Joint Appendix — Norfolk & Western Railway Co. v. Goode (No. 88-127)
Supreme Court brief1988
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Supreme Court of the United StdtesMR 2s
CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Petitioner,
Vv.
Nancy J. SCHWALB AND WILLIAM MCGLONE,
Respondents.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Petitioner,
Vv
RoBerT T. GOopDE, JR.,
Respondent.
ON WRITS OF CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT
OF VIRGINIA
CONSOLIDATED JOINT APPENDIX
WILLIAM T. PRINCE*
EDWARD L. Oast, JR.**
JOHN Y. RICHARDSON, JR.
JOAN F. MARTIN
WILLIAMS, WORRELL,
KELLY, GREER & FRANK
600 Crestar Bank Building
Norfolk, Virginia 23510
804-624-2600
Attorneys for Petitioners
*Counsel of Record
In No. 87-1979
**Counsel of Record
In No. 88-127
C. GERARD THOMPSON
Moopy, STROPLE AND
KLOEPPEL, LTD.
Commerce Sank Building
500 Crawford Street
Portsmouth, Virginia 23705
804-393-4094
Attorneys for Respondents
Schwalb and McGlone
RICHARD J. TAvss
Counsel of Record
Bruce A. WILCOx
TAvss, FLETCHER &
EARLY, P.C.
Suite 100, Royster Building
Norfolk, Virginia 23514
804-625-1214
Attorneys for Respondent
Goode .
CONSOLIDATED
JOINT APPENDIX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Relevant Docket Entries, and Ohio v.
Nancy J. Schwalb [Schwalb] .............ccccc.ccceees JA-1
Relevant Docket Entries, Chesapeake and Ohio v
William McGlone [McGlone] ..............ccccc00e00s JA-2
Relevant Docket Entries, Norfolk and Western v.
Robert T. Goode, Jr. [Goode] ...............ccc0000000 JA-3
Motion for Judgment, Schwab ...............ccccccceeeeees JA-4
Defendant’s Special Plea to Jurisdiction, Schwalb. JA-8
Motion for Judgment, McGlone ...............cccccceeeeeeee JA-9
Defendant’s Special Plea to Jurisdiction,
A JA-12
Motion for Judgment, Goode .................cccccceeeeeeeeees JA-13
Motion to Dismiss and Grounds of Defense,
A JA-17
Opinion of Supreme Court of Virginia, Schwalb and
McGlone v. Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. .. JA-20
Opinion, Circuit Court of the City of Newport News,
tial ee eaetareaatagsece JA-28
Opinion, Circuit Court of Portsmouth, Virginia,
thn cc JA-30
Opinion, Circuit Court of the City of Norfolk, Vir-
Gita, Goede .............cncnsceseceeernsoresccsesecerensesesoees JA-34
Order, Circuit Court of the City of Newport News,
a cssesenenenstbencess JA-40
Order, Circuit Court of the City of Portsmouth,
TR ATT JA-41
Order, Circuit Court of the City of Norfolk, Vir-
IIE diiiectnetsesenanictenenimenntentnenngetseeeees JA-43
Order, Supreme Court of Virginia, Schwalbe .......... JA-44
Order, Supreme Court of Virginia, McGlone ......... JA-45
il
Order, Supreme Court of Virginia, Goode ............. JA-46
33 U.S.C.A. § 902(3) (West 1986) .......................... JA-47
33 U.S.C. § 902(3) as amended in 1972 but prior
to 1984 Amendment ieectnteemnetiemenmniien JA-48
33 U.S.C.A. § 905 (West 1986) ..................ccccceeee JA-48
45 U.S.C.A. § 51 (West 1986) ........................00000. JA-49
Partial Transcript of Schwalb Evidentiary ania
anes’ = jiiianens
IE ddeiderensinpnceannsimmccemineeemenenseee JA-78
Partial Transcript of McGlone Evidentiary
IIIT dntcninccsmsnegihinteteesenecinunbiengeneetmtmetmeqnnenee JA-79
Plaintiff's for Production of Documents,
a 14.108
Defendant’s to for Production of
Docu "WcGin, wil schmsets TA-110
Partial Transcript of Goode Evidentiary Hearing . JA-127
Exhibits (Exhibit Description , Plat and 4 photo-
Exhibit from Deposition of Robert T.
Goode, Jr.) introduced in Goode Evidienting
II ccnchtsnnnentenssrsenmantestnnngetincinctttnentanmesees JA-175
Affidavit of Ronel Lee Croft, Goode ..................... JA-190
Affidavit of Raymond D. Wethington, Goode ....... JA-194
JA-1
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY V.
DATE
11/04/83
11/30/83
01/13/84
06/06/84
08/08/84
09/12/84
03/04/88
NANCY J. SCHWALB
PROCEEDINGS
Motion for Judgment (by pitf) . . . action arises
under FELA
Answer and Grounds of Defense (by deft)
Special Plea to Jurisdiction (by deft) ... sole
remedy under LHWCA
Evidentiary HEARING on jurisd. question be-
fore Judge Douglas M. Smith
Opinion Letter (DMS) . . . sustaining plea, plitf’s
remedy under LHWCA
ORDER (trial court) ... action dismissed with
prejudice ... eod 8/22/84
Notice of Appeal (by pitf)
OPINION, Virginia Supreme Court (Justice
Richard H. Poff) ... pitf not LHWCA em-
ployee
ORDER (Virginia Supreme Court) ... judg-
ment reversed and annulled, case remanded for
trial under FELA ... eod 3/4/88
ORDER (Virginia Supreme Court) ... execu-
tion of judgment suspended pending resolution
of pet. for writ of certiorari ... eod 6/8/88
JA-2
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY V.
DATE
05/31/83
06/24/83
03/29/85
05/29/85
07/02/85
03/04/88
WILLIAM MCGLONE
PROCEEDINGS
Motion for Judgment (by plitf) . . . action arises
under FELA
Special Plea to Jurisdiction (by deft) ... sole
remedy under LHWCA
Evidentiary HEARING on jurisdictional ques-
tion before Judge Lester Schlitz
Opinion Letter (LS) ... sustaining plea, plitf’s
sole remedy under LHWCA
ORDER (trial court) ... action dismissed with
prejudice ... eod 6/13/85
Notice of Appeal (by pitf)
OPINION, Virginia Supreme Court (Justice
Richard H. Poff) ... pitf not LHWCA em-
ployee
ORDER (Virginia Supreme Court) ... judg-
ment reversed and annulled, case remanded for
trial on merits under FELA .. . eod 3/4/88
ORDER (Virginia Supreme Court) ... execu-
tion of judgment suspended pending resolution
of pet. for writ of certiorari ... eod 6/8/88
JA-3
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY CO. V.
DATE
2/13/86
3/13/86
9/19/86
11/13/86
1/7/87
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.
PROCEEDINGS
Motion for Judgment (by pitf) . . . action arises
under FELA
Motion to Dismiss and Grounds of Defense (by
deft) ... exclusive jurisdiction under LHWCA
Evidentiary HEARING on jurisd. question be-
fore Judge Charles R. Waters, II
Opinion Letter (CRW) ... dismissing motion
for judg., exclusive jurisd. under LHWCA
ORDER (trial court) ... action dismissed with
prejudice ... eod 12/17/86
Notice of Appeal (by pitf)
ORDER (Virginia Supreme Court) ... judg-
ment reversed and case remanded for trial on
merits under FELA ... eod 4/22/88
ORDER, Virginia Supremé*Court, issuance of
mandate deferred
JA-4
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR
THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS
LAW NO. 8827-S
NANCY J. SCHWALB,
Plaintiff,
vs.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
A CORPORATION, |
Defendant.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT
Plaintiff moves the Court for judgment and award of
execution against the Defendant, in the sum of
$1,000,000.00, on the following grounds:
1. This action arises under the Federal Employers’ Li-
ability Act, 45 U.S.C.A., Section 51, et seq.. as hereinafter
more fully appears.
2. During all times mentioned herein, Defendant owned
and operated, in interstate commerce, a railroad, and the
operations and work of the Plaintiff, as hereinafter alleged,
were a part and parcel of the operation of the Defendant’s
line in interstate commerce at the time of injuries to the
Plaintiff.
3. Plaintiff is a resident of Newport News, Virginia, and
at all times herein mentioned, was employed by the
Defendant as a laborer, and worked at said job in the City
of Newport News, on the Defendant’s premises, which
premises were owned, operated and controlled by
Defendant.
4. Jurisdiction and venue lie with this Court by virtue
of the foregoing.
JA-5
its yards in Newport News, Virginia, under
supervision of other employees of the Defendant.
Plaintiff was required to clean the trunion rollers which
required her to walk on the catwalk, which was not lighted.
As Plaintiff was walking on the catwalk to the rollers, she
hich she
forward, striking her head on the metal catwalk, and be-
came unconscious, and injuring her thumb on the railing.
at all times herein mentioned, acting in the exercise of
reasonable care for her own safety.
- 6. At all pertinent times it became and was the duty
of Defendant to:
(a) Furnish Plaintiff a reasonably safe place to work.
(b) Exercise reasonable care and caution for the safety
of Plaintiff while she was performing said work.
7. While Plaintiff was engaged in the performance of
the aforesaid work required by Defendant, she was caused
to sustain injuries as hereinafter set forth by reason of
the violation of the Defendant of its aforesaid duties.
8. At said time and place, the Defendant and its em-
ployees as aforesaid, in violation of the Federal Employers’
Liability Act of the United States, carelessly and negli-
gently did one or more of the following acts or omissions
which were the cause of said occurrence, and the injuries
sustained by the Plaintiff.
(a) Failed to furnish Plaintiff a reasonably safe place
within which to do her said work;
JA-6
(b) Failed to provide plaintiff with safe and proper
tools and equipment to do said work;
(c) Failed to provide a flashlight and/or adequate
lighting to safely do said work;
(d) Failed to provide adequate help and assistance;
(e) Failed to inspect, repair and maintain its premises;
(f) Failed to adopt, enforce, and carry out safe cus-
toms and practices in doing said work;
(g) Negligently assigned Plaintiff to walk on a dan-
gerous catwalk without providing adequate safety
precautions and equipment; without providing a
flashlight; without providing adequate lighting;
without providing adequate help and assistance;
negligently assigning plaintiff to walk on a catwalk
which was not lighted, all of which Defendant
knew or should have known in the exercise of due
care was dangerous and unsafe for Plaintiff.
(h) Other acts of negligence which may be shown at
trial.
9. As a direct and proximate result of the aforemea-
10. That by reason of the foregoing, Plaintiff has
tained damages at the hands of the Defendant in the
JA-7
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against the
above named defendant, The Chesapeake and Ohio Railway
Company, a Corporation, in the of $1,000,000.00, to-
gether with the costs of the action incurred herein.
NANCY J. SCHWALB
By /s/ Peter W. Rowe
Of Counsel
By /s/ Donald L. Rudquist
Of Counsel
Peter W. Rowe, Esq.
STACKHOUSE, ROWE & SMITH
1400 Virginia National
Bank Building
P. 0. Box 3570
Norfolk, Virginia 23514
Tel: (804) 623-3555
and
Donald L. Rudquist, Esq.
DePARCQ, PERL, HUNEGS,
RUDQUIST & KOENIG, P.A.
608 Building, Room 565
608 Second Avenue South
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
Tel: (612) 339-4511
Plaintyff,
A CORPORATION,
Plaintiff,
v.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
SERVE
Aubrey R. Bowles, III, Esquire
Registered Agent,
Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company
901 Mutual Building
Richmond, Virginia 23219
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT
The plaintiff hereby moves this Honorable Court for a
JA-10
Federal Employers’ Liability Act’ (45 USCA Chap. 2, Sec.
51-60), as amended on August 11, 1939.
3. That at all times herein mentioned defendant was an
intrastate and interstate carrier and was engaged in in-
and commerce. At the time of his
injury, plaintiff was working in furtherance of interstate
commerce and participating in work which directly, closely
and substantially affected the general interstate commerce
carried on by the defendant.
or about February 1, 1983 the plaintiff was
an employee of the defendant, Chesapeake and Ohio Rail-
way Company, as a laborer, and on or about said date,
iH
while so employed in the regular course of his duties on
land at 6 ee ee ee
forming such duties, to-wit: While trying to blow coal out
JA-11
7. That the defendant Railway Company failed to com-
ply with the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (45 USCA
Chap. 2, Secs. 51-60) as amended on August 11, 1939, as
hereinbefore more fully appears.
caused to lose,
|
he will in the future
for against the defendant, The Chesapeake
and Ohio Railway Company, in the sum of Two Million
Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($2,500,000.00) with in-
terest and his costs.
WILLIAM C. MCGLONE
By /s/ Russell N. Brahm, III
Of Counsel
Russell] N. Brahm, III
Willard J. Moody
Moody, Strople, Brahm
& Lawrence, Ltd
P. 0. Box 1138
Portsmouth, Virginia 23704-1138
——. = rT EN
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
THE CHESAPEAKF AND OHIO
RAILWAY COMPANY
By /s/ Richard Wright West
Of Counsel
Richard Wright West, Esquire
WEST, STEIN, WEST & SMITH, P.C.
P. 0. Box 257
Newport News, VA 23607
Counsel for Defendant
JA-13
AT LAW NO. L86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.,
Plaintiff,
Vv.
Defendant.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY CO.,
iE
i oAaagl el i
JA-14
nna gettin
herein
and interstate
and
ia Hn
ree
the Hi i HE ue
Ea ti
Hs ipa
Ah i aH Hie TRH F a
i
JA-15
as amended on August 11, 1939, as hereinbefore more fully
7. That as a result of the accident complained of herein,
the Plaintiff was caused to lose, and will in the future be
caused to lose, income which he otherwise would have
earned
8. That as a result of the accident complained of herein,
the Plaintiff was caused to suffer, and will in the future
be caused to suffer, great physical pain and mental an-
guish.
That as a result of the accident complained of herein,
Plaintiff was caused to expend, and he will in the
ture be caused to expend, large sums of money for med-
10. That as a result of the accident complained of herein,
the Plaintiff was caused to be unable, and will in the future
be unable, to perform his necessary and lawful affairs.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff DEMANDS A TRIAL BY
JURY and prays for judgment against the Defendant in
the sum of One Million Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dol-
lars ($1,250,000.00).
ROBERT T. GOODE,
JR.
By /s/ Eddie W. Wilson
Of Counsel
By /s/ Richard J. Tavss
Of Counsel
By /s/ Bruce A. Wilcox
Of Counsel
Eddie W. Wilson
MILLER, BONDURANT & WILSON, LTD.
706 London Boulevard at Green Street
JA-16
Portsmouth, Virginia 23704
Richard J. Tavss
Tavss & Fletcher
Two Commercial Place
Norfolk, VA 23510
Bruce A. Wilcox
Tavss & Fletcher
Two Commercial Place
Norfolk, VA 23510
JA-17
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF
THE CITY OF NORFOLK
DOCKET NO. L-86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR..,
Plaintvff,
v.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY CO.,
Defendant.
MOTION TO DISMISS
Defendant, Norfolk and Western Railway Co., moves the
Court to dismiss this action on the grounds that the Court
is without jurisdiction of the subject matter, Congress hav-
ing vested exclusive jurisdiction in the Longshoremen’s
and Harbor Worker’s Compensation Act, 33 U.S.C.A. §
901, et seq.
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY CO.
By /s/ John Y. Richardson, Jr.
Of Counsel
JA-18
GROUNDS OF DEFENSE
Defendant, Norfolk and Western Railway Co., for its
grounds of defense to the motion for judgment filed herein,
comes and says:
1. That the allegations of paragraph 1 of the motion
for judgment are admitted.
2. That the allegations of paragraph 2 of the motion
for judgment are denied.
3. That the allegations of paragraph 3 of the motion
for judgment are admitted.
4. That at the time of the accident complained of,
plaintiff was engaged in maritime employment; defendant
expressly requests a reply to this allegation of new matter.
5. That the accident and injury complained of occurred
on the navigable waters of the United States (including
any adjoining pier, wharf, drydock, terminal, building way,
marine railway, or other adjoining area customarily used
by an employer in loading, unloading, repairing or building
a vessel); defendant expressly requests a reply to the new
matter alleged herein.
6. That with regard to the allegations contained in par-
agraph 4 of the motion for judgment, defendant admits
plaintiff was injured on or about February 11, 1985 and
was an employee of the defendant on that date, however,
a!] other allegations are denied.
7. That the allegations of paragraphs 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and
10 of the motion for judgment are denied.
8. That plaintiff was guilty of negligence which proxi-
mately caused or contributed to cause the action and the
injuries complained of, and plaintiff failed to use due care
to mitigate his damages. The plaintiff was not injured to
the extent alleged and is not entitled to recover
$1,250,000.00 or any other sum in this action.
JA-19
9. That plaintiff has waived his rights to proceed against
the defendant by his acceptance of benefits under the
Longshoremen’s and Harbor Worker’s Compensation Act
and has made a binding election of remedies.
10. That defendant reserves the right to amend its
' grounds of defense during discovery of this matter or at
trial.
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY CO.
By /s/ John Y. Richardson, Jr.
Of Counsel
Edward L, Oast, Jr.
John Y. Richardson, Jr.
Williams, Worrell, Kelly & Greer, P.C.
600 United Virginia Bank Building
Norfolk, VA 23510
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true copy of the foregoing was
mailed to Eddie W. Wilson and Richard J. Tavss, this 13th
day of March, 1986.
/s/ John Y. Richardson, Jr.
JA-20
OPINION BY JUSTICE RICHARD H. POFF
March 4, 1988
Record No. 841743
NANCY J. SCHWALB
v.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS
Douglas M. Smith, Judge
Record No. 850728
WILLIAM MCGLONE
v.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF PORTSMOUTH
Lester ©. Schlitz, Judge
JA-21
Shae Fella inteess
ui atid iN fe
e454 Hur June bli
Fea Teen ETE
yet deatpetth Het te
A : 5% estes
Magn i HE vi ara H
JA-22
Hate cant
: an
a8 cm. fe: be
iit hati
aH225 52
Hl
Fe
=
>
i
a
§
as
77)
~
e383
ist
& Co., 264 U.S. 219 (1924).
i. the LHWCA, a originally enacted, provided cover
Operating Co. v. Johnson, 396 U.S. 212, 218-20 (1969).
The 1972 amendments to the LHWCA moved the Jensen
IKE TE
se ee
ie ie fil HE
may late edt yh
ant sie if aul Heit, fi
Nialy euilee oH i liste!
868 (1976):
the status of the worker in Director,
‘orth River Associates, 459 U.S. 297, 302 n.8, 318-
e Supreme Court disapproved application of a significant rela-
standard to
v. Perim N.
ate
JA-24
& Ww. Py. Co., 618 F.2d 1059 (4th Cir.
will be reversed”. 217 Va. at 832-33, 232
was not a covered ‘employee’ within the meaning
appeals at bar, the defendant railroad relies on
Act”, and that “the order dismissing plaintiff's
at 81
a £
SESessaazy
Hay
TUE
fas]
2 4
ctf]
—
JA-25
of the LHWCA which provides an exclusive remedy”, id.
at 1062.
