Joint Appendix — Chemical Waste Management, Inc. v. Hunt
Supreme Court brief1992
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 91-471
Iu the Supreme Court of the United
OCTOBER TERM, 1991
CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC., PETITIONER
Guy HuNtT, GOVERNOR
OF THE
Vv.
STATE OF ALABAMA;
ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE; and JAMES M.
SIZEMORE, JR., COMMISSIONER OF THE ALABAMA DE-
PARTMENT OF REVENUE, RESPONDENTS
On Writ of Certiorari to the
Supreme Court of Alabama
JOINT APPENDIX
BERT S. NETTLES
Counsel of Record
ALTON B. PARKER, JR.
J. MARK HART
Spain, Gillon, Grooms
Blan & Nettles
2117 2nd Avenue North
Birmingham, AL 35203
(205) 328-4100
Counsel for Respondent
Hunt
WILLIAM D. COLEMAN
Counsel of Record
JIM B. GRANT, JR.
Capell, Howard, Knabe
& Cobbs, P.A.
57 Adams Avenue
Montgomery, AL 36104
(205) 241-8000
Counsel for Respondents
James M. Sizemore, Jr. and
the Alabama Department
of Revenue
ANDREW J. PINCUS
Counsel of Record
KENNETH S. GELLER
EVAN M. TAGER
Mayer, Brown & Platt
2000 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 7780628
FOURNIER J. GALE III
H. THOMAS WELLS, JR.
Maynard, Cooper, Frierson
& Gale, PC.
1901 Sixth Avenue, North
2400 AmSouth, Harbert Plaza
Birmingham, AL 35203
(205) 254-1000
Counsel for Petitioner
Chemical Waste Management,
Ine.
( Additional Counsel on Inside Cover)
SL LS aN EE a a ST I ETE ETE
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED SEPTEMBER 20, 1991
CERTIORARI GRANTED JANUARY 27, 1992
J. WADE HoPEe
Legal Division
Alabama Department
of Revenue
4116 Gordon Persons
Building
Montgomery, AL 36104
(205) 242-9690
TABLE OF CONTENTS *
Page
Relevant Docket Entries 200000000 1
Oral Argument on Motions (excerpts) .. 3
List of States Affected by Alabama Act 89-788 __. — 6
Testimony of Rodger Henson (excerpts)... ~
Testimony of Sue Robertson (excerpts) ....... 15
Testimony of Richard Groshong (excerpts) sae 28
Testimony of Bill Brock (excerpts)... idensenas 35
Testimony of Tom Joiner (excerpts) _. sesieodepusnasierevdsene 43
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 61 (excerpts) 54
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 62 000 57
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 77... inaiitadeas idiomas nesebbibesinndaeteiensnes 62
Peniten © ible 60 ........................................ sintetatbelissaaceds 65
Defendants’ Exhibit 14 (excerpts)... ienspaness 68
Defendants’ Exhibit 40 (excerpts) en 91
Defendants’ Exhibit 41 (excerpts). sti‘—tstsS 99
Defendants’ Exhibit 57 (excerpts)... 108
Defendants’ Exhibit 68 (excerpts) .... = ststst—<‘ets—SsSCsSI
Deposition of Leigh Pegues ina Gindesaidamenuanes 113
Deposition of Bernard Webb Siena eh a
Deposition of Rodger Henson (excerpts) == ssss—s—<‘its~s~s*s«~*2S: FF
Deposition of John Hanley (excerpts) _— 131
Deposition of William Brumund (excerpts) ce. 142
* The decision of the Supreme Court of Alabama and the decision
of the Circuit Court of Montgomery County are set forth in the
appendix to the petition for a writ of certiorari and have not been
reproduced.
SUPREME COURT OF ALABAMA
SPECIAL TERM, 1991
1901043
Guy HuNT, as Governor of the State of Alabama
Vv.
CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC.
1901044
JAMES M. SIZEMORE, J R., as Commissioner of the
Alabama Department of Revenue: and the
ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
Vv.
CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC.
1901106
CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC.
Vv.
THE ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, et al.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1991
April 5 Case docketed
April 16 CWM files cross appeal
June 13 Case argued and submitted
July 11 Opinion by Justice Shores issued: certificates of
judgment issued
2
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT
OF MONTGOMERY COUNTY, ALABAMA
Civil Action No. CV 90-1098
CHEMICAL WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC., PLAINTIFF
Vv.
THE ALABAMA Dept. OF REVENUE; JAMES M. SIZEMORE,
JR., as Commissioner of the ALABAMA DEPARTMENT OF
REVENUE; Guy HuNT, as Governor of Alabama;
CLAUDE EARL Fox, M.D., M.P.H., as State Health
Officer; and the STATE BoARD OF HEALTH, DEFENDANTS
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
1990
May 31 CWM files complaint challenging Additional Fee
and Base Fee.
July 5 Defendants Sizemore and Alabama Department
of Revenue file Answer to Complaint.
Aug. 13 Defendant Sizemore files Amendment to Answer.
Aug. 29 Defendant Hunt answers complaint and files
counterclaim seeking determination of validity of
Cap Provision.
Sept. 6 CWM files First Amendment To Complaint.
Oct. 3 CWM answers Defendant Hunt’s counterclaim.
Oct. 15 Defendant Hunt files Amended Answer to Com-
plaint.
Oct. 15-
Oct.18 Trial before Judge Phelps.
1991
Feb. 28 Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, Order
and Injunction filed.
April 2 Defendants Hunt and Sizemore file notices of
appeal.
3
ORAL ARGUMENT ON MOTIONS
July 12, 1990
« * * &
[R. 309] BY MR. NETTLES: Yes, sir. So, what the
State is saying, we want to do two things, and we'll go
through the findings of fact but just—the Legisiature,
at least, and the Governor have said we have these con-
cerns, very explic:t concerns, four pages of them and we
want to do two things; we are going to make it more
expensive for people to send it in because we want to
decrease the amount of waste coming in, one. And num-
ber two, have some money from what does come in, to
help us with, among other things, Sumter county but also
for the health department.
BY THE COURT: They said you need to treat the
in-state people the same same way.
BY MR. NETTLES: That’s right, but you don’t. We
are going back to Maine, we are also yoing back to
several other cases that we cited in brief, and while we
are staying on the law, let me refer back to the brief
because there are other case as well, older cases that
didn’t deal with hazardous wastes.
BY THE COURT: Before I lose you on this, do you
say, or does the Legislature say that these out-of-state
users are using up a resource of Alabama?
(Rk. 310} BY MR. NETTLES: That’s part of it, that’s
part of it, Your Honor. That this is a—they say it’s one
of the best—the Selma chalk is one of the best structures
for the burial of this waste anywhere.
Now, there are a lot of other possible sites as well that
are as good or better than, but those other sites have not
been developed. Back in the late seventies, Emmelle was
opened about four years or so, it was receiving this, and
not much was said or done about it, and then it’s just
continued to grow, but it hasn’t grown—hasn’t been
developed in other states.
Now, Your Honor can refer to the brief, you have the
brief before you, if you would turn to page eight, and
4
this deals with a case, I believe it was Mr. Justice Scalia
explaining the opinion of the court, and in that case,
although he found against the government institution in
that case, Limbach, who was Commissioner of Revenue,
I think in Ohio, that he never,—the court, Mr. Justice
Scalia explained, our cases leave open the possibility that
a state may validate a statute that discriminates against
interstate commerce by showing that it advances a legiti-
mate local purpose [R. 311] that cannot be adequately
served by reasonable non-discriminatory alternatives.
Sort of like a products liability case.
BY THE COURT: You go back to Maine, I guess.
BY MR. NETTLES: Yes, sir. This is perhaps just
another way of saying that what may appear to be a
discriminatory or facially discrimatory provision in the
Constitution that prohibits it, since that is a protectionist
enactment, may on closer analysis may not be so. And
that’s what we say, you read those two cases together.
BY THE COURT: You say that this court has to
look at the act and the purpose and look towards why.
BY MR. NETTLES: And the facts, yes, sir. What
we are saying, like Mr. Justice Scalia, we are saying that
our purpose cannot be adequately served by reasonable,
non-discriminatory purposes. How can we discourage
other people from sending their hazardous waste down here
and and increasing the already four million tons of haz-
ardous waste, without the total ban? But there’s no other
way to discourage them. Either a [ 312] total ban which
might well be unconstitutional, or create problems for the
entire country as well as Alabama, or with a tax.
BY THE COURT: As I understand the plaintiff’s
argument, for a rational,—a rational basis doesn’t make
any difference. The test says I am required to invoke is
whether or not it’s a different treatment, and if it is, the
whys don’t make any difference? Is that what he said?
BY MR. NETTLES: Yes, sir, but that’s wrong.
BY THE COURT: ’ll let you come back on that, but
I understand the rationale is not properly before me.
5
BY MR. NETTLES: The rationale, Your Honor, is
because of the—the scintilla, or whatever the substantial
reason,—not scintilla, but the findings of the fact of the
Legislature, the legislative findings as we set out, we cite
two Alabama Supreme Court cases holding that legisla-
tive findings are entitled to weight.
BY THE COURT: Well, he says that doesn’t make
any difference. That if you tax an out-of-state user any
amount at all more than you [R.313] tax an in-state
user, it’s per se violative of the Commerce Clause.
BY MR. NETTLES: Yes, sir, that’s what I heard him
Say, too, and that’s what the record will reflect and Mr.
Justice Scalia says differently. If you read—.
BY THE COURT: What kind of case was that?
BY MR. NETTLES: That was not a hazardous waste
case, if I recall. It was something else, Your Honor.
BY THE COURT: If it was a hazardous waste case,
you would recall it, right?
BY MR. NETTLES: Yes, sir, yes, sir. But it’s good
enough when you read with it the State of Maine, plus
with the City of Philadelphia.
Your Honor, in other words, what we have here is a
situation of has the Alabama Legislature advanced a legiti-
mate local purpose that cannot be adequately served by
reasonable, non-discriminatory alternatives.
* * * e
RCLA wastes.
The list of banned states has been revised to remove North
»
4
Hazardous waste prohibited from banned states includes
Carolina from the banned list. The Governor of Alabama
RCRA and Cl]
Oo
has signed an interstate agreement with the Governor of
North Carolina. The agreement allows North Carolina to
send hazardous waste to Alabama for land disposal.
—)
oo
for)
_
ee)
>
_—
w
on eH
i=) -)
fae} ~
. ;
3 E
y Ms
77) 5)
= g8 &
5S —S A
a Seas
— & cS §&
qo wo fe
4 S5Aa
a WO
5
jam ~
68/61/01 Spuels] UIZATA “SQ
68/F1/60 UO UZ UIYSE AA
68/1/60 Uu0Z20
ueg jo ajeq UOTPBULIOJUT
dA 1oj jsonbey s,ewmeqeiy
0} asuodsay Jo yor'y] jo
=
asnkoeg pauurg saqywig
$82°68 LOV VNVAVIV Ad GALOTAAV SALVLS AO LSIT
Environmental Management
1-9-90
Date
‘o
re)
of
=
=
Ey
=)
UISUOIST AA
430
sUxay
dossouue |
vUT[OABD YyNog
puvjs] epoyy
BluBA[ASUUdg
BWoYye|YO
o14o
68 /F1/60 BUIWOA VUI[OAR,) YRION
68/1/60 BIUIZUTA JSOAA ylOK MON
68/F1/60 BIUIBALA AQSAof MON
68/P1/60 JUOULIO A UpRAoN
68/F1/60 ByO¥R(] YINog BYSUAGAN
68/61/01 ory OLN ByOsoUUTY
68/61/60 ByONB YWON UBS IYI
68/b1/60 OdIXaTY MON S}JOSNYIUssV]Y
68/ F1/60 attysdwey MON puvypAaryy
68/1/60 vurqyuoyy Ayonyley
68/F1/60 LANOosst |x BUBISINO'T]
68/F1/60 tddississi py EMO]
68/F1/60 ouleyy vuvipu]
68/1/60 sesuey SIOuTI|]
68/61/01 IIEMEH oyrp]
68/PT/60 eploly BLI.1004)
68/F1/60 BiQUINIO,) JO JIAYSIG yNoQoeuU0,)
68/1/60 MBMLLIC OpR.10]O,)
68/1/60 wuozLiy VIUAOJTRD
68/ FT, 60 ByselLy SBSURYAY
uvg Jo aynq saqey aye paysyqnd Uo eansoyg
IATPIYA [Psodsiq] 40 yuoWywaa], BRL-68 PY Aq
[PIDAVUIWIOY JO yoR'] Jo
asnBoeg pouurg sozRrjg
PP9PIPV ION SAPS
[Shp “U)
eT Wael EIS 3
ahd 6 Shatin Det ee et
8
TESTIMONY OF RODGER HENSON
* - * *
[Tr.48] Q. Is there any difference among nonhazard-
ous and hazardous waste based upon the state where they
are generated or created?
A. There is no difference.
* * * *
(Tr.64] Q. I think we will pick up where we were at
lunch. As I understand it, you had testified that you take
hazardous waste and then solidify it or treat it and
then render it nonhazardous before or when you place
it into the trench; is that correct?
A. That is correct. That is with some waste.
Q. Possible with some waste, but not all waste?
A. Not all waste.
Q. And would you agree then with the statement that
although some wastes degrade or can be less hazardous
through treatment, some substances remain hazardous
forever?
A. I would agree with that.
” * * *
(Tr.83] Q. And incidentally is it not correct that
approximately 40,000 truckloads of hazardous waste came
into Emelle last vear?
A. I don’t know if that is the number or not.
Q. If you take 20 tons on the average truck?
A. 20 tons a truck.
Q. 780,000, almost 800,000, and you multiply that
out, would you get 40,000 truckloads of hazardous waste?
A. Is that how it divides out?
Q. Yes. We had a large complicated set of figures
with Mr. Hanley, and that is what it came out.
A. If you take 780,000 tons of waste and divide that
by 20 tons per truck you get the number of trucks.
* * * *
(Tr. 102] Q. I will ask you to read with me on page
4, paragraph D, reading your lawyer’s language, and you
9
will recognize the first few words of that, “Without the
unconstitutional restrictions discussed above, the total an-
nual demand for disposal capacity at the Emelle facility
for hazardous waste generated out of state is projected
to increase annually”. Do you agree with that statement
of your lawyers?
A. I agree.
Q. So, without the cap, without the additional fees,
you project that total annual demand for disposing ca-
pacity there at Emelle would increase for hazardous
wastes generated out of state annually?
A. To a point. There are some points somewhere in
the future where it won’t.
Q. I believe you stated in deposition that you see a
hundred years of operation there at Emelle?
(Tr.103] A. I stated in my deposition at the current
rate I believe the facility would last 100 years, at least.
Q. Now, isn’t it correct—I believe you said toward
the end of your testimony this morning that with respect
to—you were taking two situations, asked about what
happens on cleanup costs. We see a lot of cleanup of
hazardous waste from the government, Judge, or whoever
mandates that it be removed, and a lot of that is coming
to Emelle, is that correct?
A. Right.
” * * *
(Tr. 113] Q. Now, is it not correct that you have
monitoring facilities that will have to be maintained in-
definitely, or shall we say forever?
A. Monitoring facilities?
Q. The 70 monitoring wells already in place at Emelle,
for example?
A. Those wells will be monitored in perpetuity.
Q. Yes, sir. And that monitoring in perpetuity, by
definition, will extend well beyond 30 years?
A. It will.
Q. And likewise is there not going to be a require-
ment that continued safety desirabiilty, environmental
10
desirability factor to maintain the pumping out of the
leachate and hauling, gathering, storing and disposal of
leachate from this trench 19 and eventualiy trench 21,
and from these other trenches yet to be built?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that gathering, collection, storage, transpor-
tation and disposal of leachate will have to be maintained
in perpetuity?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Again, by definition, beyond 30 years?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And isn’t it a fact that the premises there at
Emelle |Tr. 114] where you have the monitoring, where
you have the pumping out of leachate, will have to be
maintained and secured in perpetuity?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. For which there will be some expense?
A. Some.
Q. In fact, all of those things that we have described,
the continued monitoring, the continued pumping, the
gathering and collection and hauling away and disposal
of leachate, and the security maintenance of the facility
will have to be maintained at some expense in perpetuity?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Now, obviously you have some 50 acres in use at
the present time, and assuming, shall we say, some an-
nual increases and operations for a hundred years, you
are talking about far more than 50 acres on down the
road being placed in active operation?
A. Yes.
Q. And the greater the facility, the larger the facility,
the larger the cost eventually in perpetuity?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And is it not correct to say that the larger the
facility the more millions of tons of hazardous waste
brought in and left there forever, whatever risks there
are likewise will increase?
(Tr. 115] A. Well, I get—when you talk about risks,
what I am maintaining is that you are not increasing
11
your risk anymore by the more material that you bring
in and put in the Selma chalk.
Q. That is your testimony?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That you can dig another hundred trenches the
size of trench 21 or trench 16, that-we saw in the photo-
raph, and not increase the risks?
