Amicus Brief — Transportation Union v. Long Island R. Co.
Supreme Court brief1982
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ss ee No.80-1925
bs , oo IN THE
. Supreme Court of the Anited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1980
UNITED TRANSPORTATION UNION
ro .
v.
LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANY and
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
t —_——— +
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE, AND BRIEF AMICUS
CURIAE OF THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
_ MUNICIPAL LAW OFFICERS IN SUPPORT OF
RESPONDENTS, LONG ISLAND RAILROAD AND
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY
Petitioner,
101 City & County Building
Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
STANLEY J. GARBER
Corporation Counsel
511 City Hall
Chicago, Illinois 60602
LEE E. HOLT
City Attorney
501 Municipal Building
Dallas, Texas 75201
GEORGE F. KNOX, JR.
City Attorney
174 E. Flagier Street
Miami, Florida 33131
WALTERM. “OWELL
ALLEN G. SCHWARTZ
Corporation Counsel
100 Church Street
Room 6A-11
New York, New York 10007
J. LAMAR SHELLEY
City Attorney
48 North Macdonald Street
Mesa, Arizona 95201
City Administration Building
Washington, D.C. 20036
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1980
No. 80-1925
UNITED TRANSPORTATION UNION,
Petitioner,
v.
LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANY and
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF
AS AMICUS CURIAE
The National Institute of Municipal Law Officers
(NIMLO) moves the Court for leave to file the attached brief
as amicus curiae in support of the Respondents, Long Island
Railroad Company and Metropolitan Transportation Au-
thority. The respondents have consented to the filing of the
brief, but the petitioner has withheld consent. The letter
granting consent has been lodged with the Clerk.
l
2
NIMLO submits that its brief can assist the Court in
determining whether publicly owned and operated transit
systems are integral and traditional governmental functions
within the meaning of the principles of Federalism as
expressed in National League of Cities v. Usery, 426 U.S.
833 (1976). NIMLO’s interest in the issue is set out in the
Interest of the Amicus Curiae section of the attached brief.
That brief analyzes the historical development of transit
operations in the United States from the days of private
ownership and operation to the present situation of forced
takeover and operation by state and local governments. It
also considers the nature of the interest involved in the
uninterrupted delivery of public transportation services.
Because of the widespread ownership and operation of
transit systems by state and local governments, this case is of
nationwide importance, and, we submit, the attached amicus
brief will assist the Court in evaluating the nationwide
importance of the decision in this case.
Therefore, we urge the Court to grant NIMLO leave to file
the attached brief as amicus curiae.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN DEKKER HENRY W. UNDERHILL,
Director of Law JR.
City Hall, 13th Floor City Attorney
455 North Main Street 600 East Trade Street
Wichita, Kansas 67202 Charlotte, North Carolina
JAMES B. BRENNAN 28202
City Attorney BENJAMIN L. BROWN
800 City Hall City Solicitor
Milwaukee, Wisconsin 101 City Hall
53202 Baltimore, Maryland
21202
ROY D. BATES
City Attorney
City Hall
P.O. Box 147
Columbia, South Carolina
29217
GEORGE AGNOST
City Attorney
206 City Hall
San Francisco, California
94102
ROGER F. CUTLER
City Attorney
101 City & County
Building
Salt Lake City, Utah 84111
STANLEY J. GARBER
Corporation Counsel
511 City Hall
Chicago, Illinois 60602
LEE E. HOLT
City Attorney
501 Municipal Building
Dallas, Texas 75201
GEORGE F. KNOX, JR.
City Attorney
174 E. Flagler Street
Miami, Florida 33131
100 Church Street
Room 6A-11
New York, New York
10007
J. LAMAR SHELLEY
City Attorney
48 North Macdonald
Street
Mesa, Arizona 95201
AARON A. WILSON
City Attorney
28th Floor - City Hall
Kansas City, Missouri
64106
JOHN W. WITT
City Attorney
202 C Street
City Administration
Building
San Diego, California
92101
MAX P. ZALL
City Attorney
City & County Building
Denver, Colorado 80202
CONARD B. MATTOX,
JR., Esq.
309 Marston Avenue
Richmond, Virginia 23221
CHARLES S. RHYNE,
Counsel of Record
MARTHA B, PEDRICK
1000 Connecticut Ave.,
N.W.
