Joint Appendix Vol I — Lee v. International Soc. for Krishna Consciousness, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1992
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
! Supreme Court, U.S,
Fil&EOD
Nos. 91-155, 91-339
n ¢—fea lo 1992
= as OFFICE OF THE CLERK |
Supreme Court of the United States”
October Term, 1991
o
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA
CONSCIOUSNESS, INC., AND BRIAN RUMBAUGH,
Petitioners and Cross-Respondents,
V.
WALTER LEE,
Respondent and Cross-Petitioner.
¢
On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States Court
Of Appeals For The Second Circuit
.
JOINT APPENDIX
VOLUME I (Pages 1-291)
¢
Barry A. FisHER ARTHUR P. BERG
Counsel of Record Counsel of Record
Davip Grosz
Rosert C. Moest
ARNOLD D. KOLIKOFF
FLEISHMAN, FisHEeR & Moest Mitton H. Pactrrer
2049 Century Park East, Attorney for Respondent
Suite 3160 and Cross-Petitioner
Los Angeles, California 90067 One World Trade Center — 66E
(310) 557-1077 New York, New York 10048
Davip M. LiperMAN (212) 435-6830
2049 Century Park East, Counsel for Respondent
Suite 3160 and Cross-Petitioner
Los Angeles, California 90067
(310) 277-9288
Jay ALAN SEKULOW
1000 Thomas Jefferson Street, N.W.,
Suite 520
Washington, D.C. 20007
(202) 337-2273
Counsel for Petitioners and Cross-Respondents
—
—
Petitions For Certiorari Filed July 24, 1991 (No. 91-155),
Aug. 26, 1991 (No. 91-339); Certiorari Granted Jan. 10, 1992
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO., (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
EDITOR'S NOTE
THE FOLLOWING PAGES WERE POOR HARD COPY
AT THE TIME OF FILMING. IF AND WHEN A
BETTER COPY CAN BE OBTAINED, A NEW FICHE
WILL BE ISSUED,
ere, “reba doesnt de
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
VOLUME I
PE TR. 0s oc cscccecvcestayecnsoccsessaciussens 1
Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief,
I GI, Be TE cc ccc cccccccccccnccccccvcccsess 20
First Amended Complaint, dktd. Oct. 27, 1977 ...... 30
Exhibit A to Amended Complaint - Eastern Air
EL, 60 d6Gn RS bK6 nes tdenscacsessesces 47
Answer of Defendant Walter Lee to Complaint,
haa cs neh anus Rede seseseeeesoess 60
Affidavit of Philip Le B. Douglas in Opposition to
Motion for Protective Order, dktd. Nov. 1, 1984... . 67
Exhibit L to Douglas Affidavit - Affidavit of
EE 94
Exhibit M to Douglas Affidavit - Declaration of
ERR ea ne aera 100
Exhibit N to Douglas Affidavit - Affidavit of
Us 653,564.46 Cviensesencececensd ss 103
Exhibit O to Douglas Affidavit - Declaration of
ECA ChGRRhGKGhN NGS Kdnesnesneensenescs 106
Exhibit P to Douglas Affidavit - Declaration of
RETO CET UP TCL TeRT LETTE eT Teee 109
Declaration of Brian Rumbaugh, in Opposition to
Motion to Dismiss, dktd. Aug. 23, 1985.......... 112
Exhibit 1 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
Second Floor Central Terminal Main Lobby at
Ts CSCiisNeGheki bh a4 es aaa 6 60a «66006
il
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Exhibit 2 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
First Floor Central Terminal Circulation Areas
at LaGuardia .......ccscccvecssuneueeeeeeneeeeen™ 117
Exhibit 3 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
First and Second Floor Delta Unit Terminal Cir-
culation Areas at LaGuardia..................+5, 118
Exhibit 4 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
Central First Floor Lobby Area of North Termi-
nal of Newark .......scssccessseesun ene neeeeee 119
Exhibit 5 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
Departure Level Mezzanine/Lobby and Corri-
dor Areas of Terminal A at Newark............. 120
Exhibit 6 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
Arrivals Level Lobby/Mezzanine Area of Ter-
minal B at Newark... ......secscsesescsnceseunen 121
Exhibit 7 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
First Floor IAB Arrivals Lobby at JFK ........... 122
Exhibit 8 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Map of
Second Floor IAB East and West Wing Building
Corridors and Lobby Areas at JFK............... 123
Exhibits 9-18 to Rumbaugh Declaration - Maps
of Various General Circulation Areas in the
Respective Unit Terminals at JFK ................ 124
Plaintiffs’ Notice of Motion for Summary Judg-
ment or for a Preliminary Injunction, dktd. Nov.
12, 198B.. 0. cccecesccccsense eee nein 134
Civil Rule 3(g) Statement of Plaintiffs’ in Support
of Motion for Summary Judgment, dktd. Nov.
12, 19BB.....cccccccececscesees ese e mene 137
ili
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Affidavit of Alan J. Attias in Support of Plaintiffs’
Motion for Summary Judgment, served Nov. 12,
IESE ER UGE SN C6 ec sceksccccacccccccccces 181
Exhibit 1 to Attias Declaration - Fact Sheet for
JFK International Airport........................ 194
Exhibit 2 to Attias Declaration - Fact Sheet for
eG ais n acs pccssaccscccs. 205
Exhibit 3 to Attias Declaration - Fact Sheet for
Newark International Airport.................... 212
Exhibit 4 to Attias Declaration - Port Authority
Capital Program 1987-1991....................... 222
VOLUME II
Exhibit 5 to Attias Declaration - 1986 Airport
EES Se 292
Exhibit 6 to Attias Declaration - Port Authority
Es 4 342
Exhibit 7 to Attias Declaration - Port Authority
News, Mar. 12, 1987 (39-87) ..................... 355
Exhibit 8 to Attias Declaration - Getting Around
at JFK, A Guide to John F. Kennedy Interna-
Sch secs cecccsccsccccccce. 365
Exhibit 9 to Attias Declaration - Getting Around
at LGA, A Guide to LaGuardia Airport .......... 392
Exhibit 10 to Attias Declaration - Getting Around
at NIA, A Guide to Newark International Air-
EMU ESEEN ES SSeS sesesscccccccscccccees 419
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Civil Rule 3(g) Statement of Port Authority in
Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary
Judgment, served Jan. 19, 1988 ................
Affidavit of Morris Sloan in Opposition to Plain-
tiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment, dktd. Jan.
Wb SUS Wa hbs bacecécecesbnenseunteus eeeaeupar>
Affidavit of Anthony A. Santangelo in Opposition
to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment,
Gs 5 oe ac ee banecseteredexdeveces
Affidavit of William F. Boice in Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment, dktd.
SO, By EE 64ab odcndabeedes chase eeaeesehenees
Exhibit B. to Affidavit of William F. Boice - Civil
Rule 3(g) Statement of Air Canada Group
Defendants in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion
for Summary Judgment....................+055
Affidavit of Leif Andersson in Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment, dktd.
SK. E- Ue < bu oe be ectreveweddeceseesebeaesscs
Transcript of Proceedings Before United States
Magistrate Michael A. Dolinger on March 25,
POU, GROG. BR DE, TO occ c cc csecccvensseces
Supplemental Affidavit of Morris Sloane in Oppo-
sition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judg-
ment, Gktd. Apr. 22, 19GB..........cccccecceess
Exhibit B to Sloan Affidavit - Amendment to
Airport Rules and Regulations Governing Non-
commercial Activity and Prohibiting Vending
SEE PE OT EE ae Oe
Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Supplemental Declaration of Frederick V. Hurst,
Jr. in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Sum-
mary Judgment, dktd. Apr. 22, 1988
Settlement Agreement and Release Between
ISKCON and Airline Defendants, dktd. May 10,
WEE S600 Wa SAGES EV adn HEKE66-000KOS 05 rye
Port Authority’s Objections to Magistrate’s Report
and Recommendation, dktd. Dec. 14, 1988
Judgment of District Court, dktd. Oct. 19, 1989 ..
Mandate of Court of Appeals, filed Feb. 25, 1991.
Page
a
.. 548
oo
DATE
10-9-75
10-30-75
11-28-75
12-19-75
12-24-75
1-22-76
1-30-76
1-30-76
1-30-76
2-3-76
3-12-76
3-12-76
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
NR.
1
2
PROCEEDINGS
Filed Complaint and issued summons.
Filed pltf’s affdvt. of personal service
upon defendants of: memorandum in
support of temp. and prel. injunction;
OSC for pre affdvt. of Barry A. Fischer
and affdvt. of John Winslow, on
10-29-75.
Filed summons & Marshal's return.
New York Port Authority
Eastern Airlines
Served: Date:
By: C. Zaffarance 11-05-75
M. Tanner 11-06-75
Filed transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 10-30-75.
Fld 1ST AMENDED COMPLT
Fld deft’s notice of motion for an order
pur to FRCP 12(b) to dismiss the
complt pur to FRCP 12(b). . . ret
2-20-76 at 10AM.
Fld Pitffs’ OSC for leave to further
amend complt & related relied . . . ret
1-30-76 at 1030 AM Rm 1106.
Fld Deft’s Affdvt inopposition to file
an Second Amended complt.
Fld Order that deft Eastern Air Lines
is dismissed from this litigation. W/O
prej and w/o costs. . . . Carter, J mn
Fld Second Amended Complt for
Declaratory & Inj Relief.
Filed transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 12-11-75
Filed transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 1-30-76
5-6-76
1-17-77
10-11-77
10-27-77
11-4-77
Filed transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 2-20-76
Fld Opinion #45525 . . . For the rea-
sons set forth, the motion to dismiss is
granted as to deft Port Authority and
denied as to deft Lee. Deft Lee is
given leave to renew his motion to dis-
miss should pltffs fail to join necessary
ptys in a reasonable time. Pitffs’
motion for a prel inj. is also
denied . . . The foregoing shal! consti-
tute the court’s findings of Fact and
conclusions of law in accordance with
FRCivP 52(a). . . . It is so Ordered.
.. . Carter, J. mn
Fld memo end on bk of Motion fld
7-18-77 - The motion to amend the
complt, not opposed by deft is
granted. So Ordered . . . Carter, J. mn
FLD FIRST AMENDED COM-
PLT .. . Iss Subp.
Fld Pitffs’ affdvt of personal service of
AMENDED compit upon
Aeroflot Airline by Ms. Kirsnova on
11-1-77
Ozark Airlines by Mr J. Julius on
11-1-77
Aerolineas Argentinas Airline by D.
Conesa on 10-28-77
Aeromexico S.A Airlines by C. Trejo
on 10-28-77
Air Afrique Airline by C. Nluners on
10-28-77
Air Canada Airline by Mr. Campbell
on 10-28-77
R. AirFrance Airline by Mr E. Eyt
Sacaza on 10-28-77
Air India Airline by Y. Alvares on
10-28-77
Air Jamaica Airline by R. E. Gladd
on 10-28-77
Air Panama Airline by P. Chempitaz
on 10-28-77
Alitalia Airline by A. D. Croce on
10-28-77
Avianca Colombian Airlines by Mr. J.
Thoen on 10-28-77
British Airways by T. Hiil on
10-28-77
CSA Czech Airline by R. Allalouf on
10-31-77
Dominican De Aviation by E. Bau-
champs on 10-25-77
Egyptair Airline Disc. 12-28-77 by Mr
A. Osman on 10-28-77
Finnair Airline by Herkert on
10-28-77
Ecuatoriana Airline Disc. 5-15-78 by
Receptionist on 11-1-77
El Al Israel Airlines Ltd by Securty
Guad on 11-1-77
Icelandic Airlines Inc by R. E. Delam
on 10-28-77
Iran Air by F. Kimmons on 10-28-77
Irish International Airlines by Mr.
Domooe on 10-28-77
Japan Air Lines by D. Eldridge on
10-28-77
JAT Yugoslav Airlines by G. Step-
anovic on 11-1-77
KLM by F. Kielman on 10-28-77
Lan Chile Airlines by Ms Migailez
on 10-28-77
Lot Polish Airlines by Mr Resica on
10-28-77
Nigeria Airways by BM Duggash on
10-31-77
Olympic Airways by P.A. Postolidis
on 10-28-77
Pakistan Intern. Airlines by B.
Bernstein on 10-28-77
Royal Air Maroc by G. Luque on
10-28-77
Allegheny Airlines by Mr. McCahley
on 10-28-77
American Airlines by D. Munoz on
10-31-77
Braniff Intern. Airways by R. de
Merias on 10-31-77
Eastern Airlines by Mrs Wheelan on
10-28-77
No Central Airlines by E. O. Connor
on 10-31-77
Northwest Airlines, Inc by M.
O’Connell on 10-28-77
Pan Ameican World Airways by R.
A. Fisher on 10-28-77
Piedmont Airlines by V. Dieringer on
10-28-77
Trans World Airlines by person
authorized on 10-31-77
United Airlines by D. Armato on
10-28-77
So. African Airways by Mr. Kor- 11-15-77 Fld Deft Swissair’s motion for summ
nedeger on 10-28-77 judg... . etc... . ret 11-25-77-10AM
11-18-77 Fld Amended Summs with Marshal’s
Swissair by Mr. Ledermann on -—.
10-28-77
TAP Port. Airways by M. Countnho
on 10-28-77
TAROM by G. Teodoresey on
10-28-77
Varig by H. Bernardo on 10-31-77
VIASA by S. Alba on 10-31-77
Sabena by R. Cohen on 11-2-77
Southern Airways by P. Ingham on
11-1-77
Air New England by N. Ashley on
11-1-77
Lufthansa German Airlines by D.
Langon on 11-1-77
11-21-77
11-30-77
12-2-77
12-16-77
12-28-77
1-5-78
1-27-78
2-2-78
2-22-78
3-21-78
3-21-78
N.Y. Airways, Inc by J. Walsh on
11-1-77
Scandianavian Airlines Sys. by L.
Rizzo on 11-2-77
Iberia Airlines of Spain by Otto on
11-2-77
Trans Mediterranean Airway by G.
Ferrari on 11-7-77.
Fld Affdvt of Service of Complt &
Summs upon:
Delta Airlines by Ms B. Langman on
11-4-77
Ozark Airlines by Ms D. Rodetis on
11-4-77
Fld Pitffs’ memo of Law in opposition
to deft Swissair’s motion for summ
judg.
Fld Answer of Deft Nigeria Airway. bf
Fld Deft Icelanic Airlines, Inc’s answer
to 1st suppl complt. Sc
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Egyptair. . . . Carter, J.
Fld Deft Walter Lee’s ANSWER.
Fid Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Avianca Colombian Air-
lines . . . Carter, J.
Fld Opinion #46852 . . . Accordingly,
Deft’s motion for summ Judg on fail-
ure to state a claima...etc... is
denied . . . Carter, J. mn
Fld Deft Air Canada, Air Jamaica, Air
Panama et al’s answer complt... sk
Fld Deft KLM’s answer to Ist
Amended Complt. sk
Fld Deft Swissair’s answer to Complt.
zrp
3-22-78
3-22-78
3-23-78
3-28-78
4-5-78
4-5-78
4-6-78
4-6-78
4-10-78
4-27-78
4-27-78
4-27-78
Fld Stip & Order of Dismissal as to
Deft Dominicana Airlines w/o prej.
Carter, J.
Fld Deft Lot Polish airlines’s answer to
Ist Amended Complt. sk
Fid Defts Air India, E. Al Israel Air-
lines, Ltd Iberia Airlines of Spain, Irish
International Airlines, Japan Airlines,
LAN-Chile Airlines, Pakistan Alnterna-
tional Airlines., SAS., Sabena Belgian
World Airlines, Varig Airlines., and
Viasa-Venezuelan Internaional Airway
(collectively, “these defts”) ‘s ANSWER
to 1st Amended complt. jrgsb
Fld Deft Air France’s Answer. bejh
Fld Defts Aerolineas Argentinas et al’s
Motion to dismiss . . . ret
4-21-78-10AM Rm 2703
Fld Defts Aerolineas Argentinas et al’s
Memo to dismiss
Fid Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to Deft Iran Air with Prej . . . Carter,
J.
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to Deft Tap-Portuguese Airway. Carter,
J.
Fld Deft Air Afrique’s Answer to Com-
pit. bejh
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Air Panama with prej.. .
Carter, J.
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Royal Air Maroc with/prej.
Carter, J.
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Finnair with/prej. Carter, J.
4-27-78
4-27-78
5-15-78
5-18-78
5-25-78
5-26-78
6-8-78
6-23-78
6-27-78
7-13-78
7-20-78
7-20-78
Fld Stip & Order of discontinuance as
to deft British W.I. Airways w/prej.
Carter, J.
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft Olympic Airways, S.A. w/prej.
Carter, J.
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to Deft Ecuatoriana . . . Carter, J.
Fid Pitffs’ memo in opposition to defts
Aero Argentinas, et al’s motion to dis-
miss the 1st amended complt.
Fld Pre Trial Schedule Order .. .
Carter, J.
Fld Memo End on Motion fld 4-5-78
Motion denied for reasons stated in
open Court .. . It is so Ordered...
Carter, J mn
Fld Stip & Order of Discontinuance as
to deft AErolineas Argentinas
ONLY .. . Carter, J.
Fld Defts Alitalia Airlines and
Lufthansa German Airlines’s Answer.
hr
Fld Notice of Reassignment to Judge
Sand nm
Fld Pitffs. Request to enter default.
Fld Stip & Order as to dft. CSA
Czechoslovak Airlines this action is
discontinued with prejudice, etc. So
Ordered Sand J.
Fld stip & Order of discontinuance as
to dft. Lot Polish Airlines with preju-
dice & without costs. So Ordered Sand
J.
7-20-78
7-20-78
9-26-78
12-18-78
1-3-79
1-31-79
2-6-79
2-14-79
Fld stip & order of discontinuance as
to dft. South African Airways with
prejudice & without costs, etc. So
Ordered Sand J.
Fid stip & order of discontinuance as
to dft. Air Jamaica with prejudice &
without costs, etc. So Ordered Sand J.
Fid Notion of reassignment to Judge
Lowe. (MN)
Filed Stip and order of discontinuance
against deft. Air Afrique without costs
to either pty. LOWE, J.
Filed Stip and order of discontinuance
as to New York Airways, Inc. deft.,
with prejudice and without costs to
either pltffs or deft. N.Y. Airways, Inc.
LOWE, J.
Filed Stip and order of discontinuance
as to deft. North Central Airlines, Inc.
