complaint, and that no harm to the environment

had been caused by the permit violations, Laidlaw should

pay a statutory penalty of $405,000.00 for NPDES per-

mit violations occurring mostly before and, in a few

minor circumstances, after the institution of the lawsuit.

Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Environmental Servy-

ices (TOC), Inc., 956 F. Supp. 588, 610 (D.S.C. 1997)

(J.A. 180-181). Injunctive relief was denied in its en-

tirety. Jd. at 611 (J.A. 183). On appeal, FOE aban-

doned its request for injunctive relief and sought only an

1The other Petitioners, Sierra Club and CLEAN, Inc., were

allowed to join the citizens suit several months later (by which

time Laidlaw was in substantial compliance) despite the fact that

neither filed the 60-day notice letter required by the Act, 33 U.S.C.

1365(b).

3.

increase in the statutory civil penalties. The Fourth Cir-

cuit reversed, holding that under this Court's ruling in

Steel Company v. Citizens for Better Environment the

case had become moot because civil penalties—which are

payable to the U.S. Treasury and not to citizen plaintiffs

—would not redress any injury claimed to have been

suffered by the Petitioners as a result of alleged ongoing

NPDES permit violations. Friends of the Earth, Inc. v.

Laidlaw Environmental Services (TOC), Inc., 149 F.3d

303, 306-07 (4th Cir. 1998).

After the Fourth Circuit issued its decision on July 16,

1998 but before this Court granted certiorari, NPDES

discharges at the Roebuck, South Carolina facility were

permanently discontinued at 7:00 a.m. on September 1,

1998 (see Affidavit of Roebuck Environmental Manager

Charisse G. McLeod, attached to this submission). Sub-

sequently, the entire facility was permanently closed. /d.

ARGUMENT

Permanent Closure of the Facility Has Mooted this Case

A case is moot, and cannot be maintained, when

““there is no reasonable expectation that the wrong will

be repeated.’ Gwaltney of Smithfield, Ltd. v. Chesapeake

Bay Foundation, Inc., 484 U.S. 49, 66 (1987), quoting

United States v. W. T. Grant Co., 345 US. 629, 633

(1953).

Respondent's permanent closure of the Roebuck facility

at issue in this case rendered the case moot because no

actual “case or controversy” continued to exist between

the parties. Article III standing requires both an “injury

in fact—an invasion of legally-protected interest which is

(a) concrete and particularized . . . and (b) actual or

imminent, not conjectural or hypothetical,” and that the

injury is capable of being “redressed by a favorable deci-

4

sion.” See Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555,

560-61 (1992) (internal quotations omitted). A plain-

tiff must be able to establish the standing requisites of

injury in fact, causation, and redressability at each stage

of the litigation. Jd. Here, the alleged injury that was

the subject of the Petitioner's complaint—ongoing and

future violations of Respondent's NPDES permit due to

incinerator wastewater discharges at the Roebuck facility

—no longer exists, and cannot reasonably be expected to

recur. The discharge has stopped entirely and the facility

is closed. The injury is no longer “actual or imminent.”

See Los Angeles v. Lyons, 461 U.S. 95, 101-02 (1983)

(“past exposure to illegal conduct does not in itself show

a present case or controversy regarding injunctive relief

. . . if unaccompanied by any continuing, present adverse

effects”), citing O'Shea v. Littleton, 414 U.S. 488, 495-

96 (1974).

Petitioners attempt to address the issue of whether the

facility closure moots this case by making three unsup-

ported and illogical arguments in their brief on the merits.

First, Petitioners assert that since the NPDES permit is

still in effect, Laidlaw “may discharge in the future when-

ever it cares to do so.” (Brief For Petitioners, p. 8, n.7).

As clearly demonstrated by the Affidavit of the Roebuck

facility's Environmental Manager, Charisse G. McLeod,

Petitioners’ assertion is incorrect—the incinerator that

generated the wastewater discharged under the NPDES

permit has been removed and discarded. In fact, the en-

tire facility is closed and most of the equipment has been

dismantled and sold or discarded. (McLeod Affidavit).

