Joint Appendix — Wilson v. Seiter
Supreme Court brief1991
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
©)
No. 89-7376
In The
Supreme Court of the United..
October Term, 1990
3
PEARLY |. WILSON,
Petitioner,
vs.
RICHARD SEITER, et al.,
Respondents.
-
—
On Writ Of Certiorari To the United States
Court Of Appeals For The Sixth Circuit
A.
vv
JOINT APPENDIX
-.
-—
EvizABETH ALEXANDER* ANTHONY J. CELEBREZZE, JR.
Davip C. Farui Attorney General of Ohio
ALVIN J. BRONSTEIN Rita S. Eppver*
Mark J. Lopez Chief, Federal Litigation
National Prison Project Section
of the American Civil Steven W. Ritz
Liberties Union Assistant Attorney
Foundation General
1875 Connecticut Ave. State Office Tower
N.W., #410 26th floor
Washington, D.C. 20009 30 East Broad Street
Telephone: (202) 234-4830 Columbus, Ohio
Counsel for Petitioner 43266-0410
Telephone: (614) 466-5414
Gorpon J. Beccs Counsel for Respondents
Evinor R. ALGER
ACLU of Ohio Foundation
*Counsel of Record
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED MAY 2, 1990
CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 1, 1990
_
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO., (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
TABLE OF CONTENTS
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
AFFIDAVIT OF ROBERT L. CASSIDY
AFFIDAVIT OF RICHARD GRIFFIN
AFFIDAVIT OF PRINCE VINSON
AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL BOCK .............. desseeds
AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH E. KENNEDY
AFFIDAVIT OF PEARLY WILSON
AFFIDAVIT OF EVERETT HUNT, JR...............
AFFIDAVIT OF HOMER FRIEND
AFFIDAVIT OF JERRY PATTON
AFFIDAVIT OF PENNETT MANNING
ATTACHMENT TO AFFIDAVIT OF BENNETT MAN-
COURT OF APPEALS OPINION
COURT OF APPEALS JUDGMENT
ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE
UNITED STATES GRANTING CERTIORARI AND
LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS,
OCTOBER 1, 1990
ee ds ee ee ee ae ~
. ~<a = >
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
Wilson, et al., v. Seiter, et al.
No. C2-86-1046
United States District Court, Southern District of Ohio,
Eastern Division
8-28-86
8-28-86
8-28-86
8-28-86
8-28-86
11-10-86
4-16-87
5-18-87
5-18-87
5-26-87
2-24-88
3-2-88
Motion by plaintiffs to proceed in forma pau-
peris
Motion to proceed in forma pauperis granted
Complaint, summons issued
Amended complaint
Petition for appointment of counsel by plain-
tiffs
Plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment
Defendants’ cross-motion for summary judg-
ment
Order granting defendants’ cross-motion for
summary judgment, judgment for defendants,
action dismissed
Judgment entered
Motion of plaintiff Wilson for reconsideration
Order denying plaintiff Wilson’s motion for
reconsideration
Notice of appeal filed by plaintiff
Wilson, et al., v. Seiter, et all.
No. 88-3194
United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
3-7-88
1-16-90
Appeal docketed
Judgment affirmed
2
ICT COURT
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTR
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT
OF OHIO, EASTERN DIVISION
i Case No.
Pearly L. Wilson a enaae
™ FIRST AMENDED
Richard Seiter, et al. COMPLAINT
I. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
1. This is an action brought by two ener a
ing Correctional Facility at Nelsonville, ween: (hereina -
HCF) to redress the violations of plaintiff inmates, te
tutional rights under color of state law 0" authority.
These violations include the general conmanens * wa
finement, failure to implement an adequate areanenrsh c -
sification system, failure to install an adequate ~ a
system at HCF, failure to install an adequate non =
system at HCF, warehousing of inenaten, ee "1
plaintiffs, at HCF, in overcrowded dormitories, wat wage
tally ill inmates as well as with severely physica y
inmates while the Plaintiffs have no mentsl - ange
infirmities whatsoever. Defendant's practices eae ‘ e
Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United Sta u#
Constitution. Plaintiffs seek appropriate declaratory a nt
injunctive relief to correct these practices and My atl
compensate plaintiffs for physical and mental injury.
II. JURISDICTION
2. Jurisdiction is conferred on this Court by 28
U.S.C.A. Section 1343 (3) and (4) which give United States
3
District Courts original jurisdiction in suits brought pur-
suant to 42 U.S.C. Section 1983 to provide relief for the
deprivation of civil rights under the color of state law.
3. Jurisdiction is also conferred on this Court by 28
U.S.C.A. Section 1331, which gives United States District
Courts original jurisdiction in suits arising under the
Constitution in which the matter in controversy exceeds
ten thousand dollars. ($10,000.00), exclusive of interest
and costs. The amount here in controversy, exclusive of
interest and costs, exceeds $10,000.00. 2
4. Declaratory relief is authorized by 28 U.S.C. Sec-
tions 2201 and 2202 and Rule 57 of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure.
Ill. PARTIES
A. Plaintiffs
5. Plaintiff Pearly L. Wilson was convicted of a fel-
ony and now confined at HCF. Plaintiff Everett Hunt, Jr.
was convicted of a felony and is now confined at HCE
Both plaintiffs have suffered, and are presently suffering
under the conditions described in this action, and
attempted to improve these conditions by advising the
named defendants who, in turn, delegated their respon-
sibilities to employees under them, (the defendants
named herein). The delegated employees could not cor-
rect the violations complained of herein.
B. Defendants
6. Richard P. Seiter serves as Director of the Ohio
Department of Rehabilitation and Correction. In that
4
capacity and pursuant to Section 5120.01 of the Ohio
Revised Code, all functions and duties of all ——-
Officers within the Department are performed under is
control and pursuant to rules prescribed by him. 0 ¥
being sued in his official capacity and in his individu
capacity.
7. Carl Humphreys serves as the Managing cl
of the Hocking Correctional Facility, an institution ~
the Department’s jurisdiction. Pursuant to Section 51 :
of the Revised Code and in that capacity, Defendant e
Humphreys is responsible for the day-to-day puget
HCF. He is being sued in his official capacity and in his
individual capacity.
IV. STATEMENT OF FACTS
8. There are over 300 inmates at HCF, incarcerated
for felonies, etc. The original intended maximum ve saga
was 200. Inmates are now being double-bunked in al
three dormitories at HCF.
9. Inmates in “B” and “C” dormitories live with at
least 141 and 143 other inmates respectively so that -a
inmate has less that [sic] 50 square feet of space. Each “
the dormitories at HCF are seriously overcrowded.
Inmates are subjecied to cramped living space and exces-
sive noise levels which create hardships in reading, od
ing, and studying. No attempt is made to regulate t ‘
noise level of fans, heaters in winter months, and drop
ping of footlocker tops by inmates.
10. Inmates are provided a stand-up lecher and :
foot locker for their personal possessions. This amount 0
space is inadequate for keeping personal possessions;
especially for those inmates, such as the Plaintiffs, who
are serving lengthy sentences.
11. Inadequate heating in the winter months causes
many problems. The “C” Dormitory, for instance, reaches
nearly frigid temperatures. The clothing provided is not
sufficient to keep the plaintiffs warm during the winter
months.
12. Temperatures in summer months are excessively
high because of improper ventilation. Inmates have prob-
lems with heat-related rashes, and those with respiratory
deficiencies have difficulty breathing.
13. In each dormitory, the restrooms (toilets only)
are inadequately cleaned and retains germs and offensive
odors. The floor to these areas is slippery and always
dirty, and not fitted to be anti-skid.
14. In each of the dormitories there are four (4) long
sinks with three (3) spigots to each sink. These are used
for tooth-brushing, washing, shaving, and washing
clothes. These sinks are inadequately cleaned and retains
germs and offensive odors. The floor around these areas
are slippery and always dirty, and not fitted to be anti-
skid.
15. The shower-heads, Fourteen (14) in “C” Dormi-
tory, is the allotted showers for that Dormitory for 143
inmates.
16. There are twelve commodes and four urinals for
“C” dormitory. These commodes and urinals are usually
dirty and frequent accumulation of water around the
urinals and commodes creates offensive odors and germs.
C. Classification
17. Inmates at HCF are classified for either mini-
mum or medium custody pursuant to Rule 5120-9-52 & 53
of the Ohio Administrative Code. Assignment to individ-
ual dormitories, however, are based on no criteria or job
assignments. Rather than factors like seriousness of the
offense, length of sentence, nature of prior criminal con-
duct or other factors enumerated in Rule 5120-9-52, no
criteria is utilized. ini
y
?
D. Dining Room and Food F
18. The food services and facilities at HCF are a
serious threat to the physical well-being of the plaintiffs
as well as all other inmates. Offensive odors are a con-
stant problem due to poor and inadequate ventilation,
poor and inadequate sewage drainage, general filth and
unsanitary facilities. Inmates working in the dining room
are allowed to wipe tables with filthy rags and, this
happens during the meals when eaten by the inmates.
Glasses of milk are left open for lengthy periods of
time when the meals are served; although the milk dis-
penser is for the individual inmate to draw his own milk
when he walks through the dining room, there is always
an inmate assigned to draw the milk during the meals
which, the inmate assigned, always draws far too many
glasses of milk and leaves same sitting for flies and other
insects to mingle or drink from the glasses. These open
glasses of milk attract flies, roaches and vermin and, the
general filth and unsanitary cleaning in the dining room
contribute to patently offensive odors.
TE
19. Inmates serving and preparing meals do not
wear hair nets and do not have clean clothes or hands.
Often the food itself contains hair, bugs and other foreign
objects and is otherwise unsightly.
20. The plaintiffs have been subjected to less favor-
able living conditions, including less freedom, and,
because of the mentally ill and physicallv ill inmates at
HCF, a more dangerous environmert aia worse prison
conditions; have incurred mental and physical stress;
have lost property and unwritten seniority rights as a
result of being transferred from the Chillicothe Correc-
tional Institute at Chillicothe, Ohio, on May 16, 1983, and
have suffered a loss of human dignity.
V. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
21. Plaintiffs repeat and reallege paragraphs one
through twenty. Forcing the plaintiffs to live under the
totality of conditions existing at Hocking Correctional
Facility shocks the conscience and sense of decency of
this society. These conditions subjects plaintiffs to depri-
vations and restrictions which bear no reasonable rela-
tionship to and are not necessary to the achievement of
any legitimate corrective goals. By maintaining such prac-
tices and policies under color of state law, Defendants
Seiter and Humphreys have violated Plaintiffs’ Eighth
and Fourteenth Amendment rights to be free from the
imposition of cruel and unusual punishment.
VI. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
NEED FOR RELIEF
22. The policies and practices described in para-
graphs one through twenty of this Amended Complaint
have caused and are causing massive violations of basic
human rights embodied in the United States Constitution.
Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law. Plaintiffs are
being substantially harmed, irreparably harmed, by the
policies and practices of the Defendants. Plaintiffs will
continue to be irreparably harmed until relief prayed for
below is secured.
VII. DEMAND FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs ask this Honorable Court to:
1. Declare that the actions of Defendants have vio-
lated and are violating the Constitutional rights of Plain-
tiffs Wilson and Hunt.
