Opposition Brief — Ludlow Park Homeowners Ass'n v. County of Westchester
Supreme Court brief1991
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 90-1787 Supreme Court, U.S
Pty D
IN THE JUN 1 8 199)
Supreme Court of the United For ine cea |
OcToBER TERM, 1991
In the Matter of the Application of The LUDLOW PARK
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, HENRY SPALLONE
as Mavor of the City of Yonkers, and G. OLIVER KOPPELL, as
Assemblyman for the 80th Assembly District,
Petitioners,
VS.
THE COUNTY OF WESTCHESTER and the
WESTCHESTER COUNTY BOARD OF LEGISLATORS,
Respondents,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and STATE OF NEW YORK,
Intervening-Respondents,
for an order pursuant to CPLR Article 78 reversing and annulling the
determination of the respondents to the effect that an environmental
impact statement regarding the construction of a sludge dewatering facility
at the Yonkers sewage treatment plant is not to be required.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
BRIEF AND APPENDIX OF WESTCHESTER COUNTY
RESPONDENTS IN OPPOSITION TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
MARILYN J. SLAATTEN
Westchester County Attorney
Attorney for Westchester
County Respondents
600 Michaelian Office Building
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
(914) 285-2673
Caroi L. VAN Scoyoc
Deputy County Attorney
Counsel of Record
MARGUERITE R. WIEss
Assistant County Attorney
RS ee ee a
TION N
1. Whether the United States
District Court abused its discretion
in accepting jurisdiction, pursuant to
the All Writs Act, 28 U.S.C. §1651,
over a New York State court proceeding
which threatened to frustrate a
Consent Decree entered by the District
Court in an enforcement action brought
by the United States, requiring
Westchester County to cease dumping
sewage sludge in the Atlantic Ocean by
December 31 1991, as required by the
Ocean Dumping Ban Act of 1988, 33
U.S.C. §§1414b and 1414c?
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
ye iy sy / ) i
i SEE. co sseces sce sees ii
- GE ne 6 8 & ae | > Fe 1v
CITATION OF OPINION BELOW........ vi
ee G0 BOUL GUNES ne ce cc crc ccces 1
A. Proceedings Below......... 1
I ae 7
C. The Consent Decree........ 8
D. The Decision of the
SE 14
8 5 17
ARGUMENT
THE PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI SHOULD BE DENIED...
A. The Petition does not present
special or important reasons
warranting review......... 19
B. There is sufficient federal
concern for the court to
retain jurisdiction
iii
C. There is no conflict between
the Court of Appeals' decision
below and the decisions of this
Court or other Courts of Appeal
reer eee eee res oe Ee 26
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
PAGE
A. CASES
Adams v. United States ex rel.
McCann, 317 U.S. 269 (1942)...... 14,20
United States v. New York Telephone
on 2 PR Pee). . ee 15,26
27,28
Yonkers, 858 F.2d 855 (2d Cir. 1988),
cert. denied, 109 S.Ct. 1527 (1989)
GEE Es A ig Pa 15,26
B. STATUTES
6 Mia ke xc cette 2
Ee ee re reer 2
ae O08. Bo eee 17
28 U.S.C. §1651 (All Writs Act).i,5,14
33 U.S.C. §§1401 et seq. (Marine
Protection, Research, and Sanctuaries
ae ae eg Pee ere 13
SS Gi i 9
33 U.S.C. §§1414b and 1414c (Ocean
Dumping Ban Act of 1988)....i,1,8,9,12,
22,49,41,49
ce ee ek | ere ee Beat
Environmental Conservation Law §8-0101
et seq. (New York State Environmental
Quality Review Act - “SEQRA")........ 3
New York Civil Practice Law and Rules,
Re er eee Pet 4
vi
The Westchester County Respondents
accept the Petitioners' citation of
the opinion below which is reproduced
in the Appendix attached to the
Petition for Certiorari.
The Consent Decree and Enforcement
Agreement, filed and entered in the
United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York in
5274 (WK)) and the District Court's
Order, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1651,
retaining jurisdiction over Ludlow
Park Homeowners Association et al v.
County of Westchester and Westchester —
vil
County Board of Legislators, are
reproduced in the Appendix to this
Brief.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. Proceedings Below
This matter arose out of an action
commenced in the United States
District Court for the Southern
District of New York by the United
States of America seeking to enjoin
the County of Westchester (County)
from dumping sewage sludge into the
Atlantic Ocean after December 31,
1991.* United States of America and
State of New York v. County of
Westchester and Westchester County
*§1414b Ocean dumping of sewage sludge
and industrial waste
(a) Termination of dumping
(1) Prohibitions on dumping
Notwithstanding any other
provisions of law -
(B) After December 31, 1991, it
shall be unlawful for any person
to dump into ocean waters
sewage sludge
Department of Environmental
Facilities, 89 Civ. 5274 (WK).
Jurisdiction was asserted pursuant to
33 U.S.C. §1415(d) and 28 U.S.C.
§§1331 and 1345. This action was
settled in July 1989 by the entry of a
Consent Decree and Enforcement
Agreement, which among other things,
required the County of Westchester to
begin on-site construction of a sludge
dewatering facility no later than
October 1, 1990.*
The County immediately
commissioned studies to determine the
location, design and type of equipment
for the dewatering facility. In
February, 1990, the Westchester County
*Consent Decree, Paragraph IV A.8. A
complete copy of the Consent Decree is
set forth in the Appendix to this
Brief.
Board of Legislators, as lead agency
under the New York State Environmental
Review Act (SEQRA), [Article 8 of New
York Environmental Conservation Law, 8
E.C.L. §8-0101 et seq.J, and on the
basis of a Full Environmental
Assessment Form and numerous studies
and reports submitted to it, resolved
to locate the dewatering facility
inside an already existing building at
its Yonkers Joint Water Treatment
Plant (YJWTP). It directed the
Commissioner of Environmental
Facilities to issue a Negative
Declaration that the location of the
facility at that site would have no
Significant impact on the environment.
Thereafter, the Petitioners herein
commenced a proceeding in the New York
State Supreme Court for Westchester
County pursuant to Article 78 of the
New York Civil Practice Law and Rules,
alleging that the issuance of the
Negative Declaration was arbitrary,
Capricious and an abuse of discretion,
and seeking a remand to the Board of
Legislators and the preparation of an
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS).
The County, pursuant to Paragraph
XII of the Consent Decree, sought
removal of the State court proceeding
to the United States District Court,
which had retained jurisdiction to
resolve such disputes arising under
its Consent Decree "as may be
necessary Or appropriate for its
implementation".* The proceeding was
removed and assigned to Judge Knapp as
*Consent Decree, Paragraph XVIII
a related case to United States of
America and State of New York v.
Westchester County and Westchester
County Department of Environmental
Facilities, (89 Civ. 5274(WK)). At a
hearing before Judge Krapp on May 10,
1990, the Petitioners indicated that
they would move to remand the
proceeding to the New York Supreme
Court. The United States countered
that it would move to retain
jurisdiction pursuant to the All Writs
Act, 28 U.S.C. §1651(a). Thereafter,
Judge Knapp granted the government's
motion to accept jurisdiction pursuant
to the All Writs Act. A copy of this
order is included in the Appendix to
this Brief.
In July 1990 the District Court
issued its Decision and Order on the
Fe
merits, dismissing Ludlow Park's
petition, holding that the County
followed the appropriate procedural
requirements under SEQRA, and that its
determination that the proposed
facility would have no significant
impact on the environment was rational
and supported by the evidence.*
The petitioners appealed both the
jurisdictional and environmental
issues to the United States Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit, which affirmed both District
Court orders in an unreported decision
on February 19, 1991.
*Petitioners have abandoned their
appeal on the merits of the
environmental question, which is not
Surprising considering that their
major contention was that six to ten
additional truck trips per day
constituted a significant adverse
impact on the environment.
