Joint Appendix — Wards Cove Packing Co. v. Atonio
Supreme Court brief1989
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 87-1387
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1988
WARDS COVE PACKING COMPANY, INC.,
CASTLE & COOKE, INC.
Petitioners,
Vv.
FRANK ATONIO, et al.,
Respondents.
JOINT APPENDIX
Douglas M. Fryer*
Douglas M. Duncan
Richard L. Phillips
MIKKELBORG, BROZ,
WELLS & FRYER
Suite 3300
1001 Fourth Avenue Plaza
Seattle, Washington 98154
(206) 623-5890
Attorneys for Petitioners
* Counsel of Record
September 9, 1988
ehC 1) Legal Promters Seattle WA
Relevant Docket Entries.
Revised Pretrial Order ...
Deposition of Harold Brindle .
Deposition of Mervin W. Lessley
Deposition of Randall Lee
Mi lhol land . . * * . . . . . *
Deposition of Russell J. Rohrer.
Deposition of Marvin Clay Snyder
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
Testimony
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
of
Clarke Kido .-...- =.
Frank Peters. ..- -
Stephen Noel Bird .
Richard Gurtiza .-
David Della . .
Orlando Bucsit.-
Andy Pascua .- .-
Michael Tardif. °
Gary Mamallo. ... .-
Mike Eddie Antonio. .
William T. Pascua .- .-
Shirley Jeanne Smith.
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued) TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Page Page
Testimony of H. J. Parrish. . .. . A-105 Testimony of Cheryl Tatom. . .. . A-407
Testimony of Jill Henderson . . . . A-112 Testimony of Charley Anderson. . . A-414
Testimony of Patrick Timothy Testimony of Robert Krapp. ... . A-422
ee se
.
>
!
~
~
>
Testimony of Richard Quirion ... A-432
Testimony of Joel Stromme . . . - - Ani23 Testimoriy of Eberle Mercer .... A-434
Testimony of Albert Belasario
Pastores, Jf. . «© « « © © «© « « « AeASS
A-127 Testimony of Frank Shucka. ... . A-447
Testimony of Earl Anderson .... A-438
Testimony of Eugene Baclig. ....
Testimony of Christopher Steele . . A-131 Testimony of James W. Yonker . . . A-453
Testimony of Phillip Fujii. . . . . A-137 Testimony of John R. Gilbert ... A-460
T -
Testimony of Cathlyn Hjorten. - . r A-141 Testimony of Winn F. Brindle . ° ° A 463
Testimony of Roderick E. Testimony of Larry L. DeFrance .. A-470
COMSEOR: CBee + 5 © Batt re Testimony of Jack Aiello ..... A-577
Testimony of Arsenio Eleccion - - - A-15! Testimony of Laurie Brindle
Testimony of Alec W. Brindle. A-156 Romine - +--+ + + + «+ + + + + + + A-586
Testimony of Warner Leonardo. - - - A-213 Testimony of Elroy Kowalski. . - - A-589
Testimony of John Lum. ...... A-614
.
.
.
>
'
N
w
~
Testimony of Donald E. Wise
Testimony of Dr. Albert Rees. - - - A=250
»
'
w
ra)
x
Testimony of Robert J. Flanagan
Testimony of Gary P. Latham .. - - A-391
Testimony of Ronald Baclig. . .- - A-402
Testimony of Alan Lew .... -+- + + A=403
-69> -iii-
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
3/20/74 Complaint filed.
5/5/82 Revised Pretrial Order
entered.
5/3 /82-
5/17/82 Trial conducted.
10/31/83 United States District
Court for the Western
District of Washington
opinion entered.
12/6/83 Order correcting opinion -
following nonjury' trial
and directing correction
of judgment entered.
8/16/85 Opinion in the Court of
Appeals affirming the
judgment entered.
11/18/85 Order withdrawing the
Court of Appeals opinion
an@ ordering rehearing en
banc entered.
9/2/87 Second opinion of the
Original panel of - the
Court of Appeals on remand
from the en banc court
entered.
11/12/87 Order Clarifying the
Opinion entered.
11/12/87 Petition for rehearing
denied.
12/23/87 Opinion of the en banc
Court of Appeals entered.
A-1
NO. 87-1387
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term 1988
WARDS COVE PACKING COMPANY,
CASTLE & COOKE, INC.,
Petitioners,
vs.
FRANK ATONIO, et al,
Respondents.
BRIEF OF PETITIONERS
APPENDIX
INC.,
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON
FRANK ATONIO,
et al.,
Plaintiffs,
NO. C 74-145 S
vs.
REVISED
WARDS COVE PACKING PRETRIAL ORDER
COMPANY, INC.,
et al.,
Defendants.
me ee ee ee ee ee ee
[PTO, p. 2]
ADMITTED FACTS
(2) The following facts are
admitted by the parties. ...
x *&
[PTO, pp. 10, 14)
80. The majority of non-resident
cannery workers are lined up by the
cannery worker foremen after management
has estimated the number that will be
needed.
A-3
[PTO, p. 16]
93. At least during 1970 through
1975, Bumble Bee has not advertised in
media for applicants for any jbos, Nor
[sic] has it posted vacancies at the
cannery.
94. Non-resident cannery workers
are those whose off-season residence is
in the Lower 48. Some have been hired
directly by Bumble Bee in Astoria.
95. At least since 1970 Bumble Bee
has on occasion recruited resident
cannery workers from Alaska Native
villages through bush pilots. (Resident
Cannery workers are those whose off-
season residence is Alaska.)
96. At least since 1970 some non-
resident cannery workers have been hired
directly by Bumble Bee in Astoria. The
majority of non-resident cannery workers
A-4
dispatched to Bumble Bee through Local
37, ILWU have been Filipino.
x *
[PTO, p. 17]
102. At least since 1970 Red Salmon
has on occasion recruited some resident
cannery workers from Alaska Native
villages. The recruitment has been
through village leaders and bush pilots,
among others.
[PTO, p. 18]
104. The machinist foremen at Wards
Cove have on occasion recommended people
for machinist jobs, among other jobs.
105. Wards Cove has not advertised
in the media for jobs at least since 1970.
Nor has it posted vacancies at the cannery
at least from 1970 through 1977. Wards
Cove has called the Alaska State
Employment Service in recruiting resident
cannery workers, but hasn't done any
media advertising.
106. At least since 1970 resident
cannery workers at Wards Cove have
generally been hired for only portions of
the season, during intense periods of
canning.
107. At least since 1977 Wards Cove
has hired some non-resident cannery
workers directly at 88 East Hamlin,
Seattle, Washington.
108. The majority of non-resident
Cannery workers dispatched to Wards Cove
through Local 37, ILW = have been
Filipino.
[PTO, p. 19]
116. It has not generally been
defendants’ practice at any time since
1970 to post written notice at Bumble Bee,
Red Salmon, Wards Cove or Ekuk canneries
A-6
of job vacancies which develop during the
season. « «. «
[PTO, p. 20]
118. A company fisherman captain's
job can be learned through prior
experience as a company fisherman's
partner.
A-7
DISTRICT COURT
DEPOSITION OF HAROLD BRINDLE
[Dep., p. 2]
HAROLD BRINDLE, being first duly
sworn by the Notary Public to tell the
whole truth, deposed and said as follows:
* * ®
[Dep., p. 33]
Q. Did you ever discuss with him
the necessity of housing crews together?
A. No, but there are various
specific advantages for doing so.
Q. Is that for call out time?
A. Basically.
Q. That's the crux of the
advantage of housing crews together?
A. Yes.
Q. Sorters would ordinarily get
called out earlier than other cannery
workers; isn't that correct? The fish
come in and have to be sorted into the
bins before they are processed?
A. Basically.
x* kt
[Dep., p. 34]
Q. And they would get called out
earlier than the other cannery workers;
right?
A. On occasion.
* *«
[Dep., pp. 35-38]
Q. When you refer to call-out time
or call-out time as you understand the
usage of the term refers to that time of
the day when the employees are told to go
to work; is that correct?
A. Basically.
Q. If the tender comes in with a
lot of fish and it's early in the morning,
the sorters would get called out to start
the fish first; right?
A-9
A. Along with the beach gang to
unload the fish.
Q. And then later in the day,
perhaps, once it's in the bins, the
cannery workers would get called out; is
that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And the machinists who are
assigned to particular departments would
get called out with them; is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. At the same time, in other
A. Yes.
oO. Port engineers might get called
out much earlier in the day if a fishing
vessel had repairs that were needed; is
that right?
A. Right.
Q. On the whole the office staff
works regular hours, say, 9:00 to 5:00?
A. No.
A-10
Q. What are their hours?
A. Normally from 8:00 in the
morning through 9:00 in the evening.
Q. But on the whole they are not
subject to call out depending on when the
tenders come in; is that correct?
A. Most normally not.
Q. They have their regular hours
duties to do; correct?
A. Right.
Q. Quality control, when do they
do their work?
A. During the time of canning.
Q. They would get called out at
the same time as the machinists assigned
to departments and the cannery workers
and the sorters; is that correct?
A. That's right.
Q. Would the call-out time for all
the culinary crew members be the same?
A. No.
Q. Who would get called out first?
A-1l
A. The first cook.
Q. And then?
A. Probably the baker.
Q. And after that?
A. Everyone else.
Q. Would the waiters get called
out before the dishwashers?
A. No.
Q. Supervisors such as the beach
boss and the first machinist and the
cannery crew foreman, would they have
their own call-out times or would they be
called out at the same time as their
crews?
A. That's pretty hard to answer.
Q. Well, as a general rule?
A. Most normally if there's an
early call-out, they would be first.
* *£
A-12
~
DISTRICT COURT
DEPOSITION OF MERVIN W. LESSLEY
[Dep., Pp. 2]
MERVIN W. LESSLEY, being first duly
sworn by the Notary Public to tell the
whole truth, deposed and said as follows:
x *
[Dep., pp. 4-5]
Q. What did you start out as?
A. Machinist.
Q. What was the first year you
worked at Red Salmon?
A. 1960.
Q. Have you worked there
continuously since 1960?
A. For the canhing season, yes.
Q. That's what I meant. And
@uring the off season have you worked at
Take Union Terminal each season since
1960?
A. Yes.
A-13
[Dep., p. 6]
Q. When did you become a machinist
foreman at Red Salmon?
A. 1972.
[Dep., p. 6]
Q. From the 1972 season onward did
you have any responsibility in hiring
machinists for Red Salmon?
A. Well, somewhat.
Q. Who else had a role in hiring
machinists?
A. Mr. A. W. Brindle.
Q. Would you recommend machinists
to him?
A. Yes.
[Dep., p. 7]
Q. If there was an opening would
Brindle ask you if you knew somebody that
could fill the job?
A-14
A. Yes.
Q. And if you knew someone, would
you recommend the person?
A. Yes. If I thought they were
qualified I would, yes.
Q. If you didn't know someone,
would you ask around your friends?
A. Yes.
Q. Would you do anything else to
find prospective machinsts?
A. Well, there would be people
come in from off the street, you know.
Q. For the most part was it a
guestion of asking around among the
people you knew?
A. Well, no, I wouldn't say so.
Q. About half and half?
A. Maybe 60-40.
Q. Which is the 60?
A. Trying to find qualified people
on your own and taking people who came in
and applied. They would make out an
A-15
application. We would ivestigate their
background and their qualifications.
xk
[Dep., p. 12]
Q. You have heard the term:
"Filipino bunkhouse,” haven't you?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard it used at Red
Salmon?
A. I suppose I have.
Q. So far as you can tell, was it
commonly used at Red Salmon up until the
time of the fire?
A. Well, that was one way of
designating the different mess halls.
*x* &
[Dep., p. 14]
Q. Is there a building that is
still called the Filipino bunkhouse
there?
A-16
A. Well, it was called that
before. That's what it's called now, I
guess.
Q. Is there a building that is
called the Native bunkhouse there now?
A. It hasn't had a Native in it for
years.
[Dep., pp. 14-15]
Q. So, it's not called the Native
bunkhouse any more?
A. It's called Native bunkhouse
but there is nobody there.
Q. Nobody lives there at all?
A. No.
Q. Have you used the term
"Filipino bunkhouse"?
A. I have, yes.
Q. Have you used the term "Native
Bunkhouse"?
A. Yes. When I went to send
somebody over to do a job there. Like
A-17
with the plumbing and et cetera, et
cetera, et cetera. They have to know
where they are going and et cetera.
Q. Did A. W. Brindle use the term
"Native bunkhouse"?
A. I guess he has.
x *&
[Dep., p. 30]
Q. When you asked around for
machinists among your acquaintances,
those that you turned up were all white;
were they not?
A. Yes.
A-18
a
6 <r .
ie...
DISTRICT COURT
DEPOSITION OF RANDALL LEE MILHOLLAND
[Dep., p- 3]
RANDALL LEE MILHOLLAND, called as a
witness by the plaintiffs, having been
first Guly sworn, testified as follows:
x *&
[Dep., pp. 3-5]
Q. Were you employed by Wards Cove
Packing Company?
A. Yes, I was.
Q. In what job?
A. Two jobs, Cannery Store Keeper
and Cannery Tenderman.
Q. What was the first year you
worked there?
A. I was trying to figure that out
last night.
Q. Was that 1970?
A. "69 or ‘70. Yeah, 1970.
Q. You were Store Keeper then?
A-19
A.
Q.
was when?
up?
up?
then?
Yes.
And the next year you went up
"72.
What was your job then?
Storekeeper.
What was the next year you went
'73 .
Were you a Tender Engineer
A Tender Engineer.
What was the next year you went
"74.
Were you a Tender Engineer
Tender Engineer.
What was the next year you went
1975.
What was your job then?
A-20
—«-
|
|
.
|
A. Tender Engineer.
Q. Were those the only seasons you
worked in Alaska?
A. Those were the only seasons.
Q. What is your date of birth?
A. September 10th, 1953.
Q. So, is it correct to say that
you were sixteen when you first got the
job of Store Keeper?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you work on more than one
tender while you worked at Wards Cove?
A. Three different tenders.
Q. Do you remember their names?
A. Vanguard, which was Wards Cove-
owned; the Puffin, which was Columbia
Wards Cove; and these were in consecutive
years; and the Petrel, I believe, which is
Werds Cove-owned.
Whoops. Excuse me. Columbia Wards
owned the Petrel, if that makes any
@ifference.
A-21
[Dep., pp. 5-6]
Q. Did your father ever work for
Wards Cove Packing Company?
A. He worked for Columbia Wards
Fisheries.
Q. Had he worked for Columbia
Wards Fishery before you were hired in
1970?
A. Yes.
Q. What was his job?
A. Fe was an accountant.
Q. Did he work in the Seattle
office or in one of the Alaska fisheries?
A. The Seattle office.
* *
[Dep., pp. 8-9]
Q. Prior to becoming the Tender
Engineer your first season had you had any
mechanical job experience?
A. No.
A-22
le
—— oe ok ae
|
.
|
:
Q. Had you taken any courses in
diesel mechanics?
A. No.
Q. Had you taken any mechanical
courses?
A. No.
Q. Had you worked on your own car
prior to that time?
A. Yes.
Q. Was that the only mechanical
experience you had prior to becoming a
Tender Engineer the first year?
A. Yes.
Q. Had you had any prior boating
jobs? In other words, jobs on boats?
A. No.
Q. Had you had any courses in
navigation?
A. No.
Q. Any other marine courses?
A. No.
A-23
[Dep., p. 42]
Q. That covers it. What kind of
work, exactly, had you done on cars just
prior to your first season as a Tender
Engineer?
A. Just basic helping with
maintenance, changing belts, checking--or
preventative maintenance. Changing oil
filters, greasing, other things with
friends who had cars, like replacing
starters, replacing brushes in
Starters--you know, just a number of
things.
Q. Had you done a complete
overhaul on a car?
A. No.
A-24
baa
St i ela
lil lL ALAA LL ASS
eee OE, nd, me 4 ee ‘
li cma
DISTRICT COURT
DEPOSITION OF RUSSELL J. ROHRER
[Dep., p- 2]
RUSSELL J. ROHRER, being first duly
sworn by the Notary Public to tell the
whole truth, deposed and said as follows:
* *«
[Dep., p- 3)
Q. How many seasons have you
worked at Ekuk?
A. Since 1956 every season except
one.
[Dep., pp. 3-4]
Q. Last season did you work as a
cannery foreman?
A. Yes.
Q. That's also known as machinist
foreman?
A. Yes.
A-25
Q. What was the first year that
you worked as a cannery foreman?
A. 1959.
Q. And you have worked as a
cannery foreman each season since then?
A. Right.
* «£
Q. Have you ever trained a reform
machinist in one season?
A. No, I think not.
* *£
[Dep., p. 15]
Q. Have you ever trained a salmon
cook in one season?
A. Yes.
Q. Who was that?
A. Tom Cattell.
**
[Dep., pp. 15-16]
Q. (By Mr. Arditi) How did Tom
Cattell come to work for you?
A-26
A. He started as a cannery worker,
I believe, in 1971.
Q. Mr. Cattell worked as a salmon
cook in 1974 and '75; is that right?
A. I think that's right.
Q. Prior to that he was a cannery
worker or a general worker?
A. Yes.
Q. Had he ever worked as a
machinist before 1974?
A. In the cannery?
Q. Yes.
A. No.
Q. Did you promote him to salmon
cook yourself?
A. Yes.
Q. How did you come to pick him?
A. His work was loading the
retorts and he worked around where, with
the salmon cook, and I think he worked it
two or three years and he learned quite a
bit about what had to be done and he
A-27
just .. . when we needed a salmon cook,
why, we offered him the job.
Q. But the learning that he did
for it was learning as a cannery worker or
general worker; correct?
A. Yes.
[Dep., p. 17]
Q. Did he have any other
qualifications for the job other than
what he had learned working around the
retorts?