Northeast Marine Terminal Co. v. Caputo,432 U.S. 249
(1977). The language the defendant quotes from that de-
cision is an abbreviated excerpt lifted from a longer pas-
sage, the import of which we construe differently.
The injuries at issue in Caputo were sustained during
the process of unloading a ship. Considering the reports
of the congressional committees that initiated the 1972
. amendments, the Court concluded that Congress intended
to cover those workers involved in the essential
elements of unloading a vessel—taking cargo out
of the hold, moving it away from the ship’s side,
and carrying it immediately to a storage or hold-
ing area . [PJersons who are on the situs but
are not engaged in the overall process of loading
and unloading vessels are not covered. Thus, em-
ployees such as truck drivers, whose responsibil
ity on the waterfront is essentially to pick up or
deliver cargo unloaded from or destined for mar
itime transportation are not covered. Also ex
cluded are employees who perform purely clerical
tasks and are not engaged in the handling of
cargo.
Id. at 267 (emphasis added). As we construe this language
the Court reasoned that, although clerical employees werk
ing on a covered situs may have responsibilities related to
1
Ny ihe il pleitt
: + 5 2 ie 13 SELL hie 3
‘ id i ei iad ball i ud
ise en a tite ' " f
JA-27
the cases
Record No. 841743 - Reversed and remanded.
Record No. 850728 - Reversed and remanded.
TALE
it i
JA-28
Newport News, Virginia 23607
August 8, 1984
5 BE 82
ele aa
~ He
Htgl Hi
ll if elf ey! i
Re: Nancy J. Schwalb v. The Chesapeake and Ohio Rail-
way Company At Law No. 8827
that
‘al -
This
in which
this cause
lacks j
heard
read the
mere
Dear Counsel:
JA-29
HE
rH:
ny “ht vale
to the jurisdiction is
Mr. West to draw the ap-
noting plaintiff's exception and objection
ving the order endorsed by opposing counsel and
pant ng A to the Court for entry.
/s/ Douglas M. Smith
Judge
Very truly yours,
PHA ate
JA-30
THIRD JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
Cireuit Court of the City of Portsmouth
May 29, 1985
Richard Wright West, Esquire
P.O. Box 257
Newport News, Virginia 23607
Russell N. Brahm, III, Esquire
P.O. Box 1138
Portsmouth, Virginia 23705-1138
Re: William McGlone v. Chesapeake and Ohio Railway
Co. L84-327
Gentlemen:
Thank you for your excellent and most exhaustive mem-
oranda. I have reviewed the pleadings, the evidence and
the argument of counsel, and I have read the memoranda
and all c* the cases cited.
William McGlone, plaintiff, was injured at Newport
News, Virginia, on February 1, 1983, and filed his Motion
for Judgment against the Chesapeake and Ohio Railway
Company, defendant, on May 31, 1983, under the Federal
Employer’s Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C. 51, et. seq.
Defendant filed a special plea to the jurisdiction on June
24, 1983, on the ground that plaintiff's sole and exclusive
remedy upon the matters alleged in the Motion for Judg-
ment is under the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’
Compensation Act (LHWCA), 33 U.S.C. 905(a).
A hearing on the special plea was heard by this Court
on March 29, 1985, evidence taken and a transcript pre-
pared. It appears from the evidence that plaintiff and em-
ployee of the Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company on
the date of the accident was working on the pier as a
laborer cleaning up coal which had fallen from a conveyor
JA-31
belt which was being used to load coal onto a ship at the
pier. The hopper and conveyor belt is an extension of the
pier. If coal is not removed in the area where the plaintiff
was cleaning up, the coal would eventually interfere with
the loading operation and bring it to a halt. This work
was frequently done by the plaintiff. Plaintiff was injured
by the conveyor belt while engaged in this work. The sole
action involved here is whether the plaintiff at the time
of his injury was working in a maritime capacity as defined
by the LHWCA.
An injured employee must meet both a “‘situs’’ and a
“status” test in order to be covered under LHWCA. There
seems to be no question here that the injured [sic] occurred
in a covered situs but we must determine whether plaintiff
occupied a status covered under LHWCA. Noqueira v. New
York, N.H., and H.R. Company. 281 U.S. 128, (1930).
The Court must resolve a conflict in the case law be-
tween a decision of the Supreme Court of Virginia, White
v. Norfolk & Western Railway Co., 217 Va. 823 (1977),
cert. denied, 434 U.S. 860 (1977) and Price v. Norfolk &
Western Railway Company, 618 F2d 105 (1080) [sic], de-
cided by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. In White
the court stated at page 832:
“Plaintiff was not actually handling any cargo
either manually or mechanically, as was the case
in the decisions principally relied on by N & W.
Moreover, plaintiff was not manipulating (except
to test) any of the controlls of the electrical mech-
anism, which furnished the power for this auto-
mated loading process. Rather, he was only
maintaining the electrical device on the shore and
attached to the pier, work which is not the tra-
ditional work of a ship’s service employee.
Plaintiff was at least one step removed from a
realistically significant relationship and from a
direct involvement with the loading of vessels.
that of a maritime worker.”
It can thus be seen that the Virginia Supreme Court
held that to qualify as an employee under LHWCA the
plaintiff must have been directly involved in the loading
of coal. Under this ruling plaintiff could not have been
held to be an employee under LHWCA. -
Price decided three years after White holds to the con-
trary.
The Fourth Circuit held that a railway employee who
was injured while painting towers used in the loading of
ships was an employee under LHWCA. The court held
that merely because the ei x1ployee was not directly involved
in the actual loading of ships, this fact did not remove
him from coverage under LHWCA because the mainte-
nance of the towers was essential to the movement of
maritime cargo and thus the employee was included in the
broad concept of maritime employment.
This view has been upheld in many Federal court de-
cisions. See: Newport News Shipbuilding and Drydock Com-
pany v. Graham, 573 F2d 167 (4th Circuit), cert. denied,
439 U.S. 979, 99 S.Ct. 563 (1978); Northeast Marine Ter-
minal Company v. Caputo, 432 U.S. 249, 97 S.Ct. 2348
(1977).
It will thus be seen that the Fourth Circuit has adopted
a broad concept of maritime employment that maintenance
of maritime cargo loading equipment is essential to the
loading of cargo and is, therefore, included in the meaning
of a person engaged in maritime employment under
LHWCA.
JA-33
| appli 5 8 |
wil aly : ill ; :
r aL We Hi tie
: hails, 2 a. Fas
es SER Saas3 ail se 2°
: TSH qi H 3 i il}
fifa staal Hal
Hylan le Hele
ag Ugieys hea] aged 2 i]
Sincerely yours,
/s/ Lester E. Schlitz
Chief Judge
JA-34
FOURTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF VIRGINIA
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE CITY OF NORFOLK
November 13, 1986
Eddie W. Wilson, Esquire
2200 Colonial Avenue, Suite 12-B
P. O. Box 11168
Norfolk, Virginia 23517
John ¥. Richardson, Jr., Esquire
Williams, Worrell, Kelly & Greer
600 United Virginia Bank Building
P. O. Box 3416
Norfolk, Virginia 23514-3416
Re: Robert T. Goode, Jr. vs. Norfolk and Western Rail-
way Co. At Law No. L-86-335
Gentlemen:
Thank you for the help that you have given the court.
JA-35
be dismissed for reason that exclusive jurisdiction lies
within the ambit of the L.H.W.C.A.
:
I fi
Ssstagg<
Ht
Wit
HEHE
ESPs
fgags
i it
ii tf
Ha
ne
nig
i
:
ai i
i ik
Hee
at
i
&
it
Hh
g
3
8
Eriges
HHT
*7
Eb
He
HH
g
ai
ul
ay
JA-36
aa}
HH
3
jiigedtees
Wil
iil;
ifaast
a
ice
3
<C.A., Nogueira v. New
1 U.S. 128, 132, 44 L.Ed. 754,
jean
rt
Hae
The Supreme Court in Herb’s Welding v. Gray, __ U.S.
working on 8 fined efthore cl-driling pistiorm was net
q33 aalaty
a ils HOH
eg ety
ul i: 3
JA-37
not seek to cover
4 we oatheny
situs who are
of loading and
mariti
those
ship
aé i ie iH ki irene
ish if Bt eng a +
HN ills ii ple ae sil
JA-38
SeSEsesEs3e BS Sg <8Eg2 £348
a Baba etledi le ip
iF jel ‘ste fase fiji it s
si Re al Hie = § 354 = 234
i tb etedal tate ij ni is3¢
iy thn + SHH sie 243;
ie ha) ul tii ipl
iota deaats biases 14ghs ual
Ht 33.2. ates 1H is: afi
gre leila Ais tiff fstag] f ii
JA-39
Sgf 838-5 l
Pa] Wau:
t AU) Tied : i
% : F & ies Z
: HE i it , |
ee eee ie]
: aut ‘j Hp
ee i
JA-41
it |
gt
a
di te
JA-43
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF NORFOLK
Docket No. L-86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.,
Plaintiff,
v.
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY CO.,
Defendant.
ORDER
This day came the parties to this action, by counsel,
pursuant to defendant’s Motion to Dismiss on the basis
dence presented, the briefs and arguments of counsel and
has filed its letter opinion dated November 13, 1986 which
is incorporated by reference.
For the reasons set forth in the opinion letter, it is
Enter this Order: 12/17/86
/s/ Charles R. Waters, II
Judge
F “
JA-44
Filed March 4, 1988
SUPREME COURT OF VIRGINIA
Record No. 841743
Circuit Court No. L-8827-S
NANCY J. SCHWALB,
Appellant,
against
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Appellee.
Upon an appeal from a judgment rendered by the
Circuit Court of the City of Newport News on the
22nd day of August, 1984.
For reasons stated in writing and filed with the record,
the Court is of opinion that the judgment appealed from
is erroneous. Accordingly, the judgment is reversed and
annulled, and the case is remanded to the said circuit court
for trial on the merits.
This order shall be certified to the said circuit court.
A Copy,
Teste:
/s/ David B. Beach
Clerk
Appellant,
against
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Appellee.
Upon an appeal from a judgment rendered by the
Circuit Court of the City of Portsmouth on the 13th
day of June, 1985.
For reasons stated in writing and filed with the record,
the Court is of opinion that the judgment appealed from
is erroneous. Accordingly, the judgment is reversed and
annulled, and the case is remanded to the said circuit court
for trial on the merits.
This order shall be certified to the said circuit court.
A Copy,
Teste:
/s/ David B. Beach
Clerk
i el i i i i i i i i ti ei ee
JA-46
April 22, 1988
SUPREME COURT OF VIRGINIA
Record No. 870252
Circuit Court No. L86-335/L2341-86
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.,
Appellant,
against
NORFOLK & WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Appellee.
Upon an appeal from a judgment rendered by the
Circuit Court of the City of Norfolk on the 17th day
of December, 1986.
ees Gi, Ge ‘ane Pate tos as
jadgment appealed from is erroneous. Accordingly, the
judgment is reversed and annulled, and case is re-
eeSaET ts tos Gad Geek ena ee hao i te rits.
This order shall be certified to the said circu:t court.
A copy,
Teste:
David B. Beach, Clerk
By: /s/ Cynthia L. McCoy
Deputy Clerk
rege ys a
JA-47
33 U.S.C.A. § 902 (West 1986).
Gas EE GRRE cele: tar one in
sion of such marina (except for routine maintenance);
(D) individuals who (i) are employed by suppliers,
mantle any recreational vessel under sixty-five feet in
length;
(G) a master or member of a crew of any vessel;
or
(H) any person engaged by a master to load or
unload or repair any small vessel under eighteen tons
net;
Wa Ha i) lapel
ea 7 aul
sf | if 5 aA eT
UWE tal enpebeiey
fi 3 : Sat : L Ho aa it
F H dts : Hf adits Hye i
lee : “ih Hie nee aE
aoe at wii? aaj sitlss trubistk
JA-49
i tiie
1 Hy
i
&
HONORABLE DOUGLAS M. SMITH, JUDGE
[T:3] (The Court Reporter was duly sworn.)
JA-51
Court: What’s your last name please?
Mr. Nexsen: Mine?
Court: Yes.
Mr. Nexsen: Nexsen, N-E-X-S-E-N.
Court: All right, Mr. West, we're here on your mo-
tion, I believe in the special plea to the jurisdiction.
Mr. West: Yes sir.
Court: You want to call some witnesses?
Mr. West: Yes sir, Mr. Overman, Mr. Gross, Mr.
McCarthy.
[T:4] Court: Come up, please.
(At this time, the witnesses were duly sworn.)
Court: You all want to separate them?
JA-52
F ;
+
ri.
8
bu ie:
Hl i aH
| i He .
i i :
HE 4 i
ntti ay F
se iy tik (i
3 ' +
ay ade ;
eit
a lle
eT
JA-54
Q In what capacity?
A Electrical foreman.
Q Mr. Overman, were you on duty on January 12, 1983
JA-55
A Yes.
Let show and ask if
Be htt my - 1 eal
A Yes, this is a walkway between the hoppers leading
to the trunnion rollers.
Q Is that where Miss Schwalb told you she had been
injured?
A Yes.
Mr. West: We ask this be marked as Defendant's
Exhibit Number One for purpose of this hearing.
(At this time, the photograph was received and
marked as Defendant's Exhibit Number One.)
By Mr. West:
Q Now, let me show you two other photographs—let me
ask you if you just recognize what's shown in those pho-
Mr. West: We ask these be merked.
(At this time, the two photographs were received and
marked as Defendant's Exhibits [T:10] Numbers Two and
Three.)
; 3 r:
sj e7 3
fyb, fag
a il!
i eidada aif
DENIS e Sea
este ca ae
Q Would you describe the areas of the [T:12] sweeping
that she was assigned to do?
A You mean the size of the area or where it is?
Q Where.
A It’s the mechanical office that sits near the bulkhead
and the shop is directly behind it.
Q Her job as a laborer, that is an unskilled job, is that
right?
A Yes, that’s it basically.
Q And her duties did not involve the actual loading of
coal, did it?
A Well, without her job, loading couldn’t continue.
Q You didn’t answer my question.
A All right.
Q Did it involve the actual loading of coal?
A No, no.
Q Did it involve the actual unloading [T:13] of coal?
A No.
A Laborers have been, but she wasn’t.
Q That’s who I am directing my questions to. Miss
Schwalb’s duties.
A No.
Q She was never required to go aboard a ship?
A No.
Q Her primary duties then was general clean-up, is that
right?
A Clean-up of trash coal. You see, we have other la-
borers that ordinarily clean the locker rooms and equip-
ment. This is just something for general housekeeping
before the next shift comes on.
Q Do you know which Union she belongs to?
A Unit?
Q Union.
A Union?
[T:14]Q Yes.
A Laborers’ Union.
Q Do you have the name?
A Oh, no.
Q That is not a Longshoremens’ Union in any event, is
that right?
A Not that I’m aware of.
Q That includes not only the piers, but the office, the
yards, the junctions and areas in the railroad facilities, is
that correct?
ae
Q I'm talking in general.
A In general, laborers do, yes.
[T:15}Q And this clean-up duties then is not unique to the
pier area, is that right?
A Well, that’s the only place they clean up trash coal.
Q Her duties did not include only cleaning up trash coal?
A Laborers can be assigned to various duties.
Q I understand that.
assigned to just clean the locker rooms, but if a person
to a certain section, each night or each shift,
then that’s his job for that shift.
Q The laborers’ clean up duties that involved, they in-
volved the whole facility, not only just on the pier?
Ms. Li: I’m talking about clean-up duties in general.
[T:16]A The clean-up duties of laborers are the position
to which they are assigned.
By Ms. Li:
Q The clean-up duties of laborer include the whole fa-
cility, is that right?
A Just the Mechanical—the Mechanical Department la-
borers have an assigned section they clean. The transpor-
tation has their own laborers that clean other sections.
Q How far in terms of feet or yardage is the dumper
from the shore line on water edge?
A Not more than three hundred foot, I would think.
Q And how far is the pier, specifically Pier 14, how
long is that pier?
A Mr. Gross could probably could answer that. | really
- I'd say probably 1200 foot, but that’s a guess. I've seen
it, but I can’t remember.
Ms. Li: That’s all I have. Thank you.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
JA-61
A No sir.
Q Did she work up in the yards?
A That’s right. :
Q Is that 45 minutes out of an eight hour shift?
A Yes.
Q What would she be doing in the other seven hours
approximately, seven hours and 15 minutes?
A Other than 20 minutes for lunch, she would be clean-
ing coal.
Q Now, would this be between the dumper and the end
of the pier?
Mr. West: That’s all I have.
RECROSS DIRECTION {sic}
(T:18] By Ms. Li:
Q One more question. When you say clearing coal, can
you describe in more detail? How does she clear coal?
A They have a shovel and they also have a scraper, a
piece of metal attached to the rod that they rake the coal.
Q And what happens to the coal?
A The coal falls to the dock where it’s cleaned up again.
Pui back on the belts.
a. ccs — ee ee —_— _—— a ee Yee
; :
JA-62
Q She had no duties as far as putting the coal back on
the belt?
A No.
Ms. Li: That’s all I have. Thank you.
Mr. West: As a matter of fact, Mr. Overman, once
a Mechanical Department laborer takes the coal and puts
it on the ground, because of Union restrictions, is
permitted to pick that coal up off the ground, is she?
A That’s right.
Mr. West: It’s the laborer in the Transportation De-
partment that has to come and do that?
That’s correct.
Court: No wonder we lose money at the [T:19] ports.
You can step down.
Mr. West: Mr. Gross.
W. C. GROSS, called as a witness by the Defendant,
having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q You're W. C. Gross, is that correct?
A That's correct.
Q And you're employed by the C and 0?
A Yes sir.
Q In what capacity?
_A General foreman, Mechanical Department at the coal
piers. .
Q Does that put you just over top of Mr. Overman in
the ordinary chain of command?
ee
JA-63
A Yes sir.
Q And you work at the coal piers at Newport News?
A Yes sir.
[T:20}Q Mr. Gross, could you give us your estimate of the
distance between dumpers at Pier 14 and the edge of the
water of the James River?
A Id say approximately 300 fee’.
Q Would you describe the area between the dumper and f
the water’s edge as an extension of Pier 14?
A Absolutely.
Q I want to show you these photographs we talked about
before. You have some familiarity with the area that Miss
A Yes sir.
Q That’s shown in Photograph Number One?
A Yes sir.
Q Can you also show the Court in Photographs Two
and Three, where the walkway shown in Photograph Num-
ber One is located?
A This area of the dumpers right here (indicating).
Q Can not be seen in the photograph?
A Can not be seen in the photograph.
