Joint Appendix — Tanner v. United States
Supreme Court brief1987
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
In The .
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1986
— 0
ANTHONY R. TANNER and
WILLIAM M. CONOVER,
Petitioners,
vs.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
~O
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
>=
2
JOINT APPENDIX
yr, =
Ww
Jouw A. DeVavutt, II Cartes Frrep
Bevett, Drrrmar, DeVavitr- Solicitor General
& Pusans, P.A. Department of Justice
The Bedell Building Washington, D.C. 20530
101 East Adams Street (206) 633-2217
Jacksonville, Florida 32202 Counsel of Record
(904) 353-0211 For Respondent
Counsel of Record
For Petitioners
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED AUGUST 2, 1986
CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 3, 1986
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO. (800) 225-0064
or cali collect (402) -2831
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Relevant Docket Entries
Indictment (6/22/83)
Trial Proceedings - Testimony of
Alexander E. Sherman (2/24/84)
Defendant Exhibit | for Identifieation
(letter F. Bennett to H. Wright 7/24/81)
Government Exhibit 1-A (Loan Contract 2/12/76)
Government Exhibit 1-F (Seminole
Conflict of Interest Poliey)
Court Exhibit
(REA Bulletin 40-6)
(REA Bidding Procedures)
Trial Proeeedings—Jury Verdict (39/84)
Defendant Tanner's Motion and Memorandum for
Interview of Jurors and Other Relief (4°19 84)
Order Granting Motion to Continne Senteneine
Date (4/23/84) ,
Hearing (5/30/84)
Defendant Exhibit in Support of Motion to Inter.
view Jurors (Sworn Statement Fred Van Lengen)
Order Denying Defendants’ Motions for Leave te
Interview Jurors and Motion for an Order Dis-
missing Indictment or euemnuamantind Granting
New Trial (5/30/84) | 7
Judgment and Prshation/Ccmmitmont Order for
William M. Conover (6/29/84) _
Judgment and Probation ‘Commitment Order for
Anthony B. Tanner (6/29/84)
Defendant Tanner's Motion to Remand to District
Court for Hearing on Motion for a New Trial
Based on Jury Misconduct (10/24/84)
Page
181
183
187
‘4
TABLE OF CONTENTS. ¢ ‘ontinned
Government's Response to Defenlant’s Motion to
Remand (10/30/84) 196
Court of Appeals Order on Defemlant’s Motion
for Remand (11/12 4) wae ..
Defendant Tanner's Motion for a New Trial Based
on Newly Discovered Evidenee of Jury Mis.
conduct (11/21/84) 203
Exhibit A—Sworn Statement of Juror
Daniel Martin Hardy —_ |
Exhibit B—Affidavit of Attorney David Best 241
Exhibit C—Affidavit of Investigator Douglas Beard 244
Exhibit D—Affidavit of Attorney David Best = 246
Government's Response to Defendant's Motion for
a New Trial (12/4/84) ues Se
Order Denying Motion for New Trial and
Evidentiary Hearing (12/4/88) 000 gg
The following opinion and order have been omitted
in printing this joint appendix because they appear on the
following pages in the appendix to the printed Petition for
Writ of Certiorari-
Order of the United States Court of Appeals
for ing ond Seen ee
hearing and Suggestion for Rehearing
Bane, dated June 26, 1986 Pet.App. 1
Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Eleventh Cireuit, dated September
0, 195 Pet App. 3
DATE
6/22/83
6/28/83
6/30/83
Il/ 1/83
12/12/83
2/14/54
3/ 9/84
3/ 9/84
4/19/84
4/25/84
5/30/84
DOCKET ENTRIES
PROCEEDINGS
INDICTMENT. (6 ets.)
ARRAIGNMENT proceedings (Tanner)
Deft. waives reading of indictment. Ar-
raigned & plead not guilty. Trial set for
weeks of Aug. 8, 15 & 22, 1983; Omnibus
hearing on 7/11/85 at 3:00 PM. Bail—
$10,000 signature bond.
ARRAIGNMENT proceedings: (Conover)
Deft. waives reading of indictment. Ar-
raigned and plead not guilty. Trial set for
Aug. 8, 15 & 22, 1983; Omnibus hearing on
7/11/83 at 3:00 PM.
PROCEEDINGS: Trial by jury. (Conover
& Tanner)
PROCEEDINGS: Jury trial (BOTH
DEFDTS.)
Jury deliberating.
Mistrial declared—Jury excused.
PROCEEDINGS—tTrial by jury. (Con-
over & Tanner)
VERDICT—xguilty cts. 1, 2, 4 & 5. NOT
GUILTY et. 3. (Tanner)
VERDICT—guilty as to ets 1 thru 5. (Con-
over)
MOTION AND MEMO for interview of
jurors and other relief (TANNER)
ORDER (BK) motion to continue sen-
tencings granted
ORDER (BK) denying motions for leave
to interview jurors and for order dismiss-
ing the indictment or alternatively, for new
trial; clerk to sch sentencings Jun 29, 1984
at 11 am
DATE
7/ 2/84
7/ 2/84
7/ 2/84
7/ 2/84
10/24/84
10/30/84
11/13/84
11/21/84
12/ 4/84
9/30/85
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE of appeal filed on 6/29/84 (TAN-
NER)
NOTICE of appeal filed on 6/29/84 (CON-
OVER)
JUDGMENT & commitment order. (TAN-
NER) 6/29/84. s/Judge BEN KRENTZ.
MAN.
JUDGMENT & commitment order. (CON-
OVER) 6/29/84. s/Judge BEN KRENTZ.
MAN
Defendant Tanner’s Motion to Remand to
Distriet Court for Hearing on Motion for a
New Trial Based on Jury Misconduct
(Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Cir-
cuit)
Government’s Response to Defendant’s Mo-
tion to Remand (Court of Appeals for the
Eleventh Cireuit )
Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Cireuit
Order on Defendant’s Motion for Remand
MOTION for new trial in the Distriet
Court based on newly discovered evidence
of jury misconduct (TANNER)
ORDER (BK) denying deft’s motion for
new trial
NOTICE OF APPEAL of order dated
12/4/84 (CONOVER)
NOTICE OF APPEAL or order dated
12/4/84 (TANNER)
Order of the United States Court of Ap-
peals for the Eleventh Cireuit on Petition
for Rehearing and Suggestion for Rehear-
ing En Bane
Opinion of the United States Court of Ap-
peals for the Eleventh Cireuit
3
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Vv. Case No. 83-70-C-T-8
WILLIAM M. CONOVER and
ANTHONY R. TANNER
The Grand Jury charges that:
COUNT ONE
1. At all times material herein, the Rural Electrifi-
cation Act (Title 7, United States Code, Section 901, et
seq.) was in full effect and it had established a program
within the United States Department of Agriculture pro-
viding financial assistance to borrowers of funds for the
construction of electrical plants and transmission lines in
rural areas not receiving central station service by guar-
anteeing loans issued to borrowers by any legally organized
lender.
2. At all times material herein, the Rural Eleetrifica-
tion Administration (hereinafter sometimes ‘*REA’’), an
agency of the United States, was in existence and it ad-
ministered and enforced the guaranteed loan program.
3. At all times material herein, the Rural Eleetrifi-
cation Administration required borrowers participating in
its guaranteed loan program to comply with its rules and
regulations applicable to the procurement of material,
equipment and services to be used in the construction of
electrical plants and transmission lines.
4. At all times material herein, Seminole Electric
Cooperative, Inc. (hereinafter ‘‘Seminole Electric’’), was
4
a Florida corporation owned by several rural electric co-
operatives, and it was engaged in the business of furnish.
ing electrical energy to the members of the cooperatives
which owned it.
5. At all times materia! herein, Seminole Electric
had applied for and received a $1,104,388,000 loan from the
Federal Financing Bank, an agency of the United States
Treasury, which loan had been and was guaranteed by the
Rural Electrification Administration in accordance with
its rules and regulations, for the purpose of constructing
an electrical plant and transmission lines in Palatka,
Florida.
6. At all times material herein, WILLIAM M. CON-
OVER was employed by Seminole Electric as its Manager
of Procurement, and his duties included the procurement
of necessary material, equipment and services, causing
competitive bids to be solicited for contracts, reviewing
bids received, recommending the awarding of contracts
to particular individuals and concerns, assuring perform-
ance of contracts and negotiating the prices and terms of
changes in contracts.
7. At all times material herein, it was the written
policy of Seminole Electric that:
‘* . employees (were) prohibited from receiving
gifts, fees, loans, or favors from suppliers, contractors,
consultants, or financial houses, which obligate(d) or
induce(d) them to compromise their responsibilities
to negotiate, obligate, inspect or audit, purchase or
award contracts, with the best interest of (Seminole
Electric) uppermost in mind...”
8. At all times material herein, ANTHONY R. TAN.
NER was President and part-owner of the following Flori-
5
da corporations: (a) Citrus Sand and Clay, Ine.; (b) Urys-
tal River Investors, Ine.; and (¢) West Central Florida
Development Corporation; and in his capacity as Presi-
dent and part-owner ANTHONY R. TANNER exercised
supervisory authority over the business affairs of these
corporations.
9. Beginning in or about January, 1980, and continu-
ing until in or about January, 1982, at Tampa and Crystal
River, in the Middle District of Florida, and elsewhere,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY R. TANNER,
defendants herein, knowingly and willfully did combine,
conspire, confederate and agree together and with other
persons unknown to the grand jury to defraud the United
States by impeding, impairing, obstructing and defeating
the lawful functions of the Rural Electrification Admini-
stration in its administration and enforcement of its guar-
anteed loan program.
The Manner and Means of the Conspiracy
10. It was part of the conspiracy that defendant
ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing business as Citrus Sand
and Clay, Ine., would and did submit bids on and receive
two contracts with Seminole Electrie for the construction
of access roads beneath certain transmission lines (one
contract being for road fill material and one being for
road construction).
11. It was further a part of the conspiracy that the
defendants would and did impede, impair, obstruct and
6
defeat the competitive bidding process selected by Semi-
nole Electric for use in awarding contracts for the con-
struction of access roads beneath certain transmission lines
by causing the following conditions to apply and events
to occur during the bidding process which would be and
were to the advantage of defendant ANTHONY R. TAN-
NER and to the disadvantage of his competitors:
(a) the specifications in the contract for the
road fill material were drawn so as to make material
owned by defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER suit-
able and to make material owned by his competitors
unsuitable ;
(b) the time period allowed to interested par-
ties in which to submit a bid on the road construction
contracts was so short as to preclude defendant AN-
THONY R. TANNER’s competitors from submitting
effective bids; and
(ce) defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER made
and caused to be made false, fictitious and fraudulent
statements to other employees of Seminole Electric
in an effort to pursuade Seminole Electric to award
the contracts to defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER.
12. It was further a part of the conspiracy that de-
fendant ANTHONY R. TANNER, through his corpora-
tions Crystal River Investors and West Central Florida
Development Corporation, would and did corruptly give,
offer and promise things of value, namely, money and
property, to defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER, because
of acts performed and to be performed by defendant WIL-
LIAM M. CONOVER in his capacity as Manager of Pro-
curement at Seminole Electric in regard to the contracts
7
for the construction of access roads beneath certain trans-
13. It was further a part of the conspiracy that de-
fendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER would and did, direetly
and indirectly, unlawfully and without authorization, ask,
demand, exact, solicit, seek, accept, receive and agree to
receive from defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER and his
above-mentioned corporations things of value for him-
self, namely, money and property, because of acts per-
formed and to be performed by him in his capacity as
Manager of Procurement at Seminole Electric in regard
to the contracts for the construction of access roads be-
neath certain transmission lines.
14. It was further a part of the conspiracy that the
defendants would and did cause Seminole Electric to false-
ly state and represent to the Rural Electrification Admini-
stration that an REA-approved competitive bidding pro-
cedure had been followed in awarding the access road con-
struction contracts.
15. It was further a part of the conspiracy that the
defendants would and did misrepresent, conceal and hide,
and cause to be misrepresented, concealed and hidden, the
purposes of and acts done in furtherance of the con-
spiracy.
16. In furtherance of and to effect the objects of
the conspiracy, and to accomplish its purposes and ob-
jectives, the defendants did and committed the following
OVERT ACTS
(a) On or about April 18, 1980, defendants WIL-
LIAM M. CONOVER and ANTHONY R. TANNER
s
travelled together from Crystal River, Florida, to the
Bahamas.
(b) On or about July 26, 1980, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER and defen-
dant ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing business »s Crystal
River Investors, entered inte a contract in which defendant
WILLIAM M. CONOVER agreed to purchase a condo-
minium from (Crystal River Investors in Crystal River,
Florida.
(ec) On or about January 20, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defeadant ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing busi-
ness as West Central Florida Development Corporation,
caused defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER, doing busi-
ness as ( & ( Associates, to enter into a contract with
another individual in which defendant WILLIAM M.
CONOVER agreed to perform certain landscaping work
at a condominium complex owned by defendant ANTHONY
R. TANNER through Crystal River Investors in exchange
for a fee.
(d) In or about March, 1981, defendant WILLIAM
M. CONOVER had a conversation with defendant AN-
THONY R. TANNER and a representative of Florida
State Engineers, Ine.
(e) On or about March 9, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER caused a
check of the following tenor and description to be written
and given to defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER:
Check Number 162, drawn on the account of Anthony
Tanner and Marglen Tanner at the First Federal
Savings and Loan Association of Brooksville, Brooks-
ville, Florida, dated March 9, 1981, payable to C & C
Associates, in the amouni of $10,085.
(f) Om or about Mareh 25, 1981, defendant WIL-
LIAM M. CONOVER had a telephone conversation with
another employee of Seminole Mleetrie.
(zg) On or about March 26, 1981, defendant AN-
THONY R. TANNER had a conversation with an em-
ployee of Seminole Electric in Citra, Florida.
(h) On or about April 2, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER caused a purchase
order for road fill material valued at $199,500 to be issued
to defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing business as
Citrus Sand & Clay.
(i) On or about April 8, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER wrote and submitted
a memorandum to another employee of Seminole Electric
concerning the road fill material co..tract.
(j) On or about April 15, 1981, defendants WIL-
LIAM M. CONOVER and ANTHONY R. TANNER trav-
elled together from Crystal River, Florida, to the Ba-
hamas.
(k) On or about April 29, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER issued a bid solicita-
tion in regard to the two read construction contracts.
(1) On or about May 7, 1981, at Tampa, Florida, de-
fendant ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing business as Citrus
Sand and Clay, submitted bids to Seminole Eleetrie on the
road construction contracts.
(m) On or about May 7, 1981, defendant WILLIAM
M. CONOVER had a conversation with another employee
of Seminole Electric in Tampa, Florida.
(n) On or about May 10, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendants WILLIAM M. CONOVER, doing busi-
ness as C & C Associates, and ANTHONY R. TANNER,
————~ doing business as West Central Florida Development Cor-
poration, entered into a contract in which defendant WIL-
LIAM M. CONOVER agreed to manage a condominium
complex for defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER in ex-
change for a fee.
(o) On or about May 13, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER caused a
check of the following tenor and description to be written
and given to defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER:
Check Number 257, drawn on the account of Anthony
Tanner and Marglen Tanner at the First Federal
Savings and Loan Association of Brooksville, Brooks-
ville, Florida, dated May 13, 1981, payable to C & C
Associates, in the amount of $6,000.
(p) On or about May 14, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER caused defendant
ANTHONY R. TANNER, doing business as Citrus Sand
and Clay, to be awarded the road fill material contract
in an amount of approximately $1,041,817, and the road
construction contract in an amount of approximately
$548,000.
(gq) On or about May 14, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER obtained
title to a condominium from defendant ANTHONY R.
TANNER, doing business as Crystal River Lnvestors.
(r) In or about June, 1981, defendant ANTHONY
R. TANNER had a conversation with an individual in
Crystal River, Florida.
ll
(s) In or about June, 1981, defendant WILLIAM
M. CONOVER had a conversation with several individuals
in Crystal River, Florida.
(t) In or about July, 1981, defendant WILLIAM
M. CONOVER had a conversation with another employee
of Seminole Electric in Tampa, Florida.
(u) On or about July 9, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER wrote and submitted
a memorandum to another employee of Seminole Electric
concerning a change in the road fil! material contract.
(v) On or about July 18, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER caused a
check of the following tenor and description to be written
and given to defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER:
Check Number 473, drawn on the account of West
Centrai Florida Dev t Corporation at the First
Marion Bank, Ocala, ida, dated July 18, 1981,
payable to C & C Associates, in an amount of $2,000.
(w) On or about July 27, 1981, at Tampa, Florida,
defendant WILLIAM M,. CONOVER wrote and submitted
a memorandum to another employee of Seminole Electric
concerning -he specifications for the road fill material
contract.
(x) On or about September 4, 1981, at Crystal River,
Florida, defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER caused a
check of the following tenor and description to be written
and given to defendant WILLIAM M. CONOVER:
Check Number 594, drawn on the account of West
Central Florida Development Corporation at the First
Marion Bank, Ocala, Florida, dated September 4, 1981,
payable to C & C Associates in an amount of $2,965,
(y) On or about November 9, 1981, defendant WIL.
LIAM M. CONOVER had a conversation with a Special
Agent of the Federal Bureau of Investigation in Tampa,
Florida.
(2) The Grand Jury realleges and ineorporates by
reference the allegations of Counts Two through Six as
overt acts as though fully set forth herein.
