Amicus Curiae Brief — PUD No. 1 of Jefferson Cty. v. Washington Dept. of Ecology
Supreme Court brief1994
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 92-1911
—EE————— es 953
IN THE
Supreme Court of the Wuited Sfitia® ™ all |
OCTOBER TERM, 1993
PUD No. | or JEFFERSON COUNTY
AND THE CITY OF TACOMA,
‘ Petitioners,
STATE OF WASHINGTON, DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES AND
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE,
______- Respondents.
On Writ of Certiorari to the
Supreme Court of the State of Washington
BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE
AMERICAN FOREST & PAPER ASSOCIATION,
AMERICAN PUBLIC POWER ASSOCIATION,
EDISON ELECTRIC INSTITUTE,
AND NATIONAL HYDROPOWER ASSOCIATION
IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS
JOHN R. MOLM
Counsel of Record
WINIFRED D. SIMPSON
JAMES A, LAMBERTH
TROUTMAN SANDERS
Suite 5200, NationsBank Plaza
600 Peachtree Street, N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30308-2216
(404) 885-3000
November 15, 1993 Counsel for Amici Curiae
(Additional Counsel Listed on Inside Cover)
WILSON - EPES PRINTING Co.. INC. - 789-0096 - WASHINGTON. D.C. 20001
EST AVAILABLE COPY
JEREMY M. METz
American Forest & Paper
Association
260 Madison Avenue
New York, N.Y. 10016-2499
(212) 340-0600
ALAN H. RICHARDSON
American Public Power
Association
2301 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20037
(202) 467-2904
HENRI D. BARTHOLOMOT
Edison Electric Institute
701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 508-5622
JONATHAN W. GOTTLIEB
National Hydropower
Association
701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 508-4000
QUESTION PRESENTED
Does a state’s inclusion of minimum stream flows for
fish habitat in a section 401 water quality certificate ex-
ceed the authority granted to the states in section 401
of the Clean Water Act and infringe on the comprehen-
sive authority to determine non-water quality related li-
cense conditions for hydroelectric projects that Congress
granted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
in the Federal Power Act?
TABLE OF CONTENTS
QUESTION PRESENTED .............. psinnncidninenimmesemediontt
TABLE OF AUTHORITERS .....2.2022..222..200.5cssdiecccscecessere -
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ................-..........c00000--.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT .........................2.......000-.
ARGUMENT
I.
II.
THE WASHINGTON SUPREME COURT'S
INTERPRETATION OF THE CERTIFICA-
TION AUTHORITY GRANTED TO THE
STATES IN SECTION 401 OF THE CLEAN
WATER ACT IS INCONSISTENT WITH
CONGRESS’ GRANT OF AUTHORITY TO
FERC IN THE FEDERAL POWER ACT........
A. The Washington Supreme Court’s Decision
Is Incompatible With The Comprehensive
Hydroelectric Licensing Program Created
HITED cc-ssenhncsodetecesdnesteptbnenasicidenungmesomunsiiiaeh-anpiieabes
R. The Washineton Department Of Ecology Ex-
ceeded The Authority Granted To The States
In The Clean Water Act ................................
THE FERC HYDROPOWER LICENSING
PROCESS WILL BE EFFECTIVELY PARA-
LYZED, AND THE NATION’S HYDRO-
ELECTRIC PROJECTS WILL BE SEVERELY
AFFECTED IF STATES ARE ALLOWED TO
IMPOSE MINIMUM FLOW CONDITIONS
FOR FISH HABITAT AND OTHER NON-
WATER QUALITY CONDITIONS THROUGH
SECTION 401 CERTIFICATIONS ~....
CONCLUSION
(iii)
17
18
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases Page
California v. FERC, 495 U.S. 490 (1990) 0... 5, 15, 16
First lowa Hydro-Electric Coop. v. FPC, 328 US.
Fee ee 5, 14, 15, 16
United States Dep’t of Interior v. FERC, 952 F.2d
eee eee 20
Washington Dep’t of Ecology v. PUD No. 1, 849
I i nisenslsahbbabieneion 15, 16
Administrative Decisions
Allegheny Electric Coop., 48 F.E.R.C. © 61,363
ERTS Es ea ee 20
Central Maine Power Co., 52 F.E.R.C. © 61,033
ESTEE A ce aaa ne nO eT 16
Noah Corp., 57 F.E.R.C. © 61,170 (1991) _....... ad 16
Town of Summersville, 50 F.E.R.C. * 61 291
ERO DES Lear ar nay CON TN See 16
Statutes
Clean Water Act § 401, 33 U.S.C. § 1341 __........... passim
Department of Energy Organization Act, 42 U.S.C.
So 7
Electric Consumers Protection Act, Pub. L. No.
99-495, 100 Stat. 1243 (1986) 0... 6, 9, 10, 12, 13
Federal Power Act, codified in various sections of
16 U.S.C. §§ 791a-825r (1988 & Supp. 1992)... passim
Oe iieiicipernrserecnemmremniannepnermnnincs 7
§ 4(e), 16 U.S.C. § 797(e) siatiaidiaaiil ... 7,8,9
§ 10(a), 16 U.S.C. § 803(a) ...................... 7,8, 10, 16
§ 10(j), 16 U.S.C. § 808(j) .................................. passim
§ 10(j) (1), 16 U.S.C. § 803(j) (1) saniiiitaaaailtiindiie 11
§ 10(j) (2), 16 U.S.C. § 803(j) (2) ~...........-.... 11
I i entctcnrssenmesenmmntenscenanteenenesnees ~
Bp Gets OO ED cccretccccvcccvcennsesrsscsensnsenvecions 14
Federal Water Power Act, ch. 285, 41 Stat. 1063
eee 7
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, 42
U.S.C. $§ 4321-4347 (1988) ................................... x
Wash. Rev. Code § 90.54.020(3) (a) (1991) scinbie 16
Vv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
Regulations
18 C.F.R. 4.41(f) (1993)
18 C.F.R. 4.51(f) (1993)
Other Authority
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 934, 99th Cong., 2d Sess.
