Appendix — Harrell ex rel. Herrell v. Wilson County Schools

Supreme Court brief1983

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

33.

APPENDIX A

OPINION

No. 817SC793

NORTH CAROLINA COURT OF APPEALS

Filed: July 20, 1982

Re: Marguerite Owens Harrell, by her par-

ents, Allen W. Harrell and Irene Burk

Harrell (Appellant) Vv. Wilson County

Schools, Dr. W.O. Fields, Jr., Superin-

tendent, and North Carolina Department of

Public Instruction, Dr. A Craig Phillips,

Superintendent (Appellees)

Appeal py plaintiff from Stevens, Judge.

Judgment entered 27 =February 41981 in

Superior Court, Wilson County. Heard in

the Court of Appeals 31 March 1982.

This appeal questions whether’ the

Wilson County Schorl System properly deter-

mined that a 13-year-old hearing impaired

34.

child would receive a free appropriate edu-

cation by placing her in a regular sixth

grade class within the Wilson Public

Schools instead of providing a grant to

subsidize the child's education at an out-

of-state residential institution.

Hopkins & Allen, by Janice Watson

Davidson and Grover Prevatte Hopkins, for

plaintiff appellant.

Rose, Jones, Rand & Orcutt, P.A. by Z.

Hardy Rose and L. Patrick Fleming, Jr., for

defendant appellees.

BECTON, Judge.

I

On 17 July 41978, the parents of

‘Marguerite Harrell, a hearing impaired

child, applied to the Wilson County Schools

for a grant, pursuant to G.S. 115-363

(1977), to cover the cost of sending

35.

Marguerite to the Central Institute for the

Deaf (CID) in St. Louis, Missouri. CID is

recognized as one of the leading institu-

tions in the world which teaches deaf child-

ren. It emphasizes an oral proyram which

prepares students for entry into mainstream

society. When the grant was initially de-

nied in 1978, the parents elected to send

Marguerite back to CID for the 1978-79

school year at their own expense.

In determining how to fulfill its duty

under G.S. 115-303, et seq. (1977) and 20

U.S.C. 1401, et seg-, the school system

evaluated Marguerite's needs and, there-

after, determined if the Wilson School Sys-

tem could satisfy her needs. A committee

formed to evaluate Marguerite developed an

Individualized Education Program (IEP) for

Marguerite which provided that she be

-*

a

36.

placed in a regular sixth grade class with

Support services.

Being dissatisfied with the recommenda-

tion of the comnittee, the parents appealed

the decision. The matter was heard on 11

October 1978 before George Ss. Willard, Jr.,

who affirmed the decision of the committee.

The parents appealed that decision, and, at

a State Review Hearing on 20 December 19738,

the decision to place Marguerite in the

Wilson School System was again affirmed.

The parents then appealed that decision to

the Superior Court of Wilson County. Judge

Stevens, making findings of fact and conclu-

sions of law, affirmed the administrative

decisions to place Marguerite in the public

schools. From the adverse decision by the

superior court, the plaintiff appeals to

this Court.

37.

II

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Our scope of review on this appeal of

an adiinistrative agency decision is deter-

mined by the “issues presented for review

by the appealing party." Utilities Comn.

V+ Oil Co., 302 N.c. 14, 21, 273 S.E. 2a

232, 236 (1981).

In Savings & Loan League v. Credit

pavings —_— —-_-_e_-__-———

Union Comm., 302 N.c. 458, 463-04, 276 S.&.

2d 404, 408-09 (1981), our Supreme Court

said:

Under the APA, a reviewing

court's power to affirm the

decision of the agency and to

remand for further proceedings

is not circuwnscribed. How-

ever, the court may reverse or

modify only if the substantial

38.

rights of the petitioners may

have been prejudiced because

the agency findings, infer-

ences, conclusions, or dec-

isions are:

(1) In violation of constitu-

tional provisions; or

(2) In excess of statutory

authority or jurisdiction of

the agency; or

(3) Made upon unlawful proce-

dure; or

(4) Affected by other error

of law; or

(5) unsupported by substan-

tial evidence admissible under

G.S. 150A-29(a) or G.S.

150A-30 in view of the entire

39.

record as submitted; or

(6) Arbitrary or capricious.

G-S.» §$150A-51 (1978).

On this appeal, the plaintiff presents

three argunents: (1) that during the assess-

ment, evaluation and placement of

Marguerite, the school committee did not

comply with due process of the applicable

federal and State regulations; (2) that the

IEP developed for Marguerite is not respon-

sive to her special needs as required by

federal and State statutes and regulations;

and (3) that the school eystem failed to

provide the most appropriate education for

Marguerite. These arguments therefore pre-

sent the following issues under G.S.

150A-51: (1) whether the actions of the

school system were in violation of consti-

40.

tutional provisions; (2) whether the deci-

sion by the school System regarding an ap-

propriate education for Marguerite was af-

fected by error of law; (3) whether the

decision was arbitrary and capricious; and

(4) whether the decision was supported by

substantial evidence.

III

APPROPRIATE EDUCATION

We address first the plaintiff's argu-

ment that G.S. 115-363 (1977) and 20 U.S.C.

1401 et seg. require the local school agen-

Cy to provide a handicapped student with

the most appropriate education. We dis-

agree.

G-S. 115-363 (1977) provides that

"Ltjhe policy of the State is to provide a

free appropriate publicly supported educa-

tion to every child with special needs."

41.

The federal statute likewise provides that

"Lilt is the purpose of this chapter to

assure that all handicapped children have

available to them, ...a free appropriate

public education which emphasizes special

education and related services designed to

meet their unique needs. ..." 2U U.S.C.

1400(c) (1982 Cum.Supp.). Title 16 of the

North Carolina Administrative Code Chapter

2, subchapter E section 1501(c) provides

that a free appropriate public education is

special education related services which:

(1) are provided at public

expense, under public. super-

vision and direction without

charge;

(2) meet the standards of the

state education agency;

(3) are provided in confor-

mity with an individualized

education prograin.

The federal statute defines free appro-

priate public education as special educa-

tion and related services which

‘

(A) have been provided at pub-

lic expense, under public su-

pervision and direction, and

without charge,

(8B) meet the standards of the

State Educational Agency,

(c) include an appropriate

preschool, elementary, or se-

condary school education in

the State involved, and

(D) are provided in confor-

mity with the individualized

education program required

under section 1414(a) (5) of

this title.

20 U.S.C. 1401 (18).

While there are no State cases inter-

preting our State provisions, the United

States Supreme Court recently interpreted

the federal provision to mean a free appro-

priate education, not the best or most ap-

propriate education. Board of Education v.

Rowley, 50 U.S.L.W. 4925 (28 June 1982).

Specifically, with regard to the federal

Statute the Rowley Court said:

When the language of the

Act and its legislative his-

tory are considered together,

the requirements imposed by

Congress become tolerably

Clear. Insofar as a State is

required to provide a _ handi-

capped child with a “free ap-

propriate public education,"

we hold that it satisfies this

requirement by providing per-

sonalized instruction with

sufficient support services to

permit the child to benefit

educationally from that in-

struction. Such instruction

and services must be provided

at pudlic expense, must meet

the State's educational stan-

dards, must approximate the

grade levels used in the

State's regular education, and

must comport with the child's

IEP. In addition, the IEP,

and therefore the personalized

instruction, should be formu-

lated in accordance with the

requirements of the Act and,

if the child is being educated

in the regular classrooms of

the public education § systeia,

‘should be reasonably calcu-

lated to enable the child to

achieve passing marks and ad-

vance from grade to grade.

50 U.S.L.W. at 4932-33.

Although our statute was designed, in

part, to bring the State in conformity with

the federal statute, see G.S. 115-363

(1977), the Rowley Court's interpretation

of Congress’ intent does not control our

interpretation of our General Assembly's

46.

intent. We believe that our General Assem-

bly “intended to eliminate the effects of

the handicap, at least to the extent that

the child will be given an equal opportuni-

ty to learn if that is reasonably possi-

ble." Rowley, 50 USLW 4925, 4936 (White,

J-, dissenting). Under this standard a han-

dicapped child should be given an opportuni-

ty to achieve his full potential commensu-

rate with that given other children. i/

1/ Chapter 115, under which this action was

brought, was rewritten by Session Laws

1981, c 423, 8.1, effective 1 July 1981,

and has been recodified as Chapter 115C. In

Chapter 115C, the General Assembly clearly

spelled out its intent by declaring “that

the policy of the State is to ensure every

child a fair and full opportunity to reach

his full potential. ..." G.s. 115C-106.

47.

Nothing we have said, however, helps

the plaintiff on the facts of this case.

Our statute, as progressive as it may be,

was not designed to require the development

of a utopian educational program for handi-

capped students any more than the public

schools are required to provide utopian

education programs for non-handicapped stu-

dents. We believe that the Wilson County

School System has fulfilled its obligation

to provide Marguerite with a free, appro-

priate education. we, therefore, hold that

the decision was not affected by error of

law and overrule this assignment.

IV

DUE PROCESS

Plaintiff argues that she was denied

due process of law because she was not pro-

vided with a fair tribunal. Specifically,

438.

plaintiff argues that because of the pres-

ence and influence of Mildred Blackburn, a

consultant for programs for the hearing

impaired in the public schools of North

Carolina with a preference for mainstream-

ing hearing impaired students rather than

putting them in residential facilities, the

conferences held to develop Marguerite's

IEP were biased. Plaintiff further alleges

that Ms. Blackburn's opinions, because of

her position, were viewed as expert opin-

ions and were given too much weight. Alleg-

ing that this bias prevented the committee

from considering that the CID residential

facility was the most appropriate place for

her, the plaintiff contends that the rules

and regulations under which the IEP were

developed were also violated. We disagree.

Pirst, the parties agreed at the hear-

——

49.

ing on 11 October 1978 that the required

due process procedures had been adequately

followed prior to anu during the hearing.

The state Review hearing officer found tnat

all State and federal regulations had been

followed in determining the needs of the

child. No exception was taken to this find-

ing. Further, the trial court found that

the parents had been yiven notice of the

hearings.

Due process requires that an indi-

Vidual receive adequate notice and be given

an Opportunity to be aeard. In re Moore,

269 eC. 95, LOL, 221 S.E. 2d 307, 309

(1970). This requirement applies to admini-

Btrative agencies performing adjudicatory

functions. Goldberg v. Kelly, 397 U.S.

224, 25 be Ede 2d 287, YU S&S Ct. LOLI

(1970); Thomas v. Ward, 529 F. 2d Ylo (4th

50.

Cir. 1975). “A fair trial in a fair tri-

bunal is a basic requirement of due pro-

cess." In re Murchison, 349 U.s. 133, 136,

99 Lb. Ed. 942, 946, 75 §.Ct. 623, 625

(1955). We are convincea that the notice

requirements of due process were met in

both the hearings below and in the ad judi-

cation in the superior court. We also find

no merit to the plaintiff's claim that the

“pias” of Mildred Blackburn resulted in a

denial of due process.