B. The Facts
The Yonkers Joint Water Treatment
Plant (YJWTP) occupies a thirty-five
(35) acre site, approximately one half
(1/2) mile long and three hundred
(300) yards wide, covering 1,500,000
square feet on the Hudson River
shoreline in an industrially zoned
area. It has been in operation since
1955 and normally handles between
100,000,000 and 115,000,000 gallons of
flow per day.
The existing building in which the
dewatering facility will be housed is
a single story 130' x 50' structure
occupying approximately 1/2 of 1% of
the total plant area, located a few
hundred feet from both the existing
sludge storage tanks and the primary
iia tera initiate
water treatment tanks. In order to
accommodate the dewatering facility,
the existing building is being altered
by the addition of a second story and
a 30' x 50' enclosed loading bay.
Construction began as required by the
Consent Decree on October 1, 1990 and
has continued without interruption.
The dewatering facility has now been
substantially completed, and is
scheduled to be placed in operation in
accordance with the terms of the
Consent Decree.
C. The Consent Decree
The Ocean Dumping Ban Act of 1988,
33 U.S.C. §§1414b and 1414c, provides
that all ocean dumping of sewage
sludge shall end by August 15, 1989,
unless the agency doing the dumping
enters into an Enforcement Agreement
pursuant to §1414b(c)(3) and obtains a
temporary permit pursuant to §1412.
In any event, all ocean dumping of
sludge must end by December 31, 1991.
Sections 1414b(c)(3) and (c)(4) set
forth in considerable detail the
provisions which must form a part of
of the Enforcement Agreement.
The Consent Dec~ee and Enforcement
Agreement entered into by the parties
in United States of America and State
WwW Vv WwW
and Westchester County Department of
Environmental Facilities conforms to
these requirements and contains, inter
alia, the following provisions:
Paragraph IV - Implementation of
Interim Land-Based Management of Sludge
1. completion of final equipment
design - 12/31/89
EES
wittn
2. advertise for sludge dewatering
equipment - 2/1/90
3. completion of final design of
facility - 4/1/90
4. award contract for equipment -
4/15/90
5. advertise for bids for all
contracts - 5/15/90
6. award all contracts - 8/15/90
7. issue Notice to Proceed for
construction of facility - 9/1/90
8. begin on-site construction of
facility - 10/1/90
9. commence operation of sludge
dewatering facility capable of
processing 100% of County's
Sludge - 12/31/91
Paragraph V - Long Term Alternative
Sludge Management
- seventeen separate steps beginning
1/1/89 and ending 9/15/95
tin
Paragraph VI - Reports and
Certifications
- requires, inter alia, monthly
reports to the District Court,
detailing the status and progress of
all projects under Paragraphs IV and V
Paragraph X - Modifications
-~ must be subject to the approval or
Order of the District Court
Paragraph XI - Appointment of Special
Master
"A special master shall be appointed
and shall serve to monitor compliance
with this Decree and the Agreement and
to assist the Court in the enforcement
thereof."
- He “shall submit quarterly written
status reports to the Court,
summarizing the progress on the tasks
-12—
listed in paragraphs IV and V ... and
apprising the Court of problems that
have or are expected to develop and of
steps that are being or need to be
taken to ensure timely completion of
the tasks enumerated in paragraph IV
and V and cessation of ocean dumping."
Paragraph XIII - Dispute Resolution
- Any party may present a disputed
matter to the Court "concerning any
matter hereunder, including, without
limitation, the schedules set forth in
paragraphs IV and V.”
Paragraph XIV - Satisfaction of Claims
"The Enforcement Agreement contained
in this Decree and Agreement is an
Enforcement Agreement pursuant to
MPRSA, 33 U.S.C. §1414b(c)(3). A
eiotent | this Enf ,
atDue
2 i wien
MPRSA."* [emphasis added].
"Paragraph XVIII - Retention of
Jurisdiction
"This Court shall retain jurisdiction
to enforce the terms and conditions of
this Decree and Agreement and to
resolve disputes arising hereunder as
may be necessary Or appropriate for
its implementation."
*The Marine Protection, Research and
Sanctuaries Act of 1972, 33 U.S.C.
§§1401 et seq.
S ,
=
D. The Mecial . phe 2 1 Ci :
In an unpublished opinion, filed
February 19, 1991, the Court of Appeals
held that it could overturn a decision
to accept jurisdiction under the All
Writs Act, 28 U.S.C. §1651 only if it
found that the district court abused
its discretion. Adams v. United
States ex rel. McCann, 317 U.S. 269,
273 (1942). The Court of Appeals
affirmed the lower court's judgment
because the record indicated that the
lengthy process involved in producing
an Environmental Impact Statement
would prevent the County from
complying with the provisions of the
Consent Decree and from ending the
ocean dumping of sewage sludge by
December 3l, 1991.
att.
Since a district court might issue
an order “to effectuate and prevent the
frustration of orders it has previously
issued in its exercise of jurisdiction
otherwise obtained", United States v.
New York Telephone Co,, 434 U.S. 159,
172 (1972), the Court of Appeals for
the Second District upheld the
retention of jurisdiction because "a
remand to the State Court would
threaten the ‘very essence’ of the
Consent Decree", which was the
cessation of ocean dumping by December
31, 1991. See Yonkers Racing Corp. v.
City of Yonkers, 858 F.2d 855 (2d Cir.
1988), cert, denied, 109 S.Ct. 1527
(1989).
On the merits, the Court of Appeals
held that "the County's conclusion that
the project would have no significant
Yo
respect on the environment is rational
and supported by the record.”
a
a
This case is not of special
importance and the United States Court
of Appeals‘ decision conflicts neither
with decisions of this Court nor other
Circuits.
Petitioners raised only two
Jurisdictional issues below: 1) that
the preparation of an Environmental
Impact Statement would not interfere
with the provisions of the Consent
Decree; and 2) that the District Court
lacked subject matter jurisdiction
under 28 U.S.C. §1441 and therefore
should have remanded the proceeding to
the State court.
The latter argument has now been
abandoned. For the first time,
=i.
petitioners now cursorily contend, in
this Court, that the exercise of
subject matter jurisdiction in this
case, is unconstitutional pursuant to
Article III, Section 2 of the
Constitution.
ade 6
htm
ARGUMENT
THE PETITION FOR A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI SHOULD BE DENIED
A. The Petition does not present
special or important reasons
warranting review.
Petitioners assert that the United
States Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit erroneously rejected their
claims that the State court proceeding
posed no threat to the implementation
of the Consent Decree, and that the
All Writs Act does not confer subject
matter jurisdiction over their State
court proceeding.
The Court of Appeals specifically
held that: "The record indicates that
the lengthy process involved in
producing an EIS would result in
substantial delay, preventing the
County from complying with the series
of interrelated milestone events
= tim
established by the Consent Decree to
complete the phase-out of ocean
dumping.”
It further held that it might
"only reverse a decision to issue an
order under [the All Writs] Act if we
find that the district court abused
its discretion in reaching that
decision. Adams v. United States ex
rel. McCann, 317 U.S. 269, 273 (1943).”
Thus, the issues presented in this
petition are whether the record
contains sufficient evidence to
support a finding that the preparation
of an EIS would delay the completion
of the project and whether the court,
in this case and upon these facts,
abused its discretion. These fact
specific issues, while of interest to
Bi tei.
#2i-
the Petitioners, are not issues of
broad application and do not affect
the application of the All Writs Act
in general, or enhance the scope of
federal jurisdiction.
Even if the pakthionere’
contentions were well-founded, this
Court has never regarded its function
as simply correcting a legal error
perceived by disappointed litigants in
a lower court decision.