LOWE, J.
Filed Deft. Walter Lee’s ans. and
responses to pltffs’ “First set of inter-
rogs to deft. Port Authority of N.Y.
and N.J. Walter Lee.
Filed deft. Lee’s memorandum of law
in response to the Ct’s request for a
memorandum setting forth deft. Lee’s
position with regard to the alleged
constitutional right of pltffs to distrib-
ute liturature and solicit donations
inside the various terminal bldgs of
Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark air-
ports.
02-20-79
02-20-79
5-23-79
7-31-79
7-31-79
11-7-79
11-8-79
3-11-81
7-23-82
10
Filed stip and order of dismissal as
against deft VIASA-VENEZUELAN
AIRLINES ONLY. and without costs to
eithe pltffs or deft VIASA. So Order.
LOWE, J.
Filed stip and order of dismissal as
against deft PAKISTAN INTERNA-
TIONAL AIRLINES ONLY. with
prejudice and without costs to either
pitffs or deft PAKISTAN. So Ordered.
LOWE, J.
Filed Stip and order of discontinuance
as to deft. El Al Israel Airlines Ltd.
with prejudice and without costs to
either pty. LOWE, J.
Filed Pitffs. Affdvt. and motion for
Preliminary Inj. ret. 8-17-79.
Filed Stip of dismissal against deft.
Nigeria Ariways Ltd. with prejudice
and without costs to either pltffs or
deft. Nigeria Airways Ltd. LOWE, J.
Filed deft. Lee’s Affdvt. by M. Sloane,
in opposition to pltffs’ motion for a
preliminary Inj.
Filed defts. notice of motion to dismiss
for lack of subject matter jurisdiction
ret. 11-30-79.
Filed Transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 1-30-81.
Fid Memo Opinion & Order
#53452 . . . Defts motion to dismiss the
amended complt for lack of jurisdiction
is denied. Pitffs motion for prel inj
relief is denied . . . Lowe, J. m/n
9-29-82
10-5-82
1-10-83
4-19-83
6-13-83
4-20-84
5-8-84
5-24-84
11
Fld Air Canada Group of defts Notice
of Motion to amend this Courts Memo
Opinion & Order of 7-21-82 to incl a
certification purs to 28 USC
1292(b) .. . etc . . . ret: 10-5-82
Fld pitffs opposition to motion for cer-
tification
Filed Transcript of record of proceed-
ings, dated 9-7-82
Fld Memo Opinion & Order
#54571 . . . Deft airlines motion for an
amendment of the memo opinion &
order of 7-21-82 to permit an interlocu-
tory appeal of the state action issue
purs to 28 USC 1292(b) is gran-
ted . . . The Court’s Memo Opinion of
7-21-82 is amended as indi-
cated .. . Lowe, J. m/n
Fld true copy of order from USCA that
the motion to grant leave to file an
interlocutory appeal is gran-
ted .. . Clerk, USCA m/n
Fld True copy of U.S.C.A. order and
opinion ordered that the appeal
remanded without costs to either party
to the District Court for further pro-
ceedings consistent with the
opinion . . . So ordered . . . Clerk,
U.S.C.A. copy sent to Lowe, J.
Filed ORDER that this action is
referred to Mag. Dolinger for purposes
indicated. Each deft is to submit a sep-
arate Pre trial Order with PIitff . . . So
Ordered, Lowe, J.
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE HELD BY
Mag. Dolinger
7-6-84
8-1-84
8-6-81
8-10-84
8-17-84
8-27-84
8-29-84
8-29-84
9-11-84
9-25-84
9-26-84
10-9-84
12
Fid Deft Lufthansa German Airlines
notice of motion for a protective order
purs to Hague Evidence Convention ret
8-1-84
Fid Stip & order of dismissal against Deft
Lan-Chile Airlines with prej, and without
costs .. . So ordered . . . Lowe, J.
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE HELD BY
MAG DOLINGER
Fld Order that that pltffs application to
modify order of 8-7-84 is denied . . . So
ordered Mag Dolinger
Fld Pitffs motion for a protective order
Fld Order that pltffs application is
granted and reply papers shall be served
and fld by 9-6-84 . . . So ordered-
.. . Dolinger Mag.
Fld Air Canada Group brief in opposition
to pitffs motion to amend complaint
Fld Air Canada Group brief in opposition
to pltffs motion for protective order
Fld opinion & Order 56612, that defts
motion for a protective order is denied
and deft shall comply with pltffs notice
for production of docs within 2 weeks
... So ordered . . . Dolinger Mag... csc.
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE HELD BY
MAG DOLINGER
Fld order that Air India group defts may
file a response before 10-2-84 . . . pltff
shall serve motion for a protective order
by 10-5-84 . . . defts shall serve and file a
response by 010-12-84 . . . discovery is to
be done by 12-31-84. . . So ordered Dol-
inger Mag m.n csc
Fld pltffs motion for protective order
with respect to second set of interrogs
10-15-84
10-15-84
11-1-84 ©
2-28-85
3-7-85
3-11-85
3-12-85
3-18-85
3-18-85
3-18-85
4-9-85
13
Fld Defts Affidavit in opposition of pltffs
motion for a protective order...
Fld Air India Deft memo of law to pitffs
for a protective order...
Fld Air India Group of Defts affidavit of
Philip Le B. Douglas in re plitffs motion
for a protective order
Fld Opinion #57308 ordered that pltffs
motion for a protective orders relieving
them of the obligation to Answer a vast
body of interrogs propounded by 2
groups of defts . . . motion is gran-
ted ...So ordered .. . Dolinger, Mag m.c
Fld Magistrates Report & Recommenda-
tion that pltffs motion to serve & file
complaint (amended) in form as indi-
cated be granted except with respect to
the form of identification of the Supt. of
Port Authority Police . . . Dolinger, Mag
m/c
Fld Air Canada Notice of motion for an
order rejecting decision of Mag Dolinger
ret 3-27-85...
Fld Deft Air India Objections to Opinion
and order of Mag. Dolinger Rec. Night
Deposit 3-11-85
Fld Defts notice of motion with support-
ing papers for an order rejecting certain
aspects of Report & Recommendation of
Mag M.H. Dolinger ret 4-4-85
Fld Defts Objections to Report & Recom-
mendation of Mag Dolinger
Fld Air India Defts Objections to report &
Recommendation of Mag Dolinger
Fld pltffs response to defts objection to
Mag Dolinger Report & Recommendation
of 3-7-85
4-15-85
6-4-85
6-4-85
6-4-85
6-4-85
8-19-85
8-23-85
6-02-87
6-01-87
14
Fid plitffs response to objections of Air
Canada & Air India in re Mag Dolingers
Opinion & order of 2-27-85.
Fld order that all discovery is to be com-
pleted by 6-10-85 . . . So ordered
. . . Dolinger, cmc
Fld Partial Stip and order of Dismissal
against Braniff Inc. . . . with prej and
costs .. . So ordered .. . Lowe, J.
Fld Partial Stip and order of dismissal
against Air Canada . . . with prej and
without costs .. . So ordered . . . Lowe, J.
Fld Stip and order of Partial dismissal
against Republic Airlines . . . without
costs .. . So ordered .. . Lowe, J.
Fld. Pitff’s in opposition to Airline Defts’
motion to dismiss.
Fid. pitff’s declaration of Brian Rum-
baugh in opposition to defts’ motion to
dismiss and exhibits.
Fid. Order on Defendant’s motions to
dismiss. If any party intends to file a
dispositive motion other than with
respect to the state action issue, it shall
do so by no later than 7/31/87, if no such
motion is filed, the parties shall submit a
joint pre-trial order by 8/31/87 . . . So
Ordered Mag. Dolinger CMC RFG
Fld. Report and Recommendation to
Judge Lowe, Defendants’ motion to dis-
miss for lack of subject matter jurisdic-
tion be denied. Pursuant to Rule 7, the
parties shall have ten days from this date
to file written objections to this report
and Recommendation. Such objection
shall be filed with the Clerk of the Court,
6-10-87
6-11-87
6-11-87
6-11-87
6-15-87
6-15-87
6-17-87
6-24-87
11-10-87
11-12-87 |
11-12-87
15
with extra copies delivered to the Cham-
bers of the Honorable Mary Johnson
Lowe, Room 803 and to the chambers of
the undersigned, Room 503. Mag. Dol-
inger RFG CMC
Fld. deft’s obj’s to Magistrates report and
recommendations. GC
Fld. Air India deft’s statement of obj. to
opinion and order of Mag. Dol-
inger ... GC
Fid. Air Canada’s affidavit of William H.
Boice . . . in support of motion .. . GC
Fld. Air Canada’s deft’s notice of motion-
.. . for an order rejecting in its entirety
the report and recommendatation issued
by Mag Dolinger .. . GC
Fld. Air India deft’s statement of obj. to
opinion and order of Mag Dolinger (org.
to Judge Lowe) GC
Fld. deft. Lufthansa German Airlines’s
statement of obj. to report and recom-
mendation to Mag Dolingers report. GC
Fld deft. Lee’s notice of motion. . . for a
order rejecting the portions of the Report
and Recommendation of Mag. Dolinger
. ret. 6-30-87. GC
Fid. pltff’s repsonse to obj. to report and
recommendation of Mag. Dolinger
we.
Fld. Stip and Order . . . Sabena Belgian
World Airlines is dismissed from the
action as a party .. . LOWE, J. GC
Fld. pltff’s brief . . . in support of motion
for summary judgment. GC
Fid. pltff’s statement of facts in support
of motion... for summary judgment. GC
11-12-87
1-19-88
1-19-88
1-19-88
1-19-88
1-19-88
1-20-88
1-20-88
1-20-88
3-16-88
3-31-88
4-22-88
4-22-88
16
Fld. pltff’s notice of motion . . . for sum-
mary judgment .. . ret. 12-21-87. GC
Fld. deft. Lufthensa German Airlines’
brief in opposition to pltff’s motion for
summary judgment . . . GC
Fid. defts affidavit of Anthony A. San-
tangelo . . . in opposition to motion for
summary judgment . . . GC
Fid. deft. Sup. of Pt. Authority Police’s
memo of law in opposition to pltff’s
motion for summary judgment . . . GC
Fld. deft’s affidavit of Morris Sloa-
ne... in opposition to pltff’s moiton for
summary judgment . . . GC
Fid. certain deft’s affidavit of William H.
Boice . . . in support of memo of law in
opposition to motion for summary judg-
ment... GC
Fid. Air India deft’s statement purs. to
rule 3(g) GC
Fld. deft. Air India affidavit of Leif
Andersson . . . in opposition to pltff’s
motion for summary judgment . . . GC
Fld. Air India deft’s memo of law at
opposition to pltff’s motion for summary
judgment .. . GC
Fld. pitff’s reply to oppostion of Superin-
tendnt of Port Authority Police to motion
for summary judgment . . . GC
Files Transcript of record of proceedings,
dated 3-25-88
Fld. deft’s supplemental memo of law in
opposition to pltff’s motion for summary
judgment . . . GC
Fld. deft’s supplemental affidvit of
Morris Sloane . . . in opposition to pltff’s
motion for summary judgment. . . GC
et ee
10-25-88
12-14-88
12-14-88
12-14-88
12-30-88
17
Fld. deft’s supplemental affidavit of Fre-
derick V. Hurst Jr. in opposition to pltff’s
motion for summary judgment... . GC
Fld. Stip and Order of Settlement agree-
ment and release . . . Airline deft’s will
pay to pltff’s the total sum of $165,000.00
within 30 days of the date . . . with preju-
dice with each party to bear its own cos-
ts... LOWE, J. cm GC
Fld. REPORT AND RECOMMENDA-
TION . . . pltff’s motion for summary
judgment be granted . . . the parties shall
have 10 days from teh date to file written
objections to the Report and Recommen-
dation . . . such objections ahll be filed
withe the clerk of the Court. with extra
copies delivered to the chambers of Mary
Johnson
Lowe... MAG. DOLINGER cmc 10-25-88
GC
Fld. deft’s memo of law . . . in support of
deft’s objections to Magistate’s report
and recommendation. GC
Fld. deft’s objections to Magistrate’s
report and recommendatoin. GC
Fld. deft’s reply affidavit of Morris Sloa-
ne... in opposition to pltff’s motion for
summary judgment and for a permanent
inj. GC
Fld. plff’s response to Port Authority’s
objection to report and recommendation
of Mag. Dolinger granting pltff’s motion
for summary judgment. GC
12-30-88
9-18-89
10-19-89
10-23-89
11-8-89
11-24-89
1-11-90
1-17-90
18
Fld. pltff’s declaration of David M. Liber-
man... in support of pltff’s reponse to
Port Authority’s objection to the report
and recommendation of Mag. Dolinger
GC
Fld. OPINION AND ORDER
#64894 ... Plaintiffs Motion for summary
judgment is granted ... LOWE J, cm DO.
Fid. JUDGMENT, . . . that defts and each
of them, and their agents, srevants,
attnys and employees are permanently
enjoined from enforcing or attempting to
enforce, . . . LOWE, J. eod: 10-23-89 NW
Fid. Stip & Order, . . . that the time for
either party to make an app. for attnys
fees . . . shall be extended until a reason-
able time and in no event less than sixty
days after all appeals or other review in
this action have become final ... LOWE,
J. NW
Fid. DEFT NOTICE OF APPEAL to the
U.S.C.A. for the second circuit, from the
final judgment on 10-23-89.
Fowarded copy of notice of appeal and
decket sheet entries to court of appeals
and copy of notice of appeals to the dis-
trict court judge. NW
Fld. Stip & Order of Record on
Appeal, .. . LOWE, J. NW
Fid. Notice that the record on appeal in
the action has been transmitted to the
U.S.C.A. for the second circuit on
1-17-90. NW
5-10-91
19
Fld True Copy of U.S.C.A. MANDATE: It
is Ordered, adjudged & decreed that the
judgment of said District Court be and it
hereby is affirmed in part, reversed in
part in accordance with the opinion of
this court. ELAINE B. GOLDSMITH,
CLERK. EOD: 5-21-91. GQ
20
BARRY A. FISHER, a member of
Fleishman, McDaniel, Brown & Weston
6922 Hollywood Boulevard, Suite 718
Hollywood, California 90028
(213) 466-6171
and
LEONARD KAUFMAN, a member of
Kommel, Rogers, Kaufman, Lorber & Shenkman
380 Madison Avenue
New York, New York 10017
(212) 986-9779
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY NO. 75CIV538RLC
FOR KRISHNA
CONSCIOUSNESS, INC. and
JOHN WINSLOW, on behalf of )
themselves and all International ) COMPLAINT FOR
—"— ~~
Society for Krishna DECLARATORY
Consciousness members, AND INJUNCTIVE
RELIEF
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
NEW YORK PORT AUTHORITY
and EASTERN AIRLINES and
WALTER LEE, Chief of Port
Authority Police, individually
and in official capacity,
Defendants.
wee ie ie ie ie oe oa ee
5 le inert we
21
I
INTRODUCTION
i 1. This is a Civil Rights suit for declaratory and
injunctive relief pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and 28
U.S.C. §§ 2201-02, brougit by the Hare Krishna Society to
enjoin enforcement of three New York Port Authority
licensing regulations which are standardless and uncon-
Stitutional both on their face and as construed and
applied to the distribution of religious literature and
solicitation of donations in those portions of Kennedy,
LaGuardia and Newark International Airports open to
the general public. The regulations at issue are defective
because they vest discretion in officials to grant or deny
licenses for the exercise of First Amendment rights, with-
out definitive, narrow, and objective standards to govern
such discretion. Plaintiffs seek temporary injunctive relief
so that they may proceed with their proselytizing which
is the very mainstay and lifeblood of their religious
movement.
I]
JURISDICTION
2. The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28
U.S.C. §§ 1331 (Federal Question) and 1343 (3-4) (Civil
Rights). The matter in controversy exceeds $10,000.00
exclusive of interest and costs. |
22
Ill
PARTIES
Plaintiffs
3. INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA
CONSCIOUSNESS, INC. (hereinafter “ISKCON” or
“Hare Krishna Society”) is an international religious soci-
ety which espouses the religious and missionary views of
Krishna Consciousness. It is duly organized as a non-
profit religious corporation under the laws of the State of
New York and maintains temples and schools in cities
throughout the United States and world, including New
York, New York.
4. JOHN WINSLOW is the President of the New
York Temple of ISKCON. He has been a devotee of the
religion for four years and was ordained as a priest in
1972. His spiritual name, the name he is commonly
known as, is GOPIJ[ANAVALLAVA DAS BRAHMACARY.
JOHN WINSLOW performs religious missionary work in
public places and wishes to continue doing so, including
in the public portions of Port Authority’s Airports.
Defendants
5. NEW YORK PORT AUTHORITY is a public cor-
poration with principal offices in the Southern District of
New York, created in 1921 by agreement between the
States of New York and New Jersey. McKinney's Consoli-
dated Laws of New York, §§ 6401, 6404. The NEW YORK
PORT AUTHORITY operates Newark, Kennedy, and
LaGuardia Airports and maintains its own police force
—
:
:
3
;
:
7
23
which is charged with law enforcement. The Port Author-
ity police are expressly provided with the powers of
“peace officers”. New York Code of Criminal Procedure,
§ 154. As such, they are charged with the implementation
and enforcement of the regulations at issue in this com-
plaint, including the arrest of those in violation. Walter
Lee is Chief of Police.
6. EASTERN AIRLINES is a Delaware corporation
with executive offices in the Southern District of new
York. EASTERN AIRLINES is a Port Authority lessee at
Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark Airports.
7. The acts and practices of the Defendants herein
and their agents, as herein alleged, were performed
under code or law, and, therefore constitute actions of the
State within the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment
to the United States Constitution.
IV
FACTS
8. The Hare Krishna Society imposes on its mem-
bers the duty to perform a religious ritual known as
Sankirtan, which consists of soliciting and accepting
donations and contributions while disseminating reli-
gious literature and information in public places. Sankir-
tan is directed to spreading religious truth as it is known
to the Kare [sic] Krishna Society, attracting new members,
and supporting the Society’s religious activities. Dona-
tions and book sales are the very lifeblood and principal
means of support of this religious movement. The
24
devotees often wear distinctive and unconventional gar-
ments, hair styles, and spiritual body markings.
9. ISKCON devotees have recently attempted to
perform Sankirtan in those portions of Kennedy, LaGuar-
dia, and Newark International Airports open to the gen-
eral public. Plaintiffs seek only to distribute literature
and solicit donations in terminals; they do not seek to
dance, chant, or to engage in any similar conduct.
