Respondents Brief — Chemical Manufacturers Ass'n v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1985
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
In Tee
Supreme Court of the United States
Ocroers Team, 198)
Cymecal ManUPACTURERS ASSOCIATION, of af.
Petitioners.
Narusal Resoueces Dere~nse Counce. Inc.
Respondent.
Usrrep Strares Exvimowmewtal Prorectrion AGency
Petitwoner
Narusal Resouces Dere~nse Counce. Ix
Responden!
On Petitions for « Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
RESPONDENT'S BRIEF IN OPPOSITION
TO THE PETITIONS
Peances DUsmOwsaK)
Artorecy for Respondent
1725 | Sereet,. N.W.. Suite GOO
Washington, OC 200
(202) 223-4210
~~
April 2. 1984 ~ + fF
BEST AVAILABLE COPY
QUESTION PRESENTED
30K) of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 11).
protututs EPA from granting vanances from national pretreat.
ment standards for toxrx pollutants
STATUTE AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED.....
STATEMENT OF THE CASE ....................
REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITIONS .....
|. THE THIRD CIRCUIT'S DECISION DOES
NOT CONFLICT WITH THE DECISION OF
ed ee
NOT CONFLICT WITH ANY DECISION OF
DISCHARGERS IS NOT SUFFICIENTLY
IMPORTANT TO WARRANT THIS COURT'S
(EET Wonbbecdebisccsedecsbbabecsecces.
4. THE COURT OF APPEALS CORRECTLY
DECIDED THAT THE CLEAN WATER ACT
PROHIBITS FDF VARIANCES FROM
PRETREATMENT STANDARDS FOR TOXIC
TED tacesdhbbenscctendecccddéccce
ptticat@et
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
CASES:
American Iron and Steel Institute vy. EPA, 526 F.2d
1027 (3d Cir. 1975), modified, 569 F.2d 589 (3d Cir.
1977), cert. denied, 435 U.S. 914 (1978) ........... 9,10
Appalachian Power Co. v. Train, 620 F.2d 1040 (4th
Cae, Beidah ds ncesecucéesicabehaebl - thddedss « 45
Association of Pacific Fisheries v. EPA, 615 F.2d 74
CD Gs HN he dcbtin déé 6ecncdeddbedethotsades .
EJ. duPont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, 430 U.S. 112
eendsndéedundnsnded ébee bdaesebcicabdensehee
EPA v. National Crushed Stone Assn., 449 U.S. 64
Se o.cuis ch dG 640eds 6660 ee di semstaeiaabas 7,12
Kennecott Copper Corp. v. EPA, 612 F.2d 1232 (10th
SO ere eee ee 8,9,10
NRDC vy. Train, 8 Env't Rep. Cas. (BNA) 2120 (D D.C.
1976), modified sub nam. NRDC v. Costie, |\2 Env't
Rep. Cas. (BNA) 1833 (D.D.C. 1979), modified sub
nom. NRDC v. Gorsuch, Nos. 2153-73, et al. (D.D.C.
Oct. 26, 1982), modified sub nom. NRDC v. Ruck-
elshaus, Nos. 2153-73, et al. (D.D.C. Aug. 2, 1983,
SE A, Ge, Ee dak ob 6604.5 Gab db ciidnn cnn cd cones 9
SEC v. Chenery Corp., 332 U.S. 194 (1947) ......... 10
SEC v. Sloan, 436 U.S. 103 (1978) ......... 6.00.45. 11
TVA v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153 (1978) ..... 2... 6 6 cece eee 11
U.S. v. Cartwright, 411 U.S. 546 (1973)............. il
Volkswagenwerk v. FMC, 390 U.S. 261 (1968) ....... il
Weyerhauser Co. v. Costle, 590 F.2d 1011 (D.C. Cir.
