Joint Appendix — PUD No. 1 of Jefferson Cty. v. Washington Dept. of Ecology
Supreme Court brief1994
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
. rere me Wy,
FILER
No. 92-1911 | ROY 1 & 1993
Oar Of MME BLARK
In The a
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1993
+
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON COUNTY
AND THE CITY OF TACOMA,
Petitioners,
V.
STATE OF WASHINGTON, DEPARTMENT OF
ECOLOGY, DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES AND
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE,
Respondents.
S
On Writ Of Certiorari To The
Supreme Court Of The State Of Washington
°
JOINT APPENDIX
o
Howarp E. SHaApiRo* Jay J. MANNING*
VAN Ness, FetoMAN & Curtis Senior Assistant
A Professional Corporation Attorney General
1050 Thomas Jefferson St., N.W. Office of the Attorney
Seventh Floor General of Washington
Washington, D.C. 20007 P.O. Box 40117
(202) 298-1800 Olympia, Washington
Counsel for Petitioners 98504-0117
(206) 459-6158
Counsel for Respondents
*Counsel of Record
Petition For Certiorari Filed June 1, 1993
Certiorari Granted October 4, 1993
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO, (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
Cg TTS Ce Pe
EP Tene LRA a ae a
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ete Cee ee 2. co ccccckssavbunnnnme 1
Affidavit of Kenneth J. Bruya, dated January 28,
BGP ceticecandenksasccecdans tenes 5
Affidavit of Brad Caldwell, dated January 28, 1987... 7
Affidavit of Hal Beecher, dated January 28, 1987... 12
Pre-hearing Order, dated June 29, 1987 ............ 15
Extracts from the original transcript of PHCB pro-
ceedings December 15 - December 18, 1987...... 21
a. Transcript Day One, December 15, 1987, p. 28,
line 2 through p. 30, line 11................. 21
b. Transcript Day Two, December 16, 1987, p. 149,
line 20 through p. 167, line 13............... 24
c. Transcript Day Three, December 17, 1987, p. 39,
line 24 through p. 89, line 10................ 41
d. Transcript Day Three, December 17, 1987, p. 96,
lines 19 through 25, and p. 97, lines 1 and 2... 88
e. Transcript Day Three, December 17, 1987, p.
109, lines 24 and 25, through p. 110, lines 1
OB PPTTTTETET TCO LIT ETT Tree 89
f. Transcript Day Four, December 18, 1987, p. 23,
line 16 through p. 27, line 5, p. 60, line 7
through p. 62, line 8; p. 72, line 1 through p. 73,
BD Bo ccvenccaccbesessvccstcccescussucareseas 91
Appellants’ Motion to Supplement the Record as to
Economic Feasibility Information, with Affidavit of
Garth Jackson, dated February 4, 1988........... 97
Respondents’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion
to Supplement the Hearing Record, dated February
SS See eee 100
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Order Denying Motion to Supplement the Hearing
Record, dated June 29, 1988 ..................... 103
Certificate of Record of the Pollution Control Hear-
ings Board, dated March 17, 1989 ............... 105
Answer to Statement of Grounds for Direct Review,
Co Ere 115
Motion to File Amicus Curiae Brief of 14 State,
Regional and National Conservation Groups, dated
EEE ee 123
The following opinions, decisions, judgments and
orders have been omitted in printing this joint appendix
because they appear on the following pages in the appen-
dix to the printed Petition for Certiorari:
Letter Order of the State of Washington Department
of Ecology Granting Request for Water Quality
Certification, issued June 11, 1986............... 82a
Order Granting Cross Motion for Summary Judgment
of the State of Washington Pollution Control Hear-
ings Board, issued April 10, 1987................ 73a
Order Denying Second Motion for Summary Judg-
ment of the State of Washington Pollution Control
Hearings Board, issued December 9, 1987........ 70a
Revised Final Findings of Fact Conclusions of Law and
Order of the State of Washington Pollution Control
Hearings Board, issued January 25, 1989........... 46a
Revised Dissenting Opinion of the State of Washing-
ton Pollution Control Hearings Board, issued Janu-
arte EPC e GCG EES SE b65460060n000000 60a
ili
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Memorandum Opinion of the Superior Court of the
State of Washington, issued May 8, 1991......... 37a
Findings of Fact Conclusions of Law and Final Judg-
ment of the Superior Court of the State of Washing-
ton in and for the County of Thurston, issued
August 14, 1991....... 6... c cece cere eee eee e eens 29a
Opinion of the Supreme Court of the State of Wash-
ington, issued April 1, 1993 ..........6ee sere eens 3a
Mandate of the Supreme Court of the State of Wash-
ington, issued May 3, 1993.......... 6005s eee eens la
The following documents have been omitted in print-
ing this joint appendix because they appear on the fol-
lowing pages in the appendix to the printed Brief in
Opposition to Petition for Certiorari:
Affidavit of Walter Bergstrom before the State of
Washington Pollution Control Hearings Board,
dated January 28, 1987 ..........600e cece ee eeees 87a
Letter of United States Environmental Protection
Agency to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,
dated January 13, 1991 ........ 6.66 e cece eee eees 90a
a
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
POLLUTION CONTROL HEARINGS BOARD
January 28, 1987 - Cross Motion for Summary Judg-
ment filed with the Pollution Control Hearing Board
January 28, 1987 - Affidavit of Ken Bruya
January 28, 1987 — Affidavit of Brad Caldwell
January 28, 1987 — Affidavit of Hal Beecher
June 29, 1987 — Pre-Hearing Order of Pollution Con-
trol Hearing Board
February 4, 1988 - Appellant’s Motion to Supplement
the Record as to Economic Feasibility Information, with
Affidavit of Garth Jackson
THURSTON COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT
February 24, 1989 — Petition for Review of the Deci-
sion of the Pollution Control Hearings Board
March 1, 1989 — Cross Petition for Review of Pollu-
tion Control Hearing Board
January 3, 1990 — Motion to Establish Briefing Sched-
ule and Date for Argument
February 27, 1990 - Notice of Hearing
November 30, 1990 - Memo in Support of City and
PUDS Cross-Appeal on the Jurisdictional Issue
November 30, 1990 — Trial Brief of the Department of
Ecology, Fisheries and Wildlife
December 17, 1990 — Response Brief of Department of
Ecology, Fisheries and Wildlife
December 20, 1990 —- City & PUD’s Reply Brief on the
Jurisdictional Preemption Issue
March 2, 1991 —- Motion for Expedited Hearing Date
May 10, 1991 - Memo Opinion of Judge Fuller
June 6, 1991 — Notice of Appeal to Supreme Court
June 14, 1991 —- Copy of Letter from Supreme Court to
Counsel
June 14, 1991 - Notice of Supreme Court No. 58272
June 26, 1991 — Designation of Clerk’s Papers &
Exhibits
July 25, 1991 — Notice of Hearing - Special Setting
July 29, 1991 - Memo of PUD and City in Support of
Their Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law &
Final Judgment
August 14, 1991 — Findings of Fact & Conclusions of
Law and Final Judgment
April 2, 1992 — Letter from Supreme Court Clerk
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
June 12, 1991 - Notice of Appeal
June 26, 1991 -— Statement of Grounds for Direct
Review
July 19, 1991 — Clerk’s Papers - 2 Volumes Received
From Thurston County
August 26, 1991 — Letter establishing Briefing Sched-~
ule
August 26, 1991 - Designation of Clerk’s Papers -
Supplemental of Clerks
September 12, 1991 - Answer of Respondents to
Statement of Grounds for Direct Review
September 12, 1991 — Clerk’s Papers - 1 Volume
pages 284-332 received from Thurston County Clerk
October 14, 1991 — Proposed Report of Proceedings -
Notification That 1 Vol. of transcript was filed in
Thurston County Clerk’s Office
November 25, 1991 -— Notation Order on Motions
Establishing Briefing Schedule
January 27, 1992 - Appellant's Brief
February 27, 1992 - Respondent's Brief
March 13, 1992 - 1 Box and 3 Charts of Administra-
tive Record Received from Thurston County
April 28, 1992 - Motion for Amicus Brief
April 30, 1992 - Appellant’s Reply Brief
May 1, 1992 - Court Ruling on Motions - (Letter
Form) Granting Motion to File Amicus Brief
May 18, 1992 - Motion to File Amicus Curiae Brief on
Behalf of 14 State, Regional and National Conservation
Groups
May 18, 1992 - Amicus Curiae Brief
May 18, 1992 - Amicus Curiae Brief of Behalf of
Conversation Amici
May 18, 1992 - Order on Motions
™ = 8, 1992 - Answer of Utilities Amicus Curiae
rie
June 9, 1992 - Notation Order on Motions
June 9, 1992 — Affidavit of Mailing Answer to Amicus
Curiae Brief
June 25, 1992 - Set for Hearing — entered June 25,
1992 En Banc 3rd Case
March 15, 1993 - Additional Authorities
April 1, 1993 ~ Opinion
May 3, 1993 —- Mandate
May 5, 1993 - Administrative Record - returned to
Thurston County
| June 8, 1993 - Supplemental Pleadings - Notice of
Filing Petition for Cert.
5
*&FORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON
COUNTY, and CITY OF
TACOMA DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES,
Appellant,
PCHB No. 86-118
AFFIDAVIT OF
KENNETH J.
BRUYA
V.
STATE OF WASHINGTON,
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
Respondent.
See Oe OO OO OO ™
STATE OF WASHINGTON )
) ss.
COUNTY OF THURSTON )
I, Kenneth J. Bruya, being first duly sworn upon oath,
depose and say:
1. Iam over 18 years of age and competent to testify
herein.
2. I am employed by the Washington State Depart-
ment of Fisheries as a Fisheries Biologist. Previously, |
was employed by the Fisheries Research Institute, Uni-
versity of Washington, as a Fisheries Biologist. | received
a Bachelor of Science Degree from the University of
Washington in Fisheries Biology in 1973. I received a
Masters of Science in Fisheries Biology from the Univer-
sity of Washington in 1981.
Se
3. I worked with Brad Caldwell and other agency
representatives on the minimum instream flow for the
bypass reach of the Elkhorn hydroelectric project. The
project is proposed to be located on the Dosewallips
River.
4. Iam well acquainted with the IFIM methodology
for determining an appropriate minimum instream flow
for a given stream.
5. The minimum instream flow that was imposed by
the Department of Ecology for the Elkhorn project in a
water quality certification dated June 11, 1986, is reason-
able and appropriate. These flows are established to
maintain habitat for anadromous fish. These flows are
necessary to protect salmon runs in the Dosewallips
River. The bypass reach is utilized by several species of
salmon for spawning, incubation, and juvenile rearing.
6. The Department of Fisheries supports the flow
that was imposed by the Department of Ecology for the
Elkhorn project.
/s/ Kenneth J. Bruya
KENNETH J. BRUYA
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me this 28th
day of January, 1987.
/s/ Beverly J. Jolley
NOTARY PUBLIC in and for
the State of Washington.
My commission expires.
12/21/89.
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON )
COUNTY, and CITY OF )
TACOMA DEPARTMENT OF ) PCHB No. 86-118
PUBLIC UTILITIES, | apenavir OF
Appellant, BRAD
wie ) CALDWELL
v. )
STATE OF WASHINGTON, ;
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
Respondent. )
)
STATE OF WASHINGTON __)
) ss.
COUNTY OF THURSTON _)
I, BRAD CALDWELLL, being first duly sworn upon
oath, depose and say:
1. I am over 18 years of age and am competent to
testify herein. All of the following testimony is from my
own personal knowledge.
2. Iam employed by the Department of Ecology as
a Fish Biologist. I work in the Department’s Water
Resources Program. My specialty is the setting of appro-
priate minimum instream flows utilizing the standard
“Instream Flow Incremental Method” (IFIM). I work
closely with other resource agencies in arriving at a sug-
gested minimum instream flow.
3. I attended college at Florida Southern College,
where I received a Bachelor of Science degree in Biology. I
received my Masters Degree from Colorado State Univer-
sity in Fisheries Biology.
4. After I received my Masters Degree, I worked for
the “Instream Flow Group” for one and one-half years.
This group originated the IFIM and is nationally recog-
nized for its expertise in the IFIM process. I taught
courses for the Instream Flow group in field technique
and computer analysis. I have also worked as a private
consultant and for the Washington State Department of
Fisheries as an instream flow specialist.
5. I worked extensively on the minimum instream
flow for the bypass reach of the proposed Elkhorn pro-
ject, utilizing the IFIM methodology. The project itself
would consist of a diversion weir, or a small dam, to be
located at river mile 13.8, just outside the Olympic
National Park. The weir would divert up to 600 cubic feet
per second of river water from the natural channel to a
penstock, or large pipe. The diverted water would run
downstream at a relatively constant elevation, while the
river drops steeply below. Then, approximately 1.2 miles
downstream, the penstock would drop almost vertically
to the powerhouse. The falling water would turn a tur-
bine in the powerhouse generating electrical energy. The
river water would then be returned to the channel. The
bypass reach is the stretch of river between the diversion
weir and the powerhouse. It was this stretch of river
upon which I concentrated in setting the minimum
instream flow in question.
6. The Dosewallips River is a free flowing, beautiful
stream which drains a large portion of the eastern Olym-
pic mountain range. The west fork drains the glaciers and
snowfields of Mt. Anderson. The main fork drains the
slopes of Mt. Hayden and Mt. Fromme. The upper por-
tion of the river runs entirely through the Olympic
National Park. The proposed Elkhorn project would be
located just outside the park boundary.
7. The Dosewallips is the second largest stream
flowing into Hood Canal. It is a very important stream
for salmon and steelhead. The Dosewallips supports
some of the largest runs of salmon and steelhead in the
entire canal. Both winter and summer steelhead utilize
the Dosewallips. Chinook, Coho, and Chum salmon are
also found in the river. The Dosewallips supports the
largest run of Pink Salmon of any stream flowing into the
Canal.
8. The bypass reach may be utilized by all of these
types of salmon and steelhead. It is utilized as a spawn-
ing area and as a rearing area for juveniles. For this
reason, a minimum instream flow is absolutely necessary
for the bypass reach. In the absence of a minimum flow,
the Elkhorn project could dewater the pypass reach for
much of the year, rendering it unfit for fish. It is impossi-
ble to quantify what impact this would have on the
steelhead and salmon runs in the Dosewallips, but a
detrimental impact, due to loss of habitat, would almost
certainly occur.
9. A water quality certification was issued for the
Elkhorn project on June 11, 1986. A copy is attached as
endintiewme §— «at
10
Exhibit 1 hereto. A condition was included in the certi-
fication which required the maintenance of a minimum
instream flow in the bypass reach for the project. The
minimum flow required is the one arrived at by me and
other agency representatives using the IFIM methodol-
ogy.
10. In arriving at this flow, I worked closely with
representatives of the Department of Fisheries, Depart-
ment of Game, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the
Point No Point Treaty Council. These agency representa-
tives are all trained in the IFIM process and are very
experienced in utilizing this method. The instream flow
in question was agreed to by the agencies listed above as
appropriate and necessary.
11. The instream flow that was imposed as a condi-
tion in the water quality certification is a very modest
one. It is, at least, a ninety (90) percent exceedance flow.
In other words, the natural flow in the stream will exceed
the minimum flow 90 percent of the time. During some
months of the year, the minimum flow will be a 98
percent exceedance flow. Therefore, in my opinion, the
minimum flow requirement is a reasonable, in fact, mini-
mal device which will protect the Dosewallips and its fish
runs and which will allow the City to construct and
operate the Elkhorn Project.
/s/ Brad Caldwell
BRAD CALDWELL
11
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me this 28
day of January, 1987.
/s/ Patricia J. Korosec
NOTARY PUBLIC in and for
the State of Washington.
My commission
expires1-16-90
12
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL HEARINGS
BOARD STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF
JEFFERSON COUNTY,
and CITY OF TACOMA
DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES,
Appellant,
PCHB No. 86-118
AFFIDAVIT OF
HAL BEECHER
V.
STATE OF
WASHINGTON,
DEPARTMENT OF
ECOLOGY,
Respondent.
eee eee eae
STATE OF WASHINGTON )
COUNTY OF THURSTON _)
I, HAL BEECHER, being first duly sworn upon oath,
depose and say:
1. Iam over 18 years of age and competent to testify
herein.
2. I am employed by the Washington State Depart-
ment of Game. I am an instream flow biologist with the
Habitat Management Division of the Department of
Game. I have been employed by the Department of Game
since 1979.
13
3. I received a Bachelor of Arts Degree in Biology
from Middleberry College in 1970. I received a Masters of
Science in Marine biology from the University of West
Florida in 1973. I received a Ph.D. in Stream Ecology and
Ichthyology from Florida State University in 1979. I am
very experienced with various instream flow meth-
odologies. | am familiar with the IFIM methodology.
