Joint Appendix Vol II — Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael
Supreme Court brief1999
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
in The AUG 2 5 1998
Supreme Court of the Wnited States
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
October Term, 1 SUPREME COURT, U.S.
e ee
KUMHO TIRE COMPANY, LTD., KUMHO U.S.A., INC.,
and HERCULES TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY, INC.,
Vv. Petitioners,
PATRICK CARMICHAEL, AN INDIVIDUAL AND
FATHER AND NEXT OF KIN TO PATRICK CARMICHAEL,
JR., A MINOR, LUZVIMINDA CARMICHAEL,
AN INDIVIDUAL, MOTHER AND NEXT FRIEND OF
CARINA HORN, A MINOR, AND ADMINISTRATRIX OF
THE SSTATE OF JANICE HORN, CARINA HORN,
A MINOR, LEONA CARMICHAEL, SHAMEELA
CARMICHAEL, NATIMAH CARMICHAEL,
Respondents.
.
On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States
Court Of Appeals For The Eleventh Circuit
¢
JOINT APPENDIX
VOLUME II, PAGES 105 TO 435
e
Sipney W. Jackson, III Warren C. HERLONG, Jr.
Steven A. MARTINO
Rosert J. Hevce
Jackson, TayLtor & Martino, P.C.
Post Office Box 894
Mobile, Alabama 36601
(334) 433-3131
Josern P. H. BasincTon
Counsel of Record
Joun T. Dukes
Hewmsinc, Sms & Leacn, PC.
Post Office Box 2767
Mobile, Alabama 36652
(334) 432-5521
KennetH S. GELLER
ALAN E. UNTEREINER
Micnwaer E. Lackey, Jr.
Mayer, Brown & Ptatr
2000 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006-1882
(202) 463-2000
Attorneys for Petitioners
Attorneys for Respondents
Petition For Certiorari Filed March 23, 1998
Certiorari Granted June 22, 1998
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO.
, (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
VOLUME I
Relevant Docket Entries, United States District
Court for the Southern District of Alabama,
Southern Division
Motion of Defendants Hercules and Kumho
U.S.A. for Summary Judgment
Motion of Defendants for Summary Judgment
Motion of All Defendants to Exclude Testimony of
Plaintiffs’ Expert Dennis P. Carlson and to Con-
duct Fed. R. Evid. 104(a) Hearing
Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendants’ Motion to
Exclude Testimony of Plaintiffs’ Expert, Dennis
P. Carlson, and Plaintiffs’ Brief in Opposition to
All Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment ....
Pre-trial Order
Order of the United States District Court for the
Southern District of Alabama, Southern Divi-
sion, dated April 1, 1996
Plaintiffs’ Motion to Reconsider
Memorandum of Law in Support of Plaintiffs’
Motion for Reconsideration
Response of Defendants to Plaintiffs’ Motion to
Reconsider
i a Ct ee! ee 5 eel a P
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Order of United States District Court for the
Southern District of Alabama, Southern Divi-
sion, dated June 5, 1996.............. 0000 c eee
Opinion ofthe United States Court of Appeals for
the Eleventh Circuit, dated December 23, 1997 ....
VOLUME II
Excerpts from deposition of Dennis P. Carlson in
Carmichael v. Kumho Tire Company, Ltd., et al.
(Exhibit A to Defendants’ Motion to Exclude)....
Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Responses to Defen-
dant Kumho, USA’s First Set of Interrogatories
and Requests for Production (Defendants’
Exhibit 2 to deposition). ..................50555
Letter from George R. Edwards to Sidney W.
Jackson, III, dated September 14, 1994 (Defen-
dants’ Exhibit 3 to deposition).................
Letter from Sidney W. Jackson, III to Dennis P.
Carlson, dated January 25, 1995 (Defendants’
Exhibit 6 to deposition). ...............6600005.
Letter from Dennis P. Carlson and George R.
Edwards to Sidney W. Jackson, III, dated March
1, 1995 (Defendants’ Exhibit 6 to deposition)...
Fee Schedule and Promotional Material from
George R. Edwards (Defendants’ Exhibit 6 to
ES <i sGce dee ensehebeds btauveesew eects
Excerpts from deposition of Dennis P. Carlson in
Tillery v. Bridgestone/Firestone, Inc. (Exhibit B to
Defendants’ Motion to Exclude)................
Page
105
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Excerpts from d ition of Thomas M. Dodson
(Exhibit A to Plaintiffs’ Response to Defen-
dants’ Motion to Exclude) .....................
Affidavit of Dennis P. Carlson, dated February 15,
1996 (Exhibit F to Plaintiffs’ Response to Defen-
dants’ Motion to Exclude) .....................
Exhibit A to Affidavit of Dennis P. Carlson ....
Affidavit of George R. Edwards, dated April 15,
1996 (Exhibit B to Memorandum of Law in Sup-
port of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Reconsideration)... .
Affidavit of R. Jeffrey Perloff, dated April 12,
1996, including additional pages of son
deposition (Exhibit C to Memorandum of Law
in Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Recon-
LS onic tell tide tga. wi cia dite mene cetees
Letter from Thomas M. Dodson to Joseph P. H.
Babington, dated December 11, 1995 (Exhibit D
to Memorandum of Law in Support of Plain-
tiffs’ Motion for Reconsideration) ..............
Page
419
105
[p. 1] IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA
SOUTHERN DIVISION
PATRICK CARMICHAEL, etc.,
et al.,
Plaintiffs,
Vs.
SAMYANG TIRES, INC., et al.,
Defendants.
CV-93-0860-CB-S
CARMICHAEL/CARSON VOL. I
The testimony of DENNIS P. CARLSON, JR., taken at the
law offices of HELMSING, LYONS, SIMS & LEACH, 2000
LaClede Building, 150 Government Street, Mobile, Ala-
bama, on the 7th day of March 1995, commencing at
approximately 10:20 a.m.
[p. 2] APPEARANCES
* * *
[p. 3] INDEX
* . *
[p. 6] DENNIS P. CARLSON, JR., the witness, after hav-
ing first been duly sworn to tell the truth, the whole
truth, and nothing but the truth, was examined and testi-
fied as follows:
106
EXAMINATION -
BY MR. BABINGTON:
@)
State your name, please.
Dennis P. Carlson, Jr.
What is your date of birth?
10/26/47.
How old does that make you right now?
Forty-seven, I think.
What is your residence address?
2537 Carolina Avenue, Louisville, Kentucky.
How long have you lived there?
Two months.
You used to live, as I understand it, in Georgia; is
that correct?
OF? 0D F&F DO F&F Oo fF DO PS
A Yes.
Q What was the reason for your move to Kentucky?
A I’m working for George Edwards, Incorporated
now. I changed jobs.
ip. 7] Q How many employees does that entity
have?
A Three.
Q Who are they?
107
A George Edwards, myself and a secretary.
Q Do you have a supervisor, per se, in your work
there?
A Well, George Edwards right now is my super-
visor, if you would.
Q What are your duties in a general sense?
I look at tires and reconstruct accidents.
That’s pretty much it?
That's about it.
On a day-to-day basis what do you do?
O > O >
[p. 8] A_ I look at tires, I read depositions and write
reports or go out and look — do an accident reconstruc-
tion.
* * *
Q Do you do any nonlitigation work at this time?
A Well, the work I do, of course, all has the [p. 9]
potential to go to litigation. But a very small percentage
of it actually gets even to the deposition stage.
Q Well, what I’m talking about is do you do any
work that is for industry where there’s not a litigation
already ot ing or threatened?
A Nex at the present.
Q So it would be fair to say that all of your work is
related to lawsuits at this time?
A It has the potential to be related, yes.
108
Q Or actually is related to an ongoing lawsuit?
A Yes.
* * *.
[p. 11] Q Now in your resume you list that you
worked for Michelin America’s Research and Develop-
ment in the period 1977 to November of 1987?
A Yes.
* * *
[p. 12} Q What Michelin location or office did you
work in or out of?
A Michelin America is located in Greenville, South
Carolina and I worked there in the Greenville location for
approximately five and a half years. And I worked at the
Laurens test track for approximately five years.
Q When you were employed at Michelin, did you
ever do any control failure simulation testing?
A Yes.
Q Can you define what that is for me?
A What we do is we have a great deal of testing [p.
13] that essentially is designed to make a certain part of
the tire fail and in that way we can compare a candidate
tire or candidate piece of rubber or construction, what-
ever you would, to our standard tire.
And this was my job for much of the time at Mich-
elin, at least five years, was to do tests that developed a
109
certain type of failure, one of which being edge belt
separation.
Q Were the tires that you tested in this fashion all
Michelin tires?
A No.
Q What types of tires did you test?
A We had many competitor tires. You name it, we
probably tested it.
Q Did you ever test a Kumho manufactured tire?
A Not that I recall specifically but I’m sure we
tested them in some tests.
Q Well, I want what you can specifically recall.
A Okay.
Q Can you recall specifically ever testing a Kumho
manufactured tire?
A Not specifically.
Q And can you recall ever testing a Hercules [p. 14]
tire?
A Yes.
Q |. you know who manufactured the Hercules
tire that you tested?
A_ I don’t recall.
Q Did you ever test a Hercules Superior XII tire?
A_ I recall testing a Hercules Superior but I don’t
remember if it had a designation after it.
eee, eee
110
Did you specifically recall that test?
I recall a handling test that used a Hercules tire.
oO > 0
And what would a handling test consist of?
A At this time we were looking at wet traction and
the handling under wet traction conditions.
Q And what would be the significance of or pur-
pose of that test?
A Just compare it against the Michelin tire to see
how other people solved the problem of wet traction.
Q Do you have any independent recollection about
what the results of that test were at this time?
A If I remember, it did well —
[p. 15] Q Well, first, do you have any independent
recollection about what the results of the test were?
A_ Ido not recall the specifics. | remember a general
recollection about it.
Q Have you seen or refreshed your recollection by
reviewing any test reports or conclusions?
A No, I could not take any of the test results when I
left Michelin.
Q And I take it over your years with Michelin you
performed a variety of tests; is that correct?
A Yes.
Q And how many such tests, control failure simula-
tion tests, would you say you performed?
111
A_ It would be in the thousands.
Q And over what length of time would you have
performed those?
A_ I spent a year and a half doing machine tests and
then I spent four years in tire design and then I spent five
years at the test track doing tests. And so direct testing
was approximately six and a half years.
But while I was in tire design there, I was requesting
tests and we had all sorts of tests that were requested. I
was in charge of that, so I was [p. 16] actually involved
with testing at that time also but in a different perspec-
tive.
Q Now going back to this test of the Hercules Supe-
rior tire, as I understand, you can’t remember the desig-
nation, you say you do have some general recollection -
A Yes.
Q - at this point about what the test showed or
resulted in?
A Well, I'm not sure -
Q What was that?
A -Ican give you specific results or even general
results because of my secrecy agreement with Michelin.
And that was not my test, it was one of my friends’ tests,
one of the associates.
Q Did you actually conduct that test?
A_ I did not request it and I did not do the test.
Q Did you participate in any fashion in the tests?
112
A_ I did participate, yes.
Q What did you do specifically?
A Well, the driver had noticed something special
[p. 17] or different and he asked me to ride with him to
verify his conclusion, the test driver.
Q So there was a test on a track as opposed to using
a dynamometer?
A Yes.
Q Can you describe what the test protocol was?
A No, I cannot.
Q You cannot because of your secrecy agreement or
you cannot because you don’t recall it?
A_ No, because of the secrecy agreement. I think that
would be a violation of the secrecy agreement. I can tell
you general things about it, it was a wet traction type test
and it had something that was somewhat significant to
the driver.
Q Well, are you relying in any way on the experi-
ence you had in that test with respect to any opinions or
conclusions or any work you've done in this case?
A I think it has no relevance to this case because it
involved wet traction and this involves separation resis-
tance.
Q So there’s no knowledge or experience that you
gained from this test that you participated in while [p. 18]
you were at Michelin that is relevant to this case or bears
upon your opinions in this case?
113
A I don’t think so.
Q Did you ever conduct any control failure simula-
tion testing that was designed to isolate the causes for
steel belt separation?
A Yes.
Q Tell me what you did in that regard.
A Well, I was responsible for the test quality of
several separation tests. Michelin has one separation test
that is used primarily for heavy truck tires and I ran that
test for five years.
Q Did you do anything else as far as control failure
simulation testing for belt separation?
A We had other tests that we were trying to develop
to find a reliable test method for belt edge separations
and I worked on that. I also examined the tires after the
tests, after they had been decorticated.
Q Now you just used the word decorticated, what
does that mean?
A Cutting the tire up.
Q How?
[p. 19] A It was with knives and nippers, done
manually.
Q In what fashion, would you cut it cross section or
lengthwise?
A We usually did what is called a decap where we
would peel the tire back and peel it back between the
belts to view the surface to see —- we were testing, you
a a FOS
114
know, all the time new rubbers or new constructions to
improve belt edge separation resistance.
And I looked at these because I needed to see if my
test method was correct and to see if our evaluation was
correct.
Q What were you concerned about as far as your
test method?
A Well, it’s a very difficult test to maintain accuracy
with.
Q Why is that?
A Well, it’s very hard to develop a reliable and
consistent test for belt edge separations.
© And what are the reasons for that?
A Because it is so variable.
Q Does that mean there were a lot of different rea-
sons why belts will separate?
A Yes.
[p. 20] Q What are some of the reasons why belts
will separate?
A Well -
Q Or let me withdraw that question. Would you list
for me all the potential causes of a belt separation?
A Okay. Well, obviously you can have a bad design
of your product, the tire can be a bad design. In other
words, the rubbers may not have the sufficient adhesion
or the belt construction can be bad in some respects.
Those are design factors.
115
Production factors, they are numerous. Contamina-
tion is perhaps the biggest thing. You can get dirt on the
product. You can get water on the product as the tire is
being made. You can get oil or grease from a person’s
hands.
Other things are that the products could be overaged,
they can not be put in the tire and cured soon enough, or
you can assemble the tire incorrectly.
Q Anything else?
A Well, those are the things that are related to the
tires. There are a few others that I'll try to remember
those, but — then, of course, there are abuse [p. 21] fac-
tors.
Q And what abuse factors are there?
A Well, the majority - the major one, of course, is
overdeflection of the tire. .
Q Can you define that for me?
A Well, it’s either running the tire overloaded or
underinflated. There are people who have used the word
overdeflected to — because it’s a little easier to say than
overloaded or underinflated.
Q Any other abuse factors?
A Well, you can - you can run the tire too fast.
Q Anything else?
A There are others that can potentially cause this
but they are not seen generally on passenger vehicles
because the tire wears out. But if you ran around curvy
116
roads all day and kept the tire hot and everything, you
might be able to generate an edge belt separation, but the
tire generally would wear out before that would occur.
Q What do you call that, is there a technical name in
the field for that problem?
A It’s called derive-induced separation, but [p. 22]
like I say, it’s impossible for a driver to really do that. We
can do it in a test track or something like that but you
can’t do it out in the field.
Q What was the first word?
A Derive — steering.
Q Derive?
A Derive is the French word for steering. Or slip
angle, excuse me.
Q Any other an abuse factor that would lead to a
separation?
A There are none that are practical.
Q Well, even if they’re impractical.
A Okay. Well, most people for tire companies, when
they get into stuff like this they say an impact can cause
that. And that’s just not true. So -
Q We'll get to that later.
A Yes.
Q What about anything else that’s an abuse factor
that you’re aware of that can cause separation or that is a
potential cause of separation?
117
A_ I think that should cover it.
Q Any other factors other than design, production,
assembly or abuse factors that would lead [p. 23] to
separation?
A Those are the big categories.
Q Anything else?
A I think that’s it.
Q Now you stated that it’s very difficult -
A Oh, excuse me, one other. There are some cases
where you can have a puncture and if the puncture is not
repaired carefully you can see where the separation can
grow from the puncture hole.
Q Anything else?
A That's it.
Q You stated that it’s very difficult to create a reli-
able test for determining belt separation or tread separa-
tion causes.
A Yes, sir.
Q Have you ever done a study of what the test error
rate would be for those types of tests?
A Well, the Michelin test had a very good — the
word co-efficient of variation.
Q Is that the same thing as an error rate?
A_ Close, but statistics — co-efficient of variation, if I
remember correctly, is generally your standard deviation
of the test divided by the mean. [p. 24] And as far as I
118
know Michelin has the only test in the industry that has a
very, very low co-efficient of variation.
There are other tests that are used by other com-
panies, and as far as I’m concerned they’re not very
reliable. They are good tests to get rid of tires that are
very, very bad in separation resistance, okay, they will
determine a first cut analysis, if you will.
Q What tests are those?