, A. It is my opinion you won't, because of the in-
tegrity of the chalk. :
‘e with the operation
[Tr.116] Q. So what we have here wi |
of this ChemWaste facility at Emelle —~ Selma chalk,
all of this is based upon an inexact science:
A. In my view. The only thing that is inexact about
~ it is the measurement of migration through chalk. You've
got people that are saying 310 years it would take to
penetrate the chalk. You have other people saying a
million years, and you have people saying 10,000 years.
It is somewhere in there somewhere, is what I am saying.
. It is going to leak? ae
4 The migration potential through that chalk is in-
exact.
* * * *
(Tr. 120] Q. And ChemWaste has the responsibility
should anything go wrong, it also has the similar respon-
sibility for the present, certainly for the 30 years under
the EPA guidelines, for anything that might go wrong
in Louisiana, or at these other five facilities?
A. That’s correct. 7
Q. So, if there were a natural disaster in Louisiana
or Texas, or one of these other facilities, hazardous waste
facilities, ChemWaste would be responsible for that; is
that not correct?
A. If they own the facility, that’s right.
Q. Yes, sir. Speaking of disasters, do you have any
plan with respect to what if an earthquake comes
through there?
A. No.
ee oe i
12
[Tr. 123] Q. Relating to this
. morning, I think you
oe most of the Fortune 500 companies ship c
ardous waste to the Emelle facility for landfill ial?
A. Many of them do. ee
Q. I think you said most.
A. I might have; most, many, some, a lot.
an Most and some, in any event let’s just say with
t at, |Tr. 124] most, some, or a lot of Fortune 500 com-
panies send to Emelle their hazardous waste. Most of
those companies, most of that waste from those companies
Is generated outside of Alabama?
A. Yes, sir.
Mg Fectggeing: ae me. Is there a similar site
ama, a similar disposal si
en ar disposal site, to ChemWaste, to
A. No, sir. We are the onl i i i
a ae y commercial disposal site
THE COURT: ‘ y i i
. a You don’t have an in-state competitor?
beri = Now, is Emelle the largest landfill, haz-
é S waste operation, anywhere in the enti ntry?
A. In land size, yes, a
Q. And, in fact, do you k i
non en teae y now of any in the world as
A. I d , ad i] . M “a. .
a ee I am not famiilar with every facility in
Q. You are not aware of an i
y landfill operation lar
than the Emelle facility anywhere in the world: are ar
A. I’m not aware of any.
Q During the video tape we heard—this is just to
clarify—I think it said on the tape that the number of
acres at Emelle was, I believe, 2400 acres, and your
sare (Tr. 133] was like 1700 acres?
Az ‘o; it was 2700. We have acqui
since the tape was made. oe
13
Q. You may have said 1700 but you meant to say
2700?
A. I meant 2700.
Q. That is the size of the Emelle facility?
A. (Witness nods head up and down.)
Q. One of the first things brought out in your testi-
mony today was the location of Emelle. It is a rather
rural area; isn’t it?
A. Itis.
Q. And this landfill is actually located between Emelle
and Geiger?
A. That’s correct.
Q. In this particular facility over there is that one of
the reasons it was chosen, because it was a very sparsely
populated area?
A. It was chosen because of geology, number one; and
the second consideration was it was chosen because it
was for sale.
* * * +
[Tr. 156] Q. Would anything coming out of any one of
those be considered leachate?
A. Yes. Materials pumped out of this pipe that is
above both of the liners would be considered leachate.
THE COURT: You are getting that now?
[Tr.157] A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where is this water coming from?
A. It is rainfall. When this trench is open and we
are disposing of things inside it, and it rains on it, the
water trickles down through, hits the synthetic liner, hits
the gravel, and flows through that pipe into the pump
and we pump it out.
THE COURT: What do you do with it?
A. It is stored on site in a tank and then we ship it
to Texas for disposal.
Q. Why do you ship it to Texas for disposal instead
of disposing of it on site?
A. Because there is a deep well injection facility in
Texas. that we don’t have. The only thing we could do
would be solidify it and put it back in the trench.
hai. oe)
eae aS ee
14
Q. Are there any deep well injection facilities in the
state of Alabama?
A. I don’t know whether there are any of those still
operating privately or not. I know there is not a com-
mercial one.
Q. There is not one that would take it?
A. There is not one in Alabama that would take our
stuff.
Q. If I can describe it as a regular landfill, do the
county landfills generate leachate?
A. Iam certain they do.
| Tr. 158] Q. What about industrial landfills that ac-
cept industrial nonhazardous waste?
A. Any landfill that is operated in anyplace where it
rains generates leachate.
THE COURT: Do you have a different category for
that leachate? Do you have hazardous and nonhazardous?
A. The leachate that is collected because of rainfall in
a hazardous waste facility is, by definition of EPA, a
hazardous liquid. The leachate generated in a landfill may
or may not be hazardous, depending on what they put in
the garbage landfill.
Q. So the leachate from a garbage landfill could be
hazardous?
A. It could have hazardous characteristics, depending
on what went in that garbage landfill. It is not defined as
hazardous as a TSD facility under RCRA.
A. It is a hazardous waste landfill, transportation
storage facility.
* * _ =
15
TESTIMONY OF SUE ROBERTSON
(Tr. 194] Q. Good morning, Ms. Robertson. Would
you state your full name for the Court, please?
A. Sue R. Robertson.
Q. Where do you live?
A. Ilive in Wallsboro, Alabama.
Q. By whom are you employed?
A. The State of Alabama, specifically the Alabama
Department of Environmental Management.
Q. In what capacity?
A. I am Chief of the Land Division, which is re-
sponsible for regulation of hazardous and solid waste.
Q. Would you please give the Court a brief summary
of your educational background?
A. I have a B.S. Degree in Chemical Engineering
from the University of Alabama. I have a Master’s in
Chemical |Tr. 195] Engineering from Georgia Tech. I
have been employed with ADEM or its predecessors for
the past 18 years.
Q. And are you a registered professional engineer?
A. Yes, in the state of Alabama.
Q. In the state of Alabama. When did you receive
that designation?
A. 1977.
[Tr. 205} A. EPA has, through their regulatory proc-
ess, classified for about 455 chemicals, specific chemicals or
listings as being hazardous. In addition, they have other
characteristic procedure which says that if a waste [Tr.
206| is corrosive or if it is reactive, or if it is ignitable,
or if it fails a test procedure, which was referred to
as an EPA tox, but now there is another test procedure
that replaced that called the toxie characteristic leaching
procedure, which you will hear a lot of people refer to as
TCLP. This covers an enormous range of chemicals, and
Chemical Waste Management, through the Part B permit
and their interim status, can landfill or can manage virtu-
ally all of those different chemicals. In addition, Chemica]
ee eee ee ee
16
Waste Management is permitted to manage PCBs or poly-
chlorinated biphenyls. And, in addition to that, they are
also permitted to take CERCLA waste, which is cleanup
waste that Dr. Henson referred to yesterday, and these
could encompass an even wider range of chemicals that
are of concern under the Clean Water Act or the Air Act.
So, there is a very broad range. These chemicals are
again determined to be hazardous, because they might be
reactive. That means if they are mixed with other chemi-
cals there would be a reaction. Ignitable at other facili-
ties in the early ’70s in the past, drums would explode
and the storage facility would catch on fire. And there’s
been some large contamination and resulting cleanups
from that tyne incidents. Corrosive—if corrosive ma-
terial would eventually eat through some [Tr. 207] stor-
age containers, then that would allow them to perhaps
react with other chemicals it was stored with, and then
they are toxic. A large percentage of the chemicals are
listed as being hazardous because they are toxic. They
have been determined to be carcinogenic and mutogenic,
and have im»act on human health.
” * * *
(Tr.216] A. * * * But there is also concern about
long term, and there are some very hazardous compounds
that are landfilled there that are considered to be haz-
ardous because of their effect on human health, that
there were studies or [Tr. 217] actual verification that
these compounds when it got into the ground water caused
cancer, caused malformed babies, caused miscarriages, et
cetera; so | would say there are two types of concerns,
the sudden, which would be ignitable waste that Dr. Hen-
son talked about, and then the long term, which would be
the cancer causing agents that could get into the water
table.
Q. Ms. Robertson, we were talking about the differ-
ences between a gasoline truck which would be going to
the gasoline station and other trucks with flammable
17
liquids which may be destined for treatment at Emelle.
Are the types of liquids contained in those trucks intended
for treatment at Emelle, are they of the same type ignita-
ble characteristics that the gasoline truck would be?
A. Part of them would be, yes.
* * * *
[Tr.219] Q. Now, tell me, if you will, what are some
of the more hazardous wastes that are stored at Emelle,
please, ma’am?
A. Stored or landfilled?
Q. Landfilled at Emelle. I’m sorry.
A. Well, again, PCBs are landfilled at Emelle in large
amounts. They are considered hazardous. You have a
large amount of plating waste that goes to Emelle. Those
are contaminated with metals such as lead, cadmium,
chrome, cyanide suppressant are present many times in
plating base, and those can be released. If they are re-
leased in a gaseous state, they are considered fatal to hu-
mans in concentrations as low as, I believe, three or 400
parts per million. So, metals are considered to be pretty
much prevalent. Once they are disposed they stay as
metals in the environment, and some of them have high
solubility in water, or cyanide, and would move into the
water table if an opportunity presented itself.
Q. You mentioned a minute ago when I asked you a
question about storage of these wastes at Emelle, and
you asked me if I meant landfilled. With respect to ma-
terials that are landfilled at the Emelle facility, how long
is it anticipated that those materials and wastes will
| Tr. 220} be landfilled there?
A. Chemical Waste Management, in their closure plan,
intends to cap that waste that is landfilled, and that it
will be left there forevermore.
Q. And these wastes that are capped in the landfill in
Alabama forever will require what type of, in general
terms, continuous regulatory activity?
A. On any particular regulatory, on my part, or
maintenance on their part?
== ys = Se
18
Q. Both. I’m sorry.
A. Okay. I will continue to have to regulate that
facility even in a closed state to insure that ChemWaste
is doing what is required under the post closure provi-
sions. When you get a permit, which is referred to as a
post closure permit when a facility is closed with waste
in place, that post closure permit would require that
ChemWaste maintain the cap so that water or liquids do
not permeate the cap, get in the landfill and cause possible
ground water contamination, requires that monitoring be
carried out on a periodic basis; and at the present, those
requirements would be for 30 years after they close the
facility or the landfill.
THE COURT: Continuing regulation for 30 years?
A. Yes, sir.
THE COURT: Why are you able to stop at the end
[Tr. 221] of 30 years?
A. The federal law or EPA specified that that was all
that is required, that 20 years; but in actuality, the waste
will be there and there will still have to be monitoring
of some sort that will go on at that facility forever, be-
cause the waste will be there forever, and the longer the
waste is there the greater the probability that the liners
may deteriorate and that there might be contamination.
(Tr. 241] Q. Now, are those, all of those that you just
read, fire, explosion, spills, and materials release, and
accidents, they have listed there under emergencies in-
herent to [Tr. 242] closure operations?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Are those all risks that are attendant to handling,
managing and landfilling hazardous waste at the Emelle
facility?
A. Yes.
Q. In your judgment, is that risk increased by in-
creased volumes of hazardous waste that is managed,
stored and landfilled at that facility?
A. Yes.
19
Q. Look at paragraph 1.4.2 under natural events,
please, and tell the Court what ChemWaste says are nat-
ural events which are potential facility emergencies.
A. There are potential facility emergencies which
could result from acts of God, including major climato-
logical, geophysical or other natural events, such as heavy
rains and surface runoff, tornadoes, heavy winds and
forest fires.
Q. Is there any mention of earthquakes in that?
A. No.
Q. And with respect to those natural events which are
potential emergencies that could occur at or around the
Emelle facility, is it your judgment that the risks attend-
ant to those would be increased based on the increased
volume that is stored and landfilled at that [Tr. 243]
facility?
A. Yes.
Q. I will ask you, Ms. Robertson, has it recently come
to your attention that an earthquake did actually occur
in Sumter County in 1886?
MR. WELLS: We will stipulate that there was an
earthquake 104 years ago in Sumter County. I don’t
think we need to ask every witness.
MR. PARKER: We will accept the stipulation.
* * * *
Q. ChemWaste’s contingency plan does not address
the potential for earthquakes; does it?
A. No, it doesn’t.
* * * *
[Tr.251] Q. You mentioned earlier the newly per-
mitted BFI landfill at Last Chance, Colorado. I ask you
are there any landfills which have been started and per-
mitted since RCRA came into existence in November of
1980 for hazardous waste?
A. No. Last Chance is the only green field site, which
[Tr. 252] means there was nothing there before they came
in and put a landfill there.
a ae We ony
20
Q. All of the other hazardous waste landfills operated
and preexisted the effective date of RCRA?
A. They came in under interim status meaning they
made that demonstration that they were accepting haz-
ardous waste and they, therefore, got a Part A permit
and didn’t go through getting a Part B, as the green
field site.
MR. PARKER: Your Honor, do you understand what
the green field site means? You might explain that, if
you would.
A. When you refer to a green field site it means that
there was nothing but grass there before, and that there
was nothing there, and you came in and put some type of
industry there.
Q. Now, with respect to Last Chance, Colorado land-
fill, which is the only permitted landfill, which is a green
field site, since RCRA, how much waste has been intro-
duced into that landfill?
A. None. It became operational or could have been
operational in the spring of this year. BFI made the
corporate decision that it would no longer manage haz-
ardous waste; and, therefore, put up for sale all of its
hazardous waste facility, so this facility was [Tr. 253]
never operated and is for sale.
Q. Has it been sold at the present time, to your know!l-
edge?
A. No.
[Tr. 298] Q. Have you reviewed the records of ADEM
to determine what spills have occurred on site at Emelle?
A. Yes.
Q. And would you please tell the Court, or summarize,
those spills, the dates and types of spills they were?
A. On October 4, 1984, a solution with a pH greater
than 13 was placed in the RCRA surface impairment
number 3, which contained a low pH sludge. The co-
mingling of these wastes resulted in an orange colored
21
atmospheric emission being emitted. On August 18, 1985
there was a hazardous waste spill, which occurred on site,
which contaminated an area of on site soil. Efforts to
contain this spill weren’t effective and there was off site
contamination. ChemWaste indicated that equipment fail-
ure caused the release. On April 4, 1986, 50 gallons of
waste acid were spilled on the ground during the loading
of a tanker when the acid apparently caused the tanker
walls to fail. On September 17, 1987, approximately 30
gallons of solvent waste was spilled when a tanker hose
failed and contaminated on site soil. On March 22, 1989,
a truck driver released a 10,000 pound load of ash with
less than 500 ppm, PCBs on a paved parking lot. On
August 31, 1989, 55 gallons of D001, F003, and F005
spilled from leaking drums on [Tr. 299] a paved parking
lot.
Q. Are those listed hazardous wastes with EPA code
numbers?
A. Yes.
Q. Go ahead.
A. On September 14, 1989 approximately 70 pounds
of DOO8 waste spilled from a truck at the ChemWaste
scales. On September Ist, 1989, one gallon of F006 haz-
ardous waste leaked onto the pavement at the site when
a truck was parked on an incline. On October 13, 1989,
20 gallons of F003 and F005 and D001 hazardous waste
spilled on facility soil. On November 3, 1989, 25 gallons
of D002 and K062 leaked from a truck at the facility.
On November 8, 1989, 10 gallons of D007 and D008,
spilled from a truck tailgated at the facility. On Decem-
ber 5, 1989, two gallons of D001 and F02 and F005 were
spilled from an unsecured lid on a tanker truck. On
December 13, 1989 approximately 20 gallons of listed
waste spilled from a tanker at the solvent recovery area.
On December 29, 1989, approximately 15 gallons of flam-
mable liquid was spilled on the pavement from a tanker
when the top vent was not secured. On January 16, 1990,
two gallons of liquid from site D004 and D004 hazardous
Toul
ee ee he Ce eee
22
waste spilled from the rear of a rolloff. In the spring of
this year there were some brominated tablets put into the
trench and came in contact with [Tr. 300] some moisture
and caused a release, an orange colored cloud release also.
Q. Now, with respect to all of those spills that have
occurred on site, that you have just identified, were all
of those spills remediated by ChemWaste?
A. Yes, they have.
Q. Now, I notice that beginning from 1984 to 1989
there were—I’m sorry. ’84 up through the beginning of
’89 there were four spills that were reported. Since ’89,
there have been one, two, three, four, five, six, seven,
eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve, by my count, that you
have reported. Is that approximately correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And how does the incident of spills correlate, if it
does, with the increase in the volumes that have been dis-
posed of at Emelle?
CA. Well, the volumes managed on site have increased
since 1985.
* * * *
(Tr. 301] Q. And accordingly then what—is there a
difference between the volumes of out-of-state waste that
are disposed of at Emelle and the volumes that are dis-
posed of from in state?
A. The majority of waste managed at Emelle, accord-
ing to the records provided by ChemWaste, according to
Dr. Henson’s testimony, is from out of state.
