Appendix — Chemical Manufacturers Ass'n v. U. S. Environmental Protection Agency

Supreme Court brief1982

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

ak

-

INDEX TO APPENDIX

inion of the Court in Natural Resources Defense Coun-

cil, Inc. v. EPA, Nos. 80-1607, et al. (D.C. Cir., March

RR SIS CR SR, Dgeeaie Le ee A-1

Order of the Court Denying Motion to Dismiss in Natural

Resources Defense Council, Inc. v. EPA, Nos. 80-1607,

et al. (D.C. Cir., March 2, 1982) ................. A-16

List of Petitioners’ Parent Companies, Sub-

oe ag Affiliates Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule

Een tn cRsGE COOKS ob bed GO eREeenda EW s «on 60s A-17

A-l

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

No. 80-1607

NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC., PETITIONER

Vv.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY and

ANNE M. GORSUCH, ADMINISTRATOR,

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, RESPONDENTS

CHEMICAL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION,

AMERICAN IRON & STEEL INSTITUTE,

EDISON ELECTRIC INSTITUTE, ET AL., INTERVENORS

And Consolidated Cases Nos. 80-1660, 80-1723, 80-1733,

80-1740, 80-1741, 80-1809, 20-1821, 80-1837, 80-1875,

80-1881, 80-1889, 80-1909, 80-1914, 80-1915, 80-1923,

80-1924, 80-1927, 80-1928, 80-1929, 80-1931, 80-1932,

80-1934, 80-1955, 80-1966, 80-1970, 80-1975, 80-1978,

80-1984, 80-1987, 80-1989, 80-1999, 80-2002, 80-2004,

80-2007, 80-2114, 80-2279, 80-2521, 81-1569, 81-1570,

81-1571, 81-1572, 81-1573, 81-1574, 81-1575, 81-1576,

81-1577, 81-1578, 81-1579, 81-1708, 81-1709, 81-1746,

81-1747, 81-1748, 81-1749, and 81-1750

On Motion to Dismiss

A-2

Argued December 15, 1981

Decided March 2, 1982

Gene W. Lafitte, with whom J. Berry St. John, Jr.,

George J. Domas, and Robert E. Holden were on the

brief, for petitioners American Iron and Steel Institute,

et al.

Alan W. Eckert, Acting Senior Litigator, Office of Gen-

eral Counsel, Environmental Protection Agency, with

whom Anthony Liotta, Acting Assistant Attorney Gen-

eral, Donald W. Stever, Chief, Environmental Defense

Section, and Elizabeth Stein and David T. Buente, Jr.,

Attorneys, Environmental Defense Section, were on the

brief, for respondent.

Ronald J. Wilson was on the brief for petitioner Nat-

ural Resources Defense Council, Inc.

Before BAZELON, Senior Circuit Judge, and MIKVA and

GINSBURG, Circuit Judges.

Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge GINSBURG.

GINsBuURG, Circuit Judge: These consolidated cases in-

volve numerous challenges to Consolidated Permit Regu-

lations (CPR’s)' issued by the Environmental Protection

Agency (EPA). Industry petitioners? contend that in-

itial jurisdiction to review the National Pollutant Dis-

140 C.F.R. pts. 122-125 (1981).

as “industry petitioners” or simply “industry.” The Natural

A-3

charge Elimination System (NPDES) portion of the

CPR’s does not reside in this court (or any other court

of appeals).* They have moved to dismiss all petitions

for review‘ insofar as the petitions challenge NPDES-

related CPR’s. The parties have fully briefed and argued

the motion to dismiss. We hold that section 509(b) (1)

(E) of the Clean Water Act (CWA), 33 U.S.C. § 1369

(b) (1) (E) (1976), vests initial authority to review the

challenged regulations in the courts of appeals. We there-

fore deny the motion to dismiss.

I.

Section 301(a) of the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C.

§1311(a) (1976), forbids anyone to discharge any pol-

lutant into navigable waters except pursuant to an

NPDES permit issued under CWA § 402, 33 U.S.C.

§ 1342 (1976 & Supp. III 1979). These permits list, for

a specific discharger, the types and amounts of pollutants

that may be discharged. Section 402 requires determina-

8 Our jurisdiction to review the non-NPDES aspects of the

CPR’s is conceded and, indeed, is exclusive. See NRDC v. EPA,

No. 80-1607, slip op. at 9 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per

curiam).

* Industry petitioners seek dismissal of their own petitions

for review as well as those filed by NRDC and others. Because

of uncertainty as to the appropriate forum for initial review

of the NPDES-related CPR’s, both NRDC and some of the

industry petitioners have sought to challenge these CPR’s by

filing complaints in district courts. See NRDC v. EPA, No.

80-1607, slip op. at 12 n.10 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per

curiam) (collecting cases). If we were to grant the motion to

dismiss, these district courts would have to decide if they had

general federal question jurisdiction to entertain the pending

complaints. See 28 U.S.C.A. § 1331 (West Cum. Supp. 1981) ;

see also E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train, 430 U.S.

112, 124-25 (1977) (regulations not initially reviewable in a

court of appeals under § 509(b) (1) (E) may be reviewed “only

in the District Court, if anywhere”). One district court has

already asserted that it has jurisdiction to review NPDES

regulations. American Petroleum Inst. v. Costle, No. 79-0858,

slip op. at 2 (W.D. La. July 27, 1981).

A-4

tion of the amounts listed in any given permit in com-

pliance with, inter alia, the requirements of sections 301

and 306, 33 U.S.C. §§1311, 1316 (1976 & Supp. III

1979). Those two sections, in turn, require the Adminis-

trator of EPA to establish by regulation effluent limita-

tions, based on pollution-control technology, for sources

of pollutants.*®

EPA promulgated a set of NPDES regulations in 1979.

These regulations do not set any numerical limitations on

pollutant discharge. Instead, they are a complex set of

procedures for issuing or denying NPDES permits. Sev-

eral parties, uncertain as to the appropriate federal

forum, sought review in both courts of appeals and dis-

trict courts. EPA repromulgated these regulations, with

slight substantive modifications, in 1980 as part of the

CPR’s.* Once again, challenges were filed in both federal

courts of appeals and federal district courts. These chal-

lenges involve both NPDES and non-NPDES aspects of

the CPR’s. Through a complex procedural history, all

court of appeals actions have been consolidated here.”

Industry contends that no statute vests initial jurisdic-

tion in courts of appeals, so a challenge to NPDES-related

CPR’s may be instituted only under the general federal

question jurisdiction of the district courts. Thus the in-

dustry petitioners have filed their motion to dismiss. EPA

5 The Administrator may also authorize any state to run an

NPDES program in lieu of the federal program. Standards

for the Administrator’s approval of a state-run program are

essentially identical to the standards that govern the federal

i toms CWA § 402(b), 33 U.S.C, § 1342(b) (1976 & Supp.

1 ;

*For a fuller discassion of the CPR’s, which govern five

separate EPA permit programs, see NRDC v. EPA, No. 80-

1607, slip op. at 8-11 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per curiam).

’ For a partial summary of this history, see NRDC v. EPA,

No. 80-1607 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 4, 1980) (per curiam).

A-5

opposes this motion, citing CWA § 509(b) (1), 33 U.S.C.

§ 1869(b) (1) (1976), which provides:

Review of the Administrator’s action... (E) in

approving or promulgating any effluent limitation or

other limitation under section 1311, 1312, or 131([6]

of this title . . . may be had by any interested person

ae ee oe ee Oe

tates....

EPA contends that this statutory section covers the

NPDES-related CPR’s.®

II.

Section 509(b) (1) (E) authorizes the courts of appeals

to review the promulgation of “any effluent limitation or

other limitation under [CWA § 301, 302, or 306,] section

1311, 1312, or 131[6] of this title.” “Effluent limitation”

is defined in CWA §502(11), 33 U.S.C. § 1362(11)

(1976), as “any restriction established by a State or the

Administrator on quantities, rates, and concentrations of

. . « constituents which are discharged . . . , including

schedules of compliance.” At first glance, one might read

subsection E to confine this court’s review to EPA’s

establishment of numerical limitations on pollutant dis-

charges.’ Two aspects of the statutory language itself,

however, indicate that the provision has a wider range:

(1) subsection E authorizes review of an “other limita-

tion,” not just an effluent limitation; and (2) section

502(11) defines “effluent limitation” as “any restriction”

* EPA also asserts that we have initial review authority

under 33 U.S.C. § 1869(b) (1) (D) (1976) and under the doc-

trine of ancillary jurisdiction. Because we find § 509(b) (1) (E)

a sufficient basis for our authority to review the NPDES-

related CPR’s, we express no opinion on EPA’s other argu-

ments.

*Cf. Montgomery Envtl. Coalition v. Costle, 646 F.2d 568,

574 (D.C. Cir. 1980) (“{E]fluent limitations are technical

specifications of the quantities of various polluting substances

that a permittee may lawfully discharge.”’).

A-6

on the amounts of pollutants discharged, not just a num-

erical restriction.

The phrase “effluent limitation or other limitation” in

section 509(b) (1) (E)" has in fact been interpreted to

include more than numerical limitations. In NRDC v.

EPA, No. 79-1639 (D.C. Cir. May 7, 1981), we addressed

a challenge to regulations governing applications for vari-

ances from the limitations imposed on municipal sewage

plants. Those regulations set no numerical limitatione;

instead they establish “criteria and standards to be ap-

plied by EPA in acting on . . . requests for modifications

to the secondary treatment requirements.” 40 C.F.R.

