Joint Appendix — Nixon v. Fitzgerald
Supreme Court brief1982
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Office Supreme Court: U.S
ae St ae
Nos. 79-1738 and 80-945 OCT 30 196
ALEXANDER L. STEVAS,
IN THE CLERK
Supreme Court of the United States
OcTOBER TERM, 1981
RICHARD M. Nixon,
Petitioner,
Vv.
A. ERNEST FITZGERALD,
Respondent.
Bryce N. HARLOW AND
ALEXANDER P. BUTTERFIELD,
Petitioners,
Vv.
A. ERNEST FITZGERALD,
Respondent.
On Writs of Certiorari
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit
JOINT APPENDIX
R. STAN MORTENSON JOHN E. Notan, Jr.
2555 M Street, N.W., Suite 500 1250 Connecticut Ave.
Washington, D.C. 20037 Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 293-6400 (202) 862-2176
Counsel for Petitioner Nixon Counsel for Respondent
E.tiot L. RICHARDSON
1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 466-4700
Counsel for Petitioners
Harlow and Butterfield
Petitions for Certiorari Filed May 14 and December 11, 1980
Certiorari Granted June 22, 1981
TABLE OF CONTENTS*
Page
1. Docket Entries la
2. Order filed April 27, 1979 54a
3. United States Civil Service Commission, Appeals
Examining Office, Decision on the Appeal of A.
Ernest Fitzgerald (Sept. 18, 1973) 60a
4. Excerpts of Depositions:
PaO J. Buchanan (R. 414) [pp. 14-19, 41-
89a
Alexander P. Butterfield (R. 42) [pp. 127-28,
130, 143-44, 147-48] 99a
John Ehrlichman (R. 444) [pp. 10-14] ............. 104a
Alexander M. Haig (R. 470) [p. 36] ..........:000++ 108a
Harry R. Haldeman (R. 418) [pp. 4-9] taken
on Feb. 7, 1980 109a
Bryce N. Harlow (R. 392) [pp. 60, 173, 176,
183-86, 189-90} 113a
Richard Kaufman (R. 472) [pp. 8-9, 28] ......... I2la
Melvin Laird (R. 455) [pp. 15, 22] ...........sc00000 123a
Robert P. Mayo (R. 460) [pp. 3-7] .......c-sseese00s 125a
Clark R. Mollenhoff (R. 330-32) [pp. 112-13,
186] 128a
Richard Nixon (R. 378) {pp. 8-16, 27-31, 37]
taken on October 2-3, | . 130a
Richard Nixon (R. 604) [pp. 9-16] taken on
February 7, 1980 140a
James R. Schlesinger (R. 432) [pp. 4-8]........... 146a
Robert C. Seamans (R. 334-35) [pp. 2-79, 2-
114 to -117, 2-124, 2-134, 2-142 to -143; 3-99
to -102, 3-110 to -112, 3-188 to -203, 3-213 to
-216, 3-219, 3-226 to -227, 3-234, 3-240 to -
243). . 150a
Roe] A. Ziegler (R. 442) [pp. 100, 105-
175a
* The opinions and orders of the court of appeals and district court in
this case are reprinted in the petitions for certiorari in No. 79-1738 (at pp. la-
10a, 35a-36a) and also in No. 80-945 (at pp. la-12a).
5. Plaintiff's Deposition Exhibits:
4A
12
19 [pp. 8-9]
25..
26A
45
59
71
84 [pp. 4-6]
94 [pp. 1-15]
113
131 [p. 1]
137
140
141
202 [p. 1006]
235B
237 [pp. 4-8, 10, 12-13]
248
249
258 [pp. 456-57]
ee
6. Defendants’ Deposition Exhibits:
109
Ss RRB in
112
113 (Jan. 1970]
135
143
150
151
163
165
169
170
172
181
7. Exhibit 84 to Plaintiff's Third Request for Admis-
ii ciinctahialendinichastbhststhisntacsntstonthannecnsseies
8. Attachments to Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant
Nixon’s and Defendant Harlow’s Second and
Defendant Butterfield’s Third Motions for Sum-
mary Judgment ( filed March 4, 1980)
Attachment A
Attachment B
Attachment H
Attachment I
e
259a
262a
265a
266a
267a
268a
270a
273a
274a
275a
276a
277a
278a
279a
280a
28a
282a
289a
290a
293a
295a
296a
300a
iv
i
9. Attachments 3 through 6 to Motion to Dismiss or, in
the Alternative, for Summary Judgment (filed
November 21, 1978) 302a
la
CIVIL DOCKET
United States District Court
for the District of Columbia
C. A. No. 178-74
ERNEST FITZGERALD
vs.
RosBert C. SEAMANS, JR., ef al
NumBer Date PROCEEDINGS
1 Jan25 Complaint, appearance Jury demand
2 Jan25 Summons, Copies (9) and Copies (9) of
Complaint issued;
3 Feb15 MOTION by defts. #1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 9
for enlargement of time; P&A’s; c/m
Appearance of Robert S. Rankin, Jr.
4 Feb20 SUMMONS, copy (1) and copy (1) of
complaint issued to deft. #1:
5 Feb20 SUMMONS, copy (1) and copy (1) of
complaint issued to D.A.:
6 Feb22 RESPONSE by pitf. to defts. motion for
enlargement of time to answer; c/s 2-22-
7 Feb27 MOTION by pltf. to take depositions by
other than stenographic means; memo-
randum; c/s 2-27-74.
8 Feb28 SUMMONS, copy (1) & copy (1) of
Complaint issued to deft. #8: served.
9 Mar8 SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum . of
points and authorities by defts in support
evga for enlargernent of time; c/m
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Mar 26
Mar 26
Apr |
Apr 5
Apr 9
Apr 10
Apr 22
2a
PROCEEDINGS
OPPOSITION by defts. #1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7,
and 9 to pitfs. motion to take deposition
by other than stenogra 2 means;
P&A’s; exhibit A; c/m 3-8-74
MOTION by defts. #3 and 8 for enlarge-
ment of time; P&A’s c/m 3-18-74.
‘ORDER granting motion of defts. Melvin
R. Laird and Durwood L. Crow, #3 and
8, for enlargement of time; extendin
time through 4-22-74 within which sai
defts. may “? ee to the complaint.
(N) Gesell
NOTICE by pltf. to take depositions of
Carl S. Wallace, Michael Ross, John
: Badin, Jr., Eugene L. Kirschbaum, Da-
vid Wilson, Alexander P. Butterfield;
. Ronald Zeigler; appendix; c/m 3-26-74.
ORDER granting motion by defts. #1, 2, 4,
5, 6, 7 and 9 for enlargement of time and
extending time through 4-22-74 within
which they may respond to the com-
laint. (N) Geseil, J.
MOTION by defts. for protection order;
P&A’s; c/s 4-5-74.
OPPOSITION by ptf. to defts. motion for .
protective order; c/s 4-5-74.
ORDER granting motion of defts. for
protective order to the extent that dis-
covery is stayed until defts. have an-
swered the complaint or have moved for
or summary judgment; vaca-
ting pltfs. notice to take depositions. (N )
ORDER denying motion of pltf. to take
depositions by other than stenographic
means. (N) Gesell, J.
MOTION by defts. for enlargement of
time; P&A’s; c/m 4-22-74.
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
*Apr 24
May 6
May 6
May 6
May 7
May 7
May 10
May 20
May 22
3a
PROCEEDINGS
MOTION by defts. #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8,
and 9 to dismiss, or in the alternative, for
summary judgment; exhibit 1, 2, 3, 4,
attachment A, B, exhibit 5, 6, attachment
A, B, C; exhibit 7, attachment A, B, C;
exhibit 8, attachment A, B, C, D, exhibit
9, exhibit 10, exhibit 11, 12, 13, 14,
attachment 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8; exhibits
15 & 16, statement; P&A’s; attachment;
4-29-74,
ORDER _—— motion of defts. for
enlargement of time through 4-29-74
within which to answer the complaint.
(N) Gesell, J.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of deft.
#4, Eugene L. Kirschbaum, and Carl S.
Wallace; c/m 5-6-74.
FIRST request by pitf. for production of
documents to deft. #4; c/m 5-6.
MOTION by pitf. for enlargement of time
within which to respond to defts. motion
to dismiss or, in the alternative, for sum-
mary judgment; P&A’s; c/m 5-6-74.
ATTACHMENT (2) to motion by pitf. for
enlargement of time.
ORDER granting pltf. through 7-8-74 wit-
hin which to respond to motion by deft.
to dismiss, or in the alternative, for sum-
mary judgment. No further extensions
will be allowed. (N) Gesell, J.
MOTION by defts. for protective order;
P&A’s; c/s 5-10-74.
MEMORANDUM of points and author-
ities by pltf. in opposition to defts.
motion for protective order; affidavit of
A. Ernest Fitzgerald; c/s 5-19-74.
SUPPLEMENTAL points and authorities
by defts. in support of motion for protec-
tive order; c/m 5-22-74.
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
Jun 18
Jul 8
Jul 9
Jul 16
Jul 19
Jul 22
Jul 22
Jul 22
PROCEEDINGS
ORDER denying motion of defts. for a
protective order. (N) Gesell, J.
AFFIDAVIT of service by John Bodner,
Jr. on Captain Bruce E. Clark on 6-6-74;
attachment.
STIPULATION extending time through 6-
14-74 within which de mey respond
to pitfs. alle gana APPROVED. MN)
STIPULATION extending time through
June 20, 1974 within which deft. may
respond to subpoena dated 6-6-74, APP-
ROVED. (FIAT) (N) Gesell, J.
MOTION by piltf. for extension of time;
P&A’s; c/s 7-8-74.
ORDER granting motion of plitf. for an
extension of time through 7-19-74 within
which to respond to motion for summary
judgment. (N) Gesell, J.
CERTIFICATE of mailing by pltf.; attach-
ments (2); c/s 7-16-74.
DEPOSITION of Carl S. Wallace for pltf.;
exhibit 1; exhibit 2; exhibit; exhibit 5;
exhibit 6; exhibit 7; exhibit 8.
DEPOSITION of Eugene L. Kirchbaum
taken on June 6, 1974 for the pitf.;
Exhibits | through 6; attached.
MEMORANDUM of pitf. in opposition to
defts’ motion to dismiss or, in the
alternative, for summary Pe swage
Statement of Genuine Issues; Affidavit of
pitf. in support of opposition; Attach-
ments A thru H; Affidavit of John Bod-
ner, Jr. with attachment; Affidavits (3);
c/s 7-22-74.
ORDER eee motion of pitf. extendin
time through 7-22-74 within which ptf.
may respond to motion of defts. to dis-
miss or in the alternative for summary
judgment. (N) Gesell, J.
45
47
48
49
50
*Sep 13
Oct 9
Sa
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of Alexander P. Butterfield
taken on June 15, 1974 for the ptf;
attachment.
DEPOSITION of Alexander P. Butterficld
taken on June 12, 1974 for the pitf;
attachment.
SUPPLEMENTAL points and authorities
of deft. in support of motion to dismiss
or, in the alternative, for summary judg-
ment; c/m 8-23-74.
SUPPLEMENTAL affidavit by pltf. in
support of opposition to defts. motion to
dismiss, or in the alternative, for sum-
mary judgment; affidavit of A. Ernest
Fitzgerald; c/s 9-16.
MOTION of deft. to dismiss or in the
alternative for summary judgment on
the statute of limitations issue only,
heard and taken under advisement.
(Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
RESPONSE by defts. to the supplemental
7 i of A. Ernest Fitzgerald; c/s 9-
SUPPLEMENTAL submission by ptf. in
opposition to defts. motion to dismiss, or
in the alternative, for summary judg-
ment; c/s 9-24-74.
SUPPLEMENTAL submission by plaintiff
in opposition to defendants’ motion to
dismiss or in the alternative for summary
judgment, c/ser 10/5.
PLY by defts. to pltfs. supplemental
submission in opposition to defts. motion
to dismiss or in the alternative for sum-
mary judgment; c/s 10-9-74.
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER grant-
ing motion of defts. for summary judg-
ment. (N) Gesell, J.
52
53
54
55
56
$7
1974
1975
Jan 9
Jan 16
1977
May 13
May 18
June 20
Jun 27
6a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE of appeal by pitf. from Memo-
randum and Order of October 9, 1974.
Deposit $5.00 by John Bodner and cred-
ited to U.S. Treasury. Copy mailed to
U.S. Attorney and John M. Kelson.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 9-13-74,
pages 1-52. (Rep: I. Watson); Court
copy.
RECORD on appeal delivered to USCA
aa receipt acknowledged. (75-
)
CERTIFIED copy of JUDGMENT USCA
affirming judgment of the USDC as to
all appellees except Butterfield, the sum-
mary judgment that the action against
appellee Butterfield is time-barred is re-
versed, and the case, insofar as it per-
tains to appellee Butterfic'd is remanded
ren = proceedings. OPINION at-
tached.
ANSWER of deft. #4 to complaint; c/m 5-
18-77. Appearance of Rebecca Ross.
ORDER filed 6-16-77 directing pltf. to file
an amended complaint by 6-25-77;
directing Dept. of Justice upon receipt of
said amended complaint to begin to
solve the representational problems of
the named defts.; plitfs. document dis-
covery will begin immediately upon the
filing of the amended complaint and
setting hearing on motion of defts. pend-
ing preliminary motions and objections
to discovery for 7-27-77 at 9:30 a.m.
(N) Gesell, J.
AMENDED complaint by pltf. changing
caption; trial by jury requested; exhibit
A; c/s 6-27-77.
58
59
61
63
65
67
68
June 29
June 29
June 29
June 29
July 12
July 15
July 15
Jul 25
7a
PROCEEDINGS
SUMMONS and copy of amended com-
plaint issued to deft. Haldeman:
FIRST request by plitf. for production of
documents to deft. #2; c/m 6-29-77.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of the
rson or persons in the U.S. Dept. of
fense who are familiar with the books
and records called for by the attached
specifications; schedule A; c/m 6-29-77.
NOTICE by pitf. to take deposition of the
person or persons in the White House
who are familiar with the books and
records called for by the attached specifi-
= schedule A; exhibit A; c/m 6-29-
NOTICE by pitf. to take deposition of the
person or persons in the U.S. Dept. of
the Air Force who are familiar with the
books and records called for by the
attached specifications; schedule A; c/m
6-29-77.
FIRST request by pitf. for production of
documents to deft. #3; c/m 6-29-77.
FIRST request by pitf. for production of
documents to deft. #1; c/m 6-29-77.
NOTICE by pitf. to take deposition of
rson or persons in thc GSA who are
amiliar with books and records called
for by the attached specifications; Sched-
ule A; exhibit A; c/m.
PARTIAL response by defts. to subpoenas
duces tecum; c/s 7-14-77.
OBJECTIONS by defts. to subpoenas
duces tecum; c/s 7-14-77.
REPLY of pitfs. to the Government’s
objections to subpoenas Duces Tecum
and Partial response to subpoenas duces
Tecum; Exhibits A thru E; c/m 7-25-77.
PROCEEDINGS
RESPONSE by deft. #2 to piltfs. first
request for production of documents;
c/m 7-26-77.
RESPONSE by deft. #1 to piltfs. first
request for production of documents;
c/m 7-26-77.
RESPONSE by deft. #3 to piltfs. first
request for production of documents;
c/m 7-26-77.
STATUS CALL. Further status call and
hearing on motions set for 9-14-77 at
9:30 a.m. Government to file motions by
8-1-77. (Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
LETTER dated 7-26-77 from government
counsel filed.
MOTION by deft. #3 to dismiss amended
complaint or in the alternative for sum-
mary judgment; motion by deft. #2 to
dismiss amended complaint; post-
remand P&A’s in support of motions;
attachment; c/m 8-1-77.
MOTION of pitff. for extension of time to
respond to Gov’ts motions to dismiss
amended complaint; c/m 8-12-77.
RESPONSE by defts. to plitfs. motion for
extension of time; c/m 8-16-77.
ORDER extending time to 9-9-77 for pltf.
to respond to motions to dismiss
— complaint. (N) Corcoran,
DEPOSITION of Steven Garfinkel for ptf.
taken on July 15, 1977.
DEPOSITION of Edward Stafford Bridges
II for pitf. taken on July 15, 1977.
DEPOSITION of Mrs. Marie Bouknight
Allen for pitff. taken on 7-15-77.
DEPOSITION of Tom Graham Morgan
for pitf. taken on July 15, 1977.
85
86
91
92
Sept 30
Oct 7
Oct 11
9a
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of Martin Abraham Miller
for pitf. taken on July 15, 1977.
DEPOSITION of William Eugene Roberts
for pltf. taken on July 15, 1977.
AFFIDAVIT of Durward L. Crow; exhibit
% affidavit of H.R. Haldeman; c/s 9-2-
MEMORANDUM by p on in opposition to
defts motion to dismiss, or, in the
alternative, for summary judgment;
statement of material facts; c/s 9-9-77.
MOTION of defts. to dismiss or in the
alternative for summary judgment heard
and denied without prejudice. (Rep: I.
Waison ) Gesell, J.
APPEARANCE of Kenneth E. Krosin and
John F. Bruce as counsel for pift.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 9-14-77,
pages 1-47. (Rep: I. Watson); Court
copy.
SUPPLEMENTAL response by pltf. to
defts. motion to dismiss or in the alterna-
tive for summary judgment; affidavit of
A. Ernest Fitzgerald; attachments A-N;
c/m 9-28-77.
PARTIAL Reply by defts. to response of
pitf. to motion of deft. to dismiss or in
the alternative for summary judgment;
affidavit of Charlotte Anne Reid; Attach-
ments | thru 3; c/m 9-30-77.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of July 27,
1977, pages 1-28. (Rep: I. Watson);
Court copy.
SUPPLEMENTAL reply of defts. to pltfs.
as lemental response to defts. motion
— or in the alternative, for sum-
poe: ju a nee, affidavit of Duward L.
Crow; davit of William Woodruff;
attachment W-1; c/m 10-11-77.
95
97
98
99
100
101
102
Nov 10
Nov 15
Nov 25
Nov 29
Nov 29
Dec 2
Dec 6
10a
PROCEEDINGS
ORDER filed on 10-13-77 granting motion
of deft. Duward L. Crow for summary
judgment. (N) Gessell, J.
MOTION of pitf. for recusal of trial judge;
memorandum of P&A’s; affidavit of bias
of A. Ernest Fitzgerald; affidavit of John
Bodner, Jr.; attachment; certificate of
counsel; c/m 11-9-77.
MOTION of pitf. for reconsideration of
order of 10-13-77; memorandum of
P&A'’s; affidavit of A. Ernest Fitzgerald;
attachments A-Q; c/m 11-10-77.
OPPOSITION of defts. to pitfs. motion for
recusal of trial judge; affidavit of Re-
becca L. Ross; affidavit of Alexis Pan-
agakos; attachment memorandum; c/m
11-15-77.
OPPOSITION of defts. to pitfs. motion for
reconsideration; memorandum; c/m 11-
NOTICE of pift. to take deposition of
rson or persons in the CSC who are
amiliar with the books and records
called for by the attached specifications;
attachment; c/m 11-29-77.
REPLY of pltf. to defts. opposition to
motion for recusal of trial judgment c/s
11-29-77.