21 (1986), reprinted in 1986 U.S.C.G:A:N. 2537.
99 Cong. Rec. $4448 (April 17,1986)
99 Cong. Rec. 815384 (October 6,1986)....
Edison Electric Inst., Statistical Yearbook of the
Electric Utility Industry/1991, No. 59 (EEI,
Washington, D.C. 1992)
i
SOOO OSH SOO SSSSES SSS SSSSESESSSSSESSSEESeeeoeS
i ee ee ee
POSS PPS S SS OSSOSSSSS SS SDSS SO SOSS SS OSS OOOSSESSSOSSSESSCS
ee eee. ee
AS SOOO SESS eeeeeeee
Richard T. Hunt and Judith Mohsberg Hunt, How
Does Hydropower Compare With Other Renew-
ok eee
National Hydropower Association, Hydro Guide:
Hydroelectric Resources of the United States,
“Introduction” (NHA, Washington, D.C. 1989) ..
3
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1993
No. 92-1911
PUD No. | oF JEFFERSON COUNTY
AND THE CITY OF TACOMA,
». Petitioners,
STATE OF WASHINGTON, DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES AND
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE,
Respondents.
On Writ of Certiorari to the
Supreme Court of the State of Washington
BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE
AMERICAN FOREST & PAPER ASSOCIATION,
AMERICAN PUBLIC POWER ASSOCIATION,
EDISON ELECTRIC INSTITUTE,
AND NATIONAL HYDROPOWER ASSOCIATION
IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE
The American Forest & Paper Association (“AFPA”),
American Public Power Association (“APPA”), Edison
Electric Institute (“EEI”), and National Hydropower
Association (“NHA”) submit this brief as amici curiae.’
' Letters from counsel for Petitioners and Respondents consent-
ing to the filing of this brief by amici curiae have been filed with
this Court.
e)
—
AFPA is the national trade association of the forest, pulp,
paper, paperboard, and wood products industry. APPA
and EEI are the national trade associations of the publicly-
owned and investor-owned segments of the nation’s electric
utility industry. NHA is the national association of hydro-
electric project owners, builders, equipment suppliers, and
consultants.” Together, APPA, EEI and NHA members
generate approximately 85% of all electricity in the United
States and serve approximately 90% of the nation’s ulti-
mate consumers of electricity.
The issues raised in Petitioners’ Brief involve the inter-
pretation and implementation by the states of section 401
of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1341 (1988) and
the effect of the states’ broad interpretation of section 401
on the licensing of hydroelectric projects by the Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission (“FERC”). The mem-
bers of the amici associations hold the vast majority of
the more than 1,000 licenses issued by FERC for hydro-
electric projects located throughout the United States.
Stream flow conditions are an essential component of
these licenses, directly affecting each project’s energy
production and cost and other benefits created by the
project. Expansion of state regulation of stream flows at
hydroelectric projects pursuant to the Clean Water Act
will have an extensive impact on the members of AFPA,
APPA, EEI, and NHA and on the development and
continued reliance on hydroelectric generating projects
throughout the country.
Furthermore, the issues in this proceeding have national
implications. FERC-licensed and other federal and non-
federal hydropower projects represent a significant part
of America’s present energy supply, providing nearly
90,000 megawatts of electricity totaling approximately
2 The particular interest of each association is more fully de-
scribed in the Appendix. (A. la-2a).
3
12% of the electric capacity in the United States.* Over
150 million consumers in 48 states, including residential,
agricultural, commercial and industrial customers, benefit
from the power generated by hydroelectric facilities.‘ The
long, useful life of hydroelectric facilities and their rela-
tively low operating and maintenance costs place hydro-
electric power among the least expensive sources of elec-
tricity, a benefit that inures directly to electricity con-
sumers.” In addition, hydropower is the nation’s preemi-
nent renewable energy resource, accounting for 83% of
the clean, renewable energy on which the country relies.”
Under authority granted by Congress to FERC in the
Federal Power Act,’ FERC establishes license conditions
for projects pursuant to its jurisdiction to protect and
reconcile competing water use demands, such as fish and
wildlife habitat, aesthetics, recreation, navigation, water
quality, water supply, generating capacity and energy out-
put. The Federal Power Act requires FERC to give equal
consideration to power and non-power values in licensing
and relicensing hydroelectric projects. By balancing all of
these considerations and tailoring <ppropriate license
terms and conditions, FERC ensures that the public inter-
est, as a whole, is served.
In contrast, state water quality agencies have a sub-
stantially narrower perspective and role in the licensing
of hydroelectric projects. Through an overbroad reading
of section 401 of the Clean Water Act, the state water
% Edison Electric Inst., Statistical Yearbook of the Electric Utility
Industry/1991, No. 59, Table 2, p. 8 (EEI, Washington, D.C., 1992).
* National Hydropower Association, Hydro Guide: Hydroelectric
Resources of the United States, “Introduction” (NHA, Washing-
ton, D.C. 1989).
5 Td.
® Richard T. Hunt and Judith Mohsberg Hunt, How Does Hydro-
power Compare With Other Renewables? 7 (1993).
7 Codified in various sections of 16 U.S.C. §§ 79la-825r (1988 &
Supp. 1992).
4
quality agency in this proceeding is seeking to usurp
FERC’s authority over the licensing process, inhibiting
FERC’s ability to weigh power and non-power values
and to formulate terms and conditions in licenses for both
new and existing hydroelectric projects.