A. He had gone to night school and
taken machine shop courses and it was all
to run a lathe and various machine shop
tools.
[Dep., p. 17]
Q. So, machine shop work is not
normally part of the salmon cook's
duties; is it?
A. No, not necessarily.
A-28
6 bn el etatne .
Cd SO ORS packs ell et EP LO
7
%
4
[Dep., p. 18]
c. So, is it correct to say that
everything you need to know to work as a
salmon cook can be learned on the job as a
cannery worker or a general worker?
A. I think some people could learn
it.
A-29
DISTRICT COURT
DEPOSITION OF MARVIN CLAY SNYDER
[Dep., p. 2]
MARVIN CLAY SNYDER, being first duly
sworn by the Notary Public to tell the
whole truth, deposed and said as follows:
x* *&
[Dep., pp. 2-3]
Q. You were previously employed by
Bumble Bee Sea Foods Division of Castle &
Cook; weren't you?
A. Yes.
Q. When did you stop your
employment with them?
A. Well, I still go North for them
at Naknek cannery.
Q. So, your job is seasonal?
A. Yes.
Q. Your ob is cannery foreman?
A. Yes.
A-30
.
:
a
Q. Is that also known as
machinists foreman?
A. Yes.
Q. How long have you been in that
capacity for Bumble Bee?
A. Since 1968.
* & &°
[Dep., p. 10]
A. Well, that was "A" is what we
used to refer to it.
Q. Have you heard the term "Native
crew"?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that in reference to the
crew that lived in Bunkhouse "A"?
A. Yes.
Q. And those would be the resident
cannery workers?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard the term "White
mess hall"?
A-31
[Dep., pp. 10-12]
Q.
It appears to be. Have you used
the term "Filipino bunkhouse"?
Q.
Do I use it?
Have you used the term?
Oh, yes.
How about "Filipino crew," have
you used that term?
A.
Q.
Q.
Yes.
"Native bunkhouse”?
Yes.
"Filipino mess hall"?
Yes.
"Native crew"?
Yes.
"White mess hall"?
Yes.
Have you heard other
supervisory personnel at Bumble Bee use
those terms?
A.
Well, yes.
A-32
«he ei ets
=~
.
:
Q. Have you heard Mr. Leonardo use
"Filipino bunkhouse”?
A. Yes.
Q. I am sorry?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard him use
"Filipino crew:?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard him use
"Filipino mess hall"?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard him use “Native
bunkhouse”?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you hear him use “Native
crew"?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you heard him use “White
mess hall"?
A.
Q.
Yes.
Are those terms in common usage
around the Bumble Bee cannery?
A-33
A. Well, I suppose they are. It's
years of that.
Q. When you say, “years of that,”
"you mean that for years they have been
called by those terms?
A. That I have been going North,
yes.
[Dep., p. 17]
Q. But he was hired as a salmon
cook ?
A. A salmon cook, yes. It was a
promotion.
Q. Briefly, what were his duties
as a stockroom worker?
A. Just putting away the stock and
dishing it out to people that come in and
wanted it.
QO. When you stay “stock,” do you
mean machine parts?
A. Well, it was everything,
machine parts mostly are in a different
A-34
+ i emneireeraalee.
sue Btn a
ed ee A a
,
r
5
»
“4
:
‘
©
-
department. That is for the canning
machines. But this is a stockroom, a
general stock they needed in the
canneries for everything, for everybody
down there.
Q. Like cans?
A. No, not cans. But bottles,
nuts, screws, just lights and brooms and
scrub brushes, anything, paint.
* *
[Dep., p- 18]
Q. Is it pretty much like being a
store clerk?
A. Well, it would be similar.
Q. In 1971 Mr. Frost was promoted
to salmon cook?
A. Yes.
Q. Was he given any training as a
salmon cook prior to the beginning of the
season?
A. Oh, yes. We showed him how to
operate the thing.
A-35
Q. Was this the only training or
work as a salmon cook, the pre-season
training that you gave him?
A. Well, then, of course, he was
there the year before and, of course, the
retorts are right alongside the
stockroom. So, he is probably, was in
there with the salmon cook in the year
before and, so, more of less...
Q. (Interposing) So, he could
watch?
A. So, he found out more or less
what the operation was, you see.
Q. The cannery workers who have
jobs with the retorts or in the lye wash
Or as inverters also work around the
salmon cook; don't they?
A. Yes, they are working on the
retorts, yes.
Q. So, they would have the same
opportunity to observe as the stockroom
man; is that right?
A-36
eth, ial aati EAL: BS my
A. Any of them could, yes.
* * ®
[Dep., p- 20)
Q. If you are fairly smart, you
could learn it as quickly as Mr. Frost
did?
A. I suppose you could.
A-37
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF CLARKE KIDO
CLARKE KIDO, being first sworn,
states:
[p. 35]
l. I live at 1381 Jefferson, Idaho
Palls, Idaho 83402. I am employed by EG&G
as a senior engineer to do structural
analysis on nuclear test reactor
facilities. Prior to that, I worked for
the Boeing Company as a structural design
engineer. I received my B.S. from the
University of Washington in aeronautical
engineering in December, 1972. I am a
plaintiff in this case. I worked for
Wares Cove Packing Company, Inc. at its
Ketchikan cannery in 1970, 1972 and 1973.
I worked for Bumble Bee Seafoods at its
South Naknek cannery in 1971.
[p. 36)
A-38
3. When I arrived at Wards Cove in
1970, the cannery worker foreman,
Salvador del Fierro, pointed out the
bunkhouse our crew was to occupy... .-
4. The bunkhouse was a two-storey
[sic] wood frame building. We were housed
three to four apiece in rooms which were
approximately eight or ten feet by twelve
feet. On the bottom floor of the
bunkhouse was our messhall, kitchen and
three or four rooms which our culinary
workers used. Our bunkhouse is marked
Building 1 on Exhibit 163. It was
commonly called the “Filipino bunkhouse”
just as the messhall was called the
"Filipino messhall" around the
cannery... .
[p. 37]
5. Most of the white employees who
lived at the cannery stayed in what is
marked Building 5 on Exhibit 163... .
A-39
[p. 38]
8. + « « The smell attracted
flies, which came through the window.
Moreover, heat from the stove rose
upstairs, making it uncomfortable to stay
in the bunkhouse. ...
* «+f
[p. 40]
15. I spoke to a person at 88 East
Hamlin named Parrish. I was looking for a
job of a sort that I could not find at
Local 37, I.L.W.U.: namely, a job other
than cannery worker. I then down to the
office with Lester Kuramoto with whom I
had previously worked at Wards Cove.
Mr. Parrish gave each of us an
application blank. I told Mr. Parrish
that I was interested in a job outside of
Local 37, I.L.W.U. On the application
blank I wrote down that I wanted a
Carpenter or assistant carpenter position
Or a machinist or mechanic helper or
A-40
trainee position. I told him I would be
willing to go to any cannery.
16. Mr. Parrish suggested that
Mr. Kuramoto and I go to Local 37,
I.L.W.U. for a job. From my experience at
Wards Cove in 1970 I knew that Local 37,
I.L.W.U. jobs were the ones which were
filled primarily by nonwhites.
Mr. Parrish also cut the conversation
short by saying that there were no
openings in any jobs. He said this before
looking at my application. He did not
check a list or consult with anyone in the
office before saying this. Among other
jobs I was interested in at the time were
quality control, storekeeper and beach
gang. I was available for work in Alaska
in mid-May that year.
17. Since I was unsuccessful in
obtaining a noncannery worker job through
88 East Hamlin, I contacted my old cannery
worker foreman, Salvador del Fierro. I
A-41
asked him what other jobs I could find
Outside of cannery worker jobs. He said
that as a cannery worker I would have to
stay a cannery worker.
[p. 41]
18. Finally, I went down to Local
37, I.L.W.U. for a cannery worker job
since no other options were open to me. I
was dispatched to the Bumble Bee cannery,
in’ South Naknek.
19. Prior to my application in
1971, I had some carpentry experience
with my uncle as well as my father. My
uncle owns an apartment building on which
I did some roofing, repairs, plumbing and
electrical work. I also put in windows
and wall partitions. Prior to my 1971
application I had also done some
Carpentry work with my father around our
home. This involved remodeling, putting
up sheetrock, laying down floors, putting
up wall partitions, doing roof repairs, a
A-42
|
4
|
d
‘
little electrical work, putting up
fences, a small amount of framing and some
household plumbing.
* *«
[p. 41]
21. At Bumble Bee the male
Local 37, I.L.W.U. crew was housed in one
bunkhouse. The cannery worker foreman
told us which bunkhouse our crew would
live in and which messhall we would eat
in. The bunkhouse is marked Building B on
Exhibit 161. The occupants were 100% non-
white. The vast majority of them were of
Filipino descent. The remaining ones
were of Asian descent. The Alaska Native
cannery workers were housed separately in
what is marked Building A on Exhibit 161.
There were a number of women cannery
workers almost all of whom were white.
They lived in what is marked Building J on
Exhibit 16l. Other white crews were
housed in other bunkhouses.
A-43
22. Our bunkhouse was a two-storey
[sic] building with rooms about 10° x 12’.
We were housed four per room. Each room
had two bunkbeds. The walls were of
shiplap type construction. Since there
was very little insulation I could feel
the wind come from one side of the
building right through the walls. In our
room there was one bare overhead light.
Since we had no closet we had to store our
clothes in trunks or suitcases underneath
the lower bunks or hang them on the walls.
Finally, we had a small table as well as
one chair.
[p. 42]
23. We use the hallways to store
our rain gear, boots, hats and other
working clothing. The fact that we worked
with raw salmon all day gave our clothes a
fishy odor. It drifted in from the hall
to the sleeping rooms. Downstairs there
was a small open area about 15° x 15'
A-44
which some crew members used for card
games.
24. The bunkhouse the Alaska
Natives lived in was approximately the
same size as ours. Some of the windows
were broken. They were not repaired
during the time that I was at Bumble Bee.
I could see dust on both sides of the
windows. I could also see the paint
peeling and cracking around the windows
as well as on the outside of the building.
The Alaska Natives also lived four to a
room in bunkbeds.
25. In contrast, the women's
bunkhouse was fairly new. It also had
aluminum siding -- unlike our bunkhouse
or the Alaska Native bunkhouse.
26. There were two messhalls at
Bumble Bee cannery. One messhall served
the Filipino crew and the Alaska Native
crew. It is marked Building T on Exhibit
161. All of the people who ate there
A-45
regularly were non-white. The other
messhall served everyone else at the
cannery, including: the women cannery
workers, the fishermen, the machinists,
the carpenters and others. Nearly
everyone who ate in that messhall was
white.
27. Mugups, which are a kind of
evening meal, were served in both
messhalls at Bumble Bee. The people who
regularly ate in our messhall were to have
their mugups there. By the same token,
those who ate their meals in the other
messhall were to take their mugups there
as well. Our messhall was commonly called
the “Filipino messhall" while the other
was usually called the “white messhall.”"
[p. 43]
28. In 1972-73 Wards Cove cannery
operated again. Consequently I went back
there for a seconée and third season. The
bunkhouse had been paintec, there were
A-46
Mee mets — sven astianeseceitaindlamanentamsinse ns renssemeeeel
|
fewer people in our rooms and the linen
was changed somewhat more frequently.
Other than that, conditions were
essentially unchanged. We continued to
sleep in the "Filipino bunkhouse," eat in
the “Filipino messhall" and perform
miscellaneous tasks our foreman assigned.
29. In 1973 our crew held a food
strike ‘to protest the quality of food
served in the Filipino messhall. We had
asked the cannery worker foreman Salvador
del Fierro for more variety, fresh fruits
and fresh vegetables. When we didn't
receive them, we held a food strike. We
showed up at the messhall at meal time but
Gidn't eat. Instead, we ought food in
town which we ate in our rooms. The food
strike lasted about three days until we
had a formal crew meeting. After that
there was a slight improvement in the
food.
A-47
30. In February, 1975, I was laid
off from work at Boeing. When I first
began looking I had trouble finding work
in my field. Consequently, I took work as
a laborer with Center Dozing for a short
time in the spring of 1975. During that
time I also worked as a survey chainman
with my uncle who is a licensed surveyor.
On and off I also worked as a delivery man
for Product Development in the spring of
1975. Among work I was looking for was a
position in the carpenter trade. In fact
at about that time I took a test for
a@mission to the apprenticeship program.
31. In the spring of 1975 I went
down to 88 East Hamlin, Seattle,
Washington once again to apply for an
upper level position. ...
* *
[p. 48]
Q. (By Mr. Phillips) Lets [sic]
talk about housing at Wards Cove for a
A-48
f
j
minute. You stayed in which bunkhouse at
Wards Cove?
A. What is called the Filipino
bunkhouse.
Q. Who gave it that name, by the
way, do you know?
A. The foreman designated
bunkhouse that we were staying at, and
everyone referred to it as such.
Q. The foreman is Salvador del
Fierro?
A. That is correct.
Q. And he is Filipino?
A. Yes.
Q. That particular bunkhouse
housed male members of the Local 37 crew?
A. That's right.
Q. Most of them were Filipino?
A. That's right.
A-49
[p. 50)
Q. Let's talk about messing for a
minute, Mr. Kido. You talk about the
white messhall. Is that the name that you
guys -- that's the name you guys gave to
that messhall, isn't it, the main mess?
A. That is what the name that
everyone seemed to give it. The women --
Q. Who else do you recall
referring to it that way?
A. The non -- the white members of
the cannery.
[p. 70]
THE COURT: Mr. Kido, your affidavit
doesn't specify your nationality, unless
I am mistaken.
THE WITNESS: That's right, it
doesn't.
THE COURT: I think it is probably
just an oversight. But for the records,
what is your nationality?
A-50
THE WITNESS: I am Japanese-
American.
THE COURT: And your parents’
backgound?
THE WITNESS: The same. Japanese-
American.
THE COURT: Are they both, as far as
their blood, full-blooded Japanese?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
A-51
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF FRANK PETERS
FRANK PETERS, being first duly
sworn, states:
[p. 75]
- 1. I lave at 1743 Summit Avenue,
Apt. 207, Seattle, Washington 98122. I
was born in American Samoa. I moved to
the United States in 1970 to attend
school. .. =.
[p. 76]
3. I graduated from Cleveland High
School in 1972. I spent the next school
year at Highline Community College
studying business and psychology. From
there I went to Seattle Central Community
College for a year. I received my 8.S.
from Portland State University in
political science in 1978. I took one
quarter of graduate work there in public
A-52
administration. I also had a quarter of
graduate work in political science at the
University of Washington. ...
* *
[p. 76]
5. [ obtained my first job with
Wards Cove Packing Company, Inc. through
the cannery worker foreman Salvador del
Pierro. A Samoan friend had asked me
whether I wanted to go to Alaska to work
for the summer. He then took me to
Mr. del Fierro'’s house. After I spoke
with him, Mr. del Fierro wrote my name
down on the list of people who were going
to work for him. He told me, “This is a
list of my crew.” Mr. del Fierro the
[sic] took me down to Local 37, I.L.W.U.
During dispatch my name was called. I
then joined the Union.
[p. 77]
6. The company flew our crew to
Ketchikan on a charter plane. When we
A-53
arrived at the cannery Mr. del Fierro
pointed out two bunkhouses -- telling us
that they were for our crew. Those
bunkhouses are marked Buildings 1 and 2 on
Exhibit 163. They were commonly called
the "Filipino bunkhouses" around the
cannery. For example, I heard the cannery
superintendent Joe Brindle, the head
machinist Ray Landry and the cannery
worker foreman Salvador del Fierro all
use the term “Filipino bunkhouse.” Other
such terms were also used around Wards
Cove. For example, our crew was commonly
called the “Filipino Crew." I heard Joe
Brindle, Ray Landry and Joe Srindle’s
Gaughter all use this term. There were
two messhalls at Wards Cove. One, which
was located in Building 1, was for the
male non-resident cannery workers. The
other, which was located in Building 5,
was for the other company employees who
lived at the cannery. Our messhall was
A-54
commonly called the "Filipino messhall."
Members of our crew often called the other
one the “white messhall.” I knew which
messhall to eat in since Mr. del Fierro
told us in a crew meeting when we first
arrived that the F.°ipino messhall was
where our crew was to eat.
* 2«£
[p. 78]
9. Bunkhouse 1 was 100% non-white
in 1972 through 1975. One white lived in
Bunkhouse 2 in 1972-3. He ate in the
white messhall rather than our messhall.
The white crews lived in what are marked
Buildings 3, 4 and 5 on Exhibit 163. Each
year during 1972-75 about 8-10 people--
all of whom were white--lived in
Bunkhouse 5. Each year during 1972-75 the
bookkeeper Jerry Steele--who is white--
lived in Building 4. The cannery
superintendent lived in what is marked
H.A.B. House on Exhibit 163. Each year
A-55
during 1972-75 about six women cannery
workers lived in Building 3. They were
all from the Lower 48. They were all
white. Japanese National egg technicians
lived there too, but they were not
employees of Wards Cove Packing Company,
Inc. Also, the watchman lived in what is
marked Watchman's House.
* «
[pp. 81-82]
18. In 1973 I asked the head
machinist Ray Landry if I could become a
machinist's helper. The conversation
took place after church on a Sunday. He
responded by asking, “What's wrong with
being on the Filipino crew?" I pointed
out to him that I needed more money to
continue in school. He told me I needed
experience in order to become a machinist
helper. I asked him if there were courses
I should take, but he did not answer.
A-56
Instead, he shook his head and walked
away.
19. Toward the end of the 1973
season I also asked the cannery
superintendent Joe Brindle what’ the
possibility of my getting a job on a
tender was. I also asked him for a
machinist or carpenter job. He told me to
talk to my foreman Arsenio Eleccion who
was- second cannery worker foreman. I did
not bring this up with Mr. Eleccion since
he only supervised cannery workers rather
than employees in the jobs I was seeking.
