Joint Appendix — Bay Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pension Trust Fund v. Ferbar Corp. of Cal.

Supreme Court brief1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

- reme Court, Us

vl FLL ED

/ JUL 16 1997

Supreme Court of the Hnited States _

OCTOBER TERM, 1996

BOARD OF TRUSTEES, BAY AREA LAUNDRY AND

Dry CLEANING PENSION TRUST FUND,

7 Petitioner,

FERBAR CORPORATION OF CALIFORNIA, INC.;

STEPHEN BARNES,

Respondents.

On Writ of Certiorari to the

United States Court of Appeals

for the Ninth Circuit

JOINT APPENDIX

MARSHA S. BERZON * WILLIAM F. TERHEYDEN *

LOWELL FINLEY JAMES D. BAKER

Scott A. KRONLAND JOHN C. CORCORAN

ALTSHULER, BERZON, NUSSBAUM, LIJITTLER MENDELSON

BERZON & RUBIN 650 California Street

177 Post Street 20th Floor

Suite 300 San Francisco, CA 94108

San Francisco, CA 94108 (415) 433-1940

(415) 421-7151 Counsel for Respondents

GEOFFREY V. WHITE

351 California Street

Suite 650

San Francisco, CA 94104

(415) 362-5658

Counsel for Petitioner

* Counsel of Record

rr —

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 10, 1996

CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 12, 1997

B GB. 0

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Relevant Docket Entries from the U.S. District Court

for the Northern District of California

Relevant Docket Entries from the U.S. Court of Ap-

peals for the Ninth Circuit

Complaint for Collection of Employer Withdrawal

Liability Payments .

Answer to Complaint of Defendants Ferbar Corpora-

tion of California, Inc. and Stephen J. Barnes

Defendants’ Statement of Undisputed Material Facts..

Declaration of Stephen J. Barnes, with Exhibits

Exhibit A. Letter from Glen Slaughter & Asso-

ciates, Bay Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pen-

sion Fund to Stephen Barnes, Superior French

Laundry. December 12, 1986. (Withdrawal

Liability Assessment and Demand for Payment) ....

Declaration of Geoffrey V. White in Opposition to De-

fendants’ Motion for Summary J udgment and in

Support of Plaintiff’s Cross-Motion for Summary

Adjudication, with Exhibits

Exhibit 2. Letter from Littler, Mendelson, Fastiff

& Tichy to Board of Trustees, Bay Area Laundry

and Dry Cleaning Pension Fund. February 27,

1987. (Request for Review of Withdrawal

Exhibit 3. Letter from Glen Slaughter & Asso-

ciates, Bay Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pen-

sion Fund to Stephen Barnes, Superior French

Laundry, April 14, 1987 (Notice of Delinquency) ..

Exhibit 4. Letter from Littler, Mendelson, Fastiff

& Tichy to Glen Slaughter and Associates, Bay

Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pension Fund.

July 8, 1987. (Notice of Initiation of Arbi-

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued

Exhibit 5. Portions of the Bay Area Dry Cleaners

and Laundry Workers Pension Plan Rules and

Regulations Pertaining to Employer Withdrawal

Liability, as amended .......... -

Plaintiff’s Counter-Statement of Undisputed Material

RGD q.ccsecercccsusacusscoemsenscciesannnistasesmesiaiaannn

Page

_ NOTICE

The following items have been omitted i: printing this Joint

Appendix because they appear on the following pages in the

printed Appendix to the Petition for a Writ of Certiorari:

Order of the United States District Court for

Northern California [Filed May 9, 1994] ..._......... 6a

Opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth

CRAGUEB a.ncccinteisbennncditieiiainaiila la

Order Denying Rehearing and Rejecting Sugges-

tion for Rehearing En Banc ............................--+.-- . 20a

RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES

United States District Court

for the Northern District of California

Docket No. 98-CV-489

DATE NO.

PROCEEDINGS

2/9/98

3/23/93

10/27/98

10/27/93

10/27/93

10/27/98

11/10/98

1

10

ll

12

13

14

COMPLAINT (Summons(es) issued) Fee

status pd entered on 2/9/98 in the amount of

$120.00 (Receipt No. 27318) (fw) [Entry

date 02/10/93]

ANSWER by defendant Ferbar Corp of CA,

defendant Stephen J. Barnes to complaint

[1-1] (fw) [Entry date 03/26/93]

NOTICE AND MOTION before Judge D. L.

Jensen by defendant Ferbar Corp of CA, de-

fendant Stephen J. Barnes for summary judg-

ment with Notice set for 11/24/93 at 10:00

am (fw) [Entry date 10/28/93]

MEMORANDUM by defendant Ferbar Corp

of -CA, defendant Stephen J. Barnes in sup-

port of motion for summary judgment [10-1]

(fw) [Entry date 10/28/93]

STATEMENT of undisputed material facts

by defendant Ferbar Corp of CA, defendant

Stephen J. Barnes in support of motion for

summary judgment [10-1] (fw) [Entry date

10/28/93]

DECLARATION by Stephen J. Barnes on be-

half of defendant Ferbar Corp of CA, defend-

ant Stephen J. Barnes re motion for summary

judgment [10-1] (fw) [Entry date 10/28/93]

NOTICE AND CROSS-MOTION before Judge

D. L. Jensen by plaintiff Bay Area Laundry&

Dry for summary adjudication with Notice

set for 11/24/93 at 10:00am [3 :93-cv-00489]

(fw) [Entry date 11/12/98]

2

DATE

NO.

PROCEEDINGS

11/10/93

11/10/93

11/10/93

11/10/93

11/17/93

12/22/93

12/22/93

12/22/98

15

15

16

17

18

21

MEMORANDUM by plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry in to motion for sum-

mary judgment [10-1] [3:93-cv-00489] (fw)

[Entry date 11/12/93]

MEMORANDUM by plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry in support of motion for sum-

mary adjudication [14-1] [3:93-cv-00489]

(fw) [Entry date 11/12/93]

DECLARATION by Geoffrey V. White on be-

half of plaintiff Bay Area Laundry&Dry re

motion for summary judgment [10-1] [3:93-

cv-00489] (fw) [Entry date 11/12/93]

STATEMENT of facts by plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry in support of memorandum

[15-1] [3:98-cv-00489] (fw) [Entry date

11/12/93]

REPLY by defendant Ferbar Corp of CA,

defendant Stephen J. Barnes re motion for

summary judgment [10-1] [3:93-cv-00489]

(fw) [Entry date 11/22/93]

MEMORANDUM by defendant Ferbar Corp

of CA, defendant Stephen J. Barnes in sup-

port of motion for summary judgment [10-1]

[3 :93-cv-00489] (fw) [Entry date 12/23/93]

MEMORANDUM by plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry in support of motion for sum-

mary adjudication [14-1] [3:93-cv-00489)

(fw) [Entry date 12/23/93)

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION by Geof-

frey V. White on behalf of plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry re memorandum [21-1] [3:93-

cv-00489] (fw) [Entry date 12/23/93]

3

DATE NO.

PROCEEDINGS

5/9/94 25

5/9/94 26

5/9/94 27

6/3/94 29

6/6/94 30

ORDER by Judge D. L. Jensen granting de-

fendants Ferbar Corporation and Stephen

Barnes motion for summary judgment [10-1] ;

Partial judgment shall be entered accordingly.

Status conference set for 8:30 5/25/94 ; All

other dates currently scheduled are vacated.