Dl idndencecettetensieveeetetebedbebudocieses 9
Vv
Page
STATUTE:
Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. (& Supp. V) 1251 et seg. 1,2
§ 301(b) 1A), 33 U.S.C. 13110 IMA).... 6.6... 2
§ 301(>)2M(A), 33 U.S.C. (& Supp. V) 1311(b)(2(A) 2
§ 301(>K2KC), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 1311(b)QKC) .. 2
© ES BP ie CEP ccocccccccccccccces 1,3,11,12
§ 301(g), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 131g) ......... 1,3,11,12
§ 301(), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 1311) ...... sees passim
, Ce necscanaccconccesete 1,6
§ 307(b), 33 U.S.C. (& Supp. V) 1317(b)........ passim
Ds SE nc ccccoucestsccccecses 1,7
§ SOMb\M1), 33 U.S.C. 1369(DMT) ... 6 6. 1,13
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS:
39 Fed. Reg. 24114-24115 (1974)... ... 2.6... ccc an 10
43 Fed. Reg. 27736-27773 (1978)... ... 6.6... 6.5005 4
a 10
46 Fed. Reg. 9404-9460 (1981)... . 6. ccc cue 4
49 Fed. Reg. 5131-5132 (February 10, 1984) ....... 6
REGULATION:
a a so i 3,11,13
LEGISLATIVE MATERIALS:
A Legislative History of the Water Pollution Control
Act Amendments of 1972, Cong. Research Service,
Comm. Print No. 1, 93d Cong., Ist Sess. (1973).... 10
Implementation of the Federal Water Pollution Control
Act, Hearings Before the Subcomm. on Investigations
and Review of the House Comm. on Public Works
and Transportation, 94th Cong., 2d Sess. (1976) ... 9
A Legislative History of the Clean Water Act of 1977,
Cong. Research Service, Comm. Print No. 14, 95th
SE Ge cvicccoececocceceeceoecs passim
In THE
Supreme Court of the Hnited States
OcToBer Term, 1983
Nos. 83-1013, 83-1373
CHEMICAL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION, ef a/.,
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
Petitioners,
v.
NATURAL Resources Derense CouNciL, INC.,
Respondent.
The opinion of the court of appeals (CMA Pet. App. Al-
A9%6)' is reported at 719 F.2d 624.
STATUTE AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED
Pertinent provisions of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C.
(& Supp. V) 1251 ef seq., are reproduced at CMA Pet. App.
A116-A121 except for Sections 301(c) and (g), 306(b), 307(d),
and S0%b\(1), 33 U.S.C. (& ee Vv) 1311(c) and (g), 1316(b),
1317(d), and 1369%(b)(1), which are set forth in the Appendix
at Al—A4. The ‘‘fundamentally different factors’’ (FDF) var-
iance provision, 40 C.F.R. 403.13, is reproduced at CMA Pet.
App. Al22-A127.
z
;
;
j
ze
e
3
+
j
1
FS
2
The Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. (& Supp. V) 1251 et.
seq., directs EPA to control two types of industrial polluters:
(1) “direct’’ dischargers, which dump their waste water
directly into navigable waters, and (2) ‘‘indirect’’ dischargers,
plants which, in turn, discharge to navigable waters.
When the law was first enacted, Congress required direct
dischargers to meet two progressively more stringent tech-
nology-based requirements: ‘best practicable control tech-
nology currently available’ (BPT) by July 1, 1977, and ““best
available technology economically achievable’ (BAT) by July
1, 1983 (ater amended to July 1, 1984). 33 U.S.C. (& Supp.