4. I am familiar with the proposed Elkhorn hydro-
electric project to be constructed on the Dosewallips
River. | worked closely with Brad Caldwell, Jean Cald-
well, and representatives of other resource agencies in
developing a suggested instream flow for the bypass
reach of the Elkhorn project. That flow was imposed as a
condition in a water quality certification issued by the
Department of Ecology for the Elkhorn project on June
11, 1986.
5. The suggested flow is absolutely necessary for
the maintenance of winter and summer steelhead runs in
the Dosewallips River. The purpose of the flow is to
maintain habitat for anadromous fish runs, and possible
for resident game fish. The Washington State Department
of Game supports the minimum instream flow that was
required by the Department of Ecology in the water qual-
ity certification previously mentioned. The flow is reason-
able and, in my opinion, necessary to the maintenance of
anadromous fish runs in the Dosewallips River.
/s/ Hal Beecher
HAL BEECHER
14 15
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me this 28th BEFORE THE
day of January, 1987. po POLLUTION CONTROL HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
/s/ Beverly J. Jolley
NOTARY PUBLIC in and for IN THE MATTER OF A _)
the State of Washington. SECTION 401 WATER )
My commission expires. CERTIFICATION )
12/21/89 GRANTED BY )
| DEPARTMENT OF )
. ECOLOGY TO )
| PUD NO. 1 OF : PCHB No. 86-118
| JEFFERSON COUNTY ) PRE-HEARING ORDER
| AND CITY OF TACOMA, }
| DEPARTMENT OF )
} PUBLIC UTILITIES, )
| Appellant, )
V. ;
STATE OF )
WASHINGTON, )
DEPARTMENT OF )
ECOLOGY, )
Respondent.
A pre-hearing conference was held before William A.
Harrison, Administrative Appeals Judge for the Pollution
Control Hearings Board on June 25, 1987, in Lacey, Wash-
ington.
Appellant was represented by Mark L. Bubenik,
Assistant City Attorney. Respondent was represented by
Jay J. Manning, Assistant Attorney General.
The following issues were set forth:
rr tls
————— ee eee SS...
16
I
ISSUES
1. Whether the specific base flows imposed by the
Department of Ecology in this instance are appropriate
for the preservation of the fishery resource and related
values?
2. What quantity and type of fish inhabit the waters
to be affected by the base flows described by the Depart-
ment of Ecology?
II
WITNESSES
Appellant's Witnesses: |
1. Dwayne Simons - City Engineer
2. Phil Hilgert - Hosey and Associates, Biologist
3. Dr. Eugene Welch - ’ ;
Rother eich - University of Washington
4. Al Solonsky - Hosey and Associates
5. Eileen Garland - Hosey and A ,
mental y ssociates, Environ-
6. Paul Svoboda - City Biologist
7. Ken Bovee - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Respondent's Witnesses:
1. Brad Caldwell - DOE
2. Hal Beecher - DOG
3. Elaine Rybak - USFS
4. Ken Bruya - DOE
17
5. Steve Ralph - Point No Point Treaty Council
6. Walt Bergstrom —- DOE
Ill
EXHIBITS
1. License Application to the Federal Energy Regu-
latory Commission dated March 17, 1986.
2. Instream Flow Study by Hosey and Associates.
3. Washington Department of Fisheries Fish Siting
Records for By-pass Reach.
4. Methodology for Determining Puget Sound Coho
Escapement Goals, Escapement Estimates, 1977 Pre-sea-
son Run Size Prediction and In-season Run Assessment,
WDF Technical Report No. 28, April 1977.
5. Aquatic Habitat and Vegetation Survey of the
Dosewallips River Floodplain, Shapiro and Associates,
October 1982.
6. MEeting Record from interagency meeting held
on September 7, 1983 (IFIM study scoping).
7. Record of interagency site visit conducted on
September 8-9, 1983 (IFIM study scoping).
8. Record of interagency site visit conducted on
September 20-21, 1983 (IFIM study scoping).
9. Letter from Jay Laughlin, Hosey and Associates
to agencies dated January 12, 1984 (requesting letters of
support for preliminary permit extension - includes sum-
mary of instream flow work to date).
ee NS OO
18
10. Record from interagency meeting held on Febru-
ary 21, 1985 (review of IFIM field data and discussion of
hydraulic modeling approach).
11. Letter from John Leder and Phil Hilgert to agen-
cies dated March 7, 1985 (comments on hydraulic model).
——t2:—Record from interagency meeting held on May
30, 1985.
13. Letter from Ken Bovee of the Instream Flow
Group.
14. Letter from Phil Hilgert to Doug Ruston, Wash-
ington Department of Ecology dated August 1, 1985
(comments on IRPP).
15. Record from interagency meeting held on Janu-
ary 14, 1986 (discussed applicants revised flow proposal).
16. Letter from Steve Ralph, Point No Point Treaty
Council to Phil Hilgert, Hosey and Associates dated
March 23, 1986 (rejecting applicants proposed flow reg-
ime and submitting the agency proposal).
17. Letter from Dave Stout, U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service to Phil Hilgert, Hosey and Associates dated
March 28, 1986 (rejecting applicants proposed flow reg-
ime and submitting the agency proposal).
18. Letter from Mark Grandstaff and Hal Beecher,
Washington Department of Game to Phil Hilgert, Hosey
and Associates dated February 5, 1986 (rejecting appli-
cants proposed flow regime and submitting the agency
proposal).
19. Instream Resources and Water Allocation Pro-
gram review dated February 1987.
19
Respondent's Exhibits:
Respondent did not identify exhibits at this confer-
ence.
The parties shall file and exchange their lists of wit-
nesses and exhibits on or before November 1, 1987.
IV
BRIEFS
The parties are not required to file briefs in this
matter. If parties elect to do so, however, all briefs shall
be file one week before hearing, which deadline is now
December 8, 1987.
V
EFFECT OF THIS ORDER
The above statement of issues (Part I) shall control
the subsequent course of the proceedings unless modified
for good cause by subsequent order of this Board. WAC
371-08-140. The above statement of witnesses (Part II and
III), when filed shall control the subsequent course of the
proceedings unless changed by notice adequate to pre-
vent prejudice to both parties.
VI
SITE VISIT
The Department of Ecology has requested the Board
to visit the site provided that weather conditions allow at
the time of hearing. In the event that weather conditions
do not allow the parties will explore the possibility of
’
20
21
cooperatively producing a video tape showing those BEFORE THE POLLUTION
places and things that will be referred to in testimony. CONTROL HEARINGS BOARD
. STATE OF WASHINGTON
DATED this 29th day of June, 1987.
POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD CITY OF TACOMA, et al.,
/s/ William A. Harrison Appellants,
WILLIAM A. HARRISON
Administrative Appeals Judge
VS.
STATE OF WASHINGTON
DEPARTMENT OF
ECOLOGY, et al.,
Respondents.
PCHB No. 86-118
me eee eee eee”
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
DAY ONE
December 15, 1987
Lacey, Washington
Lisa Alger
Registered Professional Reporter
GENE BARKER & ASSOCIATES
406 Security Building
Olympia, Washington 98501
(206) 943-2693
* + *
[28] Q Mr. Hilgert, could you briefly describe the
hydroelectric development process?
A What we are really looking at is when someone
decides they want to build a hydropower project they
22
apply for a license application from the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission, Federal Government. The Gov-
ernment gives them a permit to study a particular site,
lock in rights to that site for a period of three years.
During that preliminary permit phase you need to
develop the information in order to try and assess
impacts. This is the period where you really start working
closely with the various Fish and Wildlife Service Agen-
cies, tribes and develop the environmental studies. You
then prepare a draft license application that identifies the
resource, your proposed project, any alternatives, alterna-
tive configurations for your project and what you per-
ceive to be the impacts associated with the development.
A draft of the application goes out to the agencies,
they have a period of time to look at the draft, and then
they send their comments back to you and you revise the
draft or respond to their comments and send a revised
license application and the agencies’ comments and any
comments you have, send the whole thing [29] off to the
FERC, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, they
look at it and they generally try and get an application
where agreements are all worked out. They like to see
things all finalized mitigation plans, if necessary. Their
responsibility is to arbitrate in case you have a disagree-
ment between the applicant and the agencies.
Frankly, they don’t like to try to get into that. They
find they have problems trying to arbitrate because then
you have both sides fighting against you. They will gen-
erally send the application back and say why don’t you
guys work it out for a little bit longer. They will often
request additional information as an incentive to try and
get the applicant and the agencies to work things out. If
23
all else fails, they either accept or reject the license appli-
cation and they make an independent assessment of what
they think the project should go through, and any mitiga-
tion they feel is necessary.
It's a process that a preliminary permit takes three
years. The license, once it goes in, can take from any-
where to two to five years, depending how long it sits
back and defers, and the license is issued and you have
four years to start construction.
Q I’m showing you what's marked as Exhibit A-4.
Would you [30] please identify this document?
A This is the application for the Elkhorn hydro-
electric project submitted to the FERC in March of ‘86. It
contains the application, agency comments, our response
to those comments, notice of deficiencies. If you send an
application often times when you start the process and
when you finally send the thing in, sometimes FERC
rules will change or you'll forget a certain portion that
they may be looking at, and they will send you a defi-
ciency letter and say well, you didn’t tell us how much
this is per item cost.
* * .
24
BEFORE THE POLLUTION
CONTROL HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON
COUNTY and CITY OF TACOMA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
UTILITIES,
Appellants,
,
VS.
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE, and
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES,
Respondents.
PCHB NO. 86-118
ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
DAY TWO
December 16, 1987
Lacey, Washington
Bibiana D. Carter
Registered Professional Reporter
GENE BARKER & ASSOCIATES
406 Security Building
Olympia, Washington 98501
(206) 943-2693
}
-
25
» a *
[149] Q. Mr. Beecher, could you state your full name
and spell it for the record?
A. My name is Hal A. Beecher, H-a-l B-e-e-c-h-e-r.
Q. Mr. Beecher, by whom are you employed?
A. I am employed by the Washington Department
of Wildlife.
Q. And how long have you have been with the
Department of [150] Wildlife?
A. I have been with the Department of Wildlife,
formerly the Department of Game, since the fall of 1979,
approximately eight years.
Q. What’s your current position?
A. My current position is technical services pro-
gram manager.
Q. Could you tell us what your usual job duties are?
A. One of my job duties is instream flow biologist
and instream flow expert for the department. I also am in
charge of — I supervise people that work with habitat
evaluation procedures, mitigation banking, wetlands,
Puget Sound Water Quality Authority and —- well, a few
other related things.
Q. In the packet of exhibits in front of you, is your
resume included as Exhibit R-7?
A. Yes it is.
—
26
Q. Using that exhibit as you need to, would you
please briefly describe your educational background and
employment history?
A. I have a bachelor’s, master’s and PhD in biology
and I have worked for the Department of Wildlife for
about eight years working primarily on instream flows. |
have also worked for The Nature Conservancy as an
aquatic ecologist and as a consultant in stream ecology
and bird ecology.
Q. Have you had any specific training with regard
to the [151] instream flow incremental method?
A. Yes, I have. I have taken several of the short
courses that the Instream Flow Group has provided, both
here in Washington and also in Fort Collins, Colorado.
Q. Have you actually performed IFIM studies?
A. Yes, I have. I performed one IFIM study, really
the entire study, taking a lead on it myself and doing all
the fieldwork and computer work, and everything, on
Snow Creek which is on the Olympic Peninsula. I have
been involved in many other studies.
Q. Have you reviewed other IFIM studies that have
been -
A. Yes. I have reviewed virtually all the IFIM
Studies that have been conducted for small hydroelectric
Projects, for other types of Projects in the state of Wash-
ington, since probably ‘79.
Q. How did you first get involved with the Elkhorn
project?
nd
27
A. I was first involved with the Elkhorn project
when in 1982, early ‘82, when my job duties were to be
the - I was responsible for being the Department of
Wildlife - or Department of Game then - representative
for mitigation for hydroelectric projects on the Olympic
Peninsula and also parts of the Western Cascades.
Q. Would you please run through your involvement
with the project generally?
A. Yes. As I mentioned, my involvement began in
early 1982 [152] when I requested that the Attorney Gen-
eral’s Office intervene on behalf of the Department of
Game in this hydro project. In the end of 1982 I visited
the site with the project proponent and its consultant.
Let’s see. In early 1983, March, I had some correspon-
dence with the consultant regarding steelhead usage of
the bypass in which I had obtained information that
steelhead did in fact use the bypass reach.
Q. Let me ask you about that specifically. In your
opinion, do steelhead use the bypass reach?
A. Yes, they do.
Q. Would you tell us how you know that?
A. I have observed juvenile steelhead in the bypass.
| have been told by the proponent’s consultant that they
have been observed, adult steelhead, in the bypass. I have
talked to the Olympic National Forest, some Olympic
National Forest personnel, and also Parks personnel also
regarding their evidence that steelhead are in the Dos-
ewallips immediately upstream from the bypass and,
therefore, must have gone through the bypass reach to
get there.
28
Q. Rather than go through all of the meetings that
you went to, is it fair to say that you attended the
majority of the meetings that were held regarding the
Elkhorn project?
A. Yes, it is.
[153] Q. Have you ever been to the site?
A. Yes, I have.
Q. Have you ever snorkeled the stream?
A. Yes, I have.
Q. Would you tell us what that means and what is
involved in snorkeling?
A. We got in wet suits, masks, snorkels, and vigor-
ously climbed, scrambled from the vicinity of the pro-
posed intake down to Elkhorn Campground, and during
that time, when we had time, I stopped and looked for
fish and looked at habitat. And one of the purposes of
this trip was to get an idea of the overall conditions,
habitat conditions in the bypass, relative abundance of
different habitat types such as pools, riffles, cascades,
waterfalls, boulders, so to select the site where the IFIM
study could be conducted.
| Q. I would like you to attempt if you can to charac-
terize the bypass reach as habitat for steelhead. Is it poor,
medium, good? Could you characterize it in that nature?
A. It appears to me to be - to have a lot of good
rearing habitat. Its pools, a lot of plunge pools and boul-
der chutes.
Q. What is a plunge pool?
1 oe ’
29
tel
A. A plunge pool is a pool at the base of a waterfall
which can be a small waterfall of only a foot or two or a
large [154] waterfall. And in my experience with a variety
of streams around the state of Washington, I would say
that this is relatively good steelhead, particularly good
steelhead-rearing habitat. There is only a modest amount
of spawning habitat. It is not the abundance of spawning
habitat that you see in some other, what I would call,
more typical Puget Sound streams.
Q. We have had a lot of testimony in this case
regarding whether or not this bypass reach is spawning
limited or rearing limited. Do you know whether the
bypass reach is spawning limited or rearing limited?
A. No, I don’t.
Q. Do you have an opinion on that matter?
A. I have an opinion that there is certainly the pos-
sibility, a very real possibility, that it could be spawning
limited, and that there is some special circumstances that
make it more likely to be spawning limited than the
typical Puget Sound stream.
Q. Could you explain what those characteristics are
or what it was that you saw that formed that opinion?
A. One factor is that there are canyon walls, bed-
rock walls that come down, and the stream channel does
not spread out into a floodplain. Once the stream channel
ends, it pretty much - the bank goes steeply uphill.
Q. Mr. Beecher, I am sorry. I got a little bit out of
order [155] and I definitely want to come back to where
we are, but before you do that could you explain what
30
those two terms mean, rearing limited and spawning
limited?
A. Those two terms, they imply that there is one
factor — that one or the other factor is the factor that
limits how much production of steelhead, or whatever,
salmonid species, or other species you might be inter-
ested in, occurs.
I have some concerns about those particular terms in
the implications that they are the one and only factors.
There is a lot of work and I think a lot of opinion among
researchers in stream ecology that it’s an oversimplifica-
tion to say that there is one factor that limits production,
that in fact there are many things which, if they could be
changed, might produce a change in production.
Q. Okay. Given that caution, can you go on and tell
us what those terms mean?
A. Spawning limited would mean that the amount
of production is proportional to the amount of spawning
that can take place and presumably to the amount of
spawning habitat that’s available. And that changes in
other factors such as rearing would not affect production.
Likewise, rearing limited implies that the amount of
rearing habitat that is available is going to control the
[156] amount of production, and that changes in other
factors do not affect the amount of production.
Q. Okay. Mr. Hilgert testified that there is a general
assumption on behalf of the agencies and biologists gen-
erally that Puget Sound streams are rearing limited.
Would you agree that there is that general assumption?
a
31
A. I think there is that general assumption. There
are some qualifiers there. There are some qualifiers but,
yes, that is a widely-held assumption, again, generally,
for Puget Sound streams.
Q. Okay. And you testified just a minute ago that in
your opinion that assumption may not hold true for the
bypass reach.
A. That's correct.
Q. And could you go ahead then and get back to
where you were and tell us what it is about the bypass
reach that leads you to believe that that general assump-
tion may not be true?
A. All right. One factor about the bypass reach is
that there is not a lot of spawning habitat, and one of the
reasons is because it is a confined bedrock channel with
gravel accumulations in portions, but it is not, as in the
typical Puget Sound stream and the lower Dosewallips as
an example of that, where you have a broad floodplain,
that the entire channel is gravel and is generally suitable
to [157] some extent for spawning. That is not the case in
the bypass reach. Just patches of spawnable habitat. It’s
much less, much smaller ratio of spawnable habitat to
total area of the bypass reach.
