Joint Appendix — Hughes Aircraft Co. v. United States Ex Rel. Schumer
Supreme Court brief1997
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 95-1340 r CLEr KR
IN THE ae
Supreme Court of the Huited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1996
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY :
Petitioner,
Vv.
UNITED STATES EX REL. WILLIAM J. SCHUMER,
Respondent.
On Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit
JOINT APPENDIX
KENNETH W. STARR DAVID SILBERMAN
Counsel of Record Counsel of Record
KIRKLAND & ELLIS BREDHOFF & KAISER, P.L.L.C.
655 Fifteenth Street, N.W. 1000 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005 Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 879-5000 (202) 833-9340
Counsel for Petitioner Counsel for Respondent
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 15, 1996
CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 15, 1996
RP
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Relevant Docket Entries in the United States District
Memorandum from R.J. Soikkeli to B. George,
June 15, 1984
White Paper Entitled “Radar Commoniality,”
February 20, 1986
Report of Audit 86-5, June 23, 1986
Defense Contract Audit Agency Audit Report,
Defense Contract Audit Agency Notice of Contract
Costs Suspended and/or Disapproved [classified],
Defense Contract Audit Agency Notice of Contract
Costs Suspended and/or Disapproved [not
classified], December 10, 1987
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Letter from Thomas Tremper to Joseph Rohlinger,
Noventbar 7, IOGS «0 o.cccckbsenneevenereabesel 66
Disclosure Statement Pursuant to 31 U.S.C.
§ 3730(B)(2), January 17,1989 ........... 00.0005. 67
Complaint, January 20, 1989 ...........0 00.0005 e es 69
Motion for Leave to File a First Amen wd
Complaint [in Plaintiff s Employment
Discrimination Case], June 2,1989 ................ 83
First Amended Complaint, April3, 1990 ............. 87
Notice of Election by the United States Declining
Intervention, May 30, 1990.................005. 103
Affidavit of John Wilson, September 7,1990 ......... 106
Letter from Brian Reilly to Jeffrey McGowan,
September 19, BOGS... . os cccvbnncsseuet tena 110
Supplemental Affidavit of John Wilson,
Sententber FB, 1608... sis cicwtasavececennrsnne 113
Declaration of Laurie Bilbruck, October 12,1990 ..... 116
Letter from Brian Reilly to John Wilson,
Pobouary 5, 1008 06... ic idwbensvedis eau 118
Letter from John Wilson to Brian Reilly,
Pabsunty 11, 1008 .. cee duuviecbabeveieessree 119
Transcript of Proceedings Before the District Court,
Pabomany 34, BORE 4. vs sccevewerecees eee 120
Letter from Thomas Woolpert to John Wilson,
rere mtr ay A RT hy ee 125
Letter from John Wilson to Thomas Woolpert,
Agee S, TPE oc ckidess Perereype ss ie Fee 130
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Memorandum from Donald Erickson to Brian Reilly,
ED 132
Defense Contract Audit Agency Memorandum by
Jeffrey McGowan, November 14,1991........... 134
Letter from Brian Reilly to Everett Parker,
I 136
Deposition of Robert Davis, December 10,1991 ...... 138
Deposition of Brian Reilly, December 17, 1991
Qui Tam Plaintiff s Separate Statement of Material Facts,
a we cc ccectecccccc: 146
Declaration of Dudley Slater, January 21,1992 ....... 157
Declaration of Joseph Rohlinger, January 21,1992 .... 161
Declaration of Edward Samuel Balucas,
II, Bs BU CEG i ee alec tices ee cece 165
Declaration of Howard Stone, January 22,1992 ..._.. 168
Declaration of Joseph Rohlinger, January 23,1992 .... 170
Declaration of John Wilson, January 23,1992 ........ 171
Reise sad Aucachies in Seppor-ot— — --—
___ Memorandum of
————--—=~_Befendant’s Motion to Dismiss, January 27, 1992 .
|
Qui Tam Plaintiff s Memorandum of Points and
Authorities in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for
Summary Judgment, February 18,1992 ............ 179
Declaration of William Schumer, February 18, 1992 186
Supplemental Declaration of John Wilson,
De cen ewes 187
Declaration of Yvonne Perlberg, February 28, 1992... . 189
iv v
TABLE OF CONENTS - CONTINUED Defense Contract Audit Agency Memorandum by
Page Jeffrey McGowan, July 10,1992 ............ ...
Defendant Hughes Aircraft Company’s Reply to Letter from Brian Reilly to Fred McNutt,
Plaintiff s Opposition to Motion for Summary FT He GUE VEPs Ca ReU RS Ce RS U a Ve Cee ccc ee oe
lS er eae 191 Opinion of the Court of Appeals, August 22,1995 ....
Order of the District Court Denying Defendant's Order of the Court of Appeals Denying Defendant's
Motion to Dismiss, May 19, 0 EE a 196 Petition for Rehearing and Rejecting Defendant's
Order of the Court of Appeals Granting Defendant’s Suggestion for Rehearing En Banc,
Motion to Stay Issuance of the Mandate, cc toEushusbcceccccesce
SC UL CET 6b vnd.ene te nmeeaduedae cs 6 ox 197
Department of Defense Contract Pricing Proposal,
A eh ee ee 198
pages in the appendix to the printed Petition for
Certiorari:
Order of the District Court Denying Defendant's
jon to Dismiss, Defendant’s Motion for Summary
_______— Fae eee
Judgment, and Plaintiff's Motion to Defer Consideration
of Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment,
ST nds abs s chabtiebhdieriaio vee 34a
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES ex re/., SCHUMER,
Vv.
HUGHES AIRCRAFT Co.
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE NO. CV 89-0390 MRP
4/19/89
2
3
NOTICE OF SERVICE on the United
States filed by plaintiff.
STIPULATION of relator and the
United States for an order lifting seal,
extending time of the United States to
inform the Court of its election whether
ORDER that the seal placed upon this
action by 31 U.S.C. § 3730(b) be lifted
as of the date of this order; relator be
2
10/23/89
1/24/90
3/13/90
11
13
16
PROCEEDINGS
investigation of relator’s allegations
and inform the Court be extended to
7/24/89; all other proceedings in this
action be stayed until ten days after the
United States has informed the Court of
its election.
ORDER that the time within which the
United States may complete its investi-
gation of the relator’s allegations and
inform the Court of its election whether
to intervene in this action shall be
extended to and including 1/23/90, and
that all other proceedings in this action
shall be stayed until 10 days after the
United States has informed the Court of
its election.
ORDER extending time to 3/27/90 for
the United States to complete
investigation of relator’s allegations
and inform the Court of its election; all
other proceedings shall be stayed until
ten days after the United States has
informed the Court of its election.
ORDER that the time within which the
United States may complete its
3
4/3/90
5/31/90
7/23/90
7/23/90
7/27/90
No.
18
19
21
23
PROCEEDINGS
investigation of the relator’s allegations
and inform the Court of its election
whether to intervene in this action shall
be extended to and including 5/30/90
and that all other proceedings in this
action shall be stayed until ten days
after the United States has informed the
Court of its election.
* * * *
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
filed by plaintiff William J. Schumer.
NOTICE OF ELECTION by the United
States declining intervention filed by
the United States.
. * * *
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion to
dismiss ‘pursuant to Rule 12(b)(1) for
authorities, returnable 9/24/90 at 10:00
a.m., filed by defendant.
MEMORANDUM of points and au-
thorities in support of defendant’s
motion to dismiss filed by defendant.
OPPOSITION to motion to dismiss
filed by plaintiff.
9/7/90
9/7/90
9/7/90
9/28/90
10/3/90
No.
28
29
31
37
38
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion for
summary judgment in favor of
defendant Hughes Aircraft Co. pursuant
to FRCP 56(b), returnable 10/29/90 at
10:00 a.m., filed by defendant. . . .
MEMORANDUM 1 of points and
authorities in support of defendant
Hughes Aircraft Co.’s motion for
summary judgment pursuant to FRCP
filed by defendant.
* . * >
AFFIDAVIT of John F. Wilson filed by
defendant.
> > * >
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion for
partial summary judgment, returnable
10/29/90 at 10:00 am., filed by
laintiff
STIPULATION AND ORDER that for
the purpose of defendant’s motion for
summary judgment, the supplemental
affidavit of John F. Wilson may be
filed.
5
10/15/90
10/15/90
10/22/90
10/22/90
10/22/90
10/29/90
42
47
49
PROCEEDINGS
OPPOSITION to plaintiff's motion for
partial summary judgment filed by
defendant.
> * * >
STATEMENT of genuine issues of
material fact filed by defendant.
> > > >
OPPOSITION by plaintiff to
defendant’s motion for summary
judgment pursuant to FRCP 56 filed by
laintiff
> > > >
SUPPLEMENTAL OPPOSITION to
defendant’s motion for summary
judgment filed by plaintiff.
REPLY to opposition to plaintiff's
motion for partial summary judgment
filed by plaintiff.
6
11/1/90
11/13/90
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
No
51
52
101
102
PROCEEDINGS
ee
partial summary judgment; counsel for
plaintiff to prepare order. M.O. C/R B
Zaccaro.
ORDER that the motion to dismiss by
defendant is hereby denied; the motion
for summary judgment by defendant is
summary judgment by plaintiff is
denied; the motion to defer
consideration of the motion for
summary judgment by plaintiff is
hereby denied.
ANSWER to first amended complaint
filed by defendant Hughes Aircraft Co.
* * * *
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion to
dismiss for lack of subject matter
jurisdiction, returnable 3/9/92 at 10:00
a.m., filed by defendant; order lodged.
7
Date ’ PROCEEDINGS
Sr
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
1/27/92
104
105
107
108
109
110
111
MEMORANDUM of points and au-
thorities in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion for
summary judgment, returnable 3/9/92 at
10:00 am., filed by defendant.
Proposed statement of uncontroverted
facts and conclusions of law lodged.
Order lodged.
MEMORANDUM of points and
authorities in support of motion to
dismiss for lack of subject matter
jurisdiction filed by defendant
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
EXHIBITS in support of motion for
summary judgment filed by defendant.
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion to
amend to include claims, returnable
3/9/92 at 10:00 a.m., filed by plaintiff.
NOTICE OF MOTION and motion to
return action to jury docket, returnable
3/9/92 at 10:00 a.m., filed by plaintiff.
Date No. PROCEEDINGS
estes
2/19/92
2/19/92
2/19/92
2/19/92
2/19/92
115
116
117
118
119
OPPOSITION to plaintiff's motion to
amend complaint to include claims . . .
filed by defendant.
* * * *
EXHIBITS in support of separate
Statement of material facts in
Opposition to defendant’s motion for
summary judgment filed by plaintiff.
SEPARATE STATEMENT OF
MATERIAL FACTS in Opposition to
defendant’s motion for summary
judgment filed by plaintiff.
MEMORANDUM 1 of points and
ates in opposition to defendant's
motion summary judgment filed by
plaintiff.
OPPOSITION to motion to dismiss and
declaration of William J. Schumer in
support thereof filed by plaintiff.
NOTICE OF ERRATA respecting
Opposition to defendant’s motion to
dismiss filed by plaintiff.
* * * *
9
Date PROCEEDINGS
ee
3/2/92
3/2/92
3/2/92
3/2/92
3/9/92
225
226
229
231
232
REPLY to Schumer’s opposition to
motion to dismiss filed by defendant.
EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS and
motion to strike certain evidence
submitted in opposition to (1) motion to
dismiss and (2) motion for
judgment filed by defendant.
REPLY to plaintiff's opposition to
motion for summary judgment filed by
defendant.
REPLY to plaintiff's opposition to
Statement of uncontroverted facts and
conclusions of law in support of motion
for summary judgment filed by
defendant
EXHIBITS in support of reply to
Opposition to motion for summary
judgment filed by defendant
* * * *
REPLY to opposition to motion to
amend complaint to include claims filed
by plaintiff
OPPOSITION to defendant Hughes
Aircraft Co.’s evidentiary objections
and motion to strike certain evidence
3/11/92
233
6/15/92
246
247
250
253
Date PROCEEDINGS
ee
ORDER that the motion to dismiss is
DENIED. (entered 5/26/92) mailed
copy/noticed
ORDER that Hughes’ motion for
summary judgment is GRANTED.
(entered 5/26/92) mailed copies/noticed
and MD JS-6
NOTICE OF APPEAL to the Ninth
Circuit Court of Appeals from order
filed on 5/20/92 filed by plaintiff. Fees
paid. Party service to: Linda Maclean:
James Gallagher: Vincent B. Terlep on
6/18/92.
CROSS APPEAL to the Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals from order entered on
5/20/92 and order filed on 11/1/90 by
defendant. Fees paid. Party service to:
Mark R. Troy: Dean Francis Pace:
Michael F. Hertz on 7/8/92.
AMENDED NOTICE OF APPEAL to
the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
from order filed on 4/2/92 filed by
plaintiff. Party service to: Linda
Maclean: McKenna & Cuneo: Vincent
B. Terlep on 6/7/92. Fees waived.
12
Date No. PROCEEDINGS
eens
> 6 > a.
8/10/92 264 REPLY to Qui Tam plaintiff Schumer’s
Opposition to motion for award of
Ty © Sees, declension of Bask R.
roy.
13
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
NINTH CIRCUIT
Defendant-Appellee, Cross-Appellant
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE NOS. 92-55759 AND
92-55857
Date
12/10/92
1/21/93
PROCEEDINGS
First BRIEF and 15 copies filed by William J.
Schumer in 92-55857, (Informal: no) of 45
pages and | excerpts of record; served on
11/27/92 [92-55857, 92-55759] (ft) [92-55759
92-55857]
Second BRIEF and 15 copies filed by
(Informal: no) of 55 pages and 5 excerpts of
record; served on 1/19/93. [92-55759, 92-
55857] (sw) [92-55759 92-55857]
3/17/93
9/12/95
(92-55759, 92-5585 (92-55759 92.
$5857) 7) (sw) [92-55759 92
REPLY BRIEF and 15 copies filed by Hughes
Auremaft Co., (Informal: no) of 25 Pages; served
om 315/93 [92-55759, 92-55857] (sw) [92-
55759 92-5$857]
Stephen R. REINHARDT;
) Filed and Entered
Judgment. [92-55759, 92-55857] (bh) [92-
55759 92-55857]
ee ee
11/17/95
11/24/95
11/29/95
Judges) [92-55759, 92-55857] (gva) [92-55759
92-55857]
suggestion for rehearing en banc is
REJECTED. [92-55759, 92-S5857} (hin) [92-
55759 92-55857)
MOTION to stay issuance of mandate pendimg
petition for writ of certiorari and declaration of
Appellant Hughes Aircraft Co.; served on
11/22/95 (to DWN) [92~55759, 92-55857} (hh)
[92-S5759 92-55857]
ORDER filed (Dorothy W. NELSON, Stephen
R. REINHARDT, Melvin BRUNETTI):
Hughes Aircraft Company's motion to stay
issuance of mandate pending petition to
Supreme Court for writ of certiorari is hereby
GRANTED. [92-55759, 92-5$857] (hh) [92-
55759 92-55857]
16
COST ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD COVER SHEET AND
0.2
0.3
04
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT CERTIFICATION
REQUIRED BY PUBLIC LAW 91-379
Item
No
0.1 Company or Reporting Unit:
Name RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
Street Address
City, State and ZIP Code
Division or Subsidiary of HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
(if applicable)
Reporting Unit is: (Check one.)
A. © Corporate (home) office B. ® Group office
C. 0 Division or subsidiary D. 0 Other
Official to Contact Concerning this Statement:
Name and title PAUL HENDRICKS
MANAGER, GOVERNMENT
ACCOUNTING
Phone number (including
area code and extension) (213) 414-7178
Date of:
This statement 2 January 1984 (Submitted 3 July 1984)
Most recent prior statement
17
| certify that to the best of my knowledge and belief this Statement is
the complete and accurate disclosure as of the above date by the above-
named organization of its cost accounting practices, as required by the
Disclosure Regulation of the Cost Accounting Standards Board under 50
U.S.C. App. 2168, Public Law 91-379 (4 CFR 351).
NOT TO BE DISCLOSED
Information contained herein is J.R. ROHLINGER’s/ J.R. Rohlinger
proprietary to Hughes Aircraft
Company, is submitted in
confidence, and is protected and (Name)
| exempt from disclosure by the
U.S. Government under
paragraph (5) of the Freedom of
Information Act [illegible GROUP CONTROLLER, RADAK
phrase]. SYSTEMS GROUP
(Title)
THE PENALTY FOR MAKING A FALSE STATEMENT IN THIS
DISCLOSURE IS PRESCRIBED IN 18 U.S.C. 1001
. . © .
COST ACCOUNTING CONTINUATION SHEET
STANDARDS BOARD
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT raw 60853 Page
REQUIRED BY PUBLIC LAW
91-379 Name of Reporting Unit
Radar Systems Group
Item
No. Item Description
2.5.0 Method of Charging Direct Labor (Con'd)
Security on highly classified Special Programs is charged
direct when it is program unique, customer directed
and/or meets the requirements of Item 3.1.0.
5.
Other
(1)
(2)
Other direct labor, such as fabrication support,
cycle inventories, inventory control, stores
Support, printed wiring board support, etc., is
collected in pool accounts and applied as a
direct charge to the product on the basis of basic
direct labor charges in the department
benefitting from the effort.
The pool accounts are cleared annually and new
accounts established.
Direct supervision labor, and effective
September 1984 secretaries to direct classified
Supervision, involved in multiple contract effort,
is normally collected in pool accounts and
applied as direct charge to government
Contracts, or similar cost objectives, on the basis
(3)
(4)
19
of direct labor charges within the supervisor's
organization.
Dispatch labor involved in multiple contract
effort is collected in pool accounts and is
applied as a direct charge to Government
contracts, or similar cost objectives, on the basis
of direct labor charges within the benefitting
section.
Direct labor cost incurred for engineering
design, support and manufacture of common
hardware is collected in a holding account and is
allocated to contracts based on contemplated
requirements.
20
Memorandum UNCLASSIFIED
Northrop Corporation
In reply refer to P6OO-RJS-84-113
RUS: im
CLASSIFICATION CHANGED TO
AUTHORITY OF 132
BY _ DATE 10-30
To __B. George, ACO From: R. J. Soikkeli
15 June 1984
Subject | REQUEST FOR GOVERNMENT AUDIT
ASSISTANCE - HUGHES AIRCRAFT
Copies K.L. Thompson
R. K. Blakeney
1) 20 Sea tee povidone of DAR. 3-
-¢X3), Northrop Advanced Systems
against prime contract F33657-8 1-C-0067.
Subcontract 3MS-290450 AK.
funding responsibilities to develop an Analog
Signal Converter (ASC) and Radar Data
Processor (RDP) and costs associated with
initial fabrication of EDM hardware between
the F-15 Radar Program Office and the AP-10
Radar Program Office at Hughes has been
major concerns are:
a. What is the authority to accumulate cost
21
b. What are the costs ramifications for
interdependence between a black world
cost reimbursable type contract and a
white world firm fixed price type
contract.
c. The major concern to us is the agreement
by the vendor’s programs to share cost
without our knowledge and concurrence.
The baseline proposal negotiated with
Hughes includes total cost for design and
development of these units.
d. Journal voucher of commonality
accounts, what is the method used to
allocate cosi between both programs.