The issues involved in this
petition are so narrow and fact
specific as to preclude this Court's
decision from having any general
application in the field of federal
jurisdictional law.
o2%—
B. There was sufficient federal
concern for the District Court to
tain turiediaks
The District Court accepted
jurisdiction over the New York State
SEQRA proceeding, not because there was
any inherent federal jurisdiction over
the environmental questions, but
because the very existence of the
State court proceeding jeopardized the
timely accomplishment of the major
purpose of the Consent Decree - the
cessation of all ocean dumping by
December 31, 1991.
Any action which threatened to
delay the milestone events specified
in Paragraph IV of the Consent Decree,
threatened a violation of the terms of
the Enforcement Agreement, which in
turn constituted a violation of MPRSA,
33 U.S.C. §1414(b) and (c) (see Consent
=) =
Decree, Paragraph XIV).
By the terms of the Consent Decree,
Paragraph XVIII, the District Court
retained jurisdiction “to enforce the
terms and conditions of this Decree and
Agreement and to resolve disputes
arising hereunder as may be necessary
; € + imp) tation.”
[emphasis supplied].
At the time the District Court was
required to determine whether to retain
jurisdiction over the State court
proceeding, it was as yet unaware of
the lack of merit to Petitioners'
environmental objections. The
District Court realized that if an EIS
were required to be prepared, the
milestone events of Paragraph IV, and
the ultimate cessation of ocean
7
dumping, would be substantially
delayed.
The District Court's familiarity
with the matter, and its retention of
jurisdiction* enabled it to resolve
the environmental questions far more
expeditiously than the State court.
Furthermore, in the event that
additional environmental studies were
determined to be necessary, the
mechanism of the Special Master
provided a convenient vehicle for
pinpointing the issues, expediting the
acquisition of any additional
information, preparing an EIS, and
determining the sufficiency of the
Environmental Impact Statement.
*Paragraph XVIII of the Consent Decree
a oe
It begs the issue to argue, as
Petitioners do, that the Consent
Decree could have been modified to
accommodate any delays occasioned by
the State Court's resolution of the
matter. The Ocean Dumping Ban Act of
1988 prohibited all dumping of sewage
sludge into ocean waters after December
31, 1991. 33 U.S.C. §1414b(a)(1)(B).
The object of the Consent Decree was
not to facilitate a violation of
federal law, but to set up procedures
that would ensure compliance. Since
the cessation of ocean dumping was of
paramount importance, the District
Court acted well within its discretion
and in conformity with MPRSA and the
Ocean Dumping Ban Act, in retaining
jurisdiction over petitioners' SEQRA
proceeding.
atin
To hold otherwise would permit the
frustration of orders previously issued
by the District Court. United States
v. New York Telephone Co., 434 U.S.
159 (1977).
C. There is no conflict between the
Court of Appeals' decision below
and the decisions of this Court or
the other Courts of Appeal oo.
This petition presents no special
Or important reasons for review by
this Court. The chief cases cited by
petitioners are those primarily relied
upon by the respondents. United
States v. New York Telephone Co.,
Supra and Yonkers Racing Corp. v. City
of Yonkers, 858 F.2d 855 (2d Cir.
1988), cert. denied, 109 S.Ct. 1527
(1989). The other federal cases cited
all support federal jurisdiction and
the enjoining of other state or
federal court proceedings.
Se di
ote
Both the District Court's exercise
of discretion and the Court of
Appeals’ review and affirmance are
rooted in prior Supreme Court
decisions.
"This Court has repeatedly
recognized the power of a federal
court to issue such commands under the
All Writs Act as may be necessary or
appropriate to effectuate and prevent
the frustration of orders it has
previously issued in its exercise of
Jurisdiction otherwise obtained ...".
United States v. New York Telephone
Co., Supra, at 172.
The “jurisdiction otherwise
obtained" is the District Court's
undoubted jurisdiction under 33 U.S.C.
§1414b and §1415(d) to enforce the ban
_ =
on ocean dumping.
As this Court further declared:
"The power conferred by the Act
extends, under appropriate
circumstances, to persons who, though
not parties to the original action or
engaged in wrong doing, are in a
position to frustrate the
implementation of a court order ...".
Id at 174.
The laws of the United States
require the County to stop dumping its
sewage sludge in the Atlantic Ocean by
December 31, 1991. The United States
sued the County in the United States
District Court to force it to obey the
baie: As a result, the parties entered
into a Consent Decree which requires
the County to construct a sludge
~29q
dewatering facility by December 3l,
1991. The construction of this
facility is critical because there is
no land-based system for the disposal
sewage sludge unless it has first been
dewatered. The Petitioners commenced
an action in State Court, which, if
successful, would have made it
impossible for the County to comply
with the law (33 U.S.C. §1414b). This
case involves not only the issue of
non-compliance with the terms of the
Consent Decree, but also a direct
violation of federal law.
The facts of the instant case
bring it squarely within the bounds of
this Court's prior decisions.
Petitioners have not even suggested
any legal authorities to the
contrary. A decision on the merits
a$i-
of Petitioners’ contentions would add
nothing to the already established law
in this field since the facts here
presented do not require an extension
of the law of federal jurisdiction to
new areas.
For the foregoing reasons, the
petition for a writ of certiorari
should be denied.
Respectfully submitted,
MARILYN J. SLAATTEN
Westchester County Attorney
Attorney for the Westchester
County Respondents
600 Michaelian Office Building
PRESS Cee Ge ba
ate
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
} ; y
CAROL L. VAN SCOYOC
Deputy County Attorney
Counsel of Record
MARGUERITE R. WIESS
Assistant County Attorney
White Plains, New York
June 14, 1991
APPENDIX
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND
STATE OF NEW YORK, CONSENT DECREE
DECREE AND
ENFORCEMENT
AGREEMENT
89 Civ. 5274 (WK)
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
COUNTY OF WESTCHESTER and
WESTCHESTER COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL FACILITIES,
Defendants.
WHEREAS, the Maine Protection,
Research, and Sanctuaries Act ("MPRSA"),
33 U.S.C. §§1401 et seg., as amended by
the Ocean Dumping Ban Act of 1988, Title
I of Pub. L. 100-688, makes it unlawful
for any person to dump, or to transport
for the purpose of dumping, sewage
Sludge into the ocean after August 14,
1989, unless such person has obtained a
permit for such dumping from the United
States Environmental Protection Agency
("EPA") under Section 1412 of the MPRSA
and has entered into a compliance
agreement or enforcement agreement for
the phasing out of such ocean dumping
under Section 1414b of the MPRSA; and
WHEREAS, Section 1414b of the MPRSA
requires that any enforcement agreement
thereunder provide for the cessation of
ocean dumping of sewage sludge and that
it provide for the development and
implementation of a long-term alternative
system for management of the affected
person's sewage sludge and authorizes
the use of interim measures before
completion of the alternative systems;
and
red Pr WT we
WHEREAS, the United States, EPA, the
State of New York (the "State"), and the
County of Westchester (the "County” or
the "“defendant") enter into this Consent
Decree and Enforcement Agreement
("Decree and Agreement") to ensure the
phasing out and termination of ocean
dumping, and transportation for the
purpose of ocean dumping, of sewage
sludge pursuant to the Ban Act; and
WHEREAS, the County has agreed to
undertake all measures set forth herein
to cease ocean disposal of all of its
sewage sludge by December 31, 1991
through implementation of interim
measures; and
WHEREAS, the County has agreed to
develop and utilize a long-term
alternative system to its current ocean
disposal of sewage sludge which shall
dispose and/or reuse the sludge by
September 15, 1995; and
WHEREAS, the County contends that it
will choose its long-term disposal
solution after an evaluation of
alternatives in accordance with all
applicable law; ana
WHEREAS, the parties agree that they
shall make all reasonable efforts to
expedite the defendant's efforts to
comply with its obligations under this
Decree and Agreement, including the
review of permits, applications or
approvals as provided in paragraph XVII
herein; and
Ce ee
WHEREAS, the United States, EPS,
the State and the defendant have each
consented to the making and entering of
this Decree and Agreement, without trial
or adjudication of any issues of fact or
law, and without this Decree and
Agreement constituting an admission by
the County with respect to any such
issues; and the Court having considered
the matter and being duly advised, and
it being in the public interest, it is
hereby ORDERED and DECREED as follows:
I. JURISDICTION
This Court has jurisdiction over the
subject matter and over the parties
hereto under 28 U.S.C. §1345, and 33
U.S.C. §1415. Plaintiff's complaint
States a claim upon which relief may be
granted against the defendant.