Another factor is that the bypass reach is very close
to the upper limits of accessibility for anadromous fish.
Now, we are concerned about seeding of a reach with
juveniles. If you want to get a fish to rear in a reach, first
you've got to have fish have eggs introduced into that
region, either there or upstream from it. Well, there are
very few eggs that are introduced upstream of it because
32
there is a very - you know, you are very close to the
upper limits of fish accessibility. So there is very few fish
fry, that are going to trickle down into this area to seed
any area, so it’s going to be very important to insure that
all the habitat, all the rearing habitat is occupied, you are
going to have to get fish in there in the first place. Well
the only way you get fish in there is either by spawning
fish or possibly by planting. But planting in that particu-
lar case is not very feasible, again, because of the terrain.
(Q. Are there any other factors that lead you to
believe that this bypass reach may be spawning limited?
A. I think those are really the two primary factors
that lead me to think that it could be.
[158] Q. In the final analysis, however, are you in
the same boat with Mr. Hilgert, that you simply don’t
know whether it’s rearing limited or spawning limited?
A. That's right, I am. I don’t know.
Q. | Mr. Hilgert testified that he used a method called
the habitat ratio, and he said that using that method he
was able to support his generally-held opinion that this
stretch of the river is rearing limited. Are you familiar
with this habitat ratio method?
A. I’m familiar with it.
Q. Could you explain to us how that works?
A. You need to know the mortality rates between
each successive life stages, between each successive life
Stage, so that you can calculate how many fish of one life
Stage it’s going to take to produce a certain number of
33
another life stage. You also need to know how much
habitat an individual fish requires for each life stage.
On the first case, as far as the mortality rates, there
are estimates from various studies that do range fairly
widely so that it becomes - in doing a habitat ratio, you
have to make an assumption that one particular rate is
applicable, and those rates can vary all over the place.
And those rates also can be affected by habitat quality,
including aspects of habitat quality that are influenced by
flow. Therefore, that’s a major uncertainty [159] in using
habitat ratios.
Another, and I think a much bigger uncertainty in
using habitat ratios, is trying to estimate how much habi-
tat does an individual fish use? How much habitat is
needed by an adult for spawning, that may be reasonably
well known. How much is needed for a rearing juvenile is
not well known.
I think we recently calculated or determined from
various literature that there are ranges 200-fold, ranges in
estimates of how much habitat a juvenile steelhead
requires. You have the same sort of thing for each life
stage. You have these attempts to quantify. In addition to
that complication, then you you have to make the conver-
sion of habitat, as has been measured in habitat area
occupied by a fish, as has been measured in relatively few
studies to weighted usable area, and the two cannot be
converted one-to-one. And so there is a great number of
problems with using habitat ratios.
Q. Given these three problems that you have listed
with this habitat ratio technique, do you have an opinion
as to the reliability of this approach?
34
A. I don’t feel that it’s reliable.
Q. To your knowledge does the Department of
Wildlife except habitat ratios as a method for determining
how fish will do in a given stretch of river?
[160] A. No, I don’t.
Q. Do any of the resource agencies that were
involved in the Elkhorn project accept habitat ratios to
your knowledge?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. We heard a description of the life cycle of salmon
from Mr. Bruya. Could you briefly tell us how the life
cycle of a steelhead is different from the life cycle of a
salmon?
A. The life cycle of a steelhead is in many ways -
THE WITNESS: Thank you, Brad.
A. (Continuing) The life cycle of a steelhead is simi-
lar in that similar life phases, the timing is different.
Steelhead spawn generally in the spring during or just
prior to the spring runoff flows. They rear in the stream
for usually two full summers, two full years, so they rear
for a longer time in the stream than any of the salmon.
They migrate back up to the home spawning areas from
the sea generally during the winter, and they can migrate
almost any month of the year, but the bulk of them,
particularly the winter steelhead which is what we have
most of in the Puget Sound area, tend to migrate during
the winter and into the early spring.
Q. How long do they stay out in the ocean?
35
A. They stay out in the ocean approximately a year-
and-a-half, over two summers. They enter the ocean [161]
in the spring. They stay in the ocean through that sum-
mer, through the following winter, the following summer
and then return.
Q. Okay. Do steelhead juveniles - or let me ask it
this way: Do you agree with Mr. Hilgert’s testimony that
steelhead, juveniles and fry, generally bury into the
gravel in the streambed when the water temperature
approaches, either reaches eight .‘egrees centigrade or
colder?
A. Yes, I would agree with that.
Q. Do you have any personal experience that would
verify that phenomena?
A. Yes, I have. I have done some snorkeling in some
streams in this area, and streams where I have found in
warmer weather large numbers of juvenile fish, both coho
salmon and steelhead, and then have snorkeled there in
cold weather and been unable to see any fish whatsoever.
Q. Were you here for Mr. Hilgert’s testimony?
A. Yes, I was.
Q. And did you hear him several times use the 50
percent exceedence flow as representing existing condi-
tions?
A. Yes, I did. I believe he qualified that and did not
state that it was — I think he said it was an index of
existing conditions and backed away somewhat from say-
ing that it was existing conditions.
36
[162] Q. Mr. Beecher, I am looking for a certain
exhibit, which has been called Exhibit A-21. Are you
familiar with that exhibit?
A. Yes, I am.
Q. And is that the exhibit which is a table and it
compares the agencies’ stream flow recommendation and
Tacoma’s stream flow recommendation with the, quote,
existing conditions, unquote, represented by the 50 per-
cent exceedence flow?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you have any opinion of using the 50 percent
exceedence flow as a representation of existing condi-
tions?
A. I believe it’s inappropriate and does not repre-
sent existing conditions as experienced by any fish popu-
lation inhabiting that area.
Q. Could you explain your opinion?
A. Yes. And I think I would have to concur with Mr.
Caldwell who stated that the fish are opportunistic. The
flows vary widely. The fish experience a wide range of
habitat conditions as flows and other physical factors
change, biological factors also.
I don’t know. Did I answer your question?
Q. I think you did.
In your opinion, what is the optimum flow for fish in
the Dosewallips River and in the bypass reach?
~~
ee eee et Lewes Pere T aates ny he Ate wien.
37
[163] A. I don’t know what the optimum flow for
fish is. It would be very complicated and probably impos-
sible given our current state of knowledge to determine
what an optimum flow for fish is.
Q. Let’s say you were made the river czar of Wash-
ington and you could pick a flow that in your opinion
you felt would best protect the fish in the river. What
flow would you pick?
A. I would have to consider that I would be more
concerned about the risks of losing what we have, and
given that the rivers in Washington have historically pro-
duced fish which have become adapted to the general
seasons and the general types of flow conditions that
occur in different seasons, if I were to recommend opti-
mum, I would not recommend any deviation from natural
flows because I would be concerned lest I cause some
adverse impact to fish populations and other associated
wildlife populations.
Q. Now, the term optimum flow has been tossed
around a lot in this hearing, and does the term optimum
flow have a specific meaning in the IFIM context?
A. I think it is a term that is often used sort of as a
shortcut to saying what is often meant, but I think maybe
different people mean different things by optimum. I try
to avoid the term myself. I don’t know that I always
succeed, but I try to avoid it and try to look at the peak
[164] of the curve of weighted usabie area versus flow.
And that maximum weighted usable area I think is some-
times referred to erroneously as optimum.
38
Q. What are the habitat factors that are measured
by the IFIM?
A. Depth, velocity and substrate and/or cover.
Q. In the Elkhorn project, what were the factors that
were looked at?
A. Depth, velocity and substrate.
Q. Are there factors of habitat which are not mea-
sured and factored into the IFIM in the ultimate weighted
usable area result?
A. There are other factors which are considered in a
qualitative sense in the broader part of IFIM, again in the
more qualitative. After you have the PHABSIM, the
weighted usable area results, you have to go back and -
in fact, the slide show, slide tape show yesterday morning
talked about once you've looked at what you think your
recommendation might be, then you have to go back and
look at those other factors, reassess it in light of every-
fhing else you know about the ecology of the stream.
We try to do that and there are - did you ask me to
try to enumerate some of those factors?
Q. That was going to be my next question.
A. Qh, okay. I couldn’t remember whether you
asked that as [165] part of that question.
Things like predation, competition, territoriality,
many of these kinds of things go hand in hand. Cover,
which is at best only partially incorporated into PHAB-
SIM. Incubation is only partially addressed in PHABSIM
and not terribly well. Out-migration flows, migration bar-
riers in passage, those are factors that are not really
39
addressed in PHABSIM. Water chemistry, physical factors
like temperature, those are not addressed in PHABSIM.
Q. So none of those factors that you have just men-
tioned are actually factored into the weighted usable
area?
A. No. And those all have to be at least factored in
in a qualitative sense.
Q. And does that factoring in in a qualitative sense
occur at the interpretation phase of the IFIM?
A. Yes, it does.
Q. So was it an examination of those types of fac-
tors that led to the difference in flow regimes?
MR. BUBENIK: Objection. Leading.
MR. HARRISON: Overruled. You may answer.
Q. (By Mr. Manning): Led to the difference in flow
regimes between Tacoma and the agencies?
A. I’mnot sure I can answer that because what I can
really answer is how I, as one of the participants in the
agency [166] group that was developing the flow recom-
mendation, we considered those factors.
While I’ve listened to what Mr. Hilgert has said in
developing the applicant’s recommendations, their flow
proposals, I can’t really compare the two. All I know is
that those factors were included in the agency flow pro-
posal.
Q. Given the fact that weighted usable area is only a
function of three elements of habitat, do you have an
opinion as to the reliability of using weighted usable area
as an equivalent of habitat?
40
A. Yes, 1 do have an opinion. My opinion is that it is
a tool, but it’s an incomplete tool that should not be used
by itself. And I have had some experience where specific
analyses have showed that there really are some differ-
ences between weighted usable area and habitat. Appar-
ently — well, even just using those variables, there are a
lot ways to interpret and it is a crude index.
Q. Okay. As a final question, given your opinion of
the 50 percent exceedence as a representation of existing
conditions, and given your opinion of using weighted
usable area as the equivalent of habitat, do you feel that
Tacoma’s consultant can claim with any accuracy that
Tacoma’s flows will provide as much as or more habitat
as is available under, quote, existing conditions?
[167] A. I have real concerns that there will be a real
risk. I cannot quantify that risk, but I think there is a real
risk that with Tacoma’s proposed flows there could be
adverse impacts to fish production.
Q. As usual — Mr. Faulk is used to this - I lied by
saying this was my last question. This one is, though.
In your opinion, are the agency flows enhancement
flows? Will they actually improve fish production in the
river? ,
A. I doubt it. I seriously doubt that they would
improve it. | would hope that they would be adequate to
protect it.
MR. MANNING: Thank you very much.
+ + *
- 41
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL
- HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON
COUNTY AND CITY OF
TACOMA DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES,
Appellants,
vs. NO. 86-118
WASHINGTON STATE
DEPARTMENT OF
ECOLOGY, DEPARTMENT
OF WILDLIFE, AND
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES,
el
Respondents.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
December 17, 1987
Lacey, Washington
DAY THREE
Cheri L. Davidson
Registered Professional Reporter
GENE BARKER & ASSOCIATES
406 Security Building
Olympia, Washington 98501 .
(206) 943-2693
« * *
42
[39] Q. Ms. Caldwell, could you please state your
name and spell it for the record?
[40] A. My name is Jean Caldwell, spelled J-e-a-n,
C-a-l-d-w-e-l-l.
Q. And by whom are you employed?
A. I’m currently employed by the Tulalip Indian
Fisheries Department.
Q. How long have you been with the Tulalip Fish-
eries Department?
A. Since June, 1987.
Q. What are your job duties?
A. I'm a fisheries biologist working on instream
flow issues, water planning issues, small hydropower
project review, and issues relating to the timber fishing
wildlife agreement.
Q. In the package of exhibits before you, is your
resume one of those exhibits?
A. Yes.
Q. Which exhibit is it?
A. It’s R-9.
Q. Okay. Using that as necessary, could you tell us
about your educational background?
A. I have a bachelor’s of science in Environmental
Science from Halsey College at Western Washington Uni-
versity. | worked for — I’ve worked for the San Francisco
Bay Conservation and Development Commission
43
between 1980 and 1985. I worked for the Lumme Indian
Fisheries Department [41] doing environmental review,
major project review, small hydro project review,
instream flow study, scoping, and water rights negotia-
tion, 1985 to 1987.
I worked for the Washington Department of Fisheries
habitat management section both performing instream
flow studies for base and planning and reviewing
instream flow studies done for hydropower projects. The
job was conceived as to provide technical assistance to
the other biologist in the habitat management section,
which was specifically relating to hydrology and
instream flow issues.
Q. Okay. And after the Lummes, who did you work
for?
A. Washington State Fisheries.
Q. Can you describe your description with Fisheries
and what your job duties were?
A. I just did.
Q. Oh, you did. I thought you were still on the
Lummes. I am sorry.
A. No.
Q. Okay. And where did you go after Fisheries?
A. To the Tulalip Fisheries Department Indian Fish-
eries Department.
Q. And that started in -
A. June, 1987.
44
Q. Okay. When did
you first get ed wi
Elkhorn [42] project? sich ith the
A. Iwas hired in April, 1985, so i i
sot ae pril, , SO it would be starting
Q. At what stage was the E
Pee B.. gz e Elkhorn IFIM study in at
A. At that time the consultant had run the hydraulic
model and had come up with the questions about the best
way to run the hydraulic model and the process of dis-
cussing that, and discussing it with the instream flow
report was either going on or had just started.
Q. Have you ever been to the site?
A. Yes.
Q. How many times?
A. Once.
Q. And did you attend
Elkhorn project? meetings regarding the
A. Yes.
Q. Were you involved i
in the actual settin
agency flow regime? er
A. Yes.
rs Q. Now. Mr. Ken Bruya has previously testified in
1s case, and he is also with Department of Fisheries
Was he your boss, or how did
: that i
ment of Fisheries? tii —
A. He was not m
y boss. I was part of a section of
the [43] Department of Fisheries that consisted of two
45
civil engineers and myself, and we were supposed to
provide technical assistance to other biologists involved
in various projects, and Ken was responsible for the
entire review of the Elkhorn project, and I was supposed
to provide assistance specifically with relationship to the
instream flow study and -
Q. Okay. You may have said this also, and I am
sorry that I was not listening, but were you the Depart-
ment of Fisheries’ instream flow expert when you were
there?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, there is a packet of exhibits in front of you,
and I wonder if maybe we could take the time now since
we have not talked about all of these to go through them
fairly quickly and just identify what they are. These have
all been stipulated to and are in evidence.
A. Do you want me to just start and say this is R-3,
this is what this is?
Q. Right, right.
A. This is a — R-3 is a table of the medium monthly
flows by month with the agency’s flow proposal and both
the applicants’ flow proposal on it. It’s a small version of
the chart we have been referring to.
R-4 is a Xeroxed copy of a hydrograph that I drew
using information from Hosey and Associates, and I [44]
believe the information I got it from is from what is called
Exhibit A-21. The blue pen - at least it’s blue on mine — is
the agency’s proposed flows.
Q. Is this a smaller version of R-4?
A. Yes, yes, it is.
Q. Okay. What is R-5?
A. R-5 is a glossary of instream flow terminology
that was developed by Hal Beecher, Brad Caldwell, and
myself for a class that we taught in 7986 to agency biolo-
gists interested in learning more abowt instream flows
used. It was an attempt to simplify some of the jargon
that we all throw around too much. _-
Q. Okay.
A. Do you want me to go through the resumes too?
Q. No, just - Exhibits R-6 through R-11, what are
they?
A. Brad Caldwell’s resume, Hal Beecher’s resume,
Ken Bruya’s resume, my resume, Elaine Rybak’s resume,
and Steve Ralph’s resume.
Q. Okay. How about Exhibit R-12?
A. R-12 is something we developed in answer to the
interrogatories, a table of percentage reduction in pre-
dicted weighted usable areas if the flows proposed by
Tacoma were adopted for this project.
Q. Instead of Ecology’s flows?
A. Instead of Ecology’s flows.
[45] Q. Did you prepare R-12?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. How about R-13 through R-24?
47
A. Well, all R-13 is - it looks like responses to
meeting notes and meeting records. Should I just go one
by one, Jay?
Q. No, just generally what that group is.
A. Correspondence relating to the project from the
various agencies and Hosey and Associates.
Q. Okay. And R-25?
A. R-25 is a letter to Jefferson County PUD from
Ecology about the water quality certification containing
the agency’s recommended flows among other things.
R-26 is at least some and probably all of the weighted
usable area versus flow information that we used to
develop the flow regime that we recommended.
Q. Now, is this what we have been referring to as
the model output or the weighted usable area tables?
A. That's correct.
Q. This is what the computer actually spits out after
it’s done doing its thing?