3) The interdepartmental correspondence
Memorandum of Agreement are referenced as
follows:
a. Reference: 2172-62483/2
Dated: 24 June 1983
Subject: Allocation of
Development and
Fabrication Tasks for the
Analog Signal Converter
b. Reference: 2172-62483/1
Dated: 24 June 1983
Subject: Allocation of
Development and
Fabrication Tasks for the
Advanced Radar Data
Processor, Revision A
4)
5)
6)
7)
22
The cognizant DCAA and AFPRO offices are
located on site. Copies of the subject
of Agreement can be obtained
Audit findings are requested as soon as possible
to determine the cost impact to our negotiated
contract and related activities.
NASD has been denied access to the
"$s account records.
If additional data and/or discussion on this
request is required, please contact Mr. K. L.
Thompson, Price/ Cost Analysis, Ext, 24975 or
Mr. R. K. Blakeney Manager, Avionics
Subcontracts, Ext. 24175.
/s/ R.J. Soikkeli
R. J. Soikkeli,
Materiel Cost Management
P600/2A - Ext. 24987
Enclosure
23
2/20/86
RADAR COMMONALITY
PURPOSE
This white paper has been drafted to recap the chronology of
events through which the concept of commonality hardware
accounts has evolved at 118A.
INTRODUCTION
An internal Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) was
developed by 118A to define the common and unique tasks
associated with the development of advanced radar systems
and set forth funding responsibilities of each program using
common items for these radar systems.
BACKGROUND
An advanced Radar Data Processor (RDP) design was
conceived by 118A and development of this design was
initiated by the F-15 Radar Program Office for the F-15,
Mulit-stage Improvement Program (MSIP). During
December 1982, when MSIP customer funds were firmly
committed and design progress was sufficient to indicate low
technical and schedule risks, the Special Programs (SP) (AP-
10) Program Office proposed this advanced RDP to their
customer for system implementation with no technical,
schedule or cost impact attendant thereto. The proposed
application was approved by the Special Programs customer
in January 1983. 118A then developed an internal
commonality MOA which established the development tasks
for this RDP, and defined the shared funding responsibilities
between the MSIP and SP Program offices. This
Memorandum of Agreement was approved by 118A’s Senior
Management, then unilaterally implemented by 118A with
no customer participation. This 118A internal concept of
24
commonality was subsequently expanded these
program offices to include internal agreements nnnewat’
with common design tasks applicable to the development of
~ Analog Signal Converter (ASC) Unit/ Subunit. This
reased in was also ij
—s terdependency " implemented without
In September 1984 118A’s F-14 Program Offi ]
’ ce
ahead for an upgrade of the Radar, based on MSIP
technology for the F-14 aircraft, This now presented a more
complex commonality issue involving three 118A programs:
F-15 MSIP, Special Programs, and F-1 4D. .
1982 - 118A MOA) i
The baseline concept of commonality was defined in the
following context:
l. “Common hardware is defined drawings/
specifications which establish ma
requirements and design for the fabrication,
assembly, inspection and test of items for multi-
program usage.”
2. the 14 December 1982 Memorandum of
greement funding responsibilities for the Radar
Data Processor are as follows:
a. The F-15 Program will continue funding all
development efforts for the 8 common
c. Costs associated with fabrication, assembly
25
allocated in direct proportion to the quantity
of modules delivered to each program.
d. Each program is responsible for funding their
own unique hardware procurements.
¢. Development, fabrication and/or procurement
of the hardware required for the DSIS station
for each program, including the HOST and
STE Computer and respective peripherals
would be funded by capital expenditures
approved for each program. The common
STE support softy are would be funded by the
F-15 Program Office.
MAY 1984 INDICATED FINAL COST (IFC)
The subject IFC exercise revealed, for the first time, an
extraordinary amount of cost growth for those items
involved in the 118A Commonality scheme. The Radar Data
Processor (RDP) reflected an unauthorized growth of $2
million. The Analog Signal Converter (ASC) was shown to
have $4.6 million worth of unauthorized growth. The Radar
Signal Processor (RSP) was shown to have unauthorized
growth in the amount of $1.2 million and the rationale
furnished by the subcontractor was that these items were
now in commonality accounts. When requested, no
commonality plans were available from | 18A’s Special
Programs Program Office.
DCAA AUDIT ASSIST REQUEST
On 15 June 1984, a request was made through Barbara
George, ACO at 190A, for government audit assistance
generated by Mr. R. J. Soikkeli, Manager, Materiel Cost
Management. Mr. Soikkeli’s letter outlined our concerns
regarding the establishment of the accounts, first of all, and a
In February 1985, the intemal Memorandum of Agreement
was expanded once again by 118A, to include the F-14D
Program and expanded the scope of commonality subjects to
tasks included such things as development task “phasing.”
What had previously (in 12 December 1982) been described
as development tasks” were now being described as Initial
proportionate percentage share (per the Memorandum of
Agreement) is journaled from the common pool of costs to
27
their program accounts. They do not know in advance what
is coming, or for what tasks they are being billed. In other
words, they have no control over their participation in the
commonality Memorandum of Agreement scheme.
MORE ADDED SCOPE
In June 1985, yet another revision to the 118A MOA was
issued under the signatures of Mr. J. R. Rohlinger, Group
Vice President and Controller, and Mr. J. R. Giacoletto,
Group Vice President. This new revision includes, once
again, the funding percentage responsibilities for each of the
program offices mentioned previously. The revision
increases the number of hardware designs that are being
made common to all three programs, thereby increasing the
Special Programs investment obligation without prior
knowledge or concurrence by the customer.
SUMMARY
One of the glaring deficiencies in this Memorandum of
Agreement scheme is that no dollar values have ever been
specified, estimated, or even suggested. Only a percentage
relationship of whatever it costs is indicated.
Through the efforts of the AP-10 Business Manager, the
services of a special auditor have been provided through the
SPO. The auditor is interfacing directly with the other two
SPO’s who are participating in these MOA’s and will deter-
mine whether or not either of the other customers were
28
aware that they, » 4s well as we, are completely interdependent
from a design, schedule, and funding standpoint.
R. K. Blakeney
Major Subcontract Administrator
Radar/DMS Systems ystems Subcontracts
P330/2A, Extension 88245
CONCURRENCE:
/s/S. Rubenstein
S. Rubenstein
Avionics Controller
BS551/2A, Extension 24206
//RC.Davis
R. C. Davis
Radar
Engineering
E551/3E, Extension 23849
29
UNCLASSIFIED
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
HEADQUARTERS AIR FORCE AUDIT AGENCY
* AIR FORCE BASE, CA *
AGS 23 Jun 1986
Report of Audit 86-5, Review of Common Advanced Radar
Development Costs
ASD/CC ASD/Y6
1. Background: Hughes Aircraft Company, Radar System
Group (RSG) is developing, or improving, three radar systems
under full-scale development subcontracts from three DOD
prime contractors: Northrop for the Advanced Technology
Bomber (ATB); McDonnell Douglas for the F-15 Multi-Stage
Improvement Program (MSIP), and Grumman for the F-14D.
The Northrop subcontract is a cost-plus incentive fee (CPIF)
contract with an original definitized value of $155 million
(current estimate is $350 million). The McDonnell Douglas
subcontract is a fixed price incentive fee (FPIF) contract with
a ceiling price of $147.3 million (this contract is currently at
ceiling and projecting a loss of about $10 million). The
Grumman subcontract is an undefinitized firm fixed price
(FFP) contract with a not to exceed price of $409.2 million.
2. Each contract was negotiated as a stand alone effort. The
F-15 contract was for development efforts to upgrade their
existing system. The upgrade included major subunits that
30
were to be used on the ATB and would subsequently be used
(RSP) will share a total of 31 common hardware items. Four-
teen of the 31 hardware items will be used by all three radar
systems and the other 17 items will be common to at least two
systems.
3. Scope: This audit was requested by the Director of the ATS
Program Office (ASD/Y6). The objective was to determine
whether the costs accumulated by Hughes for the development
of common radar hardware accurately reflected resource
application and were equitably distributed among the partici-
pating programs. Our audit included review of contractual
documentation at the F-15 System Program Office, discussions
Memorandums of Agreement (MOAs). We also obtained
assistance from the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA)
4. (U) Overall Evaluation: Hughes has charged development
costs to all three customers that should be bome by the F-15
MSIP. The decision to distribute these costs and the ratio for
the distribution were made internally by Hughes with no input
from the appropriate government program offices or the prime
contractors. The DCAA audit of costs accumulated in the
31
identify significant discrepancies in common account billings.
This report and related data have been provided to the Defense
Procurement Fraud Unit for further action as they deem
appropniate.
5. Findings: Hughes had allocated $21.4 million of common
hardware development costs to the ATB and F-14D contracts.
These costs were, in our opinion, more appropriately charge-
able to the F-15 contract. Our analysis of the types of con-
tractor activity charged to six general ledger accounts indicate
they are used as cost collection accounts for hardware
development of the ASC, RDP, RSP, associated power
supplies and related sustaining engineering. As of 24 January
1986, $43 million had been charged to these accounts
(Attachment 1) with $40 million billed ($20.3 million to the F-
15, $5.7 million to the F-14D and $14 million to the ATB).
Hughes developed internal MOAs between the separate
Hughes program managers for cost sharing as early as
December 1982 and established accounts for the collection of
development costs on efforts they deemed common to more
than one system. However, the McDonnell Douglas (F-15)
subcontract was proposed, evaluated, and negotiated as a stand
alone effort. This subcontract required Hughes to design,
develop, fabricate, and test the new MSIP radar and did not
address any cost sharing with other programs. Therefore, it is
our opinion, it was not appropriate for Hughes to allocate any
of the nonrecurring development costs for the MSIP items to
the other programs.
6. (U) Auditor's Note: The McDonnell Douglas (F-15) full-
scale development contract is in an overrun condition. Every
dollar of development effort charged to that contract is a dollar
loss to Hughes. The allocation of development costs to the
other contracts reduces their loss. McDonnell Douglas also
has 1985 and 1986 production contracts with Hughes for
MSIP radars. Hughes charged these production contracts for
some of the McDonnell Douglas share of the development
costs in the “common accounts” thereby further avoiding
32
losses on the full-scale development contract. F-15 MSIP
system program office personnel stated they had identified
these charges during a financial review and were pursuing an
adjustment from Hughes through their prime contractor.
7. (U) Recommendations: ASD/CC should, with participation
from the F-14D program office, establish a working group (we
suggest chaired by ASD/Y6) to work out a unified position on
both the adjustments required for prior charges and a new
policy for all remaining efforts on development for all three
radar systems. We suggest the group should be authorized to
establish ground rules with Hughes for the following:
a. Firm definition of what development efforts are
chargeable to each contract.
b. Recoupment for erroneous charges already billed.
c. Continuous review of the overall radar
development effort (we suggest the AFPRO be included in the
working group and considered for the oversight role).
d. Mutual evaluation of cost vs benefits by program
on design and specification changes previously approved and
any proposed in the future.
8. (U) Management Comments: Management comments
(Attachment 2) were responsive to the findings and recommen-
dations in this report.
/s/ J.H. Stolarow
J.H. STOLAROW 2 Atch
The Auditor General 1. Hughes Cost Distribution
2. Management comments
cc: AF/AC
AF/RD-L
AFSC/CC
ASD/TAF
(attachments omitted in printing)
33
AUDIT REPORT NO. 4511-7B486004 OCT 16 1986
AUDIT REPORT ON REVIEW OF COSTS
FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF COMMON ADVANCED
RADAR EQUIPMENT
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
Under the provisions of Title 32, Code of Federal Regulations,
Part 290.26(b) (2), any Freedom of Information Act requests
for audit reports received by DCAA will be referred to the
cognizant contracting officer for determination as to releas-
ability and a direct response to the requester.
Contractor information contained in this audit report may be
confidential. The restrictions of 18 USC 1905 should be
considered before this information is released to the public.
This report may not be released to any Federal agency outside
the Department of Defense without the approval of
Headquarters, DCAA, except to an agency requesting the
report in negotiating or administering its contract.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
LOS ANGELES REGION
HUGHES CORPORATE RESIDENT OFFICE
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
34
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
LOS ANGELES REGION
Corporate Resident Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
200 N. Sepulveda Blvd. (E12/C130)
El Segundo, CA 90245/2463
Audit Report No. 4511-7B486004 OCT 16 1986
SUBJECT: Report on Review of Costs for the
Development of Common Advanced Radar
Equipment
Hughes Aircraft Company
Radar Systems Group
TO: Mr. Timothy J. Boyan
Audit Manager, Special Projects
Air Force Audit Agency/AGS
Building 252, Area C
Wright-Patterson AFB, OH. 45433
1. Purpose and Scope of Review.
a. In accordance with your request, dated 21 march
1986, and subsequent discussions, we have performed a review
of the cost incurred for the development of common advanced
radar equipment. The review was performed to assure the
accounting propriety of these costs.
b. Our review was performed in accordance with
generally accepted governmental auditing standards and
included such tests of the accounting records and other
auditing procedures we considered necessary in the
circumstances. It included the following related to the cost
incurred for the development of the common advanced radar
equipment.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
35
(i) Analysis of monthly direct labor cost from
inception to date.
(ii) Analysis of cost adjustments.
(iii) Limited physical observations (floor-
checks) of labor recording practices and review of work
assignment documents of certain employees who were charg-
ing time to the subject effort. Verification of the employees’
time card entries to the labor distribution records.
(iv) Coordination with the Air Force Plant
Representative Office (AFPRO) technical representatives to
determine the validity of the assumptions regarding whether
the F-15 contract should bear the full development costs and to
determine the reasonableness of the methodology developed
by the company for the allocation of the costs to the F-15, F-
14D, and the special project programs.
(v) Analysis of the contractor's Cost
Accounting Standard disclosure statement to determine its
adequacy.
2. Background Information.
The contractor established several holding accounts to
accumulate the costs for the development of the common
advanced radar equipment. These costs are then allocated
monthly to the three programs based on internal agreements
made among the three Hughes prograr) managers to share the
development costs of the common equipment.
3. Results of Review.
a. Our floorcheck review disclosed that an employee
working on an IR&D project was charging to a management
pool and having some of his time allocated to the holding
accounts. This mischarging occurred from 31 January 1986
until 26 September 1986 and totaled 269.5 hours at a cost
impact of $21,861. The contractor has agreed to credit the
holding accounts and debit it to one of its IR&D accounts.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
36
b. In addition to the mischarging of 269.5 hours, our
review disclosed minor deficiencies in timekeeping procedures
which the contractor agreed to correct.
a The contractor’s disclosure statement states,
“Direct labor cost incurred for engineering design, support and
manufacturing of common hardware is collected in a holding
account and is allocated to contracts based on contemplated
requirements.” It also states, “Direct material cost incurred in
the manufacture of common hardware is collected in a holding
account and allocated to contracts based on requirements
and/or stock transfers.” Both the AFPRO and DCAA had
found no basis to question the adequacy of the disclosure
Statement nor compliance with the cost accounting standards.
. d. The AFPRO’s technical report (See exhibit),
which we received on 10 October 1986, states the following:
my, (1) Based on review of contractual documents,
it is their opinion that the F-15 program was intended to bear
the full cost of developing any and all hardware used in the F-
15 MSIP radar. There are no statements in the documentation
for the other two programs which indicate that they will share
the burden of development costs.
(2) The facts do not seem to agree with
Hughes’ assertion that it is “obvious” that the F-15 program
was never intended to pay the full cost of the gate array
technology.
G3) The wording in the F-14D cost proposal
appears to be saying to Grumman Aircraft Company, the prime
contractor for the F-14D program, that the development costs
for certain parts have already been paid and that Grumman will
only have to pay for the production/procurement costs of those
parts. However, the internal agreement seems to say that those
parts will be developed and the cost should be bome by all
using programs.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
37
(4) The entire development engineering to the
MSIP radar was negotiated at $57.9 million. The sharing of 31
parts among three programs has already cost over $25 million
or almost half the cost to develop the MSIP radar. This
appears to be a disproportionately high price to pay for the
development of so few parts.
e. The contractor's records indicate the incurrence of
about $43 million of cost for the development of the common
advanced radar equipment as of 24 January 1986.
f. Our review disclosed no contracted sharing of
these common items. Further, we know of no program office
direction for this sharing. However, you advised us that you
were coordinating this question of sharing with the applicable
DOD program offices. Therefore, until the propriety of this
sharing question has been resolved, we are unable to reach a
definitive conclusion regarding the appropriateness of these
charges.
4, Concluding Remarks.
a. Audit matters were discussed with the contractor’s
representative, Mr. Sam Bulucas, Manager - Cost Accounting,
during the course of the review. All questions of fact were
resolved.
b. If additional audit services and/or accounting
counsel are required concerning this report, please contact Mr.
Earnest Knott at (213) 414-6590.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
38
c. Use of this audit report information for purposes
other than those immediately intended is not recommended
without prior consultation with this office regarding is applic-
ability.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT
AGENCY
/s/ Dudley P. Slater
DUDLEY P. SLATER,
Resident Auditor
Copy furnished
Mr. Tom Tremper, PACO, Hughes AFPRO
RAMD-4
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
39
AUDIT REPORT NO. 4511-7B486004S1 JUN 02 1987
SUPPLEMENTAL AUDIT REPORT ON REVIEW
OF COSTS FOR THE RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
COMMONALITY POOL
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
Under the provisions of Title 32, Code of Federal Regulations,
Part 290.26(b) (2), any Freedom of Information Act requests
for audit reports received by DCAA will be referred to the
cognizant contracting agency for determination as to releas-
ability and a direct response to the requestor.
Contractor information contained in this audit report may be
confidential. The restrictions of 18 USC 1905 should be con-
sidered before this information is released to the public.
This report may not be released to any Fe:iera] agency outside
the Department of Defense without the approval of DCAA
Headquarters, except to an agency requesting the report in
negotiating or administering its contract.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
HUGHES CORPORATE RESIDENT OFFICE
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
40
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
LOS ANGELES REGION
Corporate Resident Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
200 N. Sepulveda Blvd. (E12/C130)
El Segundo, CA 90245/2463
AUDIT REPORT NO. 4511-7B486004S1 JUN 02 1987
SUBJECT: Supplemental Report on Review of Costs for the
Radar Systems Group Commonality Pool
Hughes Aircraft Company
Radar Systems Group
E] Segundo, California 90245
TO: Air Force Plant Representative Office
Attention: William D. McKinney, Capt, USAF
Chief Pricing
__ @ In accordance with your 19 May 1987 request, we
verified the costs incurred by the Radar Systems Group
charged to its Commonality Pool. The review was performed
to verify the total pool charges incurred for the period from
February 1986 to April 1987.
b. The review was performed in accordance with
generally accepted government auditing standards and
included such tests of accounting records and such other
auditing procedures we considered necessary in the
circumstances. This review included verification of labor,
material, and other direct costs accumulated in common
general ledger accounts. These costs were then traced to
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
41
general ledger accounts within the F-14, F-15, F-18, and
AHEP Programs. A detailed review of these cost flows was
not performed due to insufficient time made available to issue
this report.
2. Background Information.
The Radar Systems Group Commonality Pool consists
of several general ledger accounts used to accumulate costs for
the development of common advanced radar equipment.
These costs are then allocated to the four programs based on
internal agreements made among the Hughes program
managers to share in the costs of this common equipment.