II. APPLICATION AND BINDING EFFECT
The provisions of this Decree and
Agreement shall apply to and be binding
upon all parties to this Decree and
Agreement, their officers, directors,
agents, servants, employees, successors,
assigns, contractors, and all persons,
firms and corporations in active concert
Or participation with them. Prior to
any transfer of ownership or operation
of the defendant's publicly owned
treatment works, the defendant shall
give written notice of this Decree and
Agreement to any successor9s) in
interest and shall simultaneously
notify, in writing, EPA and the State
that such notice has been given to each
successor in interest.
PA ein bn =
The County recognizes that the
Marine Protection, Research, and
Sanctuaries Act of 1972, 33 U.S.C.
§1401, et seq. ("MPRSA"), as amended by
the Ban Act, makes unlawful the disposal
of sewage sludge in the ocean after
December 31, 1991, and to that end the
defendant has agreed to undertake all
necessary steps, including the tasks
outlined in paragraphs IV and V of this
Decree and Agreement, to cease the ocean
disposal of its sewage sludge. The Ban
Act also requires that no ocean dumping
or transportation for the purpose of
ocean dumping sewage sludge shall be
conducted after August 14, 1989, unless
prior to such activity the defendant has
obtained a new, effective ocean dumping
permit under Section 1412 of the MPRSA.
In the event that the permit is stayed,
the defendant. shall comply with all
terms and conditions of any permit
issued, notwithstanding any challenge to
the permit during the pendency of such
challenge. Should ocean dumping
continue under this Decree and Agreement
beyond the effective term of the permit,
and no new permit be issued, the
conditions of the most recent permit
issued to the defendant. after May 31,
1989 shall continue to be complied with
as conditions of this Decree and
Agreement.
IV. IMPLEMTATION OF INTERIM LAND-BASED
MANAGEMENT OF SEWAGE SLUDGE __
A. The defendant shall implement
dewatering measures for land-based
management of sewage sludge in
compliance with the following milestone
events:
1. Complete final design of the
sludge dewatering equipment by December
31, 1969.
2. Advertise for sludge dewatering
equipment by February 1, 1990.
3. Complete final design of the
sludge dewatering facility by April l,
1990.
4. Award contract for sludge
dewatering equipment by April 15, 1990.
5. Advertise for bids for all
contracts necessary to make the sludge
dewatering facility operable, by May 15,
1990.
6. Award all contracts necessary to
make the sludge dewatering facility
operable, by August 15, 1990.
4 Issue "Notice to Proceed" for
on-site construction of the sludge
dewatering facility by September 1, 1990.
S. Commence on-site construction of
the sludge dewatering facility by
October 1, 1990.
9. Substantially complete
construction of and place into opera-
tion the sludge dewatering facility,
capable of processing 100% of the
County's sludge, by December 31, 1991.
Substantial completion shall be defined
as the facility being capable of
dewatering 100% of the County's sludge.
B. The defendant shall take the
following additional measures to
implement land-based interim sludge
management:
1. The County shall have fully
executed contracts, which shall incli=2
sufficient measures to ensure back-up
Capacity, necessary for the interim
land-based management of the County's
sewage sludge, by August 3l, 1991.
2. The County shall cease ocean
dumping of all sewage sludge by December
aa, A991.
C. Nothing set forth in Schedule IV.A
shall preclude the County from
implementing interim measures by other
means provided that (i) the County shall
cease ocean dumping of all sewage sludge
by December 31, 1991, (ii) such
substituted method, if any, provides for
reliable land-based management of sewage
Sludge, and (iii) all parties agree to
the substitution and a modification in
accordance with paragraph X is obtained.
V. LONG-TERM ALTERNATIVE SLUDGE
MANAGEMENT
The defendant shall
implement a long-term alternative
plan for the management and disposal
of sewage sludge presently
transported or dumped by the
defendant. In implementing its
long-term alternative system of
sewage sludge management and
disposal,defendant shall comply with the
following schedule:
1. commencement of detailed sludge
management facility planning to identify
the long-term alternative system to be
used to ensure permanent phase-out and
termination of ocean dumping of sewage
sludge, by January 1, 1989.
2. Completion and submittal of
detailed acceptable land-based sludge
management facility plan for the
selected long-term alternative system by
March 1, 1991.
3. Initiate selection process for
preparation of all final engineering
designs and related specifications for
the long-term alternative system
selected, by September 1, 1991.
4. Establishment of local
pretreatment limit modifications as
necessary for the long-term alternative
system by January 3l, 1992.
5. Award contract and commence
preparation of all final engineering
designs and related specifications for
the long-term alternative system
selected, by February 1, 1992.
6. Submit applications for all
necessary local, state and federal
permits for the long-term alternative
system selected, by February 1, 1993.
7. Complete preparation of all
final engineering designs and related
specifications for the long-term
alternative system selected, by May l,
1993.
8. Advertise for bids for the
necessary equipment and construction of
the long-term alternative system by June
i, 1993.
9. Acquire sites for the long-term
alternative system selected, by June l,
1993.
10. Secure all necessary permits
for construction of the long-term
alternative system selected, by August
1, 1993.
ll. Award contracts for the
necessary equipment and construction of
the long-term alternative system by
September 1, 1993.
12. Issue “Notice to Proceed" for
on-site construction of facilities for
the long-term alternative system
selected, by September 15, 1993.
13. Commence on-site construction
of facilities for the long-term
alternative system selected, by
September 30, 1993.
14. Substantially complete
construction of facilities and
installation of equipment for the
long-term alternative system selected,
by June 1, 1995. Substantial completion
shall be defined as completion such that
the facilities and equipment are capable
of meeting their intended purpose.
15. Enforce full compliance by
local industrial users with all local
pretreatment limits by January 31, 1995.
16. Commence testing of the
long-term alternative system by July l,
L993.
17. Complete testing of the
long-term alternative system and
commence full operation of said system
by September 15, 1995.
VI. REPORTS AND CERTIFICATIONS
A. Beginning with the second calendar
month after execution of this Decree and
Agreement by all parties, and continuing
monthly thereafter, the defendant shall
submit in writing to the Court, the
special master, the United States and
the State at the addresses set forth in
paragraph IX, a report and certification
detailing the status and progrees of the
projects under paragraphs IV and V for
phasing out and terminating ocean dumping
of sewage sludge and implementing interim
measures and a long-term alternative
system of sludge management. Such report
and certification shall include a
description of the work performed in the
previous month and a projection of the
work to be performed during the following
twelve-month period pursuant to this
Decree and Agreement.
B. Within five days after execution of
this Decree and Agreement by all parties,
the defendant shall designate a
responsible official to ensure that the
implementation of this Decree and
Agreement proceeds as smoothly and
efficiently as possible and that the
terms of this Decree and Agreement are
complied with. In connection with the
reports and certifications required to
be submitted, such designated official
shall certify that the defendant has met
all schedule milestones in the prior
month, and assess whether the defendant
Shall continue to meet all scheduled
milestones set forth in paragraphs IV
and V of this Decree and Agreement.