V) 1311(0IMA) and (62M A) and (C). Indirect dischargers
U.S.C. 1311(61)(A) and (2A) and 1317(b). The pretreatment
standards were especially important because municipal sew-
age plants are often not designed to treat industrial waste
water Without pretreatment, toxic industrial chemicals can
pass through the sewers into rivers and drinking water sup-
plies, contaminate large volumes of sludge, or impcir the
effectiveness of the sewage treatment plant, negating the
henefits of a multi-billion dollar investment in pollution con-
trol. A Legislative History of the Clean Water Act of 1977,
23
Fi
3
Congress therefore ordered a “‘major redirection and
refinement"’ of EPA's regulatory program to strengthen con-
trol of toxics. /d. at 326. First, it elevated the importance of
pretreatment and BAT requirements. It directed EPA to use
these requirements to control toxics and, in the case of
pretreatment standards, enacted several strengthening amend-
ments. /d. at 689-693. Second, it considered when, and under
what conditions, sources should be able to obtain variances
from BAT and pretreatment requirements. It created a new
“safety valve’’ to give flexibility to BAT limitations,’ and
ameaded a BAT variance provision that had been in the 1972
law,’ specifying in each case that these modifications would
not be available for toxic pollutants. It did not create any
variances from the pollution control requirements of pretreat-
ment standards, but it did allow indirect dischargers to get a
treatment plant, in effect splitting the pollution control be-
tween the indirect discharger and the sewage treatment plant.‘
Sirnultaneously, it enacted Section 301(), 33 U.S.C (Supp.
V) 1311@, which said: ““The Administrator may not modify
any requirement of this section as it applies to any [toxic]
pollutant +." It stressed that EPA could only modify
requirements for non-toxic , conventional pollutants, and urg-d
EPA to err on the side of caution in applying this mandate.°
Despite these directives, EPA subsequently issued reg-
ulations which allowed industries to obtain variances from
pretreatment standards for toxic pollutants. 40 C.F.R. 403.13
* Section 3li(g), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 131 1(g), p. Al, infra; 1977 Legis.
Hist., supra, at 674-675.
* Section Wiic), 33 U.S.C. 131 Nc), p. Ai, infra; 1977 Legis. Hist.,
supra, at 328-329.
* Section 307(b), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 1317(b); 1977 Legis. Hist.. supra,
at 461-462.
* E.g., “In order to reemphasize that modifications to BAT are intended
{toxic} pollutants***. The committee's intent is to prohibit both those
pollutants known to be tox or hazardous and those suspected of being
toxic or hazardous.”’ 1977 Legis. Hist.. supra, at 677.
4
(CMA Pet. App. Al22-A127).* The Third Circuit held that
variances violated Section WI1(/).
REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITIONS
The Third Circuit's decision does not conflict with the
decision of any other Circuit, is eatirely consistent with this
Court's prior interpretation of the Clean Water Act, does not
present issues sufficiently important to warrant this Court's
attention, and is required by the express language of the
Statute and the legislative history. Review by this Court is
not warranted.
1. The Third Circuit’) decision does not conflict with the
decision of any other Circuit.
a. The Third Circuit held that Section 301(/) prohibits
variances from pretreatment standards for toxic pollutants.
No other court of appeals has addressed the applicability of
Section 301(/) to pretreatment standards, since all challenges
to the vanance provision for the pretreatment program were
consolidated in the Third Circuit. There is no conflict among
the Circuits on this question; hence EPA's fear of “substantial
uncertainty and confusion™’ (EPA Pet. 8) is a non sequitur.
b. Lacking any conflict between the holdings of the
Circuits, petitioners complain that the Third Circuit's reason-
ing is inconsistent with that used by the Fourth Circuit to
validate variances from BPT limits for toxic pollutants. See
Appalachian Power Co. v. Train, 620 F.2d 1040, 1047-1048
(1980).’ Even if a difference in reasoning between the Circuiis
were sufficient to warrant this Court's review, no purpose
would be served by reviewing the reasoning of either Circuit.
The Fourth Circuit wrestled with an issue which will not
recur: whether Congyess, focused on the future direction of
the poliution control program, intended Section 301(/) to apply
* The regulations were issued on June 26, 1978, 43 Fed. Reg. 277%
27773, and amended on January 28, 1981, 46 Fed. Reg. 9404-9460.
’ Petitoners did not even cite Appalachian Power's discussion of
§ 31) to the Third Circun. thus belitthng its umportance to this case.