3. Results of Audit.
a. Our review disclosed that the contractor’s records
show $32,215,600 has have been incurred by the Radar
Systems Group Commonality Pool during the period from
February 1986 to April 1987. This total cost was allocated to
the four programs participating in this pool as follows:
F-14 $ 11,632,567
F-15 13,055,891
F-18 352,390
AHEP
—L174,752
TOTALPOOL $32,215,600
b. It should be noted that the above amounts do not
include Assist Division’s overhead or general and administra-
tive expenses. The contractor stated that these costs were not
included due to time constraints. The contractor will update
the pool expenses and submit the update to Captain McKinney.
4. Concluding Remarks.
a. If accounting counsel or additional audit services
Johnson of this office, at (213) 414-5010.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
42
b. The information contained in this audit report
should not be used for purposes other than that immediately
intended without prior consultation with this office regarding
its applicability.
c. Audit matters were discussed with the contractor’s
representative, Mr. E. S. Balucas, Manager - Cost Accounting,
during the course of the review.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT
AGENCY
/s/ Dudley P. Slater _
DUDLEY P. SLATER,
Resident Auditor
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY PAGE | OF |
NOTICE OF CONTRACT COSTS PAGE(S)
SUSPENDED AND/OR DISAPPROVED
TO: (Name and Contract Number Notice Number
Address of (1) F33657-81-C-0067 (2) 001
Contractor)
Disbursing Officer Contract
WITHHELD USAF/AFSC/ASD Administrative Office
ASPA PROGRAM
OFFICE WRIGHT WITHHELD
PATTERSON AFB, OH
This notice is issued pursuant to the authority of DoD Directive
§5105.34, as implemented by the Federal Acquisities Regulations and
DoD Far Supplement. It constitutes notice of costs suspended and/or
disapproved incident to the audit of contractor costs incurred under
referenced contract(s). Description of items and reasons for the
actions are stated below.
SUSPENDED COSTS, as referred to herein are costs which, for the
reasons stated below, have been determined by the undersigned to be
inadequately supported or otherwise questionable, and not appropnate
for reimbursement under the contract terms at this time. Such costs
may be determined reimbursable after the contractor provides the
auditor additional documentation or explanation as specified below.
DISAPPROVED COSTS, as referred to herein, are costs which, for
the reasons stated below, have been determined by the undersigned to
be unallowable, that is, not reimbursable under the contract terms.
If the contractor disagrees with this/these determinations, the
contractor may (1) request in writing the cognizant contracting officer
to consider whether the unreimbursed costs should be paid and to
discuss his or her findings with the contractor and/or (2) file a claim
under the “Disputes” clause of this contract(s).
The auditor will submit copies of the acknowledged notice to the
cognizant disbursing officer for appropriate action and to the
cognizant contracting officer.
DCAA Date of Notice | Address Signature
AUDITOR | (6) 12/10/87 WITHHELD (illegible)
CONTRACTOR'S ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF RECEIPT - The
contractor or its authorized representative shal! acknowledge receipt of
this notice to the DCAA auditor.
44
Date of Receipt
Name and Title of
(7) 10 December Authorized Official
1987
(7) _J. Gaston Kent, Jr.
Signature
(7) (illegible)
45
ITEM
NO.
(8)
Description of Items and
Reasons for Action
Costs reimbursed to subcontrac-
tor 118A are suspended at the
direction of the Administrative
Contracting Officer in accord-
ance with DAR 3-80%c\(1).
suspension will remain in effect
until such time as the ACO is
able to determine the allocability
or allowability of these costs as
stated in AFPRO letter TM-87-
161 dated 11/9/87.
UNCLASSIFIED
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY PAGE | OF | PAGE(S)
NOTICE OF CONTRACT COSTS
SUSPENDED AND/OR DISAPPROVED
TO: (Name and Contract Number Notice Number
Address of (1) F33657-81-C-0067 (2) 001
Contractor)
Northrop
Corporation
Advanced Systems Disbursing Officer Contract Administrative
rote : <4 USAF/AFSC/ASD (3) Office
Ww a Bivd ASPA PROGRAM (4) DET 31, AFPRO
ba ema OFFICE WRIGHT PICO RIVERA, CA
ret g en PATTERSON AFB, OH | 90660
45433
1. This notice is issued pursuant to the authority of DoD Directive §5105.34,
as implemented by the Federal Acquisities Regulations and DoD Far
Supplement. It constitutes notice of costs suspended and/or disapproved
incident to the audit of contractor costs incurred under referenced
contract(s). Description of items and reasons for the actions are stated
below.
2. SUSPENDED COSTS, as referred to herein are costs which, for the
reasons stated below, have been determined by the undersigned to be
inadequately supported or otherwise questionable, and not appropriate for
reimbursement under the contract terms at this time. Such costs may be
additional documentation or explanation as specified below.
3. DISAPPROVED COSTS, as referred to herein, are costs which, for the
reasons stated below, have been determined by the undersigned to be
unallowable, that is, not reimbursable under the contract terms.
4. If the contractor disagrees with this/these determinations, the contractor
may (1) request in writing the cognizant contracting officer to consider
whether the unreimbursed costs should be paid and to discuss his or her
findings with the contractor and/or (2) file a claim under the “Disputes”
clause of this contract(s).
46
5. The auditor will submit copies of the acknowledged notice to the
cognizant disbursing officer for appropriate action and to the cognizant
contracting officer.
a Oe j
47
90660-3737
Address Resident Signature
Auditor, DCAA (6) (illegible)
$900 E. Washington
Bivd., M/S 3M
Pico Rivera, CA
Date of Receipt
(7)
10 December 1987
Name and Title of
Authorized Official
(7) J. Gaston Kent, Jr.
Vice President Contract
CONTRACTOR'S ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF RECEIPT - The
contractor of the authorized representative shall acknowledge receipt of this
section to the DCAA auditor.
Signature
(7) (illegible)
contract other than one issued by
Northrup Advanced Systems
Division. This suspension will
remain in effect until such time as
the ACO is able to determine the
allocability or allowability of
these costs as stated in AFPRO
letter TM-87-161 dated 1 1/9/87.
DCAA Form | Supercedes February 1983 Edition of DCAA For |
August 1987
CLASSIFICATION CHANGED TO:
UNCLASSIFIED
BY AUTHORITY OF [UNREADABLE]
[UNREADABLE]
BY /s) DATED: [UNREADABLE]
& Pricing
ITEM | (8) Description of Items and Amount of Costs
NO. Reasons for Action
1. Costs reimbursed to $11,600,000
subcontractor 118A are
suspended at the direction of the
Administrative Contracting
Officer in accordance with DAR
3-80%(c\1). Government repre-
sentatives at the subcontractor
48
Session No. 88-03-11-402
CONTACT REPORT
Meeting Date: 10 March 1988
DCAA Attendees: Dudley Slater, John Sharenko
Hughes Attendees: E. Levenson, H. Stone
l.
2.
3.
Two documents were presented for DCAA review:
Extracts from Engineering Progress Letters
indicating chronology of events (86-1 1-21-009)
Letter 88-02-04-400 prepared by Bob Long in
response to customer’s “Form 1” Notice of
Disallowance.
Following review of the documents, Howard reviewed
the chronology of events:
Apr 1981 Began Special Programs Contract
Jan 1982 AHEP FSD development began
Dec 1982 Established design spec on AHEP ASC
Jan 1983 Began AHEP gate array design
Jun 1983 MSIP/SP Commonality MOA - ASC
Jan 1984 Modification to F15 MSIP Contract to
incorporate gate array technology into
the F15 ASC.
DCAA requested an unclassified listing of the
chronology of events.
DCAA developed the following line of questioning:
1.
When MOA was struck between Special
Programs and F15, ——
respective customer (between the buying
offices)?
How was MSIP Gate Array work bid? Did the
proposal contemplate commonality?
3,
4 Edie
49
If F-15 MSIP Contract provides for full
development costs and if a portion of those
costs were subsequently shared with Special
Programs, then there should be a contract
modification reducing the price of the F15
contract. Where is that credit adjustment?
Same line of questioning re. ARDP. Need to
determine what is on contract.
Need to trace each of the 30-or-so MOA’s for
common parts. Requested copy of each MOA
by part number and by date.
asked DCAA for breakout of $11.6M
disallowance. DCAA has not seen breakdown of the amount
but believes the $11.6M amount stems from a modification to
the F15 contract to perform the gate array work.
ACTION ITEMS FOR HUGHES:
Provide unclassified “chronology of events”
Provide copy of MOA by P/N and date for each
common item.
Determine what was in respective gate array
bids re. commonality. Determine whether
credit adjustment modifications for common-
ality exist.
No completion date for these action items was discussed.
DCAA recognized that these requests were directed to Hughes
in general and interviews with the appropriate other-program
people would have to be orchestrated.
86/09/09
86/11/21
86/11/24
87/11/24
87/11/30
None
86-07-01-001
(S)
None
None
86-1 1-21-009
None
87-1 1-24-006
87-1 1-30-005
(S)
F15 MSIP Proposal for new Gate Array
038 and 044 units.
F15 MSIP Purchase Order w/M00!
Modification dated 24 January 1984
F-15 MSIP Phase Il (FSD) WBS Dictionary
Received ltr from Colonel Scofield with
draft Audit Report 86-5.
Received DACOM (P323-BEM-87-985)
advising Form | will be issued - some
details provided in DACOM
Letter to Customer acknowledging receipt
of 87-11-24-006. Takes exception to cost
and advises formal
response will be submitted by 7 January
1988. Includes copy of Audit Report 86-5
and Hughes letters of 9 Sept 86 and 24 Nov
86
87/11/30
87/12/16
87/12/18
88/01/05
88/01/07
88/01/07
88/01/07
87-12-01-007
87-12-16-001
87-12-18-006
88-01-11-402
88-01-11-403
88-01-11-404
51
Received letter P323-BEM-87-1000
advising suspension of costs is imposed and
requesting a Hughes check for $11.5M.
Received DACOM 118A87-712 (P323-
BEM-87-1042) advising immediate
suspension of costs - debits to FSD
invoices. Customer has received Form |.
Received P323-BEM-87-1044, DCAA
Form |.
Edie called Walter to request copy of
AFPRO letter TM-87-161 dated 9 Nov 87
(cited in Form 1). Walter will have to
check with his lawyer on this.
Edie also requested a 30 day extension to
respond to Form | notice of 87-1 1-24-006.
Walter agreed to extension through first
week in February and agreed that | could
confirm his concurrence in writing.
Memo from Karl Abert to John Wilson
requesting assistance in obtaining AFPRO
letter TM-87-161 and identification of
specific elements of cost making up the
$11.6M amount.
Edie called Captain Hamilton at AFPRO to
request AFPRO letter TM-87-161. Cpt.
Hamilton advised he will try to find the
letter for us.
Letter to Captain Hamilton confirming
request for AFPRO letter TM-87-161.
Letter to customer confirming request for
AFPRO letter TM-87-161 and requesting
identification of specific cost elements of
the $11.6M withhold.
Letter to customer extension of
Form | response date to 5 February 1988.
88/01/19
88/01/20
88/01/25
88/02/04
88/03/08
88/03/07
88/03/10
88-01-20-400
88-02-04-400
88-03-08-006
None
52
Joe called Walter to follow up on request 88/03/11
for cost element breakdown of $11.6M
withhold. Walter gave Joe several GLA
and cost account numbers.
Bob Long was not able to match the cost
account numbers from Walter with those in
the DCAA Audit Report. Edie called
Walter - the cost accounts were Walter's
“best guess” based on his review of the
1985 IFC. He didn’t have any other
relevant data.
DACOM and Letter to customer reiterating
request for cost element breakdown of
$11.6M withhold and advising lack of
receipt of this breakdown may impact
Hughes’ ability to respond by 5 February to
Form |.
Edie called Cpt. Hamilton for status on
request for copy of AFPRO letter TM-87-
161. Cpt. Hamilton had located the docu-
ment and requested a copy be DACOM'd to
him. He will follow up on his request.
Letter to customer responding to Form |.
Includes Statement of Claim and
Certification
Copy of DACOm from customer DCAA to
HAC resident auditor requesting assist
audit. Includes customer letter dtd 9
December 87 (X000-87-038) to AFPRO
acknowledging AFPRO ltr TM-87-161
dated 13 Nov 87 and reiterating audit
request.
Meeting with Customer to review F 15
MSIP WBS Dictionary, F15 MSIP Proposal
for M001 re. gate array technology and F 15
MSIP Contract with Modification for
M001. See contact report 17 March 88.
Meeting with DCAA. See contact report | |
Mar 88.
88-03-1 1-402
53
Contact Report of meeting 10 March 88
during which DCAA reviewed the 4
February 88 letter to customer and
discussed chronology of events with
Howard Stone.
54
DISTRIBUTION
(LAST NAME & INITIAL)
CONTRACTS (2)
LIBRARY
LONG, B.
—-
ABERT, K.
OLSON, T.
PROKOP, R.
STONE, H.
55
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
LOS ANGELES REGION
Corporate Resident Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
200 N. Sepulveda Blvd. (E12/C130)
El Segundo, CA 90245/2463
14 June 1988
Mr. J.R. Rohlinger, Vice President - Finance
Radar Systems Group
Hughes Aircraft Company
RS, Bidg. R-1, M/S D-411
El Segundo, Cailf. 90245
Subject: Cost For Development of Common Advanced Radar
Equipment
Dear Mr. Rohlinger
To further assist us in our review, please provide
comments and/or additional supporting data as follows:
l. Based on my examination of the revised disclosure
statements (D/S) that were provided as per our request, it
appears that for period 1980 thru January 1984 the Non-
Manufacturing Division, material and labor that was subject to
commonality accounting), was not a disclosed accounting
practice. Please concur, or provide appropriate comments and
a copy of cover sheet and applicable pages of the D/S for the
subject period. The list of commonality pools provided by you
was opened in C.LS. in April 1980.
2. Included in the D/S’s submitted was a copy of the
cover sheet for the revised statement dated 3 January 1983.
However, since only the cover sheet was included for this
statement, we are unable to determine the relevancy of this
statement to the commonality accounting.
56
3. The following pages were inadvertently omitted.
(Appears to have been two sided pages, with only one side
copied) Please provide copies of the following pages only:
a) Hughes Program Instructions NO. 6-8-10, dtd 11-
25-86, p.2
b) 7 oh No. 6-11-10 & Att. 1,
dtd 8-26-86, even numbered pages.
c)“ " “ NO. 6-11-12 dtd 3-4-86, even
numbered pages.
4+ Please provide a schedule showing total actual booked
cost to all 10 of the commonality pools and a schedule
showing the subsequent amounts allocated to each program for
the period 1 January 1986 thru May 1988. This schedule will
be used by us for materiality analysis. Based on this analysis,
detail test cheking may be performed using one or more of the
commonality pool cost, prior to allocations, and after
allocations, as base amounts for detail test checking. Please
identify the Phase in which pool costs represents for stated
time period.
5. The local AFPRO has requested our report be provided
by 9 July 1988. If you should determine that there will be
delays in providing the data requested. Please notify me at the
(213) 414-6512.
/s/ Van Laurant I
VAN LAURANT II
DCAA AUDITOR
57
HUGHES
AIRCRAFT COMPANY
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
8 July 1988
In Reply ReferTo: 88H/20-20/424
Subject: Cost for Development of Common
Advanced Radar Equipment
To: Defense Contract Audit Agency
Hughes Aircraft Company
Attn: Van Laurant III, Auditor
Building E12, Mail Station C130
El Segundo, CA 90245
Reference: Your letter dated 14 June 1988
The information requested is submitted in the following
paragraphs:
l. Although Commonality was discussed in considerable
detail with the AFPRO/DCAA starting 1978, no CAS Disclo-
sure Statement change for commonality accounting was
submitted by RSG Non-Manufacturing prior to 1984 because
of the lowlevel (immateriality) for commonality at that time.
It was during the latter part of year 1983 that RSG, at the
request of the DCAA/AFPRO, determined that a CAS Disclo-
sure Statement change was in order.
2. The CAS Disclosure Statement change to include com-
eering) was included in our Disclosure Statement revision
dated 2 January 1984 (submitted 3 July 1984), which was
approved by PACO on | April 1985 (copy attached).
NOTE: The delay in submitting the 2 January 1984
Disclosure Statement until 3 July 1984 was due to consoli-
58
dating the individual manufacturing and RSG non-manufac-
turing CAS Disclosure Statement(s) into a single RSG CAS
Disclosure Statement.
3. As requested, attached are complete sets of Hughes
Program Instructions. Included are numbers 6-8-0, 6-11-10,
and 6-11-12.
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
/s/ J.R. Rohlinger
J. R. Rohlinger
Group Vice President - Finance
Radar Systems Group
/og
Attachments
59
Audit Report No. 4511-8B179009 27 September 1988
AUDIT REPORT ON REVIEW OF ACCOUNTING
PRACTICES FOR THE COMMONALITY COST POOLS
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
TheDefense Contract Audit Agency has no objection to release
of this report, at the discretion of the contracting agency, to
authorized representatives of Hughes Aircraft Company.
Under the provisions of Title 32, Code of Federal Regulations,
Part 290.26(b)(2), any Freedom of Information Act requests
for audit reports received by DCAA will be referred to the
cognizant contracting agency for determination as to releas-
ability and a direct response to the requester.
Contractor information contained in this audit report may be
confidential. The restrictions of 18 USC 1905 should be con-
sidered before this information is released to the public.
This report may not be released to any Federal agency outside
the Department of Defense without the approval of
Headquarters, DCAA, except to an agency requesting the
report in negotiating or administering its contract.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
SOUTHWESTERN REGION
HUGHES CORPORATE RESIDENT OFFICE
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
EL SEGUNDO, CALIFORNIA
FOROFFICIALUSEONLY
60
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
SOUTHWESTERN REGION
Corporate, Resident Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
200 N. Sepulveda Blvd. (E12/C130)
El Segundo, CA 90245/2463
Audit Report No. 4511-8B179009 27 September 1988
SUBJECT: Audit Report on Review of Accounting
Practices For The Commonality Cost Pools
Hughes Aircraft Company
Radar Systems Group
El Segundo, California
TO: Principal Administrative Contracting Officer
(Mr. Thomas Tremper)
Air Force Plant Representative Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
El Segundo, California
1. Purpose and Scope of Review
a. As requested in your letter dated 25 May 1988, we
have reviewed Hughes Aircraft Company Radar System
Group’s (RSG) commonality accounting practices. The
purpose of the review was to determine i) whether the
commonality accounting practices are part of RSG’s disclosed
accounting practices, ii) | whether these commonality
accounting practices are considered adequate for the allocation
of common radar costs, iii) if adequate, whether HAC has
consistently complied with these practices in both accounting
for these costs in estimating prior, current and future business,
and iv) to obtain and verify the total pool charges incurred in
the commonality pools and the subsequent allocation to the
various programs through May 30,1988.
61
b. The review was performed in accordance with
generally accepted government auditing standards and
included such tests of the contractor’s data and records and
such other auditing procedures we considered necessary in the
circumstances. It included the following specific steps related
to the commonality cost accumulation and allocation:
(1) Review of the contractor’s Disclosure
Statement addressing the initial adoption of the commonality
accounting practice, and all applicable revisions.
(2) Review ofall written operating instructions and
practices on commonality.
(3) Review of all current Memorandums of
Agreements (Cost Sharing Provisions) applicable to the ten
(10) Commonality Pools.
(4) A detail review of randomly selected labor,
material, ODC, and burden transactions recorded under GLA
No. NA67. Our review included both cost accumulation and
cost allocation transactions.
(5S) A review of the contractor’s commonality
accounting practices in conjunction with bid proposals.