Where such designated official is unable
to so certify, such designated official
Shall identify: the noncompliance; the
reasons therefor; the measures being
taken to remedy the noncompliance; the
A-20
work remaining to be done to achieve
full compliance, including a schedule
for completion of such work, and the
impact, if any, on compliance with the
final schedule dates set forth in
paragraphs IV and V; and an acceleration
plan to ensure that the schedule dates
in paragraphs IV and V shall be complied
with. The reports and certifications
shall be submitted for each month by
certified mail, return receipt requested,
by the fifteenth day of the following
month. If defendant's report or
certification indicates noncompliance,
the report or certification shall also
be submitted by telefax.
C. The EPA and the State shall confer
quarterly to evaluate the compliance of
the defendant with the schedules
established in paragraphs IV and V.
Upon fifteen days notice from either EPA
or the State, the defendant shall
provide a properly informed and
authorized representative for such
conference to discuss progress and
problems in the planning, design and
construction of the alternative systems
for sludge management and the interim
measures needed to eliminate the ocean
dumping of sewage sludge. The EPA and
the State shall endeavor to schedule
meetings at which the presence of
defendant is requested in conjunction
with a special master meeting or other
meeting already scheduled.
D. The defendant shall submit to EPA
and the State a quarterly report
detailing the volume of sludge dumped in
A-22
the ocean during the preceding quarter,
the amount of fees or penalties owing
for that volume, the date and amount of
payment cf said fees or penalties to its
trust account, the Clean Oceans Fund,
State water pollution control revolving
fund, and EPA, and copies of the checks
for each payment made. This report
shall be submitted on the fifteenth day
of the second month following the end of
the calendar quarter. The first report
shall be submitted on November 15, 1989.
VII. STIPULATED PENALTIES _
A. If the defendant fails to comply
with any applicable requirements of
paragraphs IV and V of this Decree and
Agreement, the defendant shall pay
stipulated penalties in the following
amounts for each day of each and every
violation of said requirements:
Days of Penalty for
Non-compliance Violations
or Violation __Per Day
1-30 $ 1,000
31-60 $ 5,000
Beyond 60 Days $10,000
Payments shall commence within ten days
of demand and shall become due and
payable monthly thereafter.
B. If the defendant fails to comply
with any applicable requirements of
paragraph VI of this Decree and
Agreement, the defendant shall pay
stipulated penalties in the following
amounts for each day of each and every
violation of said requirements:
Days of Penalty for
Non-compliance Violations
or Violation Per Day
1-30 $100
31-60 $200
Beyond 60 Days $500
Payments shall commence not later than
thirty days from the date of the
violation and shail become due and
payable monthly thereafter.
C. The stipulated penalties set forth
in subparagraphs A and B above shall
begin to accrue on the day that
performance is due or non-compliance
occurs, and shall continue to accrue
through the final day of correction fo
the non-compliance. Each separate
violation of this Decree and Agreement
shall constitute a separate penalty
event, and nothing herein shall prevent
the simultaneous accrual of separate
penalties for separate violations of
this Decree and Agreement. Fifty (50)
percent of the penalty shall be paid to
the State. Penalties due to the United
States shall be paid by tendering a
check in the appropriate sum, payable to
"Treasurer of the United States,” and
sent by certified mail, return receipt
requested, to the United States
Attorney for the Southern District of
New York with a copy to EPA and the New
York State Department of Environmental
Conservation ("NYSDEC"). Penalties due
to the State shall be paid by tendering
a check in the appropriate sum, payable
to "Comptroller of the State of New
York," and sent by certified mail,
return receipt requested, to the Office
of the State Comptroller, Alfred E.
Smith Office Building, Swan Street, 6th
Floor, Albany, New York 12236, with
copies sent to NYSDEC, New York State
Department of Law ("NYSDOL") and EPA.
Interest shall accure on any stipulated
penalty not paid when due at the rate
established by the Department of the
Treasury under 31 U.S.C. §3717.
D. Except for stipulated penalties
resulting from defendant's failure to
comply with the milestone events set
forth in paragraphs IV.A.8, IV.A.9,
SV .AscBv iy IV.8.2, FV.ii, Vii One V.i7,
any stipulated penalties incurred by
defendant for failure to achieve any
other milestone date in the schedules
set forth in paragraphs IV or V shall be
forgiven upon the defendant's timely
achievement of the next subsequent
milestone date in that schedule,
provided that the following conditions
are met. Such stipulated penalties
shall be paid timely and within 10 days
of demand by EPA or the State by
tendering a check in the appropriate sum
to the agent of an escrow account to be
established for each schedule hereunder.
If defendant thereafter demonstrates
compliance with the next subsequent
milestone event set forth in the
schedule, then all stipulated penalties
paid and held in escrow for violation of
the preceding missed milestone event
shall be returned to the defendant. If,
however, the defendant fails to comply
with the next subsequent milestone event
set forth in the schedule, then the
escrow agent shall pay the entire
balance of the escrow account for that
schedule, including all interest earned
thereon, to the “Treasurer of the United
States" and the "Comptroller of the
State of New York" in accordance with
paragraph VII.C hereof. Nothing
contained herein shall relieve the
defendant of any obligation to pay any
stipulated penalties hereunder that the
defendant fails to pay into the escrow
account or which the escrow agent fails
to pay to the United States and the
State.
E. In the event that defendant claims
that a force majeure event, as defined
in paragraph XII of this Decree and
Agreement, has occurred such that no
stipulated penalty is due for a missed
milestone date, defendant shall pay the
stipulated penalty into the escrow
account in accordance with the procedure
set forth in VII.D above and such
payment shall be held by the escrow
agent pending resolution of the
defendant's claim of force majeure
pursuant to paragraphs XI, XII and
XIII. If it is determined that no
stipulated penalty is due, then all
stipulated penalties paid and held in
escrow for the violation of the
milestone. dates at issue shall be
returned to the defendant. If, however,
it is determined that the stipulated
penalty is due because the delay was not
Caused by a force majeure event, then
the escrow agent shall pay the entire
balance of the escrow account for that
schedule, including all interest earned
thereon, to the “Treasurer of the United
States" and the “Comptroller of the
State of New York" in accordance with
paragraph VII.C hereof.
F. In addition to the stipulated
penalties set forth above and the fees
and penalties established by the Ban
Act, the civil penalties and other
relief provided by the MPRSA at 33
U.S.C. §1415 for violations of permits
issued under 33 U.S.C. §1412 and of this
Decree and Agreement shall apply and
remain in effect.
G. In the event of failure to pay
stipulated penalties, as set out above,
this matter may be referred to the
United States Attorney and the State
Attorney General for collection.
Defendant shall be liable for
plaintiffs' expenses, including
attorney's fees, in such collection
action.
VIII. STATUTORY FEES AND PENALTIES
A. In accordance with Sections
1414b(b)(1) and 1414b(d)(1) of the
MPRSA, the defendant shall pay the
following fees and penalties, separate
and apart from any penalties that it may
be liable for under paragraph VII, for
the sewage sludge it dumps in the ocean:
Between August 15, A fee of $100
1989 and December per dry ton
31, 1989 inclusive
During 1990 A fee of $150
per dry ton
During 1991] A fee of $200
per dry ton
The quantity of dry tons shall be based
upon the monthly average of percent
solids for the sludge dumped, or
weighted average of percent solids if
defendant has more than one wastewater
treatment plant. Penalties for
dumpingsewage sludge or transporting
sewage sludge for the purpose of dumping
it in the ocean shall be calculated for
any dumping after December 31, 1991 as
set out in Section 1414b(d)(1) of the
MPRSA. Such penalties are mandatory and
independent of any civil penalties
assessed or collected pursuant to
Section 1415 of the MPRSA and of any
stipulated penalties assessed or
collected pursuant to this Decree and
Agreement.