All in violation of Title 18, United States Code, See-
tion 371.
COUNT TWO
1. Beginning in or about January, 1980, and continu.
ing to in or about January, 1982, at Tampa and Crystal
River, in the Middle Distriet of Florida and elsewhere,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY BR. TANNER,
defendants herein, knowingly devised and intended to de-
Vise a scheme and artifice to defraud:
(a) the United States by impeding, impairing, ob-
structing and defeating the lawful function of the Rural
Electrification Administration in its administration
and enforcement of its guaranteed joan program: and
(b) Seminole Eleetrie Cooperative, Ine, of its
right to have its process and procedures for the pro-
curement of materials, equipment and serviees
honestly and free from deceit, corruption and f
and of its right to the honest and faithful serviees of
its employees.
2. The substance of the scheme and artifice and its
manner and means are described in paragraphs | through 5
and 10 through 16 of Count One of this Indictment, and the
Grand Jury realleges and incorporates by reference those
paragraphs as though fully set forth herein.
4. On or about April 22, 1981,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY RB. TANNER,
defendants herein, for the purpose of executing the afore-
said scheme and artifice to defraud, and attempting to do
so, knowingly caused to be delivered by mail in the Middle
District of Florid ee On Gen danetl ' =
envelope containing a letter, which envelope and letter were
addressed to:
Seminole Electric Cooperative, Ine.
2410 East Buseh Boulevard
Tampa, Florida 39612
Attention: Mr. Bill Conover
In violation of Title 15, United States Code, Section
1341.
OCUUNT THREE
1. The Grand Jury realleges and incorporates by ref.
erence paragraphs one and two of Count Two of this Indict-
ment as theugh fully set forth herein.
2. Un or about May 4, 1981,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY RB. TANNER,
defendants herein, for the purpose of executing the afore.
said scheme and artifice to defraud, and attempting to do
“4
so, knowingly caused to be delivered by mail in the Middle
District of Florida, aceording to the directions thereon, an
envelope containing a letter, which envelope and letter were
ackiressed to:
Mr. William M. Conover
Procurement Manager
Seminole Eleetrie Cooperative, Ine.
Post Office Box 17100
Tampa, Florida 23682
In violation of Tithe 4, United States Code, Section
1341.
COUNT POUR
1. The Grand Jury realleges and incorporates by ref-
erence paragraphs one and two of Count Two of this Indici-
ment as thengh fully set forth herein.
2. (mn or about May 11, 1981,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
amd
ANTHONY BR. TANNER,
defendants herein, for the purpose of executing the afore-
said scheme and artifice to defraud, and attempting to de so,
knowingly cau-ed to be delivered by mail in the Middle Dis-
triet of Florida, according to the directions thereon, an en-
velope containing a letter, which envelope and letter were
addressed to:
Mr. William M. Conower
Procurement Manager
Seminole Flectrie Cooperative, Ine.
Post Offiee Box 17100
Tampa, Flerida 33682
15
In violation of Title 18, Uyited States Code, Section
‘
1341. ;
COUNT FIVE
1. The Grand Jury realleges and incorporates by ref-
erence paragraphs one and two of Count Two of this Indict-
ment as though fully set forth herein.
2. On or about May 14, 1981, at Tampa, Florida, in the
Middle District of Florida,
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY R. TANNER,
defendants herein, for the purpose of executing the afore-
said scheme and artifice to defraud, and attempting to do
so, knowingly did place and cause to be placed in an author-
ized depository for mail matter to be delivered by the
United States Postal Service, an envelope containing a
mailgram addressed to:
Citrus Sand and Clay
Attn Kim Marphy
P. O. Box 2093
Crystal River, FL 32661
In violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section
1341.
COUNT SLX
On or about June 3, 1981, at Tampa, Florida, in the
Middle District of Florida,
16
WILLIAM M. CONOVER
and
ANTHONY R. TANNER,
defendants herein, did willfully and knowingly make and
cause to be made false, fictitious and fraudulent statements
concerning material facts in a matter within the jurisdiction
of the Rural Electrification Administration, an agency of
the United States, in a ‘‘Certification and Recommenda-
tion of Negotiating Committee’’ submitted by Seminole
Electric Cooperative, Inc., to the Rural Electrification Ad-
ministration in Washington, D.C., in connection with the
fill material contract, in which defendants stated and repre-
sented and caused to be stated and represented the follow-
ing:
(1) the *‘informal bidding procedure’’ had been fol-
lowed;
(2) bidding had been done on REA approved plans,
specifications and cvaluatioas ; and
(3) each qualified bidder had had an equal opportunity
to negotiate ;
whereas in truth and fact as the defendants then knew:
(1) the ‘‘informal bidding procedure’’ had not been
followed ;
(2) bidding had not been done on REA approved plans,
specifications and evaluations; and
(3) each qualified bidder had not had an equal oppor.
tunity to negotiate ;
17
In violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections
1001 and 2.
A TRUE BILL,
FOREMAN
ROBERT W. MERKLE
United States Attorney
By: /s/ Terry A. Zitek
Assistant United States Attorney
By: /s/ George E. Tragos
Chief, Criminal Division
18
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff, Case No.
= 83-70-Cr-T-08
WILLIAM M. CONOVER and Renny
ANTHONY R. TANNER, Ares be Japan
Defendants.
VOLUME EIGHT
TRANSCRIPT OF TRIAL PROCEEDINGS
BEFORE THE HONORABLE BEN KRENTZMAN
AND A JURY
| Appearances omitted in printing]
(p. 8-96) MR. ZITEK: Thank you, your Honor.
Our next witness is Mr. Alexander Sherman.
THE CLERK: Come forward and be sworn.
Are you the witness Mr. Sherman?
MR. SHERMAN: Yes, I am.
THE CLERK: Raise your right hand.
ALEXANDER E. SHERMAN, GOVERNMENT'S WIT-
NESS, SWORN
THE CLERK: Please be seated in the witness box.
Please state your name for the record and spell your
last name.
THE WITNESS: Alexander E. Sherman, S-h-e-r-
m-a-n.
19
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. ZITEK:
Q Could you tell us by whom you are employed?
A Employed with the Rural Electrification Admini-
stration.
Q Where is your office located?
A Washington, D.C.
Q What is your present title?
A Chief of the distribution and transmission engi-
neering branch.
Between 1980 and 1981, what was you position with
REA?
AI was the Chief of the power transmission branch.
Q As Chief of the power transmission branch, would
you tell(p. 8-97) us what your duties were back then!
A Yes, I coordinated the activities—the borrower's
activities related to transmission construction, and that’s
nationwide.
Q How long have you worked for REA?
A For 19 years.
Q And have you received a college education!
A Yes, B.S. Degree in Engineering from Lowell
Technological Institute.
@ Mr. Sherman, is the Rural Electrification Admini-
stration part of another branch of the Government?
A It’s part of the United States Department of Agri-
culture.
@ Are you familiar with a program that REA par
ticipates in known as the Guaranteed Loan Program?!
A Yes.
Q And, could you tell us briefly what that program
is?
A The program was established by Congress hack
about ten years ago to supplement the existing loan pro-
gram, and essentially Congress authorizezd REA to guar-
antee loans from other lending institutions.
Q And, could you tell us how that program works?
A Essentially REA reached an agreement with the
Federal Financing Bank at the same time where the Fed-
eral Financing Bank would raise money and be a resource
for those funds as an outside lending institution. Other
lending institutions (p. 8-98) could also participate in the
program, but the Federal Finance’s Bank interest rate is
so much more lower that 99 percent of the loans made were
made through the Federal Finaneing Bank. The guaran-
teed program is available to all REA borrowers who apply
for loans.
Q And, how do they go about applying for loans!
A They—first, of course, they have to qualify as an
REA borrower, and that’s —one qualification is to serve
rural areas under the Act. And, the seeond thing would
be to come forth with a project, that is, a power supply
project that is feasible, economical and effective to supply
21
rural areas; they would then apply for a loan, they would
send in a loan application.
Q If the loan application is approved, what happens
after that?
A Onee the loan application is approved, the loan
documents, loan contracts, mortgage notes are sent back
to the borrower for execution. Also a commitment—I guess
they made a commitment to F.F.B. for the money. And
then after that, then the borrower will deal strictly with
REA as an agent for the Federal Financing Bank.
Q Mr. Sherman, are you familiar with a company
known as Seminole Electric Cooperative !
A Yee
Q Do you know if Seminole Electrie Cooperative has
or is (p. 8-°S) participating in the Guaranteed Loan Pro-
gram with REA?
A Yes.
Q I've placed in front of you two Exhibits, 1-A and
1-H. Do those appear to be the loa» contract and the mort-
gage that was entered into between Seminole and REA?
A Yes, they appear to be.
Q Now, with regard to a company known as Semi-
nole Electric, have you, in your capacity as an employee
of the REA, had occasion to deal with the Seminole Elee-
trie Company itself?
A Yes.
Q Could you tell us what the nature of your relation-
ship has been with Seminole Electric?
A Seminole Electric—my involvement has been with
the transmission lines coming out of the power plant and
the planning, design, construction of those lines.
Q Did your responsibility include any patrol roads
beneath the transmission line as well as the transmission
lines themselves!
A Yea.
Q In dealing with Seminole Electric, were there any
individuals at Seminole Electric that you dealt with more
than others!
A Yes.
Q And, who are the people you dealt with?
A Bob Claussen, Bob Ross, Bill Conover, Roger Pile
and there were several others underneath.
(p. $100) y Did you know what position Bill Cono-
ver held with Seminole Electric!
A He was their, | guess, Chief Procurement Officer.
Q When you dealt with these people, was this in
person or over the phone!
A Over the phone, mostly.
Q Now, with regard to the relationship between
REA and Seminole Electric after one of these loan con.
tracts are entered into, does the REA have any kind of
publications that it issues to its borrowers telling them
or interpreting their rights and responsibilities under
these loan documents that you have in front of you?
A Yes.
Q What are those publications called!
A Bulletins.
Q Is there one that deals particularly with the
building of transmission line facilities!
A Yes.
Q What's the number of that one!
A 404.
Q In your dealings with Seminole Electric as well
as the other borrowers, do you from time to time, talk to
them about the provisions of REA Bulletin 40-6!
A Yes.
Q Now, under the provisions of the loan contract,
mortgage (p. 8-101) and these bulletins, are some contracts
that the borrower wants to enter into subject to some kind
of prior approval before they can be awarded to a con-
tractor!
A Yes.
Q And could you tell us how that approval procedure
works with regard to REA?
A All right. REA has—there are several contracts
that are subject to REA approval and several that are
not. Under the normal—normal situation, the Lorrower
would prepare plans and specifications, whether it be
transmission line or clearing, and send those into REA
and get those approved prior to releasing them to bidders,
and then they would go ahead and release to bidders, the
bids would be received, they would then award the con-
tract to the low responsible bidder and seml those con-
tracts to REA for approval if they're subject to REA
approval.
Q In this particular case, are you familiar with a
spreading contract that was awarded to a company known
as Citrus Sand and Clay?
A Yes.
Q And could you tell us how you are familiar with
that contract!
A That contract—the contract was actually preceeded
by another contract for the clearing of the transmission
line. In this other contract, the road building appeared
to be a lot (p. 8-102) larger than was anticipated, it was
gving to require a lot more fill dirt and spreading, so they
entered into a separate contract to-—to purchase fill and
another contract to spread this fill over the—for building
roads underneath the transmission lines. And, the bor-
rowers contacted us and discussing what contract for him
to use and possibly what bidding procedure.
Y Toth | of your knowledge, were both the fill
contract ane *) «) «cling contract that had followed the
award to Jos wontraets that were part of the loan
guarantee funds.
A Yes.
() Now, are there also some contracts to be awarded
by a borrower which don’t require specific prior REA
approval before they are put out on the street or awarded
to contractors!
A Yes.
Have you, with regard to Seminole Electric, from
time to time, gotten involved in negotiations with Semi-
nole Electric over contracts that did not specifically re-
quire REA approval!
A Discussions with them, yes.
Q Can you give us an example of that, of a contract
where that occurred !
A In the—prior to construction of the line, there
were several contracts issued on materials to go into the
line. One of the such contracts was for steel poles te go
in a certain section of the line that required aesthetic
structures. (p. 8-103) These steel poles were awarded to
a company under a negotiated bid procedure, the contracts
were then submitted to REA for review and for file. And,
I don’t know is this specific contract required REA ap-
proval or not. There were two different contract forms
they used for materials.
However, there was a problem with—that we saw
with one of the exceptions that one of the bidders—the
low bidder took on the contract, and we questioned the
exception taken. and I don't think it's been reselwed today.
Q Mr. Sherman, when you say you questioned it, did
you contact somebody at Seminole!
A Yes, I think we contacted Bill Conover.
Q Now, in addition to the Journagan contract and
the spreading contract, did you also have some kind of
review authority over the contract that was known by
Seminole as the Hunter Road North construction contract!
A Yea.
Q With regard to the fill material contract, did you
—<lid you ever receive a copy of that contract?
26
A Yes.
Q Before that contract was awarded, do you recall
having a conversation with anybody at Seminole Electric
about what to do about bidding that contract!
A Yes. I had conversations sometime in March, I
guess, of “S1. I believe, where they—they had contacted
me regarding (p. 8-104) the fact that they were going to
have to go out and get a separate contract for fill material.
Q And, when you say “They,” who are you talking
about?
A Exeuse me, I think it was Bob Claussen and Bob
Ross, I believe.
Q Okay. Could you tell us what the conversation
was between yourself, Mr. Claussen and Mr. Ross?
A They—
MR. MILBRATH: Excuse me, your Honor, this is
obviously hearsay.
MR. ZITEK: Judge, we're not offering this for the
truth but simply to show what took place, what conversa-
tions took place.
MR. MILBRATH: Obviowsly, then, the content
shoukin't be made public. I think that the people that
had the conversation should talk about what they said.
MR. ZITEK: Well, he is one of the people that had
the conversation, Judge.
THE COURT: I'm going to overrule the objection,
and it will be received not for the truth of the content bat
for the fact that # conversation of this type did occur.
It's a procedural matter. I'll overrule your objection.
a
BY MR. ZITEK:
Q Tell us what the conversation was, Mr. Sherman.
A The conversation entailed Seminole looking for,
one, what (p. 8-105) contract form to use for the fill;
and, two, bidding procedure to use in obtaining the fill.
And, | made some recommendations and they followed
them.
() What were vour recommendations!
A Recommendations were that they use a materials
contract form, which was Form 173, and that they use
informal competitive bidding procedure.
Q Does—informal bidding procedure, is that a «pe-
cial term that REA uses!
A That is « separate bidding procedure. REA has
three distinet bidding procedures.
Q What are they!
A Ome is formal bidding procedure, it has a public
bid opening; the second procedure is an informal bedding
procedure which does not have a public bid opening bet
the end result is that the low bid hax te be fully compliont
with the «pees, but there is some room in ther® to neeo
tiate in terms of the bidding; and the third bedding pre
cedure is the negotiated bidding procedure.
Q With regard to the fill contract, what proceedure
did Seminole indicate to you that they were going te ase!
A The informal bikling procedure
Q When they indicated that they were going te uve
that, did you tell Mr. Ross or Mr. Claussen what steps
they were te fellow if they elected te ase the informal com-
petitive bedding (p. §-106) precedare !
A Ne, they were familiar with the informal com-
petitive bidding proeedere. Seminole ssed it many times
in its power plant construction.
\ New, Mr. Sherman, with regard te the procedure
whereby a company goes about getting a release of funds,
can you tell us how that works, if you know?
A REA has a badget procedure where in order to get
mivance —I think is what you mean— advance of lean funds
from RELA, they need te submnit seme decament or some-
thing. contract, purchase orders, requests for these funds
to be appreved fer adwamee. And, omee the document
comes in and found acceptable, the money is approved for
advance ami the herrower submits a series of requisitions
to obtain these funds.
Q Is that the proceedure that Neminele was following
in this case, the procedure vou deseribed !
A Yea.
MR. ZITEK: | have ne further questions, Judge.
THE COURT: You may examine.
MR. LAZZARA: Thank you, your Honor.
CRUSS-EXAMIN ATION
BY MR. LAZZARA:
Goel afternoon, Mr. Sherman.
A Geed afterneen.
2
Q You mentioned that some contracts are subject to
REA (p. 8-107) approval and some are not, is that correct?
A That’s correct.
Q 1 have a document here for you. I'll just give
this to you here, I may be asking you some questions
about it.
(Document handed to the witness. )
Now, you mentioned—you testified that apparently
beth contracts, meaning the spreading contract and the
fill material contract, that Citrus had with Seminole were
part of the Loan Guarantee Fund, is that correct!
A That’s correct.
Q How did you determine that! How did you make
that determination?
A Well, I determined it on the basis that REA had
made a loan to Seminole for power plant and transmis-
sion lines, and the activities relating to the construction
of transmission lines, if it’s access roads or whatever, are
normally funded by REA.
@ Okay. Well, did you research any documents with
regard to these particular contracis !
A No.
Q Was the REA—did the REA have any documents
showing that these two contracts you just testified about
were, in fact, part of the Loan Guaranteed Funds?
A No.
() So, was it your opinion that-—
(p. 8-108) A Except the loan—you know, the loan
contract, we loaned the money for the transmission lines
and normally we provide for whatever it takes to build the
transmission line. The loans do not get—a lot of times
get that detailed into real small pieces of the project.