Suite 800
Washington, DC. 20036
(202) 466-5420
Attorneys for National Insti-
tute of Municipal Law
Officers as Amicus Curiae
October 1981
(i)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Interest of the amicus Curiae ..........ccccccccccccesvcvnce 1
DE CUE he codec conccevicualn bdebiedapaens te 3
EL Sc lasuddays sdccccakepebeneeuniocbieas 4
PRE ait b'3's WEd RS eneRe che descent Adedre ciceWeveeer 6
I. The question in this case is whether a state-
owned railroad, primarily engaged in the
provision of commuter service to the working
public, and only incidentally engaged in inter-
state freight operations, is an integral and
traditional government function of state and
II. The self-help provisions of the Railway Labor
Act may not constitutionally be applied to the
operation of a state-owned commuter railroad
under our Nation’s system of Federalism ............ 9
A. The facts of public transit operations, as
exemplified by the operation of the ra
Island railroad, demonstrate that
rin iti Suerte os tae patito
an integral and traditional governmental
function of state and local governments.......... 10
B. This court’s decision in Hodel v. Virginia
Surface Mining and Reclamation Associ-
ation is not determinative of the issue in this
(ii)
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases Page
American Public Transit Association v. Lewis,
Oe Ee Mes COMED 0 cc cv ascvvccvectoceuevegec 12
Hodel v. Virginia Surface Mining and Reclama-
tion Association,
POD; POA CE BS, LSD) 6c ccccdeccecccceceeve 17,18
Munn v. Illinois,
seeds can FL 0s s eWelnwes spissshesecgade 1}
National League of Cities v. Usery,
MEd CUES Ces cds cb cBisn cis ceopovegss passim
United States v. California,
EE Di cO bata bso cle cosdcheecdcabapsedgeteaces 4
Constitution, statutes and regulations:
United States Constitution, Tenth Amendment ....... passim
Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. §7401 ef seg...........++45- 16,17
Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. §201 et seg. .... 10,18
National Labor Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. §152(2)........ 18
Railway Labor Act, 45 U.S.C. §151 ef seg. .......... 5,9,10
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977,
RED ORME, vo'e'e cclecedecccvscheseccess 17,18
. Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1964, 49 U.S.C.
EMT 2hc PEUS nS UMD ce ccccccdccucdecvected 8,12,13
N.Y. Civ. Serv. Law §200 et seg. (McKinney 1973
and Supp. 1980) (“Taylor Law”) ................. 2,4,5,8
eT EME TEEU cc oi ccccscccuccospedetescess 12
Miscellaneous:
A. Altschuler, Changing Patterns of Policy: The
Decision-Making Environment of Urban Transpor-
tation, Public Policy, Spring 1977 ................000- 13
(iii)
American Public Transit Association, Transit Fact
CE FEP TE MED cevcccccicscccageceoneds 5,10,11,15
109 Congressional Record 5671-73 (1963).........-+006: 8
46 Federal Register 37488 (July 20, 1981)............... 12
The Impact of Transportation on the Central Business
District, Traffic Quarterly, October 1980 .............. 16
Institute of Public Administration, Financing Transit:
Alternatives for Local Government, July 1979 .11,12,13,14
Public Transit and Downtown Development, Metro-
SUE nc cae va ceecncvaesedian canes 16
University of Illinois at Chicago Circle, School of
Urban Sciences, Moving People: An Introduction to
Public Transportation, January 1981 ...... 7,8,11,12,13,15
Weekly Bond Buyer, July 13, 1981 ..............eeeeeee 15
Womack and Altschuler, An Examination of the
Transit Funding Process at the Local Level,
DE <atGetWKGUAGAUNs vey ee esenceaedaeaeses 10,15
IN THE .
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1980
No. 80-1925
UNITED TRANSPORTATION UNION,
Petitioner,
v.
LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANY and
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
BRIEF OF THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
MUNICIPAL LAW OFFICERS AS AMICUS CURIAE
INTEREST OF THE AMICUS CURIAE
This brief amicus curiae is filed on behalf of the more
than 1600 local governments, or political subdivisions of
states, who are members of the National Institute of
Municipal Law Officers (NIMLO). These member local
governments operate NIMLO through their chief legal
officer, variously called city or county attorney, corporation
l
2
counsel, city solicitor or law director and other titles, with
each member local government having one vote on all
actions which are casi by the organization. This brief
amicus curiae is signed by the chief legal officers of
NIMLO members on behalf of their own local government
and the chief legal officers of the members of NIMLO in
their officiai capacity.
The local government attorneys who participate in the
work of NIMLO are responsible for advising local govern-
ment officials, in cities and counties which own and
operate a public transit system, on the subject of employ-
ment relations involving transit system employees. They
assist in negotiating contracts between municipal transit
systems and their employees, both through collective
bargaining and through arbitration processes where they
exist. They must also advise the local governing body when
transit employees threaten and engage in strike actions.
