Amicus Brief — Mountain States Legal Foundation v. Costle

Supreme Court brief1981

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

=

No. 80-1084

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Octoser Term, 1980

Mountain States LEGAL FounpaTION, a nonprofit gation

on behalf of its members who are citizens of the State of re

THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS OF THE SENATE AND #euse-or

REPRESENTATIVES OF THE STATE OF COLORADO IN THEIR RESPECTIVE

OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS INDIVIDUALLY ELECTED LEGISLATORS OF THE

STATE OF CoLorapo; Senator Frep E. ANDERSON; Senator Dan D.

Nose; Senator L. DuANE Wooparp; Senator DONALD A. SANDOVAL;

Representative Rosert F. Burrorp; Representative JOHN G.

HaMutv; Representative W. H. (Bill) Becker; Representative

Bos Leon Kirscut; Representative Cart B. BLEDSOE;

Representative C. MicHAEL CALLIHAN; Senator RALPH A. COLE;

Representative Frank De Fitirepo; Representative STEVEN J.

DuruaM; Representative Cart H. Gustarson; Representative

WituiaM F. HitsMerer; Senator Don MAcManus; Representative

Joun R. McE perry; Representative Ray Powers; Representative

FRANK H. RANDALL; Representative PAuL D, SCHAUER;

Representative Bev ScHERLING; Representative JaMes M., SHEPARD;

Representative Cart E. SHOWALTER; Representative A. J. (Mick)

Spano; Representative KatHy SpeLts; Representative Nick THEOs;

and the State or CoLorapo ex rel. Mountain States Legal

Foundation,

Petitioners,

VS.

Dovuc.as M. Coste, in his official capacity as Administrator of the

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY;

Rocer L. WiiuraMs in his official capacity as Regional

Administrator of Region VIII of the Untrep STaTEs

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; the UNITED STATES

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; and the STATE oF COLORADO

ex rel, J. D. MACFARLANE,

Respondents.

On Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF

PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT OF

PETITIONERS MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION,

ET AL., AND BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF

PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT OF

PETITIONERS aaa” seal LEGAL FOUNDATION,

RONALD A. ZUMBRUN

JOHN H. FInp.ey

COUNSEL OF RECORD

ANTHONY T. Caso Pacific Legal Foundation

Pacific Legal Foundation 455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600

455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600 Sacramento, California 95814

Sacramento, California 95814 Telephone: (916) 444-0154

Telephone: (916) 444-0154 Attorneys for Amicus Curiae

Of Counsel Pacific Legal Foundation

February, 1981

BOWNE-PERNAU WALSH * 1045 SANSOME ST. © S.F., CA 04111 © (415) 981-7862

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Motion for leave to file brief amicus curiae of Pacific

Legal Foundation in support of petitioners Moun-

tain States Legal Foundation, et al...

Brief amicus curiae of Pacific Legal Foundation in

support of petitioners Mountain States Legal Foun-

GATOR PRE io Nihassicseresbebloceedin’ be Lessllthapediatisckied

I a escthametnn

Opinion below ..................:..c-:000+ Sie iebMMRE De halaamers

IEEE SA IY COND is nassvndiditectensenesicavbscsts ceed idecpaobsneneqnitiie

Summary of argument sia daiccisdivahdtadiis aincaess ceipuiccentettncoberscinaes

ID Seidl vn iia: diadib phtingdindtidesnsctsintchisaseeositieivenndiipinese

The actions of the Environmental Protection Agency

unconstitutionally interfere with the legislative

processes of state government .................scceeeeeceeeeeeeeeeees

II

State legislators have standing to litigate claims

arising under the Tenth Amendment to the Federal

IE ae RT PRON SON «LES RE MRE CO

0 a SES CLARE PRIA TRE 2 SOND e MMI ree

Page

ii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED

Cases

Page

Association of Data Processing Service Organizations,

SO Ws Coe, SOT Us De CED avin se ccpeensecnsdichiiceliconne 14

Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962) uo... cet cccsscceoee 14