For the purpose of determining the
applicable per-dry-ton fee or penalty,
the date and time of initiation of
discharge from the vessel (as reported
on the Ocean Dumping Notification Form)
shall be used.
B. Payments of statutory fees
andpenalties assessed under paragraph
VIII.A shall be made on a quarterly -
basis, on the last day of the month
following the end of a calendar
quarter. The first payment, for sewage
sludge dumped or for dumping initiated
during the calendar quarter ending
September 30, 1989, shall be made by
October 31, 1989. For the purpose of
determining the calendar quarter in
which sludge was dumped, the date and
time of initiation of discharge from the
vessel (as reported on the Ocean Dumping
Notification Form) shall be used.
C. The defendant shall establish a
trust account pursuant to Section
1414b(e) of the MPRSA for the payment
and use of that portion of the fees and
penalties established by the Ban Act
that are to be deposited in this trust
account. The defendant must receive
written approval from EPA of its trust
account prior to August 14, 1989. No.
sewage sludge may be transported for the
purpose of ocean dumping or ocean dumped
under this Decree and Agreement unless
prior to such transport or disposal the
defendant has secured approval of its
trust account by EPA.
D. Defendant shall pay fees and
penalties in accordance with Sections
1414b(b)(2)(c) and 1414b(d)(2)(c) (i)
into the Clean Oceans Fund established
under Section 1414b(c)(5) and the water
pollution control revolving fund
established under Title VI of the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act. In
the event that the State has not
established a Clean Oceans Fund or water
pollution control revolving fund by
February 28, 1990, fees and penalties
required to be paid to the Fund or
revolving fund by defendant shall be
paid to EPA pursuant to Section
1414b(b) (5).
E. In accordance with the MPRSA,
Sections 1414b(b)(2) and 1414b(d)(2),
fees shall be paid as set forth below to
the following recipients for each dry
ton of sewage sludge dumped in the ocean:
Tee Ané Penaity Per Dry Tor Dunpee
ec ents
State Water
Year in Clean Pollution
Which Sludge Trust Oceans Control Re-
Mas Durpec EPA c nt Foné* wolving Furd
asss $15.00 $ 835.00 _- --
2990 35.00 327.30 $3.75 $3.75
199) 15.00 170.60 7.30 7.50
If established; if not, to EPA pursuant to paregrap> vi3i.5.
After December 31, 1991, payment and
distribution of penalties shall be
computed and paid in accordance with
Section 104B(d)(2) of the MPRSA.
F. Fees and penalties paid to EPA under
paragraph VIII.E shall be paid by check
made payable to the “Treasurer of the
United States," and delivered by
certified mail, return receipt
requested, to EPA. Fees and penalties
paid to the Clean Oceans Fund shall be
paid by check made payable to the
"Comptroller as Custodian of the Clean
Oceans Fund" and delivered by certified
mail, return receipt requested, to the
State. Fees and penalties paid to the
state water pollution control revolving
fund shall be paid by check made payable
to the “New York State Environmental
Facilities Corporation as Custodian of
the state water pollution control
revolving fund" and delivered by
certified mail, return receipt
requested, to the State. Fees and
penalties paid to the trust account
shall be paid to the trustee for said
account. For each payment recipient, if
a payment is not received on or befcre
the day on which payment is to be made
pursuant to paragraph VIII.B, interest
will be assessed against defendant at
the annual rate established by the
Secretary of the Treasurey pursuant to
31 U.S.C. §3717, on the overdue amount
from the day on which it was due
throught the date of payment. Failure
to pay the fee or penalty in full
according to the above provisions will
result in referral of this matter to
the United States Attorney and the State
Attorney General for collection.
Interest on late payments shall be paid
to EPA for untimely payments to EPA or
the defendant's trust account and tothe
State for untimely payments to it or to
its revolving fund or Clean Oceans
Fund. Interest on late payments shall
be deposited in the U.S. Treasury or
State Treasury as appropriate as general
funds. Defendant shall be liable for
plaintiffs' expenses, including
attorneys’ fees, in such collection
action(s).
G. In the event of defendant's failure
te make full payment of the fee or
penalty to the trust account in
accordance with paragraph VIII of this
Decree and Agreement within thirty days
—————
of the date on which it was due or
defendant's failure to use amounts
withdrawn or received from the account
in accordance with Section 1414b(e) of
the MPRSA and this Decree and Agreement,
EPA may, upon finding such a failure to
have occurred and upon fifteen business
days written notice, direct the trustee
of the trust account to pay the balance
of tne amount in the trust account to
the State for use in accordance with
Section 1414b(e)(2)(C) of the MPRSA.
Pending final resolution of any district
court challenge, the trustee shall
continue to hold the funds in the trust
account.
H. Fees and penalties paid to the
trust account, the State, the Clean
Oceans Fund, or the state water
pollution control revolving fund shall
be used subject to the restrictions of
Section 1414b(c)(5), (e) and (f) of the
MPRSA. The defendant shall conduct
audits on an annual basis to establish
that such fees and penalties were paid
to the appropriate accounts. The
defendant shall obtain the services of
an auditor to conduct separate audits,
on an annual basis of defendant's
expenditures from the trust account and
from funds provided to it from the Clean
Oceans Fund, to demonstrate compliance
with Section 1414b(c)(5) and (e) of the
MPRSA. Costs incurred by the defendant
pursuant to this Decree and Agreement
and paid from the trust account and from
funds provided to defendant from the
Clean Oceans Fund shall be necessary and
reasonable, and allocable to the
projects allowed by Sections 1414b(c)(5)
and (e). The defendant may look to the
applicable cost principles on OMB
Circular A-87 (46 Federal Register 9548
(1981)) for guidance in determining
allowable costs. Such audit reports
required of the defendant shall be
submitted to EPA and the State within 90
days after the end of each calendar year.
I. Upon execution of this Decree and
Agreement and continuing biannually
thereafter, the defendant shall submit
to the Regional Administrator of EPA,
Region II, and the State a scope of work
for each project that will require
funding from the trust account in the
following six-month period. The first
submission shall be due by August 30,
1989 and shall cover the period from
August 15, 1989 through December 31,
1989. Subsequent submissions shall be
due 60 days prior to commencement of the
next six-month period (i.e., October 30,
1989, April 30, 1990, etc.). Each scope
of work will consist of a description of
the major activities to be funded in
each project, the required level of
funding for each such activity and a
cumulative six-month payment schedule
based upon projected costs to be
incurred.
J. The Regjonal Administrator of
EPA, Region II, will approve or
disapprove the scope of work and level
of funding for the major activities.
EPA will notify the trustee of the trust
account, the State and the defendant of
EPA's approval or disapproval of the
scope of work and level of funding and
will provide the trustee with a list of
the approved activities, funding levels
and associated payment schedule. If EPA
fails to act on the defendant's proposed
scope of work and payment schedule
within 60 days of its receipt, the
defendant may submit the scope of work
and payment schedule to the trustee
together with a certification that EPA
has failed to disapprove use of the
trust account as required in Section
1414b(e) (2) (A).
K. The defendant may request funds
from the trustee for immediate cash
disbursements based upon costs
incurred. The trustees will disburse
funds in accordance with the scope of
work and approved payment schedule. If
the defendant anticipates that funding
needs will exceed the levels in the
approved scope of work, the defendant
may seek approval for such additional
funding from EPA.
