Amicus Brief — Chevron USA Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1984
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Supreme Court of The United tates
October Term, 1983
CHEVRON U.S. A., INC.,
Petitioner,
v.
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et al.,
Respondents ;
AMERICAN IRON AND STEEL INSTITUTE, et al.,
Petitioners,
v.
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et. al.,
Respondents ;
ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY
Petitioner,
v.
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et al.,
Respondents.
On Writs of Certiorari
to the United States Court of mer
for the District of Columbia Circui
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE
AND BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE FOR
UNITED STEELWORKERS OF AMERICA
AFL-CIO-CLC
Of Counsel JAMES D. ENGLISH
A General Counsel
ByRNARD KLEIMAN MARY-WIN O'BRIEN
Counsel Assistant General Counsel
United Steelworkers (Counsel of Record)
of America United Steelworkers
Pittsburgh Kor Five Ga
ve Center
Pi A 15222
(412) 060-2581
SMITH BROS LAW PRINTERS, 620 SECOND AVENUE, PITTSBURGH, PA. st.
Nos. 82-1005, 82-1247, 82-1591
In THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1983
CHEVRON U.S. A., INC.,
: v. Petitioner,
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et al.,
Respondents;
AMERICAN IRON AND STEEL INSTITUTE, et al.,
v. Petitioners,
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et al.,
Respondents;
ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY
Petitioner,
v.
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
COUNCIL, INC., et al.,
Respondents.
On Writs of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit
MOTION TO FILE BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE
FOR UNITED STEELWORKERS OF AMERICA
0-CLC
The United Steelworkers of America, AFI-CIO-CLC
(Union) requests that this Court grant this Motion to file
a brief amicus curiae in support of respondent Natural
Resources Defense Council (NRDC) for the following
reasons.
2 Motion to File Brief Amicus Curiae.
1. Statement of Interest
The Union is a labor organization which represents
close to one million workers in the United States and
Canada. Approximately 250,000 of our members are em-
ployees of corporations that belong to petitioner Ameri-
can Iron and Steel Institute. Most of these members and
their families, together with substantial numbers of
other Union members and their families, live in areas of
the country where the air quality violates one or more of
the national ambient air quality standards in part be-
cause of air pollution from iron-and steelmaking opera-
tions.
Moreover, the Union was a leading force in the ef-
forts to enact the Clean Air Act (the Act) (42 U.S.C. §§
7401 et seq.) and has continued to be active in the efforts
to obtain compliance with the requirements of the Act by
a number of industries, including the steel industry. To
that end, the Union, in conjunction with the Environ-
mental Protection Agency (EPA) and various environ-
mental groups such as respondent NMC played a pri-
mary role in the development and passage of the Steel
Industry Compliance Extension Act of 1981 (Pub. L.No.
97-23, 95 Stat. 139 (1981) ) (the Extension Act) which
amended the Clean Air Act to extend compliance
deadlines in return for modernization of operations in
the steel industry. Our support of such an extension was
based on the premise that modernization of the steel
industry would benefit not only the long-term employ-
‘ment prospects of our members by providing a more
competitive industry, but also benefit their health and
that of their families in the surrounding communities
since the new, modern projects would meet existing air
pollution control requirements.
Motion to File Brief Amicus Curiae. 3
2. Issue to be Presented
The purpose of our brief amicus curiae is to focus
particular atfention on the conflict between the
plantwide definition of source now espoused by EPA, and
the Extension Act amendments extending the compli-
ance deadlines for the steel industry. Those amendments
were premised on a definition of source for non-
attainment areas that included as “sources” units of op-
eration or production built within existing plants as well
as such units built at new sites, This issue will not be
adequately addressed by petitiohers EPA and the Ameri-
can Iron and Steel Institute since they now support the
plantwide definition of source at is sue here. Respondent
NRDC, while a party to the negotiations surrounding the
Extension Act amendments, is more concerned with the
relationship of the changed definition of “source” to the
Clean Air Act in general rather than to the specific devel-
opment of the Extension Act. Moreover, NRDC lacks the
unique perspective of the Union whereby the Union
sought to provide immediate relief to the steel industry
so that the capital funds made available could be used for
modernization with the assurance that the new projects
would improve air quality in the nonattainment areas
where many cf the Union’s members and their families
live.
