Amicus Curiae Brief — Children's Legal Foundation, Inc. v. Action for Children's Television

Supreme Court brief1992

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Suprema Court, U.S,

FILED

No. 91-952

In The

ee eee ee

Supreme Court of the United States

October Term, 1991

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION,

Petitioner,

VS.

ACTION FOR CHILDREN'S TELEVISION, et al.,

Respondents.

ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE

NATIONAL FAMILY LEGAL FOUNDATION

IN SUPPORT OF THE PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

LEN L. MUNSIL

5353 North 16th Street

Suite 400

Phoenix, Arizona 85016

(602) 265-1513

Counsel of Record

Amicus Curiae

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ro

CASES Pages

Action for Children’s Television v. Federal

Communications Commission ("A.C.T. I"),

ee ee Ee CE, BOER ccc cc eee 10, 11

Butler v. Michigan,

CN ae 15

Federal Communications Commission v. Pacifica,

CN PEO, gg se cc cee ecaveeecees 7. ™

10, 14, 15

Sable Communications v. Federal Communications

Commission,

DE A RU, ov cee ee ce eesees 10, 13

STATUTES

Oo Se ee 6, 10

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE

BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE

National Family Legal Foundation respectfully

moves for leave to file the attached brief amicus curiae.

Counsel of record for Petitioner and Respondents have

consented in writing to the filing of this brief.

Respectfully submitted,

LZ tmTS

LEN L. MUNSIL

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

5353 North 16th Street

Suite 400

Phoenix, Arizona 85016

(602) 265-1513

1ii

INTEREST OF THE AMICUS CURIAE

National Family Legal Foundation is a nonprofit,

public interest corporation that seeks to preserve the

integrity of families and the innocence of children by

promoting a healthy and safe environment, free from

pornography and the sexual crimes which invariably

accompany its widespread availability. NFLF provides

legal assistance to individuals, organizations, prosecutors

and other public officials concerned about the harmful

impact of pornography on the quality of life.

NFLF founder Alan E. Sears was the Executive

Director of the Attorney General's Commission on

Pornography. In its 1986 Final Report, the Commission

discussed the harms caused by the proliferation of sexual

images in our society, and warned against the dangers of

exposing children and unconsenting adults to pornography.

Mr. Sears and the Foundation have been active in urging the

_ 1 -

a

i :

Federal Communications Commission to enforce its

prohibition of indecent broadcasts. Former Attorney

General Edwin Meese III, who presented the 1986

Commission report, continues to support enforcing

constitutional laws restricting various forms of pomography

by serving as an active member of the Board of Directors

for amicus National Family Legal Foundation.

NFLF is concerned that the decision of the D.C.

Circuit mandating that certain hours of the day be reserved

for indecent broadcasts will significantly increase the

exposure of children and unconsenting adults to offensive

pornography and profanity. NFLF believes strongly that the

decision is inconsistent with prior Supreme Court indecency

cases, and is not required by the First Amendment to the

United States Constitution. NFLF hopes that broadcast TV

and radio airwaves will remain clean, and therefore

accessible and available to families and children, as they

have been since the Golden Age of broadcasting.

INTRODUCTION

If the decision of the United States Court of Appeals

for the District of Columbia Circuit stands, American TV

and radio broadcasts will never be the same. For more than

60 years, this simple limitation has been known and

accepted —— you don't talk dirty on radio and broadcast

television. You can talk dirty on the street comer, in the

locker room, in the movies, on record albums, and lately,

even on the telephone and cable TV. But Americans have

always known they could tum on the television in their

living room with the children present, or flip the radio dial

in the family car, without fear of being assaulted by a

stream of expletives fit for a roomful of sailors. Now we

are told by the D.C. Circuit that a decent family's final

media refuge is required by our laws and the Constitution to

permit "patently offensive depictions or descriptions of sex

ee ee

’ a — i " ’ : fis 7

an a an 4 ee.

| ae > _ : : 7; 7 7

» an a 7 4,

mt 7 7 =) 7 ; rn

an) io ’

: - 2, A oT"

7 “wins>

- ~ - = bd sa

+ ak

as J ot ;

7 SS _

— 7 Fs. roe

. -; Pht = Pa 7 ae"

a a we ~ ~~ : a_i

ra | a

= is.

iN a

7 _ 7

_ ae

7 he

‘ a

=

7 -

llieteeet

7

;

a

4

a

4

or excretory functions” during certain hours of the day. In

the age of trash television, where it seems every program

(even the news) is designed to titillate, shock or repulse, can

we doubt that broadcasts featuring full nudity of both sexes,

scenes of simulated sexual intercourse complete with

moaning and heavy breathing, bathroom humor, and use of

“bullsh-—" and "fu-—", will soon be commonplace? If the

FCC can draw the line only at obscenity during some time

periods, is there any doubt that TV and radio executives will

push right up to the edge of illegal hard-core pornography

in search of higher ratings? Is this where public, family—

oriented television and radio ends?