Second, Petitioners imply that Laidlaw’s retention of its

NPDES permit indicates Laidlaw’s intent to engage in

future NPDES discharges. (Brief For Petitioners, p. 8,

n.7). As shown by Ms. McLeod's affidavit, however, the

5

NPDES permit was kept in effect to make the Roebuck

site more attractive to a prospective purchaser, not in con-

templation of any future NPDES discharges by Laidlaw.

Moreover, Ms. McLeod's affidavit references and incor-

porates a Consent Agreement, dated June 2, 1997, en-

tered into between Laidlaw and the South Carolina De-

partment of Health and Environmental Control (DHEC)

that reflects, in pertinent part, that Laidlaw shut down

the incinerator for economic reasons and that any viola-

tion of the Agreement would be deemed a violation of

state law.

Third, Petitioners assert that even the permanent clo-

sure of the facility would not moot the case because they

have members affected by alleged, but unidentified, Safety

Kleen/Laidlaw NPDES discharges at other affiliated cor-

porations. (See Brief For Petitioners, p. 8, n.7). This as-

sertion borders on the frivolous. No facts are provided in

support of this allegation. More fundamentally, the case

before this Court involves past NPDES permit violations

only at Respondent's facility located in Roebuck, South

Carolina. Respondent Laidlaw Environmental Services

(TOC), Inc. has no other facilities. Understandably, Pe-

titioners cite no authority for the proposition that moot-

ness can be avoided by claiming a possible deterrent effect

that penalties imposed on one company might have on

another company not in the lawsuit and not alleged to be

in violation of any permit.

Laidlaw invites the Court's attention to the position

taken in this case by the United States as amicus curiae,

at page 15 of its brief, that “a defendant's voluntary ces-

sation of permit violations does not moot a citizens suit

unless the defendant demonstrates that the permit viola-

tions will not recur.” (Emphasis added). The permanent

closure of the facility, as described in Ms. McLeod's affi-

6

davit, demonstrates just that. In fact, the United States,

in taking the same basic position in its brief opposing

certiorari in another case, predicted this exact scenario,

and a corresponding finding of mootness:

In the case of Clean Water Act citizens suits, the

commencement of compliance, even if accompanied

by the initiation of new procedures or the installa-

tion of new equipment, would not, as a general mat-

ter, completely moot a case because, for example,

the same neglectful behavior that led to the viola-

tions may still recur in the form of neglectful ad-

herence to the new procedures or neglectful opera-

tion and maintenance of the new equipment. Ac-

cordingly, we submit, a finding of mootness would

generally be inappropriate absent a showing that the

prospect of neglectful behavior itself is eliminated

by, for example, the permanent closing of the facility

or the permanent cessation of all discharges. See,

e.g., Pawtuxet Cove Marina, Inc. vy. Ciba-Geiev

Corp., 807 F.2d 1089 (1st Cir. 1986), cert. denied

108 S. Ct. 484 (1987) (defendant completed tie-in

with the municipal treatment facility and ceased dis-

charging under its NPDES permit). In the absence

of such a showing, Article III standing would con-

tinue as well.

—_——

Simkins Industries, Inc. v. Sierra Club, No. 88-660

(October Term, 1988), Brief for the 'Inited States

as Amicus Curiae, at pages 11-12, n.11. (Emphasis

added).

It is clear that the facts of this case satisfy even the

Solicitor General's stringent standard for establishing

mootness. Here, Laidlaw permanently closed, dismantled,

and put the Roebuck facility up for sale for economic

reasons. Laidlaw’s consideration of this course of action

was reported in the South Carolina press as early as Jan-

uary 28, 1997. (See “Laidlaw Mulling Options,” attached

>

to this submission). By June 2, 1997—when Laidlaw

and DHEC executed a Consent Agreement—the final de-

cision had been made. These facts make it patently clear

that the closure decision was not a ruse to avoid this

Court's review of the Fourth Circuit’s July 16, 1998

decision.

CONCLUSION

This case became moot prior to the grant of the Peti-

tion for Writ of Certiorari and, accordingly, the Writ

should be dismissed, and the Fourth Circuit decision al-

lowed to stand, because the Court had “no constitutional

power to decide the merits” when it acted on the petition.