3, Statement of Consent or Objection
On September 19, 1983, counsel for the Union re-
quested from counsel of record for petitioners and
respondents, their written consent or objection to the
filing of the Union’s brief amicus curiae. Consent was
obtained from the Federal government parties and
NRDC. Petitioner Chevron objected to the filing unless a
draft brief was submitted in advance. Since no brief was
so submitted, Chevron’s response was considered an ob-
r
4 Motion to File Brief Amicus Curiae.
jection to the filing of this brief. Responses were not
received from any other partier.
WHEREFORE, for the reasons set forth above, the
Union requests that this Motion to file a brief amicus
curiae be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
Mary-WIn O’BRIEN
Assistant General Counsel
United Steelworkers of America
Five Gateway Center
| Pittsburgh, PA 15222
2 Phone: 412-562-2531
Dated: October 19, 1983
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
TABLE AUTO nl i
STATEMENT OF INTEREST OF AMICUSCURIAE 1
SUMMARY OF ARuUMENT Th 3
r ce woed chooses 3
D ͥ ůůͤů ůro! nt: 90
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
STATUTES
CLEAN Am ACT (AS AMENDED 1977)
42 U.S.C. 1863 eee 2
D ũͤͥͤͤͥnð:: . ͥʒᷣ TTT TTe 5
Sree. Inpustry COMPLIANCE EXTENSION ACT
Pus. L. No. 97-23, 95 Star 139 (1981)....... passim
P EEDUEED oo rece cccccsccccccces 7
ee .. c's de 7
LEGISLATIVE MATERIALS
S. Rep. No. 97-133, 97th Cong., Ist Sess. (1981) .... 4
H. Rep. No. 97-121, 97th Cong., 1st Sess. (1981) ... 4,7,8
Before the Senate Committee on Environ-
4 = Public Works, 96th Cong., 2d Sess. ‘
Hearings on S. 63 Before the Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works, 97th Cong., Ist
/ ̃ —õ—ĩ—A—A b 6
2 on H.R. 1817, 2024, 2219, 2055, and 2286
0 Health
re the Subcommittee on and Envi-
ronment of the House Committee on Energy and
Commerce, 97th Cong., Ist Sess. (1981)........ 5,6
127 Cong. Rec. 86986 (daily ed. June 25, 1981) ..... 4
127 Cong. Rec. H2446 (daily ed. May 28, 1981) ..... 2
127 Cong. Rec. H2447 (daily ed. May 28, 1981) ..... 4
127 Cong. Rec. H2448 (daily ed. May 28, 1981) ..... 8
127 Cong. Rec. H2449 (daily ed. May 28, 19817 4
MISCELLANEOUS
New York Times, March 4, 198111111 4
BNA Environment Reporter, May 8, 19111 1
BNA Environment Reporter, July 3, 19811 4
Nos. 82-1005, 82-1247, 82-1591
In THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1983
CHEVRON U.S. A., INC.,
* Petitioner,
NATURAL — cpm COUNCIL, INC.,
et al.,
Respondents;
AMERICAN ROU AND Steet. SETS ae a>
Petitioners,
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC.,
e
Respondents;
ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY
Petitioner,
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC.,
et al.,
Respondents.
On Writs of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit
BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE
FOR UNITED STEELWORKERS OF AMERICA
AFL-CIO-CLC
STATEMENT OF INTEREST OF AMICUS CURIAE
The United Steelworkers of America, AFL-CIO-CLC
(Union) is a labor organization which represents close to
one million workers in the United States and Canada.