The Supreme Court should hear this case and reverse

the D.C. Circuit in order to preserve broadcast television

and radio as media that are available to all Americans. If

television and radio continue their slide into grotesque and

offensive depravity, unchecked by any sense of community

standards and ignoring the consensus developed over many

years as to what is appropriate to be seen and heard on the

public airwaves, concerned and responsible American

families will have to make a choice: Do we allow

ourselves to be assaulted in our own homes every night by

graphic sex, profanity and violence, or must we turn the TV

and radio off and completely give up America’s primary

forms of entertainment, and also our main sources for news,

information and ideas from around the country and sia

acund the world? Either way, the families of America

lose.

ARGUMENT

American society has suffered a serious decline in

civility over the past several decades. Common courtesy

and decency seem to be relics of a previous generation.

This decline can be seen in everything from minor traffic

altercations that end with gunfire, to profane bumper

stickers, to stadiums full of sports fans shouting vulgar

slogans inwinison at the officials. It is not so much that the

rules of civilized conduct have changed, as it is that many

members of society seem unwilling to acknowledge that any

such rules exist.

There is at least one place where such rules have

always existed, and that is the publicly owned radio and

television broadcast airwaves. Title 18 U.S.C. § 1464

provides that “Whoever utters any obscene, indecent or

profane language by means of radio communications shall

be fined not more than $10,000 or imprisoned not more than

two years, or both." This prohibition against obscene,

indecent or profane language originally appeared in the

Radio Act of 1927, and has been part of federal law ever

since. The language is straightforward, with no suggestion

that indecent or profane speech over the airwaves is

acceptable at certain hours of the day.

In Federal Communications Commission v. Pacifica,

438 U.S. 726 (1978), this Court upheld the FCC's authority

to sanction a radio station for broadcasting many of the

same profane words now heard regularly on broadcast

television, as is documented in the appendices to this brief.

Of course, the free speech absolutists argued then that we

would never be where we are now, but this Court knew

better: “We are assured by Pacifica that the free play of

market forces will discourage indecent programming ... the

prosperity of those who traffic in pornographic literature

and films would appear to justify skepticism." 438 U.S.

744, n.19. Indeed.

The TV networks, and the ACLU and its front

groups’ will probably argue now that prime-time nudity

and soft-core pornography are not the wave of the future.

But already TV and radio stations are taking advantage of

confusion in this area of the law. That confusion is

exacerbated by judicial decisions such as the one on appeal

here, decisions which refuse to take account of the rationale

behind Pacifica. Television and radio stations have

shattered one taboo after another in their search for higher

ratings. We have assembled only a few examples in our

appendices, but a quick glance indicates how far indecency

has come in the last few years.

No one seriously argues that the government does

“Action for Children's Television" sounds better on the

front end of a lawsuit than "the American Civil Liberties

Union", but we have some difficulty understanding what

interest children have in making patently offensive

depictions of sex or excretory functions available to adults

on television. Or perhaps they want children to have access

to indecent programming?

not have a compelling interest in protecting children from

indecent broadcasts. In an age where teen pregnancy and

sexually transmitted diseases are at epidemic proportions,

does it really make sense to show unedited in prime time an

R-rated movie like "Private Lessons,” (See Appendix "B"),

in which an actress who formerly starred in a series of

pornographic films spends most of the movie nude in front

of the camera as she pursues a sexual relationship with a

15-year-old boy? Does it make sense to allow moming

radio show hosts to entertain children preparing for school

with discussions of masturbation, orgasm and penis jokes?

(See Appendices "D" — "G") Does it make sense to allow

PBS to broadcast nationally a documentary by black

homosexuals that contains nudity and frequent uses of

various permutations of the "F—word"? (See Appendix "A”)

Of course not. And this Court has always

recognized that the state's interest in protecting children

from this type of material is compelling. Pacifica, 438 U.S.

