Joint Appendix — Exxon Corp. v. Hunt

Supreme Court brief1986

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

mee

2...

|

> |

bedhead

—

co

—

—

_—«

_—

o— «

—

Cs

edhe

ry)

y Be

No. 84-978

Supreme Court, U.S,

FILED

85

IN THE JOSEPH F. SPANIOL, JR.

Supreme Court of the Gnit

OCTOBER TERM 1985

EXXON CORPORATION, THE BF GOODRICH COMPANY,

UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION, MONSANTO COMPANY

AND TENNECO CHEMICALS, INC.,

Appellants,

vs.

ROBERT HUNT, Administrator of New Jersey Spill

Compensation Fund; CLIFFORD A. GOLDMAN, Treasury of

the State of New Jersey; SIDNEY GLASER, Director of the

Division of Taxation; JERRY F. ENGLISH, Commissioner of

Environmental Protection; and THE STATE OF NEW

JERSEY,

Appellees.

Appeal From the Supreme Court of New Jersey

JOINT APPENDIX

IRWIN I. KIMMELMAN JOHN J. CARLIN, JR.*

Attorney General of New Lisa J. POLLAK

Jersey MARTIN CRONIN

Attorney for Appellees FARRELL, CURTIS, CARLIN &

Richard J. Hughes Justice DAVIDSON

Complex 43 Maple Avenue

CN 112 P.O. Box 145

Trenton, New Jersey 08625 Morristown, New Jersey 07960

(609) 292-1568 (201)267-8130

MICHAEL R. COLE DANIEL M. GRIBBON

First Assistant Attorney E. EDWARD BRUCE

General DavID F. WILLIAMS

Of Counsel COVINGTON & BURLING

Mary C. JACOBSON* 1201 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.

Deputy Attorney General P.O. Box 7566

Washington, D.C. 20044

(202) 662-6000

*Counsel of Record Attorneys for Appellants

Jurisdictional Statement Filed 12/17/84

Probable Jurisdiction Noted 6/17/85

Gumance; Cooperative AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS

Wrrs States Unver THE CoMPREHENSIVE ENviRON-

MENTAL Response, COMPENSATION, AND LIABILITY

Act or 1980 (P.L. 96-510); U.S. Exvmonmenrtat

Protection Acency Orrice or EMERGENCY AND

Remepmt Response, Marcn 1982 ............. JA4

Excerpts From Appenprx oN Besar oF PLAINTIFFs-

AppeLLants, Superior Court or New Jersey, Ap-

PELLATE Drvision, Docker No. A-3913-81T1 (190

NJ Super. 131), pgs. 44a-63a ............0005. JA-12

JA-1

DOCKET ENTRIES

7/12/83—PB

SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY

Docket #21,567 Cert #C-46-83 Appeal #A-78-83

Motion #M-108-83

Exxon Corporation, The BFGoodrich

Company, et al P-P/A

Farrell, Curtis, Carlin, & Davidson, Esqs.

v.

Robert Hunt, et al D-R

Attorney General

App Div Docket #A-3913-81T2

App Div Docket # A-3546-81T2

App Div Decision Date 6/22/83

Transcripts 9/9/83 Vol 1 Copies 3

S.Ct. Argument Date 1-23-84

7/12/83—-Notice of Petition (+ Afft.)

7/12/83—Notice of Appeal (+ Afft.)

7/21/83—Pet for Cert and Appendix (+ Afft.)

7/21/83—App Div Briefs & Appx. & Reply Brief

8-12-83—Resp Brief (+ Afft.)

8-12-83—App Div Briefs

JA-2

8-8-83—Pet. & Order permitting resp. brief to be filed on

or before 8-12-83

8-24-83—Motion for extension of time to file Appellants

brief, afft. in support—Farrell, Esq.

9-28-83—-Order dismissing the motion for extension of time

to file appellants brief as moot (M-108-83)

9-9-83—Order Grant Cert

7/12/83—$250.00 Farrell, Esq. Security Deposit

12-3-84—Affidavit of Costs

7/10/85—Taxed Costs

Fees App $20-, $20-

Decision Affirm

Decision Date 9-19-84 Vote 5-0

Opinion by Clifford, J. Pages 29

10-44-83—Corrected Order on motion for an extension of

time to file the Appellants’ brief is dismissed as moot

(M-108)

12/2/83—Supplemental Letter—Farrell, Esq.

1/2/85—N/A to U.S. Supreme Ct

JA-3

SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY

Stephen W. Townsend Office of the Clerk

Clerk CN 970

Trenton, N.J. 08625

Keith M. Endo

Deputy Clerk

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

I, the undersigned, Clerk of the Supreme Court of New

Jersey, do hereby certify that the attached is a true copy

of the docket sheets in Exxon Corporation, et al. v. Robert

Hunt, et al., A-78 September Term 1982, Docket Number

21,567.