20. Shortly after I returned from
Alaska in 1973 I asked Jerry Steele for a
Clerical job or a job on a tender. Mr.
Steele was the bookkeeper at Wards Cove.
He told me to give him a call later on.
Consequently, I contacted him a second
time, but he didn't give me a definite
answer. At one point he said, “We'll
see." I asked him if he wanted me to call
A-57
him back yet again. He said yes, so I
called a third time but could not get hold
[sic] of him. I left a message but he
never called back.
21. When I talked to Ray Landry,
Joe Brindle and Jerry Steele in 1973, I
was not told to file a é written
application. They did not ask me my
qualifications or give me a chance to
state them.
[pp. 83-84]
26. Prior to my application for a
carpenter job in 1973 I had worked with my
father in American Samoa. He worked as a
carpenter building houses, cabinet and
repairing ships. I started working with
him when I was 13 or 14 through the time I
left when I was 20. During school I
worked 10 to 20 hours per week. I also
worked some Sunday [sic] as well as
vacations. My work with him entailed
A-58
painting, sharpening tools, making
cabinets, laying foundations, putting up
house frames, laying partitions, doing
roofing and helping repair boats. Also,
in Hawaii during 1968-69 I worked as a
cabinet maker's helper for about a year.
* «
28. Before going to Alaska in 1972
I had boating experience with my
grandfather in Samoa. He is a fisherman
with his own boat which is about 20 feet
in length. I worked for him 2-3 times per
week for about three years. Also, while I
worked as a bin man I also learned to
identify the various species of salmon.
* *«
[p. 116]
THE COURT: Mr. Peters, for the
record, your affidavit says you were born
in American Samoa. Are you of Samoan
descent?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
A-59
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF STEPHEN NOEL BIRD
[pp. 121-122]
STEPHEN NOEL BIRD, being first
sworn, states:
l. I live at 4302 - 79th N.W.,
Marysville, WA 98270. I am currently
employed as a shipwright by the Boatyard,
Inc. in Seattle, I worked for Wards Cove
Packing Company, Inc. as a tender
engineer during the 1974 season. ...
2. - « « I worked as a sailmaker
for two months. Then in February or
March, 1974 I was hired by Columbia Wards
Fisheries at Lake Union Terminals as
Clean-up and helper. I was generally a
go-fer, carried wood and helped put in
planks for a few months. During that time
I learned that the company had facilities
which it operated in Alaska during the
summer months which I hadn't known when I
A-60
first started. After I learned this I
asked Ray Landry who was the head
machinist if I could work on a tender.
3. I was hired to work as tender
engineer on the Vanguard which is a dry
tender. Prior to being hired as tender
engineer I had no mechanical job
experience. In fact, other than working
on cars which I owned I had no practical
mechanical experience at all. Wor had I
had any practical experience with
diesels. Similarly, prior to being hired
as a tender engineer I had no classes in
mechanics, machine repair, diesel repair
or diesel maintenance. I had done some
pleasure boating. However, I did not have
prior marine work experie - Nor had I
had any prior navigation experience.
e**
{[p. 136]
THE COURT: Do you recall anyone in
authority at Columbia Wards Fisheries
A-61
asking you about your prior mechanical
experience, prior to the time you were
hired as a tender engineer?
THE WITNESS: No.
* *
A-62
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF RICHARD GURTIZA
[pp. 140-141)
RICHARD GURTIZA, being first sworn,
states:
l. I live at 156 N.W. 84th,
Seattle, WA 98117. I am of Filipino
descent. I worked at Wards Cove Packing
Company, Inc. at its Ketchikan cannery
Guring the 1977 season as a cannery
worker. . « «
2. I attended Central Washington
State University during the 1974-75
school year. In the fall of 1975 I
attended Yakima Valley College. My major
was political science. I then attended
Shoreline Community College in the fall
of 1978 plus the fall and winter of 1981.
In the fall of 1981 I began as an
engineering major.
A-63
3. Prior to working at Wards Cove
I had worked for about eleven months as a
messman, Oiler and wiper on an ocean-
going vessel for the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration ("NOAA"). The
vessel was 231 feet in length and was
called the SS Rainier. I started as a
messman whose job duties are like those of
a waiter. I was then promoted to wiper
which involves cleaning the engine room
and assisting the engineer. As a wiper I
wor ked Girectly undex a licensed
engineer. After that I sorked as an oiler
for about three months although my
seaman's papers were not changed to
reflect that. As an oiler I took readings
in the engine room and worked with the
engineers. I was also @irectly
responsible for maintaining the diesel
engines on the survey launches. ...
A-64
[pp. 142-143]
5. My job at Wards Cove in 1977 was
called “hook fish." It involved
unloading the salmon from the tenders
onto an elevator which carried it into the
fish house. I spent much of my time in
the holds of tenders pushing the fish onto
the elevators. Both because I spent so
much time on the tenders and because of my
past sea-going experience I began to ask
for a job on a tender. I asked the
cannery superintendent Joe Brindle for
one numerous times starting a quarter or a
third of the way into the season. I told
him about my marine experience and my
Coast Guard papers. I told him I was
interested in any job on a_ tender.
Throughout the season I also asked a
number of the tender captains for work on
a tender. One of the captains I asked was
the captain of the Dagney.
A-65
6. My job as hook fish enabled me
to see changes in personnel on the
tenders. There were at least two openings
after I started asking Joe Brindle for a
tender job. They were on tenders which
had started at another cannery and then
been transferred to Wards Cove. I think
the tenders were the Dagney and the
Northern Pride. Also, the skipper of the
Dagney told me there was an opening on his
tender before the opening was filled. The
inéividuals hire@ to fill these openings ;
were white. The one hired on the Dagney
was a big, burly white fellow who wore
John Lennon-type glasses. I wasn't hired
for either of these openings.
7. After the season was over Joe
Brindle let me work on a tender called the
Sable but just for the trip south to
Seattle. That only lasted for about seven
days and simply involved helping the
captain keep watch. I was the fifth
A-66
person on the crew going south. After we
arrived in Seattle I asked Jerry Steele
for a job on a tender for the next season.
He was the bookkeeper at Wards Cove. He
would not give me a commitment for the
job. Instead, he told me to talk to him
later. Had he given me a commitment then
I would have returned the next year.
However, I did not want to go back as a
cannery worker.
A-67
TESTIMONY OF DAVID DELLA
[pp. 158-159)
Q. Mr. Della, do you have your
affidavit before you?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Let me call your attention to
page 2. Initially, can you look at
line 7? You say Bunkhouse 1 were one
hundred per cent [sic] white. Did you
mean white or non-white?
A. Non-white.
**-e
ip. 160)
1. I live at 1909 South College,
Seattle, Washington 986154. I attended
the University of Washington during 1973-
76, but @id not graduate. ...
A-68
(pp. 161-162]
4. In 1974 we had two Filipino
forklift drivers on our crew. They lived
in Bunkhouse 1. There was a white
forklift driver named Tom Slayton who
worked at the cannery in the same year.
He did not live in either Bunkhouse 1 or
Bunkhouse 2. Instead, he lived in one of
the white bunkhouses. The one white who
stayed in our bunkhouse in 1974 did not
eat in our mess hall. Instead, he ate in
what we called the “white man's mess
hall.” At Wards Cove, there were a number
of white women cannery workers from the
Lower 48. They worked under the
Local 37, I.L.W.U. contract. They did
not live in our bunkhouse. Instead, they
lived in Building 3 on Exhibit 163 with
some members of other white male crews.
Moreover, while we lived in barracks-type
buildings, they had apartments. ...
A-69
|
[p. 168]
Q.
descent?
A.
Mr. Della, you are of Filipino
Yes, I am.
* *
A-70
*
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF ORLANDO BUCSIT
{[p. 171]
ORLANDO BUCSIT, being first sworn,
states:
l. I live at 8830 Midvale Avenue
North, Seattle, Washington 98103. I
worked for Wards Cove Packing Company,
Inc. aS a cannery worker at Red Salmon in
1967, 1969 and 1970. 1 also worked at
Wards Cove cannery in 1969 and 1978-1981.
I worked a double season in 1969, starting
at Red Salmon, then finishing at Wards
Cove. In 1968, I worked for Bumble Bee
Seafoods at its cannery in South Naknek.
I was a cannery worker each year I worked
in Alaska. I attended Yakima Valley
College in 1970 and 1974-1976. I served
as a boilerman in the Navy during 1971-
1974. My work entailed tending boilers on
aircraft carriers. These boilers
A-71
supplied power for the aircraft
carriers--primarily for airplane
catapults. I am of Filipino descent.
* * ®
{[p. 172]
2. In 1980 at Wards Cove, I
learned of a deckhand vacancy on one of
the tenders. I was employed as what is
called “hook fish." As such, I helped
unload the salmon from the tenders to the
dock. As soon as I heard about the
vacancy I asked the cannery
superintendent Joe Brindle if I could
Fill it. He said that I could not because
I was in Local 37, I.L.W.U. I asked him
before the position was filled. A
deckhand on a tender was being called home
because of a family emergency. I asked
Jee Brindle after I learned that the
Geckheand was leaving but before the
Geckheand actually left. The vacancy was
eventually filled by a white individual
A-72
from Ketchikan. In Alaska that year I
also asked Joe Brindle for a job at the
Lake Union terminals boatyard in Seattle.
He suggested that I talk to Alec Brindle
after the season was over.
* * *
{[p. 173)
6. There were two messhalls at
Wards Cove each year I was there. One,
called the "Filipino messhall,” was for
the male Local 37, I.L.W.U. crew. The
other, which we called the “white
messhall,” was for the remaining
employees at the cannery. No whites ate
in our messhall regularly. Once in 1978 I
tried to eat in the white messhall. I
left because some of the machinists gave
me a dirty look. Shortly after that the
cannery worker foreman told us in a crew
meeting that we were not to go to that
messhall since there had been complaints
that some of us tried to eat there. I
A-73
often walked by the white messhall. There
is usually a bowl of fruit out. ...
* *
[p. 174)
12. Similarly, at Red Salmon there
was both a “Filipino messhall" and a
"white messhall." Once in 1967 I tried to
take a mug-up in the white messhall but
‘the cook turned me away. He seid I wasn't
supposed to be there.
A-74
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF ANDY PASCUA
{[p. 195)
ANDY PASCUA, being first sworn,
states:
1. I live at 116 West "C" Street.
Wapato, Washington 98151. I worked for
Wards Cove Packing Company, Inc. during
the 1968-71 seasons as a cannery worker.
I worked at the Wards Cove cannery in
Ketchikan during the 1968-69 seasons. I
worked at the Red Salmon cannery in Naknek
Guring the 1969-1971 seasons. I worked a
doulbe season in 1969, starting at Red
Salmon, then moving to Wards Cove. I am
of Filipino descent. ...
. * *
(pp. 198-199]
7. In 1970 I asked the cannery
worker foreman at Red Salmon how to become
Ve
a mechanic or quality control person.
A-75
That year our foreman was’7 Arsenio
Eleccion. At first he reacted in an
apathetic way. He simply turned around
and walked away. When I pressed him, he
said that those jobs were not covered by
our union and that I should forget about
them. As I became more persistent he told
me not to make trouble, to finish my job
and then to go home at the end of the
season. At one point, he told me not to
make waves. He said that if I did, I was
going to get him into trouble. I also
wanted a job in the store. Eventually, I
would have liked to work in an
administrative job. I did not ask Arsenio
Eleccion about those jobs because of the
responses he gave to my other inquiries.
8. The reason I asked Arsenio
Eleccion rather than someone else is that
our crew had been directed to take up any
complaints we had with him. He was our
A-76
supervisor, and as such, assigned jobs,
overtime, bunkhouses and mess halls.
9. In 1971, I renewed my request
for a better job with Arsenio Eleccion.
By then, I had a year of college and was a
little more assertive. Arsenio Eleccion
was more forceful in 1971 in denying my
requests. In fact, I began to be afraid
that my persistence would jeopardize the
jobs of my other family members. At that
time, my father, my brother and my cousins
were cannery workers at Red Salmon.
10. One year I also asked the
machinist foreman at Red Salmon how to
obtain a machinist job. He told me that I
had to know someone. I did not pursue my
request with him because I did not have
that type of connections. During the time
I was at Red Salmon, I saw no job openings
posted, saw no advertisements for
openings in the better jobs and knew of no
application procedure other than to ask
my foreman.
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF MICHAEL TARDIF
MICHAEL TARDIF, being first sworn,
states:
[pp. 237-239]
l. I live at 108 E. 21st St.,
Olympia, WA 98501. I am an attorney
employed by the Washington State Attorney
Generel's Office. I was employed at Red
Salmon cannery as quality control during
the 1969-71 seasons. I started as quality
control when I was 19 years old between my
sophomore and junior years in college. I
am related to Ray Landry who was the
Cannery foreman at Wards Cove cannery
then. I am white.
2. Before I applied Ray Landry
told me the company was looking for
someone with enough basic intelligence to
be a good record keeper, to understand
what the quality control job entailed and
A-78
to do what was required in the position.
Prior to being hired in 1969 I did not
have any college lab science courses. My
only lab science courses had been in high
school. I have never had any food science
or nutrituion [sic] courses. All the
training I received for the quality
control position was on the job. I had a
week to acquaint myself with the job prior
to the canning season. I reviewed some
written material, talked with a gentleman
from the National Canners Association who
was at Red Salmon and talked with the
cannery foreman and first machinist about
the job. For the first few days of
canning I also worked fairly closely with
a machinist until I fully understood what
I was supposed to do. I learned all the
basic duties of the qality control
position on the job at Red Salmon.
xk ek
A-79
[p. 240]
6. In 1969 I lived in what is
marked Building 9 on Exhibit 162. All the
occupants of the bunkhouse were white. We
were from various crews. For example,
there were carpenters and machinists as
well as myself. There was a dresser,
table, chair, light and shelves in my
room. We lived two per room. In 1970-71
I lived in what is marked Building 11 on
Exhibit 162. Again, all the occupants
were white. Again, we were from various
crews. For example, there were [sic]
beachmen and fishermen as well as myself.
(The fishermen stayed there only when no
fishing was permitted.) I had a table and
shelves in my room. There were also
benches in the hall. We lived four per
room. However, when they were fishing,
the fishermen didn't stay there, so there
were often fewer people in the rooms. In
both punkhouses we had single metal-frame
A-80
beds rather than bunk beds. Also, in both
bunkhouses we had a bull cook who changed
our sheets and made our beds. Like
Building 9, Building 11 was all white the
years I stayed there. I also had a chance
to visit Building 10. It was similar in
layout, furniture and people per room to
Building 9 except for the cannery
foreman's quarters. He either had an
extra large room or two rooms. He also
had a private bath. Building 10, like
Buildings 9 and 11, was also one of the
"white" bunkhouses.
7. On several occasions I had a
chance to go into what was commonly called
the "Filipino bunkhouse.” It is
Building 13 on Exhibit 162. It was a
different type of building from the one I
lived in in 1969. It was a large
barracks-style building with a long hall
while the building I stayed in the first
year was more like a house than barracks.
A-81
Also, it was more crowded than either of
the buildings I stayed in. In fact,
people were housed 4-8 per room there even
though the rooms were of equal size or
smaller than the ones in Building 11
where I lived in 1970-71. There were few
if any tables, chairs, or dressers in the
sleeping rooms in the "Filipino
bunkhouse.” In fact, the rooms were so
crowded there was little room. for
furniture other than the bunk beds.
Unlike the buildings where I lived the
"Filipino bunkhouse” had bunk beds rather
than regular single beds. The "Filipino
bunkhouse” appeared to be about the same
age as the buildings in which I lived.
However, in my view the facts that it was
more crowded and had less furniture made
it less desirable.
A-82
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF GARY MAMALLO
GARY MAMALLO, being first sworn,
states:
[p. 256]
Re I live at 2505 - 18th Avenue,
Seattle, Washington. I am an apprentice
carpenter. I graduated from high school
in 1973, attended North Seattle Community
College for two quarters and went to the
University of Washington for a year and
one-half. I worked for Wards Cove Packing
Company, Inc. at its Ketchikan cannery
during the 1973 season... -
xk
[p. 258]
9. There were two mess halls at
Wards Cove. One, which was called the
"Filipino mess hall,” was used to feed the
male cannery workers who lived in the
Lower 48 during the winter, all of whom
A-83
were non-white. The other mess hall was
used to feed the white crews. The women
cannery workers from the Lower 48, all of
whom were white, were also fed in that
mess hall. In evenings, separate mug-ups
were served in the two mess halls. On one
occasion, I saw what was being served for
mug-tp in the mess hall where the whites
ate. It included a variety of meats, a
variety of breads, a variety of fruit, and
some cookies for dessert. In contrast,
the mug-up in our mess hall consisted of
one type of sandwich meat, such as
bologna. We did not have nearly the
variety the whites did in their mess hall.
x* *
A-84
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF MIKE EDDIE ANTONIO
[p. 267]
MIKE EDDIE ANTONIO, being first
sworn, states:
Le I live at 3402 Jefferson,
Yakima, Washington 98902. I am employed
as a letter carrier for the U.S. Postal
Servigde. «© « «
[p. 268]
3. In 1966 or 1967, I asked Vern
Jones how to get on the beach gang. I
considered this an application. He was
the beach boss at Red Salmon during the
years I was there. He did not offer me
the job. Nor did he give me any
information about how I could go about
getting that job. The last year I worked
at Red Salmon I asked Vern Jones the same
question again. He did not offer me a job
A-85
this time either. Nor did he tell me what
else I could do to obtain the job.
x* *
[p. 268]
5. In 1966 and 1967 at Red Salmon,
I asked the first machinist how I could go
about getting a machinist job. He would
not give me any information.
x* *
A-86
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF WILLIAM T. PASCUA
{[p. 281]
WILLIAM T. PASCUA, being first
sworn, states:
l. I live at 2220 West Logan,
Duplex C, Yakima, Washington 98902. I am
employed as film director at KIMA
television in Yakima. I take care of
public service announcements as well as
editing, scheduling, and tracing
programs. I am an assistant to the
program director. I am of Filipino
descent. I worked for Wards Cove Packing
Company, Inc. at Red Salmon during the
1970-1972 seasons. In 1970-1971, I was
employed as a slimer. .. .
x* * *
[p. 282]
4. There appeared to be definite
racial barriers at Red Salmon. For
A-87
example, employees were housed almost
entirely along racial lines. There were
two bunkhouses for the male Local 37,
I.L.W.U. workers. One, which housed the
older men on the crew, was 98% non-white
each season I was there. The other was
100% non-white during the three seasons.