749-50; Sable Communications v. Federal Communications

Commission, 106 L.Ed.2d 93, 105 (1989). Nor can there be

any real question that the types of broadcasts now occurring

are "indecent" within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 1464.

Pacifica, 438 U.S. 741, n.16 (nudity and "4—letter words"

may be protected speech and not obscene, but their

broadcast might still violate the statute). So the question is

whether the means of restricting the exposure of children

and unconsenting adults is "narrowly drawn" to effectuate

the state's compelling purpose "without unnecessarily

interfering with First Amendment freedoms." Sable, 106

L.Ed.2d at 105. The D.C. Circuit, without even discussing

the evidence compiled by the FCC, held that banning the

broadcast of indecent material was not a sufficiently narrow

approach to survive First Amendment scrutiny. The court,

relying on its previous decision in Action for Children’s

Television v. Federal Communications Commission ("A.C.T.

10

I”), 852 F.2d 1332 (D.C.Cir. 1988), summarily concluded

that its holding "that the Commission must identify some

reasonable period of time during which indecent material

may be broadcast necessarily means that the Commission

may not ban such broadcasts entirely." But the evidence

shows that a 24—hour prohibition on indecent broadcasts is

the only means by which significant numbers of children and

unconsenting adults can be protected from indecent, patently

offensive broadcasts.

In its August 6, 1990 report, which was not available

to the panel that decided the "A.C.T. /” case, the FCC

examined the evidence regarding TV viewing and radio

listening habits for teenagers. The FCC determined that

"there is a reasonable risk that significant numbers of

children are in the audience for radio and television

broadcasts at all times of the day and night." (§ 65).

Regarding radio listening, evidence before the FCC

indicated that "in all time frames measured, a higher

11

percentage of all children between the ages of 12 and 17

listen to radio than the percentage of all adults age 18 and

over, even between midnight and 6 a.m.", and estimated that

716,000 teenagers were listening during any time period

between midnight and 6 a.m. (/d.) Regarding television

viewing, the FCC stated in | 66:

[A]vailable data show that children, particularly

those between the ages of 12 and 17, are in the

viewing audience until the last time period reported

for television ratings. The data further show that as

high a percentage of children ages 12 to 17 as adults

watch television during the iate evening hours.

Indeed, for the 1:45 to 2:00 a.m. time period, one

commenter has estimated that there are over 970,000

12 to 17 year olds in the television audience. These

figures, of course, do not take into consideration the

number, of children who may be using VCRs

between midnight to 6 a.m. to record television

programs for viewing at a later time.

If the concerns for children articulated in Pacifica

and Sable are to be taken seriously, then the FCC clearly

has made the case that a complete prohibition of broadcast

indecency is the most narrowly tailored means of achieving

the government's compelling interest. In Sable, this Court

12

invalidated the ban on indecent telephone messages for one

reason —— there was no evidence to support the assertion

that less restrictive means of limiting children's access

would be unsuccessful:

For all we know from this record, the FCC's

technological approach to restricting dial—a—

porn messages to adults who seek them

would be extremely effective, and only a few

of the most enterprising and disobedient

young people will manage to secure access

to such messages. If this is the case, it

seems to us that section 223(b) is not a

narrowly tailored effort to serve the

compelling interest of preventing minors

from being exposed to indecent telephone

messages.

106 L.Ed.2d at 108.

The FCC's conclusion that nearly 1.7 million

teenagers watch or listen to television or radio broadcasts

during any so-called "safe harbor" time period —— whether

it starts at 8 p.m., 10 p.m. or midnight —— proves only that

13

TT RE Revennmer

the D.C. Circuit's "safe harbor" is a mirage.’ Surely this

Court does not consider 1.7 million teenagers to be "only a

few of the most enterprising and disobedient young people"?

But that will be the result if this Court allows the D.C.

Circuit's decision to stand. More than a million

impressionable teenagers and preteens will be exposed each

night to soft-core pomography, vulgarity and profanity.

The D.C. Circuit violates this Court's precedent in

one other significant way. The decision departs from the

Pacifica rationale for limiting indecent broadcasts by

completely ignoring the interests of unconsenting adults.

Pacifica clearly relied on the right of adults to be free from

patently offensive broadcasts while flipping the radio or TV

The FCC also received comments from The Pacifica

Foundation, et al., which included a brief appendix that, if

we read it correctly, shows Arbitron's percentages of

children in the public radio audience at various times.

