Joint Appendix — Arkansas v. Oklahoma
Supreme Court brief1991
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
@D (y) ; supreme Cour, Vio |
IN THE anode.
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1990
STATE OF ARKANSAS, et al.,
e Petitioners,
STATE OF OKLAHOMA, et al.,
Respondents.
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
Petitioner,
V.
STATE OF OKLAHOMA, et ai.,
Respondents.
On Writs of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the Tenth Circuit
JOINT APPENDIX
Davip G. NORRELL ROBERT A. BUTKIN
KIRKLAND & ELLIS BRITA HAUGLAND CANTRELL
Suite 1200 STATE OF OKLAHOMA
655 15th Street, N.W. Office of the Attorney General
Washington, D.C. 20005 112 State Capitol Building
(202) 879-5070 Oklahoma City, OK 73105
Counsel for Petitioners in (405) 521-3921
No. 90-1262 Counsel for Respondents in
KENNETH W. STARR Nos. 90-1262 & 90-1266
Solicitor General
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 514-2217
Counsel for Petitioner in
No. 90-1266 Dated: May 31, 1991
a
PETITIONS FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 8, 1991
CERTIORARI GRANTED APRIL 1, 1991
TABLE OF CONTENTS
United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
ES
EPA Administrative Law Judge, Initial Decision, Jan-
uary 12, 1988 (included in Appendix to Petition for
Certiorari filed by Arkansas parties in No. 90-1262,
OO snsisbieniemnnuminemens
EPA Chief Judicial Officer, Order on Petitions for Re-
view, June 28, 1988 (included in Appendix to Petition
for Certiorari filed by Arkansas parties in No. 90-
GE
EPA Administrative Law Judge, Decision on Remand,
September 19, 1988 (included in Appendix to Petition
for Certiorari filed by Arkansas parties in No. 90-
es a cceesseesesstasuencetcnsecece
EPA Chief Judicial Officer, Second Order on Petitions
for Review, December 22, 1988 (included in Ap-
pendix to Petition for Certiorari filed by Arkansas
parties in No. 90-1262, at pp. 145a-153a) —.....0.......
1982 Oklahoma Water Quality Standards ....................
1985 Oklahoma Water Quality Standards ......................
NPDES Permit No. AR0020010 Issued to the City of
i aa csiesiipendamnens 6 Se oe
Page
64
66
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
}
No. 89-9503
STATE OF OKLAHOMA;
OKLAHOMA SCENIC RIVERS COMMISSION ;
POLLUTION CONTROL COORDINATING BOARD,
e : Petitioners,
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
Respondent,
OKLAHOMA WILDLIFE FEDERATION; STATE OF ARKANSAS;
ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND
EcoLoGy; CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, Arkansas; THE
BEAVER WATER DISTRICT,
Intervenors.
No. 89-9507
SAVE THE ILLINOIS River (STIR), a non-profit
corporation of the State of Oklahoma,
- Petitioner,
ENVIRON MENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
Respondent,
BEAVER WATER DISTRICT; STATE OF ARKANSAS; AR-
KANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND
EcoLocy; CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, Arkansas; STATE OF
OKLAHOMA; OKLAHOMA SCENIC RIVERS COMMISSION ;
POLLUTION CONTROL COORDINATING BOARD,
Intervenors.
(1)
2
No. 89-9516
STATE OF ARKANSAS; ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLU-
TION CONTROL AND ECOLOGY; THE BEAVER WATER
DISTRICT ; CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE,
Petitioners,
Vv.
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
Respondent,
SAVE THE ILLINOIS RIVER (STIR) ; STATE OF OKLAHOMA;
OKLAHOMA SCENIC RIVERS COMMISSION; POLLUTION
CONTROL COORDINATING BOARD,
Intervenors.
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1/12/89 Petition for review filed for State of Oklahoma.
1/24/89 Notice of intervention as party filed by Oklahoma
Wildlife Federation in No. 89-9503.
1/30/89 Petition for review filed for Save the Illinois.
2/8/89 Notice of intervention as party filed by City of
Fayetteville in No. 89-9503.
2/8/89 Notice of intervention as party filed by the Beaver
Water District in No. 89-9503.
2/8/89 Notice of intervention as party filed by State of
Arkansas in 89-9503, Arkansas Department of
Pollution Control & Ecology in No. 89-9503.
2/9/89 Letter from Clear Creek and Illinois River Prop-
erty Owners Association of Arkansas expressing
their opinions in the appeal.
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
2/14/89
2/14/89
2/16/89
3/3/89
3/10/89
3/10/89
3/24/89
3/28/89
3/29/89
3/31/89
Notice of intervention as party filed by the Beaver
Water District in No. 89-9507.
Notice of intervention as party filed by State of
Arkansas and Arkansas Department of Pollution
Controls & Ecology in No. 89-9507.
Notice of intervention as party filed by City of
Fayetteville in No. 89-9507.
Respondent’s motion to consolidate appeals filed
by EPA in Nos. 89-9503 and 89-9507.
Case docketed. Transfer from Eight Circuit of
Petition for Review filed by City of Fayetteville,
The Beaver Water District, Arkansas Department,
and State of Arkansas.
Notice of intervention as party filed by Save the
Illinois in 89-9516.
Motion filed by Petitioner State of Oklahoma in
No. 89-9503 to consolidate appeals, and to extend
time to file petitioner’s brief until 40 days from
which the motion to consolidate is granted.
Response filed by Save the Illinois in Nos. 89-9507
and 89-9516 to motions to consolidate appeals in
Nos. 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Notice of intervention as party filed by State of
Oklahoma in Nos. 89-9507 and 89-9516.
Intervenor’s brief filed by Oklahoma Wildlife in No.
89-9503. The Oklahoma Wildlife Federation adopts
in full and incorporates by reference the Brief in
Chief of State of Oklahoma, Oklahoma Dept. of
Pollution Control & Oklahoma Scenic Rivers Com-
mission.
4
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
4/4/89
4/6/89
4/6/89
4/10/89
4/17/89
4/21/89
4/24/89
5/2/89
Response filed by City of Fayetteville in No. 89-
9516, The Beaver Water District in No. 89-9516,
Arkansas Department in No. 89-9516, State of Ar-
kansas in No. 89-9516 to motions to consolidate
appeals in Nos. 89-9507, 89-9503, 89-9516.
Respondent’s motion to dismiss case along with
memorandum in support filed by EPA.
Respondent’s motion to consolidate appeals and
briefing schedules and to stay briefing pending
resolution of jurisdictional issues.
Order filed by RLH granting Respondent’s motion
to consolidate appeals, granting Petitioners’ mo-
tion to consolidate appeals, and granting Peti-
tioners’ motions to extend time to file opening
briefs.
Order filed by RLH deferring Respondent’s motion
to dismiss case to the panel assigned to hear the
case on the merits.
Response filed by State of Oklahoma in No. 89-9516
to Appellee/Respondent motion to dismiss case and
Appellee/Respondent motion to consolidate ap-
peals.
Response filed by Save the Illinois in No. 89-9516
to Respondent motion to dismiss case.
Response filed by Arkansas Department in No. 89-
9503, State of Arkansas in No. 89-9508, The
Beaver Water District in No. 89-9503, City of
Fayetteville in No. 89-9503, City of Fayetteville in
No. 89-9507, Arkansas Department in No. 89-9507,
State of Arkansas in No. 89-9507, The Beaver
Water District in No. 89-9507, City of Fayetteville
in No. 89-9516, The Beaver Water District in No.
89-9516, Arkansas Department in No. 89-9516,
State of Arkansas in No. 89-9516.-
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
5/3/89
5/22/89
5/22/89
6/28/89
6/28/89
8/11/89
8/11/89
8/25/89
9/11/89
Response filed by Arkansas Department in 89-
9503, State of Arkansas in 89-9503, The Beaver
Water in 89-9503, City of Fayetteville in 89-9503,
City of Fayetteville in 89-9507, Arkansas Depart-
ment in 89-9507, State of Arkansas in 89-9507,
The Beaver Water District in 89-9507, EPA in
89-9516, The Beaver Water District in 89-9516,
Arkansas Department in 89-9516, State of Ar-
kansas in 89-9516 to Respondent motion to dismiss
case in 89-9516.
Petitioner’s brief filed by State of Oklahoma in
89-9503, Save the Illinois in 89-9507.
Addendum to brief filed by Petitioner State of
Oklahoma in 89-9503, Intervenor State of Okla-
homa in 89-9507, Petitioner Save the Illinois in
89-9507, Intervenor State of Oklahoma in 89-9516,
Intervenor Save the Illinois in 89-9516.
Brief filed by Petitioner City of Fayetteville in
89-9516, Petitioner The Beaver Water District in
89-9516, Petitioner Arkansas Department in 89-
9516, Petitioner State of Arkansas in 89-9516.
Addendum to brief filed by Petitioner City of
Fayetteville in 89-9516, Petitioner The Beaver
Water District in 89-9516, Petitioner Arkansas
Department in 89-9516, Petitioner State of Ar-
kansas in 89-9516.
Respondent's brief filed by EPA in Nos. 89-9503,
89-9507, and 89-9516.
Addendum to brief filed by Respondent EPA in
Nos. 89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
Agency record filed. Volumes I-XI (ORIGINALS).
Petitioner’s reply brief filed by State of Oklahoma
in 89-9503, Save the Illinois in 89-9507, City of
Fayetteville in 89-9516, The Beaver Water District
in 89-9516, Arkansas Department in 89-9516, State
of Arkansas in 89-9516.
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
9/11/89
9/27/89
1/5/90
2/8/90
2/23/90
2/27/90
3/5/90
7/11/90
8/20/90
Addendum to brief filed by Petitioner State of
Oklahoma in 89-9503, Petitioner Save the Illinois
in 89-9507, Petitioner City of Fayetteville in 89-
9516, Petitioner The Beaver Water District in 89-
9516, Petitioner Arkansas Department in 89-9516,
Petitioner State of Arkansas in 89-9516.
Petitioner’s reply brief filed by State of Oklahoma
in 89-9503, Save the Illinois in 89-9507, City of
Fayetteville in 89-9516, The Beaver Water Dis-
trict in 89-9516, Arkansas Department in 89-9516,
State of Arkansas in 89-9516.
Hearing set for March 1990 Session, at Denver.
Petitioner’s settlement conference report filed.
Motion to enlarge the time for oral argument
filed by State of Arkansas in 89-9503, EPA in
89-9503, State of Oklahoma in 89-9503, State of
Oklahoma in 89-9507, State of Arkansas in 89-
9£07, EPA in 89-9507, State of Oklahoma in 89-
9516, EPA in 89-9516, State of Arkansas in
89-9516.
Order filed by Judge(s) Anderson, Brorby, Theis
granting motion to enlarge time for argument.
Case argued and submitted to Judges Anderson,
Brorby, Theis.
Terminated on the Merits after Oral Hearing;
Petition has been review and we REVERSE EPA’s
decision authorizing Fayetteville’s municipal treat-
ment plant to discharge a portion of its effluent to
the Illinois River basin. Written, Signed, Pub-
lished. Anderson, panel member; Brorby, author-
ing judge and Theis, panel member.
Respondent’s motion to extend time to file petition
for rehearing until 9/10/90 filed by EPA in Nos.
89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
8/21/90
8/22/90
9/6/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
9/10/90
10/11/90
Order filed by RLH granting Respondent motion
to extend time to file petition for rehearing. -
Motion to extend time to file petition for rehearing
until 9/10/90. Filed by Arkansas Department,
State of Arkansas, The Beaver Water District, City
of Fayetteville in Nos. 89-9503,, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Order filed by Judges Anderson, Brorby and Theis
granting motion to extend time to file petition for
rehearing. Petition for rehearing may be filed on
or before 9/10/90.
Motion for leave to leave to file brief of amicus
curiae filed by Arkansas Poultry in 89-9503, 89-
9507, 89-9516.
Joint motion for leave to file amici brief filed by
Associated Indust. and Arkansas Federation in
89-9503, 89-9507 and 89-9516.
Motion for leave to file amicus curiae brief filed
by Arkansas Municipal in 89-9503, 89-9507 and
89-9516.
Petition for rehearing en banc filed by EPA in
89-9503, 89-9507 and 89-9516.
Petitions for rehearing en banc filed by Arkansas
Department in 89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
Petition for rehearing en banc filed by City of
Fayetteville in 89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
Petition for rehearing en banc filed by State of
Arkansas in 89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
Petition for rehearing en banc filed by The Beaver
Water District in 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Amendment to opinion filed by Judge(s) Ander-
son, Brorby, Theis.
8
DATE
-FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
10/11/90
10/11/90
10/16/90
10/19/90
10/23/90
10/23/90
10/24/90
Order filed by Judge(s) Anderson, Brorby, Theis
granting motions of Arkansas Poultry Federation,
Associated Industries of Arkansas, and Arkansas
Federation of Air & Water Users leave to become
amicus in 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Order filed by Judge(s) Holloway, McKay, Logan,
Seymour, Moore, Anderson, Tacha, Baldock,
Brorby, Ebel, Theis denying Petitions for rehear-
ing en banc.
Motion to stay execution of the mandate until
1/11/91 pending filing of a petition for writ of
certiorari filed by Arkansas Department State of
Arkansas, The! Beaver Water District and City of
Fayetteville in 89-9503, 89-9507, and 89-9516.
Response filed by EPA in 89-9503, 89-9507, and
89-9516 to motion to stay execution of the mandate
pending a petition for writ of certiorari.