2. Issue an injunction ordering Defendants to forth-
with discontinue the warehousing of mentally and physi-
cally iil inmates with the Plaintiffs.
3. Issue an injunction ordering Defendants to forth-
with bring living conditions and practices up to constitu-
tional standards, and to decrease the population at HCF
to proper capacity, and to provide the Plaintiffs with
more than 50 square feet of living space.
4. Award compensatory damages to each of the
Plaintiffs in the amount of three hundred thousand dol-
lars ($300,000.00).
5. Award punitive damages in the amount of six
hundred thousand dollars ($600,000.00) to eacn Plaintiff
in this Action.
6. Grant any other relief in law or equity that is just
and proper, including but not limited to costs and reason-
able attorney’s fees, above and beyond the compensatory
and punitive damages demanded as judgment against the
named Defendants.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Pearly L. Wilson
(PEARLY L. WILSON) #146-097
HOCKING CORRECTIONAL
FACILITY
POST OFFICE BOX 59
NELSONVILLE, OHIO 45764
Pro se.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Everett Hunt Jr
T, JR.) #125-268
HOCKING CORRECTIONAL
FACILITY
POST OFFICE BOX 59
NELSONVILLE, OHIO 45764
Pro se.
10
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT SUPPORTING CLAIMS
ALLEGED BY PLAINTIFFS PEARLY
WILSON AND EVERETT HUNT, JR.
I, /s/ Robert L. Cassidy, a citizen of the United
States and of legal age, herein make the following state-
ment in support of claims as raised in the lawsuit by the
Plaintiffs, Pearly Wilson and Everett Hunt, Jr.
The statement is of my own free will, and of my own
knowledge. I am competent to testify thereto.
I am a prisoner, an inmate situated within the State of
Ohio, and at the Hocking Correctional Facility at Nelson-
ville, Ohio. I have been confined therein at that Facility
(hereinafter “HCF”) since July 1985.
The conditions at HCF, to my own personal knowl-
edge are as follows:
1. The living areas are far too close in proximity to be
healthy. Being that the beds are less than three to four
feet (3-4) apart.
2. The ventilation is not adequate enough for proper
breathing at any time even with the windows open dur-
ing the summer months.
3. There are two large fans situated at the East and West
ends of C-Dormitory, but neither fan, singularly, or col-
lectively, are adequate enough to pull foul air out the
dormitory and, therefore, the oxygen within the dormi-
tory is not adequate for breathing at any time. In fact,
11
during the nights when every one is sleeping, the air
turns so foul that it will awaken most of the inmates and
in many cases cause these inmates to cough severally
because of the lack of adequate ventilation. Body odors
are rampant; dormitory cleaniness, and the lack of cleani-
ness is quite noticeable at all times. The air is stagnant.
4. Living space, such as the two (2) small lockers, is not
adequate for those of us inmates who are serving lengthy
sentences.
5. The prison officials have had a policy of housing both
mentally ill and two physically ill inmates in C-dormi-
tory. Many of the mentally ill inmates have most severe
problems. Being caused to (or forced) to live with such
prisoners causes stressful situations most times. It can
only be deemed a punishment which courts have not
imposed upon any particular inmate warehoused at HCF,
because some of the mentally ill inmates are psychotic
and, for my part, I do not know how to deal with any
given situation if one should arise. As I do not know just
how an angry psychotic inmate would act and, therefore,
I have to stay away from such men in the dormitory at
HCF whenever I am approached by one whom I would
deem a mentally ill prisoner.
6. It is a policy at HCF that inmates transferred to HCF
from another prison are assigned to the food service
department without proper physical examinations or
blood tests. Many of those inmates have lung diseases;
they cough over foods where they are assigned to serve
or prepare. Also, other inmates with lung diseases work
in the dishwashing area, or the kitchen area even though
12
they are not assigned to prepare any foodstuffs what-
soever. But such diseased prisoners are not supervised in
any capacity where it could safely be said that they are no
threat to the other prisoners’ health.
7. Cleaning equipment in C-Dormitory is not adequate;
nor is the space for storing such equipment sufficient or
clean, not with sufficient air to keep the foul odors to a
minimum.
8. The noise level, that is, with fans running, and the
general inmates’ noise during the day or night even when
sleeping, is far in excess of a proper level for a peaceful
situation; whatwith the coughing of diseased inmates and
the fans or heating equipment running.
9. C-Dormitory is a cold dormitory; it has damaged
windows; damaged walls and, in many places, cracked
walls where one can see right through the wall to the
street down below in the Nelsonville populace or city
proper; being that that city is situated to close to HCF.
10. In summer months the oxygen is just not there. One
must suffer severely hot living quarters at times up to
ninety-five (95) degrees temperature. I have been caused
to suffer such hot temperatures since I have been con-.
fined at HCF, and the small fans, used at the time, were
completely inadequate for ventilation.
11. The two (2) large exhaust fans currently situated in
the East and West ends of C-Dormitory were not installed
therein until July 23rd, and July 24th of 1986. The small
stand-up fan was then removed from C-Dormitory on
July 25th, 1986 and removed permanently.
13
12. Inmates are double-bunked at HCF in each dormi-
tory.
13. Clothing for summer and winter months are ragged
and inadequate. In fact, they claim not to have any under-
wear to issue to inmates at HCF.
14. Inmates being discharged from HCF are not pro-
vided proper clothing.
15. Inmates are allowed to wipe off tables in the dining
room with dirty rags. These rags are so filthy that one
with common sense would not permit same to be used for
any purpose in the food service areas.
16. Inmates with lung diseases and other physical
health problems are assigned to serve milk to other
inmates coming into the dining room. Many times the
milk sits out for long periods of time. I, too, have been
served milk by prisoners with severe lung diseases; I, too,
have observed milk sitting out open for long periods of
time.
17. The air circulation is completely inadequate in the
dining room at HCF during the summer months.
18. Fire exits are kept closed even during the hottest of
days or nights, and these exits are locked at all times,
except for a fire drill, even though there are “crash gates”
situated in proper spots and there is not even one threat
to security with the fire exits open.
19. I am aware of the pain and penalty for perjury and
that any false statement that I make in the within
14
affidavit will subject me to penalty for perjury under laws
of the United States.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
/s/ Robert L. Cassidy
(AFFIANT)
(Jurat Omitted In Printing]
15
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT
I, RICHARD GRIFFIN, a citizen of the United States and
of legal age, after first being duly cautioned and sworn to
my oath, depose and say that I make the following state-
ments in the within affidavit without expectation of gain
or compensation of any kind. And that I have personal
knowledge of the facts and circumstances regarding the
conditions at the Hocking Correctional Facility at Nelson-
ville, Ohio (hereinafter “HCF”); and that the statement |
make are [sic] true and correct and I am competent to
testify thereto. I am aware of the pain and penalty for
perjury and that I will be prosecuted for any false state-
ment that I make in this affidavit under the laws of the
Jnited States. I therefore state that:
1. I am a prisoner confined at HCF, and have been
confined at this Facility since May 1986. I am assigned to
C-Dormitory.
2. Inmates are mostly double-bunked at HCF. There are
at this time twenty-eight (28) single beds in C-Dormitory
out of a total of one hundred forty-three (143) beds
therein. Inmates in C-Dormitory have less than 50 square
feet of space in which to live and manuver [sic].
The dormitory is seriously over-crowded; as the beds
are closely situated. In fact, when we are sleeping at
night, we can and do smell other inmates’ body odors
because the air circulation is far below that required as
habitable.
16
3. Inmates at HCF are subjected to not only cramped
living quarters, but also, excessive noise levels created by
the exhaust fans, and heater circulation fans, and cough-
ing of other inmates caused mostly by the lack of ade-
quate oxygen/air in which to breathe. (Many inmates at
HCF have severe lung problems which cause them to
cough all during the nights and days.) These noise levels
create hardship in reading, writing, studying, sleeping or
resting. When the fans are running it is impossible under
the circumstances to regulate the noise level.
4. Inadequate heat in winter months causes C-Dormi-
tory to reach near frigid temperatures.
5. The clothing provided to inmates at HCF is not suffi-
cient to keep the men warm during winter months. Many
have to stay under their bed covers in order to stay half-
warm during the winter months.
6. We inmates are subjected to excessively high tem-
peratures during summer months because of total lack of
adequate or proper ventilation even with windows open.
During these months numerous inmates have heat-
related problems, and those inmates with respiratory
problems have difficulty breathing. Some men have fell
out because of exposure to excessive heat at HCE, and
had to be placed in the prison infirmary for treatment.
7. I/we are housed with many inmates which have
severe mental problems.
8. 1/we are housed with many inmates at HCF that have
severe medical problems such as open sores after major
operations. This is because there is insufficient room to
keep post-operative inmates in the infirmary, and they
17
must be returned to their respective dormitories almost
immediately after they are returned to HCF from outside
hospitals.
9. Inmates with lung diseases and severe respiratory
problems are assigned to the Food Service Department
without adequate physical examinations or blood tests,
prior to being assigned to the food service areas. Many of
these inmates are required to serve foods to other inmates
and, during service thereof, the men who have these lung
problems cough over the foods which they serve to
myself and to other inmates as they/we come through
the dining room during meals.
10. The urinals on C-Dormitory, and the commodes,
because of accumulations of urine around these aoeaat
tioned offensive odors and germs are created. Insufficient
amounts of disinfect and detergents are provided for
cleaning, and the procedures for cleaning are inadequate.
11. Asa whole the food services and facilities as stated
herein are a serious threat to the mental and physical
well-being of inmates at HCF.
12. Because of the cracks in walls, and the holes used as
prior ventilation outlets at HCF, insects are more than a
nuicance [sic] at HCF during the warm weather. L.e., not
only mosquitos [sic], but smaller insects and wasps and
yellow jackets as well.
13. Windows are damaged to the point that 90 percent
of these windows can not be opened nor closed unless the
Maintenance Department is called. During rainy days
and nights the windows cannot be closed and damp air is
18
the norm as result of failure to have such windows in
operable condition.
14. Inmates assigned to the dining room are allowed to
use filthy cloths for washing and wiping tables which
inmates eat on. Offensive odors are a constant problem in
the entire prison due to poor and inadequate ventilation.
15. Inmates in C-Dormitory have been required to hang
wet towels and face cloths at heads of their beds even
though there is insufficient ventilation to dry any cloth
materials under 8 to 10 hours and, as a result of this
requirement, very offensive odors are created not only in
and around these areas, but also on the inmates’ bodies
and the cloth materials.
16. Fire doors are kept closed and locked at all times at
HCF as exits from the dormitories even though there are
situated at various proper places wire “crash gates” of
heavy duty wire which cannot be bent without tools.
17. Floors in C-Dormitory are usually filthy and
unhealthy because of the lack of proper cleaning mate-
rials and are threats to inmates’ health and well-being.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
/s/ Richard Griffin
(Affiant)
(Jurat Omitted In Printing]
19
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT OF PRINCE VINSON
I, Prince Vinson, a citizen of the United States and of
legal age, being of sound mind and having personal
knowledge of the conditions under which I am at this
time being subjected by the prison officials at the Hock-
ing Correctional Facility at Nelsonville, Ohio (hereinafter
“HCF”) hereby make the following true and correct state-
ments regarding these conditions. However, I make these
statements without promise or expectation of monetary
gain or other, but with the true intention of attempting to
change all or most of these conditions under which I am
constantly required to live as a prisoner of the State of
Ohio at HCF. I therefore state:
1. I have been confined at HCF since December, 1984.
2. Iam seventy-seven (77) years old at this time, and am
physically ill.
