Opposition — Zapata-Haynie Corp. v. Ward

Supreme Court brief1983

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

A Ge Supreme

No.8256 FIT ED

“Vv 1 om

IN THE ALEXANDER L.

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1982

ZAPATA-HAYNIE CORPORATION and

HARTFORD INSURANCE COMPANY

Petitioners

versus

SUNNY G. WARD, Widow of

JOHN D. WARD, Deceased

Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES

COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO CERTIORARI

Respondent's Statement of Facts .............6500006:

Reasons That This Court Should Not Grant The

chs cake e tbe eseoceosed

I. THE HOLDING OF THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

COURT OF APPEALS IN THIS CASE IS BASED

UPON THE SITUS AND STATUS TEST AS

EXEMPLIFIED IN THE 1972 AMENDMENTS

TO THE LONGSHOREMEN AND HARBOR

WORKERS’ ACT AND NOT UPON PRE-1972

Il. THE DECISION OF THIS COURT IS NOT

CONTRARY TO THE DUAL TESTS OF SITUS

AND STATUS AS SET FORTH BY THIS HON-

ORABLE COURT IN P. C. PFEIFFER CO., INC.

V. FORD, 444 US. 69 (1979), 100 S. Ct. 328,

62 L.Ed.2d 225 (1979) AND NORTHEAST

MARINE TERMINAL CO. V. CAPUTO, 432

US. 249, 53 L.Ed.2d 320, 97 S. Ct. 2348 (1977) ......

Ill. THE DECISION IN THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

COURT OF APPEALS IS NOT IN CONFLICT

WITH THE OTHER MAJOR CIRCUITS OF THE

INDEX (Continued)

Page

IV. THERE IS NO FEDERAL OR STATE

CONFLICT QUESTION .... 0... 6c ce cece cence 11

COMMTOR nc cccccesccccccccccsccccvccsccccvees 13

Certificate of Service .. 0.0... 66sec cece cece eee eeees 14

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES:

Caldwell v. Ogden Sea Transport, Inc., 618 F.2d

1037 (4th Cir. 1980), rev’d on other grounds in

Rodriguez v. Compass Shipping Co., _.— U.S.

—— , 101 S. Ct. 1945, 68 L.Ed.2d 472 (1981)....

Dravo v, Banks, 567 F.2d $93 (3rd Cir. 1977) .......

Executive Jet Aviation, Inc. v. City of Cleveland, 459

U.S. 249, 92 S. Ct. 493, 34 L.Ed.2d 454(1972) ...

Fusco v. Perini North River Associates, 601 F.2d

659 (2d Cir. 1979) vacated and remanded, 662

F.2d 111 (1980), cert. denied, 449 U.S. 1131

Dc écdehes'esenscoeeecenecseaeeeisese

Graziano v. General Dynamics, 663 F.2d 340 (ist

PL bicedbcadchdieusesstsbeanicesoeda’

Northeast Marine Terminal Co. v. Caputo, 432 U.S.

249, 53 L.Ed.2d 320, 97 S. Ct. 2348 (1977) . .4, 7,

P. C. Pfeiffer Co., Inc. v. Ford, 444 U. S. 69 (1979),

100 S. Ct. 328, 62 L.Ed.2d 225 (1979) ..........

Thibodaux v, Atlantic Richfield Co., 580 F.2d 841

(Sth Cir. 1978), cert. denied, 442 U.S. 909, 99

S. Ct. 2820, 61 L.Ed.2d 274 (1979) .............

Weyerhauser Co. v. Gilmore, 528 F.2d 947 (9th Cir.

1976), cert. denied, 429 U.S. 868, 97 S. Ct. 179,

SO L.E4.2d 148 (1976) 22... cc ccccccccccvcces

11,12

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1982

ZAPATA-HAYNIE CORPORATION and

HARTFORD INSURANCE COMPANY

Petitioners

versus

SUNNY G. WARD, Widow of

JOHN D. WARD, Deceased

Respondents

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES

COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

JURISDICTION

Jurisdiction pursuant to Title 28 U.S.C., Section 1254(1)

is not contested.