Response filed by Save the Illinois in 89-9507,
Save the Illinois in 89-9516 motion to stay execu-
tion of the mandate in 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Response filed by State of Oklahoma in 89-9503,
State of Oklahoma in 89-9507, State of Oklahoma
in 89-9516 motion to stay execution of the man-
date until in 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
Reply filed by State of Arkansas in 89-9503, Ar-
kansas Department in 89-9507, State of Arkansas
in 89-9507, Arkansas Federation in 89-9507, Ar-
kansas Municipal in 89-9507, State of Arkansas in
89-9516, Arkansas Poultry in 89-9516, Arkansas
Federation in 89-9516, Arkansas Municipal in 89-
9516 to motion to stay execution of the mandate
until in 89-9503, 89-9507, 89-9516.
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
10/31/90
10/31/90
2/15/91
2/19/91
Order filed by Judges Anderson, Brorby and Theis
granting motion to stay execution of the mandate
until 1/10/91 pending filing of petition for cer-
tiorari, if cert is filed mandate is stayed pending
disposition in Supreme Court in 89-9503, 89-9507,
89-9516.
Amended Affidavit of Shon Simpson filed by Peti-
tioner State of Oklahoma in 89-9503. Intervenor
State of Oklahoma in 89-9507 and 89-9516.
Petition for writ of certiorari filed on 2/8/91 by
Intervenor State of Arkansas in 89-9503, Inter-
venor State of Arkansas in 89-9507, Petitioner
State of Arkansas in 89-9516. Supreme Court
Number 90-1262.
Petition for writ of certiorari filed on 2/8/91 by
Respondent EPA in 89-9503, Respondent EPA in
89-9507, Respondent EPA in 89-9516. Supreme
Court Number 90-1266.
10
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
A. AGENCY ORDERS AND FINDINGS
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
A-1
A-2
A-3
A-4
A-6
A-8
A-9
A-11
A-17
A-20
A-22
A-23
A-26
A-28
A-29
A-32
01-10-86
05-07-86
05-30-86
05-30-86
06-16-86
08-21-86
09-22-86
11-17-86
05-18-87
07-31-87
08-12-87
09-01-87
01-20-88
06-30-88
07-11-88
09-13-88
Letter (partial grant of evidentiary
hearing request) (RA)
Notice of Designation (AJO)
Order (denying review) (AJO)
Correction to Order Denying Review
(AJO)
Designation of ALJ (Chief ALJ)
Order (admitting parties) and Request
for Briefs (ALJ)
Order (in limine) (ALJ)
Order (scheduling) (ALJ)
Order on Motions (summary determina-
tion and dismiss) (ALJ)
Order
(ALJ)
Order (excluding testimony of Dr.
Meyer; allowing supplemental testi-
mony of FAY) (ALJ)
Order (post-hearing briefing schedule)
(ALJ)
Initial Decision (ALJ)
Order on Petitions for Review (ALJ)
(administration of hearing)
—_
Order (briefing) and Motion (for time
extension) (ALJ)
Order Denying Motions for Reconsidera-
tion (A)
11
——— 7 SH
———
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
A-33
A-34
A-35
A-37
09-22-82
10-20-88
10-28-88
11-28-88
Decision on Remand (ALJ)
Letter (suspending swa sponte review
limit) (AJO)
Order on Motion (denying reconsidera-
tion) (ALJ)
Second Order on Petitions for Review
(denying petitions) (AJO)
B. ADMINISTRATIVE PLEADINGS
12-06-85
12-10-85
12-12-85
02-12-86
02-14-86
02-20-86
02-26-86
03-06-86
03-31-86
07-25-86
08-29-86
09-04-86
09-11-86
Request for Evidentiary Hearing (STIR)
Request for Evidentiary Hearing (OK)
Supplemental Request for Evidentiary
Hearing (STIR)
Notice of Appeal (of Partial Denial of
Hearing) (STIR)
Notice of Appeal! and Petition for Review
(OK)
Letter to R. McCallum re: OK Notice of
Appeal (EPA)
Response to STIR Notice of Appeal
(EPA)
Response to OK Petition for Review
(EPA)
Tranmittal of Record to AJO (EPA)
Response to ALJ request for Record
Supplement (EPA)
EPA Response to Order of 8-18-86 (OK
WQS status) (EPA)
Brief (Land Application) (OK)
Reply Brief (Land Application) (EPA)
12
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-25
B-26
09-17-86
09-26-86
01-06-87
01-06-87
01-08-87
01-09-87
01-09-87
01-12-87
01-12-87
01-12-87
01-15-87
01-30-87
02-10-87
02-13-87
02-17-87
02-19-87
Joint Reply Brief (Land Application)
(ARK & FAY)
Ltr. (EPA to ALJ) re: Party Avail-
ability for pre-hearing conference
(EPA)
Production of Documents (FAY)
Production of Documents (OK)
Prefiled Testimony (Cliff Thompson)
(FAY)
Prefiled Testimony
(ARK)
Prefiled Testimony (Silvester Leonard,
Garret Bondy, Larry Champagne,
Ancil Jones) (EPA)
Prefiled Testimony (Jimmy Pigg, Mike
Schornick, William Walker, Jr.) (OK)
Production of Documents (FAY)
Motion for Admission of Evidence (Ar-
kansas River Compact Commission
Order) and Prefiled Testimony
(Stephen Threlkeld) (OWF)
Supplemental Prefiled Testimony (Wa-
ter Quality Survey) (OK)
Index to Permit Record (EPA)
Response to OK Request for Production
(FAY)
Prefiled Rebuttal Testimony
Thompson) (FAY)
Production of Documents (ARK)
Response to Request for Production of
Documents and Information (EPA)
(Robert Blanz)
(Cliff
oe ee we eS
13
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-52
B-53
B-54
B-55
B-56
B-57
B-58
B-59
B-60
B-64
B-65
B-66
B-67
B-68
B-70
B-71
B-72
B-73
B-74
02-20-87
02-23-87
02-23-87
02-23-87
02-25-87
02-25-87
02-25-87
02-26-87
03-02-87
04-02-87
04-03-87
04-07-87
04-07-87
04-10-87
04-10-87
04-20-87
04-20-87
04-21-87
04-21-87
Amended Response to Request for Pro-
duction (ARK)
Transmittal Letter for Prefiled Rebuttal
Testimony (OK)
Prefiled Rebuttal Testimony (Lawrence
Edmison, William Walker, Jr., Mike
Schornick) (OK)
Amendment to Prefiled Testimony (Wil-
liam Walker, Jr.) (OK)
Prefiled Rebuttal Testimony (Jack
Gakstatter) (EPA)
Letter to EPA (IRPA)
Letter to ALJ (IRPA)
Prefiled Rebuttal Testimony (Martin
Maner) (ARK)
Production of Documents (OK)
Request for Hearing Date (OK)
Motion for Summary Determination
(EPA)
Motion to Dismiss (ARK)
Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss
(ARK)
Responsee to Request for Hearing Date
(ARK)
Response to Request for Production of
Documents and Information (ARK)
Objection to Motion to Dismiss (OWF)
Brief in Support of Objection (OWF)
Response to Motion to Dismiss (OK)
Brief in Support of Response (OK)
14
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-75
B-76
B-77
B-78
B-79
B-80
B-81
B-82
B-83
B-84
B-85
B-86
B-87
B-88
B-89
B-90
04-22-87
04-23-87
04-23-87
04-23-87
04-30-87
05-04-87
05-06-87
05-08-87
05-08-87
05-12-87
05-12-87
05-12-87
05-20-87
05-22-87
05-22-87
06-01-87
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(EPA)
Objection to Motion to Dismiss (STIR)
Objection to Motion for Summary Deter-
mination (STIR)
Brief in Support of Objections (STIR)
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(FAY)
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(BWD)
Response to Objection to Motion to Dis-
miss (EPA)
Response to Motion for Summary Deter-
mination (OK)
Brief in Support of Response (OK)
Response to Motion for Summary Deter-
mination (OWF)
Brief in Support of Response (OWF)
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(OWF)
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(STIR)
Notice of Substitution of Witness (Lee
Bohme for Silvester Leonard) (EPA)
Request for Substitution of Witness
(David Neleigh for Myron Knudson)
(EPA)
Notice of Unavailability of Witness and
Motion for Leave to Prefile Testimony
(Robert Blanz) (ARK)
15
-—-— ---
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-91
B-94
B-95
06-08-87
07-14-87
07-14-87
07-20-87
07-27-87
08-06-87
08-07-87
08-11-87
08-17-87
08-28-87
09-23-87
11-09-87
11-10-87
11-13-87
11-13-87
11-16-87
Response to Witness Substitution Re-
quest and Notice of Unavailability
(OK)
Production of Documents (BWD)
Motion for Leave to Supplement Prefiled
Testimony (Luanne Diffin) (FAY)
Motion for Leave to Supplement Prefiled
Testimony (Richard Meyers) (BWD)
Response to Request for Hearing Date
(BWD)
Prefiled Testimony (Richard Meyers)
(BWD)
Objection to Motion for Leave to Supple-
ment Testimony (OK)
Objection to Motion for Leave to Supple-
ment Testimony (STIR)
Response to Objections to Motion for
Leave to Supplement Testimony
(BWD)
Supplement to Hearing Record (EPA)
Supplement to Hearing Record (OK)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (OWF)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (FAY)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (BWD)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (EPA)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (ARK)
16
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-113
B-114
B-115
B-116
B-117
B-118
B-119
B-120
B-121
B-122
B-123
B-124
B-126
B-127
B-128
B-129
B-131
B-132
B-133
11-16-87
11-17-87
12-07-87
12-07-87
12-11-87
12-14-87
12-16-87
12-17-87
12-18-87
02-12-88
02-12-88
02-19-88
02-22-88
02-22-88
03-02-88
03-08-88
03-09-88
03-10-88
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (STIR)
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclu-
sions of Law (OK)
Reply Brief (FAY)
Reply Brief (STIR)
Reply Brief (ARK)
Reply Brief (EPA)
Reply Brief (OK)
Reply Brief (BWD)
Reply Brief (OWF)
Motion for Reconsideration (STIR)
Response to Motion for Reconsideration
(FAY)
Response to Motion for Reconsideration
(ARK)
Notice of Appeal (STIR)
Notice of Appeal and Petition for Review
(OK)
Notice of Appeal and Petition for Review
(OWF)
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (EPA)
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (BWD)
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (ARK, FAY & BWD)
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (EPA)
17
Index + Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-134
B-135
B-136
B-137
B-138
B-139
B-140
B-141
B-142
B-143
B-144
B-145
B-146
B-147
B-148
03-10-88
03-14-88
03-29-88
07-20-88
07-27-88
08-02-88
08-02-88
08-08-88
08-10-88
08-10-88
08-11-88
08-11-88
08-12-88
08-15-88
98-18-88
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (FAY)
Response to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (ARK)
Correction to Notice of Appeal and Peti-
tion for Review (OK)
Brief in Response to Order on Remand
(STIR)
Motion for Extension of Time to File
(Briefs (FAY & BWD)
Motion for Reconsideration (FAY)
Brief in Support of Motion for Recon-
sideration (FAY)
Correction to Brief in Support of Motion
for Reconsideration (FAY)
Brief in Response to Order on Remand
(FAY)
Brief in Response to Order on Remand
(EPA)
Joint Supplemental Brief in Response to
Order on Remand (ARK, FAY &
BWD)
Second Motion for
(STIR)
Reconsideration
Brief in Response to Order on Remand
(OK)
Brief in Response to Order on Remand
(OWF)
Response to Second Motion for Recon-
sideration (OK)
18
Index # Entry Date
Document and Originator
B-149
B-150
B-151
B-152
B-153
B-154
B-155
B-156
B-157
B-158
B-159
B-161
B-162
B-163
B-164
08-18-88
08-18-88
08-19-88
08-29-88
09-07-88
09-29-88
10-25-88
10-25-88
10-25-88
10-26-88
10-26-88
11-17-88
11-17-88
11-17-88
11-17-88
Response to Second Motion for Recon-
sideration (FAY)
Response to Motion for Reconsideration
(STIR)
Objection to Motion for Reconsideration
(OWF)
Response to Motion for Reconsideration
(OK)
Correction to Response (OK)
Motion for Reconsideration (EPA)
Notice of Appeal & Petition for Review
(BWD)
Notice of Appeal & Petition for Review
(STIR)
Notice of Appeal & Petition for Review
(OWF)
Notice of Appeal (EPA)
Notice of Appeal & Petition for Review
(OK)
Joint Response to [EPA] Notice of Ap-
peal (ARK, FAY & BWD)
Brief in Support of Joint Response to
[OK] Notices of Appeals (ARK, FAY
& BWD)
Joint Response to [EPA] Notice of Ap-
peal (ARK, FAY & BWD)
Brief in Support of Joint Response to
[EPA] Notice of Appeal (ARK, FAY
& BWD)
19
C. PROCEEDINGS
Index + Entered Document
C-1 08-18-87 Transcript of Proceedings
08-19-87 Transcript of Proceedings
08-20-87 Transcript of Proceedings
EPA-1 08-18-87 Direct Testimony of Silvester C. Leonard
EPA-2 08-18-87 Direct Testimony of Garrett E. Bondy
EPA-3 08-18-87 Direct Testimony of Larry Champagne
EPA-4 08-18-87 Rebuttal Testimony of Jack H. Gakstat-
ter
EPA-5 08-18-87 Letter dated May 29, 1986, from Law-
rence Edmison to Myron O. Knudson
EPA-6 08-28-87 Letter from Myron Knudson approving
1985 Oklahoma Water Quality Stand-
ards (Supplement to Record)
ARK-1 08-19-87 Rebuttal Testimony of Martin Maner
ARK-2 08-19-87 T. Phos. Data at Talequah (Computer
printout)
ARK-3 08-19-87 Wasteload Evaluation Report
ARK-4 08-19-87 Direct Testimony of Robert E. Blanz
ARK-5 08-20-87 Excerpts from “Water Quality Assess-
ment of the Illinois River Basin, Ar-
kansas”
ARK-6 08-20-87 Administrative Record of Hearing be-
fore the Arkansas-Oklahoma River
Compact Commission
BWD-1 —— Testimony of Dr. Richard L. Meyer
(Proffer Only—Rejected by Order of
ALJ)
BWD-2 —— Rejected—No Proffer (Black & Veatch
Study)
20
Index + Entered
Document
BWD-3
BWD-4
BWD-5
FAY-1
FAY-2
FAY-3
FAY-4
FAY-5
OK-1
OK-2
OK-3
OK-4
OK-5
OK-6
OK-6A
OK-7
OK-8
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-19-87
08-19-87
98-19-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-18-87
08-19-87
08-19-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
08-20-87
U.S.G.S. Topographic Map Copan, Okla-
Kans. Quadrangle
1974 NPDES Permit 0K0020168 (Copan,
Ok.)
