Appendix — CBS v. Federal Communications Commission
Supreme Court brief1981
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
:
t
g
'
Nos. 80-207, 80-213, 80-214 |
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States |
OCTOBER TERM, 1980
CBS INc.,
Petitioner,
V.
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
AND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al.,
Respondents.
AMERICAN BROADCASTING COMPANIES, INC.,
¥ Petitioner,
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
AND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al.,
Respondents.
NATIONAL BROADCASTING COMPANY, INC.
‘ Petitioner,
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
AND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, et al.,
Respondents.
On Writs of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
JOINT APPENDIX
Pi OAL RIE ARTEL ALD
(List of counsel on inside cover)
PETITIONS FOR CERTIORARI FILED AUGUST 11 AND 13, 1980
CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 3, 1980
a
J. ROGER WOLLENBERG
JOEL ROSENBLOOM
TIMOTHY B. Dyk
THOMAS W. WHITE
WILMER & PICKERING
1666 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
(202) 872-6000
Counsel for Petitioner CBS Inc.
JAMES A. MCKENNA, JR.
THOMAS N. FROHOCK
CARL R. RAMEY
DENNIS P. CORBETT
McKENNA, WILKINSON &
KITTNER
1150 17th Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 861-2600
Counsel for Petitioner American
Broadcasting Companies, Inc.
FLOYD ABRAMS
DEAN RINGEL
PATRICIA A. PICKREL
CAHILL GORDON & REINDEL
80 Pine Street
New York, New York 10005
(212) 825-0100
Counsel for Petitioner National
Broadcasting Co., Inc.
December 18, 1980
WADE H. McCREE, JR.
Solicitor General
Lou!Is F. CLAIBORNE
STEPHEN M. SHAPIRO
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 633-2217
ROBERT R. BRUCE
General Counsel
DANIEL M. ARMSTRONG, III
Associate General Counsel
C. GREY PASH, JR.
LISA B. MARGOLIS
Attorneys
Federal Communications
Commission
Washington, D.C. 20554
Counsel for the Federal
Respondents
JOHN D. LANE
RAMSEY L. WOODWORTH
HEDRICK AND LANE
1211 Connecticut Avenue,
N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 628-5923
Counsel for Respondent
Carter/Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc.
III.
IV.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
. Docket Entries in the United States Court of Ap-
peals (D.C. Cir.) in CBS Inc. v. FCC, No. 79-2403..
. Docket Entries in the United States Court of Ap-
peals (D.C. Cir.) in American Broadcasting Com-
panies, Inc. V. FCC, No. 79-2406 ................0.-.-0000s000-
Docket Entries in the United States Court of Ap-
peals (D.C. Cir.) in National Broadcasting Com-
pany, Inc. V. FCC, No. 19-2407 ..............2220000000s00000-0
Relevant Pleadings Before and Order of Federal
Communications Commission in Carter-Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc, ...............2-...c0000-0-0-00-00-
1. Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc.
Complaint Against ABC Television Network,
CBS Television Network, NBC Television
Network (October 29, 1979) ........22..2.222..2222000---
2. Letter from American Broadcasting Com-
panies, Inc. to Arthur L. Ginsburg, Chief,
Complaints and Compliance Division, Broad-
cast Bureau, Federal Communications Com-
mission (November 5, 1979) ................-2222222----
8. Response of National Broadcasting Company,
Inc. (November 6, 1979) ...................................
4. Response of CBS Inc. (November 6, 1979)...
5. Reply of Carter-Mondale Presidential Com-
mittee, Inc. (November 7, 1979) ...........000002....
6. Comments of the National Association of
Broadcasters (November 8, 1979) .................
7. Letter from Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc., to William J. Tricarico,
Secretary, Federal Communications Commis-
sion (November 9, 1979) ....................cccce0eee-
8. Comments of National Citizens Committee
for Broadcasting (November 13, 1979) .........
Page
17
25
27
52
60
75
94
108
113
115
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
Transcript of Open Commission Meeting
CRUOORIIIONT TR TT OD vovinnncscteceenncectancetcctecinceene
CBS Inc., Petition for Stay (November 21,
I ea ieincccs en tenn abiecas ble ake tepid sili Naeplegaacisvns
. CBS Inc., Petition for Reconsideration (No-
I res ID ake thectntectdicaeenmeeiniontoentakasece
Letter from National Broadcasting Company,
Inc. to William J. Tricarico, Secretary, Fed-
eral Communications Commission, Concern-
ing Reconsideration of Decision (November
ee: TR eects nicer nea loiss cettoe cectdconne
Letter from National Broadcasting Company,
Inc. to William J. Tricarico, Secretary, Fed-
eral Communications Commission, Concern-
ing Stay of Compliance Order (November
en dies
Petition for Reconsideration of American
Broadcasting Companies, Inc. (November 23,
pg 5 | FLARED SRT SUC ARPT AOL OR ERE Ree RA CI
American Broadcasting Companies, Inc., Mo-
tion for Stay (November 28, 1979) .................
Opposition of National Citizens Committee
for Broadcasting to Networks’ Petitions for
Stay (November 28, 1979) ...........................00.
Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc.,
Opposition to Petitions for Stay (November
i. ME ttcticdndaciilbaiiisescc ce cen,
Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc.,
Opposition to Petitions for Reconsideration
CERIO Ti RIP ask ariciehnnntdanicnsbacnhismnpas dices
CBS Inc., Reply to Oposition to Petitions for
Stay (November 26, 1979) ................222.2..222200--
Page
131
163
166
174
181
185
194
197
200
218
VI.
20.
21.
22.
24.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
Memorandum Opinion and Order of Federal
Communications Commission (November 26,
SS LEAT Bera ROP eR ee tae Ho as ORME iene a
National Association of Broadcasters Petition
for Reconsideration and Comments in Sup-
port of Motions for Stay (November 26,
WII? avtelisra cea cdliaiosedcraiababciabledinabtsetaiialieda tameas
Further Statement of Carter-Mondale Presi-
dential Committee, Inc. (November 27, 1979)..
Letter from National Broadcasting Company,
Inc. to William J. Tricarico, Secretary, Fed-
eral Communications Commission (November
EID aan ceaticsbh cinclnctilelicntsiseiesra lass ebaichainezcaiies
Transcript of Special Open Commission Meet-
Se CEPOWOTMOR TB, ROTO) cciccecicccsccntccettisnccsiesse
. Orders of the United States Supreme Court Grant-
ing Petitions for Certiorari (November 3, 1980)..
The following decisions, opinions, and orders have
been omitted in printing this Joint Appendix, be-
cause they appear as Appendices to the Petitions
for Writs of Certiorari in Nos. 80-207, 80-213, and
80-214, at the following pages:
1.
Memorandum Opinion and Order of the Fed-
eral Communications Commission in Carter-
Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc. (No-
ee. RR Reema ee el SN
Memorandum Opinion and Order of Federal
Communications Commission on Petitions for
Reconsideration and Stay in Carter-Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc. (November 28,
S| PUL S aae r eo wnt 9 sw, x Siero A aoe CED
Opinion of the Court of Appeals in CBS Inc.
v. FCC, Nos. 79-2408, 79-2406, 79-2407 (March
Si AOD in icicles alcaias ential ncncandadaphibedanic
Page
231
232
237
240
242
265
69a
110a
-%
7.
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
4. Order of Court of Appeals Denying Petitions
for Rehearing (May 15, 1980) ~........................
5. Order of Court of Appeals Denying Sugges-
tions of Rehearing En Banc (May 15, 1980)..
6. Order of Mr. Chief Justice Burger Granting
Extension of Time in Which to Petition for a
Writ of Certiorari (June 4, 1980) .....0.0.000.......
I
DOCKET ENTRIES
in the
United States Court of Appeals (D.C. Cir.)
in
CBS Inc. v. FCC
No. 79-2403
3
DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Nov. 28 Petitioner’s petition for review of an order of the
FCC
29 Certified copy of petition for review was mailed to
the FCC & Attorney General
28 Petitioner’s motion for stay and for expedited
consideration on the merits
28 Petitioner’s motion for expedited consideration of
motion for stay and for expedited consideration
on the merits
29 Petitioners’ (ABC, CBS, NBC) motion for leave
to file appendix in lieu of joint appendix
29 Respondent’s (FCC) opposition to motions for stay
and for expedited consideration
29 Motion of National Association of Broadcasters
for leave to intervene
29 Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting for leave to participate as amicus curiae
29 Per Curiam order that the motion for stay is
granted until further order of this Court and that
because of the obvious complexity of the issues in-
volved and the need of this Court to receive full
and complete briefing, the consideration of the
motion to expedite is deferred until the parties
agree upon a briefing schedule to be submitted to
the Court; Tamm, Robb and Wilkey (who did not
participate), CJs
80 Motion of Carter/Mondale Presidential vial
mittee, Inc. for leave to intervene
' PREVIOUS PAGE WAS BLANK |
|
4
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 4 FCC’s motion to consolidate with Nos. 79-2406 and
79-2407
FCC’s motion to adopt expedited briefing schedule
Certified Index to Record
Clerk’s order, sua sponte, that Nos. 79-2403, 79-
2406 and 79-2407 are consolidated
Clerk’s order granting the motion of Carter/Mon-
dale Presidential Committee, Inc. for leave to
intervene
Intervenor’s (Carter/Mondale) opposition to mo-
tion for stay
Clerk’s order granting the motions of National
Association of Broadcasters for leave to intervene
and the motion of National Citizens Committee for
Broadcasting et al. for leave to participate as
amicus curiae. The request to participate in oral
argument is denied without prejudice to resubmis-
sion at such time as counsel is notified of the sched-
uling or argument
Intervenor’s response to motion for stay and ex-
pedited consideration
Amicus Curiae opposition to motion for stay and
expedited consideration
Per curiam order granting the motion to adopt
expedited briefing schedule as follows: petitioner’s
and supporting intervenors—Dec. 7th, Respond-
ent’s and supporting intervenors—Dec. 18th and
reply briefs—Dec. 21st. petitioners and supporting
intervenors shall submit memoranda on or before
Dec. 17th addressed to the question of mootness.
Respondents and supporting intervenors shall sub-
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec.
12
18
17
18
18
18
18
18
19
mit separate memoranda addressed to the same
question along with their briefs on Dec. 18th.
All parties on the same side are directed to file
joint briefs wherever possible. These cases will
be heard at oral argument during the period
January 1-30th, 1980; Tamm, Robb, CJs and
Wilkey, CJ (who did not participate)
Petitioner’s brief
Intervenor’s (National Assoc. of Broadcasters)
brief
Clerk’s order granting the motion of the National
Broadcasting Co. for leave to file brief in excess
of page limitation
Petitioner’s motion for allotment of time for oral
argument and for leave to permit three counsel per
side to argue
Petitioner’s memorandum concerning the question
of mootness
Motion of Stewart Rawlings Mott et al. for leave
to participate as amicus curiae and to participate
in oral argument
Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting, for leave to participate in oral argument
Memorandum of Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc. on question of mootness
Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) brief
Intervenor’s (Carter-Mondale Presidential Com-
mittee, Inc.) brief
FCC’s motion for leave to file typewritten briefs,
pending printing
|
6
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 19 FCC’s motion for leave to file brief in excess of
19
21
21
21
27
28
page limitations
FCC’s motion for leave to file memorandum on
question of mootness, time having expired
Clerk’s order granting respondents’ motion to ac-
cept late memorandum on the question of mootness
Respondents’ memorandum on the question of
mootness
Clerk’s order denying petitioners’ motion for allot-
ment of 45 minutes to present oral argument and
the following times are allotted for oral argument:
petitioners—30 minutes and respondents—30 min-
utes. The motion for leave to permit three counsel
per side to argue is granted
Petitioner’s reply brief
Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) reply brief
Clerk’s order granting respondents’ motion to ac-
cept late brief and in excess page limitations
Respondent’s brief
Respondent’s brief
Clerk’s order granting the motion of Stewart
Rawlings Mott, et al. for leave to participate as
amicus curiae and to adopt brief and denying the
motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting, et al. for leave to participate in oral argu-
ment
Amicus Curiae (Nat’l Citizens and Stewart Rawl-
ings, etc.) brief
Clerk’s order granting petitioner’s motion to file
appendix in lieu of joint appendix
Petitioner’s appendix
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1980
Jan. 10 Argued before SCJ Bazelon, Tamm*, CJ and CJ
26
Apr. 18
May 15
Markey, U.S. Court of Customs and Patent
Appeals
Opinion for the Court filed by Senior Circuit
Judge Bazelon
Concurring opinion filed by Circuit Judge Tamm
Judgment that the orders of the FCC under review
herein are hereby affirmed, in accordance with the
opinion of this Court filed herein this date
Petitioners’ motion to extend time to file petitions
for rehearing and suggestions for rehearing en
banc to April 18, 1980
Intervenor’s (Carter-Mondale) conditional consent
to grant of petitioners’ Motion to extend time
Petitioners’ reply to intervenor’s conditional con-
sent
Petitioners’ motion for leave to file petition for
rehearing exceeding page limitations
Per Curiam order granting petitioner’s motion to
extend time and file petition for rehearing to April
21, 1980; SCJ Bazelon, Tamm, CJ and Markey,
CJ, U.S. Court of Customs and Patent Appeals
Intervenor’s (NAB) petition for rehearing
Per Curiam order, en banc denying petitioner’s
motion for leave to exceed page limitations and the
Clerk is directed to return the lodged copies of the
petition for rehearing and/or suggestion for re-
hearing en banc to counsel for CBS Inc.; CJ
Wright, Tamm, Robinson, MacKinnon (who would
grant leave to exceed page limits), Robb, Wilkey,
Wald, Mikva, and Edwards, CJ’s
8
FILIN GS—PROCEEDINGS
15
Per Curiam order denying the petitions for re-
hearing filed by NAB, ABC and NBC; SCJ
Bazelon, Tamm, CJ and Markey, Chief Judge,
U.S. Court of Customs and Patent Appeals
Per Curiam order en banc denying the sugges-
tions for rehearing filed by NAB, ABC and NBC;
CJ Wright, Temm, Robinson, MacKinnon, Robb,
Wilkey, Wald, Mikva & Edwards, CJ’s
Copy of letter from Clerk, Supreme Court ex-
tending the time to file petition for writ of cer-
tiorari to August 11, 1980 in S.C. No. A-1023
Notice from Clerk, Supreme Court that a petition
for writ of certiorari was filed in SC No. 80-207
on August 11, 1980
Certified copy order from Clerk, Supreme Court
granting the petition for writ of certiorari in SC
No. 80-207 on November 3, 1980; consolidating
with SC Nos. 80-213 and 80-214 and allotting one
hour for oral argument
II
DOCKET ENTRIES
in the
United States Court of Appeals (D.C. Cir.)
in
American Broadcasting Companies, Inc. v. FCC
No. 79-2406
11
DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Nov. 28 Petitioner’s petition for review of an order of the
FCC
29 Certified copy of petition for review was mailed
to the FCC & Attorney General
28 Petitioner’s motion for expedited consideration
and for temporary stay
29 Respondent’s (FCC) opposition to motions for stay
and for expedited consideration
29 Motion of National Association of Broadcasters
for leave to intervene
29 Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting for leave to participate as amicus curiae
29 Per Curiam order that the motion for stay is
granted until further order of this Court and that
because of the obvious complexity of the issues
involved and the need of this Court to receive
full and complete briefing, the consideration of
the motion to expedite is deferred until the parties
agree upon a briefing schedule to be submitted to
the Court; Tamm, Robb & Wilkey (who did not
participate), CJs
30 Motion of Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee,
Inc. for leave to intervene
Dec. 4 FCC’s motion to consolidate with Nos. 79-2408
and 79-2407
FCC’s motion to adopt expedited briefing schedule
Certified Index to Record
Clerk’s order, sua sponte, that Nos. 79-2408, 79-
2406 & 79-2407 are consolidated
_ PREVIOUS PAGE WAS BLANK |
rr ———
12
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
Clerk’s order granting the motion of National
Association of Broadcasters for leave to intervene
Clerk’s order granting the motion of Carter/Mon-
dale Presidential Committee, Inc. for leave to
intervene
Intervenor’s (Carter/Mondale) opposition to mo-
tion for stay
Interveror’s (Nat’l Assoc. of Broadcasters) re-
sponse to motion for stay and expedited consid-
eration
Clerk’s order granting the motions of National
Association of Broadcasters for leave to intervene
and the motion of National Citizens Committee for
Broadcasting, et al. for leave to participate as
amicus curiae. The request to participate in oral
arcument is denied without prejudice to resub-
mission at such time as counsel is notified of
the scheduling of argument
Amicus Curiae opposition to motion for stay and
expedited consideration
Per Curiam order granting the motion to adopt
expedited briefing schedule as follows: Petitioner’s
and supporting intervenor’s—Dec. 7th, Respond-
ent’s and supporting intervenors—Dec. 18th and
Reply Briefs—Dec. 21st. Petitioners and support-
ing intervenors shall submit memoranda on or
before Dec. 17th addressed to the question of moot-
ness. Respondents and supporting intervenors
shall submit separate memoranda addressed to the
same question along with their briefs on Dec. 18th.