The mere fact that a member of the

panel which developed the IEP for

Marguerite had expressed a certain profes-

sional opinion on mainstreaming versus resi-

dential placement does not result in a vio-

lation of due process. First, it is possi-

ble for members of boards or agencies to

make policy decisions and later perform

Si.

adjudicatory functions as well. “The fact

tnat an administrative tribunal acts in the

triple capacity of complainant, prosecutor

and judge is not violative of the regquire-

ments of due process." 73 CJS Public Admin-

istrative Bodies and Procedure go0, p. 391

(1951). In Tho son v. Board of Education,

reversed on other grounds 292 N.C. 406, 233

S-E. 2d 538 (1977), this Court addressed

the question of bias on the part of a

school board charged both with determining

if cause existed for Suspension of a teach-

er and for thereafter determining if the

teacher should be dismissed. In finding

that no bias or violation of due process

existed, the Court relied upon United

States Supreme Court cases which addressed

the issue of bias and prejudgment on the

52.

part of agency or board members.

In Trade Comm. v. Cement Institute,

333 U.S. 683, 92 L.Ed. 1010, 68 S. Ct. 793

(1948), members of the Commission who had

investigated the pricing system of the re-

Spondent and suggested that it was illegal

were asked to disqualify themselves. The

Supreme Court stated that there was no need

for them to do so; the fact that the commis-

sioners had formed an opinion as a result

of their prior investigation did not mean

that they could not later render an objec-

tive Opinion. 333 U.S. at 702, 92 L. Ed.

at 1035, 68 S. Ct. at 804. The court analo-

gized the role of the Commissioners to that

of a trial judge. It reasoned that due pro-

cess would not require a judge to recuse

himself simply because he had expressed an

Opinion on certain types of conduct. .

53.

at 804. In Hortonville District v. Horton-

ville Education Assoc., 426 U.S. 482, 49

leEd. 2d 1, Yo S. Ct. 2308 (1976), the Su-

preme Court rejected the claim of bias by

discharged striking teachers that the

School District could not terminate their

employment since the Board had been invol-

ved aS a negotiator during the teacher

strike. The Court stated that the fact

that the Board was involved in the collec-

tive bargaining process did not “overcome

the presumption of honesty and integrity in

policymakers with decisionmaking powers,"

and that this involvement was not “the sort

of bias" that had disqualified other dici-

sionmakers as a matter of federal due pro-

cess. Id. at 496-97, 49 L. Ed. 2d at

11-12, 96 S. Ct. at 2316.

54.

In the case sub judice, Mildred

Blackburn participated on the committee to

determine Marguerite's IEP. She expressed

views against residential placement’ for

children such as Marguerite. This view was

contrary to that presented by Marguerite’s

mother. Mainstreaming and residential

placements were two of the alternatives

considered by the comnittee. First, view-

ing the record under the whole record test,

we find that there is ccipatent, material

and substantial evidence to support the

decision below. Second, the degree of in-

volvement, prejudgment and predisposition

of Mrs. Blackburn was far less assuming

than that of the FTC Commissioners in’

Cement Industries and of the School Board

in Hortonville Education Assoc. In view of

Cement Industries and Hortonville Education

55.

Assoc., we find that the predisposition or

professional theory which Mrs. Slackburn

had, and brought to the Committee, was not

enough to constitute bias and a violation

of due process.

V

COMPLIANCE WITH STATE AND FEDERAL

RULES AND REGULATIONS

We have carefully reviewed the record

and find that the school system substanti-

ally complied with the relevant federal and

State rules and regulations in the develop-

ment of an IEP for Marguerite. Because we

so find, we also find no merit to plain-

tiff's arguments (1) that she was denied

due process of the law due to noncompliance

with those regulations; (2) that the deci-

sion was not supported by substantial evi-

dence under the whole record test; and

So.

(3) that the decision was arbitrary and

capricious.

The applicable regulations require

that a child for whom Special education is

provided be identified and evaluated before

Such services are provided. 4o NCAC

26.1510. For the hearing impaired student

the following screening and evaluation pro-

cedures are required:

(a) required screening or evaluation

before placement:

(i) education evaluation,

(ii) speech/language evaluation,

(iii) audioloyical evaluation,

(iv) otological evaluation,

(v) vision screening;

(b) recommended screening or evalu-

ation before placement:

(i) medical screening,

57.

(ii) psycnological evaluation,

(iii) adaptive behavior evalu-

ation,

(iv) Oopthalmological or opto-

metric evaluation.

lo NCAC 2£.1510(3). After the screening

and evaluation has been completed, an IEP

must be developed for each child within

thirty days of the determination that the

child is to receive special educational

programs or services. lo NCAC

26.1512(g)(3). The Iup is developed by the

local educational agency which provides the

services to the student. "The entire

school-based committee may or imay not be

involved." 16 NCAC 2E,.1512(b). Chapter 16

of the North Carolina administrative Code

Section 2£.1512(b) provides that the per-

sons charged with developing the IEP must

58.

include a representative of the local educa-

tional agency other than the child's teach-

ers, the child's teacher, the parents, and

wnen Appropriate, the child. See also 34

C.FP.R. 300.344 (1978). However io NCAC

2h.1l512(b) (7) provides that:

For a child with special needs

who has been evaluated for the

first time, the local educa-

tion agency shall have:

(A) a member of the evalua-

tion team partricipate in the

Individualized Education Pro-

gram ieeting, or

(B) 4a representative of the

local education agency, a

child's teacher, or some other

person present at the meeting

who is knowledgeable about the

59.

evaluation procedures used

with the child and who is fa-

miliar with the results of the

evaluation.

LEmphasis added. ]

Further, the IEP must include

the following goals and objec-

tives:

(1) a statement of the

child's present levels of edu-

cational performance;

(2) a statement of annual

goals;

(3) a statement of short-term

instructional objectives;

(4) a statement of specific

education and related services

to be provided to the child;

60,

(5) a description of the ex-

tent to which the child will

participate in reguiar educa-

tion programs and a descrip-

tion of the program to be pro-

vided;

(o) the projected dates for

initiation of services and the

anticipated duration of ser-

vices;

(7) objective criteria, eval-

uation procedures, and sched-

ules for determining, on at

least an annual basis, whether

the short-term instructional

objectives are being achieved.

lo NCAC 2€.1512(c). See also 34 C.F.R.

300.346 (1978).

ol.

Upon review of the record in this

case, we find that the Wilson School System

conducted the required screening and evalua-

tion of Marguerite. The IéP committee con-

sulted the following: Paul Speziale, a psy-

Chologist; Ray Lamm, Director of Instruc-

tion; Rosalie Wooten, Exceptional-Children

Teacher, Annie Dickets, a regular Admin-

istrative Committee member; Mildred Black-

burn, Consultant for the Hearing-Impaired

Child, State Department of Public Instruc-

tion; Danny Hutto, Assistant Superinten-

dent; Sandra Simmons, Staff Member at East-

ern North Carolina School for the Deaf;

Diane Parker, Director of Programs for Ex-

ceptional Children; Connie Michels, Coordin-

ator of Programs for Hearing-Impaired, At-

lantic Christian College; and Irene Har-

rell, parent. It is noted that not all of

62.

the persons listed above attended every con-

ference. The IP Comittee consisted of

Diane Parker, Martha Wrenn, and Paul Spezi-

ale, who consulted Mrs. Harrell.

The conference reports indicate that

several alternatives were discussed at meet-

ings held on 11 August, 22 Auygust, and 28

August 1978 pefore it was determined that

Maryuerite should be placed in a reyular

Classroom with support services. The re-

cords also show that the observation, as-

sessient and testing to determine

Maryuerite's needs were all done between ©”

July 1978 and 17 August 1978; that the IEP

was developed as a result of meetings on 22

August and 28 Auyust 1978; and that the com-

mittee made its recomaendation on 28 August

1978. Further, our review of the IEP re-

veals that it includes the yoals and objec-

63.

tives required by NCAC 2E.1512(c) and 34

C.FP.R. 300.340 (1978). It is clear to us

that the school system complied with the

applicable reyulations.

The plaintiff argues that the school

System made a decision to mainstream

Marguerite and then proceeded to develop an

IEP to suit the mainstreaming. That is,

what was offered the plaintiff was what the

school system could provide, not what the

plaintiff needed. This, the plaintiff main-

tains, was arbitrary and capricious. We

find no merit in this argument. The record

indicates that an evaluation was per forimed

prior to a determination of what

Marguerite's needs were. Based on the eval-

uation and assessment the committee deter-

mined that Marguerite could be served by

enrollment in a reyular sixth grade class

64.

with support services.

In addition, the decision to place

Maryuerite in a reyular sixth grade class-

room is consistent with policies estab-

lished in federal and State regulations

that handicapped children be educated along

with the non-handicapped to the extent pos-

Sible. See 20 U.S.C. $1412 (5) (8); and 16

NCAC 2E.1515(a). This policy has a ration-

al pasis to promote a valid state goal; it

does not violate due process. Therefore,

we do not find this decision to be arbi-

trary and capricious.

The plaintiff argues that the decision

by the school system was erroneous because

the school System did not consider

Marguerite's records from the CID and be-

cause it only used the Peabody Individual

Achievement Test. We find no merit in this

6.

argument. Virst, the hearing officer who

affirmed the school comnittee's decision

had before him numerous exhibits offered by

the plaintiff. Among those exhibits were

Marguerite'’s report cards from CID, an IEP

prepared by the private school, and several

puolications regarding education of deaf

children. In addition, the hearing officer

considered, and included in his findings of

facts, the reports from the Coordinator of

the Hearing Impaired Program at Atlantic

Christian College, and from an audiologist

at East Earolina University. The heariny

officer, after considering that evidence

and the evidence presented by the school

system, issued a Decision and Rationale,

which affirnned the placement determination

of the school system.

In addition, the regulations do not

66.

require, as plaintiff sugyests, that the

records from the CID, her report cards, and

work samples be considered by the committee

as it reached its decision. The statutes

and regulations require that a multi-

disciplinary diagnosis and evaluation be

performed by the school system. G.S-.

1i5-375; Lo NCAC 2E.1510. This the school

system did. Significantly, the trial court

made the following findings of fact to

which no exception was made and which are

Supported by substantial evidence in view

of the entire record:

5. At a conference on

July 27, 1978, including, a-

mong others, Dr. W.O. Fields,

Superintendent of the school

system, and Mrs. Harrell, it

was determined that it would

67.

be necessary to evaluate

Marguerite to determine if the

school system could = furnisn

her with an appropriate educa-

tional program.

6. A multi-disciplinary

diagnosis and evaluation of

Maryuerite was imade by the

respondent. She was assessed

in all areas related to her

disability. The respondent

conducted conferences on Au-

gust ll, 14, 22 of 1978 with

the petitioners and various

educational experts. After

the conferences had been con-

Cluded, an individualized edu-

cation program was developed

68.

for the child by the School

Systein.