As the national voices for all sectors of the hydropower
industry, amici are vitally interested in a proper, harmoni-
ous and consistent interpretation and application of fed-
eral statutes affecting the development of hydroelectric
power. Such interpretation and application are necessary
to ensure that hyroelectric projects are licensed in a man-
ner that best serves the public interest.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
In its decision below, the Washington Supreme Court
upheld the conditions requiring minimum stream flows
prescribed by the Washington Department of Ecology in
a water quality certificate that the Department issued for
the Elkhorn hydroelectric project. This decision misin-
terprets and fails to harmonize the authority that Congress
granted to the states in section 401 of the Clean Water
Act with the comprehensive hydropower licensing author-
ity that Congress granted to FERC in the Federal Power
Act.
First, the Washington Supreme Court’s decision im-
properly expands the scope of authority granted to the
states in section 401 of the Clean Water Act. In up-
holding the conditions requiring minimum stream flows
imposed by the Washington Department of Ecology on
the Elkhorn Project, the Washington Supreme Court held
that section 401 of the Clean Water Act grants the State
of Washington the authority to impose non-water quality
based minimum streem flows to protect fish habitat. The
Washington Supreme Court's interpretation of the author-
ity granted to the states in section 401 of the Clean Water
Act ignores provisions of the Federal Power Act in which
Congress expressly granted FERC ultimate authority over
this issue and is inconsistent with this Court’s opinions in
5
First lowa Hydro-Electric Coop. v. FPC, 328 U.S. 152
(1946) and California v. FERC, 495 U.S. 490 (1990),
which interpret the scope of FERC’s licensing authority in
relation to the state regulation of water. Moreover, the
Washington Supreme Court’s interpretation of the author-
ity granted to the states in section 401 of the Clean Water
Act conflicts with the express provisions of section 401.
Second, the Washington Supreme Court’s decision
threatens to seriously disrupt the FERC hydropower licens-
ing process. The practical consequence of the Washingtou
Supreme Court’s decision regarding the scope of state
authority under section 401 is that individual states may
usurp FERC’s licensing authority. Under the Washington
Supreme Court’s interpertation of section 401 of the
Clean Water Act, a state may impose conditions requiring
minimum stream flows to protect fish habitat that severely
constrain FERC’s ability to establish reasonable license
terms and conditions that are designed to address a
broader range of factors affecting the public interest.
Forty-eight states now have federally licensed hydroelec-
tric projects under FERC jurisdiction. If the Washington
Supreme Court's interpretation of the scope of authority
granted to the states is adopted, FERC’s authority to im-
plement a national energy policy and to control the licens-
ing process will be severely eroded, causing uncertainty
and delay in the licensing of hydroelectric projects nation-
wide and the potential loss of energy and other benefits
from this valuable resource.
6
ARGUMENT
I. THE WASHINGTON SUPREME COURT'S INTER-
PRETATION OF THE CERTIFICATION AUTHOR-
ITY GRANTED TO THE STATES IN SECTION 401
OF THE CLEAN WATER ACT IS INCONSISTENT
WITH CONGRESS’ GRANT OF AUTHORITY TO
FERC IN THE FEDERAL POWER ACT.
Under the Washington Supreme Court's interpretation
of section 401 of the Clean Water Act, a state may im-
pose conditions on a FERC license, such as minimum
stream flows to protect fish habitat, based on any state
requirement related to use of a waterway. Specifically,
the Washington Supreme Court found that, pursuant to
section 401 of the Clean Water Act, the Washington
Department of Ecology has authority to impose conditions
requiring minimum stream flows to protect fish habitat,
even though those conditions are not necessary to comply
with the State’s applicable water quality criteria. Under
the lower court’s reasoning, almost any water-related re-
quirement of state law—whether pertaining to fish, wild-
life, recreation, navigation or other non-water quality mat-
ters—can be imposed as a condition in a section 401 cer-
tificate. Congress did not intend for section 401 to apply
so expansively.
Pursuant to the Federal Power Act, as amended in
1986 by the Electric Consumers Protection Act, Pub. L.
No. 99-495, 100 Stat. 1243 (1986) (“ECPA”), FERC
possesses exclusive authority to establish license condi-
tions relating to fish and wildlife and other non-water
quality matters in the exercise of its statutory obliga-
tions to consider and reconcile competing water usc
demands. In contrast, by allowing states to issue and
condition water quality certificates for federally-licensed
activities pursuant to section 401, Congress provided the
states with only limited authority to impose appropriate
conditions based on applicable effluent limitations, water
quality standards and other provisions specified in section
401 as well as state law requirements directly relevant to
7
such factors. The Supreme Court of Washington’s inter-
pretation of section 401 significantly exceeds the bounds
of authority granted to the states and, consequently, up-
sets the balance of authority that Congress has established
between state water quality agencies in section 401 and
the federal licensing activities of agencies such as FERC
in the Federal Power Act.
A. The Washington Supreme Court’s Decision Is In-
compatible With The Comprehensive Hydroelectric
Licensing Program Created By Congress.
In 1920 Congress established the federal licensing pro-
gram for hydroelectric projects when it enacted the Fed-
eral Water Power Act, ch. 285, 41 Stat. 1063 (1920),
which was incorporated into Part I of the Federal Power
Act in 1935. The Federal Power Act established the
former Federal Power Commission as the government
agency with authority to issue licenses for most non-
federal hydroelectric projects. 16 U.S.C. § 792 (1988).
In 1977 the hydroelectric licensing authority held by the
Federal Power Commission was transferred to FERC
pursuant to the Department of Energy Organization Act.
See 42 U.S.C. § 7151(b) (1988). FERC issues licenses
not exceeding 50 years that authorize the construction,
operation and maintenance of hydroelectric projects on
navigable waterways or other bodies of water over which
Congress has jurisdiction under its authority to regulate
interstate commerce. See 16 U.S.C. § 797(e) (1988).
Part I of the Federal Power Act establishes the com-
prehensive regulatory program for hydroelectric power.
Pertinent sections of Part I that demonstrate this fact
include
—Sections 4(e), 10(a) and 10(j), which require
FERC to determine whether and under what con-
ditions a project will be best adapted to a com-
prehensive plan for use of the waterway and give
equal consideration to power and certain non-
power values in making that determination; and
8
—Section 15, which authorizes the relicensing of
projects and the inclusion of terms and conditions
in new licenses.