All parties on the same side are directed to file
file joint briefs wherever possible. These cases will
be heard at oral argument during the period Jan-
uary 1-30, 1980; Tamm, Robb, CJ’s and Wilkey
(who did not participate)
13
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS A Sg
1979
Dec. Petitioner’s brief
12
13
17
18
18
18
18
18
19
19
19
21
Intervenor’s (National Association of Broad-
casters) brief
Clerk’s order granting the motion of National
Broadcasting Co. for leave to file brief in excess
of page limits
Petitioner’s motion for allotment of time for oral
argument and for leave to permit three counsel
per side to argue
Petitioner’s memorandum concerning the question
of mootness
Motion of Stewart Rawlings Mott, et al. for leave
to participate as amicus curiae and to participate
in oral argument
Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting, for leave to participate in oral argument
Memorandum of Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc. on question of mootness
Intervenor’s (Carter-Mondale Presidential Com-
mittee, Inc.) brief
Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) brief
FCC’s motion for leave to file typewritten briefs,
pending printing
FCC’s motion for leave to file brief in excess of
page limitations
FCC’s motion for leave to file memorandum on
question of mootness, time having expired
Clerk’s order granting respondents’ motion to ac-
cept late memorandum on the question of moot-
ness
14
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 21
21
21
26
27
27
27
27
27
28
28
1980
Jan. 10
Mar. 14
Respondents’ memorandum on the question of
mootness
Clerk’s order denying petitioners’ motion for allot-
ment of 45 minutes to present argument and the
following times are allotted for oral argument:
petitioners—30 minutes and respondents—30
minutes. The motion for leave to permit three
counsel per side to argue is granted
Petitioner’s reply brief
Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) reply brief
Clerk’s order granting respondent’s motions to
accept late brief and in excess of limitations
Respondent’s brief
Respondent’s brief
Clerk’s order granting the motion of Stewart
Rawlings Mott, et al. for leave to participate as
_amicus curiae and to adopt brief and denying the
motion of Nat’l Citizens Comm. for Broadcasting,
et al. for leave to participate in oral argument
Amicus Curiae (Nat’l Citizens and Stewart
Rawlings, etc.) brief
Clerk’s order granting petitioner’s motion to file
appendix in lieu of joint appendix
Petitioner’s appendix
Argued before SCJ Bazelon, Tamm*, CJ and CJ
Markey, U.S. Court of Customs and Patent
Appeals
Opinion for the Court filed by Senior Circuit J udge
Bazelon
15
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1980
Mar.
Apr.
May
14
14
26
27
28
22
15
Concurring opinion filed by Circuit Judge Tamm
Judgment that the orders of the FCC under re-
view herein are hereby affirmed, in accordance
with the opinion of this Court filed herein this
date
Petitioners’ motion to extend time to file petitions
for rehearing and suggestion for rehearing en
banc to April 18, 1980
Intervenor’s (Carter/Mondale) conditional con-
sent to grant of petitioners’ motion to extend
time
Petitioners’ reply to intervenor’s conditional con-
sent
Per Curiam order granting petitioners’ motion to
extend time to file petition for rehearing to April
21, 1980; SCJ Bazelon, Tamm, CJ and CJ Markey,
U.S. Court of Customs and Patent Appeals
Intervenor’s (NAB) petition for rehearing
Petitioner’s petition for rehearing and suggestion
for rehearing en banc
Per Curiam order en banc denying petitioner’s
(CBS) motion for leave to exceed page limit and
the Clerk is directed to return the lodged petition
for rehearing and suggestion en banc to petitioner;
CJ Wright, Tamm, Robinson, MacKinnon (who
would grant leave to exceed page limits), Robb,
Wilkey, Wald, Mikva and Edwards, CJ’s
Per Curiam order denying the petitions of NAB,
ABC & NBC for rehearing; SCJ Bazelon, Tamm,
CJ and CJ Markey, U.S. Court of Customs and
Patent Appeals
16
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1980
May 15 Per Curiam order en banc denying the sugges-
tions of NAB, ABC & NBC for rehearing en banc;
CJ Wright, Tamm, Robinson, MacKinnon, Robb,
Wilkey, Wald, Mikva & Edwards, CJ’s
Aug. 18 Notice from Clerk, Supreme Court that a petition
for writ of certiorari was filed in SC No. 80-213 on
August 13, 1980
Nov. 5 Certified copy of order from Clerk, Supreme Court
granting the petition for writ of certiorari in SC
No. 80-213 on November 3, 1980; consolidating
with Nos. 80-207 and 80-214; and allotting one
hour for oral argument
III
DOCKET ENTRIES
in the
United States Court of Appeals (D.C. Cir.)
in
National Broadcasting Company, Inc. v. FCC
No. 79-2407
19
DOCKET ENTRIES
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Nov. 29 Petitioner’s petition for review of an order of the
FCC
29 Certified copy of petition for review was mailed
to the FCC & Attorney General
29 Petitioner’s motion for an expedited appeal, a
stay and expedited consideration
29 FCC’s opposition to motions for stay and ex-
pedited consideration
29 Motion of National Association of Broadcasters
for leave to intervene
29 Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting for leave to participate as amicus curiae
29 Per Curiam order that the motion for stay is
granted until further order of the Court and that
because of the obvious complexity of the issues
involved and the need of this Court to receive full
and complete briefing, the consideration of the
motion to expedite is deferred until the parties
agree upon a briefing schedule to be submitted to
the Court; Tamm, Robb & Wilkey (who did not
participate) CJs
80 Motion of Carter/Mondale Presidential Commit-
tee, Inc., for leave to intervene
Dec. 4 FCC’s motion to consolidate with Nos. 79-2408
and 79-2406
FCC’s motion to adopt expedited briefing schedule
Certified Index to Record
Clerk’s order, sua sponte, that Nos. 79-2408, 79-
2406 & 79-2407 are consolidated
_ PREVIOUS PAGE WAS BLANK |
20
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 65 Clerk’s order granting the motion of Carter/
Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc. for leave to
intervene
5 Intervenor’s (Carter/Mondale) opposition to mo-
tion for stay
Clerk’s order granting the motion of National
Association of Broadcasters for leave to intervene
and the motion of National Citizens Committee
for Broadcasting, et al. for leave to participate as
amicus curiae. The request to participate in oral
argument is denied without prejudice to resub-
mission at such time as counsel is notified of the
scheduling of argument.
Intervenor’s response to motion for stay and ex-
pedited consideration
Amicus Curiae opposition to motion for stay and
expedited consideration
Per Curiam order granting the motion to adopt
expedited briefing schedule as follows: petitioner’s
and supporting intervenors—Dec. 7th, respond-
ent’s and supporting intervenors—Dec. 18th, and
reply briefs—Dec. 21st. Petitioners and inter-
venors shall submit memoranda on or before Dec.
17th addressed to the question of mootness. Re-
spondents and intervenors shall submit separate
memoranda addressed to the same question along
with their briefs on Dec. 18th. All parties on the
same side are directed to file joint briefs wherever
possible. These cases will be heard at oral argu-
ment during the period January 1-30th, 1980;
Tamm, Robb, CJ’s and Wilkey, CJ (who did not
participate)
21
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 7 Petitioner’s motion for leave to file brief exceed-
ing page limitations
7 Intervenor’s (National Assoc. of Broadcasters)
brief
12 Clerk’s order granting petitioner’s motion to file
brief exceeding page limitations
12 Petitioner’s brief
13 Petitioner’s motion for allotment of time for oral
argument and for leave to permit three counsel
per side to argue
17 Petitioner’s memorandum concerning the question
of mootness
18 Motion of Stewart Rawlings Mott, et al. for leave
to participate as amicus curiae and to participate
in oral argument
18 Motion of National Citizens Committee for Broad-
casting, for leave to participate in oral argument
18 Memorandum of Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc. on question of mootness
18 Intervenor’s (Carter-Mondale Presidential Com-
mittee, Inc.) brief
18 Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) brief
19 FCC’s motion for leave to file typewritten briefs,
pending printing
19 FCC’s motion for leave to file brief in excess of
page limitation
19 FCC’s motion for leave to file memorandum on
question of mootness, time having expired
22
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1979
Dec. 21 Clerk’s order granting respondents’ motion to ac-
21
21
26
27
27
27
27
27
28
28
1980
Jan. 10
cept late memorandum on the question of mootness
Respondents’ memorandum on the question of
mootness
Clerk’s order denying petitioners’ motion for allot-
ment of 45 minutes to present oral argument and
the following times are allotted for oral argu-
ment: petitioners—30 minutes and respondents—
30 minutes. The motion for leave to permit three
counsel per side to argue is granted
Petitioner’s (NBC, Inc.) reply brief
Clerk’s order granting respondent’s motion to file
late brief and in excess page limitations
Respondent’s brief
Respondent’s brief
Clerk’s order granting the motion of Stewart
Rawlings Mott, et al. for leave to participate as
amicus curiae and to adopt brief and denying
the motion of Nat’l Citizens Comm. for Broad-
casting, et al. for leave to participate in oral
argument
Amicus Curiae (Nat’] Citizens and Stewart Rawl-
ings, etc.) brief
Clerk’s order granting petitioner’s motion to file
appendix in lieu of joint appendix
Petitioner’s appendix
Argued before SCJ Bazelon, Tamm*, CJ and CJ
Markey, U.S. Court of Customs and Patent
Appeals
23
DATE
FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1980
Mar.
Apr.
May
14
14
14
26
27
28
22
22
22
15
15
Opinion for the Court filed by Senior Circuit
Judge Bazelon
Concurring opinion filed by Circuit Judge Tamm
Judgment that the orders of the FCC under re-
view herein are hereby affirmed, in accordance
with the opinion for the Court filed herein
Petitioners’ motion to extend time to file petitions
for rehearing and suggestions for rehearing en
banc to April 18, 1980
Intervenor’s (Carter/Mondale) conditional con-
sent to grant of petitioners’ motion to extend time
Petitioners’ reply to intervenor’s conditional
consent
Per Curiam order granting petitioner’s motion to
extend time to file petition for rehearing to April
21, 1980; SCJ Bazelon, Tamm, CJ and CJ Markey,
U.S. Court of Customs and Patent Appeals
Intervenor’s (NAB) petition for rehearing
Petitioner’s petition for rehearing and suggestion
for rehearing en banc
Per Curiam order en banc denying petitioner’s
(CBS) motion for leave to exceed page limit and
directing Clerk to return the lodged petition for
rehearing and suggestion en banc to counsel for
petitioner; CJ Wright, Tamm, Robinson, Mac-
Kinnon (who would grant leave to exceed page
limits), Robb, Wilkey, Wald, Mikva & Edwards,
CJ’s
Per Curiam order denying the petitions of NAB,
ABC, & NBC for rehearing; SCJ Bazelon, Tamm,
CJ and Markey, Chief Judge, U.S. Court of Cus-
toms and Patent Appeals
24
DATE FILINGS—PROCEEDINGS
1980
May 15 Per Curiam order denying the suggestions for
rehearing en banc of NAB, ABC & NBC; CJ
Wright, Tamm, Robinson, MacKinnon, Robb,
Wilkey, Wald, Mikva and Edwards, CJ’s
Notice from Clerk, Supreme Court that a petition
for writ of certiorari was filed in SC No. 80-214
on August 13, 1980
Certified copy of order from Clerk, Supreme Court
granting the petition for writ of certiorari in
SC No. 80-214 on November 3, 1980; consolidating
with SC Nos. 80-207 and 80-213; and allotting one
hour for oral argument
IV
RELEVANT PLEADINGS BEFORE AND ORDER OF
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
in
Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc.
27
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554
In re:
ABC Television Network
CBS Television Network
NBC Television Network
To: The Commission
COMPLAINT
The Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc. (here-
inafter the “Committee”), herewith files a political broad-
casting complaint against the three television networks,
ABC, CBS, and NBC, for their refusal to sell one half-
hour time period to be used by the President in his
capacity as a candidate for renomination by the Demo-
cratic Party for the office of President of the United
States. This refusal effectively denies the candidate and
his campaign committee reasonable access to the citizenry
of this country via our only national commercial televi-
sion network system. Furthermore, it has been reported
that two candidates for the other party’s nomination are
also being foreclosed from utilizing the system by what is
rapidly becoming a common pattern of abuse of power.
This conduct of selling exclusively to commercial adver-
tisers denies these important candidates the access to
the airways mandated by Congress in section 312(a) (7)
of the Communications Act of 1934 as amended. More
importantly, it denies the public the opportunity of hear-
ing and seeing the candidates in the manner which they
have chosen to appear. In support, the Committee shows
as follows:
_ PREVIOUS PAGE WAS BLANK
28
FACTS
The Commission knows that these three television net-
works virtually control all of prime time on more than
600 stations covering nearly all television homes in the
Nation. The prime time programming of all three net-
works is almost exclusively devoted to entertainment
programming for commercial purposes. Each network
on week nights (and Saturdays) schedules six half-hour
prime time periods and eight on Sundays for a three
network total of 132 per week or 528 per month. Sales
to commercial advertisers by the networks for these
commercial time periods is a multi-billion dollar business.
The Committee requested each of the networks to pro-
vide time availabilities for the purchase of a thirty-
minute prime time period between 8:00 PM and
10:30 PM EST on either December 4, 5, 6 or 7, 1979.
(Attached as Exhibit A are the letter requests.) The
intention of the Committee was to select one of the net-
works after reviewing the availabilities. In each in-
stance, the request was denied. (Attached as Exhibit B
are the letters of denial.)
As Mr. Rafshoon indicated in his letters, the Commit-
tee is seeking to use the half-hour program for an
appearance by the President shortly after he formally
declares his candidacy for the Democratic Party nomina-
tion for President of the United States. The proposed
program would stress the President’s record and that of
his administration. It is intended to set forth the basic
ease for renomination, and thus it was desirable to air
the program shortly after the announcement. It is
planned to have the television appearance coincide with
more than 2,000 small-donor, grass roots fundraising
gatherings in communities throughout the country... A
substantial amount of careful advance planning and prep-
aration is essential to this project, thus making an im-
mediate decision in this matter imperative.
29
The request of the Committee was made nearly two
months in advance of the air date in order to ease the
scheduling burden on the networks and to give sufficient
time for appropriate announcements in such publications
as TV Guide. Also, the time requested was selected so
as not to interfere with the national ratings sweep pe-
riod which is so important to network sales.
The President Is Now Or Soon Will Be
A Legally Qualified Candidate Under the FCC’s Rules
Since none of the three networks are contending or
basing their refusal on a claim that President Carter is
not a “legally qualified candidate’ at this particular
time—it is not an issue here. Nevertheless, the Commis-
sion should be aware that the Committee can establish
that President Carter satisfies the requirements of the
Commission’s rules as set forth in section 73.1940, and
once the formal public announcement has been made—
which will be prior to the requested air time—there
should be no question whatsoever in this regard.
The Reasons Given by the Networks
for Their Refusal to Sell Are Totally
Insufficient to Justify Their Actions
The reasons advanced by the networks so far are
patently insufficient to justify their actions and dem-
onstrate that they are being unreasonable.
1) It is “too early” to begin a presidential campaign
(NBC-ABC). This is a matter which should be
viewed in light of the needs of the candidate and
not the belief of the network. Actions speak louder
than words. All three networks have been devoting
significant amounts of news coverage to the cam-
paigns. The NBC evening news in recent weeks
has been covering the campaign with a nightly
segment showing a background logo entitled “Cam-
3)
30
paign 80”. Apparently, the sales department of
this network does not agree with the news depart-
ment. ABC goes so far as to indicate they will not
sell political time until next year.
If we sell to you, we would have to honor requests
from other candidates (NBC-CBS). Of course
this is true, but there is a relatively limited num-
ber of national candidates in either party that are
willing and able to purchase network prime time
half-hours. At most, there will be three in the
Democratic Party and probably no more than that
in the Republican Party.* At preesnt, we are aware
of a total of only three in both parties who made
requests—a very limited number when compared
to the 528 prime time half-hour periods being sold
to commercial advertisers during the month of
December.