Further, the local hearing officer also

made extensive findings of fact which sup-

ported the decision to place Marguerite in

@ regular sixth grade class.

The plaintiff also argues that the IEP

is unresponsive to her needs. Specifical-

ly, she argues that the IEP was incomplete

in that it did not include a statement of

the educational services to be provided for

the child and a description of the extent

to which the child will be in the regular

Classroom. The IEP states that the percent-

aye of time to be spent in the classroom

and with resource persons was “to be deter-

mined by child's needs." While a more spe-

cific determination of the above require-

oY.

ments is desired, it is our opinion that on

the facts of this case, the answers were

sufficient. We note that this IEP was de-

veloped between 22 August and 28 August

1978, and that the initial request for

funds was not made until 17 July 1978 for

the 1978-79 school year. We believe that

the school board acted diligently and in

good faith in evaluating Maryuerite's needs

and developing the IP within this relative-

ly short period of time. We also note that

the trial court found that Marguerite was

enrolled in the Wilson School System in

September 1980 and that she is progressing

with her studies.

For the foreginy reasons, the judgnent

below is

Affirmed.

70,

Judge HILL concurs.

Judge WELLS concurs

in the result.

71.

APPENDIX 8B

JUDGMENT

Wo. SO0O0P82

SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA

October 7, i192

J. GREGORY WALLACE, Clerk

Re: Marguerite Owens Harrell, by her par-

ents, Allen WwW. Harrell and Irene Burk

Harrell (Petitioner) v. Wilson County

Schools, et al (Respondents)

Upon consideration of the Plaintiffs’

notice of appeal from the Worth Carolina

Court of Appeals, filed in this matter pur-

suant to G.S. 7A-30, and Defendants’ motion

to dismiss the appeal for lack of Signifi-

cant Public Interest and upon consideration

of Plaintifts' petition for discretionary

review of the decision of the North Caro-

lina Court of Appeals, pursuant to G.S.

7A-31, the following order was entered and

is hereby certified to the North Carolina

72.

Court ot Appeals: Defendants’ motion to

dismiss the appeal is

"Allowed by order of the Court

in Conference this the 5th day

of October 1982.

s/ Martin, J.

For the Court"

Plaintiffs' petition for discretionary re-

view is

"Denied by order of the Court

in Conference this the Sth day

of October 1982.

s/ Martin, J.

Por the Court"

Therefore, it is considered and adjudg-

ed further that plaintiff do pay the sum of

Nine and no/100 Dollars ($9.00) and that ex-

ecution issue therefor.

WITNESS my hand and the seal of the

Supreme Court of North Carolina, this the

73.

7th day of October i982.

s/ J. Gregory Wallace

Clerk of the Supreme Court

74.

APPENDIX C

JUDGMENT

79=CVS-155

WILSON COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT

February 27, 1981

Re: Marguerite Owens Harrell, by her par-

ents, Allen W. Harrell and Irene Burk

Harrell (Petitioner) v. Wilson County

Scnools, Dr. W.O. Fields, Jr., Superinten-

dent, and North Carolina Department of Pub-

lic Instruction, Dr. A. Craig Phillips,

Superintendent (Respondents)

PRELIMINARY STATEMENT

This matter was initiated by Allen WwW.

and Irene Burk Harrell (Petitioners), par-

ents of Marguerite Owens Harrell (child),

pursuant to N.C.G.S. 115-179.1 and 20 USC

$1415. The Petitioners sought to require

the Wilson County Board of Education

(Respondent) to provide an educational ex-

pense grant for their daughter, who is a

child with special needs as defined in

75.

G-S. 115-3060. The request was denied for

that the School System concluded that it

could offer an appropriate program. A hear-

ing ‘as requested and was held by George Ss.

Willard, Jr., Hearing Officer, on October

11, 1978. From a determination in favor of

the Respondent, issued on November 6, 1978,

Petitioners appealed to the State education

agency, pursuant to G.S. 115-179.1(b), le

WCAC 26. 1517(c), 20 USC §1415(c) and 45

CFR l2la-150(a). The State Review Officer,

Lowell Harris, considered the matter at a

hearing held December 20, 1978. On January

18, 1979, the decision of the Hearing Of-

ficer was upheld. The Petitioners have now

requested judicial review of this adminis-

trative decision, in accordance with Arti-

cle 4 of Chapter 150A of the General Sta-

tutes.

7o.

This matter came on for hearing pvefore

the undersigned Judge at the January 12,

1981, Civil Term of Superior Court of wWil-

son County. Attorneys for petitioners and

respondents filed briefs. After hearing

Oral arguments, the attorneys for the par-

ties herein were directed to submit pro-

posed orders containing appropriate find-

ings of fact.

Unpon the consideration of the record

herein, oral arguments and the briefs sub-

mitted, the Court makes findings as herein-

after set forth.

FINDINGS OF FACT

l.

Marguerite Owens Harrell (hereinafter

Marguerite) was born on December 20, 1964.

At all relevant times she has been a leyal

resident of Wilson County, North Carolina,

77.

and has lived in the area served by Wilson

County Schools. Allen W. Harrell and Irene

Burk Harrell are Maryguerite's paren*s and

they are residents of Wilson County, North

Carolina.

2.

Marguerite has a hearing impairment

that is rated from moderate to severe. She

is a child with special needs entitled to

receive a free, appropriate public educa-

tion under applicaple State and Federal

statutes dealing with education for the

handicapped.

3.

Marguerite had never been enrolled in

the Public Schools of Wilson County at the

time these proceedings were initiated. She

was enrolled at the Central Institute for

the Deaf in St. Louis, Missouri. She had

78.

been enrolled there since 1973. Prior to

that time, sne attended “oral commnunica-

tion” proyrams, both private and public,

located in Durham and Cary, North Carolina.

Ghe briefly attended the Eastern North Caro~

lina School for the Deaf in 1972.

4.

On June 14, 1978, Dr. W. O. Fields,

Superintendent of the Wilson County

Schools, received a letter form Mrs.

Harrell requesting forms to be used when

requesting funds for the education of

Maryquerite at the Central Institute for the

Deaf for the academic year beginning Sep-

tember, 1978. Mrs. Harrell was furnished

appropriate forms and by letter dated July

14, 1978, the application was submitted and

was received by the school system on July

17, 1978.

79.

5.

At a conference on July 27, 197, in-

cluding, among others, Dr. W. O. Fields,

Superintendent of the school system, and

Mes. darrell, it was determined that it

would be necessary to evaluate Maryuerite

to determine if the school system could

furnish her with an appropriate educational

program.

o.

A multi-disciplinary diagnosis and

evaluation of Marguerite was made by the

respondent. She was assessed in all areas

related to her disability. The respondent

conducted conferences on August ll, 14, 22

of 1978 with the petitioners and various

educational experts. After the conferences

had been concluded, an individualized educa-

tion program was developed for the child by

uO.

the School System. The program presented

by respondent included an oral comnunica-

tion education program in a reygular sixth

yrade class with support services of a

speech therapist, a resource teacher, a

psychologist and a classroom aide. A

phonic ear and its accessories were to be

used in Marguerite's program.

7.

On August 28, 1978, the Administrative

Review Committee made its findings that an

appropriate proyram could be provided.

Marguerite's parents were notified of this

decision. (As shown by Page 338 of the

Record. )

8.

The School System, after determining

that it could offer Marguerite an appropri-

ate program, denied the request for an

Bl.

educational expense grant. Marguerite was

enrolled by her parents at the Central In-

stitute for the Deaf for the 1974-1979

school year.

9.

The parents of Marguerite, after re-

ceiving the determination of the respondent

and the placement proposed for Maryuertie,

requested a hearing. The hearing was held

on October 11, 1978, with George S. Willard

presiding as Hearing Officer.

10.

At the hearing, witnesses who testi-

fied other than Mrs. Harrell and Dr. Fields

of the Wilson County Schools were: Mrs.

Connie Michels, Coordinator for the Hearing

Impaired Program at Atlantic Christian Col-

lege, Wilson, North Carolina; Diane Parker,

Director of Programs for Exceptional Child-

82.

ren, Wilson County Schools; Paul Speziale,

School Psychologist for Wilson County

Schools; Mildred Blackburn, Consultant for

the Proyram for the Hearing Impaired, State

Department of Public Instruction; Gloria

Ellis, Speecn Clinician, Wilson County

Schools; Rosalee Wooten, EMR/LD Resource

Teacher for Wilson County Schools; Evelyn

Bowden, School Nurse and Social Worker at

Wilson County Schools; Martha Wrenn, Diag-

nostic Prescriptive Teacher for the Wilson

County Schools.

ll.

A summary of the testimony of the wit-

nesses is as follows:

Mrs. Michels stated that she provided

a summer speech tutorial program for

Marguerite for two hours a week for about

twelve weeks. She testfied that there was

83.

not a program in Wilson County to accon-

modate Marguerite's educational needs and

that the program developed for the child by

Wilson County was vague and without speci-

fic time allotments special instruction and

Classroom instruction. She also stated

that such a program, however, was an on-

yOing process and one she would have to see

in a classroom setting in order to deter-

mine the adequacy of the program. She sta-

ted that she thought it would be helpful to

the child to be at home with her parents

rather than attending a residential school

Such as the one at St. fouis. She yave an

Opinion, however, that the program at the

St. Louis school was superior to the one

being developed by Wilson County for

Marguerite.

84.

There was entered in the record in

benalf of the petitioners Exhibit H-3, be-=-

ing a statement by the audiologist the East

Carolina Speech and Hearing Clinic who eval-

uated Marguerite on June 23, 1978. It was

his recommendation that she be returned to

St. Louis because, to his knowledge, there

were no programs in the State that provided

the same type of education found at that

school.

Paul Speziale testified as to the re-

Sults of various tests administered to

Marguerite by him. He testified, in his

Opinion, the program offered by the school

System would be appropriate to meet the

educational needs of the child and that, in

his opinion, his evaluation of her did not

reveal any special education needs that the

School system could not meet.

3B».

Gloria @llis, Speecn Clinician, testi-

fied as to the results of various tests ad-

ministered to Maryuerite and said she had

little ditficulty understanding her speech.

Mrs. Mildred Blackburn testified that

she was consultant for Proyrams for the

Hearing Impaired in the public schools of

North Carolina and testified as to exten-

sive education with hearing impaired child-

ren and extensive experience in teaching

same. She testified as to similar children

in North Carolina who had been in the same

Situation as Marguerite who had been re-

turned to public schools and the success

that had been had with them. She gave as

her Opinion that the prograin that had been

developed for Marguerite had all of the

components of a program that the State De-

partment would recommend for children who

86.

are hearing impaired.

