Opposition Brief — Kansas Gas and Electric Company v. William E. Brock, Secretary of Labor and James E. Wells, Jr
Supreme Court brief1986
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 85-1403
In the Supreme Court of the United 'étetes™
OCTOBER TERM, 1985
KANSAS GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY,
Petitioner
<
(ya
‘i
WILLIAM E. BROCK,
Secretary of Labor,
Respondent
and
JAMES E. WELLS, JR.,
Respondent
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF IN OPPOSITION
MICPAFL C. HELPFRT
(Counsel of Record)
DALF W. BELL
GUY, HELBERT, BELL & SMITH,
Chartered
519 Commercial, P. 0. Box 92!)
Fmporia, KS 66801-0921
316-343-6500
Attorneys for Respondent,
James F. Wells, Jr.
Supreme Court, US
FILED
MAR 28 1966
. SPANIOL, JR.
CLERK
EDITOR'S NOTE
THE FOLLOWING PAGES WERE POOR HARD COPY
AT THE TIME OF FILMING, IF AND WHEN A
BETTER COPY CAN BE OBTAINED, A NEW FICHE
WILL BE ISSUED,
QUESTION PRESENTED
Whether Section 210(a) of the Energy
Reorganization Act, 42 U.S.C. Sec.
585l(a), prohibits discrimination against
and discharge of a “quality assurance"
inspector for reporting nuclear safety
concerns to his employer.
Il
TABLE OF CONTENTS
OUFSTION PRESENTFD cccccccesscecs
TABLE OF AUTHORITIFS ceccccccevees
REASONS FOR DENYING THE WRIT «eee
I.
CONCLUSION
THF NARROW HOLDING OF
THE FIFTH CIRCUIT IN
PROWN & ROOT v.
DONOVAN, 747 F.2D
1029 (5TH CIR. 1984)
IS INSUFFICIENT IN
LIGHT OF THE CLEAR
STATUTORY PROVISIONS
AND THE FACTS AND
HOLDING IN THE
INSTANT CASE TO
JUSTIFY THF GRANTING
OF THE WRIT cscsscsccsess
I
It!
2
q
12
II!
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Brown & Root v. Donovan, 747 F.2d
1029 (5th Cir. 1984)
eecesccccccesscccehs, 5S, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12
Consolidated Edison Company of New
York, Inc. v. Donovan, 673 F.2d
61 (2nd Cir. 1982) ceccccccccccceeee SF
DeFord v. Secretary of Labor, 700
F.2d 281 (6th Cir. 1983) wccccccceee 8
Donovan v. Hahner, Foreman, & Harness,
Inc., 736 F.2d 1421 (10th Cir.
1984) cccccccccccccccccccscccccccces§ 7
Emery Mining Corp. v. Secretary of
Labor, 744 F2d 1411, 1415 (10th
Cir. 1984) cccccccccccccccccccccccce 7
In the Matter of Consumers Power Co.,
7 BEC 7, 11 (1974) cecccccccccsecece 10
Mackowiak v. University Nuclear
Systems, Inc., 735 F.2d 1159 (9th
Cire 1984) wccccccccccccccccccseerdsy Dy 9
NLRB v. Retail Fmployees' Union Common
Local 876, 570 F.2d 586 (6th Cir.),
cert. denied, 439 U.S. 819 (1978) ..6-7
IV
NLRB v. Schrivner, 405 U.S. 117
(1972) cecccccccccccccccscesevccsces
Phillips v. Interior Poard of Mine
Operations Appeals, 500 F.2d 772,
779 (C.A.D.C. 1974), cert. denied,
420 U.S. 938 (1975) cecccccccccceeces
Wheeler v. Caterpillar Tractor Co.,
(Ill. Sup. Ct. No. 60181, S4USLW
2237-38, Nov. 5, 1985) ceocccccccceces
Statutes and Regulations
42 U.S.C.e SEC. SB51 cocccccccccccccece
42 U.S.C. Sec. 5851(a) woceeeeevcceees
10 C.F.R. Part 50, App. B ceocccsveceecs
S.Rep. No. 848, 95th Cong., 2nd Sess.
at 29, 1978 U.S.C. Conq. & Ad News
at 7303 eeeeoeeeeeeneeeeeeeeeeeeeneeeeeee
No. 85-1403
In the Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1985
KANSAS GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY,
Petitioner,
vs.