A Well, they usually involve running the tire
against a steel road wheel and putting slip angle in a
program sequence.
Q These are the tests that you consider to be unreli-
able?
A Yes.
Q What is the name of the Michelin test that you
consider to have a better error rate than those tests?
A Well, we call it the cleavage test.
Q How do you spell that?_
A Well, cleavage.
Q Okay. Is that type of test something that’s gener-
ally used in the industry or just by Michelin?
A As far as I know it’s only a Michelin test.
[p. 25] Q Can you describe for me how you would
conduct such a test?
A_ I doubt it.
Q What do you mean you doubt it?
119
A_ The secrecy agreement, I don’t think they would
allow me to do that.
Q Well, without getting into all the technical aspects
of it, can you do it in a way that can generally give me a
picture?
A Okay, it’s a track test and it involves putting high
stresses on the tire in a manner that produces edge belt
separation.
Q Did you ever do such a test on a tire manufac-
tured by Kumho?
A No.
Q Did you ever do such a test on a Hercules tire?
A (Witness shakes head negatively.)
Q And specifically you haven't done such a test on
any tire at issue in this case; its that correct?
A That is correct.
Q How would you control for the various potential
causes of separation to isolate which is the [p. 26] cause
in that cleavage test?
A Would you repeat your question, it was kind of -
Q Well, as I understand it there are a lot of potential
different causes of separation; is that correct?
A That's correct.
Q And the test that you are describing, as I under-
stand it, is designed to isolate a cause?
A No.
120
Q It’s not. What is it designed to do?
A What it is designed to do is to cause the tire to
fail by edge belt separation. Okay? So then you can
change your design factors - I’m not talking about pro-
duction problems or, you know, abuse factors but your
design factors.
So you can change the rubber at the edge of the belts
or the design of the edge of the belts or something like
that and you have a reliable test to see if you have
improved the tire. Okay?
Q So you would make the change and then test it
again to see if it fares any better?
A Yes, you would make a change in a tire and we
[p. 27] had a special construction group that built test
tires and they tried to eliminate all the other production
variables; in other words, they tried to build a perfect tire
so we would get the best test quality. Okay. And you
would eliminate all - you know, you wouldn’t have prob-
lems with production. You know, you’re not looking for
that type of problem.
Q You're looking for design problems?
A Yes, exactly, just design problems.
Q So that test would not be able to isolate what
abuse factors might cause separation?
A_ No, you could do other tests that did that. I mean
it could be used for that.
Q Let's just talk about this test right now.
121
A You could use it for that and we did do a couple
of tests at one time where we abused a tire and ran it to
see it’s separation resistance to see the effect of the abuse.
Q Tell me what you did to abuse the tire.
A_ They ran it at low pressure.
Q And what happened as far as separation?
A_ I don’t recall.
Q Did the separation of the tire that was run at
[p. 28] low air pressure occur more quickly or rapidly
than on a tire that had not been abused?
A_ I don’t recall. I seem to recall that there was some
problem with the test. That we, you know, got some tires
from someplace and we could not believe that the abuse
that we saw was controlled enough to provide an accu-
rate test.
Q So the test was unreliable?
A If I remember, that we had great doubt in the
results.
Q So there was some uncertainty on whether you
could rely on the conclusion that the test would point
towards?
A If I recall, these tires were provided to us as
abused tires and we could not believe that - we could not
define the type of abuse in that case.
Q So there was some uncertainty as to the validity
of the test?
A Yes.
122
Q Have you ever done a test, a cleavage test or
cleavage test on a tire that’s been abused that you found
to be reliable?
A I don’t recall one. That was not the basis of [p. 29]
our — the thrust of our research.
Q Your research was aimed at design, as | under-
stand it?
A Building a better tire.
Q And not at testing what abuse factors might lead
to or cause separation?
A That's correct.
Q And it also was not aimed at determining what
production problems or manufacturing problems might
cause separation?
A That's correct.
Q I take it since you were working for Michelin the
type of tires on which you did these cleavage tests were
Michelin tires?
A Most of the time, yes, sir.
Q Occasionally you might test a competitor's tire; is
that correct?
A We couldn’t get them to run very long, so -
Q Well, is the answer to my question that occa-
sionally you might test a competitor's tire?
A Yes, it was done occasionally, but everytime we
did we found that Michelin was so far above the rest of
123
the industry that there was no point in testing the other
tires.
* * *
[p. 30] Q Can you tell me the time frame of your
tests of these tires?
A_ I worked at the track from approximately ‘82 to
‘87.
So after 1987 you haven't done any such tests?
No. I’ve been involved in the forensic end.
Pardon me?
I’ve been involved in forensics after that.
Since 1987 have you done any such tests?
No.
> OD > O > 0
Q Have you ever done such a test with respect to
any litigation matter that you worked on?
A No.
Q Were there any other control failure simulation
tests that you did that we haven’t talked about yet other
than this cleavage test.
A I did many tests. We had other tests that were
similar to this in developing separation.
Q Tell me about those tests.
A Well, I can’t tell you very much about it but [p.
31] they’re very similar in that you stress the tire very
heavy, you heat the tire through running and then you
stress it in a way that produces edge belt separation.
124
Q And were those again aimed at isolating design
factors that might improve the tire?
A Yes.
Q And they were not aimed at looking at produc-
tion problems or abuse factors; is that correct?
A Well, the Michelin man would tell you that
there’s very few production problems in the Michelin
plant, so that was not the basis of their research.
Q And the same goes for abuse factors, the tests
that you did were not of tires that had been abused to see
what result might happen when you subjected them to
the stresses?
A We did other tests that -
Q Can we just stick to this one test right now?
A It was not specifically designed to test abuse
factors.
Q Okay. What other controlled phase simulation
tests did you do at Michelin?
A We did quite a few tests.
Q I want to know all of them.
[p. 32] A I was responsible for the truck tire adher-
ence test program, truck and light truck.
Q Anything else?
A There were several other endurance tests that I
did, mainly having to do with specific types of failures
for truck tires.
125
Q Anything else?
A There were special tests that were done all the
time.
Q What were these special tests?
A I’m talking mainly about the time at the test
track. There were times - others that I'll have to talk
about. Special tests might be a test that sometimes we did
these that would test the abuse factors, like running a tire
at low pressure to see the temperature. Also did tempera-
ture tests on the road. I did pavement studies. We did
some ice and snow testing.
My first part at Michelin I did rolling resistance,
cornering force and ozone endurance tests. When I was in
tire design I did all types of tests having to do — I also did
noise tests. When I was in tire design I requested all the
tests that may be [p. 33] required to bring a new tire into
production, and that involves hundreds of tests at times,
everything from revolutions per mile to noise to handling
to endurance.
Testing is generally divided into measurement and
endurance type tests. Measurements, you measure some
property of the tire, like rolling resistance or cornering
force. And endurance, you see how the tire fails under
controlled conditions.
Q Okay. Let me see if I can speed this along. It
appears from your resume that you had three different
general jobs while you were at Michelin -
A That's correct.
Q - is that correct?
126
Okay. You list five years in truck tires in adherence
and endurance testing; is that where you started out?
A No, that was the last.
Q That was your last job. Your first job was one and
a half years in machine tire testing; is that correct?
A That's correct.
Q What is machine tire testing?
A I did rolling resistance, cornering force and [p.
34] ozone resistance testing. | worked in a building that
did all sorts of endurance testing. ~
Q And what is endurance testing?
A Well, there are many tests that are done in the
automobile - I mean in the tire industry. Some of the
Michelin tests are very similar to the DOT tests and tests
that are done by other parts of the industry, which mainly
is the road wheel test which you run at increasing speeds
and see where and how your tire fails.
Q And when you say the DOT required tests, what
tests are you talking about there?
A Well, there’s a road wheel test that is mainly for
truck tires, it’s also done for other types of tires, but you
run a tire at a certain speed for ten minutes and then you
run it at an increased speed for ten minutes and then you
increase it, it’s eithe~ ten miles an hour or ten kilometers
an hour. I think it’s ten miles an hour in government
tests, I get mixed up with the Michelin method.
But you essentially run the tire against the road
wheel at a certain load and pressure and then you
127
increase the speed and hold it for ten minutes and you [p.
35] increase the speed again. And the speed at which it
fails determines one measure of the tire’s quality.
Q That gives it the speed rating?
A_ No, it’s mainly used for —- I don’t know if you’ve
heard of the tire quality system, but there’s a temperature
rating on tires and this is used mainly for that. Most tire
companies use another method for speed rating although
this is a good data for a speed rating.
Q In this one and a half years in machine tire test-
ing, did you test any passenger tires?
A_ I was involved - they were not specifically my
tests but I was there and I reviewed the results.
Q _Well, did you participate in any machine tire tests
of passenger tires?
A Yes.
Q And what was your involvement?
A_ Iwas one of the engineers that assured tire qual-
ity.
Q What did you specifically do in those tests?
A Okay, specifically on those tests I was a reviewer.
They were not specifically my tests to guarantee the
quality. Michelin has engineers that are responsible for
each test and they are in charge of [p. 36] maintaining
what is called test quality. In other words, keeping your
dispersions low and making sure the test was run cor-
rectly.
128
And I had three tests that I was specifically involved
with, but I reviewed the results of the other engineers’
tests and they were responsible for the other tests. These
machine -
Q They were responsible for the passenger tire
tests?
A The passenger tire speed tests. I did the pas-
senger tire rolling resistance, cornering force and ozone
test.
Q And these were used for purposes of getting the
various quality ratings; is that correct?
A They were used for that and mainly as a test to
improve the quality of the tire. Similar to the other types
of tests I’ve described.
Q They were mainly focused at design improve-
ments?
A Design improvements, yes.
[p. 37] Q Were these tests that you were involved in
when you did machine tire testing during the first one
and a half years at Michelin, tests that were designed to
test how well a tire that had been abused would perform
under certain conditions?
A There were tests that were done for that. See —
Q Let me stop you right there. Can you tell me
about those tests? What tests did you do in that regard?
A There were many, many tests that were done, that
were instigated by designers. All testing gives you an
129
idea of how sensitive your tire is to any production
variances. Okay.
So the tire designer is always aware that, you know,
certain production problems can cause a variation in test
results. And a great deal of work is done with production
tires at times to see what the variation is [p. 38] in the
production plants. I was involved in some of that.
Q Was that of passenger car tires?
A Generally passenger and light truck, yes.
Q And what was your specific role in those tests?
A Well, when I was in testing I did some of the tests
and evaluated the tests. When I was in tire design I took -
I took several production tires and tested them to see the
variance and I set up a program that was a periodic test
of production tires.
Q To monitor quality?
A Monitor quality, yes, sir.
Q During the first one and a half years when you
did the machine tire testing you stated that you did some
tests of tires that had been abused; did I state that cor-
rectly?
A Yes.
Q What test did you do of tires that had been
abused?
A_ I know that there were many programs that were
set up and as I said, every test does give some idea of
resistance to abuse. In other words, you know, a tire [p.
130
39] that is overloaded, of course, you can tell by these
other tests how well, you know, almost all testing is done.
All endurance testing is done at conditions that are
much more severe than the use of the customer because
you have to wear out a tire and cause it to fail much
quicker. And one of the challenges of testing, of course, is
to provide an economical test which means you wear
your tire out faster but have it relevant to what happens
on the road.
Q But what I’m interested in is you stated that you
did testing -
A Yes.
Q - during your first one and a half years at Mic-
helin -
A Uh-huh.
- of tires that had been abused.
Uh-huh.
Is that correct?
Well -
Let me finish.
Okay.
Q Is that correct, did you do that type of test?
> OD > DO > O
[p. 40] A There’s two types of - okay, what I’m
trying to say, there’s deliberate abuse and then testing
under certain types of parameters. Okay. That is not done
that much.
131
Q But let me ask the question here. As I understand
what you're saying is you can create conditions in your
test that are more severe than conditions that are nor-
mally experienced on the roadway?
A That's correct.
Q And you did those tests?
A Yes.
Q I'm talking about where a tire had been abused
before the test and then you tested it to see what hap-
pened to it.
A There were many programs where it was done by
designers or whatever to test that. They would run a tire
underinflated or something like that and then make var-
ious measurement tests or endurance tests.
Q Did you ever do that?
A_ I was involved in some parts of those.
Q What was your role?
A Most of the tests that are done like that, I [p. 41]
ran the test.
Q When you say you ran the test, what do you
mean?
A_ It means I was in charge of test quality.
Q That means you were trying to make sure the test
was accurate?
A Yes.
Q And what did you do to make sure it was accu-
rate?
132
A Well, I wrote procedures and made sure that the
workers followed those procedures. I examined the tires
to make sure that there was nothing abnormal in their
failure or the failure mode or the measurement mode.
Michelin has this system where each test is mon-
itored by an engineer who is responsible for what we call
test quality. And they do everything, except we're not
direct supervisors of the workers. We had another guy
that did that.
But we did everything. We maintained the machines
in order that the workers did their job correctly, that had
good procedure, and then we analyzed the statistics to
make sure there was nothing [p. 42] abnormal on the test.
Q Did you ever perform machine tire testing of any
Kumho tire or Hercules tire?
A Not specifically. I remember them coming
through, I did some rolling resistance tests on those.
Q But did you do any that dealt with abuse?
A I'm sure they did but I don’t recall the results.
Q Well, did you have any involvement in that?
A No.
Q And as ! understand it, these machine tire tests
that you performed during your first one and a half years
with Michelin were, again, focused on the design phase
of the tire, you were using the test results to see how you
could improve design; is that correct?
A That's generally correct, yes, sir.
133
[p. 45] Q You mentioned that you did the rolling
resistance test or that there was some vague [p. 46] recol-
lection on your part that there was a rolling resistance
test of a Kumho or Hercules tire. Can you recall anything
specifically about that?
A No.
Q Did you ever do a cornering force test on a
Kumho or Hercules tire? -
A_ I don’t think so.
Q Did you ever do an ozone test on a Kumho or
Hercules tire?
A No, sir.
Q Going back to the rolling resistance test, do you
remember if the rolling resistance test was on a Hercules
tire as opposed to a Kumho tire?
A I recall a Hercules more than a Kumho. I don’t - I
don’t even know if Kumho was imported at that time. But
I do seem to recall the Hercules but it’s not a very specific
recollection.
Q So you're not even sure you tested a Hercules?
A_ I’m not positive. It was, what, 16 years ago, some-
thing like that, so — we tested thousands of tires.
Q Well, we're interested in what you can remember
to be true because this is a court of law [p. 47] and -
A Right.
134
Q - the testimony you give has to be based on your
ability to swear that what you're saying is the truth.
A Okay.
Q Can you say within that standard that you tested
a Hercules tire?
A_ I believe that I tested a Hercules tire.
Q But you’re not sure?
A But I can’t be positive.
Q And you’re not sure, as I understand it, and don’t
have any specific recollection about whether you did a
rolling resistance test on a Kumho tire?
A_ Iam definite that I did not.
Q Then you don’t know whether the Hercules tire
that you have some feeling that may have been tested
was manufactured by Kumho or any other company?
A_ I did not check that.
Q As I understand it your next progression with
Michelin involved truck tire design?
A Yes, sir, light truck also.
Q And you spent approximately four years in that
[p. 48] position?
A Yes.
Q What years were those?
A Probably somewhere around ’78 to ‘82.
Q What was your specific role in truck tire design?
135
A Well, I did light truck and truck tire. I developed
the - I helped develop the LT series of light truck tires.
And I developed many tread designs and tires in the
pilot. And I worked on the XDA tread pattern, the XM
plus S4, the XDL and there’s one other. There are several
others.
But I worked specifically on pilot sizes and regular
sizes. | did some work on the double-wides and I did
some recapping work toward the end.
* * *
[p. 49] Q Do you hold any patents at all?
A_ I don’t know, that was a different department.
Some of the work — I think Michelin patented some of the
tires I did but I was not involved with that.
Q Is your name on any patent to your knowledge?
A_ Not that I know of.
Q Did any other people have their names on pat-
ents on tires that you worked on?
A_ I know of one case, Daniel Giron had a patent in
France and he was allowed to have his name on that.
Q Do you know whether or not that was a tire that
you helped design?
A It was a tire that I helped work on - I worked on
in the U.S. to help fine tune the design for the U.S. but at
his direction.
Q And you don’t have any dispute with that being
his tire design?
136
A I don’t know how that came to be. Michelin is
very mysterious in some ways.
[p. 50) Q These tires that you worked on during
these four years were all, as | understand it, truck tires or
light tuck tires?
A They were, yes.
Q What is a truck tire as opposed to a light truck
tire?
A Okay, there’s three general classes of tires: pas-
senger, light truck and heavy truck. Okay.
Q Or truck? The last one is sometimes just called
truck tire?
