Joint Appendix — South-Central Timber Development, Inc. v. Wunnicke

Supreme Court brief1984

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1982

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.,

Petitioner,

Vv.

ESTHER WUNNICKE, COMMISSIONER OF DEPARTMENT OF

NATURAL RESOURCES OF THE STATE OF ALASKA, et al.,

Respondents,

V.

KENAI LUMBER Co., INC.,

Respondent.

On Writ Of Certiorari To The United States

Court Of Appeals For The Ninth Circuit

JOINT APPENDIX

LeRoy E. DEVEAUX NORMAN C. GORSUCH

(Counsel of Record) ATTORNEY GENERAL

RICHARD L. CRABTREE (Counsel of Record)

MICHAEL G. KARNAVAS MICHELE BROWN

WANAMAKER, DEVEAUX & ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL

CRABTREE STATE OF ALASKA

1081 West Fourth Avenue OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

Suite 401 1081 y+ Fourth Avenue

1 * oon Alaska 99501

Counsel for Plaintiff

— Counsel for Respondents

— I. BAKER RICHARD A. HELM

KAREN L. Grimm — * Pease & Kurtz

SUTHERLAND, ASBILL & BRENNAN Street

1666 K N. W. Alaska 99601

. 20006 don ae

Counsel for Respondent

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Chronological List of Relevant Docket Entries ....... la

Complaint (filed Oct. 16, 19800) 4a

Index to Materials Relevant to Alaska Primary Manufac-

ture Requirement Attached to Affidavit of James N.

W er (filed Oct. 16, 1980) 26a

* Statement of Governor William Egan (1961) (Ex-

ibit 2 to Affidavit of James N. Wanamaker, filed

D ̃ Ü-... * 28a

Logan Resolution, Senate Joint Resolution No. 59

yg: Mar. 1962) (Exhibit 3 to Affidavit of James

N. Wanamaker, filed Oct. 16, 1980) ............. 30a

— Statement of Governor William Egan (1962) (Ex-

ibit 4 to Affidavit of James N. Wanamaker, filed

, ̃ I 6 e'0s0.0 e's. 31a

Poliey Statement of Governor Walter Hickle (1968) (Ex-

ibit 5 to Affidavit of James N. Wanamaker, filed

. dae i bae de bbte comale’ 32a

Policy Statement of Governor William Egan (1974) (Ex-

ibit 6 to Affidavit of James N. Wanamaker, filed

F è7—⏑ WÄQi ⅛ Y deb ooes bultcane son 33a

Notice of Timber Sale (Exhibit 7 to Affidavit of James N.

Wanamaker, filed Oct. 16, 1980) )))) 34a

Affidavit of David E. Wallingford (filed Oct. 20, 1980) . 36a

8 Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint (filed Nov. 5, 5

State of Alaska House of Re tatives Resolution No.

3 (1979) — 1 of — tie

ment Motion, Nov. 13 Drees 52a

Tr No. 9 (1979) (Exhibit B to 1

fare of Summary Judgment Motion, filed fev R 1

Affidavit of H. Sugiyama (filed Nov. 18, 1980) ....... 56a

ley No. 2 Timber Sale Contract (Exhibit to Affidavit

Sugiyama, filed Nov. 18, 1980) ............ 60a

ii

Table of Contents Continued

Page

Lindell, Log Export Restrictions of the Western States

and British Columbia, Pacific Northwest Forest and

Range Experiment Station, U.S. De ent of

culture, Forest Service (Appendix II to Memor-

andum of Law by Defendants in Support of Motion

for Summary J nt, filed Nov. 19, 1980) 93a

eee eee eee

Memorandum and Order of the United States District

2 for the District of Alaska (entered Jan. 5, sin

oi ecient. ans a

Judgment of the United States District Court for the

istrict of Alaska (entered Jan. 6, 1981) ......... 136a

Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for the

Ninth Circuit (entered Dec. 1, 1982) N 8 138a

Judgment of the United States Court of Appeals for the

inth Circuit (entered Dec. 1, 1982) ............ 145a

W

0 4 8):

ate yah

7 card) fare .

la

JOINT APPENDIX

Chronological List of Relevant Docket Entries

1980

Oct. 16—Complaint of South-Central Timber Development,

Inc. filed. Motions of South-Central Timber Development

for Preliminary Injunction and Temporary Restraining

Order filed. Memorandum of Law of South-Central Timber

Development in Support of Injunctive Relief filed. Plaintiffs

Affidavits of Clyde Tanaka and James N. Wanamaker filed.

Oral Argument on Motion by South-Central Timber Devel-

opment for TRO set for Oct. 20, 1980.

Oct. 20—Opposition of Defendants (Robert LeResche, Geof-

frey Haynes, Theodore Smith) to Motion by South-Central

Timber Development for TRO filed. Defendants’ Affidavit

of David Wallingford filed. Plaintiff's Supplemental Affida-

vit of James N. Wanamaker filed. Memorandum of Law by

South-Central Timber Development in Reply to Opposition

by LeResche, et al. to Motions for Injunctive Relief filed.

Court Minutes re Oral Argument on Motion for TRO filed—

Decision Reserved.

Oct. 21—Memorandum and TRO Restraining State from Con-

ducting Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale Scheduled for Oct. 23,

1980 filed. Order filed Setting Preliminary Pretrial Confer-

ence.

Oct. 31—Motion by Kenai Lumber Co., Inc. to Intervene as

Defendant filed.

Nov. 14—Stipulation filed that Parties do not Oppose Motion

for Intervention by Kenai Lumber.

Nov. 18—Memorandum and Order Allowing Kenai Lumber to

Intervene as Defendant filed. Motion by Kenai Lumber to

Dismiss and Memorandum in Support filed. Brief by Kenai

Lumber on Constitutionality of Primary Manufacture filed.

Motion by South-Central Timber Development for Sum-

mary Judgment filed. Plaintiffs Affidavit of H. Sugiyama

filed.

2a

Nov. 19—Motion by LeResche, et al. for Summary Judgment

and Memorandum in Support filed.

Dec. 3—Opposition by Kenai Lumber to Motion by South-

Central Timber Development for Summary Judgment and

Memorandum in Support of Motion by LeResche, et al. for

Summary Judgment filed. Reply by South-Central Timber

Development to Memorandum of Law by LeResche, et al. in

Support of Its Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment filed.

Plaintiff's Supplemental Affidavit of H. Sugiyama filed.

Dec. 5—Reply Memorandum by State in Support of Motion for

Summary Judgment and in Opposition to Motion of South-

Central Timber Development for Summary Judgment filed.

1981

Jan. 5—District Court’s Memorandum and Order Granting

Motion by South-Central Timber Development for Sum-

mary Judgment filed; Motion by LeResche, et al. for Sum-

mary Judgment denied; Motion by Kenai Lumber to Dismiss

denied.

Jan 9.—Final Judgment of the District Court Permanently

Enjoining Alaska From Requiring Primary Manufacture of

State-Owned Timber, dated Jan. 6, 1981, filed.

Jan. 15—Notice of Appeal by LeResche, et al., filed.

Jan. 20—Case No. 81-3053 docketed and Appearances of Coun-

sel entered.

Jan. 23—Notice of Appeal by Kenai Lumber filed.

Jan. 27—Statement of Issues by Appellant filed.

Feb. 2—Case No. 81-3081 docketed and Appearance of Coun-

sel entered.

Feb. 24—Stipulation and Order Consolidating Appeals No.

81-3053 and No. 81-3081 filed.

Mar. 4—Copy of Ninth Circuit Order Consolidating Appeals

No. 81-3052 and No. 81-3081 filed.

3a

April 21—Brief and Excerpts of Record by Kenai Lumber

filed.

May 20—Motion for Leave to File and Brief of Amicus Curiae

by Association of Western Pulp and Paper Workers and its

Affiliated Ward Cove, Alaska Local 783 and of International

Woodworkers of America, AFL-CIO, Western States Re-

gional Council No. 3 and its Affiliated Alaska Local 3-193

filed.

June 3—Order filed Granting Leave to File Amicus Brief to

Association of Western Pulp and Paper Workers and its

Affiliated Ward Cove, Alaska Local 783 and the Internation-

al Woodworkers of America, AFL-CIO, Western States

Regional Council No. 3 and its Affiliated Alaska Local 3-193.

Brief, heretofore received, ordered filed.

June 11—Brief of State of Alaska filed. Excerpts of Record,

filed by Kenai Lumber Co, adopted.

June 23—Brief of South-Central Timber Development filed.

July 16—Reply Brief of Appellant Kenai Lumber filed.

July 21—Reply Brief of Appellant State of Alaska filed.

Dec. 10—Appeal argued and submitted before Goodwin, Ken-

nedy, and Skopil.

1982

Dec. 1—Ninth Circuit Court ordered Opinion (Kennedy)

reversing District Court Opinion filed and Judgment to be

filed and entered.

1983

Feb. 3—Ninth Circuit Order awarding Kenai Lumber Co.

costs in amount of $352.00 filed.

Feb. 15—Ninth Circuit Mandate issued and amended to in-

clude costs.

COMPLAINT (FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

da

WANAMAKER, DEVEAUX & CRABTREE

A Professional Corporation

909 W. 9th Ave., #140

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 279-6591

Attorneys for Plaintiff

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

Civil Action No. A80-311

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.,

Plaintiff,

V.

ROBERT LERESCHE, Commissioner of Department of

Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

GEOFFREY HAV NES, Director, Division of Lands,

Department of Natural Resources, and Deputy Commissioner

of Department of Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

and

TuHeopore G. Situ, Director of Division of Forest,

Land and Water Management, of Department of Natural

Resources of the State of Alaska,

Defendants.

FILED

OCT 16 1980

United States District Court

District of Alaska

By DC Deputy

5a

COMPLAINT

Cos Now the Plaintiff, SourH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOP.

MENT, INC. (hereinafter “SOUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER”), by and

through its attorneys of record WANAMAKER, DEVEAUX &

CRABTREE, APC, and alleges as follows:

JURISDICTION

1. This action arises under the Constitution of the United

States, Article I, § 8, as hereinafter more fully appears. The

matter in controversy exceeds, exclusive of interest and costs,

the sum of $10,000, and, therefore, jurisdiction lies under 28

U.S.C. § 1331(a). Insofar as this Complaint seeks Declaratory

Judgment, it is based on 28 U.S.C.A. 2201 and Rule 57 Federal

Rules of Civil Procedure.

2. Plaintiff now is, and since July 18, 1967, has been a

domestic corporation, duly organized and existing under the

laws of the State of Alaska, engaged in the business, among

other things, of purchasing standing timber in the State of

Alaska, logging or contracting for the logging of such timber,

and shipping the resulting logs from Alaska and into foreign

commerce. Plaintiffs corporate offices are located at Anchor-

age, Alaska, and it has timber processing facilities at Icy Bay,

Alaska (near Cape Yakataga), and Jakalof Bay, Alaska (near

Homer). Plaintiff has paid its Alaska and United States corpo-

rate taxes last due and filed its Alaska corporate report last

due.

3. Defendant RoBERT LERESCHE is Commissioner of the

Department of Natural Resources, State of Alaska. Pursuant

to AS 38.05.115, the Commissioner

“upon recommendation of the director, shall determine

the timber and other materials to be sold, and the limita-

tions, conditions and terms of sale.”

4. Defendant GEOFFREY Haynes is the Deputy Commis-

sioner of the Department of Natural Resources, State of Alas-

ka. GEOFFREY HAYNES is also the Director of the Division of

6a

Lands of the Department of Natural Resources, State of Alas-

ka. Defendant Haynes, therefore, has authority to recom-

mend terms and conditions of Alaska timber sales and to con-

duet such timber sales. Some of the functions which said De-

fendant GEOFFREY HAYNES would otherwise exercise in his

capacity of Director of the Division of Lands have been dele-

gated to THEODORE G. SmitTu, the Director of the Division of

Forest, Land and Water Management of the Department of

Natural Resources of the State of Alaska, pursuant to written

delegations, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit A.

5. Defendant THEODORE G. SMITH is the Director of the

Division of Forest, Land and Water Management of the De-

partment of Natural Resources of the State of Alaska. Pur-

suant to AS 38.05.110, et seg., and the delegations of authority

attached as Exhibit A, and certain administrative regulations,

specifically 11 AAC 76.005, et seg., he is the state official

having authority and responsibility, subject to the approval by

Defendant LERESCHE, to recommend timber sales and terms

of sale, and to conduct competitive timber sales.

6. A8 38.05. 120 declares that any violation of Title 38 of the

Alaska Statutes, or any terms of a contract for the sale of

timber, subjects the violator to appropriate legal action. 11

AAC 76.175 likewise provides that ifthe purchaser of a timber

sale breaches any of the provisions of the contract, then “the

director may terminate the contract and all timber or forest

products for which title has not passed shall vest in the

state.

7. The Defendants have advertised a notice of sale for a

sale of approximately 49,185,000 board feet of timber in the

area of icy Cape, Alaska. This proposed sale, which is known as

the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale, is scheduled to be sold at

public auction on October 23, 1980, at 2:00 o’clock p.m.

8. The notice of said Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale provides

as follows:

“Pri manufacture within the State of Alaska will be

required as a special provision of the contract.”

7a

9. Both versions of the Prospectus for said Icy Cape No. 2

Timber Sale provide as follows:

“Primary manufacturer.

Primary manufacture shall be as defined under Section 11

AAC 76.130 of the “Timber Sales R tions” and as

further defined in the Governor’s “Policy Statement on

Primary Manufacture” dated May 7, 1974.”

10. The Timber Sale Contract, which the Defendants have

developed for use on the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale, and

which the successful bidder will be required to sign, provides

as follows:

“Section 68. Primary Manufacture. Timber cut under

this contract shall not rar rg for primary manu-

facture outside the State of ka without written ap-

proval of the State.

i Manufacture is defined under 11 AAC 76.130

and the Governor’s policy statement of May 1974. For

urposes of this contract, cants may be manufactured

all species for export and will be considered to have

received primary manufacture when sawed up to a max-

imum thickness of 12 inches and may be of any width.

Timbers cut thicker than 12 inches must be squared on

four sides — their entire length with allowances for

one-third of dimension (thickness and width) allowed

in wane.

Chips are considered to have received primary manu-

facture.”

11. The primary manufacture regulation 11 AAC 76.130

provides as follows:

“11 AAC 76.130. PRIMARY MANUFACTURE.

(a) The director ma ire that primary manufac-

ture of logs, cordwood, bolts or other similar ilar products be

accomplished within the State of Alaska.

(b) The term primary manufacture means manufac-

ture which is first in order of time or development. When

used in relation to sawmilling, it means

(1) the breakdown process wherein logs have been

994 — to the extent

8a

that the residual cants, slabs or planks can be processed

by resaw equipment of the type customarily used in log

processing plants; or

(2) manufacture of a product for use without further

processing, such as structural timbers (subject to a firm

showing of an order or orders for this form of product).

(e) Primary manufacture, when used in reference to

pulp ventures, means the breakdown *. Mes a —

where the wood fibers have been se peas

from pe processing wastes shall prs to —

a primary manufacture. With res to veneer or

1 it means the produetion of green

Ano les and piling, whether treated or untreated,

when manufactured to American National Institute

Standards specifications are considered to have received

primary manufacture.”

12. The document attached as Exhibit B is a correct copy of

the Governor’s Policy Statement on Primary Manufacture

dated May 7, 1974.

13. Plaintiff SovurH-CENTRAL TIMBER is actively engaged in

timber operations in the State of Alaska. Plaintiff is, in fact,

actively logging the State of Alaska Icy Cape No. 1 Timber

Sale, which is immediately adjacent to the proposed Icy Cape

No. 2 Timber Sale. Primary manufacture is not required of logs

removed from the Icy Cape No. 1 Timber Sale.

14. Plaintiff SourH-CENTRAL TIMBER would like to bid on

the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale. However, SouTH-CENTRAL

TIMBER no longer has a mill capable of processing this volume of

timber into cants, its mill having been effectively closed by the

need to comply with State of Alaska air pollution require-

ments. Accordingly, SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER is placed at a

serious disadvantage in bidding in that, since it does not have a

mill of its own, it would have to take into account the added

costs of making cants in the mill of another company within the

working circle of this sale. Unless the unconstitutional require-

ment of primary manufacture is removed by this Court, such

added costs will effectively remove SoUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER

from the bidding on this sale.

9a

15. The primary manufacture requirement 11 AAC 76.130

is illegal and should be enjoined for the following reasons:

(A) It violates Article I, § 8, of the Constitution of the

United States of America for the following reasons:

(1) It is a per se violation of the Commerce Clause of

the United States Constitution and is con to the

doctrine as established in Foster-Fountain Packing Co.

v. Haydel, 278 U.S. 1 (1928); West v. Kansas Nat. Gas

Co., 221 U.S. 229 (1911); Pennsylvania v. West Virgi-

nia, 262 U.S. 553 (1923); and Hicklin v. Orbeck, 437

U.S. 518 (1978);

(2) The regulation is an illegal attempt by the De-

fendants to prefer the citizens of the State of Alaska in

the utilization of natural resources found within the

State of Alaska but destined for interstate or foreign

commerce;

(3) The primary manufacture requirement directly

obstructs and discriminates against interstate and for-

eign commerce and the right to carry on such com-

merce.

(B) Noaction ofthe Alaska Legislature has authorized

the adoption of such primary manufacture regulations.

(C) 11 AAC 76.130 is unconstitutionally vague.