Q. And that is the 85 to 90 percent we have been talk-
ing | Tr. 302] about?
A. That is correct.
Q. Is there any reason to believe that those percent-
ages will not continue to hold true with respect to vol-
umes that are disposed of at Emelle in the absence of
the Fee Act which has been enacted, which is in litiga-
tion today?
23
A. As I previously discussed, the number of landfills
are decreasing every year. Some of these landfills have
caps placed on them. The only one that has been cited
within the last 10 years is the Denver, Colorado facility,
which has a cap. The trend is that there are fewer and
fewer landfills that can handle this waste. There are
landfills that are going to be filled up within the next
few years. The GAO reports indicate that EPA just
doesn’t have any idea or good data on the amount of
CERCLA waste that will need to be cleaned up and prop-
erly disposed of, that they don’t have a good feel on the
amount of hazardous waste that will eventually be de-
clared to be hazardous waste. And so, even though you
have the land ban restrictions and that will minimize un-
treated waste going to the landfill, you still have these
forces that are going to increase the amount of waste
that can be hazardous and at the same time the amount
of waste, the amount [Tr. 303] of permitted disposal sites
is decreasing; so, the law of supply and demand would
indicate that the waste would still, the amount of out-of-
state waste, would still be at least the 85 to 90 percent
number, if not greater.
[Tr. 305] Q. And shown on that chart would you ex-
plain what the volumes are since 1985 at the Emelle
facility?
A. Well, as the bar chart indicates, in 1985 Chem-
Waste received 341,000 tons of waste. These are approxi-
mate numbers rounded off. In 1986 they received 456,000
tons. In 1987 they received 564,000 tons. In 1988 they
received 549,000 tons of waste. In 1989 they | Tr. 306] re-
ceived 791,000 tons of waste. And through August of
this year they have received 480,000 tons of waste.
. o * *
[Tr. 310] Q. What effect, if any, have the increased
volumes of disposal at Emelle, not disposal but landfilling
a
ee
Tt al
a
Se
a Se
ee ae eae ee” eee! be ee Pee ee ea, eee
24
of waste at Emelle had on ADEM’s ability to monitor and
otherwise perform its obligations at the Emelle facility?
A. When Emelle was accepting very large tonnages
per month it increased the difficulty of our staff being
able to monitor that operation. They were operating, in
essence, around the clock. There were trucks backed up
out of the gate onto the highway. It was impossible for
ADEM to really be able to adequately monitor the site.
& * * *
(Tr. 316] Q. Now, if you will, please tell the Court the
size and type of leachate storage facilities they have at
Emelle.
A. Emelle has a tank farm that is capable of storing
five million gallons of leachate.
Q. Five million gallons?
A. Yes.
(Tr. 334] Q. For each one of those facilities the post
closure period is 30 years; itn’t it?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Now, where is that 30 years set forth?
A. In EPA and State regulations.
Q. In the EPA and State regulations?
A. That’s right. Our regulations are identical.
Q. Do your regulations have to be identical? They
don’t; do they?
A. No. The EPA, the RCRA law says that states can
be more stringent.
Q. So, if you wanted to extend the post closure care
period beyond 30 years, you could change the State regu-
lations to do it; couldn’t you?
A. I guess that is a discussion. We have considered
that and are evaluating the 11th Circuit’s opinion to
[Tr. 335] determine if we can do that.
(Tr. 336] Q. And I assume if ADEM didn’t like the
way that corporate guarantee was written, since the per-
mit he has got to certify that it is word for word identi-
25
cal with the regulations, you can change the regulations;
is that right? .
A. On the financial assurance part of the regulations,
EPA is very cautious, and I would doubt that we could
change it without stringent tests, because of the necessity
to be equal; but, in theory, you could, yes. .
Q. Okay. What you are saying is the financial assur-
ance required not only in Alabama but everywhere in the
United States has to be word for word identical?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Under EPA regulations?
A. Yes.
* + * *
(Tr. 350] Q. So it would be fair to say that the state-
ments in here where they have any criticisms of post
closure liabilities would apply pretty much equally to any
kind of facility that closes in place?
A. In theory, yes; it is saying there is that same con-
cern.
* * * %
(Tr. 361] Q. So, I take it that if the United States of
America, hypothetically, was a responsible party, that
would relieve some of your concern about the state being
ultimately stuck, if you will, if I can use the vernacular?
A. Again we're getting back on the area of where the
federal government really is liable or would choose to be
liable.
Q. I am asking you to assume, for sake of argument,
they are absolutely, strictly, jointly and severally liable
under 107A CERCLA.
A. You may make a theoretical assumption, then, yes.
* * * ”
(Tr. 364] Q. Now, earlier you were talking generally
about risk, and risk of the what ifs that occur or could
occur, might occur, earthquakes, tornadoes, or hurricanes.
The risks other than volume was the thing that you talked
about Emelle, as I recall?
A. That’s correct.
26
Q. It didn’t really have anything to do with whether
the waste was from in state or out of state?
A. That’s correct.
Q. It really had to do with volume?
A. Quantity, yes.
Q. So you would agree that the risks don’t depend on
where the waste comes from, given equivalent quantities?
(Tr. 365] Q. The risks don’t depend on whether it is
In state waste or out of state waste; your concern is
the volume?
A. The chemical composition at the landfill would not
be any different ; but you would have the transportation
risk we discussed also. And that is related to quantities;
but you have the different routes coming in.
Q. Now, some of the routes coming in, speaking of
transportation, some of the routes coming into Emelle
only travel over Alabama highways just a few miles if
they are coming from the west?
A. Yes. |
Q. And Emelle is almost to Mississippi?
A. Almost in Mississippi, yes.
_ c oe *
(Tr. 366] Q. Now, let me ask you one thing, ji
know it. I think you had talked chews what a Pe ps
calculate as the number of trucks that went into the Emelle
facility in 1989, and I think you came up with a 40,000
figure?
A. In general, yes.
| Tr. 369] Q. Okay. Now, speaking of transporters
you have said, in terms of hazardous waste transportation,
that ADEM regulates hazardous waste transportation?
7 That’s correct.
. And you give them its i i
veniam gi permits if they meet certain
A. That’s correct.
27
Q. And one of the requirements is they have to have
adequate liability insurance to take care of things like
this. This happened to be a chemical spill?
A. That’s correct.
Q. That one you didn’t regulate until it got spilled ;
is that right?
A. That’s right.
_ But the hazardous waste trucks you regulate while
they [Tr. 370] are rolling?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And you wouldn’t give a permit to a hazardous
waste transporter if it didn’t have adequate liability cov-
erage;.would you?
A. We wouldn’t give a permit unless it complied with
the regulations which require that.
Q. The regulations require adequate liability coverage?
A. Correct.
e e * *
[Tr.410] Q. Now, Ms. Robertson, you ended up, |
think, by saying, [Tr. 411] if I caught this correctly, there
are risks inherent to managing hazardous waste; is that
correct?
A. Yes.
Q. So there would be risk to managing hazardous waste
not only at the Emelle facility, not only at the Allied
Signal incinerator, but all of the other 32 additional haz-
arduus waste treatment, storage and disposal facilities;
right?
A. Yes.
ee — 1 ae NS
ee
28
TESTIMONY OF RICHARD GROSHONG
ke! pie 7 Now, Dr. Groshong, do you presently
ach at the University of Alabama as a f ?
Sheet ull professor?
Q. What is your area of concentration or teaching?
A. Structural geology, rock deformation.
a All right, sir. Is it correct that you and Dr.
— Pricey prepared a paper back in April of this
year entitle azardous Waste Disposal ji r
Crustatious Selma Group? oe
A. That is correct. That i
Ss ¢ , is actually a composite
guidebook consisting of three individual papers.
* 7 ” *
(Tr. 268] Q. Incidentally
y, what is the position
Donahoe at the University of Alabama? sae
A. She is an associate professor of geology.
i Q. Now, is it correct that in this study that you
ave done, you have made some comments on the frac-
— — faults and joints out at Emelle?
. Slight comment on that, r ; i
, rather specific comment
on work that we di arby : in FE ‘a
a we did nearby at Port Epps, in Epps, Ala-
Q. Is that Sumter County?
A. Right.
4 aa is significant about Port Epps?
. It’s an excellent exposure of th
P. | : e Selma ch
which we were able to visit and do our work at. ani
! Q. And would you tell us briefly how you may de-
scribe fractures and joints and faults? ,
A. Okay.
4 In whatever order you think appropriate.
A. A fracture is used by many geologists and en-
wn as kind of a general term. Properly it is a
agg and can be a fault with displacement parallel]
r. 269] to the surface, can be a joint with displace-
ment perpendicular to the surface,
29
So, with the paper, we tear it—
Q. Hold that up so the Court can see that. Would
you turn please and face the Court.
A. Okay. This qualifies as a fracture. Now, if it
does nothing more than this (Indicating), then it would
be known in the geological terminology as being a joint;
and a joint might move a little bit open, it might move
a fair amount open; so that would be a joint. And there
are joints in the Selma chalk. The other thing that the
fracture might do is move parallel to its face, in which
case it becomes classified as a fault in the geological
terminology. Faults may, as you can see with this one,
produce gaps and holes along the trend of the fault when
they move.
Q. Now, what you described, those fractures, faults
and joints, were they present in the Selma chalk?
A. They are.
Q. And is that what you have done your paper on?
A. Right.
* * * ad
(Tr. 274] Q. Now, I ask you to look at your paper be-
ginning the next page, Roman Numeral 421, and tell
us in layman’s language, and if you could, just give us
a quick summary of that.
A. Okay. Well, the subject was structures influencing
the permeability of the Selma group in western Alabama.
In the numerous exposures that we have worked on, in-
cluding the one at Epps, we find that there are faults
and joints fairly commonly in the Selma chalk. Both
of those are known geologically to be commonly capable
of transmitting water. So our question was, is there
(Tr. 275] any evidence that the fractures that we see in
this area are capable of transmitting water. And we
found considerable evidence that the faults do, at least
some of the faults do, transmit water. We found less
evidence that the joints transmit water; but the faults
transmit water because they do have holes along them
from place to place, and also some of them are fairly
EQ at OB SD OE Se FS We . Ml
ind ete
30
complex zones of multiple faults, which when they move
do exactly what this piece of paper does, which is they
don’t fit properly like that (Indicating), and consequently
develop holes along the fault zone. We collected some
of the fillings, because these faults are characterized by
having calcite fillings. We collected some of the fillings,
and some of them are completely filled and appear to be
nonconductive; others there are holes that you can stick
your pencil into, in these fillings, where it is simply an
incomplete filling. The fillings are calcite that was de-
posited from saturated fluids, presumably from deep un-
derground. The fillings also show evidence that they have
been subsequently chemically etched, which means they
have been attacked by unsaturated fluids which is char-
acteristic of shallow ground water. So, that is one of
the evidences that these faults are transmitting ground
water today. Other evidence is that they are [Tr. 276]
significantly stained by iron, and only the faults were
stained. We didn’t find evidence of that on the joints.
Of course, the fairly out in the field evidence is that the
water was leaking out of the faults in the outcrop and
the plants were growing on the faults in the outcrop
as opposed to no water leaking out of intact chalk, and
no plants growing on the intact chalk in this area. So
that is the basic evidence that we had.
Q. How deep do these faults and fractures extend
into the Selma chalk, in your opinion?
A. As far as we know, they could go completely
through the chalk. We really don’t know. No one knows.
as far as I am aware.
Q. Do you mean all the way down to the Eutaw
aquifer?
A. Perfectly possible.
Q. Now, is the area around the faults and fractures
more or less permeable than the chalk itself?
A. Well, I would judge that the fault zone itself would
be more permeable than the chalk itself. It could be
more permeable by many orders of magnitude.
31
Q. What do you mean by many orders of magnitude?
A. By factor of a thousand, factor of 10,000. It en-
tirely depends upon how big the hole is and whether it
has been completely filled or partially filled. oe
(Tr. 277] Q. Now, did you reach a conclusion in your
paper, reach an opinion back earlier this year as to
whether, in your opinion, the fractures, faults, rather,
at the Emelle facility had been properly mapped?
A. We find no evidence that they have been mapped.
There are certainly no maps that I have been able to see.
So, I would have to say that, to my knowledge, they have
not been properly mapped.
Q. At my request on Thursday of last week, Thursday
and Friday, did you review the Golder & Associates re-
ports which were identified and have been identified in
this case, some 12, I believe, and the two Woodward
Clyde reports which have been furnished us by the plain-
tiff which we, in turn, furnished you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, after having reviewed those reports, do they,
in any way, affect that opinion you had reached back
in April?
A. Well, they confirm it in part. We inferred from
aerial photo studies that probably there were faults in
the pits at Emelle. Also we had photographs taken by
other people that showed the faults in the pits. The re-
ports confirmed that.
Q. Were those the pictures of trench 16, I think, that
were in the book?
(Tr. 278] A. That are in our book, right. So the re-
port did confirm the presence of the faults, and the
Woodward Clyde report, one of them, discussed doing
permeability tests on three of the faults, and their per-
meability tests showed, as far as they were concerned,
no difference in permeability on the faults than in the
rock around it, which doesn’t really alter my opinion,
because that would be true on the faults we saw our-
selves, depending upon where you measured the fault,
32
because the faults change their properties along the plain
of the fault. So, to actually document that the fault
doesn’t leak anywhere, you have to see the whole fault
and then you have to decide whether there are no holes
along the fault or whether, in fact, there is maybe, let’s
say, ona 50 foot exposure of a fault you might find two
significant holes six inches in length. So, I have no idea
whether the worst part of the fault was tested or not.
Q. Would there be anything in the Golder & Asso-
clates or these other two Woodward Clyde reports that
would indicate that had been done?
A. No. As far as I could tell, it was not done.
Q. What is your opinion, after having read these re-
ports, the 12 or so Golder & Associates reports and the
two Woodward Clyde reports?
[ Tr. 279] A. My opinion would be they really have no
idea whether the faults are potentially going to leak.
Q. Do you have an opinion as to whether the water
is moving laterally in the Selma chalk?
A. It certainly was in the exposures that we looked
at, otherwise we wouldn’t be able to see evidence of the
water moving out of the fault zones. I guess I really
don’t have an informed opinion about the waste site
itself.
Q. Now, did anyone pay for the paper that you pre-
pared, the time and effort that went into it?
Ln No; this was scientific research, just part of the
job.
Q. Originally who was to publish—
A. Originally this was to be published as a part of a
meeting related guidebook series to be published by the
State Geological Survey. ;
aun Did the State Geological Survey, in fact, publish
is?
A. Not this one, no.
Q. Was there any reason stated as to why not?
A. Nothing in writing. Informally I was told that
this was too controversial, they didn’t want to publish it.
33
Q. Who, in fact, did publish it, this paper?
A. The Alabama Geological Society, which is an or-
ganization | Tr. 280] of geologists.
Q. Of geologists here in Alabama?
A. Right.
Q. Approximately how many members?
A. Maybe a hundred and fifty.
Q. Are most geologists in Alabama members of that
society?
A. Probably the vast majority.
Q. Now, in your opinion, is it possible for the frac-
tures and faults to extend all the way down to the Eutaw
aquifer?
A. It is very possible. And we really don’t know why
those faults are there. Every place we have seen very
good exposures of the Selma chalk we tend to see the
faults. So, as far as I know, we have seen a fair amount
of it in different places.
Q. In your opinion, is it possible that the faults or
fractures that could extend vertically down into the Eutaw
aquifer, would they have increased permeability of sev-
eral orders of magnitude?
A. It is certainly possible.
Q. What about laterally at the surface?
A. It would be the same.
(Tr. 281] Q. Dr. Groshong, as I understand it, you did
not do a study of the Emelle facility; is that correct?
A. Not within the facility. We did a photo study, an
aerial photo, taken of the site.
Q. You did not do any studies on the ground or in
the ground at the facility?
A. No.
* o * *
(Tr. 282] Q. You have never done any hydrogeological
characterization of the Emelle facility; have you?
A. No,
|
i
|
|
1
|
|
|
|
|
)
.
|
a = -—-
SS ll ce
34
Q. All right, sir. You have also not done geochemi-
cal studies of the Emelle facility; have you?
* * * *
[Tr. 283] Q. Have you ever—I assume as a geologist
you have done permeability tests?
A. I haven’t done the test, no.
Q. You actually have never done a permeability test
of anything?
A. That’s true.
Q. Okay. Well, I guess you didn’t do any permeabil-
ity tests of any of this Selma chalk then; did you?
A. Nothing.
35
TESTIMONY OF BILL BROCK
[Tr.416] Q. Would you state your name, please?
A. My name is Bill Brock.
Q. What is your title?
A. I am the Director of the Alabama Emergency
Management Agency.
Q. What is the function of the Alabama Emergency
Management Agency?
A. My agency is one that controls, manages, monitors
any emergency situation that might occur within the state
of Alabama.
'Tr.417! Q. Well, would your agency have a role to
play, say, in the event of an accident on a highway?