Q And on Photograph Number Three, can you show it?
A The same general area, but can not be seen in this
photograph.
Q The distance between where Miss [T:21] Schwalb was
Soa ae SO Gp Oe wale © Qa OF
A I would say so.
JA-64
Q Are you—we’ve spoken before of the trunnion rollers
which is what Miss Schwalb was on her way to clean coal
from beneath. What are the trunnion rollers?
A Trunnion rollers are what support the dumper on the
end ring of each dumper, there’s a rail and this rail rolls
around these trunnion roller wheels in order for the dum-
per to turn over.
Q And how does the coal get there such as Miss Schwalb
was on the way to clean out?
A Well, it’s one of those unavoidable spills that gets in
between the dumper and down in the trunnion rollers and
it’s necessary to clean this coal out for the operation.
Q Does the spill occur when coal is being loaded aboard
ships?
A Yes sir, when the cars are turned over and the coal
falls out of the cars.
Q Now, if no one was assigned the duty of removing
spilled coal from the area of the trunnion rollers, what
would be the effect—be the effect, if any, on the coal
loading operation?
[T:22]A Well, it very seriously effects the operation be-
cause the dumpers are not free enough to turn and it also
causes undue repair.
Q Are you familiar with whether coal was in fact being
loaded off of Pier 14 at the time Miss Schwalb was injured?
A I don’t quite follow that.
Q Do you know whether coal in fact was being loade i
- aboard?
A No, I don’t know. I wasn’t on duty.
Q You are familiar with the ordinary tasks of someone
performing the job that Miss Schwalb was performing Jan-
uary 12, 1983?
JA-65
A Yes sir.
Q Can you give us your best estimate of the percentage
of time that a laborer would be removing spilled coal be-
tween the dumper and the end of the pier during an eight
hour shift?
A I’m sure it’s in excess of fifty percent of the time.
If the pier is operating; on the opposite side, it’s not
operating, they have duties to pull this coal away from
under belts and trunnion rollers on the opposite side and
the side that is operating, at various times during the shift,
it’s necessary to pull these rollers or get this coal under
these trunnion rollers on the side that is operating.
[T:23]Mr. West: Answer Miss Li, please.
CROSS EXAMINATION
BY Ms. Li:
Q Mr. Gross, the dumper is not located on the pier, is
' that right?
A It’s not on the pier itself, no.
Ms. Li: May I have one moment, your Honor.
(At this time, Ms.
Ms. Li: That’s all
Court: All right, th
conferred with Mr. Nexse
tness by the
Defendant, being duly sworn, tes follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
[T:24]Q Tell us your name, please.
JA-66
A John F. McCarthy.
Q Employed by the C and 0?
A Yes sir.
Q In what capacity?
A My title is Senior Claim Agent.
Q In that capacity, have you handled the claim of Miss
Schwalb against C and 0 for injury on January 12, 1983?
A Yes sir.
Q I hand you a document and ask if you can identify
it?
A Yes, that’s the Longshoreman Harbor Workers’ Form
LS201 which is the employee’s first notice of injury.
Mr. West: I ask that be marked as Defendant’s Ex-
hibit Number Four.
(At this time, the document was received and marked
as Defendant’s Exhibit Number Four.)
By Mr. West:
Q Is Exhibit Number Four one of the initial documents
that are filed with the US Department of Labor to bring
the claim under the Longshoremens and Harbor Workers’
Compensation Act?
[T:25]A Yes, it is.
Q Would you read in item 17 over the signature of
Nancy Schwalb and the date of January 14, 1983, what
that says?
A “I am requesting the employer named in item seven
to provide me appropriate compensation and medical care
for my injury and I hereby make claim for all benefits to
which I may be entitled under the Longshoremen and Har-
bor Workers’ Compensation Act or a related law.”’
JA-67
Court: What paragraph was that?
Mr. West: 17.
By Mr. West:
Q And under that act, has the C and O paid monies to
Miss Schwalb since the date of her accident?
A Yes sir.
Q Payments every two weeks?
A Bi-weekly payments.
Q And through May 29, 1984, how much money has the
C and O paid to Miss Schwalb under the act?
A $20,409.12. .
Q Are payments current?
A Yes.
Q She still is receiving payments?
A That’s correct.
Q Does the US Department of Labor [T:26] under this
act have a rehabilitation program?
A Yes.
Q Are you familiar whether Miss Schwalb was in con-
tact with the US Department of Labor to obtain rehabil-
itation services?
A Yes, I have received correspondence from the office
of Workmens’ Compensation Program, Miss Schwalb has
been in contact with Mr. Gerald Wright, who is the re-
habilitation specialist for the Workmens’ Compensation
Programs.
Mr. West: Answer Miss Li.
Ms. Li: I have no questions.
JA-68
Court: Thank you, sir. You may step down.
Mr. West: That’s the Defendant’s evidence in support
of its special plea.
Court: The Defendant rests.
Ms. Li: Your Honor, I'd like to call Miss Nancy
Schwalb.
Court: All right.
NANCY SCHWALB, called as a witness in her own
behalf, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
(T:27] DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Ms. Li:
Q Your name is Nancy Schwalb?
A Yes.
Q And you’re the Plaintiff in this case?
A Yes.
Q You were injured on January 12, 1983 while you were
performing duties for the C and 0 Railroad?
A Yes.
Q Would you please tell the Court the duties that you
were assigned to, that night?
A That night I was assigned, they had just shut down
the coal pier, so I was assigned to do a specially thorough
cleaning of trunnion rollers, make an inspection of the
tower, and continue the duties that I have every night,
which were sweeping the shop, sweeping the locker rooms,
sweeping the office, the oil house, and the lunch area.
Q Let me back up a bit. What shifts did you work?
Q The third shift.
JA-69
Q That is from what hours?
A 11 p.m. to seven a.m.
(T:28]Q Would you please tell the Court how much time
you spent in—on an average day, how much time you spent
on a given job you just described?
A Okay, they had just—well, the jobs clearing the coal
from the tower and the dumper only take, combined, only
take an hour or two in the shift. And then they had, just
because of that, just assigned several other clean-up duties
to the third shift laborer in order to fill out the shift. So
they had filled out the shift with about another six hours
of sweeping up and cleaning up in the locker rooms, in
the office and in the shop.
Q Did your duties include work on the pier?
A Not on the—walk out to the pier to get to the tower.
Q The tower is on the pier?
A Yes.
Q How much time do you spend working or clearing
coal from the tower?
A Well, the job that I do on the tower is mostly cleaning
the coal from underneath the shuttle belt and that can
only be done when the machinery is not running. They
only shut the machinery down for half an hour during the
shift change so it’s only about a half hour that I spend
on the tower.
[T:29]Q How about working on the dumper area?
A The dumper area, it takes an hour to two hours.
Q And the remaining time of your work, you’re involved
in what?
A Sweeping and cleaning, like I said, there had just
been normally the laborers didn’t have much to do on the
JA-70
third shift, so they had just filled out the duties of the
third shift laborers with a lot of clean-up duties.
Q At the time of your injury, were there loading activ-
ities on Pier 14?
A No. They weren’t loading any coal. They had just
shut down.
Q Where you ever assigned to load or unload coal?
A No.
Q Were you ever assigned to operate any of the ma-
chinery?
A No.
Q Which Union do you belong to?
A The International Brotherhood of Firemen and Oilers.
Q And is that a Railroad Union or Longshoremens’
Union?
(T:30]A Railroad Union.
Q Have you ever been aboard a ship?
A No.
Q You received Longshoremen Workers’ Compensation,
is that right?
A Yes.
Q Do you have any other income aside from that ben-
efit?
A No.
Q Tell me why did you accept the benefits?
A Well, I started getting the checks before I had gotten
a lawyer, and I had no idea that I had any choice other
than that, and I had no income whatsoever. I had been
JA-71
in the hospital for a while and I had a lot of bills to take
care of, and I needed it just to live on.
Ms. Li: That’s all I have. Thank you.
CROSS EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q Miss Schwalb, are you willing to give the C and 0
back its $21,000 approximately that you received over the
last better than a year?
(T:31]JA If they would give me some other form of com-
pensation, yes.
Q I see. Have you seen Exhibit Number Four, the doc-
ument L-201 Form?
A Yes.
Q Is that your signature on there?
A I believe so, but on January 14, I was still in the
hospital.
Q In fact, January 14, you came back to the C and 0
and filled out your required accident report, didn’t you?
A From my medical records, I was still in the hospital.
Q Let’s not talk about your medical records. Let’s talk
about what you remember. Did you sign out of the hospital
for a short period of time while you were in it and come
back to the C and 0 and fill out your accident report form?
A No.
Q You did not? Is this your signature or is it not?
A I’m pretty sure that’s my signature, but I know I
was in the hospital on the 14th.
Q With everyone of those checks you received over the
past almost a year and a half, you get a [T:32] letter
that’s signed by Mr. McCarthy, don’t you?
JA-72
A Yes.
Q That letter tells you this check is payment for you
under the Longshoremen and Harbor Workers’ Compen-
sation Act?
A Yes.
Q And you received, when did you hire a lawyer?
A Several months after I had been injured.
Q So you received a fair number of these checks since
you hired a lawyer?
A Yes.
Q Did you ever send any of them back?
A I can’t.
Q You can’t send them back?
A No, I have nothing to live on other than those checks.
Q I understand. You think you’re different than any
other employee injured while working for the C and O?
A I don’t understand what you mean.
Q Well, a lot of people do get injured while working
for the C and O, have no source of income and don’t get
paid under the Longshoremens’ Act; do you feel you're
entitled to more than those people?
[T:33]A No.
Q Your attorneys have never told you to send one of
these checks back, have they?
A No.
Q In fact, during the—since the date of your accident,
you have changed your residence—your mailing address,
have you not?
A Yes.
JA-73
Q You went to Mr. McCarthy, asked him to change the
address for yop to receive the checks?
A Yes.
Q And on two occasions, the checks got lost in the mail,
I believe. You went to Mr. McCarthy, told him you wanted
new checks issued?
A Yes.
Q And he did?
A Yes.
Q Would you take either Exhibit Two or Three, the
overall aerial views. Let’s take Number Two. I assume
you recognize what’s shown in that photograph?
A Yes.
Q Would you show the Court where the office is that
you sweep?
A This brick building here (indicating).
Q Would you say that the total size [T:34] of that office
is slightly bigger than this Courtroom?
A Around the same size.
Q And where it’s showing—show where the locker room
is?
A The building right to the left (indicating).
Q How does the size of the interior of the locker room
compare with the size of this Courtroom?
A Around the same size. Slightly bigger.
Q And how about the shop, would you show the Court
where the shop is?
A This building here (indicating).
Q How big is the shop compared to the size of this
Courtroom?
JA-74
A I think it’s a little bigger.
Q Okay. Would you say that it is accurate to describe
the total area of the shop, the locker room and the office,
as being say, four times the size of this Courtroom?
A Yes, for those three buildings, yes.
Q And each night you sweep them out?
A Those and two others.
Q And two others?
A Yes.
(T:35]Q What are the other two?
A The oil house.
Q How big is the oil house compared—
A The oil house is smaller than the Courtroom.
Q Can you show the Court where the oil house is?
A This building here (indicating). My duties were never
more than sweeping it. And then another locker room.
This other building here.
Q All of those in the same proximity to each other,
doesn’t require long walk to get from one to the other?
A No, my duties in those two buildings required more
than sweeping.
Q Total of six hours you spent in those areas?
A Yes.
Mr. West: That’s all I have.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
By Ms. Li:
JA-75
Q What other duties besides sweeping were you en-
gaged in in those two buildings?
(T:36]A Well, in the oil house, I had to clean up any spilled
oil which takes quite a while and then in the women’s
locker room, I had to do a complete clean up, I had to
clean the sinks, commodes, showers, floors, that’s about
it in the women’s locker room.
Q You work on the third shift, is that right?
A Yes. ¥
Court: I’m sorry. What was the question?
By Ms. Li:
Q You worked on the third shift, is that right?
A Yes.
Q Did the—was there—excuse me, was there coal being
loaded on an average third shift, not on the day of the
accident, but on the third shift?
A Yes.
Q And when coal was being loaded,you would not be
able to work underneath the trunnion rollers, is that right?
A No, I could work under the trunnion rollers when the
coal was being loaded, but I couldn’t work on the tower
or on any of the belts.
Ms. Li: That’s all I have.
(T:37] RECROSS EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q Miss Schwalb, where does the spilled coal come from?
A From the coal cars in the trunnion rollers comes from
the coal cars.
JA-76
Q This occurs when the coal cars are turned upside
down and the coal is dumped into the hoppers?
A Yes.
Mr. West: That’s all I’ve got.
Ms. Li: Thank you.
Court: Would you say that—how many days a week
do you work?
A Five.
Court: Of those five days a week, how many of those
five days do you work six hours cleaning, sweep-
ing,cleaning up oil, 20 minutes for lunch, which leaves you
an hour and 45 minutes to do coal, how many days do
you do that?
A All five.
Court: All five?
A Yes, I formerly had a job that was nothing but
sweeping the shop, took an eight hour shift on the former
job of mine.
[T:38] Court: All right. Thank you. All right, anything
else, Miss Li?
Ms. Li: Not for evidence, your Honor, unless you—
you would hear some oral argument.
Court: All right. All mght, Mr. West.
Mr. West: I’d like*to bring Mr. Overman back to
make a point.
Court: All right.
M. L. OVERMAN, recalled as a witness by the Defendant
in rebuttal, having been previously duly sworn, testified
as follows:
JA-77
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q Mr. Overman, to your knowledge, as foreman in the
Mechanical Department of C and O at Newport News, in
January of 1983, did you have any laborer in your de-
partment working the third shift who spent six hours of
eight hours sweeping up and cleaning up in an oil room?
A No, that—I mean—I wouldn’t—no.
(T:39] Mr. West: That’s all.
Court: All right.
Ms. Li. No questions.
JA-78
JA-79
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF PORTSMOUTH
LAW NO. L-83-327
WILLIAM T. MCGLONE,
Plaintiff,
V.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
Portsmouth, Virginia
Marck 29, 1985
Before:
HONORABLE LESTER E. SCHLITZ, CHIEF JUDGE
[T:13] ROBERT E. LAYNE, JUNIOR, called as a wit-
ness by the Defendant, being duly sworn, testified as fol-
lows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
RICHARD WRIGHT WEST, appearing for defendant.
By Mr. West:
Q State your name, please.
A Robert E. Layne, Junior.
Q And by whom are you employed, Mr. Layne?
A By the Chessie System.
Q And what is your position with Chessie?
A Electrician.
JA-80
Q And what department do you work in at Newport
News?
A Mechanical Department.
Q Do you know the Plaintiff, William McGlone?
A Yes sir, I do.
[T:14]Q He works also for C & 0?
A He did at the time, yes.
Q All right. You mean at the time of his accident?
A Yes.
Q What was his job?
A He was a laborer to clean up spilled coal around the
belts on the towers.
Q What was his—what department did he work in?
A He worked in the Mechanical Department.
Q Did he work under you?
A Yes, he did.
Q Was he working under your authority on February
1, 1983, when he was injured?
A He was.
Q Would you tell the Court where he was working when
he was injured?
A He was under the dumper cleaning coal off of the
belt between one and three main belts.
Q What would you describe as Mr. McGlone’s primary
job as a laborer in the Mechanical Department at Newport
News?
A His primary job was to keep, [T:15] clean up spilled
coal.
JA-81
Q Where would this spilled coal be located?
A Well, between the belts under the dumpers and on
the towers.
Q What percentage of an average eight hour shift would
you say Mr. McGlone would spend in cleaning up spilled
coal between the dumper and the towers?
A I would say a little over fifty per cent of his time
was contributed to that.
Q I’m going to show you a photograph, and ask if you
can identify what’s shown. Show it to Mr. Brahm first.
(At this time, the photograph was shown to Mr.
Brahm.)
By Mr. West:
Q Can you identify what’s shown on the photograph?
A These are the dumpers that—where they dump the
coal for loading the ships at Pier Fourteen.
Mr. West: I would ask that be marked as
Defendant’s—
Court: I’ll mark it as Defend[T:16]ant’s Exhibit Num-
ber One for the purposes of this proffer.
(At this time, the photograph was received and
marked as Defendant’s Exhibit Number One.)
By Mr. West:
Q Now, if we can get it so you can show the Judge
what you're talking about. Can you stand up, Mr. Layne?
A Sure.
Q In this fashion, would you show the Court where the
towers are?
A Well, this is your loading tower right here (indicat-
ing).
\
JA-82
Q What is this water?
A This is the river.
Q Which river?
A James River. This is the pier.
Q What does the tower do; what’s its purpose?
A The purpose of the tower is to distribute coal all over
the ship or barge, whichever it may be.
Court: Who employed this man, [T:17] do you know?
A Who employed Mr. McGlone?
Court: Yes.
AC&O.
Court: C & 0 Railroad?
A Yes.
By Mr. West:
Q What is the tower located on?
A It is located on the pier itself.
Q All right. Would you show the Court, use it with this
pen, by drawing an arrow, well, first, can you see in this
Exhibit Number One the place where Mr. McGlone was
when he was injured?
A Not according to this picture, you can’t see. But you
can get the vicinity in which he would be.
Q Why is it you can’t see it on this photograph?
A Because he is on ground level, and you can’t see
through all of that.
Court: You say ground level?
A In other words—
JA-83
Court: What was under his feet, dirt or piling or
what?
[T:18]A No, concrete.
Court: Concrete?
A Yes sir.
Court: Is that concrete on land or water?
A Land.
By Mr. West:
Q Would you draw an arrow to the location which is
shown above where Mr. McGlone was when he was in-
jured?
A Mr. McGlone was under -
Q Under where you show it?
A Under where the arrow is shown, yes.
Q What is the—what is around that, what is this long
thing, both of them next to the end of that arrow?
A This is the incline; these are the dumpers right here,
and this is the operator’s cab (indicating).
Q Would you explain to the Court, using this photo-
graph, how coal is—how coal gets from coal cars, railroad
coal cars onto, say, this ship or barge that’s shown in the
photograph?
[T:19]A Well, the cars are pulled up this incline, placed
on the dumper, turned completely over, into a hopper,
which is fed out to the—on the main belts.
Q Where are the main belts?
A This—are your main belts right here (indicating). This
is number one and number three (indicating).
Q When the cars are turned over at the dumper, and
the coal, by gravity, is dropped down, is it one continuous
movement in there to the ship?
JA-84
A Yes, it is.
Court: All right, sir.
By Mr. West:
Q Now, what is the distance, if you know, from the
place where Mr. McGlone was injured to the edge of the
water of the James River?
A I would say between two hundred fifty to three
hundred feet.
Q Okay. And tell us specifically what it was that Mr.
McGlone was doing when he was injured?
A Well, there was some spillage of coal between the
belts and the ground, which would shift the belt over and
make it run to one side, which would cause more spillage.