(6) The determination and verification of total costs
incurred-to-date for the ten commonality pools, and the total
cost allocations-to-date as of May 30, 1988.
2 Affecting the Revi
On 16 October 1986, we issued Audit Report No.
4511-7B486004, Subject: Audit Report on Review of Costs
For The Development of Common Advanced Radar
Equipment. The report also included the findings of the
resident Air Force Plant Representatives technical review. We
disclosed in our report that the contractor established holding
accounts to accumulate the costs for the development of the
common advanced radar equipment. These costs were then
allocated monthly to the F-15, F-14D, F-18 and the AHEP
programs based on internal memorandums of agreements made
62
between the applicable Hughes program managers to share the
development costs of the common equipment. Our review
disclosed no contracted sharing agreement of these common
items. Because we were unable to determine the existence of
any program office directions for this cost sharing, we were
unable to reach a definitive conclusion regarding the
appropriateness and accuracy of these allocations to the
various programs.
3. Results of Audit Review
a. Our review disclosed that the contractor’s Disclosure
Statement and related commonality accounting practices do
not adequately describe the contractor’s cost accounting
practices. Accordingly, we recommend the contractor submit
a revised Disclosure Statement on its commonality accounting.
Also, during our review we identified certain of the
contractor’s revised practices which we believe represent a
potential noncompliance with Cost Accounting Standard 401.
The deficiencies identified are as follows:
The contractor’s disclosed accounting practice for
commonality cost is too general. The disclosed practice does
not give the reader an adequate description of its methods of
allocation and cost sharing arrangements.
Our review indicates that there are presently ten
commonality pool accounts used for cost accumulation and ten
relief accounts used for cost allocations. The contractor’s
Memorandums of Agreement defines the common work tasks
and establishes the cost sharing of each participating program
with respect to a given common work task. We recommend
that the contractor include in its disclosure statement a current,
accurate, and complete description of each cost sharing
practice used for the allocation of common radar costs. Also
any subsequent changes to the disclosed practices shall require
63
the contractor to submit a formal disclosure statement
amendment.
(2) Potential Noncompliance-CAS 401
CAS 401.40(b) requires that cost estimates for proposal
purposes shall be presented in such a manner and in such detail
that any significant cost can be compared with actual cost
contractor simply does not address commonality cost as an
element separate and distinct from other unique effort in it’s
bid proposal estimates. Accordingly, program actuals used as
a basis for the proposal estimates do not show a break-down of
the common vs unique actual cost. Because proposed com-
monality costs cannot be compared to the recorded cost, it
appears that the contractor has a potential CAS 401
noncompliance. We recommend that the contractor’s actual
costs which are used as a basis for the proposal estimates show
the break-down of actual cost between common vs unique.
b. Except as noted below, our review of selected
transactions representing both cost accumulation and
allocation transactions disclosed no basis for taking exception
to the contractor’s current cost accumulation and cost
allocation accounting practices.
Our review disclosed that total relief costs allocated-
to-date exceeds total costs incurred-to-date for three of the ten
pool accounts. Audit inquiries disclosed that the over-alloca-
tion resulted from double accounting. The contractor asserts
that the double accounting resulted from “changes in allocation
matrixes occurring subsequent to the actual periods of cost
incurrence”. The contractor has agreed to make adjusting
correction entries in the September 1988 accounting period.
Please refer to Attachment 1, for a schedule showing compari-
son of total costs incurred-to-date with total relief costs
allocated-to-date. Attachment 2 shows the schedule of total
commonality pool costs allocated by program.
64
4 Disposition of Audit Resul
a. During the course of our review, audit matters were
discussed with Mr. J. Rohlinger, Vice President, Finance, Mr.
Sam Bulucas, Manager Cost Accounting, Ms. Jackie Davis,
Head, Cost Accounting and Mr. William Amis, Manager,
Commonality Hardware.
b. Accounting counsel or additional audit services
required may be obtained by contacting Mr. Frank Moore or
Mr. Van Laurant Ill of this office, at (213) 414-6504.
Additional audit support should be requested if required.
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT
AGENCY
/s/ Dudley P. Slater
DUDLEY P. SLATER,
Resident Auditor
* * * *
65
Audit Report No. 4511-8B179009 Attachment 1
Page 2 of 2
Explanatory Note
Our review disclosed that total costs allocated-to-date
exceeds total costs incurred-to-date for three of the ten pool
accounts. Audit inquiries disclosed that the over-allocation
resulted from double accounting. The contractor asserts that
the double accounting resulted from “changes in allocation
matrixes occuring subsequent to the actual periods of costs
incurrence”. As stated in paragraph 3.b. of the report
narrative, the contractor has agreed to make adjusting
correction entries in the September 1988 accounting period.
In addition, the local AFPRO will be provided a monthly
schedule showing total incurred-to-date and total allocated-to-
date relif costs, for analysis as considered necessary.
66
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
AF PLANT REPRESENTATIVE OFC. (DET 36) AF
CONTRACT MGT DIV (AFSC)
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY, P.O. BOX 92463
LOS ANGELES, CA 90009
7 November 1988
Mr J. R. Rohlinger
Radar Systems Group
Hughes Aircraft Company
R1/MS/D411
Dear Mr Rohlinger
The attached 27 September 1988 DCAA Audit Report No.
4511-88179009 cites a potential CAS 401 noncompliance.
The cited noncompliance pertains to the commonality
accounting practices for allocation of Common Radar Costs at
Radar System Group. Before I make a determination on this
potential CAS 401 noncompliance, | request your concurrence
with DCAA’s audit finding or submit rebuttal evidence within
30 days after receipt of this letter. If you concur with the cited
noncompliance please submit your corrective action plan. If
no answer is received within 30 days, I intend to issue a
determination of noncompliance with CAS 401.
/s/ Thomas R. Tremper
THOMAS R. TREMPER 1 Atch
Principal Administrative DCAA Audit Rpt
Contracting Officer No4511-8B1790
dtd 27 Sept 1988
cc: DCAA/Mr D. Slater
DCAA/Mr R. Barr
67
Dean Francis Pace
Wm. John Kennedy
PACE AND KENNEDY
Suite 1600 Century City
1901 Avenue of the Stars
Los Angeles, California 90067
(213) 277-2900
Attorneys for Plaintiff
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
EX REL. WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, )
) CIVIL ACTION
Plaintiff, ) CV 89-0390 MR
‘
HUGHES AIRCRAFT ‘
COMPANY, ) DISCLOSURE
) STATEMENT
Defendant ) PURSUANT TO
) 31 U.S.C. 3730 (B\(2)
)
TO THE UNITED STATES ATTORNEY, CENTRAL
DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA:
NOW COMES RELATOR, WILLIAM J. SCHUMER,
and respectfully files a Disclosure Statement with the United
States Attorney for the Central District of California incident
to the Qui Tam action United States of America ex rel. William
J. Schumer v. Hughes Aircraft Company, USDC Civil Action
CV89-0390 MRP, pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3730(b)(2).
oe) eo: oe Dean Francis Pace
Wm. John Kennedy
PACE AND KENNEDY
Dated: January 17, 1989 Suite 1600 Century City
: 1901 Avenue of the Stars
Respectfully submitted, Los Angeles. California 90067
PACE AND KENNEDY (213) 277-2900
Attorneys for Plaintiff
By rae Franc — UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Attorneys for Plaintiff
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA _)
EX REL. WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, )
a
) COMPLAINT FOR
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY, ) VIOLATION OF THE
) FALSE CLAIMS ACT
Defendant )
) DEMAND FOR JURY
) TRIAL
JURISDICTION
l.
Jurisdiction is predicated upon federal subject matter
jurisdiction pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3732(a).
70
VENUE
2.
Venue in the Central District Court for the Central
District of California is predicated upon 31 U.S.C. 3737(a).
Defendant HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY and its
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP, the entity charged herein with
violations of 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq., now and at all times
alleged herein had its principal place of business in the Central
District of California. The violations of 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq.
alleged herein occurred in the Central District of California.
Plaintiff has sustained the damages alleged herein within the
Central District of California.
PARTIES
3.
Defendant HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY (herein-
after “HUGHES”), is and was at all times alleged herein a
California corporation with its principal place of business
located within the Central District of California.
4.
HUGHES RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP (hereinafter
“RSG”), is and was at all times alleged herein a division of
HUGHES, charged with the principal performance of subcon-
tracts and prime contracts between HUGHES and the United
States Government as hereinafter alleged.
5.
Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereupon
alleges, that at all times alleged herein, Defendant HUGHES
had knowledge of, acquiesced in, authorized, directed, and/or
ratified the conduct of the officers, managers and employees
RSG in the performance of the acts as herein alleged.
6.
Plaintiff ex Rel. William J. Schumer (hereinafter
“SCHUMER?” is and at all times herein alleged was a resident
71
and citizen of the United States, the State of California, and of
the Central District of California. SCHUMER was employed
by HUGHES as Division Contract Manager at RSG until
September 2, 1988 and at the time of filing the Complaint is
employed by HUGHES as Assistant Division Contracts
The standing of Plaintiff to sue to recovery payments
made to Defendant by the United States Government upon
false claims is granted by Federal Statute, 31 U.S.C. Section
3730(b)1).
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
VIOLATION OF FALSE CLAIMS ACT
The subject matter of the instant Civil Action are the F-
15 Radar Multistage Improvement Program Contract
(hereinafter “MSIP CONTRACT”), F-18 Radar Upgrade Pro-
gram Contract (hereinafter “F-18 CONTRACT”) and a classi-
fied program designated by the unclassified nomenclature
2301 (hereinafter “2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM
submitted by Plaintiff in compliance with 31 USC.
3730(b)(2), Plaintiff is compelled to leave the allegations
contained herein general in nature. The documents, facts and
transactions are highly classified and therefore, cannot be
disclosed by SCHUMER to his Counsel Pace and Kennedy.
SCHUMER is ready, willing and able to make full disclosure
to the Justice Department and other federal agencies, including
72
the 2301 Special Projects Office and Defense Contract Audit
Agency, who have the requisite security clearances.
10.
Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereon alleges
that the wrongful acts and conduct of Defendant HUGHES as
hereinafter alleged with regard inter alia to the Commonality
Agreement have been confirmed and documented by internal
cost analysis, audits and records of HUGHES. Plaintiff is
analysis, audits and records were circulated among the officers
and management personnel of HUGHES who had full knowl-
edge thereof, and who, rather than take corrective or remedial
action with regard inter alia to the Commonality Agreement,
ordered said Commonality Agreement, cost analysis, audits or
records suppressed or concealed from the customers of
HUGHES including the United States Government.
ll.
Plaintiff alleges that the officers, managers, and
employees of HUGHES and RSG have acted in furtherance of
the above-referenced conspiracy to fraudulently obtain the
payment of false claims through the preparation of false
records, statements, and invoices, and the collaborative
omission and suppression of material facts, as herein alleged.
12.
In doing the acts herein alleged, the officers, managers,
and employees of HUGHES RSG were acting in their respec-
tive capacities as officers, agents or employees of HUGHES
and/or RSG.
13.
Defendant HUGHES knowingly misallocated and
mischarged costs incurred on the MSIP FFP CONTRACT to
the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT and F-
18 FP] CONTRACT in order to receive payment and make
profit thereon. Plaintiff alleges that each of the claims for
73
payment by HUGHES and the payments received by
HUGHES constitute false claims within the definitions set
forth in 31 U.S.C. 3729%a).
14.
The officers, managers and employees of Defendant
HUGHES have conspired to suppress and/or destroy evidence
of the false claims in order to prevent its customers, ultimately
the United States Government, from becoming aware of the
HUGHES false claims and in order to permit HUGHES to
continue to receive contract payments and to permit HUGHES
to increase its profits in violation of 31 U.S.C. 3729(a).
15.
Beginning in 1983, Defendant Hughes Aircraft
Company, Radar Systems GROUP, Los Angeles, California
(hereinafter “HUGHES”) falsely misallocated and mischarged
development costs incurred on the classified F-15 Radar
Multistage Improvement Program classified firm fixed price
(FFP) contract (hereinafter “MSIP CONTRACT”) to two
incentive contracts, to wit:
(1) The classified cost plus incentive fee award fee
(CPIF/AF) classified contract, bearing the unclassified nomen-
clature 2301 (hereinafter “2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CON-
TRACT”); and
(2) The classified fixed price incentive (FPI) contract
for the F-18 Radar Upgrade Program (hereinafter “F-18 CON-
TRACT”).
The United States Government defrayed the develop-
ment costs of the MSIP FFP CONTRACT to the extent of the
incentive share ratios of the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM
CPIF/ AF CONTRACT and the F-18 FPI CONTRACT
without authorization by contract or law and contrary to the
no-cost modification to 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM
CONTRACT. The allocation and mischarge was intentional
by HUGHES as evidenced by a 1983 Commonality Agreement
74
signed by the HUGHES MSIP Program Manager Luke
Bogdonovich, F-18 Program Manager Freeman Nelson, and
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM Manager David Lynch (as well as
the HUGHES Division Controiler Joseph Rohlinger) at the
specific request of J.R. Giacoletto, then Director of Contracts
and now President of the HUGHES Radar Systems Group and
now Vice President of Hughes Aircraft Company (hereinafter
“GIACOLETTO”). Meade Livesay, President, HUGHES
Radar Systems Group, was also fully informed in 1983.
16.
The misallocation and mischarge was contrary to the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CONTRACT agreements with
the HUGHES classified customer (hereinafter “CUSTOMER”)
and a no-cost modification to the 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACT. It is estimated by SCHUMER
that the total development incurred cost allocated away from
the MSIP FFP CONTRACT from 1983-1988 to the 2301
SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT and to the F-18
FPI CONTRACT exceeds $40,000,000 because of the MSIP
technical problems that caused severe cost overruns on the
MSIP FFP CONTRACT.
17.
On December 18, 1981, HUGHES was advised that
HUGHES had won the full scale development 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM CONTRACT to employ the existing HUGHES F-
15 APG-63 radar processing modules, except for frequency
change and repackaging of the modules.
18.
On March 8, 1982, the new 2301 SPECIAL PRO-
GRAM Division was created with SCHUMER as Division
Contracts Manager.
75
19.
On March 18, 1982, HUGHES received the executed
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CONTRACT which specified the
basic HUGHES F-15 APG-63 radar processing core modules.
20.
In April 1982, the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM mission
changes caused lengthy negotiations to revise the radar
processor core capacity specifications and to determine cost
and schedule impacts. There were two main areas of technical
concern:
(1) The novel classified antenna approach. The
antenna was of such concern that a special Risk Reduction
Program was imposed on HUGHES by its CUSTOMER.
(2) The data processing capacity for the Radar Data
Processor (hereinafter “RDP”), Analog Signal Converter
(hereinafter “ASC”) and Radar Signal Processor (hereinafter
“RSP”) and other modules where processing rates and
throughputs were increased beyond the capacity of the existing
HUGHES F-15 APG-63 radar modules which were specified
in the basic 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CONTRACT.
21.
In April, 1982, HUGHES advised the CUSTOMER
that HUGHES itself would fund the aforesaid RDP, ASC and
RSP increased radar processor core capacity changes at no cost
to the CUSTOMER. In December 1982, HUGHES advised
the CUSTOMER that HUGHES was anticipating the receipt of
a contract for the processor capacity upgrade of the existing
HUGHES F-15 APG-63 radar which became the MSIP CON-
TRACT. In several verbal and written presentations,
HUGHES represented to the CUSTOMER:
(1) That the upgrade processor core modules
developed on the SIP CONTRACT would be provided to the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM at no cost to the CUSTOMER.
HUGHES represented to the CUSTOMER there would be a
76
slight decrease in cost because the upgraded MSIP processor
modules would be simpler to frequency change than the
existing HUGHES F-15 APG-63 modules.
(2) That HUGHES would meet all processing
requirements of the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM and retain the
specification-required future growth capacity.
(3) That all costs incurred in the development,
manufacture and test of the upgrade processor modules would
be allocated and charged to the MSIP CONTRACT except for
the frequency-change and repackaging of the modules costs.
22.
In January 1983, a no-cost modification for the
upgraded processor core modules change was made to the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CONTRACT.
23.
In March 1983, HUGHES received the firm fixed price
MSIP CONTRACT for F-15 Aircraft only with no provision
for cost allocations to any other aircraft, contract or program.
24.
In July 1983, GLACOLETTO (who had been promoted
to Group Vice President on May 19, 1983 but retained his title
as Radar Systems Group Director of Contracts) told
SCHUMER to “draw up” a “Commonality Agreement”
between the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM, the F-18
PROGRAM and the MSIP PROGRAM to share equally 1/3,
1/3 and 1/3, all the upgrade processor modules development
costs incurred on the MSIP CONTRACT. The Commonality
Agreement was to be executed by the then three Program
Managers, David Lynch for the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM,
Freeman Nelson for the F-18 PROGRAM and Luke
Bogdonovich for the F-15 MSIP PROGRAM. When
SCHUMER asked GIACOLETTO if the customers were
aware of the Commonality Agreement, GIACOLETTO was
adamant in telling SCHUMER that no word of the agreement
77
was to reach anyone, especially the 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM CUSTOMER. When SCHUMER pointed out that
HUGHES had assured the CUSTOMER, as evidenced by a no-
cost contract modification, that there would no-cost for the
upgraded processor modules changes, and that the
Commonality Agreement would be “triple-dipping” ard a
conscious contractual and legal violation, GIACOLETTO
directed that the Commonality Agreement be prepared for the
signatures of the three program managers and for Joseph
Rohlinger who was then HUGHES Division Controller and
Group Vice President.
25.
In September 1983, GIACOLETTO demanded to see
what SCHUMER had done on the Commonality Agreement.
SCHUMER reported that he had done nothing to create the
agreement and SCHUMER told GIACOLETTO that he did not
want his name associated in any way with the Commonality
Agreement.
26.
In October 1983, SCHUMER informed Vern
Munushian. Submanager of Contracts (reporting to
SCHUMER) on the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM (hereinafter
“MUNUSHIAN”) about the proposed Commonality
Agreement. In November 1983, MUNUSHIAN was so
concerned that HUGHES might not be fully aware of the
contractual and legal implications of the Commonality
Agreement that MUNUSHIAN made an appointment to
express his concerns to Meade Livesay, President of the
HUGHES Radar Systems Group, who listened and said that he
would check into the matter. MUNUSHIAN wrote a
Memorandum to the File expressing contractual and legal
objections to the proposed Commonality Agreement.
27.
On December 15, 1983, GACOLETTO demanded the
Commonality Agreement. SCHUMER told GIACOLETTO
78
that he would have no part of such a secret arrangement.
GIACOLETTO said if you will not do it, I will find someone
who will. SCHUMER then wrote a Memorandum to the File
documenting the aforesaid transactions with regard to the
Commonality Agreement.
28.
In January 1984, SCHUMER was told by
GIACOLETTO that MUNUSHIAN was to be removed as
Contracts Manager on the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM
because “he was too close with the customer.”
29.
During 1984-1987, at the monthly 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM review meetings on cost, schedule, technical
problems, etc., attended by top-level management, SCHUMER
heard the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM management
(especially the Program Manager David Lynch and Assistant
Program Manager Robert Prokopf) frequently complain that
the schedule delays and huge cost growth on the 2301
SPECIAL PROGRAM was substantially caused by the
unforeseen technical problems and cost escalation on the MSIP
PROGRAM which delayed delivery of the MSIP upgraded
processor core modules to the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM.