Rosalee Wooten, EMR/LL Hl Resource

Teacher for Wilson County Schools, testi-

fied that her undergraduate degree was in

education of the hearing impaired and that

she had worked for the Eastern North Caro-

lina School of the Deaf; that at the pre-

sent time, she was working on her masters

in learning disabilities at East Carolina

University. She was of the opinion that

Marguerite, with the benefit of a phonic

ear, could function in a regular classroom,

that Marguerite functioned quite well in a

one-to-one situation and that the school

was prepared to offer her a one-to-one

basis on a daily schedule. She also stated

that there was a program in existence in

Wilson serving another child with a hearing

impairment; that the other child had been

—

87.

wainstreaued back into a regular classroom

and was fitting very well socially an aca-

demically and apparently Mrs. Michels was

not aware that such a program had already

been developed for another child and was

working well.

Mrs. Evelyn Bowden, School Nurse-

Social Worker, testified that she examined

Marguerite as it related to vision screen-

ing and that glasses really did not help

her.

Mrs. Diane Parker, Director of Pro-

grams for Exceptional Children for Wilson

County Schools, testified as to her creden-

tials in the area and as to her experience

in teaching multi-handicapped children.

She stated that she met with Mrs. Michels,

Mrs. Harrell, Martha Wrenn, the Diagnostic

Prescriptive Teacher, and Mr. Paul

8B.

Speziale, the School Psychologist. Mrs.

Harrell stated during one of the confer-

ences that she had already arranged for

Marguerite to attend the Central Institute

for the Deaf for the 1978-79 year pbefore

the summer of 1978, and that Mrs. Harrell

said that maybe Maryuerite could attend the

Wilson County program the following year,

but that she was unwilling for her to at-

tend Wilson County Schools for the year

1978-79. Regardless of what the final ele-

ments of the individual education prograin

were determined to be for Marguerite, the

decision. by Mrs. Harrell had been made to

reject it.

12.

George S. Willard, Jr., the Hearing

Officer, issued his findings of fact and

conclusions on November 6, 1978, upholding

89.

the determination by the Wilson County

Schools that an appropriate individual edu-

cation program had been developed and of-

fered to Marguerite. From this determina-

tion the petitioners appealed to the State

Education Agency pursuant to G.S.

115-179.1(b), lo NCAC 2E. 1L517(c), 20 USC

Section 14l5(c), 45 CFR 121A=-510(a).

13.

Tne appeal was heard by the State Re-

view Officer, Lowell Harris, at a hearing

held on December 20, 1978. A transcript of

the evidence of that hearing is contained

in the record. At the hearing, again oral

evidence was adduced and Mr. David Mills,

Assistant Director, Division for Exception-

al Children, Worth Carolina State Depart-

ment of Public Instruction, assisted the

heariny officer. Appearing for the Wilson

90.

County Schools were Dr. W. O. Fields, Jr.,

Superintendent, Mr. Ray Lamm, Director of

Instruction, and Mrs. Diane Parker, Direc-

tor of Programs for Exceptional Children at

the Wilson County Schools. Mrs. Allen W.

Harrell appeared on her own behalf.

14.

The State Review Officer was of the

Opinion that the Wilson County Schools

could provide Marguerite with a program

that was appropriate to meet her special

educational needs and that the school sys-

tem was willing to provide such a program.

The decision of the local Hearing Officer,

Mr. Willard, was therefore upheld.

15.

The petitioners appealed from the deci-

sion of the State Review Officer in accord-

ance with Article IV of Chapter 159A of the

91.

General Statutes.

lo.

Maryuerite was enrolled in Coon Middle

School of the Wilson County Schools on Sep-

tember 2, 1980, for the 1980-81 school

tern. Her teachers and the specialists

working with her report that she is pro-

gressing satisfactorily with her studies.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

l. The question for the Court to de-

cide is whether Wilson County Schools offer-

ed an appropriate program to meet the educa-

tional needs of Marguerite Harrell for the

1978-79 school year.

2. P.L. 94-142, now 20 USCA $1401, et

seq. and the implementing regulations, 45

CFR 912la.4, define a free, appropriate

public education as special education

related services which:

(a) Have been provided at

public expense, under public

Supervision and direction, and

without charge,

(po) Meet the standards of the

State educational agency,

(c) Include an appropriate

preschool, elementary or se-

condary school education in

the State involved, and,

(d) Are provided in conform-

ity with the individualized

education prograin.

Similarly, 16 NCAC 2E.1501(c) (proaul-

gated pursuant to the provisions of G.S.

115-3605 through 3607 and G.S. 115-375) de-

fines free, appropriate public education as

special education related services which:

3.

93.

(1) Are provided at public ex-

penses, under public supervi-

sion and direction without

charge.

(2) Meet the standards of the

State education agency.

(3) Are provided in conform-

ity with an individualized

education program.

It is the duty of a School Board

to provide an appropriate program for excep-

tional children with special needs. The

School Board is not required to provide or

pay for the best education available at

other schools but only to furnish an appro-

priate education.

4.

This Court, in reviewing the deci-

sions heretofore made herein is applying

94.

the “whole record" test as defined in

Thompson v Board of Education, 292 NC 406,

233 S.E. 2d 538 (1977). Tne “whole record"

test does not allow this Court to replace

the Board's judgment as between two reason-

ably conflicting views, even though the

Court could justifiably have reached a dif-

ferent result had this matter been before

it de novo.

5+ The “whole record" test fully sup-

ports the hearing officer and the State Re-

view Officer's decisions that Wilson County

Schools had offered the child an appro-

priate proyram and placement. The evidence

of the appropriateness of the placement and

program was presented by educational profes-

sionals trained and qualified to make such

decisions.

95.

o. The judiciary should not substi-

tute its judgment for that of educational

agencies unless pursuant to G.S. IL50A-51

the Court finds that substantial rights of

the petitioners have been prejudiced vwe-

cause the administrative findings, infer-

ences and conclusions, or decisions are:

(1) In violation of consti-

tutional provisions; or

(2) In excess of the statu-

tory authority or jurisdiction

of the agency; or

(3) Made upon unlawful proce-

dure; or

(4) Affected by other error

of law; or

(>) Unsupported by substan-

tial evidence admissible under

90.

GS. I150A-30 in view of the

entire Record as submitted; or

(6) Arbitrary or capricious.

(Emphasis supplied)

7. The Court finds that there was sub-

stantial admissible evidence to support the

decisions of the Hearing Officer and the

Review Officer.

IT IS NOW, THEREFORE, ORD®RED, ADJUD-

GED AND DECREED that the decisions of the

Hearing Officer and the Review Officer are

hereby affirmed and the petition filed in

this Court by the petitioners is hereby

dismissed.

Signed out of term and out of Wilson

County by consent of the parties.

97.

This February 27, 1981.

s/ Henry L. Stevens, III

Judge

98.

APPENDIX D

STATE REVIEW DECISION

Child's Name: Marguerite Owens Harrell

Parents (Appellants): Mr. and Mrs. Allen

W. Harrell

Address: 408 Pearson Street, Wilson, N.C.

Local School District (Appellee): Wilson

County Schools /

Representative: Dr. W.O. FPields, Jr.,

Superintendent

Review Date: December 20, 1978

Date of Decision: January 28, 1979

Review Officer: Lowell Harris

On Wednesday, December 20, 1978, in

the Education Building, Raleigh, N.C., I,

lowell Harris, represented Dr. A. Craig

Phillips, State Superintendent of Public

Instruction, in a review of the Novenber 7,

1978 decision by Mr. George S. Willard re-

sulting from the October 11, 1978, hearing

99.

reyarding an educational proyram offered by

the Wilson County Public Schools’ for

Marguerite Owens Harrell.

Although a transcript of the December

20, 1978 review is not required, I never-

theless provided for the taking of a tran-

script. I have waited until after review-

ing the transcript before inaking a final

decision. A copy of the transcript has

been ftorwarded to both parties under sepa-

rate cover.

At the December 20, 1978 review, I was

assisted by Ms. Patricia Houulik, Associate

Attorney General, Department of Justice,

and Mr. David Mills, Assistant Director,

Division for Exceptional Children, N.C.

State Departinent of Public Instruction.

Appearing for the Wilson County School were

br. W. O. Fields, Jr., Superintendent,

100.

Wilson Schools, Mr. Ray Lamm, Director of

Instruction, Wilson County Schools and Mrs.

Diane Parker, Director of Prograns for Ex-

ceptional Children, wilson County Schools.

The petitioner, Ms. Allen W. Harrell appear-

ed on her behalf.

Mr. and Mrs. Allen W. Harrell request-

ed a review of the decision by the local

hearing officer on the question of whether

Or not the Wilson County Schools can pro-

vide an appropriate educational program to

meet the special educational needs of

Marguerite Owens Harrell. Mr. George S.

Willard, the local hearing officer decided

that the Wilson County Schools can provide

such a program.

PROCEDURE AND TESTIMONIES

I reviewed the transcript of the local

hearing of October 11, 1978. At the review

LULL.

of December 20, 1978 I heard aryuments and

rebuttals from both the petitioner and the

respondent.

The transcript of the local nearing

indicates that after the Wilson County Pub-

lic Schools provided a wmultidisciplinary

evaluation of Maryuerite and developed an

individualized education program for her,

they arrived at a decision which would

place Marguerite in a regular sixth yrade

class with additional support services by

resource personnel. Mr. and Mrs. Harrell

challenged the placement decision on the

yrounds that the proposed placement would

seriously impair the progress Marguerite

has been making. Mrs. Harrell indicated

that she was in favor of mainstreaming her

daughter as early as possible but at a time

that will not interfere with her right to

102.

an appropriate education for herself. She

indicated that it was the opinion of the

teacners who have worked with her at the

Central Institute tor the feaf in St.

Louis, Missouri that Marguerite is not

ready for mainstreaming. The transcript

also indicates that the following were pre-

sented and argued by the petitioner and

others who represented her at the hearing

on October il, 1978;

1. Mr. Garrett, Zast Carolina Univer-

sity, who evaluated Maryuerite, wrote a

letter on July 12, 1978 saying that

Marguerite's auditory receptive abilities

with the use of amplification was above

average for a child with this particular

type of hearing loss. He indicated that he

felt the excellent expressive and receptive

ability was a function of the excellent

103.

program she was attendiny at Central

Institute for the Deaf. He recomnended

that she return to the institution to

complete her educational curricula because

he knew Of no proygraas in Worth Carolina

that provided the same type of educational

prograins like that found at CID.

2. Mr. Dennis Jernigan, headmaster at

the Central Institute for the Deaf, wrote a

letter saying that he agreed with the per-

son who mentioned that Marguerite might

appear to be a good candidate for early

mainstreaming. He mentioned that

Marguerite has a nice easy flow of speech

and can communicate with hearing people but

at a superficial level. He inentioned that

children like Maryuerite often get into the

mainstream of education too early and be-

come failures.

104,

3. MS. Harrell compared the indi-

vidualized education plan as prepared by

the CID with the education plan prepared by

the Wilson County Public Sehools. She men<«

tioned that the plan for the CID was a de-

tailed report and reflected an awareness of

Maryuerite's special needs. She stated

that she wanted teachers for her daughter

who had had professional training and exper-

ience in working with handicapped children.