A_ Right, that would be called a truck tire. We called
them heavy truck because in the French our department
is called the polourd department which means heavy-
weight. And cammionette is the light truck tire.
A passenger tire is like a 14- 15- or 16-inch tire. Back
then it was just up to 15 inch but now there are 16 and
even 17-inch tires and some 18-inch performance tires.
But the light truck is kind of a mixing between the
passenger and the truck tires. It’s mainly either 15-inch or
16-inch tires or 16.5-inch tires. And they were used on -
first on commercial vehicles, like UPS trucks, and then of
course we have pickup [p. 51] trucks which use these
also.
And the LT series for Michelin was kind of an area
where they went from - before, they had used mainly
truck tire principles to design their light truck tires. And
137
they were using passenger tire principles to design the
new light truck tires. And I was there during that time.
Heavy truck tires, like your 11R225 or your pilot
sizes, like a 275ADR225 or 245.
Q Heavy truck tires are for what types of vehicles?
Class eight, class seven.
What are those types of vehicles?
Semis, like you see on the road.
Dump trucks or -
Dump trucks.
0 F> 0 > O >
~ big delivery-type trucks?
A Dump trucks are not class eight usually but class
eight is a semi, 18-wheeler, whatever vou cai! it, you
krow, like ye ee on the road.
Q You talked about 15 inch, 16 inch, et cetera. When
you use that inch measurement, what measurement on
the tire is that?
[p. 52] A That is the rim diameter.
Q And there is a difference between truck tire
design principles and passenger tire design principles?
A Yes, there is.
Q And that’s due to the different use of the tires?
A Yes, different pressures.
Q What pressures typically are in passenger tires?
138
35 PSI.
And what in truck tires?
Around a hundred.
What about light truck?
> © 2 2 2
They run from 35 to about 80.
Q And the performance and operation of those
types of tires would be different than the passenger [p.
53] car tires because of the difference in air pressure?
A There’s a slight difference because of the load
that’s put on there but the principles of the new light
truck tires are just the same as passenger tires.
Q With the exception of the pressure in the tire
being different?
A Yes, and you have to design the tire for slightly
higher load sometimes. Some of the heavier passenger
tires have a very high load rating.
Q What was your specific involvement in these
tires? It sounds like from your earlier answer you were
involved mainly in the tread design; is that correct?
A_ No, we were responsible for the whole part of the
tire. We had to either make modifications to existing tires
or we created new tires from scratch.
Q And so that would have included everything
from the inner-liner out to the tread?
A Right, bead design, tread design, belt design.
139
Q Did any of the tires that you designed have a - or
worked in designing, have any type of belt edge ply or
strip?
A We were starting to look at doing that. We [p. 54]
had built some tires with an end cap.
Q And can you define an end cap for me?
A What is usually used, like in this subject tire, is a
zero degree nylon belt across the edge of the belts.
Q What is the purpose of that?
A To reduce separation.
Q How does that reduce separation?
A Well, the original theory was that by using nylon
~ nylon has a unique characteristic in that as you heat it,
it contracts. So the theory was that as the tire heated up
due to use, that this nylon belt over the edge contracted,
stabilizing the edge of the belts.
The edge of the belt is the critical element in design-
ing a radial — steel belted radial. And a lot of companies
have had trouble with separations and there was an
attempt to reduce separation. I mean to reduce separa-
tions.
oe
Q Did any of the tires that you worked on end up
having any reinforcement of any type along the belt
edge?
A That was done in the passenger department [p.
55] while I was there.
140
» * *
Q Did you actually participate in building any
A Yes.
Q Have you ever personally built a tire?
[p. 56] A Yeah.
What type of tire did you build?
Is that the only type that you built?
That’s all I recall. I think I did a light truck one
time but I can’t recall it specifically.
Q
A 1 believe it was an 11R225 truck tire.
Q
A
Q And that wasn’t a passenger tire?
A Well, it was similar but it’s not a passenger tire,
no.
Q During the four years that you were in —_s
design did you do any control failure simulation testing?
A I requested quite of a bit of it, yes.
Q Did you perform any of it yourself?
A No, I had it done by other people.
Q And the tests that you ordered were to assist you
in the design process?
A That's correct.
* * +
[p. 57] Q - by itself on one side of the car as
opposed to a tandem, two tires side by side?
141
A Yeah, I don’t want to use the word car because
it’s a truck.
Q Or truck, yeah.
A Trucks use dual mount tires and we wanted to
see — we had a request by somebody to see, if they only
carried one tire as a spare, how far would they get under
normal loads. You know, it was a trucking company that
we did work with and they asked this question. And we
did the test and I forgot what the [p. 58] answer was, but
Q So that’s where if you had both tires fail on the
double mount could they get by with just one spare
replacing it; is that what you were studying?
A Generally, yes.
—
Q And that would create, I guess, an overload to
that particular tire?
A Yes, it could.
Q What were the results of the test: do you remem-
ber?
A I don’t recall. I believe that we found that if they
used a Michelin tire they had a pretty good — they had a
good margin to make 50 miles or so. They could make 50
miles on a Michelin tire.
Q And this would have been a tire that was brand
new?
A Yes.
Q Could they go longer than 50 miles?
142
A IfI recall they could go a lot farther but we didn’t
want to tell them that they could go much farther than
that.
Q What would be the cause of tire failure of that
overloaded tire when it did fail; do you recall?
[p. 59] A Generally in that type of situation the
Michelin tire would fail in the tread area.
Q What was the failure?
A_ It would have — it would lose its tread.
Q Tread separation?
A Yes, a tread separation as opposed to a belt edge
separation, okay.
Q What's the difference between a tread separation
and a belt edge separation?
A A belt edge separation generally starts between
the two steel belts and progresses to where you lose the
tread and the outer belt. As what happened in this case.
A tread separation, the tread comes apart from the
outer belt. It’s quite a bit more rare type of separation.
Q And what's the cause of a tread separation?
A Generally it’s a manufacturing defect but it can
be caused by abuse.
Q Did you reach any conclusion as to whether the
tread separation that occurred in this Michelin tire that
you worked on and tested was the result of a manufactur-
ing defect or an abuse defect?
143
[p. 60] A It wasn’t a manufacturing defect.
Q How did you isolate that?
A Because we have tested a lot of tires and we
know when and how it fails.
Q We'll get into that a little bit more later. But other
than just saying you know when and how it fails, were
there any objective criteria that you look at that point to
how the tire failed?
A Well, when you’re in a testing procedure you can
quantify things that you can’t do out in the field some-
times. So you know how your tire works, you become
intimately aware of how the tire fails.
Q And that would be in the controlled environment
of the laboratory; is that correct?
A Yes.
Q And in the field there’s a lot more uncertainty as
to what would cause a tire to fail; is that correct?
A Well, there can be, yes.
Q And that’s because there are more variables in
the field you can’t control?
A But generally there are a lot of indicators that can
tell you exactly what happens.
[p. 61] Q But would you agree there are a lot of
variables out in the field that you can’t control and that
makes determination of the failure of a tire that fails in
the field more difficult and uncertain?
A I think that on the test track you can eliminate a
lot of variables by, you know, measuring these things.
144
* * *
[p. 68] A When you’re designing a tire, the tempera-
ture that a tire runs at is very important to your design.
[p. 69] Q Why is that important?
A Because that is a measure of its endurance, how
long it will last. And -
Why is heat so important?
Because it deteriorates the products.
What product?
Well, any of the rubber products.
So heat is the enemy of rubber?
That's right.
> DO > DH > 0
Q And you agree that heat can deteriorate a rubber
product?
A Absolutely. And so every tire design that I came
up with, we did temperature tests. Okay. We ran these
under various conditions, loads, pressures, speeds, every-
thing, and we looked at the temperature, the internal
temperature of the tire, to see that if I had the design
right.
Q And you were trying to get a tire design that
would result in a lower temperature as opposed to a
higher temperature?
A We were trying to make sure that there was not a
dangerous temperature in the tire.
Q What is a dangerous temperature in the tire?
145
[p. 70] A Well, we had certain limits and I don’t
think I can tell you those, but say X number -
Q Go ahead.
A Say some number of temperature.
Q Are there any generally accepted ranges of tem-
perature in the tire design and production field that
would constitute dangerous temperatures?
A There are - that’s a complicated, technical ques-
tion. Okay. I'll try to explain this. When you’re designing
a truck tire which is designed to go through three lives of
tread, you know, the original life, and two recaps, or
whatever, the temperature is very important. Okay. Every
degree that you have under steady state conditions at
normal running, every increase in a degree or so will
affect that on a statistical base.
Will affect what?
The life of the casing.
And by the casing you're talking about what?
The body of the truck.
The structure of the tire?
> © > © > O
Yeah. Truck tires are designed differently than
passenger cars. Okay. You've got a passenger [p. 71] tire
here. Truck tiers are designed to go through three lives, at
least. We had some Michelin tires that went over a million
miles. Okay.
And — but there is two considerations. One is your
temperature and whether you can improve it by changing
146
the structure of the tire by a degree or two. And if there is
a threshold, a limit of the temperature, that you cannot
put the tire out for any reason if it is over that tempera-
ture.
In other words, there’s a no-no level here. And then
beyond that you can change things to improve it incre-
mentally. Now that’s~just one factor in the tire life.
Q Let me stop you right there. What you're saying
is there's a temperature level above which -
A That's correct.
Q - you don’t want to go because that will destroy
the tire?
A That's correct.
Q My question is what is that temperature level? Is
there an accepted temperature level within the tire indus-
try -
A No.
[p. 72] Q - above which you don’t want to go?
A No, there isn’t one number.
Q It depends on the tire?
A It depends on the quality of the rubbers. Rubbers
all have a different problem, I mean, you know threshold
temperature. They all have different stressing due to the
design of the tire. And this is more or less theoretical, if
you would, in a consideration for a passenger tire
because passenger tires, you know, should not have a
separation during their first life.
147
Q Well, for a passenger tire, is there a temperature
level that’s accepted in the industry above which you
don’t want to go?
A_ I assume that there is.
Q Do you know what that is?
A No, I don’t.
Q As I understand it, the temperature tolerance of
any particular tire depends on the rubber chemical for-
mula that’s used?
A That's right.
Q As well as the tire design?
A That's correct.
. * *
[p. 74] Q So any passenger tire, regardless of what-
ever abuse it goes through, should never have a belt
separation or tread separation?
A_ No, it’s a complicated, technical question. So that -
Q Wait a minute, let me make sure I understand
this. Is it or is it not true that any passenger car tire,
regardless of the abuse it goes through, should not expe-
rience a tread or belt separation?
A I think that tires should not go through, with
normal usage, It should not have a separation through
normal usage which involves some abuse, if you want to
define abuse in certain ways. Okay.
148
Some tire companies think that if you hit a rock,
that’s an abuse. But you have to design the tire to with-
stand that abuse. A tire should not fly apart if it’s over-
loaded for a minute or two, you know, or when it goes
right beyond the load inflation table it should not fly
apart immediately after that.
[p. 75] You know, it should be able to withstand high
speed for a short - for a minute or two. For short periods
of time. So the definition of abuse is very difficult.
Q Well, say you have continuous abuse, i.e., under
your definition, running the tire at high speed for a long
period of time. Would you consider that to be abuse?
* ” +
A You'd have to define, you know, the speed and
the load and the conditions.
Q Well, above the speed that the tire was designed
to go. At a high speed or higher than the design speed -
A You can certainly -
Q Let me finish.
A Okay.
Q Let me start over on the question, I think we got a
little bit convoluted here. As I understand your definition
of abuse, abuse would constitute subjecting the tire to
forces for more than a minute or two that [p. 76] the tire
is not designed to be subjected to; is that abuse?
A That's a general definition of abuse, yes.
Q And if a tire is designed to be run at a certain air
pressure, if a person were to drive that tire, operate that
149
tire, below that air pressure for more than a couple of
minutes, that would constitute abuse?
A It could be, yes.
Q You say it could be. What factors would go into
whether it is or it is not?
A The degree
Q What degree would constitute abuse in your
opinion?
A Well, what I’m trying to say is that the general
idea of abuse of a tire as defined among the industry is
that you operate a tire below the load inflation curve.
Q What is the load inflation curve?
A Well, this says that if you have a certain pressure
in the tire, the tire has a certain load rating. In other
words, this is a P205 -
Q Let's not talk about this tire yet, I’ll get [p. 77] to
that in a second. We're talking generalities here.
A You have a-certain load that the tire will with-
stand and operate at a certain pressure. Okay. If you cut
the pressure in half, it can carry only half of the load,
approximately. It’s not exactly but - in other words,
there’s a curve. At each pressure there’s a certain load.
Okay.
Now that is a line and generally it’s considered that if
you're below the line you have abused the tire. Now the
tire shouldn’t fall apart immediately if it goes below the
line for a couple of minutes, you know, or even a couple
of days or whatever. It depends on how far below you
150
are, how far below the line you are, whether a tire has
been significantly abused.
* * *
[p. 78] BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q I want to focus now on the five years listed in
your resume that you were involved in truck tire adher-
ence and endurance testing while at Michelin. Do you
remember what years those were?
A_ I believe ‘82 to ’87 approximately.
Q And what do you mean by tire adherence and
endurance testing?
A We had - we were measuring the braking force
[p. 79] of a tire.
Q How long it takes the tire to slow down when
you apply the brakes?
A Essentially, yeah.
Q_ So that’s concerned with co-efficient of friction of
that tire as opposed to the various different pavement
interfaces?
A Exactly, water situations.
Q What was your specific role in those tests?
A 1 was responsible for test quality. I did machine
studies, tire studies and pavement studies.
Q To try to make sure that all the necessary controls
were in place, that you got accurate and valid test results?
A That's right.
151
~
What type of tires did you test?
Truck and light truck tires.
Did you test any passenger tires?
They were being tested at the place.
Did you test them?
I did at times, but that was not my specific role.
> O 2? © > ©
Q Did you ever test any, in this phase, did you
[p. 80] ever test any Hercules tires?
A I don’t specifically recall -
Q Did you during this -
A -— that I did.
Q - phase, this five years, ‘82 to ‘87, did you ever
test any Kumho manufactured tires?
A I don’t recall.
Q Can you describe for me how you conduct a tire
adherence and endurance test?
A Well, we have machines that run the tire at a
certain load and pressure and then they go through a
braking cycle on a test track and the forces are measured.
Q So this was actually done on a track as opposed
to in the laboratory on a dynamometer?
A Oh, yes.
Q And what were you measuring?
A The - essentially the co-efficient of friction of the
tire.
152
Q What different variables did you change to see
how the tire reacted under those variables?
A The majority of the test involved either the tread
design or the tread rubber.
[p. 81]Q And then I guess you tested it on different
types of pavement as well?
A Exactly.
Q And different types of pavement wetness, you
know, very wet as opposed to -
A Yes.
Q - dry, that sort of thing?
A Yes.
Q During this phase, these five years, did you do
any overload tests?
A The tire — the adherence was measured at differ-
ent loads, yes.
Q Were any of the loads overload situations for the
particular tire at that air pressure?
A Some of them were but mostly not.
Q And again the purpose of that test was not to see
whether the tire failed at that overload but to see how it
affected the co-efficient of friction and the braking dis-
tance of that tire under those specific circumstances?
A Yes.
Q And was all this again used primarily for the
purpose of design input?
153
[p. 82] A Yes,
[p. 84] Q Depending upon the tread depth?
A Depending upon the tread depth. And yet the
cut-off line that the industry has decided is */22 of an
inch?
A That's right.
Q Is that for all types of tire, truck, light truck and
passenger?
A The Feds have designated 2/32 as the minimum for
truck tires on drive and trailer axles but */:2 for steering
axles.
Q And that’s for trucks?
A For truck tires only.
Q What about for passenger?
[p. 85] A Passenger, the only thing the Feds say in
the Federal Code of Regulations is that you put wear bars
that are ?/x2 thick. They allow the states to write a law
saying that the tire is illegal if it is used below 7/2, and
only about half the states in the U.S. have any type of
regulation on the books talking about tread depth of
passenger tires.
154
Q Do you know whether Alabama is one such state?
A. As far as I know Alabama is a state that has that
but it is not enforced in any state rigorously except that if
you have an accident and someone sees a bald tire, they
will write you up for it.
Q Do you know what Alabama’s specific regulation
or law in that regard says?
A It’s been — I do not know the specific language.
Q What is you general understanding of what it
says?
A Well, there’s several ways of defining it. Truck
tires use the language saying that if any tread groove is
below ?/:2, then the tire shall not be used.
Passenger sometimes have where they say if you
measure it at like 12 points and a certain percentage
[p. 86] of those are below it — I don’t know what Ala-
bama’s language is specifically.