A. Depending upon the severity and if it was an ac-
cident carrying some kind of hazardous material or
chemical! spills or volatile or explosive material.
Q. What about natural disasters?
A. Yes, sir, we are responsible for emergency re-
covery phase of any disaster.
Q. Mr. Brock, are you aware that Chemical Waste
Management operates a facility at Emelie, Alabama?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that is located in Sumter County; is it not?
A. That’s correct, yes, sir.
Q. Are you aware that ChemWaste has a contingency
plan that has been introduced already as Defendant’s
Exhibit Number 55?
A. Yes, sir, I am.
Q. And the contingency plan identifies possible emer-
gencies that might occur on site; is that correct?
A. That is correct, yes, sir.
Q. And just briefly, isn’t it also correct that the
contingency plan identifies both emergencies that are
inherent to facilities operations, that is fires and acci-
dents and spills, as well as natural disasters that might
occur, such as tornadoes?
[Tr.418] A. AsT have read it, yes, sir.
36
Q. Now, would the Emergency Management Agency
play a role in the event of an emergency of any kind at
Emelle?
A. At Emelle or any other site if the emergency ex-
pands or continues to grow to the point it surpasses the
ability of that community, that subdivision, to handle it
themselves, at that point then we are there to dispatch
any other state or federal resources that are necessary in
the recovery or cleanup or any other problems that may
be occurring.
Q. In fact, the contingency plan identifies your agency
as the contact source; does it not?
A. That is correct, yes, sir.
Q. Are you familiar with the recent history of tor-
nadoes and severe thunderstorms in the Sumter County
area?
A. Yes, sir.
a And md for the last 12 months or so, can you tell
e Court whether there have been an
Sumter County? ae
A. According to our log book and the duty officers, we
maintain a duty cfficer 24 hours a day, and direct contact
by telephone and radio with the public safety people state-
wide in the region of the southeastern United States, and
also direct lines with the National Weather Service, and
any time a storm front approaches [Tr. 419] we are
notified and we have our own radar system that we mon-
itor these storms with as they develop and come in out
of > rege In the last 12 months in Sumter County
we have recorded 10 severe thundersto i
sae rm watches in Sum-
e be is a thunderstorm watch?
watch is a description issued or a cate i
gory is-
sued by the National Weather Service that said the Ae
system or cold front moving in has the potential of devel-
oping severe thunderstorms, that you need to be on the
37
Q. How does that contrast with a warning?
A. Well, in the stages as it progresses the watch oc-
curs and then when the storm starts developing and the
clouds start building in size and severity, at that point,
or some point in between, they say a severe thunderstorm
has formed. You see the intensity levels change on the
radar screen and that determines at the point a new
warning is issued, because you have seen a thunderstorm
cell build. Usually when the thunderstorm warning exists,
at that point the National Weather point will issue a
tornado watch. When the severity of the storm builds to
the point of level five or level six, the potential of a tor-
nado is forming or microbursts [Tr. 420] that are now
being identified as we have had in the last few weeks in
Alabama. They can form out of a severe thunderstorm
at any time without warning; so usually we will issue a
tornado watch at that point. Then when the tornado
watch is there, that immediately notifies us as well as the
meteorologist to be on the watch to watch those thunder-
storm cells as they travel across the state and to look
for any further development. If we see that, then a tor-
nado warning is then issued. A tornado warning can
also be issued when there is a definite hook symbol on the
radar screen or there has been a visual sighting of a
tornado.
Q. Now, you have your log book there; do you not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many severe thunderstorm warnings have
been made for Sumter County in the last 12 months?
A. In the records that we maintain we had 10 thun-
derstorm watches, four of those turned into thunder-
storm warnings. Of the four thunderstorm warnings we
had eight tornado watches for Sumter County, with two
tornado warnings, which means there were at least two
tornadoes sighted. One was within a half a mile of the
Emelle facility in Sumter County.
38
Q. When did that occur?
A. The sighting of the tornado that was within half a
(Tr. 421] mile of the site, to my recollection, without
going back through the records, would be in the second
week of February.
Q. Of this year?
A. Of this year.
(Tr. 428]
Q. Would you indicate to the Court from this exhibit,
Number 60,— Would you tell the Court what accidents
(Tr. 429| have occurred involving vehicles destined for
Emelle since 1981?
A. Would you like for me to start at the top?
Q. Yes.
A. On 2/10/81 a truck carrying acid had run off I-20
spilling the material. EPA was not notified until 2/20,
some 10 days later. On 3/27/81,—
MR. DeBRAY: Judge, the exhibit has been offered,
and I assume it will be admitted into evidence. Is the
witness going to read this entire exhibit into the record?
THE COURT: Has the exhibit been—
MR. SIMON: We can move on, Your Honor. We
offer it in evidence.
THE COURT: All right, I will admit the exhibit over
their objection.
Q. Mr. Brock, do you have an opinion, based on your
experience, as to whether an increased number of trucks
going to Emelle would increase the likelihood of accidents?
MR. DeBRAY: Objection. He hasn’t laid the proper
foundation that this witness can give an opinion of that
nature.
THE COURT: Ask him if he can.
Q. Can you give an opinion on that, Mr. Brock?
[Tr. 430] <A. Yes, sir, I feel I can.
39
Q. What is your opinion?
A. Any time you have an increase of traffic, whether
it be trucks, cars, or what, in a concentrated area such
as a rural area of Alabama where the roads were not
designed for large volume truck traffic, you are bound
to have some type of traffic buildup or backup of vehicles
in those areas, because the roads are not designed to
handle this volume of vehicles. If this is occurring at the
time we have a tornado warning, or a tornado watch, we
have got exact history recorded of what happened in
Huntsville, Alabama on November 15 of last. It was at
rush hour, the intersection started backing up with traf-
fic when the tornado came through. The majority of the
deaths that were recorded in Huntsville, Alabama from
that tornado was because of that backup or volume of
traffic on those highways. Had there not been that much
volume, had there not been that many vehicles on that
road, there would not have been as many deaths. So, at
the same time those large volumes, and I understand
some days it is in excess of a hundred trucks a day that
are going into that particular facility, it has to create a
volume or an impact on the roadways of that area.
. . * *
(Tr. 434] Q. Let me ask you this, based on your posi-
tion as Director of the Emergency Management Agency,
has the agency received any report of earthquakes?
A. Only in the last four to six months. I would say
it would be in the last six months I have been following
and monitoring the earthquake situation in the state of
Alabama. In the last four months I have instructed my
staff to start a map, start an indexing of all reported
incidences of earth tremors or earthquakes within the
boundaries of the state of Alabama. This was in prepara-
tion for a scientific prediction of what is proposed to
happen on December 2nd or 3rd of this year. The scien-
tifie community is currently studying. It has been a lot
of news reports about this particular event that is sup-
40
posed to happen in the New Madrid Fault area of New
Madrid, Missouri. Alabama is in the risk zone. We have
a risk potential all the way to an area just north of
Montgomery. In that particular area it depends on the
severity and scale of the earthquake that is supposed to
happen at that time, I felt that it would be a prudent
thing to do to start monitoring the activity, because I
just felt we would [Tr. 435] have some news inquiries,
media inquiries, about activity in the state of Alabama.
So, not only in our duty log do we record these things but
the reports we get from the central United States Earth-
quake Consortium, those reports are also recorded and one
of those particular reports, Lamar County, I believe in
May of this year, recorded an earthquake of a three scale
on the Richter scale in Lamar County. We have other
recorded incidents in northwest and west Alabama of
various tremor activity.
Q. Is Emelle in the risk zone?
A. Yes, sir, it falls within the risk zone.
a * 7. *
[Tr. 437] Q. Now, Mr. Brock, the earthquake zone
that you talked about, the risk zone that you said was
throughout north and northwest Alabama, I believe; is
that correct?
A. That’s correct. That is from the New Madrid
fault.
Q. So, facilities throughout that entire area would be
[Tr. 438] at risk; would they not?
Yes, sir.
Manufacturing facilities?
Yes, sir.
Storage facilities?
Yes, sir.
The chemical companies up there that store haz-
ardous materials, they would be at risk; is that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
SOP Ore
41
Q. You were asked a question about the contingency
plan of Emelle. Have you ever read that?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know whether or not that is in accordance
with ADEM regulations?
A. Iam not familiar with ADEM. It is in accordance
with SARA Title 3 program that we have to model the
federal government. We have approved that particular
plan with our people.
Q. So you had input in approving that plan; is that
correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You didn’t call for that plan to make any kind
of contingency, for example, for earthquakes; did you?
A. My people had the input in improving the plan.
I, in turn, direct and manage my people; but the par-
ticular area of earthquake preparedness, no, I am _ not
my [Tr. 439] that anything was asked to be put into
that
Q. Now, the tornadoes that you tziked about?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Those tornadoes are not indiginous to Sumter
County, are they? I mean, tornadoes can happen any-
where?
A. That’s correct.
Q. And you heard testimony here today that there are
34 hazardous waste treatment facilities in the state of
Alabama; have you not?
A. I don’t know.
Q. You were in the Courtroom; were you not?
A. Not at that particular point of the testimony.
Q. Believe me when I tell you that is what she testi-
fied. And if that is what she testified to, tornadoes—those
facilities would be subject to tornadoes just like the
Emelle facility; isn’t that correct?
A. That would be correct.
42
Q. When a tornado hits, it takes everything above
ground; doesn’t it?
A. Above; and if it happens to go over an open pool
of water, there are records where it actually drained that
pool of water and sucked it up like a vacuum cleaner.
Q. So, if there is waste buried underneath the ground,
it’s not necessarily subject to any kind of tornado?
[Tr.440] A. I think that would be an accurate assump-
tion.
[Tr. 453] Q. So, if waste was enroute to the Emelle
facility from the state of Michigan and had an accident,
there was a spill or incident, that required response by
your branch of government, then it wouldn’t be treated
any differently than if there were wastes that were
originated from up in the Mobile area coming to the Emelle
facility?
A. That is a correct assumption.
Q. Are the risks associated with the waste different
dependent upon the point of origin? In other words, is
there anymore risk associated with waste that originates
in the state of Michigan as waste that originates in the
city of Mobile?
A. The only risk that we would have a reason to ques-
tion the level of risk would be the volume of it. If it was
a pickup truck load from Mobile and three tanker loads
from Michigan, then naturally the risk is going to be
greater from the three tanker loads than it would be from
the pickup truck load from Mobile.
Q. If there is a tanker load from the state of Texas
and a tanker load from the city of Mobile, carrying the
same substance to the Emelle facility?
A. Under that particular scenario the risk we assume,
that we would determine, would be equal.
* * * -*
43
TESTIMONY OF TOM JOINER
Tr. 484] A. The one big question that has been kicked
around with respect to this Selma chalk is does it have any
water in it. You have heard that it doesn’t have any
water until it gets to 140 feet, which is the potentiometric
surface of the Eutaw. This study, and the other work
that had been done with shallow monitoring wells, tells
you there is water in the Selma chalk, and there is water
in the Selma chalk right up to very close to the land sur-
face. And it tells you that the water in the Selma chalk
does move. It will move from the high areas to the low
areas. Another thing that was significant on this par-
ticular study was the fact that the day before they took
their piezometer reading, the level of water in those wells
they had drilled, they went and checked the level of the
fluid in the trenches and these trenches have been placed
on here, and so this depicts the situation where these
trenches have filled with water.
(Tr. 485] Q. Which trenches?
A. All trenches shown on here, as depicted, have filled
with water to the level of the water table. They have
reached equilibrium with the water table. These arrows
that you see here. These arrows that you see here are
their interpretation of the way that water flows. You will
note it indicates definite lateral and downward movement
of the water. It is noting lateral and downward move-
ment of water out of these trenches. And getting to the
definition of leachate, that would be water that had come
in contact with the material in the trenches. Then you
would have to assume, on the basis of this diagram, that
leachate has moved out of the trenches into the Selma
chalk.
[Tr.492] Q. Now, I believe you also said that in your
opinion the water, since it was at equilibrium with the
water table, that the leachate or fluid from the trenches
would be into the Selma chalk; is that correct?
A. The flow that comes through the trenches is shown
moving out into the Selma chalk, that’s correct.
44
Q. And you say it is shown moving out into the Selma
chalk. Would you tell us what you are referring to?
A. Here is the arrow showing the flow direction. These
are flow vectors, as they call them, nonscaling. That
doesn’t mean anything quantitative; but it is just the
direction you would have flow movement.
Q. Now, if left as is, if left undisturbed, what would
be the direction of the movement of the leachate from
those trenches?
A. Well, if you were to just leave this alone and let
it flow, follow the flow vectors here, you can see that the
water is going to keep moving seeking its lowest level.
And by these flow vectors you can get in here and see that
at some point you will have some upward flow into the
stream. Now, you have also got a factor here that after
you get down to about 138 [Tr. 493] or 140 feet you start
getting some artesian pressure from the Eutaw.
Q. That is not depicted here; but you say that is the
—what would you call that point at 140 feet approxi-
mately?
A. I would call that potentiometric surface of the
Eutaw formula.
Q. So you are dealing here with two different things;
surface water on one hand and ground water in the Eutaw
on the other hand, and in the subcategory of ground water,
or a different category being ground water in the upper
portions of the—below the water table but within 10 to 12
feet of the surface up in the Demopolis chalk?
A. You have this water in the water table conditions,
yes; and you have the flow regimen that they have estab-
lished for this. Then also there is the Eutaw potentio-
metric surface that has to be considered in the overall
scheme of things. But, with the flow coming down it will
continue coming downgrade, downhill, if you will, until it
discharges at the land surface into a drainage area or
stream.
Q. Into what?
A. Into drainage area or stream.
——e
45
Q. You mentioned drainage area. Looking at the first
(Tr. 494] overlay on Exhibit 64, would you point out in
the vicinity of these trenches is there a particular drainage
area nearby?
A. You do have a drainage course coming in just north
of trench 7, that extends off slightly northwestward, and
you have another one here running going north—north-
west, just north of trench 7.
Q. Is there a downward gradient coming from those
closed trenches depicted on Exhibit 67 down into this
drainage area?
A. I do not have this drainage area related elevation-
wise to this section, so I can’t speak for that directly on
that. The thing I can tell you is that the movement of
water is downward in that direction, and, you know, it
is indicated on these sections. And it is also shown on
this potentiometric map. It shows the level of that sur-
_ water is progressing lower and lower as it comes
own.
THE COURT: ‘s this the kind of thing that they look
at when they determine whether they are going to make
this interim permit permanent or not? Does anybody
know that? Go ahead.
Q. All right, sir, this, of course, is stated to be—this
was August 1990, and I believe you testified to that; but
is it, then—what is the first wet water |Tr. 495] all year
round creek that runs in the area, or stream that runs in
this general area?
A. I guess Bodiker Creek would be the nearest one that
I know of.
Q. This is Bodiker Creek running in a roughly north-
wardly direction?
A. Generally northeasterly trend up there; and it goes
up there a ways and then runs into the Natsuga River, I
believe, and turns into the Tombigbee River.
Q. Do you know approximately how far the Tombigbee
River would be from this point?
A. No, sir, I haven’t measured that.
46
Q. Then is the Tombigbee River the boundary of
Sumter County to the east?
A. It may be. I’m not sure. Do you want me to check?
Q. Yes, sir. Let’s look at this map. Turn it over.
Looking now at the Alabama Geological Survey.
A. The Tombigbee River would be the easternmost
boundary of Sumter County, apparently all the way from
the northern part of the county to the southern boundary.
Q. Okay. Let me ask you, is there anything further
you want to say abou: that?
A. I was going to say as the crow flies it looks like it
would be about 10 miles over to the Tombigbee River
from the Emelle site.
(Tr. 496] Q. That is a straight line?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Then, can you give any estimate, in your opinion,
or do you have an opinion as to a travel time from the
trenches to the drainage area? Do you have any opinion
as to how far the leachate has moved out into the Selma
chalk or Demopolis chalk?
A. No, sir.
Q. What are variables that would impact on travel
time in this surface area of this leachate that has moved
out into the Selma chalk from the closed trenches as de-
picted on the Golder reports?
A. You are referring to travel time or migration?
Q. Migration. Excuse me.
A. I think the variables would be the material through
which the water had to move, and the condition of the
material. If it is just solid unfractured chalk it would
have one rate of movement; if it was just solid jointed
chalk it would probably be very close to that same rate.
And if one of the brittle faults, as described by Dr.
Groshong, existed you could have along that another
rate.
Q. Would that be a faster rate?
A. It would be a faster rate if the fault existed as
described in some of these.
* -_ * *
47
(Tr.510] Q. Let’s talk about risks to Alabama from
the operation of the Emelle facility and the dangers,
whatever, from a hydrogeologic engineering point of view.
A. Weii, | summarized for you, and I think I gave to
Mr. Wells in deposition, the major concern that we, we
being my staff and I saw, was the fact that this facility
is in Alabama, it is going to be here forever, and the
long term liability of the facility was a major concern.