Only two whites lived there during the
third season. Nearly all of the non-
whites in these bunkhouses were of
Filipino descent. Although they also
held cannery worker jobs, male Eskimos
were housed in two other bunkhouses.
White women cannery workers had _ yet
another bunkhouse. ...
[p. 283]
7. There were two mess halls at
Red Salmon during the years I was there.
One, which was called the "Filipino mess
hall," fed our crew. One year I was at
Red Salmon, the Eskimo cannery workers
A-88
i
$
|
also ate in our mess hall. We called the
other mess hall at the cannery the "white
mess hall.” it fed the white crews, and,
for two of the years I was there, the
Eskimo cannery workers. However, the
Eskimo cannery workers did not eat in the
same dining room as the white crews.
Instead, they were given a small room off
to the side of the main dining hall.
xk
A-89
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF SHIRLEY JEANNE SMITH
[pp. 321-322]
Q. Would you please describe your
work experience as a demographer?
A. I have had several jobs as a
demographer, the first of which was for
the Census Bureau between 1969 and 1972,
the second of which was for the Bureau of
Social Science Research here in
Washington in 1975-'76. And since that
time, I have been working for the Bureau
of Labor Statistics also here in
Washington.
[p. 324]
Q. Is there a definition of labor
supply which is standard in your field?
A. Yes, there is.
Q. What is the definition please?
A-90
A. Labor supply as we use the term
is synonymous with labor force--that is,
the employed population plus persons who
are looking for jobs and are, therefore,
unemployed.
Q. Is there a standard definition
of the term “labor force" in your field?
A. It is the same.
Q. Same as labor supply?
A. Yes.
Q. Is there a standard definition
of work force in your field?
A. Yes. Work force is synonymous
with the employed portion of the labor
force, excluding unemployed.
* * *
[pp. 327-328]
Q. Have you compared the
seasonality of the Alaskan salmon canning
industry with the seasonality of any
other industries?
A-91
A. Yes, I have. It is perhaps
unique, the degree to which it is
seasonaly [sic]. Most other industries
have some element taht [sic] carries
through during the rest of the year. For
instance, in agriculture, there are
people who--farms don't shut down during
the rest of the year; they may go into
other types of activities besides field
production, but the seasonality of the
salmon canning industry is quite
overwhelming because almost the entire
labor or the work force is involved for
two to three months in the summer and
completely outside the industry for the
rest of the year.
Q. How large is the migrant
component of the work force of the Alaskan
salmon canning industry compared to the
migrant component of the work forces of
other industries?
A-92
A. It is startlingly large. From
records that I have seen, over 60 percent
of the workers in the salmon canning
industry are migrant. We know that at
least 60 percent of them migrate to Alaska
each summer from the Lower 48, and a large
number of people who are Alaskans working
in the canneries also migrate, but I don't
have statistics on that.
x**
[pp. 329-330]
Q. In studying the labor supply
which defendants tap, did you do any
background reasearch [sic] on the
demographic characteristics of migrant
seasonal labor supplies?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. What, if anything, did you
conclude about the demographic
characteristics of such labor supplies as
compared with non-migrant labor supplies?
A-93
A. The groups of people who are
responsive to migrant labor work from the
limited amount of data which is available
on the subject appear to be atypical of
population as a whole. They--well, it
stands to reason that people who are free
to pick up and leave one place and go work
somewhere else weren't heavily tied to
the original location or in a particular
job.
And the indications are that
this group’ that is responsive to
migratory and seasonal work is
disproportionately made up of minority
groups who don't have equal opportunities
in the economic system at home.
* *
[p. 322]
Q. (By Mr. Arditi) In general, is
the racial composition of migrant
seasonal labor supplies representative of
A-94
the racial composition of the areas from
which they are drawn?
A. No.
Q. And in what way are they not
representative?
[p. 333]
A. For the most part, because
migrant and seasonal work draws on labor
supply that is available sporadically,
they tend to be people who didn't make it
into the economic system in the first
place at home. That is, people who are
unemployed or outside the labor force,
waiting for opportunities to develop.
And those groups are both
disproportionately made up of minorities
so the migrant seasonal flow tends to be
disproportionately made up of minorities.
* *
A-95
[pp. 343-345]
Q. Now, could you tell us what, if
any, trends Exhibit 63 shows?
A. Exhibit 63 shows a gradual
Gecline in the non-whtie portion of the
industry. Actually, it wasn't gradual;
it occurred in a few sort of steps over
the period from 1906 to the mid-fifties.
The industry began as a predominantly
non-white labor supply--75 percent, as a
matter of fact, of the workers at the
beginning of this series were non-white.
But the salmon butchering machine came
into use, I think, in 1903 or something
like that or it was invented in 1903. So
it predated the series- and as it came
into use, commonly it displaced a lot of
hand butchering. And the share of the
labor supply that was non-white
Giminished. It dropped into the fifties
by around 1920 and remained between 50 and
60 percent for several years thereafter
A-96
and finally dropped a second time about
1935 when unions came into effect,
dropped down to around 50 percent.
And after World War II, it
deopped [sic] between 50 and 45 percent
and sort of hovered there for the rest of
the series.
Q. Did it stabilize at a certain
point?
A. Well, it more or less
stabilized with the mid-thirties. The
decline between, say--I don't know--1938
or something like that and 1955 was not
dramatic. 1937. From there on, it ws
pretty much in the 50 to 45 range.
Q. Did the percent non-white vary
during the first half of the depression
according to Exhibit 63?
A. In the first half of the
depression, the--well, the depression
began in 1929, and in the years prior to
A-97
that, from 1925 to '28, the proportion
non-white was around 57, 59 percent.
Well, 56 or 57 percent. And the
same figures were reported through about
1934. So there really wasn't = any
noticeable change in proportion non-white
in that period.
Q. What, if anything, does that
tell you as a demographer?
A. Well, it suggests that even in
a time of job shortage that whites were
not rushing into this industry and trying
to grab up jobs.
Q. Was there a slight shift in the
second half of the depression?
A. There was. As I said, it seemed
to be it started about 1935 when the
canning industry had its first unions.
And at that point, the share whites
actually increased.
x* eek
A-98
[p. 346]
Q. What, if anything, does Exhibit
4 tell you about the entrance of cannery
worker unions on the scene as that might
or might not affect the racial
composition of the industry labor supply?
A. Exhibit 64?
Q. Yes.
A. Well, the cannery workers’
unions evolved around 1935 as I said
before. And the pattern of employment
that I have been talking about had been
going on for a long time before that. The
Chinese were already being eased out, and
the Filipinos had already established a
fairly strong position in the industry by
the time the unions we re first
established.
And in fact, the number of
Filipinos in the industry was higher a few
years before than it was right at the time
and following the institution of unions.
A-99
[pp. 369-370]
Q. Now, did you come to a
conclusion in this case on the percent
non-whtie [sic] in the labor supply as
opposed to the work force that defendants
tap for their Alaskan canneries?
A. I did, yes.
Q. And what was your conclusion?
A. My conclusion was that that
labor supply was about 50 percent non-
white.
[pp. 386-388]
Q. In your study in this case,
have you adjusted the availability labor
supply for differences in skills?
A. No, I haven't.
Q. So far as you know, is it
possible to do so?
A. I don't think for this industry
that it is possible.
A-100
Q. And why is that?
A. Well, the types of statistics
that we have to look at the industry are
not complete. We have information from
the industry, from the work force itself,
which I have used which clearly
identifies these people as available.
They have come and spent their summers in
the industry so we know they = are
available. But the detail in that
information about qualifications and
skills is lacking.
Then, there is the data source
that the defendants have used which is the
census. That identifies what people do
for a living or have done most recently
for a living, but doesn't tell us anything
about people's availability. And in
order to really focus on availability by
occupation or any sk-lled [sic] group or
anything, you have to be able to identify
occupation and race and availability, all
A-101
the same individual at the same time. And
you have to have sufficient information
about the occupation and work history and
what not to know that it really is their
qualification and not just something they
happen to be doing.
Q. Well, his prior occupation then
in your view is a good proxy for skill or
not?
A. Not if it is just single prior
occupation. The last thing you were
doing. Because there certainly are a lot
of people who temporarily work in jobs
that are completely unrelated to their
skill level.
Washington has a wonderful crew
of cab drivers with Ph.D.'s in physics and
things like that. So capturing what a
person is doing at a particular moment
isn't necessarily a good indicator of
what they can do.
A-102
:
*
|
-
e
4
:
4
$.
ORR A RE ALLIEN ITY.
[pp. 405-406]
BY MR. DUNCAN:
Q. I don't think it did. You have
previously testified in other cases to a
fairly blanket assertion that seasonal
industries are more likely to be non-
white than white in comparison areas from
which they are drawn.
x *&
Q. Have you previously testified
to that?
A. Yes, and I think that's what I
meant by what I just said as well.
Maybe I can clarify what the
problem is. We have been talking about
the general labor force in a_e fixed
location over a year-round pattern. And
we have, I think you have, some extremes.
You have the migrant workers who are
generally both seasonal and willing to
pick up and leave their location. And you
A-103
have people who are neither seasonal nor
willing to leave their location.
Migrants are quite atypical of
the group that they come from or they are
likely to be quite atypical of the group
they come from. Seasonal workers are
somewhere in between. They include
people who for the same reason as migrants
just happen to available. They are not
doing anything else. Their economic
Opportunities have not been great, and
this is their one chance to get their foot
in the work force for the year.
SO a seasonal work force is
more non-white than the total labor
force, but it is less non-white than a
migratory group because it includes a lot
of people who can continue to live their
ordinary lives in their home community
and just take on a little additional work.
x* *& &
A-104
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF H. J. PARRISH
[p. 622]
Q. Mr. Parrish, would you please
state your full name for the record and
spell your last name?
A. P-A-R-R-I-S-H, H. J.
Q. What is your first name?
A. Horace.
[pp. 622-624]
Q. Who was your last employer?
A. Wards Cove Packing Company,
Incorporated.
Q. What? What did you say after
A. Incorporated.
Q. From responses to questions
that we received in this case, they list
you as Assitant Cannery Superintendent at
A-105
Red Salmon Cannery. Was that your job
title?
A. No.
Q. What was your job title?
A. We had no title.
Q. Was your job a year around job?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you work at any other
cannery besides Red Salmon?
A. No.
Q. Did you have any duties with
Columbia Wards Fishery?
A. I had no definite duties.
Q. Did you perform tasks’ for
Columbia Wards? |
A. Yes.
Q. What did you do for Columbia
Wards?
A. I would work for various
superintendents fo [sic] the plant and
personnel at Red Salmon, and for
Mr. Brindle.
A-106
Q. What did you do for. the
superintendents fo [sic] the Columbia
Wards Fisheries Canneries? Did you help
them in hiring?
A. No.
Q. Did you help them in
bookkeeping?
A. No.
Q. What exactly did you do?
A. I would help them on
transportation, and if there was nobody
in the office, we would do purchasing for
them.
Q. If ther [sic] was no one in
which office?
A. In our main office in Seattle.
Q. Aside f rom helping with
transporation [sic] and purchasing, did
you do anything for the superintendents
of the Columbia Wards Fishery Canneries?
A. If they were up north and were
looking for help, I would try to help them
A-107
obtain anybody that they might want to
contact or replace.
Q. When you say “help,” you mean
employees?
A. Yes.
Q. So you helped in hiring, then?
A. I had nothing to do with hiring
the employee. |
Q. You helped in recruiting
employees?
A. Yes.
[p. 625]
Q. Were your duties for Columbia
Wards Fisheries more or less incidental?
* * &
[p. 627]
Q. Could you tell me which job
department you had _ recruitin- [sic]
dutues [sic] for at the Red Salmon
Cannery?
A-108
A. For all of the personnel, for
all of the departments, mainly fishermen,
cannery workers, some AFU members.
Q. Did you do the beach gang?
A. I did not hire them, but I would
help recruit them, if I could.
Q. Tender?
A. The same.
Q. AFU culinary?
A. Yes.
Q. Machinists?
A. The same; yes.
Q. Quality control?
A. No.
[p. 628]
Q. And the people who worked in
that were employees of Wards Cove Packing
Company?
A. Yes. I would recruit them and
line them up.
A-109
MR. LONG: I'm sorry. Did you
say lined up storekeepers for the Naknek
Trading Company?
THE WITNESS: Yes.
* *&
[p. 628]
Q. Who was responsible for the
actual hiring at Red Salmon Cannery? Was
that Mr. Brindle?
A. I would do some of the hiring;
he would do some of the hiring; and the
beach gang boss would do some of the
hiring.
[p. 636]
Q. Did you look for any personal
qualities in individuals you had a role in
hiring?
A. Yes, we tried to get people
that were capable, that knew--they had to
know the machinery, for instance, for the
machinists. Carpenters had to--be real
A-110
carpenters. Tender men [sic] had to have
knowledge.
{[p. 637]
Q. (By Mr. Arditi)
no set qualifications a
meet?
A. No.
Q. Pardon?
A. No.
A-111
But there were
person had to
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF JILL HENDERSON
[p. 695]
JILL HENDERSON, being first sworn,
states:
{[p. 697]
7. There were two messhals [sic]
at Red Salmon. The Filipino cannery
workers ate in one, It was commonly
called the "Filipino messhall." (The
Filipinos were also housed in what was
commonly called the "Filipino
bunkhouse.") Other employees--including
me--ate in the other messhall. Both the
Filipino cannery workers’ and white
Cannery workers like myself were Local
37, I.L.W.U. members. However, the
Filipinos ate in one messhall. We were
assigned the other one. I do not recall
any non-whites eating in our messhall
A-112
except some Japanese nationals. They
were not employees of Wards Cove Packing
Company, Inc. Instead, they were
employees of a company in Japan which
bought the salmon eggs. They were there
to make sure the eggs were processed
correctly. Tables were assigned in our
messhall. ...
A-113
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF PATRICK TIMOTHY RYAN
[pp. 705-708]
PATRICK TIMOTHY RYAN, being first
Sworn, states:
l. - « « I am a white male. I am
related to Winn Brindle who is cannery
superintendent at Alitak.
2. - « « In 1976 at age 18 I
worked for Columbia Wards Fisheries as a
machinist trainee. In 1977 at age 19 I
worked there as seamer machinist, in 1978
at age 20 as salmon butchering machinist
and 1979 at age 21 as first machinist.
3. Prior to being hired in 1976 I
had no mechanical work experience in a
paying job. I had been employed in a gas
station to sell gas, maintain shelves and
stock grocieries. My duties at the gas
station did not include mechanical work.
I had worked on my own car as well as
A-114
other people's cars. This was for
pleasure rather than compensation. It
consisted of tune-us, carburetor rebuilds
and valve jobs. The only shop class I had
taken ws a one-year high school course
which included wood as well as metal shop.
I attended a general rather than a
vocational high school. The course
included instruction in woodworking,
using wood lathes, welding, tool
grinding, forging, using metal lathes and
small engine repair and rebuilding. The
small engines we dealt with in the course
were lawn mower engines. This shop course
was the only classroom training I had
received in a mechanical field.
4. I consider machinist trainee an
entry level job. Most of my work in the
1976 season involved working with the
salmon butchering machines. The regular
salmon butchering machinist was called
away to replace two or three boat booms
A-115
which had broken. For about three weeks
during the season I was basically doing
his job. During that time I was
essentially running the fish house. I
learned about the salmon. butchering
machinery during the pre-season when I
helped the machinists set up some of the
cannery machinery. I continued to learn
about the salmon butchering machinist's
job throughout the 1976 season. While I
was a trainee in 1976 I also did some
pipefitting and welding. I had not done
pipefitting professionally before this.
The only pipefitting I had done was part
of the carpentry work I did which is
described in paragraph 13 below. The only
welding I had done before this was in my
high school shop class. During the pre-
season and post-season in 1976 I helped
the machinists put together and tear down
salmon butchering machines, seamers,
fillers and weighing machines. Finally,
A-116
I also did some parts fabrication in the
machine shop at Alitak. The only such
work I had done before this was in my high
school shop class.
5. In 1977 I became the seamer
machinist at Alitak. I had been occupied
with the salmon butchering machinery
during the 1976 season. Essentially, I
learned about seamers during the 1976
pre-season. During the 1976 post-season
I also helped dismantle the seamers and
put preservative on them. After I started
work as the seamer machinist I received
some on-the-job training on the seamers.
For example, during the 1977 pre-season
the first machinist showed me how to
rebuild seamer heads, tear down the seams
on cans and report on the quality of the
seams. I had not done any of these tasks
before then. Also, during the 1977 pre-
season the first machinist plus a
representative of American Can Company
A-117
1 on metals were helpful though not
showed me how to make adjustments on the
essential to my work as a machinist.
seamers. American Can Company is the
* *«*
manufacturer of the seamers at Alitak.