3. The beds at HCF are far too close to be a healthfu!
situation. We inmates have less than 50 square feet o
living space.
4. Being closely situated, the body odors of other men
sleeping nearby can be smelled at night because of the
almost total lack of ventilation in C-Dormitory during hot
or warm weather even though there are now two (2) large
fans used for exhaust during those times as well as dur-
ing winter months.
20
5. The two large fans, one on each end of C-Dormitory,
are totally inadequate for ventilation, singularly or collec-
tively. During the nights, the air turns quite foul and, in
most Cases, Causes inmates to cough severely. Noises of
the coughs of inmates keeps most inmates awake during
the nights.
6. Iam furnished two (2) small lockers in which to keep
my personal property. Those lockers are not adequate for
me or other inmates who have lengthy sentences. I am
Serving a lengthy sentence.
7. The prison policy at HCF is that inmates transferred
to HCF from other prisons are usually assigned to the
Food Service Department without proper examinations or
blood tests. Many of these inmates have lung diseases but
are assigned to the For.’ Service Department any way.
They cough over the foods where they are assigned to
either prepare or serve. Other inmates work in the dish-
washing area. These diseased inmates are a serious threat
to my health as well as other inmates’ health.
8. C-Dormitory is a very cold dormitory during winter
months. There are severely damaged windows, walls, and
floor space which permits frigid air to enter into the
dormitory during winter months. No adequate clothing is
furnished inmates.
9 In C-Dormitory, | have been caused to suffer tempera-
tures as high as ninety-five (95) degrees since I have been
confined therein. The two large fans were installed in
C-Dormitory, as I recall, on or about July 23rd, and July
24th of 1986; one at each end of the dorm.
21
10. Inmates are double-bunked at HCF in all three dor-
mitories.
11. Inmates working in the dining room at HCF are
allowed to use filthy rags for wiping off tables where the
inmate population eats.
12. Fire exits are kept ciosed at all times, and locked,
except for fire drills even though there are “crash gates
properly situated to preverit escape. There is no threat to
security with the fire exits open during hot or warm
weather months.
13. Because of the proximity of the toilets and latrine
areas, one can smell the foul odors from urine, etc., ever
though these areas are cleaned daily.
I am aware of the pain and penalty for perjury. |
know that I can and will be prosecuted for any false
statement which I make in this Affidavit. The claims I
have made in this Affidavit are true and correct and of
my own personal knowledge and I am competent to
testify thereto. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
/s/ Prince Vinson
(PRINCE VINSON)
[Jurat Omitted In Printing]
—“—
—
22
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL BOCK
Inmate Prison Number 183-164
I, PAUL BOCK, a citizen of the United States and of
legal age, after first being duly cautioned and sworn to
my oath, depose and say that the claims, allegations, and
contentions I make in the within affidavit are true and
correct and of my own personal knowledge and I am
competent to testify thereto. Further, These claims I make
are of my own free will and not because of promise of
gain or expectation of gain or profit in any manner. I am
aware of the pain and penalty for perjury and know that
any false statement that I make in this affidavit will
subject me to penalties under United States law for per-
jury. I therefore state:
1. lama prisoner confined at the Hocking Correctional
Facility (“HCF”) at Nelsonville, Ohio. I have been con-
fined at HCF since April 17, 1985. I am assigned to
C-Dormitory, and have been so assigned to that dorm
since I have been at HCF.
2. There are a total of one hundred anf [sic] forty-three
(143) beds in C-dorm; twenty-eight (28) of these beds are
single; the rest are double-bunk beds.
3. We inmates at HCF have less than 50 square feet of
space in which to live and manuver [sic]; the dormitory is
seriously overcrowded; and the beds are far too close for
healthy living; being that many- of the inmates have
serious lung diseases and some have mental problems
23
which are also serious. When we sleep during warm
weather we can and do smell other inmates’ body odors.
4. We inmates are subjected to not only cramped living
spaces, but also excessive noises and the levels of which
creat [sic} hardship in reading, writing, studying, as well
as sleeping and resting. There is no attempt to regulate
the noise. nor has there ever been an attempt to regulate
the noise levels which comes from heat and exhaust fans.
5. Inmates are provided with two (2) small lockess at
HCF. These lockers are not adequate to store their per-
sonal possessions. These lockers are far too small for
reasonable living space when one is serving a lengthy
sentence. There is no other place at HCF for storing
personal possessions.
6. Inadequate heating, to which I have been cong one
during the cold and winter months mostly reach frigi
temperatures; I have been caused to suffer seriously due
to the dormitory being very cold and damp. Nor are we
inmates provided with clothes sufficient to ward off the
cold, damp air during winter months.
7. Many of the inmates have to stay under the blankets
on their beds in order to stay as warm as possible in the
dormitories. Heat is definitely not working in C-dorm
except in the center of the dorm by the toilet.
8. I have been exposed to temperatures as high as
ninety-five (95) degrees at HCF since I have been con-
fined therein. There has been inmates who have fell out
because of heat exhaustion; others have heat rashes, and
those with respiratory problems have difficulty just
breathing.
24
9. I/we are housed with inmates who have been
returned to HCF with open sores due to serious opera-
tions. These inmates are returned to their dormitory
because the Inmate Health Clinic is far too small to
accomodate [sic] recuperating space for inmates in the
Infirmary.
10. Inmates with lung diseases are assigned to the Food
Service Department even though they have not had phys-
ical examinations or blood tests. These inmates are rou-
tinely assigned to serve foods and do all the other job
assignments which is called for in the Food Service
Department.
11. I/we are housed with inmates who have severe and
psychotic problems.
12. Because of the frequent accumulations of urine
around the urinals in C-dorm, germs and offensive odors
are created. Insufficient amounts of detergent and other
cleaning materials are provided, and the procedures for
exterminating insects and mice are totally inadequate.
13. Inmates in the work areas of the dining room are
permitted to use filthy rags for cleaning tables off.
14. Ventilation in C-dormitory is not adequate; that
dorm carries foul air which we inmates are required to
breathe.
15. The walls and floors are cracked and frigid air
comes right through these walls during winter months.
Inmates are required to sleep with their heads toward the
windows, where the frigid air comes through.
16. Many inmates are required to use their blankets at
the head of their beds in order to stave off the frigid air.
25
Many times, the air is not only cold, but it is damp as
well.
17. Dormitories at HCF appear to be a good living area
for we prisoners; but the fact is, our health is in jeopardy,
being that we are required to live so close to each other
and breathe each other’s body odors and foul breaths
mostly during the nights.
18. Fire exist [sic] are kept closed and locked at all times
even though there are “crash gates” situated which will
prevent escapes, or access to outside areas.
19. The so-called “Unit Management” at HCF is a total
loss of time and does not assist inmates in any manner. In
fact, there are no qualified personnel to run Unit Manage-
ment at HCF or, if there are qualified personnel, they do
not assist inmates. Rather, they do more harm to the
inmates that [sic] good. No one takes responsibility; no
one knows what they should do in any given situation;
they always refer an inmate to another department
which, when so refered [sic], the inmates gets no results
favoring him. Unit Management is a sham and a mockery
to inmates.
20 Prison conditions at HCF involves the wanton and
unnecessary infliction of physical and mental pain and
stress upon myself and 1.:2ny other inmates at HCF. Such
punishment is grossly disproportionate with or to the
severity of the crimes warranting imprisonment. As I was
sent to prison as punishment. Not for punishment.
21. Not only have prison officials been advised of the
conditions which I complain of, they, in fact, have done
nothing to alleviate the problems.
26
22. Unit Management has been asking for more beds to
be placed in C-dorm. There is unavailable any room for
other beds therein. We are grossly overcrowded at this
time already. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT
/s/ Paul Bock
(PAUL BOCK)
(Jurat Omitted In Printing]
27
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT
I, JOSEPH E. KENNEDY, a citizen of the United
States and of legal age make the following statements in
the within Affidavit without any expectation of compen-
sation or promise of gain in any manner. I have personal
knowledge of the facts and circumstances of the condi-
tions at the Hocking Correctional Facility at Nelsonville,
Ohio (hereinafter “HCF”); and the statements I make
herein are true and correct, and I am competent to testify
thereto. I am aware of the pain and penalty for perjury
and know that any false statement I make herein will
subject me to penalty for perjury under the laws of the
United States. I therefore state that:
1. I have been confined at HCF as an Ohio prisoner
serving a sentence since April, 1986. I am assigned to
C-Dormitory.
2. Inmates are mostly double-bunked at HCF. However,
there are, at this time, only twenty-eight (28) single beds
in C-Dormitory; the rest of the beds are all double-bunks,
all of which total to one hundred and forty-three (143)
including the single beds therein.
3. Inmates in C-Dormitory at HCF have less than 50
square feet of space. The dormitory is seriously over-
crowded; and the beds are very closely situated so that,
when we sleep, we can smell the body odors of those
other inmates around us as they too, are sleeping.
28
4. We inmates at HCF are subjected to cramped living
space and excessive noise levels which create hardship in
reading, writing, studying, and sleeping or resting. There
is no attempt to regulate the noise level and, in fact,
because of the exhaust fans, and the heater circulating
fans, it is impossible to regulate the noise level in C-Dor-
mitory. Nevertheless, B-Dormitory is also under like cir-
cumstances insofar as these conditions are stated herein,
because that dorm is almost to the letter exactly like
C-Dormitory.
5. Inmates are provided two (2) small lockers for their
personal possessions. This amount of space is totally
inadequate for keeping possessions, and especially inade-
quate for inmates who are serving lengthy sentences.
There is no storage space elsewhere in HCF for safekeep-
ing of inmates’ personal possessions. None is forthcom-
ing; and none will be provided.
6. Inadequate heating in winter months causes C-Dor-
mitory to reach nearly frigid temperatures. The clothing
provided inmates at HCF is not sufficient to keep the
inmates warm during winter months. Many inmates have
to stay under their bed covers in order to stay warm
during the winter months.
7. Temperatures in summer months are excessively high
because of the .ack of proper and adequate ventilation.
Inmates have problems with heat rashes, or heat-related
rashes, and those with respiratory problems have diffi-
culty breathing. There has been instances where inmates
have fell out because of the excessive heat at HCF.
8. I/we are housed with inmates who have severe men-
tal problems; many of whom are, or may be psychotic
29
and in need of psychiatric and psychological treatment
which is not provided at HCF. At least not adequately.
9. I/we are housed with inmates at HCF who when
returned from major operations from various outside hos-
pitals, are placed in close proximity with us even though
these inmates have open sores, unclean bodies, and can-
not be cared for properly in the dormitories. They are
released from the Infirmary at HCF because there is a
total lack of space for inmates to recover from their
serious operations in the Infirmary.
10. Inmates who have serious lung diseases are even
assigned to the food service department at HCF. These
inmates are not given adequate physical examinations or
blood tests prior to being assigned to the food service
department. There are many instances that inmates who
have serious lung diseases, are assigned to serve foods to
inmates coming through the dining room, and those
inmates serving food are allowed to stand over such
foods and cough right over the foods.