10. The Kennedy, LaGuardia, and Newark Airport
terminals are operated and policed by the New York Port
Authority and are thoroughfares for millions of people
yearly, including millions who are not passengers.
11. The NEW YORK PORT AUTHORITY has pro-
mulgated regulations respecting the distribution of litera-
ture and solicitation of donations at Kennedy, LaGuardia
and Newark Airports. New York Code of Rules and Reg-
ulations, Title 21, Chapter 24.
12. Section 1260.13 of the Port Authority Regula-
tions provides that “No person shall post, distribute or
display signs, advertisements, circulars, printed or writ-
ten matter at an air terminal without permission.” Section
1260.14 states that “No person shall solicit funds for any
purpose at an air terminal without permission.” Section
1260.15 provides that “No person, unless duly authorized
by the Port Authority, shall, in or upon any area, plat-
form, stairway, station, waiting room or any other appur-
tenance of an air terminal: (a) sell, or offer for sale any
article or merchandise; (d) [sic] solicit alms.”
13. Section 1260.1(h) provides that “Permission
shall mean permission granted by the manager, unless
SR eel
)
:
|
:
1
:
i
.
25
otherwise specifically provided.” Section 1260.1(e) states
that “Manager shall mean the Port Authority manager or
other Port Authority official in charge of an air terminal,
or his duly authorized representative.” No standards
whatsoever are included to guide the discretion of the
manager or his delegate.
14. The NEW YORK PORT AUTHORITY recognizes
that Plaintiffs may distribute literature and solicit dona-
tions in the public portions of the Kennedy, LaGuardia
and Newark terminals. However, the Port Authority’s
position is that it loses its jurisdiction once it leases
lobbies and other public portions of the terminals to
tenants such as EASTERN AIRLINES. The power to grant
or deny permission to engage in First Amendment con-
duct as provided in the above-referred to regulations is
considered by the Port Authority to be delegated to its
lessees such as EASTERN AIRLINES.
15. Accordingly, the Port Authority has refused to
give Plaintiffs permission to practice Sankirtan in public
portions of the airports such as lobbies which are leased
to EASTERN AIRLINES and other carriers.
16. EASTERN AIRLINES has informed Plaintiffs
that, while Plaintiffs might distribute literature, they are
prohibited from soliciting donations in those portions of
the terminal open to the general public but leased to
EASTERN AIRLINES.
17. Plaintiffs have been informed by Port Authority
police that, without EASTERN AIRLINES’ permission,
they are subject to arrest at the Eastern terminals for
trespass. No prosecutions are presently pending against
26
Plaintiffs respecting the regulations at issue in this case or
for trespass.
18. EASTERN AIRLINES’ position respecting Ken-
nedy, LaGuardia and Newark Airports differs from its
position at the Boston International Airport where the
same Port Authority-Lessee relationship pertains. The
Massachusetts Port Authority recently recognized Plain-
tiffs’ right to distribute literature and solicit donations in
terminals, but deferred to EASTERN AIRLINES as to
whether it would be allowed in the EASTERN AIRLINES
terminal. The EASTERN AIRLINES manager at Boston
International Airport readily agreed to Plaintiffs’ Sankir-
tan, including solicitation of donations, to an extent equal
to that acknowledged by the Massachusetts Port Author-
ity.
19. The regulations at issue, on their face and as
construed and applied to prohibit the distribution and
sale of religious literature by members of a religious
organization, without a permit for which no narrow or
definite standards are specified, substantively and pro-
cedurally abridges the exercise of freedoms of speech and
press, arbitrarily deprives persons of their liberty and
property without due process of law, capriciously denies
the equal protection of the laws, and is vague, ambiguous
and overbroad, all in violation of the First and Fourteenth
Amendments to the United States Constitution.
.
:
|
|
{
}
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
27
V
EQUITY AND IRREPARABLE INJURY
20. There is between the parties an actual contro-
versy as hereinbefore set forth herein. The Plaintiffs are
suffering irreparable injury and are threatened with
irreparable harm in the future by reason of the acts herein
complained of and a substantial loss or impairment of
freedom of expression has occurred and will continue to
occur so long as Defendants’ conduct continues. Plaintiffs
will be harassed and intimidated by Defendants and their
agents utilizing the ordinances at issue so long as they
continue to proselytize at the Kennedy, LaGuardia and
Newark Airports. Furthermore, the chilling effect upon
the exercise of First Amendment rights may derive from
the fact of threats of prosecution unaffected by prospects
of its success or failure.
21. Plaintiffs have no plain, adequate or complete
remedy to speedily redress the wrongs herein complained
of other than this action. Any other remedy to which
Plaintiffs could be remitted would be attended by such
uncertainties and delays as to deny substantial relief,
involve a multiplicity of suits, and cause further irrepar-
able injury, damage and inconvenience to the Plaintiffs
and to those similarly situated. The award of damages to
Plaintiffs is not adequate to protect them from the con-
tinuing police conduct and the chilling effect it has upon
the exercise ot Plaintiffs’ constitutional rights.
28
VI
RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray that this Court:
1. Declare that the New York - New Jersey Air
Terminals Regulations [New York State Code of Rules
and Regulations, Title 21, Chapter 24, Sections
1260.13-1260.15], on their face and as construed and
applied to prohibit the distribution or sale of Plaintiffs’
religious literature by members of a religious organiza-
tion, abridges the free exercise of religion and the free-
doms of speech and press, contrary to the First and
Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitu-
tion;
2. Temporarily and permanently enjoin the Defen-
dants from arresting or participating in the arrest of
Plaintiffs or their membership for violation of the New
York - New Jersey Air Terminals Regulations [New York
State Code of Rules and Regulations, Title 21, Chapter 24,
Section 1260.13-1260.15], and from any way interfering
directly or indirectly with Plaintiffs’ right to be in the
public portions of the Kennedy, LaGuardia or Newark
Airports, including arresting or participating in Plaintiffs’
arrest for trespass, where Plaintiffs or their membership
are engaged in the peaceable dissemination of literature
or solicitation of donations or sales in any portions inside
or outside of the terminals generally open to the public;
and
etre ain lee ee) ONSEN be tee re
:
:
:
:
‘
.
.
-
)
:
”
|
29
3. Grant Plaintiffs’ attorney’s fees, costs and such
other and further relief as may be equitable and just.
DATED: October 29, 1975.
FLEISHMAN, McDANIEL,
BROWN & WESTON
and
KOMMEL, ROGERS, KAUFMAN,
LORBER & SHENKMAN
By /s/ Barry A. Fisher
BARRY A. FISHER
By /s/ Jon Ns. Kaufman
JON KAUFMAN
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
30
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
- ~x
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR
KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS, INC., |
and BRIAN RUMBAUGH on behalf |
of themselves and all International |
Society for Krishna Consciousness,
Inc. members,
Plaintiffs,
a amen : Index No.
WALTER LEE, Superintendent of 75 Civ. 5388
the Port Authority Police, : (RLC)
individually and in his official
capacity, AEROFLOT SOVIET
AIRLINES, AEROLINEAS : FIRST
ARGENTINAS, AEROMEXICO, S.A.,: AMENDED
AIR AFRIQUE, AIR CANADA, AIR : COMPLAINT
FRANCE, AIR INDIA, AIR
JAMAICA, AIR PANAMA, : (Filed
ALITALIA, AVIANCA COLUMBIAN : Oct. 17, 1977)
AIRLINES, BRITISH AIRWAYS,
BRITISH WEST INDIAN AIRWAYS, :
CSA CZECHOSLOVAK AIRLINES, :
DOMINICAN DE AVIACION,
ECUATORIANA, EGYPTAIR, EL AL :
ISRAEL AIRLINES, LTD., FINNAIR, :
IBERIA AIRLINES OF SPAIN,
ICELANDIC AIRLINES, INC., IRAN :
AIR, IRISH INTERNATIONAL
AIRLINES, JAPAN AIR LINES, JAT- :
YUGOSLAV AIRLINES, KLM
ROYAL DUTCH AIRLINES, LAN-
CHILE AIRLINES, LOT POLISH
i A Ot eR eR
|
|
)
.
)
31
AIRLINES, LUFTHANSA GERMAN
AIRLINES, NIGERIA AIRWAYS,
OLYMPIC AIRWAYS, PAKISTAN
INTERNATIONAL AIRLINES, ROYAL -
AIR MAROC, SABENA-BELGIAN
WORLD AIRLINES, SAS-
SCANDINAVIAN AIRLINES, SOUTH :
AFRICAN AIRWAYS, SWISSAIR, TAP- :
PORTUGUESE AIRWAYS, TAROM
ROMANIAN AIRLINES, VARIG
AIRLINES, VIASA-VENEZUELA
INTERNATIONAL AIRWAYS, AIR
NEW ENGLAND, ALLEGHENY
AIRLINES, INC., AMERICAN
AIRLINES, INC. BRANIFF
INTERNATIONAL AIRWAYS, DELTA
AIR LINES, INC., EASTERN AIR
LINES, INC., NEW YORK AIRWAYS,
INC., NORTH CENTRAL AIRLINES,
NORTHWEST AIRLINES, INC.,
OZARK AIRLINES, PAN AMERICAN
WORLD AIRWAYS, PIEDMONT
AIRLINES, SOUTHERN AIRWAYS,
TRANS WORLD AIRLINES, and
UNITED AIRLINES, INC.,
Defendants.
PLAINTIFFS, by their undersigned attorneys, indi-
vidually and on behalf of all members of the International
Society for Krishna Consciousness, Inc. complaining of
the defendants, respectfully show to the Court and allege
as follows in this, their First Supplemental Complaint
herein.
32
I. JURISDICTION
FIRST: This is a Civil Rights action for declaratory
and injunctive relief pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §1983 and 28
U.S.C. §§2201 and 2202. Plaintiffs seek to redress the
deprivation under color of state law by the defendants of
rights secured to the plaintiffs by the First and Fourteenth
Amendments to the United States Constitution; and seek
to have declared unconstitutional defendants’ official pol-
icy, as hereinafter set forth more particularly, which
results in the deprivation of plaintiffs’ rights to speak and
freely to exercise their religion. Plaintiffs seek to enjoin
defendants permanently from enforcing said policies
against plaintiffs.
SECOND: Jurisdiction of this Court is invoked
under 28 U.S.C. §§1331 and 1343(3) and (4). There exists
between the parties an actual controversy, justiciable in
character, involving in excess of $10,000.00, exclusive of
interest and costs.
II. PARTIES
THIRD: Plaintiff International Society for Krishna
Consciousness, Inc., (hereinafter “ISKCON” or “Hare
Krishna Society”) is an international religious society
which espouses the religious and missionary views of
Krishna Consciousness. It is duly organized as a non-
profit religious corporation under the laws of the State of
New York and maintains temples and schools in cities
throughout the United States, including New York, New
York.
33
FOURTH: Plaintiff Brian Rumbaugh is the acting
President of the New York Temple of ISKCON. He has
been a devotee of the religion for seven years and was
ordained as a priest in 1971. His spiritual name, the name
by which he is commonly known, is Romapada das. Brian
Rumbaugh performs religious missionary work in public
places and wishes to continue doing so, including in John
F. Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark Airports.
FIFTH: Defendant Walter Lee is Superintendent of
the police employed by the Port Authority of New York
and New Jersey (“Port Authority”) which is an entity
created by compact between the states of New York and
New Jersey in 1921. See. McKinney’s Unconsolidated
Laws §6401 through 6404. Port Authority owns and oper-
ates John F. Kennedy and LaGuardia Airports in New
York and Newark Airport in New Jersey. Defendant Lee
is sued individually and in his official capacity as the
Superintendent of the Port Authority Police. As such
defendant Lee is charged with the principle duty of
enforcing the applicable New York and New Jersey crimi-
nal laws and the regulations of the Port Authority at the
Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark Airports.
SIXTH: Defendants Aeroflot Soviet Airlines,
Aerolineas Argentinas, Aeromexico, S.A., Air Afrique,
Air Canada. Air France, Air India, Air Jamaica, Air Pan-
ama, Alitalia, Avianca Colombian Airlines, British Air-
ways, British West Indian Airways, CSA Czechoslovak
Airlines, Dominican De Aviacion, Ecuatoriana, Egyptair,
El Al Israel Airlines, Ltd., Finnair, Iberia Airlines of
Spain, Icelandic Airlines, Inc., Iran Air, Irish International
Airlines, Japan Air Lines, JAT-Yugoslav Airlines, KLM
34
Royal Dutch Airlines, Lan-Chile Airlines, Lot Polish Air-
lines, Lufthansa German Airlines, Nigeria Airways,
Olympic Airways, Pakistan International Airlines, Royal
Air Maroc, SABENA-Belgian World Airlines, SAS-Scan-
dinavian Airlines, South African Airways, Swissair, TAP-
Portuguese Airways, TAROM Romanian Airlines, VARIG
Airlines and VIASA-Venezuela International Airways are
lessees or licensees of terminal space from the Port of
Authority at Kennedy Airport. Each of the aforesaid air-
lines (hereinafter collectively referred to as Foreign-Flag
Carriers) maintains executive, sales or ticket offices
within the Southern District of New York.
SEVENTH: Defendants Air New England, Alle-
gheny Airlines, Inc., American Airlines, Inc., Braniff
International Airways, Delta Airlines, Inc., Eastern Air
Lines, Inc., New York Airways, Inc., North Central Air-
lines, Northwest Airlines, Inc., Ozark Airlines, Pan Amer-
ican World Airways, Piedmont Airlines, Southern
Airways, Trans World Airlines and United Airlines, Inc.
(hereinafter collectively referred to as Domestic Flag-Car-
riers) are lessees or licensees of the Port of Authority at
Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark Airports. Upon infor-
mation and belief, each of the Domestic Flag Carriers
maintains executive, sales or ticket offices within the
Southern District of New York.
Ill. FACTS
EIGHTH: The Hare Krishna Society imposes on its
members the duty to perform a religious ritual known as
Sankirtan, which consists of soliciting and accepting
35
donations and contributions while disseminating reli-
gious literature and information in public places. Sankir-
tan is directed to spreading religious truth as it is known
to the Hare Krishna Society, attracting new members, and
supporting the Society’s religious activities. Donations
and book distribution are the very lifeblood and principal
means of support of this religious movement. The
devotees often wear distinctive and unconventional gar-
ments, hair styles, and spiritual body markings.
NINTH: ISKCON devotees have recently attempted
to perform Sankirtan in those portions of Kennedy,
LaGuardia and Newark International Airports open to
the general public. Plaintiffs seek only to distribute litera-
ture and solicit donations in terminals; they do not seek
to dance, chant, or to engage in any similar conduct.
TENTH: The Kennedy, LaGuardia and Newark Air-
port terminals are operated and policed by defendant Lee
and the Port Authority and are thoroughfares for millions
of people yearly including millions who are not pas-
sengers. Space is leased and licensed not only to airlines
but to other transportation facilities, food concessions,
shops, newsstands and other businesses not directly con-
nected to air transportation.
ELEVENTH: The Port Authority has promulgated
regulations, which defendant Lee is charged with enforc-
ing, respecting the distribution of literature and solicita-
tion of donations at the three airports. New York Code of
Rules and Regulations, Title 21, Chapter 24.
TWELFTH: Section 1260.13 of the Port Authority
Regulations provides that “No person shall post, distrib-
ute or display signs, advertisements, circulars, printed or
36
written matter at an air terminal without permission.”
Section 1260.14 states that “No person shall solicit funds
for any purpose at an air terminal without permission”.
Section 1260.15 provides that “No person, unless duly
authorized by the Port Authority, shall, in or upon any
area, platform, stairway, station, waiting room or any
other appurtenance of an air terminal: (a) sell, or eter for
sale any article or merchandise; (d) solicit alms.
THIRTEENTH: Section 1260.1(h) provides that
“Permission shall mean permission granted by the man-
ager, unless otherwise specifically provided.” Section
1260.1(e) states that “Manager shall mean the Port
Authority manager or other Port Authority official in
charge of an air terminal, or his duly authorized repre-
sentative.” No standards whatsoever are included to
guide the discretion of the manager or his delegate,
assuming delegation to be permissible.
FOURTEENTH: The Port Authority, through its
agents, including defendant Lee, has given to plaintiffs
permission to distribute literature and solicit contribu-
tions only within certain limited public portions of cer-
tain of the terminals at Kennedy and LaGuardia Airports.
Port Authority and defendant Lee have advised plaintiffs
that no literature distribution or fund solicitation at all
will be tolerated at Newark Airport and that permission
to perform Sankirtan at Newark Airport is subject
entirely to whatever terms and conditions may from time
to time be imposed and amended by those defendant
Domestic Flag Carriers respectively who lease or are
licensed to use space from the Port Authority at Newark
Airport.
37
FIFTEENTH: The Port Authority, through Defen-
dant Lee, has refused to grant to plaintiffs permission at
any of the three airports, to perform Sankirtan in any area
which Port Authority has leased or licensed to any of the
defendant Foreign or Domestic Flag Carriers. Plaintiffs
have been told by Port Authority and defendant Lee that
they are prohibited from doing so and will be arrested
and prosecuted if they try to do so. Defendant Lee has the
duty and authority to enforce the above regulations and
all other provisions of law in areas leased and licensed to
defendant Carriers and others.
AS AND FOR A FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST
ALL DEFENDANTS EXCEPT EASTERN AIRLINES, INC.
SIXTEENTH: At Kennedy and LaGuardia Airports,
the Port Authority has granted easements and other
rights to the defendant airlines, concessionaires and
others. The discretion vested in Port Authority officials to
license the exercise of First Amendment rights pursuant
to §§ 1260.13 - .15 has not been and cannot be lawfully
delegated or sub-delegated by Port Authority to any of
the airline defendants or others. Even if delegated, Port
Authority has promulgated no standards whatsoever to
guide the discretion of the lessees and other in exercising
their discretion respecting the grant of First Amendment
rights. If delegated, even with standards, the power to
license First Amendment rights cannot be delegated by
Port Authority to private parties, particularly such pri-
vate parties as the airline defendants who have vested
economic interest in minimizing the presence of unpopu-
lar groups, including plaintiffs, soliciting from the
licensees’ customers.
38
SEVENTEENTH: Plaintiffs have been informed by
Port Authority police under the jurisdiction of defendant
Lee that plaintiffs are subject to immediate arrest in the
terminals on criminal charges, including trespass, if they
attempt to distribute literature in any place other than as
set forth in paragraph Fourteenth above, unless plaintiffs
have permission granted by the respective airline lessees
and licensees.