And he was cleaning that coal out at the time, and he
got his arm caught in the belt and the roller.
(T:20}Q Was coal being loaded aboard a barge at the time
this happened?
A I do believe it was a barge.
Q Some sort of a vessel?
A Either—I would say there was s ship on one side and
a barge on the other.
Q All right. Now, what would occur if the spilled coal
in this instance would not be removed?
A Well, you would have damage to the belt, and you
would eventually have to shut down your operation to
clean it up, which would take twice the time delay.
Q Did Mr. McGlone, while working under you, have any
duties that were away from the pier area?
A Not while working for me, he did not.
Q Ever work up in the general yard?
JA-85
A Not for me, he didn’t.
Court: Who do you work for?
A I work for the C & 0.
By Mr. West:
[T:21]Q Did Mr.—was Mr. McGlone ever called upon to
clean an office or empty trash cans?
A Only on occasions when there was no ship or coal to
be cleaned up, he would be asked to sweep the office floor
or empty the trash can.
Q Routinely, without specific instructions, would Mr.
McGlone’s duties include cleaning up an office or emptying
trash cans?
A No.
Mr. Brahm: Is that while working for you or working
for other people?
A Well, any time.
RUSSELL N. BRAHM, III, appearing for plaintiff.
Mr. Brahm: How can you say what other people—
A I can’t tell what the other man -
Court: You'll get a chance to cross examine him.
By Mr. West:
Q Talking about this job, Mr. McGlone was performing
and had performed before—
A Right.
Q Did it include as a routine, without specific instruc-
tions, cleaning offices or trash cans?
A No, it was not a routine job.
[T:22]Q Do laborers, such as the job Mr. McGlone had,
ever go aboard ships?
JA-86
A On special occasions they may be asked to go to clean
coal off of a beam on the boom.
Q So, again, that would be cleaning spilled coal?
A That’s cleaning spilled coal.
Mr. West: Answer Mr. Brahm, please.
CROSS EXAMINATION
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. Layne, you worked for the railroad about thirty-
eight years, haven’t you?
A Yes.
Q You consider yourself a good employee, don’t you?
A I hope so.
Q Okay. How long did Mr. McGlone work for you, sir?
A Maybe three or four months.
Q Okay. So you don’t know really what he did prior to
that three or four months, do you?
A Well, I had seen him around.
(T:23]Q But you don’t know what his specific duties be-
cause he worked for someone else, isn’t that true?
A He did.
Q Now, isn’t it true that when Mr. McGlone was injured
the belts were running at that time?
A Yes.
Q Are you familiar with the Safety Rule 196, sir?
A Yes sir.
Q I show you Rule 196, and ask you if you can read
it for the record, please.
JA-87
A “Before performing’’—
Mr. West: We would note our objection to the evi-
dence, whether we violated the safety rule or not, has
nothing to do with the issue of Longshoremen’s and Har-
borworkers’ Compensation Act.
Court: Overrule your objection, and allow you to read
it in the record for a proffer.
A “Before performing any work on conveyor belts or
rollers or stepping on or across belts, employees must take
necessary precautions to assure that such equipment is
stopped and that movement is not resumed until work has
been completed and all employees are in the [T:24] clear.”
By Mr. Brahm:
Q You were with Mr. McGlone at the time he was in-
jured, isn’t that true, or shortly before that time?
A Yes, I was.
Q And you instructed Mr. McGlone to clean out under-
neath the belt while it was moving, did you not?
A I asked him to clean the coal out, yes, I did.
Q And the reason why the belts were moving was be-
cause the belts were indirectly loading the barge Maryland
or that other ship at that time?
A True, they were directly loading the ship.
Court: Did he have anything to do with the actual
putting the coal on the belt, or was he just cleaning it
out when it dropped off?
A No sir, he does not have anything to do with putting
it on the belt.
Court: He wasn’t loading that coal; he was cleaning
up the debris?
A He was cleaning it up.
JA-88
Court: All right, sir.
[T:25] By Mr. Brahm:
Q And he doesn’t put that coal he cleans up back on
the belt, does he?
A No sir, that comes under another department.
Q Now, you never saw Mr. McGlone go aboard a ship,
did you?
A No, I can’t say that I have.
Q You never ordered him to go aboard a ship, did you?
A No.’
Q You never ordered him to clean any spilled coal from
any of the ships, did you?
A No.
Q When was it you first learned that Mr. McGlone was
injured?
A When we heard him holler.
Q What did you do then?
A We went around to see what was the trouble.
Q Did you have the belt cut off?
A Well, at the time I couldn’t say that they were or
they weren’t. I really don’t remember.
Q But the belts were running at the time Mr. McGlone
was injured?
[T:26]A Right.
Mr. Brahm: I don’t have any other questions.
I do have one other question.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Can you identify this (indicating)?
JA-89
A No sir, I’ve never seen it before.
Mr. Brahm: Okay. I would like to offer this as—
Court: What is it? If he hasn’t seen it, how can you
offer it?
Mr. Brahm: Notice to employees under coverage of
the Longshoremen’s and Harborworkers’ Compensation
Act.
Mr. West: We object.
Court: Are you going to be a witness to testify what
this is?
Mr. Brahm: From a negative—
Court: I sustain the objection.
Mr. Brahm: I was just going to say—
Court: I sustain the objection.
Mr. Brahm: I don’t have any other [T:27] questions.
Court: All right. You can step outside.
Mr. West: Mr. Gross.
WILLIAM C. GROSS, called as a witness by the
Defendant, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q Tell us your full name, please.
A William C. Gross.
Q By whom are you employed?
A Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company.
Q Your position?
JA-90
A General Foreman in the Mechanical Department.
Q As such, is Mr. Layne underneath you?
A Yes sir.
[T:28]Q And would Mr. McGlone have been under him?
A Yes sir.
Q What was Mr. McGlone’s job in the area of February
1, 1983?
A He was employed as a laborer in the Mechanical De-
partment.
Q What is the primary job of a—
Court: Employed by whom, sir?
A Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company.
By Mr. West:
Q What is the primary job of a laborer in the Mechanical
Department of C & 0 in Newport News?
A To clean up trash coal as we call it, coal spillage off
the belts, and so forth, from loading coal.
Q Do you have some estimate of the percentage of time
that a laborer in the Mechanical Department of C & 0 at
Newport News, such as Mr. McGlone, would have spent
in cleaning up spilled or trash coal?
A Yes sir, well in excess of fifty per cent of his time.
Q Were you present when Mr. [T:29] McGlone was in-
jured February 1, 1983?
A No, I was not.
Court: You keep any records what per cent of time
he works during that against other time?
A No sir.
JA-91
Court: Mr. McGlone, specificially, you got any records
of what time he does that and what time he does his other
duties?
A No sir.
Court: You’re speculating as fifty per cent, well over
fifty per cent, are you? ;
A Well, the laborer’s job—
Court: Talking about Mr. McGlone.
A I’m speaking of the laborer in general.
Court: I want to know about Mr. McGlone.
A He was employed as a laborer to clean up trash coal.
Court: Do you have any records or any knowledge
of how much time he spent—
A No sir.
By Mr. West:
[T:30]Q You have such records on any laborer?
A No sir.
Q Are you aware of the place that Mr. McGlone was
when he was injured?
A Yes sir.
Q Do you know the distance from that place to the edge
of the water of the James River?
A Approximately three hundred feet.
Q And what is—between where Mr. McGlone was in-
jured and the edge of the water of the James River?
A Well, it’s the dumper and the main belt drive for the
belts, and the belt structure.
Q What is the—what happens from the time that the
coal cars are turned upside down at the dumper, and
JA-92
dropped by gravity, until that coal gets aboard a ship or
barge?
A When the cars are turned over on the dumper, the
coal free falls into a hopper, it’s fed by feeder belts onto
the main belt. The main belt takes it out the pier from
under the dumper, up the incline to the tower, where it’s
dumped onto the shuttle belt. From there the shuttle belt
is able to carry the coal from either side to [T:31] either
side of the pier, north or south side. From there it’s
dumped onto the boom belt and off the boom belt down
through the chute into the hold of the ship.
Q From the dumper to the pier, is that a straight line?
A Yes sir.
Q Is the movement of the coal from the dumper to the
tower and then onto the ship one continuous movement
while loading is going on?
A Yes.
Q Now, what happens if the spilled coal or the trash
coal is not removed?
A Well, good possibility if it gets bad enough, it can
cause damage to the equipment; therefore, it can be—could
be a major catastropife, and cut you down where you can’t
operate at all.
Court: What happens to the coal that’s spilled? Is
that used again?
A It’s cleaned up, picked up and stored, and put back
in cars. I don’t know how it’s disposed of or where it
goes once it’s put back in cars.
Court: Not thrown away as trash?
A Trash coal is an expression.
Court: I’m talking about the [T:32] coal itself, it’s
used somewhere again?
JA-93
A Yes.
Court: Have you ever done this kind of work yourself?
A No sir, not primarily employed for it, no.
Court: You have never done it either. Have you ever
done cleaning?
A I’ve used a shovel and a pick, and so forth, but it’s
not my primary job.
By Mr. West:
Q Do laborers in the Mechanical Department of the C
& 0 at Newport News go aboard ships?
A They have done it.
Q For what purpose?
Court: How about Mr. McGlone?
A I couldn't tell you anything specifically about Mr.
McGlone. Whether he has been aboard a ship or not.
Mr. Brahm: I’m going to go ahead and object to any
question—
Court: I object to what laborers, some laborers do,
because—I sustain the objection to that. It’s what Mr.
McGlone’s duties were.
By Mr. West:
(T:33]Q You're not aware of whether he ever did go aboard
a ship?
A I have no personal knowledge of it, no sir.
Q Have you ever been aboard a ship with a laborer by
the name of John Fox to clean up coal?
Mr. Brahm: I object to that.
Court: Sustain the objection.
JA-94
Mr. West: I understand Mr. Fox is going to be a
witness.
Court: It’s what this man’s duties are.
Mr. Brahm: I may not call him as a witness.
Mr. West: Then it is irrelevant.
Court: I sustain the objection. It’s regarding this par-
ticular man’s duties.
Mr. West: We except to that. I don’t agree it’s lim-
ited to just what this specific man did.
Court: I overrule your objection. it is what this man
was doing and what he was doing that is important here.
Mr. West: As long as I have (T:34] my exception.
Court: All right.
By Mr. West:
Q Other than when he might be—Mr. McGlone might
be specifically assigned to clean an office, empty trash
cans, what did he do?
A If the pier wasn’t operating, he had the towers to
clean up; he had the trunnion rollers to take care of and
the spilled coal on the walkways on the dumper.
Q Where are the towers located?
A Offshore.
Q On the pier?
A On the pier.
Mr. West: Answer Mr. Brahm.
CROSS EXAMINATION
By Mr. Brahm:
JA-95
Q In addition to cleaning the spilled coal, Mr. McGlone
would also: be required to clean offices out, would he not?
A Occasionally.
Q In addition to cleaning offices out, wouldn't he be
required to clean out portions of the [T:35] shop and the
locker rooms?
A Occasionally.
Q Isn’t it true he would also be required to clean out
the restroom of the office spaces that he would be working
in or other people would be working in?
A Not the office, but the locker rooms, probably.
Q Now, at the time of this accident, February 1, 19—
1983, did the Chessie System have certain safety rules
that were in force?
A Yes.
Q I show you a copy of the safety rules here, and I'd
like to ask you if you would read Rule 196.
Court: Hasn’t that—
Mr. Brahm: That was the other—that wasn’t intro-
duced either.
Mr. West: My same objection to the relevancy.
Court: All being proffered, se I overrule your objec-
tion. Go ahead.
A Rule 196 states, “Before performing any work on
conveyor belts or rollers or stepping on or across belts,
employees must take necessary precautions [T:36] to as-
sure that such equipment is stopped and that movement
is not resumed until work has been completed and all
employees are in the clear.’’
By Mr. Brahm:
JA-96
Q Was this safety rule in effect at the time of this
accident?
A Yes sir.
Q What is the reason for having the belts stopped be-
fore any employees work underneath it?
A For safety sake.
Mr. Brahm: Judge, we'd like to offer this as Plaintiff's
Number One.
Court: Received over his objection as Plaintiff's Ex-
hibit One.
(At this time, the document was received and marked
as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number One.)
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Now, if the belts were not running, then the barge
or the ship that was being loaded couldn't be loaded, is
that true?
A That’s true for that particular side, yes.
Q So if the belts were stopped, in accordance with the
safety rules, then the ship wouldn't [T:37] be loaded?
A Not for that period of time.
Q Now, how long did Mr. McGlone work for you, sir?
A I don’t have any record of that. I don’t know what
his employment dates were.
Q Mr. Layne testified he worked approximately four
months for Mr. Layne. Would that refresh your recollec-
tion, or would that give you some idea how much time he
worked for you?
A Well—
Q Mr. Layne worked for you?
JA-97
A For the same period of time, for that same period
of time, it would still—
Court: You say you don’t know. I don’t think you
can ask him what somebody else said.
Mr. Brahm: The only reason I did that, I thought
since Mr. Layne worked for Mr. Hamilton or Mr. Gross,
that perhaps he could probably—but if you don’t know of
your own free knowledge—that’s all the questions I have.
Court: Anything further?
Mr. West: Nothing further.
Court: You're excused, sir.
Mr. West: That concludes the [T:38] C & O proffer
of evidence.
*> *+ *
(T:67] WILLIAM C. McGLONE, called as a witness in
his own behalf, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, will you please state your address, for
the record?
A 1035 - 41st Street, Newport News, Virginia.
(T:68}Court: What's your name?
A William C. McGlone.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, on February 1, 1983, by whom were
you employed?
AC & 0 Railroad.
JA-98
Q I see. And what were you doing, what kind of job
did you have with the C & 0 Railway?
A Laborer. Janitorial work.
Q When did you begin working for the C & 0 Railroad,
sir?
A °70.
Q Would you briefly tell the Court what type of jobs
you had from 1970?
Court: What were you doing on this particular day
you were hurt?
A I was on Pier Fifteen side, was cleaning up. Like
they have Pier Fifteen, they shut down, they clean up the
motor room and the big room in there. You got to sweep
the floor and get the paper over on that side.
And Mr. Layne called me on the radio to meet him
on the dumper over on Pier Fourteen. And he asked
when I got over there, he asked me would I clean out t
belt over there, number three belt. And I told him, I
I asked him to shut it down, which I asked him that [T:
What were
ekea gy
on the radio, and—
Court: You went over to clean it out.
supposed to clean out on the belt?
A The coal spilling.
Court: Falling off the belt?
A The belt was torn, three or four inches torn off, and
it was falling down underneath that.
Court: Was that a job you generally did?
A No sir.
Court: What was your work totally, what do you do
from day to day?
JA-99
A From day to day, we clean up most bathrooms, bunk-
house, they didn’t—even need us at Pier Fourteen. They
would come and get us to send us to the—just to the
bunkhouse, making up beds, clean up the caboose, engine
and things like that.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q During that period of time, was there a lot of coal
loading on ships?
A I don’t know. I think they was loading, I don’t know
for sure what they were loading out there. They had a
lot of work coming in and out at that period of time.
[T:70]Q Mr. McGlone, were you ever required, as part of
your duties to go aboard a ship?
A No. never have.
Q Where you ever required, as part of your duties, to
load any coal aboard any ships?
A No
Court: You ever load coal on the belts?
A No sir.
By Mr: Brahm:
Q What would you do with this spilled coal that would
fall down between the belts?
A Well, that wasn’t my job. It come under transpor-
tation. They would clean it up.
Q So your job would only be to blow the coal out?
A Well, no, it wouldn’t. He just insisted me come over
there and blow it out. If they do that, it mostly would be
shut down, they would come up and get us. We working
one side, and they put us on the other side to clean up
over there sometime.
JA-100
Court: How often did you do that?
A Often as they come and get us.
Court: How often was that, (T:71] every day, every
other day?
A Sometimes practically every other day or every day
sometimes.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, how long did you work for the Me-
chanical Department just before this accident?
A From '76, the twelfth month and the ninth day of
"76.
Q How long did you work for Mr. Layne?
A Well, I was working underneath him off and on from
'76 on, until the accident. We have different shifts. I would
be under him every time since I have been there.
Q Mr. McGlone, have you ever been injured while you
worked for the railroad before?
A Yes, I have.
Q How many times, sir?
A I guess about four times, if I am not mistaken, I
believe four times.
Q Do you recall an injury that. you had in July of 1982?
A Yes, on that same belt.
Q Where was that injury, sir? Was that on the land or
over the water?
[T:72JA On land.
Q Was it closer to the water than where you were in-
jured this time?
A It was closer, yes, than where I was at that time.
JA-101
Mr. Brahm: Can I look at Plaintiff's Exhibit Number
Two, Judge? I think it’s a photograph.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q I’ll show you what has been previously admitted as
Plaintiff's Exhibit Number Two, and ask you if you can
identify the photograph, first, and if you can show us
where you were injured in July of 1982.
Why don’t you stand up and point it out to the Judge.
A Right in here on the outside of this dumper, right
down in here underneath where part of this is at (indi-
cating).
Court: Put an ‘“‘X’’ where you say it was.
(At this time, the witness complied with the request
of the Court.)
A Somewhere in here (indicating).
Court: Write down hard on it [T:73] with an “X.”
Right there (indicating)?
A Yes.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q What were you doing at the time of this injury?
A We was washing the belt, the coal out from under-
neath the belt with high pressure hose.
Q All right. And was the belts on or were they off?
A No, they was shut down. They was working the other
side. They always shut down.
Q Were you ever offered any longshoremen benefits for
this injury?
Mr. West: I object to the question and the line of
questioning unless there’s some authority for an estoppel.
JA-102
Court: Let me ask you one thing here. Were you
injured at that time”
A Yes sir.
Court: Did you receive any compensation for your
injuries?
A No sir.
Court: From any source?
A No.
Mr. West: That’s the subject of [T:74] my objection.
Unless there’s some estoppel theory.
Court: I think—
Mr. Brahm: The railroad cannot have it both ways.
Court: I think it certainly can.
Mr. West: We can.
Court: I overrule your objection.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, did you settle that claim with the rail-
road company?
A Yes.
Mr. West: My objection relates to all this.
Court: Overrule your objection. It is relevant, what
type of work he was considered by the railroad and by
him.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Can you—
Mr. West: In 1982?
Court: I understand that.
JA-103
Mr. Brahm: The act they claim coverage under was
enacted in 1972.
Court: I understand.
[T:75] By Mr. Brahm:
Q Can you identify that, sir?
A Yes sir.
Q What is that, sir?
A This was the thing where I signed to settle the claim
when I got hurt in ’82. .
Q What did the Claim Agent tel] you, what law did he
say it was under?
A FELA.
Mr. Brahm: We'd like to have this admitted as
Plaintiff's Exhibit Four.
(At this time, the document was received and marked
as Plaintiff's Exhibit Number Four.)