§ 125.56 (1981). We rejected a challenge to our juris-

diction because “[a]s a practical matter [the regulations]

restrict the discharge of sewage by limiting the avail-

ability of a variance to a class of applicants which does

not include all coastal municipalities.” Slip op. at 12.

In VEPCO v. Costle, 566 F.2d 446 (4th Cir. 1977),

the challenge was to standards regulating the construc-

tion and design of cooling water intake structures. The

court agreed that these standards were not effluent limita-

“This phrase also appears in § 505, 38 U.S.C. § 1365

A-7

tions because they were “concerned with structures... ,

not with discharges.” Id. at 449. Nonetheless, the court

held the standards reviewable as an “other limitation”:

“([T)he . . . regulations here do refer to information

that must be considered in determining the type of in-

take structures that individual point sources may employ,

and, by that token, they are iimitations.” Jd. at 450.

One court, however, has adopted the position industry

urges here. In American Iron & Steel Institute (AISI) v.

EPA, 543 F.2d 521 (3d Cir. 1976), the court held that

it had no jurisdiction to review EPA’s “net /gross” regu-

lation, which states when a permittee may receive a

“credit” for pollutants in its intake water, and a revised

version of which is contained in section 122.63(g) and

(h) of the CPR’s. The court held that the net/gross

regulation was not an effluent limitation because it merely

Sgn the policy and procedures to be followed

in connection with applications for permits.” 543 F.2d

at 526.

We believe the approach taken in NRDC and VEPCO

is sounder than that taken in AJS/. First, of course,

NRDC is binding precedent in this circuit, and in NRDC

we specifically rejected the reasoning of AISI. NRDC,

slip op. at 13. Second, the A/JS/ court. «unlike the Fourth

Cireuit in VEPCO, did not consider ..e possibility that

something that was not an “effluent limitation” could none-

theless be an “effluent limitation or other limitation.” “

Third, the AISI court seemed more concerned with the

timing of judicial review than with identification of the

™ Because § 509(b) (1) (E) provides for our review of both

effluent limitations and other limitations, we see no need to

determine that the CPR’s are one or the other. It suffices that

RR fg ry Re ee Fry: Compare

NRDC v. EPA, No. 79-1639, slip op. at 14 (D.C. Cir. May 7,

1981) (“effluent limitations”). with VEPCO v. Costle, 566

F.2d 446, 449-50 (4th Cir. 1977) (“other limitation”).

A-8

forum for review; thus the court may have blended

actions to be reviewed in courts of appeals rather than

district courts.“ In short, the issue as it is presented

2 See, e.g., 543 F.2d at 528 (declining to consider net/gross

regulation “at this stage” and “in the absence of a full and

comprehensive record”); id. at 529 (“The issue of district

% AISI was cited in support of our decision in Diamond

Shamrock Corp. v. Costle, 580 F.2d 670, 674 (D.C. Cir. 1978),

that a net/gross regulation was not ripe for review. The

parties have not yet briefed the issue of the ripeness of the

CPR’s, and we do today hold that any of them are ripe

not

for review. We hold only that this court has authority

196-97 (1980) (per curiam) ; E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co

v. Train, 430 U.S. 112, 127 n.18 (1977); VEPCO v. Costle,

566 F.2d 446, 447 (4th Cir. 1977)

in a court of appeals. Compare CWA § 509(b) (1) (six

specified categories of actions under CWA) with. e.¢., Clean

Air Act §307(b)(1), 42 U.S.C. $7607(b)(1) (Supp. Ill

1979) (eight specific categories and “any other nationally

applicable regulations promulgated, or final action taken”).

Industry petitioners argue that if the CPR’s are reviewable

directly in a court of appeals, virtually any action

reviewable, thus contravening the

|

i

|

|

ag8

It

Hi

3

Hi

iH

ttl

|

|

.

A-9

SETHE PHM PHN Be

TEN BE ; Woe fi dichal att

itt iil bhi Ee

rigtifes PSeny eet Thy

files ceil tie tee i:

5 i sail pithy tH!

Hi aeaks aga 33 : <i =}: s

FEE HA eee oir

A-10

s

HE

Nov. 4,

No, 80-1607 (D.C. Cir.

is no analogous transfer provision

ar daeee coe If we were to grant the motion to dismiss,

there would be a rea] possibility, see supra note 4, that several

served by initial review in a court

v. Costle, 566 F.2d 446, 451 (4th Cir.

28 U.S.C. §2112(a) (1976). See

be consolidated in one court, as these

, an important goal in dealing with

PCO

may

under

EPA,

There

HA

i

Hl

|

!

2

Le HH :

HE

if

Hy

iit

a

it

i

uh

¢

ae3

AE

ihe

ait

salina

TH

aH Mine

-

: isi

erates

Sateen te ae le he cee tc ten

—

determinations. See NRDC v. EPA, No. 79-1639, sli

op. at 14-35 (D.C. Cir. May 7, 1981).

Our decision, like those of the NRDC

courts, follows the lead of the Supreme Court in

ing section 509(b) (1) a practical rather than a

construction. See generally Crown Simpson Pulp

Costle, 445 U.S. 193 (1980) (per curiam). If we

grant the motion to dismiss, one or more district

i]

:

E

:

2

ges

tt

itt

aE

lich

ah

iiesqii

review numerous individual actions issui

7

i

i

i

i

i

E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. v. Train,

136 (1977). Crown Simpson and du Pont do

ocally dictate our result,’* but their reasoning strongly

supports a holding that we have jurisdiction.

ITI.

Industry petitioners argue that “due process” concerns

nonetheless require a narrow interpretation of section

509(b) (1) review authority. Section 509(b) (1) contains

a ninety-day “statute of limitations” for

action of the Administrator that falls within its terms.

Complementing this provision, section 509(b)(2), 33

U.S.C. § 1369(b) (2) (1976), provides that “[a)ction of

the Administrator with respect to which review could

1° Crown Simpson was an interpretation of § 509(b) (1) (F);

du Pont involved numerical limitations.

8

ia

L;

A-12

have been obtained under [section 509{b)(1)] shall not

be subject to judicial review in any civil and criminal

proceeding for enforcement.” Under these two provisions,

one who wishes to challenge an action of the Administra-

tor must, if the action is held to be within the categories

of section 509(b) (1), do so within ninety days or lose

forever the right to do so, even though that action might

eventually result in the imposition of severe civil or crim-

inal penalties.

Industry argues that this preclusive, “now or never”

review aspect of the CWA mandates a narrow construc-

tion of section 509(b) (1): The more broadly the section

is construed, the more likely it is that someone will have

regulations enforced against him yet be precluded from

challenging the validity of those regulations because of a

failure to seek immediate review under section 509(b) (1).

This argument finds substantial support in decisions of the

Supreme Court and this court. In Adamo Wrecking Co. v.

United States, 434 U.S. 275 (1978), the Court noted that

the presence of an identical preclusive review provision in

the Clean Air Act was a factor in determining that a

particular regulation was not an “emission standard” that

was therefore unchallengeable in an enforcement proceed-

ing. And in Chrysler Corp. v. EPA, 600 F.2d 904 (D.C.

Cir. 1979), this court construed a jurisdictional provision

of the Noise Control Act to exclude certain actions of the

Administrator, in part because of an identical preclusive

review statute. Citing Adamo, the court declared that

“(tjhe nagging presence of a substantial due process ques-

tion indicates, then, at the very least, the propriety of a

eo of” the jurisdictional statute. Jd.

at

17In Adamo, the Court did not suggest that constitutional

A-13

This review-preclusion consideration lacks in the present

case the force it had in Adamo and Chrysler. There is a

critical difference between the statutory and regulatory

schemes involved in those cases and the one here. The

CPR’s are not self-executing. As noted above, the CWA

operates by prohibiting all pollutant discharges except

those allowed by a permit. Each individual subject to the

CPR’s will of necessity have participated in a permit pro-

ceeding before being punished for violating the conditions

specified in his permit. A polluter charged with violating

those conditions will certainly be on notice of the duty he

is alleged to have breached. As EPA puts it, “The pos-

sibility of an EPA ‘sneak attack,’ resulting in criminal

sanctions with no notice to the victim other than the filing

of a complaint, appears to have been controlling in Adamo.

That factor is absent here.” EPA Reply Brief at 16-17.

See generally Adamo, 434 U.S. at 283 & n.2.

Industry counsel pointed out at oral argument, how-

ever, that another class of persons might be subject to

sanctions as a result of the CPR’s: those who were not

previously required to obtain a permit but, because of

some changed definitions in the CPR’s, are now consid-

ered polluters subject to the CWA. For example, a mem-

ber of this class might pollute an impounded stream with-

out a permit believing that he was not polluting “waters

of the United States.” He might be unaware that one of

§ 307 (b) [of the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7607(b) (Supp.

III 1979) ] in the context of a criminal prosecution.” 434 U.S.

at 291 (concurring opinion). This court, in Chrysler, based its

narrow statutor, interpretation both on “policy considera-

tions,” 600 F.2d at 912, arising from the preclusive provision,

and on doubts as to “the constitutional validity of the pre-

clusive review provision,” id. at 913. In Harrison v. PPG

Indus., 446 U.S. 578 (1980), Justice Powell noted the Chrysler

decision and declared that “constitutional difficulties may

well counsel a narrow construction of § 307 (b) (1),” the Clean

Air Act jurisdictional section analogous to CWA § 509(b) (1).