EIGHTEENTH: The spaces in the various terminals
leased or licensed to the airline defendants include areas
which are appropriate locations for the exercise of First
Amendment rights. They are functionally public thor-
oughfares and any restrictions on First Amendment activ-
ities must be carefully promulgated to protect the public
order and the free flow of traffic while permitting as wide
an exercise of First Amendment rights as possible.
NINETEENTH: The regulations at issue, on their
face and as construed and applied to prohibit the distri-
bution and sale of religious literature by members of a
religious organization, without a permit for which no
narrow or definite standards are specified, substantively
and procedurally abridge the exercise of freedoms of
speech, press and religion, arbitrarily deprive persons of
their liberty and property without due process of law,
capriciously deny the equal protection of the laws, and
are vague, ambiguous and over-broad, all in violation of
the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the United
States Constitution.
TWENTIETH: There is between the parties an
actual controversy as hereinabove set forth herein. The
39
plaintiffs are suffering irreparable injury and are threat-
ened with irreparable harm in the future by reason of the
acts herein complained of and a substantial loss or
impairment of freedom of expression has occurred and
will continue to occur so long as defendants’ conduct
continues. Plaintiffs have been, are being and will con-
tinue to be harassed and intimidated by defendants and
their agents utilizing the ordinances at issue so long as
plaintiffs continue to proselytize at Kennedy and LaGuar-
dia Airports. Furthermore, there is in fact a chilling effect
upon the exercise of First Amendment rights derived
from the fact of threats of prosecution unaffected by
prospects of its success or failure.
TWENTY-FIRST: Plaintiffs have no adequate rem-
edy at law.
AS AND FOR A SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
AGAINST DEFENDANT LEE AND DEFENDANTS
ALLEGHENY AIRLINES, INC., AMERICAN AIRLINES,
INC., BRANIFF_ INTERNATIONAL AIRWAYS, DELTA
AIR LINES, INC., EASTERN AIR LINES
. - AIR L , INC., NEW
YORK AIR WAYS, INC., NORTHWEST AIRLINES, INC.,
PIEDMONT AIRLINES, TRANS WORLD AIRLINES,
AND UNITED AIRLINES, INC.
TWENTY-SECOND: Plaintiff repeats and realleges
each and every allegation of paragraphs First through
Eighteenth as if fully and completely set forth herein.
TWENTY-THIRD: The Port Authority, at Newark
Airport, has leased or licensed easements and other
rights to the Airlines named in the caption of this second
cause of action, to concessionaires, and to others. The
discretion vested in Port Authority officials to license the
40
exercise of First Amendment rights pursuant to
§§ 1260.13 - .15 has not been and cannot lawfully be
delegated or sub-delegated to the above airline defen-
dants. Even if delegated, Port Authority has promulgated
no standards whatsoever to guide the discretion of the
lessees or licensees in exercising discretion respecting the
grant of First Amendment rights. If delegated, even with
standards, the power to license First Amendment rights
cannot lawfully be delegated by Port Authority to private
parties, particularly such as the airline defendants who
have a vested economic interests in minimizing the pres-
ence of unpopular groups, including plaintiffs, soliciting
from the licensees’ customers.
TWENTY-FOURTH: Plaintiffs have been informed
by the Port Authority Police under the jurisdiction of
defendant Lee that plaintiffs will be subject to immediate
arrest on criminal charges, including trespass, if they
attempt to distribute literature or solicit contributions
anywhere in Newark Airport without the permission of
the respective airline lessees.
TWENTY-FIFTH: The spaces in the various termi-
nals leased to the airline defendants at Newark Airport
include areas which are appropriate locations for the
exercise of First Amendment rights. They are functionally
public thoroughfares and any restrictions on First
Amendment activities must be carefully promulgated to
protect the public order and the free flow of traffic while .
permitting as wide an exercise of First Amendment rights
as possible.
41
TWENTY-SIXTH: The regulations at issue, on their
face and as construed and applied to prohibit the distri-
bution and sale of religious literature by members of a
religious organization, without a permit for which no
narrow or definite standards are specified, substantively
and procedurally abridge the exercise of freedoms of
speech, press and religion, arbitrarily deprive persons of
their liberty and property without due process of law,
capriciously deny the equal protection of the laws, and
are vague, ambiguous and over-broad, all in violation of
the First and Fourteenth Amendment» to the United
States Constitution.
TWENTY-SEVENTH: There is between the parties
an actual controversy as hereinbefore set forth herein.
The plaintiffs are suffering irreparable injury and are
threatened with irreparable harm in the future by reason
of the acts herein complained of and a substantial loss or
impairment of freedom of expression has occurred and
will continue to occur so long as defendants’ conduct
continues. Plaintiffs have been and will continue to be
harassed and intimidated by defendants and their agents
utilizing the ordinances at issue so long as plaintiffs
continue to proselytize at Newark Airport. Furthermore,
there is in fact a chilling effect upon the exercise of First
Amendment rights derived from the fact of threats of
prosecution unaffected by prospects of its success or fail-
ure.
TWENTY-EIGHTH: Plaintiffs have no adequate
remedy at law.
42
AS AND FOR A THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION AGAINST
DEFENDANTS LEE AND EASTERN AIRLINES.
TWENTY-NINTH: Plaintiffs repeat and reallege
each and every allegation of paragraphs First through
Eighteenth as if fully and completely set forth herein.
THIRTIETH: Defendant Eastern Airlines has pur-
ported to promulgate certain regulations for Kennedy
and LaGuardia Airports pursuant to authority allegedly
delegated to it by the Port Authority. (A copy of said
regulations is annexed hereto as Exhibit A).
THIRTY-FIRST: Port Authority has no right, privi-
lege or power to delegate to defendant Eastern Airlines
the authority to promulgate such regulations and in fact
has not done so. If Port Authority claims to have done so,
it has failed to establish any standards to guide the
alleged discretion of defendant Eastern Airlines in exer-
cising asserted power to restrict First Amendment rights.
If delegated, even with standards, the power to license
First Amendment rights cannot lawfully be delegated to a
private party particularly one such as defendant Eastern
Airlines which has a vested economic interest in minimiz-
ing the presence of unpopular groups, including plain-
tiffs, soliciting from defendant Eastern Airline’s
customers.
THIRTY-SECOND: The regulations promulgated by
defendant Eastern for Kennedy and LaGuardia Airports
and enforced by defendant Lee violate the First and Four-
teenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United
States in that the regulations:
43
a) Restrict the free exercise of religion of the plain-
tiffs by prohibiting the solicitation of donations in con-
nection with the distribution of literature;
b) Are overly restrictive as to the locations within
space leased or licensed to Eastern where distribution of
literature is permitted;
c) Are overly restrictive as to the distances from
ticket lines and counters, security check points, outer
doors, stairwells and escalators where plaintiffs are
allowed to distribute literature;
d) Are overly restrictive as to the number of days
during which the distribution of literature is altogether
prohibited;
e) Are overly restrictive in that suspension of a
permit “in the event of emergencies” is permitted with-
out any standard to define emergencies;
f) Are overly restrictive in that they prohibit
entirely the distribution of literature at the Air-Shuttle
terminals leased by or licensed to Eastern Air Lines at the
airports;
g) Are overly restrictive in that they allow the dis-
tribution of literature pursuant to a permit for a period of
only seven days, thereby requiring plaintiffs to make
repeated applications for renewal of the permit;
h) Are overly restrictive in that they unreasonably
limit the number of devotees who may perform Sankir-
tan;
44
i) Are unrelated by reason or need to the simple
functioning of the Eastern facilities at Kennedy and
LaGuardia airports;
j) Are designed to and do have the effect of prohib-
iting the free exercise of religion and of abridging plain-
tiffs’ freedom of speech, press activities and right of
peaceable assembly.
THIRTY-THIRD: As a direct result of the regula-
tions promulgated by defendant Eastern, plaintiffs have
suffered, are suffering, and will continue to suffer irrepa-
rable injury by reason of the acts herein complained of in
that their rights to press, speech and assembly freedoms
and freely to exercise their religion have been substan-
tially impaired.
THIRTY-FOURTH: Plaintiffs have no adequate rem-
edy at law.
WHEREFORE, plaintiffs pray that this Court;
A. Declare that the New York Port Authority Regu-
lations (N.Y.C.R.R. Title 21, Chapter 24 §§ 1260.13 to
1260.15) on their face and as construed and applied to
prohibit the distribution or sale of plaintiffs’ religious
literature by members of a religious organization, abridge
the free exercise of religion, and the freedom of speech
and the press, all in contravention of the First and Four-
teenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United
States;
B. Temporarily and permanently enjoin defendants
and their respective agents, servants and employees from
(1) arresting or participating in the arrest of, or taking
any action whatsoever against plaintiffs or plaintiffs’
Suede.
Re ee et
45
members, for any alleged violation of the Port Authority
Regulations (N.Y.C.R.R., Title 21, Chapter 24 §§ 1260.13 to
1260.15) and from (2) interfering directly or indirectly
with plaintiffs’ rights to be in the public portions of the
Kennedy, LaGuardia or Newark Airports and from (3)
participating in plaintiffs’ arrest for trespass or any other
charge where plaintiffs or their members are engaged in
the peaceable dissemination or sale of literature or mate-
rials or seeking donations in any portion inside or outside
of the terminals generally open to the public;
C. Declare that the regulations promulgated by
Eastern Airlines with respect to First Amendment activ-
ities at Kennedy and LaGuardia airport facilities leased or
licensed to defendant Eastern are over-broad and unre-
lated to the functioning of Eastern’s facilities, all in viola-
tion of the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the
United States Constitution;
D. Temporarily and permanently enjoining defen-
dants and their respective agents, servants and
employees from enforcing or attempting to enforce the
Eastern Airline’s purported regulations with respect to
Eastern Airlines space at Kennedy and LaGuardia Air-
ports or either of them; and
E. Award plaintiffs their attorneys fees pursuant to
42 U.S.C. § 1988; and
F. Grant to plaintiffs such other, further and differ-
ent relief as may be just.
Dated: New York, New York
July 28, 1977.
46
/s/ Eugene N. Harley
JEREMIAH S. GUTMAN, ESQ.
EUGENE N. HARLEY, ESQ.
- LEVY, GUTMAN, GOLDBERG
AND KAPLAN
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
363 Seventh Avenue
New York, New York 10001
(212) 736 2226
BARRY FISHER, ESQ.
Attorney for Plaintiffs
433 North Camden Drive, Suite
900
Beverly Hills, California 90210
(213) 550 7460
INDIVIDUAL VERIFICATION
STATE OF NEW YORK )
> SS:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
BRIAN RUMBAUGH, being duly sworn, deposes and
Says that deponent is one of the plaintiffs in the within
action; that deponent has read the foregoing First Supple-
mental Complaint and knows the contents thereof; that
the same are true to deponent’s own knowledge, except
as to the matters therein stated to be alleged on informa-
tion and belief, and that as to those matters deponent
believes them to be true.
/s/ Brian Rumbaugh
BRIAN RUMBAUGH
47
Sworn to before me, this 28th
day of July, 1977.
/s/ Eugene N. Harley
EUGENE N. HARLEY
Notary Public, State of New York
No. 31-6772225
Qualified ir’New York County
Commission Expires March 30, 1978
Rules for Distributing of Written, Printed or Pictorial
Religious Material at Eastern Air Lines, Inc.’s Passenger
Terminals at Jchn F. Kennedy International Airport and
La Guardia Airport
No person or group may distribute any sign, adver-
tisement, circular or other written, printed, or pictorial
religious material at Eastern Air Lines, Inc.’s (Eastern)
passenger terminals at John F. Kennedy International Air-
port or La Guardia Airport except pursuant to these
passenger terminal rules and regulations.
1. Distribution shall be made only at locations spec-
ified in these rules and/or in any permit issued by East-
ern.
2. Distribution shall not be made in any air opera-
tions area, any hanger or office area, or any departure
gate area or any curbside check-in area, or any other area
designated as a Security area under Eastern’s security
plan filed with the Federal Aviation Administration pur-
suant to Section 121 of the Federal Aviation Regulations,
any baggage claim area, any area restricted to Eastern’s
48
own employees and/or Passengers ticketed on Eastern or
any other air carrier using Eastern’s facilities or any other
area not otherwise open to the general public.
3. Distribution shall not be made within approx-
imately twenty-five (25) feet of any ticket counter, check-
in counter, or information counter nor to any persons
waiting on line at or about any ticket counter, check-in
counter or information counter, except as otherwise pro-
vided herein.
4. Any person or group distributing material in a
passenger terminal may not engage in any mass demon-
Strations or similar such group activities and may not use
any loudspeakers or similar such devices at any time and
further may not play any musical instruments or other
devices in the Passenger terminal.
5. Distribution shall not be made within approx-
imately twenty-five (25) feet of any security check point
and/or security device located within a Passenger termi-
nal nor to any persons waiting on line at or about any
security check point and/or security device, except as
otherwise provided herein.
6. Distribution shall not be made within approx-
imately twenty-five (25) feet of any outer doors of general
circulation providing means of ingress or egress to a
passenger terminal, except as otherwise provided herein.
7. Distribution shall not be made within approx-
dmately twenty-five (25) feet of ‘any stairwell, escalator or
elevator in a passenger terminal, except as otherwise
provided herein.
49
8. Distribution shall not be made in any area of
Eastern’s Passenger terminals subleased or allocated toa
tenant or concessionaire without the express permission
of such tenant, concessionaire or other appropriate entity.
9. Distribution shall not be made in any way that
would interfere with the safe operation of Eastern’s pas-
senger terminals or that would unreasonably interfere
with passenger traffic or harass, block the movement of
or interfere with the rights of other persons or otherwise
unreasonably interfere with any of the operations of the
Passenger terminal.
10. Distribution shall not be made in any way so as
to disturb the peace, or to incite lawless acts by other
persons at the passenger terminal.
11. Distribution will be made in a polite and cour-
teous fashion and material will be distributed only to
those persons willing to accept it. Members of the public
will not be harassed or otherwise unreasonably interfered
with in any way.
12. No sign, advertisement, circular or other writ-
ten, printed or pictorial matter wil] be affixed to the
Passenger terminal and no such material shall be distrib-
uted by leaving it unattended throughout the Passenger
terminal. No such material will be left unattended in any
area of the passenger terminal for an unreasonable length
of time.
13. “The total number of persons distributing mate-
rial for any group or groups within a passenger terminal
Shall not exceed the total numbers set forth below for
each passenger terminal.
50
14. No more than one group will be permitted to
distribute material in any passenger terminal at any one
time. However, the Eastern Station Manager (as used
herein, “Eastern Station Manager” means the Station
Manager and/or his/her designee) may in his discretion
permit more than one group to distribute material pro-
vided however that the total number of persons for all
groups distributing material in a passenger terminal shall
not exceed the total number set forth below at each
passenger terminal.
15. Any group distributing material at a passenger
terminal shall identify by name, address and telephone
number the organization or person sponsoring the distri-
bution of the written, printed or pictorial matter and the
persons who will be distributing such material at the
passenger terminal. The group will also provide Eastern
with the name, address and telephone number of a per-
son or persons to act as a liaison between the group and
Eastern.
16. No distribution of any material will be permit-
ted during the peak traffic periods set forth below. The
eastern Station Manager may in his discretion permit
distribution during these periods if in his reasonable
opinion such distribution would not interfere with the
safe and efficient operation of the passenger terminal. If
distribution is permitted during these peak traffic
periods, the Station Manager may limit the total number
of persons distributing material and their locations in the
passenger terminal in accordance with operational needs.
17. Any group distributing material at a passenger
terminal shall take appropriate measures to ensure that
51
the distributed matter does not litter the passenger termi-
nal.
18. The Eastern Station Manager may suspend at
any time a permit issued pursuant to these rules in the
event of emergencies such as but not limited to extended
passenger delays caused by adverse weather or operating
conditions.
19. No person or group may distribute any sign,
advertisement, circular or other written, printed or picto-
rial religious matter at Eastern’s Passenger terminals at
John F. Kennedy International Airport or the passenger
terminal known as the Air-Shuttle terminal at La Guardia
Airport except pursuant to a permit from the Eastern
Station Manager at each such Passenger terminal.
(a) An application for a permit on a form pro-
vided by Eastern (a sample of which is attached
hereto) must be submitted during normal busi-
ness hours (9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.) to the Eastern
Station Manager at the respective airport at least
24 hours but not more than one calendar week
before the date Proposed for the distribution of
the materials.
(b) The permit shall be effective for up to
seven (7) calendar days. However, the Eastern
Station Manager may in his discretion limit the
effective period of the permit to no more than
one calendar day or extend the effective period
of the permit to up to two calendar weeks. The
permit will be effective only for the dates and at
the times specified on it and at any one time no
more than one permit will be issued to any
group or person. No permits will be issued for
the peak traffic periods referenced in paragraph
52
16 and set forth below except in accordance with
the provisions of paragraph 16.
(c) A copy of this permit will be in the posses-
sion of at least one person in the group distrib-
uting material at all times that the group is
present in the passenger terminal.
(d) The permittee will report to the Eastern
Station Manager each day prior to the commen-
cement of the distribution of the material.
(e) Permits will be issued on the basis of the
chronological dates on which the application for
the permit is received by Eastern.
(f) The permit may be revoked at any time if
the person or group violates the rules set forth
herein.
20. John F. Kennedy International Airport
Distribution shall be permitted at the following loca-
tions in the passenger terminal;
(1) Upper Level -
(a) Three (3) persons shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the “waiting room”
area of the concourse - generally the area
that is carpeted and contains chairs avail-
able for passengers and other persons hav-
ing business in the terminal. Distribution is
also permitted in the area immediately
adjacent to this “waiting room” area and in
such other areas not otherwise limited in
the general rules set forth above. (Area A)
(b) One (1) person shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the walkway at the
rear of the terminal between the shops.
(Area B)
53
(2) Lower Level —
(a) One (1) person shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the walkway outside
the baggage claim area. (Area C)
(3) No distribution will be permitted during
the following peak traffic periods of each year
except as provided in paragraph 16:
(a) December 20 - December 25
(b) January 1 - January 7
(c) Weekend before Easter Weekend - Friday
through Sunday
(d) Thursday before Easter through the Week-
end after Easter Weekend
(e) Thursday before Labor Day through the
Tuesday after Labor Day
(f) Tuesday before Thanksgiving through the
Monday after Thanksgiving
(g) Any other period when traffic forecasts
indicate that passenger traffic in the terminal
shall substantially exceed that which occurs ona
normal day.