16. Plaintiff alleges that there has been no legislative

authorization for the adoption of the regulation 11 AAC 76.130.

17. Plaintiff alleges that 11 AAC 76.130 is unconstitution-

ally vague and its enforcement as a timber sale provision

should be enjoined.

18. Plaintiff alleges that the Governor’s Policy Statement

on Primary Manufacture, dated May 7, 1974, does not have the

force and effect of law, and may not be utilized either as a legal

requirement of Alaska timber sales or an interpretive aid to 11

AAC 76.130.

19. Plaintiff alleges that the terms of sale for Icy Cape No.

2 Timber Sale were changed during the advertising period.

10a

The first Prospectus provided by the STATE OF ALASKA

stated:

“Method of Payment

The bid deposit will be credited to the stumpage deposit at

the time o ny bag the contract by the purchaser. The

may od will refund the excess bid deposit to the Purchaser

at that time.

Prior to cutting of any timber under this contract, the

purchaser will deposit with the State an advance stum-

page deposit equal to the value of timber estimated to be

cut in not less than 30 calendar dauys [sic] nor more than60

calendar days.”

The second Prospectus provided by the STATE OF ALAS-

KA stated:

“Method of Payment

Purchaser shall furnish a payment bond in the amount of

$250,000.00. When the payment bond has been furnished

to the State the bid deposit will be refunded.

Purchaser shall submit stum payments and scale re-

ports to the State on the 10th of each month for the

previous months cutting.”

The difference between the two Prospectuses is as follows:

Prospectus Amount of Cash Money Which Can Be

Retained By State

Version #1 Up to $836,000

Version #2 Apparently none if a $250,000 payment

bond is provided.

Plaintiff is genuinely confused as to which is the legal

requirement for this sale. If Version #1 is controlling, it will

mean an increased cost of approximately $140,000 per year,

assuming borrowing at 17 to 18 percent interest.

20. The Defendants have performed or adopted an apprais-

al which does not accurately appraise stumpage value in that it

lla

contains a gross error in the computation of transportation

costs; it being a practical impossibility to raft logs from Icy

Cape No. 2 through the Gulf of Alaska, and in fact logs must be

transported by barge at a higher cost. Said higher cost would

indicate transportation costs of approximately $55 per thou-

sand board feet greater than appraised.

21. The contract for said Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale

provides for stumpage reappraisal in February 1981 and each

February thereafter. The Defendants have not indicated in

official sale documents how or if such appraisal mistake as

noted in paragraph 20 above will be corrected. Accordingly,

potential bidders are left only speculation as to how stumpage

will be determined.

22. This ley Cape No. 2 Timber Sale is unique in that it will

be the last opportunity for a substantial StaTe timber sale in

the Gulf of Alaska for many years to come for the reason that

determinations have been made by the STaTE that Icy Cape

No. 2 Timber Sale will result in such a complete utilization of

the allowable annual cut for the State forest lands that accord-

ingly other timber sales will not be made in this area in the near

future.

23. SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER has at the present time only

one timber sale contract (the State of Alaska Icy Cape No. 1

Timber Sale) on which it is conducting logging operations. It is

expected that this contract will be finished in two or three

operating seasons. Unless SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER is permit-

ted to bid on the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale, it will face the

prospect of having to cease logging operations by reason of the

unavailability of timber. Thus, Plaintiff will suffer irreparable

harm and injury unless the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale is

enjoined until such time as it is conducted in conformity with

law.

24. Unless the Defendants are enjoined from holding the

Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale until such time as they have

removed the constitutional defect of requiring primary manu-

facture, and have renoticed the sale with legal terms, Plaintiff

will be effectively eliminated from the bidding process.

12a

25. Unless the Defendants are enjoined from holding the

Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale until such time as they have

removed the legal defects, in addition to the primary manufac-

ture defect, Plaintiffs may be required to bid on a sale which

has not been legally conducted and which can be voided at the

instance of another bidder or other person having standing to

sue.

26. Plaintiff further alleges that in the event that this sale

is enjoined on grounds other than the illegality of primary

manufacture, or the Defendants agree to reschedule the sale

but have not eliminated the primary manufacture require-

ment, then in that event, this is an appropriate case for use of

Declaratory Judgment and requests that this Court enter its

Declaratory Judgment declaring the primary manufacture

requirement 11 AAC 76.130 to be unconstitutional, illegal, and

invalid, and that the State of Alaska may not legally convey

timber within the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale area until such

time as that requirement is removed from the notice, prospec-

tus, and contract of sale.

27. Further, Plaintiff alleges that it would be appropriate

for this Court, after enjoining this sale until defects are cor-

rected, to require Defendants to continue its proceedings for

this sale and hold the sale with the primary manufacture

requirement eliminated and other legal defects corrected,

since to cancel the sale would be to punish SouTH-CENTRAL

TimBER for insisting upon its constitutional rights.

WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff prays:

1. For preliminary and permanent injunction restraining

the Defendants from conducting the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber

Sale until such time as the requirement of primary manufac-

ture has been eliminated from the notice, prospectus, and

contract of sale, and other legal defects have been cured, and

the sale has been properly noticed.

2. Foratemporary restraining order, restraining the De-

fendants from conducting said Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale

until this matter can be heard and determined.

13a

3. That this Court enter Declaratory Judgment declaring

11 AAC 76.130 to be unconstitutional, illegal, and invalid.

4. That this Court require Defendants to continue the

proceedings for the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale and hold the

sale with the primary manufacture requirement eliminated

and other legal defects corrected, since to cancel the sale

altogether would be to punish SoUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER for

insisting upon its constitutional rights.

5. That the Plaintiff recover its costs and attorneys’ fees

herein.

6. For such other and further relief as the Court deems just

and equitable in the premises.

RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this 15th day of October, 1980.

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER

DEVELOPMENT, INC.

/s/By H. Sugiyama

H. SUGIYAMA

Vice President

WANAMAKER, DEVEAUX, & CRABTREE

A Professional Corporation

/s/By LeRoy E. DeVeaux

LeRoy E. DEVEAUx

STATE OF ALASKA )

) ss.

THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT )

H. SuGiyaMa, being first duly sworn, deposes and says:

I am the Vice President of SouUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVEL-

OPMENT, Ixc., and make this verification for and on behalf of

said corporation; SOUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT,

INC., is the Plaintiff named in the foregoing CoMPLAINT; I have

read the foregoing CoMPLAINT and understand the contents

thereof; I have executed it freely and voluntarily on behalf of

Ia

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC., as Vice Presi-

dent for the purpose set forth therein; and the same is true of

my own knowledge.

/s/ H. Sugiyama

H. SuGIYAMA

SUBSCRIBED and Sworn to before me this 15th day of Octo-

ber, 1980.

/s/ Anita M. Mowery

ANITA M. Mowery

Notary Public for Alaska

My commission expires: 10/4/82

ANITA M. MOWERY

NOTARY PUBLIC

STATE OF ALASKA

15a

MEMORANDUM STATE OF ALASKA

TO: Division Directors

FROM: Jeff Haynes

Deputy Commmissioner

DATE: July 1, 1980

FILE NO: 81/001

TELEPHONE NO:

SUBJECT: DEPARTMENT ORDER 81/001

Department Management System

The contents of this Department Order describe the manage-

ment system for the Department of Natural Resources. All

operations of the Department shall be consistent with this

management system. The six components of the Department

management system are:

(1) Department 7 —

(Project Budgeting/Monitoring/A s

ject U onitoring / Accounting System

(4 Regional —— P Plans

(5) Department Orders

(6) Directors’ Meetings

I. DEPARTMENT ORGANIZATION

The Department of Natural Resources is arranged by function.

There are five functions contained within the Department. The

five functions, and corresponding entities, are

Function Entity

Executive Office Commissioner

Deputy Commissioner

Special Assistants

Boards/Advisory Committees

Resource Division of Geological and

Inventory/Assessment Geophysical Surveys

Resource Research Division of Research and

Development

16a

Resource Management Division of Forest, Land and

Water Management

Division of Agriculture

Division of Minerals and

Energy Management

Divison of Parks

Department Services Division of Administration and

Management

Division of Technical Services

The more specific duties of these entities are set out below.

A. Executive Office

The Commissioner is the chief executive officer of the De-

partment, and possesses final decisionmaking authority on all

matters within the jurisdiction of the Department unless said

authority has been subdelegated to subordinate officers. As a

member of the Cabinet, he reports on behalf of the Department

to the Governor, the Legislature, and the Judiciary on matters

affecting the Department.

The Deputy Commissioner is the second executive officer of

the Department and may act on behalf of the Commissioner on

all matters consistent with instructions from the Commission-

er. He is also responsible for general management of all opera-

tions of the Department.

Special Assistants report through the Deputy Commission-

er to the Commissioner and perform staff functions as

assigned. Special Assistants do not possess line decisionmak-

ing authority unless specifically vested with that authority by

the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner after notification

to affected Division Directors. If the Department is operating

properly, there should be no occasion to vest Special Assis-

tants with line decisionmaking authority.

Boards and Advisory Committees perform the functions

established by the statutes creating them.

17a

B. Resource Inventory/Assessment

The Division of Geological Surveys is responsible for

performing the Resource Inventory / Assessment function for

the Department. This function consists of gathering, assess-

ing, and compiling information relating to surface and sub-

surface resources, including minerals, coal, oil and gas, geo-

thermal energy, water, uranium, soils, geologic hazards,

vegetation, soils, timber, general surficial and subsurficial fea-

tures, and use and settlement. The finished product should be

sufficient for the Division of Research and Development to

formulate alternative courses of action for the Department to

take respecting the natural resources in question, or for a

particular division to carry out a Project already approved by

the Department. Generally, the Projects performed by the

Division of Geological and Geophysical Surveys will be gener-

ated through requests from the Commissioner or other Divi-

sions within the Department based on forseeable needs.

C. Resource Research

The Resource Research function is performed by the Divi-

sion of Research and Development. On a standard resource

development Project, the Division of Research and Develop-

ment will translate inventory and assessment data provided by

the Division of Geological and Geophysical Surveys into alter-

native courses of action for approval by the Commissioner. The

Division of Research and Development is also the one inter-

divisional division within the Department, performing Proj- .

ects which affect two or more divisions and therefore require a

clearinghouse process. Under the Resource Research func-

tion, the Division of Research and Development performs six

subfunctions:

(1) a re of a data processing network

(ALARS) which will serve the requirements of various

other divisions, at least to the point that a particular

system is operational. At that stage, a decision will be

made as to whether the system is retained by the Division

or moved to the supervising authority of another division.

(2) ration of a or oh mans clearinghouse cover-

ing hob era coastal management procedures, mat-

18a

ters referred by the Commissioner or other agencies,

legislation, and similar items. The purpose is to establish

one entity which assimilates materials and positions from

various divisions, synthesizes a common position with the

consent of affected divisions, and refers appropriate mat-

ters to the Commissioner for decision.

(3) Development of regional resource plans through

the consensus of all entities within the Department which

reflect, on a general the Department’s phic policy

in the form ol preferences among — of State

(4) Performance of general poliey research at the re-

quest of the Commissioner.

(5) Development of policies and Projeets, under the

direction of the Commissioner, relating to obtaining and

defending title to State lands.

(6) Operation of an information program for the De-

partment and a repository for informational materials

generated by the Department.

As the interdivisional division within the Department, the

Division of Research and Development must undertake all of

its responsibilities with the consent of other affected entities

rather than unilaterally.

D. Resource Management |

The Resource Management function is performed by five

divisions. Generally, the Division of Forest, Land and Water

Management is responsible for management of the surface and

the Division of Minerals and Energy Management is responsi-

ble for management of the subsurface. Each of those Divisions

is charged with obtaining the consent of the other where pro-

posed actions affect both the surface and the subsurface. In

addition where an area of the surface has been designated with

a primary beneficial use of agriculture, recreation, or pipeline

corridor (through legislative designation regional resource

plan, or legal instrument), a proposed action must operate by

mutual consent between the Divisions of Agriculture, Parks,

and Pipeline surveillance, respectively, and the Divisions of

Minerals and Energy Management and Forest, Land and Wa-

ter Management, as appropriate.

19a

The Division of Forest, Land and Water Management is

responsible for general surface management of State lands,

including water rights administration, forest development and

regeneration, fire protection and suppression, and complete as

well as limited disposals of state land for private/municipal use.

The Division performs classification of State lands into various

retention and disposal categories with respect to the surface,

and administers legal documents consummating a disposal into

private use or ownership.

The Division of Minerals and Energy Management is

charged with the general management of the subsurface of

State lands, which is retained even where the surface is dis-

posed of for private use. The Division performs the permitting/

leasing of State lands for development of oil and gas, coal,

minerals, and geothermal energy resources and administers

the permitting/leasing documents for compliance with terms

and payment of revenues. In addition, the classification of

subsurface lands is effectively accomplished through adminis-

tration of mineral closing orders.

The Division of Agriculture is responsible for the promotion,

development, and financing of the agricultural industry in the

State. The Division designs agricultural projects and sales,

administers the agricultural loan program, and develops and

promotes agricultural products through plant/seed materials

development, marketing/transportation research, and state

fairs.

The Division of Parks operates the State Park System (con-

sisting of legislatively designated lands and capital facilities)

and administers Federal and State grant programs for outdoor

recreation, historical preservation, and youth conservation

corps.

The Division of Pipeline Surveillance is responsible for ad-

ministration of pipeline corridors (created through regional

plans and a legal instrument in the form of a right-of-way lease)

as well as comprehensive preparatory activities which must

precede the negotiation of a pipeline right-of-way lease.

20a

Generally, the Resource Management Divisions carry out

Projects which have been approved by the Commissioner after

raw data has been gathered by the Division of Geological and

Geophysical Surveys and alternatives have been submitted to

the Commissioner after formulation by the Division of Re-

search and Development.

E. Department Services

Department Services are performed by the Division of Ad-

ministration and Management and the Division of Technical

Services for all entities within the Department. They may

occur at any time during the Resource Inventory/Assessment

to Resource Research to Resource Management Process.

The Division of Administration and Management generally

handles fiscal, personnel, and property matters, monitors com-

pliance with the Project Budgeting/Monitoring/Accounting

component of the Department management system, and pro-

vides centralized administrative services.

The Division of Technical Services is responsible for survey-

ing and engineering performed on behalf of other Divisions

including necessary preparatory work. In addition, the Divi-

sion administers the State Recorder’s Office and serves as the

repository for all State land records, which it is charged with

maintaining.

An organization chart reflecting the above is attached and

incorporated into this Department Order as Attachment I.

II. DELEGATIONS OF AUTHORITY

The responsibilities of each Department entity reflected in the

above discussion of the Department Organization are more

specifically enumerated and described in the Delegations of

Authority. In this document, all of the legal authorities vested

by law in the Department are listed and expressly assigned to

the Commission, the Deputy Commissioner (who serves in the

statutory capacity of Director of Lands) or one or more of the

Divisions. Divisions are prohibited from undertaking any ac-

2la

tion inconsistent with the Delegations of Authority, and any

action undertaken by the Department must receive the ap-

provals reflected by the allocations of legal responsibilities

contained in the Delegations of Authority.

The Delegations of Authority are attached and incorporated

into this Department Order as Attachment II.

III. PROJECT BUDGETING/ MONITORING

ACCOUNTING SYSTEM

The Project Budgeting/Monitoring/Accounting component of

the Department management system establishes the Depart-

ment’s agenda for the fiscal year and allocates the funds

appropriated to the Department by the Legislature. It also

monitors progress towards completing the agenda during the

fiscal year and insures that funds are being expended for the

purpose they were appropriated. This component consists of

the following elements.

(1). Project Budget. Beginning approximately a year be-

fore the start of a fiscal year, the Department formulates its

proposed budget. Generally, the Department budget is

arranged in a series of Budget Request Units and Components

on a programmatic basis; that is, matters of like subject matter

are grouped together. Budget Request Units are general (e. g.,

Forest Management) and Components within Budget Request

Units are more specific (e.g., Timber Inventory/Sales, Forest

Research, Fire Protection/Suppression). Objectives are set for

each BRU.

To formulate the budget, the Department collectively de-

velops a list of individual Projects (which may be operating,

capital, or a mixture), which evnsists of all of the conceivable

activities which could be performed during the upcoming fiscal

year. To develop the list, the Department considers public

demands and expectations, legislative requests or expected

interests, requests from the Governor, and the recommenda-

tions of the Department managers.