It would involve “massive disruptions” of the reg-
ular entertainment and informational schedules of
CBS Television Network. This is a preposterous
overstatement in light of the practical circumstances
outlined above. Certainly during the month in
question there may be a few half-hour periods of
entertainment programming and a few commercial
announcements that will be rescheduled. This is not
a novel or unusual happening for any of the net-
works. From time to time they each preempt their
own programs for others, cancel shows, and insert
new programs. As far as the reference to “in-
formational” programming is concerned, the only
public affairs or informational program in the reg-
ular CBS prime time schedule is “60 Minutes” and
there would appear to be no need to disrupt it.
* Furthermore, under section 315 of the Communications Act,
only Democratic Party candidates can request “equal opportunities”
if this request is granted.
31
4) We will not sell you a half-hour but will sell a five-
minute period at 10:55 PM on Saturday night
December 8th and another in the day part. CBS
is willing to provide some time. Apparently the
only disagreement is over the amount and the day
of airing. It is past the four day time period
requested, insufficient in amount and unsuitable to
the needs of the candidate. The five minutes before
11 PM on Saturday is one of the least desirable
periods in the network prime time schedule. It is
generally regarded as the lowest rated portion of
the weekly prime time schedule. More importantly,
it is totally insufficient in‘amount to be of use to the
candidate under the circumstances. Jt is obviously
being tendered because it would enable the network
to run its full schedule of commercials for the en-
tire half-hour in 25 minutes and then sell the
additional five minutes to the candidate for a
“windfall” of additional revenue.
It is indeed ironic that all prime time periods on all
three networks are being devoted exclusively to the car-
riage of commercial messages from national advertis-
ers—none of whom are entitled to the right of “reason-
able access” which Congress accorded Federal candidates
in the 1971 amendments to the Communications Act.*
What the networks have not disclosed is that they
have presold virtually all their prime time commercial
positions to national advertisers between now and the
end of the year. They just don’t wish to disturb any
of these sales—even though they have complete flexibility
to do so under their contracts with the advertiser. We
submit that this is not a sufficient reason to refuse sales
of time to Presidential candidates.
* The Campaign Communications Reform Act of 1971 added a
new subsection (7) to section 312(a) of the Communications Act
creating these rights and obligations.
32
Further evidence of the attitude of networks toward
the important responsibilities entrusted to them by the
Communications Act and the actions of this Commission
is found in recent news interviews with network officials
and other commentary which is attached hereto as Ex-
hibit C.
The Networks Have Refused
To Provide Reasonable Access
Section 312 provides that:
(a) The Commission may revoke any station license
or construction permit—
* - * *
(7) for willful or repeated failure to allow reason-
able access to or to permit purchase of reasonable
amounts of time for the use of a broadcast station
by a legally qualified candidate for Federal elective
office on behalf of his candidacy.
The Commission has long recognized that the three com-
mercial television network corporations, as licensees of
the most important broadcast stations in the nation are
subject to their jurisdiction. Particularly, in connection
with political broadcasting matters, the FCC has said
that rate restrictions, and other provisions, are applicable
to networks as well as to individual stations, “since net-
works are, in effect, selling time on behalf of their affili-
ated stations.” The Law of Political Broadcasting and
Cablecasting, 43 Fed. Reg. 36342, at 36377 (1978). Thus,
there is no question that the FCC has jurisdiction to
resolve this matter.
In its Report and Order in Docket Number 78-102*
the FCC set forth general principles in determining
whether a judgment about a request for political broad-
* Commission Policy in Enforcing Section 312(a)(7) of the Com-
munications Act, 48 RR2d 1029 (1978).
33
cast time is reasonable. The Commission made it clear
that a candidate’s request for a prime program is
reasonable.
It should be noted that the Committee requested avail-
abilities in order to purchase—not obtain free of charge—
a single half hour on one of the three networks. It is
not asking for the time now, but for a period in early
December. It does not intend to make such purchases a
regular practice. It has not made any additional re-
quests for subsequent time, and, in part because of the
expense of such time, it is unlikely that any such re-
quests shall be made in the near future. The Committee
determined that the most effective way to present the
candidate and his record, at the beginning of the cam-
paign, was to broadcast this half-hour program showing
President Carter performing the duties of his office
as President of the United States. All three networks
disagree and have refused to sell the time, leaving the
committee with no alternative but to seek relief from
this Commission. The Committee suggests that this is
a blatant denial of reasonable access as required by Sec-
tion 312(a)(7) of the Communications Act and the
FCC’s interpretations of this provision.
WHEREFORE, the Committee requests the Commis-
sion to determine that the three networks have denied the
Committee reasonable access and to direct the networks
to make time available for purchase. Because of the
need for advance planning in order to effectively use the
time and minimize the impact on the networks, the Com-
34
mittee requests the Commission to consider this complaint
on an expedited basis.
Respectfully submitted,
/8/ Timothy G. Smith
TIMOTHY G. SMITH
General Counsel
Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc.
1413 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005
Of Counsel: fmm
John D. Lane
1211 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
Harold K. McCombs
1822 Jefferson Place, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
October 29, 1979
[Certificate of Service omitted in printing]
35
EXHIBIT A
RAFSHOON
COMMUNICATIONS
[SEAL]
1775 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
202/293-5454
October 11, 1979
Mr. Elton Rule
President
ABC
1330 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019
Dear Mr. Rule:
On behalf of the Carter/Mondale Presidential Committee,
Inc., I am requesting availabilities for a thirty (30)
minute program on ABC between 8:00 p.m. and 10:30
p.m. E.S.T. on December 4, December 5, December 6,
or December 7, 1979. This program, to be run in con-
junction with an announcement concerning his candidacy
by President Carter for the Democratic nomination for
President, consists of a documentary outlining the Pres-
ident’s record and that of his administration. At the
time this program is aired, it may be assumed that
President Carter will be a legally qualified candidate
under the Communications Act of 1934, as amended,
and that the President would appear on the program.
As you know, the first official contest to select delegates
to the Democratic National Convention occurs Janu-
36
ary 21, 1980, in Iowa, which is 47 days after Decem-
ber 7, 1979, our last requested date for availabilities.
Unlike all previous Presidential election years, the news
media has chosen to focus enormous attention on the
Florida Caucus (October 13, 1979) and Convention (No-
vember 16-18, 1979) as well as other aspects of the
1980 campaign. As illustration, I have noted that in
the six-week period from September 1 through October 9,
1979, ABC devoted 51 minutes, 22 seconds to the 1980
campaign; CBS devoted 51 minutes, 17 seconds to this
subject; and NBC devoted 70 minutes. Therefore, our
request for the above time seems eminently appropriate
in view of the escalating political climate already gen-
erated by both print and broadcast media.
I will expect to hear from one of your sales representa-
tives within the next week regarding a selection of times
in order that we may choose a mutually agreeable daie.
Sincerely,
GERALD M. RAFSHOON
President
ec: Mr. Evan Dobelle
Mr. Timothy Kraft
Mr. Timothy Smith
37
RAFSHOON
COMMUNICATIONS
[SEAL]
i775 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
202/293-5454
October 11, 1979
Mr. Fred Silverman
President
NBC, Ince.
30 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, NY 10020
Dear Mr. Silverman:
On behalf of the Carter/Mondale Presidential Commit-
tee, Inc., I am requesting availabilities for a thirty (30)
minute program on NBC between 8:00 p.m. and
10:30 p.m. E.S.T. on December 4, December 5, Decem-
ber 6, or December 7, 1979. This program, to be run
in conjunction with an announcement concerning his
candidacy by President Carter for a Democratic nomi-
nation for President, consists of a documentary outlin-
ing the President’s record and that of his administration.
At the time this program is aired, it may be assumed
that President Carter will be a legally qualified candi-
date under the Communications Act of 1934, as amended,
and that the President would appear on the program.
As you know, the first official contest to select delegates
to the Democratic National Convention occurs Januv-
ary 21, 1980, in Iowa, which is 47 days after Decem-
ber 7, 1979, our last requested date for availabilities.
38
Unlike all previous Presidenial election years, the news
media has chosen to focus enormous attention on the
lorida Caucus (October 18, 1979) and Convention (No-
vember 16-18, 1979) as well as other aspects of the
1880 campaign. As illustration, I have noted that in
the six-week period from September 1 through October 9,
1979, ABC devoted 51 minutes, 22 seconds to the 1980
campaign; CBS devoted 51 minutes, 17 seconds to this
subject; and NBC devoted 70 minutes. Therefore, our
request for the above time seems eminently appropriate
in view of the escalating political climate already gen-
erated by both print and broadcast media.
I will expect to hear from one of your sales representa-
tives within the next week regarding a selection of
times in order that we may choose a mutually agree-
able date.
Sincerely,
GERALD M. RAFSHOON
President
ec: Mr. Evan Dobelle
Mr. Timothy Kraft
Mr. Timothy Smith
39
RAFSHOON
COMMUNICATIONS
[SEAL]
1775 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
202/293-5454
October 11, 1979
Mr. John D. Backe
President
CBS, Ince.
51 West 52nd Street
New York, NY 10019
Dear Mr. Backe:
On behalf of the Carter/Mondale Presidential Commit-
tee, Inc., I am requesting availabilities for a thirty (30)
minute program on CBS between 8:00 p.m. and
10:30 p.m. E.S.T. on December 4, December 5, Decem-
ber 6, or December 7, 1979. This program, to be run
in conjunction with an announcement concerning his
candidacy by President Carter for a Democratic nomi-
nation for President, consists of a documentary outlining
the President’s record and that of his administration.
At the time this program is aired, it may be assumed
that President Carter will be a legally qualified can-
didate under the Communications Act of 1934, as
amended, and that the President would appear on the
program.
As you know, the first official contest to select delegates
to the Democratic National Convention occurs Janu-
ary 21, 1980, in Iowa, which is 47 days after Decem-
ber 7, 1979, our last requested date for availabilities.
40
Unlike all previous Presidential election years, the news
media has chosen to focus enormous attention on the
Florida Caucus (October 13, 1979) and Convention (No-
vember 16-18, 1979) as well as other aspects of the
1980 campaign. As illustration, I have noted that in
in the six-week period from September 1 through Oc-
tober 9, 1979, ABC devoted 51 minutes, 22 seconds to
the 1980 campaign; CBS devoted 51 minutes, 17 seconds
to this subject; and NBC devoted 70 minutes. Therefore,
our request for the above time seems eminently appro-
priate in view of the escalating political climate already
generated by both print and broadcast media.
I will expect to hear from one of your sales representa-
tives within the next week regarding a selection of times
in order that we may choose a mutually agreeable date.
Sincerely,
GERALD M. RAFSHOON
President
ee: Mr. Evan Dobelle
Mr. Timothy Kraft
Mr. Timothy Smith
41
EXHIBIT B
ABC TELEVISION NETWORK
1330 Avenue of the Americas
New York, New York 10019
Telephone 212 887-7142
Charles C. Allen
Vice President Sales Administration
October 23, 1979
Mr. Gerald M. Rafshoon
President
Rafshoon Communications
1775 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
Dear Mr. Rafshoon:
This is to confirm my oral response given on Octo-
ber 16th to your letter of October 11, 1979 to Mr. Elton
H. Rule, President of American Broadcasting Companies,
Inc., requesting air time for the Carter/Mondale Presi-
dential Committee, Inc. on December 4, 5, 6 or 7, 1979.
As we discussed, the ABC Television Network has not
reached a decision as to when it will start selling politi-
cal time for the 1980 Presidential campaign, and, ac-
cordingly, we are not in a position to comply with your
request. As I mentioned on the telephone, I believe that
later this year a decision will be made to make political
time for the Presidential campaign available on ABC-TV
early next year.
It was a pleasure speaking with you last week.
Sincerely yours,
/s/ Charles C. Allen
CCA/lh CHARLES C, ALLEN
ec: Elton Rule
42
NBC TELEVISION
Network
A Division of
National Broadcasting Company Inc
Thirty Rockefeller Plaza
New York, N.Y. 10020 212-664-3286
Joseph J. Iaricci
Vice President,
Sales and Administration
October 23, 1979
Mr. Gerald M. Rafshoon
President, Rafshoon Communications
1775 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
Dear Mr. Rafshoon:
This is in response to your letter of October 11, 1979
to Mr. Fred Silverman, on behalf of the Carter /Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc., requesting 30-minute avail-
abilities on NBC between 8:00 and 10:30 PM, EST, on
December 4, 5, 6 or 7, 1979.
We have evaluated your request carefully. Based upon
our experience with past campaigns, we believe it is too
early in the political season for nationwide broadcast
time to be made available for paid political purposes.
In addition, we believe that honoring your request at
this early stage of the Presidential campaign would re-
quire NBC to honor similar requests from a number
of other Presidential aspirants. The impact of such
an undertaking at this time is, of course, a significant
factor in our decision.
43
Insofar as the nomination process is now focused on
political activities in individual states like Iowa, you may
wish to contact stations serving those particular states.
Please be assured that NBC News will continue to cover
important and newsworthy aspects of President Carter’s
political activities.
Very truly yours,
/s/ JI
CBS
TELEVISION
NETWORK
A Division of CBS Inc.
51 West 52 Street
New York, New York 10019
(212) 975-4321
i October 17, 1979
Dear Mr. Rafshoon:
This is in response to your request that the CBS Televi-
sion Network make available for purchase by the Carter/
Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc., a half-hour pro-
gram in prime time to be broadcast between 8:00 and
10:30 PM EST on December 4, 5, 6 or 7, 1979.
Because of the large number of present and potential can-
didates for the Republican and Democratic presidential
nominations, we are at this time unable to accede to
your request to purchase a half-hour program. We note
that three Democrats and eleven Republicans have al-
ready announced, or may reasonably be expected shortly
to announce, their presidential candidacies; indeed two
candidates for the Republican presidential nomination
have already requested to purchase half-hour programs
on the CBS Television Network, and their requests have
been declined on the same basis as indicated below.
In light of the above circumstances, were we to provide
the half-hour program you seek, accommodating poten-
tial requests for equal treatment from other candidates
for presidential nomination would involve massive dis-
ruptions of the regular entertainment and information
schedule of the CBS Television Network. Accordingly,
we must respectfully reject your request.
We are, however, prepared to make one 5-minute seg-
ment in prime time and one 5-minute daytime segment
available for purchase by your committee. We note that
45
this is the same offer made to the Republican candidates
referred to above in response to their requests to pur-
chase half-hour time periods.
While we are unable to make available time on the dates
you have specified, we are able to offer for your purchase
a 5-minute period on December 8 between approximately
10:55 and 11:00 PM. We will also provide a specific
5-minute daytime availability for your purchase on
request.
Since it is CBS’ policy to sell time only to announced
candidates for public office, this offer is, of course, con-
ditional upon President Carter’s having announced, or
using the time purchased to announce, his presidential
candidacy.
If you are interested in purchasing such a program or
programs, please notify us promptly since substantial
lead time of approximately four to five weeks is neces-
sary for the editing required to accommodate program
segments of this length.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Raymond E. Dillon
RAYMOND E. DILLON
Director of Political Sales
Mr. Gerald M. Rafshoon, President
Rafshoon Communications
1775 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.
Suite 1250
Washington, D.C. 20006
eg
46
EXHIBIT C
NETWORKS OPPOSING
POLITICAL ADS NOW
Despite Appeals for Time, Stations
Don’t Believe That Campaign
Season Has Arrived Yet
By Les BROWN
Although the political season has begun considerably
earlier than usual, high-ranking officials of the televi-
sion networks have indicated that they would prefer to
wait until after the first of the year to sell air time to
candidates requesting it.
Two contenders for the Republican Presidential nomi-
nation, Ronald Reagan and John B. Connally, have al-
ready made formal requests to the networks for com-
mercial time to promote their candidacies. And Gerald
M. Rafshoon, who is handling advertising for President
Carter’s campaign, said on Friday that he would soon
advise the networks of his wish to buy 30 minutes of
air time on Dec. 4, 5 or 6 for Mr. Carter’s announcement
of his candidacy for a second term.
While ABC, CBS and NBC have not yet denied either
of the Republican requests and are still only anticipating
President Carter’s as yet unsubmitted application, their
inclination now is to turn them all down on the ground
that they have not had time to prepare their schedules
for an accumulation of political disruptions.
“There is no date for a political season that any one
fixes,” Howard Monderer, NBC’s vice president for legal
47
affairs in Washington, said in a telephone interview.
“But we know the political season when we see it.
We don’t think it is here yet. The decision is a manage-
ment decision, but it is based to a large extent on our
sense of whether the public is ready for political cam-
paigning.”
Probable Denial in Fall
He said that NBC would probably deny the Reagan
and Connally requests, “at least in the time frame they’re
speaking of—October and November.” He said the net-
work had not yet heard from Mr. Carter.
Specialists in the rules for political broadcasting say
that the networks are under no legal obligation to clear
time for candidates’ requests at this time, although
Section 312 of the Communications Act requires that
television and radio stations allow legally qualified can-
didates for national office to purchase “a reasonable
amount of time” in behalf of their candidacies.