Q All right. You mentioned the Journagan contract.
First you have the Journagan contract and then the Citrus
contract, correct!
A Correct.
Q You testified that the road building with regard to
the Journagan contract was a lot larger than it was antici-
pated to be?
A The road building part of it, correct.
Q And, were you in contact with Seminole during that
period of time about the problems associated with the per-
formance of the Journagan contract?
A Yes.
All right. Was that on a daily basis?
No.
And who would you be in contact with?
Bob Ross or Bob Claussen.
They’re with the Engineering Department?
> © > & FP ©
That’s correct.
Q And as a result of that, to your knowledge, was the
plant schedule behind ©chedule?
(p. 8-109) A No. As far as we knew at that time, the
plant was still on schedule. The transmission line was
butting up against the schedule.
!
31
Q Okay. To your knowledge, if the transmission line
fell behind schedule, would that affect the plant schedule?
A Yes, probably.
Q And in your capacity at that time with the REA,
did you feel that it was in the best interest of the REA
with regard to the loan guarantee that all impediments in
getting that plant on schedule be removed, if possible?
A That is correct. .
Q Now, you mentioned that in March of 1981 you had
a conversation with both Mr. Claussen and Mr. Ross, is that
correct?
A Yes.
Q All right. Did you document that conservation in
any way whatsoever!
A Imay have. I may have. There were several let-
ters written in the file on the problems with the road.
Q Okay. Do you recall when that conversation took
place?
A In March, as | understand, best | can recollect.
Q Do you recall whether it was the latter part or the
mid-part or do you know?
A No.
Q And what they were concerned about was the fill
material contract, is that correct?
(p. 8-110) A They were concerned about the fill ma-
terial contract and what was best to keep the project
moving.
32
Q Okay. And you mentioned you made some recom-
mendations to them?
A Yes.
Q Were your recommendations binding on them!
A. As far as the materials contract, it could have used
a purchase order and we could have forced the issue. As
far as the bidding procedure, that was pretty well their re-
quest to use a bidding procedure, and I suggested one. We
worked it out together and it was as binding as could be,
I guess, that they followed.
Q Could they have, under REA bidding procedures
and under 40-6, have gone out and negotiated with people
just to get fill if they wanted to without bidding it out?
A Yes. Informal quotes—they could have used infor-
mal quotes.
) So, under the REA 40-6, they didn’t necessarily
have to bid it out?
A No, they had that choice. They had a choice of
formal bidding or informal quotes, they took a compromise.
() With regard to the fill material contract itself, I
believe you said it was 173?
A Right, REA Form 173, Materials Contract.
q And you have before you Exhibit 3-N, | believe,
which is (p. 8-111) the Fill Material Contract with Citrus,
sir?
A Yes.
Q And, is that on a form-——Form 173?
A Yes, it is.
:
.
:
Q Okay. And, did that specific contract require REA
approval?
A This specific contract does not require REA ap-
proval.
Q And, to your—who is Mr. Frank Bennett, sir?
A Frank Bennett is presently Director of the North
Central area in Washington.
Q What was his position back during this period of
time that we're talking about!
A He was Director of Power Supply Division, under
which I worked.
Q Allright. Was he superior to you, sir!
A Yes.
Q Do you recall whether or not Mr. Bennett ever
gave a written opinion to Seminole to the effeet that that
contract, 3-N, did not require REA approval?
MR. ZITEK: Judge, | object, it’s beyond the scope
of Direct and I think it’s irrelevant.
THE COURT: I'l) sustain the objection. And dis-
regard the question, please.
BY MR. LAZZARA:
Q With regard to the spreading contract, did that
require (p. 8-112) REA approval?
A That contract was executed on a Form 205 and
that required REA approval.
Q Allright. Under REA procedures, was it required
that the proposed contract that was to be sent out for bid
be first submitted to you?
ot
A For our review, right.
Q To your knowledge, was a copy of that contract
sent to you for your review before it was let out for bids!
A I don’t know. That’s all I can say, I don’t know.
I have no record of—norwmally if plans and specifications
are submitted to REA for review prior to issuance, then
REA would officially approve it in writing, and 1 have no
records that I can recall.
Q I'm going to hand you what's been marked as Mr.
Conover Exhibit No. 33, sir, and ask you to look at that
particular document.
(Document handed to the witness.)
A Yes.
Q Do you recognize that particular document, sir!
A Well, it’s a letter from William Conover to me,
but whether I recognize it or not, I don’t know.
Q Allright. Under what date is it, sir!
A April 14, 1981.
Q To your knowledge, does it relate to the right-of.
way (p. 8-113) road construction contract that was to be let
by Seminole?
A The date would place it to be that contract.
Q Okay. And, to your knowledge, was it the normal
practice of the REA to receive letters of this type from
Seminole requesting REA‘s review and approval of such
contracts!
A Yes.
Q And, to your knowledge, was this letter received by
you as an official of the REA in the normal course of
REA’s business dealings with Seminole!
A 1 don’t know if i received it.
Q Is it addressed to you!
A Yes, it is.
Q If such a letter was addressed to you, would you
have normally received it and reviewed it—
A Yes.
Y —and acted upon it!
A 1 normally would have.
MR. LAZZARA: Your Honor, at this time | move
into evidence Mr. Conover’s Exhibit No. 33.
MR. ZITEK: Judge, | have to object.
THE COURT: De you want to be heard!
MR. LAZZARA: Yes, sir.
(Proeeedings had at sidebar.)
THE COURT: Didn't this, in fact come from the
REA reeords!
(p. 8114) MR. LAZZARA: Came from Seminole’:
records, but it’s a letter addressed from Mr. Sherman to
Mr. Conover.
THE COURT: He didn’t know whether he normally
would have gotten it if it had been mailed. You knew, if
anything, why doen't you have Seminole put it in if it came
from their records?
MR. LAZZAKA: Judge, at this time—maybe I should
have approached the bench before—there are certain docu-
ments | would like to get in through this man, and, of
course, it would be outside the scope of Direct Examina-
tion. I've shown them te Mr. Zitek, he said, ‘Well, you
can try." 1 don't want to waste the time of the Court or
the jury. '
THE COURT: Well, if it will save his time from
coming back, you can take him on Direct. You may have
forgotten how to do that.
MR. LAZZARA: Judge, | thought | did a pretty good
job this time in trying to get it im.
THE COURT: Yes, | guess it was, Well, I'm not
criticizing you for cross-examining, but I'm saying it's
been a long time since I've beard you ask anybody a ques-
tion on Direct, and vou get in bad habits, «pending two
weeks cross e\amining.
MR. ZITEK: Judge, I don’t have any objection if Mr.
Lazzara wants to produce records of thie witness. He's
got to be able to identify them.
(p. 8115) THE COURT: Well, I'm going to sus-
tain the objection. He can't qualify it as anybody's reeord.
But, if you've got semebhady whe ean, I'll let you take him
on Direct and see if you can get it in.
MR. LAZZARA: | wanted to seck to introduce
through this man the letter that Mr. Bennett sent to Mr.
Wright with regard to the area of approval -REA'* po
sition with regard to approval.
THE COURT: Do you know if he knows anything
about it!
37
MR. LAZZARA: We discussed it with him at the
last trial.
MR. BEST: If that letter came from the REA files,
we sure—
THE COURT: It was a copy of a letter!
MR. BEST: Yes, it was pursuant to a subpoena to
Mr. Bennett at the last trial.
MK. ZITEK: Judge, that letter was Mr. Bennett's
opinion. | think Mr. Bennett's opinion is irrelevant and
it's cumulative.
THE COURT: Ise Mr. Bennett here!
MR. BEST: Mr. Bennett hasn't been subpoenaed
yet.
THE COURT: Thee time!
MR. BEST: He was here last time bat not this time.
MR. LAZZARA: Judge, I'l) just
(p. &116) MR. BEST: They came from hi« file.
THE COURT: Well, that would be hearsay objection
but net necessarily an objection on the groumls of expres
sion of opinion.
MR. BEST: Yes, sir, | enderstand.
THE COURT: Se, what do you want te de!
MK. LAZZARA: Judge, IU try to authenticate some
decuments. (an | take him as if he were on Direct at thin
tome!
THE COURT: Yes. But, don't disclose the content
of the Exhibit becanse if it’s not held to be admissible, it's
not admissible.
MR. LAZZARA: I waderstand.
THE COURT: All right. I'll sustain the objection
to this question mean, to this Exhibit, this is—
MR. LAZZARA: Exhibit 33.
THE COURT: The Government's Exhibit 33 no,
Conover's 33. I'll sustain this one.
(End of discussion at sidebar.)
THE COURT: Now, I have sustained the objection
to that proposed—'onover's Exhibit 33. It has not been
established as a business record and it’s not otherwise
admissible.
All right, sir.
MR. LAZZARA:; Thank you, sir.
CROSS. EXAMINATION
(p. $123) BY MR. MILBRATH,
Q Good afternoon, Mr. Sherman,
A Good afternoon.
Q Mr. Sherman, which agency of the Government was
actually the agency that agreed to provide the money for
the construction (p. 8-124) of that power plant!
A Federal Financing Bank.
”
either buy the material by informal quotes from suppliers
or it could let it out for bids?
A Yes, | advised him those were the two options and
recommended the bidding, which they recommended, tov.
Q And they decided to do just that, to bid it?
A Teo bid it.
Q And you asked to se the executed contract when
it was signed!
MR. MILBRATH: Yes, sir.
(p. 127) BY MR. MILBRATH,
Q Did you evaluate the contract when it came in,
sir?
A We reviewed the evaluation.
Q Now, there was a time, was there not, when you
were involved in the decision as to whether the spreading
contract as opposed to the fill dirt contract would have to
be approved by the REA, is that treet
A No, there wae se—it was decided that it would have
to be approved and that was it, there was no discussion.
Q Now, do you recall there being some question in
the REA as to whether that contract did have to be ap
proved!
4
MR. ZITEK: Judge, I object, it's beyond the scope
of Direct.
MR. MILBRATH: Your Honor, I think he testified
about the appreval of the contract.
THE COURT: Yes, sir, that’s it. And, he just said
again that they didn't make that requirement, and that's it.
I'll sustain the objection.
BY MR. MILBRATH:
Q Was there a disagreement with—
THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection to that ques.
tion and don") ask it again,
BY MR. MILBRATH:
Q Whe was your boss at that time!
A Mr. Prank Bennett.
(p. 8128) Q Now, you testified that the contract
would have to be on a Form 208, is that correct, the spread.
ing contract!
A That is correct.
Q Whose decision was that, that it had to be on a
Form 203!
A Both Seminoles and mine.
Q Did you tell Seminole or did they ask you what
form it had te be on!
A 28 Porm was weed for the Journagan contract,
amd, therefore, it was nature to use the 200 Form for thes
contract.
¥ Is there a REA Form, sir, for spreading of fill
dirt?
A Not a form entitled spreading of fill dirt, no, sir.
y The Form 200 is essentially a right-of-way clear-
ing contract, is it not!
A That ix correct.
Q New, on what do you hase your decision that the
right—that the spreading contract was subject to REA
approval in the first place!
A Transmission construction for power supply bor-
rowers requires REA approval.
Y Im sorry.
A Contracts for transmission construction for power
supply borrowers require REA approval.
Q And where does it say that?
A Seetien 40-4
y Se, you're relying on a particular provision, 40-6?
(Pp S129) A Yes, and my experience.
y De you hawe that with you, sir, 40-6 that you re-
lied on?
AL have a copy here.
Y Could yee find for es that provision that you're
relying epon that says the spreading contract was subject
(eo approval!
A De you want me to dig out my copy?
43
Q If you don’t mind. If you have it there available.
Let me just show you mine, I think this is—
A They should be the same.
(Document handed to the witness.)
Would you like me to go on now?
Q Could you find the—
THE COURT: I'd like for you to answer the ques
tion, if you can. The question is, ean you find—upon what
in there do you rely upon for your decisions! That’s what
he wanted to know.
THE WITNESS: There’s a section in there entitled
“REA Approval of Borrower's Construction.’’ Section
C, ‘*Requiremeuts concerning REA approval of plans and
specifications in contracts for the purchase of materials
and equipment and for construction are summarized in the
enclosed exhibit form.’’
BY MR. MILBRATH:
Q And, the exhibit is attached to that, is it not?
A The exhibit is attached to it.
Q All right. Would you turn to that exhibit showing
where (p. 8-130) it says that that kind of contract would
be subject to REA approval?
A Under ‘*Transmission,’’ Transmission Form 831
requires REA approval.
Q What isa Form 831?
A That is the transmission construction.
Q That's not the form that you used on this contract,
though, was it?
44
A No, Form 203.
Is there anything on Exhibit 1 or Exhibit I, which
ever it is, that says anything about Form 203%
A Form 203 was not available at the time this 40-6
was prepared and was not added to it—it does not show
up there.
Q So, it doesn’t say that Form 203’s are subject to
REA’s approval, does it?
A Form 203 says that.
Q Where does Form 203 say that?
A At the end of the contract form, it’s subject to
REA approval, there’s a clause in the contract,
Q Well, where in your REA 40-6 does it say that that
kind of contract falls within a Form 203 that has to he
subject to approval?
A Under ‘‘ Transmission ¢ ‘onstruction.’’
THE COURT: He answered the question.
BY MR. MILBRATH:
(p. 8-131) Q And the provision you're relying upon
is the one you just quoted, Roman Numeral I11C.5?
A That's correct.
Q Now, is there anything in the definition of “‘Trans-
mission Construction,” sir, that relates to patrol roads?
A Transmission construction would—that would be
part of the transmission construction.
Q Is that defined in your REA Bulletin there!
ce ee _ —_
a a
45
A No, transmission is not defined.
Q Okay. So, you're basing that on your experience
A Correct.
Q Is it true that there’s no documents that you know
of in existence at the REA that gives the definition of
transmission lines and includes within that definition dirt
roads under them?
A No.
Q Is that true or not?
A That’s true.
Q So would it also be true that essentially—in your
opinion, that the spreading contract was covered by REA
approval was based upon your experience in dealing with
the REA?
A Construction of transmission lines, that’s correct.
Q And not upon any regulations that explicitly say
that?
A The regulations refer to transmission lines and
transmission facilities, and these would be included as
covered, in my opinion and in my experience.
(p. 8-132) Q Now, I'll show you Tanner's Exhibits
3 and 4 for identification.
(Documents handed to the witness. )
Don't tell us what the contents are yet, just tell us
whether or not you recognize seeing those before !
A Yes.
46
Q Are those memoranda on the stationery of the
United States Department of Agriculture?
A One is, the other doesn’t show it.
Q And are both documents documents maintained
and kept in the regular course of business of the REA?
A Yes, I recognize both documents.
Q And are they the kind of documents and memo.
randa that are maintained in the regular course of busi-
ness of REA?
A Yes.
Q Is the regular practice of the REA to maintain
and keep such documents—
A Yes.
Q —as a permanent business record of the REA?
A Yes.
MR. MILBRATH: Your Honor, at this time I will
offer into evidence Exhibits 3 and 4 of Mr. Tanner.
MR. ZITEK: Judge, I object on a couple of grounds.
Can we approach a sidebar!
THE COURT: You may. Now, I think they are busi-
ness (p. 8-133) records and for otherwise admissible and
established. If they're relevant, we'll find out.
(Proceedings had at sidebar. )
MR. ZITEK: Judge, these two documents appear to
go to try to prove that people in REA were talking to one
another about how they were going to handle some of
these particular contracts. How, within REA, they were
47
going to treat these contracts is totally irrelevant to the
issues in this case.
The fact is, they have to prove that Seminole abided
by these rules and regulations. Mr. Milbrath is trying to
create a defense out of nothing.
THE COURT: Well, I don’t think you need to go
much further.
MR. MILBRATH: Can I respond to that?
THE COURT: No, sir. Let me tell you this, I’ve
ruled on thie previously, that’s not an issue in this case
for the jury, certainly. It may be you offer them, and I'm
going to sustain the objection, they're not relevant.
This is not a mortgage foreclosure, this is a criminal
prosecution. And, maybe there might be that highly tech-
nical argument that something might not have required
REA approval in the first place, but we passed that about
~—well, when I denied the Motion to dismiss, | guess.
MR. MILBRATH: Your Honor, it does bear upon
this person's credibility, as well as this person has testi
fied on (p. 8-134) the request of Mr. Zitek that these con.
tracts are subject to REA approval solely on the basis of
his experience.
THE COURT: Well, vou brought that out, and that's
a collateral issue altogether. You're testing his opinion
about that. Now, you're testing his experience and his
opinion, and | must say, based on the reasoning he’s given,
I think he’s correct, and I think you take the position other
wise. So, I don't think this is a jury issue of credibility
It’s not whether he once told somebody black is white and
now he's saying white is black, that's credibility.
MR. MILBRATH: I think this is admissible for
several reasons, and for the record I'd like to explain why.
THE COURT: You may.
MR. MILBRATH: Number one, these records go to
whether or not this witness should be believed by the jury
statement that he thinks these were subject to approval.
The documents will show, in fact, that there is a dispute
within the REA as to whether or not the contracts were
subject to approval at all, and I think that’s a vital issuc
from the jurisdiction of —
THE COURT: Well, we're right where we started. |
said this was an issue made on a motion to dismiss ai the
earliest stages of the game. It had no jurisdiction, 1 de.
nied it. I found as a matter of law they do have jurisdic.
tion, and it’s not for the jury to decide that, it's not a jury
issue in this case.