Mr. West: Note our objection.
Court: All right, sir.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, are you familiar with the contract that
exists between your labor union and the railway company?
A Yes.
Q Do you know of any provision in that contract that
provides for compensation under the Longshoremen Act?
[T:76]A No sir.
Q Now, Mr. McGlone, prior to this injury in 1983, which
is the subject matter of this litigation, if you were injured,
wherever you were injured, what law or what act did you
expect to be covered under?
JA-104
Mr. West: I object.
Court: I sustain the objection. What he expected is
not relevant.
Mr. Brahm: I withdraw the question.
Mr. McGlone—Judge, may I have Plaintiff's Exhibit
Number Three, I believe it is. The notice.
(At this time, the exhibited [sic] was handed to Mr.
Brahm.)
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, in the course of your employment with
the railway company, are you required to look at bulletin
boards for notices?
A Yes—bulletin notices on the bulletin board, you have
to go there, because they put up different jobs, you check
that every day.
Q And is this—on the C & 0 pier facility?
A Yes.
(T:77)Q I ask you if you will look over Plaintiff's Exhibit
Number Three and see if you can identify that as being
posted in your—
Court: Have you ever seen a notice like that?
A No sir, never have.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Now, Mr. McGlone, were the belts moving, or were
they shut down at the time you were injured?
A They was moving.
Q Would you tell the Judge what you did just before
you were injured?
Court: Now, we’re getting into the facts of this.
JA-105
Mr. Brahm: I think it’s important, Judge, because of
the fact that he—he requested the belts be shut down.
Court: I understand that, but that’s not—we got
somewhere the FELA stuff, the Longshoremen’s and Har-
borworkers’ Act starts, and somewhere, it’s maybe here
or there, and that’s the factual situation I believe I have
to determine, but how he actually got injured doesn’t make
any difference.
The idea was what I think is [T:78] relevant, whether
he was loading or not unloading, exactly what he was
doing, which he told you he was doing. But—somewhere
there has got to be a line where one act stops and the
other one starts. And that’s what I believe I have to
determine here.
By Mr. Brahm:
Q Mr. McGlone, have you ever accepted any benefits,
compensation benefits under the Longshoremen Act?
A No sir. I didn’t know anything about it, because at
the time I was in the hospital, and when I come home
out of the hospital I had checks there at the house. And
I knew I wasn’t supposed to be getting under. He ex-
plained it to me, it comes under the maritime. And I knew
I wasn’t supposed to come under that, and I called you.
Q Did you send those checks back?
A Yes.
Q Are you receiving any benefits right now, sir?
A Yes.
Q From where?
A Railroad Retirement Board.
Q Mr. McGlone, did Mr. Layne tell you at the time of
your injury that it was important [T:79] for you to clean
JA-106
out under the belts while they were running because the
barge was being loaded?
A Yes. He insisted that I should clean out from un-
derneath the belt at the time it was running.
Q Have you ever been a member of the International
Longshoremen’s Association?
A No sir.
Mr. Brahm: That’s all the questions I have.
CROSS EXAMINATION
By Mr. West:
Q Mr. McGlone, you referred before to your agreement.
That’s the agreement between your union and the railroad
that you’re talking about?
A Yes, the Boilermakers, Oilers.
Q And you said there was nothing in there that said
that you would be covered under the Longshoremen’s and
Harborworkers’ Compensation Act?
A No, not as I know of.
Q Is there anything in there that says you won't be
covered under the Longshoremen’s and Harborworkers’
Compensation Act?
[T:80]A Well, the way they explained it to us—
Q What I’m asking, you said—
Mr. Brahm: He's trying to explain it.
Mr. West: This is what somebody told him.
By Mr. West:
Q You read the contract; is there anything in it?
A No, it’s not.
JA-107
Mr. West: That’s all I have.
Court: All right. Step outside, sir.
Mr. West: If I might make a point here. I think Mr.
Brahm will agree with it. If the Court got the impression
we are claiming the man comes under the act but are not
paying him compensation, this is pursuant to an agreement
between the C & 0 and your firm. We wouldn't just con-
tinue every two weeks sending him a check and having it
returned.
Court: Certainly not relevant for this, what we're
doing here now.
JA-108
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF PORTSMOUTH
AT LAW NO.
WILLIAM C. MCGLONE,
Plaintyf,
v.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
SERVE:
Aubrey R. Bowles, III, Esquire
Registered Agent
Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company
901 Mutual Building
Richmond, Virginia 23219
REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
Plaintiff, by counsel, pursuant to the Rules of Court,
requests that the defendant respond within twenty-eight
(28) days after service, at the offices of Moody, Strople,
Brahm & Lawrence, Ltd., 201 J. J. Henry Building, County
and Court Streets, Portsmouth, Virginia, produce or make
available for copying, or furnish the originals or copies of
the following, or permit the plaintiff to have copies made
at his expense, the following items:
1. Produce ship docking and ship departure reports for
pier 14 for February 1, 1983.
2. Produce all documents the defendant intends to rely
upon at trial or hearing in this matter.
3. Produce all Release of Claims forms executed by the
plaintiff within the last ten (10) years.
JA-109
4. Produce all Railroad Retirement Sickness Benefits
Apportionment forms executed by the plaintiff within the
last ten (10) years.
5. Produce all Notices of Compensation used by the
defendant within the last ten (10) years at its Newport
News yard.
6. Produce the plaintiff's entire personnel file.
7. Produce the plaintiff's entire medical file.
8. Copies of the lists of Railway personnel working at
the Newport News Barney yard and Pier 14 on February
1, 1983.
WILLIAM C. MCGLONE
By /s/ Russell N. Brahm, III
Of Counsel
Russell N. Brahm, III
Willard J. Moody
Moody, Strople, Brahm
& Lawrence, Ltd.
Post Office Box 1138
Portsmouth, Virginia 23704-1138
JA-110
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE
CITY OF PORTSMOUTH
LAW NO. L-83-327
WILLIAM C. MCGLONE,
Plaintiff,
vs.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR
PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
The defendant herewith responds to the plaintiff's Re-
quest For Production Of Documents and says:
1.
2.
Produced herewith to the plaintiff.
Any or all documents previously or subsequently fur-
nished by way of Answer To Interrogatories by the
defendant or in response to this or subsequent Request.
3.
PAH s
Produced herewith to the plaintiff.
Produced herewith to the plaintiff.
Produced herewith to the plaintiff.
Produced herewith to the plaintiff.
Produced herewith to the plaintiff. .
. See defendant’s Answer to Interrogatory No. 3, pre-
viously filed herein.
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO
RAILWAY COMPANY
By /s/ Richard Wright West
Of Counsel
JA-111
Richard Wright West, Esquire
WEST, STEIN, WEST & SMITH, P.C.
P. 0. Box 257
Newport News, VA 23607
Counsel for Defendant
JA-112
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
SETTLEMENT AND FINAL RELEASE OF ALL CLAIMS
Read Carefully Before Signing
The undersigned acknowledges the receipt of Two Thou-
sand & 00/100 Dollars ($2,000.00) from THE CHESA-
PEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY in full settlement and
satisfaction of all claims, demands, and causes of action
hereinafter mentioned, and in consideration of said pay-
ment hereby RELEASES and forever discharges THE
CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY, its
undersigned has or might have against them or any of
them arising out of or in any way connected with
ceived.
may be uncertain and indefinite and that injuries, damages
and losses may not now be fully known and may be more
numerous and more serious than now believed. In
this SETTLEMENT AND FINAL RELEASE the
him or her, and that this RELEASE contains the entire
agreement between the parties hereto and that all the
JA-113
terms of this RELEASE are important parts of this con-
tract and are binding upon all parties.
The word “‘injuries’’, where used in this SETTLEMENT
AND FINAL RELEASE, include all injuries which are
unknown as well as injuries which are known and includes
all consequences of such injuries which may hereafter de-
velop as well as consequences now developed. This settle-
ment is intended to be final, the undersigned taking his
or her chances that the injuries may prove to be more
serious than now believed and the other parties taking
their chances that the injuries may prove to be less serious
than now believed.
It is further understood and agreed that this is a set-
tlement by compromise of a disputed claim and that the
payment made is not to be construed as an admission of
liability, all liability being expressly denied.
I have read and understand this release W.C. Mc.
SIGNED and SEALED at N.N.VA., on this 6 day of
AUG, 1982
Witnesses Sign Here /s/ William C. McGlone
/si/ W.B. Swain
/s/ F.L. Royall
JA-114
Newport News, Virginia, August 6, 1982
The Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company having
agreed to pay the sum of xx Two Thousand & 00/100 xx
Dollars in settlement of my claim for personal injuries
received at or near Newport News, Virginia on or about
July 9, 1982, I hereby request said Railway Company to
apportion the entire amount to be paid in said settlement
to factors other than time lost. It is understood that this
request is made and this consent given for the sole purpose
of complying with the requirements of the Railroad Re-
tirement Act, the Railroad Retirement Tax Act, and the
Railroad Unemployment Insurance Act, and is not to be
so construed as to impair or limit the effect of the personal
injury settlement above mentioned or of the general re-
lease which I am to execute in consideration of said set-
tlement.
This settlement is subject to lien of the Railroad Re-
tirement Board in the amount of No lien.
/s/ William C. McGlone
Railroad Identification No. 2612047
Witnesses: /s/ W.B. Savain
/s/ F.L. Royall
The apportionment above requested is hereby made.
Executed at Richmond, Virginia on this 6th day of Au-
gust, 1982.
The Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company
By: /s/ F.R. Royall
nev. 8-71
JA-115
Invoice No. I 47392
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
1.
11.
12.
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT NUMBER
INN-0195
. AUTHORIZATION DATE
7/20/82
LAST NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE INITIAL
McGlone, William C.
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
2612047
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER
226-40-8431
. ADDRESS - NUMBER AND STREET - CITY AND STATE
- ZIP CODE
732 - 34th St., Newport News, Va. 23607
. OCCUPATION
Laborer
SEX
Male
DATE OF BIRTH
8/31/34
. AUTHORIZING OFFICER
W.C. Gross, Gen.Foreman-Piers
RESP. CODE
2024
OFFICER’S TELEPHONE
(804) 380-5080
]
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
JA-116
THIS IS FIRST REPORT
FINAL REPORT
HISTORY (INCLUDING SPECIFIC LOCATION AND DE-
SCRIPTION OF INCIDENT THAT CAUSED INJURY ON-
SET OF ILLNESS)
Patient states that he fell on a conveyor belt, sustaining
injury to his back and right hip
DATE OF INJURY OR ILLNESS
7/9/82
FINDINGS ON EXAMINATION (ATTACH RESULTS OF
X-RAYS, TESTS, OTHER STUDIES, OPERATING
NOTES, DISCHARGE SUMMARIES, ETC.)
Re: William McGlone #5697 July 22, 1982
Mr. McGlone is in the office today and he apparently
sustained an injury to his right side on July 9, 1982, when
he fell against some equipment at his job, resulting in an
injury to the mid-portion of his right thigh and the hip area.
X-rays were not performed at the time of the injury. He
was seen in the ER and evaluated for these injuries. He is
seeking an orthopaedic evaluation for an opinion as to the
nature of these injuries.
On examination, he does have signs of an injury that is
healing on the lateral aspect of his thigh, this does not
appear to be serious, but there is some swelling and soreness
around this area. We advised him that this should be treated
simply with cleansing the area and allowing it to heal over
from the sides. He also, has some soreness over the right
iliac crest. X-rays taken indicate no evidence of any frac-
tures, but there is tenderness to palpation. Moist soaks, and
moderation of activity are advised as a form of treatment.
This basically is the extent of his injuries; the diagnosis is
abrasion of the right thigh, and a contusion of the right
iliae crest. ADG/msd
DIAGNOSIS
See #15 above.
TREATMENT GIVEN PRESCRIBED (SPECIFY)
See #15 above.
18.
28.
JA-117
FURTHER TREATMENT INDICATED?
NO
. MEDICATION GIVEN PRESCRIBED?—
NO
. PATIENT HOSPITALIZED?
NO
. PATIENT TREATED BY ANYONE ELSE?—
NO
PATIENT DISPOSITION (PATIENT INSTRUCTED AS
FOLLOWS)
ABLE TO RETURN TO DUTY-NO RESTRICTIONS-ON 7/
26/82 DATE
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS SPECIFIC RECOMMENDA-
TIONS OF TREATING PHYSICIAN
See #15 above.
. TREATING PHYSICIAN SIGNATURE
/s/ A. Greene, M.D.
. DATE
7/26/82
. TREATING PHYSICIANS NAME (IF DIFFERENT FROM
PAYEE)
Arthur D. Greene, M.D.
ADDRESS - NUMBER AND STREET
2019 Cunningham Dr.
. CITY AND STATE
Hampton, VA 23666
JA-118
30. DATE ITEMIZED SERVICE SUPPLIES
7/22/82 initial visit
7/22/82 x-ray rt pelvis
31. TOTAL FEE
$75.00
RECEIVED
CHESSIE SYSTEM
AUG 2 1982
Casualty Prevention Department
BALTIMORE MARYLAND
AMOUNT
40.00
35.00
JA-119
Invoice No. I 47375
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
1.
11.
12.
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT NUMBER
INN-0195
AUTHORIZATION DATE
7/13/82
LAST NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE INITIAL
McGlone, William C.
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
2612047
. SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER
226-40-8431
ADDRESS - NUMBER AND STREET - CITY AND STATE
- ZIP CODE
732 - 34th St., Newport News, Va. 23607
. OCCUPATION
Laborer
SEX
Male
DATE OF BIRTH
8/31/34
AUTHORIZING OFFICER
W.C. Gross, Gen.Foreman-Piers
RESP. CODE
2024
OFFICER’S TELEPHONE
(804) 380-5080
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
JA-120
THIS IS FIRST REPORT
HISTORY (INCLUDING SPECIFIC LOCATION AND DE-
SCRIPTION OF INCIDENT THAT CAUSED INJURY ON-
SET OF ILLNESS)
Foot slipped while washing under, coal loading belt and fell
against metal beam hurting rt. thigh.
DATE OF INJURY OR ILLNESS
7/9/82
FINDINGS ON EXAMINATION (ATTACH RESULTS OF
X-RAYS, TESTS OTHER STUDIES OPERATING NOTES
DISCHARGE SUMMARIES ETC.)
Healing abrasion and contusion of right thigh. Strain of night
lower lumbar muscles.
DIAGNOSIS
Abrasion and contusion of thigh & back pain.
TREATMENT GIVEN PRESCRIBED (SPECIFY)
Rest, heat, fomax tablets for pain, Soaks & Neosporin Oint-
ment to abrasion.
FURTHER TREATMENT INDICATED? - DESCRIBE
YES - as above
19.
20.
21.
24.
MEDICATION GIVEN PRESCRIBED? - DESCRIBE
YES - Fomax
PATIENT HOSPITALIZED?
NO
PATIENT TREATED BY ANYONE ELSE?—
YES - ER at Riverside Hospital
PATIENT DISPOSITION (PATIENT INSTRUCTED AS
FOLLOWS)
UNABLE TO RETURN TO DUTY - ANTICIPATED LOSS
OF TIME 10 DAYS
ADDITIONAL INSTRUCTIONS - FOLLOW UP APPOINT-
MENT: ABOUT 7/20/82
TREATING PHYSICIAN SIGNATURE
/s/ Hugh Givens, Jr. MD
JA-121
25. DATE
7/13/82
RECEIVED
CHESSIE SYSTEM
AUG 2 1982
Casualty Prevention Department
BALTIMORE MARYLAND
JA-122
Invoice No. I 47393
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
1.
11.
12.
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT NUMBER
INN-0195
AUTHORIZATION DATE
7/20/82
LAST NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE INITIAL
McGlone, William C.
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
2612047
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER
226-40-8431
. ADDRESS - NUMBER AND STREET - CITY AND STATE
- ZIP CODE
732 - 34th St., Newport News, Va. 23607
. OCCUPATION
Laborer
. SEX
Male
DATE OF BIRTH
8/31/34
AUTHORIZING OFFICER
W.C. Gross, Gen. Foreman
RESP. CODE
2024
OFFICER'S TELEPHONE
(804) 380-5080
13.
14.
15.
24.
=)
JA-123
THIS IS FIRST REPORT
FINAL REPORT
HISTORY (INCLUDING SPECIFIC LOCATION AND DE-
SCRiPTION OF INCIDENT THAT CAUSED INJURY ON-
SET OF ILLNESS)
See lst report.
DATE OF INJURY OR ILLNESS
7/9/82
FINDINGS ON EXAMINATION (ATTACH RESULTS OF
X-RAYS, TESTS OTHER STUDIES OPERATING NOTES
DISCHARGE SUMMARIES ETC.)
Much improved. Laceration on thigh healing. Twinge of pain
in right lower back with certain movements.
. DIAGNOSIS
Contusion of thigh with laceration and low back strain.
. TREATMENT GIVEN PRESCRIBED (SPECIFY)
Cont. same.
. FURTHER TREATMENT INDICATED?-DESCRIBE
YES - Rest, Zomax, soak & Neosporin of ointment
. MEDICATION GIVEN PRESCRIBED?—DESCRIBE
YES - Zomax
PATIENT HOSPITALIZED”?
NO
. PATIENT TREATED BY ANYONE ELSE?
YES - ER at Riverside
PATIENT DISPOSITION (PATIENT INSTRUCTED AS
FOLLOWS)
ABLE TO RETURN TO DUTY-NO RESTRICTIONS-ON 7/
26/82 DATE
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS SPECIFIC RECOMMENDA.
TIONS OF TREATING PHYSICIAN
To work 7/26/82.
TREATING PHYSICIAN SIGNATURE
/s/ Hugh Givens, Jr.
JA-124
25. DATE
RECEIVED
CHESSIE SYSTEM
AUG 2 1982
Casualty Prevention Department
BALTIMORE MARYLAND
JA-125
Invoice No. I 47309
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT
THE CHESAPEAKE AND OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY
1.
12.
13.
ACCIDENT/INCIDENT NUMBER
INN-0195
AUTHORIZATION DATE
7/09/82
LAST NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE INITIAL
McGlone, William C.
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
2612047
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER
226-40-8431
ADDRESS - NUMBER AND STREET - CITY AND STATE
- ZIP CODE
732 - 34th St., Newport News, Va. 23607
. OCCUPATION
Laborer
SEX
Male
DATE OF BIRTH
8/31/34
. AUTHORIZING OFFICER
W.C. Gross, Gen.Foreman-Piers
. RESP. CODE
OFFICER’S TELEPHONE
(804) 380-5080
HISTORY (INCLUDING SPECIFIC LOCATION AND DE-
SCRIPTION OF INCIDENT THAT CAUSED INJURY ON-
SET OF ILLNESS)
Pt slipped and fell against some steel.