Rather than refuting the FCC's numbers, the Arbitron

figures, which do not reflect the majority of children who

listen to commercial broadcasts, seem only to prove that no

one listens to public radio.

14

dial (or today, the remote control.) Obviously a "safe

harbor" for children, even if it were to exist, would be

unsafe for unconsenting adults. Apparently the D.C. Circuit

believes "the remedy for an assault is to run away after the

first blow." Pacifica, 438 U.S. at 749.

Are there available alternative means for spreading

indecent recorded and videotaped messages? The better

question is, what other mediuiii does not have indecent

messages? As this Court noted in Pacifica, those seeking

indecency "may purchase tapes and records or go to theaters

and nightclubs to hear these words.” 438 U.S. at 750, n.28.

Video indecency is available on cable or at the

neighborhood video store, in adult bookstores, and in movie

theaters; spoken or recorded indecency can still be found at

the local record store or nightclub, or on the telephone.

There is no serious argument that a limitation on broadcast

indecency will reduce adults to hearing only what is fit for

children. Butler v. Michigan, 352 U.S. 380, 383 (1957).

15

CONCLUSION

Profanity, vulgarity and nudity have existed for

hundreds of years, and obviously were around at the birth of

radio and television. Yet we have lived in America for

decades without allowing patently offensive broadcasts over

the public airwaves. Despite the cries of censorship from

those who brought this lawsuit, did free speech really suffer

for all those years just because you couldn't say

"motherf—-——er" on the radio, .or show a striptease in place

of the Sunday night movie? The forces of incivility,

rudeness, and offensiveness have soiled virtually ever corner

of society ——- can we not leave the public airwaves to

decent men and women and families, who are trying despite

the odds to raise responsible young citizens in an indecent

world? Congress thought so, and this Court's prior cases

say so. Only allowing the FCC to prohibit indecent

16

broadcasts around the clock will settle this area of law and

prevent court challenges to the FCC's enforcement decisions

from recurring. For the sake of America’s families, the

National Family Legal Foundation urges this Court to grant

certiorari and reverse the decision of the D.C. Circuit.

Respectfully submitted,

to LPs}

LEN L. MUNSIL sal

5353 North 16th Street

Suite 400

Phoenix, Arizona 85016

(602) 265-1513

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

17

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that three copies of the foregoing

Brief of Amicus Curiae National Family Legal Foundation

have been sent by U.S. Mail, Postage Prepaid, on this 15th

day of January, 1992, to:

Timothy B. Dyk, Esq.

Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue

1450 G. Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20005-2088

John G. Roberts, Esq.

Office of the Solicitor General

U.S. Department of Justice

Washington, D.C. 20530

All Parties required to be served have been served.

Af mS)

Len L. Munsil

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

18

Appendix "A"

"TONGUES UNTIED"

These transcripts are taken from a recording of

Tongues Untied, which aired on KAET-TV in Phoenix,

Arizona on Saturday, July 20, 1991, at 11:30 p.m. This

controversial hour-long documentary by and about black

male homosexuals was broadcast nationally over numerous

PBS affiliates on a Saturday night during the summer, when

there were unquestionably significant numbers of minors in

the audience.

Tongues Untied opens with a naked man jumping

and dancing in front of the camera. On several occasions,

his genitals are briefly exposed. Later, two graphic and

lifelike cartoons depict naked men with erect penises. One

of the cartoon men is ejaculating, and ejaculate drips from

his body. The program is filled with profanity, including

frequent use of words considered indecent in F.C.C. v.

Pacifica. There are 29 uses of "fuck," "fucked," "fucking"

or "motherfucking;" 11 uses of "faggot," 3 uses of "shit,"

one reference to "ass," one reference to "dick" (meaning

penis), and one use of "cum" (meaning ejaculate). That

means one of these words was used, on average, nearly

every minute of the program.

The following are transcriptions of two brief

portions of the broadcast:

(Man narrates story of bus ride.)

I was riding on the S—2 headed to Silver Spring.

The bus, for most of the ride, had been filled with

A-1

the quiet murmur of the other passengers. Suddenly

from the back of the bus a voice rose and wailed

"You my bitch." "No, uh,uh, we are bitches." I

turned around to look at the back of the bus. There

were two brothers going at it. "No, you listen here,

I ain't wearing lipstick, you are." "I ain't no bitch,

I fucked you, you my bitch." This continued

without resolution until we arrived at 16th and U

street. The bus is packed with passengers by now.

