Supplemental Appendix — Faust v. South Carolina State Highway Department

Supreme Court brief1984

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

FILED

€ IN THE MAR12 1984

¢ SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1983 ALEXANDER \& STEVAS.

CLERK

Alean Hester Faust, Administratrix of

the Estate of Charles Lonnie Faust,

Deceased; Tommy Bennett and Curtis

Muldrow, Petitioners,

V-.

South Carolina State Hi,hway Department,

and the United States of America,

Respondents.

_ ON WRI? OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNI’ED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR WRI OF CERTIORARI

APPENDIX E

‘ bD. A. Brockinton, Jr.

Brockinton, Brockinton and Smith

2 Prioleau Street

P. O. Box 663

Charleston, S.C. 29402

(803) 722-8845

Douglas L. Hinds Reginald C Brown, Jr.

Hal M. Strange J. Anderson Berly, III

Hinds, Cowan and William P. Hatfield

Strange (Attorney of Record)

304 Front Street Hyman, Morgan, Brown,

P. O. Drawer 459 29440 Jeffords, Rushton &

Geor,etown,S.C. 29440 Hatfield

(803) 527-2441 P. O. Box 1770

Florence, S.C. 29503

(803) 662-6321

Attorneys for Petitioners

March 9_, 1984

UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION

AMENDMENT XI

RESTRICTION OF JUDICIAL POWER

The judicial power of the United

States shall not be construed to extend to

any suit in law or equity, commenced or

prosecuted against one of the United States

by citizens of another state, or by

citizens or subjects of any foreign state.

§57-15-140. South Carolina Code of Laws

(1976)

§57-15-140. Department shall operate ferry

across intracoastal waterway.

The State Highway Department shall

take over, maintain and operate the ferry

across the intracoastal waterway which

traverses State Highway No. 716 which

extends from a point on U.S. Highway No. l,

south of Georgetown, in a southeasterly

direction, to Winyah Bay, such ferry and

its approaches to form a part of State

Highway No. 716 in Georgetown County. The

provisions of Article 13 of Chapter 5 of

this Title shall not apply to the

operation, repair or maintenance of any

such ferry.

Contributions from private citizens or

public or private agencies may be made with

respect to defraying the operational or

maintenance expenses of such ferry;

provided, however, that any such

contribution shall in no wise render

— <

legally liable or responsible any of the

contributors.

Act No. 29 of the Acts and Joint Resolu-

tions of the State of South Carolina, 1947,

45 S. at L. 4a, t

No. 29

AN ACT To Authorize and Direct The

South Carolina State Highway Department To

Take Over, Maintain And Operate The Ferry

Across The Intra-Coastal Waterway On Route

No. 716, Which Route Extends From U.S.

Highway No. 17, South of Georgetown, South

Carolina, In A Southeasterly Direction, To

Winyah Bay.

BE IT ENACTED by the General Assembly of

the State of South Carolina: ¥

SECTION 1: Ferry across intra-coastal

waterway which traverses state highway No.

716 part of said highway-maintenance and

operation.-That the South Carolina State

Highway Department is authorized and

directed to take over, maintain and operate

the ferry across the intra-coastal waterway

which traverses State Highway No. 716 which

extends from a point on U.S. Highway No.

17, South of Georgetown, South Carolina, in

- E-4 -

a Southeasterly direction, to Winyah Bay,

the said Ferry and its approaches to form a

part of the said State Highway No. 716 in

said County.

SECTION 2: Repeal.-All Acts or parts of

Acts inconsistent herewith are hereby

repealed.

SECTION 3: Time Effective.-This Act shall

take effect immediately upon its approval

by the Governor.

Approved the 11 day of March, 1947.

Act No. 896 of the Acts and Joint Resolu-

tions of the State of South Carolina, 1934,

38 S. at L. 1539.

No. 896

AN ACT Authorizing the State Highway

Department to Cooperate With Berkeley and

Georgetown Counties in the Establishment

and Operation of a Ferry Across the Santee

River on State Highway No. 511 Between

Andrews and Jamestown and Limiting

Liability on Account of the Operation of

Said Ferry.

SECTION 1: State Highway Department

Cooperate with Berkeley and Georgetown

Counties in Establishing and Operating

Ferry across Santee River.--Be it enacted

by the General Assembly of the State of

South Carolina: The State Highway

Department is hereby authorized to

cooperate with the Counties of Berkeley and

Georgetown in the establishment and

operation of a Ferry, with necessary road

approaches thereto, across the Santee River

_— on

on State Highway No. 511 between Andrews

and Jamestown.

SECTION 2: Liability of Department .--The

State Highway Department is hereby

specifically relieved of any and all

liability on account of personal injury or

death, or property damages, growing out of

the establishment and operation of the

ferry and road approaches thereto referred

to in Section 1. hereof. All statutes or

parts of statutes authorizing suits against

the said Department on account of personal

injury or death, or property damages,

growing out of accidents on State Highways

are hereby specifically limited in their

operation so as not to apply to the said

ferry and road approaches thereto.

SECTION 3. All Acts or parts of Acts

inconsistent with the provisions of this

Act are hereby repealed to the extent of

such inconsistency.

- BeT -

SECTION 4. This Act shall take effect

immediately upon its approval by the 8

Governor.

Approved the 12th day of April, 1934.

33 U.S.C. $1

§1. Regulations by Secretary of the Army |

or navigation of waters generally

It shall be the duty of the

Secretary of the Army to prescribe such

regulations for the use, administration,

and navigation of the navigable waters of

the United States as in his judgment the

public necessity may require for the

protection of life and property, or of

operations of the United States in channel

improvement, covering all matters not

specifically delegated by law to some other

executive department. Such regulations

shall be posted, in conspicuous and

appropriate places, for the information of

the public; and every person and every

corporation which shall violate such

regulations shall be deemed guilty of a

misdemeanor and, on conviction thereof in

any district court of the United States

within whose territorial jurisdiction such

offense may have been committed, shali be

punished by a fine not exceeding $500, or

by imprisonment (in the case of a natural t

person) not exceeding six months, in the

discretion of the court.

Any regulations prescribed by the

Secretary of the Army in pursuance of this

section may be enforced as provided in

section 413 of this title, the provisions

whereof are made applicable to the said

regulations.

33 U.S.C.A. 401

$401. Construction of bridges, causeways,

4

dams or dikes generally; exemptions

It shall not be lawful to construct or

commence the construction of any bridge,

causeway, dam, or dike over or in any port,

roadstead, haven, harbor, canal, navigable

river, or other navigable water of the

United States until the consent of Congress

to the building of such structures shall

have been obtained and until the plans for

(1) the bridge or causeway shall have been

submitted to and approved by the secretary

of Transportation, or (2) the dam or dike

shall have been submitted to and approved

by the Chief of Engineers and Secretary of

the Army. However, such structures may be

built under authority of the legislature of

a State across rivers and other waterways

the navigable portions of which lie wholly

within the limits of a single State,

provided the location and plans thereof

thereof are submitted to and approved by

the Secretary of Transportation or by the t

Chief of Engineers and Secretary of the

Army before construction is commenced.

When plans for any bridge or other

structure have been approved by the

Secretary of Transportation or by the Chief

of Engineers and Secretary of the Army, it

shall not be lawful to deviate from such

plans either before or after completion of

the structure unless modification of said

plans has previously been submitted to and

received the approval of the Secretary of

Transportation or the Chief of Engineers

and the Secretary of the Army. The

approval required by this section of the

location and plans or any modification of

Plans of any bridge or causeway does not

apply to any bridge or causeway over waters

that are not subject to the ebb and flow of

the tide and that are not used and are not

susceptible to use in their natural condi-

tion or by reasonable improvement as a

means to transport interstate or foreign

commerce.

= B-13 -

33 U.S.C. 403

§403. Obstruction of navigable waters s

generally; wharves; piers, etc.;

excavations and filling in

The creation of any obstruction not

affirmatively authorized by Congress, to

the navigable capacity of any of the waters

of the United States is prohibited; and it

shall not be lawful to build or commence

the building of any wharf, pier, dolphin,

boom, weir, breakwater, bulkhead, jetty, or

other structures in any port, roadstead,

haven, harbor, canal, navigable river, or ‘

other water of the United States, outside

established harbor lines, or where no

harbor lines have been established, except

on plans recommended by the Chief of

Engineers and authorized by the Secretary

of the Army; and it shall not be lawful to

excavate or fill, or in any manner to alter

or modify the course, location, condition,

or capacity of, any port, roadstead, haven,

* - E-14 -

: . . r ete. 2 ~ £oy op Me ait le

y ts we eee Oe ee” Oe ST |

4

harbor, canal, lake, harbor of refuges, or

; inclosure within the limits of any

breakwater, or of the channel of any

navigable water of the United States,

unless the work has been recommended by the

Chief of Engineers and authorized by the

Secretary of the Army prior to beginning

the same.

33 U.S.C. 404

$404. Establishment of harbor lines;

conditions to grants for extension

of piers, etc.

Where it is made manifest to the

Secretary of the army that the

establishment of harbor lines is essential

to the preservation and protection of

harbors he may, and is, authorized to cause

such lines to be established, beyond which

no piers, wharves, bulkheads, or other

works shall be extended or deposits made,

except under such regulations as may be

prescribed from time to time by him:

Provided, That whenever the Secretary of

the Army grants to any person or persons

permission to extend piers, wharves,

bulkheads, or other works, or to make

deposits in any tidal harbor or river of

the United States beyond any harbor lines

established under authority of the United

States, he shall cause to be ascertained

the amount of tidewater displaced by any

such structure or by any such deposits, and

he shall, if he deem it necessary, require

the parties to whom the permission is given

to make compensation for such displacement

either by excavating in some part of the

harbor, including tidewater channels

between high and low water mark, to such an

extent as to create a basin for as much

tidewater as may be displaced by such

structure or by such deposits, or in any

other mode that may be satisfactory to

him.

33 U.S.C. 406

$406. Penalty for wrongful construction of

bridges, piers, etc.; removal of

structures

Every person and every corporation

that shall violate any of the provisions of

sections 401, 403, and 404 of this title or

any rule or regulation made by the

Secretary of the Army in pursuance of the

provisions of section 404 of this title

shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor,

and on conviction thereof shall be punished

by a fine not exceeding $2,500 nor less

than $500, or by imprisonment (in the case

of a natural person) not exceeding one

year, or by both such punishments, in the

discretion of the court. And further, the

removal of any structures or parts of

structures erected in violation of the

provisions of the said sections may be

enforced by the injunction of any district

court exercising jurisdiction in any

district in which such structures may

exist, and proper proceedings to this end

may be instituted under the direction of

the Attorney General of the United States.