DEPARTMENT ORDER DATE: 7/2/79

81-001

ATTACHMENT II

DEPARTMENT _OF NATURAL RESOURCES

DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY

FOR DIVISION OF LANDS

AS 16 FISH AND GAME

AS 16.20.030(b) Zone Potter Point Refuge by regulation

AS 16.20.030(d) Zone Goose Bay Refuge by regulation

(e) Establish access corridors across Goose Bay

Refuge to private land with ADF &G and property

owners

AS 16.20.032(d) Zone Palmer Hay Flats Refuge by

regulation

AS 16.20.034(g) Manage surface and subsurface of

Mendenhall Flats

AS 16.20.036(e) Zone Susitna Flats Refuge by regulation

(f) Establish access corridors across Susitna Flats to

private land with ADF&G and property owners

* *

xx MO OM

VESTED BY

DATE: 7/2/79 STATUTE IN:

5

2

DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES

DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY

FOR DIVISION OF LANDS

tw Director, ADL

—

Adopt regulations covering waivers and ensuring fair X

return to State

ARTICLE 4. DISPOSAL OF TIMBER AND MATERIALS

AS 38.05.110 Provide for timber cruises and appraisals of X

other materials; recommend sales and terms of sale

AS 38.05.115 Determine sales and conditions of sale X

Negotiate sales of up to 500 m. b. m. of timber or 25,000 X

cu. yds. materials

Approve negotiated sales X

AS 38.05. 118 Negotiate up to 25-year unlimited timber X

sales in areas of high unemployment

Approve such sales X

— Director,. FLWM

* *

* *

* Director. MEM

VESTED BY DELEGATED TO:

STATUTE IN:

DATE: 7/2/79

DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES

DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY

FOR DIVISION OF LANDS

DMEM (subsurface)

© Director, FLWM

* Director, MEM

Directors, FLWM

(surface) and

Director. RD

@ Director, TS

> ww Director, ADL

a

AS 38.05.120 Determine high bidder; conduct sales; sign

contracts; impose conditions

Approve contracts and conditions; decide whether to

sell at auction or by sealed bids

Hear appeals of high bid determination

Adopt regulations to determine amount of deposit

ARTICLE 5. RESERVATION OF RIGHTS TO ALASKA

AS 38.05.127 Reserve easements and rights-of-way for

access to public waters

Adopt regulations

AS 38.05.130 Determine amount of surety bond to protect X X

surface owner

* >< & Director, FLWM

e K KK

© Not delegated

—

—

—

25a

POLICY STATEMENT ON PRIMARY MANUFACTURE

Section 76.100, “Timber Sale Regulations”

Cants may be manufactured from all species for export and

shall be considered to have received primary manufacture

when sawed up to a maximum thickness of 12 inches and may

be of any width. Timber cut thicker than 12 inches must be

squared on four sides along their entire length with allowances

for one-third of each dimension (thickness and width) allowed

in wane.

Timber processing wastes from west of 141° Longitude when

manufactured into chips are considered to have received pri-

mary manufacture and may be exported. Timber processing

wastes from east of 141° Longitude in Southeast Alaska when

manufactured into chips are considered to have received pri-

mary manufacture and export may be permissive only on ac-

tion of the Commissioner. Timber processing wastes is hereby

defined as all timber, mill residue, logging residue, or other

material not presently being utilized or in demand for higher-

valued products.

With the advance approval of the Commissioner, limited

quantities of all species, excluding spruce and hemlock, may be

exported in the form of round logs for experimental purposes

only, e.g., to introduce a new product to market. Round logs

may not be exported as a marketable commodity.

The above statement is intended to clarify and/or define

Section 76.130 of the “Timber Sale Regulations” and super-

sedes all previous policy statements and/or resolutions.

/s/ William A. Egan

WILLIAM A. EGAN

Governor of Alaska

DATE: May 7, 1974

INDEX TO MATERIALS RELEVANT TO ALASKA

PRIMARY MANUFACTURE REQUIREMENT

ATTACHED TO AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES N.

WANAMAKER (FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

26a

INDEX TO MATERIALS RELEVANT TO ALASKA

PRIMARY MANUFACTURE

Alaska Statutes Concerning Primary Manufacture

There are no Alaska Statutes which require the imposition of

primary manufacture on Alaska timber as a condition of export

into interstate or foreign commerce.

Alaska Regulations

Ex. 1: 2 1 manufacture regulation, 11 AAC

Policy Statements and Resolutions

Over the years since 1961 there have been various Policy

Statements by Alaska Governors and on one occasion a Resolu-

tion passed by the Alaska Senate. These are as follows:

Ex. 2: Policy Statement of Governor Egan (1961).

Ex. 3: Logan Resolution, Senate Joint Resolution No.

59 adopted March, 1962.

Ex. 4: Policy Statement of Governor Egan (1962).

Ex. 5: Policy Statement of Governor Hickle (1968).

Ex. 6: Policy Statement of Governor Egan (1974).

Attempted Application of Primary Manufacture in Icy Cape

No. 2 Timber Sale Contract

Ex. 7: Notice of Timber Sale.

Ex. 8: Prospectus Version 1 obtained from State about

September 9, 1980. See page 3 for primary man-

ufacture requirement.

Ex. 9: Prospectus Version 2 distributed by State after

first prospectus. See page 3 for primary manu-

facture requirement.

Ex. 10: Section 68 of Icy Cape No. 2 Timbor Sale Con-

tract.

27a

Objections made by South-Central Against Including Pri-

mary Manufacture in Icy Cape No. 2

Ex. 11: South-Central Timber Development, Inc., testi-

— 1 hearings of November 29, and Novem-

ber 30, 1979, cover letter by H. Sugiyama. Ex-

hibit also includes “Alaska Export Policy”

by Cal Kerr and Merlin Wibbenmeyer.

Ex. 12: August 21, 1980 letter to Shelley Higgins, As-

sistant Attorney General with carbon copy to

Ted Smith, Larry Dutton, and Russell Hardi

to effect that primary manufacture is unconsti-

tutional. Exhibit 12 also includes the “Affidavit

of Koichi (Clyde) Tanaka—Employment” which

shows that round log — has created more

jobs than primary manufacture.

POLICY STATEMENT OF GOVERNOR WILLIAM

EGAN (1961) (EXHIBIT 2 TO AFFIDAVIT OF

JAMES N. WANAMAKER, FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

28a

GOVERNOR’SOFFICE NEWS RELEASE JUNE30,1961

Governor William A. Egan today announced a new State

timber export policy permitting conditional export of minor

timber species without primary manufacture within Alaska for

experimental purposes aimed at building new markets.

The conditional authority would be restricted to a two-year

introductory period.

Enunciation of the policy followed receipt of inquiries from

several parties interested in the possible export of minor spe-

cies such as cottonwood, Alaska cedar, aspen and birch.

Primary manufacture within Alaska will continue to be re-

quired prior to export of all major timber species such as Sitka

spruce, Western hemlock and white spruce, the Governor said.

The policy statement issued by the Governor reads as fol-

lows:

“It is the policy of the State of Alaska to protect existing

industries, provide for the establishment of new industries,

derive revenue from all timber resources, and manage the

State’s forests on a sustained yield basis.”

“The policy of the State of Alaska relating to the export and

primary manufacture of timber, within the definition con-

tained in Department regulation is as follows:”

“1. Primary manufacture, as defined by Department

regulations, will be required for all major species such as Sitka

Spruce, Western Hemlock and White Spruce.”

“2. Minor species, such as Cottonwood, Alaska-cedar,

Aspen and Birch may be exported in the form of round logs,

with the advance approval of the Commissioner of Natural

Resources on a showing of need for experimental purposes and

for the introduction of the species to new markets, when in

excess of that required by local industries but within the total

allowable annual cut. The State may permit the export of

round logs of such minor species to introduce Alaskan timber to

new market areas or to new industries for a period of two

29a

years, beginning with the date of first export to that market.

Upon conclusion of the two year introductory period, primary

manufacture will be required.”

LOGAN RESOLUTION, SENATE JOINT

RESOLUTION NO. 59 (ADOPTED MAR. 1962)

(EXHIBIT 3 TO AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES N.

WANAMAKER, FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

30a

Senate Joint Resolution No. 59, 1962 Legislature

Senate Joint Resolution No. 59 (adopted March, 1962) pro-

vides as follows:

“Relating to the state timber export policy.

“Be It Resolved by the Legislature of the State of Alaska

in Second Legislature, Second Session Assembled:

“WHEREAS Westward Alaska has a large potential tim-

— resource which is not being developed and utilized;

an

“WHEREAS this replenishable timber resource can be

harvested during the winter months of maximum unem-

ployment; and

“WHEREAS the apparent allowable annual cut of the

existing stands of mixed timber species far exceeds the

demand for domestic uses; and

“WHEREAS there exists an export market willing to

absorb this excess;

“BE IT RESOLVED by the Legislature of the State of

Alaska in Second Legislature, Second Session assembled,

that the Governor of Alaska consider liberalization of the

state’s timber export policy to allow (1) the extension of

the present 2-year permit period allowing export of round

logs in the minor species of cedar, birch, cottonwood, and

aspen to 5 years, (2) the export of squared hemlock and

spruce logs up to 36 inches in diameter cut in domestic

mills; and be it

“FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this resolution

be transmitted to the Honorable William A. Egan, Gov-

ernor of Alaska; the Commissioner of Natural Resources;

and to the Director of the Division of Lands.”

POLICY STATEMENT OF GOVERNOR WILLIAM

EGAN (1962) (EXHIBIT 4 TO AFFIDAVIT OF

JAMES N. WANAMAKER, FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

"<a

3la

The 1962 policy statement of Governor Egan following the

Logan Resolution was as follows:

“It is the policy of the State of Alaska to manage the

State’s forests on a sustained yield basis; to protect exist-

ing industries; to provide for the establishment of new

industries, and to derive revenue from all timber re-

sources.

“The policy of the State of Alaska relative to the export

and primary manufacture of timber, within the definition

contained in Department regulations, is as follows:

“1. Primary manufacture, as defined by Department

regulations, will be required for all Sitka Spruce, White

Spruce and Western Hemlock; however, squared Hem-

lock and Spruce logs up to 36 inches in diameter cut in

domestic mills may be exported.

“2. Cottonwood, Cedar, Aspen, and Birch, may be ex-

ported in the form of round logs with advance approval of

the Director, Division of Lands, when supply exceeds that

required by local industris, but is within the total allow-

able annual cut in an established management area. The

State — A iy = the export of round logs of 8 gar

for a pe wad? beginning on May 1, 1962, and

ending on May 1, 1967. Upon conclusion of the five-year

period, primary manufacture will be required.”

1 N

POLICY STATEMENT OF GOVERNOR WALTER :

as HICKLE (1968) (EXHIBIT 5 TO AFFIDAVIT OF N

JAMES N. WANAMAKER, FILE D OCT. 16, 1980)

5 2

POLICY STATEMENT ON PRIMARY MANUFACTURE

Section 406.104 “Timber Sale Regulations”

Cants may be manufactured from all species for export and

shall be considered to have received primary manufacture

when sawed up to a maximum thickness of 12 inches and may

be of any width. Timber cut thicker than 12 inches must be

squared on four sides along their entire length with allowances

for one-third of each dimension (thickness and width) allowed

in wane.

Chips made from timber processing wastes shall be con-

sidered to have received primary manufacture and export will

be permissive on action of the Commissioner. Timber proces-

sing wastes is hereby defined as all timber, mill residue, log-

ging residue or other material not presently being utilized or in

demand for higher-valued products.

With the advance approval of the Commissioner, limited

quantities of all species, excluding spruce and hemlock, may be

exported in the form of round logs for experimental purposes

only, e.g. to introduce a new product to market. Round logs

may not be exported as a marketable commodity.

The above statement is intended to clarify and/or define

Section 406.104 of the “Timber Sale Regulations” and super-

sedes all previous policy statements and/or resolutions.

April 8, 1968

1

K

*

\

A‘ ,

4

a .

‘

: —

4

*

i

“|

4

4

5 . 22

1

5 POLICY STATEMENT OF GOVERNOR WILLIAM i:

| EGAN (1974) (EXHIBIT 5 TO AFFIDAVIT OF

JAMES N. WANAMAKER, FILED OCT. 16, 1980)

Os

„

R

POLICY STATEMENT ON PRIMARY MANUFACTURE

Section 76.130, “Timber Sale Regulations”

Cants may be manufactured from all species for export and

shall be considered to have received primary manufacture

when sawed up to a maximum thickness of 12 inches and may

be of any width. Timber cut thicker than 12 inches must be

squared on four sides along their entire length with allowances

for one-third of each dimension (thickness and width) allowed

in wane.

Timber processing wastes from west of 141° Longitude when

manufactured into chips are considered to have received pri-

mary manufacture and may be exported. Timber processing

wastes from east of 141° Longitude in Southeast Alaska when

manufactured into chips are considered to have received pri-

mary manfacture and export may be permissive only on action

of the Commissioner. Timber processing wastes is hereby

defined as all timber, mill residue, logging residue, or other

material not presently being utilized or in demand for higher-

valued products.

With the advance approval of the Commissioner, limited

quantities of all species, excluding spruce and hemlock, may be

exported in the form of round logs for experimental purposes

only; e.g., to introduce a new product to market. Round logs

may not be exported as a marketable commodity.

The above statement is intended to clarify and/or define

Section 76.130 of the “Timber Sale Regulations” and super-

sedes all previous policy statements and/or resolutions.

/s/ William A. Egan

WILLIAM A. EGAN

Governor of Alaska

DATE: May 7, 1974

NOTICE OF TIMBER SALE (EXHIBIT 7 TO 55

AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES N. WANAMAKER, FILED | a

OCT. 16, 1980)

470

34a

STATE OF ALASKA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL

RESOURCES DIVISION OF FOREST, LAND AND WATER

MANAGEMENT

NOTICE OF TIMBER SALE

Timber Sale SC-557 ADL 203002

Icy Cape No. 2

Under the authority of AS 38.05.110-.120, the State of Alas-

ka, Division of Forest, Land and Water Management, South-

central District, 941 East Dowling Road, Anchorage, Alaska

will sell at an oral auction at 2:00 PM October 23, 1980 at the

above address the following described timber;

All timber designated for cutting within the protracted Sec-

tion 32, 33, and 34, Township 21 South, Range 19 East, Copper

River Meridian, Sections 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 11, and 12, Township 22

South, Range 19 East, Copper River Meridian. Sections 6, 7,

and 8, Township 22 South, Range 20 East, Copper River

Meridian. There are approximately 1,028 acres of cutting area

in eight cutting units. An estimated 34,612 MBF of Spruce and

14,573 MBF of Hemlock will be offered. The cutting and re-

moval of timber shall be carried out in compliance with Forest

Resources and Practices Act (AS 41.17.010 et seq) and regula-

tions under that act which may be subsequently adopted, and

the timber sales regulations (11 AAC 76,005-.385 and 76.600-

76.610) in effect at the time of sale.

The contract shall be a new, Division of Forest, Land and

Water Management timber sale contract with special provi-

sions added to cover conditions pertinent to this sale. The state

reserves the right to reject any and all bids or to award the

timber for the amount of the next high bid to the next highest

bidder if the director considers the highest bidder unqualified

to fulfill the requirements of the contract or if the contract is

not executed by the highest bidder. The deposit furnished by a

high bidder whose bid was declared acceptable shall be re-

tained as liquidated damages if the high bidder does not ex-

ecute the contract and furnish a satisfactory bond within 30

35a

days of receipt of the contract for execution, except as pro-

vided in Section 11 AAC 76.080(b) of the Timber Sales Regula-

tions. The state reserves the right to waive minor technical

defects in this advertisement.

No bids will be accepted for less than $240.00 per thousand

board feet of spruce and $3.00 per thousand board feet of

hemlock for a total consideration of $8,306,880.00 for spruce

and $43,718.00 for hemlock. The total price consideration in-

cludes the weight price of sawlogs and utility logs. Primary

manufacture within the State of Alaska will be required as a

special provision of the contract. The term of the contract will

be five years.

To qualify for oral bidding, bidders must submit a bid deposit

of $836,000.00 either in cash, certified check, cashier’s check,

money order, or any combination of these, in favor of the State

of Alaska, Department of Revenue. The bid deposits shall be

submitted to the selling agent prior to 2:00 PM prevailing time

on October 23, 1980 at the Southcentral District Office, 941

East Dowling Road, Anchorage, Alaska 99502. All bidders

must have proof of a current applicable State of Alaska Busi-

ness License at the time of bidding. If the bidder is bidding as

an agent for an individual, partnership, corporation or other

legally established firm, the bidder must submit with the bid

deposit written authorization of such agency.

The Contract, prospectus, maps, appraisal, cruise report

and further information can be obtained from the Alaska Divi-

sion of Forest, Land and Water Management at: Southcentral

District Office, 941 East Dowling Road, Anchorage, Alaska

99502, Telephone 349-4524; Southeast District Office, Pouch

M, Juneau, Alaska 99801, Telephone 465-2433, or the State

Foresters Office, 323 East 4th Avenue, Anchorage, Alaska

99501, Telephone 279-5577. Northcentral District Office, 4420

Airport Way, Fairbanks, Alaska 99701, Telephone 479-2243.

/s/ Theodore G. Smith

THEODORE G. Surru, Director

Division of Forest, Land and Water Management

Publish: September 8, 15, 22 and 29, 1980

AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID E. WALLINGFORD

(FILED OCT. 20, 1980)

Wilson L. Condon

Attorney General

State of Alaska

Shelley J. Higgins

Assistant Attorney General

420 L Street, Suite 100

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 276-3550

Attorneys for Defendant

State of Alaska Officials

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

Civil Action No. 80-311

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.,

Plaintiff,

v.

RoBERT LERESCHE, Commissioner of Department of

Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

GEOFFREY Haynes, Director, Division of Lands,

Department of Natural Resources, and Deputy Commissioner

of Department of Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

and

THEODORE G. Surru, Director of Division of Forest,

Land and Water Management, of Department of Natural

Resources of the State of Alaska,

Defendants.

RECEIVED

80 OCT 20 P1:18

WANAMAKER AND

DEVEAU

37a

AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID E. WALLINGFORD

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA)

) ss.

STATE OF ALASKA )

Davip E. WALLINGFORD, being first duly sworn deposes and

states as follows:

1. I am Assistant State Forester in the State of Alaska

Department of Natural Resources.