WILLIAM F. PROCK,
Secretary of Labor,
Respondent,
and
JAMFS F. WFLLS, JR.,
Respondent.
BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PETITIC. FOR A
WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
Respondent James E. Wells, Jr.,
respectfully requests that the Court deny
the Petition of Kansas Gas and Electric
Company that a writ of certiorari issue
to review the judgment and opinion of the
United States Court of Appeals for the
Tenth Circuit entered in this proceeding
on Deceinber 26, 1985.
2
STATEMENT OF CASE
The respondent concurs to some
degree with the statement of case pro-
pounded by petitioner in its brief.
Respondent submits the following in sup-
plementation of those facts submitted by
petitioner.
The Administrative Law Judge from
the Department of Labor in determining
that Wells had engaged in protective
activity looked no further than his
analysis of whether internal reports
would qualify as protected activity under
42 U.S.C. Sec. 585l(a). The Law Judge in
a very detailed analysis concluded that,
in fact, internal reports would be pro-
tected activity and, thus, it was unnec-
essary to determine whether there were
contacts with the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission (NRC). The Law Judge did note
that one report Wells filed concerned the
anchor bolt program at the Wolf Creek
Generating Station which was not correc-
ted despite a previous NRC investigation
and fine and that, in fact, the OA walk-
down group in which Wells was involved
was itself established due to that
3
inspection and fine. Furthermore, the
Law Judge found KG&E's testimony was
shifting and unreliable and the alleged
business reasons justifying its actions
were inventions and pretextural. The Law
Judge further found that the failure of
KG&E to rehire Wells was tantamount to
blacklisting. The Secretary adopted the
recommended decision of Judge Warshaw
with minor modifications and additions.
On the issue of whether or not Wells
engaged in protected activity, the
Secretary looked no further than to find
that Wells had internally submitted
safety and quality related reports, as
that was in accord with his previous
holdings and in particular with the
holding in Mackowiak v. University
Nuclear Systems, Inc., 735 F.2d 1159 (9th
Cir. 1984). In fact, during his
employment, Wells intentionally requested
that his quality/safety related reports
be placed in interoffice correspondence
Since as such it became part of the
permanent plant documentation for NRC
review and, in fact, was in contact with
NRC officials prior to his termination
4
concerning the discrepancies he had re-
ported.
REASONS FOR DENYING THE WRIT
I. THE NARROW HOLDING OF THE FIFTH
CIRCUIT IN BROWN & ROOT V. DONOVAN, 747
F.2D 1029 (5TH CIR. 1984) IS INSUFFICIENT
IN LIGHT OF THE CLEAR STATUTORY PROVI-
SIONS AND THF FACTS AND HOLDING IN THE
INSTANT CASE TO JUSTIFY THE GRANTING OF
THE WRIT.
Initially, respondent would acknow-
ledge the Tenth Circuit indicated that
they had reached a different result than
that reached in the case of Prown & Root
v. Donovan, 747 F.2d 1029 (5th Cir. 1984)
(Brown & Root). The Court stated their
rationale as follows:
"In our view, the construction of
the ERA therein employed is incor-
rect because it takes no notice of
the agency regulations, tries to
liken the term ‘action’ as synony-
mous with ‘proceeding,’ contends
that such employment determinations
are outside the competence of the
Secretary of Labor because matters
concerning nuclear safety are
exclusively involved, and discovers
5
nothing in the legislative history
to support a broad construction of
Section 5851."
The Tenth Circuit reached this conclusion
based on a very well reasoned rationale.