The cost growth on the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF
CONTRACT is classified but it is enormous. The Program
Manager David Lynch complained that it was unfair that the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM had to absorb 1/3 of the
enormous MSIP cost, caused in part as schedule pressure
mounted, to the extensive use of overtime premiums which
had not been authorized or approved by the CUSTOMER on
the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT.
30.
It is the estimate of SCHUMER from the 2301
SPECIAL PROGRAM reviews that incurred cost mischarges
to the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM under the Commonality
79
Agreement exceeded $20 million plus a like amount charged
to the F-18 FPI CONTRACT.
31.
The second generation Commonality Memorandum of
Agreement dated March 15, 1985 provides:
“2.4 (U) SPECIFIC FUNDING AGREEMENTS FOR
COMMON HARDWARE
2.4.1. (U) Radar Data Processor (RDP) Unit.
(U) The initial development phase for the common
RDP hardware has been funded solely by the F-15 MSIP
Program and has been completed. Funding for efforts during
the present Improvement/Upgrade phase shall be shared
equally (1/3 each) among the three programs. These efforts
shall include upgrades to the common module designs to
implement a dual CPU architecture.
2.4.2. (U) Analog Signal Converter (ASC) Unit,
(U) The development effort for the common ASC
modules has been shared equally between the F-15 MSIP
program and Special Programs in accordance with a previous
Memorandum of Agreement. Funding for tasks still in the
Initial Development Phase shall continue to be shared equally
by the F-15 MSIP and Special Programs. Funding for efforts
that have completed the Initial Development Phase shall be
shared equally (1/3 each) among the three programs.
2.4.3. (U) Radar Signal Processor (RSP).
(U) The programmable signal processor presently
under development, commonly referred to as the NGP (Next
Generation Processor), has been funded solely by the F-15
MSIP program. As tasks complete this Initial Development
Phase, subsequent funding during the Improvement/Upgrade
phase shall be shared equally between the F-15 MSIP program
and the F-14D program.”
80
32.
The Commonality Memorandum of Agreement
evidences that HUGHES misallocated and mischarged
incurred costs away from the MSIP FFP CONTRACT to the
9301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT and F-18
FPI CONTRACT without contractual or legal authorization, or
in violation of the no-cost modification to the 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM CONTRACT, as follows:
(1) For the Analog Signal Converter (ASC) Unit the
costs for the Initial Development Phase were misallocated and
mischarged equally between the MSIP FFP CONTRACT and
the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CPIF/ AF CONTRACT, so
as to be in violation of the no-cost modification and to
constitute false claims. Development costs after the Initial
Development Phase were misallocated and mischarged equally
among the MSIP FFP CONTRACT, 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT and F-18 FPl
CONTRACT. The cost misallocation and mischarge of one-
half of the ASC Initial Development Phase costs away from
the MSIP FFP CONTRACT to the 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CPIF/AF CONTRACT as well as the
misallocation and mischarge of two-thirds of the subsequent
ASC development costs away from the MSIP FFP CON-
TRACT to the 2301 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CPIF/AF
CONTRACT and the F-18 FPI CONTRACT constitute false
claims.
(2) For the Radar Data Processor (RDP) Unit,
SCHUMER alleges that the assertion by HUGHES that the
Initial Development Phase costs were allocated solely to the
FFP MSIP PROGRAM, is false. In fact, the Initial Develop-
ment costs phase were also misallocated and mischarged to the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CONTRACT so as to be in viola-
tion of the no-cost contract modification and to constitute false
claims. The RDP “Improvement/Upgrade Phase” costs were
misallocated equally between the FFP MSIP CONTRACT, the
2301 SPECIAL PROGRAM CPIF/AF CONTRACT and the
81
FPI F18 CONTRACT. The cost misallocation and mischarge
of two-thirds of the RDP “Improvement Upgrade Phase”
development costs away from the FFP MSIP CONTRACT to
the CPIF/AF BLACK 2301 CONTRACT and to the FPI F18
CONTRACT constitute false claims.
(3) For the Radar Signal Processor (RSP) Unit,
SCHUMER alleges that the assertion by HUGHES that the
Initial Development Phase (at least for the Next Generation
Processor) cost was allocated solely to the MSIP FFP CON-
TRACT, is false. In fact, the Initial Development costs phase
were also misallocated and mischarged to the 2301 SPECIAL
PROGRAM CONTRACT so as to be in violation of the no-
cost contract modification and constitute false claims.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays for judgment against
Defendant as follows:
1. For restitution to the United States Government of
all monies wrongfully received by HUGHES to be in excess of
$40,000,000.00 or according to proof at the time of trial,
pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq.
2. For three times the dollar amount proven to have
been wrongfully charged by HUGHES and paid by the United
States Government to HUGHES under prime and subcontracts,
pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3729%a) (7);
3. For recovery of all awards or percentages of the
proceeds of the action or settlement pursuant to 31 U.S.C.
3730(d);
4. For costs of suit incurred herein including
reasonable attorneys fees pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3730(d);
. 5. For such other and further relief as the Court deems
just and proper.
82
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Plaintiff hereby demands trial by jury pursuant to Rule
38(b), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
Dated: January 20, 1989
Respectfully submitted,
PACE AND KENNEDY
By: /s/ Dean Francis Pace
Dean Francis Pace
Attomeys for Plaintiff
Dean Francis Pace
Wm. John Kennedy
PACE & KENNEDY
Suite 1600 Century City
1901 Avenue of the Stars
Los Angeles, California 90067
(213) 277-2900
Attorneys for Plaintiff
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
WILLIAM J. SCHUMER,
Plaintiff,
) CIVIL ACTION
) CV89-0201 SVW
)
) MOTION FOR LEAVE
) TO FILE A FIRST
) AMENDED COM-
) PLAINT OR LEAVE
) TO AMEND TO CON-
) FORM TO EVIDENCE
) AT TRIAL
)
)
) DATE: July 3, 1989
) TIME: 1:30 P.M.
) COURTROOM: F
NOW COMES PLAINTIFF and respectfully moves
the Court for leave to file a First Amended Complaint or to
amend the Complaint to conform to evidence at trial,
wit:
pursuant to Rule 15(b), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, to
84
(1) Fraud and Breach of the Implied Warranty of
Good Faith and Fair Dealing for failure to give Plaintiff the
promised 1988 midyear performance review admitted by
Defendant in its Answer.
(2) Breach of Contract and the Implied Warranty
of Good Faith and Fair Dealing for failure to give Plaintiff a
1988 performance, salary and bonus review in violation of
the Hughes Aircraft Company Policy and Practice 3-2 to
reflect his satisfactory 1988 performance and the
Memorandum of commendation dated July 21, 1988.
(4) Breach of Contract and the Implied Warranty
of Good Faith and Fair Dealing for the reprisal, retaliation
and retribution by Defendant for the Pursuit by Plaintiff in
1988 of the Hughes Aircraft Company Policy and Practice
on Employee Dispute Resolution Procedure against his
Superior John F. Wilson.
(5) Breach of Contract and the Implied Warranty
of Good Faith and Fair Dealing for the reprisal, retaliation
and retribution by Defendant for the refusal of Plaintiff to
perform an unlawful act under United States Government
contracts awarded to Defendant in violation of the False
Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq., United States of America
ex rel. William J. Schumer, CV89-1963 MRP, under seal
until lifted on April 21, 1989 by the United States District
Court for the Central District of California, to wit:
(a) In July, September and December 1983,
J.R. Giacoletto, then RSG Director of Contract and now
RSG President and Corporation Senior Vice President
demanded that Plaintiff prepare and secure signatures on a
Confidentiality Agreement which was in violation of the
United States Government contracts with Defendant on
classified Special Programs.
(b) On June 23, 1986, a United States Air
Force audit report evidenced the aforesaid contract violations
85
and false claims to which Defendant responded on
September 9, 1986.
(c) Beginning in July 1986, Defendant began
restricting Plaintiff from access to the Special Program con-
tracts in order that Plaintiff would not discover the aforesaid
unlawful false claims confirmed by the United States Air
Force audit.
(d) In July 1987, Plaintiff discovered on the
desk of one of his subordinates, Joseph Schulsinger, a
Defense Contract Audit Report, DCAA Form 1, which
disapproved of the aforesaid false claims confirmed by the
United States Air Force audit. Thereupon, Plaintiff was
transferred away from the Special Programs organization in
order that he would not have access to the aforesaid false
claims confirmed in the DCAA Form | and United States
Air Force audit.
(e) On August 16, 1988, Defendant made a
presentation to the USAF AFPRO on the aforesaid
Commonality Agreement false claims reported in the DCAA
Form | and United States Air Force audit.
(f) In August 1988, during an Employee Dis-
pute Resolution Procedure conference with Salvester
Mendoza, Corporate EEOC Manager, Plaintiff responded to
questions and reiterated his position regarding the aforesaid
unlawful acts by Defendant.
(g) On September 2, 1988, Plaintiff was
terminated from his employment with Defendant by the
change of his office door lock, by the confiscation of his
security and employment badges and by escorting Plaintiff
from the premises of Defendant for the contrived cause of
“management’s good faith belief that his continued
employment was detrimental to the interests of the
organization.”
| (h) Since February 1989, the aforesaid false
claims by Defendant as confirmed by the DCAA Form | and
United States Air Force have been under investigation by the
Justice Department in Washington, D.C.
The instant motion is predicated upon all of the
papers and documents on file herein, the attached
Memorandum of Points and Authorities, and the argument
by counsel if entertained by the Court.
Dated: June 2, 1989 Respectfully submitted,
PACE AND KENNEDY
By: /s/ Dean Francis Pace
Dean Francis Pace
Attorneys for Plaintiff
87
Dean Francis Pace
PACE AND QUINN
Suite 2080 Century City North
10100 Santa Monica Boulevard
Los Angeles, California 90067
(213) 277-2900
Attomeys for Plaintiff
William J. Schumer
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
EX REL WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, )
) CIVIL ACTION
Plaintiff ) CV89-0390 MRP
)
v. )
) FIRST AMENDED
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY, ) COMPLAINT FOR
) VIOLATION OF
Defendant )THE FALSE
) CLAIMS ACT
NOW COMES PLAINTIFF and alleges:
JURISDICTION
l.
Jurisdiction is predicated upon federal subject matter
jurisdiction pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3732(a).
VENUE
2.
Venue in the Central District Court for the Central
District of California is predicated upon 31 U.S.C. 3737(a).
Defendant HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY and its
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP, the entity charged herein with
violations of 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq., now and at all times
alleged herein had its principal place of business in the Central
District of California. The violations of 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq.
alleged herein occurred in the Central District of California.
Plaintiff has sustained the damages alleged herein within the
Central District of California.
PARTIES
3.
Defendant HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
(hereinafter “HUGHES”), is and was at all times alleged
herein a Delaware corporation with its principal place of
business located in Los Angeles, California, within the Central
District of Caiifornia.
4
HUGHES RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP (hereinafter
“RSG”), is and was at all times alleged herein a division of
HUGHES in El Segundo, California, charged with the
principal performance of subcontracts and prime contracts
between HUGHES and the United States Government as
hereinafter alleged.
5.
Plaintiff ex rel William J. Schumer (hereinafter
“SCHUMER?”) is and at all times herein alleged was a resident
and citizen of the United States, the State of California, and of
the Central District of California. SCHUMER was employed
by HUGHES as Division Contract Manager at RSG until
September 2, 1988 and at the time of filing the Complaint is
employed by HUGHES as Assistant Division Contracts
89
Manager at the HUGHES Missile Systems Group in
Park, California. a
6.
The standing of Plaintiff to sue to recovery payments
made to Defendant by the United States Government upon
false claims is granted by Federal Statute, 31 U.S.C. Section
3730 (b)(1).
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
VIOLATION OF FALSE CLAIMS ACT
7.
The subject matter of the instant Civil Action are the
F14D Program Contract (hereinafter “F14-D CONTRACT”),
F-15 Radar Multistage Improvement Program Contract
(hereinafter “F-15 MSIP CONTRACT”), F-18 Radar Upgrade
Program Contract (hereinafter “F-18 CONTRACT”) and B-2
Special Programs Contracts (hereinafter “B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACTS”) performed by HUGHES RSG
.1 El Segundo, California.
Plaintiff believes that certain facts may not be alleged _
without jeopardizing national security. Pending investigation
by the United States Attorney of the Disclosure Statement
submitted by Plaintiff in compliance with 31 U.S.C.
3730(b)(2), Plaintiff is compelled to leave the allegations
contained herein general in nature. The documents, facts and
transactions, are highly classified and therefore, cannot be
disclosed by SCHUMER to his Counsel. SCHUMER is ready,
willing and able to make full disclosure to the Justice
Department and other federal agencies, including the United
States Air Force and Navy Special Project Offices and Defense
Contract Audit Agency, who have the requisite security
clearances.
90
9.
Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereon alleges
that the wrongful acts and conduct of Defendant HUGHES as
hereinafter alleged with regard inter alia to the Commonality
Agreements have been confirmed and documented by internal
cost analysis, audits and records of HUGHES. Plaintiff is
further informed and believes and thereon alleges that said cost
analysis, audits and records were circulated among the officers
and management personnel of HUGHES who had full
knowledge thereof, and who, rather than take corrective or
remedial action with regard inter alia to the Commonality
Agreements ordered said Commonality Agreements, cost
analysis, audits or records suppressed or concealed from
SCHUMER and the customers of HUGHES and the
Department of Defense, including specifically the United
States Air Force and Navy Project Offices.
10.
From 1982 to 1990, Defendant Hughes Aircraft
Company, Radar Systems Group, Los Angeles, California
(hereinafter “HUGHES”) falsely misallocated and mischarged
development costs by means of six Commonality Agreements
dated December 14, 1982 (hereinafter “AGREEMENT 1"),
June 24, 1983 (hereinafter “AGREEMENT 2"), June 24, 1983
(hereinafter “AGREEMENT 3"), February 8, 1985 (hereinafter
“AGREEMENT 4"), June 19, 1985 (hereinafter “AGREE-
MENT 5") and May 8, 1987 (hereinafter “AGREEMENT 6")
among the four programs F-14D, F-15 MSIP, F-18 and B-2
SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS.
11.
From 1982 to 1990, HUGHES falsely invoiced and the
United States Government reimbursed misbid, misallocated
and mischarged costs of the F-14D CONTRACT, the F-15
MSIP CONTRACT, the F-18 CONTRACT and to the extent
of the incentive share ratios, the B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
CPIF/AF CONTRACT without authorization of contract or
91
law and without the knowledge and approval of the
Department of Defense Project or Procurement Offices. The
misbid, misallocation and mischarge were intentional by
HUGHES as evidenced by six Commonality Agreements
signed by the HUGHES F-14 Program Manager J.V. Ferrero,
F-15 Program Managers Luke Bogdonovich and R.S. Jamison,
F-18 Project Manager E. R. Muntean, and SPECIAL PRO-
GRAMS Manager David Lynch as well as the HUGHES
Division Controller Joseph Rohlinger. J.R. Giacoletto, then
Director of Contracts and now President of the HUGHES
Radar Systems Group and Senior Vice President of Hughes
Aircraft Company, approved the six Commonality
Agreements.
12.
Without the knowledge or approval of the customers of
HUGHES or the Department of Defense, including specifically
the United States Air Force and Navy Project Offices,
HUGHES unilaterally, secretly and falsely misbid,
misallocated and mischarged costs among the F-14D, F-15
MSIP, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS
by means of six Commonality Agreements, expressly for the
Radar Data Processor, the Analog Signal Converter and the
Radar Signal Processor, including without limitation:
(1) December 11, 1982 Commonality Agreement
for the Radar Data Processor.
(2) June 24, 1983 Commonality Agreement for the
Radar Data Processor.
(3) June 24, 1983 Commonality Agreement for the
Analog Signal Converter.
(4) December 3, 1984, Commonality Agreement
(MOA dated February 8, 1985) for the Radar Data Processor,
Analog Signal Converter, and Radar Signal Processor.
92
(5) June 19, 1985 Commonality Agreement for the
Radar Data Processor, Analog Signal Converter, and Radar
Signal Processor.
(6) May 8, 1987 Commonality Agreement for the
Radar Data Processor, Analog Signal Converter, and Radar
Signal Processor. '
In or about 1982, HUGHES agreed to fund the design
and development of the Radar Data Processor on the F-15
AFCD and F-15 MSIP CONTRACTS exclusively, whereby
cost allocations or charges pursuant to the Commonality
Agreements to the F-14D, F-18 and/or B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACTS constitute false claims. In or
about 1982, HUGHES priced and bid the design and
development of the Analog Signal Converter including Gate
Arrays on the B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACT,
whereby allocations and charges to the B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACT for the Analog Sinal Converter
including Gate Arrays to be adapted to meet the specifications
of the F-14D, F-15 MSIP and F-18 CONTRACTS constitute
false claims. HUGHES double priced and bid the
development of the Analog Signal Converter including Gate
Arrays on the F-15 MSIP CONTRACT. The cost allocations
and charges for the Analog Signal Converter pursuant to the
Commonality Agreements to the F-14D, F-15 MSIP and F-18
CONTRACTS constitute false claims. The development of the
Radar Signal Processor was funded solely on the F-15 MSIP
CONTRACT to February 8, 1985 when it was made
retroactive to September 15, 1984, and thereafter, the costs of
the Radar Signal Processor were allocated and charged to the
F-14D, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS,
which constitute false claims.
13.
Without the knowledge or approval of the customers of
HUGHES or the Department of Defense, including specifically
the United States Air Force and Navy Project Offices,
HUGHES unilaterally, secretly and falsely misallocated and
93
mischarged costs among the F-14D, F-15 MSIP, F-18 and B-2
SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS by means of six
Commonality Agreements, expressly for hardware, software,
STE, LTE, leasehold, material and procurement, including
without limitations:
AGREEMENT: 1
(A) Advanced RDP including refinements and
changes (2.1.2).
(B) EDM hardware fabrication, assembly and
test (2.1.5).
(C) DSIS and STE hardware design Common-
ality (2.1.6).
(D) Changes and upgrades to common support
software (3.1.3).
(E) DSIS common software, funded solely by
SPECIAL PROGRAMS (3.1.5).
AGREEMENT: 2 COVERAGE SAME AS AGREE-
MENT 1, PLUS:
= (fio (A) RDP refinements and changes including
Engineering Support (2.1.2).
AGREEMENT: 3
(A) ASC development (2.1.1).
(B) ASC refinements, changes and Configura-
tion Management (2.1.2). —
(C) EDM hardware (2.1.5).
(D) STE hardware (2.1.6).
(E) Common Hybrids and gate arrays (2.2).
(F) Operating test and support software (3.1).
(G) Mods and improvements to support soft-
ware (3.1).
94
(H) Leasing costs for facilities (4.0).
AGREEMENT: 4 COVERAGE SAME AS AGREE-
MENT 3, PLUS:
(A) Radar Data Processor (2.4.1).
(B) Analog Signal Converter (2.4.2).
(C) Radar Signal Processor (2.4.3)
(D) Common power supplies (2.4.4).
(E) Common hardwaze fabrication (2.4.7).
(F) TRI MUX and RSP Power Converter
Modules on F-14 and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS (2.4.8).
(G) Configuration management and control of
design improvement changes (2.4.8).
(H) Laboratory test Equipment (LTE) on F-15
and SPECIAL PROGRAMS (2.4.9).
(I) DSIS and STE allocated among F-14, F-15
and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS.
costs (2.4.11).