11. Because of the frequent accumulation of urine
around the urinals and commodes, offensive odors are
created and germs. Insufficient amounts of detergent and
disinfect [sic] are provided for cleaning, and the pro-
cedures for exterminating bugs and the insects are totally
inadequate. As a whole, the food services and facilities as
herein stated create a serious threat to the mental and
physical well-being of the inmates, including myself at
HCF.
12. Inmates assigned to the dining room area are
allowed to use filthy rags to clean wastes off the dining
30
room tables. Offensive odors are a constant problem due
to poor and inadequate ventilation.
13. The dishwasher never adequately cleans trays or
silverware.
14. Inmates in C-Dormitory have been required to hang
wet towels and face cloths at the head of their beds to
dry. But, due to the total lack of proper ventilation, these
towels and face cloths do not dry under a period of eight
(8) to ten (10) hours and, therefore, being required to
hang same at heads of beds cause offensive odors not
only in the bed areas, but also on inmates’ bodies as well
at [sic] the cloth materials.
15. Ninety-nine (99) percent of the inmates housed at
HCF are well over fifty (50) years old. They are double-
bunked just as if they were well under thirty (30) years of
age, in similar circumstances.
16. I have been subjected to filthy air in C-Dormitory
due to a lack of proper ventilation even with the two (2)
huge exhaust fans placed in that Dormitory.
17. Windows in almost every area, and at least ninety
(90) percent of those windows are damaged to the point
that they can not be completely closed for the winter
months, not opened during summer months except by
the maintenance department.
18. The walls are cracked and the cold air comes right
on through to the dormitory with frigid temperatures.
19. When it rains, if a window is open, it cannot be
closed at night and beds are either wet, or damp air is the
result.
31
20. Dormitories at HCF appear to be a good living area
for prisoners; but the fact is their health is in more
jeopardy than one might understand with untrained
minds for the purpose of determining what is adequate
or proper to be habitable.
21. During warm weather insects are far too many in the
dormitories because of the totally opened areas that can-
not be closed.
22. Fire exits remain closed and locked at all times except
when a fire drill is held at HCF, even though there are
“crash gates” situated in proper places to prevent escapes
or access to other areas outside the dormitories.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
/s/ Joseph E. Kennedy
(Affiant)
{Jurat Omitted In Printing]
32
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT OF PEARLY WILSON
I, PEARLY WILSON, a citizen of the United States
and of legal age, make the following statement, present-
ing the material facts, personally known to me and I am
competent to testify thereto:
1. I ama prisoner incarcerated at the Hocking Cor-
rectional Facility (HCF) at Nelsonville, Ohio. I have been
confined at HCF since May 16, 1983.
2. I have been subjected to every inhumane, uncon-
stitutional punishment in violation of the Eighth Amend-
ment to the United States Constitution as set forth in my
original Complaint and First Amended Complaint and |
therefore incorporate, reallege and restate those same
claims as set forth therein. I have suffered both mental
and physical pain because of the named defendants’ acts,
under color of state law, or their failures to act when they
had been duly advised and notified that wrongful acts
were being heaped upon my person by their employees
and themselves as well.
3. I forwarded a letter to Defendant Richard P. Seiter
and Defendant Carl Humphreys, which consisted of three
(3) pages, complaining of the unconstitutional conditions
of confinement to which they, the defendants, were sub-
jecting me to. That letter was dated July 8, 1986. (Exhibit
Number 1, attached hereto).
3(a). At no time did Defendant Seiter respond to the
complaints listed in my letter dated July 8, 1986, and
33
forwarded to him by certified letter Number P 678 on
646, received and signed for by Defendant Seiter’s receiv-
ing agent, R. Campbell on July 14, 1986. (Exhibit Numbe~
2)
3(b). Defendant Humphreys responded by letter dated
July 14, 1986; but failed to take any responsible action to
alleviate or correct the constitutional violations com-
plained of by me and Plaintiff, Everett Hunt, Jr. Defen-
dant Humphreys referred a copy of my letter to Mr.
Freind [sic], HCF Unit Manager, and his staff. Mr. Freind
[sic] could not, and did not take any action to alleviate or
correct the constitutional violations as complained of, nor
did any member of his staff. In fact, neither Mr. Freind
[sic] or his staff has any power to correct the violations.
(See Exhibit Number 3, certified letter receipt to defen-
dant Humphreys), signed for by Melissa J. Purch, (Defen-
dant Humphrey’s receiving agent at HCF).
4. I have suffered mental pain because of the filth to
which I have been subjected at HCF in the dining room
during mealtimes, such as has been complained of in my
original Complaint and Amended Complaint. In fact, It
has been impossible for me to go to the dining room three
(3) times daily for meals because of the filth to which |
have been subjected and the diseased inmates assigned to
prepare the foods for feeding to inmate population. I
have a fear of contacting a communicable disease from
eating such foods, etc. I still suffer mental pain.
5. I have been subjected to, and still being subjected to
frigid air in C-dorm at HCF because of inadequate heat in
the dorm, and it has been like thus since May 16, 1983. I
have suffered mental and physical pain because of the
34
cold, frigid temperatured air in C-dormitory, and still
suffer same at this time during cold weather.
6. George Sideris, #189-358, was taken to an outside
hospital from HCF as a result of contacting pneumonia
due to the frigid air in C-dorm, on October 27, 1986. He
was then returned subsequently; and, again, returned to
an outside hospital on November 1, 1986, because of
problems with his contracted pneumonia.
7. I have been subjected to very high temperatures at
HCF since being incarcerated there and, at times, tem-
peratures as high as ninety-five (95) degrees.
8. I have been, and am still being, warehoused with
mentally ill inmates at HCF.
9. Ventilation is totally inadequate for a healthy envi-
ronmate [sic] at HCF, and I have been subjected to that
unhealthy environment since May 16, 1983 or there-
abouts . . . such as smelling other inmates’ body odors;
smelling the foul air and odors from men with colostomy
bags housed in C-dorm; smelling the foul odors caused
by the toilets and urinals situated in C-dorm; being situ-
ated far too close to other beds, far too close for a health-
ful situation; noises coming from heat and exhaust fans in
C-dorm; being subjected to so-called “Unit Management”
personnel who have no actual qualifications and cannot
assist inmates in any manner. Or, if Unit Management
personnel are qualified, they refuse or fail to assist
inmates; choosing to refer inmates to other departments
instead of being able to handle the problems they are
faced with by inmates. In fact,
35
10. Unit Management personnel have requested more
beds be placed in C-dorm even though C-dorm is already
overcrowded., and,
11. Even though the ventilation is totally —
Unit Management has even requested that agua ; e
installed in C-dorm; knowing well that with cu =
installed, the ventilation will be next to zero if not tota y
zero and unhealthy for the inmates as confined therein, as
it has been all along.
12. Even though C-dorm appears to be clean, it is not.
13. We inmates are subjected to insects and on A
bugs at HCF, such as wasps and yellow jackets; roac a
mice. Extermination is totally inadequate. Mosquitos a
spiders are rampant at HCF because of the many, a od
cracked walls, floors, and open areas of doors, etc.,
well as the huge fans used for exhaust in the dormitories,
and their open areas, without lubbers.
14. I am aware of the pain and penalty for perjury a
that any false statement I make in thia [sic] ngoange 0
subject me to penalty for perjury under the laws .
United States Constitution and the statutes thereof.
oe
/s/ Pearly Wilson
(Affiant)
[Certificate Of Service Omitted In Printing]
36
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
AFFIDAVIT OF EVERETT HUNT, JR.
I, EVERETT HUNT, JR, a citizen of the United States
and of legal age, make the following statement, present-
ing the material facts, personally known to me and | am
competent to testify thereto:
1. I ama prisoner incarcerated at the Hocking Cor-
recticnal Facility (HCF) at Nelsonville, Ohio. I have been
confined at HCF since May 16, 1983.
2. I have been subjected to every inhumane, uncon-
stitutional punishment in violation of the Eighth Amend-
ment to the United States Constitution as set forth in my
original Complaint and First Amended Complaint and |
therefore incorporate, reallege and restate those same
claims as set forth therein. I have suffered both mental
and physical pain because of the named defendants’ acts,
under color of state law, or their failures to act when they
had been duly advised and notified that wrongful acts
were being heaped upon my person by their employees
and themselves as well.
3. I forwarded a letter to Defendant Carl E. Hump-
hreys and Defendant Richard P. Seiter, which consisted of
three (3) pages, complaining of the unconstitutional con-
ditions of confinement to which they, the defendants,
were subjecting me to. That letter was dated July 13, 1986.
3(a). At no time did Defendant Seiter respond to the
complaints listed in my letter dated July 13, 1986.
37
3(b). Defendant Humphreys responded by letter dated
July 15, 1986; but neglected to take any responsible action
to alleviate or correct the constitutional violations com-
plained of by me and Plaintiff, Pearly Wilson. Defendant
Humphreys referred a copy of my letter to Mr. Friend,
HCF Unit Manager, and his staff. Mr. Friend could not,
and did not take any action to alleviate or correct the
constit .tional violations as complained of, nor did any
member of his staff. In fact, neither Mr. Friend cr his staff
has any power to correct the violations.
4. I have suffered mental pain because of the filth to
which I have been subjected at HCF in the dining room
during mealtimes, such as has been complained of in my
original Complaint and Amended Complaint. In fact, it
has been impossible for me to go to the dining room three
(3) times daily for meals because of the filth to which I
have been subjected and the diseased inmates assigned to
vrepare the food for feeding the inmate population. |
have a terrible fear of contacting a communicable disease
from eating such food, etc. I still suffer mental pain.
5. I have been subjected to, and still being subjected to
frigid air in B-dorm at HCF because of inadequate heat in
the dorm, and it has been like this since May 16, 1983. I
have suffered mental and physical pain because of the
cold, frigid temperatured air in B-dormitory, and still
suffer same at this time during cold weather.
6. George Sideris, #189-358, was taken to an outside
hospital from HCF as a result of contacting pneumonia
due tc the frigid air in C-dorm, on October 27, 1986. He
was then returned subsequently; and, again, returned to
38
an outside hospital on November 1, 1986, because of
problems with his contracted pneumonia.
7. I have been subjected to very high temperatures at
HCF since being confined here and, at times, tempera-
tures as high as ninety-four (94) degrees.
8. I have been, and am still being, warehoused with
mentally ill inmates at HCF.
9. Ventilation is totally inadequate for a healthy envi-
ronment at HCF, and I have been subjected to that
unhealthy environment since May 16, 1983 or thereabout
... such as smelling other inmates’ body odors; smelling
the foul air and odors from men with colostomy bags
housed in B-dor: ': smelling the foul odors caused by the
toilets and urinals situated in B-dorm; being situated far
too close to other beds, far too close for a healthful
situation; noises coming from heat and exhaust fans in
B-dorm; being subjected to so-called “Unit Management”
personnel who have no actual qualifications and cannot
assist inmates in any manner. Or, if Unit Management
personnel are qualified, they refuse or fail to assist
inmates; choosing to refer inmates to other departments
instead of being able to handle the problems they are
faced with by inmates. In fact,
10. Unit Management personnel have requested more
beds be placed in B-dorm even though B-dorm is already
overcrowded., and,
11. Even though the ventilation is totally inadequate,
Unit Management has even reqvested that cubicles be
installed in B-dorm; knowing well that with cubicles
installed, the ventilation will be next to zero if not totally
39
zero and unhealthy for the inmates as confined therein, as
it has been all along.