The Court further noted support for its
position in the holdings of Mackowiak v.
University Nuclear Systems, Inc., 735
F.2d 1159 (9th Cir. 1984) (Mackowiak);
Consolidated Fdison Company of New York,
Inc. v. Donovan, 673 F.2d 61 (2nd Cir.
1982); and Wheeler v. Caterpillar Tractor
Co., (Ill. Sup. Ct. No. 60181, 54 USLW
2237-38, Nov. 5, 1985).
Poth the instant action and
Mackowiak are examples of very reasoned
and persuasive authorities consistent
with the interpretation of the act by the
Secretary of Labor and the NRC, while
Prown & Root is a narrow and strained
interpretation of the act that should not
be extended to this case.
The statute at issue herein, 42
U.S.C. Sec. 5851, is part of the Fneray
Reorganization Act (ERA). The act deals
with functions of the NRC and bestows
jurisdiction in employment discrimination
6
matters on the Secretary of Labor. In
construing the statutory language, the
Court focused on both che legislative
history and the broad remedial purpose of
the act. The Court noted that Sec. 5851
was patterned after similar employee pro-
tection provisions in other acts includ-
ing the National Labor Management Act and
the Federal Mining Safety Act. The Court
stated in this regard:
"The Senate report on the ERA
amendment comments that, ‘[t]his
amendment is substantially identical
to provisions in the Clean Air Act
and the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act. The legislative
history of those acts indicated that
such provisions were patterned after
the National Labor Management Act
and similar provisions in public law
91-173 (FMSA) relating to the health
and safety of the nations coal min-
ers.' S. Rep. No. 848, 95th Cong.,
2nd Sess. at 29, 1978 U.S.C. Cong. &
Ad News a* 7303,"
The Court noted that the cases construing
these employee protection provisions
stand for the general proposition that
internal actions do come within the
purview of employee protection as guaran-
teed by the respective acts. NLRB v,
Schrivner, 405 U.S. 117 (1972); NLRB v,
F.2d 772, 779 (C.A.D.C. 1974
denied, 420 U.S. 938 (1975). In constru-
ing the ERA, the Court further found a
broad remedial purpose for protecting
» cert.
workers throughout the act and found
support for this in the legislative
history. The Court noted that a narrow,
hyper-technical reading of 5851 would do
little to effect the statute's aim of
protection. In drafting their opinion,
the Court did note that the Secretary's
interpretation, as well as the rules and
regulations of the MRC, were entitled to
great weight and deference. Fmery Mining
Corp. v. Secretary of Labor, 744 F.2d
1411, 1415 (10th Cir. 1984); Donovan v,
Hahner, Foreman, & Harness, Inc,, 736
F.2d 1421 (10th Cir. 1984),
Brown & Root on the other hand was a
narrow, hyper-technical reading of Sec.
5851 based predominately on the facts of
that case which were substantially
different from the instant action. The
Root rejected any argu-
Court in Brown
ment to give a broad remedial reading to
Sec. 5851. On the other hand, Chief
Judge Morton in DeFord v. Secretary of
Labor, 700 F.2d 281 (6th Cir. 1983)
pointed out that the ERA antidiscrimina-
tory provisions must be construed so as
to prevent channels of NRC information
from being dried up by employer intimida-
tion. The Court in Brown & Root mistak-
enly rejects this argument on the grounds
that the NRC benefits only indirectly by
internal reports. However, there is a
very close relationship between the
filing of internal reports and particu-
larly the job of a quality assurance
inspector and the NRC. Administrative
Law Judge Warshaw noted:
"The authorship of a report concern-
ing unsafe conditions may therefore
be deemed as the first step in com-
mencing or causing to be commenced a
proceeding under Sec. 5851."