As we approach the stop, I see ten more waiting to

step aboard. Just as the first person steps aboard a

strident, hysterical voice shouts from the back, "I'm

a forty—five—year—old black gay man who enjoys

taking dick in his rectum. I'm not your bitch, your

bitch is at home taking care of your kids."

(Man describes his difficult upbringing.)

Man:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

I heard my calling by age six. We hada

word for boys like me.

Punk!

Punk. Not because I played sex with other

boys. Everybody on the block did that.

Punk!

But because I didn't mind giving it away.

Now other boys traded: "You can have my

boody if you give me yours..." "Hmh,

mmmmh —— b—but wait a minute now. If I

A-2

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Voice:

go first...". "Hmh, mmmmh, you went first

last time." "B—but I want to be the daddy...”.

"Y—you the daddy all the time...". "B-—but

I want to be the daddy...". "I'm the daddy —

-mmmm, mmmm. Mmmm, mmmm.” Not

me, I gave it up for free.

Punk!

At age 11, we moved to Georgia. I

graduated to new knowledge.

Homo!

You don't know how to kiss...

Homo!

my best friend asked? Shocked. I didn't

know what to do with a girl when ! lost at

spin—the—bottle.

Homo!

"Tll show you," he said, his brown eyes

inviting. We practiced kissing for weeks -

dry, wet, french — until his older brother

called usaname. ~

Homo!

"What's a Homo?" I asked.

Punk! Faggot! Freak!

A-3

Man:

Voice:

Voice:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

Voice:

Man:

I understood. We stopped kissing. Best

friend became Worst enemy.

Motherfucking coon!

Age 12 they bussed me to Hepseba High on

the outskirts of Augusta.

Motherfucking coon!

A spray painted sign on the wall greeted me.

Niggers, go home!

The Rednecks hated me.

Motherfucking coon!

Because I was one of only two blacks placed

in AA. The class for Hepseba's best and

brightest.

Niggers, go home!

The blacks hated me.

Uncle Tom!

Because they assumed my class status made

me uppity.

Uncle Tom!

Assumed my silence as superiority.

A-4

Uncle Tom!

I was shy.

Motherfucking coon!

Uncle Tom!

I was confused.

Motherfucking coon!

Uncle Tom!

Niggers, go home!

I was afraid and alone.

Motherfucking coon!

Uncle Tom!

Punk! Faggot! Freak!

Niggers, go home!

Homo!

Punk!

Motherfucking coon!

Uncle Tom!

Punk! Faggot! Freak!

A-5

Voice: Homo!

Voice: Niggers, go home!

Man: Comered by identities I never wanted to

claim. I ran, fast, hard. Deep inside myself

where it is still, silent, safe. Deception.

A-6

Appendix "B"

"PRIVATE LESSONS"

Shown unedited on KZKC, an independent television

station, in Kansas City, Missouri on August 28, 1987, at

8:00 p.m. This "R"—rated movie is about a chauffeur and

a beautiful young housekeeper (HS) who try to blackmail

the 15-year-old son (Philly) of their wealthy employer.

The housekeeper, played by a former pomographic movie

star, seduces the child and fakes her death during sex with

the boy. The chauffeur and housekeeper extort $10,000

from the child while his father is away on business to keep

the death of the housekeeper quiet. The following are

transcripts and descriptions of some of the movie's most

offensive scenes:

HS: Philly, if you want to watch me undress so

badly, you should have told me.

Philly: What do you mean?

HS: Well, do you want to watch me undress?

Philly: Well, uhm, sure. I guess so.

HS: Go close the door.

Philly: What?

HS: i said "Close the door."

Philly: I'm not sure I got you right. Did you want

me in or out?

HS: Well, did you want to watch me undress?

B-1

HS Then in

Philly closes door...

HS: Have a seat.

Philly walks over to chair across from bed where

housekeeper is sitting and sits — smiling.

HS: Ready?

Housekeeper begins seductively undressing, first removing

her slip, then her garter belt and hose.

HS: You still with me Philly?

Philly: (gulping) Pardon?

HS: Do you still want me to continue?

Philly: (smiling and gulping) Y-Yea! Yes, please.

HS: Not growing bored? Are you sure?

Philly: Oh! Yes!

Housekeeper slowly removes bra, covering first breast with

hand, then showing second and then both. Philly is in

shock. Camera remains focused on topless housekeeper.