1986 NPDES Permit 0K0020168 (Copan,
Ok.)
Industrial Pretreatment Code for the
City of Fayetteville, Arkansas
Direct Testimony of Dr. Cliff Thompson
Rebuttal Testimony of Dr. Cliff Thomp-
son
Letter dated 1/25/84, from Mark S.
Coleman to Mr. Philip B. Lorenz
Memorandum dated August 7, 1986,
From Mr. Quang Pham to Mr. Larry
Edmison
Direct Testimony of Jimmy Pigg
Direct Testimony of Mike Schornick
Rebuttal Testimony of Mike Schornick
Direct Testimony of Lawrence R.
Edmison
Rebuttal Testimony of Lawrence R.
Edmison
Oklahoma’s Water Quality Standards
1985
Oklahoma’s Water Quality Standards
1982
Curriculum Vitae of William W. Walker,
Jr.
Direct Testimony of William W. Walker,
Jr.
a er
21
Index + Entered
Document
OK-9 08-20-87
OK-10 08-20-87
OK-11 08-20-87
OWF-1 08-19-87
OWF-2 08-19-87
Amendment to Direct Testimony of Wil-
liam W. Walker, Jr.
Rebuttal Testimony of William W.
Walker, Jr.
28 Photographs (supplement to record)
Order of the Arkansas River Compact
Commission
Direct Testimony of Dr. Stephen Threl-
keld
22
OKLAHOMA’S
WATER QUALITY STANDARDS
1982
23
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION
TEER SRL Sen ee a
2. ADOPTION AND ENFORCEABILITY OF THE
ETA
3. ANTI-DEGRADATION POLICY ....0000000000000....
4. STANDARDS FOR WATER QUALITY ............
4.1 Public and Private Water Supplies ........
a i eeentene
8 EE
4.1(c) Radioactive Materials ...................
8 FEST
4.1(e) Oil and Grease (Petroleum and
Non-Petroleum Related) ...........
4.2 Emergency Public and Private Water
ET a i
4.3 Fish and Wildlife Propagation ...............
4.3(a) Dissolved Oxygen ........000000000000...
4.3(b) Temperature 2...
4.3(c) pH (Hydrogen lon Activity)......
4.3(d) Oil and Grease (Petroleum and
Non-Petroleum related) ..............
4.3(e) Polychlorinated Biphenyls
A oT.
ts
4.3(g) Diversity of Benthic Macroin-
NE EE Ee a
4.3(h) Toxic Substances ..........000..0.0000.....
4.4 Agriculture (Livestock and Irrigation) ..
4.5 Hydroelectric Power Generation .............
4.6 Industrial and Municipal Process and
a ccuneeneen
4.7 Primary Body Contact Recreation ..........
I
4.8 Secondary Body Contact Recreation........
24
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
Page
SRE ae ERPS A RR NE
EE Ae ee
as rier iteecmdenininanl
AE eR
Oe I iii cia ceccisintiniaietnenionnsamene
4.10(d) Solids (Suspended and/or Set-
SE SON a
4.11 Smallmouth Bass Fisheries (Excluding
ES
4.11(a) Dissolved Oxygen ........................
4.11(b) Temperature ..................................
4.12 Trout Fisheries (Put and Take) ............
4.12(a) Dissolved Oxygen ........................
SRBC) “TOMI nena ncecccccsecceeees+20
5. BENEFICIAL USE LIMITATIONS ......0000000...
6. BENEFICIAL USE DESIGNATIONS FOR
IE eibehaabiariaibchischttinsniinisccndshinensiemenscnconees
EER ee
6.2 Municipal and Domestic ............................
a emenntione
A
Ee
a eumeionstnene
7. MIXING ZONES AND ZONES OF PASSAGE....
yg TE
ee ee cc cesetnenasenneneuns pees
8. TESTING PROCEDURES ..........---cccccccceee---.
9. ERRORS AND SEPARABILITY ...................
10. SUGGESTED BIBLIOGRAPHY ...................
11. WATER QUALITY MANAGEMENT BASINS
TIED setcsesttnaecdicsicasabindnsisibscanbianiasttersesasectansem
25
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
APPENDIX A.
APPENDIX B.
APPENDIX C.
APPENDIX D.
APPENDIX E.
APPENDIX F.
APPENDICES
BENEFICIAL USES OF VARIOUS
STREAM SEGMENTS. .....0WW0WW....
STATISTICAL PARAMETERS OF
THE HISTORICAL DATA FOR
MINERAL COMPONENTS OF
pf Gy eee
DEFINITIONS OF POLLUTION
RELATED TERMS .........................
STREAM INDEX ..............................
WATER QUALITY GOALS
BENEFICIAL USES FOR
GROUNDWATER -IN OKLA-
Page
26
SECTION 1
INTRODUCTION
In the development of water resources in the last cen-
tury, the quality of water developed has often been of
minor consequence. During recent years, however, an
increase in population has resulted in community, indus-
trial and agricultural development, and has caused the
scientific and engineering communities to reassess the
role of water quality and elevate it to a position of
comparable importance with water quantity.
The Oklahoma Water Resources Board’s statutory au-
thority and responsibility concerning water pollution and
its remedies is expressly provided for under 82 O.S. 1981,
$§ 926.1 through 926.13. Under these statutes the Okla-
homa Water Resources Board is required to set water
quality standards which are practical and in the best
public interest and to classify the State’s waters with
respect to their best present and future uses. These
standards are designed to enhance the quality of the
waters, to protect their beneficial uses, and to aid in the
prevention, control and abatement of water pollution in
the State of Oklahoma. Title 82 O.S. 1981, § 926.6(A)
provides that these standards and classifications may be
modified or revised from time to time. Under Public
Law 92-500, Section 303(c)(1) as amended by PL 95-
217, the Governor or the State water pollution control
agency is required to hold public hearings at least once
each three year period for the purpose of reviewing,
and as appropriate, modifying and adopting standards.
The Standards specify numerical and narrative criteria
for specific streams. This is accomplished by determin-
ing which beneficial uses are designated in Appendix A.
Then the numerical and narrative criteria designed to
protect each beneficial use for the stream must be re-
viewed in Section 4. The criteria that apply are the
most stringent of those reviewed for each parameter.
——— ——————
27
Since these criteria will protect the most sensitive use
assigned, they will protect all designated uses.
The purpose of the Standards is to promote and pro-
tect as many beneficial uses as are attainable and to assure
that desradation of existing quality of waters of the
State does not occur. This is accomplished by incorporat-
ing the Standards into the permitting and management
process for all dischargers, and using the Standards to
determine when a beneficial use is threatened. When
standards are exceeded, currently available treatment
technologies for point sources and such best manage-
ment practices as are applicable for nonpoint source pol-
lution should be implemented.
SECTION 2
ADOPTION AND ENFORCEABILITY
OF THE STANDARDS
The 1982 Oklahoma Water Quality Standards as en-
compassed in Section 3 through 9 and Appendices A, B,
C and D, are adopted as Rules and Regulations by the
Oklahoma Water Resources Board pursuant to the Okla-
homa Administrative Procedures Act 75 O.S. 1981, § 301
et. seq. and are fully enforceable under the laws of Okla-
homa. These standards shall apply to all waters of the
State, as defined in 82 O.S. 1981, § 926.1(6).
SECTION 3
ANTI-DEGRADATION POLICY
The intent of the Anti-degradation Policy is to protect
all waters of the State from quality degradation. Ex-
isting instream water uses shall be maintained and pro-
tected. No further water quality degradation which would
interfere with or become injurious to existing instream
water uses shall be allowed. Oklahoma’s waters consti-
tute a valuable State resource and shall be protected,
maintained and improved for the benefit of all the
citizens.
28
It is recognized that certain waters of the State possess
an existing water quality which exceeds those levels nec-
essary to support propagation of fish, shellfish, wildlife,
and recreation in and on the water. These high quality
waters shall be maintained and protected unless the
State decides, after full satisfaction of the intergovern-
mental coordination, and public participation provisions
of the State’s continuing planning process, to allow
lower water quality as a result of necessary and justi-
fiable economic or social development. Furthermore,
where limited degradation is justified, the State shall
require that any new point source of pollution or in-
creased load from an existing point source, protect all
existing and attainable beneficial uses through the high-
est statutory and regulatory requirements, and feasible
management or regulatory programs pursuant to Section
208 of Public Law 92-500 as amended by PL —— for
nonpoint sources.
No degradation shall be allowed in high quality waters
which constitute an outstanding resource or in waters
of exceptional recreational or ecological significance.
These include water bodies located in National and State
parks, Wildlife Refuges, and those designated “Scenic
Rivers” in Appendix A.
As the quality of Oklahoma waters improves, no deg-
radation of such improved waters shall be allowed. When
the yearly mean standard for a specific parameter de-
creases to the point where the goals listed in Appendix
E become attainable, degradation will be prohibited by
incorporating the goal as a standard.
In those cases where potential water quality impair-
ment associated with a thermal discharge is involved,
the anti-degradation policy and implementation method
shall be consistent with Section 316 of Public Law 92-500
as amended by PL 95-217,
29
SECTION 4
STANDARDS FOR WATER QUALITY
Title 82 O.S. 1981, § 926.2, provides as follows:
“Whereas the pollution of the waters of this state
constitute a menace to public health and welfare,
creates public nuisances, is harmful to wildlife, fish
and aquatic life, and impairs domestic, agricultural,
industrial, recreational and other legitimate bene-
ficiai uses of water, and whereas the problem of
water pollution of this state is closely related to the
problem of water pollution in adjoining states, it
is hereby declared tu be the public policy of this state
to conserve the waters of the state and to protect,
maintain and improve the quality thereof for public
water supplies, for propagation of wildlife, fish and
aquatic life and for domestic, industrial, recreational,
and other legitimate beneficial uses; to provide that
no waste be discharged into any waters of the state
without first being given the degree of treatment
necessary to protect the legitimate beneficial uses of
such waters; to provide for the prevention, abate-
ment and control of new or existing water pollu-
tion. . .”
Beneficial uses are designated for all of Oklahoma’s
waters and are protected through the restrictions imposed
by the narrative and numerical standards. Some uses
require higher quality water than others. When multiple
uses are assigned to the same waters, all such uses shall
be protected. Beneficial uses will also be protected by
permits issued in accordance with requirements of cur-
rent water quality standards and through practical man-
agement or regulatory programs for nonpoint sources.
The present beneficial uses designated by these standards
to certain waters of the state are;
Section 4.1 Public and Private Water Supplies
Section 4.2 Emergency Public and Private Water
Supplies
Section 4.3 Fish and Wildlife Propagation
Section 4.4 Agriculture
Section 4.5 Hydroelectric Power Generation
Section 4.6 Industrial and Municipal Process and
Cooling Water
Section 4.7 Primary Body Contact Recreation
Section 4.8 Secondary Body Contact Recreation
Section 4.9 Navigation
Section 4.10 Aesthetics
Section 4.11 Smallmouth Bass Fisheries (Excluding
Lake Waters)
Section 4.12 Trout Fisheries (Put and Take)
The numerical standards for perennial streams shall be
maintained any time the flow equals or exceeds the seven-
day, two-year low flow value. In intermittent streams, .
the numerical standards shall be maintained when the
ambient stream flow is at or greater than 1.0 cfs. Fur-
thermore, at such time as numerical limits do not apply,
instream conditions, including dissolved oxygen concen-
tration shall be maintained to prevent nuisance condi-
tions caused by man’s activities. Narrative standards
[Section 4.3(d), 4.3(h) (1), 4.4, 4.10(¢), 4.10(d), and
4.10(e)] shall be maintained at all times and apply to
all perennial and intermittent streams. The narrative
and numerical standard assigned to a stream is the most
stringent required to protect all the beneficial uses desig-
nated for that stream.
The control measures for other substances not men-
tioned in these standards will be based on applicable
31
Federal and State statutes, rules and regulations and
accumulated scientific data on limits above which injury
from use occurs. Such control measures when adopted
pursuant to 75 O.S. 1981, § 301 et seq. will become a part
of these standards.
4.1 PUBLIC AND PRIVATE WATER SUPPLIES
The quality of the waters of the State shall-be pro-
tected, maintained and improved, when feasible, so that
they can be used as a source of public and private raw
water supplies.
Drinking water standards dictate the quality of water
that should be achieved in a municipal water distribution
system without reference to desirable raw water quality.
Although it is possible to renovate highly polluted surface
waters to these standards, the process required would be
both complex and expensive. Raw water quality criteria
have been developed to aid in the selection of water
sources so that the water supply chosen can, by com-
monly proven applied treatment processes, achieve the
drinking water standards, all within reasonable economic
limits.
4.1(a) TOXIC LIMITS
The waters of the State shall be maintained so
they will not be toxic to humans. With specific refer-
ence to streams and lakes designated as Public and
Private Water Supplies, the following numerical lim-
its of contaminants shall not be exceeded.