U.S. Vancorp v. Bonner Mall Partnership, 513 U.S. 18,

27 (1994). The Respondent further requests that this

Court suspend the remainder of the briefing schedule in

this case pending its disposition of this Suggestion of

Mootness.

Respectfully submitted,

DONALD A. COCKRILL *

NANCY W. MONTS

OGLETREE, DEAKINS, NASH,

SMOAK & STEWarT, P.C.

The Ogletree Building

300 North Main Street

P.O. Box 2757

Greenville, SC 29602

(864) 271-1300

Counsel for Respondent

Dated: June 9, 1999 * Counsel of Record

APPENDICES

la

APPENDIX A

Spartanburg Herald Journal—1-28-97

LAIDLAW MULLING OPTIONS

Incinerator talking closure with DHEC

By GARY HENDERSON

Staff Writer

A Laidlaw Environmental Services official said Monday

the company is considering shutting down its Roebuck

incinerator because the facility is producing “poor finan-

cial results.”

Henry Taylor, vice president of legal and regulatory

affairs, said the plan to close the incinerator could be

worked out with state officials by February.

But it will be much longer before the incinerator ac-

tually stops operating.

“It might take a year, but certainly less than two

years,” Taylor said.

The decision about the possible shutdown of the in-

cinerator came during negotiations with §.C. Department

of Health and Environmental Control over Laidlaw’s

operating permit, Taylor said.

Laidlaw is currently permitted to burn 4.5 tons of haz-

ardous waste per hour year around. During the permit

process, samples of gases being emitted from a trial burn

of the incinerator must be submitted to the state’s health

authorities.

“There was a dispute about the capacity we could

burn,” Taylor said. “They wanted to go down to 3.7 tons,

and they didn’t think we provided quality samples. We

felt we did.”

2a

Taylor said Laidlaw officials then decided to approach

DHEC about closing the incinerator.

“I think they were happy to see us come with the idea,”

Taylor said, “but they were shocked.”

Taylor said it is difficult to make a profit at the Roe-

buck facility because there are so many incinerators oper-

ating in the United States. He said kilns used for making

cement now burn hazardous materials as fuel, reducing

the demand for incinerators even further.

“It is highly competitive,” Taylor said. “There is a

real over-capacity—more incinerators than there is ma-

terial to burn.”

Taylor said if the incinerator closes, Laidlaw would

still use the Roebuck site as a transfer and holding facility.

“This would become a collection point for small quan-

tities that would be combined and shipped to another in-

cinerator site,” Taylor said.

Dever Melton, a Roebuck resident who has worked

with other community activists to get the Laidlaw incin-

erator shut down, said he wants the entire facility closed.

“We will not be satisfied until there are no more toxic

chemicals brought to Roebuck,” Melton said, “We will

not be satisfied until they stop hauling the stuff down the

road or bringing it in on the rail cars.”

Taylor said that if the incinerator is shut down, the

facility’s work force of 48 employees would probably be

reduced.

“We don’t have a feel for that yet,” Taylor said, “We

will need some different skills from the ones we have now,

but the people working there will have an opportunity to

continue working with Laidlaw.”

Hazardous wastes are shipped to the Spartanburg County

facility from more than 40 states. Laidlaw, a Canadian-

3a

based company, operates collection and transfer sites in

11 states and in Canada.

A merger between Laidlaw and Rollins Environmental

was announced earlier this month, which would give the

merged company 120 facilities. Rollins Environmental is

a New Jersey-based hazardous waste management com-

pany.

‘We will not be satisfied until there are no more

toxic chemicals brought to Roebuck.’

Dever Melton

Taylor said the merged company has 120 facilities

around the country, which will probably be reduced to

100.

Explosions have occurred twice at the Roebuck plant

in the last five months after several types of hazardous

waste were transferred to a holding tank.

Officials evacuated eight homes in the area last week

and advised residents of another 65 homes to stay inside

after a 500-gallon tank exploded. The explosion emitted

a large cloud of sulfurous vapors, which the wind blew

about one-half mile from the site.

“If we have caused any fears or concern among the

citizenry, we hope it will vanish,” Taylor said. “We want

our operation to be one that protects the people and the

environment. It will continue to be.”