Since National League of Cities v. Usery, 426 U.S.
833 (1976), local governments have structured their em-
ployment relations free of federal interference in those
areas of integral and traditional government operations
expressly identified by this Court. However, lack of
guidance from this Court as to what constitutes integral
and traditional governmental operations, produces un-
certainty among local governments in providing public
services.
The essential nature of public transit service and the
very real threat of strikes by these public employees is of
great concern to local government transit system owners.
Laws such as New York’s Taylor Law were enacted to
prevent the interruption in the provision of essential
government services such as public transportation. If the
opinion of the Court of Appeals is left standing, it will
3
allow local government transit system owners to structure
employment relations based on local needs and circum-
stances. Because the Court of Appeals properly analyzed
the facts of the Long Island Railroad operations in
determining whether those operations were integral and
traditional governmental operations within the meaning
of National League, NIMLO urges affirmance of the
Judgment of the Court of Appeals.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
The Long Island Railroad (LIRR) is a state-owned and
operated railroad, primarily engaged in the transportation
of passengers from counties in Long Island to their jobs and
businesses in New York City, and incidentally in the
hauling of freight in interstate commerce. Pet. App. 4a.'
The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), an
agency of the State of New York, purchased the LIRR from
the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1966, based upon a deter-
mination that private enterprise could no longer continue
to provide the service. Pet. App. 21a. In 1968, the LIRR
became part of the largest public transit operation in the
country as subway and bus transit operations transporting
some 5.5 million daily passengers were added to the
jurisdiction of the MTA. Brief in Opposition, at 4.
Prior to its conversion to public benefit corporation
status in February, 1980, the LIRR’s 6,900 employees
"In 1980, other railroads providing local passenger service in addition
to freight services still maintained a high ratio of interstate freight
revenue to aggregate revenue (96.9%) compared to the LIRR (4%).
Brief in Opposition, at 6.
4
were the only employees of the MTA’s work force of 50,000
public employees not covered by the Taylor Law. Brief in
Opposition, at 6. Interestingly, one of the factors leading to
enactment of the Taylor Law was the transit strike in
1966. Pet. App. 14a. The principal objective of the
conversion to public benefit corporation status was to
subject the LIRR employees to the Taylor Law. Brief in
Opposition, at 3.
In light of the facts of the LIRR’s operations, and the
operation of public transit systems nationwide, the Court
of Appeals held that the state’s operation of a passenger
rail service constituted an integral governmental function
within the meaning of National League of Cities v.
Usery, 426 U.S. 833 (1976), based on the finding that
public transportation is a service that state and local
governments are particularly suited to provide and have
been forced to provide by a process of economic elimina-
tion of private suppliers. Pet. App. 18a. In addition, the
Court found the importance of the LIRR’s passenger
service to the public greater than the state-operated freight
line in United States v. California, 297 U.S. 175 (1936).
Pet. App. 18a.
. SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
State and local governments have long been involved in
the provision of transit service to the public, historically as
grantors of franchises to private transit companies to
occupy the public streets and, more recently, as owners and
operators of transit systems. The determination of whether
and when transit operations are an “integral and tradi-
tional governmental function” under National League of
Cities v. Usery, 429 U.S. 833 (1976), requires an
5
examination of the facts of public transit as it exists
today.
The State of New York faced the termination of com-
muter rail service provided by a privately-owned railroad
to the public when operating and capital costs could no
longer be financed from the revenue produced by the private
system. Rather than lose this essential public service, the
State had no choice but to purchase and operate the
system. Forced public takeover as occurred in the case of
the Long Island Railroad is typical of the forced public
takeover, occurring over the last two decades, of privately
owned transit sy.tems nationwide. Although publicly
owned systems represent only 48% of the transit industry,
they carry 91% of all transit passengers and produce 90%
of all operating revenues.’
One of the primary services performed by public transit
systems is the transportation of persons from their homes to
downtown jobs and businesses. Interruptions caused by
employee strikes in this essential public service produce
disastrous results for commuters, the city and state, and
local businesses. The pressure on the public transit owner
to avoid a strike is great. Laws like New York’s Taylor
Law were enacted to avoid the interruption in the delivery
of public services caused by a strike. Application of the
Railway Labor Act which would allow employees of a
state-owned and operated commuter railroad to strike in
contravention of the state law prohibiting strikes by public
employees, displaces the state’s ability to structure employ-
ment relationships in furnishing an essential public service
in violation of state constitutional powers as described by
2American Public Transit Association, Transit Fact Book, 1978-
1979 ed., at 38-39.