2. Iam familiar with the proposed Icy Bay No. 2 Timber

Sale. I have been involved in the administrative process of

planning and implementing the sale from its inception over a

year ago.

3. Over the last year numerous State employees repre-

senting four different departments of State government have

been actively involved to varying degrees in the process of

planning and implementing the Icy Cape No. 2 sale. The

following personnel have been involved in planning and

implementing the sale: 12-14 employees of the Division of

Forest, Land and Water Management of the Department of

Natural Resourses (DNR); 2 employees from the Division of

Parks (DNR); 2 employees from the Commissioner’s staff

DNR; 6 employees of the Department of Fish and Game; 1

employee of the Department of Environmental Conservation

and 1 Assistant Attorney General.

4. The Final Finding attached to this affidavit explains the

reasons why the State decided to offer the Icy Cape No. 2

Timber Sale and the considerations underlying the finding that

holding the sale at this time is in the best interest of the State.

Basically, the economic and employment implications caused

by the current timber shortage resulting from suspension of

timber sales on federal lands has lead the State to commit a

portion of its timber resource at Icy Bay to a 1980 timber sale.

2

5. The Office of the Division of Forest, Land and Water

Management, 423 East Fourth Avenue, Anchorage, maintains

a mailing list of potential interested bidders. The mailing of

pre-sale information to approximately 20 parties on this list,

including the prospectus and the timber sale contract, was

completed by September 12, 1980. At least four prospective

bidding parties who received the mailing have contacted the

office for additional information indicating specific interest in

the proposed Icy Cape No. 2 Sale.

6. Ihave read the Affidavit of James Wanamaker filed in

this case. Mr. Wanamaker’s affidavit omits the following facts:

(a) Mr. Wanamaker was one of only two potential bidders

who received the initial prospectus (version No. 1) prior to the

time that the State amended the prospectus to reflect the

contract term regarding method of payment. Only the

amended prospectus was sent to parties on the mailing list.

c) Prior to mailing the amended prospectus and the tim-

ber sale contract to Mr. Wanamaker on September 12, 1980,

Pierre Authier of my office notified Mr. Wanamaker by phone

that the prospectus was amended to reflect the contract terms

regarding payment.

7. To the best of my knowledge, South-Central Timber

Development, Inc., the plaintiff in this case, is the only

prospective bidder, out of all the parties who have received

information on this sale, to complain that the sale should be

cancelled or postponed because of alleged errors and dis-

satisfaction with contract terms.

8. Harvest operations will not commence under this con-

tract until summer 1981, at the earliest, due to weather condi-

tions which will preclude the new purchasers in this sale from

moving equipment into the sale area and constructing roads as

required under the contract until April 1981.

9. Since the contract requires reappraisal of the timber

annually, beginning in February 1981, it is highly unlikely that

39a

any substantial volume of timber will be harvested prior to the

effective date of the first reappraisal. Current applicable cost

data will be used in the reappraisals.

FURTHER YOUR AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.

DATED this 20th day of October, 1980.

/s/ David E. Wallingford

Davip E. WALLINGFORD

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 20th day of Octo-

ber, 1980.

/s/ Nina S. Bufi

Nina S. Buri

Notary Publie in and for Alaska

My Commission expires: 3/31/83

The undersigned hereby certifies that on the 20th day of Octo-

ber, 1980, the attached documents were hand carried to the

attorneys of record.

Shelley J. Higgins

SHELLEY J. HIGGINS

Subscribed and sworn to before me

the date last written

Nina S. Bufi

Nina S. Bur!

Notary Public

My Commission expires 3/31/83

10a

FINAL FINDING

The intent of the Division of Forest, Land and Water

Management is to offer by competitive timber sale 44 million

board feet of Sitka Spruce and Western Hemlock involving

commercial forest land in the Icy Bay / Cape Yakataga area.

The following written finding is intended to satisfy the legal

requirements of AS 38.05.035 (a)(14) with respect to the dis-

posal of these timber resources, being in the best interest ofthe

state. In making this determination, the Division has con-

sidered the following:

1.

Publie and 5 * input received under AS

38.05. 305 and public meetings held in Seward and

Anchorage on November 29th and 30th, 1979.

Estimated Allowable Cut for Alaska’s Timber Re-

source on State Lands Report (revised 1973), Division

of Lands, Department of Natural Resources.

Cultural Resources Survey-Icy Bay to Cape Suckling,

Gulf of Alaska; Office of History and Archaeology,

Division of Parks, May 8, 1980.

Report of Preliminary Reconnaissance of the Yakata-

and Icy Bay area concerning the proposed Icy Bay

O. 2 sale. Division of Forest, pa and Water

18 ment, Southeentral Distriet, September 15,

Proposed Icy Bay No. 2 Timber Sale Analysis, Divi-

sion of Forest, Land and Water Management, South-

central District, October 29, 1979.

The primary issues raised in the above and pertinent to this

finding were:

Issue

The Icy Bay No. 2 contract shall include the requirement

for primary manufacturing.

Finding

Primary manufacture will be required when necessary to

assure a continuing supply of timber for existing industry.

4la

The State of Alaska is currently heavily dependent on

nonrecurring sources of revenue to Ry boy expenses.

Ninety percent of revenues are deriv m petroleum,

most of which are from Prudhoe Bay. The State began oil

and gas leasing in the early 1960s to develop revenues to

(1) pay for government services and (2) to be translated

into recurring revenue-sources to maintain state solvency

over the long run. For a more detailed history, see the

Finding and Decis ion under AS 38.05.035(a)(14) for the

gan Sea Oil and Gas Lease Sale dated October 25,

The forest products industry of the State represents a

source of recurring revenues as it is based upon a renew-

able resource. It is in the State’s interest to maximize

revenues and other benefits from selling its commercial

forest resources by providing opportunities for economic

returns beyond simply selling round logs for export. The

— manufacturing requirement is a means of provid-

ing such opportunities.

Economic and 7 implications caused by the

timber shortage resulting from the suspension of timber

sales on the Tongass and Chugach National Forests pend-

ing the outcome of (d) (2) and RARE II, has led the division

to determine that it is in the 1 interest to commit a

238 of timber in the Icy Bay / Cape Yakataga area to a

—— 24 sale. For ag: Grn to pe — 2 ery

uring this temporary shortage of volume from fede

lands, the Director has determined that the Governor’s

Policy Statement of — Manufacture dated May 7

1974, intended to define and clarify 11 AAC 76. 130 8

apply in this case.

The ability of the Yakataga area to sustain a timber har-

vest increase of 10 million board feet over the next five

years.

Finding

The state-owned timber base in the Icy Bay/Cape Yakata-

area is not sufficient to sustain a perpetual annual

est if the annual cut is to be large enough to support an

economic operation. The remaining forest base between

Icy Bay and Cape Yakataga would allow only 10 more

years of harvesting while protecting other resources. As a

42a

result 7 8 2 the 2 on 5

available cy Bay to Cape Suckling) even though t

additional state land has not been classified for state

retention presently. Existing inventory data obtained for

the entire area of state indicates that some 25,000

acres of commercial forest land exists with an annual

allowable cut of 25 million board feet over a 100 year

rotation for Sitka spruce and western hemlock. Viewing

the entire area as a forest reserve the commercial forest

land base does have the ability to sustain this timber

harvest increase. The decision to continue harvesting this

—— er was directed by the — ea ——

supplemental operating appropriations passed by the

legislature specifically for this sale r 1 in-

terest in having this harvest operation available to the

states forest industry.

The Forest Resources and Practices Act Section 41. 17.060

(bye) which sets out the standards by which timber har-

vest can take place on state lands has been adhered to in

the absence of approved regulations. Once ae the

Forest Practice Act Regulations will be part of the sale

contract, to ensure continuous 2 and harvesting of

commercial forest species under sound forest practices.

The compatability of the pro timber sale with ade-

quate protection for area wildlife.

Finding

Through joint meetings held with the Alaska t

of Fish and Game in the and two weeks of field

Issue

Commercial timber harvest activities in the coastal area

must be conducted so as to meet Coastal Zone Manage-

ment regulations.

Finding

Pursuant to 6 AAC 80.010 (b), the Governor’s Administra-

tive Order No. 54 and the Department Order 81/003, the

Department of Natural Resources had reviewed the pro-

posed 15 Bay Timber Sale No. 2 for consisteney with the

Alaska Coastal Management (ACMP). The de-

partment finds the sale as pro under the terms of the

applicable contract to be consistent with ACM. The ap-

plicable standards of the ACMP and the pro contract

conditions and stipulations which render this timber sale

consistent with the ACMP are discussed below:

6 AAC 80.010 - COVERAGE OF CHAPTER

Prospective timber rs are uired to compl

i — by section 49 —

6 AAC 80.040 - COASTAL DEVELOPMENT

44a

These timber resources are located in the coastal area.

The major road and harvest unit locations are designed to

leave a 400 foot buffer strip along the coast. Any road

changes or additions as well as the location of support

facilities by the purchaser must be approved by the state.

(Sec. 21 of the contract).

The state has applied for a Corps of Engineers permit for

the log* dump. (Application date Febru 5, 1980,

NPACP #071-OYD-1-800021). Comments on the —

tion by the Alaska Department of Fish and Game

(ADF &G) indicate — the proposed log dump con-

sistent with the ACMP.

6 AAC 80.050 - GEOPHYSICAL HAZARDS

This standard requires that the state decision makers not

approve gg in known geophysical hazard areas

until siting, design and construction measures for

minimizing property and protecting against loss

of life have been provided. The road locations selected by

the state as well as the road, bridge, and culvert construc-

tion specifications the purchaser must follow are designed

to minimize loss of life and property due to the known soils

and flood hazards in the area (Sec. 75 of the contract).

Other improvements constructed by the purchaser must

be approved by the state (Section 15 of the contract). It is

most appropriate to specify design s to protect

= life and property — — apts —

during the approval process required under section 15 of

the contract.

6 AAC 80.060(b) - RECREATION

This standard requires state ies to give hi rit

hi pee agencies high prio y

are —

this coastal area will be increased. bts

6 AAC 80.080 - TRANSPORTATION AND UTILITIES

This standard requires that transportation —

be

routes and in the coastal be

80 as to

and

Sed inland and route

45a

or facility is water dependent or no feasible and prudent

inland alternative exists to meet the public need for the

route or facility.

The major road network and stream crossings have been

located through a joint DNR and Alaska Department of

Fish and Game effort. The road locations avoid the im-

mediate coastal area which is protected by a 400 feet

buffer. Roads are permitted to extend to tidewater to

reach facilities for loading logs on barges. Roads are only

located on beaches when this is the best place to locate a

river crossing. The purchaser must construct roads within

the locations selected by the state. Any additional roads

desired by the purchaser must be approved by the state

prior to construction (Sections 12 and 21 of the contract).

4 ae 80.100 - TIMBER HARVEST AND PROCES-

It is the Department of Natural Resources’ understanding

that the forthcoming forest resources and pate

regulations (11 AAC 96) are intended to replace the stand-

contained in AAC 80.100. The Icy Bay Timber Sale

No. 2 has been 2 and the purchaser will be re-

quired to comply with the provisions in the forthcoming

regulations.

6 AAC 80.120 - SUBSISTENCE

The state agencies are required to recognize and assure

opportunities for subsistence usage of coastal areas and

resources. The sale area has not been identified as a major

area for subsistence usage.

6 AAC 80.130 - HA#ITATS

46a

2. Wetlands and tideflats: See estuary comments.

3. Exposed high — — —— A 400 feet buffer area is

— along the coas

4. Rivers, streams and wen Stream crossing loca-

tions and construction specifications have been ap-

og by the Alaska Department of Fish and

ame. Buffer strips are left along the rivers and

streams as requested by ADF &G (April 30, 1980,

Regional Supervisor—Rick Reed). Section 68

Stream Protection of the contract specifies proce-

dures to protect streams.

5. Important upland habitat: The winter range for

goats is the most often cited important upland habi-

tat in the sale area. Logging operations are not

allowed above the 400 foot contour and cutting unit

boundaries were modified to protect areas identi-

fied by ADF &G as winter range for goats below the

400 foot contour.

6 AAC 80.140 - AIR, LAND AND WATER QUALITY

This standard requires mg Ae to hag ly with =

— on air and water quali e request for a

rps of n permit for the * dump has been

— A | by the Department of Environmental Conserva-

tion and a statement of water quality compliance 1 — been

made. (May 22, 1980 Deputy Commissioner C. De

Cowles). The purchaser will also have to meet any s

ards — to his operations (section 49 of the con-

tract

6 AAC 80.150 - HISTORIC PREHISTORIC AND

ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCE

The Division of Parks and the State — Preservation

n

sources no further investigation

Icy Bay Timber Sale No. 2 area. (May 8, 3, 1980, Greg Dixon

Archaeologist).

The findings presented above have been reviewed and con-

sidered. The case file has been found to be complete. The

requirements of all applicable statutes and regulations have

been satisfied. Therefore, it is the finding of the Director, that

47a

it is in the best interest of the state to approve this action under

the authority of AS 38.05. 035 (a)(14) and AS 38.05. 120.

Date: 9/5/80 /s/ Theodore G. Smith

Tueopore G. Situ, Director

Forest, Land and Water Management

Department of Natural Resources

(FILED NOV. 5, 1980)

Wilson L. Condon

Attorney General

State of Alaska

Shelley J. Higgins

Assistant Attorney General

420 L Street, Suite 100

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 276-3550

Attorneys for Defendant

State of Alaska

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

A80-311 Civil

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.,

Plaintiff,

Vv

RoBert LERESCHE, Commissioner of Department of

Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

GEOFFREY Haynes, Director, Division of Lands,

Department of Natural Resources, and Deputy Commissioner

of Department of Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

and

THEODORE G. Situ, Director of Division of Forest,

Land and Water Management, of Department of Natural

.tesources of the State of Alaska,

Defendants.

RECEIVED

NOV-6 1980

Burr, Pease & Kurtz, Inc.

49a

STATE DEFENDANTS’ ANSWER TO COMPLAINT

Defendants, officials of the State of Alaska, Department of

Natural Resources, through counsel, answer the Complaint in

this action as hereafter set forth.

FIRST DEFENSE

This Court lacks subject matter jurisdiction over the claims

stated in paragraphs 15(B), (C), 16, 17, 18, 19, and 20 for the

reason that such claims do not raise a federal question.

SECOND DEFENSE

The Eleventh Amendment to the United States Constitu-

tion bars maintenance of the above-referenced claims in feder-

al court against the State of Alaska and the defendant state

officials.

THIRD DEFENSE

The Complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be

granted.

FOURTH DEFENSE

Responding to the numbered allegations of the Complaint,

the State answers as follows:

1. The allegations of paragraph 1 are conclusions of law

which require no response. However, defendants specifically

deny that all of the claims in this action arise under the Con-

stitution of the United States, Article I, Section 8.

2.-12. The allegations of paragraphs 2 through 12 are

13. The allegations of paragraph 13 are admitted subject to

primary

50a

15. The allegations of sub-paragraph 15(A) are denied. The

allegation of sub-paragraph 15(B) is denied and, moreover, the

defendants assert by way of affirmative defense that this

Court lacks jurisdiction over the claim stated in this sub-

paragraph. The allegation of sub-paragraph 15(C) is denied

and the defendants allege by way of affirmative defense that

the allegations of this sub-paragraph fail to state a claim.

16. The allegation of paragraph 16 is denied and the de-

fendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this Court

lacks jurisdiction over the claims stated in this paragraph.

17. The allegation of paragraph 17 is denied and the de-

fendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this Court

lacks jurisdiction over the claims stated in this paragraph and,

furthermore, this paragraph fails to state a claim upon which

relief can be granted.

18. The allegations of paragraph 18 are denied and the

defendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this Court

lacks jurisdiction over the claim stated in this paragraph.

19. The allegations of paragraph 19 are denied and the

defendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this Court

lacks jurisdiction over the claim stated in this paragraph.

20. The allegations of paragraph 20 are denied and the

defendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this Court

lacks jurisdiction over the claim stated in this paragraph.

21. The allegations of paragraph 21 are denied and the

State defendants allege by way of affirmative defense that this

Court lacks jurisdiction over any claim stated in this para-

22. The allegations of paragraph 22 are admitted.

23. The defendants admit that plaintiff has at the present

time one state timber sale contract (the Icy Cape No. 1

Timber on which it is conducting operations and

that it is expected that the Icy Cape No. 1 contract

will be finished in two or three operating seasons. The defend-

ants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a

5la

belief as to the truth of the allegation that plaintiff will face the

prospect of having to cease logging operations by reason of the

unavailability of timber unless it is permitted to bid on the Icy

Cape No. 2 timber sale. The State defendants specifically deny

the further allegation that plaintiff will suffer irreparable harm

unless the sale is enjoined.

24.-26. The allegations of paragraphs 24 through 26 are

denied.

27. The allegations of paragrah 27 are conclusions of law

which require no response. However, the defendants specifi-

cally deny that in the event that this Court concludes that the

sale term of primary manufacture is unconstitutional and the

State decides not to re-offer the sale without the primary

manufacture requirement, cancellation of the sale would in any

way punish plaintiff for insisting upon its constitutional rights.

Furthermore, defendants assert that this Court would have no

legal grounds or power to order defendants to continue the

proceedings for the Icy Cape No. 2 timber sale and to require

the State to hold the sale without the primary manufacture

requirement.