Taylor said the negotiations with DHEC about the in-

cinerators will continue.

“It’s not final, even though we are moving in that di-

rection,” Taylor said.

4a

APPENDIX B

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE UNITED STATES

No. 98-822

FRIENDS OF THE EARTH, INC.,

Petitioners

Vv.

LAIDLAW ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES (TOC), INC.,

Respondent

AFFIDAVIT

1. My name is Charisse G. McLeod and I am em-

ployed by Safety-Kleen Systems, Inc. (formerly Laidlaw)

as the Environmental Manager at Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw’s

former hazardous waste treatment, storage and disposal

facility at 301 Railroad Street, Roebuck, South Carolina

29376.

2. Past operations at the Roebuck facility included a

liquid injection incinerator which was used to incinerate

hazardous waste. This incineration process created waste-

water which was passed through a wastewater treatment

system and thereafter discharged into the North Tyger

River pursuant to an NPDES permit issued by the South

Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Con-

trol (DHEC).

3. On June 2, 1997, Laidlaw and DHEC entered into

a consent agreement which provided, among other things,

that Laidlaw would cease operation of the liquid injection

5a

incinerator no later than August 31, 1998. A copy of

that consent agreement is attached to my affidavit as

Exhibit 1 and incorporated and made a part of this

affidavit.

4. Pursuant to the terms of that consent agreement,

Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw submitted a closure plan for the

incinerator to DHEC which was approved by DHEC on

September 15, 1998. Additionally, Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw

decided to discontinue all operations at the Roebuck fa-

cility and the closure plan for the remaining operations

was approved by DHEC on April 13, 1999.

5. At present, the entire facility is permanently closed

and for sale. The incinerator which generated the waste-

water that was discharged to the North Tyger River pur-

suant to Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw’s NPDES permit has been

removed and discarded, as have all waste feed systems

from ‘the tanks to the incinerator. The first and third

Stages of the wastewater treatment system have been re-

moved and/or sold. Only the second stage (the Lancy

metals removal system and filter press) remain and they

are for sale. The last discharge under the NPDES permit

was at 7:00 a.m. on September 1, 1998, and no customer

waste was received after August 31, 1998. Whenever

possible, we helped customers locate alternative disposal

sites. Apj oximately 60 employees have been terminated

and no employee who operated the wastewater treatment

system is currently on site. In fact, there are only five

employees (including myself) physically present at the

Roebuck site and all five employees report out of the

Company’s headquarters in Columbia, South Carolina.

6. It would be unlawful to discharge water to the

North Tyger River under the NPDES permit and Safety-

Kleen/Laidlaw has no intention of doing so. More prac-

tically, it would be impossible to do so because most of

6a

the system (including the incinerator) has been dis-

mantled and discarded or sold.

7. I have been shown footnote 7 at page 8 of the Pe-

titioner’s Brief in Friends of the Earth, et al. v. Laidlaw

Environmental Services (TOC) inc., No. 98-822, where

it is stated that “since Laidlaw’s NPDES permit is still in

effect, it may discharge in the future whenever it cares

to do so.” That is simply incorrect. It is impossible to

discharge wastewater at the Roebuck facility under the

NPDES permit since there is no waste to incinerate and

no incinerator to generate wastewater.

8. Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw took steps to keep the

NPDES permit in effect because to do so might make

the site more attractive to a prospective purchaser. The

permit has not been kept in effect in contemplation of

any future NPDES discharges by Safety-Kleen/Laidlaw.

Dated this 21st day of May, 1999.

/s/ Charisse G. McLeod

CHARISSE G. McLEop

[Notary Omitted]

_ nn

7a

APPENDIX C

THE STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA

BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH

AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL

IN RE:

LAIDLAW ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES (TOC), INC.

SCD 981 467 616

BAQ PERMIT No. 2060-0064

Spartanburg County

CONSENT AGREEMENT

97-15-HW

97-43-A

This Consent Agreement is being entered into by the

South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental

Control, hereafter the Department, and Laidlaw Environ-

mental Services (TOC), Inc., a South Carolina corpora-

tion, pursuant to the Department’s authority under 25

S.C. Code Ann. Regs. 61-79 (Supp. 1996), promulgated

pursuant to the South Carolina Hazardous Waste Man-

agement Act, S.C. Code Ann. § 44-56-10 et seq. (Supp.