* * *
[p. 88] Q. And then you say that you installed and
verified light truck tire tests hub in vehicle.
A Yes.
Q What are you talking about there?
A We had a machine that had hubs. It was essen-
tially a semi-trailer that had positions in the center of it, a
hub, an instrumented hub, or three of them, that would
load a tire up in the center and it would do the braking
test or temperature test.
155
And when I got the machine it didn’t have the light
hub - light tire - light truck tire test hub and I put that in
and verified it.
Q So that was again dealing with the tire adherence
and endurance testing?
A That's mainly adherence.
[p. 89] Q You wanted to make certain that any tires
tested on that hub, in using that equipment, would pro-
duce results that were accurate; is that correct?
A That's right, yes. You have variation in all pro-
cesses and we’re trying to reduce the machine variation
to a minimum.
Q And those variations in the machine processes
and in machines would also apply to various automobiles
and cars on which tires are installed; is that correct?
A Yeah.
Q And obviously when a tire is installed on those in
the real world you can’t control those variations; the tire
manufacturer cannot.
A Of course not.
Q And those can all affect how a tire performs and
the conditions to which it’s subjected in the real world?
A Sure.
Q. Your last sentence in that five-year period of
Michelin states that you taught SPC course to engineers
and operator.
A. Yes, sir.
156
Q. What are you talking about there?
[p. 90] A. SPC stands for statistical process control.
Q. What is that?
A. It’s a method of statistics that is used by - it was
used by the Japanese to improve their quality after World
War II. It was taught by an American, I can’t remember
his name, Denning - Demming, who died last year, |
believe. One of the great engineers in our history.
And he taught them how to improve their processes
using SPC techniques and that’s the reason their quality
was so high in the ‘80s compared to the U.S. automotive
products.
Q. So this_is a quality control method; is that cor-
rect?
A. Yeah, it’s a statistical method of maintaining
quality in a process.
Q. Did Michelin follow that?
A. They tried, yes, sir.
* * *
[p. 92} Q And then once a tire failed what did you
do to follow up on the test?
A Well, sometimes the tire was cut so that I could
evaluate the test. The cleavage test which developed belt
edge separation, we tried to stop right before the tread
came off. And then we took the tire to another depart-
ment that cut it apart and then we could look at that after
it had been decorticated.
157
Q How could you tell that the belt edge was about
to come off so that you could stop the test?
A My drivers were trained to develop - to sense a
certain type of vibration that occurred right immediately
before the tread came off.
Q Is there any other indication or physical signal
that’s transmitted from the tire to the vehicle that can be
picked up by a driver before a belt or tread separates?
A Yes.
Q And what is that?
[p. 93] A The - the tire felt oily.
What does that mean?
It means it had less lateral force, it felt squirrelly.
Q
A
Q When you say less lateral force -
A Yes.
Q - you're talking about -
A
You’re going around a corner and it feels slipp-
ery.
Side to side?
Yeah.
Well, there are visual indications.
What are those?
Q
A
Q Anything else?
A
Q
A You see the tread lift up.
158
Q Bubbles?
A Yes, right before it comes off.
Q Anything else?
A Those are the major ones.
Q Is there any change in the noise level of the tire?
A Not on a truck tire.
3 Q_ Well, in the test you were doing with truck [p. 94]
tires —
A Yes. "
Q - would the same statements be true of pas-
senger tires?
A Pretty much.
Q What would the differences be?
A The differences are that truck tires, once it starts
it proceeds much more rapidly than a passenger tire.
Q Soa passenger tire would take a longer period of
time -
A Somewhat -
Q_ - to develop a separation?
A - longer time, yes.
+ + *
[p. 98] Q Also I think you said that there was some
physical appearance differences in a tire that had a tread
separation going on as opposed to one that did not?
159
Yes.
Is that true with passenger tires as well?
> O >
Yes.
Q What would those physical appearance [p. 99]
differences be?
A You have a lifting of the tread. In other words,
the tread, particularly when it’s hot, will have a different
appearance. And this cun be shown - there’s two physical
appearances. One is a lifting of the tread, which I find
very hard to see but there are tests you can do to find -
find that. I refer you to the recapper’s manual, how they
do it, how they test it when they’re about to recap a tire.
And there aiso can be abnormal wear.
Q And abnormal wear being what?
A Generally under a separation the tire will wear
faster than in other places. You will have wear that is
uneven around the tire or you can have one side of the
tire worn faster than the other.
* * *
[p. 100} Q Do you have any knowledge or experi-
ence — well, I know you have experience, but do you have
any knowledge about the tests required under the United
States federal regulations to be conducted on tires?
A The CFR 49?
Q Yes. Are those the only ones you are aware of?
A The only ones I recall right now. I have to go
through the book every now and then to refresh my
memory.
160
Q Are those the tests that are sometime called the
Section 109 test?
A Yeah, DOT 109, used to be call.
Q Other than the DOT 109 test, are you aware of
any tests that are required of manufacturers of tires?
A I'm not sure which segments these things are in
anymore because as far as I know the DOT 109 was
incorporated into CFR 49.
But the test generally, there used to be a plunger test,
there used to be a bead seating test, there used to be a -
and then there’s the three tests that do with the - the
uniform quality grading system, [p. 101] which is one is
the temperature test, the traction test and the wear test.
The temperature test is the, as I mentioned before, is
an old test that has been incorporated in the tire quality
grading system.
Q Do you consider yourself to be an expert in that
area as to current regulations?
A Ido not remember the exact things so - I know
what they do and I know what they are and I know more
than the average person about it, so - and I’ve done these
tests, you know, most of the tests I’ve been involved with,
the development of some of the tests within my company.
So, yes, I think I’m an expert on it. But I can’t tell you the
exact test method right now without going back to my
book on some of these.
[p. 103] Q As I understand your experience in this
area, you don’t have any experience with doing the
161
mechanics of registering and stamping the DOT number
and all that on there, rather your experience with these
DOT requirements of these various tests is in having had
[p. 104] performed them when you were with Michelin; is
that correct?
A That's correct.
Q And so when you say you hold yourself out as an
expert in this area, you're saying that you've done these
tests before and you can look it up in the book, even
though you don’t remember the specifics of it right now,
you could look them up in the book and you could go out
there and set up a test procedure to accomplish what's
required; is that correct?
A Yes.
[p. 105] Q Are there any, beyond the requirements
of the federal government, are there any industry stan-
dards in the United States tire industry that are suggested
with [p. 106] respect to testing of tires?
A Well, I don’t know of any besides the size test,
you know.
Q What is the size test?
A Well, there is a standard that is put out by the
Tire and Rim Association that gives load inflation tables
and size tables. In other words, there’s a certain toler-
ance, if you put out a P205/75R14 or something like that,
then there’s a certain size requirement and a tolerance for
that size.
162
Q And this is a standard published by the Tire and
Rim Association?
A Yes.
Q Do you know what that specific standard is?
A_ I have some copies of it in my file and I have
many of their books.
Q Are there any other standards put out by the Tire
and Rim Association with respect to testing of tires?
A The Tire and Rim Association just puts out a
standard that the tire, as I understand, the tire people
certify that their tire will meet this load-carrying capacity.
What - there’s two purposes, [p. 107] two general pur-
poses for the Tire and Rim Association; that is, if you
have a certain tire size like a P205, you get a tire of a
certain size and a tire that carries a certain load at a
certain pressure.
Q So those are the only two standards that you're
aware of put out by the Tire and Rim Association?
A Those are the only ones I’m really familiar with.
Q And the first such standard is that if you label
your tire a certain size tire, it needs to meet certain
dimensional criteria so you can match it up with a rim or
whatever that’s appropriate for that size tire?
A That's correct.
Q And the second such standard deals with the
load-carrying capacity of a tire; if you have a tire that is
of a certain dimension or type then the load-carrying
capacity should be within these minimum limits?
163
A That's right.
Q Let me ask this, this may be a way to eliminate
this whole line. Are you making any [p. 108] criticism at
all of the tire at issue in this case, the Kumho Superior XII
that was on the accident vehicle with respect to any of
these Tire and Rim Association standards that you've just
mentioned?
A No.
Q So you don’t believe that’s an issue in this case?
A No, not directly.
Q Well, you said not directly; what do you mean by
not directly?
A Well, I don’t - I can’t eliminate a certain design
problem in my analysis of the tire. And that may affect
whether this one certifying it, but I cannot determine
whether it is certifiable by the Tire and Rim Association.
So no, the answer is no.
Q So the answer to the question of whether you
have any criticism of the tire at issue in this case with
respect to failure to meet the Tire and Rim Association
standard is that no, you do not have any criticism of the
tire at issue in this case under those standards?
A That's correct.
Q Since you have been involved in litigation [p. 109]
support or consulting, which I understand started when you
went to work with SEA in 1987; is that correct?
A That's correct.
164
Q Have you ever done any controlled failure sim-
ulation testing of tires?
A No.
Q So the last time you did any controlled failure
simulation testing of tires was when you were with
Michelin?
A That's correct.
Q Have you done any testing of tires since you left
Michelin?
A I have done some testing, yes.
Q What tests have you done since you left Mich-
elin?
A Well, primarily I did a study of the leakage
through nail holes of tires.
Q Was that test for a particular lawsuit?
A Those tests were, yes, sir. I've done it several
times. And there have been many leakage tests with bad
rims that I’ve done.
* 2 *
[p. 110) Q What is the purpose of the nail hole
leakage test?
A_ I’ve had several tires that have had nail holes or
improper patches and I was trying to determine the
amount of leakage. And I’ve had several tires that had
rims that for some reason did not leak, and testing the
leakage across the bead if there was bead damage.
165
Q In the nail hole leakage test what you're trying to
do is quantify the amount of air that escapes from the tire
in a given period of time?
A Yes.
Q In the other leakage test where you were looking
at the bead rim interface, you were trying to determine
the quantity of air that leaked from that point of the tire
during a certain period of time?
A First determine if it leaked and secondly to quan-
tify it.
Q How would you go about doing a nail hole leak-
age test as you described it?
[p. 111] A You inflate the tire. You come back a
week later in time, you know, measure the pressure and
then come back a week later and see the pressure.
Q So you determine the amount of air that’s
escaped by measuring the internal pressure of the tire?
A Yes.
Q How can you use that to reach a quantity of air
that’s escaped?
A Well, you just - the quantity of air that has
escaped is really not the number you’ re asking for, it’s the
reduction of pressure. Unfortunately there’s a lot of acci-
dents that occur because there are nail holes that cause
slow leaks and people don’t notice it. And five or six
weeks later - you know, they may be putting air in every
month or something like that and then they change their
- conditions or the leakage increases and they get out and
they have a problem.
166
The last case I had, we had two kids die because they
were coming back and the tire on the back had gone to a
low pressure and they had a lane change and they essen-
tially lost control and overturned and perished.
Q So nail hole leakage is a dangerous thing for
{p. 112] a tire?
A Can be.
Q Under what circumstances can it be?
A Well, if the -
MR. JACKSON: Did you say can or can’t?
MR. BABINGTON: Can.
THE WITNESS: Can. Okay, tubeless tires are
remarkably resistant to losing air pressure compared to
tube type tires. So you can have a slow leak and people
may add air every month or something like that and then
they may forget it or something like that and it goes
down to below the line on the load inflation table or it
just makes the handling squirrelly.
* * .
[p. 113] Q Let me ask you this, do you agree that
even a nail hole that appears to be patched correctly can
still leak? I mean visually you can’t always determine if a
patch leaks or not.
A_ I think you can.
Q Just by looking at the patch?
A Just by testing the patch. Looking at the patch
and determining whether it’s still stuck around the edges.
167
Q And that visual test of just looking at the patch is
a hundred percent reliable in your opinion?
A Well, that and other indications.
Q What are the other indications?
A Well, if you’re trying to blame the nail hole on a
separation there would be polishing around the nail hole
to show that the leakage did cause the separation.
* * .
[p. 115] Q You haven’t done any of those types of
tests that you just described, deceleration test or the
handling test, in this particular case?
A Oh, no.
[p. 116] BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q. I want to talk about now your time at SEA.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. As I understand what SEA is, it’s a consulting
firm that does litigation support and litigation consulting
services?
A. Some of what they do is that. Most of what they
do is that, yes, sir.
Q. And that is what you did while you were there;
is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many times have you testified in court
would you say?
168
A. Approximately 18.
Q. And how many -
[p. 117] MR. HERLONG: 18?
THE WITNESS: 18.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q. And how many times have you testified in depo-
sition?
A. Approximately 35.
Q. And were most of those while you were with
SEA?
A. Yes.
Q. All the times that you've testified in deposition
or in court, have those been as an expert witness?
A. Yes.
Q. What areas of specialty have you held yourself
out as a specialist in?
A. Ido vehicle - vehicular accident reconstruction. I
do examinations of brakes and steering systems. I’ve
done heating equipment.
Q. Heating as related to a car or -
A. Mainly house heating and factory heating sys-
tems. Generally we have the vehicle accident reconstruc-
tion, the tire failure analysis and other questions having
to do with design or failure analysis, [p. 118] as the result
of being a mechanical engineer. That's just general topics.
instead of listing specifically, we'll start with the general.
169
Q. In your resume here under SEA you state back-
ground in tire design, tire testing, vehicular brakes, statis-
tical analysis, polymer plants, oil field equipment, liquid
and natural gas equipment and machine design.
A. Yes.
Q. Are those all areas in which you've testified or
held yourself out as an expert?
A. I've not testified in some of those areas yet.
Q. Have you held yourself out as an expert in those
areas?
A. Yes.
* * *
[p. 124] Q. Was the work that you did while you
were at SEA primarily for the defendant or the company
whose [p. 125] product was under attack or was it for the
plaintiff?
A. I did some of both, but I would say it was
probably mostly defendant - defense work. I represented
several companies, auto companies and manufacturing
companies in certain cases.
Q. What companies were those that you repre-
sented?
A. American Honda, General Tire, J.T. Tire. I’ve
worked for Ford. I’ve worked for several Toyota dealers.
I’ve worked against Mazda, a Mazda dealer. I’ve worked
against a — can’t remember.
Q. But lots of different manufacturers?
170
A. Yes.
Q. Can you give me a ratio percentage wise of how
much of your work at SEA was for defendant as opposed
to plaintiff?
A. I don’t keep statistics on that and — but I think
that more than 50 percent was what you would call
defense work.
* * *
[p. 129] Q Has most of the work that you’ve done
since you've gone to work for George R. Edwards, Inc.
been in the area of tire failure analysis or tire design as
opposed to accident reconstruction?
A Yes.
Q Can you quantify the percentage that is tire
related as opposed to accident reconstruction related?
A It would probably have to be 95 percent, proba-
bly.
Q 95 percent tires?
A Yes.
Q And of that 95 percent that’s related to tires how
much of that is where George R. Edwards, Inc. is
employed by the plaintiff?
[p. 130] A_ I think it’s all of them that I’ve worked
on.
Q You seem to have gone from a firm that worked
predominantly for the defendant to one that now works
predominantly for the plaintiff; is there any reason for the
switch?
171
A No reason for it except that tire companies, when
you work for the plaintiff once, you don’t work for tire
companies anymore. So you have to choose a path or one
way or the other.
Q Why did you choose the plaintiffs’ side?
A Well, I had done some plaintiff work and I don’t
think I was going to get any — the main reason I’m going
with George Edwards is I kind of want to work for
myself. So I think that, you know, I want to work with
George Edwards and I want to work for myself after he
retires.
Q Has he indicated he’s going to retire?
A. Well, he thinks he wants to but I don’t think he'll
ever do it.
Q You said that once you worked against a tire
manufacturer that other tire manufacturers won’t hire
you as a consultant or expert to work for them. Did I hear
you say that correctly?
[p. 131] A That seems to be what happens.
Q Did anyone ever tell you that?
A They - it has been told to me by many people but
I don’t know if any of those were tire companies.
Q Did George Edwards tell you that?
A Well, he’s one of the people that says that, yes.
Q No one from Kumho or Hercules ever told you
that, did they?
A No.
172
Q And so far as you know, no one from a tire
manufacturer or designer or seller has ever told you that?
A I’ve been questioned about that and don’t
remember the exact wording, but one manufacturer, you
know, said you've got to clear that up whether you've got
a case against us or not before we'll hire you as a defense
guy.
Q So you had a case against that particular tire
manufacturer and then they were asking you to get
involved representing them?
A Yes.
Q And they perceived that as a conflict where [p.
132] you were working for someone suing them, where
they couldn’t necessarily hire you to work for them at
that same time?
A_ There’s always the danger of a conflict of inter-
ests if you do split. But they don’t want to give you
credibility.