The facility will have to be monitored. It will have to
have regulatory surveillance. It will have to be main-
tained. It will have to be secured. And if there are
any upsets of any kind that require abandonment or
remediation, that will have to be done.
Q. Now, let’s talk about monitoring. What do you
mean with resnect to monitoring?
A. Well, the monitoring that { am talking about right
there would be the maintenance of good monitoring wells
suitably placed, and hoping that you don’t have any sur-
prises with an unknown brittle fault as described by Dr.
Groshong, bypassing that. That is an uncertainty that
rests out there. But, at any rate, as they have done to
this point, and I am sure they wil! in the future, you will
have to make your best stab at installing and keeping a
good monitoring well system {Tr.511] there, which can
be checked and provide a measure of quality assurance in
the future.
Q. With that good monitoring well installation, would
that include efforts to try to intersect every brittle fault
from the various trenches?
A. I think, you know, as trenches are excavated they
can see what they have in the trench area, and decisions
for placement of monitoring wells can and are being made
on a basis of that, is my understanding. That is some-
thing that is just going to have to continue. Now, after
operations are ceased, there will be no new ones; so you
have to hope in the process of getting all of this done that
you are able to get any of these fractures or faults that
could be problems pinpointed.
48
Q. Do you know whether all of the fractures at this
time have been mapped?
A. I would be very surprised if all of the fractures
and faults have been mapped. I think they’ve probably
documented all that they have encountered in the trenches
that have been excavated.
Q. In your opinion, would it be wise, in attempting to
make sure that the monitoring wells are placed every-
where, to attempt to map all of the faults, brittle faults,
or whatever?
A. I doubt if they can map all of them. There is a
limit [Tr.512] to what you can do on the land surface
to look underneath. That will remain an uncertainty.
Q. No matter how many monitoring wells are put in,
from a practical point of view?
A. From a practical point of view, yes, sir.
[Tr.513] A. The findings of the Golder report are
significant, because they demonstrate that you can have
outward migration of this leachate toward the surface
water in the state. And from the standpoint that it is a
potential threat to the state of Alabama, I am concerned.
I would think that from the standpoint of—well, I will
just speak for myself. That is all you asked me for?
Q. Yes, sir. You mentioned secure. What do you
mean by that?
A. I mentioned secure the facility from the standpoint
of not letting people in there to have vehicle races, to
disturb the surface, the security of the facility, both
from the standpoint of the facility keeping it, (Tr. 514]
keeping the integrity of the facility good and intact.
And also from a safety standpoint of somebody getting
in there and not knowing what they are dealing with and
maybe create a problem for themselves and others. As
far as the maintenance, not to leave that completely,
maintenance of the grounds, you know. I think we have
a lot of that grassed over and maintained and other
49
structures on it: but maintenance of the grounds against
future erosion. You know, it is one thing to think 30
years and something else to think a hundred years: but
when you think about it’s going to be there as long as
this state is here, then that puts another perspective on
it. So, that could be a significant factor.
Q. You mentioned—was there some other? You had
abatement and remediation; but was there anything else
before that with respect to maintenance, security, and
monitoring?
A. Regulatory surveillance. And somebody, Sue Rob-
ertson’s peonle, or somebody in ADEM, is going to have
the regulatory responsibility for this facility as long as
it is there. They are going to have to insure that things
that need to be done get done. So, that is an ongoing
factor.
* * * *
[Tr. 515] Q. From a geological scientific point of view
or hydrogeological point of view, what, if anything,—
would there be anything involved with possible abate-
ment?
A. If a brittle fault, such as described by Dr. Grosh-
ong, existed and was capable of transmitting liquids un-
detected, the liquids could move through that fault and
be missed by your monitoring wells. Then that could, you
know, without having any specific information on how
fast the liquid can flow through those brittle faults. it
could be a few years or it could be many years: but still
quite a bit faster than liquid would move through the
chalk itself. C ~leivably you could have outward migra-
tion through on ‘hose type features that would create
a problem that ... «ii have to be remedied, have to either
abate it or go ahee." and remedy [Tr. 516]_it completely.
Q. From a geological scientific point of view what. if
anything, would there be from a remediation factor?
A. Well, that was the kind of thing that I was talking
about with abatement. If vou can stop it and it is some-
thing you can tie in with your regular monitoring and
50
regulatory surveillance, that is okay. If it has created
enough of a problem that you have to go in and remove
some of it and remedy that particular problem, then that
is the remediation I was talking about.
* . * *
[Tr. 518] Q. Would it be significant, in your opinion,
as to whether or not there had been a previous earthquake
in the Sumter County area?
A. I think it would be significant in that having once
happened there you feel reasonably sure it could happen
there again.
[Tr. 519] Q. Is the existence of a major water system,
such as the Tombigbee, a factor to be considered in meas-
uring the risk from national disasters, such as an earth-
quake, or from contamination of ground water, excuse
me, surface water?
A. It is very difficult to project or hypothesize natural
disasters, particularly as you would deal with something
as unknown as, you know, the magnitude, whether it is
going to hit or not, whether the magnitude is there or
not, to try to relate it to something in Bodiker Creek or
Tombigbee River, I think, you know, if you wanted to
come from a consequence of an earthquake to this region
of Sumter County, the one thing. and probably it would
not take a major earthquake to do this, just one where
you could feel the trembling of the ground, it could have
an impact on cracking the material that seals some of the
faults and open those again for the [Tr. 520] movement
of water through them. You know, I suppose you could
create all kinds of nightmarish situations for yourself
with respect to what a major one would be; but certainly
I am not in a position to do that. But if they did—if you
did have the effect that I was talking about, then that
could open avenues for the movement of water that do not
exist today. And that could have a fairly strong bearing
on future liability. .
51
Q. In your opinion, is there any likelihood of increased
knowledge, scientific, geologic point of view, that as we
learn more about hazardous waste and its geological and
hydrological effect from speaking on hazardous waste as
landfilled in a facility such as Emelle, do you anticipate
future increases in liability or risk or danger to the state?
A. Well, I think there’s no question but what there
will be additional knowledge gained about handling it,
storing it, the hazards associated with it, and this kind
of thing. And as that knowledge is developed and as
technology evolves to respond to it, it probably will result
in some changes in the regulations. And as changes in
regulations occur, it could mean more monitoring in some
instances for parameters not presently being monitored.
It could increase the amount and [Tr. 521] level of effort
that would have to be done in the future as this tech-
nology evolves.
Q. And the future long range cost of whoever it is
during that time doing the monitoring?
A. Whoever is doing the monitoring and the mainte-
nance, keeping the security.
Q. Of course, involved in the monitoring and removal
of leachate would be the handling of that leachate after
- it Was removed; would that not be correct?
A. That is correct.
* * * *
| Tr. 527] A. My opinion is that as far as the state of
Alabama is concerned, the more waste that we have in
the state the higher our future liability is with respect
to the facility.
Q. You are speaking of the hazardous waste landfill
facility at Emelle?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Would that be speaking of more additional waste
brought into the hazardous waste landfill facility at
Emelle?
A. The more waste we have and the more area that is
prepared to receive the waste, the larger the facility be-
52
comes, the more monitoring wells you need, the more
maintenance will be required, you increase the area that
you have to keep secure, and you have increased amount
of material that is down there to possibly create a problem.
(Tr. 546] Q. You agree, don’t you, Mr. Joiner, that
because of the Selma chalk the Emelle facility is the best
location for a hazardous waste management facility like
this in the state of Alabama; don’t you?
A. I’m not sure how many turns you have in that
question. I will not say the Emelle facility is the best
site in the state of Alabama, because I think we have
other areas within the chalk belt that could accommodate
a similar facility just as well.
Q. Well, that—
MR. NETTLES: Had you completed your answer?
MR. WELLS: I'm sorry. I didn’t mean to interrupt.
Q. But essentially the Selma chalk area?
|Tr. 547] A. The Selma chalk area for this type facil-
ity, in my Opinion, is the best that we have in the state
of Alabama.*
[Tr. 555] Q. Your opinion is based on the fact that
water will move in the Selma chalk?
A. That’s correct.
Q. Albeit it at a very, very, very slow rate?
MR. NETTLES: How many verys?
MR. WELLS: I think I had three; but I might not
have given enough.
Q. Is that correct?
A. It moves at a very slow rate, yes, sir.
Q. I believe you said that is one of the reasons this is
a good site for a facility such as this?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, in terms of anything moving through the
chalk, it is not going to depend on whatever it is that is
53
moving through the chalk, whether it came from in Ala-
bama or out of state; is it?
A. You will need to give me that one in another form,
maybe, or something.
Q. It is not going to make any difference in terms of
movement of liquid through the chalk whether the
| Tr. 556] material in the trench is from in state or out
of state; is it?
Il.
IIL.
a4
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 61
BERNARD L. WEBB
General
Born, November 27, 1924; married; two children;
4841 Mill Brook Drive, Dunwoody, Georgia 30338.
Degrees and Designations
M.S. Business Administration—University of Rich-
mond, 1964
B.S. Business Administration—University of Rich-
mond, 1949
Fellow, Casualty Actuarial Society—1964
C.P.C.U.—1956
Teaching Experience
Georgia State University, 1967-1989
Member, National CPCU Examination Panel,
1978—Present
C.P.C.U. Preparation Classes for Norfolk, Virginia
Association of Insurance Agents and State Farm
Insurance Companies, 1956-1962; Georgia Chap-
ter, Society of CPCU, 1968-Present
Member, American Academy of Actuaries, 1966
University of Richmond, 1957-1962
Member, National CPCU Grading Panel, 1961-1979
Wisconsin State University, 1963-64
Director, Basic Insurance School, National Associ-
ation of Professional Insurance Agents, 1980,
1981 and 1982
Insurance Institute for Asia and the Pacific, 1982
|
-
or
or
IV. Honors and Awards
VI.
Robert Kk. Early Visiting Scholar at the American
Institute for Property and Liability Underwrit-
ers, 1977 and 1980
Alumni Distinguished Professor, College of Busi-
ness Administration, Georgia State University,
1978
Ben F. Hadley Award, Griffith Foundation for In-
surance Education, 1976
Professional Organizations
American Academy of Actuaries
American Risk and Insurance Association
Casualty Actuarial Society
International Actuarial Association
Society for Insurance Research
Society of Chartered Property and Casualty Under-
writers (Past President of the Georgia, Virginia
and Northern Wisconsin Chapters; Past Editor
of CPCU Annals (now CPCU Journal)
Southern Risk and Insurance Association
Insurance Experience
Consultant to the Multistate Antitrust Task Force,
1988 to present.
Consultant to the Florida Academic Task Force for
the Review of the Insurance and Tort Liability
Systems, 1987-88.
Director, Physicians Insurance Company of Michi-
gan, 1985 to present.
Consultant to the United Nations Commission on
Trade and Development, 1984
"4
56
Consultant to the U.S. Department of Justice,
1977-1980
Consultant to the Subcommittee on Antitrust and
Monopoly of the Committee on the Judiciary of
the United States Senate, 1968, 1969
Actuarial Specialist, Hardware Mutual Casualty
Company, 1964-1967
Marketing Specialist (Research), Hardware Mu-
tual Casualty Company, 1962-1964
Executive Secretary, Insurance Advisory Commit-
tee of the City of Richmond, Virginia, 1955-1962
Sales Correspondent, Hardware Mutual Casualty
Company, 1953-1955
57
PLAINTIFI’S EXHIBIT 62
{State Seal |
STATE OF ALABAMA
Governor’s Office
Montgomery 36130
For Immediate Release
August 27, 1987 Contact: Terry Abbott
Stacey Rimer
261-7150
MONTGOMERY: Gov. Guy Hunt Thursday said he will
develop legislation to curtail the dumping of hazardous
and solid wastes in Alabama while the Alabama Depart-
ment of Environmental Management pursues new regula-
tions to address such health problems.
“IT wish to make it absolutely clear that we will take
any and all action available to us to keep out-of-state
waste out of Alabama. We will handle our own problem
but we don’t want anybody else’s problems,’ Gov. Hunt
said.
Gov. Hunt said he will push safeguards to ensure that
solid waste generated out-of-state destined for an Ala-
bama disposal location is comparable to that generated
in-state and does not contain hazardous or infectious
waste which are excluded from disposal in state sites.
He also called for “increased involvement of county
and municipal governing bodies in assuming more local
responsibility for approving the sighting of sanitary land-
fills” as specified in the Alabama solid waste disposal act
in section 22-27-5 of the Alabama code.
Gov. Hunt also said he wants existing facilities which
intend to begin accepting much larger volumes of solid
waste to secure a permit modification that would be as
closely scrutinized as are applications for new facilities.
58
“Tl feel there must be more stringent siting require-
ments for commercial hazardous waste landfills and in-
cineration facilities. Secondly, we must consider a cap
or limit on the amount of waste received by commercial
facilities,” Gov. Hunt said.
“Although I have publicly proclaimed that ‘Alabama
is Open for Business,’ I would like to clarify that state-
ment by saying that this welcome is not extended to those
in the business of burying solid, hazardous, or infectious
wastes in our soil... or to those that would pose a threat
to the quality of life for the citizens of this state,” Gov.
Hunt said.
“A major crisis facing this state, and this nation, is
that of waste management. Whereas the volume of both
hazardous and solid waste increases daily, the disposal
alternatives are diminishing,” Gov. Hunt said.
Gov. Hunt cited the recently internationally publicized
incident involving the barge-load of garbage which left
the Long Island community of Islip on March 22.
“After a five month ‘odyssey’ during which the waste
was rejected by five states and three foreign countries, a
solution was finally found, to return it to New York
State, burn it, and bury the residue. In other words, the
problem was returned to its point of origin for a solu-
tion,”’ Gov. Hunt said.
The governor questioned if such situations would be
more common in the future.
“My conclusion is that they will and that Alabama has
the potential to become a prime candidate for disposal
based on available land area, favorable geographical con-
ditions, and, in some instances, waste disposal fees which
provide an economic incentive to ‘bring it to Alabama,’ ”
Goy. Hunt said. :
Gov. Hunt reviewed several recent events regarding
solid waste disposal which reinforce his hypothesis.
59
Gov. Hunt said within the last month, state and en-
vironmental officials have had six inquiries from both
existing sites, as well as proposed new facilities regard-
ing the acceptance of large quantities of solid waste gen-
erated by out-of-state communities.
“This situation is alarming in the light of 41% of the
state’s sanitary landfills being unable to accommodate of
Alabama communities within the next five years because
they will be filled to capacity,” Gov. Hunt said.
“One of those inquiring stated that as whereas disposal
fees in the New York state area approximated $100 per
ton, by using the Tennessee-Tombigbee Waterway as a
conduit, waste could be barged into Alabama and disposed
of for less than $20 per ton. It is not very difficult I
believe for anyone to understand the economics involved,”
Gov. Hunt said.
The governor highlighted the hazardous waste manage-
ment and Alabama’s role in assuming a major share of
the nation’s responsibility for disposal.
“The chemical waste management site at Emelle cur-
rently manages approximately 400,000 tons of hazardous
waste per year, about 85% of which is generated outside
the state,” Gov. Hunt said. “I am convinced that other
companies are showing an interest in siting similar com-
mercial hazardous waste facilities in the state primarily
due to favorable geographical conditions. I predict that
these factors which make Alabama so attractive as a
hazardous waste disposal site will draw the solid waste
disposal industry to us like a magnet.”
Gov. Hunt noted a major hurdle in siting hazardous
waste facilities in this state was recently ruled uncon-
stitutional in federal court. He said the ruling involved
the requirement of the Minus Act that such a facility
receive approval of the Alabama Legislature.
“A significant aspect of this ruling, however, was that
it clearly defined such authority as being within the pur-
60
view of legislative functions. I will quote directly from
the conclusions of the federal court order: ‘The court
emphasizes that the constitution does not foreclose legis-
lative restrictions on hazardous waste facilities. Such
restrictions appear to this court to be essential for the
protection of the health and safety of Alabama citizens.
Storage of toxic waste is properly the subject of intense
public concern. This court only holds that the Legislature
must announce some reasonable standard which will guide
its deliberations or the deliberations of an appropriate
agency such as the Alabama Department of Environ-
mental Management in determining which applicants are
approved, and these standards must bear at least some
rational relationship to a legitimate state purpose,’ ”
Gov. Hunt said.
The governor said the creation of such standards will
be a major priority of his administration to ensure the
health and safety of Alabamians: standards that will allow
Alabama to place a priority on solving this state’s waste
disposal problems before assuming the responsibility for
other states.
In addition, the governor said there should be full
disclosure and publication of relevant details on permit
modifications to existing sites and permits for new facili-
ties to include names of corporate officials, projected
volume, and locations where the solid waste is generated
and maximizing effective public input through public
comment periods on all permit modifications for existing
facilities and applications for new sites.
And he noted an increased in disposal fees for com-
mercial hazardous waste management facilities with a
distinction in charges for the disposal of waste generated
out-of-state versus that originating in-state should be
approved by the Legislature.
“Criticai components in both of these issues will be
efforts to promote waste minimization, reduction, and
61
recycling and increased public information and educa-
tional programs,” Gov. Hunt said.