Brown v. Environmental Protection Agency, 521 F.2d

827 (9th Cir. 1975), vacated and remanded for con-

sideration of mootness, Environmental Protection

Agency v. Brown, 431 U.S. 99 (1977), reinstated in

part, Brown v. Environmental Protection Agency,

566 F.2d 665 (9th Cir. 1977) .............. 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

Charles C. Steward Machine Co. v. Davis, 301 U.S. 548

ERE. AC TE Se Nm One RAP IED ly Se, 5a 13

United States v. California, 297 U.S. 175 (1936) .......... 9

United States v. Students Challenging Regulatory

Agency Procedures (SCRAP), 412 U.S. 669 (1973) .. 14

Constitutions

Colorado Constitution:

FEES RR cc SR AAO nce eR NS a 14

a I i 14

United States Constitution:

I bili nteccnnssrvsinnccotutevnesvesesnosveahbpielabiicnislains 13

SE ts CII p.cricersctstituatsinocinininonbcdionbsisptabineliiieaedlial 6, 14

PRL EOL OS ONE 6, 13, 14

Rules

Rules of the Supreme Court of the United States,

I TI isd nncepihaiianlaiibe cutie, iiecceihecanna amelie a an 2

Statute

Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. sections 7401, et seq. ..............

EN ar EI RR EE Se 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12

’>

73

No. 80-1084

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Octosper Term, 1980

Mountain States LecAL FounpaATION, a nonprofit corporation,

Colorado;

on behalf of its members who are citizens of the State

THe FoLLOWING MEMBERS OF THE SENATE AND House OF

REPRESENTATIVES OF THE STATE OF COLORADO IN THEIR RESPECTIVE

OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS INDIVIDUALLY ELECTED LEGISLATORS OF THE

STATE OF CoLorapo; Senator Frep E. ANDERSON; Senator Dan D.

Nosex; Senator L. DuANE Wooparp; Senator DonALp A. SANDOVAL;

Representative Ropert F. Burrorp; Representative JoHN G.

HaML1y; Representative W. H. (Bill) Becxer; Representative

Bos Leon Kirscut; Representative Cart B. BLEDSOE;

Representative C. MicHAEL CALLIHAN; Senator Rap A. Coie;

Representative FRANK De Fiippo; Representative STEVEN J.

Durum; Representative Cart H. Gustarson; Representative

WiLuiAaM F. HitsMerer; Senator Don MacManus; Representative

Joun R. McEvperry; Representative Ray Powers; Representative

FRANK H. RANDALL; Representative PauL D. SCHAUER;

Representative Bev SCHERLING; Representative James M. SHEPARD;

Representative Cart E. SHowALTER; Representative A. J. (Mick)

Spano; Representative KATHY SPELTs; Representative Nick THEOs;

and the STaTe or CoLtorapo ex rel. Mountain States Legal

Foundation,

Petitioners,

vs.

Dovuctas M. Cos te, in his official capacity as Administrator of the

UnrTep STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY;

Rocer L. Wiiu1aMs in his official capacity as Regional

Administrator of Region VIII of the Unrrep States

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; the UNITED STATES

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; and the STATE or CoLORADO

ex rel, J. D. MACFARLANE,

espondents.

On Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE

OF PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT OF

PETITIONERS snes 3 — LEGAL FOUNDATION,

7%

|

2

This motion of Pacific Legal Foundation to file the an-

nexed brief amicus curiae is respectfully made pursuant

to Supreme Court Rule No. 36. Petitioners Mountain

States Legal Foundation, et al., have consented to the

filing of this brief. Counsel for the Department of Justice

has refused consent on behalf of federal respondents, how-

ever, the Solicitor General has consented on behalf of the

United States. The State of Colorado ex rel. J. D. Mac-

Farlane is of the opinion that this case is moot and has,

therefore, declined to consent to the filing of this brief.

The written consents of petitioners Mountain States Legal

Foundation, et al., and of the Solicitor General have been

lodged with the Clerk of this Court.

PLF is a nonprofit, tax-exempt corporation organized

and existing under the laws of California for the purpose

of engaging in litigation in m* ‘ters effecting the broad

public interest. Policy for PLF is set by a Board of

Trustees composed of concerned citizens, the majority of

whom are attorneys. The Board evaluates the merits of any

contemplated legal action and authorizes such legal action

only where the Foundation’s position has broad support

within the general community. The PLF Board has autho-

rized the filing of this brief.