See 16 U.S.C. §§ 797(e), 803(a), 803(j), 808.
Pursuant to authority granted in the Federal Power Act,
FERC must consider all factors affecting the public in-
terest in the comprehensive development of the waterway.
The comprehensive balancing authority granted to FERC
under the Federal Power Act constitutes the core of the
federal licensing process. Pursuant to this balancing
authority, no license for a hydroelectric project shall be
granted unless, in the judgment of FERC, the project is
best adapted to a comprehensive plan for: (1) improving
or developing a waterway for the use or benefit of com-
merce; (2) the improvement and utilization of water
power development; (3) the adequate protection, mitiga-
tion, and enhancement of fish and wildlife (including
related spawning grounds and habitat); (4) irrigation:
(5) flood control; (6) water supply; (7) recreation; and
(8) other beneficial public uses. See 16 U.S.C. $$ 803(a),
797(e) (1988).* Recent amendments to the Federal
Power Act, the legislative history of those amendments,
8 FERC’s regulations implementing Part I of the Federal Power
Act also manifest the comprehensive nature of FERC’s review of
factors relevant to the development of a waterway. In 1981, largely
in response to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, 42
U.S.C. §§ 4321-4347 (1988), FERC amended the regulations that
govern the contents of applications for hydroelectric projects.
Among other things, the amended regulations require license appli-
cants to prepare and submit to FERC several reports, including, a
Report on Water Use and Quality, a Report on Fish, Wildlife and
Botanical Resources, a Report on Historic and Archeological Re-
sources, A Report on Socio-Economic Impact, a Report on Geological
and Soil Resources, and a Report on Recreation Resources. See
18 C.F.R. 4.41(f), 4.51(f) (1993). FERC uses the information
provided in these reports in its consideration of all relevant factors
affecting the public interest in the development of the waterway.
9
and this Court’s opinions all demonstrate that in creating
this comprehensive hydroelectric licensing program Con-
gress granted FERC the exclusive authority to establish
conditions regulating stream flows for non-water quality
matters, including minimum flows to protect fish habitat,
such as those included in the State of Washington’s Water
Quality Certificate for the Elkhorn project.
In 1986, more than a decade after enacting the Clean
Water Act, Congress enacted ECPA, which amended the
Federal Power Act. The amendments that comprise
ECPA ensure that nondevelopmental values, including fish
and wildlife protection, recreational opportunities and
energy conservation, are adequately considered by FERC
in its determination of whether and under what conditions
a hydroelectric license should be issued.
Amended section 4(e) of the Federal Power Act re-
quires FERC, in determining whether to issue a license,
to give “equal consideration” to power and various non-
power values, inciuding “. . . the protection, mitigation
of damage to, and enhancement of fish and wildlife (in-
cluding related spawning grounds and habitat) . . . .” See
16 U.S.C. §797(e) (1988).° This amendment pro-
nounced the importance of FERC’s consideration of non-
developmental values, including the protection of fish and
wildlife, in the hydroelectric licensing process.
” The entire 1986 amendment to section 4(e) provides:
In deciding whether to issue any license under this Part for
any project, the Commission, in addition to the power and
development purposes for which licenses are issued, shall give
equal consideration to the purposes of energy conservation,
the protection, mitigation of damage to, and enhancement of,
fish and wildlife (including related spawning grounds and
habitat), the protection of recreational opportunities, and the
preservation of other aspects of environmental! quality.
Electric Consumers Protection Act of 1986 §3(a) (1988), (codified
as amended at 16 U.S.C. 797(e)).
10
ECPA also amended section 10(a) of the Federal
Power Act by requiring that FERC’s comprehensive plan-
ning process encompass non-developmental values, in-
cluding the protection of fish and wildlife.” As amended,
section 10(a) requires FERC to weigh numerous factors
that state water quality agencies are not required to con-
sider under section 401 of the Clean Water Act, includ-
ing regional power needs, water supply, recreation, and
the effect of a project on fish habitat.
Additionally, section 10(j) of the Federal Power Act.
as added by ECPA, explicitly reaffirms FERC’s role as
the ultimate decision-maker regarding fish and wildlife
related concerns in the issuance of hydropower licenses.
Section 10(j) provides that to “protect, mitigate damages
to, and enhance, fish and wildlife (including related spawn-
ing grounds and habitat)” affected by the project, each
license shall contain conditions for such protection, miti-
gation and enhancement “based on recommendations re-
ceived pursuant to the Fish and Wildlife Coordination
Act . . . from the National Marine Fisheries Service,
10 Amended section 10(a) provides in relevant part:
(a) Modification of plans; factors considered to secure
adaptability of project; recommendations for proposed terms
and conditions
(1) That the project adopted, including the maps, pians,
and specifications, shall be such as in the judgment of the
Commission will be best adapted to a comprehensive plan for
improving or developing a waterway or waterways for the
use or benefit of interstate or foreign commerce, for the im-
provement and utilization of water-power development, for the
adequate protection, mitigation, and enhancement of fish and
wildlife (including related spawning grounds and habitat), and
for other beneficial public uses, including irrigation, flood con-
trol, water supply, and recreational and other purposes referred
to in section 797(e) of this title if necessary in order to secure
such plan the Commission shall have authority to require the
modification of any project and of the plans and specifications
of the project works before approval.
16 U.S.C. § 803(a) (1) (1988).
1
11
the United States Fish and Wildlife Service, and State
fish and wildlife agencies.” See 16 U.S.C. § 803(j)(1)
(1988). While section 10(j) requires-FERC to give spe-
cial deference to recommendations made by state and fed-
eral fish and wildlife agencies regarding conditions appro-
priate for the protection, mitigation of damage to, and
enhancement of fish and wildlife, FERC is not required
to include such recommended conditions in the license.