(4) No more than a total number of five (5)
persons from one or more groups will be per-
mitted to distribute literature throughout the
terminal.
21. LaGuardia Airport
(1) Distribution shall be permitted at the fol-
lowing location in the main Passenger terminal.
(a) One (1) person shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the rear portion of
54
the terminal immediately adjacent to the
public walkway at the back of the terminal
(Area A).
(2) Distribution shall be permitted at the fol-
lowing location in the Air-Shuttle terminal.
(a) One (1) person shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the open areas of the
main terminal not otherwise limited in the
general rules set forth above. (Area A) Dis-
tribution shall be permitted in the area of
the writing counters in the terminal but
persons standing at these counters shall not
be approached.
(b) One (1) person shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the “waiting room”
area of the terminal - generally the area
that is carpeted and contains chairs avail-
able for passengers and other persons hav-
ing business in the terminal. (Area B)
(3) No distribution will be permitted during
the following periods of each year except as
provided in paragraph 16.
(a) December 21 - December 25
(b) January 1 - January 4
(c) Weekend before Easter Weekend - Friday
through Sunday
(d) Thursday before Easter through the Week-
end after Easter Weekend
(e) Thursday before Labor Day through the
Tuesday after Labor Day:
(f) Tuesday before Thanksgiving through the
Monday after Thanksgiving
55
(g) Any other period when traffic forecasts
indicate that passenger traffic in the terminal
shall substantially exceed that which occurs on a
normal day.
(4) (a) No more than a total number of one (1)
person from a group will be permitted to
distribute literature throughout the main
terminal.
(b) No more than a total number of two
(2) persons from one or more groups will
be permitted to distribute literature
throughout the Air-Shuttle terminal.
(22) As used herein, the term “passenger terminal”
shall mean the areas leased to Eastern for its exclusive
use from the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.
Newark International Airport
Eastern is one of four (4) airline tenants in Terminal
B, the passenger terminal at Newark International Air-
port. Eastern does not have exclusive control in Terminal
B of any of the common areas open to passengers and
other persons having business in the terminal. Under
their individual leases, control of those areas rests jointly
in the four airline tenants.
The attached rules for the distribution of religious
material in the areas set forth below at Terminal B are
acceptable to Eastern. These rules and the procedures
contained therein have not been approved by any other
air carrier tenants at Terminal B. However, Eastern will
take no unilateral action nor be a party to any action to
interfere with the distribution of religious material in
Terminal B provided that such distribution is made in
56
accordance with these rules and in the areas set forth
below. Distribution shall be permitted at the following
locations in Terminal B:
(1)
(2)
(3)
Upper level -
(a) Two (2) persons shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the “waiting room”
area of the concourse - generally the area
that is carpeted and contains chairs avail-
able for passengers and other persons hav-
ing business in the terminal. Distribution is
also permitted in the area immediately
adjacent to this “waiting room” area and in
such other areas not otherwise limited in
the general rules. (Area A)
Concourse Level -
(a) Two (2) persons shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the “waiting room”
area of the concourse - generally the area
that is carpeted and contains chairs avail-
able for passengers and other persons hav-
ing business in the terminal. Distribution is
also permitted in the walkways and other
areas on the concourse level and in such
other areas on the concourse level not oth-
erwise limited in the general rules. (Area B)
(b) No distribution whatsoever shall be
permitted in the walkways leading out
from the concourse and to the gate areas.
Lower Level -
(a) Two (2) persons shall be permitted to
distribute literature in the walkway outside
the baggage claim area. (Area C)
— i Ml, oe ite ho
57
(4) No more than a total number of six (6)
persons from one or more groups will be per-
mitted to distribute literature throughout Termi-
nal B. However, Eastern’s Station Manager may
in his discretion permit a distribution of persons
different from that set forth above; e.g., 0 per-
sons — lower level, 4 persons - concourse level, 2
persons — upper level.
(5) No distribution will be permitted during
the following peak traffic Periods of each year
except as provided in paragraph 16.
(a) December 20 - December 25
(b) January 1 - January 7
(c) Weekend before Easter Weekend - Friday
through Sunday
(d) Thursday before Easter through the Week-
end after Easter Weekend
(e) Thursday before Labor Day through the
Tuesday after Labor Day
(f) Tuesday before Thanksgiving through the
Monday after Thanksgiving
(g) Any other period when trafile forecasts
indicate that Passenger traffic in the terminal
shall substantially exceed that which occurs ona
normal day.
PERMIT APPLICATION
This application is submitted for permission to distribute
religious material at the Eastern Air Lines, Inc. (Eastern)
58
passenger terminal checked below in accordance with
Eastern’s rules for the distribution of written, printed or
pictorial religious material.
This application must be submitted during normal busi-
ness hours (9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.) te Eastern’s Station
Manager at least thirty-six (36) hours but not more than
one calendar week before the date proposed for the dis-
tribution of the materials.
Name of
Sponsoring
Organization/ Organization/ Telephone
Group Group Address Number
Name of Address of
Organization/ Organization
Group Group Telephone
Representative Representative Number
Check One:
John F. Kennedy International Airport
La Guardia Airport - Air-Shuttle Terminal
Newark International Airport
Date of Proposed Distribution
Time of Proposed Distribution ___
Date Application Submitted __
Time Application Submitted ______
59
I have read Eastern’s rules for the
distribution of written, printed or
pictorial religious material.
Date of Issuance Expiration Date
A copy of this permit will be in the Possession of at least
one person in the sponsoring group/organization distrib-
uting material at all times that the group is present in the
Passenger terminal.
The permittee will report to the Eastern Station Manager
or his/her designee each day prior to the commencemert
of the distribution of the material.
This permit is subject to the Eastern rules referred to
above.
By
Station Manager
60
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR
KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS, INC., et al.,
Plaintiffs, Index No.
, 75 Civ 5388
-against- (RLC)
WALTER LEE, Superintendent of the Port Answer
Authority Police, individually and in his
official capacity, et al.,
Defendants.
To: Jeremiah S. Gutman, Esq.
Eugene N. Harley, Esq.
Levy, Gutman, Goldberg & Kaplan
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
363 Seventh Avenue
New York, New York 10001
Defendant, WALTER LEE, named individually and in
his official capacity as Superintendent of Police for the
Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (Port
Authority), by ‘his attorney, Patrick J. Falvey, answering
the complaint of plaintiffs, respectfully alleges and shows
as follows:
AS AND FOR AN ANSWER TO THE FIRST CAUSE OF
ACTION:
1. Denies each and every allegation in the para-
graphs designated “FIRST”, and “ELEVENTH” of the
complaint.
at Af Geel
61
2. Denies knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to
the truth of each and every allegation of paragraphs
designated “SECOND”, “THIRD”, “FOURTH”, “SIXTH”,
“SEVENTH”, “EIGHT” and “NINTH” of the complaint.
3. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “FIFTH”, except admits that defendant WAL-
TER LEE is employed by the Port Authority and, at all
times mentioned herein, has acted in his official capacity
as the Superintendent of Police of the the Port Authority,
a government agency oi the States of New York and New
Jersey created in 1921 by compact between them, which
was consenied-to by Congress; that the Port Authority
operates under leases with the cities of New York and
Newark, John F. Kennedy International Airport and
LaGuardia Airport in the State of New York and Newark
International Airport in the State of New Jersey, respec-
tively; and that defendant WALTER LEE, as the Superin-
tendent of Police, is chiefly responsible for the
enforcement of applicable New York and New Jersey
criminal laws.
4. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “TENTH” of the complaint except admits that
John F. Kennedy International, LaGuardia and Newark
International Airports are operated and policed by the
Port Authority; and that, in his capacity as Superinten-
dent of Police, defendant LEE is responsible for the secu-
rity and the enforcement of the criminal laws in areas of
said airports which are under the control of the Port
Authority and, upon the request or complaint of a tenant,
in areas wholly leased to such tenant or tenants which are
under the dominion and control of said tenants; and that
space in air terminals, located at the said airports, is
62
leased or under license to tenants which include airlines,
food concessions, shops, news-stands and other busi-
nesses. Defendant requests the Court’s permission to
refer the terms of lease and/or license agreements at the
time of trial with respect to obligations as to police and
security within areas covered by those agreements, and
respectfully refers all questions of law to the court.
5. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “TWELTH” of the complaint except admiits
that Section 1260.13 of the Port Authority Regulations
provides that “No person shall post, distribute or display
signs, advertisements, circulars, printed or written matter
at an air terminal without permission”. Section 1260.14
states that “No person shall solicit funds for any purpose
at an air terminal without permission”. Section 1260.15 in
its entirety provides that “No person, unless duly autho-
rized by the Port Authority, shall, in or upon any area,
platform, stairway, station, waiting room or any other
appurtenance of an air terminal: (a) sell, or offer for sale
any article of merchandise; or (b) solicit any business or
trade, including the carrying of baggage for hire; the
shining of shoes or bootblacking; or (c) entertain any
persons by singing, dancing or playing any musical
instrument; or (d) solicit alms.
6. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “THIRTEENTH” of the complaint except
admits that Section 1260.1 (h) provides that “permission
shall mean permission granted by the manager, unless
otherwise specifically provided.” Section 1260.1 (e) pro-
vides that “manager shall mean the Port Authority man-
ager or other Port Authority official in charge of an air
terminal, or his duly authorized representative.”
63
7. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “FOURTEENTH” of the complaint except
admits that the Port Authority, through its agents, has
granted permission to plaintiffs to distribute literature
and solicit contributions within appropriate public areas
of air terminals located at John F. Kennedy International
and LaGuardia Airports; and that plaintiffs have been
advised that they should seek permission for the distribu-
tion of literature and the solicitation of funds from the
airlines who have lcased or subleased, and who do exer-
cise dominion and control over, the premises of air termi-
nals located at Newark International Airport.
8. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “FIFTEENTH” of the complaint except admits
that the Port Authority, through its agents, has not the
right to grant and has not granted to plaintiffs permission
to distribute literature and solicit funds in areas leased to
an airline or airlines and over which areas these airlines
exercise dominion and control; and that defendant LEE,
as the Port Authority’s Superintendent of Police, is
responsible for the enforcement of the criminal law at the
Port Authority’s airports. Defendant respectfully refers
all questions of law to the court.
9. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “SIXTEENTH” of the complaint except denies
information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to
the truth of plaintiffs’ allegation that the airline defen-
dants “have vested economic interest in minimizing the
presence of unpopular groups, including plaintiffs, solic-
iting from the licensees’ customers” and admits that Port
Authority officials have not delegated or sub-delegated
any discretion vested in them to grant permission for the
64
distribution of literature and the solicitation of funds to
any person or entity and that the Port Authority, at its
airports, has leased space and granted rights to airlines,
and others. Defendant respectfully refers all questions of
law to the court.
10. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “SEVENTEENTH”, “EIGHTEENTH”, “NINE-
TEENTH”, “TWENTIETH” and “TWENTY-FIRST” of the
complaint, and respectfully refers all questions of law to
the court.
AS AND FOR AN ANSWER TO THE SECOND CAUSE
OF ACTION
11. With respect to paragraph designated
“TWENTY-SECOND” of the complaint, defendant
repeats, reiterates and realleges each of his admissions
and denials answering paragraphs designated “FIRST”
through “EIGHTEENTH” of the complaint with the same
force and effect as if fully set forth at length herein.
12. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “TWENTY-THIRD” of the complaint except
denies information or knowledge sufficient to form a
belief as to the truth of plaintiffs’ allegation that the
airline defendants “have vested economic interests in
minimizing the presence of unpopular groups, including
plaintiffs, soliciting from the licensees’ customers” and
admits that under agreements between the Port Authority
and some of the airlines named in the caption of plain-
tiffs’ second cause of action and under agreements
between some of the airlines themselves, said airlines are
tenants and sub-tenants at the air terminals located at
65
Newark International Airport; and that there are conces-
sionaires who also tenant some areas in the air terminals.
Defendant respectfully refers all questions of law to the
court.
13. Denies each and every allegation of paragraphs
designated “TWENTY-FOURTH”, “TWENTY-FIFTH,”
“TWENTY-SIXTH”, “TWENTY-SEVENTH” and
“TWENTY-EIGHT” of the complaint, and defendant
respectfully refers all questions of law to the court.
AS AND FOR THE ANSWER TO THE THIRD CAUSE OF
ACTION
14. With respect to paragraph designated
“TWENTY-NINTH” of the complaint, defendant repeats,
reiterates and realleges each of his admissions and
denials in answering paragraphs designated “FIRST”
through “EIGHTEENTH” of the complaint with the same
force and effect as if fully set forth at length herein.
15. Denies each and every allegation of paragraphs
designated “THIRTIETH” and THIRTY-SECOND” of the
complaint.
16. Denies each and every allegation of paragraph
designated “THIRTY-FIRST” of the complaint except
denies information or knowledge sufficient to form a
belief as to the truth of plaintiffs’ allegation that the
defendant Eastern Airline has “vested economic interest
in minimizing the presence of unpopular groups, includ-
ing plaintiffs, soliciting from the licensees’ customers”
and admits that the Port Authority has not delegated its
66
power, if any, to defendant Eastern Airlines to promul-
gate regulations (a copy of which is annexed to the com-
plaint as Exhibit A); and that Eastern Airlines, pursuant
to lease agreements with the Port Authority, has rights
with respect to areas leased to it at Port Authority air-
ports, and defendant requests the Court’s permission to
refer to said lease agreements at the time of trial and,
further, respectfully refers all questions of law with
respect thereto to the Court.
17. Denies knowledge sufficient to form a belief as
to the truth of each and every allegation of paragraphs
designated “THIRTY-THIRD” and denies each and every
allegation of paragraph designated “THIRTY-FOURTH”
of the complaint.
WHEREFORE, defendant respectfully prays for a
judgment dismissing plaintiffs’ complaint, plus attorney’s
fees, costs and disbursements, and such other and further
relief as may seem to this court just and proper.
Dated: New York, New York
December 29, 1977
/s/ (P.J.F.)
Patrick J. Falvey
Attorney for Port Authority
Defendant Walter Lee
One World Trade Center
New York, New York 10048
Telephone (212) 466-8794
ee
67
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR ~
KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS,
INC., et al., AFFIDAVIT
Plaintiffs, 75 Civ. 5388 (MJL)
—- against -
WALTER LEE, et al.,
Defendants.
STATE OF NEW YORK )
s Oi
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
PHILIP Le B. DOUGLAS, being duly sworn, deposes
and says:
1. lama member of the Bar of this Court and of the
firm of Hale Russell & Gray, attorneys for the Air India
group of defendants in this action. I make this affidavit in
opposition to plaintiffs’ motion for a protective order
concerning interrogatories and document demands
served by the Air India defendants on July 16, 1984
(collectively “Second Air India Interrogatories”). In this
case, plaintiffs - the international “Krishna Conscious-
ness Movement” and Brian Rumbaugh - seek to perform
“sankirtan”, i.e. solicit funds, in privately-leased areas of
the International Arrivals Building at John Fitzgerald
Kennedy International Airport. To rebut plaintiffs’ con-
tention that sankirtan is a religious activity protected by
68
the First Amendment, the Second Air India Interrogato-
ries seek information concerning plaintiff’s solicitation
practices, the involvement of high Krishna officials in
those practices, and the manner in which sankirtan-
derived funds are used.
2. Plaintiffs’ motion seeks to preclude any inquiry
whatsoever into Hare Krishna governance, solicitation
methods or financial affairs. According to plaintiffs, any
such inquiry would be (1) irrelevant and not likely to lead
to the discovery of relevant evidence; (2) violative of
plaintiffs’ rights of privacy and religious freedom; and (3)
unduly burdensome and oppressive. Plaintiffs character-
ize the Air India interrogatories as “wildly” irrelevant,
“not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of
admissable evidence” and ludicrously off-beam.” (Mem-
orandum of Law in Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Protective Order with Respect to Air India Interrogatories
at 2-3). Strongly implying that defendants’ recent inter-
rogatories were propounded in bad faith to “coerce” a
settlement, plaintiffs contend that “[gliven the substantial
religious liberty and privacy interests, which are threat-
ened by the discovery, defendants have failed to demon-
strate that the information sought is sufficiently relevant
to this lawsuit to justify disclosure.” (Reply Memorandum
in Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Protective Order Con-
cerning Air Canada Interrogatories at 3) (emphasis in
original).
a’
69
Plaintiffs’ Claims Should Be Dismissed Out Of Hand For
Failure to Comply With Local Rule 3(f)
3. Before turning to plaintiffs’ claims that defen-
dants discovery requests are irrelevant and in bad faith, I
wish to briefly address their contention that the inter-
rogatories are ambiguous, overbroad and unduly burden-
some. The Air India defendants respectfully submit that
these claims should be summarily dismissed for failure to
comply with Local Rule 3(f) of this Court. As is evident
from the fact that their motion papers are not accom-
panied by the affidavit required by Local Rule 3(f), plain-
tiffs have never sought to confer with defendants in an
effort to clarify allegedly unclear interrogatories and to
lessen the burden of any discovery requests. Indeed,
plaintiffs have declined my request for such a conference.
Immediately following a status conference before Magis-
trate Dolinger on August 6, 1984, I asked David M. Liber-
man, Esq. and Eugene N. Harley, Esq. to meet with me in
an effort to resolve their objections to the interrogatories.
Messrs. Liberman and Harley’s only response, however,
was that the interrogatories were objectionable in toto.
4. I have reviewed the August 17, 1984, affidavit of
plaintiff Brian Rumbaugh claiming, among other things,
that the document production requested by defendants
“would be extremely burdensome and damaging”
because “[mJembership in the [New York] temple is cur-
rently less than half of what it was when this lawsuit
began.” (8/17/84 Rumbaugh Aff. 411). This “critical
shortage of personnel” is asserted as a ground for deny-
ing defendants’ any discovery whatsoever. (/d.) This con-
tention is spurious. As the complaint in this case asserts,
plaintiffs are not merely a “New York temple,” they are in
70
fact “all members of the International Society for Krishna
Consciousness, Inc.” which is defined in the complaint as
“an international religious society . . . [that] maintains
temples and schools in cities throughout the United
States.” (First Amended Complaint 43). As will be set
forth in great detail below, this worldwide movement has
thousands of followers who devote their services free of
charge and who are capable of raising, through sankirtan,
hundreds of thousands of dollars in a matter of days. This
powerful organization has financed dozens of expensive
lawsuits around the nation. Indeed, plaintiffs have pros-
ecuted this particular case for almost ten years repre-
sented by a stable of three law firms, at least some of
which are being paid on a hourly basis. In any event, as
noted above, the Air India defendants stand ready to
discuss reasonable ways of relieving any unnecessary
burden.