She also stated that she did not want to

take Maryuerite from a proven program (CID)

and try something else that might or might

not work.

4. Mr. Alexander Paul Speziale, psy-

chologist in the Wilson County Schools,

evaluated Marguerite and wrote a psycho-

logical report. He acknowledged that coin

munication difficulties were minimal

105.

throughout testing.

2» Ms. Harrell stated that her dauyh-

ter had had proolems in the classroom, espe-

cially behavior problems. Ms. Harrell stat-

ed that Marguerite's behavior problems were

not controlied by medication and that it

had not been determined that she needs pos-

sible medication to control the behavior

problems. She mentioned that Mr. Speziale

had reported that the Wechnoler Intelligence

Scale for children was given to Marguerite

and that her present intellectual function-

inj ranged from the borderline to average

ranges. According to Mr. Speziale's report

Marguerite appeared not to be achieving up

to her general intellectual potential in

the areas of reading and spelling.

b. Ms. Harrell stated that she had

never presented Marguerite for enrollwent

106.

in the Wilson County Schools and requested

that an appropriate program be designed for

her. She also mentioned that it had not oc-

curred to her that the Wilson County

Schools would be an appropriate placement

for Marguerite and that she had assumed

that the schools could not provide an appro-

priate prograin to Marguerite.

7. Ms. Connie Michels, coordinator of

the hearing impaired prograin at Atlantic

Christian College, reported that she worked

with Marguerite as a speech clinician in

May, 1978. She reported that Maryuerite is

a very, very oral child who used her resi-

dual hearing to its utmost. She also men-

tioned that she is an avid speech reader,

but needs a lot more work in speech and

language. Ms. Michels felt that the per-

sonnel who were to work with deaf or hard

107.

of hearing children should be trained to

work with this type of child before putting

the child into the program. She also felt

that curriculum modifications were neeued

for a hearing impaired child, as well as

additional equipment and an acoustically

treated room. Ms. Michels felt it would be

4 trenendous adjustment for Maryuerite to

change prograins. She indicated that she

did not feel that the Wilson County Schools

had established the criteria needed prior

to mainstreaming hearing impaired children.

8. Ms. Michels stated that she was

Opposed to placement of Maryuerite in the

Wilson County Schools because preparation

of the professional and the non-profes-

sional staff members should begin before

the child is placed into the proyram, not

while tne child is there. She indicated

LOS.

that an appropriate facility was needed and

that the teacher/student ratio should be

reduced. She said the she did not feel

that Marguerite was ready to be placed into

a class of regular sixth graders without

necessary preparatory work. She also felt

that her speech and languaye development

was not to a point where she cari perform

and learn in the kiid of environment pro-~

posed for Marguerite in the Wilson County

Schools. Ms. Michels stated that she felt

that the home environment is the place for

any child and that living at home could

make & contribution to her education.

The appellee was asked to present tes~-

timony. Key points that were presented

included the following:

l. Dr. W.O. Fields, Superintendent,

Wilson County Schools, stated his first

109,

contact with this matter was on June 14,

L978, when he received a copy of a letter

fron Ms. Harrell, mother of Marguerite, re-

questing funds to provide for the education

of Maryuerite at the Central Institute for

the Deaf in St. Louis.

2. Dr. Fields revealed that

Marguerite has never been enrolled in the

Wilson County Schools and there was no in-

formation to indicate that she had ever

been presented for enrollment.

3. A conference was arranged with Ms.

Harrell, Marguerite, Mr. Speziale, Psycho-

logist of Wilson County Schools, Mr. Lama,

Director of Instruction, and Mrs. Rosalee

Wooten, an EMK/LD teacher who is certified

in hearing impaired education and Dr.

Fields, Superintendent. This group of in-

dividuals decided that further evaluations

110,

would be needed before proper assessment

could be completed as to whether they could

or could not meet Marguerite's needs.

4. It was pointed out that the school

System was presently serving a hearing im-

paired student who igs approximately the

same chronoloyical aye as is Marguerite.

9+ Dr. Fields testified that the wil-

son county Schools had accepted the mandate

from Public Law 94-142 and N.C. House Bill

624, He indicated that he and his staff

had been thorough and conscientious in

their effort to respond to the needs of

Marguerite. They had Spent a yreat deal of

time assessing the educational needs of the

Child and are developing the individualized

education program. He emphasized that he

believed the Wilson County Schools had made

a placement recomnendation which will serve

lll.

the educational needs of Marguerite, in an

appropriate, least restrictive environment.

vO. Ms. Harrell stated that she had

never considered the fact that the School

System might have a program suitable for

Marguerite, but that maybe every handi-

capped child ought to first approach the

public school system.

7. Mr. Lamm, Director of Instuction,

Wilson County Schools, testified that Mr.

Paul Speziale, psychologist in the Wilson

County Schools, gave Marguerite a psycho-

logical evaluation on July 31, 19748 and

that on August 1, Miss Gloria Ellis, Speech

Clinician, gave her a speech/lanyuaye eval-

uation. Letters from Doctors Lee Clark and

Robert Sloop of the Wilson Clinic were re-

ceived on August 4, 1978. On August 22,

1978, a meeting was held to discuss an

1l2.

individualized education program for

Marguerite. Mr. Lamm stated that on August

28, 1978, the administrative placement com-

mittee wade a decision on the placement of

Macyuerite. The administrative placement

comnittee report, parental permission for

placement, the appeals procedure and a copy

of the IEP were mailed to Mr. and Mrs.

Harrell by certified mail. Mr. Lamm report-

ed that Dr. Fields did not sign the expense

grant application because he and his staff

felt they could provide an appropriate pro-

gram for Marguerite in the Wilson County

Schools.

8. Mr. Speziale, Psychologist in the

Wilson County Schools, testified that he

tested Marguerite and that she was very

pleasant, cooperative and eager to work.

He stated that she spoke freely and intel-

113.

ligibly with him. Communication problems

appeared to be minimal throughout the test-

ing. Accordiny to the results of the

tests, Marguerite’s present intellectual

functioning ranged from the borderline to

average. He speculated that what

Marguerite needed was a program in the

school system where she could receive in-

creased exposure to a more normal or more

normalized academic setting where she might

learn to function better in reading and

spelling. Mr. Speziale expressed an opin-

ion that he felt strongly that a local set-

ting would be mucn more conducive to

Marguerite’s social and emotional devel-

Opment. He stated that he felt Marguerite

was ready to enter the Wilson County School

System and that the Wilson County Schools

are ready to serve her. Mr. Speziale

114.

stated that his evaluation did not reveal

any special educational needs that the

school system could not meet.

9. Ms. Mildred Blackburn, Consultant

in Speech and Hearing, Division for Excep-

tional Children, North Carolina State De-

partment of Public Instruction, testified

that after careful review of Marguerite's

tests and academic status, she recommended

that Wilson County consider offering ser-

vices to Marguerite in the local schools,

as one possible option. She stated that

she felt confident that the personnel of

Wilson County were committed to good pro-

gramning for Marguerite, that they had com-

petencies adequate to provide a quality pro-

gram, and that the child would yreatly bene-

fit from the association with the stimu-

lation by other hearing, speaking peers.

115.

MS. Blackburn testified that the indi-

vidualized education program developed for

Maryuerite had all the components of a pro-

gram that she would recomaend for children

who are hearing impaired. She indicated

that the program offered to Marguerite met

all the legal standards. Ms. Klackburn

indicated that personnel in the State De-

partment of Public Instruction would be

available to work with the Wilson County

Schools. She also indicated that the re-

source teacher who would be working with

Marguerite and the regular class teacher is

certified to work with the hearing inm-

paired.

10. Ms. Gloria Ellis, Speech Clini-

cian in the Wilson County schools, testi-

fied that she conducted a speech/ language

evaluation of Marguerite, and recommended

lilo.

that Marguerite receive speech therapy of a

minimua of three times per week.

ll. MS. Rosalee Wooten, EMR/LD re-

source teacher for the Wilson County

Schools, testified that she had an under-

graduate degree from Atlantic Christian in

education of the hearing impaired. She

stated that she had done extensive tutoring

and observing at Eastern N.C. School for

the Deaf. Ms. Wooten stated that she felt

Marguerite could function in the regular

classroom with the use of voice aiplifica-

tion mechanisms. Ms. Wooten stated that

she would teach Maryuerite all the aca-

demics and would work with the regular

classroom teacher to reinforce what she had

taught.

12. Ms. Diane Parker, Director of Pro

graas for Exceptional Children, Wilson

i117.

County Schools, testified that she met with

the placement conmittee for two hours on

August 22, 1978 and agreed that Marguerite

would be placed in sixth grade class, which

would use an oral approach. A resource

teacher who is certified to work with the

hearing impaired, a speech therapist, psy-

Chologist, and a teacher aide would work

with Marguerite. She also stated that the

pupil/teacher ratio in the regular class

would be lowered so that Marguerite's needs

could be met. It would be determined after

the placement how much time Marguerite

would spend with the resource teacher.

This would depend on the need. Other ar-

rangements would be considered such as spe-

cial acoustical design and large print

books after Marguerite's initial placement.

Ms. Parker stated that on August 28,

118.

1978, the administrative placement commit-

tee in the Wilson County Schools met and

recommended placement at the Vick School

for Marguerite. Ms. Harrell was present at

a conference on August 22, 197% to provide

input into the IuP. Ms. Parker stated that

Ms. Harrell stated before the IEP was de-

veloped that she was already committed to

return Marguerite to the school in St.

Louis for this year.

FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS

OF THE REVIEW OFFICER

In the opinion of the review officer:

4. The Wilson County Schools have

attempted to offer and have offered to pro-

vide a program appropriate to meet the spe-

cial educational needs of Marguerite

Harrell. They have followed the appro-

priate and required procedures in federal

119.

ana state reyulations in determining tne

needs of the child.

2. The Wilson County Schools have

offered to continuously evaluate the pro-

yress of Maryuerite and provide what is

needed to assure her success. Additional

personnel with be employed if needed.

3. Even though all of the personnel

who will be working with Marguerite are not

trained to work with the hearing impaired,

the resource teacher is certified to work

with the hearing impaired.

4. State Departinent personnel froin

the Division for Exceptional Children have

oftered their services to work with the

Wilson County Schools in meeting the educa-

tional needs of Marguerite.

9. After careful reading of the tran-

script of the October 11, 1978 hearing, I

120.

feel that the local hearing officer gave

sufficient opportunity for all present to

argue or add or question anything desired

before the hearing was adjourned.

DECISION

After carefully reviewing the tran-

script of the local hearing and after hear-

ing and considering aryuments for both par-

ties, it is my opinion that the Wilson

County Schools can provide Marguerite a

program that is appropriate to meet her

special educational needs. I feel that the

Wilson County Schools are willing to pro-

vide such a program and that they will not

exclude Marguerite from such a _ procram.