A. That’s correct.
Q. How about R-27?
A. R-27 is a retyping of the work sheet that we used
to - it’s not what we used to develop the flow regime. It’s
[46] more like a summary that went around for every-
body’s information so that we would all have record of
the final flow regime and what we did.
Q. Okay. R-28?
48
A. R-28 is a periodicity chart for salmon and steel-
head on the Dosewallips River showing what life stages
are in the river at what months.
R-29 is a letter from Becky Reinecker of Hosey to
Fred Hunn of Department of Ecology containing the 1986,
October 21st, 1986, letter from FERC to Jefferson County
PUD.
Q. Are you familiar with that letter from FERC?
A. Yes.
Q. This is the so-called deficiency letter?
A. That's correct.
Q. What is that?
A. It’s the FERC response to the draft license appli-
cation.
Q. Okay. Thank you.
When did the agencies formulate their flow regime
recommendation?
A. We started at a meeting on June 10th, 1985 where
we, Elaine Rybak and Hal Beecher and myself, sat down
and did some original number crunching and put some
recommendations together. I have notes that there was an
agency meeting on August 30th, ‘85 where we discussed
it, [47] and I also have notes that on September 25th, 1985
there was a conference call between agency and triba’
biologists where we got to what we now consider the
final flow regime, which is the one up there (indicating).
So it was during that summer period where we were
reviewing it and putting it together.
i
'
:
A
4
P
49
Q. And that is what we have been referring to as
the interpretation phase of the IFIM process?
A. That’s correct.
Q. What was the basic approach that was utilized
by the agencies?
A. We were trying to optimize for the species that
would be the most sensitive to the things that the IFIM
study was measuring, which was depth, velocity, and
substrate. And our optimization, well, because of that we
ended up putting a lot more emphasis on the spawning
or the adult life stages than on the juvenile and fine life
stages because it’s my opinion that they are more sensi-
tive to changes in the things that the IFIM study mea-
sures.
Q. When you say optimizing for a given species or
life stage, what do you mean?
A. Those terms you use real loosely in — it’s what
you mean when you’re talking about interpreting IFIM
values. It usually means picking the weighted usable
areas, optimizing meaning the flow that would give you
the best [48] predicted usable area.
Q. Now, in your opinion, is that automatically the
best fish production flow?
A. There’s no way to know that. There’s no way to
know that.
MR. BUBENIK: Excuse me. I did not hear your
answer.
THE WITNESS: There’s no way to know what
the best fish production is.
50
MR. BUBENIK: Thank you.
Q. (By Mr. Manning) Was it the intent of the agen-
cies to improve or enhance the bypass reach?
A. That was not my intent, no.
Q. Are you aware of whether it was anybody’s
intent?
A. It’s my opinion that that was not anybody’s
intent. j
Q. What I would like for you to do now - oh, before
we do that I would like to ask you if you are familiar with
Exhibit A-21, which is the - well, I will just ask you, are
you familiar with Exhibit A-21?
A. Yes.
Q. And what is that again?
A. It’s a chart that I first saw at a meeting in Janu-
ary, 1986 where Hosey came in with what is now called
the applicant’s counterproposal.
Q. Okay. What I would like you to do now is - and
[49] specifically using R-27 and A-21 as necessary -
explaim-to-us how the agency flow regime was actually
developed, and let’s start with the month of January.
MR. HARRISON: Excuse me, Mr. Manning.
R-27 is just something we have one copy of, or do we
all have a copy of it?
MR. MANNING: There is an R-27 in each
packet. .
51
MR. HARRISON: All right. So we are going to
be looking at that. And then A-21
MR. MANNING: Correct.
MR. HARRISON: (Continuing) does everybody
have a copy of that?
MS. BENDOR: I don't.
MR. HARRISON: We have one. Do we have
more than one?
MR. FAULK: It’s in the packet.
MR. MANNING: It’s attached to the brief.
MR. HARRISON: Oh, okay. Fine.
Q. (By Mr. Manning) Ms. Caldwell, I don’t mean to
limit you in the exhibits that you need to reference. If
there are others, please feel free.
A. Should I just start?
Q. Just wait a second.
Okay. Why don’t you proceed? Let’s start with Janu-
ary, and if you could explain to us how the agency [50]
flow regime was developed.
A. Before I start with January I would like to go a
little bit more into some of the criteria that we set up
before we started going about it.
Q. Please do so.
A. Okay. In the meeting between Hal and Elaine
and myself we made a few assumptions because when
you have an array of information like you get from an
52
IFIM output you have to make some assumptions, and
you have to make some priorities on what species and life
stage you're going to talk about. So some of the assump-
tions we made were that if we could optimize, well, using
the term in the way that I talked about it before, if we
could optimize for steelhead, that that would take care of
whatever resident fish were in the bypass reach.
For the salmon species we decided we would pay
attention to fall and spring chinook and coho, and that
given that the different agencies and tribes all have dif-
ferent, slightly different, management priorities and spe-
cies of concern, that if we were able to meet the different
agencies’ and tribes’ varying priorities consistent with
current management and try to not foreclose options for
future managers, since this is a hydro project and they
have water rights and water rights are forever, that that
would take care of our agency [51] responsibilities of our
management.
So we were trying to be consistent with what we
knew about current management and not foreclose
options on future management.
We also decided or made a professional judgment
that when possible we would optimize for spawning life
stages or adult life stages more than rearing life stages.
Q. Could you explain why?
A. It was our opinion that the spawning life stages
are more sensitive to changes in the things that the IFIM
study measures than the rearing life stages.
Q. Those being?
53
A. Depth, velocity, and substrate. We were - at that
time we were starting to see more information on the
topic that has been discussed already, that in the winter
there’s a good chance that the juvenile fish are not going
to be active and out of the gravel that much.
And even though fry preference information was put
through the model, we were coming to the conclusion at
the time, which is still my conclusion, that fry’s habitat
requirements are not well modeled by the IFIM and that
in fact fry preference information is erroneous because
what it does — the computer model in essence tries to dry
up the river to create the kind of edge effect, the shallow,
slow water that fry like, and that’s [52] just not an accu-
rate representation of the kind of habitat needs that this
model fish have.
So we weighted the fry life stages not at all and the
juvenile life stages much more lightly then the spawning
ones because we were a lot more comfortable with that
assumption because of the limitations of the computer
model.
Q. Ms. Caldwell, could you explain the term edge
effect, what that refers to and what it means?
A. If I said edge effect that’s not correct. I think
what I meant was edge habitat, that where you find fry in
streams is in shallow, slow water, back waters, or near the
edge of the stream, and that that’s — the computer model
really does not take that into account that they are on the
edges. It will try to create the whole stream to be that, to
be shallow and slow and this steep (indicating), and
that’s just because it’s simple, a simplistic thing, okay?
54
Q. Okay. Thanks.
A. Okay. So given those weightings and the
emphasis on the adults, we kind of — we did - it’s a little
difficult to explain. It’s kind of a two-track calculation
because each species has a different optimum, but we
tried to see if we picked the optimum for one species, say
coho spawning, what it would do to the other species
present [53] and if we pick the optimum for say steel-
head, what it would do to the other species present.
So we calculated the sensitivity of each life stage to
the changes in flow. Some of the output indicates that a
change in flow isn’t going to affect every prediction the
same. Some of the output indicates that for some life
stages it would be very sensitive to changes in flow,
whereas another life stage may not be.
So we tried to see if we could optimize for as many of
the top two I guess spawning life stages as possible and
then if we picked that flow what it would do to the other
ones, and that is reflected in - and that’s what R-27 -
that’s what generated R-27.
So we didn’t try to get all of those to be a hundred
percent because you can’t do that. What we tried to do
was to get the spawning species a hundred percent and
not totally take away habitat for the rearing species.
Q. Okay. In doing that, Ms. Caldwell, was at least a
part of what you were doing based on Exhibit R-26,
which is the weighted usable area output?
A. All the calculations on how habitat would
change were based on R-26.
MS. BENDOR: Excuse me I lost that.
55
THE WITNESS: All the calculations based on
how the habitat would change are calculated from R-26.
[54] That’s what that - that’s the numbers that everybody
uses.
Q. (By Mr. Manning) Okay. Should we start with
January?
A. Sure.
For January -
Q. And you are now looking at R-27?
A. I’m looking at R-27, and the notes that I am
looking at are the original calculations that we made.
Q. Okay.
A. For January we - the species list is there. Look-
ing at coho spawning, the optimum predicted weighted
usable area is at 140 CFS. The NC that is across from fall
and spring chinook incubation means not calculated, and
it’s to remind us that there is incubation going on this
and that even though it’s not calculated in the IFIM we
have to pay attention to it, and I'll get back to why we
have to pay attention to it in a minute.
So at 140 CFS Chinook spawning we managed to get
the coho and chinook juvenile up to 96 percent of opti-
mum and steelhead and chinook at 24 percent of opti-
mum.
Q. And when you use the term optimum, how are
you using that?
A. The most habitat predicted by the output by the
IFIM model is optimum for each species and life stage.
56
| Q. Now, in January you have coho and chinook
juveniles [55] listed twice.
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. In one summer follows the term and then the
other winter follows the term -
A. Winter.
Q. (Continuing) and the percentages of maximum
weighted usable area vary.
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Could you explain that?
A. I wasn’t on staff at the time that the preference
groups were decided on, but it was clear that we were
trying to address the fact that we know there’s differ-
ences in behavior between summer and winter. And
because this is sort of an evolving science or study — that
was right about the time that at least for the salmon
juvenile species I was starting to think that we didn’t
really have enough information to split out summer and
winter, that it’s quite possible that in the winter the
habitat needs, because rearing fish would either be in
gravel or in off-channel habitats or side channels or flood
channels, that we weren’t describing their habitat needs
very well anyway and that we really didn’t quite have the
information to have these summer and winter groups to
be so definite, and in fact I don’t believe we ever ran a
summer winter salmon curves after this. I’m not totally
[56] sure about that.
| And we don’t — at least when I left Washington State
Fisheries we weren’t recommending their use. We kind of
57
collapsed the whole juvenile preference curve into one
preference curve for both coho and chinook juveniles,
and we don’t usually give it a lot of weight in analysis,
even though from snorkeling I believe that there’s a dif-
ference in behavior between coho and chinook. It’s just
my opinion that there isn’t enough data to do this.
So this is sort of the last time we had this ornate
summer and winter thing. The reason that I - I think the
reason we originally looked at summer juveniles was
because we figured if they were out they would be active
and less acting like a summer fish. I think that’s the
reasoning. But in any case that was not terribly highly
weighted in our analysis.
Q. In using winter or summer curves, would it have
changed the ultimate flow recommendation for January if
you had used summer or winter preference curves for
coho and chinook juveniles?
A. No, for two reasons. Because of our higher
weight on coho spawning, which I already talked about,
and because of the fact that we were trying to keep a
reasonably steady minimum flow regime across the
months that they [57] were in incubation in order to not
allow spawning say at one flow and then drop it really
far the next month and possibly risk drying up eggs or
something like that.
So because of the two needs for flow regime stability
and spawning and prioritizing for spawning species, I
don’t think it would have changed, no.
Q. Okay. Why don’t we go on to February?
58
A. January and February were the two most diffi-
cult months to deal with, February in particular because
there wasn’t spawning species in the way we'd arrayed
our timing charts. There wasn’t a spawning species to
prioritize for; therefore, we took the peak of the steelhead
juvenile curve, we used the winter curve on Department
of Game’s recommendation, and the peak of the coho,
chinook juvenile curve is in the summer curves on our
recommendation, and since they happen to be the same
flow, a hundred CFS, we said we will go with that.
We also made a determination that that drop from
140 to a hundred would probably not be a problem for
incubation, so we did look at that as well.
For March - should I go on?
Q. Go on to March.
A. For March the prioritizing was for steelhead
spawning, which needs 200 CFS. There’s - we figured
that there would be steelhead and salmon incubation but
that the [58] flows would be stable from 100 to 200, and
that also happened to give us pretty high predictions of
optimum weighted usable area for the juvenile species, so
we decided that the 200 was going to be fine.
For April, again 200 based on steelhead spawning
predictions. It gives 92 percent of optimum for the
salmon juveniles, and it also happens to give a hundred
percent of optimum for steelhead juveniles, which is sort
of a bonus.
Q. And was the 200 also adequate for incubation?
A. Yes, in our opinion.
59
Q. What is the final SPP all anadromous out-migra-
tion?
A. That means that during April all of the out-
migration occurs, and theoretically if you were going to
do a flow regime you would provide outflows. It’s not in
there because we think we could provide it with a mini-
mum flow. Obviously running the river project is not
going to do that, but it’s in there to remind us that that
has happened.
Q. So specific preference curves were not run for
the out-migration life stage?
A. No, no. That’s -
Q. Is it your opinion that 200 CFS would be ade-
quate for the out-migration?
A. No.
[59] Q. Then why was 200 recommended by the
agencies?
A. Because it maximized predictions for steelhead
spawning, and given that the hydro project isn’t going to
take the peak off the daily peak flows, that’s going to be
where the out-migration will occur.
Q. I am not sure I follow that. Could you explain
that in a little more detail?
A. Okay. This is the minimum flow regime (indicat-
ing). The flow events that out-migration is going to occur
at are going to be flow events that aren’t changed by the
hydro project, so they will be the high flow.
60
Q. Above the maximum machine capacity of 600
CFS?
A. That was the assumption I made, yes.
Q. Okay. Let’s move on to May.
A. For May we picked 200 CFS based on maximiz-
ing steelhead spawning. It also happens to give you a
hundred percent of the predicted optimum for steelhead
juveniles, which was nice.
Q. And again, was incubation considered in May?
A. Yes, in the sense that we were trying not to
bounce the flow regime around.
Q. Okay. June?
A. We said that the spring chinook would start com-
ing up the river in June. That’s what the adult holding
means, that there was a curve run or the theoretical
preference of [60] the fish that has to be in the river a few
months.
And the peak of the predicted weighted usable area
for adult holding happened to be 200 CFS, which also
happens to be the peak for steelhead spawning, so we
were able to maximize for both our adult life stages at the
same flow.
Q. And there are three more notations there in June.
Would you go over those?
A. Coho and chinook juveniles is at 92 percent of
the predicted weighted usable area. Salmon and steel-
head incubation is just there, so we remember that it’s in
the river and we need to not drop the flows too much
- a
et Rm ti A er te ie ae ee
61
below the flows that they were spawning at, and the out-
migration notation is there just so we remember that the
life stage is happening.
Q. Okay.
A. For July it’s the same as June. Our reasoning is
the same as June. I think everything is the same with the
exception of the out-migration flow.
Q. All right.
A. For August we picked the 200 CFS because of the
spring chinook adult holding curve. It also happens to
maximize for steelhead juveniles and doesn’t hurt coho
and chinook juveniles too much, but we picked it
basically based on the adult life stage.
[61] Q. Now, the holding, could you explain what is
going on at that stage with the fish? I mean, what are they
actually doing?
A. Hanging out.
Q. When do the spring chinook come into it?
A. We were assuming in this analysis that the
spring chinook would be in the river during June, July,
and August and they would start spawning in September,
which is basically entering the river and waiting for those
three months.
Q. Okay. September?
A. For September we decided that we would have
both spring chinook and fall chinook spawning as species
of concern. In this case if you pick the optimum for
62
spring chinook spawning, which was 150 CFS, fall chi-
nook was only 95. If you pick the optimum for fall
chinook spawning it had more affect on the spring chi-
nook predicted habitat. In other words, the — it was — oh,
boy.
Picking the spring chinook optimum affected fall chi-
nook less than picking the fall chinook optimum affecting
spring chinook, and for that reason and because of the
importance of the species we picked the spring chinook
optimum instead of the fall chinook optimum.
Q. Okay. And how about - how did we do for the
other life stages?
[62] A. The percentages are on there, and we
decided it wasn’t hurting them too much, or at least as far
as the predictions went, and the incubation flow is on
there so that we don’t drop the minimum flow for the
months later than that much below 150.
Q. Okay. Shall we move on to October?
A. For October we said that the life stages of prior-
ity would be fall chinook spawning and coho spawning.
We managed to get optimum and very close to optimum
at 140. That does not drop it too much below the spawn-
ing flows earlier in the year, so we said that would take
care of incubation. It also gives you reasonably high
predictions for the steelhead. The split between the sum-
mer juveniles and the winter juveniles was done at Game
Department’s recommendations and is in there for infor-
mation purposes.
Q. Okay. November?
- oot we he eR,
SP eA, 0M Ve eo «
63
A. November. Species of concern was coho spawn-
ing, which is predicted maximized at 140, and fall chi-
nook spawning, which gets close to maximum at 140. The
juvenile information is as you see, and since 140 is very
close to the minimum flows recommended for the rest of
the fall we decided that would take care of the incubation
requirements.
Q. Okay. And finally December.
[63] A. I think December is the same as November
with the exception of - we said the fall chinook would be
done and it would just be coho spawning as the species of
priority.