12. Even though B-dorm appears to be clean, it is not.
13. We inmates are subjected to insects and dangerous
bugs at HCF, such as wasps and yellow jackets; roaches;
and mice. Extermination is totally inadequate. Mosquitos
and spiders are rampant at HCF because of the many,
many cracked walls, floors, and open areas of doors, etc.,
as well as the huge fans used for exhaust in the dormito-
ries, and their open areas, without lubbers.
14. I am aware of the pain and penalty for perjury and
that any false statement I make in this Affidavit will
subject me to penaliy for perjury under the laws of the
United States Constitution and the statutes thereof.
DATED: November 6, 1986
/s/ Everett Hunt, Jr.
Affiant
[Certificate Of Service Omitted In Printing]
40
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
STATE OF OHIO ;: &
: AFFIDAVIT OF
COUNTY OF HOCKING : HOMER FRIEND
I, Homer Friend, being first duly sworn, hereby state
that I have personal knowledge of all the facts contained
in this Affidavit, that I am competent to testify to the
matters stated herein and that the following is true to the
best of my knowledge and belief.
1. I am the Unit Manager at the Hocking Correc-
tional Facility.
2. I have been employed at the Hocking Correc-
tional Facility since 1983 when it was initially opened as a
correctional facility.
3. I am personally familiar with the conditions of
confinement at HCF since 1983.
4. There are currently 327 inmates at HCF, with 141
and 143 inmates housed in two large dormitories, and 46
housed in the honor dormitory.
5. Because inmates are housed in open dormitories,
special measures are taken to keep down the noise level:
1) radios are only permitted with earphones; 2) no televi-
sions are permitted in the dormitory; 3) a special televi-
sion room is separate from the dormitory; 4) dormitory
rules prohibit excessive noise; and 5) guards are
instructed to keep down noise.
41
6. Each inmate is given one foot locker and one wall
locker.
7. There have been very few complaints about the
amount of storage space, and it appears to be adequate
for most inmates.
8. The heaters have been recently serviced, and they
are in good working order.
9. The dormitories are adequately heated during the
winter.
10. Inmates are not given special winter clothes
unless they have jobs which require them to be outside.
11. Inmates are permitted to buy winter clothing to
wear such as long underwear.
12. Inmates are given an extra blanket in the winter.
13. Two large exhaust fans have been installed in
each dormitory to increase ventilation and keep down the
heat in the summer.
14. The majority of windows are in working order,
and they are opened in the summer.
15. The restrooms are completely cleaned twice per
day, and porters clean them throughout each day as
needed.
16. The kitchen area and dining room are cleaned
after every meal.
17. There are currently 57 inmates who work in the
kitchen and make sure that it is clean and sanitary.
18. The kitchen and dining areas are kept very clean
every day.
42
19. HCF has contracted with an exterminator, Wells
Pest Control, and the institution is exterminated twice per
month.
20. Inmates who work around food have to wear
hats to keep hair out of food, and they are required to
wear plastic gloves.
21. Every inmate is given a health screening during
his initial reception into the prison system, and inmates
are examined when they enter HCF.
22. Since HCF opened in 1983, there have been no
outbreaks of contagious diseases.
23. Inmates with mental illness problems are sent
out of HCF to either Oakwood Forensic Center or the
Techumseh Program at Chillicothe Correctional Institute.
24. Mentally ill inmates are not “warehoused” at
HCF.
25. Because there is an older population at HCF,
some inmates have age-related health problems.
26. Physically ill inmates are not “warehoused” at
HCF, but the Department does place older inmates within
the system at HCF for their own safety among other
reasons.
/s/ Homer Friend
[Jurat Omitted In Printing]
43
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
STATE OF OHIO ae
: AFFIDAVIT OF
COUNTY OF HOCKING : JERRY PATTON
I, Jerry Patton, being first duly sworn, hereby state
that I have personal knowledge of all the facts contained
in this Affidavit, that I am competent to testify to the
matters stated herein, and that the following is true to the
best of my knowledge and belief.
1. I am the Health Care Administrator at Hocking
Correctional Facility (HCF).
2. All inmates confined at this institution were med-
ically examined upon their reception in the Ohio prison
system.
3. The initial medical examination including check-
ing the inmates for contagious diseases such as tuber-
culosis, hepatitus [sic], etc.
4. Based upon the initial medical screenings of the
inmates, I can state that there are no inmates at HCF with
active contagious diseases that can be transmitted.
5. There have been no outbreaks of contagious dis-
eases at HCF since it was converted into a prison in 1983.
6. With regard to the food service, inmates and
prison employees eat the same food prepared in the same
kitchen.
44
7. The health clinic at HCF has had no cases of food
poisoning such as Salmonella or Botulism.
8. When floors are cleaned at HCF, signs are put up
to indicate that the floors are wet and to use caution.
9. With regard to heat in the summer, there are no
medical records of any inmates being overcome by heat.
10. In the winter, the number of colds and cold-
related diseases is no higher than normal for inmates in
this age group.
11. I have reviewed the medical file for Pearly
Wilson and find that he has only been treated for routine
health problems since 1983.
12. Inmate Wilson has complained of cold symp-
toms on two occasions since 1983, and both times he was
treated with over-the-counter medications.
13. I have reviewed the medical file for Everett
Hunt, Jr., and find that he has only been treated for
rou:ine health problems since 1983.
14. Inmate Hunt has complained of cold symptoms
on twelve occasions since 1983, but he only required
treatment with over-the-counter medications on every
occasion.
Further, affiant sayeth not.
/s/ ERR Patton _
(Jurat Omitted In Printing]
45
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
STATE OF OHIO :
: AFFIDAVIT OF
COUNTY OF FRANKLIN * Boao Nc
I, Bennett Manning, being first duly sworn, hereby
state that I have personal knowledge of all the facts
contained in this Affidavit, that I am competent to testify
to the matters stated herein.
1. I am an attorney practicing with a private law
firm in Columbus, Ohio.
2. In October, 1986, I was employed as staff counsel
for the Ohio Judicial Conference.
3. On October 23, 1986, I toured the Hocking Cor-
rectional Facility with Assistant Attorney General Fre-
derick Schoch.
4. I toured the institution to prepare an article for
“Judicial Notice”, a newsletter distributed to all Ohio
judges.
5. Based upon my personal observations of the
Hocking Correctional Facility, | prepared the article.
6. Acopy of the article which I prepared is attached
to this Affidavit.
7. The article has not yet been published in “Judicial
Notice”.
46
8. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the arti-
cle gives a true and accurate account of what I observed
in my tour of Hocking Correctional Facility.
Further affiant sayeth not.
/s/ Bennett Manning
BENNETT MANNING
[Jurat Omitted In Printing]
47
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
HOCKING CORRECTIONAL FACILITY TOUR
By: Bennett A. Manning
Last week I had the opportunity to tour the Hocking
Correctional Facility at Nelsonville, Ohio. The facility, a
former tuberculosis hospital built in 1956 and converted
to a medium security prison in 1980, houses about 300
male inmates in three “dorms” or floors. I was the guest
of a lawyer from the Ohio Attorney General’s Office
investigating a complaint filed by one of the inmates
dealing with “conditions” existing at the facility.
All visitors must empty their pockets and walk
through a metal detector before being admitted to the
prison. The contents of all visitors’ pockets are inspected.
(I had a cassette tape in my coat pocket, and the guards
refused to let me take it inside the prison. “What would
you want to smuggle a tape in for?” one asked me. The
tape was returned after the tour. I don’t know if they
played it or not; if they did, they heard Rickie Lee Jones’
first album and some cuts from the Broadway musical
“New York, New York.”)
The prison itself seemed reasonably secure — the
locks were large and the wire mesh heavy on all gates,
and the facility was surrounded by twelve foot wire mesh
fences laced with a high-tech version of barbed wire
called “razor wire.” I looked at the stuff pretty closely,
and those barbs really are like razor blades. Our guide
told us that once someone gets entangled in the stuff they
have to be cut out or the situation just gets worse. There
48
have only been three escapes from Hocking Correctional
since the facility opened: one inmate escaped in a laundry
truck and two more placed blankets over the razor wire
and climbed a fence before the fences were raised from
eight to twelve feet.
Once inside, I was immediately struck by how clean
the facility was and by how much freedom the inmates
had within the facility. The first room we were shown
was the prison visitation room, which exhibited both of
these features. Far from the wire cages, bulletproof glass
and tiny windows I expected, the visitation room was an
open area that looked like a snack lounge at a high school
or (not surprisingly) a hospital. The door to the room was
open and inmates appeared to be free to associate with
visitors and each other once inside. There were vending
machines along one wall and a number of card-table-
sized tables. The wall opposite the vending machines
featured large windows which overlooked a small court-
yard. Four people (an inmate and his visitors, I presume)
were using one of the tables to play cards. The tile floor
was aging but spotless.
Speaking of age, the average age of an inmate at
Hocking Correctional is 45 years old. Eligibility to be
placed in a medium security facility such as Hocking is
based on a rating system which assigns point values to
certain prisoner attributes such as age, prior record,
whether the prisoner is likely to commit further offenses,
and so forth. Prisoners whose point totals are in a certa.
range are declared to be “medium security” material. Our
guide was tinable to tell me what kinds of crimes Hock-
ing inmates had committed, but the lawyer from the
49
attorney general's office recognized one individual whom
he knew had been found guilty of embezzling.
The dorms where the inmates sleep are nothing more
than huge rooms with long rows of bunk beds placed
about three feet apart. Each inmate gets two “lockers” to
stow personal possessions; one is a trunk placed near the
foot of each bunk and the other is a more conventional
high-school type locker, except much shorter - about
three feet high. Inmates are permitted to have radios with
earphones in the dorm area, but not televisions. Sink,
toilet and shower facilities are located along one wall of
each dorm. A three foot half-wall separates the shower/
restroom area from the sleeping area. Again, everything
was very clean and well kept up.
Inmates are awakened each day by a buzzer at 6:00
AM. The buzzer also sounds at several predetermined
intervals throughout the day for “count.” Inmates must
report to their bunks at these times so prison officials can
keep track of them. Otherwise, the inmates are left to
their own devices. Activities include watching T.V. (yes,
they have cable - with HBO), taking exercise in the gym
or yard, using the pool (as in billiards, not swimming)
and weight room and reading in the prison library. About
100 Hocking inmates are involved in continuing educa-
tion classes supervised by a prison director of education.
These and other privileges available to the inmates
are used as “carrots” to keep them on their best behavior.
This incentive system is useful because it makes inmates
feel like there’s something in it for them if they obey the
rules and don’t cause trouble. Before a privilege is taken
away, the inmate involved may request a “trial” held
50
before three prison officials at which each side is allowed
to present its case. There are five “solitary confinement”
cells for severe discipline problems.