Q I’m not talking about the conflict of interest situa-
tion, it sounds like you were saying there’s some type of
conspiracy where tire companies won't hire somebody if
they work for a plaintiff criticizing a tire.
A I think it’s generally agreed in this industry that’s
what happens, but I’m not trying to imply there is a
conspiracy.
Q Do you have any evidence to support what you
said?
173
A Well, there was one tire company that asked me
very carefully about whether I had anything against
them.
Q That was in a conflict situation I thought we
established.
A Well, it was a different case, so -
Q Well, it was a different case but you were [p. 133]
testifying in that case against that same tire company; is
that correct?
A_ I would be an expert against — on the plaintiff's
side against them, yes.
Q Did it involve the same tire, type of tire?
A Yes.
Q Don’t you agree that would be a conflict where
you were taking the position for the plaintiff in one case,
criticizing the tire, where that tire company couldn’t ask
you to represent it or be involved with it on that same
exact tire?
A_ I think I would like to work that way, but I don’t
think tire companies would like that. It could be a conflict
if you're in the same type of tire if they give you informa-
tion that you turned around and used against them.
Q That would be a big risk of that type of arrange-
ment, wouldn’t it?
A I think so.
Q And do you have any reason to believe that the
tire manufacturer who you're talking about had anything
174
in mind other than that type of a risk in refusing to
employ you?
[p. 134] A_ I don’t know.
Q You didn’t have any such discussions with them?
A No.
Q And you don’t have any evidence of any conspir-
acy among tire makers or sellers or manufacturers to not
hire experts who testify for plaintiffs in tire cases?
A_ No, it’s just that every expert in the business is on
one side or the other it seems like after awhile.
Q What is that based on?
A Just based on what people tell me and what I've
observed.
Q How many cases are you working on right now
for George R. Edwards, Inc. that involve tire failure anal-
ysis or that are tire related in any respect?
A I’m not sure I can give you an exact number.
Q Ballpark?
A Probably 25.
Q And on all those cases you're working for the
plaintiff?
A All that I can recall.
* * *
[p. 172] Q Do you have any patents or hold any
patents?
175
A No.
* * *
[p. 176] Q You're not a chemical engineer; is that
correct?
A That's correct.
Q And you don’t hold yourself out as an expert in
that field?
A No.
Q You've never testified before as a chemical
expert?
A No.
[p. 177] Q You don’t have any publications in that
field; is that correct?
A Right. There are chemical changes that occur in
tires in rare cases that I would know something about,
but I’m not a chemist. I’ve had chemical courses, many
chemical courses in school, so | know more than the
average person. But I’m not going to tell you — I’m not
going to be a chemical engineering expert or chemist
expert, except as where they may come to tires, | may
have to talk about a chemical change but I won't tell you
exactly about it, what it is, I don’t think I can.
[p. 182] Q Has any court ever refused to accept you
as an expert?
A No.
176
Q So it would be fair to say that a hundred percent
of your income is derived from work testifying in law-
suits or working on cases that are being considered with
respect to whether a lawsuit should be filed?
[p. 183] A I believe that is true. I would like to say
there are some times we are consulted by people who
want to know what happened in an accident or to a tire
and they have no intention of suing anybody. And there
is that type of work. I don’t know how to quantify that,
though.
Q Do you have any publications in any field?
A I have a master’s thesis but no publications.
* * *
[p. 184] Q You said you have some publications
currently in the works. What are those publications?
A Well, they’re tire related or vehicle handling
related.
Q Are these going to be published in any scientific
or journal related to the tire industry?
A They probably will be published in SAE, if they
ever get beyond the stage they are in now?
Q What is the SAE?
A Society of Automotive Engineers.
Q_ Do you know what the thesis of your articles are?
177
A One of them has to do with tire uniformity as
how it applies to handling. That's just in the discussion
phase w''> a professor at the University of Illinois.
Q You're collaborating with him on that article?
A Yes.
Q What is his name?
[p. 185] A Dan Metz.
Q And tire uniformity, does that refer to tire tread
uniformity as opposed to some other part of the tire?
A Mainly casing uniformity.
Interior casing?
Yeah.
Structure?
> © >
Uniformity has two meanings, okay. One is how
alike the tire is in construction from piece to piece, but
uniformity to tire guys also means the way it - whether it
has - whether it’s balanced properly or whether it has
radial force or lateral force variation.
I know that’s a big word but when you roll a tire it
may have different forces against the ground or it may
have different radiuses. You know, if you roll it freely it
may go up and down and bounce. And this is something
that tire manufacturers control very closely.
Q What is the conclusion that you and he are reach-
ing as a result of whatever research or testing you're
doing in that?
178
A_ I guess we’re in the talking stage right now [p.
186] but we're just trying to show that normal perfor-
mance tires may have a lateral force bias that is higher
than anybody thinks. And, you know, it’s - it has an
effect on handling as to where - it’s based on where.
I'm working on some cases for one of the manufac-
turers having to do with wear and I’m working against a
manufacturer for a wear case. And this was brought
about by the fact that performance tires have special
quantities that are built into them that are unlike a nor-
mal passenger tire. And this may affect wear. It may
affect -
* * *
[p. 187] Q So ifI understand, the paper that you're
working on or in the talking stage of working on, it
involves primarily the issue of wear of high performance
type tires and the factors that would influence that?
A Yes.
* + *
[p. 189] Q And you haven’t made any publications
in the tire field?
A That’s correct, I worked for a secret company for
ten years and they didn’t want anything published.
Q That's Michelin?
A_ That's Michelin.
* * +
[p. 190) Q What is your arrangement with George
R. Edwards, Inc. or George R. Edwards the individual?
179
A Well, right now I’m a salaried employee.
Q And do you have any option about buying out
his company or becoming a partner or equity owner at
some point?
A There may be a possibility of that in the future.
Q Have you specifically talked about that with him?
A We have talked about it but the details don’t need
to be published right now.
Q Well, are there any agreements?
A There are agreements but they’re very loose right
now.
Q Handshake agreements?
[p. 191] A More or less, yes.
* * *
But if you do have any agreements with Edwards, I
think, you know, given the fact that you're testifying in
this -ase on behalf of George R. Edwards, Inc. I think I’m
entitle to know about that.
A Well, he is paying me a salary. That could last for
a very long time. He could hire someone else [p. 192] to
be my boss when he retires. I could be the boss. It
depends on how things work out in the next year or so.
Q When you say how things work out, does that
mean how the money works out or how y’all get along or
what?
A Well, I tell you, it depends on whether I have any
business sense, probably.
180
* * ”
[p. 195] Q Have you inspected the van in this case?
A_ I have just seen photographs, I have not seen the
van.
* * +
[p. 196] Q Have you seen and inspected the Kumho
or Hercules Superior XII at issue in this case?
A Yes.
Q When did you first see that tire?
A This morning.
Q So the first time that you had an opportunity to
see the tire in person was this morning; is that [p. 197]
correct?
A Yes, that’s correct.
Q And where were you?
A Mr. Jackson’s office.
Q
How long did you have an opportunity to look at
it? |
A An hour or so.
Q And what did you do?
A_ I looked at it to see if the photographs that I'd
seen of the tire represented the tire.
Q When had you seen photographs?
A For a month or two.
181
About a month prior to today?
Yes, month or two.
Where were those photographs located?
> O PF OD
In our file in Louisville.
Q Did you see anything different in the tire that you
didn’t see on the photographs?
A No.
Q Do you have any change in anything you stated
on Defendants’ Exhibit 2 as a result of seeing the tire in
person?
A No.
[p. 198] Q We'll go over that in more detail, but
would you agree that Defendants’ Exhibit 2 was prepared
before today?
A Generally, yes. Not having read it in detail but -
Q Well, the date that is on Defendants’ Exhibit 2 is
March 3, 1995; is that correct?
A Yes.
Q And that’s before today?
A Yes.
Q And that’s before you saw the tire?
A Yes.
Q Did you have any input into preparing Defen-
ants’
d Exhibit 2?
182
A_ I don’t recall.
Q You don’t remember whether or not you partici-
pated in preparing Defendants’ Exhibit 2?
A_ I don’t recall.
We'll get into that in a second.
Q
A Yeah.
Q Have you seen or inspected the accident scene?
A_ No, I’ve just seen photographs.
Q Have you seen or inspected the other tires [p. 199]
that were on the vehicle at the time of the accident?
Yes, I have.
When did you first do that?
This morning.
A
Q
A
Q How long did you look at those tires?
A I looked at them during the hour period.
Q Had you seen photographs of those previously?
A Yes, I have.
Q Did you see anything in person this morning that
you didn’t note previously in the photographs?
183
A No.
Q Is there any change to any of the opinions
expressed on Defendants’ Exhibit 2 as a result of seeing
those other tires in person this morning?
A No.
* * *
[p. 200] Q Do you agree at some point in time a tire
will need to be replaced?
A Yes.
Q Tires don’t last forever?
A That's correct.
Q Tires will become unserviceable at some point
[p. 201] in time?
A That's correct.
Q Can you identify for us all the different reasons
or ways that a tire can become unserviceable?
A Yes.
Q Okay.
A Well, tread can wear out.
Q All right.
A Sometimes it can be recapped, sometimes it can’t.
Or the carcass doesn’t have the fatigue strength to last. It
can have a catastrophic failure by hitting something like a
big rock or a Volkswagen or something like that that
causes it to rupture.
184
Q Anything else?
A Well, generally it’s either fracture strength or
fatigue strength that kills a tire.
Q What do you mean by fracture strength?
A_ It means it hits something and breaks it to where
it can’t be repaired or it fatigues which means it wears
out internally.
Q And I suppose it could be a combination of the
two?
A_ It can be.
[p. 202) Q And you've seen that before in your
experience?
A Yeah, it’s very hard to define in engineering
terms but there’s been a lot of people that try to define
those things.
Q When you say it’s very hard to define, you're
talking about the situation where a tire is subject to both
fracture forces and becomes fatigued, it’s very hard to say
what part is due to the fatigue and what part is due to the
fracture?
A Well, there are a lot of forces that hit a tire and do
not cause a fracture but, you know, it is believed that they
may affect the fatigue strength.
Q Let me see if I can put that in a term that I
understand it. I think I understand what you're saying.
You’re saying that a tire may hit something, it might not
be a sufficient hit to destroy it in that moment but that it
185
can reduce the strength of the tire so that the tire wears
out before it would otherwise have worn out?
A Well, wear out is a bad word but -
Q Well, the tire will become unserviceable before it -
[p. 203] A As a tire designer you do - you design
your carcass to last a certain number of miles. And then
you have to put strength in there to have a certain
amount of reasonable impacts. It’s very hard to define
that. The only way to do it is to put them out there and
see how long they last under real world situations. If they
don’t last long enough, then you build a stronger tire.
Q What you were saying earlier is that you can
have a fracture force and a fatigue problem with a tire
that combines to cause it to come out of service. Do you
agree with that?
A lam trying to say that there is a fracture failure
which is a catastrophic failure caused by a one-time
event. Okay?
Q Okay.
A You hit something that it can’t handle, that’s a
fracture failure, okay. Most of the other types of failures
would be a combination - I mean would be a type of
fatigue failure. The fatigue loading that you have is what
I’m saying is hard to define.
You have normal loading which is if you ran a tire
forever and forever it would fail, just if it [p. 204] never
hit anything. A lot of tires fail because they hit something
that causes a fracture failure and they go out of service
right then. And they cannot be repaired. Okay.
186
And then fatigue failure, tires fail because of fatigue
failure. And that can involve the whole spectrum of what
can cause it. It can be designed to a low mileage due to
bad materials or cheap materials or whatever you want to
say. Or it can have a service life that is too heavy for it, or
something like that, or too close to the limit. It's have
hard to define that.
Q Why is that hard to define?
A Well, because the best way to do that is to send
them out under real world conditions and monitor your
results and see if there is an unacceptable failure, which
is generally, you know, zero during the first life of the
passenger tire and a certain percentage for truck tires.
Q Other than how a tire may react under the real
world, is there any other way to test that?
A Well, all the testing that is done in a lab is a way
to predict that or the test track or a machine [p. 205] test
and everything is a way to predict the life of a tire out in
the real world.
In other words, if you run a certain test and your new
tire, your candidate tire, your prototype tire lasts better
than the one that you’ve got in production at the time,
then ~ on a certain machine test, then you hope that when
you put it out in the real world that that type of experi-
ence that you get on the machine translates to real world
improvements.
Q But there’s no guarantee of that?
A There’s no guarantee.
187
Q And that’s an area that’s fraught with a lot of
uncertainty because you can’t duplicate the real world in
a laboratory, can you?
A Well, you can’t. I happen to feel that testing is a -
if it is done correctly, is a very, very good way of doing
things if you do it reasonably, like Michelin does.
And I think they do everything very well. You know,
I've said that they have engineers that are very high level
that watch the quality of the tests and they help develop
tests that are reasonable. But there is uncertainty in
everything that you do, something like [p. 206] that, so -
Q Okay. Are there any other reasons why tires will
become unserviceable, other than I think you’ve men-
tioned catastrophic failure or fracture strength failure and
then a failure due to fatigue strength and then also that
the tread will wear out.
[p. 206] A Well, anything can cause the fatigue
strength to be reduced. You know, abuse is one. If the tire
is run flat, it’s not going to last very long, it’s going to
have irreparable damage.
Q Would you agree that exposure to certain types of
«. omicals, especially petroleum products, can cause tires
to come out of service?
A Yes, that occurs mainly on truck tires where you
have an axle that leaks and you can have petroleum -
softening of the rubber.
Q Weathering of the rubber?
A Yes, ozone cracking.
188
Q Or just leaving a tire parked in a stationary posi-
tion for a long time, that can result in premature weather-
ing; is that right?
A Generally that produces a stress on the tire that
can allow ozone cracking to progress. The [p. 207] mecha-
nism is whi : n arguing about, but what you’re saying is
true but the semantics of it are -
Q Misalignment or failure to properly balance the
wheels on the vehicle on which the tires are located, can
that affect the service life of a tire?
A That can generally affect the tread wear very
drastically.
Q Poor maintenance can affect the service life of a
tire?
A Yes.
Q If the tire is punctured or cut, that can affect the
service life of the tire?
A It can.
Q I think you've already stated that bruises and
impacts, other types of fractures that the tire is subject to,
affect the service life; is that correct?
It can. It can end it very quickly?
Skid damage, can that affect it?
Yes, it can.
Are you familiar with the term projection cuts?
No.
> O > DOD >
189
Q Where some part of the vehicle projects onto [p.
208] the tire. Can that affect the tire?
A Certainly.
Q Service life?
A Certainly.
Q That would be a type of an abrasion, | guess, to
the tire; is that correct?
A Can be.
Q Are you familiar with the term spin cuts?
A Yes.
Q What does that mean to you?
A Means where the tire is spun and it loses traction
and it spins against a surface and usually forms circum-
ferential cuts in the tire.
Q That can affect the service life of a tire?
A Yes, it can.
Q Bad valves in the tire, can that affect — bad
valves?
A Valves?
Q Valves.
A The valve stem?
Q Yeah, that can affect the service life of the tire; is
that correct?
A That can cause the tire to deflate, yes.
190
[p. 209] Q A damaged rim or wheel can affect the
service life of a tire?
A Yes.
Q If the bead on the tire is torn or kinked or dis-
torted in any way that can affect service life?
A Yes, it can.
Overloading can affect service life?
Of course.
Low inflation can affect service life?
> O > 0
Yes.
Q I mean that’s a list of some of the factors in the
real word that can affect the service life of a tire: is that
correct?
A Certainly.
Q Do you agree that once rubber receives an injury
that it doesn’t heal itself like your skin would?
A Generally that is true.
Q That injury to rubber is cumulative, do you agree
with that statement?
A In a sense, yes.
Q That once it gets hurt, and if it receives hurt
again, it builds on the prior injury?
[p. 210] A. Generally the way it happens, yes.
Q Do you agree that there are numerous reasons
that tires become unserviceable that are not the result of a
design or manufacturing defect?
191
A True.
Q And we’ve gone over some of those in prior
questions but can you think of any others that I haven't
mentioned?
A Well, I’ve seen a lot of tires that were sabotaged,
you know, cut.
Q Purposely cut with a knife or something?
A Purposely cut, yes.
Q Anything else?
A That's a pretty comprehensive list, I think.
Q Do you have any opinion about when a tire
should be taken out of sérvice due to tread wear?
A I have - the 2/x is probably reasonable from an
economic sense is to take it off at 2/32 Or if there is an area
that has been skid damaged to where part of the tire is
below 2/22 and the rest of it is good or if there is very, very
bad alignment wear, I would not keep that tire on.