[pp. 708-709]
8. I was not employed between the
6. Between the 1976 and 1977
seasons I worked about 16 hours per week
1977 and 1978 seasons. Nor did I do any
while I was in college at the Lake Union
mechanical work except for repairs on my
Terminals boatyard. My work consisted of 8
own car. This consisted of rebuilding a
outfitting three fishing boats. It did
replacing the engine and transmission.
not consist of any engine or machinery
9. In 1978 I became the salmon
repairs that I can recall. It did include
butchering machinist at Alitak. I
some welding and pipefitting but not on
learned the job while I worked as a
Cannery machinery. Between the 1976 and
machinist trainee in 1976. In fact,
1977 seasons I also took a course in
during the 1976 season I learned both the
commercial welding at Seattle Central
seamer machinist and salmon butchering
Community College. It lasted one
machinist jobs. I could go to the cannery
quarter, two nights a week, three hours a
foreman or first machinist for
night. I was not nor have I ever been
consultation since they had substantially
certified as a welder. By the fall of
more general mechanical experience than
1976 I had started college. My studies in
Structural engineering did not include
: 10. Between the 1978 and 1979
any hands-on mechanical courses.
seasons I worked 16 hours a week at Lake
However, some of the theory courses I took
A-119
A-118
Union Terminals again. I was still in
college during this period. I also worked
full time during a two and one-half week
break in school in March, 1979. I worked
on the rebuild of two filler and cutter
units for Alitak there. I worked under
the supervision of Elroy Kowalski who
told me what to do. When I was in school
he would do the work on the filler and
cutter units by himself.
* *«
[p. 758]
Q. Now, if I understand your
testimony correctly, you felt that you
were qualified to be a seamer machinist
after the two or three weeks that you
spent in the 1976 preseason plus the 1977
preseason, plus the first few weeks of the
1977 season, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. However, at the time that you
were hired as the seamer machinist, and
A-120
that you held that job, the only
experience that you had was the two or
three weeks in the 1976 preseason, is that
correct?
A. Yes.
* *«
[pp. 758-759]
Q. (By Mr. Arditi) Is it fair to
say, then, that while you held the job as
a seamer machinist, you were learning?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, do you have exhibit 640 in
front of you?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. You mentioned a number of
critical duties for the seamer machinist.
Did you learn any of those critical duties
during the 1977 season?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. So prior to the time that you
were hired in that job in 1977, you were
not able to do all of the things that you
A-121
have identified as critical duties, is
that correct?
A. Yes.
A-122
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF JOEL STROMME
[p. 778-779)
JOEL STROMME, being first sworn,
states:
l. I am a 33 year old white male
and currently reside at 5687 Doren Road,
Acme, WA 98220.
2. I worked for Columbia Wards
Fisheries at its Ekuk cannery during the
1970 season as a tallyman and deckhand;
during the 1971 season as a deckhand; and
during the 1972 season as a tender
engineer.
3. Before working for Columbia
Wards Fisheries I had worked as a laborer
and a logger.
4. Prior to 1972 my 0»boating
experience was limited to my past work at
Ekuk as a deckhand and to pleasure boating
on lakes.
A-123
5. My practical mechanical
experience was limited to work on my own
car, which is pretty good.
6. During the winter of 1971-72 1
took refrigeration and diesel mechanic
courses at Bellingham Tech.
7. However, neither was helpful.
I could have done tender engineer's work
without them just with my auto
experience. The tender I worked on in
1972 did not have refrigeration
equipment.
8. My work during 1972 required
only minor repairs such as replacing
injectors and hose fitting for engine
coolers. The major repair work was done
by the port engineers.
9. Anyone who had a lot of
experience working on his car could have
Gone the work.
A-124
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF ALBERT BELASARIO
PASTORES, JR.
[p. 831]
Albert Belasario Pastores, JEeg
being first sworn, states:
1. I am a Filipino male residing
at 3705 South 205th # Place, Kent,
Washington. .. .-
2. . « « In 1971 I was sent to
Bumble Bee by Local 37, I.L.W.U., again as
a slimer. ...
{[p. 832]
4. I asked Rudy Rodriquez, the
cannery foreman, why there were no
Filipino machinists, because I did not
want to be a slimer in 1971 because the
previous year I did not like the work. I
asked him how to get another job. Rudy
told me that Filipinos were not supposed
A-125
to have the other jobs. I did not ask
anybody else about job possiblities
because I had been instructed when I got
there that if I had any questions, I was
to direct them to Rudy exclusively. I
considered Rudy to be a part of
management, and I was not aware of any
place at the cannery where I could apply
for another job. He said that if I made
waves about it, that would probably cause
a lot of problems, and that discouraged me
from making any further inquiries. I was
not aware of any openings for machinists
jobs posted at the cannery or any
advertisements.
A-126
J
3
Ta ty RE tvs
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF EUGENE BACLIG
[pp. 869-870)
EUGENE BACLIG, being first duly
sworn, states:
l. My address is Route 4, Box
4352, Wapato, Washington 98951. I am of
Filipino descent... . I worked for
Wards Cove Packing Company, Inc. at Red
Salmon during the 1969-72 seasons. I also
worked for Wards Cove Packing Company,
Inc. at Wards Cove Cannery during the 1973
season.
[pp. 870-871]
3. When we arrived at Red Salmon,
Mr. Eleccion told us which bunkhouses we
would be staying in. They are marked
Buildings 12 and 13 on Exhibit 162. I
stayed in Building 13. Buildings 12 and
13 were commonly called the “Filipino
A-127
bunkhouse." Seven of us iived in a single
room each of my four seasons at Red
Salmon. It was about fifteen feet by
fifteen feet with three double bunkbeds
plus a single bed. The only furniture in
the room was one small homemade table.
There were no bathroom facilities in the
bunkhouse. Instead, we had to use a shed
near the bunkhouse. The bunkhouse was old
in appearance, with peeling paint. The
company did not provide someone to fix the
beds or clean the bunkhouse.
4. The Alaska Native Cannery
workers were housed separately. They
lived in Building 15. Sometimes, they
also lived in Building 14. There were yet
other bunkhouses for the white crews.
5. - « « There were two messhalls
at Red Salmon.
6. One, which was called the
"Filipino messhall," was used to feed our
crew. Mr. Eleccion assigned our crew
A-128
this messhall. One or two years there
were two or three whites who lived in our
bunkhouse. They usually ate breakfast
plus one or two meals in our
messhall. .. -
7. The other messhall, which we
called the “white messhall” fed the other
crews besides ours. The Alaska Native
cannery workers ate there. However, they
did not eat in the same room as the white
crews. Instead, they had a small dining
room off to the side of the messhall.
Unlike our messhall, the white messhall
had an automatic dishwasher. The
Japanese egg technicians also ate in the
white messhall at a table in the back.
They were not employees of the company.
8. At Wards Cove, just as at Red
Salmon, housing was assigned essentially
along racial lines. There were two
bunkhouses for the Filipino crew. The
white crews lived apart from us in other
A-129
bunkhouses. There were white women
cannery workers from the Lower 48 at Wards
Cove. They did not stay in the same
bunkhouse as us. Instead, they stayed in
what is marked Building 3 on Exhibit 163.
Members of the white crews lived in the
same building. There were also Japanese
national egg technicians at Wards Cove.
Again, they were not company employees,
but employees of the purchaser of the
salmon eggs. They also stayed in
Building 3.
A-130
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF CHRISTOPHER STEELE
[p. 910)
CHRISTOPHER STEELE, called as a
witness on behalf of the plaintiffs
herein, being first duly sworn, testified
as follows:
[pp. 910-911]
Q. First of all, Mr. Steel, can
you turn to page two of the affidavit you
have in front of you?
Is that your signature on line 27?
A. Right.
Q. Now, are the statements in this
affidavit true?
A. Right.
Q. You made a correction at lines
6 and 7 which you penciled in. You
crossed out "no prior navigation
A-131
experience and no prior boating work
experience.
Can you tell me why you crossed those
out?
A. I remember making that trip
South with Doni Brindle in '67, and I went
on several of my days off following the
fishing ground rules with him.
Q. About how many days off did you
go out on?
A. Oh, five or six, sir.
Q. How long is the trip South?
A. Four days.
Q. Is Doni Brindle a friend of
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Is he a relative of Joe
Brindle?
A. Yes.
Q. And how long have known Doni
Brindle? [sic]
A. Ah, fifteen years, or so.
A-132
Q. The navigation experience,
then, would that consist of standing
wheel watch at times?
A. Right.
Q. Now, at lines 24 through 25,
you also crossed that out. Can you tell
me why you crossed that out?
A. Well, the refrigeration--the
Vanguard doesn't have any. That was after
I was engi: :er on it.
Q. Okay. In other words you took
the refrigeration course after you became
engineer?
A. Right.
[pp. 913-914]
CHRISTOPHER STEELE, being first
sworn, states:
l. I am a white male residing at
10926 - 127th Place N.E., Kirkland, WA
98033. I worked for Wards Cove Packing
Company at its Wards Cove cannery during
A-133
1966-71 and 1972-present. I was in the
service between the 1971 and 1972
seasons. My father was Gerald Steele who
was bookkeeper at the cannery when I
started. He later became the cannery
superintendent there.
2. My first job at the cannery was
machinist helper. I was 16 years old at
the time. I had not had any prior
mechanical work experience. However, I
had done some work on my own car. Prior
to becoming a machinist helper the only
mechanical course I had taken was a high
school metal shop course. I had also
taken a high school wood shop course. I
worked as a machinist helper at Wards Cove
for three seasons.
3. In 1969 I became engineer on
the Vanguard which is a Wards Cove Packing
Company tender. The Vanguard is a dry
tender which means that it does not have
facilities for refrigerating salmon.
A-134
Prior to becoming engineer on the
Vanguard I had no prior experience
working on diesel engines, no _ prior
navigation experience and no prior
boating work experience. In about 1970 I
[sic] one-semester courses at Trident in
refrigeration, diesels and navigation. I
do not recall the precise year I took
these courses. However, I do recall that
it was after my first year as engineer on
the Vanguard. The navigation course was a
night school course. Before starting
work as an engineer on the Vanguard my
only mechanical work experience had been
around the cannery but not on boats.
4. After I left the service I
became a deckhand on the Whale for the
1972 seasons. Then in 1973 I became the
skipper of the Vanguard. Prior to 1973 my
only boating work experience was my prior
jobs at Wards Cove which I have listed
above. I do not recall exactly but I may
A-135
have taken a brush-up night school course
in navigation after the one I took in
about 1970. I have also taken a
navigation course at the YMCA. However, I
took that course after I had already been
working as a skipper on the Vanguard.
* *
A-136
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF PHILLIP FUJII
[p. 925]
PHILLIP FUJII, being first duly
sworn, states:
l. I am a Japanese male residing
at 202 West Olympic Place, Seattle,
Washington 98119. I graduated from
Franklin High School in Seattle in 1971.
I received a B.A. in Urban Planning from
the University of Washington in 1975. I
have completed the course work for a
certificate in urban design during two
years of graduate school. From 1976
through 1978, I worked for the Renton
Planning Department. Then I worked for
Don Miles Associates, an architectural
firm in Seattle during 1978. Since then I
have worked for the City of Seattle,
Department of Community Develpment.
A-137
[pp. 926-927)
5. Prior to cannery work from late
1969 to 1971 I worked at Mount Baker
Cleaners. My jobs at the cleaners
included mainly cleanup and maintenance
of the machines and equipment, including
the pressers, the washers, dryers and
some of the steam pipes. I oiled,
cleaned, and changed lint baskets on the
pressers. I changed gaskets on the
washers and removed “muck,” sediment that
gathered in the bottom, from the washers.
I also added solvent and read meters on
the washers. I cleaned lint baskets and
removed foreign objects from the dryers.
I opened and closed the valves of the
steam pipes and sometimes performed
makeshift repairs. All of the training
for this job was on-the-job training and
my work was checked by two supervisors and
the owners of the dry cleaners.
A-138
[p- 930)
Q. The foreign object that you
removed from the dryer, wasn't that
simply reaching in the dryer and pulling
out buttons that had fallen off the
shirts?
A. Yes, and changing the _ wind
basket periodically.
Q. Now, the makeshift repairs you
refer to in line 6 to the steam pipes,
that was really just grabbin [sic] a piece
of cloth around leak to keep it from
leaking any further?
A. And also turning off the
valves, opening and closing valves; if
there was a major leak we would see that
and then we would turn off the steam valve
and we would makeshift repair.
Q. But the repair work you did was
simply rapping [sic] it with a cloth?
A. Yes.
A-139
Qc. It was the owners or your
supervisor who actually fixed the pipes
that leaked?
A. That is “correct or they
subcontracted it out.
x* ek
A-140
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF CATHLYN HJORTEN
[p. 939]
CATHLYN HJORTEN, being first sworn,
states:
1. - « « I worked for Bumble Bee
Seafoods as a waitress in 1970-71 and as a
cannery worker in 1980. I am presently
employed as a dental hygenist. I am
white.
x &
[p. 940)
4. There were to messhalls at
Bumble Bee, namely: the one I worked and
ate in; and, what was generally called
"the Filipino messhall" around’ the
cannery. When the fishermen were there,
about 300 people--almost all of whom were
white--ate in our messhall. Several non-
white employees also ate there each year.
However, the largest number who did was
A-141
about ten in 1980. Several Japanese
national egg technicians ate in our
messhall each year as well. In 1980 there
were 20 or more white male cannery
workers. They ate in our wmesshall.
Similarly, the women cannery workers,
most of whom were white, ate in our
messhall. So did two black male cannery
workers. Some of the white cannery
workers who ate in our meshall were from
the Lower 48. In contrast, each year the
people who ate in the "Filipino messhall"
were almost all non-white. I knew that
because I could see them lined up outside
the messhall waiting to go in just before
meal times. The non-white who ate there
included the male Filipino cannery
workers from the Lower 48 plus the male
Alaska Natives whose jobs I can't recall.
It was understood at the cannery where one
was to eat.
A-142
[p. 941]
7. I was assigned a bunkhouse each
year I was at Bumble Bee. For example, in
1980 whoever drove us in from the airport
dropped us at the bunkhouse we would be
staying in. It was one of two women's
cannery worker bunkhouses in 1980. It is
marked Building J on Exhibit 162. The
Filipino cannery workers stayed in one
bunkhouse. The 20 or more white male
cannery workers stayed in another
bunkhouse. I do not know where the one or
two. Black male cannery workers were
housed although I often saw them hanging
around the building where the white male
cannery workers were housed.
x* *
A-143
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF RODERICK E. CAMERON, JR.
[pp. 994]
RODERICK E. CAMERON, JR., called as
a witness on behalf of the plaintiff,
being first duly sworn, testified herein:
z* *«
[pp. 994-995]
Q. I would like to trace your job
history a bit, if I may. Prior to the
time that you started working as a
warehouseman, you worked for the Seattle
School District?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. And did your job consist of
cleaning buildings at night?
A. Yes.
Q. And did you also operate the
boilers?
A. Yes, I have a license.
A-144
Q. And is that essentially it as
far as your job duties went with the
school district?
A. I operated them and then in the
summer time you would tear the boilers
down and clean them out real good and
repair the pumps.
2. Now, did the Seattle School
District have a repair man or a service
man Or a mechanic who repaired the
boilers?
A. As far as repairing, retubing
of the furniace part, the oil burner part
ws.
Q. So was it they who did the major
repair work then on the b ilers?
A. Well, the big thing, like I
Say, we would replace like valves if they
leak, water glasses, repair the pumps.
Q. Prior to your work there you
were in the Navy?
A. Yes, I was.
A-145
Q. And what did you do in the Navy?
A. I was a signalman,
quartermaster.
Q. Before that you were in high
school, were you not?
A. Yes, I was.
* * &
[pp. 996-998)
Q. Did you receive any training
from the school district in operating the
boilers?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. And that was provided by the
school district?
A. Yes, they had a school.
Q. Now, aside from the high school
metal shop and the training you received
from the school district, have you have
[sic] any other mechanical training?
A. Other than hauling my own car
engines and that, no.
A-146
:
;
Q. So aside from those two
courses, have you had any other
mechanical courses?
A. No.
Q. Have you worked on your own
A. Yes.
Q. And have we covered your
mechanical experience now prior to 1968?
A. Pretty much so, I would say,
yes.
Q. In 1968, you worked at Naki
(phonetic) Packing Company, is that
correct?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. Was that your first season in
Alaska?
A. Yes.
Q. And when was your next season?
A. 1970, I think.
Q. And who did you work for then?
A. Columbia Wards Fisheries.
A-147
Q. What was your job title,
A. Helper.
Q. Was that machinist helper?
A. Yes.
Q. And did you return in 1971?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. What was your job then?
A. The iron chink man.
Q. Is that a salmon butchering
A. I guess so.
Q. Okay, @id you return the enxt
A. Yes, I did.
Q. And what was your job then?
A. The same.
Q. Now, was your year at Nacket
(phonetic) the first year you ever saw
salmon butchering machinery?
A. Yes.
A-148
Q. And you were the casin man at
Nacket, you weren't working with the
salmon buthcering [sic] machinery, is
that right?
A. I was the casin label man, I was
over there to help during the preseason.
[p. 999]
Q. Now, was it during your 1970
season, as a helper, at Ekuk, that you
learned the salmon butchering machinist
job for the next year?
A. Yes.
Q. Once you bec ame salmon
butchering machinist, did something
happen that you could not fix, would go to
the cannery foreman for assistance?
{sic}
A. Nothing happened that I
couldn't fix.
A-149
Q. Well, was he available for you
to go to if something happened that you
couldn't fix?
A. I suppose he was.
* * *
[p. 1005)
THE COURT: Did you have any
mechanical training at all in the
service, in the Navy?
THE WITNESS: No, sir.
A-150
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF ARSENIO ELECCION
Arsenio Eleccion, being first sworn,
states.
[p. 1089)
l. I am a Filipino male, residing
at 1503 South Stevens, Seattle,
Washington. I was employed by Wards Cove
Packing Company, Inc. at Red Salmon
cannery through 1972 and at Wards Cove
from 1973 to the present. I worked at Red
Salmon almost every season from 1943 to
1972.