$
retroactively to BPT limits issued before the 1977 amend-
ments. It concluded that Congress did not, relying heavily on
the maxim that retroactive application of a statute is not
favored. Jd. at 1047.
That anomaly is not present here, where the pretreatment
standards were developed well after the 1977 amendments,
nor will it recur in the programs for either direct or indirect
dischargers. The focus of the national clean water program
shifted in 1977 from development of BPT limits to BAT and
pretreatment. The Third Circuit gave EPA a clear directive
on how to proceed with the post-1977 standards; there is no
contrary directive from any other court.*
2. The Third Circuit's decision does not conflict with any
decision of this Court.
a. This case has nothing to do with this Court's decision
in EJ. duPont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, 430 U.S. 112
(1977). DuPont addressed (wo questions: whether EPA had
authority to issue industry-wide regulations for existing plants
under the Clean Water Act—it held that EPA had; and whether
nonstatutory variances were available for ir¢stry-wide stand-
ards for new sources under the same Ac ~ «t held that they
were not.
NRDC., et al. v. EPA, Nos. 80-1607, er al.
vailability of the variance to pretreatment standards for
. Reg. 5131-5132 (February 10,
1984). There has been no judicial review of this rule; hence,
|
|
classes"’ of sources. The Court concluded that BPT, like
BAT, can be set by industry-wide regulations “‘so long as
some allowance is made for variations in individual plants, as
EPA has done by including a variance clause in its [BPT)
limitations.’’ 430 U.S. at 128. DuPont did not, as EPA claims,
hold that nonstatutory variances are appropriate for BAT
requirements. To the contrary, the Court upheld EPA's BAT
limits even though they did not contain an FDF variance
clause.’
Dupont did, however, strike down nonstatutory variances
for new source standards for reasons equally applicable to
standards are set for categories of sources, rather than
individual point sources. Cf. § 307(b)(3), 33 U.S.C. 1317(b)3),
with § 306(b), 33 U.S.C. 1316(b), p. A2-A3, infra. The
ards”’ in the Act. /d. Pretreatment, like new source, standards
may require ‘‘no discharge."""® As with new source standards,
* As the Court explained, “The regulations for each subcategory
contain a variance clause, applicable only to the [BPT) limitations.’ 430
U.S. at 122-123 (emphasis added).
® Section 307(b\ 1), 33 U.S.C. 1317(bM 1), specifies that a pretreatment
standard must “prevent the discharge of any pollutant *** which ***
interferes with, passes through, or otherwise is incompatible with [the
publicly owned treatment works]. (emphasis added).
7
it is “unlawful for any owner or operator of any source to
operate any source in violation of’ a pretreatment standard.
Section 307(d), 33 U.S.C. 1317(d), p. A4, infra (emphasis
added). Finally, there is no statutory provision for variances, ''
and a variance provision would be inappropriate because
pretreatment, like new source, standards were intended to
ensure national uniformity and maximum feasible control. '’
See generally 430 U.S. at 138.
c. This Court has twice spoken on the subject of variances
under the Clean Water Act. DuPont, supra, and EPA v.
National Crushed Stone Assn., 449 U.S. 64 (1980)." Its
decisions are clear and do not conflict with the Third Circuit's
decision. There is no need once again to address variances
under this Act.
3. The FDF variance for indirect dischargers is not sufficiently
important to warrant this Court's attention.
a. Few companies are interested in the FDF variance.
Approximately 11,316 indirect dischargers (83% of the total)'*
were covered by categorical pretreatment standards when the
" Sources may be able to get a ‘credit’ for pollutant removal
court of appeals rendered its decision.'’ Only 12 companies
had applied for an FDF variance."
b. The decision below will have no adverse impact on
the administration of the Clean Water Act. It will not, as
vulnerable to challenge by plants affected by fundamentally
different factors."’ (EPA Pet. 11). Deadlines for filing FDF
variance applications had expired for over 80% of the sources
in the program when the court of appeals rendered its decision.