The decision of the local hearing officer

is therefore upheld.

RECOMMENDATIONS

l. It is recomended that the

l2i.

teachers, aide and other resource personnel

work closely with Ms. Harrell during the

first few months of school to make sure

Marguerite is adjusting to the new school

environment and that the necessary adjust~

ments be made to ensure Marguerite's suc-

cess. Continued review, evaluation and

adaptation of Marguerite’s program should

be maintained.

2. The school system should request

assistance from the Division for Excep-

tional Children, State Departinent of Public

Instruction in providing appropriate staff

development and other services to the per-

sonnel who will be working with Marguerite.

JUDICIAL REVIEW

Subject to the provisions of N.C.G.S.

150 A, 115-179, L(b), and 16 N.C.A.C. 26.

lol7d, a petition for judicial review of

122.

this decision may be filed in the Superior

Court of Wake County within thirty days

after notice of this decision is received.

Sincerely,

s/ LOWELL HARRIS

(Hearing Review Officer for

Dr. A. Craig Phillips,

State Superintendent of

Public Instruction)

Assistant Director,

Policy, \‘ersonnel

Development and

Regional Services

North Carolina Departinent

of Public Instruction

cc: Ur. A. Craig Phillips

Dr. O.E. Fields

Mr. Theodore R. Drain

Mrs. Patricia Hodulik

123.

APPENDIX £E

HEARING DECISION

November 6, 1978

Chila's name: Marguerite Owers harrell

Parents (Appellants): Mr. and Mrs. Allen

W. Harrell

Address: 408 Pearson Street, Wilson, N.C.

Local School District (Appellee): Wilson

vounty Schools

Representative: Dr. W.O. Fields, Jr.,

Superintendent

Hearing Date: October ll, 1974

Date of Decision: November 6, 1978

Hearing Officer: George S. Willard, Jr.

ISSUE AND PURPOSE OF THE HEARING

The issue in this hearing is related

to the appropriateness of the educational

program proposed for the child in question.

The appellants, the parents of the child,

contend that to place the child in a

124.

regular classroom with the support services

indicated in the Individualized Education

Program (IEP) prepared by the school system

would seriously impair the progress the

child has been making to overcome her handi-

cap in a proven program of oral education

specifically designed to meet the needs of

hearing impaired children. The school sys-

tem, the appellee, contends that the pro-

posed proyram of oral education which would

include the use of amplification equipment

in a regular classroom setting, with the

addition of the indicated supportive ser-

vices, would be appropriate to serve the

special needs of the child within the least

restrictive environinent.

WRITTEN EVIDENCE

The following documents were entered as

evidence:

125.

Letter fron Parents (Appellants)

Letter from Coordinator, Hearing

Impaired Program

Letter trom ECU Audiologist

Letter from Headmaster of

Private School

Report Carus from Private School

IuPs Prepared by Private School

IEP Prepared by School System

Letter to Governor

Two Letters from Child to Parent

Guide for Parents

Reading Achievement of the Deaf

Profiles of Former Students

of Private School

Acoustical Design of Classroom

for the Deaf

Has Oral Education Succeeded?

Speech and Lanyuage Evaluation

School System's Psycholoyical

Report

(H=1L)

(H=2)

(H=3)

(u-4)

(li=5 )

(Ho )

(H~7)

(H-8 )

(H-9)

(11-10)

(H=1L1L)

(H=12)

(H=-13)

(H=-14)

(H-1L>)

(H-16)

126.

Volta Review (September, 1977) (1i-17)

Letter from Parent (Appellant) | (S-1)

Letter from Superintendent

of School System (S-2)

Request for Education Grant (S-3)

Report of Parent-Child Conference (S-4)

School System's Psychological Report (S-5)

Speech and Language Evaluation (S-6)

Letters to Parents Concerning

Child's Vision (S-7)

Letters froin Ophthalomologists (S-8)

Conference Report (August 1l, 1978) (S-9)

Conference Report (August 14, 1978) (S=1O)

Conference Report (August 22, 1978) (S11)

Procedures for Referral, Screening,

Assessment and Placement (S-12)

Memorandum Regarding Expense Grant

Application (S-14)

DUE PROCESS

Prior to the hearing, a determination

was made by the Hearing Officer that the

127.

school system had complied with all aspects

of the required procedural safeguards. In

addition, the full disclosure requirement

was wet by the exchange of written evidence

and lists of witnesses at least five days

prior to the hearing. At the close of the

hearing, the appellant and the appellee

stipulated for the record that the required

due process procedures had been adequately

followed prior to and duriny the hearing.

The appellant was not represented by

leyal counsel. An attorney for the appel-

lee was present but did not participate in

the hearing.

PINDINGS OF FACT

1. The child, age 13, has a severe

hearing impairment. The results of an au-

diological evaluation at the East Carolina

University Speech and Hearing Clinic

128.

indicate a moderate to profound bilateral

sensorineural nearing loss. (Exhibit H-3)

2. The Superintendent of the school

system testified that he was first contact-

ed by letter from the appellant on June 14,

1978 requesting forms on which to request

an expense grant for the education of the

child in a private school. He testified

further that the child had never been en-

rolled in the school system.

3. The child has been enrolled in an

Out-of-state oral school for the deaf child-

ren since 1973 and has made proyress satis-

factory to the parents. A “Report to Par-

ents" dated May, 1978 indicates: (Exhibit

H=-5)

a. Good use of receptive lan-

guage skills includin; excel-

lent lip-reading abili y,

129.

excellent use of auditory abil-

ity, and excellent understand-

ing of simple sentences and

compound sentences when vocabu-

lary and language are famil-

iar.

D. Child is often careless

with her oral language and

shows little effort to improve

these problems.

c- Child is only interested

in her ideas and shows little

concern about her written lan-

guage.

d. Child's pronunciation

skills are poor but are improv-

ing. |

e. Child is able to do well

130.

in arithmetic when she puts

forth the effort. At times is

inattentive.

f. Child's work in reading is

acceptable some of the time.

She is showing improvement.

g- Child's work in science is

very good most of the time.

She is inattentive at times in

class, and her written work is

carelessly done.

he. In spelling, the child per-

forms acceptably some of the

time. Her errors are due to

carelessness.

i. Child needs more practice

in cursive writing.

j- Child enjoys drawing and

131.

painting assignments of all

kinds.

K»- In physical education, the

child rates very good most of

the time.

1. Child's behavior with her

peers and adults is sometimes

inappropriate. She is easily

angered.

me In the area of mental atti-

tude, the child is an active

Classroom participant.

n. Child is still inature,

and this affects progress,

Since application of learned

skills is dependent upon

maturity.

4. The Headmaster of the oral school

132.

for deaf children indicates that the child

is well-placed, progressing steadily, and

should continue in the school for two more

years following the current school year.

He states that if the child works hard dur-

ing that time she should be ready for some

kind of a mainstreaming program. (Exhibit

H-4 )

5. Information from the oral school

attended by the child indicates that child-

ren attend the school for varying lengths

of time before they are integrated into

educational programs with hearing students.

(Exhibit H-12)

6. The audiologist at the East Caro-

lina Speech and Hearing Clinic who evalu-

ated the child on June 23, 1978 expresses

the opinion that the child should continue

in an oral environment. He also recommends

133.

that she return to the special school to

complete her educational curriculum, pbe-

cause to his knowledye there are no pro-

grams in the state of North Carolina that

provide the sae type of educational para-

digm like that found at the school. He

states further that test results indicate

the child's “auditory receptive abilities

with the use of aimplication are above aver-

age for a child with this type of hearing

loss." (Exhibit H-3)

7. Tne Coordinator of the Hearing

Impaired Program at Atlantic Christian

Colleye, who provided a summer speech tutor-

ial program for the child (2 hours per week

for about 12 weeks) attributes the good pro-

gress of the child to the excellent oral

instruction she has received at the special

school. The coordinator expresses the

134.

Opinion that any deviation from the child's

present placement would be detrimental to

her education. She states that there is

not a program in Wilson to accomodate the

child's educational needs. (Exhibit H-2)

3. In testimony, the Coordinator of

the ACC Hearing Impaired Program expressed

the opinion that preparation of profes-

sional and non-professional staff inemebers

should begin before the child enters a reg-

ular public school neighborhood program,

not while the child is there. She testi-

fied concerning the IEP developed for the

child by the school system that it was

vague and without specific time allotments

for special instruction and classroom in-

struction.

9. Under cross-examination, the ACC

Coordinator acknot'ledged that the develop-

nad

135.

ment of an IEP was an ongoing process and

tnat the school system's lack of contact

with the child, and without seeing her in a

classroom setting, would make a difference.

She also expressed the opinion that a ‘judg-

ment of when the child should be main-

streamed should be left to the experts who

work with her day it and day out.

10. The appellant testified that the

law gives parents the right and responsibil-

ity to be actively involved in the planning

and implementation of their child's educa-

tion.

ll. The appellant prefers an oral com-

munication program for the child instead of

a program of total communication.

12. The appellant quoted fram the Sep-

tember, 1977 issue of Volta Review: “The

least restrictive environment is always

136.

relative to the needs of a particular

child."

ade TH testimony, the appellant ques-

tioned the advisability of placing a child

who is thirteen, almost fourteen, into a

Class of sixth graders, because the child

would strongly object to going to school

“with those babies."

14. The school system conducted a

multi-disciplinary diagnosis and evaluation

of the child. The child was assessed in

all areas related to her disability.

a. The school psychologist

employed by the school systein

administered the following

tests: Wechsler Intelligence

Scale for Children Revised

(WISC-R), Developmental Test

of Visual-Motor Integration

137.

(DT VMI), Peabody Individual

Achievement Test (PIAT), and

Peabody Picture Vocabulary

Test (PPVT). (Exhibit S-»)

(1) The child's performance

on the wISC-R- Full Scale

I.Q-"61, Verbal I.Q.#72 (73),

Performance I1.Q.=93. Present

intellectual functioniny

ranges from the wuorderline to

Average ranges. Child learns

more readily throuyh the visu-

al-motor mode rather than the

auditory. Relatively underde-

veloped areas include both

receptive and expressive lan-

guage skills as well as cer-

tain speech sounds. The

138.

child's subtest profile, with

the exception of vocabulary

subtest, is not unlike that of

the typical student with spe-

cific learning disabilities.

(2) The child's performance

on the DI'VMI indicates her

visual-motor integration

Skills are about five years

below her chronological

age--probably due in part to

her hearing handicap.

(3) Tne child's performance

on the PPVT indicates her re-

ceptive language skills are

Significantly Limited for her

age.

(4) The child's grade equi-

139.

valent scores on the PIAT are

as follows: Mathematics -

&.0; Reading Recoynition ~-

3-9; Reading Comprehension -

3-1; Spelling - 4.6; General

Information - 5.6; Total Test

- 4.5. The child's reading

and spelling skills are signi-

ficantly below expected

levels.