Q. And again, is incubation a concern at this time?
A. Yes, and we decided that since we weren't drop-
ping the flow too much from what it had been in the fall
that that would take care of that.
Q. I notice on Exhibit R-27 after each minimum flow
number it says in parentheses or natural flow. Could you
explain that?
A. It’s a common thing when we put together a
minimum flow recommendation, especially for a hydro
project that’s run on the river and not storage. What we
are requesting is the minimum flow, or if they don’t want
to provide the minimum flow they can provide the natu-
ral flow, which obviously in a hydro project is probably
going to be less than that. In other words, we are not
saying that they have to provide the minimum flow at all
costs, which you could say if the project had storage.
64
Q. Could you make clear one final time for me what
the percentage number refers to in the far right-hand
column in Exhibit R-27?
A. If the flow we picked for the recommended flow
is the same as the flow predicted by the IFIM model
output as [64] the best weighted usable area for that life
stage, if it’s the same it’s a hundred percent; if it’s less
than that it is whatever percentage that flow is of the
predicted optimum for that life stage.
Q. The predicted maximum weighted usable area?
A. Weighted usable area.
Q. I would like you to explain in a little more detail
what this Exhibit R-4 means and what these lines refer to.
A. Exhibit R-4 is a flow exceedence hydrograph for
the Dosewallips River, and it’s a blowup of one I drew,
and the numbers on the hydrograph we got at the Janu-
__ary,.1986 meeting from Hoscy and Associates, and it’s an
attempt to show the range of flows that occur at the
project intake.
It was to develop —- some of the information to
develop this hydrograph was from the real data on the
gauge at the Dosewallips River, and some of it was data
from the Duckabush and the Snoquamish River. I believe
that to be true. I was told that by Hosey’s engineer that
that was how they arrived at the hydrograph.
Q. Okay. On Exhibit Number 4, the column on the
left-hand side, what does that refer to?
A. The column on the left-hand side is cubic feet
per second, and it’s a semi-lock scale so that in order to
ee ae
Sane
ee ee 2 ee ee oe ee oS
ee
ee
65
get the range of flows necessary to show this hydrograph
[65] you -
Q. And could you explain again the 90, 50, and 10
percent numbers that are on the right-hand column?
A. They refer to flow exceedence values, which are
generated by taking by month all the daily flows in that
month and ranking them by size. The 90 percent exceed-
ence value is that flow that is equal or exceeded 90
percent of the time.
Q. Under natural conditions?
A. Under natural conditions, and can be seen in
your mind as a very low flow. The 10 percent exceedence
flow is that flow that has met or exceeded 10 percent at
the time and it can be seen as a flood flow, just for, well, if
you want to simplify it.
This is a kind of typical hydrograph for a glacial
stream in the sense that it has two peaks to it, one during
the rainy season in the winter and one during the snow
melt season later in the spring.
Q. Okay.
MR. HARRISON: Excuse me, Mr. Manning,
does that 50 percent exceedence line on Exhibit R-4 corre-
spond to the left-hand column on Exhibit A-21 that we
have been calling 50 percent exceedence?
MR. MANNING: Yes, it does.
MR. HARRISON: Thank you.
66
[66] (Pause in proceedings.)
Q. (By Mr. Manning) Could you generally charac-
terize the agency flow proposal as it relates to this
exceedence table?
A. The numbers generated from an IFIM or PHAB-
SIM computer model are generated by the computer
model on the flows that you ask it to analyze, and it’s
done without reference to whether or not that flow occurs
in the stream and how often. So that the results from an
IFIM computer model have got to be evaluated critically
against hydrographic, hydrologic statistics in some way
or another.
There’s different ways to do it. I like flow exceedence
hydrographs for a lot of reasons to do that because they
give you a real good idea of the range of conditions as
well as the time of flows. There’s several reasons to do
that. The main reason is if you’re in an agency situation
and you’re asking for a minimum flow it’s real helpful if
you don’t come in there asking for the 10 percent exceed-
ence flow as the minimum flow. There’s a way to - it
helps you check the computer predictions against some
representation of the reality of what’s going on in the
stream.
In this case, because we lad generated our flow
recommendations before we had the hydrologic statistics
[67] from the consultant, when we compared the two, I
personally was a little surprised at how low our flow
recommendations were in relation to the flow exceed-
ence. And I would characterize them as in most months
being at or below the 90 percent exceedence flow except
67
for the late summer months when they approach the 50
percent exceedence level.
Q. And the agency flows are represented on Exhibit
R-4 by the blue block of color?
A. Right.
MR. MANNING: That is all the questions that I
have.
MR. HARRISON: Thank you, Mr. Manning.
Mr. Frymire?
MR. FRYMIRE: I have no questions, Your
Honor.
MR. HARRISON: Cross-examine, please.
EXAMINATION
BY MR. BUBENIK:
Q. Do you mind if I call you Jean?
A. No.
Q. Can you, Jean, tell us the goals and policies of
the Department of Fisheries in making instream flow
recommendations like you did in this for this proposed
project?
[68] A. If you want the policy word-for-word I can’t
quote it. I can tell you what my understanding of it was.
Q. Yes, tell us what your understanding is, please.
A. To recommend a minimum flow that would as
far as possible meet the agency’s goals on preserving,
protecting, and enhancing a fisheries resource.
68
Q. Are the Department of Fisheries’ goals and poli-
cies very similar to the Department of Game's with
respect to your, well, what you just said are your goals
and policies?
A. It’s my understanding they are, but I can’t quote
you the Department of Fisheries’ policy word-for-word
on that.
Q. It’s my recollection your testimony started on
this proposed project as far as your involvement in June
of 1985?
A. April, 1985. There was a site visit in March of
1985 with a member of the instream flow team that I was
aware of because I know they knew I had the job at
Fisheries, and they were aware that’s how this site visit
was handled.
MS. BENDOR: Could you speak up, Ms. Cald-
well?
THE WITNESS: (Witness nods affirmatively.)
MS. BENDOR: Thank you.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) This one meeting which you
talked about where these assumptions were made before
you came to your proposed flow recommendations, did
you state that you and [69] Hal made those assumptions?
A. I don’t - no, I don’t think I stated that.
Q. Who was directly involved in making those
assumptions?
A. At the meeting where we started generating the
flow regime the people that were there were Hal and
69
Elaine Rybak and myself. Over the three or four months
when the agency and tribal resource people were discuss-
ing the flow regime it’s my recollection that all of us
discussed those assumptions and were aware of them.
Q. But you told us about I think six factors or
conversations, assumptions.
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Can you tell me when each one of these assump-
tions was made and who was present?
A. I don’t know if I can do that. The -
Q. Was it one meeting, or was it, as you said, at
several different meetings?
A. It’s my recollection that the assumptions and our
comfort with them was developed over the three or four
months that we were developing the agency recommen-
dations then.
Y. So by telling us about these assumptions at this
time, what you are doing is going back what, from mem-
ory or your notes?
A. (Witness nods affirmatively.)
Q. Do you have any notes with respect to each of
these [70] assumptions?
A. I’m going back from notes I took at the time and
also notes I made for the class we taught in January of ‘86
when I was a little bit closer to the issue because in that
class the Dosey was the case study that we presented, so |
had done somewhat - I had done some of the summary
work already because I was trying to - we had developed
70
the Dosey «» 1 case study for this class that we gave to
the agency *ivlogists, so I had that summary that I had
done for that as well.
Q. How much involvement did the Department of
Ecology have in making these assumptions that you have
stated?
A. It’s my recollection that there was a set of us
involved in discussing these assumptions and developing
the flow recommendations and that Brad was one of
those people of the group.
MR. MANNING: Brad being who?
, THE WITNESS: Brad Caldwell, who was work-
ing for Department of Ecology.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) But I think you earlier testified
that Hal, Elaine, and yourself were involved in -
a MR. BENDOR: I am losing you on first names,
olks.
MR. BUBENIK: Excuse me, I am sorry.
MR. BENDOR: I mean, I just have to think a
[71] little harder. It’s difficult.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) I believe you testified earlier
that Hal Beecher, Elaine Rybak, and yourself were ini-
tially involved in making the assumption, is that correct?
A. That's - we were involved in the meeting of June
10th, 1985 where we first developed - we were not the
only people involved the rest of that summer and fall.
Q. Can you tell us about the dates on the next
meetings or telephone conversations?
wi) sees ee ee ee ee
71
A. I have notes from a meeting August 30th, 1985
where my notes say we discussed the flow recommenda-
tion.
Q. Who was present at that meeting?
A. My notes say that Elaine Rybak from U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service, Al Gross from the National Marine
Fisheries Service, Steve Ralph from Point No Point Treaty
Council, Brad Caldwell from Ecology, and myself and
Ken Bruya from Department of Fisheries were present.
Q. And do you know how many of these assump-
tions were discussed and finalized at that meeting?
MR. MANNING: I am going to object to this
line of questioning. The Department of Ecology has
required the flow regime in question and is obviously
satisfied with the assumptions that went into it, and
apparently the implication of these questions are that
somehow Ecology was unaware of them or did not
approve [72] them.
I think that the proof is in the pudding. We have
required these flows, and that is the only evidence we
need that Ecology has accepted those assumptions.
MR. HARRISON: Do you wish to reply?
MR. BUBENIK: From Ms. Caldwell’s testimony
it appears that Ecology may have only been minimally
involved, and Ecology is trying to I think tell us that they
were involved, and I question whether that was actually
the case.
MR. MANNING: Well, even if Mr. Bubenik is
right, so what?
72
MR. HARRISON: I will sustain the objection
because the flows have been adopted by the department,
and they therefore are being reviewed on that basis.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) Jean, you talked about Exhibit
R-27, and you may recall about the first of December at
your deposition I believe you handed us a copy of this, an
earlier draft of this document; is that correct?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And on this earlier draft on the right-hand col-
umn are the letters NA opposite coho slash chinook incu-
bation -
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. (Continuing) as contrasted with the letters NC,
which are on the Exhibit R-27?
[73] A. Mm-hmm.
Q. What do the letters NA stand for?
A. They stood for not applicable.
Q. And the letters NC, what do they stand for?
A. Not calculated.
Q. Have the agencies changed their position with
respect to coho/chinook as not being applicable as con-
trasted with not calculated?
A. No.
Q. What is the position?
A. This document that you have was a - this docu-
ment that he has was a working draft circulated to the
73
agency biologists working on the Elkhorn project to doc-
ument and help us remember some of the assumptions
and things that we had worked out with regard to this
project because there’s a lot of instream flow projects and
a lot of recommendations.
I put it together and sent it out for comment. I said
NA because the IFIM computer model does not calculate
incubation flows. It was not - and one of the comments I|
got back on this draft was that it’s not NA. It’s not not
applicable. That was bad terminology. And so it’s not
calculated is a little bit more clear, and it really reflects
the refinement of this document, which that is.
[74] Q. Are there other changes from this draft that
we see on December Ist, 1987?
A. Yes.
Q. Can you tell us about those other changes?
A. We corrected a math error in January and
November and December for calculations of the percent
of optimum predicted for steelhead winter juveniles. We
had calculated 97, and it is in fact 94 percent of optimum
predicted weighted usable area. We added calculations
for steelhead juveniles to the months of April, May, June,
and July because they had been inadvertently left off, and
we added calculations for the percent of optimum pre-
dicted for using the winter coho and chinook juvenile
curves to January, February, March, November, and
December for completeness because we knew that that
would be discussed in this hearing.
I believe that’s all the changes.
74
Q. Was a copy of this draft or the Exhibit R-27 ever
provided to the applicant’s consultant?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Were the agencies’ concerns over some of these
life stages ever discussed or written to the applicant's
consultant?
A. Could you ask the question again?
Q. Were the agencies’ concerns over these various
life [75] stages that you have listed on this revised draft
communicated to the applicant’s consultant?
A. We have had many conversations about the
Elkhorn project between 1985 and 1987, and I believe we
discussed the issue quite often.
Q. Do you have any data or anything to support
your statement that summer curves better describe winter
behavior on juvenile coho in the bypass reach?
A. Your question is do I have any data?
Q. Yes, or anything to support your statement and
conclusion that summer curves better describe winter
behavior of juvenile coho in the bypass reach.
A. No, that’s a professional judgment call based on
reading the literature and my own feelings about how the
computer model works.
MS. BENDOR: Excuse me. Volume, please.
THE WITNESS: Excuse me.
That’s a professional judgment call based on reading
the literature and my own conclusions about how the
computer model works.
75
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) Does the potential habitat data
for summer coho juveniles peak at a higher low than the
data on winter coho juveniles?
MS. BENDOR: Sir, if it’s - well, I am having a
hard time getting the questions, and if there is a [76] chart
you are referring to or a table that is fine, but I am having
a hard time tracking the question.
A. (Pause) There’s an - I think there’s an exhibit in
the record that has this stuff graphed out, and it would be
nice if I could use it.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) What is that? Is that A-11?
A. It’s not marked. It’s A-11. This may help.
Q. I believe my question related to do the juvenile
summer curves reflect a higher flow requirement than the
juvenile winter preference curves for coho?
A. It looks like it, yes.
MR. BUBENIK: I have no further questions.
MR. HARRISON: All right. Thank you, Mr.
Bubenik.
At this point we will recess for lunch and reconvene
at 1:15, please.
(Recess.)
MR. HARRISON: We will be in order, please.
Mr. Bubenik, have you finished your cross-examina-
tion?
MR. BUBENIK: Yes, I have.
76
MR. HARRISON: All right. Are there any ques-
tions of the Board of Ms. Caldwell?
MR. FAULK: No questions on my part.
MR. HARRISON: Ms. Bendor?
[77] EXAMINATION
BY MS. BENDOR:
Q. Yes, Ms. Caldwell. I missed one of Mr. Bubenik’s
questions on cross-examination just towards the end, and
your answer was something about it was the result of my
professional judgment rather than data. Do you recall
what you were answering in response to? If not I can -
A. I think it was why we made the recommenda-
tions to move off of the winter coho curves, and I think it
was — I think the question was did I have data to back
that up.
©. For which months?
A. He used them in general was the way I under-
stood the question.
Q. Okay. So the question was to use instead of the
spring coho -
A. To use the summer curves.
©. Use summer curves?
A. Right. That’s my best recollection.
Q. Okay. I am sure that on recross it will be clarified
if that is not the case.
77
I believe it was your testimony on cross-examination
that you had first seen the agency’s recommended flow
levels and then later on you had seen a hydrographic
chart I suppose with the agency flows shown on it or that
you superimposed -
[78] A. I superimposed them, yeah.
Q. (Continuing) and that you were surprised by
how low the agency flows were?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Did you have any resulting thoughts about those
low flows? That is, did you have any concerns or any-
thing that flowed from that which -
A. Yes. It indicated to me that perhaps we were not
recommending the best flow in there, and because if the -
that perhaps the flows recommended were too low.
Q. Too low for what, preservation?
Preservation and habitat.
Or enhancement?
Preservation.
0 >>
Did you in any way discuss those thoughts?
A. The agency and tribal biologists discussed that,
and I do know that when we were evaluating Tacoma’s
counter-proposal that that was also a reason that
strengthened our desire to stay with the agency for rec-
ommending flows, and we didn’t want to get any lower.
We were already concerned it might be too low.
Q. Did you ever communicate those concerns to the
applicant that perhaps the agency flows were too low?
78
A. I didn’t, no.
Q. Do you know if anybody in the agencies commu-
nicated that?
[79] A. I don’t know. I do remember comments like
look, we are giving you so much lower. Why should we
go any lower than the minimum flows? I believe there
were comments like that.
Q. Do you have any opinion as to where they might
be too low, which months? If you don’t have any opinion
that is also an answer.
A. I don’t have an opinion specifically by month.
It’s more the fact that a lot of the time our minimum flow
is below the 90 percent exceedence, below or at the 90
percent exceedence.
Q. Do you have any opinion where it might other-
wise be preserved or enhanced? If you don’t have an
opinion at this point that is also okay.
A. I have no way of knowing that.
Q. I believe it was your testimony in cross-examina-
tion — | want to make sure I understand it — that the
minimum flows set by the department are not necessarily
the flows that will be in the stream. Is that true?
A. That is correct.
Q. And is that because during peak flows the intake
pipe capacity for the proposed project can’t handle all the
volume and therefore there might be amounts going
downstream in excess of the pipe capacity plus the mini-
mum flows?
79
[80] A. That’s correct, and also because a lot of -
some of these projects use more than one turbine, and
they don’t necessarily have to have them all on at the
same, you know -
Q. Is the maximum amount that the project can take
out limited by the pipe capacity, or is there some other
factor that we should be aware of?
A. I don’t know if it’s limited by the pipe capacity
or the turbines, but it’s my understanding that it’s either
one or the other.
Q. Whichever is less?
Right.
Whichever can accommodate less? -
Right, right.
Do you know what the pipe capacity is?
No.
Or OP 0
Do you know what the turbine capacity is?
A. In what is Exhibit A-21, my notes on the copy
that I got at the meeting in January, ‘86 say machine flow
50 to 600 CFS, and so I assumed that that was the turbine
capacity.