33 U.S.C. 409

$409. Obstruction of navigable waters by ,

vessels; fioating timber; marking

and removal of sunken vessels

It shall not be lawful to tie up or

anchor vessels or other craft in navigable

channels in such a manner as to prevent or

obstruct the passage of other vessels or

craft; or to voluntarily or carelessly

sink, or permit or cause to be sunk,

vessels or other craft in navigable

channels; or to float loose timber and

loge, or to float what is known as "sack ®

rafts of timber and logs" in streams or

channels actually navigated by steamboats

in such manner as to obstruct, impede, or

endanger navigation. And whenever a

vessel, raft, or other craft is wrecked and

sunk in a navigable channel, accidentally

or otherwise, it shall be the duty of the

owner of such sunken craft to immediately

mark it with a buoy or beacon during the

day and a lighted lantern at night, and to

‘maintain such marks until the sunken craft

is removed or abandoned, and the neglect or

failure of the said owner so to do shall be

unlawful; and it shall be the duty of the

owner of such sunken craft to commence the

immediate removal of the same, and

prosecute such removal diligently, and

failure to do so shall be considered as an

abandonment of such craft, and subject the

same to removal by the United States as

provided for in sections 411 to 416, 418,

and 502 of this title.

33 U.S.C. 411

$411. Penalty for wrongful deposit of

refuse; use of or injury to harbor

improvements, and obstruction of

navigable waters generally

Every person and every corporation

that shall violate, or that shall knowingly

aid, abet, authorize, or instigate a

violation of the provisions of sections

407, 408, and 409 of this title shall be

guilty of a misdemeanor, and on conviction

thereof shall be punished by a fine not

exceeding $2,500 nor less than $500, or by :

imprisonment (in the case of a natural

person) for not less than thirty days nor

more than one year, or by both such fine

and imprisonment, in the discretion of the

court, one-half of said fine to be paid to

the person or persons giving information

which shall lead to conviction.

33 U.S.C. 413

$413. Duty of United States attorneys and

other Federal officers in enforce-

ment of provisions; arrest of

offenders

The Department of Justice shall

conduct the legal proceedings necessary to

enforce the provisions of sections 401,

403, 404, 406, 407, 408, 409, 411, 549,

686, and 687 of this title; and it shall be

the duty of United States attorneys to

vigorously prosecute all offenders against

the same whenever requested to do so by the

Secretary of the Army or by any of the

officials hereinafter designated, and it

shall furthermore be the duty of said

United States attorneys to repért to the

Attorney General of the United States the

action taken by him against offenders so

reported, and a transcript of such reports

shall be transmitted to the Secretary of

the Army by the Attorney General; and for

the better enforcement of the said

provisions and to facilitate the detection

and bringing to punishment of such

offenders, the officers and agents of the

United States in charge of river and harbor

improvements, and the assistant engineers

and inspectors employed under them by

authority of the Secretary of the Army, and

the United States collectors of customs and

other revenue officers shall have power and

authority to swear out process, and to

arrest and take into custody, with or

without process, any person or persons who

may commit any of the acts or offenses

prohibited by the said sections, or who may

violate any of the provisions of the same:

Provided, That no person shall be arrested

without process for any offense not

‘committed in the presence of some one of

the aforesaid officials: And provided

further, That whenever any arrest is made

under such sections, the person so arrested

shall be brought forthwith before a

: commissioner, judge, or court of the United

States for examination of the offenses

alleged against him; and such commissioner,

judge, or court shall proceed in respect

thereto as authorized by law in case of

crimes against the United States.

33 U.S.C. 414

$414. Removal by Secretary of the Army of

sunken water craft generally

Whenever the navigation of any river,

lake, harbor, sound, bay, canal, or other

navigable waters of the United States shall

be obstructed or endangered by any sunken

vessel, boat, water craft, raft, or other

similar obstruction, and such obstruction

has existed for a longer period than thirty

days, or whenever the abandonment of such

obstruction can be legally established in a

less space of time, the sunken vessel,

boat, water craft, raft, or other

obstruction shall be subject to be broken

up, removed, sold, or otherwise disposed of

by the Secretary of the Army at his

discretion, without liability for any

damage to the owners of the same:

Provided, That in his discretion, the

Secretary of the Army may cause reasonable

notice of such obstruction of not less than

thirty days, unless the legal abandonment

of the obstruction can be established in a

less time, to be given by publication,

addressed "To whom it may concern," in a

newspaper published nearest to the locality

of the obstruction, requiring the removal

thereof: And provided also, That the

Secretary of the Army may, in his

discretion, at or after the time of giving

such notice, cause sealed proposals to be

solicited by public advertisement, giving

reasonable notice of not less than ten

days, for the removal of such obstruction

as soon as possible after the expiration of

the above specified thirty days' notice, in

case it has not in the meantime been so

removed, these proposals and contracts, at

his discretion, to be conditioned that such

vessel, boat, water craft, raft, or other

obstruction, and all cargo and property

contained therein, shall become the

property of the contractor, and the con-

tract shall be awarded to the bidder making

the proposition most advantageous to the “

United States: Provided, That such bidder

shall give satisfactory security to execute

the work: Provided further, That any money

received from the sale of any such wreck,

or from any contractor for the removal of

wrecks, under this paragraph shall be

covered into the Treasury of the United

States.

33 U.S.C. 415

$415. Summary removal of water craft

obstructing navigation

Under emergency, in the case of any

vessel, boat, water craft, or raft, or

other similar obstruction, sinking or

grounding, or being unnecessarily delayed

in any Government canal or lock, or in any

navigable waters mentioned in Section 414

of this title, in such manner as to stop,

seriously interfere with, or specially

endanger navigation, in the opinion of the

Secretary of the Army, or any agent of the

United States to whom the Secretary may

delegate proper authority, the Secretary of

the Army or any such agent shall have the

right to take immediate possession of such

boat, vessel, or other water craft, or

raft, so far as to remove or to destroy it

and to clear immediately the canal, lock,

or navigable waters aforesaid of the

obstruction thereby caused, using his best

judgment to prevent any unnecessary injury;

and no one shall interfere with or prevent

such removal or destruction: Provided,

That the officer or agent charged with the

removal or destruction of an obstruction

under this section may in his discretion

give notice in writing to the owners of any

such obstruction requriing them to remove

it: And provided further, That the expense

of removing any such obstruction as

aforesaid shall be a charge against such

craft and cargo; and if the owners thereof

fail or refuse to reimburse the United |

States for such expense within thirty days

after notification, then the officer or

agent aforesaid may sell the craft or

cargo, or any part thereof that may not

have been destroyed in removal, and the

proceeds of such sale shall be covered into

the Treasury of the United States.

damages should be the fair value of the

property, less any salvage value. Whether

or not there has been any enhanced: value

(i.e., whether the fair value of the

structure immediately after the repairs is

greater than its fair value immediately

before the damage occurred) is a matter to

be determined from an actual survey of the

structure and knowledge of its age and

condition. Where maintenance has equalled

depreciation there probably would be no

enhanced value.

(4) If the parties deny their

responsibility, or if they refuse or

neglect to remove any unlawful structure or

deposit or to repair the damages within the

time specified by the District Engineer,

the matter will be reported to the Chief of

Engineers with such evidence as the

District Engineer may be able to obtain and

his recommended action under Section 17 of

the Act of March 3, 1899. In a situation

- E-4h

both, in the discretion of the court. The

removal of any structures or parts of

structures erected in violation of the

provisions of the said sections may be

enforced by the injunction of any district

court exercising jurisdiction in any

district in which such structures may

exist, and proper proceedings to this end

may be instituted under the direction of

the Attorney General.

(3) It is the duty of each District

Engineer to take notice of any violations

of the laws for the protection of the

navigable waters and the works of

improvement therein that may occur in his

district and to take the necessary steps to

secure enforcement of the law. Whenever

any violation of any of these provisions of

law comes to his attention he will

investigate carefully the circumstances of

the case and will determine the amount of

the damage for which the parties committing

-E-41 ~ ~~ ms

the violation are responsible under Section

16 of the River and Harbor Act of March 3,

1899. He will advise the responsible

parties to remove the illegal structure or

deposit or to repair the damage at their

own expense within a time specified by him.

When there is reasonable doubt as to legal

liability or the facts do not appear to

warrant legal action, the District Engineer

will report the case to the Chief of

Engineers for decision before communicating

with the responsible parties. When the

damage must be repaired within a reasonable

time, if the responsible parties so request

in writing and if, when considered

advisable by the District Engineer to

protect the interests of the United States,

they furnish a satisfactory bond or other

guaranty, he may cause the repairs to be

made by employees of the United States and

then call upon the responsible parties to

pay over to him the cost of the damages

~- E-42 -

when finally ascertained. Where the

damages is not to be repaired within a

reasonable time, the District Engineer will

make final settlement with the responsible

parties as promptly as possible by

collecting the estimated amount of the

damages. All sums so received will be

deposited promptly to the credit of the

Treasurer of the United States for recredit

to the appropriation affected and will be

accounted for in the District Engineer's

money accounts by proper vouchers. With

reference to the method of ascertaining the

amount of the damages under Section 16 of

the Act, a distinction should be made

between cases involving property that

should be repaired and ‘those involving

property that should be abandoned. In the

former cases the amount of the damages

should be the total cost of repairs, less

any salvage value and any enhanced value.

In the latter cases, the amount of the

- E-43 -

ey &

portation pursuant to section 6(g)(6)(C) of

the Department of Transportation Act (80

Stat. 931).

(2) Section 10 of the River and

Harbor Act of March 3, 1899 (30 Stat. 1151;

33 U.S.C. 403), prohibits the creation of

any obstruction not affirmatively

authorized by Congress to the navigable

capacity of any of the waters of the United

States, and makes it unlawful to build any

wharf, pier, dolphin, boom weir,

breakwater, bulkhead, jetty, or other

structures, outside established harbor

lines or where no harbor lines have beer:

established, or to excavate or fill, or in

any manner to alter or modify the course,

location, condition, or chpacity of, ariy

navigable water of the United States,

unless the work has been recommended by the

Chief of Engineers and authorized by the

Secretary of the Army. The authority of

the Secretary of the Army to prevent

%

re

obstructions to navigation was extended to

artificial islands and structures on the

Outer Continental Shelf (section 4(f) of

the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act

approved Aug. 7, 1953 (67 Stat. 463; 43

U.S.C. 1333(f)).