RAW WATER NUMERICAL LIMITS
PARAMETERS NUMERICAL LIMIT (mg/L)
Inorganic Elements:
Arsenic 10
Barium 1.0
Cadmium .02
Chromium 0.05
Copper 1.0
Cyanide 0.2
Fluoride (at 90°F) 1.6
Lead 10
Mercury 0.002
Nitrates (as N) 10.0
Selenium 0.01
Silver 0.05
Zinc 5.0
Organic Chemicals:
Benzidine 0.001
Detergents (total) 0.2
Methylene blue active substances 0.5
Phthalate esters 0.003
2,4-D 0.1
2,4,5-TP Silvex 0.01
Endrin 0.0002
Lindane 0.004
Methoxychlor 0.1
Toxaphene 0.005
4.1(b) PESTICIDES
Pesticides shall not be present in such concentra-
tions as to cause the waters of the State to be toxic
or carcinogenic to human, animal, plant or aquatic
life.
The application of 2,4,5-T for currently approved
uses (rangeland and rice), in the proper manner at
the approved application rate may result in instream
33
concentrations in excess of 0.01 mg/L. Therefore,
temporary excursions not to exceed 0.1 mg/L will be
allowed in the event unforeseen rainfall events occur
within 24-hours after application.
4.1(c) RADIOACTIVE MATERIALS
There shall be no discharge of radioactive mate-
rials in excess of the limits found in Oklahoma Radia-
tion Protection Regulations, 1969, or its latest
revision. ,
The concentration of gross alpha shall not exceed
the specified limit or the naturally occurring con-
centration, whichever is higher. .
The combined dissolved concentration of Radium-
226 and Radium-228, and Strontium-90, shall not
exceed 5 picocuries/liter, and 8 picocuries/liter, re-
spectively. Gross alpha particle concentrations, in-
cluding Radium-226 but excluding radon and ura-
nium, shall not exceed 15 picocuries/liter. The gross
beta concentration shall not exceed 50 picocuries/
liter. The average annual concentration of beta par-
ticle and photon radioactivity from man-made radio-
nuclides in drinking water shall not produce an
annual dose equivalent to the total body or any
internal organ greater than 4 millirem/year.
4.1(d) COLIFORM
The bacteria of the fecal coliform group shall not
exceed a monthly geometric mean of 200/100 ml at a
point of intake for a public or private water supply.
The geometric mean will be determined by multiple
tube fermentation or membrane filter procedures
based on a minimum of not less than five (5) samples
taken over not more than a thirty (30) day period.
Further, in no more than 10% of the total samples
during any thirty (30) day period shall the bacteria
of the fecal coliform group exceed 400/100 ml.
34
4.1(e) OIL AND GREASE (PETROLEUM AND
NON-PETROLEUM RELATED)
For public and Private Water Supplies, the water
shall be maintained free from oil and grease and
taste and odors that emanate from petroleum
products.
4.2 EMERGENCY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE WATER
SUPPLIES
During emergencies, those waters designated Emer-
gency Public and Private Water Supplies may be put to
use. Each emergency will be handled on a case by case
basis, and be thoroughly evaluated by the appropriate
State agencies and/or local health authorities.
4.3 FISH AND WILDLIFE PROPAGATION
There are no generalized water quality standards ap-
licable for all kinds of fish and wildlife. Generally, un-
polluted waters support a more diverse aquatic commu-
nity while only tolerant species can survive in compara-
tively polluted waters. In addition, waters of diverse
habitat will exhibit more species than waters with lim-
ited habitat variation. The impact of a given chemical
or physical constitutent on a biological community is not
mutually exclusive of other constituents since synergistic
interactions are common. The following Narrative and
Numerical Standards are designated to promote fish and
wildlife propagation.
4.3(a) DISSOLVED OXYGEN
Two dissolved oxygen (DO) standards are de-
signed to protect the diverse warm water fisheries
of Oklahoma. Streams designated as Primary Warm
Water Fisheries are required at all times to meet a
minimum dissolved oxygen of 5.0 mg/L. Streams des-
ignated as Secondary Warm Water Fisheries are re-
quired at all times to meet a minimum dissolved
oxygen of 3.0 mg/L.
i A pay.
35
Allowable loadings designed to attain these criteria
shall be calculated at the low flow value and critical
temperature as defined in Appendix C.
4.3(b) TEMPERATURE
At no time shall heat be added to any stream in
excess of the amount that will raise the temperature
of the receiving water more than 5°F. In streams,
temperature determinations shall be made by aver-
aging representative temperature measurements of
the cross sectional area of streams at the end of the
mixing zone.
In lakes, the temperature of the water column
and/or epilimnion, if thermal stratification exists,
shall not be raised more than 3°F_ above that which
existed before the addition of heat of artificial origin,
based upon the average of temperatures taken from
the surface to the bottom or surface to the bottom of
the epilimnion, if stratified.
The normal daily and seasonal variations that
were present before the addition of heat from other
than natural sources shall be maintained. The maxi-
mum temperature due to man-made causes shall not
exceed 90°F in warm water streams and lakes except
in the segment of Arkansas River from Red Rock
Creek to the headwaters of Keystone Reservoir where
maximum temperature shall not exceed 94°F.
No artificial heat shall be added such that the
receiving water temperature exceeds the maximums
specified above.
Privately owned lakes and reservoirs used in the
process of cooling water for industrial purposes, are
not classified as waters of the State, (See Appendix
C) and are exempt from these temperature restric-
tions, provided the water released from any such
lake or reservoir into a stream system shall meet
the water quality standards of the receiving stream.
36
4.3(¢) pH (HYDROGEN ION ACTIVITY)
The pH values shall be between 6.5 and 9.0 for
Oklahoma’s water; unless pH values outside that
range are due to natural conditions.
4.3(d) OIL AND GREASE (PETROLEUM AND
NON-PETROLEUM RELATED
All waters of the State shall be maintained free
of oil and grease to prevent a visible film of oil or
globules of oil or grease on or in the water. Oil and
grease shall not be present in quantities that adhere
to stream banks and coat bottoms of water courses
or which cause deleterious effects to the biota.
4.3(e) POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS
(PCBs)
Although PCBs may occur in low concentrations
in the water column, these toxic chemicals may ac-
cumulate in bottom sediments and tissues of aquatic
organisms. Therefore, sediment and tissue analyses
should routinely be used to complement water anal-
yses. The instream concentration of PCBs shall not
exceed 0.3 micrograms per liter for the waters of the
state. When water concentrations are less than 0.3
micrograms per liter, a fish tissue level in excess of
2.0 milligrams per kilogram shall be cause for con-
cern and further investigation.
-4.3(f) PESTICIDES
Pesticides shall not be present in such concentra-
tions as to cause the waters of the State to be toxic
or carcenogenic to human, animal, plant or aquatic
life. The instream concentrations of pesticides shall
not exceed the numerical limits provided for the
waters of the State.
:
-
:
a
37
PESTICIDE STANDARDS IN THE
WATER COLUMN FOR THE PROTECTION
OF FISH AND WILDLIFE PROPAGATION
PARAMETERS NUMERICAL LIMIT (ug/L)
Aldrin, Dieldrin 1.0
Chlordane 20.0
DDT 0.2
Endosulfan 0.2
Endrin 0.2
Heptachlor 0.5
Lindane 2.0
Toxaphene 1.0
2,4,5-TP Silvex 10.0
Although pesticides can occur in low concentra-
tions in the water column, they may accumulate in
bottom sediments and tissues of aquatic organisms.
Therefore, sediment and tissue analyses should rou-
tinely be used to complement water analyses. Fish
tissue levels in excess of the following alert levels
shall be cause for concern and further investigation.
PESTICIDE ALERT LEVELS IN FISH TISSUE
PARAMETERS ALERT LEVELS (mg/kg)
Alrin/Dieldrin 0.3
Chlordane 0.3
DDT 5.0
Endrin 0.3
Heptachlor 0.3
Toxaphene 5.0
4.3(g) DIVERSITY OF BENTHIC
MACROINVERTEBRATES
The decrease in diversity of benthic macroinverte-
brates between an upstream and downstream station,
(or downstream before and after discharge from a
pollution source) shall not exceed one (1), unless
caused by natural conditions or phenomena. The de-
38
termination of this parameter shall be made in con-
junction with the Similarity Index.
The equation used for determining species divers-
ity (d) is expressed :
d—s (n:/n) log, (n:/n)
{ = j.,
Where (s) equals the total number of taxa in the
sample; (n,) equals the number of individuals per
taxon; and (n) equals the total number of individ-
uals of all taxa.
For point sources, a minimum set of six(6) sam-
ples must be collected above the discharge point and
six (6) samples at the end of the mixing zone; or, if
upstream sampling is not applicable, then sampling
must be made at the end of the mixing zone (Section
7) before and after commencement of discharge.
Samples should be collected from a variety of sub-
strate types-+f-available, but similar substrates must
be sampled above and below the discharge. Values
of diversity shall not be based on less than one hun-
dred (100) individuals per sample.
Benthos shall be collected with a Surber sampler,
Ekman Aredge, or comparable sampler. In streams
where grab samples do not accurately reflect the
benthic assemblage, the artificial substrate sampler
shall be used. Artificial substrate samplers shall be
of the Hester-Dendy or basket type. A minimum
instream duration of six (6) weeks shall be allowed
for colonization of artificial substrate samplers.
Where multiple discharges are in close proximity
on the stream segment and overlapping of mixing
zones occurs, diversity values may be used only in
support of other data collected to determine compli-
ance with these standards.
;
j
:
:
:
/
,
39
4.3(h) TOXIC SUBSTANCES
(1)
(2)
The waters of the State shall be maintained so
that they will not be toxic to fish and other ter-
restrial and aquatic life. Toxic substances in
waters of the State shall not be present in quan-
tities which allow significant bioaccumulation
and/or biomagnification in the food chain.
Selection of appropriate concentration limits
will insure the continued propagation of fish and
wildlife in and around Oklahoma’s streams.
Aside from the aesthetic qualities of fish and
wildlife, it should be realized that the health of
these populations of organisms can act as an
index which reflects overall environmental wel-
fare and potential health of neighboring human
populations.
Assigning concentration limits for the Fish
and Wildlife Propagation beneficial use is very
complex. Limits are generally assigned based
upon laboratory bioassay work designed to de-
termine the 96-hour LC,, for a_ particular
aquatic species. There are several physical,
chemical and biological problems which arise
when attempts are made to develop water qual-
ity standards based upon single maximum con-
centration values. For this reason numerical
concentration limits are developed in this sec-
tion for specified toxics. For toxics not specified,
or where data is not available in the following
table, concentrations for nonpersistent toxic
substances shall not exceed 0.1 of the 96-hour
LC,, for sensitive indigenous species. ° Concen-
trations of persistent toxicants shall not exceed
0.05 of the 96-hour LC.,,, for sensitive indige-
nous species. Concentrations of bioaccumulative
toxicants shall not exceed 0.01 of the 96-hour
LC,, for sensitive indigenous species. Bioassay
40
data for Pimephales promelas ( Fathead min-
now) and/or Lepomis macrochirus ( Bluegill )
shall be used in determining compliance with the
above standards.
There are several other criteria besides LC,,
data by which standards to protect fish and
wildlife propagation may be obtained. The lab-
oratory detection limit must be considered. The
EPA and Water Quality Management Plan rec-
ommended values must be considered. A meth-
odology incorporating all of these criteria was
used to produce the segment specific standards
presented below which are measured as the total
recoverable metals in the water column.
[Table with specific values omitted in printing
Joint Appendix]
4.4 AGRICULTURE (LIVESTOCK AND IRRIGATION )
Proper water quality is essential for irrigation of
crops and livestock consumption. The waters of the State
shall be maintained so that toxicity does not inhibit con-
tinued ingestion by livestock or irrigation of crops. Ex-
cessive concentrations of minerals in irrigation water
result in damage to crops and produce undesirable soi]
conditions. High salinity water should be used with best
management practices as outlined in “Diagnosis and
Reclamation of Saline Soils,” United States Department
of Agriculture Handbook #60, 1958.
The intake of highly mineralized water by animals
yan cause physiological disturbances of varying degrees.
Lactation and reproduction are disturbed by continuous
use of water of unfavorable mineral composition. In
some cases, particular ions within total Salinity such as
nitrate, fluoride, selenium sales and molybdenum may
be harmful to livestock.
Sufficient supplies of good quality water have always
been critically important in all forms of agricultural
renee
41
enterprise. Because of the vast number of agricultural
uses made of water, this beneficial use is assigned to all
Oklahoma streams. It is recognized, however, that many
streams are less suitable for irrigation purposes than
others. The classification set forth herein is intended
only as a guide in allocating this beneficial use, not in
limiting the allowable levels for a stream.
Class Suitability Salt Conc. (mg/L)
I suitable under almost all under 700
conditions
II suitably dependent on @ 700-2,100
crop, soil, climate, etc.
III unsuitable under most over 2,100
conditions
* Estimated as equivalent to total dissolved solids.
These guidelines are applied to the irrigation bene-
ficial use designation for the yearly mean standard of
the dissolved solid concentration in Oklahoma streams.
The resulting beneficial use designations are displayed
in Appendix A.
For the watering of livestock the limits of tolerance
vary depending on the species of animal, kind of salt
present, climate, etc. “Safe upper limits” vary from
2,860 mg/L for poultry to 15,600 mg/L for sheep. For
temporary use, sheep can tolerate up to 18,600 mg/L.
Therefore, no absolute limitation for this beneficial use
is appropriate.
For chlorides, sulfates and total dissolved solids, the
arithmetic mean of the concentration of the samples
taken for a year in a particular segment shall not
exceed the historical “‘yearly mean standard” (see Ap-
pendices B and C) generated in that segment. Further-
more, not more than one (1) in twenty (20) samples
randomly collected shall exceed the historical value of
the “sample standard” generated in that segment. In-
creased mineralization from other elements such as cal-
cium, magnesium, sodium and their associated anions,
42
ete., shall ©. maintained at or below a level that will
not restrict any beneficial use.