WHEREFORE, defendants pray that:

1. This complaint be dismissed.

2. That defendants recover their costs and attorneys fees

incurred in defending this action.

3. That defendants recover the full cost of cancelling and

rescheduling the sale from the bond submitted by plaintiff in

connection with the temporary restraining order.

DATED this 5th day of November, 1980.

Respectfully submitted,

WILSON L. CONDON

ATTORNEY GENERAL

By:/s/ Shelley J.

Sueuiey J.

Assistant Attorney General

STATE OF ALASKA HOUSE OR

REPRESENTATIVES RESOLUTION NO. 3 (1979)

_ (EXHIBIT A TO MEMORANDUM OF

SOUTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT IN

SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION,

FILED NOV. 18, 1980)

rc

1

52a

STATE OF ALASKA

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

1979

Source House

Resolve No.

HR 5 3

Relating to an amendment to the Icy Cape No. 1 timber sale,

contract number SC-182, permitting exportation of round logs.

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTA-

TIVES:

WHEREAS the Alaska Department of Natural Re-

sources let atimber sale contract in Icy Cape in 1969 which

specifically prohibited the exportation of round logs as a

marketable commodity; and

WHEREAS, as a result of state policy requiring pri-

manufacture of timber in the state, several sawmills

in have established sawmill operations suitable for

primary manufacture of timber; an

WHEREAS people who work in these sawmills are

permanent members of their communities, and the saw-

mills are an integral part of the economies of the communi-

ties in which they are located; and

WHEREAS in January, 1979 the state amended the Icy

Cape No. 1 timber sale contract, waiving the requirement

of 2 ewe of logs in the state contrary to its

; an

stated po

WHEREAS waiving of the pri manufacture re-

quirements for timber harvested in will create

great hardships not only for those people who will be

unemployed with the closing of the sa which depend

on — manufact of logs, but also for the affected

communi — which will lose an economically viable in-

WHEREAS the find made by the Department of

Natural Resources which brought Prone the waiver of

53a

primary manufacture appear to discriminate in favor of

the company holding the timber sale contract; and

WHEREAS wilderness pro under RARE II and

pending (d)(2) legislation will most likely reduce the

availability of timber in Alaska from other sources;

BE IT RESOLVED by the House of Representatives

that the amendment which waived primary manufacture

in the Icy Cape No. 1 timber sale is not in the best interests

of the state and its citizens, and be it

FURTHER RESOLVED that round logs from the Icy

Cape timber sale contract continue to be made available

under the timber sale contract to those sawmills in the

state which are capable and willing to process these logs

into lumber to provide local employment as well as build-

ing materials for the Alaska market; and be it

FURTHER RESOLVED that the House of Represent-

atives respectfully requests the Governor to direct the

Department of Natural Resources to reevaluate the

amendment waiving primary manufacture of timber in the

state giving due consideration to all parties who would be

adversely affected by permitting export of round logs.

SENATE RESOLUTION NO. 9 (1979) (EXHIBIT B

TO MEMORANDUM OF SOUTH-CENTRAL

TIMBER DEVELOPMENT IN SUPPORT OF

SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION, FILED NOV.

18, 1980)

54a

STATE OF ALASKA

SENATE

1979

Source Senate

Resolve No.

SR 6 9

oa

Relating to an amendment to the Icy Cape No. 1 timber sale,

contract number SC-182, permitting exportation of round logs.

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE SENATE:

WHEREAS the Alaska Department of Natural Re-

sources let a poet tar gt mageamne in Icy “pe in pes which

specifically prohibi e exportation of round logs as a

— commodity; and

WHEREAS, as a result of state policy requiring pri-

2 re of timber in the state, several sawmi

in have established sawmill operations suitable for

primary manufacture of timber;

WHEREAS people who work in these sawmills are

permanent members of their communities, and the saw-

mills are an integral part of the economies of the communi-

ties in which they are located; and

WHEREAS in January, 1979, the state amended the

Icy No. 1 timber sale contract, waiving the require-

ment of pri manufacture of logs in the state contrary

to its stated policy;

ai

55a

WHEREAS wilderness pro under RARE II and

pending (d)(2) legislation will most likely reduce the

availability of timber in Alaska from other sources;

BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate that the amendment

which waived 7 manufacture in the Icy Cape No. 1

timber sale is not in the best interests of the state and its

citizens; and be it

FURTHER RESOLVED that round logs from the Icy

Cape timber sale contract continue to be made available

under the timber sale contract to those sawmills in the

state which are capable and willing to process these — 5

into lumber to provide local employment as well as build-

ing materials for the Alaska market; and be it

FURTHER RESOLVED that the Senate respectfully

requests the Governor to direct the Department of Natu-

ral Resources to reevaluate the amendment waiving pri-

mary manufacture of timber in the state giving due consid-

eration to all parties who would be adversely affected by

permitting export of round logs.

<

:

:

:

~~

56a

WANAMAKER, DEVEAUX & CRABTREE

A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION

909 W. 9th Ave., #140

Anchorage, Alaska 99501

(907) 279-6591

Attorneys for Plaintiff

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC.

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

Civil Action No. A80-311

SouTH-CENTRAL TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, Ixc.,

Plaintiff,

v.

ROBERT LERESCHE, Commissioner of Department of

Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

GEOFFREY HAYNES, Director, Division of Lands,

Department of Natural Resources, and Deputy Commissioner

of Department of Natural Resources of the State of Alaska;

and

THEODORE G. Surrn, Director of Division of Forest,

Land and Water Management, of Department of Natural

Resources of the State of Alaska,

Defendants.

AFFIDAVIT OF H. SUGIYAMA

STATE OF ALASKA )

) ss.

THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT )

COMES NOW H. SUGIYAMA, and being first duly sworn,

deposes and states as follows:

1. That I am the Vice President of SOUTH-CENTRAL

TIMBER DEVELOPMENT, INC. (hereinafter “SOUTH-

CENTRAL”).

57a

2. That SOUTH-CENTRAL has its principal offices at

255 E. Fireweed Lane, Anchorage, Alaska. Since 1967

SOUTH-CENTRAL has been engaged within the State of

Alaska in the business of purchasing standing timber, provid-

ing for the logging and preparation of such timber, and export-

ing the timber in foreign commerce to Japan.

3. SOUTH-CENTRAL also has a branch office in Port-

land, Oregon. From that office, purchases of logs are made

from suppliers in Washington, Oregon, and British Columbia

and those logs are exported in foreign commerce to Japan.

4. That I was present in the Courtroom of Judge von der

Heydt on October 20, 1980, at the time the MOTION FOR

TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER was argued.

5. At that time I heard the arguments of the STATE

Defendants to the effect that the sale should be allowed to

proceed and SOUTH-CENTRAL could then bid in the sale,

and if it wished to challenge primary manufacture, could then

file suit challenging said primary manufacture requirement.

6. This possible course of action has been evaluated by me

in my capacity as Vice President of SOUTH-CENTRAL. The

evaluation has included study of the “Prospectus - Icy Cape

No. 2” attached as Exhibits to the AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES

N. WANAMAKER and the “Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale

Contract” attached hereto as Exhibit A (for this purpose only

the principal legal provisions are reproduced and the volumi-

nous maps, diagrams, and technical provisions attached to the

contract have not been included).

7. Inthe process of such analysis, I came to the following

conclusions as set forth in this affidavit:

A. That as d preface to bidding on Icy Cape No. 2 Timber

Sale it would be necessary to make a cash deposit of $836,000.

(See Prospectus.)

B. That the Prospectus provides that the $836,000 will be

forfeited if the proposed Icy Cape No. 2 contract is not signed.

58a

The exact words are found at page 4 . Prospectus as

follows:

“The deposit furnished by the successful bidder whose bid

was d acceptable shall be retained as liquidated

damages if the successful bidder does not execute the

contract and furnish satisfactory bonds within 30 days of

receipt of contract.”

C. That if the Icey Cape No. 2 Timber Sale Contract were

signed by SOUTH-CENTRAL, it would surely then be argued

that SOUTH-CENTRAL had waived its argument against

primary manufacture. Also, this step would increase SOUTH-

CENTRAL’s exposure since it would be necessary to post a

Performance Bond of $836,000 as a part of signing the contract.

(See Prospectus and Section 8 of Contract.)

D. Also, it is my evaluation that the STATE OF ALASKA

could insist that a challenge to primary manufacture after

contract signing would be a failure to abide by contract terms of

Icy Cape No. 2 Contract, thereby exposing the Performarce

Bond to being drawn upon. (Section 8 of Contract.)

E. Thus, it is my overall evaluation that by following the

plan of bidding in the timber sale and then suing to remove the

primary manufacture requirement, SOUTH-CENTRAL

would expose the corporation to the potential loss of the

$836,000 cash deposit, on the one hand, or the argument of

waiver and proceedings under the $836,000 Performance

Bond, on the other hand.

8. I reasonably believe that a deposit with the STATE OF

ALASKA of $836,000 would be placed in the General Fund of

the STATE and thus beyond the control of this Court, it being

the case that the Federal Court has jurisdiction only over

Officers of the STATE and not over the STATE itself.

9. SOUTH-CENTRAL has been a small but healthy com-

pany over its 13 years of legal existence. It is not, however,

sufficiently wealthy to risk the total loss of the cash deposit of

$836,000 or proceedings against its $836,000 Performance

Bond, if posted. This would be an unacceptably severe financial

burden to the company.

59a

10. Thus, the concept of bidding on the Icy Cape No. 2

Timber Sale Contract and then suing to enjoin primary manu-

facture is beyond the financial reach of SOUTH-CENTRAL.

11. If this Court should permit that the Icy Cape No. 2

Timber Sale could continue as first noticed and with primary“

manufacture required, economics would prohibit SOUTH-

CENTRAL from bidding in the contract and suing.

12. I have evaluated the prospect of establishing a method

of waste disposal for the sawdust and slabs which would result

from a resumption of the primary manufacture slabbing pro-

cess at SOUTH-CENTRAL’s Jakalof Bay mill. I have con-

cluded that there is no system of waste disposal which would

meet Alaska environmental requirements which could be in-

stalled and amortized within the 49 million board foot volume of

the Icy Cape No. 2 Timber Sale.

FURTHER YOUR AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.

DATED this 18th day of November, 1980.

/s/ H. Sugiyama

H. SUGIYAMA

SUBSCRIBED and SWORN to before me this 18th day of

November, 1980.

/s/

Notary Public for Alaska

My commission expires:

60a

ICY CAPE NO. 2 TIMBER SALE CONTRACT

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Section 1. Incorporation of Full Terms and Conditions 1

Section 2. Re cons— Exhibit 1

Section 3. Contract Modification .................. l

Section 4. Sale of Amber 1

Section 5. 2 ity of Timber 1

Section 6. „„ „„ 2

Section 7. Duration of Contract .................. 2

Section 8. Performance Bond 2

Section 9. Completion Date of Contract ........... 2

Sale Area—Title to Timber

Section 10. Timber Sale Areae˖e˖e 2

Section 11. Title to Timber 2

Section 12. Right to Cut and Remove Timber 2

D Růͤiqiᷣᷣ . 2

Examination— Work — Material

Section 14. Examination of Locations and Conditions 3

Section 15. Permits— Licenses —Safet .

Section 16. Materials Improvementssz 3

Section 17. Responsibility for Work ................ 4

Section 18. Final Inspection: 4

Section 19. Materials from State Property .......... 4

Section 20. Prosecution of the Work ............... 4

Logging Timber Sale Area

Section 21. Notification of Operation ............... 4

Section 22. Annual Operating Plan ................ 4

Section 23. to Reserved Trees ............ 5

Section 24. Mon At ee 5

Section 25. Slash Disposa!l!l . 6

Section = Protection of the Watershed ............ :

Section 98. Bronervadion af and Monuments 6

Section 29. Simultaneous Use of Area.............. 7

Section 30. Primary Road Maintenance ............ 7

Section 31. Maintenance Defined .................. 7

Section 32. Secondary Road Maintenance ........... 8

Fire Protection

Section 33. Fire Protectioas x

6la

Payment Bond—Indemnity

Section 34. Payment Bonn s

cans seccnccsctcceccecer s

Administration of Contract

Section 36. Extension of Time ..................... 9

Section 37. Alterations in Detail ...................

Section 38. Reservations for Scenic Purposes, Fish and

Wildlife Habitat Protection 9

Section 39. Violations, Suspensions and Cancellation 9

Section 40. Subletting of Contra et. 10

Section 41. Assignment of Contract ................ 10

r ͤ cceeccce ee 10

Section 43. Authorized Representative ............. 10

Section 44. Inspections and Records ............... 11

Section 45. Removal of Equipment and Materials 11

Section 46. Causes Beyond Controll 11

Section 47. Laws, Regulations and Orders 11

Special Provisions

Section 48. Designated Timber 12

Section 49. Payment Schedule 12

Section 50. Purchase Price ee 12

Section 51. Rate Redetermination ................. 12

Section 52. Merchantable Logg 12

Section 53. Log Measurement ...................5. 13

Section 54. Penalty Scale. 14

De ᷑ . ewes ccece 14

Section 56. Felling Exceptions .................... 14

Section 57: Timber Removal Schedule ............. 14

Séction GB. e 14

Section 59. Tree Marking 15

Section 60. Method of Yarding .................... 15

Section 61. ae CS SR et 15

Se è eae 15

Section 63. Road and Landing Construction ........ 15

Section 64. Road Maintenance ..................... 16

e ̃᷑ ˙ W . e 16

Section 66. Fire Protectic enen 16

Section 67. Camp Facilities 18

Section 68. Manufacture 18

Section 69. Bond Reduction 18

Section 70. eee eee 19

7¹. eee 1

Ht

;

ADL No. 203002

STATE OF ALASKA

DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES

DIVISION OF FOREST, LAND AND WATER MANAGE-

MENT

Timber Sale Contract No. -SC 557

Timber Sale Name-Icy Cape No. 2

This contract, made and entered into duplicate this day of

— by and between the STATE OF ALASKA DE-

TMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES, by and through

the Director, Division of Forest, Land and Water Manage-

ment, hereinafter called “STATE,” and

hereinafter called “PURCHASER,” which parties do hereby

agree as follows:

Section 1. Incorporation of Full Terms and Conditions.

This contract incorporates and is inclusive of all terms and

conditions between the parties hereto, either oral or written,

expressed or implied, relating to the subject matter of the

contract.

Section 2. Regulations—Erhibits.

(a) The State Timber Sale Regulations in effect on the

effective date of the contract are considered a provision of this

contract and have the same effect and force as any other

provision of this contract (11 AAC 76.135). Subsequent State

Forest Resources and Practices Act (AS 41.17.010 et seq)

Regulations shall be treated similarly.

(b) The following designated Exhibits, attached hereto,

are by this reference made a part of this contract:

(1) Exhibit “A”. .

(2) Exhibit B“.

(3) Exhibit C“.

(4) Exhibit D“.

63a

Section 3. Contract Modification. This contract can be

modified only by written agreement of the parties.

Section 4. Sale of Timber. Under the terms and conditions

of this contract, STATE hereby sells to PURCHASER, and

PURCHASER hereby buys from STATE, that timber desig-

nated and described in Section 49 of this contract, which timber

for all purposes of this contract is hereinafter referred to as

“timber.” The timber is located on the area or areas shown on

Exhibit “A”. PURCHASER shall pay STATE the purchase

price for timber set forth in Section 50. PURCHASER shall

pay tne purchase price for timber to STATE in accordance

with the payment schedule in Section 49 of this contract.

Section 5. Quantity—Quality of Timber. STATE makes

no guarantee or warranty to PURCHASER as to the quantity

or quality of the timber.

Section 6. Work to be Done. For all purposes of this con-

tract, “work” shall be understood to mean the furnishing of all

labor, materials, equipment, and other incidentals necessary

or convenient to the successful completion of the project,

duties and obligations, including slash disposal, imposed on

PURCHASER by this contract.

Section 7. Duration of Contract. Time is of the essence of

this contract, and PURCHASER shall complete and fully per-

form this contract within the time designated in. Section 9,

below, unless extended in accordance with Section 37, hereof;

provided, however, that under Section 26, hereof, PUR-

CHASER may be reqyired to dispose of slash at a time later

than set forth in Sections 9 or 37, hereof.

Section 8. Performance Bond. PURCHASER shall fur-

nish STATE with a performance bond in the amount of

he bond shall guarantee complete compliance by PUR-

CHASER with the terms and conditions of this contract, and

the faithful performance of all obligations required of PUR-

CHASER by this contract.

Section 9. Completion of Date of Contract. The completion

date of this contract shall be

64a

STANDARD PROVISIONS

SALE AREA — TITLE TO TIMBER

Section 10. Timber Sale Area. The timber is located on the

timber sale area. For all purposes of this contract, “timber sale

area” shall be understood to mean the area or the areas desig-

nated as such on Exhibit “A.” The boundaries of the timber sale

area are located by reference to legal subdivisions, monu-

ments, natural land features, improvements or sale boundary

signs, which references are designated on Exhibit “A.”

Section 11. Title to Timber. The ownership of and title to

the timber shall pass to PUROHASER from time to time as

and when any of the timber is paid for, cut, and scaled. How-

ever, any right of PURCHASER to cut and remove the timber

shall expire and end at the time this contract, or any extension

thereof, terminates; and further, all rights and interests of

PURCHASER, in and to the timber, and logs therefrom;

remaining on the timber sale area at said time, shall at that

time automatically revert to and revest in STATE, without

compensation to PURCHASER.