(5) Tne school psychologist

gave testimony that the pro-

gram offered by the school

system would be appropriate to

meet the educational needs of

the child. He testified under

direct examination that in his

opinion his evaluation did not

reveal any special education

needs that the school systein

could not meet.

b. The speech clinician em-

Ployed by the school system

administered the Goldman-

Fristoe Test of Articulation

(GFTA) and the Northwestern

Syntax Screening Test (NSST).

(Exhibit S-6)

(1) The child's percentile

rank of the GFTA was below

zero percent. Test designed

for those with normal hearing.

Errors are those characteris-

tic of child's hearing impair-

ent.

(2) Child gave rapid, reli-

able responses during adminis-

tration of the NSST. Some lan-

guage delay noted with posses-

sives, pronoun agreement, pre-

positional phrases, and _ in-

direct objects. Some confu-

sion with interroyative sen-

tences beginning with "Is".

Errors noted in omitting word

endinys. Phonemic errors in

reading included (k, d, s, 2z,

1, st, ts). Using recorded

sample, three auditors indenti-

fied correctly 3 out of » of

Child's sentences. Clinician

had little difficulty under-

standing the child's speech.

c+ With parents’ permission,

142.

copies of four letters relat-

ing to the child's visual prob-

lems were reviewed by the

school system. Child's best

corrected visual acuity is

20/25 in the right eye and

20/200 in the left eye.

(Exhibit S-7)

d- Child was examined by an

ophthalmologist in August,

1973. Diagnosed cause of de-

creased vision thought to be

pignentation of retina assoc-

iated with rubella syndrone.

An examination on December 20,

1974 by another = ophthaimo-

logist indicated best cor-

rected vision to be 20/25 in

143.

the right eye and 20/20U in

the left eye. (Exhibit S-3)

e. The school system's nurse-

social worker testified that

she measured the child's vi-

sion as follows: 20/30 in her

right eye and 20/200 in her

left eye.

15. The school system conducted con-

ferences (August ll, 14, 22, 1978) to dis-

cuss further the child's case and to re-

ceive input for the development of an indi-

vidualized education program for the child.

Involved in the conferences were the

Director of Programs for Exceptional Chila-

ren, the Director of Instruction, the

school psychologist, a teacher of excep-

tional children, a diagnostic-prescriptive

144.

teacher (all employed by the school

system); the mother of the child; the Co-

ordinator of the Program for Hearing Im-

paired, Atlantic Christian College; a Con-

sultant for Programs for Hearing-Impaired,

State Departinent of Public Instruction; the

Assistant Superintendent of the Eastern

North Carolina School for the Deaf and a

staff member of ENCSD. (Exhibits S-9,

S-10, S11)

lo. The school system developed an

individualized education program for the

Child. (Exhibit S-1L2)

a. A summary of present levels of

performance, long-range goals, short-term

objectives, criteria for evaluation, and

placement decisions were included in the

IEP.

b. The percentaye of time to be spent

145,

by the child with the regular teacher,

speech therapist, resource teacher, and

psychologist to be deteruined by the

child's needs subsequent to enrollment in

the school syste.

17, Placement decision of the school

systen: (Exhibit S=-12) An oral comnuni-

cation education program in a regular oth

yrade class with support services of speech

therapist, resource teacher, psychologist,

and classroom aide. A phonic ear and its

accessories would be used in the child's

prograin.

Lu. The resource teachers and/or

special education teachers proposed for the

child's program are certified in their pro-

fessional areas by the state education

agency.

19. The testimony of the State

l4o.

Department of Puplic Instruction Consultant

for Proyrams for the Hearing Impaired in

the public schools of North Carolina in-

cluded in part the following statements:

a. buring the last two years, the

number of public school programs for the

hearing impaired in the state has increased

from eighteen to forty-six programs.

b. We mainstrean hearing impaired

children only to the degree that they are

ready. If it's one hour a day, if it's

four hours a day, if it's three hours a

day» And not into a total classroow sit-

uation.

Cc. A resource teacher is needed to

give services on a one-to-one basis.

d. An aide, if needed, should be

there to accompany this child.

@. Speech therapy would be necessary.

147.

f. Amplification should be made avail-

able to this child.

9. Support services are needed for

the child from the psychologist, ancillary

personnel, art and music teachers, etc.

nh. The law requires that, to the maxi-

mum extent appropriate, handicapped child-

ren are educated with children who are not

handicapped. “I feel, of course--again, an

Opinion, but very strongly--that a century

of confinement of children in all types of

residential centers has only emphasized the

trauma of adjustment necessary when the

child returns to his own community."

i. The quality of the staff now serv-

ing North Carolina's public school hearing

impaired pupils is very good.

20. Under cross-examination, the SDPI

consultant testified:

148.

®. There are children who would, and

need to be, served in a residential center,

if they are in that state of multiple im-

pairment. But if there's any hope at all

for that child to be anything like normal,

then I think he needs to be at home where

he Lied normal living.

b. My experience, having been in resi-

dential centers and having worked with them

alinmost daily is that the opinion of people

in those centers is limited. How many of

then have really experienced in a public

school setting what that can do for a

child, as opposed to what can be done in a

residential center?

c- The program of special education

and related services proposed for the child

has all of the components of a program that

we would recommend for children who are

|

|

149.

hearing impaired. In that sense, it meets

the standards of the State Department of

Public Instruction.

d. The best schools in the nation for

hearing impaired or anything else have to

have some access to the child before they

can yet specific with his goals and objec-

tives.

€. Personnel of the State Departiwent

of Puolic Instruction would be available to

work with the school system very early upon

request.

21. The EMR/LD resource teacher for

the school system, who holds an_ under-

yraduate deyree in education of the hearing

impaired, testified that the child's oral

skills are very keen, that she is an avid

Speech reader, and that in her opinion the

child could function in a regular classroom

150.

with the use of voice amplification me-

chanisis. She testified furtner that an

oral environment would be provided for the

child and that sne would be taught for a

part of each day on a one-to-one basis.

22. The Director of Proyrams for Ex-

ceptional Children for the school systen

testified that the placement of the child

in question would involve a totally oral

approach; the resource services from a

teacher of the hearing impaired, speech

therapist, psychologist, and teacher aide;

and one-to-one instruction in a regular

Classroom setting. The director testified

further that the percentage of time to be

Spent in the support services would be de-

termined by the child's individual needs.

23. Under cross~examination, the

director acknowledyed that the child's

lol.

teacher, except for her resource teacher,

would be someone not trained to teach hear-

ing impaired children.

24. The Superintendent of tne school

system stated that with ability grouping in

the schools, if the child were placed in

sixth grade or wherever, there would be

children achieving at her levels, and she

would not be estranged to the instructional

prograi being offered for some children at

that grade level.

25. The Superintendent of the school

systen testified that the school system is

presently serving a hearing impaired stu-

dent who is approximately the same chrono-

logical age as the child in question. The

program includes a phonic ear for voice

amplification.

26. Classrooms for the deaf should be

152.

“over designed” acoustically. (Exhibit

Hi-13)

DECISION AND RATIONALE

The central issue befwre the Hearing

Officer in this case is whether or not free

appropriate puplic education is available

in the school system to meet the individual

educational needs of the child in question

as required by state and federal laws. The

adequacy of the educational proyramn offered

by the oral school for the deaf children

where the child is now enrolled is not an

issue before the Hearing Officer, and there-

fore, is not addressed in this decision.

In his letter indicating that the

child should continue her program at the

oral school for deaf children for “two more

years following this one," the Headmaster

of the school makes no reference to the

153.

appropriateness of the educational program

offered by the public school system.

Although the ECU audioloyist is un-

aware Of prograins in North Carolina that

“provide the sane type of educational

paradiyw"” as that found in the private

school attended by the child, the SbPI

consultant for proyrains for the hearing

lipairea children testifies there are now

forty-six public school proyrams for the

hearing iimpaired in the state. The audio-

loyist makes no reference to the appro-

priateness of the oral education program

offered to the child by the school systei.

Tne Coordinator of the ACC Hearing

Impaired Froyram testified that her ‘najor

reason for questioning the placement of the

child in the school system would be that

the preparation of the professional and

154.

non-professional staff members should begin

before the child is placed into the pro-

yram, not while the child is there. This

condition would be highly desirable, but it

probably would not be reasonaole to expect

the school system to make full preparation

to serve a child with special needs who

might or might not enroll for the 1978-79

school terin.

The evidence and testimony presented

at the hearing indicate that the school sys-

ten has complied with the provisions of

North Carolina House Bill 824, Public Law

94-142, and Section 504 of the Rehabilita-

tion Act of 1973 by conducting a multi-

disciplinary diaynosis and evaluation, by

developing an idividualized education pro-

yram, and by offering the child in question

a free appropriate public euucation within

1o5.

the least restrictive environment. ‘There-

fore, it is the Sedlinide of the Hearing

Officer that the placement determination

made by the school system for the child is

in compliance with state and federal laws

and is appropriate for her.

If the child is presented for place-

ment in the program proposed by the school

system for the 1978-79 school term, the

child's individualized education program

within 30 days shali be developed further

with the addition of specific short-term

objectives; and the classroom within which

the child is placed shall be of an acousti-

cal design approved by appropriate person-

nel in the State Department of Public In-

struction. Althouyh the proposed grade

placement appears to be appropriate for the

child, if a problem should arise during the

156.

1978-79 school term which seems to be attri-

butable to yrade placement, the school sys-

tem, in consultation with the appellant,

shall consider making an adjustment.

Any appeal of this decision by either

party to Dr. A. Craig Phillips, State Super-

intendent of Public Instruction, Raleigh,

N.C., must occur within 30 days after the

decision of the Hearing Officer is re-

ceived.

8/ GEORGE S. WILLARD

HEARING OFFICER

2U

2U

2U0

20

20

20

20

2U

20

20

20

Lo7.

APPENDIX F

STATUTORY AUTHORITIES

yl400(c). . . . 7 . .

p1401 (10) . . . *. . .

91401 (18)

gl40i1(19) « «© «© © ©

BR4GL2CL)'0 co) 0: 8 oe

y1412(5)(B) . - we

yl412(3)(C) « 6 «© @ *

$1412(6). « «© © @ © *@

yl413(a)(3) - + e © ©

gl415(e)(2) . « « « «

gi4i5(e) (3) . . . . -

lo:

Lo7

158.

APPENDIX F

STATUTORY AUTHORITIES

20 U.S.C. 91400(c)

Purpose. It is the purpose of this

Act to assure that all handicapped children

have available to them, within the time

periods specified in section 612(2)(i8), a

free appropriate public education which

emphasizes special education and related

services designed to meet their unique

needs, to assure that the rights of handi-

Capped children and their parents or guard-

ians are protected, to assist States and

localities to provide for the education of

all handicapped children, and to assess and

assure the eftectiveness of efforts to edu-

cate handicapped children.

159,

20 U.S.C. 91401 (le)

(Lo) The term “special education"

means specially designed instruction, at no

cost to parents or guardians, to weet the

unique needs of a handicapped child, includ-

ing classroom instruction, instruction in

physical education, home instruction, and

instruction in hospitals and institutions.