Historical data are available, only for sparsely dis-
tributed sampling stations. Therefore, the data in each
segment are averaged, and mean chloride, sulfate, and
TDS are presented in Appendix B. It is anticipated that
as sources of pollution are identified and adequately
addressed, the mineral concentrations may decrease over
a period of time. Due to the limited data, base it can
only be assumed that water within a segment is homoge-
neous. As more data becomes available, subsegmentg.may
be delineated if they differ from the remainder of the
segment. In assigning permit limitations based on water
quality standards for total dissolved solids, sulfates or
chlorides interpolation between monitoring stations will
be acceptable where appropriate.
4.5 HYDROELECTRIC POWER GENERATION
This beneficial use is not generally dependent upon
water quality.
4.6 INDUSTRIAL AND MUNICIPAL PROCESS AND
COOLING WATER
Quality criteria for water used for process or cooling
purposes vary with the type of industrial or municipal
processes involved. This use will be protected by applica-
tion of the criteria for other beneficial uses.
4.7 PRIMARY BODY CONTACT RECREATION
Primary Body Contact Recreation involves direct body
contact with the water where a possibility of ingestion
exists. In these cases the water shall not contain chem-
ical, physical or biological substances in concentrations
that are irritating to skin or sense organs or are toxic
or cause illness upon ingestion by human beings.
43
4.7(a) COLIFORM
In waters designed for Primary Body Contact Rec-
reation the following limit for fecal coliform bac-
teria shall apply only during the recreation period
of May 1 to October 1. The standards for Secondary
Body Contact Recreation will apply during the re-
mainder of the year.
The bacteria of the fecal coliform group shall
not exceed a monthly geometric means of 200/100
ml, as determined by multiple tube fermentation or
membrane filter procedures based on a minimum of
not less than five (5) samples taken over not more
than a thirty (30) day period. Further, in no more
than 10% of the total samples during any thirty
(30) day period shall the bacteria of the fecal coli-
form group exceed 400/100 ml.
4.8 SECONDARY BODY CONTACT RECREATION
The water quality requirements for Secondary Body
Contact Recreation are usually not as stringent as for
Primary Body Contact Recreation. Secondary body con-
tact recreational activities include boating, fishing, wad-
ing or other activities where ingestion of water is not
anticipated. Waters shall be maintained to be free from
human pathogens in numbers which may produce adverse
health effects.
4.9 NAVIGATION
This beneficial use is generally more dependent on
water quantity than water quality.
4.10 AESTHETICS
To be aesthetically enjoyable, the waters of the State
must be free from floating materials and suspended sub-
stances that produce objectionable color and turbidity.
The waters must be free from noxious odors and tastes,
*
44
and from materials that settle to form objectionable de-
posits, and discharges that produce undesirable or nui-
sance aquatic life.
4.10(a) COLOR
Waters of the State shall be virtually free from all
coloring materials which produce an aesthetically
unpleasant appearance. Color producing substances,
from other than natural sources, shall be limited to
concentrations equivalent to 70 color units (CU).
4.10(b) TURBIDITY
Turbidity from other than natural sources shall be
restricted to not exceed the following numerical
limits:
1. Warm Water Streams .. 50 Nephelometric Turbidity Units
2. Warm Water Lakes .... 25 Nephelometric Turbidity Units
3. Cold Water Streams .... 10 Nephelometric Turbidity Units
(Those designated as smallmouth bass fisheries
or trout fisheries)
In waters where background turbidity exceeds
these values, turbidity from point sources shall be
restricted to not exceed ambient levels. Unless due
to purely natural or non-man induced conditions the
turbidity levels may reasonably be expected to de-
crease as management of man induced nonpoint
sources occur.
These numbers apply to normal stream flow con-
ditions with turbidity levels up to seven days after a
high flow event to be decided on a case by case basis.
4.10(¢c) NUTRIENTS
The total phosphorous concentration and the nitro-
gen/phosphorous concentration ratio shall not be in-
creased to levels which result in man induced ev-
trophication problems.
+
iat a il
45
4.10(d) SOLIDS (SUSPENDED AND/OR
SETTLEABLE)
The waters of the State shall be maintained so as
to be essentially free of floating debris, bottom de-
posits, scum, foam and other materials, including
suspended substances of a persistent nature, from
other than a natural source.
4.10(e) TASTE AND ODOR
Taste and odor producing substances from other
than natural origin shall be limited to concentra-
tions that will not interfere with the production of
a potable water supply by modern treatment methods
or produce abnorma! flavors, colors, tastes and odors
in fish flesh or other edible wildlife or result in of-
fensive odors in:the vicinity of the water, or other-
wise interfere with beneficial uses.
4.11 SMALLMOUTH BASS FISHERIES (EXCLUDING
LAKE WATERS)
Water which will support smallmouth bass fisheries is
characterized by a lower temperature and higher dis-
solved oxygen concentration. The presence of smallmouth
bass generally indicates clean water conditions. Numer-
ical standards shall be maintained at all times in small-
mouth bass fisheries.
4.11(a) DISSOLVED OXYGEN
The dissolved oxygen concentration shall not be
less than 6.0 mg/L for those waters designated as
smallmouth bass fisheries.
It is recognized that diurnal fluctuations of dis-
solved oxygen occur in natural aquatic systems due
to primary production and respiration processes. Due
to natural fluctuations, a 1.0 mg/L dissolved oxygen
concentration deficit shall be allowed for not more
than eight (8) hour's during any twenty-four (24)
hour period.
46
4.11(b) TEMPERATURE
The normal daily and seasonal variations that
were present before the addition of heat from other
than natural sources shall be maintained. The maxi-
mum temperature due to man-made causes shall not
exceed 84°F in smallmouth bass streams.
4.12 TROUT FISHERIES (PUT AND TAKE)
The maintenance of trout fisheries (put and take)
generally requires cool and high quality waters. A higher
dissolved oxygen concentration is required for this bene-
ficial use than for warm water fisheries. Numerical
standards shall be maintained at all times in trout
fisheries.
4.12(a) DISSOLVED OXYGEN
The dissolved oxygen concentration shall not be
less than 6.0 mg/L for those waters designated as
trout fisheries. Due to natural fluctuations, a 1.0 mg/L
dissolved oxygen concentration deficit shall be allowed
for not more than eight (8) hours during any
twenty-four (24) hour period.
4.12(b) TEMPERATURE
The normal daily and seasonal variations that
were present before the addition of heat from other
than natural sources shall be maintained. The maxi-
mum temperature due to man-made causes shal] not
exceed 68°F in trout streams.
SECTION 5
BENEFICIAL USE LIMITATIONS
All streams and bodies of water designated as (a)
are protected by prohibition of any new point source
discharge of wastes or increased load from an existing
point source except under conditions described in Sec-
tion 3.
47
All streams designated by the State as “scenic river
areas,” and such tributaries of those streams as may be
appropriate will be so designated. Best management
practices for control of nonpoint source discharge should
be initiated when feasible.
SECTION 6
BENEFICIAL USE DESIGNATIONS FOR
GROUNDWATER
Waters are classified according to the uses for which
they are suited. Waters of the State include both surface
and groundwater. Existing groundwater beneficial uses
shall be protected from degradation. The maximum total
dissolved solids concentration which shall be allowed is
5,000 mg/L. Where multiple uses are assigned to a
groundwater basin (see definition: Groundwater Basin)
all such uses shall be protected. At this time data is
available and uses have been assigned to the twenty-one
major basins shown in Appendix F. The data base for
groundwater quality and quantity is insufficient to assign
beneficial uses to Oklahoma’s minor groundwater basins.
It is anticipated that more data will be collected and
compiled in the near future. At that time groundwater
use classifications for the remaining basins will be added.
The following beneficial use classifications are assigned
to Oklahoma’s major basins as shown in Appendix F.
CLASSIFICATIONS
Irrigation
Municipal and Domestic
Industrial
Recreation
Commercial
Fish and Wildlife
Pe ge pe
48
6.1 IRRIGATION
These are groundwaters suitable for irrigation of crops
usually grown in Oklahoma. Highly mineralized ground-
waters can damage crops and cause undesirable soil con-
ditions. High salinity groundwaters should only be used
in accordance with Best Management Practices such as
those outlined in “Diagnosis and Reclamation of Saline
Soils,” U.S. Department of Agriculture Handbook, #60,
1958.
6.2 MUNICIPAL AND DOMESTIC
These waters are suitable for potable water supplies
and include waters used for housing development and
multiple-unit domestic use. Class I waters are uncon-
taminated and Class II waters require disinfection.
There may be waters which do not fit into either the
Class I or Class II classifications but which may be suit-
able for domestic_water supply use after special treat-
ment.
(a) Class I—Uncontaminated Groundwaters:
These are groundwaters which receive a high de-
gree of natural protection and meet, without treat-
ment, all Oklahoma drinking water regulations.
(b) Class II—Waters Requiring Disinfection:
These are groundwaters which, after receiving
approved disinfection such as simple chlorination or
its equivalent will* meet Oklahoma drinking water
regulations.
-”
6.3 INDUSTRIAL
industrial use is the use of groundwater in processes
designed to convert materials of a lower order of value
into forms having greater useability and commercial
value, including water necessary for the development of
electric power and drilling of oil and gas wells.
49
Quality criteria for water used for cooling purposes
vary with the type of industrial processes involved. This
use will be protected by application of the Water Quality
Standards.
6.4 RECREATION
These are groundwaters pumped to the surface to use
for swimming, fishing, hunting, or other forms of water
recreation.
6.6 COMMERCIAL
Commercial use includes but is not limited to water
for laundries, cafes, motels, institutions, rural water
districts, feed yards, food processing, and sale of ground-
water by a permit holder.
6.6 FISH AND WILDLIFE
Includes groundwater pumped to the surface to be
used for propagation of fish and wildlife.
SECTION 7
MIXING ZONES AND ZONES OF PASSAGE
7.1 MIXING ZONES
When a liquid of different quality than the receiving
water is discharged to an aquatic system, a mixing
zone is formed. The concept of mixing zone is recog-
nized as a necessary element of Oklahoma’s Water Qual-
ity Standards. In the case of perennial streams, the
mixing zone extends downstream a distance equivalent to
thirteen (13) times the width of the water at the point
of effluent discharge. The concentration of toxic sub-
stances in a mixing zone shall not exceed the 96-hour
LC,, for sensitive indigenous species. Mixing zones in
lakes and intermittent streams shall be designated on a
case by case basis. It is recognized that the water quality
50
in the mixing zone may be unsuitable for certain bene-
ficial uses. Where overlapping mixing zones due to mul-
tiple outfalls occur, the total length of the mixing zone
will extend thirteen stream widths from the downstream
discharge.
7.2 ZONES OF PASSAGE
All discharges shall be regulated to insure that at the
outfall and throughout the mixing zone, a zone of pass-
age shall be maintained within the stream that shall be
no less than seventy-five percent (75%) of the cross-
sectional area or flow volume, whichever is more benefi-
cial to the free-swimming and drifting organisms. Water
quality standards shall be maintained throughout the zone
of passage. Zones of passage in lakes and intermittent
streams shall be designated on a case by case basis.
SECTION 8
TESTING PROCEDURES
All methods of sample collection, preservation, and an-
alysis used in applying any of the rules and regulations
in these standards shall be in accordance with those pre-
scribed in “Standard Methods For The Examination of
Water and Wastewater,” Fifteenth Edition, or any sub-
sequent edition, “Methods for Chemical Analysis of Water
and Waste” and “Methods for Benzidine, Chlorinated
Organic Compounds, Pentachlorophenol and Pesticides in
Water and Waste Water,” or other generally accepted
procedure approved by the Oklahoma Water Resources
Board.
SECTION 9
ERRORS AND SEPARABILITY
Errors resulting from inadequate and erroneous data,
human or clerical oversight will be subject to correc-
tion by the Oklahoma Water Resources Board. The dis-
51
covery of such errors does not render the remaining
and unaffected standards invalid.
If any provision of these standards, or the application
of any provision of these standards to any person or
circumstances is held to be invalid, the application of
such provisions to other persons and circumstances and
the remainder of the standards shall not be affected
thereby.
52
APPENDIX A
BENEFICIAL USES OF VARIOUS STREAM
SEGMENTS
The following portions of Section 4, Standards for
Water Quality, will apply to those streams not listed in
this appendix: 4.3(d), 4.3(h) (1), 4.4, 4.10(a), 4.10(c),
4.10(d), and 4.10(e).
The concept of goals is incorporated in the beneficial
use designations. A goal represents a beneficial use
which may be attained at some future time. Attainment
is based upon several factors, including reduction of
natural sources, advances in treatment technologies for
point sources, and further implementation of best man-
agement practices to control nonpoint sources.
Beneficial uses are assigned to specific streams in this
appendix.
An asterisk (*) designates those streams in which
further revisions are pending. These are streams for
which it is determined that detailed study and analysis
is required prior to major revisions to the designated
beneficial uses. For these streams the current uses will
remain in effect and administrative procedures will be
utilized to improve the streams to the maximum extent
possible. Each stream will receive a detailed study and
review prior to the 1985 review of the standards.
This group is composed of two categories:
1. Those streams for which biological review did
not reveal a clear understanding of the character
of the stream.
2. Those streams for which a great amount of pub-
lie concern has been expressed and which addi-
tional study and evaluation is needed to clarify
the socio-economic desires for additional waste
treatment.
53
A triangle (A) designates those streams where a liter-
ature survey indicates the need for a re-evaluation of
assigned beneficial uses, but where the biological review
has not yet been accomplished.