In Testimony Whereof, I have

hereunto set my hand and

affixed the Seal of said Court

at Trenton, this 29th day~ of

July, 1985.

/3/ StepHen W. Townsend

Clerk

JA4

GUIDANCE

COOPERATIVE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS

WITH STATES UNDER THE

COMPREHENSIVE ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSE,

COMPENSATION, AND LIABILITY ACT OF 1980

(P.L. 96-510)

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

OFFICE OF EMERGENCY AND REMEDIAL

RESPONSE

MARCH 1982

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Based on authorities provided in Section 104 of the Com-

prehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and

Liability Act of 1980 (CERCLA) and delegated in Execu-

tive Order 12316, the Environmental Protection Agency

(EPA) is authorized to take remedial actions to clean up

uncontrolled hazardous waste sites. In granting this au-

thority, Congress also included provisions in the law re-

quiring that Federal response actions be coordinated with

State actions. Four provisions are of particular importance

to Federal/State relations.

The first is the requirement that Federal remedial actions

be undertaken only after consultation with the affected

State or States. Agreements reached between the State and

EPA are documented in a Cooperative Agreement or

Superfund State Contract.

The second provision relates to assurances that the af-

JA-5

fected State must provide prior to any remedial action.

The State must assure that it will:

° Assume operations and maintenance (O&M) responsi-

bility for the site for all removal and remedial meas-

ures that are implemented.

° Provide for a facility for off-site disposal if necessary,

and

° Share in the costs of the remedial action.

These assurances are included in the Cooperative Agree-

ment or State Contract negotiated with the State.

The third and fourth provisions for coordinating State

and Federal actions relate to the granting of a credit to

an affected State for costs expended or obligated at a

remedial action site between January 1, 1978 and Decem-

ber 11, 1980. The credit is used as part of the State’s

share of costs for a Federally funded response at the site.

The following additional guidance has been established

by the Administrator to further define each of these pro-

visions :

1. STATE CONTRACTS AND COOPERATIVE AGREEMENTS

CERCLA specifies that remedial actions (including any

remedial planning activities) can be undertaken at a site

only if a Cooperative Agreement or Superfund State Con-

tract covering that action has been executed.* Both in-

*CERCLA Section 104(b) authorizes the President to ‘‘.. .

undertake such planning, legal, fiscal, economic, engineering, archi-

tectural, and other studies or investigations as he may deem neces-

sary or approproate [sic] to plan and direct response actions . . .”’

CERCLA Section 104(c) (3) requires that ‘‘.. . The President shall

not provide any remedial actions . . . unless the State in which

the release occurs first enters into a contract or cooperative agree-

ment with the President .. .’’

JA-6

struments are legally binding upon the State and EPA. The

arrangement that is executed depends on whether EPA or

the State assumes the lead responsibility for the remedial

action:

° A Cooperative Agreement is required when the State

has lead responsibility for the activity and funds are

transferred to the State

° A Superfund State Contract is required when EPA has

lead responsibility for the activity.

EPA will encourage States to assume lead responsibility

for remedial actions in order to assist them in developing

their own individual response capabilities:

Authority to bind EPA to the terms of a Cooperative

Agreement or a Superfund State Contract has been dele-

gated to the following EPA Officials.

° The Director, Grants Administration Division for Co-

operative Agreements (the Award Official)

° The Assistant Administrator, Office of Solid Waste

and Emergency Response for Superfund State Con-

tracts (the Decision Official)

The signature of an authorized State official, certified by

the State’s Attorney General as having the authority to

bind the State, also is required to execute the Cooperative

Agreement or State Contract.

As action progresses at a site, a new or amended Co-

operative Agreement or State Contract may be negotiated

if necessary to incorporate any changes.

Cooperative Agreements and State Contracts will be

site-specific and may cover one or more activities at that

site.

JA-7

2. STATE ASSURANCES

a) O&M

Prior to remedial investigation activity at a site, the

State’s Governor or Attorney General must sign a letter

acknowledging State responsibility for operating and main-

taining the action. The letter must be sumitted as an

attachment to the application for a Cooperative Agreement

or State Contract.

Prior to remedial design activity, the State must make a

firm commitment, either through a Cooperative Agreement

or a new or amended State Contract, to assume O&M re-

sponsibility. To satisfy this requirement, the State must:

° Identify the organization unit responsible for admin-

istering O&M activities,

° Identify the State’s financial mechanism for funding

O&M activities, and

° Identify milestone dates for assuming responsibility.