If, after affording the recommendations of fish and wild-
life agencies due deference and considering relevant de-
velopmental and non-developmental values, FERC deter-
mines that such recommendations are inconsistent with
the purposes and requirements of the Federal Power Act
or other applicable law, section 10(j) explicitly grants
FERC the authority to reject such recommendations. See
16 U.S.C. § 803(j)(2) (1988)."
1 Section 10(j) provides:
(j) Fish and wildlife protection, mitigation and enhancement;
consideration of recommendations; findings
(1) That in order to adequately and equitably protect, mitigate
damages to, and enhance, fish and wildlife (including related spawn-
ing grounds and habitat) affected by the development, operation,
and management of the project, each license issued under this
subchapter shall include conditions for such protection, mitigation,
and enhancement. Subject to paragraph (2), such conditions shall
be based on recommendations received pursuant to the Fish and
Wildlife Coordination Act (16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.) [16 U.S.C.A.
$661 et seq.| from the National Marine Fisheries Services, the
United States Fish and Wildlife Service, and State fish and wildlife
agencies.
(2) Whenever the Commission believes that any recommendation
referred to in paragraph (1) may be inconsistent with the purposes
and requirements of this subchapter or other applicable law, the
Commission and the agencies referred to in paragraph (1) shall
attempt to resolve any such inconsistency, giving due weight to the
recommendations, expertise, and statutory responsibilities of such
agencies. If, after such attempt, the Commission does not adopt in
whole or in part a recommendation of any such agency, the Com-
12
The legislative history of ECPA confirms Congress’
intention that FERC have ultimate authority to establish
conditions requiring minimum stream flows for non-water
quality related matters, including the protection of fish
habitat. During the debates leading to the enactment of
ECPA, the states sought to include a provision in the
Federal Power Act that would have granted the states
control over the appropriation, diversion, and use of water
by licensed projects. Immediately prior to Senate passage
of the Senate version of ECPA, Senator Baucus inserted
into the record a position paper advocating such an
amendment. Senator Baucus ultimately agreed not to offer
amendments to the Senate version of ECPA that would
grant this authority in exchange for an agreement from
Senator McClure, Chairman of the Senate Committee on
Energy and Natural Resources, to hold a Congressional
hearing on the subject. See 99 Cong. Rec. $4448-49
(April 17, 1986). Although Senator McClure’s commit-
tee conducted the hearing on September 12, 1986, no
amendments regarding the grant of additional water use
authority to the states were made to ECPA, either in con-
ference or by the House or Senate. Instead, Congress
reaflirmed FERC’s exclusive authority over water use mat-
ters associated with licensed projects when it amended
the Federal Power Act to include section 10(j). 16
U.S.C. § 803(j) (1988).
The conference report on ECPA demonstrates that
ECPA did increase the states’ role in determining fish
mission shall publish each of the following findings (together with
a statement of the basis for each of the findings) :
(A) A finding that adoption of such recommendation is in-
consistent with the purposes and requirements of this sub-
chapter or with other applicable provisions of law.
(B) A finding that the conditions selected by the Commission
comply with the requirements of paragraph (1).
Subsection (i) of this section shall not apply to the conditions re-
quired under this subsection.
16 U.S.C. § 803()j).
13
and wildlife conditions in hydroelectric licenses, including
minimum stream flow requirements, by directing FERC
to give special deference to state fish and wildlife recom-
mendations. Specifically, the conference report recog-
nized that, “[t]he new section 10(j), which stems from
the House amendment to S. 426, clearly and unmistakably
upgrades the status of recommendations of the National
Marine Fisheries Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Serv-
ice, and the State fish and wildlife agencies made pursuant
to the Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act.” See H.R.
Conf. Rep. No. 934, 99th Cong., 2d Sess. 21, 23 (1986),
reprinted in 1986 U.S.C.C.A.N. 2537, 2539. Increasing
the states’ authority in this way would have been un-
necessary if Congress had previously granted the states
authority in section 401 of the Clean Water Act to im-
pose conditions regarding fish and wildlife, including min-
imum flows to protect fish habitat, at FERC licensed
projects.
The states’ limited role in determining fish and wildlife
conditions in licenses is further demonstrated by other
statements in the legislative history of ECPA that describe
Congress’ grant of authority to FERC to determine fish
and wildlife conditions. In its description of section 10( }).
the Commitiee of Conference stated:
. while new section 10(j) certainly upgrades stat-
utorily the importance and status of fish and wildlife
recommendations under the Fish and Wildlife Co-
ordination Act, they are still recognized as “recom-
mendations,” not mandatory requirements as_pro-
vided in section 30(c) of the Federal Power Act for
exemptions under the Act.
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 934, 99th Cong. 2d Sess. 21, 25
(1986), reprinted in 1986 U.S.C.C.A.N. 2537, 2541.
Senator McClure, Chairman of the Senate Committee on
Energy and Natural Resources and Chairman of the Com-
mittee of Conference, also echoed the statements of the
Committee of Conference immediately before the Senate
passed ECPA:
14
When we considered this legislation in the Senate, we
sought to ensure that fish and wildlife considerations
were fully and deliberately reviewed by FERC in
setting conditions on a license. The House had the
same concern. Neither body considered giving the
fish and wildlife agencies the same type of mandatory
conditioning authority which they have under section
30(c) for exemptions. Neither did either body want
in any way to interfere with the role of FERC in
balancing competing values.
See 99 Cong. Rec. $15384 (October 6, 1986).”
This Court has also acknowledged FERC’s preemptive
authority to determine license conditions relating to non-
water quality related matters, including fish and wildlife.
Forty-seven years ago, the Court first recognized that the
exclusive nature of the federal hydroelectric licensing proc-
ess preempts conflicting state action. In First lowa Hydro-
Flectric Coop. v. FPC, 328 U.S. 152 (1946), the Court
rejected the State of Iowa's efforts to impose a state per-
mitting requirement on an applicant for a hydroelectric
12 Section 30 of the Federal Power Act governs exemptions from
the requirements of the Act for conduit hydroelectric facilities.