[pp. 1089-1090)
3. In 1943 and 1944 almost all of
the people who worked in the fish house
were Filipino. In both years we had two
blacks and there were no whites. The
people who have worked in the fish house
A-151
up to the present have been mostly
Filipino and there have been no whites.
4. From 1943 up until 1972, all
machinists at Red Salmon have been white.
5. From 1943 to 1972, all office
workers at REG Salmon have been white.
6. All employees who worked in the
store at Red Salmon from 1943 to 197? have
been white.
7. From 1943 to 1972 all tender
operators have been white.
8. From 1943 to 1972 among the
beach gang members there have been no
Filipinos, no Chinese, no Japanese, and
mo blacks. From 1949 on there have been
Alaska Native be ach gang members.
However, these Eskimos were from Seattle.
9. Since 1943 the Filipino crew
has had its own bunkhouse. There have
been almost no white people living in the
bunkhouse. At no time since 1943 did any
of the Filipino cannery workers live in
A-152
the same bunkhouse as the machinists or
the beach gang or the Eskimo cannery
workers. The Eskimo members of the beach
gang did not live with the rest of the
beach gang; they lived in the Eskimo
bunkhouse. That was true in 1949 through
1972.
10. Since 1943 the Local 37 crew
always lived together. There were two
Filipino bunkhouses and two Eskimo
bunkhouses.
ll. Ever since 1943 there had not
been any Filipino, Japanese or Chinese
fishermen at Red Salmon. There had been a
few Native Alaskan fishermen. The
fishermen had their own bunkhouse but the
Alaskan Native fishermen lived in the
Eskimo bunkhouse. In 1972 the few Alaskan
Native fishermen lived in the Eskimo
bunkhouse also.
12. In 1943 the Alaska Native beach
gang members did not eat with the other
A-153
beach gang members; they ate in the
Filipino messhall.
* *«
[p. 1091]
15. In 1943, the Alaska Native
beach gang members ate in our mess hall.
In 1969 the Alaska Native cannery workers
started to eat in the fishermen's
messhall.
[p. 1091]
17. The carpenters at Red Salmon
have had their own bunkhouse since 1943.
Carpenters have always been white also.
* *
[p. 1096]
Q. Alright, when nb etdidin.
when did you start working for Wards Cove
Packing Company?
A. Well, when Mr. Brindle bought
the Red Salmon in 1949, then I started to
work with Brindle company.
A-154
Q. Okay, and did Wards Cove
Packing Company own the cannery since
1949?--I will say it again, did
Mr. Brindle own Red Salmon since 1949?
A. Yeah, they bought the cannery
in 1949.
A-155
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF ALEC W. BRINDLE
* *& &
[p. 1100)
Q. Then on--still oon page 13,
paragraph 49, line 23, do you have a
correction there?
A. Yes, there is a reference to
individual fishermen earning shares in
Bristol Bay of $120,000. That is not
quite correctly stated. What it really
means is that the bulk earning was
$120,000, we have no idea how the boat
Captain would divide the earnings.
ALEC W. BRINDLE, being first duly
Sworn, On Oath deposes and says:
* * &
[p. 1114]
l. I am the President of Wards
Cove Packing Company, Inc., and a
comanager of Columbia Wards Fisheries. I
A-156
have held that position since August of
1977, following the death of my father
A. W. Brindle on July 4, 1977.
2. I am 44 years of age and was
educated as a lawyer, being admitted to
practice in both the state of Alaska and
the state of Washington. I obtained the
degree of Bachelor of Law from the
University of Washington in 1963 and also
hold a Bachelor of Arts Degree in
Political Science from the University of
Santa Clara.
{[p. 1118)
13. Readying the fish camps and
canneries for operation is accomplished
during the months of May or June,
depending on cannery location and timing
of the expected run.
14. Preseason work is intense,
involving extensive overtime, and must be
accomplished in a short period of time.
A-157
Some tenders carry supplies and equipment
to the facilities during the preseason.
In addition to dewinterizing the facility
and reinstalling equipment, docks are
repaired and pilings are replaced; boats
are launched and dewinterized; canning
equipment is tested, lubricated and
adjusted; water systems are replumbed;
and other tasks necessary to restore the
facility to viable operation are
performed. Often new buildings or docks
are constructed before the season.
15. The intense period of preseason
work allows minimal time for training
unskilled workers for skilled jobs.
Because of this, it is not practical to do
so.
16. When the cannery is open and
running, the cannery workers arrive just
before the commencement f fishing
operations. If they are idle prior to
canning they are often given unskilled
A-158
work as called for by their contract, such
as grass cutting and cannery cleanup.
(See infra, Miscellaneous Work.)
[pp. 1122-1123]
32. The hiring policies of Wards
Cove and Col]lumbia Wards during the entire
case period have been to select the best
people for any particular job without
regard to race. Two of the Columbia Wards
Fisheries superintendents, Carl Aspelund
of the fish camp at Craig and Emil Norton
of the Icy Cape cannery, are Alaska
Natives. Sam Yoshida of Japanese descent
is an employee of Columbia Wards
Fisheries and is egg production manager
in charge of the Bgg Sales Department. He
has the status of a cannery
superintendent. Osamu Marao, who is
Japanese, is employed in the home office
of Wards Cove with the title of assistant
superintendent. We have many other
A-159
minorities om our home office staff: Pete
Gasca, of Chicano descent is office
manager of Columbia Wards, is an officer
of CWC Pisheries, Inc., and he is
responsible for Wards Cove's most
sensitive financial data. Also of
Filipino descent is Jesus Canon, an
office manager, Wards Cove cannery at
Ketchikan and Juanita Quiban, Mexican
assistant accountant Columbia Wards
Pisheries. A complete list of minorities
employed in the office of Wards Cove and
Coumbia [sic] Wards, 88 East Hamlin
Street, Seattle, Washington, is attached
as Pxhibit A.
33. The primary consideration in
hiring for all jobs at our facilities is
the skill and experience of the person
under consideration. Race is not a
consideration or factor in hiring, except
for affirmative action considerations.
A-160
34. The more skilled, experienced
employees we can hire, the less time and
effort is lost in on-the-job orientation,
training, and inefficient, nonproductive
activity.
35. Our policy and practice is to
adhere to the union rehire preference
clauses and to offer employment in the
same jobs to past satisfactory employees
for the new season. Employees, including
nonresident cannery workers, take
advantage of these clauses to secure
employment.
36. Hiring for all jobs except
resident cannery workers, spring and fall
workers, and the majority of nonresident
cannery workers takes place at our home
offices in Seattle and Astoria during the
first three months of the year. Most
employees, particularly in the skilled
jobs, are hired between January 1 and
April 1 each year for the upcoming
A-161
season. The Machinists and Alaska
Fishermen's Unions are generally notified
by mid-April by our companies of the names
of persons hired in jobs under their
jurisdiction. Cannery workers are hired
a little later in May or June. Each
location has slightly different timing
depending on the commencement of the fish
run.
37. The rehire preference rights of
past employees are respected in
determining the number of vacancies to be
filled for the new season. The remaining
vacancies are filled from amongst those
who seek employment with us during the
fall and winter preceding the upcoming
season. We seldom look to applications
for the preceding season in filling
openings for the upcoming season. Rehire
preference rights are included in the
union agreements for cannery workers,
machinists, carpenters, and the AFU.
A-162
[pp. 1125-1126)
43. » « « Wone of the cannery
worker foremen at any of our facilities
are vested with any authority to hire for
any positicn outside the cannery worker
department, nor are they authorized to
even discuss those jobs on behalf of
management.
[pp. 1126-1127]
49. It also has Leen my observation
that many Alaska Natives have a distinct
preference for fishing. In fishing there
is always the possibility of large
earnings, even though in some years the
average earnings may be moderate. We have
had individual fishermen earning shares
in Bristol Bay of $120,000, at Chignik
$45,000 man share, and Southeastern of
$16,000 man share during the case period.
Tn Alaska talk of these high liners is a
A-163
popular subject of conversation so it is
natural for residents to be attracted to
these jobs. Our fishing fleets at Ekuk,
Craig, Chignik, and Hoonah are almost
entirely Native. We have many Native
fishermen at Kenai and Alitak as well. We
have also had Native fishermen at Wards
Cove cannery.
[pp. 1127-1128)
52. Local 37 of the International
Longshoremen's and Warehousemen's Union
(I.L.W.U.) has had the union contract for
cannery worker jobs with us, except for
the Ekuk facility, throughout the case
period. Local 37 is predominantly
Filipino in composition and almost
entirely Asian.
53. The hiring process at Local 37
works like this: the superintendent will
tell his cannery worker foreman how many
personnel are needed for a season. The
A-164
cannery worker foreman will then prepare
a list of persons based upon those who
worked at the cannery the previous season
and who had not been terminated. The
cannery worker foreman attempts to
contact these employees to confirm their
availability and advise them of the date
of dispatch. Within about a month from
the time of receipt of the request from
the cannery superintendent, the foreman
furnishes a list to Local 37 president,
Tony Baruso, or his predecessor Gene
Navarro. Baruso will examine the list and
delete the names of those who have moved
or died and will add names to the list if
more employees are needed than had worked
the previous season. These names are
added from members who may wish to work in
Alaska or from new applicants. On the day
of dispatch, the union dispatcher in the
union hall reads the names from the list
and when, or if, the individual is present
A-165
and responds, his union book is checked to
verify his dues payments are in order. If
the member's book does not indicate he is
current in his dues, he is referred to the
union secretary-treasurer who is located
in offices immediately adjacent to the
hall. The secretary-treasurer will
either collect past dues or straighten
out some other problems with the member's
book. At the time of dispatch, one of our
employees is also normally present.
54. Beginning in the late 1960's,
our companies first started to find a
market for salmon eggs in response to
market demands from Japan. The product is
*sujiko” and consists of eggs sorted by
grade, treated in brine solution, and
packed for export. Because the product is
unique to the Japanese market, our
customers have provided technicians to
supervise this. They are Japanese
Nationals and have been housed and fed at
A-166
the canneries. For some reason, the
Local 37 male workers refused to work in
the egghouse under supervision of the
Japanese without over time. As an
example, attached is a copy of
Exhibit 435A a complaint from the
Local 37 delegate at Wards Cove cannery
in 1970 demanding over time for the work
in the egghouse. Accordingly, we have
looked outside Local 37 as a source of
labor for the egghouse. These workers
have been predominantly white, have been
hired by the superintendent from
applicants with little input from
Local 37, but have been required to pay
union dues.
55. On the day of dispatch, our
employee in attendance at the union hall
will present a list of egg workers to
Baruso for union approval. Baruso will
sometimes negotiate additional jobs at
that time or replacements for those egg
A-167
workers who do not confirm employment.
Baruso will add names of female workers to
this lsit [sic]. The female egghouse
workers added by Baruso have been
nonwhite.
56. Local 37 thus produces an over
supply of Asians, Filipinos in
particular, in the unskilled cannery
worker jobs. We continue to use Local 37
because it has a contract with all of our
facilities except Ekuk.
* * *
[pp. 1128-1129]
57. There is a high turnover rate
of our employees from one season to the
next, particularly in the unskilled jobs.
Because of this, and because of the lack
of time which would be required to stop
work and provide training during the
season, we provide very little on-the-job
training; that is, the type of training
A-168
that would turn a "“greenhorn" into a
machinist.
58. Because of the lack of time and
personnel available for training at a
salmon cannery, skills or qualifications
cannot be considered "readily acquirable”
unless they can be acquired within a
matter of days with a minimal amount of
training time required of supervisory and
other skilled personnel.
59. To maximize production and
minimize the amount of training which
must be done at the canneries, we attempt
to hire experienced persons in all job
categories. We have found that because of
the intensity of operation, experience in
every cannery job is preferable.
* * *
[p. 1134]
61. Qualifications required for any
individual positiom depend to a certain
extent on the cannery involved, the age
A-169
and condition of equipment, the expected
harvest of fish, skill level of other
incumbents and supervisors, and other
such factors. . + +
* * *
[p. 1135]
67. There are very few promotions
during the season. If a vacancy does
occur, we feel we are better off hiring a
replacement from outside rather than
creating an empty spot in the cannery and
then hire another to fill that spot and
pay him a season's guarantee.
* * *
{[p. 1137)
79. Workers are housed primarily
according to job department and time of
arrival. The larger cannery worker
bunkhouses are generally not opened up
during the preseason. They are generally
opened up and prepared for occupancy
shortly before the cannery worker crews
A-170
arrive or upon the cannery workers
arrival. This is typically within a few
Gays of the anticipated beginning of the
salmon run at each location. By the time
the cannery workers arrive, most other
employees have already begun working and
have been housed. By the time the cannery
workers arrive, there are generally few,
if any, available spaces except in the
cannery worker bunkhouses.
80. Cannery workers are housed for
the shortest period of time of any
employees and do not need the better
insulated buildings required for the
noncannery worker employees who arrive at
the cannery earlier and stay later than
the cannery workers.
** *
[p. 1138)
86. In a general sense the policy
of our companies is to provide housing at
the various plants by job classification.
A-171
The higher paid employees receive
slightly to somewhat superior housing
facilities. The machinists, for
instance, are our highest paid group of
employees and also they spend more time at
the cannery than the others. The
machinists are the first ones to be sent
North to the canneries to open them up and
will spend three to six weeks getting ‘te
cannery ready to run. The cannery
workers, on the other hand, arrive just
shortly before canning is to commence
because they are not needed for any
signficant amount of work outside the
canning operation.
87. As workers arrive during the
preseason or during the season the
housing will develop like a series of
concentric circles. The first to arrive
will be given Bunkhouse A; the second
group Bunkhouse C and so forth.
A-172
[pp. 1139-1140) ”
91. We provide substantially equal
messing to all employees regardless of
race. The leaders of Local 37, the
bargaining representative for nonresident
cannery workers, have traditionally
demanded Oriental and Filipino food, a
separate menu, and separate eating and
cooking facilities for its members, most
of whom are Filipino and Asian.
Management has acceded to these wishes.
92. The Local 37 contract provides
for a separate culinary crew for the
Local 37 crew.
93. At Wards Cove, the food
preparation and storage area ("kitchen")
of the Local 37 mess is larger and as vell
equipped than that of the AFU mess. The
Local 37 kitchen is about 777 square feet
whereas the AFU kitchen is about 476
square feet. The Local 37 kitchen was
remodelled and added to around 1977 or
A-173
1978. Prior thereto, the Local 37
kitchen was about 407 square feet. The
AFU kitchen has also been remodelled
since its construction in the 1930's.
Thus, prior to the construction of the
Local 37 kitchen addition, the kitchens
in both messes were about the same size.
94. The quality and quantity of
food served in mess halls is’ the
responsibility of the steward or cook in
the mess hall. Virtually all complaints
about food can be traced to matters of
personal taste and preference or the
competence of the cook. We have had just
as many whites complain about the food as
we have had nonwhites complain.
95. We have ordered special food
for the nonresident cannery worker mess
halls in accordance with the wishes of the
Local 37 union leaders, the Local 37
cannery worker foreman, and the Local 37
cook or steward.
A-174
96. We have not imposed any
dissimilar budgetary or other
restrictions on the quality, quantity, or
type of food which may be ordered or
served by the cooks in any of the mess
halls in any of our facilities.
97. Our policy on messing is to
permit the cook at each facility to order
and provide what he reasonably wants.
While the general quality of food for all
employees as well as the quantity is well
above what most of us would eat in our own
homes, complaints about food have
probably existed over the years in almost
all of our facilities and aboard our
tenders. If the employees in a particular
mess do not like the food, they will go to
the cook. If the cook for some reasons
determines not to provide steak once a
week, it is because of his decision, not
that of management and he may be persuaded
A-175
by those that he feeds during the season
to make adjustments.
98. Throughout the entire case
period and by contract, Local 37 has
their own culinary department. By
tradition as well as by preference the
Local 37 cooks will order a number of
supplies such as bean sprouts, soy,
canned abalone, and rice, and yet may
often be designated as "Oriental food" in
the paperwork. Indeed, it is Oriental
food that is cooked.
99. The mess facilities may differ
‘slightly between the Local 37 and the AFU
department, but they are the same
essentially. If the AFU has additional
equipment it is for the reason that that
department is required to serve more
personnel or such as at Red Salmon and
Alitak bake for the entire camp.
100. At Alitak the main mess hall is
called the Winter Mess because when crab
A-176
are processed at Alitak during’ the
wintertime all personnel eat in the same
mess hall. Local 37 has never exercised
jurisdiction at the Ekuk cannery and Ekuk
has not had a separate mess for cannery
workers.
[p. 1141]
105. For the tender fleet it is our
policy, and we feel it is reasonable, to
allow the tender captains some discretion
in choosing crew as this work involves
living and working for extended periods
of time in close quarters, and sometimes
long hours under arduous conditions at
sea.
106. We feel that it is reasonable
to hire applicants whose qualifications
are known or who are recommended
considering the facts of cannery
operation. In addition, many jobs
require an ability to get along with
A-177
others. All jobs require sobriety.
Personal recommendations tend to weed out
troublemakers in this regard. To do
otherwise would risk setting problem
personnel in a remote location where they
are hard to replace.
107. We of ten hire additional
cannery workers from the communities near
the cannery during the season as the
salmon catch impacts’ the demand for
employees as there may not be time to look
elsewhere.
108. It is necessary to hire
beachmen, machinists, tender crews,
carpenters and office personnel early in
the season and prior to the time when
cannery workers are hired, since they go
to Alaska a month to six weeks before
canning commences.
x* *« *
A-178
[pp. 1141-1142]
109. Only in Bristol Bay, Alaska,
were there "company” or employee
fishermen.