Government had no jurisdiction in this ease, of course, it
49
might be to your advantage. Burt, it’s not going to a jury
issue in this case.
MR. MILBRATH: Well, if it’s not an issue, then I
move to strike this witness's testimony in its entirety and
I move for a mistrial.
THE COURT: No, sir, because he’s talked about
several things.
MR. MILBRATH: I think it woul be inappropriate
for this person to testify that there is authority without
me testing his believability and credibility by showing that
(p. 8-136) they're having a dispute within the REA and
he’s aware of contrary opinions as to whether or not ap-
proval was required.
THE COURT: Let me say this: As far as Seminole
is concerned, they were dealing with the REA and its of-
ficials, they were bound to take their opinions. If those
opinions were wrong, then maybe some court should say
so, but certainly not a jury in a case where a man is on
trial here.
I've ruled, and that’s all there is to it, and you've had
your say in the record) Now, vou think you're right, I
think you're wrong; it doesn’t mean that you're going to
test your credibility or mine either, it's a matter of opinion.
Your idea that vou want us to use credibility is simply
because you think you can fall back. At any time anything
goes bad of credibility, you cross-examine him about it.
This is not believability, it has te do with the question of
whether he was correct or not correct in his opinion that it
was covered.
I read—I heard what he had to say, and it’s a—I
think it’s very legieal, and I think his opinion is correct.
50
I'll sustain the objection. Don’t ask me anything about this
again. Move on.
MR. MILBRATH: All right. Your Honor —
THE COURT: That’s it.
MR. MILBRATH. Can I just raise one thing?
THE COURT: No, you cannot.
(p. 8-137) MR. MILBRATH: It’s a different point.
THE COURT: Nothing else—what else?
MR. MILBRATH: I want to move that REA Bul.
letin that he testified about in evidence on behalf of Mr.
Tanner.
THE COURT: Unless there’s more relevance that
I can think of, you can supply it as a Court’s Exhibit to
go forward with the record, not anything for you to dis-
cuss with the jury and give your opinion as an REA expert
in argument—final argument, if you get to that point.
MR. ZITEK: Judge, I suggest they put in the entire
40-6 Bulletin, the whole thing.
THE COURT: Yes. You may supply the entire
thing to go forward as a Court’s Exhibit. But, I deny—
I find under Rule 403 it’s not relevant, it’s prejudicial,
confusing, et cetera, et cetera. I’m not going to receive
it in evidence.
It’s up to you to supply it if you want it to go for-
ward with the record. You've got one.
MR. MILBRATH: You mean I can move it in my
case?
51
THE COURT: No, sir. I mean, just give it to the
Clerk at sometime outside the presence of the jury.
MR. MILBRATH: Okay.
THE COURT: It’s a Court’s Exhibit.
MR. MILBRATH: Okay. Thank you.
(End of discussion at sidebar.)
THE COURT: You may proceed. I sustained the
(p. 8-138) objection that it’s not admissible, it’s not rele-
vant to any issue in this case at this trial.
52
(DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT 1 FOR ID.)
United States Rural Washington
Department Klectrifieation D.C,
of Agriculture Administration 20250
July 24, 1981
Mr. Harry W. Wright, Manager
Seminole Electric Cooperative, Ine.
P.O. Box 17100
Tampa, Florida 33682
Dear Mr. Wright:
This is in response to your request for REA to clarify our
position with respect to Seminole’s need to obtain REA’s
approval of the limerock and fill dirt contracts.
Under the terms of the REA-Seminole loan contract and
implementing REA regulations, Seminole was not required
to obtain specifie REA approval of either the limerock
contract dated November 13, 1980, with Citra Mining, Ine.,
or the fill dirt contract dated May 14, 1981, with Citrus
Sand and Clay, Inc. While REA did receive copies of the
contracts and did provide Seminole with comments on the
contracts, neither the contracts nor the bidding procedure
used in either case required REA approval.
Sincerely,
/s8/ Frank W. Bennett
Director
Power Supply Division
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF HILLSBOROUGH
This is to certify that the foregoing is a true and
correct copy of the document on file in my office. Wit-
ness my hand and official seal this 8 day of July, 1983.
James F. Taylor, Jr., Clerk
By /s/ Amy Bickford, D.C.
ec icasea il
53
(GOVERNMENT’S EXHIBIT 1-A)
REA Project Designation:
FLORIDA 4148 SEMINOLE
LOAN CONTRACT
between
SEMINOLE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC.
and
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Dated as of February 12, 1976
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
RURAL ELECTRIFICATION ADMINISTRATION
AGREEMENT, made as of February 12, 1976,
purswent to the Rural Electrification Act of 1936, as
amemle! (7 U.S.C.A, 901 ef seq.) (hereinafter called
the ‘*Act’’), between SEMINOLE ELECTRIC CO-
OPERATIVE, INC. (hereinafter called the ‘ Bor-
rower’’), a corporation existing under the laws of
the State of Florida, and UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA (hereinafter called the ‘‘Government”’),
acting through the Acministrator of the Rural Elee-
trification Administration (hereinafter called the
‘* Administrator’’).
WHEREAS, it is intended that the Borrower shall
borrow from a legally organized lending agency an amount
not in excess of $9,000,000, the repayment of which amount
shall be guaranteed by the Government pursuant to the
Act, including without limitation the amendment thereof
of May 11, 1973 by P.L. 93-32, to finance the construction
and operation of an electric system in rural areas, and it
is contemplated that the Borrower may from time to time
54
borrow, for purposes permitted by the provisions of the
Act, as from time to time amended, additional amounts
either (i) from such legally organized lending ageney or
one or more other legally organized agencies (any such
lending agency being hereinafter called a ‘Guaranteed
Lender’’), with the repayment of such additional amounts
being guaranteed by the Government pursvant to the Aet,
as so amended, or (ii) from the Government (such amounts
and any such additional amounts being hereinafter col-
lectively called the ‘‘Loan’’) ;
NOW, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the
mutual agreements herein contained, the Borrower and
the Government agree as follows:
ARTICLE I
LOAN, NOTES AND SECURITY
SECTION 1. For the purposes of furnishing elec-
trie energy to persons in rural areas not receiving central
station electrie service, (i) the Borrower shall borrow
from the Government, and the Government shall lend, an
amount not in exeess of $0, and/or (ii) the Borrower
shall borrow from the Guaranteed Lender and the Govern-
ment shall guarantee the repayment of, an amount not in
excess of $9,000,000 to finance, pursuant to the provisions
of the Act, the construction and operation of an electric
system (hereinafter called the **System’’), consisting of
electric generating facilities, electric transmission, dis-
tribution and service lines, and all substations, trans-
formers, meters and other equipment necessary for the
efficient operation thereof, to be located in the Counties
of Citrus and Levy and in counties contiguous thereto, all
in the State of Florida.
SECTION 2. The debt created by the Loan shall be
evidenced by notes (such notes and any notes executed
and delivered to refund, or in substitution for such notes
being hereinafter collectively called the ‘‘Notes’’) to be
executed by the Borrower when an as the Administrator
shall determine, payable to, or to the order of, the ap-
propriate Guaranteed Lender or the Government, as the
case may be, in an aggregate principal amount which shall,
except as hereinafter otherwise provided, equal maximum
amount of the loan herein provided for. The Notes shall
be in form and substance satisfactory to the Adminis-
trator. If any note shall be exeeuted and delivered to
refund, or in substitution for, any of the Notes at the time
outstanding, the principal amount of such note may be
greater or less than the principal amount of the Note
which it refunds or in substitution for which it is de-
livered and, to that extent, the aggregate principal amount
of the Notes shall be greater or less than the maximum
amount of the loan herein provided for. Interest shall
accrue on the principal of each Note only in respect of
amounts which shall have been advanced to the Borrower
from time to time on account of the Loan and charged
against such Note. For purposes of this agreement, the
Government shall be deemed to be the holder of any Note
which shall evidence a loan made to the Borrower by a
Guaranteed Lender.
SEC. 5. The Notes shall be secured, as the Adminis-
trator shall elect, either by a mortgage made by the Bor-
rower to Government or by a deed of trust made by and
between the Borrower and a trustee satisfactory to the
56
Administrator (such mortgage or deed of trust, as the
case may be, being hereinafter called the “*Mortgage’’),
as supplemented by such supplemental mortgages made
hy the Borrower to the Government, or by such supple-
mental deeds of trust made by and between the Borrower
and such trustee, as the Administrator shall from time
to time require, and the Notes shall also be secured by
such chattel mortgages and such supplement or additional
chattel mortgages, made by the borrower to the Govern-
ment, as the Administrator shall from time to time require
(any such supplemental mortgage or deed of trust, and
any such chattel mortgage, supplemental or additional
chattel mortgage, as the case may be, being hereinafter
called a ‘‘supplemental mortgage’’). The Borrower shall
also take such other action as the Administrator shall
from time to time require to perpetuate or renew the lien
of the Mortgage, or any supplemental mortgage. The
Mortgage and all supplemental mortgages, if any, shall
be in form and substance satisfactory to the Administrator
and collectively shall cover all the property of the Bor-
rower now owned or hereafter acquired.
ARTICLE II
ADVANCES AND DISPOSITION OF FUNDS
SECTION 1. The Borrower shall deliver to the
Government, when direeted by the Administrator and sub-
ject to his approval, the following:
(a) one or more of the Notes, the Mortgage
and such supplemental mortgages as the Adminis-
trator shall require, all duly executed, and accom-
panied by proof of the due recordation and filing of
——
a7
the Mortgage and any supplemental mortgage in
every appropriate office in each county specified by
the Administrator ;
(b) evidence of appropriate corporate action
authorizing the execution and delivery of the Notes,
the Mortgage, and any supplemental mortgage and
amendment to this agreement;
(c) evidence that the Borvower has duly regis-
tered when and where required by law with all State
and Federal authorities and obtained therefrom all
authorizations, permits, and approvals to the extent
required by law in order to enable the Borrower
validly to execute and deliver the Notes, the Mort-
gage, and any supplemental mortgage and amendment
to this agreement; and
(d) such opinions of counsel, who shall have been
previously approved by the Administrator, as_ the
Administrator shall require.
SEC. 2. The Borrower shall from time to time sub-
mit to the Administrator requisitions in such form and
detail as the Administrator shall prescribe reouesting
the Government to make advances or cause advances to
be made on account of the Loan. Each requisition shall
be accompanied by the following:
(a) evidence satisfactory to the Administrator
that the construction of the System to the date of
the requisition complies with the provisions hereot ;
(b) a certificate of the treasurer of the Bor-
rower which shall specify (1) all payments not pre-
viously accounted for therefore made by the Bor-
rower from funds advanced by, or caused to be ad-
vanced by, the Government on account of the Loan,
and (2) all unpaid obligations of the Borrower:
(c) a statement, in such form and detail as the
Administrator shall prescribe, setting forth the pur-
poses for which it is intended the requested advance
will be used by the Borrower; and
(d) such information, opinions, documents, and
proofs in addition to the foregoing as may reason-
ably be requested by the Administrator.
SEC. 3. The Government, upon receipt of a requisi-
tion and accompanying documents complying with the pro-
visions of section 2 of this article II, shall, within a rea-
sonable time thereafter, if the Borrower has complied
with the provisions of section 1 of this article II to the
satisfaction of the Administrator, make an advance, or
cause an advance to be made, to the Borrower sufficient
for such of the purposes specified in the statement of
purposes accompanying the requisition as the Adminis-
trator shall approve. The Administrator may at any
time, as a condition to the making or approving of any
advance on account of the Loan, require compliance by
the Borrower with any one or more of the terms and
covenants of this agreement to be performed by the Bor-
rower. Advances made by, or caused to be made by, the
Government pursuant to this article II shall be charged
by the Government against any one or more of the Notes
in such manner and in such amounts as the Administrator
shail determine. The Government shall be under no obli-
gation to make or cause to be made advances on aceeu.t
of the Loan after the date of the closing of the Loan speci-
fied in the loan closing certificate.
SEC. 4. The Borrower shall hold all moneys ad-
ranced to it hereunder in trust for the Government and
shall deposit such moneys promptly after the receipt there-
of in a bank or banks which shall have been approved
by the Administrator. Any account (hereinafter called
59
‘*Special Construction Account’’) in which any such mon-
eys shall be deposited shall be designated by the corporate
name of the Borrower followed by the words ‘‘ Trustee,
Special Construction Account.’’ Moneys in any Special
Construction Account shall be used solely for the con-
struction and operation of the System and, subject to the
provisions of section 5 of article LI] and section 2(¢) of
article V hereof, may be withdrawn only upon checks,
drafts, or orders signed on behalf of the Borrower and
countersigned by an executive officer thereof. The Bor-
rower shall not deposit or allow to remain on deposit any
of its funds, regardless of the source thereof, in any
bank or other depositary after notification by the Admin-
istrator to the effect that such bank or other depositary
is not satisfactory.
SEC. 5. The Borrower shall expend each advance
on account of the Loan only for such of the purposes
specified in the statement of purposes accompanying the
requisition for such advance as shall have been approved
by the Administrator.
SEC. 6. Any funds advanced on account of the Loan
remaining unexpended in any Special Construction Ae-
count upon the closing of the Loan shall be forthwith re-
mitted by the Borrower to the Government and a credit in
respect thereof allowed against any one or more of the
Notes to be designated by the Administrator.
SEC. 7. No advances will be made on account of
the Loan for the construction of any part of the System
with respect to which the Borrower shall have failed to
submit to the Government evidence satisfactory to the
Administrator that the Borrower has obtained from the
60
appropriate agency or agencies of the Government all
necessary orders or approvals with respect to the use of
the materials required for the construction of such part
of the System. No construction shall be undertaken ex-
cept in accordance with authorizations or regulations of
any such agency or agencies having jurisdiction in the
premises.
. @ a
ARTICLE III
CONSTRUCTION
SECTION 1. The Borrower shall cause the System to
be constructed under contract by a responsible contractor
or contractors, except to the extent that the Administrator
shall permit the Borrower to construct by force account
portion or portions of the System, or to acquire existing fa-
cilities to be included in the System. The term ‘‘force ac-
ecount’’ shall mean that the prosecution of construction
work by the Borrower on its own account and the furnish-
ing by the Borrower of all labor transportation, materials,
tools, supplies, and equipment used in connection therewith.
Force account construction shall be prosecuted and the
acquisition of existing facilities shall be made subject to
such terms and conditions as the Administrator shall pre-
scribe and the Borrower shall kep accurate and detailed
records vf all costs and expenses in connection therewith.
The System shall be constructed in such sections as the Ad-
ministrator shall direct.
SEC. 2. The System shall be constructed in accord-
ance with the approved plans and specifications hereinaf-
ter provided for, the provisions of this agreement, and all
contracts and subcontractors made pursuant hereto. Con-
61
struction of the respective sections of the System shall be
commenced promptly after the Government shall have noti-
fied the Borrower to commence such construction, and the
Borrower shall cause such construction to be prosecuted
diligently and to be completed within such reasonable time
as the Administrator shall prescribe, unless prevented
from so doing by cause beyond the control and without the
fault or negligence of the Borrower, including fires, floods,
strikes, and unusually severe weather conditions. The Bor-
rower shall cause the System to be completed free and clear
of all liens and lawful claims for liens except the liens of
the Mortgage, and any supplemental mortgage.
SEC. 3. The Borrower shall, if the Administrator
shall so require, invite bids for construction work pertain-
ing to the System, and for materials, equipment, or sup-
plies to be used therein, and the Borrower shall include all
persons designated by the Administrator among those in-
vited to submit bids. If the Administrator shall so require,
the Borrower shall open bids in the presence of a represen-
tative of the Administrator and, in any event, the Bor-
rower shall open all bids publicly at the time and place
which shall have been specified in the notice to bidders.
The Borrower shall award each contract to the lowest re-
sponsible bidder, unless all bids are rejected or the Ad-
ministrator shall approve the award of the contract to
another responsible bidder upon a showing that the award
of the contract to such bidder is in the best interests of
the Borrower.
SEC. 4. The Administrator may supervise the con-
struction and equipment of the System, and shall have the
right to inspect, examine, and test all work and materials
62
relating thereto, and the Borrower shall provide reasonable
facilities therefor for the use of the Administrator and his
agents. The Administrator may reject any defective ma-
terial or workmanship and require that any such material
shall be satisfactorily corrected.