446 U.S. at 594 (concurring opinion).

A-14

the CPR’s, 40 C.F.R. § 122.3 (1981), for the first time

defines “waters of the United States” to include such

streams. Thus he could be prosecuted although at the time

of his conduct he did not know he was violating the law.

We do not believe our interpretation of the jurisdictional

provisions of the CWA should turn on the situation of a

class such as this. There are certainly few persons in

this position, and perhaps there are none. Furthermore,

it is hardly clear that such polluters would be without

recourse. If they were genuinely caught by surprise when

prosecuted for pollution without a permit, they might

raise the question whether the preclusive review provision,

section 509(b) (2), was unconstitutional as applied to

their special situation.* In a Clean Air Act case, the

Supreme Court was urged to put a narrow construction

on section 307(b) (1), 42 U.S.C. § 7607(b) (1) (Supp. III

1979), which governed court of appeals jurisdiction. It

was urged that a broad construction would be unconstitu-

tional because subsequent review of anything within sec-

tion 307(b) (1) was barred by section 307(b) (2), 42

U.S.C. § 7607(b) (2) (Supp. III 1979). The Court rejected

this argument: “The short answer .. . is that the validity

of § 307 (b) (2) is not at issue here. The constitutional

question raised by the respondents must, therefore, await

another day.” Harrison v. PPG Industries, 446 U.S. 578,

592-93 n.9 (1980). Identical reasoning applies in this

case.”

48 Similarly, one who was unaware of thy CPR’s before

seeking a permit, and who wished to attack them at the permit

stage, might argue the unconstitutionality of § 509(b) (2) as

1® We also note that the Supreme Court has twice interpreted

§ 509(b) (1), and on neither occasion has the Court sug-

A-15

IV.

We hold that the CPR’s are an “effluent limitation or

other limitation” under section 509(b) (1) (E). We reject

industry petitioners’ claim that “due process” requires a

and a constitutional attack on section 509(b) (2) must

await a later day. We have authority to review any

CPR’s that are ripe for review. The motion to dismiss is

denied.

So ordered.

A-16

United States Court of Appeals

For THE District or CotumBia Circult

September Term 1981

No. 80-1607

NATURAL Resources Derense Councit, INC.,

Petitioner,

Vv.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, and M. Gorsucn,

Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,

Respondents.

CHEMICAL MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION, ef al.,

Intervenors.

And Consolidated Case Nos. 80-1660, et ai.

ARGUED 12-15-82

BEFORE: Bazelon, Senior Circuit Judge; Mikva And Ginsburg,

Circuit Judges

ORDER

This matter is before the Court for consideration of the motion to

dismiss filed by Industry Petitioners. On consideration thereof, it is

ORDERED by the Court that the motion to dismiss is denied for the

reasons set forth in the opinion of the Court issued this date.

Per Curiam

United States Court of Appeats FOR THE COURT:

for the Gtstrict of Cohmubie Circatt George A. Fisher,

FILED March 2, 1982 Clerk

mae ea /s/ Ropert A. BONNER

Robert A. Bonner

A-17

List Of Corporate Petitioners’ Parents, Subsidiaries, And Affiliates

Pursuant To Supreme Court Rule 28.1

This list is submitted pursuant to Rule 28.1 of the Supreme Court

Rules.

Corporate Petitioners in Chemical Manufacturers Association, et al.

v. EPA, D.C. Cir. Nos. 81-1570 and 81-1578

AMERICAN CYANAMID COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Arizona Chemical Company

B. Braun-Dexon G.m.b.H.

Brewster Phosphates

Cyanamid Iberica, S.A.

Cyanamid Italia S.p.A.

Cyanamid-Ketjen Katalysator B.V.

CY/RO Industries

Cyanamid (Portugal) Limitada

Cyanamid Taiwan Corporation

Cyanamire S.p.A.

Cyanenka S.A.

Laminate Industries (Pty) Limited

Societe Ananyme Formica

Formica Espanolo S.A.

Lederle (Japan) Lid.

Mitsui-Cyanamid, Ltd.

Sherkat Sahami Cyanamid-KBC

Societe des Sutures Chirurgicales Robert &

Carriere-Lederle

TDF Tiofine B.V.

The Catalyst Company

BORDEN INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Modelos Uki

Bayamon Can Corp., Inc.

Borden Chemical Co. France S.A.

A-18

P. Barnier S.A.

Feslente Boniface SA

Borden U.K. Lid

Borden Espana, S.A.

Borden Int. Pkg. Lid.

Crecspan S.A.

Demer S.A.

Este, S.A.

Gallina Blanca, S.A.

Naturin, S.A.

Promocion deMarcados

Rifacli, S.A.

Klemme GmbH & Co. KG

Borden Int'l. Philippines, Inc.

Feslente Boniface SA

Broex, S.A.

Productors Donita, Inc.

Clover Brand Dairies

Coco Lopez Mfg. Corp.

Alba Nordeste SA Industries Quimicas

Alimentos, S.A.

Borden Chem (M) SNDBHD

Compania Casco §.A.1.C.

Cia Chiricana deLeche

Cia Colombiana de Alimentos Lactos SA

Cia Industrial de Alimentos SA

LasAmigas del Pueblo

Materiales Moldeables S.A. de C.V.

Nassau Dairy Prod. Ltd.

Grand Bahama Dairy Products, Ltd.

Prolesa S.A. de C.V.

Derivados Industriales Veracruzanos SA

Lechas Pasteurizados de Libras S.A.

Productos deLeche SA

Proteinas Lacteas y Alimentos S.A.

Italcolor S.A.

Compania Casco S.A.1L.C.

A-19

Clemco, Inc.

Galloway-West Company, Inc.

Illinois Nitrogen Corporation

Industrias LaFamosa, Inc.

Indulfor S.A.

Produits Lambiotte Freres S.A.

Borden Chem (France)

Societe d’ Application de Flockage

TRL

John Robt. Powers Attractions, Inc.

Kerry Cheese Tek Ltd.

Korea Borden Chusik Holsa

Latin America Agri-business Development Corp.

Indulfor S.A.

Mieji Borden, Inc.

Monochem, Inc.

Nassau Dairy Products

Ecuatoriana S.A.

Quimica Borden SA de CV

Shahdnab Company

Sun-Vue Fertilizers, Inc.

Trinidad Processing Company, Ltd.

The Viking Engraving Corporation

E.1, DU PONT DE NEMOURS & CO.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates '

Airport Limited Partnership

Allied Eneabba Ltd.

Concord Limited Partnership

Desarrollo Quimico Industrial, S.A.

‘In 1981, E.1. du Pont de Nemours & Company acquired Conoco Inc.

The subsidiaries and affiliates of Conoco are listed at Appx A-30-32.

Qe. «=a

A-20

Ducilo S.A.

Du Pont Canada Inc.

Augusta Natural Gas Lid.

Cedarcrest Company Limited

Du Pont Chemicals & Textiles (B.C.) Limited

Du Pont Chemicals & Textiles (Eastern) Limited

Du Pont de Quebec Limitee

Du Pont of Canada Exploration Limited

Ducanex Resources Limited

Twin Peak Resources

Petrosar Limited

Groupement D’Interet Economique Du Pont de Nemours

(France) S.A. et Rhone-Poulenc Industries

Mitsui Fluorochemicals Company, Ltd.

Bontec Company, Ltd

EDOBI

Hiroshima Sekisui

Kyokuto Kobunshi Company, Lid.

Kyushu Taiyo Kasei ——

Showa Neoprene K.K.

Societe En Nom Collectif Du Pont de Nemours (France)

S.A. et Rhone-Poulenc Industries

Syngas Company

Toyo Products Company, Ltd.

Adela Investment Company, S.A.

Conoco-Du Pont Exploration

Conoco-Du Pont Exploration II

Derivados Macroquimicos, S.A.

Derivados Sinteticos, S.A. de C.V.

Gemeinnutzige Wohnungsbau GmbH

Geomina, S.A.

Halocarburos, S.A. de C.V.

A-21

La Dominicia, S.A. de C.V.

Nylon de Mexico, S.A.

Inser, S.A.

Univex, S.A.

Pigmentos y Productos Quimicos, S.A. de C.V.

Inversiones y Terrenos del Golfo, S.A.

Quimica Fluor, S.A. de C.V.

Salgema Industrias Quimicas S.A.

Tetraetilo de Mexico, S.A.

FMC CORPORATION .

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Avicon, Inc.

Chior-Chem, Ltd.

FMC Europe, S.A.

FMC de Mexico, S.A.

FMC Saudi Arabia Limited

Foret, S.A.

Foret Arif Libanaise, S.A.R.L.

Peroxidos Organicos, S.A.

Sibelco Espanola, S.A.

KAISER ALUMINUM & CHEMICAL

CORPORATION

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Alpart Farms (Jamaica), Ltd.

Alumina Partners of Jamaica

Aluminium Bahrain

Aluminium Products Company Limited

Boyne Smelters Limited

Comalco Limited

Gerro Kaiser Dosenwerk GmbH

Grunestucksverwaltungsgesellschaft objekt Wallersheim

Hindustan Aluminium Company Limited

stm

A-22

Kaiser Alluminio Italia S.R.L.

Kaiser TelePrompter of Hawaii, Inc.

Queensland Alumina Holdings N.V.