IX. NOTIFICATIONS
A. Except as specified otherwise,
when written notification to or
communication with the United States,
EPA, the State or the defendant is
required by the terms of this Decree and
Agreement or when payment of a fee or
penalty is to be made, it shall be sent
by certified mail, return receipt
requested, and addressed as follows:
As to the United States of America:
United States Attorney's Office
Southern District of New York
One St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
_
As
Attention: Chief, Environmental
Protection Unit
United States Department of
Justice
Land & Natural Resources Division
10th & Constitution Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20530
Attention: Chief, Environmental
Enforcement Section
United States Environmental
Protection Agency
Office of Regional Counsel
26 Federal Plaza
New York, New York 10278
Attention: Chief, Water, Grants
and General Law Branch
to EPA Region II:
Financial Management Branch
Policy and Management Division
United States Environmental
Protection Agency
26 Federal Plaza
New York, New York 10278
(for payment of fees or penalties)
Water Management Division
United States Environmental
Protection Agency
26 Federal Plaza
New York, New York 10278
Telephone No.: (212) 264-2513
Telefax No.: (212) 264-2194
(for all other notifications or
communications)
A-46
As to State:
Office of the State Comptroller
Alfred E. Smith Office Building
Swan Street, 6th Floor
Albany, New York 12236
(for payment of fees or penalties
to Clean Oceans Fund and
stipulated
penalties with copies to NYSDEC
and NYSDOL)
New York State Environmentel
Facilities Corporation
50 Wolf Road
Albany, New York 12233
(for payment of fees or penalties
to state water pollution control
revolving fund with copies to
NYSDEC and NYSDOL)
Commissioner
New York State Department of
Environmental Conservation
50 Wolf Road
Albany, New York 12233
(for all notifications or
communications and copies of
payment
of all fees and penalties)
New York State Department of Law
Environmental Protection Bureau
120 Broadway
New York, New York 10271
(for all notifications or
communications and copies of
payment of all fees and penalties)
As to defendant:
Westchester County Department of
Environmental Facilities
400 Michaelian Office Building
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
Telephone No.: (914) 285-2455
Westchester County Department of
Environmental Facilities
600 Michaelian Office Building
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
Telephone No.: (914) 285-2690
Notifications to or communications with
the United States, EPA, the State or the
defendant shall be deemed submitted on
the date they are telefaxed or
postmarked and sent by certified mail,
return receipt requested, whichever
occurs later.
B. Reports required to be submitted
pursuant to paragraph VI shall be signed
by the responsible official of the
defendant designated pursuant to
paragraph VI.B and shall include the
following certification statement: "I
certify that the information contained
in or accompanying this submission is
true, accurate, and complete."
X. MODIFICATION
Except as provided for herein, there
shall be no modification of this Decree
and Agreement without written approval
of all of the parties to this Decree and
Agreement, subject to the approval of
the Court, or Order of the Court.
Nothing herein shall be construed to
limit any party's rights pursuant to
Rule 60(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure.
XI. APPOINTMENT OF SPECIAL MASTER
A. Pursuant to the provisions of
the Rule 53 of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure and Rule 19 of the Civil
Rules of the United States District
Court for the Southern District of New
York, a special master shall be
appointed and shall serve to monitor
compliance with this Decree and the
Agreement and to assist the Court in the
enforcement thereof. This special
master shall have the following duties,
responsibilities and powers:
1. The special master shall
monitor the progress of the defendant in
Carrying out the tasks enumerated in
paragraphs IV and V. To this end the
special master shall attend all progress
meetings concerning the above-referenced
schedules and receive copies of all
progress reports and correspondence.
The special master shall copy all
his/her correspondence and other written
communications with any party to all
parties, and shall notify all parties of
any physical inspections or site visits
he/she conducts. The special master
shall minimize ex parte contacts with
any party.
2. The special master shall
submit quarterly written status reports
to the Court, summarizing the progress
on the tasks listed in paragraphs IV and
V and defendant's compliance with this
Decree and Agreement, and apprising the
Court of problems that have or are
expected to develop and of steps that
are being or need to be taken to ensure
timely completion of the tasks
enumerated in paragraphs IV and V and
cessation of ocean dumping.
3. The special master shall
attempt to anticipate and avoid
potential problems. In carrying out
his/her responsibilities under this
paragraph XI, the special master may,
upon adequate notice, require
submissions from the parties, attendance
at meetings and/or participation in
hearings. The special master may
require the production of an rule upon
the admissibility of evidence and has
the authority to put witnesses under
oath and may examine them and call
parties to the action and examine them
under oath. All hearings before the
special master be on the record.
4. The parties may in the first
instance apply to the special master
with respect to (i) enforcement of this
Decree and Agreement, including
stipulated penalties as provided for in
paragraph VII, (ii) disputes arising
under the terms of the Decree and
Agreement, or (iii) any proposed
amendment or modification of paragraph
IV or V of this Decree and Agreement.
The special master may make
recommendations in accordance with
paragraph XII concerning such proposed
amendments or modifications.
5. The special master shall make
his/her recommendations provided for in
paragraph XI.A.4 in the form of a report
filed with the Court within 30 days of
receipt of stipulations or submissions
by the parties or within 30 days of the
conclusion of a hearing, if any.
B. The special master shall have
the following minimum qualifications:
1. A law degree; and
2. Extensive experience in
the environmental law field and/or in
the building or mangement of large
public construction projects or
programs; and
3. Experience involving
dispute resolution.
C. No later than September 30,
1989, the parties shall submit to the
Court the names in order of preference
to be considered for appointment as
special master. If the parties cannot
agree on such names, they shall each
submit a separate list of candidates by
September 30, 1989. The Court may
select a special master from the names
submitted or may conduct such
proceedings as it requires to make a
selection.
D. compensation for the special
master shall be paid by the defendant at
a rate to be fixed by the Court. The
special master may make interim
applications for compensation from time
to time during the period of his/her
performance and may seek compensation or
reimbursement for reasonable costs and
expenses incurred in fulfilling his/her
obligations under this Decree and
Agreement, including all necessary
expert and staff assistance. The
special master shall not retain any
experts without first seeking approval
of all of the parties sand such approval
shall not be unreasonably withheld.
E. All reports of the special
master shall be filed with the Court.
Except for status reports pursuant to
paragraph XI.A.2, all reports and
recommendations, including any facts
therein, shall be reviewable de novo by
the Court. Within 10 days after being
served with any such report, any party
may file written comments. Application
to the Court for action upon the report
and upon comments thereto shall be by
motion on notice, pursuant to the
Court's rules. The Court after hearing
may accept any recommendations contained
in the report or may modify it or may
reject it in whole or in part or may
receive further evidence or may recommit
it to the special master with
instructions. Reports of the special
master shall not be deemed adopted by
the Court except upon order of the Court.
XII. FORCE MAJEURE
A. A force majeure event is an
event (in accordance with applicable
case law, including but not limited to,
Act of God; commercial impracticability
(i1,e., extraordinary costs); contractor
Or supplier default; failure of a
federal or state regulatory agency to
issue any necessary permit or approval
in a timely fashion where the defendant
has timely submitted in good faith a
complete and legally sufficient
application and all necessary supporting
information in accordance with all
applicable laws and regulations; or a
judicial injunction issued by a court of
competent jurisdiction directed against
work actually being performed in
furtherance of sludge treatment and
disposal facilities, provided that the
defendant has exercised due diligence
and best efforts in seeking removal to
this court and in resisting such
injunction, including appeals, and the
defendant has acted in accordance with
applicable statutes and regulations)
that is beyond the control of the
defendant and which causes a delay in
implementing any of the measures
required by this Decree and Agreement.
If such event occurs, defendant shall be
entitled to a modification of the
schedule milestones to the extent that
such event was beyond the control of the
defendant. The defendant bears the
burden of establishing that the event
was beyond its control and of
demonstrating the amount of delay that
is necessary because of the force
majeure event. As a condition precedent
to obtaining any relief under this
provision, defendant shall notify the
Court and all the parties in writing
that a force majeure event has occurred
no later than 90 days after the date
defendant knew or should have known of
the occurrence of any force majeure
event.