(b>) Wrecks and similar obstructions.

Section 15 of the River and Harbor Act

of March 3, 1899 (30 Stat. 1152; 33 U.S.C.

408), makes it unlawful to tie up or anchor

vessels or other craft in navigable

channels in such a manner as to prevent or

obstruct the passage of other vessels or

craft, or to voluntarily or carelessly

sink, or permit or cause to be sunk,

vessels or other craft in navigable

channels, or to float loose timber and logs

or sack rafts of timber and logs in streams

or channels actually navigated by

steamboats in such manner as to obstruct,

impede, or endanger navigation (an Act of

Congress approved May 9, 1900, 31 Stat.

- B-38 -

172; 33 U.S.C 410, authorized the Secretary

of the Army to prescribe regulations to

govern the floating of loose timber and

logs and sack rafts and other methods of

navigation on any navigable river or

waterway of the United States or any part

thereof whereon the floating of loose

timber and logs and sack rafts is the

principal method of navigation). Whenever

a@ vessel, raf;, or other craft is wrecked

and sunk in a navigable channel

accidentally or otherwise, it is the duty

of the owner to immediately mark i: with a

buoy or beacon during the day and a lighted

lantern at night, and to maintain such

marks until the sunken craft is removed or

abandoned. By the maritime law the owner

of a vessel which is sunk without fault on

his part may abandon the wreck, in which

case he cannot be held responsible for

removing it. That law has not been changed

by the River and Harbor Act approved

March 3, 1899, which fully recognizes the

owner's right of abandonment. However, a

person who willfully or negligently permits

- @ vessel to sink in navigable waters of the

United States may not relieve himself from

all liability by merely abandoning the

wreck. He may be found guilty of a

misdemeanor and punished by fine,

imprisonment, or both, and in addition may

heve his license revoked or suspended. He

may also be’ compelled to remove the wreck

as a public nuisance or to pay for its

removal.

(f) Penalties for violations. (1)

Section 12 of the River and Harbor Act of

March 3, 1899 (30 Stat. 1151; 33 U.S.C.

406), as amended, provides that every

person and every corporation that shall

violate any of the provisions of Sections 9

and 10 shall be deemed guilty of a

misdemeanor, and on conviction thereof

shall be punished by fine, imprisonment, or

The Jones Act

46 U.S.C. 688

$688. Recovery for injury to or death of

seaman

Any seaman who shall suffer personal

injury in the course of his employment may,

at his election, maintain an action for

damages at law, with the right of trial by

jury, and in such action all statutes of

the United States modifying or extending

the common-law right or remedy in cases of

personal injury to railway employees shall

apply; and in case of the death of any

seaman as a result of any such personal

injury the personal representative of such

seaman may maintain an action for damages

at law with the right of trial by jury, and

in such action all statutes of the United

States conferring or regulating the right

of action for @eath in the case of railway

employees shall be aplicable. Jurisdiction

in such actions shall be under the court of

the district in which the defendant employ-

er resides or in which is principal office

is located.

as

The Suits in Admiralty Act (S.I.A.A.)

46 U.S.C. 742

§742. Libel in personam

In cases where if such vessel were

privately owned or operated, or if such

cargo were privately owned or possessed, or

if a private person or property were

involved, a proceeding in admiralty could

be maintained, any appropriate nonjury

proceeding in personam may be brought

against the United States or against any

corporation mentioned in section 741 of

this title. Such suits shall be brought in

the district court of the United States for

the district in which the parties so suing,

or any of them, reside or have their

principal place of business in the United

States, or in which the vessel or cargo

charged with liability is found. The

libelant shall forthwith serve a copy of

his libel on the United States attorney for

such district and mail a copy thereof by

- E-33 -

Wee SS) ee

Pee Cae

registered mail to the Attorney General of

the United States, and shall file a sworn

return of such service and mailing. Such

service and mailing shall constitute valid

service on the United States and such

corporation. In case the United states or

such corporation shall file a libel in rem

or in personam in in any district, a cross

libel in personam may be filed or a set-off

claimed against the United States or such

corporation with the same force and effect

as if the libel had been’filed by a private

party. Upon application of either party

the cause may, in the discretion of the

court, be transferred to any other district

court of the United States.

- E-34 -

The Death of the High Seas Act (D.0.H.S.A.)

46 U.S.C. 7461

§761. Right of action; where and by whom

brought.

Whenever the death of a person shall

be caused by wrongful act, neglect, or

default occurring on the high seas beyond a

marine league from the shore of any State,

or the District of Columbia, or the

Territories or dependencies of the United

States, the personal representative of the

‘decedent may maintain a suit f°. damages in

the district courts of the United States,

in admiralty, for the exclusive benefit of

the decedent's wife, husband, parent,

child, or dependent relative against the

Vessel, person, or corporatidn which would

have been liable if death had not ensued.

- E-35 -

33 C.F.R. 209, et seq. .

§209.170 Violations of laws protecting

navigable waters.

(a) Illegal structures or other

work.

(1) Section 9 of the River and Harbor

Act of March 3, 1899 (30 Stat. 1151:33

U.S.C. 401), makes it unlawful to construct

any bridge, dam, dike, or causeway over or

in any navigalle water of the United States

until the proper local authority has been

obtained and until) the location and plans 4

have been approved by the Chief of

Engineers and the Secretary of the Army.

When plans for any structure have weal 80

approved, it is unlawful to deviate from

such plans unless the modification thereof

has received the approval of the Chief of.

Engineers and the Secretary of the Army.

Plans of any bridge or causeway now require

the approval of the Department of Transpor-

The foregoing order is hereby amended

by substituting the word "district

engineer" for "officer", with the

understanding that the term "disrict

engineer" includes both officers and

civilians assigned by competent orders to

the charge of a district of the Engineer

Department at Large.

(3) The above quoted authority

eliminates the necessity for establishing

abandonment in emergency cases, but

information required by paragraph (k)(2)

will be furnished HWDA (DAEN-CWO-M)

Washington, D.C. 20314.

(4) Action under this section may be

undertaken without prior approval of the

Chief of Engineers, subject to the same

provisos contained in paragraph (h) of this

section. |

§209.200 Regulations governing navigable

waters.

- E-54 -

(a) Publication of regulations. (1)

Regulations prescribed by or under the

direction of the Secretary of the Army to

govern navigation and navigable waters,

including general, danger zone, restricted

area, dumping grounds, fishing and hunting,

and navigation regulations, are contained

in the Code of Federal Regulations, Title

33, Navigation and Navigable Waters,

Chapter II.

(b>) Navigation regulations. (1)

Section 7 of the River and Harbor Act

approved August 8, 1917 (40 Stat. 266; 33

U.S.C. 1) authorizes the Secretary of the

Army to prescribe such regulations for the

use, administration, and navigation of the

navigable waters of the United States as

public necessity may require for the

protection of life and property, or for

operations of the United States in channel

improvement, covering all matters not

specifically delegated by law to some other

7 E-55 -

duties which will be of benefit to the

Coast Guard in maintaining its system of

aids to navigation. This should include

statements...

PART 320 - GENERAL REGULATORY POLICIES

§320.1 Purpose and scope.

(a) Regulatory approach of the Corps

of Engineers. (1) The U. S. Army Corps of

Engineers has been involved in regulating

certain activities in the nation's waters

since 1890. Until 1968, the primary thrust

of the Corps' regulatory program was the

protection of navigation. As a result of

several new laws and judicial decisions,

the program evolved from one that protects

navigation only to one that considers the

full public interest by balancing the

favorable impacts against the detrimental

impacts. This is known as the "public

interest balancing process" or the "public

interest review." The program is one which

reflects the national concerns for both the

- E-58 -

requiring immediate action, the District

Engineer may report the case directly to

the U.S. attorney for the district. The

Chief of Engineers will be advised of such

action by a written report. Although the

Corps of Engineers has certain police

powers under this Act it has been the long

standing policy to secure compliance with

its provisions short of legal proceedings.

Accordingly every effort will be made to

accomplish corrective measures prior to

initiation of action leading to such

proceedings. As a general rule, while

minor and unintentional or accidental

violations of the provisions of the Act

need not be reported to the Chief of

Engineers, all willful or intentional

violations and all cases in which the

parties responsible refuse or neglect to

remove the unlawful structure or deposit or

to make good the damages suffered should be

reported promptly to the Chief of Engineers

regulations of the Coast Guard marking of

wrecks, see 33 CFR Part 64.

(h) Removal of obstruction under the

provisions of Section 19 of the River and

Harbor Act of 1899. (33 U.S.C. 414) Action

under this section may be undertaken

without prior approval of the Chief of

Engineers only when the navigation of

navigable waters of the United States is

obstructed or endangered, and if the

obstruction has been in existence over 30

days, or its abandonment by the owner can

be legally established in a shorter period.

The obstruction can be removed by any

method deemed most advantageous provided:

(2) The wreck is a sunken vessel,

boat, watercraft, raft or othér similar

obstruction.

(3) The wreck is an obstruction to

general navigation, not merely an

obstruction to a private wharf or canal or

merely aesthetically displeasing.

- E-51 -

(4) All reasonable efforts have first

been exhausted to require the owner to

remove the wreck himself within a

reasonable period. If this effort is not

successful, then removal may be undertaken

at Federal expense. The District Engineer

should institute steps to recover from the

owners the costs incurred. (Wyandotte

Transportation v. United States, 389 U.S.

205 88 S.Ct. 379 [1967]. Further, the

owner must be advised that the wreck will

be removed by the United States with the

reservation of all rights of the United

States to recover from the owner all

expenses of removal.

(1) Removal of obstructions under

provisions of Section 20 of the River and

Harbor Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 415).

(1) This section provides that action

thereunder may be taken by any Agent of the

United States to whom the Secretary of the

Army "may delegate proper authority." A

delegation of such authority was made by

the following order issued by the Secretary

of War 20 January 1905.

Whenever any vessel, boat, watercraft,

or raft sinks, grounds, or is unnecessarily

delayed in any canal, lock, or other

improvement controlled or owned by the

United States, or in any navigable waters

of the United States, under circumstances

of emergency, the officer in charge of such

lock, canal, improvement or district will

take charge of such vessel, boat,

watercraft, raft, or other obstruction with

a view to its immediate removal or

destruction, using his best judgment in all

cases to prevent any unnecessary injury.