“We think that our proposals are much the better.
Hazardsus waste: “We need to do two things. We need
to stop the increase in hazardous waste and lower it,
as we tried to do with our cap bill that did not come out
of House Judiciary (committee).
“If people are serious about tax reform next year, then
(the impact of the higher fees on the budget is) some-
thing that can be looked at there. In the meantime, we've
got to do something to stop the flow of hazardous waste
into this state, to force other states to get their inciner-
ators and do their job that they ought to do and that
we've got a right to expect them to do. I'd be tickled to
death to get both that increase and the cap bill” signed
into law, the governor said.
“What his (Harper’s) proposal is is that we allow 400
pounds for every man, woman and child in the state to
come in.”
Mail order sales: “If someone orders a hundred dollars
worth of trees .. . if California is going to charge sales
tax, then Alabama can charge sales tax. We think that
that’s much better than messing with the income tax at
this particular point in time. These (companies outside
Alabama) are competing with in-state firms that pay
sales tax and they ought to have to pay sales tax.”
62 -
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 77
| State Seal |
STATE OF ALABAMA
Governor's Office
Montgomery 36130
For Immediate Release
January 29, 1990 Contact: Terry Abbott
Stacey Rimer
242-7150
GOV. HUNT WANTS CAP ON HAZARDOUS WASTE,
HIGHER FEES, SAYS ‘NO’ TO INCOME TAX IN-
CREASE
MONTGOMERY: Alabama needs higher fees for dump-
ing hazardous waste and limits on dumping to protect the
state’s environment, but taxpayers don’t need higher
income taxes, Gov. Guy Hunt said Monday.
Responding to reporters’ questions about a legislator’s
proposal to shelve his plan to raise money for the state’s
General Fund while curtailing hazardous waste dumping,
Gov. Hunt said he believes his plan is “much the better.”
A proposal by state Rep. Taylor Harper of Grand Bay
would help balance the state’s budget by increasing many
Alabamians’ income tax payments to the state while mak-
ing only a small adjustment in the fee for dumping haz-
ardous waste in Alabama.
“We think that our proposals are much the better,”
Gov. Hunt said of his plan, which would increase the fee
for dumping hazardous waste by $85 a ton on out-of-state
shipments and $50 a ton on waste produced in Alahama.
Gov. Hunt also is proposing a bill to “cap” the dump-
ing of hazardous weste in Alabama at 650,000 tons this
63
year and reduce the dumping annually until the dump-
ing reaches a maximum 350,000 tons in 1993.
“We need to do two things. We need to stop the in-
crease in hazardous waste and lower it, as we tried to
do with our cap bill that did not come out of House
Judiciary (committee) last year,” Gov. Hunt said.
Gov. Hunt proposes using the increased fees on haz-
ardous waste dumping to partially fund law enforcement
needs, state social service programs, the prison system
and pay raises for state employees for a couple of years
while lawmakers work on reforms of the tax system.
“If people are serious about tax reform next year, then
(the impact of the higher fees on the budget is) some-
thing that can be looked at there,’ Gov. Hunt said. “In
the meantime, we’ve go to do something to stop the flow
of hazardous waste into this state, to force other states
to get their incinerators and do their job that they ought
to do and that we've got a right to expect them to do.
I'd be tickled to death to get both that increase and the
cap bill” signed into law, the governor said.
The governor said it is wrong to think that the in-
crease will make Alabama too dependent on hazardous
waste fees. He said Alabama has no real competition
for the hazardous waste and that the state should raise
its fees and impose limits on dumping to force other
States to use waste incinerators and other technology to
take care of their own problems.
Gov. Hunt also opposes Mr. Harper’s hazardous waste
bill because it would allow 950,000 tons of hazardous
waste to be dumped in the state each year.
“What his proposal is is that we allow 400 pounds for
every man, woman and child in the state to come in,”
the governor said of Mr. Harper's plan.
Gov. Hunt said rather than Mr. Harper’s plan to
increase Alabamians’ income tax payments to the state, he
64
would rather see the state extend the sales tax on mail
order sales as 20 other states have done.
“If someone orders a hundred dollars worth of trees .. .
if California is going to charge sales tax, then Alabama
can charge sales tax,” Gov. Hunt said. “We think that
that’s much better than messing with the income tax at
this particular point in time.”
Gov. Hunt is proposing the mail order sales tax as an
alternative to Mr. Harper’s reported plan to cut income
tax deductions, therefore increasing the income tax bur-
den of thousands of Alabamians.
“These (companies outside Alabama) are competing
with in-state firms that pay sales tax and they ought
to have to pay sales tax,” Gov. Hunt said of the mail
order tax plan.
ae
65
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 80
STATE OF ALABAMA
Governor’s Office
Montgomery 36130
{State Seal]
For Immediate Release
April 17, 1990- Contact: Terry Abbott
Stacey Rimer
242-7150
GOV. HUNT INCREASES HAZARDOUS WASTE
DUMPING FEE
MONTGOMERY: Gov. Guy Hunt, declaring “there are
no more environmental bargains to be found here,”
signed legislation Tuesday sharply increasing the fees
for dumping hazardous waste in Alabama, a law he
called “one of the most important pieces of environmental
protection legislation in our state’s history.”
Gov. Hunt, in a State House ceremony, signed into
law a bill raising the dumping fees to $40 a ton for
hazardous waste generated inside Alabama and $112 a
ton for waste shipped in from outside the state.
“Sunday is Earth Day, a day set aside to remember
the importance of protecting our environment. In Ala-
bama we are going to start celebrating early by signing
into law one of the most important pieces of environ-
mental protection legislation in our state’s history,” Gov.
Hunt said at the news conference.
The governor said the new law eventually will force a
reduction in the amount of hazardous waste dumped in
Alabama by making it less profitable for waste producers
to ship to Alabama.
66
“For many years Alabama has been the hazardous
waste dumping ground of the nation. In Sumter County
is the largest toxic waste dump in the world, and last
year almost 800,000 tons of hazardous chemicals were
dumped there,” Gov. Hunt said.
“Although the dump at Emelle is probably one of the
safest such facilities in the country, many believe it is a
ticking toxic time bomb. In 20 or 30 or 50 or i00
years it may leak and pose a much greater threat to the
safety of generations to come,” the governor said.
“Today we will take an important step toward scratch-
ing Alabama’s name off that list of favorite places to
dump hazardous waste,” he said. “On the day I took
office just over three years ago, toxic waste producers
in other states could drive their problems to Alabama
and dump them for only $6 a ton. But today, Alabama
is taking down that sale sign. With this law it’s going
to cost $112 a ton to bring hazardous waste into Ala-
bama from other states. Let the message go out. There
are no more environmental bargains to be found here.”
Gov. Hunt said that “in time, this sharp increase in
dumping fees will force other states to start doing a
better job of taking care of their waste problems. They
have the technology available to them now, but they
have never had the incentive to use it because Alabama
has always welcomed their dumping with open arms.
“When this bill was being debated, some in the haz-
ardous waste business warned that this would dramat-
ically reduce dumping in Alabama. Good! That’s what
we want to do,” Gov. Hunt said. “And if it is reduced,
we're going to make sure it stays that way. An important
provision in this bill will cap the amount of hazardous
waste that can be dumped in Alabama at whatever
amount is brought to the state over the next 12 months.
In other words, if the new law cuts dumping from 800,000
67
tons to 100,000 tons, then that’s going to be the limit on
dumping in Alabama.”
“This bill will, in time, force a reduction in the amount
of hazardous waste produced by those firms, and it will
require states to start using incinerators and other meth-
ods for disposal that are safer than landfilling,” Gov.
Hunt said.
Gov. Hunt said in the meantime the fees from the new
law will help to balance the state’s General Fund budget,
“and give the Legislature time to do what it says that
it wants to do: reform Alabama’s tax system.”
The governor said: “This day, as Earth Day approaches
and Tax Day has passed for another year, will be re-
membered as the day that the environment and the tax-
payers got a break.”
The new law marks the third time in three years that
Gov. Hunt has increased the fees for dumping hazardous
waste in Alabama. Gov. Hunt also signed legislation
banning shipments from states that do not accept haz-
ardous waste, and entered into a compact with four other
southern states to better manage the flow of hazardous
waste.
68
DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 14
GAO
United States General Accounting Office
Report to the Congress
June 1990
HAZARDOUS WASTE
Funding of Postclosure
Liabilities Remains
Uncertain
(GAO Seal]
GAO RCED-90-64
69
GAO
United States
General Accounting Office
Washington, D.C. 20548
Resources, Community, and
Economic Development Division
B-237563
June 1, 1990
To the President of the Senate and the
Speaker of the House of Representatives
The Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act
of 1986 directed that we study options for a program
to manage liabilities associated with hazardous waste
disposal facilities after closure which complements the
policies set forth in the Hazardous and Solid Waste
Amendments of 1984 and assures the protection of human
health and the environment. This report presents the
results of our review by discussing
* the likelihood that permitted hazardous waste disposal
facilities will leak after closure.
* the magnitude of liabilities that may be incurred.
* the adequacy of current postclosure funding assurance
requirements, and
* the feasibility of other mechanisms that could provide
greater postclosure funding assurances.
* * * *
/s/ J. Dexter Peach
J. DEXTER PEACH
Assistant Comptroller General
70
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Purpose
Although past land disposal of hazardous waste has
resulted in major environmental contamination and
serious health effects, land disposal of these wastes
continues. About 13 million metric tons of hazardous
waste is land disposed each year. Better disposal
practices—including treatment of wastes to reduce
toxicity—and containment methods are now required
at operating hazardous waste disposal facilities; nev-
ertheless, the possibility exists that hazardous sub-
stances will eventually leak from these facilities and
costly cleanup actions would be required to protect
the public health and environment.
Concerned about the funding of long-term liabili-
ties—costs, damages, or other expenses—that may
be associated with permitted hazardous waste facil-
ities once they have closed, the Congress required
GAO to conduct a study of options for managing
postclosure liabilities. GAO focused its study on the
extent and magnitude to which postclosure liabilities
are expected to occur at permitted facilities when
closed and the need for, and viability of, options for
funding these liabilities.
Background
The Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA)
regulates the management and disposal of hazardous
waste. As implemented by the Environmental Pro-
tection Agency (EPA), the act requires owners/oper-
ators of disposal facilities to obtain an operating
permit in order to continue waste disposal operations.
To obtain a permit, facilities must meet certain
standards intended to prevent and/or detect leakage
to the environment. About 200 land disposal facilities
have, or are expected to obtain, operating permits.
71
After a disposal facility ceases operation, EPA re-
quires that closure activities be performed, including
the installation of covers over the disposed waste.
EPA further requires the owner ‘operator to perform
maintenance and monitoring activities at the facility
for a 30-year postclosure period. Owners /operators
must provide financial assurance that funds will be
available to conduct mandatory postclosure activities.
Certain liabilities, such as costs for cleanup and
third-party damages, may result during postclosure
if facilities leak and contaminate the groundwater.
A posteclosure liability trust fund to manage these
costs was established under the Comprehensive En-
vironmental Response, Compensation, and Liability
Act of 1980 (CERCLA). However, concerned that,
as structured, the postclosure fund may not provide
sufficient resources, the Congress suspended the trans-
fer of any liability to the fund.
Results in Brief
The long-term effectiveness of current land disposal
practices in controlling the migration of hazardous
waste is not known, but EPA and others believe it
is likely that some of the permitted hazardous waste
disposal facilities will release hazardous substances
into the environment at some period after they close.
However, the timing and magnitude of any resulting
postclosure liabilities—such as the costs of corrective
action and off-site damages—are uncertain.
Although EPA is aware of the potential for releases,
it has not developed a strategy for addressing long-
term postclosure concerns. EPA has given this issue
a low priority in the RCRA program because of limited
resources and the lack of historical data on the mag-
nitude and extent of the potential problem.
EPA does require funding assurances for mandatory
postelosure care and known corrective action costs,
72
but it does not require funding assurances for poten-
tial but unknown postclosure liabilities. Although
there are several options for funding postclosure lia-
bilities, few of these are currently viable in large
part because the risk associated with closed hazard-
ous waste facilities is difficult to quantify. As data
on long-term risks become available, the Congress
will be in a better position to decide on the need for
additional postclosure funding mechanisms.
73
not developed a strategy to comprehensively obtain
data on the effectiveness of current disposal require-
ments and examine long-term postclosure issues be-
cause (1) experience with current disposal require-
ments is limited and (2) available resources have
been needed in other RCRA program efforts that ad-
dress more immediate environmental concerns. Such
a strategy needs to be developed and implemented in
a timely manner in order to assure that actions
needed to reduce postclosure concerns are promptly
Principal Findings | taken.
Extent of Liabilities Uncertain Funding Mechanisms Questionable
EPA requires facilities obtaining operating permits to
design and construct disposal units with waste mi-
gration prevention measures, such as liners and cov-
ers, intended to mitigate releases into the environ-
ment. Little experience-based data exist, however, on
the long-term performance of these technology re-
quirements in preventing waste migration. Although
at least one company producing liner and cover
material estimates that the material will last hun-
dreds of years, EPA and others believe that perma-
nent containment of wastes is not possible and that
leakage will occur at some time after the 30-year
postclosure period. (See ch. 2.)
When leakage occurs, liabilities could be incurred
for extended maintenance and monitoring, compliance
monitoring, corrective action, and third-party dam-
ages. However, the extent of any liabilities will-be
contingent on factors that cannot currently be as-
sessed, such as the rate and timing of leakages, the
magnitude of contamination by hazardous substances,
and the exposure to such contamination.
EPA Officials have identified activities, such as ex-
tended postclosure care and long-term research, that
may be required to identify and reduce the potential
for leakage after facilities close. However, EPA has
Owners operators are liable for any postclosure costs
that may occur. However, few funding assurances
exist for postclosure liabilities. EPA only requires
funding assurances for maintenance and monitoring
costs for 30 years after closure and corrective action
costs once a problem is identified. No financial assur-
ances exist for potential but unknown corrective ac-
tions, off-site damages, or other liabilities that may
occur after the established postclosure period. EPA
could require funding assurances for certain poten-
tial liabilities, but it does not believe it would be
appropriate to require a facility to provide funding
assurances for liabilities that may not occur. (See
ch. 3.)
Options such as insurance and risk pooling could be
pursued to better assure funding of postclosure lia-
bilities; however, their availability is limited because
the risks involved with postclosure are viewed as
high and very difficult to assess and quantify. Fed-
erally administered programs—such as a modified
postclosure trust fund or federal insurance—could
also be established; however, the appropriate struc-
ture for any such program cannot be assessed be-
cause of the lack of data on the extent and magnitude
of postclosure liabilities. Such information can only
74
be obtained when EPA implements a strategic plan
for developing data and measures to assess postclos-
ure risks. As EPA collects and analyzes the data,
the need for and structure of a postclosure funding
mechanism can be better determined.
It is important that EPA deal with the issue of long-
term postclosure liability in an orderly, reasonable,
and timely manner. GAO anticipates that EPA can
develop a strategic plan to address the postclosure
liability issue in time for the debate on the reauthor-
ization of CERCLA which is expected in 1991. More-
over, EPA should be prepared to take interim mea-
sures—such as extending the postclosure care pe-
riod—to provide greater protection to the public
health and the environment until more definitive
data are developed.
Recommendation
GAO recommends that the Administrator, EPA, develop
and impiement a strategy to address the long-term
effectiveness of current hazardous waste disposal re-
quirements so that decisions can be made about post-
closure liability funding mechanisms. Such a strat-
egy should outline the activities EPA needs to under-
- take and/or complete to assess postclosure risks, eval-
uate actions such as extended postclosure care to
reduce risks, and assess available alternatives for
funding postclosure liabilities. The strategy should
also identify required EPA resources and establish
time frames for completing such activities. Further,
GAO recommends that the Administrator periodically
report to the Congress the agency’s progress in ob-
taining the necessary data on the effectiveness of
current disposal requirements and as information
becomes available, be prepared to take interim mea-
sures to provide greater public protection until more
definitive data are developed.
75
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
As evidenced by the events at Love Canal, Times
Beach, and thousands of other sites contaminated by
hazardous wastes, land disposal of these wastes pre-
sents a significant threat to human health and the
environment. Hazardous waste disposal can contam-
inate the land as well as ground and surface waters.
Once contaminated, cleanup of a hazardous waste
site can cost millions, take many years to complete,
and in some cases it may not be possible to remove
all contamination. Moreover, many contaminants are
toxic, may lead to cancer, or have other adverse
human health effects.
Despite the acknowledged problems of hazardous
waste, land disposal of some of these wastes continues.
About 275 million metric tons of hazardous waste
are managed annually. Although a national hazard-
ous waste management program has been established
to minimize the disposal and environmental impacts
of hazardous waste, about 13 million metric tons are
still land-disposed each year.