Approximately 250,000 of our members are employees of
corporations that belong to petitioner American Iron and
2 Statement of Interest of Amicus Curiae.
Steel Institute. Most of these members and their fami-
lies, together with substantial numbers of other Union
members and their families, live in areas of the country
where the air quality violates one or more of the national
ambient air quality standards in part because of air pol-
lution from iron-and steel-making operations.
Moreover, the Union was a leading force in the
efforts to enact the Clean Air Act (the Act) (42 U.S.C.
§§ 7401 et seq.) and has continued to be active in the
efforts to obtain compliance with the requirements of the
Act by a number of industries, including the steel in-
dustry. To that en e Union, in conjunction with the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and various en-
vironmental groups such as respondent, Natural Re-
sources Defense Council (NRDC), played a primary role
in the development and passage of the Steel Industry
Compliance Extension Act of 1981 (Pub. L.No. 97-23, 95
Stat. 139 (1981) ) (the Extension Act) which amended
the Clean Air Act to extend compliance deadlines in
return for modernization of operations in the steel in-
dustry. Our support of such an extension was based on
the premise that modernizati@m of the steel industry
would benefit not only the long-term employment pros-
pects of our members by providing a more competitive
industry, but also benefit their health and that of their
families in the surrounding communities since the new,
modern projects would meet existing air pollution con-
trol requirements.'
1. As Congressman Doug Walgren stated:
Under this legislation, the same environmental
Oe ee ee ee oe
vestment required will be able to be coordinated
with new production facilities. Therefore, there is no
loss whatsoever from an environmental viewpoint.
127 Cong. Rec. H2446 (daily ed. May 28, 1981).
Argument. 3
The purpose of this brief is to focus particular atten-
tion on the conflict between the plantwide definiton of
source now espoused by EPA, and the Extension Act
amendments extending the compliance deadlines for the
steel industry. Those amendments were premised on a
definition of source for nonattainment areas that in-
cluded as sources“ units of operation or production built
within plants as well as such units built at new
sites.
\
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
The development and passage of the Extension Act,
which amended the Clean Air Act to defer certain com-
pliance deadlines for the steel industry in return for a
commitment to modernization was the result of negotia-
tions by the industry, the Union, EPA and environmental
groups such as respondent NRDC. A key principle under-
lying those negotiations was that the modernization
projects built in nonattainment areas would meet the
requirements for new source review. Moreover, the types
of sources, that were at issue and were identified by Con-
gress were production units within a st¥el plant, e. g.,
coke ovens, blast furnaces and continuous casters, not
entire plants. EPA’s subsequent regulations have under-
mined that consensus by changing the definition of
source to apply only to entire industrial plants.
ARGUMENT
The genesis of the Extension Act, its statutory lan-
guage, and legislative history make clear that the pro-
4 Argument.
duction unit definition of source, as opposed to the plant-
wide definition, was no accident nor was it incidental to
the passage of the Extension Act.“ “The bill reflects an
historic agreement hammered out last September be-
tween representatives of the steel companies, the
steelworkers union, the environmental groups, and
the Environmental tectidn Agency.” 127 Cong. Rec.
H2449 (daily ed. May 28, 198K (remarks of Congressman.
John Dingell).
This agreement was és usual in that it was
the culmination of an ended bargaining process
among four very disparate groups.“ Through this proc-
ess, these four participants achieved a consensus that
resulted in the passage of the Extension Act.* The es-
sence of this agreement was that the steel industry,
2. That passage reflected a “carefull — *
ment yenehed by te by in. r [the Union n-
mente grou 9 and EPA.” Cong. ay so (daily ed.
— 28, 1981) (remarks of Congressman Doug W. aa
“achieve healthy air 8 a 2 — 3 of mod -
— su rvised 1 — udicial system. — S. Rep. No.
97-133, 97th (1981).