PLF is a party to similar litigation currently pending

before this Court (Pacific Legal Foundation, et al. v.

Costle, et al., No. 80-828 (filed Nov. 1980)), and actively

participated in prior litigation on similar issues (Brown

v. Environmental Protection Agency, 521 F.2d 827 (9th

Cir. 1975); Environmental Protection Agency v. Brown,

431 U.S. 99 (1977); Brown v. Environmental Protection

ee

3

Agency, 566 F.2d 665 (9th Cir. 1977) ). Thus, PLF believes

that due to its unique expertise in this area and its public

interest perspective, it can provide this Court with addi-

tional argument regarding the issues in this case.

Because of the national significance of the case, Pacific

Legal Foundation feels that the present parties cannot

adequately represent the interests of the public while at

the same time representing their own localized interests.

For the foregoing reasons, Pacific Legal Foundation

requests that this motion to file the annexed brief amicus

curiae be granted.

Respectfully submitted,

RoNnALD A, ZUMBRUN

JouN H. FInDLey

COUNSEL OF RECORD

By JOHN H. FINDLEY

Pacific Legal Foundation

455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600

Antuony T. Caso

Pacific al Foundation

455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600

Sacramento, California 95814

Telephone: (916) 444-0154

Of Counsel

Sacramento, California 95814

Telephone: (916) 444-0154

Attorneys for Amicus Curiae

Paci gal Foundation

80-1084

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Octoser Term, 1980

MounTaIn States Lecat FounpaTion, a nonprofit corporation,

Colorado;

on behalf of its members who are citizens of the State

THE FOLLOWING MEMBERS OF THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF

REPRESENTATIVES OF THE STATE OF COLORADO IN THEIR RESPECTIVE

OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS INDIVIDUALLY ELECTED LEGISLATORS OF THE

STATE OF CoLorapo; Senator Frep E. ANpERsoN; Senator Dan D.

NoseEL; Senator L. DuANE Wooparp; Senator DoNALp A. SANDOVAL;

Representative Ropert F. Burrorp; Representative JoHN G.

HaMLIn; Representative W. H. (Bill) Becker; Representative

Bos Leon Kirscut; Representative Cari B. BLEDSOE;

Representative C. MicHarL CALLIMAN; Senator RALPH A. Coie;

Representative FRANK De Fiuirpo; Representative STEVEN J.

DurHAM; Representative Cart H. Gustarson; Representative

WiutuaM F. HitsMerer; Senator Don MacManus; Representative

Joun R. McExperry; Representative Ray Powers; Representative

FRANK H. RANDALL; Representative PauL D. SCHAUER;

Representative Bev SCHERLING; Representative JAMEs M. SHEPARD;

Representative Cart E. SHOWALTER; Representative A. J. (Mick)

SPANO; Representative Katuy Spe.ts; Representative Nick THEOs;

and the STaTEe or CoLorapo ex rel. Mountain States Legal

Foundation,

Petitioners,

VS.

Dovuctas M. Cost e, in his official capacity as Administrator of the

Unrrep STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY;

Rocer L. Wiiu1aMs in his official capacity as Regional

Administrator of Region VIII of the Unirep StaTEs

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; the UNITED STATES

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY; and the STATE or CoLORADO

ex rel, ; D. MACFARLANE,

On Writ of Certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit

BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE OF PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION

IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS MOUNTAIN STATES LEGAL

FOUNDATION, ET AL.

| PREVIOUS PAGE WAS BLANK §j

ne ee oe mee

'%

-*

6

INTEREST OF AMICUS

The interest of amicus curiae is set out in the preceding

motion fur leave to file this brief.

OPINION BELOW

The opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for

the Tenth Circuit is reported at 630 F.2d 754 (1980).

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

Amicus adopts petitioners’ statement of the case set out

in the petition for writ of certiorari.

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

1. The overzealous administration of the Clean Air Act

by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) brings

before this Court the question of whether, under Article

4, Section 4 of, and the Tenth Amendment to, the Federal

Constitution, the states are free to enact or refuse to enact

their own laws. Amicus asks this Court to note that in

prior litigation concerning similar issues, EPA conceded

to this Court the necessity of removing from its regulations

any requirement that states adopt laws or regulations.