110. At Red Salmon and Bumble Bee
during the case period many of the
nonwhite fishermen have chosen .o become
independent fishermen. Most resident
Alaskans in Bristol Bay who wanted to
fish, including most of our nonwhite
fishermen preferred to fish on the
Nushagak River because of its greater
reliability in fish runs and somewhat
longer season. By selecting the
Nushagak, they would not be available for
company fishermen jobs on the Naknek at
Red Salmon and Bumble Bee.
lll. The “east side" of Bristol Bay
is where Bumble Bee and Red Salmon are
located. For more than 15 years these
canneries operated in consolidation with
each other and with the CWF fish camp at
A-179
Egegik. This was called the Naknek-
Kvichak Joint Operating Agreement. Under
its terms, we split the pack 30% to Wards
Cove, 30% to Bumble Bee, and 40% to CWF.
At Egegik we had about 17 Alaska Native
company fishermen until 1973. They were
housed and fed with the white fishermen.
They also had the privilege of using Red
Salmon and Bumble Bee cannery facilities
on the Naknek. For accounting purposes
they were regarded as Red Salmon
fishermen. They were recruited primarily
by my father, A. W. Brindle.
112. By 1974 we had no company
fishermen left on the payroll. They were
phased out because accounting studies
showed that after payment of run money,
room and board, and transportation, they
were more costly than independent
fishermen.
113. We felt it reasonable to allow
company fishermen complete latitutde in
A-180
hiring a boat puller since the two must
live and work together in cramped
quarters and are paid on a share basis.
We did not view the crew as consisting of
a boss and an underling; rather they were
viewed as partners and they each received
an equal share in the catch.
114. If a boat puller wanted his own
boat and had a good recommendation from
his skipper, he might have been given a
boat.
[pp. 1142-1143]
115. There is no doubt that’ the
Filipinos refer to themselves as
Filipinos and, over the years in labor
negotiations particularly, the union
negotiators have taken great pride in the
fact that the Filipino crews at _ the
canneries are the best fish house crews
that there are.
A-181
116. There has been’ considerable
difficulty in getting over the term
"Filipino bunkhouse." I can recall
telling our affirmative action director,
Salvadore del Fierro that perhaps. we
should avoid the term. Nevertheless he
continued to use the term more often than
not when referring to the Local 37
bunkhouse. The same is true of "Filipino
crew" even though there are whites on it
or even if the foreman is Chinese (Fred
Wong).
117. Insofar as Alaska Natives are
concerned, for mere ease or habit of
identification they might be referred to
as the Native crew. After all, they are
Alaska Natives and proud of it. There are
many organizations bearing the - name
"native," i.e., Alaska Native Co-
Operative Association, Bristol Bay Native
Association, Bristol Bay Native
Corporation, etc. There are also
A-182
constant references to natives in Alaska
as "Native Claim Act,” "native rights,"
"native villages." One would normally
assume, if you recruited from a Native or
Eskimo village, the people who came from
there would be Natives or Eskimos and they
would often be referred to in that manner
just as the Norwegian fishermen are
referred to as Norwegians, Yugoslavians
who are prominent in purse seining as
"Slavonians,"” and Italians who are
prominant in gillnetting as “Italians.”
The people from Manekotok, Unalakleet,
etc., are almost entirely Eskimos and one
would tend to call them. such. Such
labeling has never been used by our
companies in either a derogatory or
restrictive sense.
[p. 1143]
118. Insofar as hiring relatives is
concerned, there is no doubt that they
A-183
have better information as to what jobs
are available and what the conditions at a
particular cannery might be. Most of the
jobs given to relatives are unskilled and
very often are cannery worker jobs.
119. Other factors which make hiring
relatives a reasonable business practice
would include that sometimes it is the
incentive to get the relative back to
Alaska or it is part of an economic
package which makes working for our
company more attractive.
x* * #
[pp. 1144-1145]
123. . « « It would be extremely
poor practice to try and run a tender with
an experienced captain and an
inexperienced crew. In the first place,
you cannot expect the captain to be on the
wheel all of the time. We lost a tender
year before last because the captain had
to lay down after a 24-hour storm and
A-184
while he was asleep the mate, whose
qualifications we later found were
suspect, managed to fall asleep and his
vessel ran into a rock in open water. In
the second place, the captain cannot be at
the wheel and oil and grease the engine at
the same time, nor in the case of an
emergency, if you have an inexperienced
crew, can you expect anybody to do
anything since they don't know what to do.
Obviously there have been’ situations
where we have tried to get by with a crew
with minimum requirements, but we
normally would limit the use of the tender
to make sure it wasn't used beyond the
capabilities of the crew. For example,
the tender VANGUARD is owned and
maintained in yacht like condition by my
uncle Joe Brindle. He spends a good part
of each winter maintaining it and it is
used only on short runs out of Wards Cove,
Ketchikan. When witnesses Bird,
A-185
Milholland, and Chris Steele were on the
VANGUARD as engineers they were on 4a
tender not typical of the rest of our
operation. We certainly could not do this
on most of our other tenders.
x* *
[p. 1146]
128. It is essential to have an
experienced crew in the machinist
department. There is absolutely no way
you can even come close to running 4a
cannery with a totally inexperienced,
unskilled crew even if they were working
under the close supervision of a first
machinist and a cannery foreman. We are
processing food in these facilities and
they are going into sealed containers and
packed under regulations promulgated by
the Food and Drug Administration. With an
inexperienced crew, you would either have
to restrict your production or you would
‘wind up with a lot of questionable pack
A-186
that would have to be reexamined or even
destroyed and this is very expensive.
x « &
[pp. 1147-1148]
138. While we do ship equipment
south for major overhaul, major
breakdowns can occur during the season.
In one instance in 1977, when we had a
heavy fishing season in southeastern
Alaska, we had a clinching machine go
wrong at Wards Cove. We had to borrow a
clincher from a competitor since we could
not get our fixed even with the assistance
of the American Can Company man. The can
shop equipment is leased from the can
company. While they try to get by and
make preseason adjustments and get out to
help when you have a problem, their
resources are limited and they have no
control over weather or airplanes so they
are not available "on call” as plaintiffs
contend (Plaintiffs' Contention No. 120).
A-187
139. As an example, in 1977 at Wards
Cove a lid got upside down in the seamer
in the reform shop. We were fortunate to
have two very qualified machinists
(Landry and Mullis) there who were able to
tear down the machine (it took all night)
and repair it. The American Can man was
not available. If we had not been able to
fix it, our production would have been cut
in half.
140. A port engineer has to
understand marine diesels and they can be
quite different from automobile engines.
Marine equipment has problems different
from regular automotive equipment. The
port engineer should understand
hydraulics. For example, he must know how
to take an engine that has been swamped
with salt water and get it running again.
He really should have very good diesel
mechanic experierce since most of the
engines in gillnet boats and seine
A-188
skiffs, as well as tenders and seine
boats, are diesels. The port engineer
has, however, so much total
responsibility that we must rely on our
tender engineers for most of the tender
repairs. For example, at Ekuk, the port
engineer has about 96 gillnet bwats to
keep running. Although the fishermen are
independent, it is essential that we keep
their boats running to keep their loyalty
and to maintain their supply of fish. If
an independent fisherman loses a day of
fishing because of an engine breakdown it
could cost him $10,000 or more. Ekuk,
Bumble Bee, Red Salmon, Chignik, Kenai,
Egegik, and Alitak all store and
winterize fishing boats under the port
engineer's supervision. -
x* ke
[pp. 1148-1149]
141. Quality control is really a
function of definition. It depends upon
A-189
what each individual superintendent
expects out of his quality control
person. If they expect that person to
check out the work of the salmon cook and
do part of the seam check, then they
should have two season's experience
working under the machinist foreman. I
can think of a bad quality control
situation a couple of years ago when we
had to recheck several days' canning of
half pound cans because of a seam defect
discovered by the Food and Drug
Administration. It was never
satisfactorily explained just who was
supposed to be doing seam checks, but it
cost about $40,000 to have that portion of
the pack re-examined at the Port of
Bellingham.
[p. 1149]
142. The work required of this crew
varies from unskilled such as_ simply
A-190
unloading fish from the tenders to highly
skilled, such as pile driving. Pile
driving involves working with very heavy
gear and mistakes can be fatal. Our crews
-_
.
have driven piling in various canneries.
Other work of the beachgang involves
launching boats, driving forklifts, and
other heavy work around the cannery.
143. The beachgang is required to do
a variety of skilled jobs. Welding,
pipefitting, Carpentry, and rigging
skills must be all possessed by the
beachgang as a collective unit. Just
moving heavy equipment like oil or water
tanks is skilled if you are going to do it
without injuring someone. Most of this
skilled work is done during the preseason
Or in the fall so the cannery workers are
not exposed to it. They probably regard
the beachgang as people whose only jos
[sic] is to unload fish.
A-191
[p. 1149]
144. Of the five class faciilties,
four have had members of the Brindle
family as superintendents: Harold at Red
Salmon and Kenai (my father, A. W., until
1977 at Red Salmon), Greg at Wards Cove
‘(my uncle Joe Brindle up until 1979), and
my brother Winn at Alitak. At Ekuk, Jim
Ekern was superintendent for many years
prior to the formation of Columbia Wards
Fisheries, and continued in that job.
* *
[p. 1149]
145. This depends on the size of the
operation. The office manager or head
bookkeeper's job requires more than a
high school course in bookkeeping. In our
Operation, they are responsible for
keeping track of records such as at Ekuk,
300 people, together with what is being
bought and sold in the store and consumed
in the mess house. At Ekuk, for instance,
A-192
the store is almost a year-round
Operation. The storekeeper must run the
store like a business.
146. These personnel have to
understand what keeping books is all
about and they also have to understand
what a cannery is all about because they
are doing many different tasks. They are
buying millions of dollars worth of fish
and they are buying hundreds of thousands
of dollars worth of equipment. We advance
hundreds of thousands of dollars to
fishermen and we advance money to
employees. People have to understand how
the union contracts work and what our
responsibilities and our rights are under
the contract. They have got to understand
when to pay bills and when not to pay them
and how to charge for personnel's time,
such as port engineer's time on a
fisherman's account, what it is charged
to and whether it charged to, the boat or
A-193
to a tender. * They also have to calculate
both state and federal taxes.
147. Bookkeeping personnel also have
to keep track of the daily canning records
and how many pounds of raw fish came out
as cans today compared with yesterday.
* *«
[p. 1312]
BY MR. ARDITI:
Q. Mr. Brindle, you are an
attorney by training, is that correct?
A. That is my formal education,
yes.
Q. And, you formerly appeared as
an attorney for the defendants in this
case, did you not?
A. That is correct, I entered a
Notice of Appearance.
Q. You had a role in forumulating
the defense in this case, I take it?
A. I don't know that I had a role
in formulating the defense because I'm
A-194
not sure what you mean by that. I had a
role in attempting to, in the early stages
of the litigation, in attempting to
comply with discovery and shortly after
the initial discovery was under way, I had
less and less other roles in the case.
Q. Let me ask you, is it true that
pages 3 thru 28 of your affidavit are
taken in large part almost verbatim from
the defense contentions in the Pretrial
Order?
A. I have to tell you, I haven't
seen the defense contentions in the.
Pretrial Order that I recall. I couldn't
tell you, but I can tell you this, I have
read these, some of this is my language
directly and some of it I have discussed
all these matters with counsel, and they
put the affidavits together. Now, these
discussions have gone on over a number of
years. I don't know whether they are ina
pretrial, what you call call [sic]
A-195
contentions, I don't know because I have
not seen those. If I have seen them, I
don't recall seeing them.
x * *
[p. 1315]
BY MR. ARDITI:
Q. This is in your handwriting?
A. It would appear to be my
printing, yes.
Q. And would you please read the
last three lines for us?
A. The last three lines?
Q. Yes.
A. "Got another phoney minority
claim today from EEOC--it never
ends"--exclamation point and my
signature.
[pp. 1319-1322]
Q. Now, you have worked as a
tender deckhand at Wards Cove when you
were younger, didn't you?
A-196
A. That is correct. ,
Q. And, how old were you--you were
about 13 or 14 when you first took that
job, is that right?
A. That is when I first started
getting paid.
Q. And, aS you were going to
school you became a tender engineer for
Wards Cove Packing Company?
A. That is correct.
Q. And in fact, by age 21 or 22,
you became a tender captain, correct?
A. I was assigned the captain's
responsibilities the year I worked in
Bristol Bay when the Skipper on a brine
tender got sick and they needed an
experienced man to take his place, and the
next most experienced fellow was the
Skipper on the boat I was on, so he was
assigned on the brine, and I was assigned
to the skipper on the Penguin which was
A-197
the vessel, and then assigned the pilot
around the river system.
Q. You were in law school at the
time, were you not?
A. That is correct, well, no I
wasn't, I was in Bristol Bay at the time,
and this was the summer I was attending
law school in the winter. Yes.
Q. That is what I meant, and you
were about age 21 or 22.
A. Somewhere in that area.
Q. Now, you learned the captain's
job through your prior experience as a
deckhand, correct?
A. Well, now, that depends on what
you mean “learned it as a deckhand". I
certainly learned it while I was on the
boat doing a deckhand's function, but in
addition to that, why, of course, the
skipper was teaching me navigation, he
was teaching me boat handling which was
teaching me the rules of the road, so
A-198
within the frame of time that I was being
a deckhand, yes, I learned the skipper's
job, but I didn't learn to be a skipper
because of or by being a deckhand.
Q. You did not have any courses in
navigation prior to the time you became a
tender caption, [sic] did you?
A. No, I had no formal courses in
navigation, only courses from the
skipper.
Q. In fact, you had no_ formal
training at all for the tender captain's
job, did you?
A. That is correct. I had no
formal schooling as such.
Q. While you worked on tenders for
Wards Cove Packing Company, you flew up to
Alaska rather than sail up with the crew
on occasion, is that true?
A. Oh, On occasion, yes.
Q. And that is because you were a
student in school at the time?
A-199
A. That is correct.
Q. Now, I--
A. Well, that wasn't because I was
a student, whether I went North on a
tender or came South on the tender
depended upon how my school schedule fit
with the tender schedule. The first time
I went up and worked, I went up on a
tender. When I was about 14.
Q. So if your school schedule did
not permit you to said [sic] up, then--
A. Then I would fly.
Q. And you started at a later
date, then, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, is it fair to say that
neither Wards Cove Packing Company nor
Columbia Wards Fisheries have fixed
experience criteria for hiring of the
beach boss?
A. Fixed experience criteria, I
don't think that is accurate.
A-200
Q.
Okay, do you recall having your
deposition taken on June 3, 1980?
A.
Q.
the following questions and answers as
follows:
Yes.
And, do you recall being asked
MR. FRYER: Page, cc’insel?
MR. ARDITI: Page 55.
BY MR. ARDITI:
Q.
questions
A.
Q. "There is no set
criteria then for hiring
of beach boss, is that
right?"
A. "Well, a beach boss
has to be able to run a
crew and do the work a
beachgang does, so he has
to know what the things
are, but that type of work
comes in many forms."
Q. "You don't measure
that with respect to
specific types of
experience, do you?"
A. "I don't know how you
would.”
Do you recall being asked those
and answering as follows?
Yes.
A-201
Q. Now, in hiring tender captains,
you look for different kinds of
experience depending on which boat you
are hiring for, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And the same is true of tender
engineer?
A. Yes.
Q. And although to lesser degree,
the same is also true of deckhand jobs,
correct?
A. I think that is correct.
[pp. 1326-1327]
Q. Okay. Could you turn to page 7
of your affidavit? At line 27 you use the
term “Iron Chink", and based on your
experience in the industry, is it your
understanding that prior to mechanization
in the industry, all the butchering of the
salmon was done by hand?
A-202
A. Well, I guess prior to
mechanization of butchering, the
butchering was done by hand, there was no
machine to do it.
Q. And that was done largely by
Chinese workers?
A. That is my understanding, it
was primarily a Chinese contract for
labor and Japanese. Certainly, there
were other Asians involved.
Q. And is it your understanding
that the salmon butchering machine was
named the "Iron Chink" because it
replaced so many Chinese workers?
A. I don't know why the gentleman
who invented the Iron Chink called it
that. There are a great many stories.
Q. Is that one of the stories you
have heard?
A. That is one, I suppose.
x* * &
A-203
[pp. 1327-1328]
Q. Now, could you turn to page ll
of your affidavit, and specifically to
lines 20 to 27 where you talk about
preference clause for the machinists?
A. Yes.
Q. And that quotation would have
come from the 1970 collective bargaining
agreement, wouldn't it?
A. Yes, I would think so.
Q. Now, in 1971, that clause
changed to require that people asserting
a rehire preference also had to sent [sic]
a rehire card in to the union, didn't it?
A. I don't recall when the rehire
card procedure was put in, but I know
there is, and I think there is today, that
same language in the machinist contract.
Q. So to assert a rehire
preference, a machinist has to send the
card in to both the union and the company?
A-204
A. That is the technical
requirement of the contract, yes.
* &
[pp. 1331-1333]
Q. Could you turn to page 14,
paragraph 53 of your affidavit. At
line 23 thru 29 you describe certain
things that Mr. Baruso does requesting
how, Or are you physically present when he
does this--when he removes names from the
list or examines the list?
A. I have been physically present
in the dispatch hall?
Q. No, what I am asking you, are
you present at the time Mr. Baruso
examines this list and deletes from the
list and adds to the list?
A. Well, let's put it this way, I
have had discussions on the _ telephone
with Mr. Baruso concerning some of the
people that were on the list that were
being deleted or about people he wanted to
A-205
put on the list. I have not been in his
presence when this was done, and I should
probably--when I say Baruso in line
twenty-five and a half, that really
shouldn't have been just limited to
Mr. Baruso, it should have really stated,
to be more accurate, the people who are
responsible for running the union hall,
Mr. Baruso was president of the union
hall, so we just talk about it as being
Mr. Baruso. He's one I _ have had
conversations with over the phone.
Q. Okay, then he makes adjustments
or he talks to you about other people who
are entitled to first preference, is that
right?