Pursuant to section 30(c) of the Federal Power Act, FERC, in
determining whether an exemption is appropriate, must consult
with the United States Fish and Wildlife Service and the relevant
state fish and wildlife agency in the manner provided in the Fish
and Wildlife Coordination Act and must include in any exemption,
terms and conditions that the United States Fish and Wildlife Serv-
ice and the relevant state agency believe are appropriate to prevent
loss of, or damage to, fish and wildlife resources. See 16 U.S.C.
§ 828a(c) (1985). Section 30(c) of the Federal Power Act there-
fore grants the states authority to impose conditions relating to
fish and wildlife in certain limited circumstances. The Committee’s
and Senator McClure’s recognition of the extraordinary authority
granted state fish and wildlife agencies in Section 30(c) and their
express acknowledgement that Congress did not intend for state
fish and wildlife agencies to have such mandatory conditioning
authority in the normal licensing process, further demonstrate
Congress’ intention that FERC have exclusive authority to deter-
mine conditions relating to fish and wildlife in hydroelectric licenses.
15
license from the Federal Power Commission. The Court
concluded that allowing the state to impose a permitting
requirement would in effect grant the state veto power
over the license and thereby subvert Congress’ intention
to concentrate comprehensive hydropower planning au-
thority in the Federal Power Commission. First Jowa,
328 U.S. at 164.
More recently, this Court considered the State of Cali-
fornia’s authority to impose minimum flow requirements
at hydroelectric projects to protect fisheries in California
v. FERC, 495 U.S. 490 (1990). In that action, Cali-
fornia argued that section 27 of the Federal Power Act,
which reserves certain authority regarding proprietary
water rights to the states, provided the state with author-
ity to Impose mandatory stream flow requirements for fish
and wildlife. This Court rejected California’s contention
and unanimously held that the stream flow requirements
mandated by California were preempted by the federal
licensing program. In making that determination, this
Court specifically recognized that the addition of section
10(j) to the Federal Power Act reaffirmed “First lowa’s
understanding that the FPA establishes a broad and para-
mount regulatory role.” See California v. FER
U.S. at 499, , er
In this proceeding, as a condition in the section 401
certificate to PUD No. 1 of Jefferson County and the
City of Tacoma, the Washington Department of Ecology
has imposed minimum stream flow requirements for the
Elkhorn project based upon recommendations made by
State fish and wildlife agencies pursuant to statutes that
are unrelated to the State’s water quality criteria adopted
under the Clean Water Act. The Washington Supreme
Court upheld the State agency's decision, in part, by con-
cluding that the phrase “any other appropriate requirement
of State law” in section 401(d) is not confined to state
water quality standards. Washington Dep't of Ecology y,
16
PUD No. 1, 849 P.2d 646, 653 (Wash. 1993). The court
found the quoted phrase to be “a congressional authoriza-
tion to the states to consider all state action related to water
quality in imposing conditions on section 401 certificates.”
Id. The state actions the Washington court references would
include the establishment of flows to provide for “pres-
ervation of wildlife, fish, scenic, aesthetic and other en-
vironmental values. and navigational values,” Wash. Rev.
Code & 90.54.020(3)(a) (1991), which are the very
matters that Congress has determined to be in the exclu-
sive purview of FERC. Because FERC has taken the
position that it must accept the terms of the 401 water
quality certificate as a part of the license,”® the inclusion
of the conditions in the section 401 certificate makes
such conditions mandatory on the Elkhorn project. As a
resilt. the Washineton Supreme Court's interpretation of
section 401 eviscerates FERC’s authority to consider
other stream flow recommerdations for fish habitat at the
Elkhorn project pursuant to section 10(j) of the Federal
Power Act and to balance competing uses of the water
resource as mandated by section 10(a) of the Federal
Power Act.
If the State of Washington had attempted to impose
the prescribed minimum flow requirements or other
similar conditions on the Elkhorn project under any
State statute independent of the Clean Water Act, the
State’s action would directly conflict with the authority
sranted FERC under the Federal Power Act as reaffirmed
by this Court in First lowa and California v. FERC. The
Washington Supreme Court's decision nevertheless inter-
prets section 401(d) to provide states with the very
authority to mandate license conditions that states could
not otherwise exercise. This illogical interpretation of
13 See Town of Summersville, 60 F.E.R.C. © 61,291 at 61,990
(1992): Noah Corp., 57 F.E.R.C. © 61,170 at 61,601 (1991); Cen-
tral Maine Power Co., 52 F.E.R.C. © 61,033 at 61,172-73 (1990).
17
the authority granted the states under section 401 of
the Clean Water Act ignores Congress’ express acknowl-
edgement of the comprehensive licensing process estab-
lished under the Federal Power Act and this Court's
explicit recognition of FERC’s paramount role in the area
of hydroelectric licensing, including fish and wildlife regu-
lation, at federally licensed hydroelectric facilities.
B. The Washington Department Of Ecology Exceeded
The Authority Granted To The States In The
Clean Water Act.
The statutory language and legislative history of sec-
tion 401 of the Clean Water Act demonstrate that Con-
gress granted the states a narrower, more limited authority
to participate in the federal licensing process than that
found by the Supreme Court of Washington. Rather than
repeat the entire argument made by the Petitioners re-
garding the State of Washington’s failure to act within
the parameters of the limited authority granted to it under
section 401 of the Clean Water Act, amici will summarize
several points addressed in more detail by Petitioners.
The Clean Water Act was enacted to regulate dis-
charges into the nation’s waters, particularly discharges
involving the addition of pollutants into those waters.