The catch is in the definition of a legally qualified
candidate. Under Federal Communications Commission
rules, a legally qualified national candidate is one who
is on the ballot in 10 states. Since it is doubtful that
any of the candidates currently requesting time have met
that criterion—including President Carter, who will not
be an announced candidate before his proposed broadcast
—the networks are free to exercise their discretion in ac-
cepting political advertising now.
Political advertising on network television has usually
begun in late March or April, a time when the networks
are winding down their own competitive campaigns and
have begun their cycle of reruns. In the spring and sum-
mer months, network programs can be preempted for
political advertising without serious consequences.
48
Battle of Ratings Now
At the moment, however, the three networks are en-
gaged in a fierce battle for popularity ratings and in the
delicate autumnal process of inculcating regular viewing
habits in the audience. In addition, they are faced with
the obligation to their affiliated stations to mount their
strongest programming in November for the periodic
“sweep” ratings. These are the audience ratings for
individual stations around the country on which they
base their future advertising rates.
Under the equal time rule of the Federal Communi-
cations Act, the networks are obliged to provide equiv-
alent time to all legally qualified candidates requesting
it if they agree to sell time to any single candidate.
Thus, the sale of a half-hour to President Carter could
result in as many as a half-dozen pre-emptions to other
Democratic candidates. This could wreck the chances for
success for certain programs or the overall programming
strategy of the network.
“Nothing is absolutely firm,” Eugene Mater, a vice
president of the CBS Broadcasting Group, stated. “We
don’t like to sell time this far ahead, but we're still ex-
ploring the question. The answer may depend on what
the candidate is asking for. A one-minute spot or a five-
minute broadcast might be accommodated; a 30-minute
program presents bigger problems.”
Ellis O. Moore, vice president of public relations for
ABC Television, remarked: “The issues of political ad-
vertising are always complicated. At present, we don’t
plan to sell until after the first of the year, but I would
hesitate to say that we have baked this policy in con-
crete. This is going to be an unusual year. It’s hard
to know what other factors may come into play.”
49
RICHARD REEVES
WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE?
Certain constitutional provisions concerning free speech
were suspended recently by Howard Monderer. He an-
nounced in New York that the United States is not
ready for debate about its political future.
“There is no date for a political season that anyone
fixes,’ Monderer said. “But we know the political sea-
son when we see it. We don’t think it is here yet. The
decision is a management decision, but it is based to
a large extent on our own sense of whether the public
is ready for political campaining.”
Monderer’s statement was backed by two of his asso-
ciates, Eugene Mater and Ellis Moore. The triumvirate
said they were considering allowing candidates for presi-
dent to speak to the nation after Jan. 1, 1980.
Who the hell are these people? Monderer is vice presi-
dent for legal affairs of the National Broadcasting Com-
pany. Mater is vice president of the Broadcast Group of
the Columbia Broadcasting System. Moore is vice presi-
dent for public affairs of the American Broadcasting
Company.
It sounds like 1984. Candidates for president want to
announce those candidacies to the nation where the na-
tion will see them, on network television. The networks,
so far, have decreed that such announcements would be
inconvenient and unprofitable for them at this time.
The candidates be damned. The public be damned!
Later, when it suits their purposes, the triumvirate
will restore the right of public debate. Then it will be
very profitable indeed.
50
The new television season—with its rating battles to
determine next year’s commercial rates—will have been
well launched by then and the public will be allowed to
hear Jimmy Carter, Teddy Kennedy, Ronald Reagan,
John Connally and the rest. Those candidates will be
allowed the privilege of paying for network time—with
contributor and taxpayer money.
Catch 22. The public owns the airwaves on which
the networks and local television operate at truly obscene
profits. Candidates for office may pay, at premium rates,
for advertising time with money raised from the public
or supplied by the U.S. Treasury through matching
funds provided by campaign reform laws.
But network “management” has the power over when
and how the money is used. The customer is not always
right.
Monuerer and friends made their arrogance about all
this public a week ago because Les Brown of The New
York Times asked them why the networks have refused
requests by Carter, Reagan and Connally to buy time
for announcements this November and December.
Brown then gave the real explanation:
“The three networks are engaged in a fierce battle for
popularity ratings and in the delicate autumnal process
of inculcating regular viewing habits in the audience. . .
In the spring and summer months (when the networks
have begun showing reruns) network programs can be
pre-empted for political advertising without serious con-
sequences,”
What about the serious consequences for democracy?
Should network management have the power to decide
when political debate can begin? Should the networks
and television stations around the country be cashing in
on the debate?
51
The explosion in the cost of campaigning in recent
years, after all, is because of television advertising rates.
That’s where the millions of dollars in politics go—and
where public corruption comes in—the money is needed
to pay for television commercials.
If politics is really the public’s business, then time for
political messages should be provided free. Most of the
money could be taken out of campaigning and, maybe,
networks and station profits could be reduced to the point
that they might be only about twice as big as the profits
of oil companies,
52
[LETTER FROM
AMERICAN BROADCASTING COMPANIES, INC,]
LAW OFFICES
MCKENNA, WILKINSON & KITTNER
1150 Seventeenth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
(202) 296-1600
James A. McKenna, Jr.
Vernon L, Wilkinson
Joseph M. Kittner
Robert W. Coll
Thomas N. Frohock
Carl R. Ramey
Edward P. Taptich
Norman P., Leventhal
Steven A. Lerman
R. Michael Senkowski
Virginia S. Carson
Lawrence J. Movshin
James S. Blaszak
W. Kennedy Keane
Kent Y. Nakamura
November 5, 1979
Arthur L. Ginsburg, Chief
Complaints and Compliance Division
Broadcast Bureau
Federal Communications Commission
Washington, D.C. 20554
Re: Political Broadcasting Complaint
of the Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc.
Dear Mr. Ginsburg:
American Broadcasting Companies, Inc., by its attor-
neys, hereby responds to the political broadcasting com-
plaint of the Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee,
Inc. (hereinafter “Committee”) filed with the Commis-
sion on October 29, 1979. The Committee seeks a Com-
mission ruling that it was unreasonable for the ABC
53
Television Network (and the television networks of
CBS and NBC) to refuse to make time available for a
30-minute program, between 8:00 p.m. and 10:30 p.m.,
on either December 4, 5, 6 or 7, 1979, to be used by
President Carter “in his capacity as a candidate for re-
nomination by the Democratic Party for the office of
President of the United States.” Complaint, p. 1. The
Committee asks the Commission to “direct the networks
to make time available for purchase” on those dates.
Complaint, p. 9.
The Committee’s request is based on the “reasonable
access” provision of the Communiestions Act (Section
312(a)(7)). In pertinent part, that provision states that
the Commission “may revoke any station license” for
“willful or repeated failure to aliow reasonable access
to or to permit purchase of reasonable amounts of time
for the use of a broadcast station by a legally qualified
candidate for Federal elective office on behalf of his
candidacy.” 47 U.S.C. 312(a) (7). The question the Com-
mittee’s complaint poses, however, is not whether any
particular federal candidate is entitled to access, or
whether any particular form of access is reasonable;
rather, the question relates exclusively to when access
should be granted.*
ABC has not taken the position that it will not make
time available. ABC has simply declined to sell pro-
gram time on the specific December, 1979, dates re-
quested by the Committee. ABC respectfully submits
that its determination was reasonable and consistent
with the public interest.
The Commission has recently addressed the precise
question presented by this complaint. In The Matter Of
* The Commission may feel that not even this question is properly
before it inasmuch as the request for time comes on behalf of a
person who is not yet a legally qualified candidate. See Complaint,
pp. 3-4,
54
Commission Policy In Enforcing Section 312(a) (7) of
the Communications Act, Report and Order released
July 31, 1978, 68 FCC 2d 1079, 48 RR 2d 1029 (1978).
There, in attempting to provide interpretive guidance
as to the “particular point during a campaign [when]
a licensee’s obligation to afford reasonable access be-
gins,” the Commission held that, generally, “a licensee
would be unreasonable if it refused to afford access to
federal candidates at least during those [statutory] time
periods” when the “lowest unit charge” provision of
Section 315 is applicable—i.e., 45 days prior to a primary
election and 60 days prior to a general election. As to
whether “reasonable access” must be afforded before those
periods, the Commission declared that this was a deter-
mination which “must be made in each case under all the
facts and circumstances present.” 68 FCC 2d at 1091,
43 RR 2d at 1045.
Commenting more directly on the situation presented
here, the Commission observed that it had “received no
Congressional guidance as to when Section 312(a) (7)
should be effective prior to a convention or caucus since
the ‘lowest unit charge’ provision applies only before
election.” 68 FCC 2d at 1092, 43 RR 2d at 1045. Ac-
cordingly, and recognizing the “large variation in pro-
cedures utilized for obtaining nomination through such
methods,” the Commission declined to suggest any time
limits on access in such situations. It simply concluded
that licensees would be expected “to afford access at a
reasonable time prior to a convention or caucus.” Id.
(emphasis added).
The 1980 Democratic National Convention is sched-
uled for August 11-14, more than eight months after the
broadcast dates requested by the Committee. The 1980
Republican National Convention is scheduled for July
14-16.
55
It is also significant that the first state primary where
the general public will be given an opportunity to vote
for Presidential candidates occurs in New Hampshire
on February 26, 1980. Presidential primaries are sched-
uled the following month in Massachusetts, Vermont,
South Carolina (Republican Party only), Alabama, Flor-
ida, Georgia, Puerto Rico (Democratic Party only), Il-
linois and Connecticut. From April 1 to June 8, 1980,
25 states and the District of Columbia hold Presidential
primaries. At least six primaries will be held in 1980
that were not conducted in 1976. In all, thirty-six Presi-
dential primaries have been scheduled for 1980—34 state
primaries plus the District of Cclumbia and Puerto Rico.
See Congressional Quarterly, October 20, 1979, p. 2336.
Moreover, it should be recognized that the ABC Televi-
sion Network, unlike any individual television station,
is a national medium. The suggestion that a single state
caucus (Complaint, Ex. A) is sufficient to trigger access
to a national medium, as distinguished from individual
stations in and serving that state, is misguided.
Against this background, ABC made the judgment—
as it is required to do under applicable law and Com-
mission interpretation thereof—that it would not begin
to sell political time on the ABC Television Network to
candidates seeking nomination at the 1980 national politi-
cal conventions until sometime in calendar 1980. In our
view, the nature and length of the Presidential cam-
paign and the multiplicity of candidates participating
in that campaign fully warrant this decision.
The Committee seems to suggest that the period for
“reasonable access” should begin when any federal can-
didate merely requests broadcast time. The Committee’s
view is contrary to Commission interpretation reached in
its 1978 Report and Order, conflicts with the traditional
principle of committing such matters to good faith li-
56
censee discretion, and would lead to unreasonable pr: c-
tical results.
As noted, the national nominating conventions are not
scheduled until late next summer, and the first Presiden-
tial primary is still nearly four months away. Following
the first primary in New Hampshire, primaries are con-
ducted in 33 states and the District of Columbia over
a three month period. This nominating process is not
only long and involved, it is immediately followed by
an extended national election period. Throughout these
many months it can be anticipated that numerous re-
quests will be made to purchase significant amounts of
advertising and program time on both network affiliated
stations (located in those states where Presidential pri-
maries are being conducted) and on the national networks
supplying programming to such stations.
The decision as to when to begin to sell time is also
complicated by the number of candidates potentially en-
titled to such time. Although the Committee has sought
to minimize this factor, it cannot be so easily minimized.
Once time is sold to one candidate—either program or
advertising time—‘“equal opportunities” must be afforded
to all other bona fide candidates.* Depending upon when
this process begins and the number of eligible candidates,
the potential disruption to normal program schedules
and the resulting impact on the national television au-
dience may be considerable.
The Committee attempts to allay these concerns by
suggesting that “there is a relatively limited number of
national candidates in either party that are willing and
* While the Committee is technically correct when it states that
granting its request would only result in other Democratic party
candidates being immediately entitled to “equal opportunities,”
ABC does not believe that, in the present circumstances, it can
reasonably decide to grant access to the Democratic Party without
deciding to afford access to the Republican Party.
57
aple to purchase network prime time half-hours.” Com-
plaint, pp. 4-5. First, there is no basis for, and neither
the Commission nor the networks can rely on, this kind
of supposition. ABC certainly is not in a position to
judge how many of the potentially eligible candidates
would be interested in or have the ability to purchase a
half-hour of network program time. Second, contrary to
the Committee’s conclusion concerning the limited num-
ber of candidates, ABC is presently aware of at least
nine candidates who have already declared for the Re-
publican Party nomination. In addition, one major Re-
publican leader and two major Democratic leaders (in
addition to President Carter) have indicated that they
will formally announce their candidacies in the next few
days or weeks. Moreover, once the process has com-
menced, there is no way of judging whether these or
additional candidates will request multiple broadcast
appearances. In short, it is apparent that the poten-
tial for significant disruptions in normal schedules well
in advance of the first Presidential balloting is real, not
theoretical, substantial, not slight.
Finally, the Committee contends that because ABC
has devoted news coverage to the candidates and early
campaign activities, it is foreclosed from determining
that the sale of political time should not commence until
sometime after the first week of December. News cov-
erage and paid political time cannot be equated. In fact,
the news coverage ABC has devoted, and will continue
to devote, to candidates and the campaign, underscores
rather than undermines the reasonableness of its de-
termination not to commence the sale of political time
this year. ABC’s continuing news coverage ensures that
the mixture of issues, developments ( including candi-
date announcements) and personalities that dominate
this early stage of the campaign are brought to the
public’s attention.
58
The “reasonable access” provision of Section 312(a)
(7) embodies a concept significantly different from the
on-going news and public affairs coverage of an election
campaign. In enacting Section 312(a) (7) Congress did
not intend to alter the role that news coverage performs
in keeping the public informed without invoking “equal
opportunities” requirements. Indeed, the news exemp-
tions of Section 315 demonstrate the intent of Congress
to foster news coverage of the political process apart from
the conditions under which individual candidates are
afforded the opportunity to purchase broadcast time.
ABC news coverage of the Presidential election proc-
ess is on-going. While it is natural that this should
escalate and expand as the election year approaches, such
journalistic pursuits must not be interpreted as a trigger
date for the beginning of time sales under the “rea-
sonable access” provision. To do so might influence
broadcasters to make news judgments based, in part at
least, on the impact that initiation of campaign coverage
would have on their overall program schedules.
In responding on October 23, 1979 to the Committee’s
request for time, ABC indicated that a decision would
be made shortly as to when political time for the Presi-
dential campaign would be made available on ABC-TV.
That decision has since been reached. ABC will make
time available beginning with the first week of January,
1980.
In our judgment, such a beginning date for the avail-
ability of national political time is reasonable and ac-
commodates all relevant interests. As a matter of com-
parison, in the 1976 Presidential campaign the first pro-
59
gram time sold by ABC was for a 5-minute program on
April 23, 1976.
Respectfully submitted,
AMERICAN BROADCASTING COMPANIES,
INC,
By EVERETT H. ERLICK
1330 Avenue of the Americas
New York, New York 10019
JAMES A. MCKENNA, JR.
THOMAS N. FROHOCK
CARL R. RAMEY
1150 Seventeenth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
Its Attorneys
ec: Timothy G. Smith, Esq.
John D. Lane, Esq.
Harold K. McCombs, Esq.
Counsel for the Carter-Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc.
60
Before the
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554
In the Matter of
The Complaint of the Carter/Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc.
To: The Commission
RESPONSE OF
NATIONAL BROADCASTING COMPANY, INC.
National Broadcasting Company, Ine. (“NBC”)
hereby responds to the Complaint filed with the Com-
mission by the Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee,
Inc. (“Committee”) on October 29, 1979, complaining
of the refusal of the ABC, CBS and NBC Television Net-
works to sell it a one-half hour time period on their re-
spective networks between 8 and 10:30 PM ET on De-
cember 4, 5, 6 and 7, 1979,* to be used for President
Carter’s campaign.
Introduction and Summary
NBC declined the request by the Committee to pur-
chase time only after full consideration of the various
factors.
It is now as early as one year before the presidential
election, and almost five months before the earliest date
during the 1976 nominating period when the NBC Tele-
vision Network sold its first half hour to a candidate
in that campaign (March 31, 1976).
* No other length of network time and no other dates were re-
quested by or appear to be satisfactory to the Committee. See
Complaint, pp. 3 and 6. NBC therefore did not consider such
alternatives.