In those cases where part or all of the selected remedy

requires future O&M, EPA will share in those costs asso-

ciated with ensuring that the remedy is functional and

operational for a period not to exceed six months after

completion of construction. Funds for this 6-month period

must be specified before hand [sic] in a Cooperative Agree-

ment.

b) Off-Site Disposal

Prior to remedial investigation activity at a site, the

State must assure EPA in writing that it will provide

an acceptable hazardous waste disposal facility, if one is

needed to implement the remedial action selected. To be

acceptable, the facility must:

° Have sufficient capacity to handle wastes from the

site, and

JAS

° Be compatibie with the type of wastes found on the

site.

The written assurances shall be obtained beforehand

from the State official who is authorized to enter into a

Cooperative Agreement or State Contract.

c) Cost-Sharing

Prior to the commencement of any activitiy at a site,

the State is required to asknowledge its responsibility to

share in the cost of the action:

° At publicly owned sites, the State must share 50 per-

cent of all response costs.

° At privately owned sites, States must share 10 percent

of remedial planning (remedial investigation, feasi-

bility study, and design) and remedial implementation.

This acknowledgement may be done either through a

Cooperative Agreement or a new or amended State Con-

tract. A State may authorize the reduction of its credit

to cover its share of costs. If the State credit is not suf-

ficient to satisfy the State’s share of the costs:

° State funds will be used simultaneously with Federal

funds for site expenses under a Cooperative Agree-

ment.

° Payment terms will be negotiated and agreed to in a

State Contract.

Prior to remedial design activity, the State must, either

through a Cooperative Agreement or a new or amended

State Contract, make a firm commitment to provide fund-

ing for remedial implementation. A State may satisfy this

assurance by:

° Authorizing the reduction of a State credit to cover

its share of costs, or

JA-9

° Identifying currently available funds earmarked for

remedial implementation, or

° Submitting a plan with milestones for obtaining neces-

sary funds.

3. STATE CREDITS

State credits must be documented on a site-specific basis

for State out-of-pocket, non-Federal eligible response costs

between January 1, 1978 and December 11, 1980. Prior to

remedial investigation activity at a site, the State must

submit its estimate of these costs as a part of the pre-

application package when a Cooperative Agreement is used,

or as a part of the State Contract.

State credits will be applied against State cost shares for

Federally funded remedial actions. A State cannot be re-

imbursed from the Fund for credit in excess of its matching

share.

_

4. STATE COST-SHARE CONTRIBUTION

Terms for obtaining State cost shares for remedial ac-

tivities will be identified in the Cooperative Agreement or

State Contract covering those activities. Where a credit

has been identified at a site, EPA will reduce that credit by

an amount equal to the State’s share of costs until the

credit is eliminated or the remedial action is complete.

For EPA-led remedial actions where there is no State

credit or the credit is not sufficient to cover State costs,

payment terms will be negotiated between EPA and the

State and documented in the State Contract. The terms

agreed to should accommodate individual State needs, with-

in these constraints:

° States should provide some up-front funds for each

planing activity (remedial investigation, feasibility

study, remedial design) before that activity starts.

JA-10

° Other payments may be scheduled during or immedi-

ately following each planning activity.

° Prior to implementing the chosen remedial action,

EPA will require full payment of the State’s share of

remedial planning.

For State-led remedial actions where there is no State

credit or the credit is not sufficient to cover State costs,

the Cooperative Agreement will cover only EPA’s share of

costs. EPA will provide the award amount to the State

through a letter of credit. States are required to match

Federal funds as work progresses. Drawdowns will be

monitored to ensure that States provide their cost shares

as Federal funds are used.

5. PRE-EMPTION

Section 114(c) of CERCLA prohibits a State from re-

quiring persons to contribute to funds for the purpose of

certain activities related to hazardous substance response.

EPA has reviewed the type of hazardous response activi-

ties covered by this section and has determined that it does

not apply to State funds which are used for the following

purposes:

° To finance the administrative costs of a State fund,

° To finance the purchase or prepositioning of hazardous

substance response equipment and other preparations

for responding to releases within a State,

° To finance the cleanup of petroleum discharges,

° To pay the required State contribution to cleanup ac-

tions financed by the CERCLA Trust Fund,

° To compensate claims for the cost of restoration and

replacement of any natural resources damaged or de-

stroyed by a release of a hazardous substance,

—eS—eEEEeEeEeEeEeEeEEEEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEEEEe———

JA-11

° To advance funds to remove or remedy releases of haz-

ardous substances eligible to be financed by the Haz-

ardous Substance Response Fund if a Cooperative

Agreement or Contract has been issued by the Environ-

mental Protection Agency.

° To compensate damage claims and to remove or remedy

releases of hazardous substances eligible to be financed

by the Fund but for which no federal reimbursement

is provided.