HS: What do you think?

Philly: (gasping) Uh?

B-2

HS:

Philly:

My breasts! How do you like them?

Oh, Nice. Very nice.

Housekeeper walks over to Philly, practically placing her

breasts in his face. During most of this scene, the

housekeeper's breasts are the camera's main focus.

HS:

Philly:

HS:

Philly:

HS:

Philly:

Well, would you like to touch them?

Touch them?

Yes.

(scene shows side view of one breast and

Philly's face) No, n—not right now. Thank

you.

Are you sure?

Uh, uh yea. Uhm, maybe later.

Good. But you still want me to continue

then?

(sighing) Yes, please.

Housekeeper slowly walks back to resume undressing and

throws Philly her bra. Smiling, he doesn't know what to do

with it, so he hangs it on sewing machine. She begins

removing her panties. Scenes go back and forth showing

her slowly removing panties and him smiling awkwardly.

Housekeeper turns around to remove panties, completely

exposing nude buttocks, and then turns around again with

only her panties in front and then offers Philly her panties.

B-3

He gets nervous and begins to leave. The camera continues

to focus on her bare buttocks, with Philly visible behind her.

Philly:

HS:

Philly:

HS:

Philly:

HS:

Philly:

I-I-I think I-I'd better go now.

So soon? You won't stay?

N-no, I'm sorry. I-I don't think so.

What a pity. All right. Well, good night

Philly.

Good night a-and thank you, I really

enjoyed it.

No, thank you. We should do this again

some time.

Yea, thank you.

As Philly tries to leave, he turns around and runs into door.

a * ”

The Housekeeper has invited Philly to her room. Scene

opens with Housekeeper taking a bubble bath. Her breasts

can be seen through the bubbles during the entire scene.

HS:

Philly:

Come in.

Hi, uhm, I looked for you in your room and

you weren't there. You said you wanted to

talk to me.

{———

“—e

ee

———

—e

=m

r

HS:

Phill Y:

HS:

Come in, Philly, come in

Uh, what are you doing in my father’s

bathtub?

Oh, I don't think he would've minded my

using his plumbing. Do you?

No, no, I guess not.

Would you like to wash my back?

Well... (Philly walks over to bathtub and

bends down and washes her back — smiling.

She moves his hand so that he's caressing her

breast.)

Would you like to join me?

Would I like to what?

Take a bath with me?

You mean in there with you? Right now?

Mmmm, mmm. Why don't you try it?

Maybe you'd like it.

Well—uh, I probably wouldn't even fit in

there.

Oh, yes you would. I promise.

You mean you want me to take off all my

clothes and everything?

B-5

HS: Do you usually wear them when you take a

bath?

Philly: No, not usually.

HS: Oh, come on Philly, I won't even look.

Philly: I-I don't know.

HS: Oh, come on. It'll be an adventure.

Philly: Oh-oh all right.

Philly gets up to leave...

HS: Hey, where are you going?

Philly: To get undressed.

Philly returns in bathrobe...

HS: Well, hello.

Philly: Hi.

HS: Don't you want to take off your robe and

join me?

Philly: O.K., just a sec.

Philly removes robe, revealing that he's wearing bathing suit.

HS: Bathing trunks? (laughing) That's marvelous.

Won't you take them off?

B-6

,

Philly: No.

HS: Well, all right then. Come in the bath with

your bathing trunks.

Philly stumbles into tub.

HS: Be careful, be careful.

Philly sits in front of the housekeeper and she washes his

back and then moves her hands to his front.

HS: How does that feel?

She kisses him on the cheek, then again. He turns around

to kiss her lightly on the lips.

HS: Are you sure you don't want to take them

off?

Philly: O.K. Under one condition.

HS: What's that.

Philly: That we put out the lights.

HS: It's a deal.

Philly gets up to turn out the lights. The housekeeper’s

breasts again are fully exposed. He returms to bathtub.

Somehow Philly's bathing trunks are removed. She caresses

him and moves her hands toward his genitals. Philly gasps,

jumps out of the tub (naked, nude buttocks showing) and

grabs his robe, trying to put it on.

B-7

Philly: I-I think I'd better go now.

HS: Philly, wait a second. Wait a second, will

you?

Philly: What?

HS: I'm sorry. Will you forgive me?

Philly: O.K.

HS: Prove it.

Philly: How?

HS: By sleeping with me tonight.