61
The equal opportunities requirement of the Com-
munications Act requires that all legally qualified can-
didates for a particular office be treated equally, re-
gardless of their significance or lack of it and no matter
how unlikely may be their chance of attracting voter
support. Were the NBC Television Network to sell a
half hour of prime time for use by President Carter
at this time, on the basis upon which the Committee
claims it, there would seem to be no basis on which the
Network could refuse to sell a similar time period dur-
ing prime time to every one of the many legally quali-
fied candidates for the Democratic and Republican
Party presidential nominations who might make a sim-
ilar request.
At this stage of the campaign, there are so many
candidates or potential candidates for these Parties’
nominations—at least 12 who are now or have been gov-
ernors, senators or representatives, plus at least 60
others who have filed with the Federal Election Com-
mission a notice of their candidacy for the presidential
nomination of the Democratic or Republican Parties
alone—that such a result could be greatly disruptive of
network program service. Should the Commission rule
in favor of this request it would require broadcasters
for the next 10 months to comply with similar claims
of a large number of other actual and potential candi-
dates, in many of whom the public has little interest
but who may be legally entitled to equal consideration
to President Carter.
The rigidity of the equal time laws simply does not
allow either NBC or the Commission to distinguish be-
tween legally qualified candidates. NBC has, through
the years, therefore supported repeal or suspension of
the equal opportunities provisions of Section 315, par-
ticularly as to candidates for nomination or election to
President of the United States. “Reasonable access” re-
62
quirements would be interpreted in the reality of the
election process, based on the significance of the election
contest and of the major candidates.
NBC therefore urges the Commision to deny the com-
plaint. NBC also urges the Commission to seek congres-
sional repeal or suspension of the equal opportunities
provisions of the Communications Act, particularly as
they apply to the nomination and election to the presi-
dency.
I. NBC WAS NOT UNREASONABLE IN DE-
CLINING THE COMMITTEE’S REQUEST.
The question before the Commision in considering the
Committee’s complaint is whether NBC was unreason-
able in reaching its decision. Among the standards used
by the Commission in determining whether judgments in
this area are reasonable are:
(a) The length of the period between the requested
broadcast and the date of the election contest with re-
spect to which broadcast time is sought. As a general
rule, the Commission considers that reasonable access
must be provided by the licensees serving that state, dur-
ing the 45 days before that state’s primary election.
Here, however, national network access is sought, rather
than broadcast station service to a state in which a
primary election is soon to be held; the relevant contest
would seem to be the national convention of the political
party, which in the case of the Democratic Party will
be in August, 1980.
(b) The number of candidates. Here, there are cur-
rently at least 12 actual or potential candidates for the
Democratic or Republican Party nomination who have
held federal elective office or been governor of a state,
plus at least 60 others who have filed with the Federal
Election Commission a notice of their candidacy for the
63
Democratic or Republican Party presidential nomination,
plus more than 50 others who have filed with the Fed-
eral Election Commission a notice of their candidacy for
nomination by other parties or as independents.
(c) Whether the demands of the candidates could
disrupt the normal broadcast program schedules. In the
case of the NBC Television Network, there are only 2
half-hour series in its regular weekly schedule, with
only 7 half-hour programs in those 2 series scheduled
during the remainder of the entire month of December
(not counting 2 children’s specials scheduled in the days
before Christmas). Obviously, preemption of these 2
entire series or of one-hour programs (in order to carry
a half-hour political broadcast and some hastily-sched-
uled filler) would be disruptive. There is simply no
way for NBC or the Commission to be assured that
many of the other candidates will not be legally en-
titled to seek and receive the same “access” as demanded
here.
A. The appropriate standard for Commission review is
whether NBC’s judgment is unreasonable.
Section 312(a)(7) of the Communications Act pro-
vides that “[t]he Commission may revoke any station
license or construction permit
“for willful or repeated failure to allow reasonable
access to or to permit purchase of reasonable
amounts of time for the use of a broadcasting sta-
tion by a legally qualified candidate for Federal
elective office on behalf of his candidacy.” *
* Paragraph 7 was added by Public Law 92-225 (the Campaign
Communications Reform Act of 1971) approved February 7, 1972,
86 Stat. 3.
5”
64
The Commission traditionally has emphasized that it
will “rely generally on the reasonable, good faith judg-
ments of licensees as to what constitutes reasonable
access under all the circumstances present in particular
eases.” Enforcing Section 312(a)(7), 68 FCC 2d 1079,
1098, 48 RR 2d 1029, 1047 (1978); see also, Summa
Corporation, 48 FCC 2d 602, 28 RR 2d 768 (1973);
Anthony R. Martin-Trigona (Radio Station WGN), 67
FCC 2d 743, 42 RR 2d 570 (1978). In Enforcing Sec-
tion 312(a)(7), supra, the Commission reviewed the
legislative and administrative history of the implemen-
tation of Section 312(a)(7) and noted specifically that
“{iJn tailoring access to meet the needs of candidates
for a particular office, licensees may consider such fac-
tors as the unavailability of particular classes of time;
a multiplicity of candidates; the specific desires of can-
didates, ete.” Jd. at 1091. The Commission has also in-
dicated it expected “licensees to afford access at a
reasonable time prior to a convention or caucus.” Jd., at
1092, emphasis added.
The Commission has stated its awareness that “there
may be situations where the number of federal candi-
dates in a particular election make it impossible for a
station to make prime time program time available.”
Id. at 1089.
As will be shown below, NBC has taken into consid-
eration the factors specified by the Commission, and its
judgment based on these factors cannot be ruled un-
reasonable.
B. Factor of timing.
NBC’s October 23, 1979 letter to the Committee ex-
plained that “[{b]ased upon our experience with past
campaigns, we believe it is too early in the political
season for nationwide broadcast time to be made avail-
able for paid political purposes.” Complaint, Exhibit B.
The fact is that it is now one year before the 1980
presidential election and about 10 months before the
Democratic Party Convention. This compares to the
45- and 60-day periods the Commission established for
stations as candidate-access periods generally applicable
to primary and general elections, respectively. Enfore-
ing Section 312(a)(7), supra, at 1091.
Neither the statute nor Commission precedent requires
that the broadcaster invariably bow to the time de-
mands of the first candidate who makes a “reasonable
access” request. While the Commission left for case-by-
case consideration what would be a reasonable period
for access prior to a convention or caucus, surely it
cannot be deemed legally unreasonable for a broadcaster
to refuse a request so long before the event as this case
involves.
Comparing the current situation to the 1976 cam-
paign, the fact is that the earliest date on which any
national television network broadcast a half-hour pro-
gram of any candidate for a presidential nomination
was March 81, 1976—a date four months later than that
sought here.*
The Committee’s letter to NBC mentioned that the
first official contest to select delegates to the Democratic
National Convention occurs January 21, 1980, in Iowa,
which is 47 days after the last date for which it re-
*The NBC Television Network sold time on that date to Ronald
Reagan, candidate for the Republican Party nomination. In this
context, it should be noted that the NBC Television Network has
not adopted a rigid policy of refusing to sell program time to can-
didates for presidential nomination. In fact, during the 1976
presidential campaign, NBC made prime time half-hour program
periods available to several presidential nomination candidates
prior to the national party conventions. NBC reaches its judgment
on a case-by-case basis after weighing all relevant factors applica-
ble in the particular case.
66
quested time (Ex. A to Complaint). This point is not
made in the Complaint. As NBC pointed out in its
response (Ex. B to Complaint), insofar as the nomina-
tion process is now focused on political activities in in-
dividual states like Iowa, the candidates may wish to
contact stations serving those particular states, not seek
national network time in states whose primaries or con-
ventions may be scheduled on dates far into 1980.
The Democratic National Convention is 10 months
away. To the extent that a candidate for that Party’s
nomination seeks national network time, it is with re-
gard to that national event. If broadcast time were
sought with regard to individual state primaries, con-
ventions or caucuses, it would be more appropriate to
reach the public in those states by ordering time from
individual stations, not the national networks.*
In this context, it should be noted that even were the
networks to carry the proferred program or the Com-
mission to order them to do so in order to serve those
few states holding early primaries, there is no assve-
ance that individual stations would choose to broadcast
it. In such cases, the networks are program distribu-
tors, not broadcasters. Stations are free to refuse the
network offering (e.g., see Section 73.658 (d) and (e)
of the Commission’s Rules). This is more than a legal
nicety, since stations located in states where their local
primaries are some months off may choose to decline
the network offering in fear that if they accepted it, they
would have to grant immediately similar access on a
local basis to all the candidates in their area. This
would move up the local campaigns to a point substan-
* Indeed, it does not appear that Section 312(a) (7) applies to
networks, since it applies explicitly to use of “a broadcast station”
and is contained in a section of the Communications Act dealing
with license revocation; networks are not a broadcast station nor
are they licensed as such.
67
tially earlier than their individual judgments may be-
lieve warranted. This also points up the awkwardness
and difficulty of a government agency overruling a net-
work’s reasonable judgment and seeking to determine
“reasonable access” as a matter of law on a natiunwide
basis when what is really involved is a series of in-
dividual state primaries, caucuses, and conventions held
at different times and places over a period of about 6
months.
During the preconvention period, the campaigns
waged by the presidential candidates are on a state-by-
state basis. They are geared to the primary elections
as they occur in the various states. Thus, the need of
the candidates to reach the primary voters in a state
is best covered by the communications media serving
that state.
C. Factor of multiplicity of candidates.
The Commission has recognized that the number of
candidates vying for nomination or election is a factor
the broadcaster may properly take into account in reach-
ing his decision as to reasonable access. Enforcing Sec-
tion 312(a)(7), supra, at 1090; Hughes Tool Co., 42
FCC 2d 894 (1973) ; Summa Corp., supra. NBC’s letter
to the Committee identified this factor as a significant
one in its own decision, noting that
- we believe that honoring your request at this
early stage of the Presidential campaign would re-
quire NBC to honor similar requests from a number
of other Presidential aspirants. The impact of such
an undertaking at this time, is, of course, a sig-
nificant factor in our decision” (Ex. B to Com-
plaint).
While acknowledging the validity of this factor, the
Complaint asserts that “there is a relatively limited num-
68
ber of national candidates in either party that are
[sic] willing and able to purchase network prime time
half-hours.” It then claims that “at most” there will be
6, 3 in each major party. It acknowledges that two
others have actually made requests already. (Complaint,
pp. 4-5)
The Complaint is correct in its acknowledgment that
this is a request for reasonable access, not for equal time.
Under Section 315, only those contending for the nomi-
nation of a particular party are entitled to equal time
to that used by a candidate for that party’s nomination. :
But here, the request is for reasonable access under Sec-
tion 312(a) (7), and the same basic principles apply to
candidates for both the Democratic and Republican Party
nominations.
However, the Complaint’s facts and conclusions are er-
coneous and unjustified. Regardless of the subjective
opinion of the Committee, there are at least 12 candi-
dates for nomination (declared or expected by these two
parties) who have held federal elective office or been
governor of a state,* plus at least 60 other identified in-
dividuals who have taken the necessary steps toward
qualification with the Federal Election Commission as
candidates for nomination by the Republican or Demo-
cratic Parties to the office of the President in 1980.**
* These are: John B. Anderson, Howard H. Baker, Jr., Edmund
G. Brown, George Bush, Jimmy Carter, John B. Connally, Philip
M. Crane, Robert J. Dole, Edward M. Kennedy, Larry Pressler,
Ronald Reagan and Harold Stassen. The Committee does not
identify the 6 it concedes would seek access.
** 33 others for nomination by the Democratic Party; 29 others
for nomination by the Republican Party. The Commission can
take official notice of such filings at the Federal Elections Commis-
sion which are published in a list, the latest which is dated October
29, 1979, Candidate Cross Index (FEC 93-1980). NBC incorporates
that list by reference in this Response; in the alternative, NBC
would be prepared to file with the Commission its copy of the
Federal Election Commission’s published list.
69
The Federal Election Commission lists more than 50
others who have filed notice of their candidacy for nomi-
nation by other parties or as independents. Section
73.1940 (a) (4) (ii) of the Commission’s Rules in effect
limits reasonable access on a national basis to those
candidates who have “made a substantial showing of bona
fide candidacy ... in at least ten states .. .,” but neither
the Commission nor NBC can, at this early stage of the
campaign and one month before the requested broadcast
time, determine (as the Committee assumes) that no
more than 5 of these individuals would seek time equiva-
lent to that sought by the Committee’s request.” Were
the Commission to base its decision on a determination
that only a certain number of candidates will request
time, what remedy would there be should that assumption
prove erroneous?
In fact, a sale of a half-hour of time to President
Carter would require NBC under the statutory equal
opportunities requirements to be prepared to sell a com-
parable period to any of the President’s legally qualified
opponents for the nomination of the Democratic Party.
47 U.S.C. Section 315; Hughes Tool Co., supra; Summa
Corp., swpra. And if broadcaster judgments are to be
overturned as unreasonable and prime time half-hour
programs are held to be legally required for the Demo-
crats, absent significantly different factual situations or
some indication in the Commission’s decision that such
a decision was applicable only to Democratic candidates,
logic would indicate that similar access periods also must
be made available, upon request, to interested legally
qualified candidates for the Republican Party presidential
nomination.
*If a candidate is legally qualified under the Commission’s
Rules and makes a timely request, he is entitled to his rights pur-
suant to Sections 315 regardless of whether the broadcaster be-
lieves he has any chance of success. Columbia Broadcasting Sys-
tem, 40 FCC 244 (1952).
70
The Commission has, in the past, recognized the va-
lidity of the disruptive nature of multiple political broad-
casts. It has held that the broadcaster need not sell
periods for political advertising which would unduly dis-
rupt its schedule. Letter to D. J. Leary, 34 FCC 2d
471 (1972). It has acknowledged that “there may be
situations where the number of federal candidates in a
particular election may make it impossible for a station
to make prime time program time available.” Enforcing
Section 312(a)(7), supra, at 1090.
If it is ever to be possible for a broadcaster to be
able to take into consideration the multiplicity of candi-
dates in reaching its determination as to reasonable ac-
cess, this case requires the Commission to acknowledge
the reasonableness of NBC’s judgment here.
C. Factor of disruption of the schedule.
The enormity of the potential disruption of the NBC
Television Network prime time schedule is obvious. NBC
would have to hold itself available to sell a prime time
half-hour to every other legally qualified candidate for
the Democratic Party nomination and probably the Re-
publican Party as well. This would be an enormous dis-
ruption of the prime time schedule, even assuming all
of it was readily available for such sale.
But despite the contrary claims made at page 2 of
the Complaint, NBC has scheduled only 9 prime time
half-hour programs for the remainder of the month of
December, 1979, starting with December 4, the first date
requested by the Committee. Of these 9 programs, two
are Christmas specials for children. The other 7 are
programs in the only 2 regular half-hour prime time
series on the NBC Television Network. Not only would
these 2 series be likely to be disrputed, but presumably,
unless the other candidates would be required to share
71
an hour,* which they usually do not like to do, NBC
would have to perform “major surgery” on the remainder
of its prime time schedule to accommodate other requests.
There is simply no way for NBC or the Commission
to be assured that many of the other candidates are not
or will not be entitled to seek and receive the same
“access” as demanded here. They are not parties to this
proceeding and the Commission cannot now rule on their
present legal qualifications, let alone on what their status
will be in a month from now. Nor can either NBC or
the Commission assume that they do not now have nor
will they be able to raise from others or their own assets
the necessary funds to purchase the network time period.
Similarly, neither NBC nor the Commission can decide
to sell a particular maximum number of half-hours to
the candidates (regardless of whether all candidates who
seek time have received it) and call it quits. Sections
315 and 312(a) (7) simply do not work that way.
It is clear that the “reasonable access” provision does
not require broadcasters to “disrupt their programming
schedules.” Enforcing Section 312(a)(7), supra, at 1090,
1096.
In this connection, it might be noted that the NBC
Television Network does not generally sell individual
program periods (whether 30 minutes in length or other-
wise) to commercial advertisers. The usual commercial
sale is of 30-second or one-minute commercial units; and
no commercial advertiser may use an entire 30-minute
period for its message. The NBC Television network
does attempt to clear longer program periods for po-
litical candidates where that is practical and reasonable
in the light of all the circumstances, and did so before
the adoption of Section 312(a) (7). But to do so in the
* Even the two regular half-hour series are back-to-back in a
one-hour period.
72
circumstances here would not only require varying from
its normal commercial format but massive disruptions
in its program service.
The Commission itself has recognized that reasonable
access “only requires that the licensee follow its usual
commercial practices” with respect to the classes and
lengths of program or spot time offered to commercial
and political advertisers. Jd., at 1090; see also WGN, 58
FCC 2d 1142, 1144 (1976). More generally, the Com-
mission has stated that Section 312(a) (7) was not de-
signed to preempt all or most broadcast time for political
purposes; that “[i]mportant as an informed electorate
is in our society, there are other elements in the public
interest standard, and the public is entitled to other
kinds of programming than political.” * Use of Broadcast
and Cablecast Facilities by Candidates for Public Office,
84 FCC 2d 510, 586 (1972). NBC respectfully submits
that these policies have particularly cogent application
to the facts and circumstances involved here.