SEC. 5. If the construction of the System or any
section or sections therefor, shall not proceed in accordance
with the terms hereof, the Administrator may appoint a
supervisor (hereinafter called the **Supervisor’’) for the
System, or such section or sections thereof as the Admini-
strator shall designate, as the representative of the Gov-
ernment and notify the Borrower of such appointment and
the duration thereof. Upon the appointment of a Super.
visor, the employment of all superintendents and managers
of the System and of all associate and assistant superin-
tendants and managers thereof shall be forthwith termi-
nated. The Borrower shall with all reasonable instruc-
tions of the Supervisor incident to the carrying out of the
obiigations of the Borrower hereunder, including, without
limitation, directions pertaining to the termination of the
employment of such employees of the Borrower as shall
be designated by the Supervisor. The Supervisor may em-
ploy such persons as he may deem necessary to assist !:im
in carrying out his functions. The salaries, fees, dishurse-
ments and expenses of the Supervisor and of any employee
appointed by him shall be paid by the Borrower, provided,
however, that the salaries, fees, disbursements and ex-
penses of any Supervisor who shall be an employee of the
Government and of any assistants who shall be employees
of the Government shall not be payable by the Borrower
unless and to the extent that the Administrator, upon writ-
ten notification to the Borrower, shall so require. So long
63
as the appointment of the Supervisor shall be in effect, all
checks, drafts and orders drawn on any Special Construe-
tion Account shall be countersigned by the Supervisor, ex-
cept that if the proper officers or employees of the Bor-
rower without the requirement of any other signature
thereon if the Supervisor shall certify that the check, draft
or order is required to carry out the obligations of the Bor-
rower hereunder. The Borrower hereby constitutes the Ad-
ministator its agent for the purchase of notifying any bank
in which any Special Construction Account shall be main-
tained of the appointment of a Supervisor and of the pro-
visions hereby with respect thereto and agrees that such
notice shall include a direction to any such bank with re-
spect to the signing or countersigning of checks, drafts,
or orders drawn on any such Special Construction Account
as in this section 5 provided.
SEC. 6. The Borrower shall, at such time as the Ad-
ministrator shall determine, furnish to the Government (a)
such certificates of the approved engineer or engineers and
of the officers and employees of the Borrower as the Ad-
ministrator shall require with respect to construction of
the System, or any section thereof, and the cost thereof,
and (b) a complete and detailed engineering and legal
description of the System, or any section thereof, including
a map or maps, in form satisfactory to the Administrator,
showing the location and classification of all generating
plants (if any), lines, substations, and transformers.
64
ARTICLE IV
PARTICULAR COVENANTS
SECTION 1. The Borrower shall designate, subject
to the Administrator’s approval: (a) a bank or banks
(which must be a member or members of Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation) in which the funds of the Bor-
rower, regardless of the source thereof, shall be deposited ;
(b) one or more engineers who shall perform the engi-
neering services involved in the construction of the System,
or the several sections thereof, and execute all cerificates
and other instruments pertaining to engineering details
required hereunder to be delivered to the Government:
and (c) a person who shall act as the superintendent of
the (the approved superintendent being hereinafter called
the ‘‘Superintendent’’). If the Administrator shall so re-
quire, the Borrower shall designate, subject to the ap-
proval of the Administrator, one or more associate or as-
sistant superintendents, and a chief operator, engineer or
other employees to have active charge of any generating
plant or plants or any transmission line or lines forming
a part of the System.
SEC. 2. The Borrower shall submit, when the Ad-
ministrator shall so require and subject to the Admini-
strator’s approval: (a) plans and specifications for the
construction of such section or sections of the System as
shall be designated by the Administrator, identified by the
signature of the approved engineer for such section or sec-
tions, and, if the Administrator shall so require, certified
by the seeretary of the Borrower as having been approved
by the board of directors thereof; (b) a contract or con-
tracts for the construction of the section or sections of the
65
System designated by the Administrator; (¢c) a contract
or contracts for the purchase of materials, equipment, and
supplies for use in connection with the construction or op-
eration of the System; (d) contracts with approved engi-
neers for all necessary engineering services in connection
with the construction of the several sections of the System;
(e) a contract or contracts for a supply of electric energy
insofar as such supply may be necessary for the operation
of the System or any part thereof; (f) a contract or con-
tracts for the acquisition of existing facilities to be included
in the System; and (g) an option or options, or a contract
or contracts, as the case may be, for the purchase, lease or
other acquisition of a parcel or parcels of land in connection
with the construction or operation of the System, or any
part thereof, if the Administrator shall so require.
SEC. 3. The Borrower shall not enter into any con-
tract for (a) the construction of any portion of the System;
(b) engineering or other services pertaining to the con-
struction or operation of the System; (c) the purchase,
with funds advanced on account of the Loan, of materials,
equipment, or supplies for use in connection with the con-
struction or operation of the System; (d) electrie energy
with which to operate the System or any part thereof; (e)
the sale of electric at wholesale; (f) the acquisition of exist-
ing facilities to be included in the System; or (g¢) the pur-
chase, lease or other acquisition of a parcel or parcels of
land in connection with the construction or operation of the
System, unless the effectiveness of each such contract shall
be conditioned upon the approval of the Administrator ;
provided, iwwever, that contracts of the nature described in
subdivision (ce) of this Section 5 for amounts not in excess
of $100 in individual instances and in the aggregate not in
66
exeess of one per centum (1%) of the amount specified in
section | of article 1 hereof shall not require the prior ap-
proval of the Administrator.
SEC. 4. The Borrower shall take out, at the time the
respective risks are ineurred, and maintain, at all times
until the completion of the System, insurance of such classes
and in such amounts as the Administrator shall have de-
termined to be advisable to safeguard the interest of the
Borrower and the Government. The Borrower shall submit
to the Administrator a schedule of the insurance which it
porposes to take out and following the Administrator's ap-
proval thereof shall deliver to the Government, subject to
the approval of the Administrator, originals or duplicate
originals of policies effecting such insurance or certificates
in respect thereof. The Borrower shall from time to time
make such changes in such insurance as the Administrator
shall determine to be advisable. In the event that the Bor-
rower shall fail to take out or maintain insurance deter-
mined by the Administrator to be advisable as aforesaid,
the Administrator may take out such insurance on behalf of
the Borrower and the Borrower shall pay the cost thereof.
Nothing herein contained shall limit the obligation of the
Borrower to take out and maintain insurance pursuant to
the provisions of the Mortgage, and any supplemental
mortgage.
* * *
SEC. 7. The Borrower shall at all times keep, in ac-
cordance with good accounting practice, and shall safely
preserve, proper books, records, and accounts in which full
and true entries shall be made of all dealings, business, and
affairs of the Borrower in connection with the use and ap-
plication of funds advanced to the Borrower on aceount of
67
the Loan. The Government, through its agents, representa-
tives, accountants, or attorneys, shall at all times during
reasonable business hours have access to and the right to
inspect and to make copies of all such books, records, and
accounts, and all invoices, contracts, leases, pay roils, can-
celed checks, statements, plants, specifications, drawings,
and other documents and papers of every kind belonging to
or in the possession of the Borrower in anywise pertaining
to the System or the construction thereof,
SEC. 8. The Borrower shall perform all covenants by
it to be performed under the Mortgage and any supple-
mental mortgage.
SEC. 9. The Borrower shall forthwith, upon receipt
thereof, deliver to the Administrator any contractor's or
subeontractor’s bond or bonds relating to the construction
of the System.
SEC. 10. The Borrower shall not operate or energize
any portion of the System until the Borrower shall have
furnished evidence satisfactory to the Administrator that
(a) such portion of the System has been properly con-
structed and is ready to be operated or energized, (b)
there are sufficient consumers ready to take service to per-
mit the enonomical operation of such portion of the System,
and (¢c) the Borrower has compiied with the provisions of
section 4 of this article LV in respect of such portion of the
System. The Borrower shall not serve any consumer
through the System until the Borrower shall have furnished
evidence satisfactory to the Administrator that such con-
sumer’s premises have been properly wired.
SEC. 11. The Borrower represents and warrants as
follows: (a) it is a corporation duly organized, existing,
and in good standing under the laws of the State specified
in the introductory paragraph of this agreement and has
corporate power to enter into this agreement and perfonn
every act required to be performed by it hereunder; (b)
all proceedings prerequisite to the valid execution of this
agreement by it have been duly taken and all required auth-
orizations therefor have been secured; (¢) the status of the
Borrower in respect of litigation and other legal proceed-
ings is as set forth in an opinion of the Borrower’s counsel
to be submitted at such time or times as the Administrator
may require; (d) it has not entered into any contract for
the construction of any portion of the System, or for engi.
neering or other services pertaining to the construction or
operation of the System, or for the acquisition of existing
facilities to be included in the System, or, except as per-
mitted by any agreement or agreements between the Gov-
ernment and the Borrower, for the purchase, with funds
advanced or to be advanced on account of the Loan, of ma-
terials, equipment, or supplies for use in connection with
the construction or operation of the System, unless such
contract has been approved by the Administrator or the
effectiveness thereof has been made subject to the approval
of the Administrator; and (e) every statement contained in
this agreement and in every other document, statement, cer-
tificate, and opinion submitted to the Government by it or
in its behalf is true and correct.
SEC. 15. The Borrower shall, whenever requested so
to do by the Administrator, submit evidence satisfactory to
the Administrator of the economic and engineering feasibil-
ity of each part of the System designated by the Adminis-
trator. If the Borrower shall fail to submit such evidence
with respect to any such part, the Government may refuse
to make, or cause to be made, any advance or further ad-
vances hereunder or the Administrator may deteriuine that
such part shall not be constructed and in such even the Bor:
rower shall not construct such part. Any determination by
the Administrator hereunder shall be conclusive and bind
ing upon both the Government and the Borrower.
ARTICLE V
EVENTS OF DEFAULT AND REMEDIES
SECTION 1. The happening of any of the following
events (hereinafter called ‘‘events of default’’) shall con-
stitute a default by the Borrower hereunder :
(a) any failure to perform or any viclation of,
any term, covenant, promise, condition, or agreement
on the part of the Borrower to be performed here-
under at the time and in the manner herein provided;
(b) any breach of any warranty or any material
or substantial inaccuracy in any representation on the
part of the Borrower; or
(e) any event of default which is specified in the
Mortgage or any supplemental mortgage.
SEC. 2 Upon the happening of any event of default,
as specified in section 1 of this article V, the Government
or the holder or holders of any one or more of the Notes,
as their respective interests may appear, may exereive any
one or more of the following rights, privileges, powers,
and remedies, to the extent that the exercise thereof is not
prohibited by law:
70
(a) refuse to make, or cause to he made, any ad-
vance or any further advances on account of the Loan,
but any thereafter made, or caused to be made, by
the Government shali not constitute a waiver of such
default :
(b) declare all unpaid principal of and all in-
terest acerued on any or all of the Notes held by such
holder or holders to be due and payable immediately
and upon such declaration all such principal and in-
terest shall become due and payable immediately, any-
thing herein or in any other agreement to which the
Borrower shall be a party, or in the Notes or in the
Mortgage or any supplemental mortgage to the con-
trary notwithstanding:
(e) enter upen and take possession of the Sys-
tem, take possession of and utilize any and all equip-
ment, materials, tools, supplies, and appliances wher-
ever loeated belonging to the Borrower, take possis-
sion of any funds in any Special Construction Ae-
count, take possession of all books, papers, records,
documents, accounts, and plans and specifications of
the Borrower relating to the System, and complete or
cause to he completed, by econtraet or otherwise, the
construction of the System, or such portion thereof as
the Administrator may seleet, for the account of the
Borrower, and the amount paid therefor by the Gov-
ernment shall be considered an advance on account of
the Loan and if said amount, together with prior ad-
vanees, is in exeess of the maximum amount which the
Government would otherwise be required to advance,
or cause to be advaneed, hereunder the Borrower shall
immediately pay to the Government the amount of
such exeess; or
(d) exercise any and all rights, privileges, reme-
dies, powers, claims, and demands which the Borrow-
er may have against third persons in any way relat-
ing or pertaining to the construction of the System
and for such purpose, the Borrower does hereby as-
sien, transfer, and set over to the Government any
and all such rights, privileges, remedies, powers,
claims, and demands, except such as by law are not
transferable or assignable, which the Borrower here-
by agrees to hold, together with any and all proceeds
resulting therefrom, in trust for the benefit of the
Government and the holder or holders of the Notes, as
their respective interests may appear.
SEC. 3. Every right, privilege, power, or remedy
herein or in the Notes or in the Mortgage or any supple-
mental mortgage conferred upon or reserved to the Gov-
ernment or any holder or holders of the Notes shall be
cumulative and shall be in addition to every other right,
privilege, power, and remedy now or hereafter existing
at law or in equity or by statute. The pursuit of any right,
privilege, power or remedy shall not be construed as an
election.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Borrower has caused
this agreement to be signed in its corporate name and its
corporate seal to be hereunto affixed and attested by its
officers thereunto duly authorized, and the Government
has caused this agreement to be duly executed, all as of
the day and year first above written.
SEMINOLE ELECTRIC
COOPERATIVE, INC.
by /s/ V. G. Erieland
President
(Seal) -
Attest: /s/ Leon E. Weaver
Secretary
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
by /s/ David A. Hamil
Administrator
of
Rural Electrification Administration
(GOVERNMENT’S EXHIBIT 1-E)
SEMINOLE ELECTRIC
COOPERATIVE INCORPORATED
(For Interoffice Use)
TO: General Service Employees DATE: April 24, 1980
FROM: Joe Casey
SUBJECT: NEW COMPANY POLICIES
Attached is a copy of the new and revised company poli-
cies as approved by the Committee on April 10, 1980.
Please read these policies over carefully. After you have
done so, please initial and pass on to the next employee —
when completed, return to Joe Casey. Thank you.
[Names deleted in printing. ]
SEMINOLE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC.
POLICY NO. 203 DATE: 4/10/80
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
I. OBJECTIVE
To spell out those areas where the Trustees, or
Employees of Seminole Electric Cooperative
should avoid conflicts of interest, or any appear-
ance of conflict of interest, so that the affairs of
Seminole Electric Cooperative will always be car-
ried out in a business like and ethical manner.
Il. CONTENT
A. The following guidelines shall apply to both
the Trustees and Employees of SECI:
1. Trustees and employees are prohibited
from receiving gifts, fees, loans, or fa-
vors from suppliers, contractors, consul-
74
tants, or financial houses, which obli-
gates or induces them to compromise
their responsibilities to negotiate, obli-
gate, inspect or audit, purchase or award
contracts, with the best interest of SECI
uppermost in mind. This does not pro-
hibit receiving gifts or favors of nominal
value or casual entertainment which
meets all standards of ethical business
conduct, and involve no element of con-
cealment.
The complete confidentiality of business
information must be respected at all
times. Employees and Trustees are pro-
hibited from knowingly disclosing such
information to those who do not have the
need to know, both inside and outside
the organization; or in any way using
this information for personal gain or ad-
vancement; or to individually conduct
negotiations or make contacts or inquir-
ies on behalf of SECI, unless officially
designated to do so.
Employees and Trustees are prohibited
from acquiring or having a financial in-
terest in any property which SECT ac-
quires or a direct or indirect financial in-
terest in a supplier, contractor, consult-
ant or other entity with which SECI
does business. This does not prohibit
the ownership of securities in a publicly-
75
owned company except in a substantial
amount’ by those in a position to ma-
terially influence or affect the business
relationship between SECT and such pub-
licly-owned company. Any other interest
in or relationship with an outside organi-
zation or individual having business deal-
ings with SECT is prohibited if this in-
terest or relationship might tend to im-
pair the ability of the emplovee or Trus-
tee to serve the best interests of SECT.
If members of the immediate family of
an employee or Trustee, as defined in
the policy on Nepotism, have a financial
interest as specified above, such interest
shall be fully disclosed to the Board of
Trustees which shall decide if such in-
terest should prevent SECI from enter-
ing into a particular transaction pur-
chase or employment of services.
Every Trustee and Employee of SECT is
expected to avoid situations which might
be construed as conflicts of interest since
it is not feasible in a policy statement
such as this to describe all the cireum-
stances and conditions that might be or
have the potential of being considered
conflicts of interest.
76
POLICY NO. 203 DATE: 4/10/80
III. RESPONSIBILITY
A.
Each Trustee shall make every reasonable ef-
fort to comply with the letter and spirit of
this policy.
The General Manager shall make every rea-
sonable effort to inform all employees about
the content of this policy and make every rea-
sonable effort based on the information avail-
able to him to see that it is complied with and
report to the Operations Committee semi-
annually on how this policy is being carried
out.
. As a minimum standard, a significant financial interest is
an interest of more than: (1) 1°/o of any class of outstand-
ing securities in a company and (2) 5%%/o interest in a part-
nership or association. Additionally, significant financial
interest means any financial interest which may influence
the judgement or action of any director, officer, or em-
ployee with respect to this company.
=
4d
(COURT’S EXHIBIT, TR. 8-137)
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Rural Electrification Administration
August 24, 1970
Supersedes 11/27/59
REA BULLETIN 40-4
SUBJECT: Construction Methods and Purehase of Ma
II.
terials and Equipment.
Purpose: To set forth Rural Electrification Ad-
ministration policy and procedure with respect to
construction of distribution, transmission, genera-
tion, and headquarters facilities, and the purchase
of materials and equipment by electric borrowers
with loan funds or general funds.
General :
A.
It is the responsibility of each borrower as
owner of its system to determine the methods
of construction and of purchase of materials
and equipment which are best suited to its
needs. However, it is recognized that from the
viewpoint of (1) protecting the security in-
teresis of the Government’s loans, and (2) ae-
couplishing the statutory objective of a sound
program of rural electrification, REA is prop-
erly concerned that the costs of construction,
materials, and equipment are reasonable and
within the limits of economic feasibility and
that the physical properties constituting the
security for loans are constructed adequately
to serve the purposes for which they are im-
tended.
This bulletin outlines general requirements
and procedures in conection with new con-
struction and additions to plant whether fi-
nanced with loan funds or general funds.
Electric system construction is a continuing
activity and both loan funds and general
funds are often used concurrently. Adher-
ance to the requirements and procedures in
this bulletin will facilitate the consideration
of loan applications which may inelude
amounts for the reimbursement of general
funds with loan funds.