NOTICE of defts. of substitution of cor-
rected filings to memo in opposition to
plitfs. motion for reconsideration filed on
11-25-77; affidavit of Alexis Panagakos;
c/s 12-2-77.
ORDER filed 12-2-77 denying motion of
pitf. for reconsideration of order of 10-
13-77. (N) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed on 12-2-77 denying motion
ng pitf. to recuse trial judge. (N ) Gessell,
105
106
110
111
1978
Jan 11
Feb 8
Feb 16
Feb 16
Mar 8
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of the
person or persons in the Civil Service
Commission who are familiar with the
books and records called for by the
attached specifications; Schedule A;
attachment; c/m 12-14-77.
STATUS REPORT on pltfs. discovery;
attachments A-D; exhibits A-C; attach-
ments E and F; c/m 12-14-77.
WITHDRAWAL of appearance of Re-
becca L. Ross as counsel for defts.; c/m
12-21-77. CD/N
STIPULATION approved whereby the
parties and the CSC agree that the notice
of deposition and subpena duces tecum
served on the CSC returnable 12-23-77 is
stayed and returnable instead on 12-30-
77. (N) (FIAT) Gesell, J.
DEPOSITION of Llewellyn M. Fischer
taken on 12-16-77 for pitf.
APPEARANCE of E. Barrett Prettyman,
Jr., Curtis E. Von Kann, Peter Raven-
Hansen, Sharon M. Williams and the
firm of Hogan & Hartson as counsel for
pitf.; c/m 2-8-78.
WITHDRAWAL of William L. Sollee as
counsel for pltf.; c/m 2-16-78.
WITHDRAWAL of John Bodner, Jr. as
counsel for pitf.; c/m 2-16-78. CD/N
APPEARANCE of Jonathan B. Smith as
counsel for defts.; appearance of Alexis
Panagakos as counsel for defts.; appear-
ance of Mark S. Landman as counsel for
defts.; c/s 3-8-78.
NuMBER
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
Date
1978
Mar 15
Mar 27
Mar 30
Apr 3
Apr 3
Apr 5
Apr 5
Apr I1
Apr 14
Apr 14
Apr 19
Apr 19
12a
PROCEEDINGS
STATUS CALL. Motion of pltf. for pro-
duction of documents to be filed by 4-19-
78; defts. to respond by 4-19-78. Hea-
ring on motions set for 5-5-78 at 9:30
a.m. Further status call set for 4-3-78 at
9:30 a.m. (Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
STIPULATION AND ORDER filed on 3-
22-78 re handling of Air Force Oral
History Project transcript. (N) Ge-
sell, J.
MEMORANDUM by pitff. concerning
Wi 's subpoena duces tecum for certain
“pe House Tape Recordings; c/s 3-30-
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum of pitf.
poor I subpoena duces tecum for
a, te House tape recordings; c/s
STATUS CALL. Discovery re two (2)
tapes to go forward. (Rep: I. Watson)
Gesell, J.
MOTION of pitf. for in camera inspection
of documents; memorandum.
MOTION of pitf. to compel production of
documents pursuant to res subpoenas
duces tecum; memo of P.
MOTION of Richard Nixon for leave to
file memorandum as amicus curiae;
memorandum; exhibit.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 3-15-78,
pages 1-44. (Rep: I. Watson) Court
copy.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of April 3,
1978, pages 1-15. (Rep: I. Watson);
Court copy.
FIRST interrogatories of defts. to pltf.; first
request for production of documents.
RESPONSE of defts. to pltfs. motion for in
camera inspection of documents.
131
132
133
May 15
May 15
May 23
13a
PROCEEDINGS
OPPOSITION of defts. to pitfs. motion to
— production of documents; exhibit
MOTION of pitf. for protective order;
memo of P&A’s.
RESPONSE of pitf. to defts. opposition to
pitfs. motion to compel production of
documents.
OPPOSITION of defts. to motion of pitf.
for protective order.
NOTICE by defts. of in ¢amera submis-
sion.
NOTICE by defts. of submission of tran-
scripts.
MOTION of pitf. for production of docu-
ments argued, granted in part and de-
nied in part. Motion of pltf. for a
Hearng order heard and granted.
earing for production of (further)
ouse documents set for 5-26-78
a 4s a.m. (Rep: I. Watson) Ge-
sell, J.
ORDER filed on 5-9-78 granting motion
for pltf. for in camera inspection of
certain documents in possession of GSA;
directing that the Archivist of the U.S.
deliver copies of said documents to the
court for inspection. (N) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed on 5-9-78 granting in ~~
and denying in part motion of pit
compel production of 69 documents; cer-
tain documents to be supplied to pier. by
5-10-78 at 10:00 a.m. (Signed 5-5-
78)(N ) Gesell, J.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of May 5,
1978, pages 1-85. (Rep: I. Watson);
Court copy.
138
139
140
141
142
June 19
June 29
July 5
July 5
July 17
l4a
PROCEEDINGS
ORDER filed on 5-24-78 granting motion
of pitf. for a protective order; directing
that defts. first interrogatories be stricken
without prejudice. (N ) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed on 5-24-78 granting motion
of Richard Nixon for leave to file memo-
randum as amicus curiae. (N ) Gesell, J.
MOTION of pitf. for product ion of docu-
ments heard and taken under advise-
ment. ( Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 6-7-78 denying without prej-
udice plitfs. motion for in camera in-
spection and production of documents.
(N) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 6-16-78 directing that certain
transcripts of White House tape recorded
conversations be delivered to pltf.
FORTHWITH; setting forth certain
directives as to said transcripts; pltf. to
file motion for leave to amend the com-
plaint within 14 days from receipt of the
transcripts. (N ) Gesell, J.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of May 26,
1978, pages 1-47. (Rep: I. Watson);
Court copy.
MOTION of pitf. for leave to file amended
complaint adding Richard M. Nixon,
Bryce N. Harlow and David Packard as
party defts.; memo of P&A's; exhibit;
verification; affidavit of A. Ernest Fitzge-
rald; exhibits A-Q.
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum . of
P&A’s in support of pltfs. inotion for
leave to amend his complaint. (Sealed
pursuant to Court’s order of 6-16-78 and
taken to Courtroom Division. )
STIPULATION extending time through 7-
21-78 within which defts. may respond
to motion for leave to file amended
owe SO ORDERED. (N) Gesell,
145
146
147
148
149
150
July 21
July 21
Aug 11
Sept 8
Sept 14
15a
PROCEEDINGS
AFFIDAVIT of James B. Rhoads with
attachments filed.
COPIES of Nixon Presidential Historical
Materials filed and se-led in large brown
envelope ) by direction of Court. ( Placed
in locked file cabinet. )
TRANSCRIPT of tape recordings within
the Nixon Presidential Historical mate-
rials filed and sealed by direction of the
Court. (Placed in “yo brown envelope
and placed in locked file cabinet. )
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s of defts. in
opposition to plitfs. motion for leave to
amend his first amended complaint; ex-
hibits 1-20.
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum . of
P&A’s of defts. in opposition to plfs.
motion for leave to amend his complaint.
(Sealed and taken to Courtroom Divi-
sion. )
REPLY of pitf. to defts. opposition to pltfs.
motion for leave to amend his first
amended complaint; Appendix; affidavit
of Clark R. Mollenhoff; list of exhibits;
exhibits S, T, U, V, W, X, and Y.
{Sealed and taken to Courtroom Divi-
sion. )
MOTION of pitff. for leave to file amended
complaint heard and granted in part and
denied in part. Granting pltff. per-
mission to add Nixon and Harlow as
party defts. & denying motion as to
adding Parkard as a deft. (Rep. Wat-
son ) Gesell, J.
ORDER denying plitfs. motion for leave to
file amended complaint as to proposed
deft. David Packard and other persons
whose identities are at this time un-
known to plitf.; no additional amend-
ment to add gory will be granted;
further ordered that pltfs. motion for
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
Sept 14
Sept 19
Sept 20
Sept 25
Sept 26
Oct 12
Oct 16
Oct 16
Oct 23
l6a
PROCEEDINGS
leave to file amended complaint is grant-
ed as to proposed defts. Richard M.
Nixon and Bryce N. Harlow; and further
ordered that the amended complaint as
resubmitted in y margins fot th this or-
der be deemed filed as of this date (N)
Gesell, J.
AMENDED complaint adding Richard M.
a and Bryce N. Harlow as party
efts.
SUMMONS (2) and ies (2) of
amended complaint Theos to defts. #3
and 4: #4 NF 10-11-78; #3 ser 10-27-78
FIRST interrogatories of defts. to pltf.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 9-8-78,
pages 1-48. (Rep: I. Watson); Court
copy.
STIPULATION oe 9-25-78 extend-
ing time through 10-23-78 within which
defts. Butterfield and Haldeman may
respond to the second amended com-
plaint, SO ORDERED. (N) Gesell, J.
SUMMONS and copy of second amended
complaint issued to Dennis Dutterer,
US. Atty: serv. 10-13-78.
STIPULATION ss extending time
through 11-21 within which defts.
Nixon and Harlow may respond to the
=“ amended complaint. (N) Gesell,
STIPULATION approved extending time
through 11-3-78 within which pltf. ma
eae first interrogatories. (N) Gessel,
RENEWED motion of defts. #1 and 2 to
dismiss or, in the alternative, for sum-
mary judgement; memo of P&A’s; ex-
hibits 1-3.
161
162
163
164
165
166
Nov. 21
Nov. 22
Nov. 22
Nov. 29
17a
PROCEEDINGS
STIPULATION gue extending time
through 11-17-78 within which pltf. may
reply to the renewed motion to dismiss
or in the alternative for summary judg-
ment. (N ) Gesell, J.
ANSWERS of pltf. to defts’ first Inter-
rogatories; Appendix
MOTION of pitf. for leave to file brief in
excess of page limitations of local Rule
1-9(e); P&A; Exhibit-( Opposition to re-
newed motion of defts. Butterfield &
Haldeman to dismiss or in the alterna-
tive for Summary Judgment; Statement
& attachment) (EXHIBIT UNDER
SEAL)
MOTION of defts. #3 & 4 to dismiss or, in
the alternative, for summary judgment;
P & A; Table of Cases; Statement; Affi-
davit of Richard Nixon & Bryce N.
Harlow as attachment | & 2; Attach-
ments 3, 4, 5, 6,
MOTION = pitf. for leave to file brief in
excess of pa ge limitations of Local Rule
1-9(e). (Fiat) Gesell, J.
OPPOSITION of pitf. to renewed motion
of defts. Butterfield and Haldeman to
dismiss or in the alternative, for sum-
judgement; Table of Contents;
Table of Authorities; Exhibit Z, AA, BB,
CC, DD, EE, FF, GG, HH, II, JJ, KK,
LL, MM. NN, OO, PP, QQ.; Statement.
STIPULATION approved 11-28-78 ex-
tending time ay 12-15-78 within
which pltf. may reply to the motion to
dismiss or in the alternative for summary
judgment filed by defts. Nixon & Har-
low & extending time through 12-29-78
within which all defts. may reply to
pitf.’s opposition to motions to dismiss or
in the alternative for summary judg-
ment. So Ordered. (N) GESELL, J.
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
Dec. 20
Dec. 27
Dec. 27
1979
**Jan. 8
Jan 10
Mar 2
Mar 5
Mar 5
Mar 7
PROCEEDINGS
OPPOSITION of pitfs. to motion to dis-
miss or, in the alternative, for summary
judgment by defts. Nixon & Harlow;
able of Contents; Table of Authorities;
Attachment; Supplemental statement
STIPULATION approved extending time
through 1-8-79 within which defts. may
file oon to motions to dismiss.
(N) ELL, J.
REQUEST ( first) of ow for production of
documents to deft. Nixon.
REQUEST ( first) of ee for production of
documents to deft. Harlow.
MOTION of defts. for leave to file brief in
excess of Page limitations of Local Rule
1-9(e); P & A; Exhibit.
ORDER granting motion of defts. to file
reply to pitfs. —— to renewed
motion of defts. Butterfield and Halde-
man to dismiss or, in the alternative for
summary judgment and to pltfs. opposi-
tion to motion of defts. Nixon and
Harlow to dismiss, or in the alternative
for summary judgment. (N ) Gesell, J.
NOTICE of defts. of submission of tran-
scripts; affidavit of James B. Rhoads;
attachment. (Sealed and taken to Marge
Whitacre, Courtroom Division. )
NOTICE of defts, of submission of post-
argument memorandum linking ele-
ments of pitf.-appellant Fitzgerald’s tort
theories to knowledge acquired within
period of the statute of limitations;
attachment.
MOTIONS argued and taken under ad-
visement. ( Rep: J. Moore) Gesell, J.
CONSENT ORDER filed 3-5-79 removin
seal from certain tape transcripts an
memoranda filed on July 5 and July 21,
177
178
179
180
182
183
184
185
Mar 9
Mar 19
Mar 20
Mar 26
Mar 26
Mar 27
Mar 30
Apr 2
Apr 5
19a
PROCEEDINGS
1978 and on March 2, 1979; vacating
Court’s order of 6-16-78 placing certain
documents under seal. ( N ) Gesell, J.
REPLY of Defts. to pitfs. March 6, 1979
letter regarding the applicability of the
ona of fraudulent concealment to
e ,
MOTION of deft. #3 for enlargement of
time to file a memorandum; supplemen-
tal memorandum. Appearance of
Jeffrey Axelrad and Larry
RESPONSE of pitf. to deft. Nixon’s mo-
tion for enlargement of time.
ORDER granting motion of defts. for an
extension of time; extending time
through 3-27-79 within which to file a
memorandum on the effect of the pardon
of former President Nixon on this suit;
pitf. to reply by 4-3-79. (N ) Gesell, J.
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum of pitf.
in Opposition to defts. motions to dismiss
or, in the alternative, for summary judg-
ment; table of contents table of author-
ities; attachments | and 2.
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum of defts.
regarding the effect of pardon, as re-
quested by the Court, March 5, 1979.
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum of pltf.
regarding the affirmative defense of
Presidential pardon.
MOTION of defts. for enlargement of time
in which to file a reply to piltfs.
supplemental memorandum.
ORDER filed 4-4-79 granting motion of
defts. for an enlargement of time within
which to reply to pltfs. supplemental
memorandum in opposition to defts. mo-
tions to dismiss or in the alternative for
— judgment; extending time
4-17. 9. (N) (Signed 4-3-79)
Gesell J.
189
190
191
192
193
Apr 17
Apr 19
Apr 27
May 2
May 9
May 11
20a
PROCEEDINGS
REPLY of defts. to Bang supplemental
memorandum regarding the affirmative
defense of the presidential pardon.
ORDER filed 4-9-79 striking supplemental
memorandum of defts. regarding the
effect of the pardon filed 3-27-79; direc-
ting that former President Nixon has
waived his defense(s) in this action
based upon his pardon unless he asserts
in isan within 10 days that the pay
absolves him from liability for damages
as alleged. (N ) Gesell, J.
REPLY of defts. to pltfs. supplemental
memorandum in opposition to deft mo-
tion to dismiss, or in the alternative, for
summary judgment.
RESPONSE of pltf. to defts. reply to pitfs.
supplemental memorandum in opposi-
tion to defts. motion to dismiss or, in the
alternative, for summary judgment.
LETTER dated 3-6-79 with attachment to
Court from Peter Raven-Hensen.
ORDER filed 4-27-79 denying in part and
granting in part motions of defts. to
dismiss or, in the alternative, for sum-
mary judgment; dismissing pltfs. claim
under the 9th Amendment, his claim for
unconstitutional and common Jaw in-
vasion of eat and his claims under
42 USC 1985(3) and 1986; withholding
ruling as to whether pltf. stakes a cause
of action under the fifth amendment.
(N )Gesell, J.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 3-5-79;
Pages | through 94; (Rep: J. Moore);
court copy.
STIPULATION whereby counsel agree
that defts. Butterfield, Nixon and Har-
low shall have through 5-22-79 within
which to respond to the second amended
——— O ORDERED. (N) Gesell,
201
202
203
204
May 23
May 24
May 24
2la
PROCEEDINGS
MOTION by piltf. to take deposition by
other than stenographic means; P&A
es set of interrogatories to deft. #3 by
pitf.
FIRST set of interrogatories by pltf. to
deft. #4.
FIRST set of interrogatories by pltf. to
deft. #1.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of
Harold Brown; attachments (2).
NOTICE of pitf. to take deposition of
= Evan Timmons; attachments
MOTION of defts. #1, 3, and 4 for enlarge-
ment of time to respond to the second
amended complaint and for a stay of all
proceedings; memo of P&A’s.
MOTION of defts. #1, 3, and 4 for a stay of
all proceedings pending this Court’s
determination on defts. motion for an
enlargement of time to respond to the
second amended complaint and for a
stay of all proceedings.
OPPOSITION of defts. to pitfs. motion to
take depositions by other than steno-
graphic means.
WITHDRAWAL of appearance of Jeffrey
Axelrad as counsel for deft. #3. CD/N.
withdrawal of appearance of Mark A.
Landman 2* atty. for same deft. and
withdraw appearance of Jonathan B.
Smith as counsel for all defts. (no longer
with the Dept. of Justice ).
SUPPLEMENTAL memorandum of defts.
in support of opposition to pitfs. motion
to take depositions by other than steno-
graphic means.
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
May 29
May 30
May 31
June |
June |
June 4
June 4
June 4
June 4
June 5
June 18
22a
PROCEEDINGS
STATUS CALL. Motion of defts. for
extension and stay to answer amended
complaint denied. Pltfs. application to
take depositions by other than steno-
graphic means, denied. All Counsel to
complete depositions by 9-1-79. (Rep: I.
Watson ) Gesell, J.
REPLY of pltf. to defts. opposition to pltfs.
motion to take depositions by other than
stenographic means; attachments A and
B; affidavit of A. Ernest Fitzgerald.
ANSWER of deft. Nixon to second
amended complaint. Appearance of
Herbert J. Miller, R. Stan Mortenson,
and Stephen L. Nightingale.
APPEARANCES of Herbert J. Miller, Jr.,
R. Stan Mortenson, & Stephen L. Night-
ingale as counsel for deft. Nixon, CD/N
ANSWER of deft. #1 to second amended
complaint. 4 gp of Jeffrey Ax-
elrad and Mark S. Landman.
ANSWER of deft. #2 to second amended
complaint.
—— of deft. #3 to take deposition of
pitf.
REQUEST of deft. #3 for production of
documents by pltf.
FIRST set of interrogatories by deft. #3.
STIPULATION for defts. Butterfield and
Harlow extending time through 6-1-79
within which defts. may respond to sec-
ond amended complaint, approved. (N)
Gesell, J.
STATUS CALL. Deposition of William
Timmons to be taken by tape recorder as
scheduled. Deposition of defts. to be
taken by regular stenographic methods.
(Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
ANSWERS of deft. #4 to pltfs. first set of
interrogatories.
229
Date
1979
June 18
June 20
June 26
June 26
June 26
June 26
June 27
June 28
July 3
July 3
July 5
July 9
July 9
23a
PROCEEDINGS
ANSWERS of deft. #1 to pltfs. first set of
interrogatories.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of
David G. Wilson; attachments (2).
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of Jack
L. Stempler; attachment.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of
Melvin R. Laird; attachment.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of Dr.
Henry A. Kissinger; attachment.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of
Robert C. Seamans, Jr.; attachment.