6
this Court’s decision in National League of Cities v.
Usery, 426 U.S. 833 (1976).
With the advent of public takeover, a substantial
program of government subsidization of capital and
operating expenses has developed to maintain this essen-
tial public service. In conjunction with government subsi-
dization of operating and capital costs, transit has
become an important means of achieving governmental
social, economic and environmental goals which benefit
not only the transit passenger, but also the community in
which the system operates.
The Court of Appeals properly analyzed the facts of the
operation of the Long Island Railroad. Those operations
were properly found to be an integral and traditional
governmental function within the meaning of the principles
set forth in Federalism as defined in National League.
ARGUMENT
I. THE QUESTION IN THIS CASE IS
WHETHER A STATE-OWNED RAIL-
ROAD, PRIMARILY ENGAGED IN
THE PROVISION OF COMMUTER
SERVICE TO THE WORKING PUBLIC,
AND ONLY INCIDENTALLY EN-
GAGED IN INTERSTATE FREIGHT
OPERATIONS, IS AN INTEGRAL AND
TRADITIONAL GOVERNMENTAL
FUNCTION OF STATE AND LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS
7
Public mass transportation systems, of which the Long
Island Railroad (LIRR) is a part,’ account for nearly 90%
of the trips entering the central business district in cities
like New York.* One of the primary services performed by
these systems, as in the case of the LIRR, Brief for the
Petitioner, at 13, is the transportation of persons from their
homes to work and downtown businesses, and home again.
Thus, the interest of the public transit system owner and
operator in the uninterrupted functioning of the system is
great. Disruption caused by labor strife is one of the
greatest threats to the system’s smooth operation and the
economic stability of the community it serves.
At the very least, this case presents a very narrow
question for decision by this Court. Both the Petitioners
United Transportation Union (UTU), Brief, at 13, and the
LIRR, Brief in Opposition at 3-4, agree that the LIRR is
unique among operators of commuter railroads.* The high
percentage of revenue derived from the LIRR’s passenger
service compared to that attributable to the hauling of
freight in interstate commerce, which the Court of Appeals
characterized as “but a fraction of the revenues of the
LIRR,” Pet. App. 10a, is not found elsewhere. The primary
public interest, then, is in the smooth operation of the
Under the jurisdiction of the Respondent Metropolitan Transporta-
tion Authority, the LIRR is part of the largest transit operation in the
Nation, carrying some 5.5 million daily rail, subway and bus riders. Brief
in Opposition, at 5.
“University of Illinois at Chicago Circle, School of Urban Sciences,
Moving People: An Introduction to Public Transportation, January
1981, at 5, hereafter referred to as Moving People.
*The United States is in agreement noting that the majority of the
business of other carriers is derived from freight operations. Amicus
Curiae Brief of the United States, at 29-30, n.24.
8
system so that commuters get to their jobs and downtown
businesses via public transportation. This is especially
true in cities like New York where such a high percentage
of trips into the central business district are via public
transportation. °
The Taylor Law was enacted for the protection of the
public to assure the orderly and uninterrupted operations
and functions of government by prohibiting strikes by
public employees. Pet. App. 14a. Continuous public
transportation is among the most important of government
operations, the uninterrupted functioning of which the
Taylor Law was designed to assure.’ A transit strike
leaves many commuters stranded, unable to get to work,
and results in severe financial losses to downdown busi-
nesses and thus to the city and state and to their employees.*
A strike produces adverse environmental effects as com-
muters turn to automobiles, thereby adding to traffic
congestion and increasing air pollution. The government
interests involved in this case, then, are those of the public
interest of New York rather than any overriding public
need of the federal government. And, in light of the nature of
public transit operations today, this Court must conclude
" ‘Moving People, supra, n.4.
7As the Court of Appeals noted, the Taylor Law was in large part a
response to the transit strike in 1966. Pet. App. 14a. Interestingly, the
legislative history of Section 13(c) of the Urban Mass Transportation
Act, 49 U.S.C. §1609(c) which requires as a condition of federal
funding under that Act, that fair and equitable arrangements be made to
protect the employees affected by the assistance, reveals that that section
was not intended to supercede state laws forbidding public employee
strikes. 109 Cong. Rec. 5671-73 (1963) (remarks of Senator Morse).
*A loss by New York City of $1.1 billion and $100 million daily by
businesses during the 11 day transit strike in April 1980 was
documented in the Court of Appeals. Pet. App. 15a.