Volta Aluminium Company Limited

MONSANTO COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Monsanto Company owns 66.5 percent of the voting

power of Fisher Controls International, Inc. All other

subsidiaries, considered in the aggregate as a single

subsidiary, would not constitute a significant

subsidiary. '

NORTHERN PETROCHEMICAL COMPANY

Parent

Internorth Company

PPG INDUSTRIES, INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Duplate Canada Inc.

102957 Canada Limited

' As reported in Monsanto Company's FORM 10-K to the Securities &

Exchange Commission for the fiscal year ended December 31, 1981.

Pittsburgh Corning (United Kingdom) Limited

Pittsburgh Corning Gesellschaft G.m.b.H.

Pittsburgh Corning (Schweiz) AG

Puerto Rico Olefins. Inc.

Pinturas Pittsburgh Iberica, S.A.

Pittsburgh Corning Europe N.V.

Inveca-Pittsburgh C.A.

Vidrio C.A.

Silenka B.V.

Tatung Coatings Co.

Antimony Products (Proprietary) Limited

Woodward lodine

Puerto Rico Olefins I

Glass Plaza Associates

P.D. Glycol

A-24

ROHM AND HAAS COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Indofil Chemicals, Limited

Rohm and Haas Mexico S.A. de C.V.

Curachem

Japan Acrylic Chemical Co., Ltd.

The Shipley Company

Tokyo Organic Chemical Industries Limited

Quimica Trepic, S.A.

Yugocry!

STAUFFER CHEMICAL COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Cornwall Chemicals, Limited

Derivados Macroquimicos, S.A.

Electroquimica Potosi, S.A.

Fluorex, S.A.

Halocarburos, S.A.

Industrias Quimicas de Mexico, S.A.

Industrias Quimicas Serpiol, S.A.

Kali-Chemie Stauffer G.m.b.H.

Kashima Industries Company

Limanol, S.A.

Montrose Chemical Corporation of California

Mount Pleasant Chemical Company

Promotora, 1.Q.S.A.

Quimica Lucava, S.A.

SWS Silicones Corporation

Stauffer Chemical Company (New Zealand), Limited

Stauffer Chemical Company of Wyoming

Stauffer Rioplatense S.A.1.C.

Texas Alkyls Belgium, S.A.

A-25

Texas Alkyls, Inc.

Toyo-Stauffer Chemical Co., Ltd.

THE B.F. GOODRICH COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

B.F. Goodrich Chemical de Venezuela C.A.

B.F. Goodrich Australia Lid.

E.P.P.C. Polyplastic S.A.

Industria Colombiana de Liantas, S.A.

Japan Power Brake, Inc.

Policyd, S.A.

Compania Hulera Euzkadi, S.A.

Lima Caucho Co., S.A.

Philippine Viny! Consortium, Inc.

Mobex Corp.

Fosroc/Tremco

Verfygungsmitten Handelsgesellachaft MBH

LIM-Holding S.A.

THE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Goodyear Canada Inc.

Goodyear India Limited

Goodyear Jamaica Limited

Goodyear Lastikleri Turk Anonim Sirketi

Goodyear Malaysia Berhad

Good yoer Maroc 2 S.A.

Goodyear Taiwan Limited

Goodyear (Thailand) Limited

P.T. Goodyear Indonesia

The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company of the

Philippines, Ltd.

GranIndustria de Neumaticos Centroamericana, S.A.

Toyobo Petcord Co. Limited

Goodyear Bendel Rubber Processing Co.

A-26

UNION CARBIDE CORPORATION

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

ACM Services

P.T. Agrocarb Indonesia

Argon, S.A.

Arizona Welding Equipment Co.

Bayox Inc.

Biosystemes S.A.

Calida Gas B.V.

Carbide Hashim Industrial Gas Co. Ltd.

Chemos Industries Pty. Ltd.

Chrome Corporation (South Africa) (Pty) Ltd.

Cia National de Calcareos e Derivados

Dai Nippon Jushi Co. Ltd.

Delvan Pty. Ltd.

Electrona Carbide Industries Pty. Ltd.

Elektrode Maatskapy Van Suid Africa (Eiendoms) Beperk

Eletro Manganes Ltda.

Eletrometalurgica Suadade Lida.

General Welding Products, Inc.

Indugas N.V.

Joint Industries (Hycel) 1970 Ltd

Karaj Road Property Co. Ltd.

P.T. Karmi Arafura Fisher.es

La Littorale S.A.

Miami Welding Supply, Inc.

Nippon Unicar Co.

Oriental Union Chemical Corp.

Oxigenio Edy S.A.

Oxigeno Del Norte, S.A.

Oy Unifos A.B.

Rodval S.A.

Societe Gabonaise Des Ferro-Alliages

Societe Miniere de Tambao S.A.

Sony-Eveready Inc.

Svenska Vicora Aktiebolaget

Tennigasco Gas Gathering Co.

we,

A-27

Tubatse Ferrochrome (Pty.) Ltd.

ina Desenvolvimento de Industrias Minerais Ltda.

Tungstenio do Brasil Minerios e Metais Ltda.

Ucar Plastics Ghana Ltd.

Unifos Kemi A.B.

Union Carbide Argentina S.A.1.C.S.

Union Carbide Australia & New Zealand Ltd.

Union Carbide Austrailia Ltd.

Union Carbide Canada Ltd.

Union Carbide Ceylon Ltd.

Union Carbide Egypt S.A.E.

Union Carbide France, S.A.

Union Carbide Ghana Ltd.

Union Carbide Kenya Ltd.

Union Carbide Malaysia Sdn. Bhd.

Union Carbide Mexican, S.A.

Union Carbide New Zealand Ltd.

Union Carbide Nigeria Ltd.

Union Carbide Pakistan Ltd.

Union Carbide Sudan Ltd.

Union Carbide Yemen Ltd.

Union Gas Co. Ltd.

Union Industrial Gas Corp.

Union Polymers Sdn. Bhd.

Union Showa K.K.

Viscora (Deutschland) G.m.b.H.

Viscora Italiana

Viscora, S.A.

Viskase Ltd.

Visking do Brasil S.A.

Sociedad Anomima White Martins

S.A. White Martins Nordeste

Wimpey Unox Ltd.

A-28

Corporate Petitioners in American Iron & Steel institute, et al. v.

EPA, D.C. Cir. Nos. 81-1576 and 81-1746'

ARMCO INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Oregon Metallurgical Corporation

JONES & LAUGHLIN STEEL CORPORATION, a

division of JONES & LAUGHLIN STEEL

INCORPORATED

Parent

The LTV Corporation

Corporate Petitioners in American Petroluem Institute, et al. v.

EPA, D.C. Cir. Nos. 81-1577 and 81-1709'

ATLANTIC RICHFIELD COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Hardy Oil Company

Sinclair Venezuelan Oil Company

Anaconda Iron Ore (Ontario) Limited

Bingham Development Company

Caribou-Chaleur Bay Mines Ltd.

Caribou-Smith Mines Ltd.

Chile Copper Company

' The above list includes only publicly-held domestic subsidiaries and

affiliates. Some of the nine corporate petitioners in American Iron & Steel

Institute v. EPA may have non-publicly-held or foreign affiliates and sub-

sidiaries. A list of these companies is available upon request.

' The listing includes petitioners’ parent companies and publicly-traded

West Mayflower Mining Company

Badger Pipe Line Company

Blair Athol Coal Pty. Ltd.

Compania de Petroleo Ganso Azul, Ltda.

Compania Mexicana de Petroleo “El Charro”, S.A.

Flower Street Lid.

Gravity Adjustment Inc.

Hydrokem Performance Chemicals Company

Iricon Agency Ltd.

Kenai Pipe Line Company

R.W. Miller (Holdings) Limited

Montoro, Empresa Para La Industria Quimica, S.A.

The Observer Magazine Limited

Platte Pipe Line Company

Sao Raimundo Agroindustrial Ltda.

Sinclair Venezuela Oil Company

Tecumseh Pipe Line Company

Texas, New Mexico Pipe Line Company

Alyeska Pipeline Service Company

Colonial Pipeline Company

Cook Inlet Pipeline Company

Delaware Bay Transportation Company

Dixie Pipeline Company

East Texas Salt Water Disposal Company

Lavan Petroleum Company

Oil Shippers Service, Inc.

Trans Mountain Oil Pipe Line Company

A-30

CHEVRON U.S.A., INC.

Parent

Standard Oil Company of California

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

AMAX Inc.

Cetus Corporation

Huntington Beach Company

Kentucky Agricultural Energy Corporation

Long Beach Oil Development Company

Rimbeg Pipe Line Co., Ltd.

Wind Farms Ltd.

CONOCO INC.

Parent

E.1. du Pont de Nemours & Company

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A/S Soties Plass 2

Associated Petroleum Terminals Ltd.

Big Sky of Montana Realty, Inc.

Bishop Coal Company

Carbon Black Espanola, S.A.

Cardinal River Coals, Ltd.

Cit-Con Oil Corporation

Cliffe Storage Ltd.

Compagnie Francaise du Carbon Black, S.A.

Conch L.N.G.

Condea Chemie, GmbH

Conoco Exploration, Ltd.

Conrhein Coal Co.

Continental Columbia Carbon Nederland, B.V.

A-31

Contochu, Inc.

Crude Oil Terminals (Humber) Lid.

Explorer Pipeline Company

Felix Oil Company

Harmar Coal Company

Humber Oil Terminals Trustee Ltd.

Iranian Investment Corp.

Iranian Oil Services (Holdings) Ltd.