Philly: No.

HS: Philly! Why not?

Philly: Well, I've tried it once before in summer

camp and I know for a fact that you can't get

a good night's sleep if someone is in the

same bunk with you. Well, thank you. It's

been a lovely evening.

HS: Philly. Just to show there's no hard feelings,

would you kiss me goodnight?

Philly: O.K.

Philly gives her a little kiss.

HS: Is it all right if I kiss you good night?

B-8

Philly: I guess so.

She gives him a long, deep kiss. Kissing down his neck,

caressing his shoulder. He runs away.

* * *

Philly and housekeeper enter bedroom. They talk briefly,

then begin kissing and undressing each other. First, her

blouse is lowered, revealing her breasts. After she takes his

shirt off, the camera focuses on her breasts. Her nipples are

clearly erect. She slowly loosens his belt and unzips his

pants, then runs her hands up his bare chest. As she walks

to the bed, the camera lingers on her naked buttocks. They

get into bed. Both are naked. They caress and massage

each other, then he rolls on top. She is breathing heavily.

Shadows show them moving back and forth in sexual

intercourse. She begins to moan and gasp in sexual

excitement. One final, loud gasp signals climax, and then

she pretends to have died. She lies-on the bed with both

breasts exposed for several moments as a panicked Philly

and the chauffeur discuss what to do.

* & -

In the last scene, the housekeeper is telling Philly goodbye.

They kiss on the bed. She removes her blouse, and is

topless in front of the camera. They kiss, and he removes

his shirt. They kiss passionately. The camera focuses on

her breasts. Her nipples are erect as Philly runs his hands

over them. She takes Philly's hand and places it on the top

of her panties. He pulls her panties off, and she is

completely nude. He runs his hands over her bare buttocks

and down her leg. He rubs her midriff, then her upper

B-9

nak ee a nrrmaaallls

thighs. She is on her back, naked. She rolls over and kisses

him, then gets on top of him and rocks back and forth, with

her breasts bouncing on his bare chest. His face is shown

as he experiences sexual pleasure. Then she is shown on

top, breathing heavily and thrusting. She closes her eyes

and moans, presumably in orgasm. The scene closes with

them asleep in bed together. This sex scene lasts several

minutes.

B-10

Appendix "C"

on re ey

MO POOR. a BN

psi

"ONE TRICK PONY"

Shown unedited on the PBS affiliate in Phoenix, Arizona on

Thanksgiving night, November 28, 1991 beginning at 11

p.m. Because Friday, November 29 was a state holiday,

there was an increased likelihood that children were in the

audience. The film, rated "R", follows the career struggles

of a musician named Jonah, played by Paul Simon. There

are about a dozen uses of the F—word, and several uses of

the other "dirty" words listed by George Carlin, in his

famous monologue, such as "bullshit" and "pussy" referring

to a female's private area. In one early scene, Jonah and a

female he just met sit and engage in a lengthy discussion in

a bathtub. Both are naked, and the woman's breasts are

uncovered and visible throughout the conversation.

In a later scene, Walter, the record company executive,

confronts Jonah as he leaves Walter's office.

Walter: Jonah, you wouldn't by any chance be

fucking my wife? Because that wouldn't be

conducive to a good artist-record company

relationship.

Next scene, Jonah and Walters wife are in bed, naked,

although covered by a sheet at the beginning of the scene.

Jonah: What was I going to say, "Yes Walter, I am

sort of fucking your wife"?

Walter's wife: Is that what we're doing, sort of fucking?

t

a a a

ot

erie? a 4. oe

- = or

* it

‘e

———

—.

ss * mi

te (a Se

i

7

a 7

ir

Jonah and Walter's wife continue talking. She gets up out

of bed, completely naked, then walks across the room nude.

As the two continue talking and getting dressed, her breasts

are completely exposed.

Appendix "D"

—

THE HOWARD STERN SHOW

Partial transcript from a broadcast on radio station WXRK-

FM, New York, New York, on December 16, 1988,

between 6:00 — 10:00 a.m.

Here's a guy who plays the piano with his penis. [I'll tell

you. What a weird crew.

She doesn't give me anything as far as jewelry is concerned.

That's because you don't have a penis.

I think it will be worth the whole show just to hear her have

an orgasm when I rub my ear.

I understand the doctor (hypnotist) explained that you would

not go for that orgasm thing. Like, in other words, that you

would not accept it... Boy, you must be difficult in bed.