(Date Entered: 5/11/94) (cc: all counsel)

[3 :98-cv-00489] (fw) [Entry date 05/11/94]

PARTIAL JUDGMENT: by Judge D. L. Jen-

sen For reasons in Order filed 5/9/94, Court

ENTERS PARTIAL JUDGMENT in favor of

defendant Ferbar Corporation and against

plaintiffs in this matter. (Date Entered:

5/11/94) (ce: all counsel) [3 :93-cv-00489]

(fw) [Entry date 05/11/94]

PARTIAL JUDGMENT: by Judge D. L. Jen-

sen For reasons stated in Order filed 5/9/94,

Court ENTERS PARTIAL JUDGMENT in

favor of defendant Stephen Barnes and

against plaintiffs in this matter. (Date En-

tered: 5/11/94) (cc: all counsel) [3:93-cv-

00489] (fw) [Entry date 05/11/94]

ORDER by Judge D. L. Jensen dismissing

party Robert J. Ferreira, party Diablo Clean-

ers, Inc, party Ferreira Farms, Inc. with prej-

udice , dismissing case (see Partial Summary

Judgment re defendants Stephen Barnes and

Ferbar Corporation- 5/9/94) (Date Entered:

6/6/94) (cc: all counsel) [3:93-cv-00489]

(fw) [Entry date 06/06/94]

NOTICE OF APPEAL by plaintiff Bay Area

Laundry&Dry from Dist. Court decision judg-

ment [27-1], judgment [26-1] PAID 109826

[3 :98-cv-00489] (fw)

4

United States Court of Appeals

for the Ninth Circuit

Docket No. 94-15976

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

6/9/94

11/16/95

1/17/96

1/30/96

2/12/96

DOCKETED CAUSE AND ENTERED APPEAR-

ANCES OF COUNSEL. CADS SENT (Y/N) :

yes. setting schedule as follows: CADS due

6/23/94 for Geoffrey White; appellant’s designa-

tion of RT is due 6/16/94; appellee’s designation

of RT is due 6/27/94, , ; appellant shall order

transcript by 7/6/94; court reporter shall file tran-

script in DC by 8/8/94 for Judith Dudeck ; certifi-

cate of record shall be filed by 8/15/94 ; appellant’s

opening brief is due 9/22/94; appellees’ brief is

due 10/24/94, , ; appellants’ reply brief is due

11/7/94; [94-15976] (vt)

ARGUED AND SUBMITTED TO William A.

NORRIS, Robert R. BEEZER, Stephen S. TROTT

[94-15976] (mlm)

FILED PER CURIAM OPINION: AFFIRMED

(Terminated on the Merits after Oral Hearing;

Affirmed; Written, Unsigned, Published. William

A. NORRIS, author; Robert R. BEEZER; Stephen

8S. TROTT, concurring.) FILED AND ENTERED

JUDGMENT. [94-15976] (ot)

Filed original and 40 copies Appellant Bay Area

Laundry petition for rehearing with suggestion for

en banc 06 p.pages, served on 1/30/96 (PNL/

ACTIVE JDGS) [94-15976] (ot)

Filed order (William A. NORRIS, Robert R.

BEEZER, Stephen S. TROTT. ) : Aple is directed

to file a response to aplt’s suggestion for rehearing

en banc filed with this court on 1/30/96. In its

response, aple should address aplt’s argument that

the decision in this case directly conflicts with the

law of three other circuits. The response shall

5

DATE

PROCEEDINGS

2/23/96

5/13/96

not exceed 15 pages, and shall be filed within 14

days of the date of this order. (phoned counsel)

[94-15976] (em)

Filed Appellee Ferbar Corporation’s response to

petition rehearing and for suggestion for enbanc

rehearing, served on 2/23/96 (PANEL & ACTIVE

JDGES) [94-15976] (ot)

Filed order (William A. NORRIS, Robert R.

BEEZER, Stephen 8. TROTT) : denying petition

for rhrg and the suggestion for enbanc rehearing

is rejected. [94-15976] (ot)

5/13/96 MANDATE ISSUED [94-15976] (mlm)

[Filed Feb. 9, 1993]

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

No. C 93 0489 DLJ

BOARD OF TRUSTEES, BAY AREA LAUNDRY AND

Dry CLEANING PENSION TrusT FUND,

Plaintiffs,

v.

FERBAR CORPORATION OF CALIFORNIA, INC., A California

corporation; FERREIRA FARMS, INc., A California cor-

poration; DIABLO CLEANERS, INC., A California corpo-

ration; STEPHEN J. BARNES, and ROBERT J. FERREIRA,

Defendants.

COMPLAINT FOR COLLECTION

OF EMPLOYER WITHDRAWAL

LIABILITY PAYMENTS

{ERISA Section 4301]

Plaintiffs allege:

1. This is an action by the Trustees of an employee

pension benefit plan to collect withdrawal liability pay-

ments from an employer which has withdrawn from the

Plan.

JURISDICTION

2. The jurisdiction of this Court is founded on Sections

4301 and 515 of the Employee Retirement Income Secu-

rity Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”) (29 U.S.C.

Sections 1451, 1145].

3. This action arises under Sections 4219(c),

4221(b)(1) and 502(g)(2) of ERISA {29 U.S.C. Sec-

7

tions 1399(c), 1401(b)(1), and 1132(g)(2)) for viola-

tions of Section 515 of ERISA (29 U.S.C. Section 1145]

VENUE

4. Venue is proper under Section 4301(d) of ERISA

(29 U.S.C. Section 1451(d)]. The BAY AREA LAUN-

DRY AND DRY CLEANING PENSION TRUST FUND

is administered in the Northern District of California. De-

fendants have their principal place of business in the

Northern District of California.

PLAINTIFF

5. At all times herein mentioned, the BAY AREA

LAUNDRY AND DRY CLEANING PENSION TRUST

FUND (“FUND”) was and is an employee pension bene-

fit plan within the meaning of Section 3(2) of ERISA

{29 U.S.C. Section 1002(2)] established and maintained

pursuant to several collective bargaining agreements be-

tween various employers engaged in commerce and AFL-

CIO Laundry, Dry Cleaning, Government and Industrial

Service Union Local 3 (“UNION”), an employee organi-

zation representing employees engaged in commerce, for

the purpose of providing pension and related benefits to

participants in the Fund and thier beneficiaries. The Fund

is a multiemployer plan as defined in Sections 3(37) and

4001(a)(3) of ERISA [29 U.S.C. Sections 1002(37),

1301(a)(3)] and subject to and bound by the terms and

provisions of ERISA, as provided in Section 4 thereof

{29 U.S.C. Section 1003(a)]. The Board of Trustees

of the Fund are the named fiduciaries of the Fund,

and are authorized pursuant to Sections 4301(a)(1) and

502(g)(2) of ERISA [29 U.S.C. Sections 1451(a)(1)

and 1132(g)(2)] to bring this action. The Fund, and the

Pension Plan maintained thereunder, were established pur-

suant to an Agreement and Declaration of Trust as

amended and restated effective July 1, 1974.

DEFENDANTS

6. Defendant FERBAR CORPORATION OF CALI-

FORNIA, INC. (“FERBAR”) is, and at all times herein

mentioned was a California corporation, engaged in the

dry cleaning business, with its principal place of business

in Oakland, California.

7. Defendant FERREIRA FARMS, INC. (“FARMS”)

is, and at all times herein mentioned was a California cor-

poration, engaged in the dry cleanin g business, with its

principal place of business in Oakland. California.

8. Defendant DIABLO CLEANERS, INC. (“DI-

ABLO”) is, and at all times herein mentioned was a

California corporation, engaged in the dry cleaning busi-

ness, with its principal place of business in Walnut Creek,

California.