II. THE CONGRESS SHOULD REPEAL OR SUS-
PEND THE EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES PRO-
VISIONS OF SECTION 315.
The present situation is caused by the equal oppor-
tunities requirement of the Communications Act, which
requires that all legally qualified candidates for a par-
ticular office be treated equally, regardless of their sig-
*In this context, it is important to recognize that the NBC
Television Network has provided the public with access to Presi-
dent Carter. Since January 1, 1979, President Carter has made
86 major appearances (speeches, messages, news conferences, inter-
views, etc.) on NBC. In addition, President Carter’s picture or
voice has appeared in over 100 reports in each of the NBC
NIGHTLY NEWS and NBC TODAY programs since the beginning
of this year.
73
nificance or lack of it and no matter how unlikely may
be their chance of attracting voter support.
Were broadcasters able to limit their sales of time
to those candidates for presidential nomination regarded
as significant, they could establish some reasonable limits
to the forced disruption of program schedules in order
to present candidates in which the public had little or no
interest. This could be done by repeal or supervision of
the equal opportunities requirements, and interpreta-
tion of “reasonable access” in terms of the reality of
the election process, based on the significance of the elec-
tion contest and of the major candidates. NBC has,
though the years, supported repeal or suspension of the
equal opportunities provisions of Section 315, particu-
larly as to candidates for nomination or election to
President of the United States.
NBC therefore respectfully urges the Commission,
concurrently with its denial of the Complaint because
NBC has not been unreasonable, again to seek from the
Congress repeal or suspension of the equal opportunities
provisions of the Communications Act, particularly as they
apply to the nomination and election to the Presidency.
74
CONCLUSION
On the facts of this case, the Commission must uphold
the judgment of the NBC Television Network in de-
clining to sell a half-hour of time between 8 and 10:30
PM ET to the Committee on December 4, 5, 6 or 7,
1979, as not unreasonable.
Respectfully submitted,
/8/ Corydon B. Dunham
CORYDON B. DUNHAM
Executive Vice President
and General Counsel
National Broadcasting Company, Inc.
30 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, New York 10020
/8/ Howard Monderer
HOWARD MONDERER
Vice President, Law, Washington
National Broadcasting Company, Inc.
1800 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006
November 5, 1979
[Certificate of Service Omitted in Printing]
75
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554
In re:
Complaint of the
Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee, Inc.
RESPONSE OF CBS INC.
I. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
This is in response to the FCC staff’s oral request, on
October 30, for CBS’ response to an October 29 com-
plaint by the Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee,
Inc.* against CBS, NBC and ABC. The complaint arises
in connection with the Committee’s request to each of the
networks to purchase a half hour of prime time between
December 4 and 7 of this year to promote President
Carter’s campaign for the Democratic presidential
nomination.
With respect to CBS, complainant contends that the offer
of the CBS Television Network to sell the Carter-Mondale
Committee two 5-minute program length segments, in-
cluding one 5-minute period in prime time, is inadequate
to satisfy the “reasone’ le access” provision set forth in
Section 312(a) (7) of the Communications Act.** Thus,
* (hereinafter ‘“Carter-Mondale Committee,” “Committee” or
complainant)
** Section 312(a) provides that “The Commission may revoke any
station license ... (7) for willful or repeated failure to allow rea-
sonable access to or to permit purchase of reasonable amounts of
time for the use of a broadcasting station by a legally qualified
candidate for Federal elective office on behalf of his candidacy.”
While the provision is addressed to stations and not the networks,
we believe that the CBS Television Network has, in any event, been
reasonable in its offer of time to the Committee.
76
complainant argues that, even at this very early date
in the presidential campaign, it has an absolute right to
purchase a 30-minute program in prime time.
We believe that complainant’s position is without legal
merit. The Commission has afforded broadcasters con-
siderable discretion in determining how they will meet
their reasonable access obligations under Section 312(a)
(7).* That discretion has extended to the amount of
time and length of program segments to be made avail-
able to federal candidates,** as well as to determining
when selling time in connection with a particular cam-
paign will begin.***
As we will demonstrate below, the instant facts present
a particularly strong case for allowing significant flexi-
bility to broadcasters in determining how much time they
will currently sell to presidential candidates. The long
campaigns for presidential nomination, which will ex-
tend over the next nine months and involve 36 primary
elections, have just begun—indeed, none of the three
major contenders for the Democratic presidential nomina-
tion has as yet even formally announced his candidacy.
Additionally, the number of contenders for the major
party presidential nominations in 1980 is unusually
large: at least three Democrats and 11 Republicans,****
* See pages 13-21, infra.
** See pages 15-17, infra.
*** See pages 19-20, infra.
**** In addition to President Carter, Senator Kennedy and Gov-
ernor Brown are now considered very likely to run for the Demo-
cratic presidential nomination. Among Republicans, Senators
Baker, Dole and Pressler; Representatives Anderson and Crane;
Governor Connally; former CIA Director George Bush and Harold
Stassen have already announced their presidential candidacies, as
has Benjamin Fernandez, a leading California businessman whose
candidacy has been widely reported in the national press and who
expects to wage a $15 million campaign for the Presidency. Addi-
77
are presently seeking, or may reasonably be expected to
seek, their party’s presidential nomination. Most im-
portant to consider at this time is the fundamental
political reality of the presidential nominating process—
that the race for convention delegates focuses largely on
a series of contests in individual states.
In these circumstances, to require that a national net-
work presently sell half-hour time periods to candidates
for presidential nomination would risk significant dis-
ruption of regular network programming over the next
nine months—disruptions that would affect a nationwide
audience, notwithstanding the fact that only scattered
local contests are presently occurring. Given these facts,
and the Commission’s recognition that “the publie is
entitled to other kinds of programming than political,” *
we respectfully submit that CBS’ present offer of two
5-minute time periods to the Carter-Mondale Committee
is fully consistent with the reasonable access provision.
Il. RELEVANT BACKGROUND
In considering this complaint—and the possible conse-
quences of a ruling favorable to the Carter-Mondale
Committee—the Commission should bear in mind that
rarely, if ever, has the CBS Television Network received
tionally, Governor Reagan has stated his intent to announce his
candidacy within the next several weeks, and its is reported that
General Alexander Haig may shortly become a candidate for the
Republican presidential nomination. Finally, many “fringe” candi-
dates for the Presidency may be expected to emerge during the
course of the campaign. In this connection, we note that, while it ™
is uncertain how many would meet this Commission’s criteria for
“legal qualification,” there are currently 115 individuals registered
as presidential candidates with the Federal Election Commission.
See, Us Magazine, November 13, 1979, p. 24.
* Report and Order, Commission Policy in Enforcing Section
312(a)(7) of the Communications Act, 483 RR 2d 1029, 1042 (1978)
(hereinafter “Report and Order’).
78
so many requests to purchase program length time per-
iods this far in advance of a presidential election. A
brief summary of the requests so far received and their
disposition by CBS follows.
By telegram of September 14, the Connally for President
Committee requested to purchase on the CBS Television
Network (1) five 5-minute time periods in prime time
between October 1 and December 1, 1979; (2) a half-
hour segment in prime time between October 15 and
November 15; (3) comparable time with 72 hours of any
“major program” on behalf of Governor Reagan; and
(4) a 15-minute program between 10 AM and 2 PM
on Thanksgiving Day. Although CBS declined to meet
this request in light of the number_of candidates for
presidential nomination, it offered to sell the Connally
Committee two 5-minute time periods, one in prime time
and another in daytime. In accordance with this offer,
the Connally Committee subsequently purchased two 5-
minute programs on the CBS Television Network to air
on October 30 and November 21. At the same time, the
Connally Committee in an October 10 letter to CBS re-
asserted its position that it was entitled to purchase all
of the program time it had originally requested, and
further demanded equal time within 72 hours “should
any of the serious unannounced candidates for the Re-
publican or Democratic nomination be granted program
time.”
On September 21, the Reagan for President Committee
requested to purchase a half-hour program in prime time
on the CBS Television Network between November 4 and
18 (excluding four dates within that period). Once
again, CBS responded by offering * one 5-minute prime
*Since Governor Reagan had not yet formally announced his
candidacy, CBS’ response to his request indicated that it was
CBS policy to sell time only to announced candidates for public
office, and its offer was accordingly made conditional on Governor
79
time and one 5-minute daytime segment, and once again
two such programs were purchased, to air on November
13 and 14 respectively.
By letter of October 11, the Carter-Mondale Committee
asked to purchase a 30-minute segment on the CBS Tele-
vision Network between 8 PM and 10:30 PM EST on
December 4, 5, 6 or 7. In its October 17 response, CBS
offered to sell the Committee a 5-minute time period on
December 8, 1979* at approximately 10:55-11:00 PM,
“plus a 5-minute daytime segment at a date and time to
be mutually agreed. In its letter, CBS explained that
it was unable presently to grant the Committee’s request
for a half-hour time period in light of the multiplicity
of candidates which now exists, and noted that it had
responded to similar requests from two candidates for the
Republican presidential nomination in an identical man-
ner. The filing of the instant complaint followed.
Reagan’s having formally announced, or using the time purchased
formally to announce, his presidential candidacy. The CBS Tele-
vision Network’s offer of time to the Carter-Mondale Committee
was similarly conditioned.
*In its complaint, the Carter-Mondale Committee criticizes
CBS’ offer of this time period on the ground that “(tlhe five
minutes before 11 PM on Saturday is one of the least desirable
time periods in the network prime time schedule.” Leaving aside
the question of whether complainant would be entitled to demand
to purchase a program length segment in prime time on a par-
ticular day of the week, see, e.g., Report and Order, 48 RR 2d at
1044, we note that CBS offered the December 8 availability because
it was the closest date to those requested by the Carter-Mondale
Committee on which a prime time program suitable for the editing
necessary to accommodate a 5-minute political broadcast was
planned. Although the Carter-Mondale Committee did not respond
to our letter of October 17, CBS was and is prepared to negotiate
with the Committee concerning the date of a 5-minute prime time
broadcast.
80
III. DISCUSSION
1. CBS’ Decision is Reasonable
As is apparent from the preceding discussion, the CBS
Television Network has been willing, even at this early
date in the 1980 campaign, to sell reasonable amounts
of program time *—including prime time segments—to
candidates seeking the presidential nominations of thei:
parties. This is in accord with CBS’ longstanding policy
of making reasonable amounts of program and “spot”
announcement ** time available for sale to political can-
didates to present their views and for fund raising pur-
poses. In addition, the CBS Television Network has tra-
ditionally sold half-hour time periods to presidential can-
didates during general election periods and will do so
again next fall.
As we have noted, however, campaigns for presiden-
tial nomination consist largely of a series of state pri-
mary elections, conventions and caucuses conducted over
many months.*** Although each of these contests
will obviously be newsworthy and the subject of nationa!
interest, the actual campaigns for delegates will neces-
sarily be conducted on a local level and focus on the
voters of individual states. Thus, while the CBS Tele-
* Both industry practice and FCC precedent support the view
that 5-minute segments constitute program time rather than “spot”
announcements. See p. 16, infra.
** Although the CBS Television Network has not yet received
requests to purchase “spot” announcement time from presidential
candidates in connection with the 1980 campaign, it of course
stands ready to make such announcements available, as it has
in previous elections.
*** Thirty-four states, plus the District of Columbia and Puerto
Rico, will hold presidential primaries in 1980. These primaries will
begin in February and will not be completed until June 8. The
national conventions will begin on July 14 (Republican) and
August 11 (Democratic).
81
vision Network has not previously sold half-hour time
periods to presidential candidates in the pre-convention
period, the CBS Owned television stations have in past
years made reasonable amounts of announcements and
program time—including half-hour segments—available
to presidential primary candidates.
At this point in the 1980 campaign, however, the CBS
Television Network has made the judgment that the
public interest does not require the preemption of ex-
tensive segments of its national program service for
political broadcasts of half-hour duration. We em-
phasize again the unusually large number of candidates
who are seeking the major party presidential nomi-
nations in 1980, and the concomitant likelihood that
many hours of programming normally expected by the
nation’s viewers will in fact be disrupted if the Com-
mission rules in favor of the Carter-Mondale Committee.
In its complaint, the Committee expends considerable
effort in an attempt to downplay the significance of the
multiplicity of presidential candidates which presently
exists. Thus, in a wholly unsupported and conclusory
statement, complainant argues that “there is a relatively
limited number of national candidates in either party
that are willing and able to purchase network prime
time half-hours.” Further, the Carter-Mondale Commit-
tee assures the Commission that complainant “does not
intend to make such purchases a regular practice,” and
that “it is unlikely that any such requests shall be made
in the near future.” *
* Complainant also contends that under Section 315 of the Com-
munications Act only Democratic Party candidates could claim
“equal opportunities” were the instant request to be granted.
While complainant is technically correct, CBS could not under
its own standards of fairness refuse to sell half-hour programs
to Republican presidential candidates while making such time
periods available to Democrats. Indeed, it is doubtful whether
such a decision would be sustainable before this Commission.
82
Complainant’s assertion that there will be only a “rela-
tively limited” demand for network half-hours by presi-
dential candidates is, of course, purely speculative. In-
deed, the experience of the CBS Television Network in
the 1976 presidential primary campaign would appear
to cast substantial doubt on this contention. Thus, be-
fore the 1976 Democratic and Republican conventions,
the CBS Television Network sold 14 five-minute time
periods* to candidates for major party presidential
nomination. It is reasonable to assume that, had half-
hour time periods been made available by the network
in connection with the primary campaigns, many of
these purchases would have been of half-hour programs.
Moreover, complainant’s assumption that only the most
serious contenders for the Presidency will make such
purchases is likewise unsupported by experience. Thus,
in the 1976 primary campaign, such candidates as Ellen
McCormick and Eugene McCarthy purchased program
time on the CBS Television Network, with Mrs. Mc-
Cormick purchasing four 5-minute segments. In the
general election period, program time on the CBS Tele-
vision Network was sold not only to the Democratic and
Republican nominees, but also to the candidates of the
Libertarian, Communist, American and Pro-Life parties,
and to Eugene McCarthy running as an independent.
While the Carter-Mondale Committee presently asserts
that it does not intend to make such purchases a “reg-
ular practice,” and that it is “unlikely” to request fur-
ther haif-hours in the “near future,” it obviously has
no power to bind other candidates in this regard. In-
deed, the fact that the campaigns for presidential nom-
ination involve a series of importaut primary elections,
with different candidates considering different primaries
crucial to their individual campaign strategies, would
* Twelve of these programs were broadcast during prime time.
83
appear to make repeated requests* for half-hour pro-
grams very likely. As noted above, the CBS Television
Network has already received three requests to purchase
half hours in connection with the 1980 campaign, months
before such requests have normally been received in the
past. It is simply illogical to assume, as complainant
apparently does, that these early requests are an indi-
cation that demand for half-hours will be limited. On
the contrary, we believe that the highly unusual amount
of political buying of network time which has already
taken place adds weight to our concern that an adverse
Commission ruling on the instant complaint will lead
to a substantial number of requests for prime time half-
hours as the campaign gathers speed with the com-
mencement of the vital state primaries.**
* Each purchase of a half-hour time period would, of course,
give rise to potential “equal opportunities” obligations under
Section 315 of the Communications Act.
** In evaluating the total impact which a favorable ruling on
the Carter-Mondale complaint is likely to have, the Commission
should be aware that presidential and other federal candidates
may also be expected to seek to purchase prime program time on
local television stations during the 1980 primary campaigns.
Moreover, in addition to federal races, gubernatorial and other
state and local primary candidates are likely to request program
time on local stations, and licensees may determine that such
requests should in the public interest be granted. We note, for
example, that primary elections for the following offices will
be held within the coverage arca of WCAU-TV, the CBS Owned
television station in Philadelphia: (1) Pennsylvania: United
States President; United States Senator (one seat) ; United States
Representative (11 seats); State Attorney General; State Auditor
General; State Treasurer; State Senator (12 seats in viewing
area); State Representative (100 seats in viewing area); (2)
Delaware: United States President; United States Representative
(one seat) ; State Governor and Lt. Governor; Secretary of State;
State Treasurer; State Auditor; State Insurance Commissioner ;
84
Finally, even if the Commission were to decide, notwith-
standing the circumstances outlined above, that candi-
dates are entitled to network half-hour time periods at
some point during the presidential primary campaign,
we submit that there would be no basis for overturning
CBS’ judgment that such sales are presently premature.