Q So as I understand the latter part of your [p. 211]
answer there, even though part of the tire may have 2/:2
tread, if another part of the tire is below 7/2 tread, you
would still think that tire should be taken out of service?
A Yeah, I’m kind of a fanatic about that. I would
like to see the wear bars even thicker, but -
Q More than 2/22?
A More than 2/22.
Q Why do you believe that?
192
A Because of the danger of hydroplaning and the
fact that most drivers are, you know, not able to handle
hydroplaning type problems.
[p. 215] Q Do you agree that a puncture of a tire
will usually result in a loss of air pressure to the tire of
some amount or degree?
A There - my experience is that there is some pres-
sure loss when there is an object in a tubeless tire. The
pressure loss is a lot less than most people would believe.
Q But there will be some pressure loss?
[p. 216] A Well, there are some people in the indus-
try that believe there is no pressure loss under certain
types of punctures. Usually the tire companies will say
that. I have always measured at least three PSI per week
in the cases that I’ve had.
Q So the best result you’ve ever seen in cases
you've looked at where there is a puncture object, punc-
turing object in a tire, is a loss of three pounds per square
inch per week?
A That’s right.
Q And you've seen cases where it’s a lot worse than
that per week I would assume?
A Oh, yes, yes.
Q You’ve seen cases where a puncture causes the
tire to go flat within a matter of minutes?
A Yes.
193
Q And also within a matter of hours?
A Yes.
Q And then there are the so-called punctures that
result in a slow leak. And by slow leak you would be
thinking about three pounds per square inch per week,
something along that line?
A That's right.
[p. 217] Q And that would result, if that went
uncorrected for a month, that would result in a loss of
about 12 pounds per square inch?
A Approximately. It’s not linear but - in other
words, you lose more at higher pressures than you do at
lower pressures.
Q So as the air pressure in the tire goes down the
rate of loss also goes down?
A Yes.
Q But there’s still air loss at the lower air pressure?
A That's correct.
* * .
Overdeflection, you used that term earlier -
A Yes.
Q - to describe the situation that occurs to a tire
when it’s underinflated or overloaded; is that correct?
A That's correct.
[p. 218] Q Can you define what you mean by that
term?
194
A Generally it means that the tire has fallen below
the load deflection curve.
Q And what is the load deflection curve?
A Okay, that’s the curve of the load a tire can take
at its inflation pressure. On the sidewall of the tire, like
this tire says it takes, I think, 1,352 pounds load at 35 PSI
maximum. Okay, if you cut that to 20 PSI then you would
have to cut the load that it can carry by a similar percent-
age.
In other words, there’s a —- every pressure has a load
it can take.
Q Is it a proportionate drop?
A It’s relatively proportional, it’s almost a straight
line. It’s defined as a straight line in most of the curves
but we found that there is a slight variation.
Q Just for an example, if you were to take a tire,
using this tire as an example, that has that rating, say
1,352 pounds at 35 PSI and you were to drop the PSI by
20 percent, then the load-carrying capacity of the tire at
that lower air pressure would be approximately 20 per-
cent less than 1,352 pounds?
[p. 219] A Yeah, approximately. The curve doesn’t
go through zero. Okay.
Q Can underinflation or overloading, the over-
deflection that you're talking about, cause a tire to come
out of service or become unserviceable?
A Yes.
195
Q Can you describe the mechanism by which that
occurs?
A Well, we talked about that a little bit earlier when
you were talking about running flat. This is in the cate-
gory that tire people talk about a run flat, a run underin-
flated or uninflated type failure or run type failure. But
run flat failures don’t have to be completely flat tires.
They can be tires that are, like you say, overdeflected.
What happens is that in the early stages you generate
~ degenerate the sidewall more than other tires and - I
mean other parts of the tire. The tread may get hotter
because the edges of the tread are loaded up more than
the center. It changes the load profile of the tire. And you
have an increase in temperature and you have flexing of
the tires beyond what they’re generally designed for -
[p. 220] Q When you say flexing of the tire, can you
tell us in laymen’s terms what you mean there?
A Well, it means that a tire has a certain height
above the rim. And when the tire goes through the con-
tact patch, as it rotates, it goes to a smaller height; in
other words, it is compressed, okay, if you will.
It’s compressed in several ways. One, most tires have
a round surface. Then it becomes flat since it’s pressed
against the - now performance tires are flat to start with
so that doesn’t mean that, but then you have a certain
what is called a loaded radius of the tire.
And that is - it has a normal loaded radius when it’s
properly inflated and properly loaded. But when it’s
overdeflected, that’s means it’s squashed down more.
Either because the air pressure doesn’t hold it up as well
196
or the load, so your tire crushes it too much. So your
sidewalls are bent at a greater angle.
Q And what injury to the tire would you expect to
see as a result of being run underinflated or overloaded?
[p. 221] A Generally you get deterioration in the
sidewall.
Q Anything else?
A_ If you were to stop the tire at that time, you could
see — and cut open the sidewall, you could see some
deterioration in the cords. Like I say, there is - the tem-
perature rises at the belt, the edge of the belts. And many
times that there is a — the bead is stressed a little bit more
against the rim.
Q And what would that result in?
A It’s many times called a rim flange compression
or bead groove, something like that, can cause that.
Q And what would that feel or look like, the rim
compression grove?
A Well, you would have a little groove that is
formed right there at the - where the rim flange is.
There’s a very high stress area there and a lot of manufac-
turers screw up the design of that. And so, you know, if
you see the bead — rim flange impression, it can be one of
many things. But if you overload the tire you can produce
those in some tires.
Q Any other injury that you expect to see to a
[p. 222] tire that is run at low air pressure?
197
A Well, if you continue to lower the pressure and
increase the load - you know, you have different levels of
this. You can have a small overload or a large overload.
You can have a case where the two tire — two parts of the
sidewall are - rub against each other internally. And that
produces a failure very quickly, a very distinctive type of
failure. And that is generally what you see in a run flat
type condition.
Q Any other injury or evidence that you would see
on a tire that’s run at low air pressure?
A Well, the deterioration in the sidewall can pro-
duce a rupture, it looks like a hatchet has been taken to
the tire and someone chops up on it. You can induce cases
of separation where you have tread separation, tread and
belt separation.
Q And that can be the result of running the tire at
low air pressure?
A That's right. And you can also have wear abnor-
malities.
Q What would those look like?
A Generally you would wear to the shoulder more
[p. 223] than the center.
Q Would that be both shoulders?
A Most likely, yes.
* * ‘
[p. 227] Q What about a ten PSI, is that reaching a
run flat condition at ten PSI?
198
A Anything below 20 is what I would consider run
flat, if you’re at rated load. But, like you say, you can
lower the load znd lower the pressure even more and
have that deflection, yes.
* * *
[p. 228] Q And if you run it at a low air pressure at
the rated load it’s going to wear out faster and come out
of service faster?
MR. JACKSON: Objection to the form.
THE WITNESS: You can kill the tire, yes.
MR. JACKSON: I object to what he means by
low air pressure.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q Can you explain the mechanism that causes low
air pressure to cause damage to the tire?
A I think we talked aboutthat earlier. Low air pres-
sure by itself is not what kills tires. But low pressure with
a high load, relatively — talking about [p. 229] relative
terms. But you're talking about deflection of the tire. If
you increase the load, you increase the deflection. If you
lower the pressure, you increase the deflection.
Q And that results in greater heat build-up?
A It can be greater heat build-up and greater flex-
ing.
Q And both of those are the enemy of the tire and
the rubber materials that make up the tire; is that correct?
A Yes.
199
* + *
[p. 230] Q I think you've stated this already, but just
for the record, you agree that some of the indicators
[p. 231] and evidence that a tire has been run and oper-
ated at overload situations or underinflation situations
are that you’d have uneven tread wear especially on the
shoulder, compression grooves in the rim; is that correct?
A That's correct.
Q Compression groves on the rim?
A That's correct, and on the tire bead.
Q And on the tire bead?
A The compression groove is found on the tire not
on the rim.
Q Would you have any markings on the rim?
A You could have a polished flange.
Q Would you have any marking other than a polish
to the rim of the tire?
A Some tires leave rubber marks on it under certain
types of bead grooving.
Q Would that be in a real serious situation?
A Generally it is, yes.
Q And you would have sidewall abrasion or dam-
age?
A You’d have sidewall deterioration. Abrasion is a
different type of thing, I would not use that [p. 232] word.
Q What's the difference between what you call a
deterioration and what I call abrasion?
A Well, they may look the same but sidewall deteri-
oration is usually very even around the circumference of
the sidewall and abrasion is caused by hitting a curb or
something. It’s localized. But they look like a roughening
of the surface at times, but if you cut into the tire or x-ray,
you can see other damage.
Q What you’re calling deterioration to the sidewall
would be circumferential, that would go around the
entire circle of the tire?
A Yes, and it may be on the outside or inside.
Q Would there be any other indicator or evidence
that a tire has been run overloaded or at low air pressure
that we haven't covered?
A Well, those are the major indicators.
Q And would you agree that if you had a tire that
had those indicators and that evidence on it, that that
could show that the tire was operated at low air pressure
and not that there was any manufacturing defect in the
tire?
[p. 233] MR. JACKSON: Object to the form.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q You agree with that?
A Well, you know, with the reservations as to
degree. There are other things that can cause either — all
of these indicators.
201
Q But if you had all of those indicators, that’s a
strong — that can be strong evidence, would you agree,
that the tire was operated at a low air pressure or at an
overloaded state?
A Yes.
Q And that a tire failure analyst like yourself would
have to rule out that those pieces of evidence didn’t point
to that in his analysis?
A That's correct.
Q If you have a tire that is run at low inflation or in
an overloaded situation so that the shoulders are worn
below 2/2 of an inch, the sidewalls have circumferential
deterioration to them, there are compression groves in the
rim flange of the wheel on which that tire was located,
would you consider that to be a substantial alteration to
that tire?
A That's an interesting word. They are [p. 234] indi-
cators — they are indicators that can suggest strongly that
the tire has been overdeflected.
Q Are you familiar with the term substantial alter-
ation?
A Is that a legal term?
Q I’m asking legal or not, have you ever heard that
term?
A I'm trying to remember. For some reason | think
I've heard that before but -
Q Well, let me ask it this way, would you consider a
tire that had all of those signs on it to be in the same
202
condition from the standpoint of strength of the tire as
one when it left the manufacturer?
A Generally, yes. Like I say, there’s something that
can cause all of those functions that can have a different
interpretation and you have to be very careful when you
look at these.
Q We'll get to that in a second.
A Okay.
Q Do you agree that a tire that’s run underinflated
or overloaded will need to be taken out of service before
a tire that has been run at the proper air pressure for the
load? .
[p. 235] A_ I think so, yes.
Q With respect to repairing a tire, do you agree that
there are certain procedures that are better than others?
A Yes.
Q And let’s focus on a puncture to a tire by a nail or
screw or other similar object —
A Right.
Q - that occurs in the crown or tread area of the
tire. What is the proper procedure for repair of that type
of puncture to the tire? And let’s again assume that it
goes all the way through the tire, even through the inner-
liner.
A Right. Well, there’s two major types of repairs.
The one that I think is slightly better, somewhat better, is
called a patch type repair where you take the tire off the
203
rim, you treat the inside and put a patch and then you fill
up the hole with gum. You sometimes have to drill it out
to make sure the wires are not pushing into the inside.
There are various types of these types of patches.
And there are many types for truck tires and then there
are the kind they use on passenger tires. [p. 236] They use
some kind of chemical, glue, heat-set glue or whatever
that glues it to the inside. You have to buff the inside
usually to make it stick better. After you treat the hole
you have to fill it up with a soft gum rubber.
Q So let me see if I can summarize this. What you're
saying is when you have a flat caused by a penetration of
an object from the outside of the tread of the tire through
the inner-liner that what you should do is you should
remove the tire from the rim and match the inner-liner
and fill the hole on the outside of the tire; is that a fair
summary of what you said?
A That's a good summary of it.
Q And I think you were saying there were different
ways you can fill the hole and patch the inner-liner, but
would you agree that a good repair would do both of
those things?
A Yes.
Q And that if you don’t, if you just patch the inner-
liner but you don’t fill the hole on the exterior of the tire,
that that’s not a good repair?
A It’s not as good. You can get away with it in [p.
237] some climates. But most of the places in most of the
United States you would get salt in the hole and it would
deteriorate the steel belts very rapidly.
204
Steel belts have the capacity to wick moisture
throughout them because they have gaps between the
steel. And that’s a very common failure in truck tires.
Q Once you get moisture into the steel belt area
that’s bad for the tire?
A Yes, it is.
Q And you would agree that if you don’t fill the
exterior hole that moisture and air and other foreign
material, dirt, salt, whatever, is going to be able to get
into that hole and migrate?
A_ Yes, it sounds bad but it seems to really affect the
Northern states much better - tires from the Northern
states because of the salt. And that seems to really cause a
problem.
Q So if a tire is operated in an area up North where
you have that, that can be bad for the tire if you don’t fill
the exterior hole?
A Well, yes, if you don’t fill the exterior hole it can
be very bad, yes.
[p. 238] Q And the air migration and moisture
migration in the steel belt layers can cause weakening of
the tire’s interior structure; you agree with that?
A Yes.
Q And that can lead to the tread separation and
steel belt separation; do you agree with that?
A Yes.
[p. 242}Q Backing up a little bit. Before the repair is
made, the tire has been penetrated by a puncturing object
and then the operator of the vehicle takes it into a service
station or some other repair facility and says, “Please fix
my tire.”
As I understand what you said earlier, that person
should take the tire off, look at both the interior and
exterior of the tire. Do you agree that [p. 243] one of the
decisions that person who is doing the repair needs to
make is whether or not there’s been any damage to the
‘interior structure of the tire, to the belts or the tread, and
whether any type of separation has begun so the tire
should be taken out of service?
A Well, in the ideal world I would say that he
should. I don’t think that people that repair tires gener-
ally have that type of expertise. But any overt types of
problems — the main things they look for are any wires
that go down in there that would go through the patch.
In other words, a lot of times when something goes
through a tire, it pushes wires that way, and that’s one
reason they try to go both ways when they drill it out.
And that’s one thing they look for. And I know that in
good tire shops, you know, that they do look for evidence
of separation, like abnormal wear and bumps or some-
thing like that.
Q What are the potential causes of loss of adhesion
in a tire between its various layers?
A Potential causes?
Q Yeah.
206
A Well, first, of course, is if the tire was [p. 244]
made improperly and - or improper design. And then
you can abuse the tire in various ways. Overdeflection is
the most common way. Or the only practical way.
Q Any other type of abuse that would result in loss
of adhesion?
A There's not any common ways.
Q Well, uncommon or not, can you list them for
me?
A As I mentioned before, you know, theoretically
it’s possible, if you treat the car like a sports car, to
develop this. But as I said before, I don’t think that’s
practical because you'll wear the tread out before you
would damage the casing. You can -
Q_ Is that where you would corner the car -
Yeah.
- at angles -
Yeah.
O > © >
~ that put a stress on the tire?
A Very high slip angles. The tire has to be heated by
running all the time. There are certain types of suspen-
sion defects, like if you're running at a very high camber,
that will produce it. For instance, like if you took a Ford
front end with a twin [p. 245] I-beam and had something
wrong with it to where the tires ran like that all the time,
you could develop it. There are certain types of suspen-
sion on older European cars that can develop that.
207
Q In your last answer you pointed your hands
inward so that the tires were sort of making a V or U
shape?
A_ High positive camber.
Q And that would be where tires are pointed, the
bottom of the tires closest to the road would be pointed in
making a V?
A Yes.
Q For lack of a better description.
A There are certain suspension problems thi‘ can
induce that, they are kind of rare but you see them on
trucks a lot more than you do on passenger tires.
Q Any other potential cause of loss of adhesion?
A There are certain tires that have come out that are
very sensitive to ambient temperature. They all fail in the
Southwest but I guess that’s a design problem.
Q Anything else you can think of?
A Not right now.
[p. 246] Q Do you agree that heat build-up can
weaken the interior strength of the tire and cause loss of
adhesion, excessive heat build-up?
A_ Excessive heat build-up.
Q And that’s what you were talking about earlier?
A Yes, there’s - there’s a threshold idea and then
there’s a proportional, the time and temperature, but that
time and temperature may not be a linear function.
208
Q Once you get to the magic number of tempera-
ture, then it happens very fast?
A Yes.
Q And up to that point it may happen more slowly?
A Yes, there’s — there may be two critical numbers.
One for long-term life and then there’s one for short-term
life, if you would, if you want to put everything in two
numbers. But everything is proportional.