The Air India Group’s Review of the Public Record Con-
cerning Plaintiffs’ Solicitation Methods .
5. Prior to propounding its interrogatories, the Air
India defendants undertook a preliminary inquiry into
the public record concerning plaintiffs’ activities over the
past decade. What has emerged from this necessarily
brief and limited investigation are shocking allegations
indicating that the International Society for Krishna Con-
sciousness, Inc. (“ISKCON”) has been operating in a man-
ner more akin to a racketeering enterprise than a religion.
As will be set forth in detail below, the public record
reveals allegations of widespread and massive fraud,
extortion, murder, assault, large-scale weapons dealing,
heroin trafficking and investments in profit-making
Aine
71
enterprises. As a consequence, defendants seek discovery
which they believe will demonstrate that, in the words of
the United States District Court for the District of New
Jersey in the Meadowlands case, that sankirtan “is no
more than a ‘confidence’ operation designed to obtain all
the money possible,” International Society for Krishna Con-
sciousness, Inc. v. New Jersey Sports and Exposition Author-
ity, 552 F. Supp. 1088, 1110 (D.N.J. 1981), aff'd, 691 F.2d
155 (3d Cir. 1982), and that the funds obtained by this
“confidence operation” are diverted to secular and even
criminal purposes. Thus, rather than being irrelevant, in
bad faith or “ludicrous”, the discovery sought by defen-
dants is amply warranted and vital to their defense of
this case. Indeed, without this information, defendants
will not be able to respond to the Second Court's request
in its remand opinion for evidence of the true “nature” of
sankirtan and defendants’ “justification” for precluding
this practice in their leaseholds. See International Society
fer Krishna Consciousness, Inc. v. Air Canada; 727 F.2d 233,
256 (2d Cir. 1984) (per curiam).
6. Outlined below is evidence gleaned from the
public record by the Air India defendants relating to
plaintiffs’ governance, sankirtan practices and use of san-
kirtan-derived funds. While some of this evidence is
derived from unverified sources, strong corroboration is
provided by the consistency of these allegations over the
years.
A. Plaintiff’s Control Over World-Wide Solicitation
Practices and the Use of Sankirtan Funds
7. Plaintiffs object to the Second Air India Inter-
rogatories, in part, because they seek information about
72
activities outside of the New York area. Thus, it is
asserted that any inquiry should be limited to “the single
corporation” and “single individual” who are allegedly
plaintiffs in this case. (Plaintiffs’ Motion for Protective
Order at 2). This assertion is typically disingenuous. As
noted above, the pending complaint is brought “on behalf
of all members of the International Society for Krishna
Consciousness, Inc.” which is defined as “an interna-
tional religious society . . . [that] maintains temples and
schools in cities throughout the United States.” (First
Amended Complaint { 3). In an obvious attempt to nar-
row defendants range of discovery, plaintiffs are now
seeking to amend their complaint to exclude from the
plaintiffs’ group, Hare Krishna organizations and
devotees located outside of the New York region. The Air
India defendants, of course, oppose this eleventh hour
maneuver.
8. However, even if plaintiffs’ motion is granted,
discovery concerning Krishna activities across the coun-
try would be proper. As will be demonstrated below,
defendants have reason to believe, and seek discovery in
order to prove, that: (1) plaintiff ISKCON as an institution
directs the fraudulent solicitation of funds on a massive
scale; and (2) at least some of these funds are not used for
religious purposes but instead are spent on real estate,
personal luxuries, weapons and narcotics. The discovery
sought is necessary to prove that, rather than being the
unauthorized actions of renegade members, solicitation
fraud is a secret policy of thé plaintiff, one which has
been approved at the highest international levels of the
organization.
73
9. At his April 14, 1979 deposition in this case,
named plaintiff, Brian Rumbaugh, a/k/a “Romapada
Das,” a/k/a “Romapada Swami”, testified that all local
groups around the globe associated with the Hare
Krishna movement are centrally controlled by an interna-
tional entity known as the Governing Body Commission
(“GBC”). (4/24/79 Rumbaugh Deposition at 30). Thus,
Rumbaugh testified, the same GBC member who controls
the United States is also responsible for Western Europe
(Id. at 36). According to Rumbaugh, one of the GBC’s
“primary responsibilities” is to ensure that the local prac-
tices are uniform. (Id. at 33). The GBC’s standards in this
regard are “explicit” and vigorously enforced: “They are
strict, very clear and they are strictly upheld.” (/d.).
Devotees from other parts of the country came to the
New York region to conduct sankirtan here and New
York Krishna members travel to other regions. (Id. at 111,
113). Although Mr. Rumbaugh was aware of a large
number of frauds and violence involving devotees, (id. at
94, 101-104, 178, 185-87, 192, 197, 200, 213-15 220), no
member has ever been expelled from the organization
because of sankirtan activities. (Id. at 122-123).
10. Newspaper articles indicate that, in connection
with a $9.7 million awarded to a woman who proved that
she had been kidnapped and brainwashed by plaintiff
ISKCON, a California cowrt held that a purported “decen-
tralization” of the organization into separate regional
units and various not-for-profit corporations was in fact
nothing more than an effort to evade the judgment. Find-
ing that the New York, California, Louisiana and Cana-
dian branches of the Hare Krishna movement conspired
to siphon assets to shell corporations, the Court held: “It
74
is clear that the Governing Body Commission controls, to
whatever extent it wishes, actions of the various corpo-
rate defendants.” (The Associated Press story reporting
this decision is annexed hereto as Exhibit A).
11. Our investigation reveals that fraud appears to
be an approved aspect of sankirtan known as “transcen-
dental trickery.” As will be described below, many former
devotees have related how they were taught to lie and
steal. According to one account by a former Krishna
member who spent five years in nearly a dozen Canadian
and eastern United States Krishna “temples,” devotees
are “told to beg for donations and make up the names of
needy causes,” and he actually solicited donations for a
fictitious “Fund for Homeless Children.” (This article is
annexed hereto as Exhibit B).
12. In an in-depth interview Ed Senesi, who at one
time had been editor-in-chief of the official Krishna mag-
azine Back to Godhead and had also served as general
manager of the entire editorial and graphic arts division
of the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, ISKCON’s publishing
arm, explained how fraud was an inherent part of sankir-
tan. (A copy of this interview is annexed hereto as Exhibit
C). Among other things, he related how the movement's
sankirtan efforts were centered around “transcendental
trickery” or “heavenly deception.” According to Senesi,
plaintiff ISKCON’s leaders have instructed their fol-
lowers that any means advancing the cause of Krishna is
justified by the ends. Because the money in a potential
donor’s wallet was believed to be stolen from Krishna,
Senesi said the Krishnas believe they have “the right -
not only the right, but the duty - to take that money from
you, even if [they] have to trick you, because by getting
75
that money from you [they] are getting Krishna’s stolen
money back.” (Ex. C at 10). Senesi continued:
“So they had to use these shuck-and jive, con-
man techniques to get the books to people, and
to get the money out of their wallets. They’d lie,
cheat, and do things like tell them, ‘We are with
muscular dystrophy,’ ‘We are with the Salvation
Army; won't you give us money” ‘We are feed-
ing children all over the world.’ And the Ameri-
cans, being big hearted, would go for it and give
them money. This is going on even to this day.
That’s how the movement changed. It got so
deceptive that anything went, because the mis-
$10N was so important.” Id.
According to Senesi, when he reported the deceptive
solicitation techniques to A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Prabhupada, the founder of ISKCON, the Swami
responded that books must be distributed, “by hook or
by crook,” and that the deceptive techniques were not
matters of concern, because the end justified the means
(Id.) |
B. Fraudulent Practices
7 13. The public record is replete with reports of
widespread fraud apparently committed at plaintiffs’
direction over the course of more than a decade. For
example, in the June 24, 1980 edition of the Sacramento
Bee, it is reported that one Hans Kary, a/k/a “Jack Lon-
don,” a/k/a “Srila Hansadutta Swami Maharaja”, was
one of the sect’s earliest adherents and, in 1974, headed
ISKCON operations in Germany. It is reported that in
1974, German authorities arrested Kary and other
76
Krishnas on charges of “begging under false pretenses.”
The German prosecuter is reported as having established
that Kary and his accomplices collected $1.1 million in
only seven months, primarily by telling donors that the
money would be sent to an ISKCON temple in India to
feed starving children. The article indicates that, in fact,
only $6,900 was ever sent to India and that even this sum
was not used to benefit children. In 1978, Kary and eight
other devotees were reportedly convicted of the false
pretense charge and ordered to pay substantial fines.
(Sacramento Bee, June 22, 1980). (Copies of these articles
are annexed hereto as Exhibit D). Despite his criminal
record, Kary was subsequently appointed cone of the rul-
ing gurus of the worldwide Hare Krishna movement,
with unquestioned power and authority. (/d.). Some evi-
dence of what Kary did with funds collected for “starving
children” is found in a May 13, 1980, article in the Sacra-
mento Bee. In May 1980, Kary was reportedly in control of
California operations for plaintiff ISKCON. At that time,
Kary was apparently again arrested for possession of an
Ingram Mac 10 9mm. machine gun, a loaded clip for that
weapon, two assault rifles, two hunting rifles and three
loaded handguns. These weapons were found in an ille-
gally-imported Mercedes Benz belonging to Kary. (Ex. E).
These charges were dropped when a Krishna aide to Kary
claimed ownership of the weapons.
14. Further evidence of fraudulent Krishna solicita-
tion comes from the November 22, 1975 edition of the Los
Angeles Times. (This article is annexed hereto as Exhibit
F). The article reports that in 1975 complaints to the
police about solicitation techniques used by members of
77
the San Diego Hare Krishna temple prompted an investi-
gation by the City Auditor’s Office of the temple’s finan-
cial records. Although the Krishnas reportedly collected
more than $250,000 in the period February 1974 to June
1975 on behalf of “starving children and suffering people
of the world,” even by the Krishnas’ own admission a
3% of those funds were used for that purpose. —
| 15. In 1976, the San Diego Union reported that Hare
Krishna solicitors were alleged to have intimidated and
used physical force against children 6 to 12 years old who
were soliciting contributions for the Muscular Dystroph
Association at the San Diego Zoo and Sea World. pt
ently the Krishnas, who were dressed up in Revolution-
ony War-period costumes to exploit the Bicentennial
spirit, resented the competition from a legitimate charity
for prospective donors’ contributions. (The San Diego
Union article is annexed hereto as Exhibit G).
~ 16. Plaintiff Brian Rumbaugh has admitted to par-
ticipating in similarly deceptive practices. At his deposi-
tion in this case, Rumbaugh conceded that, in the
approximate period 1974-1979, the New York Temple
which he headed, solicited funds during the Christmas
season by dressing devotees in Santa Claus costumes and
maving them hand out candy canes. (4/24/79 Rumbaugh
Deposition at 101-103). Rumbaugh also acknowledged
that in Grand Central Station, one devotee performed
sankirtan by pretending to be from a radio station (/d. at
212) and, in the International Arrivals Building, a cop
pied girl in a wheelchair and other women were used to
solicit donations. (Id. at 220).
78
17. Substantial evidence of deceptive Krishna prac-
tices in 1978-1979 were adduced at a trial in the Northern
District of New York of plaintiff ISKCON’s suit seeking
not to have their solicitation efforts at the New York State
Fair restricted to booths:
79
change. Devotees also on occasion “targeted”
their contributors, approaching those most
likely to succumb to pressure to contribute -
young couples with small children, teenagers
handicapped individuals, and groups of
“Several fairgoers testified that ISKCON mem-
bers approached them and initiated discussion
by either pinning a flower or button on their
lapel without permission or by placing a record
in their hand. Identification badges [required by
court order] frequently were not worn, or were
hidden beneath sweaters or the straps of shoul-
der bags that ISKCON devotees typically carry.
Discussions of a religious nature rarely fol-
lowed; instead devotees would vaguely ask for
a contribution to help “starving children” or
“drug addicts.” Witnesses testified that devotees
portrayed themselves as representatives of con-
tests giving away records to the 50 best looking
couples or as radio station employees offering a
record if the fairgoer named the correct radio
station. Several fairgoers stated that when the
Krishnas handed them record albums, they were
led to believe that performances by several nota-
ble “stars” - including George Harrison, Stevie
Wonder and Bob Marley appeared on the
albums. In fact, small print on the record jackets
indicated that these performers only “contrib-
uted to” or “supported” the ISKCON move-
ment.
Evidence was also presented that many
devotees cajoled fairgoers into giving larger
contributions and attempted to shortchange
donors by folding over bills and by distracting
the fairgoers with conversation while providing
retarded persons... .
*** © ©
The state also presented testimony of a for-
mer Krishna member, who stated that she was
explicitly taught to lie and deceive members of
the public when engaging in sankirtan.
International Society for Krishna Consciousness, Inc. v. Bar-
ber, 650 F.2d 430, 436-37 (2d Cir. 1981).
ike eee 1979, the Raleigh, North Carolina
erver reported that Raymond Kissane, a
member of the New York City Krishna community mas
arrested and charged with three felony counts of obtain-
ing money under false pretenses. (A copy of this article is
annexed hereto as Exhibit H). Kissane reportedly took
large bills from patrons at the North Carolina State Fair
saying he would make change, but refused to return the
correct amount of change. Among the other complaints
registered by fairgoers were allegations that the Krishnas:
(1) had taken money from a blind adult and a retarded
blind child; (2) had refused to give people change back
for large bills; (3) had asked for large bills in exchange for
smaller bills and then failed to provide the te (4)
had handed record albums to fairgoers and then onstched
the records back if they were not given money; and (5)
had tricked children into giving them donations. Kissane
subsequently pleaded no contest to the North Carolina
charges. Thereafter, he was given a six-month suspended
80
jail sentence, fined, and ordered to make restitution to his
victims. Kissane was no stranger to court proceedings,
having previously been convicted in other jurisdictions of
soliciting without a permit on private property, obstruct-
ing an officer by providing false information, soliciting
without a license, and disorderly conduct. (See Defen-
dant’s Exhibit BU, ISKCON v. Barber, 506 F. Supp. 147
(N.D.N.Y. 1980), rev’d, 650 F.2d 430 (2d Cir. 1981)).
19. In November 1981, the Boston Sunday Globe
reported that Kissane and two other Krishnas were
arrested in the Bangor, Maine area and charged with
felony theft by deception in connection with an “art
scam” whereby cheap, mass-produced paintings were
sold to unsuspecting customers for exorbitant prices
through misrepresentation. (A copy of this article is
annexed hereto as Exhibit I). Kissane and the others, who
claimed to represent Fine Arts Studio in New York, were
reportedly arrested meeting “with a regional Hare
Krishna representative to whom the three allegedly gave
the money they obtained in sales.” Id.
20. In September 1981, Beloit, Wisconsin police
arrested Mark J. Bass and Jonathan Rhodes for felony
theft through misrepresentation. The two, who were asso-
ciated with plaintiffs’ Moundsville, West Virginia temple,
had allegedly masqueraded as Vietnam veterans, telling
people at a shopping center they were collecting funds to
help other Vietnam veterans hospitalized because of con-
tact with Agent Orange. Rhodes subsequently pleaded
guilty to this charge and was fined $1,000. Bass jumped
bail. (Copies of articles concerning the arrests and guilty
plea are annexed hereto as Exhibit J).
81
21. B
Albany, ioe — Teoy eal atrested again in
5 In May 1982 wij
member and charged with con ee ne Ketone
| istration hospitals in many
which they apparently used as
Oliciting. The letters were al]
m Boys School. (See Interrogatory
Parts of the country,
“authorization” for s
82
mentioned in any solicitation she observed. This declar-
ant also witnessed Krishnas shortchanging foreign trav-
elers unfamiliar with American currency or exchange
rates, as well as instances where Krishnas had failed to
provide correct change to donors. The declarant stated
that she received approximately 20 complaints per day
about Krishna solicitation techniques. As a result of voic-
ing objections to the Krishnas’ methods and warning
passengers of the identity of the solicitors, the guide
testified that she received death threats and was other-
wise intimidated by the Krishnas. (Declaration of Carol
Breidenbach, dated November 30, 1978, annexed hereto
as Exhibit L).
23. In another supporting affidavit, Gloria Conklin,
an insurance counter employee at LAX, stated that she
witnessed a male Krishna solicitor approach a young
teenage girl to request a donation. After the girl’s mother
indicated that they did not wish to make a donation and
repeatedly asked to be left alone, the Krishna member
forced them backwards until the mother and daughter
were forced up against the insurance counter. At this
point, the girl began crying, and her mother asked Ms.
Conklin to call the police. The mother then slapped the
Krishna member, who was prevented from striking her
with his fist by a third party. After Ms. Conklin con-
fronted a Krishna devotee about these solicitation
methods, she was followed through the airport to her car
by a male Krishna member and was apprehensive for her
safety. Ms. Conklin also stated that she witnessed a
female Krishna devotee soliciting funds from Hispanic
people by claiming that the money would go to
the”Catholic Relief Mission.” She also observed the same
83
Hare Krishna member solicit a donation from a young
— vette Navy uniform. The Krishna said that she
’ . a aactaty to bring the M.I.A.’s home from
letnam.” The serviceman, remarking that it was for
good cause, endorsed his whole paycheck to the fem le
devotee. (Declaration of Gloria Conklin, dated Oct ‘“.
13, 1978, annexed hereto as Exhibit M). oar
al 24. Victor C. Hernandez, [sic] a Passenger at LAX,
omitted an affidavit describing an attempt by a Har
Krishna devotee at LAX to perform what is known in
Hare Krishna jargon as the “change-up” on him :
ren asked Mr. Fernandez for money “ ‘for the chil-
a! Me Mr. Fernandez offered to give her a dollar,
po ee asked him to provide a $20 bill in return for
change. When Fernandez gave the devotee a $20 bill
she gave him only $13 back and tried to hand him a book.