REA may make exceptions to the require-
ments and procedures in this bulletin since
it is not possible to foresee and include all the
types of situations and conditions which ean
arise. Borrowers are urged to work with
REA in individual instances when such ex-
ceptions are necessary or desirable.
Bulletin 406
Page 2
Engineering studies and reports, such as con-
struction work plans and engineering support
for loan applications, provide REA with the
basic for proper evaluation of the indieated
need for the construction of borrowers’ dis-
tribution, transmission and generation facil-
ities. When proper studies have not been made
or when existing studies are obsolete, arrange-
ments should be made for an up-to-date study.
IIL. Policy:
A.
Selection of Methods of Construction: In de-
termining whether construction shall be per-
formed by contract or foree account, borrow-
ers should weigh carefully the relative advan-
tages and disadvantages of both methods in
regard to the specific construction to be per-
formed. For project-type construction, ex-
perience has indicated that the contract
method of construction, with the contract
awarded on the basis of competitive bidding,
will generally provide for the construction of
facilities in the shortest time at the lowest
overall cost. Except for major construction
projects where it is evident that the contract
method of construction is preferable, REA
will not in any individual instance recommend
one method in preference to the other. The
method selected by the borrower is subject to
the approval of REA.
B. Standards, Specifications and General Re-
quirements :
1. Materials or equipment and construction
must not be below the minimum require-
ments of the standards and speeifieations
established by REA. Materials and equip-
ment for distribution and transmission
facilities meeting these standards are in-
eluded on the *‘List of Materials Accept-
able for Use on Systems of REA Electri-
fication Borrowers,’’ REA Bulletin 45-5.
80
2. If operating conditions or requirements
make the use of non-standard construc-
tion, materials or equipment necessary or
desirable, the borrower should receive aj)
proval of the REA Area Direetor, or Di
rector, Power Supply, Management and
Engineering Standards Division, prior to
the purchase of materials and equipmen:
or commencement of construction (RIA
Bulletin 44-7).
3. Construction work or the purchase of ma-
terials and equipment which is to be fi-
naneed initially or the cost of which is to
be reimbursed in whole or in part with
REA loan funds shall be in accordance
with the applicable equal employment op-
portunity provisions (REA Bulletin 20-
15).
4. Only new materials and equipment shall
be purchased unless otherwise approved
by REA in specific instances.
Bulletin 40-6
Page 3
5. All purchases of materials and equipment
are subject to the ‘Buy American”’ pro-
vision (REA Bulletin 43-9).
©. REA Approval of Borrowers’ Construction:
1. Distribution Facilities which are ineluded
in approved loans, or are included in con.
struction work plans approved by the
81
REA field engineer, or are to be financed
with general funds and meet the provis-
ions of REA Bulletin 103-2, may be con-
structed without further REA approval
except that the REA field engineer should
approve design data, drawings, and plans
and
specifications as may be appropriate
for:
a.
New substations or structural changes
in existing substations.
Lines or other facilities to serve large
power loads (REA Bulletin 112-6),
and
Nonstandard distribution construe-
tion.
Transmission Facilities. Prior to the
construction or modification of trans-
mission facilities, the REA field engi-
neer (or Power Supply, Management
and Engineering Standards Division
for power supply borrowers) should
approve design data, drawings, plan
and profile and plans and specifica-
tions as may be appropriate for trans.
mission lines or substations.
Generation Facilities. Prior to the
construction or modification of gen-
erating facilities that involves an esti-
mated expenditure of $50,000 or more,
the REA Area Office (or Power Sup-
ply, Management and Engineering
Standards Division for power suppl
borrowers) should approve design
data, drawings, plans and specifica-
tions as may be appropriate.
4. Headquarters Facilities. Prior to
the construction or remodeling of
headquarters facilities that involves a
total estimated expenditure of $25,000
or more during any year, the REA
Area Office should approve prelimi.
nary and final plans and specifications
(REA Bulletin 86-3).
5. Requirements concerning REA ap-
proval of plans and specifications and
contracts for the purchase of ma-
terials and equipment and for con-
struction are summarized in the en-
closed Exhibit I.
Competitive Bids: Experience has demon-
strated the desirability of formal competitive
bidding in the construetion of facilities and in
the purchase of materials and equipment. In
some instances, as set forth in Sections IV and
Bulletin 40-6
Page 4
VI below, REA requires that formal competi-
tive bids be taken on construction to be per-
formed under a construction contract and on
generation materials and equipment to be
purchased under a materials or equipment
83
contract. When competitive bidding is not re-
quired, REA still recommends that, in gen-
eral, borrowers use the competitive bidding
method for construction of their facilities and
for procurement of materials and equipment.
Where competitive bidding is required, devia-
tions from the requirement will be made by
REA only in individual instances, upon show-
ing by a borrower that some other procedure
would better serve its interest. Where com-
petitive bids are taken, the contract must be
awarded to the lowest responsible bidder on
the basis of the lowest bid unless all bids are
rejected or unless the borrower can show that
the award of the contract on the basis of
other than the low bid is in its best interest,
IV. Purchase of Materials and Equipment:
A.
Distribution and Transmission Materials
and Equipment:
Distribution and transmission materials and
equipment may be purchased by formal com-
petitive bids or informal quotations. These
purchases may be made by contract or pur-
chase orders not subject to REA approval,
and copies of such contracts or purchase or-
ders should not be sent to REA. When pur-
chases are made by informal quotations
rather than formal competitive bids, at least
three such informal quotations should be ob-
tained.
os
B. Generation Materials and Equipment:
1. Generation materials and equipment
amounting to $50,000 or more shall be
purchased by formal competitive bids on
a contract subject to REA approval. The
bidding documents (plans and specifica-
tions and form of contract) are subject
to REA review and approval prior to is-
suance to suppliers. Three copies of con-
tracts for materials or equipment, a tabu-
lation of the bids, the engineer's recom-
mendation, and a copy of a board reso-
lution indicating the board’s action
should be sent to REA. Two copies of
contracts approved by REA will be re-
turned to the borrower.
2. Generation materials and equipment
amounting to less than $50,000 may be
purchased by formal competitive bids or
informal quotations. These purchases
may be made by contract or purchase or-
der not subject to REA approval. One
copy of such contracts or purchase orders
should be sent to REA for its records.
Bulletin 40-6
Page 5
C. General Plant Materials and Equipment:
General plant materials and equipment may
be purchased by formal competitive bids or
by informal quotations. Purchases may be
85
made by contract or purchase order not sub-
ject to REA approval and copies of such con-
tracts or purchase orders should not be sent
to REA.
V. Biding Procedures: When competitive bids are
taken for the construction of facilities or the pur-
chase of materials or equipment, it is essential that
the arrangements prior to the bid opening are suit-
able and the bid opening is conducted properly.
This will assure that all bidders are treated fairly
and no bidder is placed in an advantageous or <lis-
advantageous position with respect to the other
bidders, and that the advantages of the competi-
tive system of bidding are maintained for all bor-
rowers. The following outlines some of the major
considerations in arranging for competitive bids
and in conducting bid openings. This is not in-
tended to be a complete list as it is to be expected
that unusual problems and situations may arise
under various circumstances. In reference to
headquarters facilities ‘‘architect’’ should be sub-
stituted for ‘‘engineer.’’
A. Btwa Opening Date: The bid opening date
should be scheduled by the borrower with the
advice of its engineer. Sufficient time should
be available to prospective bidders to prepare
their bids and, when necessary, examine the
site of the project. Usually a two to four
week period between the time plans and
specifications are available and the bid open-
ing is sufficient, with the longer period asso-
i)
A
86
ciated with large and complex construction
projects or equipment. If possible, the bid
opening should be scheduled for the middle
or end of the week rather than on Monday
or Tuesday. It usually is desirable to advise
prospective bidders of an anticipated bid
opening approximately two weeks before
plans and specifications are ready for re-
lease.
Invitations to Bid: The borrower’s engineer
is responsible for sending out invitations to
prospective bidders, informing trade associa-
tions of scheduled bid openings and any other
action necessary to procure full, free and
eompetitive bididng. For line construction
at least 12 contractors should be invited to
bid. For other types of construction and for
the procurement of materials and equipment,
the number of invitations may depend upon
the type of work to be performed, the type
of materials or equipment to be furnished,
and the location of the project. In any event,
however, sufficient invitations should be sent
out to assure adequate competition and so
that at least three bids will be received. If
less than three bids are received paragraph I
below shall apply. Subject to the foregoing
criteria, the determination of how many and
which bidders shall be permitted to bid will
be the responsibility of the borrower.
Receipt of Bids: The date and time of re-
ceipt by the borrower should be indicated on
D.
EB.
87
the outside envelope of all bids, including let-
ters or telegrams modifying bids. In general
any bid received subsequent to the time speci-
fied for opening bids should be returned to
the bidder unopened with a notation as to the
date and time of receipt. Individual situa-
tions may require a determination as to
whether a delay in delivery of a bid is beyond
the control of the bidder.
Qualifying VLilders: If the notice and in-
structions to bidders requires that bidders
show evidence of meeting certain require-
ments, the borrower, with the advice of the
engineer, should qualify bidders before any
bids are opened. This should be done as far
as possible in advance of the time scheduled
for opening of bids. The bids of unqualified
. bidders are to be returned unopened.
Conduct of Bid Openings: Bid openings
should generally be conducted by the borrow-
er’s engineer in the presence of bidders with
a representative of the borrower also pres-
ent. It usually will be desirable to have the
borrower’s attorney present at the bid open-
ing.
Review of Bids: At the time bids were
opened, the borrower’s engineer and attorney
should review all bids for irregularities, er-
rors, and exceptions. If it appears that min-
or irregularities or errors were made through
inadvertence, the borrowe may (1) authoize
88
the bidder to make changes, or (2) waive the
the errors or irregularities. In the event of
major irregularities or errors, the bid should
be rejected and the bid price not disclosed.
The bid bonds or certified checks also should
be checked for adequacy prior to reading bids.
Reading of Bids: Bid prices should not be
read until the engineer and attorney have re-
viewed each bid to determine if there are any
exceptions, alternatives, or other factors that
may affect the bid price or recommendation
as to award. These exceptions should be
made public at the same time the bid price is
announced. The order of reading bids should
be determined by the engineer. For example,
the bids may be read in the order received or
alphabetically by name of bidders.
Evaluating Bids: If factors other than the
dollar value of the bids are to be considered,
such factors should be stated in the notice and
instructions to bidders. If a bid contains an
escalation or price adjustment clause, the
maximum amount of escalation or adjustment
must be added to the base bid for purposes
of evaluating bids to determine the low bid-
der. Any bid that does not contain a price
ceiling should be rejected.
Bulletin 40-6
Page 7
Procedure When Less than Three Bids are
Received: If fewer than three bids are re-
89
received, the borrower with the advice of its
engineer, should determine whether the bids
are to be opened or returned unopened. If
the bids are opened, and the borrower desires
to award a contract on the basis oi less than
three bids, approval of the Area Office (or
Power Supply, Management and Engineering
Standards Division for power supply berrow-
ers) should be obtained prior to executing
any contract that is subject to REA approval.
Bid Rejections: In the event that no bid can
be approved, all bids are to be rejected and
the borrower should either advertise for new
bids or make other arrangement for coustrue-
tion or purchase of materials or equipment.
All bids should be rejected under conditions
such as:
1. Acceptable prices not quoted.
2. Varying interpretations resulting from
ambiguity in the specifications, or
3. An insufficient number of bona fide bids
received.
Any bid may be rejected if :
1. Itis an unbalanced bid.
2. The bidder is not qualified in accordance
with the instructions to bidders, or
3. The facts indicate the bidder has an in-
terest conflicting with that of the bor-
rower.
om)
Recommendation of Engineer: In most in-
stances, at the conclusion of the bid opening
the engineer will be in position to make known
his recommendation as to award. In some
instances it may be preferable to adjourn the
bid opening for a sufficient period of time for
the engineer to complete his tabulation, analy-
sis, and evaluation of the bids. If possibile,
the recommendation of the engineer should
be announced when the bidders have reas-
sembled at the time specified by the engineer.
The engineer should furnish each bidder with
a copy of his tabulation of the bids.
Award of Contract: It is desirable that a
board meeting be scheduled promptly follow-
ing the bid opening. The board may then
take prompt action on the engineer's recom-
mendation, and decide on the award and mapr-
ner of executing the contract. For contracts
subject te REA approval, a borrower may
award a contract on standard contract forms
without REA approval of the award if:
Bulletin 40-6
Page 8
1. The proposal was made on plans and
specifications approved by REA if such
approval is required,
te
.
A minimum of three qualified bids were
received and opened,
91
3. The bid contains no irregularities other
than minor ones which may be waived,
and
4. ‘The award is made to the lowest respon-
sible bidder.
Contracts snbject to REA approval awarded
in accordance with the foregoing, properly
examined by the borrower's attorney and en-
gineer and properly executed by the borrow-
er and contractor, are to be submitted in
triplicate to RELA together with:
1. A tabluation of the results of all bids.
2. <A written recommendation of borrower's
engineer,
3. An executed contractor’s bond on an
REA form of bond. (See REA Bulletin
40-2, *‘Insurance Coverage for Borrow-
ers’ Contractors and Engineers and Per-
formance Bond Requirements for Bor-
rowers’ Contractors),’’ and
4. <A copy of the board resolution awarding
the contract.
An information copy of contracts not subject
to REA appreval properly executed and in
accordance with the foregoing should be sent
to REA for its records.
VL. Procedure im Construction by Contract:
A. General:
1. Under this method, the construetion is
performed by an independent contractor
who has entered inte a contract with the
borrower. The contract may have been
awarded on the basis of formal competi-
tive bids, informal quotations, or nego-
tiation.
Prior to entering into any construction
contract, plans and specifications pre-
pared by the borrower's engineer should
be approved by the borrower's board of
directors. For certain types of construe.
tion the plans and specifications are to
be submitted to REA for approval (See
Exhibit 1).
Bulletin 40-6
Page 9
If any materials or equipment are to be
furnished by the borrower, they are pur-
chased by contract or purchase order.
For project-ty pe construction, experience
has indicated that a labor and materials
type of construction contract, with the
contractor furnishing the materials and
equipment will minimize scheduling diffi-
eulties and generally result in the lowest
overall cost.
For substations, generating plants or
building sites, when REA approval of
title evidence is required (See REA Bul-
letin 20-3, “Obtaining Adequate Right-
of-Way and Submission of Tithe Evidence
by Electric Borrower’’) such approval
should be obtained prior to releasing
plans and specifications for bids or con-
tract negotiation. Contracts subject to
REA approval or requests for loan funds
cannot be approved until such tithe evi-
dence has been approved.
After bids are received or negotiations
completed a construction contract is en-
tered into between the borrower and con-
tractor, For contracts subject to REA
approval (See Exhibit I) three copies of
the contract and a copy of the board
resolution should be forwarded to REA.
For contracts executed on REA standard
forms of contracts which are not subject
to REA approval, one copy should be
sent to REA for its information and ree-
ords.
Under certain engineering services con-
tracts, borrower's engineer is respon-
sible for preparing and distributing
periodical reports of progress. (See
REA Bulletin 80-11, ‘Reports of Prog.
ress of Construction and Engineering
Services.’’)
During the construction period the con-
tractor is paid monthly for completed
work in accordance with the terms of the
contract,
On completion of construction final in-
spection is made and final inventory doe-
uments are prepared, For projeet-type
construction the close-out procedures are
in REA Bulletin 81-6, **Close-out Doeu-
ments for Electric System Construction
Contracts,"’ REA Bulletin 55-1, **Close-
out Documents for Generation Projects,”’
aad REA Bulletin 86-1, “Final Doeu-
ments Required in Connection with Con-
struction of Buildings.’’
Bulletin 40-6
Page 10
B. Negotiated Construction Contracts:
1.
For the construction of certain tacilities
the borrower may determine that it is in
its best interest to negotiate a contract
rather than contracting on the basis of
formal competitive bids. This may be
desirable when the magnitude of the con-
struction would not attract sufficient in-
terest among contractors, the construe-
tion may include extensions and addi-
tions to the system over a period of time
and the exact type and extent of the con
struction may not be known at the be-
ginning of construction, or the construe-
tion may not be easily definable for bid-
ding purposes such as work involving
combinations of construction, rehalilita-
tion and mainteance. Borrowers ma)
execute negotiated contracts without
prior REA approval:
a. For distribution or transmission
facilities if the maximum contract
amount does not exceed $100,000, ex-
elusive of the value of owner-fur-
nished materials, if any. However,
if the contract includes subetation,
transmission or nonstandard distri-
bution facilities, the plans and speei-
fications must be approved by the
REA field engineer or Power Sup-
ply, Management and Engineering
Standards Division for power supply
borrowers.
b. For generating plant construction if
the maximum contract price does not
exceed $50,000,
e. For headquarters facilities construe-
tion if the maximum contract price
does not exeeed $25,000,
2. Where negotiation is permitted under
this Bulletin, borrowers may use the same
REA standard construction contract
forms as they use for competitively bid
projects, or they may use REA Form
700, ** Distribution Line Extension Con-
struction Contract (Labor an! Ma-
terials)" or REA Form 792, ** Distrilu-
tion Line Extension Construction Con-
tract (Labor Only),”’ for the construction
of distribution facilities priced on an as-
sembly unit basis where the quantities
of the units are not specified. Where
negotiation is permitted under this Bul-
letin and where borrowers determine that
payment to the contractor on other than
the basis of assembly unit prices is in
their best interest, they may use con-
tracts for distribution facility construe-
tion which provide for payments on other
bases including equipment rental costs
and hourly labor costs, for example. The
pertinent provisions of the REA stand-
ard forms of contracts should be included
in any such special contracts.