RESPONDENT'S STATEMENT OF FACTS

While the Respondent herein does not basically disagree

with the overail factual statement contained in the Petition-

er’s Statement of Facts certain additional facts should be

pointed out for the benefit of the Court.

It is noteworthy that John D. Ward met his death while

flying some two (2) miles offshore over the navigable waters

of the United States in an area where he was required to be

in order to carry out his job duties as a maritime employee of

the harvesting of menhaden, commonly known as “pogies”,

from the Gulf of Mexico. It is not contended that John D.

Ward was fortuitously over the Gulf of Mexico by virtue of

the fact that he could not carry out his job duties as a fish

line” delineating Longshoremen’s coverage. Ward's activi-

ties were not isolated, but at the time of his death, he and

three (3) other pilots, each flying separate aircraft owned by

the employer, were carrying out and performing the same

job duties for a fleet of six (6) vessels also owned by the

employer which were engaged in menhaden fishing.

REASONS THAT THIS COURT SHOULD NOT GRANT

THE PETITION FOR CERTIORARI

(1) The holding of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in

this case is based upon the situs and status test as exempli-

fied in the 1972 Amendments to the Longshoremen and

Harbor Workers’ Act and not upon pre-1972 law.

(2) The Decision of this Court is not contrary to the

dual tests of situs and status as set forth by this Honorable

Court in P. C. Pfeiffer Co., Inc. v. Ford, 444 U.S. 69 (1979),

100 S. Ct. 328, 62 L.Ed.2d 225 (1979) and Northeast

Marine Terminal Co. v. Caputo, 432 U.S. 249, 53 L.Ed.2d

320, 97 S. Ct. 2348 (1977). -

(3) The Decision in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals

is not in conflict with the other major circuits of the country.

(4) There is no federal or state conflict question.

ARGUMENT

I

THE HOLDING OF THE FIFTH CIRCUIT COURT OF

APPEALS IN THIS CASE IS BASED UPON THE SITUS

AND STATUS TEST AS EXEMPLIFIED IN THE 1972

AMENDMENTS TO THE LONGSHOREMEN AND

HARBOR WORKERS’ ACT AND NOT UPON PRE-1972

LAW.

Petitioner miscontrues the holding of the Fifth Circuit

Court of Appeals in this case by stating:

“The case squarely presents a most im-

portant issue. . . . ‘Whether Congress ex-

cluded people who would have been covered

before the 1972 Amendments. . .””

(Page 6 of Petition)

Th. “ifth Circuit based its findings on P. C. Pfeiffer Co.,

Inc. v. Ford, 444 U.S. 69, 100 S. Ct. 328, 62 L.Ed.2d 225

(1979) which holds that “maritime employment” was

determined by the purpose of the work, not solely the

particular skills used. (Page A-6 of Petition). The Court

went on to state:

“. . . Even if we were to apply the stricter

v. Gilmore, 528 F.2d 957 (9th Cir. 1976),

cert. denied, 429 U.S. 868, 97 S. Ct. 179,

50 L.Ed.2d 148 (1976); Boudreaux v. Ameri-

can Workover, Inc., 680 F.2d 1034 (Sth Cir.

1982) (en banc); Ledoux v. Petroleum Heli-

copters, Inc., 609 F.2d 824 (Sth Cir. 1980).

(Page A-6, A-7 of Petition)

The Court went on to hold that under the two prong

test of Thibodaux v. Atlantic Richfield Co., 580 F.2d 841

(5th Cir. 1978), cert. denied, 442 U.S. 909, 99 S. Ct. 2820,

61 L.Ed.2d 274 (1979) which provides that an employee

may satisfy the status test either by performing, at the time

of his injuries, activities properly classified as maritime em-

ployment or alternatively by engaging in an occupation

considered maritime employment. 580 F.2d 844. The Court

then found that since Ward was engaged in a maritime

occupation and was performing that occupation at the

“moment of injury”; he met both prongs of the Thibodaux

test. (Page A-7, A-8 of Petition).