2. The guaranty to the states of a republican form of

government and the Colorado Constitution, taken together,

grant Colorado State Legislators standing to litigate claims

based upon the sovereignty of the State of Colorado.

7

ARGUMENT

I

THE ACTIONS OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTEC.

TION AGENCY UNCONSTITUTIONALLY INTER.

FERE WITH THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESSES OF

STATE GOVERNMENT

The petition for writ of certiorari in this case asks this

Court to hear a challenge to actions of EPA that alter the

fundamental structure of Colorado state government. The

present controversy is rooted in Colorado’s participation

in the federal Clean Air Act program, 42 U.S.C. §§ 7401,

et seq. It seems that Colorado’s voluntary participation

in the program did not measure up to the desires of EPA.

Thus, EPA ordered the State Legislature to enact new

laws and when the Legislature failed to keep pace with the

schedule ordered by EPA bureaucrats, the State of Colo-

rado was subjected to severe punitive sanctions.

That EPA would take action so blatantly repugnant to

the constitutional principles of federalism should come as

a shock and surprise to this Court. In 1977, in litigation

concerning nearly identical issues, EPA conceded to this

Court the necessity of removing from its regulations re-

quirements for states to adopt legislation or regulations.

Environmental Protection Agency v. Brown, 431 U.S. 99,

103 (1977). Apparently, EPA believes that it is not bound

by its statements and promises to this Court.

The statements of EPA to this Court in 1977 were the

result of litigation commenced in California, Maryland,

Virginia, and Washington, D.C. Jd. at 102. The California

litigation was based on petitions for review of EPA regu-

7%

8

lations filed by 208 parties including the State of Cali-

fornia and Pacific Legal Foundation. See Brown v. En-

vironmental Protection Agency, 521 F.2d 827, 828 (9th

Cir. 1975), vacated and remanded for consideration of

mootness, Environmental Protection Agency v. Brown, 431

U.S. 99 (1977), reinstated in part, Brown v. Environmental

Protection Agency, 566 F.2d 665 (9th Cir. 1977). Some of

the regulations at issue in that case

“specifically directed the State of California to under-

take those tasks assigned to it, to report its compliance

to the Agency, and, in the case of the inspection and

maintenance program, to report the date by which the

State would recommend any needed legislation and to

submit ‘[a] signed statement from the Governor and

State Treasurer identifying the sources and amounts

of funds needed for the program’ and the ‘text of

needed legislation’ if existing legislation does not

authorize the funds which the program will require.”

Brown v. Environmental Protection Agency, 521 F.2d

at 830.

To enforce these regulations, EPA claimed the power to:

impose a receivership on state functions; hold state

officials in civil contempt with substantial daily fines until

compliance was secured; and require the state to allocate

funds from its budget to finance the EPA mandated proj-

ects. Id. at 831.

In holding that the Clean Air Act simply did not autho-

rize the attempts of EPA to force California to adopt laws,

the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

stated :

“Our holding recognizes that the pollution-creating

activities of the State of California, its instrumen-

9

talities and subdivisions, and its municipalities, are

subject to valid regulations promulgated by the Ad-

ministrator. We also recognize that the State must

avoid impeding any enforcement of valid regulations

which the Administrator undertakes. We reject, how-

ever, the view that the Clean Air Act authorizes the

imposition of sanctions against the State for its failure

to administer and enforce a system of regulations

promulgated by the Administrator which are designed

to control the pollution-creating activities of the

citizens of the State and others subject to its juris-

diction. Tersely put, the Act, as we see it, permits

sanctions against a state that pollutes the air, but not

against a state that chooses not to govern polluters

as the Administrator directs.” Id. at 832 (emphasis

added).

Although the Court of Appeals struck down EPA’s regu-

lations as not authorized by the Clean Air Act, the court

noted:

“Knough has been said to demonstrate why we do not

feel compelled by the language of the Act to reach

the serious constitutional issues which the Adminis-

trator’s interpretation raises. Validation of our inter-

pretation, however, requires that we set forth these

issues and, by suggesting our evaluation of them,

reveal the intensity of our desire to avoid confronting

them.” Jd. at 837.