While complainant argues that “[t]his is a matter
which should be viewed in light of the needs of the can-
didate and not the belief of the network,” prior Com-
mission decisions * make clear that the desires of can-
didates are not always paramount in this area and that
broadcasters do have substantial discretion to decide
when they will begin selling time to political candidates.
We do not believe that the CBS Television Network’s
offer of 5-minute, rather than half-hour, time periods to
presidential candidates nearly a year before the general
election and months before the earliest state primaries
can be characterized as unreasonable.
(3) New Jersey: United States President; United States Repre-
sentative (five seats).
Thus, the Carter-Mondale request to purchase a half-hour of net-
work prime program time cannot be isolated from the extensive
demands for political time that stations will receive from candi-
dates for other federal, state and local offices. In this connection,
we note that to the extent that the practical effect of Section
312(a) (7), by creating a favored class of federal candidates, is
to limit the ability of local television stations to sell time in connec-
tion with important state and local races while still preserving the
public interest in non-political programming, serious questions may
be raised concerning the constitutionality of the statute. Indeed,
in its recent Report and Order concerning enforcement of Section
312(a) (7), the Commission explicitly noted that it “[tlakes no
position on the constitutionality of Section 312(a) (7) or the fed-
eral preemption of the area of political broadcasting.” 48 RR 2d
1029, 1047 (1978).
* See pp. 19-20, infra.
7
85
2. CBS’ Decision Is Supported By Commission Precedent
The sole issue raised by the Carter-Mondale Committee’s
complaint insofar as CBS is concerned is whether CBS’
decision to make 5-minute rather than 80-minute time
periods available for purchase by candidates at this
stage of the 1980 presidential campaign is reasonable
under Section 312(a)(7), as interpreted by the Com-
mission.
There is little in the legislative history surrounding the
enactment of this provision to shed light on whether the
broadcast of 5-minute rather than 30-minute programs
is “reasonable.” * In such circumstances, we submit that
it is particularly appropriate that great reliance be
placed on the Commission’s prior interpretations of a
statute which it has been charged with administering.
While Section 312(a) (7) is a relatively recent addition
to the Communications Act, we submit that Commission
decisions interpreting the provision require an affirmance
of the reasonableness of CBS’ decision. Surely licensees
have to date relied on these interpretations and have
acted on them in considering requests by candidates for
time. The Commission has repeatedly held that the stand-
ard of review is whether the licensee has acted reason-
ably. Thus, the Commission has stated:
“[N]o embracing standard can be set. The test of
whether a licensee has met the requirement of .. .
[312 (a) (7) ] is one of reasonableness,” **
Similarly, in its recent Report and Order concerning en-
forcement of the “reasonable access” provision, the Com-
mission concluded:
* See e.g., Concerning Licensee Responsibility Under Amend-
ments to the Communications Act Made by the Federal Election
Campaign Act of 1971, 47 FCC 2d 516 (1974).
** Use of Broadcast and Cablecast Facilities by Candidates for
Public Office, 34 FCC 2d 510, 686 (1972) (hereinafter Notice).
86
“We continue to believe that the best method for
achieving a balance between the desires of candi-
dates for air time and the commitments of licensees
to the broadcast of other types of programming is
to rely on the reasonable good faith discretion of
individual licensees.” *
Thus, the Commission has stated that
“Where a licensee’s judgments or policies under
the circumstances represent a reasonable, good faith
attempt to accommodate both the right of Federal
candidates to fully inform the voters of their can-
didacies and the interest of the public in program-
ming other than political broadcasts, this Commis-
sion will be disposed to affirm such judgments and
policies as reasonably fulfilling the obligations of a
licensee under Section 312 (a) (7).” **
* Report and Order, 48 RR 2d 1029, 1043 (1978).
** Summa Corp., 28 RR 2d 768, 771 (1973). We believe that the
broad discretion which the Commission has afforded to broadcasters
in the implementation of Section 312(a) (7) is particularly appro-
priate, since serious First Amendment questions may be raised
concerning its constitutionality. Thus, in Columbia Broadcasting
System, Inc. v. Democratic National Committee, 412 U.S. 94 (1973),
the Supreme Court held that the First Amendment and the public
interest standard of the Communications Act could not be read
to require public access to the broadcast media for the presentation
of “editorial advertising.” While the Court did not reach the issue
of whether the Commission or the Congress could constitutionally
require such access, the Court was clearly sensitive to the First
Amendment concerns which any system of mandated access would
involve. Thus, the Court emphasized that the “selection and choice
of material” is the essence of the editorial process (412 U.S. at
124), and went on to state:
“The Commission’s responsibilities under a right-of-access
system would tend to draw it into a continuing case-by-case
determinination of who should be heard and when. Indeed, the
likelihood of Government involvement is so great that it has
been suggested that the accepted constitutional principles
87
In Letter to Paul A. Talmey,* the Commission staff
affirmed a licensee’s rejection of a request by a candidate
for 30-minute programs during periods of “prime audi-
ence potential.” The licensee had offered only 5-minute
programs during such high audience time periods.** The
complainant there argued, in much the same manner as
the instant complaint, that “the issues which a federal
candidate needs to discuss cannot reasonably be dealt
with in only five minutes.” The staff stated that
“the Commission has refrained from establishing a
precise definition of the ‘program time’ to which
Federal candidates are entitled under Section 312
(a) (7). Consequently, we find that [the complain-
ant’s] claim that the licensee’s offer of five-minute
prime time availabilities was unreasonable since
‘. .. five-minutes of air time is not a program...’
is without merit.” ***
Thus, the Commission staff has acknowledged that a 5-
minute program is, indeed, a program.
against control of speech content would need to be relaxed with
respect to editorial advertisements. To sacrifice First Amend-
ment protections for a speculative gain is not warranted, and
it was well within the Commission’s discretion to construe
the Act so as to avoid such a result.” (412 U.S. at 127) (foot-
notes omitted).
While the instant case involves a statute enacted by the Congress,
the inherent constitutional problems with a government agency
dictating to broadcasters what to present and when are no less
serious here than in Democratic National Committee. Accordingly,
whatever the constitutional status of Section 812(a) (7), we re-
spectfully submit that the Commission must interpret the statute
in light of the paramount importance, recognized by the Court in
DNC, of the editorial discretion of broadcasters.
* 31 RR 2d 1089 (1974).
** The licensee had also offered a half-hour program at 6 PM.
*** 31 RR 2d at 1311.
88
In another recent case, In Re Complaint of Hon, Pete
Flaherty,* a candidate for the United States Senate
sought a 414 hour segment on a number of Pennsylvania
stations for a fund-raising telethon. The Commission, in
rejecting the complaint, emphasized that it would not
dictate to licensees the precise manner of their com-
pliance with Section 312(a) (7):
“The statutory language speaks in terms of ‘reason-
able access’ and ‘reasonable amounts of time’ rather
than in any absolute terms. Similarly while our
June 1974 Public Notice recognized a right of ac-
cess by Federal candidates to prime time program-
length time, . . . we have refrained from prescrib-
ing any precise formula for measuring licensee per-
formance in honoring that right so as to not to
interfere unnecessarily with licensee scheduling and
program discretion.” **
Furthermore, while the Commission has interpreted Sec-
tion 312(a)(7) as requiring that program length seg-
ments be made available for purchase by federal candi-
dates in prime audience periods, it has recognized that
there are circumstances—such as the existence of a mul-
tiplicity of candidates—which may render this general
requirement inapplicable. Thus, in its recent Report and
Order the Commission stated:
“(Wle are aware that there may be situations
where the number of federal candidates may make
it impossible for a station to make prime time pro-
gram-time available. We have never held that the
‘prime time, program-time’ policy is absolute and in-
flexible. We will continue to make exceptions to this
policy where circumstances dictate.” ***
*31 RR 2d 258 (1974) (hereinafter “Pete Flaherty’).
** Id. at 272.
*** 43 RR 2d at 1043.
89
Here, of course, the CBS Television Network has not de-
clined to provide prime time program time but only half-
hour time periods.
In attempting to belittle the significance of potential dis-
ruptions of regular network programming resulting
from the sale of half-hour programs to candidates for
presidential nomination, the Carter-Mondale Committee
contends that “[t]he prime time programming of all
three networks is almost exclusively devoted to enter-
tainment programming.” * The Commission has repeat-
edly recognized, however, that there is a public interest
in the presentation of a licensee’s normal programming,
and that a licensee is not obligated to preempt such pro-
gramming solely because a candidate believes that a par-
ticular program length serves his interest.** Thus the
Commission has stated:
“Important as an informed electorate is in our so-
ciety, there are other elements in the public interest
standard, and the public is entitled to other kinds
of programming than political.” ***
Indeed, in Pete Flaherty the Commission rejected the
complainant’s suggestion that the “licensees be called
upon to explain ‘. . . why the public interest is better
served by presentations of old movies or network reruns
than an attempt from an aspirant to the... (U.S.
*In this connection, we note parenthetically the obvious fact
that CBS News provides very significant coverage of presidential
candidates and their views in its regular news and public affairs
broadcasts, and in news interview broadcasts such as FACE THE
NATION.
** See, e.g., Hon. Donald W. Riegle, 38 RR 2d 1343 (1976);
Paul A. Tamley, 81 RR 2d 1809 (1974); James H. Doyle, 38 RR
2d 330 (Bdcst. Bureau 1976).
*** Report and Order, 48 RR 2d at 1042, quoting Notice, 34
RR 2d at 536.
90
Senate] .. . to reach the public.’ ”” The Commission stated
that
“{O]ur scope of review over licensee action in this
area is narrow, and, were we to call upon licensees
to justify their programming selections or program
scheduling, the matter would come down to a judg-
ment as to what was presented, and when, as
against what should have been presented, and
when—a judgmental area for licensees exercising
their sound journalistic discretion and one which
this Commission must avoid.” *
The reasonableness of CBS’ decision not to sell half-
hour programs to presidential candidates at this point in
the campaign is further indicated by Commission de-
cisions sustaining the exercise of licensee discretion as
to when to begin selling time to candidates in federal
elections. Thus, in Matter of Anthony R. Martin-Tri-
gona,** a candidate in a primary for United States Sen-
ator complained under Section 312(a) (7) of a broad-
caster’s refusal to sell him announcement time until
forty-five days before the election. In rejecting this com-
plaint, the staff stated:
“A licensee’s discretion in providing coverage of
elections extends not only to the type and amount
of time to be made available to candidates, but to
the date on which its campaign coverage will com-
mence. A licensee’s decision not to accept political
advertising until 45 days before a primary election
cannot be said to be an unreasonable refusal to de-
vote adequate coverage to a significant and im-
portant election, and does not constitute a denial of
*31 RR 2d at 273.
** 66 FCC 2d 968 (Bdcst. Bureau 1977), aff., 41 RR 2d 1607
(1977).
91
reasonable access to a candidate for Federal office.
The fact that stations in other cities in the state
have sold time for political announcements seven
months in advance of the election does not render
unreasonable a contrary determination by any
other licensee.”
Similarly, in a separate case involving the same candi-
date, the Commission sustained a licensee’s determina-
tion not to sell time in connection with a March sen-
atorial primary until January 1.*
Although there are obvious differences between a cam-
paign for the U.S. Senate and the Presidency, we stress
once again that CBS has not refused to sell prime time
announcements and program length segments to the
complainant. Rather, it has declined presently to sell
half-hour time periods. A Commission ruling requiring
that half-hour programs be made available at this point
in the campaign would, in our view, be simply irrecon-
cilable with the Commission decisions cited above.**
Finally, it should be emphasized that the Commission’s
role here is not to “substitute its judgment for that of
the licensee, but, rather, . .. [to] determine in any case
*In re Anthony R. Martin-Trigona, 42 RR 2d 570 (1978).
** While complainant has ctied no Commission decision in sup-
port of its contention that it is presently entitled to purchase
half-hour program segments, a 1976 oral ruling by the Commission
on a complaint by Senator Frank Church may be thought relevant
to the present facts. In that case, the Commission found that an
Oregon television station had failed to comply with the “reasonable
access” provision by declining Senator Church’s request to pur-
chase a half-hour prime time program on the eve of the Oregon
Democratic presidential primary. Whatever the merits of the
Commission’s ruling on the Church complaint, it is clearly dis-
tinguishable from the instant situation, since the earlier case
involved the efforts of a Presidential candidate to purchase time
on a local station, in connection with a local primary, immediately
before the election in question.
92
that may arise whether the licensee can be said to have
acted reasonably and in good faith.” * Thus, the stand-
ard of review is not whether the Commission necessarily
agrees with CBS’ decision, but whether the Commission
concludes that CBS’ decision was unreasonable as a
matter of law.
CONCLUSION
CBS is cognizant of its responsibility as a broadcaster
to serve the public interest by providing information
about those seeking the nomination for this country’s
highest public office. We also are aware of the important
role fund-raising plays in the political process. In light
of these considerations, the CBS Television Network has
made available programs of 5-minutes duration—in
prime and non-prime hours—for purchase by candidates
during this pre-primary phase of the 1980 presidential
campaign.
In ruling on this complaint, the Commission need go no
further than deciding whether, as a matter of law, CBS’
actions in this matter amount to an abuse of its legiti-
mate discretion. We think the Commission’s prior cases
make clear that no such abuse of discretion is here in
issue.
Accordingly, for all the reasons set forth herein, we re-
spectfully urge the Commission to reject complainant’s
request that the Commission direct the CBS Television
* Notice, 34 FCC 2d at 586.
93
Network to make 30-minute programs available to the
Carter-Mondale Committee.
Respectfully submitted,
CBS INc. ~
By /s/ Ralph E. Goldberg
RALPH E. GOLDBERG
By /s/ Howard F. Jaeckel
HOWARD F. JAECKEL
Its Attorneys
51 West 52 Street
New York, New York 10019
November 6, 1979
ce Timothy G. Smith, Esq.
General Counsel
Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Ine.
1413 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005
94
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554
In re:
ABC Television Network
CBS Television Network
NBC Television Network
To: The Commission
REPLY OF CARTER-MONDALE
PRESIDENTIAL COMMITTEE, INC.
The networks’ responses show that the Committee’s
complaint presents the Commission with important ques-
tions of statutory interpretation, which it has not yet
had the opportunity to address in a specific context, as
to the meaning and intent of the candidate access pro-
visions of Section 312(a) (7). The reasons set forth by
the networks for their refusals to sell a one half-hour
time period provide, in fact, no justification whatsoever
under the statute for their actions. What the networks
are really telling the Commission is that, for reasons of
their own business convenience, they are not prepared
to alter their normal commercial operations and are not
required to do so by the Act. If this narrow view is sus-
tained, the Commission essentially will be announcing
that, contrary to the intent of Congress, Section 312(a)
(7) has virtually no force or meaning.
Due to the urgency of this matter and need for a de-
cision sufficiently in advance of the several alternative
dates on which time has been sought, it is requested that
the Commission address these questions in an open meet-
ing and rule no later than Wednesday, November 14,
1979.
95
I. The Networks Ignore the Obvious—This Coun-
try’s Most Important Political Campaign is Now
Underway
Contrary to the claims of the three networks:
—It is not too early to sell a network half-hour prime
time program period. The campaigns now under-
way to be a party’s Presidential candidate are not
a series of isolated, local elections, but integrated,
nationwide efforts.
—There is not a “multiplicity of candidates” at this
time.
—Network entertainment programming will not be
unduly disrupted.
First, the simple fact is that the national Presidential
campaign is now well underway.* Whether this is
philosophically desirable or not, it must be accepted by
the Commission and the networks as a fact of life.**
This differentiates “Campaign 80” (as characterized by
one of the networks) from previous election years and
means that the networks cannot simply follow their prior
* CBS altered or “disrupted” its regular programming schedule
to move its one hour CBS Reports program “Teddy”, about Senator
Kennedy, from Wednesday, November 7, 1979 to Sunday, Novem-
ber 4, 1979 because Senator Kennedy scheduled the formal
announcement of his candidacy on November 7, 1979. Washington
Post, November 3, 1979, p. B-1, 5. As to the announcement, CBS
news reported that the Kennedy campaign is now getting into
“full swing”. In addition, the Des Monies Register and Tribune
Company is sponsoring a debate on January 7, 1980 between Presi-
dent Carter and Senator Kennedy, which is expected to receive
nationwide coverage. Washington Post, November 7, 1979, p. A-1.
** The Commission has recognized that “a presidential campaign
may be in full swing almost a year before an election.” Commis-
sion Policy in Enforcing Section $12(a) (7) of the Communications
Act, 68 F.C.C.2d 1079, 1091 (1978) (hereafter Enforcing § 312
(a)(7)). Election Day, 1980 is one year away this week.
96
practices. In essence, at least two of the networks agree.
ABC thinks that the first week in December, 1979 is too
early to sell program time, yet one month later—after
the Christmas sales season is over—is acceptable to it.