It is, therefore, respectfully urged that the Court did not

base its opinion on the fact that Ward would have been

covered prior to the 1972 amendments and, therefore, he

remained covered after these amendments, but ruled that

Ward was covered under the Longshoremen and Harbor

Workers’ Act even under the restrictive test set forth in

Thibodaux, supra.

THE DECISION OF THIS COURT IS NOT CONTRARY

TO THE DUAL TESTS OF SITUS AND STATUS AS SET

FORTH BY THIS HONORABLE COURT IN P. C. PFEIF-

FER CO., INC. V. FORD, 444 U. S. 69 (1979), 100 S. Ct.

328, 62 L.ED.2D 225 (1979) AND NORTHEAST MARINE

TERMINAL CO. V. CAPUTO, 432 U. S. 249, 53 L.ED.2D

320, 97 S. Ct. 2348 (1977).

Respondent would incorporate, in support of her argu-

ment on Point 2, the authority set forth above in her argu-

ment on Point 1 and would further point out to the Court

that the factual situation of this case meets the two prong

test of situs and status as set forth in P. C. Pfeiffer Co.,

Inc. v. Ford, 444 U.S. 69, 100 S. Ct. 328, 62 L.Ed.2d 225

(1979) and Northeast Marine Terminal Co. v. Caputo, 432

US. 249, 53 L.Ed.2d 320, 97 S. Ct. 2348 (1977). No logical

factual argument may be made that the activities of John

D. Ward were not maritime in character in that they have

traditionally been so held. Neither can any argument, based

on rational analysis, be made that John Ward did not meet

his death on the situs of the navigable waters of the United

States.

THE DECISION IN THE FIFTH CIRCUIT COURT OF

APPEALS IS NOT IN CONFLICT WITH THE OTHER

MAJOR CIRCUITS OF THE COUNTRY.

The Petitioner asserts that the decisions of the First,

Second, Third, Fourth and Ninth Circuits conflict with

the decision in the case at bar. Your Respondent finds no

evidence of inconsistency with the aforementioned Circuits

the cases cited as authority in said Circuits. Respondent

would point out to the Court that in no case relied upon

Petitioner involved a fishspotter whose normal job duties

required him day in and day out to perform duties which

an integral part of navigation and commerce on the

waters of the United States.

<

FIRST CIRCUIT

Petitioner relies upon Graziano v. General Dynamics, 663

F.2d 340 (ist Cir. 1981) which deals with a maintenance-

mason employed in a shipyard who was granted coverage

based upon his meeting the “status” requirement of the

Longshoremen and Harbor Workers’ Act. This employee's

activities involved primarily the repair of masonry and

shipyard builders, 3623 F.2d 340, 341, these job duties have

a much less significant relationship to traditional maritime

activities than the job duties of John Ward.

SECOND CIRCUIT

Petitioner argues Fusco v. Perini North River Associates,

601 F.2d 659 (2d Cir. 1979) vacated and remanded, 622

F.2d 111 (1980), cert. denied, 449 U.S. 1131 (1981), con-

flicts with the holding in this case. The Fusco Court, in

defining “maritime activity”, ruled that one of the key

tests involved is whether or not the activity bears a signifi-

cant relation to navigation or to commerce on navigable

waters. The Fusco decision cannot be construed to con-

flict with the decision rendered in the case at bar inasmuch

as all of the job duties of the deceased fishspotter, Ward,

centered around navigation, commerce and the loading of

a vessel.

THIRD CIRCUIT

Petitioner further submits the holding of Dravo v. Banks,

567 F.2d 593 (3rd Cir. 1977) to be in conflict with the

case at bar. However, a close reading of the Dravo case

shows that the emphasis of the Court was on the “status”

question presented and the Court determined that the duties

of Banks, a maintenance employee who cleaned up debris,

had no traditional maritime characteristics and were not a

necessary ingredient in the shipbuilding process. In the case

at bar, there were significant maritime characteristics, based

upon Ward’s duties of aiding in navigation of the vessels.