You can run something at very low stress and pro-
duce hardly any damage over the tire for a long period of
time, you know. If you do it like that, it’s [p. 247] kind of
a threshold type of idea of stress. But you still build up a
little fatigue, it’s just that that may not have enough to
count.
Q What about your person who has a slow leak in a
tire and the tire gradually falls in air pressure and then he
brings it into the service station, fills it up back to the
proper level, and then drives it around and it gradually
falls in air pressure until he goes into the service station
again and fills up with air.
A Uh-huh.
Q_ That particular tire that undergoes that particular
pattern of losing air pressure and then being filled up,
losing air pressure and filling up, is going to experience a
cumulative weakening of the interior strength of the tire;
isn’t that correct?
A Theoretically, yes. It’s best to think about these
things as to whether the carcass is going to outlast the
209
tread life, okay. The carcass should have a margin in it
that means that it lasts longer than the tread life.
Okay, if you abuse the tire by running it flat, you may
reduce that margin. And then if you run it a little bit
more, like in this cycle, you may [p. 248] reduce it more.
And then you may reduce it to where the carcass fails
before the tread life is worn out.
And that’s the way to think about endurance of the
casing. You know, the casing should last longer than the
tread but, you know, you may reduce that margin. You
know, most people who may have a tire go flat once or
twice or ten times may never see it because they wear the
tire out before - but they have secretly reduced that
margin, but they never see it because the tire gets thrown
away at the end of the first.
Q And that would all be a matter of degree of the
abuse of the tire subject to, for example, how much it’s
overloaded or how low the air pressure is allowed to get
and how long it’s run at those various improper over-
deflected levels; is that correct?
A And the quality of the tire. Some people build in
a greater margin. And at one time some carcasses for
passengers were built to be recapped, so that margin
would be twice the original wear on average, you know,
so, you know that’s the way to think about it. It’s the best
way to think about it. ~
Q How would you isolate in tire failure analysis
[p. 249] the - to a particular potential cause of loss of
adhesion, how do you do that? -
210
A Okay, the first step is to eliminate the causes of
abuse, I mean the factors of abuse. ihere are usually
indicators on the tire that show when a tire has been
abused.
And then after that it’s very hard to isolate between
the factors I mentioned several hours ago, you know,
contamination or lack of — you know, overaging the prod-
ucts and things like that. You cannot really determine on
a vulcanized tire which factor it was.
Sometimes you can do chemical analysis and find
butyl contamination or something like that inside the tire.
But generally you eliminate the causes of abuse and that
gives you a separation that has to come from the quality
of the tire.
Q Or you find evidence that would point in the
direction of the reason for the loss of adhesion being
abuse of the tire and you can eliminate manufacturing or
design problem as the cause; is that correct?
A Most of the tires I get are that way. Most of the
tires I get are eliminated.
Q_ In other words, you don’t find a manufacturing
[p. 250] defect; is that what you're saying?
A_ I don’t find a manufacturing defect but fairly
rarely. You know, it’s a small percentage of the tires that I
see.
Q And what evidence is significant to you in going
through that process? What in particular are you looking
for?
211
A Well, in separations you look at the wear pattern,
the sidewall and the bead groove. In a nutshell.
Q Tell me what you look for in the wear pattern.
A Well, the wear pattern can indicate not only the
presence of abuse but the presence of a separation that
has been long term.
Q Would that separation may have been caused by
the abuse?
A Well, the -
Q Is that correct?
A_ It can be, depending on the nature of the wear.
Q What type of wear patterns would you expect to
see where the long-term separation is caused by the
abuse?
[p. 251] A Well, the simple answer is, you know, the
shoulder wear is more severe than the center wear. But
you have to have certain, you know, it has to be a certain
type of wear. But generally if the wear level is greater in
the shoulder than the center, it generally indicates that
you're running in an overdeflected condition.
Now you have to be very, very careful because one of
the things in tire design is to equalize the wear. And there
have been many tread designs that wore either in the
center or on the edge where it was normal wear. It’s been
very hard for radial tire manufactures tc equalize that in
some cases.
Q Have you done any study of the Hercules Supe-
rior XII in that regard?
212
A No.
Q So you don’t know whether it has any propensity
to wear at the shoulder?
A No, I don’t.
Q And you don’t have any opinion about that?
A Not right now.
Q You also mentioned that it would be sidewall
evidence?
{p. 252] A That's correct.
Q And what particular evidence would you look for
on the sidewall?
A_ I would look for the deterioration on either the
outside or the inner-liner that you can see. You can see
discolorations, you can see a change in the texture, you
can see outright deterioration of the tire.
Q And you also mentioned that there would be
evidence in the bead groove area of the tire. What would
you look for there?
A Well, to see if there is a bead groove on both
beads. There again, that is a critical area for the designer
and there are beads out there that —- most tires do have a
bead groove of some - after they’ve been in service for
awhile.
And it is rather, I think, rather difficult to determine
what is abnormal bead grooving. Usually in light truck
tires and truck tires it’s much more definitive.
Q And the converse would also be true that in a
passenger tire it would be very difficult to determine
213
what is a normal bead groove, if it’s difficult to [p. 253]
determine what is abnormal?
A Ina perfect world I would look at a lot of tires
and determine whether the manufacturer screwed up or
not, his bead design, okay, if I could see a hundred tires
that had been run under ideal conditions or whatever. I
see a small window of these tires. And we think that if it
is past a certain level of bead grooving that we're pretty
sure that the tire has been abused.
We would like to see comparable, something compa-
rable, like the tread wear, we like to see two out of the
three things I was talking about or two out of three things
to determine.
Q If you had two out of three that would be a pretty
strong indicator of abuse?
A_ It would be stronger, yes.
Q And if you had three out of three that would be
definitive in your opinion?
A It would be pretty — close as I could get.
Q Now think we mentioned earlier that when you
have really had bad overdeflection you can get actual
imprints of the bead on the rim of the tire on which that
particular tire is located; is that true?
[p. 254] A You can have polishing and you can
have, in some cases, gummy rubber on there. That’s
pretty rare to me but -
Q And if you had indications on the rim of the tire,
that would be even stronger still; would you agree with
that?
214
A Partially.
Q What part don’t you agree with?
A Well, normal use can polish the rim, normal use,
depending on the tire design. Some tires seem to be more
prone to that than others. And I’m not sure I know
everything there is about that, you know, comparing one
manufacturer to the other. But, generally, polishing that is
very, you know, very shiny and everything is an indica-
tion that you may have overdeflection.
Q Going back to the comments you were making
about the bead groove on the bead of the tire itself, you
said that ideally you would like to look at a fairly large
number of the same type of tire -
A Uh-huh.
Q - hundred or so, to see what the normal bead
groove looked like for that type tire; is that correct?
[p. 255] A Yes.
Q Have you done that with respect to the Hercules
Superior XII at issue in this case?
A No.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q Let's go back on the record, | want to ask you a
question about something that we left off on. As I under-
stand, the bead groove evidence that you would expect to
see where you have an overdeflection situation causing a
loss of adhesion, is that there would be marks on the tire
bead groove itself, correct?
215
There’s a mark on the bead, the tire bead, yes.
That's -
> G2
A groove on the tire bead.
Q A groove on the tire bead. That would be differ-
ent than the normal groove that you would see on the
same type of tire under normal situations?
A Yes.
Q And in order to make a determination as to
whether the groove on the tire bead is normal or abnor-
mal, as I understand it you need to look at a [p. 256]
hundred or so of the same type tires to see what the
normal groove looks like?
A Well, there — that is mainly to see if there is a
problem in the manufacture. Among normal tires you
have a relative indicator of the bead groove. You know, if
you suspect that it is from the manufacturing process,
you would need to see a hundred tires to determine in
fact if there was a bead design problem.
Many tires have a normal bead groove which is a
certain size. And then we classify that as - as something
that is like a normal bead groove. Okay. And it doesn’t
really indicate that there is overloading or that there is a
manufacturing problem.
But if we do see consistently — I’ve got one tire that I
suspect that has a problem. And I've seen six of these,
okay, and they all have bead grooves. And that is almost
enough for me to determine that they have a problem in
designing the bead. Okay.
216
But under normal circumstances you can determine
whether a bead is - bead groove is abnormal or not with
reasonable accuracy or confidence.
Q Let's take a step back because I think we’re miss-
ing each other on this one. I was talking in the [p. 257]
context of where you were looking at the potential causes
for loss of adhesion of the tire.
A Right.
Q And I understood you to say that basically the
two types of problems that you are looking at in that
context are some type of a manufacturing defect or prob-
lem?
A Uh-huh.
Q And then a loss of adhesion that’s caused by
overdeflection. And I think you've listed a couple of
others but you said those are very infrequent.
A Oh, okay, yes.
Q Is that a fair summary?
A_ I think so, yes.
Q And then I asked you, well, looking at the loss of
adhesion that’s caused by overdeflection -
A Uh-huh.
Q - what evidence would you expect to see. And |
understood you to say that there would be three primary
pieces of evidence or indicators, which would be abnor-
mal wear pattern on the tread, mainly in the shoulder
areas, there would be sidewall deterioration around the
217
entire circumference of the tire on the [p. 258] inside or
the outside and then you would have certain bead groove
evidence.
A That's right.
Q Now focusing just on the bead groove evidence, |
understood you to say that in order to determine whether
that bead groove evidence that you see is abnormal or
normal you would have to look at a hundred or so similar
tires of the same type to see what a normal one looked
like, only then would you be able to see if it was abnor-
mal.
A Well, that is generally correct. You don’t gener-
ally suspect that the manufacturers have a problem where
there’s an abnormal bead groove formed under normal
operating conditions. This is kind of — if I did suspect it, I
would like to see a hundred tires or, you know, some
number of tires. I only see, generally, four or five tires
from one manufacturer at a time. Maybe ten tires or
something from the different cases. If they have problems
I may see ten tires.
But if I did suspect that, I would like to see a lot of
tires, whatever the number is, as many as possible, to see
if that is - see what is an average bead groove.
[p. 259] Now if I were back at Michelin and wanted
to define this problem, you know I would look at a
hundred tires, if 1 could, and try to define the loading on
each one of those tires to see what is a normal wear in the
bead — in the bead of those tires. Okay.
Q And that would be a normal wear at the proper
load for the air pressure in the tire?
218
A That's right.
Q What we're talking about is a situation where you
have overdeflection which would be an overload for the
air pressure in the tire?
A That's correct.
Q And in that context what would you expect to see
on the bead groove?
A We -
MR. HERLONG: On the Bead.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q Well, I'm sorry, on the bead of the tire.
A Yeah, on the bead. You can have normal loading
that produces a small groove. A bigger groove, which we
have, you can see the extent of it, would be an indicator
of overloading. You know, most every tire has a small
groove in there after some usage but it [p. 260] gets
bigger and bigger with more and more deflection and
longer use.
Q All right. Now also an earlier question before we
got on this line of questioning, | understood you to say
that overdeflection can also cause polishing of the -im of
the wheel on which the tire is located and that there is a
rubber imprint or rubber residue of some type that can
also be left in that rim groove; is that correct?
A You can leave rubber deposits on the rim under
extreme circumstances and you can, conversely, have a
polished rim under normal operating conditions, so they
219
aren't really that reliable an indicator but, you know, it is
something you can look for.
Q With respect to the rim of the wheel, would you
expect to see an imprint, some type of like imprint of the
tire bead on there under extreme circumstances?
A That's too general, I think.
Q In looking at the rim of a wheel on which a tire is
located that’s suffered severe overdeflection, have you
ever seen any type of imprint left by the bead of the rim
flange?
A I've seen lots of things in different cases [p. 261]
but there’s not one there that I consider that much reli-
able. | mean that reliable an indicator of overloading
Q If you had that on a rim of a tire would that or
would that not be an indication of overdeflection?
A Depends on what you mean by calling it an
imprint. You know, a tire doesn’t leave too much of a -
doesn’t change metal, except maybe by polishing it. It
doesn’t imprint the metal. And what you may be talking
about is that there may be black marks on the rim due to
some deterioration of the rubber. You can see that.
Q And that would be evidence of overdeflection?
A Yeah, it can be but it’s not a good one. On truck
tires you see that quite often due to overheating of brakes
and such.
Q On passenger tires, if you had that type of evi-
dence that you’re talking about, would that be an indica-
tion of overdeflection?
220
A It could be an indication, yeah.
* * *
[p. 262] Q Okay, I'll get to that in a second. As far as
the rim, I’m talking about an imprint where it looks like
you've got a pattern that’s been pressed, if you will, onto
the rim where it left a little pattern.
A Okay.
Q You know what I’m talking about?
A Yeah. That’s a bad word but I know that [p. 263]
people use that. There is a pattern that can be pushed
onto the rim but it’s mainly just rubber particles, it’s not
an imprint in the metal.
Q Would that be an indication of overdeflection?
A It can be. It usually means that there’s some high
temperature there in the bead.
Q And high temperature in the bead can occur dur-
ing overdeflection?
A Kind of, yeah.
Q Is there anything else that causes that?
A Like I say, the rim getting hot for some reason,
like overbraking or conditions where there may be a
defect in the brake.
Q Anything else that could cause that?
A_ I don’t think so.
Q So the two possible causes of that on the rim
would be overbraking or overdeflection?
221
A Ina nutshell.
lp. 276] Q Do you agree that there is room for
difference of opinion with respect to interpreting the
evidence that may be located on a tire in determining
what is the potential cause of loss of adhesion?
A I think there’s always differences of opinions.
Q What I’m getting at there is that how you inter-
pret the evidence is subjective; isn’t that correct?
A To a certain extent, yes.
Q And that two people who are equally qualified
might look at that evidence and disagree about what it
means?
THE WITNESS: I don’t know what other people
would do. There should be some evidence that should
lead you in the right direction.
Q Are there any tests that you can run that can
[p. 277] pin down whether or not a loss of adhesion was
caused by overdeflection as opposed to some manufac-
turing defect? And I’m talking about after the tire had
failed. Are there any tests you can do that can eliminate
one or the other as potential cause?
A There are some.
Q What tests?
A Well, in some cases we see alignments of belts
that cause problems. And I don’t know if I mentioned
222
that earlier, but we could x-ray the tire and see if there is
a — if we suspect that the belt is either too long or too
crooked or something, we could do.
As I said there is a test for butyl contamination,
which is sometimes reliable if you suspect that. But gen-
erally there’s not a hard and fast rule to find out what
type of problem caused the loss of adhesion when there is
a manufacturing defect.
Q I'm talking about trying to pin it down between a
manufacturing defect or a loss of adhesion caused by
overdeflection and abuse to the tire. Are there any tests
you can do to eliminate one or the other of those as a
cause or potential cause?
A The indicators for overloading are the best
[p. 278] indicators of loss of adhesion.
Q And we've already gone over those items of evi-
dence and whether - I think you agree with me that
whether or not those items of evidence are present or not
is largely a subjective type of determination?
A They can be subjective in degree. They can be
caused by other things and you have to be careful.
Q As I understand your testimony there’s no test
that you can run that has any verifiable or statistical
accuracy that will eliminate manufacturing defect as a
cause or, alternatively, eliminate overdeflection as a cause
of loss of adhesion?
A Well, when we eliminate the facts - I mean the
causes — when we look for the indicators of overloading
223
or overdeflection, as I see, and eliminate those as a possi-
ble cause, then there is nothing else but a manufacturing
defect.
Q And, conversely, if those are present, those evi-
dences of overloading and overdeflection or low air pres-
sure, then that would eliminate a manufacturing defect as
a cause?
A Well, as I say, there is something that can cause
other parts of that. We like to see at least two [p. 279] of
everything, two indicators in everything. And that gener-
ally does not — that is a good indicator that there is a
manufacturing defect. It may have gotten twisted in the
double negatives.
Q I think what you're saying is if of the three indi-
cators of overdeflection, which are abnormal wear pat-
tern in the tread?
A Uh-huh.
Q The sidewall deterioration?
A Yes.
Q And the bead groove -
A Uh-huh.
Q_ - indication. If you can eliminate two of those
three, then you feel like it’s probably a manufacturing
defect.
On the other hand, if two of those three are present,
you feel like it’s probably a loss of adhesion — excuse me,
an overdeflection problem that caused the loss of adhe-
sion; is that correct?
224
A Yes.
Q I guess where I’m hung up a little bit is determin-
ing whether those indicators are present is largely a sub-
jective determination.
[p. 280] A Things like -
MR. JACKSON: Wait a minute, wait a minute,
that’s not a question. You want to ask him a question,
he'll answer it.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q Well, let me see if I can rephrase it. Determining
whether those items are present, abnormal wear pattern,
sidewall deterioration, the bead groove, is largely a sub-
jective process?