(J) Labor, residual material, lot and freight
AGREEMENT: 5 COVERAGE SAME AS AGREE-
MENT 4, PLUS:
(2.4.11)
(A) Radar Data Processor (2.4.1).
(B) Analog Signal Converter (2.4.2).
(C) Radar Signal Processor (2.4.3).
(D) Firm memory module (1.2.3).
(E) Sustaining engineering (2.2.3).
(F) Composite hardware requirements (2.4.5).
(G) Engineering material labor and ODC
95
(H) Common hardware part specifications
(2.4.12)
eain (1) Common hardware part qualification testing
(J) Material and process specifications (2.4.13)
AGREEMENT 6: COVERAGE SAME AS AGREE-
MENT 5.
14.
Without the knowledge or approval of the customers of
HUGHES or the Department of Defense, including specifically
the United States Air Force and United State Navy Project
Offices, HUGHES unilaterally, secretly and falsely misallo-
cated and mischarged costs among the F-14D, F-15 MSIP, F-
States Air Force and United States Navy Project Offices,
includi ithout limitation:
AGREEMENT 1:
(A) F-15 Advanced Fighter Capability Demonstration
“tr and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS allocated1/2 and 1/2
1.2).
(B) Identical part numbers (2.1).
(C) No definition of the mechanics of cost allocation.
AGREEMENT 2:
(A) F-15 MSIP and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
allocated 1/2 and 1/2 (2.1.2).
(B) Identical part numbers (2.1).
(C) No definition of the mechanics of cost allocation.
AGREEMENT 3:
96
(A) F-15 MSIP and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
allocated 1/2 and1/2 (2.1.1).
(B) Identical part numbers (2.1).
(C) No definition of the mechanics of cost allocation.
AGREEMENT 4:
(A) F-14, F-15 MSIP and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
allocated 1/3, 1/3 and 1/3 (2.4).
(B) Different part numbers authorized (2.1).
(C) Commonality Management Board (CMB) estab-
lished to “... approve equitable cost allocation percentages”
(1.3).
(D) Commonality Advisory Committee (CAC)
established to “... determine the status of the development
phase of common equipment and recommend equitable cost
allocation percentages for approval by the CMB” (1.3).
AGREEMENT 5:
(A) F-14, F-15 MSIP and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
allocated 1/3, 1/3 and 1/3 orl/2 and1/2 (2.4).
(B) Different part numbers authorized (2.2).
(C) Defines Commonality Management of CMB,
CAC, and subcommittees (1.3).
ean (D) Establishes cost sharing for sustaining engineering
(E) Creates specific funding agreement for RDP, ASC,
RSP and Power Supplies (2.4.1).
(F) Costs charged to Commonality Account and then
transferred out to programs (2.4.7).
(G) Requirements for Commonality plans, reports,
reviews, cost accounts and charges per “Commonality
Operating Instructions” (2.4.13).
AGREEMENT 6:
97
(A) F-14, F-15 MSIP, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS allocated 1/4, 1/4, 1/4 and 1/4 or 1/3, 1/3, and
1/3 or 1/2 and 1/2 (1.2.3, 2.4.1, 2.4.2, 2.4.3).
(B) Different part numbers stil! authorized (2.4.7).
(C) Adds duties for CAC Chairman and creates the
Commonality Change Management Board (CCMB), Materials
and Processes Management Board (MPMB) and Parts Man-
agement Board (PMB) (4.8.11).
(D) Costs of CCMB, MDMB and PMB divided by
ny Gekp ent y ob page
(E) Adds the “Control Level Item” (CLI for
proportional cost allocation (4.8.5).
(F) Material reverts to Commonality Account (4.8.11).
nasa Creates journal from Commonality Account
(H) Introduces a Contract Allocation Matrix (4.8.11).
15.
The Commonality Agreements dated February 8, 1985
and June 19, 1985 provided that the cost sharing with the F-
14D contract was retroactive to September 15, 1984. The
Commonality Agreement dated May 8, 1987 provided that cost
was retroactive to September 15, 1984. None of the
of costs or invoices predicated upon the aforesaid retroactive
cost allocations to September 15, 1984.
16.
On December 18, 1981, HUGHES was advised that
HUGHES had won the full scale development B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACT to employ the existing HUGHES
F-15 APG-63 and F-18 radar processing modules, except for
frequency change and repackaging of the modules, with no
98
provision for cost allocations to or from any other aircraft,
contract or program.
17.
On or about March 8, 1982, the new B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS Division was created with SCHUMER as
Division Contracts Manager. In or about March, 1982,
HUGHES received the letter B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
CONTRACT which specified the basic HUGHES F-15 APG-
63 and F-18 radar processing core modules for the B-2 aircraft
with no provision for cost allocations to or from any other
aircraft, contract or program.
18.
Beginning in or about April 1982, the B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS mission changes caused lengthy negotiations to
revise the radar processor core capacity specifications and to
determine cost and schedule impacts. There were two main
areas of technical concern: :
(1) The novel classified antenna approach. The
antenna was of such concern that a special Risk Reduction
Program was imposed on HUGHES.
(2) The data processing capacity for the Radar Data
Processor, Analog Signal Converter and Radar Signal
Processor, and other modules where processing rates and
throughputs were increased beyond the capacity of the existing
HUGHES F-15 APG-63 and F-18 radar modules which were
specified in the B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACT.
19.
On or about October 26, 1982, HUGHES was awarded
the definitized B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACT
which provided for the design and development of the
advanced Analog Signal Converter including Gate Arrays. In
1982 and 1983, HUGHES double priced and bid the advanced
Analog Signal Converter including Gate Arrays on the F-15
MSIP CONTRACT.
99
20.
In or about March 1983, HUGHES received the fixed
price incentive F-15 MSIP CONTRACT for F-15 aircraft only
with no provision for cost allocations to or from any other
aircraft, contract or program. Effective in or about 1984,
HUGHES received the F-14D and F-18 UPGRADE
CONTRACTS with no provision for cost allocations to or
from any other aircraft, contract or program.
21.
RELATOR is informed and believes, and thereon
alleges, that the customers of HUGHES, the Department of
Defense and specifically the United States Air Force and
United States Navy Project Offices had no knowledge, had not
made any advance agreement, and had not approved the
misbid, misallocations and mischarges made by HUGHES
among the F-14D, F-15 MSIP, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL
PROGRAMS CONTRACTS pursuant to the HUGHES
Commonality Agreements, whereby the Contracting Officer
caused the suspension of payments to HUGHES on the B-2
SPECIAL PROGRAMS subcontract under Prime Contract
F33657-81-C-0067 by the issuance of a DCAA Form |
pursuant to DOD FAR supplement 42.801 and 42.803. The F-
14D, F-15 MSIP, F-18, and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
CONTRACTS did not provide any authorization for the
unilateral and secret misbid, misallocations and mischarges by
Department of Defense.
22.
It is estimated by SCHUMER that the false misbids,
misallocations and mischarges by HUGHES among the F-14D,
F-15 MSIP, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS
CONTRACTS from 1982-1990 in the sum of $50,000,000, or
according to proof at the time of trial.
100
23.
Defendant HUGHES misbid, misallocated and mis-
charged incurred costs among the F-14, F-15 MSIP, F-18 and
B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS without contrac-
tual or legal authorization from 1982 to 1990, in violation of
the Truth in Negotiation Act, 10 U.S.C. 2306(a) and 41 U.S.C.
254(d) and Federal Acquisition Regulations 15.802(a) and
(b)(3), and 15.804-2, and 15.806, whereby HUGHES falsely
and unlawfully bid and certified proposals on the F-14D, F-15
MSIP, F-18 and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS procurements by
the Department of Defense that did not disclose the cost allo-
cations pursuant to the Commonality Agreements without
authorization of contract or law, constituting certification
violations of Federal Acquisition Regulation 15.804-4 and
Defective Cost and Pricing Data in violation of Federal Acqui-
sition Regulation 15.804-7.
24.
Defendant HUGHES knowingly misbid, misallocated
and mischarged costs incurred among the F-14D CONTRACT,
the F15 MSIP CONTRACT, the F-18 CONTRACT and the B-
2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACT in order to receive
payment and make profit thereon. Plaintiff alleges that each of
the claims for payment by HUGHES and the payments
received by HUGHES constitute false claims within the
definitions set forth in 31 U.S.C. 3729(a).
25.
The number of false claims by HUGHES from 1982 to
1990 that should bear a $5,000 to $10,000 penalty pursuant to
31 U.S.C. 3729(a)(7) is conservatively estimated to be 1,000,
whereby at $5,000 the total penalty would be $5,000,000 or at
$10,000 the total penalty would be $10,000,000. The number
of false claims by HUGHES was derived from the fact that
HUGHES vouchered at least weekly on the F14D, F15, F18
and B-2 SPECIAL PROGRAMS CONTRACTS by DD250
101
vouchers, progress payment vouchers and cost reimbursement
vouchers.
26
The officers, managers and employees of Defendant
HUGHES have conspired to suppress and/or destroy evidence
of the false claims in order to prevent its customers, ultimately
the United States Government, from becoming aware of the
HUGHES false claims and in order to permit HUGHES to
Continue to receive contract payments and to permit HUGHES
to increase its profits in violation of 31 U.S.C. 3729(a).
27.
Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereupon
alleges, that at all times alleged herein, Defendant HUGHES
28
Plaintiff alleges that the officers, managers, and
employees of HUGHES and RSG have acted in furtherance of
the above referenced conspiracy to fraudulently obtain the
payment of false claims through the preparation of false
records, statements, and invoices, and the collaborative
omission and suppression of material facts, as herein alleged.
29.
In doing the acts herein alleged, the officers, managers,
and employees of HUGHES RSG were acting in their
respective capacities as officers, agents or employees of
HUGHES and/or RSG. ’
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff for judgment against
Defendant as follows: _
(1) For restitution to the United States Government of
all monies wrongfully invoiced by HUGHES and reimbursed
by the United States Government to HUGHES in the sum of
102
$50,000,000, or according to proof at the time of trial, pursuant
to 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq.
(2) For three times the amount wrongfully invoiced by
HUGHES and reimbursed by the United States Government to
HUGHES under prime and subcontracts in the sum of
$150,000,000, or according to proof at the time of trial,
pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3729(a){7);
(3) For civil penalty of not less than $5,000 and not
more than $10,000 for each and every invoice wrongfully
submitted by HUGHES for reimbursement by the United
States Government and/or prime contractors under United
States Government Contracts from 1982-1990 in the sum of
$5,000,000 at the minimum $5,000 penalty or $10,000,000 at
the maximum $10,000,000 penalty, or according to proof at
the time of trial, pursuant to 31 U.S.C. 3730(d);
(4) For all awards or percentages of the proceeds of
the action or settlement pursuant to 31 U.S.c. 3730(d);
8) For costs of suit incurred herein including
reasonavie attorneys fees and expenses pursuant to 31 U.S.C.
3730(d);
(6) For such other and further relief as the Court
deems just and proper.
Dated: April 3, 1990
PACE AND QUINN
By:/s/ Dean France Pace
Dean Francis Pace
Attormeys for Plaintiff
William J. Schumer
103
STUART M. GERSON
Assistant Attorney General
ROBERT L. BROSIO
United States Attorney
JOHN E. NORDIN I
Asst. United States Attorney
Telephone: (213) 798-3552
MICHAEL F. HERTZ
VINCENT B. TERLEP, JR.
United States Department of Justice
Post Office Box 261
Ben Franklin Station
Washington, D.C. 20044
Telephone: (202) 304-0474
Attorneys for the United States
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, )
ex rel. WILLIAM J.SCHUMER _)
) CV 89-0390 MRP (Bx)
Plaintiff, )
) NOTICE OF
v. ) ELECTION BY THE
) UNITED STATES
HUGHES AIRCRAFT CO.,INC. ) DECLINING
104
TO THE COURT AND ALL PARTIES TO
THIS CIVIL ACTION:
Pursuant to the False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C § 3730(b)
(2)&(4), the United States of America, by its undersigned
attorneys, hereby gives notice to the Court of its election to
decline to intervene and proceed with this action at this time.
The United States requests, pursuant to 31 U.S.C.
§ 3730 (c)(3), that the parties serve copies of all pleadings
filed in the action upon it through the undersigned counsel at
the below address, and, upon its request and at its expense, that
the parties supply the United States with copies of transcripts
of depositions taken in this action.
Although the United States has declined, at this time, to
enter its appearance in this action, the Court is respectfully
referred to 31 U.S.C. § 3730(b) which provides that the relator
may carry on the action in the name of the Government, but
that “[t]he action may be dismissed only if the court and the
Attorney General give written consent to the dismissal and
their reasons for consenting.”
Therefore, the United States respectfully requests that
should this action be proposed either by the relator or the
defendant to be dismissed, settled, or otherwise discontinued,
this Court first solicit the consent of the Attorney General
through the undersigned attorneys of the United States
Department of Justice, before ruling or granting its approval.
Respectfully submitted,
STUART M. GERSON
Assistant Attorney General
Dated: May 30, 1990
105
ROBERT L. BROSIO
United States Attorney
JOHN E. NORDIN, I
Asst. United States Attorney
MICHAEL F. HERTZ
VINCENT B. TERLEP, JR.
U.S. Department of Justice
Civil Division
Post Office Box 261
Ben Franklin Station
Washington, D.C. 20044
Telephone: (202) 304-0474
Attorneys for the United States
106
JAMES J. GALLAGHER
MARK R. TROY
McKENNA & CUNEO
444 South Flower Street, 8th Floor
Los Angeles, California 90071
(213) 688-1000
Attorneys for Defendant
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, _)
ex rel, WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, _) Civil No.
) CV 89-0390-MRP
Plaintiff, )
) AFFIDAVIT OF
vs. ) JOHN F. WILSON
)
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY, )
)
Defendant. )
)
I, John F. Wilson, declare and state:
1. I am Director of Contracts for the Radar Systems
Group of Hughes Aircraft. I have read the complaint filed by
William J. Schumer in the above captioned matter and am
familiar with the allegations made therein.
2. On July 30, 1986, the Air Force Plant Representa-
tive Office (“AFPRO”) held a meeting with Hughes personnel
to discuss the findings of an audit conducted by the Air Force
107
Audit Agency. This meeting addressed the items contained in
a Department of the Air Force document entitled “Report of
Audit 86-5, Review of Common Advanced Radar Develop-
ment Costs” (hereafter “audit report”). The document which
ae classified and has recently been declassi-
| consists 0 narrative pages plus two pages consisting
of listings of general ledger accounts and dollar amounts. The
audit, had been performed during the period of August 1985 to
April 1986. A true and correct copy of the three narrative
pages is attached hereto as Exhibit 1.
3. The audit report stated that the purpose of the audit
was to examine costs accumulated by Hughes for the develop-
ment of certain radar hardware common to three radar systems
programs -- the B-2, the F-15 Multistage Improvement
Program (“MSIP”), and the F-14D -- and to determine whether
the costs accumulated for the development of the common sub-
units were “equitably” distributed among [sic] the participating
programs.” Exhibit 1 (Audit report) ¥¥ 1, 3.
4. The audit report alleged that certain subunits
developed under the F-15 program were to be used on the B-2
and F-14D programs, but that the F-15 program was to bear
the full costs for that development effort. The report identified
the common subunits as the Radar Data Processor, Analog
Signal Converter, and Radar Signal Processor. Exhibit |
(Audit report) ¥ 2.
5. The audit report alleged that the F-15 program “was
proposed, evaluated, and negotiated as a stand-alone effort . . .
requir(ing] Hughes to design, develop, fabricate, and test the
new [F-15] radar and did not address any cost sharing with
other programs.” Exhibit 1 (Audit report) ¢ 5.
6. The audit report alleged that “Hughes developed
internal [Memorandums of Agreement (“MOA’s”)] between
separate Hughes program managers for cost sharing as early as
December 1982 and established accounts for the collection of
development costs on efforts they deemed common to more
than one system.” Exhibit 1 (Audit report) ¢ 5.
108 109
7. The audit report alleged that “it was not appropriate E ted thi
for Hughes to allocate any of the non-recurring development ——«. 1990, at Los
costs for the [F-15] items to the other programs.” Exhibit |
(Audit report) ¥ 5.
8. The audit report alleged that “Hughes has charged j
development costs to all three customers [i.e. the B-2, F-14D John F. Wil
and F-15 MSIP] that should be borne by the F-15 MSIP. The tems
decision to distribute these costs and the ratio for the
distribution were made internally by Hughes with no input
from the appropriate government program offices or the prime
contractors.” Exhibit 1 (Audit report) § 4.
9. The audit report alleged that since the F-15 contract
was in an overrun condition, “every dollar of development
effort charged to that contract is a dollar loss to Hughes. The
allocation of development costs to the other contracts reduces
[Hughes’] loss.” Exhibit 1 (Audit report) ¥ 6.
10. On December 10, 1987, the Defense Contract
Audit Agency (“DCAA”) issued a “Notice of Contract Costs
Suspended and/or Disapproved” which suspended a substantial
amount of cost under Hughes’ cost reimbursement contract on
the B-2 Programs. A true and correct copy of the DCAA
notice, in the form received by Hughes, is attached hereto as
Exhibit 2.
11. Generally, audit reports questioning the allow-
ability of costs and alleging defective pricing are routinely
provided to contractors to enable them to prepare appropriate
responses. Hughes prepared and submitted its response to the
Air Force and is in the process of submitting a formal claim for
reimbursement of its costs, now that the Department of Justice
has completed its investigation and determined not to intervene
in Schumer’s action.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is
true and correct. If called upon, I could testify to the matters
contained herein.
110
DEFENSE LOGISTICS AGENCY
DEFENSE PLANT REPRESENTATIVE OFFICE
HUGHES LOS ANGELES
P.O. BOX 92463
LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA 90009-2463
DCMDW-RKA September 19, 1990
SUBJECT: Request for Audit Comment on Cost Accounting
Standards Aspect of RSG Commonality Issue
TO: DCAA/J. McGowan
+t Request DCAA review and comment on the Cost
Accounting Standards (CAS) aspects of the RSG commonality
issue. The issue originated from Air Force Audit Agency
(AFAA) Report 86-5, which found that the contractor had
allocated development costs between major radar programs
based upon internal Memorandums of Agreement (MOAs or
commonality agreements). An unclassified copy of the AFAA
report provided by the company is encl 1. Based upon the
AFAA report, DCAA audit reports (encl 2 and 3), and AFPRO
technical reviews it was recommended that the plant office
cognizant of the prime contractor withhold $15 mil. In a
parallel action a qui tam suit was brought against Hughes by a
former RSG contracts manager for the use of commonality
agreements and the suit was reviewed by the Dept of Justice
(DOJ). In approximately May 90, DOJ chose not to join the
qui tam action, and RSG requested release of the $15 mil
suspension from the prime. The DPRO recommended against
release of the suspension due to the unresolved issues (encl 4).
2. It appears that the contractor was in conflict with their
disclosed accounting practices when they allocated develop-
ment costs between contracts in accordance with the common-
ality agreements. Prior to 1984 RSG had three (3) separate
Disclosure Statements; Group Office, Non-Manufacturing
Division, and Manufacturing Division. The specific area of
Caer atme than ie 2.50, Nethed fe
for Section 2.5.0. Y (4) was as follows:
Direct labor cost incurred in the manufacture of
common hardware is collected in a holding
account and is allocated to contracts based on
; ; tard
There was no provision for the allocation of development costs
between contracts in the Non-Manufacturing Division Disclo-
sure Statement.