Within this context, section 401 specifically grants states
the limited authority to certify that federally licensed
projects will comply with applicable water quality stand-
ards and related criteria concerning discharges that are
specified in section 401. Section 401(d) further provides
that states may condition water quality certificates to
ensure compliance with these requirements and “other
appropriate requirements of State law” concerning activ-
ities that may result in discharges. As demonstrated in
Petitioners’ Brief, section 401 only grants state water
quality agencies the authority to address the effect on
water quality of discharges from federally licensed activ-
ities. This narrow grant of authority to the states was
18
not intended to intrude on the other areas of responsibility
not involving water quality that Congress reserved to
federal licensing and permitting agencies.
In this case, as a condition in the water quality certifi-
cate, the Washington Department of Ecology sought to
impose—through its water quality certificate—month-by-
month stream flow requirements for fish habitat that the
state concedes are not required for water quality. Wash-
ington’s published water quality criteria pertain to such
matters as fecal coliform, dissolved oxygen, dissolved
gases, and other water quality characteristics. By failing
to limit the section 401 conditions to requirements de-
signed to ensure that the project would comply with these
water quality criteria, the State exceeded the limited au-
thority that Congress granted it under section 401.
Il. THE FERC HYDROPOWER LICENSING PROCESS
WILL BE EFFECTIVELY PARALYZED, AND THE
NATION’S HYDROELECTRIC PROJECTS WILL BE
SEVERELY AFFECTED IF STATES ARE AL-
LOWED TO IMPOSE MINIMUM FLOW CONDI-
TIONS FOR FISH HABITAT AND OTHER NON-
WATER QUALITY CONDITIONS THROUGH SEC-
TION 401 CERTIFICATIONS.
The Washington Supreme Court’s overbroad interpreta-
tion of the authority granted the states in section 401
of the Clean Water Act directly interferes with the hydro-
electric licensing process established in the Federal Power
Act. According to FERC’s own records, between the
years 1993 and 2010, FERC must relicense 416 hydro-
electric projects with a total power capacity of 26,202
megawatts, enough power to serve more than eight mil-
lion people each year."* These figures do not reflect appli-
cations for new hydroelectric power projects.
14 Edison Electric Inst., Statistical Yearbook of the Electric
Utility Industry/1991, No. 59, Table Table 1, p. 7 (Total U.S. 1991
generating capacity) and Table 8, p. 14 (Estimated total U.S 1991
population).
19
Conditions requiring minimum stream flows are of pri-
mary importance to these federal hydroelectric licenses.
Stream flows affect not only power production but also
project economics, project viability, recreation, naviga-
tion, fish and wildlife habitat, and many other concerns
that FERC, but not a state water quality agency, must
consider under the Federal Power Act. Because FERC
has taken the position that it is constrained from modify-
ing section 401 conditions imposed by the states, FERC,
faced with overbroad section 401 conditions, cannot ade-
quately perform its licensing responsibilities under the
Federal Power Act. In fact, FERC may not be able to
issue a license for a particular project at all if the state,
by imposing improper section 401 conditions, makes the
project economically unfeasible. Under the Washington
Supreme Court’s decision, a state water resource agency
that has no obligation to consider the impact of its deci-
sion on energy production and the other benefits of hydro-
electric projects can now decide the fate of hydroelectric
projects instead of FERC, the agency to which Congress
delegated authority to make those decisions.
If states are allowed to mandate minimum stream flows
for non-water quality related matters such as fish habitat
under the guise of the Clean Water Act, without appro-
priate balancing assessments made by FERC, hydro-
power and the many benefits that it provides to con-
sumers, communities, and the nation will be severely
affected. An increase in minimum flows at a hydroelectric
project—in this case, for fish habitat—results either
in lost energy production (because water is not diverted
to power generation facilities) or in the production of
energy when it is uneconomic or not needed. In either
case, the lost hydropower must be replaced. To replace
the lost power, electric suppliers must turn to other forms
of production, particularly fossil fueled geaeration with
consequent adverse implications for air quality, cost, di-
versity of the nation’s energy supply, and other interstate
20
interests. In addition, increased minimum flows can ad-
versely affect other beneficial uses of the waterway, in-
cluding recreation and water supply.
For all of these reasons, Congress intended for the reg-
ulation of hydropower to have a comprehensive and na-
tional focus. When analyzing all of the competing inter-
ests that pertain to a hydroelectric project, FERC cannot
and does not consider only localized concerns. River
systems are not confined by state borders. Indeed, many
State borders are defined by rivers, and many of the na-
tion’s largest rivers cross between or through multiple
States. As a result, many hydroelectric projects affect
water resources in more than one state.'” Recognizing this
reality, FERC maintains a data base of hydroelectric
projects by river basin in order to consider the impacts
that a hydroelectric project may have on an entire river
basin.'* For example, FERC may impose conditions in a
license in order to facilitate fish migration from one state
19 See Map of Hydroelectric Plants Under FERC License For All
Projects Having Total Potential Capacity of 15,000 Kilowatts Or
More (As of Jan. 1, 1984), which is attached in the Appendix.
(A, 3a).
16 When multiple projects in a river basin may have “cumulative”
effects on the resources of the basin, FERC evaluates those effects
as part of its environmental review when licensing the projects.
For example, in 1989 FERC licensed a number of proposed new
hydroelectric projects at existing dams on the upper Ohio River
basin. Allegheny Electric Coop., 48 F.E.R.C. © 61,363 (1989). Be-
cause the FERC staff determined that the projects might have
significant cumulative impacts on the basin, an environmental
impact statement (“EIS”) was prepared for the projects. After
further input, the FERC staff issued a 600-page final EIS analyzing
both cumulative and site-specific impacts on environmental re-
sources, including water quality, fisheries, and recreation. As the
D.C. Circuit neted in approving FERC’s actions, the final EIS
“analyzed the proposed projects from a number of different per-
spectives, including power generation, impact on water quality
and fishery resources, effects on recreational facilities, and socio-
economic conditions.” United States Dep't of Interior v. FERC,
952 F.2d 528, 540 (D.C. Cir. 1992).
- 21
to another state for spawning. Alternatively, a dam located
on a river may provide lake recreation or water for a
municipality upstream of the dam, while releasing water
through the dam for fish habitat downstream. The up-
stream and downstream locations may be in two different
states, but the amount of flow for fish habitat will affect
the water available for municipal purposes and lake levels
at the community upstream. These considerations require
the oversight of FERC, an agency with the mandate and
responsibility to consider the consequences of flow condi-
tions across state lines.