1996) and the South Carolina Pollution Control Act

§ 48-1-10 et seqg., 1976, as amended.

FINDINGS OF FACT

1. Laidlaw Environmental Services (TOC), Inc., here-

after TOC, USEPA ID No. SCD 981 467 616, operates

a commercial hazardous waste treatment, storage and dis-

posal facility in Spartanburg County, South Carolina.

The local address of the facility is 301 Railroad Street,

Roebuck, South Carolina 29376. State regulations au-

thorize the facility to manage hazardous waste. In No-

vember 1980 the facility received interim status under the

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). On

September 30, 1988, the Department’s Bureau of Solid

and Hazardous Waste Management (BSHWM) issued a

Part B permit to the facility and the U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency (USEPA) issued a Hazardous and

Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) permit to the facility.

The Part B permit issued by the Department was modified

in 1991 to require post-closure care of closed hazardous

waste surface impoundments and to include additional

waste codes. The Part B permit has not become effective

because of appeals by the permittee and others. Conse-

quently, the facility operates under interim status. The

HSWA permit has become effective and has been amended

several times.

2. The Department’s Bureau of Air Quality (BAQ) is-

sued Air Construction Permit No. 2060-0064-CA on

December 12, 1985 to TOC. The Construction Permit

authorized the modification and operation of a hazardous

waste incinerator system with an incineration capacity of

4.5 tons per hour. On November 21, 1990, the BAO

issued Air Operating Permit No. 2060-0064 to TOC. The

Operating Permit was appealed and has not become effec-

tive. On December 15, 1996, TOC submitted a Title V

Air Operating Permit Application to the BAQ. This ap-

plication is currently under review.

3. Operations at the facility include a liquid injection in-

cinerator with a steam generating boiler system and air

and water pollution control systems. The incinerator has

an interim status thermal destruction treatment limit of

4.5 tons per hour. The air pollution control system for

9a

the incinerator includes a baghouse and a wet scrubber.

Other equipment at the facility is controlled by either

carbon absorption units or is subject to emission limits

established to comply with South Carolina Air Pollution

Control Regulation 61-62.5, Standard Number 8. The

water pollution control system is a scrubber waste water

treatment system composed of a pH adjuster, Lancy unit,

carbon adsorption and other types of filtration. The fa-

cility has been determined by the BSHWM to have

839,500 gallons of tank storage capacity and 64,230 gal-

lons per day of treatment in tank capacity. Presently, the

facility has 48,840 gallons of interim status container

storage capacity.

4. On January 16, 1986 when TOC was purchased from

its prior owner, the site had groundwater contamination

believed to have been caused by contamination from sev-

eral ponds or surface impoundments previously operated

at the site. TOC entered into a 3008(h) RCRA Cor-

rective Action Order with the USEPA to address the con-

tamination. TOC has constructed and installed a system

to remediate affected groundwater. This system will be

operated until all statutory and regulatory requirements

with respect to corrective action are achieved.

5. It is TOC’s position that marketplace realities have

had a significant effect on the commercial success of in-

cineration activities at TOC. Many of the hazardous and

nonhazardous liquid waste streams that can be incinerated

at TOC are now being burned at cement kilns and other

boilers and industrial furnaces. This competitive incinera-

tion market has driven pricing below that level which can

profitably support the high costs associated with the opera-

tion of a RCRA regulated incinerator at the Roebuck,

South Carolina location.

10a

6. After making its marketplace analysis, TOC informed

the Department’s Bureau of Land and Waste Manage-

ment, formerly known as the Bureau of Solid and Haz-

ardous Waste Management (BSHWM), that it desired

to modify its operational platform at the facility. To

effect this result, TOC submitted a revised Part A appli-

cation on April 10, 1997. The revised Part A application

was approved by the Department on April 17, 1997.