9. Defendant STEPHEN J. BARNES is, and at all

times herein mentioned was a shareholder, officer and

employee of Defendant FERBAR.

10. Defendant ROBERT J. FERREIRA is, and at all

times herein mentioned was a shareholder, officer and

employee of Defendant FERBAR, FARMS, and DIABLO,

and each of them.

FIRST CLAIM

11. At all times material hereto, Defendant FERBAR

was party to a collective bargaining agreement with the

UNION which obligated FERBAR to contribute to the

FUND on behalf of its covered employees.

12. On or about March, 1985, Defendant FERBAR

completely withdrew as a contributing employer to the

Fund by ceasing to have an obligation to contribute to the

FUND pursuant to collective bargaining with the UNION.

13. By virtue of Defendant FERBAR’s complete with-

drawal from the Fund, Defendants FERBAR, FARMS,

and DIABLO, and each of them, became liable to the

9

Fund for its withdrawal liability payments as determined

in accordance with Section 4201 of ERISA {29 U.S.C.

Section 1381].

14. On or about December 12, 1986, the Fund as-

sessed a withdrawal liability against Defendant FERBAR

in the amount of $45,570.80, and demanded payment in

monthly installments of $345.50 for 240 months, plus a

final payment of $344.96. Said notice and demand for

payment of withdrawal liability fully conformed to applica-

ble law and plan provisions. In accordance with Section

4219(c)(2) of ERISA [29 U.S.C. Section 1399(c)(2)],

Defendant FERBAR was obligated to commence payment

of its assessed withdrawal liability no later than February

1, 1987.

15. Defendant FERBAR requested review and arbitra-

tion of its withdrawal liability. No arbitration ings

have been initiated pursuant to Section 4221 of ERISA

[29 U.S.C. Section 1401].

16. At all times subsequent to February, 1987, De-

fendants FERBAR, FARMS, and DIABLO, and each of

them, have failed and refused, and continue to fail and

refuse to make the required installment payments of its

withdrawal liability, or any of them, or to make a lump

sum total payment thereof.

17. Defendant FERBAR has failed to cure its delin-

quency in payment of withdrawal liability and has de-

faulted in payment of such obligation. In accordance

with Section 4219(c)(5) and 4221(d) of ERISA [29

U.S.C. Sections 1399(c)(5), 1401 (d)], the total amount

of outstanding withdrawal liability is now due and owing

from Defendants in the sum of approimately $45,570.80,

together with interest at the rate specified in ERISA Sec-

tion 4219(c)(6) [29 U.S.C. Section 1399(c)(6)].

10

incur reasonable attorneys’ fees in amounts not yet ascer-

tained.

SECOND CLAIM _—

19. Plaintiffs reallege and replead the allegations con-

tained in Paragraphs 1 through 18, inclusive.

20. Defendants, and each of them, constitute a group of

businesses under common control and a single Employer

within the meaning of Title IV of ERISA [29 U.S.C.

Section 1301 et seq.]

21. By virtue of the facts set forth above, Defendants,

and each of them, are jointly and severally liable for the

amount of employer withdrawal liability assessed against

FERBAR.

THIRD CLAIM

22. Plaintiffs reallege and replead the allegations con-

tained in Paragraphs 1 through 18, inclusive.

23. Defendant FERBAR is and at all times mentioned

has been, the alter ego of, and a mere shell, instrumental-

ity and conduit of Defendants BARNES and FERREIRA,

in that said individual defendants transferred assets and

liabilities to and from the corporation without adequate

consideration and otherwise failed to maintain sufficient

respect for the separate identity of FERBAR.

24. By virtue of the facts set forth above Defendant

BARNES and FERREIRA are jointly and severally liable

for the amount of employer withdrawal liability assessed

against FERBAR.

FOURTH CLAIM

25. Plaintiffs reallege and replead the allegations con-

tained in Paragraphs 1 through 18, inclusive.

26. By reason of the foregoing, there is now due,

owing and unpaid from Defendants to Plaintiffs the sum

of approimately $25,375, being the amount of the de-

11

linquent monthly installment payments from February,

1987 to the date of filing of this action, and the sum of

$345.50 each month thereafter. Plaintiffs will seek leave

to amend this Complaint prior to trial to set forth the

amount remaining unpaid.

27. Plaintiffs have suffered and will continue to suffer

irreparable harm and injury unless Defeudant FERBAR

is preliminarily and permanently enjoined and required by

Order of this Court to comply with its obligations under

ERISA to make payments of its withdrawal liability as

demanded by the FUND. Plaintiffs have suffered the loss

monies owed by Defendants, adversely affecting actu-

pay bemefits to participants. As all remaining contributing

employers have withdrawn from the Plan, the Plan’s only

source of income presently is withdrawal liability pay-

ments. Unless Defendants are compelled to make install-

ment payments as demanded, higher funding costs will be

imposed on other withdrawn employers and the FUND

will soon be insolvent.

28. Plaintiffs have no plain, speedy or adequate rem-

edy at law and will be compelled to file a multiplicity of

actions unless injunctive relief is granted herein.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against

Defendants, and each of them, as follows:

On the First, Second and Third Claims:

1. For unpaid withdrawal liability payments in the sum

of approimately $45,570.80;

On the Fourth Claim:

2. For the sum of $25,375, and for such further sum

we LY De Proved due, owing and unpaid at the time of

trial;

12

3. For a preliminary and permanent injunction requir-

ing Defendants to pay the FUND each and every monthly

withdrawal liability payment in the sum of $345.

On All Claims:

4. For interest on said unpaid withdrawal liability pay-

ments from the date due until actually paid, at the rate

prescribed under ERISA Section 4219(C) (6) [29 U.S.C.

Section 1399(c)(6)];

5. For liquidated damages in an amount equal to said

interest on unpaid withdrawal liability;

6. For reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs in this ac-

tion; and

7. For such other and further relief as the Court deems

just and proper.

Dated: February 9, 1993

Law OFFICES OF GEOFFREY V. WHITE

/s/ Geoffrey V. White

GEOFFREY V. WHITE

Attorney for Plaintiffs

_

13

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

(Title Omitted)

ANSWER TO COMPLAINT

OF DEFENDANTS FERBAR

CORPORATION OF CALIFORNIA

INC. AND STEPHEN J. BARNES

COME NOW Defendants Ferbar Corporation of Cali-

fornia, Inc. and Stephen J. Barnes (hereinafter sometimes

referred to as “Defendants”) and answer the Complaint

on file herein.

1. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 1, 2, 3 AND 4

OF THE COMPLAINT, Defendants admit the allega-

tions contained therein.

2. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 5, 7, 8 AND 10

OF THE COMPLAINT, Defendants lack sufficient in-

formation and belief to answer the allegations contained

therein, and based on said lack of information and belief

Defendants deny the allegations contained therein.

3. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 6 OF THE COM.

PLAINT, Defendants deny the allegations contained

therein. Defendants admit that Defendant Ferbar Cor-

poration (“Ferbar”) was and is a California corporation,

and at one time was engaged in the dry cleaning business

with its principal place of business in Oakland, but deny

that it is currently engaged in the dry cleaning business

or that its principal place of business is located in Oak-

land, California.

4. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 9 OF THE COM.-

PLAINT, Defendants admit that Stephen J. Barnes was

a A

14

and is a shareholder and officer of Defendant Ferbar Cor-

poration of California, Inc. and admit that he was an

employee of Defendant Ferbar Corporation, but denies

that he is an employee of Defendant Ferbar.

5. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 11, 12, 13 AND

17 OF THE COMPLAINT, Defendants deny each and

every of the the allegations contained therein.

6. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 14 OF THE COM-

PLAINT, Defendants deny each and every of the allega-

tions contained therein. Defendants allege that on or

about December 12, 1986 the Fund assessed a with-

drawal liability against Superior French Laundry in the

amount of $45,570.80, and that the Fund directed Su-

perior French Laundry to commence payment of its as-

sessed withdrawal liability no later than February 1,

1987.

7. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 15 OF THE COM.-

PLAINT, Defendants deny that Defendant Ferbar re-

quested review and arbitration of its withdrawal liability,

but allege that Superior French Laundry requested a re-

view and arbitration of its assessed withdrawal liability.

Defendants deny the allegation that no arbitration pro-

ceedings have been initiated pursuant to section 4221 of

ERISA, and alleges that Superior French Laundry timely

and properly initiated arbitration Proceedings pursuant to

section 4221 of ERISA.

8. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 16 OF THE COM-

PLAINT, Defendants deny generally and singularly, each

and every of the allegations contained therein. Defend-

ants affirmatively admit that they failed and continued to

fail to pay the February 1, 1987 and subsequent install-

ment payments and to make a lump sum total payment.

9. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 18 OF THE COM.

PLAINT, Defendants lack sufficient information and be-

lief to answer the allegation contained therein and based

15

on said lack of information and belief, Defendants deny

the allegations contained therein.

10. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 19 OF THE COM-

PLAINT, Defendants incorporate by reference their an-

swers to Paragraphs | through 18, inclusive.

ll. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 20 AND 21 OF

THE COMPLAINT, Defendants deny each and every

allegation contained therein.

12. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 22 OF THE COM-

PLAINT, Defendants incorporated by reference their an-

swers to Paragraphs | through 18, inclusive.

13. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 23 AND 24 OF

THE COMPLAINT, Defendants deny each and every alle-

gation contained therein.

14. ANSWERING PARAGRAPH 25 OF THE COM-

PLAINT, Defendants incorporate by reference their an-

swers to Paragraphs | through 18, inclusive.

15. ANSWERING PARAGRAPHS 26, 27 AND 28

OF THE COMPLAINT, Defendants deny and every alle-

gation contained therein.

AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES

1. AS THEIR FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE.

Defendants allege that the Complaint and each claim

for relief fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a claim

for relief.

2. AS THEIR SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that this action was filed in excess of

the statute of limitations period set forth in 29 U.S.C.

$ 1451(f).

3. AS THEIR THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that at no time did Defendants execute

any written collective bargaining agreement with the

16

Laundry, Dry Cleaning, Government and Industrial Serv-

ice Union Local 3, AFL-CIO.

4. AS THEIR FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that Plaintiff failed to exhaust its ad-

ministrative remedies.

5. AS THEIR FIFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that Plaintiff failed and refused to

participate in timely initiated arbitration proceedings re-

lated to any withdrawal liability in this matter.

6. AS THEIR SIXTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that Plaintiff failed to file this action

as soon as it was practicable for it to do so.

7. AS THEIR SEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DE-

FENSE, Defendants allege that any contributions made by

Superior French Laundry or any Defendants were not

required, and that they were not made under a collective

bargaining agreement or as a result of a duty under

applicable labor-management relations law.

8. AS THEIR EIGHTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE.

Defendants allege that any contributions made by Superior

French Laundry or any Defendants to the Fund should not

have been utilized in making a determination of with-

drawal liability and no such liability should have been

9. AS THEIR NINTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that the Fund was inaccurate in the

manner in which it calculated the withdrawal liability, and

that the Fund did not follow the steps set forth in the

Statute for the second alternative method of calculating

withdrawal liability.

10. AS THEIR TENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE,

Defendants allege that the amount of withdrawal liability

was improperly calculated.

17

11. AS THEIR ELEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DE-

FENSE, Defendants allege that the Fund did not utilize

the proper statutory and regulatory method in calculating

withdrawal liability following the merger of the Dry Clean-

ers and Laundry Workers Pension Trust Fund.

12. AS THEIR TWELFTH AFFIRMATIVE DE-

FENSE, Defendants allege that the improper purpose and

effect of the merger of the Dry Cleaners and Laundry

Workers Pension Trust Funds was to increase the un-

funded vested benefits and concomitant withdrawal lia-

bility of employers in the Dry Cleaners Pension Fund.

13. AS THEIR THIRTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DE-

FENSE, Defendants allege that the assumptions, actuarial

and other information used in determining the unfunded

and vested benefits and calculating the withdrawal lia-

bility was incorrect.

14. AS THEIR FOURTEENTH AFFIRMATIVE DE-

FENSE, Defendants allege that Plaintiff did not follow

the prescribed default and acceleration procedure.

WHEREFORE Defendants pray that:

1. Plaintiffs take nothing by this action.

2. Judgment be entered in favor of Defendants.

3. The Complaint be dismissed against Defendants.

4. Defendants be awarded their reasonable attorneys’

fees.

5. Defendants be awarded their costs of suit herein.

6. The Court grant whatever further relief it deems

just and proper.

DATED: March 23, 1993

18

Respectfully submitted,

LITTLER, MENDELSON, FASTIFF,

Ticuy & MATHIASON

A Professional Corporation

By: /s/ William F. Terheyden

WILLIAM F. TERHEYDEN

Attorneys for Defendants

FERBAR CORPORATION OF

CALIFORNIA, INC. and

STEPHEN J. BARNES

19

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

(Title Omitted)

DEFENDANTS’ STATEMENT OF

UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS

Date: November 24, 1993

Defendant/Moving Parties’

Alleged Undisputed Facts Supporting Evidence

1. Ferbar Corporation owned Decl. of Stephen J. Barnes, p

three facilities : French 1:24-26.

Laundry, One Hour Martinizing

and Diablo Cleaners.

2. Contributions were made by Decl. of Stephen J. Barnes, p

Ferbar to the Bay Area Laundry 1:26—>p. 2

and Dry Cleaning Pension Trust

Fund on behalf of employees

working at three of its facilities

1983.

4. On March 1, 1985, Ferbar Decl. of Stephen J Barnes, p

received a petition signed by em- 2:6-9

ployees working at Superior

French Laundry and One Hour

Martinizing stating that they no

longer wanted to be represented

Defendant/Moving Parties’

Alleged Undisputed Facts

5. Ferbar Corporation made no

contributions to the Pension

Trust Fund on behalf of em-

ployees working at Superior

French Laundry or One Hour

Martinizing commencing in

March 1985 and thereafter.

6. Bay Area Laundry and Dry

Cleaning Pension Fund sent a

letter to Superior French Laun-

dry dated December 12, 1986

establishing a monthly payment

schedule for Superior French's

withdrawal liability and notify-

ing it that Superior French's

first monthly withdrawal liability

payment was due on February 1,

1987.

7. Neither Ferbar Corporation

nor Superior French Laundry

made any withdrawal liability

payment to Bay Area Laundry

and Dry Cleaning Pension Fund

on or by February 1, 1987.

8. The Complaint in this action

was filed on February 9, 1993.

20

Supporting Evidence

Decl. of Stephen J. Barnes, p.

2:10-13.

Decl. of Stephen J. Barnes, p.

2:16-21; Exh. A to Decl. of

Stephen J. Barnes; Complaint,

§ 14.

Decl. of Stephen J. Barnes, p.

3:1-3.

Complaint on file with the Court.