Because of the large number of hydroelectric projects
that must be licensed or relicensed, and the prospect that
each of the 48 states that presently has, or is proposed to
have, a FERC licensed project within its borders will in-
terpret section 401 differently in licensing proceedings,
the potential for litigation and administrative delays to
resolve section 401 disputes is enormous. By appropri-
ately defining the limitations on the authority granted state
water quality agencies under section 401 of the Clean
Water Act, this Court can prevent disruption in the fed-
eral licensing process established by Congress in the Fed-
eral Power Act, while fully honoring the provisions of
both statutes. An appropriate definition of the authority
granted to the states in section 401 will allow state and
federal agencies to perform their intended roles in imple-
menting the Federal Power Act and the Clean Water Aci,
thereby ensuring FERC’s ability to license projects in a
way that safeguards the overall public interest and pro-
tects the viability of the nation’s hydropower resources.
22
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the decision of the Supreme
Court of Washington should be reversed.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN R. MOLM
Counsel of Record
WINIFRED D. SIMPSON
JAMES A. LAMBERTH
TROUTMAN SANDERS
Suite 5200, NationsBank Plaza
600 Peachtree Street, N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30308-2216
(404) 885-3000
Counsel for Amici Curiae
JEREMY M. METZ
American Forest & Paper
Association
260 Madison Avenue
New York, N.Y. 10016-2499
(212) 340-0600
ALAN H. RICHARDSON
American Public Power
Association
2301 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20037
(202) 467-2904
IleENRI D. BARTHOLOMOT
Edison Electric Institute
701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 508-5622
JONATHAN W. GOTTLIEB
National Hydropower
Association
701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 508-4000
November 15, 1993
APPENDIX
la
APPENDIX
THE AMICI
1. American Forest & Paper Association
American Forest & Paper Association (“AFPA”)
is the national trade association of the forest, pulp, paper,
paperboard, and wood products industry, which as a
group is the third largest producer of electricity among
manufacturers in the United States and is one of the
nation’s leaders in the development and use of hydro-
electric power. AFPA represents approximately 550
member companies and related trade associations (whose
memberships are in the thousands), which grow, harvest
and process wood and wood fiber, manufacture pulp,
paper and paperboard products from both virgin and re-
covered fiber, and produce solid wood products. As a
single national trade association, AFPA represents an in-
dustry that accounts for over 7 percent of the total United
States manufacturing output and 90 percent of domestic
recycled paper manufacturing capacity.
2. American Public Power Association
American Public Power Association (“APPA”) is
the national organization representing 1,750 of the na-
tion’s 2,000 local public power systems. These systems
are located in every state except Hawaii and range in size
from the largest public power system, the Los Angeles
Department of Water and Power with more than 1.3
million customers, to small towns with fewer than 100
customers. Public power systems own approximately 11.9
percent of the total installed electric utility generating
capacity in the United States. Hydroelectric projects,
with a total installed capacity of 18,426,063 kilowatts,
comprise nearly 21 percent of public power’s total genera-
tion. There are 90 APPA member utilities with hydro-
electric capacity. Certain of these utilities, such as the
New York Power Authority and the South Carolina Pub-
2a
lic Service Authority, market this hydroelectric power at
wholesale to other publicly owned utilities.
3. Edison Electric Institute
Edison Electric Institute (“EET”) is the association
of the nation’s investor-owned electric utility companies.’
Its members serve 97 percent of the customers of the
investor-owned segment of the industry and 73 percent
of all consumers of electricity in the United States. EEI’s
members generate 78 percent of all the electricity in the
United States and service 76 percent of the nation’s ulti-
mate customers. A large number of EEI’s members rely,
either directly or through power purchase agreements,
upon hydroelectric power to supply their customers’ needs
and to operate their systems. Over the last eighty years,
investor-owned utilities have developed, operated and
maintained large numbers of hydroelectric projects, and
today operate approximately 366 such projects under li-
censes issued by the Federal Power Commission or its
successor, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.
These projects serve over 100 million Americans in
forty-one states. As the national representative of the
single largest group of hydroelectric project licensees, EEI
has a vital interest in ensuring that the federal statutes
governing the licensing of hydroelectric projects are in-
terpreted consistently and implemented properly.
4. National Hydropower Association
National Hydropower Association (“NHA”) is the
non-profit association established in 1983 to be a national
voice for the hydropower industry. NHA has over 100
members from all segments of the hydroelectric industry,
including investor-owned utilities, cooperatives, munici-
palities, private developers, manufacturers, engineers, and
legal, financial and consulting firms from all regions of
the country.
1Consumers Power Company, a member of EEI, does not join
in this amici filing.
BEST AVAILABLE COPY
OLPART MENT OF ENERGY
*EDERA, ENERGY REGU ATORY COMMISSION
“Nye ote
: 88.
INSERT (REA... [ga
i. |
an ‘
“5
| I st
}
- : — ie Ma ot cd es , ¢ ~~~} MAP OF HYDROELECTRIC PLANTS
| | * a0 oe ; bef UNDER FERC LICENSE
| i ep : , | my (AS OF JAN 1, 1984)
Note" eNSAC P mects Tay include One & more Dente
Summers wer we SE RC ormec! wwrmers ote
ote.
> —
‘» 4 LEGEND
} a; , > @ Plants i Operation sanua 4
. , . @ Miants Unde stu
@ Plants Undeveroped
} | eed
q | J
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.