B. The notice to EPA and the
State, required above, shall include, to
the extent such information is available
at the time of such notification:
1. The anticipated length of
time of the delay;
2. The cause of the force
majeure event;
3. Measures taken to
minimize the delay including time table
for implementation of any such measures;
4. Proposed date by which
subsequent schedule milestone will be
achieved; and
5. Activities that can be
taken to minimize the impact of the
force majeure event on the overall
schedule.
C. If all the parties agree that
a failure to comply with any requirement
of this Decree and Agreement, including
a schedule milestone in paragraph IV or
V was caused by a force majeure event,
the parties may seek an amendment to
this Decree and Agreement containing
such proposed modifications, including
revised schedule milestones as may be
necessary, and no stipulated penalties
shall be incurred. If the parties agree
that an extension is necessary, the
schedule of milestone dates under
paragraphs IV or V, shall be extended
for the period of time caused by the
force majeure event. In the event that
revision of the schedule milestones is
necessary, the defendant agrees to make
every effort to ensure that the
milestone events set forth in paragraphs
IV.A.8, IV.A.9, IV.8.1, IV.B.2, V.11,
V.14 and V.17 are not extended.
D. If the parties cannot agree
that a failure to achieve milestone
dates was beyond the control of the
defendant, the defendant may, within 30
days following the missed milestone
event, apply to the special master for a
recommendation as to whether all or part
of the delay was excusable due to a
force majeure event.
E. If, for any reason, the
defendant fails to achieve any schedule
milestones established in paragraph IV
or V and the parties cannot agree that
the remainder of the schedule milestones
will be affected, or how they will be
affected, then the defendant may, within
30 days following the missed schedule
milestone, petition the special master
for a recommendation concerning the
failure to achieve the milestone date(s)
requires a revision of all or part of
the remainder of the schedule
milestones as established in paragraphs
IV or V. Whenever a milestone is
missed, the defendant shall exercise its
best efforts to recoup all lost time,
including, where appropriate, the
payment of extraordinary expenses for
overtime, double shifts or additional
contractors or consultants or alternative
methods.
XIII. DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Nothing in this Decree and Agreement
shall prevent any party from presenting
a disputed matter to the Court, at any
time, concerning any matter hereunder,
including, without limitation, the
schedules set forth in paragraphs IV or
V. The filing of a petition asking the
Court to resolve a dispute shall not by
itself extend or postpone any obligation
of the defendant under this Decree and
Agreement, provided further that nothing
herein shall prevent an affected party
from applying to the Court, upon notice
to all parties, for a stay of relief
authorized or directed by this Decree
and Agreement.
XIV. SATISFACTION OF CLAIMS
Full compliance with this Decree and
Agreement shall constitute full
Satisfaction of all claims alleged
herein. The Enforcement Agreement
contained in this Decree and Agreement
is an Enforcement Agreement pursuant to
the MPRSA, 33 U.S.C. §1414b(c)(3). A
violation of this Enforcement Agreement
is a violation of the MPRSA. The EPA
and State do not, by their entry into
this Enforcement Agreement, warrant or
aver in any manner that the defendant's
complete compliance with this
Enforcement Agreement will result in
compliance with the provisions of the
MPRSA, 33 U.S.C. §1401 et seq.,
including the Ban Act. Notwithstanding
EPA's and the State's review and
approval of any plans formulated
pursuant to this Enforcement Agreement,
defendant shall remain solely
responsible for compliance with the
terms of the MPRSA, this Decree and
Agreement, and defendant's ocean dumping
permit.
XV. COMPLIANCE WITH OTHER LAWS
This Decree and Agreement in no way
affects or relieves the defendant of
responsibility to comply with any other
Federal, State, or local law or
regulation. Nothing contained in this
Decree and Agreement shall be construed
to prevent or limit the EPA's or State
right to obtain penalties or injunctive
relief under the MPRSA or other federal
or state statutes or regulations.
XVI. R V N F_R T
The EPA and State do not waive any
rights or remedies available to them for
any violation by defendant of Federal or
State laws, or regulations following
completion of the requirements of this
Decree and Agreement.
XVII. REVIEW OF PERMIT APPLICATIONS
The defendant, EPA and State shall
take all possible steps to expedite the
Submission and review, as appropriate,
of any permits, applications or
approvals needed for completion of the
interim measures and long-term
alternative system(s) set forth in
paragraph IV and V.
XVIII. RETENTION OF JURISDICTION
This Court shall retain jurisdiction
to enforce the terms and conditions of
this Decree and Agreement and to resolve
disputes arising hereunder as may be
necessary Or appropriate for its
implementation.
XIX. TERMINATION
This Decree and Agreement shall
terminate when the defendant has
complied with all applicable
requirements of this Decree and
Agreement and the United States and the
State have so certified.
The parties consent to entry of this
Decree and Agreement without further
notice.
For the United States:
s/ July 28, 1989
DONALD A. CARR Date
Acting Assistant Attorney
General
Land & Natural Resources
Division
U.S. Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
BENITO ROMANO
United States Attorney for
the Southern District of
New York
By: s/ August 3, 1989
RICHARD M. SCHWARTZ Date
GABRIEL W. GORENSTEIN
Assistant United States
Attorneys
One St. Andrews Plaza
New York, New York 10007
July 26, 1989
BRUCE C. BUCKHEIT Date
Senior Counsel
Environmental Enforcement
Section
Land & Natural Resources
Division
U.S. Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
For the United States Environ-
mental Protection Agency
s/f July 31, 1989
WILLIAM J. MUSZYNSKI Date
Acting Regional Administrator
Region II
U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency
New York, New York 10278
s/ July 28, 1989
EDWARD E. REICH Date
Acting Assistant Adminis-
trator for Enforcement and
Compliance Monitoring
U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency
Washington, D.C. 20460
July 26, 1989
CHARLES E. HOFFMAN Date
Assistant Regional Counsel
Office of Regional Counsel
U.S.—~Environmental
Protection Agency
Region II
26 Federal Plaza
New York, New York 10278
s/ 8/3/89
ANN L. GOLDWEBER DATE
Assistant Attorney
General
New York State
Department of Law
120 Broadway
New York, New York
s/ July 26, 1989
THOMAS C. JORLING Date
Commissioner
New York State Department
of Environmental Conser-
vation
50 Wolf Road
Albany, New York 12233
For Westchester County:
7731/89
WILLIAM G. BORGHARD Date
Commissioner
Westchester County
Department of Environmental
Facilities
600 Michaelian Office Building
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
—_July 31, 1989
MARILYN J. SLAATTEN Date
Westchester County Attorney
600 Michaelian Office
Building
148 Martine Avenue
White Plains, New York 10601
Dated: New York, New York
August 7, 1991
s/Whitman Knapp
United States District Sites
Southern District of New York
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
eee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ewe we we we ee oe x
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND
STATE OF NEW YORK, CONSENT DECREE
DECREE AND
ENFORCEMENT
AGREEMENT
89 Civ. 5274 (WK)
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
COUNTY OF WESTCHESTER and
WESTCHESTER COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL FACILITIES,
Defendants.
The United States having moved for
relief pursuant to the All Writs Act, 28
U.S.C. §1651(a), and this matter having
been heard by this Court on Mya 10,
1990, and upon all prior proceedings
heretofore had herein, IT IS HEREBY
ORDERED as follows:
1. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1651l(a),
this Court retains jurisdiction over the
Article 78 proceeding entitled Ludlow
Park Homeowners Assoc. v. County of
Westchester, which has been removed to
this Court as 90 Civ. 2543 (WK)
(S.0.8.7.)%
2. Pursuant ot 28 U.S.C. §1651(a),
this Court enjoins any further
litigation in state court of said
Article 78 proceeding.
Dated: New York, New York
May 24, 1990
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.