Any action taken under the above

instructions will be reported forthwith to

the Chief of Engineers for the information

or action of the Secretary of War.

(2) The above order was amended on 2

November 1917 as follows:

~ E-53 -

executive department. The statute provides

for the posting of regulations and punish-

ment for violations.

(2) Section 6 of the River and Harbor

Act approved June 13, 1902 (32 Stat. 374;

33 U.S.C. 499) provides that regulations

prescribed by the Secretary of the Army may

be enforced as provided in section 17 of

the River and Harbor Act approved March 3,

1899 (30 Stat. 1153; 33 U.S.C. 413).

(3) District Engineers will take

action with respect to regulations

prescribed for waterways under their

jurisdiction:

(11) To insure that the regulations

are properly and fairly administered.

(111) To recommend any revisions

necessary to permit full use of the

waterway by the public.

§209.325 Navigation lights, aids to

navigation, navigation charts, and related

data policy, practices and procedure.

- E-56 -

(a) Purpose. This regulation

prescribes the policy, practice and pro-

cedure to be used by all Corps of Engineers

installations and activities in connection

with aids to navigation, chart data, and

publication of information on Civil Works

activities.

(d) Cooperation with Coast Guard.

(1) District Engineers will consult with

the Coast Guard District Commander during

design of channel and harbor improvement

projects to discuss the aids to navigation

requirements and all other facets of the

projects that involve Coast Guard

responsibiility. Project material

furnished direct to Coast Guard Commanders

will include:

(3) District Engineers will furnish

direct to the various Coast Guard District

Commanders, for their immediate

information, any facts which may come to

their attention in connection with their

hs ee ee ee

in accordance with the above. It is the

policy not to recommend prosecution when

the violation of law is trivial, apparently

unpremeditated, and results in no material

public injury. Each report recommending

prosecution should be accompanied by a full

statement of the case and copies of

correspondence relating thereto.

§209.190 Removal of wrecks and other

obstructions.

(a) Laws relative to removal of

wrecks and obstructions. (1) The laws

relating to removal of wrecks and contained

in Sections 15, 19 and 20 of the River and

Harbor Act approved 3 March 1899 and

Section 86 of Title 14, United States

Code.

(2) As removal by the United States

without formal abandonment involves the

taking of private property for public

purposes, the provisions of the section of

law applicable to the particular case must

- E-N6 -

be followed strictly. Removal by the

United States is not usually undertaken if

the obstruction simply affects the

approaches to private wharves or canals and

is not obstructing or endangering

navigation.

(b) Reports on accidents or

obstructions affecting navigation. An

accident such as a vessel collision,

sink'ng or grounding, or a bridge failure

which occurs in navigable waters of the

United States and poses a threat to

navigation, shall be reported by the

District Engineer to HQDA (DAEN-CWO-m),

Washington, D.C. 20314 by teletype within

24 hours. Included in the teletype should

be a report on the extent of the danger to

navigation and an estimate of the duration

of the obstruction. When such an accident

results in an obstruction to navigation, it

shall be immediately reported by telephone

to HQDA, Chief, Operations Branch,

- B-47 -

DAEN-CWO-M. (Exempt under paragraph 7-20,

AR 335-15.)

(c) General procedure concerning

wrecks and other obstructions. (1) The

District Engineer should ascertain, at

once, whether navigation is obstructed or

endangered, and if the obstruction must be

removed, he should inform the owner

promptly of the provisions of the law.

(2) Vessel owners, masters and others

having any knowledge of wrecks or other

obstructions should be encouraged to report

their location promptly to the District

Engineer.

(3) If the owner commences removal,

the District Engineer should supervise the

operations sufficiently to insure .gainst

unreasonable interference with navigation

and see that the removal proceeds:

diligently. If removal by the United

States is necessary, the District Engineer

must act preuptiy. If the owner has not

marked the obstruction, the District

Engineer should request the local Coast

Guard District Commander to do so.

(e) Abandonment of wrecks by owners

or underwriters. (1) Every precaution

should be taken in cases involving wrecked

or sunken vessels to insure that the rights

of the United States are not prejudiced by

acceptance of abandonment when tendered by

owners or underwriters of vessels under 33

U.S.C. 409. Under no circumstances will

acceptance of abandonment be indicated. If

a letter of abandonment is received,

receipt of the letter should be merely

acknowledged and a statement include in the

reply as follows: "This acknowledgement

should in no way be construed as acteptance

by the United States of an abandonment of

such vessel, nor as waiver of any right to

enforce liability for any damage caused by

ites sinking or cost of removal." When a

notice of abandonment has not been received

- B-49 -

from the owners or underwriters, or

ownership cannot be established, the

District Engineer may, after the

obstruction has existed for over thirty

days, establish abandonment by inserting,

in a@ newspaper nearest the locality of the

obstruction, a legal advertisement

addressed "To Whom It May Concern"

requiring the removal of the obstruction

(33 U.S.C. 414).

(f) Making of wrecks by Coast Guard.

(1) Under 14 U.S.C. 86 of the cost of

continuing the marking of sunken vessel or

other obstruction to navigation, after

abandonment is established, shall be borne

by the Department of Transportation.

(2) The District Fhgineer will advise

the Coast Guard as soon as practicable if

he desires an obstruction marked and will

also notify the Coast Guard when removal

operations have been completed. For

- E-50 -

(c) The term "work" shall include,

without limitation, any dredging or

disposal of dredged material, excavation,

filling, or other modification of a

navigable water of the United States.

(a4) The term "letter of permission"

means a type of individual permit issued in

accordance with the abbreviated procedures

of 33 CFR 325.2(e).

(e) The term "individual permit"

means a department of the Army

authorization that is issued following a

case-by-case evaluation of a specific

structure or work in accordance with che

procedures of this regulation and 33 CFR

325 and a determination that the proposed

structure or work is in the public interest

pursuant to 33 CFR 320.

(f) The term "general permit" means a

Department of the Army authorization that

is issued on a nationwide ("nationwide

permits") or regional ("regional permits")

ze

- E-71 -

protection and utilization of important

resources. It is a dynamic program that

varies the weight given to a specific

public interest factor in light of the

importance of other such factors in a

particular situation.

(2) The Corps is a highly

decentralized organization. Most of the

authority for administering the regulatory

program has been given to the thirty six

district engineers. If a district or

division engineer makes a final decision on

a permit application in accordance with the

procedures and authorities contained in

these regulations (33 CFR Parts 320-330),

there is no administrative appeal of that

decision.

(5) The Corps believes that state and

Federal regulatory programs should

complement rather than duplicate one

another. Use of general permits, joint

processing procedures, interagency review

proposal must be considered including the

cumulative effects thereof: among those

are conservation, economics, aesthetics,

general environmental concerns, wetlands,

cultural values, fish and wildlife values,

flood hazards, flood plain values, land

use, navigation, recreation, water supply

and conservation, water quality, energy

needs, safety, food and fiber production,

mineral needs and, in general, the needs

and welfare of the people. No permit will

be granted unless its issuance is found to

be in the public interest.

(2) The following general criteria

will be considered in the evaluation of

every application:

(1) The relative extent of the public

and private need for the proposed structure

or work: )

(111) The extent and permanence of

the beneficial and/or detrimental effects

which the proposed structure or work may

- E-67 -

gg

have on the public and private uses to

which the area is suited.

PART 322 - PERMITS FOR STRUCTURES OR WORK

IN OR AFFECTING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF

THE UNITED STATES

§322.1 General.

This regulation prescribes, in

addition to the general policies of 33 CFR

Part 320 and procedures of 33 CFR Part 325

those special policies, practices and

procedures to be followed by the Corps of

Engineers in connection with the review of

applications for Department of Army permits

to authorize certain structures or work in

or affecting navigable waters of the United

States pursuant to Section 10 of the River

and Harbor Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403)

(hereinafter referred to as Section 10).

See 33 CFR 320.2(b). Certain structures or

work in or affecting navigable waters of

the United States are also regulated under

other authorities of the Department of the

- E-68 -

Army. These include discharges of dredged

or fill material into waters of the United

States, including the territorial seas,

pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water

Act (33 U.S.C. 1344; see CFR Part 323) and

the transportation of dredged material by

vessel for purposes of dumping in ocean

waters, including the territorial seas,

pursuant to Section 103 of the Marine

Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of

1972, as amended (33 U.S.C. 1413; see 33

CFR Part 324). A Department of Army permit

will also be required under these

additional authorities if they are

applicable to structures or work in or

affecting navigable waters of the United

States. Applicants for Department of the

Army permits under this part should refer

to the other cited authorities and

implementing regulations for these

additional permit requirements to determine

whether they also are applicable tc their

- B-69 -

proposed activities.

§322.2 Definitions.

For the purpose of this regulation,

the following terms are defined:

(a) The term "navigable waters of the

United States" means those waters of the

United States that are subject to the ebb

and flow of the tide shoreward to the mean

high water mark, and/or are presently used,

or have been used in the past, or may be

susceptible to use to transport interstate

or foreign commerce. See 33 CFR Part 329

for a more complete definition of this

term.

(db) The term "structure" shall

include, without limitation, any pier,

wharf, dolphin, weir, boom, breakwater,

bulkhead, revetment, riprap, jetty,

permanent mooring structure, power

transmission line, permanently moored

floating vessel, piling, aid to navigation,

or any other obstacle or obstruction.

nt E-70 ag 4

e

‘9

basis for a category or categories of

activities when:

(1) those activities are

substantially similar in nature and cause

only minimal individual and cumulative

environmental impacts; or

(2) the general permit would result

in avoiding unnecessary duplication of the

regulatory ccntrol exercised by another

Federal, state, or local agency provided it

har been determined that the environmertal

consequences of the action are individually

and cumulatively minimal. (See 33 CFR

325.2(e) and 33 DFR Part 330).

§322.3 Activities requiring permits.

(a) General. Department of the Army

permits are required under Section 10 for

structures and/or work in or affecting

navigable waters of the United States

except as otherwise provided in these

regulations. Actitivities that were com-

menced or completed shoreward of

- E-72 -

coordination and authority transfers (where

authorized by law) are encouraged to reduce

duplications.

(b>) Types of activities regulated.