REVISED notice of pitf. to take deposition
of Jack L. Stempler; attachment.
ANSWERS of deft. #3 to pltfs. first set of
interrogatories; exhibit A.
MOTION of deft. #2 for entry of an order
of judgment; memo of P&A’s.
NOTICE of deft. Nixon to take deposition
of Frederick Graboske; attachments (2 ).
NOTICE of = to take deposition of
William W. Woodruff; attachment.
ORDER filed 7-2-79 granting pitf. per-
mission to take depositions by other than
stenographic (tape recording) until such
time as any party withdraws his consent
to arrangement. (N) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 7-5-79 directing that the
Court’s Order of 7-2-79 be amended by
substituting the following language for
that appearing in lines 9, 10 and 11 of
the first jesecen “on June 28, 1979,
that the Timmons deposition ultimately
resulted in a transcript acceptable to
parties after review by counsel for defts.,
discussions among all counsel, and revi-
sions in the draft transcript, and that all
counsel agree to have further depos-
itions. . .” (N ) Gesell, J.
236
237
238
239
240
241
July 11
July 18
Ju'y 20
July 23
July 24
24a
PROCEEDINGS
ANSWERS of pltf. to deft. #3’s second set
of interrogatories.
SECOND set of interrogatories of pltf. to
deft. #1.
SECOND set of interrogatories of plitf. to
deft. #4.
SECOND set of interrogatories of pltf. to
deft. #3.
AMENDED notice of deft. #3 to take
deposition of Frederick Graboske.
CANCELLATION of deposition notices to
take depositions of Melvin R. Laird,
Jack L. Stempler, He A. Kissinger
and Robert C. Seamans, Jr. by ptf.
STIPULATION whereby counsel for pitf.
and deft. Heldeman agree that the ptf.
will have through 7-23-79 within which
to respond to motion for entry of an
pa of Judgment, approved. (N) Ge-
sell, J.
MOTION to pitf. to disqualify the Dept. of
Justice from representing deponents and
parties herein; memo of P&A’s; attach-
ment.
Deposition of William E. Timmons taken
on 6-15-79 for pltf.; notice of filing;
original tape cassettes (3). (sealed and
laced in vault in Room 1800). (Error)
ibits 1-20.
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s of defts. in
opposition to pitfs. motion to disqualify
the Dept. of Justice from representing
— and parties herein; exhibits A-
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s of pitf. in
— to deft. #2’s motion for entry
of an order of judgment.
NOTICE of pltf. to take deposition of Jeb
Stuart Magruder; attachment.
25a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE of defts. #1 and 4 for suomission
of affidavit of Thomas W. Nelson; exhib-
its 1-4,
WITHDRAWAL of appearance of Sharon
M. Williams and appearance of John C.
Keeney, Jr. as counsel for pltf. CD/N
RENEWED motion of plitf. to compel pro-
duction of document from GSA; memo
of P&A’s; attachments A and B.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 6-5-79,
pages 1-18. (Rep: I. Watson); Court
copy.
SUPPLEMENTAL answer to pitf. to deft.
#3’s second set of interrogatories.
REPLY of defts. to pitfs. opposition to
deft. #2’s motion for entry of an order of
judgment.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 5-24-79,
pages 1-26. (Rep: I. Watson); Court
copy.
AMENDED notice of deft. #3 to take
deposition of ptf.
ORDER filed 7-31-79 denying motion of
pitf. to disqualify the Department of
Justice from representing deponents and
parties. (N ) Gesell, J.
OBJECTION of deft #1 to pltfs. second set
of interrogatories.
OBJECTION of deft. #3 to pitfs. second set
of interrogatories.
OBJECTION of deft. #4 to pitfs. second set
of interrogatories.
STIPULATION AND ORDER filed 8-8-
79 extending time to 8-13-79 for defts. to
respond to renewed motion to compel.
(N) Penn, J.
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
1979
Aug. 13
Aug. 16
Aug. 24
Aug. 27
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 28
Aug. 30
Aug. 30
26a
PROCEEDINGS
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s by deft in
opposition to pitf’s. renewed motion to
compel production of document from
General Services Administration; attach-
ment; attachments I & II.
NOTICE by deft #2 to take deposition of
Clark Mollenhoff; attachment.
NOTICE of pitf. to take oral deposition of
General Services Administration; attach-
ment.
REQUEST (first) of pltf. for admissions;
exhibits 1-82.
REQUEST of deft. that this Court exercise
its discretion to strike immaterial and
impertinent allegations from pltf’s. sec-
ond amended complaint; P&A’s; attach-
ments A and B.
NOTICE of deft. to take the oral depos-
ition of Richard F. Kaufman; attach-
ment.
NOTICE of deft. to take the oral depos-
ition of Robert Riggs; attachment.
NOTICE of deft. to take the oral depos-
ition of Ronald L. Tammen; attachment.
NOTICE of deft. to take the oral depos-
ition of Peter Stockton; attachment.
NOTICE by = to take oral deposition of
Robert C. Seamans, Jr.; attachment.
NOTICE by ptf. to take oral deposition of
Joseph Adams; attachment.
NOTICE by ptf. to take oral deposition of
Richard M. Nixon.
NOTICE by ptf. to take oral deposition of
Bryce N. Harlow.
NOTICE by pltff. to take deposition of
Nancy Brady; attachment.
NOTICE by piltff. to take deposition of
Harriet Zimmerly; attachment.
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
Sept. 7
Sept 7
27a
PROCEEDINGS
REVISED notice by pltf. to take deposition
of Joseph Adams; attachment.
MOTION of | to terminate discovery
and to set dates for final motions, pre-
trial, and trial; memo of P&A’s.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of
H.R. Haldeman; attachment.
RESPONSE by deft. #3 to pltfs. motion to
terminate discovery and to set dates for
final motions, pretrial and trial.
REPLY memorandum by pltf. in support
of his renewed motion to ? production of
— from GSA; attachments A and
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s by defts. #1
and 4 in opposition to pltfs. motion to
terminate discovery and to set dates for
final motions pretrial, and trial; attach-
ment I.
REVISED notice to take deposition of Jeb
Stuart Magruder by pltf.; attachment.
NOTICE by deft. #3 to take deposition of
David S. Julyan; attachment
RESPONSE by pitf. to deft. #1’s request
that this Court exercise its discretion to
strick immaterial and impertinent allega-
tions from pitfs. second amended com-
plaint; attachment.
NOTICE by ptf. to take deposition of the
ay Dept. of the Air Force; attachments
).
STATUS CALL. Pitf. to submit
particularization statement by 10-19-79;
defts. to submit particularization state-
ment by 10-30- _further status call set
for 11-7-79 at 4:00 p.m.; trial set for 6-2-
80 at 9:30 a.m. Motion of defts. to enter
an order of judgment as to Haldeman
granted; pects | motion of pitf. for
release of certain document (Dean),
granted. (Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
283
284
285
286
287
288
Sept. 13
Sept 13
Sept. 13
Sept. 14
Sept. 17
Sept. 18
28a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE by deft. regarding oral depos-
itions.
ORDER filed 9-7-79 granting motion of
defts. for entry of an Order of Judgment
as to deft. Haldeman; directing that
of judgment be made FORTH-
dismissing the action as to said
deft. (N) Gesell, J
ORDER filed 9-7-79 granting motion of
pitf. to compel the relase of document A-
—. for discovery purposes. (N) Ge-
sell, J.
ORDER filed 9-7-79 denying motion of
pitf. to terminate discovery and to set
dates for final motions, pretrial and trial
discovery will terminate 10-7-79, pltf. to
file a particularized statement of his the-
ory of the case by 10-19-79, not to
exceed 20 pages; defts, to file particula-
rized statement(s) of their theories of
defense by 10-13-79, not to exceed 10
Pages; setting a status conference on 11-
7- 4 tt gua ; Setting trial for 6-2-80.
(N) Gesell,
NOTICE by deft, #3 that the depositions of
Peter Stockton, Richard F. Kaufman,
Ronald L. Tammen and Julian Julyan
previously noticed for Sept. 10, 12, 13
and 14, 1979 have been postponed and
that the deposition of Robert Riggs
noted for 9-11-79 has been cancelled.
REVISED notice by pltf. to take deposition
of Jeb Stuart Magruder; attachment.
MOTION by Jeb Stuart Magruder for a
rotective order continuing his depos-
ition until 10-8-78; memo of P&A’s.
JUDGMENT filed 9-17-79 for deft. H.R.
Halderman against pltf. A. Ernest
Fitzgerald and dismissing the complaint
as to said deft. (N) Gesell, J.
293
294
295
296
297
Sept. 21
Sept. 21
Sept. 25
Sept. 25
Sept. 25
29a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of
John Dean; attachment.
REVISED notice by pltf. to take deposition
of deft. Bryce N. Harlow.
SECOND revised notice by pltf. to take
deposition of Jeb Stuart Magruder;
attachment.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon with respect
to the release of White House documents
and asserted claims of privilege with
respect thereto.
UNREDACTED set of documents L1, S1,
$2, 83, $4, S6, S7, Al, L1*, L2, L3, L4,
LS, L6, and L7 filed and sealed by
direction of the Court. ( placed in vault).
COPY of redacted documents produced to
pitf. Fitzgerald on Sept. 11, 1979 filed
and sealed by direction of the Court.
(placed in vault)
ORDER filed 9-21-79 granting motion of
Jeb Stuart Magruder continuing his de-
position; continuing said deposition until
10-8-79 at the offices of Hogan & Hart-
son; modifying Court’s order of 9-7-79
rediscovery schedule to the extent con-
sistent with this Order; discovery will
terminate at the conclusion of Magru-
der’s deposition. (N ) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 9-21-79 upholding deft. Nix-
on’s objections to production of certain
documents; directing that production to
pltf. will be limited to the redacted set of
documents that deft. Nixon has S.
viously transmitted to pltf. (N) Gesell
ORDER filed 9-21-79 denying request of
deft. Nixon that the Court exercise its
discretion to strike certain allegations
from the second amended complaint.
(N) Gesell, J.
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
Oct. 5
Oct. 9
Oct. 11
Oct. 15
Oct. 15
Oct. 19
Oct. 22
Oct 22
30a
PROCEEDINGS
RESPONSE by defts. #1 and 4 to pltfs.
first request for admissions.
ANSWERS and objections by deft. Nixon
to pltfs. first request for admissions.
MOTION of pitf. for an order establishing
a final production date for documents in
the custody of any party; memo of
P&A’s; attachments 1-5.
NOTICE of appeal by pltf. from Order of
9-7-79, $5.00 paid and credited to U.S.
Copies mailed to Mark S. Landman and
R. Stan Mortenson.
COPIES of notice of oar and docket
sheets transmitted to USCA. USCA #79-
$65.00 USCA docketing fee paid and cred-
ited to U.S.
DEPOSITION of David G. Wilson taken
7-12-79; exhibits 21-26.
NOTICE by pltf. that the signed transcript
of the deposition of David G. Wilson
with exhibits and original tape cassettes
(2) have been filed with the Court on
this date.
ORIGINAL tape cassettes (2) by pltf.
OPPOSITION of deft. #3 to pltfs. motion
for an order establishing a final produc-
tion date for documents in the custody of
any party.
MORE particularized statement of claim
by pitf.; Appendix; attachments A-D.
MOTION by pitf. for an order that certain
of pitfs. requested admissions be deemed
admitted by deft. Nixon; memo of
P&A’s; attachment.
ERRATA by ptf. to page 3 of pltfs. more
particulanized statement claim filed 10-
19-79; page 3 attached.
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
Oct. 29
Oct. 30
Oct. 31
Nov. 6
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
Nov. 8
3la
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE by defts. of submission of affida-
vit; affidavit of H.R. Haldeman.
ORDER filed 10-25-79 wert g motion of
pitf. for an order establishing a final
production date for documents without
prejudice. (N ) Gesell, J.
RESPONSE by deft. Nixon to pitfs. mo-
tion that certain of pltfs. requested
admissions be deemed admitted.
NOTICE by pitf. of filing of deposition;
transcript of deposition; exhibits 27, 28-
A & B, 29-A & B, 30, 31(A), 32, 33, 34,
35, 36(A) 36(B), 38 (A) & (B), 39-
41(A), 41(B) & 42; Mei deposition of
William W. Woodruff (4).
PARTICULARIZED STATEMENT by
defts. of their theories of defense to
pltf’s. causes of action; appendix; exhibit
47; attachments | thru 9.
REPLY by pltf. to deft. #3’s response to
pitfs. motion that certain of pitfs. re-
quested admissions be deemed admitted.
NOTICE OF SUBMISSION OF AFFIDA-
VIT; Affidavit of Lloyd H. Cornett, Jr.;
Exh. A.
ver gg REPORT of pitfs.; Attachments
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS of
9/7/79; courts copy pg. 1-70 reporter;
Ida Z. Watson.
DEPOSITION of A. Ernest Fitzgerald tak-
en 8/14/79 for the deft.
DEPOSITION OF A. Ernest Fitzgerald
taken 8/16/79 for the deft.
DEPOSITION of A. Ernest Fitzgerald tak-
en 8/16/79 for the deft.
DEPOSITION of Arthur Ernest Fitzgerald
taken 8/17/79 for the deft.
DEPOSITION of Arthur Ernest Fitzgerald
taken 8/20/79 for the deft.
32a
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of Arthur Ernest Fitzgerald
taken 8/21/79 for the deft;
DEPOSITION of A. Ernest Fitzgerald tak-
en 8/27/79 for the deft.
DEPOSITION of A. Ernest Fitzgerald tak-
en 8/28/79 for the deft; exhibits.
STATUS report by deft. Nixon.
RECORD on appeal delivered to USCA;
receipt ackn.
DEPOSITION of Clark R. Mollenhoff tak-
en on 8-23-79.
DEPOSITION of Clark R. Mollenhoff tak-
en on 8-23- and 8-24-79 ( Exhibits 38-72
of Nixon; 73 and 73-B thru 73E of
Harlow and Butterfield); pltfs. exhibits
43-46).
DEPOSITION of CLARK R. MOLLEN-
HOFF taken on 8-24-79.
DEPOSITION of Robert C. Seamans, Jr.
taken on 9-18-79 for pitf., Vol. I.
DEPOSITION of Robert C. Seamans, Jr.
~— taken on 9-19-79 for pltf.,
ol. II.
DEPOSITION of Robert C. Seamans, Jr.
if ee taken on 9-21-79 for pitf.,
ol, III.
AGREEMENT of voluntary dismissal of
appeal with each party paying its respec-
tive costs.
SECOND set of interrogatories by defts. #1
and 4 to pitf.
ORDER FILED 11-19-79, denying pltf's
motion for an order that certain of pltf’s
requested admissions be deemed admit-
ted by deft. Nixon directing deft. Nixon,
to furnish plitf. by 12-10-79 those docu-
ments or portions thereof of the 106
pages of documents located by the Ar-
chivist in response to pltf’s August sub-
33a
PROCEEDINGS
poena duces tecum or file such docu-
ments of portions thereof with the Court,
in Camera, accompanied by a submis-
sion setting forth his objections to Es
duction to the extent practicable, which
shall be served to the pltf.; defts’ witness
list shall be updated by 12-10-79; deft
Nixon, shall produce Py 12-10-79 all
entries in the presidential daily logs for
November and December, 1969, and
January, 1970, reflecting commu-
nications with Bryce Harlow, Melbin
Laird, Robert C. Seamans, Jr,. or David
Packlard; parties to exchange lists of all
persons each desires to depose by 1-7-80;
deft., Nixon, shall notify Archives by 1-
7-80 of any documents which he seeks
relevant to this action; defts. shall notice
and complete all discovery going to
issues of liability in this case, including
Magruder deposition by 2-8-80; any
summary judgment motions or other
pretrial motions directed to any aspect of
this case; responses to pretrial motions
shall be filed by 2029080; replies to
responses by 3-8-80; oral argument of all
nding motions set for 3-21-80 at 2:00
.M. first Pretrial Conference set for 5-2-
80 at 9:30 A.M. at which time parties
shall submit a final witness list and
copies of all documents which they in-
tend to introduce at trial; second pretrial
set for 5-12-80 at 9:30 A.M. at which
time parties to submit proposed jury
instructions proposed voir dire questions,
and all evidentary objections previously
exchanged; final pretrial conference set
for 5-22-80 at 9:30 A.M.; Trial begin 6-
2-80 at 9:30 A.M. (N) Gesell J.
339 Nov.26 NOTICE by pitf. that the signed transcript
of the deposition of Joan L. Howard
— exhibits has been filed with the
urt.
353
Dec. 4
34a
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of Joan Lee Howard taken
on 9-12-79.
ORIGINAL tape cassette (1) of deposition
of Joan Lee Howard.
EXHIBITS 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, and
56 by pltf.
HEARING on motion. (OTBP) Rep: T.
Eckstone ) Gesell, J.
NOTICE by ptf. of filing of depesition.
DEPOSITION of Harriet Zimmerly taken
9-6-79.
ORIGINAL tape cassettes (2) of depos-
ition of Harriet Zimmerly.
EXHIBITS 24, 45, 46, 47 to deposition of
Harriet Zimmerly.
SECOND request by pltf. for production of
documents to deft. #4.
SECOND request by pitf. for production of
documents to deft. #3.
SECOND request by pitf. for production of
documents to deft. } l.
NOTICE by pitf. of filing of deposition
exhibits of Robert C. Seamans, Jr.
EXHIBITS 63, 64, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75. 76,
77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85. 86, 87,
88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98,
99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106,
107, 108, 109, 110, 114, 112, 113, 114,
115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122,
123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130,
131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138,
139, 140-145 to deposition of Robert C.
Seamans, Jr. (in manila envelope).
MOTION by pitf. for an order directing
Jeb Stuart Magruder to appear for the
— of his deposition; memo of
’s.
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
1979
Dec. 6
Dec. 6
Dec. 7
Dec. 7
Dec. 7
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
Dec. 10
35a
PROCEEDINGS
ORIGINAL record (11 vols., 12 vols.)
under 3 covers, 20 depositions, 4 manila
envelope of exhibits, | small expandable
folder 2 tapes, | manila envelope with 4
meet, 2 brown expandable folders of
exhibits, | appendix with 3 rubberbands
returned from USCA; receipt ackn.
NOTICE by ptf. of filing deposition exhib-
its. (in manila folder)
EXHIBITS 65, 66 and 70 to deposition of
Robert C. Seamans, Jr.
NOTICE by pitf. of filing of deposition.
DEPOSITION of Joseph John Adams tak-
en 9-12-79; exhibits 57-62.
ORIGINAL tape cassettes (2) of depos-
ition of Joseph John Adams (in manila
envelope ).
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of Melvin R. Laird; attachment.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of Harold Brown; attachment.
NOTICE by de®. Nixon to take deposition
of Henry A. Kissinger; attachment.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon regarding
identification of trial witnesses.
AMENDED answers by deft. Nixon and
objections to certain paragraphs of pitfs.
first request for admissions.
NOTICE by pif. of filing of deposition.
DEPOSITION of Nancy Brady taken 9-6-
79; exhibit 48.
ORIGINAL tape cassettes (2) of depos-
ition of Nancy Brady (in manila enve-
lope ).
SUPPLEMENTAL answers by defts. #1
and 4 to pitfs. first set of interrogatories.