9
that such operations are integral and traditional within
the meaning of the principles of Federalism set forth in
National League and other decisions of this Court.
Il. THE SELF-HELP PROVISIONS OF
THE RAILWAY LABOR ACT MAY NOT
CONSTITUTIONALLY BE APPLIED
TO THE OPERATION OF A STATE-
OWNED COMMUTER RAILROAD
UNDER OUR NATION’S SYSTEM OF
FEDERALISM
In National League of Cities v. Usery, 426 U.S. 833
(1976), this Court held that the federal government could
not, consistent with Federalism and the principles set forth
in the Tenth Amendment, “exercise [its power to regulate
commerce] so as to force directly upon the States its
choices as to how essential decisions regarding the
conduct of integral governmental functions are to be
made.”? Application of the Railway Labor Act, which
would allow employees of a state-owned and operated
commuter railroad to strike in contravention of a state law
which prohibits strikes by public employees is contrary to
the public interests of states and local governments and
displaces their ability to structure employer-employee
relationships in discharging the dual functions of adminis-
tering the public law and furnishing public services.'®
There is no question that public transportation is a vital
public service and that the state performs a vital public
interest in providing it when private interests withdraw
from this field of service. As the Court of Appeals noted,
Pet. App. 15a, the freedom to strike has a negative
influence on the collective bargaining process. The threat
*National League of Cities, supra, 426 U.S., at 855.
'°Td., at 851.
10
of a transit strike causes the public transit employer to
agree to the payment of higher wages in order to avoid a
strike.'' The freedom to strike, embodied in the Railway
Labor Act, displaces the state’s decisions in structuring its
employment relationships in the same manner as those
decisions were displaced by the minimum wage and
overtime provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act, 29
U.S.C. §201 et seg., when it was amended to include
nearly all employees of state and local governments. '?
A. THE FACTS OF PUBLIC TRANSIT
OPERATIONS, AS EXEMPLIFIED
BY THE OPERATION OF THE
LONG ISLAND RAILROAD, DE-
MONSTRATE THAT TRANSIT IS
AN INTEGRAL AND TRADITION-
AL GOVERNMENTAL FUNCTION
OF STATES AND LOCAL GOV-
ERNMENTS
Transit operations in the United States have evolved
from that of a public service provided primarily by the
private sector to one which is today, of necessity, virtually
exclusively provided by government.'? Governmental in-
"Womack and Altschuler, An Examination of the Transit Fund-
ing Process at the Local Level, May 1979, at 18 “(While [public
officials] may also feel pressure from voters and taxpayer groups if
additional revenues must be found to pay wage settlements, these only
come much later and permit more flexibility in diffusing the blame.)
Hereafter referred to as Transit Funding Process.
"Fair Labor Standards Amendments of 1974, amending 29 U.S.C.
§201 et seq.
“Publicly owned transit systems carry 91% of all transit passengers.
90% of the operating revenues of transit systems nationwide are derived
from public transit systems. Transit Fact Book, supra, at 38-39.
volvement in transit operations, though, is certainly not
new.'* This dramatic and relatively recent forced rise in
public ownership and operation of transit systems grew out
of an overall decline in the use and revenues of the private
transit industry following World War II.'* During the
same period, increased operating costs added to the
private transit system owner’s financial difficulties.'* In
the mid-1960s, operating costs were approximately equal
to operating revenues. In 1974, operating expenses were
more than one and one half times greater than operating
revenues.'’ Small wonder that private operators quit this
field of service!
Several factors have been identified as contributing to
the decline in the local transit industry. The general move
out of the central city and into the suburbs with the
accompanying rise in the use of the automobile was a
Munn vy. Illinois, 94 U.S. 113, 125 (1876) “[In the exercise of the
police power] it has been customary in England from time im-
memorial, and in this country from its first colonization, to regulate
ferries, common carriers, hackmen. . .and in so doing to fix a maximum
charge to be made for services rendered. . . .”
In 1950, transit carried 13.8 billion passengers. By 1977, ridership
had decreased to 5.7 billion. Moving People, supra, at 5.
‘Between 1950 and 1970, operating costs per transit mile increased
an average of approximately 4.2% per year while the consumer price
index for the same years increased an average of only approximately
2.4% per year. Institute of Public Administration, Financing Transit:
Alternatives for Local Government, July 1979, at 8-9, hereafter
referred to as Financing Transit.
"Transit Fact Book, supra, at 20-21.