JA-126
14. DATE OF INJURY OR ILLNESS
7/9/82
15. FINDINGS ON EXAMINATION (ATTACH RESULTS OF
X-RAYS, TESTS OTHER STUDIES OPERATING NOTES
DISCHARGE SUMMARIES ETC.)
Abrasion of epidesmis - 3cm x 15cm
16. DLAGNOSIS
ten of call ;
17. TREATMENT GIVEN PRESCRIBED (SPECIFY)
Can not read.
18. FURTHER TREATMENT INDICATED?
NO
19. MEDICATION GIVEN PRESCRIBED?
NO
20. PATIENT HOSPITALIZED”
NO
21. PATIENT TREATED BY ANYONE ELSE?
NO
22. PATIENT DISPOSITION (PATIENT INSTRUCTED AS
FOLLOWS)
ABLE TO RETURN TO DUTY-NO RESTRICTIONS-ON 7/
26/82 DATE
23 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS SPECIFIC RECOMMENDA-
TIONS OF TREATING PHYSICIAN
Can not read.
24. TREATING PHYSICIAN SIGNATURE
‘s/ Hugh Givens, Jr_ MD
25. DATE
7/9/82
RECEIVED
CHESSIE SYSTEM
JULY 21 1982
Casualty Prevention Department
BALTIMORE MARYLAND
JA-127
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF NORFOLK
LAW DOCKET NO. L86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR..,
Plaintiff,
v.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
Norfolk, Virginia
September 19, 1986
Before:
HONORABLE CHARLES R. WATERS, II, JUDGE
*-_ s+ *
[T:1ZJHERBERT R. CROWDER, called as a witness by
and on behalf of the Defendant, having been first duly
sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
JOHN Y. RICHARDSON, JR., appearing for defendant.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Mr. Crowder, state your name, please.
A Herbert R. Crowder.
Q And where do you reside, Mr. Crowder?
A 505 Bonsack Court, Chesapeake.
JA-128
The Court: Would you spell your last name?
The Witness: C-r-o-w-d-e-r.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q And where you are employed?
A Norfolk Southern Corporation.
Q Your job?
A Master mechanic.
Q Can you tell the Court briefly your career with the
railroad, when you came and the ranks you came up
through?
A It [sic] was hired in 1956 in Roanoke, Virginia, as a
machinist’s helper. I went from machinist’s helper to ma-
chinist’s helper apprentice. I was then furloughed, went —
to the car department as a labor foreman. From there to
Williamson, West Virginia, as a gang foreman. Back to
(T:13] Roanoke, Virginia, as gang foreman. Promoted to
assistant car foreman in Roanoke. Back to Williamson,
West Virginia, as a car foreman, St. Louis, Missouri, as
a general foreman, Bellevue, Ohio, as general foreman,
Moberly, Missouri, as assistant master mechanic.
Back to Roanoke, Virginia, as a mechanical super-
visor in charge of personnel, to Decatur, Illinois, as master
mechanic, and now master mechanic in Norfolk.
The Court: It would take a brilliant witness just to
remember all i
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Mr. Crowder, how long have you been at Norfolk?
A I’ve been at Norfolk since 1979.
Q You have béen a master mechanic al] that time?
JA-129
A No, sir. About four and a half years.
Q As master mechanic, what department are you re-
sponsible for?
A I have responsibility for the mechanical department
which covers the car shop repairing freight cars, loco-
motive shop servicing and repairing locomotives, and the
coal pier operation as far as the mechanical department
is concerning being here in Norfolk. I also have facilities
at Crewe, Virginia, and at Richmond, Virginia, and have
jurisdiction over the areas from Norfolk to but not in-
cluding Lynchburg.
(T:14]Q All right. Is Mr. Goode, the plaintiff, in your de-
partment?
A Yes, sir, he sure is.
Q As well as Mr. Jones and Mr. Bates standing outside?
A Yes, sir, they are.
Q Are you familiar with the term motive power de-
partment?
A Yes, sir.
Q Is that the same thing as the mechanical department,
would you describe it?
A The motive power department is I won't say a mis-
nomer. It’s a term that’s been attached locally to almost
exclusively the pier department, if you may. It is all me-
chanical department but that—when we use the terminol-
ogy here, we are normally talking about the pier group.
Q Okay. Do you know Mr. Goode’s title?
A Yes, sir.
Q And what is that?
A He’s a machinist.
JA-130
Q And is he assigned to a particular group within your
department?
A Yes, sir, he is.
Q What department is that? Is that the pier department
you were describing?
[T:15}]A The pier department, yes.
Q Does that also go by the motive power pier depart-
ment?
A That’s correct.
Q How long has he worked in this department, Mr.
Crowder?
A I believe, recollection, about 1979 the most recent.
He was employed once before, but I don’t recall those
dates.
Q Okay. Is it your understanding he came back after
being employed outside the railroad in 1979?
A Yes. All I know is he was employed before and came
back. I wasn’t sure what the circumstances were.
Q What did he come back as? If you know. If Mr. Bates
knows—
A I’m not sure. I don’t know. I'll leave it that way.
Q Other than the machinists that are assigned to the
motive power pier department, what other crafts or jobs
are assigned to the motive power pier départment?
A We have electrical workers, both electricians and
helpers. The electrical helpers cover somewhat of a wide
scope. They attend the lines for tying ships up and allow-
ing them to leave. They also operate some of the equip-
ment. They work as helpers not only for electricians but
for other [T:16} crafts as needed.
We have pipe fitters, we have not as shop craft but
we also have laborers that are under our jurisdiction.
JA-131
Q You have described, I think, what the operators do
within the electrical craft; is that correct?
A That’s correct.
Q What do the pipe fitters do?
A Prepare and renew lubricating lines, air lines, water
lines, oil lines.
Q What do the electricians who are not operators do?
A The electricians, of course, look after all our motors,
circuit breakers, power contractors, programmable con-
trollers, electrical switches.
Q Are any trainmen or members of UTU assigned to
the motive power pier department?
A No, sir, they are not.
Q Are any trainmen allowed to perform any of these
repairs or to operate any of the equipment that’s within
the motor power pier department?
A No, they are not allowed to repair anything or op-
erate the equipment.
Q Are they allowed on piers?
A Can I rephrase that?
Q Yes, sure.
[T:17]A There is one piece of equipment that the trainman
would operate. We have winches where we winch cars if
they stall on the dumper. In the same connection, we have
what is known as a rabbit. It’s a mechanical feature that
has an arm on it that will come up underneath the car
and grab the car by the axle, if you may, and move it.
It’s a matter, on the rabbit, of pushing a button. The rope
[sic] or the winch is something that can be operated by a
brakeman.
Q We may get to that when we are describing the op-
eration.
JA-132
The matter that we have had marked as Exhibit—
Court Exhibit A, have you reviewed that this morning?
A Yes, sir, I have.
Q And are the facts that are related in here essentially
correct?
A Essentially, to the best of my knowledge.
Q Any correction you would like to make?
A The only thing that I saw that maybe could be mis-
construed was that machinists repair freight cars. That’s
yes and no. SRD SD SS Sh Senne ay RES See
they will take a burning torch and trim a car if it’s too
wide for the dumper. And that’s all that’s ever has to be
done to it. It’s ready for service after that. So that could
be construed as repaired, but they don’t normally, as such,
repair car equipment.
(T:18)Q Okay. There was also, I think you discussed with
me, whether the 35 number of machinists was correct.
A That’s correct. I believe the exact figure was 29 ma-
chinists, which did not include gang leaders, and all of
those are not assigned to the coal pier operation as such.
Q Okay. Of the 29 machinists, how many are assigned
to the coal pier in the Norfolk terminal?
A 16, I believe it was.
Q Okay. So the difference between the 35 number I put
in here and the 29 is the gang foremen?
A Gang leaders.
Q Okay. All right.
Mr. Richardson: If this could be admitted into evi-
dence now, I would certainly offer it.
The Court: Well, now—
Court: I will admit it into evidence solely as
what itness
EDDIE W. WILSON, mock for the aa
that this witness would corroborate through his testimony.
That is the only basis to have its admission at this point.
Mr. Richardson: That’s right. To save two hours of
time, I am just trying to offer it as opposed to having
him recite it on the stand. I think he will recite the areas
you are concerned with. If not, I am sure you will bring
it out in cross-examination.
Mr. Wilson: The only thing I can say is there are
Mr. Richardson: Excuse me, your Honor. I'l] wait
until you are ready.
The Court: That’s all right. Go ahead.
By Mr. Richardson:
JA-134
Q Mr. Crowder, how are machinists assigned to the piers
as opposed to anywhere else in the Norfolk terminal?
A Machinists, of course, have seniority. There are jobs
advertised or railroad talk bids and they bid on their day
and their shift predominantly. The third way that [T:20]
they bid on jobs is the location. All of the machinists on
Norfolk terminal are on the same seniority roster.
If their seniority warrants, they can bid jobs at the
coal piers, pier operation, they can bid them for the main-
tenance gang, which predominantly works at 38th Street
car shop, although not necessarily, or they can bid a job
at the roundhouse.
Q The roundhouse being?
A Where locomotives are serviced or maintained.
Q Do they move around or generally stay in place as
machinists at Norfolk terminal.
A There is some slight movement, but generally speak-
ing you see the same people on about the same jobs.
Q Are the other crafts, the other unions of the railroad,
similiarly mobile depending on bidding jobs?
A Yes, sir.
Q What do the machinists do in general? If you would
define a machinist, how would you do that?
A In the pier operation or in all?
Q Let’s say in all first.
A Okay. Well, first of all, I will try to define the dif-
JA-135
ae ed PE ake gprances:
Wage hee ae | hithl
rT s ee ey og 2es8eghes
Hab idl ap oak | PAT:
: ths 2 fy a i S : Je
Hoa a i Binne
i ite hat tg epbeell
AL setpoint
Mi fist = coh <fiolp< os “33i8- HY
at Lambert’s Point where we are discussing?
A Yes, sir.
Mr. Richardson: If the Court would allow you, could
he step down and show you on these photographs the areas
we are talking about? There are the originals.
The Court: Sure.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Maybe this is the one to start with. Could you de-
scribe the equipment you were just referring to with re-
lation to this photograph which I believe is Exhibit—
The Court: It doesn’t matter which exhibit it [T:23]
is.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q What does the photograph show?
A .It shows the dumper. This is the dumper here. This
is the incline I was speaking of. And the i
A Well, the retarders are within the gauge of the track.
Is that what the question is?
Q Yes. How does it act on it? What is its purpose?
A Its purpose is to retard and to hold the freight car,
the hopper car, once he gets to the dumper. In other
words, the car is revolving as it comes on. Where we want
it to stop we will apply the retarder to stop it and then
hold it until all motion is stopped.
Q Can you show the Court what equipment the motive
power department and machinists particularly have re-
sponsibility over the maintenance and repair of in this
photograph, or would this photograph probably be better?
A This would give a more general view. This—
Q What does this photograph show?
A I'll speak in railroad east or west, if you may, because
geographic is just the opposite. But railroad east—
Q Towards the water’
JA-138
A Towards the water, going this way, this is the thaw-
ing shed.
Q The white building?
[T:25]A The white building. This is the south one and the
north one.
Q What does the thaw shed do?
A In the winter months, January and February pre-
Q How long is a car in those thaw sheds?’
A 20 minutes is a good time. There is no time limit.
Q What equipment in that shed are you responsible for?
A We are in charge of the heaters, their installation,
maintenance of the heaters, which comes under the elec-
The Court: You are talking about this pier?
The Witness: Here.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q After the car leaves the thawing shed what does i
do?
o;
that will physieally cut the two cars in
two. The mechanism is the on car to do so.
Q Is he a member of your department’
JA-139
|
Q Okay.
A Again, the barney will pick it up onto the dumper
and all of this is semi-automatic but is activated by a man
are electrical workers but they are helpers and they
referred to in our terminology as operators.
Q What, after the coal is dumped, happens to it?
A After the car is dumped, it goes down into—
funnel type
take the coal and put it on A or Al belt. There is two
series of belts that treat this whole thing. And it takes it
Q Is this the transfer house pointed out here?’
A That’s correct.
Q From where does the coal go from there?
JA-140
A It does on the C or Cl belt out the length or to the
loaders. Not necessarily the belts go the length but the
coal will come to the loaders.
Q And from the loaders to the ship?
A From C belt it goes to D belt and E and finally F
belt and into the ship.
A Yes, sir.
Q Are they operated by people in your department?
A Yes, sir.
Q Are they maintained and repaired by people in your
department?
JA-141
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Other than the equipment that you have described
that being—is it fair to say that the jurisdiction of the
motive power pier department shows somewhere around
the thaw shed as far as equipment is concerned? }
A Yes. That’s a fair assumption.
Q How far is the thaw shed, approximately, from the
river? How far is the dumpers?
[T:29]A I’m going to say the dumpers are five to six
hundred feet and the thaw shed, depending whether you're
talking about entrance or exit, six to seven hundred feet.
Purely guesstimates now.
Q I understand that. Other than the equipment you have
described which your department works on—and I say your
department, the motive power pier department—that being
the pusher, the barney, the dumpers, the thaw shed, the
shiploaders and conveyor belt system—I am sure I have
forgotten something—what other equipment does the mo-
tive power pier department work on generally, if anything?
A Well, their purpose in being there and their only pur-
pose in being thre is to maintain the coal dumping facility.
Now, I guess I’m going to answer your question. A good
bit of their work is out on these facilities that I’ve just
gone through, the dumper and the loaders and belt system.
Q If you were to assign a percentage of the time they
spent working, how much would they work on this equip-
ment.
A 99 percent, I would hope.
Q They are supposed to work on it 99 percent?
A That’s right.
Q Do they occasionally have any opportunity to fix rail
cars? I notice you took exception to my term repair rail
JA-142
cars in that factual stipulation. Can you explain what [T:30]
they do on occasion?
A The main thing I took exception to was the word .
“repair.” We will have cars that come off the dumper,
for instance, that won’t roll because the brakes have set
up, and the machinist will take a cotter key out, knock a
brake pin out, and release the brakes so that it will roll
free.
Prior to coming into the thaw shed—not necessarily
prior to, sometime it’s after, but most of the time prior
to coming into the thaw shed we have car inspectors that
will signify that a car has a spread side, if you may. The
limitation—
Q Too wide?
A That’s right. The limitations are greater than will go
- through the area that it’s supposed to, which will require,
in some instances, a burning torch, oxygen settling [sic]
torch, to trim a portion off. Sometimes this is final; you
don’t have to do anything else after you trim it. Other
times the car is rendered bad order and will go to the
car shop.
Q So when to repair cars, to use that term, and I know
it’s wrong, is to coordinate the car going through the
unloading process?
A To facilitate the smooth dumping operation, yes, sir.
Q And that’s only done on occasion?
[T:31]JA That’s right.
Q Do they occasionally rerail cars that were derailed in
the area of the dumper?
A In the area of the dumper and the kickbacks, yes.
Q Do they release hand brakes on rail cars.
A We never—they don’t. They could, but it’s really not
an assigned duty to them. They will assist—sometimes
JA-143
when we have a car derailed it’s necessary to tie the hand
brake up for safety sake. So then if they tie it up, it would
be their responsibility to untie the hand brake.
Q I also asked you earlier when we were meeting about
the breaking up of frozen coal. For Your Honor’s benefit,
the reason I am asking you these questions is these facts
are contained in Mr. Wilson’s affidavits which he is going
to submit to the Court. That’s why I’m asking him this
terminology. I’m not sure what it is either.
Are you familiar with that term?
A Yes.
Q Do machinists do that?
A Machinists could. It would not be an assigned duty
unless they had to make a repair to a hammer mill.
Q What is a hammer mill?
A A hammer mill is a mechanism that we have in the
hoppers below the dumper where the coal will come out
of a hopper car into a pocket prior to going to the belt.
And it [T:32] will—in wintertime after it’s frozen it will
come out in large chunks, to say the least, and a hammer
mill is a mechanical means of breaking the coal up so that
it will feed through to the belts and henceforth to the
ship.
And if a hammer mill breaks down, then it could
become the responsibility of the machinist to have to get
some of it away so we can get in there and repair it.
Q So it is really related to the repair of the dumping
facility?
A That’s correct.
Q All right. Now, Mr. Goode, in his deposition, which
I don’t know ‘f you had an opportunity to read and which
will be submitted to the Court, said that he worked pri-
JA-144
marily on forklifts and trucks as opposed to the coal op-
eration. Is that true?
A No, I wouldn’t—that’s—I haven’t read his deposition,
but the reason I said 99 percent, we have two forklifts
at the coal piers, six or eight trucks. But they would work
on them, yes. There’s no question from time to time they
might, but not a predominance, no.
Q Is it generally the people assigned to the piers de-
partment generally don’t spend their time working on fork-
lifts and trucks, I take it?
A That’s right.
Q If there was a piece of equipment down there [T:33]
they worked on primarily in the coal loading or unloading
process, what piece of equipment would that be? I am
talking about machinists now. Would one piece of equip-
ment be worked on more than others?
A Well, I think the dumper gives us, in general, more
problems than others because of the many, many me-
chanical facets of it.
Q Okay. To you, you are familiar with the retarders
that this gentleman was working on the day he was in-
jured, are you not?
A Yes, I am.
Q I know you have described briefly earlier what that
is. Can you tell us how a retarder works?
A The retarder is on a—let me back up just a little bit
to give a thorough picture of them.
The track that comes onto the dumper of course is
standard gauge for the railroad. It is secured to a table.
For better terms we call it a platen. It’s a movable thing.
The retarder sits inside the gauge of the rail. As the car
comes on and we wish to slow it down and/or to finally
stop it, then the retarder activates the operator—the op-
JA-145
erator activates the retarder which applies pressure into
the inside wheel face of the wheel to stop at that location.
Q Is this retarder different than other braking systems
used on the railroad?
(T:34]A It’s different in general than other retarders that
are used for the same purpose because the other retarders
will squeeze each wheel from each side.
Q Why is this retarder different than those others?
A Because of the structural limitations that we have to
work within and again the fact that it’s on a movable
table.
(T:37]Q You noted the difference, I believe, between these
retarders and other retarders. Did you explain that to the
Court?
A I thought I did but for -
Q Okay.
A The retarders on the dumper which is within the
confines of the platen, instead of squeezing both sides of
a wheel to retard this movement just applies pressure to
the inside portion of a pair of wheels.
Q And that is because of the pier 6 dumper structure?
A The structural limitations and the fact that the platen
does move.
Q To dump the car?
A That’s right.
By Mr. Richardson:
[T:38)Q Mr. Crowder, did you—as you testified earlier, you
showed the Court where those retarders are located on
the dumpers; is that correct?
JA-146
A Yes, I did.
Q Is this dumper operation something that is solely used
here in Norfolk or is it used all through the railroad?