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
Dec. 19
Dec. 19
Dec. 20
Dec. 20
Dec. 20
Dec. 21
Dec. 21
Dec. 21
Dec. 26
Dec. 27
1980
Jan. 2
Jan. 3
Jan. 4
36a
PROCEEDINGS
MOTION of pitf. for an order directing Jeb
Stuart Magruder to appear for the con-
tinuation of his deposition heard and
granted ( Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 12-17-79 that deposition of
Jeb Stuart Magruder be continued on
12-21-79 at 10:00 a.m. in offices of Ho-
gan & Hartson, 815 Conn. Ave., N.W.,
Wash., D.C.; directing that Jeb Stuart
Magruder appear at the foregoing time
and place (See order for further details. )
(N) Flannery, J.
THIRD set of interrogatories by pltf. to
defts.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of Ronald Ziegler; attachment.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of PAtrick Buchanan; attachment.
THIRD set of interrogatories by defts. #1
and 4 to pitf.
SECOND request for admissions by pltf. to
defts. Butterfield, Harlow and Nixon;
attachment.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of U.S.
Dept. of Defense; attachments (2).
AMENDED notice by pitf. to take depos-
ition of Melvin R. Laird.
DEPOSITION of Richard Nixon taken 10-
2 and 10-3-79 for pltf.; exhibits.
FIRST request by defts. #1 and 4 for
admissions by pltf.
RESPONSE by deft. Nixon to pltfs. second
request for production of documents.
NOTICE by ptf. to take deposition of Jeb
Stuart Magruder.
SUBMISSION by pltf. regarding identi-
fication of trial witnesses.
395
396
Jan 8
Jan 4
Jan 4
Jan 8
37a
PROCEEDINGS
THIRD set of interrogatories by deft. Nix-
on to pitf.
THIRD request by piltf. to defts.
Butterfield, Harlow and Nixon for
admissions; exhibits 83, 84, 85, 86, 87,
88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98,
99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106,
107, 108, 109, 110, 111 and 112.
RESPONSE by deft. Butterfield to pltfs.
second request for documents
RESPONSE by deft. Harlow to pltfs. sec-
ond request for documents.
FOURTH set of interrogatories by pltf. to
defts.
LIST of individuals by defts. Butterfield
and Harlow they presently intend to
depose.
SUBMISSION by pitf. of deponent list.
SECOND request by defts. Butterfield and
— for production of documents to
pitf.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 11-16-
79, pages 1-75. (Rep: T. Eckstone);
Court copy.
DEPOSITION of Byrce N. Harlow taken
10-5 and 10-6, 1979; correction sheet.
ORDER filed 1-4-80 sustaining deft. Nix-
on’s objection to further disclosure of
any of “49 papers”; directing the Clerk
of Court to file under seal deft. Nixon’s
submission entitled ““Unredacted Set of
Documents”. (N ) Gesell, J.
UNREDACTED/documents filed and
sealed and placed in vault.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon with respect
to release of White House documents.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon concerning
deponents.
410
411
412
_ 413
414
38a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE by pltf. to take oral deposition;
attachment.
NOTICE by pltf. to take oral deposition;
attachments (2).
NOTICE by defts. to take deposition.
AMENDED notices by deft. Nixon, of oral
deposition.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Dwight Chapin.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Robert P. Mayo.
NOTICE by defts. 1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Colonel John Badin, Jr.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Larry Higby.
AMENDED notice by defts. #1 and 4 to
take deposition of Robert P. Mayo.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of John D. Ehrlichman.
ERRATA from the list of deponents served
by Mr. Nixon on 1-7-80 Charles Peters,
Ralph Nader and Stewart Mott.
SUBMISSION by deftfs. #1 and 4 regar-
ding identification of potential trial wit-
nesses.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of James R. Schlesinger.
—— of trial witnesses by
pitf.
RESPONSE by defts. #1 and 4 to pitfs.
second request for admission.
SECOND submission by deft. Nixon regar-
ding identification of trial witnesses.
RESPONSE by deft, Nixon to pitfs. second
request for admissions.
DEPOSITION of Patrick J. Buchanan tak-
en 1-15-80 for deft. Nixon; exhibits.
39a
PROCEEDINGS
NOTICE by ptf. to take deposition of
GSA; attachment.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of
Office of Management and Budget;
attachment.
NOTICE by pltf. to take deposition of U.S.
Dept. of Energy; attachment.
DEPOSITION of Harry R. Haldeman tak-
en 9-27-79 for pltf.; exhibits.
NOTICE by pltf. of cancelling deposition
of Jeb Stuart Magruder.
AMENDED notice by pltf. to take depos-
ition of Robert E. Pursley.
NOTICE by defts. to take deposition of
Egil Krogh.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Richard Nixon.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of H.R. Haldeman.
ANSWER by pitf. to first request for
admissions by defts. #1 and 4.
CANCELLATION by pltf. of deposition
notice to take deposition of William J.
Baroody, Jr.
REVISED notice by defts. #1 and 4 to take
deposition of Robert P. Mayo.
STIPULATION that any party may take
the deposition of Colonel John Badin, Jr.
on liability and/or damages at ys time
ae to 5-2-80, so ordered. (N) Gesell,
AMENDED notice by deft. Nixon of de-
position of Melvin R. Laird.
NOTICE by sc to take deposition of
David G Wilson; attachment.
ANSWERS by piltf. to deft. Nixon’s third
set of interrogatories.
MOTION by defts. #1 and 4 for enlarge-
ment of time for all parties to file sum-
mary judgment motions or other pre-
trial motions.
44]
442
Feb. 8
Feb. 8
Feb. 11
Feb. 11
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of James R. Schlesinger
taken 1-18-80 for defts.
MOTION by the Secretary of Defense,
Harold Brown, for protective order;
memorandum
SUBMISSION by defts. #1 and 4 regar-
ding identification of expert witnesses.
RESPONSE by defits. #1 and 4 to pitfs.
third request for admissions.
RESPONSE by deft. #3 to pltfs. third
request for admissions.
SUBMISSION by deft. #3 regarding ex-
perts.
RESPONSE by deft. #3 to motion for
protective order.
RESPONSE by piltf. to defts. #1 and 4’s
second request for production of docu-
ments.
MOTION by pitf. for an order compelling
production of documents by deft. Nixon;
memo of P&A’s; attachment 1; exhibits
A,B, and C.
MOTION by piltf. for order compelling
defts. answer to pltfs. second set of inter-
ren: memo of P&A’s; exhibits A-
DEPOSITION of Ronald A. Ziegler taken
1-14-80 for deft. Nixon; exhibit 222. -
ORDER files 2-8-90 granting motion of
defts. for enlargement of time within
which to file summary judgment motions
or other pretrial matters; extending time
through 2-11-80.
DEPOSITION of John Ehrlichman taken
2-4-80; index of exhibits; exhibits (at-
tached to deposition ).
447
448
449
450
451
452
Feb. 11
Feb. 11
Feb. 11
Feb 11
Feb 11
Feb 12
Feb 12
4la
PROCEEDINGS
SUBMISSION by Richard Nixon con-
cerning his pretrial motions and the state
of the record in this case; consolidated
statement of material facts; attachment
(in black binder with tabs).
MOTION by deft. Nixon for summary
judgment based upon the statute of limi-
tations; table of contents and authorities;
memo of P&A’s
MOTION by deft. Nixon for summary
judgment on grounds of immunity and
the absence of wrongful conduct; table
of contents and authorities; memo-
randum.
MOTION by deft. Nixon to dismiss for
failure to state a claim under the Fifth
Amendment or, alternatively, for partial
summary judgment; table of contents
and authorities; memo of P&A’s.
MOTION by deft. Nixon for partial sum-
mary judgment as to pltfs. allegations
concerning the OSI inquiry, punitive
damages, intentional infliction of mental
distress, and interference with advan-
tageous economic relationships; table of
contents and authorities; memorandum
of P&A’s.
MOTION by defts. #1 and 4 for leave to
file brief in excess of page limitations of
Local Rule 1-9(e); of P&A’s.
ORDER granting defts. Butterfield and
Harlow leave to file brief in excess of
page limitations and memorandum of
points and authorities thereof in support
of motion for summary judgment. (N)
Gesell, J.
MOTION by defts. #1 and 4 for summary
judgment; exhibits; memorandum of
P&A’s; attachments 1, 2, and 3; state-
ment of material facts.
462
463
Feb 25
42a
PROCEEDINGS
ORDER granting motion of defts.
Butterfield and Harlow for leave to file
their memorandum of P&A’s in excess of
thirty-five pages in support of motion for
summary judgment. (N ) Gesell, J.
RESPONSE by pitf. to Secretary Brown’s
motion for protective order.
DEPOSITION of Melvin Laird taken 2-1-
80; exhibit list; exhibits.
ORDER nting motion of Harold
Brown, tary of Defense, for a
protective order subject to certain condi-
tions. (See order for further details. )
(N) Geseil, J.
DEPOSITION of Henry A. Kissinger taken
1-25-80 for deft. Nixon; exhibits.
MOTION by pitf. for enlargement of page
limitations; memo of P&A’s.
JOINT motion for extension of briefing
dates; memo of P&A’s.
DEPOSITION of Robert P. Mayo taken 1-
31-80; exhibits attached.
NOTICE by pitf. of filing of deposition;
attachment; exhibits 215 thru 221; taped
depositions (2) of Jeb Stuart Magruder.
NOTICE by defts. to take oral deposition
of Roy Anderson.
ORDER granting joint motion for exten-
sion of briefing dates; and extending
time for filing responses to pretrial mo-
tions from 2-29-80 to 3-3-80 and extend-
ing time for filing replies to such respon-
- from 3-8-80 to 3-11-80. (N) Gesell,
ORDER granting motion of pltf. for
enlargement of page limitations and av- .
thorizing pitf. to file a single, consoli-
dated memorandum of points and au-
thorities, not to exceed 157 pages in
length. (N ) Gesell, J.
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
Mar 4
Mar 4
Mar 4
Mar 4
Mar 4
Mar 7
Mar 7
Mar 11
43a
PROCEEDINGS
OPPOSITION by defts. #1 and 4 to motion
for order compelling defts. answers to
pitfs. second set of interrogatories.
MEMORANDUM of P&A'’s by deft. Nix-
on in opposition to plitfs. motion for an
order compelling production of docu-
ments.
MEMORANDUM of P&A’s by deft. Nix-
‘on in opposition to plitfs, motion to com-
pel answers to pltfs, second set of inter-
rogatiories.
DEPOSITION of Egil Krogh taken on 2-7-
80; exhibits 175-180 (in manila envelope
attached to deposition ).
DEPOSITION of H. R. Haldeman taken
on 2-7-80; exhibits 262 and 181 (in
manila envelope attached to deposition ).
DEPOSITION of Alexander M. Haig tak-
en on 1-27-80 for defts.; exhibits.
SUBMISSION by pltf. regarding his oppo-
sition to defts. summary judgment mo-
tions; statement of genuine issues; oppo-
sition by pitf. to deft. Nixon’s and deft.
Harlow’s second and deft. Butterfield’s
third motions for summary judgment;
exhibits and attachments list; opposition
pitf. to deft. Nixon’s and deft. Har-
low’s second and deft. Butterfield’s third
motions for summary judgment; affida-
vit of A. Ernest Fitzgerald; exhibits. and
attachments A- in black binder).
(Submissions and exhibits all in brown
manila folder. )
DEPOSITION of Richard F. Kaufman
taken on 2-1-80 for deft. Nixon.
EXHIBITS to deposition of Richard F.
Kaufman (in yellow binder).
REPLY by pitf. to deft. Nixon’s opposition
to motion for an order compelling pro-
duction of documents.
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
Mar 11
Mar 11
Mar 11
Mar 11
Mar 11
Mar 11
Mar 12
Mar 13
PROCEEDINGS
MOTION by deft. Nixon for extension of
time within which to file a reply to
Fitzgerald’s opposition to deft. Nixon’s
motion for summary judgment; memo of :
P&A’s.
REPLY by deft. Nixon to pitfs. opposition
with regard to the OSI inquiry, punitive
damages, intentional infliction of mental
distress, and interference with advan-
tageous economic relationships.
REPLY by deft. Nixon to pltfs. opposition
to motion for failure to state a claim
under the Fifth Amendment or, alterna-
tively, for partial summary judgment.
REPLY by deft. Nixon to pitfs. opposition
to motion for summary Judgment based
. the statute of limitations; attachment
REPLY by pltf. to defts. oppositions to
motion for order compelling defts. an-
swers to pltfs. second set of inter-
rogatories.
REPLY by deft. Butterfield to pits. caper
tion to deft. Nixon and deft. Harlow’s
second and deft. Butterfield’s third mo-
ine for summary judgment; attachment
REPLY by deft. Harlow to plitfs. opposi-
tion to deft. Nixon and deft. Harlow’s
second and deft. Butterfield’s third mo-
tion for summary judgment; exhibits
A,B,C, DX45 and DX 62.
REPLY by deft. Nixon to pltfs. opposition
with regard to immunity and absence of
wrongful conduct; attachment.
ORDER granting motion for extension of
time; extending time through 3-12-80
within which replies to plitfs. opposition
to the apes Bi motions for summary
judgment may be filed. ( N ) Gesell, J.
486
489
490
491
492
493
Mar 21
Mar 24
Mar 24
Mar 24
Mar 24
Mar 26
45a
PRoOcEEDINGS
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon of depos-
ition citations.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon of a chart
concerning the undisputed issues in this
case; attachment.
SUBMISSION of corrections by pltf. to
deft. Nixon’s chart concerning the
undisputed facts in this case; attachment.
SUPPLEMENTATION of record by pltf.
in response to defts. replies to pltfs.
Opposition to motions for summary judg-
ment with respect to the statute of limita-
tions; —— A; attachment; attach-
ment B.
MOTIONS heard and taken under advise-
ment. ( Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
SUPPLEMENTAL answers by pltf. to in-
terrogatory 84 of defts. first inter-
rogatories and ae 15 of deft.
Nixon’s secons set of interrogatories;
Appendices A, B, and C.
SUPPLEMENTAL answer by pitf. to in-
terrogatory NO. 4 of deft. Nixon’s third
set of interrogatories.
DEPOSITION of Roy A. Anderson taken
on 2-29-80.
ORDER granting in a and denying in
part motion of pltf. for an order com-
pelling production of documents; grant-
ed as to the memorandum for Fonald L.
Ziegler from Jerry Warren dated 9-18-73
and memorandum from Len Garment to
Mel Laird dated 9-14-73. (N) Gesell, J.
ORDER ome in part and denying in
part motions of defts. for summary —
ment; changing time of Pretrial #2 to 5-
12-80 at 2:00 p.m. and rescheduling trial
for 6-4-80 at 9:30 a.m. (See order for
further details. ) (N ) Gesell, J.
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
PROCEEDINGS
MEMORANDUM regarding statute of
limitations denying motions of each deft.
for summary judgment on grounds that
suit is barred by the statute of limita-
tions. (N ) Gesell, J.
NOTICE by pitf. to take deposition of the
National Broadcasting Co., Inc.; attach-
ments (2).
DEPOSITION of Dwight L. Chapin taken
1-17-80; exhibits.
MOTION by deft. Nixon to shorten time
for response to request for production of
documents; memorandum; attachments
A and B.
SECOND request by Richard Nixon, deft.,
for production of documents by ptf.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of John Bodner, Jr.; attachments (2).
SUPPLEMENTAL submission by defts.
#1 and 4 regarding trial witnesses.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Dr. Gardner.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Lloyd M. Doehrmann.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Mrs. Neil B. Fitzgerald.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of David H. Moran.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Frank Shrontz.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Joseph Aragon.
FURTHER identification of trial witnesses
by pitf.
MOTION by defts. #1 and 4 for a new
order regarding their motion for sum-
mary judgment; memo of P&A’s.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of Henry Durham.
$12
$13
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
47a
Date Procerpincs
1980
**Apr 11 AMENDED notice by defts. #1 and 4 to
take deposition of David H. Moran.
*Apr 10 tert fv of appeal by deft. #1 from ¢ rder
f 3-26-80. Govt. no fee. Copies mailed
re Peter Raven-Hansen and R. Stan
Mortenson.
*Apr14 COPIES of notice of appeal and docket
entries transmitted to USCA. USCA
. #80-1406.
April NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
5 _— G. Peters, Jr.; attachments
April 11 MOTION by deft. Nixon to supplement
order of 3-26-80; memo of P&A’s.
April MOTION by deft. Nixon to set date for
deposition of Secretary Harold Brown;
memo of P&A’s.
April NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
° ae Andrew Jacobs; attachments
**Apr 11 NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of William Sollee;
April NOTICE of appeal by deft. Nixon from
order of 3-26-80. Copies mailed to Peter
Raven-Hansen and Mark S. Landman.
*Apr14 COPIES of notice of appeal and docket
entries transmitted to USCA. USCA
#80-1407.
Aprl0 NOTICE of a rer by deft. #4 from order
of March 26, 1980. Govt. no fee. Copies
mailed to Peter Raven-Hansen and R.
Stan Mortenson.
*Apr14 COPIES of notice of appeal and docket
entries transmitted to USCA. USCA
#80-1408.
Apr. 15 RESPONSE of Secretary of Defense Har-
old Brown to deft. Nixon’s motion to set
date fof deposition.
534
535
536
Apr. 21
Apr. 21
Apr. 21
48a
PROCEEDINGS
$70.00 paid for notice of appeal and
eres cy | fee by deft. Nixon and credit-
OFFER of judgment by deft. Nixon.
SECOND s mp pemine submission by
defts. #1 and 4 regarding trial witnesses.
MOTION by deft. Nixon for continuance
of pretrial and trial dates; memorandum.
RETURN on service on William L. Wood-
ruff, Hughes Aircraft Co. of subpoena
and fees; attachments (2).
RETURN on service on the National
Broadcasting Co. of subpoena and fees;
attachments (3).
RETURN on service on Joan Lee Howard,
National Archives and Records Service
of subpoena and fees; attachments (2).
SECOND submission by deft. Nixon
regarding experts.
OPPOSITION by pitf. to defts. motions to
supplement this urt’s order of 3-26-80.
OPPOSITION by pitf. to deft. Nixon’s
motion for continuance of pretrial and
trial dates; attachments A and B.
ORDER filed 4-16-80 granting motion of
deft. Nixon to set date for deposition of
Secy. Harold Brown; directing that said
deposition be taken on 4-19-80 at 11:00
a.m. in accordance with the procedure
set out in Court’s order of 2-15-80. (N)
Gesell, J.
AMENDED notices by deft. Nixon to take
depositions of William Sollee, Ronald
Tammen, and David Julyan.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of John R. Glennie.
NOTICE by defts. #1 and 4 to take depos-
ition of H. Patrick Swygert.
551
$52
1980
Apr. 22
April 22
April 22
April 23
April 23
April 24
April 24
April 24
April 29
April 29
April 30
May |
May |
May 2
May 2
49a
Paoceepincs
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of Senator William Proxmire.
AMENDED notice by deft. Nixon to take
pe a of Ronald Tammen and Da-
id Julyan.
RETURN on service of subpoena for
James R. Schlesinger; attachment.
RETURN on service of subpoena for Ron-
ald L. Ziegler; attachment.