12
major factor.'* Increased labor costs were another factor. '®
A third factor was the cost of accomplishing certain
governmental social and environmental goals, among
them the provision of special services for school children,
the elderly” and the handicapped.”' The cost of complying
"Moving People, supra, at 15-16, 18. Given the lower density in
suburban areas, the cost of transit service per passenger greatly
increased. Another phenomenon known as “peaking,”’ or the concen-
tration of riders during the rush hours, in combination with labor
contracts requiring overtime for hours worked in excess of eight,
actually makes rush hour service more costly than non-rush hour
services.
'°A substantial proportion (75%) of operating expenses are attribu-
table to wages and related benefits. In 1950, the average annual transit
wage was higher than the wages of manufacturing and city employees.
Between 1950 and 1975 the rate of increase in transit wages was more
than 50% greater than that for manufacturing employees. Financing
Transit, supra, at 8, 11.
*Rates for the elderly and handicapped during non-peak hours may
not exceed one-half of the rates generally applicable during peak
hours. 49 U.S.C. § 1604(m).
""Based on the requirements of §504 of the Rehabilitation Act of
1973, as amended, 29 U.S.C §794, and §16 of the Urban Mass
Transportation Act, as amended, 49 U.S.C. §1612, requiring that
mass transit be accessible to the handicapped and elderly, the
Department of Transportation adopted implementing regulations, in
conformance with the HEW guidelines, which became effective May
31, 1979. 49 C.F.R. § §27.81-27.119 (1979). The’ regulations were
found to exceed the Department of Transportation’s authority under
§504. American Public Transit Association v. Lewis, 655 F.2d
1272 (D.C. Cir. 1981). The Department of Transportation has
promulgated an interim rule requiring recipients of federal funds to
certify that special efforts to provide transportation that handicapped
persons can use are being made pending reconsideration of the regula-
tory requirements under § §504 and 16. 46 Fed. Reg. 37488 (July 20,
1981).
13
with conditions attached to federal and state subsidies
has contributed to an overall decline in system productivity
as measured by revenue passengers per employee during
the period between 1950-1976.”?
Faced with the prospect of losing essential transit
service, state and local governments have been forced to
purchase and operate the private systems. With enactment
of the Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1964 (UMTA),
49 U.S.C. §1601 ef seq., the federal government made
federal funds for acquisition of private systems avail-
able.”> Since enactment of the UMTA, the federal
government has been heavily involved in the subsidization
of public transit systems.”
The history of the operation of the Long Island Railroad
fits the pattern of forced takeover by state and local
governments of financially troubled private systems as the
only alternative to loss of this essential public service. The
financial difficulties of the LIRR were typical of other
privately owned commuter railroads. Brief in Opposition,
at 12.
"Financing Transit, supra, at 2. Among the conditions adding to
labor costs identified by one commentator are the prevailing wage
requirements, 49 U.S.C. §1609(a), and the requirement that the
Secretary of Labor determine that “fair and equitable arrangements
are made, . . to protect the interests of employees affected by [federal]
assistance,” 49 U.S.C. § 1609(c). Generally, the Secretary will grant
certification only if all affected unions concur. Competitors threatened
by publicly aided service improvements are generally entitled to
compensation or are bought out. 49 U.S.C. §1602(e). A. Altschuler,
Changing Patterns of Policy: The Decision-Making Environment of
Urban Transportation, Public Policy, Spring 1977, at 171, 194.
“Funds for acquisition are authorized under 49 U.S.C. § 1602.
“The federal government contributes 80% of the total financial
assistance for capital expenditures and 10.9% of all operating
assistance. Moving People, supra, at 70.
14
‘As the Court of Appeals noted, the state’s purchase of the
railroad in 1966 “was premised on its finding that private
enterprise would be unable to continue to own and operate
the facility.” Pet. App. 21a, n.27.
The LIRR is the only common carrier railroad serving
Long Island. Brief for Petitioner, at 10. It carries a daily
ridership of 260,000 which is primarily commuter in
nature, Brief in Opposition, at 9, generally of the home to
work type. Brief for Petitioner, at 13. The railroad receives
the benefit of substantial federal subsidization since its
takeover by the state, having received an estimated
$450,000,000 between 1967 and 1980. Brief for Petitioner,
at 10, n.7.
The mere fact of forced public takeover and operation of
such a substantial portion of the private transit industry
over the last two decades should be sufficient to satisfy
National League’s test of integralness. But, there are other
distinguishing features of public transit operations which
lend support to the argument.
Although transit is not a free public service due to the
tradition of charging fares, it is not a self-supporting
public utility like telephone or electric utilities. Transit
competes with individual motorists while utility com-
panies enjoy the status of government-protected monopolies.