DATED: October 19, 1993

Respectfully submitted,

LITTLER, MENDELSON, FASTIFF,

Ticuy & MATHIASON

A Professional Corporation

By: /s/ William F. Terheyden

WILLIAM F. TERHEYDEN

Attorneys for Defendants 4

FERBAR CORPORATION OF

CALIFORNIA, INC. and

STEPHEN J. BARNES

21

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

(Title Omitted )

DECLARATION OF

STEPHEN J. BARNES

Date: November 24, 1993

I, STEPHEN J. BARNES, declare that this declaration

is given in support of Defendants’ Motion For Summary

Judgment, and that if I were called upon to testify, I

could of my own knowledge testify to the following:

1. [t am a shareholder in Defendant Ferbar Corpora-

tion. At one time, Ferbar made contributions to the Bay

Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pension Trust Fund on

behalf of employees working at three of its facilities.

Those facilities were Superior French Laundry, One Hour

Martinizing and Diablo Cleaners.

2. In 1983, Ferbar ceased making contributions on

behalf of employees working at Diablo Cleaners, as

Diablo was no longer owned by Ferbar at that point.

3. On March 1, 1985, employees working at Su-

perior French Laundry and One Hour Martinizing sub-

mitted a petition to me indicating that they no longer

wanted to be represented by AFL-CIO Laundry Dry Clean-

ing, Government and Industrial Services Local No. 3.

After receipt of that petition, Ferbar ceased to make

contributions to the Pension Trust Fund on behalf of

employees of Superior French Laundry and One Hour

Martinizing commencing in March, 1985, and made no

contributions thereafter. If Ferbar had any obligation to

| _ i em i i

22

contribute to the Pension Trust Fund, it no longer existed

starting in March 1985.

4. By letter dated December 12, 1986, Plaintiff Trust

Fund sent notice to Superior French Laundry that it had

a withdrawal liability obligation to the Pension Fund, and

established a monthly payment schedule for it with the

first payment due on February 1, 1987. A copy of said

notice which I received is attached hereto marked Exhibit

A.

5. Neither Ferbar nor Superior French Laundry made

any withdrawal liability payments to the Pension Fund

on or by February 1, 1987 or at any time thereafter.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of

the State of California that the foregoing is true and

correct.

Executed at San Carlos, California on October 15,

1993.

/s/ Stephen J. Barnes

STEPHEN J. BARNES

23

[ExHisit A]

BAY AREA LAUNDRY AND DRY

CLEANING PENSION FUND

Glen Slaughter & Associates, Administrator

1999 Harrison Street, Suite 500

Oakland, California 94612

Telephone (415) 451-8564

December 12, 1986

Superior French Laundry

* Stephen Barnes

* 1284 W Grand Ave

Oakland, CA 94607

RE: Withdrawal Liability Assessment and Demand for

Payment

Account Number(s): 0912270

Gentlemen:

Our records indicate that you have not contributed to the

Bay Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pension Fund since

March 1985.

Based upon this information, we conclude that you have

withdrawn from the Plan. Accordingly, you are subject

to the withdrawal liability provisions of the Multiemployer

Pension Plan Amendments Act of 1980, a federal enact-

ment amending the Employee Retirement Income Security

Act of 1974 (“ERISA”).

This statute, as you probably know, provides that when

an employer withdraws from participation in a multi-

employer pension plan, the withdrawing employer is obli-

gated to the Plan for a portion of the Plan’s unfunded

vested benefit liabilities as of the end of the Pian

Year immediately preceding the date of the employer’s

withdrawal.

24

Pursuant to the provisions of this statute and to the

implementing regulations promulgated by the Pension

Benefit Guaranty Corporation, the Board of Trustees in

the Plan have adopted certain methods of calculating the

withdrawal liabilities applicable to you. These calcula-

tions are summarized on the attached forms and indicate

a lump sum withdrawal liability assessment amount of

$45,570.80.

You may pay the withdrawal liability set forth in the

preceding paragraph by a single lump sum payment within

60 days after your receipt of this letter.

The Act also permits a schedule of payments as an option

to the lump sum payment. Under the optional schedule,

your first payment of $345.50 for 240 months is due on

February 1, 1987, with a final payment of $344.96. Pay-

ments are due on the first of each month.

The attached worksheet and exhibit illustrate the calcula-

tion of both the lump sum payment and optional schedule.

Should you fail to make your first monthly payment by

its due date, or should you fail to make any subsequent

monthly payments when due, ERISA, as amended, pro-

vides that you will incur interest charges from the date

your payment becomes due until the date payment is fi-

nally received.

Additionally, you may incur liability for liquidated dam-

ages and other sums assessed under the delinquency pro-

visions of the Plan’s Trust Agreement; and, your obliga-

tion may be subject to such additional steps as the

Trustees may require in accordance with the law.

More importantly, should you fail to pay any monthly

payment plus interest within 60 days after receiving writ-

ten notice from the Plan that such payment is delinquent,

or should you commit any other act which the Plan

deems to constitute a “default” in your payment obliga-

25

tions, ERISA, as amended, provides that the Board of

Trustees may deem you to be in default and thereby liable

for immediate payment of the outstanding amount of

your withdrawal liability from the due date of the first

payment which was not timely made. If the Plan has to

sue to collect withdrawal liability, the Act requires the

Court to award to the Plan its costs, attorneys fees, in-

terest and liquidated damages.

Within ninety (90) days from the date you receive this

notice, you may:

(1) Request the Trustees to review any specific

matter relating to the determination of your

company’s liability and payment schedule;

(2) Identify to the Trustees any claimed inaccuracy;

and

(3) Furnish the Trustees with any additional rele-

vant information.

The Plan will review any matter raised by you, and you

will subsequently be notified of the Plan’s decision, the

basis for the decision, and the reason for any change in

the determination of your liability or your schedule to

liability payments. You are required by the Act to make

the payments set forth in this letter notwithstanding any

request for review or appeal of the determination of the

amount of your liability or the schedule of payments. Any

adjustments to your liability will be reflected in your

future payments.

This letter is intended to provide you with notice of your

liability and payment obligations and of the existence of

ERISA, as amended, and of some of its provisions. This

letter is not intended as an explanation of the statute,

nor shall it be construed as limiting in any way the

rights of the Plan under the statute.

26

Sincerely,

BOARD OF TRUSTEES

Encl.: Withdrawal Liability Calculations

cc: All Trustees

Legal Counsel

Actuary

27

[Filed Nov. 10, 1993]

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

(Title Omitted)

DECLARATION OF GEOFFREY V. WHITE

IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION

FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND IN

SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS CROSS-MOTION

FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION

Date: November 24, 1993

I, GEOFFREY V. WHITE, declare as follows:

1. I am the attorney for Plaintiffs; BOARD OF

TRUSTEES, BAY AREA LAUNDRY AND DRY

CLEANING PENSION TRUST FUND, in the above-

captioned matter. I have been the attorney for the Trust

Fund since 1975. I make this Declaration in support

of Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendants’ Motion for Sum-

mary Judgment herein, and for Plaintiffs’ Cross-Motion

for Summary Adjudication of Defendants’ claim the Com-

plaint is barred by the applicable statute of limitations

under ERISA.

2. Attached hereto as Exhibit | is a true and correct

copy of the Withdrawal Liability Assessment and Demand

for Payment, dated December 12, 1986 from the Fund

addressed to Superior French Laundry and Defendants

Stephen J. Barnes. That notice informed Defendants that

they had withdrawn from the Fund by ceasing to make

contributions on and after March, 1985, that the Fund

had calculated Defendants’ withdrawal liability in the sum

28

of $45,570.80, and that Defendants could either pay the

withdrawal liability in a single lump sym payment within

sixty (60) days after receipt of that demand, or pay

the withdrawal liability in monthly payments commencing

February 1, 1987. Further, the Assessment informed

Defendants that failure to pay any installment by the due

date would incur liability for interest and liquidated dam-

ages, and any subsequent failure to pay within sixty (60)

days after receiving written notice that such payment was

delinquent would constitute a default in accordance with

ERISA and the regulations promulgated by the Pension

Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

3. On or about February 27, 1987, Superior French

Laundry submitted its Request for Review of the with-

drawal liability assessment. Attached hereto as Exhibit

2 is a true and correct copy of that letter. As indicated

in the Request for Review, the Employer challenged the

Fund's calculations of its withdrawal liability and denied

that it had any obligation to contribute to the Fund, even

though it had done so for many years, because it had

allegedly never signed a collective bargaining agreement.