Section 12. Right to Cut and Remove Timber. During the

period of this contract, and any extension thereof, PURCHAS-

ER shall have the right to cut and remove the timber; pro-

vided, however, the right to cut and remove timber shall be

conditioned upon PURCHASER complying with the provi-

sions of this contract.

Section 13. Access. PURCHASER may use the primary or

secondary roads shown or indicated on Exhibit “A” for access

to the timber sale area. The use of said roads shall be limited to

that use necessary in carrying out the terms and provisions of

this contract. PURCHASER shall comply with all applicable

terms and conditions of any access road easements or agree-

ments set forth in the Special Provisions of this contract, which

easements or agreements are by this reference made a part of

this contract as if fully set forth herein. Except as is otherwise

provided for in this contract, PURCHASER shall have the

65a

right of access over, in and through the timber sale area for the

purposes of cutting and removing the timber, or performing

the work to be done; such right shall be inclusive of the use and

improvement of existing roads, and the construction and use of

new roads. STATE shall first approve any improvement or

construction before the start of construction. PURCHASER

in so using, improving or constructing such roads shall at no

time have an interest in the land, other than said right of

access.

EXAMINATION—WORK—MATERIALS

Section 14. Examination of Locations and Conditions. It

is understood that PURCHASER, before signing this con-

tract, has made a careful examination of all plans and specifica-

tions set forth in this contract; that PURCHASER has

obtained full information as to the quality and quantity of

materials and the character of the work required; and that

PURCHASER has made a careful examination of the timber

sale area and the location and conditions of work, including

sources of supply for materials. STATE in no case will be

responsible for any loss or cost that may be suffered by PUR-

CHASER as a result of the failure of PURCHASER to be so

informed.

Section 15. Permits—Licenses—Safety. PURCHASER

shall procure all permits and licenses, pay all charges and fees,

and give all notices necessary and incident to the due and lawful

prosecution of the work unless otherwise approved in writing

by STATE. In the performance of the work to be done under

this contract, PURCHASER shall use every reasonable and

practicable means to avoid damage to property and inj

persons. PURCHASER shall use no means or methods which

will endanger, unnecessarily, either persons or property. The

responsibility of PURCHASER stated herein shall cease upon

the work being accepted as complete by STATE.

PURCHASER shall comply with the current “Logging and

Sawmill Safety Code.”

66a

Section 16. Materials—Improvements. Title to materials,

improvements and other property, required of PURCHASER

by this contract, shall vest in and become the property of

. STATE at the time such are furnished by PURCHASER and

accepted by STATE. Only materials, improvements and prop-

erty free and clear of liens, claims and encumbrances shall be so

furnished by PURCHASER. Existing improvements in the

sale area, owned by STATE, may be used by PURCHASER in

connection with this sale without further approval unless such

use is limited or prevented elsewhere in this contract. Existing

improvements when used by PURCHASER shall be kept in

good repair. Any improvements or transportation facilities

including sawmills, buildings, bridges, roads, etc. constructed

by PURCHASER in connection with this sale and within the

sale area or on other STATE land leased for the purpose must

be authorized by, and must be in accordance with standard or

special plans approved by STATE.

Section 17. Responsibility for Work. Before completion

and final acceptance of work PURCHASER shall be held re-

sponsible for any injury or damage to the work or to any part

thereof by action of the elements, or from any cause whatsoev-

er, and PURCHASER shall make good all injuries or damages

to any portion of the work.

Section 18. Final Inspection. Except as otherwise pro-

vided in the Special Provisions of this contract, STATE will

make final inspection of work done by PURCHASER within 10

days after written notification to STATE by PURCHASER

that the work is completed. If the work is not acceptable to

STATE, then STATE will so advise PURCHASER in writing

as to the particular defects to be remedied before final accept-

ance by STATE can be made.

Section 19. Materials from State Property. PURCHAS-

ER shall not take, sell, use, remove or otherwise dispose of any

sand, gravel, rock, earth or other material obtained or pro-

duced from within the limits of rights of way, gravel pits, rock

quarries or other property owned by or held by STATE, unless

authorized by this contract or written consent of STATE.

67a

Section 20. Prosecution of the Work. PURCHASER shall

not commence work to be done under this contract until the

contract has been fully executed.

LOGGING TIMBER SALE AREA

Section 21. Notification of Operation. At least 30 days

before commencement of operations on the contract area PUR-

CHASER shall notify STATE, in writing, of the date he plans

to begin operation; PURCHASER shall also notify STATE, in

writing, if he intends to cease operation for a period of 15 or

more days.

Section 22. Annual Operating Plan. PURCHASER shall,

prior to commencing any work, and prior to the start of opera-

tions each year thereafter, submit to STATE for review and

approval an operating plan which shall be followed except as

modified in writing. The Operating Plan shall be in writing and

shall show:

(1) Sale contract number and name.

(2) Approximate date project work will commence.

(3) Approximate date logging operations will com-

mence.

(4) Authorized representatives of PURCHASER, as

required by Section 44.

(5) Portions of the required 8 work or logging

operations to be subcontracted, if any, and the names of

such subcontractors as required by Section 41.

(6) General location of spur roads not designated on

— “A” which may be constructed pursuant to See-

tion 13.

(7) Location of tractor yarding roads, if approval of

such by STATE is required in this contract.

(8) Temporary stream crossings, where necessary to

protect the watershed, as — by Section 27.

(9) Location of landings and probable sequence of

logging.

68a

(10) Log brand or brands to be used on logs from the

timber sale area.

PURCHASER shall log the timber sale area and construct

the projects in a workmanlike and orderly manner using the

methods and practices generally acceptable in the logging in-

dustry. The schedule of approximate starting dates and the

sequence of logging may be subject to modification when ne-

cessitated by weather or other unpredictable circumstances,

provided PURCHASER gives 15 days notice to STATE.

STATE will furnish PURCHASER additional copies of Ex-

hibit “A” or other suitable maps which PURCHASER shall

use for showing locations of work specified in (6), (7), (8) and (9)

of this section.

STATE will, within a reasonable period of time acknowledge

in writing to PURCHASER the receipt of the Operations

Plan, and shall designate to PURCHASER the authorized

field representative of STATE to be readily available to the

area of construction and logging operations and to receive

notices in regard to performance under this contract.

STATE will within a reasonable period of time of receipt of

the Operations Plan review the plan and give to PURCHAS-

ER written notice of approval or disapproval.

When the Operating Plan contains information PURCHAS-

ER is required to furnish to STATE by other sections of this

contract, written approval of the Operating Plan by STATE

will constitute acceptance and approval of such information.

Any deviation from the approved plan must have prior writ-

ten authorization from STATE and may require amendment of

the approved plan. Authorization from STATE to deviate from

the approved plan shall be requested in writing by PUR-

CHASER. Unapproved deviation from the plan may be cause

for suspensions of operations under this contract.

Section 23. Damage to Reserved Trees. For purposes of

this section, “reserved trees” are those trees on the timber sale

area, or on adjoining STATE property, which are not sold to or

69a

are not to be cut by PURCHASER. If in connection with

operations under this contract the PURCHASER, his con-

tractors, subcontractors, or employees of any of them, cuts,

injures, or removes any reserved trees, PURCHASER shall

pay for such trees at rates determined by STATE as follows:

(1) Damage to reserved trees in the course of normal logg-

ing shall be paid for at the current contract rate.

(2) Damage to reserved trees caused by negligent or care-

less operatiofis dt PU REHASER shall be paid for at double the

current contract rate.

(3) Repeated damage to reserved trees will be cause for

suspension of this contract.

(4) Payment shall be made by PURCHASER within 10

days after written demand by STATE; provided, the payment

for reserved trees shall not release PURCHASER from liabil-

ity for other damage to the property of STATE.

Section 24. Monthly Report. On or before the 10th day of

each month that this contract is in effect, PURCHASER shall

provide STATE with a written report revealing the net board

foot volume of timber removed from the timber sale area for

the previous month. For recovery or scale sales, such report

shall itemize by certificate number or ticket number the net

scale volume of all logs, by species scaled during the preceding

calendar month. All books and records relating to scale shall be

kept in accurate and complete form by PURCHASER, and the

same shall be available-for the inspection of STATE or its

representatives at all reasonable and convenient times and

places.

Section 25. Slash Disposal. The term “slash” used in this

contract means all debris resulting from logging operations,

construction of roads or other improvements, or windthrow

timber within the sale area. PURCHASER shall bunch slash

in tractor-yarded areas as directed by STATE. PURCHASER

agrees to treat or dispose other of slash as STATE may re-

quire, and at such times and in such manner as STATE may

specify.

70a

Section 26. Protection of the Watershed. PURCHASER

shall take all practicable precautions to prevent damage to the

soil, stream banks, and any stream course, lake or reservoir on

or near the timber sale area, and to that end shall comply with

Alaska laws and with regulations promulgated under the

Forest Resources and Practices Act.

In addition to other protective measures required herein,

PURCHASER shall discontinue all or part of the operations

under this contract upon notice from STATE that due to

weather conditions such operations will cause excessive dam-

age to the watershed.

PURCHASER shall:

(1) Fell adjacent trees away from or parallel to the stream

channel so that such trees do not fall or slide into the stream

channel.

(2) Not operate tractors within 100 feet of streams, unless

authorized in writing by STATE.

(3) Not cable-yard logs across streams unless approved by

STATE in the Operating Plan.

Section 27. Safeguarding Improvements. All existing im-

provements located on or in the timber sale area, and, any

improvements placed on or in the timber sale area by PUR-

CHASER which become the property of STATE, shall be

safeguarded by PURCHASER, and if injured or damaged by

PURCHASER or by contractors of PURCHASER, shall be

repaired as soon as possible to previously existing conditions

by PURCHASER, without cost to STATE.

Section 28. Preservation of Markings and Monuments.

PURCHASER shall not remove, alter, damage or destroy any

signs, posters, land survey corners, witness trees, or corner

reference tags pertaining to the timber sale or land survey. If

PURCHASER unintentionally damages or disturbs any such

markings or monuments, PURCHASER shall be immediately

report that occurrence to STATE, and further damage or

disturbance shall be prevented by PURCHASER. If PUR-

71a

CHASER damages or disturbs any such markings or monu-

ments, or fails to immediately report such to STATE, or

completely destroys any land survey corner, PURCHASER

shall re-establish such markings, monuments or corners at his

expense to the standards prescribed by STATE.

In the event it is necessary, for the conduct of logging

operations or road construction, to disturb any legal land sur-

vey corner, PURCHASER shall so notify STATE and shall

not disturb such corner until PURCHASER has referenced or

otherwise preserved the corner, in a manner acceptable to

STATE.

Section 29. Simultaneous Use of Area. STATE reserves

the right to issue written authorization to others to use the

timber sale area or access roads thereto, provided, in the

determination of STATE, such use will not materially in-

terfere with the operations of PURCHASER. STATE further

reserves the right to sell from the timber sale area during the

period of this contract any products or materials not covered

by the terms of this contract; provided that removal of such

products or materials shall not materially interfere with the

operations of PURCHASER. PURCHASER shall not unduly

interfere with the use of roads by other authorized users.

PURCHASER shall not be held liable for any acts, omissions

or neglect of authorized simultaneous users.

Section 30. Primary Road Maintenance. If PURCHAS-

ER is the only user of the primary roads as shown or indicated

on Exhibit “A,” then PURCHASER shall perform all normal

road maintenace, as defined in Section 31, which is made neces-

sary by his use. If PURCHASER jointly uses the roads with

other parties authorized under this contract, each shall be

responsible for a proportionate part of the normal mainte-

nance, based upon the ratio of each parties’ use to total road

use.

If STATE, during any period of this contract, cause any of

the primary roads to be maintained by STATE equipment,

through road maintenance contracts with independent con-

tractors, or through agreement with third party users, then

72a

PURCHASER shall pay to STATE or to the third party at the

rates per thousand board feet, net scale, for all logs hauled by

PURCHASER over such roads, as set forth in the special

provisions of this contract. If STATE terminates the con-

tracted or third party maintenance during the period of this

contract, PURCHASER shall remain responsible for all nor-

mal maintenance of the roads, or for a proportionate part of the

maintenance during periods of joint use with other authorized

users.

Section 31.~Maintenance Defined. Normal maintenance

shall include work needed to protect the road from seasonal

weather damage, to restore damage or wear caused by PUR-

CHASER’S use, and to safeguard soil, water, and drainage

structures, as follows:

(a) Maintenance of the existing cross section of dirt,

gravelled, or shot rock road by blading or shaping surface and

shoulders. Banks shall not be undercut, and established berms

shall be maintained. Additional berms shall be placed where

needed to protect fills.

(b) Removal of bank slough, minor slides and fallen timber,

replacement of material eroded from fill slopes and by minor

washouts, and cleaning out of ditches and culverts. The work

shall be that which can practically be accomplished by a motor

patrol grader equipped with a front end blade, or comparable

equipment, and by the use of hand tools.

(c) Preventive maintenance at the end of PURCHASER’S

hauling each season to minimize weather damage during the

non-hauling period. This may include shaping and grading,

cross-ditching, and removal of debris from any stream channel,

when the debris was caused by PURCHASER’S activities and

when the debris is endangering or will cause damage to roads,

bridges, or culverts.

(d) Patching and additional rocking of gravel road surfaces

as determined necessary by STATE to repair or restore dam-

age and wear caused by PURCHASER’S operations.

73a

(e) Removal of brush or tree growth or other obstructions

to visibility as the obstructions develop during the contract

period. Herbicides may be used only with written authoriza-

tion of STATE.

While performing normal maintenance work, PURCHAS-

ER shall avoid leaving dirt or debris on gravel or bituminous

road surfaces. PURCHASER shall avoid blading surface

material off surface of roads, and shall minimize damage to

road surfaces and ditches caused by logging operations, and

shall restore the road to its original condition within a reason-

able period of time.

Section 32. Secondary Road Maintenance. Secondary

truck roads used or constructed by PURCHASER shall be

kept free of obstructions and maintained in a condition to

permit travel by standard-drive automobiles during any period

of log hauling operations under this contract, and during closed

fire season. PURCHASER shall leave these roads open and

passable upon completion of operations under this contract,

unless otherwise instructed by STATE.

FIRE PROTECTION

Section 33. Fire Protection. PURCHASER shall take all

necessary precautions for the prevention of forest fires and

shall be responsible for the suppression and bear the suppres-

sion costs of any and all fires occuring within or without the

contract area resulting from any and all operations involved in

the removal of the timber under the provisions of this contract.

The Alaska Forest Protection Act (AS 41.15.010 et seq.)

established the fire season from May 1 - September 30. AS

41.15.080 requires every person owning or operating a sawmill

or logging camp or other commercial plant or operation in

forested lands to post and keep displayed at all times a copy of

AS 41.15.050 — 080 and AS 41.15.140 in a conspicuous place

upon the building or ground of the milling, logging or commer-

cial operation.

74a

PAYMENT BOND—INDEMNITY

Section 34. Payment Bond. PURCHASER shall furnish

an acceptable bond in the form of surety bond, cash bond,

negotiable securities or an individual surety bond acceptable to

STATE to guarantee payments for timber from this timber

sale contract between STATE and PURCHASER. The bond

or securities shall be in the amount of $250,000. When the

payment bond has been furnished to STATE, the bid deposit

will be refunded to PURCHASER.

Section 35. Indemnity. PURCHASER shall be responsi-

ble and liable for all accidents, damage or injury to any person

or property resulting from any activities, duties and obliga-

tions of PURCHASER under this contract for which PUR-

CHASER may be legally liable, and PURCHASER shall hold

blameless and harmless, and shall indemnify, the State of

Alaska and its officers, employees and agents against any and

all claims, demands, loss, injury, damage, actions and costs of

actions whatsoever, which they or any of them may sustain by

reasons of any act, omission or neglect of PURCHASER, or

employees, agents, representatives or contractors of PUR-

CHASER, in connection with the activities, duties and obliga-

tions of PURCHASER under this contract.

ADMINISTRATION OF CONTRACT

Section 36. Extension of Time. An extension of time of this

contract, not to exceed one year at a time, will be approved by

STATE only upon written request from PURCHASER and

with the written consent of the surety of PURCHASER; an

extension will be granted only upon a showing by PURCHAS-

ER that the failure to perform this contract within the speci-

fied period was due to causes beyond the control of PUR-

CHASER and without fault or negligence of PURCHASER.

The written request must be received not later than 30 days or

earlier than 90 days before the expiration date of this contract.

The request shall state the date to which the extension is

desired and must describe the conditions which have pre-

vented PURCHASER from completing this contract within

the specified time.

N

T5a

Section 37. Alterations in Details. STATE reserves the

right to make, at any time during the progress of the work to be

done, the minor changes or alterations in cutting boundaries,

drainage structures, etc. as STATE may determine to be

necessary or desirable. However, the changes or alterations

shall not change the character of the work to be done, nor

increase the cost thereof unless the cost increase is approved in

writing by PURCHASER. Any changes or alterations so

made shall not invalidate this contract nor release the surety of

PURCHASER on the performance bond, and, PURCHASER

agrees to do the work as changed or altered as if it had been

part of the original contract.