Since only a handful of companies applied, few are situated
to challenge the regulations because of alleged differences
with other plants in the same industrial category. No useful
purpose would be served—indeed, it would delay enforcement
of this program—to allow these plants to raise excuses for
noncompliance for the first time “ow that EPA's rules are
pretreatment
Agency's “‘stringent deadlines.” (EPA Pet. 11) In the first
An additional 329 indirect dischargers are covered by standards
issued since the court of appeals decision, although no additional variance
have been filed. (pp. AS—A7, infra). dud
* P. A7, infra. One company filed variance applications for two plants.
another, for 24 .
Soe vp Association of Pacific Fisheries v. EPA, 615 F.2d 794, 908
n.10 (9th Cir. 1980) (subcategories divided for analytical purposes into
subdivisions of one, two, or three plants); Kennecott Copper Corp. v. EPA,
612 F.2d 1232, 1246 (10th Cir. 1979) (subcategorization of two mills was
(footnote continues)
Finally , the courts below have repeatedly extended EPA's
d. The cases petitioners cite do not help their cause.
They are either irrelevant"’ or suggest that EPA does not need
an PDF variance for the reasons claimed (i.¢., for subcate-
, the creation of that subcategory during the rule-
making had EPA been aware of and taken those factors into
Institute v. EPA, 526 F.2d 1027, 1050-
F.2d 589 (3d Cir. 1977), cert. denied,
it
Standa:ds and Water Quality Information Advisory Committee.
reprinted in Implementation of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act.
" EPA's deadlines are embodied in a consent decree entered into with
NRDC and approved by the district court in 1976. NRDC v. Train, 8 Env't
Rep. Cas. (BNA) 2120 (D.D.C. 1976), modified sub nom. NRDC v. Costle,
12 Env't Rep. Cas. (BNA) 1833 (D.D.C. 1979), modified sub nom. NRDC
v. Gorsuch, Nos. 2153-73, et al. (D.D.C. Oct. 26, 1982), modified sub nom.
NRDC v. Ruckelshaus, Nos. 2153-73, et al. (D.D.C. Aug. 2, 1983 and Jan.
* None of the cases petitioners cite address Section 301(/). Moreover.
American Iron and Steel Institute, 0.17 supra, predated enactment of
Section 31(/); Weyerhauser Co. v. Costle, 990 ¥ 2d 1011 (D.C. Cir. 1978)
account’). (EPA Pet. 15) (emphasis added).” Instead, EPA
used the FDF variance as a fig leaf for embarrassingly
discordant facts already in the record.”’ This bureaucratic
concern, rather than any “issue of fundamental importance
to the administration of the Clean Water Act," propels EPA's
petition.”
4. The court of appeals correctly decided that the Clean Water
Act prohibits FDF variances from pretreatment standards
for toxic pollutants.
Petitioners argue that the court below erred by not
accepting EPA's construction of Section 301(/) of the Clean
Water Act. An agency's interpretation of a statute is not,
however, entitled to deference where, as here, it contradicts
® Both Kennecott and AiS/ placed the burden of marshalling information
squarely on industry's shoulders. When EPA encountered factors of which
it had not been aware (¢.g.. ferrocyanide formation, 612 F.2d at 1245; water
scarcity, 526 F.2d at 1050; and engineering factors, 526 F 2d at 1049), the
courts found fatal fault with industry's failure to produce adequate infor-
mation dunng the rulemaking
* E.g., im Kennecott, EPA fell back on the PDF variance when
confronted with countervailing factors which it had been ‘fully aware of
to EPA during the rulemaking. 39 Fed. Reg. 24114, 24115 (1974).
@ CMA also cites SEC v. Chenery, 332 U.S. 194 (1947), arguing that
EPA should have discretion to choose whether to regulate atypical plants
through general rules or individual. ad hoc decision-making. Chenery.
however. is urelevant because here Congress made the for EPA.