Q. 50 to 600?
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Do you know if it was one or two turbines or
how many turbines?
A. I don’t know.
80
[81] Q. Is there any document that we have before
us now as an exhibit which would indicate what the
estimate of the actual flows would be given the realities
of the system capacity to withdraw or utilize?
A. I don’t understand.
Q. I am trying to understand what the real flows
will be in the stream understanding that the agency flows
are minimum but are not necessarily actual.
A. Oh, okay. Let’s see. Can | try to - can I try to
explain?
Q. Sure.
A. If the minimum flow is 200 and their minimum
machine flow is 50, the stream is flowing 200 or less, it
will be flowing 200. Between 200 and 249 it will be
flowing between 200 and 249. At 250 it will go back to 200
as they take the flow between 250, and if the top machine
flows 600, then it would be -
Q. I understand that.
I felt the question of if there were more than mini-
mum flow really comes in when you are talking about
high flows.
A. That and how they choose to run the power
project.
Q. Okay. Is there any way for me to understand
from the documents presented what the actual flows are
likely to be if the project is operationed?
81
[82] A. I could draw the hydrograph that I usually
draw when I’m usually trying to explain to a manager
what the -
Q. And that includes the capacity?
Yeah. I could try and draw that for you.
A
Q. If you believe it would be accurate.
A. I believe it would be a good example.
Q
Well -
A. Iam trying to do this -I know you want answers
quickly, but what -
Q. I am as concerned about the accuracy as the
quickness.
MR. HARRISON: All right. We wilfhavé a brief
recess at this point. I would like to speak with counsel,
please.
Go ahead, Ms. Caldwell.
(Recess.)
MR. HARRISON: All right. We will be in order,
please.
Now we are ready to resume your testimony, Ms.
Caldwell.
Ms. Bendor?
Q. (By Ms. Bendor) Yes, Ms. Caldwell, what I am
trying to find out is what is the actual flow going to be in
the stream. I understand that there are minimum flows
set, but that does not tell us what actually would be
occurring if the project were in place.
82
[83] A. Mm-hmm. What I’ve drawn here is a real
simplistic one-year daily flow hydrograph - I believe
there are a couple of them in evidence already — and that
is what the purple line is. So you can see that there would
be rain storms and rain events, and this is to indicate that
in the summer flow goes very low.
Q. Is the purple line a peak on a particular day, or is
it a median for the day, or -
A. It would be the daily flow, the peak on a particu-
lar day in this example, just for an example.
Q. So that is CFS?
A. CFS, cubic feet per second. So there’s both storm
events, high-flow events, and low-flow events on here.
The black line is meant to indicate a theoretical minimum
flow that’s been set for this stream for the theoretical
hydro project.
Q. That would be the agency’s recommended flow?
A. That would be the agency’s recommended flow.
Because of the range of flow events in a normal river, if
you were to put this on a real hydrograph the minimum
flow would be very low. It would be like down here, to
scale (indicating). It’s not to scale because I wanted to
make a couple points with it. It’s a little higher than the
minimum flow would appear usually.
Q. Are you drawing it straight, or logarithmically in
your [84] illustration?
A. Straight in this illustration.
Q. Okay.
83
A. The kind of salmon color is a theoretical hydro
project with some simplifying assumptions that it has got
one turbine that’s either on or off. It never breaks down.
It never goes off line. It’s whenever there’s water in the
river it will be operating. And I just did that to show you,
okay?
And because this one turbine has so much capacity it
only takes flow between here and here (indicating). So
the banner flow is the amount of water that would be
removed from the bypass reach during entire project
operation.
The couple points to make are that the storm events
will still be in the river. On this day - say if you were to
take this particular day — the flow in the river would be
the sum of the minimum flow and the flow from the
storm events put together. If you were to take this partic-
ular day, the flow in the river would be lower than the
minimum flow, and the power project would not be oper-
ating. That’s why these break and start again.
So the flow on a particular day is simply this flow
with this taken out of it (indicating).
Q. Okay. Now, my follow-up question then is does
that [85] additional sum above the salmon-colored draw-
ing -
A. Right.
Q. (Continuing) provide any additional measure of
protection or otherwise perhaps negative for the species
that you had intended to maximize at particular life
stages?
A. Does it -
84
Q. If you have an opinion on that.
A. It might or it might not. It just depends on the
species requirements. I can’t know that.
Q. Okay. Thank you.
Now, I have one or two more questions.
Regarding Exhibit R-27 what was the date that that
was finalized, if you know?
A. The date it was typed, or the date the informa-
tion was finalized in an agency sense?
Q. Well, I guess let me ask another question.
I am trying to understand - you had said something
that there was a difference between the draft version that
was attached to the deposition and the final version, and
at one point you said something about you added winter
chinook for January through March, November, Decem-
ber, for completeness —
A. Mm-hmm.
Q., (Continuing) because you knew it would be dis-
cussed at the hearing.
[86] A. Right.
Q. So am I to assume that R-27 was prepared after
the appeal was filed?
A. Right, the additions on R-27 were done after the
appeal was filed. This document | believe I generated in
typed form. This is the draft that we referred to. I believe
the date that this was — the date on it is January, 1987, and
I don’t know if that was before or after the appeal was
85
filed. I did this when I was still working for the Depart-
ment of Fisheries.
Q. So the document that was actually relied upon
for the agency decision would have been the draft R-27?
A. It would have been the draft R-27 and whatever
notes and work sheets people had developed over the
months we discussed this. This was an attempt to get in
nice, final typed form for the record what we had been
using.
Q. Okay. And one last question.
I missed something during your direct examination.
You said there were four assumptions made prior to
doing the final result, and you said, number one, if you
optimize for steelhcad, and I lost that.
A. We decided to make an assumption that if we
took care of the predicted habitat requirements for steel-
head that we would take care of whatever resident rain-
bow trout would be present.
[87] Q. Okay.
A. In other words, the other species that Depart-
ment of Game mentioned.
MS. BENDOR: Thank you. I have no further
questions.
MR. HARRISON: Mr. Manning, anything else?
86
FURTHER EXAMINATION
BY MR. MANNING:
Q. Ms. Caldwell, you expressed some concern in
your testimony that the flow regime required by the
agencies may not be enough, and I would just like to ask
your opinion on sort of the ultimate question in this case,
and that is, in your opinion, are the agency flows appro-
priate to protect the fish resource in the bypass reach?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know if it’s adequate?
A. No.
Q. Okay. And there were also some questions
regarding the use of so-called winter preference curves
for coho and chinook, juveniles.
A. (Witness nods affirmatively.)
Q. To your knowledge, do any of the agencies that
were involved in this case accept winter preference
curves for coho and chinook juvenile at this time?
[88] A. To my knowledge the agency recommenda-
tion is that those curves not be used.
MR. MANNING: Okay. That is all I have.
MR. HARRISON: Mr. Frymire?
MR. FRYMIRE: I have no questions.
MR. HARRISON: Mr. Bubenik?
87
FURTHER EXAMINATION
BY MR. BUBENIK:
Q. Ms. Caldwell, when did the agencies chart their
flow with relationship to the hydrograph, which I believe
is shown on your exhibit there by the door?
MR. BUBENIK: What is the number of that
exhibit, Jay?
MR. MANNING: R-4.
A. To the best of my recollection it was after the
meeting at the Tacoma Control Center on January 14th,
1986.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) Do your notes reflect when that
exhibit was made or something similar to that particular
exhibit?
A. Could you ask the question again?
Q. Do your notes reflect when that particular
Exhibit R-4 was created or something similar to that
particular exhibit?
A. No, I don’t have a date on it. That’s not -
Q. Do you recall when that particular diagram was
discussed? What was the exact date of the meeting you
mentioned?
[89] A. I’m sorry. Do -
Q. When was the date of the meeting when that
similar exhibit or diagram was discussed with the
agency?
88
A. I don’t have that. I just - I don’t have that
information. To the best of my knowledge it was after
January, 1986 when we were considering Tacoma’s coun-
ter-proposal.
Q. But the agency proposal was made in what,
November or October of 1985?
A. That’s correct.
* * *
* * ¢
[96] Q. Ms. Rybak, did your agency review the pro-
posed flows by the city of Tacoma?
A. Yes, we did.
Q. Did your agency as an agency reach any result or
conclusion on that?
A. Yes, we did. We - the conclusion that we reached
was that the flows would not be adequate to maintain the
fish [97] and the habitat present in that bypass reach.
MS. BENDOR: Thank you.
* * *
89
* + *
[109] Q. What was your personal opinion then as to
what flow regime should be required with regard to the
Elkhorn [110] project?
A. Well, if the cooperation of the Elkhorn hydro
project is given, then I felt comfortable with the agency
flow recommendations.
Q. What was the treaty council's intent in agreeing
to the agency flow regime?
A. To provide - our intent was to reduce the level of
risk to treaty council resources to the maximum extent
possible, that is, to provide a flow that we would feel
would under most conditions provide the kinds of habi-
tats necessary for the perpetuation of spring chinook,
steelhead, and coho in the bypass reach.
. * *
90
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON )
COUNTY and CITY OF )
TACOMA, DEPARTMENT OF )
PUBLIC UTILITIES, )
)
Appetante, ) PCHB NO. 86-118
Vs. )
DEPARTMENT OF )
ECOLOGY, DEPARTMENT )
OF WILDLIFE, and )
DEPARTMENT OF )
FISHERIES, |
)
)
Respondents.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
DAY FOUR
December 18, 1987
Lacey, Washington
KIM L. OTIS
Registered Professional Reporter
GENE BARKER & ASSOCIATES
406 Security Building
Olympia, Washington 98501
(206) 943-2693
[23] Q. Is there explanation also in the license appli-
cation as to the power generated and the need for the
power?
A. Well, there’s a section.
MR. MANNING: I am going to object to this
testimony based on hearsay. It doesn’t matter whether
this power is needed or not for the issues in this case.
MR. BUBENIK I think the maximum net bene-
fits test is an issue in the case, Your Honor.
MR. MANNING: The issue in the case is
whether or not as a legal issue we would be required to
go [24] through the maximum net benefits test. We did
not do that. The remedy if in case this board decides we
have to do that is remand with instructions telling Ecol-
ogy to go through the maximum net benefits test. I don’t
think this board is going to be able to go through the
maximum net benefits test for us.
MR. HARRISON: Well, I don’t intend to receive
evidence on feasibility in this proceeding and, therefore, I
will sustain the objection. However, there’s a related con-
cern that I think is appropriate for these proceedings and
that is — and if you don’t care to get into this, that’s fine, |
think I’ll probably raise it when I have a chance. And that
is we've had a lot of discussion about whether the agen-
cies have considered Tacoma’s flows and ultimately I'd
like to know whether the City has considered the agency
flows; in so doing, whether they made an ultimate judg-
ment that under the agency flow their proposal is feasible
or infeasible. Because if they had made a judgment that it
was feasible, I think that would have a lot to do with this
92
hearing. So at some point I want to get to that ultimate
question.
MR. MANNING: Judge Harrison, with all due
respect, I don’t think that issue is a part of this case.
Whether or not this project is feasible under the [25]
agency flow regime is clearly beyond the issues set forth
that were agreed to by the parties in the prehearing order.
The issues are what fish use the bypass reach and
whether the agency flows are appropriate to protect fish.
Whether or not Tacoma can build this project with the
agency flow regime I think is way beyond those issues
and it’s certainly beyond what I’m prepared to respond
to. None of us have dealt with that issue so far and I
think that would add a whole new realm to this case that
would take us months to prepare for.
MR. HARRISON: I’m not asking for something
to be offered for the truth thereof; I’m simply asking for
the verbal act as to whether or not Tacoma has made that
determination. And if they have made a determination
hypothetically that they could go ahead and build the
project anyway, then I think that reflects terrifically upon
the import of this case. It moots the case. Now if they say
otherwise, then it leaves it to another day and another
forum, but I would simply like the record to reflect
whether as a historical fact they made that determination.
Proceed.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) Could you address the ques-
tion that Mr. Harrison has posed?
A. I can’t. I try to avoid learning that information
because it could bias my presentation or my outlook on
[26] what flows I propose. If a project is unfeasible at
flows slightly higher than what we've proposed, that
93
would tend to influence me and I’d have to work hard
trying to avoid that bias of trying to strive more strongly
for a flow that maybe I wouldn’t have agreed to other-
wise. On the other hand, I try, | don’t want to know if the
proponent can get by with flows a lot higher than that,
because they would like to get as much energy and I like
to avoid conflict, so I would be biased.
. Another way of trying to say well, gee, guy, let’s not go
atter this fight for nothing, let’s just agree. I try not to get
involved with that aspect of it because I don’t want to be
biased one way or the other no matter what the outcome
was.
MR. HARRISON: Very well.
Q. (By Mr. Bubenik) So you do not know whether
Tacoma could feasibly construct the project with the
agencies’ proposed flows?
A. I know that analysis has been done, but I have
strictly told people that I work for that I don’t want to
know, so, sorry, Mark.
MR. BUBENIK: If the Board would like, I could
provide that with another witness if that testimony is
deemed to be relevant.
MR. HARRISON: Well, you’ve made that [27]
representation in your briefs earlier, if I recall correctly.
MR. BUBENIK: I don’t know whether I did or
not. I can’t recall if I made that representation or not. It
might be in the notice of appeal.
* * *
94
* * *
[60] Q. Now, I want to understand the mechanics of
the project just very briefly in terms of the flow that
would be remaining in the stream.
Q. Suppose the month required instream flows of
140. Is it true that at 190 cfs the flow in the river would
actually be 190 because the machines don’t turn on until
you say get to 51 cfs?
A. That is correct.
Q. But at 191 the flows in the stream would be 141
because the machines would kick on?
A. The flows in the stream would be 150, 140
because the machines would kick on.
Q. And they would take the 50 plus the one?
A. That is correct.
Q. So there’s some sort of funny discontinuity
where a certain point it suddenly drops down?
A. Correct.
Q. Now let me ask you, suppose you have that kind -
of daily fluctuation in low summer flow period? If you
want to [61] put up R-3, feel free. What does that do to
the possible incubation of eggs that are out there when
you have a sudden flow drop during the day or between
days where you have that occur? I’m talking now about a
daily or variation within a month.
* Yes. If you had that kicking on and kicking off
every day, it would have an impact on fisheries, not only
on incubation but perhaps other life stages. The thing is
95
you can’t operate a project turning it on and off that
often, the equipment wouldn’t stand up. So they look at
building the equipment and sizing it to the river so that it
achieves what they call a plant factor so that it’s on most
of the time. That’s why we say during September we
probably wouldn’t even be operating because we can’t,
you know - let’s say a couple days it goes up in Septem-
ber, you don’t want to turn it on for a couple of days. It’s
not worth it. There’s too much wear on the equipment.
Q. Let me ask you, is there anything in the docu-
ments or exhibits presented to us that clearly specify
those kind of operating limitations so that we wouldn’t
have the kind of kicking on and kicking off when you
went right over the 50 plus the cfs flow required in the
stream?
A. There’s nothing in this document, no.
Q. So we don’t know one way or the other as to a
certainty when they kick on and when they kick off and
for how long [62] and how much of a drop?
A. You don’t know that, no, that is correct, and
there is no way of you knowing that from this document.
Q. Or from any other exhibits presented to us?
A. So far, no. It hasn’t really been an issue and the
FERC people generally understand enough about it and
we can present that easily enough, it’s easy to put it
together and we can do it on a daily flow regime.
* * *
96
[72] MR. HARRISON: I have one final point to
raise. Mr. Bubenik, | will address my question to you as
counsel for the Appellant. What I am speaking to is not
any piece of evidence, but in reference to your notice of
appeal, and I ask you whether you have a copy of that
notice of appeal?
MR. BUBENIK: Yes.
MR. HARRISON: Now, on page 3 of your
notice of appeal you have set forth as one of the grounds
for appeal at paragraph 4, subparagraph D, as follows:
[Reading] Department’s decision is unjust or arbitrary
and capricious and will result in substantial economic
loss to the PUD and Tacoma because to satisfy the
requested minimum flows will result in a total inability to
proceed with this project, period, end quote.
Is that the position that the Appellants are taking in
this matter?
MR. BUBENIK: Yes, it is, Your Honor.
MR. HARRISON: Now, have the Appellants
conducted any actual analysis of the Department's mini-
mum flows before entering this pleading in this matter?
MR. BUBENIK: I do not know for certain. How-
ever, it’s my recollection that I was clearly advised that,
yes, they had analyzed the proposed flows and based —
upon that found that the project would not be [73] eco-
nomically feasible.
97
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL HEARING
BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON ) PCHB NO. 86-118
COUNTY AND CITY OF > heneenes on
TACOMA, DEPARTMENT OF )_~— cuppLEMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES, ) aaee SRARING
Appellants, . RECORD TO
ADD
* | ‘ ECONOMIC
STATE OF WASHINGTON, ) _ FEASIBILITY
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY, —}_ INFORMATION
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES and }
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE
Respondent )
)
COMES NOW the Appellant City of Tacoma and
respectfully requests that the attached Affidavit Pertain-
ing to Project Feasibility be included in the hearing
record for this matter. This information was suggested to
be provided, presumably, so that the Board could fully
evaluate the maximum net benefits analysis and argu-
ment.