Section 38. Reservations for Scenic Purposes, Fish and

Wildlife Habitat Protection. STATE may reserve from desig-

nated cutting units timber that (a) has or may subsequently

develop special scenic values in connection with water courses

and recreational sites, or (b) cannot be logged without disturb-

ing wildlife and fisheries habitat under AS 16.05.840, AS

16.05.870 and AS 41.17.010, et seq. Insofar as practical, the

STATE shall identify these reservations before the purchaser

submits his annual Operating Plan. Reservations under this

section will be confined to the smallest reasonable area neces-

sary and will not reserve more than five million board feet of

spruce and hemlock from the cutting units as designated on

Exhibit “A.”

Section 39. Violations, Suspension and Cancellation.

(1) If PURCHASER violates any of the terms or condi-

tions of this contract, including the approved Operating Plan,

STATE shall notify PURCHASER in writing of the violation,

and allow a reasonable period of time to comply with the

contract. If satisfactory compliance is not made within the time

allowed, STATE may suspend by written notice further opera-

tions under the contract, except those operations as may be

necessary to remedy the violation. The suspension will con-

tinue in effect until PURCHASER complies with the contract

in a manner satisfactory to STATE.

76a

(2) STATE may immediately suspend by written notice

further operations that, in the judgment of STATE, constitute

a threat of immediate and unacceptable resource damage or an

immediate threat to human life.

(3) If PURCHASER fails to remedy violations of this con-

tract within 30 days after receipt of the notice of violation given

under this section, STATE may, by written notice, cancel this

contract and take appropriate action to recover all damages

suffered by STATE by reason of the violations, including appli-

cation of the payment bond and/or performance bond toward

payment of the damages.

Section 40. Subletting of Contract. It is understood and

agreed that, if all or any part of the logging operations or work

to be done under this contract is subcontracted, the sub-

contracting done by PURCHASER will in no way relieve

PURCHASER of any responsibility under this contract.

PURCHASER will notify STATE of the names and addresses

of all subcontractors. Subcontracting must be acceptable to

STATE.

Section 41. Assignment of Contract. PURCHASER

agrees not to assign, transfer, convey or otherwise dispose of

this contract, or the right, title, or interest therein, either in

whole or in part, or the power of PURCHASER to execute this

contract, to any other person, firm, or corporation, without the

previous written consent of STATE.

Section 42. Notices. Any written notice to PURCHASER

which may be required under this contract to be served on

PURCHASER by STATE, may be served by personal deliv-

ery to PURCHASER or the designated representative or

representatives of PURCHASER, or by mailing the notice to

the address of PURCHASER as given in the contract, or by

leaving the notice at that address. If PURCHASER is re-

quired to notify STATE concerning the progress of the work to

be done, or concerning any matter or complaint which PUR-

CHASER may bave to make regarding the contract subject

matter, or for any other reason, that notification must be made

77a

in writing, delivered to the designated representative of

STATE in person, or mailed to the address of STATE as given

in this contract.

Section 43. Authorized Representative. During any period

of logging operations or activity on the timber sale area, and

during any period of doing the work required by this contract

on location, PURCHASER shall have a designated represen-

tative or representatives available to STATE on the timber

sale area or work location, or both where the activity is sepa-

rated; the representative or representatives shall be autho-

rized to receive on behalf of PURCHASER any notice or

instructions from STATE and to take whatever action may be

required in regard to performance of PURCHASER under

this contract. STATE shall designate an authorized field rep-

resentative or representatives who shall be authorized to re-

ceive notices, inspect progress of work, and issue instructions

in regard to performance under the terms of this contract.

Section 44. Inspections and Records. STATE, through its

authorized and designated representative or representatives,

shall at all reasonable times be allowed access to all parts of the

logging operations and work locations of PURCHASER, and

shall be furnished all information and assistance by PUR-

CHASER, or the designated representative or representa-

tives of PURCHASER, as STATE may require to make a

mplete and detailed inspection.

STATE through its authorized and designated representa-

tives, shall have access at all reasonable times to the books and

records of PURCHASER, his contractors, and sub-

contractors relating to operations under this contract including

operating cost data and selling price data. Information so

obtained shall be treated as confidential and used solely for the

administration of this contract.

Section 45. Removal of Equipment and Materials. It is

understood and agreed that PURCHASER, upon completion

of the requirements of this contract, is to promptly remove

from the timber sale area and work location, and other proper-

ty owned or controlled by STATE, all equipment, materials

78a

and other property PURCHASER has placed or caused to be

placed thereon that is not to become the property of STATE. It

is further understood and agreed that any such equipment,

materials and other property that are not removed within 90

days after the day this contract terminates, or within any

longer period of time as may be agreed upon in writing between

PURCHASER and STATE, shall become the property of

STATE and may be used or otherwise disposed of by STATE

without obligation to PURCHASER or to any party to whom

PURCHASER may transfer title. Nothing in this section shall

be construed as relieving PURCHASER from an obligation to

clean up, and to burn, remove, or dispose of debris, waste, and

similar materials, in accord with other provisions of this con-

tract.

Section 46. Causes Beyond Control. In the event PUR-

CHASER is prevented by a cause or causes beyond control of

PURCHASER from performing any obligation of this con-

tract, nonperformance resulting from such cause or causes

shall not be deemed to be a breach of this contract which will

render PURCHASER liable in damages or give rise to the

cancellation of the contract. However, if and when such cause

0) -auses cease to prevent performance, PURCHASER shall

exercise all reasonable diligence to resume and complete per-

formance of the obligation with the least possible delay. The

1 — tm sar control,” as used in this sec-

any one or more of the following causes which are

not attributable to the fault or negligence of PURCHASER

and which adversely affect the operations of PURCHASER:

fire or other casualties and accidents; strikes, riots and civil

commotions; war and acts of public enemies; storms, floods and

Section 47. Laws, Regulations and Orders. PURCHAS-

ER at all times shall observe and comply with federal and state

laws, and lawful regulations issued thereunder, and loca! by-

laws, ordinances and regulations, which in any manner affect

the activities of PURCHASER under this contract.

79a

SPECIAL PROVISIONS

Section 48. Designated Timber. Pursuant to Section 4 of

this contract, the timber sold within the sale area is as follows:

All timber within Units 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12, and all

: ght-of-way timber.

The boundaries of the sale area are marked as follows:

(1) The unit boundaries are painted and flagged.

(2) The right-of-way boundaries are flagged and blazed.

Section 49. Payment Schedule. (a) PURCHASER shall

pay within 10 days of the first of each month for all timber cut

and scaled the previous month.

(b) All payments and deposits shall be made payable to the

Alaska Department of Revenue and shall be submitted to the

Southcentral District, Division of Forest, Land and Water

Management, Department of Natural Resources.

Section 50. Purchase Price. The purchase price for all

timber removed from the timber sale area shall be paid for on

the basis of net log scale, unless otherwise specified at the rates

set forth below:

Species Estimated Volume Unit Price Total Price Bid Premium

Section 51. Rate Redetermination. STATE shall redeter-

mine the stumpage rates annually. Rates will be r? termined

in February of 1981, and each February thereafter during the

life of this contract using the amendments and interim updates

of the United State Forest Service for the fourth quarter of the

previous year.

To determine stumpage rates STATE will use procedures in

effect in the Timber Appraisal Handbook of the United States

Forest Service at the time of the redetermination. Bid Pre-

mium rates shall be added to all redetermined rates.

Section 52. Merchantable Logs. PURCHASER shall re-

move all products from the sale area which meet the merchan-

tability standards stated herein:

80a

Any conifer log which is 12 feet or more in length, and is 6

inches or more in scaling diameter and which will produce

not less than 50 percent of the gross volume in firm,

useable chips.

PURCHASER may remove logs from timber sold on the

sale area which do not meet the standards listed below.

Section 53. Log Measurement.

(1) Scaling Locations, Rules, Scaling Parties. All logs from

timber sold under the terms and conditions of this contract

shall be scaled before they leave the log transfer site at Icy Bay.

Determination of volume shall be made in accordance with the

published Official Log Scaling and Grading Rules in use by the

Puget Sound Log Scaling and Grading Bureau, with the follow-

ing exceptions concerning spruce and hemlock:

(a) For scaling purposes, the minimum volume of #3

sawmill logs has been amended downward to 10 board feet

net — nt oy results in a combination of #3 and #4

sawmill grades

(b) In scaling 3 over 42 feet in len ngth, each segment

shall be scaled — ware | of each other using the

actual scaling diameter of each segment, rather than the

“one-in-ten rule.”

Scaling shall be done by a log scaling and grading bureau,

independent third-party agency, firm or corporation, ap-

proved by STATE. PURCHASER shall enter into a written

agreement with the approved third-party scaler for the scaling

of logs removed from the timber sale area. PURCHASER

shall furnish STATE with a copy of the scaling agreement upon

request.

(2) Costs of Scaling. All costs of scaling shall be paid by

PURCHASER. All costs incurred by PURCHASER in con-

nection with reports furnished STATE will be paid by PUR-

CHASER.

(3) Sealing Instructions. PURCHASER shall require the

scaling party to furnish to STATE, by the 10th of each month

copies of all scale certificates and/or scale tickets showing gross

8la

and net volumes by species of all zogs scaled during the pre-

vious month. Upon request by STATE, PURCHASER shall

also require the scaling party to furnish and attach a log detail

listing to each monthly scale certificate showing all STATE

logs included on the certificate.

PURCHASER agrees that STATE may provide written

information and instruction to the scaling party for the scaling

of logs in accordance with terms of this contract, including

request for copies of scale certificates and log detail lists to be

furnished directly to STATE. A copy of all such instructions

shall be furnished by STATE to PURCHASER.

(4) Utilization. PURCHASER shall not deliberately buck

timber to reduce the size of logs to less than the minimum

merchantability standards of this contract, and shall take

reasonable precautions to prevent loss due to breakage in

felling and yarding of timber. PURCHASER shall buck logs in

various lengths to secure the greatest practicable utilization of

timber. For purposes of merchantability, minimum net log

volume shall be determined by the net volume of the full log

length rather than the volume of individual segments.

(5) Converting Factors. STATE may approve the use of

appropriate converting factors, sample scaling techniques, and

measurement by weight, when these methods are a more

practical means to measure the timber and logs sold by this

contract.

(6) STATE will provide for check scale of state timber at

intervals to be determined by STATE, or its authorized repre-

sentative, and in the event the check scales show a variance of

+ two percent net scale, STATE may request the scaling

party to make a rescale. In the event the scaling party deter-

mines it necessary to demand compensation for the cost of

making rescales, PURCHASER agrees to pay the scaling

party the cost of the services. PURCHASER agrees to cooper-

ate with STATE in providing conditions satisfactory to make

check scales.

82a

(7) PURCHASER will submit to STATE, in duplicate, a

raft receipt for each raft before shipping logs from Icy Cape.

Section 54. Penalty Scale. STATE shall scale logs or por-

tions of logs broken or wasted by PURCHASER due to: (1)

improper felling or bucking of the logs, (2) failure to remove the

logs before deterioration, (3) logs remaining on the sale area

after completion of logging; provided such logs were merchant-

able before breakage or wastage. PURCHASER shall pay for

these logs at the contract price designated in Section 51.

STATE shall immediately notify PURCHASER of the volume

of logs so scaled. Payment shall be considered due on that

volume as if the logs were removed on the date of the notifica-

tion.

If PURCHASER disagrees with the findings made by

STATE under this section, PURCHASER may furnish scaling

by a third-party who shall be an authorized scaler for a log

scaling and grading bureau or other qualified person; the third-

party must be acceptable to STATE. Costs and expenses of the

third-party shall be paid for by PURCHASER and the findings

of the third-party shall be final.

Section 55. Felling. PURCHASER shall comply with the

following requirements for felling on the scale area.

(a) Fell all trees and snags within the limits of the right-of-

way, and all trees within the unit boundaries.

(b) Use Humboldt undercuts in felling all merchantable

trees.

(c) Stumps will be cut so as not to exceed a height of 18

inches as measured on the side adjacent to the highest ground,

except when determined by STATE. High stumps shall be

paid for by PURCHASER at the rate of $5.00 per stump,

which sum shall be regarded as fixed, agreed, and liquidated

damages.

83a

Section 56. Felling Exceptions. STATE may reserve trees

which are needed to protect and preserve nests and habitat of

large or rare birds, e.g., ospreys, eagles, hawks, owls and

pileated woodpeckers. STATE shall designate, before timber

felling, the trees which are reserved and must not be cut.

Section 57. Timber Removal Schedule. A minimum of 20

million board feet of timber shall be cut and paid for three years

from the effective date of the contract.

rm nm Section 58. Log Branding. Every log removed from the

timber sale area by PURCHASER shall be branded unless

otherwise approved in writing by STATE. PURCHASER

shall only use the brand or brands designated or approved by

STATE. STATE may issue to PURCHASER one or more

STATE branding hammers, which shall be used to brand all

logs removed from the timber sale area; and PURCHASER

shall reimburse STATE for any branding hammers lost or

damaged by PURCHASER. PURCHASER shall not have

branding hammers on the timber sale area other than those

approved by STATE in accordance with this section.

Section 59. Tree Markings. PURCHASER shall not re-

move, alter, damage or destroy any tree markings, and shall

immediately report to STATE any markings damaged or des-

troyed. PURCHASER shall not cut or remove logs from any

tree which has a damaged or destroyed marking until the

marking has been restored by STATE.

Section 60. Method of Yarding. PURCHASER shall use

only cable systems for yarding the timber sale area. The cable

sytem shall fully suspend logs when yarding across anadro-

mous streams. Tractor yarding of logs on road and landing

locations may be permitted upon written approval of STATE.

Section 61. Progressive Logging. PURCHASER shall

complete the following logging requirements on each setting

before moving to a new setting, unless otherwise approved in

writing by STATE;

(1) Remove all merchantable logs from the setting.

Sa

(2) Construct cross-drainage ditches or waterbars as

directed by STATE and in accordance with Section 27 of this

contrat.

(3) Remove slash and debris resulting from PURCHAS-

ER’S activities from streams as an ongoing process during

logging.

To facilitate inspection of settings, PURCHASER shall give

STATE five days advance notice of the anticipated completion

date of logging operations on each setting. STATE shall com-

plete the inspection within 2 days after receiving notification.

Section 62. Landings. Before yarding, PURCHASER

shall mark the locations of suitable landings on the ground,

show their location in the Operating Plan, and obtain written

approval from STATE of the locations, under Section 22 of this

contract. If necessary, STATE may mark additional timber as

needed to construct landings. This timber shall be paid for at

the same rate as the purchase price for contract timber. PUR-

CHASER shall not yard logs across any STATE primary road

and shall deck logs only at approved landings.

Section 63. Road and Landing Construction. PURCHAS-

ER shall take all measures which STATE determines neces-

sary to protect stream banks and stream courses during road

and landing construction, and to prevent erosion and disloca-

tion of exposed soil and fill material, including but not limited to

the following:

(a) Allroads must be built to the specifications described in

Exhibit “B,” unless otherwise approved by STATE.

(b) All roads must be constructed following P-Line loca-

tions and drawings as marked on the ground by STATE unless

special written permission is granted by STATE to change

these locations.

(c) Temporary roads, tractor swings roads, and landings

must be constructed of gravel or shotrock over unbroken

ground surface where practical. Cuts, overcasts and areas of

85a

unstable materials shall be avoided. When PURCHASER

finds it impractical to avoid unstable areas, PURCHASER

shall request an on-the-ground joint examination with STATE

for the purpose of determining an acceptable solution. After

the joint site examination, STATE will issue a written decision

with respect to the location of the road or landing.

(d) Unless otherwise approved in writing and staked on

the ground by STATE, road fill placed by PURCHASER shall

not cover, encroach on, or alter permanent or intermittent

water channels.

(e) When rock overlay material is used over decking on

native log bridges, side logs or wood chinking, a woven or

polypropylene fabric blanket shall be installed prior to deposit-

ing rock overlay materials. Streams shall be cleared of debris

which results from PURCHASER’S operations and which

may affect the natural flow of the stream. Heavy equipment

shall not be operated in streams except at designated crossings

and when essential to construction of culverts and bridges.

Section 64. Road Maintenance.

(a) In removing material from sliders or other sources,

PURCHASER shall deposit the material so that the material

will not erode into streams, lakes, or reservoirs, as designated

by STATE.

(b) Allspur roads shall be put-to-bed within 6 months after

use of the road has been terminated. PURCHASER will out-

slope roads, install cross ditches, remove culverts and clean

ditches as is needed to prevent serious soil washing and to keep

the discontinued road from permanently affecting the natural

pattern of surface drainage in its vicinity. Debris from log

culverts shall be randomly dispersed over the road template

and shall be laid on the ground in a near natural location.

(c) Oncut and fill slopes, waste and spoil areas susceptible

to erosion, or along roads constructed or used by the PUR-

CHASER, PURCHASER shall revegetate by seeding with

grass. STATE may require fertilization and mulching as part

of the revegetation work.

86a

(d) The primary road will be stabilized after use has been

terminated. All bridge stringers shall be removed and laced on

the east banks of each stream or river. All debris shall be

removed from the cutslope and ditches. All ditches shall be

cleaned. If a berm has developed on the road template, it shall

be removed or, if STATE approves or directs openings in the

berm shall be constructed as marked on the ground.

(e) The road surface shall be graded to a uniform flat sur-

face with approximately 2 percent outslope, if it has been

constructed with no ditch, and graded with a crown if con-

structed with a ditch to aid surface runoff..In both instances all

wheel ruts will be eliminated.

Section 65. Permits. STATE shall secure the necessary

permits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for log trans-

fer and storage areas. STATE shall also secure the necessary

permits under AS 16.05.870 and AS 38.05.330.