ORDER filed 4-18-80 denying motions of
defts. to supplement the Court’s order of
3-26-80. (N ) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 4-18-80 denying motion of
deft. Nixon for continuance of i
and trial dates; extending time ugh
5-2-80 for final designation of witnesses
for good cause shown. (N ) Gesell, J.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of John Bodner; attachments (2).
RETURN on service of subpoena for
Frederick J. Graboske; attachments (2).
REQUEST to USCA for an expedited
hearing. (N ) Gesell, J.
NOTICE by deft. Nixon to take deposition
of pitf.
AMENDED notice io take deposition of H.
Patrick Swygert.
FURTHER identification of trial witnesses
(3) by pltf.
COPY of ORDER USCA filed 4-30-80
granting appellee’s motions to dismiss
and for expedited consideration of mo-
tion.
MOTION of defts. Butterfield & Harlow
to extend discovery for the deposition of
H. Patrick Swygert; attachment A & B.
LIST of trial witnesses by pltf.
TRIAL exhibits by ptf.
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
50a
PROCEEDINGS
PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS. Motion of
defts. y Paar discove iz og -
ition of Swygert, granted. (Rep: I. Wat-
son ) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 5-2-80 granting motion of
defts. Butterfield and Harlow to extend
discovery for the deposition of H. Patrick
Swygert and directing that said depos-
ition may be taken on or before 5-9-80.
(N) Gesell, J.
ORDER filed 5-5-80 denying motion of
pitf. for order compelling defts. answers
to second set of interrogatories. (N)
Gesell, J.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 3-21-80,
pages 1-66. (Rep: I. Watson) Gesell, J.
MOTION by deft. #4 in liminine to exclude
White House tape recorded conversa-
tions; memo of P&A’s; attachment 1;
exhibit 160.
MEMORANDUM by pitf. concerning the
handling of White House tapes and tran-
scripts at trial.
STATEMENT of issues by defts. #1 and 4
which should be resolved prior to trial.
PROPOSAL by pltf. concerning designa-
tion of depositions.
LIST of issues to be resolved through
pretrial by pltf.; attachment.
OPPOSITION by pltf. to deft. #4’s motion
in limine; attachment.
MOTION by ptf. to exclude witnesses not
listed in answers to his interrogatory
requiring the identification of trial wit-
nesses.
PRETRIAL memorandum by pitf. con-
cerning exclusion of settlement exhibits
~~ witnesses; attachment; attachments
5la
PROCEEDINGS
RESPONSE by piltf. to defts. joint state-
ment of issues which should be resolved
prior to trial.
SUBMISSION by pltf. of objections to
defts. trial exhibits; attachment.
REQUESTS by pltf. for jury instructions
and request for preliminary instructions
SUBMISSION by defts. Alexander P.
Butterfield and Bryce N. Harlow regard-
ing identification of expert witnesses.
PRETRIAL: Deft. Harlow’s objections to
tapes denied; further pretrial 05-16-80 at
10:00 A.M. (Rep: Watson) Gesell, J.
CONSPIRACY contentions by ptf.
RETURN on service; attachments (2).
JOINT opposition by defts. to pltfs. request
to exciude all witnesses with information
concerning pltfs. recent attempts to gain
other employment.
DEPOSITION of Dr. Ray Gardner taken
4-30-80; attachment.
REPLY by ptf. to defts joint opposition to
his request to exclude settlement exhibits
and witnesses; attachments (2).
—— of Frank Shrontz taken 4-
JOINT response of defts. to pitfs. reply to
defts. joint opposition to his request to
exclude settlement exhibits and wit-
nesses.
FIRST submission by deft. Nixon regard-
ing pltfs. proposed jury instructions.
JOINT response by defts. to pltfs. pro-
posed pretrial order No. 1.
SUBMISSION by deft. Nixon of proposed
form of verdict; attachment.
STIPULATION re; appointment of L.J.
Evans and employment of Richard L.
Burtner.
591
592
593
594
595
596
Date
1980
May 16
‘May 19
May 20
May 20
May 20
May 20
May 20
May 20
May 22
May 22
May 28
June 12
June 12
June 27
Aug 7
Aug 27
52a
PROCEEDINGS
sie ah proceedings. (1. Watson) Ge-
sell, J.
DESIGNATION of deposition testimony
by pitf.
FIRST designation of deposition testimony
by pitf.
MOTION by defts. for a stay; memo of
P&A’s.
DEPOSITION of Albert O. Cornelison, Jr.
taken 4-16-80 for defts.
DEPOSITION of John Bodner, Jr. taken 4-
16-80 for defts.
DEPOSITION of Andrew Jacobs, Jr. taken
4-25-80 for defts.
DEPOSITION of Charles Peters taken 4-
25-80 for defts.
DEPOSITION of Lloyd Doehrmann taken
4-24-80 for defts. #1 and 4.
MOTION by defts to stay heard & granted.
Pretrial cancelled & trial postponed in-
— (R. Weber, Reporter) Gesell,
ORDER filed 5-22-80 granting motion of
all defts to stay; staying all proceedings;
cancelling pretrial; continuing trial date
indefinitely. (N ) Gesell, J.
DEPOSITION of William Proxmire taken
5-1-80; exhibits.
DEPOSITION of onald L. Tammen taken
4-29-80; exhibits.
DEPOSITION of Henry Durham taken 4-
29-80 for defts.; errata sheet.
COPY of ORDER filed 4-30-80 granting
appellee’s motion to dimiss the appeal.
DEPOSITION of David H. Moran taken
4-26-80 for defts.; Exhibit.
601
602
603
604
Date
1980
Aug 27
Aug 27
Aug 27
Oct 30
Dec 16
1981
Feb 17
Sept 16
Oct 9
53a
PROCEEDINGS
DEPOSITION of Nell B. Fitzgerald taken
4-28-80 for defts.
DEPOSITION fo David S. Julyan taken 4-
29-80 for deft. #3; Exhibit.
DEPOSITION of John R. Glennie taken 5-
2-80 for defts.; Exhibit.
CERTIFIED copy of ORDER USCA filed
4-30-80 granting appellee’s motion to
dismiss.
TRANSCRIPT of proceedings of 15-16-
80, pages 1-172. (Rep: I. Watson)
Court copy.
DEPOSITION of Frederick J. Graboske
taken 7-9--70 for defts.; errata.
RECORD on appeal (6 boxes) with sealed
material (6 envelopes) delivered to U.S.
Supreme Court.
DEPOSITION of Richard Nixon taken 2-
7-80; exhibits; attachment.
54a
IN THE
United States District Court
For Tue District OF COLUMBIA
Civil Action No. 74-178
A. ERNEST FITZGERALD,
Plaintiff,
Vv.
ALEXANDER P. BUTTERFIELD,
H. ROBERT HALDEMAN,
RICHARD M. NIXON,
Bryce N. HARLOow,
Defendants.
ORDER
[Filed April 27, 1979]
Upon consideration of the defendants’ motions to dismiss
or, in the alternative, for summary judgment, the opposition
thereto, the entire record herein, and the oral arguments of
counsel, it is hereby
OrpDerED that the defendants’ motions to dismiss or in the
alternative for summary judgment are denied in the following
respects:
A. Causes of Action
1. Plaintiff states a cause of action under the First Amend-
ment to the United States Constitution based on defendants’
alleged retaliation for plaintiff's having exercised his rights of
free speech and petition. Mount Healthy City School Dist. Bd.
of Education v. Doyle, 429 U.S. 274, 283-84 (1977); Perry v.
Sindermann, 408 U.S. 593, 596-98 (1972). In addition, a
damage remedy lies for such a violation. Bivens v. Six
Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics, 403
U.S. 388 (1971); Dellums v. Powell, 566 F.2d 167, 194-96
(D.C. Cir. 1977), cert. denied, 46 U.S.L.W. 3803 (U.S. July 3,
1978).
55a
2. Plaintiff states a cause of action for damages under 5
U.S.C.A. § 7211 (1979 pocket part). See Cort v. Ash, 422 US.
66, 78 (1975). The plaintiff is part of the class for whose
especial benefit the statute was enacted. See Act of Aug. 24,
1912, ch. 389, § 6, 37 Stat. 555 (provision originally placed at
end of section protecting civil servants from capricious remo-
vals); 48 Cong. Rec. 4493, 5625-27, 5633-36, 10671-75 (1912).
There exists no indication of a legislative intent to deny a
private remedy under the provision, and implication of such a
remedy is not inconsistent with the underlying purposes of the
legislative scheme and impinges on no area fundamentally the
concern of the states.
3. Plaintiff states a cause of action for damages under 18
U.S.C. § 1505. That statute punishes anyone who “injures any
. . . Witness in his person or property . . . on account of his
testifying or having testified” before a committee of the Con-
gress. From this phraseology, it appears that plaintiff is a
member of a class for whose especial benefit the statute was, at
least in part, enacted. This conclusion is confirmed by the
provision’s legislative history. See S. Rep. No. 225, 79th Cong.,
Ist Sess. (1945); H.R. Rep. No. 1143, 76th Cong., Ist Sess.
(1939); 84 Cong. Rec. 9312, 10910-12 (1939). The other
factors listed in Cort v. Ash, supra, are satisfied. Of particular
significance is the fact that 5 U.S.C.A. § 7211 (1979 pocket
part) and 18 U.S.C. § 1505 may not in the context of this case
overlap in all pertinent respects; yet implication of a private
damage remedy under the first provision but not the second
would not seem to make much logical sense. Furthermore, the
Supreme Court has emphasized that, in appropriate circum-
stances, private damage remedies may be inferred from penal
statutes. Wyandotte Transportation Co. v. United States, 389
US. 191, 201-02 (1967).
4. Plaintiff states a cause of action under D.C. law for
intentional interference with (existent and prospective) eco-
nomic advantage. Carr v. Brown, No. 12922, slip op. at 8-10
(D.C. Ct. App. Nov. 24, 1978); Dunn v. Cox, 163 A.2d 609,
611 (D.C. Mun. App. 1960); Alfred A. Altimont, Inc. v.
Chatelain, Samperton & Nolan, 374 A.2d 284 (D.C. Ct. App.
1977).
56a
5. Plaintiff states a cause of action under D.C. law for
intentional infliction of mental distress by extreme and out-
rageous conduct. Clark v. Associated Retail Credit Men, 105
F.2d 62, 64-65 (App. D.C. 1939); Mosely v. Bank of Virginia,
No. 5573-77 (D.C. Super. Ct. June 19, 1978).
B. The service of process effected on defendants Nixon and
Harlow was proper, Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(d)(7), (e) & (f); D.C.
Code $§ 13-423(a) (3), 13-424, 13-431; United States v. First
National City Bank, 379 U.S. 378, 381 (1965), and this court
has personal jurisdiction over those two defendants as well, see
International Shoe Co.. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 316-19
(1945); Briggs v. Goodwin, 569 F. 2d 1, 8-10 (D.C. Cir. 1977);
D.C. Code § 13-423(a) (3); 2 Moore, Federal Practice
914.25[7].
C. Nixon
1. By reason of the doctrine of “fraudulent concealment,”
this suit is not time-barred as against defendant Nixon. Fitzge-
rald v. Seamans, 553 F. 2d 220, 228-29 (D.C. Cir. 1977). It
was not until June 1978 that plaintiff discovered facts so
sufficiently implicating Nixon in the subject matter of this case
as to meet the requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P. 11; with due
diligence plaintiff could not have discovered these facts at any
earlier date.
2. To establish either arguably applicable immunity de-
fense, the President must show that he was acting “within the
outer perimeters” of his responsibilities. Butz v. Economou, 46
U.S.L.W. 4952 (June 29, 1978); Barr v. Matteo, 360 U.S. 564
(1959); Expeditions Unlimited Aquatic Enterprises, Inc. v.
Smithsonian Institution, 566 F. 2d 289 (D.C. Cir. 1977) (en
banc), cert. denied, 46 U.S.L.W. 3803 (U.S. July 3, 1978). At
this stage of the litigation, the Court cannot conclude that
Nixon was acting within the outer perimeters of his duties when
he performed the acts which the complaint alleges he per-
formed.
a. There exist genuine issues of fact as to Nixon’s conduct
in connection with the subject matter of this suit.
57a
b. By statute and regulation, the President had no authority
to hire, discharge or interfere with the employment of an
employee such as Fitzgerald. 5 U.S.C. § 7512 (1976); 10
U.S.C. § 8012(e); 5 C.F.R. § 6.3; Fitzgerald v. Hampton,
467 F.2d 755, 762 (D.C. Cir. 1972).
c. Other statutory provisions as well bar the President
from doing what he is alleged to have done. 5 U.S.C.A.
§ 7211 (1979 pocket part); 18 U.S.C. § 1505.
Therefore, at this stage, the Court will not decide whether
defendant Nixon may be protected by an absolute or qualified
immunity defense.
3. The issues raised against defendant Nixon are justi-
ciable under Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962). Arguments
flowing from the separation of powers or resting upon the risks
inherent in permitting civil damage actions against past or
present Presidents for acts performed while in office are more
appropriately addressed when determining the kind of immun-
ity from suit which the President should enjoy.
D. Harlow
1. Plaintiffs claims against defendant Harlow are not
time-barred. Only sometime after October 1977 did plaintiff
find out about Harlow’s conversations with Seamans during the
spring of 1969. Fitzgerald Affidavit of July 5, 1978, 16;
Mollenhoff Affidavit of Aug. 1, 1978, 97. Plaintiff could not
have with due diligence discovered this information prior to
that date.
2. Genuine issues of fact remain as to the scope of
Harlow’s responsibilities, as to the nature of his actions in the
Fitzgerald matter beginning in the spring of 1969, and as to
whether such actions as he did take were performed in good
faith. Accordingly, summary judgment cannot be granted at
this time to defendant Harlow based on any claim of immunity,
whether he be entitled to assert an absolute or qualified
immunity.
58a
E. Butterfield
1. Plaintiff's claims against defendant Butterfield are not
time-barred. Discovery has not revealed any further informa-
tion bearing on plaintiffs due diligence since the opinion of the
Court of Appeals in Fitzgerald v. Seamans, supra.
2. Genuine issues of fact remain as to the scope of
Butterfield’s responsibilities, as to the nature of his actions in
the Fitzgerald matter beginning in the spring of 1969, and as to
whether such actions as he did take were performed in good
faith. Accordingly, summary judgment cannot be granted at
this time to Butterfield by reason of any immunity defense,
whether he be entitled to claim an absolute or a qualified
immunity.
ORDERED that defendants’ motions to dismiss or, in the
alternative, for summary judgment are granted in the following
respect:
Plaintiffs action against defendant Haldeman is time-
barred. The statute of limitations was no longer tolled by
operation of the “fraudulent concealment” doctrine once plain-
tiff had sufficient facts to put him on notice that he had a
potential claim. See Emmett v. Eastern Dispensary & Casualty
Hospital, 396, F.2d 931, 937-38 (D.C. Cir. 1967); Westinghouse
Electric Corp. v. City of Burlington, Vermont, 351 F.2d 762, 764
(D.C. Cir. 1965); Cole v. Kelley, 438 F. Supp. 129, 139 (C.D.
Cal. 1977). Plaintiff filed his First Amended Complaint
naming Haldeman on June 27, 1977. Plaintiff, however, knew
that Haldeman was actively involved in the Fitzgerald matter
after having taken the deposition of Butterfield on June 15,
1974. See Butterfield deposition at 260, 271, 298, 324. See also
Butterfield Memorandum of Jan. 20, 1970, addressed specific-
ally to Haldeman ( Discovered by Plaintiff in August, 1973).
ORDERED that, plaintiff having withdrawn his claim
under the Ninth Amendment to the United States Constitution,
his claim for unconstitutional and common-law invasion of
privacy, and his claims under 42 U.S.C. §§ 1985(3) & 1986,
these claims be and hereby are dismissed; and it is further.
59a
ORDERED that, since the issue is currently before the
Supreme Court, see Davis v. Passman, 571 F.2d 793 (5th Cir.
1978) (en banc), cert. granted, 47 U.S.L.W. 3301 (U.S. Oct.
20, 1978), of whether or not, under the rational of Bivens v. Six
Unknown Named Agents of Federa! Bureau of Narcotics, supra,
a private damage remedy may be based on a Fifth Amendment
violation, this Court will not now decide whether plaintiff states
a cause of action under the Fifth Amendment.
/s/ GERHARD GESELL
United States District Judge
April 26, 1979.
UNITED STATES
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
APPEALS EXAMINING OFFICE
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20415
Decision
ON THE APPEAL OF
A. ERNEST FITZGERALD
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
WASHINGTON, D.C.
Herman D. Staiman
CHIEF
ISSUED September 18, 1973
6la
APPEAL OF A. ERNEST FITZGERALD
UNDER PART 351, SUBPART I OF THE CIVIL SERVICE
REGULATIONS
Appeal from the action of the Department of the Air Force
in separating the appellant by reduction-in-force from the
position of Deputy for Management System, GS-17, Step 4,
$31,874.00 per annum, Office of the Secretary, Assistant Secre-
tary for Financial Management, Washington, D.C. effective
January 5, 1970.
INTRODUCTION
By letter dated January 20, 1970 John Bodner, Jr. and
William L. Sollee, Attorneys at Law, submitted an appeal to
this office in behalf of Mr. A. Ernest Fitzgerald. Investigation
was conducted and numerous lengthy submissions to the file
were received from both the appellant and the agency. The
appellant raised a question as to the bona fides of the reduction-
in-force (RIF) as it was applied to him, contending that the
RIF was used as a subtufuge to conceal the agency’s action in
firing him because of his November 13, 1968 testimony on the
C-5A cost overruns. Since Mr. Fitzgerald was a preference
eligible and the various submissions to the file did constitute a
prima facie showing that the reduction-in-force may have been
based upon an intention to separate the appellant for cause
rather than for a nonpersonal reason, a hearing was scheduled
to inquire into the circumstances surrounding the RIF.
The agency was requested and agreed to make available to
testify Secretary of the Air Force Robert Seamans, Assistant
Secretary Spencer Schedler, Administrative Assistant to the
Secretary John Lang, Deputy Administrative Assistant Thomas
Nelson, Air Force Chief of Staff General John D. Ryan,
Comptroller of the Air Force Lieutenant General Duward
Crow, Director of Office of Special Investigations (OSI) Briga-
dier General Joseph J. Cappucci, and Colonel James D. Pewitt.
62a
In accordance with the Civil Service regulations in effect at
that time, the hearing was not open to the public. However, a
verbatim transcript of the proceeding was prepared by an
independent court reporting firm. The hearing was conducted
on May 4, 5; June 16, 17, 18 and 22, 1971. On the latter date
the hearing was suspended in compliance with a temporary
restraining order and subsequent injunction issued by the U.S.
Disirict Court for the District of Columbia relative to the issue
of an “Open Hearing”. The hearing, open to the public,
resumed on January 26, 1973 after all litigation on this issue
had been completed. Additional hearing sessions were held on
January 29, 30, 31; February 2, 28; March 5, 6, 7, 20, 21, 22, 28,
30; April 3, 4, 5, 6, 19; and May 3, 1973.