In support of the constitutionality of its actions, EPA

argued that the regulation of air pollution, regardless

of its source, is a proper exercise of congressional power

under the Commerce Clause. Citing United States v. Cali-

fornia, 297 U.S. 175 (1936)—holding that state owned

railroads were subject to federal safety regulations—EPA

7s

10

contended that since the State of California built roads,

licensed vehicles, and made traffic laws, regulations order-

ing the state to adopt certain air pollution laws was

proper. Brown v. Environmental Protection Agency, 521

F.2d at 838. While recognizing the plenary power of

Congress ‘to regulate commerce, the Court of Appeals

noted that there is a significant distinction between regu-

lation of a state’s participation in economic activity and

regulation of a state’s governance of that same activity.

Id. at 838.

“The power of states over commerce has no more

been recognized as commerce than has the power of

Congress which is derived from the Commerce Clause.

Each find their source in the Constitution. Both are

of the same family and genus, although not of the

same species. The power of the states must yield to

Federal power in order to effectuate Federal su-

premacy, not because the power of the state is com-

merce.

“To treat the governance of commerce by the states

as within the plenary reach of the Commerce Power

would in our opinion represent such an abrupt de-

parture from previous constitutional practice as to

make us reluctant to adopt an interpretation of the

Clean Air Act which would force us to confront the

issue. Such treatment, for example, would authorize

Congress to direct the states to regulate any economic

activity that affects interstate commerce in ary man-

ner Congress sees fit... . A Commerce Vower so

expanded would reduce the states to puppets of a

ventriloquist Congress. We will not attribute to

Congress any such intent unless it is expressed un-

equivocally.” Jd. at 839 (emphasis in original).

11

On certiorari to this Court, EPA backed down from its

radical position.

“(T]he federal parties have . . . not merely renounced

an intent to pursue certain specified regulations; they

now appear to admit that those remaining in contro-

versy are invalid unless modified in certain respects:

‘The Administrator ... concedes the necessity of

removing from the regulations all requirements that

the States submit legally adopted regulations; the

[Administrator’s] regulations contain no require-

ment that the State adopt laws.’ Brief for Federal

Parties 20 n 14.

“The federal parties’ position now appears to be that,

while the challenged transportation plans do not re-

quire the enactment of state legislation, they do now

contain, and must be modified to eliminate, certain

requirements that the State promulgate regwlations.

See Reply Brief for Federal Parties 14 n 22.” Environ-

mental Protection Agency v. Brown, 431 U.S. at 103

(emphasis in original).

As a result of this concession by EPA, this Court vacated

the judgment of the Court of Appeals and remanded the

case for consideration of mootness. Jd. at 104.

When the Court of Appeals reconsidered the case pur-

suant to this Court’s order, it had not only the amended

regulations of EPA to consider but also the 1977 amend-

ments to the Clean Air Act which are before this Court

in the instant action. Although EPA amended its regu-

lations pursuant to its promise to this Court, the regulations

still required the State of California to implement a vehicle

inspection and maintenance program. The Court of Appeals

found no substantive distinction between the original regu-

e%

FS

12

lation and the amended regulation since both purported

to require the state to govern in a particular manner.

Brown v. Environmental Protection Agency, 566 F.2d at

668-70. The Court of Appeals also rejected EPA’s argu-

ment that California—as a builder of roads—could be

regulated as an indirect source of pollution under the 1977

amendments to the Clean Air Act. Jd. at 669. The court

further noted that had it been the intent of Congress to

regulate states as indirect sources of pollution, the consti-

tutionality of the legislation would be seriously in question.

Id. at 670.

Although EPA admitted to this Court the necessity of

removing from its regulations the requirement that states

adopt legisiation or regulations—it did not in fact do so.

Rather, EPA merely removed the words “legislation” and

“regulation” from its rules but continued to require af-

firmative action by the states which the states could only

comply with by enacting legislation or promulgating regu-

lations. The Ninth Circuit correctly found the new EPA

regulations to create a distinction without a difference.