7. Of the 839,500 gallons of interim status tank storage

capacity (S02) referenced in paragraph 3 above, to date

547,780 gallons of tank storage capacity has been con-

structed. The remaining 291,720 gallons of tank storage

capacity has not been constructed. TOC desires to oper-

ate additional container storage capacity (SO1) equal to

the as yet unconstructed tank storage capacity.

8. TOC desires to convert the incineration capacity

(TO3) of 4.5 tons per hour to an equivalent amount of

treatment capacity defined by the process codes of TOI,

treatment in tanks, and T04, other treatment.

9. Since the issuance date of Air Construction Permit

Number 2060-0064-CA, the facility has complied with

state emission limits during source evaluations as required

by the Construction Permit and by South Carolina Air

Pollution Control Regulation 61-62.5, Standard Number

3. The facility has obtained additional construction per-

mits for a replacement baghouse and other new air emis-

sion control devices.

10. Upon execution of this Agreement, TOC is willing to

initiate the design and subsequently the construction of a

new traffic route to the facility.

11. TOC has outstanding matters which involve the

USEPA. On September 29, 1994 TOC executed a 3013

ee

lla

Order with USEPA. To date, this Order has not been

modified. TOC also has a HSWA permit renewal appli-

cation pending with USEPA, Region IV.

NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS AGREED pursuant to

S.C.Code Ann. §§ 44-56-40, et seq. (Supp. 1995) and

the South Carolina Pollution Control Act § 48-1-10 ef

seq., 1976, as amended, that:

1. TOC shall cease operation of the liquid injection in-

cinerator no later than August 31, 1998. Until that date,

TOC may continue to operate the incinerator provided

that all regulatory requirements for operation of the incin-

erator are met.

2. Nothing in this Consent Agreement will excuse TOC

from complying with all applicable generator and interim

Status treatment, storage, and disposal facility operating

regulations, as well as, any other state and federal en-

vironmental regulations and permitting requirements.

3. As of August 31, 1998, TOC will no longer have in-

terim status for treatment of waste by incineration (T03).

The 4.5 tons per hour of incineration capacity may be

converted to an equivalent amount of treatment capacity

which is defined by the process codes, T0O1, treatment in

tanks, and T04, other treatment, provided that a process

design proposal from TOC is approved by the Depart-

ment. The Department recognizes that TOC would like

to complete construction of the converted treatment ca-

pacity before the date it surrenders its interim status in-

cineration capacity and will therefore review the process

design proposal in a timely manner. The process design

proposal shall consist of a description of the proposed

process design and the calculated caacity as derived from

all or part of the 4.5 tons per hour of incineration ca-

pacity. The cumulative total of the converted treatment

capacity, which shall consist of fuels blending, shredding,

12a

stabilization /solidification, and metals precipitation, shall

not exceed the equivalent of 4.5 tons per hour. The con-

verted treatment capacity may be utilized in addition to

the existing 64,230 gallons per day of approved treat-

ment in tank capacity (TO1) or utilized in whole or part

for other treatment (T04). TOC may construct the

equivalent treatment capacity after the effective date of

this agreement, receipt of approval of the process design

proposal, and receipt of the appropriate permits from

other entities including, but not limited to, the BAQ. All

changes to the faciilty pursuant to this Agreement must

comply with R.61-79.270.72(b) which refers to recon-

struction. TOC can not use this newly constructed equiva-

lent capacity until it ceases to operate the incinerator and

compliance with R.61-79.270.72(b) is demonstrated.

4. No later than 60 days from the execution date of this

Agreement, TOC shall submit to the Department’s Bu-

reau of Land and Waste Management a closure plan for

the liquid injection incinerator, boilers, the stack, bag-

house, induction fan and associated duct work, venturi

quench and wet scrubber. The plan shall satisfy the ap-

plicable requirements of R. 61-79.265 Subpart G.

5. No later than 180 days from the execution date of

this Agreement, FOC shall submit to the Department’s

Bureau of Land and Waste Management a revised Part

B permit application for the facility consistent with the

Part A application approved by the Department on April

17, 1997 and the Part B application will not include a

request to operate an incinerator. Any interim status in-

cineration capacity included in this permit application

will be terminated.

6. No later than August 31, 1998, TOC will withdraw

its appeal of the BAQ November 21, 1990, air permit

decision.