Current Hazardous Waste Disposal Program
Through the enactment of the Resource Conservation
and Recovery Act (RCRA), the Congress imposed
strict controls over hazardous waste to protect hu-
man health and the environment. Subtitle C of
RCRA establishes a “cradle-to-grave” system for man-
aging hazardous waste from the time it is generated
until its ultimate disposal. This system regulates
the generation, transportation, treatment, storage,
and disposal of hazardous wastes.
a a *
The hazardous waste facilities of greatest concern
are land disposal facilities—facilities that place the
76
wastes in the ground for permanent burial. RCRA
established strong controls over hazardous waste dis-
posal facilities to prevent the recurrence of past
leakage problems. The act requires any owner oper-
ator of a hazardous waste disposal facility to obtain
a permit to operate. Further, land disposal facilities
must meet certain standards for construction, opera-
tion, and closing of the facility in order to obtain
the permit and remain in compliance with the permit
conditions.
Requirements for Postclosure
As part of the regulation of hazardous waste under
RCRA, EPA established closure and postclosure re-
quirements for owners ‘operators of disposal facil-
ities. Closure is the period when wastes are no
longer accepted at a facility, and during which the
owner operator must properly apply final covers to
or cap the landfill, decontaminate or remove all
contaminated equipment and structures, and certify
that the facility has been properly closed. These
activities are required to ensure that facilities are
closed in a manner that (1) minimizes the need for
additional care and (2) controls, minimizes, or elim-
inates the potential escape of hazardous substances
to the environment.
To assure that hazardous waste land disposal facili-
ties do not pose environmental or public health haz-
ards after closure, such facilities must enter into a
postclosure care period. During this period, own-
ers operators conduct maintenance and monitoring
activities to ensure the integrity of the facility. As
required by EPA, postclosure care consists of at least
* groundwater monitoring and reporting,
* maintenance and monitoring of the waste contain-
ment systems, and
77
* security around the facility when access may pose
a hazard to human health.
EPA requires that these postclosure activities be con-
ducted for a 30-year period following the closure
certification. All disposal facilities must develop a
plan outlining the postclosure activities and have
the plan approved by EPA. Further, owners /oper-
ators must prepare postelosure cost estimates and
demonstrate the financial ability tc pay these costs
before they can obtain a permit.
Despite the protective measures now required at facil-
ities and the requirements for postclosure care and
monitoring, longstanding concerns exist over the lia-
bilities that could occur after closure and the ability
of owners ‘operators to pay for such liabilities. The
Congress addressed this issue with the enactment of
the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Com-
pensation, and Liability Act of 1980 (ceRCLA). The
act, which established the Superfund program, also
established a Postclosure Liability Trust Fund
(PCLTF) to assume the liabilities at permitted haz-
ardous waste disposal facilities after closure. Lia-
bility would be transferred to the fund within 5
years after closure and after demonstration of no
likelihood of migration or release. After transfer
of liability, the fund, generated from a tax on dis-
posed hazardous waste, would pay for damages, such
as groundwater contamination and necessary cleanup
actions, resulting from a release. The fund would
also pay for monitoring and maintenance beyond the
30-year postclosure period. The balance in the fund
was limited to $200 million, although additional taxes
could be collected if the balance dropped below that
amount.
78
However, concerns about PCLTF and the unlimited
liability that could be transferred to the government
were raised in the deliberations on reauthorizing
CERCLA in 1985. In particular, the Congress and EPA
were concerned that the fund would not have suffi-
cient resources to pay the liabilities. Subsequently,
under Section 201 of the Superfund Amendments and
Reauthorization Act (SARA), the Congress suspended
the transfer of liability to the pcitr. Further, the
Congress repealed the tax and the trust fund and
authorized the refund of the amounts collected to the
owners operators who had paid into the fund.
CERCLA will be up for reauthorization in 1991.
Objectives, Scope, and Methodology
With the repeal of the Postclosure Liability Trust
Fund, the-Congress required us to study options for
a program to manage postclosure liabilities. SARA
Section 201 established the general requirements that
a postelosure program should assure (1) incentives
are created and maintained for the safe management
and disposal of hazardous wastes, (2) the public
will have reasonable confidence that hazardous wastes
will be managed and disposed of safely and resources
will be available to address any problems that may
arise and will cover the costs of long-term care, and
(3) owners/operators of hazardous waste disposal
facilities will be able to manage their potential future
liabilities and attract inv ent capital necessary
to build, operate, and closé such facilities in a man-
ner that assures protection of human health and the
“environment. Another provision of section 201 was
that separate assessments be made for different
classes of treatment, storage, and disposal facilities
that have been or probably will be issued a permit.
Such assessments were to address the current and
future financial capabilities of owners operators, the
current and future costs associated with facilities,
79
and the availability of mechanisms to assure these
costs can be financed.
In conducting our study, we found that several of
these requirements could not be fully addressed. As
discussed later in this report, data necessary to as-
sess future costs and financial capabilities are not
available. Consequently, to best address the overall
issue of postclosure liability and provide the Con-
gress now with a meaningful perspective on liability
questions, we focused our work on addressing the
following questions.
* What is the likelihood that permitted hazardous
waste disposal facilities will leak in the post-
closure period and ‘or beyond?
What is the magnitude of liabilities that may be
incurred after these facilities close?
Do current mechanisms provide adequate funding
assurances for these liabilities?
How feasible are other mechanisms that could be
used to provide greater assurance that funds wil]
be available to address postclosure liabilities?
In addressing these issues, we relied primarily on
information from EPA’s Office of Solid Waste (osw ,
which is responsible for managing the RCRA program,
and contacted other government agencies such as the
Departments of Commerce, Treasury, and the In-
terior and the Federal Emergency Management
Agency (FEMA) and the Nuclear Regulatory Com-
mission (NRC) concerning various aspects of our
review. In addition, we gathered opinions and data
on the posteclosure liability issue from two environ-
mental groups and the commercial hazardous waste
g)
as Chapter 2
management and treatment industries’ associations. EXTENT OF POSTCLOSURE LIABILITIES
We also spoke with owners/operators of hazardous UNKNOWN
waste facilities, including one who both generates
and disposes of hazardous waste and others who only
treat and/or dispose of hazardous waste.
EPA requires permitted facilities to meet certain re-
quirements intended to prevent the leakage of haz-
ardous substances into the environment. The require-
* . . . ments for liners, leachate collection systems, covers,
and postclosure maintenance are believed capable of
preventing leakage in the short term. However, for
the long teria—beyond 30 years—there are questions
about the effectiveness of EPA’s current requirements
and concerns that leakage may occur.
Leakage that does occur after closure could result
in significant liabilities such as corrective action costs
and off-site damage claims. However, because of a
lack of experience-based informat‘on, insufficient data
exist on the extent and timing of potential leakage
as well as the actions required to correct such leak-
age. Consequently, the magnitude of postclosure lia-
bilities that could be incurred simply cannot be meas-
ured at this time.
EPA is concerned about the effectiveness of its stand-
ards for the long-term prevention of waste migration
and the potential for postclosure liabilities. Both
GAO and EPA’s Science Advisory Board have recom-
mended the development of a stratery—describing
activities and time frames for their completion—to
address such concerns. However, because postclosure
at currently operating hazardous waste disposal fa-
cilities is not viewed as a current environmental prob-
lem, EPA has made this issue a lower priority in the
RCRA program and has not developed the necessary
Strategy.
Current Requirements May Not Prevent Leakage After
Postclosure
The land disposal of hazardous waste presents the
possibility that hazardous substances may migrate
82
from the disposal facility and pose a risk to human
health and the environment. To reduce this risk be-
fore the wastes are placed in the ground, hazardous
waste must meet specified treatment standards to
make it less toxic and mobile. HSWA prohibits the
disposal of untreated hazardous wastes beyond speci-
fied dates and requires EPA to establish treatment
standards after which waste treated in accordance
with the standards could be land disposed. Treatment
standards have been established for most hazardous
wastes and standards for all remaining wastes are
scheduled for issuance in May 1990.
Nevertheless, although some wastes degrade or can
be made less hazardous through treatment, some sub-
stances remain hazardous forever. Consequently, in
order to reduce the potential for leakage of these sub-
stances from permitted disposal facilities after they
close, all such facilities must meet a number of con-
struction standards to prevent and/or reduce the mi-
gration of hazardous wastes. These standards re-
quire, according to EPA guidance, that all owners/
operators must do the following:
* Place double liners under any new landfill unit or
any replacement or expansion of an existing unit.'
Draft EPA guidance for double liners directs that
the top liner be constructed of a flexible synthetic
material, such as high-density polyethylene, and
the bottom liner be constructed of either compacted
low-permeability soil or a combination of a syn-
thetic material and compacted low-permeability soil.
* Instal! leachate collection systems over the top liner
and between the two liners. Leachate collection
systems consist of a drainage layer to collect liquids
generated in the disposal unit and a mechanism
such as a pump to remove them.
83
* Cover the disposal units at closure. EPA’s minimum
technology guidance recommends that covers be of a
multilayer design that includes a synthetic materia]
and compacted soil.
* * * *
Long-Term Effectiveness of Weste Containment
Measures Unknown
Under the current requirements, hazardous waste
disposal units are expected to be effective in prevent-
ing leakage of hazardous constituents into the en-
vironment through the 30-year postclosure period.
EPA’s design and operating requirements for land
disposal units specify that liners be constructed of
materials to prevent the migration of any hazardous
constituent through the liner during a unit’s active
life and postclosure period. The chief of osw’s Dis-
posal Technology Section said that althouch little
data are available on the-actual use of liners in
hazardous waste applications, EPA is confident that
the current technology wil! be effective in preventing
waste migration through the 30-year postclosure
period. He said that properly closed units, with the
required maintenance and leachate removal, wil] grad-
ually “dewater” and dry out during the early years of
postclosure and substantially reduce the likelihood of
leakage during the 30-year postclosure period.
However, for the longer term—beyond the 30-year
posclosure period—the effectiveness of the current
technology requirements in preventing leakage is
questionable. As stated in EPA’s March 1986 pro-
posed rule to assist in implementing the statutory
provisions of HSWA
“EPA’s position was, and still is, that absolute pre-
vention of migration forever, or for the long term,
is beyond the current technical state of the art. Thus,
84 85
at some time, some migration through the liner will United States, any state or local government, or any
probably occur.” foreign government.
* * * * e ® ® o
EPA Does Not Have a Strategy for Addressing Long-
University researchers we talked with also said that
Term Postclosure Concerns
problems may exist with the long-term effectiveness
of current waste containment technology. One re- ° ‘ . P
searcher said that there is little doubt that current The need f :, OP
z portays : : or strat %
hazardous waste facilities will leak. He said that ardous waste pt, alge ing
S
present research shows that these systems will fail
at some point, particularly after postclosure care
ends, and that he views today’s disposal of hazardous
waste as merely a storage mechanism for hazardous
waste that may have to be removed eventually. An-
other university researcher told us that the technol-
ogy used today is the best available but that it is
simply unknown if it will keep wastes in place.
Magnitude of Postclosure Liabilities Not Determinable
Postclosure liabilities are for the most part directly
related to the leakages that may occur before and
afte: a facility closes. Only one postclosure liability—
maintenance and monitoring—is required in all situ-
ations and can be estimated. Other postclosure liabili-
ties that may be incurred—compliance monitoring,
corrective action, third-party damages, and natural
resource damages—cannot be determined because of
the unknown extent and timing of potential leakages
and, in some cases, a lack of available data.
* * * *
Natural Resource Damages
Leakage from hazardous waste facilities could also
result in damages to natural resources. As defined
by CERCLA, natural resources are land, fish, wildlife,
biota, air, water, groundwater, and other such re-
sources belonging to or otherwise controlled by the
Science Advisory Board, a_ public advisory group
that provides advice to EPA. In an October 1987 re-
port on EPA’s land disposal research program, the
Board determined that it is difficult to predict that
improved land disposal will be protective of human
health and the environment for the long-term future.
The report concluded that there is a need to evalu-
ate and understand the long-term performance of
what are now considered environmentally sound land
disposal practices to ensure that these practices are
environmentally sound for many decades. The report
further concluded that there is an absence of a waste
management strategy—detailing projects, timetables,
and funding—necessary to develop the scientific and
technical knowledge for developing land disposal
guidance and regulations.
According to EPA officials, a comprehensive strategy
for addressing long-term postclosure concerns at per-
mitted hazardous waste facilities has not been de-
veloped. The officials stated that no strategy exists
in large part because postclosure concerns at operat-
ing facilities currently have a low priority relative
to other aspects of the RCRA program. They pointed
out that EPA is conducting several activities that have
statutorily mandated deadlines, such as the permit-
ting of incinerators and the issuance of hazardous
waste treatment standards and that these activities
have been given high priority by EPA. One official
added that the remaining EPA resources are directed
86
at issues that provide the most environmental benefit
and that postclosure concerns at operating facilities
is not a current environmental problem.
* aol 7 7
No Financial Assurance Requirements for Unknown
Liabilities
Postclosure financial assurance is currently required
by EPA only for 30-year maintenance and monitoring
as well as identified corrective action costs. Financial
assurances are not required, however, for potential
but unknown postclosure liabilities such as on-site
cleanup or off-site damages. According to the Direc-
tor, Permits and State Programs Division, EPA only
requires owners operators to set aside funds for
known contingencies: EPA does not believe it would
be appropriate to require funds be set aside for un-
known contingencies. Consequently, although EPA does
not want situations to occur°in the future where
funds are not available to cover liabilities, it does
not require large amounts of funds be set aside for
liabilities that may not occur. The director added
that such additional financial responsibility require-
ments could cause facilities to close, which would have
serious negative effects such as reducing hazard-
ous~ waste disposal capacity and increasing illegal
dumping.
Nevertheless, OSW officials stated that there is no
assurance that funds would be available for unknown
liabilities that may occur after permitted facilities
close. They said that no one can predict what the
future financial situation of any owner operator will
be in the long-term with any certainty, and if an
owner operator were to become bankrupt or other-
wise go out of business, there is little likelihood that
funding would be available for unanticipated post-
closure costs.
& & * *
'
87
EPA has the authority to require additional financial
assurances for certain unknown liabilities. Sectio:
3004(a) of RCRA authorizes EPA to promulgate finan-
cia! requirements for corvective action as it deem
necessary or desirable. According to EPA, this author-
ity is not limited to known releases. However, a!
though EPA has issued a proposed corrective action
rule in October 1986 that would require facilities
with known releases to provide corrective action
funding assurances, at that time EPA stated that |
will not pursue such financial assurances for un
known rejeases unti! more analysis on the issue is
completed.
* * ~
Private Sector Options
Private sector options for fundine postclosure liabili.
ties include private insurance, coinsurance, reinsur-
ance, and voluntary risk pooling. Because of the un
known liabilities and perceived risk associated with
hazardous waste disposal facilities after they close
these postclosure funding mechanisms are current!y
not viable options. Private insurance, coinsurance.
and reinsurance are currently unavailable for post-
closure liability coverage. Voluntary risk pools toe
cover postclosure liabilities have proved to he unsue-
cessful and are generally believed inappropriate for
the hazardous waste disposa! industry.
Private insurance has been unavailable for closed
hazardous waste facilities for many years
* * « »
A representative of the American Insurance Assoc’
ation stated that the postclosure insurance martet
does not exist, and they did not foresee that this
market would open up anytime in the near future.
According to the represeniative, the unavailability of
&8
private hazardous waste insurance is primarily due
to the following factors.
* The inability to measure or quantify the liability
exposure at hazardous waste facilities along with
a perception by the insurance industry that liabili-
ties are certain to occur after these facilities close.
* An unwillingness by the industry to guarantee
coverage on a perpetual, noncancellable basis to
cover the entire 30-year postclosure period.
* The financial liability of the insurance industry in
the pollution arena, where the conduct of the pol-
icyholder is no longer relevant and insurers would
be ultimately liable for cleanup costs.
EPA has also determined that private insurance
for postclosure is not available. In its October
1986 proposed rule for corrective action, EPA in-
dicated that it was aware of only one company
that had offered postclosure insurance and that
this company stopped offering such insurance as
of 1986.
Neither coinsurance nor reinsurance is a viable op-
tion for assuring postclosure liability funding. As
stated in the 1982 Treasury study, other private
sector insurance arrangements such as coinsurance
and reinsurance encounter many of the same short-
comings as private insurance, and consequently these
options are not feasible in the forseeable future. The
senior ecenomist responsible for the study told us that
the feasibility of both coinsurance and reinsurance
is dependent upon the existence of a robust private
insurance market to cover these liabilities. As pre-
vious'y discussed, this market does not exist.
As discussed in our October 1987 report, the avail-
ability of reinsurance for hazardous waste facilities
89
has been limited since 1984, when foreign reinsurers
began to leave the reinsurance market. A representa-
tive of the American Insurance Association stated
that the association does not expect a resurgence in
the reinsurance market for »oliution liabilities.
Voluntary Risk Pooling
A risk pool is a group of riskbearers who spread and
finance losses among themselves when private insur-
ance is not available or prohibitively expensive.