In addition to the above there are many streams which
will require additional study but have not yet been
identified.
| Maps Omitted In Printing]
WYO. Basin No. 1, Sheet 1
HE NETICTAL USt COMMS
® Ponte oes ‘ we tt
CY Peebles eters op gered fave thee cr centerree aes oo eennee ont «od oboe Be ont fb vs De ant ,
we heeee debeeteey capecety es caffe ncnet
1 Premary worm woter fechery
2 Sor omebony “warm water fashve ty anth pPrimory “worm wiiter fastye Se ee gow
Y Clhace P erregation
4 Clowes UE verigateon with clase TE eergation as a goal f natural condinons perme
SC hase TD peregottom wath clase Teneganen as a goal f natural Conditions permit
STREAM ORDER STR
Bek x Ft SEG)
:
ARKANSAS RIVER from mouth of Canadian River to the 12¢
mouth of the Verdigris including Webhers Falls Reservoir
Dirty Creek 12¢
Lower ILLINOIS RIVER from headwaters of Robert S. Kerr 121
Reservoir to Tenkiller Dam
Upper ILLINOIS RIVER from Tenkiller Dam, including 121
Tenkiller Reservoir, to 650 foot elevation level
Caney Creek 121
BARREN FORK to Hwy 5° 121
Tyner Creck 121
Court House Creek 121
Ben Knight Creek 121
BARREN FORK, Hwy 59 to Arkansas State Line 121
Shell Branch 121
Evansville Creek Pa
Upper ILLINOIS RIVER ahove 650 foot elevation level 121
Flint Creek 121
Ballard Creek 121
GREENLEAF CREEK including Greenleaf Lake 120
WENEBRICIAL USES
¥
<
Z
NN Sa, ~
Say
PS ~~
<S
DS
Ss;
ONO
Scenic River
Scenic River
Scenic River
BEST AVAILABLE COPY
55
APPENDIX C
DEFINITIONS OF POLLUTION
RELATED TERMS
ABATEMENT
Reduction of the degree or intensity of pollution.
ALLOWABLE LOAD
For perennial streams—the allowable load for oxy-
gen demanding substances shall be based on attain-
ing an instream DO of 5.0 mg/L for primary warm
water fisheries, 3.0 mg/L for secondary warm water
fisheries, and 6.0 mg/L for those waters designated
smallmouth bass or trout fisheries, at and above the
seven-day, two-year low flow value, and at the criti-
cal temperature.
For intermittent streams—the allowable loading for
oxygen demanding substances shall be based on at-
taining an instream DO of 5.0 mg/L for primary
warm water fisheries, 3.0 mg/L for secondary warm
water fisheries, and 6.0 mg/L for those waters des-
ignated smallmouth bass or trout fisheries, at and
above 1.0 cfs, and at the critical temperature.
ALPHA PARTICLE
A positively charged particle limited by certain
radioactive materials. It is the least penetrating of
the three common types of radiation (alpha, beta,
and gamma) and usually is not dangerous to plants,
animals or humans.
AMBIENT
Surrounding, especially of or pertaining to the en-
vironment about an entity, but undisturbed and un-
affected by it.
i
56
ANTI-DEGRADATION CLAUSE
A provision in water quality laws that prohibits
deterioration of water quality in areas where pollu-
tion levels are presently below those allowed.
AQUIFER
A formation that contains sufficient saturated, per-
meable material to yield significant quantities of
water to wells and springs. This implies an ability
to store and transmit water; unconsolidated sands
and gravels are a typical example.
ASSIMILATIVE CAPACITY
The amount of pollution a stream can receive and
still recover without permanent damage or altera-
tion of beneficial uses.
BENTHIC MACROINVERTEBRATES
Invertebrate animals that are large enough to be
seen by the unaided eye and can be retained by a
Standard No. 30 sieve, and live at least part of their
life cycles within or upon available substrates in a
body of water or water transport system.
BETA PARTICLE
A negatively charged elementary particle emitted by
radioactive decay that may cause skin burns. It is
easily stopped by a thin sheet of metal.
CARCINOGENIC
Cancer producing.
COLIFORM GROUP ORGANISMS
All of the aerobic and facultative anaerobic gram-
negative, non-spore-forming rod shaped bacteria that
ferment lactose broth with gas formation within 48
hours at 35°C.
_—
57
COLOR
Color as used herein means true color as wel! as ap-
parent color. True color is the color of the water
from which turbidity has been removed. Apparent
color includes not only the color due to substances
in solution (true color), but also that color due to
suspended matter.
CONSERVATIVE ELEMENT
A substance which persists in the environment, hav-
ing characteristics which are resistant to ordinary
biological degradation.
CRITICAL TEMPERATURE
The seven-day maximum temperature likely to occur
with a 50% probability each year, or 90°F.
DISSOLVED OXYGEN (DO)
The amount of oxygen dissolved in water at any
given time, depending upon the water temperature,
the partial pressure of oxygen in the atmosphere in
contact with the water, the concentration of dis-
solved salts in the water, and the physical aeration
of the water.
EPILIMNION
The uppermost homothermal region of a stratified
lake.
EUTROPHICATION (natural)
The normally slow aging process by which a lake
evolves into a bog or marsh and ultimately assumes
a terrestrial state. During eutrophication the lake
becomes so rich in nutritive compounds (especially
nitrogen and phosphorus) that algae and other micro-
scopic plant life become superabundant, thereby
58
“choking” the lake, and causing the lake to advance
in seral stages.
FECAL COLIFORM
A group of organisms common to the intestinal tracts
of man and of animals. The presence of fecal coli-
form bacteria in water is an indicator of pollution
and of potentially dangerous bacterial contamination.
GEOMETRIC MEAN
a—"\/B,x<B.x ...B,
Where: n= number of samples
and B.=the bacterial count for n® sample.
GROUNDWATER BASIN
For the purposes of these standards a “groundwater
basin” is a physiographic unit containing a system
of interconnected aquifers forming a groundwater
reservoir. This definition is not applicable for the
purposes of groundwater use permitting under the
Oklahoma Groundwater Law.
INTERMITTENT STREAM
A stream or reach of a stream that flows only at
certain times of the year. In such streams the run-
off from the watershed is smaller than the ground
evaporation and seepage losses in the ground. For
the purposes of these standards, 7 day 2 year low
flow of 0 will be considered intermittent.
LC,,
Lethal Concentration—the concentration of a toxi-
cant in an external medium that is lethal to fifty
percent of the test animals for a specified period of
exposure,
59
NATURAL SOURCE
Source of contamination which is not man induced.
NEPHELOMETRIC TURBIDITY UNIT (NTU)
This method is based upon a comparison of the inten-
sity of light scattered by the sample under defined
conditions with the im*ensity of light scattered by a
standard reference suspension (formazin). The
higher the intensity of scattered light, the higher
the turbidity. Readings in NTU’s are considered
comparable to the previously reported Jackson Tur-
bidity Units (JTU).
NON-CONSERVATIVE ELEMENT
A substance which undergoes degradation or change
in the environment other than dilution.
NONPOINT SOURCE
A source of pollution without a well defined point
of origin.
NUTRIENTS
Elements of compounds essential as raw materials
for organisms growth and development; these include
carbon, oxygen, nitrogen and phosphorus.
POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS (PCBs)
Polychlorinated biphenyls, a group of organic com-
pounds (206 possible) which is constructed of two
phenyl rings and more than one chlorine atom. PCBs
are used as an electrical insulating fluid in capaci-
tors and transformers, and in the manufacture of
plastics.
PERENNIAL STREAMS
A stream or reach of a stream that flows continu-
ously throughout the year either due to watershed
runoff or to inflow of the ground water to the
stream.
PICOCURIE (pCi)
That quantity of radioactive material producing 2.22
nuclear transformations per minute.
POINT SOURCE
Any discernable, confined and discrete conveyance,
including but not limited to any pipe, ditch, channel,
tunnel, well, discrete fissure, container, rolling stock
or concentrated animal feeding operation from which
pollutants are or may be discharged. This term
does not include return flows from irrigated agri-
culture.
POLLUTION
Contamination or other alteration of the physical,
chemical or biological properties of any natural
waters of the State, or such discharge of any liquid,
gaseous or solid substance into any waters of the
State as will or is likely to create a nuisance or
render such waters harmful or detrimental or in-
jurious to public health, safety or welfare, or to
domestic, commercial, industrial, agricultural, rec-
reational, or other legitimate beneficial uses, or to
livestock, wild animals, birds, fish or other aquatic
life. (82 O.S. 1981, § 926.1(1)
PRIMARY WARM WATER FISHERIES
Water quality and habitat adequate to support sen-
sitive warm water fish species in abundance. En-
vironment suitable for the full range of warm water
benthos.
61
SALINITY
The degree of salt in water.
SAMPLE STANDARD
The arithmetic mean of historical data plus two
standard deviations of the mean.
SECONDARY WARM WATER FISHERY
Water quality and habitat not adequate to support
sensitive warm water fish in abundance. This can
be as a result of two conditions:
a) Habitat and natural physical-chemical character-
istics not suitable for the full range of aquatic
organisms.
b) Man induced conditions preclude the attainment
of a full range of aquatic organisms including
sensitive warm water fish species in abundance.
SEVEN-DAY, TWO-YEAR LOW FLOW
A seven-day, two-year low flow is specified as the
design flow for determining allowable discharge load
to a stream. The flow is calculated as a moving
average of seven consecutive days for each year in
a given record. These seven-day low flow values
are ranked in ascending order. An order number
(m) is calculated based upon the number of years
record (n), with a recurrence interval (R) of two
years, as m= (n+1)/R, where R-=two years. A
value of flow corresponding to the m* order is
taken as the seven-day, two-year low flow for that
historical data.
STANDARD DEVIATION
A statistical measure of the dispersion around the
arithmetic mean of the data.
62
SIMILARITY INDEX
Where:
2C A = No. of species in the sample at
= —— upstream station.
A+B B—No. of species in the sample at
downstream station.
C=No. of species common to both A
and B.
SYNERGISTIC EFFECT
Indicates the presence of cooperative pollutant action
such that the total effect is greater than the sum of
the effects of each pollutant taken individually.
THERMAL POLLUTION
Degradation of water quality by the introduction of
heated effluent. Primarily a result of the discharge
2 cooling waters from industrial processes par-
rly from electrical power generation.
THERMAL STRATIFICATION
Horizontal layers of different densities produced in
a lake due to temperature.
WASTES
Industrial waste and all other liquid, gaseous or
solid substances which may pollute or tend to pollute
any waters of the State. (82 O.S. Supp. 1976, § 926.1
(2))
WATERS OF THE STATE
All streams, lakes, ponds, marshes, watercourses,
waterways, wells, springs, irrigation systems, drain-
age systems, and all other bodies or accumulations
63
of water, surface and underground, natural or arti-
ficial, public or private, which are contained within,
flow through, or border upon this State or any por-
tion thereof, except privately owned reservoirs used
in the process of cooling water for industrial pur-
poses, provided that water released from any such
reservoir into a stream system of the State shall be
and become waters of the State. (82 O.S. Supp.
1976, § 926.1(6) )
YEARLY MEAN STANDARD
The arithmetic mean of historical data plus one
standard deviation of the mean.
64
OKLAHOMA’S
WATER QUALITY STANDARDS
1985
SECTION 3
ANTI-DEGRADATION POLICY
Oklahoma’s waters constitute a valuable State re-
source and shall be protected, maintained and improved
for the benefit of all the citizens. The intent of the
Anti-degradation Policy is to protect all waters of the
State from degradation of water quality. Existing benefi-
cial uses shall be maintained and protected. No water
quality degradation, which will interfere with the at-
tainment or maintenance of designated beneficial uses
shall be allowed.
It is recognized that certain waters of the State possess
existing water quality which exceeds those levels neces-
sary to support propagation of fishes, shellfishes, wildlife,
and recreation in and on the water. These high quality
waters shall be maintained and protected.
No degradation shall be allowed in waters which con-
stitute an outstanding resource or in waters of excep-
tional recreational or ecological significance. These in-
clude water bodies located in National and State parks,
forests, wilderness areas, wildlife management areas,
wildlife refuges, and streams designated as “critical hab-
itat” under the Federal Endangered Species Act listed in
Appendix B. These also include streams designated
“s “critical habitat” under the Federal Endangered Spe-
cies Act listed in Appendix B. These also include streams
designated Scenic River in Appendix A.
ee he
65
As the quality of Oklahoma waters improve, no degra-
dation of such improved waters shall be allowed. When
the moving yearly mean standard for a specific param-
eter improves to the point where the goals listed in Ap-
pendix C become attainable, degradation will be prohib-
ited by incorporating the goal as a standard.
In cases where potential water quality impairment as-
sociated with a thermal discharge is involved, the anti-
degradation policy and implementation method shall be
consistent with Section 316-of Public Law 92-500 as
amended by PL 92-217.
SECTION 7.11 BENEFICIAL USE LIMITATIONS
All streams and bodies of water designated as (a) in
Appendix A are protected by prohibition of any new
point source discharge which increases pollutant loading
or increased load from an existing point source. All
stream segments designated in Appendix A as “scenic
river” and the tributaries of those stream segments are
hereby designated as (a). Best management practices
for control of nonpoint source discharges should be in-
itiated in these watersheds.
* * + *
66
Permit No. AR0020010
AUTHORIZATION TO DISCHARGE UNDER THE
NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINA-
TION SYSTEM
In compliance with the provisions of the Clean Water
Act, (33 U.S.C. 1251 et. seq., the “Act”),
City of Fayetteville
P.O. Drawer F
Fayetteville, Arkansas 72701
is authorized to discharge from a facility with outfalls
located at approximately:
White River Outfall No. 001 Latitude: 36°05’00”N
Longitude: 94°05’00”W
Mud Creek Outfall No. 002 Latitude: 36°05’25”N
Longitude: 94°06’38”W
to receiving waters named the White River-Outfall No.