When Mr. Fernandez refused the book and insisted on hi ,
change, the devotee became belligerent, Stating that oth .
people gave more money than Mr. Fernandez and thet
se already given him back $18 in change. Only after
men hag ic and argument did the devotee relent and
r. Fernandez the change that was due him. Mr
none felt that the devotee had obtained money hom
im unaer false pretenses by stating that her solicitation
was “‘for the children’ ”. (Affidavit of Victor C. Fer-
nandez, sworn to N
iene a ovember 20, 1978, annexed hereto as
, Bg An affidavit was also submitted in the LAX case
y Fierre Denard, the Air France station manager at LAX
Mr. Denard stated that in September 1978, a grou
mayors from the Polynesian Islands, on their way to is
to meet with French President Giscard d’Estaing nt
84
proceeding through an LAX terminal when two of the
mayors, who spoke only French, were accosted by two
male Krishna members. The Krishnas pinned miniature
American flags on the mayors’ lapels and requested a
donation. Each of the mayors gave a 500 French franc
note (then approximately equivalent to $120) and awaited
their change. The two Krishnas, however, pocketed the
money and departed. Still expecting change, the two
mayors followed the devotees until a French legislator
accompanying them learned of the problem and asked
the Krishnas to return the money. In response, one of the
Krishnas told the legislator that “he was nothing but a
foreigner and that he had best keep his mouth shut
because he had no right to interfere with their work.” In
the end, the Krishnas agreed to return 200 francs (approx-
imately $48). (Declaration of Pierre Denard, dated Sep-
tember 29, 1978, annexed hereto as Exhibit 0).
26. Even more appalling conduct was related in the
declaration of Paul Marks submitted in the LAX case. Mr.
Marks, a mechanic for Western Airlines, stated that,
because a fellow mechanic had ripped up a Hare Krishna
book which had been left lying in the terminal area, two
male Hare Krishna members verbally abused Mr. Marks
and, when he tried to avoid an altercation, one of the
devotees punched Mr. Marks with what appeared to be a
set of brass knuckles. After falling to the ground, Mr.
Marks tried to stand up, only to have the devotee kick
him in the mouth, knocking three of his teeth through Mr.
Marks’ upper lip. Mr. Marks required more than 50
stitches to close his wounds. (Declaration of Paul Marks
dated November 7, 1978, annexed hereto as Exhibit P).
an accounting of the
; milli
Plaintiffs over the year 10ns of dollars
"i obtained by
86
automatic weapons, stolen dynamite and hand grenades
had been spirited away after Krishna members learned
that the search was planned. A week later, Berkeley
police were reported as having discovered 350,000 rounds
of ammunition, 9 tons of gunpowder and bullet-making
equipment at the gun shop of a Hare Krishna member,
who was arrested on charges of having a fraudulent
passport. As already noted, plaintiff ISKCON’s highest
ranking official in California, Hans Kary, was arrested in
May 1980 on weapons charges. (Various newspaper arti-
cles reporting these events are collectively annexed
hereto as Exhibit R).
30. In June 1980, the Sacramento Bee reported that
the Sacramento, California Sheriff’s Department discov-
ered a cache of weapons and ammunition in a rental
locker, which a Hare Krishna official had previously
alleged contained only religious supplies. (A copy of this
article is annexed hereto as Exhibit S). From the locker,
police seized 4 rifles, 4 shotguns, 400 live rounds of
ammunition, reloading equipment and supplies, a pistol
holster and rifle slings. This seizure came just three days
after ISKCON officials had held a news conference in
Berkeley at which they claimed: “It is against the policy
of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to
keep any stockpile of weapons or ammunition for any
reason.” (/d.).
31. In May 1981, George A. Raczynski, one of plain-
tiff ISKCON’s members, was arrested in Los Angeles
after allegedly selling two fully-automatic machine guns
to an undercover federal agent. (A copy of the article
describing the arrest is annexed hereto as Exhibit T). The
arrest of Raczynski came one week after Robert A.
87
Loretto, another Hare Krishna, had been indicted for
possession of an unregistered machine gun. (/d.).
(ii) Narcotics Trafficking
32. There is also reason to believe that sankirtan
proceeds have been used to purchase large quantities of
heroin and other narcotics. In fact, one magazine article
terme narcotics trafficking a “major financial pillar of the
Krishna movement.” Exhibit V infra, at 219. For example
the June 22, 1980 Sacramento Bee reported that on Octo-
ber 22, 1977 Alexander Kulik, an aide to A.C. Bhahtive-
danta Swami Prabhupada (hereinafter “Prabhupada”).
plaintiff ISKCON’s founder, was discovered asleep ina
$60,000 Stutz Blackhawk automobile in a parking lot in
Orange County, California with more than $1 million
worth of “China white” heroin in the back seat. (A copy
of this article is annexed hereto as Exhibit U). Kulik was a
partner in Prasadam Distributing International (sve Inter-
rogatory No. 54), a firm which was reported to have
laundered drug profits and which allegedly was funded
by ISKCON seed money. (See Exhibit Y infra).
33. The article reported that Kulik had previously
been kidnapped by one Steven Bovan, a rival drug dealer
in August 1977 and held for $100,000 ransom. Upen
payment of this ransom, Kulik was released. The day
before Kulik was arrested with the heroin, Bovan was
shot to death. Three alleged Mafia members were
arrested for the murder, and Kulik, along with six other
Krishna devotees and associates, was charged with hiring
Mafia “hitmen” to kill Bovan. According to the magazine
account:
88
“At the trial, Kulik testified that he had
traveled around the world as Prabhupada’s per-
sonal fund raiser for seven years and had fun-
neled him more than $2 million. It came out that
the defendants had set up a company, Prasadam
Distributing (named after the Krishna word for
sanctified food or sustenance) partly, according
to a statement from a former associate, to laun-
der funds from the heroin smuggling and other
operations.
“Krishna spokesmen claimed all those
involved were former members with no connec-
tion to the movement. But during the trial, there
surfaced a personal letter from Prabhupada that
addressed the defendants by first names. Dated
nine months before the arrests (and after the
smuggling had been underway several years), it
congratulated them on setting up Prasadam Dis-
tributing and had this curious advice: “There is
no need to engage in anything dishonest.
Krishna has given enough money, now earn by
honest means.’
“Prabhupada died before the trial date and
so could not be called to testify.
“During the trial, the defendants pleaded
guilty to charges of conspiring to kidnap Bovan
in return for having the murder charges
dropped. Kulik and other Krishnas were sen-
tenced for this and a variety of heroin charges.”
(This article is annexed hereto as Exhibit V). The article
also reported that in April 1979 David Kulik, Alexander’s
brother, was arrested in London for possession of 65
pounds of hash oil. David Kulik was identified as a
member of the Los Angeles ISKCON temple.
89
; 34. In April 1980, Gregory Martin Gottfried, a/k/a
Guru Kripta,” a high-ranking member of the Krishna
movement, was reported to have been arrested trying to
smuggie two Kilograms (4.4 pounds) of “Asian white”
heroin through the Amsterdam airport. (See Exhibit U
supra). .
| 35. In February 1982 stories in the Orange County
Daily Pilot and The Register reported that undercover
narcotics agents arrested Roy Christopher Richard for
conspiracy to sell more than $1 million worth of “China
white” heroin, which heroin was seized from Richard at
the time of his arrest. (Copies of these articles are
annexed hereto as Exhibit W). Richard, a former presi-
dent of plaintiffs’ Laguna Beach temple, had been among
those indicted for conspiracy to commit murder in the
1977 slaying of Stephen Bovan. (See 433, supra). Also
arrested with Richard were two other members of the
temple.
| 36. In December 1982, an article in the Philadelphia
Daily News reported that a federal court in Philadelphia
convicted George Flora, a member of that city’s Hare
Krishna community and a resident of the temple, for
conspiracy to distribute three pounds of opium smuggled
from India in three Buddhist statues. (A copy of the
article is annexed hereto as Exhibit X). Flora claimed that
the statues belonged to Victor Doran, the temple vice-
president. Doran, who did not stand trial, was believed to
have fled to India after being released on bail. In his 1979
deposition in this case, named plaintiff Rumbaugh testi-
fied that, as “Regional Secretary” for ISKCON’s “North-
eastern U.S. Zone”, he had personal administrative
90
responsibility for the Philadelphia temple. (4/24/79
Rumbaugh Deposition at 20).
(iii) Profit-Making Ventures
37. Plaintiffs object to a group of interrogatories
(Nos. 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 45, 46, 47, 49, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56,
and 57) which seek information concerning a number of
separately incorporated organizations. These interrogato-
ries are designed to untangle the web of Krishna enter-
prises and ascertain the extent of the profit-making,
commercial activities carried on by plaintiffs. Defendants
seek to discover any improper diversion of monies by
individuals within the Krishna organization. Interroga-
tory 35, for example, seeks to discover information about
Spiritual Sky Scented Products, Inc. Plaintiff Brian Rum-
baugh testified at his 1979 deposition in this action that
Spiritual Sky was once part of ISKCON but later became
a separate profit-making company. (4/29/79 Deposition
of Brian Rumbaugh at 67). In fact, it appears that, after
Spiritual Sky was established by a Governing Body Com-
missioner, James Immel, as a profit-making corporation in
California in 1975, the New York temple loaned Spiritual
Sky $282,000 and negotiated royalty agreements that enti-
tled ISKCON to 7.5% of Spiritual Sky sales. In 1976,
plaintiffs’ California corporation acquired by deed of gift
the interests in Spiritual Sky then held by plaintiffs’ New
York corporation.” This transaction enabled the California
* This arguably contradicts a statement in a letter “To whom it
may concern” dated April 17, 1980 and signed by Gadahara
Pandita das, Secretary-Treasuer of ISKCON:
(Continued on following page)
91
group to benefit from Spiritual Sky sales to Balarama’s
Enterprises, Inc. (see Interrogatory 51), a private, profit-
making incense and oils wholesale distributor. Bal-
arama’s earnings were in turn siphoned off by the Bay
Area temple. The newspaper account of these dealings
also reported allegations that Balarama’s Enterprises pur-
chased a $60,000 airplane (see Interrogatories 6, 7, 8) to be
used primarily by guru Hans Kary. (This newspaper arti-
cle is annexed hereto as Exhibit Y).
38. In their motion for a protective order, (Plaintiff's
Memorandum at 4) plaintiffs characterize BALA Books
(see Interrogatory No. 38) as an entity separate from
ISKCON. Plaintiff Brian Rumbaugh, however, has testi-
fied that BALA “is part of ISKCON, Inc. [and is] not a
separate corporation.” (See 4/29/79 Rumbaugh Deposi-
tion at 135). Plaintiffs also imply that Krishna Fashions
(see Interrogatory No. 49) is not part of ISKCON. Krishna
Fashions, however, is listed in an ISKCON financial state-
ment for 1975 as a “subsidiary program”. (4/24/79 Rum-
baugh Deposition, Ex. 15).
39. Interrogatory No. 52 seeks to discover possible
dealings between ISKCON and an entity known as Pin
(Continued from previous page)
“[Wle do not make compensation to other temples,
in as much as each temple is separately incorporated
and governed by a separate group of officers. All
temples are completely autonomous in their opera-
tions with neither financial or managerial depen-
dence on another temple.”
This letter was received in evidence by the trial court in
ISKCON ov. Barber. supra, as Defendant's Ex. U.
92
Up the World. Pin Up the World is a Krishna corporation
which reportedly manufactures buttons which Krishnas
sell or use when soliciting money from the public.
According to one newspaper account, “some of the but-
tons reputedly advocate non-religious activities, such as
reform of the marijuana laws.” (See Ex. D, supra, at 3).
One former Krishna reported that devotees sold “Go
Orioles” buttons at the 1979 World Series in Baltimore;
that at the World Series of Rock that year, they sold
buttons advocating the reform of marijuana laws; and
that “wherever Pope John Paul II went during his tour of
the United States . . . devotees ‘were hustling pope but-
tons for whatever price they could get.’” (/d.)
40. Interrogatory No. 53 is aimed at discovering any
dealings between the Dey Memorial Trust and plaintiff
ISKCON. The trust has as its purpose to exist as an
“integrated auxiliary of ISKCON of California and the
international Krishna movement.” (See Ex. Y, p. 2)
(emphasis added). ISKCON of California, Inc. apparently
contributes almost $100,000 per year to the trust, which
has substantial real estate holdings. When questioned
about the trust, Robert Grant a/k/a “Rameswara
Swami”, told a reporter that he had never heard of Dey
Memorial Trust. Grant, however, had in fact been a Dey
Memorial trustee and had signed a conveyance of trust
property to a successor trustee.
Conclusion
41. As demonstrated above, the Second Air India
Interrogatories were based on substantial evidence that
(1) plaintiff ISKCON and its leadership is seeking access
93
ee areas in order to defraud their
ers of huge sums; and (2) th
: ; ese sums may b
pict to secular and even crimina] Purposes. if the
= Ae rt by defendants confirms this evidence
nadia group will be able to an )
i es | swer the Second
ii na ag inquiry on remand in the follow-
er: e “right asserted b i
! | . the plaintiffs”
in truth is the right to defr. ; ; 0
aud defendants’
The “justification” £ ~psniacmedag
or defendants refusal i
kirtan on their i sega
property is the legitimate desir
e to protect
Poe and employees from fraud and aiinde and
efendants’ prohibition would have little S om
effect” on the exercise of legitimate First Am
a endment
| WHEREFORE, it is res
tiffs’ motion for a protectiv
respects.
pectfully submitted that plain-
e order should be denied in all
/s/ Philip Le B. Douglas
Philip Le B. Douglas
Sworn to before
me this 12th day of
October, 1984
/s/ Edward F. Westfield
Notary Public
EDWARD F. WESTFIELD
Notary Public, State of
; N
No. 03-4781170 o—
Qualified in Bronx County
Commission Expires March 30, 1985
94
EXHIBIT 1
DECLARATION OF CAROL BREIDENBACH
1. My name is CAROL BREIDENBACH and I reside
in Los Angeles County, California;
2. I work for the City of Los Angeles, Department of
Airports, as an Airport Guide and am stationed in the
satellite portion of Terminal Building No. 2 (the Interna-
tional Satellite) for eight hours a day, three days a week;
3. I have personal knowledge of the following facts
and am competent to testify as to the truth of these facts
if called as a witness;
4. My duties require me to be present at an informa-
tion desk in the satellite portion of Terminal Building No.
2 that is located near the Customs Area. | offer informa-
tion and any necessary verbal assistance to air travelers,
especially those foreign air travelers using Los Angeles
International Airport;
5. I have been an Airport Guide for approximately
three (3) years and during that time have had the oppor-
tunity to view the Hare Krishna solicitors operating in the
satellite portion of Terminal Building No. 2. My desk is
located within approximately 25 feet of the top of the
escalators and close to the narrow corridors that lead to
the Boarding Gates. The Hare Krishna solicitors typically
operate very near the top of the escalators or in the
narrowest part of the narrow corridors;
6. Typically, the Hare Krishna solicitors stand either
directly in front of the up or down escalator in the satel-
lite portion of the building or they line up across a
narrow corridor that leads to the Boarding areas.
95
Rece i
oe “a Hare Krishna Solicitors have, in addition t
& the narrow corridor with their bodies staan
7. In*exchan
ge for these H ;
Solicitors seek money; articles, the Hare Krishna
96
the Hare Krishna movement. I have hears numerous Hare
Krishna solicitors state to people that they are student
teachers and then ask for donations for “educational pur-
poses”. During these solicitations which I overheard,
there was no mention of religion;
10. As mentioned earlier, the Hare Krishna solici-
tors often give out small paper American flags. They give
these flags to many of the foreign travelers coming into
Los Angeles International Airport. I have heard Hare
Krishna solicitors, after giving out these little United
States flags, state that this was “a greeting from the
United States”. Statements such as this to the foreign
traveler seems to give them the impression that the solici-
tors are either airport or government employees here to
greet them to the United States;
11. I have also seen a Hare Krishna solicitor state to
a foreign traveler that the Hare Krishna solicitor was
collecting for “an organization for children”;
12. I have also seen Hare Krishna solicitors short-
change people who wish to donate a small amount. This
shortchanging is particularly used against the foreign
travelers that often do not appear to know the American
monetary denominations or exchange rates. In addition, |
have seen many Hare Krishna solicitors confuse, intimi-
date, and hassle people into giving more money than
they originally indicated they wished to give. Typically,
the confusing and intimidating solicitation technique
takes the following form. A person who indicates that he
would be willing to give $1.00 to the Hare Krishna solici-
tor or that he is not willing to make a donation but is
willing to exchange a high denomination bill for the same
97
amount in smaller bills will be asked by the solicitor for a
$20 or a $50 bill so that the solicitor may get rid of smaller
bills in change or in exchange. If the person offers a
larger bill, the Hare Krishna solicitor typically returns
only a very small amount in change, again asking the
person to donate the remainder. In order for the person to
obtain the full amount of his change, he has to stand
there, continuously refusing to donate more, and continu-
ously demanding the full amount of his change. I have
seen this approach used by Hare Krishna solicitors many
times;
13. i have been told by a Hare Krishna solicitor by
the name of “Rosi” that the Hare Krishna solicitors quit
wearing their distinctive gowns “because people won’t
give any money if they know we are Hare Krishna”. The
Hare Krishna solicitor named “Rosi” reponded to my
question “why don’t you tell people your Hare Krishna”,
by stating that “if we told them, they wouldn’t give”;
14. People who refuse to give money to the Hare
Krishna solicitors are often times called names by the
solicitors in an apparent attempt to embarrass them and
intimidate others into giving. Approximately 20 people
per day complain to me about the Hare Krishna solicita-
tion techniques;
15. After approximately one year of watching var-
ious Hare Krishna solicitors misrepresent themselves or
their cause to people and after watching them take
advantage of the foreign travelers, | put up a hand-made
sign to the effect that “Hare Krishna devotees are solicit-
ing in the Airport. You do not have to give them any
money. Please save your money”. I did this because | felt
98
that many unsuspecting people, especially the foreign
travelers, had a right to know who they were giving
money to and that they were not airport or government
officials and further that they did not have to give any
money to these people. I put up this sign without Depart-
ment of Airports’ permission and was later told that such
signs were not permitted and that I had to take the sign
down;
16. I have been threatened and intimidated several
times by Hare Krishna devotees. I was first threatened on
February 20, 1978, when a person I knew to be a Hare
Krishna solicitor came up to me and said a Krishna
member “is going to get you killed”. Since that threat, a
person I know to be a Hare Krishna member took my
picture several times even though I indicated that I did
not want him to take my picture. The man who took my
picture has hung around the terminal watching me on
several different days. Since the initial threat, | have been
followed by Hare Krishna members and have been told
by a Hare Krishna member “you're not going to be here
much longer”;
17. I am aware of other threats made by Hare
Krishna members against airline personnel that have
either made announcements that Hare Krishna members
were in the terminals or intervened in disputes between
passengers and Hare Krishna members. Because of the
threats against me, because of the Western Airline
employee battery, and because of the other threats that
have occurred, ' am fearful for my life. These threats have
interfered with the ability to do my job and further has
required me to change my parking place and seek escorts
back and forth to the parking lot.