Iricon Agency, Ltd.

Itmann Coal Company

K/s Statfjord Transport A.S. & Co.

Kettleman North Dome Association

Lake Charles Pipe Line

Long Beach Oil Development Company

Maritime Protection (PTE) Ltd.

Maritime Protection Inc.

Mathies Coal Company

Neptune Bulk Terminals (Canada) Limited

Nippon Aluminum Alkyls, Ltd.

Nissan Conoco Corporation (CONSAN)

Oasis Oil Co. of Libya, Inc.

Oil Shippers Service, Inc.

OMW (Oberrheinische Mineraloelwerke GmbH)

Pasa Petroquimica Argentina, S.A.

Petrocokes, Lid.

Petroleum Storage Ltd.

Petroleum Terminals, Inc.

Petroquimica Espanola, S.A. (PETRESA)

Pioneer Pipe Line Company

Platte Pipe Line

Seadock, Inc.

Seaway Pipeline, Inc.

Selang Ltd.

Southern Facilities, Inc.

ea

A-32

Statfjord Transport A.S.

Stavangereske Westamarine A/S

Sulitjelma Elektronikk A/S

T.A.L.

T.A.L. (Austria)

T.A.L. (Italy)

T.A.L. (Luxembourg)

Texas Offshore Port, Inc.

The Standard Shale Products Company

Tidelands Royalty Trust

Tongue River Holdings, Inc.

Tongue River Railroad

Toyo Continental Carbon, Ltd.

Union National Bank Building

Warwickshire Oil Storage Ltd.

West Shore Pipe Line

Westmarin A/S

Yellowstone Pipe Line

EXXON CORPORATION

(identified in the court below as Exxon Company, U.S.A., a

division of Exxon Corporation

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Imperial Oil Limited

Reliance Electric Company

Exxon Pipeline Company

GETTY OIL CORPORATION

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A-33

Northern Tier Pipeline Company

Osage Pipe Line Company

Texoma Pipe Line Company

Vancouver Plywood Co., Inc.

Crescent Petroleum

Mitsubishi Oil Company, Limited

Iricon Agency Ltd.

Texas-New Mexico Pipeline Company

Tide Water Oil Company (India) Limited

Yong-Nam Chemical Company, Ltd.

Dieter Pohimann & Co.

Butte Pipeline Company

Canadian Reserve Oil and Gas Ltd.

Gibson Holdings, Ltd.

Gibson Petroleum Ltd.

Halbouty Alaska Oil Company

Wascana Pipe Line Inc.

Wascana Pipe Line Ltd.

Chisholm Pipeline Company

GULF OIL CORPORATION

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Gulf Canada Limited

China Gulf Plastics Corporation

Asia Polymer Corporation

Chinhac Chemical Company, Ltd.

Plastgama S.A.

Taiwan VCM Industries Corporation

Bioresearch Center Company, Ltd.

Laurel Pipe Line Company

Platte Pipe line Company

Venezuela Gulf Refining Company

West Texas Gulf Pipe Line Company

A/S Jargul

A/S Jargul and Co. K/S

AB Djurgardsberg

A-34

Adela Investment Company, S.A.

Allied-General Nuclear Services (partnership)

Andogas S.A.

Autobahn-Raststaette Wurenlos Ag.

China Guif Oil Company Limited

Colonial Pipeline Company

Compagnie D' Investissement Bustinbles De Reacteurs A

Haute Tp.

“Condor” Industria Quimica, S.A.

Delaware Bay Transportation Company

Det Gronlandske Olieakieselskab

Dixie Pipeline Company

Eastern Venezuelan Gas Transport Company

Ethyleen Pijpleiding Maatschappij (Belgium) S.A.

Ethyleen Pijpleiding Maatschappij (Nederland) B.V.

_ Explorer Pipeline Company

General Atomic Company (partnership)

Gulf Canada Resources Inc.

Gulf Oil Zaire S.A.R.L.

Harshaw-Murata Kabushika Kaisha

Harshaw Galvanotecnia S.A.

Harshaw-Juarez S.A. de C.V.

A-35

SAKNO S.p.A.

Societe de Combustible Pour Reacteurs A Haute

Temperature (Corhat)

Svensk Petroleum Administration A.B.

ae een ay

Petroleum Terminals, Incorporated

The Airport Company of Hilton Head Island, Inc.

Arctic LNG Transportation Co.

Automotive Fuel Corporation

Automotive Fuel Corporation of Delaware, Inc.

Badger Pipe Line Company

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Alabama

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Arkansas

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Georgia

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of lowa

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Kansas

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Mississippi

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Missouri

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Nebraska

Cheker-Imperial Oil Co. of Tennessee

Cheker Oil Company

Cheker Oil Company of Delaware, Inc.

Cheker Oil Company of Florida, Inc.

Cheker Oil Company of Indiana, Inc.

Cheker Oil company of Michigan, Inc.

A-36

Cheker Oil Company of Ohio, Inc.

Cheker Oil Company of Wisconsin, Inc.

City Point Oil Terminal, Inc.

Cook Inlet Pipe Line Co.

Dor Rae Realty, Ltd.

Ecol, Inc. (Mississippi)

Explorer Pipeline Company

Globe Oil Company, U.S.A.

Graveap, Inc.

Green Bay Terminal Corp.

Hilton Head Island Realty, Inc.

Hilton Head Management Co.., Inc.

A-37

Societa Italiana per !"Oleodotto Transalpino, S.p.A.

Transalpine Finance Holdings S.A.

Adria-Wien Pipeline Gesellschaft m.b.H.

AIMCO (ALPHA) Shipping Company

AIMCO (OMEGA) Shipping Company Ltd.

Aircraft Fuel Supply B.V.

Airtankdienst Koln

AK Chemie GmbH

AK Chemie GmbH & Co KG

Akauma Rekisei Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha

Alexandroupolis Petroleum Installation S.A.

Allied Asphalts Limited

Alpa Alet Ve Dayanikli Tuketim Mamulleri Pazarlama

A.S.

Altona Petrochemical Company Limited

' Mobil Oil Corporation is a wholly owned subsidiary of Mobil Corpora-

tion which is publicly held. Listed above are the affiliates and subsidiaries of

sidiaries which are or may be publicly held. For purposes of this list only

companies in which a five percent (5%) or greater interest is held are

considered.

A-38

Alyeska Pipeline Service Company

Ankara Gaz Satis Anonim Sirketi

Arabian American Oil Company

Arabian International Maritime Company Limited

Arabian International Maritime Company

The Arabian Petroleum Supply Company (S.A.)

Arabian Shipping & Trading Company S.A.

Aral Aktiengesellschaft

A/S Fjelivegen

A/S Kongens Plass |

A/S Moretral

Ammenn GmbH

The Associated Octel Company Limited

Associated Octel Company (Plant) Limited

ATAS-Anadolu Tesfiyehanesi Anonim Sirketi

Atlas Sahara S.A.

Australasian Petroleum Company Proprietary Limited

Australian Synthetic Rubber Company Limited

Autobahn-Betriebe Gesellschaft m.b.H.

Aviation Fuel Services Limited

A-39

Cartoenvases Valencia, S.A.

Carton de Colombia, S.A.

Carton de Venezuela, S.A.

Cartones Nationales, S.A.

Celulosa y Papel de Columbia, S.A.

Central African Petroleum Refineries (Pvt) Limited

Cercera S.A.

Changi Airport Fuel Hydrant Installation Pte. Ltd.

Colombianos Distribuidores de Combustibles, S.A.

(CODI

Colonial Pipeline Company

Combustibles Colmerauer

Comet-Brennstoffdienst GmbH

Comex-Seal France S.A.

Comex-Seal Guernsey Ltd.

Comex-Seal Limited

Comex-Seal U.K. Limited

Comex-Seal U.S. Corporation

Commodore Maritime Company, S.A.

Compagnie Africaine de Transport Cameroun

Compagnie D’Entreposage Communautaire

Compagnie Immobiliere (Comimmo)

Compagnie Regionale de Distribution de Produits

Petroilers-C.O.R.E. Dis.

Compagnie Rhenane de Raffinage

Compagnie Senegalaise des Lubrifiants (C.S.L.)

Compania Colombiana de Empaques Bates, SSA

Compania de Lubricants de Chile Limitada (Copec-Mobil

Ltda.)

Compania Mexicana de Especialidades Industriales, S.A.

de C.V.

Consortium Raymond Duez

Constructora Calle 70 S.A.

Cook Inlet Pipe Line Comp:

CORCOP

A-40

Corrugaiora de Carton, S.A.

C.R.C. Lyon Chauffage

CRCP

Cyprus Petroleum Refinery Limited

D. Muhlenbruch GmbH

D. Muhlenbruch GmbH & Co. KG

Dai Nippon Jushi K.K.

De. Ba. Deposito di Bari S.p.A.

Depot Petrolier de Mourepiane

Depot Petrolier du Gresivaudan

Depot de Petrole Cotiers

Depots Petroliers de La Corse (DPLC)

Deutsche Mobil Oil Exploration Ireland Ltd.

Deutsche Pentosin- Werke GmbH

Deutsche Transalpine Oelleitung GmbH

Dicomi S.r.1.

Disie Pipeline Company

Drivmedelscentralen AB

Dukhan Services Company

East Japan Oil Development Company Ltd.

Eastern Lease Company Ltd.

Emoieum (Asphalts) Limited

Entrepot Petrolier de Chambery

Entrepot Petrolier de Dijon

Entrepot Petrolier de Mulhouse (E.P.M.)