See id. at 668-79. In spite of the refusal of the Ninth Circuit

to sanction its tyrannical grab for power, and in spite of

its promises to this Court, EPA once again claims the

authority to order a state to enact legislation in accordance

with a schedule ordered by EPA bureaucrats. Amicus

urges this Court to grant the petition in order to reaffirm

the proposition that ours is a federal system of govern-

ment and to prevent the reduction of “the states to puppets

of a ventriloquist Congress.” Brown v. Environmental

Protection Agency, 521 F.2d at 839.

13

II

STATE LEGISLATORS HAVE STANDING TO LITI-

GATE CLAIMS ARISING UNDER THE TENTH

AMENDMENT TO THE FEDERAL CONSTITUTION

Amicus is anxious for this Court to dispel the myth that

states are the only proper parties to litigate claims arising

under the Tenth Amendment to the Federal Constitution.

The origin of this currently popular myth is somewhat

of a mystery since it finds no support in the decisions of

this Court. For example, in Charles C. Steward Machine

Co. v. Davis, 301 U.S. 548 (1937), plaintiff, an Alabama

corporation, brought suit to recover unemployment insur-

ance taxes paid under the Federal Social Security Act

claiming, inter alia, that the tax, with its 90% credit for

employers in states with state created unemployment

compensation funds, coerced states into enacting laws in

violation of the Tenth Amendment. Although this Court

held the tax to be a proper exercise of the power of

Congress to tax and spend (U.S. Const., Art. 1, 48), this

Court did allow plaintiff, a corporation, to litigate a claim

based on the sovereignty of the State of Alabama even

though the state was not a party to the action (Steward

Machine, 301 U.S. at 585-99). Steward Machine therefore

demonstrates that the question of standing to litigate

claims arising under the Tenth Amendment is not resolved

by the simplistic solution of looking at the caption to see

whether a state is a party to the suit.

In order to establish standing, the petitioners must

demonstrate that they have or will suffer injury in fact

and that the injury is to an interest that is arguably within

es

°*.

14

the zone of interest sought to be protected by the statute

or the constitutional guarantee in question. Umted States

v. Students Challengmg Regulatory Agency Procedures

(SCRAP), 412 U.S. 669, 686 (1973); Association of Data

Processing Service Organizations, Inc. v. Camp, 397 U.S.

150, 153 (1970). The fact that many suffer the same injury

is of no legal consequence. SCRAP, 412 U.S. at 687; see

Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186, 204-08 (1962). In the instant

action, the named members of the Colorado State Legis-

lature suffer direct injury in fact as a result of the un-

constitutional actions of EPA. The Federal Constitution

reserves to the states the police power (U.S. Const., Amend.

X) and requires the states to exercise that power through

a republican form of government (U.S. Const., Art. 4, 44).

By state constitution, all legislative power in Colorado is

vested in the State Legislature. Colo. Const., art. III and

art. V, $1. Thus, in Colorado the primary beneficiaries

of the Reserved Powers Clause of the Federal Constitution

are the members of the Colorado State Legislature and

any intrusion upon the sovereignty of the state is an

intrusion upon the state and federal constitutionally guar-

anteed powers of these state legislators.

ii we - a U otek

15

CONCLUSION

Despite the consistent refusal of the federal courts to

uphold the attempts of EPA to order states to govern in

a particular manner, EPA has once again attempted to

strip the last vestiges of sovereignty from the states.

These unconstitutional actions of EPA were challenged in

a timely manner by members of the Colorado State Legis-

lature and a public interest group whose members, sup-

porters, and contributors are citizens of the State of

Colorado. All of these petitioners, therefore, suffer direct

injury in fact from the unconstitutional actions of EPA.

In order to ensure that the earlier promise of EPA to this

Court that the agency would remove from its regulations

any requirement for states to adopt laws or regulations

is not forsworn, amicus urges this Court to grant the

petition.

Respectfully submitted,

RONALD A. ZUMBRUN

Joun H. Finpiey

COUNSEL OF RECORD

ANTHONY T. Caso Pacific Legal Foundation

Pacific al Foundation 455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600

455 Capitol Mall, Suite 600 Sacramento, California 95814

Sacramento, California 95814 Telephone: (916) 444-0154

Telephone: (916) 444-0154 Attorneys for Amicus Curiae

Of Counsel Pacific Legal Foundation

February, 1981.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.