4. On or about April 14, 1987, the Fund mailed to

Superior French Laundry a Notice of Delinquency in pay-

ment of its withdrawal liability assessment. A true and

correct copy of that letter is attached hereto as Exhibit 3.

As stated in the Notice of Delinquency,

That letter [the withdrawal liability Assessment] in-

formed you of your monetary obligations as a With-

drawn Employer under ERISA and provided you

with two options for payment: (1) payment of the

entire lump sum within sixty (60) days or, (2) Pay-

ment of the first installment on a series of payments

within sixty (60) days.

The letter continued by stating that since more than sixty

days had elapsed without any payment from the Em-

29

ployer, it was now considered delinquent, and would be

considered in default of its obligations to pay withdrawal

liability unless the delinquency was cured within sixty

days of the date of the Notice of Delinquency.

5. On or about July 8, 1987, Superior French Laundry

submitted its Notice of Initiation of Arbitration in re-

sponse to the Fund’s assessment of withdrawal liability.

Attached hereto as Exhibit 4 is a true and correct copy

of that Notice. Although the Employer provided this

notice of its intent to proceed to arbitration of its dis-

puted withdrawal liability, no arbitration proceedings have

yet commenced. As -ndicated therein, a copy of the

initial Assessment and demand for payment was attached

thereto as Exhibit A, and a copy of the Employers Re-

quest for Review was attached as Exhibit B.

6. In accordance with the Multi-Employer Pension

Pian Amendments Act, which amended ERISA to provide

for calculation and payment of Employer withdrawal lia-

bility, the Fund Trustes adopted rules and regulations

pertaining to employer withdrawal liability under the Pen-

sion Plan in October, 1981. These rules and regulations

were subsequently amended on October 23, 1986. At-

tached hereto as Exhibit 5 is a true and correct copy of

these rules and regulations as adopted by the Trustees.

As stated in Section 5(b) of these Rules,

Withdrawal liability shall be payable monthly, ac-

cording to the schedule determined by the Trustees.

Payment of withdrawal liability shall commence no

later than sixty days after demand is made therefore

by the Trustees.

As further stated in Section 5(b),

Failure to make any payment when due causes the

Employer to be additionally liable for interest, and

the Employer will be considered in default if the

failure to make payment is not cured within sixty

30

days after the Employer receives notice of its

delinquency.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of

the State of California that the foregoing is true and

correct, and that this Declaration was executed on No-

vember 10, 1993 at San Francisco, California.

/s/ Geoffrey V. White

GEOFFREY V. WHITE

(Exhibit 1 Omitted)

31

(Exursit 2)

LITTLER, MENDELSON, FASTIFF & TICHY

A Professional Corporation

Attorneys at Law

650 California Street, 20th Floor

San Francisco, California 94108-2693

(415) 433-1940

February 27, 1987

1999 Harrison Street, Suite 500

P.O. Box 24263

Oakland, California 94623-1263

Re: Superior French Laundry/ Account No. 0912270

Dear Members of the Board:

Pursuant to section 4219 of the Multi-Employer Pen-

sion Plan Amendments Act, the Employer, Superior

French Laundry, hereby submits this request for review of

the withdrawal liability of which you gave notice by letter

of December 12, 1986 which was received by the Em-

ployer on or about December 15, 1986.

The Employer wishes to have the Trustees review their

eemnieedion of etited 1 liability as it beli an te

bility may be imposed on it for the reasons set forth herein.

It also will identify to the Trustees what it believes to be

are inaccuracies in the Trustees’ calculation of the with-

drawal liability.

Under the second alternative method authorized by the

Act and which we believe was utilized by the Fund in

32

determining withdrawal liability, the Fund is to take into

account the “total amount required to be contributed

by the employer under the plan for the last five plan

years ending before the withdrawal.” MPPA Section

4211(c)(3)(B)(i)2 Section 4212 defines “obligation to

contribute” as “an obligation to contribute arising—(1)

under one or more collective bargaining (or related)

agreements, or (2) as a result of a duty under applicable

labor-management relations law, but does not include an

obligation to pay withdrawal liability under this section

or to pay delinquent contributions.”

Although the Employer herein did make contributions

to the Pension Fund, those contributions were not required

in that they were not made under a collective bargaining

agreement or as a result of a duty under applicable labor-

management relations law. The Employer never signed

any collective bargaining agreement with Laundry, Dry-

cleaning and Industrial Service Local 3, AFL-CIO or

with any other union local. Neither was any trust agree-

ment ever signed by the Employer. Under 29 U.S.C.

§ 186(c)(5)(B), it is unlawful for an employer to pay

or agree to pay money to a respresentative of his employ-

ees except where the detailed basis on which such pay-

ments are to be made is specified in a written agreement

with the employer. Unless there is a written agreement

upon which the requirement to contribute is based, the

Fund would be in violation of 29 U.S.C. § 186 if it de-

manded and collected pension contributions. See Moglia

v. Geoghegan, 403 F.2d 110 (2nd Cir. 1968), cert.

denied, 349 U.S. 919 (1969). As the Employer here is

not bound by any collective bargaining agreement and as

no provision of labor-management relations law could re-

11f another method of calculation was used the Employer's posi-

tion would be the same, as the other methods prescribed by Con-

gress also utilize amounts that the Employer was obligated or

required to contribute.

33

quire trust fund contributions in the absence of a writing,”

the Employer was not required or obligated to make any

contributions. Hence, any contributions made by it should

not have been utilized in making a determination of with-

drawal liability and no such liability should have been

; Moreover, the Employer believes that the Fund was

inaccurate in the manner in which it calculated the with-

drawal liability in that the Fund did not follow the steps

set forth in the statute for the second presumptive method.

It does not appear that the value (as of the end of 1984)

of all outstanding claims for withdrawal liability that can

reasonably be expected to be collected from

withdrawing before 1984 was subtracted from the amount

of the plan’s UVB's as of the end of 1984 as required

under section 4211(c)(3). Section 4211 also requires

utilization only of the total contributions for all employers

during the last five plan years preceding the withdrawal.

This amount is to be increased by employer contributions

owed for earlier periods that were collected in those five

years and decreased by amounts contributed by employers

who withdrew under the law’s withdrawal provisions dur-

ing those five years. Under Step 2 of your summary of the

withdrawal liability calculation you speak of total con-

tributions of all employees adjusted for withdrawals before

1984. It appears that the Fund may have taken into

account contributions of employers prior to 1980 and that

it did not make the appropriate increases and decreases

referred to in the section. If that was the case, the calcula-

tions should be completely revised.