[2] Since the 1973 portion of the transcript begins again
with page #1, reference to the 1971 portion of the transcript will
be shown as “L/N” while reference to the 1973 portion will be
shown as “TR”. On May 3 & 4, 1971 the agency submitted
copies of documents previously furnished to the Justice Depart-
ment. The pages are numbered consecutively from | to 117
with two (2) pages numbered 95. This submission will be
referred to as the “Justice File” and the two pages 95 will be
referred to as 95a and 95b. On June 25, 1970 the agency
submitted 409 pages of documents in response to the appel-
lant’s request. This submission will be referred to as “AF-
6/25/70”. All agency submissions will be referred to as “AF-
(date)” and all appellant’s submissions will be referred to as
“APP-(date)”. Exhibits submitted at the hearing will be
referred to as “M.Ex” for management and “A.Ex” for appel-
lant. Senator William Proxmire was Chairman of the Subcom-
mittee on Economy in Government of the Joint Economic
Committee, Congress of the United States. This Subcommittee
will be referred to as the “Proxmire Committee”. The office of
the Assistant Secretary of the Air Force for Financial Manage-
ment will be referred to as “SAFFM”, its Air Force symbol.
Final closing arguments, in the form of no reply written
briefs were received from the Air Force on July 16, 1973 and
from the appellant on July 17, 1973. While the record was
technically closed as of May 3, 1973 a newly discovered
memorandum that had just surfaced in a Senate hearing was
63a
submitted by the appellant on August 2, 1973. No objection or
comment was offered by the agency, therefore, the document
was accepted into the record.
A verbatim transcript of the entire 26 day hearing proceed-
ing is a part of the official record in this case. The appellant
was represented at the hearing by his attorneys, John Bodner,
Jr. and William L. Sollee. The agency was represented by
Lieutenant Colonel C. Claude Teagarden, Office of the General
Counsel, Department of the Air Force, and Hugh R. Gilmore,
Assistant General Counsel, Department of the Air Force.
Testimony at the hearing was obtained from the appellant and
thirteen of the witnesses he requested. The agency called no
witnesses, and presented its case through the cross examination
of appellant’s witnesses, the introduction of new documents,
and reliance on the material previously submitted.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
By letter dated November 4, 1969 the agency gave Mr.
Fitzgerald notice of his proposed separation by reduction-in-
force, effective January 5, 1970, due to the abolishment of his
position, “necessitated by a reorganization under the current
Air Force retirement program”. This notice indicated that his
assignment rights were to positions in the Excepted Service.
The Standard Form 50 (SF-50), Notification of Personnel
Action, effecting the separation on January 5, 1970, identified
the position as being in the Excepted Service.
Mr. Fitzgerald contends that he was granted career tenure
in the competitive service on September 20, 1968 and that it
was improperly taken away from him on November 25, 1968
after he testified as to the cost overruns on the C-5A airplane.
Accordingly, we will deal with this issue first.
[3] The record reveals that on September 20, 1965 Mr.
Fitzgerald received an Excepted-Conditional appointment to
the position of Deputy for Management Systems, GS-301-17, in
the Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Air Force for
Financial Management (SAFFM). This position was excepted
from the competitive service under Schedule A, Section
64a
213.3109a of the Civil Service regulations. The appointment
SF-50 clearly shows in items 12 and 28 that the appointment
was to an Excepted Service position.
Effective September 20, 1968, upon Mr. Fitzgerald’s com-
pletion of three (3) years in the Excepted Service a new SF-50
was issued. In item 12 the nature of the action was shown as a
conversion to career tenure; in item 14, the Civil Service
authority was shown as Reg. 315.202; and in item 28 the
position occupied was shown as being in the Excepted Service.
On November 25, 1968 a new SF-50 was issued correcting item
12 of the September 6, 1968 SF-50 to reflect conversion to
Excepted appointment and correcting item 14.
Mr. Fitzgerald contends that based upon the September
1968 SF-50 he was converted from the Excepted to the
Competitive service and that the corrected SF-50 of November
25, 1968 improperly took away his career tenure in the
competitive service.
Section 6-5, Rule VI of the Civil Service Rules relating to
excepted employees states:
“No person who is serving under an excepted
appointment shall be assigned to the work of a
person in the competitive service without prior appro-
val of the Commission.”
Section 315.701, Part 315 of the Civil Service regulations
concerning conversion of incumbents of positions brought into
the competitive service, states:
“(b) An agency, within the time limits set forth in
paragraph (c) of this section, may recommend that
the employment of an employee covered by para-
graph (a) of this section be converted to career or
career-conditional employment.
(d) When the Commission approves the agency’s
recommendation submitted under paragraph (b) of
this section, the employee becomes:
65a
(1) A Career conditional employee ...
(2) A Career employee ...”
It is clear from the evidence of record, and we so find that
the Air Force did not request or receive approval from the
Commission to move Mr. Fitzgerald from the excepted service
to the competitive service or to move his position [4] from the
excepted to the competitive service (A.Ex #1; A.Ex #7, P 286-
287; Justice File, P-7; AF-6/25/70, P-114; AF-1/30/70; and
TR 2768-2769).
Contrary to the appellant’s contention, the perfunctory
forwarding of a file copy of every SF-50 to the Civil Service
. Commission is not an agency recommendation or request for
prior Commission approval nor does this serve as the prior
approval by the Civil Service Commission for any conversion
from the Excepted to the Competitive Service.
Since the Air Force never recommended, requested, or
received prior approval from the Civil Service Commission to
convert Mr. Fitzgerald from the Excepted Service to the
Competitive Service the Air Force was clearly without authority
to take this action. Therefore, we find that the original
conversion action of September 1968 was null and void, and
that it was properly corrected by the agency on November 25,
1968.
The agency has contended that the initial SF-50 of
September 1968 resulted from a computer error. This is borne
out by the fact that item 28 of that SF-50 showed the position
occupied to be in the Excepted Service. It is further borne out
by item 14 which cited the Civil Service Authority as Regu-
lation 315.202. Section 315.202 of Part 315 of the Civil Service
regulations states:
“A career-conditional employee becomes a career
employee automatically on completion of the service
requirement for career tenure.”
The service requirement for conversion from career condi-
tional to career as set forth in Section 315.201 is three (3) years.
Mr. Fitzgerald did not receive a Career-Conditional appoint-
ment, he received an Excepted-Conditional appointment.
66a
Therefore, he had no entitlement to the automatic conversion
from Career-Conditional to Career that Section 315.202 pro-
vides.
In view of the foregoing, we find that Mr. Fitzgerald was
properly in the Excepted Service at the time of his separation on
January 5, 1970 and that he had no entitlement to Career
tenure in the Competitive Service.
Turning now to the reduction-in-force action itself, the
agency’s position is that as part of Defense Department’s
Project 703, the Air Force was required to reduce expenditures
one (1) billion dollars in fiscal year 1970. This involved large
cut-backs in military and civilian personnel nationwide and in
the headquarters staff of the Department. Each office in the
Secretariat was given a specific number of reductions to be
effected. SAFFM was assigned a net reduction of two (2)
spaces. As part of a reorganization of that office five (5)
positions were abolished and three (3) new positions were
established. Of the five (5) positions abolished Mr. Fitzge-
rald’s was the only professional position. The other four (4)
were secretarial positions.
[5] The agency contends that the abolishmeni of Mr.
Fitzgerald’s position, initiated by Assistant Secretary Spencer J.
Schedler and approved by Secretary Robert Seamans, was
based upon a valid management decision to reorganize SAFFM
in order to improve its cost effectiveness capability and at the
same time achieve the required reduction of two (2) spaces.
The agency further contends that Secretary Seamans and
Assistant Secretary Schedler were not in office at the time of Mr.
Fitzgerald’s November 1968 testimony; that they alone were
responsible for the decision to reorganize the financial manage-
ment office; that the testimony Mr. Fitzgerald gave a year
earlier was not the reason or a reason for their decision; and
that neither had sought or received any instructions to abolish
" the appellant’s position.
Mr. Fitzgerald contends that the RIF as applied to him
was not for non-personal reason$ and was, in essence, an
agency adverse action based upon his November 13, 1968
testimony on the C-5A cost overruns.
67a
The record reveals that out of the 80 positions abolished in
the Office of the Secretary of the Air Force, Mr. Fitzgerald was
the only employee who actually was issued a RIF notice and
who was actually separated by RIF (L/N 723-724). As his
part of the Project 703 reductions, Assistant Secretary Schedler
was required to take a cut of two (2) spaces. He accomplished
this by abolishing four (4) Secretarial positions plus Mr.
Fitzgerald’s position and creating three (3) new positions.
The Air Force, through the testimony of witnesses and
documentary evidence, did show that a reorganization of
SAFFM had taken place; that the appellant’s position had been
abolished and not recreated; and that there was some need to
reorganize in addition to reducing the office staff by two (2)
Positions.
The appellant has not questioned the validity of the Project
703 reductions and the resultant reduction-in-force, only the
agency’s decision to abolish his position and include him in that
RIF.
The reduction-in-force system as provided for by Statute
and Commission regulations is a system for releasing employees
from their competitive levels when their release is required
because of lack of work, shortage of funds, reorganization,
reclassification due to change in duties, or the exercise of
reemployment or restoration rights. The system is predicated
upon the concept of competition for retention based upon
tenure, veterans preference, length of service and performance
rating.
Reduction-in-force may be necessary because of conditions
inside or outside the agency. Agency management may reduce
certain phases of its work as the workload changes. Appropria-
tions may be reduced or cut-off entirely, or the agency may be
allowed to use only part of its appropriations. These and other
[6] factors occurring singly or in combination may make it
necessary for the agency to have a reduction-in-force.
Reduction in force may require the separation of all
employees in part of an agency or may require separation of
some and shifting about of others. Small reductions may
require no involuntary separations, when there are enough
68a
transfers, retirements, and other voluntary losses. Some reduc-
tions, in fact, require no reduction in the number of employees
but are accomplished through reorganization.
Planning the work program and organizing the work force
to accomplish agency objectives within available resources are
management responsibilities. Only the agency can decide what
positions are required, where they are to be located and where
they are to be filled, abolished or vacated. The agency
determines when there is a surplus of employees at a particular
location in a particular kind of work. A surplus of employees in
any part of an agency requires the agency to determine whether
the employees will be assigned to vacant positions, be adversely
affected for reasons related to performance or conduct or
compete in reduction in force.
These are management responsibilities and the manage-
ment determinations regarding these responsibilities are not
ordinarily subject to review by the Civil Service Commission in
a reduction-in-force appeal.
It would be a valid and proper exercise of its management
prerogative for an agency faced with the necessity for reducing
its force to select for abolishment those functions and/or
positions that are least necessary to the accomplishment of, or
are making the least substantive contribution to, the agency’s
mission.
In this situation the lack of substantive contribution may be
due to a change in the agency’s mission or its method or
approach to the accomplishment of it’s mission. It may also be
that the lack of substantative contribution is due to the in-
cumbent of the position.
Inherent in the Commission’s reduction-in-force system
and one of its fundamental precepts is that it be used only for
reasons that are non-personal to the employees affected. The
reduction-in-force system must not be used to remove in-
adequate or unsatisfactory employees in lieu of following the
Commission’s adverse action procedures set forth in Part 752 of
the Civil Service regulations.
Federal Personnel Manual Chapter 351, Subchapter |
states in part as follows:
69a
“1-9. IMPROPER USE OF REDUCTION IN
FORCE
There sometimes has been a tendancy to
distort the reduction-in-force system by
using it to eliminate inadequate employ-
ees.”
[7] Thus, an allegation that the RIF was a subterfuge to
conceal an agency removal action taken without following the
adverse action procedures, when supported by a sufficient
showing that the RIF action may have been based upon an
intention to separate the appellant rather than upon a non-
personal reason for reducing the force, goes directly to the
question of the bona-fides of the RIF and will be reviewed on
appeal.
In order to properly evaluate the propriety of the RIF
action as applied to Mr. Fitzgerald it is essential that we review
and analyze the circumstances leading up to and surrounding
the decision to abolish his position and to include him in the
Project 703 RIF.
From our review of the complete appellate record in-
cluding all submissions by both parties and the transcript of the
hearing (26 days), we find the circumstances to be as follows:
Mr. Fitzgerald received an excepted appointment to the
position of Deputy for Management Systems, Office of the
Assistant Secretary of the Air Force for Financial Management
(SAFFM) on September 20, 1965 ( AF-1/30/70, Attachment
#4). While no specific time limit was established as to the
length of this appointment, it is clear from Mr. Fitzgerald’s
testimony of his conversations with :he then Assistant Secretary,
Dr. Leonard Marks, that it was to be for only a few years (TR
2618-2621).
Assistant Secretary Marks resigned on December 31, 1967
and was succeeded by Thomas H. Nielsen who was appointed
Assistant Secretary for Financial Management on January 1,
1968 (L/N 366). Mr. Nielsen submitted a proposed reorgani-
zation plan for his office dated January 9, 1968 ( AF-6/25/70,
P-253) focusing additional attention on cost performance,
70a
designating the appellant as the focal point for this effort and
proposing increasing his staff.
Mr. Fitzgerald was first contacted by the Proxmire Com-
mittee in the Summer of 1968 to testify on the C-SA (TR 2720-
2722). This request was put into writing by Senator William
Proxmire on October 18, 1968 ( APP-1/20/70, Attachment #2).
The file contains unrefuted allegations and testimony that
there was high level Air Force and D.O.D. opposition to Mr.
Fitzgerald testifying.
Mr. Fitzgerald did testify before the Proxmire Committee
on November 13, 1968 and discussed possible cost overruns on
the C-5A plane. This testimony received a great deal of
publicity for it was the first public disclosure of cost overruns on
that project.
In October 1968 Colonel James D. Pewitt, Special Assis-
tant for Economic Analysis and Acting Executive Officer of
SAFFM, was involved in conducting a cost review of the C-SA
project. He testified that Mr. Fitzgerald used his [8] ( Pewitt’s)
figures in testifying before the Proxmire Committee (TR 1970);
that Mr. Fitzgerald’s testimony was accurate; and that the
numbers Fitzgerald used were the same numbers he would
have used (TR 1969-1970).
On November 25, 1968 a new SF-50 was issued to Mr.
Fitzgerald properly correcting an erroneous SF-50 issued on
September 6, 1968 which had purportedly granted him career
tenure.
By memo dated December 26, 1968, Mr. Fitzgerald fur-
nished Assistant Secretary Nielsen copies of the September 6
and November 25, 1968 SF-50’s regarding his tenure and
pointed out that the November 25 revocation came less than
two weeks after his appearance before Senator Proxmire’s
Subcommittee.
In response to a December 27, 1968 request from Assistant
Secretary Nielsen, John A. Lang, Jr., Administrative Assistant
to the Secretary of the Air Force submitted a memorandum
explaining Mr. Fitzgerald’s tenure situation (Justice File P-6).
Tla
A copy of this memo was delivered to Mr. Fitzgerald by Major
Metcalf on December 31, 1968 (M.Ex #7, 1/13/69 attach-
ment).
On January 1, 1969 a front page newspaper article ap-
peared in the Washington Post (attachment to M.Ex #7)
clearly implying that the November 25, 1968 revocation of
tenure was in retaliation for Mr. Fitzgerald’s testimony on the
C-5A on November 13, 1968.
In response to request for information (L/N 449-451) due
to the implications in the January 1, 1969 Washington Post
front page article, Acting Secretary of the Air Force, Dr.
Alexander N. Flax sent a memo to the Secretary of Defense
dated January 2, 1969, explaining Mr. Fitzgerald’s tenure
situation (AF-6/25/70, P 112-116).
On Friday afternoon, January 3, 1969, Mr. Thomas Nel-
son, Deputy Administrative Assistant to the Secretary of the Air
Force, received a request from Colonel Gunderson of the Air
Force Secretary’s Office to prepare a paper bringing the Secre-
tary of the Air Force up to date on what was going on with
regard to Fitzgerald, and also a discussion of what his rights
were, since the Secretary had been out of the office for a week
to ten days (L/N 452-453). John Lang furnished this informa-
tion to Secretary Brown by memo dated January 6, 1969 (M.Ex
#44). Attached thereto was a copy of Dr. Flax’ memo of
January 2, 1969 to the Secretary of Defense. The January 6,
1969 memo is referred to as the “Lang Memo”.
Mr. Nelson testified that he assumed the request, “What
are his rights” meant what are his rights when he is going to be
terminated (L/N 463-466). Mr. Fitzgerald received a copy of
the “Lang Memo” from Assistant Secretary Nielsen (L/N 474,
476-477) on January 8, 1969.
The Lang Memo identifies three (3) possible means of
effecting Mr. Fitzgerald’s departure and states in part as
follows:
[9] “As an employee in the excepted service under
Schedule A, with Veterans Preference, Mr. Fitzgerald has
certain rights, which can be grouped in two categories:
72a
(1) Adverse Actions. Chapter 752 of the Federal
Personnel Manual applies to discharges, suspensions,
furloughs without pay, and reductions in rank or com-
pensation taken by agencies against employees of the
United States Government. Mr. Fitzgerald’s rights are:
(a) Adverse action may not be taken except for such
cause as will promote the efficiency of the service;
(b) He must be given at least 30 full days advance
written notice, identifying the specific proposed action,
stating the reasons supporting the proposed action, in-
cluding names, times and places;
(c) The notice must tell the employee that he has the
right to reply, both personally and in writing and to submit
affidavits in support of his answer;
(d) Normally he must be retained in an active duty
status during the notice period;
(e) Full consideration must be given to his reply and
if the decision is to effect the action originally proposed, or
some action less severe, he must be given a dated and
written notice of the decision promptly after it is reached;
(f) The notice of decision must iaform him of the
effective date of the action, of his right to appeal the
adverse action within the agency and to the Civil Service
Commission, and of the time limits and procedures for
making the appeals.
(2) Reduction in Force. In the event his job is
abolished, Mr. Fitzgerald is in Tenure Group I in the
Excepted Service and has the right of full application of all
reduction-in-force procedures insofar as “bumping” and
“retreat” rights within his competitive level grouping.
However, since he is the only employee in his competitive
level grouping and since he did not progress to this position
from other lower grade positions, the net result is that he is
in competition only with himself. He could neither
“bump” nor displace anyone.
73a
[10] These are the rights involved should charges be
preferred or should his position be abolished. There is a third
possibility, which could result in Mr. Fitzgerald’s departure.
This action is not recommended since it is rather underhanded
and would probably not be approved by the Civil Service
Commission, even though it is legally and procedurally possi-
ble. The Air Force could request conversion of this position to
the career service, utilizing competitive procedures, and consid-
er all the eligibles from the Executive Inventory and an outside
search. Using this competitive procedure, Mr. Fitzgerald might
or might not be selected. If not, displacement action would
follow.
When Mr. Fitzgerald was appointed in September
1965 by Assistant Secretary Marks to fill the vacancy
created by the departure of Mr. J. Ronald Fox, it was with
a mutual understanding that this was to be a Schedule A
appointment of two or three years duration. There is
nothing in official records to support this understanding.
Dr. Flax contacted Mr. Marks by telephone on January 2,
1969, and verified this understanding and reflected the
conversation in his memorandum to the Secretary of
Defense, a copy of which is attached. We have carefully
screened all files and records and can find no formalized
confirmation of this understanding.”
Mr. Fitzgerald visited the Civil Service Commission on
January 10, 1969 to complain of the alleged loss of tenure and
his supervisor’s statement that his usefulness to the Air Force
was at an end. Therefore, Assistant Secretary Nielsen prepared
a memorandum for record (M.Ex #7, 1/13/69 attachment).