Bulletin 40-6
Page 11
The construction performed under the
Distribution Line Extension Construe-
tion Contracts, REA Form 7%, or
REA Form 792 or nonstandard nego-
tiated contracts is accounted for in a
manner similar to the procedure outlined
in REA Bulletin 184-2, ‘Suggested Work
Order Procedure.”’ A final inventory of
each section completed under these con-
tracts showing the number of each type
of construction unit installed is required.
The amounts paid to the contractor are
charged to a separate construction work
in progress account. The costs of con-
struction from the final inventory of con-
struction furnisher by the contractor and
other costs applicable to the work per- .
formed under the contract may be in-
eluded on REA Form 219, ‘Inventory of
Work Orders,’’ but should be clearly
identified as representing construction
under a specified contract.
C. Construction Contract Amendment:
1.
During the construction period it may be
necessary or desirable to amen’! con-
struction contracts to provide for
changes in construction or for additional
construction not contemplated when the
contract was executed. A contract
amendment will generally be one of the
following types:
a. Amendments for minor changes or
additions in work to be performed,
addition of assemly units, changes in
quantities of assembly units specified
in the contract, or extention of time
for completion of construction.
Experience shows that normally
sume changes and modifications dur-
ing the course of construction may be
expected. However, carefal design
and complete detailed plans and spe-
cifieations will minimize the number
of this type of contract amendments.
b. Amendments for additional construc-
tion or major changes which may in-
volve a substantial change in the
scope or cost of the work specified
in the contract. The borrower may
decide to amend the contract im pre-
ference to taking new bids when it
appears that such action is in its best
interest.
2. Borrowers may execute amendments of
the type set forth in paragraph a, above
- without prior REA approval. For pro-
posed amendments as outlined im para-
graph b, above, borrowers should furnish
REA with complete facts in support of
the proposed amendment including a
beard resolution prior to executing such
an amendment.
3. Each time an amendment i« executed, the
borrower shoukl make certain that:
a. The contractor's bond covers the ad-
tional work to be performed, as well
as construction covered in the or-
Bulletin 40-6
Page 12
iginal contract. If the amendment
by itself or together with preceeding
amendments amounts to more than
20% of the maximum contract price,
a bond extension will be required,
bringing the penal sum of the bond
to the total amended contract price.
A form of bend extension, REA
Form 801 is available from REA.
yy
b. If the amendment covers construction
in a county or state not included in
the original contract, the borrower
and contractor are qualified to do
business. in that location. For ex-
ample, the borrower's mortgage, if
not previously recorded, must be re-
corded in the county and the con-
tractor may be required to obtain
an additional state liecnse.
4. Amendments requiring REA approval,
properly completed and executed, are to
be submitted in triplicate to REA tor
approval with a copy of the appropriate
board resolution. An information copy
of amendments not subject to REA ap-
proval should be sent to REA for its
records.
D. Subcontracts: The standard forms of con-
struction contracts prescribe the conditions
under which a contractor may subcontract a
portion of the work. Under some forms of
construction contracts, a contractor may sub-
contract certain portions of the work without
approval of the owner, surety and REA, while
other forms of contracts require that such
subcontracts be approved by the owner, surety
and REA.
VIII. Standard Forms of Contracts and Purchase Or-
ders:
Exhibit II enclosed lists the standard forms of
contracts and purchase order for use in connection
100
with contract construction and purchase of ma-
terials and equipment. Information on the purpose
and availability of the forms is also included.
/s/ David A. Hamil >
Administrator
Enclosures
Exhibit | —Summary of Construction and Materials
and Equipment Contract Requirements
Exhibit II—REA Standard Forms for Construction
and Purchase of Materials and Equipment
Index :
CONSTRUCTION :
Methods of
CONTRACTS:
Award and Method of Construction
MATERIALS AND EQUIPMENT:
Purchase of
)
)
:
:
|
TYPE OF
FACILITY
Distribution
(including
substations)
Trans-
mission
(including
substations)
Substations
(not
included
above)
Generation
101
EXHIBIT I
SUMMARY OF CONSTRUCTION AND MATERIALS
AND EQUIPMENT CONTRACT REQUIREMENTS
PURCHASE OF MATERIALS CONSTRUCTION
& EQUIPMENT
Std. Contract REA Std. Contract
Forms Approval of Forms
Contracts
Material Not required _—__ Elec. System-
Contract 1AM REA
REA Form 173 Form 830
Purchase Line Extension-
Order 1AM REA
REA Form 551 Form 790
Line Extension-
L.O. REA
Form 792
Materials Not required Transmission-
Contract 1AM REA
REA Form 173 Form 831
Purchase (includes draw-
Order ings & specifica-
REA Form 551 tions)
(For combined
distribution and
transmission
projects)
Elec. System-IAM
REA Form 830
Materials Not required Substation
Contract Erection-REA
REA Form 173 REA Form 764
Purchase
Order
REA Form 551
Under $50,000- Under $50,000- Generating Plant-
Materials Not required. REA Form 200
Contract $50,000 or
REA Form 173 more-REA
Purchase Area Office
Order for distribution
REA Form 551 borrowers &
$50,000 or ang Supply,
more- . & Engrs
Materials . Div.
Contract power su he
REA Form 458
Equipment Plans oat
Contract specs., also
REA Form 198 subject to
REA approval.
on _ Building-
REA Form 257
(Columns continued on next page)
102
SUMMARY OF CONSTRUCTION AND MATERIALS
AND EQUIPMENT CONTRACT REQUIREMENTS
Std. Drawings
& Specs.
7.2/12.5 kv-REA
Form 804. 14.4/24.9
kv REA Form yor
Underground-R
Form 806. Substa-
tions-prepared by
borrower's engineer.
Transmission Lines-
REA Form 831 (in-
cludes contract)
rrower's engineer.
Prepared by
borrower's engineer.
Prepared by
borrower's engineer.
Prepared by
borrower's architect.
CONSTRUCTION
REA Approval of
Plans and Specs.
Not reqd. for std.
construction, REA
Field Engineer for
nonstd. construc-
tion or if substations
are included.
REA Field Engineer
for distribution bor-
rowers, REA Power
Supply, Mgt. &
Engrg. Stds. Div.
for power supply
horrowers.
REA Field Engineer
for distribution bor-
rowers, REA Power
Supply, Mgt. &
Energ. Stds. Div.
for power supply
borrowers.
Not required if
under $50,000,
$50,000 or more-
REA Area Office
for distribution
borrowers or Power
Supply, Mgt. &
Engrg. Stds. Div.
for power
borrowers.
Not required if un-
der $25,000, REA
Area Office $25,000
or more.
REA Approval
of Contracts
Not required
REA Area Office
for distribution bor-
required for REA
Form 830)
REA Area Office
for distribution
borrowers, REA
Power Supply, Met.
& Engrg. Stds. Div.
for power supply
borrowers.
REA Area Offices
for distribution bor-
rowers, REA Power
Supply, Mgt. &
Engrg. Stds. Div.
for power supply
borrowers.
Not required if
$100,000 or less.
Modify REA Form
257 per instructions
with form. REA
Area Office if over
$100,000.
103
EXHIBIT il
REA STANDARD FORMS FOR CONSTRUCTION AND
PURCHASE OF MATERIALS AND EQUIPMENT
SOURCE OF
FORM TITLE PURPOSE COPIES
(3-55) Materials Distribution, trans- Owner or
Contract mission, general plant Engineer
and _—_ tion a
niaterial a i (san copies
ment purchases. The available from
“Notice and Instruc- REA)
tions to Bidder” is
detached when formal
bids are not
(8-66) Construction Amending the Electric REA
Contract System Construction
Amendment Contract, REA Form
830; the Electric
Transmission Construc-
tion Contract, REA
Form 831; the Sub-
station Erection
Contract, REA Form
764; or the Agreement
for Right-of-Way
Clearing, REA Form
201.
(3-57) Equipment Generating plant RLA
Contract equipment purchases
requiring acceptance
tests on the
project site.
(4-59) Generating Generating plant REA
Plant construction or for
Construction the furnishing and
Contract installation of major
items of equipment.
(7-56) Right-of-Way Right-of-way clearing REA
Clearing work which is to be
Agreement performed separate
from line construction.
SOURCE OF
FORM TITLE PURPOSE COPIES
(8-56) Special drawings Owner or
i for rarely used printed on Engineer
7.2/125 kv translucent reproduces from
Construction reproduced if required. — from
(10-66) Construction Amending the REA
or Equipment Generating Plant
Contract Construction Contract
Amendment REA Form 200: the
®uilding Construction
Contract, REA Form
257; the Equi
Contract, REA Form
198; or the Materials
Contract, REA
Form 458.
(3-68) Building Headquarters build- Supt. of Docu-
Construction ings, generating plant ments, GPO,
105
(SEAL)
United States Department of Agriculture
Rural Electrifieation Administration
Washington D.C. 20250
February 17, 1981
SUBJECT: REA Bidding Procedures
TO: (ieneration and Transmission Borrowers
In recent months, several instances have come to our atten-
tion which demonstrates that some confusion exists re
garding REA established bidding procedures. I hope, by
this letter, to clarify REA’s procedures as they relate to
acceptable bilding practices.
The three bidding procedures provided for in REA Bulle.
tin 40-6, ‘Construction Methods and the Purchase of Ma-
terials and Exquipment,”’ are described as follows:
1. Formal competitive bidding: All “Notices and
Instructions to Bidders”’ in standard REA con.
tract forms are set up for formal bidding, with
sealed proposals to be submitted by the bidder,
and a public bid opening held. Under this bid
procedure. any proposal with a major exception
must be rejected immediately without reading the
bid prices. It is, therefore, essential that your
attorney as well as your consultant engineer be
present at the bid opening for the purpose of re-
viewing the proposals prior to the actual reading
of the bid. Bulletin 40-6 provides examples of
major exceptions and reasons for rejecting birls.
This bidding procedure should be used for all
tran=mission line and substation construction con.
tracts. The use of ‘‘informal’’ or “‘negotiated”’
106
bidding procedures requires prior REA approval;
such approval is rarely given for construction of
these types of facilities.
Informal competitive bidding: This procedure is
described in supplement to Bulletin 40-6 dated
May 28, 1973. Although the supplement addresses
generation facilities only, the same procedure can
be applie! to the purchasing of equipment and
materials for transmission facilities.
Under this procedure, the ** Notice to Bidders”’ is
revised to reflect that bid proposals will be pri-
vately opened, and that a subsequent round of
negotiations, where necessary and at the Owner's
option, for clarification of proposals may be un-
dertaken to arrive at a final contract bid price.
The key points te note under this procedure are:
a. The final bid proposal arrived at must
he responsive to the bid documents, which
means no major exceptions. Those pro-
posals with major exceptions remaining
after the one round of negotiations must
be rejected. Bulletin 40-4 «specifically
states that the selected bid shall be the
“‘low responsive bid conforming to the
plans and «pecifications.”’
G and T Borrowers
Page 2
b. Only one round of negotiations is allowed
and must be strictly adhered to. (Refer-
ence Bulletin 40-6 on language to add to
‘Notice to Bidders’).
107
e. Bulletin 40-6 provides for a negotiating
committee to certify to the results and a
sample form of certification is enclosed
for your use.
d. The contract package submitted to REA
for contracts subject to REA approval
should include three copies of (1) a prop-
erly exeeuted contract. (2) approrriate
board resolutions, (3) negotiating com-
mittee certification, and (4) bid tabula-
tion an] engineer's evaluation of the pro-
posals. In using contract Form 173,
**Materials Contract,’’ only one copy of
each need be submitted, since the contract
is not subject to formal REA approval.
Informal bidding procedures have been
snecessful- used for purchases of trans-
formers, breakers, steel towers, wood
poles, conductor and hardware. It is an
aceeptable procedure for purchasing most
transmission materials. Alternate liabil-
ity and escalation clanses may be used
where deemed necessary to obtain respon-
sive bids, and the clauses are identified
in Balletin 40-6.
3. Negotiated bidding: Under this procedure, the
**Notice to Bidders”’ should clearly state that pro-
posals will be privately opened and if needed, as
many negotiating sessions as necessary will take
place with the bidders until a final contract ac-
ceptable to the Owner as to terms and conditions,
technical conformance, and price is arrived at.
The same contract package as for informally bid
contracts would be submitted te REA with the ex-
ception of a negotiating committee's certification.
This procedure requires prior REA approval. It
is presently being used for purchasing load man-
agement control related systems and is recom-
mended by this office as the means of procuring
this type of equipment.
I strongly urge you, your staff, your attorney, and con-
sultant engineers to review REA Bulletin 40-6 as it relates
to the bidding procedures outlined above. REA is obli-
gated to see that these procedures are followed. We must
point out to you that REA has in past vears rejected con-
tracts where these procedures were not strictly followed.
G and T Borrowers
Page 3
It should he noted that, as stated in Bulletin 40-6, REA
bidding procedures must be adhered to regardless of the
ecouree of financing for the project and regardless of
whether or not contracts are subject to administrative ap-
proval.
Should you have any questions either regarding the above
or at any time when bids are received for materials or con-
struction, please do not hesitate to call either myself or
members of my staff at (202) 382-1440,
/s/ Alexander E. Sherman
Chief, Power Transmission Branch
Power Supply Division
Enclosure
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, CASE NO.
Plaintiff, 83-70 r-T-48
vs. Tampa, Florida
Mareh %, 1984
WILLIAM M. CONOVER and #9 @"elock_ pam.
ANTHONY R. TANNER,
Defendants.
EXCERPT OF TRIAL PROCEEDINGS
VERDICTS AND POLLING OF TILE JURORS
BEFORE THE HONORABLE BEN KRENTZMAN
ANDA JURY
[Appearances omitted in printing. }
INDEX
Verdict for William M. Conover
Verdict for Anthony KR. Tanner
Polling of the Jurors
(p. 3) (Jury in at 3:55 p.m.)
ee
THE “OURT: Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.
The Marshal reports that you report that you've reached
verdicts.
Would you fold the verdict forms and the Clerk will
come and get them and she will hand them te me and I'll
cheek to see that they ‘re completed, if they are.
You may be seated, and thank vou.
If they re completed, I'll ask the Clerk to publish them.
(Documents handed to the Court.)
THE COURT: The verdict forms are complete, they
are signed by the foreman —-forelady and they're dated, and
I'll ask the Clerk to publish the verdicts.
THE CLERK: Please stand as the verdicts are being
read.
The case of United States of America versus William
M. Conover, Case Number 83-70-Cr.-T. “Verdict: We the
jury unanimously find the defendant William M. Conover
guilty of the offense as charged in Count IL, guilty of the
offense as charged in Count Il, guilty of the offense as
charged in Coant Il, guilty of the offense as charged in
count IV, guilty of the offense as charged in Count V of the
Indictment. So say we all, (p. 4) Eloise E. Trent, Foreman,
dated at Tampa, Florida, this 9th day of March, 1954.""
Case of Uniled States of America versus Anthony R.
Tanner, Case Namber 83-70-Cr-T. “Verdict: We the jury
unanimously find the defendant Anthony R. Tanner guilty
of the offense as charged in Count |, guilty of the offense as
charged in Count II, not guilty of the offense as charged in
County (sie) TTL, guilty of the offense as charged in Count
IV, guilty of the offense as charged in Count V of the In-
dictment. So say we all. Eloise E. Trent, Foreman, dated
at Tampa, Florida, this 9th day of March, 1984."
Are these your verdicts!
THE JURY: (Nods heads affirmatively.)
THE COURT: Ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to
ask the Clerk to poll you as to the verdicts. That means that
she will ask you individually if these are your verdicts.
Please do that.
THE CLERK: Mr. Kelly, are these your verdicts!
lll
JUROR KELLY: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mrs. Asbel, are these your verdicts!
JUROR ASBEL: Yee.
THE CLERK: Mr. Abern, are these your verdicts!
JUROR AHERN: Yee.
(p.5) THE CLERK: Mts. Franklin, are these your
verdicts!
JUROR FRANKLIN: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mrs. Snapp, are these your verdicts!
JUROR SNAPP: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mrs. Kronus, are these your verdicts!
JUROR KRONUS: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mrs. MeKenzie, are these your ver-
dicts!
JUROR MeKENZIE: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mr.—Mrs. Gunther, are these your
verdicts ! |
JUROR GUNTHER: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mr. Hardy, are these your verdicts!
JUROR HARDY: Yes, ma’am.
THE CLERK: Mrs. Williams, are these your ver-
dicts!
JUROR WILLIAMS: Yes.
THE CLERK: Mrs. Fogarty, are these your ver-
dicts
112
JUROR POGARTY: Yes.
THE CLERK: And, Mrs. Trent, are these your (p. 6)
verdicts!
JUROR TRENT: Yes.
THE COURT: Does either party wich to poll the jury
further as to the verdicts!
MER. BEST: No, sir.
THE COURT: Thank you, vou may be seated.
CERTIFICATE
| certify that the foregoing is a correct transeript from
the record in the proceeding» in the above-entitled matter.