Finally, the Employer does not believe that the Fund

utilized the proper statutory or regulatory methods in cal-

culating withdrawal liability following the merger of the

* We are not dealing with a situation where a contract has ex-

pired but an exmployer is required to continue making contribu-

tions because no impasse has been reached. Here the

a written contract in the first place. = by gees

34

Drycleaners and the Laundry Workers Pension Trust

i i ffect

Funds. It believes that the improper purpose and e

of the merger was to increase the unfunded vested bene-

and concomitant withdrawal liability of employers in

ed seenenyetey or It does not believe that the

assumptions, actuarial and other information used in de-

termining the unfunded vested benefits and calculating the

withdrawal liability was correct.

hereb uests that the Trustees review

ody ae of ‘Snuie French Laundry’s with-

drawal liability and withdraw their notice of withdrawal

liability assessment. In the alternative, it specifically re-

quests that the Fund provide it with a copy of its rules on

withdrawal liability, a copy of the documents pertaining

to the Pension Plan mergers and a detailed report of all

calculations it made and the assumptions and information

utilized in determining the unfunded vested benefits and

the Employer’s withdrawal liability.

Very truly yours,

/s/ William F. Terheyden

WILLIAM F. TERHEYDEN

WFT:gmd

bec: Steve Barnes

35

(Exursit 3]

BAY AREA LAUNDRY AND

DRY CLEANING PENSION FUND

Glen Slaughter & Associates, Administrator

1999 Harrison Street, Suite 500

Oakland, California 94612

Telephone (415) 451-8564

April 14, 1987

* Superior French Laundry

* Stephen Barnes

* 1284 W. Grand Avenue

Oakland, CA 94607

RE: Withdrawal Liability Assessment and Demand for

Payment Account Number(s):

Gentlemen:

You have received a Withdrawal Liability Assessment let-

ter from this office under date of December 12, 1986.

That letter informed you of your monetary obligations as

a Withdrawn Employer under ERISA and provided you

with two options for payment: (1) Payment of the entire

lump sum within 60 days or, (2) Payment of the first

installment on a series of payments within 60 days.

Since more than 60 days has elapsed from the date of the

Withdrawal Liability Assessment Letter and we have no

response from you, it is our obligation to inform you of

your status as a Delinquent Withdrawn Employer under

ERISA and as such, additional assessments are now due.

You are required to contact this office within 10 days of

the date of this letter to avoid forced collection.

MOST IMPORTANTLY, FAILURE TO MAKE THE

NECESSARY PAYMENT WITHIN 60 DAYS OF THE

DATE OF THIS LETTER WILL CAUSE YOU TO

36

BECOME A DEFAULTED WITHDRAWN EM-

PLOYER UNDER ERISA WHICH PERMITS THE

BOARD OF TRUSTEES WITHIN THE ACT TO IN-

SIST UPON IMMEDIATE PAYMENT OF THE EN-

TIRE OUTSTANDING AMOUNT OF YOUR WITH-

DRAWAL LIABILITY. You are required by ERISA to

make the necessary payments notwithstanding any request

you may make for review or appeal of the determination

of the amount of your liability or schedule of payments.

Any adjustments to your liability will be reflected in future

payments. If legal action is required to collect Withdrawal

Liability, ERISA requires the court to award to the Plan

its costs, attorney fees, interest and liquidated damages.

Sincerely,

GLEN SLAUGHTER & ASSOCIATES

Administrator

cc: Collection Agent

Delinquency Committee

All Trustees

Legal Counsel

37

{EXHIBIT 4]

LITTLER, MENDELSON, FASTIFF & TICHY

A Professional Corporation

Attorneys at Law

650 California Street, 20th Floor

San Francisco, California 94108-2693

(415) 433-1940

July 8, 1987

CERTIFIED/RETURN

RECEIPT REQUESTED

Bay Area Laundry and Drycleaning

Pension Fund

P.O. Box 24263

Oakland, California 94623-1263

ATTENTION: GLEN SLAUGHTER & ASSOCIATES

Re: Superior French Laundry

Account No. 0912270

Dear Mr. Slaughter:

Please find enclosed the Notice of Initiation of Arbitra-

tion submitted by Superior French Laundry. Please con-

tact me so that we may begin the process of selecting an

arbitrator.

Very truly yours,

/s/ William F. Terheyden

WILLIAM F, TERHEYDEN

WFT:gmd

Enclosure

cc: Stephen Barnes (w/enc. )

38

NOTICE OF

INITIATION OF ARBITRATION

Pursuant to the regulations of the Pension Benefit Guar-

anty Corporation (29 C.F.R. § 2641.2) the Employer,

Superior French Laundry (Account No. 0912270), hereby

initiates arbitration of a withdrawal liability dispute that

it has with the Bay Area Laundry and Drycleaning Pen-

sion Fund and its Trustees.

1. On December 12, 1986, the Bay Area Laundry and

Drycleaning Pension Fund sent a withdrawal liability as-

sessment and demand for payment which is attached

hereto marked Exhibit A.

2. On February 27, 1987, Superior French Laundry

made a request for review pursuant to Section 4219 of

the Multi Employer Pension Plan Amendments Act of the

withdrawal liability assessed by the Fund. A copy of that

request for review is attached hereto marked Exhibit B.

Said request for review was received by the Fund on

March 3, 1987.

3. The Employer received no response from the Pen-

sion Fund to its request for review.

4. The Employer disputes the Plan sponsor’s determi-

nation of its withdrawal liability and is hereby initating

arbitration of the dispute. It includes in its dispute and

seeks to arbitrate all of the issues raised in its request for

review dated February 27, 1987.

DATED: July 8, 1987

Respectfully submitted,

LITTLER, MENDELSON,

FASTIFF & TICHY

By: /s/ William F. Terheyden

WILLIAM F. TERHEYDEN

A Professional Corporation

Attorneys for Superior

French Laundry

39

{Exursit 5]

BAY AREA DRY CLEANERS AND LAUNDRY

WORKERS PENSION PLANS

AMENDMENT NO. 1

to the

RULES AND REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO

EMPLOYER WITHDRAWAL LIABILITY

Effective June 25, 1986, Appendix III, Section 5(d)

shall be amended and a new subsection (e) added, as

follows:

“(d) In the event that an Employer fails to make any

payment when due, interest at a rate determined by

the Trustees in accordance with PBGC regulations,

shall accrue on the payment from the due date until

the date the payment is made.

(e¢) An Employer shall be considered in default if

failure to make any payment is not cured within 60

days after the Employer receives written notice from

the Trustees of such delinquency. An Employer

shall also be considered in default immediately upon

the filing of any petition in bankruptcy, for reorgani-

zation or arrangement, the making of any general

assignment for benefit of creditors or bulk sale of

assets, Or upon insolvency. In the event of default,

the outstanding amount of the Employer’s withdrawal

liability shall immediately become due and payable,

together with accrued interest on the total outstand-

ing liability from the due date of the first untimely

payment, or the date of default, whichever is earlier.”

The undersigned hereby certify that the above Amend-

ment to the Pension Plan was duly adopted by the Board

of Trustees at a meeting held on October 23, 1986.

/s/ Rosie M. Carr /s/ Jim P. Pettersen

Chair Secretary

40

BAY AREA DRY CLEANERS AND LAUNDRY

WORKERS PENSION PLAN

APPENDIX III

RULES AND REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO

EMPLOYER WITHDRAWAL LIABILITY

Section 1. Preamble

This Appendix III to the Bay Area Dry Cleaners and

Laundry Workers Pension Plan sets forth rules and regu-

lations applicable to the determination and payment of

Employer withdrawal Liability as established under the

Multiemployer Pension Plan Amendment Act of 1980

(the Act). These rules and regulations shall apply to

complete or partial withdrawals, as defined in the Act,

occurring after April 28, 1980. The relevant provisions

of the Act shall apply to any matter affecting an Em-

ployer’s withdrawal liability to the extent that such matter

is not addressed in this Appendix III.