Entrepot Petrolier de Nancy

Entreprise Jean Lefebvre

Erdgas- Verkaufs-Gesellschaft mbH

Erdoel-Lagergesellschaft mbH

Erdoel-Raffinerie Neustadt GmbH & Co. oHG

Erdoelbetrieb Reitbrook

Erdoelraffinerie Gesellschaft mbH in Liquidation

Establissments Bouthenet

Establissments Nicol and Cie

Faavang Autoverksted A/S

FACEL

Fairwind Maritime Company, S.A.

Felix Oil Company

A-4l

Filtroleo-Sociedade Portuguesa de Filtros Lda.

Filtros De Costa Rica S.A.

Finsbury Printing Limited

Fountain Garage (East Park) Ltd.

Fountain Garage (Meadowhead) Ltd.

Fountain Garage (Mercury) Ltd.

Fountain Garage (Newbury Park) Ltd.

Fountain Garage (Stirchley) Ltd.

Frome-Broken Hill Company Proprietary Limited

Fruehmesser mineraloelhandels GmbH & Co. KG

Fruehmesser GmbH

Fuso Operations Kabushiki Kaisha

Futuro Enterprises (Christchurch) Ltd.

Futuro Homes (N.Z.) Ltd.

Gaz Aletleri Anonim Sirketi

Geomines-Caen

Geovexin

Ghana Bunkering Services Limited

Goteborgs Branslesortering AB

Groupement Immobilier Petrolier G.1.P.

Groupement Petrolier Aviation G.P.A.

Groupement Petrolier De Brest (GPB)

Handelmaatschappij Jugenholtz & Co. B.V.

Heizoel-Handelsgessellschaft mbH

Hellas Gas Storage Company S.A.

Highgate Associates, Ltd.

Home Counties Petroleum Products Limited

Hormoz Petroleum Company

Hydranten-Betriebs-Gesellschaft, Flughafen Frankfurt

Imperial Gas Co. of P.R., Inc.

Industria de Carbon del Valle Cauca, S.A.

Iranian Oil Participants Limited

Iranian Oil Services (Holdings) Limited

Iranian Oil Services Limited

Iraq Petroleum Company, Limited

Iraq Petroleum Pensions Limited

Iraq Petroleum Transport Company Limited

Island Exploration Company Proprietary Limited

A-42

Istanbul Petrol ve Makine Yasglari Limited Sirketi

Japan Airport Fueling Service Co. Limited

Japan Solar Energy Co., Ltd.

J.E.C.0.P.

K.K. Sankyo Plastics

K.K. Toresen

Kanto Kyguns Sekiyu Hambai K.K.

Kanto Oil Pipeline Co., Ltd.

Kawasaki Kygnus Sekiyu Hambai Kabushiki Kaisha

Keihin Kygnus Sekiyu Hambai Kabushiki Kaisha

Keiyo Sea-Berth Company, Limited

Kettleman North Dome Association

Klaus Koehn GmbH

Klaus Koehn GmbH & Co. Mineraloel KG

Kobe Port Service Kabushiki Kaisha

Kurt Ammenn GmbH & Co. K.G.

Kygnus Ekika Gas Kabushiki Kaisha

Kygnus Kosan Kabushiki Kaisha

Kygnus Sekiyu Kabushiki Kaisha

Kyokyto Petroleum Services Overseas, Ltd.

Kyokuto Sekiyu Services Overseas, Ltd.

Kyokuto Sekiyu Kogyo Kabuchiki Kaisha

Les Nouveaux Comptoirs Petroliers

Les Supermarches De Cote D'Ivoire

Kikit Petrol Gazi ve Yakit Ticaret A.S.

Lubricants del Sur, S.A.

Marceaux & Cie

Matco Tankers (U.K.) Limited

Maury Manufacturing Company, Inc.

Mediterrenean Refining Company

Meentzen & Franke GmbH & Co.

Mobil Ami, S.A.

Mobil Atlas Sociedad Anonima de Capital Variable

Mobil Chemie Belgie N.V. and Mobil Chimie Belge S.A.

Mobil Comercio, Industria e Servicos Ltda.

Mobil Gaz-Mobil Petrol Gazlari Anonim Sirketi

Mobil Motor Rest AG

A-43

Mobil Oil Angola, SARL

Mobil Oil Cameroun

Mobil Oil Cote d'Ivoire

Mobili Oil Dahomey

Mobil Oil Djibouti, S.A.

Mobil Oil Gabon

Mobil Oil Ghana Limited

Mobil Oil Haute Volta

Mobil Oil Holdings, S.A.

Mobil Oil Mali

Mobil Oil Maroc

Mobil Oil Niger

Mobil Oil Nigeria Limited

Mobil Oil Nord-Africaine

Mobil Oil Philippines Inc.

Mobil Oil Portuguesa, S.A.R.L.

Mobil Oil Rwanda-Burundi (S.A.R.L.)

Mobil Oil Senegal

Mobil Oil Tchad

Mobil Oil Togo

Mobilrex

Mobil Tunisie

Mobil Tyco Solar Energy Corporation

Molinos de Carton y Papel, S.A.

Morem

Mosul Petroleum Company Limited

Motel Rest SA

Mt. Marrow Blue Metal Quarries Pty.

Ndola Oil Storage Company Limited

Near East Development Corporation

New Zealand Refining Company Limited, The

New Zealand Synthetic Fuels Corp. Ltd.

Nichimo Sekiyu Seisei Kabushiki Kaisha

Nippon Unicar Company Limited

Norddeutsche Erdgas-Aufbereitungs GmbH

Nordic Storage Company Ltd.

A-44

N.V. Rotterdam-Rijn Pijpleiding Maatschappij

N.V. Socony-Standard-Vacuum Oil Company

Occidental de Empaques, Ltda.

Octel Associates

Octel S.A.

Oil Kol (Proprietary) Limited

Oil Service Company of Iran (Private Company)

Oldenburgische Erdvel Gesellschaft mit beschrankter

Haftung

Olympic Pipe Line Company

Osage Pipe Line Company

P.T. Arun Natural Gas Liquefaction Company

P.T. Stanvac Indonesia

Petrogas Processing Ltd.

Petroleum Development (Cyprus) Limited

Petroleum Refineries (Australia) Proprietary Limited

Petroleum Services (Middle East) Limited

Petromin-Mobil Yanbu Refinery Company Ltd.

Pipe-Lines de la Pallice

Plegadizos para la Industria S.A.

Poly Oil Chimie (P.O.C.)

Qatar Petroleum Company Limited

Qualbank, Inc.

Rainbow Pipe Line Company, Ltd.

Randhurst Corporation

Reforestadora Andina, S.A.

Samarco (Alpha) Shipping Company

Samarco (Beta) Shipping Company

Sanwa Kasei Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha

SARL Garage Pineau

Sarni S.p.A.

Sa» ‘i Arabian Maritime Company

Saudi Can Company, Ltd., The

Saudi Chemicas! Industries Company Limited

Saudi Maritime Company Ltd.

Saudi Tankers Limited

Saudi, Yanbu Petrochemical Company

Schubert Kommanditgesellschaft

S.C.1. Du Fonds Du Val

Seal Participants (Holdings) Limited

Segher de Mexico, S.A. de C.V.

Seibu Kygnus Sekiyu Hambai Kabushiki Kaisha

SENERCO

Seram Societa per Azioni (S.p.A.)

Sierra Leone Petroleum Refining Company Limited, The

R. Simonnet & CIE

Sociedade Portugal Marrocos SARL

Societa Italiana per |'Oleowsto Transalpino, S.p.A.

Societe Africaine de Raffinage

Societe Agicole Des Entreprises Petrolieres (S.A.D.E.P.)

Societe Anonyme Etablissments Nicol and Cie

Societe Belge de Transport par Pipeline S.A.

Societe Camerounaise des Depots Petroliers (S.C.D.P.)

Societe Camerounaise Equatoriale De Fabrication De

Lubrifiants “S.C.E.F.L.”

Societe Civile de Mustapha

A-46

Societe Civile Immobiliere Courcelles-Etoile

Societe Civile Immobiliere de Construction de 34 Avenue

du General Leclerc a Boissy-St-Leger

Societe Civile Immobiliere de Construction “La Residence

Brune”

Societe Civile Immobiliere du 10 Bd. de la Republique A

La Garenne-Colombes

Societe Civile Immobiliere Kleber-Etoile

Societe Civile Immobiliere La Fontaine Saint Lucien

Societe Civile Immobiliere Mobil

Societe Dahomeenne d’Entreposage de Produits Petroliers

Societe d’Arement Fluvial et Maritime “SOFLUMAR”

Societe de Construction & de Gestion CB 12

Societe de Distribution Castelroussine (SODICA)

Societe de Gaz D’Oceanic (SOGADOC)

Societe de Manutention de Carburants Aviation

(S.M.C.A.)

Societe de Manutention de Carburants Aviation

Dakar- Y off

Societe de Manutention de Carburants Aviation de Tahiti

(SOMCAT)

Societe de Maperizlx d’Etancheite Pour Le Entreprises

(Meple)

Societe d’Entreposage de Bobo-Dioulasso (S.E.B.)