JA-12

SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY

APPELLATE Division

Docket No. A-3913-81T1

Exxon Corporation, The BF Goodrich Company, Union

Carbide Corporation, Monsanto Company and Tenneco

Chemicals, Inc.,

Plaintiff s-Appellants,

vs.

Robert Hunt, Administrator of N.J. Spill Compensation

Fund ; Clifford A. Goldman, Treasurer of the State of N.J.;

Sidney Glaser, Director of the Division of Taxation; and

the State of N.J.,

Defendants-Respondents.

and

Exxon Corporation, The BF Goodrich Company, Union

Carbide Corporation, Monsanto Company and Tenneco

Chemicals, Inc.,

Plaintiff s-Appellants,

vs.

Robert Hunt, Administrator of N.J. Spill Compensation

Fund; Clifford A. Goldman, Treasurer of the State of N.J.;

Sidney Glaser, Director of the Division of Taxation; Jerry

F. English, Commissioner of Environmental Protection;

and the State of N.J.,

Defendants-Respondents.

JA-13

ConsoLipatep Crvm Actions—On Appeal From Firovar

Decision or THE Tax Court or New JERSEY

Sat Betow: Hon. Joun F. Evens, J.T.C.

Docket No. A-3546-81T2

Exxon Corporation, the BF Goodrich Company, Union

Carbide Corporation, Monsanto Company and Tenneco

Chemicals, Inc.,

Appellants,

vs.

Kenneth R. Biederman, Treasurer of the State of N.J.

and the N.J. Department of the Treasury,

Respondents.

-

Crvm Actios—On AppeaL From PROMULGATION OF

REGULATIONS BY THE TREASURER OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY

APPENDIX ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS

Farre.u, Curtis, Cantus & Davison,

Attorneys for Plaintiff s-Appellants,

43 Maple Avenue,

Morristown, New Jersey (7960

(201) 267-8130

Joun J. Cag, Je.

Lisa J. Potiak

On the Brief

JA-14

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

DEPARTMENT OF LAW AND PUBLIC SAFETY

Drvision or Law

FovanciaL SEcTIoN

107 West State Street

CN 112

Trenton 08625

Telephone 609/292-1526

November 17, 1981

John J. Carlin, Jr., Esq.

Farrell, Curtis, Carlin & Davidson

43 Maple Ave.

P. O. Box 145

Morristown, NJ 07960

Re: EXXON Corp. v. Hunt

Dear Mr. Carlin:

This letter is to confirm the figures supplied to you

today by telephone. As I noted to you, these figures are

estimated and subject to verification and are being fur-

nished at your request so as to obviate the need, at the

present time, to take the depositions of the various State

officials you have previously noted. We will continue to

work on answers to your questions and will respond to

you as soon as the results are obtained.

Information furnished by the Office of the Administrator

of the Spill Compensation Fund:

Period 7/1/80 to 6/30/81

Clean-up Expenditures

Hazardous Substances $27,000,000

Petroleum $ 370,000

JA-15

Damage Claim Expenditures

Hazardous Substances $ 354,000

Petroleum $ 124,000

Information supplied by the Division of Taxation:

Fiscal Year Amount of Tax Revenue

1977 $ 1,100,415

1978 6,429,830

1979 6,402,848

1980 6,850,324

1981 12,788,846

At the present time, there are 262 taxpayers registered

under the Spill Compensation and Control Act.

I am enclosing copies of the three schedules prepared by

the Administrator of the Spill Compensation Fund.

Very truly yours, .

James R. Zazzaui

Attorney General of New Jersey

By: /s/Hersert K. GuickMAN

Herbert K. Glickman

Deputy Attorney General

encl.

JA-16

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

SCHEDULE OF REVENUES AND DISBURSEMENTS

JULY 1, 1979 TO JUNE 30, 1980

FUND BALANCE JUNE 30, 1980

Fund Balance 6/30/79 $11,823,040.37

REVENUES

Tax Deposits $6,849,636.73

Penalties &

Interest 13,161.63

Interest Trans-

ferred—Cash

Management

Fund 1,826,496.38 $8,689,294.74

Total Available 20,512,335.11

EXPENDITURES

Clean-up 2,612,390.49

Transferred to

Treasury

Administration ( 15,865.68) 2,596,524.81

Treasury

Administration 55,860.26

Transferred from

Clean-up ( 15,865.68)

Damage Claims 63,516.44

DEP

Administration 659,129.82

DEP—Research 131,399.60 909,906.12

JA-17

LIABILITIES

Clean-up

Obligations 2,130,978.82

Administration

Obligations—

Treasury 100,000.00 2,230,978.82

Total Expenditures &

Liabilities 5,753,275.43

Fund Balance June 30, 1980 $14,759,059.68

JA-18

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT

Fund Balance as of June 30, 1980 $14,759,059.68

Outstanding Violations 34,800.00

14,793,859.68

Tnabilities

Damage Claim Reserves 6/30/80

Chemical Control $1,000,000.00

Other Claims 300,000.00

Clean-up Expenses Reserves:

Chemical Control

Corporation 10,000,000.00

Pre-Act Discharges 1,500,000.00 12,800,000.00

Balance $1,959,059.68

JA-19

The cost of cleanup of the discharge of hazardous ma-

terial continues to dominate expenditures from the Fund.