20 U.S.C. 91401 (18)

(ls) The term “free appropriate pub-

lic education” means special education and

related services which (A) have been provid-

ed at public expense, under public supervi-

sion and direction, and without charge, (8)

meet the standards of the State educational

agency, (CC) include an appropriate pre-

school, elementary, or secondary school edu-

cation in the State involved, and (D) are

provided in conformity with the individual-

100,

ized education program required under sec-

tion o014(a)(5).

20 U.S.C. $1401(19)

(19) The term “individualized educa-

tion program" means a written statement for

each handicapped child developed in any

meeting by a representative of the local

educational ayency or an intermediate educa-

tional unit. who shall be qualified to pro-

vide, or supervise the provision of, speci-

ally designed instruction to meet the uni-

que needs of handicapped children, the

teacher, the parents or guardian of such

child, and, whenever appropriate, such

child, which statement shall include (A) a

statement of the present levels of educa-

tional performance of such child, (B) a

statement of annual goals, including short~

term instructional objectives, (C) a state-

lol.

ment of the specific educational services

to be provided to such child, and the ex-

tent to which such child will be aple to

participate in regular educational pro-

yraus, (D) tne projected date for initia-

tion and anticipated duration of such ser-

vices, and (£) appropriate objective cri-

teria and evaluation procedures and scned-

ules for deterinining, on at least an annual

basis, whether instructional objectives are

being achieved.

20 U.S.C. $1412(1)

In order to qualify for assistance

under this part in any fiscal year, a State

shall demonstrate to the Comuissioner that

the following conditions are met:

(1) The State has in effect a policy

that assures all handicapped children the

right to a free appropriate public educa-

lo2.

tion.

40 U.S.C. $1412(5)(B)

In order to qualify for assistance

under this part in any fiscal year, a State

shall demonstrate to the Commissioner that

the following conditions are met:

(5)(8) The State has established...

(B) procedures to assure that, to the maxi-

mum extent appropriate, handicapped child-

ren, including children in public or pri-

vate institutions or other care facilities,

are educated with children who are not han-

dicapped, and that special classes, sepa-

rate schooling, or other removal of handi-

capped children fron the regular educa-

tional environment occurs Only when the

nature or severity of the handicap is such

that education in regular classes with the

use Of supplementary aids and services can-

lo3.

not be achieved satisfactorily, and....

20 U.S.C. 91412(5)(C)

In order to qualify for assistance

under this part in any fiscal year, a State

shall demonstrate to the Commissioner that

the following conditions are met:

(9)(C) The State has estaplished...

(C) procedures to assure that testing and

evaluation imaterials and procedures util-

ized for the purposes of evaluation and

placement of handicapped children will be

Selected and administered so as not to be

racially or culturally discriminatory.

Such materials or procedures shall be pro-

Vided and adiuinistered in the child's na-

tive language or mode of communication,

unless it clearly is not feasible to do so,

and no single procedure shall be the sole

criterion for détermining an appropriate

lo4,

euucational program for a child.

20 UsS6Ce $1412(0)

In order to quality for assistance

under this part in any fiscal year, a State

shall demonstrate to the Comnissioner that

the following conditions are inet:

(o) The State educational agency

shall be responsible for assuring that the

requirements of this part are carried out

and that all educational programs for handi-

capped children within the State, including

all such programs adwinistered by any other

State or local agency, will be under the

general supervision of the persons respon-

sible for educational prograns for handi-

capped children in the State educational

agency and shall meet education standards

of the State educational agency.

los.

20 U.S.C. §1413(a) (3)

(a) Requisite features. Any State

meeting the eligibility requirements set

forth in section 612 and desiring to par-

ticipate in the program under this part

shall submit to the Commissioner, through

its State educational agency, a State plan

at such time, in such manner, and contain-

ing or accompanied by such information, as

he deems necessary. Each such plan shall...

(3) set forth, consistent with the

purposes of this Act, a description of pro-

grans and procedures for (A) the develop-

ent and implementation of a comprehensive

system of personnel development which shall

include the inservice training of yeneral

and special educational instructional and

Support personnel, detailed procedures to

assure that all personnel necessary to

loo.

carry out the purposes of this Act are ap-

propriately and adequately prepared and

trained, and effective procedures for ac-

quiring and disseminating to teachers and

administrators of programs for handicapped

Children significant information derived

from educational research, demonstration,

and similar projects, and (8) adopting,

where appropriate, promising educational

practices and materials development through

such projects;....

20 U.S.C. $1415(e) (2)

(e) Civil action; jurisdiction...

(2) Any party agrieved by the findings and

decision made under subsection (b) who does

not have the right to an appeal under sub-

section (c), and any party aygrieved by the

findings and decision under subsection (c),

shall have the right to bring a civil

lo7.

action with respect to the complaint pre-

sented pursuant to this section, which ac-

tion imay be brought in any State court of

competent jurisdiction or in a district

court of the United States without reyard

to the amount in controversy. In any ac-

tion brought under this paragraph the court

shall receive the records of the administra-

tive proceedinys, shall near additional evi-

dence at the request of a party, and, bas-

ing its decision on the preponderance of

the evidence, shall grant such relief as

the court determines is appropriate.

20 U.S.C. §$1415(e) (3)

(e) Civil action; jurisdiction...

(3) During the pendency of any proceedings

conducted pursuant to this section, unless

the State or local educational ayency and

the parents or yuardian otherwise ayree,

lou.

tne child shall remain in the then current

educational placement of such child, or, if

applying for initial admission to a public

school, shall, with the consent of the par-

ents or yuardian, be placed in the public

school program until all such proceedings

have been completed.

34

34

34

34

34

34

34

109.

APPENDIX G

FEDERAL REGULATIONS

300.340 . «. © «© « © «

3U0Us 340 2 6 0 6 wo et

yt) ee ee eer ee

00s 582s ees 0 os

300.533 « «6 © «© we « «

PUVemen ce we & se <<

300. 552 . . . . . . .

170.

APPENDIX G

FEDERAL REGULATIONS

34 C.F.R. 300.340

DEFINITION

As used in this part, the term “indi-

Vidualized education program” means a writ-

ten statement for a handicapped child that

is developed and implemented in accordance

with §»300. 341-300. 349.

34 C.F.R. 300.346

CONTENT OF INDIVIDUALIZED

EDUCATION PROGRAM

The individualized education program

for each child must include:

(a) A statement of the

Child's present levels of edu-

cational per forinance;

(b) A statement of annual

goals, including short term

instructional objectives;

(c) A statement of the spe-

cific special education and

related services to be pro-

vided to the child, and the

extent to which the child will

be able to participate in reg-

ular educational programs;

(d) The projected dates for

initiation of services and the

anticipated duration of the

services; and

(e) Appropriate objective

Criteria and evaluation proce-

dures and schedules for deter-

mining, on at least an annual

basis, whether the short term

instructional objectives are

beiny achieved.

34 C.F.R. 300.531

PREPLACEMENT EVALUATION

Before any action is taken with re-

Spect to the initial placement of a handi-

capped child in a special education pro-

gram, a full and individual evaluation of

the child's educational needs must be con-

ducted in accordance with the requirements

of 9300.532.

34 C.F.R. 300.532

EVALUATION PROCEDURES

State and local educational agencies

Shall insure, at a minimum, that;

(a) Tests and other eval-

uation materials:

(1) Are provided and admini-

Stered in the child's native

lanyuage or other wode of comm-

munication, unless it is clear-

ly not feasible to do so;

(2) Have been validated for

the specific purpose for which

they are used; and

(3) Are administered by

trained personnel in confor-

mance with the instructions

provided by their producer;

(ob) Tests and other evalu-

ation materials include those

tailored to assess specific

areas of educational need and

not merely those which are

designed to provide a_ single

general intelligence quotient;

(c) Tests are selected and

174.

administered so as best to

ensure that when a test is

adwinistered to a child with

impaired sensory, manual, or

Speaking skills, the test re-

sults accurately reflect the

child's aptitude or achieve-

ment level or whatever other

factors the test purports to

measure, rather than reflect-

ing the child's impaired sen-

sory, manual, or speaking

skills (except where those

skills are the factors which

the test purports to measure);

(d) No single procedure is

used as the sole criterion for

determining an appropriate

179.

educational proyrain for a

child; and

(e) The evaluation is made by

a multidisciplinary team or

group of persons, including at

least one teacher or other

specialist with knowledge in

the area of suspected disabil-

ity.

(f) The child is assessed in

all areas related to the sus-

pected disability, including,

where appropriate, health,

vision, hearing, social and

emotional status, general in-

telligence, academic perfor-

mance, communicative status,

and motor abilities.

176.

34 C.F.R. 300.533

PLACEMENT PROCEDURES

(a) In interpreting evaluation data

and in making placement decisions, each

public ayency shall:

(1) Draw upon information from a va-

riety of sources, including aptitude and

achievement tests, teacher recommendations,

physical conditon, social or cultural back-

ground, and adaptive behavior;

(2) Insure that information obtained

from all of these sources is documented and

carefully considered;

(3) Insure that the placement decision

is made by a group of persons, including

persons Knowledgeable about the child, the

meaning of the evaluation data, and the

placement options; and

(4) Insure that the placement decison

177.

is made in conformity with the least re-

Strictive enviroment rules in §y300.550-

3UU. 954.

(vo) If a determination is made that a

child is handicapped and needs special

education and related services, an indi-

Vidualized education proyram must be de-

veloped for the child in accordance with $9

300. 340-300.349 of Subpart C.

34 C.F.R. 300.551

CONTINUUM OF ALTERNATIVE PLACEMENTS

(a) Each public agency shall insure

that a continuum of alternative placements

is available to meet the needs of handi-

capped children for special education and

related services.

(b) The continuum required under para-

graph (a) of this section must:

(1) Include the alternative place-

178.

ents listed in the definition of special

education under 9300.13 of Subpart A (in-

struction in regular’ classes, special

classes, special schools, home instruction,

and instruction in hospitals and institu-

tions), and

(2) Make provision for supplementary

services (such as resource room or itin-

erant instruction) to be provided in con-

junction with regular class placenent.

34 C.F.R. 300.552

PLACEMENTS

Each public agency shall insure that:

(a) Each handicapped child's

educational placement: (1)

Is determined at least an-

nually,

(2) Is based on his or her

individualized education

179.

preugran, and

(3) Is as close as possible

to the chiid's home;

(b) The various alternative

placenents included under

y300.551 are available to the

extent necessary to implement

the individualized education

program for each handicapped

child;

(c) Unless a handicapped

child's individualized educa-

tion program requires some

other arrangement, the child

is educated in the school

which he or she would attend

if not handicapped; and

(d) In selecting the least

restrictive environmen, consi-

deration is given to any poten-

tial harmful effect on the

child or on the quality of

services Which he or she

needs.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.