Congress told EPA to issue standards which prevent harmful pollutants
from entenng municipal sewage treatment plants. and to “designate the
category or categories to which sucn standard shall apply.” Section
30713), 33 U.S.C. 1317K3). In fact, Congress expressly said that the
No. 1, 93d Cong., Ist Sess. 800 (1973).
a. Section 301() of the Clean Water Act is clear: it
provides that EPA “may not modify any requirement of
[Section 301) as it applies to’ a toxic pollutant. Pretreatment
of Section 301. EPA's
FDF variance would nonetheless have allowed EPA ‘‘on a
ing them less stringent for some plants.” Relying on both the
common usage of the language and the legislative histor . the
court of appeals correctly ruled that these changes ‘‘modify”
pretreatment standards so as to fall within the prohibition of
Section 301(). (CMA Pet. App. A40-A43).
b. EPA's construction of the statute, by companson, ts
“nonstatutory™ exceptions are not available. TVA v. Hill,
437 U.S. 153, 188 (1978). In addition, it makes Section 301(/)
largely redundant — at least insofar as it apphes to Section
lig). which by its terms cannot be applied to toxics.
” SEC v. Sloan, 456 U.S. 103, 117-119 (1978).
* US. v. Carteright, 411 U.S. 546, SS? (1979).
* Volkswagenwert v. FMC, 390 U.S. 261, 272-275 (1968) (rqjected
narrow reading of statutory provision because it did not square with (he
structure of the statute)
* Section Wiic), 33 U.S.C. 131 Nc), p. Al, aye, allows BAT standards
to be modified @ they surpass the ecomoma capability of the drscharger
Section lig), 33 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 131 N@). p. Al-A2, aye, allows similar
modificanons to BAT standards where water quality warrants
floor debate,” but this, says EPA, does not suggest that the
whole of Congress thought the terms were akin. The speaker
was, however, Senator Muskie, Chairman of the Subcom-
mittee on Environmental Pollution and principal author of the
1977 amendments on toxics. His words, entitled to consid-
erable weight on their own, are buttressed here by EPA's
in its Senate testimony.” and the equation of the two terms
by both the Senate Committee” and this Court."
Last, EPA asserts its “most telling’ point: Congress did
nat eutticinn either Ge “wall blished”” se of
FDF variances from BPT requirements, or this Court's duPont
decision when it enacted Section 301(/). EPA's practice was.
however, hardly “well-established.” Less than 50 of 4,000
reviewed in duPont contained no FDF variance clause (even
though the BPT limits did). 430 U.S. at 122-123.
controls. 1977 Legis. Hist., supra, at 459. Since most sources
had complied, /d. at 641, and the pollution contro: results had
been greater than anticipated, /d. at 330-331, Congress had
no need to examine carefully EPA‘’s handling of individual
dischargers.
* .977 Legis. Hist.. supra, at 461.
» Id at 1102. EPA called the statutory lic) modification , -ovision
a “variance.”
© fd. at 676-677. The Committee called the statutory $01(g) modification
provision a “variance.”
” In Netional Crushed Stone Assn. supra, this Court referred to the
statutory lic) modification provision as a vanance.
13
Moreover, BPT (and the early BAT limits) focused primarily
on conventional pollutants, not toxics. /d. at 335, 1101. Both
Congress's and EPA's attention in 1977 shifted sharply toward
control of toxic pollutants and the BAT and pretreatment
requirements designed to control them. /d. at 1135-1136. Since
Congress considered, and curtailed, the circumstances under
which these requirements could be modified, it does not make
sense to assume that Congress, without mention, would have
simultaneously authorized EPA to gran! nonstatutory vari-
ances for toxic pollutants.
c. Lacking a compelling legal argument, EPA turns to
policy, alleging that an FDF variance functions differently
from a modification. Put simply, this argument supposes that
an PDF variance is not a “variance” at all, but rather a part
of the standard-setting process in which EPA recognizes pnor
errors. The Clean Water Act, however, contains statutory
mechanisms for correcting EPA 's rulemaking errors. The Act
requires EPA to revise its rules following the same stream-
lined, informal rulemaking procedures used to set pretreatment
standards in the first place.”