During the fiscal year 7/1/79-6/30/80, the total cost for

cleanup and removal of current discharges amounted to

$2,422,152.62 of which $2,395,806.69 represents the cleanup

and removal of hazardous materials other than petroleum.

Furthermore, amendatory legislation was signed into law

in January 1980 which gives the Adminisirator authority,

subject to availability of funds, to approve the cost of

cleanup and removal of conditions which may not consti-

tute a discharge but create an imminent peril to the safety

and welfare of the public. The amended legislation also

permits the Administrator, subject to availability of funds,

to approve annual expenditures not to exceed $3 million

for the cleanup and removal of discharges which com-

menced prior to the inception of the Act. The New Jersey

Department of Environmental Protection is actively work-

ing to identify and establish priorities on this subject,

which is composed largely of abandoned sites of hazardous

materials and it is expected that the full $3 million annual

allotment will be utilized.

The previously reported legal desision in the Bergen

County Superior Court litigation of State of New Jersey,

Department of Environmental Protection vs. Ventron Cor-

poration is under appeal. Since amendments to the law

provide a limitation of $1.5 million per site for pre-Act

discharges, the impact of any decision against the Fund

may conform to the new statutory limit. However, the

possibility remains of an adverse interpretation which

would expose the resources of the Fund to unlimited .

liability.

On April 21, 1980, a major discharge of hazardous ma-

terial occurred when an explosion and fire erupted at the

site of the Chemical Control Corporation in Elizabeth, New

Jersey. The results of this occurrence created an imminent

peril to the safety and welfare of the residents of the

JA-20

City of Elizabeth and the environment which required im-

mediate action by the New Jersey Department of Environ-

mental Protection to accelerate cleanup and removal opera-

tions which were already in process. As of June 30, 1980,

it is estimated that the total cost of cleanup to be com-

pleted by November 1, 1980 will approach $12 million.

Additional obligations of approximately $1 million can be

anticipated for the payment of damage claims presented

by third parties. The cost of this cleanup will dramatically

reduce the balance in the Fund which could create an

availability probl..n in the cleanup of future discharges.

Efforts to recover funds against responsible dischargers

are continuing with legal actions being prepared and pur-

sued by deputies in the Attorney General’s office repre-

senting the Fund. Many legal issues have been raised by

alleged dischargers which have impeded reimbursement to

the Fund and will result in extended legal activity.

JA-21

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE SUMMARY

7/1/79-6/30/80

PAID

Petroleum Spills ........... $ 26,345.93

Chemical Spills ............ 2,395,806.69

Pre-Act Discharges ........ 174,372.19

RESERVES

Cleanup in Progress

Chemical Control ........ 10,000,000.00

Pre-Act Discharges ...... 1,500,000.00

IES a ccccccccescccetcncesesessecess

$14,096,524-81

JA-22

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/79-6/30/80

PETROLEUM SPILLS

NO. SPILL AMOUNT

1. 798-02 #2 oil, unknown source $ 5,565.73

Burlington

County

2. 798-06 deliberate dump-kerosene 5,281.24

Allamuchy & other oils

3. 798-07 deliberate dump-kezosene 532.08

Allamuchy & other oils

4. 778-02 illegal dump of trans- 2,790.53

Perth Amboy former oil

5. 798-11 #2 oil at truck rest area, 4,863.06

Harding Twp. source uaknown

6. 798-18 oil spill, source unknown 7,313.26

Willingboro

(Edgewater

Park) TOTAL: $26,345.93

JA-23

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

NO.

. 789-08

Jersey City

(United

Chemical

. 789-13

Newark

(Arlington

Warehouse)

. 798-09

Jackson

Township

. 798-12

Hillsborough

Twp.

. 798-14

Sayreville

. 798-15

Cape May

. 798-16

Elizabeth

(Flora St.)