* * * ¥
As discussed in the 1982 Treasury report, risk poo!-
ing is not a viable option for postclosure liability
funding. Because postclosure liability is uncertain
and potentially unlimited, Treasury determined that
underwriting the risk of postclosure is no more ac-
ceptable to mutual associations than to individual
insurance companies.
Representatives of hazardous waste disposal firms
and NSWMA also pointed out that risk pooling was
not a practical option for postclosure liabilities.
* * * *
However, although postclosure liabilities at hazardous
waste facilities are difficult to estimate and private
insurance is generally not available, federal insur-
ance officials do not believe that it is an area for
federal insurance coverage. Officials from FEMA’s
Federal Insurance Administration (FIA) said that
federal insurance may not be appropriate for post-
closure liabilities at hazardous waste disposal facili-
ties. The FIA officials cited a number of concerns with
establishing a viable postclosure liability insurance
program, including the following.
* The lack of actuarial experience with postclosure
liability costs. The officials said that with flood
insurance, for example, risks can be quantified
£0 91
based on historical data. However, the lack of ex- DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 40
perience-based data on postclosure liabilities makes
it difficult to quantify the risks, costs, and coverage.
* Coverage of bodily injury claims. The federal in- warenner S007 EPA-700/8-87-036
surance programs FIA administers have been lim-
ited to property damage only, and it is more diffi-
cult to quantify the risks associated with bodily Hazardous Waste Ground-Water
injury and potentially more expensive. Task Force
* Certainty of risk. The possibility exists that even
if facilities are built to current standards leakage
will occur. Evaluation of
* The need for perpetual insurance coverage. In
other areas insurance has a time limit, but post-
closure coverage would be forever. Emelle, Alabama
Chemical Waste Management, Inc.
FIA’s Deputy Administrator added that federal insur-
ance is usually provided as a mechanism to influence
behaviors and to achieve certain objectives while a‘ UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
the same time providing insurance coverage. For [EPA Seal]
example, to obtain flood insurance, buildings must be
built to certain standards which reduce the lilelihood ADEM
of flood damage. However, hazardous waste facilities
already have to meet high standards for construction ALABAMA
and maintenance, and therefore it appears that in- DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
surance is not needed to change the behaviors of
facility owners ‘operators.
+ * * *
EPA, however, does not believe that a modified post- | [State Seal]
closure trust fund would be appropriate federal pol-
icy. According to the Director, Permits and State
Programs Division, a federa! trust fund runs counter
to the objectives of HSWA, which establishes the fed-
eral policy of discouraging the land disposal of haz-
ardous waste. He said that a trust fund would serve
as an incentive to land disposal of these wastes and
could result in increase disposal capacity. which is
currently not needed nor is it desired by EPA.
’
INTRODUCTION
Concerns have recently been raised about whether com-
mercial hazardous waste treatment, storage and disposal
facilities (TSDFs) are complying with the ground-water
monitoring requirements promulgated under the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). In question is
the ability of existing or proposed ground-water monitor-
ing systems to detect contaminant releases from waste
management units. To evaluate these systems and deter-
mine the current compliance status, the Administrator of
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) established
a Hazardous Waste Ground-Water Task Force (Task
Force). The Task Force comprises personnel from the
EPA Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response
(OSWER), National Enforcement Investigations Center
(NEIC}), Regional! Offices and State regulatory agencies.
The Task Force is conducting in-depth on-site investiga-
tions of commercial TSDF’s with the following objectives:
* Determine compliance with interim status ground-
water monitoring requirements of 40 CFR Part
265 as promulgated under RCRA or the State
equivalent (where the State has received RCRA
authorization}.
* Evaluate the ground-water monitoring program
described in the facility’s RCRA Part B permit
application for compliance with 40 CFR Part
270.14 (¢).
* Determine if the ground water at the facility con-
tains hazardous waste constituents.
* Provide information to assist the Agency in deter-
mining if the TSDF meets EPA ground-water
monitoring requirements for waste management fa-
cilities receiving waste from response actions con-
ducted under the Comprehensive Environmental Re-
sponse, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA,
Public Law 91-510).
93
To address these objectives, each Task Force investi-
gation will determine if:
® The facility has developed and is following an ade-
quate ground-water sampling and analysis plan;
Designated RCRA and/or State required monitor-
ing wells are properly located and constructed;
Required analyses have been conducted on samples
from the designated RCRA monitoring wells; and
The ground-water quality assessment program out-
line (or plan, as appropriate) is adequate.
During September 15-25, 1986, a Task Force team
conducted an evaluation at the Chemical Waste Manage-
ment Incorporated (CWM) facility (EPA ID. No.
ALD000622464) at Emelle, Alabama (Figure 1}. The
inspection was coordinated by US-EPA Region IV En-
vironmental Services Division (ESD) and consisted of
personne! from ESD as well as US-EPA Headquarters,
the US-EPA Region IV Residuals Management Branch,
the Alabama Department of Environmental Management
(ADEM), and GCA Corporation, who was the sampling
contractor for this evaluaticn. In eveneral the inspection
involved review of state, federal, and facility records,
facility inspection, laboratory evaluation and ground-
water and landfill leachate sampling and analyses.
BACKGROUND
Based primarily on geological criteria, a group of in-
vestors, known as Resource Industries of Alabama (RIA)
acquired a tract of land which would become the Chemical
Waste Management, Inc. facility at Emelle, Alabama.
Under the authority of the Alabama Solid Waste Disposal
Act No. 771, Regular Session, 1969, the Director of the
Division of Solid Waste and Vector Control (Environ-
mental Health Administration) issued a permit to RIA
for construction and operation of a hazardous waste dis-
94
posal facility on May 4, 1977. Permitted waste types
were solids ard liquids categorized as potentially hazard-
ous Or toxic, except radioactive wastes and normal do-
mestic and commercial! waste. After meeting the condi-
tions of the permit. RIA was given final approval for
operation of a landfill on August 24, 1977. Immediately
thereafter, the site be van receiving waste.
Kifective February 23, 1978, the RIA site was reper-
mitted as Waste Management of Alabama, a subsidiary
of Waste Management, Ine. They then filed a formal
application with US-EPA cated March 10, 1978, for a
landfiil disposal permit for polychlorinated biphenyls
(PCBs). This application was approved and accordingly
issued by US-EPA on June 28, 1978, and modified in
October, 1979 to allow disposal of liquid PCBs.
linzarcous waste permit responsibilities reverted to
US-fPA on November 19, 1980 when federal regulations
under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act of
if76 became effective. On November 14, 1980, Chemical
Waste Management Ine. obtained Interim Status under
RCRA by filing a complete Part A application form prior
to November 19, 1980.
US-EPA Revion IV requested the Emelle facility's
Part B application on February 8, 19838. In response,
Chemica! Waste Management made their original sub-
mission on September 9, 1983, and final revisions were
necomplished in Aneust 1986, The application was deemed
complete in July, 1986, and at the time of the Task Force
evalivation, a craft permit was on publie notice.
- oa * os
GROUND WATER MONITORING UNDER 40 CFR
PART 264
Upon issuance of their Federal RCRA permit, CWM
will no longer be required to conduct monitoring of
the Eutaw Formation as they have been under interim
status. The State permit, however, will require CWM to
continue to monitor the Eutaw. CWM submitted a waiver
request in their Part B demonstrating that there is vir-
tually ne potential for migration of hazardous wastes or
hazardous waste constituents to the Eutaw Formation
(uppermost aquifer) within the active life and 30 year
closure and post-closure period. The transit time through
the Selma chalk was estimated by CWM to be 10,000
years. Independent EPA estimates of transit time using
conservative estimates for equation variable were 330
years and 3,000 years for estimates using Darey’s Equa-
tion and a 2-D solute transport model, respectively. The
very conservative 330-year estimate is considerably longer
than the end of the post-ciosure period.
CWM’s Federal RCRA permit will require that the
consent agreement monitoring wells be monitored in lieu
of the Eutaw wells to determine if there is migration of
hazardous waste constituents and confirm the rate of mi-
gration should it be detected. Under the permit, these
wells will be monitored semi-annually and will be evalu-
ated for contamination using specific, objective criteria.
~ * * +
It is difficult to draw any firm conclusions about possi-
ble shallow saturated chalk contamination using data from
the Task Force evaluation. Of all the data reported from
analyses of samples collected at the Consent Agreement
and PCB chalk wells, the data for selected metals (ar-
senic, cobalt, nickel and selenium) and purgeable organic
compounds are the most useful. TOC and TOX were the
priority conventional parameters and analyses was ob-
tained for these parameters from 11 of 13 and 9 of 13
96
wells, respectively. These data, however, do not appear
to be useful indicators for this evaluation, since the sam-
ples from the background well, Well BG-02, were the only
samples in which TOC and TOX were detected. It should
be stated that this well appears to be located properly
with respect to its function as a background or control
well, and no explanation can be offered at this time for
these apparently anomolous values.
The selected metals data does not indicate a clear pat-
tern with regard to fracture-screened or deep-screened
wells. Of the five wells adjacent to trenches in which these
metals were detected, two are deep wells, two are fracture
wells and one is a PCB well. The PCB wells were gener-
ally sited with respect to observed fractures and were
completed at depths approximately 25 feet below trench
bottoms. If the PCB well in question, M-58, were indeed
a fracture well equivalent, then the data might indicate
a trend towards higher metals concentrations and greater
number of metal compounds occurring in fracture wells.
Of the six purgeable organic compounds detectable in
samples collected from Consent Agreement wells, four,
two each in wells SM-5 and SM-9, were detected in frac-
ture wells. If the reasoning in the previous paragraph is
followed, the compound detected in the sample from well
M-56 could also be considered to be from a fracture well
sample, indicating that possibly five of six occurrences
of purgeable organic compounds were from fracture wells.
It would be unusual, however, if these fractures ( e.g.
Well SM-5 and SM-9 fractures) are indeed active con-
duits, that so few organic compounds were detected at the
low levels measured (all less than 15 ug/1). The leachate
in these trenches is a virtual soup of inorganic and or-
ganic compounds. One would expect, given the low levels
of detection utilized in these analyses, that more than
two purgeable organic compounds would be detected and
that extractable organic compounds would have been de-
tected as well.
97
The Task Force recommends that the following tasks be
completed to evaluate the significance and probability of
the fractures as conduits for leachate migration.
1. Conduct a trace element geochemical study of the
Selma Chalk in the vicinity of the Emelle facility.
Samples should be collected from on-site and off-
site locations with utmost regard for obtaining
pristine samples. The study should include, at a
minimum, analysis for the trace metals arsenic,
chromium, cobalt, nickel, and selenium. These
analyses should look at both total and leachable
(e.g. EP Toxicity procedure) concentrations. It
is critical that the occurrence and mobility of
these metals in the chalk be understood if deci-
sions regarding contamination are to be made on
the concentrations of arsenic, chromium and nickel
in ground water collected, from the Consent
Agreement wells. This study should be performed
by either EPA or ADEM.
2. Sampling the purgeable organic compounds in the
vicinity of active trenches, particularly downwind
should be conducted with the highest regard for
field quality control and quality assurance. Field
blanks should be prepared for purgeable organic
analyses at each station where odors and wind
blown dust are present during sampling to help
evaluate the low level concentrations of organic
compounds such as reported for Task Force sam-
ples. This task should be performed jointly by
CWM and either EPA or ADEM during several
regularly scheduled sampling events at CWM.
Ideally, samples should be split at the “hot wells”
sampled during the Task Force evaluations and
any other wells at which purgeable organic com-
pounds have been recently detected or which are in
active areas,
98
These conclusions are speculative and are based on ob-
servations made during the Task Force Evaluation.
While they are by no means conclusive, they do indicate
that some fractures may be conduits for leachate migra-
tion from certain trenches.
99
DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 41
REPORT TO CONGRESS
DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES
This publication (SW-115) was prepared by the OFFICE
OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS as
required by Section 212 of The Solid Waste Disposal
Act as amended and was delivered June 30, 1973, to the
President and the Congress
U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
1974
100
Appendix F
SUMMARY OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE
NATIONAL DISPOSAL SITE CONCEPT
In the course of investigating the NDS concept for
hazardous wastes as mandated by Section 212 of the
Solid Waste Disposal Act (P.L. 89-272, amended by P.L.
91-512), important and relevant information was de-
veloped. Appendixes B and D, respectively, provide a
list of hazardous wastes subject to treatment at such
sites and summaries of current methods of treatment and
disposal. This appendix summarizes the findings related
to site selection, methods and processes that are likely to
be used at a typical site, and costs for developing and
maintaining such sites. An earlier study contains the
detailed analyses performed and the rationale for this
information. '
SITING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE TREATMENT
AND DISPOSAL FACILITIES
The general approach to the site selection process was
to first regionalize the conterminous United States into
41 multicounty regions (spheres of influence for major
industrial waste production areas, which are closely re-
lated to hazardous waste production areas, served as the
basis for regional delineation) :
(1) Seattle, Tacoma, Everett, and Bellingham, Wash-
ington
(2) Portland, Oregon; Vancouver and Longview,
Washington
(3) San Francisco Bay Area, California
(4) Ventura, Los Angeles, and Long Beach, California
(5) San Diego, California
101
(6) Phoenix, Arizona
(7) Salt Lake and Ogden, Utah
(8) Idaho Falls and Pocatello, Idaho
(9) Denver, Colorado
(10) Santa Fe and Albuquerque, New Mexico
(11) El Paso, Texas
(12) Fort Worth, Dallas, and Waco, Texas
(13) Austin, San Antonio, and Corpus Christi, Texas
(14) Houston, Beaumont, Port Arthur, Texas City,
and Galveston, Texas
(15) Oklahoma City, Tulsa, and Bartlesville, Okla-
homa
(16) Wichita, Topeka, and Kansas City, Kansas
(17) Omaha and Lincoln, Nebraska; Des Moines, Iowa
(18) Minneapolis, St. Paul, and Duluth, Minnesota
(19) Cedar Rapids, Michigan; Burlington and Du-
buque, Iowa; Peoria, Illinois
(20) St. Louis, Missouri: Springfield, Illinois
(21) Memphis, Tennessee
(22) Shreveport, Baton Rouge, and New Orleans, Lou-
islana ; Jackson, Mississippi
(23) Mobile and Montgomery, Alabama: Tallahassee,
Florida; Biloxi and Gulfport, Mississippi; Columbus
Georgia
(24) Huntsville and Birmingham, Alabama: Atlanta
and Macon, Georgia; Chattanooga and N ashville, Tennessee
(25) Louisville, Frankfort, and Lexington, Kentucky;
Evansville, Indiana
(26) Albany, Troy, and Schenectady, New York
102
(27) Indianapolis, Indiana; Cincinnati and Dayton,
Ohio
(28) Chicago and Kankakee, Illinois; Gary, South
Bend, Hammond, and Fort Wayne, Indiana
(29) Midland, Saginaw, Grand Rapids, Detroit, Dear-
born, and Flint, Michigan; Toledo, Ohio
(30) Columbus, Cleveland, Youngstown, and Akron,
Ohio
(31) Pittsburgh, Johnstown, and Erie, Pennsylvania
(32) Charleston, West Virginia; Portsmouth and Nor-
folk, Virginia
(33) Charleston, South Carolina: Savannah and Au-
gusta, Georgia
(34) Winston-Salem, Raleigh, Greensboro, and Char-
lotte, North Carolina
(35) Baltimore, Maryland
(36) Philadelphia, Allentown, and Harrisburg, Penn-
sylvania; Camden and Elizabeth, New Jersey; Wilming-
ton, Delaware
(37) New York, New York: Newark and Paterson,
New Jersey
(38) Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Watertown, New
York
(39) Boston, Massachusetts -
(40) Orlando, Tampa, and Miami, Florida
(41) Little Rock, Pine Bluff, and Hot Springs,
Arkansas
Thirty-six waste treatment regions were identified, based
upon the distance from the 41 major industrial waste pro-
duction centers. These are shown in Figure 16. Distances
of about 200 miles (322 kilometers) in the East and 250
103
miles (402 kilometers) in the West were selected as the
Maximum distances any treatment site should be from
the industrial waste production centers in a given sub-
region. Some of the regions do not contain an industrial
Waste production center: however, their boundaries are
defined by surrounding regions containing waste produc-
tion centers. No region was generally permitted to cross
any major physiographic barrier. Notably, the regions
are smaller in the East than in the West.
Criteria for site selection were defined. The major
emphasis was placed on health and safety and environ-
mental considerations. It was recognized early that two
general types of sites would need to be identified: waste
processing plant sites and long-term hazardous waste
disposal and Storage sites. Site selection criteria and
numerical weightings are presented in Table 12.
Based on the site selection criteria, a ranking, secreen-
ing, and Weighting procedure was developed and applied
to all counties located in the 36 regions which cover
the country. The county-size areal unit appeared to be
of manageable size for the survey. The output listing of
all 3,050 counties in the conterminous United States,
grouped by regional ratings, is too voluminous for inclu-
sion here.' This listing allows for the orderly and rational
selection of counties within each region, for site-specific
reconnaissance, and for later detailed field studies that
would be required in order to prove out the feasibility of
a ca
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.