A recent innovation at Hocking is a so-called “unit
management” system, designed to help solve inmate
problems and deal with inmate complaints at an individ-
ual instead of an institutional level. Each dorm is staffed
with three professionals, including a case manager (socia!
worker) and a prison official. These professionals are
available to consult with inmates, without appointment,
for about twelve hours every day, including Saturday and
Sunday. Inmates are encouraged to bring all kinds of
pzoblems to the unit staff, whether of a personal or insti-
tutional nature. The idea is to provide immediate atten-
tion to inmate concerns, thus preventing little problems
from smoldering until they become big ones. Previously,
inmates with problems had to file a complaint or make an
appointment which might not bring results for days or
weeks.
For example, under the old system, one inmate com-
plained that his shoes didn’t fit properly. It took a weel:
to go through the proper channels and get a pair of shoes
that fit. That might not seem like a big problem, our
guide told us, “but if you were given a pair of shoes that
didn’t fit, you’d be pretty mad; and if you had to wait a
week to get shoes that did fit, you’d be pretty mad about
that, too.” Under unit management, these types of prob-
lems will in theory be remedied more quickly. (Often,
things that aren’t perceived as big probiems by the prison
staff are big problems to the inmates.)
51
Prison officials told us that unit management, which
has been used succes fully in the federal prison system
for years, has been initially almost too successful at Hock-
ing; inmates, they said, “are in there [the unit manage-
ment office] all the time” to lodge trivial or insignificant
complaints. Officials hope that the number of complaints
will decrease once the novelty of the new system wears
off.
What trip to a prison would be complete without
sampling the food? We stayed for lunch, which is the big
meal of the day. For 85¢, we got chicken fried steak (a '/s"
piece of meat (beef, I think) dipped in batter and fried in
chicken fat; it tasted terrible), mashed potatoes with
gravy (OK as instant potatoes go), cooked cabbage (I
didn’t eat any, but it looked alright), three bean salad (out
of a can, tasted fine), two slices of bread with butter,
vanilla pudding (very tasty) and coffee or milk. The
portions were more than generous. A restaurant critic
would have panned the meal so fast it wouldn’t have
time to cool off, but this isn’t the Maisonette . . . or even
Howard Johnson’s, for that matter. Put it this way: you
could survive on the food, but I wouldn’t try to get
locked up so I could eat it on a regular basis.
What does all this have to do with Ohio judges. Just
this: Since the Revised Code usually allows broad discre-
tion in sentencing guilty defendants, it is important to
know what kind of facility you are sentencing defendants
to. Only then can available discretion be used most effec-
tively. Judges should therefore strive to become familiar
with the various detention facilities both within their
jurisdiction and around the state. Further, this familiarity
should be renewed on a regular basis, because conditions
52
and facilities change. (For example, within the next year
Hocking Correctional will be expanding to accommodate
more inmates and will receive a new heating system.)
Of course, this is not meant to imply that you ought
to knock two years off (or add two years to) a sentence
based on the quality of the food served at a particular
institution, or that conditions at some or all of our prisons
violate constitutional prohibitions against cruel and
unusual punishment, but knowledge of prison conditions
could be helpful in a number of sentencing situations. For
example, if you are considering granting a motion for
shock probation with respect to a particular defendant, it
would be helpful to know what kind of “prison experi-
ence” the defendant will be subjected to prior to release.
Youthful or older offenders may be better suited to some
types of prison environments than others. Some detention
facilities are nore secure, or have better medical facilities,
or are cleaner, or more crowded, or better staffed, or more
accommodating to visitors than others.
In other words, it behooves any responsible judge to
have at least some idea about the type of confinement to
which he or she is sentencing people. Most prison offi-
cials wiil gladly permit you to inspect their facilities if
given proper notice. These opportunities should not be
wasted.
53
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
OPINION AND ORDER
Plaintiffs, Pearly Wilson and Everett Hunt, Jr., are
- prisoners at the Hocking Correctional Facility (HCF).
They bring this action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §1983 claim-
ing that the conditions of confinement at HCF deny them
their constitutional rights in violation of the Eighth and
the Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Consti-
tution. This matter is before the Court on defendants’
motion for summary judgment.
Plaintiffs allege cruel and unusual punishment due to
the general conditions of confinement, failure to
implement an adequate inmates’ classification
system, failure to install an adequate ventilation
system at HCF, failure to install an adequate
heating system at HCF, warehousing of inmates,
including the plaintiffs, at HCF, in overcrowded
dormitories, with mentally ill inmates as well as
with severely physically ill inmates while the
Plaintiffs have no mental or physical infirmities
whatsoever.
(Amended Complaint). Specifically, plaintiffs claim that
they are housed in an overcrowded facility with inade-
quate space for storage of personal possessions, inade-
quate heating in the winter, improper ventilation all year,
and unsanitary restroom, shower and sink areas. Plain-
tiffs allege that no criteria is utilized in assigning inmates
to dormitories. Plaintiffs claim that the food services and
ill
—
54
facilities are health hazards due to inadequate ventila-
tion, sewage drainage, improper maintenance pro-
cedures, and unsanitary practices and procedures.
Plaintiffs claim that as a result of being subjected to
such conditions of confinement they have and do suffer
both mental and physical stress and have lost unwritten
seniority rights.
Defendants move for summary judgment on the
ground that plaintiffs are provided with the minimal
civilized measure of life’s necessities as required by
Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S. 337, 347 (1981). Defendants
offer as support for their motion the affidavits of Homer
Friend, Unit Manger at HCF, Jerry Patton, Health Care
Administrator at HCF, and Bennett Manning, staff coun-
sel for the Ohio Judicial Conference.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(c) provides:
The judgment sought shall be rendered forth-
with if the pleadings, depositions, answers to
interrogatories, and admissions on file, together
with the affidavits, if any, show that there is no
genuine issue as to any material fact and that
the moving party is entitled to judgment as a
matter of law.
“[T]his standard provides that the mere existence of some
alleged factual dispute between the parties will not defeat
an otherwise properly supported motion for summary
judgment; the requirement is that there be no genuine
issue of material fact.” Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 54
U.S.L.W. 4755, 4757 (June 25, 1986) (No 84-1602)
(emphasis in original); Kendall v. The Hoover Co., 751 F.2d
171, 174 (6th Cir. 1984).
55
The purpose of the procedure is not to resolve factual
issues, but to determine if there are genuine issues of fact
to be tried. Lashlee v. Sumner, 570 F.2d 107, 111 (6th Cir.
1978). Therefore, summary judgment will be granted
“only where the moving party is entitled to judgment as a
matter of law, where it is quite clear what the truth
is, . . . [and where] no genuine issue remains for
trial, . . . [for] the purpose of the rule is not to cut litigants
off from their right of trial by jury if they really have
issues to try.” Poller v. Columbia Broadcasting Systems, Inc.,
368 U.S 464, 467 (1962); accord, County of Oakland v. City of
Berkley, 742 F.2d 289, 297 (6th Cir. 1984).
In a motion for summary judgment the moving party
bears the “burden of showing the absence of a genuine
issue as to any material fact, and for these purposes, the
[evidence submitted] must be viewed in the light most
favorable to the opposing party.” Adickes v. S.H. Kress &
Co., 398 U.S. 144, 157 (1970) (footnote omitted); accord,
Adams v. Union Carbide Corp., 737 F.2d 1453, 1455-56 (6th
Cir. 1984), cert. denied, 469 U.S. 1062, (1985).
As we noted in our Order of February 20, 1987, the
Eighth Amendment prohibits cruel and unsual [sic] pun-
ishment. “The Amendment embodies broad and idealistic
concepts of dignity, civilized standards, humanity and
decency . . . We have held repugnant to the Eighth
Amendment punishments which are incompatible with
‘the evolving society.’ ” Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 102;
see, Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S., at 346 (1981); Grubbs v.
Bradley, 552 F. Supp. 1052, 1120 (M.D. Tenn. 1982). The
Eighth Amendment requires that a State furnish inmates
with reasonably adequate food, clothing, shelter, sanita-
tion, medical care and personal safety. See, Newman v.
56
Alabama, 559 F.2d 283, 291 (Sth Cir. 1977), cert. denied, 438
U.S. 915 (1978); Ramos v. Lamm, 639 F.2d 559 (10th Cir.
1980), cert. denied, 450 U.S. 1041 (1981); Grubbs v. Bradley,
552 FSupp., at 1122. Conditions of confinement must be
contrary to “evolving standards of decency” before they
violate the Eighth Amendment. Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86,
101 (1957)(plurality opinion). Although “conditions
which standing alone would not be cruel or unusual,
might become so when viewed in the context of the total
prison environment,” it remains the case that “unless
there are conditions that, considered either alone or in
combination, specifically amount to cruel and unusual
punishment, there can be no Eighth Amendment viola-
tion.” Grubbs v. Bradley, 552 FSupp. at 1122. Eighth
Amendment requirements are met if prisoners are pro-
vided with a minimal civilized measure of life’s necessi-
ties. Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S., at 347. “It is obduracy
and wantonness, not inadvertence or error in good faith,
that characterize the conduct prohibited by the Cruel and
Unusual Punishments Clause . . . ” Whitley v. Albers, 54
U.S.L.W. 4236, 4239 (U.S. March 4, 1986) (No. 84-1077).
With this standard in mind, and after a thorough
review of the record presented to the Court, including the
affidavits of Homer Friend, Bennett Manning, and Jerry
Patton, we HOLD that the conditions of which plaintiffs
complain do not amount to cruel and unusual punish-
ment. These conditions exhibit no obduracy or wanton-
ness on the part of prison officials.
The Constitution does not mandate comfortable
prisons. Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S., at 349. “So long as
prison officials provide inmates with ‘a minimal civilized
measure of life’s necessities’, the requirements of the
57
Eighth Amendment have been met.” Bellamy v. Bradley,
729 F.2d 416, 420 (6th Cir. 1984) (quoting, Rhodes v. Chap-
man, 452 U.S., at 347).
Regarding the lack of a classification system in
assigning inmates to dormitories, a prison’s internal secu-
rity is a matter normally left to the discretion of prison
administrators. Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S., at n. 14. See
also, Bell v. Wolfish, 441 U.S. 520, 547 (1979). Although
plaintiffs complain that there are mentally ill inmates
housed with them, prisons house persons convicted of
serious crimes and “[t]o the extent that such conditions
are restrictive and even harsh, they are part of the penalty
that criminal offenders pay for their offenses against soci-
ety.” Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S., at 347. Plaintiffs present
no evidence that these circumstances inflict wanton pain
upon plaintiffs or that such conditions are grossly dispro-
portionate to the severity of the crimes warranting plain-
tiffs’ imprisonment. Id.-at 348.
In addition, defendants present affidavits which indi-
cate that mentally ill inmates are sent to either the Oak-
wood Forensic Center or to the Tecumseh Program at the
Chillicothe Correctional Institute.
As to plaintiffs’ complaint that they are housed with
severely physically-ill inmates, defendants present affi-
davits which state that there are no HCF inmates with
active contagious diseases. In fact, there have been no
outbreaks of contagious diseases at HCF since it was
converted into a prison in 1983. Plaintiffs do not complain
that they have contracted any such disease.