Section 66. Fire Protection. During the fire season, PUR-

CHASER shall provide and maintain sufficient fire-fighting

tools in the sale operating area to equip each man engaged in

the logging operation. In addition, PURCHASER may be

required, during periods of high fire danger, to have the follow-

ing equipment on the sale area:

(1) Water supply: a self-propelled tanker or portable trail-

er in operable condition of not less than 300 gallons;

(2) Water pump: size and capacity must be such that the

pump will provide a discharge of not less than 20 gallons per

minute when pumping through 50 feet of hose equipped with a

one-quarter inch inside diameter nozzle at pump level;

(3) Hose and nozzle: at least 500 feet of serviceable hose of

not less than three-quarter inch inside diameter, and a nozzle

with an inside diameter of one-quarter inch;

(4) Water, supply, pump, and not less than 250 feet of the

hose and the nozzle, as required by this section, must be

maintained as a connected, operating unit ready for immediate

use at any time;

87a

(5) Internal combustion engines must be equipped with a

spark arrester maintained in good condition that meets the

standards set forth in the publication of the United States

Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, entitled “Stan-

dard 5100-la for Spark Arresters for Internal Combustion

Engines,” issued March, 1976, except that fully turbocharged

internal combustion engines maintained in good condition are

exempt from these requirements;

(6) Internal combustion engines must be equipped with

one chemical fire extinguisher rated by Underwriters’ Labor-

atories at not less than 4-B.C. The fire extinguisher must be

placed on each engine so as to be visible to the operator and

ready for instant use. The extinguisher must be equipped with

a reliable and easily read pressure gauge; and

(7) All saws must be equipped with a spark-arresting de-

vice constructed to retain or destroy 90 percent or more of the

carbon particles having a major diameter greater than 0.023

inches (0.584 mm). A spark-arresting device equipped with a

woven screen with a maximum opening size of 0.023 inches

(0.584 mm), constructed of heat- and corrosion-resistant wire

at least 0.013 inchers (0.330 mm) in diameter, will be con-

sidered in compliance with this requirement, if the total screen

opening area is not less than 125 percent of the engine exhaust

port area. The unit must be constructed to permit easy remov-

al of the screen for field inspection, replacement, and cleaning.

During periods of high fire danger, PURCHASER may be

required to provide a watchman, physically capable of and

experienced in operating the firefighting equipment for the

operation area. The watchman shall:

(A) be constantly on duty for three hours after the power-

driven equipment used by the operator has been shut down for

the day;

(B) visually observe all conditions of the operation area on

which activity has been in progress; and

88a

(C) have adequate facilities for transportation and commu-

nication in order to be able to summon assistance if needed.

During periods of high fire danger, PURCHASER may also

be required to work a “hoot-owl” shift.

PURCHASER shall take action on any and all fires, in or

near the timber sale area regardless of the origin of the fire. He

shall continue suppression action until relieved by an autho-

rized officer of the agency responsible for forest protection or

by authorized State personnel.

All fires shall be reported immediately to STATE or to the

agency responsible for protection in the area regardless of the

size of apparent insignificance of the fire.

STATE may stop all or part of the logging operations of

PURCHASER during especially hazardous fire weather.

PURCHASER shall comply with all laws, regulations, and

rules promulgated and enforced by the agency responsible for

fire protection in the area.

Section 67. Camp Facilities.

(a) PURCHASER shall submit a camp plan to STATE for

approval before construction commences.

(b) PURCHASER shall secure all permits necessary from

other agencies before construction commences.

(c) Fuel will be supplied by PURCHASER toSTATE, ata

price to be negotiated, for operation of state vehicles. Shop

space will be made available by PURCHASER to STATE for

maintenance of these vehicles if it does not interfere with

PURCHASER’S operations.

(d) Uponrequest PURCHASER will furnish STATE with

room and board for state personnel at no more than $30.00 per

day.

Section 68. Primary Manufacture. Timber cut under this

contract shall not be transported for primary manufacture

outside the State of Alaska without written approval of the

State.

89a

Primary manufacture is defined under 11 AAC 76.130 and

the Governor’s policy statement of May 1974.

For purposes of this contract, cants may be manufactured from

all species for export and will be considered to have received

primary manufacture when sawed up to a maximum thickness

of 12 inches and may be of any width. Timbers cut thicker than

12 inches must be squared on four sides along their entire

length with allowances for one-third of each dimension (thick-

ness and width) allowed in wane.

Chips are considered to have received primary manufacture.

Section 69. Bond Reduction. Upon notice in writing to

STATE by PURCHASER of the completion of all projects

required under this contract, and 6 months after acceptance by

STATE of all said projects, STATE will authorize a reduction

in the amount of the performance bond to 10% of the value of

the remaining timber and remaining project costs to the

nearest $100; provided STATE or other party affected by the

reduction does not have a claim against PURCHASER.

Section 70. Project Work. PURCHASER shall complete

the following projects in accordance with specifications pro-

vided in this contract and instructions from STATE. Project

locations are shown on Exhibit A unless otherwise stated.

PURCHASER shall furnish all material unless otherwise spe-

cified.

Project No.1 Construct primary road between Point “A” and

Point “B” according to the specifications in Exhibit “B.”

Project No.2 Construct primary road between Point “B” and

Point C“ according to the specifications in Exhibit B.“

Project No.3 Construct bridges as specified in Exhibits “B”

and “D” and as marked on the ground.

Project No. 4 Furnish and install culverts as specified in

Exhibits “B” and “C” and as marked on the ground.

Project No.5 Spread the road rock according to the specifica-

tions in Exhibit “B.”

90a

Rock Source. The rock may be obtained from the STATE

land at the location shown as “Quarry” on Exhibit A, or other

locations acceptable to STATE.

Project No.6 Construct secondary (spur) roads according to

the specifications in Exhibit “B.”

Section71. Project Completion. PURCHASER shall com-

plete all projects on a road section before log hauling on that

secton. However, STATE may waive this requirement if

completion will cause damage due to logging operations, pro-

vided the section is completed as soon as the cause for the delay

is removed. Right-of-Way logs may be removed from a road

section before completion.

9la

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have sub-

scribed their names and affixed their seals as of the date set

forth in the first paragraph of this contract.

STATE OF ALASKA PURCHASER

By 2

By

Title

Date Title

Date

CERTIFICATE OF CORPORATE PURCHASER

I, , certify that I am the

Secretary of the Corporation named as

Purchaser herein and that who signed

this contract was then of that corpor-

ation; that said contract was duly signed for and in behalf of

that corporation by authority of its governing body and is

within the scope of its corporate powers.

(Corporate Seal)

STATE OF ALASKA )

) ss.

JUDICIAL DISTRICT )

THIS IS TO CERTIFY that on this — day f

19__, before the undersigned, a notary public in and for the

State of Alaska, personally appeared , and

acknowledged to me that he executed the foregoing instru-

ment for and on behalf of , freely and

voluntarily and for the use and purposes therein set forth.

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my

hand and affixed my official seal, the day and year in this

certificate first above written.

Notary Public in and for

Commission Expires:

STATE OF ALASKA )

) ss.

JUDICIAL DISTRICT )

THIS IS TO CERTIFY that on this — day f.

19, before the undersigned, a notary public in and for the

State of Alaska, personally appeared

and acknowledged to me that he executed the foregoing i instru-

ment for and on behalf of freely and

voluntarily and for the use and purposes therein set forth.

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my

hand and affixed my official seal, the day and year in this

certificate first above written.

Notary Public in and for

Commission Expires:

LINDELL, LOG EXPORT RESTRICTIONS OF

THE WESTERN STATES AND BRITISH

COLUMBIA, PACIFIC NORTHWEST FOREST

AND RANGE EXPERIMENT STATION, U.S.

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, FOREST

SERVICE (APPENDIX II TO MEMORANDUM OF

LAW BY DEFENDANTS IN SUPPORT OF

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, FILED

NOV. 19, 1980)

1978

USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PNW 63

LOG EXPORT

RESTRICTIONS OF THE

WESTERN STATES

AND

BRITISH COLUMBIA

GARY R. LINDELL

APPENDIX II

Pacific Northwest Forest And Range Experiment Station

U.S. Department of Agriculture

Forest Service

Portland Oregon

94a

The pros and cons of softwood log exports from the West

Coast have been debated for ove: a decade. Initially, the

export market was generally viewed with favor, particularly

during the early 1960’s as a needed outlet for salvaged timber.

But as exports grew with time and accounted for a growing

share of the timber harvest, concerns were expressed as to the

propriety of allowing the unrestricted export of logs (figs. 1

and 2). In response to these concerns, Alaska, Oregon, Califor-

nia, and Idaho implemented measures on State-owned lands

and Federal control regulations were initiated to limit the

export of unprocessed timber from lands managed by the U.S.

Department of Agriculture Forest Service or the Bureau of

Land Management of the U.S. Department of Interior.

This paper presents the main features of log export restric-

tions imposed by the various State and Federal agencies as

well as those of British Columbia as of mid-1977. Where appro-

priate, some historical background will be given to provide a

2. oo 8

O NORTHERN CALIFORNIA

2.00 . []} ornecon

2.250, U wasninctos -

W EXPORTS

2.750

2.000

1.750

1,500

1,250

1.000

750

= |

196 1964 1966 1968 1970 1972 1974 1976

TOTAL LOG EXPORTS (MILLION BOARD FEET, SCRIBNER SCALE)

/

Figure 1.--Softwood log exporss from ports in Washington, Oregon,

northern California, and Alaska, 1962-75. Source: Ruderman (1976).

95a

PERCENT OF HARVEST

4 4

0 * * 4 1 —

1961 1963 1965 1967 1969 1971 1973 1975

Figure 2.--Sofltwood log exports a8 percent of timber harvest

in Washington and Oregon 1961-75. Source: Ruderman (1976).

better perspective as to how present regulations evolved. For

additional background, the reader is referred to Austin (1969).

JOINT DETERMINATION BY SECRETARIES OF

AGRICULTURE AND INTERIOR

On April 16, 1968, the Secretaries of Agriculture and In-

terior issued joint determinations concerning log exports from

National Forest and Bureau of Land Management lands in

western Oregon and western Washington. These stated that a

restriction on the volume of logs harvested and exported from

Federal lands in unprocessed form was necessary to maintain a

viable domestic wood processing industry capable of proces-

sing the sustained yield of timber from the selected areas.

Authority for the action is contained in the Organic Adminis-

tration Act of June 4, 1897 (16 U.S.C. 475, 551) in the case of

the Secretary of Agriculture. The O and C Act of August 28,

1937 (50 Stat. 874), provided the enabling legislation for the

Secretary of the Interior. The volume exported was to be

limited to 350 million board feet annually to be divided between

Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management lands in the

96a

affected areas. An accompanying plan provided operating and

administrative details including the allocation of the limited or

“exempt” volume among selected National Forests, the defini-

tion of processed products, and exceptions to be allowed such

as Port-Orford-cedar which was declared surplus to domestic

needs.’

This program was to be in effect until June 30, 1969, at which

time it would be subject to review and possible renewal. It was

superseded on January 1, 1969 by the Morse Amendment.

MORSE AMENDMENT

Following hearings in 1968, Senator Wayne Morse proposed

Part IV of the Foreign Assistance Act of October 8, 1968, (82

Stat. 966) commonly called the Morse Amendment. Taking

effect January 1, 1969, the Morse Amendment legislated the

same log export quota that had been initiated by the joint

determination by the Secretaries of Agriculture and Interior.

The area under control, however, was extended to include all

Federal lands west of the 100th meridian (a line running

through central Texas) including Federal lands in Alaska. The

350 million board feet of exempted volume was jointly allocated

to areas administered by the Forest Service or the Bureau of

Land Management in Washington, Oregon, and California.

The volumes subsequently exported, however, were below the

allocated volumes (Austin 1973).

The Morse Amendment also authorized the Secretaries of

Agriculture and Interior to issue rules and regulations to pre-

vent the substitution of Federal timber for non-F ederal timber

A determination by the Secretary of Agriculture concerning pri-

mary processing of timber from National Forests of the Pacific

Northwest (unpublished). Specified in the Secretary of Agriculture

April 16, 1968 memorandum to the Chief of the Forest Service.

plan for requiring domestic primary manufacturing of logs from

National Forest land in the Pacific Northwest (unpublished). Re-

sponse to the April 16, 1968 memorandum of the Secretary of Agri-

culture. .

97a

which had been exported. In 1969 the Forest Service and

Bureau of Land Management began exploring ways and means

of implementing the substitution clause including the holding

of a joint public advisory hearing at Portland, Oregon on Sep-

tember 26, 1969, to obtain comment on a proposed plan. No

further action was taken, however.

The Morse Amendment further permitted the Secretaries of

Agriculture and Interior to declare certain amounts of unpro-

cessed timber as surplus to domestic needs and thus eligible for

export. Such a determination could only be made after the

holding of a public hearing to seek advice and counsel as to

quantities, species, and grades that might be in surplus.

Following public hearings at Portland, Oregon on December 6,

1968, Alaska-cedar was determined to be surplus to domestic

needs from Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management

lands in Washington, Oregon, and California.

Port-Orford-cedar was also found to be in surplus with the

exception of small volumes of select salvage old-growth mate-

rial which was deemed necessary for the manufacture of arrow

shafts and thus ineligible for export. Other than this minor

exception, Port-Orford-cedar may be exported in unprocessed

form.

A similar hearing at Juneau, Alaska, on May 5, 1969, estab-

lished that Alaska-cedar and western redcedar were surplus

species from Federal lands in Alaska. Consequently these

species were freely exportable from these Federal lands and

the resulting volumes were in addition to the 350 million board

feet of exempted volume.

The Morse Amendment had an expiration date of December

31, 1971. It was extended for an additional 2 years to December

31, 1973, by an amendment to the Housing and Urban Develop-

ment Act of 1970 (84 Stat. 1817).

APPROPRIATIONS RIDER

In 1972, a combination of factors including an unprecedented

housing boom both here and in Japan led to an extremely tight

98a

supply situation for west coast softwood logs. Hearings were

held in 1972 and 1973; and several proposals to limit log and/or

lumber exports, including those from private mal were in-

troduced in Congress.

Finally, in October of 1973, Congress attached a rider to the

Department of the Interior and Related Agencies Appropria-

tion Act which in effect initiated a complete ban on the export

of unprocessed timber from Federal lands in the West. The

General Provision attached to the fiscal year 1974 appropria-

tions bill stated:

No part of any appropriation under this Act shall be avail-

able to the Secretaries of the Interior and Agriculture for

use for any sale hereafter made of unprocessed timber

from Federal lands west of the 100th meridian in the

contiguous 48 States which will be exported from the

United States, or which will be used as a substitute for

timber from private lands which is exported by —

purehaser Provided, that this limitation shall not app 1

tos ¢ quantities of grade and species of timber whic

said Secretaries determine are surplus to domestic lumber

and plywood manufacturing needs.“

Thus the provisions imposed by the appropriations rider

were generally more restrictive than under the Morse Amend-

ment. The appropriations rider constituted a complete export

ban on Federal timber (except for those species and grades

declared surplus) compared with a quota of 350 million board

feet under the Morse Amendment. In addition, the language of

the substitution clause was now directive whereas formerly

the Secretaries were only authorized (but not directed) to

enact regulations to prevent substitution. On the other hand,

the appropriations rider was somewhat less restrictive in that

Federal lands in Alaska were no longer included, whereas they

were under terms of the Morse Amendment. As will be dis-

cussed later, however, log exports from National Forest lands

in Alaska are restricted according to the terms of other legisla-

tion.

Department of the Interior and Related Agencies Appropriation

Act, 1974 (P. L. 93-120, October 4, 1973), Sec. 301.

99a

The appropriations rider has been attached to the Interior

appropriations acts for each succeeding year (fiscal years 1974

through 1978) and is currently the basis for the complete ban on

the export of unprocessed timber from lands administered by

the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management in the

West (except Alaska).

The remainder of this section of the report will highlight

recent Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management at-

tempts to develop regulations to implement the terms of the

rider to agency appropriations.

FOREST SERVICE

On October 26, 1973, the Forest Service published proposed

regulations in the Federal Register and, based on comments

received, Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations was

revised to incorporate regulations prohibiting the export of

unprocessed National Forest timber or its substitution for

exported private timber. The effective date was March 13,

1974. These are the regulations currently in force; the more

important provisions are as follows:“

4 — taxa 1 .— —2 not — ulp * 7

e an u special eu In addi-

tion, the followin — defined as —1 bean pro-

cessed and thus eligible for export.

a. — and construction timber sawn on four

sides,

chips, pulp and pulp products,

green veneer and plywood,

poles and piling cut or treated for use as such,

cants cut for remanufacture, 8-3/4 inches in thick-

ness or less.

2. Substitution of public timber for private timber which

is exported occurs “when with respect to historic

levels, (1) the purchaser continues to export and in-

creases his purchase of National Forest timber, or (2)

ef? F

Code of Federal Regulations, Title 36, Chapter II, Part 223.10.

A

9

3.

100a

the purchase of National Forest timber continues

while the purchaser increases his export of unproces-

sed timber ot ped ha lands tributary to the plant

for which National Forest timber covered by a specific

contract is expected to be delivered.“ “Private lands”

does not include lands managed by other Federal or

State agencies or lands held in trust by the United

States for Indians. The term “historic level” means

119 percent of the average annual volume of Federal

timber purchased

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.