After forced public takeover, the transit system has
ceased to operate as it did when privately owned. Increased
costs are not always passed on to the consumer as is the
case with other utilities. Nor are fares necessarily tied to
transit costs per passenger.** On the contrary, increasingly
*Between 1950 and 1970, fares rose slightly less than transit costs
per passenger. However, between 1970 and 1975, transit costs per
passenger rose 14.3% per year while fares rose only 3.6% per year.
Financing Transit, supra, at 8, 10.
15
less and less of the operating expenses are recovered from
fares.** Rather, publicly owned transit systems are sup-
ported by tax revenues from transit and non-transit riders
who also benefit indirectly from transit service.”’
Public takeover has not cured the financial problems of
transit systems. Despite heavy subsidization, transit
continues to operate at a deficit.”* In 1978, transit operating
expenses exceeded operating revenues by $30.6 million.”
As public takeover has occurred, public attitudes toward the
financing of transit have changed.*® There is a great
reluctance to raise fares in cities experiencing public
takeovers, accompanied by pressures to provide special
services and higher wages to avoid transit strikes.*'
**Prior to World War II, nearly all operating and capital expenses
were recovered from revenue attributable to fares. By the 1960s, only
operating costs were recovered from fares, and by the late 1970s, fares
accounted for only half of all operating expenses and none of the
capital costs. Moving People, supra, at 15.
"In 1979, over $129 million in taxpayers’ funds were invested by the
state in the LIRR for operating expenses alone. Between 1966 and
1980, hundreds of millions of dollars in state subsidies have been
invested for capital expenses. Brief in Opposition, at 6.
**The threatened loss of federal operating and capital subsidies will,
for many systems heavily dependent on federal aid, make a bad
situation worse. The Weekly Bond Buyer, p. 5, July 13, 1981.
*Transit Fact Book, supra, at 20-21.
*Transit Funding Process, supra, at 4.
“In our case study cities we found a widespread expectation that
public ownership and subsidization would stabilize transit
finances by reducing operating costs (through new capital) and
by helping to attract new riders. However, more nearly the
opposite has occurred: unit costs (per vehicle mile and per
passenger) have increased rapidly in constant dollars during the
period of public, subsidized operation. Consequently, the amount
of public support needed to continue systems operations at a
given level has continued to grow rapidly... .”
*Yd., at 18.
16
Finally, aided by heavy government subsidization,
transit has become an integral component of the local
government planning process. That process is designed to
achieve governmental social, economic and environmental
goals for the benefit of society as a whole and not just the
transit passenger.
Transportation planning has become an integral com-
ponent of the overall comprehensive land use planning
process occurring at the local level. The availability of
public transportation allows land in the central business
district to be used at its highest potential, for commercial
office space, thus reducing its use for traffic and parking
needs. *? This is dramatically illustrated by the facts in this
case. State officials have estimated that 52 additional
lanes of expressway going into and out of New York City
would be required to accommodate traffic if the LIRR went
out of service and 10 city blocks would be needed solely for
parking. Pet. App. 17a. Access to public transportation
attracts economic development, thus aiding urban revitali-
zation efforts.*’
Public transportation figures prominently in the govern-
mental goal of achieving cleaner air as found in the Clean
Air Act.** The consistency requirements of the UMTA
illustrate the importance of public transportation to the
governmental planning process designed to achieve this
Traffic Quarterly, October 1980, p. 523.
“Cities have experienced considerable growth in construction of
commercial office space in the vicinity of public transit stations. Public
Transit and Downtown Development, Metropolitan, May-June 1980,
at 48.
442 U.S.C. §7401 et seq.
17
goal. Activities approved, supported or funded by the
Department of Transportation must conform to the State
Implementation Plan required under the Clean Air Act.*
As government involvement in transit service has grown,
the benefits accompanying transit have spread beyond
transit users to all segments of society. It is doubtful that
such governmental goals as urban revitalization, clean air
and energy conservation would be attainable if public
takeover had not occurred. The only conclusion to draw is
that public transit operations are and have been integral
operations of traditional governmental functions.
B. THIS COURT’S DECISION IN
HODEL V. VIRGINIA SURFACE
MINING AND RECLAMATION AS-
SOCIATION IS NOT DETERMI-
NATIVE OF THE ISSUE IN THIS
CASE.
Appellant’s reliance on this Court’s recent decision in
Hodel v. Virginia Surface Mining and Reclamation
Association, 452 U.S. ___. (June 15, 1981) is misplaced.
Brief for Petitioner, at 19. Hodel involved a challenge,
based on the Tenth Amendment and the principles of
Federalism as expressed in National League, to the
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977, 30
U.S.C. §1201 et seg. (Mining Act).