/s/ Kathryn Bryant May 23, 1984
Court Reporter Date
a ————————LLLL———_—LLEFBEL>____—— LS
113
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
V CASE NO. 83-70-Cr-T-8
WILLIAM M. CONOVER and
ANTHONY R. TANNER
DEFENDANT TANNER’S
MOTION AND MEMORANDUM
FOR INTERVIEW OF JURORS
AND OTHER RELIEF
(Filed April 19, 1984)
Defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER, by and through
his undersigned counsel, hereby moves the Court for entry
of an Order authorizing the interview of certain trial
jurors, the holding of an evidentiary hearing concerning
such jurors, and such other relief, including the granting of
a new trial or the dismissal of the indictment, as the Court
may deem appropriate upon the taking of the necessary
evidence. In support of this Motion, the undersigned
states:
1. The jury entered verdicts of guilty on the majority
of Counts at issue in the indictment and this cause is cur-
rently scheduled for sentencing as to both defendants on
Friday, April 20, 1984.
2. On or about Wednesday, April 18, 1984 lead trial
counsel for ANTHONY R. TANNER, David Best, Esq.,
received an unsolicited and totally unexpected telephone
eall from one of the trial jurors, Mrs. Asbul. Mrs. Asbul
informed Mr. Best, as is more particularly outlined in the
1l4
attached Affidavit, that several of the male jurors, at var-
ious times throughout the trial, consumed aleohol during
their lunch breaks and were frequently under the in-
fluence of aleohol during the trial proceedings. Mrs. Asbul
also revealed, in substance, that these jurors were actually
intoxicated on a number of occasions during the trial and
that they also consumed alcohol on breaks during the jury
deliberations leading to the return of the guilty verdicts.
Mrs. Asbul also alleged that these same jurors had brow-
beaten her into rendering a verdict of guilty against the
defendants, and had thereafter coerced the entry of guilty
verdicts.
3. It is well established that where a juror, during
the course of his duties, has become intoxicated or other-
wise has misused alcoholic beverages or controlled sub-
stances to the extent that he has been adversely affected in
the performance of his duties, the jury’s verdict must be
set aside and a new trial or other relief must be ordered.
See, e.g., United States v Provenzano, 620 F. 2d 985, 996-
993 (3rd Cir. 1980); United States v Taliaferro, 553 k. 2d
724, 726 (4th Cir. 1977); Faith v Neely, 41 FRD. 361, 366
(N.D. W.Va. 1966). See, also Jorgensen v York lee Ma-
chinery Corporation, 160 F. 2d 434 (2nd Cir. 1947); Lee v
United States, 454 A. 2d 770, 773-775 (D.C. Ct. App. 1982).
If what Mrs. Asbul has related to Mr. Best is correct, it is
clear that one or more jurors, at various times during the
trial—even during the crucial stage of jury deliberations—
misused alcoholic beverages. It is likewise clear that this
course of conduct adversely affected the deliberations of
the individual jurors and, in addition, interfered with the
decision-making process of the jury panel. Indeed, it
115
would appear from what Mrs. Asbul has stated that the
jury foreman’s apparent misuse of alcoholic beverages led
to the compulsion of guilty verdicts against the defendants.
U these circumstances, a new trial, at the very mini-
mum, would be the only appropriate relief.
4. Rule 2.04(c), Local Rules of the Middle District
of Florida, provides, in substance, that where grounds for
a legal challenge of a verdict exists, the party may move
for an Order permitting an interview of a juror or jurors
to determine whether the verdict is subject to attack. The
Rule also contemplates the holding, where necessary, of an
evidentiary hearing to inquire into the grounds for setting
aside the verdict for juror misconduct. Under the present
circumstances, this Court should permit inquiry of the jury
panel and, in addition, hold an evidentiary hearing.
5. Although the Courts are admonished not to permit
“fishing expeditions” after the return of a verdict, an evi-
dentiary hearing is a constitutional right of the accused
where reasonable grounds for investigation into the con-
duet of the jury members exists. See, e.g., United Siales
v Moon, 718 F, 2d 1210-1234 (2nd Cir. 1984); United States
v Moten, 582 F. 2d. 654, 666-667 (2nd Cir. 1978). And
where there is a well-founded basis for believing that a
juror or jurors were drunk or under the influence of al-
coholiec beverages during the trial proceedings or delibera-
tions, there clearly are reasonable grounds for an investi-
gation by evidentiary hearing. See, e.¢., Jorgensen v York
Ice Machinery Corporation, 160 F. 2d 4382, 435 (2nd Cir.
1947). Plainly, the unsolicited statement of a trial juror
that such abusive practices occurred constitutes the nee-
essary factual basis for judicial inquiry. This is not a
116
case where a party has merely speculated that juror mis-
behavior occurred; rather, the allegations of misconduct
come from a member of the very panel charged with the
deciding the guilt or innocence of the defendants. If a
juror or jurors were intoxicated during the trial and sub-
sequent deliberations, this Court would have no alterna-
tive but to grant relief from the verdicts. Unless an evi-
dentiary hearing is conducted, and the parties are afforded
the opportunity to interview jurors, it will be impossible
to resolve the accuracy of Mrs. Asbul’s representations.
6. What is more, Mrs. Asbul’s representations of
jury misuse of alcohol, raise a strong presumption of im-
propriety which must not be overlooked by the Court. The
use of alcohol involves an improper outside influence into
the jury’s deliberative process; and where outside influ-
ences have been interjected into a case, a presumption of
prejudice arises as a matter of law. See, e.g., United
States v Chiantese, 582 F. 2d 974, 979 (Sth Cir. 1978).
Under this circumstance, it is incumbent upon the Govern-
ment to rebut that presumption in the context of a full and
fair evidentiary hearing. Jd. at 582 F. 24 979. As Justice
Holmes has observed, “The theory of our system is that
the conclusion tg be reached in a case will be induced only
by evidence and argument in open Court, and not by any
outside influenee .. .” Patterson v Colorado, 205 U.S, 454,
462 (1907). Misuse of alcoholic beverages to the extent
that one or more jurors is drunk or otherwise affected,
clearly creates an outside influence of an inimical charae-
ter. Indeed, where one or more of the jurors in a trial, and
during the deliberative process leading to a verdict, is wn-
der the influence of alcohol, the very purpose of the jury
117
trial is defeated; it is simply impossible to secure a full
and fair analysis of the evidence by an impartial and at-
tentive jury.
7. It is accordingly submitted that an evidentiary
hearing to inquire further into Mrs. Asbul’s allegations is
required and that this hearing, together with any appropri-
ate interviews or inquiries of jurors, must take place prior
to the sentencing in this ease. At the minimum, this Court
must conduct an examination of Mrs. Asbul. After prob-
ing Mrs. Asbul’s recollection, further inquiry of other jur-
ors may also be necessary.
8. This Motion is filed only for the purpose of safe-
guarding the constitutional rights of the defendants, and
for no other purpose. The Motion is submitted at this late
date only because Mrs. Asbul’s charges were not revealed
to defense counsel until Wednesday, April 18, 1984.
WHEREFORE, Defendant ANTHONY R. TANNER
hereby prays for an entry of an Order granting the fol-
lowing relief:
A. The seheduling of an evidentiary hearing to in-
quire into Mrs. Asbul’s allegations of juror misconduct;
B. The entry of an Order regulating interviews of
other trial jurors and setting the time, place, circumstances
and conditions for such interviews;
C. Postponement of the sentencing scheduled for
April 20, 1984 pending resolution of this Motion and the al-
legations of Mrs. Asbul; and
D. The entry of an Order dismissing the Indietment
or, alternatively, granting a new trial because of preju-
dicial misconduet by one or more trial jurors.
118
DATED this 19th day of April, 1984.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Stephen D. Milbrath
DRAGE, deBEAUBIEN,
MILBRATH & SIMMONS
Co-counsel for Anthony R. Tanner
116 South Orange Avenue
Post Office Box 87
Orlando, Florida 32802
(305) 422-2454
[Certificate of Service omitted in printing. }
119
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE MIDDLE DisSTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
vs. Case No. 83-70 Cr-T-S
WILLIAM M CONOVER and
ANTHONY R. TANNER,
Defendant.
ORDER
(Filed April 23, 1984)
Seateneings of defendants herein was scheduled for
April 20, 1984.
At about 1:57 p.m. on April 19, each defendant filed a
motion to continue the sentencing date. Defendant Tanner
filed a motion alleging certain improprieties on the part of
members of the trial jury, requesting permission to inter-
view certain of the jurors and requesting an order «is-
missing the indictment or alternatively, granting a new
trial. Attached to said motion is the affidavit of David R.
Best, Esquire. Defendant Conover, through counsel, filed
a motion of adoption of defendant Tanner's motions.
At the time said motions were brought to my attention
I was trying a jury ease. I directed that all concerned be
telephonically notified that the motions to continue would
be granted and that I would enter a written order on April
20, 1984.
As indicated, the motion to continue was and is
GRANTED. I find good cause to continue the date for
sentencing. New sentencing dates will be noticed if and
when appropriate.
Rule 606(b) Federal Rules of Evidence in pertinent
part reads as follows:
(b) Inquiry into validity of verdiet or imliet-
ment. Upon an inquiry inte che oy tenlp cine
or indictment, a juror may not testify as to any mat-
Rue 2.03(c) Loeal Rules of the Middle District of |
Florida, page 742 West's Desk Copy Florida Rules of tf
Court State and Federal (1984) in pertinent part is as fol-
lows:
(ie) The ~—"- comluct of all members of
of this ¢ ‘ourt, admitted generally under Rule
tion of EC 7-29 and —yr-P impoxing restric
tions upon the right of counsel to interview jurors af-
Diseiplinary Rule 7-108(D) Code of Professional Re-
sponsibility adopted by the Supreme Court of Florida, and
effective October 1, 1970 (235 So.2d 723), and adopted
by reference by the Judges of the Middle Distriet of Flor-
ida, supra, reported in Volume 35, West's Florida Stat-
utes Annotated, page 353 is ax follows:
(D) After dismissal of the jury in a case with
which he is connected, a lawyer shall not communicate
with or cause another to communieate with any juror
regarding the trial except to determine whether the
verdict may be subject to legal challenge, in whieh
event he shall serupulously follow the proeedure de-
seribed and provided for in EC 7-29 hereof.
Ethical Consideration 7-29 of said Code of Profession-
al Responsibility reads as follows:
EC 7-29. To safeguard the impartiality that is
essential to the judicial process, veniremen and jurors
shoukl be protected against extraneous influences.
When unpartiality is present, publie confidence in the
judicial system ix enhanced. There should be no ex.
trajudeial communication with veniremen prior to
EC 7.30. Vexations or harassing investigations
of venios or jurors seriously impair the effeetive-
ness 4 vy system. For this reason, a lawyer or
anyor «§ — ehalf whe conduets an investigation of
veniress jurors should act with ciretiiuspeetion
and restraint.
EC 7-31. Communications with or investigations
of members of families of veniremen or jurors by a
lawyer or by anyone on his behalf are subject to the
restrictions imposed upon the lawyer with respect to
his communications with or investigations of venire-
men and jurors.
EC 7.32. Because of his duty to aid in preserving
the integrity of the jury system, a lawyer who learns
of improper conduct by or towards a venireman, a
juror, or a member of the family of either should make
& prompt report to the court regarding such conduet.
Whether or not counse! should be allowed to interview
any or all of the trial jurors, and if so, the seope of the
interview and issues to be explored are all matters that
should be determined in advance of any such interviews.
The parties are directed to file memoranda dirceted
to such issues on or before May 25, 1984. A hearing on mo-
tions for leave to interview jurors will be conducted be-
ginning at 10 a.m. on May 30, 1984. In the interim ruling
on defendants’ motions for leave to interview members of
the jury, to dismiss the indictment or grant a new trial is
DEFERRED.
In the interim and until further order of Court no
party hereto or lawyer or anyone on behalf of the parties
or the lawyers shall communicate with or cause another to
communicate to any juror about this ease.
The motion on behalf of defendant Tanner for leave
to interview and the affidavit attached thereto, filed April
19, 1984, shall be withdrawn from the Court file and (iled
by the Clerk as an in camera document rubject to a ruling
as lo its admissibility or relevance on the issues presented.
IT IS SO ORDERED at Tampa, Florida this 23 day of
April, 1984.
/s/ Ben Krentzman
Senior U.S. District Judge
a
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
Case No, 83-70-Cr-T.08
Tampa, Florida May 30,1984 = 10:00 o'clock a.m.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
vs.
WILLIAM M. CONOVER and
ANTHONY B&R. TANNER,
Defendants.
VOLUME NINETEEN
TRANSCRIPT OF TRIAL PROCREDINGS
BEFORE THE HONORABLE BEN KRENTZMAN
AND A JURY
[ Appearances omitted in printing. }
(p. 192) THE COURT: Good morning. This i+
Number &3-70-('r-T, a hearing on a motion filed by defen.
dants. This hearing is being conducted in the courtroom.
By virtue of the nature of the hearing, I have closed the
courtroom, Now, | have instructed the Marshals to allow,
of course, the defendants and their attorneys and members
of their family come in and I note that at least some mem-
bers of the family of one of the defendants is present.
I don't want to close the courtroom to anyone that
the defendants want in here. Anyone outside that you
wanted to get in that didn't get int
MR. BEST: No, sir, your Honor. I
THE COURT: All right. Fine. |
A Miss Melone, M-e-1-o-n-e, who's a reporter for the
St. Pete Times i« outside. She ix a lady whe wrote one of
the newspaper articles. She has requested a hearing be
fore | closed the courtroom; which, in some instances, has
been directed. | just told my Law Clerk to tell her I'm not
having any hearing and I'm not talking with her about this;
the courtroom is closed.
Now, I recognize that this hearing is umportant to the
parties and that I've set aside the morning for the pur-
pose of it. I want you attorneys to be at ease and feel
that vou have the right to present what you have within
the area of professionalism here today.
(p. 19-3) Now I want to make just a brief statement
and then I'll hear from vou.
The verdicts were returned in this case on March %,
1984, and I'm now reading just short excerpts from my
(rder of April 23rd:
Defendant Tanner filed a motion alleging certain im
propricties upon the part of the members of the trial jury,
requesting permission to interview certain of the jurors,
requesting an Order to dismixs the indictment, or in the
alternative granting a new trial.
I entered an order —first | granted the motion toe con.
tinue the sentencing and the parties were — the attorneys
were telephonically notified to that effect. And on April
the Died I entered an Order which, among other things,
said, ** Whether or not counsel should be allowed te inter-
view any or all of the trial jurors, and if sa, the scope of
the interview and the issues to he explored are all matters
that should be determined in advance of any such inter
view.”’ And | directed the parties te file a memorandum
directed te «ach ixenes on of before May 2, 1984 and
scheduled this bearing on the motion for 10.00 am. teday,
May 3), 1084
New that then ix the scope of thie hearing. I have re
ceived and have appreciated and have considered (p. 1%4)
and have considered the respective filings. Mr. Best filed
an initial motion on behalf of defendant Tanner, supple-
mented by his affidavit.
Mr. Lazeara on behalf of Mr. Conover filed a motion
adopting the motion filed by Mr. Best. Thereafter Mr.
Lazzara filed a memorandam—a memorandam was filed
on behalf of Mr. Tanner by Mr. Milbrath, and a memo-
randum was filed by the Government.
The memorandum filed by Mr. Milbrath has attached
a photestat of a—what appears te be a newspaper article
’ published April 24, 1984 written by a Jim Tunstall.
T-o-n-s-t-a-11, allegedly a staff writer of the Tampa Tri-
bune
New these are the matters which are im the file.
I want to, of course, grant te counsel the right to be
heard on the matters set out in the hearing—in the Order
which sets the scope of the hearing. And if you disagree as
te the scope and want te be heard aboat other things, I'll
hear you on that. Bat | think we're all agreed the memo-
randum would suggest that vou accept these as being the
central issue before me for a decision at this time.
Now I'll hear from either or both defendants in such
order as you wish to present.
(p 195) MR. LAZZARA: I) ee first, voor Honor.
THE COURT: Yes.
MR. LAZZARA: Use the pediam!
THE COURT: Yes, if route comfortable there.
Excuse me. I note that Mr. Conewer is not here.
MR. LAZZARA: Judge, be—
THE COURT: He eleeted not toe be hear!’
MR. LAZZARA: Yes, sir. He eleeted not to be here.
ee
127
THE COURT: Well he’s not required to be here. All
right.
MR. LAZZARA: I believe the Court issue here is
whether the defendants should be afforded an opportunity
to demonstrate that as a result of alleged juror misconduct
they were deprived of their Fifth Amendment right to
dve process of law and their Sixth Amendment right to
a fair trial by an impartial jury.
We go on to say that the corner stone of our criminal
justice system is the right of a citizen to be tried by a
jury capable and competent and willing to decide the case
only on the evidence before it, and that the ultimate con-
clusion reached by the jury would be untainted by any out-
side influence.
Now crucial to that Court issue in this case is (p. 1-6)
whether your Honor will allow these defendants to inter-
view the trial jury to determine if the use of alcoholic
beverages had a debilitating effect on one or more of its
members to perform their sworn duties as jurors.
I would submit to your Honor that the Court must
allow such an inquiry to take place under the close scrutiny
and supervision and guidance of this Court.
The affidavit filed by Mr. Best, I believe, details a
conversation he had with Mrs. Asbel, one of the trial jurors.
And in that regard, I would submit it’s more than sufficient
to demonstrate that some jurors were drinking alcoholic
beverages over the lunch hour during days when court
was in session and that this had an e
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.