He says he'll hypnotize Bo the Lesbian...and she's a good

subject. She's an empty slate.

Bo, you look great. Yes...Bo...getting very aggressive. Bo

just rubbed herself in my face. Juliet (one of the naked

girls) getting wild. Oh, my God. Diane (another naled

girl) is whipping Bo. Good, girls, excellent. The big black

lesbian is out of her mind with lust. Look at her. You can't

say it on the air? Were you getting excited? Fabulous. All

right. That was really good. Best part of the whole

Christmas Party.

Appendix "E"

THE GARY DEE SHOW

Partial transcript from a broadcast on radio station

WWWE-AM, Cleveland, Ohio, on June 21, 1989, between

2:00 - 6:00 p.m.

Caller:

Gary:

Caller:

"Gary, I have a comment to make and then

I want to tell you what my dream and my

goal was for me in life."

"Excellent."

"My comment is Lou told me that Chris

James gives fellatio okay. Now my dream,

ya still there, Gary?”

"Yeah."

"Now, my dream is to get in Chris James’

pants."

"Well, why don't you be a man and go down

there and say that to her face. You know,

you are just like a little kid masturbating in

public. You've go no class, you've got no

taste."

Appendix "F"

"PLAYBOY"

Excerpts from the October, 1987 issue of Playboy which

aired on radio station KSD-FM, St. Louis, Missouri on

September 28, 1987, at 6:50 a.m.

Hahn:

Scheer:

Hahn:

He put his penis in my mouth and I was just

starting to cry at that point. Because |

couldn't believe...I just started to realize

everthing that was happening.

First, of all, I couldn't breathe right. You

know, it wasn't...it wasn't...it was

just...Emotionally, I couldn't...Everything was

It was the very first thing this man did. He

has pillows under me. He's sitting like, on

my neck. I'm not breathing. I'm feeling

sick. The guy is. like, letting loose and I'm

choking. O.K. So I'm crying. Tears are

coming...

What do you mean, he was letting loose?

(closing her eyes) The guy came in my

mouth.

"EROTIC CITY"

Prince

Warner Bros.

A song aired on radio station KLUC-FM, Las Vegas,

Nevada, on May 16, 1988, at 7:53 p.m.

ALL OF MY PURPLE LIFE

I'VE BEEN LOOKIN’ FOR A DAME

THAT WOULD WANT TO BE MY WIFE

THAT WAS MY INTENTION BABE

IF WE CANNOT MAKE BABIES

MAYBE WE CAN MAKE SOME TIME

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME,

EROTIC CITY COME ALIVE

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

MAKIN LOVE TIL CHERRIES GONE

EROTIC CITY CAN'T YOU SEE

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME.

‘

EVERYTIME I COMB MY HAIR

THOUGHTS OF YOU GET IN MY EYES

YOU'RE A SINNER I DON'T CARE

I JUST WANT YOUR CREAMY THIGHS

IF WE CAN'T MAKE BABIES

MAYBE WE CAN MAKE SOME TIME

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME

EROTIC CITY COME ALIVE

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

MAKIN LOVE TIL CHERRIES GONE

EROTIC CITY CAN'T YOU SEE

G-]

=

SS ee ee

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME.

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

(INTO THE DAWN)

HOW I WISH YOU WERE MY DAME

(REPEAT)

IF YOU CANNOT MAKE BABIES,

MAYBE WE CAN MAKE SOME TIME

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME

EROTIC CITY COME ALIVE

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

MAKIN LOVE TIL CHERRIES GONE

EROTIC CITY CAN'T YOU SEE

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME.

WOOOO0O WOOO00 WOOO0 WOOO0O

BABY YOU'RE SO CREAMY

IF WE CANNOT MAKE BABIES

MAYBE WE CAN MAKE THE TIME

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME

EROTIC CITY COME ALIVE

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

MAKIN LOVE TIL CHERRIES GONE

EROTIC CITY CAN'T YOU SEE

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME.

IF YOU CANNOT MAKE BABIES,

MAYBE WE CAN MAKE SOME TIME

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME

EROTIC CITY COME ALIVE

WE CAN FUCK INTO THE DAWN

G-2

MAKIN LOVE TIL CHERRIES GONE

EROTIC CITY CAN'T YOU SEE

FUCK SO PRETTY YOU AND ME.

EROTIC CITY...YEA!

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.