58
Defendants present affidavits tending to show that
the restrooms are cleaned at least twice a day and precau-
tions are taken to keep the facilities and food in as sani-
tary a condition as possible. It must be remembered that
HCF houses 327 inmates. Measures are taken to keep
noise levels to a minimum; heaters have been recently
serviced and are in good working order; exhaust fans
have been installed in each dormitory and most windows
can be opened; kitchens and dining areas are cleaned
after every meal and those who work around food are
required to wear hats and gloves; HCF contracts with an
exterminator to keep the institution free of vermin. Con-
sequently, it is clear that prison officials take steps to
keep HCF as clean and sanitary as possible.
Plaintiffs allege that the dormitories are over-
crowded. There are two dormitories (“huge rooms with
two rows of bunks about three feet apart”) housing 141
and 143 inmates. However, the inmates are not confined
to the dormitories during the day. Recreational facilities
and a TV room are available to dormitory inmates.
Although crowded (plaintiffs allege each inmate has less
than 50 square feet of space), plaintiffs have not coun-
tered defendants’ affidavits with evidence which would
support their claim that conditions in the dormitories
amount to cruel and unusual punishment.
As for the issue of inadequate personal storage space,
plaintiff Wilson has previously litigated this issue in this
Court and was denied relief. See, Wilson v. Seiter, No.
C-2-83-2311 (S.D. Ohio August 17, 1984), aff’d., (6th Cir.
March 7, 1985). Consequently, the Court need not discuss
this claim.
59
In sum, the Court HOLDS that plaintiffs have been
provided with at least the minimal civilized measure of
life’s necessities and have not been deprived of their
Eighth Amendment right to be free from cruel and
unusual punishment. We HOLD that HCF officials do not
demonstrate obdurate or wanton behavior regarding the
conditions of HCF.
Defendants’ motion for summary judgment is hereby
GRANTED. This action is DISMISSED.
The Clerk of Court shall enter judgment for defen-
dants.
/s/ James L. Graham
James L. Graham, Judge
United States District Court
60
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
[Captioned Omitted In Printing]
JUDGMENT IN A CIVIL CASE
CASE NUMBER: C-2-86-1046
* * *
x Decision by Court. This action came to trial or hear-
ing before the Court. The issues have been tried or
heard and a decision has been rendered.
IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED defendants motion
for summary judgment is GRANTED, this action is
DISMISSED, JUDGMENT is for the defendants.
May 18, 1987 KENNETH J. MURPHY
Date Clerk
/s/ Beverly J. Robinson
(By) Deputy Clerk
61
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
EASTERN DIVISION
[Caption Omitted In Printing]
Civil Action C-2-86-1046
ORDER
Plaintiff’s May 26, 1987 motion for reconsideration is
DENIED. In issuing the May 18, 1987 Opinion and Order
dismissing this case the Court considered the affidavits of
Pearly Wilson, Everett Hunt, Jr., Robert L. Cassidy, Prince
Vinson, Richard Griffin, Paul Bock, and Joseph E. Ken-
nedy attached to plaintiff's November 10, 1986 motion for
summary judgment. These affidavits do not, when con-
sidered with the March 16, 1987 affidavit of Jerry Patton
and the March 16, 1987 affidavit of Bennett Manning,
create any conflict of material fact requiring trial.
Although plaintiffs’ affidavit conclusorily asserts that
severely mentally ill and physically ill inmates are pre-
sent at HCF, they filed no affidavits to rebut Mr. Patton’s
sworn statement that severely mentally ill inmates
receive treatment outside the institution, inmates are
treated for physical illness, and that there have been no
outbreaks of contagious diseases since the prison opened.
Plaintiffs similarly failed to offer fact specific affidavits or
other evidence to rebut defendants’ affidavits concerning
food, sanitation, noise, heat and other conditions at the
prison.
/s/ James L. Graham,
James L. Graham, Judge
United States District Judge
62
No. 88-3194
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
Peary WILSON, et al.,
On APPEAL
from the United
States District
Court for the
Southern
District of Ohio
Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
RICHARD SEITER, ET AL.,
Defendants-Appellees.
ed
Decided and Filed January 16, 1990
Before KRUPANSKY and WELLFORD, Circuit
Judges, and HARVEY, Senior District Judge.*
HARVEY, Senior District Judge. Appellants are
inmates at Hocking Correctional Facility (HCF), a
medium security prison located in Nelsonville, Ohio. On
August 28, 1986, appellants filed a complaint in the
United States District Court for the Southern District of
Ohio, claiming violations of the cruel and unusual pun-
ishments clause of the eighth amendment of the United
States Constitution. The claimed violations arose from
*Honorable James Harvey, United States Senior District Judge
for the Eastern District of Michigan, sitting by designation.
63
allegedly unfit confinement conditions; specifically over-
crowding, excessive noise, inadequate storage, inade-
quate heating and cooling, unclean lavatories, improper
classification of prisoners, and unsanitary eating condi-
tions.
On cross-motions for summary judgment, appellants
and appellees filed affidavits in support of their respec-
tive positions. Appellants’ affidavits, and those of five
additional inmates, essentially recite the alleged condi-
tions of confinement as depriving them of their eighth
amendment rights. Moreover, the affidavits of inmates
Bock, Wilson, and Hunt contend that they contacted
prison officials regarding the pertinent conditions, but
that the officials took no action in response thereto. _
Appellees’ affidavits, filed both in response to appel-
lants’ summary judgment motion and in support of their
own summary judgment motion, basically disclose efforts
taken by prison personnel regarding physical and medi-
cal conditions within HCF, and partially refute the appel-
lants’ specific claims concerning conditions at the prison.
Additionally, appellees filed the affidavit of the staff
counsel for the Ohio Judicial Conference, containing an
article recounting his observations following a tour of the
facility, respecting conditions at HCF.
In granting appellees’ motion, the district court ini-
tially found that the eighth amendment requires states to
furnish inmates with reasonably adequate food, clothing,
shelter, sanitation, medical care and personal safety. Next,
the district court noted that appellants, in order to prove
an eighth amendment violation arising from conditions of
64
confinement, n.ust demonstrate “obduracy and wanton-
ness, not inadvertence or error in good faith” on the part
' of the prison officials. Whitley v. Albers, 475 U.S. 312, 319
(1986).
Reviewing all of the affidavits ‘n light of these stan-
dards, the district court concluded that appellants faired
to establish a genuine issue of materiai fact, and that
judgment should properly cnter in appellees’ favor as a
matter of law. Briefly, the trial court concluded that the
complained-of conditions exhibited no sbduracy or wan-
tonness on the appeliees’ parts. Furthermore, the district
court examined each complained-of condition discretely,
and in several instances found appellants’ claims merit-
less given appellees’ affidavits. Particularly, the district
court dismissed averments in appellants’ supporting affi-
davits ccncerning confinement with physically-ill
inmates, cleanliness of lavatories, noise levels, heating
and cooling, ventilation, eating conditions, and general
sanitation on the strength of contrary information con-
tained in appellees’ affidavits.
Appellants now contend that the district court
improperly granted the appellees’ summary judgment
moti ‘, in that genuine issues of material fact exist con-
cerning confinement conditions, and that therefore the
district court could not, as a matter of law, enter judg-
ment.
I.
District courts may enter summary judgment in a
movant's favor upon a showing that “there is no genuine
issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is
65
entitlea to a judgment as a matter of law.” Fed. R. Civ. P.
56(c). “[A] party seeking summary judgment always
bears the initial responsibility of informing the district
court of the basis for its motion, and identifying those
portions of ‘the pleadings, depositions, answers to inter-
rogatories, and admissions on file, together with the affi-
davits, if any,’ which it believes demonstrate the absence
of a genuine issue of material fact.” Celotex Corp. v. Cat-
rett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986). The movant need not, how-
ever, “support its motion with affidavits or other similar
materials negating the opponent's claim.” Id. (emphasis in
original).
“As to materiality, the substantive law will identify
which facts are material.” Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.,
477 U.S. 242, 248 (1986). Once materiality of a fact is
established, district courts must determine whether a
genuine issue regarding that fact exists in the record. In
order to demonstrate the genuineness of any issue of
material fact, the nonmoving party “must do more than
simply show that there ‘s some metaphysical doubt as to
[that] material fact[ ].” Matsushita Electric Industrial Co.,
Ltd. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574, 586 (1986). Thus,
“[i]f the evidence [regarding existence of a genuine issue
of material fact] is merely colorable, . . . , or is not
significantly probative, . . . , summary judgment may be
granted.” Anderson, 477 U.S. at 249-250. Finally, “[o]n
summary judgment the inferences to be drawn from the
underlying facts-. . . must be viewed in the light most
favorable to the party opposing the motion.” Matsushita,
475 US. at 587, quoting United States v. Diebold, Inc., 369
U.S. 654, 655 (1962).
66
Il.
Appellants argue that genuine issues of material fact
remain regarding confinement conditions at HFC [sic],
urging that the district court improperly weighed the
affidavits of appellees against those of appellants in con-
cluding that the confinement conditions did not violate
appellants’ eighth amendment rights. Clearly, confine-
ment conditions are material given the substantive law
surrounding eighth amendment prisoner claims. See
Rhodes v. Chapman, 452 U.S. 337, 347 (1982). Moreover,
appellants’ affidavits are more than colorable, and obvi-
ously place the conditions surrounding confinement in
issue. Several circuits have found eighth amendment vio-
lations arising from conditions similar to those alleged by
the appellants. See, e.g., French v. Owens, 777 F.2d 1250
(7th Cir. 1985), cert. denied, 479 U.S. 817 (1986); Cody v.
Hillard, 799 F.2d 447, Reh’g granted (en banc), 804 F.2d 440
(8th Cir 1986); Hoptowit v. Spellman, 753 F.2d 779 (9th Cir.
1985). To the extent, therefore, that the district court
adopted the findings in appellees’ affidavits in conclud-
ing that the HFC’s [sic] confinement conditions did not
deprive appellants of their eighth amendment rights, the
district court committed error. As stated in Anderson, “the
judge’s function is not himself to weigh the evidence and
determine the truth of the matter but to determine
whether there is a genuine issue for trial.” 477 U.S. at 269.
Il.
Nevertheless, the appellants’ affidavits, evn if unop-
posed, may be insufficient to support a claimed eighth
67
amendment violation. We are able to identify eight spe-
cific conditions that appellants assert amount to infliction
of cruel and unusual punishment: (1) unsanitary eating
conditions; (2) inadequate heating and cooling; (3) hous-
ing with mentally ill inmates; (4) housing with physically
ill inmates; (5) inadequate ventilation; (6) excessive ncise;
(7) insect infestation; and (8) overcrowding. Since appel-
lees’ affidavits refute, to some degree, appellants’ claims
concerning these conditions, genuine issues of fact exist
regarding same. Our task, then, is to determine whether
these issues are material, requiring an examination of the
substantive law regarding eighth amendment confine-
ment conditions claims.
Rhodes, supra, sets forth a flexible standard for ascer-
taining whether prison conditions amount to cruel and
unusual punishment. In evaluating prison conditions, we
recognize that the eighth amendment “draw(s] its mean-
ing from the evolving standards of decency that mark the
progress of a maturing society.” Id. at 346, (quoting Trop v.