DATED this 4th day of February, 1988.
ROBERT J. BACKSTEIN
WILLIAM J. BARKER
MARK L. BUBENIK
G. S. KARAVITIS
By /s/ Mark Bubenik
Mark L. Bubenik
Of Attorneys for Appellant,
City of Tacoma
98
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL HEARING
BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON ) PCHB NO. 86-118
COUNTY AND CITY OF )
TACOMA, DEPARTMENT OF ) AFFIDAVIT
PUBLIC UTILITIES PERTAINING
) TO PROJECT
Appellants, } FEASIBILITY
v. )
STATE OF WASHINGTON, )
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY, )
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES and ?
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE ‘
Respondent )
)
STATE OF WASHINGTON )
) ss.
County of Pierce )
Garth Jackson, being first duly sworn on oath,
deposes and says:
1. That I am a professional electrical engineer
licensed by the State of Washington and employed by the
City of Tacoma, Department of Public Utilities, Light
Division.
2. That I have reviewed the economic feasibility
information provided by our consulting engineers, Hosey
& Associates, pertaining to the proposed Elkhorn project.
99
3. That the cost (in mills per Killowatt hour) is as
follows:
Applicants’ Agencies
COST (mills/Kwh) Compromise Flows Flows
Average flow 47 56
Firm 100 199
Secondary 15 15
4. Normally, when evaluating project economic fea-
sibility the firm power cost is a primary concern.
Instream flows required by the Agencies are withdrawn
from the reliable or firm power generation leaving only
the less reliable secondary power. Therefore, since the
Applicants’ firm power cost is already at the economic
threshold of 100 mills/Kwh, the proposed project would
not be economically feasible at the Agencies’ proposed
flows.
Further sayeth the affiant naught,
/s/ Garth Jackson
Garth Jackson
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 4th day of
February, 1988.
/s/ Mark Bubenik
Notary Public in and for the State
of Washington, residing at Gig Har-
bor
100
BEFORE THE POLLUTION
CONTROL HEARINGS BOARD
STATE-OF WASHINGTON
PCHB NO. 86-118
MEMORANDUM
IN OPPOSITION
TO MOTION TO
SUPPLEMENT
THE HEARING
RECORD
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON
COUNTY AND CITY OF
TACOMA, DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC UTILITIES,
Appellants,
V.
STATE OF WASHINGTON,
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES and
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE
Respondent
Nem mee ee ee ee ee ee ee”
The Department of Ecology has received the City of
Tacoma’s “Motion to Supplement The Hearing Record To
Add Economic Feasibility Information.” Ecology opposes
adding this information to the record in this matter.
Ecology recognizes that the information was pro-
vided at the request of the Board. However, the informa-
tion should not and cannot be made a part of the record.
The information in question consists of an affidavit of
Mr. Garth Jackson. Mr. Jackson did not testify at the
hearing in this matter and therefore was not subject to
cross-examination. Moreover, the prehearing order in this
case was explicit as to the issues before the Board. Those
issues were, to paraphrase, whether Ecology’s flow reg-
ime is appropriate for protecting fish, and what fish
101
utilize the bypass reach. The project’s economic fea-
sibility is of no relevance to either one of these issues.
Finally, the information in question is not necessary
to resolve Tacoma’s contention that the maximum net
benefits test must be utilized in this case. That question is
a purely legal one, and whether or not the project is
feasible with Ecology’s flow regime has no bearing what-
soever on the resolution of that issue.
For all of these reasons, Ecology urges that Tacoma’s
motion to supplement the hearing record be denied.
DATED this 10 day of February, 1988.
KENNETH O. EIKENBERRY
Attorney General
/s/ Jay J. Manning
JAY J. MANNING
Assistant Attorney General
Ecology Division- M/S PV-11
Olympia, WA 98504
(206) 459-6158
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, BECKY WALDRON, certify that on the 11th day of
February, 1988, I mailed a true and correct copy of a
Ecology’s Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Sup-
plement the Hearing Record to the following persons at
the following addresses:
Mark L. Bubenik
Assistant City Attorney
P.O. Box 11007
Tacoma, WA 98411
102
William C. Frymire
Assistnat Attorney General
M/S PB-73
Olympia, WA 98504-8071
/s/ Becky Waldron
Becky Waldron
103
BEFORE THE POLLUTION CONTROL HEARINGS
BOARD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON PCHB No. 86-118
COUNTY, AND CITY OF
TACOMA, DEPARTMENT OF Caen
PUBLIC UTILITIES DENYING
: MOTION TO
Appellants, SUPPLEMENT
. HEARING
, RECORD
STATE OF WASHINGTON
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY
Respondents,
and
STATE OF WASHINGTON
DEPARTMENT OF WILDLIFE
DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES
Intervenors.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
On February 4, 1988, appellant, City of Tacoma, filed
its Motion to Supplement the Hearing Record to Add
Economic Feasibility Information.
On February 12, 1988, respondent Washington State
Department of Ecology filed its Memorandum in Opposi-
tion.
Economic feasibility information is not relevant to
the subject of base flows which this matter presents.
Economic feasibility information may have been germane
to settlement discussions among the parties, and refer-
ence to the same was suggested solely for that purpose.
104
Wherefore, the motion is denied.
DONE at Lacey, Washington this 29th day of June,
1988.
POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD
/s/ William A. Harrison
WILLIAM A. HARRISON
Administrative Appeals Judge
105
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF THURSTON
PUD NO. 1 of Jefferson
County, and City of
Tacoma Department of Cause No.
Public Utilities, 89-2-00413-2
on, CERTIFICATE
V.
STATE OF WASHINGTON,
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY,
Respondent.
i
THIS IS TO CERTIFY that the material transmitted
herewith are originals or true and exact copies of original
documents and exhibits compiled by the Pollution Con-
trol Hearings Board relating to the hearing conducted on
the above-referenced matter (PCHB No. 86-118) and that
the written material transmitted herewith constitutes the
entire record considered by the Board in reaching its
decision in this matter.
DATED this 17th day of March, 1989.
/s/ Robyn Bryant
Robyn Bryant, Clerk of the
POLLUTION CONTROL
HEARINGS BOARD
106
PCHB No. 86-118
PUD NO. 1 of Jefferson County & City of Tacoma v.
Department of Ecology, Department of Fisheries &
Department of Wildlife Thurston County Cause No.
89-2-00413-2
DOCUMENTS
Notice of Appeal
Request for Formal Hearing &
Certificate of Mailing
Motion to Compel Answers to
Interrogatories and Affidvit in
Support of Motion to Compel
Answers to Interrogatories
Order Compelling Answers to
Interrogatories and
Certification of Mailing
Order Continuing Hearing and
Setting Date for Motion Reply
City of Tacoma’s Motion for
Summary Judgment,
Memorandum in Support of
Motion for Summary
Judgment, including affidavits
of Philip Hilgert and Eugene
Welch
Statement of Additional
Authorities
Received July 11, 1986
Received July 22, 1986
Received November 20,
1986
Dated December 1, 1986
Dated January 8, 1986
Received December 12,
1986
Dated January 22, 1987
107
Cross Motion for Summary
judgment, Memorandum in
Opposition to the City of
Tacoma’s Motion for Summary
Judgment and in Support of
Ecology’s Cross Motion for
Summary Judgment, Affidavit
of Brad Caldwell, Affidavit of
Walter Bergstrom, Affidavit of
Kenneth J. Bruya, Affidavit of
Hal Beecher, and Certificate of
Mailing
Memorandum in Reply to
DOE’s Memorandum in
Opposition to City of Tacoma
and Affidavit of Phil Hilgert
Order Granting Cross Motion
for Summary Judgment
Motion for Reconsideration
Order Retaining and
Modifying Summary
Pre-Hearing Order
City of Tacoma’s Second
Motion for Summary
Judgment
City’s Supplemental
Memorandum in Support of
Motion for Summary
Judgment
City of Tacoma’s List of
Witnesses and Exhibits
Dated January 28, 1987
Dated February 4, 1987
Dated April 10, 1987
Received April 17, 1987
Dated May 26, 1987
Dated June 29, 1987
Received November 3,
1987
Received November 10,
1987
Received November 12,
1987
108
Motion to Compel Answers to
Interrogatories and Compliance
with Pretrial Order and
Affidavit in Support of Motion
to Compel
Department of Ecology’s
Second Cross Motion for
Summary Judgment
Motion to Compel Answers to
Interrogatories or in Lieu
Thereof Sanctions and Second
Set of Interrogatories -
Submitted to the Department
of Ecology for Response and
Request for Production of
Documents
Order Denying and Granting
Motion to Compel Answers to
Interrogatories
Motion to Intervene
Order Granting Intervention
Motion for Reconsideration of
Order Granting Intervention
Second Order Granting
Intervention
Hearing Memorandum
Department of Ecology’s Trial
Brief
Order Denying Second Motion
for Summary Judgment
Received November 12,
1987
Received November 13,
1987
Received November 18,
1987
Dated November 30,
1987
Received December 1,
1987
Dated December 2, 1987
Received December 7,
1987
Dated December 7, 1987
Received December 8,
1987
Received December 8,
1987
Dated December 9, 1987
109
Motion to Strike and Motion
in Limine
Hearing Memorandum
(Revised)
Order Denying Motion to
Strike and Motion in Limine
Final Trial Memorandum
Motion to Supplement the
Hearing Record to Economic
Feasibility Information
Closing Argument
Memorandum in Opposition to
Motion to Supplement the
Hearing Record
Order Denying Motion to
Supplement the Hearing
Record
Final Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law and Order
and statement by member
Judith A. Bendor
Dissenting Opinion of Judith
A. Bendor
Petition for Reconsideration,
Memorandum in Support of
Petition for Reconsideration,
and Affidavit of Kenneth O.
Slattery
Appellant City of Tacoma’s
Memorandum in Opposition to
Petition for Reconsideration
Received December 10,
1987
Received December 14,
1987
Dated December 15,
1987
Received February 4,
1988
Received February 4,
1988
Received February 4,
1988
Received February 21,
1988
Dated June 29, 1988
Dated June 29, 1988
Dated July 15, 1988
Dated July 7, 1988
Received July 13, 1988
110
Revised Final Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law and Order
and Dissenting Opinion
Petition for Review of the
Decision of the Pollution
Control Hearings Board in
PCHB No. 86-118 and
Affidavit of Service
Cross Petition for Review of
Pollution Control Hearings
Board Decision No. 86-118
dated January 25, 1989 and
Affidavit of Service
Dated January 25, 1989
Received February 24,
1989
Received March 1, 1989
Original Transcript of Proceedings,
Day One
Day Two
Day Three
Day Four
Dated December 15,
1987
Dated December 16,
1987
Dated December 17,
1987
Dated December 18,
1987
CORRESPONDENCE
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Faulk
Letter to Board from Jay J.
Manning
Letter to Mr. Manning from
Mr. Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Dated July 10, 1986
Dated July 11, 1986
Dated July 16, 1986
Dated October 29, 1986
Dated October 27, 1986
111
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Faulk
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Mr. Manning from
Mr. Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Faulk
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from
Mr.Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Dated October 31, 1986
Received November 20,
1986
Dated December 3, 1986
Dated December 11,
1986
Dated December 30,
1986
Dated January 8, 1987
Dated January 16, 1987
Dated January 22, 1987
Dated January 26, 1987
Dated January 28, 1987
Dated January 29, 1987
Dated January 30, 1987
Dated February 4, 1987
Dated April 10, 1987
Dated April 16, 1987
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Frymire
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
112
Dated April 17, 1987
Dated May 26, 1987
Dated June 3, 1987
Dated June 29, 1987
Dated November 1, 1987
Dated November 6, 1987
Dated November 9, 1987
Dated November 10,
1987
Dated November 13,
1987
Dated November 18,
1987
Dated November 18,
1987
Dated November 30,
1987
Dated November 30,
1987
Dated December 2, 1987
Dated December 4, 1987
113
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning together with Draft
of Washington State Fisheries
Hydroelectric Project
Assessment Guidelines
Letter to Board from from Mr.
Bubenik togetherwith copy of
settlement agreement in
Northwest Steelehead, et al. v.
City of Tacoma and DOE
Letter to Board from Mr.
Bubenik
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Letter to Parties from Mr.
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr.
Manning
Dated December 7, 1987
Dated December 8, 1987
Dated December 8, 1987
Dated December 9, 1987
Dated December 9, 1987
Dated December 11,
1987
Dated December 23,
1987
Dated December 23,
1987
Dated January 15, 1988
Dated February 4, 1988
Dated February 10, 1988
Dated June 29, 1988
Dated July 7, 1988
114
Letter to Parties from Mr. Dated July 7, 1988
Harrison
Letter to Board from Mr. Dated July 12, 1988
Bubenik
Letter to Parties from Mr. Dated July 18, 1988
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr. Dated July 28, 1988
Harrison
Letter to Parties from Mr. Dated January 25, 1989
Harrison
. * *
Certificate of Dan R. Quaintance,
Court Reporter
Deposition of Hal Beecher Dated December 2, 1987
Deposition of Kenneth Joseph
Bruya Dated December 7, 1987
Deposition of Brad Caldwell, Dated December 7, 1987
Volume One, Volume Two,
and Volume Three
115
No. 58272-6
SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
P.U.D. #1 OF JEFFERSON COUNTY
and CITY OF TACOMA,
Appellants,
v.
DEPARTMENTS OF ECOLOGY, FISHERIES, and
WILDLIFE Departments of the State of Washington,
Respondents.
ANSWER OF RESPONDENTS
TO STATEMENT OF GROUNDS FOR DIRECT REVIEW
BY THE SUPREME COURT
KENNETH O. EIKENBERRY
Attorney General
JAY J. MANNING, WSBA #13579
Assistant Attorney General
(206) 459-6158
WILLIAM C. FRYMIRE,
WSBA #16551
Assistant Attorney General
(206) 586-2428
State of Washington
Departments of Ecology,
Fisheries and Wildlife
116
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE
STATE OF WASHINGTON
P.U.D. #1 OF JEFFERSON _) No. 58272-6
COUNTY and CITY OF ) ANSWER OF
TACOMA, RESPONDENTS TO
Appellants, STATEMENT OF
GROUNDS FOR DIRECT
— REVIEW BY THE
DEPARTMENTS OF SUPREME COURT
ECOLOGY, FISHERIES,
and WILDLIFE,
Departments of the State
of Washington,
Respondents.
ee eee eee eee”
INTRODUCTION
The Respondents herein (referred to as the Agencies)
hereby answer the Appellants’ previously filed Statement
of Grounds for Direct Review by the Supreme Court.
While the Agencies disagree with much of what is stated
in the Appellants’ Statement, it is agreed that direct
review by the Supreme Court is appropriate in this case.
Under Rule of Appellate Procedure 4.2(a)(4) one of
the types of cases appropriate for direct review is one
which involves “a fundamental and urgent issue of broad
public import which requires prompt and ultimate deter-
mination.” The Agencies believe that the issues presented
in this case fall directly into this category, and therefore
urge the court to grant direct review.
117
This case involves the Appellants’ proposal to con-
struct and operate a hydroelectric project on the Dos-
ewallips River which will remove most of the water from
the affected portion of the river for most of the year. The
issue here is how much water is to be left in the river.
With this background, there are two primary reasons that
direct review is appropriate here.
The first is that the outcome of this case will, in all
likelihood, determine whether chinook and coho salmon
and steelhead trout will be able to continue to use the
affected portion of the Dosewallips River. Obviously, this
is a fundamental and urgent issue of broad public import.
Second, the outcome of this case will determine whether
the Department of Ecology will continue to have the
ability to ensure that hydroelectric projects do not violate
state water quality laws, or whether, on the other hand,
Ecology will be relegated to an advisory role only; with
the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission making all
final decisions regarding hydroelectric development in
the state.
NATURE OF THE CASE
As stated in Appellants’ Statement of Grounds for
Direct Review, the Appellants, in response to a require-
ment by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
(FERC) applied for a water quality certificate from the
Department of Ecology (Ecology). A water quality certi-
fication is required under § 401 of the federal Clean Water
Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1341, for any applicant for a federal
license where the project requiring the federal license will
result in a discharge to waters of the state.
118
A water quality certificate, which is issued by the
state, is essentially a written determination that the dis-
charge at issue will not violate state water quality stan-
dards. If the discharge will violate water quality
standards, the certification should be denied. In addition,
a state may impose conditions in a certification to ensure
compliance with state water quality standards and with
“any other appropriate requirement of state law.” 33
U.S.C. § 1341(d).
In this case Ecology determined, after consultation
with state, federal and tribal natural resource agencies,
that the certification could only be issued with a condi-
tion designed to protect a fundamental component of the
water quality of the Dosewallips River. That central com-
ponent is the viability of the river as habitat for salmon
and steelhead trout.