This memo states that Mr. Nielsen reviewed the entire matter of
the tenure controversy with Mr. Fitzgerald who stated that he
mailed a copy of the first SF-50 to the Committee immediately
after the conclusion of the November 13, 1968 hearing and that
when the second form was received it was mailed directly to the
Proxmire Committee. The memo also states that Mr. Nielsen
told the appellant “I felt his actions in this connection had
ended his usefulness to the Air Force”.
74a
Secretary Seamans testified it was his belief that Mr.
Fitzgerald released the SF-50's in the tenure controversy in
order to obtain publicity and to place the Air Force in a bad
light (TR 430-431, 435-437); that his actions inflamed the
situation; exacerbated relations between Mr. Fitzgerald and
people in the Secretariat; and “that’s when it became much
more of a confrontation” (TR 480-481). Secretary Seamans
also stated that Mr. Fitzgerald was a celebrity and a con-
troversial person at that time as a result of the press releases
concerning the tenure controversy (TR 438-439).
Colonel Pewitt testified that Assistant Secretary Nielsen
gave Mr. Fitzgerald the “Lang Memo”; that Mr. Nielsen felt
Fitzgerald “had betrayed a personal confidence” by the way
the memo was handled; and that Mr. Nielsen lost confidence
[11] in the appellant and his usefulness to the Air Force (TR
1991-1992). Colonel Pewitt also stated that he thought Mr.
Fitzgerald’s days in the Air Force were numbered and that he
might be leaving because of the tenure-non tenure publicity and
the Lang Memo (TR. 2121-2122).
It is clear that the “Lang Memo” and Secretary Nielsen’s
declaration that Mr. Fitzgerald had lost his usefulness to the Air
Force both stemmed from the Washington Post January 1,
1969 front page article erroneously implying that the appellant
lost his career tenure in retaliation for his testimony on the cost
overrun in the C-5A project. It is also evident that the Air
Force considered Mr. Fitzgerald responsible for this erroneous
implication reaching the news media.
Robert C. Seamans, Jr. took office as Secretary of the Air
Force on February 15, 1969. Assistant Secretary Nielsen
submitted new reorganization proposals to Secretary Seamans
on February 26, 1969 ( AF-6/25/70, P-292) and May 5, 1969
(M.Ex#11). Prior to submitting the February 26, 1969
reorganization plan, Mr. Nielsen told Secretary Seamans that
Mr. Fitzgerald’s usefulness to the Air Force was at an end (TR
526-527). Secretary Seamans testified that the February 26,
1969 proposal was similar to the one that Mr. Nielsen had
submitted a year earlier except for changing the focal point for
75a
cost analysis capability from Mr. Fitzgerald to Colonel Pewitt
(TR 530-531).
Secretary Seamans testified that on or about April 24, 1969
Mr. Fitzgerald was scheduled to give a talk to the American
Management Association on the West Coast for the Air Force.
He did not meet that committment, apparently because he was
giving a series of lectures up at the Capitol (TR 559-561; 570-
572). As a result, Assistant Secretary Nielsen had to fulfill this
committment in the appellant’s place.
On May 5, 1969 Mr. Nielsen submitted his final proposed
reorganization plan for SAFFM (M.Ex #11). This plan did not
provide for Mr. Fitzgerald’s position of Deputy for Manage-
ment Systems.
On May 7, 1969 Secretary Seamans testified before the
House Armed Services Committee in Executive Session and
made several accusations against Mr. Fitzgerald. The following
quotations dealing with these accusations are taken from pages
2593, 2594 and 2596 of the Committee Hearing report for May
7, 1969 (APP-4/28/71 attachment).
“Secretary Seamans. I think if you are looking at the
record that you should also note where he is spending
time off duty as well as on Government time.”
Secretary Seamans. . . . I am not saying this is wrong,
mind you, but he is working with a group of staff
people up on the Hill, among them Congressman
Moorhead’s chief of staff. He [12] was scheduled to
go and make a speech on the west coast, which I
approved. He wanted to make the speech. I said go
ahead. And then he backed out of it at the last
minute because he was so busy up here doing his
extracurricular work. We had difficulty filling the
speaking assignment.”
“Mr. Stratton. Mr. Fitzgerald is up there now, and
has been for the last several weeks, as I understand it.
Secretary Seamans. I'm not familiar with detail. I do
know there is a group that engages in a so-called
seminar. It may be perfectly appropriate, but it is not
76a
official Air Force business. It is nothing that has been
scheduled with a committee through the Secretary of
the Air Force or any other responsible Air i orce
official.”
“Secretary Seamans. In my conversation, a little
earlier, I was talking about some of the reports that
came out of the Holifield committee, some of which
are confidential, that as indicated by Congressman
Moorhead, he received from Mr. Fitzgerald.
Mr. Hunt. Did Mr. Fitzgerald have the permission of
the Air Force to release that information?
Secretary Seamans. He certainly did not.
Mr. Hunt. What is being done about Mr. Fitzgerald,
then?
Secretary Seamans. I’m reviewing the case.
Mr. Hunt. Will you advise us what you are doing
with the case when you are finished?
Secretary Seamans. I certainly will.”
In addition, the following exchange took place between the
Chairman of the Committee and Secretary Seamans:
The Chairman. Is he still on the Air Force payroll?
Secretary Seamans. He is still on the Air Force
payroll, he works in the Financial Management
Office.
The Chairman. If I had a fellow like that in my
Office, he would have been long gone. You don’t
need to be afraid about firing him.”
[13] Secretary Seamans testified at the Commission's
hearing that he was not fully satisfied with Mr. Fitzgerald’s
performance; that he ( Fitzgerald) was not taking his responsi-
bilities to the Air Force seriously enough (TR 868-869); that he
was not fulfilling his duties (TR 872-874); and that he (Sea-
mans) had stated to the Committee on May 7, 1969 that Mr.
Fitzgerald had leaked confidential documents (TR 882). Sec-
77a
retary Seamans testified that on the day after his May 7, 1969
testimony he learned that no security violation was involved
(TR 636); that the word “confidential” did leave an ambiguity
(TR 637); that some damage was done (TR 637); and that it
wasn’t until six months later that he apologized to the Com-
mittee for his remarks being interpreted as a security violation
(TR 617, 637, 892).
Brigadier General Joseph J. Cappucci, former Director of
the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (OSI), testified
that on May 17, 1969 OSI opened a file, HDQ 24P-12052 and
started a special inquiry based on conflict of interest charges
made against Mr. Fitzgerald by a confidential informant.
Subsequently three (3) more people volunteered information in
June and July (TR 48-49). A number of checks were made
(TR 61-62) to test the substance of the allegations. These were
in Washington, D.C.; in New York, (TR 64); Boston, (TR 70);
and in Los Angeles to interview Leonard Marks (TR 83-85).
All the checks came back favorable (TR 111, 119) but this
favorable information was not placed in the file (TR 111).
General Cappucci testified that when these checks came
back favorable, instead of placing the favorable information in
the file he closed it and was going to destroy the file when it was
impounded (TR 112-113). All the favorable reports were
destroyed (TR 115, 120).
We find no credible explanation for OSI retaining the
derogatory allegations about Mr. Fitzgerald while destroying
all of the results of the investigation which proved that these
allegations were without substance. General Cappucci went to
great lengths to try and distinguish between a “Special Inquiry”
and an “Investigation”. However, it was a fruitless exercise in
semantics in this case.
General Cappucci also testified that the June 24, 1969
memorandum report of interview with Leonard Marks ( Justice
File P-95 ), which clearly showed that there was no substance to
the conflict of interest allegations, was not in the OSI file when
he sent it to “The Hill” (TR 157-162). We find it uncon-
scionable for OSI to have shown only the derogatory allega-
tions without also showing the results of the investigation which
78a
laid to rest these allegations. We can only view this as an
attempt to justify Mr. Fitzgerald’s separation.
General Cappucci testified that he was not directed by
anyone to open the special: inquiry on Mr. Fitzgerald; that he
did not disclose the fact that the inquiry was opened or the facts
of that inquiry, to Secretary Seamans, Assistant Secretary
Nielsen, Assistant Secretary Schedler or anyone else in the
Executive Branch of the Government outside the OSI prior to
November 4, 1969 (TR 198). General Cappucci also testified
that Secretary Seamans first learned of the existance of the OSI
file when the General gave the Secretary a few minute briefing
on November 17 or 18 [1969], the day before he testified
before the Proxmire Committee (TR 154-155).
[14] In his testimony before the Proxmire Committee on
November 17, 1969, in discussing the reorganization of the
SAFFM Office and Mr. Fitzgerald’s resultant RIF, Secretary
Seamans stated that he and Mr. Laird the Secretary of Defense
made an effort for many months to find a way to use Mr.
Fitzgerald in some other capacity; that they talked to him
personally; and considered him for other positions in the
Department of Defense but did not find a suitable solution
(APP-2/9/71, Attachment 1, P 102-103).
Secretary Seamans testified that he first gave consideration
to finding another job for Fitzgerald outside the Air Force
about the middle of May. This was shortly after he learned that
the appellant had transmitted documents to Congress and
learned the appellant had not fulfilled his committment to
deliver the West Coast address (TR 707-708). Secretary
Seamans believed that a job for Mr. Fitzgerald in DOD would
be uncluttered by some of the unfortunate relationships that
had arisen in the Air Force (TR 708).
Mr. Fitzgerald testified that he met with Secretary of
Defense Melvin Laird on June 11, 1969; that the Secretary was
very friendly but told the appellant that he had become a
personnel problem in the Air Force, which the appellant
conceded was probably true; and that he would have to go
someplace else. They discussed what might be done in other
areas of DOD (TR 2866-2871 ).
79a
One of the positions under consideration was an assign-
ment on the staff of the Fitzhugh DOD Blue Ribbon Panel (TR
714-723, 2872). Mr. Fitzgerald had meetings with Mr. Fitz-
hugh and Mr. Buzzard, the Staff Director, and then submitted
an August 25, 1969 memo to these men ( AF-6/25/70, P-118)
which stated in part:
“On the second point, I am not the only action-
oriented cost cutter now excluded from the business.
Aside from publicity, my situation is unique only in
that I have not gone away quietly as have most others
of my experience and bent.”
After receipt of this memo Mr. Fitzhugh informed Secre-
tary Seamans that he was not going to recommend Mr.
Fitzgerald for assignment to the staff (TR 728). Secretary
Seamans properly considered the above quoted statement to be
a fairly inflammatory kind of statement to put into a memo
related to consideration for another position (TR 729-31). The
Secretary considered that Mr. Fitzgerald had a chip on his
shoulder (TR 729-731). It is clear that Mr. Fitzgerald was not
interested in a position on the Fitzhugh Panel as evidenced by
the tenor of his August 25, 1969 memo.
Spencer J. Schedler replaced Thomas Nielsen as Assistant
Secretary of the Air Force for Financial Management on June
24, 1969. Mr. Schedler testified that [15] he saw the “Lang
Memo” in the summer of 1969. He testified that he considered
Mr. Fitzgerald’s performance deficient in regard to the in-
stances of the preparation of a “Should Cost Primer” and his
failure to have prepared a demonstration guide (TR 1683-
1694). Mr. Schedler testified that he first decided to abolish
Mr. Fitzgerald’s position in late September or early October
1969 when it became evident to him that as a result of the
Project 703 cutbacks he would not be able to add spaces to the
SAFFM office to improve its analytical capability (TR 1791-
1792).
On November 3, 1969 Mr. Schedler submitted a form 52
request to abolish Mr. Fitzgerald’s position by reorganization.
This request was approved by Secretary Seamans on the same
day. Thereafter, by letter dated November 4, 1969, Mr.
80a
Fitzgerald was notified of his proposed separation by reduction-
in-force which was effected on January 5, 1970.
On November 17 and 18, 1969 the Proxmire Committee
held hearings on Mr. Fitzgerald’s proposed termination by RIF.
Secretary Seamans testified at the Commission’s hearing
that between November 4 and 18, 1969 the date of his
appearance at the Committee hearing he saw and/or commu-
nicated with Republican Senators Jordan and Percy and
‘Yepublican Congressmen Brown and Conable concerning Mr.
Fitzgerald’s RIF (TR 777-778, 857-858, 860). The Secretary
admitted mentioning to Senator Percy that Mr. Fitzgerald was
not a team player (TR 782) and that there had been difficulties
in the relationship between Fitzgerald and the Air Force (TR
780). Secretary Seamans also told Senator Jordan of these
relationship difficulties; however, he denied that they were the
reason for the RIF; and he did not recall using the term “team
player”.
On May 7, 1973 former Senator Jordan was sent several
written interrogatories. His written replies were received May
19, 1973. In answer to one question Mr. Jordan recalled
Secretary Seamans stating Mr. Fitzgerald was a troublemaker,
that he was not a team player and that he was terminated for
economy reasons under a reduction in force designation.
In view of the above and the fact that Secretary Seamans
did mention the team player situation to Senator Percy, we
must conclude that he also used that term in talking to Senator
Jordan.
Assistant Secretary Schedler testified that during the same
period of time he visited Republican Senators Mundt and
Murphy and Republican Congressmen Broyhill, Buchanan,
Conable, Dickinson and Rhodes to explain Mr. Fitzgerald’s
RIF (TR 1377).
There is a conflict in the evidence as to whether or not
Assistant Secretary Schedler told Congressman Dickinson that
Mr. Fitzgerald was not a team player. Congressman Dickinson
testified (TR 2285) that at their November !1, 1969 meeting
Mr. Schedler used the term “not a team player” and the
Congressman confirmed the accuracy of a November 19, 1969
newspaper article quoting him as saying that Mr. Schedler told
him Mr. Fitzgerald was not a team player (APP-2/9/71,
Attachment #1, P 202-203).
[16] Michael L. Lehrman, a former fellow classmate of
Mr. Schedler at Harvard, testified that he met Mr. Schedler at
an Air Force Association Convention in September 1970. Mr.
Lehrman testified that at this meeting Mr. Schedler made
uncomplimenting remarks about Mr. Fitzgerald, stated that he
was “a pain in the ass” and was not a “team player” (TR 2885-
2896).
From all of the above we must conclude that Mr. Schedler
did tell Congressman Dickinson that Mr. Fitzgerald was not a
team player, or used words to that effect. «
After carefully reviewing the complete appellate record we
find the evidence of record does not support the appellant’s
allegation that his position was abolished and that he was
separated by RIF in retaliation for his having revealed the C-
5A cost overrun in testimony before the Proxmire Committee
on November 13, 1968.
In summary, the record reflects that the C-SA contract was
negotiated during a Democratic Administration. Secretary
Seamans and Assistant Secretary Schedler were not in office at
the time the contract was negotiated or at the time of Mr.
Fitzgerald’s testimony, before the Proxmire Committee on
November 13, 1968. In fact, Secretary Seamans did not take
office until February 1969 and Assistant Secretary Schedler not
until June 1969, three (3) and seven (7) months later respec-
tively; and under a Republican Administration.
Secretary Seamans agreed that there was a large cost
overrun on the C-5A project and that Mr. Fitzgerald was acting
properly in testifying after being called by the Committee. In
addition, a number of witnesses agreed with Mr. Fitzgerald’s
estimate of the possible magnitude of the overrun.
As we have previously found, and as the Air Force knew,
Mr. Fitzgerald was not entitled to career tenure. The Civil
82a
Service Commission had not been requested nor had it granted
prior approval to the Air Force to convert Mr. Fitzgerald from
the Excepted to the Competitive Service. The September 6,
1968 SF-50 was erroneously issued, obviously due to a comput-
er error, and was properly corrected by the November 25, 1968
SF-50 to show that Mr. Fitzgerald was converted from
“Excepted-Conditional to “Excepted” upon completion of three
years of service, effective September 20, 1968.
The Lang Memo of January 6, 1969 and Assistant Secre-
tary Nielsen’s January 8,°1969 comment to Mr. Fitzgerald,
which Mr. Nielsen made the subject of a memo for record on
January 13, 1969, that his usefulness of the Air Force had come
to an end did not stem from his testimony before Congress on
November 13, 1968. These two pronouncements resulted
directly from the January 1, 1969 Washington Post front-page
story that carried a clear but erroneous implication that Mr.
Fitzgerald’s career tenure had been revoked in retaliation for
his November 13, 1968 testimony. Secretary Seamans, and
others in the Air Force considered Mr. Fitzgerald to be a
publicity seeker; that the appellant was [17] directly or in-
directly responsible for the erroneous January 1, 1969 Washing-
ton Post story; and that Mr. Fitzgerald had done this for the
purpose of placing the Air Force in a bad light.
We find that the unjust publicity the Air Force received
concerning this tenure controversy, which it considered Mr.
Fitzgerald to be basically responsible for, was the prime factor
in the deterioration of relationships and development of an
adversary environment between Mr. Fitzgerald and the Air
Force.
We note that Mr. Fitzgerald received his appointment in
September 1965 during a Democratic Administration, and in
his own words the appointment was to be for only a few years.
Mr. Fitzgerald’s position carried with it the qualifications
requirement that he “be personally acceptable to the Assistant
Secretary of the Air Force (Financial Management)” (A-
6/25/70, P-145). By the end of December 1968 the appellant’s
“few years” had gone by; a Republican Administration would
83a
soon be coming into office; and thus it appeared that Mr.
Fitzgerald could possibly soon be leaving.
While Mr. Fitzgerald has denied that he was “Senator
Proxmier’s boy in the Air Force”, and he may honestly believe
it, we find this statement difficult to accept. It is evident that the
top officials in the Air Force, without specifically saying so,
considered him to be just that. The statements that he was not
a “team player” and “not on the Air Force team” go directly to
that point. We also note that upon leaving the Air Force Mr.
Fitzgerald was employed as a consultant by the Proxmire
Committee and that Senator Proxmire appeared at the Com-
mission hearing as a character witness for the appellant.
It is also clear that probably by January 1969, and
certainly no later than May 1969, Mr. Fitzgerald had achieved
controversial status and was an Air Force personnel problem as
his testimony concerning his meeting with Secretary of Defense
Melvin Laird revealed.
Assistant Secretary Nielsen considered Mr. Fitzgerald’s
usefulness to the Air Force to be at an end as of January 8,
1969. Therefore, he obviously did not include Mr. Fitzgerald in
his proposed reorganizations of February 26, 1969 and May 5,
1969. Mr. Nielsen’s last proposal is essentially the same as the
reorganization Assistant Secretary Schedler, with Secretary
Seaman’s approval, finally put into effect. This reorganization
abolished Mr. Fitzgerald’s position and led to his separation by
RIF on January 5, 1970.
Mr. Schedler testified that he did not decide to abolish Mr.
Fitzgerald’s position until late September or early October
1969. However, Secretary Seamans and Secretary Laird came
to the decision that Mr. Fitzgerald had to leave the Air Force
much earlier than Mr. Schedler was willing to admit. They
were busy looking for another position outside the Air Force for
the appellant as early as May 1969. One of the positions under
consideration was with the Fitzhugh Blue Ribbon Panel, pre-
viously discussed.
[18] Secretary Seamans denied being instructed, directed
or ordered by anyone to terminate Mr. Fitzgerald. However, he
84a
initially declined to respond to any and all questions concerning
possible communications he may have had with, or any advice
received from, the White House staff regarding Mr. Fitzgerald.