A The pier 6 dumping operation at Norfolk is not the
only one in the world by any means. It’s the only one of
its type in this portion of the country or the United States,
to my knowledge, which does—I’m not an authority on
that. But we have other dumping operations. We have a
pier 5 right beside pier 6 that dumps coal but by another
method. We have a coal facility at Sandusky, Ohio, that
dumps coal which is similar to the pier 5 operation.
Q Is is always dumped in vessels?
A Yes.
Q Is the retarder operation that you have described—
as I understand it, that’s the thing that Mr. Goode was
repairing on the day he was injured; is that [T:39] correct?
A Yes.
Q Is that essential to this pier 6 dumping operation?
A It’s a very integral part of it. If we couldn't stop
and hold the car when it got onto the dumper, we would
be sitting there all day either trying to pull the cars back
or by some means get them back in position. Yes, it is
important. If it doesn’t work, we don’t dump.
Q Does the dumper have to be shut down in order to
repair or maintain this retarder?
A Yes, sir, it sure does.
Mr. Richardson: Okay. I believe that’s all the ques-
tions I have of him, Your Honor. if Mr. Wilson has some.
* CROSS-EXAMINATION
By Mr. Wilson:
JA-147
Q Mr. Crowder, these coal cars that are brought to
Lambert’s Point, where do they originate?
A Coal fields of Southwest Virginia, West Virginia and
Q Are they loaded at the coal mines to be brought to
Lambert’s Point?
A That’s correct.
[T:41)Q Ali right. And what is thepurpose of the barney
yard?
car is equipped with, leave the arrows with them, let
down and we will classify it, if you may
they come into these switches.
Q Are the railroad brakemen the same people you called
trainmen earlier?
A Yes.
Q Are trainmen people that are assigned both closer to
the water and further away from the water than these
retarders that you were speaking of on the dumper?
A Yes. A trainman will be stationed on the water end
of each of the dumpers when we are in operation. There's
also another trainman on the inshore end off the dumpers.
There’s one at the cutter station.
[T:43]The Court: Well, they ride it only for the purpose
of hitching a ride? Why would they do that?
The Witness: When a car that has been put on the
that’s misclassed—there are hundreds of classes
i
JA-148
of coal—and they have to get it off, or we have a me-
chanical breakdown that we can’t dump that car and ha
to get rid of it so we can repair it at the facility. So |
can’t say that it never happens, but’s so remote that |
can’t remember the last time it was done.
Q Yes, sir
A He ensures that the cars get off the dumper and he
classifies cars as they come off the dumper.
A for instance,
if you may, is we classify cars coming off the dumper
between 100-ton and a 70-ton car and different railroad’s
ownership.
(T:46] By Mr. Wilson:
Q What does BC stand for?
A From B belt to C belt.
Q It’s a belt change house; is that what it is?
. A Yes, sir. You don’t change belts, so that we are talk-
JA-149
A (The witness complied.)
Q All right. And what are ‘hese lines that run between
these two red circles?
A That’s your B belt. B and 1 belt.
The Court: Underground, aren't they?
The Witness: Partially underground and partially
above.
By Mr. Wilson:
Q If you will, why don’t you draw an arrow between
those two circles for us.
A (The witness complied.)
Q Now show me where the coal goes when it changes
from one belt at the BC house onto another belt. |
A (The witness complied.)
Q And what is its final destination there?
([T:47]A To another series of belts, but its final destination
is shipped [sic] underneath the loader.
Q On the first set of arrows, this is coal en route to
the ship and it can't be diverted for any reason?
A It can be diverted.
Q It can. Where?
A We have recircle bins up here in case of a catastro-
phe.
Q Can't you reverse the belts going into the BC house
and load that coal in the railroad cars’
A No, sir.
Q Are you sure of that?
A I'm positive.
Q Yes, sir
A No.
Q If the other belt doesn’t pick it up you don’t have
any way to divert the coal; is that true?
A No. It just piles up inside the BC house. If that belt
were broke down and this one continued to operate.
A No, they do not.
Q Mr. Goode, since he came back to work in ‘79, has
he been assigned principally at the piers?
A To the best of my knowledge, he’s been at the piers
or that’s where I’ve known him is at the piers. ,
JA-151
Q He was assigned there when he was injured, was he
not?
A That’s correct.
Q And had been assigned for sometime prior to that;
is that right?
A Yes.
Q There was some discussion about where these gentle-
men report. Where do machinists such as Mr. Goode report
in the morning?
A To the mechanical or the motive power building at
the coal piers.
Q Can you show that to the Judge on this plat? I believe
it is designated. Is that the motive power building?
A Yes.
Q And in this picture showing the thawing shed, is [T:68]
A That’s correct.
Q Why is that building located down where it is?
A It was placed there—I don’t know when it was built,
but it was placed there to facilitate the piers to the coal
handling equipment or the dumping equipment.
Q Approximately how far is that from the water?
A 150 feet, approximately.
Q Is it along the same line offset from the water as
the dumpers are, approximately? Are they adjacent?
A Well, they are somewhat side by side. The dumper
is a little bit further from the water.
Q Okay. Now, Mr. Wethington who Mr. Wilson asked
you about, he is assigned to the maintenance gang?’
JA-152
A Yes, sir.
Q He is not assigned to the piers, I take it?
A His bid in job right now is the maintenance gang,
yes.
Q And Mr. Goode, as you testified previously, didn’t
work at the roundhouse or on 38th Street hopper or the
maintenance gang work that you have described; is that
correct?
A Right. His bid job is for the piers.
RECROSS EXAMINATION
(T:71] By Mr. Wilson:
Q Do you have knowledge there is a U.S. Steel plant
in Alabama that unloads rail cars and coal?
A I have no personal knowledge of that.
Q But you do have knowledge there other facilities that
unload coal not related to ships or piers or anything else;
isn’t that tfue?
A That's correct.
Mr. Wilson: That is all I have, Your Honor.
Mr. Richardson: Thank you, Mr. Crowder.
Judge, do you have any questions’
The Court: I have no questions.
Mr. Richardson: I am going to get Mr. Bates if that's
all right.
DILLARD RATES, called as a witness by and on
behalf of the Defendant, having been first duly sworn, was
examined and testified as follows:
JA-153
DIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Mr. Bates, you have been sworn in. Give us your
name, please.
A Dillard Bates.
Q And where do you live?
[T:72]A 3612 Terry Drive, Norfolk, Virginia.
Q And by whom are you employed?
A Norfolk Southern Corporation.
Q And what is your job?
A General foreman of piers.
Q General foreman of piers’
A Yes, sir.
Q Who is your supervisor, your boss’
A Mr. H. R. Crowder.
Q That is this gentleman right here?
A Yes.
Q Are you also in the department of the motive power,
the mechanical department?
A Yes, sir.
Q As general foreman of piers, are you Mr. Goode's
boss?
A Yes.
Q Okay. And how long have You known Mr. Goode?
A T've known Mr. Goode since back in 1979 when he
came with the railroad or before that.
JA-154
Q Okay. Did Mr. Goode—are you privy to what Mr.
Goode does on a day-to-day basis?
A Yes.
Q And why is that?
A Because I'm general foreman, his supervisor [T:73]
answers to me.
Q And do you participate in assignments to gentlemen
assigned to the piers department?
A Not directly. Indirectly.
Q Okay. Explain that.
A IL have a machinist supervisor that Mr. Goode comes
under who reports to me and he makes daily assignments.
Q Okay. But you participate in those decisions?
A Yes.
Q How many machinists do you all have down at the
prers department’
A At the piers? I believe right now we have about 19.
Q Okay. And since '78 or "79 when Mr. Goode returned
to the railroad, has he generally worked in the piers de-
partment?
A Generally, yes. I believe there was on period that he
worked in the maintenance gang for a short period.
Q But primarily he’s worked at the piers?
A Primarily at the piers, yes.
Q Okay. Did he come on as a line tender helper?
A Yes.
Q What does a line tender helper do?
A They help tie up ships or if they are not tying up
ships they can be assigned to help the electricians or the
(T:74] machinists or any general help that you need.
JA-155
Q What equipment is the motive power piers depart-
ment responsible for?
A They are responsible for the equipment and operation
of the piers, the dumpers, pushers, loaders is their main
responsibility at the piers.
Q The other classifications, I believe, in your depart-
ment are pipe fitters, electricians and operators which are
also in the electrical craft; is that correct?
A True.
Q What union is the machinists in?
A It’s IM—and I’m terrible because I don’t know the
official designation of the machinist’s union.
Q There are no trainmen or UTU people that work in
your department—
A No.
Q —do they?
A re they allowed to operate or repair any of the equip-
ment that is in your department?
A No. None of the trainmen, no.
Q What union are the electrical workers in?
A They come under IBEW.
Q Okay. And the pipe fitters?
A It’s SCMIA. It’s a sheet metal workers union that
takes in pipe fitters and sheet metal workers.
(T:75]Q Are the line tenders a member of the IBEW, the
electrical workers?
A Yes. The line tenders come under the electrical union,
IBEW.
Q All right. Tell me in a general way what machinists
such as Mr. Goode assigned to the piers do on a day-to-
day basis.
A They are assigned to any mechanical trouble that we
would have working the retarders on the dumpers, or they
pushers up the hill; any
of them. Or out on the loaders, any problems we have,
i with couplings on generators or tack
generators or mounting or the alignment of or pulleys.
Changing pulleys. Bearings on pulleys. Bearings on wheels
Q All the equipment you are describing is equipment
used in the dumping of coal from the thaw shed railroad
east?
A All used for the sole purpose of dumping coal.
Q Okay. Do they have occasion to deal with rail cars?
A On occasions if we get what we call a bulge side with
a broken top coping rail, they will—so that they can get
it on the dumper, they will make a burn on it. This is
something to burn it so it can get clearance. Get it on
the (T:76] dumper. Or if the kickbacks—at times we have
what they call tight brakes. They will knock a pin out of
the brakes so they will freely roll on through the empty
yard.
Q Okay. Now, you are aware that Mr. Goode was in-
jured when he was repairing a retarder?
A Yes, I am.
Q Can you tell the Court what a retarder is?
A A retarder is a mechanism on the dumper that allows
the operator to stop the hopper cars on the dumper under
the arms at the proper place.
Q Who operates this retarder?
A The operator, dumper operator.
Q Is he in the mechanical craft and also a member of
the motive power department?
JA-157
A Yes.
Q Assigned to the pier?
A Assigned to the pier.
Q Are you aware of retarders used generally throughout
the railroad?
A Yes.
Q Do the retarders used on dumper 6 differ from the
other type retarders?
A Yes. It differs from most other retarders generally
on the railroad, yes.
Q First of all, why does it differ?
(T:77]A Because of the space and the—on the dumper they
have what we call a platen. It’s movable. Normally retar-
ders in the yards squeeze a wheel from both sides. These
retarders only squeeze to the inside of the wheels. Squeeze
up against one side of the wheel. And through linkage
makes it different the way it applies on the platen retar-
ders.
The Court: Let me ask a question. If the retarder
on pier 5 is different than all the other retarders in the
world but does the same thing by a different method and
it’s different from the retarder on pier 6, what significance
is that? Why do I care about that?
Mr. Richardson: I am not saying pier 5 and pier 6.
I’m talking about pier 6.
The Court: Reverse them. What difference does it
make?
Mr. Richardson: Again, Your Honor, I anticipate that
Mr. Wilson will argue that these are the same throughout
the railroad and therefore this gentleman is repairing
equipment that everybody else would repair on the rail-
road. And [| believe—
JA-158
The Court: This is pier 5 we are talking about.
Mr. Richardson: Pier 6.
The Court: Well, now it’s different from the one on
pier 5, isn’t it?
(T:78]Mr. Richardson: I don’t know that.
The Witness: Some difference. Similar and the same but
some difference between pier 5 and pier 6.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Is pier 5’s retarder also distinguishable from normal
railroad retarders?
A Yes, it is.
Q How is that?
A It retards squeezing on the inside of the wheels.
The Court: But they all do the same thing, dont
they?
Mr. Richardson: Stop the car.
The Court: Yes.
Mr. Richardson: Yes, sir.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Now, I have also shown you the photographs and the
plats, have I not?
A Yes.
Q Do the symbols on there show the relevant landmarks
down at the pier’s area?
A Yes.
Q Where does Mr. Goode report to work?
A He reports to the motive power department at the
piers.
,
JA-159
Q Where is that building located?
[T:79]A It’s located on the waterfront. The railing where
we do power work. '
Q Is that where your office is?
A My office is in this building, yes.
Q Mr. Bates, on a day-to-day- basis, how much time
to the motive power piers department work on the dum-
pers?
A On the dumpers alone?
Q Yes.
A It can vary. A lot of times they can spend the entire
day on it. It varies as to how much problem or how much
wear you have in your retarders or what you have.
Q Do they spend the majority of the time working on
dumpers, shiploaders, conveyor belts, the thawing shed
equipment? Is that the primary portion of their time?
Mr. Wilson: Your Honor, I think he’s testifying again.
The Court: He was testifying.
Mr. Richardson: I am testifying and I know what
he’s going to say.
The Witness: 98, 99 percent of the time is spent
directly with the coal loading operation.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Mr. Bates, do these gentlemen spend a lot of time
working on forklifts and trucks?
[T:80]A Not a lot of time. We do have two forklifts that
we work on, but a very small percentage of the time would
be working on any forklifts or trucks.
Q What about fixing these rail cars you talked about
earlier?
A It goes to the vessel, yes, without stopping, to trans-
fer points to load it. It’s the only pace it can go.
Q It can’t be diverted once it’s put on that belt?
A It can be diverted to what we call bins out on the
loader but it’s then directly put back on the belt into the
vessel because at times you have to put it in a bin when
you reverse your movement of your load on your belts.
You can’t travel the coal when you put it in the bin and
put it back on the belt to the vessel. There's nowhere it
Q You are familiar, again, with the retarders that this
A Yes. If it was not retarding the cars properly because
you couldn’t stop the cars properly on the dumper to [T:81]
dump them if they are not operating properly.
Q So to work on the retarders that this gentleman is
working on, the operation would have to shut down? The
dumping operation?
A Yes. On that one particular side.
Q Okay. If the retarders on the other side were ino-
perative, that part would have to be shut down also, would
it not?
A Yes.
JA-161
A It wouldn't affect it other than it would mean you
would have cars sitting there and you could not dump.
Q Is this dumper operation unusual for the railroad, this
pier 6 dumper operation?
A It’s the only operation of its type on the railroad.
The Court: Again, is that something that is referred
to in some case law somewhere? I don’t see the signifi-
cance of that. I mean if I'm supposed to, tell me. Is that
something that was mentioned in some case law some-
where?
Mr. Richardson: Your Honor, pier 6 dumper is dif-
after reading the case law.
Q Are you familiar with Robert Jones, a gentleman hurt
as a machinist?
A Yes.
Q Where was he hurt?
A In the shop.
Q What was he ding’
A He was repairing a retarder cylinder.
Q Okay. Was he also a machinist’
A Yes, he is.
Q Mr. Bates, who controls the belts and the idle arm
JA-162
assembly that goes from the dumpers to the ships? Who
works on those?
» Who controls the belts and works on them?
Q Yes, sir.
A The motive power department, my department. The
(T:83] operators in the cab control them. Working on them,
maintenance of them, comes under my motive power ma-
chinist and electric.
Q Do they also work on the machinery out in the shi-
ploaders themselves?
A Yes.
Q What about the trim track that the shiploaders move
along?
A Pardon?
Q Is there a track out there that the shiploaders them-
selves move back and forth on?
A Yes. The loaders will travel the length of the pier,
yes.
Q Who works on that trim track?
A The motors and all related equipment, machinists on
bearings, mechanical end; electrical people on the electrical
end.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
(T:86] By Mr. Wilson:
Q Mr. Bates, you mentioned the operation of line tend-
ers. They aren’t machinists, are they?
A Line tenders are not machinists, no.
’
'
'
JA-163
Q They aren’t in the same union as machinists, are
they?
A No.
Q Prior to the unloading of railroad cars, would you
agree that machinists participate in the repair of railroad
cars?
A Machinists assist in the repair of railroad cars?
Q Yes, sir. Prior to them being unloaded in the south
side dumper.
A No, not frequently, no.
Q Do they work on railroad cars?
A Machinists?
Q Yes.
A No, sir.
. aad about the burning? Where does that take [T:87]
place?
A It takes place at—most of the time we will do it at
the scales. If we can’t do it at the scales, we will do it
at the barney pier.
Q That is well before the car has been dumped, isn’t
it?
A Yes. Before the car is dumped, yes.
Q Maybe you didn’t understand. The preface to my
question was prior to the unloading of the cars on the
dumper, don’t machinists work on railroad cars?
A They will make burning on what we call bulge cars
_where the top coping rail is broken at an angle where we
cannot put it on the dumper. We will burn it on a taper
so it will go to the dumper.
The Court: What does it mean burning?
JA-164
The Witness: You have an angle, and actually what
*t is is sometimes I load the car and it will break in the
middle. If the point is towards where it sits on the dumper
you only have six inches of clearance. It’s real close. And
if you got a jagged edge sticking out, you can catch and
turn what we call a clamp after they pull the cars on the
dumper. We burn it in a taper or burn it off so it won't
catch on these in this close clearance.
By Mr. Wilson:
Q And after the cars are unloaded on the dumper, isn’t
it true that machinists are called upon to help in the [T:88]
rerailing of derailed railroad cars?
A Yes. If we have a derailment.
Q All right, sir. Don’t they work on a device called a
pusher, which has been described as a small electric lo-
comotive, prior to the unloading of the cars?
A Yes. The pusher at the barney piers, yes.
Q Don’t they work on the repair and maintenance of
the barney which is a device used to push the cars up the
‘incline before the dumper?
A Yes, they do.
Q Don’t the trainmen activate the barney, railroad train-
men?
A No, sir. The railroad trainmen gives our dumper op-
erators a signal that it is ready to pull and he actually
pushes the button to pull the barney.
Q So they participate in the process of signalling which
causes the barney to be started?
'
A Right. They have a green light down there. When he
takes the retarders off a green light somes on. Then the
barney comes.
JA-165
Q So machinists do work in and about railroad cars with
the movement of railroad cars both before and after they
are dumped?
A Yes.
Q We have discussed a place called the BC house.
[T:89]A Yes.
Q And I understand that there are belts that run from
the south side dumper to this BC house?
A Yes.
Q Does that belt have a designation?
A The BC House?
Q No. The belt itself. Is it like B belt?
A Yes. B and BI belt, yes.
Q So B belt goes from the south side dumper to the
BC house?
A Under normal operation, yes.
Q And then the coal is dumped on another belt that
goes from the BC house to the ships; is that correct?
A That’s correct.
Q What is the designation of that belt from the ships
to the BC house?
A From the ship to the BC house? Under normal op-
eration, B belt would dump onto C belt. C belt would go
down the pier, up through the loader.
Q And that is when they put the coal in the ships, right?
A No, sir. It then dumps onto D belt.
Q So there is another belt involved?