The condition imposed by Ecology in the water qual-
ity certification Consisted of a minimum instream flow. In
essence, Ecology determined the minimum amount of
water necessary to ensure the stream’s continued via-
bility as both spawning and rearing habitat for salmon
and steelhead trout. This minimum instream flow was
arrived at only after a consortium of experts from the
state Departments of Ecology, Fisheries and Wildlife, the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Point-No-Point
Treaty Councii, conducted extensive data analysis and
engaged in lengthy discussions amongst themselves and
with the Appellants.
The Appellants appealed the water quality certifica-
tion to the Pollution Control Hearings Board, a quasi-
judicial administrative board created under ch. 42.21B
119
RCW. The Pollution Control Hearings Board (the Board)
ruled that Ecology has the requisite legal authority to
impose the minimum instream flow condition in the certi-
fication. The Board ruled first, that there is no preemption
in this case, and second, that the minimum instream flow
condition is within the scope of § 401 of the Clean Water
Act. This ruling was made on cross-motions for summary
judgment.
Later, after a four-day hearing, the Board went on to
rule that the specific minimum instream flow required by
Ecology in this case was not a true minimum flow, but
rather, was an “enhancement flow” which would actually
improve the affected portion of the Dosewallips River as
habitat for salmon and steelhead trout. The Board went
on to conclude that Ecology lacks the legal authority to
require an “enhancement” fiow under RCW
90.54.020(3)(a), and on this basis invalidated the mini-
mum flow condition in the certification.
The Appellants and the Agencies cross-appealed
from the Board’s ruling to Thurston County Superior
Court. After extensive briefing and oral argument, the
Superior Court upheld the Board’s legal reasoning on
preemption, finding that there is no preemption in this
case. More importantly, the court found the Board’s deci-
sion clearly erroneous, ruling that the Board’s factual
finding that the Agency minimum flow was actually an
enhancement flow to be mistaken after reviewing the
entire record. The court also ruled that, even assuming
the agency flow regime is an enhancement flow regime,
the condition is still appropriate because RCW
90.54.020(3)(a) expressly allows Ecology to utilize mini-
mum flows to enhance rivers and streams as wildlife
120
habitat. The Appellants now appeal from the Superior
Court’s ruling.
GROUNDS FOR DIRECT REVIEW
The most important issue presented by this case is
whether chinook and coho salmon and steelhead trout
will be able to use the portion of the Dosewallips River
that will be affected by the Appellants’ proposed hydro-
electric project. In setting the minimum instream flow at
issue, the Agencies established the stream flow which
they truly believe to be the minimum necessary to ensure
that salmon and steelhead can continue to use the
affected portion of the river. These Agency experts do not
believe that salmon and steelhead will be able to continue
to use the affected portion of the river if a lower flow is
established. The outcome of this appeal will determine
whether the Agency minimum flow proposal is upheld or
whether a lower flow, or possibly no minimum instream
flow at all, will take its place.
The other urgent issue raised by this case goes
beyond the Appellants’ proposal for a hydroelectric pro-
ject on the Dosewallips River. The Appellants argue that
the Agencies are preempted from imposing a minimum
instream flow condition in a water quality certification by
the Federal Power Act. 16 U.S.C. § 791 et seq. The Appel-
lants make the remarkable argument that the Federal
Power Act preempts another federal statute, the Clean
Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1251 et seq. In essence, Appellants
argue that Ecology is prohibited by federal law from
ensuring that hydroelectric projects comply with state
121
water quality laws. This position would result in strip-
ping Ecology of its authority and responsibility under a
number of state statutes, including ch. 90.48 RCW and ch.
90.54 RCW, and would nullify § 401 of the Clean Water
Act.
Were the Appellants to prevail in this appeal, hydro-
electric development would be virtually immune from
state water quality laws and the Agencies’ ability to
protect the state’s salmon and steelhead resources would
be eliminated. Neither the Board nor the Superior Court
has ruled for the Appellants on this issue. It is now
necessary for the Supreme Court to promptly and ulti-
mately determine this extremely important issue.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, the Agencies respect-
fully request that the Supreme Court grant direct review
in this case. The case falls squarely within RAP 4.2(a)(4)
and therefore is appropriate for direct review. In these
days of failing salmon and steelhead runs and Endan-
gered Species Act petitions, the importance of this case
can hardly be overstated.
DATED this 11 day of September, 1991.
Respectfully submitted,
KENNETH O. EIKENBERRY
Attorney General
/s/ Jay J. Manning
JAY J. MANNING, WSBA #13579
Assistant Attorney General
(206) 459-6158
122
WILLIAM C. FRYMIRE
Assistant Attorney General
(206) 586-2428
Attorneys for Respondents
State of Washington
Departments of Ecology,
Fisheries and Wildlife
123
No. 58272-6
SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
PUD NO. 1 OF JEFFERSON COUNTY AND
THE CITY OF TACOMA,
Appellants,
V.
DEPARTMENTS OF ECOLOGY, FISHERIES
AND WILDLIFE,
Departments of the State of Washington,
Respondents.
MOTION TO FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF
John B. Arum Katherine Ransel
Ziontz, Chestnut, American Rivers
Varnell, Berley & Northwest Regional
Slonim Office
2101 4th Ave., 4518 University Way NE
Ste. 1230 Seattle, WA 98103
Seattle, WA 98121 (206) 545-7133
(206) 448-1230
Attorneys for Conservation Amici
124
MOTION FOR PERMISSION TO FILE
AN AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF
Fourteen state,’ regional? and national? conservation
groups with an interest in the protection of Northwest
salmon and steelhead fisheries (collectively “conservation
amici”) hereby move the court for (1) leave to file a single
amicus curiae brief in this appeal; and (2) leave to exceed
the 20 page limit in RAP 10.4(b). The brief, lodged con-
_ currently with this motion, is approximately 35 pages in
length.
Conservation amici are groups which together have
demonstrated a long-standing interest in the protection
and preservation of Northwest salmon and steelhead
fisheries. These groups represented herein include the
some of the leading conservation groups in the State, (e.g.
Washington Environmental Council), as well as in the
nation (e.g. Natural Resources Defense Council, the
Sierra Club and American Rivers). A description of each
group and its purposes is attached to this motion as
exhibit A. As is evidenced from Exhibit A, several of
amici have intervened in proceedings before the Federal
' Washington Environmental Council, Washington Wilder-
ness Coalition, Seattle Audubon Society, Olympic Park Associ-
ates, Olympic Rivers Council, The Mountaineers and
Washington Trollers Association.
2 Northwest Rivers Council and Salmon For All.
* American Rivers, Natural Resources Defense Council,
National Wildlife Federation, Sierra Club and Friends of the
Earth.
125
Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) relating to the
very project at issue in this case.4
As a result of their long involvement in water quality
and fisheries protection issues, conservation amici are
intimately familiar with the issues presented in this
appeal. Many of the national groups represented here,
such as the Natural Resources Defense Council, were
directly involved in lobbying for the passage of the fed-
eral Clean Water Act, the construction of which is the
central issue in this case. Other state groups such as
Washington Environmental Council were involved in
lobbying for the passage of the state Water Resource Act,
the proper construction of which is also at issue here.
Finally, many groups which is also at issue here. Finally
many groups seeking to participate here have been
involved in efforts to protect the free-flowing rivers of the
Olympic Peninsula including the Dosewallips and have
intervened in proceedings before FERC relating to licens-
ing of the Elkhorn project. These groups have direct
knowledge of the Elkhorn project, the stretch of River
which Tacoma proposes to divert, as well as the fisheries
which depend on it.
The purpose of the brief that conservation amici seek
permission to file is twofold: first, to provide the Court
with additional background information concerning the
precarious state of anadromous fisheries in the Pacific
Northwest and the failure of federal agencies such as the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to protect these
* These groups include: Friends of the Earth, The Moun-
taineers, Olympic Park Associates, Seattle Audubon Society,
Sierra Club, and Washington Wilderness Coalition.
126
resources; and second, to supplement arguments made by
the respondent State agencies in support of the State's
authority under the federal Clean Water Act to deny or
condition State certification of federally licensed hydro-
power projects for the purpose of protecting the State’s
threatened anadromous fisheries. Conservation amici do
not address the state law issues in this case as these issue
have been adequately briefed by the respondent agencies.
Additional argument on the State’s authority under
the federal Clean Water Act is necessary in order to
supplement arguments made by the agencies in their
brief. The State agencies argue primarily that the condi-
tions they imposed in this case are authorized under
Section 401(d) of the Clean Water Act. While conservation
amici agree with the State’s position regarding the State's
authority under Section 401(d), we strongly believe that
the State also has the authority, and indeed the duty,
under Section 401(a)(1) of the Clean Water Act and its
own water quality standards to impose the conditions it
did. Additional briefing is necessary to inform the Court
about the State’s authority under Section 401(a)(1) to
protect the existing beneficial uses of its waterways.
Finally, conservation amici believe that it is necessary to
supplement the factual record with important, generally
available information concerning the precarious state of
Northwest salmon and steelhead fisheries and the Fed-
eral Energy Regulatory Commission’s dismal record of
protecting these resources. Much of this information,
while relevant, was not included in the State’s brief.
The issues raised by Tacoma in their appeal will have
great ramifications to conservation amici’s continuing
efforts to protect this region’s and the nation’s remaining
127
anadromous fisheries. The many groups petitioning the
Court today all have an interest in these fisheries and
deserve to be heard.
Dated: May 15, 1992.
ZIONTZ, CHESTNUT, VARNELL,
BERLEY & SLONIM
By /s/ John B. Arum
John B. Arum
WSBA # 19813
KATHERINE RANSEL
By /s/ John B. Arum for
Katherine Ransel
WSBA # 20370
Attorneys for Conservation Amici
Exhibit A
Statements of Interest of Conservation Amici
American Rivers, Inc. is a nonprofit conservation
organization incorporated under the laws of the District
of Columbia and having a Northwest Regional! Office in
Seattle, Washington. Its overall mission is to preserve and
restore North American rivers and their ecosystems. The
goal of its Northwest Regional Office is to reverse the
decline of Northwest anadromous fish populations. One
of its principal programs is the protection of rivers from
unauthorized hydroelectric projects and from hydro-
electric developments that fail to take account of the
128
needs of fish, aquatic organisms, and other natural, recre-
ational and cultural values of North American rivers.
American Rivers has approximately 20,000 members
nationwide including over 1,500 members in the Pacific
Northwest and approximately 600 members in Washing-
ton State.
Friends of the Earth is a national conservation orga-
nization formed for the purpose of protecting natural
resources, including water resources and free-flowing
rivers. The Northwest Regional Office of Friends of the
Earth, located in Seattle, Washington, serves members in
the states of Washington, Oregon and Idaho. Friends of
the Earth is a membership organization with over 12,000
members nationwide, approximately 1,200 members in
the Northwest, and approximately 900 members in Wash-
ington State. Friends of the Earth is an intervenor before
the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in the
Elkhorn Project (FERC No. 9948-000).
The Mountaineers, founded in 1906, is the oldest
recreation and conservation organization in Washington
State. Among its purposes are to explore and study the
mountains, forests and water courses of the Northwest,
and to preserve — by encouragement of protective legisla-
tion or otherwise — the natural beauty of Northwest
America. The Mountaineers’ first expedition was to the
Olympic Peninsula in 1907. The Mountaineers has partici-
pated in activities relating to protection of Olympic
National Park, and was instrumental in encouraging leg-
islation which resulted in additions to the Park in 1976.
The Mountaineers is headquartered in Seattle with four
branch offices in the Puget Sound region, and more than
129
13,000 members. It is an intervenor before FERC in the
Elkhorn Project (FERC No. 9948-000).
The National Audubon Society (“Audubon”) is a
nonprofit, national conservation organization with more
than 550,000 members, many of whom are affiliated with
one of Audubon’s 516 local chapters. The mission of
Audubon is to effect wise public policy for the environ-
ment, especially in major issues that bear on wildlife and
wildlife habitat. Audubon plays an active role in a variety
of issues that could be significantly affected by the out-
come of this case, including the protection and restora-
tion of outstanding river resources and the prudent
development of the nation’s hydropower resources.
The Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.
(NRDC), is a nonprofit membership organization dedi-
cated to the protection of human health and the environ-
ment, and the sound use and preservation of natural
resources. NRDC represents approximately 165,000 mem-
bers and supporters nationwide, including over 4,000
members in Washington State. For over twenty years
NRDC’s Clean Water Project has worked to ensure proper
implementation and legal interpretation of the Clean
Water Act, including the rights of states to protect their
waters - and members of NRDC to use those waters -
against both chemical pollution and other physical
impacts that destroy aquatic habitat. NRDC also is work-
ing actively in the Pacific Northwest to ensure adequate
instream habitat for anadromous fisheries and other uses.
Northwest Rivers Council is a nonprofit conservation
organization formed to protect the region’s free-flowing
rivers for native fish and wildlife habitat, recreation, and
130
other natural values. The Northwest Rivers Council has
more than 800 members throughout the region, and
approximately 600 members in Washington State.
Olympic Park Associates is a nonprofit organization
incorporated under the laws of Washington State, and
headquartered in Seattle, Washington. It was formed in
1948 for the specific purpose of protecting the wilderness
and natural resources of the Olympic Peninsula. Olympic
Park Associates is an intervenor before FERC in ihe
Elkhorn Project (FERC No. 9948-000).
Olympic Rivers Council is a nonprofit corporation
having its principal place of business in Hoodsport,
Washington on the Olympic Peninsula. It is a local orga-
nization whose mission is building support for the pre-
servation, enhancement and sound management of
Olympic Peninsula rivers, including protection of those
rivers against unwise hydroelectric projects.
Salmon for All is an Oregon nonprofit corporation
registered in Oregon and Washington, and headquartered
in Clatsop County, Oregon. Salmon for All is dedicated to
maintaining an economically viable commercial salmon
fishery on the Columbia River. It represents non-Indian
commercial gillnet fishers and fish processors on the
Columbia River. Salmon for All has approximately 900
members, including representatives from communities
along the lower Columbia River.
Seattle Audubon, founded in 1916, is the oldest natu-
ral history organization in Washington State. With over
5,000 members, it ranks 6th in size among the 516 chap-
ters of the National Audubon Society. Seattle Audubon
131
promotes conservation and wise stewardship of our natu-
ral resources, including native fish and wildlife and their
habitats. Seattle Audubon is an intervenor before FERC in
the Elkhorn Project (FERC No. 9948-000).
The Sierra Club is a nonprofit national conservation
organization incorporated in the State of California and
having a Northwest Regional Office in Seattle, Washing-
ton that was founded in 1963. The Sierra Club was estab-
lished in 1892 to explore, enjoy, and preserve the nation’s
forests, waters, wildlife, and wilderness. The first chapter
in the Pacific Northwest was formed in 1954. It now has
three regional chapters (the Cascade, Oregon and North-
ern Rockies chapters) as well as 21 local groups in the
region, including the Twanoh group on the Olympic Pen-
insula. The Sierra Club has approximately 600,000 mem-
bers nationwide, 30,000 members in the region, and
18,000 members, in Washington State. The Sierra Club is
an intervenor before FERC in the Elkhorn Project (FERC
No. 9948-000).
The Washington Environmental Council (WEC) is a
statewide nonprofit citizens group founded in 1967, with
its principal place of business in Seattle, Washington. It is
the largest and oldest umbrella environmental organiza-
tion in Washington State, founded to represent the public
interest in protection of the environment, including the
natural values of Washington’s free-flowing rivers. Its
members use the resources of Washington rivers, includ-
ing the Dosewallips River, for fishing, aesthetic enjoy-
ment and other recreational purposes. WEC’s
membership consists of approximately 2,000 individuals
and approximately 100 affiliated organizations represent-
ing approximately 100,000 individuals. Since passage of
132
the Federal Clean Water Act, WEC has been actively
involved in ensuring proper implementation of the Act
by the Washington State Department of Ecology.
Washington Trollers Association (WTA) is a nonprofit
organization of commercial fishermen, specifically
salmon trollers, registered in the State of Washington
under the Articles of Incorporation since 1977. The WTA
represents approximately 950 troll licenses. The WTA
functions to further and protect the needs and goals of
the commercial salmon troll industry in the State of
Washington. This is accomplished through political
lobbying on state and federal levels, litigation, and fish-
eries and habitat protection through enhancement pro-
jects and public processes. The WTA actively cooperates
with other state groups throughout the State to further
the needs of the salmon resource.
Washington Wilderness Coalition (WWC) is a non-
profit corporation organized under Washington law hav-
ing it principal place of business in Seattle, Washington.
WWC has among its purposes the protection and preser-
vation of wilderness resources, including wilderness
within Olympic National Park. WWC also has among its
purposes the protection and restoration of fisheries
resources, and the protection of river ecosystems. WWC
is an umbrella organization comprised of approximately
1,000 individual members, as well as 44 Washington envi-
ronmental groups representing over 20,000 members.
WWC is an intervenor before FERC in the Elkhorn Project
(FERC No. 9948-000).
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.