001 (Segment 4K-White River Basin) and Mud Creek-
Outfall No. 002 (Segment 3J-Arkansas River Basin)
in accordance with effluent limitations, monitoring re-
quirements and other conditions set forth in Parts I, II,
III, and IV hereof.
This permit shall become effective on December 10,
1985.
This permit and the authorization to discharge shall
expire at midnight, December 9, 1990.
Signed this 5th day of November 1985.
/s/ Myron O. Knudson
Myron O. Knupson, P.E.
Director, Water Management Division (6W)
# ee ee ees
67
Permit No. AR0020010
PART I
SECTION A. EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS AND
MONITORING REQUIREMENTS
1. Final Effluent Limits
.a. During the period beginning date of issuance and
lasting through date of expiration the permittee is au-
thorized to discharge to the White River from Outfall
No. 001. '
S:ch discharges shall be limited and monitored by the
permittee as specified below :
Effluent Characteristic Discharge Limitations
kg/day (Ibs/day ) Oiher Units
30-day Avg 30-day Avg 7-day Avg
Flow * N/A * mgd * mgd
Carbonaceous Biochemical
Oxygen Demand
(CBOD,)
December 1-March 31 235(517) 10 mg/! 15 mg/1
April 1-November 30 117(259) 5 mg/1 7 mg/l
Total Suspended Solids
December 1-March 31 352(776) 15 mg/l 22 mg/l!
April 1-November 30 117(259) 5 mg/! 7 mg/l
Ammonia Nitrogen
December 1-March 31 117(259) 5 mg/! 7mg/!
April 1-November 30 47(103) 2 mg/l 3 mg/1
Total Phosphorous 23 (52) 1 mg/! 2 mg/l
Fecal Coliform
October 1-March 31 N/A 1000/100 ml 2000/100 ml
April 1-September 30 N/A 200/100 ml 400/100 ml
Residual Chlorine N/A .05 mg/l, maximum
Dissolved Oxygen
December 1-March 3! N/A 10 mg/1, minimum
April 1-November 30 N/A 8 mg/], minimum
* Effluent flow must be monitored and reported. White River flow
near Fayetteville (U.S.G.S. Station No. 7048600) must also be moni-
tored daily and reported (30-day and 7-day averages). No discharge
to the White River is permitted unless the stream flow is 50 cfs or
more.
68
Effluent Characteristic \ Monitoring Requirements
Measurement Sample
Frequency Type
Flow * Daily Totalizing Meter
Carbonaceous Biochemical
Oxygen Demand
(CBOD,) One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Total Suspended Solids One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Ammonia Nitrogen One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Total Phosphorous One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Fecal Coliform Bacteria One/Day Grab
Residual Chlorine One/Day Grab
Dissolved Oxygen One/Day Grab
The pH shall not be less than 6.0 standard units nor
greater than 9.0 standard units and shall be monitored
by grab samples collected at the frequency shown above
for Total Suspended Solids.
There shall be no discharge of floating solids or visible
foam in other than trace amounts.
Samples taken in compliance with che monitoring re-
quirements specified above shall be taken at the discharge
from the final treatment unit.
b. During the period beginning date of issuance and
lasting through date of expiration the permittee is au-
thorized to discharge to Mud Creek from Outfall No. 002.
Such discharges shall be limited and monitored by the
permittee as specified below:
* Effluent flow must be monitored and reported. White River flow
near Fayetteville (U.S.G.S. Station No. 7048600) must also be moni-
tored daily and reported (30-day and 7-day averages). No discharge
to the White River is permitted unless the stream flow is 50 cfs or
more.
ee ee eee
69
Effluent Characteristic Discharge Limitations
kg /day (Ibs/day) Other Units
30-day Avg 30-day Avg 7-day Avg
Flow * * mgd * mgd
Carbonaceous Biochemical
Oxygen Demand
(CBOD,)
December 1-March 21 235(517) 10 mg/1! 15 mg/!
April 1-November 30 117(259) 5 mg/1 7mg/l
Total Suspended Solids
December 1-March 31 352(776) 15 mg/l 22 mg/!
April 1-November 30 117(259) 5 mg/l 7mg/l
Ammonia Nitrogen
December 1-March 31 117(259) 5 mg/l 7mg/l
April 1-November 30 47(103) 2mg/! 3 mg/l
Total Phosphorous 23 (52) 1 mg/! 2 mg/l
Fecal Coliform Bacteria
October 1-March 31 N/A 1000/100 ml 2000/100 ml
April 1-September 30 N/A 200/100 ml 400/100 ml
Residual Chlorine N/A .05 mg/l, maximum
Dissolved Oxygen
December 1-March 31 N/A 10 mg/!, minimum
April 1-November 30 N/A 8 mg/l, minimum
Effluent Characteristic Monitoring Requirements
Measurement Sample
Frequency Type
Flow * Daily Totalizing Meter
Carbonaceous Biochemical
Oxygen Demand
(CBOD.) One /Day 12-Hour Composite
Total Suspended Solids One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Ammonia Nitrogen One/ Day 12-Hour Composite
Total Phosphorous One/Day 12-Hour Composite
Fecal Coliform Bacteria One/Day Grab
Residual Chlorine One/Day Grab
Dissolved Oxygen One/Day Grab
* Effluent flow must be monitored and reported. See Part III for
additional requirements and limitations.
70
The pH shall not be less than 6.0 standard units nor
greater than 9.0 standard units and shall be monitored
by grab samples collected at the frequency shown above
for Total Suspended Solids.
There shall be no discharge of floating solids or visible
foam in other than trace amounts.
Samples taken in compliance with the monitoring re-
quirements specified above shall be taken at the discharge
from the final treatment unit.
SECTION B. MONITORING AND REPORTING
1. The permittee shall effectively monitor the opera-
tion and efficiency of all treatment and control facilities
and the quantity and quality of the treated discharge.
Samples and measurements taken for the purpose of
monitoring shall be representative of the monitored
activity.
a. If any seven-day average value exceeds the effluent
limitations specified in Part I. A., the permittee shall
report the excursion in accordance with the requirements
of Part II. A.2.
b. Any 30-day or 7-day average reported in the re-
quired Discharge Monitoring Report which is in excess
of the effluent limitation specified in Part I.A. shall
constitute evidence of violation of such effluent limitation
and of this permit.
ce. The Regional Administrator may at his discretion
require additional sampling, reporting, or monitoring in-
cluding but not limited to the taking of at least one 12
hour composite sample and/or increased frequency of
sampling.
d. Monitoring must be conducted according to test pro-
cedures approved under 40 CFR Part 136, unless other
test procedures have been specified in this permit.
71
2. Reporting
a. All reporting (including written notifications, oral
notifications, and discharge monitoring reports) required
by this permit shall, unless otherwise specified, be made
concurrently to:
(1) Director ;
Arkansas Department of Pollution
Control and Ecology
8001 National Drive
P.O. Box 9583
Little Rock, Arkansas 72209
(2) Director
Water Management Division (6W)
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,
Region VI
InterFirst Two Building
1201 Elm Street
Dallas, Texas 75270
b. Monitoring information required shall be submitted
on Discharge Monitoring Report Form EPA 3320-1.
(1) Duplicate original Discharge Monitoring Report
forms, properly completed and signed (as per paragraph
[2] below), must be submitted monthly.
(2) Each submitted Discharge Monitoring Report
shall be signed by a duly authorized agent of the permit-
tee in accordance with Part II. B.13.
(3) Reporting periods shall end on the last day of the
month.
(4) The first Discharge Monitoring Report(s) shall
represent facility operations from the effective date of
the permit through the last day of the month.
(5) Thereafter, the permittee is required to make reg-
ular monthly reports as described above and shall sub-
72
mit those reports no later than the 25th day of the
month following each reporting period.
(6) All values required on EPA Form 3320-1 shall be
reported in accordance with the “General Instructions”
provided on that form.
(7) Other measurements of oxygen demand (e.g., TOC
and COD) may be substituted for five-day Biochemical
Oxygen Demand (CBOD,) where the permittee can dem-
onstrate long-term correlation of the method with CBOD,
values. Details of correlation procedures employed must
be submitted and prior approval granted by the permit-
ting authority for this procedure to be acceptable. Data
reported must also include evidence to show that the
proper correlation continues to exist after approval.
ce. The Clean Water Act provides that any person
who knowingly makes any false statement, representa-
tion, or certification in any record or other document
submitted or required to be maintained under this per-
mit, including monitoring reports or reports of compli-
ance or noncompliance shall, upon conviction, be punished
by a fine of not more than $10,000 per violation, or by
imprisonment for not more than six months per violation,
or by both.
3. Test Procedures
a. All sampling and analytical methods used to meet
the monitoring requirements specified above shall con-
form to Section 304(h) of the Act and any regulations
promulgated therefrom.
b. The permittee shall calibrate and perform main-
tenance procedures on all monitoring and analytical in-
strumentation at intervals frequent enough to insure
accuracy of measurements and shall insure that both
calibration and maintenance activities will be conducted.
73
ce. An adequate analytical quality control program, in-
cluding the analyses of sufficient standards, spikes, and
duplicate samples to insure the accuracy of all required
analytical results shall be maintained by the permittee
or designated commercial laboratory.
d. The Clean Water Act provides that any person
who falsifies, tampers with, or knowingly renders inac-
curate any monitoring device or method required to be
maintained under this permit shall, upon conviction,
be punished by a fine of not more than $10,000 per vio-
lation, or by imprisonment for not more than six months
per violation, or both.
e. The analytical method used for Carbonaceous Bio-
chemical Oxygen Demand shall conform’ to the procedure
specified in “Standard Methods for the Examination of
Water and Wastewater,” 15th Edition.
4. Recording
The permittee shall record for each measurement or
sample taken pursuant to the requirements of this per-
mit the following information:
a. the date, exact place and time of sampling;
the dates analyses were performed ;
who performed the analyses;
the analytical techniques or methods used,
the results of all required analyses, and
the instantaneous flow at grab sample collections.
-meerear
5. Additional Monitoring by Permittee
If the permittee monitors any parameters more fre-
quently than is required by this permit, he shall include
the results of such monitoring in the calculation and re-
porting of the values required in the Discharge Monitor-
ing Report (EPA Form 3320-1 [10-77]). Such increased
74
frequency shall be indicated on the Discharge Monitor-
ing Report form.
6. Records Retention
The permittee shall retain records of all monitoring
information and records of all data used to complete the
application for this permit for a period of at least three
years from the date of the sample, measurement, report,
or application. This period may be extended by request
of the Regional Administrator at any time.
Records of monitoring information shall conform to
the requirements of 40 CFR 122.7(j).
PART II
SECTION A. MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS
1. Change in Discharge
a. The permittee shall give advance notice of any
planned changes in the permitted facility or activity
which may result in noncompliance with permit require-
ments.
b. Any change in the facility discharge (including the
introduction of any new source or significant discharge
or significant changes in the quantity or quality of exist-
ing discharges to the treatment system that may result
in new or increased discharges of pollutants) must be
reported to the permitting authority. In no case are any
new connections, increased flows, or significant changes
in influent quality permitted that will cause violation of
the effluent limitations specified herein.
2. Noncompliance Notification
a. The permittee shall report all instances of non-
compliance not reported under Part II, 2.b. below at the
75
time monitoring reports are submitted. The reports shall
contain the following information:
(1) A description of the noncompliance and its cause;
(2) The period of noncompliance, including exact dates
and times, and if the noncompliance has not been cor-
rected, the anticipated time it is expected to continue;
and
(3) Steps being taken to reduce, eliminate, and pre-
vent recurrence of the noncomplying discharge.
b. The following must be reported within 24 hours:
(1) Any unanticipated bypass which exceeds any ef-
fluent limitation in the permit;
(2) Any upset which exceeds any effluent limitations
in the permit; and
(3) Violation of a maximum daily discharge limita-
tion for any toxic pollutant or hazardous substance listed
under Part III, A. to be reported within 24 hours.
Any information shall be provided orally within 24 hours
from the time the permittee becomes aware of the circum-
stances. A written submission shall also be provided
within five days of the time the permittee becomes aware
of the circumstances. The written submission shall con-
tain the information listed in Part II, A.2.a. above.
The Regional Administrator may waive the written re-
port on a case-by-case basis if the oral report has been
received within 24 hours.
The permittee shall also report any other noncompliance
which may endanger health or the environment (such as
fish kills or other instances when timely reporting is
desirable) in this manner.
3. Bypassing
Bypass or diversion of wastes from any portions of
the treatment facilities is prohibited unless the foll: w-
ing conditions are met:
76
a. Bypass is unavoidable to prevent loss of life, per-
sonal injury or severe property damage ;
b. There are no feasible alternatives to bypass, such
as the use of auxiliary treatment facilities, retention of
untreated wastes, or maintenance during normal periods
of equipment downtime. This condition is not satisfied
if the permittee could have installed adequate backup
equipment to prevent a bypass which occurred during
normal periods of equipment downtime or preventive
maintenance;
c. The permittee submits notice of an unanticipated
bypass as required in Part II, A.2.b.; and
d. The permittee submits prior notice of an anticipated
bypass, if possible at least ten days before the date of
the bypass.
4. Upsets
An upset constitutes an affirmative defense to an en-
forcement action brought for noncompliance with tech-
nology-based permit effluent limitations if the following
requirements are met.
A permittee who wishes to establish the affirmative
defense of upset shall demonstrate through properly
signed, contemporaneous operating logs, or other rele-
vant evidence that:
a. An upset occurred and that the permittee can iden-
tify the specific cause(s) of the upset;
b. The permitted facility was at the time being prop-
erly operated ;
ce. The permittee submitted notice of the upset as re-
quired in Part II, A.2.b. of this permit; and
d. The permittee complied with any remedial measures
under Part II, B.2.
ae
77
5. Duty to Reapply
Permittees who wish to continue to discharge subse-
quent to the expiration date of their permit must apply
for reissuance of the permit using proper forms, not
less than 180 days prior to the permit expiration date.