Section 2. Calculation of Withdrawal Liability

The amount of the unfunded vested benefits allocable to

an Employee under this Section is the product of

(a) the Plan’s unfunded vested benefits as of the

end of the Plan Year preceding the Plan Year

in which the Employer withdraws, less the value

as of the end of such year of all outstanding

claims for withdrawal liability which can rea-

sonably be expected to be collected from Em-

ployers withdrawing before such year; multiplied

by

(b) a fraction

(1) the numerator of which is the total amount

required to be contributed by the Employer

under the Plan for the last 5 Plan years

ending before the withdrawal, and

41

(2) the denominator of which is the total

amount contributed under the Plan by all

Employers for the last 5 Plan Years ending

before the withdrawal, increased by Em-

ployer Contributions owed with respect to

earlier periods which were collected in

those Plan Years, and decreased by any

amount contributed to the Plan during

those Plan Years by Employers who with-

drew from the Plan under this Appendix

during those Plan Years.

Section 3. Special Rules with respect to Employer

Contributions.

For purposes of this Appendix III, Employer Contribu-

tions will be considered “made”, and amounts will be con-

sidered “contributed” for a Plan Year if they are made on

account of employment rendered in such Plan Year pro-

vided such Employer Contributions and amounts are paid

to the Plan on or before the cut-off date used by the

independent qualified public accountant engaged by the

Trustees pursuant to section 103(a)(3) of ERISA in

determining the total Employer Contribution to be re-

ported on the Plan’s Form 5500 for the Plan Year. Con-

tributions and amounts paid to the Plan after such cut-off

date will be considered made and contributed for the

Plan Year in which they are paid.

Section 4. Actuarial Assumptions.

The actuarial assumptions which shall be used by the

Plan’s enrolled actuary in determining the unfunded

vested benefits of the Plan for purposes of withdrawal

liability shall be the same as those used for purposes of

determining the Plan’s compliance with the minimum

funding standards of section 412 of the Internal Revenue

Code.

42

Section 5. Payment of Withdrawal Liabiilty.

(a) Amount of payment

(1)

(2)

(3)

Except as provided in (2) and (4) below,

and in (c) and (d) below; an Employer

shall pay the amount determined under Sec-

tion 2 (appropriately adjusted for partial

withdrawal as provided in Section 4206 of

ERISA and de minimis reductions as pro-

vided in Section 2(c) of this Appendix and

in Section 4209 of ERISA,) over the pe-

riod of years necessary to amortize the

amount in level annual payments deter-

mined under (3) below, calculated as if

the first payment were made on the first

day of the Plan Year following the Plan

Year in which the withdrawal occurs and

as if each subsequent payment were made

on the first day of each subsequent Plan

Year. Such amortization period shall be

determined based on actuarial assumptions

used in the most recent actuarial valuation

of the Plan.

In any case in which the amortization pe-

riod described in (1) above exceeds 20

years, the Employer’s liability shall be lim-

ited to the first 20 annual payments deter-

mined in (3) below.

Except as provided in (5) below, the

amount of each annual payment shall be

the product of

(A) the average number of Covered Hours

for the three consecutive Plan Years,

during the 10 consecutive Plan Years

ending before the date of withdrawal,

in which the Employer had an obli-

43

gation to contribute for the greatest

number of Covered Hours, and

(B) The highest contribution paid at which

the Employer had an obligation to

contribute under the Plan during the

10 Plan Years ending with the Plan

Year in which the withdrawal occurs.

(C) For purpose of (A) and (B) above,

if an Employer withdraws in a Plan

Year ending before January 1, 1985,

the appropriate number from the fol-

lowing shall be substituted for the

number “10” each time such number

appears.

If the Employer Then the num-

withdraws in the ber substi-

Plan Year ending tuted is

December 31, 1980

December 31, 1981

December 21, 1982

December 31, 1983

December 31, 1984

Oren awn

(4) In the case of a withdrawal of all or sub-

stantially all Employers under the Plan, as

described in Section 4219(c)(1)(D) of

ERISA, (2) above shall not apply, and

total unfunded vested benefits shall be allo-

cated among all such Employers according

to regulations established by the Pension

Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC).

(5) As described in Section 4219(c)(1)(E) of

ERISA, the amount of annual payment

may be adjusted in the event of a partial

withdrawal.

(b) Withdrawal liability shall be payable monthly,

according to the Schedule determined by the

44

Trustees. Payment of withdrawal liability shall

commence no later than 60 days after demand

is made therefor by the Trustees.

(c) An Employer shall be entitled to prepay his

(d)

withdrawal liability and accrued interest without

penalty.

In the event that an Employer fails to make

any payment when due, interest, at a rate de-

termined by the Trustees in accordance with

PBGC regulations, shall accrue on the payment

from the due date until the date the payment

is made. An Employer shall be considered in

default if such failure to make any payment is

not cured within 60 days after the Employer

receives notice from the Trustees of such failure.

In the event of a defualt, the outstanding

amount of the withdrawal liability shall imme-

diately become due and payable.

[Filed Nov. 10, 1993)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

(Title Omitted)

PLAINTIFFS’ COUNTER-STATEMENT OF

UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS

Date: November 24, 1993

Plaintiffs’ Counter-Statement

of Alleged Undisputed Facts

Laundry, One at Martinizing

and Diablo Cleaners.

2. Contributions were made by

Ferbar to the Bay Area Laundry

and Dry Cleaning Pension Trust

Fund on behalf of employees

working at three of its facilities

—Superior French Laundry, One

Hour Martinizing and Diablo

Cleaners.

3. Ferbar ceased making contri-

butions to the Pension Trust

Fund on behalf of employees

working at Diablo Cleaners in

1983.

Supporting Evidence

Admitted!

Admitted.

Admitted.

1 Where indicated, we have admitted the corresponding statement

of fact as set forth in Defendants’ Statement herein.

46

Plaintiffs’ Counter-Statement

of Alleged Undisputed Facts

4. On March 1, 1985, Ferbar re-

schedule for Superior French's

withdrawal liability and notify-

ing it that Superior French's

first monthly withdrawal liability

payment was due on February 1,

1987.

7. Neither Ferbar Corporation

nor Superior French Laundry

made any withdrawal liability

payment to Bay Area Laundry

and Dry Cleaning Pension Fund

on or by February 1, 1987.

8. Superior French Laundry

submitted a Request for Review

of its assessed withdraw! liabil-

ity by the Fund Trustees by let-

ter of February 27, 1987.

Supporting Evidence

Admitted.

Admitted.

Admitted. Decl. of Geoffrey V.

White, Exh. 1.

Admitted.

Decl. of Geoffrey V. White at p.

2; Exhibit 2.

Plaintiffs’ Counter-Statement

of Alleged Undisputed Facts

9. The Fund notified Superior

French Laundry that it was de-

linquent in payment of its as-

sessed withdrawal liability by

letter of April 14, 1987. Neither

Ferbar Corporation nor Superior

French Laundry have made any

payment of withdrawal liability

to the present date.

10. Superior French Laundry

submitted a Notice of Initiation

of Arbitration concerning its dis-

puted withdrawal liability by let-

ter of July 8, 1987. No arbitra-

a proceedings have yet been

47

Supporting Evidence

Decl. of Geoffrey V. White at pp.

2-3; Exhibit 3.

Decl. of Geoffrey V. White at p.

3; Exhibit 4.

11. The Complaint in this action Admitted.

was filed on February 9, 1993.

Respectfully submitted,

Law OFFICE OF GEOFFREY V. WHITE

/s/ Geoffrey V. White

GEOFFREY V. WHITE

Attorney for Plaintiffs

Dated: November 10, 1993

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.