This regulation and the regulations that

follow (33 CFR Parts 321-330) prescribe the

statutory authorities, and general and

special policies and procedures applicable

to the review of applications for

Department of the Army permits for various

types of activities that occur in waters of

the United States or the oceans. This part

identifies the various Federal statutes

that require Department of the Army permits

before these activities can be lawfully

undertaken; the related Federal laws

applicable to the review of each activity

that requires a Department of the ‘Army

permit; and the general policies that are

applicable to the review of all activities

that require Department of the Army

permits. Parts 321-324 address the various

types of activities that require Department

of the Army permits, including special

policies and procedures applicable to those

activities, as follows:

(2) Other structures or work

including excavation, dredging, and/or

disposal activities, in navigable waters of

the United States (Part 322);

(3) Activities that alter or modify

the course, condition, location, or

capacity of a navigable water of the United

States (Part 322);

(7) Nationwide general permits for

certain categories of these activities

(Part 330).

(c) Forms of authorization.

Department of the Army permits for the

above described activities are issued under

various forms of authorization. These

include individual permits that are issued

following a review of an individual

application for a Department of the Army

- E-61 -

permit and general permits that authorize

the performance of a category or categories

of activities in a specific geographical

region or nationwide. The term "general

permit" as used in these regulations (33

CFR Parts 320-330) refers to both those

regional permits issued by district or

division engineers on a regional basis and

to nationwide permits issued by the Chief

of Engineers through publication in the

Federal Register and applicable throughout

the nation. The nationwide permits are

found in 33 CFR Part 330. If an activity

is covered by a general permit, an appli-

cation for a Department of the Army permit

does not have to be made. In such cases, a

person must only comply” with the conditions

contained in the general permit to satisfy

requirements of law for a Department of the

Army Permit.

§320.2 Authorities to issue permits.

- E-62 -

(a) Section 9 of the River and Harbor

Act approved March 3, 1899 (33 U.S.C. 401)

(hereinafter referred to as Section 9)

prohibits the construction of any dam or

dike across any navigable water of the

United States in the absence of

Congressional consent and approval of the

Plans by the Chief of Engineers and the

Secretary of the Army. Where the navigable

portions of the waterbody lie wholly within

the limits of a single state, the structure

may be built under authority of the

legislature of that State, if the location

and plans or any modification thereof are

approved by the Chief of Engineers and by

the Secretary of the Army. The instrument

of authorization is designated a permit.

Section 9 also pertains to bridges and

causeways by the authority of the Secretary

of the Army and Chief of Engineers with

respect to bridges and causeways was

transferred to the Secretary of

- E-63 -

“A

aa .

“a aS .

“* 2 eet: ae

Transportation under the Department of

Transportation Act of October 15, 1966 (49

U.S.C. 1155g¢(6)(A)). (See also 33 CFR Part

321.) A Department of the Army permit

pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water

Act is required for the discharge of

dredged or fill material into waters of the

United States associated with bridges and

causeways. (See 33 CFR Part 323.)

(b) Section 10 of the River and

Harbor Act approved March 3, 1899 (33

U.S.C. 403) (hereinafter referred to as

Section 10) prohibits the unauthorized

obstruction or alteration of any navigable

water of the United States, The construc-

tion of any structure in or over any

navigable water of the United States, the

excavation from or depositing of material

in such waters, or the accomplishment of

any other work affecting the course,

location, condition, or capacity of such

waters is unlawful unless the work has been

- E-64 -

a

recommended by the Chief of Engineers and

authorized by the Secretary of the Army.

The instrument of authorization is

designated a permit. The authority of the

Secretary of the Army to prevent

obstructions to navigation in the navigable

waters of the United States was extended to

artificial islands, installations, and

other devices located on the outer

continental shelf by Section 4(e) of the

Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act of 1953

as amended (43 U.S.C. 1333(e)). (See also

33 CFR Part 322.)

§320.4 General policies for evaluating

permit applications.

The following policies shall be

applicable to the review of all

applications for Department of the Army

permits. Additional policies specifically

applicable to certain types of activities

are identified in Parts 321-324.

- E-65 -

(a) Public interest review. (1) The

decision whether to issue a permit will be

based on an evaluation of the probable

impact including cumulative impacts of the

proposed activity and its intended use on

the public interest. Evaluation of the

probable impact which the proposed activity

may have on the public interest requires a

careful weighing of all those factors which

become relevant in each particular case.

The benefits which reasonably may be

expected to accure from the proposal must

be balanced against its reasonably

foreseeable detriments. The decision

whether to authorize a proposal, and if so,

the conditions under which it will be

allowed to occur, are therefore determined

by the outcome of the general balancing

process. That decision should reflect the

national concern for both protection and

utilization of important resources. All

factors which may be relevant to the

as

established Federal harbor lines before May

27, 1970 (see 33 CFR 320.4(0)) also do not

require Section 10 permits; however, if

those activities involve the discharge of

dredged or fill material into waters of the

United States after October 18, 1972, a

Section 404 permit is required (see 33 CFR

Part 323).

(1) Structures or work are in the

navigable waters of the United States if

they are within limits defined in 33 CFR

Part 329. Structures or work outsice these

limits are subject to the provisions of law

cited in paragraph (a) of this section, if

these structures or work affect the course,

location, or condition of the waterbody in

such @ manner as to impact on the navigable

capacity of the waterbody. For purposes of

a Section 10 permit, a tunnel or other

structure of work under or over a navigable

water of the United States is considered to

have an impact on the navigable capacity of

the waterbody.

(2) Congress has delegated to the

Secretary of the Army and the Chief of

Engineers in Section 10 the duty to

authorize or prohibit certain work or

structures in navigable waters of the

United States. The general legislation by

which federal agencies are empowered to act

generally is not considered to be

sufficient authorization by Congress to

satisfy the purposes of Section 10. If an

agency asserts that it has Congressional

authorization meeting the test of Section

10 or would otherwise be exempt from the

provisions of Section 10, the legislative

history and/or provisions of the Act should

clearly demonstrate that Congress was

approving the exact location and plans from

which Congress could have considered the

effect on navigable waters of the United

States or that Congress intended to exempt

- E-74 -

neighboring proprietors' access to the

waterway. Obstructions can result fron

both the existence of the structure,

particularly in conjunction with other

similar facilities in the immediate

vicinity, and from its inability to

withstand wave action or other forces

which can be expected. District engineers

will inform applicants of the hazards

involved and encourage safety in location,

design and operation. Corps of Engineers

officials will also encourage cooperative

or group use facilities in lieu of

individual proprietor use facilities.

(e) Aids to navigation. The placing

of fixed and floating aids to navigation in

a navigable water of the United States is

within the purview of Section 10 of the

River and Harbor Act of 1899. Furthermore,

these aids are of particular interest to

the U.S. Coast Guard because of their

control of marking, iighting and

- E-77 -

standardization of such navigation aids. A

Section 10 nationwide permit has been

issued for such aids provided they are

approved by and installed in accordance

with the requirements of the U.S. Coast

Guard (33 CFR Part 330). Electrical

service cables to such aids are not

included in the nationwide permit (an

individual or regional Section 10 permit

will be required).

(g) Canals and other artificial

waterways connected to navigable waters of

the United States. (1) A canal or similar

artificial waterway is subject to the

regulatory authorities discussed in §322.3,

of this part, if it constitutes a navigable

water of the United States, or if it is

connectsd to navigable waters of the United

States ina manner which affects their

course, location, condition, or capacity or

if at some point in its construction or

operation it results in an effect on the

- E-78 -

course, location, condition, or capacity of

navigable waters of the United States. In

all cases the connection to navigable

waters of the United States requires a

permit. Where the canal itself constitutes

a navigable water of the United States,

evaluation of the permit application and

further exercise of regulatory authority

will be in accordance with the standard

procedures of these regulations. For all

other canals, the exercise of regulatory

authority is restricted to those activities

which affect the course, location,

condition, or capacity of the navigable

waters of the United States.

(1) Power Transmission Lines

(3) Clearances for communication

lines, stream gaging cables, ferry cables,

and other aerial crossings are usually

required to be a minimum of ten feet above

clearances required for bridges. Greater

- E-79 -

ry

clearances will be required if the public

interest so indicates.

§325.7 Modification, suspension or revo-

cation of authorizations.

(a) General. The district engineer

may reevaluate the circumstances and

conditions of any permit, including

regional permits either on his own motion,

at the request of the permittee, or a third

party, or as the result of periodic

progress inspections, and initiate action

to modify, suspend, or revoke a permit as

may be made necessary by considerations of

the public interest. In the case of

regional permits, this reevaluation may

cover individual activities, categories of

activities, or geographic areas. Among the

factors to be considered are the extent of

the permittee's compliance with the terms

and conditions of the permit; whether or

not circumstances relating to the

authorized activity have changed since the

a

permit was issued or extended, and the

continuing adequacy of the permit

conditions; any significant objections to

the authorized activity which were not

earlier considered; revisions to applicable

statutory and/or regulatory authorities;

and the extend to which modification,

suspension, or other action would adversely

affect plans, investments and actions the

permittee has reasonably made or taken in

reliance on the permit. Significant

increases in scope of a permitted activity

will be processed as new applications for

permits in accordance with §325.2 of this

part, and not as modifications under this

paragraph.

(db) Modification. Upon request by

the permittee or, as a result of

reevaluation of the circumstances and

conditions of a permit, the district

engineer may determine that the public

interest requires a modification of the

- E-81 - b a

terms or conditions of the permit. In such

cases, the district engineer will hold

informal consultations with the permittee

to ascertain whether the terms and

conditions can be modified by mutual

agreement. If a mutual agreement is

reached on modification of the terms and

conditions of the permit, the district

engineer will give the permittee written

notice of the modification, which will then

become effective on such date as the

district engineer may establish. In the

event a mutual agreement cannot be reached

by the district engineer and the permittee,

the district engineer will proceed in

accordance with paragraph (c) of this

section if immediate suspension is

warranted, In cases where immediate

suspension is not warranted by the district

engineer determines that the permit should

be modified, he will notify the permittee

of the proposed modification and reasons

- E-82 -

on

therefor, and that he may request a meeting

with the district engineer and/or a public

hearing. The modification will become

effective on the date set by the district

engineer which shall be at least ten days

after receipt of the notice by the

permittee unless hearing or meeting is

requested within that period. If the

permittee fails or refuses to comply with

the modification, the district engineer

will proceed in accordance with 33 CFR Part

326.