Congress's solution to the problem of rulemaking error
is both more direct and more uniform than the vanance route
EPA created. The FDF variance procedure entails review by
four separate tiers of government, an informal public comment
period, a hearing, and coordination between EPA's rulemaking
experts and diffuse state and regional office personnel."’ Not
surprisingly, the process has been extraordinarily slow of
resolution.
© Section 307(bx2), 33 U.S.C. 1317N2), directs EPA to revise
pretreatmer standards “from tume to ume, as contro! technology. proc-
esses. operating methods, or other alternatives change. following the same
procedures used to set pretrea:.aent standards in the first place In addition.
section SOWbK 1), 33 U.S.C. L36RDK1), p. A4, infra, gives aggrieved sources
9 days to ask a court to remand EPA's rules uniess the challenge 1s based
on information arsing after 90 days.
” An apphcation is reviewed by the state. the EPA Enforce ent
Devisson Director, the EPA Regional Administrator. and the FPA Admin-
istrator. 40 C.F.R. 403.13. (CMA Pet. App. Al22).
1s
would give a handful of companies an unfair competitive
advantage over the more than |! 1,000 sources now embarking
on a pollution control program. The Third Circuit correctly
The petition for a writ of certivrari should be denied.
rejected it.
14
applied for an
are still
date to
are
pollution
industnes
4d bat
uli
ile
Inc.
April 2, 1984
il
Hi in
lt,
Hi
yea th
11 Ni;
it
: 4 ine:
Le al
i i th
Hl Wut
neil
os i303) 3
anand
F.
batt
ilsil;
47834:
ell
al
A-l
CLEAN WATER ACT PROVISIONS
1. Section Wiic) of the Clean Water Act, as amended, 33
U.S.C. 131 Mc):
(c) The Administrator may modify the requirements of
subsection (b\(2)(A) of this section with respect to any point
source for which a permit application is filed after July !,
1977, upon a showing by the owner or operator of such point
source satisfactory to the Administrator that such modified
requirements (1) will represent the maximum use of technology
within the economic capability of the owner or operator, and
(2) will result in reasonable further progress toward the
elimination of the discharge of p~' ants.
2. Section 301(g) of the Clean Water Act, as amended, 33
U.S.C. (Supp. V) 1311(g):
(gX1) The Administrator, with the concurrence of the
State, shall modify the requirements of subsection (b)(2)(A)
of this section with respect to the discharge of any pollutant
(other than pollutants identified pursuant to section 304(a)(4)
of this Act, toxic pollutants subject to section 307(a) of this
Act, and the thermal component of discharges) from any point
source upon a showing by the owner or operator of such
point source satisfactory tc the Administrator that—
(A) Such modified requirements will result at a
minimum in compliance with the requirements of sub-
section (b) 1A) or (C) of this section, whichever is
applicable;
(B) such modified requirements will not result in any
additional requirements on any other point or nonpoint
source; and
(C) such modification will not interfere with the
attainment or maintenance of that water quality which
shall assure protection of public water supplies, and the
protection and propagation of a balanced population of
ities, in and on the water and such modification will not
result in the discharge of pollutants in quantities which
A-2
may reasonably be anticipated to pose an unacceptable
isk to human health or the environment because of
bioaccumulation, persistency in the environment, acute
toxicity, chronic toxicity (including carcinogenicity, mu-
tagenicity or teratogenicity), or synergistic propensities.
(2) If en owner or operator of a point source applies for
a modification under this subsection with respect to the
discharge of any pollutant, such owner or operator shall be
eligible to apply for modification under subsection (c) of this
section with respect to such pollutant only during the same
time-period as he is eligible to apply for a modification under
this subsection.
3. Section 306(b) of the Clean Water Act, as amended, 33
U.S.C. 1316(b):
(b\ 1A) The Administrator shall, within ninety days after
the date of enactmeni of this title publish (and from time to
time thereafter shall revise) a list of categories of sources,
year, after a category of sources is included in a list under
subparagraph (A) of this paragraph, the Administrator shall
|
|
F
2
|
eS eT Or Catt
uous).