FOURTH CIRCUIT

The case of Caldwell v. Ogden Sea Transport, Inc., 618

F.2d 1037 (4th Cir. 1980), rev'd on other grounds in

Rodriguez v. Compass Shipping Co., ___. U. §. _.__ , 101

S. Ct. 1945, 68 L.Ed.2d 472 (1981), addresses the issue of

Petitioner then cites Weyerhauser Co. v. Gilmore, 528

F.2d 957 (9th Cir. 1976), cert. denied, 429 U.S. 868, 97

con i

conflicts with the decision in the case at bar. The issue in

Lastly, the Petitioner cited Thibodaux v. Atlantic Rich-

field Co., 580 F.2d 841 (Sth Civ. 1978), cert. denied, 442

U.S. 909, 99 S. Ct. 2820, 61 L.Ed.2d 274 (1979), and

aFare

Ht

H if

i

ith

RE

:

Fs

$

F

:

shi

i

iH

et

iH

He

z

; , 845, whereas

job duties except by traveling over water.

Likewise, the case of Executive Jet Aviation, Inc. v. City

of Cleveland, 459 U.S. 249, 92 S. Ct. 493, 34 L.Ed.2d 454

(1972) does not support the contentions of the Petitioner

since the land based aircraft referred to therein was fortui-

tously over Lake Erie and was in navigation between two

10

land based air fields. The air craft in Executive Jet perform-

ed no function which could in any way be related to “‘tradi-

tionally maritime activities, involving navigation or commerce

on navigable waters”, 93 S. Ct. 493, 498, a clear distinction

from the factual issues in this case. It is respectfully submitt-

ed that Executive Jet clearly sets forth a test met by this

factual situation and that but for the employee/employer

relationship that Admiralty jurisdiction would apply. How-

ever, the Longshoremen and Harbor Workers’ Act abrogated

Admiralty jurisdiction to an employee against his employer,

except as provided in Section 905(b) of the Act, which

does not apply here.

IV

THERE IS NO FEDERAL OR STATE CONFLICT

QUESTION.

The argument on Point 4 states without authority that

the Court should decide whether Ward was a “fisherman and,

therefore, a member of the crew of a vessel or a land based

airplane pilot.” (Page 12, 13 of Petition). It would appear

inferior benefits of the Mississippi Workmen’s Compensation

S. Ct. 2348 (1977) which holds:

At no time did the Respondent agree to be bound by or to

accept state compensation payments in lieu of her statutory

vested right to compensation under the Longshoremen and

Harbor Workers’ Act which she sought from the beginning.

There is no issue before this Court regarding the application

of those payments, because it is readily conceded by the

Respondent hereto that any payments made pursuant to the

Mississippi Workmen’s Compensation Act should be credited

against the payments required under the provisions of the

Longshoremen and Harbor Workers’ Act.

12

iil

the

and novel

Petitioner

and the

rit Of

submitted

=318]i]

13

DAVID O. McCORMICK, Attomey for

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, JOHN L. HUNTER, of the law firm Cumibest, Cumbest

P. A., do hereby certify that | have this day

mailed, postage prepaid, a true and correct copy of the above

Honorable Alben N. Hopkins, Attorney-at-Law, P. O. Box

1510, Gulfport, Mississippi, 39501; Ms. Laurie M. Streeter,

Associate Solicitor, U. S. Department of Labor, Suite

N-2620, WDDL, Washington, D. C., 20210; and Mr. Ralph

M. Hartman, Director, Office of Workers’ Compensation

Programs, U.S. Department of Labor, Suite $-3524, NDOL,

DAVID O. McCORMICK

Pescagoule, MS 39567

(601) 762-5422

i4

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.