(c) Suspension. The district

engineer may suspend a permit after

preparing a written determination and

finding that immediate suspension would be

in the public interest. The district

engineer will notify the permittee in

writing by the most expeditious means

available that the permit has been

suspended with the reasons therefor, and

order the permittee to stop those

activities previously authorized by the

suspended permit. The permittee will also

be advised that following this suspension a

decision will be made to either reinstate,

modify, or revoke the permit, and that he

may within 10 days of receipt of notice of

the suspension, request a meeting with the

district engineer and/or a public hearing

to present information in this matter. If

a hearing is requested, the procedures

prescribed in 33 CFR Part 327 will be

followed. After the completion of the

meeting or hearing (or within a reasonable

period of time after issuance of the notice

to the permittee that the permit has been

suspended if no hearing or meeting is

requested), the district engineer will take

action to reinstate, modify or revoke the

permit.

(d) Revocation. Following completion

of the suspension procedures in paragraph

(c) of this section if revocation of the

- E-84 -

permit is found to be in the public

interest, the authority who made the

decisior on the original permit may revoke

it. The permittee will be advised in

writing of the final decision.

(e) Regional permits. The district

engineer may, by following the procedures

of this section, revoke regional permits

for individual activities, categories of

activities or geographic areas, the

informal discussions provided in paragraph

(b) of this section may be waived and any

written notification may be made through

the general public notice procedures of

this regulation. If a regional permit is

revoked, any permittee may then apply for

an individual permit which shall be

processed in accordance with these

regulations.

§325.8 Authority to issue or deny

permits.

that agency from the requirements of

Section 10. Very often such legislation

reserves final approval of plans or

construction for the Chief of Engineers.

In such cases evaluation and authorization

under this regulation are limited by the

intent of the statutory language involved.

(3) The policy provisions set out in

33 CFR 320.4(j) relating to state or local

certifications and/or authorizations, do

not apply to work or structures undertaken

by Federal agencies, except where

compliance with non-Federal authorization

is required by Federal law or Executive

policy, e.g., Section 313 and Section 401

of the Clean Water Act.

§322.5 Special policies.

The Secretary of the Army has

delegated to the Chief of Engineers the

authority to issue or deny Section 10

permits. The following additional special

policies and procedures shall also be

- E-75 -

applicable to the evaluation of permit

applications under this regulation.

(a) General. Department of the Army

permits are required for structures or work

in or affecting navigable waters of the

United States. However, certain structures

or work specified in 33 CFR Part 330 are

permitted by that regulation, an individual

or regional Section 10 permit will be

required.

(d) Structures for small boats. (1)

As a matter of policy, in the absence of

overriding public interest, favorable

consideration will generally be given to

applications from riparian owners for

permits for piers, boat docks, moorings,

platforms and similar structures for small

boats. Particular attention will be given

to the location and general design of such

structures to prevent possible obstructions

to navigation with respect to both the

public's use of the waterway and the

- E-76 -

(a) General. Except as otherwise

provided in thie regulation, the Secretary

of the Army, subject to such conditions as

he or his authorized representative may

from time to time impose, has authorized

the Chief of Engineers and his authorized

representatives to issue or deny permits

for construction or other work in or

affecting navigable waters of the United

States pursuant to Section 10 of the River

and Harbor Act of 1899. He also has

authorized the Chief of Engineers and his

authorized representatives to issue or deny

permits for the discharge of dredged or

fill material in waters of the United

States pursuant to section 404 of the Clean

Water Act or for the transportation of

dredged material for the purpose of

disposing of it into ocean waters pursuant

to Section 103 of the Marine Protection,

Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972, as

amended. The authority to issue or deny

- E-86 -

>

permits pursuant to Section 9 of the River

and Harbor Act of March 3, 1899 has not

been delegated to the Chief of Engineeers

or his authorized representatives.

(b) District Engineers' authority.

District engineers are authorized to issue

or deny permits in accordance with these

regulations permits pursuant to Section 10

of the River and Harbor Act of 1899;

Section 404 of the Clean Water Act; and

Section 103 of the Marine Protection,

Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972, as

amended, in all cases not required to be

referred to higher authority (see below).

It is essential to the legality of a permit

that it contain the name of the district

engineer as the issuing“officer. However,

the permit need not be signed by the

district engineer in person but may be

signed for and in behalf of him by whomever

he designates. In cases where permits are

denied for reasons other than navigation or

failure to obtain required local, State, or

other Federal approvals or certifications,

the Statement of Findings must conclusively

justify a denial decision, District

engineers are authorized to deny permits

without issuing a public notice or taking

other procedural steps where required

local, state or other Federal permits for

the proposed activity have been denied or

where he determines that the activity will

clearly interfere with navigation except in

all cases required to be referred to higher

authority (see below). District engineers

are also authorized to add, modify, or

delete special conditions in permits in

accordance with §325.4 of this part, except

for those conditions which may have been

imposed by higher authority, and to modify,

suspend and revoke permits according to the

procedures of §325.7 of this part.

District engineers will refer the following

applications to the division engineer for

resolution:

(1) When a referral is required by a

written agreement between the head of a

Federal agency and the Secretary of the

Army ;

(3) When there is substantial doubt

as to authority, law, regulations, or

policies applicable to the proposed

activity;

(4) When higher authority requests

the application be forwarded for decision;

or

(5) When the district engineer is

precluded by law or procedures required by

law from taking final action on the

application (e.g., Section 404(c) of the

Clean Water Act, Section 9 of the River and

Harbor Act of 1899, or territorial sea

baseline changes).

(c) Division Engineers' authority.

Division engineers will review and evaluate

all permit applications referred by

- E-89 -

district ergineers. Division engineers may

authorize the issuance or denial of permits

pursuant to Section 10 of the River and

Harbor Act of 1899; Section 404 of the

Clean Water Act; and Section 103 of the

Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries

Act of 1972, as amended; and the inclusion

of conditions in accordance with §325.4 of

this Part in all cases not required to be

referred to the Chief of Engineers. Divi-

sion Engineers will refer the following

applications to the Chief of Engineers for

resolution:

(1) When a referral is required by a

written agreement between the head of a

Federal agency and the Secretary of the

Army;

(2) When there is substantial doubt

as to authority, law, regulations, or

policies applicable to the proposed

activity;

Ss *

(3) When higher authority

requests the application be forwarded for

decision; or

(4) When the division engineer is

precluded by law or procedures required by

law from taking final action on the

application.

PART 326 - ENFORCEMENT, SUPERVISION AND IN-

SPECTION

§326.1 Purpose.

This regulation prescribes the policy,

practice, and procedures to be followed by

the Corps of Engineers in connection with

activities requiring Department of the Army

permits that are performed without prior

authorization; and supervision and

inspection of authorized activities.

§326.2 Discovery of unauthorized activity.

(a) When the district engineer

becomes aware of any unauthorized activity

still in progress, including a violation of

the terms and conditions of an authorized

= E-91 <-

activity, he shall immediately issue an

order prohibiting further work to all

persons responsible for and/or involved in

the performance of the activity and may

order interim protective work. If the

unauthorized activity has been completed,

he will advise the responsible party of his

discovery.

§326.3 Administrative action.

(a) Initial investigation.

Immediately upon discovery of an

unauthorized activity, the district

engineer shall commence an investigation to

ascertain the facts surrounding the

activity. In making this investigation,

the district engineer should, in

appropriate cases, depending upon the

potential impacts of the completed work

solicit the views of the Regional

Administrator of the Environmental Protec-

tion Agency, the Regional Director of the

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the

- R09

:

et ons

a ant

"etn

re £' ty.

Regional Director of the National Marine

Fisheries Service, and other Federal,

state, and/or local agencies. He shall

also request the persons involved in the

unauthorized activity to provide

appropriate information on the activity to

assist him in his evaluation and in

determining the course of action to be

taken.

(b) Remedial work. (1) The district

engineer shall determine whether as a

result of the unauthorized activity, life,

property or important public resources are

in serious jeopardy and would require

expeditious measures for protection. Such

measures may range from minor modification

of the existing work to complete

restoration of the area involved.

Important public resources are identified

in 33 CPR 320.4. If the district engineer

determines that immediate remedial work is

required, he shall issue an appropriate

- E+93 -

order describing the work, conditions and

time limits required to provide .

satisfactory protection of the resource.

(2) Voluntary restoration by the

responsible party on the party's own

initiative shall be allowed if legal action

is not otherwise necessary. However,

district engineers will advise the

responsible party of the option of an

after-the-fact application for a permit to

retain the unauthorized work. No permit

will be required when complete and

satisfactory restoration is accomplished. 7

(c) Acceptance of an after-the-fact

application. Upon completion of

appropriate remedial work, if any, the

district engineer shall accept an

application for an after-the-fact permit

for all unauthorized activities unless:

(1) Civil action to enforce an order

issued pursuant to §326.2 or §326.3(b) of

this part is required;

~- E-94 -

(2) Criminal action is appropriate

(see §326.4(a)(1) of this part);

(3) State local, or other federal

authorization or certification has been

denied or a state or local enforcement

action is pending. In the above

situations, the District Engineer may

accept an after-the-fact permit application

provided he believes it would be in the

public interest and he obtains approval of

the next higher authority.

(ad) If the responsible party fails to

submit an application as noted in paragraph

(c) of this section within a reasonable

time period, the district engineer may

proceed #m his own initiative with a

determination of whether the acti'vity is in

the public interest. The determination

will be made in accordance with appropriate

procedures described in 33 CFR Parts 320

through 325.

§326.4 Legal action.

(a) Criminal or civil action.

District engineers shall be guided by the

following policies in recommending

appropriate legal action:

(1) Criminal action. Criminal action

is considered appropriate when the facts

surrounding an unauthorized activity reveal

the necessity for punitive action and/or

when deterrence of future unauthorized

activities in the area is considered

essential to the establishment or

maintenance of a viable regulatory

program.

(2) Civil action. Civil action is

\

considered appropriate when the evaluation

of the unauthorized activity reveals that

(1) enforcement of an order pursuant to

§326.2 or §326.3(b) of this Part is

required; (11) after the procedures in

§326.3 of this Part have been completed,

unauthorized activity would be in the

public interest if altered or modified but

attempts to secure voluntary alteration or

modification have failed such that a

judicial order is necessary, or (111) after

the procedures in §326.3(c) of this Part

have been completed, a civil penalty under

Section 309 of the Clean Water Act is

warranted.

(c) Referral to local U.S. Attorney.

Except as provided in paragraph (d) of this

section, district engineers are authorized

to refer the following cases to the

Department of Justice (DOJ) in accordance

with procedures established by DOJ.