A_ It can be a subjective process to a degree. To a
degree. You know, for instance, if there is no bead groove
there you most likely suspect that there was no overload-
ing. If it were also collaborated by no abnormal tread or
no other deterioration in the sidewall, or whatever, that
would be cut and dried.
You know, you would be very confident in that. As I
was talking before, that there seems to be a - a small
groove that is formed in a lot of tires that doesn’t indicate
that it’s an overload. But it’s - you can see when it does
become an overload with some degree of certainty, you
know, fairly good.
There is a subjectiveness. You can’t measure and say
that five millimeters is something and five [p. 281] mill -
you know, six millimeters is something else. You know,
you can’t - it’s not that kind of test. We just have to rely
225
on our experience in looking at a lot of tires and testing a
lot of tires to find out where those factors are important.
Q In this area of trying to isolate the cause of loss of
adhesion to a manufacturing type defect as opposed to an
abuse injury caused by overdeflection, there is, it sounds
like, a lot of uncertainty and room for subjective deter-
mination. Is that true?
A Well, I don’t want to belabor the point of uncer-
tainty but there’s uncertainty in everything that we do.
And there is some subjectiveness in this but then there’s
hard and fast rules that we go by.
Q Do you know what the error rate is -
No.
- for this type of determination?
No.
Has that ever been calculated?
No.
O> OD > 0D >
What are the hard and fast rules you’re referring
to?
A Well, determining whether the bead groove is
[p. 282] abnormal, whether the wear is abnormal or
caused by some other factor, or the bead groove is caused
by the accident or some other - some other cause.
Q Let's talk about the bead groove.
A Uh-huh.
Q As far as the determination of whether a bead
groove is abnormal! or normal or caused by some other
226
factor, as I understood your testimony earlier, you have
to look at hundreds of tires to see what the normal
pattern looks like; is that correct?
A Well, you have to look at - if there is no bead
groove, then you would suspect that there is no problem
with overloading on any tire. You know, that if you do
have a bead groove, you have to look at both of them on
both sides.
You have to look at - you would like to look at other
tires to see if the manufacturer has the problem, which is
hard to determine, but is not that common for them to
have it, even though it is a difficult problem. Generally
they find those problems in the development of the tire,
hopefully. But all, you know, most tires do have a small
groove. And you're talking, to be really definitive, you
have to [p. 283] have a big groove there to show that
you're overloaded.
Q Can you have overloading without having a bead
groove? Or let me rephrase that. Can you have over-
deflection caused by either overloading or low air pres-
sure but not resulting in a bead groove?
A Yes.
Q So the fact that a bead groove is not present does
not mean that the tire has not been overdeflected?
A No, the conditions are very, very restrictive.
Okay. It has to be very, very short-term. You know, like
two or three cycles, you know, rotations of the tire. Okay.
And then I suspect that certain manufacturers have
less grooving than the others, so that makes it a little
harder to determine. But I think that when you have one
'
é
t
t.
227
manufacturer, I think, that has less grooving than all the
others, then that makes it a little easier.
Q Well, what tests have you done to determine the
degree of bead grooving that will occur with certain types
of overdeflection?
A Well, I’ve looked at lots of tires.
Q So you haven’t done any tests, it’s just that
[p. 284] you've looked at lots of tires; is that right?
A Right.
Q And you don’t know what the error rate is in
your experience. I mean obviously some of these tires
you've looked at, you didn’t see and witness the failure,
and you're just trying to piece together what ha
. ed
afterwards; is that correct? nb
A That's correct.
Q And there’s no way to test whether what you
concluded was right or not?
MR. JACKSON: Object to the form.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
| Q Or what your error rate is in the subjective deter-
mination you made; is that true?
A There is uncertainty in that.
Q Now with respect to tread wear, abnormal tread
wear pattern, you said that there can be other causes of
abnormal tread wear pattern besides overdeflection; is
that right?
A That's correct.
Q How do you eliminate or isolate the cause of
abnormal tread wear pattern?
A Well, you have to look at the vehicle. You [p. 285]
can look at other tires on the vehicle. You can look at the
tire and see the different patterns, the subtleties of the
pattern, of the tread wear pattern.
[p. 285] Q. Are there any tests that you can do to
determine what causes abnormal tread wear?
A. Ihave studied that for a long time and there are
many research papers that talk about that.
Q. Do any of them come to a conclusion that there
are certain tests that can be run that will say, yes, this
type of tread wear abnormality is caused by this set of
circumstances and this slightly different set of tread wear
abnormalities was caused by this other set of circum-
stances?
A. There’s quite a few.
Q. Are there any that you rely on in any of your
testimony in this case?
A. Ihave read many of them.
Q. Well, are you relying on them in your testimony
in this case?
A. Probably, the information.
229
[p. 286] MR. BABINGTON: These articles or studies
of tests that will determine what causes abnormal tread
wear pattern. If that is indeed something you're relying
on in this case.
THE WITNESS: What information I read and
studied and combined with many other studies that | did,
you know, involve my experience. You know, I can pro-
vide you with some papers, I think, if I still have them,
that are fairly definitive talking about underload and
overload of tires and the effect on the wear pattern.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q. And are these studies that have been published?
A. Yes.
Q. Are they studies that contain conclusions
reached after certain types of control tests?
A. Yes.
Q. Have they been subject to peer review?
A. I believe so, they were published by the SAE and
I don’t know anybody that’s as good about weeding out
bad papers as they.
[p. 287] Q. You haven’t authored any of these
papers, just so I understand that?
A. No.
Q. But you are relying on them in support of your
testimony in this case?
A. Well, to a certain extent, yes, it’s a part of my
knowledge.
230
[p. 289] Q Again focusing on the abnormal tread
wear pattern that you would expect to see in an over-
deflection, as a result of overdeflection, what are you
looking for specifically that would indicate whether that
tread wear pattern is the result of overdeflection as
opposed to some other cause?
A Well, generally the first thing is increased wear at
the shoulders with rounding of the shoulders. There can
be some feathering.
Q What is feathering?
A The front part of the tread block may be a little
higher than the rear or vice versa.
Q Go ahead. Anything else?
A Any edges might be a little lifted, you know.
[p. 290] Feathering can also be like if you have a sipe, or
something like that, with one side higher than the other.
You know, if you rubbed your hand across it you feel it
one way but you don’t feel it the other. That's generally
feathering.
Q Anything else?
A Well, in some cases there can be some surface
texture abnormalities that can be rougher on the edge, the
rourded area, depending on the tread design.
Q Anything else you would look for?
A I think that’s about all. There’s some people that
look at the tread grooves and there can be some polishing
231
there in the tread grooves in extreme cases with certain
types of tires and certain types of tread designs.
Q The tread grooves referring to the
oe g valley part of
A Yes.
r vi And all of those things you just mentioned would
evidence of the tire being injured as a ] -
; om j result of over
A_ It could be.
Q Well, what else could cause those?
[p. 291] A Well, you can have, like I say,
have problems with design of the tire which ie ary
big, big problem 20 years ago. And, you know, you can
have suspension problems. You can have certain align-
ment problems that can cause some of these factors.
Q Are there any manufacturing defects that can
ae types of problems in the wear pattern of the
A It’s very rare.
Q Soif you have those types of wear patterns in the
tread, specifically on the shoulder area of the tread, that
would be a very strong indicator of overdeflection?
A Well, it can be. Usually we like to say that if it’s
combined with one of the other factors, then that’s a
stronger indication. By itself it’s not that much. None of
these factors by themselves are that strong an indication
but taken together they can be strong.
232
Q Well, what else would cause that abnormal wear
pattern that you just described?
A Alignment and vehicle problems and driving
habits, you know, whatever.
[p. 292] Q So there could be a lot of different causes
of that?
A Yes, sir.
Q And so again if you were trying to make a deter-
mination of what caused the loss of adhesion, and one of
the pieces of evidence you're considering is the wear
pattern, there’s a good bit of subjectivity in determining
whether that wear pattern was a result of overdeflection
or some other cause?
A Well, I’m not sure I would call it subjectivity, you
just have to have knowledge as to what can cause wear
patterns. If that’s subjectivity, then it’s subjectivity. But I
call it knowledge.
Q As I understand what you're saying, the same
wear pattern can be an indicator of several different
things?
A Yes, you have to look at other parts.
Q And if you have an abnormal wear pattern on the
tread that you described, as well as some of these other
indicia, which are the sidewall deterioration and the bead
groove, then that would be very strong evidence of over-
deflection causing the loss of adhesion?
[p. 293] A That's right, if you have two or more
indicators then that’s very, very good evidence.
233
Q If you had just the abnormal wear pattern by
itself, that may mean that there was overdeflection but
what you're saying is it wouldn’t be definitive?
A That's correct, in most cases. It may be that
you're able to determine some other way, by eliminating
it some other way, by vehicle history or whatever.
Q Unless you can come up with another more likely
cause of the abnormal wear pattern how can you elimi-
nate overdeflection as the cause of the abnormal wear
pattern?
A That was too long a question, I’m sorry. The
process is I would like to see two of the indicators of
overload before I consider the overloading to be a factor.
With tires, you know, like I say there’s usually multiple
causes of a lot of things. And by looking at the tire, wear
is - can be a lot of things. You know, the vehicle, the way
it’s driven, construction of the tire, you know, the history
of the tire, whatever, what wheel it’s on, what wheel
position it’s on and stuff like that.
You know, the tread wear is not an indicator [p. 294]
by itself unless you have very good evidence otherwise
that the tire was overloaded. And like I say, we like to see
two of them before we will indicate that a tire has been
overloaded severely because we like to see the bead
groove and the wear pattern both.
Q Would you agree with me that tire failure anal-
ysis of the fashion that we're talking about here is not an
exact science?
A Well, very little is an exact science.
Q Well, let's talk just about this one.
234
A Yeah.
Q Would you agree it’s not an exact science?
A It depends on experience quite a bit.
Q Are there any tests to determine the adhesion
that exists between the various components of the tire?
A There’s many tests that are done by tire manufac-
turers to test the adherence.
Q Have you done any of those on the tire in tnis
case?
A No.
Q What are the types of tests that are available?
A Well, there’s pull tests and there's all types
[p. 295] of greenstick type tests. These are done generally
in the factory to test each rubber batch as it comes out of
the mixer or the mill.
They usually take a small amount of every rubber
that comes out of the mill and put it in - they put it either
with a steel cable or polyester or something like that and
do pull tests.
. * *
Q Are there any tests of adhesion that you can use
after a tire failure?
A After a tire failure there are none that I would
use.
Q And why wouldn’t you use them?
235
A Well, I think that after a tire has been [p. 296]
through an accident scenario or something like that that it
gives you rather dubious results.
Q It would be unreliable?
A 1 would think they would be unreliable. Hard-
ness test can be an indicator of cure if you suspect an
extreme undercure. But then again I think that’s unreli-
able on a tire that’s been run for several thousand miles.
[p. 297] Q Can you define for me what you mean by
separation?
A Separation is separation of products.
Q In the context of a tire what does it mean?
A It means some of the parts don’t stick together
anymore.
Q Are there different types of separation?
A_ Well, I suppose there are.
Q What are they?
A Well, generally they're classified as edge belt sep-
aration, tread separation or belt separation or separation
between the carcass and the belts or separation between
the rubber products. There can be separations between
the carcass ply or even the bead and the filler material
around the bead.
So generally it’s classified by where they are and
between the products that separate.
236
[p. 301] Q All right. Are there any tests that you're
aware of that can be used after tire failure to narrow the
cause or potential cause of separation down to a particu-
lar cause?
A Cause of what, separation?
Q Yes.
A There is, like I say, very few tests after the fact
except to eliminate other causes, to eliminate [p. 302]
certain causes, like overdeflection.
Q So there’s no test that you can perform after the
fact to say for certain that this is the cause? I’m talking
about tests now.
A. There are tests that are done but they’re very rare
and I don’t think they have that much validity after an
accident tire.
Q They’re not reliable as we discussed?
A There is butyl contamination tire, | mean test, but
that is not usually found in the tread because the butyl is
put on with the tools at the very start of the manufactur-
ing process and the belts are put on second to last, just
about.
Q So that would not be a very reliable test?
A It’s not - it’s not very common. It’s a fairly reli-
able test if you can get it done right.
Q It’s hard to do it right?
A Yes, sir.
237
Q And you haven't done that in this case?
A No.
Q So it sounds like the wa
‘Se y that you go about
determining the cause of separation is similar to a differ-
ential diagnosis in medicine where you try to [p. 303] rule
out other causes if you don’t know the cause of a particu-
lar symptom or disease; is that right?
MR. JACKSON: Object to the form.
BY MR. BABINGTON:
Q Is that right, is that what you're saying?
A I'm saying we tr imi
y to eliminate
causes. all the other
Q So you arrive at a conclusion in your tire failure
analysis by eliminating other causes?
A Yes.
, Q Are there any publications that would discuss
Ow you go about doing that sort of tire failure analysis?
A_ I don’t think so.
Q Are there any generally accepted theories on how
you go about doing that sort of tire failure analysis?
A_ I think this is a generall
il y accepted th i
eliminate all the other causes. , ie
Q And what do you base that statement on?
A I’ve read many depositions from tire experts.
238
[p. 304] What factors in general determine how long it
takes for a separation to occur?
A The quality of the tire and the type of use.
* . *
Q And would you agree as a general proposition
that if you have greater abuse of the tire you’re going to
have a quicker type of separation?
[p. 305] A Generally, yeah.
Q And if a tire is poorly made that you would
expect to see separation occur earlier in its life?
A It’s possible, yes.
Q Ifa tire lasts a long time, that’s an indication that
the tire is well made?
A It can be.
» > *
Q One follow-up question on shoulder wear. Do
you agree that shoulder wear increases as the overdeflec-
tion increases?
A It generally does.
Q And to state that another way is that shoulder
wear is directly proportional to the degree of overdeflec-
tion?
A 1 don’t think I can go with that.
Q You can’t agree with that one?
239
A No, because it generally has that factor but there
are things that can decrease that and directly propor-
tional implies a lingering relationship and
I [p. ,
think that is true. p and I [p. 306] don’t
[p. 308] Q Can you define polish for me?
A Well, it’s when the rubber products, or even the
steel, have been rubbed together to where they have a
shiny appearance.
Q How do you define shiny?
A Well, it looks shin ini
, y, shinier than what it’ -
posed to look like. te
Q And there are de a
grees of shin
agree with that? iness, would you
[p. 309] A Not reall ,
y, there’s usuall
surface or very shiny. y a very rough
Q One or the other with very little in between?
A Very little.
w
be. an you identify all potential causes of polish for
A Well, generally it means that the tires have been
rubbed together under use, rubber products have been
rubbed together under use, and it means that they are
loose, they have a lack of adhesion. ”
Q Is that the only cause of polishing?
A That's the major cause, yes.
240
* * *
[p. 310} Q And what is the mechanism that causes
polish, can you describe that for me?
A As you rotate a tire it is compressed and the two
pieces are compressed together. And as they’re com-
pressed together they slip a little bit and this polishes the
rubber.
Q How do you determine whether polish is present
or not?
A You look at it.
Q Is there any other test that you can do or any
other type of procedure?
A Ican imagine some. Measure the degree of reflec-
tivity of the rubber surface, but they aren’t generally
used. It’s mainly a visual thing.
Q Would you agree that what is shiny to one person
may not be shiny to another person?
[p. 311] A. I think this type of shininess is evident to
most people, the type of shininess that you see in a tire
that has come apart from separation.
Q You don’t think there’s any room for difference of
opinion as to whether polish is present or not when
you're doing tire failure analysis?
A 1 doubt if there’s very much room. You know,
there’s variation in every human endeavor but I don’t
think — I think this is pretty cut and dried.
241
Q Have you determined what the error rate is with
respect to trying to make a determination of whether
there is polish present?
A No.
Q Do you know if anyone has done that?
A No.
Q Are you aware of any publications that discuss
how to do that, determine whether polish is present or
not?
A No.
Q And what is chafe?
A Chafe is a rougher surface that is the beginning of
the polishing process.
[p. 312] A That's right.
Q How do you make that determination?
A That's a little harder.
Q How do you do it?
A Well, you look at it.
Q Would you agree that there’s room for difference
of opinion as to whether chafe is present or not?
A Yes.
Q And that there’s a lot of uncertainty in making
that determination?
242
A There probably is.
Q With respect to tread wear and determining tread
depth, how do you do that?
A Tread wear and determining tread depth?
Q Yeah.
[p. 313] A What do you mean?
Q How do you determine tread depth?
A You measure it with a gauge.
[p. 315] Q Doyou know what the initial tread depth
was on this tire?
A I don’t know exactly, I heard that it was "'/x
somewhere.
i 1 question while
. Sa Let me ask this genera ,
eae : i of the room. When did you first get
involved i
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.