6. Transfer of Ownership or Control
In the event of any change in control or ownership of
facilities from which the authorized discharges emanate,
the permittee shall submit a written agreement, at least
30 days in advance of the proposed transfer date, con-
taining a specific date for transfer of permit responsi-
bility and coverage between the current and new per-
mittees.
7. Other Information
Where the permittee becomes aware that it failed to
submit any relevant facts in a permit application, or
submitted incorrect information in a permit applica-
tion or in any report, it shall promptly submit such facts
or information.
SECTION B. MANAGEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES
1. Duty to Comply
a. The permittee must comply with all conditions of
this permit. Any permit noncompliance constitutes a
violation of the appropriate Act and is grounds for en-
forcement action; for permit termination, revocation and
reissuance, or modification; or for denial of a permit
renewal application.
b. The permittee shall comply with effluent standards
or prohibitions established under Section 307(a) of the
Act for toxic pollutants within the time provided in the
regulations that establish these standards or prohibi-
tions, even if the permit has not yet been modified to
incorporate the requirement.
78
ce. The Act provides that any person who violates a
permit condition implementing sections 301, 302, 306,
307, 308, 318, or 405 of the Act is subject to a civil
penalty not to exceed $10,000 per day of such violation.
Any person who willfully or negligently violates permit
conditions implementing sections 301, 302, 306, 307, or
308 of the Act is subject to a fine of not less than $2,500
or more than $25,000 per day of violation, or by impri-
sonment for not more than one year, or both.
2. Duty to Mitigate
The permittee shall take all reasonable steps to mini-
mize or prevent any discharge in violation of this per-
mit which has a reasonable likelihood of adversely af-
fecting human health or the environment.
3. Duty to Halt or Reduce not a Defense
It shall not be a defense for a permittee in an en-
forcement action that it would have been necessary to
halt or reduce the permitted activity in order to maintain
compliance with the conditions of this permit.
4. Permit Flexibility
a. This permit may be modified, revoked and reissued,
or terminated for cause. The filing of a request for a
permit modification, revocation and reissuance, or termi-
nation, or a notification of planned changes or anticipated
noncompliance, does not stay any permit condition.
b. After notice and opportunity for a hearing, this
permit may be modified, suspended, or terminated during
its term in accordance with 40 CFR 122.15-16.
5. Facility Operation and Quality Control
a._ All waste collection, control, treatment and disposal
facilities shall be operated in a manner consistent with
the following:
79
(1) At all times, all facilities or systems of control
shall be maintained in good working order and operated
as efficiently as possible and in a manner which will
minimize upsets and discharges of excessive pollutants;
(2) The permittee shall provide an adequate operating
staff which is duly qualified to carry out the operation,
maintenance and testing functions required to insure
compliance with the conditions of this permit;
(3) Maintenance of treatment facilities that results
in degradation of effluent quality shall be scheduled during
noncritical water quality periods and shall be carried out
in a manner approved by the permitting authority, as
specified in Part II, A.3.c.
b. Proper operation and maintenance includes effective
performance, adequate funding, adequate operator staff-
ing and training, and adequate laboratory and process
controls, including appropriate quality assurance pro-
cedures. This provision requires the operation of back-
up or auxiliary facilities or similar systems when nec-
essary to achieve compliance with the conditions of the
permit.
6. Removed Substances
Collected screenings, slurries, sludges, and other
solids shall be disposed of in such a manner as to pre-
vent entry of those wastes (or runoff from the wastes)
into navigable waters or their tributaries.
7. Power Failure
The permittee is responsible for maintaining adequate
safeguards to prevent the discharge of untreated or in-
adequately treated wastes during electrical power failures
either by means of alternate power sources, standby gen-
erators, or retention of inadequately treated effluent.
80
8. Availability of Reports
Except for applications, effluent data, permits, and
other data specified in 40 CFR 122.19, any information
submitted pursuant to this permit may be claimed as
confidential by the submitter. If no claim is made at the
time of submission, information may be made available to
the public without further notice.
9. Duty to Provide Information
The permittee shall furnish, within a reasonable time,
any information which the Director may request to deter-
mine whether cause exists for modifying, revoking and
reissuing, or terminating this permit, or to determine
compliance with this permit. The permittee shall also
furnish, upon request, copies of records required to be
kept by this permit.
10. State Laws
Nothing in this permit precludes more stringent State
regulation of any activity covered by this permit.
11. Property Rights
This permit does not convey any property rights of
any sort, or any exclusive privilege.
12. Right of Entry
The permittee shall allow the head of the State water
pollution control agency, the Regional Administrator,
and/or their authorized representatives, upon the presen-
tation of credentials and such other documents as may
be required by the law:
a. To enter upon the permittee’s premises or other
premises under the control of the permittee, where an
effluent source is located or in which any records are
81
required to be kept under the terms and conditions of
this permit.
b. To have access to and to copy, at reasonable times,
any records required to be kept under the terms and con-
ditions of this permit, or the Act;
ce. To inspect at reasonable times any monitoring
equipment or monitoring method required in this permit;
d. To sample at reasonable times any discharge of
pollutants; or
e. To perform at reasonable times an operation and
maintenance inspection of the permitted facility.
13. Signatory Authority
a. All permit applications shall be signed by a prin-
cipal executive officer or ranking elected official. Dis-
charge monitoring and other reports may be signed by
an authorized representative provided that a written
authorization has been submitted and that the representa-
tive so authorized is responsible for the overall operation
of the facility from which the discharge originates.
b. A person signing any document shall make the
following certification:
“I certify under penalty of law that this document and
all attachments were prepared under the direction or
supervision in accordance with a system designed to as-
sure that qualified personnel properly gather and evalu-
ate the information submitted. Based on my inquiry of
the person or persons who manage the system, or those
persons directly responsible for gathering the informa-
tion, the information submitted is, to the best of my
knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete. I
am aware that there are significant penalties for sub-
mitting false information, including the possibility of fine
and imprisonment for knowing violations.”
82
14. Civil and Criminal Liability
Except as provided in permit conditions on “Bypass-
ing” and “Upsets”, nothing in this permit shall be con-
strued to relieve the permittee from civil or criminal
penalties for noncompliance.
15. Severability
The provisions of this permit are severable, and if any
provision of this permit, or the application of any provi-
sion of this permit to any circumstance, is held invalid,
the application of such provision to other circumstances,
and the remainder of this permit, shall not be affected
thereby.
PART III
SECTION A. OTHER REQUIREMENTS
1. Contributing Industries and Pretreatment Require-
ments
a. The permittee shall operate an industrial pretreat-
ment program in accordance with section 402(b) (8) of
the Clean Water Act and the General Pretreatment Reg-
ulations (40 CFR Part 403). The program shall also be
implemented in accordance with the approved POTW pre-
treatment program submitted by the permittee which is
hereby incorporated by reference.
b. The permittee shall establish and enforce specific
limits to implement the provisions of 40 CFR § 403.5 (a)
and (b), as required by 40 CFR § 403.5(c). All specific
prohibitions or limits developed under this requirement
are deemed to be conditions of this permit. The specific
prohibitions set out in 40 CFR § 403.5(b) shall be en-
forced by the permittee unless modified under this pro-
vision.
c. The permittee shall prepare annually a list of In-
dustrial Users which, during the past twelve months,
have significantly violated pretreatment requirements.
This list is to be published annually in the largest news-
paper in the municipality during the month of April.
d. In addition, at least 14 days prior to publication,
the following information is to be submitted to the EPA
and the State for each significantly violating Industrial
User:
(1) Condition(s) violated and reason(s) for viola-
tion (s),
(2) Compliance action taken by the City, and
(3) Current compliance status.
2. Illinois River Basin Water Quality Protection Re-
quirements
a. Noncompliant Effluent Prohibition
(1) Should the effluent quality determinations reveal
that the concentration of any pollutant exceeds the 7-day
average discharge limitations specified in Part I, Section
A of the permit, the discharge to Mud Creek shall be
halted and not restarted until the plant effluent problem
is corrected.
(2) Should the effluent quality determinations reveal
that the concentration of any pollutant exceeds the 30-
dy average discharge limitations specified in Part I, Sec-
tion A of the permit, the discharge to Mud Creek shall
be halted and not restarted until the plant effluent prob-
lem is corrected.
(3) For the CBOD, parameter, the compliance deter-
mination will be made 6 days after the 7-day period under
evaluation.
b. Bypassing and Upsets
(1) Effluent which has not received complete treat-
ment (i.e., “bypassed” around any portion of the treat-
ment plant) shall not be discharged to Mud Creek.
84
(2) During periods of short-term noncompliance with
effluent limitations (“upsets”), no effluent shall be dis-
charged to Mud Creek.
c. Mud Creek Flow Limitations
(1) The 30-day average flow of treated effluent dis-
charged to Mud Creek shall not exceed 50 percent of the
30-day average flow of treated effluent from the plant.
(2) The 30-day average flow of treated effluent dis-
charged to Mud Creek shall not exceed 6.1 million gallons
per day (mgd).
d. Permit Modification
(1) A joint Arkansas/Oklahoma/EPA water quality
study of the Illinois River Basin is currently being con-
ducted to determine the existing water quality, causative
factors, and possible nutrient control measures.
(2) If the findings of this study indicate that more
stringent limitations for Fayetteville’s effluent are neces-
sary to insure that water quality standards are met, then
this permit will be modified to incorporate the more
stringent limitations. This may require that additional
treatment be provided or that City’s discharge to Mud
Creek cease.
PART IV
SECTION A. DEFINITIONS
All definitions contained in Section 502 of the Act shall
apply to this permit and are incorporated herein by ref-
erence. Additional definitions of words or phrases used
in this perimt are as follows:
1. “Act” means the Clean Water Act, Public Law 95-
217 (33 U.S.C. 1251 et seq).
2. “Administrator” means the Administrator of the
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
85
3. “Applicable effluent standards and limitations”
means all State and Federal effluent standards and limi-
tations to which a discharge is subject under the Act,
including, but not limited to, effluent limitations, stand-
ards of performance, toxic effluent standards and pro-
hibitions, and pretreatment standards.
4. “Applicable water quality standards” means all
water quality standards to which a discharge is subject
under the Act and which have been (a) approved or per-
mitted to remain in effect by the Administrator following
submission to her pursuant to section 303(a) of the Act,
or (b) promulgated by the Administrator pursuant to
section 303(b) or 203(c) of the Act.
5. “Bypass” means the intentional diversion of waste
streams from any portion of a treatment facility.
6. “Environmental Protection Agency” means the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency.
7. “Grab sample” means an individual sample collected
in less than 15 minutes.
8. “Industrial User” means a nondomestic discharger,
as identified in 40 CFR 403, introducing pollutants to a
publicly owned treatment works.
9. “National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System”
means the national program for issuing, modifying, re-
voking and reissuing, terminating, monitoring and en-
forcing permits, and imposing and enforcing pretreat-
ment requirements, under sections 307, 402, 318, and 405
of the Clean Water Act.
10. “Severe property damage” means substantial phy-
sical damage to property, damage to the treatment facili-
ties which causes them to become inoperable, or substan-
tial and permanent loss of natural resources which can
reasonably be expected to occur in the absence of a by-
pass. Severe property damage does not mean economic
loss caused by delays in production.
86
11. “Sewage sludge” means the solids, residues, and
precipitate separated from or created in sewage by the
unit processes of a publicly owned treatment works.
Sewage as used in this definition means any wastes, in-
cluding wastes from humans, households, commercial es-
tablishments, industries, and storm water runoff, that are
discharged to or otherwise enter a publicly owned treat-
ment works.
12. “7-day average”, other than for fecal coliform
bacteria, is the arithmetic mean of the values for all
effluent samples collected during the calendar week. The
7-day average for fecal coliform bacteria is the geometric
mean of the values for all effluent samples collected dur-
ing the calendar week.
13. “30-day average’, other than for fecal coliform
bacteria, is the arithmetic mean of the values for all
effluent samples collected during a calendar month. The
30-day average for fecal coliform bacteria is the geo-
metric mean of the values for all effluent samples col-
lected during a calendar month.
14. “12-hour composite sample” consists of 12 effluent
portions collected no closer together than one hour and
composited according to flow.
15. “6-hour composite sample” consists of six effluent
portions collected not closer together than one hour (with
the first portion collected no earlier than 10:00 A.M.)
and composited according to flow.
16. “3-hour composite sample” consists of three efflu-
ent portions collected no closer together than one hour
(with the first portion collected no earlier than 10:00
A.M.) and composited according to flow.
17. “Treatment works” means any devices and sys-
tems used in the storage, treatment, recycling, and
reclamation of municipal sewage and industrial wastes
of a liquid nature to implement section 201 of the Act,
87
or necessary to recycle or reuse water at the most eco-
nomical cost over the estimated life of the works, includ-
ing intercepting sewers, sewage collection systems, pump-
ing, power and other equipment, and their appurtenances,
extension, improvement, remodeling, additions, and al-
terations thereof; elements essential to provide a reliable
recycled supply such as standby treatment units and clear
well facilities, and any works, including site acquisition
of the land that will be an integral part of the treatment
process or is used for ultimate disposal of residues result-
ing from such treatment.
18. “Upset” means an exceptional incident in which
there is unintentional and temporary noncompliance with
technology-based permit effluent limitations because of
factors beyond the reasonable control of the permittee.
An upset does not include noncompliance to the extent
caused by operational error, improper designed treatment
facilities, lack of preventive maintenance, or careless or
improper operation.
19. For fecal coliform bacteria a sample consists of
one effluent grab portion collected during a 24-hour period
at peak loads.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.