He further noted that reaqulations at 10
CFR Part 50, App. PB require quality
assurance criteria be set up for all
nuclear plants and that stringent quide-
lines be established to adequately
9
protect against the potential dangers of
nuclear radiation, and that, in fact,
Wells’ walkdown group was formed because
of a NRC audit of KG&E'S quality
assurance practices and the fine assessed
against it for allowing discrepancies to
evist. Judge Warshaw noted the auality
assurance practices of a licensee, such
as KG&E, are subject to regular audit by
the NRC and the safety and discrepancy
reports filed by Wells in this case may
constitute the basis for a NRC compliance
proceedina. The Tenth Circuit noted the
same interplay between quality assurance
personnel such as Wells and the NRC. The
Court stated:
"A properly functioning licensee
quality assurance program is an
integral part of the NRC's regula-
tory program, ‘Ouality euntrol
inspectors play a crucial role in
the NRC's regulatory scheme. The
NRC regulations require licensees
and their contractors and subcon-
tractors to give inspectors the
authority and organizational freedoin
required to fulfill their role of
independent observers of the con-
Struction process.' Mackowiak vs.
University Nuc. systems, 2
effect, such a program serves as the
eyes and ears of the NRC because the
10
inspectors are always on site and
take over much of the inspection
burden from federal personnel, In
. The observations
and judgments of quality assurance
personnel on potential construction
deficiencies are documented and that
documentation is preserved and
facilitates NRC audits. The inspec-
tion team of which Wells was a part
was established to comply with these
regulations. The team was also
established in response to a prev-
ious NRC investigation in which KG&F
was cited for a violation and fined.
(Tr. 366, 572-73.)"
The Court in Brown ot refused to
B&R
ie)
consider this interrelationship.
Finally, it should further be
asserted that the narrow holding of Brown
& Root it is not necessarily inconsistent
with the decisions in the instant case,
The Court in Prown & Root remanded the
case for further consideration based upon
its decision that purely routine internal
OC reports were not protected, In this
regard, the Court held that the term “any
action" under the statute required some
formality but it refused to rule on what
degree of formality was required, In
that case the Administrative Law Judge
—
11
had found that the complainant had lied
on his application, falsified documents,
and was a totally unreliable witness; yet
found a violation for the good faith
filing of reports. Due to the falsifica-
tion of records, the Secretary refused to
order reinstatement. In the instant
Situation, we have a case where the
reports filed by wells were far from
routine, but rather focused to a large
extent on a situation which was the sub-
ject of a previous NRC investigation and
fine and which still had not been
resolved. Furthermore, Wells' ‘position
was created as a direct result of a NRC
proceeding. The Administrative Law
Judge, as well as the Secretary, found
Vells credible, and conversely found that
the witnesses of KC&F were not credible
but were shifting and unreliable in their
testimony. Wells had, in fact, contacted
the NRC and had made reasonably clear to
his supervisors that he intended to see
that his conce:ins were investigated.
Conseqently, the facts of the instant
case and those of Brown & Root are
clearly distinguishable. There is
12
present in the instant case that degree
of formality that the Court in Prow
Root felt was lacking. As a consequence,
a finding that Wells had engaged in
protected activity is not inconsistent
with the narrow holding of B
Brown & Poot was a narrow aberration
based upon a particular factual situa-
tion. The qreat weight of authority
including decisions in the Ninth, Second,
and now the Tenth Circuits when fully
considering the matter have found that
internal filings are protected by the
statute. In any event, however, in the
instant action Wells was engaged in a
proceeding within the meaning of the act,
thus his activity would in all likelihood
have been protected even by the Fifth
Circuit. Based on the instant action,
any conflicts which may exist are not
substantial enough to justify the grant-
ing of the writ in the instant action,
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated, the Petition
for a Writ of Certiorari should be
denied.
13
Respectfully submitted,
MICHAFL C. HELBFRT (Counsel
of Record)
DALF W. RELL
GUY, HELRERT, PELL & SMITH,
Chartered
519 Commercial
P. O. Rox 92)
Fmporia, KS 66801-092]
316-343-6500
Attorneys for Respondent,
James F. Wells, Jr.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.