. 798-17

Jersey City

. 789-17

Elizabeth

(Chemical

Control)

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/79-6/30/80

CHEMICAL SPILLS

SPILL AMOUNT

fire in chemical warehouse, $ 126,632.39

massive discharge of

hazardous substances; fire

originated at adjacent

location

fire in chemical warehouse, 75,365.46

discharge of hazardous

substances

alleged illegal dumping of

hazardous materials

4,525.90

hazardous materials discharge 48,285.81

from tanks and drums

50,586.36

leaking drums of hazardous

materials

leaking drums of hazardous

materials; contaminated soil

cleanup & removal of drums

of chemical waste

7,097.80

25,960.73

alleged illegal dumping of $138,688.53

hazardous materials

leaking drums of waste

chemicals ; court order

issued to clean-up; explo-

sion and fire

1,918,663.71

TOTAL: $2,395,806.69

J A-24

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/79-6/30/80

PRE-ACT DISCHARGES

NO.

1. 80-10

Altman Avenue

Rutherford

2. 80-07

Sayreville

(Atlantic

Development)

3. 80-16

New Brunswick

(A-Z Chemical)

4. 80-02

Piscataway

(Bubenick)

5. 80-05

Newark

(Thos. Cook)

6. 80-15

Howell Twp.

(El Cid)

7. 80-11

SPILL AMOUNT

Small number of drums of $¢ 2,173.00

hazardous material dumped

along roadside

Abandoned factory with 1,692.00

1,000 drums & 500 5-gallon

pails of hazardous waste,

soil contamination

Abandoned site with 10,000 84,256.15

drums of various hazardous

wastes; limited soil &

groundwater contamination

40 leaking drums of assorted 13,505.03

solvents and adhesives; 5

cubic yards of contami-

nated soil

Abandoned building with 10,744.49

7,000 gallons of formalde-

hyde in open vats; several

drums of various other

hazardous materials

Abandoned trailer contain- 11,817.20

ing 84 leaking drums of

hazardous material

Approximately 65 drums 16,070.65

Kast Rutherford containing hazardous

(Madison

Circle)

8. 80-04

Hillsborough

Twp. (Swoco)

wastes dumped along

roadside

Tanks containing 24,000 34,1*3.67

gallons of waste oil and

sludges

TOTAL: $174,372.19

JA-25

ADDENDUM

Since this report is being prepared in December 1980, a

copy of notification from the Administrator dated October

24, 1980, is attached which more clearly represents the

current status of the Fund balance in comparison to the

June 30, 1980 report.

JA-26

MEMORANDUM

Hon. Clifford Goldman

State Treasurer

and

To Sidney Glaser, Director

Division of Taxation

Department of Treasury

From Robert E. Hunt, Administrator

N.J. Spill Compensation Fund

Subject Spill Compensation Fund

Date October 24, 1980

Pursuant to the provisions of the New Jersey Spill Com-

pensation and Control Act P.L.1976,c.141, I am notifying

you that the total cost of reasonable claims against the

New Jersey Spil! Compensation Fund exceeds the Fund

balance as recorded on October 17, 1980.

Under the provisions of C 58:10-23.11h, Section 9, the

calculation of the cost of reasonable claims against the

Fund requires a tax increase on hazardous substances to

$0.04 per barrel transferred or 0.8% of the fair market

value of such hazardous substance, until the revenue pro-

duced by such increased rate equals 150% of the total

dollar amount of all pending reasonable claims resulting

from the discharge of hazardous substances other than

petroleum or petroleum products. It will not be necessary

to increase the tax on petroleum or petroleum products

since the existing rate of $0.01 per barrel transferred will

produce sufficient revenue to satisfy outstanding reason-

able claims against the Fund within one year.

The cost of reasonable claims against the Fund as the

result of discharge of hazardous substances other than

JA-27

petroleum which creates the deficit balance is $3,258,296.

Therefore, the increased tax should remain in effect until

it produces revenues on hazardous substances equal to

$4,887,444.

R.E.H.

R.E.H. :rj

JA-28

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

Fund Balance 10/17/80

Control Balance $2,258,492.

Interest 2,700,000.

Cleanup Balance 1,350,435.

Outstanding Expenses

Unpaid invoices

at DEP 1,814,000.

Unpaid invoices

at Spill Fund 510,795.

Unpaid invoices for

Pre-Act at

Spill Fund 90,198.

Cleanup obligation

(A to Z) 65,000. $2,479,993.

Commitments Against Appropriations

Administration

Spill Fund 100,000.

Dept. of Environ-

mental Protection 500,000.

Obligation for

Adjustment Services

{Chemical Control) 100,000. 700,000.

Pending Damage Claims 1,021,788.*

Expenses for Cleanup and Removal

of Current Discharges

Chemical Control 2,500,000.

Sampson Tank

(Ringwood &

West Milford) 3,000,000. 5,500,000.*

$6,308,927.

J A-29

Total costs of reasonable claims

against the Fund $9,701,781.