Dulles, 356 U.S. 86, 101 (1958) (plurality opinion)). Thus,
“[clonditions must not involve the wanton and unnecess-
ary infliction of pain, nor may they be grossly dispropor-
tionate to the severity of the crime warranting
imprisonment.” Id. at 347. Yet, “conditions that cannot be
said to be cruel and unusual under contemporary stan-
dards are not unconstitutional,” and “[t]o the exte# that
such conditions are restrictive and even harsh, they are
part of the penalty that criminal offenders pay for their
offenses against society.” Id.
Subsequent to Rhodes, this circuit had interpreted its
language as requiring an examination of “all the prison’s
“
68
conditions and circumstances, rather than isolated condi-
tions and events, when addressing eighth amendment
claims.” Walker v. Mintzes, 771 F.2d 920, 925 (6th Cir.
1985). Moreover, “[i]n certain extreme circumstances the
totality itself may amount to an eighth amendment viola-
tion, but there still must exist a specific condition on
which to base the eighth amendment claim.” Id. Specific
ccnditions found to violate the eighth amendment
include the denial of adequate access to shower facilities,
Preston v. Thompson, 589 F.2d 300 (7th Cir. 1978); denial of
medical treatment, Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976);
overcrowding, Cody v. Hillard, 799 F.2d 447 (8th Cir. 1986);
threats to safety, French v. Owens, 777 F.2d 1250 (7th Cir.
1985), cert. denied, 479 U.S. 817 (1986); vermin infestation,
Hoptowii v. Spellman, 753 F.2d 779 (9th Cir. 1985); inade-
quate lighting, id.; inadequate ventilation, id., unsanitary
eating conditions, Ramos v. Lamm, 639 F.2d 559 (10th Cir.
1980), cert. denied, 450 U.S. 1041 (1981); and housing of
inmates with known dangerous individuals, Shrader v.
White, 761 F.2d 975 (4th Cir. 1985).
Application of this precedent to the appellants’ alle-
gations leads us to conclude that some, but not all, of the
complained-of conditions suggest the type of “seriously
inadequate and indecent surroundings” necessary to
establish an eighth amendment violation. See Birrell v.
Brown, 867 F.2d 956, 958 (6th Cir. 1989). Concerning,
however, appellants’ claims regarding inadequate cool-
ing, housing with mentally ill inmates, and overcrowd-
ing, we believe that these allegations, even if true, fail to
establish constitutionally violative conditions.
First appellants suggest that their exposure during
summer months to temperatures as high as 95 degrees
69
represents cruel and unusual punishment. Undeniably,
excessive exposure to heat may in some instances consti-
tute cruel and unusual punishment, yet we are unaware
of any precedent holding that occasional exposure to 95
degree heat presents such an instance. We therefore reject
this specific condition as a basis for appellants’ claim.
Second, appellants contend that appellees’ practice of
housing mentally ill inmates in their dorm places them in
fear for their safety. Appellants do not, though, cite any
particular episodes of violence supporting this fear. In
Shrader, supra, the court accepted a magistrate’s finding
that
[oJne key to understanding when the risk of
violence reaches constitutional dimensions is its
effect on the inmate population. . . . In this
context, it is not necessary that an inmate estab-
lish that he has been the subject of an actual
attack, but he must establish that he lives in
reasonable fear of assaults from other in-
mates . . . and that the fear results in significant
mental pain. .. .
761 F.2d at 978, 979 (emphasis added). The appellants
present solely subjective feelings as a basis for their
alleved fear of violence from mentally ill inmates. While
Shrader does not mandate that a prisoner, to establish an
eighth amendment violation, demonstrate that he has
been the victim of an actual attack, it does require reason-
atle fear. The absence of ellegations of prior physical
violence involving any inmate supporting appellants’
claims leads us to conclude that their fear is not reason-
able. Their eighth amendment claim cannot therefore rest
on allegations of improper housing of mentally ill
inmates.
ee
70
Finally, on the issue of overcrowding, appellants cite
to the fact that inmates are double-bunked, and that each
receives approximately 50 square feet of living space
within the dorm. While overcrowding is generally
acknowledged as a potential basis for an eighth amend-
ment violation, courts examining this problem review all
of the circumstances surrounding confinement to ascer-
tain whether prison population density inflicts cruel and
unusual punishment. See Rhodes, 452 U.S. at 348-49; Cody,
799 F.2d at 449-50; French, 777 F.2d at 1252. If conditions
impacting upon the quality of confinement exacerbate an
already overcrowded condition, cruel and unusual pun-
ishment may exist. The record before us, undisputed by
appellants, establishes that while the inmates may indeed
have only 50 or so square feet of living space each within
their dorm, the inmates also have access during the day
to a television lounge, gymnasium, yard, weight room,
billiards table, and library. This is not, therefore, a situa-
tion wherein the inmates allege constant exposure to
overcrowding. We therefore reject any eighth amendment
claim on this basis.
Having found that appeliants’ claims cannot arise
from specific conditions of inadequate cooling, housing
with mentally ili inmates, and overcrowding, we now
examine whether the remaining conditions alleged are
adequate to sustain the appellants’ claim.
IV.
Appellees argue that even if appellants allege ccadi-
tions adequate to support an eighth amendment claim,
their affidavits fail to refute the evidence contained in
71
appellees’ affidavits of conscious efforts taken »y prison
officials concerning the relevant conditions. Since the
Supreme Court, in Whitley v. Albers, supra, has directed
that “[i]t is obduracy and wantonness, not inadvertence
or error in good faith, that characterize the conduct pro-
hibited by the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause,”
475 U.S. at 319, appellees urge that the absence of facts
rebutting evidence indicating efforts taken to assure min-
imally decent confinement conditions demonstrates an
absence of any genuine issue as to this material fact.
Initially, it is noteworthy that we have applied
Whitley's “obduracy and wantonness” standard to eighth
amendment challenges to confinement conditions. In Bir-
rell v. Brown, 867 F.2d 956 (6th Cir. 1989), we noted that
“[i]Jn addition to producing evidence of seriously inade-
quate and indecent surroundings, a plaintiff must also
establish that the conditions are the result of recklessness
by prison officials and not mere negligence or oversight.”
Id. at 958. The importance of this application of Whitley
may be merely semantic, yet it establishes that at least in
this circuit, the Whitley standard is not confined to the
facts of that case; that is, to suits alleging use of excessive
force in an effort to restore prison order.
Having concluded that a showing of obduracy and
wantonness is material to appellants’ claims, the critical,
and determinative, question becomes whether appellants’
affidav.ts place this fact in issue. Resolutior. of this ques-
tion necessitates an examination of whether such affi-
davits, although not placing appeliants’ state of mind
squarely in issue, nevertheless imply the conduct
required under Whitley. That is, could “a fair-minded
re
72
jury ... return a verdict for [appellants] on the evidence
presented.” Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. at 252.
We are aware that state of mind is typically not a
proper issue for resolution on summary judgment. See
10A Wright, Miller & Kane, Federal Practice and Procedure:
Civil 2d § 2730 (1983); Archer v. Dutcher, 733 F.2d 14 (2d
Cir. 1984); Slay v. Alabama, 636 F.2d 1045, reh’g denied, 642
F.2d 1210 (Sth Cir. 1981). Appellees contend, however,
that the appellants’ failure to present any evidence
directly refuting appellees statements suggesting affirma-
tive efforts to maintain habitable conditions at HCF dem-
onstrates that no genuine issue of fact exists regarding
these efforts. Moreover, appellees assert that such efforts
ev'dence a lack of the requisite “obduracy and wanton-
ness” necessary for an eighth amendment claim.
Appellees’ argument, although logically attractive,
ignores the well-established principle that upon a motion
for summary judgment, all reasonable inferences from
underlying facts must be drawn in the nonmovant’s
favor. United States v. Diebold, Inc., 369 U.S. 654 (1962).
Furthermore, “[iJnasmuch as a determination of some-
one’s state of mind usually entails the drawing of factual
inferences as to which reasonable men might differ - a
function traditionally left to the jury - summary judg-
ment often will be an inappropriate means of resolving
an issue of this character.” Wright, Miller & Kane, supra,
at § 2730, p. 238 (footnote omitted). The question we must
address, therefore, is whether the appellants’ affidavits,
while not directly contradicting the appellees’ affidavits,
nevertheless contain facts reasonably implying that the
appellees acted with obduracy and wantouness.
73
Importantly, the appellants do not contend that the
appellees have taken no efforts to provide them with
minimally decent confinement conditions. Rather, appel-
lants’ complaints are aimed at the results of those efforts.
The undisputed record indicates that the HCF unit man-
ager has adopted specific affirmative measures to reduce
noise levels, has had heaters serviced, provides inmates
with an extra blanket during winter months, has installed
exhaust fans for improved ventilation, requires the clean-
ing of lavatories and kitchen on a daily basis, and has
contracted with an exterminator to treat HCF for pests on
a twice-monthly basis. The appellants’ position, appar-
ently, is that despite these actions, prison conditions
remain unacceptable.
Rhodes and its progeny make clear that confinement
conditions may constitute cruel and unusual punishment
only if such conditions “compose the punishment at
issue.” 452 U.S. at 347. Nothing in the appellants’ affi-
davits implies that the appellees used confinement condi-
tions to punish the appellants. To the contrary, the
evidence shows action on the appellees’ behalf to main-
tain decent conditions at HCF. Additionally, the Whitley
standard of obduracy and wantonness requires behavior
marked by persistent malicious cruelty. The record before
us simply fails to assert facts suggesting such behavior.
At best, appellants’ claim evidences negligence on appel-
lees’ parts in implementing standards for maintaining
conditions. Negligence, clearly, is inadequate to support
an eighth amendment sclaim. See Birrell, supra, at 958.
74
V.
In conclusion, we find that appellants’ allegations
regarding inadequate cooling, housing with mentally ill
inmates, and overcrowding are insufficient to provide a
specific basis for an eighth amendment violation. Addi-
tionally, we find that appellants’ affidavits, in that they
fail to raise a reasonable inference of obduracy and wan-
tonness on the appellees’ behalf, present no genuine issue
as to that material fact. Thus, we hold that the district
court properly entered summary judgment in appellees’
favor, and therefore AFFIRM.
75
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
No. 88-3194
PEARLY WILSON and EVERETT HUNT, JR.,
Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
RICHARD SEITER and CARL HUMPHREYS,
Defendants-Appellees.
Before: KRUPANSKY and WELLFORD, Circuit Judges;
and HARVEY, Senior District Judge.
JUDGMENT
ON APPEAL from the United States District Court
for the Southern District of Ohio.
THIS CAUSE came on to be heard on the record from
the said district court and was submitted on riefs with-
out oral argument.
ON CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, It is now here
ordered and adjudged by this court that the judgment of
the said district court in this case be and the same is
hereby affirmed. ’
No costs taxed.
January 16, 1990
ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE
COURT
Leonard Green, Clerk
/s/ Leonard Green
Clerk
ee
76
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 89-7376
Pearly L. Wilson,
Petitioner
v.
Richard Seiter, et al.
On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.
On ConsipeRATION of the motion for leave to proceed
herein in forma pauperis and of the petition for writ of
certiorari, it is ordered by this Court that the motion to
proceed in forma pauperis be, and the same is hereby,
granted; and that the petition for writ of certiorari be, and
the same is hereby, granted.
October 1, 1990
©
™
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.