Information copies of all letters of

referral which go directly to a U.S.

Attorney shall be forwarded to the Chief of

Engineers, ATTN: DAEN-CCK, for transmittal

to the Chief, Pollution Control Section,

Land and Natural Resources Division,

Department of Justice, Washington, D.C.

20530.

- E-97 - i

bk

(1) Unauthorized structures or work

in or affecting navigable waters of the

United States that fall exclusively within

the purview of Section 10 of the River and

Harbor Act of 1899 (see 33 CFR Part 322)

for which a criminal fine or penalty under

Section 12 of that Act (33 U.S.C. 406) is

recommended.

(4) Cases for which a temporary

restraining order and/or preliminary

injunction is appropriate following

non-compliance with a cease and desist

order. °

$326.5 Supervision and enforcement of

authorized activities.

(a) Inspection and monitoring.

District engineers will assure that

authorized activities are conducted and

executed in conformance with approved plans

and other conditions of the permits.

Appropriate inspections should be made on

timely occasions during performance of the

activity and appropriate notices and

instructions given permittees to insure

that they do not depart from the approved

plans. Reevaluation of a permit to assure

compliance with its purposes and conditions

will be carried out as provided in 33 CFR

Part 325.7. If there are approved material

departures from the authorized plans, the

district engineer will require the

permittee to furnish corrected plans

showing the activity as actually

performed.

(b) Non-compliance. Where the

district engineer determines that there has

been non-compliance with the terms or

conditions of a permit, he should first

contact the permittee and attempt to

resolve the problem. If a mutually

agreeable resolution cannot be reached, a

written demand for compliance will be made. f

If the permittee has not agreed to comply j

within 5 days of receipt of the demand, the

district engineer will issue an immediately

effective notice of suspension in

accordance with 33 CFR Part 325.7(c) and

consider initiation of appropriate legal

action (§326.4 of this Part).

(c) Surveillance. For purposes of

inspection of permitted activities and for

surveillance of the waters of the United

States for enforcement of the permit

authorities the district engineer will use

all means at his disposal. All Corps of

Engineers employees will be instructed to

observe and report all unauthorized

activities in waters of the United States.

The assistance of members of the public and

personnel of other interested Federal,

state and local agencies to observe and

report such activities will be encouraged.

To facilitate this surveillance, the

district engineer will, in appropriate

cases, require a copy of ENG Form 4336 to

be posted conspicuously at the site of

authorized activities and will make

available to all interested persons

information on the scope of authorized

activities and the conditions prescribed in

the authorizations. Surveillance in ocean

waters will be accomplished primarily by

the Coast Guard pursuant to Section 107(c)

of the Marine Protection, Research and

Sanctuaries Act of 1972, as amended.

(e) Where the unauthorized activity

is determined not to be in the public

interest, the notification of the denial of

the permit will prescribe any corrective

actions to be taken in connection with the

work already accomplished, including

restoration of those areas subject to

denial, and establish a@ reasonable period

of time for the applicant to complete such

actions. The district engineer, after

denial of the permit, will again consider

whether to recommend civil and/or criminal

action in accordance with §326.4 of this

Part.

(f) If the applicant declines to

accept the proposed permit conditions, or

fails to take corrective action prescribed

in the notification of denial, or if the

district engineer recommends legal action

after denying the permit, the matter will

be referred to the Chief of Engineers,

Attn.: DAEN-CCK, with recommendations for

appropriate action.

(g) Division and District Engineers

are authorized and encouraged to develop '

joint surveillance and inspection

procedures with other Federal, state, and

local agencies with similar regulatory

responsibilities and with other Federal,

state and local agencies having special

interest or expertise in the Corps

regulatory program. However, any decision

to initiate legal action or to require any

restoration or other remedial work under

Corps of Engineers authority remains the *

independent responsibility of the Divison ly

or district engineer.

~

\

APPENDIX E ®

SUBCHAPTER C-AIDS TO NAVIGATION

PART 60-GENERAL

Subpart 60.01-General Provisions

Section 60.01-1 Purpose.

(a) The aids to navigation system of the

United States is for the purpose of aiding

navigation. That part of the system

administered by the Coast Guard is to serve

the needs of the Armed Forces and the

commerce of the United States. This sub-

chapter contains the rules, regulations and

procedures related thereto.

Section 60.01-5 Definition of terms.

Certain terms as used in this subchapter

are defined as follows:

(a) Aid to navigation. The term aid to

navigation or aid, as used in this sub-

chapter, means any device external to a

vessel or aircraft intended to assist a

navigator to determine his position or safe

course, or to warn him of dangers or

obstructions to navigation.

(c) Commerce. The term commerce as used

in this subchapter, in addition to the

general national and international trade and

commerce of the United States, includes trade

and travel by seasonal passenger craft

(marine and air), yachts, houseboats, fishing

boats, motor boats, and other craft whether

or not operated for hire or profit.

(ad) Commandant. The term Commandant

means the Commandant of the Coast Guard.

(e) Corps of Engineers. The term Corps

of Engineers means the Corps of Engineers,

Department of the Army.

(f) District Commander. The term

District Commander means the Commander of a

Coast Guard District.

(g) District Engineer, The term

District Engineer means the District

Engineer, Corps of Engineers, Department of

the Army.

(1) Navigable water. The term navigable

water, singular or plural, means water navi-

gable in faat which by itself, or by uniting

with other waters, navigable in fact, forms a

continuous highway over which interstate or

international commerce may be conducted in

the customary mode of trade and travel on

water.

PART 62-UNITED STATES AIDS TO

NAVIGATION SYSTEM

Subpart 62.01-Establishment of Aids

to Navigation

Section 62.0l1-1 Maritime aids.

(a) The establishment, maintenance and

operation of maritime aids to navigation,

other than loran stations, to serve the needs

of commerce of the United States may be

authorized by the Commandant to mark the

navigable waters of the United States, its

territories and possessions, the Trust

States and, on the high seas, structures

owned or operated by persons subject to the

jurisdiction of the United States;

(2) Sunken vessels in the navigable

waters or waters above the continental shelf

of the United States; and

(3) Other obstructions existing on or in

the navigable waters or waters above the

continental shelf of the United States.

(b) The following obstructions are

exempt from the requirements of this part:

(1) Dredging pipelines subject to Sub-

chapter D of this chapter;

(2) Bridges subject to Subchapter J of

this chapter;

(3) Vessels subject to the International

Regulations for preventing Collisions at Sea,

1972 (1972 COLREGS) or the Inland Navigation

Rules;

(4) Deepwater port facilities subject to

subchapter NN of this chapter; and

Se ee

Territory of the Pacific Islands and those

waters on which aids to navigation have been

established by the Coast guard prior to June

26, 1948.

(c) Any aid to navigation to be

established, maintained and operated by the

Coast Guard to serve the needs of commerce

must be necessary for the safety of

navigation, useful for commerce of a

substantial and permanent character, and must

be justified in terms of public benefit to be

derived therefrom.

Section 62.01-25 Danger, restricted, and

prohibited areas.

The Coast Guard may mark, at the request

of the cognizant District Engineer, danger,

restricted, and prohibited areas that have

been so designated by the Secretary of the

Army.

Subpart 62.15-Reporting Defects

Section 62.15-1 Procedure.

Mariners are requested to notify

immediately the nearest District Commander of

any defects observed in an aid to navigation.

Experienced mariners realize that the Coast

Guard cannot keep the thousands of aids to

navigation comprising the Federal system

under simultaneous and continuous observation

and that, for this reason, it is impossible

to maintain every buoy, day-beacon, light,

fog signal and other aid operating properly

and on its charted position at all times.

Therefore, the safety of the mariner and that

of all persons embarked or serving in vessels

will be enhanced if every person who dis-

covers an aid to be missing, sunk, capsized,

or damaged, or who observes a defect in the

position or characteristic of any aid, will

promptly notify the Coast Guard of the fact.

Radio messages should be prefixed "Coast

a?

Guard” and transmitted directly to one of the

United States Government shore radio stations

listed under "Communication" in Section 400B

of Radio Navigational Aids HO-117 for relay

to the District Commander. If the radio call

sign of the nearest United States Government

radio shore station is not known, radio-

telegraph communication may be established by

the use of the general call "NCG" on the

frequency of 500 kilocycles. Merchant ships

may send messages relating to defects noted

in aids to navigation through commercial

facilities only when they are unable to

contact a United States shore radio station.

Charges for these messages will be accepted

"collect" by the Coast Guard.

Subpart 62. 20-Lights of Fixed

Structures

Section 62.20-1 General.

Lights on fixed structures are aids to

navigation placed on shore or on marine sites

to assist a navigator to determine his

position or safe course, to mark channels and

to warn him of dangers or obstructions to

navigation. They are identified by their

light color and flashing characteristics at

night, and by the color and construction of

the structure during day time. The location,

description and characteristic of lights on

fixed structures are published in the Light

Lists.

PART 64-MARKING OF STRUCTURES,

SUNKEN VESSELS AND OTHER OBSTRUCTIONS

Subpart 64.01-General

Section 64.01-1 Purpose.

This part prescribes rules relating to

the marking of structures, sunken vessels and

other obstructions for the protection of

maritime navigation. :

Section 64.01-3 Scope.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b)

of this section these rules apply to:

(1) Structures located in or over waters

subject to the jurisdiction of the United

(5) Artificial islands and structures °

subject to Part 67 of this subchapter.

Section 64.01-6 Definition of terms.

As used in this part:

"Markings" means the lights and other

signals placed on or near structures, sunken

vessels, and other obstructions for the

protection of navigation.

"Structures" means any fixed or floating

obstruction, intentionally placed in the

water, which may interfere with or restrict

marine navigation.

Subpart 64.10-Sunken Vessels and

Other Obdstructions

Section 64.10-1 Markin ad notification

requirements

(a) The owner of a vessel, raft or other

craft wrecked and sunk in a navigable channel

is required by 33 U.S.C. 409 to mark it

immediately with a buoy or daymark during the

day and with a light at night. The courts

have interpreted the statute very broadly,

a holding that it is not to be applied to

vessels only and that "navigable channel" is

not limited to those channels marked by buoys

or other aids to navigation. Sunken vessels

and other obstructions should be marked when-

ever they constitute a hazard to navigation.

(c) Owners of other obstructions may

report the existence of such obstructions and

mark them in the same manner as prescribed

for sunken vessels.

Section 64.10-3 Approval of markings.