Operating Fund Balance 10/17/80 (3,392,854)

NOTE:

1. 134,558. represents discharge of petroleum.

2. Of the $5.5 million, $2 million represents

services already performed but not billed.

JA-30

NEW JERSEY SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

SCHEDULE OF REVENUES AND DISBURSEMENTS

FOR 1977, 1978 AND 1979

FUND BALANCE JUNE 30, 1979

Revenues

Interest on Investments $ 634,471.41

Less Accrued

Interest Paid ( 4,031.87) $ 630,439.54

Interest Due from

State of New Jersey

Cash Management

Fund 536,172.06

Profit & Loss 2,569.58 $ 1,169,181.18

Division of Taxation $13,921 ,663.86

Deposits

Less Refunds ( 23,220.60) $13,898,443.26

Penalty and Interest 81,844.84 $13,980,288.10

Appropriated Receipts (*See below) 1,267.50

TOTAL REVENUES $15,150,736.78

Disbursements

Hazardous Substance

Removal Costs $ 1,900,609.97

Cleanup and

Restoration Costs 1,361.61

JA-31

Administrative Costs

Treasury $ 99,580.48

Oil Spill-DEP 657,135.50

Oil Spill-DEP Pollu-

tion Control 200,000.00 $ 956,715.98

Liabilities

Obligations of

Appropriations $ 467,741.35

Due to Emergency

Service Trust

(*See above) 1,267.50 ¢$ 469,008.85

TOTAL DISBURSEMENTS & LIABILITIES $ 3,327,696.41

Fund Balance as of June 30, 1979 $11,823,040.37

J A-32

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT

Fund Balance as of June 30, 1979 $11,823,040.37

Outstanding Violations 34,975.00

11,858,015.37

Reserves on Active Claims

Damage Claims $ 255,667.00

Cleanup Expense:

Chemical Control 2,488,061.48

United Chemical 126,632.39

Arlington Warehouse . 75,365.46 2,945,726.33

Balance $ 8,912,289.04°

* If an appellant decision in the Ventron litigation upholds a trial

court interpretation declaring the Fund responsible for pre-Act

discharges (see narrative), additional damage claim reserves of

$13.5 million will result, producing a deficit balance of $4,587,-

710.96.

JA-33

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

ANNUAL REPORT

The Fund was used for the cleanup of (19) spills during

the period 7/1/78-6/30/79. This included three major spills

still in progress; two involving fires at chemical ware-

houses in Jersey City, N.J. and Newark, N.J., and an ex-

tensive cleanup of leaking waste chemical drums at the site

of Chemical Control Corporation, Elizabeth, N.J. The total

expense for cleanup, including reserves for work in prog-

ress will be $4,527,095.26.

As of 6/30/79, 23 damage claims have been received.

Three have been denied as not eligible for recovery and

three have been paid directly by the discharger with the

assistance of the Fund. Fifteen claims remain pending, six

of which have been denied because they involved pre-Act

discharge. The Bergen County Superior Court recently

issued a decision in the case of State of New Jersey, De-

partment of Environmental Protection vs. Ventron Cor-

poration, which appears to hold the Fund responsible for

pre-Act discharges. The full impact of this decision cannot

be evaluated until the Order for Judgment is filed. It is

expected most of the parties to the litigation will file an

appeal. If it is concluded that the Fund will be responsible

for pre-Act discharges, a reconsideration of the six known

damage claims including Ventron (presently valued at $9

million) will result in added reserves of $13.5 million.

Public awareness of the Fund continues to increase and

more time is being devoted to the evaluation and considera-

tion of damage claims. Legal activity is also increasing as

we begin subrogation actions to recover funds expended.

JA-34

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/78-6/30/79

Petroleum Spills Total ..................... $ 40,651.55

Chemical Spills Complete .................. $1,796,384.38

Chemical Spills-Reserves .................. $2,690,059.33

Cleanup in Progress

JA-35

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/78-6/30/79

PETROLEUM SPILLS

NO. SPILL AMOUNT

1. 778-02 illegal dump of trans- $25,984.09

Perth Amboy former oil

2. 789-02 underground fuel oil 2,631.25

Wayne storage tank leak

3. 789-03 underground fuel oil 726.35

Netcong storage tank leak

4. 789-07 gasoline-leaking under- 1,278.00

White House ground storage tank

Station — ‘

5. 789-10 gasoline-leaking valve at 3,374.38

Denville pump at gas station

6. 789-15 gasoline or aviation fuel, 718.40

Hillsboro Twp. source unidentified

7. 789-18 #2 fuel oil-oil storage 2,643.44

Atlantic City tank leak

8. 789-22 intentional dump of oil 3,295.64

Carneys Point

TOTAL: $40,651.55

JA-36

N.J. SPILL COMPENSATION FUND

NO.