3. The 1 Act was based on the recommenda-
tions of the Steel Tri te Committee as one part of a
p to or No. F. 121. 57 Cone ist of —
4. BNA Environment Vol 11
No. e
ox Tate ech 4 196k co
ye a
Argument. 5
which contended it had a short-term capital shortage,
would be allowed a three-year extension of the deadline
for compliance with some pollution control requirements
on the condition that the money saved by this deferred
compliance was invested in the modernization of steel-
making operations, with the modernization being carried
out under the then existing conditions for new source
review. One of the key factors in such review is the
application of the lowest achievable emission rate tech-
nology (LAER). The LAER requirement is one of the
specific conditions new and modified “sources” must
meet in order to obtain a permit under §173 of the Clean
Air Act (42 U.S.C. § 7503). Since the parties to the bar-
gaining process and Congress recognized the applicabil-
ity of LAER to the modernized production units that
were to result from the extension, this Court should
reject EPA’s belated attempt to renege on one of the
fundamental premises that precipitated the cooperative
agreement of these disparate groups.
In issuing a statement regarding his new steel in-
dustry program, President Carter emphasized compli-
ance with environmental laws:
But modernization is equally important to environ-
mental objectives, since modern facilities are inher-
ently much cleaner, and all parties (including the
industry) have agreed they will use the most mod-
ern technology available.
ne 1817, 2024, 2219, 2055, and 2286 Before
the Subcommittee on Health and Environment of the
House Committee on Energy and Commerce, 97th Cong.,
1st Sess. 130 (1981). (emphasis added).
John J. Sheehan, Legislative Director, representing
the Union at the bargaining table, reiterated the under-
standing that modern technology meant LAER:
6 Argument.
Furthermore, the amendment fosters the continued
imposition of reasonably available control technol-
ogy for existing sources and emission limitations
requirements of applicable implementation plans, in-
cluding technology to achieve lowest emission rates
for new facilities.
Id. at 82 (emphasis added).°
Finally, in testifying before the Senate Committee,
Frances Dubrowski, a senior staff attorney at the Natural
Resources Defense Council (NRDC) stated:
Fourth, the company would have to agree to meet all
applicable clean air requirements by the new compli-
ance deadline. This would include attaining the
lowest achievable emission rate (LAER) on the new
facilities and installing reasonably available control
technology (RACT) on existing facilities.
Hearings on S.63 Before the Senate Committee on Envi-
ronment and Public Works, 97th Cong., Ist Sess. 92
(1981) (emphasis added). See also Hearing on H.R. 1817,
supra at p. 86.“
5. As Union President Lloyd McBride testified when
the Steel Tripartite Committee made its report to Con-
gress in 1980, the application of LAER to the new facili-
ties was viewed as an important p — 4 —
ore the te
Committee on Environment and lic Works, 96th
6. Although the steel industry issued no direct state-
ment — 7 — voiced no 5 — to the
pepsi ts. silence is important since
as
the agreement under which the t
mA ps extension for the steel industry, the
dustry, the chief executive officers of major
Argument. 7
Congress demonstrated full awareness that LAER
would apply to production units as part of new source
review and not to whole plants. Specifically, Congress
stated:
[The] program to modernize facilities will also con-
tinue to include the application of lowest achievable
emission rate technology (LAER) on the modernized
facilities. LAER is required for any new, modified, or
reconstructed major facility in a nonattainment area.
H.R. Rep. No. 97-121, 97th Cong., 1st Sess. 12 (1981),
reprinted in 1981 U.S. Code Cong. Admin. News 63.
Both the statutory language and the legislative
history of the Extension Act clearly reflect this Con-
gressional intent to treat as stationary sources major
units of production within iron-and steel-making opera-
tions not just entire plants. For example, in setting out
the conditions necessary to obtain an extension, Con-
gress required that there must be a compliance schedule
“for each stationary source at all such person’s iron-and
steel-producing operations...” 42 U.S.C. § 7413(e) (1)
(C). Iron-and steel-producing operations were defined to
include “production facilities for iron and steel, as well
as associated processing, coke making and sintering fa-
cilities.” (42 U.S.C. § 7413(e) (2) ).7 Both of these statu-
tory
7. While the “sources” referred to in this section of
the Extension Act are existing sources which do not need
to meet the compliance requirements for new sources,
they are located within steel plants in nonattainment
areas and therefore reveal the Congressional under-
standing that the term “source” includes units of produc-
tion within steel plants rather than the plant as a whole.