3. On 5 Jul 84, the contractor submitted a revised Disclo-
sure Statement, dated 2 Jan 84, which consolidated the three
| Discl 5 and included ,
things “Refinements to statements describing the procedures
for Commonality Pools in effect at RSG”. Specifically, this
revision revised Item 2.5.0.Y (4) as follows:
design, support and manufacture of common
hardware is collected in a holding account and
is allocated to contracts based on contemplated
requirements.
112
4. Due to the time critical nature of this issue, your
cmpesiitad comments are requested by 26 Sep 90. The support
11S. aapmpecc:| alter
/s/ Brian Reilly
7 Encl BRIAN F REILLY, Principal
1. AFAA Report 86-5, Administrative Contracting
undated Officer
2. DCAA Audit 4511 1-71B486004
3. DCAA Audiit4Si1 1-71B86004S1
4. PACO ttt, did! > Aug'90
5. HAC ltr, dtd 5 July 84
6. DCAA Audit 4521-5A441400
7. PACO ltr, dtd 1 Apr 85
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
113
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) Civil No. CV 89-0390-
ex rel, WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, ) MRP
) AFFIDAVIT OF JOHN
Vs. ) F. WILSON IN
) SUPPORT OF
HUGHES AIRCRAFT ) DEFENDANT’S
COMPANY, ) MOTION FOR SUM-
) MARY JUDGMENT
Defendant. ) FRCP. 56(b)
)
) Date: October 29, 1990
) Time: 10:00 a.m.
) Courtroom: Hon.
) Mari Pfael
I, John F. Wilson, declare and state.
we 1. of He uector of Contracts for the Radar Sys-
Group of Hughes Aircraft Company . This
Affidavits a supplement to my Affidavit executed on Septen
ber 7, 1990, in support of Hughes’ motion for summary judg-
ment.
114 115
2. For purposes of Hughes’ motion for summary Executed
judgment, the disclosures of the Air Force Audit Agency ——-
Report No. 86-5, entitled “Review of Common Advanced
Radar Development Costs,” (attached as Exhibit | to the Affi-
davit of John F. Wilson), and the Defense Contract Audit
Agency (“DCAA”) Form |! “Notice of Contract Costs /s/ John F, Wilson
Suspended And/Or Disapproved,” (attached as Exhibit 2 to the John F. Wilson
Affidavit of John F. Wilson), which are at issue, are limited to
disclosures made to Northrop Corporation and to Hughes
Aircraft Company.
3. The response by Hughes to the Air Force Audit
Agency Report (Exhibit 1) and the DCAA Form |! (Exhibit 2)
is not in any way relevant to Hughes’ motion for summary
judgment.
4 Hughes received the Air Force Audit Agency
Report (Exhibit 1) on July 30, 1986.
5. Hughes received the DCAA Form | (Exhibit 2)
on December 10, 1987.
6. The Hughes copy of the Air Force Audit
Agency Report (Exhibit 1) remained classified “SECRET” as
of January 23, 1989, and remained classified until September
5, 1990, when it was declassified.
7. The DCAA Form | (Exhibit 2) has never been
classified.
8. Hughes did not receive and does not possess the
“Management Comments” referenced in the Air Force Audit
Agency Report (Exhibit 1).
9. The word “withheld” which appears three times
on the DCAA Form | (Exhibit 2) was on said DCAA Form |
when it was received by Hughes.
| declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is
true and correct. If called upon, I could testify to the matters
116
NORTHROP
B-2 Division
Northrop Corporation
8900 East Washington Boulevard
Pico Rivera, California 90660
Telephone 213 942-3000
DECLARATION
I, Laurie L. Bilbruck hereby declare that 1 am employed as
Manager, Subcontract Administration at Northrop Corporation
and, on 31 August 1989 was designated as the Custodian of
Records for all documents relating to Hughes Aircraft
Company Commonality Agreements and the sharing of costs
between 2301 Special Program, F-15 Radar Multistage
Improvement Program and F-18 Radar Program.
I further declare that the within and attached pages are true and
correct copies of original documents or the best copy available
of the following documents:
Memo dated 15 June 1984 from R.J. Soikkeli to B.
George requesting Government Audit Assistance.
Memo dated 13 February 1985 from R.C. Davis to S.
Rubenstein attaching 1982 Hughes memo and MOA.
Whitepaper on “Radar Commonality” dated 20 Febru-
ary 1986.
Memo dated 17 March 1986 from R.P. Francis to R.J.
Soikkeli.
Letter dated 14 May 1986 from W.R. Duke to J.
Shulsinger of Hughes regarding “Potential Cost Dis-
allowance.”
DCAA Form | dated 10 December 1987.
I further declare that 1 am unable to locate the Air Force Audit
Report dated June 23, 1988 requested by the Deposition Sub-
poena under Case Number CV89-0390 MRP because the date
117
appears to be in error. A document dated June 23, 1986 was
located. However, it is classified “SECRET” and cannot be
transmitted with this declaration.
IN WITNESS THEREOF, | have hereunto set my hand at Pico
Rivera, California on this 12th day of October 1990.
/s/ Laurie L. Bilbruc}
Laurie L. Bilbruck
(attachments omitted in printing)
118
DCMDW-RKA 5 Feb 91
SUBJECT: Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Request
TO: Mr. John P. Wilson, Contracts Director
Radar Systems Group
RS, RO1, 12Z32
References: (a) Pace, Quinn and Rose letter, dated 2 Jan 91.
(b) Pace, Quinn and Rose letter, dated 11 Jan
91.
The DPRO has received the attached FOIA requests for
information related to B-2 subcontracts awarded to Hughes
Aircraft Company by Northrop Corporation. Your comments
are solicited regarding these FOIA requests.
Sincerely,
2 ENCL /s/ Brian Reilly
A/S Brian Reilly, Principal
Administrative Contracting
Officer
119
HUGHES
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
11 February 1991
To: Mr. Brian Reilly,
Principal Administrative Contracting Officer
Subject: Freedom of Information (FOIA) Request
Reference: Your letter, dated 5 February 1991, same
subject, reference: DCMDW-RKA
Thank you for soliciting Hughes Aircraft Company comments
concerning Pace, Quinn and Rose letters dated 2 and 11
January 1991.
We are not specifically aware of what, if any, of the audit
reports and records being sought by Mr. Dean Francis Pace the
Defense Contract Audit Agency has in its possession. We can
only evaluate Mr. Pace’s request if we are provided with
copies of these documents or are advised of their contents.
Notwithstanding, we object to the release of the types of
documents requested as they would contain “trade secrets and
commercial or financial information” which is “privileged or
confidential” to Hughes under exemption (b) (4) of
5U.S.C.552.
Sincerely,
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
Radar Systems Group
/s/ John F. Wilson
John F. Wilson
Director Contracts
120
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
HONORABLE MARIANA R. PFAELZER,
JUDGE PRESIDING
U.S.A. EX REL WILLIAM J. )
SCHUMER,
PLAINTIFF,
)
)
)
VS. ) NO. CV. 89-390 MRP
)
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY, )
)
DEFENDANT. )
)
REPORTER’S TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 1991
BETH ESTHER ZACCARO
OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
414 UNITED STATES COURTHOUSE
312 NORTH SPRING STREET
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90012
(213) 626-2622
121
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: MONDAY,
FEBRUARY 11, 1991: 10:00
THE CLERK: ITEM NUMBER FIVE, CIVIL 89-390.
U.S.A. EX REL WILLIAM J. SCHUMER VS. HUGHES
AIRCRAFT COMPANY.
COUNSEL: PLEASE MAKE YOUR APPEAR-
ANCES.
MR. PACE: GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR,
DEAN PACE FOR PLAINTIFF.
MR. GALLAGHER: GOOD MORNING, YOUR
HONOR, JAMES J. GALLAGHER AND MARK TROY
FOR THE DEFENDANT.
THE COURT: ALL RIGHT.
I HAVE LOOKED OVER THE FILE, AND IT
SEEMS TO ME THAT IT WOULD BE APPROPRIATE TO
LET YOU GO ON UNTIL THE END OF OCTOBER WITH
THE DISCOVERY AND SET THE LAST DAY OF -
OCTOBER --- IF THAT IS A COURT DAY -- FOR THE
FILING OF MOTIONS.
ARE YOU GOING TO FILE MOTIONS?
MR. PACE: YES, YOUR HONOR.
THE COURT: WHAT DO YOU HAVE IN MIND?
MR. PACE: I BELIEVE THIS IS A MATTER OF
SUMMARY JUDGMENT, YOUR HONOR. THE FACTS
ARE REALLY NOT IN DISPUTE .
I BELIEVE THIS COURT SHOULD DETERMINE IF
BY SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND IF NOT, THIS WILL BE
A TRIAL BEFORE THE COURT BECAUSE OF THE
HIGHLY CLASSIFIED NATURE OF THESE MATTERS.
IT WOULD BE IMPOSSIBLE TO IMPANEL A JURY, SO
VIRTUALLY IF WE COULD PRESENT THE EVIDENCE
TO THE COURT BY WAY OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT, IF
122
THE COURT WOULD DECIDE THAT THERE SHOULD
BE A TRIAL AT LEAST ON CERTAIN MATTERS, I AM
CONFIDENT THAT WE COULD LIMIT THE ISSUES
THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE TRIED BEFORE THIS
COURT.
IT IS MY HOPE TO FILE A MOTION FOR
PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT QUITE SOON.
THE COURT: NOW THAT IS ON THE LIABILITY
ASPECT OF THE CASE?
MR. PACE: PERHAPS BOTH, YOUR HONOR.
THE COURT: HUM-HUM.
MR. PACE: IF IT PLEASES THE COURT, MAY I
INFORM THE COURT OF TWO DEVELOPMENTS THAT
HAVE OCCURRED SINCE WE FILED THAT JOINT
STATUS REPORT.
FIRST THERE HAS BEEN NO COMPLIANCE
WITH DISCOVERY BY DEFENDANT HUGHES
AIRCRAFT COMPANY.
INTERROGATORIES, REQUESTS FOR
PRODUCTION AND NOTICE OF A RULE 30(B)6)
WITNESS WAS FILED OR SERVED THE FIRST WEEK
OF JULY, AND THROUGH VARIOUS DELAYS, HAS
BEEN CONTINUED INCLUDING AN ORDER BY
MAGISTRATE BROWN TO FEBRUARY 4TH WHICH
WAS LAST MONDAY, AND _ THIS’ STATUS
CONFERENCE WAS CONTINUED A WEEK BECAUSE
OF THAT.
THE COURT: YES.
MR. PACE: LAST MONDAY THERE WAS
ABSOLUTELY NO PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS.
I WAS INFORMED THAT THERE MAY BE AS
MANY AS NINE RULE 30(B)(6) WITNESSES, BUT I WAS
INFORMED THAT ALL NINE OF THEM AND COUNSEL
123
WERE UNAVAILABLE FOR THEIR DEPOSITIONS AS
NOTICED LAST MONDAY.
THERE WERE OBJECTIONS TO INTERROGA-
TORIES AND SOME ANSWERS THAT REFERRED TO
DOCUMENTS THAT WERE NOT PRODUCED OR
INCORPORATED OTHER ANSWERS WHICH ARE
CLEARLY IN VIOLATION OF THE COMPLIANCE WITH
DISCOVERY.
WE HAD A LOCAL RULE 715 MOTION IN MY
OFFICE LAST MONDAY NIGHT AT 6:00 O'CLOCK. |
WAS INFORMED THAT DEFEND ANT WOULD RECON-
SIDER PREDICATED UPON NARROWING SOME OF
THE REQUESTS.
LATER IN THE WEEK I WAS INFORMED THAT
THEIR CLIENT WAS OUT OF TOWN UNTIL THURSDAY
AND I JUST THIS MORNING FIVE MINUTES BEFORE
TRIAL INDICATE THAT THEY ARE GOING TO
PRODUCE CERTAIN UNCLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS ON
WEDNESDAY, THE 13TH BUT NO MENTION ABOUT
THE RULE 30(B\6) WITNESSES AND NO MENTION
WITH REGARD TO THE INTERROGATORIES WHICH
AGAIN IS GOING TO REQUIRE FURTHER MOTIONS
BEFORE MAGISTRATE BROWN.
THIS DISCOVERY IS CRITICAL TO UNDER-
STAND THE REASON WHY HUGHES AIRCRAFT COM-
PANY TOOK THE POSITIONS THAT IT HAS TAKEN
CLEARLY CONTRARY TO D.C.A.A. POSITIONS AS WE
KNOW THEM THROUGH THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT,
AND FOR EXAMPLE, YOUR HONOR, UNDER THE COST
ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD THERE IS A
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT FILED UNDER PENALTY
OF PERJURY FOR CONTRACTS IN EXCESS OF TEN
MILLION DOLLARS WHERE AN AEROSPACE CON-
TRACTOR IS REQUIRED TO REVEAL THE METHOD IN
WHICH IT WILL ACCUMULATE AND ALLOCATE
124
COSTS AND THAT IT WHAT THIS CASE IS ALL
ABOUT.
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY FAILED TO
NOTIFY THE GOVERNMENT OF THESE UNIQUE MAT-
TERS IN WHICH THEY HAVE ACCUMULATED AND
ALLOCATED COSTS ON THE B2 PROGRAM, F14, 15
AND 18 CONTRACTS WHICH ARE AT ISSUE IN THIS
CASE.
IT IS IMPERATIVE FOR PLAINTIFF BEFORE WE
GO TO THE GOVERNMENT TO GAIN ALL OF THESE
AUDIT REPORTS, D.C.A.A. FORM 1'S WHERE D.C.A.A.
HAS ALREADY SUSPENDED ELEVEN MILLION EIGHT
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS OF COSTS AS UNRE-
IMBURSIBLE ON THE B2 CONTRACT ALONE.
WE NEED TO KNOW WHAT THEIR POSITION IS,
AND THIS HAS BEEN TERRIBLY COMPLICATED BY
THE FACT THAT SEVEN OR EIGHT MONTHS AFTER
NOTICED DISCOVERY WE DON’T HAVE ANY.
THE SECOND THING I WOULD LIKE TO ADVISE
THE COURT IS THIS.
INCONCEIVABLE AS IT IS, DEAN PACE TURNS
OUT TO BE THE ONLY QUI TAM COUNSEL OF THE
HUNDREDS OF QUI TAM CASES FILED THAT HAVE
TWO CRITICAL HIGH SECURITY MATTERS PENDING.
1 AM ADVISED THIS BY THE JUSTICE DEPART-
MENT.
IF THE COURT WILL RECALL LAST MARCH AT
THE STATUS CONFERENCE THE COURT SUGGESTED
THAT BECAUSE COUNSEL FOR HUGHES AIRCRAFT
COMPANY HAD TWO COUNSEL THAT WERE
CLEARED THAT IT WOULD BE APPROPRIATE THAT
THE RELATOR’S COUNSEL
125
DEFENSE LOGISTICS AGENCY
DEFENSE CONTRACT MANAGEMENT COMMAND
DEFENSE PLANT REPRESENTATIVE OFFICE
HUGHES LOS ANGELES
P.O. BOX 92463
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90009-2463
DCMDW-RKA 25 Mar 91
SUBJECT: Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Request
TO: Mr. John F. Wilson, Contracts Director
Radar Systems Group
RS, RO1, 12Z32
We received a revised request from Pace, Quinn and Rose
under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) for documents
and information pertaining to B-2, F-14, F15 and F18 subcon-
tracts awarded to Hughes Aircraft Company (HAC) and
specifically the following:
(1) |DCAA Audit Reports and DCAA Forms | and
ene DCAA Form | dated 10 Dec
(2) Air Force Audit Agency (AFAA) Report 86-5
and subsequent AFAA or DCAA reports;
(3) 30 Jul 86 meeting [minutes] between the
AFPRO and HAC to discuss the AFAA report;
(4) Northrop request for Government Audit
Assistance dated 15 Jun 84; and
(5) the HAC Statement of Claim Re Suspension of
Gate Array Radar Development Costs dated
4 Feb 88, including ing any supplemental HAC
claims or actions thereon by the Government.
126
To determine the releasability of the information contained in
these documents, and to give you the maximum
under the law, we ask that you review the documents and give
us the information required by the attachment to this letter
entitled “Requirements of Exemption 5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4).”
Sincerely,
/s/ Thomas E. Woolpert
2 Encl: THOMAS E. WOOLPERT
1. Requirements of Capt, USAF
Exemption 5 U.S.C. Contracting Officer
552 (b(4)
2. List of Documents w/Atch
127
REQUIREMENTS OF EXEMPTION 5 U.S.C. 552 (b)(4)
The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), as amended in 1974
by Public Law 93-502, requires federal agencies to provide
virtually all agency records, unless specifically exempted, for
public inspecting and copying. Section (b) of the Act contains
from the public. We are concerned here with the fourth
exemption which provides that “trade secrets and commercial
or financial information obtained from a person and privileged
or confidential” may be withheld from requesters (5 U.S.C.
552(b)\(4)).
To establish that the information requested is covered by the
fourth exemption of the FOIA, the information requested must
be a trade secret, commercial or financial information,
obtained from a person, and privileged or confidential
information. The United States Circuit Court of Appeals for
the District of Columbia has held that:
Commercial or financial matter is
“confidential” for purposes of the exemption if
disclosure of the information is likely to have
either of the following effects: (1) to impair
the Government’s ability to obtain necessary
information in the future; or (2) to cause
substantial harm to the competitive position of
the person from whom the information was
obtained. National Parks and Conservation
Ass'n v. Morton, 498 F.2d 765, 770 (1974).
The court has indicated that even though the government may
have no interest in keeping the information secret, “the
exemption may be invoked for the benefit of the person who
has provided commercial or financial information if it can be
shown that public disclosure is likely to cause substantial harm
to his competitive position.”
If you feel that the release of subject material would be
prejudicial to your commercial interests, and desire that the
128
government invoke the exemption for your benefit, please
notify this office in writing before 29 March 199] . Your
notification should clearly identify those specific portions of
therefore. Your notice should not be merely a conclusory legal
argument. We are prepare to apply the law, but we need 4
detailed factual discussion from you. You should keep in
mind that the Act requires that any reasonably segregable
portion of a record be provided to requesters, after deletion of
exempt portions. Therefore, if the deletion of key words or
phrases would adequately “sanitize” the material to protect
your interests, please so indicate. If you are unadle to
substantiate the adverse impact on your competitive position or
to your commercial interest, the information may be released
to the requester.
Under the FOIA, this office must respond to the requester by
2 April 199] ; therefore, we need your input by 29 March
1991 . If you have any questions concerning this matter, you
may contact Mr. Brian F. Reilly at (213) 414-6446 .
129
LIST OF DOCUMENTS
DATE PARAIN SUBJECT TO
REQUEST
10 Dec 87 (1) DCAA Form 1, Notice NORTHROP(N)
#001
27 Sep 88 (1) DCAA Report 4511-8
B179009 (N)-DCAA
8 May 89 (1) DCAA Form |, Notice 002 (N)
(undated) (2) AFAA Report 86-5
(Unclassified Version) AFAA
16 Oct 86 (2) DCAA Report 451 1- AFAA
7B486004
2 Jun 87 (2) DCAA Report 451 1- HUGHES (H)-
7B486004S | AFPRO
(3) 30 July 86 AFPRO/HAC Meeting
{so far a DPRO search has not resulted in such
a document being found on record}
15 Jun 84 (4) Northrop Request for Audit (N)-ACO
4 Feb 88
(5)
HAC “Statement of Claim Re Sus-
pension of Gate Array Radar Develop-
ment Costs Under Subcontract MPO
3NS-290450-AR,” including all sup-
plemental claims by HAC and actions
thereon by the Government.