(3) The provisions of this section shall apply to any new
source owned or operated by the United States.
A-4
4. Section 307(d) of the Clean Water Act, as amended, 33
U.S.C. 1317id):
(d) After the effective date of any effluent standard or
prohibition or pretreatment standard promulgated under this
section, it shall be unlawful for any owner or operator of any
source to operate any source in violation of any such effluent
standard or prohibition or pretreatment standard.
5. Section 50%b)(1) of the Clean Water Act, as amended, 33
U.S.C. 1369%(b\(1):
(bX 1) Review of the Administrator's ac:ion (A) in pro-
mulgating any standard of performance under section 306, (B)
in making any determination pursuant to section 306(b\1 KC),
(C) in promulgating any effluent standard, prohibition, or
pretreatment standard under section 307, (D) in making any
determination as to a State permit program submitted under
section 402(b), (E) in approving or promulgating any effluent
limitation or other limitation under section 301, 302, or 306,
and (F) in issuing or denying any permit under section 402,
may be had by any interested person in the Circuit Court of
‘.ppeals of the United States for the Federal judicial district
in which such person resides or transacts such business upon
application by such person. Any such application shall be
made within ninety days from the date of such determination,
approval, promulgation, issuance or denial, or after such date
only if such application is based solely on grounds which
arose after such ninetieth day.
oe 2 ee ee
Ku) KKK
A+
(Thurteen categoncal pretreatment standards, affecting |! 316 sources.
were final in September 1983 when the Third Circuit rendered its
tecision.}
A-?
March 22, 1984
Jim Gallup
National Pretreatment Coordinator
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Waterside Mall, West Tower
401 M Street SW
Washington, DC 20460
Dear Jim:
| am writing in response to your request that we
provide you with the results of our Freedou.: of Information
Act requests to EPA's Regional Pretreatment Coordinators.
On February 23, 1984, we requested the Regional
Pretreatment Coordinators to provide us with the follc wing:
“The identity of any indirect dischargers in your
Region (or in delegated state programs in your Region) who
have sought an FDF variance from a categorical
pretreatment standard.”
The responses we received were prepared between
February 29 and March 10, 1984. They indicate that a total
of 12 companies applied for a variance. Most companies
filed for a single plant, although one company filed for two
of its plants, and another for 24 plants. In addition, another
company filed, and then withdrew, an application.
Attached are copies of the responses from each Region
so that you can see which companies are involved.
Sincerely ,
Frances Lubrowski
Senior Attorney
ce: Bill Corcoran
Phil Cummings
John Doyle
Bob Hurley
Ron Outen
Chariene Sturbitts
As
>
©
[Letter dated February 17, 1984 from Steadman M. Overman,
Director, EPA's Office of Legislative Analysis, to Honorable
Arian Stangeland, House of Representatives, enclosing EPA's
responses to the questions submitted by Rep. Stangeland to
Administrator William D. Ruckelshaus following the latter's
testimony before the House Subcommittee on Water Re-
sources. }
Question: *** To what extent has the Agency, in the course
& Grease, Total Iron,
Total Suspended Solids, Oil
Total Copper
Total Suspended Solids, Oil
& Grease, Total Iron,
Total Copper
Total Suspended Solids
Total Suspended Solids
(40 CFR & 423.32(b)6)
(1974)}-Boiler Blowdown
(40 CFR & 423.32(b)6)
(1974)}-Boiler Blowdown
Gravel Subcategory of
Mineral Mining and
Processing
Phosphate Subcategory of Total Phosphorus Fluoride,
Fertilizer Manufacturing
Approval Point Source Category Pollutants
7/10/78 Construction Sand and
Southern California Edison 2/22/77 Steam Electric Generating
Huntington Beach
Generating Station
San Onofre Nuclear
Generating Station
Birdsall Sand and Gravel,
Oral, South Dakota
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.