We submit that Hodel is not determinative of the issue
in this case. As found by this Court, the regulatory scheme
employed in the Mining Act was one of “cooperative
federalism.” It did not require the state to participate in
the Federal program. Slip op., 22. Rather, the challenged
42 U.S.C. $7506(c).
18
provisions of the Mining Act governed only the activities
of the private coal operators and thus the requirement of
National League that the challenged federal statute must
regulate “States as States” was not met. Slip op., 21
Unlike the challenge in Hodel, the challenge here, as in
National League, is to the direct application of a federal
statute, the Railway Labor Act, to the state of New York as
employer to limit its decisions as to the structuring of its
employment relations. There is no program of cooperative
federalism involved here. The governmental transit system
owner has no choice whether or not to be governed by the
Railway Labor Act, just as it had no choice whether to
comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act.
Moreover, this Court in Hodel noted the national
interest in the environment and the economy as affected by
the surface mining industry. Slip op., 12. No such national
interests exist here. Rather, the interest in this case is in
avoiding interruptions in the provision of public services,
and this interest is purely local. Congress recognized the
local nature of this interest when it exempted all municipal
labor relations from the provisions of the National Labor
Relations Act, 29 U.S.C. §152(2).
CONCLUSION
Faced with the certain prospect of losing public transit
services provided by privately owned and operated transit
companies, state and local governments have been forced
in locality after locality to purchase the financially
troubled private systems all over our Nation in order to
continue to provide this essential public service. Typically,
employees of the private transit company have become
public employees.
19
With the aid of substantial federal, state and local
subsidies, transit has become an integral part of the
governmental planning process and is the vehicle for the
accomplishment of governmental social, economic and
environmental goals which aid not only the transit rider,
but society as a whole.
Public employee labor relations have traditionally been
matters of local interest, as distinguished from matters of
national interest. Strikes by public employees are the
greatest threat to the delivery of public services by state
and local governments. Local laws such as New York’s
Taylor Law are designed to assure the uninterrupted
delivery of essential governmental services to the public.
Public transportation is one such service the interruption
of which produces drastic results. The operations of the
LIRR are an integral component of the largest public local
transit operation in this Nation. This Court should not
allow this case to turn on the incidental 4% freight
operations of that railroad.
The concept of what is an integral governmental function
should not be static because governing is not static.
Whether it takes a year or several years of public
operation to denominate a public function as a traditional
governmental function, there can be no doubt that public
transit operations are an integral and essential govern-
mental service under the facts of our day. The decision of
the Court of Appeals should be affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN DEKKER JAMES B. BRENNAN
Director of Law City Attorney
City Hall, 13th Floor 800 City Hall
455 North Main Street Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Wichita, Kansas 67202 53202
HENRY W. UNDERHILL, LEE E. HOLT
JR.
City Attorney
600 East Trade Street
Charlotte, North Carolina
28202
BENJAMIN L. BROWN
City Solicitor
101 City Hall
Baltimore, Maryland
21202
ROY D. BATES
City Attorney
City Hall
P.O. Box 147
Columbia, South Carolina
29217
GEORGE AGNOST
City Attorney
206 City Hall
San Francisco, California
94102
ROGER F. CUTLER
City Attorney
101 City & County
Buildi
Salt Lake City, Utah
84111
STANLEY J. GARBER
Corporation Counsel
511 City Hall
Chicago Illinois 60602
City Attorney
501 Municipal Building
Dallas, Texas 75201
GEORGE F. KNOX, JR.
City Attorney
174 E. Flagler Street
Miami, Florida 33131
WALTER M. POWELL
Corporation Counsel
100 Church Street
Room 6A-11
New York, New York
10007
J. LAMAR SHELLEY
City Attorney
48 North Macdonald
Street
Mesa, Arizona 95201
AARON A. WILSON
City Attorney
28th Floor - City Hall
Kansas City, Missouri
64106
21
JOHN W.WITT
City Attorney
202 C Street
City Administration
Building
San Diego, California
92101
MAX P. ZALL
City Attorney
City and County Building
Denver, Colorado 80202
CONARD B. MATTOX,
JR., Esq.
309 Marston Avenue
Richmond, Virginia 23221
CHARLES S. RHYNE,
Counsel of Record
MARTHA B. PEDERICK
1000 Connecticut Ave.,
N.W.
Suite 800
Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 466-5420
Attorneys for National In-
stitute of Municipal Law
Officers as Amicus Curiae
October, 1981
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.