A. Mr. Baruso has discussed with
me people that he wanted to put on the
list for particular canneries, yes.
Q. Now, your understanding of the
collective bargaining agreement is the
A-206
first, second and third preference,
correct?
A. That is correct.
Q. And the third preference is for
new hirees, is that correct?
A. I think that is my
recollection. I can't recall all the
preferences clauses, I think it is the
third preference or the fourth preference
is the applicant generally or mutually
agreeable to the company. I can't
remember which.
MR. ARDITI: Could the witness be
handed a copy of say Exhibit A-2?
(The document was handed to the
witness).
BY MR. ARDITI:
Q. Okay, in fact, the third
preference goes to persons satisfactory
to the company, doesn't it?
A. Well, it says "persons
satisfactory to the company, including
A-207
but not limited to, union members or men
recruited for employment by the union".
Q. But those hired do not have to
be satisfactory to the company, correct?
A. Well, let's put it this way, if
in lining up a crew, it has been our
experience that if there was somebody
that the union wanted to put on the crew,
and unless we had some very specific
objections to that individual, that it
was in our best interest to accede to the
expressed list of the union in that
regard.
Q. And that would be in the same
way that you might accede to a
recommendation as a tender captain for a
crew member, correct?
A. Not quite.
Q. You do retain authority under
the collective bargaining agreement to
various preferences.
A-208
A. Yes, the collective bargaining
agreement gave us that power.
x* * &
[p. 1339]
Q. Pages 33 thru 37, you talk
about job qualifications for certain
jobs, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. You do not hire for those jobs,
do you?
(pp. 1352-1353]
THE COURT: Are you saying you can
never recall an instance of taking a
Cannery worker and moving him _ into
another job during the year, during the
season I should say?
THE WITNESS: Not someone under the
Local 37 jurisdiction. We have with
other cannery workers that were under the
resident jurisdiction, but we don't have
the same kind of guarantee situation. The
A-209
other problem is just simply one of
filling in the job that you have your
resident cannery workers are there, and
they're there because you need them to
perform a function, and if you pulled one
out, then you have to replace him, if
you're going to have to replace him
through Local 37, then we have another
guarantee.
THE COURT: Well, you're not
obligated to replace through Local 37,
are you?
THE WITNESS: No, but often time it
is very difficult to find the local people
to fill in that job.
x* * *
[Dep., p.- 2]
BY MR. ARDITI:
Q. Please state your name.
A. Alexander Winn Brindle.
Q. And what is your’ business
address?
A-210
A. 88 East Hamlin Street; Seattle,
Washington.
Q. What is your job title, please?
A. President of Wards Cove Packing
Company.
Q. And how long have you held that
job?
A. Since approximately September
of 1977.
Q. Do you have any =jobs with
Columbia-Wards Fisheries?
A. I am an officer of Columbia-
Wards Fisheries, Inc.
x* *&
[Dep., p. 5]
Q. There is no set criteria, then,
for hiring a beach boss; is that right?
A. Well, a beach boss has to be
able to run a crew and do the work that
the beach gang does, so he has to know
what those things are. But that type of
work comes in many forms.
A-211
Q.
But you don't measure that with
respect to specific types of experience,
do you?
look for?
Well, I don't know how you
57)
What specific experience do you
For who?
A tender captain.
On which boat, in which area?
It varies from boat to boat?
Certainly.
Is that true of tender engineer
Certainly.
Tender deck hand?
Less.
A-212
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF WARNER LEONARDO
* * &
[1509-1510]
Q. Mr. Leonardo, I have a couple
of questions--did you do the hiring for
the jobs at Bumble Bee - South Naknek
outside the classification of cannery
worker, did you do that hiring yourself?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. For those jobs, did you
generally make it a practice to interview
applicants yourself?
A. Yes, I did.
Q. And this would include people
like machinists and tendermen?
A. Right.
Q. Could you tell the court the
types of questions you customarily would
ask of people who wanted, let's say a
tender engineer's job?
A-213
A. Well, I would ask him if he had
any experience on boats before and if he
knew anything about the particular type
of diesel engines that we were using and
if he had any tools--
Q. What kinds of qualifications
did you impose for the job of, let's say,
tender deckhand? |
A. Well, I tried to get some young
people that were--that had experience, in
fact, I tried to get them out of Astoria
because most of the kids had been on boats
[sic] before with their fathers or with
somebody, and knew how to tie up a boat,
and ship, whatever it might be, and it is
better than hiring a greenhorn.
Q. Mr. Leonardo, I am going to ask
you to assume that an expert witness
testified in this case that a cannery such
as Bumble Bee could be properly operated
with the machinist foreman, a_ first
machinist, and the remainder of the
A-214
machinist crew being composed of
machinist helpers. Now, just assume that
as a fact, would you agree that Bumble Bee
- South Naknek could be operated with the
machinist crew like that?
A. Absolutely no.
(pp. 1510) 7 .o.5
Q. Do you remember my question,
Mr. Leonardo? What kind of
qualifications did you require when you
hired people at Bumble Bee - South Naknek
for the machinist crew?
A. Well, it depends on what field
he was going to be in, what part of the
Operation, why it would be the general
guestion of how much experience he had and
if he had tools and where he worked before
and stuff of that nature.
Q. Did you ever hire any
greenhorns on the machinist crew at
Bumble Bee - South Naknek?
A-215
A. No, but I have hired some
[pp. 1513-1514]
l. My name is Warner Leonardo and
I reside at 23302 Northeast 237th,
Battleground, Washington. From 1952
until 1980, I was the superintendent of
the Bumble Bee cannery at South Naknek,
Alaska. . =. -
2. During my years as
superintendent at South Naknek, I
attempted to personally interview every
applicant for a job at the cannery other
than cannery workers who were hired
through Local 37 or cannery workers hired
in Alaska. Our policy throughout the case
period was to select the best applicants
possible for any skilled job, regardless
of race. In my experience, a personal
interview was usually necessary to find
the best applicant. Qnce the season has
A-216
commenced in Alaska, I felt we could get
burned if we did not have the most
qualified person since replacements at
that time are very difficult to come by.
oe oe
[p. 1514]
3. In the 1960's we always had a
few Alaska Native fishermen. However,
the Natives went independent early
compared with the nonresident fishermen.
Some of our company fishermen were older
and did not want to make the cahnge [sic].
4. We ‘tried to take our best
fishermen and make them independent so
they would be able to pay for their boats.
Alaska Natives were among this group.
5. Our policy concerning hiring
boat pullers was mainly to let the skipper
hire his own partner. We felt that since
they had to live together under difficult
circumstances and share equally in the
catch, the skipper had to find someone
A-217
that he could work closely with. If a
skipper could not find a boat puller, I
would pick a skipper off a relatively
nonproductive boat and make him a puller.
I would always take an experienced man.
There were too many things to learn and it
was too short a season. The season starts
in the Naknek-Kvichak area on June 25 and
is over on July 20. The peak of the
season is from the 4th of July to the 10th
of July when most of the fish are actually
caught. This does not leave any time for
training.
[p. 1514]
6. For hiring in this position, I
always wanted someone who was at least 200
pounds in weight, strong and could lift
150 pounds or better. Actually, I
preferred loggers because they were used
to working with wire rope and slings and
moving heavy objects. I also looked for
A-218
backgrounds in other types ‘of heavy work
such as dock work, pile driving, wire
splicing, longshoring, and things of that
nature.
[p. 1515)
8. For tender engineers I required
that they should be able to handle tools
and make minor repairs on the tenders and
be available to fix fish boat engines on
grounds. ...
[pp. 1515-1516]
ll. We were the first company in
Bristol Bay to employ Eskimos as cannery
workers from the Bethel-Kuskokwim area.
In the 1970 season, however, we had a very
high rate of turnover. We found that many
of the Ekimoes [sic] that we hired that
year were not experienced (it was a very
heavy fishing year in Bristol Bay), did
not want to stay for the whole season, and
A-219
some even left before they went to work.
We were stuck for the cost of flying them
down from the Bethel area and for the cost
of flying them home even though they did
not work or [sic] all or only for a short
period of time.
12. Following this experience, we
decided not to hire from that area again.
We did develop the practice of employing
military personnel from the air force
base as temporary cannery workers during
periods of heavy production. They were a
mix of all races.
[p. 1516]
13. I could rarely get a local
resident (Bristol Bay) to have anything
to do with any job in the cannery. Once
in a while someone would agree to take a
tender to Egegik for me but most, if they
did take a job like that, would only last
a few days during the fishing season. On
A-220
the other hand, we frequently were able to
get local residents to work as spring and
fall laborers before and after the actual
fishing season.
[p. 1517]
17. Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 348. The
Native galley was referred to as such
Simply because the Natives ate there.
Nothing derogatory was intended. ...
* *
[p. 1517]
21. In about 1968, Local 37
objected to our plans to open one mess
hall for all employees. They insisted on
having their separate mess and Customary
style of food.
* *
CROSS EXAMINATION
[p. 1544]
BY MR. ARDITI:
A-221
Q. Mr. Leonardo, you recruited
applicants for the machinist job by word-
of-mouth is that correct?
A. Talked to them, yes.
A. And did you recruit applicants
for beachgang jobs, also, by word-of-
mouth?
A. Yes.
Q. And did you recruit applicants
for quality control jobs also by word-of-
mouth?
A. Yes.
Q. And, did you recruit applicants
for AFU culinary also by word-of-mouth?
A. Yes.
[pp. 1544-1548]
Q. Did you recruit by word-of-
mouth for all jobs, Mr. Leonardo?
A. All but thirty-seven, I didn't,
the foremen did that.
A-222
Q. So, the foremen recruited the
Local 37 workers?
A. Yes.
Q. And, you recruited by word-of-
mouth for all other jobs?
A. I think so, yes.
Q. Now, you also did some
recruiting by correspondence, didn't you?
A. Some.
Q. And some by telephone?
A. Whatever, yeah.
Q. Now, you never posted a vacancy
at the cannery, did you?
| A. Never, what?
Q. Posted a job vacancy at the
cannery?
A. No.
Q. And, you never advertised in a
newspaper or radio for a job vacancy, did
you?
A. No.
A-223
Q. And, in fact, it was your
preference to hire people whom you
recruited by word-of-mouth by telephone
or by mail, wasn't it?
A. Yes.
Q. That is true for machinist
A. Yes.
Q. Beachgang jobs?
A. Yes.
Q. For quality control jobs?
A. Yes.
Q. And for all jobs besides
cannery worker, is that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, you did not give any tests
for applicants for employment, did you?
A. No.
Q. At Bumble Bee, you hired some
tender cooks who did not have previous at-
sea experience, didn't you?
A. Yes, I had.
A-224
Q. And you hired some deckhands
who did not have previous sea experience?
A. Yes.
Q. And you also hired beachmen
without previous experience, didn't you?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, is it fair to say that in
your view, on the beachgang, all you
needed was a beach boss plus one or two
beachmen who know how to run wenches,
launch scows and run cranes?
A. Yes, it was more to it than
that, but --
Q. Now, in your affidavit, you
mention that in hiring for beachgang jobs
you wanted someone who was at least two
hundred pounds in weight, is that
correct?
A. That is a good figure.
Q. Do you know many Filipinos at
the cannery who appear to be two hundred
pounds in weight?
A-225
A. No.
Q. And most of those who appear to
meet that requirement were white, is that
correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, you did not require
everyone you hired to fill out a written
application, did you?
A. Well, most generally, I
wouldn't -- I don't know.
Q. Mr. Leonardo, can you tell me
how long there have been two mess halls at
South Naknek?
A. Ever since I have been there.
Q. And how long is that?
A. Thirty-one years.
Q. And has one also been for
cannery workers?
A. Yes.
Q. And the other has -- and has the
other been for other employeees?
A-226
A. Well, whatever. I had them
both ways.
Q. How long at South Naknek have
you housed cannery worker crews separate
from other crews?
A. State that question again.
Q. To your knowledge, how long at
South Naknek have cannery worker crews
been housed separated from other crews?
A. Well, as long as I have been
there.
Q. Now, beachmen work with the
tides sometimes, don't they?
A. Yes.
Q. And that means they unload fish
when the tide is in, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And they are housed with
Carpenters, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And carpenters prepare the
docks when the tide is out, correct?
A-227
A. Yes.
Q. So, they get up at different
times, is that correct?
A. I guess, yes.
Q. Now, are the culinary workers
for Local 37 housed with the cannery
workers?
A. I guess so, yes.
Q. Do the culinary workers have to
get up earlier than the cannery workers to
prepare breakfast?
A. Well, yes.
Q. Do the port engineers live with
machinists?
A. Yes.
Q. The port engineers have to get
up at odd hours, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. So their working times are not
necessarily the same as the other
machinsts, is that correct?
A. I guess, yes.
A-228
[1975 Dep., p. 3]
Q. You are currently employed by
Bumbie Bee Seafoods, a division of
Castle & Cook?
A. Right.
Q. In what capacity?
A. Cannery superintendent.
* *&
{1975 Dep., p. 20)
Q. Let me try to clarify the
question a bit. You stated that your
tendency is to prefer people whom you
recruit by word of mouth, by telephone, or
by mail because you know them or because
somebody has recommended them. Right?
A. Yes.
Q. This would be true for
machinists, right?
A. Yes.
Q. Would it be true for beachmen
as well?
A-229
A. Yes.
Q. Would it be true for quality
control?
A. Yes.
[1975 Dep., p. 21]
Q. Aside from cannery workers,
does this preference of people who have
been recruited over people who have
applied on a walk-in basis extend to all
job classifications?
A. Yes.
** *
[1975 Dep., pp. 58-59]
Q. The beachmen unload fish, is
that right?
A. Right.
Q. And when is their call-out time
generally?
A. Well, at all hours, depending
on the tides.
Q. They work with the tides then?
A-230
A. Yes.
Q. Now, the beachmen live with
carpenters. Is that right?
A. Yes.
Q. The carpenters don't work with
the tides, do they?
A. In some instances, yes.
Q. Why don't you state for the
record what you mean by working with the
tides?
A. If the carpenters were working
on the dock for some reason or other, why
they would have to wait for the tide to go
out.
Q. How about with regard to
beachmen?
A. Well, the beachmen have to
operate when the tide is coming in or high
Or going out.
Q. Well, the boats come in when
the tide is high, right?
A. Right.
A-231
Q. So they do unloading work when
the tide is high, right?
A. Yes.
Q. That's the time when the
Carpenters can't work on the docks,
right?
A. Yes, that's right.
Q. So all the unloading work that
the beachmen do is done at different hours
from the dock repair work that the
Carpenters do. Is that right?
A. Yes.
[1975 Dep., p. 60)
Q. Now, when carpenters aren't
working on the docks, they are working on
the buildings or the boats. Right?
A. Yes.
Q. They are not working with the
tides then, are they?
A. No.
A-232
[1975 Dep., pp. 60-61)
Q. Port engineers don't work in
operating the machinery inside the fish
house or the canning house, do they?
A. No, not in our place.
Q. But they are machinists, right?
A. They are in the machinists
contract.
Q. And they are housed with the
rest of the machinists, right?
A. Yes.
[1975 Dep., p. 63]
Q. So the salmon butchering
machinists would work the same hours as
the fish house cannery workers. Right?
You would start them a half-hour early,
right?
A. No, he probably would want to
be on the job earlier because the plant is
all electric; there are certain technical
switches that he has to pull and put the
A-233
generator plants on the line and stuff, so
he would come earlier than they would
even.
[1975 Dep., p. 64]
Q. But still, he would come at a
different time from the machinists who
worked the canning machines, right?
A. Yes.
Q. And that would be at a
different time from the time the port
engineers started work, right?
A. Well, port engineers are on a
different schedule.
* * *
[1975 Dep., pp. 65-66)
Q. The resident -- strike that.
The resident cannery workers work the
same hours as the non-resident cannery
workers, right?
A. Yes.
A-234
Q. Yet they are housed separately.
Is that right?
A. Yes.
Q. Where do the Local 37 culinary
personnel reside? Do they reside in the
Local 37 bunkhouse or elsewhere?
A. Yes.
Q. In the Local 37 bunkhouse?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, are the culinary workers
hours the same as the cannery workers?
A. No.
[1975 Dep., p. 73]
Q. Let me clarify again. At the
start of the canning season, do people
then move into those different bunkhouses
or do they stay in the same bunkhouses
they occupied in the pre-season period?
A. Some of them do.
Q. Some of them change bunkhouses?
A. Yes.
A-235
[1978 Dep., p. 2]
Q. Could you please state your
full name for the record?
A. Warner Leonardo, W-a-r-n-e-r
L-e-o-n-a-r-d-o.
Q. And are you still the cannery
superintendent at the Bumble Bee Cannery?
A. Yes.
[1978 Dep., p. 46]
Q. You don’t have any written job
qualifications at Bumble Bee, do you?
A. No.
Q. Have you ever had them?
A. No.
A-236
DISTRICT COURT
TESTIMONY OF DONALD E. WISE
[pp. 1688-89]
Q. Dr. Wise, would you refer to
Exhibit A-278 and turn to the Wards Cove
and Red Salmon tab, table four, which I
believe is the same as table two in your
affidavit.
A. Yes.
Q. So, now, were you the person
who set up these statistical tests shown
in this table?
A. Set them up may be a broad word.
Q. What was your involvement?
A. I have reviewed and designed
and prepared and interpreted the results
of these tests.
Q. Could you explain to the court
the number in the machinists column on the
same exhibit starting with BNML Critrow
(phonetic) down through CMPS or composite
A-237
deviation row and explain how those are
Calculated using that job family?
* * *
[p. 1695)
Q. So, in terms of determining
whether or not the hiring of machinist job
family at this particular group of
canneries was within two composite
standard deviations, if we look at CMPS-
DEV, row, composite deviation row--
A. That is correct.
Q. If that is in excess of one
point nine six po
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.