13a

7. TOC shall submit to the Department’s Bureau of

Land and Waste Management quarterly progress reports

discussing how the 291,720 gallons of unconstructed tank

storage capacity (S02) is being converted to container

storage capacity (SO1) and how the treatment capacity

converted from the 4.5 tons per hour of incineration ca-

pacity is being established. The first progress report will

be due September |, 1997 and the final report will state

how the converted tank storage capacity exists as con-

tainer storage capacity and how the converted treatment

capacity has been established. In no event will container

storage under interim status exceed 340,560 gallons which

represents the combination of 48,840 gallons of existing

container storage capacity and the 291,720 gallons of un-

constructed tank storage capacity.

8. Should TOC desire to change its operation methods

to affect a source of air pollution, i.e., to install or modify

control equipment or remove a source of air contamination

from service, TOC shall submit a request for an air per-

mit determination, or a request to modify the facility's

Title V permit, and/or submit a construction permit ap-

plication or such other appropriate authorization request.

TOC shall not proceed with the change or addition with-

out obtaining either a written response approving the re-

quest or without obtaining a construction permit in ac-

cordance with South Carolina Air Pollution Control Regu-

lation 61-62.1, Section II, A, if necessary.

9. TOC shall continue to comply with all conditions and

provisions of outstanding orders entered into with the

Department and effective permits issued by the Depart-

ment (including the BAQ Title V permit, if applicable)

until otherwise authorized by the appropriate Department

entity.

10. Within five (5) days of the execution date of this

Agreement, TOC will provide the Department with notifi-

14a

cation that it has contacted USEPA to confer with the

Agency about the matters referenced in paragraph 11 of

the Findings of Fact.

11. TOC shall advise the Department of the general loca-

tion of the new traffic route and associated design and

construction milestones within one hundred eighty (180)

days of the execution of this Agreement.

12. The Department and TOC recognize that circum-

stances may arise which may affect due dates and dead-

lines set out in this Agreement. Should such circum-

stances arise, TOC shall notify the Department in writing,

(fax transmission being acceptable) no later than four-

teen (14) days after the discovery of the occurrence of

any event which TOC would contend is a circumstance

causing an unavoidable delay or need for a schedule ad-

justment. The written notification to the Department shall

attempt to anticipate the length of delay, generally de-

scribe the cause or causes of the circumstance, and indi-

cate the measures, if possible, to be taken by TOC to

minimize the effect on any schedule. In the event the

Department concurs that an unavoidable situation has

occurred, this Agreement, including incorporated docu-

ments and any affected schedules, shall be modified in the

event the unavoidable situation affects such schedules.

Any such modifications or revised schedules shall be in-

corporated by reference as part of this Consent Agree-

ment.

IT IS FURTHER AGREED that failure to meet dead-

lines established herein or any other violation of the pro-

visions of this Agreement may be deemed a violation of

the South Carolina Hazardous Waste Management Act

and the South Carolina Pollution Control Act and there-

fore shall be deemed unlawful. Upon ascertaining any

15a

such violation, the Department may initiate action to ob-

tain compliance with this Agreement and the aforesaid

Acts.

THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPART-

MENT OF HEALTH AND ENVIR-

ONMENTAL CONTROL

Date: 6/2/97 By: /s/ Douglas E. Bryant

DOUGLAS E. BRYANT

Commissioner

We Consent:

LAIDLAW ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES (TOC), INC.

Date: 5-30-97 By: /s/ [Illegible]

THE SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH

AND ENVIRON MENTAL CONTROL

/s/ Hartsill W. Truesdale Date: 06/02/97

HARTSILL W. TRUESDALE, P.E.

Chief

BUREAU OF LAND & WASTE

MANAGEMENT

/s/ Richard D. Sharpe Date: 06/02/97

for JAMES A. Joy, P.E.

Chief

BUREAU OF AIR QUALITY

CONTROL

/s/ [Illegible] Date: 6-2-97

Approved by: Legal Office

pab :bkb

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Suggestion of Mootness — Friends of Earth v. Laidlaw Environmental Services · 528 U.S. 167 | Frix