99
| I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing
is true and correct and that this declaration was executed
on November 30 , 1978, at Los Angeles, California.
/s/ Carol Breidenbach
Carol Breidenbach
100
EXHIBIT 4
DECLARATION OF GLORIA CONKLIN
I, GLORIA CONKLIN, declare:
1. My name is GLORIA CONKLIN and my places of
business are the Mutual of Omaha insurance counters in
the Terminal Buildings at Los Angeles International Air-
port.
2. I have personal knowledge of the following facts
and am competent to testify as to the truth of these facts
if called as a witness.
3. All of the events described below in paragraphs
4, 6 and 7 occurred in the Satellite portion of the Terminal
Buildings at Los Angeles International Airport.
4. On Labor Day weekend, 1978, i observed a male
person I recognized as a Hare Krishna member (this
member and others had solicited and sold books near me
in front of the escalators) approach a girl, approximately
13 years old, and repeatedly requested a donation. A
middle-aged lady who was with the young girl and who
identified herself as the young girl’s mother, repeatedly
informed the Hare Krishna member that they did not
wish to make a donation and repeatedly asked the mem-
ber to leave them alone. During this solicitation attempt,
the mother and daughter backed up until they were
forced up against the insurance counter. The young girl
appeared scared and began crying and the mother
requested me to call the police. After the mother repeat-
edly requested that the Hare Krishna member leave them
alone, the mother slapped the Krishna member. The male
Hare Krishna member then formed a fist and prepared to
101
strike the mother when a third party intervened to sto
the blow. :
5. Shortly after the incident described in paragraph
4 occurred, I spoke to a Hare Krishna member about their
solicitation methods. After these confrontations, a male
person I recognized as a Hare Krishna member followed
=e out of the Satellite, down the concourse, through the
ticketing building, and into the parking structure to my
cae. Seeing the incident and physical altercation described
in paragraph 4, plus the fact that I was followed to my
car, made me afraid and apprehensive for my safety.
6. Within the last two months, I observed a person |
recognized as a Hare Krishna member (this member dis-
tributed forms and Hare Krishna books with other Hare
Krishna members) solicit funds from Hispanic people by
representing that the money would go to the “Catholic
Relief Mission.”
7. Within the last two months, I observed another
person I recognized as a Hare Krishna member (this
member distributed flowers and Hare Krishna books and
was working with other Hare Krishna members at the to
of the escalators) approach a young man ina U.S. nad
uniform and request money Stating that the Hare Krishna
member was from “a society to bring the M.I.A.’s home
from Viet Nam.” I observed and overheard the Navy man
state that he thought “this was a good cause” and he then
“tr Sane his whole pay check to the Hare Krishna mem-
er.
102
| declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing
is true and correct and that this Declaration was executed
on October 23 , 1978, at Los Angeles, California.
/s/ Gloria Conklin
GLORIA CONKLIN
103
EXHIBIT 9
AFFIDAVIT
OF
VICTOR C. FERNANDEZ
1. My name is VICTOR C. FERNANDEZ and I res-
ide in Pontiac, Michigan.
2. I have personal knowledge of the following facts
and am competent to testify as to the truth of these facts
if called as a witness.
3. On September 7, 1978, at approximately 10:30
a.m., I was in a Terminal Building at Los Angeles Interna-
tional Airport on my way to catch an airplane.
4. At the end of the tunnel concourse | used an
escalator to enter the satellite area.
5. As I stepped off the escalator, a young lady |
believe to be a Hare Krishna devotee stepped in front of
me and blocked my way. Although I tried to walk around
her, she stopped me by pinning a small imitation flower
on my lapel.
6. The devotee then asked for money stating that
“we do it for the children”. In response to this request, |
offered to give her one ($1) dollar.
7. The devotee replied that the one ($1) dollar dona-
tion would be fine and then asked if I would give her a
twenty ($20) dollar bill for nineteen ($19) dollars change.
I gave her the twenty ($20) dollar bill. She then handed
me a ten ($10) dollar bill and three (3) one ($1) dollar bills
and then tried to hand me a book about the Hare Krishna
group.
104
8. I politely refused the book and asked for the
remainder of my change.
9. The devotee then became very beligerant stating
that other people gave more than I and further that she
had already given me back eighteen ($18) dollars in
change. In response, I showed her the thirteen ($13) dol-
lars she had given me and again requested the remainder
of my change. The devotee then gave me two ($2) dollars
more but refused to give me any more of my change.
Finally, after more discussion and argument, made the
devotee return the four ($4) dollars change due me.
10. The devotee did not have permission when she
handled my clothing and I found this action offensive.
11. The devotee obtained money from me on false
pretenses in that -
a. She stated that money was “for the children”,
and
b. She had no intention of returning my change
to me.
12. The devotee obstructed my way and interfered
with my travel.
Notary Public, Oaklan
105
Executed this 20 da
ac , Michigan.
County of Oakland
y of November
, 1978, at Pon-
/s/ Victor C. Fernandez
VICTOR C FERNA
é ND
ae TO, STATED UNDER OATH _
é UBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS
ay of November , 1978.
/s/ Richard C. Hohm
Notary Public
RICHARD C. HOHM
d County, Michigan
es April 1, 1980
y Commission Expir
106
EXHIBIT 11
DECLARATION OF PIERRE DENARD
1. My name is PIERRE DENARD and | am the Sta-
tion manager in charge of Air France’s operations at Los
Angeles International Airport.
2. I speak fluent French and English.
3. On Friday, September 15, 1978, I was on duty in
Satellite 2, at the Los Angeles International Airport.
4. On the above date, a French Air Force airplane
arrived at Satellite 2 and deplaned a group of mayors
from the Polynesian Islands on their way to Paris, France,
to meet with President Giscard d’Estaing. The mayors
were accompanied by French Congressman Gaston
Flosse.
5. Two mayors, who spoke only French exited the
Customs area and were immediately grasped by two
male members of the Hare Krishna organization who
proceeded to pin miniature American flags on the
mayors’ coat lapels and then requested a donation.
6. Each of the two mayors gave the Hare Krishna
members a five hundred (500) French Franc note (equiva-
lent to approximately one hundred twenty United States
dollars ($120). The two members expected and waited for
change to be returned.
7. The two Hare Krishna members pocketed the
money and departed, but the two mayors followed still
expecting some change to be returned.
107
8. Mr. Flosse, the French Congressman, discovered
the problem and at the request of the two mayors, asked
the Hare Krishna members to return some of the money.
9. In response to this request, one of the Hare
Krishna members told Mr. Flosse that he was nothing but
a foreigner and that he had best keep his mouth shut
because he had no right to interfere with their work. The
Hare Krishna members finally agreed to return two hun-
dred (200) Francs [approximately forty-eight ($48) dol-
lars].
10. I was then asked to intervene and obtain a
return of the money. I explained to the Hare Krishna
members that the two French-speaking mayors did not
speak English and did not understand what had hap-
pened. | further asked that the Hare Krishna members
show me their identification cards. The Hare Krishna
members were very rude to me and refused to return any
more of the money or to identify themselves.
11. As Station Manager for Air France at Los
Angeles International Airport, I receive many complaints,
especially by foreign travelers, concerning the conduct of
Hare Krishna members when they are soliciting money.
12. Many of the foreign travelers I have seen solic.
ited by Hare Krishna members appear to be very con-
fused by the Hare Krishnas’ actions, and further, they
appear to feel obligated to give the members money. This
is especially true when the foreign traveler first enters
this country and is presented with a small American flag
in a large, obviously government-owned Airport.
108
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing
is true and correct.
Executed this 29th day of September 1978 at Los
Angeles, California.
/s/ Pierre Denard
PIERRE DENARD
Declarant
109
EXHIBIT 16
DECLARATION OF PAUL MARKS
I, PAUL MARKS, declare:
1. My name is PAUL MARKS and | reside in Los
Angeles County, California;
2. I work for Western Airlines as a Mechanic in
Satellite Building 5 at Los Angeles International Airport;
3. I have personal knowledge of the following facts
and am competent to testify as to the truth of these facts
if called as a witness;
4. At approximately 2:30 p.m. on December 23,
1977, I was in uniform with three fellow Western Airlines
mechanics in the Satellite portion of Terminal Building
No. 5 shortly before our shift started;
5. One of the mechanics that I was with made a
practice of collecting unwanted Krishna books lying
around in the terminals and reselling them to the
Krishnas for a price of $1.00 per book. He approached a
Hare Krishna female member and offered several books
to her for $1.00 each. She offered to pay $.50 per book. My
friend at this point started to rip one of the Hare Krishna
books up;
6. Almost immediately, two men approached the
four of us from each side. They began a verbal altercation
with us by saying “you are messing with our people.”
Another said, “what are you doing with the book? If you
want to fight, why don’t you fight with us”. We then
informed these Hare Krishna members that we could not
fight while on duty.
110
7. At this point we went back to our duty station on
the operations level of Satellite 5. About two hours after
the incident described in paragraph 6, I again entered
Satellite 5 to get a pack of cigarettes. After I had pur-
chased the cigarettes, I walked toward the elevator to go
back to the operations level when the same two male
Hare Krishna members approached me and started to
again verbally harass me. One of the Hare Krishna mem-
bers stated that he thought that I was a “faggot” and was
also a“ ___ asshole for tearing up the Krishna books”;
8. I turned around to avoid an altercation and began
to walk toward the elevator. A few feet closer to the
elevator these two members again engaged in calling me
profanities. I noticed that one of these Hare Krishna
members had a raised object on his right hand that
appeared to be brass knuckles. As I turned, again trying
to walk away from these Hare Krishna members, the one
wearing what appeared to me to be a set of brass
knuckles, struck me with them on the left side of my face,
close to my left eye. The blow sent me staggering several
feet backwards into the Mutual of Omaha insurance
counter, then into the wall, and finally I fell on the floor.
As I tried to stand up, this same Hare Krishna member
kicked me in the mouth, knocking three of my front
bottom teeth through my upper lip. He then turned and
ran down the escalators and through a side corridor to
get away.
9. I was taken to the Western Airlines Ground
Supervisor’s Office by a fellow employee after this inci-
dent. I was then driven to Centinela Valley Hospital for
emergency treatment. I was given 44 stitches on the
inside of my mouth and 12 stitches on the outside of my
111
mouth to close these wounds. I had three teeth sticking
through my lip on the way to the hospital. This caused
me extreme pain;
9. A dentist was called to the hospital to wire these
three teeth back into my lower gums. He has since
informed me that he doubts that these three teeth will
permanently remain in my lower gums due to the extent
of these injuries.
| I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing
is true and correct and that this declaration was executed
on this 7 day of November, 1978, at Los Angeles, Cali-
fornia.
/s/ Paul B.Marks
PAUL MARKS
112
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
_ \
INTERNATIONAL
SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA pgc.ARATION OF
CONSCIOUSNESS, INC., : BRIAN RUMBAUGH IN
et al., OPPOSITION TO
Plaintiffs, ° DEFENDANTS’ MOTION
TO DISMISS, AND
“age : EXHIBITS
WALTER LEE, et al.,
tices 75 Civ. 5388 (MJL)
—
Brian Rumbaugh declares under penalty of perjury as
follows:
1. I have been an adherent of the Krishna conscious-
ness religion for the past 15 years, and have been associ-
ated with the International Society for Krishna
Consciousness, Inc. (hereinafter referred to as “New York
Temple”), for this entire period. I am also known by the
Sanskrit name Romapada Swami. The purpose of this
declaration is to clarify for the Court the areas where
New York Temple members are currently permitted to
distribute literature and collect donations, and to define
the specific areas to which they currently seek access.
2. During the 15 years in which I have been a
devotee, I have served the New York Temple in a variety
of capacities, including President from 1977 to 1978, and
from 1982 to 1983. I was also sankirtan coordinator from
113
1980 to 1982, and am currently involved in the supervi-
sion of devotees throughout the New York area in preach-
ing the Krishna consciousness religion and distributing
religious literature to the general public. My duties, past
and present, include sankirtan activities at the LaGuardia,
Newark and John F. Kennedy Airports (“JFK”), both as
sankirtan coordinator, and as a book distributor. I am thus
intimately familiar with the layout and facilities at the
three airports.
3. At present, New York Temple members are per-
mitted to distribute religious literature and collect dona-
tions in certain areas at the three metropolitan airports.
Those areas, which are designated on the attached
exhibits, are as follows: (1) the second floor Central Ter-
minal main lobby area at LaGuardia, designated 1-a in
Exhibit 1, attached hereto; (2) the Central first floor lobby
area of the north Terminal at Newark, designated 4-a in
Exhibit 4, attached hereto; (3) the arrivals level lobby/
mezzanine area of Terminal B at Newark, designated 6-a
and 6-b respectively on Exhibit 6, attached hereto; and (4)
the second floor lobby/mezzanine area of the Interna-
tional Arrivals Building (“IAB”) at JFK, designated 8-a on
Exhibit 8, attached hereto.
4. New York Temple members also have limited
access to the Eastern Airlines Unit Terminal at JFK; the
Eastern Airlines Shuttle Terminal at LaGuardia Airport,
and; the Eastern Airlines departure lounge at LaGuardia.
5. New York Temple members seek further access,
however, to the following specific areas from which they
are presently excluded:
114
LaGuardia Airport: (1) the second floor Central
Terminal finger areas designated 1-b on Exhibit
1, attached hereto; (2) the second floor Central
terminal corridor areas designated 1-c on
Exhibit 1; (3) the second floor Central Terminal
West Wing lobby area designated 1-d on Exhibit
1; (4) the second floor Central Terminal depar-
ture and lobby areas designated 1-e on Exhibit 1;
(5) the first floor Central Terminal Circulation
areas designated 2-a, 2-b, and 2-c respectively
on Exhibit 2, attached hereto; and (6) the first
and second floor Delta Unit Terminal circulation
areas designated 3-a and 3-b respectively in
Exhibit 3, attached hereto.
Newark Airport: (1) The arrivals level circulation
areas of Terminal A designated 5-a and 5-b
respectively on Exhibit 5, attached hereto; (2)
the departure level mezzanine/lobby and corri-
dor areas of Terminal A designated 5-c and 5-d
respectively on Exhibit 5; (3) the arrivals level
circulation areas of Terminal B designated 6-a
and 6-b respectively on Exhibit 6, attached
hereto; and (4) the departure level mezzanine/
lobby and corridor areas of Terminal B desig-
nated 6-c and 6-d respertively on Exhibit 6.
JFK Airport: (1) the first floor IAB arrivals lobby
designated 7-a on Exhibit 7 attached hereto; (2)
the second floor East and West Wing Building
corridors and lobby areas designated 8-b, 8-c,
8-d, and 8-e respectively on Exhibit 8, attached
hereto; and (3) various general circulation areas
in the respective Unit Terminals designated in
plain yellow on Exhibits 9-18 attached hereto.
6. It should be emphasized that New York Temple
members do not seek to perform their activities in any
private offices, ticket counters and lines, check-in areas,
115
baggage claim areas or lines
ing areas which ma
above. On the contr
duct their activities
including corridors,
dered by shops, resta
cial establishments u
, Or exclusively leased wait-
y be located in the areas described
ary, ISKCON members seek to con-
only in areas of general circulation,
lobbies, and areas which are bor-
urants, lounges and other commer-
nrelated to air transportation.
. 7. Based upon my years of personal involvement
with the airports, the locations outlined above are analo-
gous to metropolitan commercial areas, and are therefore
suitable and appropriate for the performance of sankirtan.
Executed this 14th da
| y of August, 1985, at
City, New York. ° er
/s/ Brian Rumbaugh
Brian Rumbaugh
116
CENTRAL BUILDIUG
j-nens omer tn cae
-— - eee
_ } “7 ee
oe 1 oer i's ot =
TERMIVAL. BUILDWG
SECOND FLOOP Flay
= || GaanaSD)
117
EYENRTT 2
\ ot
ot CENTRAL BLOG
-—A em we = omane 29
j ; . 7
_
> ——— Atal —-" O:caeo
—p “— — eo Fy
— ~eree
TERMINAL BYULOWEe
FIAST FLOOm PLaU
7i>s 7 1S
OVERSIZE FOLDOUT(S) FOUND HERE IN
THE PRINTED EDITION OF THIS VOLUME
ARE FOUND FOLLOWING THE LAST PAGE
OF TEXT IN THIS MICROFICHE EDITION.
SEE FOLDOUT NO 4.
GLH - LEC DIME ~ eM H? CRE VEG,
a
| 4 / ;
{ i ili
ee. 1H
—_ a. ii
= AL i
een. - : .
# ’ ee 5
i?)
l \ ns
y ee 4 4 | ie
-roa4 25 o~ . m
Pilg FT OS | |
: | 3 , be . ;.
bogdbassad ess sesd O/T S |
/ io of ‘
a te
” .
"6 : |.
“86 .) q
2 .
oh is
\e ‘Ne
= '
!
DEPARTURE - CONCOURSE - CONCESSION FLOOR PLAN
120 _ ‘
PASSENGER TERMINAL “A” - TERMINAL BUILDING + | *. = | PASSENGER TERMINAL EXHIBIT 5
,nw www ww
PASSENGER TERMINAL “A” SECTION
(APPROXIMATE FLOOR LEVELS)
Mt
5 iiss it I
a2 ti rally
QQ, 5® | [sSactl . &e=
S TERwimAL BUT ONG . ———— Stalron
} , RS wee: FT) ores we
0}
.
eaTIMLED: EXHIBIT A
cab Gn Cann eae THE PORT OF NEW YORK AUTHORITY
‘NEWARK AIRPORT
FOR Tet LESseet 3-1-72 (a) MAT2-2
—— -fawr 0 .
PASSENGER TERMINAL “A” KEY PLAN C
TERMINAL BUTLDLNG . >
PASSENGER TERMINAL “A” - TERMINAL BUILDING — 6}
ARRIVAL FLOOR PLAN —
PASSE
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.