This declination was based on the doctrines of Executive
Privilege and privileged communications. Secretary Seamans
was advised by this examiner (TR 499) as follows:
“Mr. Secretary, I am without authority to order you
to answer the question. If the answer to the question
becomes relevant and material, all I can do is to take
into consideration your refusal to answer the ques-
tion.”
Secretary Seamans subsequently testified that at some
point in time prior to Mr. Fitzgerald’s job being abolished he
did receive some advice from the White House; however, he
refused to discuss it any further (TR 839).
By letter dated August 2, 1973, with a copy to the agency
representative, appellant’s attorney submitted a copy of a
January 20, 1970 internal White House memo from Alexander
Butterfield to Mr. H. R. Haldeman that had just been dis-
covered. The agency was offered but declined the opportunity
to comment. This memo states:
“You'll recall that I relayed to you my personal
comments while you were at San Clemente, but let
me cite them once again—partly for the record—and
partly because some of you with more political horse
sense than I will probably want to review the matter
prior to next Monday’s press conference.
—Fitzgerald is no doubt a top-notch cost expert, but
he must be given very low marks in loyalty; and after
all, loyalty is the name of the game.
—Last May he slipped off alone to a meeting of the
National Democratic Coalition and while there re-
vealed to a senior AFL-CIO official (who happened
to be unsympathetic) that he planned to “blow the
whistle on the Air Force” by exposing to full public
view that Service’s “shoddy purchasing practices”.
85a
Only a basic no-goodnik would take his official
business grievances so far from normal channels. As
imperfect as the Air Force and other military Services
are, they very definitely do not go out of their way to
waste government funds; in fact, quite to the con-
trary, they strive continuously (at least in spirit) to
find new ways to economize. If McNamara did
nothing else he made the Services more cost-
conscious and introspective—so I think it is safe to
say that none of their bungling is malicious ... or
even preconceived.
[19]—Upon leaving the Pentagon—on his last offi-
cial duty—he announced to the press that “contrary
to recent newspaper reports” he was not going to
work for the Federal Government, but instead, was
going to “work on the outside” as a private con-
sultant.
We should let him bleed, for a while at least. Any
rush to pick him up and put him back on the Federal
payroll would be tantamount to an admission of
earliczr wrong-doing on our part.
We owe “first choice on Fitzgerald” to Proxmire and
others who tried so hard to make him a hero.”
The information contained in the memo concerning Mr.
Fitzgerald’s May 1969 statements at a meeting of the National
Democratic Coalition had not previously come to light in this
proceeding. In the light of Secretary Seaman’s refusal to
furnish testimony on conversations he had with, or advice he
received from the White House Staff; and our notification to the
Secretary (TR 499), quoted supra, we must conclude and do
hereby find that Mr. Fitzgerald’s May 1969 statements were the
subject of Secretary Seaman’s discussion with the White House
staff. We must also conclude and do hereby find that these
statements by Mr. Fitzgerald were one of the underlying
reasons for the decision to abolish Mr. Fitzgerald’s position and
to terminate his employment with the Air Force.
The “Lang Memo” previously quoted, set out three (3)
methods by which the agency could terminate Mr. Fitzgerald.
86a
Method No. 3. was not recommended. Method No. |. was to
follow adverse action procedures with ali of the requirements
for specified charges, opportunity to reply and appeals. Meth-
od No. 2., which the agency subsequently followed, was to
abolish Mr. Fitzgerald’s position and since his assignment riglits
would only be to Excepted Service positions, he would end up
being separated. Secretary Seamans and Assistant Secretary
Schedler both saw the “Lang Memo” prior to Mr. Fitzgerald’s
position being abolished.
Our findings, supra, reveal many instances of dis-
satisfaction with Mr. Fitzgerald. In addition, Secretary Sea-
mans testified (TR 964) that:
“It is obvious from the testimony these past three
days that I was not satisfied with Mr. Fitzgerald’s
performance. I made no pretense that I was.”
After carefully reviewing the complete appellate record
and in view of all of the foregoing analysis, findings and
conclusions, we find that the agency’s decision to abolish Mr.
Fitzgerald’s position and to include him in the Project 703
reduction-in-force improperly resulted from and was influenced
[20] by reasons purely personal to the appellant; and was for
the purpose of terminating his employment with the Air Force.
Secretary Seamans, in discussing his dissatisfaction with
Mr. Fitzgerald also stated (TR 964):
“But at the same time it does not give Mr. Fitzgerald
immunity against having his job abolished, and the
abolition of the job for improvement in our manage-
ment capability was a separate and distinct step, or
action.”
It is true that an undesirable, inadequate or unsatisfactory
employee is not immune from having his position abolished.
However, the decision to abolish that employee’s, or any
employee’s, position must be based solely on reasons not
personal to the employee. These employees must be removed
from their positions by other means because the spirit, intent,
and letter of the Commission’s regulations require that the
reduction-in-force system be used for reasons that are not
87a
personal to the employees affected. The more an employee is
deserving of being fired, the more inappropriate it is to abolish
his position and separate him by reduction-in-force.
In the case at hand, where we have found from the
evidence of record that the decision to abolish Mr. Fitzgerald’s
position and to separate him by reduction-in-force was in-
fluenced by, and resulted from, reasons that were personal to
the appellant; and where the appellant was an employee
entitled to the adverse action procedures set forth in Part 752-B
of the Civil Service regulations; we find his separation by
reduction-in-force to be improper, inappropriate and contrary
to the spirit, intent, and letter of the Commission’s regulations.
RECOMMENDATION
Accordingly, we recommend that Mr. Fitzgerald be re-
stored retroactively to January 5, 1970 to the position from
which he was improperly separated, or to any other position of
like grade, salary and tenure in the Excepted Service and with
the same or similar qualifications requirements as his former
position. Please furnish this office with a copy of the SF-50
accomplishing the recommended corrective action.
The appellant requested an award of damages, costs and
reasonable attorneys’ fees. The applicable statutes, Executive
Orders and Commission regulations do not provide for any
awards of damages, costs, or attorneys’ fees by the Commission
in a decision on an appeal. Therefore, the appellant’s request in
this regard must be denied. It should be noted that during the
course of the proceeding the appellant’s attorneys contended
that they had volunteered their services and were performing
without charge.
[21] The appellant has also requested reimbursement for
the compensation he would have received if he had not been
terminated.
Retroactive corrective action as ordered by the Commis-
sion carries with it an entitlement to back pay in accordance
with the provisions of the “Back Pay Act”. However, the
Commission does not determine the amount of the back pay
entitlement, if any.
Unless this decision is further appealed within 15 calendar
days of the day on which it is received, it becomes the final
decision of the U.S. Civil Service Commission. Any further
appeal of this decision must be sent directly to:
Board of Appeals and Review
U.S. Civil Service Commission
Washington, D.C. 20415
Two copies of the letter of further appeal and all repre-
sentations which the Board should consider beyond those now
in the appeal file must be submitted within the 15 calendar day
time limitation.
/s/ Herman D. Staiman
Herman D. Staiman, Chief
Appeals Examining Office
89a
Excerpts From The
Deposition of Patrick
J. Buchanan (R. 414)
[pp. 14-19, 41-50}
[14] Q. Do you have any recollection of communicating
with the President anything having to do with Fitzgerald before
November or December of 1969? A. No.
Q. Now, focusing in on November and December of "69,
what recollection do you have concerning being aware of Mr.
Fitzgerald and any situation that arose with him and his
employment at the Department of Defense? A. Well, Fitzge-
rald, I have to assume from what we did, had become a public
issue. Clark Mollenhoff—his departure from the Department
of Defense or whatever it was—anyhow, Clark Mollenhoff
came down to my office.
I had sent out a memorandum to the Department of
Defense asking for responses to questions which were going to
—likely to come up at a Presidential press conference about A.
Ernest Fitzgerald, and they sent back a response or a number of
responses which I then collated and got together and made into
a single answer.
At the same time, Clark Mollenhoff came down to my
office and talked to me about the matter, and I sent a
subsequent—which I have seen subsequently since then—I sent
a memorandum to the President suggesting that he handle the
[15] question, if it came up, iu an altogether different way.
Q. Now, the memos you say you have seen since then, was
that memo included among the memos that I showed you this
morning before this deposition? A. Yes, I believe it was.
Q. I am having those xeroxed, and as soon as they’re done
they'll be in here and we'll go through them. I’m going to try to
cover the general turf to save time. A. Before I saw the memo,
if somebody had asked me before I’d seen the memo I sent, I
would say Mollenhoff and I sought to get the Administration to
find Fitzgerald a new job at equal pay and to make some sort of
90a
commendatory statement about the job he had done on the cost
overruns of the C-5A, because I remember working with Clark
Mollenhoff on the issue in the White House, and that was
before I saw the memoranda.
Q. Now, what was the tenure of the position taken by Mr.
Mollenhoff concerning the pros or cons or the Fitzgerald
situation vis-a-vis the wisdom of the White House backing
Fitzgerald versus the Department of Defense?
MR. KEENEY: Objection as to the form.
THE WITNESS: Pardon?
MR. KEENEY: Objection as to form.
[16] BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. He’s registering his objection. A. What was Mollen-
hoff’s position?
Q. Yes, what was the tenure concerning the Fitzgerald
situation? A. My recollection is this: Mollenhoff had looked
into the situation much more closely than I had. I had not.
And Mollenhoff came to me and said and indicated that what
we had here was a bureaucratic battle over at Defense, that
Fitzgerald was being canned because of his battle. There was a
certain institutional loyalty over there to—that Fitzgerald had
been an embarrassment, and now the issue had been made
public. And now the Nixon Administration, in particular the
White House, were being blamed for this thing and that the
President had a golden opportunity at the press conference not
only to correct a seeming injustice, but also for us to take—to
get political credit for doing what we ought to have done.
Fitzgerald had been no embarrassment to us, the C-5A
was under the Johnson Administration, so that’s precisely the
position we recommended to Mr. Nixon.
Q. Now, in your communications with Mr. Mollenhoff, did
[17] he at any time ever use any words to the ef-
fect—communicating to you the impression that the White
House’s position with regard to Mr. Fitzgerald involved a
criminal conspiracy of any sorts, a cover-up?
9la
MR. KEENEY: Objection, leading question.
MR. MORTENSON: Let me finish.
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. —a cover-up, an obstruction of justice or a retaliation of
a witness before Congress?
MR. KEENEY: Same objection; leading question.
THE WITNESS: As for the—no, I mean, I have never
—and I know Clark Mollenhoff well, and certainly not in 1969
there was no conceivable idea that there was anything criminal
involved.
Some individual had been fired over at Defense or re-
moved and it had become an embarrassment to the Adminis-
tration, and we, in the White House, were catching blame. And
it seemed to be something that was really not our problem; it
was their problem over there.
And even in °73 and I know Clark Mollenhoff well—and
he called me and used to talk to me a good deal, even during
the Watergate days when he was outside. But he never [18] to
my recollection in the matter of Mr. Fitzgerald ever used the
term or suggested something had been done that was criminal.
I mean, if you ask me did Mollenhoff suggest that the
matter had been badly screwed up, I would say yes, but the
idea that anything illegal had taken place or we were involved
in something illegal, no.
Q. Now, did you communicate in some way or another
your views and/or the views of Mr. Mollenhoff to the Presi-
dent? A. Oh, yes. Mollenhoff came down to me and I sent a
memorandum to the President as part of his briefing book,
giving a suggested response which contradicted or which was at
odds, you might say, with what the official response from the
Department of Defense was.
I felt the White House should take a stand, in other words,
should overrule the Department of Defense and the President
should himself overrule and should get credit for overruling the
Department of Defense on the whole matter of Mr. Fitzgerald
92a
by, as I think I suggested, removing him from the shop he was
in. Obviously there was bad blood there. As I say, making
some commendatory statement about the job he had done and
finding him a new and comparable position.
[19] In other words, the notion that in those days whistle-
blowers were very much in vogue and the very fact that Mr.
Nixon, the President, had not only commended one, but had
either promoted him or given him a job of comparable
responsibility would have made the Nixon Administration and
the President look good; and it was the right thing to do; and it
would have been a benefit and the only one whose noses would
have been out of joint would have been these people over there,
nameless, faceless individuals over there who apparently had
something against Mr. Fitzgerald because of what he reported
on the C-SA.
But let me say in terms of who’s involved in the Depart-
ment of Defense and what condition Mr. Fitzgerald was in and
whether these were bureaucratees he was involved in, I don’t
know. I relied on Mollenhoff for that.
Q. Now, with regard to the briefing books, did you, after
the press conferences, as a matter of course get the briefing
books back into your possession at some time? A. Right, it came
a time, I forget exactly when during the Nixon Administration,
when Nixon directed that all the briefing books be sent back to
me, and I had a file cabinet which contained all the briefing
books. And there was a
[41] date of this, because the—no, wait a minute. This is
consistent because we're still asking for information on the
Fitzgerald matter, I think, in that earlier memo.
This appears to be the Department of Defense’s responses
which I told Haldeman which would be coming in book
number II, which I used as the basis for the Department of
Defense response, to to speak, to the Fitzgerald question.
Can I take a look at that first one again? Where is
the—have you already given me or do we have a—no, we
don’t. Okay.
93a
Anything else?
Q. Let me move to Defendant’s 107(n). (The potocopied
document titled A. Ernest Fitzgerald, one page, was marked for
identification as Defendant’s Exhibit 107(n) and is attached to
the court copy of this deposition.) THE WITNESS: Okay.
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Before I ask you any questions on it, let me also place
before you 108(n). [The photocopied document titled A.
Ernest Fitzgerald, coded F-1 at the bottom, was marked for
identification as Defendant’s Exhibit 108(n) and is attached to
the court copy of this deposition. ]
[42] BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Let me represent to you that I don’t personally know
the source of the location of this document, and so I’m going to
ask you blindly, do you recognize this document, what the date
of it would have been or is or anything about it? A. This
appears to be the answer, requested answer to the A. Ernest
Fitzgerald question which I would have prepared based on the
materials sent to me by Colonel! Bolt.
In other words, I would never send Nixon five straight
questions on A. Ernest Fitzgerald; I would take all the material,
put it into one question.
Probably the ink coloring on the first one, 107(n) is
probably mine to indicate that from the materials Defense sent
me that Nixon should emphasize the point that the revelations
dealt with McNamara, not Laird.
108(n) seems to inciate—these are Nixon’s speeches I
believe, but you can check those from the briefing book, after
Nixon returned it.
This looks like, as I say, the question as it was sent to
Nixon. This looks like the question after Nixon had—makes
his own markings and as I say, makes a number of [43]
markings. That looks like the first response that Nixon gave.
Now, have we got—
Q. Let me, while you’re—then show you the next docu-
ment, 109(n). [The photocopied document, one page, dated
94a
December 8, 1969 Memorandum to the President from Patrick
J. Buchanan was marked for identification as Defendant’s
Exhibit 109(n) and is attached to the court copy of this
deposition. ]
MR. RAVEN-HANSEN: For the record, this has also
been previously marked. I think it was Plaintiff's Exhibit 106
marked during Mr. Mixon’s deposition.
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. If you can look at this and tell me whether you can
identify it and whether it puts in context the documents I gave
you just before it? A. All right, okay. Now, this is what it seems
to be: We sent the old man a memo on the Fitzgerald matter. I
sent my memorandum to him suggesting what he say.
In comes the Defense Department stuff. This is the
December 8th did you say was the date of the press conference?
[44] Q. Yes.
MR. KEENEY: Yes.
THE WITNESS: We let the President know what Defense
has said in effect, but we disagree with Defense’s position and
we reiterate that we disagree with that position and from a
public relations standpoint, is the term used here, we suggest,
once again, that the President handle the question if it comes up
in the way that we had recommended and that we should just
tell Secretary Laird that if he has to see it that’s what we're
going to do.
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Let me show you the next document, which is Defend-
ant’s Exhibit 110(n). [The photocopied document, one page,
on White House letterhead dated December 5, 1969, Memo-
randum for H. R. Haldeman was marked for identification as
Defendant’s Exhibit 110(n) and is attached to the court copy of
this deposition. }
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Do you recognize the— A. The scrawl?
Q. —handwriting? [45] A. Yes, that clearly seems to be
Mr. Nixon’s handwriting. These are the additions to the—this
95a
is, yes, this is one addition to the briefing book, right, that’s Mr.
Nixon’s writing, “Fitzgerald reinstated”.
It appears that he’s, he is, if you take a look at the
memorandum attached, the underlining could be that of Mr.
Nixon himself because it appears to be done in his pen, when
he says “direct” that appears to be Mr. Nixon’s underlining, as
I say.
It seems to me that he has taken our counsel because A, he
has underlined the word “direct” which he would do, “I have
decided to direct—”, and then he has said, “Fitzgerald rein-
stated” on the cover of the—on the memorandum, which is in
his briefing book. So he seems to be prepared to say at the
press conference that Mr. Fitzgerald has been reinstated or
something to that effect.
It seems like we had won the battle, in other words.
Q. Now, when you say that, that it seems that that’s what
he has done, do you base that solely upon the language that is
stated there, or is there built into that interpretation your
experience in dealing with him in the White House prior? [46]
A. Yes, as I mentioned, if you get something like—a note like
this, you can go through his briefing books and he will outline
or note precisely what he’s going to say. If you go through the
briefing books and then compare those with the transcript of
the press conference itself, you can see Nixon making each of
these points that are written right there in the briefing book.
The very fact that I believe this is his underlining of the
word “direct” that came out of the briefing book, it can only be
his underlining, because he and I are the only ones that dealt
with the briefing book itself, and if I had underlined it, it would
be on my typewriting. So he had underlined the word “direct”
and his writing is on the cover.
“Churchill quotes.” He probably sought to ask me for
some Churchill quote for some other question which he would
like to have included in his response. My guess is it’s not to the
Ernest Fitzgerald matter. I don’t think he was going to
compare him with Churchill.
96a
( Laughter. )
MR. RAVEN-HANSEN: Off the record.
(Discussion held off the record. )
[47] BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. While we’re going through documents, let me show you
this next one that’s in front of me, which would be Defendant’s
111(n). [The photocopied document, two pages stapled, on
White House letterhead dated January 21, 1970 marked “‘Con-
fidential” was marked for identification as Defendant’s Exhibit
111(n) and is attached to the court copy of this deposition. }
BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Do you recall, Mr. Buchanan, ever seeing this document
before? A. As recollection, no, I don’t.
Is this a two-page job? No.
Q. Let me place in front of you 112(n). [The photocopied
document, two pages stapled, on White House letterhead dated
December 5, 1969, Memorandum for the President from Clark
Mollenhoff Subject: The Fitzgerald Case was marked for
identification as Defendant’s Exhibit 112(n) for identification
and is attached to the court copy of this deposition. }
[48] BY MR. MORTENSON:
Q. Let me ask, do you recall this being a document that I
showed you this morning before the deposition began? A Yes, I
do. This, again, looks like—let me see. Again, looks like Mr.
Nixon’s handwriting on page 2, and also his form of under-
lining on page | with his pen.
Let me see. Let me read this. Obviously, he’s not going to
issue, you know, a major statement from the White House.
It’s got to be a suggested position with regard to the
upcoming press conference. It appears to be
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.