A Which is a belt going across out to your apron. It
belts onto E belt.
JA-166
(T:90]Q Is there a $hoot [sic] at the back of the BC house
where you can place coal?
A There’s a shoot [sic] at the back of the BC house?
Q At the back of the BC house.
A Yes. There is a cleanup place back there where the
cleanup belts dump off and also a place back there where
ifyou have a problem with your belt, if we ever do reverse
it, it could dump it out on the ground, yes, sir.
Q So you could actually take the coal after it’s left B
belt and going onto C belt and you can reverse C belt
and dump coal back out through the BC house; is that
correct?
A That is not done except in special emergency cases.
It cannot be just normally reversed.
Q My question is can you do that.
A It could on special conditions.
Q Has it ever been done?
A I have done it when I have come over 4 belt with a
rip.
Q Couldn’t you take the coal you dumped over the shoot
[sic] and load it in the railroad cars?
A Yes.
Q As a matter of fact, there’s a track that runs right
down beside the BC house?
Q And there are railroad cars sitting back there [T:91]
most of the time, isn’t there?
A Right.
Q And they've got coal in them, don’t they?
a ee ee
JA-167
A Yes, sir.
Q And that coal is coal that came out of the railroad
cars upon the dumper, isn’t it?
A It’s cleaned up coal, yes. It came from all over the
piers.
Q And retarders are used to stop cars, aren’t they?
A Yes.
Q And they are used all over the railroad system to
stop cars, aren’t they?
A Yes.
Mr. Wilson: That’s all the questions I have, Your Honor.
Thank you.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Just a couple, Mr. Bates. Mr. Goode was a line tender
when he initially came on the department, was he not?
A When he initially came to the piers.
Q Yes. In 79 or thereabout.
A Yes.
Q The gentleman helping Mr. Goode when he was hurt,
Mr. Dowdy, he is a line tender, is he not?
([T:92]JA Yes.
Q And line tenders are generally the first step to be-
coming an apprentice and then an electrician or machinist?
A Normally, yes. We pick apprentices from anyone that
is interested and qualified.
Q How far from the water is this dumper?
JA-168
A The dumper?
Q Yes, sir.
A I would take a guess of 500, 550 feet, approximately,
from the water.
Q Okay. And how far from the water is the motive
power buildi
A About 150 feet to 175 feet, approximately.
Q How far apart are those two dumpers and the motive
power department?
A The dumpers and the motive power building? It’s
about 300 feet. Somewhere in there. Just an estimate.
Taking extreme one side to the other.
Mr. Richardson: Okay. I think that’s all. That you
Mr. Bates.
Mr. Wilson: I have no questions, Your Honor.
The Court: Thank you, sir.
Sr PP Yr
JA-169
EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION
Plat of Lamberts’ Point Terminal
Aerial photograph of Lamberts’ Point Terminal
Aerial photograph of Lamberts’ Point Terminal
Aerial photograph of Waterside facilities
Aerial photograph of dumpers
LANDMARKS IDENTIFIED ON EXHIBITS
A. Pier 6
B. Scales
C. Thawing Shed
D. Dumpers
E.
F
G
H
West Shiploader
. East. Shiploader
. Conveyor System
. Transfer Shed
I. Motive Power Building
JA-170
EXHIBIT 1
JA-171
EXHIBIT 2
JA-172
EXHIBIT 3
JA-173
EXHIBIT 4
JA-174
EXHIBIT 5
JA-175
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF NORFOLK
AT LAW NO. L86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR..
Plaintiff,
Vv.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION
OF ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.
TAKEN ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT
June 27, 1986
[T:3] Robert T. Goode, Jr., called as a witness, having
been first duly sworn, was examined and testified as fol-
lows:
EXAMINATION
JOHN Y. RICHARDSON, JR., appearing on behalf of Nor-
folk and Western Railway Company
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Mr. Goode, my name is John Richardson, and I rep-
resent the railroad in this matter.
If there are any questions you don’t understand, tell
me, and I will try to make them [T:4] understandable. If
there is anything you want to change during the deposi-
tion, tell me to stop, and I will let you change it.
JA-176
I am trying to find out what your story is and how
you got hurt. All I am expecting are frank answers, which
I am sure you will give me.
Q Where do you live, Mr. Goode?
A Norfolk.
Q Give me your address.
A 928 Defoe Avenue.
Q And are you married?
A Yes.
Q What does your wife do?
A She is a police officer.
Q With the city of Norfolk’
A Yes.
Q What is her name?
A Nancy.
Q Any children?
A Yes.
Q Names and ages.
A Jennifer, age 12.
Q Okay. Just one?
A Yes.
Q Okay. No other dependents?
[T:5]A No.
Q Okay. Are you a native of Norfolk?
A Yes, sir.
Q And did you go to high school here in Norfolk?
JA-177
A Yes.
Q Where did you go?
A Maury.
Q When did you—did you graduate?
A Yes.
Q What year?
A Sixty-nine.
Q Did you do anything after graduating as for a edu-
cation-wise or did you come right to work for the railroad?
A I went to Tidewater Community.
Q For how long?
A About three semesters.
Q Okay. Any particular area of study?
A Police science.
Q Okay. And is that the extent of your post high school
education?
A Yes.
Q Okay. What was your first regular job after gradu-
ating from Maury?
[T:6]A I was employed with the railroad.
Q What was your seniority date?
A I am not sure.
Q Okay. About what time did you come to work?
A I was working for the railroad while I was in high
school. It was probably in 69.
Q Okay. What did you come on as?
A Bridge tender.
JA-178
Q Okay. How long were you bridge tender?
A And a painter’s helper.
Q Both under B & B department?
A Yes.
Q How long were you a bridge tender and painter's
helper?
A Approximately three years.
Q And as I understand it, that is under the bridze and
building department; is that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q Is that how you classify it?
A Yes, sir.
Q Throughout your years with the railroad, have you
always been in that department?
A No.
Q What did you do next after being a bridge [T:7] tender
and painter’s helper?
A I was drafted in the army.
Q Okay. And about when was that?
A Seventy, July of °70.
Q How long were you in the army? _
A Approximately a year and a half.
Q What did you do in the army?
A Infantry.
Q Okay. Did you just exhaust your service or were you
discharged for any particular reason?
A Just had an early discharge because the president
said it was okay.
JA-179
Q Okay. And then you came back to work for the rail-
road?
A Yes.
Q And that was 1972?
A Yes, sir.
Q Okay. What did you come back on as?
A Bridge tender.
Q How long did you stay a bridge tender this time?
A Approximately three months.
Q And then what were you promoted to?
A I resigned and went to work as a police officer.
(T:8]Q Okay. That’s after three months in ’72. Was that
nothing to do with the employment at the railroad? You
were just looking for a better job; is that it?
A That’s correct.
Q How long were you a police officer?
A Six years and ten months.
Q Just patrolman or—
A Yes.
Q And why did you leave the police department?
A To come back to the railroad.
Q Any particular reason or just tired of being a police
officer?
A Tired of being a police officer.
Q When did you come back to work?
A January 19th, 1979.
Q Okay. Did you go back to B & B department?
JA-180
A No.
Q Tell me what you were employed as that time.
A I went into the motive power department.
Q And have you been in the motive power department
from then on?
[T:9JA Yes.
Q To the present day?
A Yes, sir.
Q Tell me a little bit about the motive power depart-
ment. What is its job primarily?
A What is my job?
Q Let’s talk about the department first.
A Basically to run the east end of the railroad.
Q Okay. Is there equipment that the motive power de-
partment is particularly responsible for?
A Yes, sir.
Q Tell me about that equipment they are responsible
for.
A The thaw sheds, the pushers, the barneys, the dum-
pers, the conveyer belts.
Q Is it fair to say they are responsible for everything
on the railroad east of the thaw sheds.
A Including the thaw shed.
Q Is that where their line sort of stops and comes to-
wards the dumpers?
A No, not peally, because we work on equipment at
Portlock.
Q What kind of equipment do you work on at Portlock?
JA-181
(T:10JA Forklifts, railroad engines.
Q Do you do that at Lambert’s Point also?
A Yes, sir.
Q Olay. If you had to say what motive power mainly
dealt with on a day-to-day basis, would you say the equip-
ment in the coal loading system from the thaw shed to
east?
A No, we work on all of the equipment.
Q Okay. And—but I am talking about—do you under-
stand my question?
I am saying, does the motive power department pri-
marily work on the equipment in the coal loading process
from the thawing shed to east? Is that your primary re-
sponsibility?
A No.
Q Do you spend as much time working on the forklifts
as you do the coal loading equipment?
A Yes, sir. |
Q Okay. You spend more time working on that stuff
like railroad engines and forklifts as you do on the coal
loading equipment.
A I would say more time spent on the forklifts and
thaw sheds.
Q Okay. More time spent on forklifts than thaw sheds?
[T:11JA No, and thaw sheds.
Q Okay. And barneys and pushers?
What I am getting at is, Mr. Goode, do you spend
more time working on thaw sheds and that kind of stuff
than you do forklifts and that kind of stuff?
EDDIE W. WILSON, appearing on behalf of Robert T.
Goode, Jr.
JA-182
Mr. Wilson: Excuse me. John, if I could interject this.
I am not certain it’s clear what you are understanding—
you are asking. If you defined what you consider to
Q Assume—
Mr. Wilson: We might not accept your definition,
but—
Mr. Richardson: I understand that.
By Mr. Richardson:
_ QI will lump everything that goes into the coal dump-
ut
i
ia
{
ud One a Gs
Mr. Wilson: Before you answer it, I want to object
to the form of the question. There has been no foundation
laid to show that the coal unloading facilities start at the
thaw shed. I thiak it would be—we are assuming that for
the purposes of the question.
Mr. Richardson: Right. I understand that. I am not
saying my definition is definitive.
_I am trying to get an idea of how much time the
JA-183
By Mr. Richardson:
Q Can you answer that question?
A I am not sure.
Q Okay. Who would know that?
A I don’t know that either.
Q Who is your supervisor?
A My immediate supervisor is Bobby Jones.
Q And who is his boss?
A Chain of command would be Arnold Meadows.
Q Head of B & B or motive power?
[T:13]A No, assistant general foreman.
Q Okay. Let’s keep going. Who is next?
A Dillard Bates or D. T. Bates.
Q What is his title?
A General foreman.
Q All right. Anybody higher?
A Bobby Edwards is assistant master mechanic.
Q Mr. Crowder then?
A Yes.
Mr. Wilson: Is that Herb Crowder we are talking
about? ;
Mr. Richardson: Yes.
By Mr. Richardson:
Q He is the master mechanic, right, Mr. Goode?
A Yes.
JA-184
Q He is sort of in charge of the motive power depart-
ment?
A Yes, sir.
Q Okay. Now, since you came back to work with the
motive power department in January of 1979, what has
been your job? What was your initial job in January of
1979?
[T:14JA Line tender and helper.
Q What does that do? What do they do?
A Basically help the electricians and machinists.
Q Do what?
A Perform repair work.
Q On this kind of equipment we have been talking about
earlier?
A On anything.
Q What else did you do?
A Tied up ships on the pier.
Q Okay. Whenever a ship would come in or leave, y’ll
would tie and untie the ships?
A That’s correct.
Q How long were you a line tender and helper?
A Three months.
Q Then what did you become?
A Machinist apprentice.
Q And that essentially means you work on all equipment
that you were sescribing earlier? Is that what the ma-
chinist does?
A Yes, sir, works on cars, trucks, forklifts, railroad cars.
JA-185
Q And how long were you apprentice?
[T:15]A It’s a four-year apprenticeship.
Q Have you moved up to a machinist yet?
A Yes, sir.
Q When did that occur?
A I am not sure of the date.
Q All right. How long, a couple of years ago?
A Yes, sir.
Q And you are a machinist today?
A Yes, sir.
Q And I take it a machinist does the same thing a
machinist apprentice does essentially?
A Yes.
Q Work on cars, trucks, forklifts, things like that?
A Yes, sir.
Q All right. Just clarify something for me, Mr. Goode.
Do you actually go to the car shop and work on cars, rail
cars?
A I don’t go to the car shop and work on cars.
Q Where do you work on rail cars?
A At the scale office, in the thaw shed, and in the
barney pit, and sometimes the dumper.
Q When cars get stuck there or something, is that when
you work on them?
[T:16JA Yes, sir. And if pots) wrong with the car,
we work on it before it goes into*the dumper.
Q When you work on a car, it’s on the track between
the thaw shed and the—whatever the yard is where they
go after being dumped?
JA-186
A Sometimes they are not on the track.
Q What do you mean “sometimes’’?
A Sometimes they are derailed, and we have to put
them back on the track.
Q Okay. It’s generally out of necessity to keep the coal
process running, is that fair to say?
A I guess so.
Q Okay. What I am getting at is, you just don’t inspect
car, and you don’t—if you see something wrong that needs
to be fixed, you don’t stop the coal loading process to
work on the cars?
A It would depend on the severity of what needed to
be fixed.
Q Okay. Is that something that happens on a regular
basis?
A No.
Q Okay. So what do you do most of the time?
A Perform repair work on the equipment for the rail-
road.
[T:17}Q Okay. All right, Mr. Goode, tell us what happened
on the day you got hurt.
A Where do you want me to begin?
Q Let’s start with when did you come on that day?
A At 7 a.m.
Q Is that your typical shift, 7 to 3?
A Yes, sir
Q And when you came on, who do you go to for di-
rection on what to do that particular day?
A Report at the lunchroom at the motive power build-
ing.
JA-187
Q Where is the motive power building?
A Lambert’s Point.
Q All right. Where with respect to the Elizabeth River is
the motive power building? Is it down there near the piers
or up near the claim department and superintendent’s of-
fice?
A Approximately 150 yards east of the Elizabeth River.
Q Okay. Near the piers?
A Near them.
Q Okay. You report there. Who tells you what to do,
if anybody?
A Bobby Jones.
Q Okay. What did he tell you to do on the day you
were hurt?
[T:19]A To go to the south dumper and check and repair
the retarders.
Q Okay.
A Retarders are what stops the coal cars.
Q They act like a cushion or something when they un-
load it?
A Braking system.
Q Is it after they have been unloaded or while they are
being unloaded or prior to being dumped?
A Prior.
Q Okay. They are on the dumpers themselves?
A Yes, sir.
Q Tell me a little bit about how the retarders play a
role in the dumping process.
JA-188
A They stop the coal cars in place.
Mr. Wilson: Before you answer that, I object to the
form of the question. You are assuming they are involved
in the dumping process.
Mr. Richardson: Sure. I understand.
Mr. Wilson: Go ahead and answer it, Bob.
By Mr. Richardson:
([T:27]Q And how often do you have to replace the sword
and pins?
A I don’t know. Sometimes you have to replace them,
and sometimes you don’t.
Q Can you go years without replacing them? Is this
something you do every month or every six months or—
A You check them more often, and I am not sure the
length of time they last.
Q Okay. You weren’t surprised to see they needed to
be replaced?
A No sir.
Q Okay. Once you saw that, what did you decide to do?
A Contacted Bobby Jones and told him what the situ-
ation was, and he said to replace them.
Q Okay. And is this a big job?
A Yes, sir.
Q Does it require shutting down the dumpers?
A Yes, sir. »
Q Okay. Was the dumper shut down during [T:28] this
time?
JA-189
A Yes, sir.
Q There wasn’t any coal being loaded?
A No, sir.
Q That is when y’all do the maintenance on the dumpers
is when it’s down like that?
A Yes, sir.
Q Okay. What does the—tell me a little bit about how
you go about replacing these things.
A You have to have an acetylene and oxygen torch, and
you take the pins, which are actually bolts, out of the
linkage, and you heat up the keeper strap that is over top
of one of the pins, that is a pin, not a bolt. You bend it
out of the way, and you take the pin out, and usually or
supposedly that is all that has to be done. You take the
pin out and take the sword out.
On this particular day the bushing that the pin goes
through was broke, and I had to take the acetylene and
oxygen torch and push the bushing block off. Then I had
to go back to the shop and get a new bushing block and
new pin and come back to the dumper to replace it.
JA-190
VIRGINIA: IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
CITY OF NORFOLK
AT LAW NO. L86-335
ROBERT T. GOODE, JR.
Plaintiff,
Vv.
NORFOLK AND WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
CITY OF , to-wit:
THIS DAY, before me, the undersigned, a Notary Public
in and for the Commonwealth of Virginia, personally ap-
peared Ronel Lee Croft, who, after being duly sworn, made
oath that the following statements describe the duties and
conditions of employment for a machinist holding seniority
on Norfolk Terminal, Norfolk and Western Railway Com-
pany, Norfolk, Virginia.
12. A Norfolk Terminal railway machinist may be as-
signed duties at any geographical point on the Terminal.
As an example, machinists work at Portlock Yard (ap-
proximately 6 miles from Lamberts Point Yard).
13. All machinists on Norfolk Terminal work from a
common seniority list and may change jobs at will, based
on their seniority standing on this list.
14. Machinists perform jobs on Norfolk Terminal rang-
ing from the repair and maintenance of pier machinery;
to the repair and maintenance of railroad locomotives; to
JA-191
the repair of railroad cars; to the repair of hydraulic brak-
ing systems; to the repair of bridge raising mechanisms.
15. Norfolk Terminal machinists perform these duties at
various geographic locations ranging from the Elizabeth
River Piers, the 38th Street car shops and the locomotive
round house, all at Lamberts Point Yard; to Portlock Yard
(approximately 5 miles from Lamberts Port Yard); to
Bridge #7 (approximately 7 miles from Lamberts Point
Yard); to Crewe, Virginia (approximately 125 miles from
Lamberts Point Yard).
16. Machinists assigned to the Motive Power Depart-
ment at the Pier end of Lamberts Point Yard have job
assignments of working on Pier machinery, both over the
water and in the shop; also, work assignments involved
with railroad cars and railroad equipment, prior to the
unloading of the cars. Examples of some of these assign-
ments:
1. the repair of railroad cars;
2. the rerailing of derailed railroadcars;
3. the repair and maintenance of pushers (small electric
locomotives);
4. the repair and maintenance of the Barney;
5. the repair and maintenance of retarders; and
6. the release of handbrakes on railroad cars.
17. Retarders, such as those in use on the south side
dumper at Lamberts Point Yard, are in use throughout
the Norfolk and Western Railroad system and are common
to all railroads.
18. The purpose and function of such retarders is to
stop railroad cars.
19. The function of the retarders on the south side dum-
per is to stop railroad cars prior to the cars being un-
loaded.
JA-192
20. The conveyor belt system used to load coal on ships
begins after the unloading of railroad cars at the southside
dumper.
21. After a car is unloaded it continues its cycle back
to the coal mines to be loaded again, by continuing up a
raised track, and is then returned by gravity to an empty
car yard.
22. Different crafts of employees work beside the track
on which the south side retarder is located. As an example,
railroad brakemen work beside this track, and they are
geogra
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.