(a) All markings of sunken vessels and

other obstructions established in accordance

with Section 64.10-1 must be reported to and

approved by the appropriate District

Commander.

(b) Should the District Commander

determine that these markings are in-

consistent with Part 62 of this subchapter,

they must be replaced as soon as practicable

with approved markings. .

Section 64.10-6 Duration of marki on

sunken vessels in navigable waters.

Markings shall be maintained until:

(a) The sunken vessel or other

obstruction is removed; or

(b) The right of the owner to abandon is

legally established and exercised.

Subpart 64.20-Structures

Section 64.20-1 Marking and notification

requirements.

Before establishing a structure, the

owner or operator shall apply for Coast Guard

authorization to mark the structure in

accordance with Section 66.01-5 of this

chapter. The appropriate District Commander

will determine the marking requirements.

Section 64.20-3 Duration of marking on

structures.

Marking determined to be required shall

be established and maintained until:

(a) The structure is removed; or

(b) Otherwise directed by the District

Commander.

Subpart 64.30-Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 64.30-1 Determination of marking

necessity.

(a) In determining the necessity of

marking for the protection of maritime

navigation, the District Commander considers,

but is not limited to, the following:

(1) Physical characteristics of the

obstruction;

(2) Depth of water in which it is

located;

(3) Proximity of the obstruction to

historic or designated vessel routes;

(4) Proximity of the obstruction to

other obstructions or aids to navigation; and

(5) Type of vessel traffic at the

,

-

obstruction site.

Section 64.30-3 Marking by the Coast Guard,

(a) The District Commander may mark for

the protection of maritime navigation any ;

structure, sunken vessel or other obstruction

that is not suitably marked by the owne.

United States shall display the lights and

other signals for the protection of maritime

navigation as may be prescribed by the

Commandant. The prescribed lights and

Signals shall be installed, maintained and

operated by and at the expense of the owner,

or operator. After obtaining such approval

or a statement of no objection from the Corps

of Engineers as is required by law, the owner

or operator shall apply in accordance with

Section 66.01-5 to the District Commander

having jurisdiction over the waters in which

the structure or floating obstruction will be

located for a determination of the lights and

other signals to be displayed. This require-

ment includes the temporary lights and

signals to be displayed during the

construction of a structure. If no 3

regulation exists prescribing the lights or R

other signals required to mark any work or

obstruction, each case shail be considered

individually by the District Commander, who ¥

will prescribe such lights and signals as he

considers necessary for the safety of

navigation.

Subpart 66.05-State Aids to

Navigation

Section 66.05-1 Purpose.

(a) The purpose of the regulations in

this subpart and Subpart 66.10 of this part

is to prescribe the conditions under which

State governments may regulate aids to marine

navigation, including regulatory markers,

owned by State or local governments or »

private parties, in navigable waters of the

United States not marked with aids by the

Federal Government; and to prescribe a

uniform system of marine aids to navigation

compatible with the United States lateral

system of buoyage to which all aids to

navigation regulated by a State government

shall conform, except when they conform to

the lateral system. The United States

lateral system is described in Part 62 of

this subchapter.

Section 66.05-5 Definition of terms used in

this subpart and Subpart 66.10.

(a) The term "State waters for private

aids to navigation" means those navigable

waters of the United States which the

Commandant, upon request of a State

Administrator, has designated as waters

within which a State government may regulate

the establishment, operation, and maintenance

of marine aids to navigation, including

regulatory markers. The Commandant will

entertain requests to make such designations

with respect to navigable waters of the

United States not marked by the Federal

government. These designations when approved

will be set forth in separate sections by

States in this subpart and will briefly

describe or identify waters so designated.

(b) The term "Uniform State Waterway .

Marking System" (USWMS) means the system of

private aids to naviagtion, including

regulatory markers, which may be operated in

State waters for private aids to navigation.

Subpart 66.10 of this part describes the

Uniform State Waterway Marking System.

(c) The term "State Administrator" means

the official of a State having power under

the law of the State to regulate, establish,

operate or maintain maritime aids to bs

navigation on waters over which the State has

jurisdiction.

(d) The term "State aids to navigation"

means all private marine aids to navigation

operated in State waters for private aids to

navigation, whether owned by a State,

political subdivisions thereof or by

individuals, corporations, or organizations.

(e) The term "regulate State maritime

aids to navigation" means to control the

ar De a os

establishment, disestablishment, operation

and maintenance of State aids to navigation.

Section 66.05-10 State waters for private

aids to navigation; gnations; revisions,

and revocations.

(a) A State Administrator who desires to

regulate State maritime aids to navigation in

the navigable waters of the United States not

marked by the Federal Government, shall

request the Commandant to designate the

specific bodies of water involved as State

waters for private aids to navigation.

(bd) The request shall be forwarded to

the District Commander in whose district the

bodies of water are located. The request

shall give the name and description of the

waterway; the extent of use being made of the

waterway for marine navigation, in general

terms; an appropriate chart or sketch of the

area; and a general outline of the nature and

extent of the State aids to navigation which

Markings established by the Coast Guard do

not relieve the owner's duty or respon-

sibility to mark the sunken vessel or other

obstruction, or to remove it as required by

law.

(b) Costs for markings established by

the Coast Guard will be determined in

accordance with Part 74 of this Chapter.

(c) Costs for marking of a sunken vessel

or other obstruction shall be charged to the

owner and shall continue until:

(1) The vessel or other obstruction is

removed;

(2) The right of the owner to abandon is

legally established and has been exercised;

or

(3) The District Commander directs

otherwise.

Section 66.01-35 Marking of structures and

floating obstructions.

Any structure, mooring, mooring buoy, or

dam, in or over the navigable waters of the

the Administrator plans to establish in the

waterway.

(c) The District Commander shall review

the request and consult with the State

Administrator concerning the terms of an

initial agreement to be entered into under

provisions of Section 66.05-20. When they

have arrived at terms of an agreement

satisfactory to both, the District Commander

shall forward the request to the Commandant

with his recommendations and the terms of

agreement mutually settled upon. If they

cannot reach such agreement, the District

Commander shall forward the request with his

recommendations and a statement of the points

agreed upon and the points remaining at

issue.

(d) Upon receipt of the request, the

Commandant will determine whether or not

approval of the request is in the public

interest and will inform the State

_

Administrator and the Distric. Commander of

the Coast Guard's decision. If the request

is approved, the designation by the

Commandant of the waters in question as State

waters for private aids to navigation will be

also defined and described in this subpart.

(e) The Commandant may, upon his own

initiative or upon request, revoke or revise

any Cesignations of State waters for private

aids to navigation previously made by him.

Written notice shall be given the State

Administrator of the action contemplated by

the Commandant. e State Administrator will

be afforded a piwivd of not less than 30 days

from the date of the notice in which to

inform the Commandant of the State's views in

the matter before final action is completed

to revoke or revise such designation.

Section 66.05-20 Coast Guard-State

agreements.

(a) The District Commander in whose

District a waterway is located may enter into

agreements with State Administrators

permitting a State to regulate aids to

navigation, including regulatory markers, in

State waters for private aids to navigation,

as, in the opinion of the District Commander,

the State is able to do in a manner to

improve the safety of navigation. When a

waterway is located within the area of

jurisdiction of more than one Coast Guard

District, the District Commander in whose

District the State capital is located shall

execute the agreement in behalf of the Coast

Guard. All such agreements shall reserve to

the District Commander the right to inspect

the state aids to navigation at any time

without prior notice to the State. They

shall stipulate that State aids to navigation

will conform to the Uniform State Waterway

Marking System or to the lateral system

buoyage and that the State Administrator will

modify or remove State aids to navigation

without expense to the United States when so

directed by the District Commander, subject

to the right of appeal on the part of the

State Administrator to the Commandant.

(b) A Coast Guard-State agreement shall

become effective when both parties have

signed the agreements. In lieu of the

procedure prescribed in Section 66.01-5, the

agreement shall constitute blanket approval

by the Commandant of the State aids to

navigation, including regulatory markers,

established or to be established in State

waters for private aids to navigation

designated or to be designated by the

Commandant.

(c) In addition to the matters set farth

in paragraph (a) of this section, Coast

Guard-State agreements shall cover the

following points, together with such other

matters as the parties find it desirable to

include:

(1) A description, in sufficient detail

for publication in Notices to Mariners, of

all aids to navigation under State

jurisdiction in navigable waters of the

United States in existence prior to the

effective date of the agreement which have

not been previously approved under the

procedures of Section 66.01-5.

(2) Procedures for use by the State

Administrator to notify the District

Commander of changes made in State aids to

navigation, as required by Section 66.05-25.

(3) Specification of the marking system

to be used, whether the lateral system or the

Uniform State Waterway Marking System, or

both.

(4) Specification of standards as to

minimum size and shape of markers, the use of

identifying letters, the use of reflectors or

retroreflective materials, and any other

Similar standards so as to enable Coast Guard

inspectors to determine compliance with

Statewide standards.

Section 66.05-25 Change modification of

State aids to navigation.

(a) Wherever a State Adminstrator shall

determine the need for change in State aids

to navigation, he shall inform the District

Commander of the nature and extent of the

changes as soon as possible, preferably not

less than 30 days in advance of making the

changes.

Section 66.05-35 Private aids to navigation

other than State owned.

(a) No person, public body or other

instrumentality not under control of the

Commandant cr the State Administrator,

exclusive of the Armed Forces of the United

States, shall establish, erect or maintain in

State waters for private aids to navigation

any aid to navigation without first obtaining

permission to do so from the State Admin-

istrator. Discontinuance of any State aids

to navigation may be effected by order of the

State Administrator.

Secton 66.05-40 Corps of Engineers'

approval.

(a) In each instance where a regulatory

marker is to be established in navigable

waters of the United States which have been

designated by the Commandant as State waters

for private aids to navigation, the State

Administrator is responsible for obtaining

prior permission from the District Engineer,

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers concerned,

authorizing the State to regulate the water

area involved, or a statement that there is

no objection to the proposed regulation of

the water area. A copy of the Corps of

Engineers permit or letter of authority shall

be provided by the Administrator to the

District Commander upon request.

(b) Similarly, where an aid to

navigation is to be placed on a fixed

structure or a mooring buoy is to be

established in State waters for private aids

to navigation, the State Administrator shall

assure that prior permission or a statement

of no objection to the structures or mooring

buoys proposed is obtained from the District

Engineer concerned. A copy of the permit or

letter is not required by the District

Commander.

i = + -_ _—_-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.