Societe d’Entreposage de San Pedro (SESP)

Societe d’Entreposage Petrolier au Burundi

Societe de Renovation D’Emballages Metalliques (REM)

Societe d’Habitations a Loyer Modere de la Seine

Maritime

Societe des Bitumes et Cut-Backs du Cameroun

Societe des Establissments Goux

Societe Des Huiles Lemahieu

Societe de Pipe-Line Sud-Europeen

Societe Francaise Stoner-Mudge

Societe Gabonaise d’Entreposage de Produits Petroliers

Societe Gabonaise de Raffinage

Societe Industrielle des Asphaltes et Petroles de Lattaquie

(Syrie) S.A.

A-47

Societe Ivoirienne de Fabrication de Lubrifiants

(S.L.F.A.L.)

Societe Ivoirienne de Raffinage

Societe Mauritanienne d’Entreposage de Produits

Petroliers

Societe Nationale de Raffinage (Sonora)

Societe Nouvelle Raffinereie Meridionale De Ceresines

(RMC)

Societe Novodis

Societe Pizo De Formulation De Lubrifiants (PIZOLUB)

Societe Regionale De Produits Petroliers

Societe Regionale de Produits Energetiques

Societe Tahitienne de Depots Petroliers

Societe Tchadienne D’Sntreposage de Produits Petroliers

Societe Togolaise d’Entreposage (STE)

SOMODIP

Sonarep (South Africa) (Proprietary) Limited

SONEX

South African Oil Refinery (Proprietary) Limited

South Saskatchewan Pipe Line Company

South West Africa Road Binders (Proprietary) Limited

Statfjord Transport A.S.

SStation-Service Lunes

Sydney Metropolitan Pipeline Pty. Ltd.

Syria Petroleum Company Limited

T.R. Miller Mill Company, Inc.

Tanklagergesellschaft Koln-Bonn

Tecklenburg GmbH

Tecklenburg GmbH * Co.Energiebedarf K.G.

Texoma Pipe Line Company

Thailand Lubricant Products Limited

Thailand Solvent Products, Ltd.

Thums Long Beach Company

Toa Nenryo Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha

Tohko Plastics Co., Ltd.

Tonen Energy International Corp.

Tonen Sekiyu Kagaku Kabushiki Kaisha

Tonen Tanker Kabushiki Kaisha

A-48

Tonen Technology Kabushiki Kaisha

Total Centrafricaine de Gestion (TOCAGES)

Toulouse-Distribution Produits Petroliers

Toyoshina Film Co., Ltd.

Tradewind Maritime Co., S.A.

Transalpine Finance Holdings S.A.

Transalpine Oelleitung in Oesterreich Gessellschaft

m.b.H.

Trans-Arabian Pipe Line Company

Transgas Umschlags-Lager-Und Transport Gesellschaft

MbH

Turkish Petroleum Company Limited

Twifo Oil Plantations Ltd.

UBAG Unterflur Betankungsanlage Flughafen Zurich

Union Grafica, S.A.

United Kingdom Oil Pipelines Limited

VOSACEC, S.P.A.

W.A.G. Pipeline Pty. Lid.

Wako Kasei Kabushiki Kaisha

Wakohjushi Kabushiki Kaisha

Werner Weidemann Mineraloelvertrieb G.m.b.H.

West Shore Pipe Line Company

Wolverine Pipe Line Company

Wyco Pipe Line Company

PHILLIPS PETROLEUM COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Company

Bonny LNG Ltd. (P.P. Worldwide Gas Ltd.)

Bruin Carbon Dioxide Sales Corporation

A-49

Calatrava Empresa Para la Industria Petroquimica, S.A.

Canada Western Cordage Co., Lid.

Canyon Reef Carriers Inc.

Phillips Carbon Black Company (Pty.) Ltd.

Phillips Carbon Black Italiana S.p.A.

Phillips Carbon Black Limited

Phillips Gas Supply Corporation

Phillips Imperial Petroleum Limited

Phillips Pacific Chemical Company

Phillips Petroleum Singapore Chemicals (Private) Limited

Philmac Oils Limited

Plasticos Vanguardia S.A.

Polar | NG Shipping Corporation

Polyolefins

Powder River Corporation

Renolit Fertighaus GmbH

A-50

Seadock, Inc.

Sevalco (Holdings) Limited

Societe De Developpement Des Polyolefins

Transatlantic Reinsurance

Trenwick Lid.

Western Desert Operating Petroleum Company

White River Shale Oil Corporation

SHELL OIL COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Basin Pipe Line System

Bullenbay Marine Services, N.V.

Butte Pipe Line Company

Capline System

Capwood Pipe Line System

Crown-Shell Baytown Feeder Line System

Curacao Oil Terminal N.V.

Dixie Pipeline Company

East Texas Salt Water Disposal Company

A-5l >

Thums Long Beach Company

West Shore Pipe Line Company

Wolverine Pipe Line Company "

STANDARD OIL COMPANY (INDIANA)

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

TEXACO INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

New Zealand Refining Company Limited, The

South Africa Oil Refinery (Proprietary) Ltd.

Batangas Land Company Inc.

Changi Airport Fuel Hydrant Installation Pte. Lid.

Ndola Oil Storage Company Limited

Central African Petroleum Refineries (Private) Ltd.

East African Oil Refineries Limited

H. C. Sleigh Limited

Societe Malgache de Raffinage

Societe Reunionnaise d'Entroposage (S.R.E.)

Cia. Refinadora Petrolera Santo Domingo Inc.

Deutsche Transalpine Ollejtung GmbH

A-52

Forenade Syenska Oljeimportorers AB

Frevlig A.G.

Gas Natural Colombiana S.A.

Ghana Bunkering Services Limited

Iranian Oil Participants Limited

Iranian Oil Services (Holdings) Limited

Irish Refining Company Limited

Maghreb Gaz S.A.

Mainline Pipelines Limited

Miland Ariport Refueling Services, S.p.A. (MARS)

Mitsui- Texaco Chemicals Co., Ltd.

Montreal Pipe Line Company Limited

N.V. Rotterdam Rijn Pijpleiding Maatschappij

Oberheinische Mineralolwerke G.m.b.H.

Pars Investment Corporation

Pipelines of Puerto Rico, Inc., The

Raffinerie du Sud-Quest S.A.

Refinery Services Company S.A.

Rheem del Eduador C.A.

Rhein-Mein Rohrleitungstransportgesellschaft m.b.H.

Societa Italiana per |’Oleodotto Transalpino S.p.A.

Societa per Azioni Raffineria Padana Olii Minerali

(SARPOM)

Societe Africaine de Raffinage S.A. (SAR)

Societe Anonyme de la Raffinereie des Antilles (SARA)

Societe D’Entreposage de Bobo-Dioulasso

Societe Camerounaise d’Entreposage (SCE)

Societe Dakaroise d’Entreposage S.A. (SDE)

Societe d’Entreposage de San Pedro S.A. (SESP)

£ ciete d’Entreposage Petrolier au Burundi S.A.R.L.

(SEP-BURUNDI)

Societe De ManutentionDes Carburants Aviation Dakar

Yoff (SMACADY)

Societe Gabonaise de Raffinage (SOGARA)

A-53

Societe Gabonaise d’Entreposage du Produits Petroliers

S.A. (STEPP)

Societe Togalaise d’Entreposage S.A. (STE)

Svensk Petroleum Forvaltning Aktiebolag

Tankanglage AG Ruemlang (TAR)

Texaco Mexicana, S.A.

Transalpine Finance Holdings S.A.

Transalpine Olleitung in Osterreich GmbH

Trinidad Asphalt Holdings Limited

Trinidad Northern Areas Limited

Trintovac Developments Limited

Refineria Texaco de Honduras, S.A.

Texaco Agro-Industrial (Nigeria) Limited

Quimica Industrial “FIDES” Ss. A.

Texaco Canada Inc.

Public Fuel Transmission Systems Limited

Great Eastern Oil & Import Co. Limited, The

Texaco Norway A/S

Deutsche Texaco Aktiengesellschaft

Texaco Portugal Prospeccaoe Producao, S.A.R.L.

Texaco North Sea Norway A/S

Texaco Gabon

Texaco Togo

Zaire-Texaco S.A.R.L.

Texaco Nigeria Limited

Texaco-Cities Service Pipe Line Company

Tadlagaz S.A.

American Overseas Petroleum Limited

Bunkerservice Brunsbuttel G.m.b.H.

Societe Ivoirienne De Futs et D'Emballages

(SOGUILUBE) (See Texaco Africa Lid.)

Caltex Petroleum Corporation

Australian Lubricating Oil Refinery Limited

Phoenicia Oil Company S.A.L.

Botany Bay Tanker Company (Australia) Pty. Limited

Sydney Metropolitan Pipeline Pty. Limited

Koa Oil Company, Limited

A-54

Mediterranean Refining Company

Nippon Petroleum Refining Company, Ltd.

Tokyo Tanker Company, Limited

Caltex Deutschland G.m.b.H.

Caltex Mediterranean Limited

Condea Chemie G.m.b.H.

Federated Pipe Lines Lid.

Flexibox G.m.b.H.

LPG de Panama, S.A.

Pembroke Capital Company Inc.

P.T. Caltex Pacific Indonesia

Pev ogas, S.A.

Texaco Maroc

Societe Ivoirienne D’ Avitaillements Portuaires (S.1.A.P.)

Societe Ivoirienne D’Entrepasage De Produits Petroliers

(S.LE.P.P.)

Badger Pipe Line Company

Bayonne Industries, Inc.

Canyon Reef Carriers, Inc.