1. 789-01

Hammonton

2. 789-04

Freehold

3. 789-05

Hammonton

4. 789-06

Elizabeth

5. 789-08

Jersey City

(United

Chemical)

6. 789-11

Elizabeth

7. 789-12

New

Shrewsbury

8. 789-13

Newark

(Arlington

Warehouse)

CLEAN-UP EXPENSE

7/1/18-6/30/79

CHEMICAL SPILLS

SPILL

illegal abandonment of

leaking drums of

hazardous materials

illegal abandonment of

leaking drums of miscel-

laneous chemicals

illegal chemical dump

accidental spill of waste

chemicals

fire in chemical warehouse,

massive discharge of haz-

ardous substances; fire

originated at adjacent

location

accidenfal spill of waste

chemicals

illegally abandoned drums

of leaking hazardous

chemicals

fire in chemical ware-

house, discharge of haz-

ardous substances

AMOUNT

$ 49,761.93

195.00

273.53

547,070.69

193.51

4,958.14

1,159,530.08

JA-37

9. 789-14 lithium battery waste 16,756.20

Teaneck contaminated soil due to fire

in disposal vehicle

10. 789-17 leaking drums of waste 11,938.52

Elizabeth chemicals ; court order

(Chemical issued to clean up

Control

Corp.)

11. 789-20 deliberate dump of zinc 5,316.78

Elmwood Park chloride

TOTAL: $1,796,384.38

JA-38

ADMINISTRATOR’S ANNUAL REPORT

New Jersey Spill Compensation Fund

STATEMENT OF CASH RECEIPTS &

DISBURSEMENTS

For 15 Month Period 4/1/77 - 6/30/78

Receipts

Taxes Collected .......... $7,495,625.83

Penalties for Violations ... 34,619.00

Interest on Investments ... 207,628.66

EE ED ovensoecscetusaidevens $7,737,873.49

Disbursements

PN itcenhoneneeedaes $ 8,125.00

Administrative Services 866.68

Clean-up Expense ........ 63,574.04

Division of Taxation ...... 20,960.00

DEP Pollution Control

ETT TT TTe 200,000.00

(S 734 signed 6/30/78)

Contingent Liability

(Administration) ....... 291,716.69

Total Disbursements .............. $ 585,242.41

BUNNNGD G/GIVGD oc ccccccccccccccvccceses $7,152,631.08

J A-39

New Jersey Spill Compensation Fund

Potential Liability for Damages as of 6/30/78

Fund Balance 6/30/78 .................- $7,152,631.08

Outstanding Violations . $ 30,570.00

Pending Claims (8) ....($7,588,696.34) *

Total (Potential Deficit) ............ ($ 405,495.76) *

The potential liabilities against the Fund are recorded

at face value and include the Ventron Corp. case (see be-

low) at a value of $6,000,000. Any payment of claims, as

required by legislation, will be subject to a claims adjust-

ment evaluation and the Fund will acquire subrogation

rights to proceed for reimbursement against dischargers

if the discharger can be identified.

Since April 1, 1977, there have been ten (10) damage

claims filed against the Fund. Two (2) have been resolved

without payments from the Spill Compensation Fund. Of

the eight (8) claims pending, six (6) relate to discharges

which commenced prior to 4/1/77.

The legal issue of whether the Spill Compensation and

Control Act provides for retroactive clean-up and damage

payments is the subject of litigation in State of New Jersey,

Department of Environmental Protection vs Ventron Corp.,

Docket No. C-2996-75, Superior Court Chancery Division,

Bergen County. This case raises the question of whether

the Fund is strictly liable for clean-up, removal and abate-

ment expenses related to alleged mercury pollution of a 40

acre tract of land in Carlstadt, New Jersey, which occurred

prior to April L, 1977. The expense of such corrective pro-

cedures has been estimated at approximately $5-6 million.

To proiect the financial viability of the Fund and assure

the administration of the Fund in conformity with the

requirements of the Spill Compensation and Control Act,

JA40

the Administrator has formally taken the position through

counsel in the Ventron case that the Fund is responsible

only for discharges of hazardous substances occurring after

the effective date of the Act.

Public awareness of the Fund has been increasing. In

addition to a high frequency of telephone inquiries, there

have been seventeen (17) requests for claim forms which

have been sent out.

In general, known dischargers are responding directly

to damage claims. Because of the Fund, damage claims by

individuals and municipalities can be processed at less cost

to the public by soliciting the assistance of the Adminis-

trator who has been able to invoke the provisions of the

Act to encourage settlements by known dischargers with-

out requiring court action.

ROBERT E. HUNT

ADMINISTRATOR

/s/ Rosert E. Hont

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.