[so far a DPRO search has not resulted in such
a document being found on record}
130
HUGHES
RADAR SYSTEMS GROUP
05 April 1991
Defense Logistics Agency
Defense Contract Management Command
Defense Plant Representative Office
Hughes Los Angeles
P. O. Box 92463
Los Angeles, California 90009-2463
Re: DCMDW-RKA
Subject: Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Request
Attention: Thomas E. Woolpert
Capt., USAF
Contracting Officer
Thank you for your messages, dated 25 and 27 March 1991,
and enclosures of documents for Hughes Aircraft Company's
review concerning Pace, Quinn and Rose's request under FOIA
for documents and information pertaining to B-2, F-14, F-15
and F-18 subcontracts awarded to Hughes.
We have reviewed these materials and conclude that they must
be provided to Pace, Quinn and Rose in any event under a
discovery request in the U.S. Distirct Court for the Central
District of California in the case of Schumer v. Hughes, Civil
Action CV 89-390 MRP (Bx), C.D. Cal. However, a
protective order has been issued by the court enabling Hughes
to appropriately identify data it considers proprietary. Accord-
ingly, Hughes has stamped and is returning herewith the
documents so marked for your submittal.
Sincerely,
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY
Radar Systems Group
/s/ John F. Wilson
JOHN F. WILSON
Director of Contracts
131
132
DEFENSE LOGISTICS AGENCY
DEFENSE PLANT REPRESENTATIVE OFFICE
HUGHES LOS ANGELES
P.O. BOX 92463
LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA 90009-2463
RKEE Nov 06 1991
SUBJECT: Technical Review of the HAC/D, Lynch
Briefing of 18 Oct 91 for Capt Vance, Lt
Barchick, and B. Reilly
TO: RKA (Mr B. Reilly)
l. In response to your request, RKEE has completed a
technical review of the subject briefing. Due to the limited
time frame allocated for this task, RKEE concentrated on
validating the most important points of the briefing. This was
accomplished by reviewing as many pertinent documents as
possible (see Encl 1).
2. A review of the previous Det 36/EPE Hardware
Commonality Report, dated 30 September 1986, revealed the
following:
a. A limited number of documents were reviewed
(13 each), 6 of which were purchase orders.
b. The only technical document reviewed was the
Critical Item Development (CID) Specification for the B-2
radar. It is our belief that this Hardware Commonality Report
was based on insufficient technical and associated data which
could easily have resulted in the evaluator drawing the wrong
conclusion.
3. — Our investigation supports the information presented in
the briefing given by Mr David Lynch on 18 October 1991.
The Analog Signal Converter (ASC) initial design effort using
gate array technology was started on the B-2 Program in
eee o ge POR ® tere ©
133
March of 1982 to meet technical requirements of the B-2
radar. In June 1982, a MOA was signed by the B-2 & F-15
Program Managers to allocate costs of the development and
fabrication of this ASC. But it was not until January 1984 that
MACAIR approved a contract modification (RCP/CCP M0001
dated 4/23/83) to utilize the advanced ASC in the F-15 MISIP
radar.
4. The Advanced Radar Data Processor (RDP) was
designed for the F-15 MISIP radar and the F-15 program
funded all development efforts for the basic design. In
December 1982, the Program Managers of the F-15 and B-2
radar programs signed a MOA for the allocation of costs of
development and fabrication tasks for the RDP. In February
1983, Northrup concurred with the Hughes proposal to use the
F-15 RDP in the B-2 radar.
5. To summarize the above:
a. The ASC using gate array technology design
was started on the B-2 radar program and was later used on the
F-15 MISIP radar program with costs being allocated in
accordance with a MOA between the B-2 and F-15 program
offices.
b. The F-15 MISIP RDP design was funded by
Hughes and the F-15 MISIP radar program and then used on
the B-2 radar with costs being allocated in accordance with a
MOA between the B-2 and F-15 program offices.
6. All documentation supporting this technical report is
on file in Building R31. If you have any questions concerning
this report please contact Mr John J. Boles at 414-6619.
/s/ D.A. Erickson
1 Encl DONALD A. ERICKSON
Chief Systems Engineering Branch
(attachment omitted)
134
DEFENSE CONTRACT AUDIT AGENCY
SOUTHWESTERN REGION
Corporate Resident Office
Hughes Aircraft Company
200 N. Sepulveda Blvd. (SC/864/C 130)
El Segundo, CA 90245-2463
4511/JLM/flm 14 November 1991
MEMORANDUM TO DIVISIONAL ADMINISTRATIVE
CONTRACTING OFFICER, DPRO,
HUGHES LOS ANGELES
SUBJECT: Determination of B-2 Commonality Issue
In response to your letter DCMDW-RKA, dated 6
November 1991, we are presenting our conclusions and
recommendation on the B-2 Commonality Issue.
We concur with the contractor’s claim for reimburse-
ment of costs incurred for the design, development, fabrication
assembly, and testing of modules and components
incorporated into the Analog Signal Converter and Radar Data
Processor units for the B-2 radar system. Our original
recommendations for cost suspensions resulted from the Air
Force Audit Agency findings that development costs charged
to the Hughes’ three major programs: F-15 MSIP, F14D, and
B-2, should have been borne by the F-15 MSIP only.
Based on the original facts presented to DCAA during
the 1985/1986 timeframe we believe they made the correct
determination. Because the classified nature of the B-2 pro-
gram precluded Hughes from discussing any aspect of the B-2
program with any other Hughes’ customers or Air Force pro-
gram office personnel not cleared on B-2, this prevented
Hughes from disclosing full details regarding commonality in
its pricing on the F-15 MSIP and F-14D programs. Later, the
135
Air Force authorized Hughes to disclose certain information
without violating B-2 security requirements. Additionally as
information has periodically become available these common-
ality ambiguities have been resolved or are in the process of
resolution.
Our review of the currently available information has
shown that the Hughes’ gate array enhanced ASC became a
requirement on the B-2 subcontract and was being worked on
before the F-15 MSIP subcontract authorized funding for that
effort. Also the cost allocation system adopted pursuant to
Hughes’ internal commonality agreements was disclosed to
both Northrop and the Air Force. Therefore, the contractor’s
claim for reimbursement of costs incurred on the B-2 radar
contract is valid.
If you have any questions please call me at (310) 364-
8500.
/s/ Jeffrey L. McGowan
JEFFREY L. MCGOWAN
Resident Auditor
136
DEFENSE LOGISTICS AGENCY
DEFENSE CONTRACT MANAGEMENT COMMAND
DEFENSE PLANT REPRESENTATIVE OFFICE
HUGHES LOS ANGELES
P.O. BOX 92463
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90009-2463
DCMDW-RKA 14 Nov 91
SUBJECT: _ Release of Suspended B-2 Radar Development
Costs
TO: DPRO Northrop
ATTN: Everett Parker, DACO
DCMDW-RXA
1. References:
a. DPRO Hughes-LA Technical Review, dated 6
Nov 91
b. DPRO Hughes-LA letter dated 20 Aug 90,
subject: Request for Release of Withhold
c. AFPRO Hughes/TM letter dated 18 Jan 89,
subject: Suspension of Payment
d. AFPRO Hughes/TM letter dated 11 Aug 87,
subject: Suspension of Payment
2. It is recommended that the B-2 radar development
costs suspended in response to the above referenced letters be
released. The contractor has substantiated that the requirement
for the gate array upgraded Analog Signal Converter existed
on the B-2 program prior to the award of the F-15 MSIP
contract. The B-2 program would have borne all costs for the
development of the Analog Signal Converter if the MSIP
contract had not been received. In light of the benefits
received, allocation of Analog Signal Converter development
costs to the B-2 program is considered appropriate. It is
137
recommended that the suspended costs be released with the
following caveats. First, the Government does not waive
rights to a share in any settlement resulting from the parallel
qui tam action in the event the relator’s case is successful.
Second, that an associated issue of Cost Accounting Standards
non-compliance is still open and shall remain so until resolved
to Government satisfaction.
s/ Brain F. Reilly
ce: DLA/M. Stein BRIAN F. REILLY, Divisional
DCAA/J. McGowan Administrative Contracting
Officer
2 Encl
1. DPRO Technical Report
2. DCAA Memorandum
138
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
EX REL WILLIAM J. SCHUMER, )
)
PLAINTIFF, )
) NO. CV89-0390 MRP
VS.
HUGHES AIRCRAFT COMPANY,
DEFENDANT.
ee
DEPOSITION OF ROBERT CHARLES DAVIS
DECEMBER 10, 1991
REPORTED BY: RUTH C. MOORE, CSR NO. 8444, RPR
JOB NO. 91655
SCHUMACHER SHORTHAND REPORTING
CORPORATION
2100 SAWTELLE, SUITE 103, LOS ANGELES, CA. 90025
(301) 478-3977
Q. ON PAGE 2, THE LAST SENTENCE ON
PAGE 2 SAYS “WHEN REQUESTED, NO COMMON-
ALITY PLANS WERE AVAILABLE FROM HUGHES.”
THE REFERENCE THERE IS TO HUGHES.
IS THAT RIGHT? 118-A?
A. THAT IS CORRECT.
Q. IT SAYS THAT NO COMMONALITY
PLANS WERE AVAILABLE FROM HUGHES.
WHAT IS YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF
WHAT THAT’S REFERRING TO?
A. I BELIEVE WHAT THAT’S REFERRING TO
IS DETAILED IMPLEMENTATION PLANS OF THE
COMMONALITY IMPLEMENTATION.
Q. WOULD THAT INCLUDE THE COMMON-
ALITY AGREEMENTS THEMSELVES? IS THIS SEN-
TENCE SAYING THAT THE COMMONALITY AGREE-
MENTS WERE NOT AVAILABLE FROM HUGHES?
A. I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT’S WHAT IT’S
SAYING.
Q. THERE ARE TWO ITEMS THAT ARE DIS-
CUSSED IN THIS DOCUMENT RELATING TO INDI-
CATED FINAL COST EXERCISES OR IFC EXERCISES.
THERE’S A MAY 1984 IFC AND A MAY 1985 IFC.
DO YOU SEE THOSE REFERENCES?
A. YES, 1 DO.
Q. IN THE PARAGRAPH ON PAGE 2, THE
PARAGRAPH AT THE BOTTOM, IT USES THE TERM
UNAUTHORIZED GROWTH, OR IT’S, I BELIEVE,
REFERRING TO UNAUTHORIZED COST GROWTH.
IS THAT WHAT IT’S REFERRING TO
WHEN IT SAYS “UNAUTHORIZED GROWTH”?
140
A. YES, IT IS.
Q. WHAT IS YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF
THE MEANING OF THAT TERM “UNAUTHORIZED
GROWTH”?
A. MY UNDERSTANDING OF THAT IS THAT
SINCE THE RADAR WAS BEING PROCURED ON A
COST PLUS CONTRACT, ALL COSTS ASSOCIATED
WITH THAT CONTRACT ARE CHARGED TO THE
CUSTOMER, MEANING NORTHROP, AND DON’T HAVE
TO BE A PART OF A CHANGE THAT IS DIRECTED OR
AUTHORIZED BY NORTHROP. THEREFORE, THESE
COSTS WERE COSTS THAT WERE ASSOCIATED WITH
DEVELOPING THE ALREADY EXISTING AUTHORIZED
WORK.
MR. BENSON: COULD YOU READ THAT
RESPONSE BACK AGAIN, PLEASE.
(WHEREUPON, THE ANSWER WAS READ
BY THE REPORTER AS_ FOLLOWS: “MY
UNDERSTANDING OF THAT IS THAT SINCE THE
RADAR WAS BEING PROCURED ON A COST PLUS
CONTRACT, ALL COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THAT
CONTRACT ARE CHARGED TO THE CUSTOMER,
MEANING NORTHROP, AND DON’T HAVE TO BE A
PART OF A CHANGE THAT IS DIRECTED OR
AUTHORIZED BY NORTHROP. THEREFORE, THESE
COSTS WERE COSTS THAT WERE ASSOCIATED WITH
DEVELOPING THE ALREADY EXISTING AUTHORIZED
WORK.”)
Q. BY MR. TROY: NOW, DO YOU BELIEVE
THAT THE STATEMENTS ABOUT UNAUTHORIZED
COST GROWTH INDICATED A CONCERN THAT COSTS
WERE BEING CHARGED TO THE B-2 THAT WERE NOT
ALLOWABLE?
A. NO.
141
Q. INFACT, THE PRIMARY CONCERN THAT
NORTHROP HAD AT THIS TIME WAS NOT WHETHER
THE COSTS WERE ALLOWABLE ON THE B-2 BUT,
RATHER, A CONCERN ON COST GROWTH IN
GENERAL.
ISN’T THAT CORRECT?
A. THAT IS CORRECT.
Q. AND PART OF NORTHROP’S CONCERN
OVER COST GROWTH WAS THE LACK OF VISIBILITY
AS TO HOW THESE COSTS WERE BEING MANAGED.
IS THAT CORRECT?
A THAT IS CORRECT.
Q. LATER ON IN 1986 AND THEREAFTER,
AIR FORCE AUDITORS REVIEWED SOME OF THE
ISSUES THAT ARE DESCRIBED IN THE WHITE
PAPERS.
WERE YOU AWARE OF THAT AUDIT?
A. YES, I WAS.
142
(caption omitted in printing)
DEPOSITION OF BRIAN FRANCIS REILLY
DECEMBER 17, 1991
* * * *
Q. ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH THE ISSUE ON
THE B-2 PROGRAM RELATING TO A FORM 1
DISALLOWANCE IN THE AMOUNT OF
APPROXIMATELY $15 MILLION THAT RELATES TO
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH WHAT’S CALLED THE ASC
GATE ARRAY DEVELOPMENT EFFORT?
A. YES, SIR.
Q. DID YOU BECOME FAMILIAR WITH
THAT IN YOUR CAPACITY AS THE CHIEF OF THE
CONTRACT MANAGEMENT DIVISION?
A. YES, SIR.
Q. DO YOU KNOW WHETHER THERE ARE
ANY ONGOING NEGOTIATIONS BETWEEN HUGHES
AND THE GOVERNMENT RELATED TO OBTAINING
OR REACHING AN ADMINISTRATIVE SETTLEMENT
OF ANY CAS VIOLATION RELATED CLAIMS?
MR. GALLAGHER: OBJECTION. IT’S A VAGUE
AND AMBIGUOUS QUESTION UNLESS IT’S RELATED
SPECIFICALLY TO WHAT’S INVOLVED IN THIS
LITIGATION.
MR. BENSON: BUT IT IS.
MR. GALLAGHER: WELL, THERE’S ALL KINDS
OF POSSIBLE CAS ISSUES. ARE YOU TALKING
ABOUT THE ONE IN THIS LITIGATION?
143
MR. BENSON: RELATED TO THIS LITIGATION.
Q. IF THERE ARE ANY SETTLEMENT
NEGOTIATIONS BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT AND
HUGHES PERTAINING TO ANY CAS-RELATED
VIOLATIONS?
A. AS I UNDERSTAND IT, THE ONLY
RELATED COST ACCOUNTING STANDARDS ISSUE
OPEN AT THIS TIME IS THE ONE REFERRED TO IN MY
LETTER TO MR. PARKER. WE ARE WORKING, AS WE
DO WITH ALL ADMINISTRATIVE ISSUES, TO
RESOLVE THE ISSUE WITH THE COMPANY. THIS IS
THE INFORMATION THAT WAS PROVIDED BY MR.
LYNCH IN THE TECHNICAL REVIEW REFERRED TO IN
THE TECHNICAL REPORT PROVIDING INFORMATION
THAT SUPPORTED THE RESOLUTION OF THE COST
ACCOUNTING STANDARDS ISSUE, AND THERE’S
BEEN SUBSEQUENT MEETINGS ON THE RESOLUTION
OF THE COST ACCOUNTING ISSUE.
(WHEREUPON THE QUESTION WAS READ BY
THE REPORTER AS FOLLOWS: “PRIOR TO THE
AMENDMENT IN 1984, ARE YOU AWARE OF A COST
ACCOUNTING DISCLOSURE STATEMENT FROM
HUGHES APPLICABLE TO THE F-15 MSIP OR THE B-2
FSD WHICH SUGGESTED THE POOLING OF COSTS
RELATED TO DIRECT LABOR?”)
THE WITNESS: THE FIRST PART OF IT IS COST.
THE COST ACCOUNTING STANDARDS DISCLOSURE
STATEMENTS ARE APPLICABLE TO ALL
NEGOTIATED CONTRACTS OVER A_ CERTAIN
THRESHOLD.
Q. BY MR. BENSON: IS IT YOUR
UNDERSTANDING THAT THE B-2 FSD AND THE F-15
MSIPS EXCEEDED THAT THRESHOLD?
144
A. YES, IT IS.
Q. WHAT'S THE REST OF YOUR RESPONSE?
A. WHAT I’M AWARE, FROM THE REVIEW
THAT THE DPRO CONDUCTED, WAS WHAT WE
FOUND WAS THAT, PRIOR TO THE DISCLOSURE IN
1984, THE AMENDMENT IN 1984, THAT THE
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT SUBMITTED DID NOT
SPECIFICALLY ADDRESS THE ALLOCATION OF
DEVELOPMENT COSTS.
Q. INTO DIRECT LABOR POOLS?
A. WELL, INTO -- I WOULD PHRASE IT
DIFFERENTLY. I WOULD SAY THE ALLOCATION -- IT
WAS SILENT AS FAR AS ALLOCATION OF THE
DIRECT LABOR -- OF DEVELOPMENT COSTS FOR
DIRECT LABOR.
* * . .
Q. DO YOU KNOW IF, IN RETURNING THIS
MONEY TO HUGHES, THESE WERE PART OF THE
CONSIDERATIONS: WHETHER OR NOT THE CAS
STANDARDS INCORPORATED WHAT IT WAS,
WHETHER THEY FOLLOWED IT, WHETHER THEY
CERTIFIED TO IT WHEN THEY ASKED NORTHROP OR
THE GOVERNMENT TO GIVE THEM THE BIG BUCKS
THAT THEY THOUGHT THEY WERE ENTITLED TO?
MR. GALLAGHER: OBJECTION. VAGUE
QUESTION.
THE WITNESS: PRIOR TO THE SIGNATURE ON
EXHIBIT 75 AUTHORIZING A RELEASE AND
RECOMMENDING THE RELEASE OF THOSE
SUSPENDED COSTS, THE GOVERNMENT TOOK INTO
CONSIDERATION THE BASIS FOR THE SUSPENSION,
WHICH WAS SPECIFICALLY ANALOG SIGNAL
CONVERTER COSTS, AND LOOKED AT THE ISSUE
FROM BOTH A TECHNICAL AND ACCOUNTING
145
PERSPECTIVE AND CAME TO THE CONCLUSION
THAT THERE WAS NOT A BASIS FOR CONTINUING
THE SUSPENSION.
Q. BY MR. BENSON: THEY CAME TO THE
CONCLUSION THAT THERE HAD NOT BEEN A
VIOLATION OF THE CAS DISCLOSURE STATEMENT?
A. THEY CAME TO THE CONCLUSION THAT
THERE WAS NOT A BASIS FOR CONTINUING THE
SUSPENSION.
Q. BUT THEY DID NOT COME TO A
CONCLUS
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.