Colonial Pipeline Company

Coltexo Corporation

Dixie Pipeline Company

Explorer Pipeline Company

Felix Oil Company

Kaw Pipe Line Company

Laurel Pipe Line Company

LOCAP Inc.

LOOP Inc.

Olympic Pipe Line Company

Portland Pipe Line Corporation

Texas-New Mexico Pipe Line Company

THUMS Long Beach Company

West Shore Pipe Line Company

Wolverine Pipe Line Company

Wyco Pipe Line Company

Aircraft Fuel Supply B.V.

Airport Refueling Services S.p.A.

Aktiebolaget Svensk Petroleumlagring

A-55

United Kingdom Oil Pipelines Limited

Unterflur Betankungsanlage A.G. (UBAG)

West Australian Natural Gas Pty. Limited

Zaire Services des Entreprises Petrolieres (Zaire S.E.P.)

Aktiebol Dj ist

Association Petroliere Belge

Aviation Fueling Services, S.A.

Aviation Service Center

Compagnie Entreposage Communautaire

Singapore Refining Company Private Limited

Societe Belge de Transport Par Pipeline S.A.

Societe de Cabotage Petrolier S.A.

Societe du Pipeline Sud-European S.A.

Societe Nationale de Raffinage

Svensk Petroleumadministration AB

Total Centrafricaine de Gestion

Societe Agricole des Enterprises Petrolieres

Union des Raffineurs Belges

Svensk Petroleumlargring Tre Aktienbolag

Societe Cameranaise des Depots Petroleirs (SCDP)

TNPL

AK Chemie GmbH & Co. KG

Bergemann KG

Braunkohle-Benzin AG

Knoops & Muller Mineralolhandel GmbH

Karlsruhe-Stuttgart Rohrleitung GmbH

Bremer Mineralolhandel GmbH

Dannenberg & Co. Mineralolhandel GmbH

Mdina Weave Ltd.

W. Knierim & Co. Mineralolhaldel GmbH

Boske & Co. Mineralolhandel GmbH

HoeTex Beteiligungsgellschaft mbH

Bayonne Industries, Inc.

Canyon Reef Carriers, Inc.

Colonial Pipeline Company

Coltexo Corporation

Dixie Pipeline Company

Explorer Pipeline Company

A-56

Felix Oil Company

Kaw Pipe Line Company

Laurel Pipe Line Company

LOCAP Inc.

LOOP Inc.

Olymp'c Pipe Line Company

Portland Pipe Line Corporation

Texas-New Mexico Pipe Line Company

THUMS Long Beach Company

West Shore Pipe Line Company

Wolverine Pipe Line Company

Wyco Pipe Line Company

Aircraft Fuel Supply B.V.

Airport Refueling Services S.p.A.

Aktiebolaget Svensk Petroleumlagring

United Kingdom Oil Pipelines Limited

Unterflur Betankungsanlage A.G. (UBAG)

West Australian Natural Gas Pty. Limited

Zaire Services des Entreprises Petrolieres (Zaire S.E.P.)

Aktiebolaget Djurgardsberg

Wichmann Beteiligungsgesellschaft mbH

Caluplast Farbenfabriken Wichmann

Zerssen Mineralolhandel GmbH & Co. GmbH

UNION OIL COMPANY OF CALIFORNIA

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A-57

Duachita Fertilizer Company, Inc.

P-M-S West, Inc.

Sanitation, Inc.

Sepulveda Oil and Gas Company

Southcap Pipe Line Company

Superior Deshler Co.

Union Oil Company of Canada, Ltd.

Unoco (Philippines), Inc.

Van Salt Water Disposal Company

Corporate Petitioners in Virginia Electric and Power Company, et al.

v. EPA, D.C. Cir. Nos. 81-1569 and 81-1572

ALABAMA POWER COMPANY

Parent

The Southern Company

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Alabama Property Company

Southern Electric Generating Co.

ALLEGHENY POWER SYSTEM, INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Allegheny Power Service Corp.

Monongahela Power Co.

The Potomac Edison Co.

Allegheny Pittsburgh Coal Co.

West Penn Power Co.

West Virginia Power & Transmission Co.

West Penn West Virginia Water Power Co.

AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY, INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Appalachian Power Company

A-58

Cedar Coal Co.

Central Appalachian Coal Co.

Central Coal Co.

Central Operating Co.

Kanawha Valley Power Co.

Southern Appalachian Coal Co.

West Virginia Power Co.

Franklin Real Estate Co.

Indiana Franklin Realty, Inc.

Indiana & Michigan Electric Co.

Indiana & Michigan Power Co.

Castlegate Coal Co., Inc.

Kentucky Power Co.

Kingsport Power Co.

Ohio Power Co.

Southern Oil Coal Co.

Central Ohio Coal Co.

Windsor Power House Coal Co.

Twin Branch Railroad Co.

Beech Bottom Power Co.

Ohio Valley Electric Corp.

CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Capitan Corporation

Carolinas-Virginia Nuclear Power Assn., Inc.

ye

A-59

CENTRAL AND SOUTH WEST SERVICES, INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Central Power and Light Company

Public Service Company of Oklahoma

Transok Pipe Line Co.

Ash Creek Mining Co.

Southwestern Electric Power Company

Southwest Arkansas Utilities Corp.

Arklahoma Corp.

West Texas Utility Company

CSR Services, Inc.

CENTRAL ILLINOIS PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Union Light, Heat and Power Co.

West Harrison Gas & Electric Co.

Miami Power Corp.

Lawrenceburg Gas Co.

Lawrenceburg Gas Transmission Corp.

Tri-State Improvement Co.

YGK, Inc.

CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING

COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

A-60

COLUMBUS & SOUTHERN OHIO ELECTRIC CO.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Colomet, Inc.

Simco, Inc.

COMMONWEALTH EDISON COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Commonwealth Edison Co. of Indiana, Inc.

Illinois Maintenance Co.

72 West Adams Co.

Chicago & Illinois Midland Railway Co.

Medical Center Steam Co.

Nuclear Resources, Inc.

Cotter Corp.

Commonwealth Research Corp.

DETROIT EDISON COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Edison Illuminating Company

Midwest Energy Resources Company

Peninsular Electric Light Company

St. Clair Edison Company

Washtenaw Light & Power Company

Essex County Light & Power Co., Lid.

DUKE POWER COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Mill Power Supply Company

Crescent Land & Timber Corp.

Eastover Land Company

Eastover Mining Company

Wateree Power Co.

A-61

Catawba Mfg. & Elec. Power Co.

Western Cardina Power Co.

Caldwell Power Co.

Southern Power Co.

Greenville Gas & Electric Light & Power Co.

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Fuel Supply Service, Inc.

Land Resources Investment Co.

GULF STATES UTILITIES COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Varibus Corporation

HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPANY

Parent

Houston Industries, Inc.

ILLINOIS POWER COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Electric Energy, Inc.

IOWA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Cimmred, Inc.

Energy Development Co.

Energy Reserves, Inc.

Centennial Coal, Inc.

A-62

MIDDLE SOUTH UTILITIES, INC.

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Arkansas Power & Light Co.

Arkansas-Missouri Power Co.

Louisiana Power & Light Co.

Mississippi Power & Light Co.

New Orleans Public Service, Inc.

MINNESOTA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Superior Water, Light & Power Co.

Topeka Land Company

Energy Land, Inc.

MIONTAUP ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Eastern Utilities Associates

NEW ENGLAND POWER COMPANY

Parent

New England Electric System

NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Beebee Isiand Corporation

Moreau Manufacturing Corp.

St. Lawrence Power Co.

The Indian River Co.

NORTHERN INDIANA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Shore Line Shops, Inc.

NIPSCO Exploration Co.

NIPSCO Fuel Co.

NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY (MINN.)

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Cormorant Corporation

United Power and Land Co.

Northern States Power Co. (Wisc.)

Chippewa and Flambeau Improvement Co.

A-64

OHIO EDISON COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Pennsylvania Power Co.

OKLAHOMA GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Arklahoma Corporation

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affili

Alberta & Southern Gas Co., Ltd.

Natural Gas Corp. of California

Pacific Gas Transmission Co.

Pacific Transmission Supply Co.

Pacific Gas LNG Terminal Co.

saat

7

ow ee Om

A-65

ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Canadea Power Corp.

SOUTH CAROLINA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

THE SOUTHERN COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Alabama Power Co.

Alabama Property Co.

Georgia Power Co.

Gulf Power Co.

Southern Company Service, Inc.

TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Tampa Bay Industrial Corp.

Mid-South Towing Co.

Electro-Coal Transfer Corp.

Gulfcoast Transit Co.

Southern Marine Management Corp.

Cal-Glo Coal, Inc.

TEXAS UTILITIES COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Dallas Power & Light Co.

Texas Electric Service Co.

A-66

Old Ocean Fuel Co.

Texas Power & Light Co.

Texas Utilities Services, Inc.

Texas Utilities Fuel Co.

Texas Utilities Generating Co.

UNION ELECTRIC COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Missouri Power & Light Co.

Missouri Utilities Co.

VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND POWER COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Laurel Run Mining Co.

Virginia Nuclear, Inc.

WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Wisconsin Natural Gas Co.

Wisconsin Michigan Power Co.

Badger Service Co.

WISCONSIN POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

Subsidiaries and Affiliates

South Beloit Water, Gas & Electric Co.

Wisconsin Power & Light Nuclear Fuel, Inc.

NUFUS Resources, Inc.

Wisconsin River Power Co.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.