*
8 Argument.
provisions support the position that Congress intended
the term “source” to mean something other than an
entire iron-and steel-making plant, namely the various
production units within that plant.
Moreover, the legislative history of the Extension
Act clearly reflects Congressional intent to treat as sta-
tionary sources major units of production, not entire
plants. The House Report of the Extension Act states
that the House proposal was intended to “encourage ad-
ditional capital investments in steelmaking operations.”
H.R. Rep. No. 97-121, supra at p. 63. By “steelmaking
operations” Congress envisioned the various production
units comprising the plant. The Report specifies exam-
ples of projects that could result from such investments:
It is anticipated that the industry will use the oppor-
tunity to modernize the American steel industry by
building modern continuous casters, converting
open hearth shops to basic oxygen furnace opera-
tions or undertaking similar projects to improve the
competitive posture of the industry.
Id. (emphasis added.) It is evident from this statement
that Congress relied on a unit definition of source, not a
plant-wide definition.“
According to the above-quoted House Committee Re-
port, continuous casters, basic oxygen furnaces, and coke
ovens (which are examples of the intended moderniza-
tion projects) are subject to LAER. Only new and modi-
fied “sources” are subject to LAER. Therefore, continu-
Conclusion. 9
ous casters, basic oxygen furnaces, coke ovens, and other
like units are “sources.” There is no way to reconcile
EPA’s adoption of a plant-wide definition of “source,”
which exempts such units from LAER and other permit
requirements, with the genesis of the Extension Act, its
statutory language or its legislative history.
CONCLUSION
The development of the 1981 Steel Industry Compli-
ance Extension Act undeniably reveals that Congress
understood the law to be, and to remain, that a “source”
is a unit within a plant (such as a basic oxygen furnace),
not the plant itself. EPA’s subsequent adoption of the
plant-wide definition of source is totally inconsistent
with this understanding and thus violates a key premise
relied on by the Union in its support of the passage of the
Extension Act.
Respectfully submitted,
JAMES D. ENGLISH
Associate General Counsel
MARY-WIN O’BRIEN
Assistant General Counsel
(Counsel of Record)
United Steelworkers of America
Five Gateway Center
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222
Phone: (412) 562-2531
10 Certificate of Service.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on the 19th day of October,
1983, I served three (3) copies of the enclosed Motion for
Leave to File Brief amicus curiae and Brief amicus
curiae by first class mail, postage prepaid, to the follow-
ing counsel:
THE HONORABLE Rex E. Lee PaTRICIA A. BARALD, Esq.
Solicitor General of the U.S. Covington & Burling
U.S. Department of Justice P. O. Box 7566
Washington, DC 20530 Washington, DC 20044
WILIA F. PEDERSEN, Esq. CHARLES F Letrow, Esq.
CHARLEs S. CARTER, Esq. CLEARY, GOTTLIEB, STEEN &
Office of the General Counsel HAMILTON
U.S. Environmental Protection 1250 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Agency Washington, DC 20036
401 M Street, SW
Washington, DC 20460 Davip T. DEAL, Esq.
American Petroleum Institute
MICHAEL H. Sa.insxy, Esq. 2101 L Street, NW
Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro Washington, DC 20037
225 Bush Street
P.O. Box 7880 Rospert A. EMMETT, Esq.
San Francisco, CA 94120 Reep, Surru, SHAW & McCay
1150 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Louis E. Tost, Esq. Washington, DC 20036
WILLIAM L. PATBERG, Esq.
Fuller & Henry Davip D. DoNnIGER
1200 Edison Plaza Natural Resources Defense
P. O. Box 2088 Council
Toledo, OH 43603 1725 I St., N.W., Suite 600
Washington, D.C. 20006
MARY-WIN O'BRIEN
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.