CBS agrees that it is appropriate to sell program time
now. Its only concern is the amount of time to sell.*
Precisely because the Presidential campaign has
started and is so intense, it is particularly unreasonable
for the networks to delay selling time until later. The
Committee had explained that its reason for seeking a
half-hour program, immediately after President Carter
formally announces his candidacy, is to present in a de-
tailed and thoughtful manner the administration’s rec-
ord and set the tone for the entire campaign. This pur-
pose could not be accomplished later.
It is unrealistic even to suggest that the Presidential
electoral process leading up to the conventions is merely
a series of isolated, local and state matters, better dealt
with by individual stations. While the pre-convention
period focuses on obtaining delegates from the various
states, in reality Presidential nominating campaigns are
nationwide in scope. Moreover, as network commercial
advertisers are well aware, the purchase of network
time is the most cost-effective way to reach people. This
is a particularly important consideration, given the re-
* CBS has rejected the requests of three Presidential candidates
to purchase half-hour programs. Its response was to offer 2 five-
minute programs. This has a certain appearance of magnanimity.
However, CBS’ counter-offer is a clear refusal to sel! the Committee
the length, day and time period program which would satisfy the
Committee’s needs. Obviously, CBS did not take into considera-
tion the “candidate’s desires as to the method of conducting his or
her media campaign.” Enforcing § 312(a)(7), 68 F.C.C.2d at 1089,
n. 14. It offered a so-called program time unit which it does not
sell to its regular commercial customers and which is not even
considered a normal program unit by industry standards. See
Humphrey For President Campaign, 34 F.C.C.2d 471 (1972).
97
strictions on campaign contributions and expenditures
under the election reform laws, of which § 312(a) (7)
is only one provision.
Second, it is equally incorrect to contend that there is
a “multiplicity of candidates” problem at this time. To
support this contention, the networks point to three
Democratic candidates and about 11 Republican candi-
dates. This is not an inordinate number, particularly
when the Presidency of the United States is the most
important elective office in this country and when the
networks have access obligations only toward candidates
for that office.*
Even assuming that all 13 other candidates would
desire to make a similar purchase in December, 1979
(an assumption the Committee does not accept), the
three networks’ would have to make only one half-hour,
per week, per network available.** This would involve
only 13 additional prime-time half-hours out of a total
of 528 prime-time half-hours over any four week period.
This is only 2.5% of the total December television time
under the networks’ effective control.
Furthermore, because the networks would be acting
on behalf of their affiliates, they would be assisting in-
*In contrast, CBS has pointed out the numerous federal! offices,
in three states, towards which its O & 0, WCAU-TV, Philadelphia
has access responsibilities. (CBS Response, p. 11, footnote). This
is no doubt typical of the responsibilities of other network O & O
stations as well as network affiliated, independent and educational
stations across the United States. Individual stations have to be
concerned with a larger number of federal offices than the net-
works, without even considering the stations’ obligations toward
state and local elections.
** While the Committee requested availabilities on all three net-
works, it seeks to purchase a half-hour program on only one of the
networks. Because of the very high costs involved, there is no
reason to believe that other candidates would act differently.
98
dividual stations (who have access obligations covering
many other federal elections) in meeting a good portion
of their access obligations toward these Presidential can-
didates. As it stands now, the networks by their in-
transigence do a disservice to their affiliates.
Finally, the validity of a “disrupted program sched-
ule” defense is most questionable, even were the poten-
tial for disrupting the networks’ entertainment program-
ming schedules substantial (which is not the case here).
The Committee felt that it gave the networks consider-
able leeway in providing availabilities. The possibility
that other candidates, from both parties, might request
time is speculative at this point. Moreover, the networks
admit that ultimately they must make scheduling
changes and, in fact, now do so with regularity for their
own commercial purposes.
II. The Reasons Given by the Networks for Their
Refusals are, in Fact Reasons to Grant the Re-
quest
All three networks argue that they should not be re-
quired to sell the Committee a one half-hour period at
this time because it is too early in the campaign and
there is a multiplicity of candidates. As shown above,
these concerns are not borne out by the facts. But even
if it were assumed otherwise, they provide little support
for the networks’ position. If a true “nultiplicity of can-
didates” problem existed, there would at least be a re-
sponsibility to try to solve the problem to the maximum
extent possible, particularly where a Presidential candi-
date’s statutory rights are involved. One of the best
ways to do this would be to start selling or making avail-
able time early in the campaign to maximize opportuni-
ties and minimize disruptions.
The networks cannot have it both ways. If there are
a large number of potential candidates, they should ad-
99
just their selling practices accordingly to accommodate
candidates’ anticipated needs. On the other hand, if the
networks really believe that the campaign period has
not started yet, then they must be prepared to accept
the consequences of disrupted schedules (in line with
their restricted view of the campaign period) when
there is less time left to meet candidates’ needs.
Moreover, of all the broadcasters in this country, the
networks are in the weakest position to raise a “multi-
plicity of candidates” defense to making time available
to candidates. Unlike other licensees, the networks as
the national medium have only one group of candidates
to serve (Presidential candidates).* And from the prac-
tical standpoint, the networks have access to at least
two-thirds of the available hours on affiliated stations.
Therefore, they have more time under their effective
control than does the typical station in which to meet
their one statutory obligation to candidates for this
uniquely important office.**
Ill. The Networks Place Excessive Reliance On The
Traditional Licensee Discretion Concept
The networks defend their refusals to sell time as a
reasonable exercise of the broad discretion accorded
them under the Communications Act. They fail to rec-
ognize, however, that the traditional concept of licensee
discretion in making time available to candidates was
modified by Congress in enacting Section 312(a)(7) as
* This office also happens to be the most important from the
standpoint of the public whose interests are paramount here.
** On the other hand, other licensees, in addition to the Presi-
dential candidates in state primaries, will have “reasonable access”
obligations to numerous congressional and senatorial candidates,
as well as basic licensee obligations to important state and local
candidates. See page 4, supra.
>»
100
far as federal candidates were concerned.* The ad-
dition of this provision was not just a limited amend-
ment to the Communications Act but an important com-
ponent of the most comprehensive statutory reform of
the entire federal elective process in nearly fifty years.
As reflected in the accompanying legislative history, the
need for this reform was occasioned in large measure
by the increasing role and cost of broadcasting and par-
ticularly the critical importance of television to the en-
tire electoral process.**
The legislative history surrounding this reform clearly
demonstrates that Congress was dissatisfied with the
status quo under the then existing Communications Act
which placed great reliance on the concept of licensee
discretion in serving the needs of candidates.*** There
can be no doubt but that the essential purpose of enact-
ing Section 312(a) (7) was to place new and additional
obligations on broadcasters with respect to candidates
for federal elective office.
*The Committee is seeking to purchase a half-hour program.
In this context, Section 312(a)(7) requires that candidates be
accorded the right to purchase “reasonable amounts of time.” This
is to be contrasted with other provisions of the Communications
Act which have been traditionally interpreted to afford licensees
far greater discretion in their activities.
** That Congress appreciated and was concerned over this role is
shown by its first effort in 1970 which concerned itself solely with
political broadcasting. It was vetoed on the ground that a more
comprehensive approach covering other media and electoral prob-
lems was required.
*** Under the then existing statutory scheme, the Commission’s
role was generally limited to reminding broadcasters of their gen-
eral statutory obligation to make time available to political candi-
dates in accord with their reasonable, good faith judgment of the
situation. See, Public Notice, Licensees Reminded Of Statutory
Obligations In Contributing Time To Political Campaigns, 18 RR
2d 1216 (1968).
101
Thus, in reporting the measure to the Senate, the
Committee on Commerce unequivocably stated that it
sought “. . . to give candidates for public office greater
access to the media so that they may better explain their
stand on the issues and thereby more fully and completely
inform the voters.”* It is particularly noteworthy in
this respect that every specific ruling cited by the net-
works in defense of their refusals predate the Commis-
sion’s 1978 Policy Statement, (Enforcing § 312(a)(7)),
which accepted and restated this view.
We readily concede that the networks and other li-
censees need to have some latitude in handling requests
for political time. But by the same token, we believe
that the networks must also concede that the traditional
role of the licensee in these matters has been signif-
icantly modified by the actions of the Congress in ad-
dressing, in a most comprehensive way, this country’s
basic electoral process.**
CONCLUSION
For these reasons and for those stated in our initial
complaint, the facts of this situation require the Com-
mission to determine that the three networks have failed
“. . . to permit purchase of reasonable amounts of time
* Report of the Senate Committee on Commerce on S.382 (P.L.
92-5), page 20 (emphasis added).
** For example, as far as the time period for the conduct of
federal campaigns is concerned, Congress specifically rejected pro-
posals to limit the length of the campaign period (as is done, for
example, in Great Britain) but instead contemplated that candi-
dates would determine this period, provided the Federal Election
Campaign Act and the rules and regulations of the Federal Elec-
tion Commission are satisfied. The Committee believes it is simply
unlawful to permit the networks effectively to make judgments
which were not even entrusted to the federal agency responsible
for the supervision of the electoral process.
-
102
.. 2’ and accordingly direct the networks to make time
available for purchase.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Timothy G. Smith
TIMOTHY G. SMITH
General Counsel
Carter-Mondale Presidential
Committee, Inc.
1413 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005
Of Counsel:
John D. Lane
Ramsey L. Woodworth
1211 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
Harold K. McCombs
1822 Jefferson Place, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
November 7, 1979
[Certificate of Service Omitted in Printing]
103
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20554
In the Matter of
Complaint of the Carter-Mondale
Presidential Committee, Inc.
COMMENTS OF THE
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS
The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB)
urges the Commission to find that the refusal by the
three major television networks, ABC, CBS and NBC, to
sell the Carter-Mondale Presidential Committee a half-
hour of prime time for nationwide broadcast was neither
unreasonable under Section 312(a) (7) of the Communi-
cations Act* nor an abuse of the journalistic discretion
properly vested in their stations as licensees.
NAB is a private nonprofit, incorporated association of
radio and television broadcast stations and networks.
As of November 7, 1979, NAB’s membership included
2,553 AM radio stations, 2,030 FM radio stations, 600
television stations and the major nationwide commercial
broadcast networks. Because the FCC’s action on the
complaint will have an impact on all radio and television
stations, NAB is submitting these comments, as an
amicus curiae, to underscore the interest of broadcast
licensees in this proceeding. We urge the FCC not to
take any action which unduly circumscribes the reason-
able good faith judgment of broadcast licensees.
1 Section 312(a) provides that: “(a) The Commission may re-
voke any station license ... (7) For willful or repeated failure to
afford reasonable amounts of time for the use of a broadcasting
station by a legally qualified candidate for Federal elective office
on behalf of his candidacy.” Significantly, Section 312(a) is di-
rected to stations rather than to the networks.
104
I. The Reasonable Access Requirement Should Be
Interpreted in Light of the First Amendment In-
terest in Shielding a Broadcaster’s Journalistic
Decision from Government Second-Guessing.
The reasonable access requirement is essentially a
codification for Federal candidates for public office of
“the Commission’s prior interpretation of Section 315
(a) as requiring broadcasters to make time available
to political candidates.” * Congress recognized that the
rights of Federal candidates to time should not be abso-
lute and provided that licensees could limit such candi-
dates to a “reasonable” amount of broadcast time. How-
ever, even though Congress provided little guidance on
the meaning of the phrase “reasonable,” it empowered
the FCC to revoke the license of any station for “willful
or repeated failure” to comply with Section 312(a) (7).
With the sanction of license revocation expressly con-
tained in Section 312(a) (7), the potential for govern-
ment harassment is indeed significant.
A mounting series of court decisions have upheld the
vital First Amendment interest in shielding journalistic
decisions made by broadcasters and newspaper publishers
from Government second-guessing. In the landmark CBS
vs. DNC case, the U.S. Supreme Court warned against
“the risk of an enlargement of Government control over
the content of broadcast discussion” as well as the dan-
gers of Government oversight of “the day-to-day opera-
tions of broadcasters’ conduct.” * The Court observed
that “[rJjegimenting broadcasters is too radical a ther-
2Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Democratic National
Committee, 412 U.S. 94, 113-114 n. 12 (1973). See also S. Rep.
No. 96, 92nd Cong., Ist Sess. (1971) and 117 Cong. Rec. S12872
(daily ed. Aug. 2, 1971).
3 412 U.S. at 126-127.
105
apy” * and emphasized the importance of providing li-
censees with the utmost discretion:
“For better or worse, editing is what editors are
for; and editing is selection and choice of material.” °
The issue of Government review of a licensee’s jour-
nalistic judgment was also addressed by the Supreme
Court in a decision invalidating a Georgia privacy law
on the ground that it infringed upon the First Amend-
ment right of the petitioning broadcast station to report
information disclosed during a criminal trial. Cow
Broadcasting Corp. v. Cohn, 420 U.S. 469 (1975). Citing
its decision in Miami Herald Publishing Co. v. Tornillo,
418 U.S. 241 (1974) (invalidating on First Amendment
grounds a Florida statute providing a right of access for
candidates to newspapers), the Court concluded: “In this
instance as in others, reliance must rest upon the judg-
ment of those who decide what to publish or broadcast.”
Cox at 496.
The necessity of giving the licensee a_ substantial
amount of leeway on matters relating to issues of im-
portance to the electorate was underscored by the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
in Strauss Communications, Inc. v. FCC: °
The abiding First Amendment difficulties, however,
along with an appreciation of Congress’ intent in
enacting the Communications Act, have engendered
an important corollary: the licensee is to have the
maximum editorial freedom consistent with its posi-
tion as public trustee of a portion of the airways.
Accordingly, it is of utmost importance that the reason-
able access provision be interpreted by the Commission
4 Id.
5 Id. at 124.
* 530 F.2d 1001, 1008 (D.C. Cir. 1976).
106
in this case in light of a standard which gives great
weight to the editorial discretion of broadcasters.
II. The Commission Should Continue to Defer to the
Reasonable, Good Faith Judgment of Licensees.
For the Commission to rule in favor of the complain-
ant would clearly require that it substitute its own judg-
ment for that of the networks. While the Carter-Mondale
Presidential Committee would like to place the burden
of justification on the broadcaster, this approach is wrong
as a matter of law. The Commission has emphatically
stated, again and again, that it will not overturn a
licensee’s good faith discretionary judgment unless it is
clearly unreasonable in light of all the facts and cir-
cumstances. This policy was initially stated by the Com-
mission in a 1972 Public Notice entitled Use of Broad-
cast and Cablecast Facilities by Candidates for Public
Office :*
The test of whether a licensee has met the require-
ments of the new section is one of reasonableness.
The Commission will not substitute its judgment for
that of the licensee, but, rather, it will determine
in any case that may arise whether the licensee can
be said to have acted reasonably and in good faith
in fulfilling his obligations under this section.
Affording the licensee significant journalistic discre-
tion has been a fundamental part of the Commission’s
regulatory scheme.* This is only as it should be in light
of the mandates of the First Amendment and the no-
censorship provision (Section 326) of the Communica-
tions Act. The need to accord great latitude to the
judgment of the broadcaster as to what constitutes rea-
sonable access is underscored by the severity of the ulti-
7 34 FCC 2d 510, 536 (1972).
8 CBS v. DNC, supra, at 110-111.
107
mate penalty for violation of Section 312(a)(7). In
addition, the equal opportunities provision (Section 315)
of the Communications Act and the Fairness Doctrine
impinge upon the reasonable access provision and make it
difficult to implement, especially when there is a multi-
plicity of candidates for Federal office.
NAB believes that the deference the Commission has
given to the licensee’s good faith and reasonableness re-
mains an entirely appropriate standard. Indeed, the fol-
lowing facts, all amply documented in the network,’
three submissions, highlight the enormous problems
which would ensue from upholding the complaint:
—the extraordinary number of candidates, each po-
tentially capable of asserting a colorable “equal oppor-
tunities” claim under Section 315;
—the unprecedented earliness of the request; *
—the inability of the Commission to specify, as a
matter of law, the many factors to be considered by a
licensee (or a network) in determining whether, when
and how much time to sell to a political candidate;
—the geographical sloppiness of political boundaries
(see, e.g., CBS Comments at 11 & n. *); broadcast sta-
tions’ service areas rarely coincide neatly with the can-
didate’s targeted voting population;
® By way of comparison, in the 1976 campaign the earliest politi-
cal “program time” ABC sold was aired on April 23, 1976 (ABC
Comments at 9), and the first political half-hour NBC sold was
broadcast on March 31, 1976 (NBC Comments at 2). CBS has
already offered the complainants two 5-minute program time slots
in early December, 1979 (CBS Comments at 1).
10 For instance, to secure adequate and effective television e
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.